,*APT] #h 
,DOCTR9E ,( ,NON-,RESI/ANCE ,TO ,EVIL ,BY ,=CE ,MU/ ,9EVITABLY ,BE ,ACCEPT$ ,BY ,M5 ,( ,! ,PRES5T ,DAY 

#ahidahid 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,LEO ,TOL/OY 

,TRANSLATOR 3 ,CON/ANCE ,CL>A ,G>NETT 

,TEXT 3 

,*RI/IANITY IS ,NOT A ,SY/EM ( ,RULES1 BUT A ,NEW ,CONCEPTION ( 
,LIFE1 & !RE=E IT WAS ,NOT ,OBLIGATORY & WAS ,NOT ,ACCEPT$ 
9 ITS ,TRUE ,SIGNIFICANCE BY ,ALL1 BUT ONLY BY A ,FEW--,*RI/IANITY 
IS1 ,MOREOV]1 ,PROPHETIC ( ! ,DE/RUCTION ( ! ,PAGAN ,LIFE1 
& !RE=E ( ,NECESSITY ( ! ,ACCEPTANCE ( ! ,*RI/IAN 
,DOCTR9ES--,NONRESI/ANCE ( ,EVIL BY ,=CE IS ,ONE ,ASPECT ( ! 
,*RI/IAN ,DOCTR9E1 :I* MU/ ,9EVITABLY 9 ,\R ,TIMES BE 
,ACCEPT$ BY ,M5--,TWO ,ME?ODS ( ,DECID+ ,EV]Y ,QU>REL--,FIR/ 
,ME?OD IS TO ,F9D A ,UNIV]SAL ,DEF9ITION ( ,EVIL1 :I* ,ALL ,MU/ 
,ACCEPT1 & TO ,RESI/ ?IS ,EVIL BY ,=CE--,SECOND ,ME?OD IS ! 
,*RI/IAN ,ONE ( ,COMPLETE ,NONRESI/ANCE BY ,=CE--,?\< ! 
,FAILURE ( ! ,FIR/ ,ME?OD WAS ,RECOGNIZ$ S9CE ! ,E>LY ,DAYS ( 
,*RI/IANITY1 IT WAS ,/ILL ,PROPOS$1 & ONLY AS ,MANK9D HAS 
,PROGRESS$ IT HAS ,BECOME ,MORE & ,MORE ,EVID5T ?AT !RE ,CANNOT 
BE ANY ,UNIV]SAL ,DEF9ITION ( ,EVIL--,?IS IS ,RECOGNIZ$ BY ,ALL AT 
! ,PRES5T ,DAY1 & IF ,=CE IS ,/ILL ,US$ TO ,RESI/ ,EVIL1 IT IS 
,NOT ,BECAUSE IT IS ,N[ ,REG>D$ AS ,RI<T1 BUT ,BECAUSE ,PEOPLE ,DON'T 
,KN[ ,H[ TO ,AVOID ,IT--,! ,DIFFICULTY ( ,AVOID+ ,IT IS ! ,RESULT 
( ! ,SUBTLE & ,COMPLEX ,*>ACT] ( ! ,GOV]NM5T ,USE ( 
,=CE--,=CE IS ,US$ 9 ,F\R ,WAYS3 ,9TIMIDATION1 ,BRIB]Y1 
,HYPNOTISM1 & ,CO]CION BY ,=CE ( ,>MS--,/ATE ,VIOL5CE ,CAN ,NEV] 
BE ,SUPPRESS$ BY ! ,=CIBLE ,OV]?R[ ( ! ,GOV]NM5T--,M5 >E 
,L$ BY ! ,SUFF]+S ( ! ,PAGAN ,MODE ( ,LIFE TO ! ,NECESSITY 
( ,ACCEPT+ ,*RI/'S ,TEA*+ ) ITS ,DOCTR9E ( ,NONRESI/ANCE 
BY ,=CE--,! ,CONSCI\SNESS ( ITS ,TRU? :I* IS ,DIFFUS$ 
,?R\<\T ,\R ,SOCIETY1 ,WILL ALSO ,BR+ ,AB\T ITS ,ACCEPTANCE--,?IS 
,CONSCI\SNESS IS 9 ,COMPLETE ,CONTRADICTION ) ,\R ,LIFE--,?IS IS 
,SPECIALLY ,OBVI\S 9 ,COMPULSORY ,MILIT>Y ,S]VICE1 BUT ,?R\< 
,HABIT & ! ,APPLICATION ( ! ,F\R ,ME?ODS ( ,VIOL5CE BY ! 
,/ATE1 ,M5 DO NOT ,SEE ?IS ,9CONSI/5CY ( ,*RI/IANITY ) ,LIFE 
( A ,SOLDI]--,!Y DO ,NOT EV5 ,SEE ,IT1 ?\< ! ,AU?ORITIES 
,!MSELVES ,%[ ALL ! ,IMMORALITY ( A ,SOLDI]'S ,DUTIES ) 
,P]FECT ,CLE>NESS--,! ,CALL TO ,MILIT>Y ,S]VICE IS ! ,SUPREME 
,TE/ = ,EV]Y ,MAN1 :5 ! ,*OICE IS ,(F]$ ,HIM1 BETWE5 
,ADOPT+ ! ,*RI/IAN ,DOCTR9E ( ,NONRESI/ANCE1 OR ,SLAVI%LY 
,SUBMITT+ TO ! ,EXI/+ ,/ATE ,ORGANIZATION--,M5 ,USUALLY 
,R5\NCE ,ALL ,!Y ,HOLD ,SACR$1 & ,SUBMIT TO ! ,DEM&S ( 
,GOV]NM5T1 ,SEEM+ TO ,SEE ,NO ,O!R ,C\RSE ,OP5 TO ,!M--,= ,M5 
( ! ,PAGAN ,CONCEPTION ( ,LIFE !RE IS ,NO ,O!R ,C\RSE ,OP51 & 
,NEV] ,WILL ,BE1 9 ,SPITE ( ! ,GR[+ ,HORRORS ( ,W>--,SOCIETY1 
,MADE ,UP ( ,SU* ,M51 ,MU/ ,P]I%1 & ,NO ,SOCIAL ,REORGANIZATION ,CAN 
,SAVE ,IT--,PAGAN ,LIFE ,HAS ,REA*$ ,ITS ,EXTREME ,LIMIT1 & ,WILL 
,ANNIHILATE ,ITSELF4 

,IT IS (T5 SAID ?AT IF ,*RI/IANITY IS A TRU?1 IT \<T TO HAVE 
BE5 ACCEPT$ BY EV]YONE DIRECTLY IT APPE>$1 & \<T TO HAVE 
TRANS=M$ M5'S LIVES = ! BETT]4 ,BUT ?IS IS LIKE SAY+ 
?AT IF ! SE$ W]E RIPE IT \<T AT ONCE TO BR+ =? /ALLS1 
FL[]1 & FRUIT4 

,! ,*RI/IAN RELIGION IS NOT A LEGAL SY/EM :I*1 BE+ IMPOS$ 
BY VIOL5CE1 MAY TRANS=M M5'S LIVES4 ,*RI/IANITY IS A NEW & 
HI<] CONCEPTION ( LIFE4 ,A NEW CONCEPTION ( LIFE CANNOT BE 
IMPOS$ ON M52 IT CAN ONLY BE FREELY ASSIMILAT$4 ,& IT CAN 
ONLY BE FREELY ASSIMILAT$ 9 TWO WAYS3 ONE SPIRITUAL & 
9T]NAL1 ! O!R EXP]IM5TAL & EXT]NAL4 

,SOME PEOPLE--A M9ORITY--BY A K9D ( PROPHETIC 9/9CT DIV9E 
! TRU? ( ! DOCTR9E1 SURR5D] !MSELVES TO IT & ADOPT 
IT4 ,O!RS--! MAJORITY--ONLY ?R\< A LONG C\RSE ( MI/AKES1 
EXP]IM5TS1 & SUFF]+ >E BR\<T TO RECOGNIZE ! TRU? ( 
! DOCTR9E & ! NECESSITY ( ADOPT+ IT4 

,& BY ?IS EXP]IM5TAL EXT]NAL ME?OD ! MAJORITY ( ,*RI/IAN 
M5 HAVE N[ BE5 BR\<T TO ?IS NECESSITY ( ASSIMILAT+ ! 
DOCTR9E4 ,ONE SOMETIMES WOND]S :AT NECESSITAT$ ! CORRUPTION 
( ,*RI/IANITY :I* IS N[ ! GREATE/ OB/ACLE TO ITS 
ACCEPTANCE 9 ITS TRUE SIGNIFICANCE4 

,IF ,*RI/IANITY HAD BE5 PRES5T$ TO M5 9 ITS TRUE1 UNCORRUPT$ 
=M1 IT W\LD NOT HAVE BE5 ACCEPT$ BY ! MAJORITY1 :O W\LD 
HAVE BE5 AS UNT\*$ BY IT AS ! NATIONS ( ,ASIA >E N[4 ,! 
PEOPLES :O ACCEPT$ IT 9 ITS CORRUPT =M W]E SUBJECT$ TO ITS 
SL[ BUT C]TA9 9FLU5CE1 & BY A LONG C\RSE ( ]RORS & 
EXP]IM5TS & !IR RESULTANT SUFF]+S HAVE N[ BE5 BR\<T 
TO ! NECESSITY ( ASSIMILAT+ IT 9 ITS TRUE SIGNIFICANCE4 

,! CORRUPTION ( ,*RI/IANITY & ITS ACCEPTANCE 9 ITS CORRUPT 
=M BY ! MAJORITY ( M5 WAS AS NECESS>Y AS IT IS ?AT ! 
SE$ %\LD REMA9 HIDD5 = A C]TA9 TIME 9 ! E>? 9 ORD] 
TO G]M9ATE4 

,*RI/IANITY IS AT ONCE A DOCTR9E ( TRU? & A PROPHECY4 
,EI<TE5 C5TURIES AGO ,*RI/IANITY REVEAL$ TO M5 ! TRU? 9 
:I* !Y \<T TO LIVE1 & AT ! SAME TIME =ETOLD :AT HUMAN 
LIFE W\LD BECOME IF M5 W\LD NOT LIVE BY IT BUT CONT9U$ TO 
LIVE BY !IR PREVI\S PR9CIPLES1 & :AT IT W\LD BECOME IF 
!Y ACCEPT$ ! ,*RI/IAN DOCTR9E & C>RI$ IT \T 9 !IR 
LIVES4 

