,BEAUB\RG3 ,FUTURE ,CANC]8 

#aiig 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,JACQUES ,CAMATTE 

,TEXT 3 

,:E!R AS A TRICK1 A DIV]SION1 OR CORE-WORK )9 A WELL-E/ABLI%$ PROJECT1 ! ,BEAUB\RG ,CULTURAL ,C5T] OCCUPIES A PO9T :]E A NUMB] ( PH5OM5A CONV]GE4 ,ITS EXI/5CE IS SIGNIFICATIVE ( ! TRANS=MATION ( ! COMMUNITY ( CAPITAL4 ,ALL ?AT CANNOT BE CONSID]$ H]E4 ,I WILL RE/RICT MYSELF TO PO9T+ \T SOME FUNDAM5TAL P>ALLELS BETWE5 >T & CAPITAL4 .<#a.> 

,>T DEVELOP$ AT ! MOM5T :5 HUMAN BE+S W]E SEP>AT$ FROM !IR COMMUNITY4 ,!RE WAS NO >T 9 ! LONG PREHI/ORY PREC$+ ?AT EV5T4 ,! T]M ISOLATES ! MAT]IALIZATION ( A COGNITIVE MEANS = PEOPLE TO REPRES5T !IR WORLD1 FROM :I* !Y W]5'T SEP>AT$4 ,IT WAS P>T ( A NONAB/RACT$ KN[L$GE1 ?AT IS1 NOT PRES5T$ SOLELY ?R\< AB/RACTION1 AS OCCURR$ LAT]4 ,IT WAS :AT ,L]OI-,G\RHAN CALL$ A DRIFT+ KN[L$GE3 .<#b.> A RADIANT1 MULTIDIM5SIONAL ?\<T 9 SYMPA?Y ) ITS SURR\ND+S1 S9CE ! BREAK HADN'T YET OCCURR$4 ,SO1 9 CONTEMPOR>Y T]MS1 ?IS >T WAS SIMULTANE\SLY LANGUAGE1 SCI5CE1 MAGIC1 RITUAL1 ETC4 ,AT ! SAME TIME IT WAS P>T ( A :OLE ?AT IT RECOGNIZ$ & TO :I* IT GAVE SIGNIFICATION4 

,AFT] ! BREAK >T WAS TO BECOME ! MEANS = RECREAT+ ! OLD COMMUNITY1 ! 0,LO/ ,TOTALITY40 ,) ! LOSS ( IMM$IATE COH]5CE1 >T WAS ! M$IATION REE/ABLI%+ COMMUNICATION4 ,?IS SE>* = ! LO/ COMMUNITY IS CLE> 9 ,GREEK !AT]1 OP]A1 C9EMA1 & ! ATTEMPTS TO REALIZE TOTAL >T 7EV5 9 HAPP5+S71 EV5 IF IT NO LONG] APPE>S 9 SU* T]MS TO ?OSE DO+ !M4 ,IT'S NOT JU/ >T AS ! SUM ( ! >TI/IC ACTIONS TRY+ TO REAFFIRM A :OLE1 IT'S EA* P>TICUL> >T ?AT RU%ES 9TO ?IS 5DEAVOR4 ,IT'S AS IF EA* WANT$ TO REORD] ! :OLE & RE=M IT FROM ITSELF1 9VOLV+ A RECON/ITUTION FROM A C]TA9 VIEWPO9T & UND]/&+2 = L9E>IZATION BEGAN AS SOON AS ! 0RADIANT PH5OM5ON0 WAS DE/ROY$1 BECAUSE ( ! BREAK & ! AUTONOMIZATION ( ! P>TS CON/ITUT+ ! ORIG9AL :OLE4 ,ATTEMPTS AT RECON/ITUTION FAIL$ TO /OP ?IS1 S9CE !Y BEGAN FROM A SEP>AT$ P>T4 ,IT'S IMPOSSIBLE TO CATAPULT ONESELF /RAI<T 9TO ANO!R COMMUNITY4 ,BUT IT'S ! ONLY />T+ PO9T = R$ISCOV]+ RADIANT ?\<T4 

,NO/ALGIA = LO/ COMMUNITY IS MO/ OBVI\S AT TIMES ( APPE>ANCE ( >T D]IV$ FROM OPPOSITION BETWE5 TWO MOM5TS 9 HUMAN HI/ORY 9 A WELL-DET]M9$ >EA4 ,EXAMPLES >E ! OPPOSITIONS BETWE5 MATRI>*Y & PATRI>*Y .<#c.> 9 ,GREEK TRAG$Y1 & FEUDALISM & NASC5T B\RGEOIS SOCIETY RETURN+ TO ! OLD MODELS 7,R5AISSANCE74 ,A COMMON *>ACT]I/IC IS ?AT IT'S ! DEFEAT$ P>TS ?AT PRODUC$ >T 7SU* AS PROV9CIALS OR ,AM]ICAN S\!RN]S71 AS IF >T IS ALL ! MORE GLORI\S :5 ATTA*$ TO SOME?+ IRR$EEMABLY LO/4 ,SO = SOME >T W\LD BE A CONSOLATION = ! DEFEAT$1 IGNOR+ ITS AFFIRMATION NOT ( ! DEFEAT BUT ( CREATION OR MA9T5ANCE ( A POSSIBILITY1 A REFUSAL ( ! DIKTAT ( REALISM & ! REALITY PR9CIPLE4 

,SECUL>IZATION HAPP5S AT ! SAME TIME4 ,LOSS ( ! SACR$ LEADS >T TO TAKE NATURE AS ITS MODEL4 ,9 REACTION IT IS EQUALLY ! PLACE ( ITS CONS]VATION4 ,! H]ESIES HAVE SURVIV$ ?R\< >T4 

