,$ITOR'S ,9TRODUCTION ,! ,OLD ,MOLE ( ,9DIVIDUAL ,FRE$OM #aihaih ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,VICTOR ,S]GE ,TEXT 3 ,$,I,T,O,R',S ,9,T,R,O,D,U,C,T,I,O,N3 ,! ,OLD ,MOLE ( ,9DIVIDUAL ,FRE$OM ,V,I,C,T,O,R ,S,],G,E ,I,S ,B,E,/ ,K,N,[,N ,A,S ,A,N ,O,P,P,O,N,5,T ,( ,/,A,L,9,I,S,M1 ,A,N ,A,L,L,Y ,( ,TROTSKY :O WAS S5T TO A ,SOVIET PRISON CAMP & :O1 ?ANKS TO A WE/]N CAMPAIGN 9 HIS FAVOR1 WAS ABLE TO LEAVE ! ,SOVIET ,UNION1 :]E HE C>RI$ ON HIS FI LESS WELL KN[N IS ,S]GE'S AN>*I/ P]IOD1 :I* BEGAN 9 AN EMBRYONIC =M 9 ,BELGIUM 9 #aif & LA/$ AT LEA/ UNTIL HIS DEP>TURE = ! ,SOVIET ,UNION 9 #a#i#a#i4 ,! LESSONS HE LE>N$ AS AN AN>*I/1 & MORE P>TICUL>LY ! AN>*I/ DEF5SE ( 9DIVIDUAL FRE$OM1 W\LD NOT ONLY PLAY A KEY P>T 9 ,S]GE'S ?\*I/ P]IOD BUT W\LD ALSO 9FLECT HIS ,BOL%EVIK ACTIVITY4 ,! CONT9UITY 9 HIS ?\APHRASE ,M>X--! OLD MOLE ( 9DIVIDUAL FRE$OM BURR[$ ?R\< HIS WRIT+S 9 V>I\S GUISES1 MEANS ?AT ANY ATTEMPT TO ANALYZE ,S]GE'S LIFE BY GIV+ HIS OP5LY AN>*I/ YE>S %ORT %RIFT1 AS ,SUSAN ,WEISSMAN DOES 9 H] ,VICTOR ,S]GE3 ,A ,POLITICAL ,BIOGRAPHY1 MISSES ! CORE ( HIS POLITICAL LIFE4 ,/ILL KN[N AS ,VICTOR ,KIBAL*I*1 ,VICTOR BEGAN HIS POLITICAL ACTIVITY 9 ! ,Y\NG ,GU>D ( ! ,BELGIAN ,WORK]S' ,P>TY 7,P>TI ,\VI] ,BELGE1 OR ,P,O,B7 9 HIS NATIVE ,BRUSSELS 9 #aie :5 HE WAS ONLY F\RTE54 ,AN IMM$IATE 9DICATION ( ! CONT9UITY BETWE5 ! SOCIALISM ( HIS ADOLESC5T YE>S & HIS LAT] AN>*ISM IS ?AT TWO ( HIS CLOSE/ FRI5DS & COMRADES W]E ,RAYMOND ,CALLEM9 & ,JEAN ,DE ,BOE1 BO? ( :OM W\LD1 LIKE ,VICTOR1 MOVE TO ,P>IS :]E !Y W\LD RUN 9 ! SAME 9DIVIDUALI/ CIRCLES1 & BO? ( :OM1 LIKE ,VICTOR1 W\LD BE DEF5DANTS 9 ! TRIAL ( ! ,BONNOT ,GANG 9 #a#i#a#c4 ,CALLEM9 RECEIV$ ! DEA? P5ALTY1 ,DE ,BOE WAS S5T TO A P5AL COLONY1 & ,VICTOR1 F\ND GUILTY ( COMPLICITY1 WAS S5T5C$ TO FIVE YE>S4 ,?\< NOM9ALLY SOCIALI/1 ,VICTOR & HIS FRI5DS1 BECAUSE ( !IR EXUB]ANCE1 W]E REF]R$ TO AS 0AN>*I/S0 )9 ! P>TY1 & !Y 9 FACT SP5T TIME AT AN AN>*I/ COMMUNE \TSIDE ,BRUSSELS1 :]E ,VICTOR NOT ONLY GOT A *ANCE TO WITNESS A =M ( AN>*Y 9 ACTION BUT ALSO LE>N$ ! PR9T+ TRADE ?AT W\LD 5ABLE HIM TO E>N A LIV+ ?R\< HIS H>DE/ TIMES1 & :]E HE ALSO BEGAN HIS C>E] AS A J\RNALI/4 ,! RADICALISM ( ! ,Y\NG ,GU>D L$ !M TO WALK \T ( A ,WORK]S ,P>TY SPECIAL CONF]5CE ON ! QUE/ION ( ! ,CONGO1 :]E ! ,P,O,B SUPPORT$ ! ANNEXATION ( ! ,CONGO :ILE ! VOCALLY ANTI-IMP]IALI/ ,Y\NG ,GU>D OPPOS$ IT4 ,! P>TY BEGAN A CAMPAIGN AGA9/ ! AN>*I/S 9 !IR MID/1 & ,VICTOR & HIS FRI5DS W\LD EV5TUALLY LEAVE ! ,P,O,B & E/ABLI% !MSELVES AS ! ,REVOLUTION>Y ,Y\NG ,GU>D ( ,BRUSSELS1 *ANG+ ! NAME ( !IR NEWSPAP] FROM ,LE ,COMMUNI/E TO ,LE ,REVOLTE--! REBEL4 ,BY E>LY #a#i#h1 EV5 AS ! AN>*I/ COMMUNITY HE HAD BE5 P>T ( COLLAPS$1 ,VICTOR ID5TIFI$ HIMSELF AS AN AN>*I/ & WROTE 9 DEF5SE ( 0ILLEGALISM10 ! ADOPTION ( !FT AS A POLITICAL & ECONOMIC TACTIC BY AN>*I/S4 ,?\< HE WAS /ILL WRIT+ >TICLES AGA9/ IMP]IALISM & 9 SUPPORT ( /RIK+ WORK]S 9 ,ITALY1 CLASS /RUGGLE AN>*ISM SOON DISAPPE>$ COMPLETELY FROM ,S]GE'S WRIT+S AS HE BECAME 9CREAS+LY 9DIVIDUALI/ & 9CREAS+LY D\BTFUL ( WORK+-CLASS ACTIVITY1 CALL+ ! ,BELGIAN WORK+ CLASS A 0MASS ( C[>DS0 9 AN >TICLE PUBLI%$ 9 ,SEPTEMB] #a#i#h4 ,!RE W\LD BE NO TURN+ BACK = ,VICTOR N[1 & HE 9CREAS+LY M>K$ \T A POSITION AT ! EXTREME 5D ( AN>*I/ 9DIVIDUALISM1 DEF5D+ 9 HIS >TICLE 0,AN>*I/S-,B&ITS0 ! ,LONDON ILLEGALI/S :O HAD KILL$ TWO PEOPLE 9 :AT