,P>T #e1 ,*APT] #c 
,/ILL ,AVOID+ ! ,ISSUE 

#ahigahig 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,B5JAM9 ,R4 ,TUCK] 

,TEXT 3 

,/ILL ,AVOID+ ! ,ISSUE 

.<,LIB]TY1 ,MAY #a#b1 #a#h#h#h4.> 

,AS ,I EXPECT$1 ,H]R ,MO/1 9 HIS CONTROV]SY ) ME UPON PRIVATE PROP]TY1 ,COMMUNISM1 & ! ,/ATE1 IS AS RELUCTANT AS EV] TO COME TO CLOSE QU>T]S 9 ANY ATTEMPT TO DE/ROY MY MA9 POSITION1 &1 = SOLE RESPONSE TO MY *ALL5GE TO DO SO1 CR\*ES BEH9D ! NAME ( ,M>X1 NOT D>+ EV5 TO ATTEMPT UPON HIS [N ACC\NT ! USE ( ! WEAPONS ) :I* ,M>X HAS ASSAIL$ IT4 ,H]R ,MO/ HAD PROMIS$ TO ACCEPT PRIVATE PROP]TY IF ,I W\LD %[ HIM ?AT IT IS COMPATIBLE ) PRODUCTION ON ! L>GE SCALE )\T ! EXPLOITATION ( LABOR4 ,HE W>N$ ME1 TO BE SURE1 AGA9/ %[+ ?IS BY ,PR\DHON'S BANK+ SY/EM4 ,BUT ,I ANSW]$ ?AT HE IS B\ND TO ACCEPT MY PROPOSITION ON ! /R5G? ( :ATEV] PRO( ,I (F]1 OR ELSE DEMON/RATE ?AT ! PRO( (F]$ IS NO PRO( AT ALL1--9 O!R WORDS1 ?AT HE CANNOT REJECT MY EVID5CE )\T FIR/ REFUT+ IT4 ,MY PRO(1 ,I !N TOLD HIM1 CONSI/S PRECISELY 9 ?AT PR9CIPLE ( FRE$OM & ORGANIZATION ( CR$IT :I* IS EMBODI$ 9 ,PR\DHON'S BANK+ SY/EM & O!R SY/EMS ( A SIMIL> NATURE1 & ,I REF]R$ HIM TO A REC5T ESSAY 9 :I* ,I HAVE EXPLA9$ ! PROCESS :]EBY FREELY ORGANIZ$ CR$IT W\LD ABOLI% USURY--?AT IS1 ! EXPLOITATION ( LABOR--& MAKE PRODUCTION ON ! L>GE SCALE EASI] ?AN EV] )\T 9T]F]+ ) ! 9/ITUTION ( PRIVATE PROP]TY47#a#b#i 8 #a7  

