,*APT] #i 
,! ,ACCEPTANCE ,( ,! ,*RI/IAN ,CONCEPTION ,( ,LIFE ,WILL ,EMANCIPATE ,M5 ,FROM ,! ,MIS]IES ,( ,\R ,PAGAN ,LIFE 

#ahidahid 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,LEO ,TOL/OY 

,TRANSLATOR 3 ,CON/ANCE ,CL>A ,G>NETT 

,TEXT 3 

,! ,EXT]NAL ,LIFE ( ,*RI/IAN ,PEOPLES ,REMA9S ,PAGAN ,?\< !Y >E 

,P5ETRAT$ BY ,*RI/IAN ,CONSCI\SNESS--,! ,WAY ,\T ( ?IS ,CONTRADICTION 

IS BY ! ,ACCEPTANCE ( ! ,*RI/IAN ,!ORY ( ,LIFE--,ONLY ,?R\< 

,*RI/IANITY IS ,EV]Y ,MAN ,FREE1 & ,EMANCIPAT$ ( ,ALL ,HUMAN 

,AU?ORITY--,?IS ,EMANCIPATION CAN BE ,EFFECT$ BY NO ,*ANGE 9 ,EXT]NAL 

,CONDITIONS ( ,LIFE1 BUT ,ONLY BY A ,*ANGE 9 ! ,CONCEPTION ( ,LIFE--,! 

,*RI/IAN ,IDEAL ( ,LIFE ,REQUIRES ,R5UNCIATION ( ALL ,VIOL5CE1 & 9 

,EMANCIPAT+ ! ,MAN :O ,ACCEPTS IT1 ,EMANCIPATES ! ,:OLE ,WORLD FROM 

,ALL ,EXT]NAL ,AU?ORITIES--,! ,WAY ,\T ( ! ,PRES5T ,APP>5TLY ,HOPELESS 

,POSITION IS = ,EV]Y ,MAN :O IS ,CAPABLE ( ,ASSIMILAT+ ! ,*RI/IAN 

,CONCEPTION ( ,LIFE1 TO ,ACCEPT IT & ,LIVE 9 ,ACCORDANCE ) IT--,BUT ,M5 

,CONSID] ?IS ,WAY TOO ,SL[1 & ,LOOK = ,DELIV]ANCE ,?R\< ,*ANGES 9 

,MAT]IAL ,CONDITIONS ( ,LIFE ,AID$ BY ,GOV]NM5T--,?AT ,WILL ,LEAD TO ,NO 

,IMPROVEM5T1 AS IT IS SIMPLY ,9CREAS+ ! ,EVIL UND] :I* ,M5 >E 

,SUFF]+--,A ,/RIK+ ,9/ANCE ( ?IS IS ! ,SUBMISSION TO ,COMPULSORY 

,MILIT>Y ,S]VICE1 :I* IT W\LD BE ,MORE ,ADVANTAGE\S = ,EV]Y ,MAN TO 

,REFUSE ?AN TO ,SUBMIT TO--,! ,EMANCIPATION ( ,M5 ,CAN ,ONLY BE ,BR\<T 

,AB\T BY EA* ,9DIVIDUAL ,EMANCIPAT+ ,HIMSELF1 & ! ,EXAMPLES ( ?IS 

,SELF-EMANCIPATION :I* >E ALREADY ,APPE>+ ,?REAT5 ! ,DE/RUCTION 

( ,GOV]NM5TAL ,AU?ORITY--,REFUSAL TO ,COMPLY ) ! ,UN*RI/IAN 

,DEM&S ( ,GOV]NM5T ,UND]M9ES ! ,AU?ORITY ( ! ,/ATE & 

,EMANCIPATES ,M5--,& !RE=E ,CASES ( SU* ,NONCOMPLIANCE >E ,REG>D$ 

) MORE ,DREAD BY ,/ATE ,AU?ORITIES ?AN ANY ,CONSPIRACIES OR ,ACTS ( 

,VIOL5CE--,EXAMPLES ( ,NONCOMPLIANCE 9 ,RUSSIA1 9 ,REG>D TO ,OA? ( 

,ALLEGIANCE1 ,PAYM5T ( ,TAXES1 ,PASSPORTS1 ,POLICE ,DUTIES1 & ,MILIT>Y 

,S]VICE--,EXAMPLES ( SU* ,NONCOMPLIANCE 9 O!R ,/ATES--,GOV]NM5TS DO 

NOT ,KN[ H[ TO ,TREAT ,M5 :O ,REFUSE TO ,COMPLY ) !IR ,DEM&S ON 

,*RI/IAN ,GR\NDS--,SU* ,PEOPLE1 )\T ,/RIK+ A ,BL[1 ,UND]M9E ! 

V]Y ,BASIS ( ,GOV]NM5T FROM ,)9--,TO ,PUNI% !M IS ,EQUIVAL5T TO 

,OP5LY ,R5\NC+ ,*RI/IANITY1 & ,ASSI/+ 9 ,DIFFUS+ ! ,V]Y 

,PR9CIPLE BY :I* !SE ,M5 JU/IFY !IR ,NONCOMPLIANCE--,SO 

,GOV]NM5TS >E 9 A ,HELPLESS ,POSITION--,M5 :O ,MA9TA9 ! ,USELESSNESS 

( ,P]SONAL ,9DEP5D5CE1 ONLY ,RET>D ! ,DISSOLUTION ( ! ,PRES5T 

,/ATE ,ORGANIZATION ,BAS$ ON ,=CE4 

,! POSITION ( ! ,*RI/IAN PEOPLES 9 \R DAYS HAS REMA9$ 
JU/ AS CRUEL AS IT WAS 9 ! TIMES ( PAGANISM4 ,9 MANY 
RESPECTS1 ESPECIALLY 9 ! OPPRESSION ( ! MASSES1 IT HAS 
BECOME EV5 MORE CRUEL ?AN IT WAS 9 ! DAYS ( PAGANISM4 

,BUT BETWE5 ! CONDITION ( M5 9 ANCI5T TIMES & !IR 
CONDITION 9 \R DAYS !RE IS JU/ ! DIFF]5CE ?AT WE SEE 9 
! WORLD ( VEGETATION BETWE5 ! LA/ DAYS ( AUTUMN & ! 
FIR/ DAYS ( SPR+4 ,9 ! AUTUMN ! EXT]NAL LIFELESSNESS 9 
NATURE CORRESPONDS ) ITS 9W>D CONDITION ( DEA?1 :ILE 9 
! SPR+ ! EXT]NAL LIFELESSNESS IS 9 %>P CONTRA/ ) ! 
9T]NAL /ATE ( REVIV+ & PASS+ 9TO NEW =MS ( LIFE4 

,9 ! SAME WAY ! SIMIL>ITY BETWE5 ! ANCI5T HEA!N LIFE 
& ! LIFE ( TO-DAY IS M]ELY EXT]NAL3 ! 9W>D CONDITION ( 
M5 9 ! TIMES ( HEA!NISM WAS ABSOLUTELY DIFF]5T FROM !IR 
9W>D CONDITION AT ! PRES5T TIME4 

,!N ! \TW>D CONDITION ( CRUELTY & ( SLAV]Y WAS 9 
COMPLETE H>MONY ) ! 9N] CONSCI5CE ( M51 & EV]Y /EP 
9 ADVANCE 9T5SIFI$ ?IS H>MONY2 N[ ! \TW>D CONDITION ( 
CRUELTY & ( SLAV]Y IS COMPLETELY CONTRADICTORY TO ! 
,*RI/IAN CONSCI\SNESS ( M51 & EV]Y /EP 9 ADVANCE ONLY 
9T5SIFIES ?IS CONTRADICTION4 

,HUMANITY IS PASS+ ?R\< SEEM+LY UNNECESS>Y1 FRUITLESS 
AGONIES4 ,IT IS PASS+ ?R\< SOME?+ LIKE ! ?ROES ( 
BIR?4 ,EV]Y?+ IS READY = ! NEW LIFE1 BUT /ILL ! NEW 
LIFE DOES NOT COME4 

,!RE SEEMS NO WAY \T ( ! POSITION4 ,& !RE W\LD BE NONE1 
EXCEPT ?AT A MAN 7& !REBY ALL M57 IS GIFT$ ) ! P[] 
( =M+ A DIFF]5T1 HI<] !ORY ( LIFE1 :I* AT ONCE FREES 
HIM FROM ALL ! BONDS BY :I* HE SEEMS 9DISSOLUBLY FETT]$4 

,& SU* A !ORY IS ! ,*RI/IAN VIEW ( LIFE MADE KN[N TO 
MANK9D EI<TE5 HUNDR$ YE>S AGO4 

,A MAN NE$ ONLY MAKE ?IS !ORY ( LIFE HIS [N1 = ! FETT]S 
:I* SEEM$ SO 9DISSOLUBLY =G$ UPON HIM TO DROP (F ( 
!MSELVES1 & = HIM TO FEEL HIMSELF ABSOLUTELY FREE1 JU/ AS A 
BIRD W\LD FEEL ITSELF FREE 9 A F5C$-9 PLACE DIRECTLY IT TOOLS 
TO ITS W+S4 

,PEOPLE TALK AB\T ! LIB]TY ( ! ,*RI/IAN ,*UR*1 AB\T 
GIV+ OR NOT GIV+ FRE$OM TO ,*RI/IANS4 ,UND]LY+ ALL !SE 
IDEAS & EXPRESSIONS !RE IS SOME /RANGE MISCONCEPTION4 
,FRE$OM CANNOT BE BE/[$ ON OR TAK5 FROM A ,*RI/IAN OR 
,*RI/IANS4 ,FRE$OM IS AN 9ALI5ABLE POSSESSION ( ! 
,*RI/IAN4 

,IF WE TALK ( BE/[+ FRE$OM ON ,*RI/IANS OR )HOLD+ IT 
FROM !M1 WE >E OBVI\SLY TALK+ NOT ( REAL ,*RI/IANS BUT ( 
PEOPLE :O ONLY CALL !MSELVES ,*RI/IANS4 ,A ,*RI/IAN CANNOT 
FAIL TO BE FREE1 BECAUSE ! ATTA9M5T ( ! AIM HE SETS BE=E 
HIMSELF CANNOT BE PREV5T$ OR EV5 H9D]$ BY ANYONE OR 
ANY?+4 

,LET A MAN ONLY UND]/& HIS LIFE AS ,*RI/IANITY TEA*ES HIM TO 
UND]/& IT1 LET HIM UND]/&1 ?AT IS1 ?AT HIS LIFE BELONGS 
NOT TO HIM--NOT TO HIS [N 9DIVIDUALITY1 NOR TO HIS FAMILY1 NOR 
TO ! /ATE--BUT TO HIM :O HAS S5T HIM 9TO ! WORLD1 & LET 
HIM ONCE UND]/& ?AT HE MU/ !RE=E FULFILL NOT ! LAW ( 
HIS [N 9DIVIDUALITY1 NOR HIS FAMILY1 NOR ( ! /ATE1 BUT ! 
9F9ITE LAW ( HIM FROM :OM HE HAS COME2 & HE WILL NOT ONLY 
FEEL HIMSELF ABSOLUTELY FREE FROM EV]Y HUMAN P[]1 BUT WILL EV5 
CEASE TO REG>D SU* P[] AS AT ALL ABLE TO HAMP] ANYONE4 

,LET A MAN BUT REALIZE ?AT ! AIM ( HIS LIFE IS ! FULFILLM5T 
( ,GOD'S LAW1 & ?AT LAW WILL REPLACE ALL O!R LAWS = HIM1 
& HE WILL GIVE IT HIS SOLE ALLEGIANCE1 SO ?AT BY ?AT V]Y 
ALLEGIANCE EV]Y HUMAN LAW WILL LOSE ALL B9D+ & CONTROLL+ 
P[] 9 HIS EYES4 

