,P>T #b1 ,*APT] #b 
,! ,[N] 

#ahddahdd 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,MAX ,/IRN] 

,TEXT 3 

,! ,[N] 

,I - DO ,I COME TO MYSELF & M9E ?R\< LIB]ALISM8 ,:OM DOES ! LIB]AL LOOK UPON AS HIS EQUAL8 ,MAN6 ,BE ONLY MAN - & ?AT Y\ >E ANYWAY - & ! LIB]AL CALLS Y\ HIS BRO!R4 ,HE ASKS V]Y LITTLE AB\T Y\R PRIVATE OP9IONS & PRIVATE FOLLIES1 IF ONLY HE CAN ESPY 0,MAN0 9 Y\4 

,BUT1 AS HE TAKES LITTLE HE$ ( :AT Y\ >E PRIVATIM - 9DE$1 9 A /RICT FOLL[+ \T ( HIS PR9CIPLE SETS NO VALUE AT ALL ON IT - HE SEES 9 Y\ ONLY :AT Y\ >E G5]ATIM4 ,9 O!R WORDS1 HE SEES 9 Y\1 NOT Y\1 BUT ! SPECIES2 NOT ,TOM OR ,JIM1 BUT ,MAN2 NOT ! REAL OR UNIQUE ONE1 BUT Y\R ESS5CE OR Y\R CONCEPT2 NOT ! BODILY MAN1 BUT ! SPIRIT4 

,AS ,HANS Y\ W\LD NOT BE HIS EQUAL1 BECAUSE HE IS ,KUNZ1 !RE=E NOT ,HANS2 AS MAN Y\ >E ! SAME ?AT HE IS4 ,&1 S9CE AS ,HANS Y\ VIRTUALLY DO NOT EXI/ AT ALL = HIM 7SO F>1 NAMELY1 AS HE IS A LIB]AL & NOT UNCONSCI\SLY AN EGOI/71 HE HAS REALLY MADE 0BRO!R-LOVE0 V]Y EASY = HIMSELF3 HE LOVES 9 Y\ NOT ,HANS1 ( :OM HE KN[S NO?+ & WANTS TO KN[ NO?+1 BUT ,MAN4 

,TO SEE 9 Y\ & ME NO?+ FUR!R ?AN 0M510 ?AT IS RUNN+ ! ,*RI/IAN WAY ( LOOK+ AT ?+S1 ACCORD+ TO :I* ONE IS = ! O!R NO?+ BUT A CONCEPT 7A MAN CALL$ TO SALVATION1 = 9/ANCE71 9TO ! GR\ND4 

,*RI/IANITY PROP]LY SO CALL$ GA!RS US UND] A LESS UTT]LY G5]AL CONCEPT3 !RE WE >E 0SONS ( ,GOD0 & 0L$ BY ! ,SPIRIT ( ,GOD40 ,YET NOT ALL CAN BOA/ ( BE+ ,GOD'S SONS1 BUT 0! SAME ,SPIRIT :I* WITNESSES TO \R SPIRIT ?AT WE >E SONS ( ,GOD REVEALS ALSO :O >E ! SONS ( ! DEVIL40 ,CONSEQU5TLY1 TO BE A SON ( ,GOD ONE MU/ NOT BE A SON ( ! DEVIL2 ! SON%IP ( ,GOD EXCLUD$ C]TA9 M54 ,TO BE SONS ( M5 - ?AT IS1 M5 - ON ! CONTR>Y1 WE NE$ NO?+ BUT TO BELONG TO ! HUMAN SPECIES1 NE$ ONLY TO BE SPECIM5S ( ! SAME SPECIES4 ,:AT ,I AM AS ?IS ,I IS NO CONC]N ( Y\RS AS A GOOD LIB]AL1 BUT IS MY PRIVATE AFFAIR ALONE2 5\< ?AT WE >E BO? SONS ( ONE & ! SAME MO!R1 NAMELY1 ! HUMAN SPECIES3 AS 0A SON ( MAN0 ,I AM Y\R EQUAL4 

,:AT AM ,I N[ TO Y\8 ,P]HAPS ?IS BODILY ,I AS ,I WALK & /&8 ,ANY?+ BUT ?AT4 ,?IS BODILY ,I1 ) ITS ?\<TS1 DECISIONS1 & PASSIONS1 IS 9 Y\R EYES A 0PRIVATE AFFAIR0 :I* IS NO CONC]N ( Y\RS3 IT IS AN 0AFFAIR BY ITSELF40 ,AS AN 0AFFAIR = Y\0 !RE EXI/S ONLY MY CONCEPT1 MY G5]IC CONCEPT1 ONLY ! ,MAN1 :O1 AS HE IS CALL$ ,HANS1 C\LD JU/ AS WELL BE ,PET] OR ,MI*EL4 ,Y\ SEE 9 ME NOT ME1 ! BODILY MAN1 BUT AN UNREAL ?+1 ! SPOOK1 A ,MAN4 

,9 ! C\RSE ( ! ,*RI/IAN C5TURIES WE DECL>$ ! MO/ V>I\S P]SONS TO BE 0\R EQUALS10 BUT EA* TIME 9 ! MEASURE ( ?AT SPIRIT :I* WE EXPECT$ FROM !M - EA* ONE 9 :OM ! SPIRIT ( ! NE$ ( R$EMPTION MAY BE ASSUM$1 !N LAT] EA* ONE :O HAS ! SPIRIT ( 9TEGRITY1 F9ALLY EA* ONE :O %[S A HUMAN SPIRIT & A HUMAN FACE4 ,?US ! FUNDAM5TAL PR9CIPLE ( 0EQUALITY0 V>I$4 

,EQUALITY BE+ N[ CONCEIV$ AS EQUALITY ( ! HUMAN SPIRIT1 !RE HAS C]TA9LY BE5 DISCOV]$ AN EQUALITY ?AT 9CLUDES ALL M52 = :O C\LD D5Y ?AT WE M5 HAVE A HUMAN SPIRIT1 ?AT IS1 NO O!R ?AN A HUMAN6 

