,LANGUAGE3 ,ORIG9 & ,MEAN+ ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,JOHN ,Z]ZAN ,TEXT 3 ,FAIRLY REC5T AN?ROPOLOGY 7E4G4 ,SAHL9S1 ,R4,B4 ,LEE7 HAS VIRTUALLY OBLIT]AT$ ! LONG-DOM9ANT CONCEPTION :I* DEF9$ PREHI/ORIC HUMANITY 9 T]MS ( SC>CITY & BRUTALIZATION4 ,AS IF ! IMPLICATIONS ( ?IS >E ALREADY BECOM+ WIDELY UND]/OOD1 !RE SEEMS TO BE A GR[+ S5SE ( ?AT VA/ EPO* AS ONE ( :OL5ESS & GRACE4 ,\R TIME ON E>?1 *>ACT]IZ$ BY ! V]Y OPPOSITE ( ?OSE QUALITIES1 IS 9 ! DEEPE/ NE$ ( A REV]SAL ( ! DIALECTIC ?AT /RIPP$ ?AT :OL5ESS FROM \R LIFE AS A SPECIES4 ,BE+ ALIVE 9 NATURE1 BE=E \R AB/RACTION FROM IT1 MU/ HAVE 9VOLV$ A P]CEPTION & CONTACT ?AT WE CAN SC>CELY COMPREH5D FROM \R LEVELS ( ANGUI% & ALI5ATION4 ,! COMMUNICATION ) ALL ( EXI/5CE MU/ HAVE BE5 AN EXQUISITE PLAY ( ALL ! S5SES1 REFLECT+ ! NUMB]LESS1 NAMELESS V>IETIES ( PLEASURE & EMOTION ONCE ACCESSIBLE )9 US4 ,TO ,LEVY-,BRUHL1 ,DURKHEIM & O!RS1 ! C>D9AL & QUALITATIVE DIFF]5CE BETWE5 ! 0PRIMITIVE M9D0 & \RS IS ! PRIMITIVE'S LACK ( DETA*M5T 9 ! MOM5T ( EXP]I5CE2 0! SAVAGE M9D TOTALIZES10 AS ,LEVI-,/RAUSS PUT IT4 ,( C\RSE WE HAVE LONG BE5 9/RUCT$ ?AT ?IS ORIG9AL UNITY WAS DE/9$ TO CRUMBLE1 ?AT ALI5ATION IS ! PROV9CE ( BE+ HUMAN3 CONSCI\SNESS DEP5DS ON IT4 ,9 MU* ! SAME S5SE ?AT OBJECTIFI$ TIME HAS BE5 HELD TO BE ESS5TIAL TO CONSCI\SNESS--,HEGEL CALL$ IT 0! NECESS>Y ALI5ATION0--SO HAS LANGUAGE1 & EQUALLY FALSELY4 ,LANGUAGE MAY BE PROP]LY CONSID]$ ! FUNDAM5TAL IDEOLOGY1 P]HAPS AS DEEP A SEP>ATION FROM ! NATURAL WORLD AS SELF-EXI/5T TIME4 ,& IF TIMELESSNESS RESOLVES ! SPLIT BETWE5 SPONTANEITY & CONSCI\SNESS1 LANGUAGELESSNESS MAY BE EQUALLY NECESS>Y4 ,ADORNO1 9 ,M9IMA ,MORALIA1 WROTE3 0,TO HAPP9ESS ! SAME APPLIES AS TO TRU?3 ONE DOES NOT HAVE IT1 BUT IS 9 IT40 ,?IS C\LD /& AS AN EXCELL5T DESCRIPTION ( HUMANK9D AS WE EXI/$ BE=E ! EM]G5CE ( TIME & LANGUAGE1 BE=E ! DIVISION & DI/ANC+ ?AT EXHAU/$ AU!NTICITY4 ,LANGUAGE IS ! SUBJECT ( ?IS EXPLORATION1 UND]/OOD 9 ITS VIRUL5T S5SE4 ,A FRAGM5T FROM ,NIETZS*E 9TRODUCES ITS C5TRAL P]SPECTIVE3 0WORDS DILUTE & BRUTALIZE2 WORDS DEP]SONALIZE2 WORDS MAKE ! UNCOMMON COMMON40 ,AL?\< LANGUAGE CAN /ILL BE DESCRIB$ BY S*OL>S 9 SU* PHRASES AS 0! MO/ SIGNIFICANT & COLOSSAL WORK ?AT ! HUMAN SPIRIT HAS EVOLV$10 ?IS *>ACT]IZATION OCCURS N[ 9 A CONTEXT ( EXTREMITY 9 :I* WE >E =C$ TO CALL ! AGGREGATE ( ! WORK ( ! 0HUMAN SPIRIT0 9TO QUE/ION4 ,SIMIL>LY1 IF 9 ,C[>D & ,ELLIS' E/IMATION1 ! MO/ 0SIGNIFICANT FEATURE ( TW5TIE?-C5TURY 9TELLECTUAL DEVELOPM5T0 HAS BE5 ! LILI] WRIT]S C\LD DEF9E CONSCI\SNESS 9 A FACILE WAY AS ?AT :I* CAN BE V]BALIZ$1 OR EV5 >GUE ?AT WORDLESS ?\ACT] ( LANGUAGE RA!R ?AN ASSUME IT TO BE M]ELY A NEUTRAL1 IF NOT B5IGN1 9EVITABLE PRES5CE4 ,! PHILOSOPH]S >E N[ =C$ TO RECOGNIZE ! QUE/ION ) 9T5SIFI$ 9T]E/2 ,GADAM]1 = EXAMPLE3 0,ADMITT$LY1 ! NATURE ( LANGUAGE IS ONE ( ! MO/ MY/]I\S QUE/IONS ?AT EXI/S = MAN TO POND] ON40 ,IDEOLOGY1 ALI5ATION'S >MOR$ WAY ( SEE+1 IS A DOM9ATION EMB$D$ 9 SY/EMATIC FALSE CONSCI\SNESS4 ,IT IS EASI] /ILL TO BEG9 TO LOCATE LANGUAGE 9 !SE T]MS IF ONE TAKES UP ANO!R DEF9ITION COMMON TO BO? IDEOLOGY & LANGUAGE3 NAMELY1 ?AT EA* IS A SY/EM ( DI/ORT$ COMMUNICATION BETWE5 TWO POLES & PR$ICAT$ UPON SYMBOLIZATION4 ,LIKE IDEOLOGY1 LANGUAGE CREATES FALSE SEP>ATIONS & OBJECTIFICATIONS ?R\< ITS SYMBOLIZ+ P[]4 ,?IS FALSIFICATION IS MADE POSSIBLE BY CONCEAL+1 & ULTIMATELY VITIAT+1 ! P>TICIPATION ( ! SUBJECT 9 ! PHYSICAL WORLD4 ,MOD]N LANGUAGES1 = EXAMPLE1 EMPLOY ! WORD 0M9D0 TO DESCRIBE A ?