,DOCTR9E ( ! ,BODY ,POSSESS$ BY ! ,DEVIL ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,AMADEO ,BORDIGA ,TEXT 3 ,FIR/ ,PUBLI%$3 ,BATTAGLIA ,COMUNI/A NO4 #b#a1 #a#i#e#a2 ,S\RCE3 HTTP3_/_/WWW4GEOCITIES4COM_/,CAPITOL,HILL_/,LOBBY_/#c#i#i_/BORDIGA4HTML2 ,H,T,M,L ,M>KUP3 ,&Y ,BLUND5 #b#c4 ,IT IS VITAL TO BE QUITE CLE> AB\T ! QUE/ION ( /ATE CAPITALISM 9 ORD] TO RESET ! COMPASSES ?AT HAVE LO/ !IR BE>+S4.<#a.> ,WE HAVE MANAG$ TO GA!R MANY CONTRIBUTIONS TO ?IS QUE/ION FROM ! RANGE ( TRADITIONAL CONCEPTS ( ! M>XI/ S*OOL ?AT %[ ?AT /ATE CAPITALISM IS NOT ONLY ! LATE/ ASPECT ( ! B\RGEOIS WORLD1 BUT ?AT ITS =MS1 EV5 COMPLETE ONES1 >E V]Y OLD & CORRESPOND ) ! V]Y EM]G5CE ( ! CAPITALI/ TYPE ( PRODUCTION4 ,!Y S]V$ AS ! MA9 FACTORS 9 PRIMITIVE ACCUMULATION & LONG PREC$$ ! FICTITI\S & CONV5TIONAL 5VIRONM5T ( PRIVATE 5T]PRISE1 ( FREE 9ITIATIVE & O!R F9E ?+S :I* >E F\ND F> MORE 9 ! FIELD ( APOLOGY ?AN 9 ! REAL WORLD4 ,AS WE HAVE ALREADY SAID1 !RE >E MANY GR\PS 9 ! CAMP ( ! LEFT COMMUNI/ ANTI-/AL9I/S :O DO NOT SEE ?+S 9 ?IS WAY4 ,WE SAY TO !M1 ON ! BASIS ( E>LI] TEXTS1 = EXAMPLE3 0,:]EV] IT MAY BE1 :]EV] !RE IS ! ECONOMIC =M ( ! M>KET1 CAPITALISM IS A SOCIAL =CE4 ,IT IS A CLASS =CE4 ,& IT HAS ! POLITICAL /ATE AT ITS DISPOSAL40.<#b.> ,& LET US ADD ! =MULA :I*1 = US1 EXPRESSES V]Y WELL ! MO/ REC5T ASPECTS ( ! WORLD ECONOMY3 0,/ATE CAPITALISM IS NOT A SUBJUGATION ( CAPITALISM TO ! /ATE1 BUT A FIRM] SUBJUGATION ( ! /ATE TO CAPITAL40 ,!SE GR\PS1 H[EV]1 F9D ! T]MS ( ! FIR/ !SIS W]E3 0CORRECT UNTIL #a#i1 ! EPO* ( ! OP5+ ( IMP]IALI/ EXPANSION &1 AS SU*1 REMA9 UP TO DATE1 BUT >E 9COMPLETE :5 ! EVOLUTION ( CAPITALISM GAVE TO ! /ATE ! FUNCTION ( TAK+ OV] ! F9AL MOM5TS ( SU* AN EVOLUTION FROM PRIVATE 9ITIATIVE40 ,& !Y CONT9UE BY SAY+ ?AT WE WILL BE LATE-COM]S 9 ! WORLD ( ECONOMIC 0CULTURE0 IF WE FAIL TO UND]/& ?AT :]E ?IS !SIS FAILS TO FIT 9 ) HI/ORY1 IT CEASES TO BE M>XI/1 & IF WE DO NOT REQUE/ ! ADDITION ( ! /UDY ( ! /ATE ECONOMY TO ,M>X'S ANALYSIS1 TAK+ ?IS FROM TEXTS WRITT5 BY ! P[]FUL P]SONALITY ( ! ECONOMI/ ,KAIS]4.<#c.> ,A BAD HABIT6 ,A TEXT :I* SEEKS TO E/ABLI% GIV5 RELATIONS BETWE5 ?+S & FACTS IS *ECK$ AGA9/ ?+S & FACTS & NOT AGA9/ ! SIGNATURE ON ! BOOK1 :I* IS BAS$ ON ! MORE OR LESS P[]FUL OR P[]LESS P]SONALITY ( ! AU?OR4 ,P]SONALITIES8 ,/ICK !M UP Y\R ,KAIS] AS F> AS WE >E CONC]N$6 ,& IF 9 #aie ! IDOL ( PRIVATE 5T]PRISE IS CORROD$1 WE WELL KN[ ?AT ,SIR ,K>L R$UC$ ?IS TO M9UTE FRAGM5TS A GOOD C5TURY AGO3 Y\ SEE WE KN[ ?IS BECAUSE WE >E /UBBORN LATE-COM]S1 LAZY 9 READ+ ! LATE/ BOOKS444 ,9 ,M>XISM1 ! CONCEPT ( PRIVATE 9ITIATIVE DOES NOT EXI/3 LOOK D[N AT ! COMPASS DIAL1 NOT UP TO HEAV5 LIKE ! P]SON :O HE>S P>ADOXES 7P>ADOX -- SOME?+ :I* COMMON S5SE SAYS IS 9CORRECT :5 IT IS V]Y MU* CORRECT74 ,WE HAVE SAID 9 ?