,APP5DIX TO ,*APT] #c 

#aihaih 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,LEO ,TOL/OY 

,TEXT 3 

,! MO/ DANG]\S PEOPLE HAVE BE5 HANG$1 OR >E S]V+ S5T5CES 9 P5AL BATTALIONS1 =TRESSES & PRISONS2 T5S ( ?\S&S ( O!RS1 LESS DANG]\S1 HAVE BE5 DRIV5 \T ( ! CAPITAL CITIES & BIG T[NS & >E W&]+ >\ND ,RUSSIA1 B$RAGGL$ & HUNGRY2 ! ORD9>Y POLICE >RE/1 ! SECRET POLICE PURSUE2 ALL BOOKS & NEWSPAP]S DANG]\S TO ! GOV]NM5T >E )DRAWN FROM CIRCULATION4 ,9 ! ,DUMA DEBATES GO ON BETWE5 V>I\S P>TY SPOKESM5 AS TO H[ TO PROTECT ! WELF>E ( ! PEOPLE3 %\LD OR %\LD NOT FLEETS BE BUILT8 ,%\LD PEASANT L&-[N]%IP BE ORGANIZ$ 9 ?IS WAY OR ?AT WAY8 ,H[ & :Y A ,C\NCIL ( ,*UR*ES %\LD1 OR %\LD NOT1 BE HELD4 ,!RE >E LEAD]S :O DALLY 9 LOBBIES1 !RE >E QUORUMS1 BLOCS1 PREMI]S & EV]Y?+ ELSE D[N TO ! LA/ DETAIL1 EXACTLY AS 9 ALL CIVILIZ$ NATIONS4 ,IT W\LD SEEM ?AT WE NE$ NO?+ MORE4 ,& YET1 ! COLLAPSE ( ! EXI/+ /RUCTURE IS DRAW+ CLOS] & CLOS]1 PRECISELY H]E & PRECISELY N[1 9 ,RUSSIA4 

,F9E !N1 Y\ GOV]NM5T PEOPLE1 HANG & %OOT ANO!R FIVE1 T51 OR ?IRTY ?\S&1 AS IMITAT+ =M] REPRESSIONS ( REVOLUTIONS 9 ,EUROPE Y\ CLE>LY 9T5D TO DO4 ,F9E !N1 GO AHEAD4 ,BUT Y\ KN[1 AS WELL AS ! NOOSE1 ! GALL[S1 SPIES1 PRISONS1 RIFLES1 RIFLE-BUTTS1 ETC41 !RE >E SPIRITUAL =CES ?AT >E EXTREMELY /RONG & F> MORE P[]FUL ?AN ANY SORT ( GALL[S OR PRISON4 ,Y\ SEE1 ALL ?OSE Y\ /RANGLE ) ROPES & %OOT ABOVE GRAVES DUG \T BY M5 /ILL LIV+ HAD & HAVE FA!RS1 BRO!RS1 WIVES1 SI/]S1 FRI5DS & LIKE-M9D$ FOLL[]S1 & IF !SE EXECUTIONS SP>E Y\ FROM ?OSE :O >E BURI$ 9 ! GRAVES !Y G5]ATE1 NOT ONLY AMONG ?OSE :O W]E CLOSE TO !M1 BUT AMONG /RANG]S TOO1 TWICE AS MANY 5EMIES1 TWICE AS P]NICI\S AS ?OSE Y\ HAVE KILL$ & BURI$ 9 ! E>?4 ,! MORE PEOPLE Y\ MURD]1 ! SMALL] ! *ANCE ( SAV+ Y\RSELVES FROM Y\R *IEF 5EMY3 ! HATR$ PEOPLE FEEL T[>DS Y\4 ,BY Y\R CRIMES Y\ ONLY 9CREASE ?IS HATR$ T5FOLD & MAKE IT MORE DANG]\S TO Y\RSELVES4 

