,I BELIEVE NEI!R 9 CON/ITUTIONS1 NOR 9 LAWS 

#ahdh 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,MIKHAIL ,BAKUN9 

,TEXT 3 

,TO ,CITIZ5 ,GEORGE ,H]WE<4 

,P>IS4 .<,RUE ,/4 ,AUGU/9S.> #d 

#i .<R4 SUR ,CIRQUE.> 

,TO ,GEORGE 

,MY DE> FRI5D1 S9CE ! LETT] ?AT ,I HAVE WRITT5 FROM ,COLOGNE1 :I* ,I DO NOT KN[ IF Y\ HAVE RECEIV$1 ,I HAVE NO LONG] WRITT5 A S+LE WORD4 ,MANY ?+S HAVE *ANG$ S9CE !N1 BUT NOT \R FRI5D%IP1 NOT ! CONFID5CE ?AT WE HAVE 9 ONE ANO!R4 ,! ?\<TS ?AT >E ESS5TIAL TO US1 ! ASPIRATIONS ?AT >E ESS5TIAL TO US NON PLUS4 ,I AM CONV9C$ ?AT FROM ! FIR/ H\R ( \R REUNION WE WILL UND]/& EA* O!R AS WELL AD AS COMPLETELY AS BE=E4 ,MY FAI?1 MY RELIGION >E /ILL MORE CONFIRM$ 9 ! FACE ( ALL ! TR\BLES & ALL ! ABJECTIONS1 9 ! HE>T ( :I* ,I HAVE LIV$ = SOME MON?S4 ,& F> FROM LOS+ ALL HOPE1 ,I SEE1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 )\T ! LEA/ ILLUSION1 H[ \R WORLD1 ! WORLD APPROA*ES DE/RUCTION4 

