,A ,TALK ,AB\T ,AN>*I/ ,COMMUNISM ,BETWE5 ,TWO ,WORK]S 

#aicc 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,]RICO ,MALATE/A 

,TAGS 3 PUT EV]Y?+ 9 COMMON1 ALL 9/RUM5TS ( LABOR1 TO WORK 9 COMMON1 WORK 9 ! FIELDS1 BE FREE TO *OOSE1 EA* ASSOCIATION ( WORK]S1 9T]NATIONAL WORK+ M5'S ASSOCIATION1 9/RUM5TS ( LABOR1 EV]Y?+ 9 COMMON1 RI* & POOR4 

,TEXT 3 

  

,PHOTO BY PAVEL IVA%KOV1,C,C ,B,Y-,N,C-,S,A ,LIC5SE ,WILLIAM4 ,AH ,JACK1 IS ?AT Y\8 ,I'M GLAD TO MEET Y\4 ,I'VE BE5 WANT+ A TALK ) Y\ = A LONG TIME4 ,OH1 ,JACK6 ,JACK6 ,:AT HAVE ,I HE>D AB\T Y\6 ,:5 Y\ LIV$ 9 ! C\NTRY Y\ W]E A GOOD LAD1 QUITE AN EXAMPLE TO ! Y\NG FELL[S ( Y\R AGE--,IF Y\R POOR FA!R W]E ALIVE-- 

,JACK4 ,WILLIAM1 :Y >E Y\ SPEAK+ TO ME LIKE ?IS8 ,:AT HAVE ,I DONE ?AT Y\ REPROA* ME8 ,& :Y W\LD MY POOR FA!R HAVE BE5 DISSATISFI$ ) ME8 

,WILLIAM4 ,DON'T BE (F5D$ AT MY WORDS1 ,JACK4 ,I AM AN OLD MAN & ,I SPEAK = Y\R GOOD4 ,& BESIDES ,I WAS SU* FRI5DS ) OLD ,&REW1 Y\R FA!R1 ?AT ,I AM AS VEX$ TO SEE Y\ GO A/RAY AS ?\< Y\ W]E MY [N SON1 ESPECIALLY :5 ,I ?9K ( ! HOPES Y\R FA!R HAD ( Y\ & ! SACRIFICES HE MADE TO LEAVE Y\ A GOOD NAME4 

,JACK4 ,BUT ,WILLIAM1 :AT >E Y\ TALK+ AB\T8 ,AM ,I NOT AN HONE/ WORK+ MAN8 ,I'VE NEV] DONE ANY H>M TO ANY ONE1 & EXCUSE ME IF ,I SAY ?AT ,I'VE ALWAYS DONE AS MU* GOOD AS ,I C\LD2 SO :Y %\LD MY FA!R HAVE BE5 A%AM$ ( ME8 ,I DO MY BE/ TO LE>N & IMPROVE1 & MY MAT] & ,I >E TRY+ TO HIT UPON A REM$Y = ! EVILS :I* AFFLICT US ALL2 H[ !N HAVE ,I DES]V$ ?AT Y\ %\LD PIT* 9 IT ME LIKE ?IS8 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,AH1 ?AT IS JU/ IT6 ,I KN[ WELL 5\< ?AT Y\ WORK & HELP Y\R NEI<BORS4 ,Y\'RE A GOOD SORT ( *AP2 EV]YBODY 9 ! C\NTRYSIDE SAYS ?AT ( Y\4 ,BUT IT IS NONE ! LESS TRUE ?AT Y\ HAVE BE5 9 PRISON SEV]AL TIMES1 & PEOPLE SAY ?AT Y\ >E WAT*$ BY ! POLICE1 & ?AT EV5 TO BE SE5 ) Y\ IS 5\< TO GET ONE 9TO TR\BLE4 ,I'M MAYBE MAK+ ?+S AWKW>D = MYSELF ?IS V]Y MOM5T4 ,BUT ,I WI% Y\ WELL1 & ,I WILL SPEAK TO Y\ ALL ! SAME4 ,JACK1 LI/5 TO ! ADVICE ( AN OLD MAN2 BELIEVE ME Y\ HAD BE/ LEAVE POLITICS TO ! G5TLEM5 :O HAVE NO?+ TO DO1 & ONLY TR\BLE Y\RSELF AB\T WORK+ & DO+ :AT IS RI<T4 ,?AT IS ! WAY TO LIVE PEACEABLY & HAPPILY2 IF Y\ DON'T Y\ WILL BE LO/1 BODY & S\L4 ,LI/5 TO ME & GIVE UP Y\R BAD COMPANY2 = IT IS ?AT1 AS EV]YONE KN[S1 ?AT LEADS POOR LADS A/RAY4 

 ,JACK4 ,BELIEVE ME1 ,WILLIAM1 MY COMPANIONS >E FIR/-RATE FELL[S2 ! BREAD !Y EAT IS WAT]$ ) !IR SWEAT AD SOMETIMES ) !IR TE>S4 ,LEAVE ! MA/]S TO SPEAK ILL ( !M2 M5 :O W\LD LIKE TO SUCK ! LA/ DROP ( \R BLOOD1 & !N TREAT US AS BLACK-GU>DS & JAIL-BIRDS IF WE TRY TO BETT] \RSELVES & ESCAPE FROM !IR TYRANNY4 ,MY COMPANIONS & ,I HAVE BE5 IMPRISON1 IT IS TRUE1 BUT IT WAS = A GOOD CAUSE2 WE %ALL GO AGA91 & P]HAPS SOME?+ WORSE MAY BEFALL US1 BUT IT WILL BE = ! GOOD ( ALL1 & E CAUSE WE WI% TO DE/ROY 9JU/ICE & MIS]Y4 ,Y\ :O HAVE TOIL$ ALL Y\R LIFE & SUFF]$ LIKE US FROM HUNG]--Y\ :O P]HAPS WILL HAVE TO GO 9TO A WORKH\SE TO DIE :5 Y\ CAN TOIL NO LONG]--Y\1 AT LEA/1 \<T NOT TO PUT Y\RSELF ON ! SIDE ( ! G5TLEFOLKS & ! GOV]NM5T & FALL UPON ?OSE :O TRY TO IMPROVE ! LOT ( ! POOR4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,MY DE> BOY1 ,I KN[ ?AT ! WORLD GOES ON V]Y BADLY1 BUT TO TRY TO *ANGE IT IS LIKE TRY+ TO /RAI<T5 ! LEGS ( A B&Y-LEGG$ DOG4 ,SO LET US TAKE ?+S AS !Y >E1 & PRAY ,GOD ?AT AT LEA/ WE MAY NEV] BE 9 WANT ( A CRU/ ( BREAD4 ,!RE HAVE ALWAYS BE5 RI* & POOR1 & WE1 :O >E BORN TO LABOR1 \<T TO WORK & BE CONT5T$ ) :AT ,GOD S5DS US1 O!RWISE WE DI/URB ! PUBLIC PEACE & 9JURE \R [N *>ACT]4 

 ,JACK4 ,\R *>ACT]6 ,LOOK AT !SE G5TLEFOLKS1 AS Y\ CALL !M4 ,FIR/ ( ALL1 !Y TAKE EV]Y?+ FROM US1 & MAKE US TOIL LIKE BEA/ ( BURD5 TO E>N A CRU/ ( BREAD1 :IL/ !Y >E LIV+ LUXURI\SLY & IDLY ON ! SWEAT ( \R BR[1 & !N1 IF WE DON'T SUBMIT *E]FULLY TO SEE !M GR[+ FAT AT \R EXP5SE1 ! SAY WE >E A BAD1 DI%ONE/ LOT1 ! POLICEMAN COMES & DRAGS US TO PRISON & ! CL]GYMAN S5DS US TO HELL4 ,I TELL Y\ :AT1 ,WILLIAM1 ! REAL RASCALS & BAD *>ACT]S >E ?OSE :O LIVE BY OPPRESSION1 ?OSE :O HAVE TAK5 POSSESSION ( EV]Y?+ UND] ! SUN & HAVE GR\ND D[N ! WORK]S UNTIL !Y >E LIKE A FLOCK ( %EEP1 QUIETLY ALL[+ !MSELVES TO BE %ORN & SLAU<T]$4 ,& Y\1 Y\ HAVE NEV] SUCK$ ! LIFE-BLOOD \T ( Y\R FELL[-M51 DO Y\ TAKE ! P>T ( PEOPLE :O DO SU* ?+S1 DO Y\ TURN UPON US8 ,ISN'T IT 5\< = !M TO HAVE ! ,GOV]NM5T TO BACK !M UP8 ,GOV]NM5T IS MADE BY ! RI* = ! B5EFIT ( ! RI* & IS B\ND TO BE ON !IR SIDE1 BUT MU/ ! WORK]S1 \R [N BRO!RS TURN AGA9/ US JU/ BECAUSE WE WANT !M TO HAVE BREAD & FRE$OM8 ,AH6 ,IF IT W]5'T ?AT ,I REMEMB] ALL ! LONG AGES ( MIS]Y & S]VITUDE & DEGRAD$ HABITS ! POOR HAVE SUFF]$1 ,I %\LD SAY ?AT ! WOR/ PEOPLE ( ALL1 ?OSE :O HAVE ! LEA/ ( ! DIGNITY ( MAN1 >E ! POOR :O LET !MSELVES BE MADE ! TOOLS ( ! OPPRESSORS ( HUMANITY4 ,AS = US1 AT LEA/ WE >E RISK+ ! BIT ( BREAD & %R$ ( LIB]TY WE HAVE ?AT WE MAY BR+ AB\T A /ATE ( ?+S 9 :I* ALL MAY BE HAPPY4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,WELL1 ALL S\NDS V]Y F9E2 BUT Y\ KN[1 MY LAD1 ?AT )\T ! FE> ( ,GOD NO GOOD ?+ IS POSSIBLE & WE MU/ ALL SUBMIT TO ,HIS WILL4 

 ,JACK4 ,N[1 ,WILLIAM1 IF WE >E GO+ TO TALK REASONABLE1 DO LET US LEAVE ,GOD \T ( ! QUE/ION1 BECAUSE ! NAME ( ,GOD IS US$ AS A PRETEXT & JU/IFICATION BY ALL ?OSE ?AT >E TRY+ TO DECEIVE & OPPRESS !IR FELL[ M54 ,K+S PRET5D ?AT ,GOD HAS GIV5 !M ! RI<T TO REIGN1 & :5 TWO K+S DISPUTE AB\T ! CR[N ( A C\NTRY1 !Y BO? PRET5D TO HOLD !IR COMMISSIONS FROM ,GOD4 ,NEV]!LESS ,GOD GIVES ! VICTORY TO HIM :O HAS MO/ SOLDI]S OR ! BE/ >MS4 ,! PROPRIETOR1 ! EXPLOIT]1 ! MONOPOLI/1 ALL SPEAK ( ,GOD4 ,! ,CA?OLIC PRIE/1 ! ,PROTE/ANT1 ! ,JEWI%1 ! ,TURKI%1 ALL ALIKE CAL !MSELVES ! REPRES5TATIVE ( ,GOD1 & IT IS 9 ! NAME ( ,GOD ?AT !Y MAKE W> UPON ONE ANO!R & TRY TO BR+ GRI/ EA* ONE TO HIS [N MILL4 ,!Y ALL SEEM TO ?9K ?AT ,GOD HAS GIV5 EV]Y?+ TO !M & CONDEMN$ US ALL TO MIS]Y & GR9D+ TOIL4 ,!Y >E TO HAVE ,P>ADISE 9 ?IS WORLD & ! NEXT TOO2 BUT WE >E TO HAVE ,HELL 9 ?IS LIFE1 & ONLY TO HAVE ,P>ADISE 9 ! NEXT IF H]E WE >E OB$I5T SLAVES4 ,N[ IS Y\ COME & TELL ME ?AT & ,GOD HAS REALLY WILL$ & DESIR$ SU* & >RANGEM5TS ?IS1 ,I CAN ONLY SAY ?AT HE IS A V]Y WICK$ ONE4 ,LE/ EV]Y ONE BELIEVE AS HE ?9KS RI<T1 BUT :5 WE >E DISCUSS+ ! /ATE ( ?+S 9 ?IS WORLD1 LET US /ICK TO :AT WE KN[ SOME?+ AB\T & SEE IF IT ISN'T POSSIBLE TO GET A LITTLE HAPP9ESS 9 ?IS LIFE = \RSELVES & \R FELL[M52 = Y\ KN[ ?AT ! P>SON HIMSELF SAYS ?AT ALL M5 >E ,GOD'S *ILDR5 & !RE=E BRO!RS4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ',PON MY WORD1 Y\NG MAN1 S9CE Y\'VE BE5 TO ! T[N & TAKE TO READ+ & WRIT+1 Y\'VE GOT A WAY ( SPEAK+ ?AT W\LD PUZZLE A LAWY]4 ,BUT N[ TELL ME1 IS IT REALLY TRUE1 AS !Y SAY1 ?AT Y\ WANT TO /EAL ALL ! PROP]TY ( AYE ONE :O HAS GOT ANY8 

 ,JACK4 ,GOOD6 ,N[ AT LA/ WE'VE COME TO ! PO9T4 ,NO1 ?AT IS NOT TRUE1 WE DON'T WANT TO /EAL ANY?+ :ATEV]4 ,:AT WE DO WI% IS ?AT ! ,PEOPLE %\LD TAKE ! PROP]TY ( ! RI* & MAKE IT COMMON1 = ! B5EFIT TO ALL4 ,?AT W\LD NOT BE /EAL+1 ! ,PEOPLE W\LD SIMPLY BE TAK+ AGA9 :AT IS !IR [N4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,:AT6 ,DO Y\ MEAN TO SAY ?AT ! G5TLEFOLKS' PROP]TY IS \RS8 

 ,JACK4 ,C]TA9LY2 IT IS \R PROP]TY2 IT IS EV]YBODY'S PROP]TY4 ,:O GAVE IT TO ! RI* PEOPLE8 ,H[ HAVE !Y E>N$ IT8 ,:AT RI<T HAD !Y TO SEIZE UPON IT & :AT RI<T HAVE !Y TO KEEP IT8 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,BUT !IR ANCE/ORS HAVE LEFT IT TO !M4 

 ,JACK4 ,& :O GAVE IT TO !IR ANCE/ORS8 ,LOOK H]E N[2 ! /RONGE/ & ! LUCKIE/ TOOK ADVANTAGE ( !IR /R5G? OR !IR LUCK TO TAKE POSSESSION ( EV]Y?+ & SO =C$ ! O!RS TO WORK = !M2 & NOT SATISFI$ ) LIV+ 9 IDL5ESS !MSELVES1 OPPRESS+ & />V+ ! GREAT] P>T ( !IR CONTEMPOR>IES1 !Y MU/ NE$S LEAVE !IR SONS & GR&SONS ! =TUNE !Y HAVE USURP$1 ?US CONDEMN+ FUTURE G5]ATIONS TO BE ! SLAVES ( !IR DESC5DANTS2 ?\< N[ !SE DESC5DANTS HAVE BECOME SO 5FEEBL$ BY 9DOL5CE & ! LONG EX]CISE ( P[]1 ?AT !Y C\LD NEV] DO TO-DAY :AT !IR =EFA!RS DID LONG AGO4 ,DOES ALL ?IS SEEM TO Y\ JU/8 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,WELL1 NO2 NOT IF !Y GOT !IR WEAL? BY =CE4 ,BUT ! G5TLEFOLKS SAY ?AT !Y GOT !IR WEAL? FROM LABOR1 & IT DOES NOT SEEM FAIR TO ME TO TAKE AWAY FROM ANY MAN :AT HE HAS WORK$ =4 

 ,JACK4 ,ALWAYS ! SAME OLD /ORY6 ,PEOPLE :O DO NOT WORK & NEV] HAVE WORK$1 >E = EV] SPEAK+ 9 ! NAME ( LABOR6 ,BUT TELL ME2 ,:O PRODUC$ ! E>?1 METALS1 COAL1 /ONE & SO =?1 BY HIS LABOR8 ,OR H[ DID !SE ?+S COME TO EXI/8 ,ISN'T IT A FACT ?AT WE ALL F9D !M :5 WE COME 9TO ! WORLD1 ?AT !RE=E WE ALL \<T TO BE ABLE TO MAKE USE ( !M8 ,:AT W\LD Y\ SAY IF ! RI* PEOPLE ?\<T FIR TO TAKE POSSESSION ( ! AIR = !IR [N USE1 & ONLY TO GIVE US A LITTLE1 & ?AT ! MO/ IMPURE1 MAK+ US PAY !M = ! USE ( IT ) \R TOIL8 ,N[ ! ONLY DIFF]5CE BETWE5 ! E>? & ! AIR IS ?AT !Y HAVE BE5 ABLE TO LAY HOLD ( & DIVIDE ! E>?1 :ILE !Y C\LD NOT DO ?IS ) ! AIR1 BUT BELIEVE ME ?AT1 IF ! ?+ W]E POSSIBLE1 !Y W\LD DEAL ) ! AIR JU/ AS !Y DO ) ! L&4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,TRUE2 ?AT'S RI<T 5\<4 ,! L& & AL ! ?+S ?AT NOBODY HAS MADE \<T TO BELONG TO ALL4 ,BUT !RE >E ?+S ?AT HAVE NOT COME ( !MSELVES4 

 ,JACK4 ,C]TA9LY1 !RE >E ?+S ?AT >E MADE BY MAN'S WORK & ! L& ITSELF W\LD BE WOR? V]Y LITTLE IF IT W]E NOT CLE>$ BY ! H& ( MAN4 ,BUT 9 COMMON FAIRNESS !SE ?+S %\LD BELONG TO ?OSE :O PRODUCE !M4 ,BY :AT MIRACLE DOE SIT HAPP5 ?AT !Y >E 9 ! POSSESSION ( EXACTLY ?OSE PEOPLE :O >E DO+ ANO!R & HAVE NEV] DONE ANY?+8 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,BUT ! G5TLEFOLKS /ATE ?AT !IR FA!RS HAVE WORK$ & MADE SAV+S4 

