,NOTES ON 0,PO/-,LEFT ,AN>*ISM0 #bae ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,BOB ,BLACK ,TEXT 3 ,IT IS PLA9 ?AT ! GOAL ( REVOLUTION TODAY MU/ BE ! LIB]ATION ( DAILY LIFE - ,MURRAY ,BOOK*9.<#a.> ,:AT IS PO/-LEFT AN>*ISM8 ,I'M NOT SURE :O CO9$ ! PHRASE1 BUT IT LOOKS LIKE ,I DID4 ,AT SOME PO9T1 ,I ASK$ SEV]AL ( ! PEOPLE MO/ LIKELY TO KN[ 79CLUD+ ,JOHN ,Z]ZAN1 ,LAWR5CE ,J>A* & ,JASON ,MC,QU9N71 & NO ONE WAS AW>E ( ANYONE US+ ! PHRASE BE=E ,I DID4 ,JASON ,MC,QU9N CONFIRMS ?IS 9 A REC5T LETT]4.<#b.> ,! FIR/ KN[N USE ( ! PHRASE IS 9 ! LA/ S5T5CE ( MY BOOK ,AN>*Y AFT] ,LEFTISM1.<#c.> :I* WAS WRITT5 9 #aiif & PUBLI%$ 9 #a#i#i#g4 ,?IS IS ! BOOK'S LA/ P>AGRAPH3 0,!RE IS LIFE AFT] ! LEFT4 ,& !RE IS AN>*Y AFT] AN>*ISM4 ,PO/-LEFT AN>*I/S >E /RIK+ (F 9 MANY DIRECTIONS4 ,SOME MAY F9D ! WAY - BETT] YET1 ! WAYS - TO A FREE FUTURE40.<#d.> ,AT ! TIME1 ,I ASSUM$ ?AT PO/-LEFT AN>*ISM WAS A PHRASE 9 CURR5T CIRCULATION4 ,BE ?AT AS IT MAY1 ! PHRASE WAS TAK5 UP H]E & !RE BY V>I\S RADICAL AN>*I/S4 ,JASON WRITES TO ME 0?AT1 9SPIR$ BY Y\R ,AN>*Y AFT] ,LEFTISM TEXT1 ,I *>ACT]IZ$ Y\R TEXT AS P>T ( A !ORETICAL & PRACTICAL AN>*I/ CRITIQUE ?AT GREW \T ( HI/ORICAL AN>*I/ PRACTICES1 !#a#i#fS REBELLIONS & SITUATIONI/ 9FLU5CES 7& ?AT WAS ! ORIG9AL 9SPIRATION BEH9D ,A,J,O,D,A .<,AN>*Y3 ,A ,J\RNAL ( ,DESIRE ,>M$.>7 AS 'PO/-LEFT AN>*I/1' :5 ,I CALL$ = CONTRIBUTIONS TO ! ',PO/-,LEFT ,AN>*Y' ISSUE ( ,AN>*Y MAGAZ9E .40.<#e.> ,:AT FOLL[S IS P>T MEMOIR1 P>T HI/ORY1 & P>T CRITIQUE4 ,! MEMOIR P>T1 REG>D$ AS P>T ( ! HI/ORY P>T1 W\LD EXAGG]ATE MY P]SONAL ROLE4 ,! ESSAY %\LD BE READ ) ?IS 9 M9D4 ,&1 WRITT5 AS IT IS FROM MY P>O*IAL P]SPECTIVE1 IT CONC5TRATES ON ,NOR? ,AM]ICA ALMO/ EXCLUSIVELY1 AL?\< ! PH5OM5A ,I DESCRIBE HAVE1 & HAD1 C\NT]P>TS 9 ,BRITA91 ! ,NE!RL&S1 ,9DIA1 & ELSE:]E4 ,! PHRASE PO/-LEFT AN>*ISM 7OR AN>*Y7 N[ 5JOYS ! DUBI\S DI/9CTION ( A ,WIKIP$IA 5TRY1 :I* AM\NTS TO AN ONTOLOGICAL SEAL ( APPROVAL4 ,UNTIL ! COLLAPSE ( CIVILIZATION1 IT WILL NEV] GO AWAY4 ,I C\LD NOT N[ FULLY RECON/RUCT ! ORIG9AL MEAN+1 = ME1 ( AN EXPRESSION :I* ,I DIDN'T ?9K WAS ORIG9AL4 ,9/EAD ,I %ALL BEG9 BY1 9 A SMALL WAY1 DECON/RUCT+ IT4 0,PO/-0 ORIG9ALLY IS A TEMPORAL SIGNIFI]4 ,IT MEANS 0AFT]40 ,PO/-LEFT AN>*ISM1 :ATEV] IT MEANS1 REF]S TO AN AN>*ISM :I* HAS1 BY & L>GE1 COME AFT]1 & L>GELY \T (1 AN>*O-LEFTISM4.<#f.> ,9 MY CASE1 ,I WAS RECEPTIVE TO EXACTLY ! 9FLU5CES :I* ,JASON ,MC,QU9N M5TIONS4 ,:5 ,I USE ! PHRASE 7,I DON'T USE IT A LOT71 ,I ?9K ( AN>*I/S WRIT+ 9 ! LA/ #d OR #e YE>S :O HAVE TAK5 UP1 OR TAK5 ON1 MATT]S :I* ! TRADITIONAL AN>*O-LEFTI/S NEV] CONSID]$2 OR IF !Y OCCASIONALLY DID CONSID] !M1 !IR REACTIONS - V>I\SLY /]EOTYP$1 SUP]FICIAL1 MOCK+1 & DISMISSIVE -- CALL$ = CRITIQUE4 ,AMONG ! PEOPLE ,I WAS ?9K+ ( AS PO/-LEFT AN>*I/S W]E ,FR$Y ,P]LMAN1 ,JOHN ,Z]ZAN1 ,DAN ,TODD1 ,HAKIM ,BEY1 ,MAX ,CAF>D1 ,MI*AEL ,WILLIAM1 ,JOHN ,MOORE1 ! ,FIF? ,E/ATE WRIT]S ( ! #g'S & #h'S 7SU* AS ,GEORGE ,BRAD=D_/,DAVID ,WATSON & ,PET] ,W]BE71 ,WOLFI ,L&/REI*] 7HE HAD O!R NAMES BACK !N71 ! ,GRE5 ,AN>*ISM WRIT]S 7ESPECIALLY ,JOHN ,CONNOR71 & SEV]AL REGUL> CONTRIBUTORS TO ,AN>*Y3 ,A ,J\RNAL ( ,DESIRE 9CLUD+ ITS $ITOR ,JASON ,MC,QU9N 7!N KN[N AS ,LEV ,*]NYI71 ,LAWR5CE ,J>A*1 & ,>AGORN4 ,SEV]AL ( !M W\LD DECL9E ! HONOR4 ,JOHN ,Z]ZAN W\LD RA!R BE CONSID]$ ANTI-LEFTI/ ?AN PO/-LEFTI/4 ,SOME ( !M >E BETT] KN[N 7OR W\LD LIKE TO BE BETT] KN[N7 AS NIHILI/S1 GRE5S1 PRIMITIVI/S1 QUE]S1 9SURRECTIONI/S1 EGOI/S1 ETC4 ,SOME W]E NOTICEABLY 9FLU5C$ - AS ,I WAS -- BY ! POLITICIZ$ AVANT-G>DE >T_/ANTI->T.<#g.> CURR5TS3 ,DADA1 ,SURREALISM1 & ESPECIALLY ! ,SITUATIONI/S4 ,NONE ( :I*1 9CID5TALLY1 W]E AN>*I/1 OR EV] FULLY SUP]S$$ LEFTISM4 ,:AT WAS LIV+1 I4E41 :AT WAS NOT DEAD 7NOT LEFTI/71 91 = EXAMPLE1 9 0SITUATIONISM0 7! ,SITUATIONI/S D5\NC$ ! WORD71 IS TO BE F\ND AMONG PO/-LEFT AN>*I/S & ALMO/ NO:]E ELSE4 ,= REASONS :I* REMA9 OBSCURE1 JU/ :5 ! ,NEW ,LEFT #fS W]E EXPIR+1 MA9/REAM PUBLI%]S BEGAN TO PUBLI% OR REPUBLI% SOME ( ! AN>*I/ CLASSICS4.<#h.> ,?REE ,*>LES ,F\RI] AN?OLOGIES 7TWO ( !M ORIG9AL7 W]E PUBLI%$ BY ,D\BL$AY1 ,S*OCK5 ,BOOKS1 & ! ,H>V>D ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS4 ,DOV] ,BOOKS PUBLI%$ ,BAKUN91 ,KROPOTK91 ,GOLDMAN & ,B]KMAN4 ,GROVE ,PRESS PUBLI%$ A ,BAKUN9 AN?OLOGY4 ,V9TAGE ,BOOKS ALSO PUBLI%$ ,GOLDMAN4 ,D\BL$AY PUBLI%$ A ,PR\DHON AN?OLOGY4 ,BEACON ,PRESS PUBLI%$ ,H]B]T ,READ4 ,H>P] @& ,R[ PUBLI%$ ,ROB]T ,PAUL ,WOLFF & ,MAX ,/IRN]1 AL?\<1 9 ! LATT] CASE1 9 A SCURRIL\S CONTEXT4.<#i.> ,MA9/REAM & UNIV]SITY PRESS PUBLI%]S ALSO 9CREAS$ !IR \TPUT ( AN>*I/ HI/ORY & BIOGRAPHY BY ACADEMIC S*OL>S SU* AS ,PAUL ,AVRI*4 ,BUT :Y8 ,BECAUSE ( SOME VAGUELY FELT S5SE ?AT ! #fS W]E AN>*I/IC1 & SO MAYBE ACTUAL AN>*I/ !ORI/S MI*I/ BOOKS W]E MADE MU* MORE WIDELY AVAILABLE ?AN !Y HAD BE5 S9CE ,WORLD ,W> ,I,I1 OR 9DE$ S9CE ,WORLD ,W> ,I4 ,MANY FUTURE AN>*I/S1 LEFT OR 9CIPI5TLY PO/-LEFT1 READ !M4 ,! BACKGR\ND ( CONTEMPOR>Y NONTRADITIONAL AN>*ISM IS ! #fS - ! #fS ( ! ,NEW ,LEFT & ! ,YIPPIES1 BUT EV5 MORE SO ! IDEAS & ACTIONS ( ,MAY #a#i#f#h4.<#a.> ,! IMM$IATE ANTEC$5T ( PO/-LEFT AN>*ISM WAS ! - AT FIR/ RA!R LOCALIZ$ -- 9TELLECTUAL F]M5T ( ! #a#i#gS ESPECIALLY AS /IMULAT$ 9 ,DETROIT BY ,FR$Y ,P]LMAN'S ,BLACK @& ,R$ PUBLI%+ PROJECT &1 A LITTLE LAT]1 ! ,FIF? ,E/ATE AFT] ! AN>*I/ TAKEOV]4.<#a#a.> ,WE W]E TREAT$ TO ONE !ORETICAL OR HI/ORICAL OR AN?ROPOLOGICAL NOVELTY AFT] ANO!R4 ,WE W]E 9TRODUC$ TO ,F\CAULT1 ,CAMATTE1 ,SAHL9S1 ,DEBORD1 ,MUM=D1 ,ELLUL1 ,VANEIGEM1 ,B>ROT1 ,CLA/RES1 ,DEBORD1 ,FR$RIC ,TURN]1 & ! E>LY ,BAUDRILL>D ,WE LE>N$ ! HIDD5 HI/ORY ( ! ,RUSSIAN ,REVOLUTION FROM ,>%9OV & ,VOL9E4 ,IRONICALLY1 WE ALSO READ ,MURRAY ,BOOK*9'S ESSAYS ( ! #a#i#gS1 SU* AS 0,SPONTANEITY & ,ORGANIZATION10.<#a#c.> :I* EXPRESS$ ! V]Y ESS5CE ( :AT HE LAT] C>ICATUR$ AS LIFE/YLE AN>*ISM4 ,?IS WAS RI* F>E1 :I* WAS SOMETIMES REGURGITAT$ )\T HAV+ BE5 FULLY DIGE/$4 ,BUT !RE WAS NO?+ LIKE IT ON ! AN>*O-LEFT1 FROM :I* WE W]E1 AT V>I\S SPE$S1 DRIFT+ AWAY4 ,OV] !RE1 COLLEGE /UD5TS & B>I/AS W]E1 9 SMALL NUMB]S1 JO9+ ! ,9DU/RIAL ,WORK]S ( ! ,WORLD1 F\ND+ SELF-DE/RUCT+ AN>*I/ MEMB]%IP ORGANIZATIONS1 &_/OR FEUD+ ) EA* O!R4 ,! RISE ( PO/-LEFT AN>*ISM CO9CID$ ) ! HEYDAY ( :AT ,I CALL ! M>G9ALS MILIEU3 ! Z9E SUBCULTURE1 ! DO-IT-Y\RSELF SUBCULTURE :I* IS ! SUBJECT ( MY BOOK ,B5EA? ! ,UND]GR\ND4.<#a#c.> ,ANYBODY ) ACCESS TO COPY MA*9ES1 & POCKET MONEY = /AMPS1 C\LD JO9 94 0,PO/]I/S0 SU* AS ,UP%OT 7,JOHN & ,PAULA ,Z]ZAN7 & ,! ,LA/ ,9T]NATIONAL 7MYSELF7 F\ND PLACES TO PUBLI% PO/]S :I* HAD ORIG9ALLY TAK5 ! =M ( PO/]S1 9T5D$ TO BE /APL$ UP1 ON ! ASSUMPTION ?AT :AT !Y HAD TO SAY WAS UNPUBLI%ABLE4 ,Z9E PUBLI%]S LIK$ PO/]S BECAUSE !Y W]E %ORT1 TO ! PO9T1 (T5 WITTY1 & CAM]A-READY4 ,COLLAGE >T PROV$ TO BE ESPECIALLY CONG5IAL TO Z9ES4 ,A FEW ( ! Z9E >TI/S W]E EV5 AW>E ?AT :AT !Y W]E DO+ IS :AT ! ,SITUATIONI/S CALL$ DET\RNEM5T1 0,%ORT = DET\RNEM5T ( PREEXI/+ ES!TIC ELEM5TS40.<#a#d.