,I ,ACCUSE ,?IS ,LIB]AL ,UNIV]SITY ( ,T]ROR & ,VIOL5CE #aifi ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,FR$Y ,P]LMAN ,TEXT 3 ,ON ,FEBRU>Y #b#d?1 #a#i#f#i1 A RADICAL /UD5T WAS >RE/$ AT H] HOME E>LY 9 ! MORN+ & TAK5 TO ! ,KALAMAZOO ,JAIL4 ,%E WAS *>G$ ) 0ASSAULT & BATT]Y0 = DEF5D+ H]SELF FROM ! 9SI/5T H>ASSM5T & 9SULTS ( A /UD5T :O OPPOS$ H] ,P,O,L,I,T,I,C,S3 HE 9SULT$ H] BECAUSE %E HAD D>$ TO QUE/ION A ,POLITICAL ,SCI5CE ,PR(ESSOR & HAD TRI$ TO ,P,R,O,V,O,K,E ,D,I,S,C,U,S,S,I,O,N AMONG /UD5TS 9 A UNIV]SITY4 ,! ,POLITICAL ,SCI5CE ,PR(ESSOR DID NOT ANSW] ! QUE/IONS %E RAIS$2 HE RESPOND$ ) ,V,I,O,L,5,C,E3 HE HAD H] SUMMON$ TO A ,DEAN & A ,DISCIPL9>Y ,BO>D TO SUSP5D H] FROM S*OOL = 0DISRUPT+0 HIS CLASS1 & HE PR\DLY ANN\NC$ ?AT %E W\LD BE >RE/$ BY ! ,POLICE ,= ,V,I,O,L,5,C,E AGA9/ HIS 0GOOD0 /UD5T4 ,= TRY+ TO QUE/ION HIS C\RSE1 ! ,POLITICAL ,SCI5CE ,PR(ESSOR IS HAV+ H] ?R[N \T ( S*OOL & TRI$ = A CRIME2 ONCE HE TRANS=MS H] 9TO AN 0\TSID]0 & A 0CRIM9AL10 %E WILL NO LONG] BE ABLE TO QUE/ION HIS C\RSE3 HE CAN !N HAVE ! 0CRIM9AL \TSID]0 >RE/$ M]ELY = BE+ 9 ! UNIV]SITY4 ,9 #aifh TWO RADICAL PR(ESSORS 7,B4,R4 ,RAFF]TY & ,I7 W]E FIR$ BY ! ,ECONOMICS ,DEP>TM5T & ! ,S*OOL ( ,G5]AL ,/UDIES ( ?IS ,LIB]AL ,UNIV]SITY4 ,! REASONS W]E NOT WRITT5 D[N2 V]BALLY WE W]E ACCUS$ ( BE+ 0,UNOBJECTIVE1 ,DOGMATIC1 ,VULG>1 ,VIOL5T1 ,/AL9I/1 ,EXTREMI/4440 ,IF WE HAD REACT$ TO ! /REAM ( 9SULTS & DEF5D$ \RSELVES1 WE W\LD HAVE BE5 >RE/$ BY ! ,CITY ,POLICE = 0ASSAULT & BATT]Y40 7,I HAVE REC5TLY BE5 9=M$ ?AT ,I AM TO BE >RE/$ ON ! *>GE ( 0CONSPIRACY0 = FIE TAK+ PLACE ,N,[ AT ,?,I,S ,U,N,I,V,],S,I,T,Y1 :]E ! MAJORITY ( PR(ESSORS & /UD5TS >E ,L,I,B,],A,L4 ,! REPRESSION ( 0H]ESY0 IS NOT BE+ C>RI$ \T BY ,REACTION>IES OR 0RIX1 ,C4 ,WRIA1 & IS 0SYMPA!TIC 0 TO !M4 ,IT'S PRECISELY ,B,E,C,A,U,S,E ,H,E ,E,X,P,O,S,$ ,! ,L,I,B,],A,L ?AT ,RAFF]TY HAD TO BE DE/ROY$4 ,! ,LIB]AL SAYS HE HAS MORE 0SYMPA?Y0 = ! ,EXTREME ,LEFT ?AN = ! ,EXTREME ,RITM5T1 ! ,9TELLECTUAL ,LIB]AL NO LONG] HAS 0SYMPA?Y40 ,! RADICAL 9 ,H,I,S DEP>TM5T IS NOT A 0S*OL>0 BUT A 0,VULG> ,M>XI/10 HE'S NOT AN 09TELLECTUAL0 BUT A 0PROPAG&I/02 HE'S NOT 0OBJECTIVE0 BUT 0,DOGMATIC02 HE'S NOT A 0,!ORI/0 BUT A 0,N9ETE5? ,C5TURY ,M>XI/40 ,RAFF]TY'S 9SI,E ,E,X,T,R,E,M,I,/ ,T,],M,S ,C,\,*,$ ,9 ,A 0,M,O,D,],A,T,E0 ,L,A,N,G,U,A,G,E3 ?AT 0,VULG> ,M>XI/0 MEANS3 0,?R[ HIM \T60 ,:5 ! ,LIB]AL ,9TELLECTUAL MILDLY CALLS SOMEONE A ,VULG> ,M>XI/1 OR A ,DOGMATIC ,LEFTI/ ,PROPAG&I/1 HE'S NOT SIMPLY /AT+ HIS 0MOD]ATE DISAGREEM5T0 ) SOMEONE1 ! WAY HE DOES :5 HE SAYS 0,HE'S A CONV9C$ ,KEYNESIAN0 OR 0,HE'S A /UBBORN ,>I/OTELIAN02 HE'S MAK+ AN EXTREMI/ & FANATICAL /ATEM5T :I* MEANS3 ,H,E',S ,A ,V,U,L,G,> ,M,>,X,I,/ ,& ,D,O,E,S,N',T ,B,E,L,O,N,G ,9 ,?,I,S ,D,E,P,>,T,M,5,T6 ,H,E',S ,N,O,T ,O,B,J,E,C,T,I,V,E ,& ,%,\,L,D,N',T ,T,E,A,* ,9 ,A,N,Y ,U,N,I,V,],S,I,T,Y3 ,H,E',S ,A ,D,O,G,M,A,T,I,C ,L,E,F,T,I,/ ,& ,M,U,/ ,B,E ,/,O,P,P,$ ,F,R,O,M ,E,>,N,+ ,A,N ,9,C,O,M,E2 ,H,E ,M,U,/ ,B,E ,K,I,L,L,$6 0,VULG>0 MEANS ,D,I,R,T,Y & ,C,O,M,M,O,N2 ! 