,! ,MEAN+ ( ! ,RUSSIAN ,REVOLUTION #aif ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,LEO ,TOL/OY ,TRANSLATOR 3 ,L\ISE ,MAUDE ,TRANSLATOR 3 ,AYLM] ,MAUDE ,TEXT 3 0 ,WE LIVE 9 GLORI\S TIMES4 4 4 ,WAS !RE EV] SO MU* TO DO 8 ,\R AGE IS A REVOLUTION>Y ONE 9 ! BE/ S5SE ( ! WORD-- NOT ( PHYSICAL BUT MORAL REVOLUTION4 ,HI<] IDEAS ( ! SOCIAL /ATE1 & ( HUMAN P]FECTION1 >E AT WORK4 ,I %ALL NOT LIVE TO SEE ! H>VE/1 BUT TO S[ 9 FAI? IS NO MEAN PRIVILEGE OR HAPP9ESS40 -- ,W4 ,E4 ,*ANN+4 0 ,= ! WOR%IP]S ( UTILITY !RE IS NO MORALITY EXCEPT ! MORALITY ( PR(IT1 & NO RELIGION BUT ! RELIGION ( MAT]IAL WELF>E4 ,!Y F\ND ! BODY ( MAN CRIPPL$ & EXHAU/$ BY WANT1 & 9 !IR ILL-CONSID]$ ZEAL !Y SAID 3 ' ,LET US CURE ?IS BODY 2 & :5 IT IS /RONG1 PLUMP1 & WELL N\RI%$1 ITS S\L WILL RETURN TO IT4' ,BUT ,I SAY ?AT ?AT BODY CAN ONLY BE CUR$ :5 ITS S\L HAS BE5 CUR$4 ,9 IT LIES ! ROOT ( ! DISEASE1 & ! BODILY AILM5TS >E BUT ! \TW>D SIGNS ( ?AT DISEASE4 ,HUMANITY TO-DAY IS DY+ = LACK ( A COMMON FAI? 3 A COMMON IDEA UNIT+ E>? TO HEAV51 ! UNIV]SE TO ,GOD4 0 ,FROM ! ABS5CE ( ?IS SPIRITUAL RELIGION1 ( :I* BUT EMPTY =MS & LIFELESS =MUL>IES REMA91 & FROM A TOTAL LACK ( A S5SE ( DUTY & A CAPACITY = SELF-SACRIFICE1 MAN1 LIKE A SAVAGE1 HAS FALL5 PRO/RATE 9 ! DU/1 & HAS SET UP ON AN EMPTY ALT> ! IDOL ' UTILITY4' ,DESPOTS & ! ,PR9CES ( ?IS WORLD HAVE BECOME HIS ,HI< ,PRIE/S 2 & FROM !M HAS COME ! REVOLT+ =MUL>Y 3 ' ,EA* = HIS [N ALONE 2 EA* = HIMSELF ALONE4' 0 -- ,MAZZ9I4 0 ,:5 ,HE SAW ! MULTITUDE1 ,HE WAS MOV$ ) COMPASSION = !M1 BECAUSE !Y W]E DI/RESS$ & SCATT]$1 AS %EEP NOT HAV+ A %EPH]D4'1 --,MATT1 IX1 #c#f4 ,A ,REVOLUTION IS TAK+ PLACE 9 ,RUSSIA1 & ALL ! WORLD IS FOLL[+ IT ) EAG] ATT5TION1 GUESS+ & TRY+ TO =ESEE :I!R IT IS T5D+1 & TO :AT IT WILL BR+ ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE4 ,TO GUESS AT & TO =ESEE ?IS1 MAY BE 9T]E/+ & IMPORTANT TO \TSIDE SPECTATORS WAT*+ ! ,RUSSIAN ,REVOLUTION1 BUT = US ,RUSSIANS1 :O >E LIV+ 9 ?IS ,REVOLUTION & MAK+ IT1 ! *IEF 9T]E/ LIES NOT 9 GUESS+ :AT IS GO+ TO HAPP51 BUT 9 DEF9+ AS CLE>LY & FIRMLY AS POSSIBLE :AT WE MU/ DO 9 !SE IMM5SELY IMPORTANT1 T]RIBLE1 & DANG]\S TIMES 9 :I* WE LIVE4 ,EV]Y ,REVOLUTION IS A *ANGE ( A PEOPLE'S RELATION T[>DS ,P[]4.<#a.