,>TICLES FROM 0,CAN5]O0 #aiid ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,ALFR$O ,M>IA ,BONANNO ,AU?OR 3 ,M>CO ,BEACO ,AU?OR 3 ,MASSIMO ,PASSAMANI ,TEXT 3 ,TRANSLATOR'S ,9TRODUCTION ,CAN5]O WAS A WEEKLY AN>*I/ PUBLICATION ?AT CAME \T 9 ,ITALY BETWE5 ! 5D ( #aiid & ! BEG9N+ ( #aiig ) ONE BREAK4 ,?IS WAS :5 ! ,M>9I 9VE/IGATION AGA9/ AN>*I/S BEGAN TO BE> ITS ROTT5 FRUIT 9 AN ATTEMPT TO IMPRISON DOZ5S ( AN>*I/S ON *>GES ( 0SUBV]SIVE ASSOCIATION0 OR MEMB]%IP 9 AN 0>M$ GANG04.<#a.> ,ONE ( ! IDEAS BEH9D ,CAN5]O WAS TO PROVIDE A MEANS = ONGO+ COMMUNICATION & DISCUSSION 9 ! FACE ( ?IS REPRESSIVE OP]ATION ( ! /ATE4 ,A SUB/ANTIAL PORTION ( ! MAT]IAL 9 ! PAP] DEALT ) ! SITUATION & ! V>I\S AN>*I/ RESPONSES TO IT4 ,BUT ! $ITORS ( ,CAN5]O W]E NOT WILL+ TO ALL[ ! REPRESSIVE ACTIVITY ( ! /ATE TO DEF9E ! LIMITS ( ! DISCUSSION 9 ! PAP] !Y PUBLI%$1 SO ALONG ) 9=MATION & ANALYSIS ( ?AT SPECIFIC SITUATION O!R SIGNIFICANT QUE/IONS & IDEA W]E RAIS$ 9 ITS PAGES4 ,?US1 )9 ITS PAGES ONE C\LD F9D PO9T$1 BUT BRIEF1 !ORETICAL >TICLES1 SOCIAL & HI/ORICAL ANALYZES & BIT+LY WITTY LOOKS AT ! WEEKS NEWS4 ,( C\RSE1 AS IS APPROPRIATE = A WEEKLY PUBLICATION1 MO/ ( ! >TICLES >E SPECIFIC TO ! TIME !Y W]E WRITT51 9T5D$ = IMM$IATE USE 9 ! HEAT ( ! SITUATION ?AT WAS GO+ ON4 ,BUT !RE W]E 5\< >TICLES ( MORE G5]AL 9T]E/ ?AT ,I CONSID]$ IT WOR? MY :ILE TO TRANSLATE A NUMB] ( !M = PUBLICATION 9 ?IS =M4 ,I HAVE ALREADY MAD SOME ( ?IS MAT]IAL AVAILABLE 9 ,MORE1 ,MU* ,MORE1 A COLLECTION ( WRIT+S BY ,MASSIMO ,PASSAMANI :OSE IDEAS ,I F9D P>TICUL>LY ?\M$ /RUGGLE GR\PS ?AT APPE>$ 9 ! LA/ FEW ISSUES ( ,CAN5]O4 ,9 ?IS BOOKLET1 ,I HAVE COLLECT$ A NUMB] ( >TICLES ?AT ,I F9D P>TICUL>LY /IMULAT+4 ,I AM C]TA9LY NOT 9 AGREEM5T ) EV]Y WORD H]E4 ,BUT ,I HAVE F\ND ALL ( IT TO BE A /IMULUS TO DEEP5+ MY [N ?9K+ ON ! SORTS ( QUE/IONS RAIS$4 ,IF1 = EXAMPLE1 ,M>IO ,CACCIUCO'S DESCRIPTION ( RELATION%IPS BETWE5 PEOPLE AS ?AT ( 0SPH]ES ?AT B\NCE ( EA* O!R0 & HIS CONSEQU5T REJECTION ( ! V]Y IDEA ( LOVE & FRI5D%IP SEEM RA!R BLEAK TO ME1 ?IS IS PRECISELY :Y HIS >TICLE PROVOKES ME TO EXAM9E ! NATURE ( EV]YDAY RELATION%IPS MORE CLOSELY1 P>TICUL>LY ?OSE ?AT WE CALL 0LOVE0 & 0FRI5D%IP04 ,9 FACT1 ONE ( ! ?+S ?AT /&S \T = ME 9 !SE >TICLES IS ! WAY 9 :I* !Y >E ABLE TO RAISE SIGNIFICANT QUE/IONS1 (T5 AB\T MATT]S ?AT WE TAKE = GRANT$1 9 SO FEW WORDS4 ,I HAVE *OS5 TO PR9T ! MAT]IAL 9 *RONOLOGICAL ORD]4 ,! FIR/ >TICLE WAS AN 9TRODUCTION TO ! PROJECT & ! LA/ WAS ! $ITORS' EXPLANATION = BR++ ! PROJECT TO A CLOSE4 ,9 ?IS LA/ PIECE1 ! PROBLEMS ?AT CONFRONT ANY AN>*I/ PUBLI%+ PROJECT >E MADE CLE>4 ,AS AN>*I/S1 HOPEFULLY1 WE DO NOT PUBLI% JU/ 9 ORD] TO HAVE SOME?+ TO DO4 ,!RE HAS TO BE A PURPOSE ?AT RELATES TO \R BROAD] LIFE PROJECT ( REVOLT4 ,IF WE DON'T WANT TO BE LEAD]S OR EVANGELI/S C>RY+ A SUPPOS$ REVOLUTION>Y GOSPEL TO :ATEV] IMAG9>Y 0MASSES01 !N IT SEEMS TO ME ?AT ! IDEA ( DEVELOP+ RELATION%IPS ( AFF9ITY & COMPLICITY 9 :I* SIGNIFICANT DISCUSSION PLAYS A C5TRAL P>T W\LD BE A PRIM>Y REASON = PUBLI%+4 ,)\T ?IS1 PUBLI%+ SEEMS TO BE A MEAN+LESS SPEW+ =? ( WORDS PLAY+ 9TO ! DEGRADATION ( LANGUAGE ?AT ?IS SOCIETY IMPOSES ?R\< ITS [N ONE-WAY 0COMMUNICATION04 ,& REAL DISCUSSION IS NOT A M]E TAK+ ( POSITIONS & DEF5D+ !M FROM ! =TRESS ( \R V>I\S IDEOLOGIES4 ,IT HAS TO BE ! REAL 5C\NT] BETWE5 V>I\S & CONFLICT+ IDEAS4 ,IF1 ULTIMATELY1 ! $ITORS ( ,CAN5]O DID NOT FEEL ?AT IT /IMULAT$ ! SORT ( DISCUSSION !Y DESIR$1 IT IS MY HOPE ?AT 9 PUBLI%+ !SE >TICLES 9 ,5GLI%1 DISCUSSIONS MAY BE /IMULAT$ H]E4 ,!RE IS A LOT TO ?9K AB\T 9 !SE BRIEF WRIT+S4 ,P]HAPS IT WILL /IR SOME?+ UP4 ,WOLFI ,L&/REI*] ,FEBRU>Y #bf ,VAGABOND ,DE/RUCTION ,CAN5]O4 ,ONE WORD ALONGSIDE ANO!R4 ,A S\ND ?AT IS LO/ 9 ! CONT9U\S DEAF5+ NOISE ?AT !Y /ILL CALL LANGUAGE4 ,A WORD DIFF]5T FROM O!RS4 ,A HISS 9 ! MID/ ( %\TS4 ,A SI< FROM :I* TO MOVE 9 SE>* ( NEW MEAN+S 9 WORLD :]E EV]Y?+ HAS BE5 SAID4 ,A WORD AGA9/ O!RS1 AN AGA9/ ?AT IS O!R ) RESPECT TO WORDS1 ?AT DOESN'T 9HABIT ! SPACE ( ! OPPOSITION BETWE5 CONCEPTS1 BUT ?AT ( ! SIL5CE ?AT PREC$ES & ACCOMPANIES IT4 ,A WORD1 F9ALLY1 ?AT DOESN'T REF] TO ITSELF1 BUT ?AT CAUSES US TO S5SE ?AT REGION 9 :I*1 9 ! SIL5CE :]E ?\ITY & ! DESIRE = REVOLT AGA9/ ALL ?AT SUFFOCATES IT GR[4 ,A PAP] = ALL ?OSE :O1 9 ?IS CIVILIZATION ( COLLECTIVE ID5TITY & RECIPROCAL BELONG+1 WANT TO AFFIRM !IR NATURE AS 0/RANG]S EV]Y:]E01 AS REFRACTORIES AGA9/ EV]Y FA!RL& 7! 05TIRE WORLD0 9CLUD$74 ,VAGABOND LIKE ! ?\D ! REGAL CONDITION ( A PHILOSOPHY ADDRESS$ TO P[] SYMBOLIZ$ !MSELVES ) ! IMAGE ( ! DOG 7,KYON1 9 ,GREEK71 AS A SIGN ( REFUSAL ( HI]>*Y1 SOCIAL OBLIGATION & ! SUPPOS$ NECESSITY = LAWS4 ,REPAID1 AS IS FITT+ = ALL FREE SPIRITS1 ) C5SURE & MY/IFICATION4 ,9 \R LANGUAGE -- ?AT IS PASS$ (F AS NEUTRAL BUT CANNOT HIDE ITS *RI/IAN NATURE -- 0CYNICISM0 HAS BECOME SYNONYM\S ) VOLUPTU\S 9DIFF]5CE TO ! SUFF]+ ( O!RS4 ,?US1 ! POLICE ( IDEAS :I* TRAVELS ?R\< ! C5TURIES UND]GR\ND HAS GOTT5 RID ( :AT UTT]LY DID NOT GIVE A DAMN = GODS OR LAWS4 ,SO ?AT ! DESIRE TO BE \TSIDE DOES NOT BECAME RESIGN$ MUTILATION1 BUT >MS ITSELF 1 BUT >MS ITSELF AGA9/ EV]Y =M ( AU?ORITY & EXPLOITATION4 ,SO ?AT ONE PASSES FROM ! ,P[] ( DIALOGUE 7) :I* ONE ?9KS EV]Y?+ CAN BE RESOLV$7 & FROM ! DIALOGUE ( ,P[] 7?AT 9VITES EV]YONE TO REASONABLE NEGOTIATION7 TO A FEEL+ ( RADICAL HO/ILITY T[>D ! EXI/5T1 TO ! DE/RUCTION ( EV]Y /RUCTURE ?AT ALI5ATES1 EXPLOITS1 PROGRAMS & REGIM5TS ! LIVES ( 9DIVIDUALS4 ,! BLACK ( ! DOG 7?IS ANIMAL :I* IS G5]AL ASSOCIAT$ ) ! IDEA ( SUBMISSION1 ( S]VILE MEEKNESS7 IS PRECISELY ! DESIRE TO COME \T FROM ! H]D ( VOLUNT>Y S]VITUDE & OP5 TO ! JOY ( REBELLION4 ,NOT ! BLACK 9 :I* ALL C[S >E EQUAL 7EV5 IF IT IS 9 !IR BE+ AGA9/ OR \TSIDE71 BUT RA!R ?AT 9 :I* ! B\ND>IES BETWE5 DE/RUCTION & CREATION1 BETWE5 EXTREME DEF5SE ( ONESELF & ! CON/RUCTION ( RELATION%IPS ( MUTUALITY ) O!RS1 DISAPPE>4 ,A PAP] -- TO PIECE TOGE!R A MOSAIC ( ?\S&S ( POSSIBLE MEAN+S -- ( VAGABOND DE/RUCTION1 MEAN+ BY ?IS ! POSSIBILITY ( PASS+ TO ! ATTACK AGA9/ /ATE & DOM9ATION 9 ALL ITS MANIFE/ATIONS )\T PL$G+ ALLEGIANCE1 TO USE A WELL-KN[N EXPRESSION1 TO ANY FLAG OR ORGANIZATION4 ,AS 9DIVIDUALS1 ALWAYS1 EV5 :]E ! UN%AKABLE DESIRE = ! O!R LEADS US TO *OOSE ! PA? ( UNION4 ,! ,TE*NIQUE ( ,C]TA9TY BY ,M>CO ,BEACO 0,I WAS FRIDI ,! METAPHOR ( 0M5TAL ILLNESS0 DISPOSSESSES ! 9DIVIDUAL ( :ATEV] IS MO/ UNIQUE & P]SONAL 9 H] WAY ( LIFE1 9 HIS ME?OD ( P]CEIV+ REALITY & H]SELF 9 IT2 ?IS IS ONE ( ! MO/ DANG]\S ATTACKS AGA9/ ! S+UL>1 BECAUSE ?R\< IT ! 9DIVIDUAL IS ALWAYS BR\ 0MEAN+01 ( ! P>TICUL> 0RATIONALITY0 ?AT UND]LIES IT4 ,REASONS CONNECT ONLY TO COLLECTIVE ACTS1 :I* CAN BE BR\I\S E?NIC1 ANTAGONI/ & CRIM9AL SUBCULTURES ?AT EXI/4 ,! %>+ ( MEAN+S1 SYMBOLS & 9T]PRETATIONS ( REALITY ?US APPE>S AS ! BE/ ANTIDOTE TO MADNESS4 ,?US IF ONE :O SUDD5LY KILLS HIS FAMILY IS A LUNATIC1 OR BETT]1 A 0MON/]01 ONE :O SETS FIRE TO A REFUGE = =EIGN]S APPE>S AS A X5OPHOBE 7AT MO/1 FROM ! ME?OD1 A BIT HA/Y1 BUT /ILL )9 REASON7 & ONE :O SLAU$ W> IS NO?+ BUT A 0GOOD SOLDI]04 ,?US1 ACCORD+ TO ! CLASSIFY+ G5]ALIZATION ?AT MAKES !M ALL ALIKE1 EXPROPRIAT+ !M ( !IR LIV$ S+UL>ITY1 LUNATICS >E 0 DANG]\S TO SOCIETY04 ,TRU?FULLY1 ONE CAN ONLY AGREE ) ?IS1 C]TA9LY NOT BECAUSE ( ! SUPPOS$ & PRETEXTUAL AGGRESSIV5ESS & VIOL5CE ATTRIBUT$ TO ?OSE :O SUFF] PSY*IATRIC DIAGNOSIS 7! PSY*IATRI/S & $UCATORS ( EV]Y SORT >E UND\BT$LY MU* MORE DANG]\S71 BUT BECAUSE !Y HAVE VIOLAT$1 KN[+LY OR NOT1 ! ESS5TIALLY QUANTITATIVE CODES ?AT CON/ITUTE NORMALITY4 ,:AT IS SURPRIS+ IS ?AT AFT] LONG YE>S ( DOME/ICATION !RE IS ANYBODY :O DOES NOT RESPOND TO CULTURAL /IMULI1 IF NOT QUITE AUTOMATICALLY1 AT LEA/ 9 A HIDIANS1 S9CE IT IS (T5 ! QUALITY ( ! 9DIVIDUAL2 NO MOTIVE1 NO VALUE1 NO PURPOSE ?AT IS SOCIALLY COMPREH5SIBLE1 ONLY AN 9DIVIDUAL LOGIC1 NECESS>ILY ABNORMAL4 ,DEF5SE FROM ?IS DANG] IS 5TRU/$ TO ! PROCLAMATIONS ( SCI5CE4 ,9 O!R WORDS1 ! 0UNHEAL?Y0 GE/URE1 ! CREATOR ( :I* IS NOT RESPONSIBLE1 REMA9S AS A CONSEQU5CE ( AN EXT]NAL MIS=TUNE ?AT C\LD /RIKE & GIVE RISE TO ?\S&S ( PEOPLE LIKE HIM4 ,! ME*ANISM IS !RE=E WELL CONTRIV$1 A GE/URE DEPRIV$ ( MEAN+1 ( AN UND]LY+ WILL1 BECOMES 9NOCU\S1 & IT IS EASY TO NEUTRALIZE IT1 ALONG ) ITS CREATOR1 BEH9D ! ALIBI1 :I* IS 0SOCIAL0 AS WELL1 ( ! CURE4 ,! PSY*IATRIC DIAGNOSIS COMES D[N ON ! 9DIVIDUAL LIKE AN AX1 AMPUTAT+ H] LANGUAGE1 HIS MEAN+1 H] LIFE PA?S2 IT CLAIMS TO ELIM9ATE !M AS IRRATIONAL1 S5SELESS2 ! PSY*IATRI/ BEHAVES BE=E !M ) ! LIQUIDAT+ ATTITUDE ( ONE :O TRANS=MS ! EXP]I5CES ( LIFE 9TO MALFUNCTIONS ( ! PSY*E1 ! EMOTIONS 9TO A MALIGNANT TUMOR TO BE REMOV$4 ,PSY*IATRI/S1 AS TE*NICIANS ( C]TA9TY1 >E ! MO/ EFFICI5T POLICE ( ! SOCIAL ORD]4 ,REALITY1 LIKE ! MEAN+ ( EXI/5CE1 HAS CLE> & UNEQUIVOCAL B\ND>IES = !SE PRIE/S 9 :ITE %IRTS2 !IR MISSION3 TO 0RETURN0 ?OSE :O HAVE GOTT5 LO/ V5TUR+ ONTO ! W9D+ PA?S ( NONS5SE 0TO !IR S5SES04 ,IF ! POLICE >E LIMIT$1 AS IS CLAIM$1 TO BEAT+ Y\1 ! PSY*IATRI/ DEM&S TO HE> Y\ SAY1 0,?ANK Y\1 ,I AM WELL N[0 AS WELL4 ,! FOCAL PO9T 9 ! DISCUSSION IS NOT 9 ! F\R WALLS & ! B>S ( ! ASYLUM1 NOR 9 ! ELECTRO%OCK & CON/RA9T B$S1 NOR 9 BAD AS OPPOS$ TO GOOD PSY*IATRY1 BUT 9 0PSY*IATRIC ?\E NO?+ BUT E HELP$2 9 !SE PLACES1 ! HEAL?Y TRY TO P]SUADE ! DISEAS$ ?AT :AT !Y DID & ?\D ! B9>IES ( NORMALITY4 ,! 0AUTONOMY0 & 0SELF-REALIZATION0 AB\T :I* !SE DEMOCRATIC OP]ATORS FLAP !IR TONGUES >E EXCLUSIVELY !IR [N &1 TO !M1 IT IS NECESS>Y TO CON=M 9 ORD] TO BE ABLE TO LEAVE ! HEAL+ 5CLOSURE4 ,PSY*IATRIC M$IC9E ITSELF1 AS ANALGESIC 7ANES!TIC7 = ! M9D1 IS ! SIGN ( ! ATTEMPT TO BLOCK EV]Y DEVELOPM5T1 EV]Y PA?WAY H[EV] PA9FUL AT TIMES1 ?AT AN 9DIVIDUAL PUTS 9TO ACTION AS A REACTION TO ?AT :I* OPPRESSES H]4 ,)\T MY/IFY+ ?IS PROCESS1 ?IS MOM5T ( 0CRISIS01 ?AT IS NOT NECESS>ILY A PA?WAY TO LIB]ATION1 ! FACT ( ! MATT] REMA9S ?AT ! ANSW] ( P[] IS G5]ALIZ$ N>COSIS1 COLLECTIVE /UPEFACTION1 ?AT R5D]S US /ATIC & TRANQUIL1 AN*OR$ TO \R PLACID MIS]Y4 ,! ,OBSCURE ,CL>ITY ( ,WORDS BY ,ALFR$O ,M4 ,BONANNO ,ONE :O WRITES1 P]HAPS EV5 MORE ?AN ONE :O SPEAKS1 IS CALL$ TO CL>IFY1 TO BR+ LIRY \T ! ROLE ( PASSIVE RECEIV]4 ,! RELATION%IP (T5 TAKES ON ! APPE>ANCE ( CONFLICT1 )9 :I* TWO DIFF]5T UNIV]SES CLA% ) EA* O!R4 ,BUT ?IS CLA% IS NOT BAS$ ON ANY ACTIVE 9T5TION ON ! P>T ( ! ONE WRIT+ 7OR SPEAK+71 & A PASSIVE ONE ON ! P>T ( ! ONE HE>+ 7OR READ+74 ,! TWO MOVEM5TS >E ONLY CONTR>Y ONLY 9 APPE>ANCE4 ,! READ] P>TICIPATES 9 ! EF=T ( ! WRIT] & ! WRIT] 9 ?AT ( ! READ]4 ,EV5 IF ! TWO MOVEM5TS >E SEP>AT$ FROM EA* O!R1 !Y >E NOT SO 9 ! FACT1 :I* HAS NOT BE5 MU* CONSID]$1 ?AT ! ONE :O WRITES IS ALWAYS 7SIMULTANE\SLY7 A READ] ( ! TEXT %E IS WRIT+1 & ! ONE :O READS IS ALSO HIMSELF 7SIMULTANE\SLY7 ! WRIT] ( ! TEXT ?AT HE IS READ+4 ,H]E TWO ]RORS >E COMMITT$4 ,! FIR/ IS ?AT 9 :I* ONE 5C\NT]S ! WRIT] :O ?9KS ?AT BY READ+ :ILE HE WRITES1 HE UND]/&S :AT %E IS WRIT+1 & DOESN'T REALIZE ?AT (T5 H] COMPREH5SION IS NOT DUE TO ! CL>ITY ( ! TEXT1 BUT TO ! READ]-WRIT] CONNECTION ?AT REA*ES ! HIE UN?9KABLE TO H]1 & DOESN'T REALIZE ?AT (T5 ! 9COMPREH5SIBILITY ( ! TEXT ?AT %E READS IS NOT SO MU* DUE TO A LACK ( CL>ITY AS TO ! FACT ?AT HE W\LD HAVE WRITT5 IT DIFF]5TLY4 ,! ?+ ?AT SEEMS TO ESCAPE ?IS B9>Y RELATION%IP IS ! ?IRD ELEM5T1 I4E41 ! TOPIC ?AT IS BE+ DISCUSS$4 ,! REALITY EXAM9$ ) WORDS IS A B>RI] ?AT1 ON ! ONE H&1 MAY HELP TO ORGANIZE ! WORDS 9 A C]TA9 WAY 7ACCEPT+ SOME & REJECT+ O!RS71 BUT1 ON ! O!R H&1 C>RIES \T A DI/ORT+ PROCESS ) REG>DS TO ! EMPLOYM5T ( ! ACCEPT$ WORDS4 ,NO WORD IS NEUTRAL1 BUT EA* ONE1 BE+ ORGANIZ$ )9 CONCEPTS1 CONTRIBUTES TO TRANSF]R+ 9TO ! READ] 7& 9 /ILL DIFF]5T WAYS1 9TO ! LI/5]7 A CONCEPTION ( ! DIFFRACTION ( ! REALITY EXAM9$ 7( :I* ONE WRITES OR SPEAKS74 ,?US1 NO WORD IS CLE> OR OBSCURE AS SU*2 !RE IS NO POSSIBILITY ( DEF9ITIVELY CA/+ A POOL ( LIIFY+ IT ONCE & = ALL4 ,ONCE ! WORD IS DETA*$ FROM ! REALITY TO :I* IT REF]S & ?US FROM ! *OICE ?AT ! WRIT] 7OR SPEAK]7 MADE ON ! BASIS ( ! SUGGE/IONS ( ! REALITY EXAM9$1 IT NO LONG] MEANS ANY?+4 ,IT VANI%ES1 & ITS POSSIBILITY = BE+ ANY?+1 A MEANS = ?\Y IS LIKE A W>EH\SE ( WORDS4 ,!Y >E L9$ UP !RE ON ! %ELVES1 SOME US$ CONT9U\SLY1 O!RS ONLY R>ELY1 ALL EQUALLY AVAILABLE1 BUT ONLY A FEW ( !M ABLE TO BE COORD9AT$ TOGE!R ACCORD+ TO ! 9T5TIONS ( ! ONE :O *OOSES & ! SUGGE/IONS ( ! REALITY %E WANTS TO DRESS UP 9 WORDS4 ,IT'S JU/ ?AT WE CAN UND]/& WORDS1 & ?US DECIDE IF EA* ( !M IS 0CLE>0 = US1 ON ! CONDITION ( BE+ CONV]SANT ) ?IS OP]ATION ( DRESS+ UP4 ,!RE >E NOT WORDS ON ONE SIDE1 DEAD OBJECTS %UT UP 9 DICTION>IES1 & REALITY ON ! O!R SIDE :]E 9DIVIDUAL OBJECTS EXI/ BESIDE WORDS ?AT >E ALSO !MSELVES OBJECTS1 BUT ALL 9 A HAPHAZ>D MANN]1 )\T RELATION%IP4 ,FL[S ( MEAN+ EXI/1 I4E41 WORK+ PROC$URES 9 ! C\RSE ( :I* ! ELEM5TS ( REALITY 7?AT H]E1 = CONV5I5CE1 WE CAN CALL 0OBJECTS074 ,!Y RECEIVE MEAN+ ?R\< US1 PUTT+ ON L+UI/IC CLO!S4 ,!RE IS NO *AIR SEP>ATE FROM ! WORD ?AT MEANS IT1 & ! DIFF]5T WORDS TO :I* DIFF]5T LANGUAGES HAVE REC\RSE RECONFIRM ?IS 5DEAVOR AS A FL[ ( MEAN+1 PROPOS+ PHILOLOGICAL NUANCES ?AT ?R\< ! HI/ORY ( ! MILL5NIA (T5 CAUSE 9CR$IBLE R\TES1 EXTRAORD9>Y ADV5TURES1 TO EM]GE4 ,DRESS+ REALITY IS ?US ! PRIM>Y ACTIVITY ( ! HUMAN BE+1 ! CONDITION = ACT+ & ITSELF AN ACTION1 ! ESS5TIAL =M ( ACTION1 9S(> AS ?\K MASS ( =EBOD+ & FE>4 ,! MO/ IMPORTANT QUE/ION IS NOT ?AT ( ! GREATE/ CL>ITY 7EASIE/ WORDS1 DRESS$ MO/ MODE/LY1 L9E>ITY 9 ! CORRESPOND5CES71 BUT RA!R1 & MAYBE CONTR>ILY1 ?AT ( ! GREATE/ RI*NESS 7DIFF]5T WORDS CONTRA/+ ! COMMONPLACES1 DRESS$ 9 ! LIVELIE/ COLORS1 UNC]TA9TY ( CORRESPOND5CE74 ,! WORD IS ALSO 5*ANTM5T1 M>VEL1 JOY\S 9V5TION1 FANCY1 EVOCATION ( SOME?