\S&S ( SPEE*ES ( PROPAG&A ?AT ! SOCIALI/ PROGRAM IS = ! ABOLITION ( PRIVATE PROP]TY ( ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION1 :I* IS BORNE \T BY ,M>X'S ,CRITIQUE ( ! ,GO?A ,PROGRAM & ,L59 ON ,M>X4 ,WE SAID PROP]TY & NOT PRIVATE ECONOMY4 ,! PRECAPITALI/ ECONOMY WAS PRIVATE1 OR 9DIVIDUAL4 ,PROP]TY IS A T]M :I* DOES NOT 9DICATE A PURELY ECONOMIC RELATION%IP1 BUT ALSO A LEGAL ONE & BR+S 9TO DISCUSSION NOT JU/ ! PRODUCTIVE =CES1 BUT ALSO ! RELATIONS ( PRODUCTION4 ,PRIVATE PROP]TY MEANS PRIVATE RI1 ! GR\PS ) :I* WE >E 9 DISPUTE DO NOT /ATE ?AT /ATE CAPITALISM IS ALREADY SOCIALISM1 BUT FALL 9TO SAY+ ?AT IT IS A ?IRD & NEW =M BETWE5 PRIVATE CAPITALISM & SOCIALISM4 ,!Y SAY 9 FACT ?AT !RE >E TWO DI/9CT P]IODS3 ?AT 9 :I* 0! /ATE HAS MORE ( ! OLD] POLIC+ FUNCTION ?AN ?AT ( 9VOLVEM5T 9 ! ECONOMY01 & ?AT 9 :I* 0IT GIVES ! MAXIMUM P[] TO ! EX]CISE ( =CE SPECIFICALLY TO PROTECT ! ECONOMY C5TRALIZ$ 9 IT04 ,WE SAY ?AT 9 !SE TWO =MULAS1 :I* >E MORE OR LESS FAI?FULLY REPRODUC$1 & EV5 MORE SO ! TWO HI/ORICAL P]IODS1 ?AT CAPITALISM IS ! SAME1 ! RUL+ CLASS IS ! SAME1 & ! HI/ORICAL /ATE IS ! SAME4 ,! ECONOMY IS ! 5TIRE SOCIAL FIELD 9 :I* PRODUCTION & DI/RIBUTION OCCUR & 9CLUDES ! M5 P>TICIPAT+ 9 ?IS3 ! /ATE IS A SPECIFIC ORGANIZATION ACT+ 9 ! SOCIAL FIELD1 & ! /ATE 9 ! CAPITALI/ P]IOD HAS ALWAYS HAD ! FUNCTION ( POLICEMAN & PROTECTOR ( ! 9T]E/S ( A CLASS & A TYPE ( PRODUCTION CORRESPOND+ HI/ORICALLY ) ?IS CLASS4 ,! /ATE CONC5TRAT+ ! ECONOMY )9 ITSELF IS AN 9CONGRU\S =MULA4 ,= M>XISM1 ! /ATE IS ALWAYS PRES5T 9 ! ECONOMY -- ITS P[] & LEGAL VIOL5CE >E ECONOMIC FACTORS FROM FIR/ TO LA/4 ,ONE CAN BE/ EXPLA9 IT ?IS WAY3 9 C]TA9 CASES1 ! /ATE1 ) ITS ADM9I/RATION1 ASSUMES ! MANAGEM5T ( 9DU/RIAL CONC]NS2 & IF IT ASSUMES ! MANAGEM5T ( ALL ( !M1 !N IT WILL HAVE C5TRALIZ$ ! MANAGEM5T ( ! CONC]NS1 BUT NOT ( ! ECONOMY4 ,ESPECIALLY SO LONG AS DI/RIBUTION TAKES PLACE ) MONEY PRICES 7?AT !SE >E FIX$ (FICIALLY DOES NOT MATT]7 ! /ATE IS A FIRM AMONG FIRMS1 A CONTRACTOR AMONG CONTRACTORS2 ALL ! WORSE 9 ?AT IT CONSID]S AS FIRMS EA* ( ITS NATIONAL 5T]PRISES1 AS ) ! ,LABORITES1 ,*UR*ILLIANS & ,/AL9I/S4 ,GETT+ AWAY FROM ?IS SITUATION IS NOT A QUE/ION ( ADM9I/RATIVE MEASURES1 BUT A PROBLEM ( REVOLUTION>Y =CE1 ( CLASS W>4 ,! PROBLEM IS POS$ BETT] 9 AN 9T]E/+ BULLET9 PUBLI%$ BY ! COMRADES ( ! 0,GR\PE FRANCAIS DE LA GAU*E COMMUNI/E 9T]NATIONALE0.<#d.> ( :I* -- ) GREAT PLEASURE -- WE DO NOT KN[ ! NAMES & P]SONALITIES4 ,S5SIBLE QUE/IONS >E ASK$ ON ! PROBLEM :I* DES]VE FUR!R DEVELOPM5T1 & ! PROBLEM IS POS$ 9 CONTRA/ TO ! VISION ( ! NOT$ ,*AULIEU GR\P1 :I* IS 9FLU5C$ BY ! !ORY ( 0DECAD5CE0 & ( ! TRANSITION FROM CAPITALISM TO B>B>ISM :I* 9SPIRES 9 !M1 H[EV]1 ! SAME HORROR AS ?AT ( ! 0BUREAUCRATIC0 REGIMES4 ,A !ORY 9 :I* ONE DOES NOT KN[ :AT ON E>? ! COMPASSES >E 9DICAT+ UNTIL !Y PRATTLE AB\T M>XISM4 ,!RE >E ELEM5TS 9 ! 9T]NAL BULLET9 ( \R MOVEM5T.<#e.