,I C\LD TELL Y\ MANY ?+S AB\T ,SLAVISM1 :I* W\LD MAKE Y\ REJOICE1 BUT AS ,I AM OCCUPI$ ) ! WRIT+ ( A BOOKLET ON ! SUBJECT1 ,I DO NOT WI% TO WE>Y Y\ OR ME2 Y\ WILL SOON READ A PR9T$ TEXT ?AT ,I HAVE WRITT54 ,G]MANY (F]S AT PRES5T A MO/ 9T]E/+ & S+UL> SPECTACLE2 IT IS NOT A W> ( PHANTOMS1 BUT A W> ( %AD[S ?AT TAKE !MSELVES = REALITY1 YET EXP]I5C+ AT EA* MOM5T !IR IMMEASURABLE WEAKNESS & %[+ IT 9VOLUNT>ILY4 ,! (FICIAL REACTION & ! (FICIAL REVOLUTION COMPETE 9 VANITY & /UPIDITY1 %[+ 9 BROAD DAYLI<T ALL ! EMPTY PHRASES1 DEBONAIR & WEI<TY ) PHILOSOPHICO-RELIGI\S1 POLITICO-POETIC CONT5T1 ?AT HAVE SO LONG HAUNT$ ,G]MAN HEADS4 ,NO1 TRULY1 WE HAVE (T5 SAID IT & REPEAT$ IT1 Y\ & ME1 ?AT ?IS WAS ! 5D = ! B\RGEOISIE & ! OLD CIVILIZATION4 ,WE C\LD BELIEVE TRULY :AT WE SAID4 ,BUT NEV]1 NEV] W\LD WE HAVE ?\<T TO BE CORRECT 9 ?IS MANN] & TO SU* AN EXT5T4 ,! REACTION1 ,I MEAN BY ?AT ! REACTION 9 ! BROADE/ S5SE ( ! T]M1 IS ONE ?\<T ?AT AGE HAS MADE /UPID4 ,BUT ! REVOLUTION REPRES5TS MORE AN 9/9CT ?AN A ?\<T1 & IT ACTS1 IT PROPAGATES ITSELF LIKE AN 9/9CT & IT IS AS AN 9/9CT ?AT IT DELIV]S ITS FIR/ FI<TS4 ,?AT IS :Y ! PHILOSOPH]S1 ! LIT]>Y M5 & POLITICIANS1 ALL ?OSE :O HAVE A LITTLE SY/EM 9 !IR POCKET ALL PREP>$ & :O WANT TO CON/RA9 ?AT BOTTOMLESS OCEAN )9 SOME LIMITS & 9 A PR$ET]M9$ %[ !MSELVES TO BE SO FOOLI% & P[]LESS2 !Y >E DEPRIV$ ( ?AT 9/9CT & FE> TO PLUNGE 9TO ! WAVES ( ?AT OCEAN4 ,BUT ! REVOLUTION IS !RE1 DE> FRI5D1 IT IS EV]Y:]E1 IT ACTS & F]M5TS1 ,I HAVE FELT & F\ND IT EV]Y:]E & ,I DO NOT FE> ! REACTION4 ,WELL1 ,GEORGES1 GRANT ME N[ ?AT ,PR\DHON1 = :OM Y\'VE ALWAYS HAD AN AV]SION1 IS N[ ! ONLY ONE 9 ,P>IS1 ! ONLY ONE 9 ! POLITICAL WORLD ( LETT]S1 :O /ILL UND]/&S SOME?+ ( IT4 ,HE HAS GIV5 PRO( ( HIS GREAT C\RAGE2 9 ?IS ]A /AMP$ ) EVIL & HYPOCRISY HIS SPEE* WAS A REAL ACT1 FULL ( NOBILITY4 ,IF HE CAME TO P[] & HIS NEGATIVE DOCTR9>ISM BECAME POSITIVE1 WE W\LD 9 ALL PROBABILITY BE =C$ TO COMBAT HIM1 = HE ALSO HAS1 9 FACT1 A LITTLE SY/EM 9 ! BACKGR\ND1 BUT = ! TIME BE+ HE IS ) US &1 9 ANY CASE1 Y\ %\LD WELL ADMIT ?AT HE HAS GIV5 PRO( ( A GREAT C\RAGE1 WOR?Y ( ADMIRATION4 ,BESIDES1 ,I CONC]N MYSELF V]Y LITTLE ) ! P>LIAM5T>Y DEBATES1 ! ]A ( P>LIAM5T>Y LIFE1 ( CON/ITU5T & NATIONAL ASSEMBLIES1 ETC4 IS OV]1 & :OEV] WILL POSE ! QUE/ION HONE/LY1 MU/ ADMIT ?AT !Y NO LONG] FEEL ANY 9T]E/ OR1 OR AT LEA/1 ONLY A LIMIT$ & IRRATIONAL 9T]E/ = !SE \TDAT$ =MS4 ,I BELIEVE NEI!R 9 CON/ITUTIONS1 NOR 9 LAWS4 ,EV5 ! BE/ ( CON/ITUTIONS W\LD NOT SATISFY ME4 IT IS SOME?+ ELSE ?AT WE NE$3 EFF]VESC5CE & LIFE1 A NEW WORLD )\T LAWS & !RE=E FREE4 ,BUT ! NEGOTIATIONS AT ,VI5NE 9T]E/ ME1 H[EV]1 = !Y ALL[ US TO UND]/& 9 :AT /ATE ?IS EMPIRE REMA9S1 SO LONG UNKN[N4 ,! %IPWRECK ( ,AU/RIA IS = US1 ,SLAVS1 BUT ALSO = ALL ! P>TY ( ! REVOLUTION1 AN IMPORTANT QUE/ION4 ,WILL ,FRANCE & ,ITALY 9T]V5E OR NOT8 ,?AT DOES NOT SC>E ME4 ,! B\RGEOIS CLE>LY =ESEE ?AT A W> 9 ,ITALY C\LD TRANS=M ITSELF 9TO A G5]AL W>1 BR++ ) IT ! GREAT REVOLUTION4 ,RUGE IS H]E2 ?US F> AT ,FRANK=T HE IS RECOGNIZ$ AS ONE ( ! BE/1 NOT TO SAY ! BE/4 ,I /ILL HAVE NOT 5C\NT]$ HIM4 

,F>EWELL1 MY DE> FRI5D4 ,I MU/ GO4 

,M4,B4 

,MADAME1 ,I HOPE ?AT Y\ HAVE NOT YET COMPLETELY =GOTT5 & ?AT Y\ WILL =CE ,GEORGE/O RESPOND TO ME4 ,:AT >E Y\ DO+ 9 ,P>IS8 ,WILL Y\ /AY ?IS W9T]8 ,9 ANY CASES WE WILL NOT FAIL1 ,I HOPE1 TO MEET AGA9SOON1 & !N WE HAVE MU* TO TELL EA* O!R4 

,Y\R DEVOT$1 

,M4 ,B4 

7,S\RCE3 HTTPS3_/_/WWW4LIB]T>IAN-LABYR9?4ORG_/WORK+-TRANSLATIONS_/MIKHAIL-BAKUN9-I-BELIEVE-NEI!R-9-CON/ITUTIONS-NOR-9-LAWS-#a#h#d#h_/ 7 

,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahdg 3 ,I BELIEVE NEI!R 9 CON/ITUTIONS1 NOR 9 LAWS -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,JULY #a#d1 #bb 3 ,I BELIEVE NEI!R 9 CON/ITUTIONS1 NOR 9 LAWS -- ,ADD$4 
,JANU>Y #d1 #bbb 3 ,I BELIEVE NEI!R 9 CON/ITUTIONS1 NOR 9 LAWS -- ,UPDAT$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/