,BUT >E WE ON ?AT ACC\NT FUR!R ON N[ ?AN 9 ! BEG9N+ ( ,*RI/IANITY8 ,!N WE W]E TO HAVE A DIV9E SPIRIT1 N[ A HUMAN2 BUT1 IF ! DIV9E DID NOT EXHAU/ US1 H[ %\LD ! HUMAN :OLLY EXPRESS :AT WE >E8 ,FEU]BA* ?9KS1 ?AT IF HE HUMANIZES ! DIV9E1 HE HAS F\ND ! TRU?4 ,NO1 IF ,GOD HAS GIV5 US PA91 0,MAN0 IS CAPABLE ( P9*+ US /ILL MORE TORTUR+LY4 ,! LONG & ! %ORT ( IT IS ?IS3 ?AT WE >E M5 IS ! SLI<TE/ ?+ AB\T US1 & HAS SIGNIFICANCE ONLY 9 SO F> AS IT IS ONE ( \R QUALITIES .<,EIG5S*AFT5.>1 \R PROP]TY .<,EIG5TUM.>4 ,I AM 9DE$ AMONG O!R ?+S A MAN1 AS ,I AM A LIV+ BE+1 !RE=E AN ANIMAL1 OR A ,EUROPEAN1 A ,B]L9]1 & ! LIKE2 BUT HE :O *OSE TO HAVE REG>D = ME ONLY AS A MAN1 OR AS A ,B]L9]1 W\LD PAY ME A REG>D ?AT W\LD BE V]Y UNIMPORTANT TO ME4 ,& :]E=E8 ,BECAUSE HE W\LD HAVE REG>D ONLY = ONE ( MY QUALITIES1 NOT = ME4 

,IT IS JU/ SO ) ! SPIRIT TOO4 ,A ,*RI/IAN SPIRIT1 AN UPRI<T SPIRIT1 & ! LIKE MAY WELL BE MY ACQUIR$ QUALITY1 MY PROP]TY1 BUT ,I AM NOT ?IS SPIRIT3 IT IS M9E1 NOT ,I ITS4 

,H5CE WE HAVE 9 LIB]ALISM ONLY ! CONT9UATION ( ! OLD ,*RI/IAN DEPRECIATION ( ! ,I1 ! BODILY ,TOM4 ,9/EAD ( TAK+ ME AS ,I AM1 ONE LOOKS SOLELY AT MY PROP]TY1 MY QUALITIES1 & 5T]S 9TO M>RIAGE BONDS ) ME ONLY = ! SAKE ( MY - POSSESSIONS2 ONE M>RIES1 AS IT W]E1 :AT ,I HAVE1 NOT :AT ,I AM4 ,! ,*RI/IAN TAKES HOLD ( MY SPIRIT1 ! LIB]AL ( MY HUMANITY4 

,BUT1 IF ! SPIRIT1 :I* IS NOT REG>D$ AS ! PROP]TY ( ! BODILY EGO BUT AS ! PROP] EGO ITSELF1 IS A <O/1 !N ! ,MAN TOO1 :O IS NOT RECOGNIZ$ AS MY QUALITY BUT AS ! PROP] ,I1 IS NO?+ BUT A SPOOK1 A ?\<T1 A CONCEPT4 

,!RE=E ! LIB]AL TOO REVOLVES 9 ! SAME CIRCLE AS ! ,*RI/IAN4 ,BECAUSE ! SPIRIT ( MANK9D1 ,MAN1 DWELLS 9 Y\1 Y\ >E A MAN1 AS :5 ! SPIRIT ( ,*RI/ DWELLS 9 Y\ Y\ >E A ,*RI/IAN2 BUT1 BECAUSE IT DWELLS 9 Y\ ONLY AS A SECOND EGO1 EV5 ?\< IT BE AS Y\R PROP] OR 0BETT]0 EGO1 IT REMA9S O!RWORLDLY TO Y\1 & Y\ HAVE TO /RIVE TO BECOME :OLLY MAN4 ,A /RIV+ JU/ AS FRUITLESS AS ! ,*RI/IAN'S TO BECOME :OLLY A BLESS$ SPIRIT6 

,ONE CAN N[1 AFT] LIB]ALISM HAS PROCLAIM$ ,MAN1 DECL>E OP5LY ?AT H]E) WAS ONLY COMPLET$ ! CONSI/5T C>RY+ \T ( ,*RI/IANITY1 & ?AT 9 TRU? ,*RI/IANITY SET ITSELF NO O!R TASK FROM ! />T ?AN TO REALIZE 0MAN10 ! 0TRUE MAN40 ,H5CE1 !N1 ! ILLUSION ?AT ,*RI/IANITY ASCRIBES AN 9F9ITE VALUE TO ! EGO .<DEM ,I*.> 7AS 9 ! DOCTR9E ( IMMORTALITY1 9 ! CURE ( S\LS1 ETC47 COMES TO LI<T4 ,NO1 IT ASSIGNS ?IS VALUE TO ,MAN .<DEM ,M5S*5.> ALONE4 ,ONLY ,MAN IS IMMORTAL1 & ONLY BECAUSE ,I AM ,MAN AM ,I TOO IMMORTAL4 ,9 FACT1 ,*RI/IANITY HAD TO TEA* ?AT NO ONE IS LO/1 JU/ AS LIB]ALISM TOO PUTS ALL ON AN EQUALITY AS M52 BUT ?AT ET]NITY1 LIKE ?IS EQUALITY1 APPLI$ ONLY TO ! ,MAN 9 ME1 NOT TO ME4 ,ONLY AS ! BE>] & H>BOR] ( ,MAN DO ,I NOT DIE1 AS NOTORI\SLY 0! K+ NEV] DIES40 ,L\IS DIES1 BUT ! K+ REMA9S2 ,I DIE1 BUT MY SPIRIT1 ,MAN1 REMA9S4 ,TO ID5TIFY ME N[ 5TIRELY ) ,MAN ! DEM& HAS BE5 9V5T$1 & /AT$1 ?AT ,I MU/ BECOME A 0REAL G5]IC BE+ .<WIRKLI*ES ,GATTUNGSWES5.>40 