,AP>T FROM 9CREAS+ ! NUMB] ( Y\R 5EMIES & !IR HATR$1 ?R\< ?OSE Y\ EXECUTE1 !SE V]Y EXECUTIONS 9CREASE1 EV5 AMONG M5 :O >E P]FECT /RANG]S TO Y\RSELVES & Y\R 5EMIES1 ?AT FEEL+ ( CRUELTY & IMMORALITY Y\ ?9K Y\ >E COMBAT+ ) !SE EXECUTIONS4 ,= !SE EXECUTIONS >E NOT P]=M$ AUTOMATICALLY BY ! PAP]S :I* Y\ WRITE 9 Y\R LAW C\RTS & M9I/RIES4 ,PEOPLE >E EXECUT$ BY O!R PEOPLE4 ,A Y\NG MAN1 A =M] SOLDI]1 EVID5TLY P]PLEX$ AS TO H[ HE %\LD REACT TO ?IS1 TOLD ME ( H[ HE WAS MADE TO DIG A TR5*1 A GRAVE = T5 PEOPLE S5T5C$ TO BE %OT1 & H[ SOME SOLDI]S W]E =C$ TO %OOT !SE CONDEMN$ M51 :ILE O!RS HAD TO /& ) LOAD$ RIFLES BEH9D ! EXECUTION]S READY TO %OOT !M %\LD !Y HESITATE 9 FULFILL+ ! <A/LY1 9HUMAN TASK DEM&$ ( !M4 ,CAN ! P]=MANCE ( SU* AWFUL ACTS1 AT ! COMM& ( AU?ORITIES :OM M5 HAVE BE5 9SPIR$ TO HONOR & CONSID] SACR$1 PASS )\T AFFECT+ M5'S S\LS8 

,! O!R DAY ,I READ A NEWSPAP] REPORT AB\T SOME UN=TUNATE GOV]NOR-G5]AL :O ISSU$ AN $ICT EXPRESS+ HIS PRAISE & APPROVAL = TWO 'F9E Y\NG *APS'1 AS HE CALL$ !M1 :O HAD %OT AN UN>M$ PRISON] AS HE LEAP$ (F A C>T & TRI$ TO ESCAPE2 HE REW>D$ !M ) TW5TY-FIVE RUBLES EA*4 ,I DID NOT BELIEVE ?IS DREADFUL /ORY ( ! GOV]NOR'S BEHAVIOR & WROTE TO ! $ITOR ( ! NEWSPAP] ASK+ HIM TO CONFIRM IT4 ,I WAS S5T ! ORIG9AL COPY ( ! $ICT1 & IT WAS EXPLA9$ TO ME ?AT ?IS SORT ( PRAISE = MURD] WAS AN EV]YDAY ?+ & ?AT ! MO/ HI<-RANK+ P]SONAGES UTT]$ !SE APPROBATIONS4 

,CAN !SE SORT ( WORDS & DE$S REALLY DISAPPE> )\T TRACE8 ,?\<TS & FEEL+ SO P]V]T$ & SO AUDACI\SLY EXPRESS$ CANNOT BUT LEAVE T]RIBLE TRACES ( CORRUPTION1 IMMORALITY & CRUELTY 9 ! HE>TS ( ?OSE :O P>TICIPATE 9 !M & READ SU* ORD]S4 ,!SE DE$S & 9JUNCTIONS MU/ MAKE PEOPLE FEEL DI/RU/ & CONTEMPT = ?OSE :O PRESCRIBE SU* T]RIBLE DE$S1 SO (F5SIVE TO ! HUMAN CONSCI5CE1 & PRAISE & REW>D !M4 ,SO ?AT IF ?\S&S >E EXECUT$1 H[ MANY T5S ( ?\S&S1 :O HAVE 9 ONE WAY OR ANO!R TAK5 P>T 9 !SE DE$S1 HAVE BE5 P]V]T$ BY ?IS P>TICIPATION & DEPRIV$ ( ! LA/ REMNANTS ( !IR RELIGI\S & MORAL PR9CIPLES8 ,HAVE !Y NOT BE5 MADE READY1 IF NOT YET TO HATE1 !N TO DESPISE ?OSE :O =CE !M TO P]=M !SE EVIL DE$S1 & TO COMMIT AGA9/ !M ! V]Y SAME DE$S AT ! FIR/ OPPORTUNITY8 