+ O!R1 NOT ! SEAL ( ! ALREADY SE51 ! CONFIRMATION ( ONE'S C]TA9TIES4 ,! AIM ( SPEAK+ & WRIT+ IS !RE=E NOT ?AT ( 0CL>IFY+01 BUT ( 05RI*+0 REALITY1 ( 9VIT+ ! UNEXPECT$1 ! UNPR$ICTABLE4 ,! ONE :O COMMUNICATES HAS NO OBLIGATION TO GIVE US PRESCRIPTIONS = REPAIR1 PANACEAS = \R FE>S1 CONFIRMATIONS ( \R KN[L$GE1 BUT CAN EV5 FEEL FREE TO SUGGE/ DIFFICULT R\TES1 TO MAKE UNC]TA9TY & DANG] FL>E4 ,& :OEV] WANTS TO FEEL SAFE 9 HIS H\SE IS FREE TO /OP HIS READ+ OR COV] H] E>S4 ,! ,REV]SE ,ROAD BY ,ALFR$O ,M4 ,BONANNO ,TIMES ( D\BT & UNC]TA9TY HAVE >RIV$4 ,NEW & OLD FE>S SPUR ! SE>* = GU>ANTEES4 ,9 ! M>KET :]E HUMAN AFFAIRS >E MANAG$1 NEW MODELS ( COM=T >E BRISKLY HAGGL$ OV]4 ,MADONNAS WEEP1 POLITICIANS MAKE PROMISES2 EV]Y:]E W> & MIS]Y1 SAVAG]Y & HORROR >E RIFE1 R5D]+ US N[ UNABLE TO EV5 FEEL \TRAGE1 LET ALONE TO REBEL4 ,PEOPLE HAVE BE5 QUICK TO ACCU/OM !MSELVES TO BLOOD4 ,!Y SC>CELY SMELL ! ODOR ( ! MASSACRES1 & EV]Y DAY SOME?+ NEW & MORE 9CR$IBLE AWAITS !M3 ,TOKYO1 ,GAZA1 ! *ANGELESS ,BOSNIA1 ,BURUNDI & /ILL MORE PLACES1 REMOTE1 DI/ANT1 & YET NE>BY4 ,:AT !Y ASK IS TO BE LEFT \T ( IT4 ,BE+ 9=M$1 EV5 ( ! SMALLE/ H\SEHOLD MASSACRES1 ?OSE ( ,SATURDAY EV5+ = EXAMPLE1 :I* PATT]N DOZ5S ( DEA?S WEEKLY1 ) NO O!R PURPOSE ?AN ?AT ( KN[+ 9 ORD] TO =GET4 ,9 A WORLD ?AT IS REVEAL$ TO BE 9CREAS+LY WEAK 9 REAL MEAN+S1 9 MOTIVATIONS ?AT GIVE CONT5T TO LIFE1 9 PROJECTS WOR?Y ( BE+ LIV$1 PEOPLE GIVE AWAY FRE$OM = SPECT]S ?AT >E 9 EASY REA*1 SPECT]S ?AT COME \T FROM ! /UDIOS ( P[]4 ,RELIGION IS ONE ( !SE SPECT]S4 ,NOT ANY RELIGION :ATSOEV]1 OBJECTIFI$ 9 DI/ANT & CRU/Y PRACTICES1 GOV]N$ BY PRIE/S & SIMULATIONS LACK+ S5SE1 BUT A RELIGION ?AT CAN REA* ! EMPT9ESS ( !IR M9DS1 FILL+ IT ) ! FUTURE1 ?AT IS ) HOPE4 ,I KN[ WELL ?AT A RELIGION ( ?IS SORT DOES NOT EXI/1 BUT !RE >E MANY PEOPLE :O TRY H>D TO EXPLOIT ! NE$ ?AT EXI/S = IT4 ,AGA9/ ?IS NE$1 ! RATIONALI/ CLAIMS MADE BY ,C>TESIAN VET]ANS ( ! VICTORIES ?R\< :I* !Y HAVE CONQU]$1 & DE/ROY$1 ! WORLD >E WOR?LESS4 ,!IR *ATT] ( SCI5TIFIC C]TA9TY NO LONG] *>MS ANYONE4 ,NO ONE1 EXCEPT = A SMALL GR\P ( REL5TLESS 9TELLECTUALS1 IS WILL+ TO BELIEVE 9 ! CAPACITY ( SCI5CE TO SOLVE ALL ! PROBLEMS ( HUMANITY1 TO GIVE AN ANSW] TO ALL ! QUE/IONS CONC]N+ ! ET]NAL FE> ( ! UNKN[N4 ,N[ IT OCCURS ?AT EV5 WE AN>*I/S ALL[ \RSELVES TO TAKE ON ?IS EXTRAORD9>Y LAC]ATION1 TO :I* WE %\LD 9/EAD REMA9 EXTRANE\S1 IF WE WANT TO F9D A PA? = ACTION1 A PA? CAPABLE ( MAK+ US UND]/& REALITY1 & ?US PUTT+ US 9 A POSITION TO TRANS=M IT4 ,EV5 WE DON'T QUITE KN[ :AT TO DO4 ,ON ! ONE H&1 WE )DRAW1 HORRIFI$1 9 ! FACE ( ALWAYS DELIRI\S & DISGU/+ MANIFE/ATIONS ( FAI? 9 ALL ITS =MS4 ,SOMETIMES WE HAVE PITY = ! MAN ?AT /OOPS1 ?AT SUFF]S UND] PA91 & ?US ACCEPTS ! IMAGE ( ! 9CR$IBLE SPECT]1 & HOPES1 & CONT9UES TO SUFF] & HOPE4 ,BUT WE CAN HAVE NO MORE ?AN ?IS = HIM4 ,IMM$IATELY AFT]W>DS1 CONTEMPT TAKES OV]1 & ) CONTEMPT1 REFUSAL1 DI/ANC+1 REJECTION4 ,ON ! O!R H&1 /ILL LOOK+ C>EFULLY1 :AT DO WE F9D8 ,WE F9D AN EQUALLY CONTEMPTIBLE MIS]Y1 BUT ONE ?AT KN[S H[ TO DRESS ITSELF WELL1 ) ! G>M5TS ( CULTURE & F9E SPEE*4 ,?IS LATT] MIS]Y BELIEVES 9 SCI5CE & 9 ! WORLD ?AT CAN BE SY/EMIZ$1 9 ! WORLD ?AT IS MOV+ T[>D ITS HIS1 WAIT+ = ! /ORM TO DIE D[N1 UNCONSCI\S & PITILESS 9 ! FACE ( ! PA9 & MIS]Y ( ! RE/ ( ! WORLD4 ,?IS UNIV]SE ( SPECIALI/S & RESPECTABLE PEOPLE ALSO DISGU/S US1 9 MANY WAYS AS MU* AS OR MORE ?AN ! O!R1 ?AT AT LEA/ HAD IGNORANCE & ! PASSIONATE =CE ( EMOTION ON ITS SIDE4 ,BUT US1 :AT DO WE DO8 ,WE DON'T BEAT \R *E/S1 NOR DO WE GO >\ND ) A SLIDE-RULE 9 \R POCKETS4 ,WE BELIEVE NEI!R 9 GOD NOR 9 SCI5CE4 ,NEI!R MIRACLE WORK]S NOR WISE M5 9 :ITE COATS 9T]E/ US4 ,BUT >E WE !N REALLY BEYOND ALL ?IS8 ,I DON'T ?9K SO4 ,M]ELY REFLECT+1 WE REALIZE ?AT WE >E /ILL *ILDR5 ( \R TIMES4 ,BUT1 BE+ AN>*I/S1 WE >E SO 9 A REV]S$ MANN]4 ,WE NAIVELY ?9K ?AT IT IS 5\< TO OV]TURN ! ]RORS ( O!RS LIKE A GLOVE 9 ORD] TO HAVE ! BEAUTIFUL TRU? DI%$ \T 9 %OVELFULS4 ,IT ISN'T SO4 ,!RE=E1 REFUS+ ?AT ( ! OBSCURE :I* EXI/S 9 ! TIMES 9 :I* WE LIVE1 WE SET \R FEET ON ! C]TA9TIES ( A DIFF]5T SCI5CE1 9DE$1 A SCI5CE ?AT WE MU/ BUILD COMPLETELY \RSELVES1 FROM TOP TO BOTTOM1 BUT ?AT LIKE ! O!R ONE WILL BE BAS$ ON REASON & WILL4 ,&1 AT ! SAME TIME1 REFUS+ :AT !RE IS ( ! FUNCTIONAL & UTILIT>IAN 9 SCI5CE1 WE GO 9 SE>* ( S5SATIONS & EMOTIONS1 9TUITIONS & DESIRES FROM :I* WE EXPECT ANSW]S = ALL QUE/IONS1 ANSW]S ?AT CANNOT COME TO ! EXT5T ?AT !SE /IMULI CRUMBLE 9 \R EXCESSIVELY R\< H&S4 ,?US1 WE REEL1 N[ 9 ONE DIRECTION1 N[ 9 ANO!R4 ,WE DON'T HAVE ! IDEOLOGICAL C]TA9TIES ( A FEW DECADES AGO1 BUT ! CRITIQUES WE HAVE DEVELOP$ >E /ILL NOT ABLE TO TELL US ) ! LEA/ BIT ( TRU/WOR?9ESS :AT TO DO4 ,?9K+ ?AT WE >E 9 A POSITION TO ACT BEYOND EV]Y VALUE1 EV]Y F\NDATION1 9 ! MOM5T ?AT WE ASK \RSELVES :AT TO DO1 WE DON'T KN[ H[ TO GIVE \RSELVES A C]TA9 ANSW]4 ,9 O!R TIMES1 WE HAD LESS FE> ( RIDICULE1 WE W]E MORE OBTUSE 9 \R /UBBORN & COH]5T DO+1 LESS WORRI$ AB\T MATT]S ( /YLE4 ,I FE> ?AT WE >E TOO MU* 9 LOVE ) SUBTLETIES1 ) NUANCES4 ,CONT9U+ ALONG ?IS PA?1 WE MIT ( SOME?+ 9 ! C\RSE ( TRANS=MATION1 NOT M]E MONADS1 BRILLIANT 9 \R [N LIK TO EA* O!R4 ,/REAML9$ ,PRODUCTION BY ,ALFR$O ,M4 ,BONANNO ,AMONG ! V>I\S *>ACT]I/ICS ( ! LA/ SEV]AL YE>S1 ! FAILURE ( GLOBAL AUTOMATION 9 ! FACTORIES 7UND]/OOD 9 /RICT S5SE7 MU/ BE PO9T$ \T1 A FAILURE CAUS$ BY ! FAILURE ( ! PROSPECTS &1 IF Y\ WILL1 ! DREAMS ( MASS PRODUCTION4 ,! MEET+ BETWE5 ! TELEMATIC & TRADITIONAL FIX$ PRODUCTION 7H>% ASSEMBLY L9ES LAT] AUTOMAT$ UP TO A C]TA9 PO9T ) ! 9TRODUCTION ( ROBOTS7 HAS NOT DEVELOP$ T[>D A P]FECT+ ( ! L9ES ( AUTOMATION4 ,?IS IS NOT DUE TO PROBLEMS ( A TE*NICAL NATURE1 BUT DUE TO PROBLEMS ( AN ECONOMIC NATURE & ( ! M>KET4 ,! ?RE%OLD ( SATURATION = TE*NOLOGIES ?AT CAN REPLACE MANUAL LABOR HAS NOT BE5 EXCE$$2 ON ! CONTR>Y !RE >E ALWAYS NEW POSSIBILITIES OP5+ 9 ?IS DIRECTION4 ,RA!R1 ! /RATEGIES ( MASS PRODUCTION HAVE BE5 SURPASS$1 & HAVE ?US COME TO HAVE LITTLE IMPORTANCE = ! ECONOMIC MODEL ( MAXIMUM PR(IT4 ,! FLEXIBILITY ?AT ! TELEMATIC GU>ANTE$ & HAS /EADILY MADE POSSIBLE 9 ! PHASE ( ! RISE ( PO/-9DU/RIAL TRANS=MATION AT A C]TA9 PO9T CAUS$ SU* PR(\ND *ANGES 9 ! ORD] ( ! M>KET1 & ?US ( ! DEM&1 AS TO R5D] ! OP5+ ?AT ! TELEMATIC ITSELF HAD MADE POSSIBLE OR RA!R PUT )9 REA* USELESS4 ,?US1 ! FLEXIBILITY & EASE ( PRODUCTION IS MOV$ FROM ! SPH]E ( ! FACTORY 9TO ! SPH]E ( ! M>KET1 CAUS+ A /&/ILL 9 ! TELEMATIC DEVELOPM5T ( AUTOMATION1 & A REFL\RI%+ ( NEW PROSPECTS = AN EXTREMELY DIV]SIFI$ DEM& ?AT WAS UN?9KABLE UNTIL A FEW YE>S AGO4 ,IF ONE READS ! %>EHOLD]S' REPORTS ( SOME ( ! GREAT 9DU/RIES1 IT BECOMES CLE> ?AT AUTOMATION IS ONLY SU/A9ABLE AT 9CREAS+ CO/S ?AT QUICKLY BE COME ANTI-ECONOMICAL4 ,ONLY ! PROSPECT ( SOCIAL DISORD] ( A GREAT 9T5SITY C\LD /ILL DRIVE ! F9ANCIALLY BURD5SOME PA? ( GLOBAL AUTOMATION4 ,= ?IS REASON1 ! R$UCTION ( ! CO/S ( PRODUCTION IS N[ 5TRU/$ NOT ONLY TO ! CO/ ( LABOR1 AS HAS OCCURR$ 9 ! PA/ SEV]AL YE>S AS A CONSEQU5CE ( MASSIVE TELEMATIC REPLACEM5T1 BUT ALSO TO A RATIONAL MANAGEM5T ( SO-CALL$ PRODUCTIVE R$UNDANCY4 ,9 %ORT1 A RU?LESS ANALYSIS ( WA/E1 FROM :ATEV] PO9T ( VIEW1 &1 FIR/ ( ALL1 FROM ! P]SPECTIVE ( PRODUCTION TIMES4 ,9 ?IS WAY1 BY A V>IETY ( MEANS1 PRODUCTIVE PRESSURE IS EX]CIS$ ONCE AGA9 ON ! PRODUC] 9 FLE% & BLOOD1 DISMANTL+ ! IDEOLOGY ( CONTA9M5T ON ! BASIS ( :I* AN EAS+ ( ! CONDITIONS ( SUFF]+ & EXPLOITATION ?AT HAVE ALWAYS BE5 *>ACT]I/IC ( WAGE LABOR WAS CR$IT$ TO TELEMATIC TE*NOLOGY4 ,! R$UCTION ( WA/E ?US BECOMES ! NEW AIM ( /REAML9$ PRODUCTION1 9 ITS TIME BAS$ ON ! FLEXIBILITY ( LABOR ALREADY CONSOLIDAT$ & ! PRODUCTIVE POT5TIALITY GU>ANTE$ BY ! TELEMATIC C\PL+ AS ITS />T+ PO9T4 ,& ?IS R$UCTION ( WA/E FALLS 5TIRELY ON ! BACK ( ! PRODUC]4 ,9 FACT1 ! MA!MATICAL ANALYSIS REALIZ$ ?R\< COMPLEX SY/EMS ALREADY 9 WIDESPREAD USE 9 ! MAJOR 9DU/RIES CAN EASILY SOLVE ! TE*NICAL PROBLEMS ( CONTRACTORS1 :I* IS TO SAY1 ?OSE RELATIVE TO ! COMB9ATION ( RAW MAT]IALS & MA*9]Y1 9 VIEW ( MA9T5ANCE4 ,BUT ! SOLUTION TO !SE PROBLEMS W\LD REMA9 A M>G9AL MATT] TO PRODUCTION AS A :OLE IF ! USE ( PRODUCTION TIME W]E NOT ALSO PLAC$ UND] A REGIME ( CONTROL4 ,?US1 ! OLD TAYLORISM COMES BACK 9TO FA%ION1 ?\< N[ IT IS FILT]$ ?R\< ! NEW PSY*OLOGICAL & COMPUT+ TE*NOLOGIES4 ,! COMPREH5SIVE FLEXIBILITY ( L>GE 9DU/RY IS BAS$ ON A SECTORAL FLEXIBILITY ( V>I\S COMPON5TS1 AS WELL AS ON ! FLEXIBILITY ( ! SMALL MANUFACTUR]S ?AT P]IPH]ALLY SUPPORT ! PRODUCTIVE UNITY ( COMM&4 ,WORK TIME IS ?US ! BASIC UNITY = ! NEW PRODUCTION2 ITS CONTROL1 )\T WA/E BUT ALSO )\T /UPIDLY REPRESSIVE IRRITATIONS1 REMA9S ! 9DISP5SABLE CONNECTION BETWE5 ! OLD & NEW PRODUCTIVE MODELS4 ,!SE NEW =MS ( CONTROL HAVE A P]VASIVE NATURE4 ,9 O!R WORDS1 !Y T5D TO P5ETRATE 9TO ! M5TALITY ( ! 9DIVIDUAL PRODUC]1 TO CREATE G5]AL PSY*OLOGICAL CONDITIONS SO ?AT LITTLE BY LITTLE EXT]NAL CONTROL ?R\< A TIMETABLE ( PRODUCTION IS REPLAC$ BY SELF-CONTROL & SELF-REGULATION ( PRODUCTIVE TIMES & RHY?MS AS A FUNCTION ( ! *OICE ( OBJECTIVES1 :I* IS /ILL DET]M9$ BY ! BODIES ?AT MANAGE PRODUCTIVE UNITY4 ,BUT !SE DECISIONS MII\S PRODUCTION UNITS ) ! AIM ( IMPLANT+ ! PROCESS ( SELF-MANAGEM5T4 ,WE >E SPEAK+ ( 0SUITABLE SYN*RONISM01 NOT REALIZ$ ONCE & = ALL1 BUT DEALT ) TIME & AGA91 = S+LE PRODUCTIVE P]IODS OR SPECIFIC PRODUCTION CAMPAIGNS & PROGRAMS1 ) ! AIM ( CREAT+ A CONV]G5CE ( 9T]E/ ( 9T]E/S BETWE5 WORK]S & EMPLOY]S1 A CONV]G5CE TO BE REALIZ$ NOT ONLY ON ! TE*NICAL T]RA9 ( PRODUCTION1 BUT ALSO ON ! 9DIRECT PLANE ( SOLICITATION ( SOME CLAIM TO ! DEM&1 :I* IS TO SAY1 ON ! PLANE ( ! M>KET4 ,9 FACT1 IT IS REALLY 9 ! M>KET ?AT TWO MOVEM5TS )9 ! NEW PRODUCTIVE FLEXIBILITY >E JO9$ TOGE!R4 ,! OLD FACTORY LOOK$ TO ITSELF AS ! C5T] ( ! PRODUCTIVE WORLD & ITS /RUCTURES AS ! /ABLE ELEM5T FROM :I* TO />T 9 ORD] TO CONQU] EV]-EXP&+ SECTIONS ( CONSUMPTION TO SATISFY4 ,?IS W\LD 9DIRECTLY HAVE TO PRODUCE A WORK]-C5T]$ IDEOLOGY1 MANAG$ ?R\< GUIDANCE BY A P>TY ( ! SORT CALL$ PROLET>IAN4 ,! DECL9E ( ?IS IDEOLOGICAL-PRACTICAL P]SPECTIVE C\LD NOT BE MORE EVID5T TODAY1 NOT SO MU* BECAUSE ( ! COLLAPSE ( REAL SOCIALISM1 & ALL ! DIRECT & 9DIRECT CONSEQU5CES ?AT FOLL[$ FROM ?IS & CONT9UE TO GR[ \T ( IT1 BUT 9 REALITY1 DUE TO ! PRODUCTIVE *ANGES :I* WE >E DISCUSS+4 ,!RE IS ?US NO LONG] A DI/9CTION BETWE5 ! RIGIDITY ( PRODUCTION & ! *AOTIC & UNPR$ICTABLE FLEXIBILITY ( ! M>KET4 ,BO? !SE ASPECTS >E N[ BR\IABILITY & /REAML9+4 ,! GREAT] ABILITY TO P5ETRATE 9TO CONSUMPTION1 :E!R =ESEE+ & SOLICIT+ IT OR RE/RA9+ IT1 ALL[S ! OLD *AOS ( ! M>KET TO BE TRANS=M$ 9TO AN ACCEPTABLE1 IF NOT 5TIRELY PR$ICTABLE1 FLEXIBILITY4 ,AT ! SAME TIME1 ! OLD RIGIDITY ( ! WORLD ( PRODUCTION HAS *ANGE 9TO ! NEW PRODUCTIVE SPE$4 ,!SE TWO MOVEM5TS >E COM+ TOGE!R 9 A NEW UNIFY+ DIM5SION ON :I* ! ECONOMIC & SOCIAL DOM9ATION ( TOMORR[ WILL BE BUILT4 ,A ,EULOGY TO ,OP9ION BY ,ALFR$O ,M4 ,BONANNO ,OP9ION IS A VA/ M]*&ISE ?AT EV]YONE POSSESSES & USES4 ,ITS PRODUCTION 9VOLVES A L>GE PORTION ( ! ECONOMY1 & ITS CONSUMPTION TAKES UP MU* ( PEOPLE'S TIME4 ,ITS MA9 *>ACT]I/IC IS CL>ITY4 ,WE HA/5 TO PO9T \T ?AT !RE IS NO SU* ?+ AS AN UNCLE> OP9ION4 ,EV]Y?+ IS EI!R YES OR NO4 ,DIFF]5T LEVELS ( ?\E =EIGN TO IT4 ,H5CE ! GREAT /R5G? ?AT OP9ION GIVES TO ?OSE :O USE IT & CONSUME IT 9 MAK+ DECISIONS OR IMPOSE IT ON ! DECISIONS ( O!RS4@> ,9 A WORLD ?AT IS MOV+ AT HI< SPE$ T[>D POSITIVE_/NEGATIVE B9>Y LOGIC1 FROM R$ BUTTON TO BLACK1 ?IS R$UCTION IS AN IMPORTANT FACTOR 9 ! DEVELOPM5T ( CIVIL COHABITATION ITSELF4 ,:AT W\LD BECOME ( \R FUTURE IF WE W]E TO CONT9UE TO SUPPORT \RSELVES ON ! UNRESOLV$ CRUELTY ( D\BT8 ,H[ C\LD WE BE US$8 ,H[ C\LD WE PRODUCE8 ,CL>ITY EM]GES :5 ! POSSIBILITY ( REAL *OICE IS R$UC$4 ,ONLY ?OSE ) CLE> IDEAS KN[ :AT TO DO4 ,BUT IDEAS >E NEV] CLE>1 SO !RE >E ?OSE ON ! SC5E :O CL>IFY !M = US1 BY SUPPLY+ SIMPLE COMPREH5SIBLE 9/RUM5TS3 NOT >GUM5TS BUT QUIZZES1 NOT /UDIES BUT ALT]NATIVE B9>IES4 ,SIMPLY DAY & NII\S FACETS ( ! PROBLEM1 M]ELY A HIT >E CANCEL$ BY B9>Y PROPOSITIONS1 & >E REPLAC$ ) ! UTILITY ( 0CORRECT0 DECISIONS4 ,BUT NO ONE IS /UPID 5\< TO BELIEVE ?AT ! WORLD RE/S ON TWO LOGICAL POSITIVE & NEGATIVE B9>IES4 ,SURELY !RE IS A PLACE = UND]/&+1 A PLACE :]E IDEAS AGA9 TAKE OV] & KN[L$GE REGA9S LO/ GR\ND4 ,!RE=E1 ! DESIRE >ISES TO DELEGATE ?IS ALL TO O!RS :O SEEM TO HOLD ! ANSW]S TO ! ELABORATION ( COMPLEXITY BECAUSE !Y SUGGE/ SIMPLE SOLUTIONS TO US4 ,!Y PORTRAY ?IS ELABORATION AS SOME?+ ?AT HAS TAK5 PLACE ELSE:]E & !RE=E REPRES5T !MSELVES AS WITNESSES & DEPOSITORIES ( SCI5CE4 ,SO ! CIRCLE CLOSES4 ,! SIMPLIFI]S PRES5T !MSELVES AS ?OSE :O GU>ANTEE ! VALIDITY ( ! OP9IONS ASK$1 & !IR CONT9UAL CORRECT PRODUCTION 9 B9>Y =M4 ,!Y SEEM TO BE W>Y ( ! FACT ?AT ONCE OP9ION -- ?IS MANIPULATION ( CL>ITY -- HAS DE/ROY$ ALL CAPACITY TO UND]/& ! 9TRICATE TISSUE ?AT UND]LIES IT1 ! COMPLEX UNFOLD+S ( ! PROBLEMS ( CONSCI5CE1 ! FEV]$ ACTIVITY ( SYMBOLS & MEAN+S1 REF]5CES & 9/ITUTIONS1 IT DE/ROYS ! CONNECTIVE TISSUES ( DIFF]5CES4 ,IT ANNIHILATES !M 9 ! B9>Y UNIV]SE ( CODIFICATION :]E REALITY ONLY SEEMS TO HAVE TWO POSSIBLE SOLUTIONS1 ! LIKET :]E EV]Y POSSIBLE1 USELESS V>IETY ( ! SAME PRODUCT DOES NOT MEAN WEAL? & ABUNDANCE BUT M]ELY M]CANTILE WA/E1 AN 9CREASE 9 9=MATION DOES NOT PRODUCE A QUALITATIVE GR[? 9 OP9ION4 ,IT DOES NOT PRODUCE ANY REAL CAPACITY TO DECIDE :AT IS TRUE OR FALSE1 GOOD OR BAD1 BEAUTIFUL OR UGLY4 ,IT M]ELY R$UCES ONE ( !SE ASPECTS TO A SY/EMATIC REPRES5TATION ( A DOM9ANT MODEL4 ,9 REALITY1 !RE IS NO GOOD ON ! ONE SIDE OR BAD ON ! O!R4 ,RA!R !RE IS A :OLE RANGE ( CONDITIONS1 CASES1 SITUATIONS1 !ORIES & PRACTICES :I* ONLY A CAPACITY TO UND]/& CAN GRASP1 A CAPACITY TO USE ! 