,*UR* & ,/ATE 

#ahia 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,LEO ,TOL/OY 

,TAGS 3 DELUSION ( FAI?1 MEAN+ ( LIFE1 IDEA ( *UR*1 RELATION TO GOD1 DESIRE TO TEA*1 *UR* & /ATE1 MAN TO GOD1 DOCTR9E ( *RI/1 DELUSION ( *UR*1 MAJORITY ( *RI/IANS4 

,TEXT 3 

  

,PHOTO BY ,BOB1,C,C ,B,Y ,LIC5SE ,FAI? IS ?AT :I* 9VE/S LIFE ) MEAN+1 ?AT :I* GIVES /R5G? & DIRECTION TO LIFE4 

 ,EV]Y LIV+ MAN DISCOV]S ?IS MEAN+ & LIVES UPON IT4 

 ,HAV+ FAIL$ TO DISCOV] IT1 HE DIES4 

 ,9 HIS SE>*1 MAN AVAILS HIMSELF ( ALL ?AT HUMANITY HAS A*IEV$4 ,ALL ?AT HAS BE5 A*IEV$ BY HUMANITY IS CALL$ REVELATION4  

 ,REVELATION IS ?AT :I* HELPS MAN TO COMPREH5D ! MEAN+ ( LIFE4 

 ,SU* IS ! RELATION ( MAN TO FAI?4 
  

 ,:AT A WOND]FUL ?+1 !N6 ,M5 APPE>1 :O TOIL UNCEAS+LY TO MAKE O!R PEOPLE 5JOY JU/ ?IS & NO O!R =M OR REVELATION2 :O CANNOT RE/ UNTIL O!RS ACCEPT !IR1 JU/ !IR =M ( REVELATION1 & :O DAMN1 EXECUTE1 KILL1 AS MANY AS !Y CAN ( ! DISS5T]S4 ,O!RS DO ! SAME3 DAMN1 EXECUTE1 & KILL ONE ANO!R4  

 ,AT FIR/ IT WAS AMAZ+ TO ME H[ SU* AN EVID5T ABSURDITY1 SU* AN EVID5T CONTRADICTION1 FAIL$ TO DE/ROY FAI? ITSELF4  

 ,H[ C\LD !RE REMA9 PEOPLE :O BELIEV$ 9 ?IS DELUSION8  

 ,& 9DE$1 FROM A G5]AL PO9T ( VIEW1 ?IS IS 9CONCEIVABLE1 & IRRESI/IBLY PROVES ?AT EV]Y FAI? IS A LIE1 & ?AT ! :OLE ?+ IS SUP]/ITION -- :I* IS :AT ! REIGN+ PHILOSOPHY DOES PROVE4  

 ,LOOK+ FROM ! G5]AL PO9T ( VIEW1 ,I TOO HAD IRRESI/IBLY BE5 DRIV5 TO ! ADMISSION ?AT ALL FAI?S >E HUMAN DELUSIONS2 BUT ,I C\LD NOT FAIL TO PAUSE AT ! REFLECTION ?AT ! V]Y SILL9ESS ( ! DELUSION1 ITS MANIFE/NESS1 & ! FACT ?AT NEV]!LESS HUMANITY SUBMITS TO IT4 -- ?AT ?IS V]Y ?+ PROVES ?AT AT ! F\NDATION ( ?IS DELUSION RE/S SOME?+ ?AT IS NOT A DELUSION4  

 ,O!RWISE1 IT W]E ALL SO FOOLI% ?AT PEOPLE C\LD NOT DECEIVE !MSELVES4  

 ,! V]Y SUBMISSION ( 5TIRE HUMANITY1 :I* TRULY LIVES1 TO ! DELUSION1 OBLIG$ ME TO ACKN[L$GE ! SIGNIFICANCE ( ?AT PH5OM5ON :I* IS ! CAUSE ( ! DELUSION2 & UPON ?IS CONVICTION ,I BEGAN TO ANALYZE ! ,*RI/IAN DOCTR9E1 :I* S]VES AS ! F\NDATION ( ! DELUSION ( 5TIRE ,*RI/IAN HUMANITY4  

 ,SO IT APPE>S FROM ! G5]AL PO9T ( VIEW2 BUT FROM ! P]SONAL PO9T ( VIEW1 FROM ?AT 9CONSEQU5CE ( :I* EV]Y MAN 7& ,I71 9 ORD] TO LIVE1 MU/ HAVE FAI? 9 ! MEAN+ ( LIFE1 & HAS SU* FAI?1 -- ?AT FACT ( COMPULSION 9 ! MATT] ( FAI? IS /ILL MORE AMAZ+ 9 ITS ABSURDITY4 ,REALLY1 H[1 :Y1 TO :OM1 CAN IT BE NECESS>Y ?AT ANO!R %\LD NOT ONLY BELIEVE1 BUT PR(ESS1 9 ! SAME WAY ,I DO8  

 ,A MAN LIVES1 CONSEQU5TLY HE KN[S ! MEAN+ ( LIFE4 ,HE HAS FIX$ HIS RELATION TO ,GOD2 HE KN[S ! TRU? ( TRU?S1 & ,I KN[ ! TRU? ( TRU?S4  