,LAY+ D[N 9 ! ,S]MON ON ! ,M\NT ! PR9CIPLES BY :I* TO 
GUIDE M5'S LIVES1 ,*RI/ SAID3 0,:OSOEV] HE>E? !SE SAY+S 
( M9E1 & DOE? !M1 ,I WILL LIK5 HIM UNTO A WISE MAN1 :O 
BUILT HIS H\SE UPON A ROCK2 & ! RA9 DESC5D$1 & ! 
FLOODS CAME1 & ! W9DS BLEW1 & BEAT UPON ?AT H\SE2 & IT 
FELL NOT1 = IT WAS F\ND$ UPON A ROCK4 ,& EV]YONE ?AT 
HE>E? !SE SAY+S1 & DOE? !M NOT1 %ALL BE LIK5$ UNTO A 
FOOLI% MAN1 :O BUILT HIS H\SE UPON ! S&2 & ! RA9 
DESC5D$1 & ! FLOODS CAME1 & ! W9DS BLEW1 & BEAT UPON 
?AT H\SE2 & IT FELL3 & GREAT WAS ! FALL ( IT0 7,MATT4 VII4 
#b#d-#b#g74 

,& N[ AFT] EI<TE5 C5TURIES ! PROPHECY HAS BE5 FULFILL$4 
,NOT HAV+ FOLL[$ ,*RI/'S TEA*+ G5]ALLY & ITS 
APPLICATION TO SOCIAL LIFE 9 NONRESI/ANCE TO EVIL1 M5 HAVE 
BE5 BR\<T 9 SPITE ( !MSELVES TO ! 9EVITABLE DE/RUCTION 
=ETOLD BY ,*RI/ = ?OSE :O DO NOT FULFILL HIS TEA*+4 

,PEOPLE (T5 ?9K ! QUE/ION ( NONRESI/ANCE TO EVIL BY =CE 
IS A !ORETICAL ONE1 :I* CAN BE NEGLECT$4 ,YET ?IS QUE/ION 
IS PRES5T$ BY LIFE ITSELF TO ALL M51 & CALLS = SOME ANSW] 
FROM EV]Y ?9K+ MAN4 ,EV] S9CE ,*RI/IANITY HAS BE5 
\TW>DLY PR(ESS$1 ?IS QUE/ION IS = M5 9 !IR SOCIAL LIFE 
LIKE ! QUE/ION :I* PRES5TS ITSELF TO A TRAVEL] :5 ! 
ROAD ON :I* HE HAS BE5 J\RNEY+ DIVIDES 9TO TWO BRAN*ES4 
,HE MU/ GO ON & HE CANNOT SAY3 ,I WILL NOT ?9K AB\T IT1 BUT 
WILL GO ON JU/ AS ,I DID BE=E4 ,!RE WAS ONE ROAD1 N[ !RE 
>E TWO1 & HE MU/ MAKE HIS *OICE4 

,9 ! SAME WAY S9CE ,*RI/'S TEA*+ HAS BE5 KN[N BY M5 !Y 
CANNOT SAY3 ,I WILL LIVE AS BE=E & WILL NOT DECIDE ! QUE/ION 
( RESI/ANCE OR NONRESI/ANCE TO EVIL BY =CE4 ,AT EV]Y NEW 
/RUGGLE ?AT >ISES ONE MU/ 9EVITABLY DECIDE2 AM ,I1 OR AM ,I 
NOT1 TO RESI/ BY =CE :AT ,I REG>D AS EVIL4 

,! QUE/ION ( RESI/ANCE OR NONRESI/ANCE TO EVIL >OSE :5 
! FIR/ CONFLICT BETWE5 M5 TOOK PLACE1 S9CE EV]Y CONFLICT IS 
NO?+ ELSE ?AN RESI/ANCE BY =CE TO :AT EA* ( ! 
COMBATANTS REG>DS AS EVIL4 ,BUT BE=E ,*RI/1 M5 DID NOT SEE 
?AT RESI/ANCE BY =CE TO :AT EA* REG>DS AS EVIL1 SIMPLY 
BECAUSE ONE ?9KS EVIL :AT ! O!R ?9KS GOOD1 IS ONLY ONE ( 
! ME?ODS ( SETTL+ ! DISPUTE1 & ?AT !RE IS ANO!R 
ME?OD1 ?AT ( NOT RESI/+ EVIL BY =CE AT ALL4 

,BE=E ,*RI/'S TEA*+1 IT SEEM$ TO M5 ?AT ! ONE ONLY MEANS 
( SETTL+ A DISPUTE WAS BY RESI/ANCE TO EVIL BY =CE4 ,& 
!Y ACT$ ACCORD+LY1 EA* ( ! COMBATANTS TRY+ TO CONV9CE 
HIMSELF & O!RS ?AT :AT EA* RESPECTIVELY REG>DS AS EVIL1 IS 
ACTUALLY1 ABSOLUTELY EVIL4 

,& TO DO ?IS FROM ! E>LIE/ TIME M5 HAVE DEVIS$ DEF9ITIONS 
( EVIL & TRI$ TO MAKE !M B9D+ ON EV]YONE4 ,& SU* 
DEF9ITIONS ( EVIL SOMETIMES TOOK ! =M ( LAWS1 SUPPOS$ TO 
HAVE BE5 RECEIV$ BY SUP]NATURAL MEANS1 SOMETIMES ( ! 
COMM&S ( RUL]S OR ASSEMBLIES TO :OM 9FALLIBILITY WAS 
ATTRIBUT$4 ,M5 RESORT$ TO VIOL5CE AGA9/ O!RS1 & 
CONV9C$ !MSELVES & O!RS ?AT !Y W]E DIRECT+ !IR 
VIOL5CE AGA9/ EVIL RECOGNIZ$ AS SU* BY ALL4 

,?IS MEANS WAS EMPLOY$ FROM ! E>LIE/ TIMES1 ESPECIALLY BY 
?OSE :O HAD GA9$ POSSESSION ( AU?ORITY1 & = A LONG :ILE 
ITS IRRATIONALITY WAS NOT DETECT$4 

,BUT ! LONG] M5 LIV$ 9 ! WORLD & ! MORE COMPLEX !IR 
RELATIONS BECAME1 ! MORE EVID5T IT WAS ?AT TO RESI/ BY =CE 
:AT EA* REG>D$ AS EVIL WAS IRRATIONAL1 ?AT CONFLICT WAS 9 NO 
WAY LESS5$ !REBY1 & ?AT NO HUMAN DEF9ITIONS CAN SUCCE$ 9 
MAK+ :AT SOME REG>D AS EVIL BE ACCEPT$ AS SU* BY O!RS4 

,ALREADY AT ! TIME ,*RI/IANITY >OSE1 IT WAS EVID5T TO A GREAT 
NUMB] ( PEOPLE 9 ! ,ROMAN ,EMPIRE :]E IT >OSE1 ?AT :AT WAS 
REG>D$ AS EVIL BY ,N]O & ,CALIGULA C\LD NOT BE REG>D$ AS 
EVIL BY O!RS4 ,EV5 AT ?AT TIME M5 HAD BEGUN TO UND]/& 
?AT HUMAN LAWS1 ?\< GIV5 \T = DIV9E LAWS1 W]E COMPIL$ 
BY M51 & CANNOT BE 9FALLIBLE1 :ATEV] ! EXT]NAL MAJE/Y 
) :I* !Y >E 9VE/$1 & ?AT ]R+ M5 >E NOT R5D]$ 
9FALLIBLE BY ASSEMBL+ TOGE!R & CALL+ !MSELVES A S5ATE 
OR ANY O!R NAME4 ,EV5 AT ?AT TIME ?IS WAS FELT & UND]/OOD 
BY MANY4 ,& IT WAS !N ?AT ,*RI/ PREA*$ HIS DOCTR9E1 :I* 
CONSI/$ NOT ONLY ( ! PROHIBITION ( RESI/ANCE TO EVIL BY 
=CE1 BUT GAVE A NEW CONCEPTION ( LIFE & A MEANS ( PUTT+ AN 
5D TO CONFLICT BETWE5 ALL M51 NOT BY MAK+ IT ! DUTY ( ONE 
SECTION ONLY ( MANK9D TO SUBMIT )\T CONFLICT TO :AT IS 
PRESCRIB$ TO !M BY C]TA9 AU?ORITIES1 BUT BY MAK+ IT ! 
DUTY ( ALL--& CONSEQU5TLY ( ?OSE 9 AU?ORITY--NOT TO RESORT 
TO =CE AGA9/ ANYONE 9 ANY CIRCUM/ANCES4 

,?IS DOCTR9E WAS ACCEPT$ AT ! TIME BY ONLY A V]Y SMALL NUMB] 
( DISCIPLES4 ,! MAJORITY ( M51 ESPECIALLY ALL :O W]E 9 
P[]1 EV5 AFT] ! NOM9AL ACCEPTANCE ( ,*RI/IANITY1 
CONT9U$ TO MA9TA9 = !MSELVES ! PR9CIPLE ( RESI/ANCE 
BY =CE TO :AT !Y REG>D$ AS EVIL4 ,SO IT WAS UND] ! ,ROMAN 
& ,BYZANT9E EMP]ORS1 & SO IT CONT9U$ TO BE LAT]4 

,! 9SUFFICI5CY ( ! PR9CIPLE ( ! AU?ORITATIVE DEF9ITION 
( EVIL & RESI/ANCE TO IT BY =CE1 EVID5T AS IT WAS 9 ! 
E>LY AGES ( ,*RI/IANITY1 BECOMES /ILL MORE OBVI\S ?R\< ! 
DIVISION ( ! ,ROMAN ,EMPIRE 9TO MANY /ATES ( EQUAL AU?ORITY1 
?R\< !IR HO/ILITIES & ! 9T]NAL CONFLICTS ?AT BROKE 
\T )9 !M4 

,BUT M5 W]E NOT READY TO ACCEPT ! SOLUTION GIV5 BY ,*RI/1 & 
! OLD DEF9ITIONS ( EVIL1 :I* \<T TO BE RESI/$1 CONT9U$ 
TO BE LAID D[N BY MEANS ( MAK+ LAWS B9D+ ON ALL & 
5=C$ BY =CIBLE MEANS4 ,! AU?ORITY :O DECID$ :AT \<T 
TO BE REG>D$ AS EVIL & RESI/$ BY =CE WAS AT ONE TIME ! 
,POPE1 AT ANO!R AN EMP]OR OR K+1 AN ELECTIVE ASSEMBLY OR A 
:OLE NATION4 ,BUT BO? )9 & )\T ! /ATE !RE W]E 
ALWAYS M5 TO BE F\ND :O DID NOT ACCEPT AS B9D+ ON !MSELVES 
! LAWS GIV5 \T AS ! DECREES ( A GOD1 OR MADE BY M5 
9VE/$ ) A SACR$ *>ACT]1 OR ! 9/ITUTIONS SUPPOS$ TO 
REPRES5T ! WILL ( ! NATION2 & !RE W]E M5 :O ?\<T 
GOOD :AT ! EXI/+ AU?ORITIES REG>D$ AS BAD1 & :O 
/RUGGL$ AGA9/ ! AU?ORITIES ) ! SAME VIOL5CE AS WAS 
EMPLOY$ AGA9/ !M4 

