,DAY #f1 ,MORN+ ,SESSION ,MONDAY1 ,JULY #c ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,! ,9DU/RIAL ,WORK]S ( ! ,WORLD 7,I,W,W7 ,TEXT 3 ,C,O,N,V,5,T,I,O,N ,9DU/RIAL ,WORK]S ( ! ,WORLD ,S,I,X,? ,D,A,Y ,MONDAY1 ,JULY #c ,M,O,R,N,+ ,S,E,S,S,I,O,N ,*AIRMAN ,HAYWOOD CALL$ ! CONV5TION TO ORD] AT #i4#c ,A4 ,M4 ,! ROLL CALL ( DELEGATES WAS ON MOTION DISP5S$ )4 ,! ,SECRET>Y READ ! M9UTES ( ! PREVI\S SESSION1 & !RE BE+ NO CORRECTIONS1 !Y W]E APPROV$ AS READ4 ,C,O,M,M,U,N,I,C,A,T,I,O,N,S4 ,! FOLL[+ COMMUNICATIONS W]E READ BY ! ,SECRET>Y & ORD]$ PLAC$ ON FILE3 ,HOBOK51 ,N4 ,J41 ,JULY #b4 ,WM4 ,E4 ,TRAUTMANN1 ,9DU/RIAL ,UNION ,CONV5TION ,HALL1 ,CL>K & ,]IE /REETS4 ,*AIRMAN & ,DELEGATES3--,GREET+S4 ,\R BE/ WI%ES TO SUCCE$ 9 Y\R IMPORTANT WORK4 ,SMA% ! LABOR FAKIRS & TRAITORS4 ,TWI/ ! ROPES TO HANG ,GOMP]S1 ,MIT*ELL @& ,CO4 ,?REE *E]S = ! NEW CLASS-CONSCI\S MOVEM5T4 ,Y\RS = ! EMANCIPATION ( \R CLASS4 ,H,O,B,O,K,5 ,O,R,G,A,N,I,Z,$ ,L,O,N,G,%,O,R,E,M,5 79 G5]AL MEET+7 ,H,5,R,Y ,F4 ,S,*,R,E,C,K1 ,*AIRMAN PRO TEM4 ,F,],D ,D,I,T,T,]1 ,SECRET>Y PRO TEM4 ,LOS ,ANGELES1 ,CAL41 ,JULY #b4 ,*AIRMAN ,9DU/RIAL ,UNION ,CONV5TION1 ,BR&'S ,HALL1 ,CL>K & ,]IE /REETS1 OR #ee ,CL>K4 ,MAY A CLASS-CONSCI\S UNION CR[N Y\R EF=TS & S\ND ! DEA? KNELL ( WAGE SLAV]Y4 ,ADOPT$ AT PUBLIC MEET+ ( ,SOCIALI/ ,LABOR ,P>TY & ,SOCIALI/ ,TRADE @& ,LABOR ,ALLIANCE1 ,LOS ,ANGELES1 ,CAL4 ,H4 ,J4 ,S,*,A,D,E4 ,EA/ ,/4 ,L\IS1 ,ILL41 ,JULY #g1 #a#i#e4 ,TO ! ,9DU/RIAL ,UNION ,CONF]5CE1 ,*ICAGO1 ,ILL4 ,GREET+3--,A NUMB] ( WORK+M5 9 ?IS CITY HAS RAIS$ A PURSE = ! PURPOSE ( SECUR+ ,E4 ,V4 ,DEBS TO DELIV] AN ADDRESS 9 ?IS CITY4 ,I WAS APPROA*$ ) ! PROPOSITION & TOLD !M D\BTLESS ,E4 ,V4 WAS ATT5D+ ! ,9DU/RIAL ,UNION ,CONV5TION N[ 9 SESSION 9 ,*ICAGO & ?AT IF !Y SECUR$ HIM HE W\LD D\BTLESS TALK 9DU/RIALISM UNIONISM & OPPOSE ALL O!R =MS ( UNIONISM4 0,?AT WILL SUIT US10 !Y SAID1 0WE WANT HIM40 0,WELL10 ,I SAID1 0UPON !SE GR\NDS ,I'LL VOLUNTE] TO COMMUNICATE ) ! CONV5TION & LE>N H[ SOON HE CAN COME40 0,GOOD1 DO IT 0 !Y SAID4 ,SO N[ IF ,E4 ,V4 CAN COME UND] ! AUSPICES ( ! ,9DU/RIAL ,UNION SO ?AT ! LOCAL ,S4 ,T4 @& ,L4 ,A4 CAN TAKE *>GE1 WE WILL GET READY = A BIG MEET+ UND] ! AUSPICES ( ! NEW ORGANIZATION4 ,HOP+ ! REVOLUTION>Y SPIRIT WILL GUIDE ! NEW ORGANIZATION 9TO ! PROP] *ANNEL & LAUN* AN UP TO DATE REVOLUTION>Y UNION1 & REQUE/+ ,E4 ,V41 OR ?OSE :O MAY HAVE *>GE TO 9=M ME AS SOON AS POSSIBLE ! DATE ?AT HE CAN SPEAK 9 ,EA/ ,/4 ,L\IS1 ,I REMA9 Y\RS = ! EMANCIPATION ( ! WORK+ CLASS4 ,W4 ,W4 ,C,O,X #ebb ,NOR? #d#cRD /REET1 ,EA/ ,/4 ,L\IS1 ,ILL4 ,P4 ,S4--,!Y TELL ME EXP5SES WILL BE MET4 ,LET ME KN[ :AT !Y WILL BE4 ,ALSO A COMMUNICATION FROM A ,S*5ECTADY UNION DONAT+ FIVE DOLL>S4 ,C,R,$,5,T,I,A,L,S4 ,D,E,L4 ,:,I,T,E1 ( ! ,CR$5TIALS ,COMMITTEE1 PRES5T$ A REPORT FROM ?AT COMMITTEE RECOMM5D+ ! SEAT+ ( ,F4 ,K5KE1 REPRES5T+ PA9T]S1 TAILORS1 MA*9I/S & A NUMB] ( MIX$ TRADES1 ) #dg VOTES2 ,TIMO?Y ,MAHONEY1 ,/REET ,LABOR]S' ,UNION1 ,*ICAGO1 ) ONE VOTE4 ,IT WAS /AT$ ?AT ! LATT] BRO!R REPRES5T$ AN ORGANIZATION ( #ag MEMB]S1 :O HAD SECUR$ A N9E-H\R DAY ) @s#b A DAY1 AFT] ,GOMP]S HAD GIV5 9/RUCTIONS TO SIGN A CONTRACT = N9E & A HALF H\RS ) LESS WAGES ?AN ! MEMB]S W]E GETT+4 ,ON MOTION1 ! REPORT WAS CONCURR$ 9 & ! DELEGATES SEAT$4 ,SPECIAL COMMITTEES W]E CALL$ =1 BUT NONE HAD ANY REPORT TO MAKE4 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,REPORTS ( /&+ COMMITTEES4 ,! ,COMMITTEE ON ,CON/ITUTION4 ,D,E,L4 ,T4 ,J4 ,H,A,G,],T,Y1 SECRET>Y ( ! ,COMMITTEE ON ,CON/ITUTION3 ,! ,COMMITTEE ON ,CON/ITUTION HAS ! FOLL[+ ,PREAMBLE TO REPORT4 ,D,E,L4 ,S,*,A,T,S,K,E3 ,A PO9T ( 9=MATION4 ,BE=E ?AT IS DONE ,I W\LD LIKE TO SUGGE/ ?AT ! ,CON/ITUTION BE READ BY P>AGRAPHS1 & ?AT EV]Y P>AGRAPH %\LD BE READ TWICE4 ,D,E,L4 ,H,A,G,],T,Y3 ,I WILL READ IT 9 *UNKS IF Y\ WANT IT4 ,D,E,L4 ,S,*,A,T,S,K,E3 ,& AFT] ?AT ?AT ! P>AGRAPHS BE DISCUSS$ SEP>ATELY4 ,I MAKE ?AT AS A MOTION4 ,NO SECOND4 ,D,E,L4 ,H,A,G,],T,Y 7READ+ ,PREAMBLE73 0,! WORK+ CLASS & ! EMPLOY+ CLASS HAVE NO?+ 9 COMMON4 ,!RE CAN BE NO PEACE SO LONG AS HUNG] & WANT >E F\ND AMONG MILLIONS ( WORK+ PEOPLE1 & ! FEW :O MAKE UP ! EMPLOY+ CLASS HAVE ALL ! GOOD ?+S ( LIFE4 ,BETWE5 !SE TWO CLASSES A /RUGGLE MU/ GO ON UNTIL ALL ! TOIL]S COME TOGE!R ON ! POLITICAL AS WELL AS ON ! 9DU/RIAL FIELD1 & TAKE & HOLD ?AT :I* !Y PRODUCE BY !IR LABOR1 ?R\< AN ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION ( ! WORK+ CLASS )\T AFFILIATION ) ANY POLITICAL P>TY4 7,APPLAUSE74 ,! RAPID GA!R+ ( WEAL? & ! C5TRALIZATION ( ! MANAGEM5T ( 9DU/RY 9TO FEW] & FEW] H&S MAKE ! TRADES UNIONS ( TO-DAY UNABLE TO COPE ) ! EV]-GR[+ P[] ( ! EMPLOY+ CLASS1 BECAUSE ! TRADES UNIONS FO/] A /ATE ( ?+S :I* ALL[S ONE SET ( WORK]S TO BE PITT$ AGA9/ ANO!R SET ( WORK]S 9 ! SAME 9DU/RY1 !REBY HELP+ TO DEFEAT ONE ANO!R 9 WAGE W>S4 ,! TRADES UNIONS AID ! EMPLOY+ CLASS TO MISLEAD ! WORK]S 9TO ! BELIEF ?AT ! WORK+ CLASS HAVE 9T]E/S 9 COMMON ) !IR EMPLOY]S4 ,!SE SAD CONDITIONS CAN BE *ANG$ & ! 9T]E/S ( ! WORK+ CLASS UPHELD ONLY BY AN ORGANIZATION =M$ 9 SU* A WAY ?AT ITS MEMB]S 9 ANY ONE 9DU/RY OR 9 ALL 9DU/RIES IF NECESS>Y1 %ALL CEASE WORK :5EV] A /RIKE OR LOCK\T IS ON 9 ANY DEP>TM5T !RE(1 ?US MAK+ AN 9JURY TO ONE ! CONC]N ( ALL4 ,!RE=E1 WE ! WORK]S UNITE UND] ! FOLL[+ CON/ITUTION40 7,APPLAUSE47 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,Y\ HAVE HE>D ! READ+ ( ! ,PREAMBLE (F]$ BY Y\R ,COMMITTEE ON ,CON/ITUTION4 ,:AT IS ! PLEASURE ( ! CONV5TION8 ,D,E,L4 ,F,R,Y3 ,?AT ,PREAMBLE MAY BE ALL RI$ TO SAY IT IS NOT4 ,FROM ! READ+ ( ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N ( ! ,COMMITTEE IT IS ALMO/ IMPOSSIBLE = ! DELEGATES TO DIGE/ ! CONT5TS ( IT4 ,I BELIEVE IT %\LD BE PR9T$4 ,I BELIEVE ?AT EA* DELEGATE H]E %\LD HAVE A COPY ( IT BE=E WE TAKE ANY ACTION ON IT4 ,O!RWISE WE MAY NOT BE ABLE TO DIGE/ ! MATT] AS A :OLE4 ,I (F] ?AT AS A SUGGE/ION OR MOTION4 7,SECOND$47 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,IT HAS BE5 REGUL>LY MOV$ & SECOND$ ?AT EA* DELEGATE BE FURNI%$ ) A COPY ( ! ,PREAMBLE BE=E TAK+ ACTION ON ! ,PREAMBLE4 ,>E Y\ READY = ! QUE/ION8 ,D,E,L4 ,T4 ,J4 ,H,A,G,],T,Y3 ,I OPPOSE ?AT MOTION ON ! GR\ND ?AT ?IS ,PREAMBLE IS %ORT 5\< = ANY ONE TO CAT* ! DRIFT ( IT1 & ?AT ! PR9T+ ( ! ,PREAMBLE & DI/RIBUT+ COPIES ( IT W\LD DELAY ?IS CONV5TION BEYOND A REASONABLE L5G? ( TIME4 ,IF !RE >E ANY OBJECTIONS TO ANY ( ! PR9CIPLES LAID D[N1 ! ,PREAMBLE IS V]Y BRIEF1 SO ?AT OBJECTIONS \D A SECOND TO ! MOTION4 ,D,E,L4 ,S,*,A,T,S,K,E3 ,I SECOND IT4 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,! *AIR WILL RULE ?AT MOTION \T ( ORD]4 ,Y\ >E SPEAK+ TO ! PROPOSITION ( HAV+ ?IS ,PREAMBLE PR9T$4 ,D,E,L4 ,R,I,*,T,]3 ,I AM OPPOS$ TO ! MOTION1 = ! REASON ?AT IF IT W]E PR9T$ IT W\LD NOT FACILITATE ! WORK ( ?IS CONV5TION4 ,AS ONE ( ! ,COMMITTEE HAS /AT$1 IT IS BRIEF 5\< TO 5ABLE ! CONV5TION TO TAKE ACTION UPON IT4 ,I !RE=E MOVE AS AN AM5DM5T ?AT ! ,PREAMBLE BE TAK5 UP P>AGRAPH BY P>AGRAPH & ACT$ UPON4 7,SECOND$47 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,AN AM5DM5T HAS BE5 (F]$ ?AT ! ,PREAMBLE BE TAK5 UP P>AGRAPH BY P>AGRAPH & ACT$ UPON4 ,>E Y\ READY = ! QUE/ION8 7,QUE/ION CALL$ =74 ,?OSE 9 FAVOR ( ! AM5DM5T WILL SIGNIFY IT BY SAY+ AYE4 ,CONTR>Y1 NO4 ,! MOTION IS C>RI$4 ,READ P>AGRAPH ONE4 ,SECRET>Y ,HAG]TY READ ! FIR/ P>AGRAPH1 AS FOLL[S3 ,! WORK+ CLASS & ! EMPLOY+ CLASS HAVE NO?+ 9 COMMON4 ,!RE CAN BE NO PEACE SO LONG AS HUNG] & WANT >E F\ND AMONG MILLIONS ( WORK+ PEOPLE & ! FEW :O MAKE UP ! EMPLOY+ CLASS HAVE ALL ! GOOD ?+S ( LIFE40 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,Y\ HAVE HE>D ! READ+ ( P>AGRAPH ONE4 ,:AT IS ! PLEASURE ( ! CONV5TION8 ,D,E,L4 ,M4 ,P4 ,H,A,G,G,],T,Y3 ,I MOVE ITS ADOPTION4 7,SECOND$47 ,D,E,L4 ,M,C,E,A,*,R,53 ,I W\LD LIKE TO HAVE SOME DEF9ITE KN[L$GE AS TO :AT ! GOOD ?+S ( LIFE >E1 & IT SEEMS TO ME ?AT ! ,PREAMBLE IS OBJECTIONABLE 9 NOT SPECIFY+ !M4 ,A DELEGATE RAIS$ A PO9T ( ORD]4 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,IT HAS BE5 MOV$ & SECOND$ ?AT P>AGRAPH ONE BE ADOPT$4 ,>E Y\ READY = ! QUE/ION8 7,QUE/ION CALL$ =47 ,D,E,L4 ,R,I,*,T,]3 ,MR4 ,*AIRMAN & ,FELL[ ,DELEGATES3 ,IF ! S5D+ ( DELEGATES TO ?IS CONV5TION 9DICATES ANY?+1 IT %[S ?AT !RE IS A DESIRE AMONG ! WORK+ CLASS TO FREE ITSELF FROM OPPRESSION1 & ! RESPONSE TO ! CALL = ?IS CONV5TION %[S ?AT IT EXPECTS ?AT ?IS CONV5TION WILL EXPRESS ?R\< ITS DECL>ATION ( PR9CIPLES ! SITUATION AS IT EXI/S TO-DAY AS F> AS ! CAPITALI/ CLASS & ! WORK+ CLASS >E CONC]N$1 & ?AT IT WILL PO9T \T A POLICY BY :I* IT MAY G5]ATE /R5G? 5\< TO FREE ITSELF FROM WAGE SLAV]Y4 ,N[1 FELL[ WORKM51 ! ,PREAMBLE (F]$ BY Y\R COMMITTEE />TS \T1 0,! WORK+ CLASS & ! EMPLOY+ CLASS HAVE NO?+ 9 COMMON40 ,IT APPE>S TO ME ?AT ! P>AGRAPH AS IT /&S HAS NO S5SE & IS UNTRUE4 ,IT DOES NOT SAY ANY?+ AB\T SU* MATT]S AS WE %\LD EXPECT 9 ! ,PREAMBLE ( ?IS NEW ORGANIZATION :I* HAS SET ITSELF ! TASK ( FREE+ ! WORK+ CLASS4 ,= ?IS REASON ,I MOVE ?AT WE /RIKE \T ?AT CLAUSE & SUB/ITUTE ! FOLL[+3 0,LABOR IS NECESS>Y TO SATISFY ! NE$S ( SOCIETY4 ,!RE=E EV]Y ABLE P]SON %\LD DO SOME USEFUL WORK = ITS MA9T5ANCE4 ,! MEANS ( PRODUCTION & DI/RIBUTION HAVE GR[N TO SU* A SIZE & HAVE BECOME SO CO/LY ?AT ONLY A FEW CAN [N !M1 AS LONG AS PRIVATE [N]%IP !RE( EXI/S2 CONDEMN+ ! RE/ ( MANK9D TO OBTA9 AN EXI/5CE BY SELL+ !IR LABOR P[] TO ?OSE FEW4 ,! PRIVATE [N]%IP ( ! L& & MOD]N TOOLS ( PRODUCTION HAS TURN$ !M 9TO MEANS ( OPPRESSION & EXPLOITATION1 =C+ ! WAGE E>N+ CLASS TO SUFF] WANT & MIS]Y & 9SECURITY ( EMPLOYM5T1 :ILE ! 