,! ,*RI/IAN IS 9DEP5D5T ( EV]Y HUMAN AU?ORITY BY ! FACT 
?AT HE REG>DS ! DIV9E LAW ( LOVE1 IMPLANT$ 9 ! S\L ( 
EV]Y MAN1 & BR\<T BE=E HIS CONSCI\SNESS BY ,*RI/1 AS ! 
SOLE GUIDE ( HIS LIFE & O!R M5'S ALSO4 

,! ,*RI/IAN MAY BE SUBJECT$ TO EXT]NAL VIOL5CE1 HE MAY BE 
DEPRIV$ ( BODILY FRE$OM1 HE MAY BE 9 BONDAGE TO HIS PASSIONS 
7HE :O COMMITS S9 IS ! SLAVE ( S971 BUT HE CANNOT BE 9 
BONDAGE 9 ! S5SE ( BE+ =C$ BY ANY DANG] OR BY ANY 
?REAT ( EXT]NAL H>M TO P]=M AN ACT :I* IS AGA9/ HIS 
CONSCI5CE4 

,HE CANNOT BE COMPELL$ TO DO ?IS1 BECAUSE ! DEPRIVATIONS & 
SUFF]+S :I* =M SU* A P[]FUL WEAPON AGA9/ M5 ( ! 
/ATE CONCEPTION ( LIFE1 HAVE NOT ! LEA/ P[] TO COMPEL HIM4 

,DEPRIVATIONS & SUFF]+S TAKE FROM !M ! HAPP9ESS = :I* 
!Y LIVE2 BUT F> FROM DI/URB+ ! HAPP9ESS ( ! ,*RI/IAN1 
:I* CONSI/S 9 ! CONSCI\SNESS ( FULFILL+ ! WILL ( ,GOD1 
!Y MAY EV5 9T5SIFY IT1 :5 !Y >E 9FLICT$ ON HIM = 
FULFILL+ HIS WILL4 

,& !RE=E ! ,*RI/IAN1 :O IS SUBJECT ONLY TO ! 9N] 
DIV9E LAW1 NOT ONLY CANNOT C>RY \T ! 5ACTM5TS ( ! 
EXT]NAL LAW1 :5 !Y >E NOT 9 AGREEM5T ) ! DIV9E LAW 
( LOVE :I* HE ACKN[L$GES 7AS IS USUALLY ! CASE ) /ATE 
OBLIGATIONS71 HE CANNOT EV5 RECOGNIZE ! DUTY ( OB$I5CE TO 
ANYONE OR ANY?+ :ATEV]1 HE CANNOT RECOGNIZE ! DUTY ( :AT 
IS CALL$ ALLEGIANCE4 

,= A ,*RI/IAN ! OA? ( ALLEGIANCE TO ANY GOV]NM5T :ATEV] 
--! V]Y ACT :I* IS REG>D$ AS ! F\NDATION ( ! 
EXI/5CE ( A /ATE--IS A DIRECT R5UNCIATION ( ,*RI/IANITY4 
,= ! MAN :O PROMISES UNCONDITIONAL OB$I5CE 9 ! FUTURE TO 
LAWS1 MADE OR TO BE MADE1 BY ?AT V]Y PROMISE IS 9 ! MO/1 
POSITIVE MANN] R5\NC+ ,*RI/IANITY1 :I* MEANS OBEY+ 9 
EV]Y CIRCUM/ANCE ( LIFE ONLY ! DIV9E LAW ( LOVE HE 
RECOGNIZES )9 HIM4 

,UND] ! PAGAN CONCEPTION ( LIFE IT WAS POSSIBLE TO C>RY \T 
! WILL ( ! TEMPORAL AU?ORITIES1 )\T 9FR++ ! LAW 
( ,GOD EXPRESS$ 9 CIRCUMCISIONS1 ,SABBA?S1 FIX$ TIMES ( 
PRAY]1 AB/5TION FROM C]TA9 K9DS ( FOOD1 & SO ON4 ,! ONE 
LAW WAS NOT OPPOS$ TO ! O!R4 ,BUT ?AT IS JU/ ! 
DI/9CTION BETWE5 ! ,*RI/IAN RELIGION & HEA!N RELIGION4 
,*RI/IANITY DOES NOT REQUIRE ( A MAN C]TA9 DEF9ITE NEGATIVE 
ACTS1 BUT PUTS HIM 9 A NEW1 DIFF]5T RELATION TO M51 FROM :I* 
MAY RESULT ! MO/ DIV]SE ACTS1 :I* CANNOT BE DEF9$ 
BE=EH&4 ,& !RE=E ! ,*RI/IAN NOT ONLY CANNOT PROMISE 
TO OBEY ! WILL ( ANY O!R MAN1 )\T KN[+ :AT WILL BE 
REQUIR$ BY ?AT WILL2 HE NOT ONLY CANNOT OBEY ! *ANG+ LAWS 
( MAN1 BUT HE CANNOT EV5 PROMISE TO DO ANY?+ DEF9ITE AT A 
C]TA9 TIME1 OR TO AB/A9 FROM DO+ ANY?+ = A C]TA9 
TIME4 ,= HE CANNOT KN[ :AT AT ANY TIME WILL BE REQUIR$ ( HIM 
BY ?AT ,*RI/IAN LAW ( LOVE1 OB$I5CE TO :I* CON/ITUTES ! 
MEAN+ ( LIFE = HIM4 ,! ,*RI/IAN1 9 PROMIS+ 
UNCONDITIONAL FULFILLM5T ( ! LAWS ( M5 9 ! FUTURE1 W\LD 
%[ PLA9LY BY ?AT PROMISE ?AT ! 9N] LAW ( ,GOD DOES NOT 
CON/ITUTE = HIM ! SOLE LAW ( HIS LIFE4 

,= A ,*RI/IAN TO PROMISE OB$I5CE TO M51 OR ! LAWS ( M51 
IS JU/ AS ?\< A WORKMAN B\ND TO ONE EMPLOY] %\LD ALSO 
PROMISE TO C>RY \T EV]Y ORD] ?AT MI<T BE GIV5 HIM BY 
\TSID]S4 ,ONE CANNOT S]VE TWO MA/]S4 

,! ,*RI/IAN IS 9DEP5D5T ( HUMAN AU?ORITY1 BECAUSE HE 
ACKN[L$GES ,GOD'S AU?ORITY ALONE4 ,HIS LAW1 REVEAL$ BY ,*RI/1 
HE RECOGNIZES 9 HIMSELF1 & VOLUNT>ILY OBEYS IT4 

,& ?IS 9DEP5D5CE IS GA9$1 NOT BY MEANS ( /RIFE1 NOT BY 
! DE/RUCTION ( EXI/+ =MS ( LIFE1 BUT ONLY BY A *ANGE 9 
! 9T]PRETATION ( LIFE4 ,?IS 9DEP5D5CE RESULTS FIR/ FROM 
! ,*RI/IAN RECOGNIZ+ ! LAW ( LOVE1 REVEAL$ TO HIM BY HIS 
TEA*]1 AS P]FECTLY SUFFICI5T = ALL HUMAN RELATIONS1 & 
!RE=E HE REG>DS EV]Y USE ( =CE AS UNNECESS>Y & 
UNLAWFUL2 & SECONDLY1 FROM ! FACT ?AT ?OSE DEPRIVATIONS & 
SUFF]+S1 OR ?REATS ( DEPRIVATIONS & SUFF]+S 7:I* 
R$UCE ! MAN ( ! SOCIAL CONCEPTION ( LIFE TO ! NECESSITY 
( OBEY+7 TO ! ,*RI/IAN FROM HIS DIFF]5T CONCEPTION ( 
LIFE1 PRES5T !MSELVES M]ELY AS ! 9EVITABLE CONDITIONS ( 
EXI/5CE4 ,& !SE CONDITIONS1 )\T /RIV+ AGA9/ !M BY 
=CE1 HE PATI5TLY 5DURES1 LIKE SICKNESS1 HUNG]1 & EV]Y 
O!R H>D%IP1 BUT !Y CANNOT S]VE HIM AS A GUIDE = HIS 
ACTIONS4 ,! ONLY GUIDE = ! ,*RI/IAN'S ACTIONS IS TO BE 
F\ND 9 ! DIV9E PR9CIPLE LIV+ )9 HIM1 :I* CANNOT BE 
*ECK$ OR GOV]N$ BY ANY?+4 

,! ,*RI/IAN ACTS ACCORD+ TO ! WORDS ( ! PROPHECY APPLI$ 
TO HIS TEA*]3 0,HE %ALL NOT /RIVE1 NOR CRY2 NEI!R %ALL ANY 
MAN HE> HIS VOICE 9 ! /REETS4 ,A BRUIS$ RE$ %ALL HE NOT 
BREAK1 & SMOK+ FLAX %ALL HE NOT QU5*1 TILL HE S5D =? 
JUDGM5T UNTO VICTORY40 7,MATT4 XII4 #a#i1 #b47 

,! ,*RI/IAN WILL NOT DISPUTE ) ANYONE1 NOR ATTACK ANYONE1 NOR 
USE VIOL5CE AGA9/ ANYONE4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 HE WILL BE> 
VIOL5CE )\T OPPOS+ IT4 ,BUT BY ?IS V]Y ATTITUDE TO 
VIOL5CE1 HE WILL NOT ONLY HIMSELF BE FREE1 BUT WILL FREE ! 
:OLE WORLD FROM ALL EXT]NAL P[]4 

0,YE %ALL KN[ ! TRU?1 & ! TRU? %ALL MAKE Y\ FREE40 ,IF 
!RE W]E ANY D\BT ( ,*RI/IANITY BE+ ! TRU?1 ! P]FECT 
LIB]TY1 ?AT NO?+ CAN CURTAIL1 :I* A MAN EXP]I5CES 
DIRECTLY HE MAKES ! ,*RI/IAN !ORY ( LIFE HIS [N1 W\LD BE 
AN UNMI/AKABLE PRO( ( ITS TRU?4 

,M5 9 !IR PRES5T CONDITION >E LIKE A SW>M ( BEES HANG+ 9 
A CLU/] TO A BRAN*4 ,! POSITION ( ! BEES ON ! BRAN* IS 
TEMPOR>Y1 & MU/ 9EVITABLY BE *ANG$4 ,!Y MU/ />T (F 
& F9D !MSELVES A HABITATION4 ,EA* ( ! BEES KN[S ?IS1 
& DESIRES TO *ANGE H] [N & ! O!RS' POSITION1 BUT NO ONE 
( !M CAN DO IT TILL ! RE/ ( !M DO IT4 ,!Y CANNOT ALL 
/>T (F AT ONCE1 BECAUSE ONE HANGS ON TO ANO!R & H9D]S H] 
FROM SEP>AT+ FROM ! SW>M1 & !RE=E !Y ALL CONT9UE TO 
HANG !RE4 ,IT W\LD SEEM ?AT ! BEES C\LD NEV] ESCAPE FROM 
!IR POSITION1 JU/ AS IT SEEMS ?AT WORLDLY M51 CAU<T 9 ! 
TOILS ( ! /ATE CONCEPTION ( LIFE1 CAN NEV] ESCAPE4 ,& 
!RE W\LD BE NO ESCAPE = ! BEES1 IF EA* ( !M W]E NOT A 
LIV+1 SEP>ATE CREATURE1 5D[$ ) W+S ( ITS [N4 
,SIMIL>LY !RE W\LD BE NO ESCAPE = M51 IF EA* W]E NOT A 
LIV+ BE+ 5D[$ ) ! FACULTY ( 5T]+ 9TO ! 
,*RI/IAN CONCEPTION ( LIFE4 

