,>E ,WE ,GOOD ,5\<8 

#ahhh 

,PEOPLE 3 

,$ITOR 3 ,*>LOTTE ,WILSON 

,AU?OR 3 ,PET] ,KROPOTK9 

,TAGS 3 ABOLITION ( SLAV]Y1 PRACTICAL PEOPLE1 UNPRACTICAL CAMP1 MIS]Y-/RICK5 TAILORS1 SLAVI% 9/9CTS1 HUMAN NATURE1 PRACTICAL M51 LEFT W+1 PRACTICAL CAMP1 PRACTICAL4 

,TEXT 3 

  

,PHOTO BY ,M>G>ET ,KILLJOY1,C,C ,B,Y-,N,C-,S,A ,LIC5SE ,ONE ( ! COMMONE/ OBJECTIONS TO ,COMMUNISM IS1 ?AT M5 >E NOT GOOD 5\< TO LIVE UND] A ,COMMUNI/ /ATE ( ?+S4 ,!Y W\LD NOT SUBMIT TO A COMPULSORY ,COMMUNISM1 BUT !Y >E NOT YET RIPE = FREE1 ,AN>*I/IC ,COMMUNISM4 ,C5TURIES ( 9DIVIDUALI/IC $UCATION HAVE R5D]$ !M TOO EGOTI/IC4 ,SLAV]Y1 SUBMISSION TO ! /RONG1 & WORK UND] ! :IP ( NECESSITY1 HAVE R5D]$ !M UNFIT = A SOCIETY :]E EV]YBODY W\LD BE FREE & KN[ NO COMPULSION EXCEPT :AT RESULTS FROM A FREELY TAK5 5GAGEM5T T[>DS ! O!RS1 & !IR DISAPPROVAL IF HE W\LD NOT FULFILL ! 5GAGEM5T4 ,!RE=E1 WE >E TOLD1 SOME 9T]M$IATE TRANSITION /ATE ( SOCIETY IS NECESS>Y AS A /EP T[>DS ,COMMUNISM4 

,OLD WORDS 9 A NEW %APE2 WORDS SAID & REPEAT$ S9CE ! FIR/ ATTEMPT AT ANY RE=M1 POLITICAL OR SOCIAL1 9 ANY HUMAN SOCIETY4 ,WORDS :I* WE HE>D BE=E ! ABOLITION ( SLAV]Y2 WORDS SAID TW5TY & =TY C5TURIES AGO BY ?OSE :O LIKE TOO MU* !IR [N QUIETNESS = LIK+ RAPID *ANGES1 :OM BOLDNESS ( ?\<T FRI<T5S1 & :O !MSELVES HAVE NOT SUFF]$ 5\< FROM ! 9IQUITIES ( ! PRES5T SOCIETY TO FEEL ! DEEP NECESSITY ( NEW ISSUES6 

,M5 >E NOT GOOD 5\< = ,COMMUNISM1 BUT >E !Y GOOD 5\< = ,CAPITALISM8 ,IF ALL M5 W]E GOOD-HE>T$1 K9D1 & JU/1 !Y W\LD NEV] EXPLOIT ONE ANO!R1 AL?\< POSSESS+ ! MEANS ( DO+ SO4 ,) SU* M5 ! PRIVATE [N]%IP ( CAPITAL W\LD BE NO DANG]4 ,! CAPITALI/ W\LD HA/5 TO %>E HIS PR(ITS ) ! WORK]S1 & ! BE/ REMUN]AT$ WORK]S ) ?OSE SUFF]+ FROM OCCASIONAL CAUSES4 ,IF M5 W]E PROVID5T !Y W\LD NOT PRODUCE VELVET & >TICLES ( LUXURY :ILE FOOD IS WANT$ 9 COTTAGES3 !Y W\LD NOT BUILD PALACES AS LONG AS !RE >E SLUMS4 