9CREAS+ PR(IT ( ! CAPITALI/ CLASS SECURES TO !M A LIFE ( IDL5ESS & LUXURY40 ,I MOVE ?AT ?IS BE SUB/ITUT$ = ! FIR/ P>AGRAPH ( ! ,PREAMBLE AS SUBMITT$ BY ! ,COMMITTEE4 ,D,E,L4 ,S,*,A,T,S,K,E3 ,MR4 ,*AIRMAN & ,FELL[ ,DELEGATES-- ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,JU/ A MOM5T4 ,!RE IS NO SECOND TO ! SUB/ITUTE (F]$ = P>AGRAPH ONE4 ,! DEBATE OCCURS ON ! ORIG9AL MOTION1 :I* IS TO ADOPT P>AGRAPH ONE AS REPORT$ BY ! ,COMMITTEE ON ,CON/ITUTION4 ,D,E,L4 ,S,*,A,T,S,K,E3 ,MR4 ,*AIRMAN & ,FELL[ ,DELEGATES3 ,!RE HAS BE5 OBJECTION (F]$ AGA9/ ?IS P>AGRAPH :I* SAYS ?AT ! CAPITALI/ CLASS & ! WORK+ CLASS HAVE NO?+ 9 COMMON4 ,HAVE WE ANY?+ 9 COMMON8 ,I WAS ONCE 9 A M9+ T[N & ,I CAME TO ! PO/ (FICE4 ,!RE W]E TWO LITTLE *ILDR5 PLAY+ \T ( DOORS4 ,!Y 5JOY$ !IR PLAY V]Y MU*4 ,A MAN CAME \T FROM ! PO/ (FICE & GRABB$ ONE *ILD BY ! H& & SAID1 0,Y\ HAVE NO BUS9ESS TO PLAY ) ?IS *ILD40 ,! *ILD COMM5C$ TO CRY1 & SAID1 0,:Y1 ,I LOVE ?AT *ILD40 0,WELL10 SAID ! MAN1 0DON'T Y\ KN[ ?AT ?AT *ILD'S FA!R IS A M9] & Y\R FA!R IS A BUS9ESS MAN & ALSO ! PO/MA/]80 ,N[1 HAV5'T ?OSE TWO CLASSES SOME?+ 9 COMMON8 ,ISN'T IT FRIS 9 LUXURIES & = FL[]S1 :ILE ! WORK+M5 :O PRODUCE ALL WEAL? ?AT !SE PEOPLE 5JOY HAVE TO LIVE 9 POV]TY & DEGRADATION8 ,ISN'T ?AT A BEAUTIFUL COMMUNISM8 ,H[ DO Y\ LIKE ?AT K9D ( COMMUNISM4 ,I ASK ?AT ?IS MOTION %ALL BE ADOPT$4 ,D,E,L4 ,G,I,L,B,],T3 ,I W\LD LIKE TO SAY1 ,MR4 ,*AIRMAN & ,FELL[ ,DELEGATES1 ?AT IT IS QUITE IMPOSSIBLE = US TO SPLIT HAIRS & TO ANALYZE ) F9E ACCURACY ! SCI5TIFIC 9T]PRETATION ( ?IS OR ANY O!R DOCUM5T4 ,BUT ONE ( ! ?+S ?AT PLEAS$ ME P>TICUL>LY AB\T ?AT ,PREAMBLE WAS ?IS1 ?AT :ILE POSSIBLY IT WAS NOT /AT$ 9 ABSOLUTELY SCI5TIFIC T]MS1 IT SEEMS TO ME IT WAS /AT$ 9 ! T]SE1 ORD9>Y LANGUAGE ( ! PLA9 PEOPLE1 & ?AT IS :AT WE WANT4 ,WE DO NOT WANT TO PUT \T FROM ?IS CONV5TION AN ACADEMIC /ATEM5T4 ,WE WANT SIMPLY TO PUT \T A /ATEM5T ?AT WILL C>RY CONVICTION TO ! M9D ( ! HUMBLE TOIL]1 & :5 Y\ TALK AB\T !RE BE+ NO?+ 9 COMMON BETWE5 !M ! AV]AGE COMMON HORSE S5SE KN[S ?AT4 ,!RE=E ,I W\LD MOVE Y\ ! ADOPTION ( ?AT FIR/ CLAUSE1 )\T WA/+ ! TIME ( ! CONV5TION4 7,SECOND$47 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,! MOTION IS \T ( ORD]4 ,D,E,L4 ,:,I,T,E3 ,I HAVE HE>D A GOOD MANY ,PREAMBLES READ1 & ?IS IS ! FIR/ TIME ,I HAVE SE5 A ,PREAMBLE ?AT HAS NOT GOT ! E> M>KS ( TOO MANY PR(ESSORS4 ,! LANGUAGE S\NDS GOOD TO ME4 ,I BELIEVE WE CAN GO BE=E ! WORK+ CLASS ( ?IS C\NTRY ) IT & ?AT !Y CAN UND]/& ! REPORT )\T HAV+ TO GET DICTION>IES & F9D \T :AT IS MEANT4 ,:AT WE WANT IS TO GO BE=E ! COMMON PEOPLE ) A ,PREAMBLE SO PLA9 ?AT EV]Y HONE/ ,TOM1 ,DICK & ,H>RY1 9CLUD+ \RSELVES1 CAN UND]/& IT4 ,I AM 9 FAVOR ( ! 5TIRE ,PREAMBLE AS REPORT$ BY ! ,COMMITTEE4 ,D,E,L4 ,W,I,L,K,E3 ,I MOVE ! PREVI\S QUE/ION4 7,SECOND$47 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,! *AIR V]Y MU* DISLIKES TO 5T]TA9 SU* A MOTION4 ,IT OCCURS TO ME ?AT ?IS IS A MATT] ( ! MO/ VITAL IMPORTANCE TO ?IS CONV5TION1 & ?AT IF !RE >E ANY DELEGATES ON ! FLOOR ?AT >E OPPOS$ TO ! ,PREAMBLE !Y %\LD HAVE A RID TO IT4 ,H[EV]1 ! MOTION = ! PREVI\S QUE/ION HAS BE5 MADE4 ,?OSE 9 FAVOR WILL SIGNIFY IT BY SAY+ AYE4 ,CONTR>Y BY ! SAME SIGN1 NO4 ,! MOTION IS LO/4 ,! MOTION BE=E ! CONV5TION AT ?IS TIME IS TO ADOPT P>AGRAPH ONE4 ,>E Y\ READY = ! QUE/ION8 7,QUE/ION CALL$ =74 ,?OSE 9 FAVOR ( ADOPT+ P>AGRAPH ONE WILL SAY AYE4 ,CONTR>Y1 NO4 ,! AYES HAVE IT4 ,! MOTION IS C>RI$ & P>AGRAPH ONE ADOPT$4 7,APPLAUSE47 ,SECRET>Y ,HAG]TY !N READ ! SECOND CLAUSE ( ! ,PREAMBLE1 AS FOLL[S3 0,BETWE5 !SE TWO CLASSES A /RUGGLE MU/ GO ON UNTIL ALL ! TOIL]S COME TOGE!R ON ! POLITICAL AS WELL AS ON ! 9DU/RIAL FIELD1 & TAKE & HOLD ?AT :I* !Y PRODUCE BY !IR LABOR1 ?R\< AN ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION ( ! WORK+ CLASS )\T AFFILIATION ) ANY POLITICAL P>TY40 ,A MOTION WAS MADE & SECOND$ ?AT ! P>AGRAPH BE ADOPT$ AS READ4 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,IT HAS BE5 REGUL>LY MOV$ & SECOND$ ?AT P>AGRAPH TWO BE ADOPT$4 ,D,E,L4 ,S,I,M,O,N,S3 ,IT SEEMS TO ME WE >E TRY+ TO ADOPT SOME?+ ?AT IS ALMO/ RIDICUL\S 9 /ATEM5T4 ,IF Y\ WILL ANALYZE ?AT AS IT /&S1 IT SAYS ?AT WE >E 9 FAVOR ( POLITICAL ACTION )\T ANY POLITICAL P>TY4 ,I AM ABSOLUTELY 9 FAVOR ( NO 5DORSEM5T :ATEV] ( ANY POLITICAL P>TY4 ,AT ! SAME TIME ! WORD+ ( ?AT IS CONTRADICTORY & CONFUS+1 & !RE \LY :AT IT DOES MEAN4 ,AS IT /&S N[ IT PRACTICALLY SAYS NO POLITICAL ACTION1 )\T A POLITICAL P>TY4 ,I OBJECT TO ?AT4 ,I HAVE NOT A COPY H]E1 & SO CANNOT MAKE AN 9TELLIG5T AM5DM5T4 ,A DELEGATE MOV$ AS AN AM5DM5T ?AT ! WORD 0POLITICAL0 BE /RICK5 \T4 ,D,E,L4 ,W,R,I,<,T3 ,I WANT TO SAY ?AT ?AT P>AGRAPH DOES NOT CONTRADICT ITSELF1 9 MY OP9ION4 ,I WILL PO9T \T ! REASON4 ,! FIR/ P>T ( ! P>AGRAPH M]ELY PLACES IT UPON ! PLANE ( ! EXI/+ CIVILIZATION1 ! EXI/+ CONDITIONS UND] :I* WE LIVE 9 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES2 ?AT IS1 :]EV] IT IS POSSIBLE TO GET AT ! MASS ( WORK+ PEOPLE & PRES5T A PROGRAM ( ! ,9T]NATIONAL REVOLUTION>Y PROLET>IAT BY ME?ODS :I* GIVE US ?AT *ANCE4 ,FUR!RMORE1 IT SAYS1 0)\T AFFILIATION ) ANY POLITICAL P>TY10 :I* IS CORRECT4 ,WE CAN PURSUE ! ME?OD ( APPE>+ BE=E ! WORK+ CLASS ) ?IS PROGRAM )\T AFFILIATION1 & ,I BELIEVE ?AT ! S5T5CE OR P>AGRAPH /&S UPON ITS FEET1 NOT ?AT IT COMES \T CLE>1 BUT 5\< TO 5ABLE Y\ TO /UDY IT \T1 & ,I ?9K ?AT ANY P]SON :O WILL FOLL[ ?AT CLOSELY WILL SEE EXACTLY ! /ATUS ( IT4 ,D,E,L4 ,R,I,*,T,]3 ,! P>AGRAPH READS1 0BETWE5 !SE TWO CLASSES A /RUGGLE MU/ GO ON40 ,:Y MU/ IT GO ON8 ,D,E,L4 ,S,*,A,T,S,K,E3 ,UNTIL IT IS F9I%$4 ,D,E,L4 ,R,I,*,T,]3 0,UNTIL ! TOIL]S COME TOGE!R ON ! POLITICAL AS WELL AS ECONOMIC FIELD & TAKE & HOLD :AT !Y PRODUCE40 ,IT SAYS ?AT ! MOM5T Y\ BR+ ! WORK]S TOGE!R ON ! POLITICAL & ECONOMIC FIELD ! /RUGGLE CEASES4 ,AS A MATT] ( FACT1 IT JU/ />TS !N4 0,?AT :I* !Y PRODUCE10 :Y %\LD !Y TAKE IT8 ,DOESN'T IT BELONG TO !M8 ,IF ,I HAVE SOME?+ ,I DON'T NE$ TO TAKE IT4 ,TO TAKE IT IMPLIES ?AT ,I TAKE IT FROM SOME?+ \TSIDE ( ME1 BUT NOT FROM MYSELF4 ,?IS SAYS1 0:AT !Y PRODUCE BY !IR LABOR1 ?R\< AN ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION ( ! WORK+ CLASS )\T AFFILIATION ) ANY POLITICAL P>TY40 ,:Y %\LD ?AT /ATEM5T BE 9 ! ,PREAMBLE1 0)\T AFFILIATION ) ANY POLITICAL P>TY80 ,! =M ( ! ORGANIZATION WILL GIVE EXPRESSION !RETO4 ,AL?\< ?IS PHRASE WAS 9 ! ,MANIFE/O CALL+ ?IS CONV5TION1 ,I DO NOT SEE ANY NE$ TO HAVE IT 9 ! ,PREAMBLE4 ,MR4 ,*AIRMAN1 ,I MOVE ?AT ?IS P>AGRAPH BE /RICK5 \T & ! FOLL[+ SUB/ITUT$3 0,!RE CAN BE NO PEACE AS LONG AS AN 9CREASE ( WAGES ( ! :OLE WORK+ CLASS MEANS A CORRESPOND+ DECREASE ( PR(IT TO ! CAPITALI/ CLASS1 & VICE V]SA4 ,FROM !SE CONDITIONS A /RUGGLE >ISES :I* WILL NOT CEASE UNTIL ! WORK] IS LIFT$ \T ( HIS PRES5T M]*&ISE OR WAGE SLAV]Y POSITION ?R\< ! COLLECTIVE [N]%IP ( ! TOOLS ( PRODUCTION & DI/RIBUTION4 ,UNTIL SU* A *ANGE IS POSSIBLE ! WAGE WORK]S MU/ UNITE & ORGANIZE AS A CLASS ON ! 9DU/RIAL AS WELL AS POLITICAL FIELD1 HAV+ = !IR AIM AN EF=T TO REALIZE !IR CLASS 9T]E/S & TO SUPPORT & PROTECT !M 9 !IR /RUGGLE = EXI/5CE40 ,D,E,L4 ,P,>,K,E,S3 ,I SECOND ! MOTION TO ADOPT ! SUB/ITUTE1 TO GET IT BE=E ! H\SE4 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,IT HAS BE5 REGUL>LY MOV$ & SECOND$ ?AT P>AGRAPH TWO BE /RICK5 \T & ! SUB/ITUTE (F]$ BY ,DELEGATE ,RI*T] BE ADOPT$ 9/EAD4 ,>E Y\ READY = ! QUE/ION8 ,D,E,L4 ,D,E ,L,E,O,N3 ,! P>AGRAPH1 IF Y\ WILL LET ME READ IT OV] AGA91 SAYS3 0,BETWE5 !SE TWO CLASSES A /RUGGLE MU/ GO ON UNTIL ALL ! TOIL]S COME TOGE!R ON ! POLITICAL AS WELL AS ! 9DU/RIAL FIELD & TAKE & HOLD ?AT :I* !Y PRODUCE BY !IR LABOR1 ?R\< AN ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION ( ! WORK+ CLASS )\T AFFILIATION ) ANY POLITICAL P>TY40 ,?AT IS ! LANGUAGE AS (F]$4 ,I WI% TO SPEAK = ! CLAUSE AS A MEMB] ( ?AT COMMITTEE1 & AGA9/ ! PROPOS$ SUB/ITUTE4 ,! >GUM5T HAS BE5 MADE BY ,DELEGATE ,SIMONS ?AT ?AT IS CONTRADICTORY2 ?AT ?IS CLAUSE PROPOSES POLITICAL ACTION )\T A POLITICAL P>TY4 ,N[1 LET ME 9VITE Y\R ATT5TION TO ! ,MANIFE/O1 TO ! PROMISE & 9VITATION UND] :I* ?IS CONV5TION IS GA!R$1 & UND] ! T]MS ( :I* IT IS CONV5$4 ,Y\ WILL F9D ON PAGE F\R ( ?IS ISSUE ( ?IS =M ( ! ,MANIFE/O 7HOLD+ UP A COPY71 ?IS PASSAGE3 0,CRAFT DIVISIONS FO/] POLITICAL IGNORANCE AMONG ! WORK]S1 ?US ,D,I,V,I,D,+ ,?,A,T ,C,L,A,S,S ,A,T ,! ,B,A,L,L,O,T ,B,O,X AS WELL AS 9 %OP1 M9E & FACTORY02 & ON ! NEXT PAGE ( ! ,MANIFE/O Y\ F9D ?IS CLAUSE3 0,IT 7?IS ORGANIZATION7 %\LD BE E/ABLI%$ AS ! ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION ( ! WORK+ CLASS ,),\,T ,A,F,F,I,L,I,A,T,I,O,N ,) ,A,N,Y ,P,O,L,I,T,I,C,A,L4 ,P,>,T,Y40 ,IF TO RECOGNIZE ! NECESSITY ( UNIT+ ! WORK+ PEOPLE ON ! POLITICAL FIELD1 & 9 ! SAME BREA? TO SAY ?AT ! TAK+ & ! HOLD+ ( ! ?+S ?AT ! PEOPLE PRODUCE CAN BE DONE )\T AFFILIATION ) ANY POLITICAL P>TY--IF ?AT IS A CONTRADICTION2 IF IT CAN BE SAID ?AT !SE TWO CLAUSES 9 ?IS PROPOS$ P>AGRAPH >E CONTRADICTORY1 !N ! CONTRADICTION WAS ADVOCAT$ BY ,DELEGATE ,SIMONS HIMSELF1 :O WAS ONE ( ! SIGN]S ( ?IS ,MANIFE/O4 7,APPLAUSE74 ,H]E Y\ HAVE HIS SIGNATURE 7HOLD+ UP ! PAGE ( ! ,MANIFE/O ) ,SIMON'S SIGNATURE74 ,BUT1 DELEGATES1 !RE IS NO CONTRADICTION1 NONE :ATEV]2 & ,I CONSID] ?AT !SE TWO PASSAGES 9 ! ,MANIFE/O1 IF ANY ONE ?