,P>T #c1 ,*APT] #ae ,! ,DI/RIBUTION ( ,R5T #ahigahig ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,B5JAM9 ,R4 ,TUCK] ,TEXT 3 ,! ,DI/RIBUTION ( ,R5T4 .<,LIB]TY1 ,FEBRU>Y #b#c1 #a#h#h#i4.> ,TO ! ,$ITOR ( ,LIB]TY37#a#a#c 8 #a7 ,BE=E REPLY+ TO Y\R REJO9D] REG>D+ L& VS4 SKILL1 ,I %\LD BE PLEAS$ TO KN[ :E!R 9 AN ,AN>*I/IC /ATE1 9 ! EV5T ( A TRANSGRESSION ( EQUAL LIB]TY1 ! 9JUR$ P>TY IS TO RES5T ! ACT ACCORD+ TO HIS JUDGM5T & CAPRICE1 OR IS REPRESSION TO BE EX]CIS$ BY AN ORGANIZ$ P[] ACCORD+ TO RULES DET]M9$ BY PREVI\S AGREEM5T8 ,9 ! ONE CASE ! UNAVOIDABLE DIFF]5CE ( OP9IONS MU/ BE A S\RCE ( 9T]M9ABLE DI/URBANCES2 9 ! O!R1 WE HAVE ! OP]ATION ( AN ORGANIZ$ SOCIETY ) LAWS & SUPREME P[]1--9 FACT A POLITICAL ,/ATE4 ,IF AN AGREEM5T EXI/S1 :O IS TO EXECUTE ITS PROVISIONS8 ,& IF SOME REFUSE TO ASSI/1 & %IRK SOCIAL DUTIES1 HAVE !Y ANY CLAIM TO ! ASSI/ANCE ( ! ORGANIZATION1 HAVE !Y ANY SOCIAL RI UND]/&+ ON !SE PO9TS1 WE MIGUE =EV] )\T AVAIL47#a#a#c 8 #b7 ,ASSUM+ ?AT EQUAL LIB]TY CAN BE ATTA9$ ONLY ?R\< SOME SOCIAL COMPACT1 ,I FAIL TO SEE A DI/9CTION BETWE5 ! MONOPOLY ( A GOLD-M9E & ?AT ( AN 9V5TION4 ,! EXCLUSIVE POSSESSION ( EI!R IS ! RESULT ( A SOCIAL COMPACT1 ALL P]SONS AGREE+ NOT TO EXPLOIT ! NATURAL DEPOSIT ( ! PRECI\S METAL1 OR TO MAKE USE ( ! DEVICE SUGGE/$ BY ! 9V5TOR4 ,! MONOPOLY ( A GOLD-M9E CAN1 !RE=E1 HAVE NO EXI/5CE EXCEPT BY MUTUAL AGREEM5T1 OR EV5TUALLY A =CIBLE PREV5TION ( ?OSE :O CLAIM EQUAL LIB]TY & ATTEMPT TO EXTRACT GOLD FROM ! SAME DEPOSIT4 ,9 LIKE MANN]1 EV]Y O!R PEACEABLE 5JOYM5T ( A NATURAL OR LOCAL ADVANTAGE IS A RESULT ( MUTUAL AGREEM5T1 SUPPORT$ BY ! P[] )\T :I* ! AGREEM5T W\LD BE A DEAD LETT]4 ,! OCCUPI] ( SUP]IOR L& OR LOCATION IS !RE=E 9DEBT$ TO SOCIETY = ! RIE WILL+ TO GIVE = ! SAME RIIABLY BE (F]$1 BY ! OCCUPI]S ( ! POORE/ L& YET NE$$1 = ! POSSESSION ( BETT] OR MORE FAVORABLY LOCAT$ L&4 ,%ALL LAW =BID SU* (F]S1 OR 9VALIDATE CONTRACTS MADE 9 COMPLIANCE !RE)1 9CID5TALLY SUPPRESS+ COMPETITION2 %ALL IT P]MIT C]TA9 9DIVIDUALS1 ! SO-CALL$ L&-[N]S1 TO APPROPRIATE ?IS R5T2 OR %ALL SOCIETY SO DI/RIBUTE IT ?AT