,9 ,PRAISE ( ,IDL5ESS ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,B]TR& ,RUSSELL ,TAGS 3 C5TRAL CONTROL OV] PRODUCTION1 VIRTUE ( H>D WORK1 W>RIORS & PRIE/S1 M5 & WOM51 HOLD]S ( P[]1 DIGNITY ( LABOR1 CONTROL OV] PRODUCTION1 EASE & SECURITY1 MOD]N WORLD1 MANUAL WORK4 ,TEXT 3 ,PHOTO BY ,RI*>D ,TURN]1,C,C ,B,Y-,N,C ,LIC5SE ,9 ,PRAISE ( ,IDL5ESS ,?IS TEXT WAS FIR/ PROVID$ BY ! ,MASSA*USETTS ,GRE5 ,P>TY1 BUT ,I F\ND \T ?AT !Y HAVE MOV$ OR DELET$ !IR PAGE1 SO N[ ,I'M KEEP+ A 0MIRROR0 ( !IR TEXT4 4 ,9 ?IS ESSAY1 ,LORD ,B]TR& ,RUSSELL PROPOSES A CUT 9 ! DEF9ITION ( FULL TIME TO F\R H\RS P] DAY4 ,AS ?IS >TICLE WAS WRITT5 9 #a#i#c#b1 HE HAS NOT ! B5EFIT ( KN[+ ?AT1 AS WE ADD$ MORE WAGE-E>N]S P] FAMILY 7WOM5 5T]$ ! WORK =CE7 & FAMILIES %RUNK 7FEW] KIDS71 & ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION BECOME MORE EFFICI5T 7BETT] MA*9ES7 ! NUMB] ( H\RS EA* WAGE-E>N] MU/ WORK TO SUPPORT ! FAMILY HAS /AY$ CON/ANT4 ,!SE FACTS SEEM TO UPHOLD ,RUSSELL'S PO9T4 ,LIKE MO/ ( MY G5]ATION1 ,I WAS BR\D D[N TO ! PRES5T MOM5T4 ,BUT AL?\< MY CONSCI5CE HAS CONTROLL$ MY ACTIONS1 MY OP9IONS HAVE UND]GONE A REVOLUTION4 ,I ?9K ?AT !RE IS F> TOO MU* WORK DONE 9 ! WORLD1 ?AT IMM5SE H>M IS CAUS$ BY ! BELIEF ?AT WORK IS VIRTU\S1 & ?AT :AT NE$S TO BE PREA*$ 9 MOD]N 9DU/RIAL C\NTRIES IS QUITE DIFF]5T FROM :AT ALWAYS HAS BE5 PREA*$4 ,EV]YONE KN[S ! /ORY ( ! TRAVEL] 9 ,NAPLES :O SAW TWELVE BEGG>S LY+ 9 ! SUN 7IT WAS BE=E ! DAYS ( ,MUSSOL9I71 & (F]$ A LIRA TO ! LAZIE/ ( !M4 ,ELEV5 ( !M JUMP$ UP TO CLAIM IT1 SO HE GAVE IT TO ! TWELF?4 ?IS TRAVEL] WAS ON ! RIT A CAMPAIGN TO 9DUCE GOOD Y\NG M5 TO DO NO?+4 ,IF SO1 ,I %ALL NOT HAVE LIV$ 9 VA94 ,BE=E ADVANC+ MY [N >GUM5TS = LAZ9ESS1 ,I MU/ DISPOSE ( ONE :I* ,I CANNOT ACCEPT4 ,:5EV] A P]SON :O ALREADY HAS 5\< TO LIVE ON PROPOSES TO 5GAGE 9 SOME EV]YDAY K9D ( JOB1 SU* AS S*OOL-TEA*+ OR TYP+1 HE OR %E IS TOLD ?AT SU* CONDUCT TAKES ! BREAD \T ( O!R PEOPLE'S M\?S1 & IS !RE=E WICK$4 ,IF ?IS >GUM5T W]E VALID1 IT W\LD ONLY BE NECESS>Y = US ALL TO BE IDLE 9 ORD] ?AT WE %\LD ALL HAVE \R M\?S FULL ( BREAD4 ,:AT PEOPLE :O SAY SU* ?+S =GET IS ?AT :AT A MAN E>NS HE USUALLY SP5DS1 & 9 SP5D+ HE GIVES EMPLOYM5T4 ,AS LONG AS A MAN SP5DS HIS 9COME1 HE PUTS JU/ AS MU* BREAD 9TO PEOPLE'S M\?S 9 SP5D+ AS HE TAKES \T ( O!R PEOPLE'S M\?S 9 E>N+4 ,! REAL VILLA91 FROM ?IS PO9T ( VIEW1 IS ! MAN :O SAVES4 ,IF HE M]ELY PUTS HIS SAV+S 9 A /OCK+1 LIKE ! PROV]BIAL ,FR5* PEASANT1 IT IS OBVI\S ?AT !Y DO NOT GIVE EMPLOYM5T4 ,IF HE 9VE/S HIS SAV+S1 ! MATT] IS LESS OBVI\S1 & DIFF]5T CASES >ISE4 ,ONE ( ! COMMONE/ ?+S TO DO ) SAV+S IS TO L5D !M TO SOME ,GOV]NM5T4 ,9 VIEW ( ! FACT ?AT ! BULK ( ! PUBLIC EXP5DITURE ( MO/ CIVILIZ$ ,GOV]NM5TS CONSI/S 9 PAYM5T = PA/ W>S OR PREP>ATION = FUTURE W>S1 ! MAN :O L5DS HIS MONEY TO A ,GOV]NM5T IS 9 ! SAME POSITION AS ! BAD M5 9 ,%AKESPE>E :O HIRE MURD]]S4 ,! NET RESULT ( ! MAN'S ECONOMICAL HABITS IS TO 9CREASE ! >M$ =CES ( ! ,/ATE TO :I* HE L5DS HIS SAV+S4 ,OBVI\SLY IT W\LD BE BETT] IF HE SP5T ! MONEY1 EV5 IF HE SP5T IT 9 DR9K OR GAMBL+4 ,BUT1 ,I %ALL BE TOLD1 ! CASE IS QUITE DIFF]5T :5 SAV+S >E 9VE/$ 9 9DU/RIAL 5T]PRISES4 ,:5 SU* 5T]PRISES SUCCE$1 & PRODUCE SOME?