,REVOLUTION>Y ,=CES #aiba ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,SEBA/I5 ,FAURE ,TAGS 3 SPIRIT ( SOCIAL TRANS=MATION1 =CES ( REVOLUTION1 TRADE UNIONISM1 SOCIALI/ P>TY1 NATURAL GR\P+1 SOCIAL PROJECTS1 SOCIAL SY/EM1 SOCIAL =MS1 SOCIAL =CES1 FREE-?\RY ,GAMBONE ,PHOTO BY ,GONZALE1,C,C ,B,Y-,N,C ,LIC5SE ,COMRADES1 ,I EXPLA9$ - QUICKLY1 BUT 9 A SUFFICI5T WAY - ! FIR/ P>T ( LIB]T>IAN ,COMMUNISM1 ! CRITICAL1 NEGATIVE P>T &1 ,I HOPE ?AT ,I MANAG$ TO CONV9CE Y\ ?AT MIS]Y1 IGNORANCE1 HATR$1 REPRESSION1 SUFF]+ 9 ALL ITS =MS1 IS ! FATAL RESULT ( ! SOCIAL BACKGR\ND 9 :I* WE LIVE4 ,IF1 AS ,I HOPE1 Y\ >RIV$ AT ?IS CONVICTION1 Y\ MU/ ALSO BE CONV9C$ ( ! NE$ & ! URG5CY TO PUT AN 5D TO A SOCIAL SY/EM :I* G5]ATES SU* PA9S4 ,IT IS PRECISELY :AT WE WILL BEG9 TO /UDY ?IS EV5+4 ,IT IS NECESS>Y TO DE/ROY ! E/ABLI%$ SOCIAL ORD] S9CE IT IS G5]AT+ SUFF]+S1 9EQUALITIES1 9JU/ICES & MIS]IES4 ,IT %\LD BE DE/ROY$ AT ALL CO/S2 IT %\LD BE DE/ROY$ AS SOON AS POSSIBLE2 IT %\LD BE DE/ROY$ ROOT & BRAN*4 ,H]E >E T]MS ( ! PROBLEM ?AT IT IS NECESS>Y = US TO SOLVE3 S9CE ! CURR5T SOCIAL =MS >E 9 =MAL CONTRADICTION ) ! NE$S ( ! H\R & ! ASPIRATIONS ( ! PRES5T G5]ATION1 !SE SOCIAL =MS MU/ DISAPPE>4 ,:I* >E ! =CES WE CAN PUT 9 L9E & OPPOSE TO ! SOCIAL =CES :I* MA9TA9 ! CURR5T SITUATION8 ,:AT SPIRIT MU/ ANIMATE ! MILITANTS :O CON/ITUTE !SE VA/ ORGANIZATIONS ?AT ,I CALL ! =CES ( REVOLUTION8 ,:I* IS ! GOAL ( EA* ONE ( !SE ORGANIZATIONS1 ( EA* ONE ( !SE =CES8 ,IS IT POSSIBLE1 :]EAS EA* ONE IS 9DEP5D5T1 AUTONOM\S1 HAV+ ITS DOCTR9ES1 PR9CIPLES1 ME?ODS1 TACTICS1 TO JO9 !M TOGE!R 9 A COMMON BLOCK TO CON/ITUTE ! BLOCK ( ! ,REVOLUTION8 ,SU* IS ! PROBLEM ?AT WE WILL BE POS$ & ?AT WE HAVE TO SOLVE4 ,IT IS CLE>4 ,!RE=E1 ON :I* =CES CAN WE SUPPORT \R ACTION8 ,!SE =CES >E AS FOLL[S3 ,FREE-?\TY1 ,TRADE ,UNIONISM1 ! ,COOP]ATIVES1 ,AN>*ISM4 ,I SPEAK OBVI\SLY ONLY AB\T ! L>GE CURR5TS1 ! P[]FUL ORGANIZATIONS4 ,I AM OBLIG$ TO SOME:AT NEGLECT A CR[D ( GR\PS :I* H[EV] HAVE !IR V]Y GREAT UTILITY 9 A MASS MOVEM5T4 ,I WILL !N EXAM9E !M ALL444 ,F,R,E,E-,?,\,<,T ,9ITIALLY1 IT C\LD APPE> UNUSUAL ?AT ,I REG>D AS A =CE ( ,REVOLUTION ! FREE-?\S6 ,IT FELL 9TO ?IS MESS FROM ! ELECTORAL GAME PLAY+4 ,IT WAS US$ AS SPR+BO>D ) QUANTITY ( PR(ITE]S :O ?\TY4 ,! ,SOCIALI/ ,P>TY ORGANIZES ON ! POLITICAL GR\ND ! WORK+ MASS & ITS FRI5DS4 ,I ADD ) 9T5TION 0FRI5DS01 BECAUSE !RE IS NOT1 9 ! ,SOCIALI/ ,P>TY1 ANY WORK+M54 ,! ,SOCIALI/ ,P>TY PLACES ! ECONOMIC PROBLEM AT ! HEAD ( ITS CONC]NS2 ,I WILL EV5 SAY ?AT ! ,SOCIALI/ DOCTR9ES >E BE=E ALL ECONOMIC DOCTR9ES4 ,! ,SOCIALI/S KN[ ?AT UND] CAPITALISM1 ! ECONOMIC SITUATION DOM9ATES ! POLITICAL SITUATION1 ?AT ! AU?ORITIES >E ONLY ! POLITICAL EXPRESSION ( ! ECONOMIC P[] ( ! B\RGEOISIE444 ,SIMPLY1 ! ,SOCIALI/ ,P>TY SAYS3 0,!RE >E TWO ORGANIZATIONS3 A SPECIFICALLY WORK] &1 CONSEQU5TLY1 SPECIFICALLY ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION1 ! ,G5]AL ,CONF$]ATION ( ,LABOR 7,C,G,T $47 2 IT ?US RE/S ) ! ,SOCIALI/ ,P>TY TO REPRES5T ! POLITICAL EF=T 9 ! GREAT MOVEM5T :I* PU%ES HUMANITY T[>DS NEW DE/9Y40 ,JU/ AS TRADE UNIONISM IS TO PUT ! H& ON ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION & EX*ANGE1 9 ! SAME WAY ! PURPOSE ( ! ,SOCIALI/ ,P>TY IS TO TAKE POSSESSION1 BY ALL ( ! MEANS1 ( ,GOV]NM5T1 ! ,/ATE1 ( ,AU?ORITY4 ,I KNEW A BRIEF ?IRTY-FIVE YE>S AGO -- ?AT DOES NOT MAKE ME Y\NG P]SON - A ,SOCIALI/ ,P>TY :I* WAS !N LIKE ME1 FULL ( HEAT1 FULL ( >DOR4 ,I KEPT M9E SOME:AT4 ,ALAS6 ,! ,SOCIALI/S LO/ ALMO/ ALL ( !IRS4 ,?AT MOM5T1 ONE DID NOT SPLIT HAIRS2 ! SOCIAL SY/EM WAS F\TY WAS !N IMPETU\SLY REVOLUTION>Y4 ,IT WAS Y\NG4 ,ALAS6 ,IT AG$444IT BECAME OLD & SOME:AT PETTY B\RGEOIS4 7,FAURE !N LAYS \T H[ ! P>TY FELL 9TO M9I/]IALISM1 COMPROMISE1 WEAK-KNE$ RE=MISM ALL AS A RESULT ( P>LIAM5T>IANISM4 ,HE ALSO NOTES H[ SOME MEMB]S 9SPIR$ BY ! EXAMPLE ( ! ,RUSSIAN ,REVOLUTION SEEK TO RE-9VIGORATE ! ,P>TY & SEES HOPE !RE4 $47 ,ANO!R CONSID]ABLE =CE ( REVOLUTION1 IS TRADE UNIONISM4 ,TRADE UNIONISM GR\PS ! WORK]S SPECIFICALLY ON AN ECONOMIC BASIS4 ,TRADE UNIONISM HAS A V]Y P>TICUL> ADVANTAGE3 IT IS A NATURAL GR\P+1 & :I* ,I WILL TO SOME EXT5T DESCRIBE AS 9/9CTIVE4 ,A GR\P+ MADE UP NOT BY HET]OG5E\S ELEM5TS1 BUT1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 BY HOMOG5E\S ELEM5TS4 ,!RE >E1 )9 TRADE UNIONISM1 ! EMPLOYES1 M5 ON :I* ! LIFE DEP5DS ON AN [N]1 OR A DIRECTOR1 OR AN ADM9I/RATION1 & :O1 CONSEQU5TLY1 BELONG TRULY BY !IR SITUATION1 BY !IR DAILY LABOR TO ! WORK+ CLASS4 ,!RE IS A V]Y SPECIAL ADVANTAGE 9 ?IS FACT ?AT TRADE UNIONISM IS A NATURAL GR\P+1 9/9CTIVE1 HOMOG5E\S1 ,:5 ANIMALS - & WE >E ONLY ANIMALS HAV+ ! CLAIM TO BE HI<] ANIMALS1 BUT ,I AM NOT ( C\RSE CLE> ?AT ?IS CLAIM IS JU/IFI$1 - :5 ANIMALS >E ?REAT5$1 !Y APPROA* EA* O!R4 ,!Y DO NOT NE$ TO GIVE EA* O!R ! WORD444 ,IT IS 5\< ?AT ! 5EMY IS !RE & !N1 IMM$IATELY1 ALL ! ANTS1 ALL ! BEES1 ALL ! BIRDS :I* =M TO P>T ( ! SAME SPECIES1 ( ! SAME FAMILY1 FEEL+ A DANG] TO ?REAT5 !M1 ALL GET TOGE!R1 >E L9K$1 & ?US IS CREAT$ A =CE ALL[+ RESI/ANCE & 9CALCULABLE DEF5SE4 ,TRADE UNIONISM IS ?IS NATURAL GR\P+1 AN 9/9CTIVE ASSOCIATION AGA9/ ! 5EMY :O IS1 ! [N]1 ! EXPLOIT]1 ! CAPITALI/444 ,TRADE UNIONISM IS GOV]N$ BY ! LEGISLATION ( #a#h#h#d1 :OSE AU?OR IS ,WALDECK-,R\SSEAU4 ,DO NOT BELIEVE H[EV]1 ?AT TRADE UNIONI/S & GUILDS ONLY GO BACK TO ?IS TIME4 ,!Y W]E !RE BE=E HIM1 &1 H]E LIKE ALWAYS1 ! LEGISLATOR SIMPLY RECOGNIZ$ !M 9 ORD] TO REGULATE1 TO *ANNEL1 TO HOLD IT 9 SOME WAY UND] HIS DEP5D5CE1 HIS DOM9ATION1 ! MOVEM5T :I* EXI/$ ALREADY4 ,ONLY1 HI!RTO1 ! LABOR MOVEM5T WAS ABSOLUTELY GUILD LIKE2 EA* GR\P HAD SPECIAL CLAIMS CONC]N+ ITS WORK+ CONDITIONS1 ITS HABITS1 ACCORD+ TO ! PLACES OR ! TYPE ( WORK OR 9DU/RY4 ,ONE OCCUPI$ ONESELF V]Y LITTLE ) ONE'S NEI*O-SYNDICALISM --- CLASS /RUGGLE UNITY1 F$]ALISM1 DIRECT ACTION1 ABOLITION ( ! WAGE SY/EM4 $47 ,?US CONCEIV$ & PRACTIC$1 :AT A =CE ( REVOLUTION TRADE UNIONISM C\LD BE6 ,H]E AS 9 ! ,SOCIALI/ ,P>TY1 WE ALSO AWAIT AN EF=T ( GOODWILL A*IEV$ BY A C]TA9 NUMB] ( M5 :O HAVE ! RESOLUTION TO RETURN TO ! TRADE UNIONISM ( PRE-W> P]IOD1 TO RETURN TO CLASS /RUGGLE TRADE UNIONISM1 ) DIRECT ACTION1 ! =M] REVOLUTION>Y TRADE UNIONISM4 ,H]E /ILL1 ,I SAY3 ,BRAVO6 ,I ASSI/ ) GREAT JOY1 ?IS MOVEM5T ( RECTIFICATION2 & 9 ! WEAK MEASUREM5T ( MY MEANS ,I AM V]Y READY TO GIVE MY SUPPORT1 IF AS WELL IS AS IT CAN HAVE SOME UTILITY1 ) ?OSE :I* MAKE EF=T 9 ?IS DIRECTION4 ,ONLY1 ,I WILL ALL[ MYSELF TO GIVE !M A C\NCIL ( C]TA9 DANG]S4 ,IT IS NOT A QUE/ION1 9 A MOVEM5T AS VA/ AS ! TRADE UNIONISM1 TO MODIFY ! P]SONNEL1 TO *ANGE PURELY & SIMPLY ! M54 ,IF Y\ *ANGE ONLY ! M51 Y\ WILL NOT HAVE DONE ANY?