,P>T #a1 ,*APT] #c ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,C>L ,LEVY ,TEXT 3 ,I,I,I #a#b4 ,PRODUCTION & ,DI/RIBUTION ,ONE MU/ PRODUCE1 SAY ! GOV]NM5T & ! B\RGEOISIE4 ,ONE MU/ PRODUCE1 SAY ! RE=MI/S4 ,ONE MU/ PRODUCE1 WE 7AN>*I/S7 ALSO SAY4 ,BUT PRODUCE = :OM8 ,PRODUCE :AT8 ,& :AT >E ! REASONS ?AT NOT 5\< IS PRODUC$8 ,!Y SAY1 ! REVOLUTION CANNOT TAKE PLACE BECAUSE PRODUCTION IS 9SUFFICI5T1 & ?AT WE W\LD RUN ! RISK ( DY+ ( HUNG]4 ,WE SAY1 ! REVOLUTION MU/ TAKE PLACE SO AS TO BE ABLE TO PRODUCE & /OP ! GREAT] P>T ( ! POPULATION FROM LIV+ 9 A /ATE ( *RONIC HUNG]4.<#a#b#a.> 444 ,>TURO ,LABRIOLA1 ! WELL KN[N ,ITALIAN 9TRANSIG5T SOCIALI/1 MA9TA9$ AT A PUBLIC MEET+ SOME TIME AGO ?AT 0! URG5T PROBLEM :I* NE$S SOLV+ IS NOT ?AT ( ! DI/RIBUTION ( WEAL?1 BUT ! RATIONAL ORGANIZATION ( PRODUCTION40 ,?IS IS A MAJOR ]ROR :I* %\LD BE EXAM9$1 BECAUSE IT COMPROMISES ! V]Y BASES ( SOCIALI/ DOCTR9E1 & LEADS TO CONCLUSIONS :I* >E ANY?+ BUT SOCIALI/4 ,FROM ,MAL?US ONW>DS1 ! CONS]VATIVES ( ALL S*OOLS HAVE MA9TA9$ ?AT POV]TY DOES NOT RESULT FROM UNJU/ DI/RIBUTION ( WEAL?1 BUT FROM LIMIT$ PRODUCTIVITY OR DEFICI5T HUMAN 9DU/RY4 ,SOCIALISM1 9 ITS HI/ORIC ORIG9S & 9 ITS BASIC ESS5CE1 IS ! NEGATION ( ?IS !SIS2 IT IS A CLE> /ATEM5T ?AT ! SOCIAL PROBLEM IS ABOVE ALL A MATT] ( SOCIAL JU/ICE1 A QUE/ION ( DI/RIBUTION4 ,IF ! !SIS SU/A9$ BY ,LABRIOLA W]E TRUE1 IT W\LD BE FALSE TO MA9TA9 ?AT ! ANTAGONISMS BETWE5 BOSSES & WORK]S CANNOT BE SOLV$1 S9CE ! WORK]S W\LD F9D A SOLUTION BY REASON ( ! 9T]E/ BO? BOSSES & SAL>I$ CLASSES HAVE 9 9CREAS+ ! QUANTITY ( GOODS2 SOCIALISM W\LD !RE=E BE FALSE1 AT LEA/ AS A PRACTICAL MEANS = SOLV+ ! SOCIAL PROBLEM4.<#a#b#b.> ,\R COMRADE & FRI5D1 ,RUDOLF ,ROCK] SAYS3 0,! 9T]NATIONALIZATION ( RAW MAT]IALS 7COAL1 M9]ALS1 OIL1 ETC47 IS ONE ( ! MO/ IMPORTANT CONDITIONS = ! REALIZATION ( SOCIALISM & ! FREE+ ( HUMANITY FROM ECONOMIC1 POLITICAL & SOCIAL BONDAGE40 ,9 MY OP9ION ?IS IS A MI/AKE1 A GRAVE ]ROR :I* C\LD S]VE ! 5EMIES ( ! REVOLUTION TO P>ALYZE POPUL> MOVEM5TS 9 ?OSE C\NTRIES :I*1 :ILE LACK+ P>TICUL> RAW MAT]IALS1 CAN F9D !MSELVES1 9 A GIV5 HI/ORICAL SITUATION1 BETT] ABLE ?AN O!RS TO OV]?R[ ! CAPITALI/ SY/EM4 ,SU* WAS ! CASE 9 ,ITALY 9 #a#i#b4 ,! HAPPY CONC\RSE ( CIRCUM/ANCES MADE A REVOLUTION ( A SOCIALI/ *>ACT] 7US+ SOCIALI/ 9 ITS WIDE/ S5SE7 POSSIBLE AS WELL AS RELATIVELY EASY4 ,WE AN>*I/S & ! SYNDICALI/S ( ! ,UNIONE ,S9DACALE1 /RA9$ EV]Y N]VE TO PU% ! MASSES TO ACT = !MSELVES2 BUT ! SOCIALI/ P>TY1 :I* WAS !N L$ BY ! COMMUNI/S1 & ! ,G5]AL ,CONF$]ATION ( LABOR1 7MU* /RONG] NUM]ICALLY1 ORGANIZATIONALLY & MAT]IALLY ?AN WE W]E71 W]E DET]M9$ TO PREV5T ANY K9D ( ACTION1 & MADE GREAT USE ( ! >GUM5T ?AT WE LACK$ RAW MAT]IALS 9 ,ITALY4 ,I REMEMB] ?AT 9 ,MILAN1 DUR+ A HEAT$ DISCUSSION1 A SOCIALI/1 SECRET>Y ( ! ,*EMICAL WORK]S1 EXCLAIM$3 0,H[ DO Y\ EXPECT TO MAKE A REVOLUTION2 DON'T Y\ KN[ ?AT !RE >E NO /OCKS ( RUBB] 9 ,ITALY & ?AT 9 ! EV5T ( A REVOLUTION NONE W\LD REA* US FROM ABROAD80 ,OBVI\SLY ?AT GOOD SOCIALI/ WANT$ TO PO/PONE ! ADV5T ( SOCIALISM UNTIL EI!R RUBB] PLANTATIONS HAD BE5 E/ABLI%$ 9 ,ITALY OR =EIGN GOV]NM5TS HAD GIV5 AN UND]TAK+ TO S5D US RUBB] 9 SPITE ( ! REVOLUTION6 ,!SE RAW MAT]IALS >E OBVI\SLY V]Y USEFUL BUT !Y >E C]TA9LY NOT 9DISP5SABLE4 ,HUMANITY LIV$ = 9NUM]ABLE C5TURIES )\T C>BONIZ$ VEGETABLE MATT]1 )\T OIL1 )\T RUBB]1 )\T SU* AN ABUNDANCE ( M9]ALS--& C\LD LIVE )\T ALL ?IS /UFF 9 CONDITIONS ( JU/ICE & LIB]TY1 ?AT IS UND] SOCIALISM1 GIV5 HUMAN UND]/&+ & A DESIRE = !M4 ,! QUE/ION ( ! DI/RIBUTION ( RAW MAT]IALS HAS ASSUM$ SU* L>GE PROPORTIONS BECAUSE ( CAPITALI/ 9T]E/S :I* HAVE BE5 BUILT UP >\ND !M4 ,IT IS ! CAPITALI/S ( ! V>I\S C\NTRIES :O GET RI* BY ! EXPLOITATION ( RAW MAT]IALS & :O FI? WILL HAVE TO BE AN ECONOMIC DOMA9 AVAILABLE TO EV]YBODY1 ! RI*ES ( :I* WILL BE 5JOY$ BY ALL HUMAN BE+S4 ,BUT ?IS WILL HAPP5 AFT]1 NOT BE=E1 SOCIALISM HAS TRIUMPH$ EV]Y:]E4 ,= ! TIME BE+1 GOV]NM5TS1 9 !IR [N 9T]E/S & ON BEHALF ( !IR RESPECTIVE F9ANCI]S & CAPITALI/S1 DEF5D ! MONOPOLIES :I* !Y HAVE SECUR$ 9 ! /RUGGLE1 & WILL PROBABLY GO TO W> RA!R ?AN GIVE !M UP4 ,BRIEFLY !N1 ! 