,P>T #c1 ,*APT] #h 
,LIB]TY & ! ,GEORGE ,!ORY 

#ahigahig 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,B5JAM9 ,R4 ,TUCK] 

,TEXT 3 

,LIB]TY & ! ,GEORGE ,!ORY4 

.<,LIB]TY1 ,NOVEMB] #e1 #a#h#h#g4.> 

,!RE IS MU* 9 ,LIB]TY TO ADMIRE1 & 9 ,AN>*ISM ?AT ,I BELIEVE HAS A DIV9E RI<T ( WAY4 ,BUT ,I SEE LITTLE ( !SE QUALITIES 9 ! CRITICISMS MADE BY ,$ITOR ,TUCK] ON ! ,GEORGE MOVEM5T1 & MU*1 AS ,I ?9K1 ( ! EXAGG]ATION & 9CONSI/5CY 9H]5T 9 ! ,AN>*I/IC TEMP] & TEA*+S47#a#f 8 #a7  

,Y\ HAVE MORE RESPECT1 Y\ SAY1 = ! ,/ATE ,SOCIALI/ ?AN = ,H5RY ,GEORGE1 & 9 ! /RUGGLE BETWE5 ! TWO Y\R SYMPA?Y IS ) ! =M]4 ,?IS IS VAGUE1 TO SAY ! LEA/2 & ! MEAN+ IS NOT HELP$ BY ! COMP>ISON ) ! ,ROMAN ,CA?OLIC :O BELIEVES 9 AU?ORITY )\T QUALIFICATION1 & ! ,PROTE/ANT :O SPEAKS 9 ! NAME ( LIB]TY1 BUT DOES NOT KN[ ! MEAN+ ( ! WORD4 ,SU* EXPRESSIONS SEEM TO ME TO PO9T NO ISSUE1 BUT TO DODGE OR CONFUSE ISSUES4 ,! QUE/ION IS ?REEFOLD1 RELAT+ TO TACTICS1 SPIRIT1 & DOCTR9E1 :I* >E NOT ALWAYS ONE1 OR ( ! SAME RELATIVE IMPORTANCE4 ,Y\ DO NOT SAY :E!R ! EXPULSION ( ! ,SOCIALI/S WAS JU/1 :E!R !Y ACT$ 9 GOOD FAI? AS MEMB]S ( ! ,UNIT$ ,LABOR P>TY1 OR BELIEV$ !IR DOCTR9E HAD ANY LOGICAL FILIATION ) ITS PLAT=M4 ,?IS \<T TO HAVE SOME?+ TO DO ) \R RESPECT & SYMPA?Y4 ,TO HOLD TO ! BELIEF ( A ,ROMAN ,CA?OLIC IS ONE ?+1 & TO 5T] AN EVANGELICAL BODY AS AN EMISS>Y ( ! ,POPE IS QUITE ANO!R4 ,Y\ SEEM TO SLUR ?IS ISSUE 9 SPEAK+ M]ELY ( ! RIDICUL\S FIGURE ! ,SOCIALI/S N[ CUT 9 !IR SACKCLO? & A%ES1 = RIDICUL\S IS NOT A WORD ( A V]Y SPECIFIC MEAN+4 ,BUT Y\R CLOS+ REM>K APPE>S TO BE A CONTRADICTION ( ! FIR/ SO PRAISEFUL ( ! SIMPLE /ABLE VIEWS ( ! ,/ATE ,SOCIALI/2 = ( ! ACT ( ! ,LABOR ,5QUIR] 9 HOI/+ ,H5RY ,GEORGE'S NAME ONE DAY & PULL+ IT D[N ! NEXT Y\ SAY IT %[S1 NOT A REVOLUTION 9 IDEAS1 BUT ?AT IT HAD NO IDEAS DEF9ITE 5\< TO BE REVOLUTIONIZ$47#a#f 8 #b7  