 ,! =MS ( !SE MAY BE DIFF]5T4  

 ,! SUB/ANCE MU/ BE ONE & ! SAME1 -- WE >E BO? M54  

 ,H[1 :Y1 :AT MAY COMPEL ME TO DEM& FROM ANYBODY ?AT HE %ALL MANIFE/ HIS TRU? ABSOLUTELY AS ,I DO8  

 ,COMPEL HIM TO *ANGE HIS FAI? ,I CANNOT2 EI!R BY VIOL5CE1 CUNN+1 OR DECEPTION4 7,FALSE MIRACLES47  

 ,FAI? 9 HIS LIFE1 -- H[ !N CAN ,I TAKE AWAY HIS FAI? & GIVE HIM ANO!R8 ,IT IS LIKE TAK+ HIS HE>T \T & PUTT+ ANO!R 94  

 ,I CAN ONLY DO IT IF FAI?1 HIS AS WELL AS M9E1 IS -- WORDS1 & NOT ?AT :]EBY HE LIVES2 IF \R FAI? IS AN EXCRESC5CE1 NOT ! HE>T4  

 ,ANO!R REASON :Y ?IS CANNOT BE DONE IS ?AT IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO =CE A MAN TO BELIEVE ?AT :I* HE DOES NOT BELIEVE1 -- ?AT IS1 TO FILL HIS RELATION TO ,GOD1 -- & BECAUSE HE :O KN[S ?AT FAI? IS ! RELATION ( MAN TO ,GOD CANNOT WI% TO DET]M9E ! RELATIONS ( ANO!R MAN TO ,GOD ?R\< =CE OR FRAUD4  

 ,?IS IS IMPOSSIBLE1 BUT IS DONE & HAS BE5 DONE EV]Y:]E & ALWAYS2 ?AT IS1 IT C\LD NOT BE DONE1 S9CE IT IS IMPOSSIBLE1 BUT SOME?+ IS BE+ DONE & HAS BE5 DONE ?AT IS V]Y MU* LIKE IT4 ,:AT IS BE+ DONE & HAS BE5 DONE IS ! IMPOS+ BY SOME ON O!RS ! LIK5ESS ( FAI?1 & ! ACCEPTANCE ( ?IS LIK5ESS ( FAI? BY ! O!RS1 -- LIK5ESS ( FAI?1 -- ?AT IS1 ! DELUSION ( FAI?4  

 ,FAI? CANNOT IMPOSE ITSELF1 & CANNOT BE ADOPT$ = ! SAKE ( ANY?+1 -- VIOL5CE1 DECEPTION1 OR UTILITY2 & H5CE IT IS NOT FAI?1 BUT ! DELUSION ( FAI?4  

 ,& ?IS DELUSION ( FAI? IS ! ANCI5T CONDITION ( ! LIFE ( HUMANITY4  

 ,9 :AT1 !N1 DOES ?IS DELUSION CONSI/1 & ON :AT IS IT F\ND$8  

 ,:AT PRODUCES IT 9 ! DECEIV]S1 & :AT SU/A9S IT 9 ! DECEIV$8  

 ,I WILL NOT SPEAK AB\T ,BRAHM9ISM1 ,BUDDHISM1 ,CONFUCIANISM1 ,MOHAMM$ANISM1 9 :I* ! SAME PH5OM5A HAVE TAK5 PLACE2 NOT1 H[EV]1 BECAUSE ! SAME W\LD NOT BE F\ND TO BE ! CASE4 ,TO EV]Y ONE :O HAS READ AB\T ?OSE RELIGIONS IT WILL BE CLE> ?AT ) ?OSE FAI?S IT IS ! SAME AS ) ,*RI/IANITY4 ,I WILL SPEAK EXCLUSIVELY AB\T ,*RI/IANITY1 AS A FAI? FAMILI> TO US1 NE$FUL & DE> TO US4  

 ,9 ,*RI/IANITY ! :OLE DELUSION IS BUILT ON ! FANATICAL IDEA ( ,*UR*1 BAS$ ON NO?+1 & A/\ND+1 AT ! COMM5CEM5T ( ! /UDY ( ,*RI/IANITY1 9 ITS UNEXPECT$ & USELESS ABSURDITY4  

 ,( ALL ! GODLESS IDEAS & T]MS1 !RE IS NO T]M & CONCEPT MORE GODLESS ?AN ! IDEA ( ,*UR*4  

 ,!RE IS NO IDEA ?AT HAS PRODUC$ MORE EVIL1 NO IDEA MORE HO/ILE TO ! DOCTR9E ( ,*RI/1 ?AN ! IDEA ( ,*UR*4 ,AT BOTTOM1 ! WORD ,ECCLESIA MEANS COLLECTION & NO?+ MORE1 & SO IT IS US$ 9 ! ,GOSPELS4 ,9 ! LANGUAGES ( ALL NEW PEOPLES ! WORD ,ECCLESIA SIGNIFIES H\SE ( WOR%IP4  

 ,FUR!R ?AN !SE SIGNIFICATIONS1 9 SPITE ( ! FIFTE5 C5TURIES' EXI/5CE ( ! DELUSION ( ,*UR*1 ?IS WORD HAS NOT ADVANC$ 9 ANY LANGUAGE4  

 ,ACCORD+ TO ! DEF9ITIONS GIV5 TO ?IS WORD BY ?OSE PRIE/S :O NE$ ?IS DELUSION ( ,*UR*1 IT IS NO?+ ELSE ?AN AN 9TRODUCTION TO ?IS EFFECT3  

 0,EV]Y?+ ,I AM AB\T TO SAY IS TRU?1 &1 IF Y\ WILL NOT BELIEVE1 ,I %ALL BURN Y\1 OR DAMN Y\1 & 9 EV]Y WAY WORK Y\ 9JURY40  

 ,?IS IDEA IS A SOPHISM1 NECESS>Y = C]TA9 DIALECTICAL PURPOSES1 & IT REMA9S ! 9H]ITANCE ( ?OSE :O NE$ IT4  

 ,AMONG ! PEOPLE1 & NOT ONLY AMONG ! PEOPLE1 BUT 9 SOCIETY1 & AMONG $UCAT$ M51 9 SPITE ( ! FACT ?AT ! ,CATE*ISM TEA*ES IT1 ?IS IDEA DOES NOT EXI/4  