> ,MAIL >TI/S LIKE ,AL ,ACK]MAN1 :O HAD LONG BE5 US+ ! MAILS TO CIRCULATE 9DIVIDUALIZ$ >T1 ALSO FIT RIG9ALS MILIEU1 & !Y C\LD FAIRLY CLAIM TO HAVE ANTICIPAT$ IT4 ,! Z9E 7%ORT = 0FANZ9E07 =MAT ITSELF HAD BE5 9V5T$ BY SCI5CE FICTION F&OM 9 ! LATE #a#i#cS1 :I* ALSO OV]LAPP$ ! M>G9ALS MILIEU BY ! #a#i#hS4 ,! CONNECTION BETWE5 PUNK & AN>*ISM1 =G$ 9 ! #a#i#gS & /ILL NOT QUITE BROK51 W\LD REQUIRE ITS [N >TICLE OR BOOK TO DISCUSS4.<#a#e.> ,!RE W]E ALSO TABLOIDS1 SU* AS ,POPUL> ,REALITY1 & PHOTOCOPY MAGAZ9ES SU* AS ,DH>MA ,COMBAT & ,FEH6 & ,DEMOLITION ,D]BY1 TO M5TION JU/ A FEW ( ! BE/ ONES1 & MANY PAMPHLETE]S 79CLUD+ 0PRO-SITU0 GR\PS SU* AS ,NEGATION1 ,CONTRADICTION1 ,PO9T ,BLANK1 & ,= ,\RSELVES1 :I* W]E MO/ ACTIVE 9 ! E>LY #gS.<#a#f.>74 ,Z9E MEMBRANES W]E USUALLY P]MEABLE1 & AN>*ISM1 ESPECIALLY ! NONTRADITIONAL T5D5CIES1 P]MEAT$ ! M>G9ALS MILIEU4 ,! MILIEU ITSELF WAS 9H]5TLY AN>*I/IC 9S(> AS IT WAS RADICALLY DEC5TRALIZ$1 9DIVIDUALI/IC YET TI BUT HE PUBLI%$ ONE HIMSELF 79 NEWSLETT] =MAT73 ,COMM5T1 FROM :I* IS DRAWN HIS BE/ BOOK1 ,T[>D AN ,ECOLOGICAL ,SOCIETY4 ,FROM ITS P9NACLE 9 #a#i#h#e-#a#i#i1 ! SC5E GRADUALLY DW9DL$1 AL?\T IT HASN'T 5TIRELY DISAPPE>$4 ,BY #aiif OR SO1 ! Z9E SUBCULTURE HAD MO/LY EI!R WI!R$ AWAY OR MIGRAT$ TO ! ,9T]NET4 ,AS MU* AS ,I REGRETT$ ITS DEMISE1 IT PASS+ WAS 9 KEEP+ ) ITS [N E?OS1 AS ) M9E4 ,ALL AUTONOM\S ZONES >E NECESS>ILY TEMPOR>Y1 EV5 9 A WORLD ( ONLY AUTONOM\S ZONES4 ,!Y %\LD /ILL BE TRANSI5T1 LIKE ! CON/RUCTION ( SITUATIONS4.<#a#h.> ,! DO-IT-Y\RSELF SUBCULTURE WAS A LADD] TO BE CLIMB$1 !N KICK$ AWAY 7,WITTG5/E9 AGA9.<#a#i.> -- SORRY74 ,BUT WE GOT A KICK \T ( IT TOO4 ,9 RETROSPECT1 ,I NOTICE ?AT ,I PREVIEW$ PO/-LEFT AN>*ISM 9 A SATIRIC WAY 9 0,ELEM5T>Y ,WATSONIANISM10 :I* WAS PUBLI%$1 TO MY A/ONI%M5T1 9 ! ,C5T5NIAL ISSUE 7#a#i#h#f7 ( ! V5]ABLE ,LONDON AN>*I/ P]IODICAL ,FRE$OM4 ,AMONG ITS F\ND]S WAS ,KROPOTK94 ,NOT ALL TRADITIONALI/ AN>*I/S LACK A S5SE ( HUMOR1 AS LEFTI/S USUALLY DO4 ,I WROTE ( 0,WATSONIAN0 OR 0,TYPE #c0 AN>*ISM3 0,NEI!R AN 9DIVIDUALI/1 CAPITALI/1 RI*I/ NOR A SOCIALI/1 COLLECTIVI/1 LEFTI/ 'TYPE #b' AN>*I/1 HE IS A TYPE #c AN>*I/ & NOBODY'S FOOL40.<#b.> ,TYPE #c WAS ! TYPE ( ! ATYPICAL4 ,! IMM$IATE OCCASION = ,AN>*Y AFT] ,LEFTISM WAS ! PUBLICATION ( ,SOCIAL ,AN>*ISM OR ,LIFE/YLE ,AN>*ISM3 ,AN ,UNBRIDGEABLE ,*ASM BY ,MURRAY ,BOOK*94 ,HIS BOOK CANNOT EV5 CLAIM ORIG9ALITY4 ,BY ! #a#i#hS1 SOME AN>*O-LEFTI/S TOOK TIME (F FROM !IR COLLECTIVE N>CISSISM & 9T]NEC9E FEUD+ TO NOTICE ?AT SOME?+ WAS GO+ ON1 NOT ON !IR LEFT1 BUT BEYOND IT4 ,!Y 9V5T$ MO/ ( ! MUTUALLY 9CONSI/5T EPI!TS 7H[ CAN SOMEBODY BE AN 09DIVIDUALI/0 & A 0FASCI/0 AT ! SAME TIME8 OR B\RGEOIS & LUMP5PROLET>IAN87 :I* ,BOOK*9 LAT] ?REW >\ND4.<#b#a.> ,BECAUSE ( ! M>KET CL\T ( ! PUBLI%]1 ,A,K ,PRESS2 & BECAUSE IT S]V$ ! %ORT-T]M IDEOLOGICAL 9T]E/S ( AN>*O-LEFTI/S1 ! TRACT RECEIV$ F> MORE ATT5TION & APPROVAL ?AN IT DES]V$4 ,I NE$ NOT REPEAT H]E ALL ! MANY WAYS 9 :I* IT IS 9ACCURATE1 DI%ONE/1 HYPOCRITICAL1 & UNCIVIL TO ! PO9T ( BRUTI%NESS4 ,?AT W\LD REQUIRE AN 5TIRE BOOK4 ,AS IT HAPP5S1 ,I WROTE ?AT BOOK3 ,AN>*Y AFT] ,LEFTISM4 ,! AN>*O-LEFTI/S ACT$ AS CRASS OPPORTUNI/S4 ,!Y /ILL DO4 ,BOOK*9 BEGAN BY HIJACK+ ! EXPRESSION 0SOCIAL AN>*ISM0 = HIS [N CULT CRE$1 AL?\< ! PHRASE HAS ALWAYS HAD A MU* WID] APPLICATION4.<#b#b.> ,?AT DIDN'T BO!R HIS NEW AN>*O-LEFTI/ FANS1 :O NEV] NOTIC$ ?AT ,BOOK*9'S LATE POLITICS1 LIKE HIS E>LY POLITICS1 IS 9COMPATIBLE ) /&>D AN>*O-LEFTI/ DOCTR9ES SU* AS SYNDICALISM4 ,IT DIDN'T BO!R ! CLASS /RUGGLE AN>*I/S ?AT ,BOOK*9 REPUDIAT$ ! CLASS /RUGGLE 9 ! #a#i#fS4.<#b#c.> ,& IT DIDN'T BO!R ! ORGANIZATIONALI/S ?AT 9 ! #a#i#gS ,BOOK*9 REPUDIAT$ AN>*I/ ORGANIZATION AS 9H]5TLY VANGU>DI/4.<#b#d.> ,LATE ,BOOK*9ISM VILIFI$ ! PRIMITIVI/S1 BUT HIS SUPPOS$ MA/]PIECE1 ,! ,ECOLOGY ( ,FRE$OM1.<#b#e.> EXTOLL$ ! VIRTUES ( 0ORGANIC0 PRIMITIVE SOCIETIES4 7,9 ! V]Y LONG 9TRODUCTION TO A SECOND $ITION ( ! BOOK1 ,BOOK*9 9 EFFECT REPUDIAT$ ! BOOK47 ,AT ! V]Y TIME ,BOOK*9 WAS H&+ D[N HIS TABLET ( AN>*I/ OR?ODOXY1 HE PRIVATELY 9=M$ HIS 9N] CIRCLE ?AT HE WAS NOT AN AN>*I/4.<#b#f.> ,BUT :51 E>LI]1 ,I NOT ONLY CLAIM$1 BUT PROV$ ?AT HE WASN'T AN AN>*I/1.<#b#g.> ,I WAS DISMISS$ AS PURI/1 DOGMATIC1 SECT>IAN1 CRAZY1 ETC4 ,PO/-LEFT AN>*ISM HAD1 AT ! TIME ,I FIR/ US$ IT1 = ME1 A HI/ORICAL CONNOTATION4 ,I ?\ )1 & UNHAPPY )1 LEFTISM4 ,& ,I'VE ALWAYS ATTA*$ IMPORTANCE TO HI/ORY4 ,TODAY1 IT'S COMMON = PO/-LEFT AN>*I/S TO >RIVE AT ?AT P]SPECTIVE DIRECTLY1 )\T HAV+ BE5 LEFTI/S4 ,= SOME PEOPLE1 ,I'VE HAD SOME?+ TO DO ) ?AT4 ,?IS IS GOOD4 ,/ILL ANO!R PHRASE :I*1 AT ONE PO9T1 MADE SOME R\NDS WAS 0,! ,NEW ,AN>*I/S10 ! TITLE ( AN >TICLE BY ,PR(ESSOR ,DAVID ,GRAEB] 9 ! ,NEW ,LEFT ,REVIEW4.<#b#h.> ,HE CLAIMS ?AT ?IS WAS NOT HIS TITLE = ! >TICLE4 ,IT WAS1 AT ANY RATE1 NOT HIS CO9AGE3 IT WAS M9E4 ,9 #aiig ,I REF]R$ TO 0! ,NEW ,AN>*ISM OR1 BETT] YET1 ! ,NEW ,AN>*ISMS00.<#b#i.> -- BUT ,I'M QUITE SURE ?AT ! $ITORS ( ! ,NEW ,LEFT ,REVIEW NEV] READ ,AN>*Y AFT] ,LEFTISM4 ,= ,GRAEB]1 ! ,NEW ,AN>*I/S >E ACTIVI/S1 SU* AS ?OSE 9 ! ANTI-GLOBALIZATION PROTE/S4 ,?IS WAS SELF-PROMOT+1 BECAUSE BY !N ! M$IA HAD ALREADY MADE ,GRAEB] ! /> ( ?AT %[1 & !N ! /> ( ! NEXT %[1 ,OCCUPY4 ,HE IS NOT ONLY A ,NEW ,AN>*I/1 HE IS ! NEW ,DANIEL ,COHN-,B5DIT 7:O HAD SAID1 0,I AM SIMPLY A M\?PIECE1 A MEGAPHONE074.<#c.> ,IT ALWAYS LOOKS GOOD TO PR(ESS MODE/Y AFT] Y\ >E ALREADY 9 ! SPOTLIY AN>*I/ !ORY4 ,HE MAY HAVE KN[N V]Y LITTLE AB\T IT4 ,OR1 IF HE DID KN[ SOME?+1 HE HAD HIS REASONS TO KEEP IT TO HIMSELF4 ,GRAEB] WROTE = LEFTI/S - ?IS WAS 9 ! ,NEW ,LEFT ,REVIEW AFT] ALL6.<#c#a.> -- TRY+ TO GET !M TO WELCOME ! ,NEW ,AN>*I/S AS COMRADES 7&1 HE H9T$1 = !IR USEFULNESS3 PROVID+ BOOTS ON ! GR\ND74 ,I WROTE = AN>*I/S1 SUGGE/+ ?AT !Y GET \T ( ! LEFT1 NOT 9TO IT4 ,BECAUSE ( ,GRAEB]'S AV[$ LOYALTY TO ! LEFT1 & HIS CONFUSION ( AN>*Y ) DIRECT DEMOCRACY1 IF HE'S A ,NEW ,AN>*I/1 ,I'M NOT4 ,HE'S NOT A PO/-LEFT AN>*I/3 ?IS MU* IS C]TA94 ,AS F> AS ,I'M CONC]N$1 HE'S NOT AN AN>*I/ AT ALL4 ,:AT !N IS LEFTISM8 ,I'VE OCCASIONALLY BE5 ASK$ ?IS QUE/ION4 ,I'VE SOMETIMES REPLI$ ) :AT ,WITTG5/E9 & O!R PHILOSOPH]S CALL AN O/5SIVE DEF9ITION3 ?AT 7PO9T+7 IS 0R$03 Y\ 7FIGURATIVELY1 PO9T+7 >E A R$1 A 0LEFTI/40 ,ONLY LEFTI/S EV] ASK4 ,!Y DON'T SEEM TO NE$ A DEF9ITION = !IR [N PURPOSES1 & ,I DON'T NE$ ONE = M9E4 ,I'VE NEV] CON/RUCT$ A DEF9ITION ( LEFTISM1 BECAUSE !N LEFTI/S W\LD COMPLA9 AB\T MY DEF9ITION1 NOT AB\T MY CRITIQUE4 ,!Y KN[ :OM ,I'M TALK+ AB\T4 ,I'M TALK+ AB\T !M4 ,LEFTISM IS :AT SELF-ID5TIFI$ LEFTI/S PREA*4 ,IF ?AT CAN'T ALL BE 5COMPASS$ BY AN AU?ORITATIVE DEF9ITION1 SO MU* ! WORSE = LEFTISM1 OR = AU?ORITATIVE DEF9ITION4 ,NOBODY1 TO ! EXT5T ( MY LIMIT$ KN[L$GE1 HAS TRI$ TO DEF9E LEFTISM1.<#c#b.> AT LEA/ NOT 9 T]MS ( ITS CRIT]IA3 ! NECESS>Y & SUFFICI5T CONDITIONS = ID5TIFY+ SOME?+ AS LEFTI/4 ,!RE MAY BE NO SU* CRIT]IA4 ,I KN[ ( NO ASS]TIONS ?AT LEFTISM MU/ 9CLUDE ?IS OR ?AT1 AL?\< !RE MAY BE POSITIONS 7SU* AS RACISM.<#c#c.> OR CORPORATE CAPITALISM.<#c#d.>7 :I* MU/ BE PRECLUD$4 ,P]HAPS 0EQUALITY0 IS AN ESS5TIAL VALUE ( LEFTISM1 BUT ?AT WORD CAN MEAN ALMO/ ANY?