+1 ,9 FACT ! ME?ODS MU/ BE *ANG$1 ,IF ! MA*9E SQUEAKS1 IF IT DOES NOT FUNCTION WELL1 IF IT DOES NOT MOVE T[>DS ! GOAL2 IF IT DOES NOT C>RY \T :AT IT MU/ C>RY \T1 IT IS NECESS>Y TO SEE FROM :I* ?IS DEFECT COMES FROM ! MA*9E1 9 ORD] TO BR+ ! REM$Y NECESS>Y1 ESS5TIAL !RE4 ,IT IS NOT 9 ! M5 ?AT ! VISE ( ! TRADE UNIONISM RESIDES4 ,TODAY1 TRADE UNIONISM BECAME A P[]FUL MA*9E &1 BECAUSE ( ?IS =MIDABLE P[]1 IT TOOK ON A MASSIVE1 HEAVY1 *>ACT]4 ,IT SUFF]S FROM A C5TRALISM :I* MOVES IT AWAY FROM ! F$]ALI/ BASE ?AT ,PELL\TI] CREAT$4 ,?IS C5TRALISM REQUIRES A =MIDABLE >MY ( BUREAUCRATS4 ,& SEE SOMETIMES LANGUAGE IS 5\< TO 9DICATE A :OLE SITUATION3 !Y >E CALL$ ! 0P]MAN5T ONES01 :I* WANTS TO SAY ?AT !Y >E !RE P]MAN5TLY & 5CRU/ !MSELVES !RE SO A LONG TIME ?AT ONE CANNOT GET RID ( !M4 444,:5 !Y REMA9$ FIVE YE>S1 T5 YE>S 9 ! SAME FUNCTION1 !Y BECAME1 TO SOME EXT5T1 BUREAUCRATS1 CIVIL S]VANTS ( ! ,C4,G4,T41 NOT GO+ TO ! 0JOB04 ,!IR H&S 5D UP BECOM+ :ITE2 NOT MANIPULAT+ TOOLS1 !Y DO NOT KN[ ANY MORE ! VICISSITUDES ( ! WORK]S4444 ,!Y CAN LET PASS UNEMPLOYM5T1 !IR POSITION DOESN'T *ANGE1 !Y EAT NEV]!LESS4 ,!Y >E TO SOME EXT5T A WORK] >I/OCRACY444 ,9T]RUPTION3 0,BUT :AT WILL ONE PUT 9 !IR PLACE80 ,H]E IS A COMRADE :O ASKS ME3 0,:AT ONE WILL PUT !IR PLACE80 ,IF Y\ WANT TO UND]/& ME LI/5 MORE ATT5TIVELY ?AN ?IS COMRADE1 OR IT W\LD BE BETT] REALLY ?AT ,I CEAS$ SPEAK+ ALTOGE!R4 ,I ALREADY SAID & REPEAT$ ?AT IT IS NOT A QUE/ION ( *ANG+ ! M5 & ?AT IF Y\ *ANGE SIMPLY ?AT )\T TRANS=M+ & AM5D+1 Y\ WILL NOT HAVE DONE ANY?+444 ,& ,I SAY ?AT IF ?OSE :O HOLD A M&ATE OR EX]T A FUNCTION BECAUSE !Y HAVE ! CONFID5CE ( !IR COMRADES1 EI!R BECAUSE ( !IR COMPET5CE1 OR BECAUSE !Y >E ACTIVE1 OR BECAUSE !Y HAVE P>TICUL> APTITUDES1 W]E OBLIG$ TO GIVE UP ?IS M&ATE OR TO GIVE UP ?IS FUNCTION AT ! 5D ( A GIV5 TIME - ONE YE>1 EIS1 = EXAMPLE - ,I SUGGE/ ?IS1 IT IS UP TO Y\ TO MAKE IT PRACTICAL2 IT IS QUITE OBVI\S ?AT Y\ W\LD NOT HAVE ?IS >MY ( P]MAN5T FUNCTION>IES444 ,TRADE UNIONI/S1 RETURN TO ! HONE/ & CON/ANT PRACTICE ( F$]ALISM2 & !N1 ASSIGN A T]M = ! M&ATE ( Y\R (FICE HOLD]S4 ,!N1 Y\ WILL HAVE A MOVEM5T ?AT IS FLEXIBLE1 ALIVE1 COMBATIVE1 ALWAYS Y\NG4444 ,Y\ WILL !N HAVE FEW] D\BTFUL ELEM5TS & Y\ WILL GIVE TO ! TRADE UNIONISM AN 9COMP>ABLE =CE ( REVOLUTION4 ,A,N,O,!,R ,=,C,E ,( ,R,E,V,O,L,U,T,I,O,N3 ,! ,C,O,O,P,],A,T,I,V,E,S4 ,:5 ONE EXAM9ES H[ ! MAJORITY ( ! COOP]ATIVES FUNCTION1 ONE WOND]S TO ?9K ?AT COOP]ATISM CAN BE A REVOLUTION>Y =CE4 ,BUT AS WELL AS TRADE UNIONISM1 COOP]ATION C\LD BE AN 9CALCULABLE =CE ( REVOLUTION4 ,ON ! SAME BASIS8 ,:Y8 ,BECAUSE COOP]ATION HAS ! AIM ( GR\P+ ! WORK+ WORLD ON ! GR\ND ( CONSUMPTION1 LIKE TRADE UNIONISM HAS ! AIM ( GR\P+ ! WORK+ CLASS ON ! GR\ND ( ! PRODUCTION4 ,WORK]S1 Y\ >E NOT ONLY PRODUC]S1 - & 9 ?IS MOM5T EV51 !RE >E ?OSE AMONG Y\ :O1 /RUCK BY UNEMPLOYM5T1 CANNOT PRODUCE1 - BUT Y\ >E ABOVE ALL1 ALWAYS & NECESS>ILY CONSUM]S4 ,DO Y\ UND]/& WELL ! IMPORTANCE !RE IS TO ORGANIZ+ Y\ ON ?IS GR\ND1 LIKE ! 