,IF EV]Y BEE :O C\LD FLY1 DID NOT TRY TO FLY1 ! O!RS1 TOO1 
W\LD NEV] BE /IRR$1 & ! SW>M W\LD NEV] *ANGE ITS 
POSITION4 ,& IF ! MAN :O HAS MA/]$ ! ,*RI/IAN 
CONCEPTION ( LIFE W\LD NOT1 )\T WAIT+ = O!R PEOPLE1 
BEG9 TO LIVE 9 ACCORDANCE ) ?IS CONCEPTION1 MANK9D W\LD 
NEV] *ANGE ITS POSITION4 ,BUT ONLY LET ONE BEE SPREAD H] W+S1 
/>T (F1 & FLY AWAY1 & AFT] H] ANO!R1 & ANO!R1 & 
! CL++1 9]T CLU/] W\LD BECOME A FREELY FLY+ SW>M ( 
BEES4 ,JU/ 9 ! SAME WAY1 ONLY LET ONE MAN LOOK AT LIFE AS 
,*RI/IANITY TEA*ES HIM TO LOOK AT IT1 & AFT] HIM LET ANO!R 
& ANO!R DO ! SAME1 & ! 5*ANT$ CIRCLE ( EXI/5CE 9 
! /ATE CONCEPTION ( LIFE1 FROM :I* !RE SEEM$ NO ESCAPE1 
WILL BE BROK5 ?R\<4 

,BUT M5 ?9K ?AT TO SET ALL M5 FREE BY ?IS MEANS IS 
TOO SL[ A PROCESS1 ?AT !Y MU/ F9D SOME O!R MEANS BY :I* 
!Y C\LD SET ALL M5 FREE AT ONCE4 ,IT IS JU/ AS ?\< ! 
BEES :O WANT TO />T & FLY AWAY %\LD CONSID] IT TOO LONG A 
PROCESS TO WAIT = ALL ! SW>M TO />T ONE BY ONE2 & %\LD 
?9K !Y \<T TO F9D SOME MEANS BY :I* IT W\LD NOT BE 
NECESS>Y = EV]Y SEP>ATE BEE TO SPREAD H] W+S & FLY (F1 
BUT BY :I* ! :OLE SW>M C\LD FLY AT ONCE :]E IT WANT$ TO4 
,BUT ?AT IS NOT POSSIBLE2 TILL A FIR/1 A SECOND1 A ?IRD1 A 
HUNDR$? BEE SPREADS H] W+S & FLIES (F ( H] [N ACCORD1 
! SW>M WILL NOT FLY (F & WILL NOT BEG9 ITS NEW LIFE4 ,TILL 
EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL MAN MAKES ! ,*RI/IAN CONCEPTION ( LIFE HIS 
[N1 & BEG9S TO LIVE 9 ACCORD ) IT1 !RE CAN BE NO 
SOLUTION ( ! PROBLEM ( HUMAN LIFE1 & NO E/ABLI%M5T ( A 
NEW =M ( LIFE4 

,ONE ( ! MO/ /RIK+ PH5OM5A ( \R TIMES IS PRECISELY ?IS 
ADVOCACY ( SLAV]Y1 :I* IS PROMULGAT$ AMONG ! MASSES1 NOT BY 
GOV]NM5TS1 9 :OM IT IS 9EVITABLE1 BUT BY M5 :O1 9 
ADVOCAT+ SOCIALI/IC !ORIES1 REG>D !MSELVES AS ! 
*AMPIONS ( FRE$OM4 

,!SE PEOPLE ADVANCE ! OP9ION ?AT ! AMELIORATION ( LIFE1 
! BR++ ( ! FACTS ( LIFE 9TO H>MONY ) ! 
CONSCI5CE1 WILL COME1 NOT AS ! RESULT ( ! P]SONAL EF=TS 
( 9DIVIDUAL M51 BUT ( ITSELF AS ! RESULT ( A C]TA9 
POSSIBLE RECON/RUCTION ( SOCIETY EFFECT$ 9 SOME WAY OR O!R4 
,! IDEA IS PROMULGAT$ ?AT M5 \<T NOT TO WALK ON !IR [N 
LEGS :]E !Y WANT & \<T TO GO1 BUT ?AT A K9D ( FLOOR 
UND] !IR FEET WILL BE MOV$ SOMEH[1 SO ?AT ON IT !Y CAN 
REA* :]E !Y \<T TO GO )\T MOV+ !IR [N LEGS4 ,&1 
!RE=E1 ALL !IR EF=TS \<T TO BE DIRECT$1 NOT TO GO+ SO 
F> AS !IR /R5G? ALL[S 9 ! DIRECTION !Y \<T TO GO1 
BUT TO /&+ /ILL & CON/RUCT+ SU* A FLOOR4 

,9 ! SPH]E ( POLITICAL ECONOMY A !ORY IS PROP\ND$ :I* 
AM\NTS TO SAY+ ?AT ! WORSE ?+S >E ! BETT] !Y >E2 
?AT ! GREAT] ! ACCUMULATION ( CAPITAL1 & !RE=E ! 
OPPRESSION ( ! WORKMAN1 ! NE>] ! DAY ( EMANCIPATION1 
&1 !RE=E1 EV]Y P]SONAL EF=T ON ! P>T ( A MAN TO FREE 
HIMSELF FROM ! OPPRESSION ( CAPITAL IS USELESS4 ,9 ! SPH]E 
( GOV]NM5T IT IS MA9TA9$ ?AT ! GREAT] ! P[] ( ! 
GOV]NM5T1 :I*1 ACCORD+ TO ?IS !ORY1 \<T TO 9T]V5E 9 
EV]Y DEP>TM5T ( PRIVATE LIFE 9 :I* IT HAS NOT YET 
9T]V5$1 ! BETT] IT WILL BE1 & ?AT !RE=E WE \<T TO 
9VOKE ! 9T]F]5CE ( GOV]NM5T 9 PRIVATE LIFE4 ,9 
POLITICS & 9T]NATIONAL QUE/IONS IT IS MA9TA9$ ?AT ! 
IMPROVEM5T ( ! MEANS ( DE/RUCTION1 ! MULTIPLICATION ( 
>MAM5TS1 WILL LEAD TO ! NECESSITY ( MAK+ W> BY MEANS ( 
CONGRESSES1 >BITRATION1 & SO ON4 ,&1 M>VEL\S TO SAY1 SO 
GREAT IS ! DULLNESS ( M51 ?AT !Y BELIEVE 9 !SE !ORIES1 
9 SPITE ( ! FACT ?AT ! :OLE C\RSE ( LIFE1 EV]Y /EP 
!Y TAKE1 %[S H[ UNWOR?Y !Y >E ( BELIEF4 

,! PEOPLE >E SUFF]+ FROM OPPRESSION1 & TO DELIV] !M FROM 
?IS OPPRESSION !Y >E ADVIS$ TO FRAME G5]AL MEASURES = ! 
IMPROVEM5T ( !IR POSITION1 :I* MEASURES >E TO BE 5TRU/$ 
TO ! AU?ORITIES1 & !MSELVES TO CONT9UE TO YIELD OB$I5CE 
TO ! AU?ORITIES4 ,& OBVI\SLY ALL ?AT RESULTS FROM ?IS IS 
ONLY GREAT] P[] 9 ! H&S ( ! AU?ORITIES1 & GREAT] 
OPPRESSION RESULT+ FROM IT4 

,NOT ONE ( ! ]RORS ( M5 C>RIES !M SO F> AWAY FROM ! AIM 
T[>D :I* !Y >E /RUGGL+ AS ?IS V]Y ONE4 ,!Y DO ALL 
K9DS ( DIFF]5T ?+S = ! ATTA9M5T ( !IR AIM1 BUT NOT 
! ONE SIMPLE OBVI\S ?+ :I* IS )9 REA* ( EV]YONE4 
,!Y DEVISE ! SUBTLE/ MEANS = *ANG+ ! POSITION :I* IS 
IRKSOME TO !M1 BUT NOT ?AT SIMPLE/ MEANS1 ?AT EV]YONE %\LD 
REFRA9 FROM DO+ :AT LEADS TO ?AT POSITION4 

,I HAVE BE5 TOLD A /ORY ( A GALLANT POLICE (FIC]1 :O CAME TO 
A VILLAGE :]E ! PEASANTS W]E 9 9SURRECTION & ! MILIT>Y 
HAD BE5 CALL$ \T1 & HE UND]TOOK TO PACIFY ! 9SURRECTION 
9 ! SPIRIT ( ,NI*OLAS ,I41 BY HIS P]SONAL 9FLU5CE ALONE4 ,HE 
ORD]$ SOME LOADS ( RODS TO BE BR\<T1 & COLLECT+ ALL ! 
PEASANTS TOGE!R 9TO A B>N1 HE W5T 9 ) !M1 LOCK+ ! 
DOOR AFT] HIM4 ,TO BEG9 )1 HE SO T]RIFI$ ! PEASANTS BY 
HIS L\D ?REATS ?AT1 R$UC$ TO SUBMISSION BY HIM1 !Y SET TO 
WORK TO FLOG ONE ANO!R AT HIS COMM&4 ,& SO !Y FLOGG$ ONE 
ANO!R UNTIL A SIMPLETON WAS F\ND :O W\LD NOT ALL[ HIMSELF TO 
BE FLOGG$1 & %\T$ TO HIS COMPANIONS NOT TO FLOG ONE ANO!R4 
,ONLY !N ! FOGG+ CEAS$1 & ! POLICE (FIC] MADE HIS 
ESCAPE4 ,WELL1 ?IS SIMPLETON'S ADVICE W\LD NEV] BE FOLL[$ BY 
M5 ( ! /ATE CONCEPTION ( LIFE1 :O CONT9UE TO FLOG ONE 
ANO!R1 & TEA* PEOPLE ?AT ?IS V]Y ACT ( SELF-CA/IGATION 
IS ! LA/ WORD ( HUMAN WISDOM4 

,9DE$1 CAN ONE IMAG9E A MORE /RIK+ 9/ANCE ( M5 FLOGG+ 
!MSELVES ?AN ! SUBMISSIV5ESS ) :I* M5 ( \R TIMES 
WILL P]=M ! V]Y DUTIES REQUIR$ ( !M TO KEEP !M 9 
SLAV]Y1 ESPECIALLY ! DUTY ( MILIT>Y S]VICE8 ,WE SEE PEOPLE 
5SLAV+ !MSELVES1 SUFF]+ FROM ?IS SLAV]Y1 & BELIEV+ 
?AT IT MU/ BE SO1 ?AT IT DOES NOT MATT]1 & WILL NOT H9D] 
! EMANCIPATION ( M51 :I* IS BE+ PREP>$ SOME:]E1 
SOMEH[1 9 SPITE ( ! EV]-9CREAS+ GR[? ( SLAV]Y4 

