,LETT] TO A ,*9ESE ,G5TLEMAN #ahii ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,LEO ,TOL/OY ,TEXT 3 ,I ,DE> ,SIR1 ,I RECEIV$ Y\R BOOKS & HAVE READ !M ) GREAT 9T]E/1 ESPECIALLY ! 0,PAP]S FROM A ,VIC]OY'S ,YAM540 ,! LIFE ( ! ,*9ESE PEOPLE HAS ALWAYS 9T]E/$ ME 9 ! HIIES UPON !M4 ,I HAVE ALSO READ AB\T ,*9ESE ,BUDDHISM & BOOKS BY ,EUROPEANS UPON ,*9A4 ,LATT]LY1 MOREOV] S9CE ?OSE ATROCITIES :I* HAVE BE5 P]PETRAT$ UPON ! ,*9ESE BY ,EUROPEANS -- AMONG ! O!RS & TO A GREAT EXT5T BY ,RUSSIANS -- ! G5]AL DISPOSITION ( ! ,*9ESE PEOPLE HAS 9T]E/$ & DOES YET 9T]E/ ME4 ,! ,*9ESE PEOPLE1 :IL/ SUFF]+ SO MU* FROM ! IMMORAL & CO>SELY EGOTI/IC AV>ICE & CRUELTY ( ! ,EUROPEAN NATIONS1 HAS1 UNTIL LATELY1 ANSW]$ ALL ! VIOL5CE COMMITT$ AGA9/ IT ) A MAGNANIM\S & WISE TRANQUILITY PREF]R+ TO SUFF] RA!R ?AN TO FISELY SELFI% PEOPLE LIVIIIG M]ELY AN ANIMAL LIFE AS W]E ! ,EUROPEANS :O HAD DEAL+S ) ,*9A4 ,! TRIAL :I* ! ,*9ESE HAVE UND]GONE & >E N[ UND]GO+ IS A GREAT & HEA_*Y ONE1 BUT PRECISELY N[ IS IT IMPORTANT ?AT ! ,*9ESE PEOPLE %\LD NOT LOSE PATI5CE1 OR ALT] !IR ATTITUDE T[>DS VIOL5CE1 SO AS NOT TO DEPRIVE !MSELVES ( ALL ! VA/ RESULTS :I* MU/ FOLL[ ! 5DUR+ ( VIOL5CE )\T RETURN+ EVIL = EVIL4 ,ONLY 0 HE ?AT 5DURE? TO ! 5D ! SAME %ALL BE SAV$ '"9 IS SAID 9 ! ,*RI/IAN LAW1 & ,I ?9K ?AT IT IS AN 9DUBITABLE TRU?1 AL?\< ONE :I* M5 F9D IT H>D TO ACCEPT4 ,AB/95CE FROM RETURN+ EVIL = EVIL & NONP>TICIPATION 9 EVIL IS ! SURE/ MEANS NOT ONLY ( SALVATION BUT ( VICTORY OV] ?OSE :O COMMIT EVIL4 ,! ,*9ESE C\LD SEE A /RIK+ CONFIRMATION ( ! TRU? ( ?IS LAW AFT] !IR SURR5D] ( ,PORT ,>?UR TO ,RUSSIA4 ,! GREATE/ EF=TS TO DEF5D ,PORT ,>?UR BY >MS AGA9/ ! ,JAPANESE & ! ,RUSSIANS W\LD NOT HAVE PRODUC$ SU* RU9\S CONSEQU5CES = ,RUSSIA & ,JAPAN AS ?OSE MAT]IAL & MORAL EVILS :I* ! SURR5D] ( ,PORT ,>?UR TO ! =M] BR\ & GRIEF HE> & SEE 9 Y\R BOOK ! MANIFE/ATION 9 ,*9A ( ! SPIRIT ( /RIFE1 ( ! DESIRE TO =CIBLY RESI/ ! ATROCITIES COMMITT$ BY ! ,EUROPEAN NATIONS4 ,W]E ?IS TO BE ! CASE1 W]E ! ,*9ESE PEOPLE 9DE$ TO LOSE PATI5CE &1 >M+ !MSELVES ACCORD+ TA ! ME?ODS ( ,EUROPEANS1 TO EXPEL FROM !IR MID/ ALL ! ,EUROPEAN ROBB]S -- :I* TASK !Y C\LD EASILY ACCOMPLI% ) !IR 9TELLIG5CE1 P]SI/5CE1 & 5]GY1 & ABOVE ALL BY REASON ( !IR GREAT NUMB]S -- IT W\LD BE DREADFUL4 ,DREADFUL NOT 9 ! S5SE 9 :I* ?IS WAS UND]/OOD BY ONE ( ! CO>SE/ & MO/ B5IE B\ND SOON] OR LAT] CONSCI\SLY TO RETURN4 ,I ?9K ?AT 9 \R TIME A GREAT REVULSION IS TAK+ PLACE 9 ! LIFE ( HUMANITY1 & ?AT 9 ?IS REVULSION ,*9A1 AT ! HEAD ( ! ,EA/]N NATIONS1 MU/ PLAY A GR& P>T4 ,ME?9KS ! VOCATION ( ! ,EA/]N NATIONS1 ,*9A1 ,P]SIA1 ,TURKEY1 ,9DIA1 ,RUSSIA & P]HAPS ,JAPAN1 IF %E IS NOT YET COMPLETELY 5ME%$ 9 ! NET ( DEPRAV$ ,EUROPEAN CIVILIZATION1 -- CONSI/S 9 9DICAT+ TO ALL NATIONS ?AT TRUE WAY T[>DS FRE$OM TO :I*1 AS Y\ SAY 9 Y\R BOOK1 !RE IS 9 ! ,*9ESE LANGUAGE NO O!R WORD ?AN ,TAO1 -- ! ,WAY1 -- I4E41 AN ACTIVITY 9 CON=MITY ) ! ET]NAL & FUNDAM5TAL LAW ( HUMAN LIFE4 ,FRE$OM ACCORD+ TO ! TEA*+ ( ,JESUS IS REALIZ$ 9 ?IS SAME WAY4 0 ,& YE %ALL KN[ ! TRU? & ! TRU? %ALL MAKE Y\ FREE 0 IS SAID 9 ?AT TEA*+4 ,& IT IS ?IS FRE$OM1 :I* ,WE/]N NATIONS HAVE ALMO/ IRREVOCABLY LO/1 ?AT ! ,EA/]N NATIONS >E ME?9KS CALL$ TO REALIZE4 ,MY IDEA IS ?IS 3 ,FROM ! MO/ ANCI5T TIMES IT HAS BE5 ! CASE ?AT \T ( ! MID/ ( PEACEFUL & LABORI\S PEOPLE !RE >OSE SAVAGE M5 :O PREF]R$ VIOL5CE TO LABOR1 & !SE SAVAGE & IDLE M5 ATTACK$ & COMPELL$ ! PEACEFUL ONES TO WORK = !M4 ,SO IT HAS BE5 BO? 9 ! ,WE/ & 9 ! ,EA/ AMONG ALL NATIONS :O LIV$ ! /ATE LIFE1 & SO IT CONT9U$ = AGES & CONT9UES YET4 ,BUT 9 OLD5 TIMES :5 CONQU]ORS SEIZ$ VA/ POPULAT$ SPACES !Y C\LD NOT DO MU* H>M TO ! SUBDU$ 3 ! SMALL NUMB] ( RUL]S & GREAT NUMB] ( RUL$1 ESPECIALLY :5 ! WAYS ( COMMUNICATION W]E V]Y PRIMITIVE1 M]ELY PRODUC$ ! RESULT ( BR++ A SMALL PORTION ( ! POPULATION 9TO SUBJECTION TO ! VIOL5CE ( ! RUL]S1 :]EAS ! MAJORITY C\LD LIVE A PEACEFUL LIFE )\T COM+ 9TO DIRECT T\* ) ! OPPRESSORS4 ,?US IT WAS 9 ! :OLE WORLD1 & SO UNTIL QUITE LATT]LY DID IT CONT9UE AMONG ! ,EA/]N NATIONS AS WELL1 & ESPECIALLY 9 ! VA/ L& ( ,*9A4 ,BUT SU* A SITUATION C\LD NOT & CANNOT CONT9UE1 = TWO REASONS 3 FIR/LY1 BECAUSE CO]CIVE P[] ?R\< ITS V]Y ESS5CE KEEPS CONT9UALLY BECOM+ MORE DEPRAV$1 & SECONDLY1 