0,VULG> ,M>XI/0 OR 0,VULG> ,LEFTI/ ,PROPAG&I/0 IS SOMEONE :OSE IDEAS >E NOT BAS$ ON 0,PURE ,RESE>*0 BUT ON ,D,I,R,T,Y ,R,E,A,L,I,T,Y2 SOMEONE :O DOES NOT WRITE = ! ,SOPHI/ICAT$ ,AUDI5CE ( ,S*OL>LY ,J\RNALS 7= ,PURE ,ACADEMICS & = ! TOP BUREAUCRATS ( ,CORPORATIONS & ! ,/ATE :O PAY = !SE J\RNALS72 ! 0,VULG> ,LEFTI/0 WRITES = ! ,D,I,R,T,Y ,P,E,O,P,L,E ,9 ,! ,/,R,E,E,T4 0,VULG> ,M>XI/10 & 0,UNOBJECTIVE0 & 0HE DOESN'T CONSID] BO? SIDES10 MEAN3 ,I,T ,I,S ,L,E,G,I,T,I,M,A,T,E ,T,O ,?,R,[ ,H,I,M ,\,T6 ,!SE /ATEM5TS >E ,I,D,E,O,L,O,G,I,C,A,L ,W,E,A,P,O,N,S ,:,I,* ,J,U,/,I,F,Y ,! ,E,X,C,L,U,S,I,O,N ,( ,A ,R,A,D,I,C,A,L ,F,R,O,M ,A ,U,N,I,V,],S,I,T,Y4 ,REACTION>IES DID NOT FIRE ,RAFF]TY OR MYSELF FROM ! ,ECONOMICS ,DEP>TM5T ( ,WE/]N ,MI*IGAN ,UNIV]SITY2 ,L,I,B,],A,L,S ,F,I,R,$ ,U,S 79 ,LIB]AL J>GON1 !Y DIDN'T 0FIRE0 US2 !Y M]ELY DIDN'T 0REHIRE0 US74 ,& ,I,T ,I,S ,N,O,T ,R,E,A,C,T,I,O,N,>,I,E,S ,:,O ,>,E ,H,>,A,S,S,+ ,/,U,D,5,T,S ,T,O,D,A,Y4 ,LIB]AL ,PR(ESSORS 9ITIAT$ ! SLOGAN CAMPAIGN & RU%$ US \T BE=E WE HAD ! TIME OR ! PSY*OLOGICAL COMPOSURE TO REPLY2 ,LIB]AL ,PR(ESSORS JU/IFI$ \R ELIM9ATION1 A YE> BE=E WE W]E FIR$1 ) ! 0MOD]ATE0 ACCUSATIONS ( ,UNOBJECTIVE1 ,DOGMATIC1 ,VULG>4 "9 "9 ,! ,REACTION>Y1 :O OP5LY ID5TIFIES ) ! PROJECT ( ,BIG ,BUS9ESS1 /RAIDLY RECOGNIZES ! RADICAL AS A ?REAT TO HIS PROJECT4 ,HE IS OV]T & HONE/ :5 HE SAYS 0,?OSE RADICALS WANT TO DE/ROY ,CIVILIZATION0 7BY :I* HE MEANS HIS CORPORATE-CAPITALI/ SOCIETY71 0& ,!,R,E,=,E !Y MU/ BE DE/ROY$40 ,& HE MEANS ,D,E,/,R,O,Y,$--?R\< VIOL5CE3 ! POLICE MU/ GET !M1 & !Y MU/ BE LOCK$ UP OR %OT OR BO?4 ,! ,REACTION>Y KN[S ?AT :5 ,HE EXCLUDES A RADICAL FROM ! UNIV]SITY1 ALL HIS 0,FELL[ ,REACTION>IES0 >E PL$G$ TO DO ! SAME4 ,UNLIKE ! ,REACTION>Y1 ! ,LIB]AL DOES NOT CALL = T]ROR & VIOL5CE OV]TLY BUT COV]TLY2 HE DOES NOT CALL = VIOL5CE ALL AT ONCE BUT 9 /AGES4 ,HE DOES NOT SAY 0,EXCLUDE HIM FROM ! ,UNIV]SITY0 BUT 0,DON'T R5EW HIS CONTRACT40 ,UNLIKE ! ,REACTION>Y ! ,LIB]AL MA9TA9S A GOOD CONSCI5CE BY TELL+ HIMSELF HE HAS NO 9T5TION TO EXCLUDE ! RADICAL FROM ALL UNIV]SITIES3 HE M]ELY DOESN'T WANT ! RADICAL BACK 9 0HIS0 DEP>TM5T4 ,! ,LIB]AL DOES NOT ADMIT1 EV5 TO HIMSELF1 ?AT HE IS A MEMB] ( A GR\P2 HE DOES NOT LIKE TO BE CALL$ A ,LIB]AL2 HE DOES NOT ADMIT1 EV5 TO HIMSELF1 ?AT ,LIB]ALS RUN O!R DEP>TM5TS & O!R UNIV]SITIES1 ?AT ,LIB]ALS RUN ! DOM9ANT HI]>*IES ( ,AM]ICAN SOCIETY2 HE DOES NOT ADMIT ?AT ,H,I,S ,P,[,] ,C,O,M,E,S ,F,R,O,M ,! ,F,A,C,T ,?,A,T ,O,!,R ,L,I,B,],A,L,S ,W,I,L,L ,B,A,C,K ,H,I,M ,U,P4 ,UNLIKE ! ,REACTION>Y1 HE DOES NOT ADMIT ?AT :5 