+ DWELL+ 9DEP5D5TLY 9 \R BODIES1 AS COMP>$ ) ! ,SANSKRIT WORD1 :I* MEANS 0WORK+ )910 9VOLV+ AN ACTIVE EMBRACE ( S5SATION1 P]CEPTION1 & COGNITION4 ,! LOGIC ( IDEOLOGY1 FROM ACTIVE TO PASSIVE1 FROM UNITY TO SEP>ATION1 IS SIMIL>LY REFLECT$ 9 ! DECAY ( ! V]B =M 9 G5]AL4 ,IT IS NOTEWOR?Y ?AT ! MU* FRE] & S5SU\S HUNT]-GA!R] CULTURES GAVE WAY TO ! ,NEOLI?IC IMPOSITION ( CIVILIZATION1 WORK & PROP]TY AT ! SAME TIME ?AT V]BS DECL9$ TO APPROXIMATELY HALF ( ALL WORDS ( A LANGUAGE2 9 MOD]N ,5GLI%1 V]BS ACC\NT = LESS ?AN #a.0 ( WORDS4 ,?\< LANGUAGE1 9 ITS DEF9ITIVE FEATURES1 SEEMS TO BE COMPLETE FROM ITS 9CEPTION1 ITS PROGRESS IS M>K$ BY A /EADILY DEBAS+ PROCESS4 ,! C>V+ UP ( NATURE1 ITS R$UCTION 9TO CONCEPTS & EQUIVAL5CES1 OCCURS ALONG L9ES LAID D[N BY ! PATT]NS ( LANGUAGE4 ,& ! MORE ! MA*9]Y ( LANGUAGE1 AGA9 P>ALLEL+ IDEOLOGY1 SUBJECTS EXI/5CE TO ITSELF1 ! MORE BL9D ITS ROLE 9 REPRODUC+ A SOCIETY ( SUBJUGATION4 ,NAVAJO HAS BE5 T]M$ AN 0EXCESSIVELY LIT]AL0 LANGUAGE1 FROM ! *>ACT]I/IC BIAS ( \R TIME = ! MORE G5]AL & AB/RACT4 ,9 A MU* E>LI] TIME1 WE >E REM9D$1 ! DIRECT & CONCRETE HELD SWAY2 !RE EXI/$ A 0PLE?ORA ( T]MS = ! T\*$ & SE540 7,MELL]% #a#i#f7 ,TOYNBEE NOT$ ! 0AMAZ+ WEAL? ( 9FLECTIONS0 9 E>LY LANGUAGES & ! LAT] T5D5CY T[>D SIMPLIFICATION ( LANGUAGE ?R\< ! AB&ONM5T ( 9FLECTIONS4 ,CASSIR] SAW ! 0A/\ND+ V>IETY ( T]MS = A P>TICUL> ACTION0 AMONG ,AM]ICAN ,9DIAN TRIBES & UND]/OOD ?AT SU* T]MS BE> TO EA* O!R A RELATION ( JUXTAPOSITION RA!R ?AN ( SUBORD9ATION4 ,BUT IT IS WOR? REPEAT+ ONCE MORE ?AT :ILE V]Y E>LY ON A SUMPTU\S PRODIGALITY ( SYMBOLS OBTA9$1 IT WAS A CLOSURE ( SYMBOLS1 ( AB/RACT CONV5TIONS1 EV5 AT ?AT /AGE1 :I* MIADIGM ( IDEOLOGY1 LANGUAGE MU/ ALSO BE RECOGNIZ$ AS ! DET]M9ANT ORGANIZ] ( COGNITION4 ,AS ! PIONE] L+UI/ ,SAPIR NOT$1 HUMANS >E V]Y MU* AT ! M]CY ( LANGUAGE CONC]N+ :AT CON/ITUTES 0SOCIAL REALITY40 ,ANO!R SEM9AL AN?ROPOLOGICAL L+UI/1 ,:ORF1 TOOK ?IS FUR!R TO PROPOSE ?AT LANGUAGE DET]M9ES ONE'S 5TIRE WAY ( LIFE1 9CLUD+ ONE'S ?9K+ & ALL O!R =MS ( M5TAL ACTIVITY4 ,TO USE LANGUAGE IS TO LIMIT ONESELF TO ! MODES ( P]CEPTION ALREADY 9H]5T 9 ?AT LANGUAGE4 ,! FACT ?AT LANGUAGE IS ONLY =M & YET MOLDS EV]Y?+ GOES TO ! CORE ( :AT IDEOLOGY IS4 ,IT IS REALITY REVEAL$ ONLY IDEOLOGICALLY1 AS A /RATUM SEP>ATE FROM US4 ,9 ?IS WAY LANGUAGE CREATES1 & DEBASES ! WORLD4 0,HUMAN SPEE* CONCEALS F> MORE ?AN IT CONFIDES2 IT BLURS MU* MORE ?AN IT DEF9ES2 IT DI/ANCES MORE ?AN IT CONNECTS10 WAS ,GEORGE ,/E9]'S CONCLUSION4 ,MORE CONCRETELY1 ! ESS5CE ( LE>N+ A LANGUAGE IS LE>N+ A SY/EM1 A MODEL1 ?AT %APES & CONTROLS SPEAK+4 ,IT IS EASI] /ILL TO SEE IDEOLOGY ON ?IS LEVEL1 :]E DUE TO ! ESS5TIAL >BITR>9ESS ( ! PHONOLOGICAL1 SYNTACTIC1 & SEMANTIC RULES ( EA*1 EV]Y HUMAN LANGUAGE MU/ BE LE>N$4 ,! UNNATURAL IS IMPOS$1 AS A NECESS>Y MOM5T ( REPRODUC+ AN UNNATURAL WORLD4 ,EV5 9 ! MO/ PRIMITIVE LANGUAGES1 WORDS R>ELY BE> A RECOGNIZABLE SIMIL>ITY TO :AT !Y D5OTE2 !Y >E PURELY CONV5TIONAL4 ,( C\RSE ?IS IS P>T ( ! T5D5CY TO SEE REALITY SYMBOLICALLY1 :I* ,CIORAN REF]R$ TO AS ! 