,IF M5 HAD A DEEPLY DEVELOP$ FEEL+ ( EQUITY !Y W\LD NOT OPPRESS O!R M54 ,POLITICIANS W\LD NOT *EAT !IR ELECTORS 2 ,P>LIAM5T W\LD NOT BE A *ATT]+ & *EAT+ BOX1 & ,*>LES ,W>R5'S POLICEM5 W\LD REFUSE TO BLUDGEON ! ,TRAFALG> ,SQU>E TALK]S & LI/5]S4 ,& IF M5 W]E GALLANT1 SELF-RESPECT+1 & LESS EGOTI/IC1 EV5 A BAD CAPITALI/ W\LD NOT BE A DANG]2 ! WORK]S W\LD HAVE SOON R$UC$ HIM TO ! ROLL ( A SIMPLE COMRADE-MANAG]4 ,EV5 A K+ W\LD NOT BE DANG]\S1 BECAUSE ! PEOPLE W\LD M]ELY CONSID] HIM AS A FELL[ UNABLE TO DO BETT] WORK1 & !RE=E 5TRU/$ ) SIGN+ SOME /UPID PAP]S S5T \T TO O!R CRANKS CALL+ !MSELVES K+S4 

,BUT M5 >E NOT ?OSE FREE-M9D$1 9DEP5D5T1 PROVID5T1 LOV+1 & COMPASSIONATE FELL[S :I* WE %\LD LIKE TO SEE !M4 ,& PRECISELY1 !RE=E1 !Y MU/ NOT CONT9UE LIV+ UND] ! PRES5T SY/EM :I* P]MITS !M TO OPPRESS & EXPLOIT ONE ANO!R4 ,TAKE1 = 9/ANCE1 ?OSE MIS]Y-/RICK5 TAILORS :O P>AD$ LA/ ,SUNDAY 9 ! /REETS1 & SUPPOSE ?AT ONE ( !M HAS 9H]IT$ A HUNDR$ P\NDS FROM AN ,AM]ICAN UNCLE4 ,) !SE HUNDR$ P\NDS HE SURELY WILL NOT />T A PRODUCTIVE ASSOCIATION = A DOZ5 ( LIKE MIS]Y-/RICK5 TAILORS1 & TRY TO IMPROVE !IR CONDITION1 LIE WILL BECOME A SWEAT]4 ,&1 !RE=E1 WE SAY ?AT 9 A SOCIETY :]E M5 >E SO BAD AS ?IS ,AM]ICAN HEIR1 IT IS V]Y H>D = HIM TO HAVE MIS]Y-/RICK5 TAILORS >\ND HIM4 ,AS SOON AS HE CAN HE WILL SWEAT !M 2 :ILE IF !SE SAME TAILORS HAD A SECUR$ LIV+ FROM ! ,COMMUNI/ /ORES1 NONE ( !TA W\LD SWEAT TO 5RI* !IR EX-COMRADE1 & ! Y\NG SWEAT] W\LD HIMSELF NOT BECOME ! V]Y BAD BEA/ HE SURELY WILL BECOME IF HE CONT9UES TO BE A SWEAT]4 

,WE >E TOLD WE >E TOO SLAVI%1 TOO SNOBBI%1 TO BE PLAC$ UND] FREE 9/ITUTIONS 2 BUT WE SAY ?AT BECAUSE WE >E 9DE$ SO SLAVI% WE \<T NOT TO REMA9 ANY LONG] UND] ! PRES5T 9/ITUTIONS1 :I* FAVOR ! DEVELOPM5T ( SLAVI%NESS4 ,WE SEE ?AT ,BRITONS1 ,FR5*1 & ,AM]ICANS DISPLAY ! MO/ DISGU/+ SLAVI%NESS T[>DS ,GLAD/ONE1 ,B\LANG]1 OR ,G\LD4 ,& WE CONCLUDE ?AT 9 A HUMANITY ALREADY 5D[$ ) SU* SLAVI% 9/9CTS IT IS V]Y BAD TO HAVE ! MASSES =CIBLY DEPRIV$ ( HI<] $UCATION1 & COMPELL$ TO LIVE UND] ! PRES5T 9EQUALITY ( WEAL?1 $UCATION1 & KN[L$GE4 ,HI<] 9/RUCTION & EQUALITY ( CONDITIONS W\LD BE ! ONLY MEANS = DE/ROY+ ! 9H]IT$ SLAVI% 9/9CTS1 & WE CANNOT UND]/& H[ SLAVI% 9/9CTS CAN BE MADE AN >GUM5T = MA9TA9+1 EV5 = ONE DAY LONG]1 9EQUALITY ( CONDITIONS2 = REFUS+ EQUALITY ( 9/RUCTION TO ALL MEMB]S ( ! COMMUNITY4 

