,ECONOMICS ( ,DY] ,D4 ,LUM #ahic ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,VOLTAIR9E ,DE ,CLEYRE ,TAGS 3 ECONOMICS ( AN>*Y1 DIVISION ( LABOR1 EQUAL FRE$OM1 LUM1 COMMUNISM1 Y>ROS1 COMMUNI/1 FRE$OM1 LIB]TY1 PRODUCTION4 ,TEXT 3 ,PHOTO BY ,/EVE ,SILV]MAN1,C,C ,B,Y-,N,C-,N,D ,LIC5SE ,IF ,DY] ,D4 ,LUM W]E LIV+ ,I D\BT :E!R ! >TICLES ( ,MR4 ,BLACK1 REC5TLY COPI$ BY ! ,TW5TIE? ,C5TURY FROM ! 0,AU/RALIAN ,WORKMAN10 W\LD ELICIT ANY?+ FUR!R FROM HIM ?AN A HE>TY LAU<4 ,MR4 ,LUM HAD A V]Y KE5 APPRECIATION ( ! LUDICR\S & ! RI*NESS ( BE+ CLASS$ 9 COMPANY ) ,VICTOR ,Y>ROS AS A ,COMMUNI/ W\LD HAVE T\*$ :AT HE CALL$ HIS 0,S5SE ( TICKLETY0 SUFFICI5TLY TO HAVE COMP5SAT$ HIM = BE+ SUBJECT$ TO ! TREATM5T ( SU* A REVIEW]4 ,HE CAN1 9DE$1 WELL AF=D TO BE ACC\NT$ AS 0LACK+ 9 UND]/&+0 BY ?IS 0TURGID & TANGL$0 G5TLEMAN FROM ,NEW ,S\? ,WALES4 ,IT IS BETT] TO BE PRAIS$ BY SU* A CRITIC'S DAMNATION ?AN DAMN$ BY HIS PRAISE4 ,MR4 ,Y>ROS IS ABLE TO SPEAK = HIMSELF1 &1 IF HE DEEM IT WOR? :ILE1 WILL NO D\BT DO SO 9 T]MS :I* MAY CL>IFY ,MR4 ,BLACK'S M9D4 ,I DO NOT PRET5D TO MORE ?AN AV]AGE DISC]NM5T1 NOR DO ,I ?9K MORE IS NECESS>Y1 TO UND]/& ,Y>ROS AS HOLD+ TO ! COMPLETE/ 9DIVIDUALISM CONSONANT ) EQUAL FRE$OM1 BO? AS A POLITICAL & AN ECONOMIC PR9CIPLE4 ,!RE IS A DIFF]5CE BETWE5 ,Y>ROS & ,LUM H[EV]1 AS WILL BE F\ND BY CONTRA/+ ! LATT]'S 0,ECONOMICS ( ,AN>*Y0 ) ! =M]'S WRIT+S 9 0,LIB]TY40 ,& AS !RE >E1 NO D\BT1 MANY READ]S ( ! ,TW5TIE? ,C5TURY :O HAVE NEV] SE5 ! BOOK FROM :I* ,MR4 ,BLACK QUOTES1 ,I %ALL V5TURE TO PO9T \T :]E9 ! DIFF]5CE LIES2 NOT SO MU* = ! PURPOSE ( CLE>+ ,MR4 ,LUM FROM ! *>GE ( 9CONSI/5CY AS %[+ ,MR4 ,BLACK'S 9ABILITY TO DI/+UI% BETWE5 A VITAL ISSUE & A DIV]G5CE RECONCILEABLE ) A COMMON />T+ PO9T4 ,BUT FIR/1 A BRIEF EXPLANATION CONC]N+ ! /YLE ( 0,ECONOMICS ( ,AN>*Y40 ,IT IS1 ADMITT$LY1 NOT AN ,A1 ,B1 ,C BOOK4 ,! LANGUAGE IS HEAVY1 & TO A READ] LIKE ,MR4 ,BLACK MAY V]Y PROBABLY APPE> AS IF 0PLA9] TO ! WRIT] ?AN TO ! READ]40 7,I HAVE A SUSPICION1 9DE$1 ?AT ALL WRIT+S >E SO47 ,BE ?AT AS IT MAY1 9 ! CASE ( ,LUM'S WORK ! CAUSES W]E TWO4 ,9 ! FIR/ PLACE1 F9ANCIAL LIMITS MADE IT IMPOSSIBLE = HIM TO TREAT ( ! SUBJECT AT L5G?1 AS MU* HAD TO BE PACK$ 9TO AS SMALL A COMPASS AS POSSIBLE4 ,! *APT]S ON