5ORM\S IMPORTANCE TO GR\P Y\ >\ND PRODUCTION8 ,AH WELL6 ,?IS IS PRECISELY ! ROLE ( COOP]ATION4 7,FAURE !N DESCRIBES H[ ,*>LES ,F\RI] LAID ! GR\NDWORK = COOP]ATIVES 9 ,FRANCE7 ,!N ! IDEA CAME TO HIM 7,F\RI] $47 TO REMOVE ALL ?IS MASS ( P>ASITES :I* >E 9T]M$I>IES BETWE5 ! PRODUC] & ! CONSUM]4 ,IT IS ?IS IDEA1 COMRADES1 ?AT IS AT ! BASE ( ! COOP]ATIVE IDEA4 ,! COOP]ATIVES HAVE AS AN AIM TO GET DIRECTLY = ! PR(IT ( !IR MEMB]S1 OR ?OSE :O BUY ON !IR PREMISES1 ! PRODUCTS :I* !SE CU/OM]S NE$1 )\T SUPPORT+ ALL ! 9T]M$I>IES444 L>GE M]*ANTS TO SMALL RETAIL]S - & Y\ KN[ H[ NUM]\S !Y >E4 ,Y\ SEE1 COMRADES1 !RE IS A ?\T+ PO9T ( A =CE = REVOLUTION444 ,UN=TUNATELY1 ) !IR SUCCESS 7BECAUSE ! COOP]ATIVES />T$ TO BE PROSP]\S & SUCCESSFUL71 ! /ATE ( M9D ( ! COOP]ATORS DID NOT REMA9 ! SAME4 ,TODAY1 !RE IS ?IS P[]FUL MA*9E CALL$ ! ,GR& ,/ORE1 :I* MAKES ,F#a#d OR ,F#a#e MILLIONS BUS9ESS P] ANNUM2 :I* HAS A =MIDABLE ORGANIZATION & :OSE B5EFITS RISE EA* YE> ) T5S ( MILLIONS ( FRANCS6 ,!RE IS1 >\ND1 A MORE OR LESS HI< NUMB] PEOPLE :O >E ATTA*$ TO COMM]CIAL PROSP]ITY 7LET US SAY ! WORD7 9 ?IS E/ABLI%M5T2 SO ?AT ! SPIRIT ( REVOLUTION1 ! SPIRIT ( SOCIAL TRANS=MATION :I* %\LD HAVE DIRECT$ ! 9ITIATORS ( ?IS MOVEM5T1 ?IS SPIRIT ALMO/ COMPLETELY DISAPPE>$4 ,! PRACTICES BECAME DEFECTIVE &1 ! SPIRIT ( ! COOP]ATORS BECAME1 ALAS6 0PETTY B\RGEOIS04 ,H]E1 ,I 9DICATE ! REM$Y3 ,I AM ! ADV]S>Y ( :AT IS CALL$ ! 0REBATE0 OR 0REFUND$ PR(IT04 ,Y\ KN[ ( :AT IT CONSI/S3 AT ! 5D ( EA* YE>1 9 EA* E/ABLI%M5T1 !Y DO ! ACC\NTS & ONE SEES ! PR(ITS4 ,!SE PR(ITS >E1 = EXAMPLE1 ( #a1 #a#b1 #b .04 ,!Y ALLOT A %>E TO ! MEMB]S OR TO CU/OM]S ( ! COOP]ATIVE1 BY WAY ( REFUND+1 A PR(IT REFUND$4 ,! REMA9D] IS = ) ! OV]HEAD1 ! PAYM5T ( ! P]SONNEL1 ! RES]VE FUNDS &1 F9ALLY1 ) ! EXT5SION ( ! BUS9ESS4 ,AH WELL1 ,I AM OPPOS$ TO ! REBATE ( ! PR(IT1 & H]E IS :Y3 ,! PROSPECT = ?IS PR(IT1 ! NE$ = ALLOTT+ A P>T TO ! MEMB]S & = %[+ ( IT ?US1 ?IS NE$ 9VOLVES ! REALIZATION ( L>GE B5EFIT &1 NATURALLY1 9 ?IS =M1 ! COOP]ATIVE MAKES A RETURN ON ! TRADE1 ! TRADE CONSI/+ 9 BUY+ ! *EAPE/ POSSIBLE1 TO RESELL AS EXP5SIVE AS POSSIBLE4 ,A COOP]ATIVE COMPANY :I* HAS ! DESIRE TO REFUND ITS MEMB]S AN APPRECIABLE B5EFIT MAKES A RETURN1 )\T WANT+ IT1 9/9CTIVELY1 TO COMM]CIAL PRACTICES & A M]C5>Y ATTITUDE4 ,MOREOV]1 ?IS REBATE1 ?IS PR(IT REFUND$ /IMULATES ! LOVE ( ! PR(IT 9 ! MEMB]1 & MA9TA9S1 CONSEQU5TLY1 ALSO ! SPIRIT ( SOCIAL CONS]VATISM444 ,?IS PR(IT OBLIGES ONE TO MA9TA9 COMM]CIAL PRICES3 ONE SELLS LIKE ! NEI1 Y\ WILL F9D1 9 ! =M ( PR(IT :I* WILL BE REFUND$ TO Y\1 A P>T ( ! B5EFIT :I* WE WILL HAVE C>RI$ \T40 ,SU* >E ! REASONS = :I* ,I AM AGA9/ ! REFUND$ PR(IT4 ,& H[EV] ,I AM ( OP9ION TO MA9TA9 A LIIS1 OR 9 ! ,P>IS >EA1 IT IS A MILLION1 - Y\ HE>3 IT IS A MILLION1 - :I* IS ! AM\NT ( B5EFIT C>RI$ \T BY ! COOP]ATIVE COMPANIES6444 ,NOTICE ?AT ,I F9D IT ONLY NATURAL ?AT ?OSE :O WORK 9 ! COOP]ATIVE LIVE ( ?IS COOP]ATIVE3 !Y DEVOTE TO IT !IR TIME1 !IR ACTIVITY1 !IR KN[L$GE1 IT IS ?US P]FECTLY NORMAL ?AT !Y LIVE BY IT4 ,BUT1 ?AT BE+ SAID1 & ALL DO+ SUITABLY & REASONABLY1 Y\ SEE FROM H]E1 ) ! MILLION C>RI$ \T EA* YE> 9 ! ,P>IS >EA1 :AT ADMIRABLE SOCIAL PROJECTS ONE C\LD MAKE6 ,:]E >E SOCIAL PROJECTS EI!R CREAT$ OR SUPPORT$ BY ! COOP]ATIVE MOVEM5T8444 ,I WELL AGREE ?AT SOME L>GE COOP]ATIVES GIVE A FEW HUNDR$ OR A FEW ?