 ,JACK4 ,& !Y \<T TO SAY1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 ?AT !IR FA!RS HAVE MADE O!R WORK )\T PAY+ !M1 JU/ AS IS DONE TO-DAY4 ,HI/ORY TEA*ES US ?AT ! LOT ( ! WORK] HAS CONT9UALLY BE5 WRET*$ & ?AT HE :O HAS HONE/LY LABOR$ )\T TAK+ ADVANTAGE ( HIS NEI<BOR HAS NEV] BE5 ABLE TO LAY BY ANY CONSID]ABLE SAV+S4 ,G5]ALLY HE HAS NOT BE5 ABLE TO GET 5\< TO KEEP HIM FROM NE$4 ,LOOK AT :AT IS GO+ ON BE=E Y\ EYES4 ,DOES NOT ALL ?AT ! WORK]S PRODUCE GO 9TO ! H&S ( ! MA/]S8 ,A MAN SP5DS A FEW P\NDS ON AN UNCULTIVAT$ BIT ( M>%Y GR\ND1 PUTS SOME M5 !RE TO WORK & GIVES !M SC>CELY 5\< TO LIVE ON1 :IL/ HE /AYS QUIETLY 9 T[N & DOES NO?+4 ,A FEW YE>S AFT]1 ?IS BIT ( WA/E L& IS A G>D51 ) A HUNDR$ TIMES ITS ORIG9AL VALUE4 ,! SONS ( ! PROPRIETOR WILL 9H]IT ?IS =TUNE & SAY !Y >E 5JOY+ ! FRUITS ( !IR FA!R'S LABOR2 :IL/ ! SONS ( ! M5 :O REALLY TOIL$ & SUFF]$ !RE WILL CONT9UE TO TOIL & SUFF]4 ,?AT TO Y\ ?9K ( ?AT8 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,BUT IF1 AS Y\ SAY1 ! WORLD REALLY HAS ALWAYS BE5 ?US1 !RE IS NO?+ TO BE DONE & ! EMPLOY]S CANNOT HELP IT4 

 ,JACK4 ,WELL1 ,I AM READY TO ADMIT EV]Y?+ 9 FAVOR ( ! G5TRY4 ,LET US SUPPOSE ?AT ! HOLD]S ( PROP]TY >E ALL SONS ( PEOPLE :O HAVE WORK$ & MADE SAV+S & HE ! WORK]S >E ALL SONS ( IDLE SP5D?RIFTS4 ,?IS IS OBVI\SLY RIDICUL\S1 Y\ UND]/&2 BUT EV5 IF ?+S ACTUALLY W]E SO1 W\LD !RE BE ANY JU/ICE AT ALL 9 ! PRES5T SOCIAL ORGANIZATION8 ,IF Y\ WORK & ,I AM A LAZY DOG1 IT IS RI<T 5\< ,I %\LD BE PUNI%$ = MY LAZ9ESS2 BUT ?IS IS NO REASON ?AT MY SONS1 :O MAY BE HONE/ WORK+ M51 %\LD BE WORK$ TO DEA? & FAMI%$ TO KEEP Y\R SONS 9 IDL5ESS & PL5TY4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,ALL ?AT IS V]Y F9E1 & ,I DON'T SAY TO ! CONTR>Y1 BUT !N ! G5TLEFOLKS HAVE GOT ! PROP]TY1 &1 :5 ALL'S SAID & DONE1 WE MU/ BE GRATEFUL TO !M1 BECAUSE IF IT W]5'T = !M PEOPLE C\LD NOT GET A LIV+4 

 ,JACK4 ,IF !Y HAVE ! WEAL? IT IS BECAUSE !Y HAVE TAK5 IT BY =CE & HAVE 9CREAS$ IT BY POCKET+ ! FRUIT ( O!R PEOPLE'S LABOR4 ,BUT !Y MAY *ANCE TO LOSE IT ! SAME WAY AS IT WAS GA9$4 ,UNTIL N[ M5 HAVE BE5 FI<T+ ) ONE ANO!R2 !Y HAVE BE5 TRY+ TO SNAT* ! BREAD \T ( ONE ANO!R'S M\?S1 & EA* HAS E/EEM$ HIMSELF HAPPY IF HE C\LD SUBJUGATE HIS FELL[ & USE HIM = A BEA/ ( BURD54 ,BUT IT IS TIME ?IS /ATE ( ?+S WAS PUT AN 5D TO4 ,WE GA9 NO?+ BY FI<T+ ) ONE ANO!R2 ! ONLY H>VE/ WE HAVE REAP$ IS POV]TY1 SLAV]Y1 CRIME1 PRO/ITUTION1 & N[ & AGA91 ?OSE BLOOD-LETT+S CALL$ W>S & REVOLUTIONS4 ,IF 9/EAD WE C\LD COME TO A MUTUAL AGREEM5T1 LOVE & AID EA* O!R1 WE %\LD SEE NO MORE ( !SE EVILS2 !RE W\LD NO LONG] BE SOME PEOPLE ) A GREAT DEAL & O!R ) NO?+ AT ALL1 & WE %\LD ALL BE TRY+ TO MAKE EV]Y ONE AS WELL (F AS POSSIBLE4 ,( C\RSE ,I KN[ ?AT ! RI*1 :O >E ACCU/OM$ TO RULE & TO LIVE )\T WORK+1 WILL NOT HE> ( A *ANGE ( SY/EM4 ,WE %ALL ACT ACCORD+LY4 ,IF !Y COME TO UND]/& ?AT !RE \<T NO LONG] TO BE HATE & 9EQUALITY BETWE5 M51 & ?AT ALL \<T TO WORK1 SO MU* ! BETT]2 IF1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 !Y CLAIM A RI<T TO CONT9UE TO 5JOY ! FRUITS ( !IR [N & !IR FA!RS' VIOL5CE & ROBB]Y1 SO MU* ! WORSE = !M3 !Y HAVE TAK5 :AT !Y POSSESS BY =CE1 & BY =CE WE %ALL TAKE IT FROM !M4 ,IF ! POOR KN[ H[ TO COME TO AN UND]/&+1 !Y >E /R+] ?AN ! RI*4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,BUT :5 !RE >E NO MORE G5TLEFOLKS H[ %ALL WE MANAGE TO LIVE8 ,:O WILL GIVE US WORK8 

 ,JACK4 ,:AT A QUE/ION6 ,:Y Y\ SEE :AT HAPP5S EV]Y DAY2 ?AT IT IS Y\ :O DIG1 PL[1 S[1 REAP1 Y\ :O ?RE% ! CORN1 :O FE$ ! BEA/S1 :O MAKE ! BETT] AD *EESE1 & YET Y\ ASK ME H[ WE %ALL LIVE )\T ! G5TLEFOLLKS8 ,ASK ME RA!R H[ ! G5TRY W\LD MANAGE TO LIVE )\T US1 POOR FOOLS ( WORK+ M5 9 T[N & C\NTRY1 :O SLAVE TO CLO! & FE$ !M4 ,A MOM5T AGO Y\ WANT$ US TO BE GRATEFUL TO ! EMPLOY]S BECAUSE !Y 5ABLE US TO LIVE4 ,DON'T Y\ UND]/& ?AT IT IS !Y :O >E LIV+ ON Y\R WORK & ?AT EV]Y BIT ( BREAD !Y EAT IS TAK5 FROM Y\R *ILDR51 EV]Y F9E PRES5T !Y MAKE !IR WIVES MEANS ! POV]TY1 HUNG]1 COLD1 EV5 P]HAPS ! PRO/ITUTION ( Y\RS8 ,:AT SO !SE G5TLEFOLKS PRODUCE8 ,NO?+4 ,!RE=E :AT !Y CONSUME IS TAK5 FROM ! WORK]S4 ,SUPPOSE ALL AGRICULTURAL LABOR]S DISAPPE>$ TO-MORR[2 !RE W\LD BE NO ONE TO TILL ! GR\ND & EV]Y ONE W\LD BE />V$4 ,IF ! %OEMAK]S DISAPPE>$1 !RE W\LD BE NO MORE %OES2 IF ! MASONS VANI%$1 !RE W\LD BE NO ONE TO BUILD H\SES1 & SO =?4 ,IF EA* CLASS ( WORK]S FAIL$1 ONE AFT] AN!R1 ) EA* A BRAN* ( PRODUCTION W\LD DISAPPE> & M5 HAVE TO DO )\T SOME USEFUL OR NECESS>Y ?+S4 ,BUT :AT H>M W\LD IT DO US TO BE RID ( ! G5TRY6 ,IT W\LD BE LIKE ! DISAPPE>ANCE ( ! LOCU/S4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,YES1 IT REALLY IS WE :O PRODUCE EV]Y?+2 BUT H[ C\LD ,I1 = 9/ANCE1 GR[ CORN IF ,I HAD NEI!R L& NOR BEA/S NOR SE$8 ,I AM SURE !RE IS NO?+ = US BUT TO BE DEP5D5T UPON ! EMPLOY]S4 

 ,JACK4 ,COME N[1 ,WILLIAM1 DO WE UND]/& ONE ANO!R OR NOT8 ,I HAVE TOLD Y\ ALREADY :AT WE MU/ TAKE FROM ! MA/]S :AT IS NE$FUL TO 5ABLE US TO WORK & LIVE1 L&1 TOOLS1 SE$ & ALL4 ,I KN[ V]Y WELL ?AT AS LONG AS ! L& & 9/RUM5TS ( LABOR BELONG TO ! MA/]S1 ! WORK]S MU/ ALWAYS BE 9 SUBJECTION & WILL REAP NAU<T BUT SLAV]Y & POV]TY4 ,?IS IS JU/ :Y ! V]Y FIR/ ?+ TO DO IS TO TAKE AWAY PROP]TY FROM ! MIDDLE-CLASS2 )\T ?AT ! WORLD WILL NEV] M5D4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,Y\ >E RI<T1 Y\ DID SAY SO4 ,BUT ALL ?IS IS SO NEW ?AT ,I GET QUITE LO/4 ,N[ EXPLA9 A BIT H[ Y\ W\LD DO4 ,:AT W\LD BE DONE ) ?IS PROP]TY TAK5 FROM ! RI*8 ,IT W\LD BE DIVID$1 ,I SUPPOSE8 

 ,JACK4 ,NO1 NO1 NO?+ ( ! SORT4 ,IF Y\ HE> ANY ONE SAY ?AT WE WANT TO DIVIDE UP PROP]TY & TAKE ! PLACE ( ?OSE :O HAVE IT N[1 Y\ MAY RELY UPON IT ?AT HE DOES NOT KN[ :AT HE IS TALK+ AB\T OR IS A SC\NDREL4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,WELL !N1 ,I DON'T UND]/& 9 ! LEA/4 

 ,JACK4 ,& YET IT IS PLA9 5\<2 WE SIMPLY WI% TO PUT EV]Y?+ 9 COMMON4 ,WE />T ) ! PR9CIPLE ?AT EV]Y ONE \<T TO WORK & EV]Y ONE \<T TO BE AS WELL (F AS POSSIBLE4 ,A MAN CAN'T LIVE 9 ?IS WORLD )\T WORK2 IF HE DOES NOT WORK HIMSELF HE MU/ LIVE UPON ! LABOR ( O!RS1 :I* IS UNJU/ & HURTFUL4 ,BUT ( C\RSE Y\ MU/ UND]/& ?AT H5 ,I SAY ?AT ALL MU/ WORK1 ,I MEAN ALL ?OSE :O CAN DO2 CRIPPLES1 9VALIDS1 & OLD PEOPLE \<T TO BE SUPPORT$ BY SOCIETY1 BECAUSE HUMAN FEEL+ =BIDS US TO LET ANY ONE SUFF]2 & BESIDES WE ALL GR[ OLD1 & WE >E ALL LIABLE TO BECOME CRIPPL$ OR SICKLY AT ANY TIME1 & SO MAY ?OSE :O >E DE> TO US4 ,N[ IF Y\ ?9K IT OV] C>EFULLY1 Y\ WILL SEE ?AT ALL WEAL?1 ?AT IS TO SAY ALL ?+S :I* >E USEFUL TO MAN1 CAN BE DIVID$ 9TO TWO SORTS4 ,ONE1 :I* 9CLUDES L&1 MA*9]Y & ALL 9/RUM5TS ( LABOR1 IRON1 WOOD1 /ONE1 ! MEANS ( TRANSPORT1 ETC41 ETC41 IS ABSOLUTELY NECESS>Y TO 5ABLE US TO WORK & \<T TO BE PUT 9 COMMON = EV]Y ONE TO WORK )4 ,AS TO ! ME?OD ( WORK+1 WE %ALL SEE AB\T ?AT LAT]4 ,I BELIEVE IT W\LD BE BE/ TO WORK 9 COMMON1 BECAUSE 9 ?AT WAY ONE PRODUCES MORE ) LESS FATIGUE1 &1 9 MANY TRADES1 IF EA* P]SON HAD TO WORK SEP>ATELY1 WE %\LD HAVE TO GIVE UP US+ MA*9ES :I* GREATLY SIMPLIFY & DIM9I% ! LABOR ( MAN4 ,BESIDES1 :5 HUMAN BE+S HAVE NO NE$ TO SNAT* ! BREAD \T ( ONE ANO!R'S M\?S1 !Y WILL NOT BE LIKE CATS & DOGS1 BUT WILL TAKE PLEASURE 9BE+ TOGE!R4 ,C]TA9LY ?OSE :O *OOSE TO WORK ALONE WILL BE LEFT TO DO SO1 ! ESS5TIAL ?+ S ?AT NO ONE %\LD LIVE )\T WORK+1 ?US COMPELL+ O!RS TO WORK = HIM2 BUT ( C\RSE ?AT W\LD NOT BE LIKELY TO HAPP5 :]E EA* HAD A RI<T TO EH MAT]IAL = WORK & W\LD C]TA9LY NOT *OOSE TO MAKE HIMSELF ! S]VANT ( ANO!R4 ,! O!R SORT ( WEAL? 9CLUDES ! ?+S :I* DIRECTLY S]VE ! NE$S ( MAN1 LIKE FOOD1 CLO!S1 H\SES4 ,I ?9K !SE \<T TO BE PUT 9 COMMON & DI/RIBUT$ 9 SU* A WAY ?AT PEOPLE CAN GET ON UNTIL ! NEW H>VE/ & UNTIL 9DU/RY HAS SUPPLI$ SOME NEW PRODUCE4 ,AS = ! ?+S ?AT WILL BE PRODUC$ AFT] ! ,REVOLUTION1 :5 !RE WILL BE NO LAZY EMPLOY]S LIV+ ON ! TOIL ( FAMI%+ PROLET>IANS1 ! WORK]S ( EA* C\NTRY WILL %>E !M AS !Y *OOSE4 ,IF !Y >E WILL+ TO WORK 9 COMMON & TO PUT EV]Y?+ 9 COMMON1 ?AT WILL BE BE/2 9 ?AT CASE !Y WILL TRY TO REGULATE PRODUCTION 9 SU* A WAY AS TO SATISFY ! NE$S ( ALL1 & CONSUMPTION 9 SU* A WAY AS TO SECURE ! GREATE/ WELL-BE+ TO EV]Y ONE4 ,IF !Y DO NOT PROCE$ 9 ?IS WAY1 !Y MU/ CALCULATE :AT EA* PRODUCES SO ?AT EA* MAY TAKE AN AM\NT ( ?+ EQUIVAL5T TO :AT HE HAS PRODUC$4 ,?IS CALCULATION IS RA!R DIFFICULT1 ,I ?9K MYSELF IT IS ALMO/ IMPOSSIBLE2 SO ! RESULT WILL PROBABLY BE ?AT :5 !Y SEE ! DIFFICULTIES ( PROPORTIONATE DI/RIBUTION1 !Y WILL BE MORE 9CL9$ TO ACCEPT ! IDEA ( PUTT+ EV]Y?+ 9 COMMON4 ,BUT ANY WAY1 ?+S ( ! FIR/ NECESSITY1 LIKE BREAD1 DWELL+S1 WAT] & SU*LIKE1 MU/ BE SECUR$ TO EV]Y ONE1 REG>DLESS ( ! AM\NT ( WORK HE MAY DO4 ,:ATEV] ORGANIZATION IS ADOPT$1 9H]ITANCE %\LD EXI/ NO LONG]1 = IT IS NOT JU/ ?AT ONE %\LD BE BORN TO WEAL? & ANO!R TO HUNG] AN TOIL4 ,EV5 IF WE ADMIT ?AT EA* IS ABSOLUTE MA/] ( :AT HE PRODUCES & MAY MAKE SAV+S ON HIS [N ACC\NT1 ?OSE SAV+S \<T TO RETURN TO ! COMMUNITY AT HIS DEA?4 ,*ILDR5 \<T TO BE BR\<T UP & $UCAT$ AT ! CO/ ( ALL & 9 SU* A FA%ION AS TO PROCURE !M ! GREATE/ DEVELOPM5T & BE/ ATTA9ABLE TEA*+4 ,)\T ?AT1 !RE CAN BE NEI!R JU/ICE NOR EQUALITY1 ! PR9CIPLE ( ! RI<T ( EA* TO ! 9/RUM5TS ( LABOR WILL BE VIOLAT$1 = IT DOES NOT SUFFICE TO GIVE M5 L& & MA*9]Y IF !Y >E NOT ALSO PUT 9 A CONDITION TO MAKE ! BE/ POSSIBLE USE ( !M4 ,I DO NOT SAY ANY?+ SPECIALLY AB\T WOM51 BECAUSE WE ?9K WOM5 %\LD BE ! EQUALS ( M5 & :5 WE SPEAK ( 0M50 WE MEAN HUMAN BE+S )\T DI/9CTION ( SEX4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,!RE IS JUS TONE ?+3 TO TAKE ! =TUNE ( RI* M5 :O HAVE ROBB$ & />V$ ! POOR IS ALL V]Y WELL2 BUT IF A MAN BY H>D WORK & SAV+ HAS PUT BY SOME?+ TO BUY A LITTLE FIELD1 OR OP5 A LITTLE %OP1 :AT RI<T HAVE Y\ TO TAKE FROM HIM :AT IS REALLY ! FRUIT ( HIS LABOR8 

