,DIALOGUE ) ,/AL9 ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,AMADEO ,BORDIGA ,TEXT 3 ,FIR/ PUBLI%$3 AS ,DIALOGATO CON ,/AL9 9 ,IL ,PROGRAMMA ,COMUNI/A1 9 #d P>TS1 ,OCTOB]-,DECEMB] #a#i#e#b2 ,TRANSLAT$3 BY ,LIBRI ,9COGNITI1 LIBRI9COGNITI4WORDPRESS4COM4 ,FIR/ ,DAY ,BY SUBMITT+ ANO!R >TICLE1 A GOOD TWO YE>S AFT] HIS LA/ >TICLE1 7?AT 9FAM\S TEXT ON L+UI/ICS.<#a.> :I* WE HAD TO DEAL ) ONLY 9CID5TALLY1 BUT :I* W\LD BE WOR?Y ( DETAIL$ TREATM5T2 NEV]!LESS1 QUOD DIFF]TUR.<#b.>7 AB\T #e PAGES LONG.<#c.>1 ,/AL9 RESPONDS TO TOPICS ?AT HAVE BE5 PRES5T$ 9 ! LA/ TWO YE>S NOT ONLY 9 ! S]IES 0,?READ ( ,TIME10 BUT ALSO 9 ! WORK%OPS ON ! !ORY & PROGRAM ( ,M>XISM CONDUCT$ BY \R ,MOVEM5T1 & :I* HAVE BE5 PUBLI%$ 9 SUMM>IZ$ OR DETAIL$ =M4 ,BY :I* WE DO NOT MEAN ?AT ,/AL9 7OR HIS SECRET>IAT1 :OSE NETWORKS SPAN ! GLOBE7 W\LD HAVE LOOK$ AT ?IS MAT]IAL & TURN$ TO US4 ,WE MU/ NOT BELIEVE ?AT IF WE >E REAL ,M>XI/S1 ! GREAT HI/ORICAL DISPUTES REQUIR$ P]SONIFI$ PROTAGONI/S PRES5T+ !MSELVES TO ! A/\ND$ HUMANITY - AS IF AN ANGEL ON HIS CL\D W]E BL[+ 9TO ! HEAV5LY TRUMPET1 & ,DANTE'S DEMON ,B>B>ICCIA RESPONDS ) A S\ND ?AT COMES 0DE PR(UNDIS10 ?AT IS1 FROM ! DEP?S1 9 ! REALE/1 KN[N TO Y\1 S5SE ( ! WORD.<#d.>4 ,OR LIKE ! ,*RI/IAN ,PALAD9 & ! ,S>AC5 ,SULTAN1 :O1 BE=E !Y DRAW !IR SP>KL+ SAB]S1 9TRODUCE !MSELVES 9 A L\D VOICE1 *ALL5GE EA* O!R ) ! LI/ ( !IR ANCE/ORS & VICTORI\S T\RNAM5TS & SWE> DEA? TO EA* O!R4 ,?AT'S JU/ :AT WAS MISS+6 ,ON ! ONE H&1 ! HIGE/ /ATE & ! 0COMMUNI/0 WORLD PROLET>IAT1 & ON ! O!R H&1 A NOBODY1 A NO?+4 ,9 REALITY1 ! FACTS & MAT]IAL =CES ACT+ 9 ! SUB/RUCTURE DET]M9I/ICALLY TAKE UP ! DISCUSSION AMONG !MSELVES2 & ?OSE :O !N DICTATE ! TEXT OR HACK 9TO ! KEYS >E1 LIKE ?OSE :O GIVE ! LECTURE1 M]E ME*ANISMS1 L\DSPEAK]S ?AT PASSIVELY CONV]T ! WAVES 9TO VOICES2 & IT IS NOT SAID ?AT A L\DSPEAK] ) A P[] ( #b WATTS DOESN'T JU/ PRODUCE ! GREATE/ NONS5SE4 ,IT IS !RE=E ! SAME QUE/IONS ?AT EM]GE ) REG>D TO ! IMPORTANCE ( BO? SOCIAL CONDITIONS 9 TODAY'S ,RUSSIA & 9T]NATIONAL RELATIONS AT ! ECONOMIC1 POLITICAL & MILIT>Y LEVELS2 !Y IMPOSE !MSELVES JU/ AS MU* UP !RE AS !Y DO D[N H]E1 & !Y CAN ONLY BE CL>IFI$ IF !Y >E JUXTAPOS$ ) ! !ORY ?AT GRASPS :AT HAS ALREADY HAPP5$ & IS KN[N1 & IF !SE QUE/IONS >E JUXTAPOS$ ) ! HI/ORY ( ?IS !ORY1 :I* A V]Y LONG TIME AGO - :I* REMA9S 9DELIBLE - WAS A COMMON ONE4 ,SO WE KN[ V]Y WELL ?AT ,/AL9'S ANSW] FROM ! UPP] ,KREML9 /ORIES DOES NOT RESPOND TO \R WORDS & IS NOT ADDRESS$ TO US4 ,9 ORD] TO CONT9UE ! DEBATE1 IT IS NOT EV5 NECESS>Y = HIM TO KN[ \R !ORETICAL ORGANS.<#e.>4 ,! ?+S & =CES - :E!R L>GE OR SMALL1 PA/1 PRES5T OR FUTURE - REMA9 ! SAME1 DESPITE ! :IMS ( SYMBOLISM4 ,:5 ! ANCI5T PHILOSOPHY WROTE 0SUNT NOM9A R]UM0 7LIT]ALLY3 ! NAMES BELONG TO ?+S71 %E WANT$ TO SAY ?AT ?+S DO NOT BELONG TO ! NAME4 ,TRANSLAT$ 9TO \R LANGUAGE1 ?IS MEANS3 ! ?+ DET]M9ES ! NAME1 NOT ! O!R WAY R\ND4 ,Y\ CAN CONT9UE TO D$ICATE #i#i.0 ( Y\R WORK TO ! NAME1 PORTRAITS1 EPI!TS1 LIVES & GRAVES ( ! GREAT M53 WE WILL CONT9UE 9 ! %AD[S1 KN[+ ?AT SOON ! G5]ATION WILL COME :O WILL ONLY SMILE AT Y\1 Y\ FAM\S M5 ( ! GREAT & V]Y SMALL CALIB]4 ,BUT ! ?+S BETWE5 ! L9ES 9 ,/AL9'S WRIT+ >E TOO IMPORTANT = US TO D5Y HIM ! DIALOGUE4 ,= ?IS REASON1 & NOT FROM A 0A T\T SEIGNEUR T\T HONNEUR10 WE ANSW] & EXPECT ! NEW APPEAL - EV5 IF IT TAKES ANO!R TWO YE>S1 BECAUSE WE DON'T HAVE A HURRY 7ISN'T IT TRUE1 EX-,M>XI/874 ,TOMORR[ & ,YE/]DAY ,ALL ( ! ISSUES DEALT ) BY ,/AL9 >E JUNCTIONS ( ,M>XISM & ALMO/ ALL ( !M >E OLD NAILS1 :I* WE 9SI/5TLY DEM&$ ?AT !Y BE /RUCK FIRMLY BE=E WE PRESUME TO =GE ! FUTURE4 ,( C\RSE1 ! MAJORITY ( ! POLITICAL 0VIEW]S0 DI/RIBUT$ AMONG ! V>I\S CAMPS W]E NOT IMPRESS$ BY :AT ,/AL9 HAD COME BACK TO 9 A SUGGE/IVE WAY1 BUT BY :AT HE ANTICIPAT$ AB\T AN UNC]TA9 FUTURE4 ,RU%+ ONTO IT 7BECAUSE ?AT'S :AT IS CAUS+ A /IR7 NEI!R FRI5D NOR FOE UND]/OOD A S+LE WORD & PRES5T$ /RANGE & EXAGG]AT$ V]SIONS4 ,! P]SPECTIVE - ?AT IS !IR OBSESSION4 ,IF ! OBS]V]S >E A BUN* ( FOOLS1 ! MA*9I/ IS NO BETT] (F3 ,HE1 :O />TS ! MA*9E FROM HIS HI< PRISON1 ! HIE CONC]N$ ) :AT CAME TO HIM AS A RESULT ( HIS RETROSPECT 7:]E HE IS NOT BLOCK$ BY KIPP]S & A LOT ( :IRLW9D74 ,9 ACCORDANCE ) ! EXI/5TIALI/ CR$O1 EV]YONE OBEYS ! UTT]LY DUMB IMP]ATIVE3 TO TALK1 & ! POLITICAL PRESS PROVIDES 5T]TA9M5T JU/ :5 IT REVEALS ! FUTURE & REPORTS AB\T PROPHECIES ?AT A 0GREAT NAME0 HAS L[]$ ITSELF D[N TO PRON\NCE4 ,?IS TIME SOME?+ UNEXPECT$ CAME AB\T3 NO?+ ( WORLD REVOLUTION1 NO?+ ( PEACE ANYMORE1 BUT ALSO NO 0HOLY0 W> BETWE5 ,RUSSIA & ! RE/ ( ! WORLD1 BUT RA!R ! 9EVITABLE W> BETWE5 ! CAPITALI/ /ATES1 :I* ,RUSSIA - = ! TIME BE+ - IS NOT C\NT$ AMONG4 ,NO NEWS = ,M>XISM1 BUT ALSO 9T]E/+ = US :O DO NOT HAVE A P>TICUL> FONDNESS = POLITICAL C9EMA1 :]E ! C9EMA-GO] DOESN'T C>E MU* :E!R :AT HE SEES IS 0REALLY TRUE0 OR NOT4 ,& 9 ! DREAM WORLD ( ! L& ( B\NDLESS OPPORTUNITIES1 LUXURI\S RE/AURANTS1 :ITE TELEPHONES OR ! EMBRACE ( A FLAWLESS SUP]V5US MADE ( CELLULOID1 ! SPECTATOR1 ! SMALL EMPLOYEE OR ! WAGE SLAVE1 RETURNS CONT5T$LY TO HIS HOVEL1 :]E HE APPROA*ES HIS WIFE1 :O IS EMB>RASS$ BY ! TR\BLES ( WORK1 IF HE DOES NOT REPLACE H] ) A /REET BEAUTY4 ,WELL1 9/EAD ( FOCUS+ ON ! />T+ PO9T - BECAUSE ?AT IS ESS5TIAL - EV]YONE HAS RU%$ TO ! 5D4 ,ONE W\LD HAVE TO PUT A /OP TO ?IS :OLE FLOCK ( HALF-IDIOTS1 :O CRUMBL$ !IR HEADS OV] ! 0AFT]10 & REPULSE ! /UDY ( ! 0BE=E02 ?AT W\LD BE A LOT EASI]1 BUT !Y CAN'T ?9K ( ?AT4 ,AL?\< ONE DOES NOT UND]/& ! OP5$ PAGE1 ONE DOES NOT RESI/ ! TEMPTATION TO TURN ! PAGE FUR!R1 9 ! HOPE ( BECOM+ WISE AFT] ALL FROM ! PREVI\S ONE2 SO IT HAPP5S ?AT ! FOOL BECOMES MORE & MORE /UPID4 ,9 :ATEV] %APE ! POLICE COMM&+ PUBLIC PEACE1 :O ! ,WE/ IS SO DISGU/$ AT 7:]E ! MEANS ( DULL+ & /&>DIZ+ ! SKULLS >E T5 TIMES BIGG] & MORE REPUGNANT73 ,! DEF9ITION ( ! SOCIAL /AGE REA*$ & ! RUNN+ ECONOMIC :EELWORK 9 ,RUSSIA IS A QUE/ION ?AT IMPOSES ITSELF - LEAD+ TO ! FOLL[+ DILEMMA3 ,%\LD WE CONT9UE TO CLAIM ?AT ! ,RUSSIAN ECONOMY IS SOCIALI/1 RESPECTIVELY 9 ! FIR/ /AGE ( COMMUNISM1 OR DO WE HAVE TO ADMIT ?AT DESPITE /ATE 9DU/RIALISM1 IT IS GOV]N$ BY ! LAW ( VALUE 9H]5T TO CAPITALISM8 ,/AL9 SEEMS TO BE ATTACK+ ! LA/ !SIS & SL[+ D[N ECONOMI/S & PLANT MANAG]S :O >E 9 A HURRY TO ACCEPT IT4 ,9 REALITY1 HE IS PREP>+ ! CONFESSION.<#f.> ?AT WILL SOON FOLL[ & BE USEFUL 9 ! REVOLUTION>Y S5SE AS WELL4 ,BUT ! BULL%IT ORGANIZ$ BY ! 0FREE WORLD0 READS FROM IT ! ANN\NCEM5T ( ! TRANSITION TO ! HI<] /AGE ( FULL COMMUNISM6 ,9 ORD] TO BR+ ! QUE/ION TO ! =E1 ,/AL9 MAKES USE ( ! CLASSICAL ME?OD4 ,IT W\LD BE EASY TO BET ON A DIFF]5T COLOR ?AT W\LD FREE HIM FROM ANY OBLIGATION TO ,M>X & ,L59'S S*OOL1 BUT EV5 ! BANK ITSELF C\LD BE BL[N UP AT ?IS /AGE ( ! GAME4 ,SO 9/EAD WE />T FROM OVO4 ,WELL1 ?AT IS ALL RIN$ FROM *ILDHOOD ON3 \R CAUSE IS ?AT ( ! PROLET>IAT1 :I* HAS NO?+ TO LOSE4 ,/AL9 EXPLA9S ?AT A 0TEXTBOOK ( ! ,M>XI/ ECONOMY0 IS NECESS>Y 7WE >E 9 #a#i#e#b71 NOT ONLY = ! ,SOVIET Y\?1 BUT ALSO = COMRADES 9 O!R C\NTRIES4 ,SO WAT* \T1 9EXP]I5C$ & =GETFUL6 ,TO 9CLUDE A *APT] ON ,L59 & ,/AL9 AS ! F\ND]S ( ! POLITICAL ECONOMY ( SOCIALISM 9 SU* A BOOK1 EV5 ,/AL9 CONSID]S SUP]FLU\S BECAUSE IT W\LD NOT BR+ ANY?+ NEW4 ,?AT'S RIN$ IT - ,L59 ALWAYS EMPHASIZ$ ?IS4 ,N[ ?AT WE >E MOV+ ON TO ! FIELD ( /RICT T]M9OLOGY & 0S*OOL0 WORD+1 WE MU/ SAY 9 ADVANCE ?AT WE HAVE A PREPR9T ( ,/AL9'S TEXT1 :I* ! ,/AL9I/ NEWSPAP]S !MSELVES HAVE TAK5 FROM A NON-,RUSSIAN PRESS AG5CY4 ,WE WILL LOOK UP 9 ! FULL TEXT AS SOON AS POSSIBLE.<#g.>4 ,COMMODITIES & ,SOCIALISM ,! REF]5CE TO ! BASIC ELEM5TS ( ,M>XI/ ECONOMICS S]VES ,/AL9 TO DISCUSS ! 0SY/EM ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION 9 SOCIALISM40 ,WE HAVE EXPLA9$ 9 V>I\S TEXTS 7AVOID+ TO SAY ANY?+ NEW7 ?AT EV]Y SY/EM ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION IS A NON-SOCIALI/ SY/EM2 ?IS IS EXACTLY :AT WE WILL REAFFIRM4 ,IF ,/AL9 7,/AL91 AGA9 & AGA9 ,/AL92 WE >E DEAL+ H]E ) AN >TICLE ?AT C\LD JU/ AS WELL HAVE COME FROM A COMMISSION ?AT C\LD 09 #a YE>S0 HAVE REPLAC$ OR DISCR$IT$ ,/AL93 = SIMPLICITY'S SAKE1 H[EV]1 IT IS USEFUL TO USE NAMES AS SYMBOLS = COMPLEX EV5TS & CONTEXTS7 HAD SPOK5 ( A SY/EM ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION AFT] ! CONQUE/ ( P[] BY ! PROLET>IAT1 ?IS W\LD NOT HAVE BE5 A MON/ROSITY4 ,REF]R+ TO ,5GELS1 IT SEEMS ?AT SOME 0COMRADES0 9 ,RUSSIA HAVE SAID ?AT ! MA9T5ANCE ( ! SY/EM ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION 7RESPECTIVELY ! COMMODITY *>ACT] ( ! PRODUCTS7 AFT] NATIONALIZATION ( ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION MEANT TO MA9TA9 ! CAPITALI/ ECONOMIC SY/EM4 ,/AL9 IS C]TA9LY NOT ! MAN :O C\LD !ORETICALLY PROVE !M WRONG4 ,IF1 H[EV]1 !Y SAY ?AT1 9 CASE !Y SAY IT1 ONE HAD BE5 ABLE TO ELIM9ATE COMMODITY PRODUCTION & HAD ONLY NEGLECT$ OR =GOTT5 IT1 !N !Y %\LD BE MI/AK54 ,BUT ,/AL9 WANTS TO PROVE ?AT 9 A 0SOCIALI/ C\NTRY0 7A WORD BELONG+ TO A QUE/IONABLE S*OOL7 COMMODITY PRODUCTION CAN EXI/1 & HE DRAWS UPON ! ,M>XI/ DEF9ITIONS & !IR CLE>1 ALBEIT P]HAPS NOT 5TIRELY FLAWLESS1 SYN!SIS 9 ,L59'S PROPAG&A BRO*URE.<#h.>4 ,WE HAVE DEALT SEV]AL TIMES ) ?IS SUBJECT1 I4 E4 COMMODITY PRODUCTION1 ITS EM]G5CE & RULE1 ITS CLE>LY CAPITALI/ *>ACT]4.<#i.> ,ACCORD+ TO ,JOSEF ,/AL91 PRECISE PLANS CAN BE DRAWN UP )9 COMMODITY PRODUCTION )\T FE>+ ?AT ! T]RIBLE MAEL/ROM ( ! COMMODITY WORLD WILL DRAW ! C>ELESS PILOT 9TO ! MIDDLE ( ! VORTEX & DEV\R HIM 9 ! CAPITALI/ ABYSS4 ,H[EV]1 HIS >TICLE REVEALS 7TO :OM READ+ IT AS A ,M>XI/7 ?AT ! VORTEXES >E BECOM+ EV] TIACT]3 IT SATISFIES SOME HUMAN NE$ & IS EX*ANGEABLE = ANO!R ?+4 ,& ! L9ES JU/ BE=E SAY SIMPLY3 0,9 CAPITALI/ SOCIETY1 ! PRODUCTION ( COMMODITIES IS PR$OM9ANT1 & ,M>X'S ANALYSIS !RE=E BEG9 ) AN ANALYSIS ( COMMODITY40 ,! COMMODITY ?US POSSESSES !SE TWO *>ACT]I/ICS1 & IT DOES ONLY BECOME A COMMODITY :5 ! SECOND *>ACT]I/IC IS ADD$ TO ! FIR/4 ,! FIR/1 USE VALUE1 IS COMPREH5DABLE EV5 = FLAT MAT]IALI/S LIKE US1 EV5 = A *ILD4 ,IT CAN BE S5SUALLY EXP]I5C$3 ONCE LICK$ ON A PIECE ( SUG>1 WE /RET* \T \R H&S ONCE MORE = A SUG> CUBE4 ,BUT ! ROAD IS LONG - ,M>X FLIES OV] IT 9 ?IS GREAT P>AGRAPH - UNTIL ! SUG> TAKES ON AN EX*ANGE VALUE & ONE COMES TO ! DELICATE PROBLEM ( ,/AL91 :O IS SURPRIS$ ?AT ONE E/ABLI%$ AN EQUIVAL5CE BETWE5 GRA9 & COTTON4 ,M>X1 ,L591 ,/AL9 & WE KN[ V]Y WELL :AT A HELL DANCE IS GO+ ON AS SOON AS EX*ANGE VALUE APPE>S4 ,:AT DID ,L59 SAY8 ,:]E ! B\RGEOIS ECONOMI/S SAW RELATION%IPS BETWE5 ?+S1 ,M>X DISCOV]$ RELATION%IPS BETWE5 PEOPLE6 ,:AT DO ! ?REE VOLUMES ( ,M>X'S 0,CAPITAL0 & ! NE>LY #e PAGES ( ,L59'S WORK PROVE8 ,V]Y SIMPLE4 ,:]E CONV5TIONAL ECONOMICS SEES P]FECT EQUIVAL5CE 9 EX*ANGE1 WE NO LONG] SEE EX*ANGEABLE ?+S1 BUT PEOPLE 9 A SOCIAL MOVEM5T1 WE NO LONG] SEE EQUIVAL5CE1 BUT A SCAM4 ,K>L ,M>X SPEAKS ( A SPOOK ?AT GIVES ! GOODS ?IS /RANGE & AT FIR/ GLANCE 9COMPREH5SIBLE *>ACT]4 ,L591 LIKE ANY O!R ,M>XI/1 W\LD HAVE GRABB$ ! COLD HORROR AT ! IDEA ( BE+ ABLE TO PRODUCE & EX*ANGE GOODS :ILE AT ! SAME TIME EXPELL+ !IR 9H]5T DEVIL ?R\< EXORCISM4 ,DOES ,/AL9 BELIEVE ?AT8 ,OR DOES HE JU/ WANT TO TELL US ?AT ! DEVIL IS /RONG] ?AN HIMSELF8 ,JU/ AS ! TY CONV5TION1 ONE CAN HE> GLOAT+ LAU4 ,:5 HE WANTS TO E/ABLI% ?AT COMMODITY PRODUCTION & CAPITALISM >E NOT ABSOLUTELY ID5TICAL1 ,/AL9 AGA9 MAKES USE ( \R ME?OD4 ,FOLL[+ ! HI/ORICAL C\RSE BACKW>DS1 HE PO9TS \T1 LIKE ,M>X1 ?AT 9 C]TA9 =MS ( SOCIETY 7SLAVEKEEP] ORD]1 FEUDALISM1 ETC47 COMMODITY PRODUCTION EXI/$ BUT 0DID NOT LEAD TO CAPITALISM40 ,?IS IS 9DE$ :AT ,M>X SAYS 9 A PASSAGE ( HIS HI/ORICAL SUMM>Y1 BUT HE HAS DEVELOP$ IT QUITE DIFF]5TLY & ) A COMPLETELY DIFF]5T AIM4 ,! B\RGEOIS ECONOMI/ CLAIMS ?AT ! SY/EM ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION IS ! ONLY POSSIBLE ME*ANISM TO COMB9E PRODUCTION ) CONSUMPTION - HE KN[S ALL TOO WELL ?AT AS LONG AS ?IS ME*ANISM IS 9 PLACE1 CAPITAL WILL CONT9UE TO DOM9ATE ! WORLD4 ,M>X REPLIES3 ,WE WILL SEE :]E ! HI/ORICAL TR5D IS HEAD+2 FIR/ ( ALL1 ,I =CE Y\ TO ACKN[L$GE ! IRREFUTABLE FACTS ( ! PA/3 IT WASN'T ALWAYS COMMODITY PRODUCTION ?AT 5SUR$ ?AT ! CONSUM] WAS SUPPLI$ ) ! PRODUCT ( LABOR4 ,AS EXAMPLES1 HE M5TIONS ! PRIMITIVE SOCIETIES BAS$ ON COLLECT+ & DIRECT CONSUMPTION1 ! ANCI5T =MS ( ! FAMILY & ! TRIBE1 ! FEUDAL SY/EM ( DIRECT CONSUMPTION )9 SELF-SUFFICI5T CIRCLES1 9 :I* ! PRODUCTS DID NOT HAVE TO TAKE ON A COMMODITY =M4 ,) ! DEVELOPM5T & COMPLEXITY ( TE*NOLOGY & NE$S1 SECTORS EM]GE ?AT >E FIR/ SUPPLI$ BY B>T] TRADE & !N BY ACTUAL TRADE4 ,:I* PROVES ?AT COMMODITY PRODUCTION1 9CLUD+ PRIVATE PROP]TY1 IS NEI!R 0NATURAL0 NOR1 AS ! B\RGEOIS CLAIMS1 P]MAN5T & ET]NAL4 ,! LATE APPE>ANCE ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION 7! SY/EM ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION1 AS ,/AL9 SAYS7 & ITS EXI/5CE ON ! SIDEL9ES ( O!R MODES ( PRODUCTION S]VE ,M>X TO %[ ?AT COMMODITY PRODUCTION1 AFT] IT HAS BECOME UNIV]SAL1 JU/ AFT] ! SPREAD ( ! CAPITALI/ PRODUCTION SY/EM1 MU/ GO D[N ) IT4 ,IT W\LD TAKE TOO LONG IF WE WANT$ TO CITE ! ,M>XI/ PASSAGES DIRECT$ AGA9/ ,PR\DHON1 ,LASSALLE1 ,RODB]TUS & MANY O!RS1 D5\NC+ ANY ATTEMPT TO RECONCILE COMMODITY PRODUCTION ) ! SOCIALI/ EMANCIPATION ( ! PROLET>IAT4 ,= ,L591 ?IS IS ! CORN]/ONE ( ,M>XISM4 ,IT W\LD BE QUITE DIFFICULT TO RECONCILE IT ) ,/AL9'S CURR5T !SIS3 0,:Y !N1 ONE ASKS1 CANNOT COMMODITY PRODUCTION SIMIL>LY S]VE \R SOCIALI/ SOCIETY = A C]TA9 P]IOD0 OR 0,COMMODITY PRODUCTION LEADS TO CAPITALISM ONLY IF !RE IS PRIVATE [N]%IP ( ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION1 IF LABOR P[] APPE>S 9 ! M>KET AS A COMMODITY :I* CAN BE B\XI/ ANALYSIS1 ANY EXI/5CE ( A MASS ( COMMODITIES SUGGE/S ?AT RES]VELESS PROLET>IANS HAD TO SELL !IR LABOR-P[]4 ,IF 9 ! PA/ !RE WAS COMMODITY PRODUCTION LIMIT$ TO A FEW BRAN*ES1 IT WAS NOT BECAUSE ! LABOR-P[] WAS SOLD 0VOLUNT>ILY0 AS IT IS TODAY1 BUT RA!R BECAUSE IT WAS SQUEEZ$ BY =CE ( >MS FROM 5SLAV$ PRISON]S OR S]FS 9 P]SONAL DEP5D5CY4 ,DO WE HAVE TO QUOTE ! FIR/ TWO L9ES ( 0,CAPITAL0 AGA98 0,! WEAL? ( ?OSE SOCIETIES 9 :I* ! CAPITALI/ MODE ( PRODUCTION PREVAILS1 PRES5TS ITSELF AS 'AN IMM5SE ACCUMULATION ( COMMODITIES'40 ,! ,RUSSIAN ,ECONOMY ,AFT] ! TEXT HAS MORE OR LESS SKILLFULLY DEMON/RAT$ TO %[ RESPECT = ! ORIG9S ( ,M>XISM1 IT MOVES ON TO ! QUE/ION ( TODAY'S ,RUSSIAN ECONOMY4 ,! TASK IS TO SIL5CE ?OSE :O WANT TO HAVE DET]M9$ ?AT ! SY/EM ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION 9EVITABLY LEADS TO ! RE/ORATION ( CAPITALISM - & ?US ALSO US1 :O EV5 MORE CLE>LY SAY3 COMMODITY PRODUCTION ONLY SURVIVES 9 SO F> AS WE >E )9 A TOTALLY CAPITALI/ SY/EM4 ,9 ! FAM\S ,/AL9 PAMPHLET ONE F9DS !SE CONCESSIONS REG>D+ ! ,RUSSIAN ECONOMY3 EV5 IF ! L>GE FIRMS >E SOCIALIZ$1 ! SMALL & M$IUM-SIZ$ FIRMS H[EV] >5'T EXPROPRIAT$3 ON ! CONTR>Y1 ?IS W\LD 0BE EQUAL TO A CRIME40 ,ACCORD+ TO ! AU?OR1 !Y %\LD TRANSITION 9TO COOP]ATIVE FIRMS4 ,CURR5TLY !RE >E TWO SECTORS ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION 9 ,RUSSIA3 ON ! ONE H& ! PUBLIC1 0NATIONALLY [N$0 PRODUCTION4 ,9 ! /ATE-[N$ 5T]PRISES1 ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION & PRODUCTION ITSELF1 ?US ALSO ! PRODUCTS1 >E NATIONAL PROP]TY4 ,H[ SIMPLI/IC3 9 ,ITALY1 ! TOBACCO FACTORIES & ACCORD+LY !IR SOLD CIG>ETTES >E [N$ BY ! /ATE4 ,DOES ?IS ALREADY QUALIFY = ! ASS]TION ?AT ONE IS 9 A PHASE ( ! 