NO CITIZ5 HAS ANY REASON TO COMPLA9 ( POLITICAL FAVORITISM8 ,IS !RE A F\R? POSSIBILITY1 & IF NOT1 :I* ( ! ?REE IS CONSI/5T ) ! LAW ( EQUAL FRE$OM8 ,:I* T5D TO E/ABLI% >TIFICIAL 9EQUALITIES8 ,I REIT]ATE MY CONVICTION ?AT A NATIONALIZATION ( R5T WILL BE AN 9EVITABLE RESULT ( ! E/ABLI%M5T ( EQUAL LIB]TY47#a#a#c 8 #f7 ,IF ,I W]E ! POSSESSOR ( L& ON :I* ! PRODUCTIVITY ( LABOR EXCE$S ?AT OBTA9ABLE ON L& HELD BY O!RS1 !Y W\LD BE WILL+ TO LEASE MY L& & PAY A R5T ( NE>LY ! EXCESS ( PRODUCTIVITY4 ,BUT S9CE UND] ! SY/EM ( OCCUPY+ L&-[N]%IP SU* A CONTRACT MU/ BE VOID1 ,I %ALL NEV] VACATE ! L&1 :ATEV] 9DUCEM5TS %\LD BE (F]$ ME2 =1 UPON LEAV+ IT1 ,I & MY DESC5DANTS W\LD =EV] RECEIVE = ! SAME EF=TS A LESS RETURN ?AN IF ,I HAD RETA9$ POSSESSION ( ! SAID L&4 ,IF = ANY REASON SOME VALUABLE L& %\LD BECOME VACANT1 ! NUMB] ( APPLICANTS W\LD NATURALLY BE V]Y L>GE4 ,EA* W\LD BE WILL+ TO GIVE V]Y NE>LY ! ANNUAL EXCESS ( PRODUCTIVITY AF=D$ BY ?IS L&1 9 HIS COMPETITIVE ATTEMPT TO \TBID O!RS4 ,:O %ALL BECOME ! FUTURE OCCUPI]8 ,%ALL APPO9TM5T DECIDE1 OR %ALL ! L& BE GIV5 TO ! HIRI$ ON 9 GR\PS1 AS IT N[ IS1 :O IS ! LEGAL OCCUPI] ( ! L&8 ,! EMPLOY]1 ! MANAG]1 OR ! 5SEMBLE ( ?OSE 5GAG$ 9 ! COOP]ATIVE WORK8 ,! LATT] APPE>+ ! ONLY RATIONAL ANSW]1 IT IS NATURAL ?AT ?OSE 9 POSSESSION ( ! LESS] OPPORTUNITIES WILL (F] !MSELVES TO ! FAVOR$ GR\PS = WAGES SLIE ( !IR COOP]ATION 7:I* IS ONLY ANO!R =M ( AN (F] ( R5T74 ,BUT AS SU* AN ACCESSION TO A GR\P W\LD DISPLACE SOME ( ?OSE PREVI\SLY EMPLOY$1 PU%+ !M UPON ! LESS FAVORABLE L&1 SU* COMPETITIVE APPLICATIONS WILL BE RESI/$ TO ! UTMO/1 & COMPETITION W\LD BE H>ASS$4 ,A DEVELOPM5T ( A CLASS DI/9CTION C\LD NOT BE AVOID$47#a#a#c 8 #g7 ,! RELATION ( SOCIAL AGREEM5T TO ! DI/RIBUTION ( ! PRODUCTS ( SKILL IS TOTALLY DIFF]5T4 ,AN ATTEMPT TO DI/RIBUTE BY LAW ! PRODUCTS ( LABOR WILL DISC\RAGE PRODUCTION1 DIM9I% HAPP9ESS1 & R$UCE ! P[] TO RESI/ ADV]SE 9FLU5CES1 5ABL+ ?OSE PEOPLE TO SURVIVE 9 ! /RUGGLE = EXI/5CE :O 5C\RAGE PRODUCTION BY PROTECT+ ! PRODUC] 9 ! PEACEABLE 5JOYM5T ( ! FRUITS ( HIS LABOR1 PROVID$ HE PAYS ! VALUE ( ?AT PROTECTION47#a#a#c 8 #h7 ,EGOI/4 ,I CANNOT EXCUSE ,EGOI/1 = SEV]AL YE>S A SUBSCRIB] = ,LIB]TY1 :5 HE REQUIRES ME TO ANSW] = ! ?