 ,JACK4 ,?AT IS NOT AN OV] COMMON CASE 9 !SE DAYS :5 CAPITALI/S & GOV]NM5TS MAKE A CLEAN SWEEP ( SO MU* ( ! PRODUCE2 BUT ANY WAY1 ,I HAVE TOLD Y\ ?AT EA* P]SON HAS A RI<T TO RAW MAT]IAL & ! 9/RUM5TS ( LABOR &1 = ?AT REASON1 IF A MAN HAS A BIT ( GR\ND :I* HE CULTIVATES ) HIS [N H&S1 HE MI<T JU/ AS WELL KEEP IT & HE W\LD BE GIV5 BESIDES ALL ! BE/ TOOLS & MANURES & EV]Y?+ ELSE HE REQUIR$ TO MAKE IT PRODUCE AS MU* AS POSSIBLE4 ,C]TA9LY IT W\LD BE ! BE/ PLAN TO PUT EV]Y?+ 9 COMMON2 BUT !RE WILL BE NO NE$ TO =CE PEOPLE TO DO SO BECAUSE A LIKE 9T]E/ WILL URGE ALL TO ADOPT A COMMUNI/ SY/EM4 ,?+S WILL GO BETT] ) COMMON PROP]TY & WORK1 & V]Y LIKELY !RE MAY BE MORE1 :I* IT IS MORE CONV5I5T TO USE 9 COMMON4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,MA*9]Y6 ,! MA*9ES >E :AT WE \<T TO BURN6 ,IT IS ! MA*9ES ?AT BREAK \R >MS & TAKE AWAY \R BREAD4 ,H]E1 9 ! C\NTRY1 AS SURE AS A MA*9E COMES1 WE CAN RECKON ON \R WAGES GO+ D[N & SOME ( US LOS+ \R WORK & HAV+ TO GO SOME:]E ELSE4 ,IT MU/ BE WORSE 9 ! T[NS4 ,IF !RE W]E NO MA*9ES ! G5TLEFOLKS W\LD WANT \R LABOR MORE & SO WE %\LD LIVE A BIT BETT]4 

 ,JACK4 ,Y\'RE RI<T1 ,WILLIAM1 TO ?9K ! MA*9ES ONE CAUSE ( POV]TY & LOSS ( WORK2 BUT ?AT HAPP5S BECAUSE !Y BELONG TO ! RI*4 ,IF !Y BELONG$ TO ! WORK]S1 IT W\LD BE JU/ ! O!R WAY2 !Y W\LD BE ! PR9CIPLE CAUSE ( HUMAN COM=T4 ,= AFT] ALL1 MA*9ES ONLY WORK 9 \R PLACE & FA/] ?AN WE DO4 ,?ANKS TO MA*9]Y MAN WILL NOT BE OBLIG$ TO TOIL = LONG H\RS TO SATISFY HIS NE$S1 WILL NOT BE CONDEMN$ TO PA9FUL EX]TION EXCE$+ HIS PHYSICAL /R5G?4 ,?IS IS :Y1 IS MA*9]Y W]E APPLI$ TO ALL BRAN*ES ( PRODUCTION & BELONG$ TO EV]Y ONE1 A FEW H\RS ( LI<T & EASY WORK W\LD SUFFICE = ALL ! NE$S ( CONSUMPTION & EA* WORK] W\LD HAVE TIME TO GA9 KN[L$GE1 TO KEEP UP FRI5DLY RELATIONS1 9 A WORD1 TO LIVE & 5JOY LIFE1 PR(IT+ BY ALL ! CONQUE/S ( SCI5CE & CIVILIZATION4 ,REMEMB]1 ?AT :AT WE HAVE TO DO IS TO TAKE POSSESSION ( ! MA*9ES1 NOT DE/ROY !M4 ,Y\ MAY BE SURE ! [N]S WILL DO JU/ AS MU* TO DEF5D !IR MA*9ES AGA9/ :OSE :O WANT TO DE/ROY AS AGA9/ ?OSE :O TRY TO TAKE POSSESSION ( !M2 !RE=E1 AS !RE WILL BE ! SAME EF=T TO MAKE & ! SAME RISK TO RUN 9 EI!R CASE1 IT WILL BE A D[NRI<T FOLLY TO BREAK RA!R ?AN TAKE ! MA*9ES4 ,W\LD Y\ DE/ROY CORN & HOSES IF !Y C\LD BE %>$ BY ALL8 ,SURELY NOT6 ,WELL1 WE MU/ DO ! SAME ) ! MA*9ES2 = IF 9 ! H&S ( EMPLOY]S !Y >E 9/RUM5TAL TO \R POV]TY & S]VITUDE1 9 \R H&S !Y WILL BECOME 9/RUM5TAL TO WEAL? & FRE$OM4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,BUT IF ?+S >E TO GO WELL UND] SU* A SY/EM1 EV]Y BODY MU/ BE WILL+ TO WORK4 

 ,JACK4 ,( C\RSE4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,& SUPPOSE !RE >E SOME FOLKS ?AT W\LD LIKE TO LIVE )\T WORK+8 ,TOIL IS A H>D%IP1 EV5 DOGS DON'T LIKE IT4 

 ,JACK4 ,Y\ CONFUSE SOCIETY AS IT IS TO-DAY ) SOCIETY AS IT WILL BE AFT] ! ,REVOLUTION4 ,Y\ SAY ?AT EV5 DOGS DON'T 5JOY TOIL2 BUT C\LD Y\ SP5D :OLE DAYS DO+ NO?+8 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,I8 ,NO1 BECAUSE ,I'M ACCU/OM$ TO WORK4 ,:5 ,I'VE NO?+ TO DO MY H&S SEEM TO IT* TO BE AFT] SOME?+2 BUT !RE >E FOLKS :O W\LD /AY ALL DAY LONG AT ! PUBLIC H\SE PLAY+ C>DS OR L\NGE AB\T ) !IR H&S 9 !IR POCKETS4 

 ,JACK4 ,N[-A-DAYS1 BUT NOT AFT] ! ,REVOLUTION1 & ,I WILL TELL Y\ :Y4 ,N[-A-DAYS WORK IS DISAGREEABLE1 ILL-PAID & LOOK$ D[N UPON4 ,N[-A-DAYS ! WORK+MAN JU/ FAG HIMSELF NE>LY TO DEA? OR BE HALF />V$1 & HE IS TREAT$ LIKE A BEA/ ( BURD54 ,! WORK+ MAN HAS NO HOPE2 HE KN[S ?AT T5 TO ONE HE WILL 5D HIS DAYS 9 ! WORKH\SE4 ,HE CAN'T ATT5D TO HIS FAMILY AS HE \<T AD HE HAS SC>CELY ANY 5JOYM5T 9 HIS LIFE1 :ILE HE CONT9UALLY SUFF]S ILL-TREATM5T & HUMILIATION4 ,ON ! O!R H&1 ! MAN :O DOES NOT WORK TAKES HIS EASE 9 EV]Y POSSIBLE WAY2 HE IS LOOK$ UP TO & E/EEM$2 ALL M5 & ALL PLEASURES >E AT HIS S]VICE4 ,EV5 AMONG WORK+ M51 ?OSE :O DO LEA/ & :OSE WORK IS ! LEA/ DISAGREEABLE E>N MO/ & >E ?\<T MORE ( ?AN ! O!RS4 ,IS IT TO BE WOND]$ AT ?AT FOLKS >E DISGU/$ ) WORK & >E EAG] TO SEIZE AN OPPORTUNITY TO DO NO?+8 ,BUT :5 WORK IS DONE UND] CONDITIONS FIR = HUMAN BE+S1 = A REASONABLE TIME & ACCORD+ TO ! LAWS ( HEAL?2 :5 ! WORK] KN[S ?AT HE IS WORK+ = ! WELL-BE+ ( HIS FAMILY & ( ALL M52 :5 EV]Y ONE :O WI%ES TO BE RESPECT$ MU/ NECESS>ILY BE A WORK] & ! LAZY >E AS MU* DESPIS$ AS >E SPIES & PROCURESSES TO-DAY2 :O WILL !N WI% TO =EGO ! JOY ( KN[+ HIMSELF USEFUL & BELOV$1 ?AT HE MAY LIVE 9 AN IDL5ESS DISA/R\S ALIKE TO HIS BODY & HIS M9D8 ,EV5 N[-A-DAYS1 EV]YBODY1 AP>T SOME R>E EXCEPTIONS1 9/9CTIVELY LOA!S ! IDEA ( BE+ A SPY OR A PROCURESS4 ,& YET BY !SE VILE CALL+S MORE CAN BE GA9$ ?AN BY DIGG+ ! GR\ND2 !RE IS LITTLE OR NO WORK & MORE OR LESS ,/ATE PROTECTION4 ,BUT AS !SE TRADES >E RECKON$ ABOM9ABLE1 NE>LY EV]Y ONE PREF]S POV]TY TO ! 9FAMY ( FOLL[+ !M4 ,!RE >E EXCEPTIONS1 !RE >E WEAK1 DEGRAD$ CREATURES :O PREF] 9FAMY1 BUT ?IS IS BECAUSE !IR *OICE LIES BETWE5 9FAMY & POV]TY4 ,BUT :O W\LD *OOSE AN 9FAM\S & CONTEMPTIBLE LIFE :5 BY WORK+ HE C\LD SECURE COM=T & PUBLIC E/EEM8 ,C]TA9LY SU* A MAN W\LD BE MAD4 ,& !RE IS NO D\BT ?AT ?IS PUBLIC REPROBATION ( IDL5ESS W\LD >ISE & MAKE ITSELF FELT1 = WORK IS ESS5TIALLY NE$FUL TO SOCIETY4 ,IDLE FOLKS W\LD NOT ONLY H>D EV]YONE BY LIV+ ON :AT O!RS PRODUCES )\T CONTRIBUT+ !IR [N WORK TO SUPPLY ! WANTS ( ! COMMUNITY1 BUT ALSO BREAK ! H>MONY ( ! NEW ORD] ( ?+S & BECOME ! ELEM5TS ( A DISCONT5T$ P>TY1 :O MI<T DESIRE A RETURN TO ! PA/4 ,COLLECTIVE BODIES >E LIKE 9DIVIDUALS2 !Y LOVE & ADMIRE :AT IS OR :AT !Y ?9K OR USE1 & HATE & DESPISE :AT !Y KN[ OR BELIEVE TO BE HURTFUL4 ,!Y MAY BE DECEIV$ & TOO (T5 !Y >E2 BUT 9 ! CASE BE=E US NO MI/AKE IS POSSIBLE1 = IT IS CLE> AS DAYLI<T ?AT ! P]SON :O DOES NOT WORK1 EATS & DR9KS AT ! EXP5SE ( O!RS & IS WRONG+ EV]YBODY4 ,:Y1 SUPPOSE Y\ JO9 A P>TY ( M5 TO DO SOME WORK ALL TOGE!R & %>E & %>E ALIKE 9 ! PRODUCE2 ( C\RSE Y\ WILL BE CONSID]ATE TO ANY ( Y\R MATES :O MAY BE WEAK OR UNSKILL$1 BUT AS = A M]E %IRK] WILL HE NOT BE L$ SU* A LIFE ?AT HE WILL TAKE HIMSELF (F OR ELSE FEEL 9CL9$ TO SET HIS %\LD] TO ! :EEL8 ,?AT IS JU/ :AT WILL HAPP5 9 ! COMMUNITY AT L>GE IS ! LAZ9ESS ( SOME ( ITS MEMB]S ?REAT5S TO BECOME A S]I\S DANG]4 ,IF WE C\LD NOT GO AHEAD BECAUSE ( ?OSE :O W\LD NOT WORK1 :I* TO ME SEEMS V]Y UNLIKELY1 ! REM$Y W\LD1 AFT] ALL1 NOT BE F> TO SEEK2 !Y W\LD SIMPLY BE TURN$ \T ( ! COMMUNITY4 ,!N1 AS !Y W\LD HAVE A RI<T TO NO?+ BUT RAW MAT]IAL & ! 9/RUM5TS ( LABOR1 !Y W\LD BE =C$ TO WORK IF !Y WI%$ TO LIVE4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,Y\ >E BEG9N+ TO CONV9CE ME2 BUT TELL ME1 WILL EV]YBODY HAVE TO WORK 9 ! FIELDS8 

 ,JACK4 ,:Y %\LD !Y8 ,M5 DO NOT NE$ ONLY BREAD & BE] & MEAT4 ,WE WANT H\SES1 & CLO!S & BOOK S & ALL ! ?+S ?AT WORK]S ( ALL SORTS ( TRADES PRODUCE & NO ONE CAN BY HIMSELF SUPPLY ALL HIS [N NE$S4 ,EV5 TO TILL ! SOIL1 DO WE NOT WANT ! HELP ( ! BLACKSMI? & ! IMPLEM5T MAK] = \R TOOLS1 & CONSEQU5TLY ( ! M9] :O UNE>?S ! IRON1 ! MASON :O BUILDS H\SES & %OPS & SO FIR?4 ,IT DOES NOT FOLL[1 !RE=E1 TAT ALL MU/ TILL ! GR\ND1 ONLY ?AT ALL MU/ DO SOME USEFUL WORK4 ,BESIDES ! V>IETY ( TRADES WILL ALL[ EA* P]SON TO *OOSE :AT SUITS HUM BE/1 & ?US1 AS F> AS POSSIBLE1 WORK WILL BE NO?+ MORE ?AN EX]CISE1 & AN >D5TLY DESIR$ 5JOYM5T4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,!N EV]Y ONE WILL BE FREE TO *OOSE ANY TRADE HE LIKES8 

 ,JACK4 ,( C\RSE4 ,ONLY WE MU/ BE C>EFUL ?AT SOME TRADES >E NOT OV]/OCK$1 :IL/ O!RS WANT H&S4 ,AS WE %ALL BE WORK+ = ! PUBLIC 9T]E/1 WE MU/ >RANGE SO ?AT EV]Y?+ REALLY NECESS>Y IS PRODUC$ :IL/ 9DIVIDUAL PREF]5CES >E CONSULT$4 ,BUT Y\ WILL SEE ?AT WILL COME RI<T :5 WE HAVE NO MA/]S TO =CE US TO TOIL = A CRU/ ( BREAD1 )\T KN[+ :AT IS ! OBJECT OR USE ( \R WORK4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,Y\ SAY IT WILL ALL COME RI<T1 BUT ,I DON'T SEE IT4 ,I ?9K ?AT NO ONE WILL DO DISAGREEABLE WORK2 !Y WILL ALL BE LAWY]S & DOCTORS4 ,:O WILL WORK 9 ! FIELDS8 ,:O WILL RISK HIS LIFE & HEAL? 9 A M9E8 ,:O WILL GO D[N 9TO ! BLACK MAN-HOLES ( ! SEW]S OR CLEAN \R CESSPOOLS8 

