,LIB]TY ,VOL4 ,I,I4 ,NO4 #a4 
,NOT ! ,DAU<T] ,BUT ! ,MO!R ( ,ORD] 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,B5JAM9 ,R4 ,TUCK] 

,TEXT 3 

0,= ALWAYS 9 ?9E EYES1 ,O ,LIB]TY6 

,%9ES ?AT HI< LI<T :]EBY ! WORLD IS SAV$2 

,& ?\< ?\ SLAY US1 WE WILL TRU/ 9 !E40 

-- ,JOHN ,HAY4 

,ON ,PICKET ,DUTY4 

,ROAD ,LIB]TY'S SPL5DID (F] ( PREMIUMS TO NEW SUBSCRIB]S 9 ANO!R COLUMN4 0,LEAVES ( ,GRASS0 IS N[ SOLD OP5LY BY NE>LY ALL ! ,BO/ON BOOKSELL]S4 ,WE HAVE WON \R VICTORY1 & ! 0GU>DIANS ( ,MASSA*USETTS MORALITY0 HAVE IGNOM9I\SLY RETREAT$4 ,?IS IS WELL2 BUT MU* TR\BLE W\LD HAVE BE5 SAV$1 IF ! C[>DLY ,OSGOODS HAD ONLY /OOD UP 9 !IR %OES1 9/EAD ( SURR5D]+ )\T A /RUGGLE4 

,! WOMAN SUFFRAGI/S ( ,BO/ON MET AT ,MRS4 ,F5NO ,TUDOR'S A FEW DAYS AGO1 & VOT$ DESPITE ! REC5T DECL>ATION ( ! ,DEMOCRATIC P>TY 9 FAVOR ( WOMAN SUFFRAGE1 ?AT IT W\LD BE TIME 5\< TO 5DORSE ?AT P>TY :5 IT HAD DONE SUB/ANTIAL WORK = ! RE=M 9 QUE/ION4 ,+RATITUDE1 ?Y NAME IS WOMAN6 

,LIT]ATURE IS AB\T TO BE 5RI*$ BY AN UNEXPECT$ TREASURE4 ,PR\DHON'S FAMILY LATELY DISCOV]$ AMONG ! MANUSCRIPTS ( ?AT CELEBRAT$ PUBLICI/ A PO/HUM\S WORK1 5TITL$1 0,CEAS>IAN & ,HI/ORY40 ,IT IS ALREADY 9 PRESS1 & WILL D\BTLESS BE BE=E ! PUBLIC 9 A V]Y %ORT TIME4 ,! EAG]NESS ) :I* ! PEOPLE ( ,CONT95TAL ,EUROPE BUY & READ ! WORKS ( ,PR\DHON IS HI<LY CR$ITABLE TO !M1 & IT WILL NOT BE \R FAULT IF1 BE=E MANY YE>S1 ! ,5GLI% SPEAK+-PEOPLES DO NOT HAVE A *ANCE TO SIMIL>LY HONOR !MSELVES4 ,NEI!R ,FRANCE NOR ! :OLE WORLD CAN *]I% TOO C>EFULLY EV]Y WORD ?AT WAS WRITT5 BY HIM :OM ! NEXT C5TURY WILL PROBABLY RANK AS ! =EMO/ MAN ( ?IS4 

,G5]AL ,B5 ,BUTL] HAS ! REPUTATION ( POSSESS+ A L>GE AM\NT ( *EEK1 BUT HE IS BY NO MEANS ! *EEKIE/ ( ! C&IDATES = GOV]NOR BETWE5 :OM ,MASSA*USETTS VOT]S >E TO *OOSE ?IS FALL4 ,! PALM 9 ?AT RESPECT IS UNQUE/IONABLY BORNE (F BY ! MO/ HONE/ & E/IMABLE ( !M ALL1 ,*>LES ,ALMY1 ( ,NEW ,B$=D1 ! C&IDATE ( ! ,PROHIBITORY P>TY1 :O1 ) AN UNAPPROA*ABLE SUBLIMITY ( 9CONSI/5CY1 DECL>ES1 9 A LETT] ACCEPT+ ! NOM9ATION ( A P>TY :I* PROPOSES TO DECIDE :AT M5 %ALL & %ALL NOT DR9K1 ?AT 0! M9IMUM ( ORGANIZ$ GOV]NM5T & ! MAXIMUM ( SELF-GOV]NM5T IS TO BE 5C\RAG$40 ,?IS IS VIRTUALLY A PROPOSITION TO 5C\RAGE M5 TO GOV]N !MSELVES BY PROHIBIT+ !M FROM DO+ SO1 & IS A F9E SPECIM5 ( ! HUMORS ( POLITICS4 

,! ,PROVID5CE 0,J\RNAL0 GAVE ! LA/ NUMB] ( ,LIB]TY A HALF-COLUMN ( ATT5TION1 = :I* WE >E ITS DEBTOR4 ,AMONG O!R COMM5TS1 IT SAID1 AFT] QUOT+ SOME ( \R CRITICISMS ( ! ,/ATE3 0,WE DO NOT ?9K ?AT ! ,RHODE ,ISL& 'RE=M]S' >E QUITE $UCAT$ UP TO ?IS /&>D40 ,H[ ?IS MAY BE WE DO NOT KN[4 ,! 0,J\RNAL0 \<T TO BE BETT] PO/$ ?AN \RSELVES CONC]N+ ! $UCATIONAL /ATUS ( ,RHODE ,ISL& RE=M]S4 ,BUT ?IS WE CAN SAY1-- ?AT1 AFT] ,MASSA*USETTS1 ,RHODE ,ISL& IS ! BANN] /ATE ON \R SUBSCRIPTION LI/1 & ?AT NO O!R CITY 9 ! ,UNION TAKES AS MANY COPIES ( ,LIB]TY AS ,PROVID5CE ITSELF4 ,WE >E RAPIDLY DEVELOP+ ,AN>*I/S 9 ,LITTLE ,RHODY'S BOSOM1 & CREAT+ A CON/ITU5CY ( V]Y LIVELY NEI<BORS = ! >ROGANT ?IEVES :O RULE H] ?R\< ! COLUMNS ( ! 0,J\RNAL40 

,A MISSION IS 9 PROGRESS AT ,/4 ,M>Y'S ,CA?OLIC ,*UR* 9 ?IS CITY UND] ! CONDUCT ( ,FA!RS ,HAMILTON & ,LANCAKE4 0,DUR+ ! PA/ WEEK10 SAYS A ,BO/ON NEWSPAP]1 0! FA!RS1 HAVE LABOR$ ) ! Y\NG M5 ( ! P>I%1 & ! WEEK = ! Y\NG UNM>RI$ WOM5 COMM5C$ LA/ EV5+40 ,WE KN[ LITTLE AB\T REVIVALS1 BUT /RONGLY 9CL9E TO ! OP9ION ?AT ! WEEK :I* 0COMM5C$ LA/ EV5+0 WILL PROVE ! MORE FRUITFUL ( ! TWO4 

,! ,LIB]AL ,LEAGUE IS SP5D+ A TREM5D\S AM\NT ( 9TELLECTUAL 5]GY 9 AN EF=T TO 9DUCE ! PEOPLE TO DATE !IR LETT]S & PAP]S & DOCUM5TS ,E4 ,M4 #hb 9/EAD ( ,A4 ,D4 #a#h#h#b4 0,:]E N[10 ASKS ,C>LYLE1 0>E ! ,H5G/S & ,AL>ICS ( \R /ILL-GL[+1 /ILL-EXP&+ ,EUROPE2 :O1 :5 !IR HOME IS GR[N TOO N>R[1 WILL 5LI/1 &1 LIKE ,FIREPILL>S1 GUIDE ONW>D ?OSE SUP]FLU\S MASSES ( 9DOMITABLE LIV+ ,VALOR2 EQUIPP$1 NOT N[ ) ! BATTLE-AX & W>-*>IOT1 BUT ) ! /EAM-5G9E & PL[%>E8 ,:]E >E !Y8 -- ,PRES]V+ !IR ,GAME60 ,:]E N[1 ASKS ,LIB]TY1 >E ! ,PA9ES & ,JEFF]SON ( \R /ILL-GL[+1 /ILL-EXP&+ ,AM]ICA2 :O1 :5 !IR FELL[S HAVE BECOME TOO WRET*$ & D[N-TRODD51 WILL 5LI/ TO LIFT ! YOKES ( POV]TY & TYRANNY FROM ! NECK ( ,9DU/RY2 EQUIPP$1 NOT ) ! BULLET1 OR EV5 ) ! BALLOT1 BUT ) REASON & E>NE/NESS & PR9T]S' 9K & PEACEFUL REBELLION & NON-COMPLIANCES8 ,:]E >E !Y8 -- ,*ANG+ ! ,CAL5D>6 

,TIME BR+S QUE] *ANGES4 ,! ,DEMOCRATIC P>TY1 H]ET(ORE SUPPOS$ TO BE ! BITT]E/ FOE ( WOMAN SUFFRAGE1 HAS EMBODI$ IT 9 ITS PLAT=M 9 ,MASSA*USETTS1 & EV5 DECL>$ UNEQUIVOCALLY 9 FAVOR ( WOMAN'S EQUALITY ) MAN 9 ! BROADE/ S5SE4 ,IF ! ,DEMOCRATIC P>TY EV] GIVES WOMAN ! BALLOT1 IT WILL BE ! MO/ UNSELFI% DE$ EV] DONE BY A POLITICAL ORGANIZATION1 = IT WILL AM\NT TO NO?+ LESS ?AN SUICIDE4 ,IMM$IATELY WOMAN GETS ! RI<T TO VOTE1 %E WILL USE IT TO ?W>T & OV]TURN EV]Y PR9CIPLE ?AT A FOLL[] ( ,JEFF]SON IS SUPPOS$ TO BELIEVE 94 ,%E WILL VOTE = PROHIBITION AGA9/ FREE RUM1 = PROTECTION AGA9/ FREE TRADE1 = A ,/ATE RELIGION AGA9/ FREE ?\<T1 = ,COM/OCKISM AGA9/ A FREE PRESS1 = 9DISSOLUBLE M>RIAGE AGA9/ FREE LOVE1 & = GRE5BACKISM AGA9/ FREE MONEY2 9 %ORT1 %E WILL DO NE>LY EV]Y?+ ?AT IS \TRAGE\S & TYRANNICAL & ABSURD4 ,=1 EV5 TO A GREAT] EXT5T ?AN ! M51 %E BELIEVES ?AT ALL WRONGS CAN BE SET RI<T BY /ATUTE4 ,IT WILL BE A COLD DAY = ,LIB]TY :5 WOMAN TAKES ! RE9S ( P[]4 ,NOT ?AT ,LIB]TY IS 5TIRELY )\T FRI5DS AMONG ! LADIES4 ,9 ! RANKS ( ,LIB]TY'S *AMPIONS !RE >E NOT A FEW G5U9E ,AMAZONS1 :O MAY BE DEP5D$ UPON 9 ALL EM]G5CIES4 ,BUT1 G5]ALLY SPEAK+1 ! FEM99E M9D SEEMS TO HAVE NO CONCEPTION ( FRE$OM OR HUMAN RI<TS1 & BELIEVES ?OR\<LY 9 FIAT MORALITY4 ,:AT DOES ?IS TEA* US8 ,SIMPLY ?AT1 :ILE WOMAN %\LD BE D5I$ NO REAL RI<T1 %E %\LD BE 5TRU/$ ) NO >BITR>Y P[]4 ,GIVE WOMAN EQUALITY ) MAN1 BY ALL MEANS2 BUT DO IT BY TAK+ P[] FROM MAN1 NOT BY GIV+ IT TO WOMAN4 

,PREMIUMS ,= ,NEW ,SUBSCRIB]S4 

,LIB]TY MAKES ! FOLL[+ (F]S TO NEW SUBSCRIB]S ONLY1 & 9 SO DO+ AF=DS !M AN OPPORTUNITY ( PUR*AS+ A CONSID]ABLE LIBR>Y ( /&>D LIT]ATURE AT RATES AT LEA/ FIVE TIMES L[]?AN C\LD BE OBTA9$ ?R\< ! ORD9>Y *ANNELS ( ! BOOKTRADE3-- 

,TO EA* NEW SUBSCRIB] S5D+ US 

,FIFTY ,C5TS1 

! REGUL> SUBSCRIPTION PRICE ( ! PAP]1 WE WILL S5D ,LIB]TY = ONE YE> & A COPY ( ! FIR/ VOLUME ( ,JOHN ,RUSK9'S ,LETT]S TO ,WORKM5 & ,LABOR]S1 5TITL$1 0,=S ,CLAVIG]A40 

,TO EA* NEW SUBSCRIB] S5D+ US 

,ONE ,DOLL>1 

WE WILL S5D ,LIB]TY = ONE YE> & A COPY ( EA* ( ! FOLL[+ WORKS3-- 

,*RI/MAS ,/ORIES3 ,A ,*RI/MAS ,C>OL1 ,! ,*IMES1 ,! ,CRICKET ON ! ,HE>?1 ,! ,BATTLE ( ,LIFE1 ,! ,HAUNT$ ,MAN4 ,BY ,*]LES ,DICK5S4 ,) #af FULL-PAGE ILLU/RATIONS BY ,FR$]ICK ,B>N>D4 ,COMPLETE 9 TWO VOLUMES1 #hVO1 MANILA4 

,=S ,CLAVIG]3 ,LETT]S TO ,WORKM5 & ,LABOR]S4 ,BY ,JOHN ,RUSK91 ,9 TWO VOLUMES1 #dTO1 MANILA4 

,S>TOR ,RES>TUS3 ,! ,LIFE & ,OP9IONS ( ,H]R ,TEUFELSDOCKH4 ,BY ,?OMAS ,C>LYLE4 ,OCTAVO1 MANILA4 

,TO EA* NEW SUBSCRIB] S5D+ US 

,ONE ,DOLL> & A ,HALF1 

WE WILL S5D ,LIB]TY = ONE YE>1 &1 9 ADDITION TO ! WORKS ABOVE M5TION$1 A COPY ( EA* ( ! FOLL[+3-- 

,IDYLS ( ! ,K+4 ,BY ,ALFR$ ,T5NYSON4 ,>RANG$ 9 ! ORD] DESIGN$ BY ! AU?OR4 #dTO1 MANILA4 

,LI<T ( ,ASIA2 OR1 ,! ,GREAT ,R5UNCIATION4 ,BE+ ! ,LIFE & ,TEA*+ ( ,GAUTAMA1 ,PR9CE ( ,9DIA & ,F\ND] ( ,BUDDHISM1 AS TOLD 9 V]SE BY AN ,9DIAN ,BUDDHI/4 ,BY ,$W9 ,>NOLD4 #dTO1 MANILA4 

,MACAULAY'S ,ESSAYS3 ,MILTON1 ,DRYD51 ,BUNYAN1 ,HI/ORY1 ,SAMUEL ,JOHNSON 7TWO ESSAYS71 ,A!NIAN ,ORATORS1 & ,ROB]T ,MONTGOM]Y'S ,POEMS4 ,BY ,T4 ,B4 ,MACAULAY4 #dTO1 MANILA4 

,TO EA* NEW SUBSCRIB] S5D+ US 

,TWO ,DOLL>S1 

WE WILL S5D ,LIB]TY = ONE YE>1 ALL ! WORKS ABOVE M5TION$1 & A COPY ( EA* ( ! FOLL[+3-- 

,LO?AIR4 ,BY ,B4 ,DISRAELI4 ,COMPLETE 9 TWO VOLUMES1 ,OCTAVO1 MANILA4 

,MEMORIES ( ,MY ,EXILE4 ,BY ,LPUIS ,KOSSU?4 ,TRANSLAT$ FROM ! ORIG9AL ,HUNG>IAN BY ,F]5CZ ,JUASZ4 ,COMPLETE 9 TWO VOLUMES1 #dTO1 MANILA4 

,TO CAP ! CLIMAX1 TO EA* NEW SUBSCRIB] S5D+ 

,?REE ,DOLL>S & A ,HALF1 

WE WILL S5D ,LIB]TY = ONE YE>1 ALL ! WORKS ALREADY M5TION$1 & A FULL SET ( ! 