9TELLECT ) ! NECESS>Y PRES5CE ( S5SIBILITY & 9TUITION4 ,CULTURE IS NOT A MASS ( 9=MATION1 BUT A LIV+ & (T5 CONTRADICTORY SY/EM1 ?R\< :I* WE GA9 KN[L$GE ( ! WORLD & \RSELVES4 ,?IS IS A PROCESS :I* IS AT TIMES PA9FUL & H>DLY EV] SATISFY+1 ) :I* WE REALIZE ! RELATION%IPS :I* CON/ITUTE \R LIFE & \R CAPACITY TO LIVE4 ,BY CANCEL+ \T ALL ( !SE NUANCES1 WE AGA9 F9D \RSELVES ) A /ATI/ICAL CURVE 9 \R H&S1 AN ILLUSORY C\RSE ( EV5TS PRODUC$ BY A MA!MATICAL MODEL1 NOT A FRACTUR$ & OV]:ELM+ REALITY1 ,OP9ION PROVIDES US ) C]TA9TY ON ! ONE H&1 BUT ON ! O!R IT IMPOV]I%ES US & DEPRIVES US ( ! CAPACITY TO /RUGGLE1 BECAUSE WE 5D UP CONV9C$ ?AT ! WORLD IS SIMPL] ?AN IT IS4 ,?IS IS TOTALLY 9 ! 9T]E/ ( ?OSE :O CONTROL US4 ,A MASS ( SATISFI$ SUBJECTS CONV9C$ ?AT SCI5CE IS ON !IR SIDE1 ?AT IS :AT !Y NE$ 9 ORD] TO REALIZE ! PROJECTS ( DOM9ATION 9 ! FUTURE4 ,! ,SPECT] ,?AT ,REASSURES AS IT ,KILLS BY ,ALFR$O ,M4 ,BONANNO ,ALL AU?ORITY COMES FROM GOD1 SAID ! APO/LE1 & HE WAS RITS1 & !NCE ALSO ! CONCEPT ( ! SACR$ & UNT\*ABLE FUNCTION ( GOV]NM5T & JU/ICE1 COMES FROM ! IDEA ( GOD4 ,! 0IMMUTABLE01 DREAM$ UP BY PEOPLE AS PROTECTION AGA9/ ! FE> ( ! FUTURE & ( ! UNKN[N ?AT >E HIDD5 9 ! MI/S )9 :I* ?IS LA/ IS 5VELOP$1 IS GOD1 ! SPECT] ?AT REASSURES AS IT KILLS4 ,BUT 9 ORD] = AU?ORITY TO BE EX]CIS$ 9 ! SPH]E ( HUMAN MATT]S1 ?AT IS TO SAY1 TO BECOME /ATE & GOV]NM5T1 TO 9S9UATE ITSELF 9TO EV]Y FIB] FROM :I* SOCIETY IS COMPOS$1 IT DOESN'T JU/ NE$ ! SUPPORT PROVID$ BY ! IDEA ( GOD2 IT ALSO NE$S =CE1 REAL =CE1 SUITABLE TO ! TIMES & CONDITIONS ( ! CONFLICT ) ALL ?OSE :O1 BECAUSE !Y SUFF] ! AU?ORITY & PAY ! CONSEQU5CES = IT 9 T]MS ( REPRESSION & RE/RICTIONS ( FRE$OM1 OPPOSE IT4 ,& ?IS =CE IS MADE UP ( WEAPONS & >MIES1 GOV]NM5TS & P>LIAM5TS1 COPS & SPIES1 PRIE/S & LAWS1 JUDGES & PR(ESSORS1 9 %ORT1 ( ! 5TIRE APP>ATUS AT ! S]VICE ( P[] )\T :I* IT REMA9S A DEAD LETT]4 ,BUT ! =CE IS BAS$ ON WEAL?1 ?AT IS ON ! POSSIBILITY ( ACCUMULAT+ MONEY OR ( SECUR+ ONESELF CONTROL ( ! FL[S 9 :I* ! CIRCULATION ( MONEY IS REALIZ$4 ,) ! DEVELOPM5T ( COMM]CE & 9DU/RY1 PASS+ FROM ANCI5T TIMES ?R\< ?OSE ( ! 9DU/RIAL REVOLUTION UP 9TO ! EPO* 9 :I* WE LIVE1 AT ! BEG9N+ ( ! ?IRD MILL5NIUM1 :5 WEAL? B5DS 9TO A SPASMODIC ESS5TIALIZATION ( ITSELF1 PASS+ FROM ! OLD & /ATIC =M ( ACCUMULATION TO ! NEW1 DYNAMIC =M ( FLUX & HI< VELOCITY CIRCULATION1 ITS FUNCTION AS ! BASIS ( AU?ORITY HAS NOT *ANG$4 ,SO WE CAN SAY ?AT AN AU?ORITY )\T WEAL? IS A CONTRADICTION4 ,ALL ! TYRANTS ( ! PA/1 LIKE ALL ! POLITICAL PEOPLE ( TODAY ?AT HAVE MANAG$ & CONT9UE TO MANAGE ! PUBLIC ?+1 HAVE HAD IMM5SE QUANTITY ( WEAL? 9 !IR H&S4 ,A POOR P]SON CAN NEV] EX]CISE AU?ORITY1 :I* IS :Y AN AU?ORITY LACK+ ! WEAL? ?AT C\LD =M IT 9TO 9/ITUTIONS & GU>ANTEE IT AS SU* 9 ! CONCRETE EX]CISE ( ITS FUNCTIONS T5DS TO WEAK5 9TO AU?ORITATIV5ESS1 !NCE 9TO SOME?+ QUITE DIFF]5T4 ,A POOR P]SON MAY BE AU?ORITATIVE = H] KN[L$GE1 HIS COH]5CE1 H] ACCURACY1 BUT HE W\LD NEV] CON/ITUTE AN AU?ORITY4 ,?IS IS :Y !Y ,*UR*1 AW>E ( ITS HI/ORICAL TASK1 PASS$ ?R\< A !ORETICAL & PRACTICAL TORM5T ?AT LA/$ ?REE C5TURIES & C>RI$ IT FROM ! 9ITIAL CRITIQUE ( WEAL? 7C>RI$ \T 9 ALL ! TEXTS ( PRIMITIVE *RI/IANITY71 TO ! JU/IFICATION & ACCEPTANCE ( WEAL?1 & ! TIME 9 :I* ?IS VOYAGE WAS COMPLET$ CORRESPONDS PRECISELY TO ! PHILOSOPHICAL MATURITY ( ,/4 ,AUGU/9E & ! CONQUE/ ( P[] ?R\< ,CON/ANT9E1 NE>LY SIMULTANE\S EV5TS4 ,?IS IS :Y 9 ! 5CYCLICAL ,EVANGELIUM ,VITAE1 ! POPE CONFUSES US1 LIMIT+ HIMSELF TO QUOT+ ONLY HALF ( ! CITATION & ?US MISAPPROPRIAT+ IT TO JU/IFY 7OR RA!R E/ABLI%7 ! 0GOSPEL ( LIFE0 AS HE CALLS IT4 ,! FABLE SPEAKS ( A Y\NG MAN :O APPROA*$ ! ,MA/] & ASK$ HIM :AT TO DO 9 ORD] TO OBTA9 ET]NAL LIFE1 & ! ,MA/] TOLD HIM TO OBS]VE ! COMM&M5TS1 GO+ ?R\< A LI/ ?AT BEG9S ) 0,?\ %ALT NOT KILL04 ,IT IS FROM ?IS ?AT ! POPE DRAWS HIS CUE TO E/ABLI% ! 0GOSPEL ( LIFE0 C>RY+ \T AN ACT ( CONFUSION RA!R ?AN REASON+4 ,9 O!R WORDS1 ! MIX+ ( ! ORD] ( ! COMM&M5TS PUT 9TO PLAY H]E 9 ! GOSPEL TEXT1 :I* PLACES 0,?\ %ALT NOT KILL0 9 ! FIR/ PLACE1 IS ! PRO( ( ! WILL TO DEF5D LIFE AS ! PRIM>Y ESS5TIAL GOOD4 ,BUT ! TEXT ( ! /ORY 9 ,MAT!W CONT9UES4 ,9 FACT1 IT TELLS US ?AT ! RI* Y\NG MAN RESPONDS BY SAY+ ?AT HE HAD FOLL[$ ALL ( !SE COMM&M5TS1 BUT WANT$ TO KN[ SOME?+ MORE1 & ! RESPONSE WAS QUITE PRECISE3 0,IF Y\ WANT TO BE P]FECT1 GO1 SELL ALL ?AT Y\ [N1 GIVE IT TO ! POOR & Y\ WILL HAVE TREASURE 9 HEAV51 !N COME FOLL[ ME40 ,AS IF TO SAY ?AT WEAL? W]E AN OB/ACLE & ?AT ! ,*UR* CANNOT ACCEPT IT4 ,BUT TO REFUSE WEAL? W\LD HAVE MEANT ?AT ! ,*UR* W\LD CONDEMN ITSELF TO EXCLUSION FROM P[] & 9VALIDATE ITS P>TICIPATION 9 E>?LY AU?ORITY ?AT IT ALWAYS CONSID]$ AS A PROVISIONAL PASSAGE T[>D ! TOTAL CONQUE/ ( P[] & ! DOM9ATION ( ! WORLD1 REALIZ$1 ( C\RSE1 = ! GREAT] GLORY ( GOD4 ,?IS IS :Y IT NEV] ACCEPT$ ?IS REFUSAL1 BUT ALWAYS P]SECUT$ ) VIOL5CE & DEA?1 ) FIRE & SWORD1 ALL ?OSE :O SUPPORT$ ! NECESSITY = ! ,*UR* TO BE POOR 9 ORD] TO SPEAK TO ! POOR & NOT CONV]SE ) ! RI* OV] ! TOPICS ?AT 9T]E/ !M RELAT+ TO ! MANAGEM5T ( P[] OR TO MUTUALLY CONT5D ) !M = P[]4 ,& ?IS IS :Y ! ,*UR* HAS ALWAYS CONSID]$ ALL ?OSE :O SUPPORT ! REFUSAL ( WEAL? & ALL ?OSE :O 9T5D TO FI? TO BE H]ETICS4 ,IF IT HAD TAK5 ! CONCRETE =CE ?AT COMES FROM WEAL? & FROM COMM]CE ) ! P[]FUL1 ! ,*UR* W\LD HAVE REMOV$ ! POSSIBILITY ( ACT+ AS ! PRACTICAL F\NDATION ( AU?ORITY FROM ! IDEA ( GOD & W\LD HAVE =C$ AU?ORITY TO BECOME BLATANT TYRANNY1 CLE> & VISIBLE TO EV]YONE4 ,CONT9UE TO ,SPEAK TO ,ME BY ,ALFR$O ,M4 ,BONANNO ,FAC+ ! UND]/&+ ( ONESELF & O!RS1 UNSUSPECT$ ASPECTS ( AW>5ESS >E FREQU5TLY DISCOV]$4 ,:5 WE APPROA* A PROBLEM AB\T :I* WE KN[ LITTLE OR A P]SON :OM WE HAVE NEV] MET BE=E1 WE FEEL A S5SE ( PANIC 7OR ( PLEASURE1 A SUBTLE DIFF]5CE ?AT IS NEV] COMPLETELY CLE>74 ,WILL WE MANAGE TO GET TO ! BOTTOM ( IT8 ,WE ASK \RSELVES4 ,& ! ANSW] IS NOT ALWAYS POSITIVE4 ,MO/ ( ! TIME WE LOOK AT ! 0/RANG]0 ) SUSPICION1 ! SUSPICION ?AT ALWAYS EXI/S ( ! DIFF]5CE ?AT IS NOT YET CODIFI$4 ,:]E WILL ?IS 0/RANG]0 TAKE US8 ,C]TA9LY T[>D NEW ?+S1 & :AT WILL !SE BE LIKE8 ,!Y MI% AWAK5+ & ! NEXT4 ,FROM ?IS1 IT IS ALL ! MORE NECESS>Y NOT TO REVEAL \RSELVES4 ,S9CE \R P]SONAL WORLD1 \R [N WORLD1 IS :AT IS AT /AKE :5 WE RISK V5TUR+ 9TO ! UNKN[N1 WE >E DISPOS$ TO DEF5D IT TO ! DEA?2 ITS B\ND>IES H>D5 & PROPOSE AN 9T]PRETIVE S*EME4 ,! 0/RANG]01 :E!R P]SON OR PROBLEM1 IS ?US CATALOG$ 9 ! SPH]E ( \R S*EMES2 WE DILUTE ! =M 9 ! /RUCTURE1 SUPPRESS IT BY =CE1 EXPECT+ ! O!R TO CON=M ITSELF TO \R NE$S4 ,?US1 AFT] HAV+ KILL$ IT 9 ! RITUAL MANN] ?AT WE CAN & )9 ! LIMITS ( \R CAPACITY AS KILL]S1 WE REPRODUCE IT1 ADAPT$ TO \R AIMS1 EV5 CONT9U+ TO FE$ \R 9CLUSIVE DESIRES1 DREAMS & SLEEP4 ,9 ?IS WAY1 SOME ( US1 & C]TA9LY NOT ! WOR/1 WRAP \RSELVES UP 9 ! COCOON ( CODIFICATION1 JUDG+ OR SUSP5D+ JUDGM5T )\T BE+ AW>E ( IT4 ,BUT 9 DAILY PRACTICE1 ?IS SUSP5SION IS ALWAYS EXPRESS$ 9 TRU/+ ! O!R TO REMA9 9 ! SPH]E ( \R P]SPECTIVE BY ITSELF1 )\T \R NE$+ TO DO IT VIOL5CE4 ,9 !SE CASES1 ! COMMON S5SE ( RIDICULE HELPS 9 F9D+ TUN+S ?AT W\LD O!RWISE BE REVEAL$ AS NONEXI/5T4 ,PLEASE1 NO %\T+ Y\R CONTEMPT = ORD]2 IT IS SUFFICI5T ?AT Y\ %[ ME ?AT Y\R WAY ( LIV+ FOLL[S A LIVELY1 DANC+ QUALITATIVE LOGIC & NOT ! OBLIGATION ( ! R\T9E ( QUIET & ! CODE4 ,BUT %[ ME ?IS ) LOGICAL1 ACCURATE CONNECTIONS4 ,PLEASE1 TELL ME ?AT Y\ >E CRAZY1 JU/ LIKE ME1 BUT SAY IT ) CL>ITY4 ,PLEASE1 SPEAK TO ME ( ! T]RIBLE %UDD] ( D>KNESS1 BUT TELL ME AB\T IT 9 ! LIE SWEET LULLABIES = MY HE>T'S NE$S -- BUT SPEAK ( !M 9 AN ORD]LY MANN] SO ?AT ,I CAN UND]/& !M & ?ANKS TO !M UND]/& :AT DE/RUCTION IS4 ,9 %ORT1 ,I WANT ! WORDS TO REA* ME 9 A WELL-ORGANIZ$ =M4 ,ALAS1 IF Y\ />T TO %\T1 ,I WILL NO LONG] LI/54 ,IT IS GOOD TO DE/ROY1 BUT ) ! ORD] ?AT LOGIC IMPOSES4 ,O!RWISE WE GO 9TO ! *AOS ( ! UNREPEATABLE1 :]E EV]Y?+ FADES 9TO ! 9COMPREH5SIBLE4 ,YES1 GRANT$1 SOME?+ C\LD REA* ME EV5 ?R\< ! P]PLEX+ %\TS ( AN ,ALG]IAN M>KETPLACE ON A FEA/ DAY1 BUT ,I AM NOT US$ TO ?AT LIFE1 TO ?AT UNPR$ICTABLE & FLEET+ DANCE1 TO ! UN=ESE5 APPE>ANCE ( ! 0/RANG]04 ,IT IS NECESS>Y ?AT Y\ PUT ! CODE ( HABIT BE=E ME1 ?AT ! LANGUAGE BE MADE FULL ( IMM$IAT5ESS4 ,SPEAK TO ME1 ,I BEG Y\1 SO ?AT ! WORD BECOMES ! UMBILICAL CORD BETWE5 ME & ! WORLD ( :AT HAS ALREADY HAPP5$1 SO ?AT NO?+ PRES5TS ITSELF AS BE+ ?R[N SUDD5LY 9TO ! D>K DIM5SION ( *AOS4 ,SPEAK TO ME ( LOVE1 ( Y\R LOVE1 = ME1 ( EV]Y POSSIBLE LOVE1 EV5 ( ! MO/ REMOTE & DIFFICULT TO UND]/&1 ( ! VIOL5CE ?AT GOES AT IT FROM ! HIP1 ( VIOL5CE & DEA?1 BUT1 9 ORD] TO LET ME SEE IT ) ! EYES ( ! M9D1 SPEAK TO ME AB\T IT IMPRISON$1 CAPTUR$ 9 ! SLIMY & CORRUPTIBLE WEB ( WORDS4 ,SPEAK TO ME AB\T IT C>EFULLY1 ,I BEG Y\1 SO ?AT MY HE>T CAN BE> ITS REP]CUSSIONS4 ,!N ,I WILL MAKE A HABIT ( IT4 ,& REALLY1 S9CE Y\ HAVE SPOK5 TO ME AB\T IT1 ! LOVE WILL BECOME FAMILI> TO ME & ,I WILL C>RY IT ) ME EV]Y:]E1 LIKE ONE C>RIES A KNIFE 9 ONE'S POCKET1 A HEAVY OBJECT ?AT FURNI%ES SECURITY4 ,AS TO ?AT O!R POSSIBILITY1 AS TO ! 0/RANG]0 ?AT PRES5T$ H]SELF SUDD5LY BE=E MY EYES1 LIKE A ?IEF 9 ! NI*Y1 ?AT 9 :I* Y\ & ,I BELIEVE1 DESCRIBE ITS CONDITIONS ( UNC]TA9TY TO ME1 ! UNPR$ICTABILITY ( RELATIONS BETWE5 HUMAN BE+S F9ALLY FRE$ ( EV]Y CON/RA9T2 ) Y\R CALM1 P]SUASIVE WORDS1 TELL ME ( ! F]M5T ( ! PASSIONS ?AT BREAK LOOSE1 ! HATR$ & ! DESIRE = DE/RUCTION ?AT DON'T DISAPPE> FROM ONE DAY TO ! NEXT1 ! FE> & ! BLOOD ?AT DON'T /OP SPREAD+ & FL[+ 9 ! VE9S ( A SOCIETY ?AT IS F9ALLY DIFF]5T FROM EV]Y NIE ( ! PA/4 ,TELL ME1 ,I BEG Y\1 BUT DO IT 9 A WAY ?AT DOES NOT FRI ?AT :I* %\TS )9 Y\1 FRI FROM ANY ACCEPTANCE ( MY WILL1 Y\R [N BE+ IRREPRESSIBLY HO/ILE TO ALL CODIFICATION JU/ LIKE M9E1 AFT] ALL4 ,NOT TELL+ ME ALL !SE ?+S1 Y\ W\LD /OP FRI*ISM & ,CRITICISM ( ! ,EXI/5T BY ,B5$ETTO ,GALLUCCI ,9 A HI/ORICAL CONTEXT LIKE ! ONE 9 :I* WE LIVE 7! COLLAPSE ( IDEOLOGICAL DOGMAS1 9/ITUTIONAL C]TA9TIES1 ETC47 IT IS A MATT] ( FACT ?AT MORE & MORE PEOPLE >E BEG9N+ TO %[ AN 9T]E/ 9 AN>*ISM & TO TAKE LIB]T>IAN IDEAS 9TO CONSID]ATION4 ,AN>*I/ GR\PS & CIRCLES & LIB]T>IAN COLLECTIVES >E GR[+4 ,AT ?IS PO9T1 ,I DON'T ?9K IT W\LD BE UNTIMELY TO TALK AB\T ! DIFF]5CE BETWE5 ! 9DIVIDUAL COMRADE :O DISCOV]S AN AN>*I/ AW>5ESS & !RE=E BEG9S TO SPREAD H] AN>*I/ IDEAS & ! CLASSICAL MILITANT ( A POLITICAL ORGANIZATION4 ,AS AN>*I/S1 WE >E FOCUS$ ON ! CRITIQUE ( ! EXI/5CE ?AT SURR\NDS US1 BUT WE DON'T =GET TO TAKE TIME = 9DIVIDUAL SELF-CRITICISM ?AT S]VES TO MAKE US KEEP \R FEET QUITE FIRMLY ON ! GR\ND4 ,BUT SELF-CRITICISM IS LACK+ AMONG POLITICAL MILITANTS1 & ?IS 9EVITABLY LEADS !M TO SET !MSELVES UP ON A P$E/AL ( >ROGANCE & PRESUMPTION4 ,BY SELF-CRITICISM1 ,I MEAN ! 9DIVIDUAL PROCESS ( SELF-ANALYSIS ?AT IS A P>T ( ! LIFE ( EV]Y LIB]T>IAN1 ?R\< :I* !Y CON/ANTLY BR+ !IR WAY ( ?9K+1 ACT+1 SPEAK+ & RELAT+ ) O!RS 9TO QUE/ION4 ,IT ISN'T A QUE/ION ( M]ELY EXAM9+ ONE'S *>ACT] OR TEMP]AM5T4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 IT'S A QUE/ION ( DRIV+ \T ALL ! %IT ?AT ,P[] & ! ,*UR* 7AS WELL AS ! CURR5T EV]YDAY CONSUM] SOCIETY7 %OVES 9TO US FROM ! MOM5T WE'RE BORN4 ,C]TA9 9T]NAL ME*ANISMS ) :I* WE W]E %AP$ FROM A MO/ T5D] AGE >E QUITE DIFFICULT TO DE/ROY EV5 :5 ONE HAS ! LUCIDITY TO RECOGNIZE ?AT !Y >E 9 CLE> CONFLICT ) LIB]T>IAN PR9CIPLES4 ,ONE ALWAYS T5DS TO ?9K1 0AFT] ALL1 ,I AM MADE ?IS WAY4440 ,IT IS SAFE TO SAY ?AT IT IS A BIT HUMILIAT+ TO DISCOV] PEOPLE :O SPEAK ( SELF-DET]M9ATION1 AN>*Y & REVOLUTION :O >E TOTALLY 9CAPABLE ( C>RY+ \T AN 9T]NAL REVOLUTION ?AT IS NECESS>Y = DE/ROY+ AU?ORIT>IANISM 9 :ATEV] =M IT MANIFE/S ITSELF4 ,= EV]Y FUTURE COLLECTIVE PROJECT ( LIB]ATION1 AN 9DIVIDUAL VOYAGE TO GRASP HOLD ( ! AW>5ESS ( AN>*I/ IDEAS IS ESS5TIAL1 A PROJECT ?AT CANNOT BE SEP>AT$ FROM A PR(\ND CRITIQUE ( ! PA?OG5IC G]MS ( ,P[] PRES5T 9 EV]YONE ( US4 ,A ,YELL[ ,ROSE BY ,ALFR$O ,M4 ,BONANNO ,BUT HAVE WE TRULY F9I%$ 9T]PRET+ ! WORLD8 ,I DID NOT REALIZE ?AT ANYONE WAS TRANS=M+ IT4 ,! ABSOLUTELY 0O!R0 EV5T DOES NOT /& \T ON ! HORIZON1 :]EAS ! ME*ANISMS ( ! M>KET >E ORGANIZ+ !MSELVES ON ! OLD CODES & REPRODUCE !MSELVES1 JU/IFY+ POV]TY & WEAL?1 ! ABSURD POL>IZATIONS ( 0! WORLD GOES ?IS WAY04 ,9 ,A ,YELL[ ,ROSE1 ,BORGES MAKES US SEE H[ ! POET ,M>9O1 PR9CE ( F9E SPEE*1 SEV5TE5? C5TURY ,ITALIAN MA/] ( HUMAN LETT]S1 REALIZ$ AT ! PO9T ( DEA? ?AT SPEAK+ 7OR DO+1 :I* IS REALLY ! SAME ?+7 AS REPRODUCTION & MIRROR ( ! WORLD1 AS GR& 9T]PRETIVE PICTURE1 IS NOT POSSIBLE4 ,HE CONCLUDES MORE MODE/LY ) DO+ 7& ?US ALSO SPEAK+7 AS EXCESS1 AS SUP]FLU\S ADDITION TO A COMPOSITION ?AT IS ALREADY COMPLETE1 EV5 IF1 = US1 IT IS UNWELCOME & 9TOL]ABLE4 ,?\E NEV] SIMPLY PROJECT$1 I4E41 !Y DON'T HAVE A MEAN+ 0M]ELY0 AS A FUNCTION ( :AT !Y CONTRIBUTE TO DET]M9+ OR :AT ONE C\LD =ESEE !M AS DET]M9+4 ,FIR/ ( ALL1 !Y >E A PREVI\S HI/ORY1 I4E41 !Y >E !MSELVES EV5TS1 SIGNIFICANT 9 !IR SORT ( AUTONOMY1 FULL ( MEAN+ &1 !NCE1 C>RI]S ( ! M>K+ ?AT HUMAN ACTIVITY HAS ATTA*$ TO !M4 ,9 O!R WORDS1 !Y >E *>ACT]IZ$ MESSAGES1 PIECES 9 MOTION ( ! HUMANS ?AT HAVE ?\TS 9 ! GOAL ?AT !Y 9T5D TO A*IEVE1 I4E41 !Y >E NOT EXHAU/$ 9 ! PURPOSES ?AT HAVE APP>5TLY DET]M9$ !M4 ,! /UDY ( ?IS 0DIFF]5CE0 LEADS DIRECTLY TO ! 9T]IOR ( ! ABSOLUTELY 0O!R04 ,IF WE ?9K & ACT ) ! SOLE AIM ( ADAPT+ \RSELVES TO REALITY1 MAYBE WILDLY TOOT+ \R [N HORN TO MAKE \RSELVES BETT] HE>D1 & MORE DI/ANT1 WE DON'T HAVE TIME = NUANCES1 = ! ?+ ADD$ 9 EXCESS ( :I* ,I AM SPEAK+ H]E4 ,WE PRODUCE :AT IS NECESS>Y BECAUSE ! WORLD GOES =W>D ) \T CONTRIBUTIONS AS WELL1 & ! RULES ( ! M>KET IMPOSE ! CODES ( ?IS PRODUCTION ON US4 ,!Y TELL US 7ALONG BROAD1 BUT SUFFICI5TLY CLE>1 L9ES7 :AT TO DO SO AS TO NEV] COME \T BEL[1 OR ABOVE1 :AT IS REQUIR$ = ! PROJECT TO BE REALIZ$4 ,& :5 WE FAIL 9 ! CAPITULATION ?AT IS REQUIR$ ( US1 WE FEEL PRECISELY ?AT WE HAVE FAIL$1 WE >E FAILURES1 & WE LOOK AT \R 9EFFICI5T H&S & WEEP DESPOND5TLY4 ,P]HAPS WE WILL HAVE TO WEEP HOTT] TE>S :5 SUCCESS HAS COME PRECISELY ?R\< ! GREAT CAPACITY = ADAPT+ :AT WE DO TO ! GOALS TO BE REA*$4 ,P]HAPS PRECISELY 9 ?IS 9/ANCE1 ?AT ! 