,P>T #b1 ,*APT] #e 
,CAPITAL'S ,CLAIM TO ,9CREASE 

#ahigahig 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,B5JAM9 ,R4 ,TUCK] 

,TEXT 3 

,CAPITAL'S ,CLAIM TO ,9CREASE4 

.<,LIB]TY1 ,OCTOB] #a1 #a#h#h#a4.> 

,LIB]TY'S /RICTURES1 9 H] LA/ ISSUE1 UPON ! PROPOSAL ( ! ,MASSA*USETTS ,GRE5BACK]S1 ADOPT$ AT !IR ,WORCE/] CONV5TION1 TO ASK ! LEGISLATURE TO COMPEL ALL CORPORATIONS TO DI/RIBUTE !IR PR(ITS 9 EXCESS ( SIX P]C5T AMONG ! EMPLOYES 9 PROPORTION TO !IR WAGES HAS /IRR$ UP ,MR4 ,J4 ,M4 ,L4 ,BABCOCK1 ! AU?OR ( ?AT S+UL> PROJECT1 TO A DEF5SE ( IT4 ,& 9 DEF5D+ IT AGA9/ ,LIB]TY1 HE IS OBLIG$ TO DO SO 9 BEHALF ( CAPITAL4 ,IT SEEMS A LITTLE ODD TO F9D ?IS LONG-TIME DEF5D] ( ! RI<TS ( LABOR 9 ! ROLE ( *AMPION ( ! CLAIMS ( CAPITAL2 BUT WE REMEMB] ?AT HE IS ONE :O FOLL[S ! LEAD ( JU/ICE AS HE SEES IT1 TAKE HIM :]E IT MAY47#e#g 8 #a7  

,BE=E PREC$+ TO ! MA9 QUE/ION1 HE GIVES US TWO M9OR PO9TS TO SETTLE4 ,FIR/1 HE V]Y P]T95TLY ASKS :Y WE GRIEVE AT HIS C\RSE4 ,WE ANSW] BY TAK+ IT ALL BACK4 ,AS HE SAYS1 ,LIB]TY %\LD REJOICE1 RA!R ?AN GRIEVE1 AT ! HONE/ EX]CISE ( ! RI<T TO DIFF]4 ,:5 WE HA/ILY SAID O!RWISE1 WE SAID A V]Y FOOLI% ?+4 ,YES1 WORSE ?AN ?AT2 9 SO F> WE W]E FALSE TO \R [N /&>D4 ,MR4 ,BABCOCK HAS ,LIB]TY'S S9C]E/ ?ANKS = RECALL+ H] TO H] [N POSITION4 ,MAY HE & ALL NEV] FAIL TO %>PLY PROD US1 :5EV] !Y SIMIL>LY CAT* US NAPP+6.<#i.>7#e#g 8 #b7  

,SECOND1 HE ASSUMES ?AT ! PR(IT IDEA CANNOT BE RIDICUL\S 7AS WE PRON\NC$ IT71 S9CE ITS CONV]SE IS NOT WELL E/ABLI%$ OR G5]ALLY ACCEPT$4 ,TO SAY ?AT ! NO-PR(IT !ORY IS NOT WELL E/ABLI%$ IS TO BEG ! PR9CIPAL QUE/ION UND] DISCUSSION2 TO SAY ?AT1 BECAUSE ! !ORY IS NOT G5]ALLY ACCEPT$1 ! FRI5DS ?AT IT HAS >E NOT 5TITL$ TO RIDICULE ! POSITION ( ITS 5EMIES IS NOT 9 ACCORDANCE ) ! NATURE ( IDEAS OR ! CU/OM ( ,MR4 ,BABCOCK4 ,H[ (T5 HAVE WE LI/5$ ) DELI<T TO HIS S>CA/IC DISSECTION & M]CILESS EXPOSURE TO ! LI<T ( COMMON S5SE ( SOME POPUL> & WELL-NI< UNIV]SAL DELUSION 9 RELIGION1 POLITICS1 F9ANCE1 OR SOCIAL LIFE6 ,HE IS 9 ! HABIT ( HOLD+ RIDICUL\S ALL ?OSE ?+S1 :OEV] SUPPORTS !M1 :I* HIS [N REASON PRON\NCES ABSURD4 ,& HE IS RI<T 9 DO+ SO1 & WRONG 9 SAY+ ?AT WE \<T NOT TO FOLL[ HIS EXAMPLE4 ,SO1 :ILE IT IS CLE> ?AT ON ! FIR/ M9OR PO9T ,MR4 ,BABCOCK HAS ! BETT] ( ,LIB]TY1 ON ! SECOND ,LIB]TY AS DECID$LY HAS ! BETT] ( ,MR4 ,BABCOCK47#e#g 8 #c7  

