,*APT] #f ,ECONOMIC ,DEVELOPM5T & ,SOCIALISM ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,ROSA ,LUXEMBURG ,TEXT 3 ,! GREATE/ CONQUE/ ( ! DEVELOP+ PROLET>IAN MOVEM5T HAS BE5 ! DISCOV]Y ( GR\NDS ( SUPPORT = ! REALIZATION ( SOCIALISM 9 ! ECONOMIC CONDITION ( CAPITALI/ SOCIETY4 ,AS A RESULT ( ?IS DISCOV]Y1 SOCIALISM WAS *ANG$ FROM AN 0IDEAL0 DREAM$ ( BY HUMANITY = ?\S&S ( YE>S TO A ?+ ( HI/ORIC NECESSITY4 ,B]N/E9 D5IES ! EXI/5CE ( ! ECONOMIC CONDITIONS = SOCIALISM 9 ! SOCIETY ( TODAY4 ,ON ?IS C\NT HIS REASON+ HAS UND]GONE AN 9T]E/+ EVOLUTION4 ,AT FIR/1 9 ! ,NEUE ,ZEIT1 HE SIMPLY CONTE/$ ! RAPIDITY ( ! PROCESS ( CONC5TRATION TAK+ PLACE 9 9DU/RY4 ,HE BAS$ HIS POSITION ON A COMP>ISON ( ! OCCUPATIONAL /ATI/ICS ( ,G]MANY 9 #ahhb & #a#h#i#e4 ,9 ORD] TO USE !SE FIGURES = HIS PURPOSE1 HE WAS OBLIG$ TO PROCE$ 9 AN 5TIRELY SUMM>Y & ME*ANICAL FA%ION4 ,9 ! MO/ FAVORABLE CASE1 HE C\LD NOT1 EV5 BY DEMON/RAT+ ! P]SI/5CE ( MIDDLE-SIZ$ 5T]PRISES1 WEAK5 9 ANY ! ,M>XIAN ANALYSIS BECAUSE ! LATT] DOES NOT SUPPOSE AS A CONDITION = ! REALIZATION ( SOCIALISM EI!R A DEF9ITE RATE ( CONC5TRATION ( 9DU/RY - ?AT IS1 A DEF9ITE DELAY ( ! REALIZATION ( SOCIALISM - OR1 AS WE HAVE ALREADY %[N1 ! ABSOLUTE DISAPPE>ANCE ( SMALL CAPITALS1 USUALLY DESCRIB$ AS ! DISAPPE>ANCE ( ! PETIT B\RGEOISIE4 ,9 ! C\RSE ( ! LATE/ DEVELOPM5T ( HIS IDEAS ,B]N/E9 FURNI%ES US1 9 HIS BOOK1 A NEW ASSORTM5T ( PRO(S3 ! /ATI/ICS ( %>EHOLD+ SOCIETIES4 ,!SE /ATI/ICS >E US$ 9 ORD] TO PROVE ?AT ! NUMB] ( %>EHOLD]S 9CREASES CON/ANTLY & AS A RESULT ! CAPITALI/ CLASS DOES NOT BECOME SMALL] BUT GR[S BIGG]4 ,IT IS SURPRIS+ ?AT ,B]N/E9 HAS SO LITTLE ACQUA9TANCE ) HIS MAT]IAL4 ,& IT IS A/ONI%+ H[ POORLY HE UTILIZES ! EXI/+ DATA 9 HIS [N BEHALF4 ,IF HE WANT$ TO DISPROVE ! ,M>XIAN LAW ( 9DU/RIAL DEVELOPM5T BY REF]R+ TO ! CONDITION ( %>EHOLD+ SOCIETIES1 HE %\LD HAVE RESORT$ TO 5TIRELY DIFF]5T FIGURES4 ,ANYBODY :O IS ACQUA9T$ ) ! HI/ORY ( %>EHOLD+ SOCIETIES 9 ,G]MANY KN[S ?AT !IR AV]AGE F\NDATION CAPITAL HAS DIM9I%$ ALMO/ CON/ANTLY4 ,?US :ILE BE=E #ahga !IR AV]AGE F\NDATION CAPITAL REA*$ ! FIGURE ( #a4#h MILLION M>KS1 IT WAS ONLY #d4#a MILLION M>KS 9 #a#h#g#a1 #c4#h MILLION M>KS 9 #a#h#g#c1 LESS ?AN A MILLION FROM #ahhb TO #a#h#h#g1 4#e#b MILLION 9 #ahia & ONLY 4#f#b MILLION 9 #a#h#i#b4 ,AFT] ?IS DATE ! FIGURES OSCILLAT$ >\ND #a MILLION M>KS1 FALL+ TO #a4#g#h 9 #ahie & TO #a4#a#i 9 ! C\RSE ( ! FIR/ HALF ( #a#h#i#g4 7,VAN DE ,BORE SURPRIS+ FIGURES4 ,US+ !M1 ,B]N/E9 HOP$ TO %[ ! EXI/5CE ( A C\NT]-,M>XIAN T5D5CY = RETRANS=MATION ( L>GE 5T]PRISES 9TO SMALL ONES4 ,! OBVI\S ANSW] TO HIS ATTEMPT IS ! FOLL[+4 ,IF Y\ >E TO PROVE ANY?+ AT ALL BY MEANS ( Y\R /ATI/ICS1 Y\ MU/ FIR/ %[ ?AT !Y REF] TO ! SAME BRAN*ES ( 9DU/RY4 ,Y\ MU/ NOT %[ ?AT SMALL 5T]PRISES REALLY REPLACE L>GE ONES1 ?AT !Y DO NOT4 ,9/EAD1 !Y APPE> ONLY :]E SMALL 5T]PRISES OR EV5 >TISAN 9DU/RY W]E ! RULE BE=E4 ,?IS1 H[EV]1 Y\ CANNOT %[ TO BE TRUE4 ,! /ATI/ICAL PASSAGE ( IMM5SE %>EHOLD+ SOCIETIES TO MIDDLE-SIZE & SMALL 5T]PRISES CAN BE EXPLA9$ ONLY BY REF]R+ TO ! FACT ?AT ! SY/EM ( %>EHOLD+ SOCIETIES CONT9UES TO P5ETRATE NEW BRAN*ES ( PRODUCTION4 ,BE=E1 ONLY A SMALL NUMB] ( L>GE 5T]PRISES W]E ORGANIZ$ AS %>EHOLD+ SOCIETIES4 ,GRADUALLY %>EHOLD+ ORGANIZATION HAS WON MIDDLE-SIZE & EV5 SMALL 5T]PRISES4 ,TODAY WE CAN OBS]VE %>EHOLD+ SOCIETIES ) A CAPITAL ( BEL[ #a1 M>KS4 ,N[1 :AT IS ! ECONOMIC SIGNIFICANCE ( ! EXT5SION ( ! SY/EM ( %>EHOLD+ SOCIETIES8 ,ECONOMICALLY1 ! SPREAD ( %>EHOLD+ SOCIETIES /&S = ! GR[+ SOCIALIZATION ( PRODUCTION UND] ! CAPITALI/ =M - SOCIALIZATION NOT ONLY ( L>GE BUT ALSO ( MIDDLE-SIZE & SMALL PRODUCTION4 ,! EXT5SION ( %>EHOLD+ DOES NOT1 !RE=E1 CONTRADICT ,M>XI/ !ORY BUT ON ! CONTR>Y1 CONFIRMS IT EMPHATICALLY4 ,:AT DOES ! ECONOMIC PH5OM5ON ( A %>EHOLD+ SOCIETY ACTUALLY AM\NT TO8 ,IT REPRES5TS1 ON ! ONE H&1 ! UNIFICATION ( A NUMB] ( SMALL =TUNES 9TO A L>GE CAPITAL ( PRODUCTION4 ,IT /&S1 ON ! O!R H&1 = ! SEP>ATION ( PRODUCTION FROM CAPITALI/ [N]%IP4 ,?AT IS1 IT D5OTES ?AT A D\BLE VICTORY BE+ WON OV] ! CAPITALI/ MODE ( PRODUCTION - BUT /ILL ON A CAPITALI/ BASE4 ,:AT IS ! MEAN+1 !RE=E1 ( ! /ATI/ICS CIT$ BY ,B]N/E9 ACCORD+ TO :I* AN EV]-GREAT] NUMB] ( %>EHOLD]S P>TICIPATE 9 CAPITALI/ 5T]PRISES8 ,!SE /ATI/ICS GO ON TO DEMON/RATE PRECISELY ! FOLL[+3 AT PRES5T A CAPITALI/ 5T]PRISE DOES NOT CORRESPOND1 AS BE=E1 TO A S+LE PROPRIETOR ( CAPITAL BUT TO A NUMB] ( CAPITALI/S4 ,CONSEQU5TLY1 ! ECONOMIC NOTION ( 0CAPITALI/0 NO LONG] SIGNIFIES AN ISOLAT$ 9DIVIDUAL4 ,! 