> ON ! DECAD5CE ( CAPITALISM :]E WE DEAL ) ! FALSE !ORY ( ! DESC5D+ CURVE4 ,)\T ANY HAUE DECAY+4 ,JU/ IMAG9E ?AT IT IS DECAY+444 ,AS = B>B>ISM1 IT IS ! OPPOSITE ( CIVILIZATION & SO ( BUREAUCRACY4 ,\R B>B>IAN ANCE/ORS1 LUCKY !M1 DID NOT HAVE ORGANIZATIONAL APP>ATUSES BAS$ 7OLD ,5GELS67 ON TWO ELEM5TS -- A DEF9$ RUL+ CLASS & A DEF9$ T]RITORY4 ,!RE WAS ! CLAN1 ! TRIBE1 BUT /ILL NOT ! CIVITAS4 ,CIVITAS MEANS CITY & ALSO /ATE4 ,CIVILIZATION IS ! OPPOSITE ( B>B>ISM & MEANS /ATE ORGANIZATION1 !RE=E NECESS>ILY BUREAUCRACY4 ,MORE /ATE MEANS MORE CIVILIZATION MEANS MORE BUREAUCRACY1 :ILE CLASS CIVILIZATIONS FOLL[ ONE UPON ! O!R4 ,?IS IS :AT M>XISM SAYS4 ,IT IS NOT ! RETURN TO B>B>ISM1 BUT ! />T ( SUP]CIVILIZATION1 :I* IS DUP+ US EV]Y:]E1 ?AT ! MON/]S ( CONTEMPOR>Y /ATE SUP]-ORGANIZATIONS DOM9ATE4 ,BUT LET US LEAVE ! MEMB]S ( ,SOCIALISME \ B>B>IE TO !IR EXI/5TIAL CRISIS4 ,! BULLET9 WE QUOT$ REFUTES !M 9 AN >TICLE ) ! CORRECT TITLE3 ,DEUX ANS DE BAV>DAGE3 ,TWO YE>S ( *ATT]+ -- ,NO *ATT]+ H]E1 PLEASE NOTE6 ,LET US COME TO ! BALANC$ =MULA ) :I* ! ,FR5* COMRADES =MULAT$ ! QUE/ION -- ! DEF9ITION ( ! RUL+ CLASS ( ! /ATE CAPITALI/ C\NTRIES1 ! EXACTITUDE OR 9SUFFICI5CY ( ! DEF9ITION3 CAPITALISM HEIR TO ! LIB]AL REVOLUTIONS4 ,! CONCLUSION PRES5T$ BY ?IS GR\P IS CORRECT3 /OP PRES5T+ ! BUREAUCRACY AS AN AUTONOM\S CLASS1 P]FIDI\SLY W>M$-UP )9 ! PROLET>IAT1 & 9/EAD CONSID] IT AS A HUGE APP>ATUS L9K$ TO A GIV5 HI/ORICAL SITUATION 9 ! WORLD-WIDE EVOLUTION ( CAPITALISM4 ,H]E WE >E ON ! RIS TO BE ! PROTAGONI/ ON ! /AGE -- WE TOO W]E AB\T TO SAY 9 ! PHASE ( DECAD5CE -- !Y >E 9 FACT PRE-REVOLUTION>Y PHASES & ?OSE ( MAXIMUM EXPANSION4 ,:Y CALL ! SOCIETY READY = ! MIDWIFE ( ! REVOLUTION1 ! OB/ETRICIAN :O WILL GIVE BIR? TO ! NEW SOCIETY1 DECAD5T8 ,! PREGNANT WOMAN IS NOT DECAD5T1 BUT ! /]ILE ONE IS4 ,*AULIEU SEES ! 9FLAT$ BELLY ( CAPITALI/ SOCIETY & MI/AKES ! 9ADEQUATE SKILL ( ! OB/ETRICIAN CONFRONT$ ) ! SWOLL5 UT]US ) ! IMAG9>Y 9F]TILITY ( ! PREGNANT WOMAN4 ,!Y ACCUSE ! ,KREML9 BUREAUCRACY ( GIV+ US A /ILL-BORN SOCIALISM DUE TO !IR ABUSE ( P[]1 :ILE ! FAULT LIES 9 NOT HAV+ TAK5 UP ! =CEPS ( ! REVOLUTION TO OP5 UP ! BELLY ( ,EUROPE-,AM]ICA1 DRIV5 BY FL\RI%+ CAPITAL ACCUMULATION1 & HAV+ MADE A USELESS EF=T ON AN 9F]TILE WOMB4 ,& P]HAPS ONLY ON AN 9F]TILE WOMB1 9V]T+ ! BATTLE = GRA9 ) ! BATTLE = SE$4.<#f.> ,LET US GO ON TO ! PURELY M>XI/-ECONOMIC PO9T AFT] ?IS BRIEF CL>IFICATION4 ,! /ATEM5T 0CAPITALISM HEIR TO ! LIB]AL REVOLUTIONS01 :I* CORRECTLY MADE ! C5TRAL PO9T1 CONTA9S ! PRECISE HI/ORICAL !SIS3 CAPITALISM HAS A CYCLE1 A S+LE CLASS C\RSE1 FROM ! B\RGEOIS TO ! PROLET>IAN REVOLUTION1 & IT CANNOT BE SPLIT 9TO SEV]AL CYCLES )\T R5\NC+ REVOLUTION>Y M>XISM4 ,BUT1 IT MU/ BE SAID1 AS IT IS SAID A LITTLE FUR!R ON1 CAPITALISM APPE>$ FROM ! B\RGEOIS 7NOT LIB]AL7 REVOLUTIONS OR1 BETT] /ILL1 0ANTI-FEUDAL0 REVOLUTIONS4 ,9 FACT LIB]ALISM BECAME ! GOAL & MOTIVE ( !SE REVOLUTIONS1 !IR G5]AL IDEA1 ONLY ?R\< B\RGEOIS