,& DO Y\ REALLY BELIEVE ?AT ,PROTE/ANTISM IS NOT AN ADVANCE ON ,ROMAN ,CA?OLICISM2 ?AT SU* M5 AS ,LU!R1 ,WESLEY1 ,*ANN+1 >E NOT AS RESPECTABLE AS ! ,ROMAN PONTIFFS8 ,DO Y\ ?9K ! APO/ATE OR REBELLI\S ELEM5T 9 BO? ,*UR* & ,/ATE IS NOT AS DES]V+ ( RESPECT AS ! OLD] BODY1 SIMPLY BECAUSE IT DOES NOT REA* ! GOAL ( FRE$OM AT A B\ND8 ,HAVE Y\ MORE SYMPA?Y ) ,ASIA ?AN ,EUROPE1 ) ,EUROPE ?AN ,AM]ICA1 ) UNQUALIFI$ DESPOTISM ?AN ) A CON/ITUTIONAL MON>*Y1 ) MON>*Y ?AN ) REPUBLICANISM8 ,& IS !RE NO ROOM = !ORY OR EXP]IM5T BETWE5 ,/ATE ,SOCIALISM & ,AN>*ISM1 NO FOO?OLD = L>GE VIEWS & MANLY PURPOSES8 ,>E ,H5RY ,GEORGE & HIS C[ORK]S ( ! CLASS :O SPEAK 9 ! NAME ( LIB]TY1 BUT DO NOT KN[ ! MEAN+ ( ! WORD8 ,IS !IR TALK & SPIRIT RUBBI% BY ! SIDE NOT ONLY ( ,AN>*ISM1 BUT ITS OPPOSITE1 ,/ATE ,SOCIALISM8 ,DID LIB]TY HAVE NO?+ TO DO ) ! WRIT+ ( ,PROGRESS & ,POV]TY1--?AT BOOK ?AT HAS SET SO MANY TO ?9K+ & ACT+1 & HAS DONE MORE TO POPUL>IZE ! SCI5CE ( POLITICAL ECONOMY ?AN ! WRIT+S ( ANY DOZ5 M51 IF NOT ( ALL M51 ON ?AT !ME8 ,HAD LIB]TY NO?+ TO DO ) ! />T+ ( ! ,/&>D1 ! ,ANTI-,POV]TY ,SOCIETY1 ! ANO9T+ ( ,MC,GLYNN1 ,P5TECO/1 ,HUNT+TON1 ,R$PA?1 ,MC,GUIRE1 & ! RE/ ( ! NEW APO/OLATE ( FRE$OM8 ,I AM AW>E !RE >E ?+S CONNECT$ ) ?IS RE=M TO :I* EXCEPTIONS CAN & MU/ BE MADE2 BUT !Y DO NOT PROVE IT IS NOT ,LIB]TY'S (FSPR+1 AN ONW>D MOVEM5T FREI<T$ ) B5EFIT = ! RACE47#a#f 8 #c7  