9DU/RIAL CAPITALI/ ( TODAY IS A COLLECTIVE P]SON COMPOS$ ( HUNDR$S & EV5 ( ?\S&S ( 9DIVIDUALS4 ,! CATEGORY 0CAPITALI/0 HAS ITSELF BECOME A SOCIAL CATEGORY4 ,IT HAS BECOME 0SOCIALIZ$0 - )9 ! FRAME-WORK ( CAPITALI/ SOCIETY4 ,9 ?AT CASE1 H[ %ALL WE EXPLA9 ,B]N/E9'S BELIEF ?AT ! PH5OM5ON ( %>E-HOLD+ SOCIETIES /&S = ! DISP]SION & NOT ! CONC5TRATION ( CAPITAL8 ,:Y DOES HE SEE ! EXT5SION ( CAPITALI/ PROP]TY :]E ,M>X SAW ITS SUPPRESSION8 ,?AT IS A SIMPLE ECONOMIC ]ROR4 ,BY 0CAPITALI/10 ,B]N/E9 DOES NOT MEAN A CATEGORY ( PRODUCTION BUT ! RIGE NUMB] ( %>E FROM /OCKHOLD] ,MUELL] IS ALSO A CAPITALI/ = ,B]N/E94 ,?AT IS :Y = ,B]N/E9 ! 5TIRE WORLD SEEMS TO SW>M ) CAPITALI/S4 ,H]E TOO1 ! !ORETIC BASE ( HIS ECONOMIC ]ROR IS HIS 0POPUL>IZATION0 ( SOCIALISM4 ,= ?IS IS :AT HE DOES4 ,BY TRANSPORT+ ! CONCEPT ( CAPITALISM FROM ITS PRODUCTIVE RELATIONS TO PROP]TY RELATIONS1 & BY SPEAK+ ( SIMPLE 9DIVIDUALS 9/EAD ( SPEAK+ ( 5TREPR5EURS1 HE MOVES ! QUE/ION ( SOCIALISM FROM ! DOMA9 ( PRODUCTION 9TO ! DOMA9 ( RELATIONS ( =TUNE - ?AT IS1 FROM ! RELATION BETWE5 ,CAPITAL & ,LABOR TO ! RELATION BETWE5 POOR & RI*4 ,9 ?IS MANN] WE >E M]RILY L$ FROM ,M>X & ,5GELS TO ! AU?OR ( ! ,EVANGEL ( ! ,POOR ,FI%]MAN4 ,!RE IS ?IS DIFF]5CE1 H[EV]4 ,WEITL+1 ) ! SURE 9/9CT ( ! PROLET>IAN1 SAW 9 ! OPPOSITION BETWE5 ! POOR & ! RI*1 ! CLASS ANTAGONISMS 9 !IR PRIMITIVE =M1 & WANT$ TO MAKE ( !SE ANTAGONISMS A LEV] ( ! MOVEM5T = SOCIALISM4 ,B]N/E91 ON ! O!R H&1 LOCATES ! REALIZATION ( SOCIALISM 9 ! POSSIBILITY ( MAK+ ! POOR RI*4 ,?AT IS1 HE LOCATES IT 9 ! ATT5UATION ( CLASS ANTAGONISMS & !RE=E 9 ! PETTY B\RGEOISIE4 ,TRUE1 ,B]N/E9 DOES NOT LIMIT HIMSELF TO ! /ATI/ICS ( 9COMES4 ,HE FURNI%ES /ATI/ICS ( ECONOMIC 5T]PRISES1 ESPECIALLY ?OSE ( ! FOLL[+ C\NTRIES3 ,G]MANY1 ,FRANCE1 ,5GL&1 ,SWITZ]L&1 ,AU/RIA & ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES4 ,BUT !SE /ATI/ICS >E NOT ! COMP>ATIVE FIGURES ( DIFF]5T P]IODS 9 EA* C\NTRY BUT ( EA* P]IOD 9 DIFF]5T C\NTRIES4 ,WE >E NOT !RE=E (F]$ 7) ! EXCEPTION ( ,G]MANY :]E HE REPEATS ! OLD CONTRA/ BETWE5 #ahie & #a#h#i#b71 A COMP>ISON ( ! /ATI/ICS ( 5T]PRISES ( A GIV5 C\NTRY AT DIFF]5T EPO*S BUT ! ABSOLUTE FIGURES = DIFF]5T C\NTRIES3 ,5GL& 9 #a#h#i#a1 ,FRANCE 9 #a#h#i#d1 ,UNIT$ ,/ATES 9 #a#h#i1 ETC4 ,HE REA*ES ! FOLL[+ CONCLUSION3 0,?\< IT IS TRUE ?AT L>GE EXPLOITATION IS ALREADY SUPREME 9 9DU/RY TODAY1 IT NEV]!LESS1 REPRES5TS1 9CLUD+ ! 5T]PRISES DEP5D5T ON L>GE EXPLOITATION1 EV5 9 A C\NTRY AS DEVELOP$ 9 ,PRUSSIA1 ONLY HALF ( ! POPULATION OCCUPI$ 9 PRODUCTION40 ,?IS IS ALSO TRUE AB\T ,G]MANY1 ,5GL&1 ,BELGIUM1 ETC4 ,:AT DOES HE ACTUALLY PROVE H]E8 ,HE PROVES NOT ! EXI/5CE ( SU* OR SU* A T5D5CY ( ECONOMIC DEVELOPM5T BUT M]ELY ! ABSOLUTE RELATION ( =CES ( DIFF]5T =MS ( 5T]PRISE1 OR PUT 9 O!R WORDS1 ! ABSOLUTE RELATIONS ( ! V>I\S CLASSES 9 \R SOCIETY4 ,N[ IF ONE WANTS TO PROVE 9 ?IS MANN] ! IMPOSSIBILITY ( REALIZ+ SOCIALISM ONE'S REASON+ MU/ RE/ ON ! !ORY ACCORD+ TO :I* ! RESULT ( SOCIAL EF=TS IS DECID$ BY ! RELATION ( ! NUM]ICAL MAT]IAL =CES ( ! ELEM5TS 9 ! /RUGGLE1 ?AT IS1 BY ! FACTOR ( VIOL5CE4 ,9 O!R WORDS1 ,B]N/E91 :O ALWAYS ?UND]S AGA9/ ,BLANQUISM .<,SEE3 ,L\IS ,BLANQUI.>1 HIMSELF FALLS 9TO ! GROSSE/ ,BLANQUI/ ]ROR4 ,!RE IS ?IS DIFF]5CE1 H[EV]4 ,TO ! ,BLANQUI/S1 :O REPRES5T$ A SOCIALI/ & REVOLUTION>Y T5D5CY1 ! POSSIBILITY ( ! ECONOMIC REALIZATION ( SOCIALISM APPE>$ QUITE NATURAL4 ,ON ?IS POSSIBILITY !Y BUILT ! *ANCES ( A VIOL5T REVOLUTION - EV5 BY A SMALL M9ORITY4 ,B]N/E91 ON ! CONTR>Y1 9F]S FROM ! NUM]ICAL 9SUFFICI5CY ( A SOCIALI/ MAJORITY1 ! IMPOSSIBILITY ( ! ECONOMIC REALIZATION ( SOCIALISM4 ,! ,SOCIAL-,DEMOCRACY DOES NOT1 H[EV]1 EXPECT TO ATTA9 ITS AIM EI!R AS A RESULT ( ! VICTORI\S VIOL5CE ( A M9ORITY OR ?R\< ! NUM]ICAL SUP]IORITY ( A MAJORITY4 ,IT SEES SOCIALISM COME AS A RESULT ( ECONOMIC NECESSITY - & ! COMPREH5SION ( ?AT NECESSITY - LEAD+ TO ! SUPPRESSION ( CAPITALISM BY ! WORK+ MASSES4 ,& ?IS NECESSITY MANIFE/S ITSELF ABOVE ALL 9 ! AN>*Y ( CAPITALISM4 ,:AT IS ,B]N/E9'S