BECAME KN[N AS ! ,TOTT5HAM ,\TRAGE ( ,JANU>Y #aii & PRAIS+ !M AS EXEMPL>S ( ! REVOLUTION>Y SPIRIT1 M5 :O LIV$ BY ! MOTTO 0,AN>*I/S ,NEV] ,SURR5D]60 ,AMONG HIS F9AL ACTIVITIES 9 ,BELGIUM WAS HIS DEF5SE ( ! ,RUSSIAN T]RORI/ ,H>T5/E91 TRI$ & F\ND GUILTY ( KILL+ A POLICEMAN :O HAD COME TO >RE/ HIM = PLANT+ A BOMB4 ,VICTOR S]V$ AS A *>ACT] WITNESS AT ,H>T5/E9'S TRIAL & WROTE GL[+LY AB\T ! DEF5DANT 9 HIS >TICLE 0,A ,MAN0 9 ,LE ,REVOLTE4 ,BUT ! /AGNATION ( ! ,LEFT 9 ,BELGIUM1 DOM9AT$ BY ! RE=MI/ ,P,O,B1 ALONG ) DISPUTES ) O!R AN>*I/S 9 ,BRUSSELS L$ ,VICTOR1 DESPAIR+ ( ANY *ANGE 9 ,BELGIUM1 TO MOVE TO ! HE>T ( AN>*I/ 9DIVIDUALISM1 ,P>IS4 ,!RE HE IMM$IATELY BEGAN WRIT+ =1 & EV5TUALLY $IT+1 ! MOVEM5T'S PR9CIPAL ORGAN1 L'AN>*IE 7ALL LETT]S L[]CAS$ TO SIGNIFY ?AT NONE WAS MORE IMPORTANT ?AN ANY O!R71 F\ND$ BY ! GREAT ,ALB]T ,LIB]TAD 9 #a#i#e4 ,AS AN ACTIVE J\RNALI/ AT ! HE>T ( ,FRANCOPHONE AN>*ISM1 ONLY OCCASIONALLY W]E HIS WRIT+S COMM5T>Y ON NEWS ( ! DAY1 EV5TS LIKE ! ,LIABEUF ,AFFAIR1 ! >RE/ & EXECUTION ( AN APA*E 7/REET T\<7 = MURD]+ TWO POLICEM5 TRY+ TO >RE/ HIM1 & ! E>LY C>E] ( ! ,BONNOT ,GANG4 ,= ! MO/ P>T1 9/EAD1 HIS WRIT+ REVOLV$ >\ND MORE G5]AL !MES COMMON TO 9DIVIDUALI/ AN>*ISM S9CE ! FIR/ APPE>ANCE ( ! MOVEM5T 9 ,FRANCE >\ND #a#h#i4 ,!SE !MES W]E ANTIREVOLUTIONISM1 CONTEMPT = ! MASSES1 ! OBLIGATION ?AT 9DIVIDUALS MAKE !IR [N REVOLUTION IMM$IATELY1 & ILLEGALISM4 ,ALL ( !SE !MES >E 9T]TW9$ & FL[ TOGE!R NATURALLY3 ! CONTEMPTIBLE MASSES MAKE A SUCCESSFUL REVOLUTION IMPOSSIBLE1 MAK+ IT NECESS>Y = 9DIVIDUALI/S TO MAKE ! REVOLUTION N[ 9 :ATEV] WAY !Y CAN1 ) ! MO/ BRUTAL & DIRECT WAY BE+ ILLEGALISM4 ,!SE W]E NOT ! ONLY !MES CURR5T 9 ,VICTOR'S 9DIVIDUALI/ MILIEU1 BUT IT IS SIGNIFICANT ?AT !Y W]E ! ONES = :I* HE %[$ ! GREATE/ CONC]N4 ,! FACT ?AT HE IGNOR$ O!R COMMON AN>*I/ 9DIVIDUALI/ ISSUES LIKE NEO-,MAL?USIANISM1 DIET & G5]AL HEAL?-FADDISM1 FREE & PLURAL LOVE1 & ! EXTREME BIOLOGICAL DET]M9ISM ?AT PLAY$ SO IMPORTANT A P>T 9 ! MOVEM5T1 SPEAKS VOLUMES4 ,SO /RONG WAS ?IS LATT] CURR5T ?AT HE W\LD LAT] SPEAK AB\T A SPLIT BETWE5 0SCI5TIFICS0 & 0S5TIM5TALS0--! LATT] ALL[+ FEEL+S A ROLE 9 HUMAN ACTIVITY & DEVELOPM5T & ! =M] BELIEV+ ?AT VIRTUALLY EV]Y?+ WAS BIOLOGICALLY DET]M9$4 ,VICTOR WAS A 0S5TIM5TAL10 :ILE ! MEMB]S ( ! ,BONNOT ,GANG1 ) :OM HE WAS = A P]IOD ALLI$1 W]E ALMO/ ALL 0SCI5TIFICS40 ,H]E9 LIES MU* ( ! ORIG9AL T5SION BETWE5 ,VICTOR & HIS COMRADES1 :I* W\LD MANIFE/ ITSELF AT !IR TRIAL 9 #a#i#a#c1 :5 ,S]GE SEP>AT$ HIMSELF FROM ! B&ITS ) :OM HE WAS ON TRIAL4 ,NONE ( !SE =MS ( LIFE/YLE AN>*ISM HELD ANY P>TICUL> ATTRACTION = ,VICTOR1 & HE DIDN'T EXP5D MU* 5]GY ON !M4 ,:5 READ+ HIS AN>*I/ WRIT+S1 :AT IS /RIK+ IS SOME?+ ?AT IS V]Y MU* A P>T ( ! 9DIVIDUALI/ TRADITION3 ! LACK ( REF]5CES TO AU?ORITIES4 ,IF ,M>XI/S &1 LAT]1 ,L59I/S 9VOLV$ !MSELVES 9 ,TALMUDIC DISPUTES OV] PASSAGES 9 ! WORKS ( ! MA/]S1 9DIVIDUALI/S ALMO/ COMPLETELY ES*EW$ ?IS PRACTICE4 ,ALL ( AN>*I/ 9DIVIDUALISM GREW \T ( ,MAX ,/IRN]'S ,! ,EGO & ,HIS ,[N1 :I* WAS ORIG9ALLY PUBLI%$ 9 ,FRANCE 9 #a#h#i1 BUT ,/IRN]'S NAME IS NEV] US$ TO BACK UP ANY ( ,VICTOR'S >GUM5TS4 ,TO DO SO NOT ONLY W\LD HAVE MEANT ABDICAT+ HIS 9DIVIDUALITY BUT ALSO W\LD HAVE CON/ITUT$ ]ECT+ ,/IRN] 9TO A H]O1 AN IDEA ?AT WAS ANA!MA 9 HIS CIRCLES4 ,:ILE /ILL 9 ,BELGIUM1 9 AN >TICLE WRITT5 ON ! ANNIV]S>Y ( ! DEA? ( ,EMILE ,H5RY1 A MAN HE CLE>LY ADMIR$1 ,VICTOR ISSU$ ?IS CAVEAT3 0,LET !M NOT REPROA* ME = GLORIFY+ A MAN1 MAK+ HIM 9TO A BANN]4 ,WE WANT NEI!R TRIBUNES NOR M>TYRS NOR PROPHETS40.