,POPUL> ,HI/ORY ( ,5GL&3 ,A ,HI/ORY ( ,SOCIETY & ,GOV]NM5T FROM ! ,E>LIE/ ,P]IOD TO ,\R ,[N ,TIMES4 ,BY ,*>LES ,KNI<T4 ,COMPLETE 9 ,EI<T VOLUMES4 #dTO1 MANILA4 

,?US WE (F]1 BESIDES AN ANNUAL SUBSCRIPTION TO ?IS PAP]1 A LIBR>Y ( TW5TY /&>D VOLUMES = @s#c4#e4 ,& !SE BOOKS1 REMEMB]1 >E NOT ISSU$ 9 TRA%Y =M1 BUT PR9T$ FROM GOOD TYPE1 ON CLE> :ITE PAP]1 & B\ND 9 F9E PO/AL-C>D MANILA1-- BOOKS AS DURABLE AS ! AV]AGE WORK+MAN CAN AF=D TO [N UNTIL ! DOCTR9ES ( ,LIB]TY %ALL BE REALIZ$1 AFT] :I* HE ALONE WILL BE ABLE TO DRESS HIS FAVORITE AU?ORS 9 GILT LEAVES & MOROCCO COV]S4 

0,A FREE MAN IS ONE :O 5JOYS ! USE ( HIS REASON & HIS FACULTIES2 :O IS NEI!R BL9D$ BY PASSION1 NOT H9D]$ OR DRIV5 BY OPPRESSION1 NOT DECEIV$ BY ]RONE\S OP9IONS40 -- ,PR\DHON4 

,B\ND ,VOLUMES ( ,LIB]TY4 

,WE HAVE = SALE ?REE H&SOMELY-B\ND COPIES ( ! FIR/ VOLUME ( ,LIB]TY4 ,AS ! NUMB] :O DESIRE !M IS L>GE1 WE HAVE DET]M9$1 NOT AS A MATT] ( EQUITY1 BUT AS A MEANS ( VOLUNT>Y TAXATION ( ?OSE BE/ ABLE TO GIVE US A HELP+ H&1 TO AW>D ! VOLUMES TO ! ?REE P]SONS S5D+ 9 ! HI<E/ BIDS = !M PRIOR TO ! NEXT ISSUE ( ! PAP]4 ,AT ?AT TIME ! SUCCESSFUL BIDD]S WILL BE NOTIFI$1 &1 ON RECEIPT ( ! SUMS (F]$1 ! BOOKS WILL BE =W>D$4 

,LIB]TY ! ,MO!R ( ,ORD]4 

,IT IS GRATIFY+ TO BE 9=M$1 AS WE HAVE BE51 BY MANY ( \R PATRONS N[ R5EW+ !IR SUBSCRIPTIONS ?AT !Y HAVE ALREADY COME TO SEE PLA9LY :AT WE >E DRIV+ AT & >E MORE & MORE DEEPLY 9T]E/$ TO FOLL[ US4 

,:5 \R LITTLE %EET WAS FIR/ S5T \T TO DO BATTLE = RE=M WE NATURALLY EXPECT$ TO BE IMM$IATELY CONFRONT$ BY SU* SUP]FICIAL OBJECTIONS AS !SE3 0,Y\ >E SUBV]SIVE ( LAW & ORD]20 0Y\R SY/EM 9VITES COMPLETE SOCIAL *AOS20 0Y\ DE/ROY )\T (F]+ ANY?+ UPON :I* TO BUILD ANEW20 0Y\ (F] NO?+ 9 ! PLACE ( GOV]NM5T20 0Y\ >E ALL SAIL & NO COMPASS10 ETC4 ,( C\RSE NO KE5 /UD5T ( SOCIAL SCI5CE C\LD DESC5D TO SU* UNSCI5TIFIC OBJECTIONS1 BUT A LITTL]E=M %EET LIKE ,LIB]TY HAS NOT *IEFLY TO DEAL ) TRA9$ /UD5TS ( SOCIOLOGY1 BUT ) ! AV]AGE CITIZ5 ( A 0PRACTICAL0 WORLD4 

,NOT A FEW ( \R READ]S1 H[EV]1 >E ALREADY BEG9N+ TO SEE ?AT SO F> FROM BE+ SUBV]SIVE ( LAW & ORD] >E WE ?AT \R MISSION IS REALLY TO E/ABLI% LAW & ORD] 9 ! PLACE ( ! PREVAIL+ SOCIAL *AOS :I* GOES BY ?AT NAME4 ,!RE IS NO SU* FRIVOL\S CAT*-WORD 9 ! AIR TO-DAY TO GULL ! WEAK & UNW>Y AS ?IS CANT+ :9E ( 0LAW & ORD]40 ,LAW6 YES3 BUT :AT LAW8 ,! LAW ( NATURE AS DEVELOP$ \T ( A RATIONAL ANALYSIS ( SOCIAL =CES & BAS$ UPON ! SOV]EIGNTY ( ! 9DIVIDUAL1 OR SOME LAW MANUFACTUR$ = DESIGN+ 5DS BE=E WE W]E BORN & )\T \R CONS5T8 LS LAW A ?+ TO BE 5ACT$ BY ROGUES 9 CAUCUS1 & EXECUT$ BY =CE UPON ! UNWILL+1 OR IS LAW A PR9CIPLE ( NATURE1-- A ?+ ?AT IS1 & ?AT CANNOT BE MADE4 ,AS BRAVE OLD ,LYS&] ,SPOON] SAYS1 IT IS ABSURD TO TALK AB\T 0MAK+0 LAWS4 ,LAWS >E1 & ! ONLY RI<T ( A HUMAN BE+ IS TO SE>* AFT] !M & OBEY !M = HIMSELF1 LEAV+ O!RS TO DO ! SAME1 OR CONTR>YWISE1 AT !IR [N CO/4 

,& ORD]1 TOO1-- ALL REV]5CE = ORD]6 ,BUT :OSE ORD]8 ,IS IT ! ORD] ( NATURE1 MEAN+ ! H>MONY BEGOTT5 ( A TRUE KN[L$GE ( SOCIAL =CES & !IR HEAL?Y COORD9ATION 9 PRACTICAL LIFE1 OR IS IT ! ORD] CONCOCT$ BY W>D POLITICIANS )9 WALLS REEK+ ) BRIB]Y & OP5H&$ CORRUPTION 9 ! 9T]E/ ( SOCIAL SLAVE-MA/]S8 ,ORD] MEANS NO?+ UNTIL Y\ 9/ITUTE A CORRECT PHILOSOPHICAL /&>D ( ORD]4 ,! ?+ N[ CALL$ ORD] DOES NOT EV5 PROTECT LIFE2 WITNESS ! PAUP] RATE 9 ,GREAT ,BRITA91 & ALL ! MURD]\S RESULTS ( CAPITAL'S SWAY OV] LABOR4 ,IF ! PREVAIL+ ORD] DOES PROTECT PROP]TY1 IT SIMPLY PROTECTS ROBB]Y2 IT DOES NOT PROTECT HONE/ POSSESSION ( ! FRUITS ( LABOR BY ?OSE :O CREATE IT1 BUT RA!RDESPOILS PRODUC]S ( :AT !Y PRODUCE1 :I* IS VIRTUALLY ! :OLE S*EME ( PROP]TY4 

,N[1 SO F> FROM NOT (F]+ ANY?+ 9 ! PLACE ( :AT IS N[ FALSELY CALL$ GOV]NM5T1 WE HAVE SOME?+ V]Y TANGIBLE TO (F]1-- SOME?+ V]Y RATIONAL1 PRACTICAL1 & EASY ( APPLICATION4 ,WE (F] COOP]ATION4 ,WE (F] RECIPROCITY4 ,WE (F] ASSOCIATIVE COMB9ATION4 ,WE (F] NON-COMPULSIVE ORGANIZATION4 ,WE (F] EV]Y POSSIBLE ME?OD ( VOLUNT>Y SOCIAL UNION BY :I* M5 & WOM5 MAY ACT TOGE!R = ! FUR!RANCE ( WELL-BE+4 ,9 %ORT1 WE (F] VOLUNT>Y SCI5TIFIC SOCIALISM 9 ! PLACE ( ! PRES5T COMPULSORY UNSCI5TIFIC ORGANIZATION :I* *>ACT]IZES ! ,/ATE & ALL ITS RAMIFICATIONS4 

,IS NOT ?IS GOV]NM5T 9 ITS ONLY RATIONAL S5SE8 ,IF ?IS BE *AOS1 !N !RE IS NO NATURAL LAW4 ,IF M5 & WOM5 CAN BE GOV]N$ UND] >BITR>Y COMPULSION1 & CANNOT BE GOV]N$ UND] ! V]Y LAW ( !IR [N BE+1 !N ! UNIV]SE IS A FAILURE1 & A TYPE ( RE=M] ABOVE ! LEVEL ( ! ,CZ> ( ,RUSSIA & ,JOHN ,KELLY HAS LITTLE LEFT TO LIVE =4 

,!RE >E ?REE PREVAIL+ SOCIAL DRIFTS N[ AT WORK4 ,! FIR/ IS ! ,/ATE1 OR ! PRES5T ORD] ( POLITICAL GOV]NM5T1 :OSE SYNONYM IS USURPATION4 ,! SECOND IS SOCIALISM1-- ?AT PHASE ( IT N[ MANIFE/ 9 ! ,SOCIAL ,DEMOCRACY ( ,EUROPE & :I* IS ONLY A MODIFICATION ( ! ,/ATE4 ,! ?IRD IS REVOLUTION>Y SOCIALISM1 & TO ?AT PHASE ,LIB]TY IS ALLI$4 ,! REVOLUTION>Y SOCIALI/1 LIKE ! ORD9>Y SOCIALI/1 BELIEVES 9 ! SUB/ITUTION ( 9TEGRAL ORGANIZATION = ! OLD POLITICAL ORGANIZATION1 ) ?IS DI/9CTION 7& IT IS AN IRRECONCILABLE ONE71-- NAMELY1 ?AT ! OLD ORD] MU/ NOT BE REMODEL$1 BUT UTT]LY OV]?R[N & DISC>D$1 & ?AT 9 ALL SUBSEQU5T SOCIAL COOP]ATION NO MANN] ( ORGANIZATION OR COMB9ATION :ATSOEV] %ALL BE B9D+ UPON ANY 9DIVIDUAL )\T HIS CONS5T4 ,REVOLUTION>Y SOCIALISM D5IES ! RI<T ( A MAJORITY TO CO]CE A M9ORITY4 ,IT 9SI/S UPON ! ABSOLUTE SOV]EIGNTY ( EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL4 ,ITS SYNONYM IS ,LIB]TY4 

,BUT IT HAS A SY/EM AS RATIONAL1 JU/1 & POT5T AS NATURE4 ,IT AIMS AT TRUE LAW & ORD]4 ,IT IS CON/RUCTIVE AT EV]Y PO9T :]E IT IS DE/RUCTIVE4 ,IT IS ! V]Y ANTIPODE ( *AOS4 ,IT IS AN 9DEFATIGABLE BUILD]4 ,FOLL[ US PATI5TLY1 FRI5DS1 & \R LI<T WILL BEG9 TO REVEAL TO Y\ ! *AOS EXI/+ 9 ! HI< & HOLY PLACES :]E Y\ HAVE BE5 FALSELY $UCAT$ TO BELIEVE 9 A QUACK ,GOD1 BOGUS GOV]NM5T1 UNLAWFUL LAW1 & MASK$ DISORD]4 

0,DOOTY40 

,! ,NEW ,YORK PAP]S REPORT ?AT ! POLICEMAN 9 *>GE ( ,C5TRAL ,P>K LOOK UPON ! RAGG$ UR*9S :O FREQU5T HAT PUBLIC GR\ND AS 0SUSPICI\S *>ACT]S10 & 9 NUM]\S 9/ANCES HAVE PROCE$$ TO 0CLUB !M \T10 :ILE O!R *ILDR51 WELL DRESS$1 >E LEFT TO ROMP AT PLEASURE4 ,&1 :5 !SE GU>DIANS ( ! PUBLIC GOOD HAVE BE5 REMON/RAT$ )1 !Y HAVE EI!R RES5T$ ) 9DIGNATION ! 0IMPUD5T 9T]F]5CE ( A M]E CIVILIAN10 OR HAVE PROTE/$ ?AT !Y W]E 0ONLY DO+ !IR DOOTY40 

',TIS BUT A SAMPLE ( ! SOLEMN F>CE BE+ DAILY 5ACT$ ?R\<\T ! SO-CALL$ CIVILIZ$ WORLD4 

,ALL ! TYRANTS1 GREAT & SMALL1 >E 0ONLY DO+ !IR DOOTY40 

,& :AT IS REM>KABLE 9 IT ALL IS ?AT SO MANY O!RWISE 9TELLIG5T PEOPLE >E RE/+ UND] ! DELUSION ?AT ! PRES]VATION ( NE$FUL ORD] DEP5DS ON !IR ADHESION TO ?IS OLD TYRANNIZ+ SY/EM4 ,HALF ASLEEP1 !Y 9DULGE 9 ! DREAM ?AT1 !Y >E 0ONLY DO+ !IR DOOTY40 

,WE >E1 H[EV]1 CONV9C$ ?AT ! GREAT MASS ( !M >E1 AT ! PRES5T TIME1 NOT )\T A SUSPICION1 AT LEA/1 ?AT SOME?+ IS RADICALLY WRONG4 ,!Y >E /RIK+ \T 9 MANY DIRECTIONS1 HOP+1 AS WE SUPPOSE1 TO HIT ! EVIL 9 ! EYE4 

,= 9/ANCE1 !RE IS JU/ N[ 9 ?IS C\NTRY A GREAT \TCRY AGA9/ 0BOSS RULE40 ,EV]YBODY APPE>S TO BE D[N ON IT4 ,! ,CONKL+S & ! ,CAM]ONS >E BE+ SWEPT AWAY 9 ! NAME ( \TRAG$ PEOPLE :O >E CLAMOR\S = !IR FRE$OM4 ,!Y WILL NOT BE DICTAT$ TO4 ,!Y WANT FRE$OM ( OP9ION & FRE$OM ( ACTION4 ,ALL ( :I* IS V]Y COMM5DABLE4 ,! SPIRIT ( IT IS EXCELL5T4 

,BUT ! QUE/ION IS1 ,WILL IT GO F> 5\< & /RIKE DEEP 5\<8 ,WILL IT COV] OV] & TAKE 9 ALL ! BOSSES8 ,WILL IT MEAN TO BE ?OR\<8 ,WILL IT E/ABLI% FRE$OM 9 REALITY1 OR WILL IT ONLY DAILY ALONG1 SUPPRESS+ !SE COMP>ATIVELY 9(F5SIVE P>TY BOSSES1 :ILE ! VA/ SY/EM ( GOV]NM5TAL BOSS+ IS TO RUN ON 9DEF9ITELY8 

,WE REALIZE ! SL[ PACE AT :I* ! WORLD MOVES1 & SO >E NOT SANGU9E ?AT ?IS 9CIPI5T REBELLION AGA9/ ! TYRANN\S RULE ( 0BOSSES 0 WILL RIP5 9TO AN IMM$IATE & FRUITFUL H>VE/4 ,BUT1 AS WE HAVE SAID1 ! SPIRIT ( IT IS GOOD1 & IT AF=DS US ! OPPORTUNITY TO MEET !SE FRE$OM-%RIEK+ REBELS ON !IR [N GR\ND1 :]E WE %ALL /RIVE TO %[ !M ?AT1 IF !Y MEAN TO /EADILY MA9TA9 IT1 !Y MU/ CONQU] MORE4 ,AS IT IS1 !Y HAVE ONLY RUN \T = A LITTLE SKIRMI%4 ,! GREAT BATTLE IS /ILL IMP5D+4 

,!RE=E1 TO ! 5EMIES ( 0BOSS RULE0 WE SAY3 ,:AT ELSE HAVE WE EV]Y:]E E/ABLI%$ FROM PRESID5T D[N TO POLICEMAN8 ,IF IT BE NOT 0BOSS RULE10 :AT IS IT8 ,:5 Y\ COME S]I\SLY TO POND] ?IS QUE/ION1 WE DECL>E TO Y\ ?AT Y\ WILL SEE ?AT CUR 5TIRE GOV]NM5TAL SY/EM IS A SY/EM ( IRRESPONSIBLE BOSS+4 ,SOMETIMES ?IS BOSS IS ONE 9DIVIDUAL1 & SOMETIMES MANY4 ,IT IS :OEV] OR :ATEV] IS 9 P[]4 ,N[ IT IS ! ,REPUBLICAN P>TY ?AT IS BOSS+ US4 ,:5 WE GET TO ! PO9T BEYOND :I* 5DURANCE IS IMPOSSIBLE1 :AT %ALL WE DO8 ,:Y1 *ANGE BOSSES1-- IF WE >E ABLE4 ,= A ,REPUBLICAN WE %ALL TRY A ,DEMOCRAT2 & SO1 SW++ BACK & =?1 GET MATT]S EAS$ UP MU* AS WE CAN4 

,BUT ALWAYS A 0BOSS10 :O1 UND] ! SPECI\S BUT EFFECTIVE PLEA1 ( DO+ HIS 0DOOTY10 IS 5TITL$ TO DEFY & DRIVE US LIKE SO MANY DUMB %EEP1 FIT ONLY TO BE FLEEC$4 ,:AT A SC&AL\S 9TIMATION ( P[] WAS ?AT 9DULG$ 9 BY ! JUDGE 9 ! ,/> ,R\TE CASES1 :5 HE SAID TO ! JURY ?AT HE MI<T YET DECIDE TO %UT !M UP ON BREAD & WAT]1 & SO =CE !M 9TO A V]DICT4 ,A JURY ?US ASSAIL$1 HAD ITS MEMB]S BE5 9 ANY DEGREE ALIVE TO !IR RI<TS AS FREEM51 W\LD HAVE 9/ANTLY DECL9$ FUR!R S]VICE4 ,SU* A ?REAT %\LD ONLY HAVE BE5 SCORN$ & DEFI$4 ,BUT NO2 ! JUDGE C\LD CLAIM ?AT HE1 UND] ? COMMON LAW1 WAS 0ONLY DO+ HIS DOOTY40 ,& IT WAS ! TRADITIONAL 0DOOTY0 ( ! JURY IGNOBLY TO SUBMIT4 