,( A PIECE ) ?IS CRITICISM IS ANO!R >TICLE 9 ! SAME NUMB]1 9 :I* Y\ GO EV5 F>!R1 & SAY3 ,MR4 ,GEORGE MAY AS WELL UND]/& FIR/ AS LA/ ?AT LABOR WILL REFUSE TO BEG9 ?IS WORLD ANEW4 ,IT NEV] WILL AB&ON EV5 ITS PRES5T MEAG] 5JOYM5T ( WEAL? & ! MEANS ( WEAL? :I* HAVE GR[N \T ( ITS AGES ( SORR[1 SUFF]+1 & SLAV]Y4 ,IF ,MR4 ,GEORGE (F]S IT L& ALONE1 IT WILL TURN ITS BACK UPON HIM4 ,IT 9SI/S UPON BO? L& & TOOLS4 ,?AT IS AN A/\ND+ ASS]TION ?AT HE ASKS LABOR TO BEG9 ?IS WORLD ANEW1 & TO AB&ON :AT IT ALREADY HAS1 & \<T TO BE BACK$ BY SOME %[ ( >GUM5T2 BUT ,I SEE NONE4 ,H[ >E ! PEOPLE TO LOSE BY BE+ MADE !IR [N L&LORDS8 ,H[ >E !Y TO BE ROBB$ ( !IR PRES5T ADVANTAGES 9 HAV+ ! L& MADE FREE8 ,Y\R :OLE >GUM5T1 FILL+ A COLUMN1 IS ?AT ! CITY OP]ATIVE WILL NOT BE TEMPT$ TO LEAVE :AT HE HAS = ! SEMI-B>B>\S CONDITION ( ! BACKWOODSMAN )\T AN AX1 BUILD+ A HUT ( MUD1 /RIK+ FIRE ) FL9T & /EEL1 & SCRAT*+ A LIV+ ) HIS F+] NAILS6 ,N[1 IF ! VACANT LOTS & TRACTS ( L& 9 & AB\T ALL ! CITIES >E BR\<T 9TO USE BY BE+ BUILT UPON OR CULTIVAT$1 WILL NOT ! /IMULUS GIV5 TO 9DU/RY & ! 9CREAS$ OPPORTUNITY = EMPLOYM5T RESULT+ !REFROM NOT ONLY 5ABLE ! OP]ATIVE TO BUY AN AX1 RAKE1 HOE1 HAMM]1 SAW1 & EV5 A HORSE & PL[8 ,& NOT ONLY ?IS1 BUT TO F9D A SUITABLE PAT* ( L& )\T GO+ SO F> BEYOND ! B\ND>IES ( CIVILIZATION AS Y\ IMAG9E8 ,BUT ! IDEA IS NOT ?AT EV]Y ONE WILL BECOME A F>M] OR L&[N]1 BUT ?AT ! *EAP5+ & FREE+ ( ?IS PRIM>Y FACTOR ( PRODUCTION1 ! L&1 WILL MAKE IT POSSIBLE = ?OSE ( V]Y LIMIT$ MEANS & RES\RCES TO DO MORE = !MSELVES & = ! WORLD ?AN N[1 BESIDES R5D]+ CAPITAL MORE ACTIVE1 MORE PRODUCTIVE2 ! CLE> T5D5CY ( :I* W\LD BE TO RELIEVE ! LABOR M>KET1 & MAKE ! DEM& = LABOR GREAT] ?AN ! SUPPLY1 & SO RAISE WAGES & SECURE TO LABOR ITS JU/ REW>D4 ,& Y\ DO NOT SEE H[ ?IS IS 9 ! 9T]E/ ( FRE$OM2 H[ ! FREE+ ( L& WILL 5ABLE M5 TO BECOME ! POSSESSORS1 NOT ONLY ( ! TOOLS !Y NE$1 BUT ( !IR 9DIVIDUALITY AS WELL6 ,TAK+ TAXES (F 9DU/RY1 & SUB/ITUT+ !RE= ! SOCIAL VALUES GIV5 TO L&1 Y\ CALL RETROGRESSION1 OR RA!R A REM$Y SIMIL>--= A P>T ( MANK9D AT LEA/--TO ?AT ATTRIBUT$ TO ! ,NIHILI/S1 ! TOTAL DE/RUCTION ( ! EXI/+ SOCIAL ORD]1 & ! CREATION ( A NEW ONE ON ITS RU9S6 ,?IS IS WILD TALK1 & IS NONE ! LESS SO BECAUSE ( ! USE ( ! FEEBLE ADJECTIVE1 SIMIL>1 & ! HALT+ PHRASE1 AT LEA/ A P>T ( MANK9D1 :I* DE/ROY ! VALUE ( ! COMP>ISON = ! PURPOSE ( >GUM5T1 &1 LIKE ! WRODS RESPECT1 SYMPA?Y1 RIDICUL\S1 & SEMI-B>B>\S1 %[ ?AT ,LIB]TY1 ! ,AN>*I/ ORGAN P> EXCELL5CE1 MAY DOGMATIZE 9/EAD ( REASON1 & MAKE P]SONAL DICTUM OR CAPRICE ! /&>D ( RI<T47#a#f 8 #d7  

