,ON ,COLLECTIVE ,RESPONSIBILITY #aic ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,]RICO ,MALATE/A ,TEXT 3 ,I HAVE SE5 A /ATEM5T BY ! ,GR\P ( ! #a#hE :]E1 9 AGREEM5T ) ! ,RUSSIANS' 0,PLAT=M0 & ) COMRADE ,MAKHNO1 IT IS HELD ?AT ! 0PR9CIPLE ( COLLECTIVE RESPONSIBILITY0 IS ! BASIS ( EV]Y S]I\S ORGANIZATION4 ,I HAVE ALREADY1 9 MY CRITICISM ( ! 0,PLAT=M0 & 9 MY REPLY TO ! OP5 LETT] DIRECT$ TO ME BY ,MAKHNO1 9DICAT$ MY OP9ION ON ?IS SUPPOS$ PR9CIPLE4 ,BUT AS !RE IS SOME 9SI/5CE ON AN IDEA OR AT LEA/ AN EXPRESSION :I* W\LD SEEM TO ME TO BE MORE AT HOME 9 A MILIT>Y B>RACKS ?AN AMONG AN>*I/ GR\PS1 ,I HOPE ,I WILL BE P]MITT$ TO SAY ANO!R FEW WORDS ON ! QUE/ION4 ,! COMRADES ( ! #a#hE SAY ?AT 0COMMUNI/ AN>*I/S MU/ WORK 9 SU* A WAY ?AT !IR 9FLU5CE HAS ! GREATE/ PROBABILITIES = SUCCESS & ?AT ?IS RESULT WILL NOT COME AB\T UNLESS !IR PROPAG&A CAN DEVELOP COLLECTIVELY1 P]MAN5TLY & HOMOG5E\SLY04 ,I AGREE6 ,BUT IT SEEMS ?AT ?AT IS NOT ! CASE2 S9CE ?OSE COMRADES COMPLA9 ?AT 09 ! NAME ( ! SAME ORGANIZATION1 9 EV]Y CORN] ( ,FRANCE1 ! MO/ DIV]SE1 & EV5 CONTR>Y !ORIES >E SPREAD+04 ,?AT IS MO/ DEPLORABLE1 BUT IT SIMPLY MEANS ?AT ?AT ORGANIZATION HAS NO CLE> & PRECISE PROGRAM :I* IS UND]/OOD & ACCEPT$ BY ALL ITS MEMB]S1 & ?AT )9 ! P>TY1 CONFUS$ BY A COMMON LABEL1 >E M5 :O DO NOT HAVE ! SAME IDEAS & :O %\LD GR\P TOGE!R 9 SEP>ATE ORGANIZATIONS OR REMA9 UNATTA*$ IF !Y >E UNABLE TO F9D O!RS :O ?9K AS !Y DO4 ,IF1 AS ! COMRADES ( ! #a#hE SAY1 ! ,U,A,C,R 7,UNION ,AN>*I/E ,COMMUNI/E ,REVOLUTIONNAIRE7 DOES NO?+ TO E/ABLI% A PROGRAM :I* CAN BE ACCEPT$ BY ALL ITS MEMB]S & P]MIT IT TO BE ABLE TO ACT TOGE!R 9 SU* SITUATIONS AS MAY PRES5T !MSELVES1 IF1 9 O!R WORDS1 ! ,U,A,C,R LACKS KN[L$GE1 COHESION OR AGREEM5T1 ITS PROBLEM IS ?IS1 & NO?+ WILL BE REM$I$ BY PROCLAIM+ 0COLLECTIVE RESPONSIBILITY0 :I*1 UNLESS IT MEANS ! BL9D SUBMISSION ( ALL TO ! WILL ( SOME1 IS A MORAL ABSURDITY 9 !ORY & G5]AL IRRESPONSIBILITY 9 PRACTICE4 ,BUT ALL ?IS IS P]HAPS ONLY A QUE/ION ( WORDS4 ,9 MY REPLY TO ,MAKHNO ,I ALREADY SAID3 0,IT MAY BE ?AT1 BY ! T]M COLLECTIVE RESPONSIBILITY1 