,AT ! TIME ( CAPITAL'S =MAL DOM9ATION OV] SOCIETY1 >T C\LD REMA9 \TSIDE IT & ACCOMPLI% ITS ANTI-B\RGEOIS FUNCTION4 ,AS IT HAPP5$1 IT WAS ANTICAPITALI/1 = ! B\RGEOISIE HI/ORICALLY NE$$ >T TO IMPOSE ITSELF ON ! WORLD1 AS IT WAS A CLASS ?AT EXALT$ IT4 

,?IS OPPOSITION CONT9U$ UNTIL ! ATTEMPT BY ! ,DADA MOVEM5T TO L9K UP ) ! REVOLUTION !N OCCURR+ 9 ,G]MANY4 ,?IS SIMULTANE\SLY ADMITT$ ?AT NO SEP>AT$ ACTIVITY C\LD REORGANIZE A TOTALITY OR BE A />T+ PO9T = ANO!R COMMUNITY4 ,NONE!LESS >TI/S AT ?AT TIME %[$ MORE 9SI<T ?AN REVOLUTION>IES1 .<#d.> BECAUSE !IR PROCLAMATION ( ! DEA? ( >T WAS L9K$ TO !IR P]CEPTION ( ! 5D ( A WORLD1 ! OLD B\RGEOIS SOCIETY1 BECAUSE ( ! PASSAGE FROM =MAL TO REAL DOM9ATION ( CAPITAL1 :I* OCCURR$ OV] SEV]AL YE>S 7NOTABLY #a#i#a#d-#d#e74 ,AT ! TURN ( ! C5TURY1 PA9T]S HAD ALREADY ANTICIPAT$ CAPITAL'S DEVELOPM5T 9 BREAK+ ALL REF]5CE TO NATURE & 9 DISCOV]+ ?AT EV]Y?+ IS POSSIBLE4 

,! ,FUTURI/S W]E ! FIR/ TO 5TIRELY & ME?ODICALLY REJECT ! HEGEMONY ( CULTURAL /]EOTYPES4 ,ONCE ! SOCIAL B>RI]S W]E ABOLI%$1 ! MASSES - = :OM ! QUANTITATIVE APPE>$ AS ! NEW TW5TIE?-C5TURY DET]M9ANT - W\LD HAVE TO ORGANIZE ! WORLD DIFF]5TLY4 ,! NEW DYNAMISM & ITS COLLECTIVE NATURE MADE IT TRANSGRESS ! OLD SOCIAL CATEGORIES & IMPOS$ AN ACTIVE TRANS=MATIVE LOGIC ALREADY =ESE5 BY ,M>X4 ,SO ! WORLD NO LONG] APPE>S AS 9EVITABILITY BUT AS A COLLECTION ( POSSIBILITIES4 ,9 ! EUPHORIA ( ?IS NEW FRE$OM1 EXP]I5C$ 9 SEV]AL >EAS ( CONTEMPOR>Y 9TELLECTUAL LIFE1 CLASSES & NOBLE SUBJECTS VANI%$ FROM ! COLLECTION ( SOCIAL RELATIONS4 7,ONE ( ! ?+S PASS+ ?R\< ?IS BREA* WAS TOTALIT>IAN PRACTICE47 

,N[1 0,EV]Y?+ IS POSSIBLE0 IS CAPITAL'S FUNDAM5TAL *>ACT]I/IC4 ,IT'S ESS5TIALLY REVOLUTION>Y BECAUSE IT DE/ROYS OB/ACLES IMP$+ DEVELOPM5T & ELIM9ATES TABOOS & CONGEAL$ MIMESIS3 ALL >E PUT BACK 9TO QUE/ION & 9TO MOVEM5T4 7,TABOOS ?AT CANNOT BE LIFT$ >E EXT]IORIZ$ & CONSUM$ 9 REPRES5TATION1 = EXAMPLE1 ! 9CE/ TABOO & PSY*OANALYSIS47 ,IF CAPITAL 7UND] ITS MOD]N AS WELL AS ANTIQUAT$ =MS7 ?US BECAME DEF9ITE BY TAK+ OV] ! IMM$IATE PRODUCTION PROCESS1 ?IS WAS DUE TO ! CONFLU5CE BETWE5 ! MOVEM5TS ( EX*ANGE VALUE'S AUTONOMIZATION & PEOPLES' EXPROPRIATION4 ,IT C\LD SUCCESSFULLY PASS TO ITS REAL DOM9ATION OV] SOCIETY ONLY AT ANO!R MOM5T1 BECAUSE ( CONFLU5CE BETWE5 ITS NATURE & ! DEEP DESIRES ( PEOPLE SEP>AT$ FROM !IR COMMUNITY & /RIPP$ ( DIV9E & NATURAL REF]5TS4 ,9 ACCOMPLI%+ ?IS EV5 ! IMPLI$ CONSEQU5CES C\LD BE =GOTT53 DESIRE BECOM+ ALL ! GR&] & IMP]I\S ! MORE PEOPLE >E DESUB/ANTIALIZ$ & ALI5AT$4 

,! RE/RICT$ MAN OR WOMAN1 SEP>AT$ FROM EV]Y?+1 WI%ES TO RECON/ITUTE EV]Y?+ FROM POT5TIALITIES1 BEG9N+ ! OP5+ ( ! FIELD ( APPLI$ SCI5CE4 ,= A TIME1 ! REF]5T C\LD /ILL BE ! 9DIVIDUAL HUMAN BE+1 UNTIL CAPITAL'S AN?ROPOMORPHOSIS1 :5 IT REALIZ$ ITS REAL DOM9ATION OV] SOCIETY & E/ABLI%$ ITSELF AS REPRES5TATION 7& !RE=E AS REF]5T74 ,?IS RECON/ITUTES ! SPL9T]$ P]SON1 :O IS EV] MORE 5SLAV$4 ,SO :AT ,ELIADE SAID RELATES ONLY TO ! 9ITIAL MOM5T3 