> ,SU* A *ANGE IS N[ TAK+ PLACE 9 ,RUSSIA1 & WE1 ! :OLE ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE1 >E ACCOMPLI%+ IT4 ,!RE=E TO KN[ H[ WE CAN & %\LD *ANGE \R RELATION T[>DS ,P[]1 WE MU/ UND]/& ! NATURE ( ,P[] 3 :AT IT CONSI/S (1 H[ IT >OSE1 & H[ BE/ TO TREAT IT4 ,CONT5TS #a ,I4 #b ,I,I4 #c ,I,I,I4 #d ,I,V4 #e ,V4 #f ,V,I4 #g ,V,I,I4 #h ,V,I,I,I4 #i ,I,X4 #a ,X4 #aa ,X,I4 #ab ,X,I,I4 #ac ,X,I,I,I4 #ad ,X,I,V4 #ae ,X,V4 #af ,X,V,I4 #ag ,X,V,I,I4 #ah ,REF]5CES ,I4 ,ALWAYS & AMONG ALL NATIONS ! SAME ?+ HAS OCCURR$4 ,AMONG PEOPLE OCCUPI$ ) ! NECESS>Y WORK NATURAL TO ALL M51 ( PROVID+ FOOD = !MSELVES & !IR FAMILIES1 BY ! *ASE 7HUNT+ ANIMALS71 OR AS H]DSM5 7NOMADS71 OR BY AGRICULTURE1 !RE APPE>$ M5 ( !IR [N OR ANO!R NATION1 :O =CIBLY SEIZ$ ! FRUIT ( ! WORK]S' TOIL - FIR/ ROBB+1 !N 5SLAV+ !M1 & EXACT+ FROM !M EI!R LABOR OR TRIBUTE1 ,?IS US$ TO HAPP5 9 OLD TIMES1 & /ILL HAPP5S 9 ,AFRICA & ,ASIA4 ,& ALWAYS & EV]Y:]E ! WORK]S 7OCCUPI$ ) !IR ACCU/OM$1 UNAVOIDABLY NECESS>Y1 & UNREMITT+ TASK 7!IR /RUGGLE ) NATURE TO FE$ !MSELVES & RE> !IR *ILDR57 ?\< BY F> MORE NUM]\S & ALWAYS MORE MORAL ?AN !IR CONQU]ORS1 SUBMITT$ TO !M & FULFILL$ !IR DEM&S4 ,!Y SUBMITT$ BECAUSE IT IS NATURAL TO ALL M5 7& ESPECIALLY TO ?OSE 5GAG$ 9 A S]I\S /RUGGLE ) NATURE TO SUPPORT !MSELVES & !IR FAMILIES7 TO DISLIKE /RIFE ) O!R M5 2 & FEEL+ ?IS AV]SION1 !Y PREF]R$ TO 5DURE ! CONSEQU5CES ( ! VIOL5CE PUT UPON !M1 RA!R ?AN TO GIVE UP !IR NECESS>Y1 CU/OM>Y1 & BELOV$ LABOR4 ,!RE W]E1 C]TA9LY1 NONE ( ?OSE CONTRACTS :]EBY ,HUGO ,GROTIUS & ,R\SSEAU EXPLA9 ! RELATIONS BETWE5 ! SUBDU$ & !IR SUBDU]S4 ,NEI!R WAS !RE1 NOR C\LD !RE BE1 ANY AGREEM5T AS TO ! BE/ WAY ( >RANG+ SOCIAL LIFE1 SU* AS ,H]B]T ,SP5C] IMAG9ES 9 HIS 0 ,PR9CIPLES ( ,SOCIOLOGY 0 2 BUT IT HAPP5$ 9 ! MO/ NATURAL WAY1 ?AT :5 ONE SET ( M5 DID VIOL5CE TO ANO!R SET1 ! LATT] PREF]R$ TO 5DURE NOT M]ELY MANY H>D%IPS1 BUT (T5 EV5 GREAT DI/RESS1 RA!R ?AN FACE ! C>ES & EF=TS NECESS>Y TO )/& !IR OPPRESSORS 2 MORE ESPECIALLY AS ! CONQU]ORS TOOK ON !MSELVES ! DUTY ( PROTECT+ ! CONQU]$ PEOPLE AGA9/ 9T]NAL & EXT]NAL DI/URB]S ( ! PEACE4 ,& SO ! MAJORITY ( M51 OCCUPI$ ) ! BUS9ESS NECESS>Y TO ALL M5 & TO ALL ANIMALS 7?AT ( FE$+ !MSELVES & !IR FAMILIES7 NOT ONLY 5DUR$ ! UNAVOIDABLE 9CONV5I5CES & H>D%IPS1 & EV5 ! CRUELTY1 ( !IR OPPRESSORS1 )\T FI ALL ! H>D%IPS