,LIB]TY ,VOL4 ,I,I4 ,NO4 #c4 
,NOT ! ,DAU<T] BUT ! ,MO!R ( ,ORD] 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,B5JAM9 ,R4 ,TUCK] 

,TEXT 3 

0,= ALWAYS 9 ?9E EYES1 ,O ,LIB]TY6 

,%9ES ?AT HI< LI<T :]EBY ! WORLD IS SAV$2 

,& ?\< ?\ SLAY US1 WE WILL TRU/ 9 !E40 

,JOHN ,HAY4 

,ON ,PICKET ,DUTY4 

,! TRUE/ & MO/ IMPORTANT ?+ SAID BY ,G5]AL ,BUTL] DUR+ HIS REC5T CAMPAIGN = ! GOV]NOR%IP WAS ?IS3 0,Y\ HE> AB\T M5 MAK+ MONEY2 !Y GET IT AWAY FROM EA* O!R4 ,IT IS ALL PRODUC$ FROM ! SOIL AT FIR/40 ,?IS IS A SIMPLE1 PLA91 & =CIBLE WAY ( SAY+ ?AT 9T]E/1 R5T1 & PR(IT >E DI%ONE/ AB/RACTIONS FROM ! POCKETS ( LABOR4 

,LIB]TY SC>CELY GETS A FAIR %[ 9 ! 0,NOR? ,AM]ICAN ,REVIEW0 DISCUSSION CONC]N+ ! SUPPRESSION ( OBSC5E LIT]ATURE BETWE5 ,AN?ONY ,COM/OCK1 AID$ BY A CL]GYMAN1 ON ! ONE H&1 & ,O4 ,B4 ,FRO?+HAM ON ! O!R4 ,TWO AGA9/ ONE1 & ?AT ONE HALF 9 SYMPA?Y ) ! 5EMY1 IS NOT A CONDITION ( A SQU>E FI<T4 ,EI!R ,JAMES ,P>TON OR ,ELIZUR ,WRI<T W\LD HAVE BE5 A MU* MORE ACCEPTABLE & EFFECTIVE *AMPION ( ,LIB]TY4 ,:Y WAS NOT ONE ( !M 9VIT$ TO 5T] ! LI/S8 

,! ,BO/ON 0,ADV]TIZ]10 REF]R+ TO ! /ATEM5T MADE 9 A REC5T CABLE DISPAT* ?AT ! ,FR5* ,AN>*I/S HAVE CORRESPOND5TS 9 ,BO/ON & ,MONTEVIDEO1 SAYS ?AT 0! BOA/ ( ! REVOLUTIONI/S ?AT !Y HAVE A CORRESPOND5T 9 ,BO/ON IS EMPTY4 ,ANY FOOL 9 ANY P>T ( ! WORLD CAN EX*ANGE VAPOR+S ) SOME ONE 9 ,BO/ON40 ,:5 ONE CONSID]S ?AT 9 ?IS 9/ANCE ! 0TOOLS0 >E SU* M5 AS ,PR9CE ,KROPOTK91 A PROM95T CONTRIBUTOR TO ! 0,5CYCLOP$IA ,BRITANNICA0 & ! ,5GLI% REVIEWS1 & ,ELISEE ,RECLUS1 P]HAPS ! =EMO/ GEOGRAPH] ( ! WORLD1 ! 0,ADV]TIZ]'S0 /ATEM5T IS SE5 TO BE *>ACT]I/ICALLY RIDICUL\S1 & >\SES ! QU]Y :E!R ANY ASS 9 ! 0,ADV]TIZ]0 (FICE CAN %[ HIS -- WELL1 HIS PO/]IOR 9 ! $ITORIAL COLUMN4 ,SO 9DEC5T AN EXPOSURE SEEMS EXPLICABLE ON NO O!R HYPO!SIS4 

,= ! FOLL[+ 9T]E/+ & 9/RUCTIVE ITEM WE >E 9DEBT$ TO ! ,LONDON 0,TRU?03 0,M4 ,ELISEE ,RECLUS1 ! ILLU/RI\S AU?OR ( ! ',GEOGRAPHIE ,UNIV]SELLE1' HAS 9AUGURAT$ FREE M>RIAGE1 & UNIT$ HIS TWO DAU<T]S 'FREELY' TO TWO Y\NG M5 ( !IR *OICE4 ,?IS ADV]B 'FREELY' MEANS ?AT ,M4 ,RECLUS HAS DISP5S$ NOT ONLY ) ! RELIGI\S C]EMONY ( M>RIAGE1 BUT ALSO ) ! CIVIL M>RIAGE 9 PRES5CE ( ! MAYOR4 ,HE SIMPLY 9VIT$ HIS FRI5DS & RELATIVES TO A BANQUET AT ! ,GR& ,HOTEL1 OV] :I* HE PRESID$1 MORE AVORUM1 & !RE & !N1 LIT]ALLY 5TRE LES POIRES ET LE FROMAGE1 OR1 AS WE %\LD SAY1 'ACROSS ! WALNUTS & ! W9E1' HE DECL>$ ! UNION ( HIS TWO GIRLS ) !IR RESPECTIVE SWEE!>TS40 ,?IS V]Y S5SIBLE CONDUCT IS SAID TO HAVE MADE A 0PA9FUL IMPRESSION0 UPON ,M4 ,RECLUS'S SCI5TIFIC FRI5DS 9 ,5GL&4 ,*>ITY PROMPTS ! HOPE ?AT !SE PURE S\LS MAY F9D AN E>LY OPPORTUNITY ( ASC5SION & ?US BE SAV$ ! UTT] AGONY SURE TO BE 9FLICT$ UPON !M1 IF !Y LIVE A FEW YE>S LONG]1 9 CONSEQU5CE ( ! GR[+ 9CL9ATION TO FOLL[ ,M4 ,RECLUS'S WISE EXAMPLE4 

,LIB]TY TAKES ! GREATE/ SATISFACTION 9 CALL+ ATT5TION TO A PAMPHLET LATELY RECEIV$1 5TITL$ 0,LIB]TY & ,MORALITY10 & WRITT5 BY ,W4 ,S4 ,BELL4 ,WE W>MLY GREET IT AS ONE ( ! MANY EVID5CES N[ ACCUMULAT+ ON EV]Y H& ?AT \R WORK IS TELL+1 ?AT WE >E HAV+ AN 9FLU5CE ON ! PUBLIC M9D1 & ?AT WE >E $UCAT+ ! TEA*]S4 ,IT IS WRITT5 TO %[ ! TYRANNY ( COMPULSORY MORAL /&>DS & ! FUTILITY ( EXPECT+ MORALITY TO ?RIVE EXCEPT AS 9CREAS+ ,LIB]TY PREVAILS2 & AL?\< ! WORD ,AN>*Y IS NOT 7WE BELIEVE7 TO BE F\ND 9 IT1 SC>CELY A PAGE BUT CONTA9S AN EPIGRAMMATIC S5T5CE :I* MI<T FITLY S]VE AS A MOTTO = ?IS OR ANY O!R ,AN>*I/IC J\RNAL4 ,?R\<\T IT IS ELOQU5T1 DISCRIM9AT+1 & PR(\ND1 & 9DICATIVE ( A DEGREE ( ABILITY = :I* WE HAVE NEV] GIV5 ITS AU?OR CR$IT4 ,HE ORIG9ALLY DELIV]$ IT AS A LECTURE BE=E ! ,WATK9S ,FREE?9K]S' ,CONV5TION1 & PROPOSES TO REPEAT IT FREQU5TLY DUR+ AN APPROA*+ LECTURE T\R 9 ! ,WE/4 ,WE BESPEAK = HIM & HIS ?\<T A HE>TY WELCOME4 ,HE MAY BE ADDRESS$ AT 0#a#h ,EA/ ,SPR+FIELD ,/REET1 ,BO/ON1 ,MASS40 