0,! NIHILISM ( ! E>LY REVOLUTION>IES & NIHILI/S REPRES5T ATTITUDES ALREADY SURPASS$ 9 MOD]N ,>T4 ,NO GREAT >TI/ ( \R TIMES BELIEVES 9 ! DEG5]ACY & IMM95T DISAPPE>ANCE ( HIS_/H] >T4 ,FROM ?IS PO9T ( VIEW1 !IR ATTITUDE RESEMBLES ?AT ( ! 0PRIMITIVES03 !Y HAVE CONTRIBUT$ TO ! DE/RUCTION ( !IR WORLD & !IR >TI/IC UNIV]SE - 9 ORD] TO CREATE ANO!R ONE40 .<#e.> 

,NOT ONLY HAS ! NATURAL REF]5T BE5 DE/ROY$ & ANO!R WORLD CREAT$1 BUT ! V]Y =MS COM+ FROM ! PREVI\S GREAT DE/RUCTIVE MOVEM5T HAVE !MSELVES BE5 DE/ROY$ 7ESPECIALLY 9 ,PICASSO74 .<#f.> ,?IS AGA9 RESEMBLES CAPITAL'S MOVEM5T1 :I* IS IMP$$ BY SUB/ANTIALIZATION & MU/ AVOID BECOM+ FIX$4 ,ELIADE CONT9UES 9 AN EQUALLY ILLUM9AT+ WAY3 

0,IT'S SIGNIFICANT ?AT ! DE/RUCTION ( >TI/IC LANGUAGE CO9CID$ ) ! DEVELOPM5T ( PSY*OANALYSIS4 ,DEP? ,PSY*OLOGY BR\<T R5EWAL ( 9T]E/ 9 ORIG9S1 AN 9T]E/ *>ACT]I/IC ( PEOPLE 9 >*AIC SOCIETY4 ,A CLOSE /UDY ( ! PROCESS ( REEVALUATION ( ! MY? ( ! 5D ( ! WORLD 9 MOD]N ,>T W\LD BE 9T]E/+4 ,IT W\LD BE F\ND ?AT >TI/S1 F> FROM BE+ ! NEUROTICS !Y >E (T5 CALL$1 >E1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 PSY*OLOGICALLY MORE SANE ?AN MANY MOD]N PEOPLE4 .<#g.> ,!Y'VE UND]/OOD ?AT A TRUE BEG9N+ CAN COME ONLY AFT] A TRUE 5D4 ,& >TI/S W]E ! FIR/ MOD]NS TO APPLY !MSELVES TO DE/ROY+ !IR WORLD1 .<#h.> TO RECREATE AN >TI/IC UNIV]SE 9 :I* PEOPLE C\LD SIMULTANE\SLY LIVE1 OBS]VE & DREAM40 .<#i.> 

,! WORLD CREAT$ S9CE ! #a#i#bS IS ACTUALLY ONE 9 :I* PEOPLE HAVE DECREAS+ IMPORTANCE & SIGNIFICANCE1 BECAUSE PSY*OANALYSIS HAS DEPRIV$ !M ( !SE QUALITIES3 ! V>I\S QUALITIES ( ! PSY*E HAVE BE5 EXT]IORIZ$ & TRANS=M$ 9TO REPRES5TATIONS4 .<#a.> ,! >TI/IC UNIV]SE CREAT$ IS METAPHORICALLY ?AT ( CAPITAL4 ,SU* IS ,BEAUB\RG3 ! IDEALIZ$ & IDEAL FACTORY1 9DU/RIAL REVELATION & CAPITAL1 PRES5T+ ITSELF AS >T4 ,! SUBJECT BECOMES >T ITSELF1 COMPLETELY REALIZ+ IT1 GO+ BEYOND ITS RECONCILIATION ) LIFE4 

,BEAUB\RG REABSORBS ! DIM5SION ( >T AS NO/ALGIA = ! PA/1 S9CE IT IS A MUSEUM1 A PLACE = HO>D+ 7! OLD =M ( BEHAVIOR ( EX*ANGE VALUE BECOME CAPITAL74 ,S9CE EXHIBITIONS ( CONTEMPOR>Y PA9T+ >E HELD 9 IT1 .<#a#a.> IT'S ALSO ! PLACE :]E CR$IT IS OBTA9$4 ,AS ,CAILLOIX .<#a#b.> JU/LY REM>K$1 CR$IT 9VADES >T3 

0,:5 EXECUTION IS REPLAC$ BY CR$IT1 BY A BLANK *ECK1 ,>T F9DS ITSELF R$UC$ TO D]ISORY SIZE &1 AT ! EXTREME1 DISAPPE>S4 ,IT DISAPPE>S BY BECOM+ ALMO/ ! OPPOSITE IDEA40 