\S&S FRANCS TO !SE PROJECTS1 BUT :]E IS ! EF=T COMP>ABLE ) ?AT :I* C\LD1 :I* %\LD1 BE C>RI$ \T8 ,:AT IMM5SE EF=TS ( $UCATION C\LD BE ESPECIALLY ACCOMPLI%$ 9 FAVOR ( WOM5 & *ILDR51 :O ONE C\LD 9T]E/ ?US 9 ! REVOLUTION>Y MOVEM5T3 FE/IVALS GIV51 S*OOLS F\ND$1 S*OOL COLONIES1 HOLIDAY CAMPS1 ETC4444P5ETRAT$ ( A NEW SPIRIT1 R5\NC+ ! DEFECTIVE PRACTICES1 MOV+ AWAY MORE & MORE FROM ! COMM]CIAL SPIRIT1 COOP]ATION C\LD BECOME1 ALSO1 SIMIL> TO TRADE UNIONISM & A P[]FUL =CE ( REVOLUTION4 ,& H]E ,I >RIVE AT ! LA/ ( ! =CES ( ,REVOLUTION :I* ,I WANT TO /UDY3 ,AN>*ISM4 ,IT IS1 9 MY OP9ION1 ! =CE ( REVOLUTION P> EXCELL5CE1 ! 9COMP>ABLE =CE ( REVOLUTION4 ,I HE> WELL ?AT ONE C\LD SAY TO ME3 0,MR ,JOSSE1 Y\ >E A GOLDSMI?6 ,IT IS NOT A/ONI%+ ?AT Y\ PRAISE Y\R GOODS1 I4E4 AN>*ISM1 S9CE Y\ >E AN>*I/IC4 ,IT IS V]Y NATURAL60 ,AH WELL1 IT IS V]Y NATURAL4 ,BUT IF ,I DID NOT BELIEVE ?AT AN>*ISM IS ! BE/ ( ALL SOCIAL DOCTR9ES1 ! PURE/ & HIY MOVEM5T1 & ?AT ,I KNEW ( SOME O!R PUR] & MORE F]TILE ?AN AN>*ISM1 ,I W\LD GO TO ?IS O!R6 ,AN>*ISM1 COMRADES1 SUMM>IZES ALL ! =CES AB\T :I* ,I ALREADY SPOKE4 ,IT IS1 SO TO SPEAK1 ! SYN!SIS444 ,NOT ONLY ! B\RGEOISIE >E NOT MI/AK5 !RE1 BUT ALL ! EM95T SOCIOLOGI/S1 ALL ! PHILOSOPH]S1 ALL ! ?9K]S :O OCCUPI$ !MSELVES ( ! SOCIAL QUE/ION1 ALL ! !ORI/S1 EV5 ?OSE ( ! S*OOLS :I* >E NOT AN>*I/IC1 RECOGNIZ$ V]Y HONE/LY ?AT AN>*ISM WAS ! PO9T T]M9US1 ! CLIMAX ( ! SOCIAL IDEAL & ?AT IT WAS !RE1 ?R\< ?\S&S & ?\S&S ( DIFFICULTIES1 HUMANITY1 F9ALLY RELEAS$1 W\LD MOVE ONE DAY4 ,9TEGRAL ,COMMUNISM OR AN>*ISM1 IT IS ! SAME ?+4 ,IT IS1 9DE$1 T[>DS ?IS SPL5DID IDEAL ?AT1 :ATEV] ! S*OOL TO :I* Y\ BELONG1 MU/ DIRECT Y\R ?\Y TO GO !RE IMM$IATELY2 WE ?9K ?AT IT IS NOT NECESS>Y TO TAKE A DIV]T$ ROAD & ?AT WE GO /RAIDS ! GOAL1 & ,I HAVE ! C]TA9TY ?AT1 ALL ( Y\ ADMIRE ! GR&EUR1 NOBILITY & BEAUTY ( ?IS M>VEL\S IDEAL4 ,AN>*ISM IS1 9DE$1 ! MEET+ ( ALL ! =CES AB\T :I* ,I SPOKE ?IS EV5+1 IT IS1 ,I SAID1 ! SYN!SIS3 AN>*ISM IS ) FREE-?\RIES \T AGA9/ RELIGION & ALL =MS ( 9TELLECTUAL & MORAL OPPRESSION2 AN>*ISM IS ) ! ,SOCIALI/ ,P>TY 9 ! FI*ISM IS ) TRADE UNIONISM 9 ! FIRIES \T = ! WORK]S AGA9/ EMPLOY]S & EXPLOIT]S ( WORK2 AN>*ISM IS ) ! COOP]ATIVES 9 !IR FIASITISM & ! 9T]M$I>IES :I* PR(IT FROM ?IS P>ASITISM4 ,WAS ,I NOT RI*ISM IS LIKE ! SYN!SIS1 LIKE ! SUMM>Y ( ALL ! O!R =CES ( REVOLUTION2 :AT COND5SES !M1 CR[NS & JO9S !M ALL TOGE!R8 ,YES1 IT IS ! SUMM>Y & CR[N+6 ,AN>*ISM REJECTS ANY =M ( ! DOM9ATION ( ! MAN BY MAN1 & NO =M ( ! EXPLOITATION ( MAN BY MAN1 S9CE IT TACKLES ALL =MS ( AU?ORITY3 ,POLITICAL AU?ORITY3 ! ,/ATE4 ,ECONOMIC AU?ORITY3 ,PROP]TY4 ,MORAL AU?ORITY3 ,FA!RL&1 ,RELIGION1 ,FAMILY4 ,LEGAL AU?ORITY3 ,C\RTS1 ,LAWS & ,POLICE ,=CE4 ,ALL ! 