\S&-&-FIR/ TIME ! QUE/IONS :I* HE PUTS TO ME 9 HIS OP5+ P>AGRAPH4 ,IT HAS BE5 /AT$ & RE/AT$ 9 !SE COLUMNS1 UNTIL ,I HAVE GR[N WE>Y ( ! REIT]ATION1 ?AT VOLUNT>Y ASSOCIATION = ! PURPOSE ( PREV5T+ TRANSGRESSION ( EQUAL LIB]TY WILL BE P]FECTLY 9 KEEP+ ) ,AN>*ISM1 & WILL PROBABLY EXI/ UND] ,AN>*ISM UNTIL IT CO/S MORE ?AN IT COMES TO2 ?AT ! PROVISIONS ( SU* ASSOCIATIONS WILL BE EXECUT$ BY SU* AG5TS AS IT MAY SELECT 9 ACCORDANCE ) SU* ME?ODS AS IT MAY PRESCRIBE1 PROVID$ SU* ME?ODS DO NOT !MSELVES 9VOLVE A TRANSGRESSION ( ! LIB]TY ( ! 9NOC5T2 ?AT SU* ASSOCIATION WILL RE/RA9 ONLY ! CRIM9AL 7MEAN+ BY CRIM9AL ! TRANSGRESSOR ( EQUAL LIB]TY72 ?AT NON-MEMB]%IP & NONSUPPORT ( IT IS NOT A CRIM9AL ACT2 BUT ?AT SU* A C\RSE NEV]!LESS DEPRIVES ! NONMEMB] ( ANY TITLE TO ! B5EFITS ( ! ASSOCIATION1 EXCEPT SU* AS COME TO HIM 9CID5TALLY & UNAVOIDABLY4 ,IT HAS ALSO BE5 REPEAT$LY AFFIRM$ ?AT1 9 PROPOS+ TO ABOLI% ! ,/ATE1 ! ,AN>*I/S EXPRESSLY EXCLUDE FROM !IR DEF9ITION ( ! ,/ATE SU* ASSOCIATIONS AS ?AT JU/ REF]R$ TO1 & ?AT :OEV] EXCLUDES FROM HIS DEF9ITION & *AMPION%IP ( ! ,/ATE EV]Y?+ EXCEPT SU* ASSOCIATIONS HAS NO QU>REL ) ! ,AN>*I/S BEYOND A V]BAL ONE4 ,I %\LD TRU/ ?AT ! UND]/&+ ON !SE PO9TS IS N[ CLE>1 W]E IT NOT ?AT EXP]I5CE HAS CONV9C$ ME ?AT MY COMM& ( ! ,5GLI% LANGUAGE IS NOT ADEQUATE TO ! CON/RUCTION ( A F\NDATION = SU* TRU/47#a#a#c 8 #i7 ,! FACT ?AT ,EGOI/ PO9TS \T A SIMIL>ITY BETWE5 ! MONOPOLY ( A GOLD-M9E & ?AT ( AN 9V5TION BY NO MEANS DE/ROYS ! DIFF]5CE BETWE5 !M :I* ,I PO9T$ \T1--?IS DIFF]5CE BE+ ?AT1 :]EAS 9 ! =M] CASE IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO PREV5T OR NULLIFY ! MONOPOLY )\T RE/RICT+ ! LIB]TY ( ! MONOPOLI/1 9 ! LATT] IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO SU/A9 IT )\T RE/RICT+ ! LIB]TY ( ! W\LD-BE COMPETITORS4 ,TO ! ,AN>*I/1 :O BELIEVES 9 ! M9IMUM ( RE/RICTION UPON LIB]TY1 ?IS DIFF]5CE IS A VITAL ONE1--QUITE SUFFICI5T TO W>RANT HIM 9 REFUS+ TO PREV5T ! ONE :ILE