,*APT] #h ,9 ,SE>* ( ! ,PRIMITIVI/S ,P>T ,I,I3 ,PRIMITIVE ,AFFLU5CE #aiigaiig ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,BOB ,BLACK ,TEXT 3 ,*APT] #h3 ,9 ,SE>* ( ! ,PRIMITIVI/S ,P>T ,I,I3 ,PRIMITIVE ,AFFLU5CE ,ACCORD+ TO ! ,DEAN1 ! NOTION ( PRIMITIVE AFFLU5CE IS SOME SILL9ESS ! HIPPIES SMOK$ UP & PUT OV] ON ! AN?ROPOLOGI/S 9 ! '#fS3 ,MU* ( .<,GEORGE ,BRAD=D'S.> 0CRITICAL AN?ROPOLOGY0 APPE>S TO D]IVE FROM IDEAS PROP\ND$ AT ! 0,MAN ! ,HUNT]0 SYMPOSIUM1 CONV5$ 9 ,APRIL #aiff AT ! ,UNIV]SITY ( ,*ICAGO4 ,AL?\< MO/ ( ! PAP]S CONTRIBUT$ TO ?IS SYMPOSIUM W]E IMM5SELY VALUABLE1 A NUMB] ( !M CON=M$ TO ! NAIVE MY/IFICATION ( 0PRIMITIVITY0 ?AT WAS P]COLAT+ ?R\< ! #a#i#fS C\NT]-CULTURE -- & ?AT L+]S ON TO ?IS DAY4 ,! HIPPIE CULTURE1 :I* 9FLU5C$ QUITE A FEW AN?ROPOLOGI/S ( ! TIME1 AV]R$ ?AT HUNT+-GA!R+ PEOPLES TODAY HAD BE5 BYPASS$ BY ! SOCIAL & ECONOMIC =CES AT WORK 9 ! RE/ ( ! WORLD & /ILL LIV$ 9 A PRI/9E /ATE1 AS ISOLAT$ REMNANTS ( ,NEOLI?IC & ,PALEOLI?IC LIFEWAYS4 ,FUR!R1 AS HUNT]-GA!R]S1 !IR LIVES W]E NOTABLY HEAL?Y & PEACEFUL1 LIV+ !N AS N[ ON AN AMPLE NATURAL L>GESS 7#c#g74 ,! *IEF VILLA9 ( ! PIECE WAS AN?ROPOLOGI/ ,RI*>D ,B4 ,LEE1 :O HAD 0E/IMAT$ ?AT ! CALORIC 9TAKE ( 'PRIMITIVE' PEOPLES WAS QUITE HI< & !IR FOOD SUPPLY ABUNDANT1 MAK+ = A K9D ( VIRG9AL 'AFFLU5CE' 9 :I* PEOPLE NE$$ TO =AGE ONLY A FEW H\RS EA* DAY0 7#c#g-#c#h74 ,9 ! ABOVE-QUOT$ PASSAGE1 0IT W\LD TAKE A FULL-SIZ$ ESSAY 9 ITSELF TO UNSCRAMBLE1 LET ALONE REFUTE1 ?IS ABSURD BALD]DA%1 9 :I* A FEW TRU?S >E EI!R MIX$ ) OR COAT$ 9 %E] FANTASY0 7#c#g74 ,! ,DEAN REF]S TO A PASSAGE HE QUOTES FROM ,BRAD=D1 BUT MI5'T EV5 A FEW TRU?S 9 HIS PASSAGE1 NOT EV5 MIX$ OR COAT$ ) FANTASY4 ,! REVISION ( ! ,HOBBESIAN PO/ULATE ?AT PRIMITIVE LIFE IS NA/Y1 BRUTI% & %ORT COMM5C$1 NOT AT ! 0,MAN ! ,HUNT]0 SYMPOSIUM 9 #aiff 7,LEE @& ,DE,VORE #a#i#f#h71 BUT AT ! SYMPOSIUM ON B& SOCIETIES 9 ,OTTAWA 9 #aife 7,DAMAS #a#i#f#i74 ,! ,*ICAGO SYMPOSIUM ONLY EXT5D$ ! !SES ( ! PIONE]+ ,OTTAWA GA!R+ 7,R5\F #a#i#i#a3 #h#i-#i74 ,APRIL #aife & EV5 ,APRIL #aiff 7,LEE @& ,DE,VORE #a#i#f#h3 VII7 >E IMPLAUSIBLY E>LY DATES TO ASSUME MU* HIPPIE 9FLU5CE ON ACADEMIC S*OL>%IP1 & ! ,DEAN ADDUCES NO EVID5CE 9 SUPPORT ( HIS SELF-S]V+ CONJECTURE4 ,!RE'S NO TRACE ( C\NT]CULTURE 9FLU5CE1 = 9/ANCE1 9 ,BOOK*9'S #aife BOOK ,CRISIS 9 ,\R ,CITIES 7,H]B] #a#i#f#e7 OR HIS #aife ESSAY 0,ECOLOGY & ,REVOLUTION>Y ,?