,HOLD ,Y\R ,TONGUE ,DEMAGOGUE 
,TURN+ ,A ,DEAF ,E> ,TO ,PURE ,BUFE-OON]Y 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,LAWR5CE ,J>A* 

,TEXT 3 

,WE DON'T KN[ AB\T Y\ BUT :5 SOMEONE COMM&S US TO DO SOME?+1 !RE'S AN 9T]NAL SUBJECTIVE ME*ANISM ?AT IMM$IATELY TURNS D[N ! VOLUME4 ,?IS WORKS NICELY 9 GETT+ ?R\< A DAY AT WORK OR :5 CONFRONT$ BY DEMAGOGUES1 UNTIL ! D9 GETS TO A C]TA9 %RILL PIT*1 !N WE REACT RA!R ?AN TURN A DEAF E> -- ESPECIALLY :5 ASPECTS ( ! RANT HAVE TO DO ) US P]SONALLY OR FRI5DS4 

,DEMAGOGUES1 LIKE BOSSES1 >E NOT 9T]E/$ 9 %>+ & CONTRA/+ !IR ?\<TS & FEEL+S ) PEOPLE !Y M]ELY WANT TO CLUB !M 9TO L9E ) !IR [N4 ,ALONG ! WAY !Y DEVELOP AN >CANE J>GON -- SOMETIMES ) COMMON WORDS -- 9 ORD] TO DAZZLE & MY/IFY ! UNCRITICAL4 ,SO IT IS ) ,*AZ ,BUFE 9 HIS REC5T PAMPHLET1 ,LI/51 ,AN>*I/6 7,L1,A74 ,?IS TRACT C\LD HAVE BE5 SUBTITL$ 0,FROM ,BOOK*9 TO ,L59 7OR ,MOSES70 S9CE HE BORR[S ELEM5TS ( /YLE FROM ALL ?REE4 ,9 ! 5D HE TELLS PEOPLE :AT !Y MU/ DO TO SUCCE$ AS A C]TA9 EXCLUSIVE CATEGORY ( HUMAN -- AN>*I/4 

,A NUMB] ( PEOPLE :O BEGAN RESPONSES TO ,BUFE'S DIATRIBE DECID$ IT JU/ WASN'T WOR? ! EF=T4 ,O!RS1 NOTABLY ,FIF? ,E/ATE1 FELT ?AT HIS PAMPHLET WAS 0COM$IC P>ODY ( AU?ORIT>IAN AN>*ISM40 ,!IR REACTIONS >E QUITE JU/IFIABLE & WE ALSO HAVE ! CONC]N ?AT RESPOND+ GIVES MORE CR$5CE ?AN IS DUE TO AN O!RWISE N>R[M9D$ TRACT4 ,?IS RESPONSE IS LONG] ?AN ,L1,A PRIM>ILY BECAUSE WE ?\<T IT NECESS>Y TO DEAL ) HIS OMISSIONS1 DI/ORTIONS1 & FALSIFICATIONS ( SPECIFIC EV5TS1 AS WELL AS1 TO TRY TO COV] ! G5]AL TOPICS MORE ?OR\<LY ?AN ! SIMPLI/IC WAY 9 :I* HE DOES SO4 

,L1,A'S AU?OR SEEMS TO BE AN ANGRY & BITT] GUY ) LITTLE OR NO S5SE ( HUMOR OR IRONY 7MAYBE IT'S ! COMPANY HE KEEPS7 :O SAYS HE IS CONC]N$ AB\T CR$IBILITY 7= AN>*I/S & AN>*ISM71 SCI5CE1 RATIONALITY1 & AGA9/ M>G9ALISM1 OBSCURANTISM1 ABUSE ( T]MS1 SECT>IANISM1 MY/ICISM 444 BUT :O FAILS TO SET A V]Y GOOD EXAMPLE RI<T (F4 ,WELL1 JU/ BECAUSE ,*AZ IS NO FUN DOESN'T I MEAN WE CAN'T BE4 

,ON ,PURE ,BUFE-OON]Y 

,= SOMEONE :O 9SI/S ?AT 0,WE 7SIC7 %\LD TAKE GREAT C>E 444 TO EMPLOY SIMPLE1 CLE> LANGUAGE0 & :O ?9KS ?AT 0USE ( AB/RACTIONS %\LD BE AVOID$0 ,BUFE HAS MADE HIS PAMPHLET RIFE ) AMBIGU\S WORDS4 ,:ILE ! LANGUAGE MAY BE SIMPLE1 HIS USE ! FOLL[+ T]MS 9 ! CONTEXT ( ,L1,A IS V]Y UNCLE> S9CE HE REFUS$ TO DEF9E !M3 ,AN>*ISM2 ,M>G9ALIZATION2 ,WORK2 ,TE*NOLOGY2 ,MY/ICISM2 ,VIOL5CE2 & TOO MANY MORE TO TAKE UP SPACE DISPUT+4 

,! FACT ?AT !RE IS NOT EV5 A M9IMUM DEF9ITION ( AN>*ISM1 ! PRACTITION]S ( :I* HE IS SUPPOS$LY DIRECT+ HIS COMM5TS AT1 IS A CONSPICU\S OMISSION4 ,HE NEV] BO!RS TO DEF9E ?IS CATEGORY'S FUNDAM5TAL ELEM5TS AS HE UND]/&S !M LET ALONE H[ O!RS >\ND HIM DO4 ,?IS UND]L9ES ,*AZ'S MO/ OBVI\S FAILURE -- ?R\<\T HIS TRACT HE FAILS TO DEF9E HIS T]MS :ILE RANT+ AB\T O!RS' ALLEG$ FAILURE TO DO ! SAME4 

,ONE WORK+-DEF9ITION ( AN>*ISM MI<T BE ?AT IT IS AN OPPOSITION TO ALL =MS ( CO]CION & AU?ORITY4 LN FACT1 ?AT IS ONE DICTION>Y DEF9ITION4 ,BUT DICTION>Y DEF9ITIONS >E NEV] ADEQUATE 444 ,A SLI<TLY DIFF]5T VIEW ON ! T]M WAS PROVID$ BY A ,POLI% SYMPA?IZ]_/CRITIC ( AN>*ISM :O VISIT$ ,B\ND ,TOGE!R LA/ YE> & SAID ?AT AN>*ISM IS JU/ ANO!R SY/EM1 & ,HECTOR ,SUBIRATS1 A ,MEXICAN SYMP_/CRIT_/AU?OR1 :O F9I%$ ! ?\<T YE>S E>LI] :5 HE SAID ?AT HE WAS NOT = AN>*ISM BUT = AN>*Y4 

,:Y A S]I\S ANTI-AU?ORIT>IAN REBELLI\S CULTURE HAS ,DOT BE5 SU/A9$ 9 ! WORLD AT L>GE & ! ,U4,S4 9 P>TICUL> IS WOR?Y ( SOME 9VE/IGATION4 ,:Y ! PROSYLITIZ]S ( ,AN>*ISM HAVE NOT TAK5 ! C\NTRY BY /ORM IS ( SOME:AT LESS 9T]E/4 LN ANY CASE1 ,*AZ SEEMS TO MISS ! M>K CONSID]ABLY4 

,AS F> AS CR$IBILITY GOES HE BEG9S HIS TRACT TALK+ AB\T ,NOR? ,AM]ICAN AN>*I/S BUT LAT] /ATES ?AT HE IS REALLY SPEAK+ ONLY ( ,CANADA & ! ,U4,S4 =GETT+ ,MEXICO4 ,:E!R ?IS WAS PURPOSEFUL OR :E!R HE =GOT ,MEXICO IS P>T ( ,NOR? ,AM]ICA IS NOT CLE>4 ,IF IT'S ! LATT] :AT HAPP5S TO HIS CR$IBILITY AS A SOMEONE 9VOLV$ 9 0L4AT9 ,AM]ICAN SOLID>ITY WORK0 7& :AT0S ?AT MEAN ANYWAY874 

,?AT ,*AZ HASN'T COME TO T]MS ) HIS [N IRRATIONALITY IS REFLECT$ 9 HIS HYPOCRITICAL PSEUDONOM9\S CONTACTS ) ,FIF? ,E/ATE BECAUSE HE WAS 0AFRAID ( :AT !IR RESPONSE W\LD BE0 IF HE US$ HIS REAL NAME AFT] HE WROTE TO !M ASS]T+ HE NO LONG] WANT$ TO DEAL ) !M2 LET ALONE HIS T5D5CY T[>D SECT>IANISM REFLECT$ 9 HIS [N DISMISSIVE CONTEMPT & CONDEMNATION (O!RS APP>5TLY NOT SO GIFT$ AS HIMSELF2 HIS REWRITE ( SIMPLE LOCAL HI/ORY ) HALF-TRU?S & PURE DI/ORTIONS2 ALL ( HIS CONTRADICTORY APPEALS TO HI<] AU?ORITY 70,OH ,GOD60 IS A FREQU5T ONE = ?IS AV[$ A!I/72 & HIS ,OLD ,TE/AM5T ,AN>*ISM REFLECT$ 9 HIS ,T5 ,COMM&M5TS & HIS COMPULSIVE QUOT+ ( CORPSES TO VALIDATE HIS POSITION -- :ATEV] IT IS 4444 ,*AZ BR+S UP S]I\S MATT]S1 TOO BAD HE FAILS TO DISCUSS !M S]I\SLY -- WE WILL TRY TO REM$Y ?AT4 

,M>G97AL7 ,COMM5TS ,O,N ,M,A,9,/,R,E,A,M ,A,S,P,I,R,A,T,I,O,N,S 

,HIS FIR/ SECTION PROMISES TO BE AB\T M>G9ALIZATION BUT HE NEV] DOES PROVIDE ANY?+ REMOTELY RESEMBL+ A DEF9ITION ( :AT 0DELIB]ATE SELF4M>G9ALIZATION0 IS 9 ?IS SECTION & PROVIDES ONLY ! B>E/ \TL9E ( :AT HE ?9KS IT IS4 ,!SE H9TS >E ?AT ?IS 9VOLVES A P]SON ON WELF>E 7PRACTIC+ 0P>ASITISM0 :I* HE !N SAYS IS NOT TO BE CON/RU$ AS AN ATTACK ON WELF>E RECIPI5TS -- OH YEAH87 :O ES*EWS WORK 7& WORK]S7 & :O IS ANTI-ORGANIZATIONAL4 ,MU* MORE ?AN ?AT WE WILL NOT LE>N 9 ?IS PAMPHLET4 LT IS MU* MU* TOO EASY TO PICK ON /RAW M5 & WOM5 ?AN DEAL ) REAL P]SONALITIES S9CE IT TURNS \T MU* ( :AT HE ATTRIBUTES TO 0M>G9AL0 TYPES IS ADVOCAT$ BY PEOPLE HE WAS ONCE FRI5DS ) MO/ ( :OM ALSO HAPP5 TO WORK -- AS IF ?AT MATT]S4 