<#a#g.> ,9/EAD ( RELY+ ON SPECIFIC PASSAGES 9 ,/IRN]'S WRIT+S1 IT IS HIS WELTANS*AUUNG ?AT S]VES AS ! F\NDATION = ALMO/ ALL ( ,VICTOR'S POSITIONS4 ,A ?9K] :O WAS CLE>LY ( GREAT IMPORTANCE TO Y\NG ,KIBAL*I* WAS ,GU/AVE ,LE ,BON1 :OSE #ahie WORK 0,! ,PSY*OLOGY ( ,CR[DS0 DEMON/RAT$ ?AT CR[DS SUBSUME ! 9DIVIDUAL & OBLIT]ATE ! ID5TITY ( ! 9DIVIDUALS )9 IT1 IDEAS :I* ,VICTOR SOMETIMES CR$IT$ TO ,LE ,BON 9 HIS >TICLES & O!R TIMES SIMPLY P>APHRAS$4 ,JU/ AS ,/IRN] WAS NECESS>Y = ,VICTOR 9 E/ABLI%+ ! PRIMACY ( ! ,ONE1 ,LE ,BON WAS NE$$ TO DEMON/RATE ! DANG]S ( ! ,MANY4 ,9 ?IS REG>D ANO!R WRIT]1 ONE F> LESS KN[N1 9FLU5C$ ,VICTOR3 ! UNCOMPROMIS+LY PESSIMI/IC 9DIVIDUALI/ ,GEORGES ,PALANTE4 ,PALANTE POSIT$ NOT JU/ ! NE$ = ! ,SELF TO AFFIRM ITSELF BUT ALSO E/ABLI%$ ?AT !RE WAS A CLE> ANT9OMY BETWE5 ! 9DIVIDUAL & SOCIETY1 ?AT !Y W]E ET]NAL 5EMIES4 0,9DIVIDUALISM10 HE WROTE1 0IS ! S5TIM5T ( A PR(\ND1 IRR$UCIBLE ANT9OMY BETWE5 ! 9DIVIDUAL & SOCIETY4 ,! 9DIVIDUALI/ IS HE :O1 BY VIRTUE ( HIS TEMP]AM5T1 IS PR$ISPOS$ TO FEEL 9 A P>TICUL>LY ACUTE FA%ION ! 9ELUCTABLE DI%>MONIES BETWE5 HIS 9TIMATE BE+ & HIS SOCIAL MILIEU40 ,IF MO/ AN>*I/S1 9DE$ MO/ REVOLUTION>IES1 CONT5T$ !MSELVES ) VIEW+ ! /ATE AS ! 5EMY1 ONE ?AT C\LD BE DEFEAT$ BECAUSE IT WAS A SPECIFIC 5TITY1 = ,PALANTE SOCIETY ITSELF1 A F> L>G] & MORE NEBUL\S FOE1 WAS ! TRUE ADV]S>Y1 ONE :OSE AIM WAS ! GR9D+ D[N ( ! 9DIVIDUAL4 ,9DE$1 ! SAME PESSIMISM ?AT ,VICTOR (T5 EXPRESS$ CONC]N+ ! POSSIBILITIES & EV5 DESIRABILITY ( SOCIAL *ANGE ALSO APPE>$ 9 ! PAGES ( ,PALANTE3 0,9 ! NAME ( HIS [N EXP]I5CE & HIS P]SONAL S5SATION ( LIFE ! 9DIVIDUALI/ FEELS HE HAS ! RIMONY BETWE5 ! 9DIVIDUAL & SOCIETY WILL BE E/ABLI%$4 ,F> FROM ! DEVELOPM5T ( SOCIETY DIM9I%+ EVIL1 IT DOES NO?+ BUT 9T5SIFY IT BY R5D]+ ! LIFE ( ! 9DIVIDUAL MORE COMPLICAT$1 MORE LABORI\S & MORE DIFFICULT 9 ! MIDDLE ( ! ?\S& GE>S ( AN 9CREAS+LY TYRANNICAL SOCIAL ME*ANISM40 ,IT %\LD BE NOT$ ?AT !SE EXTRACTS FROM ,PALANTE'S 0,LA ,S5SBILITE ,9DIVIDUALI/E0 W]E PUBLI%$ 9 #a#i#i1 ! YE> ,VICTOR ,KIBAL*I* >RIV$ 9 ,P>IS1 & APPE>$ 9 ! *APT] ( ! BOOK TITL$ 0,AN>*ISM & ,9DIVIDUALISM40 ,VICTOR WAS C]TA9LY AW>E ( !SE WRIT+S & QUOT$ OR CIT$ ,PALANTE ON SEV]AL OCCASIONS1 9CLUD+ 9 ONE ( HIS F9AL >TICLES BE=E LEAV+ = ,R$ ,RUSSIA 9 #a#i#a#i4 ,PALANTE'S 9FLU5CE CAN BE SE5 UP TO ! 5D ( ,VICTOR'S SPELL AS $ITOR ( L'AN>*IE4 ,A TALK HE GAVE ON ,JANU>Y #b#h1 #a#i#a#b1 AT ! ,CAUS]IES ,POPULAIRES LECTURE S]IES WAS TITL$ 0,! ,9DIVIDUAL AGA9/ ,SOCIETY10 & HIS NOTES = ! TALK %[ ?AT HIS OP5+ REM>KS ON ! SUBJECT W]E1 0,IT'S RA!R ! CONTR>Y ?AT %\LD BE SAID3 'SOCIETY IS ! 5EMY ( ANY 9DIVIDUALITY4'0.<#a#h.> ,! FIGURE ( ,FRI$RI* ,NIETZS*E FLOATS OV] ,VICTOR'S WRIT+S AS WELL4 ,VICTOR SETTL$ ACC\NTS ) ! PHILOSOPH] ( ! ,UB]M5S* 9 A REC5TLY R$ISCOV]$ ESSAY WRITT5 9 #aiag :ILE HE WAS LIV+ 9 ,B>CELONA1 0,A ,CRITICAL ,ESSAY ON ,NIETZS*E0 79 ?IS COLLECTION1 #a#c#e74 ,NIETZS*E WAS ONE ( ! TUTEL>Y FIGURES ( AN>*I/ 9DIVIDUALISM1 & ,VICTOR EXAM9$ ,NIETZS*E'S WRIT+S 9 ORD] TO E/ABLI% ! WAYS 9 :I* HE WAS AT ONE ) OR 9 OPPOSITION TO ! AN>*I/S4 ,Z>A?U/RIAN OV]TONES CAN BE F\ND ?R\<\T HIS NEWSPAP] WRIT+S1 ) !IR CALL TO LIVE A FREE & FULL LIFE4 ,?IS IS MO/ GL>+LY CLE> 9 HIS >TICLE 0,BY ,BE+ ,BOLD10 A DI?YRAMBIC PIECE ON ! ,P]UVIAN AVIATOR ,JORGE ,*AVEZ1 :O DI$ 9 #aia :ILE ATTEMPT+ TO BECOME ! FIR/ MAN TO FLY OV] ! ,ALPS4 ,VICTOR WROTE ?AT 0HAV+ REA*$ !SE HEIT ( HIS AN>*I/ WRIT+S4 ,CONTEMPT = ! MASSES1 = ! 