 ,JACK4 ,OH1 Y\ MAY LEAVE \T ! LAWY]S4 ,LAWY]S & PRIE/S >E A SORT ( GANGR5E 9 SOCIETY ?AT ! REVOLUTION WILL CURE4 ,LET US TALK AB\T USEFUL WORK & NOT AB\T OCCUPATIONS C>RI$ ON AT ! EXP5SE ( ONE'S NEI<BORS2 O!RWISE WE MI<T C\NT ! BURGL> AS A WORK]2 HE (T5 HAS PL5TY ( EX]TION4 ,N[-A-DAYS WE PREF] ONE TRADE TO ANO!R NOT BECAUSE IT IS MORE OR LESS 9 ACCORDANCE ) \R TA/ES & FACULTIES1 BUT BECAUSE IT IS EASI] TO LE>N1 BECAUSE WE E>N1 OR HOPE TO E>N1 MORE BY IT1 OR BECAUSE WE ?9K WE %ALL RUN ! BE/ *ANCE ( EMPLOYM5T 9 ?AT L9E2 IT IS ONLY 9 ! SECOND PLACE ?AT WE CONSID] IF SU* & SU* WORK IS MORE DISAGREEABLE ?AN ANO!R SORT4 ,9 F9E1 ! *OICE ( A TRADE IS MO/LY IMPOS$ UPON US BY \R BIR?1 BY *ANCE & BY SOCIAL PREJUDICE4 ,! WORK ( AN AGRICULTURAL LABOR]1 = 9/ANCE1 W\LD NOT PLEASE EV5 ! POORE/ T[NSMAN4 ,& YET !RE IS NO?+ REPULSIVE 9 AGRICULTURE 9 ITSELF1 & LIKE 9 ! FIELDS IS NOT )\T ITS PLEASURES4 ,V]Y MU* ! CONTR>Y2 IF Y\ READ ! POETS Y\ WILL SEE ?AT !Y >E 5?USIA/IC AB\T C\NTRY LIFE4 ,BUT ! TRU? IS ?AT ! POETS :O WRITE BOOKS HAVE V]Y SELDOM TILL$ ! SOIL1 :IL/ ! F>M LABOR]S >E WORK \T ) WORK & HALF />V$1 LIVE WORSE ?AN ! BEA/S & >E TREAT$ AS NOBODIES1 UNTIL ! POORE/ WRET* 9 A T[N W\LD H>DLY *ANGE PLACES ) !M4 ,H[ CAN Y\ EXPECT PEOPLE TO LIKE TO BE AGRICULTURAL LABOR]S8 ,EV5 WE :O W]E BORN 9 ! C\NTRY1 LEAVE IT AS SOON AS WE CAN1 BECAUSE :ATEV] WE DO1 WE >E BETT] (F & ?\<T MORE ( ELSE:]E4 ,BUT H[ MANY ( US W\LD WI% TO LEAVE ! C\NTRY1 IF WE W]E WORK+ !RE ON \R [N ACC\NT & C\LD F9D COM=T1 FRE$OM & RESPECT 9 \R WORK8 ,IT IS JU/ ! SAME 9 ALL TRADES1 BECAUSE AS ?+S >E N[1 ! H>D] & ! MORE NECESS>Y ANY WORK IS1 ! WORSE IT IS PAID1 ! MORE IT IS DESPIS$ & ! MORE 9HUMAN >E ! CONDITIONS UND] :I* IT MU/ BE DONE4 ,GO1 = EXAMPLE1 9TO A GOLDSMI?'S %OP & Y\ WILL F9D ?AT1 9 COMP>ISON ) ! WRET*$ HOLES WE LIVE 91 ! PLACE IS CLEAN1 WELL V5TILAT$ & W>M$1 ?AT ! WORK+ H\RS >E NOT V]Y LONG & ?AT ?\< ! M5 >E ILL PAID1 = ! EMPLOY] TAKES ! BE/ P>T ( :AT !Y PRODUCE1 /ILL !Y >E WELL (F COMP>$ TO O!R WORK]S2 !Y CAN AMUSE !MSELVES 9 ! EV5+2 :5 !Y TAKE (F !IR WORK+ JACKETS1 !Y CAN GO :]E !Y LIKE1 ) NO FE> ( BE+ />$ OR SNE]$ AT4 ,BUT IF Y\ GO 9TO A CUTL]'S WORK%OP1 Y\ WILL SEE POOR FELL[S KNIFE-GR9D+ !RE = A MIS]ABLE WAGE1 9 A POISON\S ATMOSPH]E1 :I* WILL DE/ROY !IR LIVES 9 A FEW YE>S1 & IF1 AFT] !IR WORK1 !Y TAKE ! LIB]TY ( GO+ :]E G5TLEM5 >E1 !Y WILL BE LUCKY IF !Y >E NOT MADE TO FEEL !MSELVES RIDICUL\S4 ,IT WILL NOT BE SURPRIS+ IF1 UND] SU* CIRCUM/ANCES1 A MAN PREF]S GOLD WORK+ TO CUTL]Y4 ,TO SAY NO?+ ( ! WORK]S :O USE NO TOOL BUT A P54 ,JU/ ?9K2 A MAN :O ONLY WRITES BAD NEWSPAP] >TICLES E>NS T5 TIME MORE ?AN A F>M LABOR] & IS ?\<T ( MU* MORE HI<LY4 ,:5 J\RNALI/S1 5G9E]S1 DOCTORS1 >TI/S1 PR(ESSORS1 >E 9 WORK & KN[ !IR BUS9ESS WELL1 !Y LIVE 9 COM=T2 BUT COMPOSITORS1 BRICKLAY]S1 %OEMAK]S1 ALL SOTS ( H&-WORK]S1 & SOME POOR TEA*]S & O!R BRA9-WORK]S TOO1 >E HALF-/>V$1 :IL/ !Y >E WORK$ TO DEA?4 ,I DON'T MEAN TO IMPLY ?AT ! ONLY WAY ( CONQU]+ ,NATURE1 BECOM+ CIVILIZ$1 GA9+ GREAT] FRE$OM & WELL-BE+2 DOCTORS1 5G9E]S1 *EMI/S1 TEA*]S1 >E AS USEFUL 9 MOD]N SOCIETY AS F>M-LABOR]S & O!R H&WORK]S4 ,I ONLY MEAN TO SAY ?AT ALL USEFUL WORK %\LD BE EQUALLY APPRECIAT$ & SO >RANG$ ?AT ! WORK] MAY F9D EQUAL SATISFACTION 9 DO+ IT2 & ALSO ?AT 9TELLECTUALLY WORK1 BE+ A GREAT PLEASURE 9 ITSELF1 & GIV+ ! MAN :O DOE IT A GREAT SUP]IORITY OV] ?OSE :O REMA9 9 IGNORANCE1 %\LD BE PUT )9 ! REA* ( EV]Y ONE & NOT REMA9 ! PRIVILEGE ( A FEW4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,BUT IF1 AS Y\ Y\RSELF SAY1 9TELLECTUAL WORK IS A GREAT PLEASURE & GIVES ?OSE :O DO IT AN ADVANTAGE OV] O!RS :O >E IGNORANT1 SURELY EV]Y ONE W\LD WANT TO /UDY2 ,I %\LD AS MU* AS ANYBODY4 ,& !N :O IS TO DO ! MANUAL WORK8 

 ,JACK4 ,EV]Y ONE2 BECAUSE :IL/ /UDY+ LIT]ATURE & SCI5CE !Y %\LD ALSO DO PHYSICAL WORK2 EV]Y ONE %\LD WORK ) BO? HEAD & H&S4 ,!SE TWO SORTS ( WORK1 SO F> FROM 9T]F]+ ) ONE ANO!R1 >E SUPPLEM5T>Y2 = A HEAL?Y MAN NE$S TO EX]CISE ALL HIS ORGANS1 HIS BRA9S AS WELL AS HIS MUSCLES4 ,HE :OSE 9TELLIG5CE IS DEVELOP$ & :O IS ACCU/OM$ TO ?9K DOES BE/ AT MANUAL WORK1 & HE :O IS S\ND & HEAL?Y1 AS PEOPLE >E :O EX]CISE !IR LIMBS UND] HEAL?Y CONDITIONS1 HAS HIS M9D 9 A MORE WIDE-AWAKE & P5ETRAT+ /ATE4 ,BESIDES1 AS BO? K9DS ( WORK >E NECESS>Y & AS ONE IS PLEASANT] ?AN ! O!R & HAS 5ABL$ MAN TO ATTA9 TO ! DIGNITY ( SELF-CONSCI\SNESS1 IT IS NOT JU/ ?AT A P>T ( MANK9D %\LD BE CONDEMN$ TO ! /UPEFY+ EFFECTS ( EXCLUSIVELY MANUAL TOIL1 ?AT ! PRIVILEGE ( SCI5CE1 :I* MEANS P[]1 MAY BE LEFT TO A FEW4 ,!RE=E1 ,I SAY AGA91 EV]Y BODY %\LD WORK AT ONCE PHYSICALLY & 9TELLECTUALLY4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,I CAN UND]/& ?AT2 BUT !RE IS MANUAL WORK :I* IS H>D & MANUAL WORK :I* IS EASY1 SOME IS UGLY1 SOME IS BEAUTIFUL4 ,N[ :O W\LD BE A M9]1 = 9/ANCE1 OR A SCAV5G]8 

 ,JACK4 ,MY DE> ,WILLIAM1 IF Y\ ONLY KNEW :AT 9V5TIONS & RESE>*ES >E BE+ MADE EV]Y DAY1 Y\ W\LD SEE ?AT EV5 N[1 IF ! ORGANIZATION ( WORK DID NOT DEP5D UPON PEOPLE :O >E NOT WORK+ !MSELVES & CONSEQU5TLY DON'T TR\BLE AB\T ! COM=T ( ! WORK]S1 ALL MANUAL LABOR C\LD BE C>RI$ ON UND] CONDITIONS :I* W\LD PREV5T IT FROM BE+ REPULSIVE1 UNHEAL?Y & TOILSOME4 ,!RE=E !RE IS NO REASON :Y ANY WORK %\LD NOT BE DONE BY WORK]S :O HAVE *OS5 IT VOLUNT>ILY4 ,& IF ?IS W\LD BE POSSIBLE TO-DAY1 JU/ FANCY :AT MI<T HAPP5 :51 EV]YBODY HAV+ TO WORK1 ! /UDIES & EF=TS ( ALL W\LD BE DIRECT$ T[>DS MAK+ WORK LESS BURD5SOME & MORE PLEASANT4 ,& IF AFT] ALL !RE WEE /ILL SOME CRAFTS H>D] ?AN O!RS1 IT C\LD BE >RANG$ TO MAKE UP = !SE 9EQUALITIES BY SOME SPECIAL ADVANTAGES4 ,BESIDES1 :5 M5 >E WORK+ 9 COMMON1 = ! COMMON B5EFIT1 WE SEE >IS+ AMONG !M ?AT SAME SPIRIT ( BRO!RL9ESS & COMPLIANCE :I* BELONGS TO FAMILY LIFE 9 ITS BE/ ASPECT2 SO ?AT EA*1 F> FROM SEEK+ ONLY TO SAVE HIMSELF TR\BLE1 TRIES RA!R TO TAKE ! HEAVIE/ WORK = HIS [N %>E4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,RI<T 5\<1 IF ALL ?IS HAPP5S2 BUT SUPPOSE IT DOESN'T8 

 ,JACK4 ,WELL1 IF 9 SPITE ( ALL ?IS1 !RE /ILL REMA9S SOME NE$FUL WORK :I* NO ONE WILL DO BY *OICE1 !N WE %ALL EV]Y ONE ( US HAVE TO TAKE A H& AT IT1 EA* DO+ A LITTLE1 WORK+ AT IT1 = EXAMPLE1 ONE DAY A MON?1 ONE WEEK A YEA1 OR SOME?+ LIKE ?AT4 ,BUT SET Y\R M9D AT RE/4 ,IF A ?+ IS NE$FUL = EV]Y ONE1 MEANS WILL C]TA9LY BE F\ND TO DO IT4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,DO Y\ KN[1 Y\ >E BEG9N+ TO TALK ME OV]6 ,YET !RE'S ONE ?+ ,I CAN'T RI<TLY SEE MY WAY TO4 ,IT'S A BIG JOB ?AT TAK+ AWAY PROP]TY FROM ! G5TRY4 ,I DON'T KN[1 BUT--ISN'T !RE ANY?+ ELSE Y\ C\LD DO8 

 ,JACK4 ,H[ W\LD Y\ MANAGE8 ,:IL/ IT REMA9S 9 ! H&S ( ! RI* !Y WILL BE COCKS O' ! WALK & WILL FOLL[ UP !IR [N 9T]E/S )\T TR\BL+ AB\T \RS1 AS !Y HAVE DONE S9CE ! BEG9N+ ( TIME4 ,BUT :Y DON'T Y\ WANT TO TAKE AWAY PROP]TY FROM ! G5TLEFOLK8 ,P]HAPS Y\ FANCY ?AT IT W\LD BE UNFAIR1 & A WRONG ?+ TO DO8 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,NO1 NO2 AFT] :AT Y\ HAVE TOLD ME IT SEEMS TO ME ?AT IT W\LD BE V]Y RI<T1 AS 9 TE>+ AWAY =M !M1 WE >E SNAT*+ FROM !M ALSO \R WON BODIES ON :I* !Y >E FE$+4 ,& BESIDES WE >E NOT TAK+ !IR =TUNE = \RSELVES1 BUT TO PUT IT 9 COMMON TO DO GOOD TO EV]Y ONE1 >5'T WE8 

 ,JACK4 ,MO/ ASSUR$LY4 ,& IF Y\ LOOK CLOSE AT ! MATT]1 Y\ WILL SEE ?AT ! G5TRY !MSELVES WILL ALSO BE ! GA9]S4 ,!Y WILL HAVE TO GIVE UP ORD]+ O!RS AB\T1 PUTT+ ON AIRS & GRACES1 & IDL+2 !Y WILL HAVE TO SET TO WORK1 BUT :5 WORK IS DONE ) ! HELP ( ! WORK]S1 IT WILL BECOME NO?+ BUT A USEFUL1 PLEASANT EX]CISE4 ,DO NOT ! G5TRY N[-A-DAYS GO HUNT+8 ,DO !Y NOT RIDE ON HORSEBACK1 PRACTICE GYMNA/ICS & TAKE EX]CISE 9 O!R WAYS :I* PROVE ?AT MUSCUL> EX]TION IS A NECESSITY & A PLEASURE TO HEAL?Y1 WELL-F$ M58 ,= !M !N IT IS M]ELY A QUE/ION ( PUTT+ 9TO PRODUCTION ! PHYSICAL 5]GY !Y N[ PUT =? PURELY AS AN AMUSEM5T4 ,& !N H[ MU* ADVANTAGE !Y WILL REAP FROM ! G5]AL WELL-BE+6 ,LOOK1 = EXAMPLE1 AT :AT WE SEE BE=E \R EYES4 ,A FEW G5TLEFOLKS >E WEAL?Y & CAN PLAY ! LORD 9 !IR [N H\SES1 BUT = !M AS = US ! /REETS >E HIDE\S & FIL?Y1 & ! BAD AIR :I* RISES FROM \R HOVELS & SLUMS MAKES !M ILL AS WELL AS US2 ) !IR PRIVATE =TUNES !Y CAN'T IMPROVE ! :OLE C\NTRY1 A ?+ :I* C\LD BE DONE EASILY IF EV]Y ONE SET AB\T IT4 ,\R POV]TY IS A CONT9UAL BLI<T UPON !IR LIVES1 ACT+ UPON !M 9DIRECTLY 9 A MILLION WAYS1 )\T C\NT+ !IR DREAD ( A VIOL5T REVOLUTION4 ,Y\ SEE !N ?AT WE %ALL BE ONLY DO+ GOOD TO ! G5TLEFOLK BY TAK+ !IR WEAL?4 ,?\< !Y C]TA9LY DON'T UND]/& ?IS1 & NEV] WILL1 BECAUSE !Y LIKE TO GIVE ORD]S & !Y FANCY ?AT ! POOR >E FA%ION$ ( A DIFF]5T CLAY FROM !MSELVES4 ,BUT :AT MATT]8 ,IF !Y WILL NOT COME TO T]MS ) US1 SO MU* ! WORSE = !M1 WE %ALL KN[ H[ TO =CE !M TO DO SO4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,?AT IS ALL FAIR 5\<2 BUT CAN'T ?+S BE DONE BIT BY BIT1 BY MUTUAL AGREEM5T8 ,PROP]TY MI<T BE LEFT TO ?OSE :O POSSESS IT1 BUT ON CONDITION ?AT !Y W\LD 9CREASE WAGES1 & TREAT US LIKE HUMAN BE+S4 ,!N1 GRADUALLY1 WE MI<T LAY BY SOME?+1 & WE TOO MI<T BUY A BIT ( L&1 &1 AT LA/1 :5 WE W]E ALL PROP]TY [N]S1 WE W\LD PUT EV]Y?+ 9 COMMON1 AS Y\ SAY4 ,!RE WAS A *AP ,I HE>D PROPOS+ SOME?+ ( ! SORT4 

 ,JACK4 ,N[ LOOK H]E6 ,!RE IS ONLY ONE WAY ( COM+ TO FRI5DLY T]MS1 & ?AT IS = ! PROP]TY [N]S VOLUNT>ILY TO R5\NCE !IR PROP]TY4 ,BUT Y\ KN[1 AS WELL AS ,I DO1 ?AT IT IS NO GOOD ?9K+ ( ?AT4 ,:IL/ PRIVATE PROP]TY EXI/S1 ?AT IS :IL/ ! L&1 9/EAD ( BELONG+ TO EV]Y ONE1 BELONGS TO ,PET] OR ,PAUL1 !RE WILL ALWAYS BE POV]TY & ?+S WILL GO FROM BAD TO WORSE4 ,UND] PRIVATE PROP]TY EA* IS TRY+ ALL ! TIME TO BE+ GRI/ TO HIS [N MILL4 ,! PROP]TY [N]S NOT ONLY TRY TO GIVE ! WORK]S AS LITTLE AS !Y CAN1 BUT !Y >E ALWAYS FI<T+ AMONG !MSELVES4 ,G5]ALLY SPEAK+ EA* TRIES TO SELL HIS PRODUCE = AS MU* AS HE CAN1 & EA* BUY]1 ON HIS SIDE1 TRIES TO PAY AS LITTLE AS POSSIBLE4 ,& !N :AT HAPP5S8 ,! L& [N]S1 MANUFACTUR]S1 & L>GE M]*ANTS1 :O CAN MANUFACTURE & SELL :OLESALE1 PROVIDE !MSELVES ) MA*9]Y1 TAKE ADVANTAGE ( ALL FAVORABLE /ATES ( ! M>KET1 WAIT UNTIL ! RI<T MOM5T TO SELL OR EV5 SELL AT A LOSS = A TIME1 5D BY RU9+ ! SMALL PROPRIETORS & DEAL]S1 :O S9K 9TO POV]TY & >E OBLIG$1 !Y & !IR *ILDR51 TO GO & WORK = A DAILY WAGE4 ,?US 7IT S A ?+ WE SEE EV]Y DAY7 M5 :O WORK ON !IR [N ACC\NT ALONE OR ) A FEW J\RNEYM51 >E DRIV51 AFT] A BITT] /RUGGLE1 TO %IT UP %OP1 & GO TO SEEK WORK 9 BIG FACTORIES1 SMALL L&-[N]S :O CANNOT GET 5\< CAPITAL = !IR F>M+ & CANNOT EV5 PAY !IR TI!S & TAXES HAVE TO SELL !IR FIELDS & H\SES TO ! L>GE PROPRIETORS1 & SO ON4 ,IF A K9DHE>T$ EMPLOY] REALLY WI%$ TO BETT] ! CONDITION ( HIS WORK-PEOPLE1 HE C\LD ONLY PUT HIMSELF 9 A POSITION TO BE RU9$ BY COMPETITION4 

