,ON ,ZIONISM 

#ai* 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,EMMA ,GOLDMAN 

,TEXT 3 

  

,PHOTO BY ,BROCCO1,C,C ,B,Y-,S,A ,LIC5SE ,TO ! ,$ITOR1  
 0,SPA9 & ! ,WORLD04 

,DE> ,COMRADE1 

,I WAS 9T]E/$ 9 ! >TICLE1 ',PALE/9E & ,SOCIALI/ ,POLICY'1 BY \R GOOD FRI5D ,REG9ALD ,REYNOLDS 9 ',SPA9 & ! ,WORLD' ( ,JULY #b#i?4 ,!RE IS MU* 9 IT ) :I* ,I FULLY AGREE1 BUT A GREAT DEAL MORE :I* SEEMS TO ME CONTRADICTORY = A ,SOCIALI/ & A NE>-AN>*I/4 ,BE=E ,I PO9T \T !SE 9CONSI/5CIES1 ,I WI% TO SAY ?AT \R FRI5D'S >TICLE L5DS ITSELF TO ! IMPRESSION ?AT HE IS A RABID ANTI-,SEMITE4 ,9 PO9T ( TRU?1 ,I HAVE BE5 ASK$ BY SEV]AL PEOPLE H[ IT HAPP5S ?AT ',SPA9 & ! ,WORLD' PR9T$ SU* AN ANTI-,SEMITIC >TICLE4 ,!IR SURPRISE WAS EV5 GREAT] ?AT ,REG9ALD ,REYNOLDS %\LD BE GUILTY ( SU* T5D5CY4 ,KN[+ ! WRIT] ,I FELT QUITE SAFE 9 ASSUR+ MY ,JEWI% FRI5DS ?AT ,REG9ALD ,REYNOLDS HAS NOT A P>TICLE ( ANTI-,SEMITIC FEEL+ 9 HIM1 AL?\< IT IS QUITE TRUE ?AT HIS >TICLE UN=TUNATELY GIVES SU* AN IMPRESSION4 

,I HAVE NO QU>REL ) \R GOOD FRI5D AB\T HIS *>GES AGA9/ ! ,ZIONI/S4 ,9 PO9T ( FACT ,I HAVE = MANY YE>S OPPOS$ ,ZIONISM AS ! DREAM ( CAPITALI/ ,JEWRY ! WORLD OV] = A ,JEWI% ,/ATE ) ALL ITS TRIMM+S1 SU* AS ,GOV]NM5T1 LAWS1 POLICE1 MILIT>ISM & ! RE/4 ,9 O!R WORDS1 A ,JEWI% ,/ATE MA*9]Y TO PROTECT ! PRIVILEGES ( ! FEW AGA9/ ! MANY4 

,REG9ALD ,REYNOLDS IS WRONG1 H[EV]1 :5 HE MAKES IT APPE> ?AT ! ,ZIONI/S W]E ! SOLE BACK]S ( ,JEWI% EMIGRATION TO ,PALE/9E4 ,P]HAPS HE DOES NOT KN[ ?AT ! ,JEWI% MASSES 9 EV]Y C\NTRY & ESPECIALLY 9 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES ( ,AM]ICA HAVE CONTRIBUT$ VA/ AM\NTS ( MONEY = ! SAME PURPOSE4 ,!Y HAVE GIV5 UN/9T+LY \T ( !IR E>N+S 9 ! HOPE ?AT ,PALE/9E MAY PROVE TO BE AN ASYLUM = !IR BRO!RS1 CRUELLY P]SECUT$ 9 NE>LY EV]Y ,EUROPEAN C\NTRY4 ,! FACT ?AT !RE >E MANY NON-,ZIONI/ COMMUNES 9 ,PALE/9E GOES TO PROVE ?AT ! ,JEWI% WORK]S :O HAVE HELP$ ! P]SECUT$ & H\ND$ ,JEWS HAVE DONE SO NOT BECAUSE !Y >E ,ZIONI/S1 BUT = ! REASON ,I HAVE ALREADY /AT$1 ?AT !Y MI<T BE LEFT 9 PEACE 9 ,PALE/9E TO TAKE ROOT & LIVE !IR [N LIVES4 