,UNTIL ,*AZ1 POP SOCIOLOGI/S HAVE T5D$ TO REF] TO PEOPLE AS M>G9AL :O *OSE TO LEAVE ! UPW>D MOBILITY RAT-RACE :I* (T5 MEANS WORK+ 0BEL[0 :AT !IR TRA9+ & $UCATION W\LD 9DICATE4 ,EV5 ?IS VALIDITY ( ?IS DEF9ITION IS >GUABLE S9CE IS NO REAL M>G9ALITY TO SOCIETY O!R ?AN ACTUAL WILD]NESS LIV+ & CAV$WELL+4 

,I 7,LAWR5CE7 %>E A CONC]N ) :AT ,*AZ CALLS ! 0M>G9ALIZ$ MILIEU40 ,I W\LD CONSID] 0M>G9AL ELEM5TS0 TO 9CLUDE ! FOLL[+3 >TI/S1 MUSICIANS1 POETS1 WRIT]S 444 Y\R BASIC BOHEMIANS4 ,!Y PUT !MSELVES ON ! 0M>G9S0 7\TSIDE ! 0MA9/REAM07 ( SOCIETY BECAUSE !Y SEE MAJOR CONTRADICTIONS BETWE5 !IR DESIRES & ! REALITY ?AT HUNDR$S ( YE>S ( ,WE/]N CULTURAL 9]TIA HAS PRES5T$ TO !M4 ,SOME PREF] NOT TO WORK2 SOME WORK DESPITE !IR DESIRE TO RE/RUCTURE IMM$IATELY ! PREMISES ( LABOR2 SOME DON'T NE$ TO WORK4 ,MANY 0M>G9ALIZ$0 9DIVIDUALS EV5TUALLY BECOME 0MA9/REAM0 :5 !Y REALIZE ?AT !IR ACTIVITIES CANNOT1 BY !MSELVES1 FOM5T ! RADICAL *ANGES ?AT !Y DESIRE4 0,M>G9ALIZ$0 PEOPLE HAVE EXI/$ ?R\<\T HI/ORY & WILL CONT9UE TO EXI/ SO LONG AS SOCIAL RELATIONS AMONG PEOPLE REMA9 UN*ANG$2 9DE$1 SU* FOLKS WILL PROBABLY EXI/ EV5 AFT] A G5U9E SOCIAL REVOLUTION4 ,BUFE'S MA9 CONC]N SEEMS TO BE :AT HE P]CEIVES AS A MISREPRES5TATION ( AN>*ISM ?R\< ! MORE VISIBLE & \TSPOK5 0FA%ION AN>*I/S40 ,I AGREE4 ,! 0FA%ION AN>*I/S0 -- (T5 JU/ FRU/RAT$ LIB]ALS -- SEEM TO BE ! ONES ,*AZ CLAIMS 0C\LDN'T (F] A COH]5T DEF9ITION ( AN>*ISM TO SAVE !IR LIVES20 !Y >E ! ONES :O WILL BE EMB>RASS$ BY OR REMEMB] FONDLY !IR JUV5ILE TRAPP+S SU* AS SEV5 PI]CES 9 AN E> 7NOSE PI]CE OPTIONAL71 !IR CIRCLE4,A TATTOOS1 & SPRAY@>@>PA9T$ JACKETS4 ,I'M SURE ?AT !RE MAY BE ?OSE :O WON'T BE EMB>RASS$ BY IT1 & :O MAY EV5 BE PR\D TO /ILL BE LOOK$ AT FUNNILY :5 !Y WALK D[N A /REET 9 #aiie ) A SPIK$ BLUE MOHAWK1 BUT !Y /ILL PROBABLY C\LDN'T GIVE ANYONE AN IDEA ( :AT AN>*ISM1 AS A HI/ORICAL PHILOSOPHY1 IS4 ,!SE PEOPLE >E QUITE DIFF]5T ?AN 0M>G9ALS10 & ,*AZ DOES HIS [N BIT ( MISREPRES5TATION H]E4 ,AGA91 HE HAS NEV] 7AS F> AS WE KN[7 PROVID$ 0A COH]5T DEF9ITION ( AN>*ISM0 9 ANY?+ HE'S WRITT5 :I* M]ELY S]VES TO TRIVIALIZE HIS CONDEMNATIONS4 

,IT IS PROBABLY SAFE TO PRESUME ?AT ! 0B\RGEOIS LIES0 TO :I* HE REF]S >E ?OSE QUOT$ FROM HIS CORPSE FRI5D1 ,LUIGI ,FABBRI1 BUT HE DOESN'T SAY1 SO WE >E LEFT TO WOND] & 9 ANY CASE ,EABBRI NEV] DESCRIBES !M EI!R4 ,>E ! UND]P9N+S ( AN>*ISM >I/ROCRATIC LIES BECAUSE PEOPLE LIKE ,BAKUN9 & ,KROPOTK9 W]E >I/OCRATS8 ,OR ANTI-SEMITIC LIES BECAUSE ! FIR/ P]SON KN[N TO HAVE SAID 0.>E SUIS UN AN>*I/E60 7,PRODH\N7 WAS ANTI4SEMITIC8 ,DOES IT REALLY MATT]8 

0,HONOR ,WORK0 

444 PAY HOMAGE TO ! WORK]10 SEEMS TO BE ONE ( ,*AZ'S MOTTOS BUT ,HITL] SAID IT FIR/4 ,& ALL LEAD]S_/ORGANIZ]S1 ,EA/ & ,WE/1 HAVE !IR [N V]SION4 ,AH1 SWEET SLAV]Y4 

,IT IS CURI\S ?AT HE ATTRIBUTES ! ANTI-WORK P]SPECTIVE TO ! 0M>G9ALIZ$ MILIEU0 7! J>GONNY WORD 0MILIEU0 IS US$ BY MANY 9CLUD+ ,*AZ H]E1 AS ONE =M ( CLUB OR ANO!R -- MORE ON ?IS LAT]74 ,IT IS KN[N ?AT HE ACT$ AS AN ,S,S,I PAYEE = A GUY :O HOLDS AN ANTI-WORK POSITION 7& CONSID]+ ,*AZ'S OBVI\S DISGU/ = ?IS P]SON'S LIFE-/YLE ONE W\LD HAVE TO ASK :Y7 BUT HE HAS ALSO HAD MU* CONTACT ) PEOPLE :O WORK1 LIKE ! COLLABORATORS ON ?IS RESPONSE1 & :O DON'T ?9K IT'S ANY?+ TO WRITE HOME AB\T4 

,IT DOESN'T /OP ) US4 ,IF Y\ KEEPS Y\R E>S OP51 IT IS NOT UNCOMMON TO HE> CONV]SATIONS LIKE ! FOLL[+ ON ! BUS DUR+ COMMUT] H\RS3 

,/UD5T TO COMMUT]3 ,SO H[ >E Y\ ?IS EV5+8 

,COMMUT]3 ,TIR$6 

,/UD5T3 ,?AT'S :AT Y\ SAID ?IS MORN+ & :AT Y\ ALWAYS SAY :5EV] ,I SEE Y\4 ,IS !RE ANY TIME ?AT Y\'RE NOT TIR$8 

,COMMUT]3 ,YEAH1 :5 ,I DON'T HAVE TO WORK4 

,NOR DOES IT /OP !RE :AT ) PEOPLE 9 ,POL&1 NOT UNLIKE PROTE/]S 9 ,TANZANIA1 *ANT+ ! SLOGAN 0,PROHIBIT WORK1 PROHIBIT PAY40 ,& E>LI] ?IS YE>1 A DISSID5T PRESS 9 ,YUGOSLAVIA ANN\NC$ ITS 9T5TION TO PUBLI% A SEV]AL HUNDR$ PAGE BOOK ON ! HI/ORY ( ! /RUGGLE AGA9/ WORK4 ,! /RUGGLE AGA9/ WORK IS AN 9T]NATIONAL ONE4 

,*AZ'S *>ACT]IZATION ( ! 0ANTI4WORK ATTITUDE0 AS1 0,:AT Y\'RE DO+ 7WORK7 IS WORSE ?AN USELESS1 & Y\'RE /UPID = DO+ IT10 IS RIDICUL\S4 ,?AT IS NOT ! ATTITUDE ( ANY ( ! 0ANTI-WORK0 PEOPLE WE KN[ 7IT IS NOT UNLIKE ! ANTI-W> ATTITUDE ( PACIFI/S T[>D SOLDI]S & SAILORS1 H[EV]72 ! ATTITUDE ( PEOPLE :O >E 0ANTI-WORK0 9 EFFECT /ATES3 0IT SUCKS HAV+ TO WORK BECAUSE MO/ ( :AT WE'RE DO+ IS WOR?LESS1 & ! UPHOLD]S ( ?IS ECONOMIC SY/EM >E /UPID = COMPELL+ US TO DO IT40 ,*AZ IGNORES ! PEOPLE :OSE OCCUPATIONS >E EV5 MORE 0P>ASITIC0 ?AN ?AT ( A WELF>E 0BUM03 BANK]S1 L&LORDS1 LAWY]S 7& ! 5TIRE LEGAL APP>ATUS71 SOCIAL WORK]S1 PSY*IATRI/S1 & >T CRITICS444 

,APP>5TLY1 S9CE ?OSE :O P]=M !SE FUNCTIONS >E WORK+1 !Y >E OK BY ,*AZ4 0,WORK0 IS NEV] DEF9$2 IT IS /AT$ ?AT IT ,MU/ BE P]=M$ 09 ORD] = SOCIETY TO EXI/40 ,*AZ PROBABLY US$ ! G5]IC SCI5TIFIC DEF9ITION ( WORK 7REMEMB] IT FROM #g? GRADE873 ! EXP5DITURE OR TRANSF] ( 5]GY4 ,?IS IS PURE R$UCTIONISM 7:AT IS PRAIS$ BY SCI5TI/S7 & AGA9 HAS NO CONTEXT4 ,AS ,I WRITE ?IS ,I AM EXP5D+ 5]GY BUT ,I DON'T CONSID] IT AS 0WORK40 ,P]HAPS A QUICK LOOK AT ! ETYMOLOGY ( ! T]M W\LD BE USEFUL4 0,WORK0 COMES FROM ! ,LAT9 LABORIS1 MEAN+ TOIL1 PA92 9 O!R WORDS1 NOT AN ACTIVITY ONE W\LD 5GAGE 9 VOLUNT>ILY IF ONE BELIEVES ?AT LIFE %\LD CONSI/ ( ! PURSUIT ( ONE'S DESIRES4 

