,P>T #b3 ,M>XISM - ,*APT] #f 

#aiaaaiaa 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,GU/AV ,L&AU] 

,TEXT 3 

#f 

  

,IT WAS A MEMORABLE MOM5T 9 ! HI/ORY ( \R ]A1 :5 ,PI]RE ,JOSEPH ,PR\DHON1 AFT] ! ,FR5* ,FEBRU>Y REVOLUTION ( ! YE> #a#h#d#h1 TOLD HIS PEOPLE :AT IT HAD TO DO TO E/ABLI% A SOCIETY ( JU/ICE & FRE$OM4 ,HE WAS /ILL LIV+1 LIKE ALL HIS REVOLUTION>Y COMPATROITS ( ! TIME1 COMPLETELY 9 ! TRADITION ( ! REVOLUTION :I* HAD ]UPT$ EXT]NALLY 9 #a<i & HAD1 AS WAS !N FELT1 BE5 NIPP$ 9 ! BUD BY ! C\NT]REVOLUTION & SUBSEQU5T GOV]NM5TS4 ,HE SAID3 ,! REVOLUTION PUT AN 5D TO FEUDALISM4 ,SOME?+ NEW MU/ REPLACE IT4 ,FEUDALISM WAS AN ORD] 9 ! >EA ( ! ECONOMY ( ! ,/ATE1 IT WAS AN >TICULAT$1 MILIT>Y SY/EM ( DEP5D5CIES4 ,= C5TURIES IT HAD BE5 UND]M9$ BY FRE$OMS2 CIVIL LIB]TIES HAD GA9$ MORE & MORE GR\ND4 ,H[EV]1 !Y ALSO DE/ROY$ ! OLD ORD] & SECURITY1 ! OLD ASSOCIATIONS & LEAGUES4 ,A FEW M5 BECAME RI* UND] ! NEW FRE$OM & MOBILITY1 :ILE ! MASSES W]E EXPOS$ TO H>D%IP & 9SECURITY4 ,H[ CAN WE BO? PRES]VE1 EXT5D & CREATE FRE$OM = ALL1 AS WELL AS BR+ AB\T SECURITY1 ! GREAT EQUALIZATION ( PROP]TY & CONDITIONS ( LIFE1 ! NEW ORD]8 

,! REVOLUTION>IES1 HE SAYS1 DO NOT YET KN[ ?AT ! REVOLUTION WILL PUT AN 5D TO MILIT>ISM1 I4E41 TO ! GOV]NM5T2 ?AT ITS TASK IS TO REPLACE POLITICS BY SOCIAL LIFE1 POLITICAL C5TRALISM BY A DIRECT UNITY ( ECONOMIC 9T]E/S1 AN ECONOMIC C5T] :I* DOES NOT RULE OV] P]SONS1 BUT TAKES C>E ( BUS9ESS4 

,Y\ ,FR5*M51 HE SAYS1 >E SMALL & M$IUM-SIZ$ F>M]S1 SMALL & M$IUM-SIZ$ CRAFTSM52 Y\ >E ACTIVE 9 AGRICULTURE1 9DU/RY1 TRANSPORTATION & COMMUNICATIONS4 ,UNTIL N[ Y\ NE$$ K+S & !IR (FICIALS 9 ORD] TO COME TOGE!R & PROTECT Y\RSELVES ONE FROM ! O!R4 ,9 #agic Y\ ABOLI%$ ! K+ ( ! /ATE1 BUT Y\ RETA9$ ! K+ ( ! ECONOMY1 GOLD4 ,BECAUSE Y\ ?US LEFT MIS=TUNE1 DISORD] & 9SECURITY 9 ! C\NTRY1 Y\ HAD TO LET ! K+S & (FICIALS & >MIES RETURN4 ,DO AWAY ) ! AU?ORIT>IAN 9T]M$I>IES4 ,ABOLI% ! P>ASITES4 ,SEE TO ! DIRECT UNITY ( Y\R 9T]E/S4 ,!N Y\ WILL HAVE SOCIETY AS ! HEIR TO FEUDALISM & ! /ATE4 

,:AT IS GOLD8 ,:AT IS CAPITAL8 ,IT IS NOT A ?+ LIKE A %OE OR A TABLE OR A H\SE4 ,IT IS NOT A ?+1 IT IS NO?+ REAL4 ,GOLD IS ! SIGN = A RELATION%IP4 ,CAPITAL IS SOME?+ ?AT GOES BACK & =? AS A RELATION%IP BETWE5 M54 ,IT IS SOME?+ BETWE5 M54 ,CAPITAL IS CR$IT1 CR$IT IS MUTUALITY ( 9T]E/S4 ,Y\ >E N[ 9 ! REVOLUTION4 ,! REVOLUTION -- 5?USIASM1 A SPIRIT ( TRU/1 ! EXUB]ANCE ( EQUALIZATION1 ! DESIRE TO GO = ! :OLE -- HAS COME OV] Y\1 HAS >IS5 AMONG Y\3 CREATE = Y\RSELVES DIRECT MUTUALITY4 ,SET UP AN 9/ITUTION :]EBY Y\ COME TO ONE ANO!R ) ! PRODUCTION ( Y\R WORK )\T ANY P>ASITIC1 VAMPIRE-LIKE 9T]M$I>IES4 ,!N Y\ WILL NE$ NO TUTEL>Y AU?ORITY1 NOR ! TRANSF] ( ! ABSOLUTE P[] ( ! POLITICAL GOV]NM5T TO ECONOMIC LIFE1 ( :I* ! NEWE/ BUNGL]S1 ! ,COMMUNI/S1 SPEAK4 ,! TASK IS3 TO ASS]T & CREATE FRE$OM 9 ! ECONOMY & PUBLIC LIFE & TO SEE TO AN EQUALIZATION TO ABOLI% H>D%IP1 9SECURITY1 & PROP]TY1 :I* IS NOT ! [N]%IP ( ?+S BUT ! DOM9ATION ( M5 & SLAVE-[N]%IP1 & 9T]E/1 :I* IS USURY4 ,CREATE AN EX*ANGE BANK6 