,ANO!R \TRAGE ON ! FRE$OM ( ! PRESS HAS BE5 COMMITT$ BY ,AN?ONY ,COM/OCK4 ,AB\T A =TNI<T AGO HE VISIT$ ,PR9CETON1 & >RE/$ ,E4 ,H4 ,HEYWOOD1 $ITOR ( ! 0,WORD10 :O HAS BE5 ONCE BE=E HIS VICTIM4 ,MR4 ,HEYWOOD WAS BR\<T TO ,BO/ON & PLAC$ 9 ,*>LES ,/REET JAIL1 :]E HE REMA9$ OV] TWO NI<TS & WAS !N BAIL$ \T BY HIS BRO!R1 ,S4 ,R4 ,HEYWOOD1 ( ,WORCE/]1 :O APP>5TLY HAS 0EXP]I5C$ A *ANGE ( HE>T40 ,IT IS NOT DEF9ITELY KN[N :AT ALL ! *>GES TO BE PREF]R$ AGA9/ ,MR4 ,HEYWOOD >E1 BUT HE IS UND\BT$LY TO BE COMPLA9$ ( = CIRCULAT+ A PR9T$ SLIP CONTA9+ ! TWO 0OBJECTIONABLE0 POEMS FROM 0,LEAVES ( ,GRASS0 & = ADV]TIS+ AN >TICLE KN[N AS ! ,COM/OCK SYR+E = ! PREV5TION ( CONCEPTION4 ,9 BO? !SE ACTS ,MR4 ,HEYWOOD ONLY DID :AT HE HAD A P]FECT RI<T TO DO AGA9/ ! :OLE WORLD1 & IT IS ! DUTY ( EV]Y E>NE/ ,LIB]AL TO COME TO HIS AID 9 HIS H\R ( TRIAL4 ,9 ?IS CONNECTION WE MU/ EXPRESS \R 9DIGNATION AT ! C[>DLY CONDUCT ( ,D4 ,M4 ,B5NETT1 $ITOR ( ! 0,TRU?-,SEEK]10 :O PRATES AB\T ,MR4 ,HEYWOOD'S TA/E & ME?ODS4 ,WE DO NOT APPROVE ( ,MR4 ,HEYWOOD'S TA/E & ME?ODS1 BUT NEI!R DID WE ( ,MR4 ,B5NETT'S :5 WE DID \R LITTLE BE/ A FEW YE>S AGO TO SAVE HIM FROM ,COM/OCK'S CLUT*ES4 ,IT IS NOT A QUE/ION ( TA/E1 BUT ( ,LIB]TY1 & NO MAN :O FAILS TO SEE ?IS & ACT ACCORD+LY CAN OV] FAIRLY CALL HIMSELF A ,LIB]AL AGA94 ,MR4 ,HEYWOOD'S PRELIM9>Y EXAM9ATION WILL COME (F 9 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES C\RT-H\SE ,NOVEMB] #a#f1 & WE HOPE ?AT EV]Y FRI5D ( ,LIB]TY WILL ATT5D TO GIVE ! PRISON] C\NT5ANCE4 ,N[1 A FEW PLA9 WORDS TO ,MR4 ,HEYWOOD HIMSELF4 ,HE IS V]Y LIKELY1 9 \R OP9ION1 TO BE CLE>$ ON ! 0,LEAVES ( ,GRASS0 *>GE1 BUT 9 REG>D TO ! SYR+E HIS POSITION SEEMS TO US V]Y 0TICKLI%40 ,! /ATUTE :I* =BIDS ! ADV]TIS+ ( SYR+ES1 ETC41 IS SO DEF9ITE AS TO ADMIT ( NO IMPORTANT DIFF]5CE ( 9T]PRETATION1 & ,MR4 ,HEYWOOD HAS BUT ONE HOPE WOR? TRU/+ TO (-ESCAP+ ITS 5=CEM5T UPON HIM4 ,?AT HOPE LIES 9 HIS ABILITY TO CONV9CE SOME MEMB] ( ! JURY ?AT HE HAS ! RI<T1 REG>DLESS ( ! C\RT'S 9/RUCTIONS1 TO JUDGE1 NOT ONLY ! FACTS1 BUT ! LAW & ! JU/ICE ( ! LAW4 ,IF ,MR4 ,HEYWOOD IS %REWD1 HE WILL EMPLOY NO LAWY] EXCEPT 9 AN ADVISORY CAPACITY1 BUT WILL BR+ HIS [N WELL-KN[N P[]S ( ORATORY & >GUM5T DIRECTLY TO BE> UPON ! JURY 9 NAIL+ & CL9*+ ?AT PO9T4 ,O!RWISE1 IT IS TO BE FE>$ ?AT HIS FATE WILL BE A H>D ONE4 

0,A FREE MAN IS ONE :O 5JOYS ! USE ( HIS REASON & HIS FACULTIES2 :O IS NEI!R BL9D$ BY PASSION1 NOT H9D]$ OR DRIV5 BY OPPRESSION1 NOT DECEIV$ BY ]RONE\S OP9IONS40 -- ,PR\DHON4 

,= A ,SPY'S ,5LI<T5M5T4 

,AN?ONY ,COM/OCK3 

,DESPICABLE ,SIR1-- ,I AM 9=M$ BY ,MR4 ,E4 ,H4 ,HEYWOOD ?AT1 9 A LETT] :I* Y\ REC5TLY ADDRESS$ TO HIM OV] ! FALSE SIGNATURE ( 0,J4 ,A4 ,MATTOCK0 9 ACCORDANCE ) Y\R USUAL DI%ONE/ PRACTICE1 Y\ ASK$ !SE QUE/IONS3 0,:AT IS ,MR4 ,TUCK]'S ADDRESS & HIS FIR/ NAME8 ,WAS IT ,FRANKL9 OR ,FRANCIS1 C\LD Y\ GIVE ME HIS ADDRESS40 

,I DO NOT KN[ :E!R ,MR4 ,HEYWOOD HAS ACCOMMODAT$ Y\ ) ! DESIR$ 9=MATION2 !RE=E P]MIT ME1 LE/ HE HAS NOT DONE SO1 TO IMP>T TO Y\ ! KN[L$GE ( :I* Y\ >E 9 SE>*1 ?\< KN[+ FULL WELL ?AT1 HYPOCRITE ?AT Y\ >E1 Y\ ASK = :AT Y\ ALREADY KN[ & HAVE KN[N = SOME YE>S PA/1 Y\R SOLE PURPOSE 9 SO ASK+ HAV+ BE5 TO MISLEAD ,MR4 ,HEYWOOD 9TO ! BELIEF ?AT HE WAS DEAL+ ) AN HONE/ 9QUIR] 9/EAD ( ) A SNEAK & A SPY4 

,MY NAME & ADDRESS Y\ WILL F9D APP5D$ TO ?IS LETT]4 ,ANY?+ BE>+ ?AT ADDRESS WILL PRETTY SURELY REA* ME4 ,ANY COMM&S ( A BUS9ESS NATURE 7,I DECL9E ALL O!R CORRESPOND5CE ) Y\7 SO RECEIV$ 9 RESPONSE TO ADV]TISEM5TS ( M9E ,I %ALL TAKE PA9S TO FULFILL ) MY USUAL FAI?FULNESS1 :E!R PURPORT+ TO ISSUE FROM ,AN?ONY ,COM/OCK OR ONE ( ! NUM]\S 9DIVIDUALS :OSE NAMES HE HAS BEF\L$ BY FALSELY ASSUM+4 ,I RECOMM5D Y\1 H[EV]1 TO USE Y\R [N NAME H]EAFT]1 & ?US MAKE NO BLACK] ! DISGRACEFUL RECORD ( :AT W\LD BE Y\R %AME W]E Y\ NOT %AMELESS4 

,ACCEPT1 SIR1 ! E>NE/ ASSURANCE ( MY PR(\NDE/ CONTEMPT4 

,B5J4 ,R4 ,TUCK]4 

,BOX #c#c#f#f1 ,BO/ON1 ,MASS41 ,NOVEMB] #a#a1 #a#h#h#b4 

,AM]ICAN ,CZ>DOM ,UNMASK$4 

,! GOV]NM5T ( ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES IS ! MO/ ABSOLUTE DESPOTISM ON ! FACE ( ! E>?4 ,! RAG UPON :I* IS EMBLAZON$ ! />S & /RIPES IS A PA9T$ FRAUD4 ,! ROBB] BIRD IS ALONE TRU?FUL AMONG \R NATIONAL SYMBOLS4 

0,FANATICISM60 CRIES SOME CONCEIT$ ,AM]ICAN ,F\R?-(-,JULY PHILOSOPH]2 & D\BTLESS1 :5 HE READS SU* A %OCK+ 9DICTM5T1 A SUPPRESS$ LONG+ ?AT ,AN?ONY ,COM/OCK MAY YET ABLE TO REA* SU* ,AN>*I/IC MISCREANTS 9 HIS PI\S RAID UPON BLASPHEMY & 9FIDELITY SEIZES HIM4 

,BUT LET US REASON A LITTLE TOGE!R6 ,:AT W\LD NATURALLY BE ! MO/ ABSOLUTE DESPOTISM AMONG GOV]NM5TS8 ,W\LD IT NOT BE ?AT GOV]NM5T FROM :OSE DICTUM1 AS EXPRESS$ UND] ITS =MS1 !RE WAS ! LEA/ POSSIBILITY ( APPEAL8 

0,& IS ?IS ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES80 CRIES ! 9DIGNANT PATRIOT1 FRE% FROM ! GU% ( ! ,SUNDAY S*OOL & ! DRIPP+S ( ! POLITICAL RO/RUM4 

,YES1 IT IS ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES ABOVE EV]Y O!R GOV]NM5T ON ! FACE ( ! E>?4 ,!RE IS AN ELEM5T 9 \R 9/ITUTIONS MORE /RONGLY & SACR$LY =TIFI$ AGA9/ APPEAL ?AN >E ALL ! POMP\S ASSUMPTIONS ( ! CZ> ( ,RUSSIA & ! O!R CR[N$ DESPOTS ( ,EUROPE1 & ?IS CLEM5T IS AN EV] ACTIVE1 UNIV]SAL1 & TIRELESS ONE4 ,IT IS ! SO-CALL$ 0WILL ( ! MAJORITY40 