9T]NATIONALIZATION ( NATURAL WEAL? IS NOT ! CONDITION =1 BUT ! CONSEQU5CE (1 SOCIALISM4.<#a#b#c.> ,! >TIFICIAL SC>CITY ( GOODS IS A *>ACT]I/IC ( ! CAPITALI/ SY/EM & IT IS ! TASK ( ! REVOLUTION TO MAKE RATIONAL USE ( ! L& & ! TOOLS ( PRODUCTION 9 ORD] TO 9CREASE PRODUCTION TO ! PO9T :]E IT AMPLY SATISFIES ! NE$S ( ALL4.<#a#b#d.> ,S9CE ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION 7L&1 TOOLS1 ETC47 BELONG TO A SMALL NUMB] ( PEOPLE :O USE !M TO MAKE O!RS WORK = !IR PR(IT1 IT FOLL[S ?AT PRODUCTION 9CREASES SO LONG AS ! EMPLOY]S' PR(ITS 9CREASE1 & IS >TIFICIALLY HELD BACK1 :5 9CREAS$ PRODUCTION RESULTS 9 SMALL] PR(ITS4 ,9 O!R WORDS1 ! EMPLOY] LIMITS PRODUCTION TO :AT HE CAN SELL AT A PR(IT1 & HALTS PRODUCTION AS SOON AS HE /OPS MAK+ PR(ITS1 OR :5 ! PROSPECTS ( SO DO+ SEEM REMOTE4 ,& ?US1 ! :OLE ECONOMIC LIFE ( SOCIETY1 /EMS NOT FROM ! NECESSITY ( SATISFY+ ! NE$S ( EV]YBODY1 BUT FROM ! 9T]E/S ( ! EMPLOY]S & BY ! COMPETITION 9 :I* !Y >E 5GAG$ AMONG !MSELVES4 ,H5CE LIMIT$ PRODUCTION TO KEEP PRICES HI<2 H5CE ! PH5OM5ON ( UNEMPLOYM5T EV5 :5 ! NE$S >E URG5T2 H5CE UNCULTIVAT$ OR BADLY CULTIVAT$ L&2 H5CE POV]TY & ! SUBJECTION ( ! MAJORITY ( WORK]S4 ,UND] SU* CONDITIONS1 H[ IS IT POSSIBLE TO PRODUCE 9 ABUNDANCE = EV]YBODY8.<#a#b#e.> ,!RE HAVE BE5 MANY AN>*I/S1 & AMONG !M SOME ( ! MO/ EM95T1 :O HAVE PROPAGAT$ ! IDEA ?AT ! QUANTITY ( GOODS PRODUC$ & /OR$ 9 ! W>EH\SES & GRAN>IES IS SO OV]-ABUNDANT ?AT IT W\LD ONLY BE NECESS>Y TO DRAW ON !SE /ORES TO FULLY SATISFY ! NE$S & WI%ES ( ALL )\T HAV+ TO WORRY \RSELVES AB\T ! PROBLEMS ( WORK & PRODUCTION = A LONG TIME TO COME4 ,&1 ( C\RSE1 !Y F\ND PEOPLE :O W]E WILL+ TO BELIEVE !M4 ,HUMAN BE+S >E ONLY TOO LIABLE TO SUCCUMB TO A T5D5CY TO AVOID TOIL & DANG]S4 ,JU/ AS ! SOCIAL DEMOCRATS F\ND A CONSID]ABLE MEASURE ( SUPPORT AMONG ! MASSES :5 !Y TRI$ TO MAKE \T ?AT IT WAS SUFFICI5T TO PUT A PIECE ( PAP] 9 ! BALLOT BOX 9 ORD] TO EMANCIPATE ONESELF1 SO SOME AN>*I/S ATTRACT$ O!R MASSES BY ASSUR+ !M ALL ?AT WAS NE$$ WAS A ONE-DAY EPIC /RUGGLE 9 ORD] TO 5JOY1 )\T EF=T1 OR ) A M9IMUM ( EF=T1 ! P>ADISE ( ABUNDANCE 9 A /ATE ( FRE$OM4 ,N[1 ?IS IS PRECISELY ! CONTR>Y ( ! TRU?4 ,CAPITALI/S MAKE O!RS PRODUCE TO SELL = PR(IT1 & !RE=E /OP PRODUCTION AS SOON AS !Y SEE ?AT PR(ITS W\LD DIM9I% OR DISAPPE>4 ,!Y G5]ALLY F9D IT MORE ADVANTAGE\S TO KEEP M>KETS 9 A SITUATION ( RELATIVE %ORTAGE2 & ?IS IS %[N BY ! FACT ?AT ONE BAD H>VE/ CAN RESULT 9 GOODS BE+ 9 %ORT SUPPLY OR EV5 NOT AVAILABLE AT ALL4 ,IT CAN BE SAID !RE=E1 ?AT ! GREATE/ H>M WR\MY ( P>ASITES ?AT IT FE$S1 AS ! OB/ACLES IT PLACES 9 ! WAY ( ! PRODUCTION ( USEFUL COMMODITIES4 ,! HUNGRY & ! BADLY CLO!D >E DAZZL$ :5 !Y PASS %OPS BULG+ ) GOODS ( EV]Y K9D2 BUT TRY TO DI/RIBUTE ?IS WEAL? AMONG ALL ! NE$Y & Y\ WILL SEE H[ SMALL W\LD BE EA* ONE'S %>E6 ,SOCIALISM1 ! ASPIRATION TO SOCIALISM1 9 ! BROAD S5SE ( ! WORD1 APPE>S AS A PROBLEM ( DI/RIBUTION 9 SO F> AS IT IS ! SPECTACLE ( ! POV]TY ( WORK]S COMP>$ ) ! COM=T & LUXURY ( ! P>ASITES1 & ! MORAL REVOLT AGA9/ ! BLATANT SOCIAL 9JU/ICES :I* HAVE DRIV5 ! VICTIMS1 & ALL M5 ( FEEL+1 TO SEEK & TO ADVOCATE BETT] WAYS ( LIV+ TOGE!R 9 SOCIETY4 ,BUT ! A*IEVEM5T ( SOCIALISM--BE IT AN>*I/ OR AU?ORIT>IAN1 MUTUALI/ OR 9DIVIDUALI/1 ETC4--IS ABOVE ALL A PROBLEM ( PRODUCTION4 ,:5 ! GOODS DO NOT EXI/1 IT IS USELESS TO SEEK ! BE/ WAY ( DI/RIBUT+ !M1 & IF M5 >E R$UC$ TO FIE 9 DANG] ( BE+ OV]:ELM$ BY ! BRUTAL /RUGGLE = EXI/5CE4 ,=TUNATELY TODAY ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION AB\ND4 ,ME*ANIZATION1 SCI5CE1 & TE*NOLOGY HAVE C5TUPL$ ! PRODUCTIVE POT5TIAL ( HUMAN LABOR4 ,BUT ONE HAS TO WORK1 & TO DO SO USEFULLY ONE MU/ HAVE ! KN[-H[3 H[ TO DO ! WORK & H[ TO ORGANIZE IT 9 ! MO/ ECONOMICAL WAY4 ,IF AN>*I/S WANT TO ACT EFFECTIVELY 9 COMPETITION ) ! V>I\S POLITICAL P>TIES1 !Y MU/ /UDY 9 DEP?--EA* ONE ! BRAN* ) :I* HE IS MO/ FAMILI>--ALL ! !ORETICAL & PRACTICAL PROBLEMS RELAT$ TO USEFUL WORK4.