+ USEFUL1 ?IS MAY BE CONC$$4 ,9 !SE DAYS1 H[EV]1 NO ONE WILL D5Y ?AT MO/ 5T]PRISES FAIL4 ,?AT MEANS ?AT A L>GE AM\NT ( HUMAN LABOR1 :I* MITIES = HIS FRI5DS1 !Y 7WE MAY HOPE7 W\LD GET PLEASURE1 & SO W\LD ALL ?OSE UPON :OM HE SP5T MONEY1 SU* AS ! BUT*]1 ! BAK]1 & ! BOOTLEGG]4 ,BUT IF HE SP5DS IT 7LET US SAY7 UPON LAY+ D[N RAILS = SURFACE C>D 9 SOME PLACE :]E SURFACE C>S TURN \T NOT TO BE WANT$1 HE HAS DIV]T$ A MASS ( LABOR 9TO *ANNELS :]E IT GIVES PLEASURE TO NO ONE4 ,NEV]!LESS1 :5 HE BECOMES POOR ?R\< FAILURE ( HIS 9VE/M5T HE WILL BE REG>D$ AS A VICTIM ( UNDES]V$ MIS=TUNE1 :]EAS ! GAY SP5D?RIFT1 :O HAS SP5T HIS MONEY PHILAN?ROPICALLY1 WILL BE DESPIS$ AS A FOOL & A FRIVOL\S P]SON4 ,ALL ?IS IS ONLY PRELIM9>Y4 ,I WANT TO SAY1 9 ALL S]I\SNESS1 ?AT A GREAT DEAL ( H>M IS BE+ DONE 9 ! MOD]N WORLD BY BELIEF 9 ! VIRTU\SNESS ( WORK1 & ?AT ! ROAD TO HAPP9ESS & PROSP]ITY LIES 9 AN ORGANIZ$ DIM9UTION ( WORK4 ,FIR/ ( ALL3 :AT IS WORK8 ,WORK IS ( TWO K9DS3 FIR/1 ALT]+ ! POSITION ( MATT] AT OR NE> ! E>?'S SURFACE RELATIVELY TO O!R SU* MATT]2 SECOND1 TELL+ O!R PEOPLE TO DO SO4 ,! FIR/ K9D IS UNPLEASANT & ILL PAID2 ! SECOND IS PLEASANT & HIE NOT ONLY ?OSE :O GIVE ORD]S1 BUT ?OSE :O GIVE ADVICE AS TO :AT ORD]S %\LD BE GIV54 ,USUALLY TWO OPPOSITE K9DS ( ADVICE >E GIV5 SIMULTANE\SLY BY TWO ORGANIZ$ BODIES ( M52 ?IS IS CALL$ POLITICS4 ,! SKILL REQUIR$ = ?IS K9D ( WORK IS NOT KN[L$GE ( ! SUBJECTS AS TO :I* ADVICE IS GIV51 BUT KN[L$GE ( ! >T ( P]SUASIVE SPEAK+ & WRIT+1 I4E4 ( ADV]TIS+4 ,?R\<\T ,EUROPE1 ?\< NOT 9 ,AM]ICA1 !RE IS A ?IRD CLASS ( M51 MORE RESPECT$ ?AN EI!R ( ! CLASSES ( WORK]S4 ,!RE >E M5 :O1 ?R\< [N]%IP ( L&1 >E ABLE TO MAKE O!RS PAY = ! PRIVILEGE ( BE+ ALL[$ TO EXI/ & TO WORK4 ,!SE L&[N]S >E IDLE1 & ,I MID WORK LITTLE MORE ?AN WAS REQUIR$ = ! SUBSI/5CE ( HIMSELF & HIS FAMILY1 AL?\< HIS WIFE WORK$ AT LEA/ AS H>D AS HE DID1 & HIS *ILDR5 ADD$ !IR LABOR AS SOON AS !Y W]E OLD 5\< TO DO SO4 ,! SMALL SURPLUS ABOVE B>E NECESS>IES WAS NOT LEFT TO ?OSE :O PRODUC$ IT1 BUT WAS APPROPRIAT$ BY W>RIORS & PRIE/S4 ,9 TIMES ( FAM9E !RE WAS NO SURPLUS2 ! W>RIORS & PRIE/S1 H[EV]1 /ILL SECUR$ AS MU* AS AT O!R TIMES1 ) ! RESULT ?AT MANY ( ! WORK]S DI$ ( HUNG]4 ,?IS SY/EM P]SI/$ 9 ,RUSSIA UNTIL #aiag .<#a.>1 & /ILL P]SI/S 9 ! ,EA/2 9 ,5GL&1 9 SPITE ( ! ,9DU/RIAL ,REVOLUTION1 IT REMA9$ 9 FULL =CE ?R\<\T ! ,NAPOLEONIC W>S1 & UNTIL A HUNDR$ YE>S AGO1 :5 ! NEW CLASS ( MANUFACTUR]S ACQUIR$ P[]4 ,9 ,AM]ICA1 ! SY/EM CAME TO AN 5D ) ! ,REVOLUTION1 EXCEPT 9 ! ,S\?1 :]E IT P]SI/$ UNTIL ! ,CIVIL ,W>4 ,A SY/EM :I* LA/$ SO LONG & 5D$ SO REC5TLY HAS NATURALLY LEFT A PR(\ND IMPRESS UPON M5'S ?