+ WAS TO BE PICK$ \T MORE PROM95T ?AN ANY O!R1 >E 9DE$ SIGNIFICANT ( ! /AGE ( DEVELOPM5T1 G5U9E CAPITALI/IC DEVELOPM5T 9 ,AM]ICA4 ,?IS ,MANIFE/O 5UM]ATES A S]IES ( EVILS ?AT RESULT FROM ! PRES5T CRAFT DIVISION3--IT %ATT]S ! RANKS ( ! WORK]S & R5D]S 9DU/RIAL & F9ANCIAL SOLID>ITY IMPOSSIBLE2 UNION M5 SCAB IT UPON ONE ANO!R2 JEAL\SY IS CREAT$1 & PROHIBITIVE 9ITIATION FEES >E ADOPT$2 0CRAFT DIVISIONS FO/] POLITICAL IGNORANCE AMONG ! WORK+ CLASS1 ?US DIVID+ !M AT ! BALLOT BOX40 ,IF ?IS1 ! DIVISION ( ! WORK+ CLASS ON ! POLITICAL FIELD1 IS AN EVIL1 !N IT FOLL[S ?AT UNITY ( ! WORK+ PEOPLE ON ! POLITICAL FIELD IS A ?+ TO BE DESIR$4 ,& SO IT IS2 & ?IS CLAUSE 9 ! ,PREAMBLE CORRECTLY SO /ATES IT4 ,?AT BE+ SO1 DOES ?IS O!R S5T5CE S\ND CONTRADICTORY1 ! S5T5CE ?AT PROVIDES ?AT ! NEW ORGANIZATION %ALL BE )\T AFFILIATION ) ANY POLITICAL P>TY8 ,! SITUATION 9 ,AM]ICA1 AS PRES5T$ BY ! ?\S& & ONE CAUSES ?AT GO TO CREATE PRES5T CONDITIONS1 REMOVES ! SEEM+ CONTRADICTION4 ,?AT SITUATION E/ABLI%ES ! FACT ?AT ! 0TAK+ & ! HOLD+0 ( ! ?+S ?AT LABOR NE$S TO BE FREE CAN NEV] DEP5D UPON A POLITICAL P>TY4 7,APPLAUSE74 ,IF ANY?+ IS CLE> 9 ! ,AM]ICAN SITUATION IT IS ?IS3 ,?AT IF ANY 9DIVIDUAL IS ELECT$ TO (FICE UPON A REVOLUTION>Y BALLOT1 ?AT 9DIVIDUAL IS A SUSPICI\S *>ACT]4 7,APPLAUSE74 ,:OEV] IS RETURN$ ELECT$ TO (FICE ON A PROGRAM ( LABOR EMANCIPATION2 :OEV] IS ALL[$ TO BE FILT]$ ?R\< BY ! POLITICAL ELECTION 9SPECTORS ( ! CAPITALI/IC CLASS2--?AT MAN IS A C>EFULLY SELECT$ TOOL1 A TRAITOR ( ! WORK+ PEOPLE1 SELECT$ BY ! CAPITALI/ CLASS4 7,APPLAUSE47 ,IT IS \T ( ! QUE/ION ?AT H]E 9 ,AM]ICA--,I AM SPEAK+ ( ,AM]ICA & NOT ,EUROPE--?AT H]E 9 ,AM]ICA A POLITICAL P>TY CAN ACCOMPLI% ?AT :I* ?IS CLAUSE DEM&S1 ! 0TAK+ & ! HOLD+40 ,I KN[ NOT A S+LE EXCEPTION ( ANY P>TY C&IDATE1 EV] ELECT$ UPON A POLITICAL PLAT=M ( ! EMANCIPATION ( ! WORK+ CLASS1 :O DID NOT SELL !M \T AS FA/ AS ELECT$4 7,APPLAUSE74 ,N[1 IT MAY BE ASK$1 0?AT BE+ SO1 :Y NOT ABOLI% ALTOGE!R ! POLITICAL MOVEM5T8 ,:Y1 AT ALL1 UNITE ! WORK]S ON ! POLITICAL FIELD80 ,! ASPIRATION TO UNITE ! WORK]S UPON ! POLITICAL FIELD IS AN ASPIRATION 9 L9E & 9 /EP ) CIVILIZATION4 ,CIVILIZ$ MAN1 :5 HE >GUES ) AN ADV]S>Y1 DOES NOT />T ) CL5*+ HIS FI/ & TELL+ HIM1 0SMELL ?IS BUN* ( BONES40 ,HE DOES NOT />T BY TELL+ HIM1 0FEEL MY BICEPS40 ,HE BEG9S ) >GU+2 PHYSICAL =CE BY >MS IS ! LA/ RESORT4 ,?AT IS ! ME?OD ( ! CIVILIZ$ MAN1 & ! ME?OD ( CIVILIZ$ MAN IS ! ME?OD ( CIVILIZ$ ORGANIZATION4 ,! B>B>IAN BEG9S ) PHYSICAL =CE2 ! CIVILIZ$ MAN 5DS ) ?AT1 :5 PHYSICAL =CE IS NECESS>Y4 7,APPLAUSE74 ,CIVILIZ$ MAN WILL ALWAYS H]E 9 ,AM]ICA GIVE A *ANCE TO PEACE2 HE WILL1 ACCORD+LY1 PROCE$ ALONG ! L9ES ?AT MAKE PEACE POSSIBLE4 ,BUT CIVILIZ$ MAN1 UNLESS HE IS A VISION>Y1 WILL KN[ ?AT UNLESS !RE IS ,MIY1 TO 0TAKE & HOLD40 ,)\T ! WORK+ PEOPLE >E UNIT$ ON ! POLITICAL FIELD2 )\T ! DELUSION HAS BE5 REMOV$ FROM !IR M9DS ?AT ANY ( ! ISSUES ( ! CAPITALI/ CLASS CAN DO = !M ANY?+ P]MAN5TLY1 OR EV5 TEMPOR>ILY2 )\T ! WORK+ PEOPLE HAVE BE5 REMOV$ ALTOGE!R FROM ! M5TAL ?RALLDOM ( ! CAPITALI/ CLASS1 FROM ITS 9SIDI\S 9FLU5CE1 !RE IS NO POSSIBILITY ( Y\R HAV+ ?OSE CONDITIONS UND] :I* !Y CAN REALLY ORGANIZE !MSELVES ECONOMICALLY 9 SU* A WAY AS TO 0TAKE & HOLD40 ,& AFT] ?OSE M5TAL CONDITIONS >E G5]ALLY E/ABLI%$1 !RE NE$S SOME?+ MORE ?AN ! /ATEM5T TO 0TAKE & HOLD02 SOME?+ MORE ?AN A POLITICAL DECL>ATION1 SOME?+ MORE ?AN ! P]MISSION ( ! CAPITALI/ POLITICAL 9SPECTORS TO ALL[ ?IS OR ?AT C&IDATE TO FILT] ?R\<4 ,Y\ !N NE$ ! 9DU/RIAL ORGANIZATION ( ! WORK+ CLASS1 SO ?AT1 IF ! CAPITALI/ %\LD BE FOOLI% 5\< 9 ,AM]ICA TO DEFEAT1 TO ?W>T ! WILL ( ! WORK]S EXPRESS$ BY ! BALLOT--,I DO NOT SAY 0! WILL ( ! WORK]S1 AS RETURN$ BY ! CAPITALI/ ELECTION 9SPECTORS10 BUT ! WILL ( ! PEOPLE AS EXPRESS$ AT ! BALLOT BOX--!N !RE WILL BE A CONDITION ( ?+S BY :I* ! WORK+ CLASS CAN ABSOLUTELY CEASE PRODUCTION1 & !REBY />VE \T ! CAPITALI/ CLASS1 & R5D] !IR PRES5T ECONOMIC MEANS & ALL !IR PREP>ATIONS = W> ABSOLUTELY USELESS4 7,APPLAUSE74 ,!N1 ! CLAUSE 0BETWE5 !SE TWO CLASSES A /RUGGLE MU/ GO ON UNTIL ALL ! TOIL]S COME TOGE!R ON ! POLITICAL AS WELL AS 9DU/RIAL FIELD1 & ,T,A,K,E ,& ,H,O,L,D ?AT :I* !Y PRODUCE BY !IR LABOR0--?R\< :AT8 ,?,R,\,< ,A,N ,E,C,O,N,O,M,I,C ,O,R,G,A,N,I,Z,A,T,I,O,N ,( ,! ,W,O,R,K,+ ,C,L,A,S,S1 0)\T AFFILIATION ) ANY POLITICAL P>TY10 /&S \T 9 ALL ! CLE>NESS ( ITS SOLID F\NDATION & *ALL5G+ S\NDNESS4 ,?AT CLAUSE IS A COND5SATION1 ,I %\LD SAY1 ( HUNDR$S ( VOLUMES N[ 9 ! LIBR>IES ( ! C\NTRY1 & ( MANY MORE VOLUMES ?AT HAVE NOT YET BE5 WRITT51 BUT ! FACTS UPON :I* !Y >E BAS$ >E COM+ =W>D4 ,ONE ( ! FACTS1 A FACT ( GREAT IMPORTANCE IS ?AT CURI\S APP>ITION--! VISION>Y POLITICIAN1 ! MAN :O IMAG9ES ?AT BY GO+ TO ! BALLOT BOX1 & TAK+ A PIECE ( PAP]1 & LOOK+ AB\T TO SEE IF ANYBODY IS WAT*+1 & ?R[+ IT 9 & !N RUBB+ HIS H&S & JOLLY+ HIMSELF ) ! EXPECTATION ?AT ?R\< ?AT PROCESS1 ?R\< SOME MY/IC AL*EMY1 ! BALLOT WILL T]M9ATE CAPITALISM1 & ! ,SOCIALI/ ,COMMONWEAL? WILL >ISE LIKE A FAIRY \T ( ! BALLOT BOX4 ,?AT IS NOT ONLY VISION>Y2 IT IS ! PRODUCT ( ?AT C[>DICE :I* WE F9D V]Y G5]ALLY 9 ! POLITICS ( SOME M5 :O CLAIM TO REPRES5T ! WORK+ CLASS 7APPLAUSE71 ON ACC\NT ( :I* WE F9D ?AT SU* POLITICS 9 N9E CASES \T ( T5 DEG5]ATE 9TO :AT IS CALL$ 0POSSIBILISM40 ,IT BR+S AB\T A REPETITION ( ! ME?ODS ( ! ,*RI/IAN *UR*1 :I* RAISES A F9E1 MAGNIFIC5T IDEAL 9 ! REMOTE FUTURE1 TO BE >RIV$ AT SOME TIME1 SOON] OR LAT]--RA!R LAT] ?AN SOON]--EV5TUALLY IF NOT LAT]--& 9 ! MEANTIME PRACTICES ALL 0POSSIBLE10 0PRACTICAL0 WRONG4 7,APPLAUSE74 ,I MA9TA9 ?AT ?IS CLAUSE1 CONSEQU5TLY1 IS NOT CONTRADICTORY1 BUT /ATES ! F\R-SQU>$ FACT4 7,APPLAUSE47 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,Y\R TIME IS UP4 ,D,E,L4 ,D,E ,L,E,O,N3 ,I AM DONE4 ,D,E,L4 ,M,U,R,T,A,U,<3 ,I DESIRE TO SPEAK 9 FAVOR ( ! CLAUSE AS READ1 NOT EXACTLY = ! REASONS PO9T$ \T BY ! PREVI\S SPEAK]1 BUT SIMPLY BECAUSE IT IS 9 ! FIELD ( POSSIBILISM & PRACTICABILITY4 7,APPLAUSE74 ,I CANNOT AGREE ) ! S5TIM5TS JU/ EXPRESS$1 BUT ) ! CLAUSE JU/ WRITT54 ,9 LOOK+ OV] ! PA/ & CONSID]+ ! GREAT NUMB] ( M51 ! M5 ( MANY IDEAS POLITICALLY & O!RWISE1 ?AT HAVE CONTEMPLAT$ COM+ 9TO ?IS ORGANIZATION1 ,I ?9K ?AT ?IS CLAUSE IS JU/ EXACTLY ! ?+1 & IT IS BORN ( EXACTLY ! SAME NE$ ?AT ! OLD L9E TRADE UNIONS MEAN :5 !Y SAY 0NO POLITICS 9 ! UNION40 ,IT IS BORN EXACTLY ( ?AT SAME NE$4 ,IT IS USELESS = US H]E TO ATTEMPT TO DISGUISE ! FACT ?AT WE HAVE EV]Y %ADE ( POLITICAL OP9ION4 ,WE HAVE ! ,SOCIALI/S--,I HAPP5 TO BE ONE ( !M--:O BELIEVE ?AT ACTION 9 ! POLITICAL L9E IS ABSOLUTELY NECESS>Y4 ,WE HAVE ! ,SOCIALI/1 ON ! O!R H&1 :O IS SO NE> ! AN>*I/ ?AT HE IS BEG9N+ TO ?9K AS ! AN>*I/ DOES1 ?AT ACTION ALONG ! POLITICAL L9E IS ABSOLUTELY H>MFUL 9/EAD ( BE+ USELESS4 ,WE HAVE ON ! O!R H&1 MEMB]S ( DIFF]5T RELIGI\S FAI?S1 RECOGNIZ+ ! FACT ( ! ABSOLUTE NECESSITY ( ! SOLID>ITY ( ! WORK+ CLASS1 BUT :O /ILL CANNOT GET AWAY FROM !IR E>LY TEA*+S1 !IR E>LY SUP]/ITION1 IF Y\ PLEASE1 & CANNOT GET 9TO ANY POLITICAL P>TY4 ,N[1 IF WE >E GO+ TO BE PRACTICAL1 IF WE >E GO+ TO WORK = POSSIBILISM1 AS IT HAS BE5 EXPRESS$1 WE HAD BETT] />T \T ALONG ! L9ES EXPRESS$ 9 ?AT SECTION ( ! ,PREAMBLE1 BECAUSE ONLY ALONG SU* L9ES IS IT POSSIBLE TO AMALGAMATE ! =CES ?AT WE WI% TO AMALGAMATE4 7,APPLAUSE47 ,D,E,L4 ,M,C,E,A,*,R,53 ,MR4 ,*AIRMAN & ,FELL[ ,DELEGATES3 ,I W\LD LIKE TO SPEAK 9 FAVOR ( ! CLAUSE AS PRES5T$ TO ?IS CONV5TION4 ,I W\LD LIKE TO SPEAK = ! CLAUSE1 NOT = ! LANGUAGE IT IS C\*$ 91 BUT = ! IDEAS IT REPRES5TS4 ,! IDEA 9VOLV$ 9 ?IS CLAUSE ( ?IS ,PREAMBLE IS ?IS3 ,?AT AN ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION1 F\ND$ UPON CLASS L9ES1 WILL SOON] OR LAT] AS AN ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION EXPRESS ITSELF POLITICALLY4 ,TO SAY AT ?IS TIME ?AT Y\ MU/ 5DORSE A POLITICAL P>TY :I* DOES NOT EXI/1 W\LD BE TO ANTICIPATE SOME?+ 9 ! FUTURE4 ,I BELIEVE ?AT ?IS CLAUSE IS ?OR\ICATOR4 ,D,E,L4 ,C,L,>,5,C,E ,S,M,I,?3 ,I CONFESS FRANKLY ?AT ,I AM UNABLE TO SAY :E!R ,I AGREE ) ! IDEAS ( ! ,COMMITTEE ON ,CON/ITUTION OR NOT1 SIMPLY BECAUSE ! ,PREAMBLE DOES NOT EXPRESS CLE>LY TO ME ANY IDEA OR ANY PR9CIPLE4 ,IT SEEMS TO ME ?AT ?IS P>AGRAPH ( ! ,PREAMBLE P>TICUL>LY IS 9T5D$1 NOT TO REPRES5T ! PR9CIPLES & PURPOSES ( 9DU/RIALISM1 BUT REPRES5TS A TOADYISM TO ?REE DIFF]5T FACTIONS 9 ?IS CONV5TION 7APPLAUSE71 & ,I AM OPPOS$ TO ?IS ORGANIZATION TOADY+ TO ANY MAN OR ANY FACTION ( M54 ,LET ?IS CONV5TION /ATE ! PR9CIPLES ( 9DU/RIALISM1 & IF ! FACTIONS SEE FIT TO FALL 9 L9E & SUPPORT !N1 WELL & GOOD4 ,IT SEEMS TO ME ?AT ?IS P>AGRAPH C\LD NOT HAVE BE5 MORE 9VOLV$ OR MORE CONFUS+ IF IT HAD BE5 WRITT5 BY ! PLAT=M COMMITTEE ( ! ,REPUBLICAN OR ,DEMOCRATIC P>TY4 ,IT SEEMS TO ME AS IF ! P>AGRAPH IS 9T5D$ TO BE TOADY+ TO ! MAN :O DOES NOT BELIEVE 9 POLITICS AT ALL1 ! PURE & SIMPLE TRADE UNIONI/ AS WE HAVE COME TO CALL HIM2 ?AT IT MEANS A TOADY+ TO ! ,SOCIALI/1 & ALSO TO ! AN>*I/1 IF Y\ PLEASE4 ,IT SEEMS TO ME ?AT ?IS P>AGRAPH IS 9T5D$ TO BE SU* ?AT ! SUPPORT] ( ?IS MOVEM5T CAN PO9T TO IT :5 TALK+ TO A PURE & SIMPLE UNIONI/ & SAY1 0?AT IS JU/ :AT Y\ WANT1 & EXPRESSES :AT Y\ BELIEVE 940 ,I BELIEVE IT IS 9T5D$ TO BE SU* ?AT A ,SOCIALI/ CAN BE PO9T$ TO ?IS PLAT=M ) ! /ATEM5T ?AT 0?IS IS ,SOCIALISM40 ,I BELIEVE IT IS 9T5D$ TO BE SU* ?AT AN AN>*I/ CAN BE CONFRONT$ ) ?IS PLAT=M & TOLD ?AT 0?IS MEANS AN>*Y AS IT IS WRITT5 RIAGRAPH40 ,I BELIEVE ?AT IS :AT ?IS P>AGRAPH IS 9T5D$ TO BE1 & ,I AM OPPOS$ TO ?AT SORT ( FAD MYSELF4 ,I MAY BE WRONG1 ,MR4 ,*AIRMAN4 ,?IS P>AGRAPH MAY BE 5TIRELY CLE> TO EV]Y O!R P]SON 9 ?IS CONV5TION1 BUT ,I CONFESS IT IS NOT CLE> TO ME4 ,I EXPECT TO DO SOME TALK+ = ?IS MOVEM5T AFT] ?IS CONV5TION4 ,I AM GO+ TO TALK TO 9DIVIDUALS :]EV] ,I F9D !M = ?IS MOVEM5T1 & ,I CANNOT AF=D TO HAVE ,BRO!R ,DE ,LEON ALONG ) ME EV]Y TIME ,I MEET A MAN1 TO EXPLA9 :AT ?IS P>AGRAPH MEANS4 7,APPLAUSE74 ,I MOVE Y\ ?AT ?IS P>AGRAPH & ! BALANCE ( ?IS ,PREAMBLE BE REF]R$ BACK TO ! ,COMMITTEE ON ,CON/ITUTION = A CLE>] P>AGRAPH & A ,PREAMBLE ?AT REPRES5TS MORE CLE>LY ! PR9CIPLES & PURPOSES ( 9DU/RIALISM4 7,SECOND$47 ,D,E,L4 ,S,I,M,O,N,S3 ,I RISE TO SECOND ?AT MOTION4 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,! DELEGATES :O HAVE SPOK5 SEEM TO ?9K ?AT !Y >E TALK+ ON P>AGRAPH TWO ( Y\R ,CON/ITUTIONAL ,COMMITTEE'S ,PREAMBLE4 ,?AT IS NOT ! FACT4 ,! DELEGATE H]E (F]$ A SUB/ITUTE ?AT IS N[ BE=E ! CONV5TION4 ,D,E,L4 ,S,I,M,O,N,S3 ,IS ?IS MOTION \T ( ORD] !N8 ,D,E,L4 ,S,M,I,?3 ,IS A MOTION TO REF] \T ( ORD]8 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,NO1 A MOTION TO REF] IS 9 ORD]1 BUT Y\ W]E TALK+ 5TIRELY TO ?IS P>AGRAPH1 & ! DELEGATE N[ RISES TO A QUE/ION ( PRIVILEGE4 ,D,E,L4 ,S,I,M,O,N,S3 ,NO1 ,I SIMPLY SECOND ?IS MOTION1 & IF ?AT MOTION COMES BE=E ! H\SE ,I W\LD LIKE TO SPEAK ON IT4 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,! MOTION IS TO REF] ?IS ,PREAMBLE BACK TO ! ,COMMITTEE ON ,CON/ITUTION4 ,>E Y\ READY = ! QUE/ION8 ,D,E,L4 ,S,I,M,O,N,S3 ,I JU/ WANT TO SUGGE/ TWO OR ?REE O!R ?+S ?AT ,I AM SATISFI$ \E C]TA9 ?+S ?AT \E C]TA9 ?+S ?AT DI/+UI% ?IS ORGANIZATION CLE>LY & PLA9LY FROM O!R ORGANIZATIONS4 ,!RE IS ! ONE TE/ 9 !RE1 ! PR9CIPLE ( ! CLASS /RUGGLE4 ,! PR9CIPLE ( ! 9DEP5D5T POLITICAL ACTION1 ,I AM NOT 9SI/+ ON4 ,I W\LD LIKE TO HAVE IT2 ?AT IS MY SIDE ( ! PROPOSITION4 ,I AM 9 FAVOR ( IT1 & ,I WANT TO SEE IT 9 !RE4 ,I ALSO BELIEVE ?AT ?IS %\LD BE BROAD 5\<1 & ,I ?9K ,COMRADE ,SMI? WILL ALSO AGREE ) ME ?AT IT %\LD BE BROAD 5\< TO ADMIT ! AN>*I/ & ! ,SOCIALI/ & ! M5 :O DO NOT BELIEVE 9 POLITICAL ACTION AT ALL 9 ANY WAY1 PROVID+ !Y /& BY ! O!R PR9CIPLE4 ,! FACT IS ?AT WE ALL ADMIT ! TWO PR9CIPLES :I* /& \T CLE>LY ON ! ECONOMIC FIELD2 FIR/1 ?AT ?IS ORGANIZATION IS OPPOS$ TO ALL B>GA9+ ACROSS ! L9E BETWE5 ! CAPITALI/ & ! LABOR]2 & 9 ! SECOND PLACE1 ?AT ! =M ( ORGANIZATION %\LD BE 9DU/RIAL & NOT CRAFT4 ,N[1 IT SEEMS TO ME ?AT ?OSE PO9TS >E NOT BR\LY 9 ?AT ,PREAMBLE1 & ?OSE >E ! ?+S ?AT \ ABOVE EV]Y?+ ELSE4 ,IT MAY BE MY FAULT ?AT ,I CANNOT UND]/&1 BUT ,I DO NOT SEE IT4 ,D,E,L4 ,D,E ,L,E,O,N3 ,I AM TALK+ H]E TO ! MOTION ( ,DELEGATE ,SMI?4 ,DELEGATE ,SMI?'S /ATEM5T WAS ?AT ?IS P>AGRAPH IS A TOADY+ TO ?REE DI/9CT IDEAS2 ! PURE & SIMPLE IDEA1 ! ,SOCIALI/ POLITICAL ACTION IDEA1 & ! AN>*I/ IDEA4 ,DO ,I UND]/& Y\ CORRECTLY8 ,D,E,L4 ,C,L,>,5,C,E ,S,M,I,?3 ,YES18 ,D,E,L4 ,D,E ,L,E,O,N3 ,?AT WAS ! SUB/ANCE4 ,N[1 HE C]TA9LY IS MI/AK5 :5 HE SAYS ?AT !RE IS ANY TOADY+ H]E TO ! PURE & SIMPLE IDEA1 BECAUSE ! PURE & SIMPL] /ATES ?AT POLITICS >E EXACTLY LIKE RELIGION1 & ?AT A MAN CAN GO HIS [N WAY UPON IT4 ,I DO NOT KN[ A S+LE 9/ANCE ( A PURE & SIMPL] :O WILL SAY ?AT ! WORK+ PEOPLE MU/ BE UNIT$ ON ! POLITICAL FIELD2 SO ?AT SO F> AS TOADY+ TO ! PURE & SIMPL] IS CONC]N$1 ,I FAIL TO SEE IT4 ,!RE REMA9S :AT IS LOOSELY CALL$ ! ,SOCIALI/ POLITICAL & ! AN>*I/ IDEA1 UND]/&+ BY ! LATT] ! RECOGNITION ( ! MISSION ( PHYSICAL =CE4 ,>E !Y TOADI$ TO8 ,IF IT IS BELIEV$ ?AT !RE IS ANY TOADY+ DONE T[>DS EI!R1 IT MU/ PROCE$ FROM ! OP9ION ?AT ANY ONE ( !M HAS1 EXCLUSIVE ( ! O!R1 ! :OLE TRU?2 IT MU/ PROCE$ FROM ! IDEA ?AT ONE OR ! O!R IS ABSOLUTELY WRONG4 ,! TRU? IS ?AT !Y >E BO? BUT A FRACTION ( ! TRU?4 ,I DO NOT BELIEVE ?AT :5 Y\ /ATE ?AT TWO BONES BELONG TO A BODY Y\ >E TOADY+ TO EI!R BONE4 ,IF Y\ SCRAT* A POLITICAL ,SOCIALI/ Y\ WILL F9D A MAN :O SAYS ?AT ! TRADE UNION IS GO+ TO DIE \T & !RE IS NO USE BO!R+ AB\T IT4 ,!Y DON'T WANT ANY ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION2 !Y DON'T WANT ANY 9DU/RIAL ORGANIZATION2 H5CE !Y >E MOONCALVES1 BALLOT MANIACS4 ,ON ! O!R H&1 IF Y\ LOOK AT ! AN>*I/1 HE1 DISGU/$ AT ! POLITICAL MOONCALVES1 FLIES TO ! O!R EXTREME1 & SAYS3 0POLITICAL ACTION IS :OLLY USELESS10 & Y\ ?9K ( PHYSICAL =CE 9/ANTLY & ALONE4 ,! POSITION ( ! ,COMMITTEE WAS ACCORD+LY ONE1 NOT ( TOADY+ T[>DS EI!R ( ! TWO1 BUT ( RECOGNIZ+ ! TRU? 9 BO? CAMPS3 ! TRU? 9 ! ,SOCIALI/ POLITICAL CAMP1 ?AT POLITICAL ACTION & ! MEANS ( CIVILIZATION MU/ BE GIV5 AN OPPORTUNITY2 & RECOGNIZ+ AT ! SAME TIME ! FACT ?AT 9 ?IS C\NTRY1 = ONE1 IT IS \T ( ! QUE/ION TO IMAG9E ?AT A POLITICAL P>TY CAN 0TAKE & HOLD40 ,CONSEQU5TLY !RE >E TWO DI/9CT IDEAS ?AT RUN 9TO EA* O!R1 & ! OP9ION ( ,DELEGATE ,SMI? UPON ! SUBJECT PROCE$S FROM ! NOTION ?AT ! TWO CAMPS1 AN>*I/1 SO-CALL$1 & ,SOCIALI/1 >E DIVID$ BY AN UNBRIDGEABLE *ASM2 O!RWISE !RE CANNOT BE ANY TOADY+4 ,= IF !RE IS SOME?+ ?AT Y\ HOLD IS RI AS ! PURE & SIMPL] IS CONC]N$1 HE IS KNOCK$ ON ! HEAD--DO Y\ CALL ?AT TOADY+8 ,I GUESS HE DOES NOT--BECAUSE HIS ATTITUDE IS ?AT POLITICS >E SIMPLY LIKE RELIGION & %\LD BE EXCLUD$ ABSOLUTELY4 ,D,E,L4 ,G,I,L,B,],T3 ,I WI% TO SPEAK TO ! MOTION TO REF]4 ,I AM OPPOS$ TO ! MOTION TO REF] = ! SIMPLE REASON ?AT !RE IS NO CON/ITUTIONAL QUE/ION 9VOLV$4 ,IF WE WILL LOOK AT ?AT IT IS QUITE LIKELY WE WILL DISCOV] ?IS4 ,FIR/1 WE >E H]E TO EFFECT AN ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION4 ,!RE >E TWO ELEM5TS 9 ?IS CONV5TION4 ,ONE ELEM5T PROPOSES TO DO AWAY ) POLITICAL ACTION 5TIRELY4 ,ANO!R ELEM5T IS 9CL9$ T[>D POLITICAL ACTION4 ,ALL ?AT ?IS P>AGRAPH IS 9 ESS5CE IS ?IS3 ,IT FIR/ ( ALL /ATES V]Y CLE>LY & PLA9LY ?AT ?IS IS PRIM>ILY AN ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION BAS$ UPON ! CONFLICT ( CLASSES4 ,SECONDLY1 IT SAYS 9 ESS5CE ?IS3 ,?AT AS 9DIVIDUALS Y\ >E P]FECTLY FREE TO TAKE SU* POLITICAL ACTION AS Y\ MAY SEE FIT4 ,AS AN ORGANIZATION Y\ CANNOT4 ,?AT IS CORRECT4 7,APPLAUSE74 ,?IRDLY1 9 ESS5CE IT SAYS ?IS3 ,Y\ %ALL NOT AS AN ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION /& COMMITT$ TO ANY POLITICAL P>TY AT PRES5T 9 EXI/5CE4 ,Y\ MAY SAY1 0,:Y1 !N1 %ALL WE SAY ?AT !RE IS ANY USE 9 ! BALLOT80 ,?IS IS :Y3 ,BECAUSE1 AS ,COMRADE ,DE ,LEON M5TION$ E>LI] 9 ! DISCUSSION1 ! BALLOT IS ONE ( ! ?+S G5]ALLY AGRE$ UPON BY CIVILIZ$ M5 TO FITS ( ?IS 9DU/RIAL ORGANIZATION1 ! 9DIVIDUALS COMPOS+ IT1 :5EV] !Y SEE FIT TO VOTE !Y WILL ONLY VOTE = ?AT POLITICAL P>TY ?AT REFLECTS !IR ECONOMIC 9T]E/4 7,APPLAUSE74 ,I DO NOT C>E :AT NAME ?AT POLITICAL P>TY HAS4 ,Y\ CANNOT CONJURE ) A NAME4 ,IF ! ,SOCIALI/ P>TY WANTS TO REPRES5T ! ECONOMIC 9T]E/ ( ! WORK+ CLASS IT CAN ONLY DO SO BY COM+ BE=E US ) SU* A PROGRAM ?AT IT APPEALS TO \R ECONOMIC 9T]E/4 7,APPLAUSE74 ,IF IT FAILS TO DO ?AT1 & IF ! ,SOCIALI/ ,LABOR ,P>TY DOES IT1 !N ! ,SOCIALI/ ,LABOR ,P>TY WILL HAVE CLAIMS ON ! 9DIVIDUAL'S FEALTY4 ,& IF ?AT FAILS TO DO IT SOME POLITICAL P>TY WILL >ISE1 BECAUSE WE %\LD REMEMB] ?IS1 ,MR4 ,*AIRMAN & ,COMRADES1 ?AT ANY POLITICAL P>TY1 ,I C>E NOT :AT IT MAY BE1 IT CAN ONLY EXI/ AS ! MANIFE/ATION ( AN ECONOMIC 9T]E/1 ?AT IS ALL4 ,CONSEQU5TLY ?IS DOES NOT 9VOLVE A CON/ITUTIONAL QUE/ION4 ,WE >E SIMPLY /AT+ ?AT PRIM>ILY WE >E AN ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION BAS$ UPON ! CONFLICT ( CLASSES4 ,SECONDLY1 ?AT AS 9DIVIDUALS WE MAY USE EV]Y MEANS1 BO? POLITICAL & ECONOMIC2 ?IRDLY1 ?AT WE DO NOT /& COMMITT$ TO ANY POLITICAL ORGANIZATION 9 EXI/5CE4 ,!RE=E1 ,I ?9K IT %\LD /& AS WRITT54 7,APPLAUSE47 ,D,E,L4 ,K,L,E,M,5,S,I,C3 ,MR4 ,*AIRMAN & ,FELL[ ,DELEGATES3 ,WE MU/ NOT OV]LOOK ! FACT ?AT WE >E H]E AS WORK+M51 & AS SU* WE DO NOT RECOGNIZE ! ,SOCIALI/1 ! AN>*I/ OR ANY O!R K9D ( I/4 ,WE >E H]E AS WORK+M5 & AS REBELS4 7,APPLAUSE74 ,! REASON :Y WE >E H]E IS ?AT WE WANT TO DEVISE WAYS & MEANS :]EBY WE ALL CAN AGREE1 & AS ! PREVI\S SPEAK] /AT$ ALREADY1 ! ECONOMIC CONDITION ( ! WORK+MAN IS ! F\NDATION1 IS ! FUNDAM5TAL CONDITION ( HIS BE+ & HIS WELF>E & HIS DEVELOPM5T4 ,N[1 !N1 ?IS BE+ ! CASE1 IT LAYS ! F\NDATION ?AT ECONOMICALLY WE ALL >E UNIT$ & WE ALL HAVE ! DESIRE TO UNITE1 = ! SIMPLE FACT ?AT 9 ! PA/ HI/ORY ( EV]Y ONE ( US \R DIVISION CAME FROM ! WORK ( ! CAPITALI/ & EXPLOIT+ CLASS4 ,N[1 !N1 WE COME H]E TO AGREE1 & WE ALL AGREE ON ! ECONOMICS AS ! FUNDAM5TAL QUE/ION4 ,WE READILY RECOGNIZE ! FACT ?AT !RE >E M5 :O BELIEVE 9 POLITICAL ACTION1 & !Y >E 5TITL$ TO2 !RE >E O!RS ?AT BELIEVE /RAITIES >E RIT )1 \R ECONOMIC F\NDATION IS ! ONE ON :I* WE >E ALL AGRE$1 & !SE TWO WAYS1 POLITICAL ACTION & NONPOLITICAL ACTION1 >E ONLY A QUE/ION ( ME?OD1 A QUE/ION ( JUDGM5T1 ( PRACTICABILITY OR :ATEV] IT IS4 ,BUT1 AS ,COMRADE ,DE ,LEON /AT$ IT V]Y WELL1 !RE >E MANY *ANCES 9 EV]Y POLITICAL P>TY TO GIVE WEITY & ! ,SOCIALI/ ,LABOR ,P>TY >E LOOK+ AFT] IT TO ELIM9ATE ! FAKIR AS MU* AS POSSIBLE4 ,!RE=E1 ,I APPEAL TO ALL ( Y\ NOT TO =GET ! PO9T ON :I* WE >E UNIT$1 ! FUNDAM5TAL ECONOMIC ACTION4 ,I ?9K ! ,MANIFE/O 9 ITS CLAUSE IS %ORT & BRIEF1 BUT IS BROAD 5\< TO EMBODY ALL !SE DIFF]5T FACTIONS1 & ,I AM HE>TILY 9 FAVOR ( ?IS CLAUSE AS IT /&S4 ,D,E,L4 ,T4 ,J4 ,H,A,G,],T,Y3 ,MR4 ,*AIRMAN1 AS A MEMB] ( ! ,COMMITTEE ON ,CON/ITUTION1 ,I AM OPPOS$ TO REF]R+ ?IS CLAUSE BACK TO ?IS ,COMMITTEE1 NOT ONLY = ! REASONS SO V]Y PLA9LY & CONV9C+LY \TL9$ BY ,DELEGATES ,GILB]T1 ,DE ,LEON1 ,KLEM5SIC1 & O!RS1 BUT ALSO = ! REASON ?AT ?IS ,PREAMBLE IS NOT DRAWN UP BY ! ,PRESS & ,LIT]ATURE ,COMMITTEE1 BUT BY ! ,CON/ITUTION ,COMMITTEE4 ,IT IS NOT DESIGN$ AS AN EXHAU/IVE TREATISE ON !SE QUE/IONS4 ,ITS FUNCTION1 AS WE UND]/& IT1 IS SIMPLY A /ATEM5T ( B>E FACTS & NOT ! PRO( ( ?OSE FACTS1 :I* IS IMPOSSIBLE 9 A ,PREAMBLE4 ,WE >E AGRE$ ON ! BREAD & BUTT] QUE/ION1 ALL ( US4 ,WE >E AGRE$ ?AT WE NE$ FOOD1 %ELT] & RAIM5T4 ,! ECONOMIC1 AS ,COMRADE ,KLEM5SIC JU/ SAID1 IS ! F\NDATION 9 ! LA/ ANALYSIS1 & IT IS NOT ! P>T ( ! ,CON/ITUTION ,COMMITTEE TO 5GAGE 9 A LONG-W9D$ RHETORICAL FLIE PL5TY ( OPPORTUNITIES1 ) ?IS ,PREAMBLE AS A BASIS1 = ALL MANN] ( ORATORS & ALL K9DS ( POLITICIANS TO BURN UP ! OXYG5 \T ( ! ATMOSPH]E ) LONG PHRASES & F9E TE*NICAL HAIRSPLITT+4 ,! FUNDAM5TAL FACT IS H]E /AT$ & \T ( ! $UCATIONAL PROPAG&A ( ! PROPOS$ ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION4 ,TO LOAD D[N ?IS ,PREAMBLE ) ALL ! SUGGE/IONS ?AT >E TURN$ 9 H]E1 ESPECIALLY ! SUGGE/IONS FROM ONE ( ! DELEGATES1 W\LD MEAN ! TURN+ ( ?IS ,CON/ITUTION 9TO A FOLIO ( A HUNDR$ PAGES OR MORE BY ! TIME Y\ GOT ?R\<4 ,! ,CON/ITUTION %\LD BE A BRIEF1 PI?Y1 CONCISE DOCUM5T1 WRITT5 9 ! LANGUAGE ( WORK+M51 NOT WRITT5 9 ! LANGUAGE ( ,PR\DHON1 NOT WRITT5 9 ! LANGUAGE ( ,BAKUN9 OR ,M>X OR ,5GELS1 BUT WRITT5 9 ! PLA91 EV]YDAY LANGUAGE ( ! MAN 9 OV]ALLS4 ,WE WANT TO APPEAL TO ! MAN 9 OV]ALLS4 7,APPLAUSE74 ,WE WANT TO ORGANIZE ! PLA9 COMMON WORK+MAN1 ! WORK+MAN :O C\LD NOT1 TO SAVE HIS IMMORTAL S\L1 TELL Y\ ! DIFF]5CE BETWE5 V>IABLE CAPITAL & CON/ANT CAPITAL1 :O C\LD NOT DI/+UI% ! MO/ TE*NICAL PROPOSITION 9 AN ACADEMIC /ATEM5T4 ,WE WANT TO TALK TO ?AT MAN 9 HIS [N LANGUAGE4 ,!RE=E1 ,I AM OPPOS$ TO REF]R+ ?IS ?+ BACK AGA94 ,I ALSO WANT P]SONALLY TO RES5T ! 9S9UATION ( ,DELEGATE ,SMI? ?AT ?IS IS TOADY+ TO ANYBODY1 NO MATT] :O HE IS OR :AT HE IS1 OR TO ANY EXI/+ 9/ITUTION1 NO MATT] :AT IT MAY BE4 ,WE >E WORK+ H]E = ! WORK+ CLASS4 ,WE DO NOT C>E AB\T ANY FACTIONS4 ,WE >E AGRE$ ONLY ON ! SUB/ANCE1 UPON ! FACT ?AT WE WANT TO TAKE & HOLD ALL ! ?+S ?AT BELONG TO ! WORK+ CLASS1 & WE WANT ! GOODS1 & WE WANT TO PUT ! BOOTS TO ! O!R FELL[4 7,APPLAUSE47 ,D,E,L4 ,L,I,L,I,A,N ,=,B,],G3 ,I WANT TO OPPOSE ! AM5DM5T ?AT WAS (F]$ BY ,COMRADE ,SMI?1 BECAUSE IT SEEMS TO ME IT IS A WA/E ( TIME4 ,IT SEEMS TO ME ?AT ?IS P>AGRAPH 9 ! ,PREAMBLE IS JU/ AS CLE> & PLA9 ON :AT WE >E GO+ TO DO AS LANGUAGE CAN BE MADE TO EXPRESS IT4 ,IT SAYS DI/9CTLY ?AT ?IS /RUGGLE1 MEAN+ ! /RUGGLE BETWE5 CAPITAL & LABOR1 MU/ GO ON UNTIL ! =CES >E UNIT$ ON ! POLITICAL FIELD4 ,?AT MEANS ! =CES ( CAPITAL ON ! ONE SIDE UNIT$ 9 A SOLID POLITICAL P>TY1 & ! =CES ( ! WORK+ PEOPLE ON ! O!R SIDE4 ,IT DI/9CTLY SAYS ?AT ?IS /RUGGLE MU/ GO ON4 ,IT /ATES 9 ! NEXT P>AGRAPH ?AT WE COME H]E TO ORGANIZE AN ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION ( ! WORK+ CLASS1 BAS$ ON ! CLASS /RUGGLE1 )\T ANY AFFILIATION ) ANY POLITICAL P>TY :ATSOEV]4 ,:AT HAS BE5 ! TR\BLE ) ! WORK+ CLASS MOVEM5T 9 ALL ! TIME ?AT HAS GONE BE=E8 ,BECAUSE !RE HAS BE5 NO ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION BAS$ ON ! CLASS /RUGGLE4 ,! OLD ,AM]ICAN ,F$]ATION ( ,LABOR IS BAS$ ON ! IDEA ( H>MONY1 ?AT ! 9T]E/S ( CAPITAL & LABOR >E ID5TICAL1 & ! OLD POLITICAL P>TIES HAVE BE5 ! EXPRESSION ( ?AT IDEA1 & HAVE BE5 JU/ AS MUDDL$ AS ! EXPRESSION ( ! ,AM]ICAN ,F$]ATION ( ,LABOR4 ,IF Y\ ORGANIZE H]E AN ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION BAS$ ON ! CLASS /RUGGLE1 ! WORK+M5 ?AT CAME 9TO ?AT ORGANIZATION WILL UND]/& ?AT IT IS BATTL+ ON ! WORK+MAN'S SIDE1 & !Y WILL COME TO UND]/& ?AT NO POLITICAL P>TY CAN BE PUT UP BY ! CAPITALI/S TO REPRES5T ! WORK+ CLASS1 & ! TIME WILL COME :5 NO POLITICAL P>TY :I* IS ! EXPRESSION ( ! 9T]E/S ( ! CAPITALI/S CAN GET ! VOTE ( A WORK+MAN BELONG+ TO AN ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION ( ! WORK+ CLASS BAS$ ON ! CLASS /RUGGLE4 7,APPLAUSE47 ,D,E,L4 ,D,+,]3 ,I %ALL NOT TAKE UP MU* ( Y\R TIME4 ,:AT ,I HAVE TO SAY ,I CAN SAY 9 V]Y FEW WORDS4 ,IT SEEMS TO ME ?AT WE WORK+M5 :O COME H]E FROM ALL OV] ?IS C\NTRY1 COME H]E = BUS9ESS4 & NOT = ANY O!R PURPOSE4 ,WE COME H]E TO EXPRESS 9 ! CON/ITUTION ?AT WE MAY ADOPT ! S5TIM5TS ?AT CAUS$ ?IS GA!R+ TO COME TOGE!R4 ,IT SEEMS TO ME ?AT ! PROPOSITION ( ,DELEGATE ,SIMONS IS /RANGELY CONTRADICTORY4 ,HE /AT$ ?AT HE AGRE$ ) ! O!R DELEGATE ?AT ?IS ,COMMITTEE WAS TRY+ TO TOADY TO SOME ( ! ELEM5TS 9 ?IS CONV5TION1 & !N HE GOES ON RECORD AS SAY+ ?AT HE WI%ES ?IS REF]R$ BACK TO ! ,COMMITTEE TO MAKE IT BROAD 5\<4 ,N[1 IF ,I UND]/& ! MEAN+ ( BROADNESS CORRECTLY1 9 ?IS CASE IT MEANS JU/ ! V]Y SAME ?+ ?AT HE CONDEMNS4 ,?IS IS BROAD 5\< = ME4 ,I WANT TO TELL Y\ AS A MEMB] ( ! ,S4 ,T4 @& ,L4 ,A4 & ! ,SOCIALI/ ,LABOR ,P>TY ?AT ,I AM NOT H]E TO =CE MY IDEAS UPON ANY ONE4 ,UNLESS ,I CAN CONV9CE A MAN ?AT ,I AM RITY4 ,I BELIEVE ?AT ! ,SOCIALI/ ,LABOR ,P>TY IS RITY IS ! ONLY POLITICAL ORGANIZATION 9 EXI/5CE ?AT CAN EMANCIPATE ! WORK+ CLASS4 ,BUT ?AT HAS NO?+ TO DO ) ! CASE4 ,I AM A MEMB] ( ! ,SOCIALI/ ,LABOR ,P>TY ONLY 9 SO F> AS ,I BELIEVE & AM FIRM 9 ! CONVICTION ?AT IT REPRES5TS ! 9T]E/S ( MY CLASS4 ,O!RWISE1 ,I DO NOT C>E ONE :IT = ! ,SOCIALI/ ,LABOR ,P>TY4 7,APPLAUSE74 ,I AM OPPOS$ TO POLITICAL TIE NOT P]=M+4 ,WE >E WAGE SLAVES FROM ! MILLS1 M9ES & FACTORIES4 ,N[1 LET US ADOPT A COMMON S5SE PROPOSITION UPON :I* WE CAN PROCE$4 ,I AM ANXI\S TO BE ONE ( ?OSE :O WILL GO \T & TRY TO GET MORE ( \R FELL[ WORK+M5 TO AFFILIATE ) ?IS ORGANIZATION1 BUT IF Y\ WANT ME TO DO ?AT ,I WANT A PROP] BASIS ON :I* TO PROCE$4 ,I WANT TO HAVE SOME K9D ( A PR9CIPLE UPON :I* TO /& SO ?AT ,I NE$ NOT BE A%AM$ ( MY AFFILIATION ) ! ,SOCIALI/ ,LABOR ,P>TY4 ,I BELIEVE1 ,MR4 ,*AIRMAN & ,DELEGATES1 ?AT ?IS IS SUFFICI5TLY CLE>1 & ,I BELIEVE ?AT !RE IS NO MAN 9 ?IS MOVEM5T :O CANNOT GO =? SATISFI$ ?AT HE IS REPRES5T+ ! 9T]E/S ( ! WORK+ CLASS BY ADOPT+ ! ORIG9AL AS IT IS4 ,I AM OPPOS$ TO REF]R+ IT TO ! ,COMMITTEE4 ,D,E,L4 ,L,A ,M,O,N,T,E3 ,I W\LD LIKE TO ASK1 AS A MATT] ( 9=MATION1 TO HAVE ,COMRADE ,DE ,LEON'S AM5DM5T READ4 ,I W\LD LIKE TO KN[ JU/ :]E WE >E AT BE=E ,I GO ON4 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,I DON'T UND]/& Y\4 ,D,E,L4 ,L,A ,M,O,N,T,E3 ,:AT IS ! /ATUS ( ! BUS9ESS8 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,! MOTION BE=E ! CONV5TION AT ?IS TIME IS TO REF] ?IS ,PREAMBLE BACK TO ! ,COMMITTEE ON ,CON/ITUTION1 ?IS P>AGRAPH TWO4 ,P>AGRAPH ONE HAS BE5 ADOPT$4 ,D,E,L4 ,L,A ,M,O,N,T,E3 ,?IS ?+ HAS BE5 PUT 9TO AS PLA9 ,5GLI% AS IT IS POSSIBLE TO GET IT4 ,!Y HAVE MADE A /ATEM5T ( ! CLASS /RUGGLE1 & UPON ?AT PO9T IT W\LD ONLY BE A WA/E ( TIME TO REF] IT BACK TO ! ,COMMITTEE & MAKE ! ,COMMITTEE DO ! WORK OV] AGA9 ?AT !Y HAVE HONE/LY SP5T !IR TIME UPON = TWO DAYS4 ,:Y %\LD ?IS ?+ BE REPEAT$8 ,I HAVE BE5 H]E = DAYS1 & ?IS CONV5TION HAS BE5 WA/+ ITS TIME 9 W9DJAMM+4 ,Y\ HAVE GOT A /ATEM5T H]E BR\I\S P>TS ( ! HALL4 ,D,E,L4 ,G,L,A,S,G,[3 ,IT HAS BE5 SAID ?AT !RE HAS NEV] BE5 AN ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION BAS$ ON ! CLASS /RUGGLE4 ,I WANT TO SAY ?AT ! ,KNIE CORRECT1 BRO!R4 ,I ?9K Y\ HAVE /AT$ ! PROPOSITION CORRECTLY4 ,! DELEGATE MAY PROCE$4 ,D,E,L4 ,G,L,A,S,G,[3 ,N[1 ,I MU/ RETURN TO ! QUE/ION ( ! ,KNIE NOT :AT Y\R CON/ITUTION PROVIDES1 IT IS ! ,PREAMBLE ?AT MU/ DET]M9E ALL \R FUTURE ACTIONS1 & UPON ?AT H+ES ! V>I\S O!R ?+S4 ,! ,PREAMBLE ( ! ,KNII\S LABOR ORGANIZATIONS1 & ! PRES5T ,PREAMBLE WILL BE NO ADVANTAGE OV] ! PRES5T DECL>ATION ( ! ,AM]ICAN ,F$]ATION ( ,LABOR4 ,! QUE/ION WILL BE CON/ANTLY RAIS$ 9 \R ORGANIZATIONS1 0NO POLITICAL ACTION1 NO POLITICAL TALK20 SO !RE WILL BE NO POLITICAL DISCUSSIONS ON ! ECONOMIC SIDE1 & NO POLITICAL ECONOMICS W\LD BE P]MITT$ 9 \R LABOR ORGANIZATIONS4 ,WE W\LD SIMPLY BE TY+ ! MOVEM5T UP1 AS IT W]E4 ,N[ WE %\LD GO ON1 & ,I BELIEVE ?AT IF A FEW WORDS W]E /RICK5 \T ?AT WE C\LD AGREE TO LEAVE ! QUE/ION OP5 = ! ORGANIZATIONS TO DO AS !Y SAW FIT4 ,:Y W]E ! ,KNITY1 ,BOB ,NELSON1 A MOLD]4 ,! DI/RICT C\NSEL APPROPRIAT$ A C]TA9 SUM ( MONEY = ! PURPOSE ( C>RY+ ON ?AT CAMPAIGN4 ,IMM$IATELY !RE CAME ,P[D]LY4 ,Y\ ALL KN[ :O ,P[D]LY WAS1 ,I BELIEVE4 ,A ,D,E,L,E,G,A,T,E3 ,A TRAITOR4 ,D,E,L4 ,G,L,A,S,G,[3 ,P[D]LY CAME ) 9/RUCTION ?AT ?AT MONEY %\LD BE PUT BACK 9TO ! TREASURY & NO POLITICAL ACTION W\LD BE P]MITT$4 ,IT WAS A MOVEM5T ON ! P>T ( ! CAPITALI/S1 & !Y US$ ,P[D]LY = ! PURPOSE ( DE/ROY+ ! ,KNIT]S4 ,& Y\ KN[ ,P[D]LY WAS TAK5 C>E ( JU/ AS ,GOMP]S WILL BE TAK5 C>E ( :5 HE IS \T ( ! LABOR FIELD4 ,?AT WAS ! POSITION 9 :I* WE W]E4 ,! CAPITALI/S DO NOT BELIEVE 9 =M+ A POLITICAL ORGANIZATION4 ,:Y8 ,!Y HAVE GOT BEH9D !M ! ,PRESID5T4 ,!Y HAVE GOT BEH9D !M ! C\RTS4 ,!Y HAVE GOT BEH9D !M ! GUNS ?AT BACK UP !SE ?+S4 ,UNTIL WE GET POSSESSION ( ! POLITICAL FIELD WE WILL NOT BE ABLE TO CONTROL ANY ( !SE AV5UES BY :I* ! GOV]NM5T IS US$ BY ! CAPITALI/S ?AT KEEP US 9 ! CONDITION ( WAGE SLAVES4 ,IS MY TIME UP8 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,Y\ HAVE ?REE M9UTES YET4 ,D,E,L4 ,G,L,A,S,G,[3 ,N[ ?AT IS ! POSITION ,I TAKE4 ,!N WE %\LD BE C>EFUL ?AT WE TAKE NO ACTION ?AT WILL PREV5T 9 \R ORGANIZATIONS ! PRIVILEGE ( DISCUSS+ AT LEA/ ECONOMIC QUE/IONS1 & POLITICAL QUE/IONS 9 H>MONY ) !M4 ,BUT ,I DO NOT BELIEVE ?AT WE %\LD TAKE ! POSITION ( DECL>+ = A POLITICAL P>TY AT ! \T/>T1 BUT ?IS IF ADOPT$ DON'T SAY ?AT OR ANY?