,! M5 9VE/$ ) RELIGI\S AU?ORITY REG>D$ AS EVIL :AT 
! M5 & 9/ITUTIONS 9VE/$ ) TEMPORAL AU?ORITY REG>D$ 
AS GOOD & VISE V]SA1 & ! /RUGGLE GREW MORE & MORE 
9T5SE4 ,& ! LONG] M5 US$ VIOL5CE AS ! MEANS ( 
SETTL+ !IR DISPUTES1 ! MORE OBVI\S IT BECAME ?AT IT WAS AN 
UNSUITABLE MEANS1 S9CE !RE C\LD BE NO EXT]NAL AU?ORITY ABLE 
TO DEF9E EVIL RECOGNIZ$ BY ALL4 

,?+S W5T ON LIKE ?IS = EI<TE5 C5TURIES1 & AT LA/ 
REA*$ ! PRES5T POSITION 9 :I* IT IS ABSOLUTELY OBVI\S 
?AT !RE IS1 & CAN BE1 NO EXT]NAL DEF9ITION ( EVIL B9D+ 
UPON ALL4 ,M5 HAVE COME TO ! PO9T ( CEAS+ TO BELIEVE 9 ! 
POSSIBILITY OR EV5 DESIRABILITY ( F9D+ & E/ABLI%+ SU* 
A G5]AL DEF9ITION4 ,IT HAS COME TO M5 9 P[] CEAS+ TO 
ATTEMPT TO PROVE ?AT :AT !Y REG>D AS EVIL IS EVIL1 & SIMPLY 
DECL>+ ?AT !Y REG>D AS EVIL :AT !Y DON'T LIKE1 :ILE 
!IR SUBJECTS NO LONG] OBEY !M BECAUSE !Y ACCEPT ! 
DEF9ITION ( EVIL LAID D[N BY !M1 BUT SIMPLY OBEY BECAUSE !Y 
CANNOT HELP !MSELVES4 ,IT WAS NOT BECAUSE IT WAS A GOOD ?+1 
NECESS>Y & B5EFICIAL TO M51 & ! CONTR>Y C\RSE W\LD 
HAVE BE5 AN EVIL1 BUT SIMPLY BECAUSE IT WAS ! WILL ( ?OSE 9 
P[] ?AT ,NICE WAS 9CORPORAT$ 9TO ,FRANCE1 & ,LORRA9E 9TO 
,G]MANY1 & ,BOHEMIA 9TO ,AU/RIA1 & ?AT ,POL& WAS DIVID$1 
& ,IREL& & ,9DIA RUL$ BY ! ,5GLI% GOV]NM5T1 & ?AT 
! ,*9ESE >E ATTACK$ & ! ,AFRICANS SLAU<T]$1 & ! 
,*9ESE PREV5T$ FROM IMMIGRAT+ BY ! ,AM]ICANS1 & ! ,JEWS 
P]SECUT$ BY ! ,RUSSIANS1 & ?AT L&[N]S APPROPRIATE L&S 
!Y DO NOT CULTIVATE & CAPITALI/S 5JOY ! FRUITS ( ! 
LABOR ( O!RS4 ,IT HAS COME TO ! PRES5T /ATE ( ?+S2 ONE 
SET ( M5 COMMIT ACTS ( VIOL5CE NO LONG] ON ! PRETEXT ( 
RESI/ANCE TO EVIL1 BUT SIMPLY = !IR PR(IT OR !IR CAPRICE1 
& ANO!R SET SUBMIT TO VIOL5CE1 NOT BECAUSE !Y SUPPOSE1 AS 
WAS SUPPOS$ 9 =M] TIMES1 ?AT ?IS VIOL5CE WAS PRACTIC$ 
UPON !M = ! SAKE ( SECUR+ !M FROM EVIL1 BUT SIMPLY 
BECAUSE !Y CANNOT AVOID IT4 

,IF ! ,ROMAN1 OR ! MAN ( M$IEVAL TIMES1 OR ! AV]AGE 
,RUSSIAN ( FIFTY YE>S AGO1 AS ,I REMEMB] HIM1 WAS CONV9C$ 
)\T A %ADE ( D\BT ?AT ! VIOL5CE ( AU?ORITY WAS 
9DISP5SABLE TO PRES]VE HIM FROM EVIL2 ?AT TAXES1 DUES1 
S]FAGE1 PRISONS1 SC\RG+1 KN\TS1 EXECUTIONS1 ! >MY & W> 
W]E :AT \<T TO BE--WE KN[ N[ ?AT ONE CAN SELDOM F9D A MAN 
:O BELIEVES ?AT ALL !SE MEANS ( VIOL5CE PRES]VE ANYONE FROM 
ANY EVIL :ATEV]1 & 9DE$ DOES NOT CLE>LY P]CEIVE ?AT MO/ 
( !SE ACTS ( VIOL5CE TO :I* HE IS EXPOS$1 & 9 :I* HE 
HAS SOME %>E1 >E 9 !MSELVES A GREAT & USELESS EVIL4 

,!RE IS NO ONE TO-DAY :O DOES NOT SEE ! USELESSNESS & 9JU/ICE ( 
COLLECT+ TAXES FROM ! TOIL+ MASSES TO 5RI* IDLE (FICIALS2 OR 
! S5SELESSNESS ( 9FLICT+ PUNI%M5TS ON WEAK OR DEPRAV$ P]SONS 
9 ! %APE ( TRANSPORTATION FROM ONE PLACE TO ANO!R1 OR ( 
IMPRISONM5T 9 A =TRESS :]E1 LIV+ 9 SECURITY & 9DOL5CE1 !Y 
ONLY BECOME WEAK] & MORE DEPRAV$2 OR ! WORSE ?AN USELESSNESS & 
9JU/ICE1 ! POSITIVE 9SANITY & B>B>ITY ( PREP>ATIONS = W> 
& ( W>S1 CAUS+ DEVA/ATION & RU91 & HAV+ NO K9D ( 
JU/IFICATION4 ,YET !SE =MS ( VIOL5CE CONT9UE & >E SUPPORT$ BY 
! V]Y PEOPLE :O SEE !IR USELESSNESS1 9JU/ICE1 & CRUELTY1 & 
SUFF] FROM !M4 ,IF FIFTY YE>S AGO ! IDLE RI* MAN & ! 
ILLIT]ATE LABOR] W]E BO? ALIKE CONV9C$ ?AT !IR /ATE ( 
EV]LA/+ HOLIDAY = ONE & EV]LA/+ TOIL = ! O!R WAS 
ORDA9$ BY ,GOD HIMSELF1 WE KN[ V]Y WELL ?AT N[ADAYS1 ?ANKS TO ! 
GR[? ( POPULATION & ! DIFFUSION ( BOOKS & $UCATION1 IT W\LD 
BE H>D TO F9D 9 ,EUROPE OR EV5 9 ,RUSSIA1 EI!R AMONG RI* OR POOR1 
A MAN TO :OM 9 ONE %APE OR ANO!R A D\BT AS TO ! JU/ICE ( ?IS 
/ATE ( ?+S HAD NEV] PRES5T$ ITSELF4 ,! RI* KN[ ?AT !Y >E 
GUILTY 9 ! V]Y FACT ( BE+ RI*1 & TRY TO EXPIATE !IR GUILT BY 
SACRIFICES TO >T & SCI5CE1 AS ( OLD !Y EXPIAT$ !IR S9S BY 
SACRIFICES TO ! ,*UR*4 ,& EV5 ! L>G] HALF ( ! WORK+ PEOPLE 
OP5LY DECL>E ?AT ! EXI/+ ORD] IS 9IQUIT\S & B\ND TO BE 
DE/ROY$ OR RE=M$4 ,ONE SET ( RELIGI\S PEOPLE ( :OM !RE >E 
MILLIONS 9 ,RUSSIA1 ! SO-CALL$ SECT>IES1 CONSID] ! EXI/+ 
SOCIAL ORD] AS UNJU/ & TO BE DE/ROY$ ON ! GR\ND ( ! ,GOSPEL 
TEA*+ TAK5 9 ITS TRUE S5SE4 ,O!RS REG>D IT AS UNJU/ ON ! 
GR\ND ( ! SOCIALI/IC1 COMMUNI/IC1 OR AN>*I/IC !ORIES1 :I* 
>E SPR++ UP 9 ! L[] /RATA ( ! WORK+ PEOPLE4 ,VIOL5CE NO 
LONG] RE/S ON ! BELIEF 9 ITS UTILITY1 BUT ONLY ON ! FACT ( ITS 
HAV+ EXI/$ SO LONG1 & BE+ ORGANIZ$ BY ! RUL+ CLASSES :O 
PR(IT BY IT1 SO ?AT ?OSE :O >E UND] !IR AU?ORITY CANNOT 
EXTRICATE !MSELVES FROM IT4 ,! GOV]NM5TS ( \R DAY--ALL ( !M1 
! MO/ DESPOTIC & ! LIB]AL ALIKE--HAVE BECOME :AT ,H]Z5 SO WELL 
CALL$ 0,<5<IS ,KHAN ) ! TELEGRAPH20 ?AT IS TO SAY1 ORGANIZATIONS 
( VIOL5CE BAS$ ON NO PR9CIPLE BUT ! GROSSE/ TYRANNY1 & AT ! 
SAME TIME TAK+ ADVANTAGE ( ALL ! MEANS 9V5T$ BY SCI5CE = ! 
PEACEFUL COLLECTIVE SOCIAL ACTIVITY ( FREE & EQUAL M51 US$ BY !M 
TO 5?RALL$ & OPPRESS !IR FELL[S4 

,GOV]NM5TS & ! RUL+ CLASSES NO LONG] TAKE !IR /& ON 
RI<T OR EV5 ON ! SEMBLANCE ( JU/ICE1 BUT ON A SKILLFUL 
ORGANIZATION C>RI$ TO SU* A PO9T ( P]FECTION BY ! AID ( 
SCI5CE ?AT EV]YONE IS CAU<T 9 ! CIRCLE ( VIOL5CE & HAS 
NO *ANCE ( ESCAP+ FROM IT4 ,?IS CIRCLE IS MADE UP N[ ( F\R 
ME?ODS ( WORK+ UPON M51 JO9$ TOGE!R LIKE ! LIMES ( A 
*A9 R+4 