,:AT IS ! REM$Y8 

,! REM$Y IS = ! PEOPLE TO REFUSE AS 9DIVIDUALS TO DELEGATE A P[] :I* CANNOT AT ONCE BE CONFRONT$ BY EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL 9T]E/$1 & REVOK$4 ,!RE IS1 9 ONE S5SE1 PL5TY ( BOSS+ TO BE DONE 9 ?IS WORLD1 BUT NOT AGA9/ ! WILL OR DESIRE ( ANY ! HUMBLE/ P]SON4 ,P]SONAL GOV]NM5T IS ! ONLY TRUE GOV]NM5T1 BUT ! DIFF]5CE BETWE5 A FREE PEOPLE1 SO GOV]N$1 & A SLAVE PEOPLE GOV]N$1 IS ?AT ! GOV]NM5T 9/ITUT$ BY ! =M] PROCE$S ONLY BY ! CON/ANT CONS5T ( ALL 9T]E/$1 :ILE ! LATT] IS C>RI$ ON 9 ! NAME EI!R ( ONE ABSOLUTE MON>*1 OR1 AS WE ( ,AM]ICA SAY1 9 ! NAME ( 0! MAJORITY10 :E!R ?OSE :O >E GOV]N$ CONS5T OR NOT4 ,WE HAVE AN IDEA 9 ?IS C\NTRY ?AT ! MAJORITY CAN DO ,LIB]TY NO WRONG4 ,LAWS A K+ MI<T PROCLAIM 9 ! 9T]E/ ( TYRANNY BECOME1 WE SEEM TO ?9K1 NOT TYRANNICAL IF !Y >E ONLY 5ACT$ 9 DUE PROCESS ( \R MAJORITY LEGISLATION4 ,! ?+ DONE DOES NOT SO MU* SIGNIFY ) US4 ,WE P9 \R SALVATION TO A =M ( DO+ ,\R 0BALLOT /UFF+0 ,C>LYLE RO>$ AT?R[S A SANCTITY OV] EV]Y K9D ( 9IQUITY4 ,WE LOSE SI<T ( ! CRIME 5ACT$1 SEE+ ONLY ?AT IT WAS GR\ND \T BY \R ,REPUBLICAN =MULA1 & ?AT !RE IS A P>TY 9 ! C\NTRY /RONG 5\< TO 5=CE IT4 ,C>LYLE WAS = NE>] RI<T :5 HE LU/ILY CALL$ = ! 0,ABLE-MAN10 -- ! MAN ) S5SE 5\< ALWAYS TO KN[ :AT IS ! RI<T ?+ TO DO1 & B5T1 ONLY ON HONE/LY DO+ IT1 LET ! PEOPLE GIVE ?ANKS OR H[L4 

,H]E >E ?REE CONCEPTIONS3 

#a4 ,! RI<T ?+ )\T REG>D TO ME?OD4 
#b4 ,! ME?OD AT ALL HAZ>D )\T REG>D TO ! ?+ DONE4 
#c4 ,! ME?OD & ! ?+ DONE 9SEP>ABLY CONNECT$4 

,! FIR/ MAY SUMM>IZE ! DOCTR9E ( ! ,C>LYLE S*OOL2 ! SECOND IS \R ,REPUBLICAN DOGMA2 ! ?IRD IS ! GOSPEL ( ,LIB]TY4 

,AS TO ! FIR/1 :ILE WE UNHESITAT+LY DECL>E IT TO BE 9F9ITELY BETT] ?AN ! SECOND1 IT IS SIMPLY A QUE/ION AS TO :E!R IT IS TO ! ADVANTAGE ( ! PEOPLE TO HAVE !IR WORK DONE = !M IRRESPECTIVE ( !IR WI% OR CONS5T1 OR TO HAVE IT DONE BY !IR FREE CONS5T & E>NE/ DESIRE4 ,WAIV+ H]O ! QUE/ION ( RI<T1 WE SIMPLY RAISE ! TE/ ( ADVANTAGE4 ,WE ASK1 IS IT BETT] = ! PEOPLE TO HAVE ! RI<T ?+ DONE BY DESPOTISM OR BY FRE$OM8 ,& \R RESPONSE SIMPLY IS ?AT IT MU/ C]TA9LY BE BE/ = ! PEOPLE TO HAVE EX]CISE 9 ! DO+ ( ! RI<T ?+ = !MSELVES4 ,?IS MU/ BE TRUE1 IF GR[? SELF-RELIANCE1 & 9DIVIDUAL CAPACITY >E ALONE ATTA9ABLE ?R\< 9DIVIDUAL EXP]I5CE & CULTURE4 

,!RE=E1 ,LIB]TY HOLDS /EADFA/LY TO ! ME?OD( FRE$OM4 ,! RI<T ?+1 9 FACT1 CAN ONLY BE DONE BY ?AT ME?OD4 ,:ATEV] DESPOTISM DOES HAS A FALSE F\NDATION4 ,9 ! 5D IT FAILS = WANT ( SUPPORT4 ,IT HAS NO BASIS 9 ! *>ACT] ( ! PEOPLE4 ,IT HAS NOT GR[N \T ( !M1 IS NOT A P>T ( !M2 !Y DO NOT UND]/& OR APPRECIATE IT4 ,IT FAILS1 & MU/ ONE DAY GIVE PLACE TO :AT ! PEOPLE FREELY BUILD4 ,NOT ?AT FRE$OM MAKES NO MI/AKES4 ,NO ONE AFFIRMS ?IS4 ,BUT ! MI/AKES ( FRE$OM >E ITS $UCATION & ITS DISCIPL9E4 ,BY ITS MI/AKES1 AS BY ITS SUCCESSES1 ! PEOPLE GR[ 9 /R5G? & IMPROVE 9 CAPABLE ACTION4 

,H5CE ,LIB]TY /&S NOT = RESULT ALONE1 AS ?IS IS IMPOSSIBLE4 ,! TRUE RESULT IS OBTA9ABLE ONLY BY ! TRUE ME?OD4 

,! IDIOTIC DELUSION TO :I* ?IS C\NTRY IS = ! TIME BE+ W$D$1-- ?AT ( /ICK+ TO ! =MULA ( MAJORITY RULE1 LET ! RESULT BE :AT IT MAY -- IS ! MO/ IGNOBLE ?+ DONE 9 FRE$OM'S NAME ?AT ! SUN %9ES UPON4 ,= IT PLACES ,RI<T1 ,JU/ICE1 ,9DIVIDUAL OR ,P]SONAL ,FRE$OM 9 ! BACKGR\ND4 ,UND] ITS SWAY ! MO/ DEVILI% ?+S >E NOT ONLY POSSIBLE1 BUT CAN BE BOL/]$ UP & MADE RESPECTABLE4 ,:5 !Y BECOME 0! LAW10 WE 5%R9E !M 9 A SACR$ CIRCLE )9 :I* NO ONE MAY SETFOOT BUT AT HIS P]IL4 

,%IFT & EXPLA9 ! FACTS AS Y\ MAY1 ! MO/ CONSPICU\S FACT ( ALL REMA9S1-- NAMELY1 ?AT ! :OLE SY/EM IS AN >BITR>Y ONE1 F\ND$ NOT 9 FREE *OICE1 BUT RELY+ ON =CE1 :I* GOOD & HONE/ CITIZ5S = ! MO/ P>T SUPPORT ONLY BECAUSE !Y HAVE AN 9H]IT$ 9/9CT ?AT !Y >E !REBY DO+ !IR DUTY4 ,!Y WILL ANY3 0,C]TA9LY1 WE >E = LIB]TY4 ,BUT1 !N1 SOCIETY NE$S SOME SAFEGU>DS1 & ! WOR/ GOV]NM5T IS BETT] ?AN NO GOV]NM5T40 ,IT IS !IR DUTY1 !RE=E1 TO MA9TA9! GOV]NM5T1 :ATEV] ?AT GOV]NM5T MAY BE4 

,N[1 WE SUGGE/ TO ALL SU* P]SONS ?AT1 IF !Y >E S]I\SLY 9 LOVE ) ,LIB]TY1 IT IS :OLLY WRONG 9 !N TO CONTRIBUTE !IR 9FLU5CE & !IR MEANS TO P]PETUATE ORGANIZATIONS :OSE V]Y 9CEPTION IS A BL[ AIM$ DIRECTLY AT ! SUPPRESSION ( ,LIB]TY4 ,SOCIETY -- ?AT IS1 ! 9DIVIDUALS COMPOS+ SOCIETY -- MU/1 9DE$1 HAVE 0 SAFEGU>DS40 ,BUT ! V]Y FIR/ /EP ( Y\R DESPOTIC ORGANIZATION IS TO TE> D[N ALL NATURAL SAFEGU>DS & PLACE ! 9DIVIDUAL :OLLY AT ! M]CY ( SOME 9/ITUT$ 0BOSS40 ,9 ,REPUBLICAN ,AM]ICA1 AS 9 ,AUTOCRATIC ,RUSSIA1 ?AT IS ! 9EVITABLE FIR/ /EP 9 :AT IS CALL$ GOV]NM5TALORGANIZATION4 ,IT IS TO E/ABLI% A MA*9E RULE2 & AL?\<1 G5TLEM51 Y\ MAY PR(ESS TO PLAY ?AT MA*9E 9 BEHALF ( ,LIB]TY & GOOD ORD]1 Y\ CAN NOT GIVE TO IT ONE SOLIT>Y MOTION )\T DEFY+ ,LIB]TY & R5D]+ GOOD ORD] IMPOSSIBLE4 

,GRANT1 IF Y\ PLEASE1 ?AT ! RUNN+ ( SU* A MA*9E HAS 9 PA/ TIMES BE5 A NECESSITY2 GRANT1 EV51 ?AT = SOME TIME YET = V>I\S CAUSES IT WILL NECESS>ILY BE KEPT 9 MOTION3 WE >E NOT DISCUSS+ ?AT PO9T4 ,BUT1 WE >E TALK+ TO Y\ :O HAVE ADVANC$ = 5\< 9TO ! LI<T ( ,LIB]TY TO SEE ?AT ! 0MA*9E0 9 POLITICS & 0BOSS RULE0 >E ,LIB]TY'S 5EMIES1 TO Y\ :O W\LD E>NE/LY DO SOME:AT TO DELIV] ! C\NTRY FROM ALL MANN] ( OPPRESSIONS4 ,:AT \<T Y\ TO DO TO BE CONSI/5T ) Y\R ASPIRATIONS8 

,%ALL WE ANSW] = Y\8 ,!N1 WE WILL SAY3 ,LEAVE ! ORGANIZATION ( DESPOTISM1 & TURN TO ! ORGANIZATION ( FRE$OM4 

,LIB]TY ASKS Y\ TO SEE Y\R DUTY 9 ?AT DIRECTION4 ,GIVE NO MORE SUPPORT TO BOSSES1 L[ OR HI<1 :O >E 0ONLY DO+ !IR DOOTY0 :5 !Y 9VADE EV]Y P]SONAL RI<T A FREE PEOPLE MAY CLAIM4 

,UND] ! OLD SY/EM ! PEOPLE SURR5D] ALL RI<TS1 !IR :OLE FRE$OM1 9TO ! H&S ( GOV]NM5TAL (FICIALS1 & RECEIVE ALL !Y GET 9 RETURN ?AT BE>S ! SEMBLANCE ( FRE$OM AS SOME?+ GRANT$ TO !M4 ,WE KN[ WELL 5\< & DO NOT DISPUTE ?AT 9 MOD]N TIMES & 9 ?IS C\NTRY MU* IS 0GRANT$40 ,BUT :AT IS 0GRANT$0 MAY ALSO BE )HELD IF ! RUL+ 0BOSS0 HAS ! DISPOSITION & ! P[]4 ,& MU* IS )HELD1 EV5 H]E1 AS IT IS4 ,EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL MAY BE SAID TO HAVE A C]TA9 L5G? ( ROPE1 BUT HE IS FA/5$ !RETO2 &1 :5 ! 0BOSS0 REQUIRES EI!R HIS P]SON OR HIS PROP]TY1 HE IS HAUL$ 91 & MU/ SURR5D] BO?1-- & ?AT NOT BECAUSE HE IS A CRIM9AL *>G$ ) AN (F5SE1 BUT BECAUSE ! 0P[]S ?AT BE10 TO :OM HE IS 9 0DOOTY0 B\ND TO SUBMIT1 HAVE SO WILL$ IT4 

,BUT UND] ! NEW SY/EM1 UND] ! ORGANIZATIONS FRE$OM %ALL 9V5T & MA9TA91 NO?+ IS SURR5D]$1 ALL RI<TS >E RES]V$1 & ,LIB]TY TO MA9TA9 ITSELF DOES NOT 9VADE ITSELF4 ,A SOCIETY SO CON/RUCT$1 ACT+ NOT UND] ! RULE ( =CE1 BUT /IMULAT$ BY ! 9TELLIG5T APPRECIATION BY ALL ITS MEMB]S ( !IR COMMON 9T]E/S1 FURNI%ES ! ONLY EXAMPLE ( GOOD ORD]1 TRUE PROSP]ITY1 & 5DUR+ PEACE :I* IT IS POSSIBLE TO CONCEIVE4 

,9 ITS REALM WILL BE F\ND NO (FICIALS IGNORANTLY & 9HUMANLY 0DO+ !IR DOOTY40 0,DOOTY0 WILL BECOME DUTY1 & DUTY BE TRANSFIGUR$ 9TO ,LOVE4 

0,UNHAPPY ,IREL&40 

,WE MI<T AS WELL SPEAK PLA9LY & SAY ?AT ! ,IRI% ,L& ,LEAGUE1 ( ONCE GLORI\S PROMISE1 HAS DEG5]AT$ 9TO A MIS]ABLE1 HUMILIAT+ F>CE1 & :AT !RE IS LEFT ( IT IS NOT WOR? HOLD+ A SECOND-CLASS ,IRI% WAKE OV]4 ,WE REGRET EXCE$+LY TO SAY?IS1 = AT ONE TIME1 :ILE ! MAMMO? NO-R5T /RIKE WAS 9 FULL BLA/1 ,IREL& SEEM$ DE/9$ TO SCORE A VICTORY 9 MOD]N SOCIAL ME?ODS :I* W\LD HAVE REVOLUTIONIZ$ RE=M & /RUCK ) SURE DEA? L&LORDISM & POLITICS AT ONE BL[4 

,! CAUSE ( ,IREL&'S LAM5TABLE DEFEAT MAY BE PLA9LY TRAC$ TO A FEW C[>DLY NUISANCES :O HAVE FIGUR$ AS 0LEAD]S40 ,! FIR/ ( !SE IS ,GOD1 ,PATRICK ,=D'S MAN1 :O AS USUAL HAS GONE OV] TO ! HEAVIE/ BATTALIONS & LEFT ! POOR ,IRI% TO WRE/LE ON 9 ! TOILS ( ! L&LORDS & ?AT >MY ( BLOOD-SUCK+ PRIE/S :O1 AL?\< ! ,IRI% DO NOT LIKE TO BE TOLD ( IT1 >E ! BOTTOM 5EMIES ( ,IREL&4 

,! SECOND NUISANCE1 NOT DIV9E BUT HUMAN1 IS ,*>LES ,/EW>T ,P>NELL1 ! DI/+UI%$ P>LIAM5T>IAN ( ,KILMA9HAM-COMPACT NOTORIETY4 ,A MORE CONTEMPTIBLE PIECE ( POLITICAL SMALL W>E NEV] SOLD \T A CONFID+ NATION ( POOR1 \TRAG$1 MAN-WOR%IP+ DUPES4 

,! ?IRD NUISANCE IS ,MI*AEL ,DAVITT4 ,?IS ONCE BRAVE ,AL>IO ( ! CAUSE1 :O S5T T]ROR TO ! OPPRESSOR BY DECL>+ ALL R5T TO BE AN IMMORAL TAX1 PROVES TO BE MADE ( SU* S(T /UFF ?AT ALL HIS MORAL & M5TAL /AM9A CAN BE WIP$ \T BETWE5 ! GOOD CLO? & RESPECTABILITY ( ,P>NELL & ! 9FANTILE SOPHI/RY ( ,H5RY ,GEORGE4 

,!RE >E MANY MORE NUISAUCES ON ! /AGE ( ?IS MELAN*OLY ,IRI% F>CE1 BUT ! PO9T :I* WE WI% TO GET AT IS ?AT !RE IS LITTLE HOPE = ,IREL& UNTIL H] PEOPLE BECOME SO F> 5LI<T5$ ?AT !Y CAN KEEP ,GOD & ! PRIE/S \T ( RE=M1 & LE>N TO /OP ! MAN-WOR%IP ( LEAD]S4 ,GOD IS A POLITICIAN :O 9V>IABLY GOES BACK ON ! PEOPLE1 & ! PRIE/S >E FAT VULTURES :O LIVE ON ! SUCCESS ( ! ,/ATE & ALL IT PORT5DS = DESPOTISM4 