,N[ IT W\LD NATURALLY BE ASSUM$ ?AT1 9 ANSW] TO ?IS1 SOME EXAM9ATION W\LD BE MADE ( ! PROCESS REF]R$ TO & ! FLAW 9 IT TO BE PO9T$ \T4 ,BUT DID ,H]R ,MO/ DO ANY?+ ( ! K9D8 ,NOT HE4 ,HIS ONLY ANSW] IS ?AT ,M>X DISPOS$ ( ,PR\DHON'S BANK+ SY/EM LONG AGO1 ?AT IT IS FIFTY YE>S BEH9D ! TIMES1 & ?AT IT IS NOT AT ALL CLE> ?AT !RE IS ANY F\NDATION = ! CLAIM ?AT1 ) ! PREVAIL+ 9EQUALITIES ( PROP]TY1 ALL C\LD OBTA9 CR$IT4 ,NO1 ,H]R ,MO/1 NOR IS IT CLE> ?AT ANY SU* CLAIM WAS EV] MADE BY ANY SANE *AMPION ( ! ORGANIZATION ( CR$IT4 ,! REAL CLAIM IS1 NOT ?AT ALL C\LD /RAI<TWAY GET CR$IT IF CR$IT W]E NOT MONOPOLIZ$1 BUT ?AT1 IF ALL OR HALF OR A QU>T] ( SU* CR$IT AS C\LD BE AT ONCE OBTA9$ UND] A FREE SY/EM %\LD BE UTILIZ$1 A TREM5D\S IMPETUS W\LD !REBY BE GIV5 TO PRODUCTION & 5T]PRISE :I* W\LD GRADUALLY 9CREASE ! DEM& = LABOR & !RE=E ! RATE ( WAGES & !RE=E ! NUMB] ( PEOPLE ABLE TO GET CR$IT1 UNTIL AT LA/ EV]Y LABOR] W\LD BE ABLE TO SAY TO HIS EMPLOY]1 ,H]E1 BOSS1 Y\ >E A GOOD BUS9ESS MANAG]1 & ,I AM WILL+ TO CONT9UE TO WORK UND] Y\R SUP]9T5D5CE ON A /RICTLY EQUITABLE BASIS2 BUT1 UNLESS Y\ >E WILL+ TO CONT5T Y\RSELF ) A %>E ( \R JO9T PRODUCT PROPORTIONAL TO Y\R %>E ( ! LABOR & GIVE ME ! BALANCE = MY %>E ( ! LABOR1 ,I WILL WORK = Y\ NO LONG]1 BUT WILL SET UP 9 BUS9ESS = MYSELF ON ! CAPITAL :I* ,I CAN N[ OBTA9 ON MY CR$IT4 ,H]R ,MO/'S MIS/ATEM5T ( ! CLAIM MADE BY ! FRI5DS ( FREE BANK+ %[S ?AT HE HAS NO KN[L$GE ( !IR >GUM5TS OR SY/EM1 :I* PROBABLY EXPLA9S HIS RELUCTANCE TO DISCUSS !M O!RWISE ?AN BY REIT]ATION ( ! MAGIC NAME ( ,M>X4 ,PR\DHON'S BANK+ SY/EM MAY BE FIFTY YE>S BEH9D ! TIMES1 BUT IT IS EVID5TLY F> 9 ADVANCE ( ! PO9T :I* ,H]R ,MO/ HAS REA*$ 9 ! PA? ( ECONOMIC 9VE/IGATION47#a#b#i 8 #b7  

,EV5 MORE C>EFUL IS ! W>Y $ITOR ( ,FREIHEIT TO AVOID ! FOLL[+ QUE/ION1 :I* ,I ASK$ HIM A PROPOS ( HIS PROMISE3 ,IF ,COMMUNISM IS REALLY1 AS ,H]R ,MO/ G5]ALLY CLAIMS1 NO 9FR+EM5T ( LIB]TY1 & IF 9 ITSELF IT IS SU* A GOOD & P]FECT ?+1 :Y AB&ON IT = PRIVATE PROP]TY SIMPLY BECAUSE ! POSSIBILITY ( ! LATT]'S EXI/5CE )\T ! EXPLOITATION ( LABOR HAS BE5 DEMON/RAT$8 ,TO DECL>E ONE'S WILL+NESS TO DO SO IS PLA9LY TO AFFIRM ?AT1 EXPLOITATION ASIDE1 PRIVATE PROP]TY IS SUP]IOR TO ,COMMUNISM1 & ?AT1 EXPLOITATION ADMITT$1 ,COMMUNISM IS *OS5 ONLY AS ! LESS] EVIL4 ,H]R ,MO/ KNEW ?AT IT W\LD NEV] DO TO ADMIT ?AT ,COMMUNISM CURTAILS LIB]TY4 ,YET HE C\LD NOT ANSW] ?IS QUE/ION )\T ADMITT+ IT4 ,SO HE PRUD5TLY LET IT ALONE47#a#b#i 8 #c7  