<#a#b#f.> ,WE MU/ BE> 9 M9D ?AT ON ! MORR[ ( ! REVOLUTION WE %ALL BE FAC$ ) ! DANG] ( HUNG]4 ,?IS IS NOT A REASON = DELAY+ ! REVOLUTION1 BECAUSE ! /ATE ( PRODUCTION WILL1 ) M9OR V>IATIONS1 REMA9 ! SAME1 SO LONG AS ! CAPITALI/ SY/EM LA/S4 ,BUT IT IS A REASON = US TO PAY ATT5TION TO ! PROBLEM & ( H[ 9 A REVOLUTION>Y SITUATION1 TO AVOID ALL WA/E1 TO PREA* ! NE$ = R$UC+ CONSUMPTION TO A M9IMUM1 & TO TAKE IMM$IATE /EPS TO 9CREASE PRODUCTION1 ESPECIALLY ( FOOD4.<#a#b#g.> ,AT ! V]Y MOM5T ( ! REVOLUTION1 AS SOON AS ! DEFEAT ( B\RGEOIS MILIT>Y P[] MAKES IT POSSIBLE1 WE %\LD PUT 9TO EFFECT1 BY MEANS ( ! FREE 9ITIATIVE ( ALL WORK]S' ORGANIZATIONS1 BY ALL MILITANT GR\PS1 & ALL VOLUNTE]S ( ! REVOLUTION>Y MOVEM5T1 ! EXPROPRIATION & ! PLAC+ ( ALL EXI/+ WEAL? 9 COMMON &1 )\T DELAY1 PROCE$ TO ! ORGANIZATION ( DI/RIBUTION & ! REORGANIZATION ( PRODUCTION ACCORD+ TO ! NE$S & WI%ES ( ! DIFF]5T REGIONS1 COMMUNES1 & GR\PS1 & ?US >RIVE1 UND] ! IMPETUS ( ! IDEA & ( NE$S1 AT ! UND]/&+S1 AGREEM5TS1 & DECISIONS NE$$ TO C>RY ON ! LIFE ( SOCIETY4.<#a#b#h.> ,PRODUCTION & DI/RIBUTION MU/ BE CONTROLL$1 ?AT IS ONE MU/ ASC]TA9 :I* COMMODITIES >E NE$$ & 9 :AT QUANTITIES2 :]E !Y >E NE$$ & :AT MEANS >E AVAILABLE TO PRODUCE !M & DI/RIBUTE !M4 ,COLOM] SAYS ?AT 0UND] AN>*Y IT IS ! 9DIVIDUAL :O DET]M9ES PRODUCTION & CONSUMPTION 9 RELATION TO HIS NE$S & HIS CAPABILITIES02 BUT A MOM5T'S REFLECTION %\LD MAKE HIM REALIZE ?AT HE IS TALK+ NONS5SE4 ,S9CE AN 9DIVIDUAL CANNOT ALONE PRODUCE ALL HE NE$S & MU/ EX*ANGE HIS PRODUCTS ) ?OSE ( O!RS1 IT IS NECESS>Y ?AT EA* %\LD KN[ NOT ONLY :AT HE CAN PRODUCE & :AT HE REQUIRES1 BUT BE AW>E ( ! NE$S & CAPABILITIES ( O!RS AS WELL4.<#a#b#i.> ,LIB]TY & LABOR >E ! PR]EQUISITES ( SOCIALISM 7AN>*I/1 COMMUNI/1 ETC47 JU/ AS !Y ALSO >E ! PR]EQUISITES ( ALL HUMAN PROGRESS4.<#a#c.> #a#c4 ,! ,L& ,! PROBLEM ( ! L& IS P]HAPS ! MO/ S]I\S1 & DANG]\S PROBLEM :I* ! REVOLUTION WILL HAVE TO SOLVE4 ,9 JU/ICE 7AB/RACT JU/ICE :I* IS CONTA9$ 9 ! SAY+ TO EA* HIS [N7 ! L& BELONGS TO EV]YBODY & MU/ BE AT ! DISPOSAL ( :OEV] WANTS TO WORK IT1 BY :ATEV] MEANS HE PREF]S1 :E!R 9DIVIDUALLY1 OR 9 SMALL OR L>GE GR\PS1 = HIS [N B5EFIT OR ON BEHALF ( ! COMMUNITY4 ,BUT JU/ICE DOES NOT SUFFICE TO 5SURE CIVILIZ$ LIFE1 & IF IT IS NOT TEMP]$1 ALMO/ CANCEL$ \T1 BY ! SPIRIT ( BRO!RHOOD1 BY ! CONSCI\SNESS ( HUMAN SOLID>ITY1 IT LEADS1 ?R\< ! /RUGGLE ( EA* AGA9/ ALL1 TO SUBJECTION & ! EXPLOITATION ( ! VANQUI%$1 & ?AT IS1 TO 9JU/ICE 9 ALL SOCIAL RELATIONS4 ,TO EA* HIS [N4 ,! [N ( EA* %\LD BE ! P>T %>E DUE TO HIM ( ! NATURAL WEAL? & ! ACCUMULAT$ WEAL? ( PA/ G5]ATIONS ON TOP ( :AT HE PRODUCES BY HIS [N EF=TS4 ,BUT H[ TO DIVIDE JU/LY ! NATURAL WEAL?1 & DET]M9E 9 ! COMPLEXITY ( CIVILIZ$ LIFE & 9 ! COMPLEX PROCESS ( PRODUCTION1 :AT IS AN 9DIVIDUAL'S PRODUCTION8 ,& H[ IS ONE TO MEASURE ! VALUE ( ! PRODUCTS = ! PURPOSES ( EX*ANGE8 ,IF ONE />TS FROM ! PR9CIPLE1 ( EA* = HIMSELF1 IT IS UTOPIAN TO HOPE = JU/ICE1 & TO CLAIM IT1 IS HYPOCRISY1 MAYBE UNCONSCI\S1 :I* S]VES TO COV] UP ! MEANE/ EGOISM1 ! DESIRE = DOM9ATION & ! AVIDITY ( EA* 9DIVIDUAL4 ,COMMUNISM !N APPE>S TO BE ! ONLY POSSIBLE SOLUTION2 ! ONLY SY/EM1 BAS$ ON NATURAL SOLID>ITY1 :I* L9KS ALL MANK9D2 & ONLY A DESIR$ SOLID>ITY L9K+ !M 9 BRO!RHOOD1 CAN RECONCILE ! 9T]E/S ( ALL & S]VE AS ! BASIS = A SOCIETY 9 :I* EV]YONE IS GU>ANTE$ ! GREATE/ POSSIBLE WELL-BE+ & FRE$OM4 ,ON ! QUE/ION ( POSSESSION & UTILIZATION ( ! L& IT IS EV5 CLE>]4 ,IF ALL ! CULTIVABLE L&MASSES W]E EQUALLY F]TILE1 EQUALLY HEAL?Y1 & EQUALLY WELL SITUAT$ = ! PURPOSE ( B>T]1 ONE C\LD VISUALIZE A DIVISION ( ! L& 9 EQUAL P>TS AMONG ALL ! WORK]S1 :O W\LD !N WORK1 9 ASSOCIATION IF !Y WI%$1 & H[ !Y WI%$1 9 ! 