,:5 ! ,IRI% PEOPLE GET SO F> EMANCIPAT$ ?AT !Y WILL /OP RU%+ S]VILELY ) !IR P5NIES1 N[ AS ,P>NELL M51 N[ AS ,DAVITT M51 & LE>N TO BE 9DEP5D5T1 SELF-RELIANT 9DIVIDUALS1 NO SU* RI<TE\S MOVE AS ! MI<TY NO-R5T RESOLVE CAN BE SUCCESSFULLY MISGUID$ TO ITS RU9 BY 9DIVIDUAL CORRUPTION1 C[>DICE1 OR /UPIDITY4 

,A ,RELIGION ( ,HYPOCRISY & ,B>B>ISM4 

,FROM ! ,>*BI%OP ( ,YORK'S LETT] TO ! ,BI%OPS ( HIS DIOCESE4 

,AN>*Y 9 ,EGYPT MEANT DANG] TO ?AT WIDE ,EMPIRE :I* WE HAVE RECEIV$ AS A TRU/1 & :I* WE MAY NOT AB&ON2 & \R W> AGA9/ AN>*Y WAS AN 9EVITABLE W>4 ,?R\< ,GOD'S GREAT GOODNESS ! /RUGGLE ( A FEW H\RS HAS SCATT]$ ! REBELS1 HAS MADE ORD] & FRE$OM POSSIBLE 9 ,EGYPT1 HAS RESCU$ ?AT C\NTRY FROM ! IMP5D+ LOSS ( NEXT YE>'S CROPS1 & HAS SO PREV5T$ ITS RU94 ,M\RN+ AS WE DO ?OSE :O HAVE FALL5 = !IR C\NTRY1 WE >E ?ANKFUL ?AT ! SKILLFUL DISPOSITIONS ( \R COMM&] HAVE SAV$ MANY LIVES1 & HAVE PRES]V$ A GREAT CITY FROM IRREP>ABLE RAVAGES4 ,= !SE M]CIES1 AS = MANY O!RS V\*SAF$ TO US BY ! ,MO/ ,HI<1 WE [E ,HIM ?ANKS & PRAISE4 ,AT ! REQUE/ ( ! ,>*BI%OP ( ,CANT]BURY ,I 9VITE Y\ TO DIRECT ?AT NEXT ,SUNDAY %ALL BE OBS]V$ AS A DAY ( ?ANKSGIV+ 9 ALL *UR*ES & *APELS 9 \R DIOCESE4 

,FROM ! CABLE DISPAT*ES TO ! DAILY NEWSPAP]S4 

,! ,CAIRO CORRESPOND5T ( ! ,COLOGNE ,GAZETTE DECL>ES ?AT ! ,EGYPTIAN W\ND$ W]E MURD]$ BY ! ,BRITI% 9 ! TR5*ES AT ,TEL-EL-,KEBIR1 LONG AFT] ALL RESI/ANCE HAD CEAS$4 

,A LETT] FROM A NONCOMMISSION$ (FIC] ( ! #d#bD REGIM5T1 PUBLI%$ 9 ! ,LONDON ,TIMES1 SAYS ! ORD]S W]E TO SP>E NONE ( ! 5EMY1 & TO BAYONET EV]Y ONE ( !M1 AS !Y W\LD %OOT ! SOLDI]S TREA*]\SLY IF ! LATT] PASS$ !M4 

,LAW & ,AU?ORITY4 

,I,V4 

.<,TRANSLAT$ FROM0 ,LE ,REVOLTE40.> 

,IF WE CONSID] ! MILLIONS ( LAWS ?AT GOV]N HUMANITY1 WE SEE AT ONCE ?AT !Y MAY BE SUBDIVID$ 9TO ?REE GREAT CATEGORIES3 PROTECTION ( PROP]TY1 PROTECTION ( P]SONS1 PROTECTION ( ! GOV]NM5T4 ,&1 9 ANALYZ+ !SE ?REE CATEGORIES1 WE >RIVE1 9 REG>D TO EA* ( !M1 AT ?IS LOGICAL & NECESS>Y CONCLUSION3 ,USELESSNESS & P]NICI\SNESS ( ! ,LAW4 

,AS = ! PROTECTION ( PROP]TY1 SOCIALI/S KN[ :AT ?AT IS4 ,! LAWS ON PROP]TY >E NOT MADE TO GU>ANTEE TO ! 9DIVIDUAL OR TO SOCIETY ! 5JOYM5T ( ! PRODUCTS ( !IR LABOR4 ,!Y >E MADE1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 TO /RIP ! PRODUC] ( A PORTION ( :AT HE PRODUCES & TO ASSURE TO A FEW ! PORTION ?US /RIPP$ FROM ! PRODUC]S OR FROM ! 5TIRE SOCIETY4 ,:5 ! LAW E/ABLI%ES ! RI<T ( ,MR4 ,SO-&-SO TO A H\SE1 = EXAMPLE1 IT E/ABLI%ES HIS RI<T1 NOT TO A COTTAGE :I* HE HAS BUILT HIMSELF1 OR TO A H\SE :I* HE HAS ]ECT$ ) ! AID ( A FEW FRI5DS2 NO ONE W\LD HAVE DISPUT$ ?IS RI<T IF SU* HAD BE5 ! CASE4 ,! LAW1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 E/ABLI%ES HIS RI<T TO A H\SE :I* IS NOT ! PRODUCT ( HIS LABOR1 FIR/1 BECAUSE HE HAS HAD IT BUILT BY O!RS TO :OM HE HAS NOT PAID ! FULL VALUE ( !IR LABOR1 &1 SECOND1 BECAUSE ! H\SE REPRES5TS A SOCIAL VALUE :I* HE C\LD NOT HAVE PRODUC$ HIMSELF3 ! LAW E/ABLI%ES HIS RI<T TO A PORTION ( ?AT :I* BELONGS TO EV]YBODY & TO NOBODY 9 P>TICUL>4 ,! SAME H\SE1 BUILT 9 ! 9T]IOR ( ,SILI]IA1 W\LD NOT HAVE ! VALUE ?AT IT HAS 9 A GREAT CITY1 & ! LATT] VALUE RESULTS1 AS WE KN[1 FROM ! LABOR ( FIFTY G5]ATIONS :O BUILT ! CITY1 ADORN$ IT1 PROVID$ IT ) WAT] & GAS1 F9E /REETS1 UNIV]SITIES1 !AT]S & W>EH\SES1 & RAILROADS & HI<WAYS RADIAT+ FROM IT 9 ALL DIRECTIONS4 ,9 RECOGNIZ+1 !N1 ! RI<T ( ,MR4 ,SO-&-SO TO A H\SE 9 ,P>IS1 ,LONDON1 ,R\51 @&C41 ! LAW APPROPRIATES TO HIM -- UNJU/LY -- A C]TA9 PORTION ( ! PRODUCTS ( ! LABOR ( 5TIRE HUMANITY4 ,& IT IS JU/ BECAUSE ?IS APPROPRIATION IS A CRY+ 9JU/ICE 7ALL O!R =MS ( PROP]TY HAVE ! SAME *>ACT]7 ?AT A :OLE >S5AL ( LAWS & A :OLE >MY ( SOLDI]S1 POLICEM51 & JUDGES >E NECESS>Y TO MA9TA9 IT AGA9/ COMMON S5SE & ! S5TIM5T ( JU/ICE 9H]5T 9 HUMANITY4 

,WELL1 HALF ( \R LAWS -- ! CIVIL CODES ( EV]Y C\NTRY -- HAVE NO O!R OBJECT ?AN ?AT ( MA9TA9+ ?IS APPROPRIATION1 ?IS MONOPOLY1 = ! B5EFIT ( A FEW AGA9/ 5TIRE HUMANITY4 ,?REE-F\R?S ( ! CASES PASS$ UPON BY ! C\RTS >E ONLY QU>RELS >IS+ BETWE5 MONOPOLI/S1-- TWO ROBB]S DISPUT+ OV] !IR PLUND]4 ,& NO SMALL PORTION ( \R CRIM9AL LAWS HAVE ALSO ! SAME OBJECT1 !IR PURPOSE BE+ TO KEEP ! LABOR] SUBORD9ATE TO ! EMPLOY] 9 ORD] TO SECURE TO ! LATT] ! EXPLOITATION ( ! =M]4 

,AS = GU>ANTEE+ TO ! PRODUC] ! PRODUCTS ( HIS LABOR1 !RE IS NOT A LAW :I* UND]TAKES IT4 ,?AT IS A MATT] SO SIMPLE & SO NATURAL1 SO MU* A P>T ( ! CU/OMS & HABITS ( HUMANITY1 ?AT ! ,LAW HAS NOT EV5 CONSID]$ IT4 ,OP5 BRIG&AGE1 ) WEAPONS 9 H&1 BELONGS NO LONG] TO \R C5TURY2 NO LABOR] 9 !SE DAYS EV] DISPUTES ) ANO!R OV] ! PRODUCT ( HIS LABOR2 IF !RE IS ANY MISUND]/&+ BETWE5 !M1 !Y SETTLE IT )\T REC\RSE TO ! ,LAW1 BY ADDRESS+ !MSELVES TO A ?IRD P>TY2 & ! ONLY MAN :O N[ DEM&S ( ANO!R A C]TA9 PORTION ( HIS PRODUCT IS ! PROPRIETOR1 :O D$UCTS 9 ADVANCE ! LION'S %>E4 ,AS = HUMANITY 9 G5]AL1 IT UNIV]SALLY RESPECTS ! RI<T ( EA* TO :AT HE PRODUCES1 NOT NE$+ SPECIAL LAWS TO COMPEL IT TO SU* A C\RSE4 

,ALL ! LAWS UPON PROP]TY1 :I* FILL HUGE VOLUMES ( CODES & >E ! DELI<T ( ! LAWY]S1 HAV+1 AS WE HAVE SE51 NO O!R OBJECT ?AN ?AT ( PROTECT+ ! UNJU/ APPROPRIATION ( ! PRODUCTS ( ! LABOR ( HUMANITY BY C]TA9 MONOPOLI/S1 !RE IS NO EXCUSE = !IR EXI/5CE1 & ! REVOLUTION>Y SOCIALI/S >E FULLY DET]M9$ TO WIPE !M \T ON ! DAY ( ! ,REVOLUTION4 ,& WE CAN1 9DE$1 ) 5TIRE JU/ICE1 MAKE A COMPLETE AUTO-DA-FE( ALL ! LAWS 9 RELATION TO ! SO-CALL$ 0RI<TS ( PROP]TY10 ( ALL PROP]TY TITLES1 ( ALL ! >*IVES1-- 9 %ORT1 ( EV]Y?+ REF]R+ TO ?IS 9/ITUTION SOON TO BE CONSID]$ AS A HUMILIAT+ /A9 UPON ! HI/ORY ( HUMANITY EQUALLY ) ! SLAV]Y & S]VITUDE ( C5TURIES GONE BY4 

,:AT WE HAVE JU/ SAID ( ! LAWS CONC]N+ PROP]TY FULLY APPLIES TO ?IS SECOND CATEGORY ( LAWS1-- ! LAWS S]V+ TO MA9TA9 ! GOV]NM5T1 OR CON/ITUTIONAL LAWS4 

,H]E AGA9 IS A :OLE >S5AL ( LAWS1 DECREES1 ORD9ANCES1OP9IONS1 @&C41 S]V+ TO PROTECT ! V>I\S1 =MS ( REPRES5TATIVE GOV]NM5T 7BY DELEGATION OR BY USURPATION7 UND] :I* HUMAN SOCIETIES /ILL /RUGGLE4 ,WE KN[ V]Y WELL 7! ,AN>*I/S HAVE (T5 5\< DEMON/RAT$ IT 9 !IR 9CESSANT CRITICISMS ( ! V>I\S =MS ( GOV]NM5T7 ?AT ! MISSION ( ALL GOV]NM5TS1 MON>*ICAL1 CON/ITUTIONAL1 & REPUBLICAN1 IS TO PROTECT & TO MA9TA9 BY =CE ! PRIVILEGES ( ! POSSESS+ CLASSES1-- >I/OCRACY1 PRIE/HOOD1 & B\RGEOISIE4 ,A GOOD ?IRD ( \R LAWS1-- ! 0FUNDAM5TAL0 LAWS1 LAWS ON TAXATION1 ON CU/OM-H\SES1 ON ! ORGANIZATION ( M9I/RIES & !IR DEP>TM5TS1 ON ! >MY1 ! POLICE1 ! *UR*1 @&C4 7& !RE >E T5S ( ?\S&S 9 EV]Y C\NTRY7 -- HAVE NO O!R OBJECT ?AN TO MA9TA91 REHABILITATE1 & DEVELOP ! GOV]NM5TAL MA*9E1 :I* S]VES 9 ITS TURN ALMO/ EXCLUSIVELY TO PROTECT ! PRIVILEGES ( ! POSSESS+ CLASSES4 ,ANALYZE ALL !SE LAWS1 OBS]VE !IR ACTION DAY BY DAY1 & Y\ WILL P]CEIVE ?AT !RE IS NOT A S+LE ONE WOR?Y ( PRES]VATION1 BEG9N+ ) ?OSE :I* DELIV] ! COMMUNES1 B\ND H& & FOOT1 TO ! P>I%-PRIE/1 ! BIG B\RGEOIS ( ! LOCALITY1 & ! SUB-PREFECT1 & 5D+ ) ?IS FAM\S CON/ITUTION 7! N9ETE5? OR TW5TIE? S9CE #a#g#h#i71 :I* GIVES US A ,*AMB] ( IDIOTS & PETTY SPECULATORS PREP>+ ! WAY = ! DICTATOR%IP ( ! ADV5TUR]1 ,GAMBETTA1 IF NOT = ! GOV]NM5T ( A CR[N$ CABBAGE-HEAD4 

,9 %ORT1 REG>D+ ALL !SE LAWS !RE CAN BE NO D\BT4 ,NOT ONLY ! ,AN>*I/S1 BUT EV5 ! MORE OR LESS REVOLUTION>Y ( ! B\RGEOISE1 AGREE 9 ?IS1-- ?AT ! ONLY USE ?AT CAN BE MADE ( ALL ! LAWS CONC]N+ ! ORGANIZATION ( GOV]NM5T IS TO MAKE A BONFIRE ( !M4 

,!RE REMA9S ! ?IRD CATEGORY ( LAWS1 ! MO/ IMPORTANT1 S9CE TO IT ATTA*ES ! GREATE/ NUMB] ( PREJUDICES1-- ! LAWS CONC]N+ ! PROTECTION ( P]SONS1 ! PUNI%M5T & PREV5TION ( 0CRIMES40 ,9 FACT1 ?IS CATEGORY IS ! MO/ IMPORTANT1 BECAUSE :ATEV] CONSID]ATION ! ,LAW MAY 5JOY IS DUE TO ! BELIEF ?AT LAWS ( ?IS SORT >E ABSOLUTELY 9DISP5SABLE TO ! MA9T5ANCE ( SECURITY 9 \R SOCIETIES4 ,!SE >E ! LAWS :I* >E DEVELOP$ FROM ! NUCLEUS ( CU/OMS USEFUL TO HUMAN SOCIETIES & TAK5 ADVANTAGE ( BY ! RUL]S TO SANCTIFY !IR SWAY4 ,! AU?ORITY ( ! *IEFS ( TRIBES1 ( ! WEAL?Y FAMILIES 9 ! COMMUNES1 & ( ! K+ WAS BAS$ UPON ! JUDICIAL FUNCTIONS :I* !Y EX]CIS$2 & EV5 TO ! PRES5T DAY1 :5EV] ! NECESSITY ( GOV]NM5T IS SPOK5 (1 ITS FUNCTION AS SUPREME JUDGE IS TACITLY UND]/OOD TO BE REF]R$ TO4 0,)\T GOV]NM5T M5 W\LD \T EA* O!R'S ?ROATS10 SAYS ! VILLAGE PHILOSOPH]4 0,! F9AL PURPOSE ( EV]Y GOV]NM5T IS TO GIVETWELVE HONE/ JURORS TO EV]Y ACCUS$ P]SON10 SAID ,BURKE4 

,WELL1 9 SPITE ( ALL ! PREJUDICES EXI/+ 9 ?IS MATT]1 IT IS HI< TIME = ! ,AN>*I/S TO DECL>E BOLDLY ?AT ?IS CATEGORY ( LAWS IS AS USELESS & P]NICI\S AS ! PREC$+ ONES4 

,9 ! FIR/ PLACE1 AS = ! SO-CALL$ 0CRIMES10 ASSAULTS UPON P]SONS1 IT IS KN[N ?AT TWO-?IRDS & (T5 EV5 ?REE-F\R?S ( ALL !SE 0CRIMES0 >E 9SPIR$ BY ! DESIRE TO GET POSSESSION ( ! WEAL? BELONG+ TO SOME ONE4 ,?IS IMM5SE CATEGORY ( SO-CALL$ 0CRIMES & (F5SES0 WILL DISAPPE> ON ! DAY :5 PRIVATE PROP]TY %ALL CEASE TO EXI/4 0,BUT10 WE /ALL BE TOLD1 0!RE WILL ALWAYS BE BRUTES TO ASSAIL ! LIVES ( CITIZ5S1 TO DEAL A KNIFE ?RU/ 9 EV]Y QU>REL1 TO AV5GE ! SLI<TE/ (F5SE BY A MURD]1 IF !RE >E NO LAWS TO RE/RA9 !M & NO PUNI%M5TS TO )HOLD !M40 ,?AT IS ! REFRA9 SUNG TO US AS SOON AS WE CALL 9 QUE/ION SOCIETY'S RI<T TO PUNI%4 