,BUT :AT1 !N1 DOES HE SAY 9 HIS ?REE-COLUMN >TICLE87#a#b#i 8 #d7  

,WELL1 = ONE ?+1 HE TRIES TO MAKE HIS READ]S ?9K ?AT ,I (F]$ MY 9CID5TAL REM>KS1 RA!R SUGGE/IVE ?AN CONCLUSIVE1 REG>D+ ! LIKELIHOOD ?AT ! ,COMMUNI/S' POSITION1 BE+ BAS$ ON A SUPPOS$ NECESSITY ( GREAT COMB9ATIONS 9 ORD] TO PRODUCE ON ! L>GE SCALE1 MI<T SOON BE UND]M9$ BY ! T5D5CY1 ( :I* SYMPTOMS >E BEG9N+ TO APPE>1 T[>DS ! SIMPLIFICATION & *EAP5+ ( MA*9]Y1--HE TRIES TO MAKE HIS READ]S ?9K1 ,I SAY1 ?AT ,I (F]$ !SE REM>KS AS A NECESS>Y L9K 9 MY >GUM5T4 ,ON SU* GR\NDS1 HE SAYS1 WE >E EXPECT$ TO BELIEVE1 ETC41 GIV+ NO H9T ( MY EXPRESS DECL>ATION ?AT ,I (F]$ ?IS IDEA = :AT IT WAS WOR? & NOT AS ESS5TIAL TO MY POSITION47#a#b#i 8 #e7  

,NEV]!LESS IT IS NOT EASY TO SEE :Y HE %\LD REG>D ?IS ?\<T AS SO UTT]LY *IM]ICAL1 :5 HE F9DS IT SO EASY1 9 ORD] TO %[ ,COMMUNISM TO BE PRACTICABLE1 TO ASSUME ?AT ! TIME IS NOT F> DI/ANT :5 WEAL? WILL BE SO ABUNDANT ?AT 9DIVIDUALS WILL NOT ?9K ( QU>REL+ OV] ITS POSSESSION1 BUT WILL LIVE AS BIRDS DO 9 !IR HEMP-SE$4 ,( ! TWO HYPO!SES ! LATT] SEEMS TO ME ! MORE VISION>Y4 ,C]TA9LY GREAT /RIDES >E YET TO BE TAK5 9 LABOR-SAV+1 & ,I DO NOT D\BT AT ALL ?AT A /ATE ( SOCIETY WILL BE ATTA9$ 9 :I* EV]Y S\ND 9DIVIDUAL WILL BE ABLE TO SECURE A COM=TABLE EXI/5CE BY A V]Y FEW H\RS ( TOIL DAILY4 ,BUT ?AT !RE WILL EV] BE ANY SU* PROPORTION BETWE5 HUMAN LABOR & ! OBJECTS ( HUMAN CONSUMPTION AS N[ EXI/S BETWE5 BIRD LABOR & HEMP-SE$1 OR ?AT L& & O!R CAPITAL WILL EV] BE SUP]ABUNDANT1 IS 9ADMISSIBLE4 ,IF1 H[EV]1 ! MEANS ( LIFE %ALL EV] BECOME SO UTT]LY DIVORC$ FROM HUMAN TOIL ?AT ALL M5 LOOK ON ALL WEAL? AS AIR IS N[ LOOK$ UPON1 ,I WILL !N ADMIT ?AT1 SO F> AS MAT]IAL 5JOYM5T IS CONC]N$1 ,COMMUNISM WILL BE PRACTICABLE 7,I DO NOT SAY ADVISABLE7 )\T VIOLATION ( LIB]TY4 ,UNTIL !N1 ,I MU/ 9SI/ ?AT A ,/ATE WILL BE NECESS>Y TO ITS REALIZATION & MA9T5ANCE47#a#b#i 8 #f7  

