,FI ,F,R,F,I ,IT SEEMS D\BLY IRONIC ?AT Y\ 5TITL$ Y\R RANT AGA9/ AN>*ISM 0! AN>*I/ S*OOL ( FALSIFICATION0 7ISSUE NO4 #a#g#d74 ,FIR/LY1 ?IS RANT WAS FALSELY PRES5T$ AS A REVIEW ( AN AN>*I/ PAMPHLET &1 SECONDLY1 ! >TICLE WAS ITSELF RIDDL$ ) FALSEHOODS4 ,IT CLAIMS ?AT 0MO/ AN>*I/S HAVE LITTLE KN[L$GE0 ( !IR [N HI/ORY1 !N TALKS AB\T ,KROPOTK9 & ! SYNDICALI/ ,J\HAUX SUPPORT+ ! ALLIES 9 ! ,FIR/ ,WORLD ,W>4 ,BO? !SE FACTS >E CONTA9$ 9 ! PAMPHLET Y\ CLAIM TO BE REVIEW+6 ,KROPOTK9 IS ON PAGE #ai & PAGE #ab TALKS AB\T ! BETRAYAL ( ! ,FR5* ,C,G,T LEAD]%IP4 ,PRESUMABLY ! PAMPHLET 0FALSIFIES0 HI/ORY BY 9=M+ ITS READ]S ! FACTS Y\ IMPLY WE 0CLOAK08 ,H[ DI%ONE/4 ,!N1 ( C\RSE1 Y\ FAIL TO M5TION ?AT :ILE ,KROPOTK9 & ,J\HAUX SUPPORT$ ! W>1 ! VA/ MAJORITY ( AN>*I/S DID NOT4 ,MALATE/A1 ,B]KMAN1 ,GOLDMAN & ,ROCK]1 = EXAMPLE1 OPPOS$ ,KROPOTK9'S POSITION & TOOK A 0NO W> BUT ! CLASS W>0 L9E4 ,P]HAPS Y\R REVIEW] DID NOT M5TION ?IS FACT BECAUSE HE WAS FELT GUILTY ?AT :ILE ! BULK ( ! PRE-W> ,M>XI/ MOVEM5T SUPPORT$ !IR GOV]NM5TS 9 ! W>1 ALMO/ ALL AN>*I/S DID NOT8 ,! DI%ONE/Y IS1 YET AGA91 CLE>4 ,MOREOV]1 GIV5 ?AT ! REVIEW] IS KE5 TO PRES5T ,M>XI/ ANTI-IMP]IALI/ CR$5TIALS1 IT SEEMS /RANGE ?AT HE GOES NOT NOTE ,M>X'S OP9ION1 AT ! />T ( ! ,FRANCO-,PRUSSIAN W>1 ?AT ! 0,FR5* NE$ A ?RA%+10 9 P>T BECAUSE ,PRUSSIA'S 0DOM9ATION OV] ! ,FR5* ON ! WORLD /AGE W\LD MEAN LIKEWISE ! DOM9ANCE ( \R !ORY OV] ?AT ( ,PR\DHON1 ETC40 ,SIGNIFICANTLY1 IT WAS ,BAKUN9 :O RAIS$ ! IDEA ( TURN+ ! IMP]IALI/ W> 9TO A REVOLUTION>Y W> JU/1 AS BE=E1 HE RAIS$ ! BANN] ( NATIONAL LIB]ATION AGA9/ IMP]IALI/ DOM9ATION :ILE ,M>X & ,5GELS OPPOS$ MANY SU* MOVEM5TS4 ,SPACE EXCLUDES REPLY+ TO ! MANY O!R DI/ORTIONS & D[NRITICLE 0,AGA9/ ,W> & ,CAPITALISM0 DOES NOT 0D5Y ! EXI/5CE ( IMP]IALISM10 AS CLAIM$4 ,RA!R1 IT ATTACKS ! IDEOLOGY ( 0ANTI-IMP]IALISM10 :I* IS NOT ! SAME ?