,?IS IS EVID5T S9CE1 TO ! EXT5T ?AT !RE REMA9 NO CONCRETE REPRES5TATIONS & REF]5TS ?R\< :I* PEOPLE C\LD COME TOGE!R AGA91 IT'S CLE> ?AT ! IMPORTANT ?+ WILL BE ! 9DIVIDUAL'S CR$IT1 :E!R ACCORD$ SPONTANE\SLY OR ?R\< ! 9FLU5CE ( ADV]TIS+ 7SOME?+ BECOM-+ IMPORTANT 9 >T74 .<#a#c.> ,N[1 CR$IT IS ! MEANS ( APPRAISAL & BEHAVIOR 9 ! MAT]IAL COMMUNITY ( CAPITAL1 :I* IS P>TLY 9/ITUT$ ?R\< G5]ALIZATION ( CR$IT4 ,) 9FLATION ?IS BECOMES CAPITAL'S CONFID5CE 9 ITSELF4 ,! SAME PROCESS RULES OV] ! :OLE HUMAN 5VIRONM5T4 ,PEOPLE DISCONNECT$ FROM !IR OLD RELATION%IPS1 REF]5TS1 & S5TIM5TS CAN ONLY RECON/RUCT !IR 0UNITY0 & SOCIAL RELATION%IPS ?R\< EXT]NAL ME*ANISMS SU* AS ADV]TIS+1 CRITICISM1 ETC4 7,IT'S NO LONG] POSSIBLE TO SPEAK ( COMMUNITY1 S9CE IT'S ?AT ( CAPITAL 9 EV]Y CASE74 

,PROGRESSIVE AB/RACTION IS B\ND TO ! LOSS ( ! G5]AL REF]5T 7G5]AL EQUIVAL5T74 ,?IS IMPLIES ?AT !RE'S NOT JU/ AB/RACTION BUT ALSO ITS AUTONOMIZATION4 ,SO IT BECOMES PRACTICALLY SYNONYM\S ) ! >BITR>Y3 0,! >BITR>Y H]E IS BASICALLY ! ABS5CE ( ALL JU/IFICATION0 7,CAILLOIX71 A K9D ( GRATUIT\S ACT 7SO ,GIDE'S !ORY ISN'T )\T HI/ORICAL SIGNIFICANCE74 ,P>ADOXICALLY1 ! GRATUIT\S IS REAL = O!RS ONLY ?R\< APPE>ANCE ( ! CR$IT BE/[$ BY JU/IFI$ SIGNIFICANCE OR SIGNIFICANT JU/IFICATION4 ,OBVI\SLY ?IS HAS A CLE> RELATION%IP TO ! SATURATION ( ! >T M>KET AT ! 5D ( ! LA/ C5TURY1 :I* MEANT ?AT NEW OP5+S HAD TO BE F\ND4 ,! PICTURE C\LD BE DECOMPOS$ EV5 TO ! EXT5T ?AT UNPREP>$ CANVAS W\LD BE PUT =W>D AS ! >TWORK1 A WORK ) MULTIPLE POSSIBILITIES4 ,BUT ?AT IS BUT AN EFFECT ( ! PH5OM5ON1 S9CE IT TOO W\LD HAVE TO LEAD TO ! DEM& = ! 5D ( >T4 

,?AT DEA? >RIV$4 ,NEV]!LESS1 >T /ILL EXI/S4 ,IT NO LONG] HAS ANY?+ TO DO ) :AT WAS PREVI\SLY UND]/OOD BY ! T]M4 ,& ?OSE WANT+ TO REVIVE ,DADA'S PROJECT CAN ONLY C>RY \T A 0MURD] ( ! DEAD40 .<#a#d.> ,CAPITAL'S >T IS KN[L$GE ( CAPITAL4 ,IT'S A WAY TO A*IEVE KN[L$GE ( ! NEW WORLD IT HAS CREAT$1 9 :I* ! SACR$1 NATURE1 M5 & WOM5 EXI/ ONLY BEH9D DEA? MASKS4 

,AS ,CAILLOIX EMPHASIZ$1 ! RIDICUL\S (T5 ACCOMPANIES ! >BITR>Y4 ,IT CANNOT FULLY REALIZE ITSELF OR ELSE ! CAPITALIZATION ( ! PICTURES PRODUC$ W\LD CEASE1 PUTT+ AN 5D TO HO>D-+ & RU9+ MANY PEOPLE1 & ALSO BREAK+ D[N MANY MUSEOGRAPHICAL 9/ITUTIONS4 ,! RIDICUL\S CORRESPONDS TO ! DISAPPE>$ & EPHEM]AL1 ?+S AFFECT$ BY PRES5T-DAY CAPITALISM4 ,H]E ! SAME =MS >E AGA9 F\ND3 CAPITAL TOO CANNOT REALLY ELIM9ATE HO>D+1 GOLD1 & ! PA/ & CREATE ITSELF1 SO TO SPEAK1 EX NIHILO4 ,BASICALLY IT CAN ONLY ESCAPE ! PA/ BY RUNN+ AWAY FROM IT3 9FLATION4 

,H]E WE 5C\NT] CAPITAL'S ESS5TIAL 0PROJECT03 IT MU/ DOM9ATE ! FUTURE OR ELSE ITS P[] W\LD BE PUT BACK 9TO QUE/ION & ITS DOM9ATION W\LDN'T BE REAL4 ,?IS IS ALREADY PRES5T 9 ! CONCEPT ( CAPITAL1 BUT CAN ONLY BE A*IEV$ AT A GIV5 MOM5T 9 ITS 0LIFE40 .<#a#e.> 

,CONSEQU5TLY1 !RE CAN NO LONG] BE A SPECIFIC ANTICIPATION & AB/RACTION ( ! HE>T ( A TOTALITY 7A P]CEIV$ AB/RACTION7 BY :I* TO P]CEIVE ! DI/9CTIVE & SIGNIFICANT P>TS4 ,9ITIALLY ! FUTURE IS PRODUC$2 !RE IS AS MU* IMAG9ATION AS POSSIBLE2 REALITY & IMAGE >E FUZ$4 .<#a#f.> ,! IMPOS$ IMAGE 9VADES EV]Y?+1 TO ! EXT5T ?AT IT ISN'T YET PRODUC$ ) ITS REALITY4 ,9 EFFECT1 CAPITAL NE$$ ITS [N IMAGE TO BE ABLE TO IMPLANT ITSELF )9 ! SOCIOECONOMIC :OLE & TO DOM9ATE IT4 ,IT !N HAD TO ANNEX ALL IMAGES &1 TO CONFIRM ITS DOM9ATION1 ]ADICATE !IR PRESUPPOSITIONS & REPLACE !M ) ITS [N4 