+ ( ?AT K9D1 & ,I BELIEVE IT W\LD BE DISA/R\S & PLACE US BACK JU/ :]E WE >E TO-DAY UND] ! PRES5T TRADE UNION REGIME4 ,D,E,L4 ,R,I,*,T,]3 ,MR4 ,*AIRMAN1 HAVE ,I A RIGUM5T4 ,D,E,L4 ,S,A,U,N,D,],S3 ,I W\LD LIKE TO ASK1 BE=E ,I DISCUSS ?IS QUE/ION1 ! READ+ ( ?AT CLAUSE TO BE REF]R$4 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,WILL Y\ READ ?AT CLAUSE8 ,D,E,L4 ,T4 ,J4 ,H,A,G,],T,Y3 0,BETWE5 !SE TWO CLASSES--0 ,D,E,L4 ,M,C,D,O,N,A,L,D3 ,! MOTION BE=E ! H\SE IS TO REF] ! 5TIRE ,PREAMBLE BACK TO ! ,COMMITTEE ON ,CON/ITUTION1 IS IT NOT8 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,NO1 ! MOTION BE=E ! H\SE IS TO REF] ?IS CLAUSE1 AS ,I UND]/& IT1 CLAUSE ONE HAV+ ALREADY BE5 ADOPT$ BY ! CONV5TION4 ,D,E,L4 ,M,C,D,O,N,A,L,D3 ,I DO NOT ?9K ?AT IS ! S5SE ( ! MOTION TO REF]4 ,IT W\LD BE ABSOLUTELY SILLY & FOLLY ON ! P>T ( ! MOV] ( ! MOTION TO REF] A C]TA9 CLAUSE BACK )\T REF]R+ ! 5TIRE ,PREAMBLE BACK4 ,D,E,L4 ,C,L,>,5,C,E ,S,M,I,?3 ,! MOTION WAS TO REF] ?IS P>AGRAPH & ! BALANCE ( ! ,PREAMBLE8 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,NOT ! P>AGRAPH ?AT HAS BE5 ALREADY ADOPT$4 ,D,E,L4 ,S,M,I,?3 ,WE CANNOT DO ?AT4 ,D,E,L4 ,H,A,G,],T,Y 7READ+73 ^*,BETWE5 !SE TWO CLASSES A /RUGGLE MU/ GO ON UNTIL ALL ! TOIL]S COME TOGE!R ON ! POLITICAL AS WELL AS ON ! ECONOMIC FIELD & TAKE & HOLD ?AT :I* !Y PRODUCE BY !IR LABOR1 ?R\< AN ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION ( ! WORK+ CLASS )\T AFFILIATION ) ANY POLITICAL P>TY40 ,QUE/ION CALL$ = FROM MANY P>TS ( ! HALL4 ,D,E,L4 ,R,I,*,T,]3 ,MR4 ,*AIRMAN & ,FELL[ ,DELEGATES-- ,D,E,L4 ,S,A,U,N,D,],S3 ,I BELIEVE ,I WAS RECOGNIZ$ BE=E ?IS DELEGATE4 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,?IS DELEGATE 7REF]R+ TO ,DELEGATE ,RI*T]7 HAS ! FLOOR4 ,Y\ JU/ ROSE TO HAVE ! P>AGRAPH READ4 ,D,E,L4 ,S,A,U,N,D,],S3 ,I ASK$ TO HAVE IT READ PRIOR TO DISCUSS+ ! QUE/ION4 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,?IS DELEGATE HAS ! FLOOR1 & HE ASK$ = IT BE=E Y\ CAME 9TO ! HALL4 ,D,E,L4 ,R,I,*,T,]3 ,MR4 ,*AIRMAN & ,FELL[ ,DELEGATES3 ,IT IS NOT ?AT ,I RISE TO %[ :AT ,I KN[ OR DO NOT KN[1 BUT ,I MAY /ATE ?AT ,I DID NOT COME 9TO ! LABOR MOVEM5T YE/]DAY2 ?AT DUR+ ! LA/ T5 YE>S ,I HAVE SE5 ! UPS & D[NS ( ! LABOR MOVEM5T1 ECONOMIC AS WELL AS POLITICAL1 & IF ANY?+ WAS RESPONSIBLE = ! DEFEAT ?AT IT SUFF]$ IT WAS ! LACK ( RECOGNITION ( !IR 9T]E/S AS A CLASS4 ,I DEFY ANY DELEGATE H]E TO %[ ME 9 ! P>AGRAPH PRES5T$ BY ! ,COMMITTEE1 ANY?+ ?AT REF]S TO ! CLASS /RUGGLE 9 ANY O!R MANN] ?AN BY /AT+ ! WORDS 0CLASS /RUGGLE0 & ?AT IT MU/ GO ON4 ,N[1 :AT DOES ?IS SAY8 ,DOES ?AT GIVE US A CONCEPTION ( ! CLASS /RUGGLE8 ,IT DOES NOT4 ,IF ?IS DECL>ATION OR ,PREAMBLE %ALL BE ( ANY USE1 IT MU/ BE ! MEANS :]EBY ! SPEAK] 9 ! MEET+S OR :]EV] IT BE %ALL HAVE A *ANCE TO GO BACK TO ITS DECL>ATION ( PR9CIPLES1 SO AS TO %UT \T ANY ELEM5T 9JURI\S TO ! MOVEM5T1 & TO 9CITE AN EF=T TO GA9 AN UND]/&+ ( IT4 ,) ! WORD+ ( ?IS P>AGRAPH AS IT IS1 AS IT HAS BE5 PO9T$ \T BY SOME ( ! SPEAK]S1 Y\ LEAVE ! DOOR OP5 TO ANY ONE4 ,JU/ LI/53 0,?R\< AN ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION ( ! WORK+ CLASS40 ,N[1 A /ORE KEEP] ALONG ! AV5UE H]E IS A WORK]2 A SMALL F>M] IS A WORK]2 & SO Y\ GO ALONG ! L9E4 ,ON :AT GR\ND CAN Y\ PREV5T !M FROM JO9+ ?IS ORGANIZATION8 ,IF ! CLASS /RUGGLE HAS ANY S5SE AT ALL IT MEANS ! /RUGGLE BUILT UPON ! CLASS 9T]E/S ( ! WAGE WORK+ CLASS2 & !RE=E IT SPR+S FROM ! FACT ?AT AN 9CREASE 9 ! WAGES ( ! :OLE WORK+ CLASS MEANS A CORRESPOND+ DECREASE ( ! PR(ITS ( ! CAPITALI/ CLASS4 ,FROM ?IS CONDITION SPR+S ! CLASS /RUGGLE1 NOT FROM AN ORGANIZATION ( ! WORK+ CLASS4 ,BUT ,I AM OPPOS$ TO REF]R+ IT BACK TO ! ,COMMITTEE1 AS ! ,COMMITTEE HAS1 ?R\< TWO ( ITS REPRES5TATIVES1 EXPRESS$ ITSELF & %[N ?AT IT HAS NO DESIRE TO *ANGE OR ALT] ! ,PREAMBLE 9 SU* A MANN] AS TO GIVE A DIFF]5T EXPRESSION TO ?OSE ESS5TIALS1 ?OSE FACTORS :I* CON/ITUTE OR >E ACTIVE 9 ?IS /RUGGLE4 ,:5 WE SAY 0CLASS /RUGGLE10 Y\ HE> ! WORD & Y\ MAY ?9K ANY?+ ( IT IF Y\ >E NOT 9=M$ & >E SO BL9D ?AT Y\ DESIRE SU* PLA9 LANGUAGE1 YET ! RESULT ( ?IS BL9DNESS MEANS MORE CONFUSION TO US & MORE /R5G? TO ! 5EMIES ( ! WORK+ CLASS4 ,I AM A DELEGATE FROM ONE ( ! ,LOCALS ( ! ,S4 ,T4 @& ,L4 ,A41 & ,I WAS C]TA9LY =CIBLY REM9D$ ( ! WORDS ( ,DELEGATE ,DEBS ON LA/ ,?URSDAY1 ?AT 0! !ORY ( ! ,S4 ,T1 @& ,L4 ,A4 IS CORRECT1 BUT !RE IS SOME?+ WRONG ) ITS ME?OD40 ,& C]TA9LY ! SPEAK]S ?AT HAVE /OOD UPON ! FLOOR H]E HAVE %[N BY !IR V]Y POSITION ?AT ! *>GE WAS WELL F\ND$4 ,N[1 FELL[ WORK]S1 IF ?IS ORGANIZATION %ALL AM\NT TO ANY?+1 Y\ MU/ BR+ TO EV]Y MAN AS F> AS POSSIBLE A RECOGNITION ( !IR CLASS 9T]E/S4 ,IF Y\ CANNOT DO ?IS Y\ MAY AMALGAMATE ALL ! WORK]S1 BUT Y\ WILL NOT BE 9 A POSITION TO G5]ATE ! /R5G? TO BR+ =? ! 5]GY ESS5TIAL TO OV]COME ! CAPITALI/ CLASS4 ,DELEGATE ,DE ,LEON SAID ?AT WE MU/ HAVE ! WORK]S' ECONOMIC P[]2 ?AT ,RID ( ! CAPITALI/ CLASS1 BUT IT CAN MAKE ?OSE EMPTY /OMA*S /RONG :5 !Y >E ACCOMPANI$ BY AN 9TELLIG5CE & BY A KN[L$GE ( ! FACTORS ( ! CLASS /RUGGLE :I* WILL MEAN !IR DE/RUCTION4 ,IT MAKES ?OSE EMPTY /OMA*S /RONG :5 !Y >E ACCOMPANI$ BY A KN[L$GE ( ! FACTORS 9 ?IS CLASS /RUGGLE :I* WORK T[>D ! UPLIFT+ ( ! WORK+ CLASS4 ,& ?AT IS ! ONLY P>T :I* ! WAGE WORK+ CLASS HAS ?R\< ITS ORGANIZATION TO ACCOMPLI% ITS MISSION4 ,N[1 ,MR4 ,*AIRMAN & ,FELL[ ,DELEGATES1 AFT] LI/5+ TO ! EXPRESSION ( ! S5TIM5TS ( ?IS CONV5TION ,I DO NOT EXPECT ?AT IT WILL ADOPT ! SUB/ITUTE4 ,I !RE=E DO NOT HOLD ?AT ! WAGE WORK+ CLASS WILL NOT PROGRESS4 ,:AT ?IS CONV5TION MAY LEAVE UNDONE SOME O!R CONV5TION WILL DO4 ,BUT ,I FEEL IT MY DUTY NOT TO BE GUID$ BY A REV]5CE = SOME HI< & GR& M9D1 :E!R IT BELONGS TO ?IS ORGANIZATION OR ANY O!R ORGANIZATION1 OR TO DECL9E TO ACT BECAUSE TO EXPRESS A C]TA9 CONDITION C]TA9 WORDS MU/ BE EMPLOY$ :I* >E UNFAMILI> TO MANY M51 BUT :I* Y\ MU/ EMPLOY IF Y\ WANT TO BR+ HOME TO MAN A KN[L$GE ( :AT IS = ! 9T]E/ ( HIS CLASS2 & = ?IS REASON ,I HAVE SPOK54 ,D,E,L4 ,B,],N,9,E3 ,MR4 ,*AIRMAN & ,DELEGATES TO ! ,CONV5TION3 ,IT WAS NECESS>Y ?AT !RE %\LD BE A LONG C\RSE ( ACADEMICS & DEBATE 9 ! PRELIM9>Y & E>LI] WORK LEAD+ UP TO ! LABOR MOVEM5T4 ,IT WAS NECESS>Y AT ONE TIME ?AT WE %\LD DI/9CTLY /ATE ?AT1 :5 WE SPOKE ( ! WORK+ CLASS1 ?AT WE %\LD REF] TO IT AS ! WAGE E>N+ CLASS 9 ORD] ?AT PEOPLE MIE ALL 9 ACCORD AS TO :AT IS MEANT BY ! WORK+ CLASS1 & ,I ?9K ?AT !RE CAN BE NO SPLITT+ ( HAIRS H]E4 ,IT WAS A LONG TIME BE=E WE C\LD IMPRESS UPON ?AT WORK+ CLASS A RECOGNITION ( ! FACT ?AT !RE WAS A CLASS /RUGGLE1 BUT ! COM+ TOGE!R ( ?IS CONV5TION %[S US ?AT ?AT CLASS /RUGGLE HAS BE5 RECOGNIZ$4 ,IT %[S US ?AT ! NECESSITY = ACADEMIC DISCUSSION HAS GONE BY1 & ?AT WE CAN CONFID5TLY APPROA* ! WORK+ CLASS AT ?IS TIME ) A PLA9 /ATEM5T ( T]MS1 )\T ANY SCI5TIFIC TRIMM+S4 ,I ?9K WE >E ALL SUFFICI5TLY AW>E BY ?IS TIME ?AT ! WORK+ CLASS MU/ BE UNIT$ POLITICALLY4 ,I ?9K WE >E SUFFICI5TLY AW>E ?AT !Y MU/ BE UNIT$ UPON !IR MAT]IAL CLASS 9T]E/S1 & AS ,I SAID WE CAN COME 9 ?IS SIMPLE LANGUAGE TO ! WORK+ CLASS & ASK !M TO ORGANIZE UPON ! PROPOSITION ?AT !RE IS A /RUGGLE 9 SOCIETY BETWE5 ! CLASSES1 :I* WILL NOT 5D UNTIL ! WORK+ CLASS IS UNIT$ ECONOMICALLY & POLITICALLY TO TAKE & HOLD ?AT :I* !Y HAVE PRODUC$4 7,APPLAUSE74 ,! TIME = C]TA9 ACTION HAS COME4 ,& :AT IS ?AT ACTION8 ,SIMPLY TO CUT ?AT /R+ :I* B9DS ! WORK+ CLASS TO ! CAPITALI/ CLASS4 ,?AT IS ! ACTION ?AT WE HAVE TO TAKE H]E AT ?IS TIME4 ,IT IS TO SET ! WORK+ CLASS FREE FROM ! CAPITALI/ CLASS BY /RIK+ (F ! FETT]S ?AT WEID TO ?AT PO9T :]E WE KN[ DEF9ITELY ?AT ALL CLASS /RUGGLE IS A POLITICAL /RUGGLE1 OR 9 O!R WORDS1 A /RUGGLE = ! PUBLIC P[]S1 9 ORD] ?AT WE MI4 ,I RECOGNIZE ! FACT ?AT WE >E H]E = ACTION & NOT = ECONOMIC DISCUSSION1 & ,I AM NOT 9 FAVOR ( ?AT MOTION TO REF]4 ,D,E,L4 ,B,>,T,L,E,T,T3 ,I AM 9 FAVOR ( REF]R+ BACK TO ! ,COMMITTEE = ?IS REASON3 ,I ?9K ! WORK+ CLASS HAS BE5 SUFFICI5TLY HYPNOTIZ$ 9 REG>D TO :AT TRUE WORK+ CLASS POLITICS >E4 ,! PREVAIL+ OP9ION EXI/S AMONG ! WORK+M5 ?AT GO+ UP TO A CAPITALI/ BALLOT BOX & DROPP+ A PIECE ( PAP] 9 IT MEANS WORK+ CLASS POLITICS4 ,I WANT TO TELL Y\ ?AT ?AT IS ! MO/ CONTEMPTIBLE LIE ?AT WAS EV] TOLD Y\1 = ?IS REASON3 ,TO IMAG9E ?AT Y\ C\LD GO 9TO A CAPITALI/ HALL ( ,CONGRESS & BY A VOTE TAKE POSSESSION ( !IR PROP]TY4 ,ISN'T ?AT A PIECE ( RANK NONS5SE8 ,Y\ MID ( ,DIRECTORS' ROOM ( ! ,NOR? ,WE/]N ,RAILWAY ,COMPANY & CA/ A VOTE TO TAKE POSSESSION ( !IR PROP]TY4 ,DO Y\ ?9K !Y W\LD H& IT OV] TO Y\8 ,NO4 ,!Y WILL NEV] DO ANY?+ LIKE ?AT4 ,SO GET ?AT MICROBE \T ( Y\R HEAD4 ,:AT WE >E UP AGA9/ Y\ ALL KN[ PRETTY WELL4 ,!RE >E C]TA9 REASONS :Y WE CAN'T TELL ! TRU? RI,T,L,E,T,T3 ,BUT ! FACT ?AT />ES US 9 ! FACE IS ?AT WE HAVE A /RUGGLE AHEAD ( US1 & ?IS /RUGGLE IS GO+ TO BE A BITT] ONE1 & ! CLE>] WE CAN GET1 ! NE>] TO ! E>? WE CAN GET1 ! BETT] IT WILL BE = Y\R C>CASSES4 ,N[1 :AT >E TRUE WORK+ CLASS POLITICS8 ,IS IT ?AT Y\ >E VOT+ AT A CAPITALI/ BALLOT BOX8 ,NO4 ,TRUE WORK+ CLASS POLITICS MEANS ?IS3 ,?AT 9 SO F> AS ! WORK+ CLASS IS ORGANIZ$ TO TAKE POSSESSION & 5=CE !IR DEM&S ON ! ECONOMIC FIELD1 WORK+ CLASS POLITICS GR[S CO-EXT5SIVELY ) ?IS ECONOMIC P[]1 & ALL ! VOT+ ?AT Y\ FELL[S HAVE TO DO IS AMONG Y\RSELVES AS TO :AT PLAN ( ACTION Y\ WILL TAKE AGA9/ ?IS CAPITALI/ CLASS1 & TIME WILL REVEAL TO Y\ FELL[S ! RANK NONS5SE ( VOT+ AT A CAPITALI/ BALLOT BOX4 ,Y\ CAN VOTE BETT] PROBABLY ) MA*9E GUNS & H& GR5ADES 9 ! C\RSE ( TIME4 7,MANIFE/ATIONS ( DISAPPROVAL 9 V>I\S P>TS ( ! HAIL47 ,D,E,L4 ,B,>,T,L,E,T,T3 ,I AM 9 FAVOR ( REF]R+ ?AT RESOLUTION BACK TO ! ,COMMITTEE 9 ORD] ?AT !Y CAN /RIKE \T ALL ( ?AT CONFUS+ LANGUAGE AB\T POLITICAL ACTION AT ! CAPITALI/ BALLOT BOX & ALL ?AT /UFF1 & BR+ BACK 9 PLACE ( ?AT CLAUSE A PLA9 /ATEM5T ( :AT ! WORK+ CLASS IS GO+ TO DO ON ! ECONOMIC FIELD4 ,I ?ANK Y\4 ,D,E,L4 ,P,>,K,E,S3 ,WE DO NOT KN[ A ?