+4 ,SIMIL>LY1 ITS COMM5T ON 0ANTI-IMP]IALI/S0 SUPPORT+ ! ,TALIBAN IS OBVI\SLY A REF]5CE TO ! W> AGA9/ ,AF 9 ! #a#i#hS 7:]E 0ANTI-IMP]IALI/S0 LIKE ! ,R,C,G SUPPORT$ ! 0PROGRESSIVE0 IMP]IALISM ( ! ,U,S,S,R74 ,= ! REVIEW] TO /ATE 0,?IS IS A LIE60 IS SIMPLY TO LIE HIMSELF4 ,AS = ! ,SPANI% REVOLUTION1 WELL1 !RE CAN BE NO AN>*I/S :O DO NOT KN[ ?AT ! ,C,N,T LEAD]%IP JO9$ ! GOV]NM5T -- ALL !Y HAVE TO DO IS READ ! NUM]\S AN>*I/ WORKS EXPLA9+ :Y ?IS HAPP5$ & :Y IT WAS A MI/AKE4 ,H[EV]1 ! GREATE/ LIE IS ! AU?OR'S ASS]TION ?AT ! ,MAKHNOVI/S 0JO9$ ! C\NT]-REVOLUTION>Y ,:ITE & IMP]IALI/ >MIES0 & 0C>RI$ \T POGROMS AGA9/ ,JEWI% COMMUNITIES40 ,MAK+ SU* A CLAIM IS1 TRULY1 TO FALSIFY HI/ORY4 ,LITTLE WOND] !RE IS NO ATTEMPT TO PROVIDE SU* S]I\S ASS]TIONS ) ANY SORT ( EVID5CE -- = !RE IS NONE4 ,DID ! ,MAKHNOVI/S JO9 ! ,:ITES8 ,F> FROM IT4 ,M>XI/ ,VICTOR ,S]GE NOT$ ! 0/R5U\S CALUMNIES PUT \T BY ! ,COMMUNI/ ,P>TY0 AGA9/ ,MAKHNO 0:I* W5T SO F> AS TO ACCUSE HIM ( SIGN+ PACTS ) ! ,:ITES AT ! V]Y MOM5T :5 HE WAS 5GAG$ 9 A LIFE-&-DEA? /RUGGLE AGA9/ !M40 7,MEMOIRS ( A ,REVOLUTION>Y74 ,SOME ?+S NEV] *ANGE4 ,AS = BE+ POGROMI/S1 ?IS CLAIM IS JU/ AS FALSE4 ,! ,MAKHNOVI/S CONTA9$ NUM]\S ,JEWI% AN>*I/S AS WELL AS VOLUNTE] FITILL]Y BATT]Y & 9FANTRY DETA*M5T74 ,AFT] ! W>1 ,JEWI% AN>*I/S LIKE ,ALEX&] ,B]KMAN1 ,EMMA ,GOLDMAN1 ,%OLEM ,S*W>TZB>D1 ,VOL9E1 ,S5YA ,FLE%91 & ,MOLLIE ,/EIM] DID NOT CRITICIZE ,MAKHNO AS AN ANTI-,SEMITE & DEF5D$ HIM AGA9/ SU* CLAIMS4 ,SIGNIFICANTLY1 ,S*W>TZB>D ASSASS9AT$ ! ,UKRA9IAN ,NATIONALI/ LEAD] ,PETLIURA 9 #aibf BECAUSE HE CONSID]$ HIM RESPONSIBLE = POGROMS DUR+ ! CIVIL W>4 ,HE %OT ,PETLIURA ! DAY AFT] HE1 ,MAKHNO & ,B]KMAN HAD SE5 HIM AT A ,RUSSIAN RE/AURANT 9 ,P>IS4 ,TURN+ TO ,VOL9E1 AN ACTIVE P>TICIPANT 9 ! ,MAKHNOVI/S 7:5 NOT UND] >RE/ BY ! ,BOL%EVIKS71 WE F9D HIM QUOT+ ! EM95T ,JEWI% HI/ORIAN ,M4 ,T*]IKOV] AB\T ! QUE/ION ( ! ,MAKHNOVI/S & ANTI-,SEMITISM4 ,AN EXP]T ON !SE MATT]S1 ,T*]IKOV] /AT$ 0IT IS UND5IABLE ?AT1 ( ALL !SE >MIES1 9CLUD+ ! ,R$ ,>MY1 ! ,MAKHNOVI/S BEHAV$ BE/ ) REG>D ! CIVIL POPULATION 9 G5]AL & ! ,JEWI% POPULATION 9 P>TICUL>40 ,MOREOV]1 0DO NOT SPEAK ( POGROMS ALLEG$ TO HAVE BE5 ORGANIZ$ BY ,MAKHNO HIMSELF4 ,?AT IS A SL&] OR AN ]ROR4 ,NO?+ ( ! SORT OCCURR$4 ,AS = ! ,MAKHNOVI/ ,>MY 444 .OT ONCE HAVE ,I BE5 ABLE TO PROVE ! EXI/5CE ( A ,MAKHNOVI/ UNIT AT ! PLACE A POGROM AGA9/ ! ,JEWS TOOK PLACE4 ,CONSEQU5TLY1 ! POGROMS 9 QUE/ION C\LD NOT HAVE BE5 ! WORK ( ! ,MAKHNOVI/S40 7,VOL9E1 ,! ,UNKN[N ,REVOLUTION7 ,! LIE ?AT ! ,MAKHNOVI/S W]E POGROMI/S IS COMMON 9 ,M>XI/ CIRCLES4 ,:Y8 ,LET ME QUOTE ANO!R ,JEWI% AN>*I/S ACTIVE 9 ! MOVEM5T 7&1 LIKE SO MANY O!RS1 %OT BY ! ,BOL%EVIKS74 ,TALK+ TO ,B]KMAN1 ,YOSSIF ! ,EMIGRANT /AT$ ?AT 0,NE/OR IS M]CILESS T[>D ?OSE GUILTY ( ,JEW-BAIT+4 ,MO/ ( Y\ HAVE READ HIS NUM]\S PROCLAMATIONS AGA9/ POGROMS1 & Y\ KN[ H[ SEV]ELY HE PUNI%ES SU* ?+S40 ,HE /RESS$ ?AT ANY /ORIES ( ATROCITIES & POGROMS COMMITT$ BY ! ,MAKHNOVI/S W]E 0LIES WILLFULLY SPREAD BY ! ,BOL%EVIKS0 :O 0HATE ,NE/OR WORSE ?AN !Y DO ,WRANGEL40 ,= ,YOSSIF1 0,MAKHNO REPRES5TS ! REAL SPIRIT ( ,OCTOB]40 7,! ,BOL%EVIK ,MY?7 ,MAKHNO REPRES5T$ ! DREAM ( ! ,RUSSIAN REVOLUTION 7SOVIET DEMOCRACY1 SOCIALISM1 WORK]S' CONTROL7 :ILE ! ,BOL%EVIKS REPRES5T$ ITS NIE 7P>TY DICTATOR%IP1 /ATE CAPITALISM1 CONTROLL$ WORK]S74 ,NO WOND] ,M>XI/S1 !N & N[1 HATE & SL&] HIM4 ,!N !RE IS ! /RANGE 9CLUSION ( ,PR\DHON 9 ! DIATRIBE4 ,YES1 AN>*I/S KN[ HE WAS SEXI/ & RACI/ & WE ALL REJECT !SE ASPECTS ( HIS IDEAS4 ,SO TO M5TION HIM SUGGE/S ?AT ! 