,:AT IS AN EX*ANGE BANK8 ,NO?+ BUT ! EXT]NAL =M1 ! OBJECTIVE 9/ITUTION = FRE$OM & EQUALITY4 ,:OEV] IS 5GAG$ 9 USEFUL WORK -- ! F>M]1 ! CRAFTSMAN1 ! WORK]S ASSOCIATION- %\LD ALL SIMPLY CONT9UE TO WORK4 ,WORK NE$ NOT BE ORGANIZ$1 I4E41 COMM&$ BY ! AU?ORITIES1 OR NATIONALIZ$4 ,CAB9ETMAK]1 MAKE FURNITURE2 %OEMAK]1 MAKE BOOTS2 BAK]1 BAKE BREAD2 & SO ON1 9 ! PRODUCTION ( EV]Y?+ ! PEOPLE NE$S4 ,CAB9ETMAK]1 Y\ HAVE NO BREAD8 ,( C\RSE Y\ CANNOT GO TO ! BAK] & (F] HIM *AIRS & CAB9ETS HE DOES NOT NE$4 ,GO TO ! EX*ANGE BANK & HAVE Y\R ORD]S & Y\R PRODUCTS BE *ANG$ 9TO UNIV]SALLY VALID *ECKS4 ,PROLET>IANS1 Y\ WANT NO LONG] TO GO TO ! 5TREPR5EUR 9 ORD] TO WORK = WAGES8 ,Y\ WANT TO BE 9DEP5D5T8 ,BUT Y\ HAVE NO WORK%OP1 NO TOOLS1 NO FOOD8 ,Y\ CANNOT WAIT & Y\ MU/ HIRE Y\RSELF \T RI<T AWAY8 ,BUT DON'T Y\ HAVE CU/OM]S8 ,DON'T ! O!R PROLET>IANS1 DON'T Y\ PROLET>IANS1 ONE & ALL1 PREF] TO PUR*ASE Y\R PRODUCTS FROM ONE ANO!R1 )\T 9T]M$I>Y ( ! EXPLOITATORY MIDDLE-M58 ,!N SEE TO Y\R [N PUR*ASES & SALES1 Y\ DOLTS6 ,! CLI5TELE IS VALID4 ,! CLI5TELE IS MONEY1 AS ?AT IS CALL$ TODAY4 ,MU/ ! SEQU5CE ALWAYS BE3 POV]TY -- SLAV]Y -- WORK -- PRODUCT8 ,MUTUALITY *ANGES ! C\RSE ( ?+S4 ,MUTUALITY RE/ORES ! ORD] ( NATURE4 ,MUTUALITY ABOLI%ES ! RULE ( MONEY4 ,MUTUALITY IS PRIM>Y3 ! SPIRIT BETWE5 M5 ?AT ALL[S ALL M5 :O WANT TO WORK TO DO SO & TO SATISFY !IR NE$S4 

,SEEK NO GUILTY ONES1 HE SAYS1 ALL >E GUILTY4 ,SOME 5?RALL$1 & O!RS TAKE AWAY ! MO/ BASIC NECESSITIES OR LEAVE ONLY ! B>E/ NECESSITY1 OR S]VE ! 5SLAV+ LORDS AS AG5TS & SUP]VIS]S4 ,NOT FROM ! SPIRIT ( REV5GE1 ANG] OR DE/RUCTIV5ESS WILL ! NEW BE CREAT$4 ,DE/RUCTION MU/ BE DONE \T ( A CON/RUCTIVE SPIRIT4 ,REVOLUTION & CONS]VATION >E NOT MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE4 

,/OP COPY+ ! ANCI5T ,ROMANS4 ,! ,JACOBITE DICTATOR%IP PLAY$ ITS ROLE 9 ! PA/1 BUT ! GREAT !AT] ( ! TRIBUNES & ! BEAUTIFUL GE/URE DOES NOT CREATE Y\R SOCIETY4 ,IT MU/ BE C>RI$ \T 9 REALITY4 ,Y\ MAKE USEFUL OBJECTS 9 SUFFICI5T QUANTITY2 Y\ W\LD LIKE TO CONSUME USEFUL ?+S 9 JU/ DI/RIBUTION2 SO Y\ MU/ EX*ANGE CORRECTLY4 

,!RE IS NO VALUE1 HE SAYS1 ?AT IS NOT CREAT$ BY WORK2 ! WORK]S HAVE CREAT$ ! SUP]IORITY ( ! CAPITALI/S1 & Y\ HAVE NOT BE5 ABLE TO KEEP & USE ! VALUES Y\ CREATE BECAUSE Y\ >E ISOLAT$ & PROP]TYLESS M5 :O 9CREASE ! WEAL? ( ! [N]S & !REBY PROVIDE !M ) P[] OV] SLAVES & PROP]TY4 ,BUT H[ *ILDI% IT IS1 HE C\LD SAY1 !RE=E ONLY TO />E AT ! PRES5T /OCKPILE ( ACCUMULAT$ PROP]TY 9 ! H&S ( ! PRIVILEG$ & TO ?9K ONLY ( TAK+ IT AWAY FROM !M BY POLITICAL OR VIOL5T ME?ODS4 ,IT IS ALWAYS 9 FLUX1 ALWAYS 9 CIRCULATION4 ,TODAY IT FL[S FROM ! CAPITALI/ VIA ! WORK]S AS CONSUM]S BACK TO ! CAPITALI/2 SET UP NEW 9/ITUTIONS BY TRANS=M+ Y\R MUTUAL BEHAVIOR SO ?AT IT WILL GO FROM ! CAPITALI/ TO ! CONSUM+ WORK]S1 BUT FROM !M NOT BACK TO ! CAPITALI/S1 BUT 9TO ! H&S ( ! SAME WORK]S1 ! PRODUC+ WORK]S4 

,) 9COMP>ABLE P[]1 ) A GREAT COMB9ATION ( SOBRIETY & W>M?1 ( PASSION & OBJECTIVITY1 ,PR\DHON SAID ?IS TO HIS PEOPLE4 ,9 ! MOM5T ( REVOLUTION1 DISSOLUTION1 TRANSITION & ! POSSIBILITY ( COMPREH5SIVE & FUNDAM5TAL MEASURES1 HE PROPOS$ ! 9DIVIDUAL /EPS & DECREES ?AT W\LD HAVE CREAT$ ! NEW SOCIETY & W\LD HAVE BE5 ! LA/ ACT ( ! GOV]NM5T1 & MADE ?AT GOV]NM5T REALLY :AT IT WAS CALL$3 A PROVISIONAL GOV]NM5T4 

,! VOICE WAS !RE1 BUT ! LI/5]S W]E MISS+4 ,! RI<T TIME WAS !RE BUT IT PASS$1 & N[ IT IS GONE =EV]4 

,PR\DHON ! MAN KNEW :AT WE SOCIALI/S HAVE RE-DISCOV]$3 SOCIALISM IS POSSIBLE AT ALL TIMES & IMPOSSIBLE AT ALL TIMES4 ,IT IS POSSIBLE :5 ! RI<T M5 >E !RE :O WANT IT1 I4E41 :O C>RY IT 9TO ACTION1 & IT IS IMPOSSIBLE :5 M5 DO NOT WANT IT OR ONLY SUPPOS$LY WANT IT BUT CANNOT ACT ACCORD+LY4 ,SO ?IS MAN WAS NOT HE>D4 ,M5 HE>D 9/EAD ANO!R VOICE :I* PRES5T$ ! FALSE SCI5CE WE HAVE EXAM9$ & REJECT$1 :I* TAU<T ?AT SOCIALISM IS ! CR[N+ ( ! CAPITALI/ BIG 9DU/RY2 ?AT IT COMES ONLY :5 V]Y FEW CAPITALI/S HAVE PRIVATE [N]%IP ( 9/ITUTIONS ?AT HAVE ALREADY ALMO/ BECOME SOCIALI/ SO ?AT IT W\LD BE EASY = ! UNIT$ PROLET>IAN MASSES TO TRANSF] IT FROM PRIVATE [N]%IP TO SOCIAL [N]%IP4 