POSITION ON ! DECISIVE QUE/ION ( AN>*Y 9 CAPITALI/ ECONOMY8 ,HE D5IES ONLY ! GREAT G5]AL CRISES4 ,HE DOES NOT D5Y P>TIAL & NATIONAL CRISES4 ,9 O!R WORDS1 HE REFUSES TO SEE A GREAT DEAL ( ! AN>*Y ( CAPITALISM2 HE SEES ONLY A LITTLE ( IT4 ,HE IS - TO USE ,M>X'S ILLU/RATION - LIKE ! FOOLI% VIRG9 :O HAD A *ILD 0:O WAS ONLY V]Y SMALL40 ,BUT ! MIS=TUNE IS ?AT 9 MATT]S LIKE ECONOMIC AN>*Y LITTLE & MU* >E EQUALLY BAD4 ,IF ,B]N/E9 RECOGNIZES ! EXI/5CE ( A LITTLE ( ?IS AN>*Y1 WE MAY PO9T \T TO HIM ?AT BY ! ME*ANISM ( ! M>KET ECONOMY ?IS BIT ( AN>*Y WILL BE EXT5D$ TO UNHE>D ( PROPORTIONS1 TO 5D 9 COLLAPSE4 ,BUT IF ,B]N/E9 HOPES TO TRANS=M GRADUALLY HIS BIT ( AN>*Y 9TO ORD] & H>MONY :ILE MA9TA9+ ! SY/EM ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION1 HE AGA9 FALLS 9TO ONE ( ! FUNDAM5TAL ]RORS ( B\RGEOIS POLITICAL ECONOMY ACCORD+ TO :I* ! MODE ( EX*ANGE IS 9DEP5D5T ( ! MODE ( PRODUCTION4 ,?IS IS NOT ! PLACE = A L5G?Y DEMON/RATION ( ,B]N/E9'S SURPRIS+ CONFUSION CONC]N+ ! MO/ ELEM5T>Y PR9CIPLES ( POLITICAL ECONOMY4 ,BUT !RE IS ONE PO9T - TO :I* WE >E L$ BY ! FUNDAM5TAL QUE/IONS ( CAPITALI/ AN>*Y - ?AT MU/ BE CL>IFI$ IMM$IATELY4 ,B]N/E9 DECL>ES ?AT ,M>X'S LAW ( SURPLUS VALUE IS A SIMPLE AB/RACTION4 ,9 POLITICAL ECONOMY A /ATEM5T ( ?IS SORT OBVI\SLY CON/ITUTES AN 9SULT4 ,BUT IF SURPLUS VALUE IS ONLY A SIMPLE AB/RACTION1 IF IT IS ONLY A FIGM5T ( ! M9D - !N EV]Y NORMAL CITIZ5 :O HAS DONE MILIT>Y DUTY & PAYS HIS TAXES ON TIME HAS ! SAME RIL ,M>X TO FA%ION HIS 9DIVIDUAL ABSURDITY1 TO MAKE HIS [N LAW ( VALUE4 0,M>X HAS AS MU* RIE NO MORE ?AN ! 9C>NATION ( QUANTITIES ( SIMPLE HUMAN LABOR AS HAVE ! ECONOMI/S ( ! ,BOHMM-,JEVONS S*OOL TO MAKE AN AB/RACTION ( ALL ! QUALITIES ( COMMODITIES \TSIDE ( !IR UTILITY40 ,?AT IS1 TO ,B]N/E91 ,M>X'S SOCIAL LABOR & ,M5G]'S AB/RACT UTILITY >E QUITE SIMIL> - PURE AB/RACTIONS4 ,B]N/E9 =GETS COMPLETELY ?AT ,M>X'S AB/RACTION IS NOT AN 9V5TION4 ,IT IS A DISCOV]Y4 ,IT DOES NOT EXI/ 9 ,M>X'S HEAD BUT 9 M>KET ECONOMY4 ,IT HAS NOT AN IMAG9>Y EXI/5CE1 BUT A REAL SOCIAL EXI/5CE1 SO REAL ?AT IT CAN BE CUT1 HAMM]$1 WEI<$ & PUT 9 ! =M ( ! MONEY4 ,! AB/RACT