9CREAS+LY 9T5SE EFFICI5CY ( MOD]N TE*NIQUES SUGGE/S TO US EV]Y DAY1 WE HAVE SUPPLI$ \R LITTLE CONTRIBUTION TO ! GREAT CON/RUCTIONS ( P[]4 ,& ?IS EV5 :5 ! PROJECT ASSUM$ ! P>TICUL>S ( REVOLUTION1 ( ! SUBV]SION ( 9/ITUTIONS & VALUES1 CU/OMS & TRADITIONS4 ,9 ?IS CASE1 9 SMALL & BIG ?+S1 WE >E SET UP AS SUPPLI]S ( ! FUTURE EXECUTION]1 WE HAVE CONCLUD$ \R EF=TS 9 ! P]FECTION ( :AT WE HAD ?\T+ HYPO!SIS IS ALWAYS SE5 AS A HI<] DEGREE ( SUCCESS4 ,GOALS HAVE BE5 A*IEV$1 F9I% L9ES CROSS$1 HOPES SATISFI$4 ,N[ ! PEOPLE HAVE !IR FREE RULES1 OLD TYRANNIES >E DEAD1 NEW FRE$OMS >E 5GRAV$ ON %9Y NEW TABLETS4 ,WE CAN PRES5T ! BILL4 ,WE >E ! LIB]ATORS3 WE >E ! CREATORS ( ! PROJECT & ITS DETAILS4 ,WE HAVE 9CUBAT$ HI< SOCIAL MEAN+ ! WAY A PEACOCK EGG IS 9CUBAT$1 & N[ WE WITNESS ! %9+ ( ! SUN'S GOLD5 FEA!RS4 ,! =CE ( ! GOAL TO A*IEVE HAS KILL$ ! 9ITIAL *>ACT] ( ACTION & ?\ACT] WAS ! ADH]5CE ( TO ! CONCRETE ACTIVITY ( ! ONE :O ?\K ( SUBORD9ATION TO SOME?+ EXT]NAL1 BUT ) ITS [N EXUB]ANCE1 ) ! EXCESS ?AT ?IS V]Y ?9K+ & ACT+ PRODUCE4 ,! CONC]N ( ! ONE :O ACTS & ?9KS1 & :O MAKES ( H] ?\RIVE FROM ! \TSIDE1 FROM O!RS OR FROM :AT ONE HOPES TO OBTA94 ,IF ! PROJECT IS NOT CLE> )9 US1 IF WE >E !RE=E NOT WILL+ TO 9CUR ! RISKS ?AT \R IDEAS & ACTIONS 5TAIL1 WE CANNOT EXPECT A M]E POSITIVE RESULT TO FURNI% US ) :AT WE LACK4 ,BY ACCEPT+ ?IS CONCEPTION1 WE PRES5T \RSELVES AS CR$ITORS2 WE WANT A CONCRETE RESULT BUT ONLY = \RSELVES1 PRECISELY BECAUSE WE HAVE ALWAYS BE5 AW>E ( ?AT 9ITIAL LACK & HAVE ALWAYS GONE 9 SE>* ( A COMPLET5ESS4 ,IF1 H[EV]1 WE >E SURE ( :AT WE ?9K & ( ! REASONS ?AT MOVE US TO ACT1 WE >E COMPLETE FROM ! />T4 ,& IF WE >E COMPLETE1 WE CAN MAKE A GIFT ( \RSELVES TO ! O!R1 WE CAN MAKE A GIFT ( \RSELVES TO ! OBJECTIVE WE WANT TO A*IEVE4 ,& ?IS GIFT ( \RSELVES WILL APPE> IMM$IATELY = :AT IT IS3 ! EX*ANGE ( A GIFT BETWE5 \RSELVES & ! O!R1 BETWE5 \RSELVES & ! REALITY ?AT /&S BE=E US1 UNKN[N BUT DESIR$1 ?AT WE WANT TO TRANS=M4 ,\R GIFT IS NOT REM$IAL1 IT DOESN'T EQUALIZE1 IT DOESN'T BR+ JU/ICE1 IT DOESN'T SMOO? \T FAULTS4 ,IT DE/ROYS & CREATES1 ADDS ! IMMEASURABLE EXCESS BEYOND :I* ALL CALCULATION BECOMES IMPOSSIBLE4 ,IT FILLS \R HE>TS BEYOND ANY ECONOMIC CALCULATION4 ,! ,P]SI/5T ,REFUSAL ( ,P>ADISE BY ,P5ELOPE ,N9 ,IT IS RUMOR$ ?AT WE 7A 0WE0 NOT WELL-DEF9$ :OSE LACK ( DEF9ITION SUITS ! RUMOR-MONG]S7 HAVE NO?+ TO DO ) AN>*ISM1 BE+ 9 REALITY NIHILI/S DISGUIS$ = ! PURPOSE ( P5ETRAT+ 9TO ! SANCTU>Y ( AN>*Y ) BAD 9T5TIONS4 ,IT IS NOT$ ?AT ONE :O TAKES UP ! TASK ( GU>D+ ! TEMPLE 5DS UP SEE+ ?IEVES EV]Y:]E1 & MAYBE ! H\R HAS COME TO QUIET 0\R0 TR\BL$ DETRACTORS4 ,FIR/ ( ALL1 !Y MU/ EXPLA9 :AT !Y MEAN BY NIHILISM4 ,P]SONALLY1 ,I VIEW ANYONE :O EXTOLS ! JOYS ( NIHILISM TO ME ) SUSPICION BECAUSE ,I CONSID] NIHILISM1 AS ! SUB/ANTIATION ( NO?+1 TO BE A DECEPTION4 ,:5 ! 9COMPLET5ESS ( ALL IS CULTIVAT$ ) A FEEL+ ( FULLNESS1 IT IS DIFFICULT TO RESI/ ! TEMPTATION TO REPLACE ! OLD ABSOLUTE ) ITS MO/ AB/RACT MOM5T 9 :I* NO?+ IS IMM$IATELY TRANS=M$ 9TO ALL & IS !RE=E TOTALIZ$4 ,ULTIMATELY1 NIHILISM SEEMS TO ME TO BE A CRAFTY =M ( REASON+1 ?AT DRIVES ! :OLE /RUCTURE ( KN[L$GE 9TO ! D>KNESS ( ,NO?+NESS ONLY TO RECEIVE1 ?R\< ?IS SPECTACUL>1 RADICAL NEGATION1 /ILL MORE ( ! LI?LY P>ADISE1 TO =ESEE ITS FUNCTION+1 TO /UDY ITS ORGANIZATION1 TO PRAISE ITS P]FECTION4 ,ONE IS NIHILI/IC :51 9/EAD ( TAK+ & VALU+ ALL ! MOM5TS ( RELATIVE FRE$OM (F]$ BY ?IS SOCIETY1 ONE RADICALLY NEGATES IT1 PREF]R+ ! DRA/IC CONCLUSION ?AT NONE ( IT IS WOR? SAV+4 ,F9ALLY1 ONE IS NIHILI/IC :51 9/EAD ( PROPOS+ SOME?+ CON/RUCTIVE1 ONE'S ACTIVITY COMES D[N TO AN 0 OBSESSIVE EXULTATION ( ! DE/RUCTION ( ?IS WORLD40 ,IF ?IS IS ! >GUM5T1 IT IS1 9DE$ A MEAG] ONE4 ,TO BEG91 AN>*ISM -- ! ,IDEA -- IS ONE ?+1 & ! AN>*I/ MOVEM5T -- ! 5SEMBLE ( M5 & WOM5 :O SUPPORT ?IS ,IDEA -- IS ANO!R4 ,IT MAKES NO S5SE TO ME TO SAY ( ! ,IDEA :AT 9 REALITY ONLY A FEW AN>*I/S ASS]T4 ,! ,IDEA ( AN>*ISM IS ! ABSOLUTE 9COMPATIBILITY BETWE5 FRE$OM & AU?ORITY4 ,FROM ?IS IT FOLL[S ?AT ONE CAN 5JOY TOTAL FRE$OM 9 ! COMPLETE ABS5CE ( ,P[]4 ,BECAUSE ,P[] EXI/S & HAS NO 9T5TION ( DISAPPE>+ VOLUNT>ILY1 IT WILL BE NECESS>Y 9DE$ TO CREATE A WAY TO ELIM9ATE IT4 ,CORRECT ME IF ,I'M MI/AK54 ,I DON'T UND]/& :Y SU* A PREMISE1 :I* NO AN>*I/ 0NIHILI/0 HAS EV] DREAM$ ( D5Y+ & SUPPRESS+1 MU/ LEAD NECESS>ILY TO PO/ULAT+ NEW SOCIAL REGULATIONS4 ,I DON'T UND]/& :Y1 9 ORD] TO 0BE P>T0 ( ! AN>*I/ MOVEM5T1 ONE MU/ FIR/ UND]GO A DOCTORAL EXAM9ATION 9 ! >*ITECTURE ( ! NEW WORLD1 & :Y IT ISN'T 5\< TO LOVE FRE$OM & HATE EV]Y =M ( AU?ORITY ) ALL ?AT 5TAILS4 ,ALL ?IS IS NOT ONLY ABSURD FROM ! !ORETICAL PO9T ( VIEW1 BUT ALSO FALSE FROM ! HI/ORICAL PO9T ( VIEW 7& ! AN>*I/ RUMOR-MONG]S %[ SO MU* F]VOR = ,HI/ORY74 ,ONE ( ! PO9TS AB\T :I* ,MALATE/A & ,GALLEANI CLA%$ REGUL>LY WAS PRECISELY ! QUE/ION ( :E!R IT WAS NECESS>Y TO PLAN :AT W\LD BE CREAT$ AFT] ! REVOLUTION OR NOT4 ,MALATE/A >GU$ ?AT AN>*I/S MU/ BEG9 IMM$IATELY TO DEVELOP IDEAS ( H[ TO ORGANIZE SOCIAL LIFE BECAUSE IT DOESN'T ALL[ = 9T]RUPTION2 ,GALLEANI1 ON ! O!R H&1 >GU$ ?AT ! TASK ( AN>*I/S WAS ! DE/RUCTION ( ?IS SOCIETY1 & ?AT FUTURE G5]ATIONS ?AT >E IMMUNE TO ! LOGIC ( DOM9ATION WILL FIGURE \T H[ TO REBUILD4 ,9 SPITE ( !SE DIFF]5CES1 ,MALATE/A DID NOT ACCUSE ,GALLEANI ( BE+ NIHILI/4 ,TO MAKE SU* AN ACCUSATION W\LD HAVE BE5 GRATUIT\S BECAUSE !IR DIFF]5CE WAS ONLY OV] ! CON/RUCTIVE ASPECT ( ! QUE/ION2 !Y AGRE$ COMPLETELY AB\T ! DE/RUCTIVE ASPECT4 ,?\< ?IS IS OMITT$ BY MANY ( HIS EXEGETES1 ,MALATE/A WAS1 9DE$1 AN 9SURRECTIONALI/1 A CONFIRM$ SUPPORT] ( A VIOL5T 9SURRECTION CAPABLE ( DEMOLI%+ ! /ATE4 ,TODAY1 H[EV]1 ONE M]ELY NE$S TO PO9T \T ?AT ANYONE :O HOLDS P[] DOES NOT GIVE UP !IR PRIVILEGES VOLUNT>ILY & DRAW ! DUE CONCLUSIONS TO BE ACCUS$ ( NIHILISM4 ,)9 ! AN>*I/ MOVEM5T1 AS EV]Y:]E1 TIMES *ANGE4 ,:]EAS ONCE ! DEBATE AMONG AN>*I/S DEALT ) ! WAY ( CONCEIV+ ! REVOLUTION1 TODAY IT SEEMS ?AT ALL DISCUSSION C5T]S >\ND ! WAY TO AVOID IT4 ,:AT O!R PURPOSE C\LD ALL !SE DISQUISITIONS ON SELF-GOV]NM5T1 LIB]T>IAN MUNICIPALISM1 OR ! BLESS$ UTOPIA ( GOOD S5SE HAVE8 ,IT IS CLE> ?AT ONCE ONE REJECTS ! 9SURRECTIONAL PROJECT AS SU*1 ! DE/RUCTIVE HYPO!SIS BEG9S TO ASSUME FRI*I/S REPRES5TS A HORROR4 ,:5 PI\S S\LS HE> ! B>K ( A DOG1 !Y ALWAYS ?9K ?AT A F]OCI\S WOLF IS COM+4 ,= !M ! BL[+ ( ! W9D BECOMES AN APPROA*+ TORNADO4 ,9 ! SAME WAY1 TO ANYONE :O HAS 5TRU/$ ! TASK ( TRANS=M+ ! WORLD TO P]SUASION ALONE1 ! WORD DE/RUCTION IS UPSETT+ TO ! M9D1 EVOK+ PA9FUL & UNPLEASANT IMAGES4 ,!SE ?+S MAKE A BAD IMPRESSION ON ! PEOPLE :O1 IF !Y >E TO BE CONV]T$ & F9ALLY FLOCK 9TO ! RANKS ( REASON1 MU/ HAVE A RELIGION ?AT PROMISES AN ,$5 ( PEACE & BRO!RHOOD4 ,:E!R IT DEALS ) P>ADISE1 NIRVANA OR AN>*Y IS ( LITTLE IMPORTANCE4 ,& ANYONE :O D>ES TO PLACE SU* A RELIGION 9TO QUE/ION CANNOT BE ?\E CALL$ 0NIHILI/S04 ,BUT ! NIHILISM 9 ALL ?IS1 :AT IS ! PO9T8 ,PRISON]S ( A ,S+LE ,WORLD BY ,GRUPPO ,AN>*ICO ,9SURREZIONALI/A 0,E4 ,MALATE/A0 0,! FACT IS ?AT ! /ATE W\LD NOT BE SO P]NICI\S IF ?OSE :O WANT$ TO W]E ABLE TO IGNORE IT & LIVE !IR LIVES 9 !IR [N WAY TOGE!R ) ?OSE ) :OM !Y GET ALONG4 ,BUT IT HAS 9VAD$ EV]Y FUNCTION ( SOCIAL LIFE1 /&+ OV] ALL ! ACTIVITIES ( \R LIVES & WE >E EV5 PREV5T$ FROM DEF5D+ \RSELVES :5 WE >E ATTACK$4 0,IT IS NECESS>Y TO SUBMIT TO IT OR BR+ IT D[N40 -- ,]RICO ,MALATE/A ,IF WE W]E NOT DEEPLY DISSATISFI$ ) ?IS WORLD1 WE W\LD NOT WRITE ON ?IS PAP] & Y\ W\LD NOT READ ?IS >TICLE4 ,IT IS !RE=E USELESS TO WA/E FUR!R WORDS TO CONFIRM \R AV]SION TO ,P[] & ITS MANIFE/ATIONS4 ,RA!R1 :AT SEEMS USEFUL TO US IS ! ATTEMPT TO DET]M9E :E!R A REVOLT ?AT IS NOT OP5LY & RESOLUTELY AGA9/ ! /ATE & P[] IS POSSIBLE4 ,! QUE/ION %\LD NOT SEEM ODD4 ,9 FACT1 !RE >E ?OSE :O SEE 9 ! /RUGGLE AGA9/ ! /ATE NO?+ BUT A FUR!R CONFIRMATION ( ! EXT5T TO :I* IT HAS P5ETRAT$ 9TO US1 MANAG+ TO DET]M9E \R ACTIONS -- EV5 IF ONLY 9 ! NEGATIVE4 ,) ITS CUMB]SOME PRES5CE1 ! /ATE W\LD DI/RACT US FROM ?AT :I* %\LD BE \R TRUE OBJECTIVE3 LIV+ LIFE \R WAY4 ,IF WE ?9K ( TAK+ D[N ! /ATE1 ( OB/RUCT+ IT1 ( FIT TO CONSID] IT NOT ) HO/ILITY1 BUT ) 9DIFF]5CE4 ,RA!R ?AN GIV+ \RSELVES TO TRY+ TO DE/ROY ITS WORLD -- ! WORLD ( AU?ORITY -- IT IS BETT] TO BUILD \R [N1 ?AT ( FRE$OM4 ,IT IS NECESS>Y TO /OP ?9K+ AB\T ! 5EMY1 :AT IT DOES1 :]E IT IS F\ND1 :AT TO DO TO /RIKE IT1 & D$ICATE \RSELVES TO \RSELVES1 TO \R 0DAILY LIFE01 TO \R RELATION%IPS1 TO \R SPACES ?AT NE$ TO EXP& & IMPROVE MORE & MORE4 ,O!RWISE1 WE WILL NEV] DO ANY?+ BUT FOLL[ ! 9CL9ATIONS ( P[]4 ,! AN>*I/ MOVEM5T TODAY IS FULL ( ?IS SORT ( REASON+1 ! CONT9UAL SE>* = JU/IFICATIONS DISGUIS$ AS !ORETICAL ANALYZES ?AT EXCUSE ONE'S ABSOLUTE 9ACTION4 ,!RE >E ?OSE :O WANT TO DO NO?+ BECAUSE !Y >E SKEPTICAL1 ?OSE :O DO NOT WANT TO IMPOSE ANY?+ ON ANYONE1 ?OSE :O CONSID] P[] TOO /RONG = !M & ?OSE :O DON'T WANT TO FOLL[ ITS RHY?MS & TIMES2 EV]Y ONE ( !SE EXCUSES IS GOOD4 ,BUT !SE AN>*I/S1 DO !Y HAVE A DREAM CAPABLE ( SETT+ !IR HE>TS AFLAME8 ,9 ORD] TO CLE> ! FIELD ( !SE MIS]ABLE EXCUSES1 IT IS WOR? ! EF=T TO REMEMB] A FEW ?+S4 ,!RE >E NOT TWO WORLDS1 \RS & !IRS1 & EV5 IF1 TO BE ABSURD1 !Y DID EXI/1 H[ C\LD !Y BE MADE TO CO-EXI/8 ,!RE IS A S+LE WORLD1 ! WORLD ( AU?ORITY & MONEY1 ( EXPLOITATION & OB$I5CE3 ! WORLD 9 :I* WE >E ALL =C$ TO LIVE4 ,IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO PRET5D ?AT WE >E \TSIDE4 ,?IS IS :Y WE CANNOT ALL[ \RSELVES TO BE 9DIFF]5T1 ?IS IS :Y WE CANNOT MANAGE TO IGNORE IT4 ,IF WE OPPOSE \RSELVES TO ! /ATE1 IF WE >E ALWAYS QUICK TO SEIZE ! OCCASION TO ATTACK IT1 IT IS NOT BECAUSE WE >E 9DIRECTLY MOLD$ BY IT1 IT IS NOT BECAUSE WE HAVE SACRIFIC$ \R DESIRES ON ! ALT> ( REVOLUTION1 BUT BECAUSE \R DESIRES CANNOT BE REALIZ$ AS LONG AS ! /ATE EXI/S1 AS LONG AS ANY ,P[] EXI/S4 ,! REVOLUTION DOES NOT DI/RACT US FROM \R DREAMS1 BUT RA!R IS ! ONLY POSSIBILITY ?AT ALL[S ! CONDITIONS = !IR REALIZATION4 ,WE WANT TO OV]TURN ?IS WORLD AS QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE H]E & N[1 BECAUSE H]E & N[ !RE >E ONLY B>RACKS1 C\RTS1 BANKS1 CONCRETE1 SUP]M>KETS1 PRISONS4 ,H]E & N[ !RE IS ONLY EXPLOITATION1 :ILE FRE$OM1 AS WE UND]/& IT1 DOES NOT REALLY EXI/4 ,?IS DOES NOT MEAN ?AT WE GIVE UP ON CREAT+ SPACES ( \R [N 9 :I* TO EXP]IM5T ) ! RELATION%IPS ?AT WE PREF]4 ,IT ONLY MEANS ?AT !SE SPACES1 !SE RELATION%IPS1 DO NOT REPRES5T ! COMPLETE FRE$OM ?AT WE DESIRE = \RSELVES & = EV]YONE4 ,!Y >E A /EP1 BUT NOT ! F9AL ONE1 MU* LESS ! DEF9ITIVE ONE4 ,A FRE$OM ?AT 5DS ON ! ?RE%OLD ( \R OCCUPI$ H\SE1 ( \R 0FREE0 COMMUNE1 IS NOT 5\<1 IT DOES NOT SATISFY US4 ,SU* FRE$OM IS ILLUSORY1 BECAUSE IT FREES ONLY AS LONG AS WE /AY AT HOME & DON'T LEAVE ! CONF9ES ?AT >E IMPOS$ ON US4 ,IF WE DON'T CONSID] ! NECESSITY ( ATTACK+ ! /ATE 7& !RE IS MU* ?AT WE C\LD SAY AB\T ?IS CONCEPT ( 0ATTACK071 !N1 BY DEF9ITION1 WE CAN ONLY DO :AT IT ALL[S US TO DO AT ITS CONV5I5CE1 =EV]1 LIMIT+ \RSELVES TO SURVIV+ 9 ! LITTLE 0HAPPY ISLE0 ?AT WE WILL BUILD \RSELVES4 ,KEEP+ \R DI/ANCE FROM ! /ATE MEANS CONS]V+ LIFE1 CONFRONT+ IT MEANS LIV+4 ,\R CAPITULATION IS IMPLICIT 9 9DIFF]5CE T[>D ! /ATE4 ,IT IS AS IF WE W]E ADMITT+ ?AT ! /ATE IS /RONG]1 IS 9V9CIBLE1 IS BEYOND CONTE/ATION1 ONE MIMS & CONSID] CULTIVAT+ ONE'S KIT*5 G>D54 ,IS IT POSSIBLE TO CALL ?IS REVOLT8 ,IT SEEMS TO US RA!R TO BE A COMPLETELY 9N] ATTITUDE1 CIRCUMSCRIB$ BY A K9D ( DIFFID5CE1 9COMPATIBILITY ) & DIS9T]E/ 9 ?AT :I* SURR\NDS US4 ,BUT RESIGNATION REMA9S IMPLICIT 9 SU* AN ATTITUDE4 ,CONTEMPTU\S RESIGNATION IF Y\ WILL1 BUT RESIGNATION NONE!LESS4 ,IT IS LIKE ?R[+ PUN*ES ?AT >E LIMIT$ TO W>D+ (F BL[S )\T EV] TRY+ TO BR+ ! ADV]S>Y ?AT ONE HATES D[N4 ,BUT \R ADV]S>Y DOES NOT GIVE US ANY RESPITE4 ,WE CANNOT M]ELY LEAVE ! R+ & GO ON MAK+ A LAU<+-/OCK ( IT4 ,IT IS NECESS>Y TO BR+ \R ADV]S>Y D[N2 DODG+ & EXPRESS+ \R DISAPPO9TM5T 9 IT IS NOT SUFFICI5T4 ,CAMOMILLO BY ,P5ELOPE ,N9 ,AT ?IS TIME1 A LOT ( AN>*I/S FROM ALL OV] ,ITALY >E FLOOD+ 9TO ,ROME4 ,A MON? AGO1 BY ! ORD] ( A PUBLIC PROSECUTOR :O WAS LOOK+ = EASY GLORY1 AB\T ?IRTY 5EMIES ( AU?ORITY W]E TAK5 9TO CU/ODY & LOCK$ UP 9 ,REBIBBIA1 A PRISON 9 ! \TLY+ SUBURBS4 ,TO PROTE/ AGA9/ ! >ROGANCE & V5GEFUL SPIRIT ( ! JUDGES :O HAVE DECID$ TO TAKE AWAY !IR FRE$OM1 ONE ( !M HAS BEGUN A HUNG] & ?IR/ /RIKE TO ! DEA?4 ,BUT LA/ ,SATURDAY1 !SE AN>*I/S W]E NOT ALONE 9 BREA?+ ! AIR ( ! ET]NAL CITY4 ,O!RS JO9$ !M !RE1 GUE/S ?IS TIME ( ! 9T]NATIONAL BOOK%OP1 ,IL ,MANIFE/O1 :]E !Y W5T TO *ATT] -- TOGE!R ) COMMUNI/S1 M>XI/S & HI/ORIANS -- AB\T ,CAMILLO ,B]N]I1 0AN AN>*I/ BETWE5 ,GRAMSCI & ,GOBETTI01 AS ! TITLE ( ! CONF]5CE SAID4 ,IT WAS PROMOT$ BY ! DAILY NEWSPAP] ( VIA ,TOMACELLI .<#b.> BY ! LIB]T>IAN /UDIES C5T] ( ,MILAN & BY ! ,HI/ORICAL ,REVIEW ( ,AN>*ISM ( ,PISA1 9 COLLABORATION ) ! ,ROMAN BOOK%OP ,ANOMOLIA4 ,IT'S A GOOD ?+ ?AT !RE >E AN>*I/S WILL+ TO CLEANSE ! GOOD NAME ( AN>*Y1 WA%+ AWAY ! AWFUL REPUTATION ?AT A FEW HO!ADS W\LD LIKE TO ATTA* TO IT4 ,9 PR9T+ ! NEWS ( ! >RE/S A MON? AGO1 ,IL ,MANIFE/O HAD ALREADY ATT5TIVELY MADE NOTE ( H[ ! 9VE/IGATORS 0A BIT TOO EASILY0 GRANT$ 0A S+LE IDEOLOGICAL-POLITICAL MOTIVATION TO ACTIONS ?AT SEEM LIKE ?OSE ( A B& ( COMMON CRIM9ALS40 ,BUT A F9E CONV5TION ORGANIZ$ ALL TOGE!R WAS ! ?+ NE$$ TO DISSIPATE ! LA/ D\BTS1 TO F9ALLY BR+ BACK A BIT ( S]5ITY4 ,9 RESPONSE TO ?IS PROPOSAL1 IT WAS IMM$IATELY SAID ?AT A BETT] SUBJECT C\LD NOT HAVE BE5 *OS54 ,:AT AN>*I/ MORE ?AN ,CAMOMILLO ,B]N]I C\LD HAVE BR\*I/S & P]SONAGES SU* AS ,VAL5T9O ,P>LATO1 ,G(FR$O ,F(I 7:O IS PUBLI%+ AN AN?OLOGY ( ,B]N]I'S WRIT+S71 & ,5ZO ,SANT>ELLI ONTO A COMMON T]RA98 ,FIGURES ( ?IS SORT C]TA9LY C\LD NOT REMA9 9S5SITIVE TO ! FASC9ATION EX]CIS$ BY ! LEAD+ EXPON5T ( AN>*I/ REVISIONISM & BY HIS UNSETTL+ DEF9ITIONS ( ,AN>*Y -- 0! SOCIETY 9 :I* TE*NICAL AU?ORITY1 /RIPP$ ( EV]Y FUNCTION ( POLITICAL DOM9ATION1 COMES TO =M A HI]>*Y CONCEIV$ & REALIZ$ AS A SY/EM ( DI/RIBUTION ( WORK0 -- & ( FRE$OM -- 0! P[] ( OBEY+ REASON04 0,AN>*I/ SUI G5]IS.