+1 NOR IS IT UNIQUE TO LEFTISM4 ,PROTE/ANTISM1 LIB]ALISM1 & M>KET CAPITALISM ESP\SE V]SIONS ( EQUALITY4 ,P]HAPS 0FRE$OM10 BUT ALMO/ EV]YBODY ESP\SES ?AT TOO4.<#c#e.> ,AL?\< DO+ SO MI TO BE FA%IONABLE OR LAZY1 ,I AM 9CL9$ TO BR+ 9 ,WITTG5/E9'S NOTION ( FAMILY RESEMBLANCE3 0,WE F9D ?AT :AT CONNECTS ALL ! CASES ( COMP>+ IS A VA/ NUMB] ( OV]LAPP+ SIMIL>ITIES1 & AS SOON AS WE SEE ?IS1 WE NO LONG] FEEL COMPELL$ TO SAY ?AT !RE MU/ BE SOME FEATURE COMMON TO !M ALL40.<#c#f.> ,I NEV] FELT FEEL ?IS COMPULSION4 ,!N !RE IS ! G5EALOGICAL APPROA*4 ,LEFTISM DOES HAVE A WELL-DOCUM5T$ P$IGREE DAT+ FROM ! #a#h? C5TURY4 ,! 0LEFT0 ORIG9ALLY REF]R$ TO ! SEAT+ >RANGEM5TS 9 ! ,FR5* ,ASSEMBLY DUR+ ! ,REVOLUTION4 ,ALMO/ EV]Y MOD]N LEFTI/ IDEOLOGY1 FROM LIB]ALISM TO /ATE COMMUNISM1 PUT 9 AN APPE>ANCE 9 ,P>IS BETWE5 #a*ISM IS ABS5T4 ,MI*ISM IS NOT A LEFTI/ IDEOLOGY8.<#c#g.> ,! EXPRESSION PO/-LEFT AN>*ISM IS IMPLICITLY CRITICAL ( LEFTISM4 ,C]TA9LY ,I MEANT IT ?AT WAY4 ,LEFTISM IS SOME?+ TO BE SURPASS$4 0,PO/-LEFT AN>*Y10 ,I WROTE1 0IS POIS$ TO >TICULATE - NOT A PROGRAM - BUT A NUMB] ( REVOLUTION>Y !MES ) CONTEMPOR>Y RELEVANCE & RESONANCE40.<#c#h.> ,WRIT+ AS ,I WAS AGA9/ ,BOOK*91 ,I PROVID$ A %ORT1 NON-EXCLUSIVE LI/ ( DIFF]5CES4 ,I SUGGE/$ ?AT PO/-LEFT AN>*ISM WAS 7#a7 0UNAMBIGU\SLY ANTI-POLITICAL0 - NO VOT+1 = 9/ANCE2 7#b72 H$ONI/IC 70,MANY PEOPLE WOND] :AT'S WRONG ) WANT+ TO BE HAPPY072 & 7#c7 IF NOT NECESS>ILY REJECTIVE1 !N AT LEA/ SUSPICI\S ( MOD]N TE*NOLOGY & ! EXTRAVAGANT LIB]ATORY CLAIMS MADE = IT4.<#c#i.> ,BUT !RE W]E O!R PO9TS LEFT (F ?IS P>TICUL> LI/1 SU* AS ! REJECTION ( AN>*I/ ORGANIZATIONALISM1 9 ! S5SE ( RECRUIT+ ! WORK+ CLASS 9TO TRADE-UNIONS 7AN>*O-SYNDICALISM71 & ALSO 9 ! S5SE ( RECRUITM5T ( ALL AN>*I/S 9TO ONE DISCIPL9$ PROGRAMMATIC VANGU>D ORGANIZATION 7NEO-,PLAT=MISM74 ,BO? >E IMPOSSIBLE1 BO? >E UNDESIRABLE1 & BO? >E PREPO/]\S4 ,& BO? >E PR(\NDLY ANTI-AN>*I/4 ,I'VE BE5 CRITICIZ+ ! SYNDICALI/S = MANY YE>S1 AS ,I DID 9 MY MO/ REC5T BOOK1 9 DEAL+ ) ,NOAM ,*OMSKY4.<#d.> ,I'VE ALSO CRITICIZ$ NEO-,PLAT=MISM 7AN>*O-,L59ISM74.<#d#a.> ,IF !SE DOCTR9ES >E LEFT AN>*I/1 & M>KET$ AS AN>*I/ 7AS !Y >E71 !N EV]Y REAL AN>*I/ HAS TO BE A PO/-LEFT1 OR AT LEA/ A NON-LEFT1 AN>*I/4 ,) A FEW EXCEPTIONS AMONG ! NIHILI/S & 9DIVIDUALI/S1 PO/-LEFT AN>*ISM IS A SOCIAL AN>*ISM4 ,I PREF] SPEAK ( 0FREE ASSOCIATION0 RA!R ?AN ORGANIZATION1 BECAUSE ! ORGANIZ] LEFTI/S HAVE FREI*Y1 MEMB]%IP EXCLUSIVITY & DOCTR9AL OR?ODOXY4 ,MAX ,/IRN]'S 0UNION ( EGOI/S0 IS MORE TO MY LIK+1 PROVID$ IT BE UND]/OOD ?AT HE WAS NOT REF]R+ TO ,ONE ,BIG ,UNION OR TO LABOR UNIONS1 BUT TO A BASIS = FREE ASSOCIATION4.<#d#c.> ,I MIE EXHAU/$ BY1 WORK]S SEIZ+ [N]%IP & CONTROL ( ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION FROM ! CAPITALI/S4.<#d#d.> ,!N !RE IS ! RELAT$ DOCTR9E ( 0WORK]ISM10 :I* TYPICALLY COMB9ES ! CELEBRATION ( ! WORK] AS WORK]1 ) ! GLORIFICATION ( WORK1 & ) ! NOTION ?AT ! WORK+ CLASS1 OR SOME SECTOR ( IT1 IS ! NECESS>Y & PRIVILEG$ AG5CY ( SOCIAL REVOLUTION4 ,! PROMISE ( WORK]ISM IS SELF-MANAG$ S]VITUDE - & ! DUTY TO ATT5D A LOT ( MEET+S4.<#d#d.> ,!SE DOGMAS >E C\NT]-REVOLUTION>Y NONS5SE4 ,V]Y FEW WORK]S >E WORK]I/S1 & Y\ WILL F9D F> MORE WORK]I/S 9 CLASSROOMS OR CAFES ?AN 9 FACTORIES OR (FICES4 ,& Y\ WILL F9D FEW WORK]S EV5 9 ?OSE PRIVILEG$ PLACES4 ,WORK]S >E MORE (T5 TO BE F\ND 9 B>S OR AT BASEBALL GAMES4 ,MANY1 ?\< NOT ALL1 PO/-LEFT AN>*I/S REJECT MORALISM4 ,SEV]AL W\LD DI/+UI% E?ICS FROM MORALITY2 ,I ?9K ?IS GOES TOO MU* AGA9/ E/ABLI%$ USAGE4 ,?IS IS NOT ! PLACE TO M\NT ANY SU/A9$ CRITIQUE ( MORALISM3 !SE >E READILY AVAILABLE FROM ,B5JAM9 ,TUCK]1 ,FRI$RI* ,NIETZS*E1 ,MAX ,/IRN]1 ,EMMA ,GOLDMAN.<#d#e.> &1 ON ! CONTEMPOR>Y SC5E1 ,WOLFI ,L&/REI*] & ,JASON ,MC,QU9N4 ,BUT ,I WILL QUOTE MYSELF A LITTLE ON ?AT FA%IONABLE D]IVATIVE ( MORALITY1 0HUMAN RI*I/S4 ,IT IS ONLY A R\NDAB\T WAY ( EXPRESS+ PREF]5CES :I* MI ,! KNEEJ]K RETORT FROM ! DOGMATIC1 DOCTR9AIRE1 PURI/ & SECT>IAN AN>*O-LEFTI/S IS ?AT PO/-LEFT AN>*I/S >E 0DOGMATIC10 0DOCTR9AIRE10 0PURI/0 & 0SECT>IAN40 ,?IS IS ! V]Y VOCABUL>Y ( ABUSE :I* ,M>XI/S APPLY TO ALL AN>*I/S1 !MSELVES 9CLUD$4 ,& AS ! 7HIMSELF V]Y DOGMATIC7 LEFT COMMUNI/ ,AMADEO ,BORDIGA OBS]V$3 0,DAMN ?OSE :O TALK AB\T DOGMAS6 ,!RE HAS YET TO BE A R5EGADE :O DID NOT USE ?IS WORD40.<#d#g.> ,?IS FIR/ EPI!T1 0DOGMATIC10 IS AN AMUS+ BIT ( D\BLE?9K & D\BLETALK4 ,D5\NC]S ( DOGMATISM APP>5TLY DON'T KN[ :AT ! WORD 0DOGMA0 MEANS4 ,IT HAS A RELIGI\S1 ,*RI/IAN ORIG94 ,DOGMAS >E AU?ORITATIVE1 BELIEF-IT-OR-ELSE DOCTR9ES 7SU* AS ! ,HOLY ,TR9ITY1 ,ORIG9AL ,S91 & ! 9FALLIBILITY ( ! ,POPE74 ,IT IS LEFTI/S LIKE ! NEO-,PLAT=MI/S :O SOLEMNLY PROMULGATE OBLIGATORY CODES - ! 0,PLAT=M0 ITSELF1 = 9/ANCE4.<#d#h.> ,ONE ( ! WOR/ ( ! AN>*O-LEFTI/S1 & POSSIBLY ! /UPIDE/1 IS ,*AZ ,BUFE1 :O ONCE 7IF Y\ CAN BELIEVE IT7 H&$ D[N ,T5 ,COMM&M5TS - T5 MORAL COMM&M5TS -- = AN>*I/S1.<#d#i.> SOME ( :I* HE & HIS ,M>XI/ FRI5DS W]E !N CONSPICU\SLY VIOLAT+4.<#e.> 0,?\ %ALL NOT BE> FALSE WITNESS AGA9/ ?Y NEI FROM AN E>LI] V]SION ( ! ,T5 ,COMM&M5TS1 IS ! ONE ?AT ,BUFE & MANY AN>*O-LEFTI/S HAVE ! MO/ TR\BLE )4 ,M>XI/S R\T9ELY USE AN>*O-LEFTI/S LIKE ,BUFE 7AS DID ,PROCESS$ ,WORLD7 AS !IR DUPES4 ,AMORALI/S T5D TO BE MORE MORAL ?AN MORALI/S1 JU/ AS A!I/S T5D TO BE BETT] BEHAV$ ?AN ,*RI/IANS4 ,I DEFY ANY LEFTI/ TO ID5TIFY ANY PO/-LEFT PLAT=M OR CR$O4 ,:ILE Y\ CAN F9D 9/ANCES ( DOGMATISM 9 ! WRIT+S ( PO/-LEFTI/S1 CR$OS & CATE*ISMS >E NO:]E AT HOME !RE4 ,& :AT ,I'VE JU/ WRITT5 H]E IS NEI!R4 ,ONE M]IT ( ! FAMILY RESEMBLANCE NOTION IS ITS FLEXIBILITY4 ,ANYBODY :O HAS MO/ OR ALL ( :AT ,I CONSID] ! TYPICAL ATTRIBUTES ( LEFTISM IS SOMEBODY ,I W\LD PROBABLY CALL A LEFTI/1 OR MAYBE SOME?+ WORSE1 IF !RE WAS AN OCCASION = ?AT4 ,BUT %E MITICUL>1 ,I AM 9CL9$ TO BE OP5-M9D$4 ,UP TO ! PO9T :]E 0OP5-M9D$0 PASSES OV] 9TO 0GULLIBLE40 ,LEFTI/S1 IF ! MATT] COMES UP1 R>ELY D5Y BE+ LEFTI/S4 ,AN EXCEPTION MAY BE SOME ( ?OSE :O CALL !MSELVES 0PROGRESSIVES40 ,!SE >E PEOPLE :O ADOPT$ ?IS WORD TO AVOID BE+ /IGMATIZ$ AS RADICALS1 BUT )\T ADMITT+ ?AT !Y >E LIB]ALS4.<#e#b.> ,!IR CLASS BASE IS ! YUPPIES 70Y\NG URBAN PR(ESSIONALS0 -- MANY ( :OM >E1 H[EV]1 APPROA*+ RETIREM5T AGE7.<#e#c.> - PLUS ! ACADEMICS & GRADUATE /UD5TS 9 ! HUMANITIES & ! S(T 7V]Y S(T7 SOCIAL SCI5CES1 ( :I* ! S(TE/ >E ,CULTURAL ,/UDIES1 ,WOM5'S ,/UDIES1 ,AFRICAN-,AM]ICAN ,/UDIES1 ,QUE] ,/UDIES 7! NEW KID ON ! BLOCKHEAD BLOC71 LAW S*OOL ,CRITICAL ,RACE ,!ORY !ORI/S1 ETC41 AD NAUSEAM4 ,ANO!R T5D5CY :I* IS WIDELY1 BUT NOT UNIV]SALLY %>$ BY PO/-LEFT AN>*I/S IS AN EXI/5TIAL PREF]5CE = ! CONCRETE & ! P>TICUL>1 & A CORRESPOND+ DI/RU/ ( GR& N>RATIVES & SUPPOS$ UNIV]SAL TRU?S4.<#e#d.> ,NEO-LIB]ALISM & ,M>XISM >E EXAMPLES ( GR& N>RATIVES :I* AN>*I/S %\LD1 & MO/LY DO1 REJECT4 ,PO/-MOD]NISM IS A GR& N>RATIVE PRET5D+ TO BE ! REJECTION ( GR& N>RATIVES4 ,HUMAN NATURE & ITS SUPPOS$ D]IVATIVE1 HUMAN RIE UNIV]SAL TRU?S :I* AN>*I/S %\LD REJECT1 NOT ONLY BECAUSE !Y SIMPLY DON'T EXI/1 BUT ALSO BECAUSE !IR POLITICAL T5D5CY IS LIB]AL OR CONS]VATIVE 7AN 9CREAS+LY ELUSIVE DI/9CTION74 ,?IS PREF]5CE 7OR PREJUDICE7 - ,MURRAY ,BOOK*9 CALL$ IT1 AS IF ?IS W]E A BAD ?