0ABOLI%M5T ( ! WAGE LABOR SY/EM0 & ! RESPECTIVE WORK]S W]5'T 0=C$0 TO SELL !IR LABOR P[]8 ,SURELY NOT4 ,LET'S MOVE ON TO ! O!R SECTOR3 AGRICULTURE4 ,9 ! KOLKHOZES1 SAYS ! BRO*URE1 L& & MA*9ES >E /ATE PROP]TY1 BUT ! PRODUCTS ( LABOR DON'T BELONG TO ! /ATE1 BUT TO ! KOLKHOZ4 ,& ! KOLKHOZ %$S ONLY FROM !M BECAUSE !Y >E COMMODITIES1 :I* >E EX*ANGEABLE = O!R COMMODITIES ?AT ONE NE$S4 ,!RE IS NO L9K BETWE5 ! RURAL KOLKHOZ & ! URBAN REGIONS :I* IS NOT BAS$ ON EX*ANGE4 0,!RE=E COMMODITY PRODUCTION & COMMODITY CIRCULATION >E /ILL SU* A NECESSITY AS !Y HAVE BE5 ?IRTY YE>S AGO = EXAMPLE40 ,LET'S PUT ASIDE = A MOM5T ! >GUM5T AB\T ! REMOTE POSSIBILITY ( OV]COM+ ?IS SITUATION4 ,IT IS TO BE NOT$ ?AT :AT ,L59 PROPOS$ 9 #aibb IS \T ( ! QUE/ION3 0,WE WIELD ! POLITICAL P[] 9 \R H&S1 & WE WILL P]SEV]E MILIT>ILY1 BUT 9 ! ECONOMIC DOMA9 WE NE$ TO FALL BACK ON ! PURELY CAPITALI/ =M ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION40 ,COROLL>Y ( ?IS /ATEM5T WAS3 IF WE 9T]RUPT = A C]TA9 TIME ! ]ECTION ( ! SOCIALI/ ECONOMY1 WE WILL GET BACK AT IT AFT] ! ,EUROPEAN REVOLUTION4 ,TODAY'S PROPOSITIONS >E DIAMETRICALLY OPPOS$ TO ?IS4 ,ONE DOESN'T EV5 TRY ANYMORE TO MAKE A CASE SU* AS ! FOLL[+3 9 ! TRANSITION FROM CAPITALISM TO SOCIALISM C]TA9 SECTORS ( PRODUCTION = A :ILE >E /ILL SUBJECT$ TO COMMODITY PRODUCTION4 ,9/EAD1 ONE SIMPLY SAYS3 EV]Y?+ IS A COMMODITY2 !RE IS NO O!R ECONOMIC FRAMEWORK BUT ?AT ( COMMODITY EX*ANGE & ACCORD+LY ( ! BUY+ ( LABOR P[]1 NOT EV5 9 /ATE-[N$1 L>GE FIRMS4 ,9DE$1 FROM :]E DOES ! FACTORY WORK] GET HIS MEANS ( SUBSI/5CE8 ,! KOLKHOZ SELLS !M TO HIM M$IAT$ BY PRIVATE M]*ANTS2 PREF]ABLY IT SELLS !M TO ! /ATE1 FROM :I* IT OBTA9S TOOLS1 F]TILIZ] ETC42 ! WORK] !N MU/ PROCURE ! MEANS ( SUBSI/5CE 9 ! /ATE-[N$ /ORES = H>D-E>N$ RUBLES4 ,C\LDN'T ! /ATE DI/RIBUTE ! PRODUCTS1 ( :I* IT CAN DISPOSE1 DIRECTLY TO ITS WORK]S8 ,SURELY NOT1 BECAUSE ! WORK] 7ESPECIALLY ! ,RUSSIAN ONE7 DOESN'T CONSUME TRACTORS1 VEHICLES1 LOCOMOTIVES1 NOT TO SPEAK ( CANNONS & MA*9E GUNS4 ,& CLO?+ & FURNITURE >E ( C\RSE PRODUC$ 9 ! SMALL- & M$IUM-SIZ$ FIRMS UNT\*$ BY ! /ATE4 ,! /ATE !RE=E CAN GIVE ! WORK]S :I* >E DEP5D5T UPON IT NO?+ BUT A MONET>Y WAGE1 ) :I* !Y !N BUY :AT !Y WANT 7A B\RGEOIS EUPHEMISM =3 ! LITTLE !Y CAN BUY74 ,?AT ! WAGE-DI/RIBUT+ 5TREPR5EUR IS ! /ATE1 :I* PRES5TS ITSELF AS ! 0IDEAL0 OR 0LEGITIMATE0 REPRES5TATIVE ( ! WORK+ CLASS1 DOESN'T SAY ! SLI*Y & ,DESPOTISM ,/AL9 APPROA*ES SOME ,M>XI/ GOALS1 :I* WE CONT9U\SLY BR\ATION BETWE5 MANUAL & M5TAL LABOR & TO ]ASE ! LEFTOV]S ( B\RGEOIS IDEOLOGY4 ,AT ! ASSEMBLY 9 ,JULY #aieb 9 ,ROME1 WE DEALT ) ! TOPIC ( ! #a#b4 *APT] ( 0,CAPITAL03 0,SEP>ATION ( LABOR & FACTORY10 = 0FACTORY0 READ 0BUS9ESS40 ,IT WAS %[N3 TO LEAVE CAPITALISM1 ALONG ) ! SY/EM ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION1 ! SOCIAL DIVISION ( LABOR - ( :I* ,/AL9 ALSO SPEAKS - & AS WELL ! TE*NICAL1 RESPECTIVELY MANAG]IAL DIVISION ( LABOR1 :I* LEADS TO ! BRUTALIZATION ( ! WORK] & :I* IS ! ORIG9 ( FACTORY DESPOTISM1 MU/ BE DE/ROY$4 ,! TWO AXES ( ! B\RGEOIS SY/EM >E SOCIAL AN>*Y & FACTORY DESPOTISM4 ,9 ,/AL91 WE CAN AT LEA/ RECOGNIZE ! /RUGGLE TO FIY ,RUSSIA IS MOV+ T[>DS ! DIRECTION ( ! PROGRAMMATICAL GOALS1 NEI!R ?OSE NAM$ BY ,/AL91 NOR ?OSE ( :I* NOBODY TALKS ANYWAY4 ,IF A - TODAY AS TOMORR[ 9SURM\NTABLE - B>RI] IS L[]$ D[N BETWE5 /ATE FIRM & KOLKHOZ1 :I* ONLY LIFTS TO ALL[ = BUS9ESS 0= MUTUAL GA90 TO BE MADE1 :AT %\LD BR+ T[N & C\NTRY CLOS] TOGE!R1 :AT %\LD FREE ! WORK] FROM ! NECESSITY TO SELL TOO MANY WORK+ H\RS = LITTLE MONEY1 RESPECTIVELY A FEW MEANS ( SUBSI/5CE & GIVE HIM !RE=E ! POSSIBILITY ( DISPUT+ ! SCI5TIFIC & CULTURAL MONOPOLY ( CAPITALI/ TRADITION8 ,WE !RE=E NOT ONLY HAV5'T GOT ! FIR/ PHASE ( SOCIALISM 9 FRONT ( US1 BUT ALSO NOT EV5 A TOTAL /ATE CAPITALISM1 ?AT MEANS AN ECONOMY1 9 :I* - EV5 ?\< ALL PRODUCTS >E COMMODITIES & CIRCULATE = MONEY - ! /ATE DISPOSES ( EV]Y PRODUCT2 SO1 A =M 9 :I* ! /ATE CAN C5TRALLY DET]M9E ALL PROPORTIONS ( EQUIVAL5CE1 9CLUD+ LABOR P[]4 ,SU* A /ATE AS WELL C\LDN'T BE CONTROLL$ NOR CONQU]$ ECONOMICALLY_/POLITICALLY BY ! WORK+ CLASS & W\LD FUNCTION 9 S]VICE ( ! ANONYM\S & HIDD5LY OP]AT+ CAPITAL4 ,BUT ,RUSSIA IS F> AWAY FROM ?AT ANYWAYS3 ALL ?AT IS !RE1 IS ! AFT] ! ANTI-FEUDAL REVOLUTION >IS5 /ATE 9DU/RIALISM.<#a#a.>4 ,?ANKS TO PUBLIC 9VE/M5T 9 EXT5SIVE PUBLIC PROJECTS1 ?IS SY/EM ALL[$ = ! QUICK DEVELOPM5T & DISP]SION ( 9DU/RY & ( CAPITALISM1 ACCEL]AT$ ! B\RGEOIS TRANS=MATION ( AGRICULTURE & AGRICULTURAL LAW4 ,BUT ! 0COLLECTIVI/ ECONOMIC0 AGRICULTURAL BUS9ESSES HAVE NO?+ PUBLIC1 MU* LESS SOCIALI/ 9 !M3 !Y'RE ON ! LEVEL ( COOP]ATIVES1 JU/ AS !Y EXI/$ >\ND ! TURN ( ! C5TURY 9 ! ,ITALIAN ,PADAN ,PLA9 & :I* PRODUC$ ON LEAS$ OR 7(T5 \T ( /ATE [N]%IP7 B\ ( ?AT4 ,! 9DU/RIAL /ATE MU/ NEGOTIATE ! BUY+ ( ! MEANS ( CONSUMPTION ON ! 0FREE M>KET10 :I* MEANS ?AT WAGE & LABOR TIME >E ON ! SAME LEVEL AS 9 ! CAPITALI/ PRIVATE 9DU/RY4 ,CONC]N+ ! ECONOMIC DEVELOPM5T1 IT IS TO BE SAID ?AT = EXAMPLE ,AM]ICA IS CLOS] TO COMPLETE /ATE CAPITALISM ?AN ,RUSSIA3 AFT] ALL ! ,RUSSIAN WORK] HAS TO SP5D ?REE FIF?S ( HIS WAGE ON AGR>IAN PRODUCTS1 :]EAS ! ,AM]ICAN WORK] SP5DS ! SAME RATIO ON 9DU/RIAL PRODUCTS2 HE EV5 GETS ! FOOD DELIV]$ BY ! 9DU/RY = ! MO/ P>T 9 CANS - ! POOR DEVIL4 ,/ATE & ,RETREAT ,AT ?IS PO9T1 !RE IS ANO!R IMPORTANT QUE/ION TO BE POS$4 ,! RELATION%IP BETWE5 AGRICULTURE & 9DU/RY /AYS ON AN 5TIRELY B\RGEOIS LEVEL1 NO MATT] H[ SUB/ANTIAL ! 9EXORABLE PROGRESS ( 9DU/RY4 ,/AL9 CONFESSES1 ?AT NOT EV5 FUTURE 9T]V5TIONS 9TO ?IS RELATION >E TO BE EXPECT$1 :I* W\LD AM\NT TO MORE /ATISM1 MU* LESS SOCIALISM4 ,?IS DRAWBACK ALSO HIDES SUBTLY BEH9D ! ,M>XI/ DOCTR9E4 ,:AT CAN WE DO8 ,EXPROPRIATE ! KOLKHOZES BRUTALLY8 ,= ?AT WE W\LD NE$ TO MAKE USE ( ! /ATE P[]4 ,& PRECISELY H]E ,/AL9 RE9TRODUCES ! WI!R+ AWAY ( ! /ATE1 :I* HE WANT$ TO DO AWAY ) ON ANO!R OCCASION1 :]EAS HE BACK !N PUT A MASK ON1 AS IF HE WANT$ TO SAY3 0,Y\'RE ONLY MAK+ FUN1 RIIAN SECTOR IS /ILL COMMODITY BAS$ & PRIVATELY ORGANIZ$4 ,BECAUSE EV5 IF ONE W\LD = A MOM5T ACCEPT ! E>LI] CONTE/$ !SIS ( ! EXI/5CE ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION UND] SOCIALISM1 IT W\LD BE 9SEP>ABLE FROM ! O!R !SIS3 ,IF COMMODITY PRODUCTION ISN'T ABOLI%$ EV]Y:]E1 ! WI!R+ AWAY ( ! /ATE CANNOT BE ON ! TABLE4 ,ULTIMATELY1 WE CAN ONLY REASON ?AT ! FUNDAM5TAL RELATION BETWE5 T[N & C\NTRY 7?AT DUR+ ! DRAMATIC DEVELOPM5T ( ?\S&S ( YE>S FRE$ ITSELF FROM ,ASIATIC & FEUDAL =MS7 IS SOLV$ !RE EXACTLY AS CAPITALISM PLANS & :AT IS EXPRESS$ BY ! CLASSICAL1 9 B\RGEOIS C\NTRIES US$ WORDS3 ,TO REGULATE ! COMMODITY EX*ANGE BETWE5 9DU/RY- & AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTION RATIONALLY4 ,?IS SY/EM 0REQUIRES ?US A GIGANTIC 9CREASE0 ( 9DU/RIAL PRODUCTION .<,/AL91 P4 #i#e.>4 ,WELL !N6 ,IF ONE DISREG>DS = A MOM5T ! FANTASIZ$ CORRECT /ATE - A VIRTUALLY 0LIB]AL0 SOLUTION4 "9 "9 "9 ,! QUE/ION ( ! RELATION BETWE5 AGRICULTURE & 9DU/RY WAS ANSW]$ BY ! CONFESSION ( ! IMPOT5CE TO DO ANY?+ BUT TO 9DU/RIALIZE & TO 9CREASE PRODUCTION1 ?US AT ! EXP5SE ( ! WORK]S4 ,AT ?IS PO9T1 AS ALREADY M5TION$1 !RE >E ! O!R TWO GREAT QUE/IONS ( ! RELATION BETWE5 /ATE & BUS9ESS & AMONG BUS9ESSES TO BE POS$4 ,= ,/AL91 IT PRES5T$ ITSELF LIKE ?IS3 ,DOES ! LAW ( VALUE :I* APPLIES 9 CAPITALI/ PRODUCTION ALSO EXI/ 9 ,RUSSIA8 ,DOES IT ALSO APPLY = ! /ATE [N$1 L>GE SCALE 9DU/RY8 ,?IS LAW DET]M9ES1 ?AT COMMODITY EX*ANGE ALWAYS FOLL[S EQUIVAL5TS3 ! APPE>ANCE ( 0FRE$OM1 EQUALITY & ,B5?AM0.<#a#b.>1 :I* ,M>X DE/ROY$1 :5 HE %[$ ?AT CAPITALISM DOESN'T PRODUCE = ! PRODUCT1 BUT = PR(IT4 ,COMM& & CONTROL ( ! ECONOMIC LAWS - BETWE5 ?OSE TWO CLIFFS ,/AL9'S 0MANIFE/O0 MANEUV]S BACK & =? & ?US CONFIRMS \R !SIS3 ,9 ITS MO/ P[]FUL =M1 CAPITAL SUBORD9ATES ITSELF TO ! /ATE1 EV5 :5 ! /ATE APPE>S AS ! JUDICIAL SOLE [N] ( ALL BUS9ESSES4 ,ON ! SECOND DAY1 OH ,S*EH]AZADE.<#a#c.>1 WE WILL TELL Y\ ( ?AT1 & ON ! ?IRD DAY ( ! WORLD M>KET & W>4 ,SECOND ,DAY ,TO PRECISELY DEF9E ! ECONOMY ( CONTEMPOR>Y ,RUSSIA1 WE ON ! FIR/ DAY ( ?IS DISPUTE ) ,/AL9'S 0ANSW]S0 TO \R ,M>XI/ 9QUIRIES & DEMON/RATIONS MA9LY CONC]N$ \RSELVES EMPHASIZ+ ! 9COMM5SURAT5ESS ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION & SOCIALI/ ECONOMY4 ,= US1 EV]Y SY/EM ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION 9 ! MOD]N WORLD1 A WORLD ( ASSOCIAT$ LABOR1 ?AT IS ! AGGREGATION ( WORK]S 9 PRODUCTION PLANTS1 IS DEF9$ AS CAPITALI/ ECONOMY4 ,LET'S N[ GET TO ! QUE/ION ( ! /AGES ( SOCIALI/ ECONOMY 7BETT]3 ( SOCIALI/ ORGANIZATION7 & ! DI/9CTION BETWE5 L[] & HI<] /AGE ( COMMUNISM4 ,TO GET AWAY FROM ! DEF9ITION ( 0IMMOVABLE0 & ?US AB/RACT SY/EMS & TO PUT \RSELVES ON ! GR\ND ( HI/ORY1 LET'S ANTICIPATE ! C5TRAL ASS]TION ( \R DOCTR9E3 ,! TRANSITION FROM CAPITALI/ TO SOCIALI/ ECONOMY DOESN'T HAPP5 9 AN 9/ANT1 BUT 9 A LONG PROCESS4 ,WE MU/ ?US ASSUME1 ?AT = A RELATIVELY LONG P]IOD !RE MIE B\KET ECONOMY EXI/S 7HE FUR!R CONFIRMS ! EXI/5CE ( PRIVATE ECONOMY1 9S(> AS SOME MEANS ( PRODUCTION >E 9 PRIVATE [N]%IP AS WELL71 & HE ASS]TS ?AT ! 9DU/RIAL SECTOR 7L>GE SCALE 9DU/RY7 ONLY PRODUCES COMMODITIES :5 GOODS = CONSUMPTION1 BUT NOT :5 GOODS = PRODUCTION >E PRODUC$4 ,NEV]!LESS HE ACTS CONV9C$1 TO NOT ONLY BE ABLE TO CALL ! SECTOR ( L>GE SCALE 9DU/RY1 BUT ! 5TIRE ,RUSSIAN ECONOMY SOCIALI/1 EV5 ?\< COMMODITY PRODUCTION CONT9UES TO PREVAIL ON A BIG BASIS4 ,WE ADDRESS$ ALL ?IS ALREADY 9 \R TEXTS1 :I* DEALT ) ! BASIC DOCUM5TS ( ,M>XISM & ! DATA ( G5]AL ECONOMIC HI/ORY2 TODAY WE MU/ MOVE OV] TO ! QUE/ION ( ! 0ECONOMIC LAWS10 P>TICUL>LY 0! LAW ( VALUE40 ,C]TA9TIES & UNC]TA9TIES ,LET'S FIR/ REM>K3 ,TO MEET ! OBJECTIONS ( ,RUSSIAN ECONOMI/S1 ?AT 9VOKE ,5GELS TO CL>IFY ?AT ONE CAN ONLY LEAVE CAPITALISM IF ONE LEAVES COMMODITY PRODUCTION1 ?AT CAPITALISM IS ONLY OV]COME :]E COMMODITY PRODUCTION IS OV]COME1 ,/AL9 ONLY TRIES TO READ SOME?+ DIFF]5T \T ( A S+LE P>AGRAPH 9 0,ANTI-,DUHR+0 ?AN :AT IS WRITT5 !RE1 :]EAS 9 ! 5TIRE SECTION 0,SOCIALISM3 ,!ORETICAL - ,PRODUCTION - ,DI/RIBUTION0 ,5GELS DEVELOPS ! ADDRESS$ !SIS - & V]Y WELL-TAILOR$ = ! ,/AL9I/ ,DUHR+ AS WELL4 ,! P>AGRAPH READS3 0,) ! SEIZ+ ( ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION BY SOCIETY PRODUCTION ( COMMODITIES IS DONE AWAY )1 &1 SIMULTANE\SLY1 ! MA/]Y ( ! PRODUCT OV] ! PRODUC]440 ,5GELS1 REM>KS ,/AL91 DIDN'T SPECIFY :E!R ?IS CONC]NS 0ALL0 OR ONLY 0A P>T0 ( ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION4 ,! DI/9CTION MIT TO ONE1 FROM A !ORETICAL PO9T ( VIEW H[EV]1 IT IS WRONG4 ,ONLY1 SO ,/AL9 FUR!R1 ! SOCIAL SEIZ+ ( 0ALL0 MEANS ( PRODUCTION 7,SMALL & L>GE SCALE 9DU/RY1 AGRICULTURE7 ALL[S TO 0GET RID0 ( ! SY/EM ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION4 ,C>AMBA6 ,9 #aiai WE BE/IRR$ \RSELVES TOGE!R ) ,L59 7& ,/AL97 UNTIL EXHAU/ION1 TO =CE D[N ! /UBBORN SOCIAL DEMOCRATS' & AN>*I/S' ?ROATS1 ?AT ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION CANNOT BE CONQU]$ ON A S+LE DAY & BY C\P1 & ?AT PRECISELY BECAUSE ( ?IS - & ONLY BECAUSE ( ?IS - ! T]ROR1 ! DICTATOR%IP1 IS NECESS>Y4 ,& TODAY1 NEW TEXTBOOKS ON POLITICAL ECONOMY %ALL BE PUBLI%$1 ?AT ! ABSURDITY1 ?AT ALL PRODUCTS LOSE !IR *>ACT] AS COMMODITIES ON ! DAY ON :I* A FUNCTION>Y ASC5D$ TO ! ,KREML9 PRES5TS SOME ,/AL9 ) A DECREE = SIGNATURE1 :I* EXPROPRIATES ! LA/ *ICK5 ( ! LA/ MEMB] ( ! LA/ KOLKHOZ1 IS ACCEPT$4 ,9 ANO!R P>AGRAPH1 ,5GELS TALKS AB\T ! SEIZ+ ( ALL MEANS ( PRODUCTION1 :I* IS :Y WE N[ NE$ TO HE> ?AT ! ABOVE CIT$ 0=MULA ( ,5GELS CANNOT BE DESCRIB$ AS 5TIRELY CLE> & EXACT0 .<,/AL91 P4 #a#a.>4 ,BY ! BE>D ( ! PROPHET ,ABRAHAM1 ?AT'S /RONG /UFF6 ,FRI$RI* ,5GELS1 ( ALL PEOPLE1 ! CONTEMPLATIVE1 CALM1 %>PLY DEF9+1 CRY/AL CLE> ,FRI$RI*1 MA/] ( ! PATI5CE TO GET A HOL$ %IP GO+ AGA9 & TO /RAIE UNREA*ABLE 7BEH9D ! IMPETU\S ,M>X1 :O OCCASIONALLY MI SIY WORD1 NOR ADDS AN UNNECESS>Y ONE3 ( ALL PEOPLE1 ONE ACCUSES HIM ( A LACK ( PRECISION & CL>ITY6 ,ONE MU/ PUT ?+S 9TO !IR PLACE3 ,WE >E NOT 9 ! ORGANIZATIONAL (FICE OR 9 ! AGITATION COMMITTEE H]E1 :]E Y\1 EX-COMRADE ,JOSEF1 MIE 9 ! S*OOL ( PR9CIPLES H]E4 ,:]E IS ! TALK ( ! SEIZURE ( ALL MEANS ( PRODUCTION8 ,MAYBE !RE1 :]E ! TALK IS ( COMMODITIES8 ,NEV]4 0,S9CE ! HI/ORICAL APPE>ANCE ( ! CAPITALI/ MODE ( PRODUCTION1 ! APPROPRIATION BY SOCIETY ( ALL ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION HAS (T5 BE5 DREAM$ (1 MORE OR LESS VAGUELY1 BY 9DIVIDUALS1 AS WELL AS BY SECTS1 AS ! IDEAL ( ! FUTURE410 REM9DS US ,5GELS4 ,PRECISELY BECAUSE = US IT IS NOT A ?+ ( AN IDEAL1 BUT ( SCI5CE1 WE CANNOT LET A 0MORE OR LESS0 CLE>1 RESPECTIVELY UNCLE>1 PASS4 ,& :5 ,5GELS1 A FEW PAGES ON1 TALKS AB\T SOCIETY AS MI/RESS ( ALL MEANS ( PRODUCTION1 !N PRECISELY 9 ! PASSAGE1 :]E HE DEALS ) ! 5TIRETY ( DEM&S3 BECAUSE ONLY ?R\< ?IS UPHEAVAL WILL ! EMANCIPATION ( ALL 9DIVIDUALS BE A*IEV$4 ,5GELS !N %[S1 ?AT ! SUBLATION ( ! DIVIDE BETWE5 T[N & C\NTRY1 MANUAL & M5TAL LABOR1 ! SOCIAL & PR(ESSIONAL DIVISION ( LABOR WAS ALREADY DEM&$ BY ! UTOPIANS1 P>TICUL>LY ! KE5 ,F\RI] & ,[5 7,/AL9 9DE$ ADMITS ! FIR/ TWO DIVIDES1 BUT CLAIMS1 AGA9 !ORETICALLY BE+ GRAVELY 9 ! WRONG3 0,?IS PROBLEM WASN'T DEALT ) BY ! CLASSICS ( ,M>XISM0 .<,/AL91 P4#b#h.>73 ,9 BO?1 POPULATION %\LD DISP5SE ACROSS ! C\NTRY 9 GR\PS ( #af TO #c1 & M5TAL & MANUAL LABOR >E 9 CON/ANT %IFT4 ,5GELS *>GES ?OSE JU/IFI$ & EXALT$ DEM&S ONLY ) ONE DEFICI5CY3 ! MISS+ EVID5CE 7?AT ONLY ,M>XISM PROVID$7 ( !IR REALIZATION GIV5 ! BASIS ( ! !N A*IEV$ & N[ EXCESSIVE DEVELOPM5T ( ! PRODUCTIVE =CES4 ,ANTICIPAT+ ! HIY VICTORY1 ,5GELS DESCRIBES AN 0ORGANIZATION ( PRODUCTION10 9 :I* REG>D+ PRODUCTIVE LABOR 0BURD5 BECOMES PASSION0 & REM9DS US ( ! CLOS$ REASON+ 9 ! #a#b4 ,*APT] ( ! FIR/ VOLUME ( 0,CAPITAL0 AB\T ! DE/RUCTION ( ! SOCIAL DIVISION ( LABOR & ! HUMAN CRIPPL+ FACTORY DESPOTISM4 ,NEI!R ,/AL9 NOR ,MAL5KOV.<#a#d.> CAN BOA/ TO HAVE MADE A /EP 9 ?AT DIRECTION4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y3 ,/A*ANOVISM & /URMOV*9A.<#a#e.> 7DIALECTICAL REACTIONS ( POOR1 CRIPPL$ VICTIMS TO ! DESPOTISM 9 ! HALO$ 0SWEAT%OPS07 >E ! PRO(1 ?AT ONE IS M>*+ 9TO ! DIRECTION ( ! ALL /IFL+ CAPITALISM4 ,/AL9 IS TRIVIALIZ+ ?OSE PO/ULATES1 BY R$UC+ !M TO ! 0DISAPPE>ANCE ( ! CONTRADICTION ( 9T]E/0 BETWE5 9DU/RY & AGRICULTURE1 BETWE5 PHYSICALLY WORK+ PEOPLE & ! 0LEAD+ P]SONNEL40 ,BUT SOME?+ COMPLETELY ELSE IS ! PO9T3 ,! ABOLITION ( A SOCIAL ORGANIZATION1 9 :I* ! ALLOCATION ( PEOPLE ONTO !SE SECTORS & FUNCTIONS ADH]ES TO A /RICT DIVISION ( LABOR4 ,:]E HAVE !SE PASSAGES ( ,5GELS EV] ALL[$ TO SAY1 ?AT IT W\LDN'T BE NECESS>Y = ! 5TIRE VA/ BUILD+ ( ! FUTURE SOCIETY1 TO DE/ROY ) EV]Y TURN ( ! %OVEL ! PRODUCTION ( COMMODITIES1 TO %OVEL UP PO/ BY PO/ ( ITS REEK+ TR5*ES8 ,WE ( C\RSE H]E CANNOT RECITE = ,/AL9 ALL ! *APT]S1 BUT AS USUAL WE CITE ! ESS5TIAL1 BECAUSE CLE> & UNEQUIVOCAL P>AGRAPHS1 :I* WE ACCEPT )\T RE/RICTIONS & NOT SAY CUM GRANO SALIS .<) A GRA9 ( SALT.>4 ,WE KN[ BY OLD EXP]I5CE1 H[ SU* GRA9S ( SALT HAVE TURN$ 9TO M\NTA9S4 ,5GELS3 0,! 'EX*ANGE ( LABOR = LABOR ON ! PR9CIPLE ( EQUAL VALUATION'1 9 SO F> AS IT HAS ANY MEAN+1 ?AT IS TO SAY1 ! MUTUAL EX*ANGEABILITY ( PRODUCTS ( EQUAL SOCIAL LABOR1 H5CE ! LAW ( VALUE1 IS ! FUNDAM5TAL LAW ( PRECISELY COMMODITY PRODUCTION1 H5CE ALSO ( ITS HIKET ECONOMY & NOT SEE+1 H[ HE IS ?US DESCRIB+ A CAPITALI/ ECONOMY4 ,AN 0IMAG9>Y SOCIETY10 ,5GELS SAYS4 ,AT LEA/ ,/AL9 9 HIS NOT TO BE DESPIS$ SCRIPTURE DESCRIBES AN ACTUALLY EXI/+ CAPITALI/ ECONOMY4 ,M>X3 0,LET US N[ PICTURE TO \RSELVES1 BY WAY ( *ANGE1 A COMMUNITY ( FREE 9DIVIDUALS1 C>RY+ ON !IR WORK ) ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION 9 COMMON1 9 :I* ! LABOR P[] ( ALL ! DIFF]5T 9DIVIDUALS IS CONSCI\SLY APPLI$ AS ! COMB9$ LABOR P[] ( ! COMMUNITY440 ,?IS S5T5CE ALONE IS A REVOLUTION>Y PROGRAM4 ,) ! FUTURE A*IEVEM5T ( ?IS =M ( SOCIAL ORGANIZATION1 SUCC9CTLY LABEL$ AS COMMUNISM1 ONE RETURNS TO ! ,ROB9SON ) :I* ONE />T$4 ,:AT DOES ?AT MEAN8 ,ROB9SON'S PRODUCT WAS NO COMMODITY1 BUT AN OBJECT ( USE1 BECAUSE !RE WAS - ( C\RSE - NO EX*ANGE4 ,) EAGLE W+S WE FLY OV] ! 