,NEV]!LESS1 AS TO ?AT1 !RE IS TODAY ONE ?+ WELL E/ABLI%$3 ,! SEV]ITY ( PUNI%M5T DOES NOT DIM9I% ! NUMB] ( 0CRIMES40 ,9 FACT1 HANG1 QU>T]1 IF Y\ WILL1 ! ASSASS9S1 ! NUMB] ( ASSASS9ATIONS WILL NOT DIM9I% BY A S+LE ONE4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 ABOLI% ! DEA? P5ALTY1 & !RE WILL NOT BE A S+LE ASSASS9ATION ! MORE2 !RE WILL BE EV5 FEW]4 ,/ATI/ICS E/ABLI% ?IS4 ,BUT LET ! H>VE/ BE GOOD1 LET BREAD BE *EAP1 LET ! WEA!R BE F9E1 & ! NUMB] ( ASSASS9ATIONS WILL IMM$IATELY DIM9I%2 /ATI/ICS AGA9 PROVE ?AT ! NUMB] ( CRIMES 9CREASES & DIM9I%ES ) ! PRICE ( PROVISIONS & ! SEV]ITY ( ! SEASON4 ,NOT ?AT ALL ASSASS9ATIONS >E PROMPT$ BY HUNG]4 ,NOT AT ALL2 BUT1 :5 ! H>VE/ IS GOOD & PROVISIONS >E EASILY OBTA9ABLE1 M51 GAY]1 LESS WRET*$ ?AN USUAL1 DO NOT GIVE WAY TO ! D>K] PASSIONS & FEEL NO DESIRE TO PLUNGE A KNIFE 9TO ! HE>T ( ONE ( !IR FELL[S FROM TRIVIAL MOTIVES4 

,FUR!R1 IT IS KN[N ALSO ?AT ! FE> ( PUNI%M5T HAS NEV] DET]R$ A S+LE ASSASS94 ,HE :O GOES =? TO KILL HIS NEI<BOR FROM V5GEANCE OR FROM POV]TY DOES NOT REASON OV]MU* AB\T ! CONSEQU5CES2 & NEV] ASSASS9 :O HAD NOT ! FIRM CONVICTION ?AT HE W\LD ESCAPE PROSECUTION4 ,!RE >E A ?\S& O!R REASONS BESIDES1 :I* WE MI<T ADDUCE H]E1-- \R SPACE IS LIMIT$1-- BUT LET EA* ONE REASON ON ?IS SUBJECT = HIMSELF1 LET HIM ANALYZE CRIMES & P5ALTIES1 !IR MOTIVES & CONSEQU5CES1 &1 IF HE KN[S H[ TO REASON UN9FLU5C$ BY PRECONCEIV$ IDEAS1 HE WILL NECESS>ILY REA* ?IS CONCLUSION3 

,SAY+ NO?+ ( A SOCIETY 9 :I* MAN WILL RECEIVE A HI<] $UCATION1 9 :I* ! DEVELOPM5T ( ALL HIS FACULTIES & ! POSSIBILITY ( 5JOY+ !M WILL SECURE HIM SO MANY PLEASURES ?AT HE WILL NOT C>E TO LOSE !M BY A MURD]1-- SAY+ NO?+ ( ! SOCIETY ( ! FUTURE1 EV5 9 \R PRES5T SOCIETY1 EV5 ) !SE SAD PRODUCTS ( ! MIS]Y :I* WE SEE TODAY 9 ! POT-H\SES ( ! L>GE CITIES1 ON ! DAY :5 NO PUNI%M5T %ALL BE 9FLICT$ UPON ASSASS9S ! NUMB] ( ASSASS9ATIONS WILL NOT 9CREASE BY A S+LE ONE2 & IT IS HI<LY PROBABLE ?AT1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 IT WILL DIM9I% BY ALL ?OSE CASES N[ DUE TO SECOND (F5D]S :O HAVE BE5 BRUTALIZ$ 9 PRISONS4 

,WE >E CONT9UALLY TOLD ( ! B5EFITS ( ! LAW & ! B5EFIC5T EFFECTS ( P5ALTIES4 ,BUT HAVE ?OSE :O TELL US !SE ?+S EV] TRI$ TO /RIKE A BALANCE BETWE5 !SE B5EFITS :I* !Y ATTRIBUTE TO ,LAW & TO P5ALTIES1 & ! DEGRAD+ EFFECT ( !SE P5ALTIES ON HUMANITY8 ,LET !M ONLY CALCULATE ! SUM TOTAL ( BAD PASSIONS AWAK5$ 9 HUMANITY BY ! ATROCI\S PUNI%M5TS =M]LY 9FLICT$ 9 \R /REETS4 ,:O1 !N1 NURS$ & DEVELOP$ ! 9/9CTS ( CRUELTY 9 MAN 79/9CTS UNKN[N EV5 TO ! MONKEYS1 MAN HAV+ BECOME ! MO/ CRUEL ANIMAL ON E>?71 IF NOT ! K+1 ! JUDGE1 & ! PRIE/1 >M$ ) ! LAW1 :O MADE HIM TE> FLE% 9TO %R$S1 P\R BURN+ PIT* 9TO W\NDS1 DISLOCATE LIMBS1 CRU% BONES1 & SAW M5 9 TWO TO MA9TA9 !IR AU?ORITY8 ,LET !M ONLY E/IMATE ! TORR5T ( DEPRAVITY %$ 9TO HUMAN SOCIETY BY 9=M]S1 FAVOR$ BY JUDGES & REW>D$ ) ! R++ CO9S ( GOV]NM5T1 UND] PRETEXT ( AID+ 9 ! DISCOV]Y ( CRIMES4 ,LET !M GO 9TO PRISON & !RE /UDY :AT MAN BECOMES :5 DEPRIV$ ( LIB]TY1 %UT UP ) O!R DEPRAV$ WRET*ES :O IMBUE EA* O!R ) ALL ! CORRUPTION & ALL ! VICES :I* OOZE FROM ! PRISONS ( TODAY1 & LET !M ONLY REMEMB] ?AT1 ! MORE WE RE=M !SE 9/ITUTIONS1 ! MORE DETE/ABLE !Y >E1 ALL \R MOD]N & MODEL P5IT5TI>IES BE+ A HUNDR$ TIMES MORE ABOM9ABLE ?AN ! DUNGEONS ( ! ,MIDDLE ,AGES4 ,LET !M CONSID]1 F9ALLY1 :AT CORRUPTION1 :AT DEPRAVITY ( M9D IS MA9TA9$ 9 HUMANITY BY ?IS IDEA ( OB$I5CE 7! ESS5CE ( ! LAW71 ( *A/ISEM5T1 ( AU?ORITY HAV+ ! RI<T TO *A/ISE & TO JUDGE REG>DLESS ( \R CONSCI5CE & ! E/EEM ( \R FRI5DS1 ( AN EXECUTION]1 ( A JAIL]1 ( A COMMON 9=M]1-- 9 %ORT1 ( ALL !SE ATTRIBUTES ( ,LAW & ,AU?ORITY4 ,LET !M CONSID] ALL ?IS1 & !Y WILL C]TA9LY AGREE ) US :5 WE SAY ?AT ! ,LAW 9FLICT+ P5ALTIES IS AN ABOM9ATION :I* \<T TO CEASE TO EXI/4 

,MOREOV]1 NON-POLIC$ &1 CONSEQU5TLY1 LESS DEPRAV$ PEOPLES HAVE CLE>LY UND]/OOD ?AT HE :O IS CALL$ A 0CRIM9AL0 IS SIMPLY AN UN=TUNATE1-- NOT TO BE FLOGG$1 *A9$1 OR PUT TO DEA? ON ! SCAFFOLD OR 9 PRISON1 BUT TO BE COM=T$ BY ! MO/ FRAT]NAL C>ES BY TREATM5T AS AN EQUAL1 BY ASSOCIATION ) HONE/ PEOPLE4 ,& 9 ! NEXT REVOLUTION WE HOPE TO HE> ?IS CRY GO =?3 

,BURN ! GUILLOT9ES2 TE> D[N ! PRISONS2 BANI% ! JUDGE1 ! POLICEMAN1 ! 9=M]1-- AS UNCLEAN A CREW AS ! E>? EV] HELD2 TREAT AS A BRO!R HIM :O HAS BE5 DRIV5 BY PASSION TO DO EVIL TO HIS NEI<BOR2 ABOVE ALL1 TAKE AWAY FROM ! GREAT CRIM9ALS1 ?OSE IGNOBLE PRODUCTS ( ! IDL5ESS ( ! B\RGEOISIE1 ! POSSIBILITY ( >RAY+ !IR VICES 9 S$UCTIVE G>B1-- & BE SURE ?AT \R SOCIETY WILL !N BE SIGNALIZ$ BY V]Y FEW CRIMES4 ,?AT :I* MA9 MA9TA9S CRIME 7BESIDE IDL5ESS7 IS ,LAW & ,AU?ORITY3 ! LAW ON PROP]TY1 ! LAW ON GOV]NM5T1 ! LAW ON P5ALTIES & (F5SES1 & ! AU?ORITY :I* ASSUMES TO MAKE !SE LAWS & APPLY !M4 

,NO MORE LAWS1 NO MORE JUDGES6 ,LIB]TY1 ,EQUALITY1 & ! PRACTICE ( ,SOLID>ITY =M ! ONLY EFFECTIVE B>RI] :I* WE CAN OPPOSE TO CRIME4 

,JU/ ! ,SIZE ( ,IT4 

0,LE ,REVOLTE10 REF]R+ TO ! !ORY ( L& NATIONALIZATION ADVOCAT$ BY ,JOHN ,/U>T ,MILL & N[ *AMPION$ BY ,HYNDMAN1 ,GEORGE1 & ,WALLACE1 TRULY SAYS3 

,! IDEA ( ! NATIONALIZATION ( ! SOIL IS ONLY A COMPROMISE BETWE5 PRIVATE PROP]TY & SOCIALISM4 ,! SOIL IS TO BE PROCLAIM$ NATIONAL PROP]TY 7REIMBURS+ ! L&LORDS1 SAY ! AU?ORS ( ! IDEA1-- )\T REIMBURS+ !M1 SAY ! WORK+M574 ,! ,/ATE1 :I* IS TO BE MANAG]1 IS TO R5T IT TO SU* AS DESIRE TO CULTIVATE IT !MSELVES1 & ?IS R5T IS TO REPLACE TAXATION4 ,?IS1 !N1 W\LD BE AN 9TRODUCTION ( ! SAME SY/EM ?AT EXI/S 9 C]TA9 PORTIONS ( ! ,5GLI% ,9DIES 7:I* DOES NOT PREV5T ! CULTIVATORS ( ! SOIL FROM DY+ ( HUNG] BY MILLIONS71 OR ELSE 9 ,SIB]IA1 :]E ALSO ! L& BELONGS TO ! ,/ATE & IS R5T$ TO ! COMMUNES1 :I* NEV]!LESS >E RU9$ BY TAXES & (FICIALS4 ,! IDEA ITSELF IS NOT WOR? MU*4 ,BUT :AT 9T]E/S US IS ! FACT ?AT ?IS IDEA ( DISPOSSESSION ( ! L&LORDS IS APPROV$ BY L>GE NUMB]S ( PEOPLE1 EV5 9 ! RANKS ( ! B\RGEOISIE & ! WELL-TO-DO CLASSES G5]ALLY4 ,ITS PROGRESS MAY ALMO/ BE SAID TO BE VISIBLE TO ! EYE4 

,H5RY ,GEORGE ,EXAM9$ 

,%\LD ,L& BE ,NATIONALIZ$ OR ,9DIVIDUALIZ$8 ,BY ,J4 ,K4 ,+ALLS4 

,$ITOR ,IRI% ,WORLD3.<#b.>-- ,H[EV] 9T]E/+ = ! MOM5T MAY BE ! QUE/IONS AS TO :E!R ,MESSRS4 ,P>NELL & ,DAVITT >E ACT+ 9 UNITY1 & AS TO :E!R ,MR4 ,GEORGE HAS CAPTUR$ ! LATT] G5TLEMAN1 A F> GRAV] QUE/ION MU/ ULTIMATELY PRES5T ITSELF 9 CONNECTION ) ! DISPOSITION & F9AL CONTROL ( ! L&4 ,AMONG ! ADVOCATES ( ! 0NEW DEP>TURE0 ,I HAVE OBS]V$ BUT ONE :O HAS SEEM$ TO APPREH5D ! EXACT ISSUE1-- VIZ41 Y\R CORRESPOND5T1 0,W4 ,M4 ,C40 0,PHILLIP10 9DE$1 APPREH5DS ?AT ! SOLUTION MU/ HAVE A MORE 9DIVIDUALI/IC APPLICATION ?AN IS NECESS>ILY EMBRAC$ 9 ! T]M 0NATIONALIZATION ( ! L&10 BUT1 UNTIL HE FULLY DEVELOPS HIS IDEAS1 ,I WILL SUSP5D JUDGM5T ON !M4 

,N[1 POT5TIALLY1 !RE CAN BE NO DIFF]5CE BETWE5 MONOPOLY UND] LEASE & MONOPOLY UND] FREEHOLD1 AS WE %ALL SEE ON C>EFUL 9VE/IGATION4 ,BUT LET US FIR/ ASC]TA9 :AT ?IS PHRASE REALLY MEANS4 ,DOES IT MEAN L& = ! :OLE PEOPLE8 ,!N :O W\LD WANT TO R5T OR LET8 ,DOES IT MEAN [N]%IP BY ! GOV]NM5T OR ,/ATE8 ,IF SO1 IT IS NOT ! SOLUTION1 BUT ONLY ! /AT+1 ( ! L& PROBLEM4 ,AT ! \TSET ?IS IS !ORY ( ALL GOV]NM5TS4 

,:5 ,WILLIAM ( ,NORM&Y DEFEAT$ ,H>OLD1 HE1 AS HEAD ( ! ,/ATE1 ASSUM$ CONTROL ( ! L& & P>CELI$ IT \T TO HIS B&IT LIEUT5ANTS & FAVORITES4 ,! ,5GLI% MON>*S DID ! SAME 9 ,IREL&4 

,9 ANCI5T ,ROME ! NATION CLAIM$ ! DOMA92 BUT AFT] A FEW HUNDR$ YE>S IT WAS ALL 9 ! H&S ( A FEW PATRICIANS & MILIT>Y *IEFTA9S4 ,! L& 9 !SE ,UNIT$ ,/ATES1 AT ! ADOPTION ( ,CON/ITUTION1 WAS MA9LY NATIONAL DOMA94 ,LESS ?AN HUNDR$ YE>S SUFFIC$ TO PLACE IT 9 ! H&S ( SPECULATORS1 FAVOR$ CORPORATIONS1 & DOME/IC & =EIGN L&LORDS4 ,LESS ?AN ONE-QU>T] IS N[ HELD BY ! GOV]NM5T1 & BUT A SMALL PROPORTION BY ACTUAL CULTIVATORS1 & EV5 ONE-HALF ( ?AT IS MORTGAG$ TO MONEY-L5D]S BEYOND ALL HOPE ( R$EMPTION4 

,I %ALL BE TOLD ?AT IT IS NOT 9TEUD$ TO ALL[ PRIVATE PROP]TY 9 L& AT ALL1 & ?AT H5CE NO MONOPOLI/IC ACCUMULATION C\LD >ISE4 ,WELL1 !N1 !RE CAN BE NO PUBLIC PROP]TY 9 L&2 OR1 IF SO CALL$ OR HELD1 IT MU/ BE ) ?IS SWEEP+ LIMITATION1-- ?AT ! PUBLIC1 ,/ATE1 OR GOV]NM5T CAN NEV] TRANSF] IT TO PRIVATE CONTROL4 ,:AT ,I WI% TO 9DICATE H]E IS ?AT NO /EP :ATSOEV] T[>DS SECUR+ ! 9DIVIDUAL PEOPLE 9 !IR 0RI<TS ( SOIL0 CAN BE TAK5 )\T 0LIMITATION ( ! PR9CIPLE ( PROP]TY0 9 ITS APPLICATION TO ! L&4 

,BUT ,I %ALL BE TOLD ALSO ?AT = ! 9DIVIDUAL TO LEASE HIS L& FROM ! ,/ATE OR GOV]NM5T WILL OBVIATE ALL DANG] ?AT ANY P]SON WILL BE EXCLUD$ FROM CULTIVAT+ ! SOIL :O HONE/LY SEEKS TO DO SO4 ,?IS W\LD BE SATISFACTORY IF IT W]E PROPOS$1 AS 0,W4 ,M4 ,C40 PROPOSES1 TO LIMIT LEASE-HOLDS SO ?AT ALL C\LD HAVE OPPORTUNITY4 