HE FIRES A RADICAL HE EXPECTS O!R ,LIB]ALS TO DO ! SAME4 ,! ,LIB]AL'S 0LIB]ALISM0 IS AN IDEOLOGY :I* 9=MS HIM ?AT HE'S AN 09DIVIDUAL0 :O EXI/S 9 A VACUUM1 & ?AT HIS DECISION DOES NOT B9D ANYONE ELSE4 ,HE D5IES ?AT ALL ,LIB]ALS >E B\ND TO ONE ,LIB]AL'S DECISION4 ,HE LIES TO HIMSELF3 IF IT EV] HAPP5$ ?AT A GR\P ( ,LIB]ALS REHIR$ ! RADICAL & FIR$ ! ,LIB]AL1 ! ,LIB]AL W\LD %\T 0,WE ALL AGREE ?AT4440 & 0,\R BASIC PR9CIPLE IS4440 & 0,H[ CAN WE TOL]ATE SU* A BLATANT D5IAL ( \R MO/ SACR$4440--9 O!R WORDS1 0,W,E',R,E ,A,L,L ,P,L,$,G,$ ,T,O ,A,C,T ,T,O,G,E,!,R02 0,W,E',R,E ,M,E,M,B,],S ,( ,! ,S,A,M,E ,G,R,\,P02 0,W,E',R,E ,A,L,L ,5,G,A,G,$ ,9 ,! ,S,A,M,E ,P,R,O,J,E,C,T0--& ! PROJECT IS ! CONT9U$ FUNCTION+ ( ! CORPORATE-MILIT>Y SY/EM4 ,CONSEQU5TLY1 IF ONE ,LIB]AL SPOTS A RADICAL1 HE SPOTS HIM = ALL ,LIB]ALS2 HE SP>ES !M ! TR\BLE ( SPOTT+ HIM4 ,! ,LIB]AL'S ,L,I,E IS TO TELL HIMSELF ?AT ,! ,O,!,R,S >E NOT B\ND TO EXCLUDE ! RADICAL 0JU/ BECAUSE 0 HE EXCLUDES HIM4 ,BY HIS PHILOSOPHY1 ! ,O!RS1 LIKE HIMSELF1 >E ,PURE ,9DIVIDUALS ,:O ,MAY ,HIRE ,HIM ,EV5 ,IF ,I ,FIRE ,HIM4 "9 "9 ,! ,REACTION>Y DOES NOT CLAIM TO BE 0NEUTRAL03 HE'S OV]TLY PRO-,CAPITALI/2 HE'S AN >D5T SUPPORT] ( EV]Y ,AM]ICAN CORPORATE & MILIT>Y BUREAUCRACY2 HE'S OP5LY FIE PRES5TLY DOM9ANT1 & HE OV]TLY WANTS TO ELIM9ATE ANY REAL ?REATS TO ?AT P[]4 ,! ,LIB]AL CLAIMS TO BE 0NEUTRAL0 & 0OBJECTIVE02 HE CLAIMS ?AT HE'S ,N,E,I,!,R ON ! SIDE ( ! 0E/ABLI%M5T0 NOR ON ! 0O!R SIDE02 HE CLAIMS ?AT HE'S NOT ON ANY SIDE3 HE'S NOT 9 SOCIETY BUT ABOVE IT4 ,H[EV]1 TO ! ,LIB]AL1 ONLY ! ACTION ( ! CORPORATE-MILIT>Y BUREAUCRACY IS 0LEGITIMATE02 ! ACTION ( ! RADICAL IS NOT4 ,& JU/ LIKE ! ,REACTION>Y1 ! ,LIB]AL ?9KS ( ! ACTION ( RADICALS ,A,S ,A ,?,R,E,A,T1 :I* MEANS ?AT ! ,LIB]AL SEES HIMSELF ,O,N ,! ,D,O,M,9,A,N,T ,S,I,D,E1 ! SIDE ?AT'S ?REAT5$4 ,HE DOES NOT RECOGNIZE ! PROVOCATIONS ( ! BUREAUCRACY AS PROVOCATIONS2 ONLY ! ACTIONS ( RADICALS >E PROVOCATIONS4 ,! ,LIB]AL ACCEPTS ! RULES ( ! DOM9ANT BUREAUCRACY1 & HE DEF5DS ?OSE RULES4 ,HE'S NOT 0OBJECTIVE40 ,A *ALL5GE ( ! DOM9ANT RULES IS1 = HIM1 A 0PROVOCATION40 ,! ,LIB]AL MOVES ,),9 ,! ,D,O,M,9,A,N,T ,B,U,R,E,A,U,C,R,A,C,Y2 HIS SUCCESS COMES FROM ,P,L,E,A,S,+ ,! ,P,E,O,P,L,E ,:,O ,>,E ,O,N ,T,O,P4 ,! ,LIB]AL 7:E!R PR(ESSOR OR /UD5T7 CLIMBS ,),9 ,! ,H,I,],>,*,Y & HE WANTS TO DO SO ,) ,A ,G,O,O,D ,C,O,N,S,C,I,5,C,E4 ,! SO-CALL$ 0RADICAL SYMPA?IES0 ( ! ,LIB]AL >E HIS MEANS TO MA9TA9 A GOOD CONSCI5CE :ILE SELL+ HIMSELF TO ?OSE 9 P[]4 ,! ,LIB]AL'S GREATE/ FE>1 9 FACT1 IS TO BECOME 0AN \TSID]02 HE WANTS TO BE AN 09SID]0 :O IS ,GOOD & ,MORAL1 ,JU/ & ,OBJECTIVE4 ,! ,LIB]AL REJECTS ,IMP]IALISM1 ,PATRIOTISM1 ,RACISM1 & EV5 ,CAPITALISM--,9 ,W,O,R,D,S1 BUT NEV] 9 ACTIONS2 & HE KN[S ! L9E BETWE5 WORDS & ACTIONS4 ,WORDS MAKE IT POSSIBLE = HIM TO BE A ,G,O,O,D ,P,],S,O,N2 ACTION W\LD MAKE HIM AN ,\,T,S,I,D,]4 ,?AT'S :Y ! RADICAL IS A ?REAT TO ! ,LIB]AL2 ,H,E ,=,C,E,S ,! ,L,I,B,],A,L ,T,O ,*,O,O,S,E4 ,9 ! FACE ( A RADICAL1 ! ,LIB]AL IS =C$ TO *OOSE BETWE5 ACT+ ON HIS 0PR9CIPLES0 7& !RE=E BECOM+ AN 0\TSID]071 OR ACCEPT+ ! DOM9ANT BUREAUCRACY4 ,! M]E PRES5CE ( ! RADICAL EXPOSES ! 