9T]E/S ( PRODUCTION4 ,BUT ! CONDITIONS ( F]TILITY1 ! HEAL? & SITUATION ( ! L& >E SO DIFF]5T ?AT IT IS IMPOSSIBLE TO ?9K 9 T]MS ( AN EQUABLE DI/RIBUTION4 ,A GOV]NM5T BY NATIONALIZ+ ! L& & R5T+ IT TO L& WORK]S C\LD1 9 !ORY1 RESOLVE ! PROBLEM BY A TAX1 :I* W\LD GO TO ! ,/ATE1 :AT ECONOMI/S CALL ! ECONOMIC RETURN 7?AT IS1 :ATEV] A PIECE ( L&1 GIV5 EQUAL WORK1 PRODUCES 9 EXCESS OV] ! WORSE PIECE74 ,IT IS ! SY/EM ADVOCAT$ BY ! ,AM]ICAN ,H5RY ,GEORGE4 ,BUT ONE SEES IMM$IATELY ?AT SU* A SY/EM PRESUPPOSES ! CONT9UATION ( ! B\RGEOIS ORD]1 AP>T FROM ! GR[+ P[] ( ! ,/ATE & ! GOV]NM5TAL & BUREAUCRATIC P[]S ) :I* ONE W\LD HAVE TO CONT5D4 ,SO1 = US1 :O NEI!R WANT GOV]NM5T NOR BELIEVE ?AT 9DIVIDUAL POSSESSION ( AGRICULTURAL L& IS POSSIBLE OR DESIRABLE--ECONOMICALLY OR MORALLY--! ONLY SOLUTION IS COMMUNISM4 ,& = ?IS REASON WE >E COMMUNI/S4 ,BUT COMMUNISM MU/ BE VOLUNT>Y1 FREELY DESIR$1 & ACCEPT$2 = W]E IT 9/EAD TO BE IMPOS$1 IT W\LD PRODUCE ! MO/ MON/R\S TYRANNY :I* W\LD RESULT 9 A RETURN TO B\RGEOIS 9DIVIDUALISM4 ,N[1 :ILE WAIT+ = COMMUNISM TO DEMON/RATE1 BY ! EXAMPLE ( ! COLLECTIVES SO ORGANIZ$ FROM ! \TSET1 ITS ADVANTAGES & BE DESIR$ BY ALL1 :AT IS \R PRACTICAL AGR>IAN PROGRAM1 TO BE PUT 9TO OP]ATION AS SOON AS ! REVOLUTION TAKES PLACE8 ,ONCE LEGAL PROTECTION HAS BE5 REMOV$ FROM PROP]TY1 ! WORK]S WILL HAVE TO TAKE POSSESSION ( ALL L& :I* IS NOT BE+ DIRECTLY CULTIVAT$1 BY EXI/+ [N]S ) !IR [N H&S2 !Y WILL HAVE TO E/ABLI% !MSELVES 9TO ASSOCIATIONS & ORGANIZE PRODUCTION1 MAK+ USE ( ! ABILITY & ALL ! TE*NICAL SKILLS ( ?OSE :O HAVE ALWAYS BE5 WORK]S1 AS WELL AS ( ! =M] B\RGEOISIE :O HAV+ BE5 EXPROPRIAT$ &1 BE+ NO LONG] ABLE TO LIVE BY ! WORK ( O!RS1 WILL BY ! NECESSITY ( ?+S HAVE BECOME WORK]S AS WELL4 ,AGREEM5TS WILL BE PROMPTLY REA*$ ) ! ASSOCIATIONS ( 9DU/RIAL WORK]S = ! EX*ANGE ( GOODS1 EI!R ON A COMMUNI/IC BASIS OR 9 ACCORDANCE ) ! DIFF]5T CRIT]IA PREVAIL+ 9 DIFF]5T LOCALITIES4 ,MEAN:ILE ALL FOOD /OCKS W\LD BE EXPROPRIAT$ BY ! PEOPLE 9 REVOLT & DI/RIBUTION TO ! DIFF]5T LOCALITIES & 9DIVIDUALS ORGANIZ$ ?R\< ! 9ITIATIVE ( ! REVOLUTION>Y GR\PS4 ,SE$S1 F]TILIZ]S & F>M MA*9]Y1 & WORK+ ANIMALS WILL BE SUPPLI$ TO ! L& WORK]S2 FREE ACCESS TO ! L& = :OEV] WANTS TO WORK IT4 ,!RE REMA9S ! QUE/ION ( PEASANT PROPRIETORS4 ,%\LD !Y REFUSE TO JO9 =CES ) ! O!RS !RE W\LD BE NO REASON TO H>ASS !M SO LONG AS !Y DO ! WORK !MSELVES & DO NOT EXPLOIT ! LABOR ( O!RS4444 ,! DISADVANTAGES1 ! VIRTUAL IMPOSSIBILITY ( ISOLAT$ WORK1 W\LD SOON ATTRACT !M 9TO ! ORBIT ( ! COLLECTIVITY4444.<#a#c#a.> #a#d4 ,MONEY & ,BANKS ,IT IS A MI/AKE TO BELIEVE AS SOME DO ?AT ! BANKS >E1 OR >E 9 ! MA91 A MEANS TO FACILITATE EX*ANGE2 !Y >E A MEANS TO SPECULATE ON EX*ANGE & CURR5CIES1 TO 9VE/ CAPITAL & MAKE IT PRODUCE 9T]E/1 & TO FULFILL O!R TYPICALLY CAPITALI/ OP]ATIONS1 :I* WILL DISAPPE> AS SOON AS ! PR9CIPLE ?AT NO ONE HAS ! RIY P]IOD1 9 ! P]IOD ( REORGANIZATION & TRANSITION1 !RE MII$ SOLUTIONS ACCORD+ TO ! SY/EM ( PRODUCTION & DI/RIBUTION :I* WILL PREVAIL 9 ! DIFF]5T LOCALITIES & AMONG ! MANY NATURAL & >TIFICIAL GR\P+S ?AT WILL EXI/4 ,:AT SEEMS ESS5TIAL TO ME IS ?AT ALL MONEY ACTUALLY 9 CIRCULATION1 9DU/RIAL %>ES1 TITLE DE$S1 GOV]NM5T SECURITIES1 & ALL O!R SECURITIES :I* REPRES5T ! RI AS IT IS POSSIBLE TO DO SO1 DE/ROY$4.<#a#c#b.> ,IT IS CU/OM>Y 9 .*I/.> CIRCLES TO (F] A SIMPLICI/ SOLUTION TO ! PROBLEM .<( MONEY.> BY SAY+ ?AT IT MU/ BE ABOLI%$4 ,& ?IS W\LD BE ! SOLUTION IF IT W]E A QUE/ION ( AN AN>*I/ SOCIETY1 OR ( A HYPO!TICAL REVOLUTION TO TAKE PLACE 9 ! NEXT HUNDR$ YE>S1 ALWAYS ASSUM+ ?AT ! MASSES C\LD BECOME AN>*I/ & COMMUNI/ BE=E ! CONDITIONS UND] :I* WE LIVE HAD BE5 RADICALLY *ANG$ BY A REVOLUTION4 ,BUT TODAY ! PROBLEM IS COMPLICAT$ 9 QUITE A DIFF]5T WAY4 ,MONEY IS A P[]FUL MEANS ( EXPLOITATION & OPPRESSION2 BUT IT IS ALSO ! ONLY MEANS 7AP>T FROM ! MO/ TYRANNICAL DICTATOR%IP OR ! MO/ IDYLLIC ACCORD7 SO F> DEVIS$ BY HUMAN 9TELLIG5CE TO REGULATE PRODUCTION & DI/RIBUTION AUTOMATICALLY4 ,= ! MOM5T1 RA!R ?AN CONC]N+ ONESELF ) ! ABOLITION ( MONEY ONE %\LD SEEK A WAY TO 5SURE ?AT MONEY TRULY REPRES5TS ! USEFUL WORK P]=M$ BY ITS POSSESSORS4444 ,LET US ASSUME ?AT A SUCCESSFUL 9SURRECTION TAKES PLACE TOMORR[4 ,AN>*Y OR NO AN>*Y1 ! PEOPLE MU/ GO ON EAT+ & PROVID+ = ALL !IR BASIC NE$S4 ,! L>GE CITIES MU/ BE SUPPLI$ ) NECESSITIES MORE OR LESS AS USUAL4 ,IF ! PEASANTS & C>RI]S1 ETC4 REFUSE TO SUPPLY GOODS & S]VICES = NO?