REFUS+ TO SU/A9 ! O!R47#a#a#c 8 #a7 ,EGOI/ SAYS ?AT AN OCCUPI] IS NOT A TRANSGRESSOR ( EQUAL LIB]TY UNLESS HE CLAIMS & RECEIVES ! RI*ISM HOLDS1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 9 ACCORDANCE ) ! PR9CIPLES /AT$ AT ! \TSET ( ?IS REJO9D]1 ?AT AN OCCUPI] IS NOT A TRANSGRESSOR EV5 IF1 NOT CLAIM+ IT OR PAY+ = IT1 HE DOES RECEIVE ?IS RILY DISCUSS$ 9 !SE COLUMNS )9 A FEW MON?S BY ,J4 ,WM4 ,LLOYD1 & AN EXTRACT 9 CONFIRMATION ( HIS POSITION HAS BE5 REPR9T$ FROM ,HUMBOLDT4 ,I REF] ,EGOI/ TO ?OSE >TICLES47#a#a#c 8 #a#a7 ,! ASS]TION ?AT ! DI/RIBUTION ( SKILL IS ABSOLUTELY 9DEP5D5T ( SOCIAL AGREEM5T IS ABSOLUTELY ]RONE\S4 ,9 PRO( ( ?IS ,I NE$ ONLY CALL ATT5TION TO ! APPR5TICE%IP REGULATIONS ( ! TRADE UNIONS & ! V>I\S $UCATIONAL SY/EMS ?AT >E OR HAVE BE5 9 VOGUE1 NOT ONLY AS EVID5CE ( :AT HAS ALREADY BE5 DONE 9 ! DIRECTION ( CONTROLL+ ! DI/RIBUTION ( SKILL1 BUT ALSO AS AN 9DICATION ( :AT MORE MAY BE DONE IF ,/ATE ,SOCIALISM EV] GETS A *ANCE TO TRY UPON HUMANITY ! 9T]E/+ EXP]IM5TS :I* IT PROPOSES4 ,ON ! O!R H&1 ! COLLECTION ( R5T BY ! COLLECTIVITY DOES NOT NECESS>ILY AFFECT ! DI/RIBUTION ( L&4 ,L& TITLES WILL REMA9 UN*ANG$ AS LONG AS ! TAX 7OR R5T7 %ALL BE PAID4 ,BUT IT DOES DI/RIBUTE ! PRODUCTS RESULT+ FROM DIFF]5CES ( L&1 & IT IS LIKEWISE POSSIBLE TO DI/RIBUTE ! PRODUCTS RESULT+ FROM DIFF]5CES ( SKILL4 ,N[ UNTIL ?IS POSITION IS OV]?R[N 7& ,I DEFY ANY ONE TO SUCCESSFULLY DISPUTE IT71 IT IS S5SELESS TO LIK5 DISSATISFACTION ) ! DI/RIBUTION ( SKILL TO ! CRY+ ( A *ILD BECAUSE IT CANNOT FLY4 ,! ABSURDITY ( HIS ANALOGY1 9 :I* ! POSSIBILITY ( DI/RIBUT+ PRODUCTS IS IGNOR$1 W\LD HAVE BE5 APP>5T IF IT HAD BE5 IMM$IATELY FOLL[$ BY ! ADMISSION ( ?IS POSSIBILITY :I* ,EGOI/ PLACES SEV]AL P>AGRAPHS FUR!R D[N4 ,TO BE SURE1 HE DECL>ES EV5 !RE ?AT IT IS IMPOSSIBLE1 BUT ONLY 9 ! S5SE 9 :I* ,PR\DHON DECL>ES 9T]E/-BE>+ IMPOSSIBLE1--?AT ( PRODUC+ ANTI-SOCIAL RESULTS :I* EV5TUALLY KILL IT OR COMPEL ITS AB&ONM5T4 ,I CONT5D ?AT SIMIL>LY ANTI-SOCIAL RESULTS WILL FOLL[ ANY ATTEMPT TO DI/RIBUTE BY LAW ! PRODUCTS >IS+ FROM DIFF]5CES ( L&2 & ,I ASK1 AS ,I HAVE ASK$ BE=E )\T OBTA9+ AN ANSW]1 :Y ! COLLECTIVITY1 IF 9 ITS RID TO ! ATTITUDE ( ,AN>*I/IC ASSOCIATIONS T[>DS R5T & ITS COLLECTION1 ,I W\LD SAY ?AT !Y MITIFICIAL 9EQUALITY2 & ?AT ! WOR/ ( ALL 9EQUALITIES1--! 