0NEUTRALITY0 ( ! ,LIB]AL3 ,H,E ,*,O,O,S,E,S ,T,O ,A,C,C,E,P,T ,! ,D,O,M,9,A,N,T ,B,U,R,E,A,U,C,R,A,C,Y4 ,! ,LIB]AL DOES NOT SEE HIMSELF AS A DEHUMANIZ$ FACTOR 9 A BUREAUCRATIC /RUCTURE3 HIS EXI/5CE AS A HUMAN BE+ & HIS POSITION 9 ! HI]>*Y >E ! SAME TO HIM4 ,?,A,T',S ,:,Y HE CANNOT ID5TIFY ) ! RADICAL4 ,= ! RADICAL1 ! PROVOCATIONS ( ! BUREAUCRACY REA* A ,L,I,M,I,T BEYOND :I* !Y'RE NO LONG] ACCEPTABLE3 !Y NEGATE HIS EXI/5CE AS A HUMAN BE+ & HE FI*Y 7S9CE HE ,I,S AN 0ASSOCIATE PR(ESSOR10 A 0DIRECTOR10 ETC471 S9CE HE ACCEPTS HIMSELF AS A SLOT & TITLE 9 ! BUREAUCRACY1 HE CANNOT BE PROVOK$ BY ! BUREAUCRACY2 HIS HUMANITY CANNOT BE NEGAT$ BY ! BUREAUCRACY ,B,E,C,A,U,S,E ,H,E ,N,E,G,A,T,E,S ,I,T ,H,I,M,S,E,L,F4 ,= HIM !RE'S ALSO A LIMIT3 ?IS LIMIT IS REA*$ :5 AN 0\TSID]0 ?REAT5S ! BUREAUCRACY4 "9 "9 ,= ! ,LIB]AL1 ! ,L,I,M,I,T IS REA*$ :5 A WRITT5 OR UNWRITT5 0RULE0 ( ! BUREAUCRACY IS BROK51 A ,L,I,M,I,T :I* IS CROSS$ BY ANY RADICAL AS SOON AS HE ACTS4 ,?IS ,LIMIT IS1 9 FACT1 COMPLETELY >BITR>Y3 ! FACT ( 0CROSS+ ! LIMIT0 IS :AT 5ABLES ! ,LIB]AL TO JU/IFY REPRESSION3 0,Y\ CAN >GUE1 BUT Y\ HAVE TO PRES5T BO? SIDES10 0,Y\ CAN GIVE \T LEAFLETS 9 ! HALL1 BUT NOT 9 ! CLASSROOM40 ,! ,LIMIT1 ! ,L9E1 IS NOT AN ACTION ( ! BUREAUCRACY :I* GOES BEYOND ! LIMIT ( HUMAN DEC5CY2 ! ,L9E IS AN ACTION ( A RADICAL :I* *ALL5GES ! PEACEFUL & ORD]LY FUNCTION+ ( ! DOM9ANT SY/EM4 ,& :5 ! ,LIB]AL DRAWS ?IS L9E1 :]EV] HE DRAWS IT1 ,H,E ,J,U,/,I,F,I,E,S ,! ,E,L,I,M,9,A,T,I,O,N ,( ,! ,O,N,E ,:,O ,C,R,O,S,S,$ ,! ,L,9,E4 ,?IS ,LIMIT IS A JU/IFICATION ( ,V,I,O,L,5,C,E4 ,:5 ! ,LIB]AL SAYS3 0,IT'S ALL RITICUL> CASE HE DID SU* & SU* & W5T TOO F>4440 ,HE ALWAYS HAS REASONS TO ACCEPT EV]Y ,C,O,N,C,R,E,T,E LYN*+ ?AT TAKES PLACE1 :ILE ,P,H,I,L,O,S,O,P,H,I,C,A,L,L,Y HE REMA9S OPPOS$ TO LYN*+1 :I* HE SAYS IS 0HORRIBLE & A CRIME40 ,! ,LIB]AL ,PR(ESSOR IS AGA9/ H>ASSM5T & P]SECUTION ( /UD5TS2 HE HAS ALL K9DS ( ,CIVIL ,LIB]T>IAN PR9CIPLES AB\T IT4 ,HE'S AGA9/ SUPPRESS+ ANYONE'S FRE$OM ( SPEE*4 ,BUT ! SAME ,LIB]AL IS AMONG ! FIR/ TO SUPPORT ! EXPULSION ( A RADICAL /UD5T2 HE WAS AMONG ! FIR/ TO SUPPORT ! FIR+ ( ,RAFF]TY & MYSELF 7& MANY O!RS74 ,HIS ,P,R,9,C,I,P,L,E,S >E BEAUTIFUL3 !Y CAN ALL BE FRAM$4 ,ONE CAN KN[ :O ! ,REACTION>Y IS FROM :AT HE SAYS2 BUT :AT ! ,LIB]AL SAYS GIVES NO CLUE TO :O HE IS4 "9 "9 ,! ,LIB]AL ,PR(ESSOR SP5DS HIS LIFE MANIPULAT+ /UD5TS TO FIT ! REQUIREM5TS ( A CORPORATE OR /ATE BUREAUCRACY2 HIS RELATIONS ) PEOPLE >E MANIPULATIVE RELATIONS4 ,HE PROGRAMS /UD5TS4 ,! PROGRAM HE 9JECTS 9TO !M IS 0,SCI5CE0 7I4E4 ,T,R,U,?74 ,HE 9JECTS ?IS PROGRAM 9TO /UD5TS BY MEANS ( ,M,A,N,I,P,U,L,A,T,I,O,N4 ,HE ASSUMES ?AT MANIPULATIVE RELATIONS >E ! ONLY POSSIBLE HUMAN RELATIONS3 HE /IMULATES & PUNI%ES /UD5TS ) TE/S & GRADES2 HE BLACKMAILS MALE /UD5TS ) ! ?REAT ( 9DUCTION 9TO ! MILIT>Y1 & :5 !SE ME?ODS FAIL1 HE CALLS ON ! POLICE4 ,! ,LIB]AL 0TOL]ATES0 O!R 0OP9IONS40 ,H[EV]1 0OP9IONS0 >E SOME?+ LESS ?AN ,T,R,U,?1 & ! 0TOL]ATION ( SU* OP9IONS ,H,A,S ,A ,L,I,M,I,T4 ,AN 9DIVIDUAL PR(ESSOR MAY LEGITIMATELY BE 0HET]ODOX02 HE MAY LEGITIMATELY HOLD 0H]ETICAL VIEWS02 ,B,U,T ,H,E ,M,U,/ ,N,O,T ,C,O,M,M,U,N,I,C,A,T,E ,!,S,E ,V,I,E,W,S ,T,O ,/,U,D,5,T,S4 ,S9CE1 = ! ,LIB]AL1 COMMUNICATION CAN ONLY TAKE PLACE BY MEANS ( MANIPULATION1 ! COMMUNICATION ( 0H]ESY0 ,M,U,/ TAKE PLACE BY MEANS ( MANIPULATION4 ,H[EV]1 :5 0TOL]AT$ OP9IONS0 >E COMMUNICAT$ TO /UD5TS1 ! /UD5TS >E NOT $UCAT$ 7S9CE ONLY ,T,R,U,? CAN $IFY72 !Y >E ,M,I,S,L,$4 ,CONSEQU5TLY1 IF /UD5TS RESI/ !IR [N DEHUMANIZATION1 IT IS ONLY BECAUSE !Y W]E ,M,I,S,L,$ BY 0\TSIDE AGITATORS0 & 0,VULG> ,M>XI/S40 ,! ,LIB]AL DOES NOT GIVE /UD5TS CR$IT = BE+ ABLE TO DRAW !IR [N CONCLUSION AB\T :AT HE DOES TO !M4 ,FUR!RMORE1 IF ! ,LIB]AL CANNOT SEE ! ,9,/,R,U,M,5,T,S ) :I* 0H]ESIES0 >E COMMUNICAT$1 IF HE CANNOT SEE ! TE/S1 ! GRADES1 ! BLACKMAIL & ! 9TIMIDATION1 HE DOES NOT CONCLUDE ?AT ! COMMUNICATION IS NOT MANIPULATIVE 7SOME?+ UNKN[N TO HIM72 HE CONCLUDES ?AT ,! ,9,/,R,U,M,5,T,S ,= ,S,U,* ,M,A,N,I,P,U,L,A,T,I,O,N ,M,U,/ ,B,E ,D,E,M,O,N,I,C4 ,CONSEQU5TLY ONE :O REJECTS ! (FICIAL DOCTR9E1 ONE :O REJECTS ! ,*UR*'S ,T,R,U,?1 IS A ,SATANIC ,M,I,S,L,E,A,D,] ( 9NOC5T S\LS1 A ,PI$ ,PIP] :O 5TICES 9NOC5T SPIRITS /RAILI] C5TURIES1 ,M,U,/ ,B,E ,D,E,/,R,O,Y,$4 ,AS SOON AS ! ,LIB]AL JU/IFIES ! USE ( VIOL5CE AGA9/ A RADICAL1 HE CALLS ! RADICAL ,V,I,O,L,5,T4 ,ANO!R ( ,RAFF]TY'S 9SIE ,P,U,R,E ,P,R,O,J,E,C,T,I,O,N,S ,( ,H,I,S ,[,N ,V,I,O,L,5,C,E4 ,IT IS PRECISELY :5 HE'S 9 ! ACT ( EXCLUD+ ! RADICAL BY MEANS ( VIOL5CE ?AT ! ,LIB]AL %\TS 0,V,I,O,L,5,C,E60 ,! RADICAL IS EXCLUD$ QUICKLY1 9 ! D>K1 UND] ! COV] ( BUREAUCRATIC PRETEXTS1 BE=E HE'S ABLE TO REACT4 ,! ,LIB]AL KN[S AB\T ! 9]TIA ?AT *>ACT]IZES DAILY LIFE2 HE KN[S ?AT A C\NT]-ATTACK AGA9/ SY/EMATIC EXCLUSION CANNOT BE QUICKLY ORGANIZ$4 ,HE C\NTS ON ! RADICAL'S PHYSICAL OR PSY*OLOGICAL 9ABILITY TO LAUN* A C\NT]-ATTACK4 ,H[EV]1 ! ,LIB]AL IS ,9 ,F,A,C,T 7IF NOT BY *OICE7 A HUMAN BE+1 & CANNOT KEEP HIMSELF FROM KN[+ ?AT :AT HE HAS DONE TO ANO!R HUMAN BE+ IS HUMANLY UNACCEPTABLE & DEGRAD+4 ,HE KN[S ?AT ONE WAY ! RADICAL CAN REAFFIRM HIS DEGRAD$ HUMANITY IS BY TAK+ REV5GE4 7,AS ,FRANTZ ,FANON PO9T$ \T 9 ,! ,WRET*$ ( ! ,E>?1 ! ,COLONIZ] FE>S1 & PREP>ES =1 ! VIOL5CE ( ! ,COLONIZ$ ,B,E,=,E ,! ,C,O,L,O,N,I,Z,$ ,E,V,5 ,B,E,G,9,S ,T,O ,A,C,T1 PRECISELY BECAUSE HE KN[S ,:,A,T ,H,E ,W,\,L,D ,D,O ,I,F ,H,E ,W,],E ,9 ,! ,P,L,A,C,E ,( ,! ,C,O,L,O,N,I,Z,$47 ,?AT'S :Y HE YELLS ,V,I,O,L,5,C,E & FE>S IT4 ,! ,LIB]AL HAS DEHUMANIZ$ HIMSELF ,9 ,O,R,D,] TO DEHUMANIZE ! O!R1 BUT HE NEV]!LESS KN[S H[ HE W\LD REACT AS A HUMAN BE+3 :E!R ! SLAVE RETURNS ) A GUN OR NOT1 ,?,A,T',S ,:,A,T ,H,E ,%,\,L,D ,D,O4 ,?,A,T',S ,:,Y ! ,LIB]AL YELLS ,V,I,O,L,5,C,E AT SOMEONE :O HAS NEV] HELD A WEAPON 9 HIS H&4 7,! ,LIB]ALS ( ! ,W,M,U ,ECONOMICS ,DEP>TM5T YELL$ ,V,I,O,L,5,C,E AT PEOPLE :O HAD NOT YET TAK5 A /ICK AGA9/ ANYONE47 ,! ACCUSATION ( VIOL5CE IS NOT AN ANALYSIS ( :AT ! RADICAL ,D,O,E,S2 IT IS AN ANALYSIS ( :AT ! RADICAL ,%,\,L,D ,D,O IF HE W]E ABLE TO REACT 9 A HUMAN WAY4 ,! ,LIB]AL KN[S ?AT ,H,E IS UNABLE TO REACT AS A COMPLETE HUMAN BE+2 HE KN[S ?AT ,H,E DEHUMANIZES HIMSELF 9 ORD] TO ADVANCE2 HE KN[S ?AT ,H,E CANNOT /RUGGLE AGA9/ ! BUREAUCRACY TO AFFIRM HIS [N LIFE & HIS [N PROJECT4 ,& ! ,LIB]AL PROJECTS HIS 9ABILITY ON ! RADICAL1 ,& ,C,\,N,T,S ,O,N ,I,T4 ,= HIS [N ,PEACE & ,QUIET1 HE HAS TO C\NT ON ! PHYSICAL REPRESSION ,O,R ! PSY*OLOGICAL BREAKD[N ( ! RADICAL4 "9 "9 ,! BREAKD[N ( ! RADICAL IS1 9 FACT1 ! USUAL CONSEQU5CE ( REPRESSION4 ,:5 ?IS HAPP5S1 ! ,LIB]AL IS ,9,D,I,F,F,],5,T1 S9CE HE IS 9NOC5T1 & HE'S ,R,E,L,I,E,V,$1 S9CE ! RADICAL NO LONG] POSES A ?REAT ,:AT DOES ! /UD5T DO ONCE ?R[N \T ( ! UNIV]SITY8 ,BECOME A WAITRESS OR A BANK CL]K8 ,MOVE 9TO A 0HIPPIE COMMUNE80 ,OR BREAK D[N PSY*OLOGICALLY8 ,?AT'S NOT ! ,LIB]AL'S 0BUS9ESS40 ,A SOPHOMORE :O IS TOTALLY SICK5$ BY ! UNIV]SITY FREQU5TLY SEEKS 0ADVICE0 FROM A ,LIB]AL4 ,& ! ,LIB]AL BL&LY 0ADVISES0 ! /UD5T ?AT SOME ?+S CAN BE DONE1 ,B,U,T ,! ,/,U,D,5,T ,C,A,N,N,O,T ,G,O ,B,E,Y,O,N,D ,A ,C,],T,A,9 ,L,9,E4 ,IF HE DOES1 HE WILL BE ?R[N \T ( ! UNIV]SITY4 ,IF ! /UD5T TRIES TO FIE SO HUGE ?AT ! /UD5T MAY BREAK D[N4 ,& IT IS PRECISELY ! PSY*OLOGICAL BREAKD[N ( ?IS /UD5T ?AT ! ,LIB]AL C\NTS ON4 ,IF HE DIDN'T1 HE'D NEV] ?R[ ANYONE \T4 ,IF HE DIDN'T ?9K !SE /UD5TS W\LD BE PSY*OLOGICALLY DE/ROY$ & 9CAPACITAT$ EV5 BE=E ! POLICE GOT TO !M1 HE'D BE DEA?LY AFRAID TO ?R[ ANYONE \T2 HE'D KN[ ALL !SE PEOPLE W\LD BE BACK 9 0HORDES0 TO PU% ! ,LIB]ALS \T4 ,HE C\NTS ON ! PHYSICAL OR PSY*OLOGICAL DEA? ( !SE /UD5TS4 ,BUT HE IS NEV] ,R,E,S,P,O,N,S,I,B,L,E = ANY?+ ?AT HAPP5S TO A /UD5T :O ONCE S\N$ A GREAT DEAL EV5 9 ! CAPITALI/ UNIV]SITY1 BECOMES A WAITRESS = LIFE1 ! ,LIB]AL IS ,G,U,I,L,T,L,E,S,S3 NO?