,BOOK #b1 ,*APT] #ac 

#ahiiahii 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,LEO ,TOL/OY 

,TEXT 3 

,AS SOON AS ! ,S5ATORS SEAT$ !MSELVES AT ! TABLE 
9 ! CONSULTATION-ROOM1 ,WOLF BEGAN TO SET =? 9 AN 
ANIMAT$ MANN] ! GR\NDS UPON :I* HE ?\<T ! 
CASE \<T TO BE REV]S$4 

,! ,PRESID5T1 ALWAYS AN ILL-NATUR$ MAN1 WAS 9 A 
P>TICUL>LY BAD HUMOR TO-DAY4 ,:ILE LI/5+ TO ! 
CASE DUR+ ! SESSION HE =M$ HIS OP9ION1 & SAT1 
ABSORB$ 9 HIS ?\<TS1 )\T LI/5+ TO ,WOLF4 
,!SE ?\<TS CONSI/$ 9 A RECOLLECTION ( :AT NOTE 
HE HAD MADE ! O!R DAY 9 HIS MEMOIRS AN5T ! APPO9TM5T 
( ,VELIAN(F TO AN IMPORTANT PO/ :I* HE 
DESIR$ = HIMSELF4 ,! ,PRESID5T1 ,NIKIT91 QUITE S9C]ELY 
?\<T ?AT ! (FICIALS ) :OM HIS DUTIES 
BR\<T HIM 9 CONTACT W]E WOR?Y ( A PLACE 9 HI/ORY4 
,HAV+ WRITT5 AN >TICLE ! O!R DAY 9 :I* SOME 
( !SE (FICIALS W]E VEHEM5TLY D5\NC$ = 9T]F]+ 
) HIS PLAN TO SAVE ,RUSSIA FROM RU91 AS HE 
PUT IT1 BUT 9 REALITY = 9T]F]+ ) HIS GETT+ A 
L>G] SAL>Y ?AN HE WAS N[ GETT+1 HE WAS N[ ?9K+ 
?AT PO/]ITY W\LD GIVE AN 5TIRELY NEW 9T]PRETATION 
TO ?AT 9CID5T4 

0,:Y1 C]TA9LY10 HE SAID TO ,WOLF1 :O WAS ADDRESS+ 
HIM1 AL?\< HE DID NOT HE> :AT ,WOLF SAID4 

,BE LI/5$ TO ,WOLF ) A SAD FACE1 DRAW+ G>L&S 
ON A PIECE ( PAP] :I* LAY BE=E HIM4 ,BE WAS A 
LIB]AL ( ! DEEPE/ DYE4 ,HE SC>CELY HELD TO ! TRADITIONS 
( ! SIXTIES1 & IF HE EV] DEVIAT$ FROM /RICT 
IMP>TIALITY1 IT WAS 9V>IABLY 9 FAVOR ( LIB]ALITY4 
,?US1 9 ?IS CASE1 BESIDES ! CONSID]ATION ?AT ! 
COMPLA9+ PRESID5T ( ! /OCK COMPANY WAS AN UNCLEAN 
MAN1 ,BE WAS 9 FAVOR ( AFFIRM+ ! JUDGM5T1 
ALSO BECAUSE ?IS *>GE ( LIBEL AGA9/ A J\RNALI/ WAS 
A RE/RICTION ON ! FRE$OM ( ! PRESS4 ,:5 ,WOLF 
HAD F9I%$ HIS >GUM5T1 ,BE1 LEAV+ ! G>L& UNF9I%$1 
9 A SAD--IT WAS SAD = HIM TO BE OBLIG$ TO 
PROVE SU* TRUISMS--S(T1 PLEASANT VOICE1 CONV9C+LY 
PROV$ 9 A FEW SIMPLE WORDS ?AT ! *>GE HAD NO 
F\NDATION1 &1 AGA9 DROOP+ HIS HO>Y HEAD1 CONT9U$ 
TO COMPLETE ! G>L&4 