,9/EAD ( ,PI]RE ,JOSEPH ,PR\DHON1 ! MAN ( SYN!SIS1 ,K>L ,M>X1 ! MAN ( ANALYSIS1 WAS HE>D & SO ! DISSOLUTION1 DECAY & DECL9E WAS ALL[$ TO CONT9UE4 

,M>X1 ! MAN ( ANALYSIS1 WORK$ ) FIX$1 RIGID CONCEPTS IMPRISON$ 9 !IR WORD-CAS+S4 ,) !SE CONCEPTS HE WANT$ TO EXPRESS & ALMO/ DICTATE ! LAWS ( DEVELOPM5T4 

,PR\DHON1 ! MAN ( SYN!SIS1 TAU<T US ?AT ! CLOS$ CONCEPTUAL WORDS >E ONLY SYMBOLS = 9CESSANT MOVEM5T4 ,HE DISSOLV$ CONCEPTS 9 /REAM+ CONT9UITY4 

,M>X1 ! MAN ( APP>5TLY /RICT SCI5CE1 WAS ! LEGISLATOR & DICTATOR ( DEVELOPM5T4 ,HE MADE PRON\NCEM5TS ON IT2 & AS HE DET]M9$ IT1 SO IT %\LD BE ONCE & = ALL4 ,EV5TS W]E TO BEHAVE LIKE A F9I%$1 CLOS$1 DEAD REALITY4 ,!RE=E ,M>XISM EXI/S AS A DOCTR9E & ALMO/ A DOGMA4 

,PR\DHON1 :O S\<T TO SOLVE NO PROBLEM ) ! ?+-WORDS1 :O 9/EAD ( CLOS$ ?+S POSIT$ MOVEM5TS1 & RELATIONS1 9/EAD ( APP>5T BE+1 BECOM+1 9/EAD ( CRUDE VISIBILITY1 AN 9VISIBLE FLUCTUATION1 :O F9ALLY -- 9 HIS MO/ MATURE WRIT+S -- TRANS=M$ ! SOCIAL ECONOMY 9TO PSY*OLOGY1 :ILE TRANS=M+ PSY*OLOGY FROM RIGID 9DIVIDUAL PSY*OLOGY1 :I* MAKES AN ISOLAT$ ?+ \T ( 9DIVIDUAL MAN1 9TO SOCIAL PSY*OLOGY1 :I* CONCEIVES ( MAN AS A MEMB] ( AN 9F9ITE1 9SEP>ABLE & 9EXPRESSIBLE /REAM ( BECOM+4 ,SO !RE IS NO ,PR\DHONISM1 BUT ONLY A ,PR\DHON4 ,SO :AT ,PR\DHON SAID ( TRU? = A C]TA9 MOM5T CAN NO LONG] APPLY TODAY1 :5 ?+S HAVE BE5 ALL[$ TO CONT9UE = DECADES4 ,VALID IS ONLY :AT IS ET]NAL 9 ,PR\DHON'S IDEAS2 NO ATTEMPT %\LD BE MADE TO RETURN SLAVI%LY TO HIM1 OR TO ANY PA/ HI/ORICAL MOM5T4 

,:AT ! ,M>XI/S HAVE SAID ( ,PR\DHON1 ?AT HIS SOCIALISM IS A SOCIALISM ( ! PETIT-B\RGEOIS & SMALL F>M]S1 IS1 LET US REPEAT IT1 COMPLETELY TRUE & IS HIS HI<E/ TITLE TO FAME4 ,HIS SOCIALISM1 9 O!R WORDS1 ( ! YE>S #ahdh TO #ahea WAS ! SOCIALISM ( ! ,FR5* PEOPLE 9 ! YE>S #ahdh TO #a#h#e#a4 ,IT WAS ! SOCIALISM ?AT WAS POSSIBLE & NECESS>Y AT ?AT MOM5T4 ,PR\DHON WAS NOT A ,UTOPIAN & A PROPHET2 NOT A ,F\RI] & NOT A ,M>X4 ,HE WAS A MAN ( ACTION & REALIZATION4 

,WE >E SPEAK+ H]E EXPRESSLY ( ,PR\DHON1 ! MAN ( #ahdh TO #a#h#e#a4 ,?IS MAN SAID1 & ! AGE WAS CON/ITUT$ = HIM TO SAY3 0,Y\ REVOLUTION>IES1 IF Y\ DO ?AT1 Y\ WILL A*IEVE ! GREAT TRANS=MATION40 

,! MAN ( LAT] YE>S1 FROM :OM WE HAVE AS MU* TO LE>N AS FROM ! ONE ( #a#h#d#h1 DID NOT LIKE TO REPEAT ! REVOLUTION>Y WORDS HE HAD SPOK5 AFT] ! REVOLUTION1 9 A VA9 MELODRAMATIC OR PORNOGRAPHIC SELF-IMITATION4 ,EV]Y?+ HAS ITS TIME1 & EV]Y TIME AFT] ! REVOLUTION IS A TIME BE=E ! REVOLUTION = ALL :OSE LIFE DID NOT /OP AT ! GREAT MOM5T ( ! PA/4 ,PR\DHON LIV$ ON1 ?\< HE BL$ FROM MANY W\NDS4 ,HE N[ ASK$ HIMSELF3 0,I SAID1 IF Y\ DO IT2 BUT :Y DIDN'T !Y DO IT80 ,HE F\ND ! ANSW] & HE WROTE IT D[N 9 HIS LAT] WORKS1 ! ANSW] ?AT 9 \R LANGUAGE IS3 BECAUSE ! SPIRIT WAS MISS+4 