<#c.>0 -- SO HE LOV$ TO DESCRIBE HIMSELF -- ,B]N]I F\*ISM \T FROM ! MI/S ( UTOPIA AT BL[S ) REALITY4 0,BETT] ! PRES5T EVIL ?AN SOME?+ WORSE0 WAS ! BATTLE CRY ?AT ACCOMPANI$ HIM ?R\<\T HIS LIFE & TO :I* HE ALWAYS REMA9$ FAI?FUL4 ,?IS S5SE ( MEASURE L$ HIM TO SALUTE ! ,BOL%EVIK REGIME 9 #a#i#a#h1 DESPISE AB/5TIONISM.<#d.> :I* HE DISMISS$ AS 0CRET9ISM01 COLLABORATE ) LIB]ALS LIKE ,GOBETTI1 & MAKE SYMPA!TIC GE/URES T[>D A P>T ( ! ,CA?OLIC WORLD ) :I* HE %>$ ! IDEA ( WOMAN AS WIFE1 PROCREATOR & IDEAL H\SEKEEP]4 ,& ! DEEP S5SE ( DUTY -- :I* ,CAMOMILLO ID5TIFI$ ) ,GOD IS :AT MADE HIM WRITE WORDS FULL ( CAUTI\S COMMON S5SE AB\T ! NECESSITY ( MONEY & ! 9EVITABILITY ( PRISON1 ) ! CONSCI\SNESS ?AT IT IS ALWAYS NECESS>Y TO REA* A 0COMPROMISE BETWE5 ! ,IDEA & ! FACT1 BETWE5 TOMORR[ & TODAY40 ,B]N]I WAS KILL$ 9 ,B>CELONA DUR+ ! DAYS ( ,MAY #a#i#c#g1 9 ! HEAT ( ! ,SPANI% REVOLUTION4 ,HIS M>TYRDOM E>N$ HIM CANONIZATION BY A P>T ( ! V5]ABLE AN>*I/ ,*UR*4 ,! FACT ?AT HIS MURD]]S W]E PRECISELY ! COMMUNI/S :O ,P>LATO1 ,F(I & !IR COMRADES PRAIS$ SO HITICUL> ?AT IS UTT]LY 9SIGNIFICANT4 ,! FACT REMA9S ONLY ,CAMOMILLO ,B]N]I -- ! AN>*I/ :O US$ TO C&IDLY MA9TA9 ?AT 0A M9IMUM ( AU?ORITY IS 9DISP5SABLE0 -- C\LD HAVE BECOME ! L9E ( UNION BETWE5 /AL9I/S & AN>*I/S1 ! UNBELIEV]S :O -- LIKE ,GOBETTI & ,GRAMSCI -- DO NO?+ BUT FE$ DOGMA ) !IR H]ESY4 ,BUT1 OKAY1 LET'S SAY IT3 AS F> AS IT GOES1 !SE JUDGES >E P]FECTLY RIE AN>*I/S & 0AN>*I/S04 ,SOME >E BAD & >E RIROZZA1 ,GIAMPIETRO ,B]TI -- >E GOOD4 ,SO GOOD ?AT !Y CAN 5JOY ! E/EEM ( ALL ! RESPECTABLE PEOPLE ( ?IS WORLD4 ,A TOA/ !RE=E TO ,CAMOMILLO4 ,& TO HELL ) ! 0AN>*I/S0 9 PRISON4 ,HE ,JOKES ) ,M5 BY ,P5ELOPE ,N9 0,BUT EXPROPRIATIONS & VIOL5T ACTIONS ?AT PUT ! LIVES ( PEOPLE AT RISK1 & MORE G5]ALLY ! !ORY & PRACTICE ( ILLEGALISM AT ALL CO/S >E F> FROM \R AN>*ISM4 ,SU* ACTIONS >E 9 CLE> CONTRA/ ) ! ANTI-VIOL5T ,MALATE/IAN SPIRIT ?AT WE HAVE MADE \R [N40 7FROM ,G]M9AL1 _? #g#a_/#g#b1 P4 #b#f7 ,! GREATE/ MIS=TUNE ?AT CAN BEFALL A HUMAN BE+ 5D[$ ) ANY QUALITY IS TO BE SURR\ND$ BY FOLL[]S4 ,AS LONG AS HE REMA9S ALIVE1 HE WILL BE P]PETUALLY COMPELL$ TO KEEP WAT* SO ?AT NO?+ /UPID IS SAID OR DONE 9 HIS NAME1 TOIL ?AT WILL PROVE USELESS H[EV] :51 AFT] HIS DEA?1 ! 9ITIATES QU>REL OV] H[ TO ADVANCE ! PA? ( HIS 5DEAVOR4 ,! FOLL[]S >E NEV] AT ! LEVEL ( !IR 0TEA*]01 S9CE ONLY ?OSE :O LACK !IR [N IDEAS TAKE ON ?OSE ( O!RS -- BECOM+1 PRECISELY1 !IR FOLL[]S4 ,?US1 FOLL[]S NOT ONLY PROVE TO BE 9CAPABLE ( CAUS+ SOME?+ ?AT HAS ALREADY BE5 />T$ TO ADVANCE1 BUT S9CE !Y LACK ! QUALITIES ( ! ONE :O CAME BE=E !M1 !Y EASILY REA* ! PO9T ( DI/ORT+ & BETRAY+ ! IDEAS !Y CLAIM TO SUPPORT4 ,! PH5OM5ON1 DEPRECABLE 9 ITSELF1 TAKES ON LUDICR\S & EV5 AMUS+ FEATURES & DIRECTIONS1 P>TICUL>LY :5 ! UN=TUNATE 0TEA*]0 IS AN AN>*I/1 ?AT IS TO SAY AN 9DIVIDUAL HO/ILE TO ALL AU?ORITY & !RE=E OPPOS$ 9 PR9CIPLE TO ! H]D M5TALITY4 ,& YET :O CAN D5Y ?AT EV5 )9 ! AN>*I/ MOVEM5T SU* CASES HAVE OCCURR$8 ,TO AVOID GO+ TOO F>1 IT IS 5\< TO CONSID] ,]RICO ,MALATE/A1 ! FAM\S ,ITALIAN AN>*I/4 ,ALL ! FRI5DS & S*OL>S ( ! ?\*I/S >E SU* BECAUSE !Y WANT AN>*Y & IT IS ONLY POSSIBLE TO REALIZE AN>*Y BY MAK+ REVOLUTION1 A REVOLUTION ?AT W\LD NECESS>ILY BE VIOL5T1 ! FIR/ /EP ( :I* IS 9SURRECTION4 ,IT SEEMS TO BE A BANALITY1 & 9DE$ IT IS4 ,& YET IT IS A BANALITY FROM :I* MANY AN>*I/S T5D TO DI/ANCE !MSELVES ) A S5SE ( DISGU/4 ,LUIGI ,FABBRI WROTE3 0,9SURRECTION IS ! NECESS>Y & 9ESCAPABLE EV5T ( EV]Y REVOLUTION1 ! CONCRETE EV5T ?R\< :I* IT BECOMES REALITY = EV]YONE4 ,IT IS FROM ?IS FACT ?AT ,MALATE/A'S AV]SION = EV]Y !ORY & ME?OD ?AT T5DS1 DIRECTLY OR 9DIRECTLY1 TO DISCR$IT IT1 TO AV]T ! ATT5TION ( ! MASSES & ! ACTIVITY ( REVOLUTION>IES FROM IT1 TO REPLACE IT ) MEANS ?AT >E APP>5TLY MORE CONV5I5T & PEACEFUL GREW40 ,NOT JU/ REVOLUTION>Y1 S9CE 0ANYONE CAN CALL !MSELVES REVOLUTION>Y :ILE US+ ! PRUD5CE TO PO/PONE ! DESIR$ TRANS=MATION TO F> DI/ANT TIMES 7:5 ! TIME IS RIPE1 AS !Y SAY710 ,MALATE/A WAS ABOVE ALL AN 9SURRECTIONI/ 9ASMU* AS HE WANT$ TO MAKE ! REVOLUTION IMM$IATELY -- A REVOLUTION UND]/OOD 09 ! S5SE ( VIOL5T *ANGE C>RI$ \T ?R\< =CE AGA9/ ! PRES]V+ P[]S2 & IT ?US IMPLIES MAT]IAL /RUGGLE1 >M$ 9SURRECTION1 ) ! RET9UE ( B>RICADES1 >M$ GR\PS1 ! CONFISCATION ( GOODS FROM ! CLASS AGA9/ :I* ONE FI*I/S IF IT DID NOT COME ON ITS [N ?R\< NATURAL EV5TS4 ,YES1 ,I KN[2 :O IS NOT FAMILI> ) C]TA9 CRITIQUES ,MALATE/A MADE ( VIOL5CE & POLEMICS ?AT HE WROTE AB\T ,EMILE ,H5RY OR ,PAOLO ,S*I*I8 ,NEV]!LESS1 ,MALATE/A DID NOT D5Y ! LEGITIMACY & EV5 ! NECESSITY ( ! USE ( VIOL5CE AS SU*2 HE ONLY OPPOS$ A VIOL5CE ?AT 0/RIKES BL9DLY1 )\T DI/+UI%+ BETWE5 ! GUILTY & ! 9NOC5T40 ,IT IS NO ACCID5T ?AT ! EXAMPLE ( BL9D VIOL5CE ?AT HE ,USUALLY GAVE WAS ?AT ( ! BOMB ?AT EXPLOD$ 9 ,B>CELONA DUR+ A RELIGI\S PROCESSION1 CAUS+ =TY DEA?S & NUM]\S 9JURIES4 ,?IS IS BECAUSE HE W\LD HAVE NO CRITIQUE TO MAKE 9 ! FACE ( REBELLI\S ACTIONS AGA9/ PRECISE T>GETS ?AT HAVE NO CONSEQU5CE = EXTRANE\S PEOPLE4 ,9 FACT1 9 ! C\RSE ( ONE ( HIS FAM\S 9T]VIEWS ) CONC$$ TO ,LE ,FIG>O1 9 :I* ! 9T]VIEW] TRI$ TO PRESS HIM TO DISAPPROVE ( ,RAVA*OL'S BOMBS1 & ( ! ATTACK AT ! B\LEV>D ,MAG5TA1 ,MALATE/A ANSW]$3 0,Y\R CONCLUSIONS >E HA/Y4 ,9 ! AFFAIR ( RUE ,CLI*Y1 IT SEEMS QUITE CLE> TO ME ?AT IT WAS 9T5D$ TO BL[ UP A JUDGE2 BUT ,I REGRET ?AT IT WAS C>RI$ \T -- QUITE 9VOLUNT>ILY1 ,I BELIEVE -- 9 A WAY ?AT BR\D ,MAG5TA -- OH6 ,I HAVE NO RES]VATIONS AB\T ?AT6 ,LH]OT & ,V]Y HAD BECOME ACCOMPLICES ( ! POLICE & IT WAS A F9E ACT ( /RUGGLE TO BL[ !M UP40 ,IT SEEMS CLE> ?AT ALL ! DISCUSSION & POLEMICS ?AT OCCURR$ 9 ?OSE DI/ANT YE>S -- ?AT C]TA9 PRES5T-DAY AN>*I/S RUN ?R\< AGA9 9 ORD] TO SELL US ! IMAGE ( AN ANTI-VIOL5T ,MALATE/A -- W]E NOT 9 FACT AIM$ AT ! USE ( VIOL5CE 9 ITSELF1 BUT ONLY ! LIMITS ONE C\LD NOT EXCE$ )\T PLAC+ ! V]Y PR9CIPLES ( AN>*ISM 9 QUE/ION1 OR AT MO/ ?OSE LIMITS SUGGE/$ BY CONSID]ATIONS ( A TACTICAL ORD]4 ,BUT LET'S LEAVE 0! D>K 5D ( AN E>LI] C5TURY0 & ! POLEMICS ?AT !N RAG$ 9 ! AN>*I/ MOVEM5T1 & RETURN TO ! PRES5T4 ,NO EXPLOSIVE ACTIONS CLAIM$ BY AN>*I/S 9 REC5T YE>S C\LD BE CONSID]$ AS BE+ C>RI$ \T 9 A 0BL9D0 & 09S5SITIVE0 MANN]4 ,RA!R ALL C\LD BE SAID TO HAVE BE5 DIRECT$ AGA9/ ! /RUCTURES ( DOM9ATION )\T PUTT+ 0! LIVES ( PEOPLE AT RISK40 ,SO H[ CAN ONE JU/IFY ! REPUDIATION ( !SE ACTIONS ON ! P>T ( C]TA9 AN>*I/S8 ,C]TA9LY NOT BY BORR[+ FROM ! ?\IO ,CACCIUCCO ,9 ADDITION TO EXPLA9+1 LANGUAGE 9 ITS FUNCTION ( ALL[+ COMMUNICATION BETWE5 9DIVIDUALS1 SITUATIONS & MAT]IALITY IS SET ! MISGUID$ TASK ( 5CLOS+ EMOTIONS1 M5TAL /ATES & RELATION%IPS BETWE5 9DIVIDUALS & O!RS )9 SYLLABLES4 ,9 MY OP9ION1 ! MY/IFICATION ( RELATION%IPS ( LOVE & FRI5D%IP IS SPURI\S4 ,EXAMPLES FROM LIV$ EXP]I5CE W\LD BE A GREAT HELP 9 EXPLA9+ MY REFLECTION1 BUT ,I WANT TO TRY TO CL>IFY IT BY US+1 9 MY [N WAY1 ! WRITT5 WORD4 ,I />T FROM ! PRESUPPOSITION ?AT EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL IS DIFF]5T 9 H] ATTITUDES1 ASPIRATIONS1 PHYSICAL ASPECT1 PLEASURES4 ,! RELATION%IPS ?AT EXI/ BETWE5 9DIVIDUALS >E LIKE SPH]ES ?AT B\NCE (F EA* O!R 9 A :IRL ( CONTACTS1 )\T CAUS+ ANY FUSION4 ,MODIFICATIONS1 BUT NEV] FUSIONS4 ,I ON ! O!R1 ! O!R ON ME4 ,9 EV]Y 9/ANCE1 EA* SPH]E MA9TA9S ITS UNIQU5ESS4 ,/>T+ FROM MY [N UNIQU5ESS1 ,I ?US DECIDE TO EMB>K ON AN UNLIMIT$ SE>* = CONTACTS & SITUATIONS CLOSE TO M9E1 9 ORD] TO REALIZE MYSELF EXCESSIVELY BY 5JOY+ ! DIFF]5CES ( O!RS4 ,& ,I DO SO BY AFFIRM+ MY WILL TO PRES]VE MY DECISION-MAK+ ABILITIES H[EV] & :5EV]4 ,9 G5]AL1 ,I RECOGNIZE ! DIFF]5CE ( O!RS1 ,I AM ATTRACT$ TO IT1 LIKE A *ILD :O SEES A CL[N PIR\ETTE & IS ATTRACT$ BY ! NOVELTY & LIKABL5ESS ?AT IT COMMUNICATES TO HIM4 ,I RECOGNIZE ! *>M ( ALL ?AT IS EXT]NAL TO ME1 ! KN[N1 ! LESS KN[N & ! UNKN[N4 ,! CONTACTS ?AT ,I E/ABLI% MAY BE MORE OR LESS LA/+4 ,CIRCUM/ANCE CONTRIBUTE TO A L>GE EXT5T4 ,BUT !Y ALWAYS 5D ) ! OPTION ( REOP5+4 ,:5 ,I TALK AB\T SEEK+ AFF9ITY1 ,I SPEAK ( GRANT+ MYSELF A S]IES ( CONTACTS ) O!R 9DIVIDUALS1 :I* DO NOT CAUSE H>M TO MY CAPACITY TO ACT1 BUT >E RA!R CAPABLE ( GIV+ ME NEW /R5G?1 NEW CAPACITIES1 MULTIPLY+ ! B\NC+ ( MY SPH]E ON ?OSE ( O!RS1 SOME?+ 9DISP5SABLE = ! SE>* = MYSELF & MY SATISFACTION4 ,! COMMON MEAN+S ( 0LOVE0 & 0FRI5D%IP0 ?US LEAVE ME P]PLEX$4 ,:5 RELATION%IPS OP51 ONE CANNOT E/ABLI% A PRIORI H[ !Y MIE & ?AT IS ALL4 ,! R&OMNESS ( EV5TS & ! MANIFE/ATION ( 9DIVIDUAL WILL CONTRIBUTE TO CREAT+ A C]TA9 SOME?+4 ,& :5 ,I SAY A C]TA9 SOME?+1 ,I MEAN EV]Y?+4 ,FROM ! MO/ HEAT$ PASSIONS1 TO C>NALITY1 TO CRIME1 TO S5SORY EC/ASY1 TO E/EEM1 TO 9DIFF]5CE1 TO ANNOYANCE4 ,EXCLUD+ IS A BIT LIKE MAK+ LAWS1 DEPRIV+ ONESELF ( POSSIBILITIES = MOVEM5T4 ,UNIT+ DIFF]5T EV5TS CAN CAUSE ! S5SE ( !IR ORIG9ALITY & UNIQU5ESS TO BE LO/4 ,IF = SOME A KISS IS LOVE1 = ME IT IS A S5SATION ( ! LIPS TO EXP]IM5T ) EA* TIME4 ,! 9DIVIDUALS ) :OM ,I %>E MOM5TS >E PR(\NDLY DIFF]5T FROM ONE ANO!R4 ,EA* 9/ANCE1 HAV+ PECULI> *>ACT]I/ICS1 HAS NO?+ TO DO ) ANY O!R 9/ANCE4 ,!RE IS NO D\BT4 ,SO1 :AT IS LOVE & :AT IS FRI5D%IP :5 ONE SPEAKS ( RELATION%IPS8 ,>E !Y ORACLES TO :I* TO PRO/RATE \RSELVES ( OB/ACLES TO EV]Y?+8 ,:O IS ! P]SON ?AT WE CAN GET TAKE P>T 9 ONE ( !SE CATEGORIES ) C]TA9TY8 ,& W\LDN'T ?IS C]TA9TY BE A MISGUID$ & MISLEAD+ BOLDNESS8 ,W\LDN'T IT ALWAYS BE TO SMALL8 ,IF 0! FRAGILE CAGE ( LANGUAGE0 IS :AT /ILL CREATES !SE PROBLEMS = US1 :Y NOT 5T] A BIT MORE 9TO CONTACT ) ONESELF & DO AWAY ) !SE OH SO MY/]I\S & 9TANGIBLE WORDS ?AT LEAD ! FRUIT ( \R P]SONAL EMOTIONS & AGREEABL5ESS BACK TO SOME?+ ?AT DOESN'T EXI/8 ,:Y MAKE ONESELF ! SPOKESP]SON ( CONCEPTS AIM$ AT DEF9+1 E/ABLI%+1 :5 AN UNCONDITION$ ]UPTION ( \R DESIR$ C\LD CANCEL ALL ?IS 9 ORD] TO LEAD IT 9TO ! ABYSS ( ! POSSIBLE1 ! CONCEIVABLE8 ,& :Y NOT CLE>LY1 DECISIVELY1 =CEFULLY DE/ROY ! RELATION%IP :5 IT BECOMES HATEFUL TO US S9CE ! PA/ IS A ?+ ?AT BECOMES EXTRANE\S TO ! EXT5T ?AT Y\ CAN NO LONG] PUT Y\R H&S ON IT4 ,& MEMORIES >E USEFUL1 MORE ?AN ANY?+ ELSE1 TO ?OSE :O MOM5T>ILY LIVE F> FROM !IR WILL4 ,COMRADES1 FRI5DS1 LOV]S1 = ME DISSOLUTION UNITES ALL !SE DESCRIPTIONS4 ,I LOVE1 ,I PREF]1 ,I *OOSE 9 MY [N WAY1 AS A LAWLESS ONE4 ,I DON'T KN[ :AT LOVE IS1 & ,I DON'T KN[ :AT FRI5D%IP IS1 P]HAPS BECAUSE !Y DON'T EXI/ OR P]HAPS BECAUSE ,I HAVE NO NE$ TO USE !SE WORDS1 BECAUSE A HAVE A MORE OR LESS CLE> IDEA ( :AT ! DYNAMIC ( KN[+ & /&+ TOGE!R ) O!RS1 9 AGREEM5T OR DISAGREEM5T1 IS4 ,RELATION%IPS )\T ! DISQUIET+ & UNBE>ABLE PRES5CE ( AU?ORITY >E ! ONLY ONES ?AT ,I PUT UP )1 & ,I RELY ON !M TO EXPRESS MY B\NDLESS ,I ,:5 ONE ( !SE RELATION%IPS T5DS TO CREATE A BIT ( RE/LESSNESS OR SACRIFICE OR ?AT SM>MY ?+ KN[N AS TOL]ANCE1 !N ,I HOLD ?AT ! TIME HAS COME TO REMOVE MYSELF FROM IT1 TO />T OV] 9 ANO!R ( ! 9F9ITE SITUATIONS ?AT ! EXI/5T PROPOSES TO ME4 ,/>T+ AGA9 FROM A GRATIFY+ DETA*M5T4 ,A ,LITTLE1 ,LITTLE ,GIANT BY ,IL ,P&A .<,!RE >E MOM5TS :5 IT SEEMS ?AT ANY?+ C\LD OP5 UP1 ?AT ALL POSSIBILITIES >E 9 PLAY4 ,!SE >E ! MOM5TS WE NE$ TO SEIZE 9 ORD] TO REALIZE \R REBELLI\S DREAMS4 ,!RE >E NO GU>ANTEES 9 !SE MOM5TS1 ONLY POSSIBILITIES4 ,! FOLL[+ >TICLE WAS WRITT5 9 ! MID/ ( ONE SU* MOM5T ?AT OCCURR$ SEV]AL YE>S AGO 9 ,FRANCE4 -- TRANSLATOR.> ,IT IS NOT JU/ A MATT] ( PROPORTIONS4 ,WE ALWAYS APPE> SO V]Y LITTLE 9 ! FACE ( ?IS WORLD ?AT OV]:ELMS US & ?AT NOT ONLY SEEMS 9COMPREH5SIBLE -- ) ITS 5DLESS & 9TRICATE NETWORK ( RELATION%IPS & DEP5D5CIES BETWE5 5DLESS CAUSES & EFFECTS -- BUT ALSO UNASSAILABLE4 ,YES1 ( C\RSE1 WE'D LIKE TO TURN ?IS WORLD UPSIDE D[N1 WE'D LIKE TO DE/ROY !SE RELATION%IPS1 BUT WE DON'T KN[ :]E TO BEG92 EV]Y?+ SEEMS USELESS TO US1 ALL \R DE/RUCTIVE FURY SEEMS TO BE R$UC$ TO AN ALMO/ 9(F5SIVE TICKLE AGA9/ AN IMPASSIVE GIANT4 ,\R HE>TS >E /IRR$ TO REVOLT1 BUT H[ MANY TIMES HAVE WE RUN UP AGA9/ ! SUPPOS$ IMMUTABILITY ( ! GIANT ?AT OPPRESSES US8 ,! POT IS BOIL+1 WE ?9K2 BUT WE DON'T KN[ H[ TO LIFT ITS LID1 ?IS BLESS$ POT1 WE DON'T UND]/& IS RHYME OR REASON4 ,& EV5 IF ! URG5CY ( ?+S ALWAYS GOADS US 9TO ACTION1 IT DOESN'T SEEM TO US ?AT ?IS MANAGES TO PRIME ! ME*ANISM ?AT C\LD PUT ! EXI/5T 9TO A H>D SPOT4 ,\R CONT9UE CLA%ES ) ! WORLD DON'T SUCCE$ 9 REPRODUC+ !MSELVES1 R\S+ ! PASSIONS1 ! WILD & COLLECTIVE FEA/S1 ! REVOLUTIONS ?AT WE DESIRE4 ,& YET1 AS WE KN[1 ! GIANT IS NEI!R SO BIG NOR SO PASSIVE AS WE IMAG9E IT TO BE4 ,! FEA/ IS ALWAYS RI\ND ! CORN]1 BECAUSE IF ! PA?S ( DOM9ATION >E 9F9ITE1 SO >E ! PA?S ( REVOLT3 ! GIANT ?AT WE HAVE 9 \R HEADS IS REALLY A NETWORK ( RELATIONS1 5ORM\S 9DE$1 BUT QUITE CONCRETE1 & !SE RELATIONS USE DET]M9$ *ANNELS1 DET]M9$ PA?S4 ,& !SE PA?S C\LD1 9DE$1 BE BLOCK$1 PRIM+1 9 TIME1 UNPR$ICTABLE ME*ANISMS4 ,SU* AN EV5TUALITY HAS BE5 BR++ DIFFICULT MOM5TS TO LIFE = ! ,FR5* = SEV]AL WEEKS4 ,TRUCK DRIV]S -- ?OSE WAGE-LABOR]S :O DRIVE BACK & =? ACROSS ,FRANCE & ,EUROPE1 TRANSPORT+ COMMODITIES = ! PR(IT ( CAPITAL -- >E ON /RIKE4 ,NOT ONLY >E ALL !SE GOODS NOT BE+ B\K !IR SEMIS AT ! 5TRANCES ( CITIES1 ON ! EXPRESSWAYS & BLOCK TRAFFIC2 OR !Y SURR\ND REF9]IES 9 ORD] TO PREV5T ! RESUPPLY+ ( FUEL4 ,BORDEAUX IS ALREADY COMPLETELY BLOCK$1 LIKE A CONSI/5T NUMB] ( ! CITIES ( ! WE/ & ! S\!A/1 & 9 ,P>IS1 ! SIEGE IS />T+4 ,?9K1 :AT CAN A BLOCKADE ( ?IS SORT >\SE3 ALREADY1 JU/ A FEW %ORT DAYS AFT] ! />T ( ! PROTE/1 A FEW FACTORIES >E NOTICEABLY SL[+ D[N PRODUCTION4 ,)\T RAW MAT]IALS1 9DU/RY CAN'T WORK S9CE ITS PRODUCTS >E NOT TRANSPORT$ & SOLD4 ,& ALONG ) ! FACTORIES1 (FICES & M9I/RIES >E %AK54 ,:AT CAN HAPP5 9 A BLOCKAD$ CITY8 ,EV]Y?+ & NO?+1 IT'S A QUE/ION ( TIME4 ,CITIES >E BUILT >\ND WORK & ITS TIME4 ,! TIME ( ! CITY IS SCANN$ FROM ! H&S ( A CLOCK1 ! TICK+ ( :I* RULES \R LIVES BR&+ \R DAYS ) FIRE4 ,! (FICE1 ! FAMILY1 ,SUNDAYS1 EV5+S1 SURVIVAL DOESN'T SURVIVE )\T ! TICK+ ( ! CLOCKS4 ,H[EV]1 9 A BLOCKAD$ CITY1 TIME MIE BORN ?AT UNLEA% UNPR$ICTABLE ME*ANISMS -- TO SU* AN EXT5T ?AT ! !Y DISPLACE ! N>R[ LIMITS ( DEM&S1 BEYOND :I* IT NO LONG] MATT]S :AT ! TRUCK DRIV]S WANT$ TO NEGOTIATE1 :E!R WAGES1 P5SIONS OR WORK H\RS1 BECAUSE :AT IS AT /AKE IS SOME?