,SKOVORODNIK(F1 :O WAS SITT+ OPPOSITE ,WOLF1 CONT9UALLY 
GA!R+ ) HIS ?ICK F+]S HIS BE>D & 
MU/A*E 9TO HIS M\?1 AS SOON AS ,BE WAS ?R\< ) 
HIS >GUM5T1 /OPP$ *EW+ HIS BE>D1 &1 9 A L\D1 
RASP+ VOICE1 SAID ?AT AL?\< ! PRESID5T ( ! 
/OCK COMPANY WAS A VILLA91 HE %\LD FAVOR A REV]SAL 
IF !RE W]E LEGAL GR\NDS TO SU/A9 IT1 BUT AS !RE 
W]E NONE1 HE JO9$ 9 ! OP9ION ( ,IVAN ,SEM5OVIT* 
7,BE71 & HE 9V>IABLY REJOIC$ AT ?IS %OT AIM$ AT 
,WOLF4 ,! ,PRESID5T SUPPORT$ ,SKOVORODNIK(F'S OP9ION1 
& ! JUDGM5T WAS CONFIRM$4 

,WOLF WAS DISSATISFI$1 ESPECIALLY BECAUSE BY ?IS JUDGM5T 
HE SEEM$ TO /& CONVICT$ ( >GU+ 9 BAD 
FAI?2 BUT1 FEIGN+ 9DIFF]5CE1 HE OP5$ HIS PAP]S 
9 ! NEXT CASE1 ,MASLOVA'S1 & BEGAN TO P]USE IT ATT5TIVELY4 
,! O!R ,S5ATORS 9 ! MEANTIME CALL$ 
= TEA1 & BEGAN A TALK AB\T ,KAM5SKY'S DUEL & HIS 
DEA?1 :I* WAS !N ! SUBJECT ( CONV]SATION 
?R\<\T ! CITY4 

,! U%] 5T]$ & ANN\NC$ ! DESIRE ( ! 
LAWY] & ,NEKHLUD(F TO BE PRES5T AT ! HE>+ ( ! 
CASE4 

0,?IS CASE H]E10 SAID ,WOLF1 0IS A :OLE ROMANTIC 
/ORY10 & HE RELAT$ :AT HE KNEW ( ,NEKHLUD(F'S RELATIONS 
TO ,MASLOVA4 

,AFT] TALK+ A:ILE ( ! /ORY1 SMOK+ CIG>ETTES 
& F9I%+ !IR TEA1 ! ,S5ATORS RETURN$ TO ! 
SESSION-ROOM1 ANN\NC$ !IR DECISION 9 ! PREC$+ 
CASE1 & BEGAN TO CONSID] ,MASLOVA'S CASE4 

,WOLF V]Y CIRCUM/ANTIALLY SET =? ,MASLOVA'S APPEAL 
FROM ! S5T5CE1 & AGA9 NOT )\T P>TIALITY1 BUT 
) ! EVID5T DESIRE TO REV]SE ! JUDGM5T4 