5TIRE HI/ORY ( HUMANITY3 0,ALL ! *>ACT]I/ICS ( ,ROB9SON'S LABOR >E H]E .<0H]E0 MEANS3 9 ! COMMUNI/ ASSOCIATION.> REPEAT$1 BUT ) ?IS DIFF]5CE1 ?AT !Y >E SOCIAL1 9/EAD ( 9DIVIDUAL440 ,! ONLY NECESS>Y TEXTBOOK TO LE>N TO READ IS ! PRIM]6 ,& ONE READS3 ,! PRODUCT ( LABOR CEASES TO BE A COMMODITY1 :5 SOCIETY IS SOCIALI/4 ,!N ,M>X >RIVES AT ! JUXTAPOSITION ( ?IS 0/ATE ( ?+S0 7( SOCIALISM7 ) COMMODITY PRODUCTION1 & %[S1 ?AT ONE IS ! DIALECTICAL1 UTT]1 REL5TLESS & IRRECONCILABLE OPPOSITE ( ! O!R4 ,SOCIETY & HOMEL& ,BE=E WE H[EV] GET TO ! QUE/ION ( ECONOMIC LAWS1 WE MU/ REM>K A GREAT DEAL TO ! ,/AL9I/ V]SION ( ! SOCIALI/ PROGRAM PUT =W>D BY ,5GELS 9 ! 0,ANTI-,DUHR+40 ,?IS IS EV5 MORE IMPORTANT1 AS ,/AL9 79 REFUTATION ( V>I\S ,RUSSIAN ECONOMI/S7 REFRA9S H]E FROM DI/ORTIONS & REVISIONS ( ! CLASSICAL TEXTS & CITES :OLE PASSAGES1 :ILE HE 9 ?IS SUBJECT UTT]S A VEHEM5T 0P>TY CONDEMNATION0 AGA9/ ANY VIOLATION ( OR?ODOXY4 ,AGA9 & AGA9 ,5GELS TALKS 9 HIS FUNDAM5TAL WORK AB\T ! SEIZURE ( ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION BY SOCIETY1 & FIR/ & =EMO/ 7WE UND]L9E ?AT A HUNDR$ TIMES7 AB\T ! SEIZURE ( ! PRODUCTS - PRODUCTS1 :I* TODAY RULE OV] ! PRODUC] & EV5 ! CONSUM]1 SO ?AT FROM \R PO9T ( VIEW1 CAPITALISM CAN BE DESCRIB$ AS A SY/EM1 :I* NOT ONLY NEGATES ! PRODUC]S' DISPOSAL ( ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION1 BUT RA!R ! DISPOSAL ( ! PRODUCTS4 ,9 ! ,MUSCOVITE P>APHRASE ! 0SOCIETY0 DISAPPE>S1 9/EAD ! TALK IS AB\T ! TRANSF] ( ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION TO ! /ATE1 ! NATION & 7:5 9 ! T]M9AL ELEM5T ( ! EV5TS ! PO9T IS TO 9FLAME PASSIONS & 9VOKE ! RITUAL OVATIONS7 TO ! PEOPLE1 ! SOCIALI/ HOMEL&6 ,IF ONE GIVES ! SUMM>Y ( ! ,/AL9I/ N>RATIVE1 NOT )\T D5Y+ IT ! M]IT ( BRUTAL HONE/Y1 ! SEIZURE ( ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION REG>D+ L& & ! L>GE EQUIPM5T GOODS ( AGRICULTURE PROVES TO BE A M]E LEGAL QUE/ION1 BECAUSE ANY ( ITS PRACTICAL CONSEQU5CES IS ALREADY CONTA9$ )9 ! /ATUTES ( ,>TEL.<#a#f.> OR ! LA/ ,SOVIET CON/ITUTION 7:I* %ALL BE REVIS$74 ,ONE MU/ SEE1 ?AT ?OSE SOLEMN /ATEM5TS AB\T ! RIIAN PRODUCTS1 :I* >E DIVID$ BETWE5 ! KOLKHOZES & ! S+LE KOLKOHZNIKI4 ,FACTUALLY TRUE IS ! SEIZURE ?R\< ! /ATE ONLY 9 ! L>GE-SCALE 9DU/RY1 BECAUSE ! /ATE ONLY H]E DISPOSES ( PRODUCTS1 & ?OSE IT SELLS1 AS F> AS !Y >E PRODUCTS ( CONSUMPTION1 AGA94 ,9 ! SMALL & M$IUM SIZ$ BUS9ESSES & 9 ! COMM]CIAL 5T]PRISES H[EV]1 !RE IS NO SEIZURE ( PRODUCTS1 NOT EV5 ( ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION1 BY ! /ATE4 ,?IS ALSO APPLIES TO ! MICRO-EQUIPM5T ( ! /ATE-SPONSOR$ FAMILY & P>CEL ECONOMY4 ,DESPITE ! EXI/5CE ( HUGE FACTORIES & GIANT PUBLIC CON/RUCTION PROJECTS1 ! SELF-PROCLAIM$ SOCIALI/ & ,SOVIET REPUBLIC LEADS & CONTROLS NOT A LOT2 & NOT MU* WAS TRULY SOCIALIZ$ & NATIONALIZ$4 ,! MEAN+ ( /ATE PROP]TY 9 RELATION TO ! 5TIRE ECONOMY IS PROBABLY BIGG] 9 SOME B\RGEOIS /ATES4 ,:O !N1 :I* 9/ITUTION1 :I* P[]1 WIELDS :AT WAS WRE/$ FROM ! PRIVATE H& AFT] ! REVOLUTION8 ,! PEOPLE1 ! NATION1 ! HOMEL&8 ,NEV] HAVE ,5GELS & ,M>X US$ ?OSE WORDS4 ,! TRANS=MATION ( PRIVATE PROP]TY 9TO /ATE PROP]TY1 0DOES NOT DO AWAY ) ! CAPITALI/IC NATURE ( ! PRODUCTIVE =CES10 ,5GELS REM>KS4 ,ONLY :5 SOCIETY DISPOSES ( ! PRODUCTS1 ONLY !N IT IS CLE>1 ?AT IT HAS OV]COME ! CLASS ANTAGONISMS & HAS BECOME A CLASSLESS SOCIETY4 ,BUT AS LONG AS !RE >E CLASSES1 SOCIETY WILL BE ORGANIZ$ BY ?AT 0CLASS SOLELY10 :I* MU/ SUBLATE ALL CLASSES1 & AS A DIALECTICAL CONSEQU5CE ITSELF4 ,H]E1 IT IS TI$ ON ! MA/]FUL ILLU/RATION ( ! !ORY ( ! /ATE1 :I* EM]G$ ALREADY 9 #a#h#d#g3 0,! PROLET>IAT SEIZES ! /ATE P[] & 9ITIALLY TURNS ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION 9TO /ATE PROP]TY40 7,5GELS IS CIT+ ,M>X H]E74 0,BUT1 9 DO+ ?IS1 IT ABOLI%ES ITSELF AS PROLET>IAT1 ABOLI%ES ALL CLASS DI/9CTION & CLASS ANTAGONISMS1 ABOLI%ES ALSO ! /ATE AS /ATE440 ,ONLY !N1 & ONLY ON ?IS ROYAL ROAD IT IS SOCIETY1 :I* >ISES AS ! ACT+ FACTOR & F9ALLY DISPOSES ( ! PRODUCTIVE =CES1 ALL PRODUCTS1 AS WELL AS RES\RCES4 ,BUT ! PEOPLE1 :AT ! HECK IS ?AT8 ,A MI%MA% ( DIFF]5T CLASSES1 AN 09TEGRAL0 ( EXPROPRIATORS & SLAVES1 ( POLITICAL OR BUS9ESS PR(ESSIONALS & ! />V+1 RESPECTIVELY ! OPPRESS$4 ,! 0PEOPLE0 WE ALREADY LEFT TO ! ASSOCIATIONS = FRE$OM & DEMOCRACY1 FRE$OM & PROGRESS1 BE=E #a#h#d#h4 ,) ITS NOTORI\S 0MAJORITIES10 ! PEOPLE IS NOT ! SUBJECT ( ECONOMIC PLANN+1 BUT M]ELY AN OBJECT ( EXPROPRIATION & FRAUD4 ,& ! NATION8 ,AS A NECESSITY & P]QUISITE = ! EM]G5CE ( CAPITALISM IT EXPRESSES ! SAME MIXTURE ( SOCIAL CLASSES1 NOT LIKE 0PEOPLE0 9 ! /ALE1 LEGAL & PHILOSOPHIC S5SE1 BUT ON A GEOGRAPHICAL1 E?NOGRAPHICAL & L+UI/IC LEVEL4 ,! 0NATION0 AS WELL DOESN'T SEIZE ANY?+3 ,9 FAM\S PASSAGES ,M>X RIDICUL$ ! EXPRESSIONS 0NATIONAL WEAL?0 & 0NATIONAL 9COME0 7:I* PLAYS AN IMPORTANT ROLE 9 ,/AL9'S ANALYSIS ( ,RUSSIA7 & %[$1 ?AT ! NATION 5RI*ES ITSELF PRECISELY :5 ! WORK] IS SCREW$4 ,IF ! B\RGEOIS REVOLUTIONS & ! ASS]TION ( MOD]N 9DU/RY1 :I* EXTRUD$ FEUDALISM 9 ,EUROPE & V>I\S O!R SY/EMS 9 ! RE/ ( ! WORLD1 DIDN'T C>RY \T 9 ! NAME ( ! B\RGEOISIE & CAPITAL1 BUT PRECISELY 9 ! NAME ( ! PEOPLE & NATIONS1 IF ?IS WAS 9 ! ,M>XI/ CONCEPTION A REVOLUTION>Y & NECESS>Y TRANSITION1 !N WE CAN D$UCE1 H[ CONSI/5TLY ! ,MUSCOVITE CO9CIDE ) ?AT3 ! JETTISON ( ,M>XI/ POLITICAL ECONOMY & ! R5UNCIATION ( ! PROLET>IAN1 REVOLUTION>Y & 9T]NATIONALI/ 0CATEGORY0 SOCIETY 7A CATEGORY ?AT IS US$ 9 CLASSIC TEXTS71 AS WELL AS AN ORI5TATION T[>DS ! POLITICAL CATEGORIES IMMAN5T 9 B\RGEOIS IDEOLOGY & PROPAG&A3 PEOPLE'S DEMOCRACY & NATIONAL 9DEP5D5CE4 ,ONE DOES NOT NE$ TO BE SURPRIS$ !N1 :5 #bf YE>S LAT] ! \TRAGE\S SLOGAN IS REPEAT$1 :I* WE ,M>XI/S BURN$ ALL BRIDGES )3 TO 0PICK UP0.<#a#g.> ! BANN] ( ! B\RGEOISIE4 ,! BANN]1 :I* 9 ! DAYS ( A ,CROMWELL1 ,WA%+TON1 ,ROBESPI]RE OR ,G>IBALDI WAS UPHELD & !N ?R[N OV]BO>D2 ! REVOLUTION 9 ITS M>* H[EV]1 WILL LEAVE IT 9 ! MUD - BECAUSE !IR LIES & MY?S ( PEOPLES1 NATIONS & HOMEL&S IT C\NT]POSES ) ! SOCIALI/ SOCIETY4 ,LAW & !ORY ,9 ! ,MUSCOVITE DEBATE1 ! COMP>ISON BETWE5 ! LAWS ( ! ,RUSSIAN ECONOMY & ! E/ABLI%$ LAWS ( B\RGEOIS ECONOMY BY ,M>XISM ALSO CAME UP4 ,! NAMELY TEXT FIY ECONOMY4 ,IF Y\ %[ US1 ?AT ?IS IS IMPOSSIBLE1 !N LET'S D$UCE FROM ?AT1 ?AT WE LIVE 9 A SOCIETY1 :OSE ECONOMY IS 5TIRELY CAPITALI/4 ,:AT DOES IT HELP TO FOOL \RSELVES80 ,9 CONTRA/ TO ?AT1 O!RS WANT TO %ELVE CRIT]IA ?AT DI/+UI% SOCIALISM 9 ,M>XISM2 ,/AL9 BE/IRS TO ANSW] BO?4 ,?OSE NAIVE RESE>*]S >E ( C\RSE NO ACTIVE 0POLITICAL0 ELEM5TS3 O!RWISE IT W\LD HAVE BE5 EASY TO TAKE !M \T BY A PURGE4 ,WE >E ONLY DEAL+ ) 0TE*NICIANS0 & EXP]TS ( ! APP>ATUS ( PRODUCTION1 ?R\< :OSE M$IATION ! C5TRAL GOV]NM5T LE>NS1 :E!R ! HUGE MA*9]Y RUNS SMOO?LY OR HAS /ALL$2 & :5 !Y W]E RIE SURFAC+ TODAY1 OR PUT MORE ACCURATELY1 COME TO LIE NOT ( ACADEMIC1 CRITICAL OR EV5 0P>LIAM5T>Y0 NATURE - TO MOVE BEYOND SU* /IT*ES1 NO 0GREAT MAN0 NE$S TO COME1 A SMALL POLITICAL P>V5U C\LD H&LE ?AT4 ,! DIFFICULTIES ON ! O!R H& >E REAL1 MAT]IAL1 !Y LIE )9 ! ?+S1 NOT 9 ! HEADS4 ,= ANSW]+ ( ! OBJECTIONS1 ! C5TRAL GOV]NM5T HAS TO 9SI/ ON TWO ?+S3 FIR/1 ?AT 9 A SOCIALI/ SOCIETY1 PEOPLE ALSO HAVE TO OBEY TO ECONOMIC LAWS :I* CANNOT BE SUSP5D$4 ,SECOND1 ?AT ?OSE LAWS - 9 :ATEV] WAY !Y WILL DIFF] 9 ! FUTURE FULL COMMUNISM ALL & SUNDRY FROM ! LAWS ( CAPITALISM - 9 ! SOCIALI/ PHASE P>TLY CORRESPOND TO ! LAWS ( CAPITALI/ PRODUCTION & DI/RIBUTION1 P>TLY DIFF] FROM !M4 ,& IF ! APP>5TLY 9SURM\NTABLE LAWS >E SETTL$ !N1 ONE MU/ NOT IGNORE !M BY ! PUNI%M5T ( DEMISE & ONE P>TICUL>LY MU/ NOT CONTRAV5E !M4 ,SO F> ,/AL94 ,!N A SPECIAL1 ALBEIT ESS5TIAL QUE/ION >ISES3 IS ! LAW ( VALUE P>T ( ?OSE LAWS :I* CONT9UE TO P]SI/ 9 ! ,RUSSIAN ECONOMY8 ,& IF YES1 ISN'T EV]Y ME*ANISM ?AT ADH]ES TO ! LAW ( VALUE PURE CAPITALISM8 ,/AL9 REPLIES TO ! FIR/ QUE/ION3 ,YES1 ! LAW ( VALUE IS 9 EFFECT OV] H]E1 ?\< NOT EV]Y:]E4 ,& TO ! SECOND3 ,NO1 NOT EV]Y ECONOMY 9 :I* ! LAW ( VALUE OP]ATES IS CAPITALI/4 ,9 ! 5TIRE1 SOLEMNLY PRES5T$ !ORETICAL 0ESSAY10 ! /RUCTURE SEEMS TO BE V]Y FRAGM5T$ & MO/ NOTABLY IT SUITS ! BOOK ( ! 5EMIES ( ,M>XISM4 ,?OSE1 :O EMPLOY 0PHILOSOPHICAL0 WEAPONS1 WILL HAVE AN EASY JOB1 BECAUSE ! EFFECTS ( ! LAWS ( NATURE & ! EFFECTS ( ! ECONOMIC LAWS ON ! HUMAN SPECIES >E EQUAT$2 :ILE ?OSE1 :O PREF] ! WEAPON ( 0ECONOMY0 & :O HAVE BE5 WAIT+ = A C5TURY = A REVAN*E AGA9/ ,M>X1 CAN BELIEVE TO HAVE MADE IT3 0,! LAWS ( ECONOMIC PR(ITABILITY & COMPETITION ( SOCIAL 9T]E/S1 LIKE WE UND]/& !M1 Y\ WILL NEV] BE ABLE TO EVADE40 ,ONE HAS TO DI/+UI% BETWE5 !ORY1 LAW & PROGRAM4 ,9 A C]TA9 PASSAGE ! FOLL[+ S5T5CE SLIPS \T ( ,/AL9'S M\?3 0,M>X1 HE1 AS WE KN[1 DID NOT LIKE .<6.> TO DIGRESS FROM HIS 9VE/IGATION ( ! LAWS ( CAPITALI/ PRODUCTION0 .<,/AL91 P4 #h#b.>4 ,WE ALREADY %[$ AT ! LA/ ASSEMBLY 9 ,SEPTEMB] #aieb 9 ,MILAN1 ?AT ,M>X'S AIM DIDN'T LIE 9 ! /]ILE DESCRIPTION ( ! CAPITALI/ 0/ATUS QUO10 BUT ?AT FROM EV]Y R[ ! DEM& & ! PROGRAM ( ! DE/RUCTION ( CAPITALISM />ES ONE 9 ! FACE4 ,\R PO9T WASN'T ONLY TO DE/ROY ! OLD & /ALE OPPORTUNI/ LEG5D1 BUT TO %[ ! 5TIRE POLEMICAL & MILITANT NATURE 9TR9SIC TO ,M>X'S WORK4 ,?AT'S :Y ,M>X DOESN'T LOSE HIMSELF )9 ! DESCRIPTION ( CAPITALISM1 OR RESPECTIVE CAPITALISMS1 BUT 9/EAD HE DESCRIBES A CAPITALI/ SY/EM1 AN AB/RACT1 YES1 NON-EXI/5T1 YES1 TYPICAL CAPITALISM1 :I* NEV]!LESS 5TIRELY CORRESPONDS TO ! GLORIFY+ !SES ( ! B\RGEOIS ECONOMI/S4 ,IMPORTANT IS SOLELY ! CLA% ( BO? POSITIONS 7A CLA% ( CLASSES & P>TIES1 NOT A MUNDANE DISPUTE BETWE5 9TELLECTUALS71 ( :I* ONE WANTS TO PROVE ! P]MAN5CE1 ! ET]NITY ( CAPITALI/ MA*9]Y1 :ILE ! O!R PROVES ITS COM+ DEA?4 ,9 ?IS LIY ,M>X C>$ TO ADMIT1 ?AT ! CLOCKWORK1 P]FECTLY C5T]$ & BY ! FRE$OM ( COMPETITION1 & ! RIXIAN REASON+ W\LD HAVE SUFF]$ %IPWRECK4 ,BUT IT CONT9UES TO %9E ) FULL =CE1 AS CAPITALISM CONT9UES1 BUT ONLY BY MONOPOLIZATION1 SUPPRESSION1 DICTATOR%IP & MASSACRE2 & ITS ECONOMIC DEVELOPM5T PRECISELY FOLL[S ! RESULTS ( ! ANALYSIS ( ! PURE TYPE3 CONFIRMATION ( \R DOCTR9E1 REFUTATION ( ! LACKEYS ( CAPITAL4 ,9 ?IS S5SE1 ,M>X HAS D$ICAT$ HIS :OLE LIFE TO ! DESCRIPTION ( SOCIALISM1 ( COMMUNISM2 HAD IT CONC]N$ ONLY ! DESCRIPTION ( CAPITALISM1 HE W\LDN'T HAVE GIV5 A DAMN AB\T IT4 ,M>X 9VE/IGAT$ & DEVELOP$ ! 0ECONOMIC LAWS0 ( CAPITALISM 9DE$1 BUT ! ME?OD1 9 :I* HE DID ?IS1 9DICATES ! SY/EM ( SOCIALI/ *>ACT]I/ICS 5TIRELY & 9 DIALECTICAL CONTRADICTION TO !M4 ,SO1 DOES SOCIALISM ADH]E TO ?OSE LAWS8 ,>E !Y O!RS8 ,& IF YES1 :I*8 ,JU/ A MOM5T6 ,9 ! C5T] ( ! ,M>XI/ WORK WE PUT ! PROGRAM1 AS A MOM5T ?AT FOLL[S A SOB] EXAM9ATION4 0,! PHILOSOPH]S HAVE ONLY 9T]PRET$ ! WORLD1 9 V>I\S WAYS2 ! PO9T IS TO *ANGE IT10 0,!SES ON ,FEU]BA*10 & EV]Y $UCAT$ DORK ADDS3 0Y\?0 !SES4 ,BUT BE=E ! PROGRAM1 & EV5 BE=E ! DEPICTION ( ! DISCOV]$ LAWS1 ! DOCTR9E AS A :OLE1 ! SY/EM ( 0!ORIES10 HAS TO BE DET]M9$4 ,SOME ( ?OSE !ORIES ,M>X HAS F\ND READY-MADE AT HIS ADV]S>IES1 E4G4 ,RIC>DO'S VALUE !ORY1 & ! !ORY ( SURPLUS VALUE AS WELL4 ,?OSE !ORIES 7WE DON'T WANT TO CLAIM ,/AL9 NEV] KNEW ( !M7 >E SOME?+ DIFF]5T FROM ! BY ,M>X ?OR\IFY ! DI/9CTION BETWE5 !ORY & LAW1 A DI/9CTION1 :I* ALSO APPLIES 9 SCI5CE4 ,!ORY IS ! DEPICTION ( REAL PROCESSES & !IR RELATIONS1 TO EASE ! G5]AL UND]/&+ ON A C]TA9 >EA - PR$ICTION & MODIFICATION ( ?OSE PROC$URES ONLY FOLL[ ?AT4 ,LAW IS ! PRECISE EXPRESSION ( A C]TA9 RELATION BETWE5 MULTIPLE1 P>TICUL>LY BETWE5 TWO S]IES ( MAT]IAL CIRCUM/ANCES3 A RELATION1 :OSE VALIDITY IS V]IFIABLE AT ANY PO9T & :I* ALL[S TO CALCULATE UNKN[N PROPORTIONS 7NO MATT]1 Y\ PHILOSOPH]S1 IF IT IS AB\T FUTURE1 P>T OR PRES5T ONES4 ,= EXAMPLE ,I AM1 ) A WELL DISCOV]$ LAW1 ABLE TO DET]M9E1 H[ HI< ! SEA LEVEL WAS A ?\S& YE>S AGO2 ! ONLY DIFF]5CE1 ?AT ,I CANNOT TE/1 IS1 H[ MU* MORE Y\ /9K TO HI< HEAV5 TODAY474 ,!ORY IS SOME?+ UNIV]SAL1 ! LAW SOME?+ /RICTLY DIFF]5TIAT$ & P>TICUL>4 ,!ORY IS G5]ALLY QUALITATIVE & S]VES ! DEF9ITION ( C]TA9 MAGNITUDES & ESS5CES4 ,! LAW IS QUANTITATIVE & AIMS AT !IR MEASUREM5T4 ,AN EXAMPLE FROM PHYSICS3 9 ! HI/ORY ( OPTICS1 TWO !ORIES ( LIY+ SUCCESS4 ,ACCORD+ TO ! P>TICLE !ORY1 ! TRANSMISSION ( LIANCES & LAWS ?AT DECID$ ! *OICE4 ,N[1 ACCORD+ TO ,/AL9'S TEXT1 ! 0LAW ( ! EX*ANGE ( EQUIVAL5TS0 IS SAID TO BE COMPATIBLE BO? ) HIS 0!ORY03 0,9 SOCIALI/ ECONOMY !RE >E =MS ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION10 AS WELL AS ) \R !ORY ?AT SAYS3 0,IF COMMODITY PRODUCTION & MASS PRODUCTION EXI/1 !N ?AT'S CAPITALISM40 ,! LAW IS EASILY TE/$3 ,ONE DRIVES TO ,RUSSIA & ONE WILL SEE1 ?AT ! EX*ANGE HAPP5S AT DET]M9$ PRICES ) RUBLES1 LIKE ON ANY >BITR>Y M>KET3 ?US1 ! LAW ( ! EX*ANGE BETWE5 EQUIVAL5TS PREVAILS4 ,TO SEE N[1 :I* !ORY IS ! CORRECT ONE1 IT'S A BIT MORE DIFFICULT4 ,WE1 = \R P>T1 D$UCE3 ,9 ,RUSSIA ONE F9DS ONESELF )9 ! PURE & REAL CAPITALISM4 ,AS = ,/AL91 HE FABRICATES A !ORY - PRECISELY3 !ORIES >E 9V5T$1 LAWS DISCOV]$ - & 9 DEFIANCE ( FA!R ,M>X SAYS3 C]TA9 ECONOMIC APPE>ANCES ( SOCIALISM OBEY USUALLY TO ! LAW ( EX*ANGE 7LAW ( VALUE74 ,NATURE & HI/ORY ,BE=E WE GET TO ! PO9T - :I* LAWS ( CAPITALISM ,M>X PUTS =W>D1 :I* DI/+UI% CAPITALISM FROM SOCIALISM1 RESPECTIVELY :I* >E 7P]HAPS7 COMMON TO BO? -1 WE MU/ PO9T AT ! COMMON EQUATION ( LAWS ( NATURE ) LAWS ( SOCIETY4 ,AS /UD5TS ( ,M>X WE MU/ BE MILITANTS & POLEMICS2 WE MU/ NOT SOLVE SU* A QUE/ION S*OLA/ICALLY & 9SI/S ON ! !ORETICAL ANALOGY ( BO? >EAS1 P]HAPS ) ! 0POLITICAL0 GOAL1 TO DODGE ! FOLL[+ >GUM5T3 0,N[1 IF ! LAWS ( SOCIETY >5'T AS 9SURM\NTABLE AS = EXAMPLE ! LAW ( GRAVITY1 !N LET'S GO3 LET'S KNOCK SOME OV]40 ,H[ C\LD WE =GET1 ?AT ! FIX & ! PAID GANG 9 ! UNIV]SITIES ( CAPITAL FL>$ UP ON ! PO9T1 ?AT ! LAWS ( B\RGEOIS ECONOMY >E 0NO LAWS ( NATURE10 & WE !RE=E NOT ONLY WANT TO BU/ ?IS CIRCLE ( HELL1 BUT CAN BU/ IT4 ,IT IS TRUE1 ?AT ,/AL9'S SCRIPTURE REM9DS1 ?AT ) ,M>X ! LAWS ( ECONOMY >5'T 0ET]NAL10 BUT 9/EAD CORRESPOND TO C]TA9 SOCIAL PHASES & EPO*S3 SLAV]Y1 FEUDALISM1 CAPITALISM4 ,BUT ,/AL9 WANTS TO PO9T \T ?AT 0C]TA9 LAWS0 >E COMMON TO ALL EPO*S & ?US ALSO ASS]T !MSELVES 9 SOCIALISM1 :I* ALLEG$LY HAS AN [N 0POLITICAL ECONOMY40 ,/AL9 RIDICULES ,Y>O%5KO & ,BUKH>91 ?AT SAID1 ?AT POLITICAL ECONOMY IS SUCCE$$ BY A 0TE*NIQUE ( SOCIAL ORGANIZATION0 .<,/AL91 P4#f#e.>4 ,H>%LY HE REPLIES TO ?AT1 ?AT ?IS NEW DISCIPL9E1 :I* PSEUDO-,M>XI/ & TREMBL+ BE=E ! ,CZ>I/ POLICE ECONOMI/S.<#a#h.> W\LD HAVE ATT5D$ TO1 IS 9 REALITY AN 0ECONOMIC POLICY0 - & AS SU* HE ALL[S IT .<,/AL91 P4#g#d.>4 ,WELL1 :E!R !RE WILL BE AN ECONOMIC SCI5CE 9 SOCIALISM1 WE WILL DISCUSS ONCE ?+S HAVE BE5 PUT 9 !IR CORRECT PLACE AGA9.<#a#i.