+ HE EV] DID L$ H] TO DO ?AT1 & 0NOT EV]YONE CAN BE A /UD5T 9 ANY CASE40 ,HE KN[S ?AT SOME RADICALS WILL1 H[EV] AWKW>DLY1 TRY TO FIASSM5TS1 ! >RE/S1 ! TRIALS1 ! JAIL+S ,>,E ,N,O,T ,V,I,O,L,5,C,E = ! ,LIB]AL4 ,ONLY ! RADICAL'S /RUGGLE TO MA9TA9 HIS HUMANITY IS ,V,I,O,L,5,C,E = ! ,LIB]AL2 ! RADICAL'S /RUGGLE TO REGA9 ! HUMANITY :I* ! ,LIB]AL DEPRIV$ HIM ( IS ,V,I,O,L,5,C,E4 ,?AT'S :Y1 :5 HE CRIES ,V,I,O,L,5,C,E1 HE'S SC>$3 0,MY JOB6 ,MY H\SE6 ,MY BOOKS60 ,ONCE ! RADICAL IS ?R[N \T1 HE'S NO LONG] 9 ! ,LIB]AL'S JURISDICTION3 HE'S AN 0\TSIDE AGITATOR10 & A 0CRIM9AL40 ,! ,\TSID] NO LONG] 0BELONGS0 9 ! ,LIB]AL'S UNIV]SITY4 ,MEMB]S ( ! ,COLUMBIA ,S,D,S ,*APT]1 = EXAMPLE1 >E N[ 0\TSIDE AGITATORS02 !Y >E 0NOT /UD5TS0 & CONSEQU5TLY 0HAVE NO RI ,!,Y ,W,],E ,/,U,D,5,T,S ,( ,C,O,L,U,M,B,I,A ,U,N,I,V,],S,I,T,Y2 !Y W]E ?R[N \T BY ,LIB]ALS1 & IF !Y RETURN TO FIRE/$ BY COPS4 ,CONSEQU5TLY1 ANYONE :O OBJECTS & :O FITM5T4 ,IF HE WAS JAIL$ OR %OT BY ! ,POLICE1 ,?,A,T',S ,N,O,T ,M,Y ,C,O,N,C,],N2 ,I',M ,C,O,M,P,L,E,T,E,L,Y ,9,N,O,C,5,T6 ,I ,D,I,D,N',T ,H,A,V,E ,A,N,Y,?,+ ,T,O ,D,O ,) ,?,A,T1 & 9 ANY CASE1 ?AT M]ELY %[S :AT K9D ( P]SON ,H,E REALLY WAS40 ,! ,LIB]AL'S PROJECT IS TO EXCLUDE ! RADICAL FROM SOCIETY1 BUT HE DOES NOT TAKE RESPONSIBILITY = ! PROJECT2 HE REALIZES HIS PROJECT 9 /AGES1 BUT HE IS ONLY RESPONSIBLE = ! 09NOC5T0 FIR/ /AGE4 ,O,!,R,S ,D,O ,! ,R,E,/4 ,! ,LIB]AL M]ELY 9ITIATES ! PROCESS1 & IS NOT RESPONSIBLE = :AT ! O!RS DO4 ,! ,REACTION>Y HITS ! RADICAL DIRECTLY2 ! ,LIB]AL DOES NOT DO HIS [N HITT+4 ,! ,LIB]AL M]ELY ,P,R,O,V,O,K,E,S ! RADICAL UNTIL HE RESPONDS TO ! PROVOCATION1 & :5 HE RESPONDS1 ,! ,C,O,P,S ,G,E,T ,! ,R,A,D,I,C,A,L4 ,! ,LIB]AL MA9TA9S HIS GOOD CONSCI5CE3 ,H,E DIDN'T ACT--! RADICAL ACT$2 ,H,E DIDN'T REPRESS ! RADICAL--! COPS DID4 ,! ,L,I,B,],A,L ,I,S ,A,L,W,A,Y,S ,9,N,O,C,5,T2 HIS ONLY DESIRE IS PEACE & QUIET4 ,! ,REACTION>Y ?R[S \T A RADICAL & !N HAS HIM >RE/$ = ,LOIT]+ OR ,CONSPIRACY OR \TSIDE ,AGITATION IF ! RADICAL RETURNS TO FIY 0EGGS ON0 & H>ASSES UNTIL ! RADICAL IS PROVOK$ TO HIT BACK1 & !N HAS HIM >RE/$ = ,ASSAULT & ,BATT]Y2 ! ,REACTION>Y TRIES TO EXCLUDE ! RADICAL FROM ANY S\RCES ( 9COME 9 ORD] TO HAVE HIM LOCK$ UP AS A ?IEF4 ,TO ! ,REACTION>Y1 ! RADICAL IS ,A,L,R,E,A,D,Y ,A ,C,R,I,M,9,A,L ,:,5 ,H,E ,E,X,P,R,E,S,S,E,S ,H,I,S ,?,\,<,T,S ,! ,LIB]AL KN[S JU/ AS WELL AS ! ,REACTION>Y ?AT 0,! COPS'LL GET 'IM02 ,H,E ,C,\,N,T,S ,O,N ,! ,C,O,P,S ,T,O ,P,R,O,T,E,C,T ,H,I,S ,P,E,A,C,E ,& ,Q,U,I,E,T2 BUT1 AS ,RAFF]TY REPEAT$LY OBS]V$1 ,! ,L,I,B,],A,L ,D,O,E,S,N',T ,W,A,N,T ,T,O ,S,E,E ,! ,C,O,P,S ,:,O ,P,R,O,T,E,C,T ,H,I,M4 ,! ,LIB]AL CAN BE COMP>$ TO ! ,M$IEVAL ,*UR*4 ,! ,*UR* EXCOMMUNICAT$ A H]ETIC1 BUT DID NOT ITSELF PUT ! H]ETIC TO DEA?4 ,! ,CIVIL ,AU?ORITY1 ! ,SECUL> ,AU?ORITY1 TOOK *>GE ( ! H]ETIC'S BODY4 ,! ,*UR* WAS 9NOC5T2 ! ,CIVIL ,AU?ORITIES & ! ,EXECUTION] W]E ! ONES RESPONSIBLE = PHYSICAL EXT]M9ATION4 ,! EXCOMMUNICATORS ( ! ,*UR* MA9TA9$ CLEAN CONSCI5CES4 ,?US ALSO ! ,LIB]AL3 ,ALL HE DOES IS TO EXCOMMUNICATE ! RADICAL1 TO EXCLUDE HIM 0SPIRITUALLY02 ! ,CIVIL ,AU?ORITIES DO ! RE/4 ,AT EV]Y S+LE /EP HE APPLIES SY/EMATIC T]ROR & VIOL5CE1 & AT EV]Y S+LE /EP HE MANAGES TO MA9TA9 HIS CLEAN CONSCI5CE4 ,! ,LIB]AL ,A,L,R,E,A,D,Y ,K,N,[,S ?AT :5 HIS 0,LEFTI/ ,COLLEAGUE0 IS AN UNEMPLOY$ RADICAL HE WILL DO SOME?