,)\T SU* LIMITATION LETT+S W\LD HAVE TO BE MADE AT AUCTION2 & IT W\LD BE NO MORE DIFFICULT = ! MILLIONAIRE TO BID (F ALL ! LEASES ( A SECTION1 T[N%IP1 OR C\NTRY ?AN TO BUY UP ALL ! FEES SIMPLE4 ,9DE$1 IT W\LD BE F> EASI]1 = IT W\LD REQUIRE HIM TO 9VE/ NONE ( HIS CAPITAL 9 L&1 AS N[4 ,TO NATIONALIZE ! L& 9 ANY SU* S5SE AS ?AT W\LD HELP NO POOR MAN TO A PIECE ( L&1 BUT W\LD ONLY SUBJECT LABOR TO DEP5D5CE ON A SPECULAT+ & ADV5TUR] CLASS 9/EAD ( AN H]$IT>Y L&LORD1 & UPON ! FAVORS ( A P>TISAN BOSSISM 9/EAD ( A =EIGN GOV]NM5T4 

,WE %\LD HAVE \R 0SEV5TY-?\S&-ACRE F>MS0 RUN BY 0PRODUCE K+S0 ALD$ BY MA*9]Y & 0TRANSI5T HELP0 9 SE$ TIME & H>VE/1 RESULT+ 9 ! ULTIMATE EXHAU/ION ( ! SOIL & ! R$UCTION ( LABOR TO ! TRAMP /ATE4 \R /OCK-JOBB+ SY/EM W\LD BE M]CILESSLY APPLI$ H]E1 & ! CONDITION ( ! POOR1 BY LACK ( OPPORTUNITY = SELF-EMPLOYM5T1 W\LD BE R5D]$ CON/ANTLY WORSE & WORSE 9/EAD ( BE+ IMPROV$4 

,I DO NOT MEAN 9 ANY DEGREE TO 9TIMATE ?AT ,MR4 ,DAVITT OR ,MR4 ,GEORGE CONTEMPLATES ANY SU* RESULTS1 BUT ?IS IS ! LOGICAL \TCOME TO ANY PLAN ( OCCUPANCY :I* DOES NOT POSITIVELY ASSURE ! 9DIVIDUAL RI<T TO 5T] UPON & CULTIVATE ! L& NECESS>Y TO HIS SU/5ANCE1 & ?AT )\T ACC\NT+ TO L&LORD OR GOV]NM5T (FICIAL4 ,I AM GRATIFI$ ?AT ! 0,IRI% ,WORLD0 HAS NOT COMMITT$ ITSELF TO ANY PLAN :I* DOES NOT EFFECTUALLY REALIZE ?IS AIM4 

0,R5T10 ACCORD+ TO ,MR4 ,DAVITT1 0IS AN IMMORAL TAX10 &1 ACCORD+ TO ,MR4 ,GEORGE1 IS 0! PRICE ( MONOPOLY10 & :E!R PAID TO A S+LE OR TO A COLLECTIVE L&LORD1 IS UN*ANG$ 9 ITS NATURE4 

,9 VIEW ( ! BRAVE & NOBLE WORK :I* ,MR4 ,GEORGE HAS DONE & IS /ILL DO+ = ! CAUSE ( L& RE=M1 IT PA9S ME TO SAY ?AT HE DOES NOT SEEM TO HAVE APPRECIAT$ HIS [N WORDS1 MU* LESS COMPREH5D$ ! CLE>-CAT DEF9ITION ( ,MR4 ,DAVITT1 &1 AS TO ! TW9 BLASPHEMY ( USURY1 NOT TO HAVE APPREH5D$ IT AT ALL4 ,EV5 AS LATE AS ,M>* #a1 #a#h#h#b1 HE SPEAKS ( ! 9CREASE ( R5T ) ! GR[? ( SOCIETY AS 0A MO/ BEAUTIFUL EVID5CE ( CREATIVE DESIGN40 

,9 SO LATE A NUMB] ( ! 0,IRI% ,WORLD0 AS ,JULY #h?1 9 ! REPORT ( HIS ,DUBL9 LECTURE1 AFT] REIT]AT+ ?AT ! PRES5T AGITATION 0MOANS L& = ! :OLE PEOPLE -- EV]Y MAN1 WOMAN1 *ILD1 RI* & POOR10 A 0SOLUTION :I* GIVES TO EV]Y MAN ?AT :I* HE FAIRLY E>NS10 HE GIVES UTT]ANCE TO SU* 9CONSI/5T ECONOMIC TWADDLE AS ?IS1 SAY+ IT IS 0,MI*AEL ,DAVITT'S PLAN30 0,TO SOLVE ! L& QUE/ION & ! LABOR QUE/ION IT IS M]ELY NECESS>Y .<NOT TO NATIONALIZE ! L&.> TO TAKE = ! B5EFIT ( ! :OLE PEOPLE ?OSE FRUITS COM+ FROM ! L& :I* >E NOT DUE TO ! EX]TIONS ( LABOR OR USE ( CAPITAL ( ?OSE :O >E 5GAG$ 9 US+ IT40 ,D\BTLESS1 ,MR4 ,GEORGE W\LD BE UNABLE TO F9D EV5 9 ,IREL& AN 9/ANCE :]E1 ! L&LORD BE+ A JUDGE1 ANY?+ MORE ?AN !SE FRUITS W]E TAK5 AS R5T4 ,! ONLY DIFF]5CE BETWE5 ?IS PLAN1 :I* ,MR4 ,GEORGE WAS C>EFUL TO /ATE WAS NOT 0,MR4 ,DAVITT'S P>TICULALRY0 7,I %\LD HOPE NOT71 & CURR5T L&LORDISM IS ?AT 9 ONE 9/ANCE ?OSE FRUITS GO TO A CLASS1 & 9 O!R TO ! :OLE PEOPLE2 9 O!R WORDS TO ! RUL+ POLITICAL P>TY OR ADM9I/RATION4 ,HE DOES NOT /OP TO CONSID] ?AT ?IS CIRCUM/ANCE W\LD 9 NO S5SE *ANGE ! IMMORAL NATURE ( ! TAX1 H[EV] IT MI<T MITIGATE ITS PUBLIC IMPOLICY4 ,AS TO ! PORTION ( FRUITS :I* >E TO GO TO ! USE ( CAPITAL EMPLOY$ 9 CULTIVAT+ ! L&1 IT W\LD BE HOPELESS TO F9D ANY F>M] OR OP]ATOR 9 ANY FIELD ( 9DU/RY TO ADMIT ?AT MORE WAS N[ RECEIV$ ?AN WAS !IR DUE4 ,POLITICAL ECONOMI/S DO NOT ADMIT ANY SU* ?+1 & WE LOOK ?R\< 0,PROGRESS & ,POV]TY0 9 VA9 TO F9D ANY SU* 9TIMATION FROM ,MR4 ,GEORGE4 

,?AT HE AIMS AT ! SAME G5]AL RESULT AS O!R L& RE=M]S1 ,I HAVE NO %AD[ ( D\BT2 BUT HIS PREMISES AS TO ! USE ( CAPITAL & ITS REPRODUCTIVE P[]1 TOGE!R ) HIS !ORY ( R5T -- ?AT IT IS ! RESULT ( SOME?+ PRODUC$ BY ! L& )\T LABOR1-- IS :OLLY UNSUPPORT$ BY ANY KN[N FACTS2 & HIS PLAN ( TAX+ BACK :AT IS WRONGFULLY WRUNG FROM LABOR UND] ?IS FALSE PRET5SE CAN BUT PROVE DELUSIVE4 ,IF SUCCESSFUL AS A TAX1 IT W\LD TO ?AT EXT5T PROVE USELESS AS A MEASURE ( EQUITY4 ,IF SUCCESSFUL1 AS HE CONCEIVES1 9 GIV+ EV]Y ONE A FOO?OLD ON ,GOD'S FOOT/OOL1 IT W\LD CEASE TO YIELD ANY REV5UE :ATEV]1 & ?US PROVE SELF-DE/RUCTIVE1 = NO ONE NOT DEPRIV$ ( L& BY LAW OR =CE W\LD PAY R5T TO GOV]NM5T L&LORD4 

,! F>!R DISCUSSION ( ! QUE/ION ,I HAVE PUT 9 ! =M (4 

,DIALOGUE4 

,JONA?AN -- ,GOOD MORN+ ,GEORGE4 ,I AM GLAD Y\ HAVE CALL$4 ,I AM BECOM+ DEEPLY 9T]E/$ 9 ! L& QUE/ION4 ,TO ME IT SEEMS ( IMPORTANCE TO O!R C\NTRIES AS WELL AS TO ,IREL&1 & ?AT WE CANNOT FULLY SYMPA?IZE ) ! MOVEM5T !RE UNTIL WE UND]/& IT AS A PROBLEM ( WORLD-WIDE APPLICATION4 

,GEORGE -- ,Y\ CANNOT BE 9T]E/$ 9 A QUE/ION ( DEEP] IMPORTANCE1 & Y\ >E RI<T 9 ?9K+ IT A SUBJECT ( UNIV]SAL CONC]N4 ,! MONOPOLY ( ! L& N EV]Y C\NTRY LIES AT ! F\NDATION ( CLASS DOM9ATION & ( ! POV]TY & 9DU/RIAL SUBJECTION :I* PREVAIL WIDELY EV5 9 ?IS L& ( CIVIL & POLITICAL FRE$OM4 ,PRIVATE PROP]TY 9 L&1 :E!R UND] 9H]ITANCE OR COMM]CIAL TRAFFIC1 NECESS>ILY 5DS1 SOON] OR LAT]1 9 ITS ABSORPTION 9TO ! H&S ( A SMALL PRIVILEG$ CLASS1 :ILE ! MAJORITY ( ! CULTIVATORS1 & 9DE$1 ALL WORK]S1 WILL BE R$UC$ TO ! CONDITION ( T5ANTS1 WAGE-WORK]S1 & TRAMPS4 

,J4 -- ,?AT IS ALSO MY ?\<T1 AL?\< AS TO PRIVATE PROP]TY 9 L& ,I AM NOT C]TA9 IT C\LD NOT BE SO DEF9$ & GU>D$ AS TO MAKE IT OP]ATE 9 FAVOR ( EQUAL OPPORTUNITY & EQUAL SECURITY4 ,= 9/ANCE1 H]E ,I [N =TY ACRES4 ,?IS W\LD 9T]F]E ) NO ONE'S OPPORTUNITY IF SOME W]E NOT ALL[$ TO BUY UP HUNDR$S & ?\S&S ( ACRES1 NOT = ! PURPOSE ( CULTIVAT+ OR OCCUPY+1 BUT TO HOLD !M AGA9/ ! POOR & HOMELESS1 9 ORD] ?AT !Y MAY TAX ! TOIL APPLI$ 9 !IR CULTIVATION & PREV5T ?OSE :O NE$ FROM GO+ UPON !M & MAK+ HOMES4 

,G4 -- ,I SEE Y\ HAVE NOT /UDI$ ?IS L& QUE/ION 9 ALL ITS PHASES4 ,PRIVATE PROP]TY MEANS PROP]TY1 &1 IF Y\ ATTEMPT TO GU>D OR CONTROL IT1 IT CEASES TO BE SU*4 ,I ?9K NATIONALIZATION ( ! L& ! ONLY PRACTICAL SOLUTION ( ! QUE/ION1 & ?AT CAN BE MO/ READILY EFFECT$ BY TAX+ BACK ! VALUE ( ! L& -- I4E41 ! R5T :I* IT WILL BR+ -- = ! B5EFIT ( ! :OLE PEOPLE4 

,J4 -- ,! NATIONALIZATION ( ! L& 9 A COMPREH5SIVE S5SE IS A ?+ G5]ALLY ADMITT$1 ,I ?9K4 ,NO ONE DISPUTES ?AT ! L& ( ANY C\NTRY BELONGS TO ! :OLE PEOPLE ( ?AT C\NTRY4 ,! ONLY QUE/ION IS1 H[ CAN ! PR9CIPLE BE APPLI$ TO PROTECT ! 9DIVIDUAL 9 HIS NATURAL RI<T ( ACCESS TO HIS NORMAL 5VIRONM5T SO AS NOT TO 9VALIDATE ! RI<T ( 0EM95T DOMA910 :I* IS EX]CIS$ MORE OR LESS WIDELY & WISELY BY ! GOV]NM5TS ( ALL C\NTRIES1 & :I* BY ! G5IUS ( \R LAWS IS SUPPOS$ TO RESIDE 9 ! :OLE PEOPLE8 ,! :OLE PEOPLE CANNOT BE EVICT$4 ,IT IS ONLY BY ALL[+ ! 9DIVIDUAL TO BE EVICT$ & DEB>R$ FROM HIS NATURAL 9H]ITANCE ?AT SOCIETY CAN BE 5DANG]$ BY L& MONOPOLY4 ,SOCIETY HAS1 !RE=E1 AN UND\BT$ RI<T TO PROHIBIT ! OCCUPANCY BY ANY P]SON ( SU* EXT5T ( ! COMMON 9H]ITANCE AS W\LD CR[D OR EXCLUDE ! WEAKE/ MEMB] FROM HIS FOO?OLD ON ! SOIL4 

,:E!R ! OCCUPANT HOLDS HIS H\SE AS PROP]TY1 CONTRIBUT+ HIS %>E ( ! PUBLIC BURD5 9 ! =M ( A TAX1 OR AS A T5ANT & CONTRIBUT+ UND] ! =M ( R5T1 W\LD SEEM TO MATT] LITTLE SO LONG AS ! L>GE OCCUPANCY ( ! RI*] & /RONG] DID NOT IMP]IL ! OPPORTUNITY ( ! POOR & WEAK4 ,BY ! LATE M5TION ( A BOOK ,I HAVE NOT YET READ1 ,I JUDGE ?AT ,MR4 ,WALLACE ALONE AMONG ,5GLI% L& RE=M]S RECOGNIZES ! NECESSITY ( LIMITATION ( OCCUPANCY UND] LEASEHOLD1 & ADVOCATES FEATURES ( FIXITY :I* WILL SECURE P]MAN5T HOLD+ & ! 9VIOLABILITY ( HOME TO ! FAMILY4 ,AS TO LETT+ R5T GO ON1 AS UND] ! L&LORD SY/EM1 & ! TAX+ IT ALL BACK = ! B5EFIT ( ! :OLE PEOPLE1 ,I AM UNABLE TO SEE H[ ?AT PLAN CAN BE MADE TO H>MONIZE ) ANY DEMOCRATIC IDEA OR FAIL TO BECOME A MO/ DANG]\S EXP]IM5T = ANY GOV]NM5T TO ATTEMPT4 ,9DU/RY AT MO/ %\LD BE TAX$ ONLY = ! REASONABLE NECESSITIES ( GOV]NM5T1 & ONLY AFT] SU* NECESSITY HAS RIS5 & HONE/ E/IMATES MADE4 ,TO LEVY TAXES = ! ACCUMULATION ( AN 9DEF9ITE SUM1 = :I* EXP5DITURES HAVE TO BE F\ND1 IS TO CREATE A FUND 9VIT+ CORRUPTION & PECULATION & ! BETRAYAL ( PUBLIC TRU/4 ,NO EXP]I5CE :I* ANY PEOPLE 9 ANY TIME HAVE HAD W\LD JU/IFY IT1 & IT C\LD NOT LOGICALLY BE SANCTION$ BY ANYONE BUT ! ADVOCATE ( ! NATIONALIZ+ ( 9DU/RY AS WELL AS ( ! L&1 & ( :OLESALE GOV]NM5TAL COOP]ATION1 :I* W\LD MAKE ! GOV]NM5T ! EMPLOY] ( ALL LABOR & ! DET]M9] ( ALL WAGES4 ,I DO NOT UND]/& Y\ TO ADVOCATE ?IS4 

,G4 -- ,OH1 NO4 ,H[EV] ,I MAY AGREE 9 ! AB/RACT ) :AT Y\ SAY1 ,I CANNOT AVOID SEE+ ?AT IT IS PRIVATE PROP]TY 9 L& :I* IS ! F\NDATION ( ! EVIL4 ,ABOLI% ?IS BY MAK+ ! NATION ! [N]1 &1 ( C\RSE1 NO SU* ?+ AS MONOPOLY C\LD EXI/4 ,Y\ MU/ ADMIT ?AT TO EQUALLY DI/RIBUTE ! L& AMONG ! PEOPLE W\LD BE IMPOSSIBLE1 EV5 IF DESIRABLE1 :I* IT IS NOT4 ,MANY WANT NO L&1 BUT ALL >E 5TITL$ TO !IR %>E ( :AT IT PRODUCES1 M9US ! AM\NT JU/LY DUE ! CULTIVATOR1 & M9US ! P>T RI<TFULLY DUE ! CAPITALI/1 :O HAS FURNI%$ OR ADVANC$ MEANS TO FURNI% ! /OCK & G5]AL PLANT EMPLOY$ 9 CULTIVAT+ ! L&4 