,SO ! FACTORY BECOMES 9DISP5SABLE - >T HAS TO BE PRODUC$ FROM >T & >TI/S 9 A MANN] AM5ABLE TO CAPITAL4 ,= :AT MATT]S IS TO T\* ! MASS ( HUMAN BE+S 7O!RWISE !RE W\LD BE NO REALIZATION ( >T7 .<#a#g.> :O /ILL HAV5'T 9T]NALIZ$ CAPITAL'S LIFE/YLE1 :O >E /ILL MORE OR LESS B\ND TO C]TA9 RHY?MS1 PRACTICES1 SUP]/ITIONS1 ETC41 & :O 7EV5 IF !Y HAVE TAK5 UP ! V]TIGO ( CAPITAL'S RHY?M ( LIFE7 DON'T NECESS>ILY UTILIZE ITS IMAGE1 & !RE=E LIVE A CONTRADICTION OR J>R+1 & >E CON/ANTLY EXPOS$ TO 0FUTURE %OCK40 

,EV]Y?+ MU/ BE UND]/OOD ?R\< CAPITAL'S IMAGE4 ,SU* IS ,BEAUB\RG'S FUNCTION3 A C>C9OMA1 A NEOPLASM ?AT MU/ DIV]T ! ES!TIC FLUX 9TO DOM9ATION ( ! FUTURE4 ,IT WILL CREATE ROLES TO ?AT 5D4 ,?IS C>C9OMA WILL OV]RUN EV]Y?+ & SECRETE ITS META/ASES EV]Y:]E4 ,NO 9DIVIDUAL 5C\NT]+ ,BEAUB\RG WILL REMA9 UNALT]$3 HIS_/H] IMAGE WILL BE REORI5T$1 REORD]$1 OR COMPLETELY TRANS=M$ 7ALL ! MORE :5 TAK5 9 ! TOTALITY7 ?R\< EXPOSURE TO LIV+ 9 ANTICIPATION4 

,BEAUB\RG IS ! FUTURE CANC]4 ,IT ORGANIZES ! DE/RUCTION ( >T EXTOLL$ BY ,DADA &1 TO ! EXT5T ?AT CULTURE IS PRES5T$ AS NATURE1 DEPRIVES HUMAN BE+S ( ANY POSSIBILITY ( ESCAPE4 ,?IS IS ALL ! MORE TRUE BECAUSE ( ! NE$ = NATURE P[]FULLY AFFIRM$ S9CE #a#i#f#h3 IT HAS TO BE DIV]T$ T[>D A :OLLY =M$1 DOM9AT$1 & PROGRAMM$ NATURE1 MAGICALLY CAPTUR+ ALL REVOLT4 .<#a#h.> 

,BEAUB\RG'S ROLE ISN'T ANNIHILATION ( ALL REVOLT 7AT LEA/ NOT IMM$IATELY71 S9CE1 AS HAS BE5 SAID1 ONE ( >T'S S\RCES RISES FROM ! CLA% BETWE5 TWO HI/ORICAL MOM5TS4 ,! 9TEGRATION-REALIZATION ( >T BY CAPITAL IMPLIES ITS 9TEGRATION ( REVOLT4 ,IT WILL BE ABSORB$4 ,BETT]3 REVOLT WILL BE DECL>$ 9SIGNIFICANT & A MORE TOTAL REBELLION PROPOS$ TO ! 9DIVIDUAL1 DR[N+ HIM_/H] 9 REVOLUTION>Y POSSIBILITIES BECAUSE !RE >E NO REF]5CE PO9TS & HE_/%E IS DIS[N$4 ,REVOLT CAN NO LONG] BEG9 FROM ! 9DIVIDUAL & HIS_/H] RELEAS$ POSSIBILITIES2 ! BE+ CAN NO LONG] GIVE /RUCTURE TO HIS_/H] REVOLT1 = 5JOYM5T IS ALWAYS ! BASIC MODEL3 ALWAYS PROMIS$ BUT NEV] ATTA9$1 BECAUSE IT'S ALWAYS DEF]R$4444 

,SO EV5 IF PA9T]S1 MUSICIANS1 & POETS >RIV$ AT AN 9TUITION ( ELEM5TS ( ! HUMAN COMMUNITY1 !Y C\LD DO SO ONLY TO ! EXT5T ?AT !Y ACCEPT$ WORK AT A C5T] LIKE ,BEAUB\RG4 ,IT PROVIDES ! POSSIBILITY TO RE9VIGORATE ! IMAGE ( CAPITAL1 :I* SWAMPS EV]Y?+1 EV5 IF ?IS IS TO P]V]T IT1 S9CE IT IS ! GREAT 0EMBEZZL]0 7DET\RNEUR74 