,! HUMAN RELIGION IS ONLY ! LA/ METAMORPHOSIS ( ! ,*RI/IAN RELIGION4 ,= LIB]ALISM IS A RELIGION BECAUSE IT SEP>ATES MY ESS5CE FROM ME & SETS IT ABOVE ME1 BECAUSE IT EXALTS 0,MAN0 TO ! SAME EXT5T AS ANY O!R RELIGION DOES ITS ,GOD OR IDOL1 BECAUSE IT MAKES :AT IS M9E 9TO SOME?+ O!RWORLDLY1 BECAUSE 9 G5]AL IT MAKES \T ( :AT IS M9E1 \T ( MY QUALITIES & MY PROP]TY1 SOME?+ ALI5 - NAMELY1 AN 0ESS5CE02 9 %ORT1 BECAUSE IT SETS ME B5EA? ,MAN1 & !REBY CREATES = ME A 0VOCATION40 ,BUT LIB]ALISM DECL>ES ITSELF A RELIGION 9 =M TOO :5 IT DEM&S = ?IS SUPREME BE+1 ,MAN1 A ZEAL ( FAI?1 0A FAI? ?AT SOME DAY WILL AT LA/ PROVE ITS FI]Y ZEAL TOO1 A ZEAL ?AT WILL BE 9V9CIBLE40 ,BUT1 AS LIB]ALISM IS A HUMAN RELIGION1 ITS PR(ESSOR TAKES A TOL]ANT ATTITUDE T[>D ! PR(ESSOR ( ANY O!R 7,CA?OLIC1 ,JEWI%1 ETC471 AS ,FR$]ICK ! ,GREAT DID T[>D EV]Y ONE :O P]=M$ HIS DUTIES AS A SUBJECT1 :ATEV] FA%ION ( BECOM+ BLESS$ HE MI<T BE 9CL9$ T[>D4 ,?IS RELIGION IS N[ TO BE RAIS$ TO ! RANK ( ! G5]ALLY CU/OM>Y ONE1 & SEP>AT$ FROM ! O!RS AS M]E 0PRIVATE FOLLIES10 T[>D :I*1 BESIDES1 ONE TAKES A HI<LY LIB]AL ATTITUDE ON ACC\NT ( !IR UNESS5TIALNESS4 

,ONE MAY CALL IT ! /ATE-RELIGION1 ! RELIGION ( ! 0FREE /ATE10 NOT 9 ! S5SE HI!RTO CURR5T ?AT IT IS ! ONE FAVOR$ OR PRIVILEG$ BY ! /ATE1 BUT AS ?AT RELIGION :I* ! 0FREE /ATE0 NOT ONLY HAS ! RI<T1 BUT IS COMPELL$1 TO DEM& FROM EA* ( ?OSE :O BELONG TO IT1 LET HIM BE PRIVATIM A ,JEW1 A ,*RI/IAN1 OR ANY?+ ELSE4 ,= IT DOES ! SAME S]VICE TO ! /ATE AS FILIAL PIETY TO ! FAMILY4 ,IF ! FAMILY IS TO BE RECOGNIZ$ & MA9TA9$1 9 ITS EXI/+ CONDITION1 BY EA* ONE ( ?OSE :O BELONG TO IT1 !N TO HIM ! TIE ( BLOOD MU/ BE SACR$1 & HIS FEEL+ = IT MU/ BE ?AT ( PIETY1 ( RESPECT = ! TIES ( BLOOD1 BY :I* EV]Y BLOOD-RELATION BECOMES TO HIM A CONSECRAT$ P]SON4 ,SO ALSO TO EV]Y MEMB] ( ! /ATE-COMMUNITY ?IS COMMUNITY MU/ BE SACR$1 & ! CONCEPT :I* IS ! HI<E/ TO ! /ATE MU/ LIKEWISE BE ! HI<E/ TO HIM4 

,BUT :AT CONCEPT IS ! HI<E/ TO ! /ATE8 ,D\BTLESS ?AT ( BE+ A REALLY HUMAN SOCIETY1 A SOCIETY 9 :I* EV]Y ONE :O IS REALLY A MAN1 ?AT IS1 NOT AN UN-MAN1 CAN OBTA9 ADMISSION AS A MEMB]4 ,LET A /ATE'S TOL]ANCE GO EV] SO F>1 T[>D AN UN-MAN & T[>D :AT IS 9HUMAN IT CEASES4 ,& YET ?IS 0UN-MAN0 IS A MAN1 YET ! 09HUMAN0 ITSELF IS SOME?+ HUMAN1 YES1 POSSIBLE ONLY TO A MAN1 NOT TO ANY BEA/2 IT IS1 9 FACT1 SOME?+ 0POSSIBLE TO MAN40 ,BUT1 AL?\< EV]Y UN-MAN IS A MAN1 YET ! /ATE EXCLUDES HIM2 IT LOCKS HIM UP1 OR TRANS=MS HIM FROM A FELL[ ( ! /ATE 9TO A FELL[ ( ! PRISON 7FELL[ ( ! LUNATIC ASYLUM OR HOSPITAL1 ACCORD+ TO ,COMMUNISM74 

,TO SAY 9 BLUNT WORDS :AT AN UN-MAN IS IS NOT P>TICUL>LY H>D3 IT IS A MAN :O DOES NOT CORRESPOND TO ! CONCEPT MAN1 AS ! 9HUMAN IS SOME?+ HUMAN :I* IS NOT CON=M$ TO ! CONCEPT ( ! HUMAN4 ,LOGIC CALLS ?IS A 0SELF-CONTRADICTORY JUDGM5T40 ,W\LD IT BE P]MISSIBLE = ONE TO PRON\NCE ?IS JUDGM5T1 ?AT ONE CAN BE A MAN )\T BE+ A MAN1 IF HE DID NOT ADMIT ! HYPO!SIS ?AT ! CONCEPT ( MAN CAN BE SEP>AT$ FROM ! EXI/5CE1 ! ESS5CE FROM ! APPE>ANCE8 ,!Y SAY1 HE APPE>S 9DE$ AS A MAN1 BUT IS NOT A MAN4 

,M5 HAVE PASS$ ?IS 0SELF-CONTRADICTORY JUDGM5T0 ?R\< A LONG L9E ( C5TURIES6 ,9DE$1 :AT IS /ILL MORE1 9 ?IS LONG TIME !RE W]E ONLY - UN-M54 ,:AT 9DIVIDUAL CAN HAVE CORRESPOND$ TO HIS CONCEPT8 ,*RI/IANITY KN[S ONLY ONE ,MAN1 & ?IS ONE - ,*RI/ - IS AT ONCE AN UN-MAN AGA9 9 ! REV]SE S5SE1 NAMELY1 A SUP]HUMAN MAN1 A 0,GOD40 ,ONLY ! - UN-MAN IS A REAL MAN4 