,ON ! O!R H&1 ! WORK]S >E GOAD$ BY HUNG] 9TO COMPET+ ) ONE ANO!R2 & AS !RE >E MORE H&S TO BE HAD ?AN >E NE$$ = ! WORK TO BE DONE1 !Y >E CONT9UALLY SNAT*+ ! BREAD \T ( EA* O!R'S M\?S4 ,NOT ?AT !RE IS NOT PL5TY ( WORK ?AT NE$S DO+1 BUT ?AT AT ANY P>TICUL> TIME !RE IS ONLY A C]TA9 AM\NT :I* IT PAYS ! EMPLOY] TO HAVE DONE4 ,?ANKS TO ?IS SITUATION1 PROGRESS ITSELF BECOMES A MIS=TUNE4 ,A MA*9E IS 9V5T$3 IMM$IATELY A NUMB] ( M5 >E ?R[N \T ( WORK2 !Y CAN E>N NO?+1 !RE=E CANNOT CONSUME AS BE=E1 & ?US 9DIRECTLY EFFECT ! BREADW9N+ ( O!R WORK]S4 ,9 ,AM]ICA WIDE TRACTS ( L& >E BR\<T UND] CULTIVATION & MU* CORN PRODUC$3 ! L&-[N+1 OR C\RSE )\T 9QUIR+ IF EV]YBODY 9 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES HAS PL5TY TO EAT1 %IP !IR GRA9 OV] H]E ?AT !Y MAY GET MORE = IT4 ,H]E ! PRICE ( CORN IS L[]1 BUT ! POOR DO NOT REAP ! ADVANTAGE1 = ! ,EUROPEAN L&-[N]S1 NOT ABLE TO COMPETE ) ?IS *EAPNESS1 LET ! SOIL GO \T ( CULTIVATION1 EXCEPT SOME ( ! MO/ PRODUCTIVE PORTIONS1 & ?US A NUMB] ( AGRICULTURAL LABOR]S LOSE !IR EMPLOYM5T4 ,:5 A MAN HAS NOT EV5 A P5NY 9 HIS POCKET *EAP BREAD IS NO GOOD TO HIM4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,AH2 N[ ,I UND]/&6 ,I'VE HE>D SAY ?AT !Y W\LD NOT LET ! CORN COME FROM ABROAD1 & ,I ?\<T IS A RASCALLY ?+ TO TRY TO KEEP FOOD \T ( ! C\NTRY2 ,I BELIEV$ ! G5TLEFOLKS & ! F>M]S BETWE5 !M WANT$ TO />VE ! PEOPLE4 ,BUT N[ ,I SEE !Y HAD !IR REASONS4 

 ,JACK4 ,NO1 NO2 IF ! CORN DID NOT COME IT W\LD BE V]Y BAD FROM ANO!R PO9T ( VIEW4 ,!N ! L&LORDS & F>M]S1 HAV+ NO COMPETITION TO FE> FROM \TSIDE1 W\LD SELL AT ANY PRICE !Y *OSE &-- 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,!N :AT IS TO BE DONE8 

 ,JACK4 ,DONE8 ,I TOLD Y\ BE=E2 EV]Y?+ MU/ BE PUT 9 COMMON4 ,& !N ! MORE PRODUCE !RE IS ! BETT] IT WILL BE4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,BUT N[ TELL ME3 H[ W\LD IT BE IF AN >RANGEM5T W]E MADE ) ! [N]S ( PROP]TY3 !Y TO CONTRIBUTE ! L& & CAPITAL & WE ! WORK2 ! PRODUCE TO BE %>$ BETWE5 US & !M8 ,:AT DO Y\ SAY TO ?AT8 

 ,JACK4 ,FIR/ ( ALL ,I SAY ?AT IF Y\ W]E WILL+ TO GO %>ES1 T5 TO ONE Y\R MA/] W\LD BE WILL+ TO DO NO?+ ( ! SORT4 ,Y\ W\LD BE OBLIG$ TO USE =CE TO BR+ HIM TO IT4 ,BUT 9 ?AT CASE1 :Y DO ?+S BY HALVES8 ,:Y CONT5T Y\RSELF ) A SY/EM :I* ALL[S 9JU/ICE & P>ASITISM TO CONT9UE & PRES5TS ! 9CREASE ( PRODUCTION8 ,& FUR!R1 :AT RI<T HAVE C]TA9 M5 :O DO NOT WORK TO COME & TAKE HALF ( :AT IS PRODUC$ BY ! WORK]S8 ,BESIDES1 AS ,I HAVE TOLD Y\1 IT IS NOT ONLY ?AT HALF ! PRODUCE W\LD GO TO ! EMPLOY]S1 BUT ?AT ! SUM TOTAL ( PRODUCE W\LD BE LESS ?AN IT MI<T BE1 BECAUSE :]E Y\ HAVE PRIVATE PROP]TY & ISOLAT$ LABOR LESS IS PRODUC$ ?AT BY WORK+ 9 COMMON4 ,IT IS LIKE :5 Y\ WANT TO MOVE A ROCK3 A HUNDR$ M5 W\LD NOT SUCCE$ BY TRY+ S+LY1 :]EAS BY UNIT+ !IR EF=TS TWO OR ?REE CAN RAISE IT EASILY4 ,IF ONE MAN WI%$ TO MAKE A P91 ,I DON'T KN[ IF HE C\LD GET ?R\< IT 9 AN H\R2 :]EAS T5 M5 WORK+ 9TO EA* O!R'S H&S CAN MAKE ?\S&S ( P9S A DAY4 ,ECONOMI/S1 MANY ( :OM HAVE LE !MSELVES BE SC&AL\SLY BIAS$ BY CLASS PREJUDICE1 HAVE (T5 SAID ?AT PROP]TY IS NOT ! RESULT ( ! SEIZURE ( PROP]TY BY ! UPP] CLASSES1 BUT ( ! SC>CITY ( NATURAL PRODUCTS1 :I* W\LD1 SAY !Y1 BE QUITE 9SUFFICI5T1 IF !Y W]E DI/RIBUT$ TO ALL M54 ,?IS 5ABLES ! SAID ECONOMI/S & !IR DISCIPLES TO CONCLUDE ?AT POV]TY IS AN 9EVITABLE ?+1 AGA9/ :I* NO MEASURES CAN BE TAK54 ,DON'T BELIEVE A WORD ( IT4 ,EV5 AS ?+S >E ORGANIZ$ TO-DAY1 ! PRODUCE ( ! E>? & ( 9DU/RY IS 5\< TO 5ABLE EV]Y MAN TO LIVE 9 COM=T2 & IF IT IS NOT MORE ABUNDANT1 ?AT IS ! EMPLOY]'S FAULT4 ,!Y ?+ ( NO?+ BUT H[ MU* !Y CAN GA91 & EV5 GO SO F> AS TO DE/ROY >TICLES OR LET !M GO TO WA/E M]ELY TO KEEP UP ! PRICE4 ,:IL/ !Y PRET5D !RE IS NOT 5\< NATURAL WEAL?1 !Y >E LEAV+ L>GE TRACTS ( C\NTRY UNCULTIVAT$ & NUMB]S ( WORKM5 ) NO?+ TO DO4 ,BUT1 ANSW] A C]TA9 S*OOL ( ECONOMI/S1 EV5 :5 ALL GR\ND IS BR\<T UND] CULTIVATION & TILL$ AS 9TELLIG5TLY AS MAY BE1 /ILL ! PRODUCTIVE P[] ( ! E>? IS LIMIT$ & ! 9CREASE ( POPULATION IS NOT4 ,!RE=E !RE MU/ ALWAYS SOME A MOM5T :5 ! PRODUCTION ( FOOD /UFFS WILL BE /ATION>Y1 :IL/ POPULATION WILL GO ON GR[+ 9DEF9ITELY & ) IT FAM9E4 ,! SOLE REM$Y1 !Y CONCLUDE1 = SOCIAL ILLS IS ?AT ! POOR %\LD HAVE V]Y FEW *ILDR54 ,I'M NOT V]Y LE>N$ AB\T ! LAW ( R5T BUT ,I'M SURE ?IS REM$Y IS NO CURE = \R SOCIAL EVILS4 ,Y\ HAVE ONLY TO LOOK AT C\NTRIES :]E !RE IS PL5TY ( L& & A SCANTY POPULATION2 Y\ WILL SEE AS MU* OR MORE POV]TY AS :]E POPULATION IS D5SE4 ,WE MU/ *ANGE \R SOCIAL ORGANIZATION & BR+ ALL ! L& UND] CULTIVATION1 & !N1 IF ! POPULATION SEEMS GR[+ TOO FA/1 WE CAN CONSID] H[ TO *ECK IT4 ,BUT LET US GO BACK TO ! QUE/ION ( PRODUCE-%>+ BETWE5 PROP]TY-[N] & WORKMAN4 ,IT IS A SY/EM :I* US$ TO EXI/ 9 P>TS ( ,FRANCE 9 FIELD WORK4 ,IT /ILL EXI/S 9 ,TUSCANY1 BUT IT IS GRADUALLY DISAPPE>+ BECAUSE ! L&[N]S F9D DAY-LABOR PAY !M BETT]4 ,N[-A-DAYS1 :AT ) MA*9ES1 SCI5TIFIC CULTURE & =EIGN PRODUCE1 ! MA/]S >E OBLIG$ TO F>M ON A L>GE SCALE & EMPLOY HIR$ LABOR]S4 ,IF !Y DON'T1 !Y >E RU9$ BY COMPETITION4 ,IF !Y PRES5T SY/EM GOES ON1 ,I BELIEVE ?AT PROP]TY WILL BE MORE & MORE CONC5TRAT$ 9 ! H&S ( A FEW1 & ! WORK]S R$UC$ TO UTT] WRET*$NESS BY MA*9]Y & RAPID ME?ODS ( PRODUCTION4 ,WE %ALL HAVE A FEW BIG F9ANCI]S & CAPITALI/S MA/]S ( ! WORLD1 A C]TA9 NUMB] ( WORKM5 ATT5D+ UPON ! MA*9ES1 & A NUMB] ( S]VANTS & POLICE TO WAIT ON & DEF5D ! A=ESAID BIG M54 ,! MASS ( ! PEOPLE WILL HAVE TO DIE ( HUNG] OR LIVE ON *>ITY4 ,! BEG9N+S ( SU* A /AT ( ?+S MAY ALREADY BE SE52 SMALL PROP]TIES >E DISAPPE>+1 ! NUMB]S ( \T-O'-WORKS 9CREASES1 ! G5TLEFOLKS1 FROM FE> OR FROM PITY1 BUSY !MSELVES ) S\P KIT*5S & ! S*EMES ( ,G5]AL ,BOO?4 ,IF ! PEOPLE DO NOT WI% TO BE R$UC$ TO BEG !IR BREAD FROM RI* PHILAN?ROPI/S OR ,LOCAL ,BO>DS1 AS !Y ONCE DID AT ! GATES ( MONA/]IES1 LET !M LOSE NO TIME 9 TAK+ POSSESSION ( ! L& & MA*9]Y & WORK+ ON !IR [N ACC\NT4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,BUT H[ W\LD IT DO IF ,GOV]NM5T W]E TO MAKE SOME GOOD LAWS TO =CE RI* PEOPLE NOT TO MAKE ! POOR SUFF]8 

 ,JACK4 ,! SAME OLD /ORY1 ,WILLIAM6 ,ISN'T ! GOV]NM5T MADE UP ( G5TLEFOLKS1 & IS IT LIKELY ?AT !Y WILL MAKE LAWS AGA9/ !MSELVES8 ,BUT EV5 SUPPOS+ ! POOR C\LD MANAGE TO TAKE !IR TURN AT GOV]N+1 W\LD ?AT BE A REASON = LEAV+ ! RI* ) ! MEANS ( GETT+ ! UPP] H& AGA98 ,RELY UPON IT1 :]EV] !RE >E RI* & POOR1 ! POOR MAY MAKE !IR VOICES HE>D = A MOM5T DUR+ AN \TBREAK1 BUT ! RI* WILL ALWAYS GET HOLD ( ! P[] 9 ! 5D4 ,?IS IS :Y WE1 IF WE >E ! /R+] = EV] SO %ORT A TIME1 MU/ AT ONCE TAKE PROP]TY AWAY FROM ! RI*1 SO ?AT !Y MAY NOT HAVE ! MEANS ( PUTT+ ?+S BACK AS !Y W]E BE=E4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,I UND]/&4 ,WE MU/ HAVE A REAL ,REPUBLIC1 MAKE ALL M5 EQUAL1 & !N ! MAN :O WORKS WILL EAT1 & ! MAN :O DOES NO?+ CAN GO ) AN EMPTY /OMA*4 ,AH ME6 ,I'M SORRY ,I'M OLD4 ,Y\ Y\NG FOLKS WILL SEE A GOOD TIME4 

 ,JACK4 ,S(TLY1 S(TLY1 FRI5D6 ,BY ! WORD 0,REPUBLIC0 Y\ MEAN ! ,SOCIAL ,REVOLUTION1 & = ?OSE :O UND]/& Y\ ?AT IS ALL V]Y WELL4 ,BUT Y\ >E EXPRESS+ Y\RSELF BADLY2 = :AT IS COMMONLY UND]/OOD BY A ,REPUBLIC IS NOT AT ALL :AT Y\ MEAN4 ,GET IT WELL 9TO Y\R HEAD ?AT REPUBLICAN GOV]NM5T IS A GOV]NM5T LIKE ! RE/2 ONLY 9/EAD ( A K+ !RE IS A PRESID5T & M9I/]S1 :O REALLY HAVE JU/ ! SAME P[]S4 ,WE SEE ?AT V]Y PLA9LY ACROSS ! ,*ANNEL1 & EV5 IF ! ,FR5* HAD ! DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC PROMIS$ BY !IR RADICALS1 !Y W\LDN'T BE ANY BETT] (F4 ,9/EAD ( TWO ,*AMB]S !Y W\LD HAVE ONE1 ! ,*AMB] ( ,DEPUTIES1 BUT W\LDN'T ! PEOPLE BE =C$ TO BE SOLDI]S & TO WORK LIKE SLAVES ALL ! SAME1 9 SPITE ( ALL ! F9E PROMISES ( ! G5TLEM5 DEPUTIES8 ,DON'T Y\ SEE ?AT AS LONG AS !RE >E RI* & POOR1 ! RI* WILL HAVE ! UPP] H&8 ,:E!R WE LIVE UND] A ,REPUBLIC OR A ,MON>*Y ! RESULTS :I* SPR+ FROM PRIVATE PROP]TY WILL ALWAYS EXI/4 ,:IL/ ECONOMIC RELATIONS >E REGULAT$ BY COMPETITION1 PROP]TY WILL BE CONC5TRAT$ 9 A FEW H&S1 MA*9ES WILL TAKE WORK FROM WORK+ M5 & ! MASSES WILL BE R$UC$ TO MIS]Y4 ,HAVE ANY ( ! ,REPUBLICS ?AT EXI/ S]I\SLY BETT]$ ! CONDITION ( ! WORK+ CLASSES8 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,WELL TO BE SURE6 ,& ,I ALWAYS BELIEV$ ?AT ,REPUBLIC MEANT EQUITY6 

 ,JACK4 ,YES1 ! REPUBLICANS SAY SO1 & ?IS IS H[ !Y MAKE IT BUT2 0,UND] A REALLY DEMOCRATIC ,REPUBLIC10 SAY !Y1 0! MEMB]S ( P>LIAM5T :O MAKE ! LAWS >E ELECT$ BY ! :OLE PEOPLE4 ,CONSEQU5TLY :5 ! PEOPLE >E NOT CONT5T$1 !Y *ANGE !IR ,M4,P4'S = BETT] ONES & EV]Y?+ COMES RI<T4 ,& AS ! POOR >E ! GREAT MAJORITY1 IT IS PRACTICALLY !Y :O GOV]N40 ,?AT IS :AT ! REPUBLICANS SAY1 BUT ! REALITY IS SOME?+ QUITE DIFF]5T4 ,! V]Y POV]TY ( ! POOR CAUSES !M TO BE IGNORANT & SUP]/ITI\S1 & !Y WILL REMA9 SO AS LONG AS !Y >E NOT ECONOMICALLY 9DEP5D5T & >E UNCONSCI\S ( !IR TRUE 9T]E/4 ,Y\ & ,I :O HAVE BE5 LUCKY 5\< TO E>N MORE ?AN SOME & TO BE ABLE TO TEA* \RSELVES A LITTLE1 MAY HAVE 9TELLIG5CE TO UND]/& :]E \R 9T]E/S LIE & /R5G? TO FACE ! EMPLOY]S' REV5GE2 BUT ! GREAT MASS WILL NEV] BE ABLE TO DO SO AS LONG AS PRES5T CONDITIONS LA/4 ,9 A TIME ( ,REVOLUTION ONE BRAVE MAN IS WOR? A SCORE ( TIMID ONES & DRAWS ALONG ) HIM NUMB]S :O1 LEFT TO !MSELVES1 W\LD NEV] HAVE ! 5]GY TO REVOLT4 ,BUT 9 FRONT ( A BALLOT-BOX *>ACT] & 5]GY GO = NO?+4 ,M]E NUMB]S >E ALL ?AT TELL4 ,& 9 ! PRES5T /ATE ( ?+S ! GREATE/ NUMB] WILL ALWAYS BE = ! M5 :O HOLD !IR DAILY BREAD 9 !IR H&S & CAN GIVE OR )HOLD IT AT !IR PLEASURE4 ,HAV5'T Y\ HAPP5$ TO NOTICE AS MU*8 ,TO-DAY ! GREAT] P>T ( ! ELECTORS >E POOR1 BUT H[ (T5 DO Y\ SEE !M *OOS+ M5 ( !IR [N CLASS TO REPRES5T !M & DEF5D !IR 9T]E/S8 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,NO1 MO/ ( 'EM DON'T LIKE TO RUN ! *ANCE ( (F5D+ ! L&LORD1 ! P>SON1 OR !IR EMPLOY]4 ,IF !Y DO1 !Y >E AS LIKE AS NOT TO BE TURN$ (F & EV5 EVICT$4 