\Y ,?\GE 9 HIS #aig ESSAY OPPORTUNI/ICALLY LAUD+ Y\? CULTURE 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g3 #e#a-#f#c74 ,! TIMES !Y W]E A-*ANG9'4 ,TO ,BOOK*9'S ANNOYANCE1 !Y /ILL >E4 ,IF !RE IS ANY RELATION%IP BETWE5 '#fS HIPPIE CULTURE & ! ANTI-,HOBBESIAN TURN 9 AN?ROPOLOGY1 IT IS ( ! SORT ! /ATI/ICIANS CALL A SPURI\S RELATION%IP4 ,?AT IS1 ! V>IABLES >E ASSOCIAT$ ) EA* O!R1 NOT AS CAUSE & EFFECT1 BUT AS CONSEQU5CES ( A COMMON CAUSE 7,BABBIE #a#i#i#b3 #d#a#f74 ,! COMMON CAUSE W\LD HAVE BE5 ! G5]AL CLIMATE ( DI/RU/ ( AU?ORITY & OR?ODOXY4 ,IF Y\ READ ! ,DEAN'S PASSAGE ) MORE C>E ?AN IT WAS WRITT5 )1 IT'S NOTICEABLE ?AT HE ATTRIBUTES MO/ ( ! MALIGN 9FLU5CE ON ! PRIMITIVI/S1 NOT TO ! AN?ROPOLOGI/S1 BUT TO ! HIPPIES4 ,I AM DRAW+ ON MY [N DI/ANT MEMORIES H]E1 BUT MY RECOLLECTION IS ?AT :AT ! HIPPIES ROMANTICIZ$ WAS TRIBAL SOCIETY ON ! MODEL1 USUALLY ILL-UND]/OOD1 ( C]TA9 PACIFIC ,NATIVE ,AM]ICAN TRIBES LIKE ! ,HOPI & ! ,NAVAJO4 ,AT ! TIME1 ,BOOK*9 APP>5TLY ?\P0 7#c#i71 :I* WAS EXPRESSLY & ONLY AB\T REVIS+ ! ,HOBBESIAN VIEW ( HUNT]-GA!R]S4 ,= ! MO/ P>T1 HUNT]-GA!R]S DON'T EV5 LIVE 9 TRIBES1 !Y LIVE 9 B&S 7,LEE @& ,DE,VORE #a#i#f#hB3 #g-#h74 ,9 CONTRA/1 TRIBAL PEOPLES -- HORTICULTURALI/S OR H]D]S -- OCCUPY A SOCIAL SPACE 0BETWE5 B&S & /ATES0 7,GREGG #a#i#i#a74 ,MANY ( !IR SOCIETIES >E ALSO AN>*I/ & AS SU* >E ALSO 9T]E/+1 AS WELL AS 9T]E/+ 9 !IR [N RIILY !RE >E NOT AS MANY VALID G5]ALIZATIONS AB\T PRIMITIVES AS !RE >E AB\T =AG]S4 ,ALL =AG]S >E PRIMITIVES1 BUT NOT ALL PRIMITIVES >E =AG]S4 ,9 A WAY1 IT'S ,BRAD=D'S FAULT = 9VIT+ ! ,DEAN TO FOM5T CONFUSION4 ,IF ! ,DEAN QUOTES HIM CORRECTLY -- ALWAYS A BIG IF :]E ! ,DEAN IS CONC]N$ -- ,BRAD=D WROTE 9 #aiia ?AT ! 0(FICIAL0 AN?ROPOLOGICAL VIEW ( =AG]S IS ! ,HOBBESIAN ONE4 ,?AT WAS ALREADY *ANG+ EV5 :5 ,M>%ALL ,SAHL9S MADE ! SAME PO9T 9 HIS #aifh ESSAY 0,! ,ORIG9AL ,AFFLU5T ,SOCIETY0 7,SAHL9S #a#i#g#a3 *4 #a74 ,TODAY ! 0CURR5T MODEL0 7,R5\F #a#i#i#a3 #h#i-#i7 IS ! ONE ADVANC$ AT ! ,OTTAWA & ,*ICAGO CONF]5CES3 0AL?