,! CZ>1 BE+ ONE ) ,GOD BY DIV9E RI<T1 IS ( C\RSE A MAJORITY4 ,BUT1 ?ANKS TO ! RI<TE\S ACTIVITY ( ! ,NIHILI/S1 !RE IS A POSSIBILITY ( EFFECTIVE APPEAL 9 ,RUSSIA1 & IT IS ONLY A QUE/ION ( TIME :5 ! HEAD ( ?AT MAJORITY WILL BE EI!R CUT (F OR BL[N (F4 ,9 ?AT CASE !RE IS TOL]ABLE CAUSE TO HOPE ?AT ANO!R MAJORITY-HEAD ( ?AT /AMP WILL NOT D>E TO %[ ITSELF4 ,IF IT DOES1 !N ! ,NIHILI/S >E PREP>$ TO REE*O ! WORDS ( ,AM]ICA'S PSY*O-LOGICAL-BOMB EXECUTION]1 ,GEORGE ,FRANCIS ,TRA93-- 0,WE'LL GO Y\ SIX1 T51 OR A DOZ5 CZ>S BETT]60 

,! CZ>DOM ONCE EXT]M9AT$1 ! ABSOLUTE DESPOTISM PECULI> TO ,RUSSIA IS ABOLI%$4 ,! EMPIRE ONCE OV]?R[N 9 ,G]MANY1 ! PECULI> MAJORITY DESPOTISM :I* ,BISM>CK HAS SO LONG WIELD$ IS NO MORE4 ,9 ALL ?OSE MON>*ICAL C\NTRIES LOV]S ( JU/ICE SEE A SURE WAY ( SUCCESSFUL APPEAL AHEAD ( !M1 & !Y >E IMPROV+ IT ) A RAPIDITY ?AT HAUNTS !IR CR[N$ OPPRESSORS DAY & NI<T4 

,BUT :AT %[ ( APPEAL IS !RE FROM ! ,AM]ICAN SPECIES ( DESPOTISM8 ,IF IT W]E A S+LE HEAD1 IT C\LD NOT /AY ON LONG4 ,IF IT W]E ANY MOD]ATE NUMB] ( HEADS UPON :OM ! :OLE RESPONSIBILITY C\LD BE DI/9CTLY FIX$1 ?OSE HEADS W\LD PROBABLY BO TAK5 (F4 ,! FACT IS ?AT ! ROOT ( MAJORITY DESPOTISM 9 ?IS C\NTRY IS A SUP]/ITION F\ND 9 ALMO/ EV]YBODY'S HEAD1 & :I* C\LD NOT BE EXT]M9AT$ EV5 IF MILLIONS ( HEADS W]E TAK5 (F4 ,ON GR\NDS ( UTILITY AS WELL AS HUMANITY1 !N1 ! ,AM]ICAN ,AN>*I/ MU/ TR\BLE NO MAN'S HEAD ANY F>!R ?AN TO GET ! SUP]/ITION \T & GET SOME?+ BETT] 94 

0,! WILL ( ! MAJORITY60 ,SO SAYS ! CZ> TOO2 SIMPLY SUPPLEM5T+ IT BY ! MODE/ CLAUSE1 0& ,I AM ! MAJORITY40 0,! WILL ( ! MAJORITY60 ,SO SAYS ,BISM>CK2 ONLY ADD+ ! SIGNIFICANT CONDITION1 0& ! EMP]OR1 MYSELF1 & ! >MY >E ! MAJORITY40 

,BUT :5 ! ,AM]ICAN SAYS1 0,! WILL ( ! MAJORITY60 HE MEANS 9 HIS %ALL[ CONTE/ A TREM5D\SLY BIG ?+4 ,! PROGRESSIVE ,RUSSIAN & ,G]MAN1 SEE+ :AT A MAJORITY MEANS UND] !IR SY/EMS1 DO NOT BELIEVE 9 IT1 & >E DET]M9$ TO ?R[ IT (F !IR NECKS4 ,! AV]AGE ,AM]ICAN1 H[EV]1 F9DS 9 A MAJORITY SOME?+ V]Y SACR$1 V]Y RESPECTABLE1 & BEYOND APPEAL4 0,! MAJORITY HAVE YE EV] ) Y\10 MI<T WELL BE WRITT5 ON ! DOME ( ! ,CAPITOL AS A FITT+ SATIRE ON \R NATIONAL SUP]FICIALITY4 ,YES1 ) US1 & AGA9/ US TOO4 

,?IS 0WILL ( ! MAJORITY0 IS ! V]Y DESPOT ITSELF :I*1 9 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES ABOVE ANY O!R C\NTRY1 CANNOT BE REA*$4 ,9 ! FIR/ PLACE !RE IS NO POSSIBILITY UND] \R SY/EM1 OR ANY O!R SY/EM1 ( EV] F9D+ \T :AT IS ! WILL ( ! MAJORITY1 & 9 ! SECOND PLACE1 EV5 IF IT W]E POSSIBLE TO F9D \T ! WILL ( ! MAJORITY1 ?AT MAJORITY2 9 ASSUM+ TO BE SOV]EIGN OV] ! M9ORITY1 OR EV5 OV] ONE S+LE 9DIVIDUAL )\T HIS CONS5T1 IS ON EXACTLY ! SAME PLANE AS ! CZ>1-- 9 FACT1 IS SIMPLY ! CZ> TRANS=M$4 ,FROM ! ,RUSSIAN DESPOT !RE IS1 AS ! WORLD RECOGNIZES ) MORE OR LOSS SATISFACTION1 A SURE WAY ( APPEAL4 ,FROM ! ,AM]ICAN DESPOT !RE IS NO IMM$IATE WAY ( APPEAL4 ,ONE MAJORITY SUCCE$S ANO!R1 MAK+ \R DESPOTISM ROT>Y1 BUT ! DESPOT IS ALWAYS !RE1 & ! ,AM]ICAN IS ! EXCEPTIONAL POLITICAL DUPE AMONG ! NATIONS TO AFFIRM ?AT HIS DESPOT IS SACR$1 IMMUTABLE1 & BEYOND APPEAL4 

,! LEGITIMATE EFFECT ( ?IS ABJECT S]VILITY TO MAJORITY RULE IS ?AT A PEOPLE /ULTIFI$ BY IT NATURALLY LIE D[N & SUBMIT TO ! MO/ 9IQUIT\S ASSAULTS UPON 9DIVIDUAL ,LIB]TY )\T A PROTE/1 IF IT DO? ONLY APPE> ?AT IT WAS ! 0WILL ( ! MAJORITY40 ,9 ?IS RESPECT ,AM]ICANS >E ! GREATE/ C[>DS ON ! FACE ( ! E>?4 ,H]B]T ,SP5C]1 ! EM95T SOCIOLOGI/1 HAS DISCOV]$ BY CONTACT ) US :AT HE HAD ALREADY SCI5TIFICALLY ANTICIPAT$1-- ?AT ,AM]ICANS >E %AMELESSLY 9DIFF]5T TO SMALL 5CROA*M5TS UPON !IR 9DIVIDUAL RI<TS4 ,9 A LATE 9T]VIEW HE REM>K$ ?AT WE W]E /EADILY GO+ ! WAY ( ! ,ITALIAN REPUBLICS ( ! MIDDLE AGES1 9 :I* 0:ILE !RE WAS GR[+ UP A GREAT COMM]CIAL ACTIVITY1 A DEVELOPM5T ( ! >TS :I* MADE !M ! 5VY ( ,EUROPE1 & A BUILD+ ( PR9CELY MANSIONS :I* /ILL CONT9UE TO BE ! ADMIRATION ( TRAVEL]S1 !IR PEOPLE W]E GRADUALLY LOS+ !IR LIB]TY04 

,9 NO O!R C\NTRY 9 ! WORLD C\LD SO PALPABLE A HYPOCRITE AS ,AN?ONY ,COM/OCK 9VADE ! P]SONAL ,LIB]TY ( CITIZ5S ) BOA/+ IMPUNITY4 ,SOME ( ,H]B]T ,SP5C]'S /RICTURES ON ,AM]ICAN 9DIFF]5CE LOOK V]Y MU* AS ?\< A KN[L$GE ( ,COM/OCK'S 9FAM\S DO+S WAS 9 HIS M9D :5 HE SPOKE4 

,:5 ! CZ> & ,BISM>CK 9VADE ,LIB]TY ( ! PRESS1 !Y DO IT ) DIRECTNESS1 & ) SOME %[ ( DIGNITY & HONOR4 ,COM/OCK COMP\NDS ) CRIME1 DECOYS HIS VICTIMS1 OP5LY PUBLI%ES HIS DET]M9ATION TO SUPPRESS 09FIDELITY & BLASPHEMY10 & YET ! ,AM]ICAN PEOPLE WILL SEE A MAN GO TO PRISON1 = PUBLI%+ HIS OP9IONS ON SOCIOLOGY1 ) ! GREATE/ UNCONC]N1 BECAUSE ,COM/OCK D]IVES HIS AU?ORITY FROM AN ACT ( ,CONGRESS1 & ,CONGRESS MEANS 0! WILL ( ! MAJORITY40 