0H]D10 DRIPS FROM HIS WRIT+S ( ! 0L'AN>*IE0 P]IOD FROM #a#i#i-#a#b1 & IF !RE >E ANY ,RETIFIAN ADJECTIVES !Y >E SP9ELESS 7VEULE7 & C[>DLY 7LA*E71 :I* RECUR FREQU5TLY 9 HIS >TICLES4 ,BUT ALREADY 9 ,BELGIUM1 AT ! TIME ( ! ,H>T5/E9 ,AFFAIR1 HE COMPLA9$ ( ! COMMON RUN ( M51 0H[ UGLY !Y >E1 H[ PETTY1 WICK$ & HYPOCRITICAL !Y >E T[>D EA* O!R 444 CAN ?IS BE CALL$ LIV+8 ,CAN !SE PITIFUL BE+S BE CALL$ M580 ,EV]Y?+ ! MASSES 5JOY IS SUBJECT TO HIS SCORN4 ,FROM ! TIME ( ,LIB]TAD 9DIVIDUALI/S HAD DEMON/RAT$ RIDICULE = FE/IVALS & ANNIV]S>IES1 & FOLL[+ 9 ,LIB]TAD'S FOOT/EPS ,VICTOR W\LD WRITE ?AT 0JOY ON COMM& IS UNHEAL?Y1 GROTESQUE & /UPID1 LIKE ?OSE :O SAVOR IT10 & ! FE/IVITIES ! PEOPLE 5GAGE 9 >E 0! APO!OSIS ( ! /UPIDITY1 ! ILLOGIC1 & ! C[>DICE ( VA/ HUMAN H]DS40 ,M]E CONTACT ) ?IS GUTLESS MASS IS REPELL5T TO ,KIBAL*I*3 0,! M5 ,I RUB %\LD]S ) WRONG ME AT EV]Y MOM5T4 ,!IR LIMPNESS1 !IR RAPACITY1 !IR FOOLI%NESS PREV5T ME FROM LIV+40.<#a#i.> ,:5 ,FRANCE WAS 9 AN UPRO> OV] ! FIR/ CRIME ( ! ,BONNOT ,GANG1 ! ROBB]Y & %OOT+ ON ! ,RUE ,ORD5] ( A MESS5G] = ! ,SOCIETE ,G5]ALE1 ,VICTOR FELT NO SYMPA?Y1 RA!R CONTEMPT & SATISFACTION AT HIS FATE3 0,?IS POOR WRET*1 ?R\< HIS SUBMISSIVE WEAKNESS & HIS /UPID HONE/Y WAS ! ACCOMPLICE ( CRIM9ALS ( A F> HI<] CALIB] ?AN ! ONES !Y >E HUNT+ D[N40.<#b.> ,DESPITE C\NTLESS COMM5TS SIMIL> TO !SE1 ,VICTOR CLAIM$ NOT TO HATE ! PEOPLE3 0,WE LOVE Y\1 = WE LOVE M540 ,:AT HE HAT$ WAS NOT 0M50 BUT :AT !Y DID ) !IR POT5TIALLY EXALT$ HUMAN /ATUS3 0,WE DEEPLY DETE/ Y\R VEGETATIVE & BE/IAL EXI/5CE1 Y\R PITIFUL LACK ( 9TELLIG5CE40.<#b#a.> ,! S\RCES ( ?IS MISAN?ROPY & ELITISM >E V>I$4 ,NONE ( ,VICTOR'S COMRADES W]E ( ! LEISURE CLASS2 NONE HAD RECEIV$ UNIV]SITY $UCATIONS1 & ,VICTOR HAD RECEIV$ VIRTUALLY NO =MAL $UCATION4 ,TO A L>GE EXT5T ALL W]E AUTODIDACTS1 & !IR FEEL+ ?AT IF !Y W]E ABLE TO RISE ABOVE !IR ORIG9AL MUCK ! O!RS C\LD DO SO AS WELL IS CLE> 9 ! WRIT+S ( ! TIME4 ,S9CE ALL ! 9DIVIDUAL NE$S DO IS WILL SOME?+ = IT TO *ANGE1 ! M5 ( ! H]D W]E COMPLICIT 9 ! CONT9UATION ( AN ABSURD SOCIETY & W]E WOR?Y ( SCORN1 IF NOT WORSE4 ,! NEXT LOGICAL /EP 9 ?IS IDEA *A9 IS ! D5IAL ( ! POSSIBILITY ( A SUCCESSFUL REVOLUTION4 ,?IS IDEA IS 5TIRELY CONSI/5T ) ! PREC$+ ONE1 & IS F> MORE LOGICAL ?AN ! REVOLUTION>Y HOPES 9VE/$ 9 ! MASSES BY SYNDICALI/S & SOCIALI/S4 ,ALL ( !SE S*OOLS ACKN[L$G$ ! DEGRAD$ /ATE ( ! WORK] UND] ! CURR5T SOCIAL SY/EM4 ,ONLY ! 9DIVIDUALI/S1 & ,VICTOR FIR/ AMONG !M1 ASK$ ! QUE/ION3 ,H[ CAN WE EXPECT PEOPLE :O ACCEPT SU* A FATE TO BE CAPABLE ( MAK+ A REVOLUTION1 ( BUILD+ A RADIANT TOMORR[8 ,= ,VICTOR ?IS WAS NOT A SUBJECTIVE VIEWPO9T BUT RA!R AN OBJECTIVE FACT SETTL$ BY SCI5CE3 0,9 ALL >EAS IMP>TIAL SCI5CE DEMON/RATES TO US ! 9F]IORITY ( ! WORK+ CLASS40 ,:AT DID ,VICTOR SEE BE=E HIM BUT 0! DEG5]ATES1 ! H]$IT>Y SLAVES1 ! PITIFUL MASS ( WORK+ /IFFS ?AT WE KN[ DE VISU >E PHYSIOLOGICALLY 9CAPABLE ( LIV+ 9 H>MONY40 ,= ! \VRI]I/ES ! ANSW] TO ! QUE/ION ( :E!R OR NOT ! WORK]S CAN *ANGE SOCIETY WAS 0',YES' 7)\T EV] EXPLA9+ :Y702 = ,VICTOR1 GIV5 ! DEG5]ATE /ATE ( ! M5 :O MAKE UP ! WORK+ CLASS1 0ORGANIZ+ ! WORK+ CLASS 9 ORD] TO C>RY \T SOCIAL TRANS=MATION MEANS WA/+ TIME & 5]GY40.