>2 BUT :]E !RE IS /ILL AN ECONOMIC POLICY 7LIKE IT IS UND] ! DICTATOR%IP ( ! PROLET>IAT71 !RE >E RIVAL+ CLASSES1 & WE >E NOT YET 9 SOCIALISM4 ,& WE MU/ ASK LIKE ,L593 ,:O HAS ! P[]8 ,& ACCORD+LY3 ,:I* DIRECTION DOES ! ECONOMIC DEVELOPM5T TAKE1 :I* - !RE WE CONCUR - TAKES PLACE 9 /AGES8 ,?AT WILL ! LAWS ( ?IS DEVELOPM5T TELL US4 ,AS TO ! G5]AL QUE/ION ( LAWS 9 NATURE & HI/ORY1 IT WILL BE DEALT ) 9 \R !ORETICAL 9VE/IGATIONS !RE1 :]E WE REPLY TO ! EXPECT$ ATTACKS1 :I* ,M>XISM - :I* 9DE$ HAS = #iii ( #a WRIT]S E/ABLI%$ FIX$ ABODE 9 ,MOSC[ - WILL BE SUBJECT$ TO3 ,ATTACKS REG>D+ ,/AL9'S BANALIZATION ( ! !ORY ( HI/ORICAL MAT]IALISM 7?AT'S A !ORY1 NOT A LAW7 & REG>D+ ! QUE/IONS ( DET]M9ISM & WILL1 CAUSALITY & AMBITION4 ,! ORIG9AL CONT5T ( ! ,M>XIAN POSITION 7B>ELY UND]/OOD & V]Y 9CONV5I5T = PEOPLE1 ?AT PURSUE A POLICY ( OPPORTUNI/ SUCCESS7 IS ALWAYS ?AT ( ! DIRECT CLASS /RUGGLE & ! HI/ORICAL ANTAGONISM BETWE5 ! CLASSES1 A /RUGGLE1 :I* ALT]NATELY RESORTS TO ! TYPEWRIT] & ! MA*9E GUN - PROVID$ ONE ISN'T ABLE TO TALK ( 0FEA!R & SWORD0 ANYMORE4 ,WE CONC$$ TO ! B\RGEOISIE ! A*IEVEM5T1 9 ITS W> AGA9/ ! OLD CLASSES1 TO HAVE PROMOT$ ! CRITICAL-SCI5TIFIC ME?OD & TO HAVE BOLDLY APPLI$ IT TO ! >EA ( NATURE & !N TO ?AT ( SOCIETY4 ,IT DISCOV]$ & PROCLAIM$ !ORIES1 :I* TODAY >E \RS3 VALUE !ORY 7! VALUE ( A COMMODITY IS DET]M9$ BY ! SOCIALLY NECESS>Y LABOR TIME REQUIR$ = ITS PRODUCTION7 & ! SURPLUS VALUE !ORY 7! VALUE ( EV]Y COMMODITY CONTA9S ADVANC$ CAPITAL & SURPLUS VALUE1 !RE=E A REFUND & PR(IT74 ,& TRIUMPHANTLY ! B\RGEOISIE !N PROCLAIM$3 0,IF Y\ ADMIT0 7& SCI5CE WILL ADMIT IT ONE C5TURY LAT]71 0?AT ! SAME PHYSICAL LAWS APPLY = ! PRIMORDIAL NEBULA AS = \R PLANET TODAY1 !N Y\ MU/ ALSO ADMIT1 ?AT ! CURR5T SOCIAL CONDITIONS WILL APPLY = ALL FUTURE SOCIETIES1 BECAUSE WE CONS5SUALLY BANI% BO? ! 9T]V5TION ( GOD AS WELL AS PURE ?\XISM BY CONTRA/ DELIV]S ! SCI5TIFIC PRO(1 ?AT )9 ! SOCIAL COSMOS1 A CYCLE C>RIES \T1 :I* WILL DE/ROY ! CAPITALI/ =MS & LAWS1 & ?AT ! FUTURE SOCIAL COSMOS WILL ADH]E TO O!R LAWS4 ,S9CE Y\ DON'T M9D TO REMODEL & BANALIZE ?IS MIXI/10 0SOCIALI/0 & 0COMMUNI/10 & 9/EAD USE 0ECONOMI/10 0POPULI/10 0PROGRESSIVE10 & IT FITS LIKE A GLOVE4 ,M>X & ! LAWS ,5GELS ACKN[L$G$ ,M>X AS ! F\ND] ( HI/ORICAL MAT]IALISM4 ,M>X EXPLA9$1 HIS CONTRIBUTION 9 ! APPLICATION ( ?IS !ORY TO ! MOD]N WORLD CONSI/$ NOT ( DISCOV]+ CLASS /RUGGLE1 BUT TO 9TRODUCE ! CONCEPT ( ! DICTATOR%IP ( ! PROLET>IAT4 ,?US1 !ORY LEADS TO ! CLASS & P>TY PROGRAM1 TO ! ORGANIZATION ( ! WORK+ CLASS = ! 9SURRECTION & ! SEIZURE ( P[]4 ,9 ?IS GREAT P]SPECTIVE1 ! 9VE/IGATION ( ! LAWS ( CAPITALISM L9ES UP4 ,TWO REAL & FUNDAM5TAL LAWS >E PUT D[N 9 0,CAPITAL40 ,9 ! FIR/ VOLUME1 ! G5]AL LAW ( CAPITALI/ ACCUMULATION1 ALSO KN[N AS ! LAW ( 9CREAS+ IMPOV]I%M5T 7(T5 DEALT ) BY US73 ) ! 9CREAS+ CONC5TRATION ( CAPITAL ! NUMB] ( PROLET>IANS & ! 0RES]VE >MY0 GR[S2 WE HAVE EXPLA9$ MULTIPLE TIMES ALREADY1 ?AT ?IS NOT NECESS>ILY IMPLIES A FALL 9 ! LEVEL ( CONSUMPTION OR REAL LIV+ /&>DS ( WORK]S4 ,9 ! SECOND & ?IRD VOLUME1 ! LAW ( ! REPRODUCTION ( CAPITAL IS DEVELOP$ 7:I* IS 9T]RELAT$ ) ! LAW ( ! T5D5CY ( ! AV]AGE RATE ( PR(IT TO FALL1 :I* WE WILL GET BACK TO73 A P>T ( ! PRODUCT & ?US ( LABOR1 MU/ BE PUT ASIDE BY ! CAPITALI/1 TO 5SURE ! REPRODUCTION ( DEPRECIAT$ MA*9ES1 FACTORIES ETC4 7CAPITAL GOODS1 = ECONOMI/S74 ,IF ! CAPITALI/ 9CREASES ! %>E DE/9$ AS RES]VE ASS]TS1 HE 09VE/S10 MEAN+ HE EXP&S ! /OCK ( PRODUCTION FACILITIES & MEANS ( PRODUCTION4 ,M>X'S LAWS ON ! ALLOCATION ( ! SOCIAL PRODUCT BETWE5 IMM$IATE CONSUMPTION- & 9VE/M5T GOODS PROVE1 ?AT AS LONG AS COMMODITY EX*ANGE & WAGE SY/EM P]SI/1 ! SY/EM FACES CRISES & REVOLUTIONS4 ,! FIR/ LAW C]TA9LY CANNOT BE APPLI$ TO ! SOCIALI/ SOCIETY1 BECAUSE IT ORGANIZES PRECISELY = ! REASON ?AT ! SOCIAL RES]VE CON/ITUTES AN 9DIVIDUAL SECURITY = EV]YONE1 AL?\< ?IS RES]VE NEI!R BELONGS TO ANYBODY1 NOR H[ 9 PRECAPITALI/IC TIMES1 IS DIVID$ 9TO X LITTLE P>TS4 ,! SECOND LAW1 ,/AL9 TELLS US1 P]SI/S 9 SOCIALISM2 & HE ASSURES1 ,M>X HAD =ESE5 ?AT4 ,M>XISM M]ELY E/ABLI%$ 7AMONG O!RS 9 ! KN[N PASSAGE 9 ! 0,CRITIQUE ( ! ,GO?A ,PROGRAM071 ?AT 9 COMMUNISM !RE WILL BE A SOCIAL D$UCTION ( 9DIVIDUAL LABOR AS WELL1 TO KEEP ! PRODUCTION FACILITIES 9 GOOD CONDITION1 TO 5SURE ! PUBLIC S]VICES ETC4 ,?IS D$UCTION W\LD NOT BE ( EXPROPRIATIVE *>ACT]1 PRECISELY BECAUSE IT DOESN'T NE$ TO BE M$IAT$ M>KET-BAS$ & !RE=E ! SOCIAL RES]VE FUNDS WILL E/ABLI% A /ABLE EQUILIBRIUM - 9/EAD ( S]IAL TREMORS - NAMELY BETWE5 ! PRODUCTS = CONSUMPTION & ! PRODUCTS :I* >E 9CLUD$ 9 ! FOLL[+ CYCLE ( PRODUCTION AS MEANS ( PRODUCTION4 ,! CRUCIAL PO9T 9 ALL ?AT IS ! FOLL[+3 ,/AL9 MAKES ! VALUABLE CONCESSION1 ?AT - BECAUSE 9 ! /ATE 9DU/RY ! LAW ( VALUE IS 9 EFFECT - ITS BUS9ESSES FUNCTION BAS$ ON 0CO/ ACC\NT+ & PR(ITABL5ESS1 PRODUCTION CO/S1 PRICES1 ETC40 .<,/AL91 P4#b.>4 ,= 0ETC40 WE POSE3 PR(ITABLE4 ,ADDITIONALLY1 HE EXPLA9S ?AT ! FUTURE PROGRAM CONSI/S ( AN 9CREASE ( ! PRODUCTION ( ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION1 MEAN+1 ?AT ! 0PLANS0 ( ! ,SOVIET GOV]NM5T = ! 9DU/RIALIZATION ( ! C\NTRY NOT SO MU* ALL[ = GOODS ( CONSUMPTION = ! POPULATION1 BUT 9/EAD MA9LY CONSI/S ( PRODUC+ MA*9ES1 AGR>IAN TOOLS1 TRACTORS1 F]TILIZ] ETC4 & TO TACKLE GIANT PUBLIC PROJECTS4 ,PLANS ASIDE3 ,! CAPITALI/ /ATES MAKE PLANS1 ! PROLET>IAN DICTATOR%IP WILL MAKE PLANS4 ,BUT ! FIR/ TRUE SOCIALI/ PLAN 7:I* MU/ BE UND]/OOD AS AN IMM$IATE DESPOTIC 9ROAD1 SEE ! 0,MANIFE/O07 WILL EV5TUALLY BE A PLAN TO ! 9CREASE ( ! CO/S ( PRODUCTION1 %ORT5+ ( ! WORK DAY1 DIVE/M5T ( CAPITAL1 QUANTITATIVE & ESPECIALLY QUALITATIVE LEVEL+ ( CONSUMPTION 7:I* IS UND] CAPITALI/ AN>*Y TO N9E T5?S AN ABSURD WA/E ( PRODUCT71 BECAUSE ONLY 9 ?IS WAY IT WILL BE POSSIBLE TO COPE ) 0BUS9ESS PR(ITABILITY0 & 0PR(ITABLE PRICES40 ,SO1 A PLAN ( UND]PRODUCTION = ! DRA/IC R$UCTION ( ! %>E ( CAPITAL GOODS 9 PRODUCTION4 ,! LAW ( REPRODUCTION WILL RUN \T ( BREA? IMM$IATELY1 :5 ! ,M>XIAN 0DEP>TM5T ,I,I0 7PRODUCTION ( MEANS ( CONSUMPTION7 EV5TUALLY SUCCE$S 9 KNOCK+ \T 0DEP>TM5T ,I0 7PRODUCTION ( MEANS ( PRODUCTION74 ,9 ANY WAY1 ! CAPITALI/ 0CONC]T0 HAS = TOO LONG PUNI%$ \R E>DRUMS4 ,! MEANS ( CONSUMPTION >E = ! WORK]S1 ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION = ! 5TREPR5EURS4 ,IF ! BUS9ESS MA/] IS ! WORK]S' /ATE1 IT %ALL ( C\RSE IMM$IATELY BE ACCEPT$1 ?AT ! WORK]S >E 9T]E/$ TO 09VE/0 & TO SWEAT FROM F\R TO EITM5T ,I6 ,IF N[ ,Y>O%5KO ABRIDGES ! CRITIQUE ( ! /AGG]+ 9CREASE ( ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION TO ! =MULA 0PRIMACY ( CONSUMPTION 9/EAD ( PRIMACY ( PRODUCTION10 HE BECOMES V]Y MUNDANE4 ,NO LESS %ALL[ - TO SMUGGLE 9 /ATE 9DU/RIALISM UND] SOCIALI/ BANN] - >E AGITATIONAL =MULAS LIKE3 0,HE :O DOESN'T WORK %ALL NOT EAT0 OR 0,ABOLITION ( ! EXPROPRIATION ( HUMANS ?R\< HUMANS10 AS IF IT WAS ! HIIANIZ+ HUMANS8 ,:]E %ALL IT TAKE ! HUMANS FROM8 ,! C\RSE IS ?AT ( PRIMITIVE ACCUMULATION1 & MO/LY ! MEANS >E AS HORRIBLE AS ?OSE1 ?AT >E DEPICT$ 9 0,CAPITAL03 SOMETIME IT HITS ! KOLKHOZNIKI1 :O SUDD5LY /& !RE )\T !IR C[2 SOMETIME ! NOMADIC %EPH]DS ( ,ASIA1 :I* GET SNAT*$ FROM !IR SUBM]SION 9TO ! VIEW ( ! ,URSA ,MAJOR2 OR ! FEUDAL S]FS 9 ,MONGOLIA1 :I* >E UPROOT$ FROM !IR MILL5NIUMS-OLD SOIL4 ,! SLOGAN IS ) C]TA9TY3 MORE PRODUCTION GOODS1 MORE WORK]S1 LONG] WORK TIME1 HI<] WORK 9T5SITY - 9 O!R WORDS3 EXP&$ ACCUMULATION & REPRODUCTION ( CAPITAL 9 9F]NAL PACE4 ,PRECISELY ?AT IS ! HONOR1 ?AT WE1 9 DEFIANCE ( A BUN* ( DORKS1 BE/[ UPON ! 0GREAT ,/AL940 ,JU/ 9 ! DIM5SION 9 :I* ! PROCESS ( ! BEG9N+ ACCUMULATION ( CAPITAL TAKES PLACE & EMBRACES ! PROV9CES ( ! GIANT ,*9A1 ! MY/]I\S ,TIBET1 ! LEG5D>Y ,C5TRAL ,ASIA 7\T ( :I* ! ,EUROPEAN TRIBE EM]G$71 WILL IT BE REVOLUTION>Y & SP9 ! :EEL ( HI/ORY =W>D4 ,BUT ?IS IS NOT A SOCIALI/1 BUT A CAPITALI/ PROCESS4 ,9 ?IS BIG P>T ( ! GLOBE1 ! GLORIFICATION ( ! DEVELOPM5T ( PRODUCTIVE =CES IS NECESS>Y4 ,/AL9 CORRECTLY SAYS1 ?AT ?IS IS NOT HIS CR$IT1 BUT ?AT ( ! ECONOMIC LAWS1 :I* 5=CES !SE 0POLICIES0 UPON HIM4 ,HIS 5TIRE UND]TAK+ IS MADE UP ( FRAUDUL5T LABEL+3 ?IS IS AS WELL A CLASSICAL MEAN ( ! BE>]S ( PRIMITIVE ACCUMULATION6 ,9 ! WE/1 H[EV]1 ! EXUB]ANT PRODUCTIVE =CES = A LONG TIME TRIGG] FLOOD WAVES1 ONE AFT] ANO!R1 :I* PROMPTS ! /ATES TO SUPPRESS1 TO DEV\R M>KETS & REGIONS1 TO PREP>E BLOOD BA?S & W>S4 ,H]E NO PLANS TO 9CREASE PRODUCTION HELP1 9/EAD ONLY ! PLAN TO SMA% A GANG ( CRIM9ALS CAN HELP H]E4 ,ESPECIALLY ! PLAN1 TO TRA% !IR REEK+ FLAG ( FRE$OM & P>LIAM5T>ISM4 ,SOCIALISM & ,COMMUNISM ,WE WILL CONCLUDE ! ECONOMIC >GUM5T ) A SYN!SIS ( ! /AGES ( ! FUTURE SOCIETY - A TOPIC1 9 :I* ! :OLE ( ,/AL9'S 0DOCUM5T0 7WE W]E LOOK+ = ?AT WORD ! 5TIRE TIME7 IS CAUS+ CONFUSION4 0,FRANCE ,PRESS0 ACCUS$ ,/AL9 ( PLAGI>IZ+ ! SCRIPTURE ( ,NIKOLAI ,BUKH>9 AB\T ! ECONOMIC LAWS ( ! TRANSITION P]IOD4 ,/AL9 H[EV] M5TIONS ! TEXTS SEV]AL TIMES & EV5 DRAWS UPON A CRITIQUE AU?OR$ BY ,L59.<#b.>4 ,COMMISSION$ ) ! PREP>ATION ( ! PROGRAM ( ! ,COM9T]N 7:I* /AY$ A DRAFT71 ,BUKH>9 DES]VES ! GREAT CR$IT ( EMPHASIZ+ ! COMMODITY-NEGAT+ PO/ULATE ( ! SOCIALI/ REVOLUTION AS AN ISSUE ( PRIM>Y IMPORTANCE4 ,HE ALSO FOLL[$ ,L59 9 ! ANALYSIS ( ! TRANS=MATION P]IOD 09 ,RUSSIA0 & ! ASSESSM5T1 ?AT DUR+ ! DICTATOR%IP ( ! PROLET>IAT1 =MS ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION W]E TO BE TOL]AT$4 ,EV]Y?+ BECOMES CLE>1 IF ONE BE>S 9 M9D1 ?AT !SE 9VE/IGATIONS ( ,L59 & ,BUKH>9 DIDN'T CONC]N !MSELVES ) ! TWO /AGES ( COMMUNI/ SOCIETY1 ( :I* ,M>X TALKS & :I* ,L59 9 A WOND]FUL PASSAGE ( 0,/ATE & ,REVOLUTION0 \TL9ES1 BUT ) A PHASE1 :I* PREC$ES BO? ?OSE /AGES4 ,! FOLL[+ S*EME CAN S]VE AS A SUMM>Y ( ! C]TA9LY NOT EASY TOPIC ( TODAY'S 0DIALOGUE40 ,TRANSITION /AGE3 ,! PROLET>IAT HAS CONQU]$ POLITICAL P[] & R5D]S ALL NON-PROLET>IAN CLASSES POLITICALLY P[]LESS1 PRECISELY BECAUSE IT CANNOT 0GET RID0 ( ?OSE CLASSES 9 AN 9/ANT4 ,?IS MEANS1 ! PROLET>IAN /ATE CONTROLS AN ECONOMY1 9 :I* P>TLY1 EV5 IF 9 DECREAS+ AM\NT1 BO? A M>KET-BAS$ DI/RIBUTION AS WELL AS =MS ( PRIVATE DISPOSAL ( PRODUCTS & MEANS ( PRODUCTION EXI/ 7!SE BE FRAGM5T$ OR CONC5TRAT$74 ,! ECONOMY IS NOT YET SOCIALI/1 IT'S A TRANSITION ECONOMY4 ,L[] /AGE ( COMMUNISM1 OR IF Y\ WANT1 SOCIALISM3 SOCIETY DISPOSES ALREADY G5]ALLY ( PRODUCTS1 :I* >E ALLOCAT$ TO MEMB]S ( SOCIETY BY QUOTAS4 ,?IS FUNCTION DOESN'T REQUIRE COMMODITY EX*ANGE OR MONEY ANYMORE - ONE CANNOT LET ,/AL9'S /ATEM5T PASS1 ACCORD+ TO :I* ! SIMPLE EX*ANGE )\T MONEY1 BUT /ILL BAS$ ON ! LAW ( VALUE1 %\LD BR+ US CLOS] TO COMMUNISM3 RA!R IT IS AB\T A K9D ( REGRESSION TO B>T]+4 ,! ALLOCATION ( PRODUCTS ON ! CONTR>Y FOLL[S FROM ! C5T]1 )\T RETURN ( AN EQUIVAL5T4 ,EXAMPLE3 ,IF A MAL>IA EPIDEMIC BREAKS \T1 9 ! AFFECT$ REGION QU99E IS DI/RIBUT$ = FREE1 BUT SOLELY ONE TUBULE P] P]SON4 ,9 ?IS PHASE1 NOT ONLY COMPULSORY WORK IS NECESS>Y1 BUT ALSO ! RECORD+ ( ! P]=M$ LABOR TIME & ITS C]TIFICATE - ! FAM\S 0LABOR V\*]10 SO MU* DISCUSS$ 9 ! LA/ C5TURY4 ,! PECULI>ITY ( ?IS C]TIFICATE IS1 ?AT IT CANNOT BE KEPT 9 RES]VE1 SO ?AT ANY TRY TO ACCUMULATE IT LEADS TO ! LOSS ( ! P]=M$ LABOR QUANTUM )\T COMP5SATION4 ,! LAW ( VALUE IS BURI$4 ,5GELS3 0,H5CE1 ON ! ASSUMPTIONS WE MADE ABOVE1 SOCIETY WILL NOT ASSIGN VALUES TO PRODUCTS40 ,HI<] /AGE ( COMMUNISM1 :I* CAN BE UNHESITAT+LY CAN BE CALL$ 9TEGRAL SOCIALISM3 ! PRODUCTIVITY ( LABOR IS 9 SU* A WAY1 ?AT1 AP>T FROM PA?OLOGICAL CASES1 NEI!R CO]CION NOR RATION+ >E NECESS>Y1 TO EXCLUDE ! SQU&]+ ( PRODUCTS & HUMAN 5]GY4 ,FREE CONSUMPTION = ALL4 ,EXAMPLE3 ,! PH>MACIES >E DI/RIBUT+ QU99E FREE & )\T CON/RA9TS4 ,& IF ONE W\LD TAKE T5 TUBULES TO POISON HIMSELF8 ,HE W\LD OBVI\SLY BE JU/ AS /UPID AS ! PEOPLE1 :I* CONFUSE A ROTT5 B\RGEOIS SOCIETY ) SOCIALISM4 ,9 :I* /AGE DOES ,/AL9 F9D HIMSELF8 ,9 NONE ( ! ?REE4 ,HE IS 9 A TRANSITION P]IOD1 NOT AWAY FROM CAPITALISM1 BUT T[>DS CAPITALISM4 ,IT'S ALMO/ HONORABLE & C]TA9LY NOT SELF POISON+4 ,?IRD ,DAY 7,MORN+7 ,ON DAY ONE WE >GU$ ! FACT1 ?AT ANY SY/EM ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION IS A CAPITALI/ SY/EM1 EV] S9CE ?R\< ! LABOR ( MASSES ( HUMANS 5ORM\S ACCUMULATIONS ( COMMODITIES >E PRODUC$4 ,CAPITALISM & COMMODITY PRODUCTION WILL TOGE!R FADE \T ( ! SPH]ES ( 9FLU5CE ?AT !Y GRADUALLY CONQU]$ 9 ! MOD]N WORLD4 ,ON ! SECOND DAY ?IS GOT TAK5 UP AGA92 & COM+ FROM ! G5]AL PROCESS TO TODAY'S ,RUSSIAN ECONOMY1 WE ?\D+ ! /RUCTURE ( ! ,RUSSIAN ECONOMY AS APPROPRIATE4 ,! DIAGNOSIS ( PURE CAPITALISM1 9 ! /AGE ( 0GREAT /ATE 9DU/RIALISM0 WAS CONFIRM$4 ,ACCORD+ TO ! NOTION ( \R DIALOGUE P>TN]1 ?IS SUFFICI5TLY DEF9$ & CONCRETE PROCESS CAN1 APPLI$ TO GIANT >EAS & POPULATIONS1 LEAD TO ! ACCUMULATION & CONC5TRATION ( A HEAVY 9DU/RY1 :I* DOESN'T RANK BEH9D O!RS1 & 9DE$ SOLELY ON ! BASIS ( ! S9CE #aiag 5SU$ ELIM9ATION ( BIG L&[N]S1 )\T 9EVITABLY REPEAT+1 AS AT ?AT TIME 9 ,5GL&1 ,FRANCE ETC41 HORRIBLE EXPROPRIATION ( ! L[] POPULATION /RATA1 :O >E CAUATE 9VE/IGATION1 NAMELY ) ! TREATM5T ( ! 0AGR>IAN QUE/ION40 ,C\LD BE1 ?AT ,/AL9 WILL %[1 ATTA9+ COMPLETE CAPITALISM NOT BY HORSE & C>T1 BUT BY PLANE - BUT HE %\LD AT LEA/ /ATE ! 0DIRECTION40 ,WE1 ! RANK & FILE1 TRANSMIT TO HIM FROM MANY GR\ND /ATIONS A SET ( DATA - H[EV] EV5 ! RAD> CAN GO HAYWIRE4 ,& N[ A ?IRD PO9T3 ! 9T]NATIONAL RELATIONS )9 ! COMPLEX OV]ALL CONTEXT ( PRODUCTION1 EX*ANGE & CONSUMPTION2 POLITICAL & MILIT>Y BALANCES ( P[]4 ,! ?REE PO9TS >E ONLY ASPECTS ( ONE & ! SAME BIG QUE/ION4 ,! FIR/ C\LD BE CALL$ ! HI/ORICAL1 ! SECOND ! ECONOMIC & ! ?IRD ! POLITICAL ASPECT4 ,DIRECTION & GOAL ( ! 9VE/IGATION MU/ BE SET 9 ONE4 ,PRODUCTS & EX*ANGE ,9 HIS !ORETICAL CORRECTIONS & ! CORRESPOND+LY H>% REF]RALS AGA9/ ! OBJECTIONS ( ! 0COMRADES10 ! ,RUSSIAN /ATE & P>TY LEAD] APP>5TLY NE$S TO *ANGE FRONTS EV]Y TIME1 :5 HE GETS ON FROM ! CIRCULATION )9 ! C\NTRY BORD]S TO ! TRANSC5D+ CIRCULATION4 ,WE ALREADY ALLUD$1 ! READ] WILL RECALL1 ?AT ! WE/]N 0BORD] GU>DS0 AT ?IS PO9T HAVE P]K$ UP !IR E>S4 ,F> FROM AGA9 /RIK+ UP ! SONG ( A MILL5>IAN AUT>KY1 ! MAN 9 ! ,KREML9 CALMLY HAS SET ! B9OCUL>S ON ! >EAS BEYOND ! ,IRON ,CURTA92 & OLD /ORIES AB\T ! DIVISION ( SPH]ES ( 9FLU5CE AS AN ALT]NATIVE TO ! SAB] RATTL+ & ! AB&ONM5T ( RELATIONS GET A *ANCE4 ,AT LEA/ ONE ?+1 ?AT DOESN'T S\ND AS SPECTACUL> & IMP]T95T1 AS ! LITANY AB\T G5OCIDE & CRAZE ( AGGRESSION4 ,/AL9 CLAIMS1 ! MANN]1 H[ )9 ,RUSSIA 7& ! SI/] C\NTRIES7 9DU/RY ITEMS >E ASSIGN$ TO ! RURAL POPULATION & AGR>IAN PRODUCTS TO ! URBANITES1 IS P]FECTLY 9 ACCORDANCE ) SOCIALISM - :ILE SLAY+ EV]YONE & EV]Y?+ ) QUOTES ( ,M>X & ,5GELS1 &1 :5 NECESS>Y1 CORRECT+ !IR WORDS1 S5T5CES & WORD+S EX (FICIO4 ,! KOLKHOZES 0FREELY0 SELL !IR PRODUCTS - !RE IS NO O!R WAY ( GETT+ HOLD ( !IR MAK+S2 SO AFT] ALL ?R\< ! M>KET1 BUT !RE >E SPECIAL RULES3 /ATE ADM9I/]$ PRICES 7,NOVELTY6 ,SPECIALTY ( ! H\SE67 & EV5 SPECIAL 0CONTRACTS0 AB\T COMMODITY DELIV]IES ) 0NON-COMMODITY *>ACT]0.<#b#a.>1 BECAUSE ! /ATE BUS9ESS DON'T OP]ATE ) MONEY1 BUT UND]TAKE (FSET AGREEM5TS 7,HIE ! HUCK/] AT ! NEXT CORN]1 ! ,AM]ICAN M>9E1 :I* PRECISELY KN[S AB\T ! EQUIVAL5CE ( KISS+ & CIG>ETTES1 & ! MUNDANE 0CLE>+S0 ( ! WE/]N C\NTRIES674 ,H[EV]1 ! MA/] DOESN'T F9D ! EXPRESSION 0COMMODITY DELIV]Y0 APPROPRIATE1 ONE %\LD TALK AB\T PRODUCT EX*ANGE4 7,ADD+ ?IS ONLY1 SO ! MI/AKE ISN'T SE>*$ = 9 ! TRANSLATION74 ,9 %ORT1 ALL MORE OR LESS CONV5TIONAL EQUIVAL5T SY/EMS1 FROM ! B>T] ( ! SAVAGES TO MONEY AS UNIV]SAL EQUIVAL5T = ALL PRODUCTS1 ! GAZILLION SY/EMS TO ISSUE P]=MANCE & REW>D1 :I* REA* FROM ! H\SEKEEP+ BOOK TO ! COMPLICAT$ BANK+ BUS9ESS1 :]E ELECTRONIC BRA9S ADD UP 5DLESS QUEUES ( NUMB]S1 :ILE DAILY ! /IFL+ FLOOD ( KICK+ !IR HEELS SELL]S ( LABOR P[] SWELLS - :Y DID ALL ?IS EM]GE1 :AT IS IT GOOD =1 IF NOT = ! EX*ANGE ( PRODUCTS1 & SOLELY = IT8 ,BUT ,/AL9 WANTS TO CRACK ! GNAW+ CORE ( ! PROBLEM1 NAMELY1 ?AT \T ( ! 