,M5 ?AT >E NOT M51 :AT %\LD !Y BE BUT <O/S8 ,EV]Y REAL MAN1 BECAUSE HE DOES NOT CORRESPOND TO ! CONCEPT 0MAN10 OR BECAUSE HE IS NOT A 0G5]IC MAN10 IS A SPOOK4 ,BUT DO ,I /ILL REMA9 AN UN-MAN EV5 IF ,I BR+ ,MAN 7:O T[]$ ABOVE ME & REMA9$ O!RWORLDLY TO ME ONLY AS MY IDEAL1 MY TASK1 MY ESS5CE OR CONCEPT7 D[N TO BE MY QUALITY1 MY [N & 9H]5T 9 ME2 SO ?AT ,MAN IS NO?+ ELSE ?AN MY HUMANITY1 MY HUMAN EXI/5CE1 & EV]Y?+ ?AT ,I DO IS HUMAN PRECISELY BECAUSE ,IDO IT1 BUT NOT BECAUSE IT CORRESPONDS TO ! CONCEPT 0MAN08 ,IAM REALLY ,MAN & ! UN-MAN 9 ONE2 = ,I AM A MAN & AT ! SAME TIME MORE ?AN A MAN2 ,I AM ! EGO ( ?IS MY M]E QUALITY4 

,IT HAD TO COME TO ?IS AT LA/1 ?AT IT WAS NO LONG] M]ELY DEM&$ ( US TO BE ,*RI/IANS1 BUT TO BECOME M52 =1 ?\< WE C\LD NEV] REALLY BECOME EV5 ,*RI/IANS1 BUT ALWAYS REMA9$ 0POOR S9N]S0 7= ! ,*RI/IAN WAS AN UNATTA9ABLE IDEAL TOO71 YET 9 ?IS ! CONTRADICTOR9ESS DID NOT COME BE=E \R CONSCI\SNESS SO1 & ! ILLUSION WAS EASI] ?AN N[ :5 ( US1 :O >E M5 ACT HUMANLY 7YES1 CANNOT DO O!RWISE ?AN BE SU* & ACT SO71 ! DEM& IS MADE ?AT WE >E TO BE M51 0REAL M540 

,\R /ATES ( TODAY1 BECAUSE !Y /ILL HAVE ALL SORTS ( ?+S /ICK+ TO !M1 LEFT FROM !IR *UR*LY MO!R1 DO 9DE$ LOAD ?OSE :O BELONG TO !M ) V>I\S OBLIGATIONS 7SU* AS *UR*LY RELIGI\SNESS7 :I* PROP]LY DO NOT A BIT CONC]N !M1 ! /ATES2 YET ON ! :OLE !Y DO NOT D5Y !IR SIGNIFICANCE1 4S9CE !Y WANT TO BE LOOK$ UPON AS HUMAN SOCIETIES1 9 :I* MAN AS MAN CAN BE A MEMB]1 EV5 IF HE IS LESS PRIVILEG$ ?AN O!R MEMB]S2 MO/ ( !M ADMIT ADH]5CE ( EV]Y RELIGI\S SECT1 & RECEIVE PEOPLE )\T DI/9CTION ( RACE OR NATION3 ,JEWS1 ,TURKS1 ,MOORS1 ETC41 CAN BECOME ,FR5* CITIZ5S4 ,9 ! ACT ( RECEPTION1 !RE=E1 ! /ATE LOOKS ONLY TO SEE :E!R ONE IS A MAN4 ,! ,*UR*1 AS A SOCIETY ( BELIEV]S1 C\LD NOT RECEIVE EV]Y MAN 9TO H] BOSOM2 ! /ATE1 AS A SOCIETY ( M51 CAN4 ,BUT1 :5 ! /ATE HAS C>RI$ ITS PR9CIPLE CLE> ?R\<1 ( PRESUPPOS+ 9 ITS CON/ITU5TS NO?+ BUT ?AT !Y >E M5 7EV5 ! ,NOR? ,AM]ICANS /ILL PRESUPPOSE 9 !IRS ?AT !Y HAVE RELIGION1 AT LEA/ ! RELIGION ( 9TEGRITY1 ( RESPONSIBILITY71 !N IT HAS DUG ITS GRAVE4 ,:ILE IT WILL FANCY ?AT ?OSE :OM IT POSSESSES >E )\T EXCEPTION M51 !SE HAVE MEAN:ILE BECOME )\T EXCEPTION EGOI/S1 EA* ( :OM UTILIZES IT ACCORD+ TO HIS EGOI/IC P[]S & 5DS4 ,AGA9/ ! EGOI/S 0HUMAN SOCIETY0 IS WRECK$2 = !Y NO LONG] HAVE TO DO ) EA* O!R AS M51 BUT APPE> EGOI/ICALLY AS AN ,IAGA9/ A,Y\ ALTOGE!R DIFF]5T FROM ME & 9 OPPOSITION TO ME4 

,IF ! /ATE MU/ C\NT ON \R HUMANITY1 IT IS ! SAME IF ONE SAYS IT MU/ C\NT ON \R MORALITY4 ,SEE+ ,MAN 9 EA* O!R1 & ACT+ AS M5 T[>D EA* O!R1 IS CALL$ MORAL BEHAVIOR4 ,?IS IS EV]Y :IT ! 0SPIRITUAL LOVE0 ( ,*RI/IANITY4 ,=1 IF ,I SEE ,MAN 9 Y\1 AS 9 MYSELF ,I SEE ,MAN & NO?+ BUT ,MAN1 !N ,I C>E = Y\ AS ,I W\LD C>E = MYSELF2 = WE REPRES5T1 Y\ SEE1 NO?+ BUT ! MA!MATICAL PROPOSITION3 ,A "7 ,C & ,B "7 ,C1 CONSEQU5TLY ,A "7 ,B - ,I NO?+ BUT MAN & Y\ NO?+ BUT MAN1 CONSEQU5TLY ,I & Y\ ! SAME4 ,MORALITY IS 9COMPATIBLE ) EGOISM1 BECAUSE ! =M] DOES NOT ALL[ VALIDITY TO ME1 BUT ONLY TO ! ,MAN 9 ME4 ,BUT1 IF ! /ATE IS A SOCIETY ( M51 NOT A UNION ( EGOS .<,V]E9 VON ,I*5.> EA* ( :OM HAS ONLY HIMSELF BE=E HIS EYES1 !N IT CANNOT LA/ )\T MORALITY1 & MU/ 9SI/ ON MORALITY4 