,COMRADE ,REYNOLDS RES5TS ! CONT5TION ( ! ,JEWS ?AT ,PALE/9E HAD BE5 !IR HOMEL& TWO ?\S& YE>S AGO4 ,HE 9SI/S ?AT ?IS IS ( NO IMPORTANCE AS AGA9/ ! ,>ABS :O HAVE LIV$ 9 ,PALE/9E = G5]ATIONS4 ,I DO NOT ?9K EI!R CLAIM ( GREAT MOM5T1 UNLESS ONE BELIEVES 9 ! MONOPOLY ( L& & ! RI<T ( ,GOV]NM5TS 9 EV]Y C\NTRY TO KEEP \T ! NEWCOM]S4 

,SURELY ,REG9ALD ,REYNOLDS KN[S ?AT ! ,>AB PEOPLE HAVE AB\T AS MU* TO SAY :O %\LD OR %\LD NOT COME 9TO !IR C\NTRY AS ! UND]-PRIVILEG$ ( O!R L&S4 ,9 PO9T ( FACT \R FRI5D ADMITS AS MU* :5 HE /ATES ?AT ! ,>AB FEUDAL LORDS HAD SOLD ! L& TO ! ,JEWS )\T ! KN[L$GE ( ! ,>AB PEOPLE4 ,?IS IS ( C\RSE NO?+ NEW 9 \R WORLD4 ,! CAPITALI/ CLASS EV]Y:]E [NS1 CONTROLS & DISPOSES ( ITS WEAL? TO SUIT ITSELF4 ,! MASSES1 :E!R ,>AB1 ,5GLI% OR ANY O!R1 HAVE V]Y LITTLE TO SAY 9 ! MATT]4 

,9 CLAIM+ ! RI<T ( ! ,>ABS TO KEEP \T ,JEWI% IMMIGRATION FROM ,PALE/9E1 \R GOOD FRI5D IS GUILTY ( ! SAME BREA* ( ,SOCIALISM AS HIS COMRADE1 ,JOHN ,MC,GOV]N4 ,TO BE SURE ! LATT] MAKES HIMSELF ! *AMPION ( ,BRITI% ,IMP]IALISM :ILE ,REG9ALD ,REYNOLDS SPONSORS ,>AB CAPITALI/ RI<TS4 ,?AT IS BAD 5\< = A REVOLUTION>Y SOCIALI/4 ,WORSE /ILL IS ! 9CONSI/5CY 9 PLEAD+ ON BEHALF ( L& MONOPOLY1 TO :I* ! ,>ABS ALONE %\LD HAVE ! RI<T4 

,P]HAPS MY REVOLUTION>Y $UCATION HAS BE5 SADLY NEGLECT$1 BUT ,I HAVE BE5 TAU<T ?AT ! L& %\LD BELONG TO ?OSE :O TILL ! SOIL4 ,) ALL ( HIS DEEP-SEAT$ SYMPA?IES ) ! ,>ABS1 \R COMRADE CANNOT POSSIBLY D5Y ?AT ! ,JEWS 9 ,PALE/9E HAVE TILL$ ! SOIL4 ,T5S ( ?\S&S ( !M1 Y\NG & DEEPLY DEV\T IDEALI/S1 HAVE FLOCK$ TO ,PALE/9E1 !RE TO TILL ! SOIL UND] ! MO/ TRY+ PIONE] CONDITIONS4 ,!Y HAVE RECLAIM$ WA/EL&S & HAVE TURN$ !M 9TO F]TILE FIELDS & BLOOM+ G>D5S4 ,N[ ,I DO NOT SAY ?AT !RE=E ,JEWS >E 5TITL$ TO MORE RI<TS ?AN ! ,>ABS1 BUT = AN >D5T SOCIALI/ TO SAY ?AT ! ,JEWS HAVE NO BUS9ESS 9 ,PALE/9E SEEMS TO ME RA!R A /RANGE K9D ( SOCIALISM4 