,9 FACT1 TAKE ANY MAN ( ! PRES5T TIME :ATEV] 7,I DON'T MEAN A 
TRUE ,*RI/IAN1 BUT AN AV]AGE MAN ( ! PRES5T DAY71 $UCAT$ 
OR UN$UCAT$1 BELIEV+ OR UNBELIEV+1 RI* OR POOR1 M>RI$ OR 
UNM>RI$4 ,SU* A MAN LIVES WORK+ AT HIS WORK1 OR 5JOY+ HIS 
AMUSEM5TS1 SP5D+ ! FRUITS ( HIS LABORS ON HIMSELF OR ON 
?OSE NE> TO HIM1 &1 LIKE EV]YONE1 HAT+ EV]Y K9D ( 
RE/RICTION & DEPRIVATION1 DISS5SION & SUFF]+4 ,SU* A MAN 
IS GO+ HIS WAY PEACEABLY1 :5 SUDD5LY PEOPLE COME & SAY TO 
HIM3 ,FIR/1 PROMISE & SWE> TO US ?AT Y\ WILL SLAVI%LY OBEY 
US 9 EV]Y?+ WE DICTATE TO Y\1 & WILL CONSID] ABSOLUTELY 
GOOD & AU?ORITATIVE EV]Y?+ WE PLAN1 DECIDE1 & CALL LAW4 
,SECONDLY1 H& OV] A P>T ( ! FRUITS ( Y\R LABORS = US TO 
DISPOSE (--WE WILL USE ! MONEY TO KEEP Y\ 9 SLAV]Y1 & TO 
H9D] Y\ FROM =CIBLY OPPOS+ \R ORD]S4 ,?IRDLY1 ELECT 
O!RS1 OR BE Y\RSELF ELECT$1 TO TAKE A PRET5D$ %>E 9 ! 
GOV]NM5T1 KN[+ ALL ! :ILE ?AT ! GOV]NM5T WILL PROCE$ 
QUITE )\T REG>D TO ! FOOLI% SPEE*ES Y\1 & ?OSE LIKE 
Y\1 MAY UTT]1 & KN[+ ?AT ITS PROCE$+S WILL BE ACCORD+ 
TO \R WILL1 ! WILL ( ?OSE :O HAVE ! >MY 9 !IR H&S4 
,F\R?LY1 COME AT A C]TA9 TIME TO ! LAW C\RTS & TAKE Y\R 
%>E 9 ?OSE S5SELESS CRUELTIES :I* WE P]PETRATE ON S9N]S1 
& ?OSE :OM WE HAVE CORRUPT$1 9 ! %APE ( P5AL S]VITUDE1 
EXILE1 SOLIT>Y CONF9EM5T1 & DEA?4 ,& FIF?LY & LA/LY1 
MORE ?AN ALL ?IS1 9 SPITE ( ! FACT ?AT Y\ MAYBE ON ! 
FRI5DLIE/ T]MS ) PEOPLE ( O!R NATIONS1 BE READY1 DIRECTLY 
WE ORD] Y\ TO DO SO1 TO REG>D ?OSE :OM WE 9DICATE TO Y\ AS 
Y\R 5EMIES2 & BE READY TO ASSI/1 EI!R 9 P]SON OR BY 
PROXY1 9 DEVA/ATION1 PLUND]1 & MURD] ( !IR M51 WOM51 
*ILDR51 & AG$ ALIKE--POSSIBLY Y\R [N K9SM5 OR RELATIONS--IF 
?AT IS NECESS>Y TO US4 

,ONE W\LD EXPECT ?AT EV]Y MAN ( ! PRES5T DAY :O HAS A GRA9 
( S5SE LEFT1 MI<T REPLY TO SU* REQUIREM5TS1 0,BUT :Y %\LD ,I 
DO ALL ?IS80 ,ONE W\LD ?9K EV]Y RI<T-M9D$ MAN MU/ SAY 9 
AMAZEM5T3 0,:Y %\LD ,I PROMISE TO YIELD OB$I5CE TO EV]Y?+ 
?AT HAS BE5 DECRE$ FIR/ BY ,SALISBURY1 !N BY ,GLAD/ONE2 ONE 
DAY BY ,B\LANG]1 & ANO!R BY ,P>LIAM5T2 ONE DAY BY ,PET] 
,I,I,I41 ! NEXT BY ,CA!R9E1 & ! DAY AFT] BY ,P\GA*EF2 ONE 
DAY BY A MAD K+ ( ,BAV>IA1 ANO!R BY ,WILLIAM8 ,:Y %\LD ,I 
PROMISE TO OBEY !M1 KN[+ !M TO BE WICK$ OR FOOLI% PEOPLE1 
OR ELSE NOT KN[+ !M AT ALL8 ,:Y AM ,I TO H& OV] ! FRUITS 
( MY LABORS TO !M 9 ! %APE ( TAXES1 KN[+ ?AT ! MONEY 
WILL BE SP5T ON ! SUPPORT ( (FICIALS1 PRISONS1 *UR*ES1 
>MIES1 ON ?+S ?AT >E H>MFUL1 & ON MY [N 5SLAVEM5T8 
,:Y %\LD ,I PUNI% MYSELF8 ,:Y %\LD ,I GO WA/+ MY TIME & 
HOODW9K+ MYSELF1 GIV+ TO MISCREANT EVILDO]S A SEMBLANCE ( 
LEGALITY1 BY TAK+ P>T 9 ELECTIONS1 & PRET5D+ ?AT ,I AM 
TAK+ P>T 9 ! GOV]NM5T1 :5 ,I KN[ V]Y WELL ?AT ! REAL 
CONTROL ( ! GOV]NM5T IS 9 ! H&S ( ?OSE :O HAVE GOT 
HOLD ( ! >MY8 ,:Y %\LD ,I GO TO ! LAW C\RTS TO TAKE P>T 
9 ! TRIAL & PUNI%M5T ( M5 BECAUSE !Y HAVE S9N$1 
KN[+1 IF ,I AM A ,*RI/IAN1 ?AT ! LAW ( V5GEANCE IS REPLAC$ 
BY ! LAW ( LOVE1 &1 IF ,I AM AN $UCAT$ MAN1 ?AT PUNI%M5TS 
DO NOT RE=M1 BUT ONLY DEPRAVE ?OSE ON :OM !Y >E 9FLICT$8 
,& :Y1 MO/ ( ALL1 AM ,I TO CONSID] AS 5EMIES ! PEOPLE ( A 
NEI<BOR+ NATION1 ) :OM ,I HAVE HI!RTO LIV$ & ) :OM 
,I WI% TO LIVE 9 LOVE & H>MONY1 & TO KILL & ROB !M1 OR 
TO BR+ !M TO MIS]Y1 SIMPLY 9 ORD] ?AT ! KEYS ( ! 
TEMPLE AT ,J]USALEM MAY BE 9 ! H&S ( ONE >*BI%OP & NOT 
ANO!R1 ?AT ONE ,G]MAN & NOT ANO!R MAY BE PR9CE 9 
,BULG>IA1 OR ?AT ! ,5GLI% RA!R ?AN ! ,AM]ICAN M]*ANTS 
MAY CAPTURE SEALS8 

,& :Y1 MO/ ( ALL1 %\LD ,I TAKE P>T 9 P]SON OR HIRE O!RS 
TO MURD] MY [N BRO!RS & K9SM58 ,:Y %\LD ,I FLOG MYSELF8 
,IT IS ALTOGE!R UNNECESS>Y = ME2 IT IS HURTFUL TO ME1 & FROM 
EV]Y PO9T ( VIEW IT IS IMMORAL1 BASE1 & VILE4 ,SO :Y %\LD 
,I DO ?IS8 ,IF Y\ TELL ME ?AT IF ,I DO IT NOT ,I %ALL RECEIVE 
SOME 9JURY FROM SOMEONE1 !N1 9 ! FIR/ PLACE1 ,I CANNOT 
ANTICIPATE FROM ANYONE AN 9JURY SO GREAT AS ! 9JURY Y\ BR+ 
ON ME IF ,I OBEY Y\2 & SECONDLY1 IT IS P]FECTLY CLE> TO ME 
?AT IF WE \R [N SELVES DO NOT FLOG \RSELVES1 NO ONE WILL FLOG 
US4 

,AS = ! GOV]NM5T--?AT MEANS ! CZ>S1 M9I/]S1 & 
(FICIALS ) P5S 9 !IR H&S1 :O CANNOT =CE US 9TO DO+ 
ANY?+1 AS ?AT (FIC] ( POLICE COMPELL$ ! PEASANTS2 ! 
M5 :O WILL DRAG US TO ! LAW C\RT1 TO PRISON1 & TO 
EXECUTION1 >E NOT CZ>S OR (FICIALS ) P5S 9 !IR H&S1 
BUT ! V]Y PEOPLE :O >E 9 ! SAME POSITION AS WE >E4 ,& 
IT IS JU/ AS UNPR(ITABLE & H>MFUL & UNPLEASANT TO !M TO 
BE FLOGG$ AS TO ME1 & !RE=E !RE IS EV]Y LIKELIHOOD ?AT 
IF ,I OP5 !IR EYES !Y NOT ONLY W\LD NOT TREAT ME ) 
VIOL5CE1 BUT W\LD DO JU/ AS ,I AM DO+4 

,?IRDLY1 EV5 IF IT %\LD COME TO PASS ?AT ,I HAD TO SUFF] = IT1 
EV5 !N IT W\LD BE BETT] = ME TO BE EXIL$ OR S5T TO PRISON = 
/&+ UP = COMMON S5SE & RI<T--:I*1 IF NOT TO-DAY1 AT LEA/ 
)9 A V]Y %ORT TIME1 MU/ BE TRIUMPHANT--?AN TO SUFF] = FOLLY 
& WRONG :I* MU/ COME TO AN 5D DIRECTLY4 ,& !RE=E1 EV5 9 
?AT CASE1 IT IS BETT] TO RUN ! RISK ( !IR BANI%+ ME1 %UTT+ 
ME UP 9 PRISON1 OR EXECUT+ ME1 ?AN ( MY LIV+ ALL MY LIFE 9 
BONDAGE1 ?R\< MY [N FAULT1 TO WICK$ M54 ,BETT] IS ?IS ?AN ! 
POSSIBILITY ( BE+ DE/ROY$ BY VICTORI\S 5EMIES1 & BE+ /UPIDLY 
TORTUR$ & KILL$ BY !M1 9 FI<T+ = A CANNON1 OR A PIECE ( 
L& ( NO USE TO ANYONE1 OR = A S5SELESS RAG CALL$ A BANN]4 

,I DON'T WANT TO FLOG MYSELF & ,I WON'T DO IT4 ,I HAVE NO REASON TO DO 
IT4 ,DO IT Y\RSELVES1 IF Y\ WANT IT DONE2 BUT ,I WON'T DO IT4 

,ONE W\LD HAVE ?\<T ?AT NOT RELIGI\S OR MORAL FEEL+ ALONE1 
BUT ! SIMPLE/ COMMON S5SE & =ESI<T %\LD IMPEL EV]Y MAN 
( ! PRES5T DAY TO ANSW] & TO ACT 9 ?AT WAY4 ,BUT NOT SO4 
,M5 ( ! /ATE CONCEPTION ( LIFE >E ( ! OP9ION ?AT TO ACT 
9 ?AT WAY IS NOT NECESS>Y1 & IS EV5 PREJUDICIAL TO ! 
ATTA9M5T ( !IR OBJECT1 ! EMANCIPATION ( M5 FROM SLAV]Y4 
,!Y HOLD ?AT WE MU/ CONT9UE1 LIKE ! POLICE (FIC]'S 
PEASANTS1 TO FLOG ONE ANO!R1 CONSOL+ \RSELVES ) ! 
REFLECTION ?AT WE >E TALK+ AWAY 9 ! ASSEMBLIES & 
MEET+S1 F\ND+ TRADES UNIONS1 M>*+ ?R\< ! /REETS ON 
! #a/ ( ,MAY1 GETT+ UP CONSPIRACIES1 & /EAL?ILY TEAS+ 
! GOV]NM5T ?AT IS FLOGG+ US1 & ?AT ?R\< ALL ?IS IT 
WILL BE BR\<T TO PASS ?AT1 BY 5SLAV+ \RSELVES 9 CLOS] & 
CLOS] BONDAGE1 WE %ALL V]Y SOON BE FREE4 

,NO?+ H9D]S ! EMANCIPATION ( M5 FROM SLAV]Y SO MU* AS 
?IS AMAZ+ ]ROR4 ,9/EAD ( EV]Y MAN DIRECT+ HIS 5]GIES 
TO FREE+ HIMSELF1 TO TRANS=M+ HIS CONCEPTION ( LIFE1 PEOPLE 
SEEK = AN EXT]NAL UNIT$ ME?OD ( GA9+ FRE$OM1 & 
CONT9UE TO RIVET !IR *A9S FA/] & FA/]4 