+1 0P]SONALI/IC0.<#e#e.> -- ULTIMATELY D]IVES FROM ! #fS3 FROM ! CRITIQUE ( EV]YDAY LIFE 7,H5RI ,LEFEBVRE & ! ,SITUATIONI/S7 & FROM 0! P]SONAL IS ! POLITICAL0 7! FEM9I/S71 & MAYBE A LITTLE FROM SOME?+ E>LI]1 EXI/5TIALISM - AMONG O!R S\RCES4 ,! ULTIMATE S\RCE IS ,ROMANTICISM4 ,EV5 :5 IT'S ONLY A MOOD1 ,I S5SE IT H]E & !RE1 & ,I FEEL IT MYSELF4 ,I LIKE ! WAY IT FEELS4 ,TAK+ ! EPI!TS \T ( ORD] - ALL MY LIFE ,I HAVE F\ND MYSELF RUL$ \T ( ORD] - H[ AB\T 0SECT>IAN0.<#e#f.>8 ,?IS ONE IS SO DUMB ?AT IT MAKES ! O!R DUMB ADJECTIVES LOOK ALMO/ SM>T4 ,SECT>IANS >E1 BY DEF9ITION1 ORGANIZATIONALI/S4 ,SECTS >E ORGANIZATIONS4 ,?OSE :O /RIVE TO 0ORGANIZE0 7ALL ?IS MEANS IS1 TO RECRUIT7 PEOPLE 9TO MEMB]%IP ORGANIZATIONS ) DOCTR9AL 70DOGMATIC07 ADMISSIONS REQUIREM5TS >E SECT>IANS4 ,!RE >E NO PO/-LEFT AN>*I/ C\NT]P>TS TO ?IS SORT ( SECT>IANISM4 ,!RE >E ONLY AFF9ITY GR\PS1 COMMUNICATIONS NETWORKS1 PUBLI%+ PROJECTS1 & 7HORRORS67 9DIVIDUALS4 ,I'VE NEV] JO9$ AN AN>*I/ ORGANIZATION 9 MY LIFE4 ,SO H[ CAN ,I BE A SECT>IAN8 0,DOCTR9AIRE0 IS MORE ( ! SAME1 & IT ALSO DOESN'T M]IT MU* ATT5TION4 ,IT WAS A FAVORITE ( ,V4,I4 ,L59 7AS 9 HIS D5UNCIATION ( 0,LEFT DOCTR9AIRES0 9 #a#i#b74.<#e#g.> ,GEORGE ,WOODCOCK1 ! AU?OR ( ! BE/ G5]AL HI/ORY ( AN>*ISM 9 ! ,5GLI% LANGUAGE1.<#e#h.> CRITICIZ$ ,NOAM ,*OMSKY & ,DANIEL ,GU]9 = NOT BE+1 AS !Y CLAIM$1 AN>*I/S1 BUT RA!R LEFT-W+ ,M>XI/S PILF]+ AN>*ISM TO PRETTY UP !IR ,M>XISM4.<#e#i.> ,I HAVE DRAWN ATT5TION TO :AT A ,*OMSKY ]R&-BOY1 ,MILAN ,RAI1 HAD TO SAY AB\T ?AT3 0,?IS IS A GOOD EXAMPLE ( :AT MI*ISM1 P]HAPS ALSO ! DOM9ANT APPROA*40.<#f.> ,MY RESPONSE3 0,:AT ,RAI CALLS '! DOCTR9AL APPROA* TO AN>*ISM' IS :AT AN>*I/S CALL 'AN>*ISM40.<#f#a.> ,& F9ALLY1 ! DAMN+ *>GE ( 0PURISM40.<#f#b.> ,N[1 JU/ BECAUSE Y\ BELIEVE :AT Y\ BELIEVE1 & Y\ DON'T BELIEVE :AT Y\ DON'T BELIEVE1 DOES NOT MAKE Y\ A PURI/1 BECAUSE !N EV]YBODY W\LD BE A PURI/ AB\T EV]Y?+1 IF ONLY = ! TIME BE+4.<#f#c.> ,!RE'S NO?+ BIGOT$ OR AU?ORIT>IAN AB\T MAK+ UP Y\R M9D4 ,JUDG+ IS NOT NECESS>ILY PREJUDG+4 ,AN OP5 M9D IS NOT AN EMPTY M9D1 BUT IT IS AVAILABLE = FILL+4 ,ALMO/ ALWAYS ?IS 0PURI/0 EPI!T IS ?R[N1 LIKE MUD AGA9/ A WALL1 AT EV]YBODY ! ?R[] DISAGREES )1 HOP+ ?AT IT /ICKS4 ,IT DOESN'T /ICK1 BUT IT /9KS4 ,I AM PR9CIPL$1 & Y\ >E A PURI/1 & HE IS A DOGMATI/1 DEP5D+ ON :O IS TALK+4 ,! MEAN+1 ! D5OTATION1 IS ! SAME4 ,! REF]5CE & ! CONNOTATION >E ! ONLY DIFF]5CES4 ,BUT !SE DIFF]5CES MAKE ALL ! DIFF]5CE4 ,I MIXI/S & ! AN>*O-LEFTI/S1 A T]M ( ABUSE4 ,(T5 IT'S 9CORPORAT$ 9TO ! TRITE PHRASE 0RUGG$ 9DIVIDUALISM10 9 ORD] TO ALIGN ,MAX ,/IRN] OR ,H5RY ,DAVID ,?OREAU OR ,R5ZO ,NOVATORE OR MYSELF ) ,GILD$ ,AGE ROBB] B>ONS LIKE ,&REW ,C>NEGIE & ,JOHN ,D4 ,ROCKEFELL]4 ,NOT HAV+ READ HIM1 ! LEFTI/S DON'T KN[ ?AT ,/IRN] WAS ANTI-CAPITALI/4.<#f#d.> ,ACTUALLY1 MO/ ( ! PO/-LEFT AN>*I/S ,I AM FAMILI> ) >E BETT] DESCRIB$ AS RUGG$ COLLECTIVI/S4 ,ANYBODY :O ?9KS HE IS AN AN>*I/1 BUT D5\NCES 9DIVIDUALISM1 IS NOT AN AN>*I/4 ,!RE IS 0AN 9DIVIDUALI/ ASPECT TO AN>*ISM :I* EXI/S 9 ALL ITS =MS40.<#f#e.> ,DOES A WORD LIKE 0AN>*ISM0 MEAN ANY?+8 ,IT'S NOT A RE/RICTIVE P]SPECTIVE4 ,IT'S ! LEA/ RE/RICTIVE PR9CIPLE - 9 PR9CIPLE -- ( ALL POLITICAL PR9CIPLES4 ,9 ITS HI/ORY1 IT HAS AT TIMES1 NONE!LESS1 BE5 9T]PRET$ 9 A TOO RE/RICTIVE WAY4 ,?AT'S H[ ! AN>*O-LEFTI/S WANT IT TO BE N[4 ,BUT UNLESS AN>*ISM HAS SOME CORE MEAN+ - & ,I W\LD KEEP ?AT TO A M9IMUM 7& ALWAYS OP5 TO RECONSID]ATION7 - ANYBODY CAN CLAIM TO BE AN AN>*I/ OR BE ACCUS$ ( BE+ ONE4 ,WE >E NOT F> FROM ?AT PO9T4 ,ACCORD+ TO ,S5ATOR ,H>RY ,REID1 ! ,TEA ,P>TY IS 0AN>*I/40 ,?AT'S RIDICUL\S4 ,BUT IT'S NOT MU* MORE RIDICUL\S ?AN SAY+ ?AT ,MURRAY ,BOOK*9 WAS1 OR ?AT ,NOAM ,*OMSKY OR ,RAMSEY ,KANAAN IS1 AN AN>*I/4 ,HI/ORICALLY1 IT HAS SOMETIMES HAPP5$ ?AT EV5 SOME ( ! AN>*I/ GREAT ONES HAVE1 :5 A CRISIS >OSE1 BETRAY$ !IR PR9CIPLES4 ,?US ,PET] ,KROPOTK9 & ,JEAN ,GRAVE1 & A FEW O!RS1 R5\NC$ !IR ANTI-MILIT>ISM & 9T]NATIONALISM BY SUPPORT+ ! ,ALLIES 9 ,WORLD ,W> ,I4 ,!IR AN>*I/ CRITICS - ! PURI/S LIKE ,]RICO ,MALATE/A - CALL$ ?AT 0AN>*O-TR5*ISM0.<#f#f.>74 ,9 #a#i#c#f1 9 ,SPA91 :5 ! >MY ATTEMPT$ A PUTS*1 (FICIALS ( ! AN>*O-SYNDICALI/ ,C,N,T 7& EV5 ! AN>*O-PURI/ ,F,A,I7 SUPPORT$ ! ,LOYALI/ GOV]NM5T &1 9DE$1 P>TICIPAT$ 9 IT4 ,!Y TOO HAD !IR PURI/ CRITICS1 SU* AS ! ,FRI5DS ( ,DURRUTI4 ,! CRITICS W]E RI*I/S4 ,! LIB]ALS & ,M>XI/S SOON SUPPRESS$ ! AN>*I/S 7& LO/ ! W>74 ,IS !RE ANY?+ ?AT AN>*I/S JU/ CANNOT ACCEPT AS AN>*I/8 ,I ASSUM$ AS MU* = A LONG TIME1 BUT ,I'M NOT SURE N[4 ,I ?\T ( ! M9IMALI/ PROGRAM4 ,BUT ,NOAM ,*OMSKY1 :O PURPORTS TO BE AN AN>*I/1 VOTES REGUL>LY4.<#f#g.> ,NOAM ,*OMSKY HAS ONLY A FEW AN>*I/ QUOTATIONS AT HIS DISPOSAL1 SO HE RECYCLES !M4 ,ONE ( !SE IS1 0AN>*ISM HAS A BROAD BACK40.<#f#h.> ,HE USES IT TO AVOID ANSW]+ QUE/IONS AB\T HIS [N AN>*I/ BONA FIDES 7SU* AS HIS VOT+74 ,! QUOTATION IS FROM ,OCTAVE ,MIRBEAU4 ,MIRBEAU IS ! #a#i? C5TURY ,FR5* AN>*I/ AU?OR ( ! WITTY ANTI-VOT+ POLEMIC 0,VOT]S' ,/RIKE60.<#f#i.> :I* ,I'M SURE ,*OMSKY HASN'T READ4 ,*OMSKY CULL$ ! QUOTATION1 AS HE CULLS MO/ ( HIS AN>*I/ QUOTATIONS1 FROM A SECOND>Y S\RCE4.<#g.> ,MIRBEAU DIDN'T ?9K ?AT AN>*Y'S BACK WAS SO BROAD AS TO SUPPORT VOT+4 ,BUT 9 #b#h1 :5 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES ELECT$ A BLACK ,PRESID5T1 ,*OMSKY VOT$ = HIM4 ,PRESID5T-ELECT ,B>ACK ,OBAMA'S AN>*O-LEFTI/ SUPPORT]S 7MO/LY COLLEGE PR(ESSORS SU* AS ,DANA ,W>D & ,C9DY ,MIL/E97 PROPOS$ TO P>TICIPATE1 AS ! 0,HOPE ,BLOC10 AS :ITE P5IT5TS1 9 ! ,9AUGURAL P>ADE4 ,I SUSPECT ?AT !Y W]E LAU<$ (F4 ,!Y DON'T TALK AB\T IT ANY MORE4 ,:Y ! AN>*O-LEFTI/S CL+ TO LEFTISM :5 MO/ PEOPLE1 & WORK]S ESPECIALLY1 %UN IT1 IS SOME?+ ( A MY/]Y4 ,ONE MI*I/ PUBLI%]4 ,! BUS9ESS PROSP]$1 & A FEW YE>S LAT]1 HE OP5$ A BRAN* 9 ,SAN ,FRANCISCO1 & HE RELOCAT$ !RE4 ,A,K ,PRESS PUBLI%$ 7& SOLD3 IT WAS AT ! SAME TIME ,A,K ,DI/RIBUTION7 - BOOKS )1 = MANY YE>S1 POOR PRODUCTION VALUES -- MANY BOOKS1 NOT TO M5TION ,C,DS1 ,D,V,DS & ,T-%IRTS4 ,! SUB/ANTIAL MAJORITY ( !SE BOOKS W]E NOT BY AN>*I/S OR AB\T AN>*ISM4 ,9/EAD !Y W]E /&>D G5]IC LEFTI/ F>E3 ,?IRD ,WORLD NATIONAL LIB]ATION MOVEM5TS1 RACIAL ID5TITY POLITICS1 ,M>XISM1 FEM9ISM1 PUNK FA%ION AN>*ISM 7! ,T-%IRT M>KET71 VEGET>IANISM1 GAY RII\S RE=MI/ LEFTISMS4 ,! TIM+ - ! E>LY#a#i#iS - WAS P]FECT1 IF =TUIT\S 7OR WAS IT874 ,MANY LEFTI/S1 9CLUD+ LEFTI/S :O NEV] CONSID]$ !MSELVES ,M>XI/S - NOT EXACTLY1 ANYWAY - W]E REEL+ AFT] ! COLLAPSE ( ,EUROPEAN ,COMMUNISM4 ,N[ IT WAS !IR TURN TO BE NO:]E AT HOME4 ,A,K ,PRESS (F]$ !M AN EASY WAY 9TO AN>*ISM1 :I* WAS1 AT ! V]Y SAME TIME1 BECOM+ FA%IONABLE AFT] ! ,BATTLE ( ,SEATTLE & O!R ANTI-GLOBALIZATION ACTIONS4 ,= !SE HOMELESS LEFTI/S1 ,A,K ,PRESS AN>*ISM WAS AS FAMILI> & COM=TABLE AS AN OLD %OE 7BUT NOT A WOOD5 %OE74 ,ASIDE FROM PICK+ UP A FEW NEW CAT*PHRASES - SU* AS 0MUTUAL AID0 & 0DIRECT ACTION0 - & ABJUR+ A FEW OLD ONES 7! VANGU>D P>TY1 ! DICTATOR%IP ( ! PROLET>IAT1 ETC471 !Y FIT RI*ISM4 ,LEFTI/S C\LD EV5 CONT9UE TO READ & IDOLIZE ,NOAM ,*OMSKY - PUBLI%$ BY ,A,K ,PRESS -- :O1 !Y LE>N$ TO !IR SURPRISE1 & RELIEF1 IS AN AN>*I/6 ,IF ,*OMSKY'S AN AN>*I/1 ALMO/ ANY LEFTI/ ?IS SIDE ( ,NOR? ,KOREA CAN BE AN AN>*I/1 & %9E 9 ! REFLECT$ GLORY ( ANTI-GLOBALIZATION1 ! NEO-,ZAPATI/AS1 ,>G5T9E 0HORIZONTALISM10 & ,OCCUPY4 ,BY ! TIME ,A,K ,PRESS CAME ALONG1 ,*OMSKY WAS RUNN+ \T ( PUBLI%]S4 ,!Y W]E 0JU/ 9 TIME0 = EA* O!R4 ,IT MAY BE ?AT ,*OMSKY DOESN'T HAVE TO SUBSIDIZE ! PUBLICATION ( HIS [N BOOKS 7AS ,I ONCE SPECULAT$ ?AT HE DID74 ,I WAS %OCK$ TO BE TOLD1 AB\T A YE> & A HALF AGO1 ?AT ,*OMSKY ON ,AN>*ISM HAD SOLD #b#g1 COPIES4 ,SALES BY N[ >E REPORT$LY MU* HI<]40.