,!RE=E WE TWO1 ! /ATE & ,I1 >E 5EMIES4 ,I1 ! EGOI/1 HAVE NOT AT HE>T ! WELF>E ( ?IS 0HUMAN SOCIETY10 ,I SACRIFICE NO?+ TO IT1 ,I ONLY UTILIZE IT2 BUT TO BE ABLE TO UTILIZE IT COMPLETELY ,I TRANS=M IT RA!R 9TO MY PROP]TY & MY CREATURE2 ?AT IS1 ,I ANNIHILATE IT1 & =M 9 ITS PLACE ! ,UNION ( ,EGOI/S .<,V]E9 VON ,EGOI/5.>4 

,SO ! /ATE BETRAYS ITS 5MITY TO ME BY DEM&+ ?AT ,I BE A MAN1 :I* PRESUPPOSES ?AT ,I MAY ALSO NOT BE A MAN1 BUT RANK = IT AS AN 0UN-MAN02 IT IMPOSES BE+ A MAN UPON ME AS A DUTY4 ,FUR!R1 IT DESIRES ME TO DO NO?+ ALONG ) :I* IT CANNOT LA/2 SO ITS P]MAN5CE IS TO BE SACR$ = ME4 ,!N ,I AM NOT TO BE AN EGOI/1 BUT A 0RESPECTABLE1 UPRI<T10 ?US MORAL1 MAN4 ,5\<3 BE=E IT & ITS P]MAN5CE ,I AM TO BE IMPOT5T & RESPECTFUL4 

,?IS /ATE1 NOT A PRES5T ONE 9DE$1 BUT /ILL 9 NE$ ( BE+ FIR/ CREAT$1 IS ! IDEAL ( ADVANC+ LIB]ALISM4 ,!RE IS TO COME 9TO EXI/5CE A TRUE 0SOCIETY ( M510 9 :I* EV]Y 0MAN0 F9DS ROOM4 ,LIB]ALISM MEANS TO REALIZE 0,MAN10 CREATE A WORLD = HIM2 & ?IS %\LD BE ! HUMAN WORLD OR ! G5]AL 7,COMMUNI/IC7 SOCIETY ( M54 ,IT WAS SAID1 0,! ,*UR* C\LD REG>D ONLY ! SPIRIT1 ! /ATE S TO REG>D ! :OLE MAN4 ,BUT IS NOT 0,MAN0 0SPIRIT08 ,! K]NEL ( ! /ATE IS SIMPLY 0,MAN10 ?IS UNREALITY1 & IT ITSELF IS ONLY A 0SOCIETY ( M540 ,! WORLD :I* ! BELIEV] 7BELIEV+ SPIRIT7 CREATES IS CALL$ ,*UR*1 ! WORLD :I* ! MAN 7HUMAN OR HUMANE SPIRIT7 CREATES IS CALL$ /ATE4 ,BUT ?AT IS NOT MY WORLD4 ,I NEV] EXECUTE ANY?+ HUMAN 9 ! AB/RACT1 BUT ALWAYS MY [N ?+S2 MY HUMAN ACT IS DIV]SE FROM EV]Y O!R HUMAN ACT1 & ONLY BY ?IS DIV]SITY IS IT A REAL ACT BELONG+ TO ME4 ,! HUMAN 9 IT IS AN AB/RACTION1 &1 AS SU*1 SPIRIT1 AB/RACT$ ESS5CE4 

,BRUNO ,BAU] /ATES 7,JUD5FRAGE1 P4 #h#d7 ?AT ! TRU? ( CRITICISM IS ! F9AL TRU?1 & 9 FACT ! TRU? S\<T = BY ,*RI/IANITY ITSELF - NAMELY1 0,MAN40 ,HE SAYS1 0,! HI/ORY ( ! ,*RI/IAN WORLD IS ! HI/ORY ( ! SUPREME FI<T = TRU?1 = 9 IT - & 9 IT ONLY6 - ! ?+ AT ISSUE IS ! DISCOV]Y ( ! F9AL OR ! PRIMAL TRU? - MAN & FRE$OM40 

,ALL RI<T1 LET US ACCEPT ?IS GA91 & LET US TAKE MAN AS ! ULTIMATELY F\ND RESULT ( ,*RI/IAN HI/ORY & ( ! RELIGI\S OR IDEAL EF=TS ( MAN 9 G5]AL4 ,N[1 :O IS ,MAN8 ,IAM6 ,MAN1 ! 5D & \TCOME ( ,*RI/IANITY1 IS1 AS ,I1 ! BEG9N+ & RAW MAT]IAL ( ! NEW HI/ORY1 A HI/ORY ( 5JOYM5T AFT] ! HI/ORY ( SACRIFICES1 A HI/ORY NOT ( MAN OR HUMANITY1 BUT ( - ME4 ,MAN RANKS AS ! G5]AL4 ,N[ !N1 ,I & ! EGOI/IC >E ! REALLY G5]AL1 S9CE EV]Y ONE IS AN EGOI/ & ( P>AM\NT IMPORTANCE TO HIMSELF4 ,! ,JEWI% IS NOT ! PURELY EGOI/IC1 BECAUSE ! ,JEW /ILL DEVOTES HIMSELF TO ,JEHOVAH2 ! ,*RI/IAN IS NOT1 BECAUSE ! ,*RI/IAN LIVES ON ! GRACE ( ,GOD & SUBJECTS HIMSELF TO HIM4 ,AS ,JEW & AS ,*RI/IAN ALIKE A MAN SATISFIES ONLY C]TA9 ( HIS WANTS1 ONLY A C]TA9 NE$1 NOT HIMSELF3 A HALF-EGOISM1 BECAUSE ! EGOISM ( A HALF-MAN1 :O IS HALF HE1 HALF ,JEW1 OR HALF HIS [N PROPRIETOR1 HALF A SLAVE4 ,!RE=E1 TOO1 ,JEW & ,*RI/IAN ALWAYS HALF-WAY EXCLUDE EA* O!R2 AS M5 !Y RECOGNIZE EA* O!R1 AS SLAVES !Y EXCLUDE EA* O!R1 BECAUSE !Y >E S]VANTS ( TWO DIFF]5T MA/]S4 ,IF !Y C\LD BE COMPLETE EGOI/S1 !Y W\LD EXCLUDE EA* O!R :OLLY & HOLD TOGE!R SO MU* ! MORE FIRMLY4 ,!IR IGNOM9Y IS NOT ?AT !Y EXCLUDE EA* O!R1 BUT ?AT ?IS IS DONE ONLY HALF-WAY4 ,BRUNO ,BAU]1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 ?9KS ,JEWS & ,*RI/IANS CANNOT REG>D & TREAT EA* O!R AS 0M50 UNTIL !Y GIVE UP ! SEP>ATE ESS5CE :I* P>TS !M & OBLIGATES !M TO ET]NAL SEP>ATION1 RECOGNIZE ! G5]AL ESS5CE ( 0,MAN10 & REG>D ?IS AS !IR 0TRUE ESS5CE40 

