,! ,LOGIC ( ,COMMUNISM 

#ahhg 

,PEOPLE 3 

,$ITOR 3 ,*>LOTTE ,WILSON 

,TAGS 3 PRODUCT ( A MAN'S [N LABOR1 PRODUCT1 LABOR1 WEAL?1 WORK1 SOCIALISM1 WORK]1 SOCIAL1 OPPORTUNITIES1 SOCIALI/4 

,TEXT 3 

  

,PHOTO BY ,D,F,I,D1,C,C ,B,Y-,S,A ,LIC5SE ,IT IS A COMMON CANT ) MANY ( ?OSE :O >E ON ! ROAD TO ,SOCIALISM ?AT 9 ! R5OVAT$ ORD] :I* !Y CONTEMPLATE1 EA* WORK] %ALL 5JOY ! FULL FRUITS ( HIS [N LABOR4 7,EV5 \R COMRADES ( ! ,SOCIALI/ ,LEAGUE1 :ILE PREA*+ ON ONE PAGE ( ! ,COMMONWEAL PURE ,COMMUNI/ DOCTR9E1 HAVE ON O!RS HELD \T ?IS PROMISE TO ! PROLET>IAT74 ,IT IS A PROMISE ?AT 9 REALITY IS MEAN+LESS1 & 9 ! MEAN+ COMMONLY ATTA*$ TO IT1 DELUSIVE & IMPOSSIBLE TO BE FULFILL$4 ,?AT ! PHRASE %\LD BE US$ IS 9TELLIGIBLE 5\<4 ,WE *>GE AGA9/ ! PREVAIL+ SOCIAL SY/EM ?AT BY IT ! WORK]S >E ROBB$ ( ! WEAL? :I* !Y PRODUCE1 BY ! EXACTION ( R5TS = ! OPPORTUNITIES ( WORK+4 ,& IT SEEMS M]ELY RE/AT+ ! SAME TRU? TO SAY ?AT :5 WE HAVE DE/ROY$ ?AT SY/EM1 EA* MAN %ALL REAP ! FULL PRODUCT ( HIS [N ACTIVITY4 ,IT IS NECESS>Y TO RECOGNIZE CLE>LY ?AT ! PROPOSITION CANNOT BE CONNECT$ 9 ?IS MANN]1 & ?AT ,SOCIALISM CANNOT1 IF IT W\LD1 MAKE ANY SU* PROMISE4 

,IT IS ASSUM$ BY ?OSE :O DO CONFID5TLY MAKE IT1 ?AT1 ONCE ! LAW-SUPPORT$ MONOPOLY ( ! MAT]IAL 9/RUM5TS ( PRODUCTION IS DONE AWAY1 EV]Y MAN WILL RECEIVE FROM ,SOCIETY A ME$ ( WEAL? PROPORTIONAL TO ! USEFULNESS ( HIS WORK4 ,CALL+ !MSELVES ,SOCIALI/S1 !Y SPEAK AS ?\< ?IS W]E ! FULL CONT5T ( ,SOCIALISM1 & \R AIM W]E NO MORE ?AN ! REMOVAL ( C]TA9 >TIFICIALLY PRIVILEG$ CLASSES ( PILLAG]S1 9 ORD] ?AT ! %>ES 9 ! GAME ( GRAB MAY !NCE=W>D BE DIVID$ BY NATURAL ABILITIES & OPPORTUNITIES ALONE4 7,IF ?IS /ATEM5T BE JUDG$ UNFAIR1 IT NE$ NOT BE PRESS$74 ,BUT ! REAL WEAKNESS ( ! POSITION WE W\LD CRITICIZE LIES MORE G5]ALLY 9 ! ASSUMPTION ?AT 9 A SOCIALIZ$ COMMUNITY1 & CONSI/5TLY ) ,SOCIALI/ PR9CIPLES1 ! VALUE ( A MAN'S WORK CAN BE APPRAIS$ & ! ACTUAL PRODUCT ( ! ACTIVITY ( 9DIVIDUALS ASSIGN$ TO !M1 9 SOME MANN] ANALOG\S TO ! REMUN]ATION ( DIFF]5T SECTIONS ( ! PROLET>IAT AT ! PRES5T TIME4 