 ,?IS DEF9ITION 7H[EV] A%AM$ ONE MAY BE TO ANALYZE IT S]I\SLY1 IT HAS TO BE DONE1 SEE+ ?AT SO MANY PEOPLE PUT IT =W>D AS SOME?+ IMPORTANT7 IS TOTALLY FALSE4  

 ,:5 IT IS SAID ?AT ! ,*UR* IS ! CONGREGATION ( ! TRULY-FAI?FUL1 NO?+ IS REALLY SAID2 S9CE1 IF ,I SAY ?AT A *APEL IS ! CONGREGATION ( ALL TRUE MUSICIANS1 ,I SAY NO?+ IF ,I DO NOT DECL>E :OM ,I CALL TRUE MUSICIANS4  

 ,:ILE1 ACCORD+ TO !OLOGY1 ! TRULY-FAI?FUL >E ?OSE :O FOLL[ ! DOCTR9E ( ! ,*UR*1 -- ?AT IS1 >E 9 ! ,*UR*4  

 ,TO SAY NO?+ ( ! CIRCUM/ANCE ?AT ( SU* TRUE FAI?S !RE >E HUNDR$S1 ! DEF9ITION TELLS US NO?+1 & W\LD EV5 SEEM USELESS1 DID NOT ! TRACE ( A C]TA9 E>-M>K BECOME P]CEPTIBLE H]E4  

 ,! ,*UR* IS TRUE & ONE1 & 9 H] >E ! PA/ORS & PAPACIES2 & ! PA/ORS1 APPO9T$ BY ,GOD1 TEA* ?IS TRUE & UNIT>Y DOCTR9E1 -- ?AT IS1  

 0,BY ,GOD1 ,EV]Y?+ ,WE >E ,GO+ TO ,SAY1 EV]Y?+ IS G5U9E TRU?40  

 ,& NO?+ MORE6  

 ,! :OLE DELUSION IS H]E1 9 ! WORD & 9 ! IDEA1 ,*UR*4 ,& ! DELUSION ONLY SIGNIFIES ?AT !RE >E PEOPLE :O HAVE AN IMMOD]ATE DESIRE TO TEA* !IR FAI? TO O!RS4  

 ,BUT = :AT 5D DO !Y WI% SO /RONGLY TO TEA* O!RS !IR FAI?8  

 ,DID !Y POSSESS G5U9E FAI?1 !Y W\LD KN[ ?AT 9 FAI? IS ! MEAN+ ( LIFE1 ! RELATION TO ,GOD1 FIX$ BY EV]Y MAN 9DIVIDUALLY1 & ?AT IT IS !RE=E IMPOSSIBLE TO TEA* FAI?1 BUT ONLY ! DELUSION ( FAI?4  

 ,BUT !Y DESIRE TO TEA*4  

 ,TO :AT 5D8  

 ,! SIMPLE/ ANSW] W\LD BE ?AT ! ,POPE NE$S CAKE & EGGS1 ! BI%OPS A CA/LE1 FI%PIE1 & A SILK5 CASSOCK4 ,BUT ?IS ANSW] IS 9SUFFICI5T4  

 ,SU*1 NO D\BT1 IS ! 9W>D1 PSY*OLOGICAL MOTIVE ( ! DELUSION1 ! MOTIVE MA9TA9+ IT2 BUT1 REASON+ ?US1 H[ C\LD ONE MAN 7EXECUTION]7 V5TURE TO KILL ANO!R AGA9/ :OM HE HAS NO MALICE8  

 ,IT W\LD BE 9ADEQUATE TO SAY ?AT ! EXECUTION] KILLS BECAUSE HE IS NOT GIV5 BR&Y1 A LOAF ( :ITE BREAD1 & A R$ %IRT2 JU/ 9 ! SAME DEGREE W\LD IT BE 9ADEQUATE TO SAY ?AT ! ,METROPOLITAN ( ,KIEFF & ! MONKS FILL ASKS ) /RAW :I* !Y CALL SA9TS' RELICS1 JU/ = ! SAKE ( GETT+ AN 9COME ( ?IRTY ?\S&4  

 ,BO? ACTS1 ! ONE & ! O!R1 >E TOO T]RIBLE & REPUGNANT TO HUMAN NATURE TO ALL[ SU* AN EXPLANATION TO BE ADEQUATE4  

 ,AS ! EXECUTION]1 SO ! ,METROPOLITAN1 9 EXPLA9+ HIS ACT1 WILL CITE A :OLE S]IES ( PRO(S1 ! *IEF BASIS ( :I* WILL BE HI/ORICAL TRADITION4  

 0,IT IS NECESS>Y TO EXECUTE M52 S9CE ! WORLD CAME 9TO EXI/5CE !RE HAVE BE5 EXECUTIONS4 ,IF NOT ,I1 !N SOMEBODY ELSE4 ,I WILL DO IT1 ,I HOPE1 ) ! AID ( ,GOD1 BETT] ?AN ANO!R10 WILL SAY ! EXECUTION]4  

 0,=MAL WOR%IP IS NECESS>Y2 S9CE ! WORLD CAME 9TO EXI/5CE1 ! RELICS ( ! SA9TS HAVE BE5 HONOR$10 WILL SAY ! ,METROPOLITAN2 0! RELICS ( ! CAVES >E HONOR$2 PEOPLE COME H]E4 ,IF NOT ,I1 !N SOMEBODY ELSE WILL PLAY ! HO/ H]E4 ,& ,I1 ) ! AID ( GOD1 HOPE TO DISPOSE ( ! MONEY1 GOT BY BLASPHEM\S FRAUD1 9 A WAY MORE PLEAS+ TO ,GOD40  