,ACCORD+ TO HIS REPRES5TATION ! DEFECT ( ! ,JEWS & ! ,*RI/IANS ALIKE LIES 9 !IR WANT+ TO BE & HAVE SOME?+ 0P>TICUL>0 9/EAD ( ONLY BE+ M5 & 5DEAVOR+ AFT] :AT IS HUMAN - NAMELY1 ! 0G5]AL RI<TS ( MAN40 ,HE ?9KS !IR FUNDAM5TAL ]ROR CONSI/S 9 ! BELIEF ?AT !Y >E 0PRIVILEG$10 POSSESS 0PR]OGATIVES02 9 G5]AL1 9 ! BELIEF 9 PR]OGATIVE .<,VORRE*T.>4 ,9 OPPOSITION TO ?IS HE HOLDS UP TO !M ! G5]AL RI<TS ( MAN .<,M5S*5RE*T.>4 ,! RI<TS ( MAN6 - 

,MAN IS MAN 9 G5]AL1 & 9 SO F> EV]Y ONE :O IS A MAN4 ,N[ EV]Y ONE IS TO HAVE ! ET]NAL RI<TS ( MAN1 &1 ACCORD+ TO ! OP9ION ( ,COMMUNISM1 5JOY !M 9 ! COMPLETE 0DEMOCRACY10 OR1 AS IT \<T MORE CORRECTLY TO BE CALL$ - AN?ROPOCRACY4 ,BUT IT IS ,I ALONE :O HAVE EV]Y?+ ?AT ,I - PROCURE = MYSELF2 AS MAN ,I HAVE NO?+4 ,PEOPLE W\LD LIKE TO GIVE EV]Y MAN AN AFFLU5CE ( ALL GOOD1 M]ELY BECAUSE HE HAS ! TITLE 0MAN40 ,BUT ,I PUT ! ACC5T ON ME1 NOT ON MY BE+ MAN4 

,MAN IS SOME?+ ONLY AS MY QUALITY .<,EIG5S*AFT.> 7PROP]TY .<,EIG5TUM.>71 LIKE MASCUL9ITY OR FEM99ITY4 ,! ANCI5TS F\ND ! IDEAL 9 ONE'S BE+ MALE 9 ! FULL S5SE2 !IR VIRTUE IS VIRTUS & >ETE - MANL9ESS4 ,:AT IS ONE TO ?9K ( A WOMAN :O %\LD WANT ONLY TO BE P]FECTLY 0WOMAN80 ,?AT IS NOT GIV5 TO ALL1 & MANY A ONE W\LD !RE9 BE FIX+ = H]SELF AN UNATTA9ABLE GOAL4 ,FEM99E1 ON ! O!R H&1 %E IS ANYH[1 BY NATURE2 FEM99ITY IS H] QUALITY1 & %E DOES NOT NE$ 0TRUE FEM99ITY40 ,I AM A MAN JU/ AS ! E>? IS A />4 ,AS RIDICUL\S AS IT W\LD BE TO SET ! E>? ! TASK ( BE+ A 0?OR\< .<RE*T].> />10 SO RIDICUL\S IT IS TO BURD5 ME ) ! CALL TO BE A 0?OR\< MAN40 

,:5 ,FI*TE SAYS1 0,! EGO IS ALL10 ?IS SEEMS TO H>MONIZE P]FECTLY ) MY !SIS4 ,BUT IT IS NOT ?AT ! EGO IS ALL1 BUT ! EGO DE/ROYS ALL1 & ONLY ! SELF-DISSOLV+ EGO1 ! NEV]-BE+ EGO1 ! - F9ITE EGO IS REALLY ,I4 ,FI*TE SPEAKS ( ! 0ABSOLUTE0 EGO1 BUT ,I SPEAK ( ME1 ! TRANSITORY EGO4 