0/ICKY SYMBOLIC NET0 ( LANGUAGE1 AN 9F9ITE REGRESSION :I* CUTS US (F FROM ! WORLD4 ,! >BITR>Y1 SELF-CONTA9$ NATURE ( LANGUAGE'S SYMBOLIC CREATES GR[+ >EAS ( FALSE C]TA9TY :]E WOND]1 MULTIPLICITY & NONEQUIVAL5CE %\LD PREVAIL4 ,B>!S' DEPICTION ( LANGUAGE AS 0ABSOLUTELY T]RORI/0 IS MU* TO ! PO9T H]E2 HE SAW ?AT ITS SY/EMATIC NATURE 09 ORD] TO BE COMPLETE NE$S ONLY TO BE VALID1 & NOT TO BE TRUE40 ,LANGUAGE EFFECTS ! ORIG9AL SPLIT BETWE5 WISDOM & ME?OD4 ,ALONG !SE L9ES1 9 T]MS ( /RUCTURE1 IT IS EVID5T ?AT 0FRE$OM ( SPEE*0 DOES NOT EXI/2 GRAMM> IS ! 9VISIBLE 0?\TS :I*1 AS CONCEPTS1 CAN BE MANIPULAT$ AS IF !Y W]E OBJECTS4 ,HORKHEIM] PO9T$ \T ?AT IDEOLOGY CONSI/S MORE 9 :AT PEOPLE >E LIKE--!IR M5TAL CON/RICT$NESS1 !IR COMPLETE DEP5D5CE ON ASSOCIATIONS PROVID$ = !M--?AN 9 :AT !Y BELIEVE4 ,9 A /ATEM5T ?AT SEEMS AS P]T95T TO LANGUAGE AS TO IDEOLOGY1 HE ADD$ ?AT PEOPLE EXP]I5CE EV]Y?+ ONLY )9 ! CONV5TIONAL FRAMEWORK ( CONCEPTS4 ,IT HAS BE5 ASS]T$ ?AT REIFICATION IS NECESS>Y TO M5TAL FUNCTION+1 ?AT ! =MATION ( CONCEPTS :I* CAN !MSELVES BE MI/AK5 = LIV+ PROP]TIES & RELATION%IPS DOES AWAY ) ! O!RWISE ALMO/ 9TOL]ABLE EXP]I5CE ( RELAT+ ONE EXP]I5CE TO ANO!R4 ,CASSIR] SAID ( ?IS DI/ANC+ FROM EXP]I5CE1 0,PHYSICAL REALITY SEEMS TO R$UCE 9 PROPORTION AS MAN'S SYMBOLIC ACTIVITY ADVANCES40 ,REPRES5TATION & UNI=MITY BEG9 ) LANGUAGE1 REM9D+ US ( ,HEIDEGG]'S 9SI/5CE ?AT SOME?+ EXTRAORD9>ILY IMPORTANT HAS BE5 =GOTT5 BY CIVILIZATION4 ,CIVILIZATION IS (T5 ?\D1 ALL[+ US TO PR(IT FROM O!R'S EXP]I5CES AS ?\< !Y W]E \R [N4 ,P]HAPS :AT IS =GOTT5 IS SIMPLY ?AT O!R'S EXP]I5CES >E NOT \R [N1 ?AT ! CIVILIZ+ PROCESS IS ?US A VIC>I\S & 9AU!NTIC ONE4 ,:5 LANGUAGE1 = GOOD REASON1 IS HELD TO BE VIRTUALLY COT]M9\S ) LIFE1 WE >E DEAL+ ) ANO!R WAY ( SAY+ ?AT LIFE HAS MOV$ PROGRESSIVELY F>!R FROM DIRECTLY LIV$ EXP]I5CE4 ,LANGUAGE1 LIKE IDEOLOGY1 M$IATES ! H]E & N[1 ATTACK+ DIRECT1 SPONTANE\S CONNECTIONS4 ,A DESCRIPTIVE EXAMPLE WAS PROVID$ BY A MO!R OBJECT+ TO ! PRESSURE TO LE>N TO READ3 0,ONCE A *ILD IS LIT]ATE1 !RE IS NO TURN+ BACK4 ,WALK ?R\< AN >T MUSEUM4 ,WAT* ! LIT]ATE /UD5TS READ ! TITLE C>DS BE=E VIEW+ ! PA9T+S TO BE SURE ?AT !Y KN[ :AT TO SEE4 ,OR WAT* !M READ ! C>DS & IGNORE ! PA9T+S 5TIRELY444,AS ! PRIM]S PO9T \T1 READ+ OP5S DOORS4 ,BUT ONCE ?OSE DOORS >E OP51 IT IS V]Y DIFFICULT TO SEE ! WORLD )\T LOOK+ ?R\< !M40 ,! PROCESS ( TRANS=M+ ALL DIRECT EXP]I5CE 9TO ! SUPREME SYMBOLIC EXPRESSION1 LANGUAGE1 MONOPOLIZES LIFE4 ,LIKE IDEOLOGY1 LANGUAGE CONCEALS & JU/IFIES1 COMPELL+ US TO SUSP5D \R D\BTS AB\T ITS CLAIM TO VALIDITY4 ,IT IS AT ! ROOT ( CIVILIZATION1 ! DYNAMIC CODE ( CIVILIZATION'S ALI5AT$ NATURE4 ,AS ! P>ADIGM ( IDEOLOGY1 LANGUAGE /&S BEH9D ALL ( ! MASSIVE LEGITIMATION NECESS>Y TO HOLD CIVILIZATION TOGE!R4 ,IT REMA9S = US TO CL>IFY :AT =MS ( NASC5T DOM9ATION 5G5D]$ ?IS JU/IFICATION1 MADE LANGUAGE NECESS>Y AS A BASIC MEANS ( REPRESSION4 ,IT %\LD BE CLE>1 FIR/ ( ALL1 ?AT ! >BITR>Y & DECISIVE ASSOCIATION ( A P>TICUL> S\ND ) A P>TICUL> ?+ IS H>DLY 9EVITABLE OR ACCID5TAL4 ,LANGUAGE IS AN 9V5TION = ! REASON ?AT COGNITIVE PROCESSES MU/ PREC$E !IR EXPRESSION 9 LANGUAGE4 ,TO ASS]T ?AT HUMANITY IS ONLY HUMAN BECAUSE ( LANGUAGE G5]ALLY NEGLECTS ! COROLL>Y ?AT BE+ HUMAN IS ! PRECONDITION ( 9V5T+ LANGUAGE4 ,! QUE/ION IS H[ DID WORDS FIR/ COME TO BE ACCEPT$ AS SIGNS AT ALL8 ,H[ DID ! FIR/ SYMBOL ORIG9ATE8 ,CONTEMPOR>Y L+UI/S F9D ?IS 0SU* A S]I\S PROBLEM ?AT ONE MAY DESPAIR ( F9D+ A WAY \T ( ITS DIFFICULTIES40 ,AMONG ! MORE ?AN T5 ?