APOLOGETICS4 ,M>X REJECT$ ?IS & = HIM ! HI/ORICAL GOAL ( !SE REVOLUTIONS IS ! DE/RUCTION ( ! OB/ACLES TO ! DOM9ATION ( ! CAPITALI/ CLASS4 ,ONLY 9 ?AT S5SE IS ! ABBREVIAT$ =MULATION CORRECT4 ,IT IS QUITE CLE>3 CAPITAL CAN EASILY GET RID ( LIB]ALISM )\T *ANG+ ITS NATURE4 ,& ?IS IS ALSO CLE>3 ! DIRECTION ( ! DEG5]ATION1 ! DEG5]ATION ( ! REVOLUTION 9 ,RUSSIA DOES NOT PASS FROM ! REVOLUTION = COMMUNISM TO ! REVOLUTION = A DEVELOP$ K9D ( CAPITALISM1 BUT TO A PURE CAPITALI/ REVOLUTION4 ,IT RUNS 9 P>ALLEL ) WORLD-WIDE CAPITALI/ DOM9ATION :I*1 BY SUCCESSIVE /EPS1 ELIM9ATES OLD FEUDAL & ,ASIATIC =MS 9 V>I\S ZONES4 ,:ILE ! HI/ORICAL SITUATION 9 ! SEV5TE5?1 EIIAN & BUREAUCRATIC ONES4 ,! DIFF]5CE IS NOT DUE TO BASIC QUALITATIVE V>IATIONS ( CAPITALISM1 BUT TO ! HUGE DIV]SITY 9 QUANTITATIVE DEVELOPM5T1 AS ) ! 9T5SITY 9 EA* METROPOLE1 & ! DIFFUSION OV] ! PLANET'S SURFACE4 ,! FACT ?AT CAPITALISM DECREAS+LY ADOPTS = ITS CONS]VATION1 JU/ AS = ITS DEVELOPM5T & 5L>GEM5T1 LIB]AL *IT-*AT & EV] 9CREAS+LY USES POLICE ME?ODS & BUREAUCRATIC SUFFOCATION1 :5 ! HI/ORICAL L9E IS CLE>LY SE51 DOES NOT CAUSE ! SLIIAN REVOLUTION4 ,IT WILL MAKE USE ( ?IS VIOL5CE1 P[]1 /ATE & BUREAUCRACY1 DESPOTISM AS ! ,MANIFE/O CALL$ IT ) A YET MORE DREADFUL T]M #ac YE>S AGO4 ,!N IT WILL KN[ H[ TO GET RID ( ALL ( !M4 ,! SURGEON DOES NOT PUT D[N ! BLOOD /A9$ LANCET BE=E ! NEW LIFE HAS EM]G$ & HAS DRAWN ITS FIR/ BREA?1 ! HYMN TO LIFE4 ,YE/]DAY ,DOES NOT ! BASIC =M ( CAPITALISM DISAPPE> ) ! DISAPPE>ANCE ( ! PRIVATE 9DIVIDUALS :O1 AS [N]S ( FACTORIES1 ORGANIZE PRODUCTION8 ,?IS IS ! OBJECTION 9 ! ECONOMIC FIELD :I* ATTRACTS MANY PEOPLE'S ATT5TION4 0,! CAPITALI/0 IS NAM$ A HUNDR$ TIMES BY ,M>X4 ,BESIDES1 ! WORD 0CAPITAL0 COMES FROM ! WORD CAPUT1 MEAN+ HEAD1 & SO TRADITIONALLY CAPITAL IS ANY WEAL? L9K$1 9TE/ATE1 TO ANY S+UL> TITUL> P]SON4 ,H[EV]1 ! !SIS TO :I* WE HAVE D$ICAT$ EXPOSITIONS = A LONG TIME DOESN'T CONTA9 ANY?+ NEW1 BUT ONLY EXPLA9S1 REMA9+ TRUE1 ?AT ! M>XI/ ANALYSIS ( CAPITALISM DOES NOT CONSID] AS VITAL ! ELEM5T ( ! P]SON ( ! FACTORY [N]4 ,QUOTATIONS FROM ,M>X W\LD BE 9NUM]ABLE3 LET US !N CONCLUDE ) JU/ ONE4 ,LET US TAKE ! SO CALL$ 0CLASSIC0 CAPITALISM ( ! 0FREE0 FACTORY4 ,M>X ALWAYS PUT !SE 9 QUOTATION M>KS1 !Y 9 FACT *>ACT]IZE ! B\RGEOIS S*OOL HE F\1 HAD A SUM ( MONEY TO H&4 ,GOOD4 ,5TIRE SECTIONS ( ,M>X'S WORK REPLY ) ! QUE/ION3 H[ COME8 ,! REPLIES V>Y3 !FT1 ROBB]Y1 USURY1 BLACK M>KETE]+ OR1 AS WE HAVE SE5 MORE ?AN A FEW TIMES1 ROYAL *>T] OR LAW ( ! L&4 ,SO ,X1 9/EAD ( /A%+ HIS GOLD CO9S 9 A SACK1 SO AS TO RUN HIS F+]S ?R\< !M EV]Y NIIAN SOCIAL IDEALS4 ,HE NOBLY FACES ! RISKS & CIRCULATES HIS CAPITAL4 ,SO1 FIR/ ELEM5T ACCUMULAT$ MONEY4 ,SECOND ELEM5T1 ACQUISITION ( RAW MAT]IALS1 ! CLASSIC RAW COTTON BALES1 ( SO MANY LITTLE *APT]S & P>AGRAPHS4 ,?IRD ELEM5T1 ACQUISITION ( ! WORKS :]E HE SETS UP PLANT & LOOMS TO SP9 & WEAVE4 ,F\R? ELEM5T1 TE*NICAL ORGANIZATION & MANAGEM5T4 ,! CLASSIC CAPITALI/ LOOKS AFT] ?IS HIMSELF4 ,HE HAS /UDI$1 GONE ON TRIPS & J\RNEYS & HAS ?