,H[ NATURAL IS ! SUPPOSITION ?AT MAN & EGO MEAN ! SAME6 ,& YET ONE SEES1 AS BY ,FEU]BA*1 ?AT ! EXPRESSION 0MAN0 IS TO DESIGNATE ! ABSOLUTE EGO1 ! SPECIES1 NOT ! TRANSITORY1 9DIVIDUAL EGO4 ,EGOISM & HUMANITY 7HUMAN5ESS7 \<T TO MEAN ! SAME1 BUT ACCORD+ TO ,FEU]BA* ! 9DIVIDUAL CAN 0ONLY LIFT HIMSELF ABOVE ! LIMITS ( HIS 9DIVIDUALITY1 BUT NOT ABOVE ! LAWS1 ! POSITIVE ORD9ANCES1 ( HIS SPECIES4 ,BUT ! SPECIES IS NO?+1 &1 IF ! 9DIVIDUAL LIFTS HIMSELF ABOVE ! LIMITS ( HIS 9DIVIDUALITY1 ?IS IS RA!R HIS V]Y SELF AS AN 9DIVIDUAL2 HE EXI/S ONLY 9 RAIS+ HIMSELF1 HE EXI/S ONLY 9 NOT REMA9+ :AT HE IS2 O!RWISE HE W\LD BE DONE1 DEAD4 ,MAN ) ! GREAT ,M IS ONLY AN IDEAL1 ! SPECIES ONLY SOME?+ ?\<T (4 ,TO BE A MAN IS NOT TO REALIZE ! IDEAL ( ,MAN1 BUT TO PRES5T ONESELF1 ! 9DIVIDUAL4 ,IT IS NOT H[ ,I REALIZE ! G5]ALLY HUMAN ?AT NE$S TO BE MY TASK1 BUT H[ ,I SATISFY MYSELF4 ,I AM MY SPECIES1 AM )\T NORM1 )\T LAW1 )\T MODEL1 & ! LIKE4 ,IT IS POSSIBLE ?AT ,I CAN MAKE V]Y LITTLE \T ( MYSELF2 BUT ?IS LITTLE IS EV]Y?+1 & IS BETT] ?AN :AT ,I ALL[ TO BE MADE \T ( ME BY ! MI<T ( O!RS1 BY ! TRA9+ ( CU/OM1 RELIGION1 ! LAWS1 ! /ATE4 ,BETT] - IF ! TALK IS TO BE ( BETT] AT ALL - BETT] AN UNMANN]LY *ILD ?AN AN OLD HEAD ON Y\NG %\LD]S1 BETT] A MULI% MAN ?AN A MAN COMPLIANT 9 EV]Y?+4 ,! UNMANN]LY & MULI% FELL[ IS /ILL ON ! WAY TO =M HIMSELF ACCORD+ TO HIS [N WILL2 ! PREMATURELY KN[+ & COMPLIANT ONE IS DET]M9$ BY ! 0SPECIES10 ! G5]AL DEM&S - ! SPECIES IS LAW TO HIM4 ,HE IS DET]M9$ .<BE/IMMT.> BY IT2 = :AT ELSE IS ! SPECIES TO HIM BUT HIS DE/9Y .<,BE/IMMUNG.>1 HIS 0CALL+08 ,:E!R ,I LOOK TO 0HUMANITY10 ! SPECIES1 9 ORD] TO /RIVE T[>D ?IS IDEAL1 OR TO ,GOD & ,*RI/ ) LIKE 5DEAVOR1 :]E IS ! ESS5TIAL DISSIMIL>ITY8 ,AT MO/ ! =M] IS MORE WA%$-\T ?AN ! LATT]4 ,AS ! 9DIVIDUAL IS ! :OLE ( NATURE1 SO HE IS ! :OLE ( ! SPECIES TOO4 

,EV]Y?+ ?AT ,I DO1 ?9K - 9 %ORT1 MY EXPRESSION OR MANIFE/ATION - IS 9DE$ CONDITION$ BY :AT ,I AM4 ,! ,JEW CAN WILL ONLY ?US OR ?US1 CAN 0PRES5T HIMSELF0 ONLY ?US2 ! ,*RI/IAN CAN PRES5T & MANIFE/ HIMSELF ONLY ,*RI/IANLY1 ETC4 ,IF IT W]E POSSIBLE ?AT Y\ C\LD BE A ,JEW OR ,*RI/IAN1 Y\ W\LD 9DE$ BR+ \T ONLY :AT WAS ,JEWI% OR ,*RI/IAN2 BUT IT IS NOT POSSIBLE2 9 ! MO/ RIGOR\S CONDUCT Y\ YET REMA9 AN EGOI/1 A S9N] AGA9/ ?AT CONCEPT - Y\ >E NOT ! PRECISE EQUIVAL5T ( ,JEW4 ,N[1 BECAUSE ! EGOI/IC ALWAYS KEEPS PEEP+ ?R\<1 PEOPLE HAVE 9QUIR$ = A MORE P]FECT CONCEPT :I* %\LD REALLY :OLLY EXPRESS :AT Y\ >E1 & :I*1 BECAUSE IT IS Y\R TRUE NATURE1 %\LD CONTA9 ALL ! LAWS ( Y\R ACTIVITY4 ,! MO/ P]FECT ?+ ( ! K9D HAS BE5 ATTA9$ 9 0,MAN40 ,AS A ,JEW Y\ >E TOO LITTLE1 & ! ,JEWI% IS NOT Y\R TASK2 TO BE A ,GREEK1 A ,G]MAN1 DOES NOT SUFFICE4 ,BUT BE A - MAN1 !N Y\ HAVE EV]Y?+2 LOOK UPON ! HUMAN AS Y\R CALL+4 

,N[ ,I KN[ :AT IS EXPECT$ ( ME1 & ! NEW CATE*ISM CAN BE WRITT54 ,! SUBJECT IS AGA9 SUBJECT$ TO ! PR$ICATE1 ! 9DIVIDUAL TO SOME?+ G5]AL2 ! DOM9ION IS AGA9 SECUR$ TO AN IDEA1 & ! F\NDATION LAID = A NEW RELIGION4 ,?IS IS A /EP =W>D 9 ! DOMA9 ( RELIGION1 & 9 P>TICUL> ( ,*RI/IANITY2 NOT A /EP \T BEYOND IT4 

,TO /EP \T BEYOND IT LEADS 9TO ! UNSPEAKABLE4 ,= ME PALTRY LANGUAGE HAS NO WORD1 & 0! ,WORD10 ! ,LOGOS1 IS TO ME A M]E WORD40 

,MY ESS5CE IS S\<T =4 ,IF NOT ! ,JEW1 ! ,G]MAN1 !N AT ANY RATE IT IS - ! MAN4 0,MAN IS MY ESS5CE40 

,I AM REPULSIVE OR REPUGNANT TO MYSELF2 ,I HAVE A HORROR & LOA?+ ( MYSELF1 ,I AM A HORROR TO MYSELF1 OR1 ,I AM NEV] 5\< = MYSELF & NEV] DO 5\< TO SATISFY MYSELF4 ,FROM SU* FEEL+S SPR+S SELF-DISSOLUTION OR SELF-CRITICISM4 ,RELIGI\SNESS BEG9S ) SELF-R5UNCIATION1 5DS ) COMPLET$ CRITICISM4 