BECAUSE ! SUBJUGAT$ PEOPLE1 BECOM+ MORE & MORE 5LINESS ! EVIL ( !IR SUBMISSION TO P[] ,! EFFECT ( ?IS IS FUR!R 9CREAS$ BY TE*NICAL IMPROVEM5TS 94 ! MEANS ( COMMUNICATION 3 ROADS1 ! PO/1 TELEGRAPH1 TELEPHONES1 [+ TO :I* ! RUL]S MANIFE/ !IR 9FLU5CE 9 PLACES :]E IT C\LD NOT O!RWISE HAVE REA*$ 2 & ! OPPRESS$ ALSO 9T]ASSOCIAT+ EV] MORE CLOSELY1 UND]/& CLE>] & CLE>] ! DISADVANTAGES ( !IR POSITION4 ,& ! DISADVANTAGES 9 C\RSE ( TIME BECOME SO HEAVY ?AT ! SUBDU$ FEEL IMPELL$ TO ALT] 9 SOME WAY OR ANO!R !IR RELATION TO AU?ORITY4 ,! ,WE/]N NATIONS HAVE LONG FELT ?IS NECESSITY & HAVE LONG S9CE *ANG$ !IR ATTITUDE TO P[] BY ! ONE MEANS1 COMMON TO ALL ,WE/]N PEOPLES -- BY ! LIMITATION ( P[] ?R\< REPRES5TATIVES1 ?AT IS AS A MATT] ( FACT BY ! SPREAD+ ( P[]1 BY ITS TRANSF]5CE FROM ONE OR A FEW TO ! MANY4 ,AT ! PRES5T TIME ,I ?9K ?AT ! T]M HAS >RIV$ = ! ,EA/]N NATIONS ALSO & = ,*FNA SIMIL>LY TO REALIZE ALL ! EVIL ( DESPOTIC P[] & TO SE>* = ! MEANS ( LIB]ATION FROM IT ! PRES5T CONDITIONS ( LIFE HAV+ BECOME UNBE>ABLE4 ,I,V4 ,I KN[ ?AT 9 ,*9A !RE EXI/S A TEA*+ IMPLY+ ?AT ! *IEF RUL]1 ! 0 ,BOGDIKHAN10 %\LD BE ! WISE/ & MO/ VIRTU\S MAN1 & ?AT IF HE BE NOT SU*1 !N ! SUBJECTS MAY & %\LD CEASE TO OBEY HIM4 ,BUT ,I ?9K ?AT SU* A TEA*+ IS M]ELY A JU/IFICATION ( P[]1 & AS UNS\ND AS ! TEA*+ ( ,PAUL CIRCULAT$ AMONG ! ,EUROPEAN NATIONS1 :I* AFFIRMS ?AT ! P[]S >E ( ,GOD4 ,! ,*9ESE PEOPLE CANNOT KN[ :E!R !IR ,EMP]OR IS WISE & VIRTU\S1 JU/ AS ! ,*RI/IAN NATIONS C\LD NOT KN[ :E!R \R P[] WAS GRANT$ BY ,GOD TO ?IS RUL] & NOT TO ?AT O!R ONE :O F\E NOT EFFECTIVE1 & NATIONS HAVE TO ALT] ONE WAY OR ANO!R !IR ATTITUDE TO AU?ORITY4 ,& ! ,WE/]N NATIONS HAVE LONG AGO MADE ?IS ALT]ATION 3 IT IS N[ ! TURN ( ! ,EA/4 ,IT IS ,I ?9K 9 SU* A POSITION ?AT ,RUSSIA & ,P]SIA1 ,TURKEY & ,*9A N[ F9D !MSELVES4 ,ALL !SE NATIONS HAVE ATTA9$ ! P]IOD :5 !Y CAN NO LONG] REMA9 9 !IR =M] ATTITUDE T[>DS !IR RUL]S4 ,AS WAS CORRECTLY REM>K$ BY ! ,RUSSIAN WRIT] ,G]TZ5 3 A ,G5GIS ,KHAN ) TELEGRAPHS & ELECTRIC MOTORS IS IMPOSSIBLE4 ,IF ,G5GIS ,KHANS OR M5 SIMIL> TO !M /ILL EXI/ 9 ! ,EA/1 IT IS CLE> ?AT !IR H\R HAS COME & ?AT !Y >E ! LA/4 ,!Y CANNOT CONT9UE TO EXI/ BO? BECAUSE [+ TO TELEGRAPHS & ALL ?AT IS CALL$ CIVILIZATION !IR P[] IS BECOM+ TOO OPPRESSIVE1 & BECAUSE ! NATIONS1 [+ TO ! SAME CIVILIZATION1 FEEL & RECOGNIZE ) ESPECIAL KE5NESS ?AT ! EXI/5CE OR NONEXI/5CE ( !SE ,G5GIS ,KHANS IS = !M NOT A MATT] ( 9DIFF]5CE AS IT US$ TO BE ( OLD1 BUT ?AT ALMO/ ALL ! CALAMITIES FROM :I* !Y SUFF] >E PRODUC$ PRECISELY BY ?IS P[] TO' :I* !Y SUBMIT )\T ANY ADVANTAGE TO !M- SELVES BUT M]ELY BY HABIT4 ,9 ,RUSSIA ?IS IS C]TA9LY ! CASE 2 ,I ?9K ?AT ! SAME IS TRUE ALSO ( ,TURKEY & ,P]SIA & ,*9A4 ,= ,*9A ?IS IS ESPECIALLY TRUE1 [+ TO ! PEACEFUL DIS- POSITION ( ITS POPULATION & ! BAD ORGANIZATION ( ITS ,>MY ,L,E,T,T,] ,T,O ,A ,*,9,E,S,E ,G,5,T,L,E,M,A,N4 ,S@5 :I* GIVES ! ,EUROPEANS ! POSSIBILITY ( ROBB+ ) IMPUNITY ,*9ESE L&S UND] ! PRETEXT ( COLLISIONS & DIFF]5CES ) ! ,*9ESE ,GOV]NM5T4 ,! ,*9ESE PEOPLE CANNOT BUT FEEL ! NECESSITY ( *ANG+ ITS RELATION TO P[]4 ,V4 ,& N[ ,I GA!R FROM Y\R BOOK & O!R 9=MATION ?AT SOME LITY ( RE=M1 ?9K ?AT ?IS ALT]ATION %\LD CONSI/ 9 FOLL[+ ! ME?ODS ( ! ,WE/]N NATIONS1 T'4E4Y 9 SUB/ITUT+ A REPRES5TATIVE ,GOV]NM5T = A DESPOTIC ONE1 9 ORGANIZ+ AN >MY SIMIL> TO ?AT ( ,WE/]N NATIONS1 & A SIMIL> ORGANIZATION ( 9DU/RY4 ,?IS SOLUTION1 :I* AT FIR/ SIS ! SIMPLE/ & MO/ NATURAL1 IS NOT ONLY A SUP]FICIAL ONE1 BUT V]Y SILLY1 &1 ACCORD+ TO ALL ,I KN[ AB\T ,*9A1 IT IS ALTOGE!R ALI5 TO ! WISE ,*9ESE PEOPLE4 ,TO ORGANIZE SU* A ,CON/ITUTION1 SU* AN ,>MY1 P]HAPS1 ALSO1 SU* A CONSCRIPTION1 & SU* AN 9DU/RY AS ! ,WE/]N NATIONS HAVE GOT1 W\LD MEAN TO R5\NCE ALL ?AT BY :I* ! ,*9ESE PEOPLE HAVE LIV$ & >E LIV+1 TO R5\NCE !IR PA/1 TO R5\NCE !IR RATIONAL1 PEACEFUL1 AGRICULTURAL LIFE1 ?AT LIFE :I* CON/ITUTES ! TRUE & ONLY WAY ( ,TAO1 NOT ONLY = ,*9A1 BUT = ALL MANK9D4 ,LET US ADMIT ?AT1 HAV+ 9TRODUC$ AMONG !MSELVES ,EUROPEAN 9/ITUTIONS1 ! ,*9ESE W]E TO EXPEL ! ,EUROPEANS & TO HAVE A ,CON/ITUTION1 A P[]FUL /&+ ,>MY1 & AN 9DU/RIAL DEVELOPM5T SIMIL> TO ! ,EUROPEAN4 ,JAPAN HAS DONE ?IS1 HAS 9TRODUC$ A ,CON/ITUTION & EXT5D$ ! ,>MY & ,FLEET1 & DEVELOP$ 9DU/RY1 & ! RESULT ( ALL !SE 9SEP>ABLY 