\T$ ) ! SL5D] SURPLUS UPON :I* ! W>RIORS & PRIE/S SUBSI/$1 BUT W\LD HAVE EI!R PRODUC$ LESS OR CONSUM$ MORE4 ,AT FIR/1 %E] =CE COMPELL$ !M TO PRODUCE & P>T ) ! SURPLUS4 ,GRADUALLY1 H[EV]1 IT WAS F\ND POSSIBLE TO 9DUCE MANY ( !M TO ACCEPT AN E?IC ACCORD+ TO :I* IT WAS !IR DUTY TO WORK H>D1 AL?\< P>T ( !IR WORK W5T TO SUPPORT O!RS 9 IDL5ESS4 ,BY ?IS MEANS ! AM\NT ( COMPULSION REQUIR$ WAS LESS5$1 & ! EXP5SES ( GOV]NM5T W]E DIM9I%$4 ,TO ?IS DAY1 #ii P]C5T ( ,BRITI% WAGE-E>N]S W\LD BE G5U9ELY %OCK$ IF IT W]E PROPOS$ ?AT ! ,K+ %\LD NOT HAVE A L>G] 9COME ?AN A WORK+ MAN4 ,! CONCEPTION ( DUTY1 SPEAK+ HI/ORICALLY1 HAS BE5 A MEANS US$ BY ! HOLD]S ( P[] TO 9DUCE O!RS TO LIVE = ! 9T]E/S ( !IR MA/]S RA!R ?AN = !IR [N4 ,( C\RSE ! HOLD]S ( P[] CONCEAL ?IS FACT FROM !MSELVES BY MANAG+ TO BELIEVE ?AT !IR 9T]E/S >E ID5TICAL ) ! L>G] 9T]E/S ( HUMANITY4 ,SOMETIMES ?IS IS TRUE2 ,A!NIAN SLAVE-[N]S1 = 9/ANCE1 EMPLOY$ P>T ( !IR LEISURE 9 MAK+ A P]MAN5T CONTRIBUTION TO CIVILIZATION :I* W\LD HAVE BE5 IMPOSSIBLE UND] A JU/ ECONOMIC SY/EM4 ,LEISURE IS ESS5TIAL TO CIVILIZATION1 & 9 =M] TIMES LEISURE = ! FEW WAS ONLY R5D]$ POSSIBLE BY ! LABORS ( ! MANY4 ,BUT !IR LABORS W]E VALUABLE1 NOT BECAUSE WORK IS GOOD1 BUT BECAUSE LEISURE IS GOOD4 ,& ) MOD]N TE*NIQUE IT W\LD BE POSSIBLE TO DI/RIBUTE LEISURE JU/LY )\T 9JURY TO CIVILIZATION4 ,MOD]N TE*NIQUE HAS MADE IT POSSIBLE TO DIM9I% 5ORM\SLY ! AM\NT ( LABOR REQUIR$ TO SECURE ! NECESS>IES ( LIFE = EV]YONE4 ,?IS WAS MADE OBVI\S DUR+ ! W>4 ,AT ?AT TIME ALL ! M5 9 ! >M$ =CES1 & ALL ! M5 & WOM5 5GAG$ 9 ! PRODUCTION ( MUNITIONS1 ALL ! M5 & WOM5 5GAG$ 9 SPY+1 W> PROPAG&A1 OR ,GOV]NM5T (FICES CONNECT$ ) ! W>1 W]E )DRAWN FROM PRODUCTIVE OCCUPATIONS4 ,9 SPITE ( ?IS1 ! G5]AL LEVEL ( WELL-BE+ AMONG UNSKILL$ WAGE-E>N]S ON ! SIDE ( ! ,ALLIES WAS HI<] ?AN BE=E OR S9CE4 ,! SIGNIFICANCE ( ?IS FACT WAS CONCEAL$ BY F9ANCE3 BORR[+ MADE IT APPE> AS IF ! FUTURE WAS N\RI%+ ! PRES5T4 ,BUT ?AT1 ( C\RSE1 W\LD HAVE BE5 IMPOSSIBLE2 A MAN CANNOT EAT A LOAF ( BREAD ?AT DOES NOT YET EXI/4 ,! W> %[$ CONCLUSIVELY ?AT1 BY ! SCI5TIFIC ORGANIZATION ( PRODUCTION1 IT IS POSSIBLE TO KEEP MOD]N POPULATIONS 9 FAIR COM=T ON A SMALL P>T ( ! WORK+ CAPACITY ( ! MOD]N WORLD4 ,IF1 AT ! 5D ( ! W>1 ! SCI5TIFIC ORGANIZATION1 :I* HAD BE5 CREAT$ 9 ORD] TO LIB]ATE M5 = FIVE AS UNEMPLOY$4 ,:Y8 ,BECAUSE WORK IS A DUTY1 & A MAN %\LD NOT RECEIVE WAGES 9 PROPORTION TO :AT HE HAS PRODUC$1 BUT 9 PROPORTION TO HIS VIRTUE AS EXEMPLIFI$ BY HIS 9DU/RY4 ,?IS IS ! MORALITY ( ! ,SLAVE ,/ATE1 APPLI$ 9 CIRCUM/ANCES TOTALLY UNLIKE ?OSE 9 :I* IT >OSE4 ,NO WOND] ! RESULT HAS BE5 DISA/R\S4 ,LET US TAKE AN ILLU/RATION4 ,SUPPOSE ?AT1 AT A GIV5 MOM5T1 A C]TA9 NUMB] ( PEOPLE >E 5GAG$ 9 ! MANUFACTURE ( P9S4 ,!Y MAKE AS MANY P9S AS ! WORLD NE$S1 WORK+ 7SAY7 EIE ALREADY SO *EAP ?AT H>DLY ANY MORE WILL BE B\E TOO MANY P9S1 SOME EMPLOY]S GO BANKRUPT1 & HALF ! M5 PREVI\SLY CONC]N$ 9 MAK+ P9S >E ?R[N \T ( WORK4 ,!RE IS1 9 ! 