,A ,GREAT ,9IQUITY 

#aie 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,LEO ,TOL/OY 

,TEXT 3 

,RUSSIA IS LIV+ ?R\< AN IMPORTANT TIME DE/9$ TO HAVE 5ORM\S RESULTS4 

,! PROXIMITY & 9EVITABL5ESS ( ! APPROA*+ *ANGE IS1 AS 9DE$ IS ALWAYS ! CASE1 ESPECIALLY KE5LY FELT BY ?OSE CLASSES (  
SOCIETY :O1 BY !IR POSITION1 >E FREE FROM ! NECESSITY ( PHYSICAL LABOR ABSORB+ ALL !IR TIME & P[]1 & !RE=E HAVE ! POSSIBILITY ( OCCUPY+ !MSELVES ) POLITICAL QUE/IONS4 ,!SE M5--! NOBLES1 M]*ANTS1 ,GOV]NM5T (FICIALS1 DOCTORS1 5G9E]S1 PR(ESSORS1 TEA*]S1 >TI/S1 /UD5TS1 ADVOCATES1 *IEFLY T[NSPEOPLE1 ! SO-CALL$ 09TELLECTUALS0-->E N[ 9 ,RUSSIA DIRECT+ ! MOVEM5T :I* IS TAK+ PLACE1 & !Y DEVOTE ALL !IR P[]S TO  
! ALT]ATION ( ! EXI/+ POLITICAL ORD]1 & TO REPLAC+ IT BY ANO!R REG>D$ BY ?IS OR ?AT P>TY AS ! MO/ EXP$I5T & LIKELY TO 5SURE ! LIB]TY & WELF>E ( ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE4 ,!SE M51 CONT9UALLY SUFF]+ FROM EV]Y K9D ( RE/RICTION & CO]CION ON ! P>T ( ! ,GOV]NM5T1 FROM >BITR>Y EXILE1 9C>C]ATIONS1 PROHIBITION ( MEET+S1 PROHIBITION ( BOOKS1 NEWSPAP]S1 /RIKES1 UNIONS--FROM ! LIMITATION ( ! RI<TS ( V>I\S NATIONALITIES1 & AT ! SAME TIME LIV+ A LIFE COMPLETELY E/RANG$ FROM ! MAJORITY ( ! ,RUSSIAN AGRICULTURAL PEOPLE1 NATURALLY SEE 9 !SE RE/RICTIONS ! *IEF EVIL1 & 9 ! LIB]ATION FROM !M ! *IEF WELF>E1 ( ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE4 

 ,?US ?9K ! ,LIB]ALS4 ,SO ALSO ?9K ! ,SOCIAL ,DEMOCRATS1 :O HOPE1 ?R\< POPUL> REPRES5TATION1 BY ! AID ( ,/ATE P[] TO REALIZE A NEW SOCIAL ORD] 9 ACCORDANCE ) !IR !ORY4 ,SO ALSO ?9K ! REVOLUTION>IES1 HOP+1 BY SUB/ITUT+ A NEW ,GOV]NM5T = ! EXI/+ ONE1 TO E/ABLI% LAWS 5SUR+ ! GREATE/ FRE$OM & WELF>E ( ! :OLE PEOPLE4 

,YET ONE NE$ ONLY = A TIME FREE ONESELF FROM ! IDEA :I* HAS TAK5 ROOT AMONG \R 9TELLECTUALS1 ?AT ! WORK N[ BE=E ,RUSSIA IS ! 9TRODUCTION 9TO \R C\NTRY ( ?OSE SAME =MS ( POLITICAL LIFE :I* HAVE BE5 9TRODUC$ 9TO ,EUROPE & ,AM]ICA1 & >E SUPPOS$ TO  
5SURE ! LIB]TY & WELF>E ( ALL ! CITIZ5S--& TO SIMPLY ?9K ( :AT IS MORALLY WRONG 9 \R LIFE1 9 ORD] TO SEE QUITE CLE>LY ?AT ! *IEF EVIL FROM :I* ! :OLE ( ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE >E UNCEAS+LY & CRUELLY SUFF]+ AN EVIL ( :I* !Y >E KE5LY CONSCI\S & TO :I* !Y CONT9UALLY PO9T--CANNOT BE REMOV$ BY ANY POLITICAL RE=MS1 JU/ AS IT IS NOT UP TO ! PRES5T TIME REMOV$ BY ANY ( ! POLITICAL RE=MS ( ,EUROPE & ,AM]ICA4 ,?IS EVIL--! FUNDAM5TAL EVIL FROM :I* ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE1 AS WELL AS ! PEOPLES ( ,EUROPE & ,AM]ICA1 >E SUFF]+--IS ! FACT ?AT ! MAJORITY ( ! PEOPLE >E DEPRIV$ ( ! 9DISPUTABLE NATURAL RI<T ( EV]Y MAN TO USE A PORTION ( ! L& ON :I* HE WAS BORN4 ,IT IS SUFFICI5T TO UND]/& ALL ! CRIM9ALITY1 ! S9FULNESS ( ! SITUATION 9 ?IS RESPECT1 9 ORD] TO UND]/& ?AT UNTIL ?IS ATROCITY1 CONT9UALLY BE+ COMMITT$ BY ! [N]S ( ! L&1 %ALL CEASE1 NO POLITICAL RE=MS WILL GIVE FRE$OM & WELF>E TO ! PEOPLE1 BUT ?AT1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 ONLY ! EMANCIPATION ( ! MAJORITY ( ! PEOPLE FROM ?AT L& SLAV]Y 9 :I* !Y >E N[ HELD CAN R5D] POLITICAL RE=MS--NOT A PLAY?+ & A TOOL = P]SONAL AIMS 9 ! H&S ( POLITICIANS--BUT ! REAL EXPRESSION ( ! WILL ( ! PEOPLE4 

,IT IS ?IS ?\<T :I* ,I WI% TO COMMUNICATE 9 ?IS >TICLE TO ?OSE :O1 AT ! PRES5T IMPORTANT MOM5T = ,RUSSIA1 DESIRE TO S]VE NOT1 !IR P]SONAL AIMS1 BUT ! TRUE WELF>E ( ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE4 

  

,I4 

,! O!R DAY ,I WAS WALK+ ALONG ! HI< ROAD TO ,TULA4 ,IT WAS ON ! ,SATURDAY ( ,HOLY ,WEEK2 ! PEOPLE W]E DRIV+ TO M>KET 9 L9ES ( C>TS1 ) CALVES1 H5S1 HORSES1 C[S 7SOME ( ! C[S W]E BE+ CONVEY$ 9 ! C>TS1 SO />V$ W]E !Y74 ,A WR9KL$ OLD WOMAN WAS LEAD+ A LEAN1 SICKLY C[4 ,I KNEW ! OLD WOMAN1 & ASK$ H] :Y %E WAS LEAD+ ! C[4 

0,%E'S )\T MILK10 SAID ! WOMAN4 0,I \<T TO SELL H] & BUY ONE ) MILK4 ,LIKELY ,I'LL HAVE TO ADD T5 RUBLES1 BUT ,I HAVE ONLY FIVE4 ,:]E %ALL ,I TAKE IT8 ,DUR+ ! W9T] WE HAVE HAD TO SP5D EI<TE5 RUBLES ON FL\R1 & WE'VE ONLY GOT ONE BREAD-W9N]4 ,I LIVE ALONE ) MY DAU<T]-9-LAW & F\R GR&*ILDR52 MY SON IS H\SE-PORT] 9 T[N40 

0,:Y DOESN'T Y\R SON LIVE AT HOME80 ,I ASK$4 

0,HE'S NO?+ TO WORK ON4 ,:AT'S \R L&8 ,JU/ 5\< = ,KVAS4.<#a.> 

,A PEASANT W5T TRAMP+ ALONG1 ?9 & PALE1 HIS TR\S]S BESPATT]$ ) M9E CLAY4 

0,:AT BUS9ESS 9 T[N80 ,I ASK$4 

0,TO BUY A HORSE2 IT'S TIME TO PL[ & ,I HAV5'T GOT ONE4 ,BUT !Y SAY HORSES >E DE>40 

0,:AT PRICE DO Y\ WANT TO GIVE80 

 0,WELL1 ACCORD+ TO :AT ,I HAVE40 

0,H[ MU* HAVE Y\80 

0,I'VE SCRAP$ TOGE!R FIFTE5 RUBLES4.<#b.> ,BUT :AT CAN Y\ BUY AT ! PRES5T TIME = FIFTE5 RUBLES8 

0,A KNACK]'S BEA/10 PUT 9 ANO!R PEASANT4 

0,9 :OSE M9E DO Y\ WORK80 ,I ASK$1 GLANC+ AT HIS TR\S]S /RET*$ AT ! KNEE & COLOR$ ) R$ CLAY4 

0,9 ,KOM>(F'S1 ,IVAN ,KOM>(FS40 

0,:Y HAVE Y\ MADE SO LITTLE80 

0,OH1 ,I WAS WORK+ = HALF PR(IT40 

0,H[ MU* DID Y\ E>N80 ,I ASK$4 

0,TWO RUBLES A WEEK OR EV5 LESS4 ,:AT CAN ONE DO8 ,BREAD DIDN'T LA/ TILL ,*RI/MAS4 ,WE CAN'T BUY 5\<40 

,A LITTLE FUR!R1 A Y\NG PEASANT WAS LEAD+ A SLEEK1 WELL F$ HORSE TO SELL4 

0,NICE HORSE10 SAID ,I4 

0,C\LDN'T BE BETT]10 SAID HE1 ?9K+ ME A BUY]4 0,GOOD = PL[+ & DRIV+40 

0,!N :Y DO Y\ SELL IT80 

0,I CAN'T USE IT4 ,I'VE ONLY TWO ALLOTM5TS4 ,I CAN MANAGE !M ) ONE HORSE4 ,I'VE KEPT !M BO? OV] ! W9T]1 & ,I'M SORRY 5\< = IT4 ,! CATTLE HAVE EAT5 UP EV]Y?+1 & WE WANT MONEY TO PAY ! R5T40 

0,FROM :OM DO Y\ R5T80 

0,FROM ,M>IA ,IVANOVNA2 ?ANKS BE TO H]1 %E LET US HAVE IT4 ,O!RWISE IT W\LD HAVE BE5 ! 5D ( US40 

0,:AT >E ! T]MS80 

0,%E FLEECES US ( F\RTE5 RUBLES4 ,BUT :]E ELSE CAN WE GO8 ,SO WE TAKE IT40 

,A WOMAN PASS$ DRIV+ ALONG ) A BOY WE>+ A LITTLE CAP4 ,%E KNEW ME1 CLAMB]$ \T1 & (F]$ ME H] BOY = S]VICE4 ,! BOY IS QUITE A T9Y FELL[ ) QUICK1 9TELLIG5T EYES4 

,HE LOOKS SMALL1 BUT HE CAN DO EV]Y?+10 %E SAYS4 

0,BUT :Y DO Y\ HIRE \T SU* A LITTLE ONE80 

0,WELL1 SIR1 AT LEA/ IT'LL BE ONE M\? LESS TO FE$4 ,I HAVE F\R BESIDES MYSELF1 & ONLY ONE ALLOTM5T4 ,GOD KN[S1 WE'VE NO?+ TO EAT4 ,!Y ASK = BREAD & ,I'VE NONE TO GIVE !M40 

,) :OMSOEV] ONE TALKS1 ALL COMPLA9 ( !IR WANT & ALL SIMIL>LY FROM ONE SIDE OR ANO!R COME BACK TO ! SOLE REASON4 ,!RE IS 9SUFFICI5T BREAD1 & BREAD IS 9SUFFICI5T BECAUSE !RE IS NO L&4 

,!SE MAY BE M]E CASUAL MEET+S ON ! ROAD2 BUT CROSS ALL ,RUSSIA1 ALL ITS PEASANT WORLD1 & ONE MAY OBS]VE ALL ! DREADFUL CALAMITIES & SUFF]+S :I* PROCE$ FROM ! OBVI\S CAUSE ?AT ! AGRICULTURAL MASSES >E DEPRIV$ ( L&4 ,HALF ! ,RUSSIAN PEASANTRY LIVE SO ?AT = !M ! QUE/ION IS NOT H[ TO IMPROVE !IR POSITION1 BUT ONLY H[ NOT TO DIE ( HUNG]1 !Y & !IR FAMILIES1 & ?IS ONLY BECAUSE !Y HAVE NO L&4 

,TRAV]SE ALL ,RUSSIA & ASK ALL ! WORK+ PEOPLE :Y !IR LIFE IS H>D1 :AT !Y WANT1 & ALL ( !M ) ONE VOICE WILL SAY ONE & ! SAME ?+1 ?AT :I* !Y UNCEAS+LY DESIRE & EXPECT1 & = :I* !Y UNCEAS+LY HOPE1 ( :I* !Y UNCEAS+LY ?9K4 