,N[ TO ! QUE/ION PROP]4 ,LABOR1 SAYS \R FRI5D1 NEV] GA9S ANY?+ BY EXTRAVAGANT CLAIMS4 ,TRUE2 & NO CLAIM IS EXTRAVAGANT ?AT DOES NOT EXCE$ JU/ICE4 ,BUT IT IS EQUALLY TRUE ?AT LABOR ALWAYS LOSES BY FOOLI% CONCESSIONS2 & 9 ?IS 9DU/RIAL /RUGGLE EV]Y CONCESSION IS FOOLI% ?AT FALLS %ORT ( JU/ICE4 ,IT IS TO BE DECID$1 !N1 NOT :E!R ,LIB]TY'S CLAIM = LABOR IS EXTRAVAGANT1 BUT :E!R IT IS JU/4 ,:ATEV] CONTRIBUTES TO PRODUCTION IS 5TITL$ TO AN EQUITABLE %>E 9 ! DI/RIBUTION6 ,WRONG6 ,:OEV] CONTRIBUTES TO PRODUCTION IS ALONE SO 5TITL$4 ,:AT HAS NO RI<TS ?AT ,:O IS B\ND TO RESPECT4 ,:AT IS A ?+4 ,:O IS A P]SON4 ,?+S HAVE NO CLAIMS2 !Y EXI/ ONLY TO BE CLAIM$4 ,! POSSESSION ( A RI<T CANNOT BE PR$ICAT$ ( DEAD MAT]IAL1 BUT ONLY ( A LIV+ P]SON4 ,9 ! PRODUCTION ( A LOAF ( BREAD1 ! PL[ P]=MS AN IMPORTANT S]VICE1 & EQUITABLY COMES 9 = A %>E ( ! LOAF4 ,ABSURD6 ,A PL[ CANNOT [N BREAD1 &1 IF IT C\LD1 W\LD BE UNABLE TO EAT IT4 ,A PL[ IS A ,:AT1 ONE ( ?OSE ?+S ABOVE M5TION$1 TO :I* NO RI<TS >E ATTRIBUTABLE47#e#g 8 #d7  

,OH6 BUT WE SEE4 ,SUPPOSE ONE MAN SP5DS HIS LIFE 9 MAK+ PL[S TO BE US$ BY O!RS :O S[ & H>VE/ :EAT4 ,IF HE FURNI%ES HIS PL[S ONLY ON CONDITION ?AT !Y BE RETURN$ TO HIM 9 AS GOOD /ATE AS :5 TAK5 AWAY1 H[ IS HE TO GET HIS BREAD8 ,IT IS ! MAK] ( ! PL[1 !N1 & NOT ! PL[ ITSELF1 ?AT IS 5TITL$ TO A REW>D8 ,:AT HAS GIV5 PLACE TO ,:O4 ,WELL1 WE'LL NOT QU>REL OV] ?AT4 ,! MAK] ( ! PL[ C]TA9LY IS 5TITL$ TO PAY = HIS WORK4 ,FULL PAY1 PAID ONCE2 NO MORE4 ,?AT PAY IS ! PL[ ITSELF1 OR ITS EQUIVAL5T 9 O!R M>KETABLE PRODUCTS1 SAID EQUIVAL5T BE+ MEASUR$ BY ! AM\NT ( LABOR EMPLOY$ 9 !IR PRODUCTION4 ,BUT IF HE L5DS HIS PL[ & GETS ONLY HIS PL[ BACK1 H[ IS HE TO GET HIS BREAD8 ASKS ,MR4 ,BABCOCK1 MU* CONC]N$4 ,ASK US AN EASY ONE1 IF Y\ PLEASE4 ,WE GIVE ?IS ONE UP4 ,BUT :Y %\LD HE L5D HIS PL[8 ,:Y DOES HE NOT SELL IT TO ! F>M]1 & USE ! PROCE$S TO BUY BREAD ( ! BAK]8 ,SEE1 ,MR4 ,BABCOCK8 ,IF ! L5D] ( ! PL[ RECEIVES NO?+ MORE ?AN HIS PL[ AGA91 HE RECEIVES NO?+ = ! PRODUCT ( HIS [N LABOR1 & IS ON ! WAY TO />VATION4 ,WELL1 IF ! FOOL WILL NOT SELL HIS PL[1 LET HIM />VE4 ,:O C>ES8 ,IT'S HIS [N FAULT4 ,H[ CAN HE EXPECT TO RECEIVE ANY?+ = ! PRODUCT ( HIS [N LABOR IF HE REFUSES TO P]MAN5TLY P>T ) IT8 ,DOES ,MR4 ,BABCOCK PROPOSE TO /EADILY ADD TO ?IS PRODUCT AT ! EXP5SE ( SOME LABOR]1 & MEAN:ILE ALL[ ?IS IDL]1 :O HAS ONLY MADE A PL[1 TO LOAF ON 9 LUXURY1 = ! BALANCE ( HIS LIFE1 ON ! /R5G? ( HIS ONE A*IEVEM5T8 ,C]TA9LY NOT1 :5 \R FRI5D UND]/&S HIMSELF4 ,& !N HE WILL SAY ) US ?AT ! SLICE ( BREAD :I* ! PL[-L5D] %\LD RECEIVE CAN BE NEI!R L>GE NOR SMALL1 BUT MU/ BE NO?+47#e#g 8 #e7  