5D1 JU/ AS MU* LEISURE AS ON ! O!R PLAN1 BUT HALF ! M5 >E TOTALLY IDLE :ILE HALF >E /ILL OV]WORK$4 ,9 ?IS WAY1 IT IS 9SUR$ ?AT ! UNAVOIDABLE LEISURE %ALL CAUSE MIS]Y ALL R\ND 9/EAD ( BE+ A UNIV]SAL S\RCE ( HAPP9ESS4 ,CAN ANY?+ MORE 9SANE BE IMAG9$8 ,! IDEA ?AT ! POOR %\LD HAVE LEISURE HAS ALWAYS BE5 %OCK+ TO ! RI*4 ,9 ,5GL&1 9 ! E>LY N9ETE5? C5TURY1 FIFTE5 H\RS WAS ! ORD9>Y DAY'S WORK = A MAN2 *ILDR5 SOMETIMES DID AS MU*1 & V]Y COMMONLY DID TWELVE H\RS A DAY4 ,:5 M$DLESOME BUSYBODIES SUGGE/$ ?AT P]HAPS !SE H\RS W]E RA!R LONG1 !Y W]E TOLD ?AT WORK KEPT ADULTS FROM DR9K & *ILDR5 FROM MIS*IEF4 ,:5 ,I WAS A *ILD1 %ORTLY AFT] URBAN WORK+ M5 HAD ACQUIR$ ! VOTE1 C]TA9 PUBLIC HOLIDAYS W]E E/ABLI%$ BY LAW1 TO ! GREAT 9DIGNATION ( ! UPP] CLASSES4 ,I REMEMB] HE>+ AN OLD ,DU*ESS SAY3 ',:AT DO ! POOR WANT ) HOLIDAYS8 ,!Y \E LESS FRANK1 BUT ! S5TIM5T P]SI/S1 & IS ! S\RCE ( MU* ( \R ECONOMIC CONFUSION4 ,LET US1 = A MOM5T1 CONSID] ! E?ICS ( WORK FRANKLY1 )\T SUP]/ITION4 ,EV]Y HUMAN BE+1 ( NECESSITY1 CONSUMES1 9 ! C\RSE ( HIS LIFE1 A C]TA9 AM\NT ( ! PRODUCE ( HUMAN LABOR4 ,ASSUM+1 AS WE MAY1 ?AT LABOR IS ON ! :OLE DISAGREEABLE1 IT IS UNJU/ ?AT A MAN %\LD CONSUME MORE ?AN HE PRODUCES4 ,( C\RSE HE MAY PROVIDE S]VICES RA!R ?AN COMMODITIES1 LIKE A M$ICAL MAN1 = EXAMPLE2 BUT HE %\LD PROVIDE SOME?+ 9 RETURN = HIS BO>D & LODG+4 TO ?IS EXT5T1 ! DUTY ( WORK MU/ BE ADMITT$1 BUT TO ?IS EXT5T ONLY4 ,I %ALL NOT DWELL UPON ! FACT ?AT1 9 ALL MOD]N SOCIETIES \TSIDE ! ,U,S,S,R1 MANY PEOPLE ESCAPE EV5 ?IS M9IMUM AM\NT ( WORK1 NAMELY ALL ?OSE :O 9H]IT MONEY & ALL ?OSE :O M>RY MONEY4 ,I DO NOT ?9K ! FACT ?AT !SE PEOPLE >E ALL[$ TO BE IDLE IS NE>LY SO H>MFUL AS ! FACT ?AT WAGE-E>N]S >E EXPECT$ TO OV]WORK OR />VE4 ,IF ! ORD9>Y WAGE-E>N] WORK$ F\R H\RS A DAY1 !RE W\LD BE 5\< = EV]YBODY & NO UNEMPLOYM5T -- ASSUM+ A C]TA9 V]Y MOD]ATE AM\NT ( S5SIBLE ORGANIZATION4 ,?IS IDEA %OCKS ! WELL-TO-DO1 BECAUSE !Y >E CONV9C$ ?AT ! POOR W\LD NOT KN[ H[ TO USE SO MU* LEISURE4 ,9 ,AM]ICA M5 (T5 WORK LONG H\RS EV5 :5 !Y >E WELL (F2 SU* M51 NATURALLY1 >E 9DIGNANT AT ! IDEA ( LEISURE = WAGE-E>N]S1 EXCEPT AS ! GRIM PUNI%M5T ( UNEMPLOYM5T2 9 FACT1 !Y DISLIKE LEISURE EV5 = !IR SONS4 ,ODDLY 5\<1 :ILE !Y WI% !IR SONS TO WORK SO H>D AS TO HAVE NO TIME TO BE CIVILIZ$1 !Y DO NOT M9D !IR WIVES & DAUI/OCRATIC SOCIETY1 EXT5DS TO BO? SEXES1 IS1 UND] A PLUTOCRACY1 CONF9$ TO WOM52 ?IS1 H[EV]1 DOES NOT MAKE IT ANY MORE 9 AGREEM5T ) COMMON S5SE4 ,! WISE USE ( LEISURE1 IT MU/ BE CONC$$1 IS A PRODUCT ( CIVILIZATION & $UCATION4 ,A MAN :O HAS WORK$ LONG H\RS ALL HIS LIFE WILL BECOME BOR$ IF HE BECOMES SUDD5LY IDLE4 ,BUT )\T A CONSID]ABLE AM\NT ( LEISURE A MAN IS CUT (F FROM MANY ( ! BE/ ?+S4 ,!RE IS NO LONG] ANY REASON :Y ! BULK ( ! POPULATION %\LD SUFF] ?IS DEPRIVATION2 ONLY A FOOLI% ASCETICISM1 USUALLY VIC>I\S1 MAKES US CONT9UE TO 9SI/ ON WORK 9 EXCESSIVE QUANTITIES N[ ?AT ! NE$ NO LONG] EXI/S4 ,9 ! NEW CRE$ :I* CONTROLS ! GOV]NM5T ( ,RUSSIA1 :ILE !RE IS MU* ?AT IS V]Y DIFF]5T FROM ! TRADITIONAL TEA*+ ( ! ,WE/1 !RE >E SOME ?