+1 & DEM& PAYM5T 9 MONEY :I* !Y >E ACCU/OM$ TO CONSID]+ AS REAL WEAL?1 :AT DOES ONE DO8 ,OBLIGE !M BY =CE8 ,9 :I* CASE WE MI*ISM & TO ANY POSSIBLE *ANGE = ! BETT]4 ,LET ! ,RUSSIAN EXP]I5CE S]VE AS A LESSON4 ,& SO8 ,! COMRADES G5]ALLY REPLY3 ,BUT ! PEASANTS WILL UND]/& ! ADVANTAGES ( COMMUNISM OR AT LEA/ ( ! DIRECT EX*ANGE ( GOODS = GOODS4 ,?IS IS ALL V]Y WELL2 BUT C]TA9LY NOT 9 A DAY1 & ! PEOPLE CANNOT /AY )\T EAT+ = EV5 A DAY4 ,I DID NOT MEAN TO PROPOSE SOLUTIONS .4 ,:AT ,I DO WANT TO DO IS TO DRAW ! COMRADES' ATT5TION TO ! MO/ IMPORTANT QUE/IONS :I* WE %ALL BE FAC$ ) 9 ! REALITY ( A REVOLUTION>Y MORR[4.<#a#c#c.> #a#e4 ,PROP]TY ,\R OPPON5TS1 9T]E/$ DEF5D]S ( ! EXI/+ SY/EM >E 9 ! HABIT ( SAY+1 TO JU/IFY ! RIANTEE ( FRE$OM4 ,& WE AGREE ) !M4 ,>E WE NOT ALWAYS REPEAT+ ?AT HE :O IS POOR IS A SLAVE8 ,!N :Y >E !Y \R OPPON5TS8 ,! REASON IS CLE> & IS ?AT 9 FACT ! PROP]TY !Y DEF5D IS CAPITALI/ PROP]TY1 ?AT IS1 PROP]TY :I* ALL[S SOME TO LIVE BY ! WORK ( O!RS & :I* !RE=E PRESUPPOSES A CLASS ( DISPOSSESS$1 PROP]TYLESS PEOPLE1 OBLIG$ TO SELL !IR LABOR P[] TO ! PROP]TY-[N]S = LESS ?AN ITS VALUE4444.<#a#c#d.> ,! PR9CIPAL REASON = ! BAD EXPLOITATION ( NATURE1 & ( ! MIS]IES ( ! WORK]S1 ( ! ANTAGONISMS & ! SOCIAL /RUGGLES1 IS ! RIANTEE A MAXIMUM PR(IT = ! [N]S ( PROP]TY4 ,IT IS NECESS>Y !RE=E TO ABOLI% PROP]TY4.<#a#c#e.> ,! PR9CIPLE = :I* WE MU/ FIGE OR SMALL4 ,! ABOLITION ( 9DIVIDUAL PROP]TY1 9 ! LIT]AL S5SE ( ! WORD1 WILL COME1 IF IT COMES1 BY ! =CE ( CIRCUM/ANCES1 BY ! DEMON/RABLE ADVANTAGES ( COMMUNI/IC MANAGEM5T1 & BY ! GR[+ SPIRIT ( BRO!RHOOD4 ,BUT :AT HAS TO BE DE/ROY$ AT ONCE1 EV5 ) VIOL5CE IF NECESS>Y1 IS CAPITALI/IC PROP]TY1 ?AT IS1 ! FACT ?AT A FEW CONTROL ! NATURAL WEAL? & ! 9/RUM5TS ( PRODUCTION & CAN ?US OBLIGE O!RS TO WORK = !M4 ,IMPOS$ COMMUNISM W\LD BE ! MO/ DETE/ABLE TYRANNY ?AT ! HUMAN M9D C\LD CONCEIVE4 ,& FREE & VOLUNT>Y COMMUNISM IS IRONICAL IF ONE HAS NOT ! RIGE ORGANIZATIONS ( PRODUCTION W\LD WANT TO BE EXPLOIT$ BY A SMALL EMPLOY]--,I WAS SAY+1 IT REMA9S TO BE SE5 :E!R !SE ISOLAT$ WORK]S W\LD NOT F9D IT MORE CONV5I5T TO COMB9E ) O!RS & VOLUNT>ILY JO9 ONE ( ! EXI/+ COMMUNITIES4 ,! DE/RUCTION ( TITLE DE$S W\LD NOT H>M ! 9DEP5D5T WORK] :OSE REAL TITLE IS POSSESSION & ! WORK DONE4 ,:AT WE >E CONC]N$ ) IS ! DE/RUCTION ( ! TITLES ( ! PROPRIETORS :O EXPLOIT ! LABOR ( O!RS &1 ABOVE ALL1 ( EXPROPRIAT+ !M 9 FACT 9 ORD] TO PUT ! L&1 H\SES1 FACTORIES1 & ALL ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION AT ! DISPOSAL ( ?OSE :O DO ! WORK4 ,IT GOES )\T SAY+ ?AT =M] [N]S W\LD ONLY HAVE TO TAKE P>T 9 PRODUCTION 9 :ATEV] WAY !Y CAN1 TO BE CONSID]$ EQUALS ) ALL O!R WORK]S4.<#a#c#f.> ,WILL PROP]TY .<9 ! REVOLUTION>Y P]IOD.> HAVE TO BE 9DIVIDUAL OR COLLECTIVE8 ,& WILL ! COLLECTIVE HOLD+ ! UNDIVID$ GOODS BE ! LOCAL GR\P1 ! FUNCTIONAL GR\P1 ! GR\P BAS$ ON POLITICAL AFF9ITY1 ! FAMILY GR\P--WILL IT COMPRISE ALL ! 9HABITANTS ( A NATION 5 BLOC & EV5TUALLY ALL HUMANITY8 ,:AT =MS WILL PRODUCTION & EX*ANGE ASSUME8 ,WILL IT BE ! TRIUMPH ( COMMUNISM 7PRODUCTION 9 ASSOCIATION & FREE CONSUMPTION = ALL7 OR COLLECTIVISM 7PRODUCTION 9 COMMON & ! DI/RIBUTION ( GOODS ON ! BASIS ( ! WORK DONE BY EA* 9DIVIDUAL71 OR 9DIVIDUALISM 7TO EA* ! 9DIVIDUAL [N]%IP ( ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION & ! 5JOYM5T ( ! FULL PRODUCT ( HIS LABOR71 OR O!R COMPOSITE =MS ?AT 9DIVIDUAL 9T]E/ & SOCIAL 9/9CT1 ILLUM9AT$ BY EXP]I5CE1 WILL SUGGE/8 ,PROBABLY EV]Y POSSIBLE =M ( POSSESSION & UTILIZATION ( ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION & ALL WAYS ( DI/RIBUTION ( PRODUCE WILL BE TRI$ \T AT ! SAME TIME 9 ONE OR MANY REGIONS1 & !Y WILL COMB9E & BE MODIFI$ 9 V>I\S WAYS UNTIL EXP]I5CE WILL 9DICATE :I* =M1 OR =MS1 IS OR >E1 ! MO/ SUITABLE4 ,9 ! MEANTIME 444 ! NE$ = NOT 9T]RUPT+ PRODUCTION1 & ! IMPOSSIBILITY ( SUSP5D+ CONSUMPTION ( ! NECESSITIES ( LIFE1 WILL MAKE IT NECESS>Y TO TAKE DECISIONS = ! CONT9UATION ( DAILY LIFE AT ! SAME TIME AS EXPROPRIATION PROCE$S4 ,ONE WILL HAVE TO DO ! BE/ ONE CAN1 & SO LONG AS ONE PREV5TS ! CON/ITUTION & CONSOLIDATION ( NEW PRIVILEGE1 !RE WILL BE TIME TO F9D ! BE/ SOLUTIONS4 ,BUT :AT IS ! SOLUTION ?AT SEEMS BE/ TO ME & TO :I* ONE %\LD TRY TO APPROXIMATE8 ,I CALL MYSELF A COMMUNI/1 BECAUSE COMMUNISM1 IT SEEMS TO ME1 IS ! IDEAL TO :I* MANK9D WILL ASPIRE AS LOVE BETWE5 M51 & AN ABUNDANCE ( PRODUCTION1 WILL FREE !M FROM ! FE> ( HUNG] & WILL ?US DE/ROY ! MAJOR OB/ACLE TO BRO!RHOOD BETWE5 !M4 ,BUT REALLY1 EV5 MORE ?AN ! PRACTICAL =MS ( ORGANIZATION :I* MU/ 9EVITABLY BE ADJU/$ ACCORD+ TO ! CIRCUM/ANCES1 & WILL ALWAYS BE 9 A CON/ANT /ATE ( *ANGE1 :AT IS IMPORTANT IS ! SPIRIT :I* 9=MS ?OSE ORGANIZATIONS1 & ! ME?OD US$ TO BR+ !M AB\T2 :AT ,I BELIEVE IMPORTANT IS ?AT !Y %\LD BE GUID$ BY ! SPIRIT ( JU/ICE & ! DESIRE ( ! G5]AL GOOD1 & ?AT !Y %\LD ALWAYS A*IEVE !IR OBJECTIVES ?R\< FRE$OM1 & VOLUNT>ILY4 ,IF FRE$OM & A SPIRIT ( BRO!RHOOD TRULY EXI/1 ALL SOLUTIONS AIM AT ! SAME OBJECTIVE ( EMANCIPATION & HUMAN 5LIY1 !RE IS NO FRE$OM & ! DESIRE = ! GOOD ( ALL IS LACK+1 ALL =MS ( ORGANIZATION CAN RESULT 9 9JU/ICE1 EXPLOITATION1 & DESPOTISM4.<#a#c#g.> #a#f4 ,CRIME & ,PUNI%M5T ,EV]Y AN>*I/ PROPAG&I/ IS FAMILI> ) ! KEY OBJECTIONS3 :O WILL KEEP CRIM9ALS 9 *ECK .<9 ! AN>*I/ SOCIETY.>8 ,TO MY M9D !IR CONC]N IS EXAGG]AT$ S9CE DEL9QU5CY IS A PH5OM5ON ( LITTLE IMPORTANCE COMP>$ ) ! VA/NESS ( EV] PRES5T & G5]AL SOCIAL REALITIES4 ,& ONE CAN BELIEVE 9 ITS AUTOMATIC DISAPPE>ANCE AS A RESULT ( AN 9CREASE 9 MAT]IAL WELL-BE+ & $UCATION1 NOT TO M5TION ADVANCES 9 P$AGOGY & M$IC9E4 ,BUT H[EV] OPTIMI/IC MAY BE \R HOPES1 & ROSY ! FUTURE1 ! FACT REMA9S ?AT DEL9QU5CY & ! FE> ( CRIME TODAY PREV5TS PEACEFUL SOCIAL RELATIONS1 & IT WILL C]TA9LY NOT DISAPPE> FROM ONE MOM5T TO ! NEXT FOLL[+ A REVOLUTION1 H[EV] RADICAL & ?OR\Y ?AT AN>*I/S %\LD CONSID] ! PROBLEM 9 GREAT] DETAIL ?AN !Y NORMALLY DO1 NOT ONLY 9 ORD] ! BETT] TO DEAL ) A POPUL> 0OBJECTION0 BUT 9 ORD] NOT TO EXPOSE !MSELVES TO UNPLEASANT SURPRISES & DANG]\S CONTRADICTIONS4 ,NATURALLY ! CRIMES WE >E TALK+ AB\T >E ANTI-SOCIAL ACTS1 ?AT IS ?OSE :I* (F5D HUMAN FEEL+S & :I* 9FR+E ! RI ,CRIME1 9 \R OP9ION1 IS ANY ACTION :I* T5DS TO CONSCI\SLY 9CREASE HUMAN SUFF]+2 IT IS ! VIOLATION ( ! RIE CRIM9AL & :I* >E NOT2 = ,MAN'S VIEWS DIFF] AS TO :AT CAUSES PA9 OR HAPP9ESS1 :AT IS GOOD & :AT IS BAD1 EXCEPT 9 ?OSE BE/IAL CRIMES :I* (F5D FUNDAM5TAL HUMAN FEEL+S & >E !RE=E UNIV]SALLY CONDEMN$4.<#a#c#i.> ,I IMAG9E ?AT NO ONE W\LD BE PREP>$1 !ORETICALLY1 TO D5Y ?AT FRE$OM UND]/OOD 9 ! S5SE ( RECIPROCITY1 IS ! BASIC PR]EQUISITE ( ANY CIVILIZATION1 ( 0HUMANITY02 BUT ONLY AN>*Y REPRES5TS ITS LOGICAL & COMPLETE REALIZATION4 ,ON ?IS ASSUMPTION1 HE IS A CRIM9AL--NOT AGA9/ NATURE OR ! RESULT ( A METAPHYSICAL LAW1 BUT AGA9/ HIS FELL[ M5 & BECAUSE ! 9T]E/S & FEEL+S ( O!RS HAVE BE5 (F5D$--:OEV] VIOLATES ! EQUAL FRE$OM ( O!RS4 ,& SO LONG AS SU* PEOPLE EXI/1 WE MU/ DEF5D \RSELVES4.<#a#d.> ,?IS NECESS>Y DEF5SE AGA9/ ?OSE :O VIOLATE NOT ! /ATUS QUO BUT ! DEEPE/ FEEL+S :I* DI/+UI% M5 FROM BEA/S1 IS ONE ( ! PRETEXTS BY :I* GOV]NM5TS JU/IFY !IR EXI/5CE4 ,ONE MU/ ELIM9ATE ALL ! SOCIAL CAUSES ( CRIME1 ONE MU/ DEVELOP 9 MAN BRO!RLY FEEL+S1 & MUTUAL RESPECT2 ONE MU/1 AS ,F\RI] PUT IT1 SEEK USEFUL ALT]NATIVES TO CRIME4 ,BUT IF1 & SO LONG AS1 !RE >E CRIM9ALS1 EI!R ! PEOPLE WILL F9D ! MEANS1 & HAVE ! 5]GY1 TO DIRECTLY DEF5D !MSELVES AGA9/ !M1 OR ! POLICE & ! MAGI/RATURE WILL REAPPE> & ) !M1 GOV]NM5T4 ,IT IS NOT BY D5Y+ A PROBLEM ?AT ONE SOLVES IT4.<#a#d#a.> ,ONE CAN1 ) JU/IFICATION1 FE> ?AT ?IS NECESS>Y DEF5SE AGA9/ CRIME C\LD BE ! BEG9N+ ( & ! PRETEXT =1 A NEW SY/EM ( OPPRESSION & PRIVILEGE4 ,IT IS ! AN>*I/S' MISSION TO SEE ?AT ?IS DOES NOT HAPP54 ,BY SEEK+ ! CAUSES ( EA* CRIME & MAK+ EV]Y EF=T TO ELIM9ATE !M2 BY MAK+ IT IMPOSSIBLE = ANYBODY TO D]IVE P]SONAL ADVANTAGE \T ( ! DETECTION ( CRIME1 & LEAV+ IT TO ! 