\E SPOOL -- ?AT HAPP5$ 9 ! SEMI-B>B>IC TIMES ( 9DIVIDUAL PRODUCTION4 ,BUT AT ! SAME TIME !RE WILL BE TR\BLE IF !Y REMOVE A S+LE ?READ ( COTTON TO PAT* !IR TR\S]S4 ,!Y >E REW>D$ ) A JU/ EQUIVAL5T = !IR LABOR TIME4.<#g.> ,?R\< ! COMB9ATION ( !SE ELEM5TS1 ONE A*IEVES ! ONE ?AT IS ! MOTIVE & ! REASON = ! :OLE PROCESS3 ! MASS ( Y>N OR TEXTILES4 ,! ESS5TIAL FACT IS ?AT ONLY ! CAPITALI/ CAN TAKE ?IS TO M>KET & ! F9ANCIAL RETURN IS HIS & HIS ALONE4 ,ALWAYS ! SAME OLD /ORY4 ,YES1 Y\ KN[ ! LITTLE SUM -- ! CO/ ( ! RAW COTTON1 SOME?+ = ! WE> & TE> ON PLANT & MA*9]Y1 ! WORK]S WAGES4 ,RECEIPTS3 ! PRICE ( ! PRODUCT SOLD4 ,?IS IS GREAT] ?AN ! SUM ( ! CO/S & ! DIFF]5CE CON/ITUTES ! PR(IT M>G9 ( ! FACTORY4 ,IT MATT]S LITTLE ?AT ! CAPITALI/ DOES :AT HE LIKES ) ! MONEY HE GETS BACK -- HE C\LD DO ?AT ) HIS ORIG9AL CA% ALREADY )\T MANUFACTUR+ ANY?+4 ,! IMPORTANT FACT IS ?AT AFT] RE/OCK+ 9 EV]Y?+ TO ! LEVEL ( HIS ORIG9AL 9VE/M5T1 HE /ILL HAS A MASS ( MONEY ON H&4 ,HE C\LD CONSUME IT HIMSELF1 C]TA9LY4 ,BUT SOCIALLY HE CANNOT1 & SOME?+ =CES HIM TO 9 L>GE P>T 9VE/ IT1 TO TRANSLATE IT 9TO CAPITAL AGA94 ,M>X SAYS ?AT ! LIFE CYCLE ( CAPITAL CONSI/S ONLY 9 ITS MOVEM5T AS VALUE P]PETUALLY SET 9 MOTION SO AS TO MULTIPLY ITSELF4 ,! DESIRE ( ! P]SON ( ! CAPITALI/ IS NOT REQUIR$ 9 ?IS1 NOR W\LD HE BE ABLE TO IMP$E IT4 ,ECONOMIC DET]M9ISM NOT ONLY OBLIGES ! WORK] TO SELL HIS LABOR TIME1 BUT SIMIL>LY ! CAPITALI/ TO 9VE/ & ACCUMULATE4 ,\R CRITICISM ( LIB]ALISM DOES NOT CONSI/ 9 SAY+ !RE IS A FREE CLASS & A SLAVE CLASS4 ,!RE IS AN EXPLOIT$ ONE & A PR(ITE]+ ONE1 BUT !Y >E BO? TI$ TO ! LAWS ( ! HI/ORICAL CAPITALI/ MODE ( PRODUCTION4 ,! PROCESS IS !RE=E NOT )9 ! FACTORY1 BUT IS SOCIAL & CAN ONLY BE UND]/OOD AS SU*4 ,ALREADY 9 ,M>X !RE IS ! HYPO!SIS ( ! SEP>ATION ( ! V>I\S ELEM5TS FROM ! P]SON ( ! CAPITALI/ 5TREPR5EUR1 :I* IS SUB/ITUT$ ) A %>E P>TICIPATION 9 ! PR(IT M>G9 ( ! PRODUCTIVE 5T]PRISE4 ,FIR/LY1 ! MONEY CAN BE GOT FROM A L5D]1 A BANK1 :O RECEIVES P]IODIC 9T]E/4 ,SECONDLY1 9 SU* A CASE ! MAT]IALS ACQUIR$ ) ?AT MONEY >E NOT REALLY ! PROP]TY ( ! 5TREPR5EUR1 BUT ( ! F9ANCI]4 ,?IRDLY1 9 ,5GL& ! [N] ( A BUILD+1 H\SE OR FACTORY MAY NOT BE ! [N] ( ! L& ON :I* IT /&S3 ?US H\SES & FACTORIES CAN BE R5T$4 ,NO?+ PROHIBITS ! SAME = LOOMS & O!R MA*9]Y & TOOLS4 ,F\R? ELEM5T1 ! 5TREPR5EUR MAY LACK TE*NICAL & ADM9I/RATIVE MANAG]IAL CAPACITIES1 HE HIRES 5G9E]S & ACC\NTANTS4 ,FIF? ELEM5T1 WORK]S' WAGES -- EVID5TLY !IR PAYM5T TOO IS MADE FROM LOANS FROM ! F9ANCI]4 ,! /RICT FUNCTION ( ! 5TREPR5EUR IS R$UC$ TO ?AT ( HAV+ SE5 ?AT !RE IS A M>KET DEM& = A C]TA9 MASS ( PRODUCTS :I* HAVE A SALE PRICE ABOVE ! TOTAL CO/ ( ! PREC$+ ELEM5TS4 ,H]E ! CAPITALI/ CLASS IS RE/RICT$ TO ! 