,WORK1 !N1 IS SOME?+ ONE DOES BECAUSE ONE IS COMPELL$ OR =C$ TO DO IT4 

,H[ W\LD ,*AZ'S AN>*I/ SOCIETY COMPEL ANYONE TO WORK8 ,H[ C\LD ANYONE 9 SU* A SOCIETY BE =C$ TO DO ANY?+ & /ILL HAVE ?AT SOCIETY CONSID]$ AN>*I/8 ,AN AN>*I/ SOCIETY W\LD BE ONE 9 :I* =CE CANNOT PLAY A USEFUL P>T 9 SOCIAL RELATIONS BECAUSE AN>*Y BY DEF9ITION IS A CONDITION ( EXI/5CE BAS$ ON VOLUNT>Y ASSOCIATIONS4 

,!RE IS A LIT]ATURE AB\T ! DESIRABILITY ( & POSSIBILITY ( PLAY 9/EAD ( WORK4 ,*AZ HAS ACCESS TO IT BUT IT'S NOT :]E HIS HE>T IS2 HE'D PREF] TO MI/AKE HIS P]SPECTIVE & [N LACK ( ASPIRATIONS = ?AT ( ! CLASS1 ) HIS MULTITUDE ( DEGREES1 ( :I* HE CLAIMS TO BE AP>T4 ,?IS LIT]ATURE 9CLUDES ! ,SITUATIONI/S1 ,M>X'S SON49@>@>LAW'S ,! ,RI<T TO BE ,LAZY1 ,BOB ,BLACK'S REC5T PAMPHLET ON ! TOPIC1 NUM]\S AN?ROPOLOGICAL /UDIES1 A REC5T BOOK-CALL$ ,*ILDR5 ( ! ,CITY GIVES SOME COV]AGE444 

,& ONCE AGA9 ,*AZ GRASPS AT /RAWS 7M5 & WOM57 :5 HE ASS]TS ?AT IT IS 0RA!R DIFFICULT TO TAKE S]I\SLY ?OSE :O RAIL AGA9/ WORK :ILE GRASP+ A BLACK FLAG 9 ONE H& & A WELF>E *ECK 9 ! O!R10 S9CE MANY ( ?OSE1 P]HAPS MO/1 :O RAIL AGA9/ WORK WORK 7& AGA9 SO :AT -- CONT9U$ SLAV]Y IS NO >GUM5T = NOBILITY74 

,! QUE/ION ( H[ WE GET FROM H]E TO !RE M]ELY UND]L9ES ! IMM5SITY ( ! TASK AT H&1 BUT DOES NOT1 AS ,*AZ ASS]TS1 R5D] ! >GUM5T = PLAY MOOT4 LF HE ?9KS IT DOES !N HE MU/ APPLY ! QUE/ION TO ! ADVOCACY ( AN 5D TO ALL GOV]NM5T OR EV5 SIMPLY TO WAGE SLAV]Y4 ,?AT !RE IS A QUE/ION ( H[ TO GET !RE DOESN'T R5D] ! ASPIRATION TO GET !RE MOOT AT ALL-IT M]ELY EMPHASIZES :AT A =MIDABLE TASK IS AHEAD = ANYONE ) ?OSE ASPIRATIONS4 ,& = SOME IT LEADS TO DESPAIR AT ! SEEM+ IMPOSSIBLITY -- BEW>E ANYONE :O HAS EASY 7OR SIMPLE7 ANSW]S4 

,ORD] @& ,DISCIPL9E 

,9 HIS SECTION ON 0ANTI-ORGANIZATIONAL BIAS0 HE L9KS UP HIS UNDEF9$ 0DELIB]ATE SELF-M>G9ALIZATION0 & AN ANTI-WORK ATTITUDE & !N ASS]TS ?AT ?IS COMES FROM A 0LACK ( /UDY ( AN>*I/ !ORY40 ,?IS REALLY FLIES 9 ! FACE ( ! REALITY HE KN[S1 & EXPOSES HIS GRASP+ AT /RAWS S9CE ALL ! PEOPLE WE >E AW>E (1 9CLUD+ ! 0P>ASITE0 HE WAS A PAYEE = 7& :O 9CID5TLY HAS PRODUC$ HIS [N RESPONSE TO ,*AZ'S DI/ORTIONS1 HALF@>@>TRU?S1 & HYPOCRISY7 & ! PEOPLE AT ,FIF? ,E/ATE1 HAVE /UDI$ AN>*I/ !ORY -- 0VIRTUALLY ALL ( ! MO/ PROM95T0 TOO4 ,*AZ /UDI$ !M & AGRE$1 O!RS /UDI$ & DISAGRE$1 ) H[ HE 9T]PRETS !IR POSITION ON ORGANIZATION4 ,BUT IF Y\ ?9K ( ! MANY TASKS Y\ DO DUR+ A DAY ?AT >E NOT =MALIZ$ ?AT IS ORGANIZ$1 IT IS REALLY NOT TOO T> TO GO TO BE ABLE TO ASS]T ?AT !RE MI<T BE SOME?+ POSITIVE 9 ?IS K9D ( SPONTANE\S PROCESS -- & IT DOES GET ?+S DONE4 

,AT ?IS PO9T ,*AZ BR+S UP A REM>K ?AT HAS BE5 ATTRIBUT$ TO ME 7,BRIAN7 ELSE:]E TO ! EFFECT ?AT ,I SAID ALL ORGANIZATION IS 9H]5TLY CAPITALI/4 ,I DON'T HAVE ! B5EFIT ( TOTAL RECALL H]E BUT ,I'LL WAG] ?IS REM>K WAS NOT MADE 9 A COMPLETELY S]I\S CONTEXT :I* PO9TS \T A S]I\S PROBLEM ) ,*AZ'S ATTRIBUTIONS -- HE LEAVES \T CONTEXT :I* IS EXTREMELY IMPORTANT 9 ANY 5DEAVOR GE>$ T[>D UND]/&+ A GIV5 CIRCUM/ANCE4 ,NONE!LESS ,I AM NOT 9T]E/$ 9 COMPLETELY DIS[N+ ?AT REM>K S9CE 9 ! CURR5T 7ANTI7SOCIAL ORGANIZATION ( ?+S 7CAPITALISM IF Y\ WILL7 EV]Y =MAL ORGANIZATION ACCUMULATES CAPITAL1 PROP]TY & P[] :I* ) V]Y FEW EXCEPTIONS ONLY A FEW PEOPLE 9 ! ORGANIZATION CONTROL -- EV5 ALLEG$LY 0DEMOCRATIC0 ONES OR ?OSE ?AT ACT 9 ! NAME ( ! PEOPLE1 ! COLLECTIVE OR ! 7(FICE7 WORK]S4 ,IT IS ( FUR!R 9T]E/ ?AT ONE ( ,*AZ'S PSEUDONOM9\S NAMESAKES1 ,ALEX&] ,B]KMAN1 ALSO HAD A CONC]N AB\T & AGA9/ ! 0HYPOCRISY ( ORGANIZ$ SOCIETY40 7CF4 ,! ,MAT*1 ,FALL1 L#i#h#e74 

,IT IS ALSO 9 ?IS SECTION ?AT ,*AZ FIR/ MAKES REF]5CE TO AN AN>*I/ 0MOVEM5T0 BUT IT'S FACILE S9CE !RE IS NONE4 ,IT IS H[EV] REPRES5TATIVE ( HIS M9DSET ?AT !RE IS SOME CLOS$ CIRCLE ( PEOPLE ?AT CAN BE BLANKET$ ) ! LABEL 0MILIEU10 0MOVEM5T10 0COMMUNITY10 OR 0',WE0 ABSOLUTELY DI/9CT FROM & DIFF]5T ?AN ! RE/ ( SOCIETY4 ,ONCE HAV+ CREAT$ ?IS $IFICE HE CAN ATTRIBUTE ! FAIL+S ( MAJOR PROJECTS TO ?OSE ANTI-ORGANIZATIONAL TWITS )9 IT -- HO HUM4 ,9 HIS SECTION 0,SECT>IANISM0 HE BELITTLES IT = ,SALLY ,FRYE 7:ILE PO9T+ A F+] AT H] HE ALSO FAILS TO NAME H] EV5 ?\< %E IS R>ELY WILL+ TO HIDE BEH9D PSEUDONYMNITY & :O IT ALSO HAPP5S IS NOT 0ANTI@>@>ORGANIZATIONAL07 BUT H]E HE V]ITIBLY :9ES ?AT 0:5 ?R\< D9T ( H>D WORK Y\ DO SUCCE$ 9 ORGANIZ+ A PROJECT1 Y\'LL ALMO/ C]TA9LY BE ATTACK$ BY0 HE SAYS 0! ANTI-ORGANIZATIONAL FR+E40 ,BUT ,SALLY GOT TO EXP]I5CE IT FROM :AT ,I GUESS %\LD BE CON/RU$ AS ! ORGANIZATIONAL MA9/REAM 7MORE ON ?IS UND] 0,DISP>ATE ,ELEM5TS074 

,S9CE ,*AZ IS SO HUNG UP ON ! PROBLEM ( ORGANIZATION V]SUS ! ANTI-ORGANIZATIONAL FR+E H[ COME HE NEV] BO!RS TO TELL US :AT ! HELL HE MEANS BY ! T]MS -- OR DOES EV]YBODY KN[ ALREADY4 ,:AT HE DOES BO!R TO DO H[EV]1 IS HIDE BEH9D A VEIL 7SKIRT7 ( ANONYMNITY 9 ORD] TO CITE 0A POLITICALLY ACTIVE FRI5D0 ( HIS AS ?\< %E W]E AN UNIMPEA*ABLE S\RCE4 ,BUT :AT IS ATTRIBUT$ TO H] IS NEV] ELABORAT$ ON4 ,:AT'S IT MEAN TO LABEL AN>*I/S AS UNCOOP]ATIVE1 IRRESPONSIBLE & SELFI% BECAUSE ( *ANCE MEET+S 0) SEV]AL ( ! LOCAL M>G9ALI/S80 ,!RE >E MANY PEOPLE WE KN[ :O W\LD LABEL POLITICAL ACTIVI/S ! WAY ,*AZ'S FRI5D LABEL$ AN>*I/S & WORSE 7ADD+ AT ! V]Y LEA/ SELF-RI<TE\S & OV]BE>+74 