0SAL>IES0 ( EX*ANGE BETWE5 EQUIVAL5TS A PRIVATE ACCUMULATION EM]GES2 & HE SAYS1 !RE W]E GU>ANTEES AGA9/ ?AT4 ,EV5 = A G5]ALISSIMO IT IS DIFFICULT TO /AY 9 ! SADDLE ) SU* A !SIS & ALT]NATELY F5CE 9 TWO DIRECTIONS - ONE BL[ AGA9/ !ORETICAL RIGOR1 ONE BL[ AGA9/ ! REVISIONI/ CONCESSIONS4 ,ELA/ICITY ( ! REAL ,L59I/ ,BOL%EVISM8 ,NO1 ECLECTICISM1 WAS \R ANSW]2 BACK !N ?AT WAS ! LA/ /RAW = ! ,BOL%EVIKS4 ,N[1 NO MATT] 9 :AT %APE ! DOME/IC CONDITIONS MIFUL1 BECAUSE HE CLAIM$ ?AT EV5 ! MA*9ES & TOOLS PRODUC$ 9 ! /ATE BUS9ESSES >E COMMODITIES4 ,!Y HAVE VALUE1 !IR PRICE IS DET]M9$ & YET !Y >5'T COMMODITIES8 ,ONE CAN LIT]ALLY SEE ,NOTK9 BE+ AE1 ACCORD+ TO ,/AL91 0NE$$ 9 ORD]1 9 ! 9T]E/S ( \R =EIGN TRADE1 TO CONDUCT SALES ( MEANS ( PRODUCTION TO =EIGN C\NTRIES4 ,H]E1 9 ! SPH]E ( =EIGN TRADE1 BUT ONLY 9 ?IS SPH]E0 7UND]L9$ 9 ! ORIG9AL71 0\R MEANS ( PRODUCTION REALLY >E COMMODITIES1 & REALLY >E SOLD 79 ! DIRECT MEAN+ ( ! T]M740 .<,/AL91 P4 #e#c.>4 ,! LA/ P>5!SES ORIG9ATE 9 ! (FICIALLY RELEAS$ TEXT4 ,PRESUMABLY ! IMPROVID5T ,NOTK9 PUT ! WORD 0SOLD10 :I* A ,M>XI/ & ,BOL%EVIK IS QUITE F$ UP )1 9 QUOTES4 ,HE MU/ HAVE MISS$ ! LATE/ TRA9+ C\RSES4 ,9 A FEW YE>S1 WE W\LD BE 9T]E/$ 9 ! FOLL[+ 9=MATION3 ,! VOLUME ( ! BALANCE ( TRADE PLEASE1 SO ! RATIO ( COMMODITY IMPORT & EXPORT4 ,& ANO!R ?+3 %\LD ?IS BALANCE TURN \T POSITIVELY OR NEGATIVELY8 ,FROM ! SO CALL$ LAW ( ! WELL-PLANN$ 0PROPORTIONAL0 DEVELOPM5T ( ! NATIONAL ECONOMY WE KN[ ?AT ! SOCIAL PRODUCT %\LD GR[ AT A FURI\S SPE$4 ,WE DON'T SPEAK ,RUSSIAN1 BUT ASSUME ?AT !REBY IT IS TO BE UND]/OOD3 PLANS = ! 0UN9T]RUPT$ GR[? ( PRODUCTION10 ?AT IS ANALOG\S TO ! LAW ( POPULATION GR[? OR COMP\ND 9T]E/4 ,WE !RE=E PROPOSE ! FOLL[+1 CORRECT D5OTATION3 PLANN+ ( GR[? 9 GEOMETRIC PROGRESSION4 ,! 0CURVE0 DRAWN RITS :]E ?IS CURVE BREAKS D[N4 ,= TODAY WE RECORD ,/AL9'S CONCESSION3 ! PRODUCTS DE/9$ = =EIGN TRADE1 AMONG !M ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION1 >E COMMODITIES1 NOT ONLY 0=MALLY10 9 ACC\NT+1 BUT ALSO 9 0*>ACT]40 ,?AT IS ONE ?+4 ,IT IS 5\< TO DISCUSS ACROSS A FEW ?\S& KILOMET]S TO F9ALLY COME TO UND]/&+ REG>D+ ANY?+4 ,PR(IT & SURPLUS VALUE ,A LITTLE BIT MORE PATI5CE1 !N WE WILL TALK ( HI< POLITICS & /RATEGY1 & !N ! FR[N+ WILL 5D1 BECAUSE EV]YONE UND]/&S ! PO9T3 WILL ,CES> ATTACK8 ,POMPEIUS FLEE8 ,DO WE MEET AT ,PHILIPPI AGA98 ,WILL WE CROSS ! ,RUBICON8 ,?AT IS WELCOM$ FODD] = CONV]SATION ?AT LIFTS ! SPIRITS4 ,WE MU/ PO9T TO ANO!R PO9T ( ,M>XI/ POLITICAL ECONOMY4 ,! P[] ( ?+S LEADS ! M>%AL TO ! EXPLOSIVE PROBLEM ( ! WORLD M>KET4 ,! ,U,S,S,R1 HE SAYS1 SUPPORTS ITS SI/] C\NTRIES ?R\< ECONOMIC AID1 :I* ACCEL]ATES !IR 9DU/RIALIZATION4 ,DOES ?AT ALSO APPLY = ,CZE*OSLOVAKIA AS WELL AS ,*9A1 ?AT IS1 = AN ALREADY CAPITALI/ C\NTRY1 AS WELL AS = A C\NTRY1 9 :I* ! CAPITALI/ MODE ( PRODUCTION IS /ILL 9 ! E>LY /AGES & ONLY CON/ITUTES A FRACTION ( AGGREGATE PRODUCTION8 ,LET'S SEE4 0,IT MAY BE CONFID5TLY SAID ?AT1 ) ?IS PACE ( 9DU/RIAL DEVELOPM5T1 IT WILL SOON COME TO PASS ?AT !SE C\NTRIES WILL NOT ONLY BE 9 NO NE$ ( IMPORTS FROM CAPITALI/ C\NTRIES1 BUT WILL !MSELVES FEEL ! NECESSITY ( F9D+ AN \TSIDE M>KET = !IR SURPLUS PRODUCTS40 .<,/AL91 P4#c#b.>4 ,:I* AGA9 BR+S UP ! QUE/ION3 IF PRODUCTION 7& EXPORT7 IS DONE = ! WE/1 !N ?OSE >E COMMODITIES2 & IF IT IS DONE = ,RUSSIA1 :AT >E !Y !N8 ,! PO9T AB\T ?IS RETURN TO ! SY/EM ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION1 CONSUMMAT$ ) FLY+ COLORS1 :I* IS ID5TICAL ) ! CAPITALI/ SY/EM 9 =M & *>ACT] 7IF ONE DOES NOT FALL = ! ECONOMIC MAKE-UP71 IS ?AT IT IS F\ND$ ON ! IMP]ATIVE3 EXPORT TO PRODUCE MORE6 ,EFFECTIVELY IT IS ! SAME IMP]ATIVE :I* ALSO P]TA9S )9 ! SUPPOS$ 0SOCIALI/ C\NTRY03 ! RELATIONS BETWE5 T[N & C\NTRY1 BETWE5 ! FAM\S 0ASSOCIAT$ CLASSES10 >E AB\T AN IMPORT-EXPORT BUS9ESS1 BECAUSE H]E ALSO1 AS ALREADY M5TION$1 ! LAW ( GEOMETRIC PROGRESSION APPLIES1 :I* SAYS3 MORE PRODUCTION6 ,MORE PRODUCTION6 ,:AT REMA9S ( ,M>XISM8 ,B>ELY ANY?+6 ,S9CE 0! WORK+ CLASS1 . N[ 9 P[]10 IT IS 0NECESS>Y0 TO 0AB&ON0 ! (F5SIVE =MULAS :I* DI/+UI% BETWE5 NECESS>Y LABOR & SURPLUS LABOR1 PAID & UNPAID LABOR .<,/AL91 P4#a#h_/#a#i.>4 ,:ILE ! LAW ( SURPLUS VALUE 7:I* H]E ACCORD+ TO ,/AL9'S CRIT]IA IS A !ORY & NOT A LAW71 FIR/ SOME:AT WAS SP>$1 FROM TODAY ! FOLL[+ APPLIES3 0,IT IS SAID ?AT ! LAW ( ! AV]AGE RATE ( PR(IT IS ! BASIC ECONOMIC LAW ( MOD]N CAPITALISM4 ,?AT IS NOT TRUE4 ,MOD]N CAPITALISM1 MONOPOLY CAPITALISM0 7!RE Y\ GO3 :AT DID Y\ KN[1 POOR ,M>X87 0CANNOT CONT5T IT-SELF ) ! AV]AGE PR(IT1 :I* MOREOV] HAS A T5D5CY TO DECL9E1 9 VIEW ( ! 9CREAS+ ORGANIC COMPOSITION ( CAPITAL4 ,IT IS NOT ! AV]AGE PR(IT1 BUT ! MAXIMUM PR(IT ?AT MOD]N MONOPOLY CAPITALISM DEM&S40 ,:ILE ! SUBORD9ATE CLAUSE 70:I* IT NE$S44407 SEEMS TO BR+ ! EXT+UI%$ ,M>XIAN LAW 9TO BE+ = A MOM5T1 ! NEW LAW IS DECRE$ AFT] ALL3 ,! DEM& = MAXIMUM PR(IT 0WILL BE ! BASIC ECONOMIC LAW ( MOD]N CAPITALISM0 .<,/AL91 P4#c#i.>4 ,IF ! FLAME?R[] 9 ! LIBR>Y ISN'T HALT$1 NOT EV5 HIS MU/A*E IS GO+ TO BE SP>$4 ,?OSE TWI/$ C\NT]-!SES1 :I* TRY TO SECURE !MSELVES AGA9/ ANY OBJECTION1 >E UNBE>ABLE4 ,FIR/1 IT IS /AT$ ?AT ! ECONOMIC LAWS ( MONOPOLY CAPITALISM W\LD 5TIRELY DIFF] FROM ! CAPITALISM 0( ,M>X40 ,& !N ! SAME C\NT]-!SES ASS]T ?AT ! ECONOMIC LAWS ( SOCIALISM C\LD V]Y WELL BE ! SAME AS ?OSE ( CAPITALISM4 ,FRE% AIR1 QUICK6 ,LET'S H]OICALLY RETURN TO ! ,A,B,C4 ,ONE H]E HAS TO REM9D ( ! DI/9CTION BETWE5 ! MASS ( PR(IT & ! MASS ( SURPLUS VALUE1 BETWE5 RATE ( PR(IT & RATE ( SURPLUS VALUE1 & ( ! MEAN+ ( ! ,M>XIAN LAW ( ! T5D5CY ( ! AV]AGE RATE ( PR(IT TO FALL1 :I* IS /AT$ 9 DETAIL AT ! BEG9N+ ( ! ?IRD 0,CAPITAL0 VOLUME4 ,READ+ - UND]/&+6 ,IT IS NOT ! CAPITALI/ ?AT T5DS TO DECREASE PR(IT4 ,IT IS NOT PR(IT 7! MASS ( PR(IT7 ?AT DECREASES1 BUT ! RATE ( PR(IT6 ,NOT ! RATE ( ANY PR(IT1 BUT ! AV]AGE RATE ( SOCIAL PR(IT4 ,NOT ANY WEEK OR 9 ANY ISSUE ( ! 0,F9ANCIAL ,TIMES10 BUT HI/ORICALLY1 9 ! DEVELOPM5T PR$E/9$ BY ,M>X T[>DS ! 0SOCIAL MONOPOLY ( ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION0 9 ! GRIP ( CAPITAL1 :OSE DEF9ITION1 G5ESIS1 LIFE & DEA? >E WRITT54 ,HE :O UND]/&S ?IS1 CAN SEE ?AT ! EF=T1 NOT ( ! S+LE CAPITALI/ 7A M9OR FIGURE 9 ,M>X71 BUT ( ! HI/ORICAL MA*9E ( CAPITAL 7?IS 05S\L$ CORPUS0 TAL5T$ ) 0VIS VITALIS071 TO ESCAPE ! LAW ( ! T5D5CY ( ! RATE ( PR(IT TO FALL IS FUTILE2 & PRECISELY ?IS LAW LET'S US CONCLUDE ! FOLL[+1 CLASSICAL !SES 7TO :I* ,/AL91 CONFUS+ ! WE/1 AGA9 CONFESSES73 ,FIR/3 ,9EVITABILITY ( W> BETWE5 ! CAPITALI/ C\NTRIES4 ,SECOND3 ,9EVITABILITY ( ! REVOLUTION>Y OV]?R[ ( CAPITALISM1 :]ESOEV]4 ,IT IS A GIANT EF=T ?AT ! CAPITALI/ SY/EM DEPLOYS 9 FIX ,= \R L9E ( >GUM5T1 WE ONCE AGA9 HAVE TO RETURN TO ,M>X & ,5GELS4 ,?IS TIME NOT TO ! SELF-CONTA9$ & COMPLETE TEXTS1 AS IF MADE FROM ONE PIECE BY ONE OR ! O!R1 WRITT5 ) FULL P[] & ! GR\NDBREAK+ EAG]NESS ( ?OSE :O KN[ NEI!R D\BT1 NOR >E FLU/]$ & :O REMOVE OB/ACLES 9 ! WAY1 )\T C>+ AB\T !IR RESI/ANCE4 ,IT IS AB\T ! ,M>X1 ( :I* HIS 0EXECUTOR ( TE/AM5T0 GIVES ACC\NT 9 ! ALMO/ DRAMATIC PREFACES TO ! ,I,I4 7#e4#e4#a#h#h#e7 & TO ! ,I,I,I4 7#d4#a4#a#h#i#d7 VOLUME ( 0,CAPITAL40 ,FIR/ IT IS AB\T EXPLA9+ ! /ATE ( ! 5ORM\S MASS ( MAT]IALS & MANUSCRIPTS - !Y REA* FROM *APT]S 9 ELABORAT$ =M TO LOOSE PAGES1 NOTICES1 SUMM>IES1 ILLEGIBLE ABBREVIATIONS1 PROMISES REG>D+ LAT] TO BE DEVELOP$ PO9TS1 AS WELL AS UNC]TA9LY & CAUTI\SLY COMPOS$ PAGES PROVID$ ) ANNOTATIONS - ) ! DET]IORAT+ HEAL? ( ,M>X1 ) ! 9ESCAPABLE RAMIFICATIONS ( ! PROGRESS+ DISEASE :I* =CES 9T]RUPTIONS UPON HIM1 :I* QUAIL & ATTACK ! MIS #ahfc & #a#h#f#g1 AMONG IT ! FLAWLESSLY COMPOS$ FIR/ VOLUME ( HIS MA9 WORK1 IS IMMEASURABLE4 ,ALREADY 9 ! YE>S #ahfd TO #ahfe ! DISEASE %[$ FIR/ SIGNS ( HEAL? DISORD]S2 ! IMP]TURBABLE SIS . . WRIT+ TIME TO A M9IMUM10 AS HE GOT DISALL[$ FROM 0TAK+ ! QUILL 9TO ! H& UND] >TIFICIAL LIEAS1 9 :I* ! BRUNT MORE & MORE FELL TO HIM 0SOLELY40 ,ONE YE> LAT]1 HE DI$4 ,?IS IS NEI!R 9CID5TAL NOR CONCEIT$4 ,IT %\LD ONLY MAKE CLE> ?AT ! ASPIRATION ( $ITORIAL DILIG5CE :I* DET]M9$ ,5GELS' COMPILATION WORK 5G5D]$ ?AT 9 ! LA/ TWO VOLUMES ( ,CAPITAL ! P]IODICALLY RETURN+ SECTIONS ( SYN!SIS & SUMM>Y ALMO/ FULLY >E MISS+4 ,5GELS' QUILL WE ALSO [E SU* P>5!SES1 & NOT FEW OR ( LITTLE USE ( !M2 BUT HE DOESN'T WANT TO MANAGE SOME?+ 0:I* JU/ WASN'T 9 ,M>X' BOOK10 & SO HE CONF9ES HIMSELF TO ANALYSIS4 ,HAD IT BE5 DIFF]5T1 C]TA9 %ADY 9T]PRETATIONS 7TODAY AS HALF A C5TURY AGO7 W\LD HAVE BE5 FUTILE1 = EXAMPLE ! SAD LEG5D1 ACCORD+ TO :I* ,M>X 9 ! ?IRD & LA/ VOLUME REVOK$ - ACCORD+ TO ! P]SONAL TA/E ( ! AU?OR3 9 ! PHILOSOPHY1 ! ECONOMIC SCI5CE OR ! POLITICS - SOME?+4 ,9 TRU? 9 ! FIR/ VOLUME !RE >E AS MANY EXPLICIT REF]5CES TO ! E>LY SCRIPTURES OR ! 0,MANIFE/O0 AS CONNECTIONS BETWE5 ! LA/ TWO SCRIPTURES & ! FIR/ VOLUME - ?\S&S ( PASSAGE ( CORRESPOND5CE RE9=CE ?IS4 ,H]E IT IS EV5 LESS ?AN 9 ,5GELS' WORK AB\T CONDUCT+ 0,CAPITAL RESE>*40 ,LET'S JU/ REM>K ?AT ,M>X 9 ONE ( ?OSE %ORT SUMM>IES SAYS1 :Y HE IS SO ?OR\5!SES1 0BECAUSE1 ?\< A REHA% ( ! NOTES ( ! ORIG9AL MANUSCRIPT1 IT GOES 9 SOME PO9TS BEYOND ! SCOPE ( ! MAT]IAL F\ND 9 ! ORIG9AL40 0.<,! LAW ( 9CREAS$ PRODUCTIVITY ( LABOR IS NOT1 !RE=E1 ABSOLUTELY VALID = CAPITAL4 ,SO F> AS CAPITAL IS CONC]N$1 PRODUCTIV5ESS DOES NOT 9CREASE ?R\< A SAV+ 9 LIV+ LABOR 9 G5]AL1 BUT ONLY ?R\< A SAV+ 9 ! PAID PORTION ( LIV+ LABOR1 AS COMP>$ TO LABOR EXP5D$ 9 ! PA/1 AS WE HAVE ALREADY 9DICAT$ 9 PASS+ 9 ,BOOK ,I 7,*4 ,X,I ,I,I1 #b1 #e4 #d#i_/#c#i#h74 ,H]E ! CAPITALI/ MODE ( PRODUCTION IS BESET ) ANO!R CONTRADICTION4 ,ITS HI/ORICAL MISSION IS UNCON/RA9$ DEVELOPM5T 9 GEOMETRICAL PROGRESSION ( ! PRODUCTIVITY ( HUMAN LABOR4 ,IT GOES BACK ON ITS MISSION :5EV]1 AS H]E1 IT *ECKS ! DEVELOPM5T ( PRODUCTIVITY4 ,IT ?US DEMON/RATES AGA9 ?AT IT IS BECOM+ S5ILE & ?AT IT IS MORE & MORE \TLIV$4.>0 ,UNAFFECT$ BY ! PH>ISAIC OBJECTION ?AT AFT] ANO!R #f YE>S ( CAPITALISM 7H[EV] ) A /RONG DA% ( DECAY7 ONE %\LD ) ! AS ALWAYS 0C>ELESS0 ,M>X TRIPLE ! P>5!SES 9/EAD ( CANCEL !M \T1 WE EMPHASIZE ! PROGRAMMATIC !SES :I* ,M>X SO 0GLADLY0 9S]T$ 9 ! DISC]N+ & PR(\ND ANALYZES4 ,SO CAPITALISM WILL COLLAPSE4 ,& PO/-CAPITALISM8 ,IT IS LIKE ?AT3 ,AS ! PRODUCTIVITY ( EV]Y WORK UNIT 9CREASES1 WE DO NOT 9CREASE ! MASS ( PRODUCTS1 BUT DECREASE ! WORK+ TIME ( ! LIV+4 ,:Y DOES ! ,WE/ NOT WANT TO KN[ SOME?+ AB\T ?AT8 ,BECAUSE !RE IS ONLY ONE S+LE WAY TO FLEE FROM ! LAW ( ! FALL 9 ! RATE ( PR(IT3 OV]PRODUCTION4 ,& ! ,EA/8 ,DITTO4 ,BUT = ! SAKE ( FAIRNESS LET'S REM>K ?AT CAPITALISM !RE IS /ILL UND]GO+ ITS ADOLESC5CE4 ,RATE & ,MASS ,IT IS TIME TO AGA9 TURN T[>DS ! D$UCTION ( ! LAW3 ,AS LONG AS WE >E NOT SMITT5 ) BL9DNESS1 IT IS ANYWAY NOT ON ! SCRAP HEAP4 ,WE WILL !RE CIRCUMV5T BO? ! LANGUAGE ( NUMB]S AS WELL AS ALGEBRAIC SYMBOLISM &1 AS F> AS POSSIBLE1 PRES]VE ! BREVITY & ! POLI% ( ! FABLE4 0,C\LD COMMODITIES !MSELVES SPEAK10 ,M>X SAYS 9 ONE ( ?OSE WOND]FUL PASSAGES ( 0,CAPITAL10 0!Y W\LD SAY3 ,\R USE VALUE MAY BE A ?+ ?AT 9T]E/S M54 ,IT IS NO P>T ( US AS OBJECTS4 ,:AT1 H[EV]1 DOES BELONG TO US AS OBJECTS1 IS \R VALUE4 ,\R NATURAL 9T]C\RSE AS COMMODITIES PROVES IT4 ,9 ! EYES ( EA* O!R WE >E NO?+ BUT EX*ANGE VALUES40 ,SO WE ATTA*$ A MICROPHONE ON ! M>KETPLACE ON :I* ! COMMODITIES HAIL+ FROM ,RUSSIA & ,AM]ICA MEET4 ,! ONES FROM ! 0HI<] LEVELS0 HAVE ALL[$ !M TO SPEAK A COMMON ECONOMIC LANGUAGE4 ,= BO? COMMODITIES1 ! SACROSANCT PR9CIPLE APPLIES ?AT ! T>GET$ M>KET PRICE MU/ LIE ABOVE ! CO/ ( PRODUCTION 7O!RWISE !Y W\LD NOT HAVE TRAVEL$ ! LONG WAY74 ,9 BO? HOMEL&S ONE IS CONC]N$ ) PRODUC+ !M AT L[ CO/ & TO SELL AT HI< PRICE4 ,! COMMODITY HAIL+ FROM ! L& ( CAPITALI/ !ORY HAS ! WORD3 0,I AM MADE ( TWO P>TS & !RE=E ONLY ONE WELD IS VISIBLE ON ME3 ! CO/ ( PRODUCTION 7A LIV+ & US$ UP ADVANCE ( MY PRODUC]7 & ! PR(IT1 ?AT TOGE!R ADD UP TO ! PRECISE SUM BEL[ ,I1 DON'T DELUDE Y\RSELVES1 DON'T MEET MY PR9CIPLES4 ,TO 5C\RAGE ! BUY]1 ,I CONT5T MYSELF ) A MODE/ PR(IT3 ?R\< A SIMPLE CALCULATION - PR(IT DIVID$ BY CO/ ( PRODUCTION - Y\ CAN *ECK ! RATE ( ?IS PR(IT4 ,SUPPOSE MY CO/ IS #a & Y\ CAN [N ME = #a#a1 DO Y\ WANT TO BE /+Y & CLAIM ?AT ! T5 P]C5T RATE IS EXCESSIVELY HI<8 ,/EP RIXI/ ECONOMICS IS CRITICAL4 ,Y\ SEE TWO WELDS ON ME4 ,I HAVE NO REASON TO HIDE ?AT3 ,BECAUSE ,I CONSI/ ( ?REE & NOT ( TWO P>TS4 ,! TRICK ) ! O!R COMMODITY IS ?AT IT ISN'T VISIBLE !RE4 ,TO PRODUCE ME1 !RE >E TWO EXP5DITURES3 RAW MAT]IALS1 CONSUMPTION ( 9/RUM5TS ( PRODUCTION & SU*LIKE1 :I* WE CALL CON/ANT CAPITAL 9VE/$ 9 ME - & ! COMP5SATION ( HUMAN LABOR1 :I* WE CALL V>IABLE CAPITAL4 ,! SUM =MS :AT ! LADY BE=E ME CALL$ CO/ ( PRODUCTION4 ,= ME AS WELL Y\ HAVE TO ADD A YIELD1 AN E>N+ OR PR(IT1 :I* IS MY ?IRD & LA/ P>T3 CALL$ SURPLUS VALUE4 ,= ! ADVANC$ CON/ANT CAPITAL1 WE CALCULATE NO?+ ON TOP1 AS WE KN[ ?AT IT DOES NOT ADD VALUE3 ONLY LABOR1 MEAN+ ! V>IABLE P>T ( ! ADVANCE CREATES VALUE4 ,SO1 IF Y\ WANT TO DET]M9E ! P]C5TAGE OR ! RATE1 NOT ( PR(IT BUT ( SURPLUS VALUE1 IT IS V]Y EASY AS WELL3 Y\ JU/ HAVE TO DIVIDE ! SURPLUS VALUE BY ! SECOND P>T ( ! CAPITAL ADVANC$ = ME1 ?AT IS1 ! WAGES40 ,:]EUPON ! ORD9>Y BUY] REPLIES3 0,EXPLA9 ?AT TO Y\R HAIRDRESS]6 ,! ONLY ?+ MY WALLET IS 9T]E/$ 9 IS ! 5D CO/1 ?AT IS1 Y\R RESPECTIVE SALE PRICE40 ,!RE IS SPAT BETWE5 ! TWO COMMODITIES1 9 :I* EA* CLAIMS TO WANT TO CLOSE ! LESS PR(ITABLE DEAL & TO SETTLE = ! L[E/ PR(IT RATE4 ,AS NEI!R ( !M CAN PRESS IT D[N TO Z]O1 ! ONE ?AT ACTUALLY HAS ! L[E/ CO/ ( PRODUCTION W9S1 AS ,/AL9 ALSO 9CESSANTLY 9DICATES4 ,= ! CON/ANT P>T1 QUANTITY & QUALITY ( RAW MAT]IALS >E GIV54 ,! COMPETITION 9 BO? EXPORT C\NTRIES IS /AG$ ON ! V>IABLE P>T4 ,& C]TA9LY1 !RE IS ! SOLUTION TO PAY ! WORK]S LESS1 TO LET !M WORK LONG]1 BUT PR$OM9ANTLY LABOR PRODUCTIVITY IS BACK$1 :I* IS CONDITION$ BY TE*NOLOGICAL PROGRESS1 ! USE ( MORE P[]FUL MA*9ES & ! EV] MORE RATIONAL ORGANIZATION ( FIRMS4 ,ALREADY BO? SIDES >E DISPLAY+ GLOSSY PR9TS ( !IR L>GE-SCALE PLANTS1 :]E EA* PRIDES ITSELF 9 HAV+ R$UC$ ! NUMB] ( EMPLOYES AT CON/ANT OR L>G] SCALE ( PRODUCTION4 ,BUT ONE ?+ ?AT ! BUY]S C>E EV5 LESS AB\T IS KN[+ ON :I* SIDE ( ! CONTE/$ M>KET ! WORK]S >E BE+ PAID & TREAT$ BETT]4 ,! READ] WILL1 SO WE ?9K1 )\T EF=T DET]M9E ! DIFF]5CE BETWE5 BO? ME?ODS ( VALUE ANALYSIS4 ,! RATE ( SURPLUS VALUE IS ALWAYS MU* HI<] ?AN ! RATE ( PR(IT1 & ALL ! MORE AS ! CON/ANT CAPITAL \TWEIIABLE4 ,N[1 ! ,M>XIAN LAW ( ! FALL ( ! AV]AGE RATE ( PR(IT DEALS ) PR(IT AS A :OLE1 ?AT IS1 ! TOTAL RETURN ( ALL SPH]ES ( PRODUCTION1 REG>DLESS ( ! LAT] TO DEAL ) DI/RIBUTION 7BETWE5 ! BANK]1 ! 9DU/RIALI/ & ! L&[N]74 ,9 ! #a#c4 *APT] ( ! ?IRD VOLUME ( 0,CAPITAL10 ,M>X REM9DS3 0,WE 9T5TIONALLY PRES5T ?IS LAW BE=E GO+ ON TO ! DIVISION ( PR(IT0 70,PR(IT IS = US1 = ! TIME BE+1 ONLY ANO!R NAME = OR ANO!R CATEGORY ( SURPLUS VALUE07 09TO DIFF]5T 9DEP5D5T CATEGORIES40 ,?IS 0%[S FROM ! \TSET ?AT ?IS LAW IS1 9 ITS 5TIRETY1 9DEP5D5T ( ?IS DIVISION40 ,& SO IT ALSO APPLIES IF ! /ATE BEHAVES AS [N]1 BANK] & 5TREPR5EUR4 ,! LAW IS BAS$ ON ! G5]AL HI/ORICAL PROCESS - D5I$ BY NO ONE1 APOLOGIZ$ = BY EV]YONE - ( ! 9CESSANT DEVELOPM5T ( PRODUCTIVITY DUE TO ! APPLICATION ( EV] MORE COMPLICAT$ 9/RUM5TS1 TOOLS1 MA*9ES1 EV] MORE DIV]SE TE*NICAL PROCESSES & ( SCI5TIFIC A*IEVEM5TS ON MANUAL LABOR4 ,= A GIV5 MASS ( PRODUCTS1 FEW] & FEW] WORK]S >E NE$$4 ,! CAPITAL ADVANC$ ?AT NE$$ TO BE 9VE/$ TO GET H&S ON ?IS MASS ( PRODUCTS CONT9U\SLY *ANGES :AT ,M>X CALLS ! ORGANIC COMPOSITION3 EV] MORE SUB/ANCE-BAS$ CAPITAL1 EV] LESS WAGE CAPITAL4 ,FEW WORK]S SUFFICE TO BE/[ AN 5ORM\S 09CREASE 9 VALUE0 ON ! TO BE PROCESS$ MAT]IAL1 BECAUSE !Y CAN PROCESS A LOT MORE ( IT 9 COMP>ISON TO ! PA/4 ,9 ?IS TOO ONE AGREES4 ,& FUR!R8 ,EV5 ASSUM$ ?AT CAPITAL EXAC]BATES EXPLOITATION & 9CREASES ! RATE ( SURPLUS VALUE BY PAY+ ! WORK]S LESS 7EV5 ?