\< ! MORE IDEALIZ$ ASPECTS ( ! ,LEE & ,DE,VORE MODEL >E COMMONLY ACKN[L$G$1 ,I ?9K IT IS FAIR TO SAY ?AT NO FUNDAM5TAL REVISION ( IT HAS BE5 MADE0 7IBID43 #i74 ,SIMIL>LY1 ANO!R AN?ROPOLOGI/ REF]S TO ! CONT9U+ PREVAL5CE ( 0! REVIS$ G5]AL V]SION ( HUNT]-GA!R]S ( ! MID- #a#i#fS0 7,CONKEY #a#i#h#d3 #b#e#g74 ,JOHN ,Z]ZAN1 NOT ,GEORGE ,BRAD=D1 IS CORRECT 9 SAY+ ?AT 0A NE>LY COMPLETE REV]SAL 9 AN?ROPOLOGICAL OR?ODOXY HAS COME AB\T1 ) IMPORTANT IMPLICATIONS0 7#a#i#i#d3 #a#f74 ,BRAD=D'S FAILURE TO UPDATE ! OP9IONS HE'S EXPRESS$ S9CE ! #a#i#gS -- :I* IS TYPICAL ( ! ,FIF? ,E/ATE -- AF=D$ ! ,DEAN AN UNDES]V$ OPPORTUNITY TO CLAIM SCI5TIFIC RESPECTABILITY = A VIEWPO9T LONG S9CE DISCR$IT$4 ,BRAD=D'S O!R MI/AKE1 EAG]LY EXPLOIT$ BY ! ,DEAN1 IS ?AT HE ALLEG$LY WROTE ?AT ! REVISIONI/ VIEW IS BAS$ ON 0GREAT] ACCESS TO ! VIEWS ( PRIMAL PEOPLE & !IR NATIVE DESC5DANTS0 7#c#g74 ,?AT GAVE ! ,DEAN HIS *ANCE TO DISMISS PRIMITIVE AFFLU5CE AS ! 0$5IC0 MY? ( NO/ALGIC NATIVES 7#c#f7 FE$+ !IR FANTASIES1 & P]HAPS !IR PEYOTE1 TO CR$UL\S :ITE HIPPIES4 ,?IS IS ALL WRONG4 ,IT WAS ! E>LIE/ /UDIES ( HUNT]-GA!R]S1 9CLUD+ CLASSIC ACC\NTS BY ,KROEB]1 ,BOAS & ,RADCLIFFE-,BR[N1 :I* RELI$ ON OLD] 9=MANTS' MEMORIES ( CONDITIONS #b#e-#e YE>S BE=E1 ON 0E?NOGRAPHIC RECON/RUCTIONS ( SITUATIONS :I* W]E NO LONG] 9TACT0 7,LEE @& ,DE,VORE #a#i#f#hC3 #e-#f74 ,! ,MAN ! ,HUNT] SYMPOSIUM1 F> FROM OV]LOOK+ ?IS ME?OD'S %ORTCOM+S1 MADE ?AT A 0C5TRAL !ME0 7IBID43 #f74 ,CONTEMPOR>Y AN?ROPOLOGI/S HAVE LESS]1 NOT GREAT] ACCESS TO ! VIEWS ( SO-CALL$ PRIMAL PEOPLE4 ,9 ! FIR/ PLACE1 PRIMAL PEOPLE >E DISAPPE>+ ALMO/ AS RAPIDLY AS LEFTI/S >E4 ,& SECONDLY1 ,WE/]N AN?ROPOLOGI/S NO LONG] 5JOY AS MU* 0ACCESS0 AS !Y DID :5 ! PEOPLE !Y /UDI$ W]E SUBJECT TO ,WE/]N COLONIAL RULE4 ,MO/ 9DIG5\S PEOPLES N[ HAVE MORE P[] TO DET]M9E :E!R & ON :AT T]MS !Y WILL RECEIVE RESID5T & EV5 VISIT+ E?NOGRAPH]S4 ,SOME EXCLUDE !M 5TIRELY4 ,& ! NATIONAL GOV]NM5TS ( SOME =M] COLONIAL POSSESSIONS :I* >E N[ 9DEP5D5T /ATES RE/RICT OR EXCLUDE =EIGN AN?ROPOLOGI/S = A V>IETY ( REASONS 7,BEALS #a#i#f#i3 #b-#b#g74 ,MORE IMPORTANT1 ! AFFLU5CE !SIS IS BAS$ ON OBS]VATION & MEASUREM5T1 NOT MY? & MEMORY4 ,RI*>D ,B4 ,LEE CONCLUD$ ?AT ! 