,TO HIS 0FRI5D0 IT IS A NEGATIVE QUALITY TO BE UNCOOP]ATIVE4 ,BUT ONE NE$S TO EXPLORE ! ROOTS ( ?IS UNCOOP]ATIV5ESS4 ,>E PEOPLE LABEL$ UNCOOP]ATIVE BECAUSE !Y W]E UNWILL+ TO SUBMIT TO SOME POLITICAL ACTION ON H] T]MS8 ,DID !IR FAILURE TO FOLL[ MAKE !M IRRESPONSIBLE8 ,& !IR 9SI/5CE ON BE+ TREAT$ AS EQUALS TO ! 0POLITICALLY ACTIVE FRI5D0 R5D] !M SELFI%8 ,WE'VE SE5 IT HAPP54 ,KN[+ TOO MANY ( ,BUFE'S FRI5DS1 IT IS NOT AN IMPLAUSIBLE SCRIPT4 

,MEANS @& ,5DS 

,*AZ'S REM>KS ON VIOL5CE 9 ! AB/RACT >E AB\T ! ONLY ONES ?AT HAVE ANY VALUE = REAL DISC\RSE1 BUT EV5 H]E HE MISSES ! M>K IF HE IS GROP+ = AN UND]/&+ ( :Y !RE IS NO SU/A9$ REBELLI\S & ANTI-AU?ORIT>IAN CULTURE 9 ?IS SOCIETY4 ,IT IS TRUE 5\< ?AT EPI!T 0AN>*Y0 IS US$ BY ! M$IA TO DESCRIBE SOME LEFTI/ T]RORISM1 ! VIOL5CE ( ,S\? ,AFRICANS AGA9/ AP>!ID1 & ! VIOL5CE AGA9/ POLICE ON ! P>T ( ,EUROPE'S SQUATT]S4 

,H[EV]1 IT IS JU/ AS TRUE ?AT !Y HAVE US$ ! T]M TO DESCRIBE SOME COMPLETELY NONVIOL5T ACTIVITIES SU* AS ?OSE ( ,SOLID>NOSC 9 ,POL&1 & MO/ REC5TLY ?OSE ( ! ,SANCTU>Y MOVEM5T 9 ! ,U4,S4 ,& 9 ANY CASE W\LD HE >GUE ?AT ALL ! ABOVE ACTS (VIOL5CE >E HUD8 ,AS = ! UNCRITICAL PRAISE GIV5 AU?ORIT>IAN GR\PS BY AV[$LY ANTI-AU?ORIT>IAN PUBLICATIONS -- WELL SO CRITICIZE !M4 ,BUT ! H>M SU* WRIT+ DOES IS PROBABLY ONLY 9CALCULABLE ON ! M9USCULE SIDE4 

,9 ! SECTION CALL$ 0,VIOL5CE0 ,*AZ AVOIDS DISCUSS+ :AT 0VIOL5CE0 ACTUALLY MEANS1 HE TIES VIOL5CE TO T]RORISM AS 9EXORABLY AS LIB]ALS1 PACIFI/S1 & 0! M$IA10 & (F]S ! MO/ LAME >GUM5T = NOT 5GAG+ 9 >M$ /RUGGLE4 ,AS USUAL !RE IS ! IRRITAT+ LACK ( DEF9ITION & CONTEXT :I* LEADS DIRECTLY TO HIS EQUAT+ 0VIOL5CE0 ) 0T]RORISM40 

,HIS ANALYSIS ( ! ,VANC\V] ,FIVE & ,OP5 ,ROAD IS ALSO IRRITAT+3 TO IMAG9E ?AT ! ,FIVE W]E SPURR$ 9TO ACTION BY READ+ 0>TICLES ROMANTICIZ+ VIOL5CE0 79 ,OP5 ,ROAD7 C\PL$ ) 0DESP]ATION OR MISPLAC$ IDEALISM0 GIVES !M ABSOLUTELY NO CR$IT = HAV+ BRA9S4 ,EA* ACTION !Y ADMITT$ COMMITT+ %[$ H[ CONC]N$ & C>EFUL !Y W]E AB\T POSSIBLE 9JURY TO PEOPLE 7EXCEPT P]HAPS ! ,LITTON BOMB+71 PRO( ( DELIB]ATION1 NOT DESP]ATION2 0MISPLAC$ IDEALISM0 MAY HAVE BE5 ! CASE = ,G]RY & ,JULIE1 BUT NOT = ,D\G1 ,ANNE1 & ,BRANT1 ALL ( :OM W]E EXP]I5C$ POLITICAL ACTIVI/S4 ,& N[ HIS FRI5D AT ,! ,MAT* IS EV5 9S9UAT+ ?AT ,OP5 ,ROAD IS ,/ATE-F9ANC$4 7LT %\LD BE EMPHASIZ$ ?AT HE IS 9S9UAT+ IT I4E4 NOT SAY+ IT DIRECTLY1 HONE/LY1 NOR ) ANY FACTUAL OR P]SONAL 9=MATION TO SUPPORT ! ASS]TION4 ,HOPEFULLY1 BUT D\BTFULLY1 ,*AZ HAS SOME?+ TO SAY AB\T ?AT67 

,! >GUM5T ?AT SU* BOMB+S 0CREATE AN ATMOSPH]E ( HY/]IA :I* GAVE ! ,CANADIAN GOV]NM5T A P]FECT EXCUSE TO RAM ?R\< REPRESSIVE LEGISLATION0 IS QUITE SILLY3 NO GOV]NM5T EV] NE$S AN 0EXCUSE0 7P]FECT OR NOT7 TO 0RAM ?R\<0 REPRESSIVE LAWS4 ,SU* LAWS CAN BE RAMM$ ?R\<0 7?AT IS )\T MU* PUBLIC AW>5ESS7 )- ! HELP ( ! SELF4IMPOS$ SIL5CE ON ! P>T ( ORGANS ( COMMUNICATION4 ,AN EXAMPLE ( ?IS IS ! LACK ( PUBLIC AW>5ESS 9 ! ,U4,S4 ( ! SEV]AL 0ANTI-T]RORI/0 BILLS CIRCULAT+ 9 ,WA%+TON ,D4,C42 MORE 0DOME/IC T]RORISM0 MAY OR MAY NOT ACCEL]ATE ! PASS+ ( !SE BILLS 9TO ,F$]AL ,LAWS BUT ! M]E FACT ?AT !Y EXI/ AT ALL %[S ?AT ?OSE :O GOV]N DON'T NE$ AN 0EXCUSE0 TO IMPLEM5T !M4 

,TO ATTA* EV5 MORE AMBIGU\S & VAGUE NOTIONS ONTO ! QUE/ION ( VIOL5CE1 ,*AZ DEM&S 79 ! ,T5 ,COMM&M5TS AGA97 ?AT 0WEE 7SIC7 %\LD AVOID ! USE ( VIOL5CE EXCEPT 9 SELF-DEF5SE & 9 REVOLUTION>Y SITUATIONS40 ,?AT'S A P]FECTLY CLE> ?\<T ) NO POSSIBILITY = DIFF]+ 9T]PRETATIONS4 ,ONE C\LD WOND] IF ,*AZ ?\<T IT WAS 0SELF-DEF5SE0 OR A 0REVOLUTION>Y SITUATION0 :5 HE & AB\T #b O!R PEOPLE 79CLUD+ ME1 ,LAWR5CE7 WANT$ TO CONFRONT FASCI/ SK9HEADS ) HEAVY OBJECTS 9 H& 7,I HAD A /ICK1 ,*AZ HAD A HAMM]78 ,OR1 ONE C\LD WOND] :Y ,BOB ,BLACK'S ACTIONS1 = :I* ,*AZ HAS A BLANKET CONDEMNATION1 DON'T FALL UND] ! EUPHEMISM 0SELF-DEF5SE80 ,BLACK ?\<T !Y DID4 

,DISP>ATE ,ELEM5TS VS4 ,SECRET>IAN ,DISSOCIATION 

,*AZ'S SECTIONS ON 0,SECT>IANISM10 0,VIOL5T ,ATTACKS10 & 0,MISUSE ( ,T]MS0 >E SOME ( ! WOR/ ONE-SID$ REWRIT+S ( HY/]Y WE'VE SE54 ,! FIR/ ELEM5T ( CURIOSITY IS ?AT ?IS MEMB] ( ! ,AN>*O-,SYNDICALI/ SECT W\LD PO9T ! F+] AT O!RS = BE+ SECT>IAN1 FLY+ 9 ! FACE ( ! NORMAL MEAN+ ( ! T]M4 