\< ?IS (T5 HAPP5S1 IT ONLY HAS ! *>ACT] ( A LAW FROM ! PO9T ( VIEW ( L\NGE REVOLUTION>IES71 ! SQUEEZ$ \T SURPLUS VALUE1 RESPECTIVELY PR(IT1 WILL 9DE$ 9CREASE1 9 FACE ( ! MU* /RONG] 9CREASE ( ! MASS ( PUR*AS$ RAW MAT]IALS1 ) EQUAL NUMB] ( LABOR P[]S1 ! PR(IT RATE WILL CONT9UE TO FALL3 ,PRECISELY BECAUSE ! RATE EXPRESSES ! RELATION ( ! SLIIAT GR[S1 ! PROCESS$ MAT]IAL BECOMES EV] MORE IMPRESSIVE & ! MASS ( PRODUCTS 9CREASES4 ,9 9FANCY3 SMALL CAPITALS1 DIVID$ BETWE5 MANY & 9VE/$ AT A GOOD RATE2 9 OLD AGE3 GIANT CAPITALS1 DIVID$ ON FEW 7CONSEQU5CE ( CONC5TRATION :I* DEVELOPS 9 P>ALLEL TO ACCUMULATION71 ADMITT$LY 9VE/$ AT A L[ RATE1 H[EV] ) ! RESULT ( ! EXORBITANT1 V]TIGO-9DUC+ 9CREASE ( SOCIAL CAPITAL1 ( SOCIAL PR(IT1 ( AV]AGE BUS9ESS CAPITAL & PR(IT4 ,!RE IS NO CONTRADICTION ) ! ,M>XIAN LAW ( ! FALL 9 ! RATE ( PR(IT1 :I* C\LD ONLY BE DETA9$ BY ! R$UCTION ( LABOR PRODUCTIVITY1 BY 0DEG5]ATION0 ( ! ORGANIC COMPOSITION ( CAPITAL2 AN ISSUE AGA9/ :I* ,/AL9 AT ! MOM5T HAULS \T ! BIG GUNS1 A T]RA9 ON :I* HE DESP]ATELY TRIES TO SUBDUE HIS 5EMIES4 #a#i? & #b? C5TURY ,9 NO4 #b 7#a#i#e#b7 ( 0,IL PROGRAMMA COMUNI/A0 WE PUBLI%$ SOME PLA9 NUMB]S FROM CAPITALI/ S\RCES AB\T ! ,AM]ICAN ECONOMY4 ,!Y PROVE ! LAW DET]M9$ BY ,M>X & NEGAT$ BY ,/AL94 ,ACCORD+ TO /ATI/ICS #a#h#d#h1 ?AT IS1 AT ! APPE>ANCE ( 9DU/RIAL CAPITALISM 9 ! ,U,S,A1 ( #a VALUE UNITS :I* W]E ADD$ TO ! PROCESS$ MAT]IAL 9 ! PROCESS ( PRODUCTION1 #ea UNITS W5T AS WAGES TO ! WORK]S & #di AS PR(IT TO ! 5TREPR5EURS4 ,IF ONE DISREG>DS DEPRECIATION ( MA*9ES1 G5]AL EXP5SES ETC41 ?OSE NUMB]S ON ! ONE H& REPRES5T V>IABLE CAPITAL1 ON ! O!R H& REPRES5T SURPLUS VALUE4 ,!IR RATIO1 OR ! RATE ( SURPLUS VALUE1 IS #i#f.04 ,H[ DID ! B\RGEOIS CALCULATE ! RATE ( PR(IT8 ,TO ANSW] ?IS1 WE HAVE TO KN[ ! VALUE ( ! PROCESS$ RAW MAT]IALS4 ,WE CAN ONLY GUESS IT1 BY ASSUM+ ! HYPO!SIS ?AT 9 ! CRAWL+ PHASE ( 9DU/RY EV]Y WORK] PRODUCES ! QUADRUPLE ( HIS WAGE ON AV]AGE4 ,IF ! WAGES AM\NT TO #e#a1 ! CON/ITUTE #b4#d UNITS4 ,! CO/S ( PRODUCTION AM\NT TO #b4#e#e 9 TOTAL4 ,HI< RATE ( PR(IT3 #a#i1#b.04 ,WE NOTICE ANYWAY ?AT IT ALWAYS LIES B5EA? ! RATE ( SURPLUS VALUE4 ,9 ! YE> #a#i#b#i1 AFT] A LONG CYCLE ( 9SANE GR[?1 ! WORK]S ONLY RECEIV$ #cfb ( #a4 NEWLY ADD$ VALUE UNITS1 ! CAPITALI/S H[EV] #f#c#h4 ,DON'T />T TO GET CONFUS$ N[3 ,UNTIL 0BLACK ,FRIDAY0 ! WAGES 9CREAS$1 & ! LIV+ /&>D ( ! WORK]S 9CREAS$ /RONGLY - ?AT DOESN'T *ANGE A ?+4 ,AS ONE SEES1 ! RATE ( SURPLUS VALUE1 RESPECTIVELY EXPLOITATION 9CREAS$ DRA/ICALLY3 FROM #i#f.0 TO #a#g#f.04 ,IF N[1 AFT] ONE HAS WRITT5 ONE'S F+]S TO ! BONE1 !RE IS /ILL SOMEONE :O DOESN'T UND]/& ?AT ONE CAN BE EXPLOIT$ EV5 MORE DESPITE HI<] WAGES & BETT] FOOD1 !N HE %\LD GO HOME6 ,HE HAS NOT UND]/OOD ! CONSEQU5CES ( ! 9CREAS$ PRODUCTIVITY ( LABOR P[]1 CONSI/+ ( SWEAT & BLOOD ( H>D WORK]S & 5D+ UP 9 ! POCKETS ( ! B\RGEOIS4 ,LET'S N[ DET]M9E ! VALUE ( TOTAL PRODUCTION4 ,LET'S ASSUME ?AT BETWE5 #ahdh & #aibi ?ANKS TO IMPROV$ MA*9ES & ) SAME NUMB] ( WORK]S T5 TIMES MORE RAW MAT]IALS ?AN BE=E C\LD BE PROCESS$4 ,WE CAN QUIETLY ASSUME ?OSE L[ NUMB]S3 ) ! C]TA9TY ( ONE1 :O IS SOME:AT FAMILI> ) SCI5TIFIC SYN!SES & !RE=E )\T PROBLEMS />TS ) PRECONDITIONS :I* >E 9CONV5I5T = ! [N !SIS & :I* B5EFIT ! 5EMY1 ?OSE HAIRSPLITT]S1 :I* TAKE DELIE 9 RAW MAT]IALS DECREAS$ FROM #b4#d TO #a4#d#d#h2 ! OPPOSITE IS ! CASE3 ! %>E RISES TO #a#d4#d#h4 ,) A TOTAL EXP5SE ( #a#d4#h#d#b 9 9VE/M5TS & A PR(IT ( #f#c#h1 ONE HAS A RATE ( PR(IT ( AB\T #d1#e.04 ,! FALL ( ! RATE ( PR(IT3 H]E WE HAVE IT4 ,IT IS 5\< TO PULL (F ONE'S HEAD BE=E ,M>X2 IT IS NOT NECESS>Y TO H& A TISSUE TO 0,UNCLE ,SAM0 TO DRY HIS CROCODILE TE>S6 ,Y\ HAVE UND]/OOD1 WE SE>*$ = ! RATE & NOT ! MASS ( PR(IT4 ,TO GET AN IMAGE ( ! TOTAL EXT5T ( PRODUCTION - EV5 IF NOT 9 REAL VALUES1 !N /ILL 9 =M ( A COMP>ISON BETWE5 BO? EPO*S - ONE HAS TO CONSID] ?AT A NATIONAL PRODUCT ( #cd 9 ! YE> #ahdh IS FAC$ ) #a#e4#d#h 9 #a#i#b#i3 ) NON-NOTEWOR?Y 9CREASE ( WORK] H&S4 ,9 REALITY H[EV]1 ! WORK] POPULATION HAS MULTIPLI$ BY T5 9 ! C\RSE ( ! #h YE>S4 ,ONE CAN ?US E/IMATE ! TOTAL PRODUCT AT #a#e#d4#h1 AB\T ! FIFTYFOLD ( ! YE> #a#h#d#h4 ,:ILE ! AV]AGE RATE ( PR(IT ( ! FACTORY [N]S FELL FROM #a#i1#b.0 TO #d1#c.01 ! MASS ( PR(IT 9CREAS$ FROM #di TO #f4#c#i1 MEAN+ IT IS F\RTE5 TIMES AS HI<4 ,SURELY \R NUMB]S >E /ILL F> TOO MODE/4 ,IMPORTANT WAS ONLY TO PROVE1 ?AT ,AM]ICAN CAPITALISM 9 ! RACE TO ! MAXIMUM PR(IT ADH]ES TO ! LAW ( ! FALL 9 ! RATE ( PR(IT4 ,/AL9 CANNOT $UCE ANY NEW LAWS FROM IT4 ,ADDITIONALLY1 WE DIDN'T ACC\NT = ! CONC5TRATION2 IF WE APPLY A FACTOR ( #a H]E1 ! AV]AGE PR(IT 79 MASS7 ( ! ,AM]ICAN 5T]PRISES AM\NTS TO ! #a#d-FOLD4 ,!RE IT IS3 ! C\RSE = CRISIS1 & ! CONFIRMATION ( ,M>XISM4 ,WE WILL ALL[ \RSELVES AN EV5 BOLD] CALCULATION N[4 ,LET'S ASSUME ! ,AM]ICAN WORK+ CLASS ASSUMES P[] 9 A SITUATION AS 9 ?AT ( #a#i#b#i2 LET'S REPEAT ! NUMB]S3 #a#d4#d#h RAW MAT]IALS1 #cfb LABOR P[]S1 #f* PR(IT1 MEAN+ #a#e4#d#h TOTAL PRODUCT4 ,& !N ! WORK]S READ ,M>X & USE 0! 9CREAS$ PRODUCTIVE P[] ( CAPITAL = ! SAV+ ( LIV+ LABOR AS SU*40 ,A DECREE ( ! REVOLUTION>Y COMMITTEE PU%ES D[N PRODUCTION TO #a4 7:]E IT IS PU%$ D[N WE WILL SEE2 REM9D Y\RSELVES ?AT !RE WON'T BE ANY PRESID5TIAL ELECTIONS OR SIMIL> EV5TS ANYMORE74 ,! WORK]S WILL FIR/ SETTLE = NOT ADD+ ! 5TIRE PR(IT 7:I* IS BURD5$ ) DUES & G5]AL EXP5SES7 TO !IR WAGE ( #c#f#b1 BUT MU* LESS1 SO !Y >RIVE AT1 LET'S SAY #e4 ,= ! FUNCTION+ ( PUBLIC FACILITIES & /ATE-RUN ADM9I/RATIVE BODIES WE D$UCE EV5 MORE ?AN ! #f* ( ! N[ REMOV$ CAPITALI/S1 LET'S SAY #g4 ,ACCORD+ TO \R CALCULATION !RE >E ONLY #h4#h ( TO BE PROCESS$ RAW MAT]IALS 9/EAD ( #a#d4#d#h2 IF ! NUMB] ( WORK]S /AYS CON/ANT1 ! WORK+ DAY ( EA* IS R$UC$ BY #d.03 FROM #h TO LESS ?AN #e H\RS4 ,AS A FIR/ /EP1 ?AT'S NEAT4 ,IF WE N[ CALCULATE ! H\RLY WAGE1 WE W\LD SEE ?AT IT 9CREAS$ BY AB\T #acb P]C5T3 FROM A BIT1 MORE ( #dd TO AB\T #a#c4 ,?IS W\LD NOT BE SOCIALISM4 ,BUT :ILE ,/AL9 ASSUMES TO HAVE DISCOV]$ A NEW LAW ( SOCIALISM1 :I* IS 9 TRU? A LAW ( CAPITALISM 7) ! 9CREASE ( LABOR PRODUCTIVITY PRODUCTION GR[S71 WE CONFRONT HIM ) ! OPPOSITE LAW3 ! 9CREASE ( PRODUCTIVITY LEADS TO ! DECREASE ( HUMAN LABOR EF=T1 :]E ! EXT5T ( PRODUCTION EI!R /AYS CON/ANT OR LAT]1 AFT] ! POISON DRIPP+ & BLOOD SUCK+ BRAN*ES ( ! CAPITALI/ TRUNK HAS BE5 REMOV$1 BEG9S TO 9CREASE 9 A SMOO? CURVE & 9 A WAY ADEQUATE = HUMANITY4 ,AS LONG AS ! CALL RES\NDS TO 9CREASE PRODUCTION BY MOBILIZATION ( ALL P[]S1 ?AT JU/ MEANS TO DESP]ATELY RESI/ AGA9/ ! ,M>XIAN LAW ( ! FALL ( ! RATE ( PR(IT4 ,BECAUSE ! RATE ( PR(IT DECREASES1 EV5 ?\< ! MASS ( SURPLUS VALUE & PR(IT DO NOT DECREASE1 PROGRESS RHETORIC & HURRIES WILL %\T AT A SCAMP]$ HUMANITY EV] MORE L\DLY3 WORK MORE1 PRODUCE MORE6 ,& :5 ! LOCAL WORK]S FAC$ ) !IR FRUGAL COMP5SATION CANNOT BUY ! SURPLUS PRODUCT1 ONE NE$S TO F9D MEANS TO CONQU] M>KETS 9 =EIGN C\NTRIES TO 5SURE CONSUMPTION4 ,?AT IS ! VICI\S CYCLE ( IMP]IALISM1 :I* 9EVITABLY HAS F\ND ITS SOLUTION 9 W> - & A TEMPOR>Y ESCAPE FROM ! F9AL CRISIS 9 ! RECON/RUCTION ( ! DE/ROY$ WORKS ( HUMANITY1 CREAT$ 9 C5TURIES4 ,RECON/RUCTION ( ! DE/ROY$1 !N CON/RUCTION ( CAPITALI/ PRODUCTION FACILITIES 9 VA/ >EAS1 & TODAY ! RACE = M>KETS3 ,?OSE >E ALL RAILS :I* ,/AL9 IS FOLL[+2 & ?IS TRA91 UND]TAK5 BY :OEV]1 KN[S ONLY TWO *ANG+ PO9TS3 L[ CO/S ( PRODUCTION OR W>4 ,WE WILL F9I% ! DEPICTION ( ?IS FUNDAM5TAL LAW ) ANO!R WORD+ AB\T CAPITALISM1 :I* ,M>X ADDS 9 ! FIFTE5? *APT] ( ! ?IRD VOLUME4 ,AS ALWAYS1 IT SIMULTANE\SLY /&S = ! PROGRAM ( COMMUNI/ SOCIETY4 0,?REE C>D9AL FACTS ( CAPITALI/ PRODUCTION3 #a7 ,CONC5TRATION ( MEANS ( PRODUCTION 9 FEW H&S1 :]EBY !Y CEASE TO APPE> AS ! PROP]TY ( ! IMM$IATE LABOR]S & TURN 9TO SOCIAL PRODUCTION CAPACITIES4 ,EV5 IF 9ITIALLY !Y >E ! PRIVATE PROP]TY ( CAPITALI/S4 ,!SE >E ! TRU/EES ( B\RGEOIS SOCIETY1 BUT !Y POCKET ALL ! PROCE$S ( ?IS TRU/EE%IP4 #b7 ,ORGANIZATION ( LABOR ITSELF 9TO SOCIAL LABOR3 ?R\< COOP]ATION1 DIVISION ( LABOR1 & ! UNIT+ ( LABOR ) ! NATURAL SCI5CES4 ,9 !SE TWO S5SES1 ! CAPITALI/ MODE ( PRODUCTION ABOLI%ES PRIVATE PROP]TY & PRIVATE LABOR1 EV5 ?\< 9 CONTRADICTORY =MS4 #c7 ,CREATION ( ! WORLD-M>KET40 ,AS USUAL ! 0?READ0 LEAD US :]E IT NE$$ TO LEAD US4 ,& ! READ] %\LD KN[ ?AT ! 0DAY0 /ILL HAS NOT DRAWN TO A CLOSE1 BUT ?AT IT IS ONLY NOON4 ,! 0MORN+0 MID & COMPLICAT$ AS A SYMPHONY BY ,WAGN]4 ,WILL ! CONCLUD+ 0AFT]NOON0 PLAY A LI8 ,H[EV]1 \R FAUN APPE>S 9 ! CO>SE FIGURE & ) ! ?REAT5+ GE/URE ( ! BLOOD R$ M>S4 ,?IRD ,DAY 7,AFT]NOON7 ,ON ! FIR/ TWO DAYS & DUR+ TODAY'S MORN+ WE DEALT ) ALL PASSAGES 9 ,/AL9'S SCRIPTURE :I* ALL[ TO F9D ?OSE LAWS BY :I* ! ,RUSSIAN ECONOMY CAN BE DIRECT$4 ,9 !ORETICAL REG>D1 WE HAVE FUNDAM5TALLY REFUT$ ?AT AN ECONOMY D5OT$ BY SU* LAWS C\LD BE DEF9$ AS SOCIALISM OR ITS L[] /AGE1 EQUALLY WE DISPUT$ ?AT ONE IS ABLE TO APPO9T TO ,M>X'S & ,5GELS' FUNDAM5TAL TEXTS = SU* A PURPOSE4 ,9 ?OSE SCRIPTURES1 WE F9D1 EV5 IF NOT 9 ! BANAL EASE :I* ONE GLAZES OV] A COMIC1 ! ECONOMIC *>ACT]I/ICS ( CAPITALISM1 AS WELL AS ?OSE ( SOCIALISM & ! PH5OM5A :I* ALL[ TO V]IFY ! ECONOMIC TRANSITION FROM ONE TO ! O!R MODE ( PRODUCTION4 ,9 EMPIRICAL REG>D1 WE C\LD DRAW A S]IES ( DEF9ITE CONCLUSIONS4 ,9 ! ,RUSSIAN DOME/IC M>KET1 ! LAW ( VALUE PREVAILS2 !RE=E3 ,! PRODUCTS HAVE COMMODITY *>ACT]2 ,A M>KET EXI/S2 ,! EX*ANGE TAKES PLACE1 ACCORD+ TO ! LAW ( VALUE1 BETWE5 EQUIVAL5TS2 & ! EQUIVAL5TS HAVE A MONET>Y EXPRESSION4 ,! GREAT MASS ( AGR>IAN BUS9ESSES WORKS SOLELY ) REG>D TO COMMODITY PRODUCTION & P>TLY 9 =M ( AN 9DIVIDUAL APPROPRIATION ( PRODUCTS ON ! SIDE ( P>CEL F>M]S 7:I* 9 ! O!R P>T ( HIS LABOR TIME FUNCTIONS AS COOP]ATIVE F>M]1 KOLKHOZNIKI71 A =M !RE=E1 :I* IS EV5 FUR!R AWAY FROM SOCIALISM1 9 SOME S5SE PRECAPITALI/IC & B>T] ECONOMIC4 ,! SMALL & M$IUM SIZ$ BUS9ESSES1 :I* MANUFACTURE FACTORY COMMODITIES1 ALSO WORK = SALES ON ! M>KET4 ,! L>GE 5T]PRISES F9ALLY >E [N$ BY ! /ATE1 :I* DOESN'T MEAN MU*3 !IR BOOKKEEP+ C>RIES A MONET>Y *>ACT] & BY PRICES - 9 :I* ! REIGN ( ! LAW ( VALUE IS ALREADY IMPLI$ - EXP5DITURES 7= RAW MAT]IALS1 WAGES7 & REV5UES 7SOLD PRODUCTS7 >E CONFRONT$ ) EA* O!R1 !RE=E AUDIT$ :E!R ! 5T]PRISES OP]ATE VIABLE1 MEAN+ :E!R !Y YIELD A PR(IT1 A SURPLUS4 ,! REASON+ AB\T ! SCOPE ( ! ,M>XI/ LAW ( ! RATE ( PR(IT & ITS FALL WAS GOOD = EXPOS+ ,/AL9'S HOLL[ ANTI!SIS3 ,BECAUSE ! PROLET>IAT WIELD$ P[]1 ! GIGANTIC APP>ATUS ( NATIONALIZ$ 9DU/RY W\LDN'T AIM = MAXIMUM PR(IT 7LIKE 9 ! CAPITALI/ C\NTRIES71 BUT IS CONC]N$ = ! MAXIMUM WELF>E ( ! WORK]S & ! PEOPLE4 ,T[>DS ! !SIS ACCORD+ TO :I* BETWE5 ! 9T]E/S ( ! WORK]S 9 ! /ATE 9DU/RY & ?OSE ( ! 0,SOVIET PEOPLE0 - ?IS MI%MA% ( 9DIVIDUAL- & COOP]ATIVE F>M]S1 HUCK/]S1 MANAG]S ( SMALL & MID-SIZ$ 9DU/RIAL FIRMS & SO ON - !RE W]5'T ANY FUNDAM5TAL ANTAGONISMS1 NOT ON ! LEVEL ( DAILY DEM&S EI!R1 WE HAVE ! BIGGE/ RES]VATIONS4 ,BUT AP>T FROM ?AT1 WE HAVE GOT ! PRO( PRECISELY \T ( ! 0LAW ( ! PLANN$ DEVELOPM5T ( ! NATIONAL ECONOMY 9 GEOMETRICAL PROGRESSION0 CONFIRM$ BY ,/AL91 ?AT ! CAPITALI/ LAW ( ! FALL 9 ! RATE ( PR(IT IS 9 EFFECT4 ,IF A FIVE YE> PLAN PURPORTS AN 9CREASE 9 PRODUCTION BY #b.01 MEAN+ FROM #a TO #a#b1 & ! FOLL[+ PLAN AGA9 PURPORTS A GR[? ( #b.01 !N ?IS MEANS ?AT PRODUCTION %\LD NOT GR[ FROM #ab TO #a#d1 BUT FROM #ab TO #add 7#b.0 9CREASE ( ! NEW CYCLE1 :I* N[ />TS ) #a#b74 ,HE :O IS A BIT FAMILI> ) NUMB]S KN[S ?AT ! DIFF]5CE AT ! />T SEEMS M>G9AL1 LAT] H[EV] ASSUMES GIGANTIC MAGNITUDES4 ,DO Y\ REMEMB] ! /ORY ( ! CREATOR ( *ESS1 :O WANT$ TO MAKE A PRES5T TO ! EMP]OR ( ,*9A8 ,HE ASK$ = ONE CORN ON ! FIR/ SQU>E1 TWO ON ! SECOND1 F\R ON ! ?IRD444 ALL CORN *AMB]S ( ! HEAV5LY EMPIRE W\LDN'T HAVE SUFFIC$ TO FILL ! #fd SQU>ES4 ,N[1 HIS LAW IS DE FACTO NO?+ ELSE ?AN ! CATEGORICAL IMP]ATIVE3 PRODUCE EV]MORE6 ,?IS IMP]ATIVE BELONGS SOLELY TO CAPITALISM & ! FOLL[+ *A9 ( CAUSES IS AT ITS F\NDATION3 ,9CREASE ( LABOR PRODUCTIVITY - 9CREASE ( CON/ANT CAPITAL 9 RELATION TO V>IABLE CAPITAL1 ?US ! ORGANIC COMPOSITION - FALL 9 ! RATE ( PR(IT - NECESSITY TO COMP5SATE ! FALL ) ! RAMPANT 9CREASE ( CAPITAL 9VE/M5TS & PRODUCTION ( COMMODITIES4 ,IF WE HAD REALLY />T$ TO BUILD UP ! SOCIALI/ ECONOMY 9 A RUDIM5T>Y WAY1 WE W\LD HAVE NOTIC$ ?AT ! ECONOMIC IMP]ATIVE HAD *ANG$1 & ?AT IT W\LD HAVE TURN$ \T TO BE \RS3 S9CE ! P[] ( HUMAN LABOR IS MULTIPLI$ BY TE*NICAL A*IEVEM5TS3 ) /EADY PRODUCTION1 WORK LESS6 ,& :]E ! CONDITIONS ( A REVOLUTION>Y P[] ( ! PROLET>IAT REALLY DO EXI/1 ?AT IS TO SAY1 9 ?OSE C\NTRIES :I* >E ALREADY OV]-EQUIPP$ ) FACILITIES3 PRODUCE LESS & WORK EV5 LESS6 ,! M]E FACT ?AT ,RUSSIA HAS TO ISSUE ! SLOGAN ( 09CREAS+ PRODUCT MASS0 CONFIRMS \R !SIS4 ,IT IS F9ALLY CONFIRM$ BY ! FACT ?AT A SIGNIFICANT PROPORTION ( ! PRODUCTS ( MAJOR /ATE-[N$ 9DU/RY >E SOLD ON =EIGN M>KETS1 & H]E ,/AL9 OP5LY /ATES ?AT ! RELATION%IP IS NOT ONLY = ACC\NT+ PURPOSES1 BUT BY ! V]Y NATURE ( ?+S A COMMODITY RELATION4 ,BASICALLY1 ?IS 9CLUDES ! CONFESSION ?AT 0BUILD+ SOCIALISM 9 ONE C\NTRY0 IS NOT POSSIBLE1 EV5 IF IT W]E ONLY BECAUSE ( WORLDWIDE COMPETITION 7:I* IS ALWAYS PREP>$ TO %OOT ) CANNONS & ATOMIC BOMBS 9/EAD ( ! >TILL]Y ( L[ PRICES74 ,ONLY 9 ! ABSURD HYPO!SIS ?AT ! 0SOCIALI/ C\NTRY0 C\LD CLOSE ITSELF (F BEH9D A REAL IRON CURTA9 W\LD IT BE POSSIBLE = ! C\NTRY TO TAKE ! FIR/ /EPS 9 ONE DIRECTION 7PLANN+ 0BY SOCIETY 9 ! 9T]E/ ( SOCIETY071 :I*1 ?ANKS TO ! LABOR PRODUCTIVITY A*IEV$ BY TE*NICAL A*IEVEM5TS1 W\LD LEAD TO A R$UCTION 9 LABOR EF=TS & EXPLOITATION ( ! WORK]4 ,& ONLY )9 SU* A HYPO!SIS C\LD ! PLAN BE1 AFT] ! 9SANE GEOMETRIC CURVE ( CAPITALI/ MADNESS HAS BE5 AB&ON$3 ,LET US DET]M9E A C]TA9 /&>D ( CONSUMPTION = ALL RESID5TS1 SET BY ! PLAN2 ONCE WE HAVE REA*$ ?AT LEVEL1 WE WILL /OP PRODUCTION & RESI/ ! CRIM9AL TEMPTATION TO PU% IT FUR!R1 JU/ TO SEE :]E WE GET RID ( IT AGA91 :O WE CAN =CE IT ON4 ,H[EV]1 ! ,KREML9'S FULL ATT5TION1 BO? IDEOLOGICALLY & PRACTICALLY1 IS FOCUS$ ON ! WORLD M>KET4 ,COMPETITION & ,MONOPOLY ,A SUP]FICIAL APPROA* PLACES ! ,M>XI/ !ORIES ( MOD]N COLONIALISM & IMP]IALISM NEXT TO ! ,M>XI/ DESCRIPTION ( CAPITALISM ( FREE COMPETITION 7:I* SUPPOS$LY UNFOLD$ UNTIL AB\T #a#h#h71 AS IF !SE W]E DIFF]5T TREATISES OR AT BE/ SUPPLEM5TS4 ,9 V>I\S SPEE*ES WE HAVE 9SI/$ ?AT ! ALLEG$LY SOB] DESCRIPTION ( A 0LIB]AL0 & 0PEACEFUL0 CAPITALISM 9 ,M>X1 :I* BY ! WAY NEV] EXI/$1 IS 9 REALITY NO?+ MORE ?AN A GIGANTIC 0POLEMICAL DEMON/RATION FROM A P>TY & CLASS PO9T ( VIEW10 ON ! BASIS ( :I* - IF ONE RECOGNIZES = A MOM5T ?AT CAPITALISM FUNCTIONS 9 ACCORDANCE ) ! UNRE/RICT$ DYNAMICS ( FREE EX*ANGE BETWE5 ! BE>]S ( EQUIVAL5T VALUES 7:I* DOESN'T EXPRESS ANY?+ ELSE ?AN ! FAM\S LAW ( VALUE7 - ! *>ACT] ( CAPITALISM CAN BE CONCEIV$3 ,NAMELY1 TO BE A SOCIETAL CLASS MONOPOLY :I*1 FROM ! FIR/ EPISODES ( PRIMITIVE ACCUMULATION UP TO TODAY'S ROBB]Y1 9CESSANTLY /RIVES TO HEI/ ! G5]AT$ 0BALANCES0 UND] ! MASK ( ! CONTRACTUALLY SECUR$1 FREE & EQUAL EX*ANGE4 ,/>T+ FROM ! EX*ANGE ( EQUAL COMMODITY VALUES1 ,M>X %[S ! CREATION ( SURPLUS VALUE1 :I* IS 9VE/$1 LEAD+ TO ! ACCUMULATION ( NEW1 9CREAS+LY CONC5TRAT$ CAPITAL2 HE FUR!R %[S ?AT ! ONLY WAY 7COMPATIBLE ) ! CONT9UATION ( CAPITALI/ PRODUCTION7 TO RESOLVE ! CONTRADICTION BETWE5 ! ACCUMULATION ( WEAL? ON ONE POLE & ! ACCUMULATION ( MIS]Y ON ! OPPOSITE POLE & TO ESCAPE ! RESULT+ LAW ( ! FALL 9 ! RATE ( PR(IT IS TO PRODUCE MORE & MORE BEYOND :AT IS NECESS>Y = CONSUMPTION2 BY PO9T+ ?IS \T1 IT BECOMES CLE> ?AT FROM ! \TSET ! CLA% BETWE5 ! CAPITALI/ C\NTRIES IS LOOM+2 EV]YONE FEELS ! IRRESI/IBLE URGE TO SELL !IR [N COMMODITIES ON ! T]RITORY ( ! O!R & TO AV]T !IR [N CRISIS BY /IRR+ IT UP AT ! RIVAL4 ,(FICIAL ECONOMICS TRI$ 9 VA9 TO PROVE ! POSSIBILITY ( A*IEV+ A /ABLE EQUILIBRIUM ON ! WORLD M>KET ) ! RULES & ME*ANISMS ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION1 EV5 CLAIM+ ?AT CRISES W\LD BE A ?