,CAPITAL'S FUTURE LIES 9 ! COMPLETE UPROOT+ ( ALL K9DS ( PEOPLE1 SO ?AT !Y'RE COMPLETELY LIB]AT$ & CAN BE MOV$ 9 ANY DIRECTION :ATSOEV]1 TO DO :ATEV] !Y'RE TOLD TO DO4 ,IT WILL AM\NT TO HUMAN LIFE )\T HUMAN BE+S1 JU/ AS CANC] 7! HI< PO9T ( ALI5ATION7 IS LIFE EXCLUD+ ! LIFE ( ! BE+ 9 :I* IT DEVELOP$4 ,BUT SIMULTANE\SLY IT IS ! ULTIMATE VITAL REACTION ( A BODY AFFLICT$ ) A BIZ>RE LIFE1 AS MU* ON ! NUTRITIONAL AS ! AFFECTIVE OR 9TELLECTUAL PLANE1 = CANC] IS CAUS$ BY NO MICROBE1 VIRUS1 OR PA?OG5IC AG5T4 ,IT'S CAUS$ BY ! W&]+ ( HUMANITY & IS ! TYPICAL HUMAN SICKNESS UND] ! DOM9ATION ( CAPITAL1 :I* IS ALSO A PRODUCT ( ! GREAT W&]+4 ,NO !RAPEUTIC LIKE RE=MISM OR REVOLUTION CAN CURE ! HUMAN SPECIES1 ONLY ! AB&ONM5T ( ! CRAZY DYNAMIC IT'S BE5 FOLL[+4 

,I'M WELL AW>E ?AT MANY PEOPLE CONSID] ?AT ,I'M MAK+ CAPITAL 9TO AN 5TITY1 A MY/]I\S BE+ \TSIDE HUMAN BE+S1 :ILE ,I'M SIMPLY %[+ ?AT IT REALIZES A HUMAN PROJECT 7DOM9ATION OV] NATURE71 ?R\< ! PROCESS ( AN?ROPOMORPHOSIS4 ,!Y ALSO D5Y ?AT MY DESCRIPTION ( DEVELOPM5T IS CORRECT & RECALL :AT ,ELIADE SAID CONC]N+ ! CREATION ( AN >TI/IC UNIV]SE3 ?AT PEOPLE C\LD *ANGE A MOVEM5T2 ?AT !Y C\LD DIV]T :AT IS N[ MOV+ T[>D DE/RUCTION1 REIFICATION1 ETC444 ,!Y DON'T ACTUALLY RECOGNIZE ?AT SOON] OR LAT] !Y WILL BE R$UC$ TO SAY+ 0,I DIDN'T WANT ?AT0 LIKE ?OSE 9TELLECTUALS :O 9ITIALLY SUPPORT$ FASCISM4 ,IT'S UN=TUNATE ?AT1 IF TRU? IS AN UNVEIL+1 = MANY IT HAPP5S ONLY RETROSPECTIVELY4 ,NEV]!LESS1 EV5 ?IS RETROSPECT ALREADY DISPLAYS MANY FACETS ?AT ALL 9DICATE A S+LE REALITY4 ,EV5 ! BL9DE/ MU/ RECOGNIZE ?AT IT'S NECESS>Y TO AB&ON ?IS WORLD :I* IS SO CONG5IAL TO ! FUTURE CANC]1 ! 9EVITABLE PROMISE ( ABOM9ABLE EV5TS4 

7,M>*1 #a#i#g#g7 

.<#a.> ,= EXAMPLE1 IT W\LD CLE>LY BE NECESS>Y TO /UDY ,BEAUB\RG'S IMPORTANCE ) REG>D TO ! ORGANIZATION ( SPACE & URBANIZATION 7I4E41 ! M9]ALIZATION ( ORGANIC NATURE74 ,NOR AM ,I CONSID]+ SIMIL> PH5OM5A ALREADY UND] WAY 9 O!R C\NTRIES1 ESPECIALLY ! ,U4,S4,A4 

.<#b.> ,SEE ,LE ,GE/E ET ,LA ,P>OLE 7#a#i#f#d74 ,NO P>TICUL> PASSAGE IS CIT$ S9CE ! 5TIRE BOOK MU/ BE NOT ONLY READ BUT /UDI$4 

.<#c.> ,!SE T]MS >E US$ = SIMPLIFICATION & TO AVOID LONG !ORETICAL DIGRESSIONS ON ! NATURE ( ! HUMAN GR\P+S 9 ! ,GREECE ( ,AES*YLUS & ,EURIPIDES4 

.<#d.> ,?IS /ATEM5T %\LD BE TEMP]$ BY CONSID]ATION ( ! ,AN>*I/ MOVEM5T AT ! TURN ( ! C5TURY1 :I*1 9 ITS T]RORI/ & NEGATIONI/ T5D5CIES1 DECL>$ ! WI% TO SPE$ UP ?IS 5D1 AVOID DECOMPOSITION1 DRAG ! MASSES FROM ! LI/LESSNESS 9DUC$ BY DEMOCRACY1 & BUILD AFRE%4 

.<#e.> ,SEE ,ASPECTS DU ,MY! 7#a#i#f#b1 PP4 #i#c-#i#d74 

.<#f.> ,SEE ,CAILLOIX'S 0,PICASSO ! ,LIQUIDATOR0 _<,LE ,MONDE1 #b#h_/#a#a_/#g#e_> & ! 5SU+ POLEMICS4 

.<#g.> ,NEV]!LESS1 CAN'T !Y BE SAID TO BE MORE S5SITIVE TO HUMAN PA?OLOGY1 9 ! S5SE ?AT !Y'VE HAD A MORE %OCK+ GLIMPSE ( ! RESULT ( ! W&]+8 