,NOT ONLY DOES HE RESORT TO A CLAIM ?AT 09T]NAL RELATIONS )9 ! AN>*I/ MOVEM5T >E 9 T]RIBLE %APE0 7ONLY POSSIBLE IF !RE W]E AN AN>*I/ MOVEM5T TO BE 9SIDE :I* !RE A9'T7 BUT RESORTS TO SCAPEGOAT+ & REGURGITATES ! LABEL+ ( AN 9DIVIDUAL1 ,SALLY ,FRYE1 :OM HE *OOSES = UNKN[N REASONS NOT TO NAME1 & :O HAD 0?R\< D9T ( H>D WORK & 9VE/M5T ( H] LIMIT$ FREE TIME & MONEY SUCCE$$ 7) O!RS7 9 ORGANIZ+ A PROJECT0 7& AB\T :I* ONE C\LD REASONABLY EXPECT H] TO FEEL A P]SONAL OR 9 ,*AZ'S WORDS 0PROPRIET>Y 9T]E/0 -- H] LOVE & LABOR W]E DEEPLY 9VE/$7 9 ?IS CASE ,NO ,MIDDLE ,GR\ND1 & !N WAS V]BALLY ATTACK$1 & F9ALLY PURG$1 AS BE+ SECT>IAN BECAUSE %E WANT$ B] FEEL+S & REFLECTIONS REPRES5T$ 9'! PAGES ( ?AT MAGAZ9E -- NO?+ MORE NO?+ LESS4 ,%E NEV] EV] /AT$ ?AT ONLY >TICLES REFLECT+ H] PO9T ( VIEW %\LD GO 9 7:I* W\LD HAVE BE5 SECT>IAN7 & 9 FACT ! ONE ?AT %E RESPOND$ TO WAS ONE %E ADVOCAT$ GO+ 9 EV5 ?\< %E F\ND IT V]Y DISAGREEABLE -- H>DLY SECT>IAN 9 ANY COMMON UND]/&+ ( ! WORD4 ,= H] TR\BLE %E WAS ?REAT5$ 0,Y\'LL BE SORRY 4440 BUT WAS NEV] TOLD :AT ?AT MEANT EV5 ?\< %E ASK$ ! PEOPLE 9VOLV$ :AT !Y MEANT4 ,%E HAD ! COPS CALL$ ON H] 7M]ELY ?REAT5$ IT TURN$ \T7 & ! EXT5T ( ! SOLID>ITY ( H] FELL[ ,N,M,G]S WAS TO 5C\RAGE H] TO LEAVE RA!R ?AN CONFRONT ! COP-CALL] 7:O ALSO HAPP5$ TO BE ,CAITL9 ,MANN+ ! AU?OR ( ! >TICLE ,SALLY CRITICIZ$71 & ULTIMATELY ALONG ) ,CAITL9 !Y PURG$ H]4 ,!RE CAN BE NO O!R WORD S9CE DESPITE ,*AZ'S CLAIM !RE WAS NOT AN 0UNSPOK5 CONS5SUS ?AT ! PROJECT WAS DEAD40 ,SALLY H]SELF WAS DISC\RAG$ FROM F9D+ \T JU/ :AT ! CONS5SUS WAS AT ! TIME ! MA*9ATIONS AGA9/ H] W]E PROCE$+ BY SOMEONE %E /ILL ?\<T ( AS A FRI5D4 ,AS A MATT] ( FACT ! CONCEPT ( 0UNSPOK5 CONS5SUS0 IS A TRAVE/Y ON ! T]M CONS5SUS :I* MU/ BE ACTIVE1 NOT PASSIVE1 & OP51 SPOK5 IF Y\ WILL1 IF IT IS TO BE ANY?+ RESEMBL+ DEMOCRATIC4 

,IT APPE>S ?AT ,*AZ & HIS COHORTS /ILL CAN'T FACE UP TO !IR [N ABUSIVE BEHAVIOR T[>D PEOPLE ?\< !Y C]TA9LY *URN \T A LOT ( RHETORIC AGA9/ O!RS :O >E REACT+ TO !IRS4 ,PURGE C]TA9LY %\LD CONJURE UP IMAGES ( ,/AL9 -- ?AT'S :Y IT WAS AN UNACCEPTABLE PROCESS4 

,AS TO ! REF]5CE TO ,PROCESS$ ,WORLD BE+ ,L59I/1 WELL ,MANN+ = ONE HAS BE5 HE>D TO MAKE /ATEM5TS AB\T H] PRES5CE 9 0! VANGU>D01 & :ATEV] ITS ALLEG$ ADVOCACY1 & ?AT REMA9S UNCLE>1 ,P,W IS A HI]>*ICAL GR\P4 ,& IF ,*AZ IS ! ANTI*RI/ ?AT W\LD C]TA9LY BE A PLUS -- TOO BAD HE MISSES ON ALL ?REE C\NTS4 

,IT GOES )\T SAY+ ?AT WE HAVE LITTLE SYMPA?Y ) HIS RANTS AB\T ,FIF? ,E/ATE SUFFICE IT TO SAY ! $ITORS >E (T5 SATIRICAL -- & HUMOR IS IRRATIONAL4 ,*AZ'S REM>KS AB\T !M >E FILL$ ) HIS *>ACT]I/IC HUMORLESS 9T]PRETATIONS2 :5 WE READ ! HORRIBLE & DEFAMATORY LETT] 9 ,F,E BY 0,TALL ,K+ ,A,Z ,HOLE0 WE DIDN'T = ONE MOM5T ?9K ?AT ,WOODWOR? HAD WRITT5 IT4 ,( C\RSE WE HAVE TWO ADVANTAGES OV] ,*AZ 9 REG>DS TO ,F,E3 L7 WE UND]/& !IR SATIRE & 0FABRICATIONS0 7BLATANT F>CES7 SU* AS ,MANUAL = ,REVOLUTION>Y ,LEAD]S & A CIRCULAT$ LETT] AB\T ,*AZ ,BUFE BE+ A PSEUDONYM = A WIT*ES' COV56 & #b7 WE HAVE S5SES ( HUMOR4 

,:5 SOMEONE DOES TAKE /RONG UMBRAGE ) SOME?+ !Y'VE PR9T$ !Y SEEM TO PROVIDE !IR READ]S ! OPPORTUNITY ( CONTACT+ !IR CRITIC IF !Y WI%4 ,!Y HAVE DONE ?IS ) ,F]D ,WOODWOR? & ,! ,MAT*4 ,BY ! WAY ?IS SOME?+ ?AT HIS BELOV$ ,PROCESS$ ,WORLD HAS B5T OV] BACKW>DS NOT TO DO4 ,SO :O IS SECT>IAN8 

,! ,CASE ( ! ,%RIEK+ ,VIOLETS3 ,CO]CION1 ,9TIMIDATION1 ,VIOL5T ,ATTACKS444 

,! SECTION 0,VIOL5T ,ATTACKS0 IS SO FULL ( HOLES ?AT ! ONLY REM$Y IS TO GET A COPY ( ,! ,BABY & ! ,BA?WAT] 7AVAILABLE FROM ,B,T7 BECAUSE 9 IT >E DOCUM5TATIONS ( EV]Y 0ATTACK0 & 0C\NT]-ATTACK0 BY ,ROB]T ,C4 ,BLACK1 JR4 & BY ,P,W]S4 

,SCI5TI/S1 EV5 SOCIAL ONES1 T5D TO BELIEVE 9 SOME?+ KN[N AS CAUSE & EFFECT4 ,NOT ,*AZ4 ,ACCORD+ TO 0,VIOL5T ,ATTACKS0 ,BLACK ACT$ 9 A TOTAL VACUUM AS F> AS ! BEHAVIOR ( ,PROCESS$ ,WORLD PEOPLE W]E CONC]N$4 ,?AT ,*AZ WAS NOT >\ND TO WITNESS V]Y MU* ( EV]YONE'S ACTIVITIES \<T TO BE M5TION$4 ,SOME ( US HAVE BE5 H]E = ! :OLE %[4 ,EV5 ?\< MANY >E ! PEOPLE :O HAVE BE5 CO]C$ & 9TIMIDAT$ & ?REAT5$ BY ,P,W PR9CIPLES HE WANTS JUDGM5T SUSP5D$4 ,= HIM 0,AN 9JURY TO ONE IS AN 9JURY TO ALL0 SEEMS TO MEAN 0,AN 9JURY TO ,PROCESS$ ,WORLD IS AN 9JURY TO ALL1 BUT AN 9JURY TO ANYONE ELSE BY !M -- FUCK 'EM40 

,:5 ,CAITL9 ?REAT5$ TO CALL ! COPS NO ONE EXHIBIT$ ANY SOLID>ITY ) ,SALLY AGA9/ ?IS /ATI/ 7& PROPRIET>Y7 AGGRESSION4 ,& :5 ,CAITL9 ASSUM$ A ,SUMO WRE/L] POSITION 9 ,BRIAN'S PA? ON ,HAI<T ,/REET ONE EV5+ & BEGAN SPITT+ 0C[>D1 C[>D0 AT HIM TO HIS AMUSEM5T1 ,*AZ'S ONLY 7S]I\S7 RESPONSE TO ?IS SILLY *ILDI% BEHAVIOR WAS ?AT HE 0WI%$ !RE WAS NOT SO MU* CONFLICT0 BUT ( C\RSE NOT TO H] FACE ONLY TO ,BRIAN'S & HE HAD NOT SAID A WORD4 

,:5 Y\R FRI5DS >E CALL+ ! POLICE & US+ ! C\RTS1 AS ,*AZ'S HAVE1 IT IS A BUN* ( HYPOCRISY TO ,F,B,I-BAIT AS HE DOES 9 HIS 0,V,A0 SECTION & DID 9 HIS RESIGNATION LETT] TO ,B\ND ,TOGE!R 9 ,MAY 7#a#i#h#e74 ,BO? ,BLACK & ,P,W HAVE TRI$ TO USE ! C\RTS & POLICE 7) ,P,W1 AS 9 MANY ( ! =MS ( H>ASSM5T !Y RESORT TO1 LEAD+ ! WAY1 ONE NE$S TO ADD7 TO !IR 0B5EFIT0 EA* ) SOME MODICUM ( 0SUCCESS0 7= LACK ( BETT] WORDS74 ,*AZ /ATES DEF9ITIVELY ?AT HE IS A P>T ( ?AT :I* IS KN[N AS ,PROCESS$ ,WRIRLD ?\< ?AT C\LDN'T BE SAID AB\T ?OSE ( US HE PREF]S TO ?9K ( AS 0SID+ ) ,BOB ,BLACK40 ,AS F> AS ! ,F$S >E CONC]N$1 IT SEEMS ?AT ,*AZ CAN'T UND]/& ?AT DIFF]5CES 9 TEMP]M5TS1 PRIORITIES1 & PR$ISPOSITIONS WILL 9EVITABLY YIELD CONFLICTS & DI/URBANCES4 ,! ,F,B,I DOESN'T NE$ TO DO ANY?+ TO ,BAY ,>EA 0DISSID5T GR\PS0 9 ORD] 0TO CAUSE DISRUPTION & 9FI<T+20 !Y CAN SCREW EA* O!R UP QUITE WELL )\T ,F,B,I 9T]V5TION4 

,9 FACT1 EV5 9 ! ALLEG$ DEA? ?REAT TELEPHONE-CALL ?AT HAS BE5 ATTRIBUT$ TO ,BLACK1 H[EV] ONE MI<T DISAGREE ) ! TACTIC LIKE WE DID1 ! CALL] MADE HIS 9T5T COMPLETELY DEP5D5T ON ! CESSATION ( 9TIMIDAT+ & H>ASS+ BE+ C>RI$ ON BY ,P,W]S4 ,9 O!R WORDS1 IF ! H>ASSM5T ( HIS FRI5DS /OPP$1 NO PROBLEM4 ,( C\RSE1 IT DIDN'T & ?+S DEVOLV$ FROM !RE4 