<#b#b.> ,LE ,RETIF PROV$ HIS CASE BY ATTACK+ ! MO/ SACR$ ( WORK+-CLASS C[S1 ! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE ( #a#h#g#a1 & 9 FACT DID SO 9 TWO >TICLES 5TIRELY D$ICAT$ TO SCA?+ ATTACKS ON ITS FOLLY4 ,! UPRIS+ WAS PO9TLESS1 = 0CR[DS >E FICKLE1 PU]ILE1 CR$UL\S4444 ,!Y >E CAPABLE ( H]OISM1 BUT !Y CAN ALSO COMMIT MON/ROSITIES4 ,& 9 ALL CASES !Y NE$ MA/]S40.<#b#c.> ,NO1 !RE WAS NO PO9T 9 EV] SEIZ+ P[]1 = 0TO ?9K ?AT IMPULSIVE1 DEFECTIVE1 IGNORANT CR[DS WILL HAVE DONE ) ! MORBID ILLOGIC ( CAPITALI/ SOCIETY IS A VULG> ILLUSION40.<#b#d.> ,9DE$1 EV5 ?\< ! DEFEAT ( ! ,COMMUNE ]AS$ ALL ! POSITIVE *ANGES IT HAD MADE1 0!IR VICTORY W\LD HAVE ANNIHILAT$ !M1 S9CE !Y'D PRES]V$ ! ESS5CE ( ! SY/EM ( SOCIAL OPPRESSION ?R\< PRIVATE PROP]TY & ! LAW40.<#b#e.> ,NOT ONLY DID ! ,COMMUNE FAIL1 BUT ALL REVOLUTIONS HAVE FAIL$3 0,!Y HAVE NEI!R DE/ROY$ :AT !Y WANT$ TO DE/ROY NOR CON/RUCT$ ANY?+ BETT]40 ,AGA9 ,VICTOR RETURNS TO ! ROOT CAUSE ( ?IS 9EVITABLE FAILURE3 0,LACK+ 9 $UCATION1 NOT US$ TO ?9K+1 NOT KN[+ H[ TO C\NT ON !MSELVES 444 C\LD ! WORK]S ( #aiab DO ANY BETT]80.<#b#f.> ,NONE ( ?IS1 ( C\RSE1 IMPLIES ?AT A REBEL %\LD SIT IDLY BY :ILE ! VULG> H]D DOES NO?+ OR FOOLI%LY ATTEMPTS TO RISE UP4 ,!RE MU/ BE A *ANGE TO ! ROTT5 WORLD ?AT CREAT$ ! DEG5]ATE HUMANITY ?AT SURR\NDS & 9HIBITS ,VICTOR4 ,9 ANSW] TO ! QUE/ION ( :O %\LD BE C\NT$ ON1 MASS ACTION BE+ WOR?LESS1 0! AN>*I/S WILL ANSW] ) 9DIVIDUAL REVOLT40.<#b#g.> ,?IS WILL BE DONE 9 SEV]AL WAYS1 = 0FROM ?IS DAY ON AN>*I/S LIB]ATE M9DS40 ,EV5 ! LONE AN>*I/ LIV+ HIS FREE LIFE HAS GREAT REVOLUTION>Y RAMIFICATIONS1 = 0ALL M5 PR(IT FROM ! ACT ( REVOLT ( ONE40 ,UNLIKE ?OSE :O ?9K ! MASSES WILL LEAD ! WAY1 LIKE ! SOCIALI/ ,JEAN ,JAURES & HIS AN>*I/ RIVAL ,JEAN ,GRAVE1 ,VICTOR TELLS US ?AT 0!RE IS NO MORE CONSI/5T ELEM5T ( PROGRESS ?AN 9DIVIDUAL 9ITIATIVE0.<#b#h.> & ?AT 09 EV]Y SOCIAL GR\P+ ! 9DIVIDUALI/ WILL REMA9 A REBEL40.<#b#i.> ,! AN>*I/1 9 Y\NG ,VICTOR'S EYES1 E*O+ ! ,NIETZS*EAN NOTION ( ! BLOND BEA/ 0IS ABOVE ALL A P]SON :O *ALL5GES4444 ,9 DECAD5T CIVILIZATION HE IS ! SALUT>Y B>B>IAN1 ! ONLY ONE /ILL CAPABLE ( CREAT+1 ( ]ECT+ HIS 9DIVIDUALITY ABOVE ! PE/IL5CE40.<#c.> ,9 HIS MEMOIRS1 ,S]GE W\LD LAT] WRITE ?AT 0,AN>*ISM SWEPT US AWAY COMPLETELY BECAUSE IT BO? DEM&$ EV]Y?+ ( US & (F]$ US EV]Y?+10.<#c#a.> & DUR+ HIS Y\? HE HAD WRITT5 ?AT 0WE CONSID] AN>*ISM TO BE1 ABOVE ALL1 A WAY ( LIFE40 ,AN>*I/S >E CREATURES ( PURE WILL1 9 ?IS S5SE AGA9 DISCIPLES ( ,NIETZS*E3 0AN>*I/S =MULATE NEI!R WI%ES NOR V[S3 !Y WANT & IMM$IATELY ACT ACCORD+ TO !IR WILL40.<#c#b.> ,FRE$OM1 9DIVIDUAL FRE$OM1 IS ! BE ALL & 5D ALL ( AN>*I/ 9DIVIDUALISM1 & EV5 9 ! UNLIKELY EV5T ?AT A MASS REVOLUTION W]E TO SUCCE$1 ?AT SUCCESS W\LD DO NO?+ = ! FREE 9DIVIDUAL S9CE 0! HYPO!SIS ( A COLLECTIVI/ TOMORR[ PRESAGES A F]OCI\S /RUGGLE BETWE5 ! /ATE & ! FEW 9DIVIDUALS DESIR\S ( PRES]V+ !IR AUTONOMY40.<#c#c.> ,NOTE ! USE ( ! WORD 0FEW10 ! IMPLICIT ELITISM 9 ! PHRASE1 S9CE ! RE/ WILL BE QUITE CONT5T TO ACCEPT ! NEW YOKE ( ! NEW ORD]4 ,VICTOR'S 9DIVIDUALI/ AN>*I/ IS NOT ONLY ONE :O *ALL5GES1 HE IS ALSO & PRIM>ILY ONE :O FI ,NOT JU/ ! CONQU]+ BUT ! PRES]VATION ( ! LITTLE FRE$OM ALL[$ ! 