 ,JACK4 ,NOT A HOPEFUL \TLOOK = ! B5EFITS TO BE EXPECT$ FROM UNIV]SAL SUFFRAGE1 IS IT8 ,! PEOPLE WILL ALWAYS S5D MIDDLE-CLASS M5 TO P>LIAM5T1 & !SE WILL ALWAYS BE CONTRIV+ H[ TO KEEP ! PEOPLE AS DEP5D5T & SUBMISSIVE AS POSSIBLE4 ,EV5 IF WE W]E TO HAVE PAID MEMB]S & ! POOR W]E TO TAKE ADVANTAGE ( ?IS TO S5D WORK+ M5 TO REPRES5T !M1 :AT C\LD !Y DO 9 SO CORRUPT A M$IUM8 ,! FEW ?AT HAVE BE5 TRI$ HAVE NOT CUT A V]Y BRILLIANT FIGURE 9 ANY C\NTRY1 ,NO6 DUR+ ! NEXT REVOLUTION ! PEOPLE MU/ NOT ALL[ !MSELVES TO BE HOODW9K$ AS !Y HAVE SO (T5 BE5 BY DEMOCRATS & REPUBLICANS4 ,OV] & OV] AGA9 ! PEOPLE HAVE DROPP$ !IR >MS ON BE+ PROMIS$ A ,REPUBLIC1 BECAUSE !Y HAVE BE5 TAU<T TO BELIEVE ?AT IT IS ! BE/ POSSIBLE =M ( ORGANIZATION & WILL WORK M>VELS 9 !IR CONDITION4 ,NEXT TIME !Y MU/ NOT RE/ CONT5T ) EMPTY WORDS1 !Y MU/ RESOLUTELY LAY H&S UPON PROP]TY4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,Y\ >E RI<T4 ,WE HAVE BE5 DECEIV$ SO (T51 IT IS TIME WE OP5$ \R EYES4 ,BUT /ILL !RE MU/ ALWAYS BE A GOV]NM5T1 = IF !RE IS NO ONE TO GIVE ORD]S1 H[ CAN ?+S GO ON8 

 ,JACK4 ,& :Y MU/ WE BE ORD]$8 ,:Y CAN'T WE MANAGE \R AFFAIRS \RSELVES8 ,HE :O RULES ALWAYS SEEKS HIS [N ADVANTAGE1 &1 EI!R IGNORANTLY OR WILLFULLY1 BETRAYS ! PEOPLE4 ,P[] MAKES EV5 ! BE/ ( M5 GIDDY ) PRIDE4 ,BESIDES1 & ?IS IS ! PR9CIPAL REASON = NOT WI%+ TO HAVE AN *IEF1 M5 MU/ CEASE TO BE L$ LIKE A FLOCK4 ,!Y MU/ GR[ ACCU/OM$ TO ?9K1 & LE>N TO RECOGNIZE !IR DIGNITY & /R5G?4 ,IF ! PEOPLE >E TO BE $UCAT$1 & ACCU/OM$ TO FRE$OM & ! MANAGEM5T ( !IR [N AFFAIRS1 !Y MU/ BE LEFT TO ACT = !MSELVES & FEEL !MSELVES RESPONSIBLE = !IR CONDUCT4 ,!Y MAY (T5 MAKE MI/AKES & DO WRONG1 BUT !Y WILL SEE ! CONSEQU5CES = !MSELVES1 & UND]/& ?AT !Y HAVE DONE AMISS & MU/ GO ON ANO!R TACK4 ,ANO!R ?+4 ,! H>M ! PEOPLE MAY DO LEFT TO !MSELVES WILL NEV] BE ONE MILLIONE? P>T ( ?AT :I* IS DONE BY ! BE/ ( GOV]NM5TS4 ,IF A *ILD IS TO LE>N TO WALK1 HE MU/ BE LET WALK BY HIMSELF1 & NOT BE AFRAID ( ! FALLS HE MAY HAVE4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,YES1 BUT BE=E A *ILD CAN BE SET D[N TO WALK HE MU/ HAVE SOME /R5G? 9 HIS LEGS2 IF HE HAS NONE1 HE MU/ SAY 9 HIS MO!R'S >MS4 

 ,JACK4 ,?AT'S TRUE4 ,BUT GOV]NM5TS >E NOT 9 ! LEA/ LIKE MO!RS4 ,IT IS NOT !Y :O IMPROVE & BUILD UP A NATION4 ,AS A MATT] ( FACT1 SOCIAL PROGRESS IS ALMO/ ALWAYS MADE 9 OPPOSITION TO ! GOV]NM5T OR 9 SPITE ( IT4 ,! MO/ GOV]NM5T DOES IS TO PUT :AT ! MASSES HAVE BEGUN TO NE$ & DESIRE 9TO ! =M ( LAW1 & ?IS IT SPOILS ) ITS SPIRIT ( DOM9ATION & MONOPOLY4 ,! PEOPLES >E 9 DIFF]5T /AGES ( ADVANCEM5T2 BUT 9 NO MATT] :AT /ATE ( CIVILIZATION1 OR EV5 ( B>B>ISM1 A PEOPLE MAY BE1 !Y C\LD MANAGE !IR AFFAIRS BETT] )\T ! GOV]NM5T :I* HAS SPRUNG UP AMONG !M4 ,AS F> AS ,I CAN SEE Y\ FANCY ?AT ! GOV]NM5T IS COMPOS$ ( ! MO/ 9TELLIG5T & CAPABLE M54 ,NO?+ ( ! SORT4 ,G5]ALLY SPEAK+ GOV]NM5TS >E DIRECTLY1 OR BE DELEGATION1 COMPOS$ ( ?OSE :O HAVE ! MO/ MONEY4 ,& BESIDES1 ! EX]CISE ( P[] SPOILS ! F9E/ SPIRITS4 ,PUT ?OSE :O HAVE HI!RTO BE5 ! BE/ ( M5 9TO ! GOV]NM5T & SEE :AT HAPP5S4 ,!Y NO LONG] UND]/& ! NE$S ( ! PEOPLE1 !Y >E OBLIG$ TO BUSY !MSELVES ) ! 9T]E/S CREAT$ BY POLITICS1 !Y >E CORRUPT$ BY ! ABS5CE ( ! EMULATION & CRITICISM ( !IR SOCIAL EQUALS1 & !Y >E DIV]T$ FROM ! SPH]E ( ACTION 9 :I* !Y W]E REALLY COMPET5T1 TO MAKE LAWS AB\T ?+S !Y HAVE NOT EV5 HE>D ( BE=E4 ,F9ALLY1 !Y 5D BY BELIEV+ !MSELVES A SUP]I\R ORD] ( BE+S1 & =M A CA/E :I* TAKES NO HE$ ( ! PEOPLE EXCEPT TO *ECK & BAFFLE !M4 ,BETT]1 F> BETT]1 = US TO MANAGE \R [N AFFAIRS1 BY PUTT+ \RSELVES 9 AGREEM5T ) ! WORK]S ( O!R TRADES & O!R P>TS ( ! C\NTRY2 & NOT ONLY ) ?OSE ( ,5GL& & ,EUROPE1 BUT ( ! :OLE WORLD2 = ALL M5 >E BRE?R5 & HAVE AN 9T]E/ 9 AID+ ONE ANO!R4 ,DON'T Y\ ?9K SO8 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,YES1 Y\ >E RI<T4 ,BUT :AT AB\T ! WICK$8 ,:AT IS TO BE DONE ) ?IEVES & ROBB]S8 

 ,JACK4 ,TO BEG9 )1 :5 !RE IS NO MORE PROP]TY & IGNORANCE WE %AN'T BE TR\BL$ ) MANY ( ?AT SORT4 ,BUT EV5 SUPPOS+ !RE W]E SOME LEFT1 IS ?AT A REASON TO HAVE A GOV]NM5T & POLICE8 ,CAN'T WE \RSELVES BR+ !M TO REASON8 ,NOT BY ILL-TREAT+ !M1 AS BO? 9NOC5T & GUILTY >E ILL-US$ TODAY1 BUT BY PUTT+ !M 9 CONDITIONS :]E !Y CAN'T DO ANY H>M1 & DO+ EV]Y?+ 9 \R P[] TO SET !M ON ! RI<T ROAD AGA94 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,SO :5 WE HAVE ,SOCIALISM1 EV]YBODY WILL BE HAPPY & CONT5T$1 & !RE WILL BE NO MORE WRET*$NESS1 HATR$1 JEAL\SLY1 PRO/ITUTION1 W>1 OR 9JU/ICE8 

 ,JACK4 ,I CAN'T TELL H[ F> HUMAN FELICITY MAY GO1 BUT ,I'M SURE ?+S WILL BE V]Y MU* BETT] ?AN N[4 ,Y\ SEE1 M5 WILL GO ON TRY+ TO BETT] ?+S1 & ALL ! PROGRESS MADE !N WILL B5EFIT EV]Y ONE1 NOT ONLY A FEW4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,BUT :5 IS ALL ?IS GO+ TO HAPP58 ,I'M AN OLD FELL[1 & N[ ?AT ,I KN[ ?AT ! WORLD ISN'T ALWAYS GO+ ON AS IT DOES AT PRES5T1 ,I %\LDN'T LIKE TO DIE )\T HAV+ SE5 ONE DAY ( JU/ICE4 

 ,JACK4 ,:5 WILL IT HAPP58 ,I DON'T KN[4 ,IT DEP5DS UPON US4 ,! MORE WE DO TO OP5 FOLK'S EYES1 ! SOON] ! *ANGE WILL COME AB\T4 ,H[EV]1 !RE IS ONE ?+ TO BE SAID4 ,A GOOD ADVANCE HAS ALREADY BE5 MADE4 ,A FEW YE>S AGO !RE W]E V]Y FEW :O PREA*ES ,SOCIALISM1 & !Y W]E TREAT$ AS FOOLS1 MADM51 OR 9C5DI>IES4 ,TO-DAY ! IDEA IS UND]/OOD BY MANY4 ,!N ! POOR SUFF]$ 9 SIL5CE1 OR REVOLT$ :5 MADD5$ BY HUNG]1 )\T KN[+ ! CAUSES OR ! REM$IES ( !IR WRONGS1 & W]E MASSACR$1 OR MADE TO MASSACRE ONE ANO!R4 ,TO-DAY ALL OV] ! WORLD !Y COME TO A COMMON UND]/&+1 AGITATE & REVOLT ) ! IDEA ( LIB]AT+ !MSELVES FROM !IR EMPLOY]S & FROM GOV]NM5T4 ,!Y DO NOT C\NT ON ANY?+ BUT !IR [N P[]S1 HAV+ AT LA/ BEGUN TO UND]/& ?AT ALL ! P>TIES1 9TO :I* !IR EMPLOY]S >E DIVID$1 >E EQUALLY !IR 5EMIES4 ,LET US1 !N1 BE ACTIVE 9 SPREAD+ \R IDEAS N[1 :5 ! MOM5T IS FAVORABLE4 ,LET ALL ( US :O UND]/& ! QUE/ION UNITE MORE CLOSELY4 ,LET US FAN ! FIRE :I* SMOLD]S AMONG ! MASSES4 ,LET US PR(IT BY ALL DISCONT5T1 EV]Y AGITATION1 EV]Y REVOLT4 ,LET US /RIKE :ILE ! IRON IS HOT1 )\T FE> OR HESITATION4 ,!N IT WILL SOON BE ALL UP ) ! MIDDLE-CLASS1 & ! REIGN ( WELL-BE+ WILL BEG94 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,GOOD6 ,BUT WE MU/ TAKE C>E TO C\NT ! CO/4 ,TO TAKE ! PROP]TY ( ! EMPLOY]S IS EASILY SAID4 ,BUT !RE >E ! POLICE1 ! SOLDI]S4 ,N[ ?AT ,I COME TO ?9K ( IT1 ,I'M AFRAID H&-CUFFS1 SWORDS & GUNS >E MADE MORE TO DEF5D ! MIDDLECLASS ?AN ANY?+ ELSE4 

 ,JACK4 ,?AT'S AS PLA9 AS A PIKE-/AFF4 ,BUT IS ! MIDDLE-CLASS GOV]NM5T USE >MS AGA9/ US & TRY TO KEEP US 9 SLAV]Y ) !IR P[D] & MEL9ITE1 WE MU/ TEA* !M ?AT WE TOO CAN PLAY AT SU* A GAME AS ?AT ) ! APPLIANCES ( MOD]N SCI5TIFIC W>F>E4 ,! POOR >E ! IMM5SE MAJORITY1 & IF !Y BEG9 TO UND]/& & TA/E ! ADVANTAGES ( SOCIALISM1 !RE IS NO P[] ON E>? :I* AN =CE !M TO REMA9 AS !Y >E4 ,CONSID]1 ! POOR >E ?OSE :O WORK & MAKE EV]Y?+4 ,IF ONLY ONE L>GE SECTION ( !M W]E TO /OP WORK+1 !RE W\LD BE SU* A TO-DO1 SU* A PANIC1 ?AT ! REVOLUTION W\LD QUICKLY PROVE TO BE ! ONLY POSSIBLE WAY \T4 ,CONSID] TOO1 ?AT SOLDI]S1 = ! MO/ P>T >E !MSELVES POOR M51 DRIV5 BY HUNG] TO SELL !MSELVES TO HURT & BUT*] !IR [N BRO!RS4 ,AS SOON AS !Y HAVE SE5 & UND]/OOD ! FACTS1 !Y WILL SYMPA?IZE1 AT FIR/ SECRETLY & !N OP5LY1 ) ! PEOPLE4 ,Y\ MAY BE SURE ! REVOLUTION WILL NOT BE HALF SO DIFFICULT AS IT APPE>S AT FIR/4 ,! ESS5TIAL ?+ IS TO KEEP ! IDEA ?AT ! REVOLUTION IS NECESS>Y CON/ANTLY TO ! =E2 TO BE ALWAYS PREP>$ = IT4 ,IF WE DO ?IS1 !RE'S NO D\BT ?AT SOMEH[ OR ANO!R ! *ANCE TO ACT WILL CROP UP4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,SO Y\ SAY1 & ,I BELIEVE Y\ >E RI<T4 ,BUT !RE >E ?OSE :O SAY ?AT ! REVOLUTION W\LD DO NO GOOD1 & ?AT ?+S WILL SL[LY RIP5 ( !MSELVES4 ,:AT DO Y\ SAY TO ?AT8 

 ,JACK4 ,Y\ MU/ KN[ ?AT S9CE ,SOCIALISM HAS BECOME AS S]I\S MATT]1 & ! MIDDLE-CLASS HAVE BEGUN TO BE REALLY AFRAID ( IT1 !Y HAVE BE5 TRY+ 9 EV]Y POSSIBLE WAY TO TURN ASIDE ! TEMPE/ & DECEIVE ! PEOPLE4 ,ALL SORTS1 EV5 EMP]ORS1 >E BEG9N+ TO SAY !Y >E SOCIALI/S1 & ,I LEAVE Y\ TO GUESS :AT SU* 0SOCIALISM3 IS WOR?4 ,EV5 AMONG \R [N COMRADES1 !RE HAVE BE5 TRAITORS TEMPT$ BY ATT5TION FROM ! G5TLEFOLKS1 & ! ADVANTAGES !Y MI<T GA91 TO DES]T ! REVOLUTION>Y CAUSE & SET !MSELVES TO PREA* LEGAL MEANS & ALLIANCE ) POLITICAL P>TIES1 :I* !Y SAY >E ALL MORE OR LESS SOCIALI/IC4 0,WE >E ALL SOCIALI/S NOT60 AS ,H>C\RT SAID 9 ! ,H\SE ( ,COMMONS4 ,SU* M5 TREAT REVOLUTION>IES AS FOOLS & WORSE4 ,SOME ( !M PR(ESS /ILL TO WI% = A REVOLUTION1 BUT1 MEANTIME !Y WI% A GREAT DEAL MORE TO BE ,M4,P'S4 ,:5 ANY ONE TELLS Y\ ?AT ! REVOLUTION IS NOT NECESS>Y & BEG9S TALK+ AB\T NOM9AT+ ,M4,P4'S & ,C\NTY ,C\NCILORS1 ( MAK+ COMMON CAUSE ) ANY MIDDLE-CLASS P>TY1 IF HE IS A MIDDLE-CLASS MAN1 OR SEEMS AS IF HE W\LD LIKE TO BE ONE1 S5D HUM AB\T HIS BUS9ESS4 ,AMONG ?OSE MI/AK5 ,SOCIALI/S !RE >E SOME :O 9 ALL GOOD FAI? WI% TO DO GOOD1 & BELIEVE !Y >E DO+ IT2 BUT IF SOME ONE S9C]ELY BELIEV+ HE IS DO+ Y\ GOOD1 ?RA%ES Y\ TILL Y\'RE HALF DEAD1 Y\ WILL ?9K FIR/ ( ALL H[ TO GET ! /ICK \T ( HIS H&S4 ,! MO/ HIS GOOD 9T5TIONS WILL DO WILL BE TO /OP Y\1 :5 Y\ HAVE GOT ! /ICK1 FROM BREAK+ HIS HEAD ) IT4 

 ,WILLIAM4 ,RI<T Y\ >E6 ,BUT N[ !RE'S SOME?+ ELSE ,I WANT TO ASK Y\4 ,:5 Y\ SAY ,SOCIALI/S1 :AT DO Y\ MEAN EXACTLY8 ,I (T5 HE> TELL ( ,SOCIALI/S1 & ,COMMUNI/S1 & ,COLLECTIVI/S1 & ,AN>*I/S1 & ,I KN[ NO MORE ?AN ,ADAM :AT ALL ?OSE WORDS MEAN4 