,ALSO1 9 ?IS SECTION ,*AZ REF]S1 \T ( CONTEXT1 TO A COMM5T ,BRIAN MADE AB\T UND]/&+ ANG] & FRU/RATION BUT 9 FACT IT HAD NO?+ TO DO ) ,PROCESS$ ,WORLD IT HAD TO ) HIM & ! ANG] & SCORN HE EXPRESS$ T[>D ,SALLY ,FRYE ON ! PHONE ONE DAY 7%E /ILL OP]AT+ UND] ! ASSUMPTION ! TWO ( !M C\LD SOMEH[ RESOLVE !IR DIFF]5CES7 & ! REACTION ?AT G5]AT$ 9 A CLOSE FRI5D ( H]S :I* WAS NOT A DEA? ?REAT AS ,*AZ CLAIMS BUT MORE LIKE CRANK CALL TO ! EFFECT ?AT 0,Y\'LL GET Y\RS ,/AL9I/0 7A PASS+ REF]5CE NO D\BT TO ! PURG+ ?AT WAS GO+ ON -- AS ,*AZ CORRECTLY UND]/&S74 ,/AL9 DI$ ( NATURAL CAUSES SO IT IS C]TA9LY OP5 TO SPECULATION AS TO :AT ?IS 0?REAT0 MEANT :I* SO F> IS NO?+4 ,! 0,FUCK Y\1 ,SALLY 444 CLICK0 :I* PREC$$ ?IS CRANK CALL WASN'T EXACTLY A V]Y P]SONABLE WAY ( H&L+ ONESELF EI!R4 ,BUT ?IS IS LO/ ON ,*AZ4 

,& ONCE MORE1 HE MAKES IT CONFUS+ AS TO :AT A M>G9ALI/ IS S9CE ?OSE ( US :O 0SID$ ) ,BOB ,BLACK0 WORK 7,BRIAN @& ,FR$DIE 9 ,P_/,W'S T>GET (FICE 9DU/RY AS A MATT] ( FACT47 

,T]M79AL7 ,ABUSE 

,AL?\< HIS :OLE TRACT IS FRAU<T ) ! MISUSE ( T]MS1 ?AT DOESN'T /OP ,*AZ FROM D$ICAT+ A SECTION TO IT4 ,FIR/ !RE IS ?AT EV]-PRES5T 0MOVEM5T10 !N ! QUE/ION ( 0C5SOR%IP0 & !N ?AT ( 0,BOB ,BLACK0S ALLIES10 & F9ALLY M>G9ALISM1 AN>*ISM1 & NUM]\S O!R T]MS REMA9 UNDEF9$ AS TO ,*AZ'S DEF9ITION ( !M LET ALONE ANYONE ELSE'S4 

,HIS COMM5TS ON C5SOR%IP LEAN T[>D BE+ MEAN+LESS DUE TO HIS FAILURE TO ADDRESS ! QUE/ION DIRECTLY 9 ! CONTEXT ( ,B,T AS A BOOK/ORE = ! DISSEM9ATION ( AN>*I/_/ANTI-AU?ORIT>IAN_/ALT]NATIVE LIT]ATURE1 HI/ORY1 ANALYZES1 & !ORIES4 ,AS SU* AN \TLET1 SOME COLLECTIVE MEMB]S 7AGA9 9CLUD+ ! COLLABORATORS ON ?IS RESPONSE7 FELT ?AT S9CE ,B,T C>RIES ,P,W1 !RE WAS A RESPONSIBILITY TO PROVIDE PEOPLE :O GET ,P,W AT ,B,T ) ACCESS TO ,! ,BABY & ! ,BA?WAT]1 ! ONLY WRITT5 CRITIQUE ( ,P,W 7AS WELL AS ,BAY ,>EA 0ANTI-AU?ORIT>IANS0 9 G5]AL & ,B,T TOO74 ,AS = ,BOB ,BLACK BE+ 0VULG>1 PSY*OTIC1 P]SONAL ATTACKS10 ,*AZ ADMITT$ ! NI<T ( DISCUSSION ?AT HE HADN'T EV5 READ IT6 ,AT ! MEET+ :]E ?IS WAS DISCUSS$ & :]E ! WORD 0C5SOR%IP0 CAUS$ SO MU* FLAK1 IT WAS ALSO SUGGE/$ BY SOME ( ! SAME FOLKS ?AT IF ,B,T COLLECTIVE MEMB]S REFUS$ TO C>RY ,B@&,B1 !N WE %\LD ALSO DISCONT9UE /OCK+ ,P,W4 ,= ,*AZ TO EQUATE ?IS ) A REFUSAL TO SELL ,MAOI/ & ,/AL9I/ G>BAGE IS DI%ONE/ & 9SULT+ & SKIRTS ! ISSUE ( H[ ,B,T IS TO FUNCTION AS A SPACE SPECIFICALLY GE>$ TO MAK+ AN>*I/ IDEAS AVAILABLE4 ,BESIDES1 IF ! WRIT]S AT ,REVOLUTION>Y ,WORK] OR ,BREAK?R\< />T$ MAK+ ATTACKS ON AN>*I/S OR AN>*ISM CONSI/5TLY 7!Y USUALLY ONLY DO SO 9 PASS+7 IT W\LD MAKE S5SE = ,B,T TO BE US$ AS A PLACE ( ACCESS = ?AT AS WELL4 

,ANYWAY1 :ATEV] ELSE ,BOB ,BLACK DOES 9 ! WAY ( S>CASM1 RIDICULE OR :ATEV] IT (F]S A HI/ORY & CRITIQUE ( A GR\P ( PEOPLE :O HAVE 5GAG$ 9 ! 0PREV5TION ( 7NUM]\S PEOPLE7 FREELY EXPRESS+ 7!MSELVES7 444 ?R\< ! USE ( CO]CION1 9TIMIDATION1 &_/OR =CE40 ,?AT SOMEONE ALSO MAKES SOME DISAGREEABLE REM>KS OR TAKES SOME DISAGREEABLE ACTIONS1 TOO1 IS REASON 5\< TO CRITICIZE BUT NOT REASON 5\< TO P>TICIPATE 9 ! PROCESS ( RE/RICTIVE AVAILABILITY ESPECIALLY :5 O!RWISE RESPECT$ MEMB]S ( ! COLLECTIVE W]E 9T]E/$ 9 HAV+ IT AVAILABLE BECAUSE ELEM5TS ( IT DO REFLECT !IR EXP]I5CE ( ,P,W & ! 9QUISITORIAL BR& ( ,MANN+'S POLITICAL ACTIVISM4 ,! FACT ?AT .<!Y.> WANT$ ! BOOK 9 NO WAY MADE !M IPSO FACTO 0,BOB ,BLACK'S ALLIES40 LN ?IS CASE IT MEANT ?AT ! PEOPLE ,*AZ REF]S TO1 SPECIFICALLY ,FR$DIE ,BA] & ,BRIAN ,KANE1 HAD HAD EXP]I5CES ) ,P,W :I* W]E REFLECT$ 9 ,BABY 9 A MORE HONE/ WAY ?AN ,P,W WAS DEAL+ ) !M4 ,SOME ( !SE EXP]I5CES 9VOLV$ C5SOR%IP AS HE DEF9ES IT 9 HIS LA/ P>AGRAPH ( HIS 0,MISUSE0 SECTION1 ?\< ,*AZ DOESN'T SEE IT ?AT WAY4 

,ACTUALLY ! :OLE QUE/ION ( C5SOR%IP IS REALLY NOT DEVELOP$ H]E COMPLEXLY 5\<4 ,= 9/ANCE1 REPORTS >E ?AT MORE PEOPLE READ ! UND]GR\ND PRESS 9 ,POL& ?AN ! (FICIAL PRESS1 BUT FEW1 EXCEPT = ,P>TY HACKS1 W\LD >GUE ?AT ,POL& DOESN'T SUFF] FROM C5SOR%IP4 ,&1 MANY /ORIES GO UN- OR UND]REPORT$ 9 ! ,U4,S4 DUE TO SUBTL] ME*ANISMS ?AN CO]CION OR =CE BUT C]TA9LY :I* AM\NT TO A TYPE ( C5SOR%IP4 

,:5 AN AU?OR1 >TI/1 OR ANYONE ELSE = ?AT MATT]1 IS REQUIR$ TO HAVE !IR WORK REFLECT O!R PEOPLE'S PO9T ( VIEW BE=E IT GETS TO SEE ! LI<T ( DAY 9 A PROJECT !Y TOO >E WORK+ ON OR O!RWISE HELP+ ) OR RESPOND+ TO1 ! 9DIVIDUAL DISAPPE>S UND] ! TYRANNY ( 0SELF-MANAGEM5T0 :]E ! KEY WORD BECOMES MANAGEM5T NOT SELF4 

,9 ADDITION TO BE+ ! AU?OR ( ,LI/51 ,AN>*I/61 ,*AZ1 :5 A MEMB] ( ! ,B\ND ,TOGE!R ,COLLECTIVE ,BOOK/ORE1 WROTE TWO LETT]S 9 TWO CONSECUTIVE DAYS 7,MAY ,I#e & ,I#f1 L#i#h#e7 :I* HE PLAC$ 9 ! /ORE'S J\RNAL4 ,9 !M HE DISPLAYS :AT >E TO BE HIS HALLM>KS 9 ! PAMPHLET3 USE ( ! IMP]ATIVE T5SE1 LACK ( DEF9ITIONS = ! 7SOMETIMES AMBIGU\S7 T]MS HE USES1 CONFUSION CONC]N+ ! MEAN+ & USE ( ! T]M 0C5SOR%IP10 ATTACKS ON /RAW PEOPLE1 & AG5T-BAIT+4 

,QUOT+ FROM HIS FIR/ LETT]3 0LET'S444 QUIT CALL+ ,B\ND ,TOGE!R A 'COLLECTIVE' 444 ,COLLECTIVES NORMALLY HAVE A HI< DEGREE ( COHESIV5ESS & MUTUAL TRU/ AMONG MEMB]S4440 ,HE USES ! IMP]ATIVE T5SE & FAILS TO DEF9E :AT HE ?9KS A 0COLLECTIVE0 IS1 AL?\< HE DOES PROVIDE TWO *>ACT]I/ICS HE ASSOCIATES ) ! CONCEPT4 ,UN=TUNATELY1 *>ACT]I/ICS >E NOT DEF9ITIONS SO ! CONCEPT ( A COLLECTIVE & H[ ?AT RELATES TO ! CONTEXT ( ,B,T,Q REMA9S OBSCURE4 ,9T]E/+LY1 ?IS UPHOLD] ( ! AN>*I/ FAI? GOES ON TO DISP>AGE DISP>AT5ESS4 