0,HAVE Y\ ANY?+ TO ADD80 ! ,PRESID5T ASK$ 
,FANIR94 

,FANIR9 ROSE1 &1 PROJECT+ HIS BROAD1 />*$ FRONT1 
) REM>KABLE PRECISION ( EXPRESSION BEGAN TO DISCUSS 
! ]RORS ( ! C\RT BEL[ 9 ! APPLICATION ( ! 
LAW ON ! SIX PO9TS RAIS$1 & P]MITT$ HIMSELF1 
?\< BRIEFLY1 TO T\* UPON ! M]ITS ( ! CASE & 
! CRY+ 9JU/ICE ( ! DECISION4 ,BY ! TONE ( HIS 
%ORT BUT /RONG SPEE*1 HE SEEM$ TO EXCUSE HIMSELF1 
TO 9SI/ ?AT ! HONORABLE ,S5ATORS ) !IR P[] 
( P5ETRATION & JUDICIAL WISDOM SAW & UND]/OOD 
BETT] ?AN HE1 BUT ?AT HE WAS SPEAK+ ONLY BECAUSE 
HIS DUTIES DEM&$ IT4 ,AFT] ,FANIR9'S SPEE* !RE 
SEEM$ TO BE NO D\BT LEFT ?AT ! ,S5ATE HAD TO REV]SE 
! JUDGM5T4 ,:5 HE WAS ?R\<1 ,FANIR9 SMIL$ 
TRIUMPHANTLY4 ,LOOK+ AT HIS LAWY] & SEE+ ?AT 
SMILE1 ,NEKHLUD(F WAS CONV9C$ ?AT ! CASE WAS WON4 
,BUT AS HE LOOK$ AT ! ,S5ATORS ,NEKHLUD(F SAW ?AT 
,FANIR9 ALONE WAS SMIL+ & TRIUMPHANT4 ,! ,S5ATORS 
& ,ASSOCIATE ,ATTORNEY ,G5]AL W]E NEI!R SMIL+ 
NOR TRIUMPHANT1 BUT WORE ! AIR ( PEOPLE SUFF]+ FROM 
5NUI & SAY+3 0,OH1 WE KN[ !SE CASES6 ,Y\ >E 
WA/+ Y\R TIME40 ,!Y W]E ALL EVID5TLY RELIEV$ 
ONLY :5 ! LAWY] HAD F9I%$1 & !Y W]E NO 
LONG] UNNECESS>ILY DETA9$4 ,AFT] ! SPEE* ! 
,PRESID5T TURN$ TO ,SEL591 :O PLA9LY1 BRIEFLY & ACCURATELY 
EXPRESS$ HIMSELF AGA9/ A REV]SAL4 ,!N ! 
,S5ATORS >OSE & W5T TO CONSULT4 

,! ,S5ATORS W]E DIVID$4 ,WOLF FAVOR$ A REV]SAL4 
,BE1 :O ?OR\<LY UND]/OOD ! CASE1 W>MLY >GU$ 
ALSO 9 FAVOR ( A REV]SAL1 & 9 GL[+ T]MS PICTUR$ 
! C\RT SC5E & ! MISUND]/&+ ( ! JURY4 
,NIKIT91 :O1 AS USUAL1 /OOD = SEV]ITY & = /RICT 
=MALITY1 WAS AGA9/ IT4 ,! :OLE CASE1 !N1 DEP5D$ 
ON ,SKOVORODNIK(F'S VOTE4 ,& HIS VOTE WAS ?R[N 
AGA9/ A REV]SAL1 PR9CIPALLY = ! REASON ?AT ,NEKHLUD(F'S 
DET]M9ATION TO M>RY ! GIRL ON MORAL GR\NDS 
WAS EXTREMELY REPUGNANT TO HIM4 

,SKOVORODNIK(F WAS A MAT]IALI/1 A ,D>W9I/1 & 
CONSID]$ EV]Y MANIFE/ATION ( AB/RACT MORALITY1 OR1 
WORSE /ILL1 PIETY1 NOT ONLY AS CONTEMPTIBLE & ABSURD BUT 
AS AN AFFRONT TO HIS P]SON4 ,ALL ?IS BU/LE AB\T A FALL5 
GIRL1 & ! PRES5CE !RE 9 ! ,S5ATE ( H] FAM\S 
C\NSEL & ,NEKHLUD(F HIMSELF1 WAS TO HIM SIMPLY DISGU/+4 
,&1 /UFF+ HIS M\? ) HIS BE>D1 & 
MAK+ GRIMACES1 HE 9 A V]Y NATURAL MANN] PRET5D$ 
TO KN[ NO?+ ( ! 5TIRE AFFAIR1 EXCEPT ?AT ! 
GR\NDS ( APPEAL W]E 9SUFFICI5T1 & !RE=E AGRE$ 
) ! ,PRESID5T TO AFFIRM ! JUDGM5T4 

,! APPEAL WAS D5I$4 

7,S\RCE3 ,! ,AWAK5+ BY GRAF ,LEO ,TOL/OY1 ,TRANSLAT$ BY ,SMI?1 ,WILLIAM ,E41 ,A,K,A3 ,! ,RESURRECTION4 ,TEXT FROM ,GUT5B]G4ORG47 

,FROM 3 ,GUT5B]G4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahih 3 ,BOOK #b1 ,*APT] #ac -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,FEBRU>Y #a#c1 #bag 3 ,BOOK #b1 ,*APT] #ac -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/