,IT IS MU* AS IF M5 W]E TO MA9TA9 ?AT TO MAKE UP A FIRE !RE 
WAS NO NE$ TO K9DLE ANY ( ! COALS1 BUT ?AT ALL ?AT WAS 
NECESS>Y WAS TO >RANGE ! COALS 9 A C]TA9 ORD]4 ,YET ! 
FACT ?AT ! FRE$OM ( ALL M5 WILL BE BR\<T AB\T ONLY 
?R\< ! FRE$OM ( 9DIVIDUAL P]SONS1 BECOMES MORE & MORE 
CLE> AS TIME GOES ON4 ,! FRE$OM ( 9DIVIDUAL M51 9 ! NAME 
( ! ,*RI/IAN CONCEPTION ( LIFE1 FROM /ATE DOM9ATION1 :I* 
WAS =M]LY AN EXCEPTIONAL & UNNOTIC$ PH5OM5ON1 HAS ( LATE 
ACQUIR$ ?REAT5+ SIGNIFICANCE = /ATE AU?ORITIES4 

,IF 9 A =M] AGE1 9 ! ,ROMAN TIMES1 IT HAPP5$ ?AT A 
,*RI/IAN CONFESS$ HIS RELIGION & REFUS$ TO TAKE P>T 9 
SACRIFICES1 & TO WOR%IP ! EMP]ORS OR ! GODS2 OR 9 ! 
,MIDDLE ,AGES A ,*RI/IAN REFUS$ TO WOR%IP IMAGES1 OR TO 
ACKN[L$GE ! AU?ORITY ( ! ,POPE--!SE CASES W]E 9 ! 
FIR/ PLACE A MATT] ( *ANCE4 ,A MAN MI<T BE PLAC$ UND] ! 
NECESSITY ( CONFESS+ HIS FAI?1 OR HE MI<T LIVE ALL HIS LIFE 
)\T BE+ PLAC$ UND] ?IS NECESSITY4 ,BUT N[ ALL M51 
)\T EXCEPTION1 >E SUBJECT$ TO ?IS TRIAL ( !IR FAI?4 
,EV]Y MAN ( ! PRES5T DAY IS UND] ! NECESSITY ( TAK+ P>T 
9 ! CRUELTIES ( PAGAN LIFE1 OR ( REFUS+ ALL P>TICIPATION 
9 !M4 ,& SECONDLY1 9 ?OSE DAYS CASES ( REFUSAL TO WOR%IP 
! GODS OR ! IMAGES OR ! ,POPE W]E NOT 9CID5TS ?AT HAD ANY 
MAT]IAL BE>+ ON ! /ATE4 ,:E!R M5 WOR%IP$ OR DID NOT 
WOR%IP ! GODS OR ! IMAGES OR ! ,POPE1 ! /ATE REMA9$ 
JU/ AS P[]FUL4 ,BUT N[ CASES ( REFUS+ TO COMPLY ) ! 
UN*RI/IAN DEM&S ( ! GOV]NM5T >E /RIK+ AT ! V]Y 
ROOT ( /ATE AU?ORITY1 BECAUSE ! :OLE AU?ORITY ( ! /ATE 
IS BAS$ ON ! COMPLIANCE ) !SE UN*RI/IAN DEM&S4 

,! SOV]EIGN P[]S ( ! WORLD HAVE 9 ! C\RSE ( TIME BE5 
BR\<T 9TO A POSITION 9 :I*1 = !IR [N PRES]VATION1 !Y 
MU/ REQUIRE FROM ALL M5 ACTIONS :I* CANNOT BE P]=M$ BY M5 
:O PR(ESS TRUE ,*RI/IANITY4 

,& !RE=E 9 \R DAYS EV]Y PR(ESSION ( TRUE ,*RI/IANITY1 
BY ANY 9DIVIDUAL MAN1 /RIKES AT ! MO/ ESS5TIAL P[] ( ! 
/ATE1 & 9EVITABLY LEADS ! WAY = ! EMANCIPATION ( ALL4 

,:AT IMPORTANCE1 ONE MI<T ?9K1 CAN ONE ATTA* TO SU* AN 
9CID5T AS SOME DOZ5S ( CRAZY FELL[S1 AS PEOPLE WILL CALL 
!M1 REFUS+ TO TAKE ! OA? ( ALLEGIANCE TO ! GOV]NM5T1 
REFUS+ TO PAY TAXES1 TO TAKE P>T 9 LAW PROCE$+S OR 9 
MILIT>Y S]VICE8 

,!SE PEOPLE >E PUNI%$ & EXIL$ TO A DI/ANCE1 & LIFE GOES 
ON 9 ITS OLD WAY4 ,ONE MI<T ?9K !RE WAS NO IMPORTANCE 9 
SU* 9CID5TS2 BUT YET1 IT IS JU/ ?OSE 9CID5TS1 MORE ?AN 
ANY?+ ELSE1 ?AT WILL UND]M9E ! P[] ( ! /ATE & 
PREP>E ! WAY = ! FRE$OM ( M54 ,!SE >E ! 9DIVIDUAL 
BEES1 :O >E BEG9N+ TO SEP>ATE FROM ! SW>M1 & >E FLY+ 
NE> IT1 WAIT+ TILL ! :OLE SW>M CAN NO LONG] BE PREV5T$ 
FROM />T+ (F AFT] !M4 ,& ! GOV]NM5TS KN[ ?IS1 & 
FE> SU* 9CID5TS MORE ?AN ALL ! SOCIALI/S1 COMMUNI/S1 & 
AN>*I/S1 & !IR PLOTS & DYNAMITE BOMBS4 

,A NEW REIGN IS BEG9N+4 ,ACCORD+ TO ! UNIV]SAL RULE & 
E/ABLI%$ ORD] IT IS REQUIR$ ?AT ALL ! SUBJECTS %\LD TAKE 
! OA? ( ALLEGIANCE TO ! NEW GOV]NM5T4 ,!RE IS A G5]AL 
DECREE TO ?AT EFFECT1 & ALL >E SUMMON$ TO ! C\NCIL-H\SES 
TO TAKE ! OA?4 ,ALL AT ONCE ONE MAN 9 ,P]M1 ANO!R 9 ,TULA1 A 
?IRD 9 ,MOSC[1 & A F\R? 9 ,KAL\GA DECL>E ?AT !Y WILL 
NOT TAKE ! OA?1 & ?\< !RE IS NO COMMUNICATION BETWE5 
!M1 !Y ALL EXPLA9 !IR REFUSAL ON ! SAME GR\NDS--NAMELY1 
?AT SWE>+ IS =BIDD5 BY ! LAW ( ,*RI/1 & ?AT EV5 IF 
SWE>+ HAD NOT BE5 =BIDD51 !Y C\LD NOT1 9 ! SPIRIT ( 
! LAW ( ,*RI/1 PROMISE TO P]=M ! EVIL ACTIONS REQUIR$ ( 
!M 9 ! OA?1 SU* AS 9=M+ AGA9/ ALL SU* AS MAY ACT 
AGA9/ ! 9T]E/S ( ! GOV]NM5T1 OR DEF5D+ !IR 
GOV]NM5T ) FIRE>MS OR ATTACK+ ITS 5EMIES4 ,!Y >E 
BR\<T BE=E RURAL POLICE (FIC]S1 DI/RICT POLICE CAPTA9S1 
PRIE/S1 & GOV]NORS4 ,!Y >E ADMONI%$1 QUE/ION$1 
?REAT5$1 & PUNI%$2 BUT !Y ADH]E TO !IR RESOLUTION1 & 
DO NOT TAKE ! OA?4 ,& AMONG ! MILLIONS ( ?OSE :O DID 
TAKE ! OA?1 ?OSE DOZ5S GO ON LIV+ :O DID NOT TAKE ! 
OA?4 ,& !Y >E QUE/ION$3 

0,:AT1 DIDN'T Y\ TAKE ! OA?80 

0,NO1 ,I DIDN'T TAKE ! OA?40 

0,& :AT HAPP5$--NO?+80 

0,NO?+40 

,! SUBJECTS ( A /ATE >E ALL B\ND TO PAY TAXES4 ,& EV]YONE 
PAYS TAXES1 TILL SUDD5LY ONE MAN 9 ,KH>KOV1 ANO!R 9 ,TV]1 & 
A ?IRD 9 ,SAM>A REFUSE TO PAY TAXES--ALL1 AS ?\< 9 
COLLUSION1 SAY+ ! SAME ?+4 ,ONE SAYS HE WILL ONLY PAY :5 
!Y TELL HIM :AT OBJECT ! MONEY TAK5 FROM HIM WILL BE SP5T 
ON4 0,IF IT IS = GOOD DE$S10 HE SAYS1 0HE WILL GIVE IT ( HIS 
[N ACCORD1 & MORE EV5 ?AN IS REQUIR$ ( HIM4 ,IF = EVIL 
DE$S1 !N HE WILL GIVE NO?+ VOLUNT>ILY1 BECAUSE BY ! LAW 
( ,*RI/1 :OSE FOLL[] HE IS1 HE CANNOT TAKE P>T 9 EVIL 
DE$S40 ,! O!RS1 TOO1 SAY ! SAME 9 O!R WORDS1 & WILL 
NOT VOLUNT>ILY PAY ! TAXES4 

,?OSE :O HAVE ANY?+ TO BE TAK5 HAVE !IR PROP]TY TAK5 FROM 
!M BY =CE2 AS = ?OSE :O HAVE NO?+1 !Y >E LEFT ALONE4 

0,:AT1 DIDN'T Y\ PAY ! TAX80 

0,NO1 ,I DIDN'T PAY IT40 

0,& :AT HAPP5$-NO?+80 

0,NO?+40 

,!RE IS ! 9/ITUTION ( PASSPORTS4 ,EV]YONE MOV+ FROM HIS 
PLACE ( RESID5CE IS B\ND TO C>RY ONE1 & TO PAY A DUTY ON IT4 
,SUDD5LY PEOPLE >E TO BE F\ND 9 V>I\S PLACES DECL>+ ?AT 
TO C>RY A PASSPORT IS NOT NECESS>Y1 ?AT ONE \<T NOT TO 
RECOGNIZE ONE'S DEP5D5CE ON A /ATE :I* EXI/S BY MEANS ( 
=CE2 & !SE PEOPLE DO NOT C>RY PASSPORTS1 OR PAY ! DUTY ON 
!M4 ,& AGA91 IT'S IMPOSSIBLE TO =CE ?OSE PEOPLE BY ANY 
MEANS TO DO :AT IS REQUIR$4 ,!Y S5D !M TO JAIL1 & LET 
!M \T AGA91 & !SE PEOPLE LIVE )\T PASSPORTS4 

,ALL PEASANTS >E B\ND TO FILL C]TA9 POLICE (FICES--?AT ( 
VILLAGE CON/ABLE1 & ( WAT*MAN1 & SO ON4 ,SUDD5LY 9 
,KH>KOV A PEASANT REFUSES TO P]=M ?IS DUTY1 JU/IFY+ HIS 
REFUSAL ON ! GR\ND ?AT BY ! LAW ( ,*RI/1 ( :I* HE IS A 
FOLL[]1 HE CANNOT PUT ANY MAN 9 FETT]S1 LOCK HIM UP1 OR DRAG 
HIM FROM PLACE TO PLACE4 ,! SAME DECL>ATION IS MADE BY A 
PEASANT 9 ,TV]1 ANO!R 9 ,TAMBOV4 ,!SE PEASANTS >E ABUS$1 
BEAT51 %UT UP 9 PRISON1 BUT !Y /ICK TO !IR RESOLUTION & 
DON'T FILL !SE (FICES AGA9/ !IR CONVICTIONS4 ,& AT LA/ 
!Y CEASE TO APPO9T !M AS CON/ABLES4 ,& AGA9 NO?+ 
HAPP5S4 