,BUT !RE IS SOME?+ ( MORE CONSEQU5CE ?AN ! VULN]ABLE PO9TS 9 ,LIB]TY'S LOGIC1 = IT GOES DEEP]4 ,GRANT+ ?AT ?IS RE=M DOES MEAN ! CREATION ( A NEW ORD] 9VOLV+ LOSSES & SACRIFICES TO ! 9DIVIDUAL = A G5]ATION1 IS ?AT ITS CONDEMNATION8 ,WORDS CANNOT EXPRESS MY A/ONI%M5T AT ! MANN] 9 :I* ,LIB]TY TELLS ITS READ]S ?AT ! CITY OP]ATIVE CANNOT BE TEMPT$ TO BEG9 LIFE AS A B>B>IAN1 EV5 ) ! HOPE ?AT 9 ! C\RSE ( A LIFETIME HE MAY SLI<TLY IMPROVE HIS CONDITION1 = HE W\LD BE A FOOL NOT TO PREF] TO ?IS ! CITY ) ITS /REET B&S1 %OP W9D[S1 !AT]S1 & *UR*ES1 EV5 ?\< HE HAVE TO BREA! TA9T$ AIR & DRESS 9 RAGS4 ,AH1 IT IS 9DE$ TRUE1 AS Y\ SAY1 MAN DOES NOT LIVE BY BREAD ALONE1 & = ?AT REASON HE PREF]S PURE AIR & 9DEP5D5CE ALONG ) ISOLATION & /RUGGLE1 TO TA9T$ AIR & S]FDOM ALONG ) BRASS B&S & H& ORGANS1 GAUDY W9D[S1 & ,BLACK ,CROOK P]=MANCES4 ,BUT IS ?AT BEG9N+ LIFE AS A B>B>IAN1 NO MATT] ) IMPLEM5TS H[EV] RUDE1 AT PLACES H[EV] REMOTE FROM ! C5T]S ( PRIDE & LUXURY1 ) FRUITS ( TOIL H[EV] SL[ 9 RIP5+1 IF ! P]SONS >E MOV$ BY ! ?\<T ( BETT]+1 NOT !IR [N CONDITION M]ELY1 BUT ?AT ( ! WORLD1 ( ! G5]ATIONS TO COME8 ,HAVE NOT ! PIONE]S ( FRE$OM1 ! VANGU>DS ( CIVILIZATION1 AGA9 & AGA9 BEGUN LIFE AS ! B>B>IAN1 SO TO SPEAK8 ,?IS RE=M1 IT IS TRUE1 MEANS BREAD1 BUT BREAD = ALL1 ?\< !RE BY LUXURY = NONE4 ,WE KN[ ! ADVANTAGES ( CITY LIFE1 & = ?AT REASON WE W\LD D5Y \RSELVES ?OSE ADVANTAGES 9 ORD] ?AT CITIES MI<T SPREAD & CIVILIZATION EXP&47#a#f 8 #e7  

,WE WANT ! E>?1 BUT DO NOT MEAN TO RUN AWAY ) IT2 !RE WILL /ILL BE PL5TY ( ROOM1--YES1 MORE ?AN BE=E1 F> MORE4 ,IT WILL BE ! BEG9N+1 NOT ! 5D1 ( RE=M2 NOT ! LA/ /EP1 BUT A GREAT /RIDE =W>D4 ,SOCIALISM & ,AN>*ISM WILL BO? HAVE A BETT] *ANCE ?AN N[1 IF ! 9SUFFICI5CY ( ! PR9CIPLE IS PROV54 ,= IT IS ,SOCIALI/IC 9 ASS]T+ ! COMMON [N]%IP ( ! SOIL & GOV]NM5TAL CONTROL ( SU* ?+S AS >E 9 !IR NATURE MONOPOLIES1 :ILE IT IS ,AN>*I/IC 9 LEAV+ ALL ELSE TO ! NATURAL *ANNELS ( FREE PRODUCTION & EX*ANGE1 TO FREE CONTRACT & SPONTANE\S COOP]ATION47#a#f 8 #f7 

,T4 ,W4 ,CURTIS 
  

,MR4 ,CURTIS'S CRITICISMS >E BAS$ UPON A S]IES ( MISAPPREH5SIONS ( ,LIB]TY'S /ATEM5TS1 & 9 ONE 9/ANCE UPON SOME?+ ?AT LOOKS V]Y LIKE DELIB]ATE MISREPRES5TATION47#a#f 8 #g7  