0REVIEW]0 RAN \T ( IDEAS & IS AS IRRELEVANT TO A CRITIQUE ( AN>*ISM AS M5TION+ ! RACISM & HOMOPHOBIA (1 SAY1 ,5GELS4 ,OR1 P]HAPS1 ,M>XI/S 7LIKE ,5GELS7 CONSID] ,MEXICANS 0LAZY0 & SUPPORT ,U,S IMP]IALISM AGA9/ !M8 ,OR CONSID] ?AT PEOPLES DOM9AT$ BY O!R C\NTRIES %\LD 0GRATEFUL0 ?AT ! IMP]IALI/ NATION HAS 0TAK5 ! TR\BLE TO CIVILIZE !M0 7AS ,5GELS DID AS REG>DS ! ,G]MANS & ,SLAVS74 ,OR1 LIKE ,5GELS1 SEE A POSITIVE SIDE TO G5OCIDE 7AS 0! ,AU/RIAN ,G]MANS & ,MAGY>S WILL BE SET FREE & WRECK A BLOODY REV5GE ON ! ,SLAV B>B>IANS4 ,! G5]AL W> :I* WILL !N BREAK \T WILL 444 WIPE \T ALL !SE PETTY HIDEB\ND NATIONS1 D[N TO !IR V]Y NAMES 444 .<& ?IS W>.> WILL RESULT 9 ! DISAPPE>ANCE FROM ! FACE ( ! E>? 4444 ( 5TIRE REACTION>Y PEOPLES4 ,& ?AT1 TOO1 IS A /EP =W>D07 ,BUT1 !N AGA91 = ,M>XI/S RACISM AGA9/ ,SLAVS IS USUALLY NOT WOR?Y ( NOTE4 ,:AT AB\T ,BLACKS8 ,WELL1 ,M>X WAS ( ! OP9ION ?AT 0! MA9 /OCK ( . ,NEGROES 9 ,JAMAICA ALWAYS CONSI/$ ( FRE%LY IMPORT$ B>B>IANS 444 .<:ILE.> ! PRES5T G5]ATION ( ,NEGROES 9 ,AM]ICA IS A NATIVE PRODUCT1 MORE OR LESS ,YANKEEFI$1 ,5GLI% SPEAK+1 ETC41 & H5CE CAPABLE ( BE+ EMANCIPAT$40 ,OBVI\SLY1 ONLY :ITES HAVE A VALID CULTURE & HAVE ! DUTY TO BR+ UP ! LESS =TUNATE 9 !IR [N IMAGE4 ,P]HAPS ?IS EXPLA9S ,M>X & ,5GELS SUPPORT = 0PROGRESSIVE0 IMP]IALISM 9 SO MANY NON-CAPITALI/ NATIONS8 ,BUT ALL ?AT IS AS IRRELEVANT AS ,PR\DHON'S RACISM & SEXISM4 ,ANY S]I\S CRITIQUE ( ,M>XISM W\LD />T ) ! POSITIONS HELD BY MOD]N ,M>XI/S1 NOT ! P]SONAL FAIL+S ( ! LIKES ( ,M>X & ,5GELS4 ,?AT ! REVIEW] SIMPLY ATTACKS ! FAIL+S ( 9DIVIDUAL AN>*I/S & SL&]S O!RS %[S ?AT HE IS UNABLE TO CRITIQUE AN>*ISM AS A !ORY & AS A MOVEM5T4 ,IF HE C\LD1 HE W\LD NOT HAVE TO SWOOP TO P]SONAL ATTACKS1 REPEAT LIES &1 D>E ,I SAY1 FALSIFY HI/ORY4 ,I'M SORRY ?AT ?IS LETT] IS SO LONG4 ,LY+ TAKES LITTLE SPACE1 REFUT+ LIES TAKES MU* MORE4 ,I HOPE ?AT Y\ DO NOT USE ! L5G? ( ?IS LETT] AS AN EXCUSE NOT TO PR9T IT4 ,AFT] ALL1 Y\ W\LD NOT WANT TO KEEP Y\R READ]S 9 ! SAME IGNORANCE Y\ CLAIM ! AN>*I/ 0LEAD]%IP0 IMPOSES ON O!R AN>*I/S1 W\LD Y\8 ,BUT1 LOOK+ AT 0,! ,AN>*I/ ,S*OOL ( ,FALSIFICATION0 REVIEW1 ,I HAVE