,BUT ,H]R ,MO/ ASKS ME1 IF RESPECT = PRIVATE PROP]TY IS CONCEIVABLE )\T A ,/ATE1 :Y IS NOT ,COMMUNISM SO CONCEIVABLE8 ,SIMPLY BECAUSE ! ONLY =CE EV] NECESS>Y TO SECURE RESPECT = PRIVATE PROP]TY IS ! =CE ( DEF5SE1--! =CE :I* PROTECTS ! LABOR] 9 ! POSSESSION ( HIS PRODUCT OR 9 ! FREE EX*ANGE !RE(1--:ILE ! =CE REQUIR$ TO SECURE ,COMMUNISM IS ! =CE ( (F5SE1--! =CE :I* COMPELS ! LABOR] TO POOL HIS PRODUCT ) ! PRODUCTS ( ALL & =BIDS HIM TO SELL HIS LABOR OR HIS PRODUCT4 ,N[1 =CE ( (F5SE IS ! PR9CIPLE ( ! ,/ATE1 :ILE =CE ( DEF5SE IS ONE ASPECT ( ! PR9CIPLE ( LIB]TY4 ,?IS IS ! REASON :Y PRIVATE PROP]TY DOES NOT IMPLY A ,/ATE1 :ILE ,COMMUNISM DOES4 ,H]R ,MO/ SEEMS TO BE AS IGNORANT ( ! REAL NATURE ( ! ,/ATE AS HE IS ( ,PR\DHON'S BANK+ SY/EM4 ,9 OPPOS+ IT HE ACTS1 NOT AS AN 9TELLIG5T FOE ( ,AU?ORITY1 BUT SIMPLY AS A REBEL AGA9/ ! P[]S ?AT BE47#a#b#i 8 #g7  

,:AT IS ! USE1 9 FACT1 ( DISCUSS+ ) HIM AT ALL8 ,DOES HE NOT CONFESS AT ! V]Y \TSET ( ! >TICLE ,I AM N[ EXAM9+ ?AT1 AL?\< HE HAS RACK$ HIS BRA9S1 !Y REFUSE TO P]CEIVE MY DI/9CTION BETWE5 ! LABOR]'S 9DIVIDUAL POSSESSION ( HIS PRODUCT & ! SUM TOTAL ( LEGAL PRIVILEGES BE/[$ UPON ! HOLD]S ( WEAL?8 ,IS !RE ANY HOPE ?AT SU* A M9D WILL EV] GRASP AN ECONOMIC LAW8 ,! REASON HE GIVES = HIS 9ABILITY TO RECOGNIZE ?IS DI/9CTION IS HIS CONVICTION ?AT PRIVATE POSSESSION & PRIVILEGE >E 9SEP>ABLE4 ,! MORE ONE CALLS HIS [N1 HE SAYS1 ! LESS O!RS WILL BE ABLE TO POSSESS4 ,?IS IS NOT TRUE :]E ALL PROP]TY RE/S ON A LABOR TITLE1 & NO O!R PROP]TY DO ,I FAVOR4 ,IT IS ONLY TRUE ( ! 9CREASE ( PROP]TY ?R\< USURY4 ,BUT USURY1 AS HAS ALREADY BE5 %[N1 RE/S ON PRIVILEGE4 ,:5 ! PROP]TY ( ONE 9CREASES ?R\< AN ADVANCE 9 ! PRODUCTIVITY ( HIS LABOR1 ! PROP]TY ( O!RS1 F> FROM DECREAS+ ON ?AT ACC\NT1 9CREASES TO AN ALMO/ EQUAL EXT5T4 ,?IS YE> ,A PRODUCES #a 9 HATS & ,B #a 9 %OES4 ,EA* CONSUMES #e 9 HIS [N PRODUCT1 & EX*ANGES ! REMA9+ #e = ! O!R'S REMA9+ #e4 ,SUPPOSE ?AT NEXT YE> ,A'S PRODUCTION REMA9S ! SAME1 BUT ?AT ,B'S1 ) NO EXTRA LABOR1 RISES TO #b4 ,9 ?AT CASE ,A'S REMA9+ #e1 9/EAD ( EX*ANG+ = ,B'S REMA9+ #e AS ?IS YE>1 WILL EX*ANGE = #a 9 ,B'S PRODUCT4 ,UND] PRIVATE POSSESSION1 UNACCOMPANI$ BY USURY1 MORE = ONE MAN MEANS1 NOT LESS = ANO!R MAN1 BUT MORE = ALL M54 ,:]E1 !N1 IS ! PRIVILEGE87#a#b#i 8 #h7  