Y\ MEAN ! AGREEM5T & SOLID>ITY ?AT MU/ EXI/ AMONG ! MEMB]S ( AN ASSOCIATION4 ,& IF ?AT IS SO1 Y\R EXPRESSION W\LD1 9 MY OP9ION1 AM\NT TO AN IMPROP] USE ( LANGUAGE1 & !RE=E1 BE+ ONLY A QUE/ION ( WORDS1 WE W\LD BE CLOS] TO UND]/&+ EA* O!R40 ,& N[1 READ+ :AT ! COMRADES ( ! #a#hE SAY1 ,I F9D MYSELF MORE OR LESS 9 AGREEM5T ) !IR WAY ( CONCEIV+ ! AN>*I/ ORGANIZATION 7BE+ V]Y F> FROM ! AU?ORIT>IAN SPIRIT :I* ! 0,PLAT=M0 SEEM$ TO REVEAL7 & ,I CONFIRM MY BELIEF ?AT BEH9D ! L+UI/IC DIFF]5CES REALLY LIE ID5TICAL POSITIONS4 ,BUT IF ?IS IS ! CASE1 :Y P]SI/ 9 AN EXPRESSION :I* S]VES ONLY TO DEFY CL>IFICATION ( :AT WAS ONE ( ! CAUSES ( ! MISUND]/&+ PROVOK$ BY ! 0,PLAT=M08 ,:Y NOT SPEAK AS ALL DO 9 SU* A WAY AS TO BE UND]/OOD & NOT CREATE CONFUSION8 ,MORAL RESPONSIBILITY 7& 9 \R CASE WE CAN TALK ( NO?+ BUT MORAL RESPONSIBILITY7 IS 9DIVIDUAL BY ITS V]Y NATURE4 ,ONLY ! SPIRIT ( DOM9ATION1 9 ITS V>I\S POLITICAL1 MILIT>Y1 ECCLESIA/ICAL 7ETC47 GUISES1 HAS BE5 ABLE TO HOLD M5 RESPONSIBLE = :AT !Y HAVE NOT DONE VOLUNT>ILY4 ,IF A NUMB] ( M5 AGREE TO DO SOME?+ & ONE ( !M ALL[S ! 9ITIATIVE TO FAIL ?R\< NOT C>RY+ \T :AT HE HAD PROMIS$1 EV]YONE WILL SAY ?AT IT WAS HIS FAULT & ?AT !RE=E IT IS HE :O IS RESPONSIBLE1 NOT ?OSE :O DID :AT !Y W]E SUPPOS$ TO RI* _/ ,APRIL #aic 7,S\RCE3 ,RETRIEV$ ON #b#i? ,JULY #bb FROM WWW4NE/ORMAKHNO49FO4 ,?IS IS A LETT] FROM ,]RICO ,MALATE/A TO ! AN>*I/ GR\P ( ! #a#hE ,>RONDISSEM5T 9 ,P>IS1 WRITT5 9 ,M>* OR ,APRIL #aic & PUBLI%$ 9 ,P>IS 9 0,LE ,LIB]TAIRE0 ,NO4#b#e#b ON #a#i? ,APRIL #a#i#c4 ,! LETT] CONFIRMS ,MALATE/A'S OP9ION ON ! CONCEPT ( ! 0COLLECTIVE RESPONSIBILITY0 ( ! ORGANIZATION4 ,BO? AT ! LA/ CONGRESS ( ORGANIZ$ ,FR5* AN>*I/S & 9 ! PAGES ( 0,LE ,LIB]TAIRE0 ! ISSUE WAS BE+ HOTLY DEBAT$47 ,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,FEBRU>Y #b#h1 #aic 3 ,ON ,COLLECTIVE ,RESPONSIBILITY -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,M>* #b#a1 #bba 3 ,ON ,COLLECTIVE ,RESPONSIBILITY -- ,ADD$4 ,JANU>Y #i1 #bbb 3 ,ON ,COLLECTIVE ,RESPONSIBILITY -- ,UPDAT$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/