,!Y CANNOT HELP ?9K+ & FEEL+ ?IS1 =1 AP>T FROM ! *IEF ?+1 ! 9SUFFICI5CY ( L& = ! MA9T5ANCE ( MO/ ( !M1 !Y CANNOT BUT FEEL !MSELVES ! SLAVES ( ! L&$ G5TRY1 & M]*ANTS1 & L&[N]S1 :OSE E/ATES HAVE SURR\ND$ !IR SMALL 9SUFFICI5T ALLOTM5TS1 & !Y CANNOT BUT ?9K & FEEL ?IS--= EV]Y M9UTE1 = A BAG ( GRASS1 = A H&FUL ( FUEL1 )\T :I* !Y CANNOT LIVE1 = A HORSE GONE A/RAY FROM !IR L& ON TO ! L&LORD'S1 !Y P]PETUALLY SUFF] F9ES1 BL[S1 HUMILIATION4 

,ONCE1 AS ,I WAS GO+ ALONG ! ROAD4 ,I 5T]$ 9TO CONV]SATION ) A BL9D PEASANT BEGG>4 ,RECOGNIZ+ 9 ME FROM MY CONV]SATION A LIT]ATE  
MAN :O READ ! PAP]S1 BUT NOT TAK+ ME = A G5TLEMAN1 HE SUDD5LY /OPP$ & GRAVELY ASK$3 0,WELL1 & IS !RE ANY RUMOR80 

,I ASK$1 0,AB\T :AT80 

0,:Y1 AB\T ! G5TRY'S L&40 

,I SAID ,I HAD HE>D NO?+4 ,! BL9D MAN %OOK HIS HEAD & DIDN'T ASK ME ANY?+ MORE4 

0,WELL1 :AT DO !Y SAY AB\T ! L&80 ,I ASK$ A %ORT TIME AGO ( A =M] PUPIL ( M9E1 A RI*1 /EADY1 & 9TELLIG5T LIT]ATE PEASANT4 

0,IT IS TRUE ! PEOPLE PRATTLE40 

0,& Y\ Y\RSELF1 :AT DO Y\ ?9K80 

0,WELL1 IT'LL PROBABLY COME OV] TO US10 HE SAID4 

,( ALL EV5TS :I* >E TAK+ PLACE1 ?IS ALONE IS IMPORTANT & 9T]E/+ TO ! :OLE PEOPLE4 ,& !Y BELIEVE1 & CANNOT BUT BELIEVE1 ?AT IT WILL 0COME OV]40 

,!Y CANNOT BUT BELIEVE ?IS1 BECAUSE IT IS CLE> TO !M ?AT A MULTIPLY+ PEOPLE LIV+ BY AGRICULTURE CANNOT CONT9UE TO EXI/ :5 ONLY A SMALL PORTION ( ! L& IS LEFT !M FROM :I* !Y MU/ FE$ !MSELVES & ALL ! P>ASITES :O HAVE FA/5$ ON TO !M & >E CRAWL+ AB\T !M4 

  

,I,I4 

0,:AT IS MAN80 SAYS ,H5RY ,GEORGE 9 ONE ( HIS SPEE*ES4 

0,9 ! FIR/ PLACE1 HE IS AN ANIMAL1 A L& ANIMAL :O CANNOT LIVE )\T L&4 ,ALL ?AT MAN PRODUCES COMES FROM ! L&2 ALL PRODUCTIVE LABOR1 9 ! F9AL ANALYSIS1 CONSI/S 9 WORK+ UP L&1 OR MAT]IALS DRAWN FROM L&1 9TO SU* =MS AS FIT !M = ! SATISFACTION ( HUMAN WANTS & DESIRES4 ,:Y1 MAN'S V]Y BODY IS DRAWN FROM ! L&4 ,*ILDR5 ( ! SOIL1 WE COME FROM ! L&1 & TO ! L& WE MU/ RETURN4 ,TAKE AWAY FROM MAN ALL ?AT BELONGS TO ! L&1 & :AT 
HAVE Y\ BUT A DISEMBODI$ SPIRIT8 ,!RE=E HE :O HOLDS ! L& ON :I* & FROM :I* ANO!R MAN MU/ LIVE IS ?AT MAN'S MA/]1 & ! MAN IS HIS SLAVE4 ,! MAN :O HOLDS ! L& ON :I* ,I MU/ LIVE CAN COMM& ME TO LIFE OR TO DEA? JU/ AS ABSOLUTELY AS ?\< ,I W]E HIS *ATTEL4 ,TALK AB\T ABOLI%+ SLAV]Y--WE HAVE NOT ABOLI%$ SLAV]Y2 WE HAVE ONLY ABOLI%$ ONE RUDE =M ( IT1 *ATTEL SLAV]Y4 ,!RE IS A DEEP] & MORE 9SIDI\S =M1 A MORE CURS$ =M YET BE=E US1 TO ABOLI%1 9 ?IS 9DU/RIAL SLAV]Y ?AT MAKES A MAN A VIRTUAL SLAVE1 :ILE TAUNT+ HIM & MOCK+ HIM 9 ! NAME ( FRE$OM40.<#c.> 

,DID Y\ EV] ?9K10 SAYS ,H5RY ,GEORGE 9 ANO!R P>T ( ! SAME SPEE*1 0( ! UTT] ABSURDITY & /RANG5ESS ( ! FACT ?AT ALL OV] ! CIVILIZ$ WORLD ! WORK+ CLASSES >E ! POOR CLASSES8 ,?9K = A MOM5T H[ IT W\LD /RIKE A RATIONAL BE+ :O HAD NEV] BE5 ON ! E>? BE=E IF SU* AN 9TELLIG5CE C\LD COME D[N1 & Y\ W]E TO EXPLA9 TO HIM H[ WE LIVE ON E>?1 H[ H\SES & FOOD & CLO?+ & ALL ! MANY ?+S WE NE$ W]E ALL PRODUC$ BY WORK1 
W\LD HE NOT ?9K ?AT ! WORK+ PEOPLE W\LD BE ! PEOPLE :O LIV$ 9 ! F9E/ H\SES & HAD MO/ ( EV]Y?+ ?AT WORK PRODUCES8 ,YET1 :E!R Y\ TOOK HIM TO ,LONDON OR ,P>IS OR ,NEW ,YORK1 OR EV5 TO ,BURL+TON1 HE W\LD F9D ?AT ?OSE CALL$ ! WORK+ PEOPLE  

W]E ! PEOPLE :O LIV$ 9 ! POORE/ H\SES40.<#d.> 

7,! SAME ?+1 ,I W\LD ADD1 TAKES PLACE 9 A YET GREAT] DEGREE 9 ! C\NTRY4 ,IDLE PEOPLE LIVE 9 LUXURI\S PALACES1 9 SPACI\S & F9E ABODES4 ,! WORK]S LIVE 9 D>K & DIRTY HOVELS47 

0,ALL ?IS IS /RANGE--JU/ ?9K ( IT4 ,WE NATURALLY  

DESPISE POV]TY1 & IT IS REASONABLE ?AT WE %\LD 4MW-P>S]-\TPUT 4N[RAP14MW-P>S]-\TPUT 4N[RAP A3BE=E14MW-P>S]-\TPUT 4N[RAP 4SELFL9K3BE=E_<:ITE-SPACE3N[RAP_>4 4 4 4 ,NATURE GIVES TO LABOR1 & TO LABOR ALONE2 !RE MU/ BE HUMAN WORK BE=E ANY >TICLE ( WEAL? CAN BE PRODUC$2 & 9 ! NATURAL /ATE ( ?+S ! MAN :O TOIL$ HONE/LY & WELL W\LD BE ! RI* MAN1 & HE :O DID NOT WORK W\LD BE POOR4 ,WE HAVE SO REV]S$ ! ORD] ( ,NATURE ?AT WE >E ACCU/OM$ TO ?9K ( ! WORK+ MAN AS A POOR MAN4 4 4 4 ,! PRIM>Y CAUSE ( ?IS IS ?AT WE COMPEL ?OSE :O WORK TO PAY O!RS = P]MISSION TO DO SO4 ,Y\ MAY BUY A COAT1 A HORSE1 A H\SE2 !RE Y\ >E PAY+ ! SELL] = LABOR EX]T$1 = SOME?+ ?AT HE HAS PRODUC$1 OR ?AT HE HAS GOT FROM ! MAN :O DID PRODUCE IT2 BUT :5 Y\ PAY A MAN = L&1 :AT >E Y\ PAY+ HIM =8 ,Y\ >E PAY+ = SOME?+ ?AT NO MAN HAS PRODUC$2 Y\ PAY HIM = SOME?+ ?AT WAS H]E BE=E MAN WAS1 OR = A VALUE ?AT WAS CREAT$1 NOT BY HIM 9DIVIDUALLY1 BUT BY ! COMMUNITY ( :I* Y\ >E A P>T40.<#e.> 

7,IT IS = ?IS REASON ?AT ! ONE :O HAS SEIZ$ ! L& & POSSESSES IT IS RI*1 :]EAS HE :O CULTIVATES IT OR WORKS ON ITS PRODUCTS IS POOR47 

0,WE TALK AB\T OV]-PRODUCTION4 ,H[ CAN !RE BE SU* A ?+ AS OV]-PRODUCTION :ILE PEOPLE WANT8 ,ALL !SE ?+S ?AT >E SAID TO BE OV]-PRODUC$ >E DESIR$ BY MANY PEOPLE4 ,:Y DO !Y NOT GET !M8 ,!Y DO NOT GET !M BECAUSE !Y HAVE NOT ! MEANS TO BUY !M2 NOT ?AT !Y DO NOT WANT !M4 ,:Y HAVE NOT !Y ! MEANS TO BUY !M8 ,!Y E>N TOO LITTLE4 ,:5 ! GREAT MASS ( M5 HAVE TO WORK = AN AV]AGE ( @s#a4#d A DAY1 IT IS NO WOND] ?AT GREAT QUANTITIES ( GOODS CANNOT BE SOLD4 

0,N[1 :Y IS IT ?AT M5 HAVE TO WORK = SU* L[ WAGES8 ,BECAUSE IF !Y W]E TO DEM& HI<] WAGES !RE >E PL5TY ( UNEMPLOY$ M5 READY TO /EP 9TO !IR PLACES4 ,IT IS ?IS MASS ( UNEMPLOY$ M5 :O COMPEL ?AT FI]CE COMPETITION ?AT DRIVES WAGES D[N TO ! PO9T ( B>E SUBSI/5CE4 ,:Y IS IT ?AT !RE >E M5 :O CANNOT GET EMPLOYM5T8 ,DID Y\ EV] ?9K :AT A /RANGE ?+ IT IS ?AT M5 CANNOT F9D EMPLOYM5T8 ,ADAM HAD NO DIFFICULTY 9 F9D+ EMPLOYM5T1 NEI!R HAD ,ROB9SON ,CRUSOE2 ! F9D+ ( EMPLOYM5T WAS ! LA/ ?+ ?AT TR\BL$ !M4 

0,IF M5 CANNOT F9D AN EMPLOY]1 :Y CANNOT !Y EMPLOY !MSELVES8 ,SIMPLY BECAUSE !Y >E %UT \T FROM ! ELEM5T ON :I* HUMAN LABOR CAN ALONE BE EX]T$4 ,M5 >E COMPELL$ TO COMPETE ) EA* O!R 
= ! WAGES ( AN EMPLOY]1 BECAUSE !Y HAVE BE5 ROBB$ ( ! NATURAL OPPORTUNITIES ( EMPLOY+ !MSELVES2 BECAUSE !Y CANNOT F9D A PIECE ( ,GOD'S WORLD ON :I* TO WORK )\T PAY+ SOME O!R HUMAN  
CREATURE = ! PRIVILEGE40.<#f.> 

 0,M5 PRAY TO ! ,ALMI<TY TO RELIEVE POV]TY4 ,BUT POV]TY COMES NOT FROM ,GOD'S LAWS--IT IS BLASPHEMY ( ! WOR/ K9D TO SAY ?AT2 IT COMES FROM MAN'S 9JU/ICE TO HIS FELL[S4 ,SUPPOS+ ! ,ALMI<TY W]E TO HE> ! PRAY]1 H[ C\LD ,HE C>RY \T ! REQUE/ SO LONG AS ,HIS LAWS >E :AT !Y >E8 ,CONSID]1 ! ,ALMI<TY GIVES US NO?+ ( ! ?+S ?AT CON/ITUTE WEAL?2 ,HE  
M]ELY GIVES US ! RAW MAT]IAL1 :I* MU/ BE UTILIZ$ BY M5 TO PRODUCE WEAL?4 ,DOES ,HE NOT GIVE US 5\< ( ?AT N[8 ,H[ C\LD ,HE RELIEVE POV]TY EV5 IF ,HE W]E TO GIVE US MORE8 ,SUPPOS+ 9 ANSW] TO !SE PRAY]S ,HE W]E TO 9CREASE ! P[] ( ! SUN1 OR ! VIRTUE ( ! SOIL8 ,SUPPOS+ ,HE W]E TO MAKE PLANTS MORE PROLIFIC1 OR ANIMALS TO PRODUCE AFT] !IR K9D MORE ABUNDANTLY8 ,:O W\LD GET ! B5EFIT ( IT8 ,TAKE A C\NTRY :]E L& IS COMPLETELY MONOPOLIZ$1 AS IT IS 9 MO/ ( ! CIVILIZ$ C\NTRIES1 :O W\LD GET ! B5EFIT ( IT8 ,SIMPLY ! L&[N]S4 ,& EV5 IF ,GOD 9 ANSW] TO PRAY] W]E TO S5D D[N \T ( ! HEAV5S ?OSE ?+S ?AT M5 REQUIRE1 :O W\LD GET ! B5EFIT8 