+ ( ! PA/ ONCE ! 0CIVILIZ$0 ORGANIZATION ( CAPITALISM HAD SPREAD EV]Y:]E4 ,?AT IS :Y ,M>X HAD TO 5GAGE 9 AN AB/RACT DISCUSSION ( ! LAWS ( A S+LE1 NON-EXPORT+1 FICTITI\S C\NTRY ( FULLY DEVELOP$ CAPITALISM - & HE PROV$ ?AT ?IS C\NTRY WILL 0EXPLODE40 ,IT IS ALL ! MORE OBVI\S ?AT1 :]E ! ABOVE-M5TION$ COMMODITY RELATIONS >ISE BETWE5 TWO CLOS$ ECONOMIC ZONES1 !Y >E NOT AN ELEM5T ( PACIFICATION BUT ONE ( %OCK & ! !SIS ( ! 0CIVILIZ$ WORLD ORGANIZATION0 BECOMES ALL ! MORE OBSOLETE4 ,ONLY 9 ONE CASE W\LD WE BE 9 S]I\S !ORETICAL EMB>RASSM5T3 IF ! FIR/ #e YE>S ( ?IS C5TURY HAD CONT9U$ TO BE WRAPP$ 9 ECONOMIC & POLITICAL COTTON WOOL1 ) S]I\S FREE TRADE1 NEUTRALITY & DIS>MAM5T AGREEM5TS4 ,S9CE ! WORLD ON ! CONTR>Y HAS BECOME A HUNDR$ TIMES MORE CAPITALI/1 IT HAS BE5 %AK5 A HUNDR$ TIMES MORE BY E>?QUAKES 9 EV]Y RESPECT4 ,TO %[ :O DOESN'T TWI/ ! WORDS H]E1 WE QUOTE A FOOTNOTE FROM ! #b#d? *APT] ( ,CAPITAL VOLUME ,I3 0,WE H]E TAKE NO ACC\NT ( EXPORT TRADE1 BY MEANS ( :I* A NATION CAN *ANGE >TICLES ( LUXURY EI!R 9TO MEANS ( PRODUCTION OR MEANS ( SUBSI/5CE1 & VICE V]SA4 ,9 ORD] TO EXAM9E ! OBJECT ( \R 9VE/IGATION 9 ITS 9TEGRITY1 FREE FROM ALL DI/URB+ SUBSIDI>Y CIRCUM/ANCES1 WE MU/ TREAT ! :OLE WORLD AS ONE NATION1 & ASSUME ?AT CAPITALI/ PRODUCTION IS EV]Y:]E E/ABLI%$ & HAS POSSESS$ ITSELF ( EV]Y BRAN* ( 9DU/RY40 ,! WORK ( ,M>X - 9 :I*1 AS WE ALWAYS EMPHASIZE1 !ORY & PROGRAM =M AN 9SEP>ABLE :OLE - WAS CONCEIV$ FROM ! \TSET 9 SU* A WAY ?AT IT CONCLUDES ) ! PHASE 9 :I* ! CONTRADICTIONS ( ! FIR/ CAPITALI/ C5T]S >E REPRODUC$ ON AN 9T]NATIONAL LEVEL4 ,! DEMON/RATION ?AT A 0SOCIAL P>TN]%IP0 BETWE5 ! SOCIAL CLASSES ( A C\NTRY IS IMPOSSIBLE AS A DEF9ITIVE SOLUTION & REGRESSIVE AS A TEMPOR>Y SOLUTION1 ATT5DS ! 9 ALL PO9TS ANALOG\S DEMON/RATION ( ! ILLUSORY *>ACT] ( A PEACE TREATY BETWE5 /ATES4 ,IT HAS BE5 RECALL$ SEV]AL TIMES ?AT 9 ! PREFACE TO HIS #ahei BOOK 0,A ,CONTRIBUTION TO ! ,CRITIQUE ( ,POLITICAL ,ECONOMY10 ,M>X \TL9$ ! ORD] ( ! HEAD+S AS FOLL[S3 0CAPITAL1 L&$ PROP]TY1 WAGE-LABOR2 ! ,/ATE1 =EIGN TRADE1 WORLD M>KET4 ,! ECONOMIC CONDITIONS ( EXI/5CE ( ! ?REE GREAT CLASSES 9TO :I* MOD]N B\RGEOIS SOCIETY IS DIVID$ >E ANALYZ$ UND] ! FIR/ ?REE HEAD+S20 & HE ADDS3 0! 9T]CONNECTION ( ! O!R ?REE HEAD+S IS SELF-EVID5T40 ,:5 ,M>X BEGAN WRIT+ D[N 0,CAPITAL10 :OSE FIR/ P>T 9TEGRATES ! SUBJECT ( 0,A ,CONTRIBUTION TO ! ,CRITIQUE ( ,POLITICAL ,ECONOMY10 ! PLAN WAS ON ! ONE H& DEEP5$ & ON ! O!R H& IT SEEM$ TO BE RE/RICT$4 ,9 ! PREFACE TO ! FIR/ VOLUME 70,! ,PROCESS ( ,PRODUCTION ( ,CAPITAL07 ,M>X ANN\NC$ ?AT ! ,I,I4 VOLUME DEALS ) ! 0PROCESS ( CIRCULATION0 7SIMPLE & EXT5D$ REPRODUCTION ( ! CAPITAL 9VE/$ 9 PRODUCTION7 & ! ,I,I,I4 W\LD DEAL ) 0! =MS ASSUM$ BY CAPITAL 9 ! C\RSE ( ITS DEVELOPM5T40 ,AP>T FROM BOOK ,I,V AB\T ! HI/ORY ( ! !ORIES ( VALUE1 :OSE MAT]IALS HAVE BE5 AVAILABLE S9CE ! 0,CRITIQUE10 VOLUME ,I,I,I 9DE$ DEALS ) ! REPRES5TATION ( ! OV]ALL PROCESS1 EXAM9ES ! DI/RIBUTION ( SURPLUS VALUE BETWE5 9DU/RIALI/S1 L&[N]S & BANK]S1 & CONCLUDES ) ! 0DISCONT9U$0 *APT] ON 0,! CLASSES40 ,! F9AL V]SION WAS OBVI\SLY 9T5D$ TO DEVELOP ! QUE/ION ( ! /ATE & ! 9T]NATIONAL M>KET1 = :I* ! PREP>ATORY WORK HAD BE5 DONE BE=E & AFT] ,CAPITAL 9 O!R L&M>K TEXTS ( ,M>XISM4 ,M>KETS & ,EMPIRES ,ALREADY 9 ! 0,MANIFE/O0 & ! VOLUME ,I ( ,CAPITAL1 ! EM]G5CE ( ! OV]SEAS M>KET 9 ! WAKE ( ! GEOGRAPHIC DISCOV]IES ( ! #a#e? C5TURY IS HIY IMPORTANCE ( ! TRADE W>S BETWE5 ,PORTUGAL1 ,SPA91 ,HOLL&1 ,FRANCE & ,5GL& IS PO9T$ \T4 ,AT ! TIME ( ! POLEMICAL & CLASS-/RUGGL+ PORTRAYAL ( 0TYPICAL0 CAPITALISM1 ! ,5GLI% ,EMPIRE DOM9AT$ ! WORLD /AGE1 & SO ,M>X & ,5GELS PAID ! GREATE/ ATT5TION TO IT & ITS ECONOMY4 ,9 !ORY1 ?IS ECONOMY PRET5D$ TO BE LIB]ALISM2 9 REALITY1 IT WAS AN IMP]IALISM ?AT HAD HELD ! WORLD MONOPOLY AT LEA/ S9CE #a#h#e#e4 ,9 0,IMP]IALISM10 ,L59 REF]S 9 ?IS RESPECT TO LETT]S FROM ,5GELS & TO ! =EWORD ?AT HE #ahib PUT 9 FRONT ( ! NEW $ITION ( HIS /UDY 0,! ,SITUATION ( ! ,WORK+ ,CLASS 9 ,5GL&0 ( #a#h#d#d4 ,5GELS REFUS$ TO 0/RIKE \T ( ! TEXT ! MANY PROPHECIES1 AMONG O!RS ?AT ( AN IMM95T SOCIAL REVOLUTION 9 ,5GL&0 FROM ! TEXT BE>+ ! 0/AMP ( ! AU?OR'S Y\?40 ,MU* MORE IMPORTANT TO HIM SEEM$ TO HAVE =ESE5 ?AT ,5GL& W\LD LOSE ITS 9DU/RIAL WORLD MONOPOLY2 & HE WAS RIKET & COLONIAL MONOPOLY0 HAD ! EFFECT ( PUTT+ ! ,5GLI% PROLET>IAT TO SLEEP - ! WORLD'S FIR/ PROLET>IAT ) A PRON\NC$ CLASS *>ACT] - ! 5D ( ! ,BRITI% MONOPOLY SPREAD ! SE$S ( CLASS /RUGGLE & REVOLUTION ?R\<\T ! WORLD4 ,CLE>LY1 ?IS TAKES MORE TIME ?AN 9 ! 0FICTITI\S S+LE1 ?OR\Y SOLUTION IS ALREADY !ORETICALLY =ESE51 ! DET\RS & REASONS = ITS 0PO/PONEM5T0 ONLY CONFIRM ITS VALIDITY4 ,IT WILL COME4 ,LET'S GO BACK TO ! =EWORD BY ,5GELS 7:I* IS REPRODUC$ A LITTLE DIFF]5TLY 9 ,L59'S CASE73 0,! ,FREE ,TRADE !ORY WAS BAS$ UPON ONE ASSUMPTION3 ?AT ,5GL& WAS TO BE ! ONE GREAT MANUFACTUR+ C5T] ( AN AGRICULTURAL WORLD4 ,& ! ACTUAL FACT IS ?AT ?IS ASSUMPTION HAS TURN$ \T TO BE A PURE DELUSION4 ,! CONDITIONS ( MOD]N 9DU/RY1 /EAM-P[] & MA*9]Y1 CAN BE E/ABLI%$ :]EV] !RE IS FUEL1 ESPECIALLY COALS4 ,& O!R C\NTRIES BESIDES ,5GL&-,FRANCE1 ,BELGIUM1 ,G]MANY1 ,AM]ICA1 EV5 ,RUSSIA HAVE COALS4 ,& ! PEOPLE OV] !RE DID NOT SEE ! ADVANTAGE ( BE+ TURN$ 9TO ,IRI% PAUP] F>M]S M]ELY = ! GREAT] WEAL? & GLORY ( ,5GLI% CAPITALI/S4 ,!Y SET RESOLUTELY AB\T MANUFACTUR+1 NOT ONLY = !MSELVES1 BUT = ! RE/ ( ! WORLD2 & ! CONSEQU5CE IS ?AT ! MANUFACTUR+ MONOPOLY 5JOY$ BY ,5GL& = NE>LY A C5TURY IS IRRETRIEVABLY BROK5 UP40 ,A P>ADOX8 ,WE C\LD ONLY REFUTE ! COM$Y ( 0LIB]AL0 CAPITALISM BECAUSE ?IS WAS ! - = A LIMIT$ P]IOD - UNPREC$5T$ HI/ORICAL FALL ( A WORLD MONOPOLY4 0,LAISSEZ FAIRE1 LAISSEZ PASS]0.<#b#c.>1 BUT KEEP ! FLEET 7L>G] ?AN ALL ! O!RS PUT TOGE!R7 ON AL]T SO ?AT NONE ( ! ,NAPOLEONS ESCAPE FROM ! ,SA9T ,HEL5A'S4444 ,9 ! 0MORN+0 WE HAVE QUOT$ A PASSAGE FROM VOLUME ,I,I,I1 CONCLUD+ A NEW SYN!SIS ( CAPITALI/ *>ACT]I/ICS ) ! WORDS3 0,CREATION ( ! WORLD-M>KET40 ,IT WILL NOT DO US ANY H>M TO REPEAT ANO!R P[]FUL PASSAGE4 0,! REAL B>RI] ( CAPITALI/ PRODUCTION IS CAPITAL ITSELF4 ,IT IS ?AT CAPITAL & ITS SELF-EXPANSION APPE> AS ! />T+ & ! CLOS+ PO9T1 ! MOTIVE & ! PURPOSE ( PRODUCTION2 ?AT PRODUCTION IS ONLY PRODUCTION = CAPITAL & NOT VICE V]SA1 ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION >E NOT M]E MEANS = A CON/ANT EXPANSION ( ! LIV+ PROCESS ( ! SOCIETY ( PRODUC]S4 ,! LIMITS )9 :I* ! PRES]VATION & SELF-EXPANSION ( ! VALUE ( CAPITAL RE/+ ON ! EXPROPRIATION & PAUP]IZATION ( ! GREAT MASS ( PRODUC]S CAN ALONE MOVE - !SE LIMITS COME CONT9UALLY 9TO CONFLICT ) ! ME?ODS ( PRODUCTION EMPLOY$ BY CAPITAL = ITS PURPOSES1 :I* DRIVE T[>DS UNLIMIT$ EXT5SION ( PRODUCTION1 T[>DS PRODUCTION AS AN 5D 9 ITSELF1 T[>DS UNCONDITIONAL DEVELOPM5T ( ! SOCIAL PRODUCTIVITY ( LABOR4 ,! MEANS - UNCONDITIONAL DEVELOPM5T ( ! PRODUCTIVE =CES ( SOCIETY - COMES CONT9UALLY 9TO CONFLICT ) ! LIMIT$ PURPOSE1 ! SELF-EXPANSION ( ! EXI/+ CAPITAL4 ,! CAPITALI/ MODE ( PRODUCTION IS1 = ?IS REASON1 A HI/ORICAL MEANS ( DEVELOP+ ! MAT]IAL =CES ( PRODUCTION & CREAT+ AN APPROPRIATE WORLD-M>KET & IS1 AT ! SAME TIME1 A CONT9UAL CONFLICT BETWE5 ?IS ITS HI/ORICAL TASK & ITS [N CORRESPOND+ RELATIONS ( SOCIAL PRODUCTION40 ,ONCE AGA91 IT REMA9S TRUE3 ,RUSSIAN 0ECONOMIC POLICY0 HAS C]TA9LY DEVELOP$ ! MAT]IAL PRODUCTIVE =CES1 HAS 9DE$ EXP&$ ! WORLD M>KET1 BUT )9 ! CAPITALI/ =MS ( PRODUCTION4 ,IT DOES 9DE$ REPRES5T A USEFUL HI/ORICAL TOOL3 NO LESS ?AN ! 9DU/RIAL 9VASION AT ! EXP5SE ( ! />V+ ,SCOTS & ,IRI% OR ! ,WILD ,WE/ ,9DIANS1 BUT IT CANNOT LOOS5 ! REL5TLESS GRIP ( ! CONTRADICTIONS ( CAPITALISM1 :I* V]Y WELL POT5TIATES ! =CES ( SOCIETY1 BUT :I* = ?AT MU/ DEBILITATE & SUBJUGATE ! WORK]S' ASSOCIATION4 ,NO MATT] FROM :I* SIDE Y\ LOOK AT IT1 ! 5D PO9T IS ALWAYS ! WORLD M>KET - JU/ AS ) ,/AL94 ,IT HAS NEV] BE5 0UNI=M10 EXCEPT 9 AB/RACT T]MS1 AS 9 ?AT HYPO!TICAL C\NTRY ( ABSOLUTE & *EMICALLY PURE CAPITALISM1 :OSE UNREALIZABILITY WE HAVE MA!MATICALLY PROV54 ,%\LD IT EV] >ISE1 IT W\LD IMM$IATELY DIS9TEGRATE 9TO ITS 9DIVIDUAL P>TS1 SU* AS C]TA9 ATOMS & CRY/ALS ?AT ONLY EXI/ = A FRACTION ( A SECOND4 ,!RE=E1 :5 ! DREAM ( A UNIFI$ /]L+ M>KET HAD BE5 OV]1 ,L59 WAS ABLE TO GIVE A FITT+ DESCRIPTION ( ! COLONIAL & SEMI-COLONIAL DIVISION ( ! WORLD BETWE5 FIVE OR SIX IMP]IALI/ MON/] /ATES ON ! EVE ( ,WORLD ,W> ,I4 ,! W> WAS NOT FOLL[$ BY A SY/EM ( EQUILIBRIUM1 BUT BY A NEW & DIFF]5T DIVISION2 EV5 ,/AL9 ADMITS1 ?AT ,G]MANY 0HAV+ BROK5 \T ( BONDAGE & TAK5 ! PA? ( 9DEP5D5T DEVELOPM5T10 HAD REASON TO TURN ITS =CES AGA9/ ! IMP]IALI/ ,FRANCO-,5GLI%-,AM]ICAN BLOC DUR+ ! ,SECOND ,WORLD ,W>4 ,BUT H[ CAN ALL ?IS BE RECONCIL$ ) ! HYPOCRITICAL PROPAG&A ?AT = YE>S REPRES5T$ ! W> ( ?IS BLOC AS NON-IMP]IALI/1 EV5 0DEMOCRATIC08 ,H[ CAN ?IS BE RECONCIL$ ) ! HY/]ICAL %\T+ AB\T ! P>DON ( ! 0W> CRIM9AL0 ,KESSELR+.<#b#d.>8 ,WOE BETIDE COMRADES ,TOMOVI*1 ,DICKOVI* & ,H>RYVI* IF !Y D>E TO ASK SU* QUE/IONS6 ,SO1 NEW DIVISION ( ! WORLD1 & A NEW REASON TO WAGE W>4 ,BE=E COM+ TO ,/AL9'S JUDGM5T ( ! DIVISION RESULT+ AFT] ! ,SECOND ,WORLD ,W>1 WE CANNOT RESI/ ! TEMPTATION TO M5TION ANO!R PASSAGE FROM ,L59'S 0IMP]IALISM10 :I* WE D$ICATE 9 P>TICUL> TO ! ECONOMIC P>T ( ! 0DIALOGUE0 ( ! PREVI\S DAYS4 ,L59 MOCKS A ,G]MAN ECONOMI/ NAM$ ,LIEFMANN1 :O WROTE ! FOLL[+ SONG ( PRAISE = IMP]IALISM3 0,COMM]CE IS AN OCCUPATION HAV+ = ITS OBJECT ! COLLECTION1 /ORAGE & SUPPLY ( GOODS40 ,L59 GIVES HIM A BL[ ?AT HITS HIM ) MANY O!R ,LIEFMANNS3 0,FROM ?IS IT W\LD FOLL[ ?AT COMM]CE EXI/$ 9 ! TIME ( PRIMITIVE MAN1 :O KNEW NO?+ AB\T EX*ANGE1 & ?AT IT WILL EXI/ UND] SOCIALISM60 ,! EXCLAMATION M>K IS ( C\RSE FROM ,L594 ,MOSC[1 :]E WILL Y\ PUT IT8 ,LATITUDE & LONGITUDE DEGREES ,ACCORD+ TO ,/AL91 ! MO/ IMPORTANT ECONOMIC \TCOME ( ! ,SECOND ,WORLD ,W> IS NOT SO MU* TO HAVE KNOCK$ \T TWO MAJOR 9DU/RIALIZ$ C\NTRIES1 NAMELY ,G]MANY & ,JAPAN 7AL?\< DISREG>D+ ,ITALY71 9 SE>* ( SALES M>KETS1 BUT RA!R TO HAVE SPLIT ! WORLD M>KET 9TO TWO P>TS4 ,FIR/ HE USES ! EXPRESSION 0DIS9TEGRATION10 !N HE SPECIFIES 0?AT ! S+LE ALL-EMBRAC+ WORLD M>KET DIS9TEGRAT$1 SO ?AT N[ WE HAVE TWO P>ALLEL WORLD M>KETS1 ALSO CONFRONT+ ONE ANO!R40 ,IT IS CLE> :O !SE TWO CAMPS %\LD BE3 ON ! ONE H&1 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES1 ,5GL&1 ,FRANCE & ALL ! C\NTRIES ?AT FIR/ CAME UND] ! SPELL ( ! ,M>%ALL ,PLAN = ,EUROPEAN 0RECON/RUCTION10 !N ! ,NOR? ,ATLANTIC ,PACT = 0DEF5SE10 BETT] ! RE>MAM5T ( ,EUROPE & ! ,WE/2 ,ON ! O!R H&1 ,RUSSIA1 :I* TOGE!R ) ! 0PEOPLE'S DEMOCRATIC C\NTRIES0 & ,*9A1 :I* >E EXPOS$ TO A BLOCKADE1 =MS A NEW1 SEP>ATE M>KET4 ,GEOGRAPHICALLY1 ?IS IS CORRECT1 BUT ! WORD+ IS NOT V]Y =TUNATE 7SAVE = ! USUAL TRANSLATION ]RORS74 ,LET US ASSUME = A MOM5T ?AT1 ON ! EVE ( ! ,SECOND ,WORLD ,W>1 !RE W\LD HAVE BE5 A G5U9E1 UNI=M WORLD M>KET1 ! TRAD+ PLACES ( :I* W\LD HAVE BE5 ACCESSIBLE TO ALL PRODUCTS FROM ALL C\NTRIES1 !N IT W\LD NOT HAVE BE5 ABLE TO DIS9TEGRATE 9TO 0TWO WORLD M>KETS10 BUT ! WORLD M>KET W\LD HAVE CEAS$ TO EXI/ & W\LD HAVE BE5 REPLAC$ BY TWO 9T]NATIONAL M>KETS1 SEP>AT$ BY A RIGOR\S CURTA9 :I* W\LD NOT ALL[ COMMODITIES & PAYM5TS TO PASS ?R\< 7!ORETICALLY1 & ONLY ACCORD+ TO :AT ! CU/OMS AU?ORITIES >E AW>E (1 :I* IS V]Y LITTLE TODAY74 ,TWO SU* M>KETS >E N[ FAC+ EA* O!R1 BUT 9 P>ALLEL1 9DIRECTLY ADMITT+ ?AT ! DOME/IC ECONOMIES ( ! TWO MAJOR CAMPS 9TO :I* ?IS GLOBE IS DIVID$ >E 0P>ALLEL10 I4 E4 ( ! SAME HI/ORICAL TYPE2 ?IS IS CONSI/5T ) \R !ORETICAL TREATISE & CONTRADICTS ! !SIS ?AT ,/AL9'S WRIT+S >E 9T5D$ TO PUT 9TO CIRCULATION4 ,9 BO? CAMPS ! M>KET EXI/S1 ]GO ! COMMODITY SY/EM1 ]GO ! CAPITALI/ ECONOMY4 ,SO WE ALL[ ! EXPRESSION ( ! P>ALLEL M>KETS TO PASS ?R\<1 BUT :AT WE COMPLETELY REJECT IS ! DEF9ITION ACCORD+ TO :I* !RE IS A CAPITALI/ M>KET 9 ! ,WE/ & A SOCIALI/ ONE 9 ! ,EA/1 A CONTRADICTIO 9 ADJECTO.<#b#e.>4 ,WELL3 ,TWO 0HALF-WORLD0 M>KETS1 :OSE DIVID+ L9E1 BY ! WAY - AT LEA/ IF IT IS AB\T ! MORE DEVELOP$ P>T ( ! POPULAT$ WORLD - DOES NOT RUN ON A P>ALLEL CIRCLE OR LATITUDE1 BUT ON ! LONGITUDE ( ! DEFEAT$ ,B]L94 ,?IS L9E LEADS ,/AL9 TO A MO/ REM>KABLE CONCLUSION 7ESPECIALLY :5 COMP>$ TO ! FAIL$ HYPO!SIS ( ! S+LE WORLD M>KET1 :I* W\LD HAVE BE5 EI!R UND] ! CONTROL ( A CONF$]ATION ( ALL W9N+ /ATES OR UND] ! SOLE CONTROL ( ! ,WE/]N BLOC L$ BY ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES71 NAMELY1 ?AT ! SPH]E ( EXPLOITATION ( ! WORLD'S RES\RCES BY ! MAJOR CAPITALI/ C\NTRIES 7,U4,S4,A41 ,BRITA91 ,FRANCE7 WILL NOT EXP&1 BUT CONTRACT2 ?AT !IR OPPORTUNITIES = SALE 9 ! WORLD M>KET0 7MEANS3 ON ! =EIGN M>KET7 0WILL DET]IORATE1 & ?AT !IR 9DU/RIES WILL BE OP]AT+ MORE & MORE BEL[ CAPACITY4 ,?AT1 9 FACT1 IS :AT IS MEANT BY ! DEEP5+ ( ! G5]AL CRISIS ( ! WORLD CAPITALI/ SY/EM 9 CONNECTION ) ! DIS9TEGRATION ( ! WORLD M>KET40 ,?IS HAS1 ( C\RSE1 /IRR$ UP SOME DU/2 :ILE V>I\S PUPPETS HAVE BE5 S5T (F1 ( ! BAT* ( AN ,EHR5BURG OR A ,N5NI.<#b#f.> TO FIALLEL ECONOMIC >EAS1 ,MOSC[ IS S5D+ ! MESSAGE ?AT IT IS /ILL EXPECT+ ! ,WE/ TO SUFFOCATE UND] A M\NTA9 ( UNSALABLE COMMODITIES 7:I* C\LD NOT EV5 BE GIV5 AWAY BECAUSE !N ! DEBTS W\LD PILE UP EV5 MORE7 & BL[ UP AS A RESULT ( ?IS CRISIS4 ,NOT EV5 9 ! UNBRIDL$ >MS RACE OR 9 ! ,KOREAN W> & O!R IMP]IALI/ RAIDS1 ,MOSC[ SEES AN OPPORTUNITY TO SAVE ! ,WE/4 ,IF ?IS HAS %AK5 ! B\RGEOISIE1 IT IS NOT 5\< TO GET US ,M>XI/S GO+4 ,WE HAVE TO ASK :AT WILL DET]M9E SU* A PROCESS 9 ! O!R 0P>ALLEL0 CAMP - ON ! BASIS ( ! (FICIAL TEXT WE HAVE ALREADY %[N ?AT IT IS SUBJECT TO ! SAME CON/RA9TS3 PRODUCE MORE & SELL MORE PRODUCTS TO ! \TSIDE WORLD4 ,& !N1 AS ALWAYS1 WE MU/ DRAW ! DECISIVE CONCLUSIONS FROM ! RISE ( ?IS HI/ORICAL MOVEM5T .<( ,/AL9ISM.> & ! CONTRADICTION ?AT WE >E WITNESS+ TODAY3 ,ON ! ONE H&1 ! PO/HUM\S ATTEMPT TO 0REHABILITATE0 ,M>X_/,L59'S REVOLUTION>Y VISION ( ! FUTURE - ACCUMULATION1 OV]PRODUCTION1 CRISIS1 W>1 REVOLUTION2 ON ! O!R H&1 9 ! C\RSE ( A LONG P]IOD ( DEVELOPM5T1 TO HAVE E/ABLI%$ VIRTUALLY IRREV]SIBLE HI/ORICAL & POLITICAL POSITIONS ?AT >E /ILL P]SI/5TLY DEF5D$ BY ! 0COMMUNI/0 P>TIES OP]AT+ 9 ! ,WE/ 7:I* WILL SOON BE PLAGU$ BY ! CRISIS7 & DIAMETRICALLY CONTRADICT ANY UNFOLD+ ( CLASS ANTAGONISM & ! REVOLUTION>Y PREP>ATION ( ! MASSES4 ,CLASSES & ,/ATES ,BE=E ! ,FIR/ ,WORLD ,W>1 TWO P]SPECTIVES COLLIDE4 ,! 9EVITABLE DISPUTE OV] ! M>KETS WILL LEAD TO W>2 REG>DLESS ( :O W9S FROM ! W>1 IMP]IALI/ T5SIONS WILL P]SI/ UNTIL ! PROLET>IAN REVOLUTION OR UNTIL A NEW GLOBAL CONFLICT3 ?AT IS ,L59'S P]SPECTIVE4 ,! OPPOSITE IS ! TRAITOR ( ! WORK+ CLASS & ! ,9T]NATIONAL3 AFT] ! SUPPRESSION ( ! 