,9 ! FIR/ PLACE1 HE MISAPPREH5DS MY EXPRESSION ( GREAT] RESPECT = & SYMPA?Y ) ! ,/ATE ,SOCIALI/S ?AN ,H5RY ,GEORGE1 SEEM+ TO ?9K ?AT ?IS PREF]5CE 9CLUD$ 9 ITS SWEEP NOT ONLY MATT]S ( DOCTR9E1 BUT MATT]S ( TACTICS & SPIRIT4 ,! =M ( MY ASS]TION %[S ?AT ,I CONF9$ IT TO DOCTR9E SIMPLY4 ,! DECL>ATION WAS ?AT ,I HAVE F> MORE RESPECT = ! ,/ATE ,SOCIALI/S ?AN = ,GEORGE1 JU/ AS ,I HAVE MORE RESPECT = ! ,ROMAN ,CA?OLIC ,*RI/IAN1 :O BELIEVES 9 AU?ORITY )\T QUALIFICATION1 ?AN = ! ,PROTE/ANT ,*RI/IAN1 :O SPEAKS 9 ! NAME ( LIB]TY1 BUT DOES NOT KN[ ! MEAN+ ( ! WORD4 ,NO ONE BUT ,MR4 ,CURTIS W\LD DREAM ( 9F]R+ FROM !SE WORDS ?AT ,I PREF] ! TACTICS & SPIRIT ( ,TORQUEMADA TO ?OSE ( ,*ANN+4 ,I LEFT TACTICS & SPIRIT 5TIRELY ASIDE 9 MAK+ ! ABOVE /ATEM5T4 ,9 RESPECT TO CONDUCT ,I ASS]T$ SUP]IORITY NEI!R = ! ,/ATE ,SOCIALI/ NOR = ,GEORGE4 ,:E!R ! ,/ATE ,SOCIALI/S W5T TO ,GEORGE OR HE W5T TO !M1 OR :I* SEC$$ FROM OR BETRAY$ ! O!R1 >E QUE/IONS :I* 9T]E/ ME ONLY 9 A M9OR DEGREE4 ,TO ME REASON IS ! HI<E/ & GR&E/ FACULTY ( MAN2 & ,I PLACE ,GEORGE L[] 9 MY E/EEM ?AN ! ,/ATE ,SOCIALI/1 BECAUSE ,I CONSID] HIM ! GREAT] (F5D] AGA9/ REASON4 ,?IS IS ! S5SE 9 :I* ,I PREF] ,CA?OLICISM TO ,PROTE/ANTISM1 ,ASIA TO ,EUROPE1 & MON>*Y TO REPUBLICANISM4 ,! ,CA?OLIC1 ! ,ASIATIC1 & ! MON>* >E MORE LOGICAL1 MORE CONSI/5T1 MORE /RAI<T=W>D1 LESS CORKSCREWY1 MORE /RICTLY PLUMB-L9E ?AN ! ,PROTE/ANT1 ! ,EUROPEAN1 & ! REPUBLICAN4 ,?IS IS NOT A NOVEL IDEA1 & ,I AM AT A LOSS TO ACC\NT = ,MR4 ,CURTIS'S SURPRISE OV] IT4 ,DID HE NEV] H]E ?AT !RE IS NO HALF-WAY H\SE BETWE5 ,ROME & ,REASON8 ,LIKEWISE !RE IS NO ROOM = LOGICAL1 CONSI/5T !ORY OR 9TELLIG5T1 SY/EMATIC EXP]IM5T BETWE5 ,/ATE ,SOCIALISM & ,AN>*ISM4 ,!RE IS PL5TY ( ROOM BETWE5 !M TO JUMBLE !ORIES & TO EXP]IM5T BL9DLY1 BUT ?AT IS ALL4 ,! PITY IS ?AT ROOM ( ?IS K9D %\LD BE SO POPUL>47#a#f 8 #h7  