0,9 ! ,OLD ,TE/AM5T WE >E TOLD ?AT :5 ! ,ISRAELITES J\RNEY$ ?R\< ! DES]T !Y W]E HUNG]$1 & ?AT ,GOD S5T MANNA D[N \T ( ! HEAV5S4 ,!RE WAS 5\< = ALL ( !M1 & !Y ALL TOOK IT & W]E RELIEV$4 ,BUT SUPPOS+ ?AT ! DES]T HAD BE5 HELD AS PRIVATE PROP]TY1 AS ! SOIL ( ,GREAT ,BRITA9 IS HELD1 AS ! SOIL EV5 ( \R NEW ,/ATES IS BE+ HELD2 SUPPOSE ?AT ONE ( ! ,ISRAELITES HAD A SQU>E MILE & ANO!R ONE HAD TW5TY SQU>E MILES1 & ANO!R ONE HAD A HUNDR$ SQU>E MILES1 & ! GREAT MAJORITY ( ! ,ISRAELITES DID NOT HAVE 5\< TO SET ! SOLES ( !IR FEET UPON :I* !Y C\LD CALL !IR [N--:AT W\LD BECOME ( ! MANNA8 ,:AT GOOD W\LD IT HAVE  
DONE TO ! MAJORITY8 ,NOT A :IT4 ,?\< ,GOD HAD S5T D[N MANNA 5\< = ALL1 ?AT MANNA W\LD HAVE BE5 ! PROP]TY ( ! L&HOLD]S1 !Y W\LD HAVE EMPLOY$ SOME ( ! O!RS P]HAPS TO GA!R IT UP 9TO HEAPS = !M1 & W\LD HAVE SOLD IT TO !IR HUNGRY BRE?R54 ,CONSID] IT2 ?IS PUR*ASE & SALE ( MANNA MI<T HAVE GONE ON UNTIL ! MAJORITY ( ,ISRAELITES HAD GIV5 ALL !Y HAD1 EV5 TO ! CLO!S (F !IR BACKS4 ,:AT !N8 ,!N !Y W\LD NOT HAVE HAD ANY?+ TO BUY MANNA )1 & ! CONSEQU5CES W\LD HAVE BE5 ?AT :ILE !Y W5T HUNGRY ! MANNA W\LD HAVE LA9 9 GREAT HEAPS1 & ! L&[N]S W\LD HAVE BE5 COMPLA9+ ( ! OV]-PRODUCTION ( MANNA4 ,!RE W\LD HAVE BE5 A GREAT H>VE/ ( MANNA & HUNGRY PEOPLE1 JU/ PRECISELY ! PH5OM5ON ?AT WE SEE TODAY40.<#g.> 

0,I DO NOT MEAN TO SAY ?AT EV5 AFT] Y\ HAD SET RI<T ?IS FUNDAM5TAL 9JU/ICE !RE W\LD NOT BE MANY ?+S TO DO2 BUT ?IS ,I DO MEAN TO SAY1 ?AT \R TREATM5T ( L& LIES AT ! BOTTOM ( ALL SOCIAL QUE/IONS4 ,?IS ,I DO MEAN TO SAY1 ?AT1 DO :AT Y\ PLEASE1 RE=M AS Y\ MAY1 Y\ NEV] CAN GET RID ( WIDESPREAD POV]TY SO LONG AS ! ELEM5T ON :I* & FROM :I* ALL M5 MU/ LIVE IS MADE ! PRIVATE PROP]TY ( SOME M54 ,IT IS UTT]LY IMPOSSIBLE4 ,RE=M GOV]NM5T2 GET TAXES D[N TO ! M9IMUM2 BUILD RAILROADS1 9/ITUTE COOP]ATIVE /ORES2 DIVIDE PR(ITS1 IF Y\ *OOSE1 BETWE5 EMPLOY]S & EMPLOY$--& :AT WILL BE ! RESULT8 ,! RESULT WILL BE ?AT ! L& WILL 9CREASE 9 VALUE--?AT WILL BE ! RESULT--?AT & NO?+ ELSE4 ,EXP]I5CE %[S ?IS4 ,DO NOT ALL IMPROVEM5TS SIMPLY 9CREASE ! VALUE ( L& !--PRICE ?AT SOME MU/ PAY O!RS = ! PRIVILEGE ( LIV+80.<#h.> 

,! SAME1 ,I %ALL ADD1 DO WE UNCEAS+LY SEE 9 ,RUSSIA4 ,ALL L&[N]S COMPLA9 ( ! UNPR(ITABL5ESS & EXP5SE ( !IR E/ATES :IL/ ! PRICE ( ! L& IS CONT9UALLY RIS+4 ,IT CANNOT BUT RISE S9CE ! POPULATION IS 9CREAS+1 & L& IS A QUE/ION ( LIFE & DEA? = ?IS POPULATION4 

,& !RE=E ! PEOPLE SURR5D] EV]Y?+ !Y CAN1 NOT ONLY !IR LABOR1 BUT EV5 !IR LIVES1 = ! L& :I* IS BE+ )HELD FROM !M4 

  

,I,I,I4 

,!RE US$ TO BE CANNIBALISM & HUMAN SACRIFICES2 !RE US$ TO BE RELIGI\S PRO/ITUTION & ! MURD] ( WEAK *ILDR5 & ( GIRLS2 !RE US$ TO BE BLOODY REV5GE & ! SLAU<T] ( :OLE POPULATIONS1 JUDICIAL TORTURES1 QU>T]+S1 BURN+S AT ! /AKE1 ! LA%2 & !RE HAVE BE51 )9 \R MEMORY1 SPITZRU!NS.<#i.> & SLAV]Y1 :I* HAVE ALSO DISAPPE>$4 ,BUT IF WE  
HAVE \TLIV$ !SE DREADFUL CU/OMS & 9/ITUTIONS1 ?IS DOES NOT PROVE ?AT !RE DO NOT EXI/ 9/ITUTIONS & CU/OMS AMONG US :I* HAVE BECOME AS ABHORR5T TO 5LI<T5$ REASON & CONSCI5CE AS ?OSE :I* HAVE 9 !IR TIME BE5 ABOLI%$ & HAVE BECOME = US ONLY A DREADFUL REMEMBRANCE4 ,! WAY ( HUMAN P]FECT+ IS 5DLESS1 & AT EV]Y MOM5T ( HI/ORICAL LIFE !RE >E SUP]/ITIONS1 DECEITS1 P]NICI\S & EVIL 9/ITUTIONS1 ALREADY \TLIV$ BY M5 & BELONG+ TO ! PA/2 !RE >E O!RS :I* APPE> TO US 9 ! F> MI/S ( ! FUTURE2 & !RE >E SOME :I* WE >E N[ LIV+ ?R\< & :OSE OV]LIV+ =MS ! OBJECT ( \R LIFE4 ,SU* 9 \R TIME IS CAPITAL PUNI%M5T & ALL PUNI%M5T 9 G5]AL4 ,SU* IS PRO/ITUTION1 SU* IS FLE%-EAT+1 SU* IS ! WORK ( MILIT>ISM1 W>1 & SU* IS ! NE>E/ & MO/ OBVI\S EVIL1 PRIVATE PROP]TY 9 L&4 

,BUT AS PEOPLE NEV] SUDD5LY FRE$ !MSELVES FROM ALL ! 9JU/ICES :I* HAD BECOME CU/OM>Y1 NOR EV5 DID SO IMM$IATELY AFT] ! MORE S5SITIVE 9DIVIDUAL HAD RECOGNIZ$ !IR 9IQUITY1 BUT ADVANC$ ONLY BY LEAPS1 HALTS1 RESUM+S1 & AGA9 NEW LEAPS T[>DS FRE$OM1 SIMIL> TO ! /RUGGLES ( *ILDBIR?1 SO HAS IT BE5 ( LATE ) ! ABOLITION ( SLAV]Y1 & SO IS IT N[ )  
PRIVATE PROP]TY 9 L&4 

,! EVIL & 9JU/ICE ( PRIVATE PROP]TY 9 L& HAVE BE5 PO9T$ \T A ?\S& YE>S AGO BY ! PROPHETS & SAGES ( OLD4 ,LAT] PROGRESSIVE ?9K]S ( ,EUROPE HAVE BE5 (T5] & (T5] PO9T+ IT \T4 ,) SPECIAL CLE>NESS DID ! WORK]S ( ! ,FR5* ,REVOLUTION DO SO4 ,9 LATT] DAYS1 [+ TO ! 9CREASE ( ! POPULATION & ! SEIZ+ BY ! RI* ( A GREAT QUANTITY ( PREVI\SLY FREE L&1 ALSO [+ TO G5]AL 5LI<T5M5T & ! SPREAD ( HUMANIT>IANISM1 ?IS 9JU/ICE HAS BECOME SO OBVI\S ?AT NOT ONLY ! PROGRESSIVE1 BUT EV5 ! MO/ AV]AGE PEOPLE CANNOT HELP SEE+ & FEEL+ IT4 ,BUT M51 ESPECIALLY ?OSE :O PR(IT BY ! ADVANTAGES ( L&$ PROP]TY--! [N]S !MSELVES1 AS WELL AS ?OSE :OSE 9T]E/S >E CONNECT$ ) ?IS 9/ITUTION >E SO ACCU/OM$ TO ?IS ORD] ( ?+S1 !Y HAVE = SO LONG PR(IT$ BY IT1 HAVE SO MU* DEP5D$ UPON IT1 ?AT (T5 !Y !MSELVES DO NOT SEE ITS 9JU/ICE1 & !Y USE ALL POSSIBLE MEANS TO CONCEAL FROM !MSELVES & O!RS ! TRU? :I* IS DISCLOS+ ITSELF MORE & MORE CLE>LY1 & TO CRU%1 EXT+UI%1 & DI/ORT IT1 OR1 IF !SE DO NOT SUCCE$1 TO HU% IT UP4 

,*>ACT]I/ICALLY WAS ?IS ! FATE ( ! ACTIVITY ( ! REM>KABLE MAN :O APPE>$ T[>DS ! 5D ( LA/ C5TURY--,H5RY ,GEORGE--:O DEVOT$ HIS GREAT M5TAL P[]S TO ! ELUCIDATION ( ! 9JU/ICE & CRUELTY ( L&$ PROP]TY & TO ! 9DICATION ( ! MEANS ( CORRECT+ ?IS EVIL BY ! HELP ( ! /ATE787 ORGANIZATION N[ EXI/+ AMONG ALL NATIONS4 ,HE DID ?IS 9 HIS BOOKS1 >TICLES1 & SPEE*ES ) SU* EXTRAORD9>Y P[] & LUCIDITY ?AT NO MAN )\T  
PRECONCEIV$ IDEAS C\LD1 AFT] READ+ HIS BOOKS1 FAIL TO AGREE ) HIS >GUM5TS1 & TO SEE ?AT NO RE=MS CAN IMPROVE ! CONDITION ( ! PEOPLE UNTIL ?IS FUNDAM5TAL 9JU/ICE BE DE/ROY$1 & ?AT ! MEANS HE PROPOSES = ITS ABOLITION >E RATIONAL1 JU/1 & EXP$I5T4 

,BUT :AT HAS HAPP5$8 ,NOT)/&+ ?AT AT ! TIME ( !IR APPE>ANCE ! ,5GLI% WRIT+S ( ,H5RY ,GEORGE SPREAD V]Y QUICKLY 9 ! ,ANGLO-,SAXON WORLD1 & DID NOT FAIL TO BE APPRECIAT$ TO ! FULL EXT5T ( !IR GREAT M]IT1 IT V]Y SOON APPE>$ ?AT 9 ,5GL&1 & EV5 9 ,IREL&1 :]E ! CRY+ 9JU/ICE ( PRIVATE L&$ PROP]TY IS P>TICUL>LY MANIFE/1 ! MAJORITY ( ! MO/ 9FLU5TIAL $UCAT$ PEOPLE1 NOT)/&+ ! CONCLUSIV5ESS ( ,H5RY ,GEORGE'S >GUM5TS & ! PRACTICABILITY ( ! REM$Y HE PROPOSES1 OPPOS$ HIS TEA*+4 ,RADICAL AGITATORS LIKE ,P>NELL1 :O AT FIR/ SYMPA?IZ$ ) ,GEORGE'S S*EME1 V]Y SOON %RANK FROM IT1 REG>D+ POLITICAL RE=MS AS MORE IMPORTANT4 ,9 ,5GL& ALMO/ ALL ! >I/OCRATS W]E AGA9/ IT1 ALSO1 AMONG O!RS1 ! FAM\S ,TOYNBEE1 ,GLAD/ONE1 & ,H]B]T ,SP5C]--?AT ,SP5C] :O 9 HIS 0,/ATICS0 AT FIR/ MO/ CATEGORICALLY ASS]T$ ! 9JU/ICE ( L&$ PROP]TY1 & !N1 R5\NC+ ?IS VIEW ( HIS1 B\<T UP ! OLD $ITIONS ( HIS WRIT+S 9 ORD] TO ELIM9ATE FROM !M ALL ?AT HE HAD SAID CONC]N+ ! 9JU/ICE ( L&$ PROP]TY4 