5TREPR5EURIAL CLASS1 :I* IS A SOCIAL & POLITICAL =CE1 & ! PR9CIPAL BASIS ( ! B\RGEOIS /ATE4 ,BUT ! /RATA ( 5TREPR5EURS DOES NOT CO9CIDE ) ?AT ( MONEY1 L&1 H\S+ & FACTORY [N]S & COMMODITY SUPPLI]S4 ,!RE >E TWO BASIC =MS & PO9TS REQUIR$ TO RECOGNIZE CAPITALISM4 ,ONE IS ?AT ! RIDS ?IS C5TRAL RIY SOCIETY IS FROM ! \TSET A CLASS MONOPOLY1 IT IS A /RUCTURE ( P[]1 & ! /ATE1 ! JUDICI>Y & POLICE PUNI% :OEV] BREAKS ?IS NORM4 ,SU* IS ! CONDITION = 5T]PRISE PRODUCTION4 ,! O!R PO9T IS ?AT ! SOCIAL CLASSES >E NOT ISOLAT$ ONE FROM ANO!R4 ,!RE >E NO LONG]1 HI/ORICALLY SPEAK+1 CA/ES OR ORD]S4 ,BELONG+ TO ! L&$ >I/OCRACY WAS SOME?+ ?AT LA/$ MORE ?AN ONE LIFESPAN1 AS ! TITLE WAS H&$ D[N ?R\< ! G5]ATIONS4 ,[N]%IP ( BUILD+S OR L>GE F9ANCES LA/S ON AV]AGE AT LEA/ A LIFESPAN4 ,! 0AV]AGE P]IOD ( P]SONAL MEMB]%IP ( A GIV5 9DIVIDUAL TO ! RUL+ CLASS0 T5DS TO BECOME EV5 %ORT]4 ,= ?IS REASON WE >E CONC]N$ AB\T ! EXTREMELY DEVELOP$ =M ( CAPITAL1 NOT ! CAPITALI/4 ,?IS DIRECTOR DOES NOT NE$ FIX$ PEOPLE4 ,IT F9DS & RECRUITS !M :]EV] IT WANTS & *ANGES !M 9 EV] MORE M9D B5D+ %IFTS4 ,TODAY ,H]E WE CANNOT DEMON/RATE ?AT ,L59'S 0P>ASITIC CAPITALISM0 DOES NOT MEAN ?AT P[] LIES MORE 9 ! H&S ( ! F9ANCIAL CAPITALI/S ?AN 9 ?OSE ( ! 9DU/RIAL CAPITALI/S4 ,CAPITALISM C\LD NOT SPREAD & EXP& )\T GR[+ MORE COMPLICAT$ & PROGRESSIVELY SEP>AT+ 9TO ! V>I\S ELEM5TS :I* 5T] 9TO ! COMPETITION = SPECULATIVE GA93 F9ANCE1 TE*NOLOGY1 EQUIPM5T1 ADM9I/RATION4 ,! T5D5CY IS = ! L>GE/ M>G9 & SOCIAL CONTROL TO SLIP FROM ! GRASP ( POSITIVE & ACTIVE ELEM5TS TO BECOME CONC5TRAT$ 9 ! H&S ( SPECULATORS & BUS9ESS B&ITRY4 ,WE %ALL !RE=E FLY FROM ,M>X TO444 ,DON ,/URZO4 ,?IS LATT]1 ) HIS HABITUAL PRUD5CE1 TOOK 9 H& ! ,9,A SC&AL.<#h.>4 ,:AT HE SAID IS 9T]E/+3 0,I CANNOT SAY :AT HAPP5$ DUR+ FASCISM BECAUSE ,I WAS 9 ,AM]ICA1 BUT :]E !SE ?+S >E ! ORD] ( ! DAY1 MANY O!RS MAY COME TO LIASITISM ( CONTEMPOR>Y ,ITALY BEATS ?AT ( ,MUSSOL9I1 & BO? REMA9 *ILD'S PLAY 9 COMP>ISON ) :EEL]-DEAL] ,U,S BUS9ESS4 ,9,A HAD HUGE F9ANCES BECAUSE IT COLLECT$ ALL ! WORK]S' SOCIAL SECURITY CONTRIBUTIONS1 LIKE O!R SIMIL> /ATE 9/ITUTIONS ) !IR WELL KN[N 9ITIALS4 ,IT PAYS SL[LY SO ITS SAFES >E /UFF$ ) READY CA%4 ,IT !RE=E HAS ! RIE 9 ! CIVILIZATION ( HABEUS CORPUS7 NOT TO LET SU* WEAL? LIE IDLE1 SO IT EMPLOYS & 9VE/S IT4 ,:AT GOOD LUCK = ! MOD]N 5TREPR5EUR6 ,HE IS ! CAPITALI/ )\T CAPITAL1 JU/ AS DIALECTICALLY MOD]N CAPITAL IS CAPITAL )\T ! BOSS1 ACEPHAL\S4 ,! BAD BUS9ESS1 ! CLEV] ,SICILIAN PRIE/ SAYS 7?OSE 9 ! GALL]Y YE>N SOON TO MAKE AN EXAGG]AT$ ORATION AT HIS FUN]AL7 WAS ! =MATION ( TOO MANY FRONT COMPANIES UND] ! ,9,A4 ,:AT ! HELL >E FRONT COMPANIES8 ,SOME TYPES1 V]S$ 9 BUS9ESS :O HAVE LUXURI\S (FICES & HAVE CREPT 9TO ! ECONOMIC & POLITICAL \T] (FICES1 :O DO NOT HAVE A P5NY OR REGI/]$ /OCK OR BUILD+S TO !IR NAMES1 7!Y DO NOT EV5 R5T H\SES1 BUT LIVE 9 BIG HOTELS1 !Y KN[ ,VANONI.<#i.> BACKW>DS1 BUT ,VANONI DOES NOT KN[ !M.<#a.