+S ?AT >E QUITE UN*ANG$4 ,! ATTITUDE ( ! GOV]N+ CLASSES1 & ESPECIALLY ( ?OSE :O CONDUCT $UCATIONAL PROPAG&A1 ON ! SUBJECT ( ! DIGNITY ( LABOR1 IS ALMO/ EXACTLY ?AT :I* ! GOV]N+ CLASSES ( ! WORLD HAVE ALWAYS PREA*$ TO :AT W]E CALL$ ! 'HONE/ POOR'4 ,9DU/RY1 SOBRIETY1 WILL+NESS TO WORK LONG H\RS = DI/ANT ADVANTAGES1 EV5 SUBMISSIV5ESS TO AU?ORITY1 ALL !SE REAPPE>2 MOREOV] AU?ORITY /ILL REPRES5TS ! WILL ( ! ,RUL] ( ! ,UNIV]SE1 ,:O1 H[EV]1 IS N[ CALL$ BY A NEW NAME1 ,DIALECTICAL ,MAT]IALISM4 ,! VICTORY ( ! PROLET>IAT 9 ,RUSSIA HAS SOME PO9TS 9 COMMON ) ! VICTORY ( ! FEM9I/S 9 SOME O!R C\NTRIES4 ,= AGES1 M5 HAD CONC$$ ! SUP]IOR SA9TL9ESS ( WOM51 & HAD CONSOL$ WOM5 = !IR 9F]IORITY BY MA9TA9+ ?AT SA9TL9ESS IS MORE DESIRABLE ?AN P[]4 ,AT LA/ ! FEM9I/S DECID$ ?AT !Y W\LD HAVE BO?1 S9CE ! PIONE]S AMONG !M BELIEV$ ALL ?AT ! M5 HAD TOLD !M AB\T ! DESIRABILITY ( VIRTUE1 BUT NOT :AT !Y HAD TOLD !M AB\T ! WOR?LESSNESS ( POLITICAL P[]4 ,A SIMIL> ?+ HAS HAPP5$ 9 ,RUSSIA AS REG>DS MANUAL WORK4 ,= AGES1 ! RI* & !IR SYCOPHANTS HAVE WRITT5 9 PRAISE ( 'HONE/ TOIL'1 HAVE PRAIS$ ! SIMPLE LIFE1 HAVE PR(ESS$ A RELIGION :I* TEA*ES ?AT ! POOR >E MU* MORE LIKELY TO GO TO HEAV5 ?AN ! RI*1 & 9 G5]AL HAVE TRI$ TO MAKE MANUAL WORK]S BELIEVE ?AT !RE IS SOME SPECIAL NOBILITY AB\T ALT]+ ! POSITION ( MATT] 9 SPACE1 JU/ AS M5 TRI$ TO MAKE WOM5 BELIEVE ?AT !Y D]IV$ SOME SPECIAL NOBILITY FROM !IR SEXUAL 5SLAVEM5T4 ,9 ,RUSSIA1 ALL ?IS TEA*+ AB\T ! EXCELL5CE ( MANUAL WORK HAS BE5 TAK5 S]I\SLY1 ) ! RESULT ?AT ! MANUAL WORK] IS MORE HONOR$ ?AN ANYONE ELSE4 ,:AT >E1 9 ESS5CE1 REVIVALI/ APPEALS >E MADE1 BUT NOT = ! OLD PURPOSES3 !Y >E MADE TO SECURE %OCK WORK]S = SPECIAL TASKS4 ,MANUAL WORK IS ! IDEAL :I* IS HELD BE=E ! Y\NG1 & IS ! BASIS ( ALL E?ICAL TEA*+4 ,= ! PRES5T1 POSSIBLY1 ?IS IS ALL TO ! GOOD4 ,A L>GE C\NTRY1 FULL ( NATURAL RES\RCES1 AWAITS DEVELOPM5T1 & HAS HAS TO BE DEVELOP$ ) V]Y LITTLE USE ( CR$IT4 ,9 !SE CIRCUM/ANCES1 H>D WORK IS NECESS>Y1 & IS LIKELY TO BR+ A GREAT REW>D4 ,BUT :AT WILL HAPP5 :5 ! PO9T HAS BE5 REA*$ :]E EV]YBODY C\LD BE COM=TABLE )\T WORK+ LONG H\RS8 ,9 ! ,WE/1 WE HAVE V>I\S WAYS ( DEAL+ ) ?IS PROBLEM4 ,WE HAVE NO ATTEMPT AT ECONOMIC JU/ICE1 SO ?AT A L>GE PROPORTION ( ! TOTAL PRODUCE GOES TO A SMALL M9ORITY ( ! POPULATION1 MANY ( :OM DO NO WORK AT ALL4 ,[+ TO ! ABS5CE ( ANY C5TRAL CONTROL OV] PRODUCTION1 WE PRODUCE HO/S ( ?+S ?AT >E NOT WANT$4 ,WE KEEP A L>GE P]C5TAGE ( ! WORK+ POPULATION IDLE1 BECAUSE WE CAN DISP5SE ) !IR LABOR BY MAK+ ! O!RS OV]WORK4 ,:5 ALL !SE ME?ODS PROVE 9ADEQUATE1 WE HAVE A W>3 WE CAUSE A NUMB] ( PEOPLE TO MANUFACTURE HI< EXPLOSIVES1 & A NUMB] ( O!RS TO EXPLODE !M1 AS IF WE W]E *ILDR5 :O HAD JU/ DISCOV]$ FIREWORKS4 ,BY A COMB9ATION ( ALL !SE DEVICES WE MANAGE1 ?