,9 ,OX=D DUR+ ,GEORGE'S LECTURES ! /UD5TS ORGANIZ$ HO/ILE MANIFE/ATIONS1 :ILE ! ,ROMAN ,CA?OLIC P>TY REG>D$ ,GEORGE'S TEA*+ AS POSITIVELY S9FUL & IMMORAL1 DANG]\S1 & CONTR>Y TO ,*RI/'S TEA*+4 ,ALSO ! OR?ODOX SCI5CE ( POLITICAL ECONOMY REVOLT$ AGA9/ ,GEORGE'S TEA*+4 ,LE>N$ PR(ESSORS FROM ! HEI<T ( !IR SUP]IORITY REFUT$ HIS TEA*+ )\T UND]/&+ IT1 *IEFLY BECAUSE IT DID NOT RECOGNIZE ! FUNDAM5TAL PR9CIPLES ( !IR IMAG9>Y SCI5CE4 ,! ,SOCIALI/S W]E ALSO 9IMICAL1 RECOGNIZ+ AS ! MO/ IMPORTANT PROBLEM ( ! DAY NOT ! L& PROBLEM1 BUT ! COMPLETE ABOLITION ( PRIVATE PROP]TY4 

,! *IEF WEAPON AGA9/ ! TEA*+ ( ,H5RY ,GEORGE WAS ?AT :I* IS ALWAYS US$ AGA9/ IRREFUTABLE & SELF-EVID5T TRU?S4 ,?IS ME?OD1 :I* IS /ILL BE+ APPLI$ 9 RELATION TO ,GEORGE1 WAS ?AT ( HU%+ UP4 ,?IS HU%+ UP WAS EFFECT$ SO SUCCESSFULLY ?AT A MEMB] ( ! ,BRITI% ,P>LIAM5T1 ,LAB\*]E1 C\LD PUBLICLY SAY1 )\T MEET+ ANY REFUTATION1 ?AT 0HE WAS NOT SU* A VISION>Y AS ,H5RY ,GEORGE4 ,HE DID NOT PROPOSE TO TAKE ! L& FROM ! L&LORDS & R5T IT \T AGA94 ,:AT HE WAS 9 FAVOR ( WAS PUTT+ A TAX ON L& VALUES40.<#a.> ,?AT IS1 :IL/ ATTRIBUT+ TO ,GEORGE :AT HE C\LD NOT POSSIBLY HAVE SAID1 ,LAB\*]E1 BY WAY ( CORRECT+ !SE IMAG9>Y FANTASIES1 SUGGE/$ ?AT :I* ,H5RY ,GEORGE DID 9DE$ SAY4 

,?ANKS TO ! COLLECTIVE EF=TS ( ALL ?OSE 9T]E/$ 9 DEF5D+ ! 9/ITUTION ( L&$ PROP]TY1 ! TEA*+ ( ,GEORGE1 IRRESI/IBLY CONV9C+ 9 ITS SIMPLICITY & CLE>NESS1 REMA9S ALMO/ UNKN[N1 & ( LATE YE>S ATTRACTS LESS & LESS ATT5TION4 

,H]E & !RE 9 ,SCOTL&1 ,PORTUGAL1 OR ,NEW ,ZEAL& HE IS RECALL$ TO M9D1 & AMONG HUNDR$S ( SCI5TI/S !RE APPE>S ONE :O KN[S & DEF5DS HIS TEA*+S4 ,BUT 9 ,5GL& & ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES ! NUMB] ( HIS ADH]5TS DW9DLES SMALL] & SMALL]2 9 ,FRANCE HIS TEA*+ IS ALMO/ UNKN[N2 9 ,G]MANY IT IS PREA*$ 9 A V]Y SMALL CIRCLE1 & IS EV]Y:]E /IFL$ BY ! NOISY TEA*+ ( ,SOCIALISM4 

  

,I,V4 

,PEOPLE DO NOT >GUE ) ! TEA*+ ( ,GEORGE1 !Y SIMPLY DO NOT KN[ IT4 7,& IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO DO O!RWISE ) HIS TEA*+1 = HE :O BECOMES ACQUA9T$ ) IT CANNOT BUT AGREE47 

,IF PEOPLE REF] TO ?IS TEA*+ !Y DO SO EI!R 9 ATTRIBUT+ TO IT ?AT :I* IT DOES NOT SAY1 OR 9 RE-ASS]T+ ?AT :I* HAS BE5 REFUT$ BY ,GEORGE1 OR ELSE1 ABOVE ALL1 !Y REJECT IT SIMPLY BECAUSE IT DOES NOT CON=M ) ?OSE P$ANTIC1 >BITR>Y1 SUP]FICIAL PR9CIPLES ( SO-CALL$ POLITICAL ECONOMY :I* >E RECOGNIZ$ AS 9DISPUTABLE TRU?S4 

,YET1 NOT)/&+ ?IS1 ! TRU? ?AT L& CANNOT BE AN OBJECT ( PROP]TY HAS BECOME SO ELUCIDAT$ BY ! V]Y LIFE ( CONTEMPOR>Y MANK9D1 ?AT 9 ORD] TO CONT9UE TO RETA9 A WAY ( LIFE 9 :I* PRIVATE L&$ PROP]TY IS RECOGNIZ$1 !RE IS ONLY ONE MEANS--NOT TO ?9K ( IT1 TO IGNORE ! TRU?1 & TO OCCUPY ONESELF ) O!R  
ABSORB+ BUS9ESS4 ,SO1 9DE$1 DO ! M5 ( \R TIME4 

,POLITICAL WORK]S ( ,EUROPE & ,AM]ICA OCCUPY !MSELVES = ! WELF>E ( !IR NATIONS 9 V>I\S MATT]S2 T>IFFS1 COLONIES1 9COME TAXES1 MILIT>Y & NAVAL BUDGETS1 SOCIALI/IC ASSEMBLIES1 UNIONS1 SYNDICATES1 ! ELECTION ( PRESID5TS1 DIPLOMATIC CONNECTIONS--BY ANY?+ SAVE ! ONE ?+ )\T :I* !RE CANNOT BE ANY TRUE IMPROVEM5T 9 ! CONDITION ( ! PEOPLE--! REE/ABLI%M5T ( ! 9FR+$ RI<T ( ALL M5 TO USE ! L&4 ,AL?\< 9 ! DEP? ( !IR S\LS POLITICAL WORK]S ( ! ,*RI/IAN WORLD FEEL--CANNOT BUT FEEL--?AT ALL !IR ACTIVITY1! COMM]CIAL /RIFE ) :I* !Y >E OCCUPI$1 AS WELL AS ! MILIT>Y /RIFE 9 :I* !Y PUT ALL !IR 5]GIES--CAN LEAD TO NO?+ BUT A G5]AL EXHAU/ION ( ! /R5G? ( NATIONS2 /ILL !Y1 )\T LOOK+ =W>D1 GIVE !MSELVES UP TO  
! DEM& ( ! M9UTE1 &1 AS IF ) ! ONE DESIRE TO =GET !MSELVES1 CONT9UE TO TURN R\ND & R\ND 9 AN 5*ANT$ CIRCLE \T ( :I* !RE IS NO ISSUE4 

,H[EV] /RANGE ?IS TEMPOR>Y BL9DNESS ( ! POLITICAL WORK]S ( ,EUROPE & ,AM]ICA1 IT CAN BE EXPLA9$ BY ! FACT ?AT 9 ,EUROPE & ,AM]ICA PEOPLE HAVE ALREADY GONE SO F> ALONG A WRONG ROAD ?AT ! MAJORITY ( !IR POPULATION IS ALREADY TORN FROM ! L& 79 ,AM]ICA IT HAS NEV] LIV$ ON ! L&71 BUT LIVES EI!R 9 FACTORIES OR BY HIR$ AGRICULTURAL LABOR1 & DESIRES & DEM&S ONLY ONE ?+--! IMPROVEM5T ( ITS POSITION AS HIR$ LABOR]S4 ,IT IS !RE=E COMPREH5SIBLE ?AT TO ! POLITICAL WORK]S ( ,EUROPE & ,AM]ICA--LI/5+ TO ! DEM&S ( ! MAJORITY--IT MAY SEEM ?AT ! *IEF MEANS = ! IMPROVEM5T ( ! POSITION ( ! PEOPLE CONSI/S 9 T>IFFS1 TRU/S1 & COLONIES1 BUT TO ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE 9 ,RUSSIA1 :]E ! AGRICULTURAL POPULATION COMPOSES #h P] C5T4 ( ! :OLE  
NATION1 :]E ALL ?IS PEOPLE REQUE/ ONLY ONE ?+--?AT OPPORTUNITY BE GIV5 !M TO REMA9 9 ?IS /ATE--IT W\LD SEEM IT %\LD BE CLE>  
?AT = ! IMPROVEM5T ( ! POSITION ( ! PEOPLE SOME?+ ELSE IS NECESS>Y4 

,! PEOPLE ( ,EUROPE & ,AM]ICA >E 9 ! POSITION ( A MAN :O HAS GONE SO F> ALONG A ROAD :I* AT FIR/ APPE>$ ! RI<T ONE1 BUT  
:I* ! FUR!R HE GOES ! MORE IT REMOVES HIM FROM HIS OBJECT1 ?AT HE IS AFRAID ( CONFESS+ HIS MI/AKE4 ,BUT ! ,RUSSIANS >E YET /&+ BE=E ! TURN+ ( ! PA? & CAN1 ACCORD+ TO ! WISE SAY+1 0ASK !IR WAY :ILE YET ON ! ROAD40 

,& :AT >E ?OSE ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE DO+ :O DESIRE1 OR1 AT ALL EV5TS1 SAY !Y DESIRE1 TO ORGANIZE A GOOD LIFE = ! PEOPLE8 ,9 EV]Y?+ !Y SLAVI%LY IMITATE :ATEV] IS BE+ DONE 9 ,EUROPE & ,AM]ICA4 

,= ! >RANGEM5T ( A GOOD LIFE = ! PEOPLE !Y >E CONC]N$ ) ! FRE$OM ( ! ,PRESS1 RELIGI\S TOL]ANCE1 LIB]TY ( UNION1 T>IFFS1 CONDITIONAL PUNI%M5T1 ! SEP>ATION ( ! ,*UR* FROM ! ,/ATE1 COOP]ATIVE ASSOCIATIONS1 FUTURE COMMUNALIZATION ( ! IMPLEM5TS ( WORK1 &1 ABOVE ALL1 ) REPRES5TATIVE GOV]NM5T--?AT SAME REPRES5TATIVE GOV]NM5T :I* HAS LONG EXI/$ 9 ,EUROPEAN & ,AM]ICAN ,/ATES1 BUT :OSE EXI/5CE HAS NOT 9 ! SLI<TE/ CONTRIBUT$1 NOR DOES N[ CONTRIBUTE1 NOT ONLY TO ! SOLUTION BUT EV5 TO ! RAIS+ ( ?AT ONE L& PROBLEM :I* SOLVES ALL DIFFICULTIES4 ,IF ,RUSSIAN POLITICAL WORK]S DO SPEAK AB\T L& ABUSE1 :I* !Y = SOME REASON CALL ! AGR>IAN QUE/ION--POSSIBLY ?9K+ ?AT ?IS SILLY WORD WILL CONCEAL ! SUB/ANCE ( ! MATT]--!Y SPEAK ( IT1 NOT 9 ! S5SE ?AT PRIVATE L&$ PROP]TY IS AN EVIL :I* %\LD BE ABOLI%$1 BUT 9 ! S5SE ?AT IT IS NECESS>Y 9 SOME WAY OR O!R1 BY V>I\S PAT*+S & PALLIATIVES TO PLA/] UP1 HU% UP1 & PASS OV] ?IS ESS5TIAL1 ANCI5T1 & CRUEL1 ?IS OBVI\S & CRY+ 9JU/ICE1 :I* IS AWAIT+ ITS TURN = ABOLITION NOT ONLY 9 ,RUSSIA1 BUT 9 ! :OLE WORLD4 