+ UNLESS WE KN[ ! REASON = ! ?+4 ,! DISCUSSION ?AT HAS GONE =? AS A RESULT ( !SE MOTIONS HAS CLE>$ UP ?IS QUE/ION 9 MY M9D1 & ,I ?9K IT HAS CLE>$ IT UP 9 ! M9DS ( A NUMB] ( O!RS4 ,! FUNCTION ( A CON/ITUTION IS NOT TO TEA* ! CLASS /RUGGLE4 ,! CON/ITUTION CON/ITUTES ! FRAME-WORK ( ! ORGANIZATION1 & 9 ! MAK+ ( ?AT CON/ITUTION WE >E GUID$ BY ! PR9CIPLES ( WORK+ CLASS ECONOMICS & ! CLASS /RUGGLE2 & IT SEEMS TO ME ?AT ! ,COMMITTEE HAVE DONE WELL 9 !IR /ATEM5T ( ! PROPOSITION1 AL?\< ,I WAS ! ONE :O SECOND$ ! MOTION TO ADOPT ! SUB/ITUTE BECAUSE ,I DID NOT KN[ ! REASON+ UPON :I* !Y BAS$ !IR D$UCTIONS :I* !Y MADE4 ,TO GIVE Y\ AN ANALOGY1 IT IS NOT NECESS>Y = AN >*ITECT TO TEA* MA!MATICS 9 ORD] TO ]ECT A /RUCTURE4 ,9 ORD] TO APPLY ! PR9CIPLES ( ! CLASS /RUGGLE & BUILD UP AN ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION UPON ! L9ES ( ! CLASS /RUGGLE1 IT IS NOT NECESS>Y ?AT ! PR9CIPLES ( ! CLASS /RUGGLE %ALL BE TAUATION ( PR9CIPLES ( ! ,KNITY4 ,IT IS MORE1 = IT IS A CRY/ALLIZATION ( S5TIM5TS & MEASURES = ! B5EFIT ( ! :OLE PEOPLE40 ,! B5EFIT ( ! :OLE PEOPLE IS ! DECL>ATION ( ! ,KNI5T1 :5 EX]CIS+ ! RIDLESS ( P>TY1 TO ASSI/ 9 NOM9AT+ & SUPPORT+ BY !IR VOTES SU* C&IDATES AS WILL SUPPORT !SE MEASURES4 ,NO ONE1 H[EV]1 %ALL BE COMPELL$ TO VOTE ) ! MAJORITY40 ,?OSE >E QUOTATIONS FROM ! DECL>ATION ( PR9CIPLES ( ! ,KNID H]E IS F\ND$ UPON WRONG PREMISES4 ,NEV]!LESS1 ,I ?9K IT HAS RESULT$ 9 CLE>+ UP A GREAT DEAL ( D\BT 9 ! M9DS ( MANY4 ,HAV+ READ ! SUB/ITUTE OV] A NUMB] ( TIMES1 ,I HAVE COME TO ! CONCLUSION ?AT IT IS NOT NECESS>Y TO REF] ?IS P>AGRAPH BACK TO ! ,COMMITTEE1 BUT ?AT IT \S1 ,I WANT TO SAY SOME?+ AT ?IS TIME4 ,?AT SECOND DECL>ATION 9 ! ,PREAMBLE FOLL[S ! FIR/1 & ! FIR/ IS ?AT !RE IS NO H>MONY BETWE5 ! TWO CLASSES4 ,! MAJORITY ( ! ,CON/ITUTION ,COMMITTEE :O PREP>$ ! ,PREAMBLE IS MADE UP ( M5 LIKE MYSELF4 ,Y\ HAVE HE>D & ,I HAVE HE>D M5 :O HAVE REPRES5T$ SO-CALL$ LABOR ORGANIZATIONS1 /& BE=E AUDI5CES & SAY TO ?OSE AUDI5CES ( WORK+M51 0,Y\R 9T]E/S & ! CAPITALI/S' 9T]E/S >E ID5TICAL40 ,I AM H]E TO SAY ?AT ! FIR/ CLAUSE 9 ?AT ,PREAMBLE CONTA9S A /ATEM5T ?AT !Y /& DIAMETRICALLY OPPOSITE1 & ! MAN :O1 PROPOS+ TO REPRES5T LABOR1 W\LD /& BE=E AN AUDI5CE & MAKE ! DECL>ATION ?AT !IR 9T]E/S >E ID5TICAL1 IS EI!R A KNAVE OR A FOOL4 ,IT IS ?IS CONDITION ( ?+S & A KN[L$GE ( ?IS CONDITION AMONG M5 :O HAVE1 = YE>S & YE>S1 CONT5D$ AS BE/ WE C\LD = \R RID IT READ BY ! ,SECRET>Y ,I RECOGNIZ$ ! FACT ?AT IT COV]$ ! GR\ND :]E9 ! O!RS HAD FAIL$1 & ?AT IT GIVES TO EV]Y MAN :O WILL READ IT ! V]Y ?+ ?AT Y\ WANT HIM TO HAVE1 & ?AT IS ?AT HE CAN READILY SEE ?AT ?IS ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION IS BAS$ UPON ! FACT ( ! CLASS /RUGGLE1 & ?AT HIS 9T]E/S & ! 9T]E/S ( HIS MA/]S >E NOT ! SAME4 ,IT SAYS ?AT ?IS /RUGGLE MU/ GO ON & ON4 ,UNTIL :AT8 ,UNTIL LABOR HAS BE5 ORGANIZ$ TO SEE ITS SOLID>ITY1 UNTIL ! WORK+ CLASS CAN CLAIM ITS [N4 ,SOME ( Y\ PEOPLE HAVE TALK$ AB\T POLITICS4 ,ONE ACTUALLY TALK$ AB\T %OOT+4 ,LET ME TELL Y\ SOME?+4 ,IT REQUIRES A GREAT DEAL MORE C\RAGE ON ! P>T ( SOME M5 TO VOTE ?AN IT DOES TO %OOT4 ,Y\ FELL[S :O TALK ?AT WAY1 PUT ?AT 9 Y\R HAT4 ,I HAVE BE5 !RE4 ,I WAS A REBEL 9 #a#h#f#d-#e1 :E!R IT WAS ANY CR$IT TO ME OR NOT4 ,I HAVE BE5 FAMILI> ) EV5TS FROM ! ,BALTIMORE RIOTS 9 #ahgg UNTIL ! ?RA%+ ( ! /REET RAILWAY EMPLOYES 9 ,NEW ,ORLEANS TWO YE>S AGO1 & ,I AM PRETTY WELL ACQUA9T$ ) EV]Y CONTE/ ?AT HAS TAK5 PLACE4 ,9 #ahha ,I WAS UPON ! 0,Q0 SY/EM :5 ! 5G9E]S HAD !IR LONG CONTE/1 :5 IT CO/ SOME ( US A SIX OR EI A DAY JOB4 ,IF EV]Y MAN :O LABORS & PRODUCES WEAL? HAD BE5 JO9$ 9 A LABOR ORGANIZATION SO ?AT EV]Y MAN C\LD HAVE HAD EV]Y O!R MAN'S ASSI/ANCE1 !RE IS NOT A TIME OR PLACE 9 HI/ORY IF !Y W\LD /& TOGE!R 9 SOLID PHALANX BUT :AT !Y C\LD GET :AT !Y WANT )\T EI!R %OOT+ OR FIGU+ = ! O!R SIDE2 ,I AM >GU+ ONLY = ! MAN :O WORKS 9 A USEFUL OCCUPATION & PRODUCES SOME?+ NECESS>Y = ! USE ( SOCIETY4 ,I HAVE NO USE = ! P>ASITES ( SOCIETY AT ALL4 ,?IS SECOND DECL>ATION 9 ?IS ,PREAMBLE SAYS ?AT ?IS /RUGGLE MU/ GO ON & ON BECAUSE ! 5CROA*M5TS ( ! P>ASITES UPON ! PRODUC] ( WEAL? ROB HIM ( :AT HE PRODUCES & PREV5T HIM & ?OSE :O >E DEP5D5T UPON HIM FROM HAV+ NOT ONLY ! GOOD ?+S ( LIFE1 BUT EV5 ! NECESS>IES ( LIFE 9 MANY 9/ANCES4 ,A COMRADE ASK$ :AT WE MEANT BY ! GOOD ?+S ( LIFE4 ,I HATE TO MAKE ?IS REF]5CE1 BUT ,I HOPE !RE IS NO MAN 9 ?IS AUDI5CE :O IS A DELEGATE ?AT IS NON COMPOS M5TIS1 NOT S\ND 9 M9D4 ,! GOOD ?+S ( LIFE REF]R$ TO !RE--& ,I AM SATISFI$ ?AT ! ,COMMITTEE WILL BE> ME \T 9 IT--MEAN ?AT ! TOIL]S ( ! L& MAY HAVE GOOD H\SES1 GOOD CLO!S & GOOD FOOD1 & ?AT !IR *ILDR5 %ALL HAVE ! *ANCE ( A GOOD $UCATION4 ,I WANT TO SAY ?AT ,I DON'T WANT TO SEE A VOTE CA/ BY A DELEGATE TO REF] ?AT BACK1 BUT ,I HOPE IT WILL BE ADOPT$ UNANIM\SLY4 ,D,E,L4 ,H,O,P,K,9,S3 ,MR4 ,*AIRMAN1 ,I DON'T WANT TO TAKE UP ! TIME ( ?IS CONV5TION 9 ANY USELESS DISCUSSION ON ?IS QUE/ION4 ,WE HAVE ALREADY SP5T TWO H\RS ( \R TIME H]E & HAVE ACCOMPLI%$ NO?+4 ,WE HAVE COME FROM ALL OV] ! C\NTRY1 FROM ALL OV] ?IS BROAD L& ) ONE PURPOSE 9 VIEW1 & ?AT WAS TO ORGANIZE ! WORK+ PEOPLE ( ?IS L& 9TO ONE SOLID COMPACT BODY4 ,BUT IT SEEMS FROM ! TWO H\RS' DISCUSSION H]E ?AT ?IS CONV5TION HAS BE5 CALL$ = TWO PURPOSES2 ONE1 ) ! UND]/&+ ?AT IT IS TO ORGANIZE ! LABOR+ CLASS1 ,I BELIEVE1 & ! O!R ?AT IT IS TO ORGANIZE A POLITICAL P>TY4 ,WE >E TAK+ UP TOO MU* ( \R TIME DISCUSS+ ?IS WORD 0POLITICS40 ,WE %\LD LEAVE ?AT \T ALTOGE!R1 LEAVE ?AT TO ONE SIDE4 ,WE DON'T C>E TO DISCUSS POLITICS OR TO REF] 9 ! CONV5TION TO POLITICAL ORGANIZATIONS4 ,WE COME H]E = ! PURPOSE ( ORGANIZ+ \RSELVES 9TO A COMPACT BODY SO ?AT WE CAN GO \T & MEET ! FOE4 ,WE RECOGNIZE1 ! FACT ?AT !RE >E BUT TWO CLASSES 9 ?IS L&1 ONE ! CAPITALI/ CLASS & ! O!R ! LABOR+ CLASS1 & ?AT ! CAPITALI/ CLASS IS ALREADY B\ND & ORGANIZ$ 9TO SOLID BODIES ON ! BATTLEFIELD :ILE WE >E SCATT]$ 9 ! TRADE UNIONS4 ,! WORK+ CLASS HAVE DISCOV]$ ?IS FACT1 & !Y HAVE S5T US TO REPRES5T !M & NOT ! POLITICAL BODIES4 ,WE >E H]E REPRES5T+ ! LABOR]S ( ?IS GREAT L&4 ,WE W]E S5T H]E = ONLY ONE PURPOSE1 & ?AT WAS TO ORGANIZE ?IS 9DU/RIAL LABOR]S' ORGANIZATION4 ,LET US DO ?AT2 LET US ACCOMPLI% ?AT4 ,WE HAVE HAD A COMMITTEE \T = ! LA/ TWO DAYS WORK+4 ,!Y HAVE BE5 WORK+ DAY & NIE TAK+ UP UNNECESS>Y TIME 9 DISCUSS+ ?AT H]E BY 9JECT+ TOO MU* POLITICS 9 IT4 ,TO REF] ?IS BACK TO ! ,COMMITTEE W\LD TAKE TWO MORE DAYS ( TIME4 ,!Y W\LD !N PRES5T IT TO ?IS CONV5TION1 & WE W\LD CONSUME ?REE OR F\R MORE DAYS ) ! ,PREAMBLE1 & DO NO?+ EXCEPT 9CREASE EXP5SE TO \RSELVES & TO ?OSE :OM WE REPRES5T & :O S5T US H]E4 ,!RE=E1 ,I MOVE Y\ ! PREVI\S QUE/ION4 7,APPLAUSE47 ,D,E,L4 ,J,A,C,K,S,O,N3 ,:5 ! DELEGATE BEH9D ME SPOKE 9 FAVOR ( REF]R+ ?IS P>AGRAPH BACK TO ! ,COMMITTEE HE /AT$ ?AT C]TA9 FACTS MADE IT IMPOSSIBLE TO TELL ! TRU? 9 ?IS CONV5TION4 ,N[1 ,I DISAGREE ) HIM4 ,I CLAIM ?AT ! TRU? HAS BE5 TOLD 9 ?IS P>AGRAPH 9 SU* A BRIEF =M ?AT IF ANY >TICLE W]E LEFT \T IT W\LD BE A HALF TRU?1 & ?AT W\LD BE NO TRU? AT ALL4 ,N[ ! FIR/ PHRASE IS1 0,! TOIL]S MU/ COME TOGE!R ON ! POLITICAL FIELD AS WELL AS ! 9DU/RIAL FIELD40 ,?AT IS A TRU?1 A SOLID FACT4 ,! ELEV5? COMM&M5T ( ,GOMP]S1 :O /ATES ?AT 0,?\ %ALT HAVE NO POLITICS 9 ! UNION10 IS PROV5 TO BE A LIE1 BECAUSE JU/ AS SOON AS A UNION MAN GETS UP TO DISCUSS WORK+ CLASS ECONOMICS & NOT POLITICAL ACTION1 !N HE IS %UT (F4 ,?AT PROVES ?AT ! DISCUSSION ( ECONOMICS FROM ! WORK+ CLASS /&PO9T 9 TRADES UNIONS MU/ 9EVITABLY BR+ \T A DISCUSSION ( ! POLITICAL ACTION ( ! WORK+ CLASS4 7,APPLAUSE74 ,N[1 IT HAS BE5 SAID & >GU$ ?AT ?AT LA/ CLAUSE PROVID+ = NONAFFILIATION ) ANY POLITICAL P>TIES CONFLICTS ) ?AT POSITION4 ,IT DOES NOT4 ,! FIR/ CLAUSE SIMPLY %[S ! WORK+MAN 9T5D+ TO AFFILIATE ) ?IS 9DU/RIAL UNION ?AT HE MU/ BE PREP>$ TO DISCUSS WORK+ CLASS ECONOMICS 9 ?AT UNION1 & 9EVITABLY MU/ FOLL[ POLITICAL DISCUSSION4 ,BUT ?AT DOES NOT 5TAIL ! (FICIAL AFFILIATION OR 5DORSEM5T ( ANY POLITICAL P>TY4 ,I AM SATISFI$ ?AT IF ?IS 9DU/RIAL UNION ?R[S OP5 ITS DOORS TO ! DISCUSSION ( ! ECONOMICS ( ! WORK+ CLASS1 !N IT MU/ 5TAIL ! DISCUSSION ( ! POLITICAL ACTION ( ! WORK+ CLASS1 & !RE=E ! 5DORSEM5T ( ANY SPECIFIC POLITICAL P>TY IS ABSOLUTELY UNNECESS>Y4 ,QUE/ION CALL$ =4 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,! MOTION IS ?AT P>AGRAPH TWO ( ! ,PREAMBLE BE REF]R$ BACK TO ! ,COMMITTEE4 ,?OSE 9 FAVOR ( ! MOTION WILL SIGNIFY IT BY SAY+ AYE4 ,CONTR>Y NO4 ,MOTION LO/4 ,! MOTION N[ OCCURS ON ! SUB/ITUTE 9TRODUC$ BY ,DELEGATE ,RI*T]4 ,>E4 Y\ READY = ! SUB/ITUTE8 7,QUE/ION CALL$ =74 ,?OSE 9 FAVOR ( ADOPT+ ! SUB/ITUTE WILL SAY AYE4 ,CONTR>Y1 NO4 ,! SUB/ITUTE IS LO/4 ,! ORIG9AL MOTION IS TO ADOPT P>AGRAPH TWO4 ,>E Y\ READY1 = ! QUE/ION8 7,QUE/ION CALL$ =74 ,?OSE 9 FAVOR WILL SIGNIFY IT BY SAY+ AYE4 ,CONTR>Y1 NO4 ,! MOTION IS C>RI$4 ,! P>AGRAPH IS ADOPT$1 & ! ,SECRET>Y WILL READ4 7,APPLAUSE47 ,D,E,L4 ,T4 ,J4 ,H,A,G,],T,Y1 ( ! ,COMMITTEE1 READ+3 0,?IRD P>AGRAPH4 ,! RAPID GA!R+ ( WEAL? & ! C5T]+ ( ! MANAGEM5T ( 9DU/RIES 9TO FEW] & FEW] H&S MAKE ! TRADE UNIONS ( TO-DAY UNABLE TO COPE ) ! EV]-GR[+ P[] ( ! EMPLOY+ CLASS1 BECAUSE ! TRADES UNIONS FO/] A /ATE ( ?