9DIVIDUAL TODAY IS A DUTY1 & ANY *ALL5GE TO IT MU/ BE REACT$ TO =CEFULLY4 ,9 ,BELGIUM1 ,VICTOR HAD BE5 EXTREMELY VOCAL 9 SUPPORT ( ! ACCUS$ AN>*I/ BOMB-MAK] ,H>T5/E9--GIV+ HIM ! HIRE/ HIM--& HAD NOT ONLY WRITT5 AB\T HIM 9 ,LE ,REVOLTE BUT ALSO S]V$ AS A *>ACT] WITNESS AT HIS TRIAL4 ,HE HAD ALSO DEF5D$ ! ,RUSSIAN AN>*I/S :O DI$ FI ,= ,VICTOR & = 9DIVIDUALI/S 9 G5]AL IT IS NOT ONLY POLITICAL REBELS :O >E WOR?Y ( SUPPORT1 LEAD+ US 9EVITABLY TO ! VEX$ SUBJECT ( ILLEGALISM1 :I* HAD BE5 A P>T ( AN>*I/ 9DIVIDUALISM = YE>S BE=E ,VICTOR'S >RIVAL ON ! SC5E4 ,! BELIEF ?AT AN>*I/S1 RECOGNIZ+ NO LAWS1 W]E SELF-EVID5TLY B\ND BY NO LAWS F\ND ITS JU/IFICATION 9 ! MOVEM5T'S F\NDATIONAL TEXT1 ,MAX ,/IRN]'S ,! ,EGO & ,HIS ,[N1 :]E HE WRITES ?AT 0S9CE ! /ATE IS ! 'LORD%IP ( LAW' ITS HI]>*Y1 IT FOLL[S ?AT ! EGOI/1 9 ALL CASES :]E HIS ADVANTAGE RUNS AGA9/ ! ,/ATE'S1 CAN SATISFY HIMSELF ONLY BY ,CRIME40.<#c#f.> ,ILLEGALI/S HAD BE5 P>TICUL>LY FOND ( C\NT]FEIT+1 BUT A NEW BRE$ ( ILLEGALI/S WAS APPE>+ ON ! SC5E1 A BRE$ F> MORE VIOL5T ?AN EV] PREVI\SLY SE51 !IR AVAT> BE+ :AT CAME TO BE KN[N AS ! ,BONNOT ,GANG4 ,AT ! GANG'S TRIAL 9 #aiac ,VICTOR D5I$ EV] HAV+ ADVOCAT$ ILLEGALISM2 9DE$ HE CLAIM$ TO HAVE OPPOS$ IT4 ,!RE CAN BE NO QUE/ION ?AT HE CAME TO OPPOSE IT1 & ?AT AT ! TIME ( HIS TRIAL HIS CONDEMNATION ( ! 0WA/E0 ( M5 & 5]GIES IT 5TAIL$ WAS S9C]E4 ,:AT IS DIFFICULT TO P9 D[N IS :5 HE BECAME AN OPPON5T ( ILLEGALISM1 = NO S]I\S READ] ( HIS >TICLES ON ! SUBJECT WRITT5 DUR+ ! YE>S #a#i#h-#a#b C\LD F9D ANY OPPOSITION TO ?IS NATURAL \TGR[? ( ! 9SI/5CE ON ! PRIMACY ( 9DIVIDUALS & !IR WILL4 ,P>TICUL>LY TELL+ IS ANO!R ( HIS FAVORITE NEGATIVE EPI!TS3 0HONE/10 US$ AS A PEJORATIVE AGA9/ ?OSE AN>*I/S OPPOS$ TO ILLEGALISM1 ?OSE 0HONE/ M510 & ! G5]AL USE ( ! ADJECTIVE AGA9/ ANYONE :O CONDEMNS REBELS4.<#c#g.> ,P>ADOXICALLY1 EV5 CRIM9ALS CAN BE SME>$ ) ?AT BRU%3 0,! APA*ES 9 G5]AL DON'T 9T]E/ ME4 ,!Y DIFF] TOO LITTLE FROM HONE/ PEOPLE40.<#c#h.> ,9 SOME CASES HE EX]CIS$ SMALL FEATS ( LEG]DEMA9 TO DISGUISE HIS SUPPORT ( ILLEGALISM4 ,:ILE /ILL 9 ,BELGIUM HE CLAIM$ ?AT 0EV]Y REVOLT IS 9 ESS5CE AN>*I/4 ,& WE %\LD /& ALONGSIDE ! ECONOMIC REBEL ! SAME WAY WE /& BESIDE ! POLITICAL1 ANTIMILIT>I/ & PROPAG&I/ REBEL40.<#c#i.> ,ALL REBELS1 ?US >E EQUAL4 ,HE DID1 H[EV] RECOGNIZE ?AT ILLEGALI/S 0REMA9 F> FROM US1 F> FROM \R DREAMS & WI%ES4 ,BUT :AT DIFF]5CE DOES ?AT MAKE80 ,IF EXI/+ MEANS RESI/+1 & CRIME IS A =M ( REVOLT1 !N ! ILLEGALI/S EXI/ 0& !Y >5'T P>T ( ! H]D40 ,! LOGIC ( !IR ACTS IS PAT5T4 0,AN 9TELLECTUAL & MORAL REBEL1 IT IS ON FACT ONLY LOGICAL ?AT ! AN>*I/ DOESN'T FE> BECOM+1 :5EV] ! CIRCUM/ANCES SEEM FAVORABLE1 AN ECONOMIC REBEL4.<#d.> ,9 ! IMM$IATE AFT]MA? ( ! FIR/ ACTS ( ! ,BONNOT CRIME WAVE HE PRAIS$ ! B&ITS = !IR 0D>+10 :I* WAS ONE ( ,VICTOR'S FAVOR$ POSITIVE *>ACT]I/ICS4 ,& IF HE DIDN'T ADVOCATE CRIME AS AN AN>*I/ ACT1 HE NEV]!LESS SAID1 0,I AM ) ! B&ITS4 ,I F9D !IR ROLE TO BE NOBLE4 ,SOMETIMES ,I SEE 9 !M M510 ! LA/ WORD H]E TOO BE+ A T]M ( PRAISE 9 ! ,RETIFIAN LEXICON4.<#d#a.> ,HE P]HAPS CAME CLOSE/ TO OP5 ADVOCACY ( CRIME 9 HIS >TICLE 0,AGA9/ ,HUNG]10 AN >TICLE CONSID]$ IMPORTANT 5\< TO BE ISSU$ AS A PAMPHLET ALMO/ IMM$IATELY AFT] APPE>+ 9 L'AN>*IE4 ,9 IT HE DECL>ES ?AT 09DIVIDUAL RE-APPROPRIATION--!FT--IS ! LOGICAL OPPOSITE ( ! MONOPOLIZ+ ( WEAL?1 JU/ AS 9DIVIDUAL REVOLT IS NATURALLY OPPOS$ TO ! >BITR>9ESS ( ! LAW & ITS AG5TS4.<#d#b.