.<#h.> ,ELIADE WAS F> AHEAD 9 REPORT+ A DISCOV]Y ANN\NC$ BY ,ATTALI 9 0,NOISE03 ?AT MUSIC ANTICIPATES SOCIAL DEVELOPM5T4 ,& :AT GOES = MUSIC GOES = ALL ! >TS4 ,?AT'S A COMMONPLACE4 ,ITS 9T]E/ IS ?AT ,ATTALI MAKES HIMSELF ! RECUP]ATOR ( ITS 0NOISE0 & POSES AS M$IATOR ( CAPITAL4 ,:AT'S HE ACTUALLY TELL+ US8  
 0,A NEW !ORY ( P[] & A NEW POLITICS >E NE$$4 ,BO? REQUIRE ! ELABORATION ( A POLITICS ( NOISE &1 MORE SUBTLY1 AN EXPLOSION 9 ! CAPACITY TO CREATE ORD] />T+ FROM EA* 9DIVIDUAL'S NOISE1 BEYOND ! *ANNEL+ ( PLEASURE 9TO ! NORM40  
 ,= HIM1 IT'S A MATT] ( LI/5+ - AS IS ! CASE = ! CURR5T ECOLOGICAL DEM&S - 9 ORD] TO RECUP]ATE ! V>I\S 0NOISES0 TO 5SURE ! SURVIVAL ( !ORY1 P[]1 & POLITICS4 ,IT'S WORRY+ ?AT1 TO ALL[ SCI5TIFIC COMP>ISON1 HE /ILL WANTS TO R$UCE US444 TO NOISES6 

.<#i.> ,IT %\LDN'T BE =GOTT5 ?AT ,WE/]N >T ACCOMPLI%$ ?IS DE/RUCTION-CREATION BY PLUND]+ SO-CALL$ 0PRIMITIVE0 PEOPLES3 ,AM]ICAN ,9DIANS & ,AFRICANS4 ,?IS IS ANO!R ASPECT ( CAPITAL'S 0REJUV5ATION0 :I* ,I DESCRIB$ 9 ,9V>IANCE ,VOL4 #b ,NO4 #f 9 0,WORK+ ,!SES ON ,COMMUNI/ ,REVOLUTION40 

.<#a.> ,LET US ADD ?AT ! M$IATION ( P$AGOGY & E?OLOGY MEANS ?AT ! WORLD ( *ILDHOOD & E>LY MOM5TS 9 ! LIFE ( \R SPECIES >E ALSO AFFECT$4 ,9 P>TICUL>1 ) REG>D TO *ILDHOOD1 IT HAS ALL[$ ! CREATION ( AN 9DU/RY ( PLAY?+S & PRODUCTS 0SPECIFIC0 TO *ILDR51 :O W]E EXCLUD$ FROM !IR LIFE & CREATION4 ,! MOM5T :5 0,HOMO ,LUD5S0 7,HUIZ+A7 IS DISCOV]$ IS ?AT :5 HUMANS >E 9CREAS+LY ROBB$ ( PLAY4 

.<#a#a.> ,BY SIMULTANE\SLY 9CORPORAT+ MUSEUM & EXP]IM5TAL C5T]1 ,BEAUB\RG REALIZES ONE ( ,T(FL]'S PROJECTS3 ! E/ABLI%M5T ( PA/ COMMUNITIES TO ALL[ ?OSE UNABLE TO FOLL[ P[]'S RHY?M TO GET !IR BE>+S1 & FUTURE COMMUNITIES = ?OSE LIV+ ONLY ?R\< ANTICIPATION 7SEE ,FUTURE ,%OCK74  
 ,! 9CORPORATION ( A ,C5T] ( ,CONTEMPOR>Y ,>*ITECTURE PLAGI>IZES ,VOY]'S 0,9/ITUTE ( ,CONTEMPOR>Y ,PREHI/ORY40 ,BRIEFLY1 ! PRES5CE ( EXP]IM5TAL C5T]S 9DICATES A WI% TO FUZE SCI5CE & >T4 ,MORE PRECISELY1 :AT IS SE5 H]E RE9=CES AN ALREADY DI/9CT PHILOSOPHICAL T5D5CY3 ! LOSS ( AUTONOMY4 ,>T & PHILOSOPHY FOLL[ 9 SCI5CE'S WAKE 9 ORD] TO PRODUCE SOME?+4 ,!Y BECOME COMM5T>IES ON SCI5CE1 H]M5EUTICS4 

.<#a#b.> ,SEE 0,PICASSO ! ,LIQUIDATOR10 AN >TICLE TO :I* ,I WILL RETURN LAT]4 

.<#a#c.> ,LAT] IT WILL BE NECESS>Y TO 9VE/IGATE FA%ION & ADV]TIS+1 CONSID]+ !M AS =MS = CREAT+ & REPRES5T+ ! WORLD ( CAPITAL4 

.<#a#d.> ,! TITLE ( AN >TICLE BY ,BORDIGA1 9 :I* HE %[$ ?AT CAPITAL CAN ONLY REG5]ATE ITSELF BY DE/ROY+ ALL DEAD1 ACCUMULAT$ LABOR :I* IMP$ES ITS PROCESS ( VALORIZATION- CAPITALIZATION4 