6,KUNG ,SAN_/,BU%M5 DID REM>KABLY LITTLE WORK COMP>$ TO US -- NOT BY SITT+ AT ! FEET ( ! ,OLD ,WISE ,MAN LIKE !Y DO AT ,GODD>D ,COLLEGE -- BUT BY FOLL[+ ! ,SAN >\ND TO SEE :AT !Y W]E DO+ & = H[ LONG4 ,HE BAS$ HIS CONCLUSIONS AS TO ! SUFFICI5CY ( !IR DIET ON MEASUR+ ! CALORIES !Y +E/$ & EXP5D$ 7,LEE #a#i#f#i1 #a#i#g#i71 SOME?+ R>ELY DONE PREVI\SLY4 ,ONE ( ! RESULT+ >TICLES WAS TITL$ 06,KUNG ,BU%M5 ,SUBSI/5CE3 ,AN ,9PUT-,\TPUT ,ANALYSIS0 7,LEE #a#i#f#i74 ,?IS IS SCI5CE AT ITS MO/ MUSCUL>1 NOT FREE-=M FANTASY4 ,IT DOESN'T NECESS>ILY FOLL[1 ( C\RSE1 ?AT IF ,SAN SOCIETY IS 9 A V]Y TANGIBLE1 MEASURABLE S5SE LEISURELY & AFFLU5T1 !N SO >E ALL OR MO/ O!R =AG+ SOCIETIES4 ,BUT ON ! ,HOBBESIAN NEW1 ! ,SAN AS !Y LIV$ 9 ! #a#i#fS W]E IMPOSSIBLE1 SO ! ,HOBBESIAN VIEW 9 ! MUSCUL> =M ESP\S$ BY ! ,DEAN HAS TO BE QUALIFI$ OR1 AS ! SOCIAL SCI5TI/S SAY1 0SPECIFI$0 7! SCOPE ( ITS VALIDITY N>R[$7 7,BABBIE #a#i#i#b3 #d#b#a-#d#b#b7 OR ELSE REJECT$ ALTOGE!R4 ,& :AT'S SO 9TRIGU+ IS ?AT ! ,SAN LIVE !IR AFFLU5CE 9 ! >ID ,KALAH>I ,DES]T1 NOT SOMEPLACE APPROXIMAT+ ! ,G>D5 ( ,$5 7,Z]ZAN #a#i#i#d3 #b#i74 ,IF =AG+ LIFE C\LD BE AFFLU5T !RE1 IT MI74 ,!SE IMPLICATIONS HAVE NOT ONLY REORI5T$ FIELDWORK1 !Y HAVE ALSO OCCASION$ ! RE9T]PRETATION ( ALREADY AVAILABLE ACC\NTS ( HUNT]-GA!R]S1 BO? HI/ORICAL S\RCES & =MAL E?NOGRAPHIES4 ,SAHL9S 7#a#i#g#a3 *4 #a7 DID SOME ( BO? 9 0,! ,ORIG9AL ,AFFLU5T ,SOCIETY10 :OSE CONCLUSIONS HE'D PREVIEW$ AS A DISCUSSANT AT ! ,MAN ! ,HUNT] SYMPOSIUM 7,LEE @& ,DE,VORE #a#i#f#h3 #h#e-#h#i74 ,! ABUNDANT HI/ORICAL ACC\NTS ( ! ,AU/RALIAN ABORIG9ES1 = ALL !IR MISP]CEPTIONS1 IF C>EFULLY READ1 CONFIRM ! AFFLU5CE !SIS4 ,& ! E>LI] E?NOGRAPH]S ( HUNT]-GA!R]S1 AL?\< !Y HAD (T5 ANN\NC$ AS !IR CONCLUSIONS ! ,HOBBESIAN P>TY L9E1 REPORT AMPLE DATA :I* CONTRADICT ?OSE CONCLUSIONS4 ,AN?ROPOLOGI/S :O ONCE SLIE N[ COMB+ !M V]Y C>EFULLY 7E4G41 ,P>K+TON #a#i#h#d74 ,UNLIKE ,BRAD=D1 ! ,MAN ! ,HUNT] AN?ROPOLOGI/S W]E NOT 9T]E/$ 9 PRIMITIVE ANIMISM1 H>MONY ) NATURE1 OR 0EC/ATIC TE*NIQUES10 A PHRASE ! ,DEAN ATTRIBUTES TO ,BRAD=D 7#c#f74 ,AN?ROPOLOGI/S HAD LONG S9CE DOCUM5T$ BEYOND ANY REASONABLE POSSIBILITY ( REFUTATION ALL !SE ASPECTS ( MANY PRIMITIVE CULTURES4 ,:AT ! ,MAN-!