HUMAN LABOR DISCOV]$ BY ,M>X IS1 9 ITS DEVELOP$ =M1 NO O!R ?AN MONEY4 ,?AT IS PRECISELY ONE ( ! GREATE/ ( ,M>X'S DISCOV]IES1 :ILE TO ALL B\RGEOIS POLITICAL ECONOMI/S1 FROM ! FIR/ ( ! M]CANTILI/S TO ! LA/ ( ! CLASSICI/S1 ! ESS5CE ( MONEY HAS REMA9$ A MY/IC 5IGMA4 ,! ,BOEHM-,JEVONS AB/RACT UTILITY IS1 9 FACT1 A CONCEIT ( ! M9D4 ,OR /AT$ MORE CORRECTLY1 IT IS A REPRES5TATION ( 9TELLECTUAL EMPT9ESS1 A PRIVATE ABSURDITY1 = :I* NEI!R CAPITALISM NOR ANY O!R SOCIETY CAN BE MADE RESPONSIBLE1 BUT ONLY VULG> B\RGEOIS ECONOMY ITSELF4 ,HUGG+ !IR BRA9-*ILD1 ,B]N/E91 ,BOHMM & ,JEVONS1 & ! 5TIRE SUBJECTIVE FRAT]NITY1 CAN REMA9 TW5TY YE>S OR MORE BE=E ! MY/]Y ( MONEY1 )\T >RIV+ AT A SOLUTION ?AT IS DIFF]5T FROM ! ONE REA*$ BY ANY COBBL]1 NAMELY ?AT MONEY IS ALSO A 0USEFUL0 ?+4 ,B]N/E9 HAS LO/ ALL COMPREH5SION ( ,M>X'S LAW ( VALUE4 ,ANYBODY ) A SMALL UND]/&+ ( ,M>XIAN ECONOMICS CAN SEE ?AT )\T ! LAW ( VALUE1 ,M>X'S DOCTR9E IS 9COMPREH5SIBLE4 ,OR TO SPEAK MORE CONCRETELY - = HIM :O DOES NOT UND]/& ! NATURE ( ! COMMODITY & ITS EX*ANGE ! 5TIRE ECONOMY ( CAPITALISM1 ) ALL ITS CONCAT5ATIONS1 MU/ ( NECESSITY REMA9 AN 5IGMA4 ,:AT PRECISELY WAS ! KEY :I* 5ABL$ ,M>X TO OP5 ! DOOR TO ! SECRETS ( CAPITALI/ PH5OM5A & SOLVE1 AS IF 9 PLAY1 PROBLEMS ?AT W]E NOT EV5 SUSPECT$ BY ! GREATE/ M9DS ( CLASSIC B\RGEOIS ECONOMY8 ,IT WAS HIS CONCEPTION ( CAPITALI/ ECONOMY AS AN HI/ORIC PH5OM5ON - NOT M]ELY 9 ! S5SE RECOGNIZ$ 9 ! BE/ ( CASES BY ! CLASSIC ECONOMI/S1 ?AT IS1 :5 IT CONC]NS ! FEUDAL PA/ ( CAPITALISM - BUT ALSO 9 SO F> AS IT CONC]NS ! SOCIALI/ FUTURE ( ! WORLD4 ,! SECRET ( ,M>X'S !ORY ( VALUE1 ( HIS ANALYSIS ( ! PROBLEM ( MONEY1 ( HIS !ORY ( CAPITAL1 ( ! !ORY ( ! RATE ( PR(IT & CONSEQU5TLY ( ! 5TIRE EXI/+ ECONOMIC SY/EM IS F\ND 9 ! TRANSITORY *>ACT] ( CAPITALI/ ECONOMY1 ! 9EVITABILITY ( ITS COLLAPSE LEAD+ - & ?IS IS ONLY ANO!R ASPECT ( ! SAME PH5OM5ON - TO SOCIALISM4 ,IT IS ONLY BECAUSE ,M>X LOOK$ AT CAPITALISM FROM ! SOCIALI/'S VIEWPO9T1 ?AT IS FROM ! HI/ORIC VIEWPO9T1 ?AT HE WAS 5ABL$ TO DECIPH] ! HI]OGLYPHICS ( CAPITALI/ ECONOMY4 ,& IT IS PRECISELY BECAUSE HE TOOK ! SOCIALI/ VIEWPO9T AS A PO9T ( DEP>TURE = HIS ANALYSIS ( B\RGEOIS SOCIETY ?AT HE WAS 9 ! POSITION TO GIVE A SCI5TIFIC BASE TO ! SOCIALI/ MOVEM5T4 ,?IS IS ! MEASURE BY :I* WE EVALUATE ,B]N/E9'S REM>KS4 ,HE COMPLA9S ( ! 