,MOREOV]1 ,REG9ALD ,REYNOLDS NOT ONLY D5IES ! ,JEWS ! RI<T TO ASYLUM 9 ,PALE/9E1 BUT HE ALSO 9SI/S ?AT ,AU/RALIA1 ,MADAGASC> & ,EA/ ,AFRICA W\LD BE JU/IFI$ 9 CLOS+ !IR PORTS AGA9/ ! ,JEWS4 ,IF ALL !SE C\NTRIES >E 9 !IR RI<T1 :Y NOT ! ,NAZIS 9 ,G]MANY OR ,AU/RIA8 ,9 FACT1 ALL C\NTRIES4 ,UN=TUNATELY1 \R COMRADE DOES NOT SUGGE/ A S+LE PLACE :]E ! ,JEWS MI<T F9D PEACE & SECURITY4 

,I TAKE IT ?AT ,REG9ALD ,REYNOLDS BELIEVES 9 ! RI<T ( ASYLUM = POLITICAL REFUGEES4 ,I AM C]TA9 HE RES5TS ! LOSS ( ?IS GREAT PR9CIPLE1 ONCE ! PRIDE & GLORY ( ,5GL&1 AS MU* AS ,I DO4 ,H[ !N1 CAN HE RECONCILE HIS FEEL+S AB\T POLITICAL REFUGEES ) HIS D5IAL ( ASYLUM TO ! ,JEWS4 ,I MU/ SAY ,I AM PUZZL$4 

,\R FRI5D WAXES V]Y HOT AB\T NATIONAL 9DEP5D5CE = ! ,>ABS & = ALL O!R PEOPLES UND] ,BRITI% ,DOM9ION4 ,I AM NOT OPPOS$ TO ! /RUGGLE = IT1 BUT ,I DO NOT SEE ! SAME BLESS+S 9 NATIONAL 9DEP5D5CE UND] ! CAPITALI/ REGIME4 ,ALL ! ADVANCEM5T CLAIM$ = IT IS LIKE ! CLAIMS = DEMOCRACY1 A DELUSION & A SN>E4 ,ONE HAS TO PO9T \T SOME ( ! C\NTRIES ?AT HAVE A*IEV$ NATIONAL 9DEP5D5CE4 ,POL&1 = 9/ANCE1 ! ,BALTIC ,/ATES OR SOME ( ! ,BALKAN C\NTRIES4 ,F> FROM BE+ PROGRESSIVE 9 ! TRUE S5SE1 !Y HAVE BECOME ,FASCI/4 ,POLITICAL P]SECUTION IS NOT LESS SEV]E ?AN UND] ! ,CZ>1 :ILE ANTI-,SEMITISM1 =M]LY FO/]$ FROM ON TOP1 HAS S9CE 9FE/$ EV]Y LAY] ( SOCIAL LIFE 9 !SE C\NTRIES4 

,H[EV]1 S9CE \R FRI5D *AMPIONS NATIONAL 9DEP5D5CE1 :Y NOT BE CONSI/5T & RECOGNIZE ! RI<T ( ! ,ZIONI/S OR ! ,JEWS AT L>GE TO NATIONAL 9DEP5D5CE8 ,IF ANY?+1 !IR PREC>I\S CONDITION1 ! FACT ?AT !Y >E NO:]E WANT$1 %\LD 5TITLE !M TO AT LEA/ ! SAME CONSID]ATION ?AT \R COMRADE SO E>NE/LY GIVES TO ! ,>ABS4 