,YES1 ,H5RY ,GEORGE & HIS C[ORK]S >E ( ?AT CLASS :O SPEAK 9 ! NAME ( LIB]TY1 BUT DO NOT KN[ ! MEAN+ ( ! WORD4 ,MR4 ,GEORGE HAS NO CONCEPTION ( LIB]TY AS A UNIV]SAL SOCIAL LAW4 ,HE HAPP5S TO SEE ?AT 9 SOME ?+S IT W\LD LEAD TO GOOD RESULTS1 & !RE=E 9 ?OSE ?+S FAVORS IT4 ,BUT IT HAS NEV] DAWN$ UPON HIS M9D ?AT DISORD] IS ! 9EVITABLE FRUIT ( EV]Y PLANT :I* HAS AU?ORITY = ITS ROOT4 ,AS ,JOHN ,F4 ,KELLY SAYS ( HIM1 HE IS 9CL9$ TO LOOK ) FAVOR ON ! PR9CIPLE ( LAISSEZ FAIRE1 YET HE WILL AB&ON IT AT ANY MOM5T1 :5EV] REGULATION SEEMS MORE LIKELY TO PRODUCE IMM$IATE B5EFITS1 REG>DLESS ( ! EVILS !REBY PRODUC$ BY MAK+ ! PEOPLE LESS JEAL\S ( ,/ATE 9T]F]5CE4 ,! NATURE ( HIS BELIEF 9 LIB]TY IS WELL ILLU/RAT$ BY HIS ATTITUDE ON ! T>IFF QUE/ION4 ,ONE W\LD SUPPOSE FROM HIS G5]ALIZATION ?AT HE HAS ! UTMO/ FAI? 9 FRE$OM ( COMPETITION2 BUT ONE DOES NOT REALIZE H[ LITTLE ?IS FAI? AM\NTS TO UNTIL HE HE>S HIM1 AFT] MAK+ L\D FREE-TRADE PR(ESSIONS1 PROPOSE TO SUB/ITUTE A SY/EM ( B\NTIES = ! T>IFF SY/EM4 ,IF SU* POLITICAL & ECONOMIC EMPIRICISM IS NOT RUBBI% BESIDE ! COH]5T PROPOSALS ( EI!R ,AN>*ISM OR ,/ATE ,SOCIALISM1 !N ,I DON'T KN[ *AFF FROM :EAT47#a#f 8 #i7  

,LIB]TY1 ( C\RSE1 HAD SOME?+ TO DO ) ! WRIT+ ( ,PROGRESS & ,POV]TY4 ,IT ALSO HAD SOME?+ TO DO ) ! FRAM+ ( DIVORCE LAWS AS A RELIEF FROM 9DISSOLUBLE M>RIAGE4 ,BUT ! DIVORCE LAWS1 9/EAD ( BE+ LIB]T>IAN1 >E AN EXPRESS RECOGNITION ( ! RI<TFULNESS ( AU?ORITY OV] ! SEXUAL RELATIONS4 ,SIMIL>LY ,PROGRESS & ,POV]TY EXPRESSLY RECOGNIZES ! RI<TFULNESS ( AU?ORITY OV] ! CULTIVATION & USE ( L&4 ,= SOME C5TURIES N[ EVOLUTION HAS BE5 LITTLE ELSE ?AN ! HI/ORY ( LIB]TY2 NEV]!LESS ALL ITS FACTORS HAVE NOT BE5 *ILDR5 ( LIB]TY47#a#f 8 #a7  