> ,NOR %\LD WE ?9K ?AT IT WAS ONLY 9 HIS WRIT+S ?AT ,KIBAL*I* DEF5D$ ILLEGALISM & ILLEGALI/S4 ,9 ! NOTES = :AT MU/ HAVE BE5 HIS F9AL TALK AT ! ,CAUS]IES ,POPULAIRES HE SAYS ( CRIME ?AT 0WE ?9K ?IS IS LOGICAL_/9ELUCTABLE_/NECESS>Y10 & 5D$ HIS TALK BY SAY+ ( ! ILLEGALI/ AN>*I/S ?AT 0ALONG ) US1 !Y >E ! ONLY M5 :O D>E DEM& LIFE40.<#d#c.> ,?US WE CAN SEE ?AT )9 ,VICTOR ,S]GE'S AN>*I/ WRIT+S !RE IS A NATURAL & CONSI/5T FL[1 ?AT ! CONNECTIONS BETWE5 ! F\R !MES COMMON TO 9DIVIDUALI/ AN>*ISM >E LOGICAL1 9ELUCTABLE1 & NECESS>Y4 ,RI*>D ,P>RY1 9 HIS EXCELL5T & ESS5TIAL BOOK ON ! ,BONNOT ,GANG1 COMES TO ! ]RONE\S CONCLUSION ?AT ,VICTOR SO L\DLY PRAIS$ ILLEGALISM BECAUSE 0HE SIMPLY WANT$ TO MAKE A NAME = HIMSELF AS ! MO/ 'COMBATIVE' WRIT] 9 ! MILIEU40.<#d#d.> ,AS WE HAVE SE51 F> FROM ?IS BE+ ! CASE1 ,VICTOR WAS BE+ UTT]LY S9C]E & TOTALLY CONSI/5T :5 HE DEF5D$ ILLEGALISM 9 ! AB/RACT & ! ,BONNOT ,GANG 9 P>TICUL>4 ,HIS SUBSEQU5T CONDEMNATION ( IT WAS ! FIR/ /EP ALONG ! ROAD TO ! BREAK ?AT W\LD LEAD HIM TO AB&ON AN>*ISM :ILE MA9TA9+ ITS ESS5CE1 BUT ! PROCESS1 CONTR>Y TO ! PICTURE PA9T$ 9 HIS ,MEMOIRS1 WAS AN EXTREMELY SL[ ONE4 ,! BREAK APPE>S TO HAVE BEGUN DUR+ ! YE> HE SP5T 9 PRISON BETWE5 HIS >RE/ ON ,JANU>Y #c#a1 #a#i#a#b1 & ! TRIAL ( ! SURVIV+ MEMB]S ( ! ,BONNOT ,GANG MEMB]S4 ,HIS REFLECTIONS ON ! FOLLY ( ILLEGALISM RESULT$ 9 HIS REFUS+ TO ACCEPT RESPONSIBILITY = ! ACTS ( ! ,TRAGIC ,B&ITS1 :O = !IR P>T D5I$ !IR GUILT4 ,HE WAS S9C]E 9 SAY+ HE DIDN'T SUPPORT ILLEGALISM AT ! TRIAL1 = BY ?AT TIME HE APPE>S TO HAVE COME TO CONDEMN IT2 HE W5T TOO F> 9 CLAIM+ ?AT HE HAD ALWAYS OPPOS$ IT4 ,HE SP5T A FUR!R F\R YE>S 9 JAIL1 S]V+ A TOTAL ( FIVE FULL YE>S1 & DUR+ ?AT TIME HE BEGAN TO S]I\SLY REFLECT ON HIS 5TIRE BELIEF SY/EM UP UNTIL !N4 ,SO BY ,FEBRU>Y #a#i#a#g1 IMM$IATELY UPON HIS RELEASE FROM PRISON1 HE WROTE TO ,EMILE ,>M& ?AT 0,I NO LONG] BELIEVE ?AT ! AN>*I/ =MULA CAN BE CONTA9$ 9 ONE =MULA ALONE2 ,I GRANT MU* LESS IMPORTANCE TO WORDS ?AN REALITIES1 TO IDEAS ?AN TO ASPIRATIONS1 TO =MULAS ?AN TO S5TIM5TS & ACTS4 ,I AM ?US READY TO COLLABORATE ) ALL ?OSE :O WILL %[ A FRAT]NAL GOODWILL )\T ATTRIBUT+ GREAT IMPORTANCE TO SECOND>Y DIV]G5CES 9 IDEAS40 ,HE CONT9U$ 9 ! SAME MODE A MON? LAT]1 AGA9 9 A LETT] TO ,>M&1 /AT+ ?AT HE HAD 0LO/ ! SECT>IAN 9TRANSIG5CE ( ! PA/0 & WAS 0CAPABLE ( WORK+ ) ALL ?OSE :O1 ANIMAT$ BY ! SAME DESIRE = A BETT] LIFE--ONE CLE>] & MORE 9TELLIG5T--ADVANCE T[>D !IR FUTURE1 EV5 IF !IR PA?S >E DIFF]5T FROM M9E1 & EV5 IF !Y GIVE DIFF]5T NAMES ,I DON'T KN[ TO :AT 9 REALITY IS \R COMMON GOAL40.<#d#e.> ,9 HIS EXILE 9 ,B>CELONA HE WORK$ ) SYNDICALI/S & P>TICIPAT$ 9 A 7FAIL$7 MASS UPRIS+1 BUT 9 HIS L5G?Y SETTL+ ( ACC\NTS ) ,NIETZS*E1 0,A ,CRITICAL ,ESSAY ON ,NIETZS*E10 HE PO9TS \T ! SIMIL>ITIES ( ,NIETZS*E'S IDEAS TO ! MO/ REACTION>Y IDEAS !N CURR5T1 & SPEAKS DISMISSIVELY ( ,NIETZS*E'S EFFECT ON AN>*I/S4 ,HE SAYS ?AT :5 AN AN>*I/ READS ,NIETZS*E1 0A K9D ( PU]ILE PRIDE SEIZES HOLD ( \R COMRADE & ISOLATES HIM 9 A /]ILE & LIMIT$ 'CULT ( ! SELF4'0 ,?AT CULT ( ! SELF WAS ! BASIS = ALL ( ,VICTOR'S ACTIVITY UNTIL ?AT PO9T4 ,:ILE 9 ,SPA9 HE WROTE = ! AN>*I/ NEWSPAP] ,TI]RA Y ,LIB]TAD1 & ?