,I AM POSSESS$1 & WANT TO GET RID ( ! 0EVIL SPIRIT40 ,H[ DO ,I SET AB\T IT8 ,I FE>LESSLY COMMIT ! S9 ?AT SEEMS TO ! ,*RI/IAN ! MO/ DIRE1 ! S9 & BLASPHEMY AGA9/ ! ,HOLY ,SPIRIT4 0,HE :O BLASPHEMES ! ,HOLY ,SPIRIT HAS NO =GIV5ESS =EV]1 BUT IS LIABLE TO ! ET]NAL JUDGM5T6 7,M>K #c3#b#i_> ,I WANT NO =GIV5ESS1 & AM NOT AFRAID ( ! JUDGM5T4 

,MAN IS ! LA/ EVIL SPIRIT OR SPOOK1 ! MO/ DECEPTIVE OR MO/ 9TIMATE1 ! CRAFTIE/ LI> ) HONE/ MI51 ! FA!R ( LIES4 

,! EGOI/1 TURN+ AGA9/ ! DEM&S & CONCEPTS ( ! PRES5T1 EXECUTES PITILESSLY ! MO/ MEASURELESS - DESECRATION4 ,NO?+ IS HOLY TO HIM6 

,IT W\LD BE FOOLI% TO ASS]T ?AT !RE IS NO P[] ABOVE M9E4 ,ONLY ! ATTITUDE ?AT ,I TAKE T[>D IT WILL BE QUITE ANO!R ?AN ?AT ( ! RELIGI\S AGE3 ,I %ALL BE ! 5EMY ( - EV]Y HI<] P[]1 :ILE RELIGION TEA*ES US TO MAKE IT \R FRI5D & BE HUMBLE T[>D IT4 

,! DESECRATOR PUTS =? HIS /R5G? AGA9/ EV]Y FE> ( ,GOD1 = FE> ( ,GOD W\LD DET]M9E HIM 9 EV]Y?+ ?AT HE LEFT /&+ AS SACR$4 ,:E!R IT IS ! ,GOD OR ! ,MAN ?AT EX]CISES ! HALL[+ P[] 9 ! ,GOD-MAN - :E!R1 !RE=E1 ANY?+ IS HELD SACR$ = ,GOD'S SAKE OR = ,MAN'S 7,HUMANITY'S7 - ?IS DOES NOT *ANGE ! FE> ( ,GOD1 S9CE ,MAN IS REV]$ AS 0SUPREME ESS5CE10 AS MU* AS ON ! SPECIFICALLY RELIGI\S /&-PO9T ,GOD AS 0SUPREME ESS5CE0 CALLS = \R FE> .<,FUR*T.> & REV]5CE .<,EHRFUR*T.>2 BO? OV]AWE US4 

,! FE> ( ,GOD 9 ! PROP] S5SE WAS %AK5 LONG AGO1 & A MORE OR LESS CONSCI\S 0A!ISM10 EXT]NALLY RECOGNIZABLE BY A WIDE-SPREAD 0UN*UR*L9ESS10 HAS 9VOLUNT>ILY BECOME ! MODE4 ,BUT :AT WAS TAK5 FROM ,GOD HAS BE5 SUP]ADD$ TO ,MAN1 & ! P[] ( HUMANITY GREW GREAT] 9 JU/ ! DEGREE ?AT ?AT ( PIETY LO/ WEI<T3 0,MAN0 IS ! ,GOD ( TODAY1 & FE> ( ,MAN HAS TAK5 ! PLACE ( ! OLD FE> ( ,GOD4 

,BUT1 BECAUSE ,MAN REPRES5TS ONLY ANO!R ,SUPREME ,BE+1 NO?+ 9 FACT HAS TAK5 PLACE BUT A METAMORPHOSIS 9 ! ,SUPREME ,BE+1 & ! FE> ( ,MAN IS M]ELY AN ALT]$ =M ( ! FE> ( ,GOD4 

,\R A!I/S >E PI\S PEOPLE4 

,IF 9 ! SO-CALL$ FEUDAL TIMES WE HELD EV]Y?+ AS A FIEF FROM ,GOD1 9 ! LIB]AL P]IOD ! SAME FEUDAL RELATION EXI/S ) ,MAN4 ,GOD WAS ! ,LORD1 N[ ,MAN IS ! ,LORD2 ,GOD WAS ! ,M$IATOR1 N[ ,MAN IS2 ,GOD WAS ! ,SPIRIT1 N[ ,MAN IS4 ,9 ?IS ?REE FOLD REG>D ! FEUDAL RELATION HAS EXP]I5C$ A TRANS=MATION4 ,= N[1 FIR/LY1 WE HOLD4AS A FIEF FROM ALL-P[]FUL ,MAN \R P[]1 :I*1 BECAUSE IT COMES FROM A HI<]1 IS NOT CALL$ P[] OR MI<T1 BUT 0RI<T0 - ! 0RI<TS ( MAN02 WE FUR!R HOLD AS A FIEF FROM HIM \R POSITION 9 ! WORLD1 = HE1 ! M$IATOR1 M$IATES \R 9T]C\RSE ) O!RS1 :I* !RE=E MAY NOT BE O!RWISE ?AN 0HUMAN02 F9ALLY1 WE HOLD AS A FIEF FROM HIM \RSELVES - NAMELY1 \R [N VALUE1 OR ALL ?AT WE >E WOR? - 9ASMU* AS WE >E WOR? NO?+ :5 HE DOES NOT DWELL 9 US1 & :5 OR :]E WE >E NOT 0HUMAN40 ,! P[] IS ,MAN'S1 ! WORLD IS ,MAN'S1 ,I AM ,MAN'S4 

,BUT AM ,I NOT /ILL UNRE/RA9$ FROM DECL>+ MYSELF ! 5TITL]1 ! M$IATOR1 & ! [N SELF8 ,!N IT RUNS ?US3 ,MY P[] IS MY PROP]TY4 ,MY P[] GIVES ME PROP]TY4 ,MY P[] AM ,I MYSELF1 & ?R\< IT AM ,I MY PROP]TY4 

,FROM 3 ,WIKI,S\RCE4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahdc 3 ,P>T #b1 ,*APT] #b -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,FEBRU>Y #b1 #bag 3 ,P>T #b1 ,*APT] #b -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/