9T]CONNECT$ MEASURES IS ALREADY OBVI\S ,! CONDITION ( ITS PEOPLE MORE & MORE APPROA*ES ! POSITION ( ! ,EUROPEAN NATIONS1 & ?IS POSITION IS EXTREMELY BURD5SOME4 ,V,I ,! ,/ATES ( ,WE/]N ,EUROPE1 EXT]NALLY V]Y P[]FUL1 MAY N[ CRU% ! ,*9ESE >MY 2 BUT ! POSITION ( ! PEOPLE LIV+ 9 !SE ,/ATES NOT ONLY CANNOT BE COMP>$ ) ! POSITION ( ! ,*9ESE1 BUT1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 IT IS MO/ CALAMIT\S4 ,AMONG ALL !SE NATIONS !RE UNCEAS+LY PROCE$S A /RIFE BETWE5 ! DE/ITUTE1 EXASP]AT$ WORK+ PEOPLE & ! ,GOV]NM5T & WEAL?Y1 A /RIFE :I* IS RE/RA9$ ONLY BY CO]CION ON ! P>T ( DECEIV$ M5 :O CON/ITUTE ! ,>MY 2 A SIMIL> /RIFE IS CONT9UALLY WAG+ BETWE5 ! DIFF]5T ,/ATES DEM&+ 5DLESSLY 9CREAS+ >MAM5TS1 A /RIFE :I* IS ANY MOM5T READY TO PLUNGE 9TO ! GREATE/ CATA/ROPHES4 ,BUT H[EV] DREADFUL ?IS /ATE ( ?+S MAY BE1 IT DOES NOT CON/ITUTE ! ESS5CE ( ! CALAMITY ( ! ,WE/]N NATIONS4 ,!IR *IEF & FUNDAM5TAL CALAMITY IS ?AT ! :OLE LIFE ( !SE NATIONS :O >E UNABLE TO FURNI% !MSELVES ) FOOD1 IS 5TIRELY BAS$ ON ! NECESSITY ( PROCUR+ MEANS ( SU/5ANCE BY VIOL5CE & CUNN+ FROM O!R NATIONS1 :O1 LIKE ,*9A1 ,9DIA1 ,RUSSIA & O!RS1 /ILL PRES]VE A RATIONAL AGRICULTURAL LIFE4 ,& IT IS !SE P>ASITICAL NATIONS & !IR ACTIVITY ?AT Y\ >E 9VIT$ TO IMITATE BY ! M5 ( ! ,RE=M P>TY 6 ,CON/ITUTIONS1 PROTECTIVE T>IFFS1 /&+ >MIES1 ALL ?IS TO- GE!R HAS R5D]$ ! ,WE/]N NATIONS :AT !Y >E -- PEOPLE :O HAVE AB&ON$ AGRICULTURE & BECOME UNUS$ TO IT1 OCCUPI$ 9 T[NS & FACTORIES 9 ! PRODUCTION ( >TICLES = ! MO/ P>T UNNECESS>Y1 PEOPLE :O ) !IR >MIES >E ADAPT$ ONLY TO EV]Y K9D ( VIOL5CE & ROBB]Y4 ,H[EV] BRILLIANT !IR POSITION MAY APPE> AT FIR/ SID TO BECOME A SIMIL> IMMORAL BLACKGU>D ONESELF4 ,! ,*9ESE %\LD NOT IMITATE ,WE/]N NATIONS1 BUT PR(IT BY !IR EXAMPLE 9 ORD] TO AVOID FALL+ 9TO ! SAME DESP]ATE /RAITS4 ,ALL ?AT ! ,WE/]N NATIONS >E DO+ CAN & %\LD BE AN EXAMPLE = ! ,EA/]N ONES1 -- NOT1 H[EV]1 AN EXAMPLE ( :AT !Y %\LD DO1 BUT ( :AT !Y %\LD NOT DO UND] ANY CONSID]ATION :ATEV]4 ,V,I,I ,TO FOLL[ ! WAY ( ! ,WE/]N NATIONS MEANS TO GO ! WAY TO C]TA9 RU94 ,BUT ALSO TO REMA9 9 ! POSITION 9 :I* ! ,RUSSIANS 9 ,RUSSIA1 ! ,P]SIANS 9 ,P]SIA1 ! ,TURKS 9 ,TURKEY1 & ! ,*9ESE 9 ,*9A >E IS ALSO IMPOSSIBLE4 ,BUT = Y\1 ! ,*9ESE1 IT IS P>TICUL>LY OBVI\SLY IMPOSSIBLE1 BECAUSE Y\ REMA9+ ) Y\R LOVE ( PEACE 9 ! POSITION ( A ,/ATE )\T AN >MY AMID >M$ ,/ATES1 :I* >E UNABLE TO EXI/ 9DEP5D5TLY1 WILL 9EVITABLY BE SUBJECT TO PLUND] & SEIZURE :I* !SE ,/ATES >E COMPELL$ TO HAVE REC\RSE TO = !IR MA9T5ANCE4 ,:AT1 !N1 IS TO BE DONE 8 ,= US ,RUSSIANS ,I KN[1 ,I MO/ UND\BT$LY KN[1 :AT WE ,RUSSIANS %\LD NOT DO & :AT WE %\LD DO 9 ORD] TO FREE \RSELVES FROM ! EVILS FROM :I* WE >E SUFF]+1 &1 NOT TO FALL 9TO /ILL WORSE ONES4 ,WE ,RUSSIANS FIR/ ( ALL %\LD NOT OBEY ! EXI/+ AU?ORITIES1 BUT WE ALSO %\LD NOT DO ?AT :I* IS BE+ ATTEMPT$ AMONG US BY UN5LITY ( RE=M1 -- WE %\LD NOT IMITATE ! ,WE/ 3 WE %\LD NOT SUB/ITUTE ONE ,P[] = ANO!R & ORGANIZE A CON/ITUTION1 :E!R IT BE MON>*IAL OR REPUBLICAN4 ,?IS = C]TA9 WE %\LD NOT DO1 BECAUSE IT W\LD NECESS>ILY BR+ US TO ! SAME CALAMIT\S POSITION 9 :I* ! ,WE/]N NATIONS >E PLAC$4 ,BUT WE %\LD & CAN DO ONLY ONE ?+1 & ?AT ! MO/ SIMPLE 3 LIVE A PEACEFUL AGRICULTURAL LIFE1 BE>+ ! ACTS ( VIOL5CE :I* MAY BE P]PETRAT$ UPON US )\T /RUGGL+ AGA9/ !M & )\T P>TICIPAT+ 9 !M4 ,! SAME ?+@5 ,I PRESUME1 & ) YET /RONG] REASONS1 %\LD Y\ ,*9ESE DO 9 ORD] NOT ONLY TO FREE Y\RSELVES FROM ! SEIZURES ( Y\R L& & ! PLUND] :I* ! ,EUROPEAN NATIONS SUBJECT Y\ TO1 BUT ALSO FROM ! UNREASONABLE DEM&S ( Y\R ,GOV]NM5T :I* EXACTS FROM Y\ ACTIONS CONTR>Y TO Y\R MORAL TEA*+ & CONSCI\SNESS4 ,ONLY ADH]E TO ?AT LIB]TY :I* CONSI/S 9 FOLL[+ ! RATIONAL WAY ( LIFE1 Z4E4Y ,TAO1 & ( !MSELVES WILL BE ABOLI%$ ALL ! CALAMITIES :I* Y\R (FICIALS CAUSE Y\1 & Y\R OPPRESSION & PLUND] BY ,EUROPEANS WILL BECOME IMPOSSIBK4 ,Y\ WILL FREE Y\RSELVES FROM Y\R (FICIALS BY NOT FULFILL+ !IR DEM&S1 &1 ABOVE ALL1 BY NOT OBEY+1 Y\ WILL CEASE TO CON- TRIBUTE TO ! OPPRESSION & PLUND] ( EA* O!R4 ,Y\ WILL FREE Y\RSELVES FROM PLUND] ON ! P>T ( ,EUROPEANS BY KEEP+ ! ,TAO1 & NOT RECOGNIZ+ Y\RSELVES AS BELONG+ TO ANY ,/ATE1 OR AS BE+ RESPONSIBLE = ! DE$S COMMITT$ BY Y\R ,GOV]NM5T4 ,ALL ! SEIZURES & PLUND] Y\ >E SUBJECT TO FROM ,EUROPEAN