,ALL CITIZ5S >E OBLIG$ TO TAKE A %>E 9 LAW PROCE$+S 9 ! 
*>ACT] ( JURYM54 ,SUDD5LY ! MO/ DIFF]5T PEOPLE--ME*ANICS1 
PR(ESSORS1 TRADESM51 PEASANTS1 S]VANTS1 AS ?\< BY AGREEM5T REFUSE 
TO FILL ?IS (FICE1 & NOT ON ! GR\NDS ALL[$ AS SUFFICI5T BY 
LAW1 BUT BECAUSE ANY PROCESS AT LAW IS1 ACCORD+ TO !IR VIEWS1 
UN*RI/IAN4 ,!Y F9E !SE PEOPLE1 TRY+ NOT TO LET !M HAVE AN 
OPPORTUNITY ( EXPLA9+ !IR MOTIVES 9 PUBLIC1 & REPLACE !M BY 
O!RS4 ,& AGA9 NO?+ CAN BE DONE4 

,ALL Y\NG M5 ( TW5TY-ONE YE>S ( AGE >E OBLIG$ TO DRAW LOTS 
= S]VICE 9 ! >MY4 ,ALL AT ONCE ONE Y\NG MAN 9 ,MOSC[1 
ANO!R 9 ,TV]1 A ?IRD 9 ,KH>KOV1 & A F\R? 9 ,KIEV PRES5T 
!MSELVES BE=E ! AU?ORITIES1 &1 AS ?\< BY PREVI\S 
AGREEM5T1 DECL>E ?AT !Y WILL NOT TAKE ! OA?1 !Y WILL NOT 
S]VE BECAUSE !Y >E ,*RI/IANS4 ,I WILL GIVE ! DETAILS ( ONE 
( ! FIR/ CASES1 S9CE !Y HAVE BECOME MORE FREQU5T1 :I* ,I 
HAPP5 TO KN[ AB\T .<FOOTNOTE3 ,ALL ! DETAILS ( ?IS CASE1 AS 
WELL AS ?OSE PREC$+ IT1 >E AU!NTIC.>4 ,! SAME TREATM5T 
HAS BE5 REPEAT$ 9 EV]Y O!R CASE4 ,A Y\NG MAN ( FAIR 
$UCATION REFUSES 9 ! ,MOSC[ ,T[NHALL TO TAKE ! OA?4 ,NO 
ATT5TION IS PAID TO :AT HE SAYS1 & IT IS REQUE/$ ?AT HE 
%\LD PRON\NCE ! WORDS ( ! OA? LIKE ! RE/4 ,HE 
DECL9ES1 QUOT+ A P>TICUL> PASSAGE ( ! ,GOSPEL 9 :I* 
SWE>+ IS =BIDD54 ,NO ATT5TION IS PAID TO HIS >GUM5TS1 & 
HE IS AGA9 REQUE/$ TO COMPLY ) ! ORD]1 BUT HE DOES NOT 
COMPLY ) IT4 ,!N IT IS SUPPOS$ ?AT HE IS A SECT>Y & 
!RE=E DOES NOT UND]/& ,*RI/IANITY 9 ! RI<T S5SE1 
?AT IS TO SAY1 NOT 9 ! S5SE 9 :I* ! PRIE/S 9 ! PAY 
( ! GOV]NM5T UND]/& IT4 ,& ! Y\NG MAN IS CONDUCT$ 
UND] ESCORT TO ! PRIE/S1 ?AT !Y MAY BR+ HIM TO REASON4 
,! PRIE/S BEG9 TO REASON ) HIM1 BUT !IR EF=TS 9 
,*RI/'S NAME TO P]SUADE HIM TO R5\NCE ,*RI/ OBVI\SLY HAVE NO 
9FLU5CE ON HIM2 HE IS PRON\NC$ 9CORRIGIBLE & S5T BACK 
AGA9 TO ! >MY4 ,HE P]SI/S 9 NOT TAK+ ! OA? & OP5LY 
REFUSES TO P]=M ANY MILIT>Y DUTIES4 ,IT IS A CASE ?AT HAS NOT 
BE5 PROVID$ = BY ! LAWS4 ,TO OV]LOOK SU* A REFUSAL TO 
COMPLY ) ! DEM&S ( ! AU?ORITIES IS \T ( ! QUE/ION1 
BUT TO PUT SU* A CASE ON A P> ) SIMPLE BREA* ( DISCIPL9E 
IS ALSO \T ( ! QUE/ION4 

,AFT] DELIB]ATION AMONG !MSELVES1 ! MILIT>Y AU?ORITIES 
DECIDE TO GET RID ( ! TR\BLESOME Y\NG MAN1 TO CONSID] HIM AS 
A REVOLUTIONI/1 & !Y DISPAT* HIM UND] ESCORT TO ! 
COMMITTEE ( ! SECRET POLICE4 ,! POLICE AU?ORITIES & 
G5D>MES CROSS-QUE/ION HIM1 BUT NO?+ ?AT HE SAYS CAN BE 
BR\<T UND] ! HEAD ( ANY ( ! MISDEMEANORS :I* COME UND] 
!IR JURISDICTION4 ,& !RE IS NO POSSIBILITY ( ACCUS+ HIM 
EI!R ( REVOLUTION>Y ACTS OR REVOLUTION>Y PLOTT+1 S9CE HE 
DECL>ES ?AT HE DOES NOT WI% TO ATTACK ANY?+1 BUT1 ON ! 
CONTR>Y1 IS OPPOS$ TO ANY USE ( =CE1 &1 F> FROM PLOTT+ 
9 SECRET1 HE SEEKS EV]Y OPPORTUNITY ( SAY+ & DO+ ALL ?AT 
HE SAYS & DOES 9 ! MO/ OP5 MANN]4 ,& ! G5D>MES1 
?\< !Y >E B\ND BY NO H>D-&-FA/ RULES1 /ILL F9D NO 
GR\ND = A CRIM9AL *>GE 9 ! Y\NG MAN1 &1 LIKE ! 
CL]GY1 !Y S5D HIM BACK TO ! >MY4 ,AGA9 ! AU?ORITIES 
DELIB]ATE TOGE!R1 & DECIDE TO ACCEPT HIM ?\< HE HAS NOT 
TAK5 ! OA?1 & TO 5ROLL HIM AMONG ! SOLDI]S4 ,!Y PUT HIM 
9TO ! UNI=M1 5ROLL HIM1 & S5D HIM UND] GU>D TO ! PLACE 
:]E ! >MY IS QU>T]$4 ,!RE ! *IEF (FIC] ( ! 
DIVISION :I* HE 5T]S AGA9 EXPECTS ! Y\NG MAN TO P]=M 
HIS MILIT>Y DUTIES1 & AGA9 HE REFUSES TO OBEY1 & 9 ! 
PRES5CE ( O!R SOLDI]S EXPLA9S ! REASON ( HIS REFUSAL1 
SAY+ ?AT HE AS A ,*RI/IAN CANNOT VOLUNT>ILY PREP>E HIMSELF 
TO COMMIT MURD]1 :I* IS =BIDD5 BY ! LAW ( ,MOSES4 

,?IS 9CID5T OCCURS 9 A PROV9CIAL T[N4 ,! CASE AWAK5S ! 
9T]E/1 & EV5 ! SYMPA?Y1 NOT ONLY ( \TSID]S1 BUT EV5 
( ! (FIC]S4 ,& ! *IEF (FIC]S CONSEQU5TLY DO NOT 
DECIDE TO PUNI% ?IS REFUSAL ( OB$I5CE ) DISCIPL9>Y 
MEASURES4 ,TO SAVE APPE>ANCES1 ?\<1 !Y %UT ! Y\NG MAN UP 
9 PRISON1 & WRITE TO ! HI<E/ MILIT>Y AU?ORITIES TO 
9QUIRE :AT !Y >E TO DO4 ,TO REFUSE TO S]VE 9 ! >MY1 9 
:I* ! ,CZ> HIMSELF S]VES1 & :I* 5JOYS ! BLESS+ ( 
! ,*UR*1 SEEMS 9SANITY FROM ! (FICIAL PO9T ( VIEW4 
,CONSEQU5TLY !Y WRITE FROM ,PET]SBURG ?AT1 S9CE ! Y\NG MAN 
MU/ BE \T ( HIS M9D1 !Y MU/ NOT USE ANY SEV]E TREATM5T 
) HIM1 BUT MU/ S5D HIM TO A LUNATIC ASYLUM1 ?AT HIS M5TAL 
CONDITION MAY BE 9QUIR$ 9TO & BE SCI5TIFICALLY TREAT$4 
,!Y S5D HIM TO ! ASYLUM 9 ! HOPE ?AT HE WILL REMA9 !RE1 
LIKE ANO!R Y\NG MAN1 :O REFUS$ T5 YE>S AGO AT ,TV] TO S]VE 
9 ! >MY1 & :O WAS TORTUR$ 9 ! ASYLUM TILL HE SUBMITT$4 
,BUT EV5 ?IS /EP DOES NOT RID ! MILIT>Y AU?ORITIES ( ! 
9CONV5I5T MAN4 ,! DOCTORS EXAM9E HIM1 9T]E/ !MSELVES 
W>MLY 9 HIS CASE1 & NATURALLY F9D+ 9 HIM NO SYMPTOMS ( 
M5TAL DISEASE1 S5D HIM BACK TO ! >MY4 ,!RE !Y RECEIVE 
HIM1 & MAK+ BELIEVE TO HAVE =GOTT5 HIS REFUSAL1 & HIS 
MOTIVES = IT1 !Y AGA9 REQUE/ HIM TO GO TO DRILL1 & AGA9 
9 ! PRES5CE ( ! O!R SOLDI]S HE REFUSES & EXPLA9S ! 
REASON ( HIS REFUSAL4 ,! AFFAIR CONT9UES TO ATTRACT MORE & 
MORE ATT5TION1 BO? AMONG ! SOLDI]S & ! 9HABITANTS ( ! 
T[N4 ,AGA9 !Y WRITE TO ,PET]SBURG1 & !NCE COMES ! DECREE 
TO TRANSF] ! Y\NG MAN TO SOME DIVISION ( ! >MY /ATION$ 
ON ! FRONTI]1 9 SOME PLACE :]E ! >MY IS UND] M>TIAL 
LAW1 :]E HE CAN BE %OT = REFUS+ TO OBEY1 & :]E ! 
MATT] CAN PROCE$ )\T ATTRACT+ OBS]VATION1 SEE+ ?AT 
!RE >E FEW ,RUSSIANS & ,*RI/IANS 9 SU* A DI/ANT P>T1 BUT 
! MAJORITY >E =EIGN]S & ,MOHAMM$ANS4 ,?IS IS ACCORD+LY 
DONE4 ,!Y TRANSF] HIM TO A DIVISION /ATION$ ON ! ,ZACASPIAN 
BORD]1 & 9 COMPANY ) CONVICTS S5D HIM TO A *IEF (FIC] 
:O IS NOTORI\S = HIS H>%NESS & SEV]ITY4 