L& & CAPITAL W]E NECESS>ILY CR[D$ 9TO A FEW PAGES1 & EV]Y S5T5CE WAS 0BOIL$ D[N0 TILL IT WAS ?ICK4 ,! AU?OR WAS COMPELL$ TO DEP5D ON ! READ] = DILUTIONS4 ,9 ! SECOND PLACE1 ,MR4 ,LUM WAS1 ON S]I\S SUBJECTS1 ALWAYS A CONCISE WRIT]4 ,A LIFELONG /UD5T1 HE WAS AS FAMILI> ) JAWBREAK+ T]M9OLOGIES AS MO/ ( US >E ) ! MULTIPLICATION TABLE4 ,& AS ONE TE*NICAL T]M (T5 EXPRESSES PRECISELY :AT HALF A DOZ5 O!R WORDS FAIL TO CONVEY ) EXACTNESS1 HE NATURALLY *OSE ! =M]4 ,I DI/9CTLY REMEMB] HIS REPLY TO ME :5 ,I COMPLA9$ ?AT WORK+ PEOPLE C\LD NOT UND]/& HIM3 0,I CAN'T TALK PHILOSOPHY 9 UNPHILOSOPHIC LANGUAGE--0 7A BRILLIANT BUT %ALL[ ORATOR7 0TRIES TO DO IT & SUCCE$S--BY MAK+ AN ASS ( HIMSELF40 ,SO MU* = ! ALLEG$ TURGIDITY4 ,9 ! S5T5CE 0,ANY ATTEMPT TO 9/ITUTE >TIFICIAL REGULATIONS OV] PRODUCTION1 TO LIMIT ! FREE SCOPE ( 9DIVIDUAL ACTION BY ! ORGANIZATION ( GR\PS 9 :I* SELF-ELECT$ NE$S RA!R ?AN DE$S BECOME ! GOV]N+ PR9CIPLE ( DI/RIBUTION1 IS A VIOLATION ( LOGICAL D$UCTIONS FROM LIB]TY10 TO :I* S5T5CE ,MR4 ,BLACK OBJECTS1 ?AT IT 0BEG9S BY ATTACK+ '>TIFICIAL REGULATION OV] PRODUCTION1' & CONCLUDES BY %[+ ?AT HE WAS REALLY TILT+ AT REGULAT$ DI/RIBUTION10 \R CRITIC SEEMS NOT TO UND]/& ?AT ! SECOND VIOLATION IS NOT GIV5 AS A SEQU5CE ( ! FIR/1 BUT ?AT EI!R ( ! ?+S1 BO? ( :I* >E 9 ! PROGRAM ( GOV]NM5T ,COMMUNISM1 & ! LATT] 9 SOME PHASES ( SO-CALL$ FREE ,COMMUNISM1 >E VIOLATIONS ( LIB]TY4 ,EQUAL FRE$OM6 ,?IS IS ! F\NDATION ROCK ( ! ,9DIVIDUALI/S6 ,& ! S5T5CE QUOT$ MIDS FRE$OM1 BUT T[>DS SOLID>ITY4 ,& 9 ,MR4 ,BLACKS SECOND QUOTATION1 :ILE REGI/]+ HIS PROTE/ AGA9/ ! AU?ORITATIVE 0C5TRAL BUREAU0 ( ,SOCIALISM1 :I* W\LD CREATE SOLID>ITY FROM ! TOP D[N1 HE EXPLA9S H[ SU* SOLID>ITY MI*I/S0 CONSID] ! PRES5T IMM5SE MASS+ ( WORKM5 TOGE!R 9 %OPS & FACTORIES 7A *>ACT]I/IC FEATURE ( \R PRES5T CONDITIONS CON/ANTLY EMPHASIZ$ BY ,SOCIALI/S7 AS AN \TGR[? ( ! 9TRODUCTION ( /EAM P[] & ITS COMPLICAT$ MA*9]Y2 ?AT ! :OLE SY/EM IS !RE=E LIABLE TO BE AGA9 REVOLUTIONIZ$ ! MOM5T /EAM IS SUP]S$$ BY SOME SUP]IOR AG5T1 SAY ELECTRICITY1 :I* CAN BE UTILIZ$ BY ! WORKMAN AT HOME OR 9 SMALL %OPS1 :]E ! SLAV]Y ( ! L>GE FACTORY CAN GIVE PLACE TO ! 9DEP5D5CE ( ! 