,A MI<TY $UCATIONAL WORK IS AHEAD ( TRUE RE=M]S4 ,IT MAY TAKE A LONG :ILE BE=E ?AT WORK WILL BEG9 TO EFFECT S]I\S HEADWAY AGA9/ ,AM]ICAN POLITICAL SUP]/ITION2 BUT1 IF ,LIB]TY CAN ONLY SUCCESSFULLY 9ITIATE ! WORK1 DEMON/RATE ITS NECESSITY1 & SEE IT RECOGNIZ$ AS ! BASIS ( ALL O!R SOCIAL RE=M1 ITS MISSION WILL BE LOOK$ BACK UPON AS 9VALUABLE4 

,:O >E ! ,T]RORI/S 9 ,FRANCE8 

,FRANCE IS 9 A TURMOIL4 ,! 9DU/RIAL DEEPS >E BEG9N+ TO BOIL AGA91 & ! \TCOME IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO =ESEE4 ,NOR IS IT EASY TO ACC\NT = ALL ?AT HAS REC5TLY HAPP5$ OR LOCATE ! RESPONSIBILITIES !RE=4 ,! NEWSPAP]S ATTRIBUTE ALL TO ! T]RIBLE ,AN>*I/S1 BUT H[ F> !Y HAVE REALLY HAD A F+] 9 ! PRES5T REVOLUTION>Y PIE IS AS YET A MATT] ( CONSID]ABLE UNC]TA9TY4 ,C]TA9 IT IS1 H[EV]1 ?AT ! ,FR5* AU?ORITIES DESIRE = SOME REASON TO LAY ! BURD5 ON ,AN>*I/IC %\LD]S1 & IT IS BY NO MEANS IMPROBABLE ?AT ,GAMBETTA1 ?R\< HIS TOOLS1 ! M9I/]S N[ 9 P[]1 HAS TAK5 ADVANTAGE ( A LOCAL DI/URBANCE 9 ! M9+ DI/RICTS TO FOM5T DISS5SION1 FUR!R \TRAGE ! OPPRESS$1 CREATE CON/]NATION & 9DIGNATION BY >BITR>Y >RE/S1 PLACE :OLE DI/RICTS SUB/ANTIALLY UND] M>TIAL LAW1 & ?US1 IF POSSIBLE1 PRECIPITATE A REVOLUTION & PREP>E ! WAY = ! DICTATOR%IP :I* ?IS R5EGADE RADICAL HAS SO LONG COVET$4 

,LET US BRIEFLY REVIEW ! REC5T DI/URBANCES4 ,! TR\BLE BEGAN LA/ ,AUGU/ 9 ! LITTLE VILLAGE ( ,MONTCEAU-LES-,M9ES1 SITUAT$ 9 ! M9+ DI/RICTS & 9HABIT$ PR9CIPALLY BY M9]S4 ,! CONDITION ( ! 9DU/RIAL POPULATION 9 ?AT LOCALITY & ! OPPRESSION UND] :I* !Y LABOR AF=D A S+UL>LY /RIK+ ILLU/RATION ( ! MUTUAL SUPPORT & C\NT5ANCE 9 TYRANNY EXT5D$ TO EA* O!R BY CAPITAL & ! *UR*1 BO? UND] ! PROTECTION ( ! ,/ATE4 ,A DEF9ITE ALLIANCE APPE>S TO HAVE BE5 =M$ !RE BETWE5 ! M9+ COMPANIES ON ! ONE H& & ! ,CA?OLIC *UR* ON ! O!R = ! PURPOSE ( KEEP+ ! WORKM5 9 ABJECT SUBMISSION1 EXTORT+ FROM !M !IR E>N+S1 & DIVID+ ! SPOILS4 ,! M9]S GREW GRADUALLY RE/LESS UND] ! RELIGI\S REGIME 5=C$ UPON !M :]EBY !Y W]E NOT ONLY PREV5T$ FROM ACT+ ACCORD+ TO !IR [N BELIEFS BUT EV5 COMPELL$ TO P>TICIPATE 9 ,CA?OLIC RITES1 & !Y FIR/ MANIFE/$ !IR DISCONT5T BY TE>+ D[N CROSSES :I* ! RELIGI\S SOCIETIES HAD ILLEGALLY ]ECT$ AT V>I\S /REET-CORN]S4 ,F9ALLY1 SO IT IS SAID1 ON ! NI<T ( ! FIFTE5? ( ,AUGU/ A SMALL B& ( !M BUR/ 9TO ! *APEL ( ,BOIS-,DUV]NE & BROKE SOME ( ! W9D[S & ALT> P>APH]NALIA4 ,MEAN:ILE ANO!R B& W5T TO A CONV5T-S*OOL NE> BY & SMA%$ A FEW W9D[-PANES1 S++ REVOLUTION>Y SONGS & UTT]+ ?REATS4 ,BO? B>DS !N PROCUR$ >MS & RETURN$ TO ! *APEL1 :]E !Y MADE A BONFIRE ( ! ALT> ORNAM5TS1 AFT] :I* !Y M>*$ TO ! WOODS1 C>RY+ A R$ FLAG1 & DISP]S$1 A FEW ( !M TEMPOR>ILY >RE/+ & ?REAT5+ A PRIE/ ON ! ROAD4 ,9 CONSEQU5TCE ( !SE EV5TS TW5TY-?REE >RE/S W]E MADE BY TITE AU?ORITIES ON *>GES ( PILLAGE1 DEVA/ATION1 & MASSACRE1 & IT WAS PRET5D$ ?AT ! PRISON]S W]E MEMB]S ( A SECRET SOCIETY KN[N AS ! 0,BLACK ,B&0 -- A SOCIETY :OSE EXI/5CE IS D\BTFUL1 BUT :OSE DESCRIPTION IS NOT UNLIKE ?OSE GIV5 ( ! &MU*-MALIGN$ 0,MOLLIE ,MAGUIRES0 ( ,P5NSYLVANIA4 ,BE=E GO+ FUR!R ) ! /ORY WE MAY PR(ITABLY READ ,H5RI ,RO*E=T'S EXPLANATION ( ! CAUSES ( ?IS REVOLT ( ! M9]S3 

,! M9+ COMPANY 9 ?AT REGION IS 5TIRELY AT ! DISPOSAL ( ! PRIE/S1 & ! PRIE/S >E AT ! DISPOSAL ( ! COMPANY4 ,! PRIE/S FROM !IR PULPITS EULOGIZE ! EMPLOY]S1 :O 9 TURN REQUIRE ( ! LABOR]S A /RICT FULFILLM5T ( !IR RELIGI\S DUTIES4 ,SU* A CONFUSION ( MA/]S RESULTS FROM ?IS ILLICIT ASSOCIATION ?AT ! UN=TUNATE M9]S >E AS DEP5D5T ON ! *UR*1 :I* =CES !M TO RECEIVE ! SACRAM5T1 AS ON ! COMPANY1 :I* PAYS !M4 

,:5 ! WIFE ( ONE ( !SE SLAVES NEGLECTS A PRAY]1 OR :5 ONE ( HIS *ILDR5 FAILS 9 ! CATE*ISM1 IMM$IATELY ! PRIE/ COMPLA9S ( ! HEAD ( ! FAMILY TO ! EMPLOY]1 :O PITILESSLY DIS*>GES HIM4 ,?US IS HE =C$1 UND] P5ALTY ( DY+ ( HUNG] ) HIS :OLE FAMILY1 TO B5D HIS NECK UND] ! CL]ICAL YOKE4 ,IT IS NOT MONEY OR Y\R LIFE1 BUT ! MASS OR Y\R LIFE4 

,:5 ?IS ABOM9ABLE SY/EM ( BLACKMAIL+ BECAME 9TOL]ABLE1 ! M9]S LO/ PATI5CE4 ,! REPORT WAS CIRCULAT$ !N ?AT A PRIE/ HAD BE5 >RE/$ BY B&S TRAV]S+ ! WOODS1 & ?AT HIS RECTORY HAD N>R[LY ESCAP$ DE/RUCTION BY REPEAT$ EXPLOSIONS ( DYNAMITE C>TRIDGES2 & ! PUBLIC1 :OM !Y TELL ONLY ?AT :I* !Y WI% !M TO KN[1 ASK$ 9 /UPETI$ TONES :AT RASCALLY PROVOCATIONS HAD SUCCE$$ 9 PU%+ =M]LY PEACEABLE WORKM5 TO SU* MISDE$S4 ,! MATT] IS EASILY EXPLA9$3 ! M9]S ( ,MONTEAU >RE/$ !IR PRIE/ BECAUSE !Y =MALLY ACCUSE HIM ( HAV+ DRIV5 FROM ! M9E & ! TILE-KILN 9 LESS ?AN A YE> MORE ?AN =TY ( !IR NUMB]1 :O N[ HAVE NEI!R FOOD NOR %ELT]4 