9T]E/$ GR\PS !MSELVES TO TAKE :ATEV] /EPS !Y DEEM NECESS>Y = !IR DEF5SE2 BY ACCU/OM+ ONESELF TO CONSID] CRIM9ALS AS BRO!RS :O HAVE /RAY$1 AS SICK PEOPLE NE$+ LOV+ TREATM5T1 AS ONE W\LD = ANY HYDROPHOBE OR DANG]\S LUNATIC--IT WILL BE POSSIBLE TO RECONCILE ! COMPLETE FRE$OM ( ALL ) DEF5SE AGA9/ ?OSE :O OBVI\SLY & DANG]\SLY ?REAT5 IT4 ,OBVI\SLY ?IS IS POSSIBLE1 :5 CRIME WILL BE R$UC$ TO SPORADIC1 9DIVIDUAL1 & TRULY PA?OLOGICAL CASES4 ,IF IT W]E A FACT ?AT CRIM9ALS W]E TOO NUM]\S & P[]FUL2 IF1 = EXAMPLE1 !Y W]E :AT ! B\RGEOISIE & FASCISM >E TODAY .<#a#i#b#b.>1 !N IT IS NOT A QUE/ION ( DISCUSS+ :AT WE WILL DO 9 AN AN>*I/ SOCIETY4.<#a#d#b.> ,) ! GR[? ( CIVILIZATION1 & ( SOCIAL RELATIONS2 ) ! GR[+ AW>5ESS ( HUMAN SOLID>ITY :I* UNITES MANK9D2 ) ! DEVELOPM5T ( 9TELLIG5CE & A REF9EM5T ( FEEL+S !RE IS C]TA9LY A CORRESPOND+ GR[? ( SOCIAL DUTIES1 & MANY ACTIONS :I* W]E CONSID]$ AS /RICTLY 9DIVIDUAL RIE1 MATT]S AFFECT+ EV]YBODY1 & MU/ !RE=E BE C>RI$ \T 9 CON=MITY ) ! G5]AL 9T]E/4 ,= 9/ANCE1 EV5 9 \R TIMES P>5TS >E NOT ALL[$ TO KEEP !IR *ILDR5 9 IGNORANCE & BR+ !M UP 9 A WAY :I* IS H>MFUL TO !IR DEVELOPM5T & FUTURE WELL-BE+4 ,A P]SON IS NOT ALL[$ TO LIVE 9 FIL?Y CONDITIONS & NEGLECT ?OSE RULES ( HYGI5E :I* CAN AFFECT ! HEAL? ( O!RS2 ONE IS NOT ALL[$ TO HAVE AN 9FECTI\S DISEASE & NOT HAVE IT TREAT$4 ,9 A FUTURE SOCIETY IT WILL BE CONSID]$ A DUTY TO SEEK TO 5SURE ! GOOD ( ALL1 JU/ AS IT WILL BE CONSID]$ BLAMEWOR?Y TO PROCREATE IF !RE >E REASONS TO BELIEVE ?AT ! PROG5Y WILL BE UNHEAL?Y & UNHAPPY4 ,BUT ?IS S5SE ( \R DUTIES TO O!RS1 & ( !IRS TO US MU/1 ACCORD+ TO \R SOCIAL CONCEPTS1 DEVELOP )\T ANY O!R \TSIDE SANCTION ?AN ! E/EEM OR ! DISAPPROVAL ( \R FELL[ CITIZ5S4 ,RESPECT1 ! DESIRE = ! WELL-BE+ ( O!RS1 MU/ 5T] 9TO ! CU/OMS1 & MANIFE/ !MSELVES NOT AS DUTIES BUT AS A NORMAL SATISFACTION ( SOCIAL 9/9CTS4 ,!RE >E ?OSE :O W\LD IMPROVE ! MORALITY ( PEOPLE BY =CE1 :O W\LD WI% TO 9TRODUCE AN ,>TICLE 9TO ! P5AL CODE = EV]Y POSSIBLE HUMAN ACTION1 :O W\LD PLACE A G5D>ME ALONGSIDE EV]Y NUPTIAL B$ & BY EV]Y TABLE4 ,BUT !SE PEOPLE IF !Y LACK ! CO]CIVE P[]S TO IMPOSE !IR IDEAS1 ONLY SUCCE$ 9 MAK+ A MOCK]Y ( ! BE/ ?+S2 & IF !Y HAVE ! P[] TO COMM&1 MAKE :AT IS GOOD HATEFUL1 & 5C\RAGE REACTION4444 ,= US ! C>RY+ \T ( SOCIAL DUTIES MU/ BE A VOLUNT>Y ACT1 & ONE HAS ! RIY DEF5SE8 ,:O WILL E/ABLI% :AT MEASURES ( RE/RA9T >E TO BE US$8 ,WE DO NOT SEE ANY O!R WAY ?AN ?AT ( LEAV+ IT TO ! 9T]E/$ P>TIES1 TO ! PEOPLE1 ?AT IS ! MASS ( CITIZ5S1 :O WILL ACT 9 DIFF]5T WAYS ACCORD+ TO ! CIRCUM/ANCES & ACCORD+ TO !IR DIFF]5T DEGREES ( SOCIAL DEVELOPM5T4 ,ONE MU/1 ABOVE ALL1 AVOID ! CREATION ( BODIES SPECIALIZ+ 9 POLICE WORK2 P]HAPS SOME?+ WILL BE LO/ 9 REPRESSIVE EFFICI5CY BUT ONE WILL ALSO AVOID ! CREATION ( ! 9/RUM5T ( EV]Y TYRANNY4 ,WE DO NOT BELIEVE 9 ! 9FALLIBILITY1 NOR EV5 9 ! G5]AL GOODNESS ( ! MASSES2 ON ! CONTR>Y4 ,BUT WE BELIEVE EV5 LESS 9 ! 9FALLIBILITY & GOODNESS ( ?OSE :O SEIZE P[] & LEGISLATE1 :O CONSOLIDATE & P]PETUATE ! IDEAS & 9T]E/S :I* PREVAIL AT ANY GIV5 MOM5T4 ,9 EV]Y RESPECT ! 9JU/ICE1 & TRANSITORY VIOL5CE ( ! PEOPLE IS PREF]ABLE TO ! LEAD5-RULE1 ! LEGALIZ$ ,/ATE VIOL5CE ( ! JUDICI>Y & POLICE4 ,WE >E1 9 ANY CASE1 ONLY ONE ( ! =CES ACT+ 9 SOCIETY1 & HI/ORY WILL ADVANCE1 AS ALWAYS1 9 ! DIRECTION ( ! RESULTANT ( ALL ! . =CES4.<#a#d#c.> ,WE MU/ RECKON ) A RESIDUE ( DEL9QU5CY 444 :I* WE HOPE WILL BE ELIM9AT$ MORE OR LESS RAPIDLY1 BUT :I* 9 ! MEANTIME WILL OBLIGE ! MASS ( WORK]S TO TAKE DEF5SIVE ACTION4 ,DISC>D+ EV]Y CONCEPT ( PUNI%M5T & REV5GE1 :I* /ILL DOM9ATE P5AL LAW1 & GUID$ ONLY BY ! NE$ = SELF-DEF5SE & ! DESIRE TO REHABILITATE1 WE MU/ SEEK ! MEANS TO A*IEVE \R GOAL1 )\T FALL+ 9TO ! DANG]S ( AU?ORIT>IANISM & CONSEQU5TLY F9D+ \RSELVES 9 CONTRADICTION ) ! SY/EM ( LIB]TY & FREE-WILL ON :I* WE SEEK TO BUILD ! NEW SOCIETY4.<#a#d#d.