,TO ?AT 5D WE COMM5D TO ,MR4 ,BABCOCK ! WORDS ( HIS [N C&IDATE = ,SECRET>Y ( ,/ATE1 NOM9AT$ AT ! ,WORCE/] CONV5TION1 ,A4 ,B4 ,BR[N1 $ITOR ( ,! ,REPUBLIC1 :O SAYS3 ,! LABOR]S ( ! WORLD1 9/EAD ( HAV+ ONLY A SMALL FRACTION ( ! WEAL? 9 ! WORLD1 %\LD HAVE ALL ! WEAL?4 ,TO EFFECT ?IS ALL MONOPOLIES %\LD BE T]M9AT$1--:E!R !Y BE MONOPOLIES ( S+LE 9DIVIDUALS OR MAJORITIES1--& LABOR-CO/ MU/ BE RECOGNIZ$ AS ! MEASURE & LIMIT ( PRICE4 ,IF ,MR4 ,BR[N /ICKS TO !SE WORDS1 & ! ,GRE5BACK]S TO !IR PLAT=M1 !RE IS GO+ TO BE A COLLISION1 & ,MR4 ,BR[N WILL KEEP ! TRACK4 ,BUT LE/ ,MR4 ,BR[N'S AU?ORITY %\LD NOT PROVE SUFFICI5T1 WE REF] ,MR4 ,BABCOCK TO ONE ( HIS FAVORITE AU?ORS1 ,JOHN ,RUSK91 :O >GUES ?IS V]Y PO9T ON ,MR4 ,BABCOCK'S [N GR\ND1 EXCEPT ?AT HE ILLU/RATES HIS POSITION BY A PLANE 9/EAD ( A PL[4 ,MR4 ,BABCOCK MAY F9D HIS WORDS UND] ! HEAD+1 ,! ,POSITION ( ,WILLIAM1 IMM$IATELY FOLL[+ HIS [N LETT] TO US4 ,IF HE SUCCE$S 9 %[+ ,MR4 ,BR[N'S ASS]TIONS TO BE BASELESS & ,MR4 ,RUSK9'S >GUM5TS TO BE ILLOGICAL1 HE MAY !N COME TO ,LIB]TY = O!R FOES TO CONQU]4 ,TILL !N WE %ALL BE BUT AN 9T]E/$ SPECTATOR ( HIS CONTE/47#e#g 8 #f7 

#eg N4 #a4 ,READ+ ?IS P>AGRAPH ELEV5 YE>S LAT]1 ,I AM 9CL9$ TO REGRET ?AT ,I WROTE IT4 ,SO FEW >E ! MANIFE/ATIONS ( GOOD NATURE 9 MY POLEMICAL WRIT+S1 ?AT ,I CAN ILL AF=D TO DIS[N ANY ( !M2 BUT IT REALLY SEEMS ?AT ON ?IS OCCASION ,I TRI$ A LITTLE TOO H>D TO BE FAIR4 ,! GRIEF = :I* ,I ?US APOLOGIZ$ WAS OV] ! FACT ?AT ,MR4 ,BABCOCK HELD AN OP9ION 9 FAVOR ( 9JU/ICE1 -- NOT OV] ! FACT ?AT1 HOLD+ SU* AN OP9ION1 HE GAVE EXPRESSION TO IT4 8 

,FROM 3 FAIR-USE4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahif 3 ,P>T #b1 ,*APT] #e -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,FEBRU>Y #b1 #bag 3 ,P>T #b1 ,*APT] #e -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/