<#g#a.> ,BUT ,I AM SURE ,*OMSKY SUBSIDIZES ! PUBLICATION ( O!R ,A,K ,PRESS MAT]IAL4 ,SO1 REPUT$LY1 DOES ! AN>*O-LEFTI/ B& ,*UMBAWAMBA4 ,& ,RAMSEY ,KANAAN'S FAMILY MONEY MAY NOT HAVE RUN \T YET4 ,AT SOME PO9T1 ! ,A,K ,PRESS COLLECTIVE :I* HE F\ND$1 ON HI<-S\ND+ PR9CIPLES ( EGALIT>IANISM1 BECAME IRKSOME TO ,RAMSEY BECAUSE IT DIDN'T ALWAYS1 ONLY USUALLY1 DO :AT HE WANT$4 ,SO -- PROBABLY ) MORE FAMILY MONEY -- HE F\ND$ ,P,M ,PRESS1 :OSE COLLECTIVE ALWAYS DOES :AT HE WANTS4 ,IF IT EV] DOESN'T1 HE CAN ALWAYS BUY HIMSELF ANO!R ONE4 ,TO A PO/-LEFT AN>*I/1 ! ,A,K & ,P,M PUBLI%+ AG5DAS >E 9DI/+UI%ABLE4 ,FROM A PO/-LEFT AN>*I/ P]SPECTIVE1 !RE IS MU* ON ! CURR5T AN>*I/ SC5E TO BE DISSATISFI$ )3 ,?AT ! RANGE ( AN>*I/S . 9CLUDES ! CL[NS FROM PROTE/ ALLEY1 MICROMET]-TOT+ SPECIALI/S ( OPPRESSION-ID5TIFICATION1 & ,M>XI/S :O WE> BLACK FLAGS ISN'T A CONDEMNATION ( AN>*I/ IDEAS BUT IS A SIGNIFICANT REASON = PAUSE4 ,9 ?AT PAUSE WE HAVE TO *ALL5GE \R ASSUMPTIONS AB\T AN>*Y4 ,:AT DO WE REALLY %>E ) O!RS 9 ! BIG T5T 7OR %\LD IT BE CALL$ A CIRCUS T5T7 ( AN>*ISM8.<#g#b.> ,BUT PO/-LEFT AN>*I/S >E DEPLOY+ ! WEAPONS ( CRITICISM4 ,AS OPPOS$ TO ! ,A,K ,PRESS_/,P,M ,PRESS C>TEL1 ,L,B,C ,BOOKS IS M\NT+ A MAJOR *ALL5GE AS TO BO? PUBLICATION & DI/RIBUTION4 ,O!R PUBLI%]S1 SU* AS ,C4,A4,L4 ,PRESS & ,EB]H>DT ,PRESS1 >E /ILL PUBLI%+ DESPITE ECONOMIC CONDITIONS :I* >E ADV]SE TO SMALL PRESS PUBLI%+ 9 G5]AL1 & AN>*I/ PUBLI%+ 9 P>TICUL>4 ,AS C\NT]PO9T TO ! ANNUAL AN>*O-LEFTI/ BOOKFAIR 9 ,SAN ,FRANCISCO 7:AT ,I CALL ! 0AN>*I/ ,T-%IRT FAIR071 !RE IS N[ AN ANNUAL1 PR$OM9ANTY PO/-LEFT AN>*I/ BOOKFAIR 9 ,B]KELEY4 ,! BATTLE ( ! BOOKS HAS BEGUN4 ,SPEAK+ ( BOOKS1 MORE & MORE BOOKS ( A PO/-LEFT T5D5CY1 OR COMPLEM5T>Y TO IT1 >E F9D+ !IR WAY 9TO PR9T4 ,GRE5 AN>*ISM HAS AN AN?OLOGY.<#g#c.>4 ,SO DOES ! QUE] NIHILI/ T5D5CY1 ,BA% ,BACK4.<#g#d.> ,AN AN?OLOGY ( ,PO/-,LEFT ,AN>*Y IS =?COM+ FROM ,C4,A4,L4 ,PRESS4 ,!RE'S EV5 ! POSSIBILITY ?AT SOME?+ LIKE ,Z][ORK3 ,! ,ANTIWORK ,AN?OLOGY1 :I* ,I COMPIL$ 9 ! E>LY #a#i#i'S -- BUT :I* WAS TRA%$ BY ! PUBLI%] ,AUTONOM$IA1 = REASONS NEV] EXPLA9$ - MI ?AN LEFTI/S MI ,SOME EXPRESSIONS HAVE !IR USES1 = !IR TIME1 & !N FALL 9TO DISUSE4 0,PO/-LEFT AN>*ISM0 MAY TURN \T TO BE ONE ( ?OSE PHRASES4 ,I W\LD NOT M\RN ITS PASS+4 ,:AT IT SUBSUMES1 H[EV]1 IS AN>*I/ CRITIQUES ( LEFTISM1 :I* WILL NEV] GO AWAY UNTIL AN>*O-LEFTISM GOES AWAY1 OR AN>*ISM DOES4 ,LEFTISM IS ! ONLY IDEOLOGY :I*1 ON ! 9TELLECTUAL PLANE1 REMA9S A ?REAT TO AN>*ISM - & VISE V]SA4 ,PO/-LEFT AN>*ISM IS ! ONLY -- !ORY1 IDEOLOGY1 TAKE Y\R PICK - :I* DEBUNKS ! 9ANITIES ( TRADITIONAL CONS]VATISM1 M>KET LIB]T>IANISM1 & 7?IS IS ! ONLY ONE ?AT MATT]S7 NEO-LIB]ALISM - & LEFTISM4 ,IT IS1 AS YET ANYWAY1 ! ONLY POSSIBLE REVOLUTION>Y POLITICS AFT] LEAV+ ! #b? C5TURY4 ,! NEO-LIB]ALS & ! NEO-CONS]VATIVES CAN & DO BRU% (F ! FOLLIES ( LEFTISM1 BUT !Y CANNOT ANSW] ! PO/-LEFT AN>*ISMS1 EXCEPT ) ! SIL5T TREATM5T3 OR1 ! CRITICISM ( WEAPONS4 ,) :I* !Y >E WELL-SUPPLI$4 ,BUT WE >E WELL-SUPPLI$ ) ! WEAPONS ( CRITICISM4 ,UNLIKE LEFTI/S1 :O HAVE NEI!R WEAPONS NOR CRITIQUE4 ,! ,TEA ,P>TY AT LEA/ HAS GUNS1 IF NOT ROSES1 ONLY NEUROSES4 ,WE HAVE HAD SOME MOD]N REVOLUTIONS1 SU* AS 9 ,FRANCE 9 ,MAY-,JUNE #a#i#f#h1 ! ,IRANIAN ,REVOLUTION ( #a#i#g#i1 ,NIC>AGUA ?AT YE> TOO1 ! ,VELVET ,REVOLUTIONS 9 ,EA/]N ,EUROPE & !N ! ,U4,S4,S4,R41 & ! ,>AB ,SPR+4 ,?AT !Y W]E NOT REVOLUTIONS 5TIRELY TO ! TA/E ( ANY AN>*I/S IS BESIDE ! PO9T4 ,ANYBODY :O /ILL SUBSCRIBES TO ,FRANCIS ,FUKUYAMA'S DELIRI\S 05D ( HI/ORY0 !SIS IS JU/ PLA9 /UPID4 ,!RE ISN'T ANY:]E 9 ! WORLD :]E !RE MIY \TBREAKS4 ,NOT EV5 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES6 ,AS HE SO (T5 DID1 ,FR$Y ,P]LMAN GOT IT EXACTLY RI ,BUT !SE REVOLUTIONS WILL NOT CON=M - !Y NEV] HAVE - TO ,L59I/ OR SYNDICALI/ OR ,PLAT=MI/ SC5>IOS4 ,!Y WILL NOT BE COMM5C$1 OR CONTROLL$1 BY LEFT-W+ ORGANIZATIONS3 LEA/ ( ALL BY NUM]ICALLY NEGLIGIBLE AN>*O-LEFTI/ ORGANIZATIONS :OSE %ELF LIVES >E %ORT4 ,EXCEPT = ! CURR5T CAMPUS- & -CAFE-BAS$ C>ICATURE CALL+ ITSELF ! ,I,W,W4 ,IT L+]S ON1 A LIV+ FOSSIL1 IF Y\ CALL ?AT LIV+44 ,LEFTISM MIY EVIL1 9 ! PA/4 ,NOBODY IS CAPABLE ( V]IFY+ A CONT5TION LIKE ?AT4 ,I HAVE D\BTS4 ,BY N[1 SO MU* IS SORDID 9 ! HI/ORY ( ! LEFT ?AT ,I DON'T UND]/& :Y ANYONE W\LD WANT AN ACCURS$ %>E ( IT4 ,WELL1 9 A WAY DO ,I UND]/&4 ,ID5TIFICATION ) ! LEFT IS A WAY = UNIMPORTANT PEOPLE TO FEEL IMPORTANT )\T DO+ ANY?+ IMPORTANT4 .<#a.> ,MURRAY ,BOOK*91 0,PO/-,SC>CITY ,AN>*ISM10 ,PO/-,SC>CITY ,AN>*ISM 7,B]KELEY1 ,C,A3 ,! ,RAMP>TS ,PRESS1 #a#i#g#a71 #d#d4 .<#b.> ,LETT]1 ,JASON ,MC,QU9N TO ,BOB ,BLACK1 ,DECEMB] #a#i1 #b#a#c1 P4 #a4 .<#c.> ,AN>*Y AFT] ,LEFTISM 7,COLUMBIA1 ,M,O3 ,C4,A4,L4 ,PRESS1 #a#i#i#g74 ,A SECOND $ITION1 ) A NEW 9TRODUCTION BY ,JASON ,MC,QU9N1 IS =?COM+ FROM ,C4,A4,L4 ,PRESS4 .<#d.> ,IBID41 #a#e4 .<#e.> ,LETT]1 ,MC,QU9N TO ,BLACK1 PP4 #a-#b4 ,ANO!R ISSUE :I* WAS SUB/ANTIALLY DEVOT$ TO PO/-LEFT AN>*ISM WAS ,NO4 #$ 7#b7#b77 7,W9T] #b#b-#b#c74 ,CONTRIBUTORS TO ?AT ISSUE 9CLUD$ ,JOHN ,Z]ZAN1 ,LAWR5CE ,J>A*1 ,JASON ,MC,QU9N1 ,ALEX ,TROTT] & MYSELF4 .<#f.> ,I %ALL BE REF]R+ ?R\<\T TO AN>*O-LEFTISM1 NOT TO LEFT AN>*ISM OR LEFT-W+ AN>*ISM4 ,I DO SO BECAUSE EV]Y TIME A CONFLICT >ISES BETWE5 HIS AN>*ISM & HIS LEFTISM1 ! AN>*O-LEFTI/ COMES D[N ON ! SIDE ( LEFTISM4 ,!RE'S A DIFF]5CE BETWE5 MEAN+ 70S5SE07 & REF]5CE1 AS WAS FIR/ EXPLICAT$ BY ,GOTTLOB ,FREGE4 .<#g.> ,ANTI->T HAS LONG S9CE BE5 RECUP]AT$ BY ! >T 9DU/RY & ITS ACADEMIC ADJUNCTS4 ,SEE1 E4G41 ,ON ! ,PASSAGE ( A ,FEW ,PEOPLE ,?R\< A ,RA!R ,BRIEF ,P]IOD 9 ,TIME3 ,! ,SITUATIONI/ ,9T]NATIONAL1 #a#i#e#g-#a#i#g#b1 $4 ,ELIZABE? ,SUSSMAN 7,CAMBRIDGE1 ,M,A @& ,LONDON3 ,! ,M,I,T ,PRESS1 #a#i#h#i71 PUBLI%$ TO ACCOMPANY A TRAVEL+ EXHIBITION ( ,SITUATIONI/ >T 9 #a#i#h#i-#a#i#i4 ,! EXHIBITION WAS FUND$ BY 0! ,NATIONAL ,5D[M5T = ! ,>TS1 ,MASSA*USETTS ,C\NCIL ON ! ,>TS & ,HUMANITIES1 & ,ASSOCIATION ,FRANCAISE D',ACTION ,>TI/IQUE40 ,I SAW ! EXHIBITION 9 ,BO/ON4 ,I DISCUSS IT1 DISP>AG+LY1 9 ,BOB ,BLACK1 0,! ,REALIZATION & ,SUPPRESSION ( ,SITUATIONISM10 ,B5EA? ! ,UND]GR\ND 7,PORTL&1 ,O,R3 ,F]AL ,H\SE1 #a#i#i#d71 #h#e-#h#i4 .<#h.