9EQUALITY ( LIB]TY1 OR P]HAPS IT W\LD BE MORE ACCURATE TO CALL IT ! EQUALITY ( SLAV]Y4 ,! FIR/ OR SECOND W\LD AT ! WOR/ FAIL TO 5TIRELY ABOLI% NATURAL 9EQUALITIES47#a#a#c 8 #a#c7 ,! POSSIBILITY ( VALUABLE L& BECOM+ VACANT IS H>DLY WOR? CONSID]ATION4 ,/ILL1 IF ANY OCCUPANT ( VALUABLE L& %\LD BE FOOLI% 5\< TO QUIT IT )\T FIR/ SELL+ IT1 ! E/ATE W\LD BE LIABLE TO SEIZURE BY ! FIR/ COM]1 :O W\LD IMM$IATELY HAVE A FOOT+ SIMIL> TO ?AT ( O!R L&-HOLD]S4 ,IF ?IS BE FAVORITISM1 ,I CAN ONLY SAY ?AT ! WORLD IS NOT DE/9$ TO SEE ! TIME :5 SOME ?+S WILL NOT GO BY FAVOR47#a#a#c 8 #a#d7 ,EGOI/'S >GUM5T ?AT FREE COMPETITION WILL T5D TO DI/RIBUTE R5T BY A READJU/M5T ( WAGES IS EXACTLY TO MY PURPOSE4 ,HAVE ,I NOT TOLD HIM FROM ! />T ?AT ,AN>*I/S WILL GLADLY WELCOME ANY T5D5CY TO EQUALITY ?R\< LIB]TY8 ,BUT ,EGOI/ SEEMS TO OBJECT TO REA*+ EQUALITY BY ?IS ROAD4 ,IT MU/ BE REA*$ BY LAW OR NOT AT ALL4 ,IF REA*$ BY COMPETITION1 COMPETITION W\LD BE H>ASS$4 ,9 O!R WORDS1 COMPETITION W\LD H>ASS COMPETITION4 ,?IS WE>S ! ASPECT ( ANO!R ABSURDITY4 ,IT IS V]Y LIKELY ?AT COMPETITORS W\LD H>ASS COMPETITORS1 BUT COMPETITION )\T H>ASS$ COMPETITORS IS SC>CELY ?9KABLE4 ,IT IS EV5 NOT IMPROBABLE ?AT CLASS DI/9CTIONS W\LD BE DEVELOP$1 AS ,EGOI/ SAYS4 ,WORK]S W\LD F9D ! PLACES :I* !IR CAPACITIES1 CONDITIONS1 & 9CL9ATIONS QUALIFY !M TO FILL1 & W\LD ?US BE CLASSIFI$1 OR DIVID$ 9TO DI/9CT CLASSES4 ,DOES ,EGOI/ ?9K ?AT 9 SU* AN EV5T LIFE W\LD NOT BE WOR? LIV+8 ,( C\RSE ! WORDS H>ASS & CLASS DI/9CTION HAVE AN UGLY S\ND1 & COMPETITION IS DECID$LY MORE ATTRACTIVE :5 ASSOCIAT$ 9/EAD ) EXCEL & ORGANIZATION4 ,BUT ,AN>*I/S NEV] RECOIL FROM DISAGREEABLE T]MS4 ,ONLY !IR OPPON5TS >E TO BE FRIT #c1 ,*APT] #ae -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,FEBRU>Y #b#a1 #bag 3 ,P>T #c1 ,*APT] #ae -- ,ADD$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/