,IT WAS MISS+ !N & IT HAS BE5 MISS+ = SIXTY YE>S & HAS BE5 LO/ & SUNK5 EV] DEEP]4 ,EV]Y?+ WE HAVE %[N TILL N[ CAN BE SUMM$ UP 9 ONE S5T5CE3 WAIT+ = ! SUPPOS$ RI<T MOM5T =ESE5 9 HI/ORY HAS PO/PON$ ?IS GOAL FUR!R & FUR!R & PU%$ IT 9TO BLURR$ D>KNESS2 TRU/ 9 PROGRESS & DEVELOPM5T WAS ! NAME ( REGRESSION & ?IS 0DEVELOPM5T0 ADAPT$ ! EXT]NAL & 9T]NAL CONDITIONS MORE & MORE TO DEGRADATION & MADE ! GREAT *ANGE EV] MORE REMOTE4 ,! ,M>XI/S WILL BE RI<T ) !IR 0,IT IS NOT YET TIME60 AS LONG AS M5 BELIEVE !M1 & !Y WILL NEV] BE LESS1 BUT ALWAYS MORE RI<T4 ,IS IT NOT ! MO/ FRI<TFUL MADNESS ?AT EV] LIV$ & HAPP5$1 ?AT A SAY+ IS TRUE1 BECAUSE IT WAS SPOK5 & HE>D CR$UL\SLY8 ,& MU/ NOT EV]YONE NOTICE ?AT ! ATTEMPT TO EXPRESS BECOM+ AS IF IT W]E F9AL1 COMPLET$ BE+1 IF IT W9S P[] OV] ! M9DS ( M51 MU/ ULTIMATELY CRIPPLE ! P[]S ( =M & CREATIVITY8 

,?AT IS ! REASON = \R UNTIR+ ATTACK ON ,M>XISM4 ,?AT IS :Y WE ALMO/ CANNOT LET IT GO & MU/ HATE IT ) ALL \R HE>T4 ,IT IS NOT A DESCRIPTION & A SCI5CE1 :I* IT PRET5DS TO BE1 BUT A NEGAT+1 DE/RUCTIVE & CRIPPL+ APPEAL TO IMPOT5CE1 LACK ( WILL1 SURR5D] & 9DIFF]5CE4 ,SOCIAL ,DEMOCRACY'S BEE-LIKE WORK ON DETAILS -- 9CID5TALLY ,SOCIAL ,DEMOCRACY IS NOT ,M>XISM -- IS ONLY ! O!R SIDE ( ?IS IMPOT5CE & ONLY EXPRESSES ?AT SOCIALISM IS NOT !RE3 = SOCIALISM 9 SMALL & GREAT MATT]S AIMS = ! :OLE4 ,NOT DETAIL$ WORK AS SU* IS TO BE REJECT$1 BUT ONLY H[ IT IS PRACTIC$1 DRIV5 AB\T 9 ! CIRCLE ( EXI/+ NONS5SE LIKE A DRY LEAF 9 A TORNADO4 

,! SO-CALL$ REVISIONI/S1 :O >E ESPECIALLY ZEAL\S AB\T DETAILS & :OSE CRITIQUE ( ,M>XISM (T5 CO9CIDES ) \RS -- NO WOND]1 !Y HAVE TAK5 IT 9 GREAT P>T FROM AN>*I/S1 FROM ,EUG5 ,DUHR+ & O!R 9DEP5D5T SOCIALI/S -- HAVE GRADUALLY FALL5 9 LOVE ) SOME?+ ?AT C\LD BE CALL$ TACTICS ( PR9CIPLE1 SO ?AT TOGE!R ) ,M>XISM !Y HAVE ALSO REJECT$ SOCIALISM ALMO/ D[N TO ! LA/ TRACE4 ,!Y >E 9 ! PROCESS ( F\ND+ A P>TY TO PROMOTE ! WORK+ CLASS 9 CAPITALI/ SOCIETY BY P>LIAM5T>Y & ECONOMIC MEANS4 ,! ,M>XI/S BELIEVE 9 PROGRESS A LA ,HEGEL1 :ILE ! REVISIONI/S >E ADH]5TS ( EVOLUTION A LA ,D>W94 ,!Y NO LONG] BELIEVE 9 CATA/ROPHE & SUDD5NESS2 CAPITALISM WILL NOT BECOME SOCIALISM BY A SUDD5 REVOLUTION1 !Y BELIEVE1 BUT IT WILL GRADUALLY ASSUME A MORE TOL]ABLE =M4 

,A FEW ( !M W\LD PREF] TO ADMIT ?AT !Y >E NOT SOCIALI/S1 & GO SURPRIS+LY F> 9 !IR ADAPTATION TO P>LIAM5T>ISM & P>TY POLITICS1 VOTE-GETT+ & MON>*ISM4 ,O!RS /ILL CONSID] !MSELVES COMPLETELY TO BE SOCIALI/S4 ,!Y BELIEVE !Y SEE A CON/ANT1 SL[1 BUT UNHALT+ IMPROVEM5T ( ! PRIVATE SITUATION ( ! WORK]S1 ( ! WORK]S' %>E 9 PRODUCTION BY SO-CALL$ 9DU/RIAL CON/ITUTIONALISM1 & ( PUBLIC & LEGAL CONDITIONS ?R\< ! EXPANSION ( DEMOCRATIC 9/ITUTIONS 9 ALL C\NTRIES4 ,FROM ! FAILURE ( ,M>XI/ DOCTR9E1 :I* !Y BO? RECOGNIZE & P>TIALLY CAUSE1 !Y DRAW ! CONCLUSION ?AT CAPITALISM IS ALREADY WELL ON ! WAY TO SOCIALISM & ?AT ! 5]GETIC PROMOTION ( ?IS DEVELOPM5T IS ! MISSION ( SOCIALI/S4 ,) ?IS VIEW !Y >E NOT SO V]Y F> FROM :AT ,M>XISM SAID FROM ! FIR/1 & ! SO-CALL$ RADICALS W]E ALWAYS ON ! SAME PA? & HAVE ONLY ! WI% ?AT ?IS VIEW NOT BE TOLD TO ! MASSES ( VOT]S :O HAVE BE5 :IPP$ UP TO & HELD TOGE!R BY REVOLUTION>ISM4 

,! TRUE RELATION ( ! ,M>XI/S TO ! REVISIONI/S IS AS FOLL[S3 ,M>X & ! BE/ ( HIS DISCIPLES HAD 9 M9D ! :OLE ( \R CONDITIONS 9 !IR HI/ORICAL CONTEXT & TRI$ TO >RANGE ! DETAILS ( \R SOCIAL LIFE UND] G5]AL CONCEPTS4 ,! REVISIONI/S >E EPIGONAL SKEPTICS :O SEE CLE>LY ?AT ! E/ABLI%$ G5]ALITIES DO NOT CO9CIDE ) ! NEWLY >IS5 REALITIES1 BUT :O /ILL HAVE ! NE$ = A NEW & ESS5TIALLY DIFF]5T TOTAL UND]/&+ ( \R TIME4 