> ,I WON'T BURD5 ! READ]S ) CITATIONS1 EXCEPT 9 ! NEXT FOOTNOTE4 ,TO A LESS] EXT5T !RE WAS A REVIVAL ( 9T]E/ 9 ! #a#i#f'S1 AS 9DICAT$1 = 9/ANCE1 BY ! G5]AL HI/ORIES ( AN>*ISM BY ,GEORGE ,WOODCOCK & ,JAMES ,JOLL40 0,AN>*ISM ,REVISIT$10 ,AN>*ISM & ,AN>*I/S3 ,ESSAYS BY ,GEORGE ,WOODCOCK 7,K+TON1 ,ONT>IO1 ,CANADA3 ,QU>RY ,PRESS1 #a#i#i#b1 #d#d4 .<#i.> ,MAX ,/IRN]3 ,! ,EGO & ,HIS ,[N1 $4 ,JOHN ,C>ROLL 7,NEW ,YORK3 ,H>P] ,TOR*BOOKS1 #a#i#g#a74 ,?IS WAS AN ABRIDGM5T4 ,I'M NOT NECESS>ILY AGA9/ EV5H&$ ABRIDGM5TS ( REPETITI\S WRIT]S SU* AS ,/IRN]1 OR PROLIX WRIT]S SU* AS ,WILLIAM ,GODW94 ,:AT WAS OBJECTIONABLE1 9DE$ (F5SIVE1 AB\T ?IS V]SION ( ! BOOK WAS ITS PLACEM5T 9 A %ORT-LIV$ S]IES CALL$ 0,ROOTS ( ! ,RI 0,9TRODUCTION10 #bac ,L,B,C ,BOOKS ,REVIEW 7.<,B]KELEY1 ,C,A.>3 ,L,B,C ,BOOKS1 N4D471 #d4 .<#a#a.> ,SEE ,LORRA9E ,P]LMAN1 ,HAV+ ,LITTLE1 ,BE+ ,MU*3 ,A ,*RONICLE ( ,FR$Y ,P]LMAN'S ,FIFTY ,YE>S 7,DETROIT1 ,M,I3 ,BLACK @& ,R$1 #a#i#h#i74 .<#a#c.> ,SEE ALSO ,MIKE ,GUND]LOY @& ,C>I ,GOLDB]G ,JANICE1 ,! ,WORLD ( ,Z9ES 7,NEW ,YORK3 ,P5GU9 ,BOOKS1 #a#i#i#b74 ,!Y $IT$ ,FACT%EET ,FIVE1 F\ND$ BY ,GUND]LOY 7AN AN>*I/71 :I* REVIEW$ Z9ES & RELAT$ >TIFACTS1 & :I* ,I WAS READ+ FROM ! TIME IT WAS ONE MIMEOGRAPH$ %EET UNTIL IT WAS OV] A HUNDR$ PAGES AN ISSUE ( F9E PR9T4 ,GUND]LOY DONAT$ ! T5S ( ?\S&S ( ! Z9ES HE REVIEW$ TO ! ,NEW ,YORK ,/ATE ,LIBR>Y4 ,!RE >E MAT]IALS = MANY A DISS]TATION !RE4 ,CF4 ,URI ,GORDON1 ,AN>*Y ,ALIVE6 ,ANTI-,AU?ORIT>IAN ,POLITICS FROM ,PRACTICE TO ,!ORY 7,LONDON @& ,ANN ,>BOR1 ,M,I3 ,PLUTO ,PRESS1 #b#h71 #i4 .<#a#c.> ,SEE ALSO ,MIKE ,GUND]LOY @& ,C>I ,GOLDB]G ,JANICE1 ,! ,WORLD ( ,Z9ES 7,NEW ,YORK3 ,P5GU9 ,BOOKS1 #a#i#i#b74 ,!Y $IT$ ,FACT%EET ,FIVE1 F\ND$ BY ,GUND]LOY 7AN AN>*I/71 :I* REVIEW$ Z9ES & RELAT$ >TIFACTS1 & :I* ,I WAS READ+ FROM ! TIME IT WAS ONE MIMEOGRAPH$ %EET UNTIL IT WAS OV] A HUNDR$ PAGES AN ISSUE ( F9E PR9T4 ,GUND]LOY DONAT$ ! T5S ( ?\S&S ( ! Z9ES HE REVIEW$ TO ! ,NEW ,YORK ,/ATE ,LIBR>Y4 ,!RE >E MAT]IALS = MANY A DISS]TATION !RE4 ,CF4 ,URI ,GORDON1 ,AN>*Y ,ALIVE6 ,ANTI-,AU?ORIT>IAN ,POLITICS FROM ,PRACTICE TO ,!ORY 7,LONDON @& ,ANN ,>BOR1 ,M,I3 ,PLUTO ,PRESS1 #b#h71 #i4 .<#a#d.> 0,! 9TEGRATION ( PRES5T OR PA/ >TI/IC PRODUCTIONS 9TO A SUP]IOR CON/RUCTION ( A MILIEU40 0,DEF9ITIONS10 9 ,SUTUATIONI/ ,9T]NATIONAL ,AN?OLOGY1 $4 @& TR4 ,K5 ,KNABB 7REV4 @& EXP4 $2 ,B]KELEY1 ,C,A3 ,BUREAU ( ,PUBLIC ,SECRETS1 #b#f71 #e#b4 ,EXAMPLES APPE> ON ! COV]S ( MY FIR/ ?REE BOOKS4 .<#a#e.> ,GORDON1 ,AN>*Y ,ATTACKS61 #a#i4 ,A GOOD PLACE NOT TO />T IS ,GREIL ,M>CUS1 ,LIP/ICK ,TRACES3 ,A ,SECRET ,HI/ORY ( ! ,TW5TIE? ,C5TURY 7,CAMBRIDGE3 ,H>V>D ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS1 #a#i#h#i74 ,& !N !RE IS 0CYB]PUNK10 A SCI5CE FICTION T5D5CY 9 ! #a#i#hS :I* WAS 9FLU5C$ BY ! M>G9ALS MILIEU4 ,E4G41 ,LEWIS ,%9]1 ,SLAM 7,NEW ,YORK3 ,D\BL$AY1 #a#i#i7 7:]E EV5 ! ,LOOMPANICS ,CATALOG PUTS 9 AN APPE>ANCE74 ,IT WAS ALSO 9FLU5C$ BY MY ANTI-WORK CRITIQUE4 ,E4G41 ,BRUCE ,/]L+1 ,ISL&S 9 ! ,NET 7,NEW ,YORK3 ,>BOR ,H\SE1 #a#i#h#h7 7! AUTOGRAPH ON MY COPY SAYS1 0,= 9SPIRATION074 ,!RE IS EV5 A BRIEF BORR[+ FROM 0,! ,ABOLITION ( ,WORK0 AT PP4 #a#g#a-#g#b4 ,/]L+1 & ,GREG ,KRUPEY 7:O WAS WELL-KN[N 9 ! Z9E SC5E71 JO9$ ME = A Z][ORK PANEL DISCUSSION 9 #a#i#i#b1 AT AN EV5T 9 ,ATLANTA CALL$ ,PH5OMI,CON #b4 .<#a#f.> ,EXAMPLES3 ,PUBLC ,SECRETS3 ,COLLECTIVE ,SKIRMI%ES ( ,K5 ,KNABB 7,B]KELEY1 ,C,A3 ,BUREAU ( ,PUBLIC ,SECRETS1 #a#i#i#g71 #a#f#f-#b#h#g2 ,PO9T-,BLANK6 ,NO4 #a 7,B]KELEY1 ,C,A3 ,PO9T-,BLANK1 #a#i#g#b72 ,= ,\RSELVES1 ,! ,RI ,BOOK*91 ,SOCIAL ,AN>*ISM OR ,LIFE/YLE ,AN>*ISM3 ,AN ,UNBRIDGEABLE ,*ASM 7,$9BUR<1 ,SCOTL& @& ,SAN ,FRANCISCO1 ,C,A3 ,A,K ,PRESS1 #a#i#i#f71 #e#d4 .<#a#h.> 0,WE MU/ TRY TO CON/RUCT SITUATIONS1 ?AT IS TO SAY1 COLLECTIVE AMBIANCES1 5SEMBLES ( IMPRESSIONS DET]M9+ ! QUALITY ( A MOM5T40 ,GUY ,DEBORD1 0,REPORT ON ! ,CON/RUCTION ( ,SITUATIONS10 ,SITUATIONI/ ,9T]NATIONAL ,AN?OLOGY1 $4 @& TRANS4 ,K5 ,KNABB 7REV4 @& EXP4 ,$42 ,B]KELEY1 ,C,A3 ,BUREAU ( ,PUBLIC ,SECRETS1 #b#f71 #d4 .<#a#i.> ',HE .<:O UND]/&S ME.> MU/ SO TO SPEAK ?R[ AWAY ! LADD]1 AFT] HE HAS CLIMB$ UP ON IT40 ,LUDWIG ,WITTG5/E91 ,TRACTATUS ,LOGICO-,PHILOSOPHICUS1 TRANS4 ,C4,K4 ,OGD5 7,LONDON3 ,R\TL$GE @& ,KEGAN ,PAUL1 #a#i#h#c71 #a#h#e4 .<#b.> 0,ON A SCALE FROM LEFT TO RI*I/ IS (F ON A TANG5T40 ,BOB ,BLACK10,ELEM5T>Y ,WATSONIANISM10 ,FRI5DLY ,FIRE 7,BROOKLYN1 ,N,Y3 ,AUTONOM$IA1 #a#i#i#b71 #b#g4 ,?IS IS ! BOOK ON :I* ,AUTONOM$IA HAS1 = #ah YE>S1 REFUS$ TO PAY ROYALTIES1 AL?\< IT /ILL RETAILS IT4 .<#b#a.> ,= A CAU/IC RESPONSE TO ONE ( !M1 NAM$ ,MI*AEL ,KOLH(F1 SEE ,BOB ,BLACK 7) ,MIKE ,GUND]LOY71 00',NEO-,9DIVIDUALISM' ,RECONSID]$10 ,FRI5DLY ,FIRE1 #a#i#i-#b#a4 ,I AM TOLD ?AT ,KOLH(F HAS RECANT$4 .<#b#b.> ,= EXAMPLE1 ONE ( ! 0F\RFOLD T5ETS0 ( ,BOOK*9'S M9IMAL PROGRAM = SOCIAL AN>*ISM IS 0MUNICIPAL CONF$]ALISM0 - HIS PET CAUSE - :I* NO AN>*I/ HAS EV] CONSID]$ A LITMUS TE/ = AN>*I/ OR?ODOXY1 NOT EV5 ,KROPOTK94 ,IBID41 #f4 ,! ACADEMIC AN>*I/ J\RNAL ,SOCIAL ,AN>*ISM 7#a#i#h-71 = 9/ANCE1 HAS NEV] BE5 CONF9$ TO ?IS N>R[ PROGRAM1 AL?\< ,BOOK*9 WAS PUBLI%$ !RE4 ,EV5 ,I HAVE BE5 PUBLI%$ !RE - AL?\< ,I AM OMITT$ FROM ! ,AU?ORS ,LI/ AT ! WEBSITE4 ,I AM N[ AN UNP]SON !RE1 AS 9 ! OLD PHOTOS ( ! RUL+ ELITE ON ! RO/RUM AT ! ANNUAL ,MAYDAY P>ADE 9 ,MOSC[ FROM :I* ?OSE :O LAT] FELL FROM FAVOR >E LAT] CROPP$ \T4 .<#b#c.> ,BOOK*91 0,9TRODUCTION10 ,PO/-,SC>CITY ,AN>*ISM1 #bh -- A BOOK :I* HAS BE5 REPR9T$ BY ! CLASS /RUGGLE PUBLI%] ,A,K ,PRESS6 -- 9 ITS 0,WORK+ ,CLASSICS0 S]IES6 .<#b#d.> ,BOOK*91 0,SPONTANEITY & ,ORGANIZATION10 #b#e#a-#b#g#d 4 .<#b#e.> ,! ,ECOLOGY ( ,FRE$OM3 ,! ,EM]G5CE & ,DISSOLUTION ( ,HI]>*Y 7,PALO ,ALTO1 ,C,A3 ,*E%IRE ,BOOKS1 #a#i#h#b74 ,= MY BROAD] CRITIQUE ( ,BOOK*91 SEE ,BOB ,BLACK1 ,NIES ( ,REASON1 AVAILABLE ONL9E AT ,! ,AN>*Y ,LIBR>Y1 WWW4!AN>*YLIBR>Y4COM4 ,I SUMM>IZ$1 ) D]ISION1 ! BOOK'S RECEPTION BY ACADEMICS 9 ,AN>*Y AFT] ,LEFTISM1 #i#b-#i#f4 .<#b#f.> ,MURRAY ,BOOK*91 0,! ,COMMUNALI/ ,PROJECT10 ,COMMUNALISM ,NO4 #b 7,NOV4 #b#b71 AVAILABLE AT HTTP3_/_/WWW4COMMUNALISM4ORG_/ .<#b#g.> ,BLACK1 ,AN>*Y AFT] ,LEFTISM1 *4 #e @& PASSIM4 .<#b#h.> ,DAVID ,GRAEB]1 0,! ,NEW ,AN>*I/S10 ,NEW ,LEFT ,REVIEW #ac 7,JAN4-,FEB4 #b#b73 #f#a-#g#c1 AVAILABLE AT HTTP3_/_/NEWLEFTREVIEW4ORG_/,I,I_/#a#c_/DAVID-GRAEB]-!-NEW-AN>*I/S4 .<#b#i.> ,BLACK1 ,AN>*Y AFT] ,LEFTISM1 #a#d#e4 .<#c.> ,DANIEL @& ,GABRIEL ,COHN-,B5DIT1 ,OBSOLETE ,COMMUNISM3 ,! ,LEFT-,W+ ,ALT]NATIVE 1 TRANS4 ,>NOLD ,POM]ANS 7,$9BUR<1 ,SCOTL&3 ,A,K ,PRESS1 #b71 #b#c#e2 ,DAVID ,GRAEB]1 ,! ,DEMOCRACY ,PROJECT3 ,A ,HI/ORY1 A ,CRISIS1 A ,MOVEM5T 7,NEW ,YORK3 ,SPIEGEL @& ,GRAU1 #b#a#c71 #d4 .<#c#a.