7AU?ORIT>IAN7 SOCIAL =CES RECEIVE ! VIGOR\S & 9CISIVE BL[S ?AT ! AN>*I/S ATTACK !M )4 ,AN>*ISM1 9DE$1 IS AGA9/ ALL OPPRESSIONS1 ALL CON/RA9TS1 IT DOES NOT ASSIGN ANY LIMIT TO ITS ACTION444 ,FROM :]E DO HUMANITY'S SUFF]+S COME8 444 ,I PUT SIDE ! 9H]5T SUFF]+ ?AT >ISES FROM NATURE ITSELF1 BUT ALL ! O!R SUFF]+S1 ALL ! O!R PA9 HAS TO DUE ) BAD SOCIAL ORGANIZATION444 ,H]E IS :AT ! AN>*I/ SAYS TO ! OPPRESS$1 TO ! SUFF]+ ONES4 ,ONE C\LD HOPE ?AT SU* A DEVELOP$ PHILOSOPHY1 AS PURE A DOCTR9E W\LD BE SAV$ FROM ! H>MFUL 9FLU5CE ( ! ,W>4 ,ALAS6 IT WAS IF NO?+4 ,I SAY ?IS 9 %AME6 ,AMONG ! MO/ NOTORI\S AN>*I/S1 AMONG ?OSE :OM WE REG>D$ AS SPIRITUAL ADVIS]S1 - NOT LEAD]S1 !RE >E NONE ON \R PREMISES1 BUT Y\ KN[ AS WELL AS ME AS !RE >E VOICES :O >E LI/5$ TO MORE ?AN O!RS & ( ! CONSCI5CES :I* SEEM TO REFLECT ! CONSCI5CE ( ! O!R AN>*I/S1 - WE W]E 9 PA9 TO SEE SOME ( !SE1 :OM WE REG>D$ AS \R ELD] BRO!RS1 LIKE \R SPIRITUAL ADVIS]S1 UND]GO+ A CURS$ FAILURE6 7#b7 ,!Y BELIEV$ ?IS W> WAS NOT LIKE O!RS1 ?AT ,FRANCE HAD BE5 ATTACK$ & NE$$ DEF5D+ VIGOR\SLY2 !Y BECAME ! COLLABORATORS ( ! 0,UNION ,SACREE0 & MADE A PACT ) ! DEF5D]S ( ! NATION1 !Y W]E W>RIORS RI+ ( A LEAD] TO REPUDIATE ITSELF6 ,ASK SOMEBODY :O HI!RTO HAD PROCLAIM$ TRU?S :I* WE BELIEV$ ALMO/ )\T DISCUSSION1 TO ASK ?IS MAN TO RECOGNIZE ?AT HE MADE AN ]ROR6 ,?IS MAN1 :O BELIEV$ HIMSELF AN>*I/IC1 WILL LOOK Y\ TOP TO BOTTOM & WILL NEV] ADMIT HE C\LD BE MI/AK54 7#c7 ,LIKE ALL ! *IEFS & ! LEAD]S ( PEOPLE1 LIKE ALL ! DRIV]S ( CR[D1 ! AN>*I/-W>RIORS W]E VICTIMS ( !IR /UPID PRIDE1 & !Y PLAC$ !IR P]SONAL VANITY ABOVE ALL4 ,& YET1 ,I IMAG9E ?AT :5 AN ]ROR IS MADE1 IT IS SUITABLE & WOR?Y TO RECOGNIZE IT HONE/LY & ?AT ! ONLY MEANS ( REPAIR+ IT IS TO PROCLAIM IT PUBLICLY4 ,WE DID NOT HAVE NE$1 WE AN>*I/S1 TO EXCLUDE !SE AN>*I/-W>RIORS1 TO DRIVE \T !M3 !Y UND]/OOD WELL ?AT !Y DID NOT HAVE ANY?+ 9 COMMON ) US1 ?AT IT WAS NECESS>Y TO EXCLUDE !MSELVES444 ,AFT] HAV+ BETRAY$1 AFT] HAV+ DISAV[$ !IR PA/1 !SE M5 >E ALONE TODAY4 ,)\T TAK+ SANCTIONS AGA9/ !M1 !Y CONDEMN$ !MSELVES VOLUNT>ILY TO ISOLATION & IT IS !RE !IR PUNI%M5T LIES2 !Y >E SURR\ND$ TODAY ONLY ) !IR LONEL9ESS & !IR AB&ONM5T444 ,( ALL ! =CES ( REVOLUTION :I* ,I QUOT$1 AN>*ISM IS P]HAPS ! SMALLE/4 ,WE DO NOT HAVE ILLUSIONS AB\T \R NUM]ICAL P[]1 WE KN[ ?AT WE DO NOT HAVE ! COMPACT BATTALIONS 1 LIKE ! ,SOCIALI/ ,P>TY1 TRADE UNIONS & ! COOP]ATIVES3 ! AN>*I/S W]E ALWAYS A M9ORITY &1 - TO PO9T \T :AT ,I SAY TO Y\1 - !Y WILL ALWAYS REMA9 A M9ORITY4 ,?IS IS 9EVITABLE4 ,AH6 WE TOO W\LD LIKE TO RECRUIT1 BUT RECRUITM5T IS NOT EASY = US4 ,9ITIALLY1 \R IDEAL IS SO HI< & SO BROAD6 ,MOREOV]1 IT IS A TO SOME EXT5T AN UNLIMIT$ IDEAL :I* DEVELOPS EA* DAY1 ) EV5TS1 HI<] & BROAD]1 SO ?AT1 TO EMBRACE ?IS IDEAL1 TO FOLL[ IT & PROPAGATE IT1 WE >E NE$$ SO TO SPEAK1 TO BE MORE DEVELOP$ M54 ,IT IS RA!R IMMODE/ ( ME TO SAY ?IS1 ,I KN[1 H[EV]1 ,I MU/ SAY IT BECAUSE IT IS ! TRU? & ?AT IS MY FEEL+2 & !N1 !RE IS NO VANITY TO SPEAK AB\T ONESELF & ITS COMRADES1 :5 IT IS DONE FRANKLY & HONE/LY4 ,YES1 IT IS NECESS>Y TO =M P>T ( ! ELITE1 IT IS NECESS>Y TO BE A MORE DEVELOP$ MAN1 TO RISE TO SU* ALTITUDES1 TO :]E FLIES ! AN>*I/IC IDEA4 ,:AT MAKES AN>*I/IC RECRUITM5T ESPECIALLY DIFFICULT1 IS ?AT !RE IS NO?