,M>XISM HAD = A TIME L$ GREAT NUMB]S ( ! DIS9H]IT$ TO AW>5ESS ( !IR POV]TY1 DISSATISFACTION & AN IDEALI/IC MOOD FAVORABLE TO AN OV]ALL *ANGE4 ,?AT C\LD NOT LA/1 BECAUSE UND] ! 9FLU5CE ( ?IS SCI5TIFIC FOLLY ! MASSES %IFT$ TO WAIT+ & BECAME 9CAPABLE ( ANY SOCIALI/ ACTIVITY4 ,SO GRADUALLY DULLNESS & CALM W\LD HAVE LONG S9CE RETURN$ TO ! MASSES1 IF !Y HAD NOT BE5 CON/ANTLY SPURR$ ON BY POLITICAL & DEMAGOGICAL ME?ODS4 ,! REVISIONI/S N[ SEE ?AT ! V]Y WOR/ B>B>ITIES ( E>LY CAPITALISM HAVE BE5 REMOV$1 ?AT ! WORK]S HAVE GR[N MORE ACCU/OM$ TO PROLET>IAN CONDITIONS & ?AT CAPITALISM BY NO MEANS IS NE>+ ITS FALL4 ,9 ALL ?IS1 ( C\RSE1 WE SEE ! TREM5D\S DANG] ( ! CONT9UATION ( CAPITALISM4 ,9 TRU? ! SITUATION ( ! WORK+ CLASS -- AS SE5 AS A :OLE -- HAS NOT IMPROV$4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 LIFE HAS BECOME MORE DIFFICULT & UNPLEASANT4 ,IT HAS BECOME SO UNPLEASANT ?AT ! WORK]S HAVE BECOME JOYLESS1 HOPELESS & IMPOV]I%$ 9 SPIRIT & *>ACT]4 ,ABOVE ALL1 H[EV]1 ! /RUGGLE = SOCIALISM1 ! RI<T /RUGGLE1 DOES NOT H+E EXCLUSIVELY ON FEEL+S ( PITY OR PRIM>ILY ON ! FATE ( A C]TA9 CLASS ( M54 ,IT HAS TO DO ) A COMPLETE TRANS=MATION ( ! F\NDATIONS ( SOCIETY4 ,ITS GOAL IS A NEW CREATION4 

,\R WORK]S HAVE LO/ ?IS MOOD 7= IT WAS NEV] MORE ?AN A MOOD7 MORE & MORE1 BECAUSE 9 ,M>XISM ! ELEM5TS ( DISSOLUTION & IMPOT5CE W]E FROM ! FIR/ /RONG] ?AN ! =CES ( 9DIGNATION1 & LACK$ EV]Y POSITIVE CONT5T4 ,! PH5OM5ON ( REVISIONISM & ITS 9DULG5T SKEPTICISM IS ONLY ! 0IDEOLOGICAL SUP]/RUCTURE0 OV] ! 9ACTION1 9DECISION1 & COMPLAC5CY ( ! MASSES & %[S1 TO ALL :O ALREADY KNEW IT1 ?AT ! WORK+ =CE IS NOT ! *OS5 PEOPLE ( ,GOD1 ( DEVELOPM5T BY HI/ORICAL NECESSITY1 BUT RA!R ! P>T ( ! PEOPLE SUFF]+ MO/ SEV]ELY1 & BECAUSE ( PSY*IC *ANGES ?AT ACCOMPANY MIS]Y IT WILL F9D IT H>DE/ TO ACQUIRE KN[L$GE4 ,IT IS BE/ TO AVOID ALL G5]ALIZATIONS 9 ?IS >EA4 ,! WORK+ CLASS IS HI<LY DISP>ATE1 & SUFF]+ HAS ALWAYS HAD V]Y DIFF]5T EFFECTS ON V]Y DIFF]5T M54 ,BUT A MAJOR P>T ( SUFF]+ IS ! REALIZATION ( ONE'S BAD SITUATION2 & H[ MANY PROLET>IANS TO ?IS EXT5T UND]GO NOT ! LEA/ SUFF]+6 

,WE KN[ H[ ! RELATIONS HAVE *ANG$ 9 !SE TIMES AFT] ! REVOLUTION FAIL$1 9 !SE SIXTY YE>S BE=E ! REVOLUTION4 ,!SE W]E ! DECADES ( ADAPTATION ( CAPITALISM1 ( ADAPTATION TO PROLET>IZATION1 & IT IS TRULY AN ADAPTATION ?AT 9 MANY WAYS HAS ALREADY BECOME H]$IT>Y4 ,!RE IS A DET]IORATION ( ! RELATIONS BETWE5 M51 :I* HAS ALREADY NOTICEABLY BECOME A DECAY ( V]Y MANY BODIES ( 9DIVIDUAL M54 

,?AT IS A TREM5D\S DANG] WE >E SPEAK+ ( H]E4 ,WE HAVE SAID3 SOCIALISM DOES NOT HAVE TO COME1 AS ! ,M>XI/S ?9K4 ,N[ WE SAY3 ! MOM5T CAN COME1 IF ! V>I\S PEOPLES CONT9UE TO HESITATE1 ! TIME WILL COME :5 SOCIALISM WILL NO LONG] BE POSSIBLE = !M4 ,M5 MAY YET ACT SO FOOLI%LY1 SO BASELY T[>D ONE ANO!R4 ,!Y MAY SURR5D] SO UTT]LY TO 5SLAVEM5T & ACCEPT !IR [N BRUTALITY3 ALL ?AT IS SOME?+ BETWE5 M51 SOME?+ FUNCTIONAL & CAN BE *ANG$ 9 ! NEXT G5]ATION OR ALREADY = M5 N[ LIV+1 IF A DECISIVE1 VIBRANT EMOTION S]VES !M4 ,AS LONG AS IT IS A QUE/ION ( !SE SOCIAL OR1 AS !Y >E USUALLY CALL$1 PSY*OLOGICAL RELATIONS1 ! SITUATION IS NOT YET BAD4 ,MASS MIS]Y1 POV]TY1 HUNG]1 HOMELESSNESS1 PSY*OLOGICAL DEMORALIZATION & DEPRAVITY1 AS WELL AS PLEASURE-SEEK+1 /UPID LUXURY1 MILIT>ISM1 SPIRITLESSNESS -- ALL ?IS1 BAD AS IT IS1 CAN BE CUR$ IF ! RI<T DOCTOR COMES3 \T ( ! CREATIVE SPIRIT1 ! GREAT REVOLUTION & REG5]ATION4 ,H[EV]1 IF ALL ! H>D%IP & PRESSURE &1 UNSPIRIT CEASES TO BE SOME?+ BETWE5 M51 A DI/URBANCE ( !IR RELATION%IPS ?AT RESIDES 9 ! S\L1 IF IT IS NO LONG] A DI/URBANCE 9 ! COMPLEX ( RELATIONS BETWE5 M51 :I* WE CALL S\L1 IF 9/EAD *RONIC UND]N\RI%M5T1 ALCOHOLISM1 LONG-LA/+ BRUTALIZATION1 CONT9U\S DISSATISFACTION1 ACUTE SPIRITLESSNESS1 ) F>-REA*+ EFFECTS RESULT 9 *ANGES ( ! 9DIVIDUAL BODIES1 :OSE SIGNIFICANCE TO ! S\L & TO ! SOCIAL /RUCTURE IS AS ! SPID] TO ITS WEB1 !N NO REM$Y CAN HELP ANY MORE & IT MAY HAPP5 ?AT 5TIRE SECTIONS ( ! PEOPLE OR 5TIRE PEOPLES >E DAMN$ TO DE/RUCTION4 ,!Y P]I% AS PEOPLES HAVE ALWAYS P]I%$3 O!R1 HEAL?Y PEOPLES BECOME !IR MA/]S & A MIXTURE ( PEOPLES1 & SOMETIMES EV5 P>TIAL EXT]M9ATION TAKES PLACE -- IF1 AT LEA/1 O!R1 HEAL?Y PEOPLES /ILL EXI/4 ,ONE %\LD NOT PLAY FACILE GAMES ) ANALOGIES FROM E>LI] P]IODS ( ! HI/ORY ( NATIONS4 ,= :5 ! TIME COMES1 ?+S NE$ NOT AGA9 PROCE$ AS !Y DID 9 ! TIMES ( ! SO-CALL$ MIGRATION ( NATIONS4 ,WE >E LIV+ 9 TIMES ( ! BEG9N+ ( MANK9D1 & IT CANNOT BE COMPLETELY RUL$ \T ?AT ?IS 9CIPI5T MANK9D MI<T BE ! BEG9N+ ( ! 5D ( MANK9D4 ,P]HAPS NO AGE HAS EV] SE5 ! 5D ( ! WORLD LOOM+ SO DANG]\SLY BE=E ITS EYES1 AS \R DOES4 