,/ILL LAT] HE EXPLA9S AN 9CID5T AT A COLLECTIVE MEET+3 0,I F\ND IT RA!R 9T]E/+ ?AT :5 ,I WAS JUMP+ ALL OV] ,FR$DIE = APP>5TLY KN[+ :O DE/ROY$ SOME 'COLLECTIVE' PROP]TY1 BUT REFUS+ TO TELL ! RE/ ( ! ',COLLECTIVE' :O DID IT1 ?AT PEOPLE JUMP$ ON ME4 7,SOME J]K EV5 CALL$ ME A 'COP' -- A COMM5T ,I DEEPLY RES5T470 ,?IS REF]S TO ?REE COPIES ( ,P,W :I* W]E SLA%$ AT ,B,T 7SEE ! ,SLA%]'S LETT] 9 ,RABIES71 ,*AZ'S 9TOXICAT$ ?IRD DEGREE 9T]ROGATION ( ,FR$DIE 7:I* 9CLUD$ GETT+ FLU%$1 US+ AN ACCUSATIVE & HO/ILE TONE ( VOICE1 & WAV+ HIS PO9T$ F+] 9 H] FACE71 & MY 7,LAWR5CE7 ANGRY QUE/ION TO HIM3 0,:5 DID Y\ BECOME A COP1 ,*AZ804 ,HIS BEHAVIOR T[>D ,FR$DIE WAS COP-LIKE & ,I RESPOND$ ACCORD+LY1 EFFECTIVELY %UTT+ HIM UP2 HE CAN RES5T ! ACCURACY ( MY *>ACT]IZATION ( HIS BEHAVIOR ALL HE WANTS1 

,I DON'T C>E4 ,BUT ,I DO C>E ?AT RA!R ?AN ATTACK+ ME 9 RETURN HE *OSE TO ATTACK 0SOME J]K40 ,*AZ KN[S ME & MY NAME1 SO :Y DOES HE AVOID US+ IT & LAY+ ! RESPONSIBILITY = ! ACCUSATION ON ME :]E IT BELONGS8 ,! ONLY 9T]PRETATION ,I CAN COME UP ) IS ?AT HE DELIB]ATELY OMITT$ MY NAME BECAUSE HE DIDN'T WANT PEOPLE ASK+ ME :AT ! CONTEXT ( MY COMM5T WAS4 

,UNLIKE :AT HE /ATES 9 ! PAMPHLET1 HE DOESN'T SEEM TO BE ?AT 9T]E/$ 9 AVOID+ DI%ONE/Y4 

,?IS LETT] & O!R WRIT+S CONTA9 ANO!R ?+ WE CAN'T BROOK4 ,?AT IS ! PSY*OBABBLE ) :I* ,BUFE1 ,P,W & !IR COHORTS ATTEMPT TO DISCR$IT !IR CRITICS4 ,IT JU/ DOESN'T /RIKE US ,REI*4 ,:ILE ANTI-AU?ORIT>IANS G5]ALLY ,LA+ = AN 5D TO PSY*OT]ROR 9CLUD+ ITS J>GON !SE POP-PSY*IATRI/S SE>* = MOD]N /RAI<T-JACKETS4 ,ANYONE :O HAS EV] DREAM$ WILL SEE !Y JU/ >5'T ,JUNG 5\< TO UND]/&4 ,= ?AT WE ?9K !Y %\LD BE ,FREUD 9 !IR [N JUICES4 

,= ,SIMPLE ,LANGUAGE OR A ,LANGUAGE ( ,SIMPLETONS 

,IT'S NOT DIFFICULT TO AGREE ?AT UND] MO/ CIRCUM/ANCES ! MORE SIMPLY SOME?+ CAN BE PHRAS$ ! BETT]4 ,BUT LANGUAGE LIKE LIFE IS COMPLEX1 & IS NOT M]ELY UTILIT>IAN4 ,IT CAN BE PLAY$ ) AS 9 POETRY OR 9 ! QUOTE ( ,BLACK'S LETT] 9 ,*AZ'S SECTION 5TITL$ 0,OBSCURANTISM40 ,CONTR>Y TO :AT ,*AZ SAYS & EXCEPT = ! LA/ S5T5CE IT SEEMS FAIRLY CRY/ALL9E4 ,9 FACT1 IT SEEMS TO BE AB\T SOME ELEM5TS ( DAILY LIFE ?AT ,BOB >GUES >E C5TRAL TO 0SOCIAL LIFE AT ITS 7CON7S5SUAL BE/40 

,P>5!TICALLY1 S9CE ,ORWELL HAS (T5 BE5 US$ TO SUPPORT CONFLICT+ P]SPECTIVES1 HIS [N WRIT+ HAS FAIL$ HIS TRANSP>5CY DICTUM4 ,! LACK ( UND]/&+ ( ,E,E'S DEF9ITION ( TE*NOLOGY ON ! P>T ( ,*AZ & HIS C[ORK]S ONLY 9DICATES ?AT !Y >E UN9T]E/$ 9 ?9K+ AB\T TE*NOLOGY & ANALYZ+ ! IMPORTANCE ( SEP>ATION1 DOM9ATION & DEP5D5CE4 ,?+S ?AT HAVE A HELL ( A LOT TO DO ) DAY-TO-DAY LIFE6 

,ANYWAY1 ! POLL+ ( ONE'S WORKMATES1 :O W]E UND\BT$LY PROVID$ A MO/ NEUTRAL CONTEXT 9 :I* TO JUDGE ! PIECE ON TE*NOLOGY1 :ILE IT MAY (F] SOME 9SI<T 9TO SOME PEOPLE'S FEEL+S1 IS AS AB\T AS POOR A SUPPORT = ! TRU? OR FALSITY ( AN >GUM5T AS ONE CAN GIVE4 LT W\LD BE 9T]E/+ TO KN[ IF ,*AZ HAS %>$ HIS ,L1,A TRACT OR ! WRIT+S ( ! ,OLD ,TE/AM5T ,AN>*I/S HE QUOTES1 OR ,M>X1 OR :E!R HE HAS RUN PA/ CONCEPTS HE USES1 LIKE B\RGEOISIE OR BR++ AN 5D TO GOV]NM5T1 WAGE SLAV]Y1 MONEY1 M>KETS & EX*ANGE1 PA/ HIS WORKMATES1 & :AT !IR 5?USIA/IC RESPONSE WAS4 ,MAYBE HE'S NOT 9TO 5D+ SOME ( ?OSE ?+S4 ,OR MAYBE1 JU/ MAYBE1 HE REALIZES ?AT !RE IS NO P>TICUL> REASON = US TO BELIEVE UND] ! CIRCUM/ANCES HE PROVIDES ?AT !SE WORK]S >E ANY MORE 0TATIONAL0 ?AN ?OSE :O VOT$ = ,HITL]-OR ANY LESS SO 444 

,BACK TO ! ,FACTORIES 

,AFT] HE HAS SAID ?AT ! ,FIF? ,E/ATE QUOTE 7\T ( CONTEXT YET AGA97 WAS IMPOSSIBLE TO 0MAKE HEAD NOR TAIL (10 HE !N CONCLUDES ?AT IT IS REPRES5TATIVE 0( BL9D REJECTION ( SCI5CE1 RATIONALITY & TE*NOLOGY0 7NONE ( :I* T]MS DOES HE BO!R TO DEF9E1 BY ! WAY1 SO WE DON'T KN[ IF IT IS OR ISN'T BY HIS ACC\NT74 ,HE %[S HIS COMPLETE IGNORANCE :5 HE EQUATES TE*NOLOGY ) MA*9]Y4 0,TE*NOLOGY0 IS AN UMBRELLA T]M :I* ( C\RSE COV]S TOOLS & MA*9ES1 BUT MORE IMPORTANTLY1 IT 9CLUDES ! IDEOLOGY OR M9D@>@>SET ?AT ALL[S OR MAKES NECESS>Y ?OSE V]Y TOOLS & MA*9ES4 ,= EXAMPLE1 0COMPUT] TE*NOLOGY0 IS NOT JU/ ,P,CS2 ! T]M MU/ 9CLUDE ! PRODUCTION ME?ODS :I* ALL[ & EV5 NECESSITATE WORK+ ) TOXCIC SOLV5TS1 A COMPLETE DISREG>D = ! HEAL? DANG]S ( LOOK+ AT ,V,D,T,S1 & ! IDEOLOGY ( BOOKKEEP+ & COMPUTATION4 ,COMPUT] TE*NOLOGY DANG]S CANNOT BE DISMISS$ BY SAY+ ?AT 0,UND] SOCIALISM 7OR COMMUNISM1 OR AN>*ISM7 !SE DANG]S WILL DISAPPE> BECAUSE !Y ONLY EXI/ DUE TO ! CAPITALI/ SY/EM ( PRODUCTION40 ,?IS IS NONS5SE4 ,V,D,TS WILL ALWAYS POSE HEAL? ?REATS2 & IF IT W]E EASI] TO MANUFACTURE COMPON5TS )\T TOXIC SOLV5TS1 IT C\LD BE DONE EV5 UND] CAPITALISM4 ,BUT MORE IMPORTANTLY1 IT IS ! IDEOLOGY ( COMPUTATION ?AT CREATES ! 0NE$0 = QUICK & ACCURATE BOOKKEEP+1 A 0NE$0 FULFILL$ BY COMPUT]S4 

,:ATEV] ! EXT5T ( ,F,E'S REJECTION ( TE*NOLOGY IT C\LD H>DLY BE SAID TO BE BL9D CONSID]+ ! L5G?S TO :I* ,F,E $ITORS HAVE GONE TO DESCRIBE V>I\S =MS ( & ! SY/EMATIC 7ANTI7NATURE ( MANY =MS ( TE*NOLOGY 9 !IR WRIT+S & ! WAYS 9 :I* !SE DEGRADE HUMANITY4 