+ TO GA9 ) US2 NO?+ TO GA9 & MU* TO LOSE444 ,WE HAVE1 9DE$1 NEI!R (FICES1 NOR FUNCTION>IES1 NO?+444 NOT EV5 NOTORIETY TO BE (F]$ TO \R FOLL[]S4 ,I AM MI/AK53 !RE IS1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 MU* TO GA9 AMONG US2 BUT !SE PR(ITS ( :I* ,I WANT TO SPEAK UND\BT$LY ALLURE ONLY A M9ORITY1 :I* IS ?IS ELITE AB\T :I* ,I SPOKE4 ,!RE IS NO?+ TO GA9 LIKE A SITUATION NOR MONEY1 BUT !RE IS TO MU* TO GA91 IF ONE WANTS TO BE SATISFI$1 BY WAY ( COMP5SATION1 ( ! PURE & NOBLE JOYS ( A SATISFI$ HE>T 1 ( ! SPIRIT1 ( A HI< CONSCI5CE4 ,&1 9DE$1 ! AN>*I/ F9DS JOYS 9COMP>ABLE & WOR? 9F9ITELY MORE 9 HIS EYES ?AN ! MAT]IAL ADVANTAGES ?AT RATTLE ! VANITY4 ,WE >E ?US A M9ORITY1 BUT1 SU* IS ! COMMON FATE ( ALL NEW IDEAS2 SU* NEV] JO9$ TOGE!R >\ND !M BUT A NEGLIGIBLE M9ORITY4 ,:5 AN IDEA />TS TO GR\P >\ND IT AN IMPOS+ M9ORITY1 IT IS !N ?AT ! TRU? IS 9 MOTION444 ,TODAY1 IT IS AN>*ISM :I* JO9S TOGE!R ?IS ELITE4 ,M9ORITY1 YES3 BUT IT IS NOT NECESS>Y TO BE NUM]\S TO DO MU* WORK2 IT IS EV5 BETT] (T51 BE+ FEW]3 QUALITY H]E OV]RIDES QUANTITY4 ,I LIKE BETT] A HUNDR$ 9DIVIDUALS ?AT ONE F9DS EV]Y:]E1 :O GO :]E !RE IS WORK TO DO1 :]E 9TELLIG5CE & ACTIVITY >E DEPLOY$2 ,I LIKE GOOD HUNDR$ 9DIVIDUALS :O SPEAK1 :O WRITE1 :O ACT1 9 WORDS DELIV]$ ) HEAT1 ?AN A ?\S& :O REMA9 QUIETLY ON !IR PREMISES444 ,! AN>*I/S >E & WILL BE ?US ALWAYS V]Y FEW1 BUT !Y >E EV]Y:]E4 ,!Y >E :AT ,I WILL CALL ! LEAV5 :I* RAISES ! BREAD4 ,ALREADY1 Y\ SEE !M 9VOLV$ EV]Y:]E4 ,AT SIDE ( ! FEW ?\S& DECL>$ AN>*I/S BELONG+ TO AN>*I/ GR\PS1 WE SEE ?\S&S & ?\S&S 9 O!R GR\PS3 9 ! ,FREE-?\TY1 & ) ,C ,G ,T4 ,I KN[ GREAT NUMB]S ( !M1 9 SU* SMALL CITIES & ! C\NTRYSIDE1 FEEL+ ! NE$ TO DO SOME?+1 & DESIRE TO MIX 9 ! LOCAL FI\ND !M4 ,!Y ADH]E TO ! SOCIALI/ MOVEM5T2 BUT !Y DO NOT GIVE UP !IR AN>*I/IC IDEAS4 ,!Y >E ALSO 9 ! TRADE UNIONS1 ! COOP]ATIVES1 !Y >E EV]Y:]E444 ,!RE >E EV5 ?OSE :O >E UNAW>E ( IT6 ,BECAUSE ONCE ONE EXPLA9S TO !M :AT IS AN>*ISM1 !Y SAY3 0,BUT IF IT IS ?AT1 ,I AM AN>*I/IC6 ,I AM ) Y\60 ,YES1 AN>*ISM IS EV]Y:]E444 ,SU* >E ! =CES ( REVOLUTION ( :I* IT WAS ESS5TIAL TO SP5D ?IS EV5+ 9 REVIEW4 ,I F9I%1 BECAUSE WE HAVE BE5 NE>LY TWO H\RS 9 ATT5DANCE4 ,ONE C\LD HAVE HAD ! :OLE CONF]5CE TO /UDY EA* ( !SE =CES & WE W\LD NOT HAVE EV5 EXHAU/$ ! SUBJECT4 ,I DEVOT$ MYSELF ?IS EV5+ TO A SIMPLE DESCRIPTION ( EA* CURR5T1 ( EA* ORGANIZATION1 A FA/ & %ORT DESCRIPTION4 ,I NEGLECT$ A C]TA9 NUMB] ( O!R CURR5TS1 O!R =CES1 O!R GR\P+S :I* >E NOT )\T VALUE & :O1 ON ! DAY ( ! ,REVOLUTION1 W\LD 9FLU5CE ! G5]AL MOVEM5T2 SU* >E1 = EXAMPLE1 ! FEM9I/ GR\P+S & ! BIR? CONTROL MOVEM5T1 ! ANTI-ALCOHOL & ANTIMILIT>I/ GR\PS1 & ! ,REPUBLICAN ,ASSOCIATION ( EX-,S]VICEM5 :I* HAS ! AIM ( GR\P+ 9 P>TICUL> ! VICTIMS ( ! LA/ W>4 ,LA/LY1 WE HAVE ! ,SOCIALI/ ,Y\?1 TRADE UNIONI/ & AN>*I/ Y\?1 SE$B$S ( ! ACTIVE MILITANTS ( TOMORR[4 ,IT IS ?IS Y\? :I* IS ALL \R HOPE & :I*1 WILL BE ! ABUNDANT H>VE/ ( TOMORR[6 ,!RE IS ?US1 AS Y\ SEE IT1 A :OLE LEGION ( GR\P+S FULL ( GOODWILL & EAG] TO GET MOV+4 ,I SPOKE ?IS EV5+ ONLY AB\T ! L>GE =CES BECAUSE ,I C\LD NOT OBVI\SLY TALK AB\T ALL ! =CES4 ,! L>GE =CES >E AUTONOM\S & 9DEP5D5T2 EA* ONE ( !M L>GELY DEPLOYS ITS FLAG ON ! GR\ND :I* IS P>TICUL> TO IT4 ,! 