,! ,IDEA ( ,EQUALITY & ! ,BOL%EVIKS 

#aibf 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,NE/OR ,MAKHNO 

,TEXT 3 

,! #a#d? ,CONGRESS ( ! ,RUSSIAN ,COMMUNI/ ,P>TY HAS R\NDLY CONDEMN$ ! NOTION ( EQUALITY4 ,PRIOR TO ! CONGRESS1 ,Z9OVIEV HAD M5TION$ ! IDEA 9 ! C\RSE ( HIS POLEMIC AGA9/ ,U/RIALOV & ,BUKH>94 ,HE DECL>$ !N ?AT ! :OLE ( CONTEMPOR>Y PHILOSOPHY WAS SU/A9$ BY ! IDEA ( EQUALITY4 ,KAL99 SPOKE UP =CEFULLY AT ! CONGRESS AGA9/ ?AT CONT5TION1 TAK+ ! L9E ?AT ANY REF]5CE TO EQUALITY C\LD NOT HELP BUT BE H>MFUL & WAS NOT TO BE TOL]AT$4 ,HIS REASON+ WAS AS FOLL[S3 

0,CAN WE TALK TO PEASANTS AB\T EQUALITY8 ,NO1 ?AT IS \T ( ! QUE/ION1 = 9 ?AT CASE1 !Y W\LD SET AB\T DEM&+ ! SAME RI<TS AS WORK]S1 :I* W\LD BE 9 COMPLETE CONTRADICTION ) ! DICTATOR%IP ( ! PROLET>IAT4 ,LIKEWISE1 CAN WE TALK ( EQUALITY TO WORK]S8 ,NO1 ?AT IS \T ( ! QUE/ION TOO1 = IF1 SAY1 A COMMUNI/ & A NONP>TY MEMB] DO ! SAME JOB1 ! DIFF]5CE RESIDES 9 ! =M] BE+ PAID TWICE ! WAGE ( ! LATT]4 ,TO CONC$E EQUALITY W\LD ALL[ NONP>TY MEMB]S TO DEM& ! SAME PAY AS IS PAID \T TO A COMMUNI/4 ,IS ?AT ACCEPTABLE1 COMRADES8 ,NO1 IT IS NOT4 ,CAN WE CALL = EQUALITY AMONG COMMUNI/S !N8 ,NO1 ?AT IS NOT ON EI!R1 = !Y TOO OCCUPY DIFF]5T POSITIONS1 9 T]MS ( !IR RI<TS & !IR MAT]IAL CIRCUM/ANCES 
ALIKE40 

,ON ! BASIS ( SU* CONSID]ATIONS1 ,KAL99 CONCLUD$ ?AT ,Z9OVIEV'S USE ( ! T]M 0EQUALITY0 C\LD ONLY HAVE BE5 DEMAGOGIC & H>MFUL4 ,9 HIS REPLY1 ,Z9OVIEV 9 TURN TOLD ! CONGRESS ?AT1 :IL/ HE HAD SPOK5 ( EQUALITY1 HE HAD MEANT IT 9 QUITE A DIFF]5T S5SE4 ,AS = HIMSELF1 ALL HE HAD HAD 9 M9D WAS 0SOCIALI/ EQUALITY10 ?AT IS1 ! EQUALITY ?AT W\LD ONE DAY COME TO PASS 9 A MORE OR LESS DI/ANT FUTURE4 ,= ! TIME BE+1 UNTIL SU* TIME AS ! WORLD REVOLUTION HAD TAK5 PLACE & AS !RE WAS NO WAY ( KN[+ :5 IT W\LD1 !RE C\LD BE NO QUE/ION ( ANY EQUALITY4 ,9 P>TICUL>1 !RE C\LD BE NO EQUALITY ( RI<TS1 = ?AT W\LD RISK DRAGG+ US 9 ! DIRECTION ( V]Y DANG]\S 0DEMOCRATIC0 DEVIATIONS4 

,?IS UND]/&+ ON ! NOTION ( EQUALITY WAS NOT SPELL$ \T 9 A RESOLUTION FROM ! CONGRESS4 ,BUT1 ESS5TIALLY1 ! TWO CAMPS ?AT CLA%$ AT ! CONGRESS W]E AGRE$ 9 REG>D+ ! IDEA ( EQUALITY AS 9TOL]ABLE4 