,& :Y >E !Y & !IR *ILD]N HUNGRY & COLD8 ,BECAUSE !Y REFUS$ TO KNEE AT ! GO+ ( ! CONFESSIONAL4 ,SU* IS ! RESPECT %[N = LIB]TY ( CONSCI5CE UND] ! FREE-?9K+ REPUBLIC6 ,& SO TRUE IS IT ?AT NO O!R CAUSE IS ASSIGNABLE = ! AGITATION ( ,MONTEAU-LES-,M9ES ?AT A NEI<BOR+ PRIE/1 HAV+ HAD ! GOOD S5SE TO CONF9E HIMSELF TO ! FUNCTIONS ( HIS M9I/RY )\T TRY+ TO EX]CISE ANY MAT]IAL OR MORAL PRESSURE UPON ! WORK+M5 ( ! VILLAGE1 DID NOT F9D IT NECESS>Y TO REPEL ! SLI<TE/ ATTACK FROM !M4 

,ON ! EI<TE5? ( ,OCTOB]1 AFT] ! PRISON]S HAD BE5 9 CU/ODY = TWO MON?S1 !Y W]E PLAC$ ON TRIAL AT ,*ALON4 ,SOME FIFTY WITNESSES W]E EXAM9$1 BUT ! TE/IMONY AGA9/ !M WAS SO RIDICUL\SLY WEAK ?AT IT SOON BECAME EVID5T ?AT NONE ( !M C\LD BE CONVICT$ ( ANY?+ MORE S]I\S ?AN ! CREATION ( A NOISY DI/URBANCE 9 ! /REETS AT NI<T4 ,WE %\LD LIKE TO GIVE MANY SAMPLES ( ! EVID5CE (F]$1 BUT MU/ CONT5T \RSELVES ) REPRODUC+ 0,L',9TRANSIGEANT'S0 REPORT ( ! EXAM9ATION ( ,*AGOT1 ! MANAG] ( ! M9ES3 

,*AGOT KN[S :AT HAS HAPP5$ ONLY BY HE>SAY4 ,TO BELIEVE HIS /ORY1 ! CONDITION ( HIS WORKM5 IS EXCEPTIONAL4 ,! PRO(1 HE SAYS1 IS ?AT ,I HAVE RECEIV$ FROM ! M9]S ( ,/4 ,ETI5NE A NOTE 9 :I* !IR DEM&S >E =MULAT$1 & ,I NOTIC$ ?AT MY WORKM5 5JOY$ MU* MORE COM=T ?AN ?AT ASK$ = BY !IR COLLEAGUES ( ,/4 ,ETI5NE4 

,HE EXPLA9S ! SY/EM ( P5SIONS :I* HE HAS ORGANIZ$4 ,HE DOES NOT SEE :AT FUR!R HIS WORKM5 CAN ASK4 ,!Y >E MORE =TUNATE ?AN ANY O!R M9]S4 ,HE SAYS ?AT ?REE OR F\R YE>S AGO1 A PROPOS ( HIS P5SION FUND1 !RE WAS TALK ( ! ORGANIZATION ( WORK+M5'S SOCIETIES4 ,9 HIS OP9ION HIS WORKM5 >E 9 BETT] CIRCUM/ANCES1 ?ANKS TO HIS SY/EM4 ?AN IF ! COMMUNI/IC !ORIES PREA*$ TO !M W]E REALIZ$4 

,HE !N TELLS ( ! DE/RUCTION ( ! CROSSES1 :I*1 HE DRONES \T1 DID NO H>M TO ANY ONE4 ,?IS DECL>ATION IS RECEIV$ ) %\TS ( LAU<T]4 ,TO A QUE/ION ( ! C\RT ,M4 ,*AGOT1 P]CEPTIBLY CONFUS$1 REPLIES1 0,YES1 MONSEIGNEUR40 ,! POOR MAN FANCIES HIMSELF AT ! PALACE ( BIS BI%OP4 

,! CL]ICAL PRESSURE :I* ,I HAVE BR\<T TO BE>1 ADDS ! PI\S ,*AGOT1 HAS BE5 (F]$ AS AN EXCUSE = !SE \TBREAKS4 ,LIKE EV]YBODY ELSE1 ,I HAVE RELIGI\S S5TIM5TS2 BUT NEV] HAVE ,I OBLIG$ MY WORKM51 :OM ,I CONSID] AS MY *ILDR51 TO GO TO MASS4 

,*AGOT ADMITS1 NEV]!LESS1 HAV+ PREV5T$ ANTI-RELIGI\S MANIFE/ATIONS1 :I*1 HE SAYS1 >E ANTI-SOCIAL4 ,NEV] WILL HE AU?ORIZE ANTI-RELIGI\S MANIFE/ATIONS2 IF ANY APPE>1 HE WILL TREAT !M RIGOR\SLY4 

,*AGOT CONCLUDES BY 5UM]AT+1 ) A S]I\SNESS WOR?Y ( A BETT] CAUSE1 ! PRET5D$ ADVANTAGES :I* ! LABOR]S UND] HIS ORD]S 5JOY4 ,ACCORD+ TO HIS ACC\NT1 !Y >E MORE COM=TABLY SITUAT$ ?AN ! /OCKHOLD]S4 

,LAGU]RE1 C\NSEL = ! DEF5SE1 ASKS ! WITNESS IF HE CONSID]S ! PRES5CE ( ONE ( HIS WORKM5 AT A CIVIL BURIAL AT AN ANTI-RELIGI\S MANIFE/ATION1 & IF1 9 CASE ( SU* AN EV5T1 HE W\LD DIS*>GE ! WORKMAN4 

,Y,E,S6 REPLIES ,*AGOT4 

,WELL MI<T ,RO*E=T EXCLAIM 9 VIEW ( ?IS A/\ND+ CONFESSION3 

,WE /ILL NE$ TO ABOLI% ! ,9QUISITION4 ,IT HAS LO/ NO?+ ( ITS T]RIBLE P[]4 ,)9 A HUNDR$ LEAGUES ( ,P>IS1 ?REE KILOMET]S FROM ,*ALON-SUR-,SAONE1 IT /ILL REIGNS SUPREME1 AS 9 ! DAYS ( ,PHILIP ,I,V4 ,ONLY1 ! ,DUKE ( ,ALVA HAS BECOME ! MANAG] ( A M9N+ COMPANY UND] ! NAME ( ,*AGOT & IS PROTECT$ 9 HIS EXECUTIONS & AUTO-DA-FES BY G5D>MES & TROOPS ( ! L9E :I* ! GOV]NM5T IS BASE 5\< TO PUT AT HIS DISPOSITION4 

,AS ! CASE ( ! GOV]NM5T AGA9/ ! PRISON]S GREW WEAK]1 NEW DEVELOPM5TS OCCURR$4 ,?REAT5+ LETT]S W]E S5T TO ! JURY1 DYNAMITE BOMBS W]E EXPLOD$ 9 A RE/AURANT AT ,LYONS1 & W>N+S W]E RECEIV$ BY OCCUPANTS ( PUBLIC BUILD+S ?AT ! BUILD+S W]E TO BE BL[N UP4 ,! GOV]NM5T !N 9/ITUT$ ! POLICY ( 9DISCRIM9ATE >RE/4 ,REVOLUTION>Y J\RNALS W]E SEIZ$1 ,AN>*I/IC AGITATORS W]E >RE/$1 WITNESSES = ! DEF5SE 9 ! CASES ON TRIAL W]E PUT 9 PRISON1 TROOPS W]E /ATION$ ?R\<\T ! DI/RICT1 & M5 W]E TAK5 9TO CU/ODY = HAV+ 9 !IR POSSESSION LETT]S FROM ,KROPOTK91 ,RECLUS1 & O!RS4 ,EV]Y?+ POSSIBLE WAS DONE TO GIVE A T]RORI/IC ASPECT TO AFFAIRS1 & ! RADICAL PRESS ( ,FRANCE OP5LY *>GE ?AT ! LETT]S1 BOMBS1 W>N+S1 >RE/S1 & ALL W]E P>TS ( A GOV]NM5T PLOT TO 9DUCE ! BELIEF ?AT ! FAIR TRIAL ( ! >RE/$ M9]S WAS IMPOSSIBLE UND] SU* CIRCUM/ANCES1 & ON ?AT GR\ND SUSP5D ! TRIAL UNTIL ! NEXT C\RT SESSION ?REE MON?S LAT]1 !REBY SECUR+ 9 ADVANCE ( A V]DICT A SLONG AN IMPRISONM5T AS POSSIBLE1 KN[+ ?AT AN IMM$IATE V]DICT W\LD PROBABLY SET ! PRISON]S FREE AT ONCE4 ,! PLOT SUCCE$$1 & ON ! TW5TY-F\R? ( ,OCTOB] ! SUSP5SION WAS ANN\NC$ BY ! C\RT1 ?US CONDEMN+ PRESUMABLY 9NOC5T M5 TO A NE$LESS PREV5TIVE DET5TION ( N9ETY DAYS1 :ILE !IR DEP5D5T FAMILIES >E />V+ 9 !IR HOMES4 ,SU* MANIFE/ 9JU/ICE HAS BR\<T AB\T A /RONG REVULSION ( FEEL+ 9 MANY QU>T]S1 AN 9/ANCE ( :I* MAY BE SE5 9 ! FOLL[+ WORDS WRITT5 BY A MAN ( MOD]ATE VIEWS TO 0,L',9TRANSIGEANT30 0,AFT] ! FIR/ NEWSPAP] ACC\NTS ,I W\LD HAVE CONDEMN$ ! ACCUS$ TO TWO YE>S' IMPRISONM5T2 AFT] ! 9DICTM5T WAS PREF]R$ ,I W\LD HAVE CONDEMN$ !M TO ?REE MON?S2 ALT] ! TE/IMONY ( ,M4 ,*AGOT ,I W\LD HAVE ACQUITT$ !M2 S9CE ! LATE/ >RE/S ,I DEM& ! 9DICTM5T ( ! M9I/RY40 