,9 ,RUSSIA1 :]E A HUNDR$ MILLION ( ! MASSES UNCEAS+LY SUFF] FROM ! SEIZURE ( ! L& BY PRIVATE [N]S1 & UNCEAS+LY CRY \T AB\T IT1 ! POSITION ( ?OSE PEOPLE :O >E  
VA9LY SE>*+ EV]Y:]E BUT :]E IT REALLY IS1 = ! MEANS ( IMPROV+ ! CONDITION ( ! PEOPLE1 REM9DS ONE EXACTLY ( ?AT :I* TAKES PLACE ON ! /AGE1 :5 ALL ! SPECTATORS SEE P]FECTLY WELL ! MAN :O HAS HIDD5 HIMSELF1 & ! ACTORS !MSELVES \<T TO SEE HIM1 BUT PRET5D !Y DO NOT1 9T5TIONALLY DI/RACT+ EA* O!R'S ATT5TION & SEE+ EV]Y?+ EXCEPT ?AT :I* IT IS NECESS>Y = !M TO SEE1 BUT :I* !Y DO NOT WI% TO SEE4 

  

,V4 

,PEOPLE HAVE DRIV5 A H]D ( C[S1 ON ! MILK PRODUCTS ( :I* !Y >E F$1 9TO AN 5CLOSURE4 ,! C[S HAVE EAT5 UP & TRAMPL$ ! =AGE 9 ! 5CLOSURE1 !Y >E HUNGRY1 !Y HAVE *EW$ EA* O!R'S TAILS1 !Y L[ & MOAN1 IMPLOR+ TO BE RELEAS$ FROM ! 5CLOSURE & SET FREE 9 ! PA/URES4 ,BUT ! V]Y M5 :O FE$ !MSELVES ON ! MILK ( !SE C[S HAVE SET >\ND ! 5CLOSURE PLANTATIONS ( M9T1 ( PLANTS  
= DYE+ PURPOSES1 & ( TOBACCO2 !Y HAVE CULTIVAT$ FL[]S1 LAID \T A RACEC\RSE1 A P>K1 & A LAWN T5NIS GR\ND1 & !Y DO NOT LET \T ! C[S LE/ !Y SPOIL !SE >RANGEM5TS4 ,BUT ! C[S BELL[1 GET ?91 & ! M5 BEG9  
TO BE AFRAID ?AT ! C[S MAY CEASE TO YIELD MILK1 & !Y 9V5T V>I\S MEANS ( IMPROV+ ! CONDITION ( !SE C[S4 ,!Y ]ECT %$S OV] !M1 !Y 9TRODUCE WET BRU%ES = RUBB+ ! C[S1 !Y GILD !IR HORNS1 ALT] ! H\R ( MILK+1 CONC]N !MSELVES ) ! H\S+ & TREAT+ ( 9VALID & OLD C[S1 !Y 9V5T NEW & IMPROV$ ME?ODS ( MILK+1 !Y EXPECT ?AT SOME K9D ( WOND]FULLY NUTRITI\S GRASS !Y HAVE S[N 9 ! 5CLOSURE WILL GR[ UP1 !Y >GUE AB\T !SE & MANY O!R V>I$ MATT]S1 BUT !Y DO NOT1 CANNOT--)\T DI/URB+ ALL !Y HAVE >RANG$ >\ND ! 5CLOSURE--DO ! ONLY SIMPLE ?+ NECESS>Y = !MSELVES AS WELL AS = ! C[S--TO WIT1 ! TAK+ D[N ( ! F5CE & GRANT+ ! C[S !IR NATURAL FRE$OM ( US+ 9 PL5TY ! PA/URES SURR\ND+ !M4 

,ACT+ ?US1 M5 ACT UNREASONABLY1 BUT !RE IS AN EXPLANATION ( !IR ACTION2 !Y >E SORRY = ! FATE ( ALL !Y HAVE >RANG$ >\ND ! 5CLOSURE4 ,BUT :AT %ALL WE CALL ?OSE PEOPLE :O HAVE SET NO?+ >\ND ! F5CE1 BUT :O1 \T ( IMITATION ( ?OSE :O DO NOT SET FREE !IR C[S1 [+ TO :AT !Y HAD >RANG$ >\ND ! 5CLOSURE1 ALSO KEEP !IR C[S 9SIDE ! F5CE1 & ASS]T ?AT !Y DO SO = ! WELF>E ( ! C[S !MSELVES8 

,PRECISELY ?US ACT ?OSE ,RUSSIANS1 BO? ,GOV]NM5TAL & ANTI-,GOV]NM5TAL1 :O >RANGE = ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE1 UNCEAS+LY SUFF]+ FROM ! WANT ( L&1 EV]Y K9D ( ,EUROPEAN 9/ITUTION1 =GETT+ & D5Y+ ! *IEF ?+2 ?AT :I* ALONE ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE REQUIRE--! LIB]ATION ( ! L& FROM PRIVATE PROP]TY1 ! E/ABLI%M5T ( EQUAL RI<TS ON ! L& = ALL M54 

,ONE CAN UND]/& H[ ,EUROPEAN P>ASITES LIV+ NOT DIRECTLY BY ! LABOR ( !IR [N ,BRITI%1 ,FR5* OR ,G]MAN WORK+ M51 BUT BY ! LABOR ( ,COLONIAL WORK+ M5 :O PRODUCE ! BREAD = :I* ! O!RS EX*ANGE !IR FACTORY PRODUCE1 MAY1 )\T SEE+ ! LABOR & SUFF]+S ( ?OSE WORK+ M5 :O FE$ & SUPPORT !M1 9V5T A FUTURE ,SOCIALI/IC ORGANIZATION = :I* !Y ?9K !Y >E $UCAT+ MANK9D1 & ) UNAWAK5$ CONSCI5CE AMUSE !MSELVES ) ELECTIONE]+ CAMPAIGNS1 ! /RIFE ( P>TIES1 P>LIAM5T>Y DEBATES1 ! E/ABLI%M5T & OV]?R[ ( M9I/]IES1 & EV]Y O!R K9D ( RECREATION :I* !Y CALL SCI5CE & >T4 

,! TRUE BREAD SUPPORT]S ( !SE ,EUROPEAN P>ASITES >E ! LABOR]S !Y DO NOT SEE1 9 ,9DIA1 ,AFRICA1 ,AU/RALIA1 & P>TLY 9 ,RUSSIA4 ,BUT IT IS NOT SO = US ,RUSSIANS 2 WE HAVE NO COLONIES :]E SLAVES 9VISIBLE TO \RSELVES FE$ US = \R MANUFACTUR+ PRODUCE4 ,\R BREAD-W9N]S1 SUFF]+1 HUNGRY1 >E ALWAYS BE=E \R EYES1 & WE CANNOT TRANSF] ! BURD5 ( \R 9IQUIT\S LIFE TO DI/ANT COLONIES ?AT SLAVES 9VISIBLE TO US %\LD FE$ US4 ,\R S9S >E ALWAYS BE=E US4 

,& BEHOLD1 9/EAD ( 5T]+ 9TO ! NE$S ( ?OSE :O SUPPORT US1 9/EAD ( HE>+ !IR CRIES & 5DEAVOR+ TO SATISFY !M1 WE1 9/EAD ( ?IS1 UND] PRETEXT ( S]V+ !M1 ALSO PREP>E1 ACCORD+ TO ! ,EUROPEAN SAMPLE1 ,SOCIALI/IC ORGANIZATIONS = ! FUTURE1 & 9 ! PRES5T OCCUPY \RSELVES ) :AT AMUSES & DI/RACTS US1 & APPE>S TO BE DIRECT$ TO ! WELF>E ( ! PEOPLE \T ( :OM WE >E SQUEEZ+ !IR LA/ /R5G? 9 ORD] TO SUPPORT US1 !IR P>ASITES4 

,= ! WELF>E ( ! PEOPLE WE 5DEAVOR TO ABOLI% ! C5SOR%IP ( BOOKS1 >BITR>Y BANI%M5TS1 & TO ORGANIZE EV]Y:]E S*OOLS1 COMMON & AGRICULTURAL1 TO 9CREASE ! NUMB] ( HOSPITALS1 TO CANCEL PASSPORTS & MONOPOLIES1 TO 9/ITUTE /RICT 9SPECTION 9 ! FACTORIES1 TO REW>D MAIM$ WORK]S1 TO M>K B\ND>IES BETWE5 PROP]TIES1 TO CONTRIBUTE ?R\< BANKS TO ! PUR*ASE ( L& BY PEASANTS1 & MU* ELSE4 

,ONE NE$ ONLY 5T] 9TO ! UNCEAS+ SUFF]+S ( MILLIONS ( ! PEOPLE2 ! DY+ \T FROM WANT ( ! AG$1 WOM51 & *ILDR51 & ( ! WORK]S FROM EXCESSIVE WORK & 9SUFFICI5T FOOD--ONE NE$ ONLY 5T] 9TO ! S]VITUDE1 ! HUMILIATIONS1 ALL ! USELESS EXP5DITURES ( /R5G?1 9TO ! DEPRIVATIONS1 9TO ALL ! HORROR ( ! NE$LESS CALAMITIES ( ! ,RUSSIAN RURAL POPULATION :I* ALL PROCE$ FROM 9SUFFICI5CY ( L&--9 ORD] ?AT IT %\LD BECOME QUITE CLE> ?AT ALL SU* MEASURES AS ! ABOLITION ( C5SOR%IP1 ( >BITR>Y BANI%M5T1 ETC41 :I* >E BE+ /RIV5 AFT] BY ! PSEUDO-DEF5D]S ( ! PEOPLE1 EV5 W]E !Y TO BE REALIZ$1 W\LD =M ONLY ! MO/ 9SIGNIFICANT DROP 9 ! OCEAN ( ?AT WANT FROM :I* ! PEOPLE >E SUFF]+4 

,BUT NOT ONLY DO ?OSE CONC]N$ ) ! WELF>E ( ! PEOPLE1 :ILE 9V5T+ ALT]ATIONS1 TRIFL+1 UNIMPORTANT1 BO? 9 QUALITY & QUANTITY1 LEAVE A HUNDR$ MILLIONS ( ! PEOPLE 9 UNCEAS+ SLAV]Y [+ TO ! SEIZURE ( ! L&--MORE ?AN ?IS1 MANY ( !SE PEOPLE1 ( ! MO/ PROGRESSIVE AMONG !M1 DESIRE ?AT ! SUFF]+ ( ?IS PEOPLE %\LD1 BY ITS CONT9UAL 9CREASE1 DRIVE !M TO ! NECESSITY AFT] LEAV+  
ON !IR WAY MILLIONS ( VICTIMS1 P]I%$ FROM WANT & DEPRAVITY ( EX*ANG+ !IR  CU/OM>Y & HAPPY1 FAVORITE & REASONABLE AGRICULTURAL LIFE = ?AT IMPROV$ FACTORY LIFE :I* !Y HAVE 9V5T$ = !M4 

,! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE--[+ TO !IR AGRICULTURAL 5VIRONM5T1 !IR LOVE = ?IS =M ( LIFE1 !IR ,*RI/IAN TR5D ( *>ACT]1 [+ TO ! CIRCUM/ANCE ?AT !Y1 ALMO/ ALONE ( ALL ,EUROPEAN NATIONS1 CONT9UE TO BE AN AGRICULTURAL NATION & DESIRE TO REMA9 SU*-->E1 AS IT W]E1 PROVID5TIALLY PLAC$ BY HI/ORIC CONDITIONS = ! SOLUTION ( :AT IS CALL$ ! LABOR QUE/ION1 9 SU* A POSITION AS TO /& 9 ! FRONT ( ! TRUE PROGRESSIVE MOVEM5T ( ALL MANK9D4 ,YET ?IS ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE >E 9VIT$ BY ITS FANCI$ REPRES5TATIVES & LEAD]S TO FOLL[ 9 ! WAKE ( ! DY+-\T & 5TANGL$ ,EUROPEAN & ,AM]ICAN NATIONS1 TO BECOME DEPRAV$1 & TO REL9QUI% ITS [N CALL+ AS QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE 9 ORD] TO BECOME LIKE ,EUROPEANS 9 G5]AL4 

,A/\ND+ IS ! POV]TY ( ?\<T ( !SE M51 :O DO NOT ?9K ) !IR [N M9DS1 BUT ONLY S]VILELY REPEAT :ATEV] IS GIV5 =? BY!IR ,EUROPEAN MODELS2 BUT /ILL MORE A/\ND+ IS ! H>DNESS ( !IR HE>TS1 !IR CRUELTY4 

  

,V,I4 

  

0,WOE UNTO Y\1 SCRIBES & ,PH>ISEES1 HYPOCRITES6 = YE >E LIKE UNTO :IT$ SEPUL*]S1 :I* \TW>DLY APPE> BEAUTIFUL1 BUT 9W>DLY >E FULL ( DEAD M5'S BONES & ( ALL UNCLEANNESS4 ,EV5 SO YE ALSO \TW>DLY APPE> RI<TE\S UNTO M51 BUT 9W>DLY YE >E FULL ( HYPOCRISY & 9IQUITY0 7,MATT1 XXIII4 #b#g1 #b#h74 

,!RE WAS A TIME :5 9 ! NAME ( ,GOD & ( TRUE FAI? 9 ,HIM1 M5 W]E DE/ROY$1 TORTUR$1 EXECUT$1 BEAT5 9 SCORES & HUNDR$S ( ?\S&S4 ,WE1 FROM ! HEI<T ( \R ATTA9M5TS1 N[ LOOK D[N UPON ! M5 :O DID !SE ?+S4 