,=M]LY1 & NOT ALL ?AT LONG AGO1 ! ,BOL%EVIKS SPOKE QUITE A DIFF]5T LANGUAGE4 ,IT WAS UND] ! BANN] ( EQUALITY ?AT !Y OP]AT$ DUR+ ! GREAT ,RUSSIAN REVOLUTION1 TO OV]?R[ ! B\RGEOISIE1 9 CONC]T ) ! WORK]S & PEASANTS1 AT :OSE EXP5SE !Y ROSE TO POLITICAL CONTROL OV] ! C\NTRY4 ,IT WAS UND] ?OSE COLORS ?AT1 AFT] EI<T YE>S ( RUL+ OV] ! LIVES & LIB]TIES ( ! TOIL]S ( ! =M] ,RUSSIA - H5CE=? TO BE KN[N AS ! 
0,UNION ( ,SOVIET ,SOCIALI/ ,REPUBLICS0 ! ,BOL%EVIK CZ>S S\<T TO P]SUADE ! TOIL]S ( ?AT 
0,UNION01 7OPPRESS$ BY !M71 AS WELL AS ! TOIL]S FROM O!R C\NTRIES 7:I* !Y DO NOT YET CONTROL71 ?AT IF !Y HAVE P]SECUT$1 LEFT TO ROT 9 PRISON OR DEPORT$ & MURD]$ !IR POLITICAL 5EMIES1 ?IS HAS BE5 DONE EXCLUSIVELY 9 ! NAME ( ! REVOLUTION1 ITS EGALIT>IAN F\NDATIONS 7:I* !Y ALLEG$LY HAD 9TRODUC$ 9TO ! REVOLUTION7 :I* !IR 5EMIES SUPPOS$LY WI%$ TO DE/ROY4 

,IT %ALL SOON BE EI<T YE>S S9CE ! BLOOD ( AN>*I/S BEGAN TO FL[ BECAUSE ( !IR REFUSAL TO S]VILELY B[ BE=E ! VIOL5CE OR EFFRONT]Y ( ?OSE :O HAVE SEIZ$ P[]1 NOR BE=E !IR FAM\SLY LY+ IDEOLOGY & !IR UTT] IRRESPONSIBILITY4 

,9 ?AT CRIM9AL ACT1 AN ACT ?AT CANNOT BE DESCRIB$ AS O!R ?AN A BLOODLU/ ( ! ,BOL%EVIK GODS1 ! F9E/ (FSPR+ ( ! REVOLUTION HAVE P]I%$ BECAUSE !Y W]E ! MO/ LOYAL EXPON5TS ( REVOLUTION>Y IDEALS & BECAUSE !Y C\LD NOT BE BRIB$ 9TO BETRAY+ !M4 ,9 HONE/LY DEF5D+ ! PRECEPTS ( ! REVOLUTION1 !SE *ILDR5 ( ! REVOLUTION S\<T TO F5D (F ! MADNESS ( ! ,BOL%EVIK GODS & F9D A WAY \T ( !IR DEAD 5D1 SO AS TO =GE A PA? TO REAL FRE$OM & G5U9E EQUALITY ( ! TOIL]S4 

,! ,BOL%EVIK POT5TATES QUICKLY REALIZ$ ?AT ! ASPIRATIONS ( !SE *ILDR5 ( ! REVOLUTION W\LD SPELL DOOM = !IR MADNESS & ABOVE ALL = ! PRIVILEGES !Y ADROITLY 9H]IT$ FROM ! TOPPL$ B\RGEOISIE1 !N TREA*]\SLY BEEF$ UP TO !IR ADVANTAGE4 ,ON !SE GR\NDS !Y CONDEMN$ ! REVOLUTION>IES TO DEA?4 ,M5 ) ! S\LS ( SLAVES SUPPORT$ !M 9 ?IS & ! BLOOD FL[$4 ,= ! PA/ EI<T YE>S IT HAS GONE ON FL[+1 & 9 ! NAME ( :AT1 WE MI<T ASK8 ,9 ! NAME ( FRE$OM & EQUALITY ( ! TOIL]S1 SAY ! ,BOL%EVIKS1 CONT9U+ TO EXT]M9ATE ?\S&S ( NAMELESS REVOLUTION>IES1 FI<T]S = ! SOCIAL REVOLUTION1 LABEL$ AS 0B&ITS0 & 0C\NT]-REVOLUTION>IES40 