,SU* IS ! TRUE /ORY ( ! TR\BLES 9 ,FRANCE4 ,WE HAVE TOLD IT AT CONSID]ABLE L5G? TO %[ H[ SLI<T IS ! BASIS = ! VIOL5T D5UNCIATIONS ( ! ,FR5* ,AN>*I/S W9* HAVE BE5 GO+ ! R\NDS ( ! ,AM]ICAN PRESS4 

,\R ,CREE$ & A ,CRE$ ,NOT ,\RS4 

,! ,PROVID5CE 0,J\RNAL0 IS REALLY FRI<T5$ AT ! GR[+ 9FLU5CE ( ,LIB]TY1 & CONT9UES TO FREQU5TLY & FRANTICALLY W>N ITS READ]S AGA9/ \R DANG]\S DOCTR9ES4 ,WE W\LD NOT M9D ?IS1 IF ! 0,J\RNAL0 W\LD ONLY FAIRLY /ATE !SE DOCTR9ES4 ,BUT IT P]SI/5TLY MIS/ATES & DI/ORTS !M4 ,9 A REC5T $ITORIAL WE F9D !SE REM>KABLE WORDS3 

,A SOCIETY1 SMALL 9 NUMB]S & WEAK 9 *>ACT] & 9 9FLU5CE1 BUT ACTIVE & AGGRESSIVE1 HOLDS ITS FREQU5T MEET+S1 & IS /RUGGL+ TO EXT5D ITS P[] 9 ! 9T]E/ ( COMMUNISM 9 ,RHODE ,ISL&1 & ITS ORATORS BOLDLY DECL>E ?AT ! GOODS ( LIFE BELONG EQUALLY TO ! 9DU/RI\S & ! IDLE1 TO ! VIRTU\S & ! VICI\S2 ?AT CAPITAL1 :I* IS BUT ! SAV$ ACCUMULATION ( LABOR1 IS ! FOE ( LABOR2 ?AT ALL LAWS 9 RE/RA9T ( ! NATURAL 9CL9ATIONS & PROP5SITIES ( ANY PORTION ( ! PEOPLE1 >E USURPATION2 9 !IR [N T]SE EXPRESSION1 ?AT 09T]E/ IS EXTORTION1 WAGES IS CRIME1 R5T IS ROBB]Y1 PROP]TY IS PLUND]40 ,A PAP]1 PUBLI%$ 9 ,BO/ON1 OP5LY ADVOCAT+ !SE DOCTR9ES1 )\T SUBT]FUGE1 OR ! PRET5SE ( CONCEALM5T1 BUT ) A BOLDNESS :I*1 AT LEA/1 IS CR$ITABLE1 /YL+ !M1 AS !Y >E1 ! DOCTR9ES ( 0AN>*Y0 BOA/S ?AT ITS CIRCULATION IS L>G] 9 ,PROVID5CE ?AN 9 ANY O!R CITY 9 ,NEW ,5GL&4 ,AT MEET+S ( ! ,EQUAL ,RI<TS ,ASSOCIATION1 !SE DOCTR9ES HAVE BE5 DECL>$1 MA9LY BY IMPORT$ ORATORS1 BUT1 9 SOME 9/ANCES1 BY ?OSE AT H444E1 & HAVE BE5 RECEIV$ ) A DEGREE ( APPLAUSE :I* MANIFE/S ! GR[+ APPROBATION ( ! LI/5]S4 

,WE >E 9=M$ BY ONE ( \R ,PROVID5CE READ]S ?AT NO SU* SOCIETY AS ! 0,J\RNAL0 DESCRIBES MEETS OR EXI/S 9 ?AT CITY1 & ?AT SO F> ?IS /ATEM5T ( ! 0,J\RNAL0 IS A 0WITFUL LIE40 ,LIB]TY DOES NOT PR(ESS TO KN[ :E!R ! 0,J\RNAL0 LIES OR NOT3 BUT1 AS WE HAVE ONCE ADMITT$ 9 !SE COLUMNS ?AT ! 0,J\RNAL0 \<T TO BE BETT] PO/$ ?AN \RSELVES CONC]N+ ! $UCATIONAL /ATUS ( ,RHODE ,ISL& RE=M]S1 IT IS NO MORE ?AN FAIR TO ALL[ N[ ?AT ,RHODE ,ISL& RE=M]S \<T TO BE BETT] PO/$ ?AN \RSELVES CONC]N+ ! MORAL /ATUS ( ! 0,J\RNAL40 

,BUT LET ?AT PASS4 ,WE >E *IEFLY 9T]E/$ H]E 9 ! QUE] HODGE-PODGE ( DOCTR9ES ATTRIBUT$ TO US4 ,LIB]TY IS WRITT5 9 9TELLIGIBLE ,5GLI%1 & IT W\LD SEEM ?AT ANY HONE/ NEWSPAP]1 AFT] READ+ IT AS LONG & C>EFULLY AS ! 0,J\RNAL0 HAS BE5 READ+ IT1 \<T TO KN[ :AT IT IS 9 FAVOR ( & :AT IT IS AGA9/4 ,WILL ! 0,J\RNAL0 N[ PAY /RICT ATT5TION TO A 0T]SE0 /ATEM5T ( :AT WE DO & DO NOT BELIEVE AB\T ! MATT]S M5TION$8 

,9/EAD ( WORK+ 9 ! 09T]E/ ( COMMUNIISM0 WE HATE COMMUNISM ABOVE ALL O!R EVILS1 & >E FI<T+ IT ) ALL \R /R5G?1 :E!R IT BE ! COMMUNISM ( ,JAY ,G\LD & ! ,PROVID5CE 0,J\RNAL10 :I* AIMS TO 9DIRECTLY OPPRESS ! MANY BY ! FEW1 OR ! COMMUNISM ( ,K>L ,M>X1 :I* AIMS TO DIRECTLY OPPRESS ! FEW BY ! MANY4 ,WE BELIEVE1 ) ,PR\DHON1 ?AT COMMUNISM IS ! RELIGION ( POV]TY & SLAV]Y3 AT BOTTOM IT IS ! MAJORITY PR9CIPLE ITSELF1 & ,LIB]TY LIVES TO DO IT BATTLE4 

,9/EAD ( DECL>+ ?AT 0! GOODS ( LIFE BELONG EQUALLY TO ! 9DU/RI\S & ! IDLE1 TO ! VIRTU\S & ! VICI\S10 \R CRY+ GRIEVANCE & COMPLA9T HAS BE5 & IS ?AT ! GOODS ( LIFE >E ALMO/ EXCLUSIVELY 9 ! H&S & CONTROL ( ! IDLE & ! VICI\S1 & ?AT ! 9DU/RI\S & VIRTU\S >E *EAT$ & PLUND]$ & />V$4 

,WE DO BELIEVE ?AT CAPITAL1 :ILE IT REMA9S 9 ! H&S ( IDL5ESS1 IS 0! FOE ( LABOR10 BUT WE ALSO BELIEVE ?AT1 :5 IT %ALL BE RE/OR$ TO ! H&S ( LABOR1 :I* CREAT$ IT1 IT WILL PROVE LABOR'S MO/ POT5T FRI5D4 

,WE DO BELIEVE ?AT ALL /ATUTE LAWS >E 0USURPATION10 BUT WE ALSO BELIEVE ?AT ALL REAL LAWS >E ET]NAL & BEYOND ! P[] ( M5 TO MANUFACTURE1 & ?AT !SE1 :5 M5 DO NOT FOOLI%LY ATTEMPT TO ?W>T !M BY SO-CALL$ LAWS ( !IR [N MAK+1 >E AMPLY SUFFICI5T1 NOT TO 0RE/RA910 BUT TO H>MONIZE ! 0NATURAL 9CL9ATIONS & PROP5SITIES10 NOT ( 0ANY PORTION (10 BUT ( ALL ! PEOPLE4 

,WE DO BELIEVE ?AT 09T]E/ IS EXTORTION10 ?AT 0R5T IS ROBB]Y10 & ?AT 0PROP]TY10 SO F> AS IT IS A CREATURE ( PRIVILEGE & NOT ( LABOR1 0IS PLUND]20 BUT WE DO NOT BELIEVE1 & NEV] HAVE SAID1 ?AT 0WAGES IS CRIME40 ,?IS LA/ DOCTR9E HAS BE5 REPEAT$LY ATTRIBUT$ TO US BY ! 0,J\RNAL0 )\T ANY %AD[ ( JU/IFICATION4 ,IT =TUNATELY HAPP5S ?AT ,LIB]TY HAS HAD 9 TYPE = MANY MON?S1 WAIT+ = ROOM 9 ITS CR[D$ COLUMNS1 A %ORT /ATEM5T ( :AT WE BELIEVE AB\T WAGES4 ,! 0,J\RNAL0 MAY F9D IT 9 ! PRES5T ISSUE UND] ! HEAD ( 0,BUFFET$ ,LABOR10 & MAY BE ABLE TO GA!R !REFROM ?AT WE BELIEVE MO/ UNEQUIVOCALLY 9 WAGES SY/EM4 