,! FIR/ & OLDE/ ME?OD IS 9TIMIDATION4 ,?IS CONSI/S 9 
REPRES5T+ ! EXI/+ /ATE ORGANIZATION--:ATEV] IT MAY BE1 
FREE REPUBLIC OR ! MO/ SAVAGE DESPOTISM--AS SOME?+ SACR$ 
& IMMUTABLE1 & !RE=E FOLL[+ ANY EF=TS TO ALT] IT 
) ! CRUELE/ PUNI%M5TS4 ,?IS ME?OD IS 9 USE N[--AS IT 
HAS BE5 FROM OLD5 TIMES--:]EV] !RE IS A GOV]NM5T3 9 
,RUSSIA AGA9/ ! SO-CALL$ ,NIHILI/S1 9 ,AM]ICA AGA9/ 
,AN>*I/S1 9 ,FRANCE AGA9/ ,IMP]IALI/S1 ,LEGITIMI/S1 
,COMMUN>DS1 & ,AN>*I/S4 

,RAILWAYS1 TELEGRAPHS1 TELEPHONES1 PHOTOGRAPHS1 & ! GREAT 
P]FECTION ( ! MEANS ( GETT+ RID ( M5 = YE>S1 )\T 
KILL+ !M1 BY SOLIT>Y CONF9EM5T1 :]E1 HIDD5 FROM ! 
WORLD1 !Y P]I% & >E =GOTT51 & ! MANY O!R MOD]N 
9V5TIONS EMPLOY$ BY GOV]NM5T1 GIVE SU* P[] ?AT :5 ONCE 
AU?ORITY HAS COME 9TO C]TA9 H&S1 ! POLICE1 OP5 & 
SECRET1 ! ADM9I/RATION & PROSECUTORS1 JAIL]S & 
EXECUTION]S ( ALL K9DS1 DO !IR WORK SO ZEAL\SLY ?AT !RE 
IS NO *ANCE ( OV]TURN+ ! GOV]NM5T1 H[EV] CRUEL & 
S5SELESS IT MAY BE4 

,! SECOND ME?OD IS CORRUPTION4 ,IT CONSI/S 9 PLUND]+ ! 
9DU/RI\S WORK+ PEOPLE ( !IR WEAL? BY MEANS ( TAXES & 
DI/RIBUT+ IT 9 SATISFY+ ! GRE$ ( (FICIALS1 :O >E 
B\ND 9 RETURN TO SUPPORT & KEEP UP ! OPPRESSION ( ! 
PEOPLE4 ,!SE B\<T (FICIALS1 FROM ! HI<E/ M9I/]S TO ! 
POORE/ COPY+ CL]KS1 MAKE UP AN UNBROK5 NETWORK ( M5 B\ND 
TOGE!R BY ! SAME 9T]E/--?AT ( LIV+ AT ! EXP5SE ( 
! PEOPLE4 ,!Y BECOME ! RI*] ! MORE SUBMISSIVELY !Y 
C>RY \T ! WILL ( ! GOV]NM5T2 & AT ALL TIMES & PLACES1 
/ICK+ AT NO?+1 9 ALL DEP>TM5TS SUPPORT BY WORD & DE$ 
! VIOL5CE ( GOV]NM5T1 ON :I* !IR [N PROSP]ITY ALSO 
RE/S4 

,! ?IRD ME?OD IS :AT ,I CAN ONLY DESCRIBE AS HYPNOTIZ+ ! 
PEOPLE4 ,?IS CONSI/S 9 *ECK+ ! MORAL DEVELOPM5T ( M51 
& BY V>I\S SUGGE/IONS KEEP+ !M BACK 9 ! IDEAL ( LIFE1 
\TGR[N BY MANK9D AT L>GE1 ON :I* ! P[] ( GOV]NM5T 
RE/S4 ,?IS HYPNOTIZ+ PROCESS IS ORGANIZ$ AT ! PRES5T 9 ! 
MO/ COMPLEX MANN]1 & />T+ FROM !IR E>LIE/ *ILDHOOD1 
CONT9UES TO ACT ON M5 TILL ! DAY ( !IR DEA?4 ,IT BEG9S 9 
!IR E>LIE/ YE>S 9 ! COMPULSORY S*OOLS1 CREAT$ = ?IS 
PURPOSE1 9 :I* ! *ILDR5 HAVE 9/ILL$ 9TO !M ! IDEAS 
( LIFE ( !IR ANCE/ORS1 :I* >E 9 DIRECT ANTAGONISM ) 
! CONSCI5CE ( ! MOD]N WORLD4 ,9 C\NTRIES :]E !RE IS A 
/ATE RELIGION1 !Y TEA* ! *ILDR5 ! S5SELESS BLASPHEMIES 
( ! ,*UR* CATE*ISMS1 TOGE!R ) ! DUTY ( OB$I5CE TO 
!IR SUP]IORS4 ,9 REPUBLICAN /ATES !Y TEA* !M ! SAVAGE 
SUP]/ITION ( PATRIOTISM & ! SAME PRET5D$ OB$I5CE TO ! 
GOV]N+ AU?ORITIES4 

,! PROCESS IS KEPT UP DUR+ LAT] YE>S BY ! 5C\RAGEM5T ( 
RELIGI\S & PATRIOTIC SUP]/ITIONS4 

,! RELIGI\S SUP]/ITION IS 5C\RAG$ BY E/ABLI%+1 ) 
MONEY TAK5 FROM ! PEOPLE1 TEMPLES1 PROCESSIONS1 MEMORIALS1 & 
FE/IVALS1 :I*1 AID$ BY PA9T+1 >*ITECTURE1 MUSIC1 & 
9C5SE1 9TOXICATE ! PEOPLE1 & ABOVE ALL BY ! SUPPORT ( 
! CL]GY1 :OSE DUTY CONSI/S 9 BRUTALIZ+ ! PEOPLE & 
KEEP+ !M 9 A P]MAN5T /ATE ( /UPEFACTION BY !IR 
TEA*+1 ! SOLEMNITY ( !IR S]VICES1 !IR S]MONS1 & 
!IR 9T]F]5CE 9 PRIVATE LIFE--AT BIR?S1 DEA?S1 & 
M>RIAGES4 ,! PATRIOTIC SUP]/ITION IS 5C\RAG$ BY ! 
CREATION1 ) MONEY TAK5 FROM ! PEOPLE1 ( NATIONAL FETES1 
SPECTACLES1 MONUM5TS1 & FE/IVALS TO DISPOSE M5 TO ATTA* 
IMPORTANCE TO !IR [N NATION1 & TO ! AGGR&IZEM5T ( ! 
/ATE & ITS RUL]S1 & TO FEEL ANTAGONISM & EV5 HATR$ = 
O!R NATIONS4 ,) !SE OBJECTS UND] DESPOTIC GOV]NM5TS !RE 
IS DIRECT PROHIBITION AGA9/ PR9T+ & DISSEM9AT+ BOOKS TO 
5LI<T5 ! PEOPLE1 & EV]YONE :O MI<T R\SE ! PEOPLE FROM 
!IR LE?>GY IS EXIL$ OR IMPRISON$4 ,MOREOV]1 UND] EV]Y 
GOV]NM5T )\T EXCEPTION EV]Y?+ IS KEPT BACK ?AT MI<T 
EMANCIPATE & EV]Y?+ 5C\RAG$ ?AT T5DS TO CORRUPT ! 
PEOPLE1 SU* AS LIT]>Y WORKS T5D+ TO KEEP !M 9 ! 
B>B>ISM ( RELIGI\S & PATRIOTIC SUP]/ITION1 ALL K9DS ( 
S5SUAL AMUSEM5TS1 SPECTACLES1 CIRCUSES1 !AT]S1 & EV5 ! 
PHYSICAL MEANS ( 9DUC+ /UPEFACTION1 AS TOBACCO & ALCOHOL1 
:I* =M ! PR9CIPAL S\RCE ( REV5UE ( /ATES4 ,EV5 
PRO/ITUTION IS 5C\RAG$1 & NOT ONLY RECOGNIZ$1 BUT EV5 
ORGANIZ$ BY ! GOV]NM5T 9 ! MAJORITY ( /ATES4 ,SO MU* = 
! ?IRD ME?OD4 

,! F\R? ME?OD CONSI/S 9 SELECT+ FROM ALL ! M5 :O HAVE 
BE5 /UPEFI$ & 5SLAV$ BY ! ?REE =M] ME?ODS A C]TA9 
NUMB]1 EXPOS+ !M TO SPECIAL & 9T5SIFI$ MEANS ( 
/UPEFACTION & BRUTALIZATION1 & SO MAK+ !M 9TO A PASSIVE 
9/RUM5T = C>RY+ \T ALL ! CRUELTIES & BRUTALITIES 
NE$$ BY ! GOV]NM5T4 ,?IS RESULT IS ATTA9$ BY TAK+ !M 
AT ! Y\?FUL AGE :5 M5 HAVE NOT HAD TIME TO =M CLE> & 
DEF9ITE PR9CIPLES ( MORALS1 & REMOV+ !M FROM ALL NATURAL 
& HUMAN CONDITIONS ( LIFE1 HOME1 FAMILY & K9DR$1 & USEFUL 
LABOR4 ,!Y >E %UT UP TOGE!R 9 B>RACKS1 DRESS$ 9 SPECIAL 
CLO!S1 & WORK$ UPON BY CRIES1 DRUMS1 MUSIC1 & %9+ 
OBJECTS TO GO ?R\< C]TA9 DAILY ACTIONS 9V5T$ = ?IS 
PURPOSE1 & BY ?IS MEANS >E BR\<T 9TO AN HYPNOTIC CONDITION 
9 :I* !Y CEASE TO BE M5 & BECOME M]E S5SELESS MA*9ES1 
SUBMISSIVE TO ! HYPNOTIZ]4 ,!SE PHYSICALLY VIGOR\S Y\NG M5 
79 !SE DAYS ( UNIV]SAL CONSCRIPTION1 ALL Y\NG M571 
HYPNOTIZ$1 >M$ ) MURD]\S WEAPONS1 ALWAYS OB$I5T TO ! 
GOV]N+ AU?ORITIES & READY = ANY ACT ( VIOL5CE AT !IR 
COMM&1 CON/ITUTE ! F\R? & PR9CIPAL ME?OD ( 5SLAV+ 
M54 

,BY ?IS ME?OD ! CIRCLE ( VIOL5CE IS COMPLET$4 

,9TIMIDATION1 CORRUPTION1 & HYPNOTIZ+ BR+ PEOPLE 9TO A 
CONDITION 9 :I* !Y >E WILL+ TO BE SOLDI]S2 ! SOLDI]S 
GIVE ! P[] ( PUNI%+ & PLUND]+ !M 7& PUR*AS+ 
(FICIALS ) ! SPOILS71 & HYPNOTIZ+ !M & CONV]T+ 
!M 9 TIME 9TO !SE SAME SOLDI]S AGA94 