,J4 -- ,& ! CO/S ( COLLECT+ & DI/RIBUT+ ! SAME AMONG ! :OLE BODY ( CLAIMANTS8 

,G4 -- ,YES2 BUT ?AT IS UNAVOIDABLE1 & MI<T BE CONSID]$ AS COMP5SAT$ BY RELIEF FROM ALL O!R =MS ( TAXATION4 ,I WAS GO+ TO ADD ?AT R5T IS AN ECONOMICAL FRUIT NOT ! RESULT ( LABOR1 BUT 9 ADDITION TO IT1 :I* ! HOLD] ( L& :O CULTIVATES IT HIMSELF RECEIVES OV] & ABOVE ! COMP5SATION ( HIS LABOR JU/ AS TRULY AS ! IDLE L&LORD4 

,J4 -- ,IS R5T AT ! SAME TIME1 !1 0AN IMMORAL TAX10 AS ,MR4 ,DAVITT ASS]TS8 

,G4 -- ,YES1 :5 PAID TO L&LORDS1 BUT IF PAID TO ! GOV]NM5T1 & BY ?AT APPLI$ TO ! PUBLIC WELF>E1 EA* MEMB] ( ! COMMUNITY GETS HIS JU/ %>E ( ! NATURAL PRODUCE ( ! L&4 ,R5T1 ECONOMICAL R5T AT LEA/1 >ISES :OLLY FROM ! DIFF]5T F]TILITY ( SPECIAL SOILS1 AS EXPLA9$ BY ,RIC>DO & O!R POLITICAL ECONOMI/4 

,J4 -- ,I AM NOT UNAW>E ( ?AT1 OR ( ! USE ,MAL?US & O!R WRIT]S HAVE MADE ( ?IS !ORY TO SATISFY ! LABOR] ?AT EVICTION & />VATION >E 9 ! ORD] ( ,PROVID5CE & NOT RESULTS ( UNJU/ & B>B>\S LAWS ( T5URE4 ,?AT UND] ANY SY/EM ( FRE$OM ( ! L& !RE W\LD BE A *OICE ( LOCATIONS & ( QUALITIES ( ! SOIL !RE CAN BE NO D\BT2 ?AT P>TIES W\LD BE WILL+ TO PAY SOME?+ = SU* *OICE !RE CAN BE AS LITTLE2 BUT ?AT SU* TRANSACTIONS W\LD DEG5]ATE 9TO FIX$ R5TS1 )\T L&LORDS1 IS H>DLY CONCEIVABLE1-- NOT C]TA9LY :ILE AS AT PRES5T !RE IS ABUNDANCE ( L& ( GOOD QUALITY TO PRODUCE ALL ?AT IS NECESS>Y = ! PUBLIC CONSUMPTION4 ,! 9HUMAN MOCK]Y ( ?IS PLAUSIBLE !ORY IS ALL TOO APP>5T :5 WE REFLECT ?AT MU* ( ! BE/ L& EV5 9 ,IREL& IS N[ UNTILL$1 :ILE T5ANTS >E BE+ EVICT$ FROM ! POORE/ BECAUSE !Y WILL NOT PAY A R5T AT A RATE ALMO/1 IF NOT QUITE1 AS HI< AS ! BE/ L& W\LD COMM&4 ,TAKE AWAY ! WRIT ( EJECTM5T FROM ! L&LORD1 ) :I* HE IS N[ CLO!D1 & ! CON/ABUL>Y & MILIT>Y :I* 5ABLE HIM TO 5=CE IT1 & ALL ! R5T HE W\LD BE ABLE TO COLLECT FROM *OICE ( PLACE OR PREF]5CE ( SOILS W\LD NOT DI/RESS OR S]I\SLY WRONG ANY4 ,[N]%IP UND] SU* LIMITATION AS W\LD ALWAYS LEAVE L& OP5 TO OCCUPATION1 EV5 ( A POOR QUALITY1 W\LD REMOVE DI/RESSFUL POV]TY F> FROM ! DOOR ( ! 9DU/RI\S & FRUGAL4 ,! FEW :O >E LAZY & IMPROVID5T ALSO W\LD IMPROVE !IR CONDITION AS OPPORTUNITIES 9CREAS$ AS *ANCES ( DO+ BETT] BY IDLE S*EM+ ?AN BY HONES WORK DECREAS$4 

,G4 -- ,IT SEEMS TO ME Y\ TREAT ! R5T !ORY ) TOO LITTLE CONSID]ATION4 ,IT 9 V]Y CLE> TO ME ?AT R5T ONLY REPRES5TS ! DIFF]5CE BETWE5 ! PRODUCTIV5ESS ( ! BE/ L&S & ?AT :I* IS NOT SUFFICI5TLY PRODUCTIVE TO YIELD R5T4 ,IF ! CULTIVATOR [NS ! L& HIMSELF1 ?IS PRODUCTION 9 EXCESS ( ?AT POOR] L& :I* IS CULTIVAT$ IS A GRATUITY TO HIM :I* COMES FROM ,NATURE1 & NOT FROM HIS TOIL1 S9CE HE HAS TOIL$ NO H>D] ?AN ! MAN :O HAS PRODUC$ ! SMALL] YIELD2 & ! ONLY WAY TO EQUALIZE ! AW>D ( 9DU/RY IS TO TAX AWAY ?IS EXCESS & GIVE IT TO ! PUBLIC4 ,! !ORY IS ITSELF SO PLA9 & G5]ALLY ACCEPT$ ?AT ,I WOND] Y\ HAVE ! C\RAGE TO DISPUTE IT4 ,MR4 ,MILL D5OM9ATES IT ! 0PONS AS9ORUM40 

,J4 -- ,I AM AW>E ( IT1 BUT WAS ALWAYS 9 A LITTLE D\BT AS TO HIS APPLICATION ( ! T]M4 ,IT MI<T BE ?AT HE MEANT SU* A BRIDGE ?AT ALL ASSES COM+ NE> W\LD BE SURE TO GO OV]4 ,IT IS NOT SO MU* ! !ORY AS ! USE :I* IS MADE ( IT ?AT ,I DEPRECATE4 ,?AT !RE IS DIFF]5CE 9 SOILS & 9 ! DESIRABL5ESS ( SITUATIONS IS TRUE 5\<1 BUT ?AT SU* DIFF]5CE CON/ITUTES ! 5TIRE R5TAL IS TOO ABSURD = S]I\S DISCUSSION4 ,=1 !N1 IF ALL SOILS W]E EQUALLY F]TILE1 & ALL SITUATIONS EQUALLY DESIRABLE1 NO R5T C\LD BE OBTA9$1 H[EV] ! L& MI<T BE MONOPOLIZ$4 ,?IS REM9DS ME ( ! !SIS ( ! METAPHYSICIAN1 ?AT1 IF AN ASS WAS PLAC$ EQUI-DI/ANT BETWE5 TWO EQUALLY ATTRACTIVE BUNDLES ( HAY1 HE W\LD DIE ( />VATION )\T BE+ ABLE TO DECIDE BETWE5 ! TWO4 ,&1 !ORETICALLY1 ?IS IS ALL S\ND2 PRACTICALLY1 IT IS NONS5SE4 ,9 TRU?1 R5T >ISES FROM EXACTLY ! OPPOSITE DIRECTION TO ?AT H]E ASSUM$4 ,! AM\NT ANY L& WILL YIELD ABOVE ! B>E NECESSITIES ( ! CULTIVATOR BECOMES ! MEASURE ( R5T UND] L& MONOPOLY4 ,& TO APPLY ! S*EME ( TAX+ BACK L& VALUES OR R5T = ! PUBLIC GOOD MEANS1 IF IT MEANS ANY?+1 ! TAX+ ( PRODUCTIVE LABOR1 ALL ABOVE A B>E SUBSI/5CE1 & DIVID+ IT AMONG ALL1 :E!R WORK]S OR O!RWISE4 ,! 9EQUALITY :I* W\LD >ISE FROM ! WORK+ ( L&S ( UNEQUAL F]TILITY IS GREATLY OV]-E/IMAT$1 & IT SEEMS TO ME C\LD BE REM$I$ BY MU* EASI] & MORE NATURAL ME?ODS4 ,) A RATIONAL SY/EM ( LIMIT$ OCCUPANCY ! RE/RICTION W\LD EMBRACE ! CONSID]ATION ( SUP]IOR F]TILITY1 & ) MORE L& ( AN 9F]IOR QUALITY1 ) MORE V>I$ CROPS & C>EFUL TILLAGE1 ALL S]I\S 9EQUALITIES W\LD BE OV]COME4 ,!RE >E ALSO MANY COMP5SATIONS NOT DISC]NIBLE ON ! B>E /ATEM5T4 ,! MAN ) EASI] TILLAGE & MORE PRODUCTIVE SOIL WILL BE ABLE1 D\BTLESS1 TO OBTA9 ! SAME PRICE = HIS GRA9 OR FRUITS AS ! MAN ) POOR] SOIL & %ORT] CROPS4 ,HE WILL LEAVE SOME:AT MORE TO EX*ANGE1 & WILL ) ! EXCESS PUR*ASE LUXURIES4 ,?IS1 :ILE IT MAY /IMULATE O!R 9DU/RIES1 WILL NOT 9CREASE ! CO/ ( ANY NECESS>IES TO ! NEI<BOR4 ,ANO!R PR9CIPLE WILL ALSO COME 9 TO R5D] !SE 9EQUALITIES LESS S]I\S1 IF !Y C\LD BE REG>D$ AS S]I\S AT ALL4 ,! PR9CIPLE ( S]V+ FIR/ ! FIR/ COM] W\LD R5D] ALL SU* 9EQUALITY ( LITTLE ACC\NT4 ,ONLY AS POPULATION 9CREAS$ & PROGRESS 9 PRODUCTION ADVANC$ W\LD ! LESS DESIRABLE PLACES COME 9TO REQUISITION4 ,! OLD] & FEEBLE W\LD BE 9 POSSESSION ( ! MORE PRODUCTIVE1 :ILE ! Y\NG & /RONG W\LD ATTACK ! MORE UNFRI5DLY SITUATION4 ,! R5T !ORY GOES ALWAYS UPON ! NOTION ?AT ! BE/ L& WILL KEEP PRODUC+ B\NTIFULLY YE> AFT] YE> & G5]ATION AFT] G5]ATION4 ,?IS IS FOLLY4 ,L& ,H[EV] F]TILE :5 FIR/ TAK5 UP OR :5 IT FIR/ COMES 9TO POSSESSION ( ! CULTIVATOR1 WILL SOON WORK D[N TO A CONDITION :]E IT WILL DO NO MORE ?AN IS DONE = IT4 ,ITS PRODUCTIV5ESS WILL !N DEP5D ON :AT IS DONE 9 ! WAY ( RETURN+ ! ELEM5TS ( F]TILITY & PROP] CULTURE4 ,! ORIG9AL DIFF]5CE ( MO/ CULTIVATABLE L& WILL SOON DISAPPE> UND] AN EQUITABLE SY/EM ( APPORTIONM5T & 9TELLIG5T USE4 

,G4 -- ,WELL1 ,I CAME TO READ Y\ A LECTURE ON ?IS SUBJECT1 BUT Y\ HAVE READ ME ONE4 ,I HAVE NEV] HE>D ! 0R5T !ORY0 ATTACK$ 9 ?IS WAY BE=E4 ,IF R5T MEANS ONLY ! DIFF]5T DEGREES ( PRODUCTIV5ESS ( DIFF]5T SOILS1 !RE SEEMS =CE 9 Y\R SUGGE/ION ?AT !N NO R5T C\LD BE COLLECT$ IF ALL L&S W]E EQUALLY DESIRABLE4 ,BUT IT IS QUITE APP>5T ?AT L&LORDISM C\LD NOT /& ON ANY SU* POSITION AS ?AT4 ,I %ALL HAVE TO MODIFY ! /ATEM5T BY SAY+ ?AT UND] PRIVATE [N]%IP ( ! SOIL MONOPOLY IS 5ABL$ TO EXACT ! DIFF]5CE BETWE5 ! PRODUCTION ( ! BE/ L& & ( SU* L& AS W\LD BE WORK$ = ITS 5TIRE PRODUCT )\T R5T4 

,J4 -- ,WELL1 DO Y\ NOT SEE ?AT Y\ PROCE$ 9 ! WRONG DIRECTION 9 DRAW+ Y\R CONCLUSION8 ,IT COMES RALLY TO AN ISSUE UPON ! QUE/ION AS TO ! 0NATURAL RATE ( WAGES40 ,ADAM ,SMI? ASS]TS ?AT TO BE ! 5TIRE LABOR PRODUCT4 ,RIC>DO1 ! AU?OR ( ! 0,!ORY ( ,R5T10 CONSI/5T ) HIS !ORY1 MAKES B>E SUBSI/5CE ! NATURAL RATE4 ,IF ?IS IS TRUE1 AS IT MU/ BE1 OR ! !ORY ( R5T BE AB&ON$1 !N R5T BEG9S AT ?IS 5D & NOT AT ! EXCESS 5D ( ! 9DU/RIAL PROBLEM1 & DOES NOT ABSOLUTELY REQUIRE ?AT ANY BUT ! POORE/ L&S BE CULTIVAT$ TO PRODUCE A R5T1 IF SU* L&S WILL YIELD ANY?+ BESIDES A B>E SUBSI/5CE TO ! CULTIVATOR4 

,:E!R ?IS !ORY W\LD WORK IF LEFT TO ! OP]ATION ( NATURAL LAWS IS ANO!R QUE/ION1 :I* IT WILL BE TIME 5\< TO EXAM9E :5 \R CLASS LAWS >E REPEAL$ & EQUAL OPPORTUNITIES >E 5JOY$4 

,IT W\LD BE V]Y EASY TO %[ ?AT COMMODITIES HAVE A PRICE ONLY BECAUSE !RE IS A DIFF]5CE 9 !IR QUALITY1 ETC4 ,= 9/ANCE1 ! PRICE ( POTATOES IS ONLY ! DIFF]5CE BETWE5 SIZE & QUALITY ( ?OSE MO/ DESIR$ & ?OSE :I* >E SO SMALL & ( SO POOR A QUALITY ?AT !Y CAN BE HAD = NO?+4 ,BUT AN ECONOMICS :O %\LD ATTEMPT TO 9CORPORATE SU* A CIRCUM/ANCE 9TO A BASIC ECONOMIC PR9CIPLE1 OR SEEK TO TAX BACK ! :OLE VALUE ?US F\ND = ! PUBLIC USE1 W\LD SIMPLY /ULTIFY HIMSELF4 

,Y\R MI/AKE >ISES 9 SUPPOS+ ?AT !RE IS SU* A ?+ AS WEAL? PRODUC$ )\T LABOR4 ,) EQUAL ACCESS TO ! E>? & ITS NATURAL SPONTANE\S PRODUCTION1 ! LABOR ( GA!R+ IS ALL !RE IS ( PRODUCTION1 & ALL ?AT ONE MAN CAN JU/LY EX*ANGE ) ANO!R HIS S]VICE HE HAS R5D]$ 9 SU* GA!R+4 ,& ?AT1 9 ! ABS5CE ( MONOPOLY1 IS ALL ?AT CAN HAVE PRICE4 ,H[ ONE :O /&S ALO( & DOES NO?+ T[>DS ?IS GA!R+ CAN CLAIM A PORTION ( ! WAGES ( ! GA!R] IS NOT CONSI/5T ) ANY CONCEIVABLE SY/EM ( EQUITY4 ,ONLY UPON REPAY+ ! S]VICE R5D]$ IS HE 5TITL$ TO ANY 9T]E/ 9 ! ?+ H>VE/$ & !N HE RECEIVES UND] AN EQUITABLE EX*ANGE ! SAME PROPORTION ACCORD+ TO HIS S]VICE AS ! MAN :O GA!R$4 

,9 ?IS WAY ! RI<T ( SOIL IS ESS5TIALLY V9DICAT$4 ,! >TISAN1 >TI/1 TEA*]1 LITT]ATEUR1 & FOLL[] ( ANY TRADE ( PR(ESSION IS PROTECT$1 = EA* REQUIRES & USUALLY CONSUMES QUITE AS MU* ( ! E>?'S PRODUCTS AS ! CULTIVATOR1 & ?AT1 TOO1 )\T R5D]+ DISPROPORTIONATE S]VICE4 ,:Y !N1 %\LD ! CULTIVATOR BE TAX$ TO B5EFIT ! O!RS8 ,UND] FREE L& ( EFFECTIVE LIMITATION ( ITS [N]%IP IT W\LD BE OPTIONAL ) ANYONE ( ANO!R CALL+ :O FELT HE WAS UNFAIRLY TREAT$ TO PLANT & GA!R ! FRUITS ( ! E>? HIMSELF4 ,ALL ?IS W\LD REQUIRE NO COMPLICAT$ S*EME ( TAXATION1 NO CUMB]SOME (FICIAL MA*9]Y1 BUT SIMPLY A REPEAL ( ! CLASS LAWS ( T5URE & ! EXT5SION ( ! PR9CIPLE ( LIMITATION F\ND SO SALUT>Y 9 ALL O!R MATT]S ( CIVIL RULE4 

,G4 -- ,9 VIEW ( ALL Y\ HAVE SAID1 ,I /ILL ?9K ?AT R5T >ISES1 TO AN EXT5T1 AT LEA/1 FROM A 0GRATUITY ( ,NATURE10 & DOES BELONG PROP]LY TO ! :OLE PEOPLE1 & ,I SEE NO BETT] ME?OD ?AN TO TAX AWAY ?IS GRATUITY FROM ! L&LORD = ! B5EFIT ( ALL4 