,I KN[ ( C\RSE ?AT A GREAT MANY ( ! ,JEWS CAN LAY NO CLAIM TO BE+ POLITICAL REFUGEES4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 MO/ ( !M HAVE REMA9$ 9DIFF]5T TO ! P]SECUTION ( WORK]S1 SOCIALI/S1 COMMUNI/S1 TRADE-UNIONI/S & AN>*I/S1 SO LONG AS !IR [N SK9S W]E SAFE4 ,LIKE ! MIDDLE-CLASS 9 ,G]MANY & ,AU/RIA1 !Y HAVE EXPLOIT$ LABOR & HAVE BE5 ANTAGONI/IC TO ANY ATTEMPT ON ! P>T ( ! MASSES TO BETT] !IR CONDITION4 ,SOME ,G]MAN ,JEWS HAD ! TEM]ITY TO SAY ?AT !Y W\LD NOT OBJECT TO DRIV+ \T ! ',O/,JUD5' 7,JEWS COM+ FROM ,POL& & O!R C\NTRIES74 ,ALL ?AT IS TRUE1 BUT ! FACT REMA9S ?AT S9CE ,HITL]'S ASC5DANCY TO P[] ALL ,JEWS )\T EXCEPTION HAVE BE5 SUBJECT$ TO ! MO/ FI5DI% P]SECUTION & ! MO/ HORRIBLE 9DIGNITIES1 BESIDES BE+ ROBB$ ( ALL ( ! POSSESSIONS4 ,IT !RE=E SEEMS /RANGE = A ,SOCIALI/ TO D5Y !SE UN=TUNATE PEOPLE A *ANCE ( TAK+ ROOT 9 NEW C\NTRIES1 !RE TO BEG9 A NEW LIFE4 

,! LA/ P>AGRAPH 9 ',PALE/9E & ,SOCIAL ,POLICY' CAPS ! CLIMAX4 ,! AU?OR WRITES3 0,:AT DOES IT MATT] :O MAKES A DEM& OR :Y IT IS MADE1 OR :O PAYS ! BILL IF ?AT DEM& IS JU/8 ,TO REJECT A JU/ DEM& IS TO BR& \RSELVES AS FRI5DS ( TYRANNY & OPPRESSION2 TO ACCEPT IT & TO WORK = IT IS NOT ONLY \R DUTY BUT ! ONLY POLICY ?AT WILL EXPOSE ! PRET5SIONS ( \R 5EMIES40 

,! QUE/ION IS1 DE> ,REG9ALD ,REYNOLDS1 :O IS TO DECIDE :AT IS A 'JU/ DEM&'8 ,UNLESS ONE MAKES ONESELF GUILTY ( ! *>GE ! WRIT] HURLS AGA9/ ! ,JEWS1 0! 9TOL]ABLE >ROGANCE ( PEOPLE :O REG>D !IR [N RACE AS SUP]IOR01 ONE CANNOT V]Y WELL DECIDE :E!R ! DEM& ( NATIVES = ! MONOPOLY ( !IR C\NTRY IS ANY MORE JU/ ?AN ! DESP]ATE NE$ ( MILLIONS ( PEOPLE :O >E SL[LY BE+ EXT]M9AT$4 

,9 CONCLUSION1 ,I WI% TO SAY ?AT MY ATTITUDE TO ! :OLE TRAGIC QUE/ION IS NOT DICTAT$ BY MY ,JEWI% ANTEC$5TS4 ,IT IS MOTIVAT$ BY MY ABHORR5CE ( 9JU/ICE1 & MAN'S 9HUMANITY TO MAN4 ,IT IS BECAUSE ( ?IS ?AT ,I HAVE F\<T ALL MY LIFE = AN>*ISM :I* ALONE WILL DO AWAY ) ! HORRORS ( ! CAPITALI/ REGIME & PLACE ALL RACES & PEOPLES1 9CLUD+ ! ,JEWS1 ON A FREE & EQUAL BASIS4 ,UNTIL !N ,I CONSID] IT HI<LY 9CONSI/5T = SOCIALI/S & AN>*I/S TO DISCRIM9ATE 9 ANY %APE OR =M AGA9/ ! ,JEWS4 

,EMMA ,GOLDMAN  

#b#f? ,AUGU/ #ai* 

,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,AUGU/ #b#f1 #ai* 3 ,ON ,ZIONISM -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,JULY #a#b1 #bai 3 ,ON ,ZIONISM -- ,ADD$4 
,JANU>Y #c1 #bbb 3 ,ON ,ZIONISM -- ,UPDAT$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/