,IT IS ALSO UNTRUE ?AT !Y HAVE M]ELY 0PICK$ ! EASIE/ POSSIBLE T>GETS0 LIKE NUCLE> P[] & AUTOMOTIVE TE* 7IT'S NOT EV5 TRUE ?AT !SE >E P>TICUL>LY EASY S9CE SOME ( ,*AZ'S CURR5T CRONIES >E FOND ( BO?74 LT IS NICE H[EV] TO KN[ ?AT ,*AZ AT LEA/ HOPES ?AT !SE MI<T BE ELIM9AT$ 9 ANY TYPE ( 0SANE0 7PSY*OBABBLE7 SOCIETY4 ,F,E = ITS P>T HAS TALK$ AB\T TE*NOLOGY BE+ SY/EMATIC & SY/EMIC & !Y HAVE TALK$ AB\T H[ IT FITS 9 FACTORIES & FIELDS FROM ,DETROIT TO ,BHOPAL4 ,!Y HAVE EV5 QUE/ION$ :AT IT MEANS TO USE 5VIRONM5TALLY DEGRAD+ TE*NOLOGIES TO PRODUCE !IR PROJECT & AB\T H[ !Y HAV5'T RESOLV$ ! APP>5T CONTRADICTION1 EI!R4 ,DESPITE HIS DEGREES ONECAN ONLY WOND] IF ,*AZ HAS EV] LE>N$ TO READ FROM HIS FAIL+ TO HAVE F\ND ?IS 9 ,F,E'S WRIT+S4 ,AS F> AS IS KN[N1 ,*AZ KN[S NO CAVEM5 EV5 NEO4 

,ON ! O!R H& IT IS NOT UNCOMMON = ,*AZ'S CRONIES TO WAX UNELOQU5TLY AB\T !IR VISION ( SELF-MANAG$ FACTORIES1 LIB]ATORY COMPUT] TE*NOLOGY1 ROBOTICS )\T BL9K+ AN EYE OR GIV+ MU* ?\<T TO ! DEGRAD+ ASPECTS ( !SE TE*NOLOGICAL PROCESSES4 ,!Y M]ELY DECL>E ?AT IT IS NOT A POLITICAL QUE/ION & ?AT IS ?AT4 

,EV5 HIS REF]5CE TO M$ICAL TE*NOLOGY CONTA9S NO 9KL+ 9TO ! CONTROV]SIES AB\T ! DIRECTIONS 9 :I* ! BL9D ACCEPTANCE ( HI< TE*NOLOGIES HAVE L$4 LT TURNS \T ?AT EV5 *IMPANZEES BE5 ABLE TO DISCOV] P[]FUL ANTIBIOTICS ! KN[L$GE ( :I* = SCI5TI/S HAS 0EM]G$ ONLY GRADUALLY40 ,SO IT IS NOT A GIV5 ?AT HEAL? & CURES >E DEP5D5T ON MOD]N TE*NOLOGIES1 & 9 \R HA/E TO MOD]N IT MAY BE ?AT WE HAVE =GOTT5 & LO/ MORE ?AN WE C\LD AF=D4 

,! QUE/ION ( :I* TE*NOLOGIES1 :Y & :5 CAN ONLY BE DECID$ BY AN UNFETT]$ SOCIETY4 ,BUT NO MATT] H[ IT IS DECID$ !IR USE & ABUSE WILL ALWAYS BE A POLITICAL MATT] -- I4E4 A CONC]N AB\T RELATION%IPS ( P[]4 

,AN>*I/ ,REALISM 

,BUFE CLAIMS TO BE OPPOS$ TO :AT HE T]MS 0MY/ICISM0 7ONCE AGA9 HE PROVIDES NO DEF9ITION1 SO ! READ] MU/ 9F] :AT ,*AZ IS TALK+ AB\T7 BUT ,L1,A CONTA9S IDEAS ?AT ONLY A MORALI/IC P]SON W\LD 5T]TA94 ,HE ASKS1 0ONCE Y\ AB&ON RATIONALITY1 H[ DO Y\ DET]M9E RI<T FROM WRONG80 ,A QUE/ION = HIM & TO ALL MORALI/S TO CONSID] IS3 ,H[ CAN Y\ EV5 CONCEIVE ( ! NOTIONS ( 0RI<T & WRONG0 )\T US+ MY/ICISM OR METAPHYSICS8 ,!RE IS NO RATIONAL1 OBJECTIVE F\NDATION = DI/+UI%+ :AT IS 0GOOD0 FROM :AT IS 0BAD40 ,:E!R DET]M9$ BY 0MY/IC AB/RACTIONS SU* AS GOD & C\NTRY0 OR BY 0,SOCIETY10 ! BASES ( MORALS >E F\ND 9 SU* EXT]NAL & SUP]/ITI\S CONCEPTS2 MORALISM IS A SY/EM ( BELIEFS 9 /&>DS ( BEHAVIOR :I* NECESSITATE JUDGM5TS TO BE PASS$ OV] 9DIVIDUALS4 ,:AT ALL[S ANYONE ! PRIVILEGE TO DO ?IS8 ,H[ CAN ONE BE A CONSI/5T AN>*I/ & MA9TA9 SU* /UPID IDEAS AS /&>DS ( PROPRIETY & MORALITY8 

,ALSO 9 HIS 0,REV]SION TO ,MY/ICISM0 SECTION1 ,*AZ MAKES A CURI\S CLAIM TO OMNISCI5CE4 ,HE KN[S :Y ! ,G]MAN WORK+ CLASS SUPPORT$ L4LITLET -- BECAUSE IT 0FELT RI<T40 LF !Y HAD ONLY POSSESS$ HIS CAPACITY = PURE & CORRECT REASON !Y W\LD NOT HAVE DONE ?AT4 LT IS CURI\S ?AT AT LEA/ SOME ( ! AN>*I/S AT ,CASAS ,VIEJAS 9 ,SPA9 ?\<T !MSELVES IRRATIONAL AFT] ! FACT ( ! FAIL$ REBELLION AGA9/ ,SPA9I% AU?ORITIES4 ,BUT ,I'D WAG] ?AT ,*AZ W\LD HAVE SUPPORT$ !IR 0IRRATIONAL0 /RUGGLE EV5 ?\< 9 RETROSPECT ! UPRIS+ WAS C]TA9LY AGA9/ !IR 9T]E/ -- ESPECIALLY ?OSE :O DI$4 

,S9CE HIS TRACT CALLS ON PEOPLE TO DISP5SE ) C]TA9 ELEM5TS ( *OICE & SUBJECTIVITY & SETS \T TO E/ABLI% RA!R RIGID & AU/]E RULES ( BEHAVIOR ESPECIALLY ) REG>D TO WRITT5 MAT]IAL1 :AT'S TO /OP HIM1 %\LD HE EV] GET ! *ANCE1 & ?OSE :O HAVE SAID !Y AGREE ) HIM )\T QUALIFICATION1 FROM APPLY+ SIMIL> /&>DS = O!R ASPECTS ( LIFE LIKE >T & MUSIC -- A SORT ( ,AN>*I/ ,REALISM NOT UNLIKE ! ,SOCIALI/ V]SION4 ,WE %UDD] TO ?9K4 

,! ,T5 ,COMM&M5TS 

,HIS LA/ SECTION IS1 IRONICALLY 5\< = ?IS A!I/1 A ,T5 ,COMM&M5TS ( :AT ! POLITICALLY CORRECT AN>*I/ %\LD & MU/ DO 9 ORD] TO HAVE CR$IBILITY 9 ,BUFE'S EYES4 ,IF Y\ ,S91 Y\ WON'T BE ALL[$ 9TO ! ,*UR*1 & ! WAY TO ACCOMPLI% ATONEM5T = PA/ ,S9S IS UNCLE>4 

,9 ,COMM&M5T ,F\R HE SAYS ?AT 0WE MU/ REFUSE TO TOL]ATE P]SONAL ABUSE1 PHYSICAL H>ASSM5T4440 :I* HAPP5S TO BE :Y ,P,W HAS F\ND ITSELF 9 ! PICKLE IT IS 9 BECAUSE IT HAS DEALT \T SU* ABUSE REGUL>LY4 ,HE'S RI<T3 SU* ATTACKS HAVE POISON$ ! ATMOSPH]E & A NUMB] ( ?OSE :O HAVE BE5 SUBJECT$ TO !IR ABUSE HAVE SUPPORT$ EA* O!R DESPITE & EV5 BECAUSE ( O!R DIFF]5CES !Y HAVE4 

,9 ,COMM&M5T ,FIVE HE SAYS ?AT 0WE %\LD NOT C[] BEH9D PSEUDONYMS4440 BUT ?AT IS :AT HE DID AFT] HIS CALUMNY ) ,F,E -- :AT AFT] ALL W]E !Y GO+ TO DO ALL ! WAY 9 ,DETROIT4 ETC1 ETC1 ETC1 AD NAUSEUM4 

,IT IS HI<LY SIGNIFICANT ?AT ,*AZ'S DIATRIBE 5DS ) ! WORD 0PREA*10 S9CE ?AT IS ! ESS5CE ( :AT IS CONTA9$ 9 ,LI/51 ,AN>*I/6 ,FROM ! RANT AGA9/ 0DELIB]ATE SELF-M>G9ALIZATION0 ON PAGE #a TO ! ,T5 ,COMM&M5TS1 AS WRITT5 BY ! ,AN>*I/ ,LAWGIV] AT ! 5D1 ! TONE IS ( A MORAL F]VOR ?AT REM9DS ONE MORE ( AN EVANGELI/ ?AN AN ANTI-MY/IC RATIONALI/4 ,SADLY1 ONCE ALL IS SAID & DONE1 ?IS EVANGELI/ PREA*] )\T A ,*UR* LOOK+ = PULPIT1 LIKE ALL O!R EVANGELI/S1 IS ULTIMATELY ONLY WOR? IGNOR+ &_/OR LAU<+ AT AS ! SELF@>@>P>ODY IT IS4 

"9 "9 "9 

,! OP9IONS EXPRESS$ 9 ! ABOVE RESPONSE %\LD NOT BE CON/RU$ AS O!R ?AN ?OSE ( ! AU?ORS4 ,!Y ESPECIALLY %\LD NOT BE CONSID]$ TO BE ! OP9IONS ( ANY O!R ,B\ND ,TOGE!R MEMB]S4 

,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,APRIL #b#d1 #bb 3 ,HOLD ,Y\R ,TONGUE ,DEMAGOGUE -- ,ADD$4 
,JANU>Y #d1 #bbb 3 ,HOLD ,Y\R ,TONGUE ,DEMAGOGUE -- ,UPDAT$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/