\S& WORKS ON ! ORIG9 ( LANGUAGE1 EV5 ! MO/ REC5T ADMIT ?AT ! !ORETICAL DISCREPANCIES >E /AGG]+4 ,! QUE/ION ( :5 LANGUAGE BEGAN HAS ALSO BR\D ,CAMPELL IS F> FROM ALONE 9 HIS JUDGM5T ?AT 0,WE SIMPLY DO NOT KN[1 & NEV] WILL1 H[ OR :5 LANGUAGE BEGAN40 ,MANY ( ! !ORIES ?AT HAVE BE5 PUT =? AS TO ! ORIG9 ( LANGUAGE >E TRIVIAL3 !Y EXPLA9 NO?+ AB\T ! QUALITATIVE1 9T5TIONAL *ANGES 9TRODUC$ BY LANGUAGE4 ,! 0D+-DONG0 !ORY MA9TA9S ?AT !RE IS SOMEH[ AN 9NATE CONNECTION BETWE5 S\ND & MEAN+2 ! 0POOH-POOH0 !ORY HOLDS ?AT LANGUAGE AT FIR/ CONSI/$ ( EJACULATIONS ( SURPRISE1 FE>1 PLEASURE1 PA91 ETC42 ! 0TA-TA0 !ORY POSITS ! IMITATION ( BODILY MOVEM5TS AS ! G5ESIS ( LANGUAGE1 & SO ON AMONG EXPLANATIONS ?AT ONLY BEG ! QUE/ION4 ,! HYPO!SIS ?AT ! REQUIREM5TS ( HUNT+ MADE LANGUAGE NECESS>Y1 ON ! O!R H&1 IS EASILY REFUT$2 ANIMALS HUNT TOGE!R )\T LANGUAGE1 & IT IS (T5 NECESS>Y = HUMANS TO REMA9 SIL5T 9 ORD] TO HUNT4 ,SOME:AT CLOS] TO ! M>K1 ,I BELIEVE1 IS ! APPROA* ( CONTEMPOR>Y L+UI/ ,E4,H4 ,/URTEVANT3 S9CE ALL 9T5TIONS & EMOTIONS >E 9VOLUNT>ILY EXPRESS$ BY GE/URE1 LOOK1 OR S\ND1 VOLUNT>Y COMMUNICATION1 SU* AS LANGUAGE1 MU/ HAVE BE5 9V5T$ = ! PURPOSE ( LY+ OR DECEIV+4 ,9 A MORE CIRCUMSPECT VE91 ! PHILOSOPH] ,CAWS 9SI/$ ?AT 0TRU?444IS A COMP>ATIVE LATECOM] ON ! L+UI/IC SC5E1 & IT IS C]TA9LY A MI/AKE TO SUPPOSE ?AT LANGUAGE WAS 9V5T$ = ! PURPOSE ( TELL+ IT40 ,BUT IT IS 9 ! SPECIFIC SOCIAL CONTEXT ( \R EXPLORATION1 ! T]MS & *OICES ( CONCRETE ACTIVITIES & RELATION%IPS1 ?AT MORE UND]/&+ ( ! G5ESIS ( LANGUAGE MU/ BE S\$ V]Y E>LY2 0,SURELY444NOT LONG AFT] MAN HAD BEGUN TO FA%ION TOOLS %AP$ TO A SPECIAL PATT]N40 ,! FLAK+ OR *IPP+ ( /ONE TOOLS1 DUR+ ! MILLION OR TWO YE>S ( ,PALEOLI?IC LIFE1 H[EV]1 SEEMS MU* MORE APT TO HAVE BE5 %>$ BY DIRECT1 9TIMATE DEMON/RATION ?AN BY SPOK5 DIRECTIONS4 ,NEV]!LESS1 ! PROPOSITION ?AT LANGUAGE >OSE ) ! BEG9N+S ( TE*NOLOGY--?AT IS1 9 ! S5SE ( DIVISION ( LABOR & ITS CONCOMITANTS1 SU* AS A /&>DIZ+ ( ?+S & EV5TS & ! EFFECTIVE P[] ( SPECIALI/S OV] O!RS--IS AT ! HE>T ( ! MATT]1 9 MY VIEW4 ,IT W\LD SEEM V]Y DIFFICULT TO DIS5GAGE ! DIVISION ( LABOR--0! S\RCE ( CIVILIZATION10 9 ,DURKHEIM'S PHRASE--FROM LANGUAGE AT ANY /AGE1 P]HAPS LEA/ ( ALL ! BEG9N+4 ,DIVISION ( LABOR NECESSITATES A RELATIVELY COMPLEX CONTROL ( GR\P ACTION2 9 EFFECT IT DEM&S ?AT ! :OLE COMMUNITY BE ORGANIZ$ & DIRECT$4 ,?IS HAPP5S ?R\< ! BREAKD[N ( FUNCTIONS PREVI\SLY P]=M$ BY EV]YBODY1 9TO A PROGRESSIVELY GREAT] DIFF]5TIATION ( TASKS1 & H5CE ( ROLES & DI/9CTIONS4 ,:]EAS ,VLAHOS FELT ?AT SPEE* >OSE QUITE E>LY1 9 RELATION TO SIMPLE /ONE TOOLS & !IR REPRODUCTION1 ,JULIAN ,JAYNES HAS RAIS$ P]HAPS A MORE 9T]E/+ QUE/ION :I* IS ASSUM$ 9 HIS CONTR>Y OP9ION ?AT LANGUAGE %[$ UP MU* LAT]4 ,HE ASKS1 H[ IT IS1 IF HUMANITY HAD SPEE* HAD = A C\PLE ( MILLION YE>S1 ?AT !RE WAS VIRTUALLY NO DEVELOPM5T ( TE*NOLOGY8 ,JAYNES'S QUE/ION IMPLIES A UTILIT>IAN VALUE 9H]+ 9 LANGUAGE1 A SUPPOS$ RELEASE ( LAT5T POT5TIALITIES ( A POSITIVE NATURE4 ,BUT GIV5 ! DE/RUCTIVE DYNAMIC ( ! DIVISION ( LABOR1 REF]R$ TO ABOVE1 IT MAY BE ?AT :ILE LANGUAGE & TE*NOLOGY >E 9DE$ L9K$1 !Y W]E BO? SUCCESSFULLY RESI/$ = ?\S&S ( G5]ATIONS4 ,AT ITS ORIG9S LANGUAGE HAD TO MEET ! REQUIREM5TS ( A PROBLEM ?AT EXI/$ \TSIDE LANGUAGE4 ,9 LIAT$4 ,?IS RUPTURE IS ! MOM5T ( DISSOLUTION ( ! ORIG9AL UNITY BETWE5 HUMANITY & NATURE2 IT CO9CIDES ) ! 