,BUT1 AFT] ALL1 IT MAKES V]Y LITTLE DIFF]5CE TO ,H]R ,MO/ :AT A MAN BELIEVES 9 ECONOMICS4 ,! TE/ ( FELL[%IP ) HIM LIES 9 ACCEPTANCE ( DYNAMITE AS A CURE-ALL4 ,?\< ,I %\LD PROVE ?AT MY ECONOMIC VIEWS1 IF REALIZ$1 W\LD TURN \R SOCIAL SY/EM 9SIDE \T1 HE W\LD NOT !RE=E REG>D ME AS A REVOLUTIONI/4 ,HE DECL>ES \TRI<T ?AT ,I AM NO REVOLUTIONI/1 BECAUSE ! ?\<T ( ! COM+ REVOLUTION 7BY DYNAMITE1 HE MEANS7 MAKES MY FLE% CREEP4 ,WELL1 ,I FRANKLY CONFESS ?AT ,I TAKE NO PLEASURE 9 ! ?\<T ( BLOOD%$ & MUTILATION & DEA?4 ,AT !SE ?+S MY FEEL+S REVOLT4 ,& IF DELI<T 9 !M IS A REQUISITE ( A REVOLUTIONI/1 !N 9DE$ ,I AM NO REVOLUTIONI/4 ,:5 REVOLUTIONI/ & CANNIBAL BECOME SYNONYMS1 C\NT ME \T1 IF Y\ PLEASE4 ,BUT1 ?\< MY FEEL+S REVOLT1 ,I AM NOT MA/]$ BY !M OR MADE A C[>D BY !M4 ,MORE ?AN FROM DYNAMITE & BLOOD DO ,I %R9K FROM ! ?\<T ( A P]MAN5T SY/EM ( SOCIETY 9VOLV+ ! SL[ />VATION ( ! MO/ 9DU/RI\S & DES]V+ ( ITS MEMB]S4 ,IF ,I %\LD EV] BECOME CONV9C$ ?AT ! POLICY ( BLOOD%$ IS NECESS>Y TO 5D \R SOCIAL SY/EM1 ! L\DE/ ( TO-DAY'S %RIEK]S = BLOOD W\LD NOT SURPASS ME 9 ! /OICISM ) :I* ,I W\LD FACE ! 9EVITABLE4 ,9DE$1 A PLUMB-L9] TO ! LA/1 ,I AM CONFID5T ?AT UND] SU* CIRCUM/ANCES MANY :O N[ ?9K ME *ICK5-HE>T$ W\LD CONDEMN ! /ONY-HE>T$NESS ) :I* ,I %\LD FAVOR ! UTT] SACRIFICE ( EV]Y FEEL+ ( PITY TO ! NECESSITIES ( ! T]RORI/IC POLICY4 ,NEI!R FE> NOR S5TIM5TALISM1 !N1 DICTATES MY OPPOSITION TO =CIBLE ME?ODS4 ,SU* BE+ ! CASE1 H[ /UPID1 H[ UNFAIR1 9 ,H]R ,MO/1 TO PICTURE ME AS CROSS+ MYSELF AT ! M5TION ( ! WORD REVOLUTION SIMPLY BECAUSE ,I /EADFA/LY ACT ON MY WELL-KN[N BELIEF ?AT =CE CANNOT SUB/ITUTE TRU? = A LIE 9 POLITICAL ECONOMY67#a#b#i 8 #i7 

,FROM 3 FAIR-USE4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahif 3 ,P>T #e1 ,*APT] #c -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,FEBRU>Y #b#a1 #bag 3 ,P>T #e1 ,*APT] #c -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/