 ,TO UND]/& ! DELUSION ( FAI?1 IT IS NECESS>Y TO GO TO ITS S\RCE1 TO ! ORIG94  

 ,WE SPEAK ( ?AT :I* WE KN[ 9 REF]5CE TO ,*RI/IANITY4  

 ,TURN+ TO ! ORIG9AL ,*RI/IAN DOCTR9E 9 ! ,GOSPELS1 WE F9D A DOCTR9E DIRECTLY EXCLUD+ =MAL WOR%IP1 C5SUR+ IT1 & ONE ?AT ) P>TICUL> PLA9NESS & POSITIV5ESS D5IES ALL TEA*+4  

 ,BUT S9CE ,*RI/'S TIME1 & D[N TO \RS1 WE F9D A DEVIATION ( DOCTR9E FROM ! F\NDATIONS LAID BY ,*RI/4  

 ,?IS DEVIATION BEG9S AT ! TIME ( ! APO/LES1 ESPECIALLY ) ?AT LOV] ( TEA*+1 ,PAUL3 & ! WID] ,*RI/IANITY EXT5DS1 ! MORE IT DEVIATES & APPROPRIATES ! ME?ODS ( ?AT V]Y EXT]NAL WOR%IP & DOGMATISM ! D5IAL ( :I* WAS SO POSITIVELY EXPRESS$ BY ,*RI/4  

 ,BUT 9 ! FIR/ DAYS ( ,*RI/IANITY ! IDEA ( ,*UR* IS US$ ONLY AS A REPRES5TATION ( ALL ?OSE :O %>E ! FAI? :I* ,I CONSID] ! TRUE ONE4  

 ,A :OLLY TRUE IDEA1 PROVID$ IT DOES NOT 9CLUDE M]E V]BAL MANIFE/ATIONS ( BELIEFS 7BUT EXPRESSIONS Y MEANS ( ! 5TIRE LIFE71 S9CE BELIEFS CANNOT BE MANIFE/$ BY WORDS4  

 ,! CONCEPTION ( ! TRUE ,*UR* WAS ALSO US$ AS AN >GUM5T AGA9/ ! OPPON5TS2 BUT UNTIL ,EMP]OR ,CON/ANT9E & ! ,NICAEAN ,C\NCIL1 ,*UR*  WAS ONLY AN IDEA4 ,BUT S9CE ,CON/ANT9E & ! ,NICAEAN ,C\NCIL ! ,*UR* HAS BE5 A ?+1 & A ?+ ( FRAUD4  

 ,! ,FRAUD BEG9S ) ! ,METROPOLITAN & ! RELICS1 ! PRIE/S & ! ,LORD'S ,SUPP]1 ,SYNODS1 & ! LIKE1 :I* SO A/\ND & HORRIFY US1 & :I*1 FROM !IR UGL9ESS1 DO NOT F9D AN ADEQUATE EXPLANATION 9 ! M]E ADVANTAGE D]IV$ BY ?OSE P]SONS4  

 ,! DELUSION IS OLD1 & DID NOT PROCE$ FROM ! M]E ADVANTAGES TO PRIVATE P]SONS3 !RE LIVES NO SU* MAN1 MON/]1 :O W\LD DET]M9E TO DO IT IF HE W]E ! FIR/ & IF !RE W]E NO O!R CAUSES4  

 ,! CAUSES ?AT L$ TO IT W]E BAD ONES4  

 0,BY !IR FRUITS %ALL Y\ KN[ !M40  

 ,! S\RCE WAS EVIL3 HATE1 HUMAN PRIDE1 HO/ILITY T[>DS ,>IUS & O!RS1 & ANO!R /ILL GRAV] EVIL1 -- ! UNION ( ,*RI/IANITY ) P[]4  

 ,P[]3 ,CON/ANT9E1 EMP]OR1 ACCORD+ TO HEA!N IDEAS ONE :O /&S AT ! HEI<T ( HUMAN GR&EUR 7 HE WAS C\NT$ AMONG ! GODS71 ACCEPTS ,*RI/IANITY1 FURNI%ES AN EXAMPLE TO ! :OLE NATION1 CONV]TS ! NATION1 & EXT5DS A HELP+ H& AS AGA9/ H]ETICS1 & ?R\< ! ECUM5ICAL C\NCIL FIXES ! UNIT>Y OR?ODOX ,*RI/IAN FAI?4  

 ,! ,*RI/IAN ,CA?OLIC FAI? IS FIX$ =EV]4  

 ,SO NATURAL WAS IT TO YIELD TO ?AT DELUSION ?AT EV5 UNTO ?IS DAY M5 BELIEVE 9 ! SALUT>9ESS ( ?AT EV5T4 ,:ILE ! EV5T WAS REALLY SU* ?AT1 ?ANKS TO IT1 ! MAJORITY ( ,*RI/IANS HAVE REPUDIAT$ !IR FAI?4 ,?AT WAS ! PO9T :]E ! OV]:ELM+ MAJORITY ( ,*RI/IANS TOOK ! HEA!N ROAD1 :I* IS /ILL FOLL[$4  

 ,*>LES ! ,GREAT1 ,VLADIMIR1 CONT9UE ! SAME WORK4  

 ,& ! DELUSION HAS CONT9U$ UP TO \R TIME1 ! DELUSION BE+ RI<T H]E1 - = ! ACCEPTANCE ( P[] BY ,*RI/IANITY IS NE$FUL = ?OSE :O UND]/& ! LETT]1 BUT NOT ! SPIRIT1 ( ,*RI/IANITY4  