9ITIATION ( DIVISION ( LABOR4 ,M>X RECOGNIZ$ ?AT ! RISE ( IDEOLOGICAL CONSCI\SNESS WAS E/ABLI%$ BY ! DIVISION ( LABOR2 LANGUAGE WAS HIM ! PRIM>Y P>ADIGM ( 0PRODUCTIVE LABOR40 ,EV]Y /EP 9 ! ADVANCEM5T ( CIVILIZATION HAS MEANT ADD$ LABOR1 H[EV]1 & ! FUNDAM5TALLY ALI5 REALITY ( PRODUCTIVE LABOR_/WORK IS REALIZ$ & ADVANC$ VIA LANGUAGE4 ,IDEOLOGY RECEIVES ITS SUB/ANCE FROM DIVISION ( LABOR1 &1 9SEP>ABLY1 ITS =M FROM LANGUAGE4 ,5GELS1 VALORIZ+ LABOR EV5 MORE EXPLICITLY ?AN ,M>X1 EXPLA9$ ! ORIG9 ( LANGUAGE FROM & ) LABOR1 ! 0MA/]Y ( NATURE40 ,HE EXPRESS$ ! ESS5TIAL CONNECTION BY ! PHRASE1 0FIR/ LABOR1 AFT] IT & !N ) IT SPEE*40 ,TO PUT IT MORE CRITICALLY1 ! >TIFICIAL COMMUNICATION :I* IS LANGUAGE WAS & IS ! VOICE ( ! >TIFICIAL SEP>ATION :I* IS 7DIVISION (7 LABOR4 7,9 ! USUAL1 REPRESSIVE P>LANCE1 ?IS IS PHRAS$ POSITIVELY1 ( C\RSE1 9 T]MS ( ! 9VALUABLE NATURE ( LANGUAGE 9 ORGANIZ+ 09DIVIDUAL RESPONSIBILITIES407 ,LANGUAGE WAS ELABORAT$ = ! SUPPRESSION ( FEEL+S2 AS ! CODE ( CIVILIZATION IT EXPRESSES ! SUBLIMATION ( ,]OS1 ! REPRESSION ( 9/9CT1 :I* IS ! CORE ( CIVILIZATION4 ,FREUD1 9 ! ONE P>AGRAPH HE DEVOT$ TO ! ORIG9 ( LANGUAGE1 CONNECT$ ORIG9AL SPEE* TO SEXUAL BOND+ AS ! 9/RUM5TALITY BY :I* WORK WAS MADE ACCEPTABLE AS 0AN EQUIVAL5CE & SUB/ITUTE = SEXUAL ACTIVITY40 ,?IS TRANSF]5CE FROM A FREE SEXUALITY TO WORK IS ORIG9AL SUBLIMATION1 & ,FREUD SAW LANGUAGE CON/ITUT$ 9 ! E/ABLI%+ ( ! L9K BETWE5 MAT+ CALLS & WORK PROCESSES4 ,! NEO-,FREUDIAN ,LACAN C>RIES ?IS ANALYSIS FUR!R1 ASS]T+ ?AT ! UNCONSCI\S IS =M$ BY ! PRIM>Y REPRESSION ( ACQUISITION ( LANGUAGE4 ,= ,LACAN ! UNCONSCI\S IS ?US 0/RUCTUR$ LIKE A LANGUAGE0 & FUNCTIONS L+UI/ICALLY1 NOT 9/9CTIVELY OR SYMBOLICALLY 9 ! TRADITIONAL ,FREUDIAN S5SE4 ,TO LOOK AT ! PROBLEM ( ORIG9 ON A FIGURATIVE PLANE1 IT 9T]E/+ TO CONSID] ! MY? ( ! ,T[] ( ,BABEL4 ,! /ORY ( ! CONF\ND+ ( LANGUAGE1 LIKE ?AT O!R /ORY 9 ,G5ESIS1 ! ,FALL FROM ! GRACE ( ! ,G>D51 IS AN ATTEMPT TO COME TO T]MS ) ! ORIG9 ( EVIL4 ,! SPL9T]+ ( AN 0ORIG9AL LANGUAGE0 9TO MUTUALLY UN9TELLIGIBLE MAY BE/ BE UND]/OOD AS ! EM]G5CE ( SYMBOLIC LANGUAGE1 ! ECLIPSE ( AN E>LI] /ATE ( MORE TOTAL & AU!NTIC COMMUNICATION4 ,9 NUM]\S TRADITIONS ( P>ADISE1 = EXAMPLE1 ANIMALS CAN TALK & HUMANS CAN UND]/& !M4 ,I HAVE >GU$ ELSE:]E ?AT ! ,FALL CAN BE UND]/OOD AS A FALL 9TO TIME4 ,LIKEWISE ! FAILURE ( ! ,T[] ( ,BABEL SUGGE/S1 AS ,RUSSELL ,FRAS] PUT IT1 0! ISOLATION ( MAN 9 HI/ORICAL TIME40 ,BUT ! ,FALL ALSO HAS A MEAN+ 9 T]MS ( ! ORIG9 ( LANGUAGE4 ,B5JAM9 F\ND IT 9 ! M$IATION :I* IS LANGUAGE & ! 0ORIG9 ( AB/RACTION1 TOO1 AS A FACULTY ( LANGUAGE-M9D40 0,! FALL IS 9TO LANGUAGE10 ACCORD+ TO ,NORMAN ,O4 ,BR[N4 ,ANO!R P>T ( ,G5ESIS PROVIDES ,BIBLICAL COMM5T>Y ON AN ESS5TIAL ( LANGUAGE1 NAMES1 & ON ! NOTION ?AT NAM+ IS AN ACT ( DOM9ATION4 ,I REF] TO ! CREATION MY?1 :I* 9CLUDES 0& :ATSOEV] ,ADAM CALL$ EV]Y LIV+ CREATURE1 ?AT WAS ! NAME !RE(40 ,?IS BE>S DIRECTLY ON ! NECESS>Y L+UI/IC COMPON5T ( ! DOM9ATION ( NATURE3 MAN BECAME MA/] ( ?+S ONLY BECAUSE HE FIR/ NAM$ !M1 9 ! =MULATION ( ,DUFR5NE4 ,AS ,SP5GL] HAD IT1 0,TO NAME ANY?