\< ) DIFFICULTY1 TO KEEP ALIVE ! NOTION ?AT A GREAT DEAL ( SEV]E MANUAL WORK MU/ BE ! LOT ( ! AV]AGE MAN4 ,9 ,RUSSIA1 [+ TO MORE ECONOMIC JU/ICE & C5TRAL CONTROL OV] PRODUCTION1 ! PROBLEM WILL HAVE TO BE DIFF]5TLY SOLV$4 ! RATIONAL SOLUTION W\LD BE1 AS SOON AS ! NECESS>IES & ELEM5T>Y COM=TS CAN BE PROVID$ = ALL1 TO R$UCE ! H\RS ( LABOR GRADUALLY1 ALL[+ A POPUL> VOTE TO DECIDE1 AT EA* /AGE1 :E!R MORE LEISURE OR MORE GOODS W]E TO BE PREF]R$4 ,BUT1 HAV+ TAUD WORK1 IT IS DIFFICULT TO SEE H[ ! AU?ORITIES CAN AIM AT A P>ADISE 9 :I* !RE WILL BE MU* LEISURE & LITTLE WORK4 ,IT SEEMS MORE LIKELY ?AT !Y WILL F9D CONT9UALLY FRE% S*EMES1 BY :I* PRES5T LEISURE IS TO BE SACRIFIC$ TO FUTURE PRODUCTIVITY4 ,I READ REC5TLY ( AN +5I\S PLAN PUT =W>D BY ,RUSSIAN 5G9E]S1 = MAK+ ! ,:ITE ,SEA & ! NOR!RN COA/S ( ,SIB]IA W>M1 BY PUTT+ A DAM ACROSS ! ,K>A ,SEA4 ,AN ADMIRABLE PROJECT1 BUT LIABLE TO PO/PONE PROLET>IAN COM=T = A G5]ATION1 :ILE ! NOBILITY ( TOIL IS BE+ DISPLAY$ AMID ! ICE-FIELDS & SN[/ORMS ( ! ,>CTIC ,OCEAN4 ,?IS SORT ( ?+1 IF IT HAPP5S1 WILL BE ! RESULT ( REG>D+ ! VIRTUE ( H>D WORK AS AN 5D 9 ITSELF1 RA!R ?AN AS A MEANS TO A /ATE ( AFFAIRS 9 :I* IT IS NO LONG] NE$$4 ,! FACT IS ?AT MOV+ MATT] AB\T1 :ILE A C]TA9 AM\NT ( IT IS NECESS>Y TO \R EXI/5CE1 IS EMPHATICALLY NOT ONE ( ! 5DS ( HUMAN LIFE4 ,IF IT W]E1 WE %\LD HAVE TO CONSID] EV]Y NAVVY SUP]IOR TO ,%AKESPE>E4 ,WE HAVE BE5 MISL$ 9 ?IS MATT] BY TWO CAUSES4 ,ONE IS ! NECESSITY ( KEEP+ ! POOR CONT5T$1 :I* HAS L$ ! RI*1 = ?\S&S ( YE>S1 TO PREA* ! DIGNITY ( LABOR1 :ILE TAK+ C>E !MSELVES TO REMA9 UNDIGNIFI$ 9 ?IS RESPECT4 ,! O!R IS ! NEW PLEASURE 9 ME*ANISM1 :I* MAKES US DELI?'S SURFACE4 ,NEI!R ( !SE MOTIVES MAKES ANY GREAT APPEAL TO ! ACTUAL WORK]4 ,IF Y\ ASK HIM :AT HE ?9KS ! BE/ P>T ( HIS LIFE1 HE IS NOT LIKELY TO SAY3 ',I 5JOY MANUAL WORK BECAUSE IT MAKES ME FEEL ?AT ,I AM FULFILL+ MAN'S NOBLE/ TASK1 & BECAUSE ,I LIKE TO ?9K H[ MU* MAN CAN TRANS=M HIS PLANET4 ,IT IS TRUE ?AT MY BODY DEM&S P]IODS ( RE/1 :I* ,I HAVE TO FILL 9 AS BE/ ,I MAY1 BUT ,I AM NEV] SO HAPPY AS :5 ! MORN+ COMES & ,I CAN RETURN TO ! TOIL FROM :I* MY CONT5TM5T SPR+S4' ,I HAVE NEV] HE>D WORK+ M5 SAY ?IS SORT ( ?+4 ,!Y CONSID] WORK1 AS IT %\LD BE CONSID]$1 A NECESS>Y MEANS TO A LIVELIHOOD1 & IT IS FROM !IR LEISURE ?AT !Y D]IVE :ATEV] HAPP9ESS !Y MAY 5JOY4 ,IT WILL BE SAID ?AT1 :ILE A LITTLE LEISURE IS PLEASANT1 M5 W\LD NOT KN[ H[ TO FILL !IR DAYS IF !Y HAD ONLY F\R H\RS ( WORK \T ( ! TW5TY-F\R4 ,9 SO F> AS ?IS IS TRUE 9 ! MOD]N WORLD1 IT IS A CONDEMNATION ( \R CIVILIZATION2 IT W\LD NOT HAVE BE5 TRUE AT ANY E>LI] P]IOD4 ,!RE WAS =M]LY A CAPACITY = LIT$NESS & PLAY :I* HAS BE5 TO SOME EXT5T 9HIBIT$ BY ! CULT ( EFFICI5CY4 ,! MOD]N MAN ?9KS ?AT EV]Y?+ \E CONT9UALLY CONDEMN+ ! HABIT ( GO+ TO ! C9EMA1 & TELL+ US ?AT IT LEADS ! Y\NG 9TO CRIME4 ,BUT ALL ! WORK ?AT GOES TO PRODUC+ A C9EMA IS RESPECTABLE1 BECAUSE IT IS WORK1 & BECAUSE IT BR+S A MONEY PR(IT4 ,! NOTION ?AT ! DESIRABLE ACTIVITIES >E ?OSE ?AT BR+ A PR(IT HAS MADE EV]Y?