,! CIRCLE IS COMPLETE1 & !RE IS NO *ANCE ( BREAK+ ?R\< 
IT BY =CE4 

,SOME P]SONS MA9TA9 ?AT FRE$OM FROM VIOL5CE1 OR AT LEA/ A 
GREAT DIM9UTION ( IT1 MAY BE GA9$ BY ! OPPRESS$ =CIBLY 
OV]TURN+ ! OPPRESSIVE GOV]NM5T & REPLAC+ IT BY A NEW 
ONE UND] :I* SU* VIOL5CE & OPPRESSION WILL BE UNNECESS>Y1 
BUT !Y DECEIVE !MSELVES & O!RS1 & !IR EF=TS DO NOT 
BETT] ! POSITION ( ! OPPRESS$1 BUT ONLY MAKE IT WORSE4 
,!IR CONDUCT ONLY T5DS TO 9CREASE ! DESPOTISM ( GOV]NM5T4 
,!IR EF=TS ONLY AF=D A PLAUSIBLE PRETEXT = GOV]NM5T TO 
/R5G!N !IR P[]4 

,EV5 IF WE ADMIT ?AT UND] A COMB9ATION ( CIRCUM/ANCES 
SPECIALLY UNFAVORABLE = ! GOV]NM5T1 AS 9 ,FRANCE 9 #a#h#g1 
ANY GOV]NM5T MI<T BE =CIBLY OV]TURN$ & ! P[] 
TRANSF]R$ TO O!R H&S1 ! NEW AU?ORITY W\LD R>ELY BE LESS 
OPPRESSIVE ?AN ! OLD ONE2 ON ! CONTR>Y1 ALWAYS HAV+ TO 
DEF5D ITSELF AGA9/ ITS DISPOSSESS$ & EXASP]AT$ 5EMIES1 IT 
W\LD BE MORE DESPOTIC & CRUEL1 AS HAS ALWAYS BE5 ! RULE 9 
ALL REVOLUTIONS4 

,:ILE SOCIALI/S & COMMUNI/S REG>D ! 9DIVIDUALI/IC1 
CAPITALI/IC ORGANIZATION ( SOCIETY AS AN EVIL1 & ! 
AN>*I/S REG>D AS AN EVIL ALL GOV]NM5T :ATEV]1 !RE >E 
ROYALI/S1 CONS]VATIVES1 & CAPITALI/S :O CONSID] ANY 
SOCIALI/IC OR COMMUNI/IC ORGANIZATION OR AN>*Y AS AN EVIL1 & 
ALL !SE P>TIES HAVE NO MEANS O!R ?AN VIOL5CE TO BR+ M5 
TO AGREEM5T4 ,:I*EV] ( !SE P>TIES W]E SUCCESSFUL 9 
BR++ !IR S*EMES TO PASS1 MU/ RESORT TO SUPPORT ITS 
AU?ORITY TO ALL ! EXI/+ ME?ODS ( VIOL5CE1 & EV5 9V5T 
NEW ONES4 

,! OPPRESS$ W\LD BE ANO!R SET ( PEOPLE1 & CO]CION W\LD 
TAKE SOME NEW =M2 BUT ! VIOL5CE & OPPRESSION W\LD BE 
UN*ANG$ OR EV5 MORE CRUEL1 S9CE HATR$ W\LD BE 9T5SIFI$ BY 
! /RUGGLE1 & NEW =MS ( OPPRESSION W\LD HAVE BE5 DEVIS$4 
,SO IT HAS ALWAYS BE5 AFT] ALL REVOLUTIONS & ALL ATTEMPTS AT 
REVOLUTION1 ALL CONSPIRACIES1 & ALL VIOL5T *ANGES ( 
GOV]NM5T4 ,EV]Y CONFLICT ONLY /R5G!NS ! MEANS ( 
OPPRESSION 9 ! H&S ( ?OSE :O HAPP5 AT A GIV5 MOM5T TO 
BE 9 P[]4 

,! POSITION ( \R ,*RI/IAN SOCIETY1 & ESPECIALLY ! IDEALS 
MO/ CURR5T 9 IT1 PROVE ?IS 9 A /RIK+LY CONV9C+ WAY4 

,!RE REMA9S N[ ONLY ONE SPH]E ( HUMAN LIFE NOT 5CROA*$ 
UPON BY GOV]NM5T AU?ORITY--?AT IS ! DOME/IC1 ECONOMIC 
SPH]E1 ! SPH]E ( PRIVATE LIFE & LABOR4 ,& EV5 ?IS IS 
N[--?ANKS TO ! EF=TS ( COMMUNI/S & SOCIALI/S--BE+ 
GRADUALLY 5CROA*$ UPON BY GOV]NM5T1 SO ?AT LABOR & 
RECREATION1 DWELL+S1 DRESS1 & FOOD WILL GRADUALLY1 IF ! 
HOPES ( ! RE=M]S >E SUCCESSFUL1 BE PRESCRIB$ & REGULAT$ 
BY GOV]NM5T4 

,! SL[ PROGRESS ( EI<TE5 C5TURIES HAS BR\<T ! ,*RI/IAN 
NATIONS AGA9 TO ! NECESSITY ( DECID+ ! QUE/ION !Y HAVE 
EVAD$--! QUE/ION ( ! ACCEPTANCE OR NON-ACCEPTANCE ( 
,*RI/'S TEA*+1 & ! QUE/ION FOLL[+ UPON IT 9 SOCIAL 
LIFE ( RESI/ANCE OR NONRESI/ANCE TO EVIL BY =CE4 ,BUT !RE 
IS ?IS DIFF]5CE1 ?AT :]EAS =M]LY M5 C\LD ACCEPT OR 
REFUSE TO ACCEPT ! SOLUTION GIV5 BY ,*RI/1 N[ ?AT SOLUTION 
CANNOT BE AVOID$1 S9CE IT ALONE CAN SAVE M5 FROM ! SLAV]Y 9 
:I* !Y >E CAU<T LIKE A NET4 

,BUT IT IS NOT ONLY ! MIS]Y ( ! POSITION :I* MAKES ?IS 
9EVITABLE4 

,:ILE ! PAGAN ORGANIZATION HAS BE5 PROV$ MORE & MORE FALSE1 
! TRU? ( ! ,*RI/IAN RELIGION HAS BE5 GR[+ MORE & MORE 
EVID5T4 

,NOT 9 VA9 HAVE ! BE/ M5 ( ,*RI/IAN HUMANITY1 :O 
APPREH5D$ ! TRU? BY SPIRITUAL 9TUITION1 = EI<TE5 
C5TURIES TE/IFI$ TO IT 9 SPITE ( EV]Y M5ACE1 EV]Y 
PRIVATION1 & EV]Y SUFF]+4 ,BY !IR M>TYRDOM !Y PASS$ ON 
! TRU? TO ! MASSES1 & IMPRESS$ IT ON !IR HE>TS4 

,*RI/IANITY HAS P5ETRAT$ 9TO ! CONSCI\SNESS ( HUMANITY1 
NOT ONLY NEGATIVELY BY ! DEMON/RATION ( ! IMPOSSIBILITY ( 
CONT9U+ 9 ! PAGAN LIFE1 BUT ALSO ?R\< ITS SIMPLIFICATION1 
ITS 9CREAS$ CLE>NESS & FRE$OM FROM ! SUP]/ITIONS 
9T]M+L$ ) IT1 & ITS DIFFUSION ?R\< ALL CLASSES ( ! 
POPULATION4 

,EI<TE5 C5TURIES ( ,*RI/IANITY HAVE NOT PASS$ )\T AN 
EFFECT EV5 ON ?OSE :O ACCEPT$ IT ONLY EXT]NALLY4 ,!SE 
EI<TE5 C5TURIES HAVE BR\<T M5 SO F> ?AT EV5 :ILE !Y 
CONT9UE TO LIVE ! PAGAN LIFE :I* IS NO LONG] CONSI/5T ) 
! DEVELOPM5T ( HUMANITY1 !Y NOT ONLY SEE CLE>LY ALL ! 
WRET*$NESS ( !IR POSITION1 BUT 9 ! DEP?S ( !IR S\LS 
!Y BELIEVE 7!Y CAN ONLY LIVE ?R\< ?IS BELIEF7 ?AT ! 
ONLY SALVATION FROM ?IS POSITION IS TO BE F\ND 9 FULFILL+ ! 
,*RI/IAN DOCTR9E 9 ITS TRUE SIGNIFICANCE4 ,AS TO ! TIME & 
MANN] ( SALVATION1 OP9IONS >E DIVID$ ACCORD+ TO ! 
9TELLECTUAL DEVELOPM5T & ! PREJUDICES ( EA* SOCIETY4 ,BUT 
EV]Y MAN ( ! MOD]N WORLD RECOGNIZES ?AT \R SALVATION LIES 
9 FULFILL+ ! LAW ( ,*RI/4 ,SOME BELIEV]S 9 ! 
SUP]NATURAL *>ACT] ( ,*RI/IANITY HOLD ?AT SALVATION WILL 
COME :5 ALL M5 >E BR\<T TO BELIEVE 9 ,*RI/1 :OSE SECOND 
COM+ IS AT H&4 ,O!R BELIEV]S 9 SUP]NATURAL ,*RI/IANITY 
HOLD ?AT SALVATION WILL COME ?R\< ! ,*UR*1 :I* WILL DRAW 
ALL M5 9TO ITS FOLD1 TRA9 !M 9 ! ,*RI/IAN VIRTUES1 & 
TRANS=M !IR LIFE4 ,A ?IRD SECTION1 :O DO NOT ADMIT ! 
DIV9ITY ( ,*RI/1 HOLD ?AT ! SALVATION ( MANK9D WILL BE 
BR\<T AB\T BY SL[ & GRADUAL PROGRESS1 ?R\< :I* ! 
PAGAN PR9CIPLES ( \R EXI/5CE WILL BE REPLAC$ BY ! 
PR9CIPLES ( LIB]TY1 EQUALITY1 & FRAT]NITY--?AT IS1 BY 
,*RI/IAN PR9CIPLES4 ,A F\R? SECTION1 :O BELIEVE 9 ! SOCIAL 
REVOLUTION1 HOLD ?AT SALVATION WILL COME :5 ?R\< A VIOL5T 
REVOLUTION M5 >E =C$ 9TO COMMUNITY ( PROP]TY1 ABOLITION ( 
GOV]NM5T1 & COLLECTIVE 9/EAD ( 9DIVIDUAL 9DU/RY--?AT IS 
TO SAY1 ! REALIZATION ( ONE SIDE ( ! ,*RI/IAN DOCTR9E4 ,9 
ONE WAY OR ANO!R ALL M5 ( \R DAY 9 !IR 9N] CONSCI\SNESS 
CONDEMN ! EXI/+ EFFETE PAGAN ORD]1 & ADMIT1 (T5 
UNCONSCI\SLY & :ILE REG>D+ !MSELVES AS HO/ILE TO 
,*RI/IANITY1 ?AT \R SALVATION IS ONLY TO BE F\ND 9 ! 
APPLICATION ( ! ,*RI/IAN DOCTR9E1 OR P>TS ( IT1 9 ITS TRUE 
SIGNIFICANCE TO \R DAILY LIFE4 