MY D\BTS Y\ W\LD HAVE ! HONE/Y & REVOLUTION>Y PR9CIPLES TO PUBLI% MY LETT]4 ,I HOPE Y\ WILL PROVE ME WRONG1 BUT ,I WILL NOT HOLD MY BREA?4 Y\RS 9 DISGU/1 ,IA9 ,MC,KAY ,SECOND ,LETT] ,DE> ,F,R,F,I ,I SEE Y\R FALSIFICATION ( HI/ORY KN[S NO B\NDS4 ,G]MAN GIVE AS REF]5CES TO ! ASS]TION ?AT ! ,MAKHNOVI/S W]E POGROMI/S TWO REF]5CES4 ,USUALLY1 ) REF]5CES1 Y\ PROVIDE BOOK TITLES & PAGE NUMB]S4 ,IT IS OBVI\S :Y ?IS WAS NOT DONE BY ,JIMMY ,G]MAN AS ! REF]5CES HE GIVES DO NOT SUPPORT HIS ASS]TIONS4 ,LOOK+ AT ! FIR/ ONE 7UNNAM$1 BUT :I* ,I TAKE AS ,E4,H4 ,C>R'S 0,! ,BOL%EVIK ,REVOLUTION071 !RE IS NO REF]5CE TO POGROMS C>RI$ \T BY ! ,MAKHNOVI/S 7LOOK+ 9 ! 9DEX = 0,MAKHNO074 ,P]HAPS ,G]MAN C\LD 5LI AS ! SECOND ONE GOES1 ,AVRI* DOES NOT M5TION IT 9 0,! ,AN>*I/S 9 ! ,RUSSIAN ,REVOLUTION0 7HE ADDRESSES ! ISSUE 9 0,AN>*I/ ,PORTRAITS10 CONCLUD+ SU* *>GES >E FALSE74 ,SO ,G]MAN IS EXPOS$ AS A LAIR 7YET AGA91 -- SEE ! UNPUBLI%$ LETT] ,I S5T TO ,F,R,F,I BE=E74 ,G]MAN COMPLA9S ?AT ! ,MAKHNOVI/S CALL+ UPON ,R$ ,>MY TROOPS TO DES]T WAS 0AN ACT ( W>40 ,YET ?IS CALL WAS MADE 9 ,JUNE #a#i#b1 AFT] ! ,BOL%EVIKS HAD ATTACK$ ! ,MAKHNOVI/S SIX MON?S BE=E1 AFT] ! LATT] HAD PLAY$ ! KEY ROLE 9 DEFEAT+ ,D5IK94 ,?IS ,BOL%EVIK CREAT$ CONFLICT1 9CID5TALLY1 5C\RAG$ ! ,:ITES UND] ,WRANGEL TO R5EW !IR ATTACK 7SO MU* = ! ,R$ ,>MY 0DEF5D+0 AGA9/ 0IMP]IALI/ 9VASION0674 ,HE ALSO COMPLA9S ?AT ! ,MAKHNOVI/ LEAFLETS CANNOT BE CONSID]$ AS 0AN EXAMPLE ( ANTI-MILIT>ISM40 ,?IS IGNORES ! FACT ?AT ! ,R$ ,>MY WAS ID5TICAL TO A CAPITALI/ MILIT>Y MA*9E1 BAS$ ON (FIC]S APPO9T$ FROM ABOVE & US$ TO CRU% WORK+ CLASS RESI/ANCE TO ! 