+ TOPSY-TURVY4 ,! BUT*] :O PROVIDES Y\ ) MEAT & ! BAK] :O PROVIDES Y\ ) BREAD >E PRAISEWOR?Y1 BECAUSE !Y >E MAK+ MONEY2 BUT :5 Y\ 5JOY ! FOOD !Y HAVE PROVID$1 Y\ >E M]ELY FRIVOL\S1 UNLESS Y\ EAT ONLY TO GET /R5G? = Y\R WORK4 ,BROADLY SPEAK+1 IT IS HELD ?AT GETT+ MONEY IS GOOD & SP5D+ MONEY IS BAD4 ,SEE+ ?AT !Y >E TWO SIDES ( ONE TRANSACTION1 ?IS IS ABSURD2 ONE MIE GOOD1 BUT KEYHOLES >E BAD4 ,:ATEV] M]IT !RE MAY BE 9 ! PRODUCTION ( GOODS MU/ BE 5TIRELY D]IVATIVE FROM ! ADVANTAGE TO BE OBTA9$ BY CONSUM+ !M4 ,! 9DIVIDUAL1 9 \R SOCIETY1 WORKS = PR(IT2 BUT ! SOCIAL PURPOSE ( HIS WORK LIES 9 ! CONSUMPTION ( :AT HE PRODUCES4 ,IT IS ?IS DIVORCE BETWE5 ! 9DIVIDUAL & ! SOCIAL PURPOSE ( PRODUCTION ?AT MAKES IT SO DIFFICULT = M5 TO ?9K CLE>LY 9 A WORLD 9 :I* PR(IT-MAK+ IS ! 9C5TIVE TO 9DU/RY4 ,WE ?9K TOO MU* ( PRODUCTION1 & TOO LITTLE ( CONSUMPTION4 ,ONE RESULT IS ?AT WE ATTA* TOO LITTLE IMPORTANCE TO 5JOYM5T & SIMPLE HAPP9ESS1 & ?AT WE DO NOT JUDGE PRODUCTION BY ! PLEASURE ?AT IT GIVES TO ! CONSUM]4 ,:5 ,I SUGGE/ ?AT WORK+ H\RS %\LD BE R$UC$ TO F\R1 ,I AM NOT MEAN+ TO IMPLY ?AT ALL ! REMA9+ TIME %\LD NECESS>ILY BE SP5T 9 PURE FRIVOLITY4 ,I MEAN ?AT F\R H\RS' WORK A DAY %\LD 5TITLE A MAN TO ! NECESSITIES & ELEM5T>Y COM=TS ( LIFE1 & ?AT ! RE/ ( HIS TIME %\LD BE HIS TO USE AS HE MIT ( ANY SU* SOCIAL SY/EM ?AT $UCATION %\LD BE C>RI$ FUR!R ?AN IT USUALLY IS AT PRES5T1 & %\LD AIM1 9 P>T1 AT PROVID+ TA/ES :I* W\LD 5ABLE A MAN TO USE LEISURE 9TELLIG5TLY4 ,I AM NOT ?9K+ MA9LY ( ! SORT ( ?+S ?AT W\LD BE CONSID]$ 'HIEAS1 BUT ! IMPULSES :I* CAUS$ !M TO BE CULTIVAT$ MU/ /ILL EXI/ 9 HUMAN NATURE4 ,! PLEASURES ( URBAN POPULATIONS HAVE BECOME MA9LY PASSIVE3 SEE+ C9EMAS1 WAT*+ FOOTBALL MAT*ES1 LI/5+ TO ! RADIO1 & SO ON4 ,?IS RESULTS FROM ! FACT ?AT !IR ACTIVE 5]GIES >E FULLY TAK5 UP ) WORK2 IF !Y HAD MORE LEISURE1 !Y W\LD AGA9 5JOY PLEASURES 9 :I* !Y TOOK AN ACTIVE P>T4 ,9 ! PA/1 !RE WAS A SMALL LEISURE CLASS & A L>G] WORK+ CLASS4 ,! LEISURE CLASS 5JOY$ ADVANTAGES = :I* !RE WAS NO BASIS 9 SOCIAL JU/ICE2 ?IS NECESS>ILY MADE IT OPPRESSIVE1 LIMIT$ ITS SYMPA?IES1 & CAUS$ IT TO 9V5T !ORIES BY :I* TO JU/IFY ITS PRIVILEGES4 ,!SE FACTS GREATLY DIM9I%$ ITS EXCELL5CE1 BUT 9 SPITE ( ?IS DRAWBACK IT CONTRIBUT$ NE>LY ! :OLE ( :AT WE CALL CIVILIZATION4 ,IT CULTIVAT$ ! >TS & DISCOV]$ ! SCI5CES2 IT WROTE ! BOOKS1 9V5T$ ! PHILOSOPHIES1 & REF9$ SOCIAL RELATIONS4 ,EV5 ! LIB]ATION ( ! OPPRESS$ HAS USUALLY BE5 9AUGURAT$ FROM ABOVE4 ,)\T ! LEISURE CLASS1 MANK9D W\LD NEV] HAVE EM]G$ FROM B>B>ISM4 ,! ME?OD ( A LEISURE CLASS )\T DUTIES WAS1 H[EV]1 EXTRAORD9>ILY WA/EFUL4 ,NONE ( ! MEMB]S ( ! CLASS HAD TO BE TAUW91 BUT AGA9/ HIM HAD TO BE SET T5S ( ?\S&S ( C\NTRY G5TLEM5 :O NEV] ?\E SUPPOS$ TO PROVIDE1 9 A MORE SY/EMATIC WAY1 :AT ! LEISURE CLASS PROVID$ ACCID5TALLY & AS A BYPRODUCT4 ,?IS IS A GREAT IMPROVEM5T1 BUT IT HAS C]TA9 DRAWBACKS4 ,UNIV]SITY LIFE IS SO DIFF]5T FROM LIFE 9 ! WORLD AT L>GE ?AT M5 :O LIVE 9 ACADEMIC MILIEU T5D TO BE UNAW>E ( ! PREOCCUPATIONS & PROBLEMS ( ORD9>Y M5 & WOM52 MOREOV] !IR WAYS ( EXPRESS+ !MSELVES >E USUALLY SU* AS TO ROB !IR OP9IONS ( ! 