,) ?AT %AMELESS FALSEHOOD1 ! ,BOL%EVIKS HAVE HIDD5 ! TRUE /ATE ( AFFAIRS 9 ,RUSSIA FROM ! EYES ( TOIL]S ! WORLD OV]1 P>TICUL>LY !IR UTT] BANKRUPTCY 9 ! MATT] ( BUILD+ SOCIALISM1 :5 ?IS IS ALL TOO APP>5T TO ALL :O HAVE ! EYES TO SEE4 

,AN>*I/S AL]T$ TOIL]S ( EV]Y C\NTRY 9 TIME TO ! ,BOL%EVIKS' CRIMES 9 ! ,RUSSIAN REVOLUTION4 ,BOL%EVISM1 EMBODY+ ! IDEAL ( A C5TRALIZ+ ,/ATE1 HAS %[N ITSELF AS ! DEADLY 5EMY ( ! FREE SPIRIT ( REVOLUTION>Y TOIL]S4 ,RESORT+ TO UNPREC$5T$ MEASURES1 IT HAS SABOTAG$ ! DEVELOPM5T ( ! REVOLUTION & BESMIR*$ ! HONOR ( ITS F9E/ ASPECT4 ,SUCCESSFULLY DISGUIS$1 IT CONCEAL$ ITS REAL FACE FROM ! GAZE ( ! TOIL]S1 PASS+ ITSELF (F AS ! *AMPION ( !IR 9T]E/S4 ,ONLY N[1 AFT] AN EI<T YE>S' REIGN1 9CREAS+LY FLIRT+ ) ! 9T]NATIONAL B\RGEOISIE1 DOES IT BEG9 TO CA/ ASIDE ITS MASK ( REVOLUTION & EXPOSE TO ! WORLD ( LABOR ! FACE ( A RAPACI\S EXPLOIT]4 

,! ,BOL%EVIKS HAVE JETTISON$ ! IDEA ( EQUALITY1 NOT JU/ 9 PRACTICE BUT ALSO 9 !ORY1 = ! V]Y 5UNCIATION ( IT /RIKES !M AS DANG]\S N[4 ,?IS IS QUITE UND]/&ABLE1 = !IR 5TIRE RULE DEP5DS ON A DIAMETRICALLY CONTRA/+ NOTION1 ON A SCREAM+ 9EQUALITY1 ! 5TIRE HORROR & EVILS ( :I* HAVE BATT5$ UPON ! BACKS ( ! WORK]S4 ,LET US HOPE ?AT ! TOIL]S ( EV]Y C\NTRY MAY DRAW ! NECESS>Y CONCLUSIONS &1 9 TURN1 F9I% ) ! ,BOL%EVIKS1 ?OSE EXPON5TS ( ! IDEA ( SLAV]Y & OPPRESSORS ( 
,LABOR4 

7,S\RCE3 ,DELO ,TRUDA ,N8#i1 ,FEBRU>Y #a#i#b#f1 PP4 #i-#a4  ,TEXT FROM 0,! ,/RUGGLE ,AGA9/ ! ,/ATE & O!R ESSAYS0 BY ,NE/OR ,MAKHNO1 ,$IT$ BY ,ALEX&RE ,SIRDA1 ,TRANSLAT$ BY ,PAUL ,%>KEY1 ,PUBLI%$ BY ,A,K ,PRESS47 

,FROM 3 ,NE/OR,MAKHNO49FO4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,JANU>Y #c#a1 #aibf 3 ,! ,IDEA ( ,EQUALITY & ! ,BOL%EVIKS -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,M>* #b#i1 #bba 3 ,! ,IDEA ( ,EQUALITY & ! ,BOL%EVIKS -- ,ADD$4 
,JANU>Y #i1 #bbb 3 ,! ,IDEA ( ,EQUALITY & ! ,BOL%EVIKS -- ,UPDAT$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/