> ,N,L,R'S POLITICAL SYMPA?IES1 OR RA!R ANTIPA?IES1 MAY BE 9F]R$ FROM ! >TICLES IT PUBLI%$ AB\T ! ,SITUATIONI/S1 SU* AS ,REGIS ,DEBRAY1 0,REM>KS ON ! ,SPECTACLE10 ,N,L,R ,I_/#b#a#d 7,JULY-,AUG4 #a#i#i#f71 #a#c#d-#a#d#a4 ,REGIS ,DEBRAY6 ,! ,MAOI/ TURN$ ADVIS] TO ! ,PRESID5T ( ,FRANCE6 ,PET] ,WOLL51 0,! ,SITUATIONI/ ,9T]NATIONAL10 ,N,L,R ,I_/#a#g#d 7,M>*-,APRIL #a#i#h#i73 #a#c#d-#a#d#a1 REPR9T$ AS 0,BITT] ,VICTORY3 ,! ,>T & ,POLITICS ( ! ,SITUATIONI/ ,9T]NATIONAL10 9 ,ON ! ,PASSAGE ( A ,FEW ,PEOPLE ,?R\< A ,RA!R ,BRIEF ,MOM5T 9 ,TIME1 #b-#f#a 7,WOLL51 A SOMETIME >TS $ITOR = ,N,L,R1 ORGANIZ$ ! >T EXHIBITION = :I* ?IS BOOK WAS ! ACCOMPANIM5T74 ,DEBRAY VILIFIES ! ,SITUATIONI/S4 ,WOLL51 & ,DEBRAY AS WELL1 MAGNIFY ! >TI/IC IMPORTANCE ( ! ,S4,I4 9 ORD] TO M9IMIZE ITS POLITICAL IMPORTANCE4 ,T4,J4 ,CL>K @& ,DONALD ,NI*OLSON-,SMI?1 0,:Y ,>T ,CAN'T ,KILL ! ,SITUATIONI/ ,9T]NATIONAL10 ,OCTOB] #gi 7,W9T] #a#i#i#g73 #a#e-#c#a1 REPR9T$ 9 ,GUY ,DEBORD & ! ,SITUATIONI/ ,9T]NATIONAL1 $4 ,TOM ,MC,DON\< 7,CAMBRIDGE1 ,M,A @& ,LONDON3 ,! ,M,I,T ,PRESS1 #b#d71 #d#f#g-#d#h#h4 ,ALL ! CONTRIBUTORS TO BO? VOLUMES APPE> TO BE ACADEMICS OR >TS CRITICS1 EXCEPT ,CL>K & ,NI*OLSON-,SMI?1 :O HAD BE5 MEMB]S ( ! ,S4,I4 .<#c#b.> ,BUT SEE ,MURRAY ,BOOK*91 0,! ,LEFT ,?AT ,WAS10 9 ,SOCIAL ,AN>*ISM OR ,LIFE/YLE ,AN>*ISM1 #f#f-#h#f4 ,! ,DUT* TRANSLATOR ( ,AN>*Y AFT] ,LEFTISM DIDN'T TRANSLATE 0LEFTISM0 LIT]ALLY BECAUSE1 HE EXPLA9S1 AL?\< !RE'S A ,DUT* WORD1L9KSISME1 NOBODY KN[S IT4 ,LETT]1 ,FRANK DE ,GRASSE TO ,BOB ,BLACK1 ,JAN4 #a#b1 #b#a#d4 ,= A USEFUL DISCUSSION ( LEFTISM :I* LIKEWISE DOES NOT ATTEMPT A DICTION>Y-/YLE DEF9ITION1 SEE ,LAWR5CE ,J>A*1 0,LEFTISM #a#a10 9 ,UNCIVILIZ$3 ,! ,BE/ ( ,GRE5 ,AN>*Y 7N4P43 ,GRE5 ,AN>*Y ,PRESS1 #b#a#b71 #i#b-#i#i &1 EV5 MORE BRIEFLY1 & ) EV5 MORE MALICE1 ,BOB ,BLACK1 0,LEFT ,RITES10 9 ,! ,ABOLITION ( ,WORK & ,O!R ,ESSAYS 7,PORT ,T[NS5D1 ,W,A3 ,LOOMPANICS ,UNLIMIT$1 #a#i#h#f71 #g#i-#h#a4 .<#c#c.> ,MAYBE NOT EV5 ?AT4 ,9 ! #aibb DUR+ ! GREAT ,R& /RIKE BY :ITE M9]S 9 ,S\? ,AFRICA1 ! SLOGAN ( ! WORK]S WAS 0,WORK]S ( ! ,WORLD1 ,UNITE6 & ,FITY SUPPORT$ ! /RIKE 7IT WAS MORE LIKE AN 9SURRECTION7 :I* WAS SUPPRESS$ BY ! MILIT>Y AT A CO/ ( #b LIVES4 ,!N !RE IS ! RACISM ( SOME LEFT-W+1 ID5TITY-POLITICS 9TELLECTUALS ) TIME ON !IR H&S :O >E ,P]SONS ( ,COLOR4 ,SOME ( !SE SELF-IMPORTANT *>ACT]S PLAY$ A DIVISIVE & DEMORALIZ+ ROLE 9 ,OCCUPY ,OAKL&1 & !Y CONT9UE TO DO SO4 .<#c#d.> ,MAYBE NOT EV5 ?AT4 ,9 ,ITALY1 SYNDICALISM %AD$ (F 9TO NATIONAL SYNDICALISM :I* %AD$ (F 9TO CORPORATISM1 :I* IS ! ECONOMICS ( FASCISM4 ,DAVID ,D4 ,ROB]TS1 ,! ,SYNDICALI/ ,TRADITION & ,ITALIAN ,FASCISM 7,*APEL ,HILL1 ,N,C3 ,UNIV]SITY ( ,NOR? ,C>OL9A ,PRESS1 #a#i#g#i74 .<#c#e.> ,GORDON1 ,AN>*Y ,ATTACKS61 #c#b4 .<#c#f.> ,LUDWIG ,WITTG5/E91 0,! ,BR[N ,BOOK10 ,! ,BLUE & ,BR[N ,BOOKS 7#bD $42 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,H>P] ,TOR*BOOKS1 #a#i#f#e71 #h#g4 ,HE DOESN'T USE ! PHRASE 0FAMILY RESEMBLANCE0 H]E3 IT FIR/ APPE>S 9 ,PHILOSOPHICAL ,9VE/IGATIONS1 $4 ,P4,M4,S4 ,HACK] @& ,JOA*IM ,S*ULTE1 TRANS4 ,G4,E4,M4 ,ANSCOMBE1 ,P4,M4,S4 ,HACK] 1 @& ,JOA*IM ,S*ULTE 7#d? $41 REV42 ,MALD51 ,M,A3 ,WILEY-,BLACKWELL1 #b#i71 #cf 78 #f#g74 .<#c#g.> 0,FROM ! TIME AN>*ISM WAS FIR/ DEF9$ AS A DI/9CT RADICAL MOVEM5T IT HAS BE5 ASSOCIAT$ ) ! LEFT1 BUT ! ASSOCIATION HAS ALWAYS BE5 UNEASY40 ,WOLFI ,L&/REI*]1 0,FROM ,POLITICS TO ,LIFE3 ,RIDD+ ,AN>*Y ( ! ,LEFTI/ ,MILL/ONE10 ,AN>*Y3 ,A ,J\RNAL ( ,DESIRE ,>M$ ,NO4 #$ 7#b7#b77 7,W9T] #b#b-#b#c71 #d#g4 0,! RELATION%IP BETWE5 AN>*I/S & ,M>XI/S HAS NEV] BE5 HAPPY40 ,RU? ,K9NAH1 ,AN>*ISM3 ,A ,BEG9N]'S ,GUIDE 7,OX=D3 ,ONEWORLD ,PUBLICATIONS1 #b#e71 #b#g1 QUOT$ 9 ,BLACK1 0,*OMSKY ON ! ,NOD10 #a#c#a4 ,!SE MAY BE UND]/ATEM5TS4 .<#c#h.> ,BLACK1 ,AN>*Y AFT] ,LEFTISM1 #a#d#c-#d#d4 .<#c#i.> ,BLACK1 ,AN>*Y AFT] ,LEFTISM1 #a#d#d-#d#e4 ,I KN[ ?AT PRIMITIVI/S WILL NOT BE SATISFI$ ) PO9T 7#c7 AS PHRAS$4 ,!Y BELIEVE ?AT AN>*ISM 5TAILS PRIMITIVISM4 ,TO :I* ,I REPLY ?AT RADICAL CRITIQUES ( TE*NOLOGY >E NOT CONF9$ TO AN>*O-PRIMITIVI/S OR1 9DE$1 TO AN>*I/S1 AL?\< ! PRIMITIVI/ CRITIQUE CAN BE DIFFICULT TO DI/+UI% FROM PRIMITIVISM G5]ALLY4 ,GORDON1 ,AN>*Y ,ALIVE61 #a#i-#a4 .<#d.> ,BOB ,BLACK1 0,*OMSKY ON ! ,NOD10 ,DEFAC+ ! ,CURR5CY3 ,SELECT$ ,WRIT+S1 #a#i#i#b-#b#a#b 7,B]KELEY1 ,C,A3 ,L,B,C ,BOOKS1 #b#a#b71 #a#c#b-#a#d#d4 ,:AT ,*OMSKY ESP\SES MAY BE SLI*O-SYNDICALISM1 BUT TO ME !Y APPE> MU* ! SAME1 & ,*OMSKY HIMSELF HAS V>I\SLY ID5TIFI$ ) BO? POSITIONS4 .<#d#a.> ,BOB ,BLACK1 0,WOOD5 ,%OES OR ,PLAT=M ,%OES8 ,ON ! ,ORGANIZATIONAL ,PLAT=M ( ! ,LIB]T>IAN ,COMMUNI/S10 ,AN>*Y3 ,A ,J\RNAL ( ,DESIRE ,>M$ ,NO4 #$ 7#b7#b77 7,W9T] #b#b-#b#c71 #a#d-#a#e1 #a#i4 .<#d#c.> ,JEAN ,BAUDRILL>D1 ,! ,MIRROR ( ,PRODUCTION1 TRANS4 ,M>K ,PO/] 7,/4 ,L\IS1 ,M,O3 ,TELOS ,PRESS1 #a#i#g#e74 .<#d#d.> ,BLACK1 0,*OMSKY ON ! ,NOD10 #a#d2 SEE ,MI*AEL ,WALZ]1 0,A ,DAY 9 ! ,LIFE ( A ,SOCIALI/ ,CITIZ510 ,DISS5T #a#e7#c7 7,MAY #a#i#f#h71 REPR9T$ 9 ,WALZ]1 ,RADICAL ,PR9CIPLES3 ,REFLECTIONS ( AN ,UNRECON/RUCT$ ,DEMOCRAT 7,NEW ,YORK3 ,BASIC ,BOOKS1 #a#i#h71 #a#a#h-#a#b#h4 .<#d#d.> ,BLACK1 0,*OMSKY ON ! ,NOD10 #a#d2 SEE ,MI*AEL ,WALZ]1 0,A ,DAY 9 ! ,LIFE ( A ,SOCIALI/ ,CITIZ510 ,DISS5T #a#e7#c7 7,MAY #a#i#f#h71 REPR9T$ 9 ,WALZ]1 ,RADICAL ,PR9CIPLES3 ,REFLECTIONS ( AN ,UNRECON/RUCT$ ,DEMOCRAT 7,NEW ,YORK3 ,BASIC ,BOOKS1 #a#i#h71 #a#a#h-#a#b#h4 .<#d#e.> ,ACCORD+ TO ,EMMA ,GOLDMAN1 0NO O!R SUP]/ITION IS SO DETRIM5TAL TO GR[?1 SO 5]VAT+ & P>ALYZ+ TO ! M9DS & HE>TS ( ! PEOPLE1 AS ! SUP]/ITION ( MORALITY10 9 ,R$ ,EMMA ,SPEAKS3 ,SELECT$ ,WRIT+S & ,SPEE*ES1 $4 ,ALIX ,KATES ,S*ULMAN 7,NEW ,YORK3 ,R&OM ,H\SE1 #a#i#g#b71 #a#b#g1 QUOT$ 9 ,BLACK1 0,*OMSKY ON ,! ,NOD10 #a#b#d-#b#e4 ,EMMA ,GOLDMAN IS A MAJOR EMB>RASSM5T TO AN>*O-LEFTI/S4 ,%E IS AV[$LY & 9DISPUTABLY AN AN>*O-COMMUNI/ - & A WOMAN6 & A FEM9I/6 - BUT %E IS = SEXUAL FRE$OM & AGA9/ MORALITY4 ,IT IS ,GOLDMAN'S MIS=TUNE ?AT H] PAP]S1 ,! ,EMMA ,GOLDMAN ,PAP]S1 5D$ UP AT ! ,UNIV]SITY ( ,CALI=NIA 7,B]KELEY7 :]E !IR $ITOR & DIRECTOR1 S9CE #a#i#h1 HAS BE5 ,C&ACE ,FALK4 ,FALK1 :O VA/LY PREF]S ,GOLDMAN'S FEM9ISM TO H] AN>*ISM1 WROTE A BIOGRAPHY :I* DEPICTS ,GOLDMAN AS A MAN-CRAZY1 DICK-:IPP$ NEUROTIC4 ,LOVE1 ,AN>*Y & ,EMMA ,GOLDMAN3 ,A ,BIOGRAPHY 7,NEW ,YORK3 ,HOLT1 ,R9EH>T @& ,W9/ON1 #a#i#h#d74 ,IT IS REM9ISC5T ( :AT HAPP5$ :5 ,NIETZS*E'S SI/]1 AN ANTI-,SEMITE & ,G]MAN NATIONALI/1 AFT] HIS DEA? CONTROLL$ HIS PUBLICATIONS & MANUSCRIPTS4 .<#d#f.> ,BLACK1 0,*OMSKY ON ! ,NOD10 #a#b#d4 .<#d#g.> 0,! ,SPIRIT ( ,HORSEP[]10 ,MURD]+ ! ,DEAD3 ,AMADEO ,BORDIGA ON ,CAPITALISM & ,O!R ,DISA/]S 7,LONDON3 ,ANTAGONISM ,PRESS1 N4D471 #g#e4 .<#d#h.> ,! ,GR\P ( ,RUSSIAN ,AN>*I/S ,ABROAD1 0,! ,ORGANIZATIONAL ,PLAT=M ( ! ,G5]AL ,UNION ( ,AN>*I/S 7,DRAFT7 ,JUNE #b1 #a#i#b#f10 9 ,ALEX&RE ,SKIRDA1 ,FAC+ ! ,5EMY3 ,A ,HI/ORY ( ,AN>*I/ ,ORGANIZATION FROM ,PR\DHON TO ,MAY #a#i#f#h1 TRANS4 ,PAUL ,%>KEY 7,$9BUR<1 ,SCOTL& @& ,OAKL&1 ,C,A3 ,A,K ,PRESS1 #b#b71 #a#i#b-#b#a#c3 A ,PLAT=M = AN IMAG9>Y ORGANIZATION4 ,SKIRDA HAS WRITT5 AN ALT]NATIVE-UNIV]SE /ORY 9 :I* ,PLAT=MISM HAS ALWAYS BE5 A PRES5CE & HAS ALWAYS BE5 IMPORTANT 9 ! AN>*I/ MOVEM5T4 .<#d#i.> ,*AZ ,BUFE1 ,LI/51 ,AN>*I/60 AVAILABLE ONL9E AT WWW4!AN>*I/LIBR>Y4COM 7ORIG9ALLY PUBLI%$ 9 #a#i#h#g7 ,?IS IS ! AN>*O-LEFTI/ ,PROTOCOLS ( ! ,ELD]S ( ,ZION4 ,BUFE CONCEALS HIS HIDD5 AG5DA AS AN AG5T ( ! CRYPTO-,M>XI/ SLICK MAGAZ9E ,PROCESS$ ,WORLD :I* DEALT ) ME1 ITS CRITIC1 RU?LESSLY & VIOL5TLY4 ,SEE ,BLACK1 0,CIRCLE-,A ,DECEIT0 & 0,NOTES ON ',CIRCLE-,A ,DECEIT1'0 ,! ,ABOLITION ( ,WORK & ,O!R ,ESSAYS1 #i#a-#i#i2 ,BOB ,BLACK1 ,! ,BABY & ! ,BA?WAT] 7REPR4 $42 ,NEW ,YORK3 ,FEH6 ,PRESS1 N4D47 7ORIG9ALLY PUBLI%$ 9 #a#i#h#e72 & ! ,KANE & ,J>A* TEXT CIT$ 9FRA FN4 #d#g4 .