 ,JACK4 ,AH1 ,I'M GLAD Y\'VE GOT ON ?AT4 ,!RE'S NO?+ LIKE CLE>+ UP ! MEAN+ ( WORDS4 ,WELL N[1 ,SOCIALI/S >E FOLKS :O BELIEVE ?AT PROP]TY IS ! FIR/ CAUSE ( ALL SOCIAL ILLS1 & ?AT AS LONG AS POV]TY IS NOT DE/ROY$1 NEI!R IGNORANCE1 NOR SLAV]Y1 NOR POLITICAL 9EQUALITY1 NOR PRO/ITUTION1 NOR ANY ( ! EVILS :I* KEEP ! PEOPLE 9 SU* A HORRIBLE CONDITION1 CAN BE ROOT$ \T2 TO SAY NO?+ ( ! FRI<TFUL SUFF]+ :I* >ISES FROM ACTUAL WANT4 ,SOCIALI/S BELIEVE ?AT POV]TY RESULTS FROM ! FACT ?AT ! SOIL & ALL RAW MAT]IALS1 MA*9]Y & ALL 9/RUM5TS ( LABOR1 BELONG TO A FEW 9DIVIDUALS1 :O ?US >E ABLE TO DISPOSE ( ! LIVES ( ALL ! WORK+ CLASS1 & F9D !MSELVES 9VOLV$ 9 P]PETUAL /RUGGLE & COMPETITION1 NOT ONLY ) ! PROLET>IAT 7?OSE :O HAVE NO?+71 BUT ALSO AMONG !MSELVES1 = ! POSSESSION ( PROP]TY4 ,! ,SOCIALI/S BELIEVE ?AT BY ABOLI%+ PRIVATE PROP]TY1 I4E41 ! CAUSE1 !Y WILL AT ! SAME TIME ABOLI% POV]TY1 ! EFFECT4 ,?IS PROP]TY CAN & \<T TO BE ABOLI%$2 = ! ORGANIZATION & DI/RIBUTION ( WEAL? \<T TO BE REGULAT$ BY ! REAL 9T]E/S ( M51 )\T REG>D = ! SO-CALL$ 3ACQUIR$ RI<TS1@&_?#a#d#h2 :I* ! MIDDLE-CLASS CLAIM = !MSELVES1 BECAUSE !IR ANCE/ORS W]E /RONG]1 MORE LUCKY1 OR MORE KNAVI% ?AN O!R M54 ,SO Y\ SEE ! NAME ,S,O,C,I,A,L,I,/ BETOK5S ALL ?OSE :O WI% ?AT SOCIAL WEAL? %\LD BE AT ! S]VICE OR ALL M51 & ?AT !RE %\LD NO LONG] BE PROP]TY-[N]S & PROLET>IANS1 RI* & POOR1 EMPLOY]S & EMPLOY$4  

  ,WILLIAM4 ,!N Y\ >E A ,SOCIALI/1 ?AT@&_?#a#d#f2S SURE4 ,BUT :AT DO ! WORDS ,C,O,M,M,U,N,I,/ & ,C,O,L,L,E,C,T,I,V,I,/ MEAN8  

  ,JACK4 ,BO? ,COMMUNI/S & ,COLLECTIVI/S >E ,SOCIALI/S1 BUT !Y HAVE DIFF]5T IDEAS AS TO :AT \<T TO BE DONE :5 PROP]TY %ALL BE PUT 9 COMMON4 ,! ,COLLECTIVI/S SAY3 ,EA* WORK]1 OR RA!R EA* ASSOCIATION ( WORK]S1 HAS A RI<T TO RAW MAT]IAL & ! 9/RUM5TS ( LABOR & EA* MAN IS MA/] ( ! PRODUCE ( HIS [N TOIL4 ,:IL/ HE LIVES HE DOES :AT HE LIKES ) IT2 :5 HE DOES ANY?+ HE HAS PUT ON ONE SIDE RETURNS TO ! ASSOCIATION4 ,HIS *ILDR51 9 !IR TURN1 HAVE ! MEANS ( WORK+ & ( 5JOY+ ! FRUIT ( !IR LABOR2 TO LET !M 9H]IT ANY?+ W\LD BE A FI/ /EP T[>DS 9EQUALITY & PRIVILEGE4 ,AS REG>DS 9/RUCTION1 ! $UCATION ( *ILDR51 ! MA9T5ANCE ( ! AG$ & 9FIRM1 & PUBLIC WORKS 9 G5]AL1 EA* ASSOCIATION ( WORK]S MU/ GIVE :AT IS NE$$ TO SUPPLY ! UNSUPPLI$ WANTS ( ! MEMB]S ( ! COMMUNITY4 ,! ,COMMUNI/S SAY3 ,M5 MU/ LOVE EA* O!R & LOOK ON EA* O!R AS MEMB]S ( ONE FAMILY1 IF ?+S >E TO GO WELL ) !M4 ,PROP]TY \<T TO BE COMMON4 ,WORK1 IF IT IS TO BE AS PRODUCTIVE AS POSSIBLE & ! AID ( MA*9]Y EMPLOY$ TO ! UTT]MO/1 MU/ BE DONE BY L>GE P>TIES ( WORK]S4 ,IF WE >E TO MAKE ! MO/ ( ALL V>IETIES ( SOIL & ATMOSPH]IC CONDITION & PRODUCE 9 EA* LOCALITY :AT ?AT LOCALITY CAN PRODUCE BE/1 & IT1 ON ! O!R H&1 WE >E TO AVOID COMPETITION & H>$ BETWE5 DIV]SE C\NTRIES1 IT IS NE$FUL TO E/ABLI% P]FECT SOLID>ITY BETWE5 ! M5 ( ! :OLE WORLD4 ,!RE=E1 9/EAD ( RUNN+ ! RISK ( MAK+ A CONFUSION 9 TRY+ TO DI/+UI% :AT Y\ & ,I EA* DO1 LET US ALL WORK & PUT EV]Y?+ 9 COMMON4 ,9 ?IS WAY EA* WILL GIVE TO SOCIETY ALL ?AT HIS /R5G? P]MITS UNTIL 5\< IS PRODUC$ = EV]Y ONE2 & EA* WILL TAKE ALL ?AT HE NE$S1 LIMIT+ HIS NE$S ONLY 9 ?OSE ?+S ( :I* !RE IS NOT YET PL5TY = EV]Y ONE4  

  ,WILLIAM4 ,NOT SO FA/6 ,FIR/ ( ALL1 :AT DO Y\ MEAN BY ,S,O,L,I,D,>,I,T,Y8 ,Y\ SAY !RE \<T TO BE SOLID>ITY BETWE5 M5 & ,I DON@&_?#a#d#f2T KN[ :AT Y\ MEAN4  

  ,JACK4 ,LOOK H]E3 9 Y\R FAMILY1 = 9/ANCE1 ALL ?AT Y\ & Y\R BRO!RS1 Y\R WIFE & Y\R SON E>N Y\ PUT 9 COMMON4 ,Y\ GET SOME FOOD & Y\ EAT ALTOGE!R1 & IF !RE IS NOT 5\< Y\ ALL P9* Y\RSELVES A BIT4 ,IF ONE ( Y\ IS LUCKY & GA9S ! MORE ?AN USUAL1 IT IS A GOOD ?+ = EV]Y ONE4 ,IF1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 ONE IS \T ( WORK OR ILL1 IT IS A MIS=TUNE = Y\ ALL2 = C]TA9LY AMONG Y\RSELVES ! ONE :O IS NOT WORK+ EATS ALL ! SAME AT ! COMMON BO>D1 & ! ONE :O FALLS ILL CO/S MORE ?AN ANYBODY ELSE4 ,SO 9 Y\R FAMILY1 9/EAD ( TRY+ TO TAKE WORK & BREAD AWAY FROM EA* O!R1 Y\ TRY TO AID EA* O!R1 BECAUSE ! GOOD O ONE IS ! GOOD ( ALL1 & ! ILL ( ONE ! ILL ( ALL4 ,?US 5VY & HATR$ >E KEPT AF> (F & A MUTUAL AFFECTION IS DEVELOP$1 :I* NEV] EXI/S 9 A FAMILY :]E !RE >E DIVID$ 9T]E/S4 ,?AT IS :AT IS CALL$ SOLID>ITY4 ,WE MU/ E/ABLI% AMONG MANK9D ! SAME RELATIONS AS EXI/ 9 A TRULY UNIT$ FAMILY4  

  ,WILLIAM4 ,I UND]/& ?AT4 ,BUT LET US RETURN TO :AT WE W]E SPEAK+ (4 ,TELL ME1 >E Y\ A ,COLLECTIVI/ ( A ,COMMUNI/8  

  ,JACK4 ,AS = ME1 ,I AM A ,COMMUNI/1 BECAUSE IF PEOPLE >E GO+ TO BE FRI5DS1 ,I BELIEVE !Y \<T NOT TO BE FRI5DS BY HALVES4 ,COLLECTIVISM LEAVES ! G]MS ( RIVALRY & HATR$ /ILL 9 EXI/5CE4 ,BUT ,I GO FUR!R4 ,EV5 IF EA* C\LD LIVE ON :AT HE PRODUCES HIMSELF1 ,COLLECTIVISM W\LD BE 9F]IOR TO ,COMMUNISM1 BECAUSE IT W\LD KEEP M5 ISOLAT$1 & SO LESS5 !IR /R5G? & !IR SYMPA?Y4 ,BESIDES1 AS ! %OE-MAK] CAN@&_?#a#d#f2T EAT HIS %OES1 NOR ! BLACKSMI? LIVE ON IRON1 & AS ! AGRICULTURI/ CANNOT TILL ! COIL )\T ! WORK]S :O PREP>E IRON1 MANUFACTURE IMPLEM5TS1 ETC41 IT WILL BE NECESS>Y TO ORGANIZE EX*ANGE BETWE5 ! V>I\S PRODUC]S1 KEEP+ A RECKON+ ( :AT EA* ONES4 ,!N IT WILL NECESS>ILY HAPP5 ?AT ! %OE MAK]1 = 9/ANCE1 WILL TRY TO PUFF ! VALUE ( HIS %OES & GET AS MU* MONEY AS HE CAN 9 EX*ANGE1 :IL/ ! AGRICULTURI/1 ON HIS SIDE1 WILL GIVE HIM AS LITTLE AS POSSIBLE4 ,H[ ! DEVIL CAN WE MANAGE WILL ALL ?IS8 ,COLLECTIVISM SEEMS TO ME TO GIVE RISE TO MANY DIFFICULT PROBLEMS & BE A SY/EM LIKELY TO LEAD TO CONFUSION4 ,COMMUNISM1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 WILL NOT GIVE RISE TO ANY DIFFICULTIES4 ,IF ALL WORK1 & ALL 5JOY ( ! WORK ( ALL1 IT ONLY REMA9S TO SEE :AT >E ! ?+S NE$$ TO SATISFY EV]Y BODY & TO >RANGE ?AT !SE ?+S %ALL BE PRODUC$ 9 PL5TY4  

  ,WILLIAM4 ,SO UND] ,COMMUNISM NO MONEY W\LD BE WANT$4  

  ,JACK4 ,NEI!R MONEY NOR ANY?+ 9 ITS PLACE4 ,NO?+ BUT A REGI/] ( :AT IS NE$$ & ( :AT IS PRODUC$1 SO ?AT PRODUCTION MAY BE KEPT UP ! LEVEL ( NE$4 ,! ONLY S]I\S DIFFICULTY W\LD BE IF MANY M5 REFUSES TO WORK4 ,BUT ,I HAVE ALREADY TOLD Y\ ! REASONS :Y WORK1 :I* TO-DAY IS A H>D%IP1 W\LD !N BECOME A PLEASURE1 &1 AT ! SAME TIME1 A MORAL OBLIGATION FROM :I* V]Y FEW W\LD WI% TO RELIEVE !MSELVES4 ,BESIDES1 IF1 9 CONSEQU5CE ( ! BAD $UCATION WE HAVE HAD1 SOME 9DIVIDUALS %\LD REFUSE TO WORK :5 ! NEW SOCIETY BEG9S1 !Y CAN BE LEFT \TSIDE ! COMMUNITY & GIV5 RAW MAT]IAL & TOOLS4 ,!N1 IF !Y WANT TO EAT1 !Y WILL SET TO WORK4 ,BUT AT ?IS MOM5T :AT WE HAVE TO REALIZE IS ?AT ! SOIL1 RAW MAT]IAL & 9/RUM5TS ( LABOR1 H\SES & ALL EXI/+ WEAL? MU/ BE PUT 9 COMMON4 ,AS = ! ME?OD ( ORGANIZATION1 ! PEOPLE WILL DO AS !Y PLEASE4 ,PRACTICE ONLY WILL %[ !M ! BE/ SY/EM4 ,IT IS EASY TO =ESEE ?AT 9 MANY PLACES !Y WILL E/ABLI% ,COLLECTIVISM & 9 MANY O!RS ,COMMUNISM4 ,:5 BO? HAVE BE5 PUT TO ! PRO(1 ! BETT] WILL BE WIDELY ADOPT$4 ,BUT M9D1 ! *IEF ?+ IS ?AT NOBODY %\LD BEG9 TO ORD] ! O!RS AB\T OR TO APPROPRIATE ! SOIL OR 9/RUM5TS ( LABOR4 ,IT WILL BE NECESS>Y TO B EON ! WAT*1 & IF ?IS IS ATTEMPT$1 TO PREV5T IT1 EV5 BY =CE ( >MS4 ,! RE/ WILL FOLL[ NATURALLY ( ITSELF4  

  ,WILLIAM4 ,?AT TOO ,I UND]/&4 ,BUT1 TELL ME1 :AT DOES ! WORD ,A,N,>,*,I,S,M MEAN8  

  ,JACK4 ,A,N,>,*,Y MEANS ,),\,T ,G,O,V,],N,M,5,T4 ,I@&_?#a#d#f2VE TOLD Y\ ALREADY ?AT GOV]NM5T IS GOOD = NO?+ BUT TO DEF5D ! MIDDLE-CLASS1 & ?AT1 :]E \R 9T]E/S >E 9 QUE/ION1 ! BE/ ?+ WE CAN DO IS TO LOOK AFT] !M \RSELVES4 ,9/EAD ( ELECT+ ,M4,P4@&_?#a#d#f2S & ,C\NTY ,C\NCILORS TO MAKE & UNMAKE LAWS = US TO OBEY1 WE WILL DISCUSS \R AFFAIRS \RSELVES1 & :5 IT IS NE$FUL TO COMMISSION SOMEONE ELSE TO C>RY \T \R DECISIONS1 WE WILL ASK HUM TO DO SO & SO1 & NOT O!RWISE4 ,IF !RE IS SOME?+ :I* CAN@&_?#a#d#f2T BE DOME RI<T (F1 WE WILL COMMISSION CAPABLE P]SONS TO LOOK 9TO IT1 /UDY IT & LET US KN[ :AT !Y ?9K HAD BETT] BE DONE4 ,BUT1 AT ALL EV5TS1 NO?+ WILL BE DONE ON \R BEHALF )\T \R WILL4 ,& ?US \R DELEGATES WILL NOT BE 9DIVIDUALS TO :OM WE HAVE GIV5 ! RI<T TO COMM& US & IMPOSE LAWS UPON US4 ,!Y WILL BE P]SONS *OS5 = !IR CAPACITY1 H[ WILL HAVE NO AU?ORITY1 BUT SIMPLY BE *>G$ ) ! DUTY ( EXECUT+ :AT ! PEOPLE HAVE DECID$ UPON4 ,= EXAMPLE1 SOME WILL BE *>G$ TO ORGANIZE S*OOLS1 O!RS TO MAKE /REETS1 OR LOOK AFT] ! EX*ANGE ( PRODUCE1 JU/ AS TO-DAY A %OE-MAK] IS ASK$ TO MAKE A PAIR ( %OES4  

  ,WILLIAM4 ,PRAY EXPLA9 A LITTLE MORE4 ,H[ C\LD ,I1 A POOR1 IGNORANT OLD FELL[1 UND]TAKE ALL ! BUS9ESS :I* IS DONE BY ,M4,P4@&_?#a#d#f2S & M9I/]S8  