,\R SPACE IS LIMIT$1 BUT SUBMIT TO ! SAME ANALYSIS ANY ( ! ASPECTS ( \R SOCIAL LIFE1 & Y\ WILL SEE ?AT ! PRES5T CAPITALI/1 AU?ORIT>IAN SY/EM IS ABSOLUTELY 9APPROPRIATE TO A SOCIETY ( M5 SO IMPROVID5T1 SO RAPACI\S1 SO EGOTI/IC1 & SO SLAVI% AS !Y >E N[4 ,!RE=E1 :5 WE HE> M5 SAY+ ?AT ! ,AN>*I/S IMAG9E M5 MU* BETT] ?AN !Y REALLY >E1 WE M]ELY WOND] H[ 9TELLIG5T PEOPLE CAN REPEAT ?AT NONS5SE4 ,DO WE NOT SAY CONT9UALLY ?AT ! ONLY MEANS ( R5D]+ M5 LESS RAPACI\S & EGOTI/IC1 LESS AMBITI\S & LESS SLAVI% AT ! SAME TIME1 IS TO ELIM9ATE ?OSE CONDITIONS :I* FAVOR ! GR[? ( EGOTISM & RAPACITY1 ( SLAVI%NESS & AMBITION8 ,! ONLY DIFF]5CE BETWE5 US & ?OSE :O MAKE ! ABOVE OBJECTION IS ?IS3 ,WE DO NOT1 LIKE !M1 EXAGG]ATE ! 9F]IOR 9/9CTS ( ! MASSES1 & DO NOT COMPLAC5TLY %UT \R EYES TO ! SAME BAD 9/9CTS 9 ! UPP] CLASSES4 ,WE MA9TA9 ?AT BO? RUL]S & RUL$ >E SPOIL$ BY AU?ORITY2 BO? EXPLOIT]S & EXPLOIT$ >E SPOIL$ BY EXPLOITATION2 :ILE \R OPPON5TS SEEM TO ADMIT ?AT !RE IS A K9D ( SALT ( ! E>? --- ! RUL]S1 ! EMPLOY]S1 ! LEAD]S --- :O1 HAPPILY 5\<1 PREV5T ?OSE BAD M5 --- ! RUL$1 ! EXPLOIT$1 ! L$ --- FROM BECOM+ /ILL WORSE ?AN !Y >E4 

,!RE IS ! DIFF]5CE1 & A V]Y IMPORTANT ONE4 ,WE ADMIT ! IMP]FECTIONS ( HUMAN NATURE1 BUT WE MAKE NO EXCEPTION = ! RUL]S4 ,!Y MAKE IT1 AL?\< SOMETIMES UNCONSCI\SLY1 & BECAUSE WE MAKE NO SU* EXCEPTION1 !Y SAY ?AT WE >E DREAM]S1 0UNPRACTICAL M540 

,AN OLD QU>REL1 ?AT QU>REL BETWE5 ! 0PRACTICAL M50 & ! 0UNPRACTICAL10 ! SO-CALL$ ,UTOPI/S3 A QU>REL R5EW$ AT EA* PROPOS$ *ANGE1 & ALWAYS T]M9AT+ BY ! TOTAL DEFEAT ( ?OSE :O NAME !MSELVES PRACTICAL PEOPLE4 

,MANY ( US MU/ REMEMB] ! QU>REL :5 IT RAG$ 9 ,AM]ICA BE=E ! ABOLITION ( SLAV]Y4 ,:5 ! FULL EMANCIPATION ( ! ,NEGROES WAS ADVOCAT$1 ! PRACTICAL PEOPLE US$ TO SAY ?AT IF ! ,NEGROES W]E NO MORE COMPELL$ TO LABOR BY ! :IPS ( !IR [N]S1 !Y W\LD NOT WORK AT ALL1 & SOON W\LD1 BECOME A *>GE UPON ! COMMUNITY4 ,?ICK :IPS C\LD BE PROHIBIT$1 !Y SAID1 & ! ?ICKNESS ( ! :IPS MI<T BE PROGRESSIVELY R$UC$ BY LAW TO HALF AN 9* FIR/ & !N TO A M]E TRIFLE ( A FEW T5?S ( AN 9*2 BUT SOME K9D ( :IP MU/ BE MA9TA9$4 ,& :5 ! ABOLITIONI/S SAID --- JU/ AS WE SAY N[ --- ?AT ! 5JOYM5T ( ! PRODUCE ( ONE'S LABOR W\LD BE A MU* MORE P[]FUL 9DUCEM5T TO WORK ?AN ! ?ICKE/ :IP1 0,NONS5SE1 MY FRI5D10 !Y W]E TOLD --- JU/ AS WE >E TOLD N[4 0,Y\ DON'T KN[ HUMAN NATURE6 ,YE>S ( SLAV]Y HAVE R5D]$ !M IMPROVID5T1 LAZY & SLAVI%1 & HUMAN NATURE CANNOT BE *ANG$ 9 ONE DAY4 ,Y\ >E IMBU$1 ( C\RSE1 ) ! BE/ 9T5TIONS1 BUT Y\ >E QUITE 0UNPRACTICAL40 