,! NEWSPAP] REPORTS1 PR9T$ DAILY & READ BY MILLIONS1 ON ! NUMB] ( PEOPLE EXECUT$ & S5T5C$ TO DEA?1 HAVE AN EFFECT SIMIL> TO NEWS ( *ANGES 9 ! WEA!R - SOME?+ ?AT IS B\ND TO *ANGE CONT9UALLY1 BY ! DAY4 ,EV5 IF ?OSE :O READ ?IS SORT ( NEWS EV]Y DAY DO NOT ASK !MSELVES H[ TO RECONCILE SU* DE$S1 COMMITT$ UND] ORD]S FROM ! HI<E/ AU?ORITIES )1 LET US SAY1 NOT ! ,GOSPELS1 BUT ! SIX? COMM&M5T ( ,MOSES1 AT LEA/ ! CONTRADICTIONS MU/ EVOKE CONTEMPT 9 !IR HE>TS = ! COMM&M5TS1 = RELIGION 9 G5]AL1 & = ! AU?ORITIES :O P]=M DE$S SO EVID5TLY CONTR>Y TO BO? ! RELIGI\S LAWS & CONSCI5CE4 

,SURELY IT IS APP>5T ?AT EVIL DE$S COMMITT$ BY ! GOV]N+ P[]S 9 ORD] TO RID !MSELVES ( !IR VISIBLE 5EMIES GA!R TWICE OR EV5 T5 TIMES AS MANY 9VISIBLE 5EMIES1 :O >E F> MORE ANGRY4 

,ONE W\LD ?9K IT W]E OBVI\S TO EV]Y ?9K+ P]SON ?AT SU* BEHAVIOR FROM ! GOV]NM5T CANNOT IMPROVE ! SITUATION4 ,IT %\LD BE OBVI\S NOT ONLY TO \TSID]S BUT TO ! RUL]S !MSELVES4 ,!Y MU/ SEE ! EVID5T FUTILITY ( :AT !Y >E DO+1 & !Y MU/ SEE ! CRIM9ALITY ( IT4 ,!Y MU/ SEE ?IS1 = ,*RI/'S TEA*+ ( LOVE = ONE'S 5EMY1 SO C>EFULLY CONCEAL$ BY ?OSE :O LIVE ACCORD+ TO VIOL5CE1 HAS P5ETRAT$ ! CONSCI\SNESS ( ! PEOPLE ( ! ,*RI/IAN WORLD1 ALBEIT NOT 9 ! 5TIRETY ( ITS COMPLETE & REAL MEAN+4 ,I BELIEVE ,I AM NOT MI/AK5 9 SAY+ ?AT ?IS TEA*+ HAS BE5 P>TICUL>LY KE5LY ADOPT$ BY ! SIMPLE ,RUSSIAN WORK+ PEOPLE1 :OM ! GOV]NM5T >E N[ SO FI]CELY P]V]T+4 