,*RI/IANITY CANNOT1 AS ITS ,F\ND] SAID1 BE REALIZ$ BY ! 
MAJORITY ( M5 ALL AT ONCE2 IT MU/ GR[ LIKE A HUGE TREE FROM A 
T9Y SE$4 ,& SO IT HAS GR[N1 & N[ HAS REA*$ ITS FULL 
DEVELOPM5T1 NOT YET 9 ACTUAL LIFE1 BUT 9 ! CONSCI5CE ( M5 
( TO-DAY4 

,N[ NOT ONLY ! M9ORITY1 :O HAVE ALWAYS COMPREH5D$ 
,*RI/IANITY BY SPIRITUAL 9TUITION1 BUT ALL ! VA/ MAJORITY :O 
SEEM SO F> FROM IT 9 !IR SOCIAL EXI/5CE RECOGNIZE ITS TRUE 
SIGNIFICANCE4 

,LOOK AT 9DIVIDUAL M5 9 !IR PRIVATE LIFE1 LI/5 TO !IR 
/&>DS ( CONDUCT 9 !IR JUDGM5T ( ONE ANO!R2 HE> NOT 
ONLY !IR PUBLIC UTT]ANCES1 BUT ! C\NSELS GIV5 BY P>5TS 
& GU>DIANS TO ! Y\NG 9 !IR *>GE2 & Y\ WILL SEE ?AT1 
F> AS !IR SOCIAL LIFE BAS$ ON VIOL5CE MAY BE FROM REALIZ+ 
,*RI/IAN TRU?1 9 !IR PRIVATE LIFE :AT IS CONSID]$ GOOD BY 
ALL )\T EXCEPTION IS NO?+ BUT ! ,*RI/IAN VIRTUES2 :AT 
IS CONSID]$ AS BAD IS NO?+ BUT ! ANTI*RI/IAN VISES4 ,?OSE 
:O CONSECRATE !IR LIVES SELF-SACRIFIC+LY TO ! S]VICE ( 
HUMANITY >E REG>D$ AS ! BE/ M54 ,! SELFI%1 :O MAKE USE 
( ! MIS=TUNES ( O!RS = !IR [N ADVANTAGE1 >E REG>D$ 
AS ! WOR/ ( M54 

,?\< SOME NON-,*RI/IAN IDEALS1 SU* AS /R5G?1 C\RAGE1 & 
WEAL?1 >E /ILL WOR%IP$ BY A FEW :O HAVE NOT BE5 P5ETRAT$ 
BY ! ,*RI/IAN SPIRIT1 !SE IDEALS >E \T ( DATE & >E 
AB&ON$1 IF NOT BY ALL1 AT LEA/ BY ALL ?OSE REG>D$ AS ! 
BE/ PEOPLE4 ,!RE >E NO IDEALS1 O!R ?AN ! ,*RI/IAN IDEALS1 
:I* >E ACCEPT$ BY ALL & REG>D$ AS B9D+ ON ALL4 

,! POSITION ( \R ,*RI/IAN HUMANITY1 IF Y\ LOOK AT IT FROM ! 
\TSIDE ) ALL ITS CRUELTY & DEGRADATION ( M51 IS T]RIBLE 
9DE$4 ,BUT IF ONE LOOKS AT IT )91 9 ITS 9N] CONSCI\SNESS1 
! SPECTACLE IT PRES5TS IS ABSOLUTELY DIFF]5T4 

,ALL ! EVIL ( \R LIFE SEEMS TO EXI/ ONLY BECAUSE IT HAS BE5 
SO = SO LONG2 ?OSE :O DO ! EVIL HAVE NOT HAD TIME YET TO 
LE>N H[ TO ACT O!RWISE1 ?\< !Y DO NOT WANT TO ACT AS !Y 
DO4 

,ALL ! EVIL SEEMS TO EXI/ ?R\< SOME CAUSE 9DEP5D5T ( ! 
CONSCI5CE ( M54 

,/RANGE & CONTRADICTORY AS IT SEEMS1 ALL M5 ( ! PRES5T DAY 
HATE ! V]Y SOCIAL ORD] !Y >E !MSELVES SUPPORT+4 

,I ?9K IT IS ,MAX ,MULL] :O DESCRIBES ! AMAZEM5T ( AN ,9DIAN 
CONV]T TO ,*RI/IANITY1 :O AFT] ABSORB+ ! ESS5CE ( ! 
,*RI/IAN DOCTR9E CAME TO ,EUROPE & SAW ! ACTUAL LIFE ( 
,*RI/IANS4 ,HE C\LD NOT RECOV] FROM HIS A/ONI%M5T AT ! 
COMPLETE CONTRA/ BETWE5 ! REALITY & :AT HE HAD EXPECT$ TO 
F9D AMONG ,*RI/IAN NATIONS4 ,IF WE FEEL NO A/ONI%M5T AT ! 
CONTRA/ BETWE5 \R CONVICTIONS & \R CONDUCT1 ?AT IS BECAUSE 
! 9FLU5CES1 T5D+ TO OBSCURE ! CONTRA/1 PRODUCE AN EFFECT 
UPON US TOO4 ,WE NE$ ONLY LOOK AT \R LIFE FROM ! PO9T ( VIEW 
( ?AT ,9DIAN1 :O UND]/OOD ,*RI/IANITY 9 ITS TRUE 
SIGNIFICANCE1 )\T ANY COMPROMISES OR CONCESSIONS1 WE NE$ BUT 
LOOK AT ! SAVAGE BRUTALITIES ( :I* \R LIFE IS FULL1 TO BE 
APPALL$ AT ! CONTRADICTIONS 9 ! MID/ ( :I* WE LIVE (T5 
)\T OBS]V+ !M4 

,WE NE$ ONLY RECALL ! PREP>ATIONS = W>1 ! MITRAILLEUSES1 
! SILV]-GILT BULLETS1 ! TORP$OES1 &--! ,R$ ,CROSS2 ! 
SOLIT>Y PRISON CELLS1 ! EXP]IM5TS ( EXECUTION BY 
ELECTRICITY--& ! C>E ( ! HYGI5IC WELF>E ( PRISON]S2 
! PHILAN?ROPY ( ! RI*1 & !IR LIFE1 :I* PRODUCES ! 
POOR !Y >E B5EFIT+4 

,& !SE 9CONSI/5CIES >E NOT1 AS IT MI<T SEEM1 BECAUSE M5 
PRET5D TO BE ,*RI/IANS :ILE !Y >E REALLY PAGANS1 BUT BECAUSE 
( SOME?+ LACK+ 9 M51 OR SOME K9D ( =CE H9D]+ !M 
FROM BE+ :AT !Y ALREADY FEEL !MSELVES TO BE 9 !IR 
CONSCI\SNESS1 & :AT !Y G5U9ELY WI% TO BE4 ,M5 ( ! 
PRES5T DAY DO NOT M]ELY PRET5D TO HATE OPPRESSION1 9EQUALITY1 
CLASS DI/9CTION1 & EV]Y K9D ( CRUELTY TO ANIMALS AS WELL AS 
HUMAN BE+S4 ,!Y G5U9ELY DETE/ ALL ?IS1 BUT !Y DO NOT 
KN[ H[ TO PUT A /OP TO IT1 OR P]HAPS CANNOT DECIDE TO GIVE UP 
:AT PRES]VES IT ALL1 & SEEMS TO !M NECESS>Y4 

,9DE$1 ASK EV]Y MAN SEP>ATELY :E!R HE ?9KS IT LAUDABLE & 
WOR?Y ( A MAN ( ?IS AGE TO HOLD A POSITION FROM :I* HE 
RECEIVES A SAL>Y DISPROPORTIONATE TO HIS WORK2 TO TAKE FROM ! 
PEOPLE--(T5 9 POV]TY--TAXES TO BE SP5T ON CON/RUCT+ 
CANNON1 TORP$OES1 & O!R 9/RUM5TS ( BUT*]Y1 SO AS TO 
MAKE W> ON PEOPLE ) :OM WE WI% TO BE AT PEACE1 & :O FEEL 
! SAME WI% 9 REG>D TO US2 OR TO RECEIVE A SAL>Y = DEVOT+ 
ONE'S :OLE LIFE TO CON/RUCT+ !SE 9/RUM5TS ( BUT*]Y1 OR 
TO PREP>+ ONESELF & O!RS = ! WORK ( MURD]4 ,& ASK 
HIM :E!R IT IS LAUDABLE & WOR?Y ( A MAN1 & SUITABLE = A 
,*RI/IAN1 TO EMPLOY HIMSELF1 = A SAL>Y1 9 SEIZ+ WRET*$1 
MISGUID$1 (T5 ILLIT]ATE & DRUNK51 CREATURES BECAUSE !Y 
APPROPRIATE ! PROP]TY ( O!RS--ON A MU* SMALL] SCALE ?AN 
WE DO--OR BECAUSE !Y KILL M5 9 A DIFF]5T FA%ION FROM ?AT 
9 :I* WE UND]TAKE TO DO IT--& %UTT+ !M 9 PRISON = 
IT1 ILL TREAT+ !M & KILL+ !M2 & :E!R IT IS LAUDABLE 
& WOR?Y ( A MAN & A ,*RI/IAN TO PREA* = A SAL>Y TO ! 
PEOPLE NOT ,*RI/IANITY1 BUT SUP]/ITIONS :I* ONE KN[S TO BE 
/UPID & P]NICI\S2 & :E!R IT IS LAUDABLE & WOR?Y ( A 
MAN TO ROB HIS NEI<BOR = HIS GRATIFICATION ( :AT HE WANTS TO 
SATISFY HIS SIMPLE/ NE$S1 AS ! GREAT L&[N]S DO2 OR TO 
=CE HIM TO EXHAU/+ LABOR BEYOND HIS /R5G? TO AUGM5T ONE'S 
WEAL?1 AS DO FACTORY [N]S & MANUFACTUR]S2 OR TO PR(IT BY 
! POV]TY ( M5 TO 9CREASE ONE'S GA9S1 AS M]*ANTS DO4 ,& 
EV]YONE TAK5 SEP>ATELY1 ESPECIALLY IF ONE'S REM>KS >E 
DIRECT$ AT SOMEONE ELSE1 NOT HIMSELF1 WILL ANSW]1 ,NO6 ,& YET 
! V]Y MAN :O SEES ALL ! BAS5ESS ( ?OSE ACTIONS1 ( HIS 
[N FREE WILL1 UNCO]C$ BY ANYONE1 (T5 EV5 = NO PECUNI>Y 
PR(IT1 BUT ONLY FROM *ILDI% VANITY1 = A *9A CROSS1 A SCRAP 
( RIBBON1 A BIT ( FR+E HE IS ALL[$ TO WE>1 WILL 5T] 
MILIT>Y S]VICE1 BECOME A MAGI/RATE OR JU/ICE ( ! PEACE1 
COMMISSION]1 >*BI%OP1 OR BEADLE1 ?\< 9 FULFILL+ !SE 
(FICES HE MU/ COMMIT ACTS ! BAS5ESS & %AMEFULNESS ( :I* 
HE CANNOT FAIL TO RECOGNIZE4 