,J4 -- ,)\T >GU+ ?AT PO9T F>!R1 IT REALLY APPE>S TO ME ?AT TO E/IMATE ?AT AS A GRATUITY :I* IS ACKN[L$G$ TO BE 0! PRICE ( MONOPOLY10 IS ILLOGICAL 9 ! LA/ DEGREE4 ,IF ,NATURE HAS GRATUITIES1 IT IS = ?OSE :O GA!R !M4 ,) EQUAL OPPORTUNITY1 IF ANY REFUSE OR NEGLECT TO GA!R !M 7NOT 9FANTS OR DISABL$71 !Y HAVE NO EQUITABLE OR MORAL CLAIM UPON ?AT :I* O!R HAVE GA!R$2 =1 BY R5D]+ A RECIPROCAL S]VICE 9 ?AT :I* !Y PREF] TO DO1 !Y CAN SECURE :AT !Y NE$4 ,:E!R ANY SU* ?+ AS ECONOMIC R5T EXI/S AT ALL CAN ONLY BE DET]M9$ 9 ! ABS5CE ( MONOPOLY4 ,?AT R5TS >E GREATLY ABOVE ANY POSSIBLE BID = *OICE1 & :OLLY SEP>ATE !REFROM1 IS SE5 BY ! FACT ?AT1 :]E HI<E/1 PREMIUMS >E (T5 PAID ON LEASEHOLDS4 ,TAXATION ON A BASIS SO 9DEF9ITE1 SO :OLLY DEP5D5T ON MONOPOLY & ! LIMIT ( 5DURANCE :I* ! POOR WILL SU/A91 IS AS DEVOID ( ECONOMIC JUDGM5T AS ( DEMOCRATIC SIMPLICITY4 

,G4 -- ,BUT AN 5D MU/ BE PUT TO ! OPPRESSION ( L&LORDISM1 &1 AS ! L& CANNOT BE DIVID$ 9 SU* A WAY ?AT ALL %ALL %>E ITS B5EFIT4 ,I KNEW ( NO O!R WAY TO MAKE ! ?+ EQUITABLE4 ,! T5D5CY ( PRODUCTIVE 9DU/RY TO CONSOLIDATE ITSELF 9 ! H&S ( L>GE CORPORATIONS MU/ NECESS>ILY EXT5D TO ! CULTIVATION ( ! L&1 :]E IT IS SE5 ?AT A FEW L>GE 5T]PRISES CAN BE C>RI$ ON MU* MORE SUCCESSFULLY ?AN MANY SMALL ONES4 ,TO DIVIDE UP ! L& 9TO SMALL HOLD+S W\LD BE DETRIM5TAL TO PRODUCTION1 AS IS HELD BY MANY WRIT]S4 

,J4 -- ,BUT MANY WRIT]S ( EM95CE TAKE AN OPPOSITE VIEW1 CIT+ ,FRANCE1 ,BELGIUM1 ,SWITZ]L&1 @&C4 ,BUT1 ?\< ! ISSUE IS AT LEA/ EV5LY CONTE/$4 ,I DO NOT PROPOSE TO MAKE A PO9T ( ?AT4 ,EV5 IF :OLLY AS Y\ SAY1 9 ITS M]E RELATION TO PRODUCTION1 IT W\LD NOT BE CONCLUSIVE4 ,!RE >E O!R & BROAD] QUE/IONS ?AN ?AT ( L>GE PRODUCTION4 ,! MA9T5ANCE ( ! F]TILITY ( ! SOIL & ! DEVELOPM5T & IMPROVEM5T ( ! 9DIVIDUALS ( ! RACE >E AIMS TO :I* M9OR ECONOMIES %\LD BE SACRIFIC$1 IF NE$ BE4 

,G4 -- ,Y\ WILL ADMIT ?AT ! 0DIVISION ( LABOR0 HAS EXT]D$ A P[]FUL 9FLU5CE 9 ?AT DIRECTION6 

,J4 -- ,C]TA9LY2 BUT Y\ MU/ ALSO ADMIT ?AT1 C>RI$ TO ! EXTREMES :I* >E EXHIBIT$ 9 \R L>GE MANUFACTUR+ E/ABLI%M5TS1 IT T5DS TO R$UCE ! WORK] TO A M]E APP5DAGE ( A MA*9E1 & CAN HAVE ONLY ONE EFFECT1-- ! DET]IORATION ( ALL MANL9ESS & ! DE/RUCTION ( ALL SELF-RESPECT4 ,! PO9T+ ( A P91 AS A CONT95TAL EMPLOYM5T = TWELVE OR F\RTE5 H\RS A DAY1 CAN 5D ONLY BY R$UC+ ( P9S CAN WELL BE SACRIFIC$ TO A GREAT] DIV]SITY ( EMPLOYM5T = ! 9DIVIDUAL1 & ! DEVELOPM5T ( A HI<] MANHOOD2 IF NOT 9 ! 9T]E/ ( SIMPLE POLITICAL ECONOMY1 AT LEA/ 9 ! HI<] 9T]E/ ( SOCIAL ECONOMY4 

,G4 -- ,MY PLAN EMBRACES ! IDEA ( 0GIV+ TO EV]Y MAN ?AT :I* FAIRLY C>NS10 & TO CAPITAL :AT IS 0DUE = ITS USE20 BUT ?AT :I* GOES AS R5T TO ! L& ,I W\LD HAVE DIVID$ EQUALLY AMONG ALL1 S9CE IT BELONGS TO ALL4 ,9T]E/ ON MONEY & PR(ITS D]IV$ FROM COMMODITIES 9 PROCESS ( EX*ANGE & DI/RIBUTION >E DIFF]5T 9 !IR NATURE FROM R5T1 & >E REALIZ$ 0AFT] LABOR HAS BE5 DULY REW>D$40 

,J4 -- ,I AM AW>E ?AT ECONOMICTS SEEK TO DRAW ?IS DI/9CTION2 BUT IT IS :OLLY TE*NICAL4 ,! UNION ( CAPITAL ) LABOR IS NO MORE COMPLETE ?AN ( ! L& ) LABOR4 ,NO ESS5TIAL DIFF]5CE CAN BE %[N BETWE5 R5T1 9T]E/1 & PR(ITS4 

,R5T IS ! 9T]E/ UPON ! MONEY = :I* ! HIR$ L& W\LD EX*ANGE4 ,9T]E/ IS ! R5T ( ! L& :I* ! MONEY W\LD PUR*ASE4 ,IT CAN MAKE NO POSSIBLE DIFF]5CE TO ! F>M] :E!R ! SUM HE PAYS IS PAID AS R5T OR AS 9T]E/ ON ! PUR*ASE MONEY ( HIS F>M4 ,BO? ! R5T & 9T]E/ MAY BE LOAD$ ) EXP5SES1 TAXES1 REPAIRS1 @&C41 BUT /RIPP$ ( ALL !SE1 !Y >E ID5TICAL 9 ?IS3 !Y >E A TAX UPON ! PRODUCTION ( ?OSE :O WORK = ! B5EFIT ( ?OSE :O DO NO WORK4 ,PR(ITS >E ALSO LOAD$ ) CO/S ( SUP]9T5D5CE1 EXP5SES1 @&C4 ,/RIPP$ ( 0DUES = S]VICE10 H[EV]1 !Y >E ID5TICAL ) R5T & 9T]E/1-- AN 0IMMORAL TAX0 ON ! PRODUCTIONS ( 9DU/RY4 

,G4 -- ,BUT Y\ =GET ?AT ,I ASSUME ?AT R5T >ISES NOT FROM ! LABOR1 BUT 9DEP5D5T ( IT1 AS TAU<T BY ALL POLITICAL ECONOMIC/4 ,& IT IS TO TAX ?AT BACK = ! B5EFIT ( ALL ?AT ,I AM CONT5D+4 ,! QUE/ION ( 9T]E/ & PR(ITS IS HELD TO BE DIFF]5T FROM R5T2 BUT Y\R WAY PUTT+ IT IS NOVEL4 ,YET IT SEEMS TO ME !SE >E BO? RI<T1 & W\LD WORK NO GREAT EVIL BUT = A MONOPOLY ( ! L&4 

,J4 -- ,BUT !SE1 9 COMMON ) R5T1 TAKE SO MU* FROM ! ANNUAL PRODUCTION ( LABOR1 )\T ANY RETURN :ATSOEV]1 :5 /RIPP$ ( ! EXTRANE\S PORTIONS ) :I* !Y >E USUALLY CONNECT$4 ,I ?9K ,I HAVE SATISFACTORILY %[N ?AT R5T >ISES 9 NO SU* WAY AS CLAIM$1 BUT :OLLY AS 0A MONOPOLY PRICE20 ?AT WEAL? HAS NO SU* P[] ( 9CREASE AS IS CLAIM$ 9 JU/IFICATION ( 9T]E/ OR USURY2 ?AT TRADE HAS NO P[] TO MULTIPLY WEAL?1 & ?AT COMM]CE CAN ONLY ADD TO ! WEAL? ( SOCIETY BY P]=M+ SPECIFIC S]VICE 9 ITS PRODUCTION :]E & :5 NE$$ = CONSUMPTION1 & ?AT :5 SU* S]VICE IS FAIRLY REW>D$1 NO?+ REMA9S = PR(ITS BUT AN IMMORAL TAX4 

,G4 -- ,BUT SURELY Y\ DO NOT PROPOSE TO CONTROL 9T]E/ & PR(ITS AS WELL AS R5T8 ,?AT W\LD 9VOLVE A DEGREE ( GOV]NM5TAL SUP]VISION :I* ,I AM SURE W\LD BE REPUGNANT TO ! SPIRIT ( ANY FREE PEOPLE4 

,J4 -- ,D\BTLESS2 BUT ! DILEMMA IS Y\RS1 NOT M9E4 ,I WAS JU/ GO+ TO SAY ?AT1 WAIV+ MY OBJECTIONS TO ! 0R5T !ORY10 ADMITT+ ! P[] ( WEAL? TO 9CREASE ( ITSELF )\T LABOR1 & ( COMMODITIES 9 PROCESS ( EX*ANGE TO MULTIPLY ON ! H&S ( ! HOLD]S1-- ?\< EA* PROPOSITION IS VA/LY ABSURD1-- ! CONCLUSION IS UNAVOIDABLE ?AT 9T]E/ ON MONEY & PR(ITS ON TRADE >E EQUALLY GRATUITIES >IS+ 9 ,NATURE1 TO :I* ALL >E EQUALLY 5TITL$ AS WELL AS TO ! ECONOMIC R5T >IS+ FROM ! L&4 ,H[ Y\ CAN LOGICALLY REFUSE TO TAX BACK ! MONEY & TRADE VALUES1 IF AN SU* NATURALLY EXI/1 AS WELL AS ! L& VALUES IS A MATT] ( GREAT WOND] TO ME4 

,G4 -- ,BUT ,I SEE NO O!R ME?OD ( R$RESS+ ! GREAT WRONG ( L& MONOPOLY1 &1 ?AT EVIL OBVIAT$1 IT SEEMS TO ME ?AT ! O!R EVILS W\LD REM$Y !MSELVES1 IF !Y >E EVILS4 

,J4 -- ,?AT IS ALSO MY BELIEF4 ,9 Y\R PLAN1 H[EV]1 ,I SEE NO C]TA9TY ( REM$Y+ ! BASIC EVIL4 ,TO DO AWAY ) L& MONOPOLY ONLY ONE C\RSE IS OP51-- ABOLI% IT1 AS *ATTEL SLAV]Y WAS ABOLI%$4 ,REPEAL ALL LAWS GIV+ TITLES TO L& & MAKE OCCUPATION ! ONLY VALID T5URE4 ,?IS W\LD DO AWAY ) ALL DISCUSSION AS TO ! NATURE ( PROP]TY 9 IT4 ,PRODUCTION IS ! ONLY ?+ :I* CAN BE TAX$4 ,IMPROVEM5TS %\LD BE EXEMPT1 :ILE CO]CIVE TAXATION REMA9S4 ,! 0,NO-,R5T0 MANIFE/O IS ! TRUE GOSPEL ( ,L& ,RE=M & BECOMES REALIZ$ AS SOON AS ! LEGAL PROCESS = COLLECTION & = EJECTM5T IS TAK5 AWAY1 & ! CON/ABLE & SOLDI] >E )DRAWN FROM 5=C+ SU* LAWS4 ,ONLY C\RAGE & MORAL PURPOSE 9 ! PEOPLE >E NECESS>Y TO ABOLI% ?IS GREAT EVIL2 S*EMES & PLANS TO CIRCUMV5T IT1 BY 9DIRECT MEANS1 WILL PROVE VA94 

,G4- ,BUT ! DIFFICULTY /ILL REMA9S4 ,EQUAL DI/RIBUTION IS IMPOSSIBLE4 ,BESIDES1 SOME WANT MU* L&1 O!RS LITTLE1 & /ILL O!RS NONE AT ALL4 0,NATIONALIZATION MI<T BE *ANG$ TO ,T[N%IPIZATION10.<#a.> & SO ! LOCAL GOV]NM5T1 :ATEV] ITS =M1 HAVE CONTROL4 ,! L>GE HOLD]S W\LD !N %>E1 UND] ! SY/EM ( TAXATION1 ) ?OSE :O HELD LITTLE OR NONE4 ,EA* W\LD R5T ( ALL1 & SO ! VALUES BE EQUALLY DI/RIBUT$4 

,J4 -- ,I AM V]Y GLAT TO HE> Y\ SAY ?IS4 ,IT IS ONE /EP MORE 9 ! RI<T DIRECTION4 ,?IS W\LD APPROA* NE>LY TO ! T[N%IP OR VILLAGE COMMUNITY1 ONCE ! G5]AL SY/EM ( L& T5URE 9 ,EUROPE4 ,A /EP OR TWO MORE WILL PLACE YO ON SOLID GR\ND4 ,! FAMILIZATION & 9DIVIDUALIZATION ( ! L& FOLL[ AS A LOGICAL SEQU5CE FROM Y\R ADMISSION4 

,G4 -- ,BUT Y\ DO NOT NOTICE MY PO9T ?AT MANY 9DIVIDUALS DO NOT WANT L& AT ALL4 

,J4 -- ,I WAS AB\T TO SAY ?AT IS UNTRUE4 ,EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL NE$S A PLACE TO LIVE & WORK 94 ,?US F> ! WANTS ( ALL >E NE>LY EQUAL4 ,WE >E 0T5ANTS 9 COMMON10 UPON ! BOSOM ( MO!R ,E>?1 & NO ONE HAS ANY JU/ CLAIM AGA9/ ANO!R = OBTA9+ ?AT :I* ) EQUAL OPPORTUNITY HE DECL9ES TO APPROPRIATE4 ,HIS REFUSAL TO OCCUPY PROVES ?AT HE E/IMATES HIS ADVANTAGE TO ! OCCUPI] IS QUITE IF NOT MORE ?AN COMP5SAT$ ?R\< RECIPROCAL EX*ANGE4 

,!RE EXI/S NO REASON :Y ANY ONE %\LD HIRE A HOME :I* DOES NOT APPLY ) GREAT] =CE TO ! REASONS :Y HE %\LD [N IT4 ,EV5 A S+LE ROOM CAN BE [N$1 S9CE IT CAN BE HIRE4 ,REQUIR+ TO *ANGE HIS RESID5CE1 ONE W\LD EXP]I5CE NO MORE DIFFICULTY 9 F9D+ A PUR*AS] ?AN W\LD ! L&LORD 7NATION OR T[N%IP7 9 F9D+ A T5ANT = IT4 ,ANY DISPOSITION ( ! L& :I* DOES NOT EMBRACE ! PRIVATE [N]%IP ( HOME & ! NORMAL 5VIRONM5T ( ! 9DIVIDUAL WILL NOT BE ! F9AL ONE4 ,UND] ?AT1 EV5 ! *ANGEFUL & MIGRATORY W\LD F9D NO S]I\S 9CONV5I5CE1 :I* ! MANY W\LD 5JOY1 9 ITS SECURITY & /ABILITY1 A P]MAN5T RELIANCE1 & 9 ITS HEAL?FUL /IMULUS1 ! NOBLE/ 9C5TIVES TO BEAUTIFY & ADORN ! LIMIT$ PORTION FALL+ TO !IR CONTROL4 

.<#a.> ,! 9TRODUCTORY PORTION ( ?IS >TICLE1 PREC$+ ! DIALOGUE1 APPE>$ ORIG9ALY 9 ! 0,IRSIH ,WORLD40 ,! REMA9D] WAS (F]$ TO ! $ITOR ( ?AT PAP]1 BUT REJECT$ BY HIM4 -- ,$ITOR ,LIB]TY4 

.<#b.> ,SEE ,H5RY ,GEORGE 9 0,IRI% ,WORLD0 = ,AUGU/ #b#f4 

,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,JANU>Y #a#c1 #bba 3 ,LIB]TY ,VOL4 ,I,I4 ,NO4 #a4 -- ,ADD$4 
,JANU>Y #f1 #bbb 3 ,LIB]TY ,VOL4 ,I,I4 ,NO4 #a4 -- ,UPDAT$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/