+ BY A NAME IS TO W9 P[] OV] IT40 ,! BEG9N+ ( HUMANK9D'S SEP>ATION FROM & CONQUE/ ( ! WORLD IS ?US LOCAT$ 9 ! NAM+ ( ! WORLD4 ,LOGOS ITSELF AS GOD IS 9VOLV$ 9 ! FIR/ NAM+1 :I* REPRES5TS ! DOM9ATION ( ! DEITY4 ,! WELL-KN[N PASSAGE IS CONTA9$ 9 ! ,GOSPEL ( ,JOHN3 0,9 ! BEG9N+ WAS ! ,WORD1 & ! ,WORD WAS ) ,GOD1 & ! ,WORD WAS ,GOD40 ,RETURN+ TO ! QUE/ION ( ! ORIG9 ( LANGUAGE 9 REAL T]MS1 WE ALSO COME BACK TO ! NOTION ?AT ! PROBLEM ( LANGUAGE IS ! PROBLEM ( CIVILIZATION4 ,! AN?ROPOLOGI/ ,LIZOT NOT$ ?AT ! HUNT]-GA!R] MODE EXHIBIT$ ?AT LACK ( TE*NOLOGY & DIVISION ( LABOR ?AT ,JAYNES FELT MU/ HAVE BESPOK5 AN ABS5CE ( LANGUAGE2 07,PRIMITIVE PEOPLE'S7 CONTEMPT = WORK & !IR DIS9T]E/ 9 TE*NOLOGICAL PROGRESS P] SE >E BEYOND QUE/ION40 ,FUR!RMORE1 0! BULK ( REC5T /UDIES10 9 ,LEE'S WORDS ( #a#i#h#a1 %[S ! HUNT]-GA!R]S TO HAVE BE5 0WELL N\RI%$ & TO HAVE 7HAD7 ABUNDANT LEISURE TIME40 ,E>LY HUMANITY WAS NOT DET]R$ FROM LANGUAGE BY ! PRESSURES ( CON/ANT WORRIES AB\T SURVIVAL2 ! TIME = REFLECTION & L+UI/IC DEVELOPM5T WAS AVAILABLE BUT ?IS PA? WAS APP>5TLY REFUS$ = MANY ?\S&S ( YE>S4 ,NOR DID ! CONCLUSIVE VICTORY ( AGRICULTURE1 CIVILIZATION'S CORN]/ONE1 TAKE PLACE 79 ! =M ( ! ,NEOLI?IC REVOLUTION7 BECAUSE ( FOOD %ORTAGES OR POPULATION PRESSURES4 ,9 FACT1 AS ,LEWIS ,B9=D HAS CONCLUD$1 0,! QUE/ION TO BE ASK$ IS NOT :Y AGRICULTURE & FOOD-/ORAGE TE*NIQUES W]E NOT DEVELOP$ EV]Y:]E1 BUT :Y !Y W]E DEVELOP$ AT ALL40 ,! DOM9ANCE ( AGRICULTURE1 9CLUD+ PROP]TY [N]%IP1 LAW1 CITIES1 MA!MATICS1 SURPLUS1 P]MAN5T HI]>*Y & SPECIALIZATION1 & WRIT+1 TO M5TION A FEW ( ITS ELEM5TS1 WAS NO 9EVITABLE /EP 9 HUMAN 0PROGRESS02 NEI!R WAS LANGUAGE ITSELF4 ,! REALITY ( PRE-,NEOLI?IC LIFE DEMON/RATES ! DEGRADATION OR DEFEAT 9VOLV$ 9 :AT HAS BE5 G5]ALLY SE5 AS AN 5ORM\S /EP =W>D1 AN ADMIRABLE TRANSC5D+ ( NATURE1 ETC44 ,9 ?IS LIE MADE EQUIVOCAL BY !IR FALSE CONCLUSION ?AT 0,M5 HAVE ALWAYS HAD TO *OOSE BETWE5 !IR SUBJUGATION TO NATURE OR ! SUBJUGATION ( NATURE TO ! ,SELF40 0,NO:]E IS CIVILIZATION SO P]FECTLY MIRROR$ AS 9 SPEE*10 AS ,PEI COMM5T$1 & 9 SOME V]Y SIGNIFICANT WAYS LANGUAGE HAS NOT ONLY REFLECT$ BUT DET]M9$ %IFTS 9 HUMAN LIFE4 ,! DEEP1 P[]FUL BREAK ?AT WAS ANN\NC$ BY ! BIR? ( LANGUAGE PREFIGUR$ & OV]%AD[$ ! >RIVAL ( CIVILIZATION & HI/ORY1 A M]E #a1 YE>S AGO4 ,9 ! REA* ( LANGUAGE1 0! :OLE ( ,HI/ORY /&S UNIFI$ & COMPLETE 9 ! MANN] ( A ,NATURAL ,ORD]10 SAYS ,B>!S4 ,MY?OLOGY1 :I*1 AS ,CASSIR] NOT$1 0IS FROM ITS V]Y BEG9N+ POT5TIAL RELIGION10 CAN BE UND]/OOD AS A FUNCTION ( LANGUAGE1 SUBJECT TO ITS REQUIREM5TS LIKE ANY IDEOLOGICAL PRODUCT4 ,! N9ETE5?-C5TURY L+UI/ ,MULL] DESCRIB$ MY?OLOGY AS A 0DISEASE ( LANGUAGE0 9 JU/ ?IS S5SE2 LANGUAGE DE=MS ?\K %AD[ :I* ?R[S UPON ?\ TILL LANGUAGE BECOMES 5TIRELY COMM5SURATE ) ?\T ( HUMANITY'S LONG+ = A LO/ PRIMEVAL /ATE4 ,AS REM>K$ UPON ABOVE1 ! ,T[] ( ,BABEL IS ONE ( ! 5DUR+ SIGNIFICATIONS ( ?IS YE>N+ TO TRULY COMMUNE ) EA* O!R & NATURE4 ,9 ?AT E>LI] 7BUT LONG 5DUR+7 CONDITION NATURE & SOCIETY =M$ A COH]5T :OLE1 9T]CONNECT$ BY ! CLOSE/ BONDS4 ,! /EP FROM P>TICIPATION 9 ! TOTALITY ( NATURE TO RELIGION 9VOLV$ A DETA*+ ( =CES & BE+S 9TO \TW>D1 9V]T$ EXI/5CES4 ,?IS SEP>ATION TOOK ! =M ( DEITIES1 & ! RELIGI\S PRACTITION]1 ! %AMAN1 WAS ! FIR/ SPECIALI/4 ,! DECISIVE M$IATIONS ( MY?OLOGY & RELIGION >E NOT1 H[EV]1 ! ONLY PR(\ND CULTURAL DEVELOPM5TS UND]LY+ \R MOD]N E/RANGEM5T4 ,ALSO 9 ! ,UPP] ,PALEOLI?IC ]A1 AS ! SPECIES ,NE&]?AL GAVE WAY TO ,CRO-,MAGNON 7& ! BRA9 ACTUALLY %RANK 9 SIZE71 >T WAS BORN4 ,9 ! CELEBRAT$ CAVE PA9T+S ( R\S AGO IS F\ND A WIDE ASSORTM5T ( AB/RACT SIGNS2 ! SYMBOLISM ( LATE ,PALEOLI?IC >T SL[LY /IFF5S 9TO ! MU* MORE /YLIZ$ =MS ( ! ,NEOLI?IC AGRICULTURALI/S4 ,DUR+ ?IS P]IOD1 :I* IS EI!R SYNONYM\S ) ! BEG9N+S ( LANGUAGE OR REGI/]S ITS FIR/ REAL DOM9ANCE1 A M\NT+ UNRE/ SURFAC$4 ,JOHN ,PFEIFF] DESCRIB$ ?IS 9 T]MS ( ! ]OSION ( ! EGALIT>IAN HUNT]-GA!R] TRADITIONS1 AS ,CRO-,MAGNON E/ABLI%$ ITS HEGEMONY4 ,:]EAS !RE WAS 0NO TRACE ( RANK0 UNTIL ! ,UPP] ,PALEOLI?IC1 ! EM]G+ DIVISION ( LABOR & ITS IMM$IATE SOCIAL CONSEQU5CES DEM&$ A DISCIPL9+ ( ?OSE RESI/+ ! GRADUAL APPROA* ( CIVILIZATION4 ,AS A =MALIZ+1 9DOCTR9AT+ DEVICE1 ! DRAMATIC P[] ( >T FULFILL$ ?IS NE$ = CULTURAL COH]5CE & ! CONT9UITY ( AU?ORITY4 ,LANGUAGE1 MY?1 RELIGION & >T ?US ADVANC$ AS DEEPLY 0POLITICAL0 CONDITIONS ( SOCIAL LIFE1 BY :I* ! >TIFICIAL M$IA ( SYMBOLIC =MS REPLAC$ ! DIRECTLY-LIV$ QUALITY ( LIFE BE=E DIVISION ( LABOR4 ,FROM ?IS PO9T ON1 HUMANITY C\LD NO LONG] SEE REALITY FACE TO FACE2 ! LOGIC ( DOM9ATION DREW A VEIL OV] PLAY1 FRE$OM1 AFFLU5CE4 ,AT ! CLOSE ( ! ,PALEOLI?IC ,AGE1 AS A DECREAS$ PROPORTION ( V]BS 9 ! LANGUAGE REFLECT$ ! DECL9E ( UNIQUE & FREELY *OS5 ACTS 9 CONSEQU5CE ( DIVISION ( LABOR1 LANGUAGE /ILL POSSESS$ NO T5SES4 ,AL?\< ! CREATION ( A SYMBOLIC WORLD WAS ! CONDITION = ! EXI/5CE ( TIME1 NO FIX$ DIFF]5TIATIONS HAD DEVELOP$ BE=E HUNT]-GA!R] LIFE WAS DISPLAC$ BY ,NEOLI?IC F>M+4 ,BUT :5 EV]Y V]B %[S A T5SE1 LANGUAGE IS 0DEM&+ LIP S]VICE TO TIME EV5 :5 TIME IS FUR!/ ( \R ?\T FROM GRAMM>4 ,ONCE ! /RUCTURE ( SPEE* 9CORPORATES TIME & IS !REBY ANIMAT$ BY IT AT EV]Y EXPRESSION1 DIVISION ( LABOR CONCLUSIVELY DE/ROY$ AN E>LI] REALITY4 ,) ,D]RIDA1 ONE CAN ACCURATELY REF] TO 0LANGUAGE AS ! ORIG9 ( HI/ORY40 ,LANGUAGE ITSELF IS A REPRESSION1 & ALONG ITS PROGRESS REPRESSION GA!RS--AS IDEOLOGY1 AS WORK--SO AS TO G5]ATE HI/ORICAL TIME4 ,)\T LANGUAGE ALL ( HI/ORY W\LD DISAPPE>4 ,PRE-HI/ORY IS PRE-WRIT+2 WRIT+ ( SOME SORT IS ! SIGNAL ?AT CIVILIZATION HAS BEGUN4 0,ONCE GETS ! IMPRESSION10 ,FREUD WROTE 9 ,! ,FUTURE ( AN ,ILLUSION1 0?AT CIVILIZATION IS SOME?+ :I* WAS IMPOS$ ON A RESI/+ MAJORITY BY A M9ORITY :I* UND]/OOD H[ TO OBTA9 POSSESSION ( ! MEANS ( P[] & CO]CION40 ,IF ! MATT] ( TIME & LANGUAGE CAN SEEM PROBLEMATIC1 WRIT+ AS A /AGE ( LANGUAGE MAKES IT APPE>ANCE CONTRIBUT+ TO SUBJUGATION 9 RA!R NAK$ FA%ION4 ,FREUD C\LD HAVE BE5 LEGITIMATELY PO9T$ TO WRITT5 LANGUAGE AS ! LEV] BY :I* CIVILIZATION WAS IMPOS$ & CONSOLIDAT$4 ,BY AB\T #a1 ,B4,C41 EXT5SIVE DIVISION ( LABOR HAD PRODUC$ ! K9D ( SOCIAL CONTROL REFLECT$ BY CITIES & TEMPLES4 ,! E>LIE/ WRIT+S >E RECORDS ( TAXES1 LAWS1 T]MS ( LABOR S]VITUDE4 ,?IS OBJECTIFI$ DOM9ATION ?US ORIG9AT$ FROM ! PRACTICAL NE$S ( POLITICAL ECONOMY4 ,AN 9CREAS$ USE ( LETT]S & TABLETS SOON 5ABL$ ?OSE 9 *>GE TO REA* NEW HEIANCE 9 \R MID/1 HAD ALLI$ ITSELF ) FALSEHOOD40 ,LANGUAGE AT ?IS JUNCTURE BECOMES ! REPRES5TATION ( REPRES5TATION1 9 HI]OGLYPHIC & IDEOGRAPHIC WRIT+ & !N 9 PHONETIC-ALPHABETIC WRIT+4 ,! PROGRESS ( SYMBOLIZATION1 FROM ! SYMBOLIZ+ ( WORDS1 TO ?AT ( SYLLABLES1 & F9ALLY TO LETT]S 9 AN ALPHABET1 IMPOS$ AN 9CREAS+LY IRRESI/IBLE S5SE ( ORD] & CONTROL4 ,& 9 ! REIFICATION ?AT WRIT+ P]MITS1 LANGUAGE IS NO LONG] TI$ TO A SPEAK+ SUBJECT OR COMMUNITY ( DISC\RSE1 BUT CREATES AN AUTONOM\S FIELD FROM :I* EV]Y SUBJECT CAN BE ABS5T4 ,9 ! CONTEMPOR>Y WORLD1 ! AVANT-G>DE ( >T HAS1 MO/ NOTICEABLY1 P]=M$ ! GE/URES ( REFUSAL ( ! PRISON ( LANGUAGE4 ,S9CE ,MALL>ME1 A GOOD DEAL ( MOD]NI/ POETRY & PROSE HAS MOV$ AGA9/ ! TAK5-=-GRANT$NESS ( NORMAL SPEE*4 ,TO ! QUE/ION 0,:O IS SPEAK+80 ,MALL>ME ANSW]$1 0,LANGUAGE IS SPEAK+40 ,AFT] ?IS REPLY1 & ESPECIALLY S9CE ! EXPLOSIVE P]IOD >\ND ,WORLD ,W> ,I :5 ,JOYCE1 ,/E9 & O!RS ATTEMPT$ A NEW SYNTAX AS WELL AS A NEW VOCABUL>Y1 ! RE/RA9TS & DI/ORTIONS ( LANGUAGE HAVE BE5 ASSAULT$ :OLESALE 9 LIT]ATURE4 ,RUSSIAN FUTURI/S1 ,DADA 7E4G4 ,HUGO ,BALL'S EF=TS 9 ! #a#i#bS TO CREATE 0POETRY )\T WORDS071 ,>TAUD1 ! ,SURREALI/S & LETTRI/ES W]E AMONG ! MORE EXOTIC ELEM5TS ( A G5]AL RESI/ANCE TO LANGUAGE4 ,! ,SYMBOLI/ POETS1 & MANY :O C\LD BE CALL$ !IR DESC5DANTS1 HELD ?AT DEFIANCE ( SOCIETY ALSO 9CLUDES DEFIANCE ( ITS LANGUAGE4 ,BUT 9ADEQUACY 9 ! =M] >5A PRECLUD$ SUCCESS 9 ! LATT]1 BR++ ONE TO ASK :E!R AVANT-G>DE /RIV+S CAN BE ANY?+ MORE ?AN AB/RACT1 H]METIC GE/URES4 ,LANGUAGE1 :I* AT ANY GIV5 MOM5T EMBODIES ! IDEOLOGY ( A P>TICUL> CULTURE1 MU/ BE 5D$ 9 ORD] TO ABOLI% BO? CATEGORIES ( E/RANGEM5T2 A PROJECT ( SOME CONSID]ABLE DIM5SIONS1 LET US SAY4 ,?AT LIT]>Y TEXTS 7E4G4 ,F9NEGAN'S ,WAKE1 ! POETRY ( E4E4 CUMM+S7 BREAKS ! RULES ( LANGUAGE SEEMS MA9LY TO HAVE ! P>ADOXICAL EFFECT ( EVOK+ ! RULES !MSELVES4 ,BY P]MITT+ ! FREE PLAY ( IDEAS AB\T LANGUAGE1 SOCIETY TREATS !SE IDEAS AS M]E PLAY4 ,! MASSIVE AM\NT ( LIES--(FICIAL1 COMM]CIAL & O!RWISE--IS P]HAPS 9 ITSELF SUFFICI5T TO EXPLA9 :Y ,JOHNNY ,CAN'T ,READ OR ,WRITE1 :Y ILLIT]ACY IS 9CREAS+ 9 ! METROPOLE4 ,9 ANY CASE1 IT IS NOT ONLY ?AT 0! PRESSURE ON LANGUAGE HAS GOTT5 V]Y GREAT10 ACCORD+ TO ,CANETTI1 BUT ?AT 0UNLE>N+0 HAS COME 0TO BE A =CE 9 ALMO/ EV]Y FIELD ( ?\BISON'S E/IMATION4 ,TODAY 09CR$IBLE0 & 0AWESOME0 >E APPLI$ TO ! MO/ COMMONLY TRIVIAL & BOR+1 IT IS NO ACCID5T ?AT P[]FUL & %OCK+ WORDS B>ELY EXI/ ANYMORE4 ,! DET]IORATION ( LANGUAGE MIRRORS A MORE G5]AL E/RANGEM5T2 IT HAS BECOME ALMO/ TOTALLY EXT]NAL TO US4 ,FROM ,KAFKA TO ,P9T] SIL5CE ITSELF IS A FITT+ VOICE ( \R TIMES4 0,FEW BOOKS >E =GIVABLE4 ,BLACK ON ! CANVAS1 SIL5CE ON ! SCRE51 AN EMPTY :ITE %EET FO PAP]1 >E P]HAPS FEASIBLE10 AS ,R4,D4 ,LA+ PUT IT SO WELL4 ,MEAN:ILE1 ! /RUCTURALI/S--,LEVI-,/RAUSS1 ,B>!S1 ,F\CAULT1 ,LACAN1 ,D]RIDA--HAVE BE5 ALMO/ 5TIRELY OCCUPI$ ) ! DUPLICITY LANGUAGE 9 !IR 5DLESS EXEGETICAL BURR[+S 9TO IT4 ,!Y HAVE VIRTUALLY R5\NC$ ! PROJECT ( EXTRACT+ MEAN+ FROM LANGUAGE4 ,I AM WRIT+ 7OBVI\SLY7 5CLOS$ 9 LANGUAGE1 AW>E ?AT LANGUAGE REIFIES ! RESI/ANCE TO REIFICATION4 ,AS ,T4,S4 ,ELIOT'S ,SWE5EY EXPLA9S1 0,I'VE GOTTA USE WORDS :5 ,I TALK TO Y\40 ,ONE CAN IMAG9E REPLAC+ ! IMPRISONM5T ( TIME ) A BRILLIANT PRES5T--ONLY BY IMAG9+ A WORLD )\T DIVISION ( LABOR1 )\T ?AT DIVORCE FROM NATURE FROM :I* ALL IDEOLOGY & AU?ORITY ACCRUE4 ,WE C\LDN'T LIVE 9 ?IS WORLD )\T LANGUAGE & ?AT IS JU/ H[ PR(\NDLY WE MU/ TRANS=M ?IS WORLD4 ,WORDS BESPEAK A SADNESS2 !Y >E US$ TO SOAK UP ! EMPT9ESS ( UNBRIDL$ TIME4 ,WE HAVE ALL HAD ?AT DESIRE TO GO FUR!R1 DEEP] ?AN WORDS1 ! FEEL+ ( WANT+ ONLY TO BE DONE ) ALL ! TALK1 KN[+ ?AT BE+ ALL[$ TO LIVE COH]5TLY ]ASES ! NE$ TO =MULATE COH]5CE4 ,!RE IS A PR(\ND TRU? TO ! NOTION ?AT 0LOV]S NE$ NO WORDS40 ,! PO9T IS ?AT WE MU/ HAVE A WORLD ( LOV]S1 A WORLD ( ! FACE-TO-FACE1 9 :I* EV5 NAMES CAN BE =GOTT51 A WORLD :I* KN[S ?AT 5*ANTM5T IS ! OPPOSITE ( IGNORANCE4 ,ONLY A POLITICS ?AT UNDOES LANGUAGE & TIME & IS ?US VISION>Y TO ! PO9T ( VOLUPTU\SNESS HAS ANY MEAN+4 ,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,APRIL #b#c1 #bb 3 ,LANGUAGE3 ,ORIG9 & ,MEAN+ -- ,ADD$4 ,JANU>Y #d1 #bbb 3 ,LANGUAGE3 ,ORIG9 & ,MEAN+ -- ,UPDAT$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/