0DUALISM0 F\ND EV]Y:]E 9 ,M>X'S MONUM5TAL ,CAPITAL4 0,! WORK WI%ES TO BE A SCI5TIFIC /UDY & PROVE1 AT ! SAME TIME1 A !SIS ?AT WAS COMPLETELY ELABORAT$ A LONG TIME BE=E ! $IT+ ( ! BOOK2 IT IS BAS$ ON A S*EMA ?AT ALREADY CONTA9S ! RESULT TO :I* HE WANTS TO LEAD4 ,! RETURN TO ! ,COMMUNI/ ,MANIFE/O 7?AT IS ! SOCIALI/ GOAL6 - ,R4,L471 PROVES ! EXI/5CE ( VE/IGES ( UTOPIANISM 9 ,M>X'S DOCTR9E40 ,BUT :AT IS ,M>X'S 0DUALISM0 IF NOT ! DUALISM ( ! SOCIALI/ FUTURE & ! CAPITALI/ PRES5T8 ,IT IS ! DUALISM ( ,CAPITALISM & ,LABOR1 ! DUALISM ( ! B\RGEOISIE & ! PROLET>IAT4 ,IT IS ! SCI5TIFIC REFLECTION ( ! DUALISM EXI/+ 9 B\RGEOIS SOCIETY1 ! DUALISM ( ! CLASS ANTAGONISM WRI?+ 9SIDE ! SOCIAL ORD] ( CAPITALISM4 ,B]N/E9'S RECOGNITION ( ?IS !ORETIC DUALISM 9 ,M>X AS 0A SURVIVAL ( UTOPIANISM0 IS REALLY HIS NAIVE AV[AL ?AT HE D5IES ! CLASS ANTAGONISMS 9 CAPITALISM4 ,IT IS HIS CONFESSION ?AT SOCIALISM HAS BECOME = HIM ONLY A 0SURVIVAL ( UTOPIANISM40 ,:AT IS ,B]N/E9'S 0MONISM0 - ,B]N/E9'S UNITY - BUT ! ET]NAL UNITY ( ! CAPITALI/ REGIME1 ! UNITY ( ! =M] SOCIALI/ :O HAS R5\NC$ HIS AIM & HAS DECID$ TO F9D 9 B\RGEOIS SOCIETY1 ONE & IMMUTABLE1 ! GOAL ( HUMAN DEVELOPM5T8 ,B]N/E9 DOES NOT SEE 9 ! ECONOMIC /RUCTURE ( CAPITALISM ! DEVELOPM5T ?AT LEADS TO SOCIALISM4 ,BUT 9 ORD] TO CONS]VE HIS SOCIALI/ PROGRAM1 AT LEA/ 9 =M1 HE IS OBLIG$ TO TAKE REFUGE 9 AN IDEALI/ CON/RUCTION PLAC$ \TSIDE ( ALL ECONOMIC DEVELOPM5T4 ,HE IS OBLIG$ TO TRANS=M SOCIALISM ITSELF FROM A DEF9ITE HI/ORICAL PHASE ( SOCIAL DEVELOPM5T 9TO AN AB/RACT 0PR9CIPLE40 ,?AT IS :Y ! 0COOP]ATIVE PR9CIPLE0 - ! MEAG] DECANTATION ( SOCIALISM BY :I* ,B]N/E9 WI%ES TO G>NI% CAPITALI/ ECONOMY - APPE>S AS A CONCESSION MADE NOT TO ! SOCIALI/ FUTURE ( SOCIETY BUT TO ,B]N/E9'S [N SOCIALI/ PA/4 ,FROM 3 ,M>XI/S4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,M>* #e1 #bba 3 ,*APT] #f -- ,ADD$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/