>70PLAN0 A GIV5 DEAL & REGI/] A COMPANY ) ! PLAN AS ITS SOLE ASSET4 ,9,A1 OR SOME SIMIL> BODY1 WILL GIVE IT ! MONEY & IF SOME 0SPECIAL LAW0 IS REQUIR$1 LET US SAY = RAIS+ COCKS 9 OLD >MY BASES1 A PROBLEM IS HA/ILY BR\IO W5T TO ! BANK TO BORR[ MONEY TO USE 9 ! BUS9ESS PLANN$4 ,! BANK REPLI$3 GOOD1 H]E IT IS1 :]E >E Y\R SECURITIES8 ,\T ) Y\R PROP]TY & O!R TITLES444 ,BUT A /ATE-RUN ORGANIZATION DOES NOT HAVE !SE TRIFL+ NE$S3 ! NATIONAL GOOD IS 5\< = IT TO PULL \T ! CA%4 ,! RE/ ( ! TALE TELLS ITSELF4 ,IF ! OLD IMPRES>IO ) HIS PLAN & PRODUCTION PROJECT CREAT$ NOT COCKS BUT COCK-UPS1 HE WAS F9I%$ -- HE DID NOT GET HIS MONEY BACK & HE EXIT$ FROM ! BOSS CLASS HUMILIAT$4 ,\R FRONT COMPANY ) ITS BRILLIANT G5]AL /AFF DOES NOT LIVE 9 ?IS FE>3 IF IT PRODUCES COCKS1 !Y >E SOLD TO P\LTRY F>M]S = A GOOD PRICE1 MONEY IS E>N$4 ,IF1 SUPPOS+ IT DOES NOT PRODUCE COCKS OR NO ONE WANTS COCKS1 NO MATT] -- H&-\TS1 9DEMNITIES & PR(IT %>ES HAVE ALL BE5 CA%$ 9 & ,9,A PAYS = ! MI/AK5 COCK F>M PLAN4 ,WE HAVE EXPLA9$ :AT /ATE CAPITALISM 7OR ! ECONOMY C5TRALIZ$ 9 ! /ATE7 MEANS BY ?IS SMALL & BANAL EXAMPLE4 ,IT %\LD BE SAID ?AT ,9,A'S LOSS IS %>$ BY ALL ! POOR UN=TUNATES :O PAY 9TO ITS C(F]S ANO!R CUT ( !IR DAILY WAGES4 ,/ATE CAPITALISM IS F9ANCE CONC5TRAT$ 9 ! /ATE AT ! DISPOSAL ( PASS+ :EEL]-DEAL]S ( 5T]PRISE 9ITIATIVE4 ,NEV] HAS FREE 5T]PRISE BE5 SO FREE AS :5 ! PR(IT REMA9$ BUT ! LOSS RISK HAS BE5 REMOV$ & TRANSF]R$ TO ! COMMUNITY4 ,! /ATE ALONE CAN PR9T AS MU* MONEY AS IT WANTS & CAN DEAL ) ! =G]4 ,! PROGRESSIVE EXPROPRIATION ( SMALL [N]S & CAPITALI/ CONC5TRATION 9 SUCCESSIVE HI/ORICAL =MS IS BAS$ ON ?IS 9ITIAL PR9CIPAL ( =CE4 ,WE HAVE ) REASON REPEAT$LY /AT$ ?AT NO ECONOMY 9 :I* FIRMS PRES5T ACC\NTS & EX*ANGE IS C>RI$ \T 9 MONEY1 CAN AVOID SU* LAWS4 ,! P[] ( ! /ATE IS !RE=E BAS$ ON ! CONV]G5T 9T]E/S ( !SE PR(ITE]S B5EFIT+ FROM SPECULATIVE PLANS ( FIRMS & FROM !IR WEB ( DEEP-SEAT$ 9T]NATIONAL RELATIONS4 ,H[ CAN !SE /ATES NOT L5D CAPITAL TO ?OSE GANGS :I* NEV] SETTLE !IR DEBTS ) ! /ATE EXCEPT BY =C+ ! EXPLOIT$ CLASSES TO PAY UP8 ,!RE IS ! PRO( ?AT !SE 0CAPITALIZ+0 /ATES >E 9 *RONIC DEBT TO ! B\RGEOIS CLASS1 OR IF Y\ WANT FRE% PRO(1 IT LIES 9 ! FACT ?AT !Y >E OBLIG$ TO BORR[1 TAK+ BACK !IR MONEY & PAY+ 9T]E/ ON IT4 ,! SOCIALI/ ADM9I/RATION ( A 0C5TRALIZ$ ECONOMY0 W\LD NOT PROVIDE \TSIDE TAK+S TO ANY 0PLAN0 JU/ AS IT W\LD NOT PAY 9T]E/4 ,BESIDES1 IT W\LD NOT DEAL 9 MONEY4 ,CAPITAL IS ONLY CONC5TRAT$ 9 ! /ATE = ! CONV5I5CE ( SURPLUS-VALUE & PR(IT MANEUV]+4 ,IT REMA9S 0AVAILABLE TO ALL0 OR AVAILABLE TO ! COMPON5TS ( ! 