+ = :I* IT WILL BE LEGITIMATE TO ?R[ HIM 9 JAIL1 BUT ! ,LIB]AL DOESN'T WANT TO BE AW>E ?AT ,H,I,S ,P,E,A,C,E ,& ,Q,U,I,E,T ,>,E ,M,A,9,T,A,9,$ ,?,R,\,< ,T,],R,O,R,I,S,M ,& ,V,I,O,L,5,C,E4 ,9 O!R WORDS1 ! ,LIB]AL'S WEAPONS >E ! SAME AS ! REACTION>Y'S2 ! ONLY DIFF]5CE BETWE5 !M IS ?AT ! ,LIB]AL DOESN'T LOOK1 & HAS A GOOD CONSCI5CE4 ,HE'S 0TOL]ANT10 HE 0READS RADICAL LIT]ATURE10 HE'S ! 0ONLY ONE :O TALKS TO RADICALS10 HE'S ,M,O,R,A,L 9 EV]Y S+LE WAY2 HE GOES \T ( HIS WAY TO 0HELP RADICALS02 HE'LL DO EV]Y?+ = RADICALS :I* WILL HELP HIM KEEP HIS GOOD CONSCI5CE ,:,I,L,E ,H,E ,C,O,N,T,9,U,E,S ,T,O ,R,E,L,Y ,O,N ,T,],R,O,R ,& ,V,I,O,L,5,C,E4 ,LIB]AL PR(ESSORS & /UD5TS :OSE SITUATIONS CAN ONLY BE MA9TA9$ ?R\< T]ROR & VIOL5CE1 ?R\< SY/EMATIC PSY*OLOGICAL & PHYSICAL MURD]1 ADV]TISE 0,MAKE ,LOVE ,NOT ,W>40 ,LIB]AL /UD5TS :O HAVE ,A,L,R,E,A,D,Y ,*,O,S,5 TO HELP MA9TA9 ! DOM9ANT PROJECT :5 !IR TIME COMES1 >E BUSY 0ACCUMULAT+0 L>GE 0/OCKS0 ( GOOD CONSCI5CE :ILE !Y CAN1 :ILE !IR 0NEW /YLES ( LIFE0 DO NOT YET CONFLICT ) !IR FUTURE 0RESPONSIBILITIES40 ,LIB]ALS >E NOT 0MOD]ATE40 ,?AT'S !IR [N SELF-IMAGE4 ,!Y'RE EXTREMI/S1 BUT UNLIKE REACTION>IES1 ,!,Y',R,E ,E,X,T,R,E,M,I,/,S ,) ,G,O,O,D ,C,O,N,S,C,I,5,C,E,S4 ,!IR 9/RUM5TS >E NOT 0IDEAS02 !IR 9/RUM5TS >E ,T,],R,O,R & ,V,I,O,L,5,C,E4 ,BUT UNLIKE LYN*]S1 ,! ,L,I,B,],A,L,S ,T,U,R,N ,!,I,R ,E,Y,E,S ,A,W,A,Y TO MA9TA9 !IR 9NOC5CE4 ,PEOPLE >E ,E,X,C,L,U,D,$2 ?\S&S ( PEOPLE >E ,\,T,S,I,D,],S2 YET ! ,LIB]ALS :O =C$ !M \T >E ,T,O,T,A,L,L,Y ,G,U,I,L,T,L,E,S,S1 & HAVE ! ILLUSION ?AT !Y >E ! ONES :O >E 0SYMPA!TIC0 TO ! ,RADICAL ,/UD5TS1 ! ,EMOTIONALLY ,:AT-,HAVE-,Y\ ,/UD5TS1 ! ,HIPPIE ,/UD5TS4 ,! ,LIB]AL :O IS ! FIR/ TO MOVE ,:,5,E,V,] ,S,O,M,E,O,N,E ,C,R,O,S,S,E,S ,O,N,E ,( ,H,I,S ,L,9,E,S AT ! SAME TIME 0CONTRIBUTES G5]\SLY0 TO 0,LEFT-W+ ORGANIZATIONS0 & 0IS AGA9/ ! W> 9 ,VIETNAM40 ,HE IS A SUPPORT] ( ALL ,G,O,O,D ,?,+,S2 HE IS A ,G,O,O,D ,P,],S,O,N2 HE'S ! ,B,E,/ ,P,],S,O,N ,9 ,! ,W,O,R,L,D4 ,HE IS ABLE TO ACCEPT PHYSICAL & PSY*OLOGICAL ,T,],R,O,R & ,V,I,O,L,5,C,E ,) ,A ,G,O,O,D ,C,O,N,S,C,I,5,C,E ,& ,*,R,I,/,I,A,N ,M,O,R,A,L,S4 ,KALAMAZOO1 ,FEBRU>Y #aifi ,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,FEBRU>Y #b#h1 #aifi 3 ,I ,ACCUSE ,?IS ,LIB]AL ,UNIV]SITY ( ,T]ROR & ,VIOL5CE -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,APRIL #b#f1 #bb 3 ,I ,ACCUSE ,?IS ,LIB]AL ,UNIV]SITY ( ,T]ROR & ,VIOL5CE -- ,ADD$4 ,JANU>Y #d1 #bbb 3 ,I ,ACCUSE ,?IS ,LIB]AL ,UNIV]SITY ( ,T]ROR & ,VIOL5CE -- ,UPDAT$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/