  ,JACK4 ,& :AT GOOD DO !SE ,M4,P4@&_?#a#d#f2S & M9I/]S DO1 ?AT Y\ %\LD BEMOAN Y\RSELF = NOT BE+ ABLE TO DO ! LIKE8 ,!Y MAKE LAWS & ORGANIZE ! PUBLIC MI<T TO KEEP ! PEOPLE D[N1 9 ! 9T]E/ ( ! PROP]TY-[N]S4 ,?AT@&_?#a#d#f2S ALL4 ,IT IS A SKILL WE DO NOT NE$4 ,TRUE1 ! M9I/]S & ,M4,P4@&_?#a#d#f2S DO BUSY !MSELVES AB\T GOOD & USEFUL ?+S1 BUT ONLY TO TURN !M TO ! PR(IT ( A CLASS & H9D] PROGRESS BY MEANS ( USELESS & VEXATI\S 5ACTM5TS4 ,= 9/ANCE1 !SE G5TRY BUSY !MSELVES AB\T RAILWAYS2 BUT :Y %\LD !Y8 ,W\LD NOT ! 5G9E]S1 ME*ANICS1 & WORKM5 ( ALL SORTS BE 5\<8 ,& W\LD NOT ! LOCOMOTIVES RUN JU/ ! SAME IF M9I/]S1 ,M4,P4@&_?#a#d#f2S1 %>EHOLD]S1 & O!R P>ASITES DISAPPE>$8 ,IT IS JU/ ! SAME ) ! PO/ & TELEGRAPH (FICE1 NAVIGATION1 $UCATION1 HOSPITALS1 ALL ?+S C>RI$ ON BY WORK]S ( ONE SORT OR ANO!R1 ) :OM ! GOV]NM5T ONLY 9T]F]ES TO DO H>M4 ,POLITICS1 AS !Y >E UND]/OOD BY POLITICIANS1 >E A DIFFICULT >T = US1 BECAUSE 9 GOOD E>NE/ !Y HAVE NO?+ TO DO ) ! PEOPLE@&_?#a#d#f2S REAL 9T]E/S4 ,BUT IF !Y >E UND]/OOD BY POLITICIANS1 >E A DIFFICULT >T = US1 BECAUSE 9 GOOD E>NE/ !Y HAVE NO?+ TO DO ) ! PEOPLE@&_?#a#d#f2S REAL 9T]E/S4 ,BUT IF !IR 5D WAS TO SATISFY ! ACTUAL NE$S ( ! POPULATION1 :5 !Y W\LD BE MORE DIFFICULT = AN ,M4,P4 ?AN = US4 ,:AT CAN ,M4,P4@&_?#a#d#f2S RESID+ 9 ,LONDON KN[ ( ! NE$S ( ! C\NTRY DI/RICTS8 ,H[ CAN !SE FOLKS1 :O HAVE MO/LY WA/$ !IR TIME 9 TRY+ TO LE>N ,GREEK & ,LAT91 :I* !Y DON@&_?#a#d#f2T KN[ AFT] ALL1 UND]/& ! 9T]E/S ( ! V>I\S CRAFTS & 9DU/RIES8 ,?+S W\LD GO V]Y DIFF]5TLY IF EA* BUSI$ HIMSELF ) :AT HE KN[S AB\T & HE NE$S HE HAS ASC]TA9$ ON HIS [N ACC\NT4 ,:5 ONCE ! REVOLUTION HAS TAK5 PLACE1 WE %ALL HAVE TO BEG9 AT ! BOTTOM1 SO TO SPEAK4 ,UND] ! 9FLU5CE ( ! PROPAG&A & ! 5?USIASM ( ! TIME1 ! V>I\S TRADES 9 EA* DI/RICT1 P>I%1 OR T[N1 WILL =M ASSOCIATIONS4 ,& :O CAN UND]/& BETT] ?AN Y\ ! 9T]E/S ( Y\R [N TRADE & Y\R [N LOCALITY4 ,AFT]W>DS1 :5 IT IS DESIRABLE TO BR+ SEV]AL TRADES OR SEV]AL DI/RICTS TO A COMMON AGREEM5T1 DELEGATES FROM EA* WILL C>RY ! WI%ES ( ?OSE :O HAVE S5T !M TO A SPECIAL CONGRESS1 & DO !IR BE/ TO RECONCILE ! DIV]SE NE$S & WI%ES4 ,BUT !IR DELIB]ATIONS WILL ALWAYS BE SUBMITT$ TO ! CONTROL & APPROBATION ( !IR PR9CIPALS1 SO ?AT ! 9T]E/S ( ! PEOPLE WILL NOT BE NEGLECT$4 ,?US GRADUALLY ! HUMAN RACE WILL BE BR\<T 9TO H>MONY4  

  ,WILLIAM4 ,BUT H[ %ALL WE MANAGE IF 9 A C\NTRY OR AN ASSOCIATION !RE >E SOME :O >E ( A DIFF]5T OP9ION FROM ! RE/8 ,! L>G] NUMB] WILL BE SURE TO HAVE ! UPP] H&1 WON@&_?#a#d#f2T !Y8  

  ,JACK4 ,NOT BY RI<T4 ,= AS REG>DS TRU? & JU/ICE NUMB]S \<T TO GO = NO?+4 ,ONE MAY BE 9 ! RI<T AGA9/ A HUNDR$1 AGA9/ A HUNDR$ ?\S&1 AGA9/ EV]Y BODY4 ,PRACTICALLY1 WE MU/ DO AS BE/ WE CAN4 ,IF WE CANNOT OBTA9 UNANIMITY1 ?OSE :O AGREE & >E ! MAJORITY WILL C>RY \T !IR IDEA1 )9 ! LIMITS ( !IR WON GR\P1 & IF EXP]I5CE %[S !Y W]E RI<T1 !RE IS NO D\BT BUT ?AT !Y WILL BE IMITAT$4  ,IF NOT1 IT IS A PRO( ?AT ! M9ORITY W]E 9 ! RI<T1 & ACTION WILL BE TAK5 ACCORD+LY4 ,?US ! PR9CIPLES ( EQUALITY & JU/ICE1 UPON :I* SOCIETY \<T TO BE F\ND$1 WILL NOT BE VIOLAT$4 ,BUT REM>K ?AT ! QUE/IONS UPON :I* PEOPLE CANNOT COME TO AN AGREEM5T WILL BE SMALL 9 NUMB] & IMPORTANCE1 BECAUSE !RE WILL NO LONG] BE ! DIVISION ( 9T]E/S :I* EXI/S TO-DAY4 ,= EA* WILL !N BE FREE TO *OOSE HIS C\NTRY & ! ASSOCIATION1 I4E41 ! COMPANIONS ) :OM HE LIKES TO LIVE4 ,ALSO ! MATT]S TO BE DECID$ WILL BE ?+S EV]Y ONE CAN UND]/&1 BELONG+ RA!R TO PRACTICAL LIFE & POSITIVE SCI5CE ?AN TO ! DOMA9 ( !ORY ) ?IS 5DLESS DIFF]5CES ( OP9ION4 ,:5 ! BE/ SOLUTION ( SU* & SU* A PROBLEM HAS BE5 >RIV$ AT BY EXP]I5CE1 ! QUE/ION WILL BE H[ TO P]SUADE FOLKS BY PRACTICALLY %[+ !M ! ?+1 NOT H[ TO CRU% !M UND] A MAJORITY ( VOTES4 ,W\LD Y\ NOT LAU< IF TO-DAY CITIZ5S W]E CALL$ UPON TO VOTE ! SEASON = S[+ SE$1 :5 IT IS A MATT] ALREADY SETTL$ BY EXP]I5CE8 ,& IF IT W]E NOT YET 5TIRELY FIX$1 W\LD Y\ HAVE REC\RSE TO A VOTE TO DECIDE IT1 RA!R ?AN TO EXP]I5CE8 ,ALL PUBLIC & PRIVATE AFFAIRS WILL BE TREAT$ LIKE ?IS4  

  ,WILLIAM4 ,BUT :AT IF SOME \T ( M]E PI<EAD$NESS & SELF-WILL %\LD OPPOSE A DECISION MADE 9 ! 9T]E/S ( ALL8  

  ,JACK4 ,!N1 ( C\RSE1 IT W\LD BE NE$FUL TO TAKE =CIBLE ACTION4 ,= IF IT IS UNJU/ ?AT ! MAJORITY %\LD OPPRESS ! M9ORITY1 ! CONTR>Y W\LD BE QUITE AS UNJU/2 & IF ! M9ORITY HAS A RI<T TO REBEL1 ! MAJORITY HAS A RI<T TO DEF5D ITSELF4 ,BUT DO NOT =GET ?AT ALWAYS & EV]Y:]E ALL M5 HAVE AN UND5IABLE RI<T TO ! MAT]IALS & 9/RUM5TS ( LABOR4 ,?\< IT IS TRU? HAT ?IS SOLUTION IS NOT COMPLETELY SATISFACTORY4 ,! 9DIVIDUALS PUT \T ( ! ASSOCIATION W\LD BE DEPRIV$ ( MANY SOCIAL ADVANTAGES1 :I* AN ISOLAT$ P]SON OR GR\P MU/ DO )\T1 BECAUSE !Y CAN ONLY BE PROCUR$ BY ! COOP]ATION ( A GREAT NUMB] ( HUMAN BE+S4 ,BUT :AT W\LD Y\ HAVE8 ,!SE MALCONT5TS CANNOT FAIRLY DEM& ?AT ! WI%ES ( MANY O!RS %\LD BE SACRIFIC$ = !IR SAKES4 ,GIV5 SOLID>ITY1 FRAT]NITY1 MUTUAL AID1 &1 :]E NE$FUL1 MUTUAL CONSID]ATION & SUPPORT1 & Y\ MAY BE CONV9C$ ?AT CIVIL TYRANNY OR W> WILL NOT >ISE4 ,RE/ ASSUR$ RA!R1 ?AT M5 WILL H>DLY HAVE BECOME MA/]S ( !IR [N DE/9IES BE=E SOLID>ITY WILL GR[ UP AMONG !M4 ,= TYRANNY & CIVIL W> WORK EVIL TO ALL1 & SOLID>ITY IS ! ONLY CONDITION 9 :I* \R IDEALS CAN BE REALIZ$1 & :I* WILL BR+ ) IT PEACE1 PROSP]ITY1 & UNIV]SAL FRE$OM4 ,NOTE TOO ?AT PROGRESS1 :ILE IT R5DS ALWAYS TO UNITE M51 T5DS ALSO TO R5D] !M MORE 9DEP5D5T & SELF-SUFFIC+4 ,= EXAMPLE1 TO-DAY1 TO RAVEL RAPIDLY OV] L&1 IT IS NECESS>Y TO MAKE USE ( ! RAILWAY1 ! CON/RUCTION & WORK+ ( :I* REQUIRE ! COLLECTIVE LABOR ( MANY P]SONS4 ,!RE=E ! TRAVEL] WILL /ILL1 UND] ,AN>*Y1 BE OBLIG$ TO ADAPT HIS >RANGEM5TS TO ! \RS & REGULATIONS :I* ! MAJORITY HAVE ?\<T BE/4 ,IT1 H[EV]1 SOMEONE 9V5TS A LOCOMOTIVE :I* ONE MAN CAN GUIDE1 )\T DANG] TO HIMSELF OR O!RS1 ON ANY /REET1 !N HE WILL NOT NE$ TO ADAPT HIMSELF 9 ?IS MATT] TO ! >RANGEM5TS ( O!R FOLKS1 & EV]Y ONE WILL BE ABLE TO TRAVEL :]E & :5 HE PLEASES4 ,S,O IT ID ) ?\S&S ( O!R ?+S ?AT >E1 OR ?AT WILL BE 9 ! FUTURE4 ,?US IT IS CLE> ?AT ! T5D5CY ( PROGRESS IS T[>DS A C]TA9 RELATION BETWE5 M51 :I* MAY BE DEF9$ BY ! =MULA ,M,O,R,A,L ,S,O,L,I,D,>,I,T,Y ,& ,M,A,T,],I,A,L ,9,D,E,P,5,D,5,C,E4  

  ,WILLIAM4 ,?AT IS JU/ IS4 ,S,O Y\ >E A ,SOCIALI/1 & AMONG ,SOCIALI/S Y\ >E SPECIFICALLY A ,COMMUNI/ & AN ,AN>*I/4 ,BUT ,I HAVE HE>D SAY TOO ?AT Y\ >E AN ,9T]NATIONALI/4 ,:AT DOES ?AT MEAN8  

  ,JACK4 ,DID Y\ EV] HE> ( ! ,9T]NATIONAL ,WORK+ ,M5@&_?#a#d#f2S ,ASSOCIATION8 ,AB\T ?IRTY YE>S AGO1 A GREAT ASSOCIATION WAS =M$ AMONG ! WORKM5 ( ALL CIVILIZ$ C\NTRIES1 TO TAKE C\NSEL TOGE!R AB\T ! WRONGS :I* ! WORK]S ( EV]Y L& ALIKE SUFF] FROM ! EXPLOITATION ( PROP]TY-[N]S1 & TO ACT TOGE!R SO AS TO BR+ AB\T A UNIV]SAL SOCIAL REVOLUTION4 ,=1 9 EV]Y C\NTRY :I* HAS REA*$ \R /AGE ( CIVILIZATION1 ! WORK]S >E EXPLOIT$ 9 MU* ! SAME WAY1 & ! RUL+ CLASSES >E B&$ TOGE!R TO KEEP ! MASSES D[N4 ,!RE=E1 ! COMMON 9T]E/S ( ! WORK]S ( ALL L&S >E F> /RONG] ?AN !IR NATIONAL DIFF]5CES1 & IT IS ONLY BY ACT+ 9 COMMON1 AS !IR EXPLOIT]S ACT 9 COMMON1 ?AT !Y CAN ?R[ (F ! YOKE ( CAPITALISM4 ,! ,9T]NATIONAL ,WORK+ ,M5@&_?#a#d#f2S ,ASSOCIATION NO LONG] EXI/S4 ,NEV]!LESS1 ! GREAT LABOR MOVEM5TS :I* AGITATE ! WORK]S HAVE >IS5 FROM IT4 ,ALSO ! C>I\S ,SOCIALI/ P>TIES 9 DIFF]5T C\NTRIES1 SPECIFICALLY ! ,9T]NATIONAL ,SOCIALI/ ,AN>*I/ ,REVOLUTION>Y ,P>TY1 :I* IS N[ ORGANIZ+ TO GIVE ! DEA? BL[ TO ! MIDDLE-CLASS SOCIETY ( TO-DAY4 ,! AIM ( ?IS P>TY IS ( DO EV]Y?+ TO SPREAD ! PR9CIPLES ( ,AN>*I/ ,SOCIALISM2 TO %[ H[ HOPELESS IT IS TO LOOK TO VOLUNT>Y CONCESSIONS FROM PROP]TY [N]S OR GOV]NM5TS1 OR TO GRADUAL CON/ITUTIONAL RE=MS2 TO AWAK5 ! PEOPLE TO A CONSCI\SNESS ( !IR RI<TS1 & R\SE 9 !M ! SPIRIT ( REVOLT2 TO URGE !M ON TO MAKE ! SOCIAL REVOLUTION1 I4E41 TO DE/ROY ALL GOV]NM5T & TO PUT ALL EXI/+ WEAL? 9 COMMON4 ,ANY ONE :O ACCEPTS ?IS PROGRAM & WI%ES TO JO9 O!RS 9 /RIV+ = IT1 BELONGS TO ?IS P>TY4 ,! P>TY HAS NO HEAD1 NO AU?ORITY2 IT IS 5TIRELY F\ND$ ON SPONTANE\S & VOLUNT>Y AGREEM5T AMONG ?OSE :O >E FI<T+ = ! SAME CAUSE4 ,!RE=E1 EA* 9DIVIDUAL ?AT BELONGS TO IT IS COMPLETELY FREE TO JO9 9 9TIMATE COMPANION%IP ) ?OSE HE PREF]S1 TO USE SU* MEANS AS HE ?+S BE/1 & TO SPREAD HIS [N P>TICUL> IDEAS 9 HIS [N P>TICUL> WAY1 SO LONG1 ( C\RSE1 AS HE DOES NOT !REBY OPPOSE ! G5]AL PROGRAM & TACTICS ( ! P>TY4  

  ,WILLIAM4 ,!N >E ALL :O ACCEPT ,SOCIALI/IC1 ,AN>*IC1 ,REVOLUTION>Y PR9CIPLES MEMB]S ( ?IS P>TY8  

  ,JACK4 ,NO4 ,A MAN MY P]FECTLY AGREE ) \R PROGRAM1 BUT1 = ONE REASON OR ANO!R1 MAY PREF] TO ACT ALONE1 OR ) A FEW O!RS1 )\T =M+ CONNECTIONS ( EFFECTIVE SOLID>ITY & COOP]ATION ) ! MASS ( ?OSE :O ACCEPT ! PROGRAM4 ,?IS MAY BE SUITABLE = C]TA9 9DIVIDUALS1 OR = C]TA9 SPECIAL PURPOSES1 BUT IT CANNOT BE ! G5]AL ME?OD1 BECAUSE ISOLATION IS A CAUSE ( WEAKNESS1 & CREATES ANTIPA?Y & RIVALRY :]E !RE \<T TO BE FRAT]NITY & CONCORD4 ,/ILL 9 EV]Y WAY WE ALWAYS CONSID] AS FRI5DS & COMRADES ! M5 & WOM5 :O >E /RIV+ 9 ANY FA%ION = ! IDEA = :I* WE /RIVE4 ,BUT AGA9 !RE MAY BE FOLKS CONV9C$ ( ! TRU? ( ! IDEA1 BUT KEEP+ !IR CONVICTIONS TO !MSELVES1 NOT TAK+ ! TR\BLE TO SPREAD :AT !Y BELIEVE IS RI<T4 ,ONE CAN@&_?#a#d#f2T SAY ?AT SU* FOLKS >E NOT ,SOCIALI/S & ,AN>*I/S !ORETICALLY1 BECAUSE !Y ?9K AS WE DO2 BUT !IR CONVICTIONS C]TA9LY MU/ BE V]Y WEAK1 OR !Y !MSELVES V]Y POOR SPIRIT$4 ,:5 A MAN SEES ! T]RIBLE EVILS ?AT AFFLICT HIMSELF & HIS FELL[S1 & BELIEVES HE KN[S A REM$Y :I* W\LD CURE !M1 H[ CAN HE /& 9ACTIVE1 IF HE HAS ANY HE>T AT ALL8 ,IF A MAN DOES NOT KN[ ! TRU?1 HE CANNOT BE BLAM$2 BUT ! MAN :O KN[S IT & SET IT ON ONE SIDE IS A HE>TLESS C[>D4  

  ,WILLIAM4  ,Y\ >E RI<T4 ,I@&_?#a#d#f2M GO+ TO ?9K V]Y S]I\SLY 9DE$ OV] :AT Y\@&_?#a#d#f2VE SAID4 ,& :5 ,I@&_?#a#d#f2M ?OR\<LY CONV9C$ 9 MY [N M9D ?AT IT@&_?#a#d#f2S TRUE1 ,I %ALL JO9 ! P>TY1 & DO ALL ,I CAN TO SPREAD ! SACR$ TRU?4 ,& IF ! G5TLEFOLKS %\LD CALL ME A SC\NDREL OR A FOOL1 ,I WILL TELL !M TO WORK & SUFF] AS ,I DO1 & !N !Y WILL HAVE A RI<T TO SPEAK4  

7,S\RCE3 ,FRE$OM1 #a#i#c#c47 

,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #aicb 3 ,A ,TALK ,AB\T ,AN>*I/ ,COMMUNISM ,BETWE5 ,TWO ,WORK]S -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,JANU>Y #a#c1 #bag 3 ,A ,TALK ,AB\T ,AN>*I/ ,COMMUNISM ,BETWE5 ,TWO ,WORK]S -- ,ADD$4 
,DECEMB] #c1 #bba 3 ,A ,TALK ,AB\T ,AN>*I/ ,COMMUNISM ,BETWE5 ,TWO ,WORK]S -- ,UPDAT$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/