,ALL ?IS TIME1 ?R\< ALL !SE *ANGES FROM PLACE TO PLACE1 ! 
Y\NG MAN IS R\<LY TREAT$1 KEPT 9 COLD1 HUNG]1 & FIL?1 & 
LIFE IS MADE BURD5SOME TO HIM G5]ALLY4 ,BUT ALL !SE 
SUFF]+S DO NOT COMPEL HIM TO *ANGE HIS RESOLUTION4 ,ON ! 
,ZACASPIAN BORD]1 :]E HE IS AGA9 REQUE/$ TO GO ON GU>D FULLY 
>M$1 HE AGA9 DECL9ES TO OBEY4 ,HE DOES NOT REFUSE TO GO & 
/& NE> ! HAY/ACKS :]E !Y PLACE HIM1 BUT REFUSES TO TAKE 
HIS >MS1 DECL>+ ?AT HE WILL NOT USE VIOL5CE 9 ANY CASE 
AGA9/ ANYONE4 ,ALL ?IS TAKES PLACE 9 ! PRES5CE ( ! O!R 
SOLDI]S4 ,TO LET SU* A REFUSAL PASS UNPUNI%$ IS IMPOSSIBLE1 
& ! Y\NG MAN IS PUT ON HIS TRIAL = BREA* ( DISCIPL9E4 
,! TRIAL TAKES PLACE1 & HE IS S5T5C$ TO CONF9EM5T 9 ! 
MILIT>Y PRISON = TWO YE>S4 ,HE IS AGA9 TRANSF]R$1 9 
COMPANY ) CONVICTS1 BY ETAPE1 TO ,CAUCASUS1 & !RE HE IS %UT 
UP 9 PRISON & FALLS UND] ! IRRESPONSIBLE P[] ( ! 
JAIL]4 ,!RE HE IS P]SECUT$ = A YE> & A HALF1 BUT HE DOES 
NOT = ALL ?AT ALT] HIS DECISION NOT TO BE> >MS1 & HE 
EXPLA9S :Y HE WILL NOT DO ?IS TO EV]YONE ) :OM HE IS 
BR\<T 9 CONTACT4 ,AT ! 5D ( ! SECOND YE> !Y SET HIM 
FREE1 BE=E ! 5D ( HIS T]M ( IMPRISONM5T1 RECKON+ IT 
CONTR>Y TO LAW TO KEEP HIM 9 PRISON AFT] HIS TIME ( MILIT>Y 
S]VICE WAS OV]1 & ONLY TOO GLAD TO GET RID ( HIM AS SOON AS 
POSSIBLE4 

,O!R M5 9 V>I\S P>TS ( ,RUSSIA BEHAVE1 AS ?\< BY 
AGREEM5T1 PRECISELY 9 ! SAME WAY AS ?IS Y\NG MAN1 & 9 ALL 
!SE CASES ! GOV]NM5T HAS ADOPT$ ! SAME TIMOR\S1 
UNDECID$1 & SECRETIVE C\RSE ( ACTION4 ,SOME ( !SE M5 >E 
S5T TO ! LUNATIC ASYLUM1 SOME >E 5ROLL$ AS CL]KS & 
TRANSF]R$ TO ,SIB]IA1 SOME >E S5T TO WORK 9 ! =E/S1 SOME 
>E S5T TO PRISON1 SOME >E F9$4 ,& AT ?IS V]Y TIME SOME 
M5 ( ?IS K9D >E 9 PRISON1 NOT *>G$ ) !IR REAL 
(F5SE--?AT IS1 D5Y+ ! LAWFULNESS ( ! ACTION ( ! 
GOV]NM5T1 BUT = NON-FULFILLM5T ( SPECIAL OBLIGATIONS IMPOS$ 
BY GOV]NM5T4 ,?US AN (FIC] ( RES]VE1 :O DID NOT REPORT HIS 
*ANGE ( RESID5CE1 & JU/IFI$ ?IS ON ! GR\ND ?AT HE 
W\LD NOT S]VE 9 ! >MY ANY LONG]1 WAS F9$ ?IRTY RUBLES 
= NONCOMPLIANCE ) ! ORD]S ( ! SUP]IOR AU?ORITY4 
,?IS F9E HE ALSO DECL9$ VOLUNT>ILY TO PAY4 ,9 ! SAME WAY 
SOME PEASANTS & SOLDI]S :O HAVE REFUS$ TO BE DRILL$ & TO 
BE> >MS HAVE BE5 PLAC$ UND] >RE/ ON A *>GE ( BREA* ( 
DISCIPL9E & 9SOL5CE4 

,& CASES ( REFUS+ TO COMPLY ) ! DEM&S ( GOV]NM5T :5 !Y 
>E OPPOS$ TO ,*RI/IANITY1 & ESPECIALLY CASES ( REFUS+ TO S]VE 
9 ! >MY1 >E OCCURR+ ( LATE NOT 9 ,RUSSIA ONLY1 BUT EV]Y:]E4 
,?US ,I HAPP5 TO KN[ ?AT 9 ,S]VIA M5 ( ! SO-CALL$ SECT ( 
,NAZ>5ES /EADILY REFUSE TO S]VE 9 ! >MY1 & ! ,AU/RIAN 
,GOV]NM5T HAS BE5 C>RY+ ON A FRUITLESS CONTE/ ) !M = YE>S1 
PUNI%+ !M ) IMPRISONM5T4 ,9 ! YE> #ahhe !RE W]E #ac SU* 
CASES4 ,I KN[ ?AT 9 ,SWITZ]L& 9 ! YE> #ahi !RE W]E M5 9 
PRISON 9 ! CA/LE ( ,*ILLON = DECL9+ TO S]VE 9 ! >MY1 
:OSE RESOLUTION WAS NOT %AK5 BY !IR PUNI%M5T4 ,!RE HAVE BE5 
SU* CASES 9 ,SW$51 & ! M5 :O REFUS$ OB$I5CE W]E S5T TO 
PRISON 9 EXACTLY ! SAME WAY1 & ! GOV]NM5T /UDI\SLY CONCEAL$ 
!SE CASES FROM ! PEOPLE4 ,!RE HAVE BE5 SIMIL> CASES ALSO 9 
,PRUSSIA4 ,I KN[ ( ! CASE ( A SUB-LIEUT5ANT ( ! ,GU>DS1 :O 9 
#ahia DECL>$ TO ! AU?ORITIES 9 ,B]L9 ?AT HE W\LD NOT1 AS A 
,*RI/IAN1 CONT9UE TO S]VE1 & 9 SPITE ( ALL ADMONITIONS1 ?REATS1 
& PUNI%M5TS HE /UCK TO HIS RESOLUTION4 ,9 ! S\? ( ,FRANCE A 
SOCIETY HAS >IS5 ( LATE BE>+ ! NAME ( ! ,H9S*I/S 7!SE 
FACTS >E TAK5 FROM ! ,P,E,A,C,E ,H,],A,L,D1 ,JULY1 #a#h#i#a71 ! MEMB]S ( :I* 
REFUSE TO 5T] MILIT>Y S]VICE ON ! GR\NDS ( !IR ,*RI/IAN 
PR9CIPLES4 ,AT FIR/ !Y W]E 5ROLL$ 9 ! AMBULANCE CORPS1 BUT N[1 
AS !IR NUMB]S 9CREASE1 !Y >E SUBJECT$ TO PUNI%M5T = 
NONCOMPLIANCE1 BUT !Y /ILL REFUSE TO BE> >MS JU/ ! SAME4 

,! SOCIALI/S1 ! COMMUNI/S1 ! AN>*I/S1 ) !IR BOMBS 
& RIOTS & REVOLUTIONS1 >E NOT NE>LY SO MU* DREAD$ BY 
GOV]NM5TS AS !SE DISCONNECT$ 9DIVIDUALS COM+ FROM 
DIFF]5T P>TS1 & ALL JU/IFY+ !IR NONCOMPLIANCE ON ! 
GR\NDS ( ! SAME RELIGION1 :I* IS KN[N TO ALL ! WORLD4 
,EV]Y GOV]NM5T KN[S BY :AT MEANS & 9 :AT MANN] TO DEF5D 
ITSELF FROM REVOLUTIONI/S1 & HAS RES\RCES = DO+ SO1 & 
!RE=E DOES NOT DREAD !SE EXT]NAL FOES4 ,BUT :AT >E 
GOV]NM5TS TO DO AGA9/ M5 :O %[ ! USELESSNESS1 
SUP]FLU\SNESS1 & P]NICI\SNESS ( ALL GOV]NM5TS1 & :O 
DO NOT CONT5D AGA9/ !M1 BUT SIMPLY DO NOT NE$ !M & DO 
)\T !M1 & !RE=E >E UNWILL+ TO TAKE ANY P>T 9 
!M8 ,! REVOLUTIONI/S SAY3 ,! =M ( GOV]NM5T IS BAD 9 
?IS RESPECT & ?AT RESPECT2 WE MU/ OV]TURN IT & SUB/ITUTE 
?IS OR ?AT =M ( GOV]NM5T4 ,! ,*RI/IAN SAYS3 ,I KN[ 
NO?+ AB\T ! =M ( GOV]NM5T1 ,I DON'T KN[ :E!R IT IS 
GOOD OR BAD1 & ,I DON'T WANT TO OV]TURN IT PRECISELY BECAUSE ,I 
DON'T KN[ :E!R IT IS GOOD OR BAD1 BUT = ! V]Y SAME REASON 
,I DON'T WANT TO SUPPORT IT EI!R4 ,& ,I NOT ONLY DON'T WANT TO1 
BUT ,I CAN'T1 BECAUSE :AT IT DEM&S ( ME IS AGA9/ MY 
CONSCI5CE4 

,ALL /ATE OBLIGATIONS >E AGA9/ ! CONSCI5CE ( A ,*RI/IAN--! 
OA? ( ALLEGIANCE1 TAXES1 LAW PROCE$+S1 & MILIT>Y S]VICE4 ,& 
! :OLE P[] ( ! GOV]NM5T RE/S ON !SE V]Y OBLIGATIONS4 

,REVOLUTION>Y 5EMIES ATTACK ! GOV]NM5T FROM )\T4 
,*RI/IANITY DOES NOT ATTACK IT AT ALL1 BUT1 FROM )91 IT 
DE/ROYS ALL ! F\NDATIONS ON :I* GOV]NM5T RE/S4 

,AMONG ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE1 ESPECIALLY S9CE ! AGE ( ,PET] ,I41 ! 
PROTE/ ( ,*RI/IANITY AGA9/ ! GOV]NM5T HAS NEV] CEAS$1 & ! 
SOCIAL ORGANIZATION HAS BE5 SU* ?AT M5 EMIGRATE 9 COMMUNES TO 
,TURKEY1 TO ,*9A1 & TO UN9HABIT$ L&S1 & NOT ONLY FEEL NO NE$ ( 
/ATE AID1 BUT ALWAYS REG>D ! /ATE AS A USELESS BURD51 ONLY TO BE 
5DUR$ AS A MIS=TUNE1 :E!R IT HAPP5S TO BE ,TURKI%1 ,RUSSIAN1 OR 
,*9ESE4 ,& SO1 TOO1 AMONG ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE MORE & MORE FREQU5T 
EXAMPLES HAVE ( LATE APPE>$ ( CONSCI\S ,*RI/IAN FRE$OM FROM 
SUBJECTION TO ! /ATE4 ,& !SE EXAMPLES >E ! MORE AL>M+ = 
! GOV]NM5T FROM ! FACT ?AT !SE NON-COMPLIANT P]SONS (T5 
BELONG NOT TO ! SO-CALL$ L[] UN$UCAT$ CLASSES1 BUT >E M5 ( 
FAIR OR GOOD $UCATION2 & ALSO FROM ! FACT ?AT !Y DO NOT 9 !SE 
DAYS JU/IFY !IR POSITION BY ANY MY/IC & EXCEPTIONAL VIEWS1 AS 9 
=M] TIMES1 DO NOT ASSOCIATE !MSELVES ) ANY SUP]/ITI\S OR 
FANATIC RITES1 LIKE ! SECTS :O PRACTICE SELF-IMMOLATION BY FIRE1 OR 
! W&]+ PILGRIMS1 BUT PUT !IR REFUSAL ON ! V]Y SIMPLE/ & 
CLE>E/ GR\NDS1 COMPREH5SIBLE TO ALL1 & RECOGNIZ$ AS TRUE BY ALL4 