,WELL1 = SOME TIME ! PRACTICAL M5 HAD !IR [N WAY 9 ELABORAT+ S*EMES = ! GRADUAL EMANCIPATION ( ,NEGROES4 ,BUT1 ALAS6 ! S*EMES PROV$ QUITE UNPRACTICAL1 & ! CIVIL W> --- ! BLOODIE/ ON RECORD --- BROKE \T4 ,BUT ! W> RESULT$ 9 ! ABOLITION ( SLAV]Y1 )\T ANY TRANSITION P]IOD 2 --- & SEE1 NONE ( ! T]RIBLE CONSEQU5CES =ESE5 BY ! PRACTICAL PEOPLE FOLL[$4 ,! ,NEGROES WORK1 !Y >E 9DU/RI\S & LABORI\S1 !Y >E PROVID5T --- NAY1 TOO PROVID5T1 9DE$ --- & ! ONLY REGRET ?AT CAN BE EXPRESS$ IS1 ?AT ! S*EME ADVOCAT$ BY ! LEFT W+ ( ! UNPRACTICAL CAMP --- FULL EQUALITY & L& ALLOTM5TS --- WAS NOT REALIZ$3 IT W\LD HAVE SAV$ MU* TR\BLE N[4 

,AB\T ! SAME TIME A LIKE QU>REL RAG$ 9 ,RUSSIA1 & ITS CAUSE WAS ?IS4 ,!RE W]E 9 ,RUSSIA TW5TY MILLION S]FS4 ,= G5]ATIONS PA/ !Y HAD BE5 UND] ! RULE1 OR RA!R ! BIR*-ROD1 ( !IR [N]S4 ,!Y W]E FLOGG$ = TILL+ !IR SOIL BADLY1 FLOGG$ = WANT ( CLEANL9ESS 9 !IR H\SEHOLDS1 FLOGG$ = IMP]FECT WEAV+ ( !IR CLO?1 FLOGG$ = NOT SOON] M>RY+ !IR BOYS & GIRLS --- FLOGG$ = EV]Y?+4 ,SLAVI%NESS1 IMPROVID5CE1 W]E !IR REPUT$ *>ACT]I/ICS4 

,N[ CAME ! ,UTOPI/S & ASK$ NO?+ %ORT ( ! FOLL[+3 

,COMPLETE LIB]ATION ( ! S]FS2 IMM$IATE ABOLITION ( ANY OBLIGATION ( ! S]F T[>DS ! LORD4 ,MORE ?AN ?AT3 IMM$IATE ABOLITION ( ! LORD'S JURISDICTION & HIS AB&ONM5T ( ALL ! AFFAIRS UPON :I* HE =M]LY JUDG$1 TO PEASANTS TRIBUNALS ELECT$ BY ! PEASANTS & JUDG+1 NOT 9 ACCORDANCE ) LAW :I* !Y DO NOT KN[1 BUT ) !IR UNWRITT5 CU/OMS4 ,SU* WAS ! UNPRACTICAL S*EME ( ! UNPRACTICAL CAMP4 ,IT WAS TREAT$ AS A M]E FOLLY BY PRACTICAL PEOPLE4 

,BUT HAPPILY 5\< !RE WAS BY ?AT TIME 9 ,RUSSIA A GOOD DEAL ( UNPRACTICALNESS 9 ! AIR1 & IT WAS MA9TA9$ BY ! UNPRACTICALNESS ( ! PEASANTS1 :O REVOLT$ ) /ICKS AGA9/ GUNS1 & REFUS$ TO SUBMIT1 NOT)/&+ ! MASSACRES1 & ?US 5=C$ ! UNPRACTICAL /ATE ( M9D TO SU* A DEGREE AS TO P]MIT ! UNPRACTICAL CAMP TO =CE ! ,CZ> TO SIGN !IR S*EME --- /ILL MUTILAT$ TO SOME EXT5T4 ,! MO/ PRACTICAL PEOPLE HA/5$ TO FLEE AWAY FROM ,RUSSIA1 ?AT !Y MI<T NOT HAVE !IR ?ROATS CUT A FEW DAYS AFT] ! PROMULGATION ( ?AT UNPRACTICAL S*EME4 