,I KN[ ?AT MANY ( !SE M5 WILL CONFID5TLY TRY TO PROVE ?AT 
!Y HAVE REASONS = REG>D+ !IR POSITION AS LEGITIMATE & 
QUITE 9DISP5SABLE4 ,!Y WILL SAY 9 !IR DEF5SE ?AT 
AU?ORITY IS GIV5 BY ,GOD1 ?AT ! FUNCTIONS ( ! /ATE >E 
9DISP5SABLE = ! WELF>E ( HUMANITY1 ?AT PROP]TY IS NOT 
OPPOS$ TO ,*RI/IANITY1 ?AT ! RI* Y\NG MAN WAS ONLY 
COMM&$ TO SELL ALL HE HAD & GIVE TO ! POOR IF HE WI%$ TO 
BE P]FECT1 ?AT ! EXI/+ DI/RIBUTION ( PROP]TY & \R 
COMM]CIAL SY/EM MU/ ALWAYS REMA9 AS !Y >E1 & >E TO ! 
ADVANTAGE ( ALL1 & SO ON4 ,BUT1 H[EV] MU* !Y TRY TO 
DECEIVE !MSELVES & O!RS1 !Y ALL KN[ ?AT :AT !Y >E 
DO+ IS OPPOS$ TO ALL ! BELIEFS :I* !Y PR(ESS1 & 9 ! 
DEP?S ( !IR S\LS1 :5 !Y >E LEFT ALONE ) !IR 
CONSCI5CE1 !Y >E A%AM$ & MIS]ABLE AT ! RECOLLECTION ( 
IT1 ESPECIALLY IF ! BAS5ESS ( !IR ACTION HAS BE5 PO9T$ 
\T TO !M4 ,A MAN ( ! PRES5T DAY1 :E!R HE BELIEVES 9 ! 
DIV9ITY ( ,*RI/ OR NOT1 CANNOT FAIL TO SEE ?AT TO ASSI/ 9 
! CAPACITY ( CZ>1 M9I/]1 GOV]NOR1 OR COMMISSION] 9 
TAK+ FROM A POOR FAMILY ITS LA/ C[ = TAXES TO BE SP5T ON 
CANNONS1 OR ON ! PAY & P5SIONS ( IDLE (FICIALS1 :O LIVE 9 
LUXURY & >E WORSE ?AN USELESS2 OR 9 PUTT+ 9TO PRISON SOME 
MAN WE HAVE \RSELVES CORRUPT$1 & ?R[+ HIS FAMILY ON ! 
/REETS2 OR 9 PLUND]+ & BUT*]+ 9 W>2 OR 9 9CULCAT+ 
SAVAGE & IDOLATR\S SUP]/ITI\S 9 ! PLACE ( ! LAW ( 
,*RI/2 OR 9 IMP\ND+ ! C[ F\ND ON ONE'S L&1 ?\< IT 
BELONGS TO A MAN :O HAS NO L&2 OR TO *EAT ! WORKMAN 9 A 
FACTORY1 BY IMPOS+ F9ES = ACCID5TALLY SPOIL$ >TICLES2 OR 
MAK+ A POOR MAN PAY D\BLE ! VALUE = ANY?+ SIMPLY BECAUSE 
HE IS 9 ! DIRE/ POV]TY2--NOT A MAN ( ! PRES5T DAY CAN 
FAIL TO KN[ ?AT ALL !SE ACTIONS >E BASE & DISGRACEFUL1 & 
?AT !Y NE$ NOT DO !M4 ,!Y ALL KN[ IT4 ,!Y KN[ ?AT 
:AT !Y >E DO+ IS WRONG1 & W\LD NOT DO IT = ANY?+ 9 
! WORLD IF !Y HAD ! P[] ( RESI/+ ! =CES :I* %UT 
!IR EYES TO ! CRIM9ALITY ( !IR ACTIONS & IMPEL !M TO 
COMMIT !M4 

,9 NO?+ IS ! PIT* ( 9CONSI/5CY MOD]N LIFE HAS ATTA9$ 
TO SO EVID5T AS 9 UNIV]SAL CONSCRIPTION1 :I* IS ! LA/ 
RES\RCE & ! F9AL EXPRESSION ( VIOL5CE4 

,9DE$1 IT IS ONLY BECAUSE ?IS /ATE ( UNIV]SAL >MAM5T HAS 
BE5 BR\<T AB\T GRADUALLY & IMP]CEPTIBLY1 & BECAUSE 
GOV]NM5TS HAVE EX]T$1 9 MA9TA9+ IT1 EV]Y RES\RCE ( 
9TIMIDATION1 CORRUPTION1 BRUTALIZATION1 & VIOL5CE1 ?AT WE DO 
NOT SEE ITS FLAGRANT 9CONSI/5CY ) ! ,*RI/IAN IDEAS & 
S5TIM5TS BY :I* ! MOD]N WORLD IS P]MEAT$4 

,WE >E SO ACCU/OM$ TO ! 9CONSI/5CY ?AT WE DO NOT SEE ALL 
! HIDE\S FOLLY & IMMORALITY ( M5 VOLUNT>ILY *OOS+ ! 
PR(ESSION ( BUT*]Y AS ?\< IT W]E AN HONORABLE C>E]1 ( 
POOR WRET*ES SUBMITT+ TO CONSCRIPTION1 OR 9 C\NTRIES :]E 
COMPULSORY S]VICE HAS NOT BE5 9TRODUC$1 ( PEOPLE VOLUNT>ILY 
AB&ON+ A LIFE ( 9DU/RY TO RECRUIT SOLDI]S & TRA9 !M 
AS MURD]]S4 ,WE KN[ ?AT ALL ( !SE M5 >E EI!R 
,*RI/IANS1 OR PR(ESS HUMANE & LIB]AL PR9CIPLES1 & !Y 
KN[ ?AT !Y ?US BECOME P>TLY RESPONSIBLE--?R\< UNIV]SAL 
CONSCRIPTION1 P]SONALLY RESPONSIBLE--= ! MO/ 9SANE1 
AIMLESS1 & BRUTAL MURD]S4 ,& YET !Y ALL DO IT4 

,MORE ?AN ?AT1 9 ,G]MANY1 :]E COMPULSORY S]VICE FIR/ 
ORIG9AT$1 ,CAPRIVI HAS GIV5 EXPRESSION TO :AT HAD BE5 HI!RTO 
SO ASSIDU\SLY CONCEAL$--?AT IS1 ?AT ! M5 ?AT ! SOLDI]S 
WILL HAVE TO KILL >E NOT =EIGN]S ALONE1 BUT !IR [N 
C\NTRYM51 ! V]Y WORK+ PEOPLE FROM :OM !Y !MSELVES >E 
TAK54 ,& ?IS ADMISSION HAS NOT OP5$ PEOPLE'S EYES1 HAS NOT 
HORRIFI$ !M6 ,!Y /ILL GO LIKE %EEP TO ! SLAU<T]1 & 
SUBMIT TO EV]Y?+ REQUIR$ ( !M4 

,& ?AT IS NOT ALL3 ! ,EMP]OR ( ,G]MANY HAS LATELY %[N /ILL 
MORE CLE>LY ! DUTIES ( ! >MY1 BY ?ANK+ & REW>D+ A 
SOLDI] = KILL+ A DEF5SELESS CITIZ5 :O MADE HIS APPROA* 
9CAUTI\SLY4 ,BY REW>D+ AN ACTION ALWAYS REG>D$ AS BASE & 
C[>DLY EV5 BY M5 ON ! L[E/ LEVEL ( MORALITY1 ,WILLIAM HAS 
%[N ?AT A SOLDI]'S *IEF DUTY--! ONE MO/ APPRECIAT$ BY ! 
AU?ORITIES--IS ?AT ( EXECUTION]2 & NOT A PR(ESSIONAL 
EXECUTION] :O KILLS ONLY CONDEMN$ CRIM9ALS1 BUT ONE READY TO 
BUT*] ANY 9NOC5T MAN AT ! WORD ( COMM&4 

,& EV5 ?AT IS NOT ALL4 ,9 #a#h#i#b1 ! SAME ,WILLIAM1 ! ,5,F,A,N,T 
,T,],R,I,B,L,E ( /ATE AU?ORITY1 :O SAYS PLA9LY :AT O!R PEOPLE 
ONLY ?9K1 9 ADDRESS+ SOME SOLDI]S GAVE PUBLIC UTT]ANCE TO 
! FOLL[+ SPEE*1 :I* WAS REPORT$ NEXT DAY 9 ?\S&S ( 
NEWSPAP]S3 0,CONSCRIPTS60 HE SAID1 0Y\ HAVE SWORN FIDELITY TO ,M,E 
BE=E ! ALT> & ! M9I/] ( ,GOD6 ,Y\ >E /ILL TOO Y\NG 
TO UND]/& ALL ! IMPORTANCE ( :AT HAS BE5 SAID H]E2 LET 
Y\R C>E BE=E ALL ?+S BE TO OBEY ! ORD]S & 9/RUCTIONS 
GIV5 Y\4 ,Y\ HAVE SWORN FIDELITY ,T,O ,M,E1 LADS ( MY GU>D2 ,?,A,T 
,M,E,A,N,S ,?,A,T ,Y,\ ,>,E ,N,[ ,M,Y ,S,O,L,D,I,],S1 ?AT ,Y,\ ,H,A,V,E ,G,I,V,5 ,Y,\,R,S,E,L,V,E,S 
,T,O ,M,E ,B,O,D,Y ,& ,S,\,L4 ,= Y\ !RE IS N[ BUT ONE 5EMY1 ,M,Y 
5EMY4 ,9 ,!,S,E ,D,A,Y,S ,( ,S,O,C,I,A,L,I,/,I,C ,S,$,I,T,I,O,N ,I,T ,M,A,Y ,C,O,M,E ,T,O ,P,A,S,S 
,?,A,T ,I ,C,O,M,M,& ,Y,\ ,T,O ,F,I,R,E ,O,N ,Y,\,R ,[,N ,K,9,D,R,$1 ,Y,\,R ,B,R,O,!,R,S1 
,E,V,5 ,Y,\,R ,[,N ,F,A,!,R,S ,& ,M,O,!,R,S--,:,I,* ,G,O,D ,=,B,I,D6--EV5 !N 
Y\ >E B\ND TO OBEY MY ORD]S )\T HESITATION40 