\< HE LAT] CLAIM$ 9 HIS ,MEMOIRS ?AT HE HAD BE5 IMM$IATELY SEIZ$ ) 5?USIASM = ! ,RUSSIAN ,REVOLUTION1 HIS CONTEMPOR>Y WRIT+S DON'T BE> ?AT \T4 ,9 ! ,APRIL #d1 #a#i#a#g1 ISSUE ( ! PAP] HE WAS /ILL SAY+ ?AT 0ONE MU/N'T EXPECT GREAT RESULTS FROM POLITICAL REVOLUTIONS4444 ,& SO TRUE POLITICAL P[] HAS H>DLY *ANG$40 ,AFT] ! FAILURE ( ! ,JULY UPRIS+ 9 ,B>CELONA 9 #aiag HE W5T TO ,FRANCE 9 AN EF=T TO JO9 ! ,RUSSIAN >MY & BE S5T TO HIS P>5TS' HOMEL&4 ,>RE/$ 9 ,OCTOB] #aiag = VIOLAT+ HIS EXPULSION ORD]1 HE SP5T OV] A YE> 9 ,FR5* DET5TION CAMPS BUT WAS /ILL ABLE TO WRITE OCCASIONALLY = ! AN>*I/ PRESS1 :]E HIS PRAISE ( ! ,RUSSIAN ,REVOLUTION REMA9$ MUT$4 ,BUT IT WAS >\ND ?IS TIME ?AT HIS AN>*ISM & 9DIVIDUALISM S\TICLE 9 ! AN>*I/ PAP] ,LA ,MELEE BE=E HIS DEP>TURE1 AN>*I/S MU/ 09T]E/ \RSELVES ) ALL \R MI ,BO? IDEAS--9DIVIDUALISM & AN>*ISM--CONT9U$ TO PLAY A P>T 9 HIS ?\*ISM CONT9U$ TO PLAY A ROLE 9 HIS LIFE & 9 9FLECT+ HIS ?\%NESS ( ! IDEOLOGY ( ! RUL+ P>TY4 ,9 #a#i#b#a1 TWO YE>S AFT] HIS >RIVAL 9 ! ,U,S,S,R1 HE W\LD WRITE ?AT 0,I AM ONLY A COMMUNI/--( LIB]T>IAN PHILOSOPHY & E?ICS--BECAUSE ,I SEE NO POSSIBILITY = ! FUTURE LIB]ATION ( ! 9DIVIDUAL \TSIDE ( A COMMUNISM CALL$ ON TO EVOLVE A GREAT DEAL 7ONCE IT HAS EM]G$ VICTORI\S470.<#d#g.> ,?IS PASSAGE FROM 0,NEW ,T5D5CIES 9 ,RUSSIAN ,AN>*ISM0 IS ( 5ORM\S IMPORTANCE4 ,! FIR/ & MO/ OBVI\S ELEM5T IS ,S]GE'S DEF9ITION ( HIMSELF AS A S*ISMATIC COMMUNI/4 ,?AT IT WAS ALL[$ TO APPE> 9 AN (FICIAL ,COM9T]N J\RNAL1 ,BULLET9 ,COMMUNI/E1 IS 9 ITSELF SIGNIFICANT1 S9CE DISSID5T WORKS W]E EV5 !N NOT COMMON1 ?\< NOT AS IMPOSSIBLE AS !Y W\LD SOON BECOME4 ,! ,BOL%EVIKS W]E CLE>LY US+ ,S]GE AS A WAY ( PROJECT+ !IR OP5NESS1 AS A WAY ( ATTRACT+ SUPPORT FROM ! AN>*I/S4 ,?AT HE ALSO SAID ?AT ! COMMUNISM ( ! ,BOL%EVIKS HAD TO EVOLVE GREATLY IS ALSO A BOLD /ATEM5T4 ,! P>5!TIC REM>K ?AT 5DS ?IS S5T5CE IS SIGNIFICANT3 HE MAKES IT CLE> ?AT 9 :ATEV] WAY ,BOL%EVISM WILL EVOLVE1 ?IS EVOLUTION CAN ONLY OCCUR AFT] VICTORY4 ,UNTIL !N1 HE IMPLIES1 ! ME?ODS CURR5TLY 9 PLACE--H>%LY REPRESSIVE ONES ?AT DO NOT LIB]ATE ! 9DIVIDUAL--CAN & MU/ CONT9UE4 ,HIS SUPPORT ( ! ,*EKA IS H]E EXPLA9$4 ,BUT ?IS BRIEF PASSAGE CONTA9S A /ATEM5T ( HIS NEW VIEW ( ! 9DIVIDUAL1 AN IDEA ?AT WILL H5CE=? DOM9ATE HIS ?\T ( SOCIETY1 A P>T ( A MOVEM5T1 SOMEONE TO BE LIB]AT$ ?R\< COMMON ACTION & :OSE NE$S >E NOT OPPOS$ TO SOCIETY BUT >E AN 9TEGRAL P>T ( IT4 ,!RE IS NO LONG] AN ANT9OMY BETWE5 ! 9DIVIDUAL & SOCIETY4 ,= ,S]GE ! 9DIVIDUAL CAN N[ ONLY BE LIB]AT$ ALONG ) O!RS1 NOT AGA9/ O!RS4 ,ELSE:]E 9 ?IS >TICLE HE RECOGNIZES ! DIFFICULTIES ( H&+ OV] ! LIB]ATION ( ! 9DIVIDUAL TO ! ,COMMUNI/S3 0,:AT IS TOO (T5 LACK+ 9 COMMUNI/ IDEOLOGY IS A PHILOSOPHY ( ! 9DIVIDUAL = ! 9DIVIDUAL'S SAKE40 ,HE KN[S TO FE> ! TOTAL SUBSUM+ ( ! 9DIVIDUAL BY ! 7WORK]'S7 /ATE4 ,BUT HE WAS CONFID5T ?AT ONCE VICTORY OV] ! ,:ITES WAS 5SUR$1 ! AN>*I/S 7:O 9 ?IS SAME >TICLE HE 9SI/S >E NOT ?AT DIFF]5T FROM ! ,BOL%EVIKS7 W\LD PLAY A VITAL ROLE 9 RE%AP+ SOCIETY4 ,HIS OPTIMISM WAS MISPLAC$4 ,& JU/ AS HIS DEF5SE ( ILLEGALISM PLAY$ A ROLE 9 HIS BE+ CONSID]$ SO DANG]\S BY ! ,FR5* AU?ORITIES ?AT HE WAS GIV5 AS H>% A S5T5CE AS POSSIBLE AFT] ! ,BONNOT TRIAL1 IT IS C]TA9 ?AT HIS HOPES = ! 9DIVIDUAL UND] ,BOL%EVISM1 ?IS TIME UND] ! =M ( ,TROTSKYISM1 W\LD CONTRIBUTE TO HIS FATE !RE4 ,! ROAD FROM ,FR5* DET5TION CAMPS TO ,SOVIET ONES WAS TWI/$1 BUT DIRECT4 .-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.- ,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,NOVEMB] #c1 #aig 3 ,$ITOR'S ,9TRODUCTION -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,JANU>Y #a#a1 #bba 3 ,$ITOR'S ,9TRODUCTION -- ,ADD$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/