-,HUNT] REVISIONI/S ADD$ WAS PRECISELY :AT ! ,DEAN CLAIMS IS MISS+1 ! SOCIAL DIM5SION3 0,EGALIT>IANISM1 %>+1 & L[ WORK EF=T W]E /RESS$1 AS WAS ! IMPORTANCE ( GA!R+ FOODS &1 BY EXT5SION1 WOM5'S DIRECT ROLE 9 ! ECONOMY0 7,R5\F #a#i#i#a3 #h#i74 ,! ,DEAN'S 5TIRE RHETORICAL /RATEGY IS AS MISDIRECT$ AS IT IS MALICI\S4 ,PRIMITIVI/S CONTRA/ ! ORD]LY AN>*Y & ! G5]\S EGALIT>IANISM ( =AG]S ) ! *AOTIC /ATISM & CLASS HI]>*Y ( URBAN CIVILIZATION4 ,! ,DEAN DR$GES UP ONE =AG+ SOCIETY1 ! ,YUQUI ( ,BOLIVIA1 :I*1 HE CLAIMS1 9CLUDES ! 9/ITUTION ( H]$IT>Y SLAV]Y -- AL?\< HE HAS TO ADMIT ?AT 0?IS FEATURE IS N[ REG>D$ AS A FEATURE ( =M] HORTICULTURAL LIFEWAYS0 7#d#e74 ,Y\ C\LD H>DLY ASK = A BETT] EXAMPLE ( ! EXCEPTION ?AT PROVES ! RULE4 ,!RE W]E ONLY #dc ,YUQUI AT CONTACT 9 ! #a#i#eS1 F> BEL[ ! M9IMUM -- USUALLY PUT AT AB\T #e -- = SOCIAL VIABILITY4 ,!Y >E PROBABLY DESC5D$ FROM A ,GU>ANI RAID+ P>TY ( ! LATE PRE-,COLUMBIAN P]IOD :I* WAS UNABLE TO F9D ITS WAY BACK TO ,P>AGUAY4 ,REM>KABLY1 !Y MA9TA9$ VE/IGES ( SLAV]Y1 SOME?+ 0DIFFICULT TO IMAG9E1 BUT IT DID EXI/40 ,! ,DEAN NEGLECTS TO M5TION ?AT UPON FALL+ 9TO ! CLUT*ES ( ! MISSION>IES1 ?IS SOCIAL SPL9T] AB&ON$ BO? =AG+ & SLAV]Y 7,/E>MAN #a#i#h#i74 ,?IS EXAMPLE PROVES1 AT ! MO/1 ?AT =AG+ SOCIETIES >E NOT ALWAYS AN>*I/ & EGALIT>IAN1 LEAV+ UNT\*$ ! CONCLUSION1 :I* EV5 ! ,DEAN DOESN'T D5Y1 ?AT !Y >E ALMO/ ALWAYS AN>*I/ & EGALIT>IAN4 ,ON ! O!R H&1 9 ?IRTY YE>S ( CELEBRAT+ URBANISM1 ! ,DEAN HAS YET TO ID5TIFY A /ABLE1 AN>*IC1 EGALIT>IAN URBAN SOCIETY4 ,P]HAPS REVOLUTION>Y ,B>CELONA APPROXIMAT$ ONE = A FEW MON?S 9 #a#i#c#f-#a#i#c#g1 & ,P>IS 9 #aifh = SEV]AL WEEKS4 ,BUT AT BE/ !SE >E ONLY BLIPS ON A SOCIAL SCRE5 ( ALMO/ UNRELIEV$ URBAN /ATISM & CLASS /RATIFICATION4 ,!SE 0\TLI]S10 AS ! /ATI/ICIANS REF] TO R>E VALUES ( V>IABLES1 F> \TSIDE ! RANGE ( ALL O!RS1 DO REM9D US -- AS DO ! ,YUQUI -- ( ! HUMAN CAPACITY = EXTREME SOCIAL PLA/ICITY4 ,AS SU*1 !Y HE>T5 ME1 BUT !Y FAIL TO P]SUADE ME ?AT 0SOME K9D ( URBAN COMMUNITY IS NOT ONLY ! 5VIRONM5T ( HUMANITY3 IT IS ITS DE/9Y0 7,BOOK*9 #a#i#g#d3 #b74 ,I DON'T ?9K ANATOMY IS DE/9Y & ,I DON'T ?9K URBANITY IS DE/9Y EI!R4 ,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,NOVEMB] #c1 #aiif 3 ,*APT] #h -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,NOVEMB] #b#i1 #bb 3 ,*APT] #h -- ,ADD$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/