,MR4 ,CURTIS TRIES TO CONVICT ME ( CONTRADICTION BY PO9T+ TO MY /ATEM5T ?AT ,BURNETTE ,HASKELL1 A ,/ATE ,SOCIALI/1 HAS NO DEF9ITE IDEAS4 ,?IS HE ?9KS 9CONSI/5T ) MY PRAISE ( ! SIMPLE /ABLE VIEWS ( ! ,/ATE ,SOCIALI/4 ,H]E IS :]E ! COLOR ( MISREPRES5TATION APPE>S4 ,9 ORD] TO MAKE HIS PO9T ,MR4 ,CURTIS IS OBLIG$ TO QUOTE ME 9CORRECTLY4 ,HE ATTRIBUTES TO ME ! FOLL[+ PHRASE ! RIDICUL\S FIGURE ! ,SOCIALI/S N[ CUT 9 !IR SACKCLO? & A%ES4 ,MY REAL WORDS W]E3 ! RIDICUL\S FIGURE ?AT SOME ( !M N[ CUT 9 !IR SACKCLO? & A%ES4 ,IT MAKES ALL ! DIFF]5CE :E!R 9 ?IS S5T5CE ,I REF]R$ TO ! :OLE BODY ( ,/ATE ,SOCIALI/S OR ONLY TO A FEW 9DIVIDUALS AMONG !M4 ,IT WAS PRECISELY BECAUSE ,I WAS AB\T TO CRITICIZE ! CONDUCT ( ONE ,/ATE ,SOCIALI/ 9 ORD] TO %[ ?AT HE HAD NO REAL IDEA ( ,/ATE ,SOCIALISM ?AT ,I FELT IT NECESS>Y TO PREFACE MY CRITICISM BY SEP>AT+ DOCTR9E FROM CONDUCT & DECL>+ MY PREF]5CE = ! ,/ATE ,SOCIALI/ OV] ,GEORGE 9 ! MATT] ( DOCTR9E4 ,BUT ,MR4 ,CURTIS WILL HAVE IT ?AT ,I TOOK ,HASKELL AS A TYPICAL ,/ATE ,SOCIALI/1 EV5 IF HE HAS TO RESORT TO MISQUOTATION TO PROVE IT47#a#f 8 #a#a7  

,HE NEXT TURNS HIS ATT5TION TO ! $ITORIAL ON ,SECOND>Y ,FACTORS4 ,HE ?9KS ?AT MY ASS]TION ?AT ,GEORGE ASKS LABOR TO BEG9 ?IS WORLD ANEW \<T TO BE BACK$ BY SOME %[ ( >GUM5T4 ,GRACI\S HEAV5S6 ,I BACK$ IT AT ! BEG9N+ ( MY >TICLE BY A QUOTATION FROM ,GEORGE HIMSELF4 ,DISLODG$ BY HIS CRITICS FROM ONE PO9T AFT] ANO!R1 ,GEORGE HAD DECL>$ ?AT LABOR & L&1 EV5 9 ! ABS5CE ( SECOND>Y FACTORS OBTA9$ FROM !IR PRODUCE1 HAVE 9 !IR UNION TO-DAY1 AS !Y HAD 9 ! BEG9N+1 ! POT5TIALITY ( ALL ?AT MAN EV] HAS BR\<T1 OR EV] CAN BR+1 9TO BE+4 ,:5 SU* WORDS AS !SE >E US$ TO PROVE ?AT1 IF L& W]E FREE1 LABOR W\LD SETTLE ON IT1 EV5 )\T SECOND>Y FACTORS1--?AT IS1 )\T TOOLS1--:AT DO !Y MEAN EXCEPT ?AT ! LABOR] IS EXPECT$ TO BEG9 ! WORLD ANEW8 ,BUT IF ?IS IS NOT 5\< = ,MR4 ,CURTIS1 MAY ,I REF] HIM TO ! DEBATE BETWE5 ,GEORGE & ,%EWIT*1 9 :I* ! =M]1 BE+ ASK$ BY ! LATT] :AT W\LD HAVE BECOME ( ,FRIDAY IF ,CRUSOE HAD F5C$ (F HALF ! ISL& & TURN$ HIM LOOSE UPON IT )\T ANY TOOLS1 ANSW]$ ?AT ,FRIDAY W\LD HAVE MADE SOME FI%-HOOKS \T ( BONES1 & GONE FI%+8 ,ISN'T ?AT SUFFICI5TLY PRIMITIVE TO SUB/ANTIATE MY ASS]TION1 ,MR4 ,CURTIS8 ,TELL ,MR4 ,GEORGE ?AT ! LABOR] CAN DO NO?+ )\T CAPITAL1 & HE WILL ANSW] Y\ SUB/ANTIALLY AS FOLL[S3 ,ORIG9ALLY !RE WAS NO?+ BUT A NAK$ MAN & ! NAK$ L&2 FREE ! L&1 & !N1 IF ! LABOR] HAS NO TOOLS1 HE WILL AGA9 BE A NAK$ MAN ON NAK$ L& & CAN DO ALL ?AT ,ADAM DID4 ,:5 ,I PO9T \T ?AT SU* A RETURN TO B>B>ISM IS ON A P> ) ! REM$Y ATTRIBUT$ TO ! ,NIHILI/S1 ,MR4 ,CURTIS ASS]TS ?AT ?IS IS WILD TALK2 BUT HIS ASS]TION1 IT SEEMS TO ME1 \<T TO BE BACK$ BY SOME %[ ( >GUM5T47#a#f 8 #a#b7  