<#e.> ,BRIAN ,KANE @& ,LAWR5CE ,J>A*1 0,HOLD ,Y\R ,TONGUE ,DEMAGOGUE3 ,TURN+ A ,DEAF ,E> TO ,PURE ,BUFE-OON]Y10 AVAILABLE ONL9E AT WWW4!AN>*I/LIBR>Y4COM4 ,! ,AN>*I/ ,LIBR>Y PUTS UP EV5 A LY+ & LIBEL\S SCRE$ LIKE 0,LI/51 ,AN>*I/60 9 ! 9T]E/ ( FREE DISCUSSION & DEBATE4 ,! LEFTI/ WEBSITES :I* PO/ ,BUFE1 SU* AS LIB4COM1 DON'T PO/ ! REBUTTAL BY ,KANE & ,J>A*4 ,BUFE REPR9T$ HIS TRACT 9 #b1 )1 ,I SUSPECT1 F9ANCIAL ASSI/ANCE FROM A V5GEFUL ,MURRAY ,BOOK*9 7HIS GIRLFRI5D WROTE ! NEW 9TRODUCTION74 ,BY !N ,BUFE HAD READ ! CRITIQUE BY ,KANE & ,J>A*41 :I* EXPOS$ HIS ]RORS ( FACT & *ALL5G$ HIS >GUM5T4 ,BUT HE DIDN'T *ANGE A S+LE WORD4 ,ALL ?IS IS EXEMPL>Y ( 7TO BORR[ A PHRASE FROM ,TROTSKY7 0!IR MORALS & \RS40 ,I SOMETIMES SUSPECT ?AT MORALISM & MORALITY >E 9V]SELY PROPORTIONATE4 .<#e#a.> ,EXOD4 #b3#a#f 7,K,J,V74 .<#e#b.> 0,! 'PROGRESSIVE COMMUNITY' 9 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES IS DEF9$ BY LEFT-LEAN+ VOT]S & ACTIVI/S :O BELIEVE ?AT WORK+ ?R\< ! ,DEMOCRATIC ,P>TY IS ! BE/ WAY TO A*IEVE POLITICAL *ANGE 9 ,AM]ICA40 ,GRAEB]1 ,! ,DEMOCRACY ,PROJECT1 #i#e4 .<#e#c.> 0,MU* ( ! HESITATION .<( PROGRESSIVES TO ACCEPT RADICAL1 DIRECT-ACTION AN>*I/S.>1 ,I SUSPECT1 LIES 9 ! RELUCTANCE ( ?OSE :O HAVE LONG FANCI$ !MSELVES RADICALS ( SOME SORT TO COME TO T]MS ) ! FACT ?AT !Y >E REALLY LIB]ALS3 9T]E/$ 9 EXP&+ 9DIVIDUAL FRE$OMS & PURSU+ SOCIAL JU/ICE1 BUT NOT 9 WAYS ?AT W\LD S]I\SLY *ALL5GE ! EXI/5CE ( REIGN+ 9/ITUTIONS LIKE CAPITAL OR /ATE40 ,GRAEB]1 0,! ,NEW ,AN>*I/S40 .<#e#d.> ,= EXAMPLE1 ! HOOPLA AB\T UNIV]SAL & OBJECTIVELY EXI/+ HUMAN RIE MY?ICAL1 E?NOC5TRIC1 & IMPLICITLY /ATI/4 ,AN>*I/S >E AT RISK ( BE+ DRAWN 9TO RE=MISM BY TAK+ UP ?IS P>TICUL> CAUSE4 ,I SPOKE ON ?IS SUBJECT AT ! ,LONG ,HAUL 9 ,B]KELEY 9 ,AUGU/ #b#a#c1 & ,I'LL EV5TUALLY WRITE AN >TICLE AB\T IT4 .<#e#e.> ,BOOK*91 ,SOCIAL ,AN>*ISM OR ,LIFE/YLE ,AN>*ISM1 #d @& PASSIM @& AD NAUSEUM4 .<#e#f.> ,PRIOR TO ,WORLD ,W> ,I1 AN>*I/S & SYNDICALI/S DEBAT$ ! ROLE ( TRADE-UNIONS 9 ! REVOLUTION>Y /RUGGLE & 9 AN AN>*I/ SOCIETY4 ,! AN>*I/S W]E !RE=E 0SECT>IAN AN>*I/S0 ACCORD+ TO HI/ORIAN 7& EX-,/AL9I/7 ,DANIEL ,GU]9 - BUT ! SYNDICALI/S1 IT SEEMS1 W]E NOT4 ,DANIEL ,GU]91 ,AN>*ISM3 ,FROM ,!ORY TO ,PRACTICE1 TR4 ,M>Y ,KLOPP] 7,NEW ,YORK3 ,MON?LY ,REVIEW ,PRESS1 #a#i#g71 #h4 ,?IS BOOK CONTA9S A LAUDATORY 9TRODUCTION BY ,NOAM ,*OMSKY1 S9CE REPR9T$ 9 ,*OMSKY ON ,AN>*ISM1 $4 ,B>RY ,PATEMAN 7,OAKL&1 ,C,A @& ,$9BUR<1 ,SCOTL&3 ,A,K ,PRESS1 #b#e71 #a#a#h-#a#c#b1 AS 0,NOTES ON ,AN>*ISM40 ,?IS IS ! BOOK ,I TRA%$ 9 0,*OMSKY ON ! ,NOD10 9 ,DEFAC+ ! ,CURR5CY1 #f#a-#a#g#b - A REVIEW ESSAY :I* HAS ALSO BE5 PUBLI%$ 9 ,MOD]N ,SLAV]Y _?#c4 ,PATEMAN1 BY ! WAY1 WORKS UND] ,C&ACE ,FALK AT ! ,EMMA ,GOLDMAN ,PAP]S 9 ,B]KELEY4 .<#e#g.> ,V4,I4 ,L591 0,LEFT-,W+0 ,COMMUNISM1 ,AN ,9FANTILE ,DISORD] 7,PEK+1 ,*9A3 ,=EIGN ,LANGUAGES ,PRESS1 #a#i#f#e71 #a#i4 ,D5IGRATION-BY-QUOTATION-M>KS IS R\T9E AMONG AN>*O-LEFTI/S1 AS AMONG PO/-MOD]NI/S1 :O LE>N$ IT FROM ,M>XI/S1 :O HAVE BE5 DO+ IT EV] S9CE ,M>X4 ,IT IS REPREH5SIBLE4 ,SEE ,!ODOR ,W4 ,ADORNO1 0,PUNCTUATION ,M>KS10 ,ANTIO* ,REVIEW 7,SUMM] #a#i#i71 #c#c1 QUOT$ 9 ,BLACK1 ,AN>*Y AFT] ,LEFTISM1 #c#h4 .<#e#h.> ,AN>*ISM3 ,A ,HI/ORY ( ,LIB]T>IAN ,IDEAS & ,MOVEM5TS 7,CLEVEL&1 ,O,H @& ,NEW ,YORK3 ,M]IDIAN ,BOOKS1 #a#i#f#a74 .<#e#i.> ,GEORGE ,WOODCOCK1 0,*OMSKY'S ,AN>*ISM10 9 ,AN>*ISM & ,AN>*I/S 7,K+/ON1 ,ONT>IO1 ,CANADA3 ,QU>RY ,PRESS1 #a#i#i#b71 #b#b#h2 SEE ,K9NAH1 ,AN>*ISM1 #b#e4 .<#f.> ,MILAN ,RAI1 ,*OMSKY'S ,POLITICS 7,LONDON @& ,NEW ,YORK3 ,V]SO1 #a#i#i#e71 #i#e4 ,RAI DOES NOT EV5 PRET5D TO BE AN AN>*I/3 HE'S JU/ A PEAC5IK4 .<#f#a.> ,BLACK1 0,*OMSKY ON ! ,NOD10 #bbg N4 #c#f4 .<#f#b.> ,SEE ,SA%A ,K41 0',ACTIVISM' & ',AN>*O-,PURISM1'0 ONL9E AT WWW4!AN>*YLIBR>Y4COM4 .<#f#c.> ,) ! POSSIBLE EXCEPTION ( PO/-MOD]NI/S3 0,! DIFF]5CE BETWE5 ANCI5T SOCIETY1 MOD]NISM1 & PO/-MOD]NISM IS ?IS3 ! ANCI5TS KNEW ?AT !Y BELIEV$1 ! MOD]NI/S BELIEV$ ?AT !Y KNEW1 & ! PO/-MOD]NI/S BELIEVE ?AT !Y DON'T BELIEVE 9 ANY?+ ANYMORE4 ,IT IS PRECISELY ?IS LATT] BELIEF ?AT WE HAVE TO DE/ROY40 ,GUILLAUME ,PAOLI1 ,DEMOTIVATIONAL ,TRA9+ 7.<,B]KELEY1 ,C,A.>3 ,CRUEL ,HOSPICE1 #b#a#c71 #a#b-#a#c4 .<#f#d.> ,BLACK1 0,*OMSKY ON ! ,NOD10 #g#g-#g#h4 .<#f#e.> ,GORDON1 ,AN>*Y ,ATTACKS61 #c#i4 .<#f#f.> ,]RICO ,MALATE/A1 0,AN>*I/S ,HAVE ,=GOTT5 ,!IR ,PR9CIPLES0 & 0,PRO-,GOV]NM5T ,AN>*I/S10 ,MALATE/A3 ,HIS ,LIFE & ,IDEAS1 $4 ,V]NON ,RI*>DS 7,LONDON3 ,FRE$OM ,PRESS1 #a#i#g#g71 #b#d#c-#b#e#a4 .<#f#g.> ,BLACK1 0,*OMSKY ON ! ,NOD10 #a#e#c-#e#f @& PASSIM4 .<#f#h.> ,E4G1 ,NOAM ,*OMSKY1 0,AFT] ,?IRTY ,YE>S ( ,CLASS ,W>10 ,OCCUPY 7,BROOKLYN1 ,N,Y3 ,ZUCCOTTI ,P>K ,PRESS1 #b#a#b71 #f#d2 0,NOTES ON ,AN>*ISM10 #a#a#h4 ,/ILL WORK+ ?AT ONE AFT] #db YE>S4 .<#f#i.> ,OCTAVE ,MIRBEAU1 0,VOT]S' ,/RIKE60 9 ,RANTS & ,9C5DI>Y ,TRACTS1 $4 ,BOB ,BLACK @& ,ADAM ,P>FREY 7,NEW ,YORK3 ,AMOK ,PRESS @& ,PORT ,T[NS5D1 ,W,A3 ,LOOMPANICS ,UNLIMIT$1 #a#i#h#i71 #g#d-#g#h4 ,?IS TEXT 7TRANSLAT$ BY ,HAKIM ,BEY7 APPE>$ 9 ! AN?OLOGY ONLY AT MY 9SI/5CE4 ,I WAS HOP+ ! AN>*I/ PRESS W\LD NOTICE IT & REPR9T IT4 ,AS F> AS ,I KN[1 ?AT NEV] HAPP5$4 .<#g.> ,JAMES ,JOLL1 ,! ,AN>*I/S 7#bD $42 ,LONDON3 ,ME?U51 #a#i#g#i74 ,ACTUALLY AT ?IRD H&3 ,JOLL IS ALSO QUOT+ A SECOND>Y S\RCE1 ,JEAN ,MAITRON4 .<#g#a.> 0,9TRODUCTION10 #bac ,L,B,C ,BOOKS ,REVIEW1 #a 70LESS ?AN #a10 - PRESUMABLY NOT A LOT LESS ?AN #a174 .<#g#b.> ,>AGORN61 ,BOOM3 ,9TRODUCTORY ,WRIT+S ON ,NIHILISM 7N4P42 ,PI/OLS ,DRAWN1 #b#a#c71 #i#c-#i#d4 .<#g#c.> ,UNCIVILIZ$3 ,! ,BE/ ( ,GRE5 ,AN>*Y4 ,= A LONG TIME1 ,JOHN ,Z]ZAN DID MU* ( ! HEAVY LIFT+ = AN>*O-PRIMITIVISM4 ,?IS AN?OLOGY %[S ?AT1 BY N[1 MANY O!RS >E WEI<+ 94 ,!RE IS ALSO N[ AVAILABLE A SY/EMATIC1 COMPREH5SIVE AN>*O-PRIMITIVI/ ANALYSIS & CRITIQUE ( CIVILIZATION3 ,5RICO ,MANIC>DI1 ,FREE FROM ,CIVILIZATION 7N4P43 ,GRE5 ,AN>*Y ,PRESS1 #b#a#b74 ,?IS MAY DIM9I% A C]TA9 CULT ( P]SONALITY >\ND ,Z]ZAN :I* ,I AM SURE HE ISN'T COM=TABLE )4 .<#g#d.> ,QUE] ,ULTRAVIOL5CE1 $4 ,FRAY ,B>OQUE @& ,TEGAN ,EANELLI 7.<,B]KELEY1 ,C,A.>3 ,>D5T ,PRESS1 #b#a#a72 ,QUE] ,ULTRAVIOL5CE 7#bD $41 ABR42 ,B]KELEY1 ,C,A3 ,>D5T ,PRESS1 #b#a#c72 SEE ALSO ,BA$AN3 ,J\RNAL ( ,QUE] ,NIHILISM ,NO4 #a 7#b#a#b74 .<#g#e.> ,A NEW WEBSITE 7LAUN*$ ,JANU>Y #b#a#d71 ABOLI%WORK4COM1 IS 9 ! E>LY /AGES ( COMPIL+ ANTI-WORK & RELAT$ TEXTS4 .<#g#f.> ,FR$Y ,P]LMAN1 0,ANY?+ ,CAN ,HAPP510 ,ANY?+ ,CAN ,HAPP5 7,LONDON3 ,PH5IX ,PRESS1 #a#i#i#b71 #g-#a#d4 ,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,NOVEMB] #c1 #bad 3 ,NOTES ON 0,PO/-,LEFT ,AN>*ISM0 -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,APRIL #a#h1 #bb 3 ,NOTES ON 0,PO/-,LEFT ,AN>*ISM0 -- ,ADD$4 ,JANU>Y #c1 #bbb 3 ,NOTES ON 0,PO/-,LEFT ,AN>*ISM0 -- ,UPDAT$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/