+ ELSE 5TIRELY1 SOME?+ = EV]YONE4 ,OR ELSE NO?+ C\LD HAPP5 9 A BLOCKAD$ CITY4 ,IT C\LD BE A HUGE1 V]Y SAD ,SUNDAY4 ,! POT BOILS & ! GIANT IS NEV] TOO BIG = US2 IT CANNOT EV5 SLEEP PEACEFULLY4 ,ITS >T]IES -- ?AT >E ROADS1 ELECTRIC WIRES & COMPUT] NETWORKS -- >E EXPOS$ & CAN BE CUT1 G5]AT+ AN 9F9ITE & UNPR$ICTABLE S]IES ( POSSIBILITIES4 ,BEYOND ! ,LAW BY ,P5ELOPE ,N9 ,TO TELL ! TRU?1 ,I DON'T QUITE UND]/& :AT IS MEANT TODAY :5 PEOPLE SPEAK ( 0ILLEGALISM04 ,I ?\*I/ MOVEM5T ANY MORE1 %UT UP =EV] ) ! EQUALLY ANCI5T 0PROPAG&A ( ! DE$04 ,:5 ,I HAVE HE>D IT TALK$ AB\T AGA9 9 REC5T TIMES 9 SU* %AMELESSLY CRITICAL TONES1 ,I HAV5'T BE5 ABLE TO HOLD BACK A S5SATION ( A/ONI%M5T4 ,I BEG9 TO F9D ?IS MANIA = DU/+ (F OLD >GUM5TS 9 ORD] TO AVOID DEAL+ ) NEW DISCUSSIONS 9TOL]ABLE1 BUT !RE IS SO MU* ( ?IS4 ,ONE ?+1 H[EV]1 SEEMS CLE> TO ME4 ,! ILLEGALISM ?AT IS SPOK5 ( 7BADLY7 TODAY IS NOT ! CONCEPT ?AT WAS DEBAT$ ) SO MU* HE>T-FELT ANIMATION BY ! AN>*I/ MOVEM5T AT ! BEG9N+ ( ! #b? C5TURY4 ,AT ?AT TIME ?IS T]M WAS US$ TO 9DICATE ALL ?OSE PRACTICES PROHIBIT$ BY LAW ?AT W]E USEFUL = RESOLV+ ! ECONOMIC PROBLEMS ( COMRADES3 ROBB]Y1 !FT1 SMUGGL+1 C\NT]FEIT+ MONEY & SO ON4 ,IT SEEMS TO ME ?AT TODAY SOME AN>*I/S1 LACK+ ANY?+ CONCRETE TO DISCUSS1 >E T5D+ MU* TOO EASILY TO CLAIM ?AT ILLEGALISM MEANS A REF9$ GLORIFICATION = ITS [N SAKE ( EV]Y BEHAVIOR =BIDD5 BY LAW1 NOT ONLY ( ?OSE DICTAT$ BY ! REQUIREM5TS ( SURVIVAL4 ,9 %ORT1 ILLEGALISM W\LD BECOME A K9D ( !ORETICAL FRAMEWORK = ]ECT+ ILLEGALITY AS A SY/EM1 A LIFE VALUE4 ,SOME PEOPLE PU% IT EV5 FUR!R1 TO ! PO9T ( C5SUR+ A NO BETT] DEF9$ 0ILLEGALISM AT ALL CO/S01 YE>N+ = COMRADES :O W\LD VIOLATE ! LAW EV5 :5 !Y C\LD DO O!RWISE SIMPLY TO SAVOR ! ?RILL ( ! =BIDD5 OR P]HAPS 9 ORD] TO SATISFY SOME IDEOLOGICAL DOGMA4 ,BUT ,I ASK1 :]E HAVE !SE COMRADES RUN ACROSS ?IS ILLEGALISM AT ALL CO/S1 :O HAS SPOK5 ( IT8 ,:O W\LD BE SU* A FOOL AS TO *ALL5GE ! SEV]ITY ( ! LAW :5 %E C\LD DO O!RWISE8 ,OBVI\SLY1 NOBODY4 ,BUT !RE IS PROBABLY ANO!R PO9T ON :I* IT W\LD BE USEFUL TO REFLECT4 ,CAN AN AN>*I/ AVOID *ALL5G+ ! LAW8 ,C]TA9LY 9 MANY CIRCUM/ANCES ?IS IS POSSIBLE4 ,= EXAMPLE1 AT ! MOM5T ,I AM WRIT+ = A PAP] ?AT IS PUBLI%$ LEGALLY2 DOES ?IS P]HAPS MAKE ME A LEGALI/ AN>*I/8 ,ON ! O!R H&1 IF ,I W]E TO GO ?IS EV5+ TO PUT UP CL&E/9E FLI]S1 W\LD ?IS MAKE ME AN ILLEGALI/ AN>*I/8 ,BUT !N1 :AT W\LD EV] DI/+UI% !SE TWO CATEGORIES ( AN>*I/S8 ,! QUE/ION ( ! RELATION%IP BETWE5 AN AN>*I/ & ! LAW CANNOT BE SETTL$ 9 SU* A HA/Y & MISLEAD+ WAY4 ,AS ,I SEE IT1 ! ACTIONS ( AN AN>*I/ CANNOT BE CONDITION$ BY ! LAW 9 EI!R ! POSITIVE OR ! NEGATIVE4 ,I MEAN ?AT IT CANNOT BE EI!R ! REV]5TIAL RESPECT = ! GUID+ /&>DS ( ! TIME OR ! PLEASURE ( TRANSGRESSION AS AN 5D 9 ITSELF ?AT DRIVES H]1 BUT RA!R HIS IDEAS & DREAMS UNIT$ TO H] 9DIVIDUAL 9CL9ATIONS4 ,9 O!R WORDS1 AN AN>*I/ CAN ONLY BE AN ALEGALI/1 AN 9DIVIDUAL :O PROPOSES TO DO :AT MO/ PLEASES HIM BEYOND ! LAW1 )\T BAS+ H]SELF ON :AT ! P5AL CODE ALL[S OR =BIDS4 ,( C\RSE1 ! LAW EXI/S & ONE CANNOT PRET5D NOT TO SEE IT4 ,I AM QUITE AW>E ?AT !RE IS ALWAYS A BLUDGEON READY TO ATT5D TO \R DESIRES ALONG ! WAY T[>D !IR REALIZATION1 BUT ?IS ?REAT %\LD NOT 9FLU5CE \R DECISION AB\T ! MEANS TO USE TO REALIZE ?AT :I* IS DE>E/ TO \R HE>TS4 ,IF ,I CONSID] IT IMPORTANT TO PUBLI% A PAP] -- A ?+ ?AT IS CONSID]$ LEGAL -- ,I CAN EASILY ATTEMPT TO FOLL[ ! PROVISIONS ( ! LAW AB\T ! PRESS 9 ORD] TO AVOID USELESS ANNOYANCE1 S9CE ?IS DOES NOT *ANGE ! CONT5TS ( :AT ,I 9T5D TO COMMUNICATE AT ALL4 ,BUT1 ON ! O!R H&1 IF ,I CONSID] IT IMPORTANT TO C>RY AN ACTION CONSID]$ ILLEGAL -- LIKE ! ATTACK AGA9/ ! /RUCTURES & PEOPLE ( P[] -- ,I WILL NOT *ANGE MY M9D SIMPLY BECAUSE SOMEONE WAVES ! R$ FLAG ( ! RISKS ,I WILL FACE BE=E MY EYES4 ,IF ,I ACT$ O!RWISE1 ! P5AL CODE W\LD BE ADVIS+ ME AB\T :AT MY CONDUCT %\LD BE1 GREATLY LIMIT+ MY POSSIBILITIES TO ACT & ?US TO EXPRESS MYSELF4 ,BUT IF IT IS AN ABSURDITY TO DESCRIBE AN AN>*I/ AS 0ILLEGALI/01 IT W\LD BE RIDICUL\S TO ATTRIBUTE ! QUALITY ( 0LEGALI/0 TO H]4 ,H[ C\LD AN AN>*I/1 AN 9DIVIDUAL :O DESIRES A WORLD )\T AU?ORITY1 EXPECT TO BE ABLE TO REALIZE HIS DREAM )\T EV] BREAK+ ! LAW1 :I* IS ! MO/ IMM$IATE EXPRESSION ( AU?ORITY1 ?AT IS TO SAY1 )\T TRANSGRESS+ ?OSE NORMS ?AT HAVE BE5 DELIB]ATELY E/ABLI%$ & WRITT5 9 ORD] TO DEF5D ! SOCIAL ORD]8 ,ANYONE :O 9T5DS TO RADICALLY TRANS=M ?IS WORLD W\LD NECESS>ILY HAVE TO PLACE H]SELF SOON] OR LAT] AGA9/ ! LAW ?AT AIMS TO CONS]VE IT4 ,UNLESS444,UNLESS ! DESIRE TO *ANGE ?AT WORLD ?AT /ILL SMOLD]S 9 ! HE>TS ( !SE AN>*I/S IS 9 SOME WAY SUBORD9AT$ TO ! WORRIES AB\T ! RISKS !Y MI*I/S IS CONSID]$ A GREAT & BEAUTIFUL ?+1 BUT MA9LY 9 ! REALM ( !ORY -- MANIFE/+ ITSELF 9 ! 9(F5SIVE BANT] EX*ANG$ =K ! >M*AIRS AFT] A SUFFOCAT+ DAY ( WORK -- BECAUSE FROM ! PRACTICAL PO9T ( VIEW ! /R5G? ( DOM9ATION (F]S NO HOPE4 ,!N IT IS ADVISABLE TO MAKE UTOPIA 9TO SOME?+ CONCRETE1 ) ITS FEET UPON ! GR\ND1 UNIT+ IT ) GOOD S5SE1 BECAUSE REVOLUTION C\LD NEV] BE CONSID]$ LEGAL UND] ANY P5AL CODE4 ,5\< ( DREAM+ ! IMPOSSIBLE2 LET'S TRY TO OBTA9 ! TOL]ABLE4 ,H]E IT IS1 ! 9VECTIVE AGA9/ ! MY? ( ILLEGALISM COM+ FROM C]TA9 AN>*I/S TAKES ON A PRECISE MEAN+1 ?AT ( JU/IFY+ !IR SELF-9T]E/$ PR$ISPOSITION TO CON=M TO ! DICTATES ( ! LAW1 SETT+ ASIDE EV]Y FOOLI%1 IMMOD]ATE ASPIRATION4 ,9 ! NAME ( REALISM1 ( C\RSE4 ,! ,RUDIM5TS ( ,T]ROR ,! RUL+ ORD] & ITS *ALL5G] FACE EA* O!R4 ,! =M] HAS EV]Y?+3 AN ORGANIZATION -- ! /ATE -- ECONOMIC P[]1 MILIT>Y P[]1 CONTROL OV] ! 5TIRE NATION4 ,! LATT] HAS LITTLE AT ITS DISPOSAL4 ,ONLY A SPECIFIC NUMB] ( PEOPLE1 FULL ( DESP]ATION1 ) A FEW RUDIM5T>Y WEAPONS4 ,BUT !SE FEW >E 9SPIR$ BY A T]RIBLE PROPULSIVE =CE1 ! AMBITION = DOM9ATION1 ?AT IS GREAT 5\< TO MOVE !M TO LAUN* !IR *ALL5GE4 ,!Y KN[ ?AT !Y >E WEAK] ?AN !IR ADV]S>Y1 SO !Y MU/ /RIKE & RUN1 /RIKE & RUN4 ,& :5 A P[] -- EV5 9 EMBRYO -- MU/ /RIKE1 IT KN[S ONLY ONE TOOL3 T]RORISM1 ! USE ( 9T5TIONALLY BL9D & 9DISCRIM9ATE VIOL5CE4 ,LIKE ?AT ( ,DECEMB] #c1 #aiif 9 ,P>IS :I* CAUS$ ! DEA? ( TWO PEOPLE & ! W\ND+ ( FIFTY MORE1 MANGL$ BY ! EXPLOSION ( A BOMB ?AT HAPP5$ 9 A SUBWAY C>4 ,T]RORISM HAS RETURN$ -- ! MASS M$IA ?R\<\T ! WORLD HAS BEGUN TO SCREAM IT4 ,IT HAS RETURN$8 ,BUT :5 DID IT EV] GO AWAY8 ,( C\RSE1 ! T]RORISM ( ! *ALL5G+ P[] IS BLATANT & IS IMM$IATELY D5\NC$ AS SU* BY ! M$IA ( ITS RIVAL4 ,BUT :O WILL HAVE ! BOLDNESS TO D5\NCE ! T]RORISM ( ! P[] 9 (FICE1 ! T]RORISM ( ! /ATE1 P>TICUL>LY ! P[]FUL /ATES ?AT MA9TA9 ! GLOBAL ORD]8 ,! IMAGES ( MANGL$ BODIES HAVE TRAVEL$ >\ND ! GLOBE1 R\S+ ! HORROR ( ALL1 P]HAPS 5\< TO MAKE PEOPLE =GET ?AT = ?OSE 9 P[] 7& = ?OSE SEEK+ IT7 ! 0COMMON PEOPLE0 HAVE ALWAYS BE5 ?\ OR ON A BATTLEFIELD DOESN'T REALLY MAKE ANY DIFF]5CE4 ,!SE DEA?S & 9JURIES >E JU/ LIKE ! DEA?S & 9JURIES CAUS$ BY A]IAL BOMB+1 LIKE ?OSE ?AT OCCUR YE>-R\ND AT WORKPLACES1 9 B>RACKS1 9 POLICE /ATIONS1 9 HOSPITALS1 9 PRISONS4 ,LIKE ?OSE BR\ P[] PLANTS1 BY ! ADULT]ATION ( \R FOOD1 BY ATMOSPH]IC POLLUTION OR BY ! PSY*OSOMATIC ILLNESSES CAUS$ BY ! WAY ( LIFE ?AT IS IMPOS$ ON US 9 ?IS WORLD4 ,SO H]E IT IS1 ! VIOL5CE ?AT /RIKES EV]YONE 9 A BL9D & 9DISCRIM9ATE FA%ION4 ,H]E IT IS1 ! T]RORISM ( ! /ATE4 ,POOR ,H]OES 0,HIS DEA? UNLEA%$ A FRANTIC PROPAG&A AB\T ! H]O ,DURRUTI4 ,ANY DISCUSSION W\LD 5D ) ! CITATION ( HIS NAME4 ,& EA* TIME HE WAS NAM$1 A BIT ( HIS ?\*I/ 9 ! WORLD4 ,HIS NAME IS L9K$ TO ! ,SPANI% REVOLUTION1 TO ! SUMM] ( #a#i#c#f1 :5 ! ,IB]IAN PROLET>IAT ROSE UP1 >MS 9 H&1 AGA9/ P[] & ATTACK$ ! MILIT>Y BASES1 BURN$ ! *UR*ES1 OCCUPI$ ! FACTORIES4 ,IT IS ?IS /RUGGLE1 :]E HE F\ES TO BR+ HIS /ATEM5TS OR HIS ACTIONS 9TO QUE/ION4 ,NO ONE4 ,! D>K SIDES ( H]OES NE$ NEV] BE PUT ON DISPLAY2 !Y >E JU/IFI$4 ,& ,DURUTTI HAD HIS D>K SIDES AS EV]Y HUMAN BE+ DOES4 ,( ?OSE L9K$ TO HIS *>ACT]1 SU* AS HIS HATR$ = HOMOSEXUALS1 !RE IS NO?+ MORE TO SAY4 ,EV]YONE IS MADE AS !Y >E1 & BESIDES SO MU* WAT] HAS PASS$ UND] ! BRIDGE S9CE !N4 ,BUT :AT ( ?OSE L9K$ TO HIS *OICES 9 LIFE8 ,:AT CAN BE SAID AB\T !SE8 ,:AT1 = EXAMPLE1 CAN BE SAID AB\T HIS PA/ AS A BANK ROBB]8 ,SOME?+ NE$S TO BE SAID AB\T IT TODAY :5 !RE >E AN>*I/S 9 PRISON ACCUS$ ( ROBB+ BANKS4 ,CAN ONE S+ ! PRAISES ( ?AT DI/ANT AN>*I/ ROBB]1 D$ICATE A F9E COMMEMORATIVE BOOK TO HIM & KEEP SIL5T AB\T ! AN>*I/ ROBB]S ( \R TIME8 ,A RESPONSE TO ?IS IS NECESS>Y2 ! COMP>ISON IS F> TOO OBVI\S4 ,&1 AS USUAL1 ! RESPONSE IS F\ND 9 HIS TIME1 9 HIS IMPLACABLE RAIDS1 9 HIS ABILITY TO 0OBJECTIVELY0 *ANGE CONTEXTS & SITUATIONS4 ,& !N !RE IS ! MAN1 ,BU5AV5TURA ,DURUTTI4 ,WASN'T HE1 9 FACT1 ! ONE :O SAID -- & ! WORD ( A H]O IS SACR$ -- ?AT 0!N ,I FOLL[$ ?AT ME?OD BECAUSE ! CIRCUM/ANCES W]E DIFF]5T FROM ?OSE ( ! PRES5T DAY01 & 0,B&ITRY1 NO4 ,COLLECTIVE EXPROPRIATION1 YES6 ,YE/]DAY IS SURPASS$ BY ! ROAD ( HI/ORY ITSELF4 ,& ANYONE :O DESIRES TO REVIVE IT1 TAK+ REFUGE 9 '! RIRY \T ! GREAT REVOLUTION40 ,=GET ?AT1 AFT] ! PROPITI\S MOM5T :5 HE URG$ COLLECTIVE ACTION HAD PASS$1 IT W\LD BE ! TIME = ,SABATE1 ,FAC]IAS & O!R AN>*I/ PROPON5TS ( 9DIVIDUAL ACTION -- :O W]E MALIGN$ & DIS[N$ = ?IS BY O!R AN>*I/S AFRAID ?AT !IR ORGANIZATION MIE WE 9 A MOM5T PROPITI\S = REVOLUTION8 ,& BESIDES1 DON'T ,DURUTTI'S ?\T ( SU* ORGANIZATIONS1 AHO HAVE ALWAYS /RONGLY AFFIRM$ 9DIVIDUAL RESPONSIBILITY = !IR ACTIONS8 ,HAS ,DURUTTI'S MEAN+ BE5 ]AS$ 9 ORD] TO USE HIS WORDS AGA9/ !SE PEOPLE8 ,?OSE :O HAVE SOME?+ TO SAY >E ONLY HIS SELF-9T]E/$ 9T]PRET]S1 PREOCCUPI$ ) CONFIRM+ = ! MILLION? TIME ?AT !RE IS NO SALVATION \TSIDE ! *UR*4 ,POOR ,DURUTTI4 ,HIS NAME -- :5 NOT US$ TO *RI/5 AN AFT]-WORK B> = COMRADES -- IS R$UC$ TO A M]E POLEMICAL TOOL4 "9 "9 "9 "9 "9 ,! NEXT F\R TEXTS W]E PR9T$ 9 ,CAN5]O 9 ORD] TO /IMULATE ON ONGO+ DISCUSSION4 ,UN=TUNATELY1 ?IS DISCUSSION NEV] W5T BEYOND :AT IS PR9T$ H]E & A FEW V]Y BRIEF /ATEM5TS ?AT M]ELY AM\NT$ TO TAK+ SIDES RA!R ?AN FUR!R+ ! DEBATE4 ,AL?\< ,I AM QUITE AW>E ?AT ! SPECIFIC DETAIL ( ! SITUATION 9 ,ITALY 9 #a#i#i#f-#g W]E QUITE DIFF]5T FROM \R PRES5T SITUATION1 ,I1 NONE!LESS1 ?9K ?AT !RE >E BROAD] IDEAS PRES5T$ 9 !SE TEXTS WOR?Y ( DISCUSSION & DEBATE 9 RELATION%IP TO A REAL PRACTICE H]E AS WELL4 ,I HOPE ?AT !RE >E ?OSE :O WILL BE MOV$ TO FUR!R ?IS DISCUSSION 9 T]MS ( \R SITUATION H]E & N[4 -- ! TRANSLATOR "9 "9 "9 "9 "9 ,COMMUNIQUE ,FROM ,PRISON ,ON ! DAY ?AT ! /ATE-CAPITAL 9 ITS TWO-FOLD CAPACITY ( JUDGE-OPPRESSOR WILL (FICIATE ITS V9DICATORY TRIAL 79 ! ,OCCORSIO HALL ( ! C\RT 9 ,ROME ON ,DECEMB] #a1 #a#i#i#f7 AGA9/ ! AN>*I/ MOVEM5T -- AN >*AIC RITE ( 9SULT & CRIM9ALIZATION AGA9/ ! TRANSGRESSORS ( B\RGEOIS SOCIETY -- 9 ! ATTEMPT TO EXPUNGE EV]Y =M ( 9DIVIDUAL OR ORGANIZ$ REVOLUTION>Y ANTAGONISM COMBAT+ ! EXPLOITATION ( ! HUMAN BE+1 WE FE>LESSLY AFFIRM COMBATANT REVOLUTION>Y ACTION1 )\T UNREALI/IC APHORISMS OR ANA!MAS WE WILL CLAIM \R ID5TITY AS AN >M$ ORGANIZATION AGA9/ ! /ATE4 ,9 ?AT HALL-LIKE PLACE1 =MAL REPRES5TATION ( ! LEGITIMACY ( B\RGEOIS LAW1 WE WILL PRACTICE MILITANT AN>*I/ ANTI-JUDICIALISM BY AB/A9+ FROM ! F>CE ( ! DEBATE ( ! TRIAL4 ,WE WILL NOT 5DORSE ! MY?ICAL 0DE JURE01 JUDICIAL DOCTR9E1 AGE-OLD NORMATIVE H]ITAGE ( /ATES ?AT >E DEVELOP$ ON ! AGE-OLD USURPATIONS ( SLAV]Y1 TORTURE & ! EXPLOITATION ( O!R PEOPLE'S LABOR1 ?AT GU>ANTEES DEF5SE = ?OSE 9VE/IGAT$1 (F]+ !M ! JUDICIAL TOOL ( REPLY1 A WAY ( GU>ANTEE+ ! 0DEMOCRATIC0 =M ( ! PROSECUT+ TRIAL1 A %>P1 CORRUPT & DECEPTIVE WAY DISGUISE A PRIORI ! PREJUDICE AGA9/ ! DEF5DANTS :O DON'T APPE> 9 C\RT4 ,WE WILL NOT RECOGNIZE ! JUDGES6 ,9DU/RIAL CIVILIZATION IS ! HIE P[]FUL ORGANIZ]S ( CULTURE1 ! CULTURE ?AT IS SUMM$ UP 9 ! SYMBOLS ( ! COMMODITY AS M$IATIONS BETWE5 PRODUCTION & CONSUMPTION4 ,! GLOBALIZATION ( EXPLOITATION N[ SO EXTREMELY NORMAL IS 9TELLECTUAL4 ,! C]EBRAL FLATT5+ TO ! PREORDA9$ S*EMATA ( 9TELLIG5T MA*9ES1 ! HOMOG5IZATION ( ! CULTURES ( PEOPLES TO ! NEW LANGUAGES ( COMMUNICATIONS & PRODUCTION >E ! AIM ( ! NEW IMP]IALI/ COLONIALISM4 ,CYB]NETIC UNIV]SALISM1 OR MULTIM$IA COMMUNICATION1 IS A TOOL ( ! SY/EMATIC & QUANTITATIVE REORGANIZATION ( ! NEW WORLD ORD]1 9 ! SECTORS ( ! M>KET1 ( CAPITAL1 ( ! 9/ITUTIONAL ORD] & ( ! T]RITORIAL 9FRA/RUCTURE1 ( ! REPRESSION ( ANTAGONI/S1 REFRACTORY TO ! HOMOG5IZATION ( ! NEW SCI5TISM1 9TELLECTUAL /&>DIZ]4 ,9SPIR+ \RSELVES CRITICALLY ) ! EXP]I5CES ( ! ANTAGONI/ >M$ MOVEM5T ( ! #a#i#gS & P>TICUL>LY ) ! AN>*I/ H]ITAGE1 ) /RUGGLES = REGIONAL 9DEP5D5CE1 /ABLE REF]5CES = \R PA? ( CONFLICT ) ! /ATE-CAPITAL AIM$ AT EXT+UI%+ !M ?R\< 9SURRECTIONAL MEANS1 !RE=E1 ON ! BASIS ( ?IS HI/ORICAL H]ITAGE1 WE ALLUDE TO CON/RUCT+ A COMMUNI/ SOCIETY 9 AN>*I/ PRODUCTION 9 ! ANTI-LEGAL S5SE1 )\T C\RTS OR PRISONS1 ?R\< /RUGGLE AGA9/ EV]Y =M ( GOV]NM5T & P[] ?AT IS REALIZ$ ?R\< ! EF=TS ( ! EXPLOIT$2 AN ICONOCLA/IC SOCIETY 9SPIR$ BY FREE COOP]ATION AMONG PEOPLE & BY FREE $UCATION4 ,WE RECOGNIZE 9 ?IS C\RT ! FAWN+ ROLE ( ! S]VANT ( ! /ATE1 9 :I*1 LIV+ LIKE A C\RTI] (F ! SWEAT ( ! PRODUCTIVE LABOR ( WORK]S & PEASANTS1 IT 9SURES ?AT ! EXPLOIT$ POPULACE CONT9UES ITS OBSEQUI\S S]VICE TO B\RGEOIS JU/ICE4 ,EV]Y REVOLUTION>Y ACTION AGA9/ ! /ATE & B\RGEOIS 9/ITUTIONS WILL BE CLAIM$ AS ! SIGN ( A BEG9N+ & A CONT9UATION ( A PRECISE ANTAGONI/IC PA?1 CALL$ ,COMBATANT ,REVOLUTION>Y ,ACTION1 = :I* WE WILL ASSUME ALL RESPONSIBILITY 9 FRONT ( P[]4 ,NO CLAIM AT ALL -- AT LEA/ ON \R P>T -- = ACTIONS AGA9/ ! /ATE ) ! CIRCLE ,A1 BECAUSE ?IS EXPOSES ! AN>*I/ MOVEM5T TO CONT9U\S PROVOCATIONS1 :ILE IT IS RIY S5SE ( A COMBATANT1 9T]NATIONALI/1 ANTI-IMP]IALI/ AN>*I/ ORGANIZATION1 9 RELATION ) ALL REVOLUTION>Y =CES ?AT 9T5D TO SUBV]T ! ORD] ( ! B\RGEOIS CAPITALI/ /ATE 9 ITS PHASE ( GLOBALIZATION1 9 ORD] TO 9TRODUCE \RSELVES AS A UNIQUE PRODUCTIVE & ORGANIZATIONAL MODEL = RELATIONS BETWE5 HUMAN BE+S4 ,TO ! MANY-C5T]$ & CAM\FLAG$ CON=MATION ( CYB]NETIC-9DU/RIAL P[]1 WE WILL RESPOND ) WIDE-SPREAD & WELL-AIM$ ACTIONS TO UND]M9E IT BO? ON ! T]RITORY & 9 ! URBAN SPACE 9 :I* ! ORGANIZATIONAL & 9=MATIONAL 9FRA/RUCTURES ( ITS DOM9ATION >E C5T]$4 ,LIV+ =CE TO ALL REVOLUTION>Y PRISON]S & TO ALL COMBATANTS1 = A NEW FREE1 AN>*I/ & COMMUNI/ ANTI-AU?ORIT>IAN SOCIETY4 ,LET'S REMEMB] TO AV5GE ALL ! COMRADES /RUCK BY ! FIRE ( ! REPRESSION ( ! /ATE-CAPITAL4 ,LONG LIVE AN>*Y1 LONG LIVE >M$ /RUGGLE4 ,ROME1 ,DECEMB] #a1 #aiif ,PIPPO ,/ASI1 ,K>E*9 ,CRICORIAN 7,G>AG9 ,GREGORIAN7 ,! ,FULLNESS ( A ,/RUGGLE ,)\T ,ADJECTIVES ,REC5TLY A COMMUNIQUE FROM PRISON WAS DI/RIBUT$ ?AT HAS PROBABLY DI/URB$ QUITE A FEW COMRADES4 ,WE >E REPRODUC+ IT H]E4 ,?