NATIONS TAKE PLACE ONLY BECAUSE !RE EXI/S A ,GOV]NM5T ( :I* Y\ RECOGNIZE Y\RSELVES AS SUBJECTS4 ,IF !RE W]E NO ,*9ESE ,GOV]NM5T1 =EIGN NATIONS W\LD HAVE NO PRETEXT1 UND] GUISE ( 9T]NATIONAL RELATIONS1 TO COMMIT !IR ATROCITIES4 ,& IF1 BY REFUS+ TO OBEY Y\R ,GOV]NM5T1 Y\ WILL CEASE TO 5C\RAGE =EIGN ,P[]S 9 !IR ACTS ( VIOL5CE AGA9/ Y\ 3 IF Y\ DO NOT S]VE ! ,GOV]NM5T1 EI!R 9 PRIVATE1 OR ,/ATE1 OR MILIT>Y S]VICE-- !N !RE WILL NOT EXI/ ALL ?OSE CALAMITIES FROM :I* Y\ SUFF]4 ,V,I,I,I ,9 ORD] TO FREE ONESELF FROM ! EVIL ONE %\LD NOT FIDS HUMAN AU?ORITY4 ,IF ! PEOPLE RECOGNIZE HUMAN P[] AS HI<] ?AN ! P[] ( ,GOD1 HI<] ?AN ! LAW 7,TAO71 !N ! PEOPLE WILL ALWAYS BE SLAVES & ! MORE SO ! MORE COMPLEX !IR ORGANIZATION ( ,P[] 7SU* AS A CON/ITUTIONAL ONE7 :I* !Y 9/ITUTE & TO :I* !Y SUBMIT4 ,ONLY ?OSE PEOPLE CAN BE FREE = :OM ! LAW ( ,GOD 7,TAO7 IS ! SOLE SUPREME LAW TO :I* ALL O!RS %\LD BE SUBORD9AT$4 ,I,X4 ,9DIVIDUALS & SOCIETIES >E ALWAYS 9 A TRANSITORY /ATE FROM ONE AGE TO ANO!R1 BUT !RE >C TIMES :5 !SE TRANSITIONS BO? = 9DIVIDUALS & = SOCIETIES >E ESPECIALLY APP>5T & VIVIDLY REALIZ$4 ,AS IT HAPP5S ) A MAN :O HAS SUDD5LY COME TO FEEL ?AT HE CAN NO LONG] CONT9UE A *ILDI% LIFE1 SO ALSO 9 ! LIFE ( NATIONS !RE COME P]IODS :5 SOCIETIES CAN NO LONG] CONT9UE TO LIVE AS !Y DID1 & !Y REALIZE ! NECESSITY ( *ANG+ !IR HABITS1 !IR ORGANIZATION & ACTIVITY4 ,& IT IS SU* A P]IOD ( TRANSITION FROM *ILDHOOD TO MANHOOD ?AT1 AS IT APPE>S TO ME1 ALL NATIONS >E N[ PASS+ ?R\<1 ! ,EA/]N AS WELL AS ! ,WE/]N4 ,?IS TRANSITION CONSI/S 9 ! NECESSITY ( FREE+ !MSELVES FROM HUMAN AU?ORITY :I* HAS BECOME UNBE>ABLE1 & ( ! E/ABLI%M5T ( LIFE ON F\NDATIONS O!R ?AN HUMAN P[]4 ,& ?IS TASK IS1 ,I ?9K1 BY HI/ORICAL FATE PR$E/9$ PRECISELY TO ! ,EA/]N NATIONS4 ,! ,EA/]N NATIONS >E PLAC$ = ?IS PURPOSE 9 ESPECIALLY HAPPY CONDITIONS1 NOT HAV+ YET AB&ON$ AGRICULTURE1 NOT BE+ YET DEPRAV$ BY MILIT>Y1 CON/ITUTIONAL & 9DU/RIAL LIFE1 & NOT HAV+ YET LO/ FAI? 9 ! NECESSITY ( ! SUPREME LAW ( ,HEAV5 OR ,GOD1 !Y >E /&+ AT ! P>T+ ( ! WAYS FROM :I* ! ,EUROPEAN NATIONS HAVE LONG AGO TURN$1 ON TO ! FALSE WAY 9 :I* LIB]ATION FROM HUMAN AU?ORITY HAS BECOME P>TICUL>LY DIFFICULT4.