,IS ! 0,J\RNAL0 FAIR 5\< TO PR9T ?IS CRE$ ( \RS 9 \R [N WORDS8 ,OR WILL IT CONT9UE TO MISREPRES5T US8 ,9 ! LATT] CASE1 WE %ALL F9D CONSOLATION 9 ! FACT ?AT EA* FRE% ASSAULT :I* IT MAKES UPON US IS FOLL[$ BV A BAT* ( NEW SUBSCRIPTIONS FROM ,PROVID5CE1 G5]ALLV ACCOMPANI$ BY !SE OR SIMIL> REM>KS3 0,:ATEV] ! 0,J\RNAL0 MALIGNS IS ALWAYS WOR?Y ( PATRONAGE1 & ITS ABUSE IS AN 9FALLIBLE PAT5T ( E/EEM = DEC5T PEOPLE40 

,! ,MOD]N ,*>LES ,/U>T4 

,IF ! CABLEGRAMS RI<TLY 9=M US1 ,*>LES ,/U>T ,P>NELL1 ! DI/+UI%$ ,IRI% TRAITOR1 HAS IMPPL5T$ HIS P>LIAM5T>IAN PROJECTS BY SECUR+ WRITS ( EVICTION = ?REE ( HIS T5ANTS1 & ?AT1 TOO ON SUITS = >RE>S ( R5T4 

,?IS ACT1 \TRAGE\S AS IT IS1 IS 9 P]FECT KEEP+ ) ! 9/9CTS ( A POLITICAL TRAD] :O SC>DS BY ! ,/ATE AS AGA9/ ! M>* ( IDEAS4 ,! ,P>NELLS FROM ! FIR/ 7,ANNA POSSIBLY EXCEPT$1 HAVE BE5 A SORRY 9VE/M5T = ! AFFLICT$ ,IRI% PEOPLE4 ,! MEMB]S ( ! FAMILY HAVE EV] :9$ OV]!IR 9DIVIDUAL SACRIFIES4 0,MY SON ,*>LES0 HAS MANIFE/LY ON MANY OCCASIONS BE5 A MORE TE>WOR?Y OBJECT ?AN \TRAG$ ,IREL&4 0,MY BRO!R ,*>LES0 W\LD SPURN TO ADVOCATE SU* COMMUNI/IC DOCTR9ES AS ?AT RONT IS MORALLY =FEIT$ 9 EQUITY4 ,! ,P>NELL FAMILY HAVE /EADILY BE5 A MORE IMPORTANT 9/ITUTION 9 !IR [N EYES ?AN ! GREAT HUMAN FAMILY1 IF ! ,P>NELLS W\LD ONLY GO HOME TO !IR E/ATES & /AY !RE1 ?US RE9/AT+ ! FAMILY AMONG ! O!R RESPECTABLE L&LORD FAMILIES ( ! WORLD1 IT W\LD BE WELL = ,IREL&4 

,BUFFET$ ,LABOR4 

,TO ! $ITOR ( ,LIB]TY3 

,DE> ,SIR1-- ,AWAY BACK 9 ,GREAT ,BRITA91 ! L& P> EXCEL5CE ( TYRANTS & SLAVES1 ,I WAS A REBEL TO ALL 9 P[]1-- K+S1 L&LORDS1 CAPITALI/S2 & TO-DAY1 H]E AMONG ! M\NTA9S ( ,NEW ,MEXICO1 ,I MEAN TO BE AS UNCOMPROMIS+ AS EV] TO AU?ORITY1 & AM DET]M9$ TO DO MY BE/ TO HELP ALL :O WANT TO LEVEL OLD SOCIETY & BUILD UP A NEW CIVILIZATION ON A SCI5TIFIC BASIS4 ,I KN[ !RE >E MANY :O SAY ?AT ! PRES5T /ATE ( AFFAIRS IS ALL RI<T1 AL?\< ! PEOPLE >E NOT CONT5D$ ANY:]E 9 ANY ( ! SO-CALL$ CIVILIZ$ C\NTRIES ( ! WORLD4 ,EV5 H]E1 9 ?IS BOA/$ REPUBLIC ! USEFUL PEOPLE >E BE+ BUFFET$ AB\T AT ! M]EY ( ! IDLE & USELESS2 ! WORK]S :O HAVE BUILT UP ALL ! WEAL? ( ! NATIONS HAVE NOT ANY:]E A SECURE HOME2 !Y [N NO?+1 :ILE ! CAPITALI/S [NS EV]Y?+4 ,! GREAT MASS ( ! TOIL]S DO NOT KN[ YET ! WAY \T ( !IR 9SECURE WAGE SLAV]Y4 ,LIB]TY WILL %[ !M4 ,!Y ?9K ?AT IT IS QUITE RI<T ?AT !Y %\LD BE DRIV5 TO /RUGGLE = EXI/5CE1 AT ! M]CY ( ! CAPITALI/S1 FROM ,M9NESOTA TO ,TEXAS & ,MASSA*USETTS TO ,CALI=NIA4 ,!Y DO NOT YET KN[ ?AT !Y %\LD NOT BE DRIV5 TO SEEK LABOR OV] A CONT95T1 BUT ?AT IT %\LD COME TO !M LIKE A HAV5-S5T-BLESS+4 

,Y\RS = ,AN>*Y1 ,JOHN ,MC,LAUGL94 

,BLOSSBURG1 ,RATON1 ,NEW ,MEXICO4 

.<,\R FRI5D %\LD BEW>E ( ?AT S5SELESS & MIS*IEV\S PHRASE1 0WAGE SLAV]Y40 ,!RE IS NO SU* ?+4 ,A MAN'S TRUE WAGES >E FIX$ & PAID BY NATURE1 & CONSI/ ( :AT HE PRODUCES OR ITS EQUIVAL5T4 ,NO MAN IS A SLAVE BECAUSE HE GETS HIS WAGES1 ?\< MANY M5 >E SLAVES BECAUSE !Y DO NOT GET !IR WAGES4 ,AS F> AS FRE$OM IS CONC]N$1 !RE IS NO DIFF]5CE BETWE5 ! MAN :O PRODUCES = UNKN[N P>TIES ON PROBLEMATICAL T]MS1 WORK+ ) HIS [N TOOLS AT HIS [N RISK1 & ! MAN :O PRODUCES = KN[N P>ITES ON SPECIFI$ T]MS1 WORK+ ) !IR TOOLS AT !IR RISK4 ,BO? ( !SE >E WAGE SY/EMS1 & !RE IS NO O!R SY/EM4 ,:]E !RE IS MONOPOLY1 BO? >E SLAVE SY/EMS2 :]E !RE IS NO MONOPOLY1 NEI!R IS A SLAVE SY/EM4 ,! ONE CONDITION ESS5TIAL TO ! RI<TFULNESS ( BO? IS ! ABS5CE ( ! USUR]1 :OSE SOLE FUNCTION IS TO SECRETE = HIS [N B5EFIT A PORTION ( ! LABOR]'S WAGES4 ,IT IS ! FUNDAM5TAL CRIME ( CONS]VATIVE POLITICAL ECONOMY ?AT ! USUR] -- ?AT IS1 ! MONOPOLI/ -- IS PRIVILEG$ TO KEEP BACK A P]C5TAGE ( ?AT PRODUCT4 ,USURY1 SLAV]Y1 !N -- NOT WAGE SLAV]Y1-- IS ! L& ( BONDAGE \T ( :I* ,LIB]TY1 ,LABOR'S ,MOSES1 IS DE/9$ TO GUIDE ! *ILDR5 ( ,9DU/RY -- ,$ITOR ,LIB]TY4.> 

,T*]NI*EVSKI4 

,= FIFTE5 YE>S ,T*]NI*EVSKI1 ! AU?OR ( ! CELEBRAT$ NOVEL 0,:AT TO DO0 & ONE ( ! MO/ REM>KABLE ( ,RUSSIAN SOCIALI/IC WRIT]S1 HAS BE5 9T]N$ 9 A LITTLE T[N ( ,SIB]IA4 ,A ,RUSSIAN REVIEW PUBLI%$ 9 ,G5EVA CONTA9S AN 9T]E/+ COMMUNICATION RELATIVE TO ! ULLU/RI\S VICTIM ( PROSCRIPTION1 = :OSE LIB]ATION LIB]AL ,RUSSIA HAS SO LONG PLEAD$ 9 VA93 

,?\< ! ,RUSSIAN PATRIOT ,T*]NI*EVSKI IS NOT DEAD1 AS HAS BE5 MORE ?AN ONCE REPORT$1 HE IS DEAD TO SOCIETY4 ,HE /ILL LIVES 9 ! REMOTE/ PORTION ( ,SIB]IA1 ?AT ICY C\NTRY :I* HAS WITNESS$ ! DEA? ( SO MANY ILLU/RI\S CONDEMN$4 