\< IT HAS ! TONE ( A PROCLAMATION & C]TA9 /ATEM5TS >E AMBIGU\S1 IT SEEMS TO US ?AT WE CAN RULE \T ! IDEA ?AT WE >E CONFRONT+ ! ANN\NCEM5T ( ! =MATION ( AN AN>*I/ >M$ ORGANIZATION4 ,?IS W\LD BE ILLOGICAL = V>I\S REASONS4 ,= EXAMPLE1 BECAUSE1 ?R\<\T TIME1 >M$ GR\PS HAVE BE5 %REWD 5\< TO EXPLA9 !MSELVES AFT] !Y HAVE ACT$1 & IT DOESN'T APPE> TO US AS IF ! ACRONYM 0,COMBATANT ,REVOLUTION>Y ,ACTION0 HAS EV] CLAIM$ ANY?+4 ,FUR!RMORE1 IF ! COMRADES :O SIGN$ ! COMMUNIQUE HAD1 9DE$1 =M$ AN >M$ ORGANIZATION1 !IR DOCUM5T W\LD BECOME AN EXPLICIT SELF-D5UNCIATION BE=E ! C\RT1 & ?IS EV5 BE=E HAV+ 9ITIAT$ HO/ILITIES4 ,IF SU* A ?+ W]E TRUE1 IT W\LD MAKE NO S5SE AT ALL4 ,FROM ?IS1 WE D$UCE ?AT ! TEXT %\LD BE 9T]PRET$ AS A SIMPLE PROPOSAL4 ,UN=TUNATELY1 ! WRET*$ L+UI/IC /YLE 9 :I* IT WAS =MULAT$ RISKS PROVOK+ MISUND]/&+S & 9COMPREH5SION ?AT IT W\LD BE BE/ = EV]YONE TO AVOID4 ,MORE SIMPLY1 WE BELIEVE ?AT ,PIPPO ,/ASI & ,G>AG9 ,GREGORIAN WI% TO 9VITE ! AN>*I/ MOVEM5T TO REFLECT ON ! >GUM5TS ?AT !Y SET =?1 LIKE ! NECESSITY = A PORTION ( AN>*I/S TO UND]TAKE A PA? ( >M$ /RUGGLE &1 !RE=E TO CREATE A SPECIFIC >M$ /RUGGLE4 ,& S9CE !SE COMRADES HAVE NOT HESITAT$ TO /ATE :AT !Y ?9K1 ASSUM+ ALL RESPONSIBILITY1 WE ASSUME ?AT NO ONE WILL TAKE IT BADLY IF WE DO ! SAME4 ,AS WE HAVE (T5 TAK5 ! OPPORTUNITY TO SAY 9 ! COLUMNS ( ?IS PAP]1 WE >E DECID$LY OPPOS$ TO ALL >M$ ORGANIZATION1 9CLUD+ AN UNLIKELY AN>*I/ >M$ ORGANIZATION4 ,H]E IT IS NOT A QUE/ION ( A M]E DIV]G5CE ( VIEWS1 BUT ( A SUB/ANTIAL RADICAL DIFF]5CE ?AT GOES WELL BEYOND ANY CONSID]ATIONS ( EXP$I5CY OR CONT+5CY4 ,WE >E AGA9/ ANY >M$ ORGANIZATION TODAY1 AS WE W]E YE/]DAY & WILL BE TOMORR[4 ,& WE CONFIRM ?AT ?IS AV]SION ( \RS IS NOT LIMIT$ TO =MAL DISAGREEM5T4 ,NOT ONLY WILL WE NEV] SUPPORT AN >M$ ORGANIZATION1 BUT WE WILL OPPOSE IT ) A H>% CRITIQUE4 ,WE WILL OPPOSE ITS =MATION & SPREAD BECAUSE WE CONSID] IT HO/ILE TO US1 9S(> AS IT IS NOT CAPABLE ( G5]AT+ PROSPECTS ?AT WE F9D DESIRABLE4 ,WE ?9K ?AT ! 9DIVIDUAL :O RISES UP1 ! 9DIVIDUAL :O REBELS AGA9/ ?IS WORLD ?AT IS TOO CRAMP$ TO CONTA9 HIS DREAMS1 HAS NO 9T]E/ 9 LIMIT+ !IR POSSIBILITIES1 BUT 9 EXT5D+ !M 9F9ITELY IF POSSIBLE4 ,?IR/Y = FRE$OM1 EAG] = EXP]I5CE1 ANYONE :O REBELS IS 9 CONT9U\S SE>* = NEW AFF9ITIES1 = NEW TOOLS ) :I* TO EXPRESS H]SELF1 ) :I* TO GO TO ! ATTACK ON ! EXI/5T 9 ORD] TO SUBV]T IT FROM ! F\NDATIONS4 ,?IS IS :Y 9SURRECTIONAL /RUGGLE %\LD F9D ITS /IMULUS & 5]GY 9 \R CAPACITY = FILL+ ITS >S5AL ) EV] NEW WEAPONS1 BEYOND & AGA9/ ALL R$UCTIVE SPECIALIZATION4 ,! EXP]TS 9 PI/OLS >E LIKE ! EXP]TS 9 BOOKS1 OR OCCUPATIONS1 OR :ATEV] ELSE4 ,!Y >E BOR+ BECAUSE !Y ALWAYS & ONLY SPEAK AB\T !MSELVES & !IR FAVORITE MEANS4 ,PRECISELY BECAUSE WE DO NOT PRIVILEGE ONE TOOL OV] ANY ( ! O!RS1 WE LOVE & SUPPORT NUMB]LESS ACTIONS1 C>RI$ \T ?R\< ! MO/ V>I$ MEANS1 ?AT OCCUR DAILY AGA9/ ! RUL+ ORD] & ITS /RUCTURES4 ,BECAUSE REVOLT IS LIKE POETRY3 TO BE SU* IT MU/ BE MADE BY ALL1 NOT BY ONE ALONE1 P>TICUL>LY NOT AN EXP]T4 ,N[ ! SPECIFIC >M$ ORGANIZATION IS ! NEGATION ( ?IS 9SURRECTION>Y /RUGGLE1 ! P>ASITE POISON+ ! BLOOD4 ,:]EAS 9SURRECTION 5C\RAGES 5JOYM5T & ! REALIZATION ( :AT WE HAVE AT HE>T1 >M$ ORGANIZATION ONLY PROMISES SACRIFICE & IDEOLOGY4 ,:]EAS 9SURRECTION EXALTS ! POSSIBILITIES ( 9DIVIDUALS1 >M$ ORGANIZATION ONLY EXALTS ! TE*NIQUES ( ITS SOLDI]S4 ,:]EAS 9SURRECTION CONSID]S A GUN OR A /ICK ( DYNAMITE TO BE ONLY ONE ( ! WEAPONS AVAILABLE TO IT1 ! >M$ ORGANIZATION MAKES IT ! ONLY WEAPON1 ! ONLY TOOL TO USE 70,LONG LIVE >M$ /RUGGLE074 ,:]EAS 9SURRECTION AIMS TO G5]ALIZE ITSELF & 9VITES EV]YONE TO P>TICIPATE 9 ITS FE/IVAL1 ! >M$ ORGANIZATION IS CLOS$ BY =CE ( CIRCUM/ANCE & -- EXCEPT = ITS FEW MILITANTS -- NO?+ IS LEFT = O!RS TO DO EXCEPT TO *E] IT ON4 ,! SUBV]SION ( LIFE IS A VA/ PROJECT ?AT KN[S NO LIMITS1 BECAUSE IT AIMS TO DISRUPT ! TOTALITY ( SOCIETY4 ,>M$ ORGANIZATION IS ONLY ABLE TO GLIMPSE A M>G9AL ASPECT ( ?IS /RUGGLE -- ! MILIT>Y CONFLICT AGA9/ ! /ATE -- & MI/AKES IT = ! :OLE4 ,& EV5 ?IS CONFLICT1 EV5 ! >M$ ATTACK AGA9/ ! /ATE1 LOSES ANY LIB]ATORY MEAN+1 ANY BREA? ( LIFE1 :5 ITS 5TIRE IMPETUS IS R$UC$ TO ! PROMOTION ( A PROGRAM AN ACRONYM TO SP5D AT ! POLITICAL M>KET4 ,IT IS RA!R 9 ANONYMITY ?AT ALL POLITICAL CALCULATION VANI%ES1 LEAV+ SPACE = ! ?\S&S ( 9DIVIDUAL T5SIONS & VIBRATIONS1 & = ! POSSIBILITY = !M TO MEET1 COME TOGE!R & AB&ON !MSELVES 9 EA* O!R4 ,& ( :AT USE >E NEON SIGNS TO ?OSE ) NO COMMODITIES TO SELL4 ,AS TO ! ACCUSATION AGA9/ ?OSE ACTIONS CLAIM$ ) A 0CIRCLE ,A01 CLAIM+ ?AT !Y EXPOSE ! :OLE AN>*I/ MOVEM5T TO POLICE PROVOCATION1 O!R AN>*I/S1 T]RORIZ$ BY ! IDEA ?AT SOMEONE MI*I/S ( HAV+ SIGN$ AN ACTION ) A 0CIRCLE ,A01 ! POLICE WILL SUSPECT !M ( BE+ P>T ( A SPECIFIC GR\P4 ,IT SEEMS TO US TO BE A BIT HA/Y TO CLAIM ?AT 9 ! #a#i#gS1 ! AN>*I/ MOVEM5T KNEW SPECIFIC EXP]I5CES ( ! COMBATANT MODEL1 S9CE ! 0,REVOLUTION>Y ,ACTION0 7,>7 >*IPELAGO -- TO :I* WE ASSUME ,/ASI & ,GREGORIAN >E REF]R+ -- CAN ONLY BE DESCRIB$ AS 0AN>*I/0 AT ! CO/ ( A HUGE IDEOLOGICAL DI/ORTION4 ,9 FACT1 COMRADES ( V>I\S ORIG9S CAME TOGE!R 9 ,> 1 ANIMAT$ AT ! BEG9N+ BY A LIB]T>IAN & ANTI-/AL9I/ SPIRIT ?AT DEF9$ ITS EXP]IM5T = A BRIEF TIME AS AN>*O-COMMUNI/1 CONSID]$ AS ! SUMMATION ( ! V>I\S POSITIONS ( ! COMRADES4 ,BUT IT HAS BECOME CLE> TO MANY AN>*I/S ?AT >M$ ORGANIZATIONS1 NONE ( !M EXCLUD$1 CONTRIBUT$ TO ! DECL9E ( SOCIAL SUBV]SION 9 ?OSE YE>S4 ,& !SE CRITICAL REFLECTIONS >E NOT NEW1 BUT HAVE BE5 EXPRESS$ BY V>I\S AN>*I/S ON MANY OCCASIONS S9CE ! #a#i#gS4 ,WE DON'T KN[ :AT REASONS PU%$ ,/ASI & ,GREGORIAN TO DI/RIBUTE ?IS WRIT+4 ,TO SAY IT ALL1 !IR PROPOSAL SEEMS \T ( ?IS WORLD TO US1 A BIT LIKE ! RHETORIC US$ = ! OCCASION1 ?AT SEEMS TO COME DIRECTLY FROM DEBATES ?AT RAG$ 9 ! #a#i#gS1 POISON+ ! ATMOSPH]E4 ,BUT MORE ?AN ANY?+ ELSE1 WE DON'T LIKE TO SEE COMRADES ACCEPT ! ULTIMATUM ! P[] PUTS =? TODAY 7EI!R RE=MISM OR >M$ /RUGGLE7 ALL[+ !MSELVES TO GET DRAWN 9TO ! FOOLI% GAME ( UPP+ ! ANTE3 S9CE WE >E ACCUS$ ( BELONG+ TO AN >M$ B& ?AT DOESN'T EXI/1 :Y NOT =M A REAL ONE8 ,WELL1 ?IS TEMPTATION1 ?IS ATTRACTION T[>D ! ONE-WAY MIRROR ( ! >M$ ORGANIZATION1 HAS NO GRIP ON US1 & WE WILL NEV] TIRE ( CRITICIZ+ IT :]EV] IT MANIFE/S ITSELF4 ,9SURRECTION HAS DESIRES & REASONS ?AT NO MILIT>Y LOGIC C\LD EV] UND]/&4 ,A ,MISS+ ,DEBATE ,?REE WEEKS AGO1 :5 WE PUBLI%$ ,G>AG9 ,GREGORIAN & ,PIPPO ,/ASI'S COMMUNIQUE FROM PRISON1 WE ?\E ALWAYS RELEVANT 7SPECIALIZATION1 SPECIFIC >M$ ORGANIZATION1 ATTACK1 JU/ICE7 & ON O!RS ?AT -- HAV+ NEV] REALLY DISAPPE>$ -- HAVE RETURN$ AFT] MANY YE>S TO %AKE UP \R LIVES 7! QUE/ION ( GO+ ON ! LAM1 = EXAMPLE74 ,9 \R OP9ION1 ALL !SE TOPICS %\LD BE FAC$ 9 P]SPECTIVE4 ,BY ?IS WE MEAN ?AT !Y %\LD BE CONFRONT$ NOT JU/ ON ! BASIS ( ! MU* TOO OBVI\S LOGIC ( 0COMRADES >E GR[N-UP1 WEAN$ & *OOSE :AT TO DO = !MSELVES04 ,WE'VE ALL REA*$ ?IS PO9T1 & IT SEEMS RIDICUL\S TO REPEAT IT4 ,IT IS NOT SO NECESS>Y TO SAY :I* CONCEPTION SEEMS TO US TO BE MORE OR LESS COMPATIBLE ) 0AN>*I/ E?ICS & TRADITION01 BUT :I* ONE SEEMS LIKE IT C\LD MOVE 9 \R P]SPECTIVE4 ,AN >M$ B& C\LD POSSIBLY BE ORGANIZ$ 9 A HORIZONTAL MANN]1 BUT :AT DOES ?AT HAVE TO DO ) \R 9SURRECTION8 ,9 ! >TICLE ?AT ACCOMPANI$ ! COMRADES' COMMUNIQUE1 WE DID NO?+ MORE ?AN REASS]T ! BASIC BANALITIES ON ! QUE/ION ( >M$ /RUGGLE1 ! IMPORTANT MATT]S ?AT ,CAN5]O HAS ALWAYS BE5 FOND ( EMPHASIZ+4 ,BUT SO MANY O!R QUE/IONS REMA9 OP51 QUE/IONS ?AT NE$ TO BE RAIS$ SOON] OR LAT]4 ,AN EXAMPLE = ALL3 ! POLICE KNOCK AT \R DOOR ) AN >RE/ W>RANT4 ,9 ! SITUATION :]E WE MANAGE TO GIVE !M ! SLIP1 :AT DO WE DO8 ,TAKE C>E1 ?IS IS A S]I\S PROBLEM BECAUSE =C$ CL&E/9ITY %\LD NOT CAUSE ! 9T]RUPTION ( \R PROJECTS4 ,WE %\LD MAKE \RSELVES CAPABLE ( FAC+ ! NEW SITUATION 9 A WAY ?AT MAKES IT POSSIBLE = US TO /ILL ATTACK ! RUL+ ORD]1 & TO CONT9UE TO LIVE FULLY & ) PASSION 9 ALL ! SPACES ?AT1 DESPITE EV]Y?+1 WE >E ABLE TO CONQU]4 ,TO DO ?IS1 CLE> IDEAS & USABLE TOOLS W\LD BE ( S]VICE TO US -- BE=E ! >RE/ W>RANTS -- TO MAKES SURE ?AT \R LIFE IS NOT R$UC$ TO FLIE ALSO ! NEW WAY = ORGANIZ+ ) RESPECT TO ! NEW SITUATION1 ! NEW WAY ( COMMUNICAT+ ) /RUGGLES 9 C\RSE & ) COMRADES :O >E NOT BE+ PURSU$4 ,EV]Y?+ ) ! SAME P]SPECTIVE ( ! COMPLETE OV]TURN+ ( LIFE1 SACRIFICE & ! EXI/5T ?AT ANIMAT$ US BE=E WE HAD TO GO ON ! LAM4 ,& :AT AB\T ?IS1 :AT C\LD IT EV] HAVE TO DO ) A SPECIFIC COMBATANT ORGANIZATION -- EV5 ONE ?AT IS HORIZONTAL1 BUT /ILL HAS ACRONYMS1 PROGRAMS & ! LIMITS ?AT FOLL[ FROM ?IS8 ,9 ANY CASE1 WE W]E WRONG4 ,! DEBATE HAD A H>D TIME GETT+ (F ! GR\ND & ONLY ONE CONTRIBUTION TO ! DISCUSSION HAS REA*$ US UP TO N[ .<444.>4 ,ALL ! RE/ HAVE BE5 COLLECTIVE COMMUNIQUES & ! TAK+ ( /&S .<444.> ?AT DON'T DEAL ) ! TOPICS 9 QUE/ION ) SUFFICI5T DEP?4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 IT SEEMS TO US ?AT !Y REVEAL1 AT LEA/ P>TIALLY1 SOME COMMON FLAWS & PU% US TO CONSID] A FEW ?+S4 ,! FIR/ IS ?AT IT IS NECESS>Y TO KN[ H[ TO READ4 ,BY ?IS WE MEAN ?AT IF SOMEONE WRITES ?AT ! SPECIFIC >M$ ORGANIZATION1 EV5 :5 IT DECL>ES ITSELF AN>*I/1 IS A /RUCTURE ?AT WE CONSID] \R 5EMY -- AS WE WROTE 9 ! LA/ ISSUE -- BECAUSE IT PROSPECTS UTT]LY OPPOS$ TO ?OSE WE HOPE =1 ONE %\LD NOT READ ?AT ?OSE :O PROPOSE IT OR PRACTICE IT >E \R 5EMIES4 ,IF WE W]E TO /ATE ?AT ! AN>*O-SYNDICALI/ P]SPECTIVE1 = EXAMPLE1 IS NOT JU/ EXTRANE\S1 BUT ALSO HO/ILE1 TO US1 WE >E C]TA9 ?AT NO ONE W\LD MISUND]/& \R WORDS4 ,NO ONE W\LD ?9K ?AT WE 9T5D$ TO WAIT \TSIDE ! H\SES ( COMRADES :O %>E ?IS P]SPECTIVE 9 ORD] TO DO !M 91 OR ?AT WE W\LD REFUSE TO GIVE \R SOLID>ITY IF !Y W]E /RUCK BY REPRESSION4 ,! ?+ ?AT T\*ES US IS ?AT 9 !IR VISION !RE IS A PLACE READY = US AS WELL1 ?AT WE1 H[EV]1 DO NOT WANT TO OCCUPY4 ,& \R CRITIQUE ORIG9ATES FROM !IR PROJECT ( 5CLOS+ US 9 ?AT PLACE & \R FIRM 9T5TION NOT TO BE 5CLOS$4 ,& !SE TWO P]SPECTIVES1 \RS & !IRS1 HAVE EV]Y?+ TO GA9 FROM A MUTUAL1 CON/ANT & HEAT$ CRITIQUE1 EV5 H>% :5 NECESS>Y4 ,BECAUSE ONLY ?R\< CRITIQUE CAN DI/ANCES WID5 OR BE BRIDG$ & ! ME?OD BE F\ND = MAK+ ! CLA% ( PROJECTS ?AT >E SO DIFF]5T AS TO BE HO/ILE WOR?:ILE4 ,KN[+ H[ TO READ ALSO MEANS ?AT :5 SOMEONE WRITES ?AT AN EXP]I5CE LIKE ,REVOLUTION>Y ,ACTION 7,>7 CAN BE DESCRIB$ AS AN>*I/ ONLY AT ! CO/ ( A HUGE DI/ORTION1 ONE %\LD NOT READ ?AT !RE W]E NO AN>*I/ 9 ! ,>4 ,!RE W]E MANY AN>*I/S 9 ! ,>1 BUT !RE W]E ALSO MANY O!R RESPECTABLE COMRADES :O1 & ?IS IS NOT \R FAULT1 W]E NOT AN>*I/S4 ,IT IS NOT )\T REASON ?AT WE CONSID] ! DEBATE AB\T ! ,> MORE 9T]E/+ ?AN ?AT AB\T ! ,R$ ,BRIGADES OR O!R COMBATANT P>TIES4 ,& !N -- TO BR+ UP ANO!R FLAW -- IF ! ONE :O PROPOSES C]TA9 P]SPECTIVES HAS ! MIS=TUNE ( BE+ 9 PRISON1 WE C]TA9LY CANNOT PLAY ! ROLE ( ,R$ ,CROSS NURSES1 ACCEPT+ ANY?+ ?AT COMES TO US FROM BEH9D B>S ) A COMPLIANT SMILE OR APPLAUSE EV5 :5 WE CONSID] IT RUBBI%4 ,AS LONG AS WE CONSID] COMRADES 9 PRISON AS POOR ?+S :O WE MU/ ALWAYS CONSID] RIE ALWAYS RI$ YET AGA9 & -- 9 TURN -- ! COMRADES 9 PRISON WILL BE LEFT MORE & MORE ISOLAT$4 ,IT W\LD BE BE/ TO %AKE ! GU]RILLA W> OR POLITICAL MY?S ( M$ALS FROM \R HEADS -- ! MY?S ACCORD+ TO :I* ! MORE TIME ONE HAS BE5 OR HAS TO BE 9 PRISON1 ! MORE REVOLUTION>Y &1 ?US1 ! MORE CORRECT !Y MU/ BE -- & REASON PASSIONATELY ON \R PROBLEMS1 :I* >E ALSO ! PROBLEMS ( ! IMPRISON$ :O HAVE !IR SAY AS WELL4 ,?IS IS :Y ,CAN5]O D$ICATES !SE PAGES TO ?IS TOPIC .<444.> ,F9ALLY1 ONE MORE ?+ %9ES ?R\< 9 SOME ( ! /ATEM5TS ( POSITION3 ! CONC]N ?AT ,CAN5]O %\LD OR WANTS TO BE ! REPRES5TATIVE PAP] ( 0AN >EA04 ,CAN5]O REPRES5TS A SMALL PIECE ( ! LIVES ( ?OSE :O PUBLI% IT4 ,SO DON'T ?9K ILL ( US IF WE DON'T CONSULT ALL 7ALL ( :O8 :I* >EA87 BE=E SAY+ :AT WE ?9K AB\T :AT COMES TO US1 OR IF WE >E NOT SO MANY EXP]TS TO TEA* ! DOCTR9E1 S9CE WE WANT TO HAVE NO?+ TO DO ) DOCTR9ES4 -- ! $ITORS ( ,CAN5]O ,LETT] ON ,SPECIALIZATION 7,NOT PUTT+ ONE'S DE/9Y 9TO PLAY UNLESS ONE IS WILL+ TO PLAY ) ALL ( ONE'S POSSIBILITIES7 ,TODAY ,I ?\ATIONS ?AT ! /ATE & ! ECONOMY 9FLICT ON \R LIVES MU* TOO CLOSELY4 ,TAKE WORK1 = EXAMPLE4 ,! REPRODUCTION ( ! CONDITIONS ( EXI/5CE 7I4E41 ! ACTIVITY ( PUTT+ \T ! EF=T 9 ORD] TO EAT1 SLEEP1 /AY W>M1 ETC47 %\LD BE COMPLETELY ONE ) DISCUSSION1 PLAY1 ! CONT9U\S TRANS=MATION ( ! 5VIRONM5T1 LOV+ RELATION%IPS1 CONFLICT1 9 %ORT ) ! ?