 ,9 REALITY1 ! ACCEPTANCE ( ,*RI/IANITY )\T ! REPUDIATION ( P[] IS A MOCK]Y & P]VESION ( ,*RI/IANITY4  

 ,! CONSECRATION ( GOV]NM5TAL P[] BY ,*RI/IANITY IS BLASPHEMY1 IS ! DOOM ( ,*RI/IANITY4  

 ,HAV+ LIV$ FIFTE5 HUNDR$ YE>S UND] ?IS BLASPHEM\S UNION ( PRET5D$ ,*RI/IANITY ) ,GOV]NM5T1 IT IS NECESS>Y TO MAKE A GREAT EF=T T9 ORD] TO =GET ?OSE 9TRICATE SOPHISMS :I* = FIFTE5 C5TURIES1 EV]Y:]E1 AT P[]'S PLEASURE1 HAVE P]V]T$ ! DOCTR9E ( ,*RI/1 TO MAKE IT COMPATIBLE ) ,GOV]NM5T1 & ! ATTEMPTS TO EXPLA9 ! SACR$NESS1 LEGITIMACY ( ,GOV]NM5T1 & ! POSSIBILITY ( ITS BE+ ,*RI/IAN4  

 ,AT BOTTOM1 ! WORDS1 0,*RI/IAN ,GOV]NM5T0 >E LIKE ! WORDS1 0W>M1 HOT ICE40  

 ,EI!R !RE IS NO ,GOV]NM5T1 OR !RE IS NO ,*RI/IANITY4  

 ,TO UND]/& ?IS CLE>LY1 IT IS NECESS>Y TO =GET ALL ?OSE FANTASIES 9 :I* WE >E C>EFULLY $UCAT$1 & PLA9LY 9QUIRE 9TO ! IMPORT ( ?OSE SCI5CES1 HI/ORICAL & JUDICIAL1 :I* WE >E TAU<T4  

 ,!SE SCI5CES >E )\T ANY F\NDATIONS2 ALL !SE SCI5CES >E NO?+ ELSE FROM AN APOLOGY = VIOL5CE4  

 ,PASS+ BY ! HI/ORY ( !  ,M$ES & ,P]SIANS1 ETC41 LET US TAKE ?AT ,GOV]NM5T :I* FIR/ MADE A UNION ) ,*RI/IANITY4  

 ,!RE WAS A CUT-?ROATS' NE/ 9 ,ROME4 ,IT SPREAD BY ROBB]Y1 VIOL5CE1 MURD]4 ,9 CONQU]$ NATIONS4 ,! ROBB]S & !IR DESC5DANTS1 ) *IEFS 7:O W]E CALL$1 N[ ,CES>1 N[ ,AUGU/US7 AT !IR HEAD1 PLUND]$ & TORTUR$ ! PEOPLE TO GRATIFY !IR DESIRES4 ,ONE ( ! DESC5DANTS ( !SE CUT-?ROATS1 ,CON/ANT9E1 HAV+ READ A GREAT DEAL 9 BOOKS & HAV+ BECOME SATIATE ) HIS VOLUPTU\S LIV+1 PREF]R$ C]TA9 DOGMAS ( ,*RI/IANITY TO PREVI\S BELIEFS2 TO ! BR++ ( HUMAN SC>IFIES1 HE PREF]R$ GR& MASS2 TO ! WOR%IP ( ,APOLLO & ,V5US & ,JUPIT]1 HE PREF]R$ ! ONE ,GOD1 ) HIS ,SON ,*RI/2 & HE ORD]$ ! 9TRODUCTION ( ?IS FAI? AMONG ?OSE :O W]E UND] HIS AU?ORITY4  

 0,K+S RULE OV] !IR PEOPLES2 ?IS %ALL NOT BE AMONG Y\4 -- ,DO NOT KILL4 -- ,DO NOT COMMIT ADULT]Y4 -- ,ABJURE RI*ES4 -- ,DO NOT JUDGE2 DO NOT CONDEMN4 -- ,5DURE EVIL40  

 ,ALL ( ?IS NOBODY TOLD HIM (4  

 0,OH1 Y\ WI% TO CALL Y\RSELF A ,*RI/IAN & CONT9UE TO BE ! *IEF ( ! CUT-?ROATS1 -- TO ASSAULT1 BURN1 FI<T1 DO MIS*IEF1 EXECUTE1 & REVEL8 ,ALL RI<T60  

 ,& !Y FURNI%$ HIM A ,*RI/IANITY1 & MADE IT V]Y COM=TABLE1 -- BETT] ?AN C\LD HAVE BE5 EXPECT$4  

 ,!Y ANTICIPAT$ ?AT HE MI<T1 ON READ+ ! ,GOSPEL1 BE?9K HIMSELF ?AT !RE MORE IS DEM&$ ( HIM ?AN ! BUILD+ ( *UR*ES & ! VISIT+ !M1 ?AT A ,*RI/IAN LIFE IS !RE REQUIR$2 & !Y ?\<TFULLY & ) =ESI<T CON/RUCT$ SU* A ,*RI/IANITY = HIM ?AT HE C\LD )\T EMB>RASSM5T LIVE 9 ! OLD1 HEA!N WAY4  

 ,ON ! ON EL&1 ,*RI/1 ! ,SON ( ,GOD1 APPE>$ = NO O!R PURPOSE ?AN TO R$EEM HIM1 ,CON/ANT9E1 & ALL ! O!RS4 ,BECAUSE ,*RI/ DI$1 ,CON/ANT9E CAN LIVE AS HE PLEASES4  