,BUT WE >E WRONG4 ,AMONG US !RE >E MANY SU* PEOPLE2 ! DIFF]5CE LIES ONLY H]E--?AT ?OSE M5 ( OLD DID !SE ?+S !N 9 ! NAME  
( ,GOD1 & ( ,HIS TRUE S]VICE1 :IL/ N[ ?OSE :O COMMIT ! SAME EVIL AMONG US DO SO 9 ! NAME ( 0! PEOPLE10 0= ! TRUE S]VICE  
( ! PEOPLE40 ,& AS AMONG ! =M] !RE W]E M5 9SANELY SELF-CONV9C$ ?AT !Y KNEW ! TRU?1 & !RE W]E O!RS HYPOCRITES TAK+  
UP !IR POSITION UND] ! PRETEXT ( S]V+ ,GOD1 & !RE WAS A CR[D )\T CONSID]ATION FOLL[+ ! MORE DEXT]\S & BOLD1 SO ALSO N[  
?OSE :O DO EVIL 9 ! NAME ( S]V+ ! PEOPLE CONSI/ ( M5 9SANELY SELF-CONV9C$ ?AT !Y ALONE KN[ ! TRU?1 ( HYPOCRITES & ( !  
CR[D4 ,MU* EVIL HAVE ! SELF-PROCLAIM$ S]VANTS ( ,GOD DONE 9 !IR TIME1 ?ANKS TO ! TEA*+ :I* !Y CALL$ ,!OLOGY1 BUT ! S]VANTS ( ! PEOPLE1 ?ANKS TO ! TEA*+ :I* !Y CALL ,SCI5CE1 IF !Y HAVE DONE LESS EVIL IT IS ONLY BECAUSE !Y HAVE NOT YET HAD TIME TO DO IT1  
BUT ALREADY ON !IR CONSCI5CE !RE LIE RIV]S ( BLOOD & GREAT DIVISIONS & EXASP]ATION AMONG M54 

,! FEATURES ( BO? !SE ACTIVITIES >E ! SAME4 

,FIR/1 !RE IS ! DISSOLUTE BAD LIFE ( ! MAJORITY ( !SE 0S]VANTS10 BO? ( ,GOD & ( ! PEOPLE4 7,!IR CALL+ !MSELVES S]VANTS ( ,GOD OR ( ! PEOPLE1 ACCORD+ TO !IR IDEAS1 FREES !M FROM RE/RICT+ !MSELVES 9 !IR CONDUCT47 

,! SECOND FEATURE IS ! UTT] ABS5CE ( 9T]E/1 ATT5TION1 OR LOVE T[>DS ?AT :I* !Y DESIRE TO S]VE4 ,GOD1 ) !SE S]VANTS ( ,HIS1 HAS BE5 & IS ONLY A BANN]1 :IL/ 9 REALITY !SE S]VANTS ( ,HIS DID NOT SEEK  COMMUNION ) ,HIM1 DID NOT KN[1 OR DESIRE TO KN[1 ,HIM4 ,SO ALSO ) MANY ( ! S]VANTS ( ! PEOPLE--! PEOPLE >E ONLY A BANN] & !Y1 F> FROM LOV+ !M1 DO NOT SEEK COMMUNION ) !M & DO NOT KN[ !M1 BUT 9 ! DEP? ( !IR S\LS LOOK D[N UPON !M ) CONTEMPT1 DISGU/1 & FE>4 

,! ?IRD FEATURE IS ?AT :ILE !Y >E CONC]N$1 ! =M] ) ! S]VICE ( ONE & ! SAME ,GOD1 ! LATT] ) ! S]VICE ( ONE & ! SAME PEOPLE1 !Y NOT ONLY DISAGREE AMONG !MSELVES CONC]N+ ! ME?ODS ( !IR S]VICE1 BUT PRON\NCE ! ACTIVITY ( ALL :O DO NOT AGREE ) !M AS FALSE & P]NICI\S1 & DEM& ITS COMPULSORY SUSP5SION4 ,H5CE /AKES1 9QUISITIONS1 SLAU<T]S 9 ! =M] CASE1 & EXECUTIONS1 IMPRISONM5TS1 REVOLUTIONS1 & MANSLAU<T]S 9 ! LATT]4 

,F9ALLY1 ! *IEF & ! MO/ *>ACT]I/IC FEATURE ( ! ONE & ! O!R IS !IR COMPLETE 9DIFF]5CE1 !IR ABSOLUTE IGNOR+ ( ?AT :I* ! ,ONE !Y PR(ESS TO S]VE HAS /AT$ & IS /AT+ ?AT ,HE DESIRES & DEM&S4 ,GOD1 ,:OM !Y HAVE S]V$ & >E S]V+ SO ZEAL\SLY1 HAS DIRECTLY & CLE>LY EXPRESS$1 9 ?AT :I* !Y RECOGNIZE AS ,DIV9E REVELATION1 ?AT IT IS NECESS>Y TO S]VE ,HIM ONLY BY LOV+ ONE'S NEI<BOR1 BY ACT+ T[>DS EA* O!R AS ONE DESIRES O!RS TO ACT T[>DS HIMSELF4 ,BUT !Y DID NOT RECOGNIZE ?IS AS ! MEANS ( S]V+ ,GOD2 !Y DEM&$ SOME?+ QUITE DIFF]5T1 ?AT :I* !Y !MSELVES 9V5T$ & GAVE \T = ! DEM&S ( ,GOD4 ,SO LIKEWISE ACT ! S]VANTS ( ! PEOPLE--!Y DO NOT AT ALL RECOGNIZE :AT ! PEOPLE DESIRE & CLE>LY ASK =1 & !Y *OOSE TO S]VE !M ?R\< ?AT :I* ! PEOPLE NOT ONLY DO NOT ASK FROM !M1 & ( :I* !Y HAVE NOT ! SLI<TE/ IDEA1 BUT :I* !SE S]VANTS ( ! PEOPLE HAVE 9V5T$ = !M2 & NOT BY ?AT ALONE = :I* ! PEOPLE UNCEAS+LY LOOK1 & = :I* !Y UNCEAS+LY ASK4 

  

,V,I,I4 

,( ALL 9DISP5SABLE ALT]ATIONS ( ! =MS ( SOCIAL LIFE1 !RE IS 9 ! LIFE ( ! WORLD ONE :I* IS MO/ RIPE1 ONE )\T :I* NOT A S+LE /EP =W>D 9 IMPROVEM5T 9 ! LIFE ( M5 CAN BE ACCOMPLI%$4 ,! NECESSITY ( ?IS ALT]ATION IS  
OBVI\S TO EV]Y MAN :O IS FREE FROM PRECONCEIV$ !ORIES4 ,?IS ALT]ATION IS NOT ! WORK ( ,RUSSIA ALONE1 BUT ( ! :OLE WORLD4 ,ALL ! CALAMITIES ( MANK9D 9 \R TIME >E CONNECT$ ) ?IS CONDITION4 ,WE1 9 ,RUSSIA1 >E 9 ! =TUNATE POSITION ?AT ! GREAT MAJORITY ( \R PEOPLE1 LIV+ BY AGRICULTURAL LABOR1 DO NOT RECOGNIZE PRIVATE PROP]TY 9 L& & DESIRE & DEM& ! ABOLITION ( ?IS OLD ABUSE1 & DO NOT CEASE TO EXPRESS ?IS DESIRE4 

,BUT NO ONE SEES ?IS1 NO ONE WANTS TO SEE IT6 

,:5CE ?IS DREADFUL P]V]SITY8 ,:Y DO K9D1 GOOD1 9TELLIG5T M51 ( :I* !RE >E MANY AMONG ! ,LIB]ALS1 ,SOCIALI/S1 & ,REVOLUTIONI/S1 NOT EXCLUD+ EV5 ,GOV]NM5T (FICIALS--:Y DO !SE M51 DESIR+ ! PEOPLE'S WELF>E1 NOT SEE ! ONE ?+ !Y >E 9 NE$ (1 ?AT T[>DS :I* !Y UNCEAS+LY /RIVE1 & )\T :I* !Y CEASELESSLY SUFF]8 ,:Y >E !Y CONC]N$ 9/EAD ) ! MO/ V>I\S ?+S1 ! REALIZATION ( :I*1 )\T ! REALIZATION ( ?AT :I* ! PEOPLE DESIRE1 CAN 9 NO CASE CONTRIBUTE TO !IR WELF>E8 ,! :OLE ( ! ACTIVITY ( GOV]NM5TAL AS WELL AS ( ANTI-GOV]NM5TAL S]VANTS ( ! PEOPLE RESEMBLES ?AT ( A MAN :O1 :IL/ TRY+ TO HELP A HORSE /UCK 9 A BOG1 SITS 9 ! C>T & TRANSF]S FROM ONE PLACE TO ANO!R ! LOAD :I* IS 9 ! C>T1 IMAG9+ ?AT HE CAN ?US HELP MATT]S4 

,:Y IS ?IS8 

,! ANSW] TO ?IS QUE/ION IS ! SAME AS TO ALL QUE/IONS AS TO :Y PEOPLE ( \R TIME1 :O MI<T LIVE WELL & HAPPILY1 >E LIV+ BADLY & MIS]ABLY4 

,IT COMES FROM ! CIRCUM/ANCE ?AT !SE M51 BO? GOV]NM5TAL & ANTI-GOV]NM5TAL1 :O >E ORGANIZ+ ! WELF>E ( ! PEOPLE1 HAVE NO RELIGION--= )\T RELIGION MAN CANNOT HIMSELF LEAD A RATIONAL LIFE1 & /ILL LESS CAN HE KN[ :AT IS GOOD & :AT IS BAD1 :AT IS NECESS>Y & :AT UNNECESS>Y1 = O!R PEOPLE4 ,= ?IS REASON ALONE DO PEOPLE ( \R TIME 9 G5]AL1 & ! ,RUSSIAN $UCAT$ PEOPLE 9 P>TICUL>--ALTOGE!R B]EFT ( RELIGI\S CONSCI\SNESS & OP5LY  
ANN\NC+ ?IS ) PRIDE--SO P]V]SELY MISUND]/& LIFE & ! DEM&S ( ! PEOPLE !Y WI% TO S]VE1 DEM&+ = !M EV]Y?+ SAVE ! ONE ?+ :I* !Y REQUIRE4 

,)\T RELIGION ONE CANNOT REALLY LOVE M51 & )\T LOV+ M5 ONE CANNOT KN[ :AT !Y REQUIRE1 & :AT IS MORE1 & :AT IS LESS1 NECESS>Y = !M4 ,ONLY ?OSE :O >E NOT RELIGI\S1 & !RE=E DO NOT TRULY LOVE1 CAN 9V5T TRIFL+1 UNIMPORTANT IMPROVEM5TS 9 ! CONDITION ( ! PEOPLE )\T SEE+ ?AT *IEF EVIL FROM :I* O!RS >E SUFF]+1 & :I* !Y !MSELVES >E P>TLY PRODUC+4 ,ONLY SU* PEOPLE CAN PREA* MORE OR LESS CLEV]LY-CON/RUCT$ AB/RACT !ORIES SUPPOS$ TO R5D] ! PEOPLE HAPPY 9 ! FUTURE & NOT SEE ! SUFF]+S ! PEOPLE >E BE>+ 9 ! PRES5T & :I* DEM& IMM$IATE & PRACTICAL ALLEVIATION4 ,AS IT W]E1 A MAN :O HAS DEPRIV$ A HUNGRY MAN ( HIS FOOD IS GIV+ HIM HIS C\NSEL 7& ?AT ( A V]Y D\BTFUL *>ACT]7 AS TO H[ HE %\LD GET FOOD 9 ! FUTURE1 )\T DEEM+ IT NECESS>Y IMM$IATELY TO %>E ) HIM ?AT P>T ( HIS [N ABUNDANCE CONSI/+ ( ! FOOD HE HAS ACTUALLY TAK5 AWAY FROM ! MAN4 

,=TUNATELY1 GREAT B5EFICIAL MOVEM5TS 9 HUMANITY >E ACCOMPLI%$ NOT BY P>ASITES FE$+ ON ! LIFE-BLOOD ( ! PEOPLE1 :ATEV] !Y  
MAY CALL !MSELVES--,GOV]NM5TS1 ,REVOLUTIONI/S1 OR ,LIB]ALS--BUT BY RELIGI\S PEOPLE--?AT IS1 BY PEOPLE :O >E S]I\S1 SIMPLE1 LABORI\S1 & :O LIVE NOT = !IR [N PR(IT1 VANITY1 OR AMBITION1 & NOT = ! ATTA9M5T ( EXT]NAL RESULTS1 BUT = ! FULFILLM5T BE=E ,GOD ( !IR HUMAN VOCATION4 