0AGGRESSOR0 7,G]MANY71 ! WORLD WILL AGA9 BE CIVILIZ$1 PEACEFUL & OP5 TO 0SOCIAL PROGRESS40 ,DIFF]5T P]SPECTIVES CORRESPOND TO DIFF]5T SOLUTIONS3 ! TRAITORS CALL = NATIONAL ,BURGFRI$51 ,L59 = REVOLUTION>Y DEFEATISM )9 EA* NATION4 ,! W> WAS PO/PON$ UNTIL #a#i#a#d1 BECAUSE ! WORLD M>KET WAS /ILL 9 ITS 0=MATION PHASE0 9 ! ,M>XI/ S5SE4 ,AS WE HAVE %[N ) REG>D TO CAPITALI/ COMMODITY PRODUCTION1 ! ,M>XI/ BASIC CONCEPT ( 0CREATION ( ! WORLD M>KET0 IS BAS$ ON ! LIMIT$ 0SPH]ES ( LIFE & SPH]ES ( ACTION0 *>ACT]IZ+ PRE-CAPITALISM1 9 :I* A LOCAL1 SELF-SUFFICI5T ECONOMY IS US$ TO PRODUCE & CONSUME 7AS 9 ! >I/OCRATIC PR9CIPALITIES & ,ASIAN FEUDAL /ATES7 IS DISSOLV$ 9 9 ! S+LE ECONOMIC MAGMA ( COMMODITY TRADE & SALES4 ,AS LONG AS !SE 0OIL /A9S0 ( ! AUT>*IC ECONOMIES 0M]GE0 ) ! UNIV]SAL SOLV5T ( CAPITALISM BO? 9T]NALLY & EXT]NALLY1 ! B\RGEOIS BUBBLE ( PRODUCTION CAN SU/A9 ! TEMPO ( ITS 0GEOMETRIC0 SWELL+ )\T BUR/+4 ,H[EV] ?IS IS NOT YET ! REASON :Y !SE ISL&S WILL 5T] 9TO A GLOBAL & UNIFI$ M>KET ?AT IS FREE ( B>RI]S3 ,PROTECTIONISM IS AN ANCI5T AFFAIR = ! NATIONAL T]RITORIES1 & = ! =EIGN TRADE C5T]S DISCOV]$ BY SEAF>]S IT APPLIES ?AT ! V>I\S NATIONS >E TRY+ TO PLACE !M UND] !IR MONOPOLY - BE IT BY MEANS ( CONCESSIONS FROM ! COLORFUL RUL]S & TRIBAL PR9CES2 BE IT ?R\< TRAD+ COMPANIES1 SU* AS ?OSE ( ! ,DUT*1 ,PORTUGUESE & ,5GLI%2 OR BE IT UND] ! PROTECTION ( ! W> FLEET &1 9 ! BEG9N+1 EV5 ! PIRATE %IPS ( ROAM+ 0M>9E P>TISANS40 ,9 ANY CASE1 ACCORD+ TO ,L591 WE >E NOT ONLY FAC+ AN ALMO/ WORLDWIDE SATURATION1 BUT ! ONES :O HAVE >RIV$ MO/ REC5TLY >E 9 A CRISIS ON ! SALES M>KETS2 H5CE ! W>4 ,SECOND ,WORLD ,W>4 ,ACCORD+ TO ,/AL91 ,G]MANY'S REAPPE>ANCE AS A L>GE 9DU/RIALIZ$ C\NTRY WAS AT ! 9/IGATION ( ! ,WE/]N P[]S1 :O W]E ONLY TOO HAPPY TO RE>M ! /RONE PRIM>ILY TO BE SE5 9 ! FACT ?AT ! ,G]MAN T]RITORY WAS NOT DEVA/AT$ DUR+ ! W> & WAS NOT OCCUPI$ BY MILIT>Y =CES AFT] ! CEASEFIRE4 ,9 ! SAME BREA?1 ,/AL9 ADMITS ?AT ! IMP]IALI/ & ECONOMIC CAUSES1 & NOT ! 0POLITICAL0 & 0IDEOLOGICAL0 ONES1 W]E DECISIVE = ! \TBREAK ( ! ,SECOND ,WORLD ,W>1 ESPECIALLY S9CE ,G]MANY HAD RU%$ FIR/ TO ! ,WE/ & NOT TO ,RUSSIA4 ,?US IT REMA9S TRUE ?AT ! W> ( #a#i#c#i-#d#e WAS AN IMP]IALI/ W>4 ,CONSEQU5TLY1 !RE W]E AGA9 ! TWO P]SPECTIVES3 EI!R NEW W>S 7IRRESPECTIVE ( :O W\LD W97 OR REVOLUTION 7PROVID$ ?AT ! W> W\LD NOT BE RESPOND$ TO ) NATIONAL 0SOCIAL P>TN]%IP0 BUT ) CLASS /RUGGLE7 &1 9 CONTRA/1 ! B\RGEOIS P]SPECTIVE1 ID5TICAL TO ?AT ( ! ,FIR/ ,WORLD ,W>3 ,EV]Y?+ DEP5DS ON ! REPRESSION ( ! CRIM9AL ,G]MANY2 IF ?IS SUCCE$S1 ! WAY IS CLE> = PEACE1 G5]AL DIS>MAM5T1 FRE$OM & PROSP]ITY ( ! PEOPLES4 ,/AL9 IS N[ TAK+ UP ! FIR/ ,L59I/ P]SPECTIVE1 & PUTS ! IMP]IALI/ CAUSE ( W> & ! /RUGGLE = M>KETS 9 ! =EGR\ND2 BUT IT IS TOO LATE = SOMEONE :O YE/]DAY ?REW ! FULL POT5TIAL ( ! 9T]NATIONAL MOVEM5T ONTO ! O!R P]SPECTIVE3 ! FI = IDEALS08 ,P]HAPS TO HAVE A POLITICALLY EASY GAME 9 ! NEXT W> BY PRES5T+ IT AS A BATTLE BETWE5 ! CAPITALI/ IDEAL ( ! ,WE/ & ! SOCIALI/ IDEAL ( ! ,EA/8 ,TO %OOT !MSELVES 9TO ! POLITICIANS' /UPID COMPETITION1 9 :I* EA* CAMP 9SI/S ON SMO!R+ ! O!R UND] ! T]RIBLE ACCUSATION ( 0FASCISM08 ,N[1 ! 9T]E/+ ?+ AB\T ,JOSEF ,/AL9'S TEXT IS ?AT HE REPLIES TO ?IS ) 0NO40 ,COMPLETELY UNIMPRESS$ BY HIS HI/ORICAL RESPONSIBILITY TO HAVE DE/ROY$ ,L59'S !ORY ON ! 9EVITABILITY ( W>S BETWE5 ! CAPITALI/ C\NTRIES & ON PROLET>IAN REVOLUTION AS ! ONLY WAY \T ( ,WORLD ,W> ,I,I1 & EQUALLY S]5E 9 ! FACE ( ! EV5 MORE S]I\S RESPONSIBILITY TO HAVE BROK5 ) ! ONLY POLITICAL ORI5TATION CORRESPOND+ TO ,L59'S !ORY BY ORD]+ ! ,COMMUNI/S1 FIR/ 9 ,G]MANY & !N 9 ,FRANCE1 ,5GL& & ,AM]ICA1 TO MAKE 0,BURGFRI$50 ) !IR [N /ATE & B\RGEOIS GOV]NM5T1 ! HEAD ( TODAY'S ,RUSSIA REPRIM&S ?OSE COMRADES :O BELIEVE 9 ! NECESSITY ( AN >M$ CLA% BETWE5 ! 0SOCIALI/0 & ! 0CAPITALI/0 WORLD OR DEMIMONDE4 ,BUT 9/EAD ( EVAD+ ! PROPHECY ( A W> BETWE5 CAPITALISM & SOCIALISM ) ! WORN-\T IDEOLOGY ( PACIFISM1 COMPETITION & ! COEXI/5CE ( ! TWO WORLDS1 HE SAYS ?AT IT IS ONLY 0!ORETICALLY0 CORRECT1 ?AT 0! CONTRADICTIONS BETWE5 CAPITALISM & SOCIALISM >E /RONG]0 N[ & 9 ! FUTURE 0?AN ! CONTRADICTIONS AMONG ! CAPITALI/ C\NTRIES40 ,TRUE ,M>XI/S MU/ TAKE S]I\SLY ALL POSSIBLE PR$ICTIONS AB\T ! CONTRADICTIONS )9 ! ,ATLANTIC GR\P ( /ATES & ! RESURG5CE ( AUTONOM\S & /RONG CAPITALISMS 9 DEFEAT$ C\NTRIES SU* AS ,G]MANY & ,JAPAN4 ,BUT ,/AL9'S CONCLUSION ) REG>D TO ! NEXT CONFLICT IS TO BE TREAT$ ) CAUTION1 S9CE HE 9VOKES ! SITUATION ON ! EVE ( ! ,SECOND ,WORLD ,W> BY ANALOGY3 0,CONSEQU5TLY1 ! /RUGGLE ( ! CAPITALI/ C\NTRIES = M>KETS & !IR DESIRE TO CRU% !IR COMPETITORS PROV$ 9 PRACTICE TO BE /RONG] ?AN ! CONTRADICTIONS BETWE5 ! CAPITALI/ CAMP & ! SOCIALI/ CAMP40 ,:AT SOCIALI/ CAMP8 ,IF1 AS WE HAVE %[N 9 Y\R [N WORDS1 Y\R 0SOCIALI/0 LABEL$ CAMP PRODUCES EXPORT COMMODITIES AT ! TO BE MAXIMALLY 9CREAS$ SPE$1 IS IT NOT ! SAME 0/RUGGLE = M>KETS0 & 0DESIRE TO CRU% COMPETITORS0 7OR NOT TO BE CRU%$1 :I* AM\NTS TO ! SAME ?+78 ,WILL Y\ NOT & WILL Y\ NOT HAVE TO JO9 ! W>1 AS PRODUC]S ( COMMODITIES1 :I* 9 ! ,M>XI/ LANGUAGE MEANS3 AS CAPITALI/S8 ,! ONLY DIFF]5CE BETWE5 Y\ ,RUSSIANS & ! O!RS IS ?AT ! FULLY DEVELOP$ 9DU/RIALIZ$ C\NTRIES HAVE LONG S9CE LEFT BEH9D ! ALT]NATIVE ( 09N] COLONIZATION0 ( SURVIV+ PRE-COMMODITY PRODUC+ ISL&S :ILE Y\ >E /ILL GO+ ?R\< ?IS PROCESS4 ,! CONSEQU5CE ( ?IS CAN ONLY BE ONE ?+3 ! WE/]N /ATES WILL SQUEEZE Y\ \T ON ! GR\ND ( M>KET COMPETITION LIKE A LEMON 7DON'T =GET1 Y\ HAVE ACCEPT$ ! MOVEM5T ( COMMODITIES & MONEY1 & AS LONG AS Y\ >E AT ! LEVEL ( COMPETITION1 Y\ ALSO CAN ONLY TAKE ! PA? ( L[ CO/S1 MEAG] WAGES & A MAD RU% TO WORK = ! ,RUSSIAN PROLET>IAT72 BECAUSE IT WILL 9EVITABLY COME TO W> & ! O!RS WILL HAVE BETT] 0>MAM5T10 !Y WILL BEAT Y\ MILIT>ILY AFT] !Y HAVE DONE AWAY ) Y\ ECONOMICALLY4 ,SO H[ CAN WE PROCE$ 9 ORD] TO PREV5T AN ,AM]ICAN VICTORY1 :I* IS ALSO ! GREATE/ ( ALL EVILS = US8 ,/AL9'S =MULA IS QUITE CLEV] - BUT ABOVE ALL1 IT IS BE/ SUIT$ TO KEEP ! REVOLUTION>Y PROLET>IAT 9 /UNN$ CONDITION & DO+ ! GREATE/ S]VICE TO ,ATLANTIC IMP]IALISM4 ,HE AVOIDS AT ALL CO/S DECL>+ ! FAM\S 0HOLY W>10 :I* W\LD PUT HIM 9 A BAD LI 7A RETURN ?AT IS HI/ORICALLY IMPOSSIBLE ANYWAYS74 ,! ,/AL9I/ LANGUAGE IS RA!R DUBI\S3 AS ,L59 SAID1 ! W> IS F\E WE GONNA DO8 ,DO WE CALL1 AS HE DID1 ! WORK]S ( ALL C\NTRIES ON BO? FRONTS TO ! CLASS W>1 TO TURN ! GUNS >\ND8 ,NEV] AGA94 ,WE'LL REPEAT ! SAME ELEGANT MANEUV] WE DID 9 ,WORLD ,W> ,I,I4 ,WE >E JO9+ ) ONE ( ! TWO COALITIONS1 = EXAMPLE ,FRANCE & ,5GL& AGA9/ ! ,U,S,A4 ,9 ?IS WAY1 WE >E BREAK+ ! FRONT L9E & ! DAY WILL COME :5 WE WILL TAKE ON ! 0LA/ ,MOHAWK0 NO MATT] :E!R IT IS A =M] ALLY OR NOT4 ,SU* PILLS >E ADM9I/]$ TO ! LA/ GULLIBLE PROLET>IANS 9 D>K BACK ROOMS1 AS LONG AS !Y HAVE NOT YET BE5 CONV]T$ TO CON=MISM BY EV5 WORSE MEANS4 ,W> OR ,PEACE8 ,BUT1 HAVE MANY ASK$ ! SUPREME LEAD]1 IF WE N[ BELIEVE AGA9 9 ! 9EVITABILITY ( W>1 :AT WILL HAPP5 TO ! HUGE APP>ATUS WE HAVE BUILT = ! PEACE CAMPAIGN8 ,! ANSW] R$UCES ! POSSIBILITY ( A PEACE CAMPAIGN TO A MEAG] DEGREE4 ,IT C\LD 0RESULT 9 PREV5T+ A P>TICUL> W>1 9 ITS TEMPOR>Y PO/PONEM5T1 9 ! RESIGNATION ( A BELLICOSE GOV]NM5T0 & ITS REPLACEM5T BY A PEACE-KEEP+ GOV]NM5T 7IS ?IS LIKELY TO CURB ! APPETITE = M>KETS1 :I* HAS BE5 PRES5T$ AS A DECISIVE FACT MANY TIMES BE=E874 ,BUT 0! 9EVITABILITY ( W>S0 REMA9S4 0,IT IS POSSIBLE ?AT 9 A DEF9ITE CONJUNCTURE ( CIRCUM/ANCES ! FIS & !IR 9EVITABILITY1 ?AT IS ,/AL9'S F9AL S5T5CE1 0IT IS NECESS>Y TO ABOLI% IMP]IALISM40 ,GOOD4 ,& H[ DO WE DO ?AT1 H[ DO WE DE/ROY IMP]IALISM8 ,/AL93 0,9 ?IS RESPECT1 ! PRES5T-DAY PEACE MOVEM5T DIFF]S FROM ! MOVEM5T ( ! TIME ( ! ,FIR/ ,WORLD ,W> = ! CONV]SION ( ! IMP]IALI/ W> 9TO CIVIL W>1 S9CE ! LATT] MOVEM5T W5T F>!R & PURSU$ SOCIALI/ AIMS40 ,COMPLETELY CLE>3 ,L59'S SLOGAN WAS ! SOCIAL CIVIL W>1 I4 E4 ! PROLET>IAT'S W> AGA9/ ! B\RGEOISIE4 ,BUT Y\1 H[EV]1 HAVE ALREADY LEFT ! ,L59I/ WAY BE=E ,WORLD ,W> ,I,I & 9/EAD PRACTIC$ NATIONAL 0COLLABORATION0 OR 0P>TISAN W>02 Y\ HAVE REJECT$ ! SOCIAL W>1 DEF5D+ ONE B\RGEOIS & CAPITALI/ CAMP AGA9/ ANO!R4 ,SO WE WILL BE ATTACK+ IMP]IALISM - BUT :51 9 W> OR 9 PEACE8 ,IF ONE DAY IMP]IALISM & CAPITALISM FALL1 WILL IT BE 9 TIMES ( PEACE OR W>8 ,9 PEACEFUL TIMES Y\ SAY3 ,LEAVE ! ,U,S,S,R ALONE1 & WE WILL ABIDE /RICTLY BY ! LAWS - NO TALK ( OV]?R[+ CAPITALISM4 ,9 TIMES ( W> Y\ SAY3 ! TIMES ( CIVIL W> >E OV]1 ! SITUATION IS NO LONG] ?AT ( #a#i#a#d-#a#h2 ! WORK]S WILL HAVE TO COORD9ATE !IR ACTIONS ) \R RESPECTIVE POLITICAL & MILIT>Y ALLIANCES ) ?IS OR ?AT CAPITALI/ CAMP4 ,?AT'S H[1 C\NTRY AFT] C\NTRY1 ! CLASS /RUGGLE GETS SMO!R$ 9 MUD4 ,:ATEV] NONS5SE ! P>LIAM5T & ! PRESS MAY SAY1 BIG CAPITAL CAN EASILY UND]/& ?AT ,/AL9'S 0DOCUM5T0 IS NOT A DECL>ATION ( W>1 BUT A LIFE 9SURANCE POLICY4 ,JUS PRIMAE NOCTIS.<#b#g.> ,AS 9 HIS ACC\NTABILITY REPORTS1 ,/AL9 LIKES TO TALK AB\T ! GREAT DE$S ( ! ,RUSSIAN GOV]NM5T ON A TE*NICAL & ECONOMIC LEVEL4 ,SO N[1 TOO3 ONE HAD TO FACE A VIRG9 GR\ND1 09 VIEW ( ! ABS5CE 9 ! C\NTRY ( ANY READY-MADE RUDIM5TS ( A SOCIALI/ ECONOMY1 IT HAD TO CREATE NEW1 SOCIALI/ =MS ( ECONOMY1 0/>T+ FROM SCRAT*10 SO TO SPEAK40 ,?IS 0UNPREC$5T$0 TASK1 ,/AL9 SAYS1 WAS 0ACCOMPLI%$ .<444.> ) CR$IT40 ,WELL1 IT'S TRUE3 Y\ W]E FAC+ A VIRG9 SOIL4 ,?AT WAS Y\R =TUNE & ! MIS=TUNE ( ! PROLET>IAN REVOLUTION \TSIDE ,RUSSIA4 ,A REVOLUTION - NO MATT] :I* K9D IT MAY BE 9 HI/ORY - !N /ORMS =W>D ) FULL =CE :5 IT ONLY HAS TO DO ) ! OB/ACLES ( A WILD1 M]CILESS BUT UNT\*$ GR\ND4 ,BUT :51 9 ! YE>S FOLL[+ ! CONQUE/ ( P[] 9 ! VA/ CZ>I/ EMPIRE1 ! DELEGATES ( ! ,R$ ,PROLET>IAT ( ! :OLE WORLD MET 9 ! ,KREML9'S B>OQUE GOLD-PLAT$ HALLS TO SET ! GUIDEL9ES = ?AT REVOLUTION :I* WAS SUPPOS$ TO DE/ROY ! IMP]IAL =TRESSES ( ! ,WE/]N B\RGEOISIES1 SOME?+ ESS5TIAL WAS SAID 9 VA91 NOT EV5 ,L59 UND]/OOD IT.<#b#h.>4 ,IF1 !RE=E1 ! BALANCE %EET ( ! L>GE DAMS & P[] /ATIONS1 ! BALANCE %EET ( ! COLONIZATION ( ! VA/ /EPPES1 IS CONCLUD$ ) HONOR1 ! BALANCE %EET ( ! REVOLUTION 9 ! CAPITALI/ ,WE/ WAS NOT ONLY CONCLUD$ DI%ONORABLE1 :I* W\LD NOT BE ! WOR/1 BUT ) A DEFEAT FROM :I* IT W\LD NOT RECOV] = DECADES TO COME4 ,:AT HAS BE5 SAID 9 VA93 9 ! B\RGEOIS WORLD1 ! WORLD ( ,*RI/IAN P>LIAM5T>Y CIVILIZATION & PRODUCTION ( COMMODITIES1 ! REVOLUTION FACES A PRO/ITUTE GR\ND4 ,Y\ LET IT CONTAM9ATE ITSELF & DIE ( IT4 ,BUT EV5 FROM ?IS D>K EXP]I5CE ,I,T WILL >ISE AGA94 ,NOTES #a4 ,REF]S TO ,/AL93 0,M>XISM & ,PROBLEMS ( ,L+UI/ICS10 #a#i#e1 ,CRITICIZ$ 9 0,! ,FACTORS ( ,RACE & ,NATION 9 ,M>XI/ ,!ORY0 7,I FATTORI DI RAZZA E NAZIONE NELLA TEORIA M>XI/A71 ,IL PROGRAMMA COMUNI/A1 ,NO4 #a#f-#b1#a#i#e#c4 #b4 ,QUOD DIFF]TUR1 NON AUF]TUR 7LAT473 PO/PON$ IS NOT CANCEL$4 #c4 ,/AL93 ,ECONOMIC ,PROBLEMS ( ,SOCIALISM 9 ! ,U,S,S,R1 #aieb #d4 ,B>B>ICCIA30CURLY BE>D10 ONE ( ! DEVIL'S NAMES 9 ,DANTE'S 0,DIV9E ,COM$Y03 0,HELL10 #b#a/ *ANT1 :]E V]SE #aci SAYS3 0& HE US$ HIS BUTT AS A TRUMPET40 #e4 ,! !ORETICAL ORGAN ( ! COMMUNI/ LEFT 9 ,ITALY HAS BE5 CALL$ 0,BATTAGLIA COMUNI/A0 S9CE #a#i#d#e2 AFT] ! SPLIT 9 #a#i#e#a1 ! ORGAN ( ! MOVEM5T TO :I* ,AMADEO ,BORDIGA BELONG$ WAS CALL$ 0,IL PROGRAMMA COMUNI/A40 #f4 ,CONFESSION3 ,BORDIGA MEANS ?AT ! ECONOMIC & SOCIAL /RUCTURE ( ,RUSSIA WILL =CE ,RUSSIAN POLITICIANS TO ADMIT 7! PRES5T PAP] DATES FROM #a#i#e#b7 ?AT 0SOCIALISM0 9 ,RUSSIA IS NO?+ MORE ?AN CAPITALISM1 EV5 IF !Y DO NOT =MULATE IT EXPLICITLY4 #g4 ,ALL QUOTES M>K$ ) 0,/AL90 >E TAK5 FROM3 0,ECONOMIC ,PROBLEMS ( ,SOCIALISM 9 ! ,U,S,S,R40 #a#i#e#b4 #h4 ,V4,I4 ,L593 0,K>L ,M>X10 #a#i#a#d1 ,L59'S ,COLLECT$ ,WORKS1 ,MOSC[1 #a#i#g#d1 ,VOLUME #b#a1 PP4 #d#c-#i#a4 #i4 ,SEE AMONG O!RS3 ,FILO #i#b10,9 ! ,VORTEX ( ,CAPITALI/ ,AN>*Y02 ,BATTAGLIA COMUNI/A1 NO4 #i1 ,MAY #a#i#e#b1 :]E ! ,M>X *APT]3 0,! ,FETI%ISM ( ,COMMODITIES & ! ,SECRET !RE(0 IS TAK5 AS A BASIS4 #a4 ,! #a#i? ,P>TY ,CONGRESS ( ! ,C,P,S,U TOOK PLACE 9 ,OCTOB] #aieb & CO9CID$ ) ! ECONOMIC DEBATE DISCUSS$ H]E4 #a#a4 ,/ATE 9DU/RIALISM H]E MEANS ?AT ! /ATE IS ! [N] ( ! 9DU/RY :I* IT ALSO MANAGES & ADM9I/]S1 :ILE AGRICULTURE IS H>DLY AFFECT$ AT ALL 7EXCEPT = ! SMALL P>T ( ! ,SOVIETS74 ,= ,L591 /ATE CAPITALISM WAS ! HIIAT'S DICTATOR%IP C\LD SET ITSELF 9 ANTICIPATION ( ! 9T]NATIONAL REVOLUTION4 ,IT WAS TO S]VE AS A LEV] = ! TRANS=MATION ( AGRICULTURE1 :I* REMA9$ AT ! LEVEL ( SMALL-SCALE & PATRI>*AL NATURAL PRODUCTION4 ,! ,/AL9I/ C\NT]REVOLUTION MA9TA9$ /ATE LEAD]%IP & PROP]TY RIM1 IT =TIFI$ A MODE ( PRODUCTION ?AT WAS EV5 F> BEL[ ! /ATE CAPITALI/ LEVEL4 #a#b4 ,SEE3 ,K>L ,M>X1 ,CAPITAL ,VOLUME ,I1 #a#h#f#g1 ,*APT] #f1 P4 #a#b#c4 #a#c4 ,ALLUSION TO ! CLOS+ SEQU5CE ( EA* FAIRY TALE FROM 0,?\S& & ,ONE ,NIRATOR'S NAME4 ,?R\< H] N>RATIVE1 ! CLEV] ,S*EH]EZADE CAPTIVATES A K+ :O 9T5DS TO KILL H]4 ,%E SP9S ! FAIRY TALES FROM NIY #a#i#e#e1 AFT] A FAIL$ 0C\P ATTEMPT0 AGA9/ ,KHRU%*EV 9 ,JULY #a#i#e#g4 ,HE !N BECAME DIRECTOR ( AN ELECTRICITY PLANT 9 ,KAZAKH/AN4 #a#e4 ,/A*ANOV MOVEM5T3 ANO!R ATTEMPT TO 9CREASE LABOR PRODUCTIVITY & E/ABLI% ! PIECEWORK WAGE4 ,= ,/AL91 %E PREP>$ ! 0TRANSITION FROM SOCIALISM TO COMMUNISM40 ,BUT SOON 5\<1 H[EV]1 ! ,/A*ANOVI/S 70H]OES ( LABOR07 SEEM$ TO HAVE A RA!R 9HIBIT+ EFFECT ON PRODUCTIVITY1 & SO !Y W]E GRADUALLY 0DISMANTL$0 AS LEAD+ POLITICAL FIGURES4 ,SEE ALSO ,TROTSKY3 ! ,/A*ANOV MOVEM5T 9 0,! ,REVOLUTION ,BETRAY$ 04 #a#f4 ,>TEL3 AN OLD =M ( PEASANT1 COOP]ATIVE UNION ( ,TAT> ORIG92 IT S]V$ ,/AL9 AS ! BASIS ( ! COLLECTIVE F>M4 #a#g4 ,! #bf YE>S REF] TO ! YE> #a#i#b#e1 :5 ,Z9OVIEV HAD GIV5 ! ,ITALIAN COMMUNI/S ! SLOGAN3 0,LONG LIVE FRE$OM6 ,9 #aieb AT ! #a#i? ,P>TY ,CONGRESS1 ,/AL9 SAID3 0,! FLAG ( NATIONAL 9DEP5D5CE & SOV]EIGNTY WAS ?R[N OV]BO>D .4 ,!RE IS NO D\BT ?AT Y\1 ! REPRES5TATIVES ( ! COMMUNI/ & DEMOCRATIC P>TIES1 WILL HAVE TO LIFT ?IS FLAG & C>RY IT =W>D IF Y\ WANT TO BE PATRIOTS1 IF Y\ WANT TO BECOME ! LEAD] ( ! NATION4 ,Y\ >E ! ONLY ONE :O CAN PICK !M UP 04 #a#h4 ,ALLUSION TO ,BUKH>9 & ,BOGDANOV4 #a#i4 0,AS LONG AGO AS #ahdd ,I /AT$ ?AT ! ABOVE-M5TION$ BALANC+ ( USEFUL EFFECTS & EXP5DITURE ( LABOR ON MAK+ DECISIONS CONC]N+ PRODUCTION WAS ALL ?AT W\LD BE LEFT1 9 A COMMUNI/ SOCIETY1 ( ! POLITICO-ECONOMIC CONCEPT ( VALUE4 7,DEUTS*-,FRANZOSIS*E ,JAHRBU*]1 P4 #i#e7 ,! SCI5TIFIC JU/IFICATION = ?IS /ATEM5T1 H[EV]1 AS CAN BE SE51 WAS MADE POSSIBLE ONLY BY ,M>X'S ,CAPITAL40 - ,FRI$RI* ,5GELS1 ,ANTI-,DUHR+1 #ahgg #b4 ,L593 ,REM>KS ON ,NIKOLAI ,BUKH>9'S 0,ECONOMY ( ! ,TRANS=MATION ,P]IOD10 #a#i#h#a4 #b#a4 ,9 ?IS CONTEXT1 ,/AL9 PUTS ! WORD 0COMMODITY0 9 QUOTATION M>KS4 ,HE PROPOSES TO REPLACE ! T]M 0COMMODITY DELIV]Y0 ) 0PRODUCT EX*ANGE0 & SUGGE/S ?AT ! 0TRANSITION FROM SOCIALISM TO COMMUNISM0 W\LD MEAN N>R[+ ! SCOPE ( CIRCULATION ( COMMODITIES & BROAD5+ ?AT ( PRODUCT EX*ANGE4 #b#b4 ,L' APRES-MIDI D' UNE FAUNE3 0,! ,AFT]NOON ( A ,FAUN02 MUSIC BY ,DEBUSSY4 #b#c4 ,LAISSEZ FAIRE1 LAISSEZ PASS] 7,FR5*73 0,LAISSEZ FAIRE1 LAISSEZ PASS]1 LE MONDE VA DE LUI-MEME0 70,LET IT HAPP51 LET IT PASS1 ! WORLD WILL GO ON ON ITS [N071 A /ATEM5T BY ,V9C5T DE ,G\RNAY 7#a#g#a#b-#e#i71 ATTRIBUT$ TO A ,FR5* ECONOMI/4 ,APPLIES AS A BUZZWORD ( ECONOMIC LIB]ALISM1 AS AN 9VITATION TO ! /ATE P[] NOT TO 9T]V5E 9 ECONOMIC PROCESSES4 #b#d4 ,KESSELR+3 FROM #a#i#d#a-#d#e COMM&]-9-*IEF ( ! ,WEHRMA*T 9 ,ITALY & ,NOR? ,AFRICA4 #b#e4 ,CONTRADICTIO 9 ADJECTO 7LAT473 ,CONTRADICTION 9 ITSELF4 #b#f4 ,EHR5BURG3 ,RUSSIAN WRIT]4 ,APOLOGETE ( PEACEFUL COEXI/5CE & ! 0?AW40 ,N5NI3 ,SECRET>Y ,G5]AL ( ,P,S,I4 ,O!RWISE SEE ,EHR5BURG4 #b#g4 ,JUS PRIMAE NOCTIS 7LAT473 0,RIE NO LONG] 0VIRG90 BUT RA!R OV]RIPE4 ,! ,ITALIAN LEFT HAS EMPHASIZ$ ! DANG] ( AN 0ELA/IC0 TACTIC T[>DS ! SOCIAL DEMOCRATIC P>TIES1 P>TICUL>LY ) REG>D TO ! TACTICS ( ! POLITICAL 7NONUNION67 UNIT$ FRONT & A COMMON WORK]S GOV]NM5T ) !SE P>TIES4 ,! ,LEFT CONSID]$ ?AT ! Y\NG ,COMMUNI/ P>TIES %\LD NOT COMPROMISE !MSELVES BY ACT+ 9 CONC]T ) SOCIAL DEMOCRATIC OR SIMIL> P>TIES1 :ILE O!R DELEGATES & ! ,BOL%EVIKS >GU$ ?AT !Y %\LD FIR/ GA!R ALL =CES TO 0SIFT0 AT A LAT] DATE4 ,FROM 3 ,M>XI/S4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,M>* #c1 #bba 3 ,DIALOGUE ) ,/AL9 -- ,ADD$4 ,JANU>Y #h1 #bbb 3 ,DIALOGUE ) ,/AL9 -- ,UPDAT$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/