 ,& IF ?IS IS NOT 5\<1 ONE MAY REP5T & SWALL[ A PIECE ( BREAD ) SOME W9E2 -- 9 ?IS !RE WILL BE SALVATION & ALL WILL BE =GIV54 ,& NOT SATISFI$ ) ?IS1 !Y EV5 CONSECRAT$ HIS RUFFIANLY P[]1 & SAID ?AT HE WAS FROM ,GOD2 & ANO9T$ HIM ) OIL4  

 ,= ?IS HE1 TOO1 >RANG$ = !M AS !Y DESIR$4 ,HE CALL$ A C\NCIL ( PRIE/S1 HAD !M DECL>E :AT ! RELATION ( EV]Y MAN %\LD BE TO ,GOD & EV]Y O!R MAN1 & ! SAME HE ORD]$ TO BE REPEAT$4  

 ,& ALL W]E SATISFI$2 & ?US = A ?\S& YE>S HAS ?IS FAI? LIV$ 9 ! WORLD1 & O!R CUT?ROAT *IEFS HAVE 9TRODUC$ IT1 & !Y >E ALL ANO9T$1 & EV]Y?+1 EV]Y?+1 IS FROM ,GOD4  

 ,IF SOME VILLA9 PLUND]S EV]YBODY1 MASSACRES MANY PEOPLE1 HE WILL BE ANO9T$ BY !M1 -- HE IS FROM ,GOD4  

 ,SOME NATIONS HAVE HAD HUSB&-SLAY]S & LIB]T9ES4  

 ,! ,FR5* HAVE HAD ,NAPOLEON4  

 ,& ! PRIE/S1 9 COMP5SATION = ?IS1 NOT ONLY >E FROM ,GOD1 BUT ALMO/ >E !MSELVES GODS1 S9CE 9 !M RESIDES ! ,HOLY ,<O/4 ,HE RESIDES 9 ! PRIE/S AS WELL AS 9 ! ,SYNOD1 ) ITS COMM&]S1 ! (FICIALS4  

 ,& AS SOON AS A C]TA9 ANO9T$ -- ?AT IS1 A CUT?ROAT *IEF -- BECOMES POSSESS$ ( ! DESIRE TO MASSACRE ANO!R AS WELL AS HIS PEOPLE1 HOLY WAT] IS AT ONCE MADE FRO HIM1 SOME ( IT IS SPR9KL$1 ! CROSS IS TAK5 UP 7?AT V]Y CROSS C>RY+ :I* ,*RI/ DI$1 BECAUSE HE REPUDIAT$ !SE V]Y CUT-?ROATS71 & A BLESS+ IS BE/[$ ON MASSACRE1 HANG+S1 & BEHEAD+S4  

 ,& EV]Y?+ W\LD BE WELL2 BUT EV5 H]E !Y C\LD NOT AGREE AMONG !MSELVES1 & ! ANO9T$ PROCE$$ TO CALL EA* O!R CUT-?ROATS 7?AT :I* !Y REALLY >E71 :ILE ! PEOPLE BEGAN TO LI/5 & CEAS$ TO BELIEVE EI!R ! ANO9T$ OR ! KEEP]S ( ! ,HOLY ,<O/1 BUT LE>N$ FROM !IR [N LIPS TO CALL !M BY !IR REAL NAMES1 AS !Y !MSELVES CALL EA* O!R1 -- NAMELY1 CUT-?ROATS & IMPOS]S4  

 ,BUT TO ! CUT-?ROATS WE HAVE ONLY REF]R$ A PROPOS1 S9CE !Y HAD TRADUC$ ! IMPO/ORS4  

 ,\R TALK IS PROP]LY AB\T ! IMPO/ORS1 ! PRET5D$ ,*RI/IANS4  

 ,SU* !Y HAVE BECOME 9 CONSEQU5CE ( ! UNION ) ! CUT-?ROATS4  

 ,& IT C\LD NOT BE O!RWISE4 !Y DEVIAT$ FROM ! PA? AT ! FIR/ M9UTE ?AT !Y CONSECRAT$ ! FIR/ ,EMP]OR1 & ASSUR$ HIM ?AT HE C\LD HELP ! FAI? ) HIS VIOL5CE1 -- ! FAI? ( HUMILITY1 SELF-D5IAL1 & ! 5DURANCE ( 9JURY4  

 ,! :OLE HI/ORY ( ! ACTUAL ,*UR*1 -- NOT ! FANTA/IC1 -- ?AT IS1 ! HI/ORY ( ! HI]>*Y UND] ! AU?ORITY ( ! EMP]ORS1 IS A S]IES ( VA9 ATTEMPTS ON ! P>T ( ?IS UN=TUNATE HI]>*Y TO PRES]VE ! TRU? ( ! DOCTR9E1 :ILE PROPAGAT+ IT BY MEANS ( LIES & ABJUR+ IT 9 PRACTICE4  

 ,! IMPORTANCE ( ! HI]>*Y IS BAS$ ONLY ON ! DOCTR9E :I* IT 9T5DS TO TEA*4  

 ,! DOCTR9E SPEAKS AB\T HUMILITY1 SELF ABNEGATION1 LOVE1 DE/ITUTION2 BUT ! DOCTR9E IS PROPAGAT$ BY VIOL5CE1 HATR$1 & EVIL4  