,SU* M51 & ONLY SU*1 BY !IR NOISELESS BUT RESOLUTE ACTIVITY1 MOVE MANK9D =W>D4 ,SU* M5 WILL NOT1 DESIR+ TO DI/+UI% !MSELVES 9 ! EYES ( O!RS1 9V5T ?IS OR ?AT IMPROVEM5T 9 ! CONDITION ( ! PEOPLE 7!RE CAN BE AN 5DLESS NUMB] ( SU* IMPROVEM5TS1 & !Y >E ALL 9SIGNIFICANT IF ! *IEF ?+ IS NOT DONE71 BUT WILL 5DEAVOR TO LIVE 9 ACCORDANCE ) ! LAW ( ,GOD1 ) CONSCI5CE1 & 9 5DEAVOR+ TO LIVE SO !Y WILL NATURALLY COME ACROSS ! MO/  
OBVI\S TRANSGRESSION ( ?IS LAW1 & = !MSELVES & = O!RS WILL SE>* = ! MEANS ( FREE+ !MSELVES FROM IT4 

,! O!R DAY A DOCTOR ( MY ACQUA9TANCE :IL/ WAIT+ = A TRA9 9 ! ?IRD CLASS WAIT+-ROOM ( A BIG RAILWAY /ATION WAS READ+ A PAP]4 ,A PEASANT SITT+ BY HIM 9QUIR$ AB\T ! NEWS4 ,9 ! COPY ( ! PAP] !RE WAS AN >TICLE AB\T ! 0AGR>IAN0 CONV5TION4 ,! DOCTOR TRANSLAT$ 9TO ,RUSSIAN ?IS FUNNY WORD 0AGR>IAN10 & :5 IT WAS UND]/OOD ?AT ! QUE/ION CONC]N$ ! L&1 ! PEASANT REQUE/$ HIM TO READ ! >TICLE4 ,! DOCTOR BEGAN TO READ1 O!R PEASANTS CAME UP4 ,A SMALL CR[D COLLECT$2 !Y W]E PRESS+ ON EA* O!R'S BACKS1 SOME SITT+ ON ! FLOOR2 ! FACES ( ALL W]E SOLEMNLY CONC5TRAT$4 ,:5 ! READ+ WAS OV]1 ONE ( ! H9DMO/1 AN OLD MAN1 SI<$ DEEPLY & CROSS$ HIMSELF4 ,?IS MAN1 = C]TA91 DID NOT UND]/& ANY?+ ( ! CONFUS$ J>GON 9 :I* ! >TICLE WAS WRITT51 & :I* IT IS DIFFICULT TO UND]/& EV5 = ?OSE :O KN[ H[ TO TALK ?IS J>GON !MSELVES4 ,HE UND]/OOD NO?+ ( :AT WAS WRITT5 9 ! >TICLE1 BUT HE UND]/OOD ?AT ! MATT] CONC]N$ ! GREAT1 ! OLD S9 FROM :I* ALL HIS ANCE/ORS HAD SUFF]$ & FROM :I* HE ALSO SUFF]S2 HE UND]/OOD ?AT ?OSE :O >E COMMITT+ ?IS S9 >E BECOM+ CONSCI\S ( IT4 ,& HAV+ UND]/OOD ?IS1 HE M5TALLY TURN$ TO ,GOD & CROSS$ HIMSELF4 ,9 ?IS ONE MOVEM5T ( ?IS MAN'S H& !RE IS MORE MEAN+ & CONT5T ?AN 9 ALL ! PRATTLE :I* N[ FILLS ! COLUMNS ( ! PAP]S4 ,?IS MAN UND]/&S1 AS DOES ! :OLE ( ! PEOPLE1 ?AT ! SEIZURE ( ! L& BY ?OSE :O DO NOT CULTIVATE IT IS A GREAT S91 UND] :I* HIS ANCE/ORS PHYSICALLY SUFF]$ & P]I%$1 & UND] :I* HE HIMSELF & HIS NEI<BORS ALSO PHYSICALLY SUFF]1 :ILE ALL ! TIME ?OSE :O  
HAVE COMMITT$ ?IS S9 & :O >E N[ COMMITT+ IT1 SPIRITUALLY SUFF]--& ?AT ?IS S91 LIKE EV]Y S9--LIKE1 9 HIS MEMORY1 ! S9 ( S]FDOM--MU/ 9EVITABLY COME TO AN 5D4 ,HE KN[S & FEELS ?IS1 & !RE=E HE CANNOT BUT TURN TO ,GOD AT ! ?\<T ( ! APPROA* (  
! SOLUTION4 

  

,V,I,I,I4 

0,GREAT SOCIAL RE=MS10 SAYS ,MAZZ9I1 0ALWAYS HAVE BE5 & WILL BE ! RESULT ( GREAT RELIGI\S MOVEM5TS40 

,SU* IS ! RELIGI\S MOVEM5T :I* IS N[ P5D+ = ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE1 = ALL ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE1 = ! WORK+ CLASSES DEPRIV$ ( L& AS WELL AS1 & ESPECIALLY =1 ! BIG1 M$IUM1 & SMALL L&[N]S1 & = ALL ?OSE HUNDR$S ( ?\S&S ( M5 :O1 AL?\< !Y DO NOT DIRECTLY POSSESS L&1 YET OCCUPY AN ADVANTAGE\S POSITION1 ?ANKS TO ! COMPULSORY LABOR ( ! PEOPLE :O >E DEPRIV$ ( L&4 

,! RELIGI\S MOVEM5T N[ DUE AMONG ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE CONSI/S 9 UNDO+ ! GREAT S9 :I* = A LONG TIME HAS BE5 HURT+ & IS DIVID+ M51 NOT ONLY 9 ,RUSSIA1 BUT 9 ALL ! WORLD4 

,?IS S9 CAN BE UNDONE1 NOT BY POLITICAL RE=M1 NOR ,SOCIALI/IC S*EMES = ! FUTURE1 NOT BY REVOLUTIONS 9 ! PRES5T1 & /ILL LESS BY PHILAN?ROPIC ASSI/ANCE OR GOV]NM5TAL ORGANIZATION = ! PUR*ASE & DI/RIBUTION ( L& AMONG ! PEASANTS4 

,SU* PALLIATIVE MEASURES ONLY DI/RACT ATT5TION FROM ! ESS5CE ( ! PROBLEM & ?US RET>D ITS SOLUTION4 

,NO >TIFICIAL SACRIFICES >E NECESS>Y1 NO CONC]N AB\T ! PEOPLE !RE IS ONLY NECESS>Y ! CONSCI\SNESS ( ?IS S9 BY ALL ?OSE :O COMMIT OR P>TICIPATE 9 IT1 & ! DESIRE TO FREE !MSELVES FROM IT4 

,IT IS ONLY NECESS>Y ?AT ! UND5IABLE TRU? :I* ! BE/ M5 ( ! PEOPLE ALWAYS KNEW & KN[--?AT ! L& CANNOT BE ! EXCLUSIVE PROP]TY ( SOME1 & ?AT ! NON-ADMISSION TO ! L& ( ?OSE :O >E 9 NE$ ( IT IS A S9--?AT ?IS TRU? %\LD BECOME G5]ALLY RECOGNIZ$ BY ALL M52 ?AT PEOPLE %\LD BECOME A%AM$ ( RETA9+ ! L& FROM ?OSE :O WANT TO FE$ !MSELVES FROM IT2 ?AT IT %\LD BECOME A %AME 9 ANY WAY TO P>TICIPATE 9 ?IS RET5TION ( ! L& FROM ?OSE :O NE$ IT1 A %AME TO POSSESS L&1 A %AME TO PR(IT BY ! LABOR ( M5 COMPELL$ TO WORK ONLY BECAUSE !Y HAVE BE5 DEPRIV$ ( !IR LEGITIMATE RI<T TO ! L&4 

 ,IT IS NECESS>Y ?AT !RE %\LD OCCUR ?AT :I* TOOK PLACE ) ! LAW ( S]FDOM :5 NOBLES & L&[N]S BECAME A%AM$ TO POSSESS S]FS1 ! ,GOV]NM5T BECAME A%AM$ ( MA9TA9+ !SE UNJU/ & CRUEL LAWS1 :5 IT BECAME EVID5T TO ! PEASANTS !MSELVES ?AT AN UTT]LY UNJU/IFIABLE 9IQUITY WAS BE+ COMMITT$ UPON !M4 ,! SAME MU/ TAKE PLACE ALSO ) L&$ PROP]TY4 ,& ?IS IS NECESS>Y1 NOT = ANY ONE CLASS1 H[EV] NUM]\S IT MAY BE1 BUT IT IS NECESS>Y = ALL CLASSES1 & NOT ONLY = ALL CLASSES & ALL M5 ( ANY ONE C\NTRY1 BUT = ! :OLE ( MANK9D4 

  

,I,X4 

,SOCIAL RE=M IS NOT TO BE SECUR$ BY NOISE & %\T+1 BY COMPLA9TS & D5UNCIATION1 BY ! =MATION ( P>TIES OR ! MAK+ ( REVOLUTIONS 7WROTE ,H5RY ,GEORGE71 BUT BY ! AWAK5+ ( ?\<T & ! PROGRESS ( IDEAS4 ,UNTIL !RE BE CORRECT ?\<T !RE CANNOT BE RI<T ACTION1 & :5 !RE IS CORRECT ?\<T RI<T ACTION WILL FOLL[4 4 4 4 

,! GREAT WORK ( ! PRES5T = EV]Y MAN & EV]Y ORGANIZATION ( M5 :O W\LD IMPROVE SOCIAL CONDITIONS IS ! WORK ( $UCATION1 ! PROPAGATION ( IDEAS4 ,IT IS ONLY AS IT AIDS ?IS ?AT ANY?+ ELSE CAN AVAIL4 ,& 9 ?IS WORK EV]Y ONE :O CAN ?9K MAY AID1 FIR/ BY =M+ CLE> IDEAS HIMSELF & !N BY 5DEAVOR+ TO >\SE ! ?\<T ( ?OSE ) :OM HE COMES 9  

CONTACT4.<#a#a.> 

,?IS IS QUITE TRUE2 BUT1 9 ORD] TO S]VE ?IS GREAT CAUSE1 BESIDES ?\<T !RE MU/ ALSO BE SOME?+ MORE A RELIGI\S FEEL+ ?AT FEEL+ [+ TO :I* 9 ! LA/ C5TURY ! [N]S ( S]FS RECOGNIZ$ !MSELVES CULPABLE1 &1 NOT)/&+ P]SONAL LOSS & EV5 RU91 S\<T ! MEANS ( FREE+ !MSELVES FROM ! S9 :I* WEI<$ UPON !M4 

 ,IT IS ?IS FEEL+ 9 REG>D TO L&$ PROP]TY :I* MU/ AWAK5 9 ! WELL-TO-DO CLASSES 9 ORD] ?AT ! GREAT WORK ( ! LIB]ATION ( ! L& %\LD BE ACCOMPLI%$2 ?IS FEEL+ %\LD  
AWAK5 9 SU* A DEGREE ?AT PEOPLE %\LD BE READY TO SACRIFICE EV]Y?+ IF ONLY !Y CAN FREE !MSELVES FROM ! S9 9 :I* !Y HAVE LIV$ & >E LIV+4 

,POSSESS+ HUNDR$S1 ?\S&S1 SCORES ( ?\S&S ( ACRES1 TRAD+ 9 L&1 PR(IT+ ONE WAY OR ! O!R BY L&$ PROP]TY1 & LIV+ LUXURI\SLY1 ?ANKS TO ! OPPRESSION ( ! PEOPLE1 POSSIBLE ?R\< ?IS CRUEL & OBVI\S 9JU/ICE--TO >GUE 9 V>I\S COMMITTEES & ASSEMBLIES AB\T ! IMPROVEM5T ( ! CONDITIONS ( ! PEASANT'S LIFE )\T SURR5D]+ ONE'S [N EXCLUSIVELY ADVANTAGE\S POSITION GR[+ FROM ?IS 9JU/ICE1 IS NOT ONLY AN UNK9D BUT A DETE/ABLE & EVIL ?+1 EQUALLY CONDEMNABLE BY COMMON S5SE1 HONE/Y1 & ,*RI/IANITY4 ,IT IS NECESS>Y1 NOT TO 9V5T CUNN+ DEVICES = ! IMPROVEM5T ( M5 DEPRIV$ ( !IR LAWFUL RI<T TO ! L&1 BUT TO UND]/& ONE'S [N S9 9 RELATION TO !M1 & BE=E ALL ELSE TO CEASE TO P>TICIPATE 9 IT1 :ATEV] ?IS MAY CO/4 ,ONLY SU* MORAL ACTIVITY ( EV]Y MAN CAN & WILL CONTRIBUTE TO ! SOLUTION ( ! QUE/ION N[ /&+ BE=E HUMANITY4 