,MANK9D1 9 ! S5SE ( A REAL COMPLEX ( RELATIONS1 A WORLD SOCIETY HELD TOGE!R BY EXT]NAL BONDS & AN 9N] ATTRACTION & URGE SURPASS+ NATIONAL B\NDS1 ( C\RSE DOES NOT YET EXI/4 ,SURROGATES = IT >E1 H[EV]1 !RE1 & !Y MAY BE MORE ?AN AN ]SATZ4 ,!Y C\LD BE ! BEG9N+3 ! WORLD M>KET1 9T]NATIONAL TREATIES OR GOV]NM5TAL POLICIES1 9T]NATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS & CONGRESSES ( ! MO/ MANIFOLD TYPES1 TRAFFIC & COMMUNICATIONS >\ND ! GLOBE1 ALL ?IS CREATES MORE & MORE1 IF NOT EQUALITY1 !N AT LEA/ AN ASSIMILATION ( 9T]E/S1 CU/OMS1 >T OR ITS MODI% SUB/ITUTE1 ! SPIRIT ( TE*NOLOGY1 ! POLITICAL =MS4 ,WORK]S >E ALSO BE+ L5T MORE & MORE FROM SOME NATIONS TO O!RS4 ,FUR!RMORE ALL SPIRITUAL REALITY -- RELIGION1 >T1 LANGUAGE1 COMMON SPIRIT 9 G5]AL -- IS D\BLY !RE OR SEEMS TO US DUPLICAT$ BY A NATURAL COMPULSION3 FIR/1 9 ! 9DIVIDUAL S\L AS A QUALITY OR FACULTY1 & SECONDLY1 \TSIDE1 AS SOME?+ 9T]WOV5 BETWE5 M5 & CREAT+ ORGANIZATIONS & ASSOCIATIONS4 ,ALL ?IS IS EXPRESS$ IMPRECISELY4 ,:AT CAN BE CORRECT$ 9 PASS+ WILL BE DONE IMM$IATELY1 BUT WE CANNOT AT ?IS TIME DESC5D TO ! V]Y BOTTOM ( !SE ABYSSES ( LANGUAGE CRITICISM & !ORY ( IDEAS 7! TWO ?+S BELONG TOGE!R74 ,ALL ?IS IS M]ELY M5TION$ 9 ORD] TO SAY3 HUMANITAS1 HUMANITE1 HUMANITY & MANK9D -- = :I* WE N[ SAY1 ) AN EXPRESSION ( FALSE PITY+ CONDESC5SION1 WEAK5$ & DEPRIV$ ( DEP?1 0HUMAN5ESS0 -- ALL !SE WORDS ORIG9ALLY REF]R$ ONLY TO ! MANK9D LIV+ & RUL+ 9 ! 9DIVIDUAL4 ,IT WAS ONCE V]Y /RONGLY PRES5T1 V]Y PHYSICALLY FELT1 AT LEA/ 9 ! HI< TIMES ( ,*RI/IANITY4 ,WE WILL >RIVE AT A REAL HUMANITY 9 ! EXT]NAL S5SE ONLY :5 RECIPROCITY AS ID5TICAL COMMUNITY HAS COME = ! HUMANITY CONC5TRAT$ 9 ! 9DIVIDUAL & ! HUMANITY GR[+ BETWE5 ! 9DIVIDUALS4 ,! PLANT DWELLS 9 ! SE$1 JU/ AS ! SE$ IS ONLY ! QU9TESS5CE ( ! 9F9ITE *A9 ( ANCE/RAL PLANTS4 ,MANK9D OBTA9S ITS G5U9E EXI/5CE FROM ! HUMANNESS ( ! 9DIVIDUAL1 JU/ AS ?IS HUMANNESS ( ! 9DIVIDUAL IS ONLY ! HEIR ( ! 9F9ITE G5]ATIONS ( ! PA/ & ALL !IR MUTUAL RELATION%IPS4 ,:AT HAS BECOME IS ! BECOM+1 ! MICROCOSM IS ! MACROCOSM4 ,! 9DIVIDUAL IS ! PEOPLE1 ! SPIRIT IS ! COMMUNITY1 ! IDEA IS ! BOND ( UNITY4 