,BUT EV]Y?+ W5T ON QUITE SMOO?LY1 NOT)/&+ ! MANY BLUND]S /ILL COMMITT$ BY PRACTICAL PEOPLE4 ,!SE SLAVES :O W]E REPUT$ IMPROVID5T1 SELFI% BRUTES1 & SO ON1 DISPLAY$ SU* GOOD S5SE1 SU* AN ORGANIZ+ CAPACITY AS TO SURPASS ! EXPECTATIONS ( EV5 ! MO/ UNPRACTICAL ,UTOPI/S2 & 9 ?REE YE>S AFT] ! ,EMANCIPATION ! G5]AL PHYSIOGNOMY ( ! VILLAGES HAD COMPLETELY *ANG$4 ,! SLAVES W]E BECOM+ ,M56 

,! ,UTOPI/S WON ! BATTLE4 ,!Y PROV$ ?AT !Y W]E ! REALLY PRACTICAL PEOPLE1 & ?AT ?OSE :O PRET5D$ TO BE PRACTICAL W]E IMBECILES4 ,& ! ONLY REGRET EXPRESS$ N[ BY ALL :O KN[ ! ,RUSSIAN PEASANTRY IS1 ?AT TOO MANY CONCESSIONS W]E MADE TO ?OSE PRACTICAL IMBECILES & N>R[-M9D$ EGOTI/S3 ?AT ! ADVICE ( ! LEFT W+ ( ! UNPRACTICAL CAMP WAS NOT FOLL[$ 9 FULL4 

,WE CANNOT GIVE MORE EXAMPLES4 ,BUT WE E>NE/LY 9VITE ?OSE :O LIKE TO REASON = !MSELVES TO /UDY ! HI/ORY ( ANY ( ! GREAT SOCIAL *ANGES :I* HAVE OCCURR$ 9 HUMANITY FROM ! RISE ( ! ,COMMUNES TO ! ,RE=M & TO \R MOD]N TIMES4 ,!Y WILL SEE ?AT HI/ORY IS NO?+ BUT A /RUGGLE BETWE5 ! RUL]S & ! RUL$1 ! OPPRESSORS & ! OPPRESS$1 9 :I* /RUGGLE ! PRACTICAL CAMP ALWAYS AIDES ) ! RUL]S & ! OPPRESSORS1 :ILE ! UNPRACTICAL CAMP SIDES ) ! OPPRESS$2 & !Y WILL SEE ?AT ! /RUGGLE ALWAYS 5DS 9 A F9AL DEFEAT ( ! PRACTICAL CAMP AFT] MU* BLOOD%$ & SUFF]+1 DUE TO :AT !Y CALL !IR 0PRACTICAL GOOD S5SE40 

,IF BY SAY+ ?AT WE >E UNPRACTICAL \R OPPON5TS MEAN ?AT WE =ESEE ! M>* ( EV5TS BETT] ?AN ! PRACTICAL %ORT-SI<T$ C[>DS1 !N !Y >E RI<T4 ,BUT IF !Y MEAN ?AT !Y1 ! PRACTICAL PEOPLE1 HAVE A BETT] =ESI<T ( EV5TS1 !N WE S5D !M TO HI/ORY & ASK !M TO PUT !MSELVES 9 ACCORDANCE ) ITS TEA*+S BE=E MAK+ ?AT PRESUMPTU\S ASS]TION4 

7,S\RCE3 ,FRE$OM3 ,A ,J\RNAL ( ,AN>*I/ ,SOCIALISM1 ,VOL4 #b -- ,NO4 #b#a1 ,JUNE1 #a#h#h#h1 TEXT FROM ,AN>*Y ,>*IVES HTTP3_/_/DW>DMAC4PITZ]4$U_/AN>*I/.->*IVES_/J\RNALS_/FRE$OM_/FRE$OM#b.-#b#a4HTML 47 

,FROM 3 ,AN>*Y,>*IVES4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,JUNE #a1 #ahhh 3 ,>E ,WE ,GOOD ,5\<8 -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,APRIL #a#h1 #bah 3 ,>E ,WE ,GOOD ,5\<8 -- ,ADD$4 
,DECEMB] #c1 #bba 3 ,>E ,WE ,GOOD ,5\<8 -- ,UPDAT$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/