> ,= AU?ORIT>IANS & /ATESM51 ! QUE/ION IS A SIMPLE ONE3 A LEGISLATIVE BODY TO LI/ ! CRIMES & PRESCRIBE ! PUNI%M5TS2 A POLICE =CE TO HUNT \T ! DEL9QU5TS2 A MAGI/RATURE TO JUDGE !M2 & A PRISON S]VICE TO MAKE !M SUFF]4 ,&1 AS IS UND]/&ABLE1 ! LEGISLATIVE BODY SEEKS ?R\< ITS P5AL LAWS TO DEF5D1 ABOVE ALL1 E/ABLI%$ 9T]E/1 :I* IT REPRES5TS1 & TO PROTECT ! ,/ATE FROM ?OSE :O SEEK TO 0SUBV]T0 IT4 ,! POLICE =CE EXI/S TO SUPPRESS CRIME1 & HAV+ !RE=E AN 9T]E/ 9 ! CONT9U$ EXI/5CE ( CRIME BECOMES PROVOCATIVE1 & DEVELOPS 9 ITS (FIC]S AGGRESSIVE & P]V]SE 9/9CTS2 ! MAGI/RATURE ALSO LIVES & PROSP]S ?ANKS TO CRIME & DEL9QU5TS1 & S]VES ! 9T]E/S ( ! GOV]NM5T & ! RUL+ CLASSES1 & ACQUIRES1 9 ! C\RSE ( EX]CIS+ ITS FUNCTION1 A SPECIAL WAY ( REASON+1 :I* MAKES IT 9TO A MA*9E = AW>D+ A MAXIMUM NUMB] ( PEOPLE ! LONGE/ S5T5CES IT CAN4 ,! W>D]S >E1 OR BECOME1 9S5SITIVE TO ! SUFF]+ ( PRISON]S & AT BE/1 PASSIVELY OBS]VE ! RULES )\T A SP>K ( HUMAN FEEL+4 ,ONE SEES ! RESULTS 9 /ATI/ICS ON DEL9QU5CY4 ,! P5AL LAWS >E *ANG$1 ! POLICE =CE & ! MAGI/RATURE >E REORGANIZ$1 ! PRISON SY/EM IS RE=M$ 444 & DEL9QU5CY P]SI/S & RESI/S ALL ATTEMPTS TO DE/ROY1 OR R$UCE IT4 ,IT IS TRUE ( ! PA/ & ! PRES5T1 & WE ?9K IT WILL APPLY 9 ! FUTURE TOO1 IF ! :OLE CONCEPT ( CRIME IS NOT *ANG$1 & ALL ! ORGANISMS :I* LIVE ON ! PREV5TION & REPRESSION ( DEL9QU5CY >E NOT ABOLI%$4.<#a#d#e.> ,!RE >E 9 ,FRANCE /R+5T LAWS AGA9/ ! TRAFFIC 9 DRUGS & AGA9/ ?OSE :O TAKE !M4 ,& AS ALWAYS HAPP5S1 ! SC\RGE GR[S & SPREADS 9 SPITE1 & P]HAPS BECAUSE (1 ! LAWS4 ,! SAME IS HAPP5+ 9 ! RE/ ( ,EUROPE & 9 ,AM]ICA4 ,DOCTOR ,C\RTOIS-,SUFFIT1 ( ! ,FR5* ,ACADEMY ( ,M$IC9E1 :O1 ALREADY LA/ YE> .<#a#i#b#a.>1 HAD S\ND$ ! AL>M AGA9/ ! DANG]S ( COCA9E1 NOT+ ! FAILURE ( P5AL LEGISLATION1 N[ DEM&S 444 NEW & MORE /R+5T LAWS4 ,IT IS ! OLD MI/AKE ( LEGISLATORS1 9 SPITE ( EXP]I5CE 9V>IABLY %[+ ?AT LAWS1 H[EV] B>B>\S !Y MAY BE1 HAVE NEV] S]V$ TO SUPPRESS VICE OR TO DISC\RAGE DEL9QU5CY4 ,! MORE SEV]E ! P5ALTIES IMPOS$ ON ! CONSUM]S & TRAFFICK]S ( COCA9E1 ! GREAT] WILL BE ! ATTRACTION ( =BIDD5 FRUITS & ! FASC9ATION ( ! RISKS 9CURR$ BY ! CONSUM]1 & ! GREAT] WILL BE ! PR(ITS MADE BY ! SPECULATORS1 AVID = MONEY4 ,IT IS USELESS1 !RE=E TO HOPE = ANY?+ FROM ! LAW4 ,WE MU/ SUGGE/ ANO!R SOLUTION4 ,MAKE ! USE & SALE ( COCA9E FREE .1 & OP5 KIOSKS :]E IT W\LD BE SOLD AT CO/ PRICE OR EV5 UND] CO/4 ,& !N LAUN* A GREAT PROPAG&A CAMPAIGN TO EXPLA9 TO ! PUBLIC1 & LET !M SEE = !MSELVES1 ! EVILS ( COCA9E2 NO ONE W\LD 5GAGE 9 C\NT]-PROPAG&A BECAUSE NOBODY C\LD EXPLOIT ! MIS=TUNES ( COCA9E ADDICTS4 ,C]TA9LY ! H>MFUL USE ( COCA9E W\LD NOT DISAPPE> COMPLETELY1 BECAUSE ! SOCIAL CAUSES :I* CREATE & DRIVE ?OSE POOR DEVILS TO ! USE ( DRUGS W\LD /ILL EXI/4 ,BUT 9 ANY CASE ! EVIL W\LD DECREASE1 BECAUSE NOBODY C\LD MAKE PR(ITS \T ( ITS SALE1 & NOBODY C\LD SPECULATE ON ! HUNT = SPECULATORS4 ,& = ?IS REASON \R SUGGE/ION EI!R WILL NOT BE TAK5 9TO ACC\NT1 OR IT WILL BE CONSID]$ IMPRACTICAL & MAD4 ,YET 9TELLIG5T & DIS9T]E/$ PEOPLE MI*I/ ME?OD8.<#a#d#f.> ,WE WILL NOT REPEAT ! CLASSICAL >GUM5TS AGA9/ ! DEA? P5ALTY4 ,!Y SEEM LIES1 :5 WE HE> !M US$ BY ?OSE :O !N COME \T 9 FAVOR ( LIFE IMPRISONM5T & O!R 9HUMAN SUB/ITUTES = ! DEA? P5ALTY4 ,NOR WILL WE SPEAK ( ! 0SANCTITY ( LIFE0 :I* ALL AFFIRM BUT VIOLATE :5 IT SUITS !M1 EI!R BY ACTUALLY TAK+ LIFE OR TREAT+ O!RS 9 SU* A WAY AS TO TORM5T OR %ORT5 !IR LIVES4 ,=TUNATELY ONLY FEW M5 >E BORN1 OR BECOME1 MORAL BLOOD?IR/Y & SADI/IC MON/]S :OSE DEA? WE W\LD NOT KN[ H[ TO M\RN4 ,IF !SE POOR DEVILS W]E TO BE A CONT9U\S ?REAT TO EV]YBODY & !RE W]E NO O!R WAY ( DEF5D+ \RSELVES O!R ?AN BY KILL+ !M1 ONE C\LD ALSO ADMIT ! DEA? P5ALTY4 ,BUT ! TR\BLE IS ?AT 9 ORD] TO C>RY \T ! DEA? P5ALTY ONE NE$S AN EXECUTION]4 ,! EXECUTION] IS1 OR BECOMES1 A MON/]2 & ON BALANCE IT IS BETT] TO LET ! MON/]S ?AT !RE >E GO ON LIV+1 RA!R ?AN TO CREATE O!RS4 ,& ?IS APPLIES TO REAL DEL9QU5TS1 ANTI-SOCIAL BE+S :O >\SE NO SYMPA?Y & PROVOKE NO COMMIS]ATION4 ,:5 IT COMES TO ! DEA? P5ALTY AS A MEANS ( POLITICAL /RUGGLE1 !N 444 WELL HI/ORY TEA*ES US :AT CAN BE ! CONSEQU5CES4.<#a#d#g.> ,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,JANU>Y #b#h1 #bba 3 ,P>T #a1 ,*APT] #c -- ,ADD$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/