,BUT = ! FIR/ TIME 9 ! HI/ORY ( ! FEW ?\S& YE>S ?AT WE KN[1 MANK9D WANTS TO BECOME EXT]NALLY UNIFI$ 9 ! COMPLETE S5SE & SCOPE4 ,! E>? HAS BE5 ALMO/ COMPLETELY EXPLOR$1 SOON IT WILL BE ALMO/ COMPLETELY 9HABIT$ & [N$4 ,:AT IS NE$$ N[ IS R5EWAL SU* AS NEV] EXI/$ BE=E 9 ! WORLD ( M5 WE KN[4 ,?AT IS ! DECISIVE TRAIT ( \R TIME1 ?IS NEW ?+ ?AT \<T TO OV]:ELM US F> MORE4 ,MANK9D ALL >\ND ! GLOBE WANTS TO BE CREAT$1 & WANTS ?IS AT A MOM5T :5 A MI<TY R5EWAL MU/ COME OV] MANK9D1 IF ! BEG9N+ ( A UNIFI$ MANK9D IS NOT TO BE ITS 5D4 ,=M]LY SU* R5EWAL WAS (T5 ID5TICAL ) ! NEW PEOPLES ?AT EM]G$ FROM RE/ & CULTURAL MIXTURE1 OR ) NEW C\NTRIES 9TO :I* MIGRATIONS TOOK PLACE4 ,! MORE SIMIL> ! PEOPLES BECOME TO ONE ANO!R1 ! MORE D5SELY C\NTRIES >E 9HABIT$1 ! LESS HOPE !RE IS = SU* R5EWAL FROM ! \TSIDE OR FROM )94 ,?OSE :O ALREADY WANT TO DESPAIR ( \R [N PEOPLES OR AT LEA/ BELIEVE ?AT ! EXT]NAL IMPULSE = ! RADICAL R5EWAL ( M9DS & VITAL 5]GY MU/ COME FROM ! \TSIDE1 FROM OLD PEOPLES :O HAVE REC5TLY AWAK5$ FROM A HEAL+ SLEEP1 CAN /ILL BUILD SOME HOPES ON ! ,*9ESE1 ,9DIAN OR MAYBE ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLES4 ,SOME CAN /ILL HOPE ?AT BEH9D ! PU]ILE ,NOR? ,AM]ICAN B>B>ITY !RE /ILL SLUMB]S P]HAPS A /ILL HIDD5 IDEALISM & SURPLUS 5]GY ( >D5T SPIRIT ?AT C\LD ]UPT M>VEL\SLY4 ,H[EV]1 IT IS CONCEIVABLE ?AT WE :O >E #d OR #e YE>S OLD WILL YET EXP]I5CE ! DISAPPO9TM5T ( !SE ROMANTIC EXPECTATIONS1 & ?AT ! ,*9ESE WILL FOLL[ ! ,JAPANESE 9 IMITAT+ ! ,WE/1 ?AT ! ,9DIANS WILL >ISE1 ONLY TO QUICKLY GLIDE 9TO ! *ANNELS ( DECAY1 ETC4 ,ASSIMILATION IS PROCE$+ V]Y RAPIDLY4 ,CIVILIZATION IS SPREAD+1 & ) IT A V]ITABLE PHYSICAL & PHYSIOLOGICAL DECAD5CE4 

,WE MU/ PLUNGE 9TO ?IS ABYSS 9 ORD] TO OBTA9 ! C\RAGE & URG5CY ?AT WE NE$4 ,?IS TIME ! R5EWAL MU/ BE GREAT] & DIFF]5T ?AN IT WAS 9 ANY KN[N TIMES4 ,WE >E NOT SEEK+ ONLY ! CULTURE & HUMAN BEAUTY ( LIFE TOGE!R4 ,WE >E SEEK+ A REM$Y2 WE >E SEEK+ SALVATION4 ,! GREATE/ EXT]IOR ?AT EV] EXI/$ ON E>? MU/ BE CREAT$ & IS ALREADY BE+ PREP>$ 9 PRIVILEG$ /RATA3 GLOBAL MANK9D4 ,YET IS CANNOT COME ?R\< EXT]NAL BONDS1 ?R\< TREATIES & A GOV]NM5TAL /RUCTURE OR A WORLD /ATE ( HORRID 9V5TION1 BUT ONLY BY WAY ( ! MO/ 9DIVIDUAL 9DIVIDUALISM & ! REE/ABLI%M5T ( ! SMALLE/ GR\PS3 ( ! COMMUNITIES1 ABOVE ALL4 ,A COMPREH5SIVE SOCIETY MU/ BE BUILT1 & ! CON/RUCTION MU/ BEG9 ON A SMALL SCALE2 WE MU/ EXT5D \RSELVES 9TO ALL LATITUDES & WE CAN DO IT ONLY IF WE DIG V]Y DEEP1 = NO HELP CAN COME ANY MORE FROM ! \TSIDE4 ,NO MORE UNOCCUPI$ L& 9VITES ! D5SELY CR[D$ PEOPLES TO SETTLE2 WE MU/ E/ABLI% MANK9D & CAN F9D IT ONLY 9 HUMANNESS4 ,WE CAN LET IT >ISE ONLY \T ( ! VOLUNT>Y BOND ( 9DIVIDUALS & \T ( ! COMMUNITY ( ORIG9ALLY 9DEP5D5T M5 :O >E NATURALLY DRAWN TO ONE ANO!R4 

,ONLY N[ CAN WE SOCIALI/S BREA! FREELY & ACCEPT ! 9ESCAPABLE H>D%IP1 \R TASK1 AS A PIECE ( \R EXI/5CE4 ,N[ WE FEEL ! LIV+ C]TA9TY ?AT \R IDEA IS NOT AN OP9ION :I* WE ADOPT BUT A MI<TY COMPULSION ?AT PLACES US BE=E ! *OICE3 EI!R TO EXP]I5CE ! REAL DE/RUCTION ( MANK9D 9 ADVANCE & TO WAT* ITS BEG9N+S ]OD+ >\ND US1 OR TO MAKE ! FIR/ BEG9N+ ( ! ASC5T ) \R [N ACTION4 