,HE IS SURE1 H[EV]1 ?AT !RE IS NO NE$ ( GO+ TO ! BACKWOODS4 ,!RE IS 5\< VACANT L& 9 ! NEI<BORHOOD ( CITIES1 HE ?9KS1 TO EMPLOY ! SURPLUS WORK]S1 & ?US RELIEVE ! LABOR M>KET4 ,BUT ?IS L& WILL NOT EMPLOY ANY WORK]S ?AT HAVE NO CAPITAL1 & ?OSE ?AT HAVE CAPITAL CAN GET ! L& N[4 ,?US ! OLD QUE/ION COMES BACK AGA94 ,MAKE CAPITAL FREE BY ORGANIZ+ CR$IT ON A MUTUAL PLAN1 & !N !SE VACANT L&S WILL COME 9TO USE1 & !N 9DU/RY WILL BE /IMULAT$1 & !N OP]ATIVES WILL BE ABLE TO BUY AXES & RAKES & HOES1 & !N !Y WILL BE 9DEP5D5T ( !IR EMPLOY]S1 & !N ! LABOR PROBLEM WILL BE SOLV$47#a#f 8 #a#c7  

,MY WOR/ (F5SE ,MR4 ,CURTIS RES]VES TILL ! LA/4 ,IT CONSI/S 9 TELL+ ! WORK+MAN ?AT HE W\LD BE A FOOL NOT TO PREF] ! /REET B&S1 ! %OP W9D[S1 ! !AT]S1 & ! *UR*ES TO A R5EWAL ( B>B>IC LIFE4 ,MR4 ,CURTIS AGA9 MISAPPREH5DS ME 9 ?9K+ ?AT ,I COMM5D ! B&S1 ! W9D[S1 ETC4 ,I SAID EXPLICITLY ?AT !RE IS NO?+ IDEAL AB\T !M4 ,BUT SOCIETY HAS COME TO BE MAN'S DE>E/ POSSESSION1 & ! ADVANTAGES & PRIVILEGES :I* ,I CIT$1 CRUDE & VULG> & BASE AS SOME ( !M >E1 REPRES5T SOCIETY TO ! OP]ATIVE4 ,HE WILL NOT GIVE !M UP1 & ,I ?9K HE IS WISE4 ,PURE AIR IS GOOD1 BUT NO ONE WANTS TO BREA! IT LONG ALONE4 ,9DEP5D5CE IS GOOD1 BUT ISOLATION IS TOO HEAVY A PRICE TO PAY = IT4 ,BO? PURE AIR & 9DEP5D5CE MU/ BE RECONCIL$ ) SOCIETY1 OR NOT MANY LABOR]S WILL EV] 5JOY !M4 ,LUCKILY !Y CAN BE & WILL BE1 ?\< NOT BY TAX+ L& VALUES4 ,AS = ! IDEA ?AT P]SONS CAN BE 9DUC$ TO BECOME B>B>IANS FROM ALTRUI/IC MOTIVES 9 SUFFICI5T NUMB]S TO AFFECT ! LABOR M>KET1 IT IS ONE ?AT ,I HAVE NO TIME TO DISCUSS4 ,9 ONE RESPECT AT LEA/ ,MR4 ,GEORGE IS PREF]ABLE TO ,MR4 ,CURTIS AS AN OPPON5T3 HE USUALLY DEALS 9 ECONOMIC >GUM5T RA!R ?AN S5TIM5TALISM47#a#f 8 #a#d7 

,FROM 3 FAIR-USE4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahif 3 ,P>T #c1 ,*APT] #h -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,FEBRU>Y #b#a1 #bag 3 ,P>T #c1 ,*APT] #h -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/