,WE SPEAK1 9 ! LANGUAGE ( ! PREVAIL+ 9DU/RIAL SY/EM1 ( ! WORK ( ONE AS MORE VALUABLE ?AN ?AT ( ANO!R4 ,BUT AS ,SOCIALI/S WE CAN NEV] =GET ?AT ! 0VALUE0 ( SU* S]VICES IS & CAN BE APPRAIS$ ONLY BY COMPETITION4 ,IF WE ADMIT ! MO/ ELEM5T>Y & FUNDAM5TAL PR9CIPLE ( ,SOCIALISM1 WE LEAVE \RSELVES NO P[] ( CLAIM+ ?AT !RE IS ANY JU/IFICATION1 A PRIORI1 = ! MORE ABLE WORK] RECEIV+ A MORE AMPLE REMUN]ATION4 ,= WE RECOGNIZE1 FIR/LY1 ?AT EV]Y MAN'S P[]S = USEFUL WORK >E VE/$ 9 HIM BY PURE ACCID5T4 ,EA* MAN'S ABILITIES1 ( BRA9 OR S9EW1 >E ! APEX ( A MILLION CONV]G+ ?READS ( PHYSICAL & SOCIAL EVOLUTION1 & B[ %\LD BE BE 5TITL$ MORE ?AN HIS BRO!R OR SI/]1 OR ANY MAN OR WOMAN ( HIS NATION1 TO BE CLO!D 9 PURPLE & F9E L95 & F>E SUMPTU\SLY :ILE O!RS GO B>E & HUNGRY1 M]ELY = HIS EX]CISE ( ?IS DEPOSIT ( HUMAN 5]GY4 ,NAY1 TRANSF] HIM1 ABILITY & ALL1 FROM HIS PRES5T SOCIAL 5VIRONM5T1 & HE MAY BE UNABLE TO PRODUCE ANY?+ ?AT C\LD BE CALL$ WEAL? AT ALL1 EI!R = HIS [N NE$S OR = O!R'S SATISFACTION4 ,ALL HIS P[]S >E DUE TO ,SOCIETY1 & ALL HIS OPPORTUNITIES = !IR EX]CISE4 ,:O1 !N1 SAVE ,SOCIETY ITSELF1 HAS ANY CLAIM ( RI<T TO ! PRODUCT ( ?OSE P[]S & OPPORTUNITIES8 

,SECONDLY1 WE REMEMB] ?AT 9 DEVELOP$ SOCIETIES1 NO MAN'S WEAL? IS ! ACTUAL PRODUCT ( HIS [N ACTIVITY4 ,! DIVISION ( LABOR HAS 5D$ ?AT4 ,:ATEV] A WORK] 9 A MOD]N COMMUNITY MAY BE PRODUC+1 HIS WEAL? IS ! AM\NT ( NECESS>IES-COM=TS1 OR ADVANTAGES :I* LIE RECEIVES 9 EX*ANGE1 ,BUT ! FACT ?AT HE CAN EX*ANGE ! PRODUCT ( HIS LABOR = ANY?+ DEP5DS 5TIRELY ON ! UTILITY ( ?AT LABOR = O!RS4 ,! TAILOR MAY />VE 9 A C\NTRY :]E CLO!S >E UNKN[N1 AS ! CLO?-MAK] MAY />VE 9 ,5GL& IF ! FA%ION *ANGES4 ,EA* MAN'S P[] TO PRODUCE 0WEAL?0 DEP5DS UPON ! WANTS ( HIS FELL[S4 