,! 5D ( ! WORLD1 :I* WE H]E ALL[ TO ?REAT5 AS A SPECT] ( POSSIBLE REALITY1 ( C\RSE DOES NOT MEAN SUDD5 EXT9CTION4 ,WE W>N AGA9/ ! ANALOGY & 9CL9ATION TO F9D AN 9VIOLABLE SORT ( RULE 9 IT1 BECAUSE WE KN[ ( A FEW TIMES ( DECL9E :I* W]E !N FOLL[$ BY GREAT P]IODS4 ,:5 WE VISUALIZE ) :AT UNP>ALLEL$ SPE$ ! NATIONS & !IR CLASSES >E BECOM+ MORE ALIKE 9 ?IS CAPITALI/ CIVILIZATION3 H[ ! PROLET>IANS >E BECOM+ DULL1 SUBMISSIVE1 CRUDE1 EXT]NAL1 & TO AN 9CREAS+ EXT5T1 ALCOHOLICS1 H[ TOGE!R ) !IR LOSS ( RELIGION !Y >E BEG9N+ TO LOSE EV]Y SORT ( 9T]NAL FEEL+ & RESPONSIBILITY1 H[ ALL ?IS IS BEG9N+ TO TAKE PHYSICAL EFFECT2 H[ ! UPP] CLASSES >E LOS+ ! P[] = POLITICS1 = A COMPREH5SIVE VIEW & DECISIVE ACTION1 H[ >T IS BE+ REPLAC$ BY FOPP]Y1 MODI% FRIPP]Y1 & >*AEOLOGICAL OR HI/ORICAL IMITATION1 H[ ) ! OLD RELIGION & MORALITY EV]Y FIRM /&>D1 EV]Y SACR$ ALLEGIANCE1 EV]Y FIRMNESS ( *>ACT] IS BE+ LO/1 H[ WOM5 >E BE+ DRAWN 9TO ! :IRLPOOL ( SUP]FICIAL S5SUALITY1 ( COLORFUL1 DECORATIVE LASCIVI\SNESS2 H[ ! NATURAL UNREFLECT$ POPULATION 9CREASE IS BEG9N+ TO DECL9E 9 ALL /RATA ( ! PEOPLE & BE+ REPLAC$ BY SEX )\T *ILDR5 UND] ! GUIDANCE ( SCI5CE & TE*NOLOGY2 H[ IRRESPONSIBILITY IS P]VAD+ PRECISELY ! BETT] ELEM5TS AMONG ! PROLET>IANS & CITIZ5S1 :O CAN NO LONG] BE> TO DO JOYLESS WORK UND] ! PREVAIL+ CONDITIONS4 ,IF WE SEE H[ ALL ?IS IS BEG9N+ TO TURN 9TO NEUROSIS & HY/]IA 9 ALL /RATA ( SOCIETY1 !N ONE MU/ ASK :]E ! PEOPLE IS ?AT WILL PULL ITSELF TOGE!R = RECOV]Y1 = ! CREATION ( NEW 9/ITUTIONS8 ,IS IT QUITE C]TA91 >E !RE UNMI/AKABLE SIGNS ?AT WE WILL RISE AGA91 AS =M]LY A NEW BEG9N+ CAME \T ( DECAY+ REF9$ CIVILIZATION & FRE% BLOOD8 ,IS IT C]TA9 ?AT MANK9D IS NOT A TEMPOR>Y1 9ACCURATE WORD = :AT WILL LAT] BE3 ! 5D ( NATIONS8 ,ALREADY ! VOICES ( DEG5]ATE1 UNRE/RA9$ & UPROOT$ FEMALES & !IR MALE CONSORTS >E PROCLAIM+ PROMISCUITY & SEEK+ TO REPLACE ! FAMILY ) ! PLEASURE ( V>IETY1 FREE1 UNRE/RA9$ UNION1 FA!RHOOD ) /ATE MO!RHOOD 9SURANCE4 ,! SPIRIT NE$S FRE$OM & CONTA9S IT4 ,:]E SPIRIT CREATES SU* UNIONS AS FAMILY1 COOP]ATIVE1 PR(ESSIONAL GR\P1 COMMUNITY & NATION1 !RE IS FRE$OM & MANK9D TOO CAN COME AB\T4 ,BUT DO WE KN[1 CAN WE BE SURE ?AT WE CAN 5DURE :AT N[ IS BEG9N+ TO RAGE 9/EAD ( ! SPIRIT MISS+ 9 ! CO]CIVE 9/ITUTIONS ( DOM9ATION ?AT HAVE REPLAC$ IT3 FRE$OM )\T SPIRIT1 S5SUAL FRE$OM1 FRE$OM TO IRRESPONSIBLE PLEASURE8 OR :E!R ! 9EVITABLE RESULT ( ALL ?IS WILL NOT BE ! MO/ GRUESOME TORM5TS & DESOLATION1 ! MO/ DECREPIT WEAKNESS & DULL APA?Y8 ,:E!R A MOM5T ( >D5T EMOTION1 ( REBIR?1 ( ! GREAT P]IOD ( ! F$]ATION ( CULTURAL COMMUNITIES WILL EV] COME TO US8 ,TIMES :5 SONG DWELLS OV] ! PEOPLE1 :5 T[]S BE> ! UNITY & 5?USIASM TO HEAV5 & GREAT WORKS >E CREAT$ TO REPRES5T ! PEOPLE'S GREATNESS BY T[]+ M5 9 :OSE SPIRIT ! PEOPLE IS CONC5TRAT$8 

,WE DO NOT KN[1 & !RE=E WE KN[ ?AT ! ATTEMPT IS \R TASK4 ,EV]Y ALLEG$ SCI5CE ( ! FUTURE HAS N[ BE5 SWEPT AWAY COMPLETELY4 ,NOT ONLY DO WE KN[ NO LAWS ( DEVELOPM5T4 ,WE EV5 KN[ ! MI<TY DANG] ?AT WE MAY BE TOO LATE ALREADY1 ?AT ALL \R ATTEMPTS & ACTIONS MAY P]HAPS NO LONG] HELP4 ,& SO WE HAVE CA/ (F ! LA/ BONDS FROM US1 9 ALL \R KN[L$GE1 WE KN[ NO?+ MORE4 ,WE /& LIKE PRIMITIVE M5 BE=E SOME?+ UNDESCRIB$ & 9DESCRIBABLE4 ,WE HAVE NO?+ BE=E US & EV]Y?+ ONLY 9 US3 9 US ! REALITY OR EFFICACY NOT ( FUTURE MANK9D1 BUT ( PA/ MANK9D :I* !RE=E EXI/S ESS5TIALLY 9 US4 ,! ACCOMPLI%M5T IS 9 US4 ,! UNDECEIVABLE DUTY ?AT S5DS US ON \R WAY IS 9 US4 ,! IMAGE ( :AT FULFILLM5T %\LD BECOME IS 9 US4 ,! NE$ TO LEAVE BAS5ESS & MIS]Y BEH9D IS 9 US4 ,JU/ICE ?AT IS )\T D\BT & REL5TLESS IS 9 US4 ,DEC5CY ?AT SEEKS MUTUAL RESPONSE IS 9 US1 & REASON ?AT RECOGNIZES ! 9T]E/S ( ALL4 

,?OSE :O FEEL AS IS H]E WRITT51 :OSE GREATE/ C\RAGE GR[S \T ( ! GREATE/ NE$1 :O WI% TO ATTEMPT ! R5EWAL DESPITE EV]Y?+ -- LET !M GA!R >\ND N[2 !Y >E ! ONES BE+ CALL$2 LET !M TELL ! NATIONS :AT MU/ BE DONE1 & %[ ! PEOPLES H[ TO BEG94 

,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #aia 3 ,P>T #b3 ,M>XISM - ,*APT] #f -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,JULY #a#c1 #bai 3 ,P>T #b3 ,M>XISM - ,*APT] #f -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/