,! EMANCIPATION ( ! S]FS 9 ,RUSSIA WAS EFFECT$ NOT BY ,ALEX&] ,I,I41 BUT BY ?OSE M5 :O UND]/OOD ! S9 ( S]FDOM1 & 9DEP5D5TLY ( !IR [N ADVANTAGES 5DEAVOR$ TO FREE !MSELVES FROM IT1 & IT WAS *IEFLY EFFECT$ BY SU* M5 AS ,NOVIK(F1 ,RADIS*EFF1 ! ,DECEMBRI/S1.<#a#b.> ?OSE M5 :O W]E READY TO SUFF] & DID !MSELVES SUFF] 7)\T MAK+ ANY ONE ELSE SUFF]7 9 ! NAME ( LOYALTY TO ?AT :I* !Y RECOGNIZ$ AS ! TRU?4 

,! SAME MU/ TAKE PLACE 9 RELATION TO ! L&4 

,I BELIEVE ?AT !RE DO N[ EXI/ SU* M51 & ?AT !Y WILL FULFILL ?AT GREAT WORK NOT ONLY ,RUSSIAN1 BUT UNIV]SAL1 :I* IS BE=E ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE4 

,! L& QUE/ION HAS AT ! PRES5T TIME REA*$ SU* A /ATE ( RIP5ESS AS FIFTY YE>S AGO WAS REA*$ BY ! QUE/ION ( S]FDOM4 ,EXACTLY ! SAME IS BE+ REPEAT$4 ,AS AT ?AT TIME M5 SE>*$ = ! MEANS ( REM$Y+ ! G5]AL UNEAS9ESS & DISSATISFACTION :I* W]E FELT 9 SOCIETY1 & APPLI$ ALL K9DS ( EXT]NAL GOV]NM5TAL MEANS1 BUT NO?+ HELP$ NOR C\LD HELP :IL/ !RE REMA9$ ! RIP5+ & UNSOLV$ QUE/ION ( P]SONAL SLAV]Y1 SO ALSO N[ NO EXT]NAL MEASURES WILL HELP OR CAN HELP UNTIL ! RIPE QUE/ION ( L&$ PROP]TY BE SOLV$4 ,AS N[ MEASURES >E PROPOS$ = ADD+ SLICES TO ! PEASANTS' L&1 = ! PUR*ASE ( L& BY ! AID ( BANKS1 ETC41 SO !N ALSO PALLIATIVE MEASURES W]E PROPOS$ & 5ACT$1 MAT]IAL IMPROVEM5TS1 RULES AB\T ?REE DAYS' LABOR1 & SO =?4 ,EV5 AS N[ ! [N]S ( L& TALK AB\T ! 9JU/ICE ( PUTT+ A /OP TO !IR CRIM9AL [N]%IP1 SO !N PEOPLE TALK$ AB\T ! UNLAWFULNESS ( DEPRIV+ [N]S ( !IR S]FS4 ,AS !N ! ,*UR* JU/IFI$ ! S]F RI<T1 SO N[ ?AT :I* OCCUPIES ! PLACE ( ! ,*UR*--,SCI5CE--JU/IFIES L&$ PROP]TY4 ,JU/ AS !N SLAVE-[N]S1 REALIZ+ !IR S91 MORE OR LESS 5DEAVOR$ 9 V>I\S WAYS )\T UNDO+ IT TO MITIGATE IT1 & SUB/ITUT+ ! PAYM5T ( A RANSOM BY ! S]FS = DIRECT COMPULSORY WORK = !IR MA/]S1 MOD]AT$ !IR EXACTIONS FROM ! PEASANTS1 SO ALSO N[ ! MORE S5SITIVE  L&[N]S1 FEEL+ !IR GUILT1 5DEAVOR TO R$EEM IT BY R5T+ !IR L& TO ! PEASANTS ON MORE L5I5T CONDITIONS1 BY SELL+ IT ?R\< ! PEASANT BANKS1 BY >RANG+ S*OOLS = ! PEOPLE1 RIDICUL\S H\SES ( RECREATION1 MAGIC LANT]N LECTURES1 & !AT]S4 

,EXACTLY ! SAME ALSO IS ! 9DIFF]5T ATTITUDE ( ! ,GOV]NM5T TO ! QUE/ION4 ,& AS !N ! QUE/ION WAS SOLV$1 NOT BY ?OSE :O 9V5T$ >TFUL DEVICES = ! ALLEVIATION & IMPROVEM5T ( ! CONDITION ( PEASANT LIFE1 BUT BY ?OSE :O1 RECOGNIZ+ ! URG5T NECESSITY ( ! RI<T SOLUTION1 DID NOT PO/PONE IT 9DEF9ITELY1 DID NOT =ESEE SPECIAL DIFFICULTIES 9 IT1 BUT IMM$IATELY1 /RAI<T (F1 5DEAVOR$ TO >RE/ ! EVIL & DID NOT ADMIT ! IDEA ?AT !RE C\LD BE CONDITIONS 9 :I* EVIL ONCE RECOGNIZ$ MU/ CONT9UE1 BUT TOOK ?AT C\RSE :I* UND] ! EXI/+ CONDITIONS APPE>$ ! BE/--! SAME N[ ALSO ) ! L& QUE/ION4 

,! QUE/ION WILL BE SOLV$1 NOT BY ?OSE :O WILL 5DEAVOR TO MITIGATE ! EVIL OR TO 9V5T ALLEVIATIONS = ! PEOPLE OR TO PO/PONE ! TASK ( ! FUTURE1 BUT BY ?OSE :O WILL UND]/& ?AT1 H[EV] ONE MAY MITIGATE A WRONG1 IT REMA9S A WRONG1 & ?AT IT IS S5SELESS TO 9V5T ALLEVIATIONS = A MAN WE >E TORTUR+ & ?AT ONE CANNOT PO/PONE :5 PEOPLE >E SUFF]+1 BUT %\LD IMM$IATELY TAKE ! BE/ WAY ( SOLV+ ! DIFFICULTY & IMM$IATELY APPLY IT 9 PRACTICE4 ,& ! MORE %\LD IT BE SO ?AT ! ME?OD ( SOLV+ ! L& PROBLEM HAS BE5 ELABORAT$ BY  
,H5RY ,GEORGE TO SU* A DEGREE ( P]FECTION ?AT1 UND] ! EXI/+ ,/ATE ORGANIZATION & COMPULSORY TAXATION.<#a#c.> IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO 9V5T ANY O!R BETT]1 MORE JU/1 PRACTICAL1 & PEACEFUL SOLUTION4 

0,TO BEAT D[N & COV] UP ! TRU? ?AT ,I HAVE TRI$ TO-NI<T TO MAKE CLE> TO Y\10 SAID ,H5RY ,GEORGE1 0SELFI%NESS WILL CALL ON IGNORANCE4 ,BUT IT HAS 9 IT ! G]M9ATIVE =CE ( TRU?1 & ! TIMES >E RIPE = IT4 4 4 4 

0,! GR\ND IS PL[$2 ! SE$ IS SET2 ! GOOD TREE WILL GR[4 ,SO LITTLE N[2 ONLY ! EYE ( FAI? CAN SEE IT40.<#a#d.> 

,& ,I ?9K ?AT ,H5RY ,GEORGE IS RI<T1 ?AT ! REMOVAL ( ! S9 ( L&$ PROP]TY IS NE>1 ?AT ! MOVEM5T CALL$ =? BY ,H5RY ,GEORGE WAS ! LA/ BIR?-?ROE1 & ?AT ! BIR? IS ON ! PO9T ( TAK+ PLACE2 ! LIB]ATION ( M5 FROM ! SUFF]+S !Y HAVE SO LONG BORNE MU/ N[ BE REALIZ$4 ,BESIDES ?IS ,I ?9K 7& ,I W\LD LIKE TO CONTRIBUTE TO ?IS1 9 H[EV] SMALL A MEASURE7 ?AT ! REMOVAL ( ?IS GREAT UNIV]SAL S9--A REMOVAL :I* WILL =M AN EPO* 9 ! HI/ORY ( MANK9D--IS TO BE EFFECT$ PRECISELY BY ! ,RUSSIAN ,SLAVONIAN PEOPLE1 :O >E1 BY !IR SPIRITUAL & ECONOMIC *>ACT]1 PR$E/9$ = ?IS GREAT UNIV]SAL TASK--?AT ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE %\LD NOT BECOME PROLET>IANS 9 IMITATION ( ! PEOPLES ( ,EUROPE & ,AM]ICA1 BUT1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 ?AT !Y %\LD SOLVE ! L& QUE/ION AT  
HOME BY ! ABOLITION ( L&$ PROP]TY1 & %[ O!R NATIONS ! WAY TO A RATIONAL1 FREE1 & HAPPY LIFE1 \TSIDE 9DU/RIAL1 FACTORY1 OR CAPITALI/IC CO]CION & SLAV]Y--?AT 9 ?IS LIES !IR GREAT HI/ORICAL CALL+4 

,I W\LD LIKE TO ?9K ?AT WE ,RUSSIAN P>ASITES1 RE>$ BY & HAV+ RECEIV$ LEISURE = M5TAL WORK ?R\< ! PEOPLE'S LABOR1 WILL UND]/& \R S91 &1 9DEP5D5TLY ( \R P]SONAL ADVANTAGE1 9 ! NAME ( ! TRU? ?AT CONDEMNS US1 WILL 5DEAVOR TO UNDO IT4 

  

,YASNAYA ,POLIANA1 ,JULY1 #a#i#e4  

4MW-P>S]-\TPUT 4W/-SMALLREFS_<FONT-SIZE3#h#c.02CLE>3BO?2L9E-HEI<T3#a4#b#e_> 

8 ,KVAS1 A COMMON ,RUSSIAN BEV]AGE PREP>$ FROM BLACK RYE BREAD4 7,TRANS74 

8 ,A RUBLE IS AB\T TWO %ILL+S4 7,TRANS74 

8 ,! ,WORKS ( ,H5RY ,GEORGE1 ,VOL4 ,I,X41 P4 #a#i#i4 

8 ,IBID41 ,VOL4 ,I,X41 P4 #b#b4 

8 ,IBID41 ,VOL4 ,I,X41 PP4 #b#b-#b#c4 

8 ,IBID41 ,VOL4 ,I,X41 P4 #b#d4 

8 ,IBID41 ,VOL4 ,I,X41 PP4 #b#e-#b#f4 

8 ,IBID41 ,VOL4 ,I,X41 PP4 #b#d-#b#e4 

8 ,SPITZRU!NS--/ICKS US$ BY SOLDI]S :5 ONE ( !M IS CONDEMN$ TO RUN ! GANTLET1 A PUNI%M5T :I* ! VICTIM (T5 DID NOT SURVIVE4 7,TRANS47 

8 ,! ,WORKS ( ,H5RY ,GEORGE1 ,VOL4 ,X44 P4 #e#a#f4 

8 0,SOCIAL ,PROBLEMS10 BY ,H5RY ,GEORGE 7,KEGAN ,PAUL1 ,TR5*1 ,TRUBN] & ,CO471 PP4 #b#b#i-#b#c4 

8 ,RUSSIAN ,RADICAL RE=M]S AT ! 5D ( #a#h? & COMM5CEM5T ( ! #a#i? C5TURIES1 :O OPPOS$ ! ,GOV]NM5T & SUFF]$ P]SECUTION AT ITS H&S4 7,TRANS74 

8 ,9 VIEW ( A SEEM+ CONTRADICTION 9 ! EYES ( SOME READ]S ( ,TOL/OY BETWE5 HIS SUPPORT ( ,H5RY ,GEORGE'S S*EME & HIS SIMULTANE\S D5IAL ( ALL CO]CIVE ,/ATE P[]1 IT IS IMPORTANT TO PAY P>TICUL> ATT5TION TO !SE WORDS ITALICIZ$ BY ! AU?OR HIMSELF4 ,TOL/OY H]E EMPHASIZES A RES]VATION1 ?AT HE RECOMM5DS ,H5RY ,GEORGE'S S*EME ONLY UND] CONDITIONS ( ,/ATE ORGANIZATION & COMPULSORY TAXATION4 ,IT GOES )\T SAY+1 ?AT IF ! ,*RI/IAN TEA*+ AS ,TOL/OY UND]/&S IT W]E TO BE ?OR\<LY APPLI$ TO LIFE1 !N !RE W\LD BE NEI!R CO]CIVE GOV]NM5T NOR COMPULSORY TAXATION1 & 9 ! DI/RIBUTION ( ! L& !RE W\LD BE PRACTIC$ AMONG M5 A VOLUNT>Y AGREEM5T ( A YET FRE] & MORE JU/ K9D ?AN ! S+LE TAX SY/EM ( ,H5RY ,GEORGE4 7,TRANS74 

8 ,! ,WORKS ( ,H5RY ,GEORGE1 ,VOL4 ,X41 P4 #b#i#f4 

7,S\RCE3 ,TRANSLAT$ BY ,ISABELLA ,FYVIE ,MAYO & ,VLADIMIR ,GRIGORIEVIT* ,T*]TK(F47 

,FROM 3 ,WIKIS\RCE4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #aid 3 ,A ,GREAT ,9IQUITY -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,JULY #a#f1 #bba 3 ,A ,GREAT ,9IQUITY -- ,ADD$4 
,JANU>Y #i1 #bbb 3 ,A ,GREAT ,9IQUITY -- ,UPDAT$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/