,SEE+ !N1 H[ EA* MAN'S ABILITY IS PURELY RELATIVE1 H[ EA* DEP5DS UPON HIS FELL[S = HIS [N EFFICI5CY1 H[ EV]Y G5]ATION [ES MORE ?AN ! LA/ TO ALL ?AT HAVE PREC$$ IT1 WE >E =C$ IRRESI/IBLY TO ! CONCLUSION ?AT ALL LABOR MU/ BE RECOGNIZ$ AS ESS5TIALLY GRATUIT\S1 & ?AT IT IS IMPOSSIBLE BY ANY CONSID]ATIONS ( M]IT OR ( NATURAL PROPRIETY TO ASSIGN A HI<] WAGE TO ONE WILL+ WORK] ?AN TO ANO!R4 

,H[ IS IT ?AT ?OSE :O SPEAK ( 0! PRODUCT ( A MAN'S [N LABOR0 NEV] GO FUR!R1 & TRY TO DEF9E :AT ! PRODUCT ( A MAN'S 0[N0 LABOR IS8 ,! CONT5TION ( ,SOCIALISM IS ?AT 9 NO CIRCUM/ANCES IS IT POSSIBLE TO DO ?IS4 ,AS BETWE5 C[ORK]S 9 ! SAME 9DU/RY1 ! DIRECTOR & ! EXECUTOR ( DIRECTIONS1 ! L&1 ! 9/RUM5TS & MA*9ES1 ! PRES5T WORK]S & ! G5]ATIONS \T ( :OM !Y & !IR 9DU/RY & !IR NATION HAVE BE5 UNFOLD$1 :O CAN SIFT & SEP>ATE ! CONTRIBUTION TO ! PRODUCT ( EA* ( ! ELEM5TS ASSI/+8 ,:]E ! CROP ( ONE FIELD HAS FAIL$ ?R\< DR\<T1 & ?AT ( ! NEI<BOR HAS HAD RA9 9 SEASON1 :AT IS ! PRODUCT ( ! LABOR] :]E NO CROP HAS RIP5$1 & ( HIM :O HAS REAP$ ! ABUNDANT H>VE/8 

,!RE IS NO MEANS ( JUDG+ ON ! PREMISES ATTA9ABLE1 & ! ONLY GUIDE = ! DI/RIBUTION ( ! PRODUCTS ?AT REMA9S IS ?AT EQUALITY %\LD BE AIM$ AT1 & EQUALITY NOT ( QUANTITY ( GOODS BUT ( SATISFACTION !REFROM1 = ?US WILL ! :OLE AM\NT ( SATISFACTION BE GREATE/ = ! COMMUNITY4 ,:5 A ROAN IS WILL+ TO WORK FROM SOCIAL MOTIVES1 HE WILL DELI<T TO WORK TO HIS FULL /R5G?1 & HIS REW>D CANNOT BE MET$ 9 MAT]IAL WEAL?4 ,FROM ! ,SOCIALI/ PO9T ( VIEW1 = MORALIZ$1 DEVELOP$1 SOCIALIZ$ HUMAN BE+S1 !RE CAN BE BUT ONE RULE = WORK & WAGES-- 

0,FROM EA* ACCORD+ TO HIS ABILITY1  

,TO EA* ACCORD+ TO HIS NE$S40 

 ,S4,O4 

,FRE$OM3 ,A ,J\RNAL ( ,AN>*I/ ,SOCIALISM 

,VOL4 #a -- ,NO4 #a1 

,J,U,L,Y1 #ahhg 

,S\RCE3 HTTP3_/_/DW>DMAC4PITZ]4$U_/AN>*I/.->*IVES_/J\RNALS_/FRE$OM_/FRE$OM#a.-#a4HTML 

,FROM 3 ,AN>*Y,>*IVES4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,JULY #a1 #ahhg 3 ,! ,LOGIC ( ,COMMUNISM -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,APRIL #b#b1 #bah 3 ,! ,LOGIC ( ,COMMUNISM -- ,ADD$4 
,DECEMB] #c1 #bba 3 ,! ,LOGIC ( ,COMMUNISM -- ,UPDAT$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/