+S :I* ALL[S ONE SET ( WORK]S TO BE PITT$ AGA9/ ANO!R SET ( WORK]S 9 ! SAME 9DU/RY1 !REBY HELP+ TO DEFEAT ONE ANO!R 9 WAGE W>S4 ,! TRADES UNIONS AID ! EMPLOY+ CLASS TO MISLEAD ! WORK]S 9TO ! BELIEF ?AT ! WORK+ CLASS HAVE 9T]E/S 9 COMMON ) !IR EMPLOY]S40 ,D,E,L1 ,O',N,E,I,L3 ,I MOVE ! ADOPTION ( ?AT P>AGRAPH4 7,SECOND$47 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,IT HAS1 BE5 REGUL>LY MOV$ & SECOND$ ?AT P>AGRAPH ?REE BE ADOPT$ AS READ4 ,>E Y\ READY = ! QUE/ION8 7,QUE/ION CALL$ =74 ,?OSE 9 FAVOR WILL SIGNIFY IT BY SAY+ AYE4 ,CONTR>Y1 NO4 ,! MOTION IS C>RI$ & ! P>AGRAPH IS ADOPT$4 7,APPLAUSE74 ,! ,SECRET>Y WILL READ4 ,D,E,L4 ,T4 ,J4 ,H,A,G,],T,Y3 ,F\R? P>AGRAPH3 0,!SE SAD CONDITIONS CAN BE *ANG$ & ! 9T]E/S ( ! WORK+ CLASS UPHELD ONLY BY AN ORGANIZATION =M$ 9 SU* A WAY ?AT ALL ITS MEMB]S IS ANY ONE 9DU/RY1 OR 9 ALL 9DU/RIES1 IF NECESS>Y1 CEASE WORK :5EV] A /RIKE OR LOCK\T IS ON 9 ANY DEP>TM5T !RE(1 ?US MAK+ AN 9JURY TO ONE ! CONC]N ( ALL40 7,APPLAUSE47 ,! P>AGRAPH WAS READ A SECOND TIME [+ TO ! FACT1 TO :I* ,DELEGATE ,DE ,LEON CALL$ ! ATT5TION ( ! ,SECRET>Y ( ! ,COMMITTEE1 ?AT ! WORD 0ONLY0 AFT] 0UPHELD0 HAD BE5 9ADV]T5TLY OMITT$ ON ! FIR/ READ+4 ,D,E,L4 ,S,*,A,T,S,K,E3 ,I MOVE ! ADOPTION ( ?IS P>AGRAPH4 7,SECOND$47 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,IT HAS BE5 REGUL>LY MOV$ & SECOND$ ?AT P>AGRAPH F\R BE ADOPT$ AS READ4 ,>E Y\ READY = ! QUE/ION8 ,D,E,L4 ,C,O,A,T,E,S3 ,I JU/ WANT TO ASK ! COMMITTEE TO ALL[ AN AM5DM5T4 ,I WANT ! LA/ P>T ( ! P>AGRAPH TO READ3 0AN 9JURY TO ONE IS AN 9JURY TO ALL10 NOT 0! CONC]N ( ALL40 ,I WANT TO MAKE IT ! 9JURY ( ALL4 ,I ASK ! ,COMMITTEE TO ACCEPT ?AT AS AN AM5DM5T2 IF NOT ,I WILL PUT IT TO ! H\SE TO AM5D IT 9 ?AT WAY4 ,D,E,L4 ,S,*,A,T,S,K,E3 ,I SUGGE/ ! SAME ?+4 ,D,E,L4 ,D,E ,L,E,O,N3 ,I ASK ?AT ! DELEGATE PUT ?AT AS AN AM5DM5T1 BECAUSE WE ( ! ,COMMITTEE HAVE NO P[] TO *ANGE IT4 ,D,E,L4 ,C,O,A,T,E,S3 ,JU/ READ ! LA/ FEW WORDS4 ,D,E,L4 ,T4 ,J4 ,H,A,G,],T,Y3 0,?US MAK+ AN 9JURY TO ONE ! CONC]N ( ALL40 ,D,E,L4 ,C,O,A,T,E,S3 ,I MOVE TO AM5D BY MAK+ IT READ1 0?US MAK+ AN 9JURY TO ONE ! 9JURY ( ALL40 7,SECOND$47 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,HAS ! ,COMMITTEE ANY OBJECTION TO MAK+ ! *ANGE8 ,D,E,L4 ,H,A,G,],T,Y3 ,I HAVE1 AS A MEMB] ( ! ,COMMITTEE1 AN OBJECTION TO MAK+ ?AT *ANGE4 ,D,E,L4 ,D,E ,L,E,O,N3 ,IT CAN ONLY BE DONE BY ! H\SE AS A :OLE4 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,DO Y\ (F] ?AT AS AN AM5DM5T8 ,D,E,L4 ,C,O,A,T,E,S3 ,YES4 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,IT HAS BE5 MOV$ & SECOND$ ?AT ! CLAUSE BE AM5D$ BY MAK+ IT READ1 0! 9JURY ( ALL0 9/EAD ( 0! CONC]N ( ALL40 ,D,E,L4 ,H,A,G,],T,Y3 ,I OBJECT TO ?AT1 BECAUSE AN 9JURY TO ONE IS NOT EXACTLY AN 9JURY TO ALL1 BUT IS ! CONC]N ( ALL4 ,AN 9JURY TO A MAN 9 ,CALI=NIA IS NOT A DIRECT 9JURY TO A MAN 9 ,*ICAGO4 ,IT IS ! CONC]N ( ! MAN 9 ,*ICAGO4 ,IT IS ! CONC]N ( HIS CLASS1 BUT IT IS NOT A DIRECT 9JURY4 ,IT IS ! CONC]N ( ALL WORK+M51 ! BUS9ESS ( ! 5TIRE WORK+ CLASS TO RES5T ?AT DIRECT 9JURY1 BUT 9 ACTUAL FACT AN 9JURY DONE TO ONE WORK+MAN IS NOT FELT BY ! 5TIRE WORK+ CLASS AT ALL4 ,A WAGE WORK] H]E 9 ,*ICAGO MAY BE DIS*>G$ = HIS ACTIVITY 9 UNIONISM4 ,! 9JURY IS CONF9$ TO ?AT ONE WAGE WORK]1 BUT HIS 9JURY IS ! CONC]N ( ALL WAGE WORK]S1 ! CONC]N ( EV]Y O!R MEMB] ( ! WORK+ CLASS1 BUT IT IS NOT A DIRECT 9JURY TO EV]Y WORK]4 ,MOREOV]1 ?IS P>TICUL> PHRASE 0AN 9JURY TO ONE IS ! CONC]N ( ALL10 IS FAMILI> TO ALL WORK+M51 & IT SEEMS TO ME 9 VIEW ( !SE FACTS ?AT IT \S PECULI>LY CLE> TO ME ?AT ! 9JURY ( ONE ( ?AT CLASS IS ! 9JURY ( EV]Y ONE ( ?AT CLASS4 7,APPLAUSE74 ,WE CAN TWI/ IT AS WE PLEASE AS LONG AS WE >E 9 ?IS CLASS /RUGGLE ! 9JURY ( ONE IS ! 9JURY ( EV]Y ONE ( ?AT CLASS4 ,D,E,L4 ,D,E ,L,E,O,N3 ,I W\LD LIKE TO ASK ,DELEGATE ,HAG]TY1 ,DELEGATE ,HAG]TY AS A PHYSICIAN1 IF AN 9JURY TO ANY P>T ( ! BODY IS NOT AN 9JURY TO ! :OLE BODY1 AS A M$ICAL QUE/ION8 ,D,E,L4 ,T4 ,J4 ,H,A,G,],T,Y3 ,NOT NECESS>ILY1 NOT AS A M$ICAL QUE/ION1 IS AN 9JURY TO ONE P>T AN 9JURY TO ! 5TIRE BODY4 ,IT DEP5DS ON :E!R IT IS FUNCTIONAL OR ORGANIC4 ,IF !RE IS AN ORGANIC 9JURY1 ( ! HE>T1 = 9/ANCE1 ! 5TIRE BODY IS 9JUR$4 ,BUT Y\ CAN HAVE A N]VE 9JUR$ )\T 9JUR+ ! 5TIRE BODY4 ,Y\ CAN HAVE A N]VE 9JUR$ )\T 9T]F]+ AT ALL ) Y\R DIGE/ION4 ,Y\R DIGE/ION WILL GO ON JU/ AS WELL AFT]W>DS1 & ALL ! DIFF]5T PROCESSES WILL GO ON JU/ AS WELL AS BE=E4 ,D,E,L4 ,S,A,M,U,E,L,S3 ,COMRADE ,*AIRMAN & ,D,E,L,E,G,A,T,E,S3 ,WE WANT TO MAKE ?IS QUE/ION SO AS TO BE UND]/OOD NOT ONLY BY ! PROGRESSIVE DELEGATE & PROGRESSIVE WORK+MAN1 BUT BY ALL WORK+M54 ,ALL ,I WANT TO TELL Y\ IS ?IS3 ,!RE >E V]Y FEW PEOPLE :O UND]/& ?AT AN 9JURY TO ONE IS AN 9JURY TO ALL1 & !RE=E WE HAVE GOT TO MAKE IT PLA9 SO ?AT EV]Y WORK+MAN WILL UND]/& IT4 ,D,E,L4 ,J,A,C,K,S,O,N3 ,DELEGATE ,HAG]TY SAYS ?AT AN 9JURY TO AN 9DIVIDUAL IS NOT A DIRECT 9JURY TO ANY BUT ! ONE4 ,I ?9K NOT4 ,IF A MAN IS 9JUR$1 IF A MEMB] ( ! WORK+ CLASS IS 9JUR$1 WE KN[ ?AT EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL 9 ?AT CLASS IS LIABLE TO ?AT 9JURY1 & ,I BELIEVE ?AT IF WE TAKE ! /&PO9T ( ! CONC]N ( ALL WE WILL TAKE ?AT /&PO9T AS A SYMPA!TIC /RIKE1 & IT CANNOT BE PUT 9 ?AT POSITION4 ,EV]Y 9DU/RY OR EV]Y CRAFT MU/ /RIKE FROM ! /&PO9T ( ITS MAT]IAL 9T]E/S AS A CRAFT4 ,I AM 9 FAVOR ( *ANG+ ?AT WORD TO 09JURY40 ,D,E,L4 ,M,O,R,R,I,S,O,N3 ,I DO NOT AGREE ) ,DELEGATE ,HAG]TY1 & ,I WILL GIVE Y\ MY REASONS = IT4 ,I HE>TILY AGREE ) ! PROPOSITION TO AM5D4 ,AN 9JURY TO AN 9DIVIDUAL UNIT ( ?IS GREAT BODY ( WORK+M5 9 ,SAN ,FRANCISCO W\LD BE ! CONC]N ( ALL ( ! 9DIVIDUALS BECAUSE ?\< ! CONC]N ( AN 9DIVIDUAL MU/ BE ADDRESS$ DIRECTLY TO ! 9DIVIDUAL1 YET IF IT IS AN 9JURY :I* AFFECTS ! :OLE CLASS DIRECTLY OR REMOTELY IT CAUSES AN 9JURY TO EA* 9DIVIDUAL UNIT ( ! ORGANIZATION4 ,!RE=E ,I /& = ! AM5DM5T TO *ANGE ! WORD+ ( ?AT FROM ! CONC]N ( ALL TO ! 9JURY ( ALL4 ,D,E,L4 ,B,O,S,K,Y3 ,I DISAGREE ) ,COMRADE ,HAG]TY4 ,I BELIEVE ?AT :ATEV] HURTS ANY 9DIVIDUAL LABOR+ MAN HURTS AT ! SAME TIME ! :OLE CLASS ( LABOR+ M54 ,?AT IS AN ECONOMIC LAW4 ,ECONOMIC LAWS >E SU* ?AT ANY B5EFIT ?AT ! CAPITALI/ CLASS D]IVE IMM$IATELY \T ( AN 9DIVIDUAL IS AN 9JURY ?AT CONC]NS ALL ( US4 ,! SCI5CE ( ECONOMICS MU/ BE TAULIAM5T>Y RULES 9 AN ORGANIZATION ( ?IS K9D4 ,ECONOMIC LAWS >E 9VOLV$ 9 AN ECONOMIC MOVEM5T1 & !Y MU/ BE ! F\NDATION ( ! ,CON/ITUTION & EV]Y?+ ELSE4 ,D,E,L4 ,S,A,U,N,D,],S3 ,I MOVE ! PREVI\S QUE/ION4 7,SECOND$47 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,! QUE/ION OCCURS ON ! AM5DM5T1 :I* IS TO 9S]T ! WORD 09JURY0 9 PLACE ( 0CONC]N40 ,?OSE 9 FAVOR ( ! AM5DM5T WILL SIGNIFY IT BY SAY+ AYE4 ,CONTR>Y1 NO4 ,! AM5DM5T IS C>RI$4 ,! QUE/ION N[ OCCURS ON ! ORIG9AL MOTION TO ADOPT P>AGRAPH F\R AS AM5D$4 ,>E Y\ READY = ! QUE/ION8 7,QUE/ION CALL$ =74 ,?OSE 9 FAVOR ( ! MOTION WILL SIGNIFY IT BY SAY+ AYE4 ,CONTR>Y1 NO4 ,! P>AGRAPH IS ADOPT$ AS AM5D$4 ,A MOTION W\LD BE 9 ORD] TO ADOPT ! ,PREAMBLE 9 ITS 5TIRETY4 ,D,E,L4 ,D,E ,L,E,O,N3 ,I MOVE ?AT IT BE ADOPT$ AS A :OLE4 7,SECOND$47 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,IT HAS BE5 REGUL>LY MOV$ & SECOND$ ?AT ! ,PREAMBLE BE ADOPT$ 9 ITS 5TIRETY4 ,A ,D,E,L,E,G,A,T,E3 ,AS AM5D$8 ,! ,*,A,I,R,M,A,N3 ,YES1 ! :OLE ,PREAMBLE4 ,?OSE 9 FAVOR ( ADOPT+ ?IS ,PREAMBLE AS AM5D$ WILL SIGNIFY IT BY SAY+ AYE4 ,CONTR>Y1 NO4 ,! ,PREAMBLE IS ADOPT$ AS AM5D$4 7,GREAT APPLAUSE47 ,P,R,E,A,M,B,L,E4 ,! WORK+ CLASS & ! EMPLOY+ CLASS HAVE NO?+ 9 COMMON4 ,!RE CAN BE NO PEACE SO LONG AS HUNG] & WANT >E F\ND AMONG MILLIONS ( WORK+ PEOPLE & ! FEW1 :O MAKE UP ! EMPLOY+ CLASS1 HAVE ALL ! GOOD ?+S ( LIFE4 ,BETWE5 !SE TWO CLASSES A /RUGGLE MU/ GO ON UNTIL ALL ! TOIL]S COME TOGE!R ON ! POLITICAL1 AS WELL AS ON ! 9DU/RIAL FIELD1 & TAKE & HOLD ?AT :I* !Y PRODUCE BY !IR LABOR1 ?R\< AN ECONOMIC ORGANIZATION ( ! WORK+ CLASS )\T AFFILIATION ) ANY POLITICAL P>TY4 ,! RAPID GA!R+ ( WEAL? & ! C5T]+ ( ! MANAGEM5T ( 9DU/RIES 9TO FEW] & FEW] H&S MAKE ! TRADES UNION UNABLE TO COPE ) ! EV]-GR[+ P[] ( ! EMPLOY+ CLASS1 BECAUSE ! TRADES UNIONS FO/] A /ATE ( ?+S :I* ALL[S ONE SET ( WORK]S TO BE PITT$ AGA9/ ANO!R SET ( WORK]S 9 ! SAME 9DU/RY1 !REBY HELP+ DEFEAT ONE ANO!R 9 WAGE W>S4 ,! TRADES UNIONS AID ! EMPLOY+ CLASS TO MISLEAD ! WORK]S 9TO ! BELIEF ?AT ! WORK+ CLASS HAVE 9T]E/S 9 COMMON ) !IR EMPLOY]S4 ,!SE SAD CONDITIONS CAN BE *ANG$ & ! 9T]E/S ( ! WORK+ CLASS UPHELD ONLY BY AN ORGANIZATION =M$ 9 SU* A WAY ?AT ALL ITS MEMB]S 9 ANY ONE 9DU/RY1 OR 9 ALL 9DU/RIES1 IF NECESS>Y1 CEASE WORK :5EV] A /RIKE OR LOCK\T IS ON 9 ANY DEP>TM5T !RE(1 ?US MAK+ AN 9JURY TO ONE AN 9JURY TO ALL4 ,!RE=E1 WE1 ! WORK+ CLASS1 UNITE UND] ! FOLL[+ CON/ITUTION4 ,A,N,N,\,N,C,E,M,5,T,S ,A NUMB] ( ANN\NCEM5TS W]E MADE AS TO MEET+S ( V>I\S COMMITTEES4 ,R,E,S,O,L,U,T,I,O,N ,NO4 #ag ,DEL4 ,COATES1 ( ! ,RESOLUTION ,COMMITTEE1 REPORT$ BACK ,RESOLUTION ,NO4 #a#g1 (F]$ BY ,DELEGATE ,*AS4 ,KIEHN1 ( ,HOBOK51 9 REG>D TO ! /RUGGLE ( ! PEOPLE 9 ,RUSSIA ) A RECOMM5DATION ON ! P>T ( ! ,COMMITTEE ON ,RESOLUTIONS ?AT ! RESOLUTION BE PASS$4 ,IT WAS MOV$ & SECOND$ TO CONCUR 9 ! REPORT ( ! COMMITTEE4 ,! MOTION WAS C>RI$ & ! RESOLUTION ADOPT$4 ,NO FUR!R COMMITTEES W]E READY TO REPORT1 & AT TWELVE O'CLOCK ! CONV5TION ADJ\RN$ UNTIL ONE O'CLOCK4 ,FROM 3 ,M>XI/S4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,JANU>Y #a#h1 #bba 3 ,DAY #f1 ,MORN+ ,SESSION -- ,ADD$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/