,T*]NI*EVSKI IS 9T]N$ AT ,KOLIMSK2 HE IS ALONE1 SEP>AT$ BY ! GIGANTIC B>RI]S ( SN[ & ICE ( ,YAK\TSK FROM EV]BODY ?AT CAN UND]/& HIM4 

,! LITTLE T[N TO :I* HE IS CONSI/$ C\NTS BUT A FEW HUNDR$ 9HABITANTS2 ! LIT]>Y SOCIETY ( ! VIC9ITY IS COMPOS$ ( TWO OR ?REE (FICIALS4 

,AS !RE >E NO AVAILABLE LODG+S 9 ! PLACE1 ! EXILE LIVES 9 A S+LE ROOM 9 ! GU>D-H\SE1 :]E HE CAN BE MO/ CONV5I5TLY SUBJECT$ TO A V]Y RIGOR\S SURVEILLANCE4 ,DUR+ ! DAY HE IS ALL[$ TO WALK ! /REETS1 BUT MU/ PRES5T HIMSELF EV]Y EV5+ BE=E HIS GU>DIANS4 

,! LABORS ( SCI5CE :I* MI<T DI/RACT & OCCUPY HIS M9D >E ALMO/ IMPOSSIBLE1 = HE HAS NO BOOKS2 HE IS =BIDD5 TO READ NEWSPAP]S OR LIT]>Y PUBLICATIONS4 

,ONE DAY HE TRI$ TO S5D AN >TICLE TO A ,RUSSIAN J\RNAL1 BUT ! GOV]NOR CONFISCAT$ ! PACKAGE4 

,T*]NI*EVSKI1 NEV]!LESS1 WRITES OCCASIONALLY1 BUT TE>S UP & BURNS ALL HIS PRODUCTIONS4 ,!RE IS SOME?+ MY/]I\S AB\T ?IS ME?OD ( PROC$URE4 ,! POOR EXILE HAS A LITTLE G>D5 :I* HE CULTIVATES HIMSELF1 HE GIVES MU* ATT5TION & C>EFULLY WAT*ES ! GR[ ( HIS PLANTS2 HE HAS DRA9$ ! SOIL ( HIS G>D51 :I* IS M>%Y4 ,HE LIVES BY ! PRODUCTS :I* HE RAISES & CATS ONLY VEGETABLES2 HE LIVES SO PLA9LY ?AT 9 ! 5TIRE YE> HE DOES NO EXP5D ! SUM ( ONE HUNDR$ & TW5TY RUBLES ALL[$ HIM BY ! ,RUSSIAN GOV]NM5T2 HIS SAV+ >E DEPOSIT$ ) ! POLICE COMMISSION]4 

,! HEAL? ( ! EXILE IS BAD2 HE HAS GR[N OLD & B5T 9 ! LITTLE T[N :]E HE IS 9T]N$ ! PEOPLE REV]E HIM & CONSID] AS A SA9T1-- NOT1 ( C\RSE1 BECAUSE ( HIS LIT]>Y G5IUS OR SCI5TIFIC KN[L$GE1 ( :I* !SE POOR PEOPLE HAVE PROBABYL NEV] HE>D2 BUT ! WISDOM1 GOODNESS1 & *>ITY ( ?IS MAN1 :OSE LIFE IS ABSOLUTELY PURE & :O BE>S HIS BURD5 ) SU* T\*+ RESIGNATION1 9SPIRE 9 ALL A S5TIM5T ( ! PR(\NDE/ PITY4 

,SOCIAL ,SPONGES4 

,IF ?REE1 F\R1 OR FIVE M51 WRITES ,RUFUS ,HAT* 9 ! ,NEW ,YORK 0,H\R0 CAN ACCUMULATE A HUNDR$ MILLION DOLL>S A YE> EA* BY SELL+ SOME?+ ?AT CO/ NO?+1 ! PUBLIC WILL GET TIR$ ( IT1 &1 REMEMB]+ H[ ,MR4 ,V&]BILT LAUN*ES HIS ANA!MAS AGA9/ !M1 !Y WILL BE LIKELY TO RISE UP & ASS]T !IR P[]4 ,NOT ONE ( !SE M5 IS A PRODUC] 9 ! S5SE ?AT IMPLIES PROGRESS1 OR ! 9CREASE ( ! PUBLIC WEAL?4 ,!Y ?9K1 OR SAY1 !Y >E 0DEVELOP+0 ?AT WEAL?1 :ILE1 AS A MATT] ( FACT1 !Y >E ONLY ABSORB+ IT1 JU/ AS GREAT SPONGES SOAK UP WAT]4 ,) !SE M51 IT SEEMS1 ! ONLY ?+ TO DO IS TO BUILD A RAILWAY OR P>ALLEL ANO!R ONE1 MORTGAGE IT = TWICE :AT ! ROAD CO/1 ISSUE /OCK TWO OR ?REE TIMES TOO L>GE 9 AM\NT1 & FE$ ! 0LAMBS0 9 ,WALL ,/REET ) IT4 ,IF ! BUILD+ ( ?IS L9E DI/URBS ANY ( ! CONDITIONS :I* FAVOR SOME MAN'S 5RI*M5T & MONOPOLY-P[]1 ALL HE HAS TO DO IS TO GET HIS SONS TO BUY IT UP4 ,PAP] C>-:EELS HAVE BE5 A SUCCESS = SEV]AL YE>S PA/1 & C>S RUN V]Y WELL ON !M2 BUT TRY+ TU RUN A RAILWAY ALTOGE!R ON PAP] IS TRY+ TO DO TOO MU*4 

,\R ,PATRONAGE ,DONE ,=4 

,TO ! $ITOR ( ,LIB]TY1-- ,?IS IS TO NOTIFY Y\ ?AT ,I DO NOT 9T5D TO R5EW SUBSCRIPTION TO ,LIB]TY4 ,SO ?IS WILL CLOSE ITS PATRONAGE4 

,Y\RS @&C41 

,GEORGE ,H[E4 

,PROVID5CE1 ,R4,I4 ,OCTOB] #b#i1 #a#h#h#b4 

.<,?IS SETTLES IT4 ,MR4 ,H[E DECIDES ?AT ,LIB]TY'S SUPPLIES MU/ BE /OPP$1 & ( C\RSE !Y WILL BE4 ,CURI\SLY1 ! SAME MAIL ?AT BR\<T US ,MR4 ,H[E'S DISCONT9UANCE BR\<T ALSO ONE R5EWAL & ?REE NEW SUBSCRIB]S4 ,REALLY1 :AT AN 5ORM\S CONCEIT ?IS MAN ,H[E MU/ HAVE6 -- ,$ITOR ,LIB]TY.> 

0,?OSE ,FIL?Y ,*9ESE40 

,H[ MANY ,AM]ICANS W\LD HAVE ! SELF-RELIANCE TO ACT AFT] ! MANN] ( ! ,*9ESE :OSE DO+ >E ?US REPORT$ BY ! ,VIRG9IA ,CITY 0,*RONICLE08 

,A GANG ( ,*9AM5 HAVE = ! PA/ FEW DAYS BE5 AT WORK LAY+ A SEW] FROM A WA%-H\SE CLOSE TO ! C\RT-H\SE ON ,B4 /REET ACROSS TO ,TAYLOR /REET1 TO CONNECT ) ! MA9 SEW] !RE4 ,?IS UNUSUAL SI<T HAS CAUS$ MANY TO SUPPOSE ?AT ! C\NTRY COMMISSION]S >E EMPLOY+ ,*9ESE LABOR UPON ! /REETS4 ,?IS IS A MI/AKE4 ,! ,*9AM5 >E LAY+ ! SEW] = !IR [N CONV5I5CE1 NOT HAV+ BE5 ABLE TO GET IT DONE AT PUBLIC EXP5SE4 ,! JOB WILL CO/ ! WA%-H\SE ,MONGOLIANS OV] @s#a4 

,! ,CRISIS 9 ,FRANCE4 

.<,NEW ,YORK 0,H\R0.> 

,! 5D IS N[ AT H&4 ,!RE IS GO+ TO BE A DET]M9$ TUSSLE BETWE5 ! B\RGEOISIE & ! PROLET>IAT4 ,! MASSES >E R\S$1 & ! PRELIM9>Y /RUGGLE WILL BE SE5 9 ! ,*AMB]S4 ,WILL SOME LEAD] EM]GE FROM IT DOM9ANT1 VICTORI\S8 ,IT MAY BE A PR9CE4 ,IT MAY BE ,GAMBETTA4 ,IF IT IS ,GAMBETTA1 HIS DICTATOR%IP MAY BE %ORT4 ,!RE IS A SPIRIT ABROAD 9 ,FRANCE :I* IS OM9\S ( ASSASS9ATION4 

,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,JANU>Y #a#c1 #bba 3 ,LIB]TY ,VOL4 ,I,I4 ,NO4 #c4 -- ,ADD$4 
,JANU>Y #f1 #bbb 3 ,LIB]TY ,VOL4 ,I,I4 ,NO4 #c4 -- ,UPDAT$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/