<#a.> ,& !RE=E1 ,EA/]N NATIONS SEE+ ALL ! CALAMITY ( ! ,WE/- ]N PEOPLES1 %\LD NATURALLY 5DEAVOR TO FREE !MSELVES FROM ! ]ROR ( HUMAN AU?ORITY1 NOT BY ?AT >TIFICIAL & DELUSIVE ME?OD CONSI/+ 9 ! IMAG9>Y LIMITATION ( P[]1 & 9 REPRES5TA- TION BY :I* ,WE/]N NATIONS HAVE 5DEAVOR$ TO FREE !MSELVES1 BUT %\LD SOLVE ! PROBLEM ( ,P[] BY ANO!R MORE RADICAL & SIMPLE PLAN4 ,& ?IS PLAN ( ITSELF APPEALS TO ?OSE :O HAVE NOT YET LO/ FAI? 9 ! SUPREME1 B9D+ LAW ( ,HEAV5 OR ,GOD1 ! LAW ( ,TAO4 ,IT CONSI/S M]ELY 9 ! FOLL[+ ( ?IS LAW :I* EXCLUDES ! POSSIBILITY ( OBEY+ HUMAN AU?ORITY4 ,IF ! ,*9ESE PEOPLE W]E ONLY TO CONT9UE TO LIVE1 AS !Y HAVE =M]LY LIV$1 A PEACEFUL 9DU/RI\S AGRICULTURAL LITE1 FOLL[+ 9 !IR CONDUCT ! PR9CIPLES ( !IR ?REE RELIGIONS 3 ,CONFUCIANISM1 ,TAOISM1 ,BUDDHISM1 ALL ?REE 9 !IR BASIS CO9CID+ 3 ,CONFUCIANISM 9 ! LIB]ATION FROM ALL HUMAN AU?ORITY1 ,TAOISM 9 NOT DO+ TO O!RS :AT ONE DOES NOT WI% DONE TO ONESELF1 & ,BUDDHISM 9 LOVE T[>DS ALL M5 & ALL LIV+ BE+S1 !N ( !MSELVES W\LD DISAPPE> ALL ?OSE CALAMITIES FROM :I* !Y N[ SUFF]1 & NO ,P[]S C\LD OV]COME !M4 ,! TASK :I*1 ACCORD+ TO MY OP9ION1 IS N[ P5D+ NOT ONLY = ,*9A BUT = ALL ! ,EA/]N NATIONS1 DOES NOT M]ELY CONSI/ 9 FREE+ !MSELVES FROM ! EVILS !Y SUFF] FROM !IR [N ,GOV]NM5TS & =EIGN NATIONS1 BUT 9 PO9T+ \T TO ALL NATIONS ! ISSUE \T ( ! TRANSITORY POSITION 9 :I* !Y ALL >E4 ,& !RE IS & CAN BE NO O!R ISSUE ?AN ! LIB]ATION ( ONESELF FRON HUMAN AU?ORITY1 & SUBMISSION TO ! DIV9E AU?ORITY4 ,ORIG9AL FOOTNOTES 8 ,AS TO :Y ?IS IS SO ,I HAVE /AT$ 9 DETAIL 9 MY >TICLE 5TITL$1 0,! ,SIGNIFICANCE ( ! ,RUSSIAN ,REVOLUTION40 7,S\RCE3 ,WRITT5 9 #a#h#i#i1 & TRANSLAT$ BY ,VLADIMIR ,G4 ,T*]TK(F1 ?IS LETT] WAS PUBLI%$ 9 #ai BY ,! ,FREE ,AGE ,PRESS47 ,FROM 3 ,WIKIS\RCE4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahih 3 ,LETT] TO A ,*9ESE ,G5TLEMAN -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,AUGU/ #b1 #bba 3 ,LETT] TO A ,*9ESE ,G5TLEMAN -- ,ADD$4 ,JANU>Y #i1 #bbb 3 ,LETT] TO A ,*9ESE ,G5TLEMAN -- ,UPDAT$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/