 ,?AT ! HI]>*Y MAY HAVE SOME?+ TO TEA*1 ?AT !RE MAY BE DISCIPLES1 IT IS NE$FUL NOT TO =SAKE ! DOCTR9E2 :ILE 9 ORD] TO :ITEWA% ITSELF & ITS ILLEGITIMATE UNION ) P[]1 IT IS NECESS>Y TO DISGUISE BY ! %REWDE/ CONSID]ATIONS ! SUB/ANCE ( ! DOCTR9E & TO TRANSF] = ! PURPOSE ITS C5T] ( GRAVITY1 FROM ! SUB/ANCE ( ! DOCTR9E TO ITS =MAL SIDE4  

 ,& ?IS IS :AT ! HI]>*Y IS DO+1 -- ?IS IS ! S\RCE ( ?AT DELUSION ( FAI? PROPAGAT$ BY ! ,*UR*4  

 ,! S\RCE IS ! UNION ( ! HI]>*Y ) VIOL5CE UND] ! RESPECTIVE NAMES ( ,*UR* & P[]4  

 ,AS TO ! S\RCE ( PEOPLE'S DESIRE TO TEA* !IR FAI? TO O!RS1 IT IS F\ND 9 ! FACT ?AT FAI? UNMASKS !M1 & !Y >E OBLIG$ TO SUB/ITUTE1 9 PLACE ( G5U9E FAI?1 ONE ( !IR [N 9V5TION1 TO BE JU/IFI$ BY IT4  

 ,G5U9E FAI? MAY EXI/ EV]Y:]E EXCEPT :]E IT IS OBVI\SLY FALSE1 - ?AT IS1 ADDICT$ TO VIOL5CE4  

 ,EV]Y:]E1 BUT NOT 9 ,GOV]NM5T-IMPOS$ FAI?4  

 ,G5U9E FAI? MAY EXI/ 9 ALL SO-CALL$ S*ISMS1 H]ESIES1 BUT C]TA9LY CANNOT EXI/ ONLY :]E IT IS UNIT$ ) ,GOV]NM5T4  

 ,/RANGE TO SAY1 BUT ! APPELLATIONS1 OR?ODOX1 ,CA?OLIC1 ,PROTE/ANT FAI?1 AS !SE WORDS >E FIX$ 9 COMMON SPEE*1 SIGNIFY NO?+ ELSE ?AN FAI? UNIT$ ) P[]1 ,GOV]NM5T FAI?1 & H5CE FALSE4  

 ,! CONCEPTION ( ,*UR*1 -- ?AT IS1 UNANIMITY ( MANY1 ( ! MAJORITY1 & AT ! SAME TIME ! PROXIMITY TO ! S\RCE DUR+ ! FIR/ TWO C5TURIES ( ,*RI/IANITY1 -- WAS BUT ONE ( ! WEAK =MAL >GUM5TS4  

 ,PAUL SAID3  

 0,I KN[ FROM ,*RI/ HIMSELF40  

 ,ANO!R SAID3  

 0,I KN[ FROM ,LUKE40  

 ,& ALL SAID3  

 0,WE ?9K RI<TLY1 & ! PRO( ( ?IS IS ?AT !RE IS A L>GE CONGREGATION ( US1 ,ECCLESIA1 ,*UR*40  

 ,BUT ONLY AFT] ! ,NICAEAN ,C\NCIL1 >RANG$ BY ! ,EMP]OR1 DID ! DIRECT & CONSCI\S DELUSION BEG9 = A P>T ( ?OSE :O PR(ESS$ ! SAME FAI?4  

 0IT PLEASES US & ! ,HOLY ,<O/10 !Y BEGAN TO SAY !N4  

 ,! CONCEPTION ( ,*UR* BECAME NOT M]ELY A POOR >GUM5T1 BUT ALSO1 = SOME1 A P[]4  

 ,! ,*UR* UNIT$ ) P[]1 & BEGAN TO ACT AS A P[]4  

 ,& EV]Y?+ ?AT UNIT$ ITSELF ) P[] & YIELD$ TO IT CEAS$ TO BE FAI?1 & BECAME DELUSION4  

 ,:AT DOES ,*RI/IANITY TEA*1 :E!R UND]/OOD AS ! DOCTR9E ( A GIV5 *UR*1 OR ( ALL *UR*ES8  

 ,ANALYZE IT AS Y\ LIKE1 %IFT OR SUBDIVIDE1 ! ,*RI/IAN DOCTR9E WILL AT ONCE SEP>ATE ITSELF 9TO TWO %>P P>TS3  

 #a4 ,! DOCTR9E ( DOGMAS1 BEG9N+ ) ,GOD'S ,SON1 ,HOLY <O/1 & ! RELATION BETWE5 !SE P]SONALITIES1 D[N TO ! ,LORD'S ,SUPP]1 ) OR )\T W9E1 ) FRE% OR S\R BREAD4  

 #b4 ,& ! MORAL DOCTR9E1 -- HUMILITY1 9DIFF]5CE TO WEAL?1 BODILY & SPIRITUAL PURITY1 *>ITY1 EMANCIPATION FROM SLAV]Y1 BONDS1 & WORLDL9ESS4  

 ,NOT)/&+ ALL ! EF=TS ( ! ,*UR* TO BL5D !SE TWO PHASES ( ! DOCTR9E1 !Y NEV] 9T]MIX1 &1 LIKE OIL & WAT]1 HAVE ALWAYS KEPT AP>T FROM EA* O!R 9 L>GE OR SMALL DROPS4  

 ,! DIFF]5CE BETWE5 !SE TWO SIDES ( ! DOCTR9E IS CLE> TO EV]Y ONE1 & EV]Y ONE MAY TRACE ! FRUITS ( ONE & O!R SIDE ( ! DOCTR9E 9 ! LIVES ( NATIONS1 & FROM !SE FRUITS MAY CONCLUDE :I* SIDE IS ! MORE IMPORTANT2 OR1 IF ONE MAY SAY TRU]1 !N :I* ONE IS ! TRU]8  