9FLU5CE ?AT !Y \E ORGANIZ$1 & ! MAN :O ?9KS ( SOME ORIG9AL L9E ( RESE>* IS LIKELY TO BE DISC\RAG$4 ,ACADEMIC 9/ITUTIONS1 !RE=E1 USEFUL AS !Y >E1 >E NOT ADEQUATE GU>DIANS ( ! 9T]E/S ( CIVILIZATION 9 A WORLD :]E EV]YONE \TSIDE !IR WALLS IS TOO BUSY = UNUTILIT>IAN PURSUITS4 ,9 A WORLD :]E NO ONE IS COMPELL$ TO WORK MORE ?AN F\R H\RS A DAY1 EV]Y P]SON POSSESS$ ( SCI5TIFIC CURIOSITY WILL BE ABLE TO 9DULGE IT1 & EV]Y PA9T] WILL BE ABLE TO PA9T )\T />V+1 H[EV] EXCELL5T HIS PICTURES MAY BE4 ,Y\NG WRIT]S WILL NOT BE OBLIG$ TO DRAW ATT5TION TO !MSELVES BY S5SATIONAL POT-BOIL]S1 ) A VIEW TO ACQUIR+ ! ECONOMIC 9DEP5D5CE NE$$ = MONUM5TAL WORKS1 = :I*1 :5 ! TIME AT LA/ COMES1 !Y WILL HAVE LO/ ! TA/E & CAPACITY4 ,M5 :O1 9 !IR PR(ESSIONAL WORK1 HAVE BECOME 9T]E/$ 9 SOME PHASE ( ECONOMICS OR GOV]NM5T1 WILL BE ABLE TO DEVELOP !IR IDEAS )\T ! ACADEMIC DETA*M5T ?AT MAKES ! WORK ( UNIV]SITY ECONOMI/S (T5 SEEM LACK+ 9 REALITY4 ,M$ICAL M5 WILL HAVE ! TIME TO LE>N AB\T ! PROGRESS ( M$IC9E1 TEA*]S WILL NOT BE EXASP]AT$LY /RUGGL+ TO TEA* BY R\T9E ME?ODS ?+S :I* !Y LE>N$ 9 !IR Y\?1 :I* MAY1 9 ! 9T]VAL1 HAVE BE5 PROV$ TO BE UNTRUE4 ,ABOVE ALL1 !RE WILL BE HAPP9ESS & JOY ( LIFE1 9/EAD ( FRAY$ N]VES1 WE>9ESS1 & DYSPEPSIA4 ,! WORK EXACT$ WILL BE 5\< TO MAKE LEISURE DELIE TIME1 !Y WILL NOT DEM& ONLY SU* AMUSEM5TS AS >E PASSIVE & VAPID4 ,AT LEA/ ONE P]C5T WILL PROBABLY DEVOTE ! TIME NOT SP5T 9 PR(ESSIONAL WORK TO PURSUITS ( SOME PUBLIC IMPORTANCE1 &1 S9CE !Y WILL NOT DEP5D UPON !SE PURSUITS = !IR LIVELIHOOD1 !IR ORIG9ALITY WILL BE UNHAMP]$1 & !RE WILL BE NO NE$ TO CON=M TO ! /&>DS SET BY ELD]LY PUNDITS4 ,BUT IT IS NOT ONLY 9 !SE EXCEPTIONAL CASES ?AT ! ADVANTAGES ( LEISURE WILL APPE>4 ,ORD9>Y M5 & WOM51 HAV+ ! OPPORTUNITY ( A HAPPY LIFE1 WILL BECOME MORE K9DLY & LESS P]SECUT+ & LESS 9CL9$ TO VIEW O!RS ) SUSPICION4 ,! TA/E = W> WILL DIE \T1 P>TLY = ?IS REASON1 & P>TLY BECAUSE IT WILL 9VOLVE LONG & SEV]E WORK = ALL4 ,GOOD NATURE IS1 ( ALL MORAL QUALITIES1 ! ONE ?AT ! WORLD NE$S MO/1 & GOOD NATURE IS ! RESULT ( EASE & SECURITY1 NOT ( A LIFE ( >DU\S /RUGGLE4 ,MOD]N ME?ODS ( PRODUCTION HAVE GIV5 US ! POSSIBILITY ( EASE & SECURITY = ALL2 WE HAVE *OS51 9/EAD1 TO HAVE OV]WORK = SOME & />VATION = O!RS4 ,HI!RTO WE HAVE CONT9U$ TO BE AS 5]GETIC AS WE W]E BE=E !RE W]E MA*9ES2 9 ?IS WE HAVE BE5 FOOLI%1 BUT !RE IS NO REASON TO GO ON BE+ FOOLI% =EV]4 .<#a.> ,S9CE !N1 MEMB]S ( ! ,COMMUNI/ ,P>TY HAVE SUCCE$$ TO ?IS PRIVILEGE ( ! W>RIORS & PRIE/S4 4 ,FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/WWW4GEOCITIES4COM_/,A!NS_/,ORACLE_/#b#e#b#h_/BR.-IDLE4HTM4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,FEBRU>Y #a1 #bag 3 ,9 ,PRAISE ( ,IDL5ESS -- ,ADD$4 ,DECEMB] #c1 #bba 3 ,9 ,PRAISE ( ,IDL5ESS -- ,UPDAT$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/