,?US !Y REFUSE ! VOLUNT>Y PAYM5T ( TAXES1 BECAUSE TAXES >E SP5T 
ON DE$S ( VIOL5CE--ON ! PAY ( M5 ( VIOL5CE--SOLDI]S1 ON ! 
CON/RUCTION ( PRISONS1 =TRESSES1 & CANNONS4 ,!Y AS ,*RI/IANS 
REG>D IT AS S9FUL & IMMORAL TO HAVE ANY H& 9 SU* DE$S4 

,?OSE :O REFUSE TO TAKE ! OA? ( ALLEGIANCE REFUSE BECAUSE TO 
PROMISE OB$I5CE TO AU?ORITIES1 ?AT IS1 TO M5 :O >E GIV5 TO 
DE$S ( VIOL5CE1 IS CONTR>Y TO ! S5SE ( ,*RI/'S TEA*+4 
,!Y REFUSE TO TAKE ! OA? 9 ! LAW C\RTS1 BECAUSE OA?S >E 
DIRECTLY =BIDD5 BY ! ,GOSPEL4 ,!Y REFUSE TO P]=M POLICE 
DUTIES1 BECAUSE 9 ! P]=MANCE ( !SE DUTIES !Y MU/ USE 
=CE AGA9/ !IR BRO!RS & ILL TREAT !M1 & A ,*RI/IAN 
CANNOT DO ?AT4 ,!Y REFUSE TO TAKE P>T 9 TRIALS AT LAW1 
BECAUSE !Y CONSID] EV]Y APPEAL TO LAW IS FULFILL+ ! LAW ( 
V5GEANCE1 :I* IS 9CONSI/5T ) ! ,*RI/IAN LAW ( 
=GIV5ESS & LOVE4 ,!Y REFUSE TO TAKE ANY P>T 9 MILIT>Y 
PREP>ATIONS & 9 ! >MY1 BECAUSE !Y CANNOT BE EXECUTION]S1 
& !Y >E UNWILL+ TO PREP>E !MSELVES TO BE SO4 

,! MOTIVES 9 ALL !SE CASES >E SO EXCELL5T ?AT1 H[EV] 
DESPOTIC GOV]NM5TS MAY BE1 !Y C\LD H>DLY PUNI% !M OP5LY4 
,TO PUNI% M5 = REFUS+ TO ACT AGA9/ !IR CONSCI5CE ! 
GOV]NM5T MU/ R5\NCE ALL CLAIM TO GOOD S5SE & B5EVOL5CE4 
,& !Y ASSURE PEOPLE ?AT !Y ONLY RULE 9 ! NAME ( GOOD 
S5SE & B5EVOL5CE4 

,:AT >E GOV]NM5TS TO DO AGA9/ SU* PEOPLE8 

,GOV]NM5TS CAN ( C\RSE FLOG TO DEA? OR EXECUTE OR KEEP 9 
P]PETUAL IMPRISONM5T ALL 5EMIES :O WANT TO OV]TURN !M BY 
VIOL5CE1 !Y CAN LAVI% GOLD ON ?AT SECTION ( ! PEOPLE :O 
>E READY TO DE/ROY !IR 5EMIES4 ,BUT :AT CAN !Y DO AGA9/ 
M5 :O1 )\T WI%+ TO OV]TURN OR DE/ROY ANY?+1 DESIRE 
SIMPLY = !IR P>T TO DO NO?+ AGA9/ ! LAW ( ,*RI/1 & 
:O1 !RE=E1 REFUSE TO P]=M ! COMMONE/ /ATE 
REQUIREM5TS1 :I* >E1 !RE=E1 ! MO/ 9DISP5SABLE TO ! 
MA9T5ANCE ( ! /ATE8 

,IF !Y HAD BE5 REVOLUTIONI/S1 ADVOCAT+ & PRACTIC+ 
VIOL5CE & MURD]1 !IR SUPPRESSION W\LD HAVE BE5 AN EASY 
MATT]2 SOME ( !M C\LD HAVE BE5 B\<T OV]1 SOME C\LD HAVE 
BE5 DUP$1 SOME C\LD HAVE BE5 OV]AW$1 & !SE :O C\LD NOT 
BE B\<T OV]1 DUP$1 OR OV]AW$ W\LD HAVE BE5 TREAT$ AS 
CRIM9ALS1 5EMIES ( SOCIETY1 W\LD HAVE BE5 EXECUT$ OR 
IMPRISON$1 & ! CR[D W\LD HAVE APPROV$ ( ! ACTION ( ! 
GOV]NM5T4 ,IF !Y HAD BE5 FANATICS1 PR(ESS+ SOME PECULI> 
BELIEF1 IT MI<T HAVE BE5 POSSIBLE1 9 DISPROV+ ! 
SUP]/ITI\S ]RORS MIX$ 9 ) !IR RELIGION1 TO ATTACK ALSO 
! TRU? !Y ADVOCATE4 ,BUT :AT IS TO BE DONE ) M5 :O 
PR(ESS NO REVOLUTION>Y IDEAS NOR ANY PECULI> RELIGI\S DOGMAS1 
BUT M]ELY BECAUSE !Y >E UNWILL+ TO DO EVIL TO ANY MAN1 
REFUSE TO TAKE ! OA?1 TO PAY TAXES1 TO TAKE P>T 9 LAW 
PROCE$+S1 TO S]VE 9 ! >MY1 TO FULFILL1 9 FACT1 ANY ( ! 
OBLIGATIONS UPON :I* ! :OLE FABRIC ( A /ATE RE/S8 ,:AT IS 
TO DONE ) SU* PEOPLE8 ,TO BUY !M OV] ) BRIBES IS 
IMPOSSIBLE2 ! V]Y RISKS TO :I* !Y VOLUNT>ILY EXPOSE 
!MSELVES %[ ?AT !Y >E 9CORRUPTIBLE4 ,TO DUPE !M 9TO 
BELIEV+ ?AT ?IS IS !IR DUTY TO ,GOD IS ALSO IMPOSSIBLE1 S9CE 
!IR REFUSAL IS BAS$ ON ! CLE>1 UNMI/AKABLE LAW ( ,GOD1 
RECOGNIZ$ EV5 BY ?OSE :O >E TRY+ TO COMPEL M5 TO ACT 
AGA9/ IT4 ,TO T]RIFY !M BY ?REATS IS /ILL LESS POSSIBLE1 
BECAUSE ! DEPRIVATIONS & SUFF]+S TO :I* !Y >E 
SUBJECT$ ONLY /R5G!N !IR DESIRE TO FOLL[ ! FAI? BY 
:I* !Y >E COMM&$3 TO OBEY ,GOD RA!R ?AN M51 & NOT TO 
FE> ?OSE :O CAN DE/ROY ! BODY1 BUT TO FE> HIM :O CAN 
DE/ROY BODY & S\L4 ,TO KILL !M OR KEEP !M 9 P]PETUAL 
IMPRISONM5T IS ALSO IMPOSSIBLE4 ,!SE M5 HAVE FRI5DS1 & A 
PA/2 !IR WAY ( ?9K+ & ACT+ IS WELL KN[N2 !Y >E 
KN[N BY EV]YONE = GOOD1 G5TLE1 PEACEABLE PEOPLE1 & !Y 
CANNOT BE REG>D$ AS CRIM9ALS :O MU/ BE REMOV$ = ! SAFETY 
( SOCIETY4 ,& TO PUT M5 TO DEA? :O >E REG>D$ AS GOOD M5 
IS TO PROVOKE O!RS TO *AMPION !M & JU/IFY !IR REFUSAL4 
,& IT IS ONLY NECESS>Y TO EXPLA9 ! REASONS ( !IR REFUSAL 
TO MAKE CLE> TO EV]YONE ?AT !SE REASONS HAVE ! SAME =CE 
= ALL O!R M51 & ?AT !Y ALL \<T TO HAVE DONE ! SAME 
LONG AGO4 ,!SE CASES PUT ! RUL+ P[]S 9TO A DESP]ATE 
POSITION4 ,!Y SEE ?AT ! PROPHECY ( ,*RI/IANITY IS COM+ TO 
PASS1 ?AT IT IS LOOS5+ ! FETT]S ( ?OSE 9 *A9S1 & 
SETT+ FREE !M ?AT >E 9 BONDAGE1 & ?AT ?IS MU/ 
9EVITABLY BE ! 5D ( ALL OPPRESSORS4 ,! RUL+ AU?ORITIES 
SEE ?IS1 !Y KN[ ?AT !IR H\RS >E NUMB]$1 & !Y CAN DO 
NO?+4 ,ALL ?AT !Y CAN DO TO SAVE !MSELVES IS ONLY 
DEF]R+ ! H\R ( !IR D[NFALL4 ,& ?IS !Y DO1 BUT !IR 
POSITION IS NONE ! LESS DESP]ATE4 

,IT IS LIKE ! POSITION ( A CONQU]OR :O IS TRY+ TO SAVE A 
T[N :I* HAS BE5 SET ON FIRE BY ITS [N 9HABITANTS4 
,DIRECTLY HE PUTS \T ! CONFLAGRATION 9 ONE PLACE1 IT IS ALI<T 
9 TWO O!R PLACES2 DIRECTLY HE GIVES 9 TO ! FIRE & CUTS (F 
:AT IS ON FIRE FROM A L>GE BUILD+1 ! BUILD+ ITSELF IS 
ALI<T AT BO? 5DS4 ,!SE SEP>ATE FIRES MAY BE FEW1 BUT !Y 
>E BURN+ ) A FLAME :I*1 H[EV] SMALL A SP>K IT />TS 
FROM1 NEV] CEASES TILL IT HAS SET ! :OLE ABLAZE4 

,?US IT IS ?AT ! RUL+ AU?ORITIES >E 9 SU* A DEF5SELESS 
POSITION BE=E M5 :O ADVOCATE ,*RI/IANITY1 ?AT BUT LITTLE IS 
NECESS>Y TO OV]?R[ ?IS SOV]EIGN P[] :I* SEEMS SO 
P[]FUL1 & HAS HELD SU* AN EXALT$ POSITION = SO MANY 
C5TURIES4 ,& YET SOCIAL RE=M]S >E BUSY PROMULGAT+ ! 
IDEA ?AT IT IS NOT NECESS>Y & IS EV5 P]NICI\S & IMMORAL 
= EV]Y MAN SEP>ATELY TO WORK \T HIS [N FRE$OM4 ,AS ?\<1 
:ILE ONE SET ( M5 HAVE BE5 AT WORK A LONG :ILE TURN+ A 
RIV] 9TO A NEW *ANNEL1 & HAD DUG \T A COMPLETE WAT]-C\RSE 
& HAD ONLY TO OP5 ! FLOODGATES = ! WAT] TO RU% 9 & 
DO ! RE/1 ANO!R SET ( M5 %\LD COME ALONG & BEG9 TO 
ADVISE !M ?AT IT W\LD BE MU* BETT]1 9/EAD ( LETT+ ! 
WAT] \T1 TO CON/RUCT A MA*9E :I* W\LD LADLE ! WAT] UP 
FROM ONE SIDE & P\R IT OV] ! O!R SIDE4 

,BUT ! ?+ HAS GONE TOO F>4 ,ALREADY RUL+ GOV]NM5TS FEEL 
!IR WEAK & DEF5SELESS POSITION1 & M5 ( ,*RI/IAN 
PR9CIPLES >E AWAK5+ FROM !IR APA?Y1 & ALREADY BEG9 TO 
FEEL !IR P[]4 

0,I AM COME TO S5D A FIRE ON ! E>?10 SAID ,*RI/1 0& :AT 
WILL ,I1 IF IT BE ALREADY K9DL$80 

,& ?IS FIRE IS BEG9N+ TO BURN4 

,FROM 3 ,GUT5B]G4ORG4 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahic 3 ,*APT] #i -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,FEBRU>Y #a#a1 #bag 3 ,*APT] #i -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/