5EMY FEELS ?IS ?REAT1 IS ORGANIZ$ & UNIT$3 NEV] WAS REPRESSION AS SEV]E1 NEV] W]E ! EMPLOY]S SO FIRMLY ORGANIZ$1 NEV] ! POLICE SO >ROGANT1 NEV] DID ! C\RTS GIVE SO MANY JUDGM5TS1 NEV]1 9 A WORD1 WAS ! 5EMY MORE VALIANTLY DEF5D$4 ,IT IS ?US A QUE/ION ( 5GAG+ ! BATTLE ) ALL \R =CES JO9$ TOGE!R4 ,WE DO NOT REQUE/ ANY GR\P TO SACRIFICE ITS PR9CIPLES1 ITS DOCTR9ES1 ITS ME?ODS1 ITS ACTIONS3 WE WI%1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 ?AT EA* ONE1 ?AT EA* GR\P+ KEEPS & PRES]VES ITS ME?ODS1 DOCTR9ES1 PR9CIPLES1 SO ?AT ALL CAN BE US$ :5 ! H\R S\NDS1 BECAUSE WE HAVE A GOAL TO REA*1 MAJOR PROJECT TO BE A*IEV$4 ,ALL !SE ASSOCIAT$ =CES WILL BE ESS5TIAL4 ,! SOCIAL /RUCTURE ?REAT5S RU94 ,IT IS NOT READY TO COLLAPSE1 ,I DO NOT MISLEAD Y\ !RE3 !RE >E CRACKS4 ,H[EV]1 ! SOCIAL /RUCTURE IS /ILL SOLID & WILL NE$ A HEAVY BL[ TO DEMOLI% IT4 ,:AT IS NECESS>Y1 AT ! PRES5T TIME1 IS ?AT A P[]FUL BREA? ( REVOLT RISES & PASSES ?R\< ALL M5 ( GOODWILL1 = ! >ROGANCE ( \R ,MA/]S IS MADE ( \R IGNORANCE1 !IR =CE IS MADE ( \R WEAKNESS1 !IR C\RAGE IS MADE ( \R FAILURE & !IR RI*NESS IS MADE ( \R POV]TY6 ,! SPIRIT ( SUBMISSION DEGRAD$ !IR *>ACT]S1 REVOLT WILL RAISE !M2 ! PRACTICE ( OB$I5CE CURV$ !IR SP9ES1 REVOLT WILL /RAI*I/S1 WE DO NOT WANT TO LIVE ANY MORE AS SLAVES4 ,WE DECL>$ A PITILESS W> AGA9/ ! ,SY/EM1 YES1 A W> ) ! KNIFE6 ,WE KN[ ?AT IT IS NECESS>Y = US TO W9 OR DIE4 ,WE HAVE ?US DECID$ TO BATTLE1 BATTLE AT EV]Y MOM5T AGA9/ ALL OB/ACLES & ALL CON/RA9TS3 ,RELIGION1 ,CAPITAL1 ,GOV]NM5T1 ,MILIT>ISM1 ,POLICE1 ETC4 ,& WE >E DET]M9$ TO C>RY \T ?IS BATTLE UNTIL VICTORY IS COMPLETE4 ,WE WANT TO NOT ONLY BE FREE \RSELVES1 BUT ?AT ALL M5 %ALL BE FREE4 ,AS LONG AS !RE WILL BE *A9S1 EV5 IF !Y W\LD BE GILD$1 EV5 IF !Y W\LD BE LIM3 WE WANT ALL ! *A9S BROK5 (F1 ALL & =EV]6 ,LIBRAIRIE SOCIALE1 ,P>IS1 #a#i#b#a4 0,LA ,BRO*URE ,M5SUELLE0 DANS LES S]IES 0,LA BONNE COLLECTION0 ET 0,PROPOS SUBV]SIFS04 ,RETRANSCRIPTION D'UNE CONF]5CE FAITE P> ,SEBA/I5 ,FAURE A ,P>IS1 LE #be JANVI] #aiba DANS LA GR&E SALLE DE LA ,MAISON DES ,SYNDICATS4 ,PIQUE SUR3 ,H,Y,P,],L,9,K HTTP3_/_/BIBLIOLIB4NET_/,FAURE-,REV=C4HTM ,I CUT \T A PORTION ( ?IS SPEE*4 ,REPETITION MO/LY1 & SUMM>IZ$ O!R >EAS NOT IMPORTANT TO ! OV]ALL MEAN+ ( ! TEXT4 ,I ALSO HAVE A QUE/ION = ! READ]4 ,:AT >E ! =CES ( ! REVOLUTION TODAY8 ,L,G 7#a7 REF]S TO ,EMILE ,P\GET1 ,JEAN ,GRAVE & ,PET] ,KROPOTK9 :O SUPPORT$ ,W,W#a 7#b7 REF]S TO ,JEAN ,GRAVE :O LEAD A FACTION ( PRO-W> AN>*I/S 9 ! #a#i#bS4 7#c7 ,?IS GR\P WAS1 AS ,FAURE MA9TA9S1 T9Y1 ISOLAT$ & IRRELEVANT4 ,FROM 3 ,AN>*Y ,>*IVES4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,NOVEMB] #c1 #aib 3 ,REVOLUTION>Y ,=CES -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,FEBRU>Y #e1 #bag 3 ,REVOLUTION>Y ,=CES -- ,ADD$4 ,DECEMB] #c1 #bba 3 ,REVOLUTION>Y ,=CES -- ,UPDAT$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/