9DIVIDUAL4 ,?AT ALL =MS ( PRODUCTION >E PASS+ PHASES DEP5D5T UPON CIRCUM/ANCES :I* IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO =ESEE2 & H5CE WISDOM 9 ! MATT] WILL CONT5T ITSELF BY SAY+ LAISSEZ FAIRE4 ,LUM1 H[EV]1 BELIEV$ ?AT ! FACTORY REPRES5T$ NOT ONLY P[] & MA*9]Y BUT DIVISION ( LABOR & AS DIVISION ( LABOR APPE>S AS A CONT9U\S PROCESS 9 ALL ORGANIC LIFE1 FROM PROTI/A UP1 HE C\LD H>DLY CONCEIVE A REV]SAL ( ! LAW 9 ! CASE ( ! SOCIAL ORGANISM4 ,= ?IS REASON HE LAID EMPHASIS UPON ! COM+ SOLIDIFICATION ( 9DU/RY2 & BECAUSE HE DID WAS ACCUS$1 ON ! ONE SIDE1 ( TRUCKL+ TO ,COMMUNI/S1 & ON ! O!R WAS CLAIM$ AS A ,COMMUNI/ AFT] HIS DEA? BY ! V]Y MAN :O DID HIS BE/ TO MANEUV] HIM \T ( ! $ITOR%IP ( ! 0,AL>M0 :ILE LIV+1 BECAUSE ( HIS ,9DIVIDUALISM--,JOHN ,MO/4 ,POSSIBLY ,MR4 ,BLACK MAY CONSID] ?IS CORROBORATIVE ( HIS CLASSIFICATION ( ,LUM AS A ,COMMUNI/2 ,I DO NOT1 H[EV]1 CR$IT ,MO/ ) /UPIDITY4 ,) ! ,MO/IAN EXPOSITION ( ,COMMUNISM1 :I* SIXTE5 DAYS BE=E HIS DEA? HE DECL>$ 0LOGICALLY LEADS TO & RE/S UPON AU?ORITY10 ,LUM MADE NO COMPROMISE4 ,BUT BETWE5 HIS MUTUALISM & ! ,COMMUNISM ( ,KRAPOTK9 ! DIFF]5CE IS NOT ONE ( IRRECONCILABLE BASIS1 BUT *IEFLY ONE ( FAI?4 8,?AT !RE IS A DI/9CT DIFF]5CE BETWE5 GOV]NM5T & SOCIAL ADM9I/RATION1 ?AT ! =M] T5DS ALWAYS TO CRY/ALLIZE EXI/+ =MS1 ?US FA/5+ ON ! LIV+ ! SLAV]Y ( ! DEAD1 :ILE ! LATT] GIVES FREE PLAY TO ALL ! PLA/IC ELEM5TS ( SOCIETY1 CON/ANTLY ADAPT+ & READAPT+ ITSELF TO *ANG+ DEM&S1 IS SOME?+ ,MR4 ,BLACK EVID5TLY DOES NOT SEE1 BUT :I* ,MR4 ,LUM DID4 ,H5CE HIS 0BO>DS ( ADM9I/RATION10 *OS5 BY 0NATURAL SELECTION10 NOT MAJORITY VOTE1 HAV+ JURISDICTION ONLY OV] AFFILIAT$ 9DU/RIES1 9 NO WISE M$DL+ ) AFFAIRS !Y DO NOT UND]/&1 & 9 NO WISE 5=C+ !IR DECISIONS1 EV5 )9 !IR LIMITS1 BY LEGAL P5ALTIES4 ,KRAPOTK9'S ILLU/RATIONS 9 HIS 0,AN>*I/ ,COMMUNISM >E V]Y MU* 9 PO9T4 ,9 CONCLUSION1 MY 9T5TION HAS BE5 TO %[ ,MR ,BLACK'S 9COMPET5CY TO CRITICIZE ,MR4 ,LUM4 ,?AT HE IS EQUALLY 9COMPET5T TO CRITICIZE ! O!R ,AN>*I/S QUOT$ C\LD BE EASILY DEMON/RAT$4 ,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahib 3 ,ECONOMICS ( ,DY] ,D4 ,LUM -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,M>* #c1 #bai 3 ,ECONOMICS ( ,DY] ,D4 ,LUM -- ,ADD$4 ,JANU>Y #c1 #bbb 3 ,ECONOMICS ( ,DY] ,D4 ,LUM -- ,UPDAT$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/