7NEW7 BOSS CLASS4 ,R$ MILIT>ISM IS /ILL MILIT>ISM & A ?REAT TO ! LIB]TY ( ! MASSES4 ,HE !N /ATES ?AT ! ,MAKHNOVI/S W]E 0BRIG&S0 & ?AT 0!Y LIV$ (F PLUND]40 ,R>ELY DO 0BRIG&S0 PROCLAIM SOCIO-POLITICAL IDEALS & AIMS1 YET ! ,MAKHNOVI/S DID JU/ ?AT4 ,!Y PROCLAIM$ & IMPLEM5T$ FREE SOVIETS1 SOCIALIZATION & SELF-MANAGEM5T :ILE ! ,BOL%EVIKS PROCLAIM$ & IMPLEM5T$ P>TY DICTATOR%IP1 /ATE CONTROL & ONE-MAN MANAGEM5T4 ,G]MAN'S COMM5T IS1 MOREOV]1 DEEPLY IRONIC1 GIV5 ?AT ! ,BOL%EVIK REGIME 0LIV$ (F PLUND]40 ,!Y PLUND]$ ! PEASANTS CROPS BY >M$ =CE4 ,!Y ALSO PLUND]$ ! WORK]S1 /EAL+ BO? !IR MEANS ( PRODUCTION & ! PRODUCT ( !IR LABOR 7BY NATIONALIZATION & APPO9T+ ONE-MAN MANAGEM5T ) 0DICTATORIAL0 P[]S74 ,! ,BOL%EVIKS ULTIMATE ACT ( PLUND] WAS1 ( C\RSE1 /EAL+ ! REVOLUTION FROM ! ,RUSSIAN MASSES4 ,GIV5 ?IS1 ! ,MAKHNOVI/S APPE> 9 A GOOD LIMY74 ,YET !IR RELATIONS TO ! PEASANTRY W]E EXCELL5T 7UNLIKELY1 IF !Y W]E 0BRIG&S07 & LOOT]S W]E %OT 7,MAKHNO OPPOS$ LOOT+ FROM ! />T1 9CID5TALLY74 ,SO TO ASS]T ?AT ! ,MAKHNOVI/S W]E 0BRIG&S0 IS A LIE1 PURE & SIMPLE4 ,MOREOV]1 ,G]MAN'S LOGIC SEEMS /RANGE4 ,PRESUMABLY1 HE W\LD HAVE PREF]R$ ! ,MAKHNOVI/S TO FIMY WAS NOT 0DEF5D+ ! FL$GL+ ,SOVIET SOCIALI/ /ATE10 IT WAS DEF5D+ ! P>TY DICTATOR%IP OV] ! SOVIETS1 DEF5D+ /ATE CAPITALISM AGA9/ SOCIALISM4 ,HE >GUES ?AT 0AN>*I/ POLITICS0 >E 0EXPOS$0 AS 0RADICAL LIB]ALISM1 ) NO CLASS CONT5T :ATSOEV]40 ,! OPPOSITE IS ! CASE4 ,AN>*I/ OPPOSITION TO ,BOL%EVIK TYRANNY WAS BAS$ ON CLE> CLASS L9ES1 RESI/+ A NEW SET ( 0R$0 BOSSES LORD+ IT OV] ! WORK]S4 ,AS ! ,MAKHNOVI/S PO9T$ \T 9 !IR PROPAG&A4 ,G]MAN'S FALSIFICATION ( HI/ORY 79 ! BE/ ,/AL9I/ FA%ION7 %[S ?AT IT IS ,L59ISM :I* HAS NO WORK+ CLASS CONT5T4 ,ONCE 9 P[]1 IT QUICKLY BECAME ! 0DICTATOR%IP OV] ! PROLET>IAT0 -- 5=C$ BY ! MILIT>IZ$ ,R$ ,>MY & SECRET POLICE & DEF5D$ TO ?IS DAY BY ! LIKES ( ,G]MAN4 ,H5CE ,G]MAN'S FALSIFICATIONS1 LIES & DI/ORTIONS -- AN HONE/ ACC\NT ( AN>*ISM W\LD MAKE HIS READ]S QUE/ION ,L59ISM & ITS CLAIMS TO /& = WORK+ CLASS LIB]TY & P[]4 Y\RS 9 DISGU/1 ,IA9 ,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,FEBRU>Y #b1 #bba 3 ,FIY #g1 #bbb 3 ,FI