IT 9VOLVES1 ?AN TO GIVE UP ! NECESSAIY WORK ( SUPPORT+ !MSELVES & !IR FAMILIES ,9 ORD] TO FIE1 DEP5D5T ON ECONOMIC CONDITIONS1 ,BUT TO ASS]T ?IS IS M]ELY TO SUB/ITUTE = ! CLE> & EVID5T CAUSE ( A PH5OM5ON ONE ( ITS EFFECTS4 ,! CAUSE ( ?IS OR ?AT ECONOMIC CONDITION ALWAYS WAS 7& C\LD NOT BUT BE7 ! OPPRESSION ( SOME M5 BY O!RS4 ,ECONOMIC CONDITIONS >E A RESULT ( VIOL5CE1 & CANNOT !RE=E BE ! CAUSE ( HUMAN RELATIONS4 ,EVIL M5 -- ! ,CA9S -- :O LOV$ IDL5ESS & W]E COVET\S1 ALWAYS ATTACK$ GOOD M5 -- ! ,ABELS -- ! TILL]S ( ! SOIL1 & BY KILL+ !M OR ?REAT5+ TO KILL !M1 PR(IT$ BY !IR TOIL4 ,! GOOD1 G5TLE1 & 9DU/RI\S PEOPLE1 9/EAD ( FITLY BECAUSE !Y DID NOT WI% TO FITLY BECAUSE !Y C\LD NOT DO SO )\T 9T]RUPT+ !IR WORK ( FE$+ !MSELVES & !IR NEIE1 BAS$ & BUILT4 ,I,I4 ,FROM ! MO/ ANCI5T TIMES1 & AMONG ALL ! NATIONS ( ! E>?1 ! RELATIONS ( ! RUL]S TO ! RUL$ HAVE BE5 BAS$ ON VIOL5CE4 ,BUT ?IS RELATION1 LIKE EV]Y?+ ELSE 9 ! WORLD1 WAS & IS CONT9UALLY *ANG+4 ,IT *ANGES FROM TWO CAUSES4 ,FIR/ BECAUSE ! MORE SECURE !IR P[] BECOMES & ! LONG] IT LA/S1 ! MORE DO ?OSE 9 P[] 7! LEISUR$ CLASSES :O HAVE P[]7 GR[ DEPRAV$1 UNREASONABLE & CRUEL1 & ! MORE 9JURI\S TO !IR SUBJECTS DO !IR DEM&S BECOME4 ,SECONDLY1 BECAUSE AS ?OSE 9 P[] GR[ MORE DEPRAV$1 !IR SUBJECTS SEE MORE & MORE CLE>LY ! H>M & FOLLY ( SUBMITT+ TO SU* DEPRAV$ P[]4 ,& ?OSE 9 P[] ALWAYS BECOME DEPRAV$ 3 FIR/LY1 BECAUSE SU* PEOPLE1 IMMORAL BY NATURE1 & PREF]R+ IDL5ESS & VIOL5CE TO WORK1 HAV+ GRASP$ P[] & US$ IT TO SATISFY !IR LU/S & PASSIONS1 GIVE !MSELVES UP MORE & MORE TO !SE PASSIONS & VICES2 & SECONDLY1 BECAUSE LU/S & PASSIONS1 :I* 9 ! CASE ( ORD9>Y M5 CANNOT BE GRATIFI$ )\T MEET+ ) OB/ACLES1 NOT ONLY DO NOT MEET SU* OB/ACLES & DO NOT >\SE ANY CONDEMNATION 9 ! CASE ( ?OSE :O RULE1 BUT ON ! CONTR>Y >E APPLAUD$ BY ALL :O SURR\ND !M4 ,! LATT] G5]ALLY B5EFIT BY ! MADNESS ( !IR MA/]S 2 & BESIDES1 IT PLEASES !M TO IMAG9E ?AT ! VIRTUES & WISDOM TO :I* ALONE 'IT IS NATURAL = REASONABLE M5 TO SUBMIT >E TO BE F\ND 9 ! M5 TO :OM !Y SUBMIT 2 & !RE=E1 ! VICES ( ?OSE 9 P[] >E LAUD$ AS IF !Y W]E VIRTUES1 & GR[ TO T]RIBLE PROPORTIONS4 ,CONSEQU5TLY ! FOLLY & VICE ( ! CR[N$ & UNCR[N$ RUL]S ( ! NATIONS HAVE REA*$ SU* APPALL+ DIM5SIONS AS W]E REA*$ BY ! ,N]OS1 ,*>LESES1 ,H5RYS1 ,L\IS1 ,JOHNS1 ,PET]S1 ,CA!R9ES1 & ,M>ATS4 ,NOR IS ?IS ALL4 ,IF ! RUL]S W]E SATISFI$ ) !IR P]SONAL DEBAU*]Y & VICES !Y W\LD NOT DO SO MU* H>M 2 BUT IDLE1 SATIAT$1 & DEPRAV$ M51 SU* AS RUL]S W]E & >E1 MU/ HAVE SOME?