5TREPR5EURIAL CLASS -- NO LONG] SIMPLY PRODUCTION 5TREPR5EURS1 BUT OP5LY BUS9ESS 5TREPR5EURS -- !Y NO LONG] PRODUCE COMMODITIES1 BUT1 ,M>X HAS ALREADY SAID1 !Y PRODUCE SURPLUS VALUE4 ,! CAPITALI/ AS P]SON NO LONG] S]VES 9 ?IS -- CAPITAL LIVES )\T HIM BUT ) ITS SAME FUNCTION MULTIPLI$ #a FOLD4 ,! HUMAN SUBJECT HAS BECOME USELESS4 ,A CLASS )\T MEMB]S TO COMPOSE IT8 ,! /ATE NOT AT ! S]VICE ( A SOCIAL GR\P1 BUT AN IMPALPABLE =CE1 ! WORK ( ! ,HOLY ,LES'S IRONY4 ,WE (F] ! PROMIS$ QUOTATION3 0,BY TURN+ HIS MONEY 9TO COMMODITIES :I* S]VE AS ! BUILD+ MAT]IALS = A NEW PRODUCT1 & AS FACTORS 9 ! LABOR PROCESS1 BY 9CORPORAT+ LIV+ LABOR 9TO !IR LIFELESS OBJECTIVITY1 ! CAPITALI/ SIMULTANE\SLY TRANS=MS VALUE1 I4E4 PA/ LABOR 9 ITS OBJECTIFI$ & LIFELESS =M1 9TO CAPITAL1 VALUE :I* CAN P]=M ITS [N VALORIZATION PROCESS1 AN ANIMAT$ MON/] :I* BEG9S TO 'WORK'1 'AS IF POSSESS$ BY ! DEVIL'40.<#a#a.> ,CAPITAL MU/ BE SEIZ$ BY ! HORNS4 ,FOOTNOTES .<#a.> ,CF4 ,BUSSOLE IMPAZZITE 7COMPASSES /RUCK ) MADNESS74 .<#b.> ,PROPRIETA' E CAPITALE 7,ISKRA1 ,MILAN1 #a#i#h7 P4 #a#c4 .<#c.> ,H5RY ,KAIS] PROPOS$ 0SOCIAL0 CAPITALISM ) WORK]S %>+ ! PR(ITS4 .<#d.> ,A BULLET9 ISSU$ 9 ,SEPTEMB] #aiea BY ! GR\P ?AT LAT] BECAME ! ,FR5* SECTION ( ! ,9T]NATIONAL ,COMMUNI/ ,P>TY4 ,*AULIEU "7 ,CA/ORIADIS1 A F\ND] ( ! GR\P ,SOCIALISME \ B>B>IE4 .<#e.> 0,IL ROVESCIAM5TO DELLA PRASSI0 N[ 9 ,P>TITO E CLASSE 7,MILAN1 #a#i#g#b7 PP4 #a#b-#a1 #a#c4 0,?IS !ORY 7( ! DESC5D+ CURVE7 COMES FROM GRADUALI/ RE=MISM3 !RE >E NO DROPS1 %AK+ OR LEAPS40 7,PO9T #d7 .<#f.> ,REF]5CE TO ! ,/AL9-,KHRUS*EV ATTEMPT TO 9CREASE CORN YIELDS4 .<#g.> ,PUBLI%]S ,NOTE -- ,BORDIGA'S USE ( ! T]M 0LABOR TIME0 IS P]HAPS A SLIP ( ! P54 ,BASIC = ,M>X IS ?AT DESPITE ! APPE>ANCE ?AT WORK]S >E PAID = !IR LABOR OR LABOR TIME1 !Y ACTUALLY SELL & RECEIVE PAYM5T = !IR LABOR P[] -- !IR CAPACITY TO LABOR4 ,! VALUE ( ?IS LABOR P[] IS ITS CO/ ( REPRODUCTION3 0! VALUE ( ! MEANS ( SUBSI/5CE NECESS>Y = ! MA9T5ANCE ( ITS [N]40 7,CAPITAL ,VOL4 ,I1 P #b#g#d7 ,:ILE ! WAGE =M GIVES ! APPE>ANCE ?AT ALL A WORK]'S LABOR IS PAID =1 = ,M>X P>T ( WORK]S' LABOR TIME REPRODUCES ! VALUE ( !IR LABOR P[] & IS ?US 0PAID0 -- & ! RE/ ( IT IS SURPLUS TO ?IS & ?US IS 0UNPAID04 7,SEE ,CAPITAL ,VOL4 ,I1 *APT]S #f @& #g7 .<#h.> ,DON ,/URZO3 =M] PRIE/1 LEAD] ( ! CA?OLIC RITY & ! /ATE4 ,9,A 7,I/ITUTO ,NAZIONALE DELLE ,ASSICURAZIONI7 LAUN*$ 9 #aiab TO BECOME ! /ATE MONOPOLY1 LIB]AL OPPOSITION L$ TO IT BE+ MADE 9TO A /ATE BODY BUT MA9TA9+ 0GREAT] AUTONOMY & A MORE /RIK+LY PRIVATE TYPE ( 9T]NAL /RUCTURE ?AN /ATE BODIES0 7,C&ELORO ,/ORIA DELL' ,ITALIA MOD]NA1 ,MILAN1 #a#i#g#d1 ,VOL4 ,V,I,I1 P4 #c#g74 ,IT C\LD !RE=E OP]ATE 9 ! WAY DESCRIB$ 9 ! TEXT4 .<#i.> ,PUBLI%]'S ,NOTE -- ,VANONI WAS ! ,ITALIAN ,M9I/] ( ,F9ANCE ( ! DAY4 .<#a.> ,CF4 FOOTNOTE #h ABOVE4 .<#a#a.> ,CAPITAL ,VOL4 ,I1 P4 #c#b4 ,! F9AL QUOTATION FROM ,GOE!'S ,FAU/1 IS MORE CORRECTLY TRANSLAT$ AS 0AS IF ITS BODY W]E BY LOVE POSSESS$04 ,FROM 3 ,M>XI/S4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,M>* #c1 #bba 3 ,DOCTR9E ( ! ,BODY ,POSSESS$ BY ! ,DEVIL -- ,ADD$4 ,JANU>Y #h1 #bbb 3 ,DOCTR9E ( ! ,BODY ,POSSESS$ BY ! ,DEVIL -- ,UPDAT$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/