 ,GLANCE AT ! HI/ORY ( ,*RI/IANITY FROM ?IS SIDE1 & A T]ROR WILL COME UPON Y\4  

 ,)\T EXCEPTION1 FROM ! V]Y BEG9N+ TO ! V]Y 5D1 TO \R TIME1 :]EV] Y\ WILL LOOK1 :ATEV] DOGMA Y\ WILL GLANCE AT1 EV5 AT ! FIR/1 - ! DOGMAS ( ! DIV9ITY ( ,*RI/1 -- & D[N TO ! COMMUNION1 ) OR )\T W9E1 ! FRUITS ( ALL !SE 9TELLECTUAL LABORS UPON ! ELUCIDATION ( DOGMAS >E3 MALICE1 HATR$1 EXECUTIONS1 EXPULSIONS1 ! MASSACRES ( WIVES & *ILDR51 /AKES1 & TORTURES4  

 ,LOOK AT ! O!RS DIE1 -- ! MORAL DOCTR9E3 FROM ! RETIR+ TO ! DES]T = COMMUNION ) ,GOD1 D[N TO ! CU/OM TO C>RY LOAVES ( BREAD TO ! PRISON1 ! FRUITS ( ?IS DOCTR9E >E ALL \R IDEAS ( GOOD1 ALL \R JOY1 CONSOLATION1 & LI<T4  

 ,?OSE M5 BE=E :OSE EYES ! FRUITS ( ! ONE & ! O!R HAVE NOT YET CLE>LY MANIFE/$ !MSELVES C\LD FALL 9TO ]ROR1 C\LD ONLY FALL 9TO ]ROR4 ,?OSE1 TOO1 C\LD FALL 9TO ]ROR :O W]E S9C]ELY C>RI$ AWAY BY ! DISPUTES AB\T DOGMAS1 NOT P]CEIV+ ?AT !Y1 BY !SE DOGMAS1 NOT P]CEIV+ ?AT !Y1 BY !SE DOGMAS1 S]V$ HE DEVIL1 NOT ,GOD1 NOT NOT+ ?AT ,*RI/ EXPLICITLY SAID ?AT HE HAD COME TO DE/ROY ALL DOGMAS4  

 ,?OSE1 TOO1 C\LD FALL 9TO ]ROR :O1 HAV+ 9H]IT$ ! TRADITIONS AB\T ! IMPORTANCE ( ?OSE DOGMAS1 RECEIV$ SU* A WRONG M5TAL TRA9+ ?AT !Y CANNOT SEE !IR MI/AKE4  

 ,?OSE1 TOO1 MAY ]R :O >E IGNORANT & TO :OM !SE DOGMAS REPRES5T NO?+ BUT WORDS & FANTA/IC IMAGES4  

 ,BUT WE1 TO :OM IS OP5 ! ORIG9AL MEAN+ ( ! ,GOSPELS1 :I* D5IES ALL DOGMAS2 WE :O HAVE BE=E \R EYES ! FRUITS ( !SE DOGMAS 9 HI/ORY1 WE MAY NOT ]R4 ,HI/ORY IS = US ! TE/ ( ! TRU? ( ! DOCTR9E1 A TE/ ALMO/ ME*ANICAL4  

 ,! DOGMAS ( IMMACULATE CONCEPTION1 IS IT NE$FUL OR NOT8  

 ,:AT HAS RESULT$ FROM IT8  

 ,WICK$NESS1 ABUSE1 D]ISION4  

 ,WAS !RE ANY B5EFIT8  

 ,NONE4  

 ,! DOCTR9E ?AT ! ADULT]ESS IS NOT TO BE CONDEMN$1 IS IT NE$FUL OR NOT8  

 ,:AT HAS RESULT$ FROM IT8  

 ,?\S&S & ?\S&S ( TIMES HAVE M5 BE5 MOLLIFI$ BY ?IS REM9D]4  

 ,ANO!R CONSID]ATION4 ,TAKE ANY DOGMAS :ATEV]1 >E ALL AGRE$ UPON IT8 ,NO4  

 ,& AB\T GIV+ TO HIM :O BEGS8  

 ,ALL4  

 ,?US1 ! FIR/1 ! DOGMAS1 ON :I* !RE IS NO AGREEM5T1 :I* NOBODY NE$S1 :I* RU9S M51 -- ?IS ! HI]>*Y HAS ADVANC$ & IS ADVANC+ AS ! FAI?2 :ILE ! SECOND1 ?AT ON :I* ALL >E AGRE$1 :I* ALL NE$1 & :I* SAVES M51 -- ?IS1 ?\< ! HI]>*Y HAS NOT D>$ TO D5Y IT1 IT ALSO HAS NOT D>$ TO ADVANCE AS ! DOCTR9E1 = ?IS DOCTR9E D5IES ! HI]>*Y ITSELF4  

7,S\RCE3 ,C\NT ,LEO ,TOL/OI 7#a#h#i#a74 ,*UR* & ,/ATE & ,O!R ,ESSAYS4 ,BO/ON1 ,MASS43 ,B5JAM9 ,R4 ,TUCK]1 ,PUBLI%]4  ,TRANSLAT$ BY ,VICTOR ,Y>ROS47 

,FROM 3 ,AN>*Y ,>*IVES4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahi 3 ,*UR* & ,/ATE -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,FEBRU>Y #a#a1 #bag 3 ,*UR* & ,/ATE -- ,ADD$4 
,DECEMB] #c1 #bba 3 ,*UR* & ,/ATE -- ,UPDAT$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/