\S&S ( EXPRESSIONS ( \R UNIQU5ESS4 ,9/EAD1 WORK HAS NOT ONLY BECOME ! C5T] ( EV]Y CONC]N1 BUT CONFID5T 9 ITS 9DEP5D5CE1 IT ALSO IMPOSES ITS MEASURE ON FREE TIME1 AMUSEM5T1 5C\NT]S & REFLECTION4 ,9 %ORT1 IT IS PRES5T$ AS ! MEASURE ( LIFE ITSELF4 ,9 FACT1 S9CE ?IS IS !IR SOCIAL ID5TITY1 ALMO/ EV]YONE IS DEF9$ 9 T]MS ( ! JOB !Y C>RY \T1 I4E41 9 T]MS ( MIS]Y4 ,I AM REF]R+ P>TICUL>LY TO ! REP]CUSSIONS ?AT ! FRAGM5TATION ?AT P[] IMPOSES ON EV]YONE'S LIVES HAS ON ! !ORY & PRACTICE ( SUBV]SIVES4 ,= EXAMPLE1 TAKE >MS4 ,IT SEEMS OBVI\S TO ME ?AT A REVOLUTION )\T >MS IS IMPOSSIBLE1 BUT IT IS EQUALLY CLE> ?AT >MS >E NOT 5\<4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 ,I BELIEVE ?AT ! MORE REVOLUTION>Y A *ANGE IS1 ! LESS >M$ CONFLICT IS ITS MEASURE4 ,! BROAD]1 MORE CONSCI\S & MORE JOY\S ! TRANS=MATION IS1 ! GREAT] IS ! CONDITION ( NO RETURN ?AT IS CREAT$ 9 RELATION%IP TO ! PA/4 ,IF SUBV]SION IS C>RI$ 9TO EV]Y SPH]E ( EXI/5CE1 ! >M$ DEF5SE ( ONE'S POSSIBILITY = DE/ROY+ BECOMES COMPLETELY ONE ) ! CREATION ( NEW RELATION%IPS & NEW 5VIRONM5TS4 ,!N1 EV]YONE W\LD BE >M$4 ,O!RWISE1 SPECIALI/S COME 9TO BE+ -- FUTURE BOSSES & BUREAUCRATS -- :O 0DEF5D0 :ILE EV]YONE ELSE DEMOLI%ES & REBUILDS444 !IR [N SLAV]Y4 ,?IS IS ESPECIALLY IMPORTANT BECAUSE IT IS NOT 0MILIT>Y0 DEFEATS ?AT SET (F ! DECL9E & ! CONSEQU5T TRIUMPH ( ! OLD WORLD1 BUT RA!R ! DY+ AWAY ( AUTONOM\S ACTION & 5?USIASM ?AT >E SMO!R$ BY ! LIE ( ! 0H>% NECESSITIES ( ! TRANSITION0 7SACRIFICE BE=E HAPP9ESS 9 COMMUNISM1 OB$I5CE TO P[] BE=E FRE$OM 9 AN>*Y74 ,& HI/ORICALLY1 ! MO/ BRUTAL REPRESSION IS ALWAYS PLAY$ \T PRECISELY 9 ?IS DECL9E1 NEV] 9 ! MOM5T ( WIDESPREAD & UNCONTA9ABLE 9SURRECTION4 ,P>ADOXICALLY1 AN>*I/S %\LD PU%1 >M 9 H&1 SO ?AT >MS >E NE$$ AS LITTLE AS POSSIBLE & SO ?AT !Y >E NEV] SEP>AT$ FROM ! TOTALITY ( REVOLT4 ,!N ,I ASK MYSELF :AT 0>M$ /RUGGLE0 C\LD EV] MEAN4 ,I UND]/& IT :5 A L59I/ IS SPEAK+ AB\T IT1 S9CE HE POSSESSES NO?+ ( REVOLUTION EXCEPT ! MIS]Y HE SETS UP -- ! C\P D'ETAT1 ! TAK+ ( ! ,W9T] ,PALACE4 ,BUT = AN ANTI-AU?ORIT>IAN8 ,P]HAPS1 9 ! FACE ( ! G5]AL REFUSAL TO ATTACK ! /ATE & CAPITAL1 IT C\LD HAVE ! SIGNIFICANCE ( EMPHASIZ+ ! 9(F5SIV5ESS ( EV]Y P>TIAL OPPOSITION & ! ILLUSOR9ESS ( A LIB]ATION ?AT TRIES TO ABOLI% ! RUL+ ORD] SIMPLY BY 0DELEGITIMAT+ IT01 OR SELF-MANAG+ ONE'S ELSE:]E4 ,IT C\LD BE4 ,BUT IF !RE IS ANY?+ P>TIAL1 IT IS PRECISELY ! GU]RILLA MY?OLOGY1 ) ITS 5TIRE /OCK ( SLOGANS1 IDEOLOGIES & HI]>*ICAL SEP>ATIONS4 ,SO ONE IS H>MLESS TO P[]1 :5 ONE ACCEPTS GO+ D[N ! PA?S KN[N TO IT &1 ?US1 HELPS TO IMP$E ALL ?OSE IT DOES NOT KN[4 ,AS TO ILLUSIONS1 :AT ELSE CAN ONE CALL ! !SIS ACCORD+ TO :I* DAILY LIFE -- ) ITS ROLES1 DUTIES & PASSIVITY -- IS CRITICIZ$ ?R\< >M$ ORGANIZATION4 ,I ABSOLUTELY RECALL ! !SIS3 ! 5DEAVOR WAS TO SUPPLY A LIB]T>IAN & NON-VANGU>DI/ ALT]NATIVE TO ! /AL9I/ COMBATANT ORGANIZATIONS4 ,! RESULTS W]E ALREADY WRITT5 9 ! ME?ODS4 ,AS IF TO ATTACK ! /ATE & CAPITAL1 !RE W\LD BE NE$ = ACRONYMS1 BOR+ CLAIMS1 UNREADABLE COMMUNIQUES & ALL ! RE/4 ,& /ILL WE HE> TALK ( 0,>M$ ,/RUGGLE0 & 0COMBATANT0 ORGANIZATIONS4 ,REMEMB]+ -- 9 ! MID/ ( SO MU* SELF-9T]E/$ AMNESIA -- ?AT >MS ALSO MAKE UP A P>T ( ! /RUGGLE CAN ONLY BE POSITIVE4 ,BUT :AT DOES ?IS MEAN8 ,?AT WE %\LD NO LONG] PUBLI% J\RNALS1 HAVE DEBATES1 PUBLICLY CALL = ! ELIM9ATION ( ! POPE1 ?R[ EGGS AT JUDGES OR YOGURT AT J\RNALI/S1 LOOT DUR+ M>*ES1 OCCUPY SPACES OR BLOCKADE ! $ITORIAL (FICE ( :ATEV] NEWSPAP]8 ,OR DOES IT MEAN -- EXACTLY AS SOME MAGI/RATES DREAM -- ?AT ?IS 0LEVEL0 %\LD BE LEFT TO SOME SO ?AT O!RS CAN BECOME SPECIALI/S ( ! 0ATTACK08 ,FUR!RMORE1 ) ! 9T5TION ( SP>+ ! USELESS 9VOLVEM5T ( ! 5TIRE MOVEM5T = ! ACTIONS ( A FEW1 AS IF IT W]E NOT SEP>ATIONS ?AT HAVE ALWAYS PREP>$ ! BE/ T]RA9 = REPRESSION4 ,IT W\LD BE NECESS>Y TO FREE ! PRACTICES ( ATTACK FROM ANY 0COMBATANT0 PHRASEOLOGY1 9 ORD] TO CAUSE !M TO BECOME ! REAL MEET+ ( ALL REVOLTS4 ,?IS IS ! BE/ WAY TO PREV5T !M FROM FALL+ 9TO A RUT4 ,SO MU* ! MORE SO1 S9CE ! EXPLOIT$ !MSELVES SOMETIMES MOVE TO ! ATTACK )\T WAIT+ = 9/RUCTION FROM ANY ORGANIZATION :ATSOEV]4 ,DISSATISFACTION >MS ITSELF AGA9/ ! T]RORI/ SPECTACLE ( P[]1 SOMETIMES FE$+ ! SPECTACLE4 ,& AN>*I/S %\LD NOT BE ! ONE'S TO DIS>M IT4 ,9 ORD] TO HIDE EV]Y SIGN ( DISSATISFACTION1 9 ORD] TO %[ ?AT NO ONE -- EXCEPT ! LATE/ 0T]RORI/S0 -- REBELS AGA9/ DEMOCRACY1 ! /ATE TRIES TO 9V5T A CL&E/9E AN>*I/ ORGANIZATION TO :I* IT ATTRIBUTES ?\S&S ( EXPRESSIONS ( REVOLT -- A REVOLT ?AT GOES BEYOND ANY GANG1 >M$ OR NOT -- 9 ORD] TO NEGATE !M4 ,?IS WAY1 IT MANAGES SIL5CE & SOCIAL CONS5SUS4 ,PRECISELY BECAUSE ! MA/]S W\LD LIKE TO 5CLOSE \R ACTIVITIES 9TO A MILIT>Y /RUCTURE1 DIVID+ !M 9TO DIFF]5T 0LEVELS01 IT IS NECESS>Y = US TO EXP& & UNITE !M AS MU* AS POSSIBLE 9TO A REVOLUTION>Y PROJECT ?AT SURPASSES ! >M$ MY?OLOGY ?R\< EXCESS4 ,EA* ONE ) H] [N APTITUDES & DESIRES4 ,& MORE ?AN ?IS1 C>RY+ SUBV]SION 9TO EV]Y SPH]E ( EXI/5CE4 ,! >M ?AT CONTA9S ALL >MS IS ! WILL TO LIVE ) ALL ONE'S POSSIBILITIES1 IMM$IATELY4 ,& :AT ( ! !SIS ACCORD+ TO :I* IT IS NECESS>Y TO TAKE ONE'S RESPONSIBILITY 9 ! FACE ( P[] BY CLAIM+ ONE'S ACTIONS8 ,IT SEEMS CLE> TO ME ?AT ACRONYMS READY = /ICK+ ON 9CONV5I5T 9DIVIDUALS MAKE ! POLICE HAPPY4 ,SO IF RESPONSIBILITY IS NOT TO BE A LIE OR A PRETEXT = CONTROL1 IT MU/ BE 9DIVIDUAL4 ,EA* P]SON IS RESPONSIBLE TO H]SELF 9 H] ACTIONS4 ,! MUTUAL RECOGNITION ( RESPONSIBILITY ONLY HAPP5S ON A PLANE ( MUTUALITY4 ,!RE=E1 !RE IS NO RESPONSIBILITY 9 ! FACE ( ?OSE :O1 BY EXPLOIT+1 PLACE !MSELVES AGA9/ ALL MUTUALITY4 ,9 ! FACE ( AU?ORITY1 !RE IS NO T]RA9 -- POLITICAL OR MILIT>Y CONFLICT -- ( COMMON RECOGNITION1 BUT ONLY HO/ILITY4 ,:AT DOES IT MEAN1 !N1 TO TAKE ONE'S RESPONSIBILITY 9 ! FACE ( P[]8 ,C\LD IT MAYBE MEAN -- 9 P]FECT L59I/ OBS]VANCE -- BE+ RECOGNIZ$ BY IT AS AN ORGANIZATION8 ,H]E RESPONSIBILITY 5DS & ITS COLLECTIVE SUB/ITUTE1 ! SPECTACLE ( SOCIAL W>1 BEG9S4 ,! LEFTI/ DEMOCRAT1 RESPECTFUL ( ! LAW1 IS ! FIR/ ONE TO BECOME 9FATUAT$ ) GU]RILLA ICONOGRAPHY 7ESPECIALLY :5 IT IS EXOTIC7 & ONCE ! GU]RILLA HAS LAID D[N HIS >MS1 HE IS ! FIR/ ONE TO RETURN1 GRADUALLY FROM ! LEFT1 TO LAW & DEMOCRACY4 ,FROM ?IS PO9T ( VIEW1 ! ONE :O DECL>ES ! 9SURRECTIONAL P]SPECTIVE CLOS$ 9 ITS 5TIRE RANGE1 ADH]+ MORE OR LESS DIRECTLY TO RE=MISM1 HELPS TO RE9=CE ! FALSE NE$ = COMBATANT ORGANIZATIONS -- REV]S$ PROJECTIONS ( POLITICAL IMPOT5CE4 ,LEFTI/ MILITANTS >E EV5 ABLE TO USE SUBCOMM&ANTE ,M>COS TO LEGITIMATE !IR ROLE AGA9/ RIT1 ! SUBCOMM&ANTE HOPES = NO?+ MORE ?AN TO BE ABLE TO ACT DEMOCRATICALLY = HIS FA!RL&4 ,LEAV+ BEH9D ! MORE OR LESS MOD]NIZ$ L59I/S1 WE COME TO ! SPH]E ( AN>*I/S4 ,EV5 H]E1 AMONG ! SPECIALI/S ( DEBATE1 MANY CLASP$ ! 0,*IAPAS 9SURG5TS0 TO !IR HE>TS1 PROVID$ ?AT 9SURRECTION -- ?IS 9FANTILE DISORD] ( AN>*ISM -- IS NEV] TALK$ AB\T FROM \R SIDE444 ,& AS LONG AS ONE TAKES ! DUE DI/ANCE FROM ?OSE :O CONT9UE TO TALK AB\T IT4 ,ONCE AT ! V]Y 5D ( A MEET+ ON SELF-MANAG$ SPACES1 A FRI5D ( M9E TOLD ME ?AT 9 ! #a#i#gS !RE WAS ! FIRM BELIEF ?AT ANYONE :O US$ A GUN1 = ?IS REASON ALONE1 WAS RIREL TO ?OSE :O OCCUPY SPACES4 ,9T]*ANGEABLE SPECIALIZATIONS4 ,9 ITSELF1 OCCUPY+ SPACES IS AN IMPORTANT ME?OD ( /RUGGLE1 :I* CONTA9S ! V]Y POSSIBILITY ( ALL SUBV]SION 9 A NUT%ELL3 ! DET]M9ATION TO REA* \T A H& & TAKE ONE'S SPACE4 ,?IS CLE>LY DOESN'T MEAN ?AT SU* A ME?OD1 BY ITSELF1 C\LD PUT AN 5D TO ! WORLD ( CON/RA9TS & COMMODITIES4 ,AS ALWAYS1 ! IDEAS & DESIRES ( ?OSE :O APPLY IT MAKE ! DIFF]5CE4 ,IF ANYONE 9 ! OCCUPI$ SPACES SEEKS ! GU>ANTEE ( SURVIVAL 9 A SLAPDA% WAY1 %E WILL F9D IT !RE1 JU/ AS -- BY PUTT+ ! OCCUPATION ITSELF 9TO PLAY -- %E C\LD F9D ! PO9T ( DEP>TURE = HIS MO/ B\NDLESS DEM&S !RE4 ,! SAME GOES = BOOKS1 EXPLOSIVES OR LOVE AFFAIRS4 ,! MO/ IMPORTANT ?+ IS NOT TO PLACE LIMITS -- 9 ONE DIRECTION OR ! O!R -- BORR[$ FROM ! RUL+ CRIT]IA 7LAW1 ! NUMB]1 ! =TUNE ( SUCCESS74 ,P]SONALLY1 ,I DON'T KN[ 0! 9SURRECTIONALI/S02 ,I ONLY KN[ 9DIVIDUALS :O SUPPORT ! NECESSITY ( 9SURRECTION1 EA* ) HIS [N REASONS OR ME?ODS4 ,A NECESSITY1 AS ONE ( \R FRI5DS SAID1 DET]M9$ BY ! FACT ?AT )9 ! PRES5T SOCIETY IT IS ONLY POSSIBLE TO PROPOSE DIFF]5T WAYS ( RESPOND+ TO ! EXI/+ QUE/IONS 7P]HAPS ) DIRECT DEMOCRACY1 CITIZ5S' COMMITTEES1 ETC471 :]EAS ) 9SURRECTION ! QUE/IONS !MSELVES *ANGE4 ,& IF WE REFUSE ALL SPECIALIZATION1 :Y DESCRIBE \RSELVES AS 0SQUATT]S08 ,:Y DESCRIBE \RSELVES ?R\< ONE PRACTICE ALONE8 ,IS IT MAYBE BECAUSE WE CAN SPEAK PUBLICLY ( ?IS PRACTICE1 BECAUSE IT CAN SPREAD FUR!R ?AN O!RS & BECAUSE IT IMPLIES A COLLECTIVE DIM5SION8 ,POOR CRIT]IA1 9 MY OP9ION4 ,ONE CAN ALSO SPEAK PUBLICLY ( SABOTAGE1 AS LONG AS !RE ISN'T ANY NE$ TO SAY1 0,I DID ?IS0 OR 0?AT GUY DID ! O!R ?+01 9 ORD] TO DISCUSS A QUE/ION4 ,SEV]AL PEOPLE C\LD ALSO C>RY \T AN ACT ( SABOTAGE TOGE!R1 BUT IF ONLY ONE P]SON W]E TO PUT IT 9TO PRACTICE1 ?IS W\LD NOT MAKE ! ACTION LOSE ITS MEAN+4 ,IT SEEMS TO ME ?AT ! QUE/ION ( ! CAPACITY = SPREAD+ 9 ITSELF %\LD BE A REASON = REFLECTION1 C]TA9LY NOT A UNIT ( MEASURE4 ,IF SOMEONE :O LOVES BREAK+ ! W9D[S ( BANKS OR %OPP+ C5T]S W]E TO SAY TO Y\1 0,HI1 ,I AM A V&AL10 IT W\LD MAKE Y\ LAU<4 ,IT W\LD BE EQUALLY RIDICUL\S IF A SUBV]SIVE DESCRIB$ HIMSELF AS A 0WRIT]0 BECAUSE HE DOESN'T DISDA9 PUBLI%+ SOME BOOK OR >TICLE4 ,I HAVE NEV] HE>D ANY AN>*I/ PRES5T H]SELF AS A 0SABOTEUR04 ,IF ,I EV] HE>D ?IS1 ,I W\LD ?9K ,I WAS MEET+ A CRET94 ,FUR!RMORE1 :O HAS EV] CRITIQU$ OCCUPATION AS SU*8 ,:O HAS EV] SAID ?AT DYNAMITE IS 0MORE REVOLUTION>Y0 ?AN CR[B>S8 ,MAK+ ! /RUGGLE 9 ALL ITS =M 9TO AN 9DIVISIBLE TOTALITY -- ?IS IS ! PO9T4 ,I W\LD SAY ?IS NOT ( ! /RUGGLE1 BUT ( MY LIFE4 ,)\T 0PROPAG&A0 & 0! >MS ( CRITIQUE01 0>M$ /RUGGLE0 & 0! CRITIQUE ( >MS01 0DAILY LIFE0 & 0REVOLUTION01 09DIVIDUAL0 & 0ORGANIZATION01 0SELF-MANAGEM5T0 & 0DIRECT ACTION01 & AWAY ) PIGEONHOL+4 ,BUT )\T SPECIFIC PROPOSALS 7LABOR /RUGGLE1 ! OCCUPATION ( SPACES OR SOME?+ ELSE71 H[ DO Y\ CREATE A BROAD] 9VOLVEM5T8 ,PROPOSALS >E POSSIBLE1 EV5 ?\< IT IS NECESS>Y TO AGREE ON :AT & ) :OM4 ,BUT SU* PROPOSALS >E EI!R 9/ANCES ( A !ORETICAL CRITIQUE & A GLOBAL PRACTICE1 OR !Y >E444 ACCEPT$ PROPOSALS4 ,NONE!LESS1 NOT EV]Y?+ IS TO BE DE/ROY$4 ,! POSSIBILITY ( DE/RUCTION MU/ NOT BE DE/ROY$4 ,?IS IS NOT WORDPLAY4 ,DE/RUCTION IS ?\T ( ! OCCASION1 EV]Y?+ IS A WEAPON = ! MAN :OSE WILL IS NOT DIS>M$40 ,I SAY AGA93 EV]Y?+ TOGE!R OR NO?+4 ,:5 ONE CLAIMS TO SUBV]T ! WORLD ONLY ) DISCUSSION1 OR OCCUPATIONS1 OR BOOKS1 OR >MS1 ONE 5DS UP TRY+ TO DIRECT ASSEMBLIES1 OCCUPY+ HOVELS1 WRIT+ BADLY & %OOT+ WORSE4 ,! FACT IS ?AT BY REPEAT+ !SE BANALITIES ?AT %\LD BE ! F\NDATION = />T+ TO TRULY DISCUSS1 ONE BECOMES BOR+ LIKE ! SPECIALI/S ( REPETITION4 ,! WORN-\T DIALOGUES *ANGE BY *ANG+ ! SITUATION4 ,MASSIMO ,PASSAMANI ,AN ,ADV5TURE ,)\T ,REGRETS ,DE> READ]S1 ,:AT Y\ HAVE 9 Y\R H&S IS ! LA/ ISSUE ( ,CAN5]O4 ,V>I\S REASONS HAVE MOV$ US TO DECIDE TO BR+ IT TO A CLOSE4 ,!Y ALL REF] BACK TO :AT WE SAID 9 ! $ITORIAL ( _?#c#c1 ! FIR/ 9 ! NEW S]IES3 0,CAN5]O IS A WAG] ?AT ONLY HAS MEAN+ IF !RE IS SOMEONE WILL+ TO PLAY40 ,& SO N[1 ?OSE :O HAVE BE5 WILL+ TO GAMBLE ON ?IS /AKE >E NO LONG] SO4 ,WE >E NO LONG] AVAILABLE TO DO ,CAN5]O BECAUSE ITS PUBLICATION HAS COME TO TAKE UP TOO MU* ( ! TIME ( \R LIVES1 PREV5T+ US NOT ONLY FROM C>RY+ \T O!R PROJECTS ?AT >E CLOSE TO \R HE>TS1 BUT ALSO FROM BE+ ABLE TO FULLY UTILIZE ! V]Y 9/RUM5T TO :I* WE GAVE LIFE4 ,IF AN AN>*I/ WEEKLY DOESN'T WANT TO HAVE ! AIM ( M]ELY BE+ AN ACC\NT1 IT MU/ NECESS>ILY BE US$1 & P>ADOXICALLY ?OSE :O MADE ?IS ONE DIDN'T HAVE ! OPPORTUNITY TO USE IT AS WE W\LD HAVE LIK$4 ,BESIDES ! LIMIT$ L5G? = >TICLES 9 A WEEKLY CONCEIV$ LIKE ?IS 7! FAM\S PAGE & A HALF7 V]Y (T5 AT MO/ ALL[$ US TO \TL9E C]TA9 DISCUSSIONS1 TO !N LEAVE !M UNRESOLV$4 ,S9CE IT IS UN?9KABLE ?AT ! SUBSEQU5T DEEP5+ ( ! DISCUSSION C\LD HAPP5 9 A WEEKLY ( ?IS SORT1 IT C\LD ONLY HAVE BE5 BR\TICUL>LY 9 TIMES LIKE !SE1 A WEEKLY MANAGES IS ABLE TO /IMULATE REFLECTION & WOR?:ILE DEBATE ONLY ) GREAT DIFFICULTY4 ,9CR$IBLY1 PRECISELY DUE TO IRS DECISION TO PUT \T QUE/IONS TO BE CONFRONT$1 ,CAN5]O HAS 5D$ UP BECOM+ AN OBJECT ( DEBATE ITSELF1 & NOT ONE ( ?OSE 9VOLV$ 9 DEBATE4 ,TO SPEAK CLE>LY1 A WEEKLY IS ALIVE :5 IT IS ABLE TO 9VOLVE AS MANY 9DIVIDUALS AS POSSIBLE1 I4E41 :5 ! IDEAS EXPRESS$ >E ABLE TO TRIGG] *A9 REACTIONS1 EV5 VIOL5T ONES IF Y\ WILL1 PROVID$ ?AT !Y OCCUR 9 CONDITIONS ( MUTUALITY4 ,O!RWISE1 ! PAP] FALLS BACK ON ITSELF & ! ONLY ?+ LEFT IS = IT TO DIE1 IF IT DOESN'T WANT TO SURVIVE AS A PA!TIC MONUM5T TO ! IDEA4 ,& SO1 ?IS CONFRONTATION IS LACK+4 ,?OSE :O DIDN'T AGREE ) \R IDEAS DIDN'T CONTRIBUTE1 ONLY BE+ ABLE TO S5D LETT]S ( 9SULTS & ACCUSATION1 LACK+ ! LEA/ BIT ( >GUM5TATION4 ,& ?OSE :O %>$ \R IDEAS -- EV5 IF ONLY P>TIALLY -- DIDN'T CONTRIBUTE4 ,WORSE YET1 WE REALIZ$ ?AT A REPRES5TATIVE TASK HAD BE5 5TRU/$ TO ! WEEKLY3 BE+ ! VOICE ( ?OSE :O HAVE NONE4 ,& ! ONLY DISCUSSIONS ?AT ,CAN5]O SEEMS TO HAVE BE5 ABLE TO RAISE >E ?OSE RELAT+ TO ITS ABILITY OR LACK !RE( TO P]=M A TASK ?AT NONE ( US EV] DESIR$4 ,9 ?IS REG>D1 ! POSITION-TAK+ ?AT APPE>$ 9 ! LA/ ISSUE1 9 ITS 0/ODGY SUPPLEM5T01 >E AN 9DICATIVE EXAMPLE4 ,A BROAD1 9T]E/+ DEBATE CAPABLE ( EXPRESS+ MANY IMAG9ABLE FACETS & NUANCES WAS NOT BORN FROM ! CLA% ( TWO DIFF]5T P]SPECTIVES4 ,ALL ?AT WAS BORN WAS A DI/RESS+ S]IES ( DECL>ATIONS = OR AGA9/4 ,BUT = OR AGA9/ :AT1 & :Y8 ,SIL5CE4 ,EV]YONE KEEPS QUIET4 ,A SIL5CE ?AT RECONFIRMS \R D\BTS AB\T ! CURR5T VALIDITY ( ,CAN5]O1 & ONLY 9CREASES ! NE$ TO AB&ON AN ANALYTICAL TOOL LIKE A WEEKLY ?AT MAYBE DUE TO ITS OV]LY N>R[ TIME S*$ULE DOES NOT ALL[ A BETT] SETTL+ ( ! IDEAS CONTA9$ 9 IT1 LIMIT+ ITSELF 9EVITABLY TO PIL+ UP PROBLEMS & QUE/IONS ?AT /ILL REMA9 OP54 ,& = ALL ( !SE REASONS1 WE HAVE DECID$ TO PUT AN 5D TO ,CAN5]O4 ,)\T REGRETS4 ,! $ITORS .<#a.> ,V5OM\S ,BUTT]FLY ,PUBLICATIONS HAS PUBLI%$ A PAMPHLET ( MAT]IAL DEAL+ SPECIFICALLY ) ?IS 9VE/IGATION & TRIAL CALL$ SIMPLY ,! ,M>9I ,TRIAL4 .<#b.> ,ALSO CALL$ ,IL ,MANIFE/O4 -- TRANSLATOR4 .<#c.> 0HIS [N K9D ( AN>*I/04 -- TRANSLATOR4 .<#d.> REFUSAL TO P>TICIPATE 9 ! ELECTORAL PROCESS4 -- TRANSLATOR4 ,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,NOVEMB] #c1 #aiic 3 ,>TICLES FROM 0,CAN5]O0 -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,APRIL #a#f1 #bb 3 ,>TICLES FROM 0,CAN5]O0 -- ,ADD$4 ,JANU>Y #c1 #bbb 3 ,>TICLES FROM 0,CAN5]O0 -- ,UPDAT$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/