,EV5 IF ,M>CUS ,AURELIUS C\LD1 DESPITE HIS G5TL5ESS & WISDOM1 CONDUCT W>S & CONDEMN PEOPLE TO DEA? ) A CLE> CONSCI5CE1 ! PEOPLE ( TODAY'S ,*RI/IAN WORLD CAN NO LONG] DO SO )\T AN 9N] AW>5ESS ( !IR GUILT4 ,NO MATT] :AT HYPOCRITICAL & /UPID ,HAGUE CONF]5CES & CONDITIONAL PUNI%M5TS >E 9V5T$1 ALL !SE SUP]FICIAL ABSURDITIES NOT ONLY FAIL TO CONCEAL !IR CRIMES1 BUT ON ! CONTR>Y1 PO9T TO ! FACT ?AT !SE M5 ALREADY KN[ !MSELVES ?AT :AT !Y >E DO+ IS WRONG4 ,H[EV] MU* !Y MAY ASSURE !MSELVES & O!RS ?AT V>I\S HI<] CONSID]ATIONS DICTATE !SE DREADFUL VIOLATIONS ( ALL HUMAN & DIV9E LAWS1 :I* >E CONT9UALLY COMMITT$1 !Y CANNOT HIDE1 EI!R FROM !MSELVES OR FROM DEC5T PEOPLE1 ! UTT] CRIM9ALITY1 IMMORALITY & BAS5ESS ( !IR CONDUCT4 ,= N[ADAYS EV]YONE KN[S ?AT MURD] ( :ATEV] K9D IS VILE1 CRIM9AL & WRONG2 ALL ! CZ>S1 M9I/]S & G5]ALS KN[ ?IS1 H[EV] MU* !Y HIDE BEH9D SOME 9V5T$ SUP]IOR CONSID]ATIONS4 

,IT IS ! SAME ) REVOLUTION>IES ( :ATEV] P>TY1 IF !Y P]MIT MURD] = ! ATTA9M5T ( !IR AIMS4 ,NO MATT] :AT !Y SAY AB\T ! FACT ?AT :5 P[] IS 9 !IR H&S !Y WILL HAVE NO USE = ! VIOL5T MEANS !Y N[ EMPLOY1 !IR CRIMES >E JU/ AS IMMORAL & CRUEL AS ! ACTIVITIES ( ! GOV]NM5T4 ,& !Y !RE=E LEAD TO ! SAME AWFUL CONSEQU5CES AS DO ! EVIL-DO+S ( ! GOV]NM5T3 ! ANIMOSITY1 BE/IALIZATION & CORRUPTION ( ! PEOPLE4 

,!IR ACTIVITY ONLY DIFF]S 9 ?IS 7:I* IS :Y IT APPE>S LESS CRIM9AL71 ?AT ! FUTILITY ( ! ACTIVITIES ( ! GOV]NM5T 9 P[] IS APP>5T1 :ILE ! ACTIVITY ( ! REVOLUTION>IES - :I* IS MANIFE/$ = ! MO/ P>T 9 !ORY & ONLY OCCASIONALLY PUT 9TO PRACTICE DUR+ REVOLUTIONS1 SU* AS WE HAVE N[ 9 ,RUSSIA - IS NOT SO EVID5T4 

,! MEANS & ! ME?OD ( /RUGGLE ( BO? SIDES >E EQUALLY ALI5 TO ! HUMAN S\L & TO ! T5ETS ( ! ,*RI/IAN TEA*+4 ,BO? EMBITT] PEOPLE1 LEAD+ !M TO EXTREME LEVELS ( IRRATIONALITY & BRUTALITY1 :ILE FAIL+ TO ATTA9 ! DECL>$ AIM1 & DI/ANC+ O!RS FROM ANY *ANCE ( ATTA9+ IT4 

,! POSITION & ! ACTIVITY ( BO? W>R+ P>TIES - ! GOV]NM5T & ! REVOLUTION>IES - H]E 9 ,RUSSIA1 AS 9 ! RE/ ( ! WORLD1 ) !IR VIOL5T ME?ODS ( IMPROV+ HUMAN EXI/5CE1 IS SIMIL> TO ?AT ( PEOPLE :O1 9 ORD] TO W>M !MSELVES1 BREAK D[N ! WALLS ( ! H\SE !Y LIVE 9 & *OP IT UP = FIREWOOD4 

  

,FROM 3 ,WIKIS\RCE4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #aig 3 ,APP5DIX TO ,*APT] #c -- ,PUBLICATION4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/