,?IS MAN EXPRESSES :AT ALL S5SIBLE RUL]S ?9K1 BUT /UDI\SLY 
CONCEAL4 ,HE SAYS OP5LY ?AT ! SOLDI]S >E 9 ,H,I,S S]VICE1 AT 
,H,I,S DISPOSAL1 & MU/ BE READY = ,H,I,S ADVANTAGE TO MURD] EV5 
!IR BRO!RS & FA!RS4 

,9 ! MO/ BRUTAL WORDS HE FRANKLY EXPOSES ALL ! HORRORS & 
CRIM9ALITY = :I* M5 PREP>E !MSELVES 9 5T]+ ! >MY1 
& ! DEP?S ( IGNOM9Y TO :I* !Y FALL 9 PROMIS+ 
OB$I5CE4 ,LIKE A BOLD HYPNOTIZ]1 HE TE/S ! DEGREE ( 
9S5SIBILITY ( ! HYPNOTIZ$ SUBJECT4 ,HE T\*ES HIS SK9 ) 
A R$-HOT IRON2 ! SK9 SMOKES & SCOR*ES1 BUT ! SLEEP] DOES 
NOT AWAKE4 

,?IS MIS]ABLE MAN1 IMBECILE & DRUNK ) P[]1 \TRAGES 9 
?IS UTT]ANCE EV]Y?+ ?AT CAN BE SACR$ = A MAN ( ! 
MOD]N WORLD4 ,& YET ALL ! ,*RI/IANS1 LIB]ALS1 & 
CULTIVAT$ PEOPLE1 F> FROM RES5T+ ?IS \TRAGE1 DID NOT EV5 
OBS]VE IT4 

,! LA/1 ! MO/ EXTREME TE/ IS PUT BE=E M5 9 ITS CO>SE/ 
=M4 ,& !Y DO NOT SEEM EV5 TO NOTICE ?AT IT IS A TE/1 ?AT 
!RE IS ANY *OICE AB\T IT4 ,!Y SEEM TO ?9K !RE IS NO 
C\RSE OP5 BUT SLAVI% SUBMISSION4 ,ONE W\LD HAVE ?\<T !SE 
9SANE WORDS1 :I* \TRAGE EV]Y?+ A MAN ( ! PRES5T DAY 
HOLDS SACR$1 MU/ R\SE 9DIGNATION4 ,BUT !RE HAS BE5 NO?+ 
( ! K9D4 

,ALL ! Y\NG M5 ?R\< ! :OLE ( ,EUROPE >E EXPOS$ YE> 
AFT] YE> TO ?IS TE/1 & ) V]Y FEW EXCEPTIONS !Y 
R5\NCE ALL ?AT A MAN CAN HOLD SACR$1 ALL EXPRESS !IR 
READ9ESS TO KILL !IR BRO!RS1 EV5 !IR FA!RS1 AT ! 
BIDD+ ( ! FIR/ CRAZY CREATURE DRESS$ UP 9 A LIV]Y ) 
R$ & GOLD TRIMM+1 & ONLY WAIT TO BE TOLD :]E & :5 
!Y >E TO KILL4 ,& !Y ACTUALLY >E READY4 

,EV]Y SAVAGE HAS SOME?+ HE HOLDS SACR$1 SOME?+ = :I* HE 
IS READY TO SUFF]1 SOME?+ HE WILL NOT CONS5T TO DO4 ,BUT :AT 
IS IT ?AT IS SACR$ TO ! CIVILIZ$ MAN ( TO-DAY8 ,!Y SAY TO 
HIM3 0,Y\ MU/ BECOME MY SLAVE1 & ?IS SLAV]Y MAY =CE Y\ 
TO KILL EV5 Y\R [N FA!R20 & HE1 (T5 V]Y WELL $UCAT$1 
TRA9$ 9 ALL ! SCI5CES AT ! UNIV]SITY1 QUIETLY PUTS HIS 
HEAD UND] ! YOKE4 ,!Y DRESS HIM UP 9 A CL[N'S CO/UME1 & 
ORD] HIM TO CUT CAP]S1 TURN & TWI/ & B[1 & KILL--HE DOES 
IT ALL SUBMISSIVELY4 ,& :5 !Y LET HIM GO1 HE SEEMS TO %AKE 
HIMSELF & GO BACK TO HIS =M] LIFE1 & HE CONT9UES TO 
DISC\RSE UPON ! DIGNITY ( MAN1 LIB]TY1 EQUALITY1 & 
FRAT]NITY AS BE=E4 

0,YES1 BUT :AT IS ONE TO DO80 PEOPLE (T5 ASK 9 G5U9E 
P]PLEXITY4 0,IF EV]YONE W\LD /& \T IT W\LD BE SOME?+1 
BUT BY MYSELF1 ,I %ALL ONLY SUFF] )\T DO+ ANY GOOD TO 
ANYONE40 

,& ?AT IS TRUE4 ,A MAN ) ! SOCIAL CONCEPTION ( LIFE CANNOT 
RESI/4 ,! AIM ( HIS LIFE IS HIS P]SONAL WELF>E4 ,IT IS BETT] 
= HIS P]SONAL WELF>E = HIM TO SUBMIT1 & HE SUBMITS4 

,:ATEV] !Y DO TO HIM1 H[EV] !Y TORTURE OR HUMILIATE HIM1 HE 
WILL SUBMIT1 =1 ALONE1 HE CAN DO NO?+2 HE HAS NO PR9CIPLE 
= ! SAKE ( :I* HE C\LD RESI/ VIOL5CE ALONE4 ,& ?OSE 
:O CONTROL !M NEV] ALL[ !M TO UNITE TOGE!R4 ,IT IS (T5 
SAID ?AT ! 9V5TION ( T]RIBLE WEAPONS ( DE/RUCTION WILL 
PUT AN 5D TO W>4 ,?AT IS AN ]ROR4 ,AS ! MEANS ( 
EXT]M9ATION >E IMPROV$1 ! MEANS ( R$UC+ M5 :O HOLD ! 
/ATE CONCEPTION ( LIFE TO SUBMISSION CAN BE IMPROV$ TO 
CORRESPOND4 ,!Y MAY SLAU<T] !M BY ?\S&S1 BY MILLIONS1 
!Y MAY TE> !M TO PIECES1 /ILL !Y WILL M>* TO W> LIKE 
S5SELESS CATTLE4 ,SOME WILL WANT BEAT+ TO MAKE !M MOVE1 
O!RS WILL BE PR\D TO GO IF !Y >E ALL[$ TO WE> A SCRAP ( 
RIBBON OR GOLD LACE4 

,& ( ?IS MASS ( M5 SO BRUTALIZ$ AS TO BE READY TO PROMISE TO 
KILL !IR [N P>5TS1 ! SOCIAL RE=M]S--CONS]VATIVES1 
LIB]ALS1 SOCIALI/S1 & AN>*I/S--PROPOSE TO =M A RATIONAL 
& MORAL SOCIETY4 ,:AT SORT ( MORAL & RATIONAL SOCIETY CAN BE 
=M$ \T ( SU* ELEM5TS8 ,) W>P$ & ROTT5 PLANKS Y\ 
CANNOT BUILD A H\SE1 H[EV] Y\ PUT !M TOGE!R4 ,& TO =M 
A RATIONAL MORAL SOCIETY ( SU* M5 IS JU/ AS IMPOSSIBLE A TASK4 
,!Y CAN BE =M$ 9TO NO?+ BUT A H]D ( CATTLE1 DRIV5 BY 
! %\TS & :IPS ( ! H]DSM54 ,AS 9DE$ !Y >E4 

,SO1 !N1 WE HAVE ON ONE SIDE M5 CALL+ !MSELVES ,*RI/IANS1 
& PR(ESS+ ! PR9CIPLES ( LIB]TY1 EQUALITY1 & 
FRAT]NITY1 & ALONG ) ?AT READY1 9 ! NAME ( LIB]TY1 TO 
SUBMIT TO ! MO/ SLAVI% DEGRADATION2 9 ! NAME ( EQUALITY1 
TO ACCEPT ! CRUDE/1 MO/ S5SELESS DIVISION ( M5 BY EXT]NALS 
M]ELY 9TO HI<] & L[] CLASSES1 ALLIES & 5EMIES2 &1 9 
! NAME ( FRAT]NITY1 READY TO MURD] !IR BRO!RS .<SEE 
FOOTNOTE.>4 

.<,FOOTNOTE3 ,! FACT ?AT AMONG C]TA9 NATIONS1 AS 
 ! ,5GLI% & ! ,AM]ICAN1 MILIT>Y S]VICE IS NOT 
 COMPULSORY 7?\< ALREADY ONE HE>S !RE >E SOME 
 :O ADVOCATE ?AT IT %\LD BE MADE SO7 DOES NOT 
 AFFECT ! S]VILITY ( ! CITIZ5S TO ! GOV]NM5T 
 9 PR9CIPLE4 ,H]E WE HAVE EA* TO GO & KILL OR BE 
 KILL$1 !RE !Y HAVE EA* TO GIVE ! FRUIT ( !IR 
 TOIL TO PAY = ! RECRUIT+ & TRA9+ ( SOLDI]S4.> 

,! CONTRADICTION BETWE5 LIFE & CONSCI5CE & ! MIS]Y 
RESULT+ FROM IT HAVE REA*$ ! EXTREME LIMIT & CAN GO NO 
FUR!R4 ,! /ATE ORGANIZATION ( LIFE BAS$ ON VIOL5CE1 ! 
AIM ( :I* WAS ! SECURITY ( P]SONAL1 FAMILY1 & SOCIAL 
WELF>E1 HAS COME TO ! PO9T ( R5\NC+ ! V]Y OBJECTS = 
:I* IT WAS F\ND$--IT HAS R$UC$ M5 TO ABSOLUTE R5UNCIATION 
& LOSS ( ! WELF>E IT WAS TO SECURE4 

,! FIR/ HALF ( ! PROPHECY HAS BE5 FULFILL$ 9 ! 
G5]ATION ( M5 :O HAVE NOT ACCEPT$ ,*RI/'S TEA*+1 ,!IR 
DESC5DANTS HAVE BE5 BR\<T N[ TO ! ABSOLUTE NECESSITY ( 
PATT+ ! TRU? ( ! SECOND HALF TO ! TE/ ( EXP]I5CE4 

,FROM 3 ,GUT5B]G4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahic 3 ,*APT] #h -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,FEBRU>Y #a#a1 #bag 3 ,*APT] #h -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/