.<#a#e.> ,SEE ,9V>IANCE4 ,VOL4 #b ,NO4 #f3 0,H]E IS ! FE>1 JUMP H]E40 

.<#a#f.> ,ONE ?US GOES BEYOND AB/RACT >T1 ! MOM5T ( 9TUITION ( ! BASIC ELEM5TS ( ! COMMUNITY ( CAPITAL1 :I* HAD H>DLY YET APPE>$4 ,?IS CAN N[ BE REPRES5T$ 9 ITS TOTALITY1 SO REALISM IS POSSIBLE4 ,?IS %[S ! EXT5T TO :I* ,SOCIALI/ ,REALISM IS B\ND TO AN IDEOLOGICAL P]SPECTIVE & NOT TO A SOCIAL MOVEM5T4 ,! ,SOVIET LEAD]S DON'T REALIZE TO :AT EXT5T AB/RACT >T 7AS WELL AS O!R REC5T ,WE/]N >T7 REPRES5TS A REALITY4 ,!IR FE> ( ?IS K9D ( >T IS ACTUALLY A FE> ( ! SUBV]SIVE 9 CAPITAL1 ?AT 0,EV]Y?+ IS POSSIBLE10 :I* C\LD BE EASILY DIV]T$ 9 A SOCIETY 9 :I* ! CAPITALI/ MODE ( PRODUCTION HAS GREAT DIFFICULTY IMPLANT+ ITSELF4 ,SO ! ,SOVIETS >E CONDEMN$ TO UND]/& ONLY ! DESPOTISM ( CAPITAL1 )\T EV] 05JOY+0 ITS REVOLUTION>Y LIB]AT+ ASPECT4 ,?IS EXPLA9S ! PRO-,WE/]N VIEWS ( ELEM5TS 9 ! PRES5T-DAY ,U,S,S,R 09TELLIG5TSIA40  
 ,L]OI-,G\RHAN'S /ATEM5T CONC]N+ FIGURATION1 V]Y CLE> 9 ! ,U,S,S,R1 IS ALSO VITAL4 ,I'M DRAW+ ATT5TION TO IT1 & WILL EV5TUALLY RETURN TO IT1 S9CE IT CONC]NS ! SPECIFICITY ( ! :OLE HUMAN PH5OM5ON1 & ! BIOLOGICAL MADNESS AFFLICT+ HUMANITY 9 P>TICUL>3  
 0,! CRISIS ( ,FIGURATION IS ! COROLL>Y ( ! MA/]Y ( MA*9ISM4444 ,IT'S P>TICUL>LY /RIK+ TO OBS]VE ?AT1 9 SOCIETIES EXCLUD+ ,SCI5CE & ,WORK FROM ! METAPHYSICAL PLANE1 ! GREATE/ EF=TS >E MADE TO SAVE FIGURALISM4444 ,9 FACT IT SEEMS ?AT AN EQUILIBRIUM AS CON/ANT AS ?AT CO-COORD9AT+ ! ROLES ( FIGURATION & TE*NIQUE CANNOT BE DE/ROY$ )\T PUTT+ ! V]Y S5SE ( ! HUMAN ADV5TURE 9TO QUE/ION40  
 ,A SIMPLE REM>K3 AS ,I SUGGE/$ ABOVE1 CAPITAL C\LD V]Y WELL RE9TRODUCE FIGURALISM4 ,BUT1 AGA91 IT'S NO LONG] >T AS HUMAN REF]5T 7NOR HAS IT BE5 SO = SOME TIME7 BUT ! >T ( CAPITAL4 

.<#a#g.> ,ON ?IS SUBJECT1 ,I CAN BUT RAISE A MATT] ( GREAT !ORETICAL & HI/ORICAL BREAD?3 ?AT ( ! CONT9UAL DEGRADATION1 ! REIFICATION-EXTRANEIZATION L9K$ ) ! MASSIFICATION-DEMOCRATIZATION TAK+ PLACE D[N ! MILL5NIA4 ,PROGRESS IS (T5 JU/IFI$ BY SAY+ ?AT IT GAVE SOME?+ =M]LY RE/RICT$ TO A LIMIT$ CIRCLE ( 9DIVIDUALS TO EV]-9CREAS+ NUMB]S ( PEOPLE4 ,9 SAY+ ?IS1 :AT IS =GOTT5 IS ! COMPLEM5T>Y PROCESS ( LOSS ( ! SACR$1 NATURE1 & HUMANITY 7E4G41 9 ! S5SE ( AN >T ( LIFE 9 SOCIETY SU* AS ?AT 9 ! EI<TE5? C5TURY7 LEAD+ TO DESUB/ANTIALIZATION ( HUMAN BE+S & !IR R$UCTION TO TRANSI5T1 9SIGNIFICANT BE+S4 ,IT'S ! UND5IABLE EXI/5CE ( ?IS PROCESS ?AT EXPLA9S ! PREGNANCY ( ! >I/OCRATIC CRITIQUE & A C]TA9 =M ( >T1 AS WELL AS ! ,NAZI LUCUBRATIONS4  
 ,LET US ALSO ADD ?AT ! HOPE ?AT 0! MASSES W\LD HAVE TO ORGANIZE ! WORLD DIFF]5TLY0 WAS L>GELY DISAPPO9T$1 & ?AT ?IS DRAWS US TO ! QUE/ION ( ! PROLET>IAT'S HI/ORIC MISSION & ! ILLUSION ?AT ?IS CLASS C\LD DIV]T ! DEVELOPM5T ( PRODUCTIVE =CES 9 A HUMAN WAY4 ,!SE MASSES HAV5'T BE5 ABLE TO ORGANIZE3 CAPITAL DID IT 9/EAD & ORGANIZ$ !M AT ! SAME TIME4 ,SO ! SOLUTION NO LONG] LIES 9 ELITES OR MASSES6 

.<#a#h.> ,CAPITAL MU/ PROVOKE & RE9V5T REVOLT1 !RE=E ORGANIZE IT1 & P]FECTLY REALIZE ! SPECTACLE AS DESCRIB$ BY ! ,SITUATIONI/ ,9T]NATIONAL4 ,! SEP>ATION BETWE5 ACTORS & SPECTATORS T5DS TO DISAPPE>1 BECAUSE ! SPECTACLE MU/ BE WORK$ BY ALL HUMAN BE+S SET 9 MOTION BY SOME 0MA/] ILLUSIONI/S0 7,L]OI-,G\RHAN1 ,LE ,GE/E ET LA ,P>OLE71 M$IATORS ( CAPITAL4 

,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #aiif 3 ,BEAUB\RG3 ,FUTURE ,CANC]8 -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,APRIL #b#a1 #bb 3 ,BEAUB\RG3 ,FUTURE ,CANC]8 -- ,ADD$4 
,JANU>Y #d1 #bbb 3 ,BEAUB\RG3 ,FUTURE ,CANC]8 -- ,UPDAT$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/