+ TO LIVE = -- MU/ HAVE SOME AIMS & TRY TO ATTA9 !M4 ,& SU* M5 CAN HAVE NO AIM EXCEPT TO GET MORE & MORE FAME4 ,ALL O!R PASSIONS SOON REA* ! LIMITS ( SATIETY4 ,ONLY AMBITION HAS NO LIMITS1 & !RE=E ALMO/ ALL POT5TATES ALWAYS /ROVE & /RIVE AFT] FAME1 ESPECIALLY MILIT>Y FAME1 ! ONLY K9D ATTA9ABLE BY DEPRAV$ M5 UNACQUA9T$ )1 & 9CAPABLE (1 REAL WORK4 ,= ! W>S DEVIS$ BY ! POT5TATES1 MONEY1 >MIES &1 ABOVE ALL1 ! SLAUE NECESS>Y 2 & 9 CONSEQU5CE ( ?IS ! CONDITION ( ! RUL$ BECOMES H>D] & H>D]1 & AT LA/ ! OPPRESSION REA*ES A PO9T AT :I* ! RUL$ CAN NO LONG] CONT9UE TO SUBMIT TO ! RUL+ P[]1 BUT MU/ TRY TO ALT] !IR RELATION T[>DS IT4 ,I,I,I4 ,SU* IS ONE REASON ( ALT]ATION 9 ! RELATIONS BETWE5 ! RUL]S & ! RUL$4 ,ANO!R /ILL MORE IMPORTANT REASON ( ?IS *ANGE IS ?AT ! RUL$ -- BELIEV+ 9 ! RIMFULNESS ( ?IS RULE1 BUT ALSO ?AT TO SUBMIT TO SU* P[] IS BECOM+ IMMORAL4 ,IT WAS POSSIBLE FIVE HUNDR$ OR A ?\S& YE>S AGO = PEOPLE1 9 OB$I5CE TO !IR RUL]S1 TO SLAUT]1 5CAGE1 DE/ROY & 5?RALL$ :OLE NATIONS4 ,BUT 9 ! N9ETE5? & TW5TIE? C5TURIES1 SUBJUGAT$ PEOPLE1 5- LIIAN TEA*+S :I* HAVE GR[N UP \T ( IT1 CAN NO LONG] )\T PANGS ( CONSCI5CE SUBMIT TO ! P[]S :I* DEM& ?AT !Y %\LD P>TICIPATE 9 ! SLAUS7 & CAN NO LONG] ) QUIET CONSCI5CES1 AS =M]LY1 KN[ !MSELVES TO BE P>TICIPATORS 9 ! DE$S ( VIOL5CE & ! EXECUTIONS :I* >E BE+ COMMITT$ BY ! ,GOV]NM5TS ( !IR C\NTRIES4 ,SO ?AT =CE-US+ P[] DE/ROYS ITSELF 9 TWO WAYS4 ,IT DE/ROYS ITSELF ?R\< ! EV]-GR[+ DEPRAVITY ( ?OSE 9 AU?ORITY1 & ! CONSEQU5T CONT9UALLY-9CREAS+ BURD5 BORNE BY ! RUL$ 2 & ?R\< ITS EV]-9CREAS+ DEVIATION FROM ! EV] DEVELOP+ MORAL P]CEPTION ( ! RUL$4 ,!RE=E1 :]E =CE-US+ P[] EXI/S1 A MOM5T MU/ 9EVITABLY COME :5 ! RELATION ( ! PEOPLE T[>DS ?AT P[] MU/ *ANGE4 ,?IS MOM5T MAY COME SOON] OR LAT] ACCORD+ TO ! DEGREE & ! RAPIDITY ( ! CORRUPTION ( ! RUL]S1 TO ! AM\NT ( !IR CUNN+1 TO ! QUIET] OR MORE RE/LESS TEMP]AM5T ( ! PEOPLE1 & EV5 FROM !IR GEOGRAPHICAL POSITION HELP+ OR H9D]+ ! 9T]C\RSE ( ! PEOPLE AMONG !MSELVES 2 BUT SOON] OR LAT] ?AT MOM5T MU/ 9EVITABLY COME TO ALL NATIONS4 ,TO ! ,WE/]N NATIONS1 :I* >OSE ON ! RU9S ( ! ,ROMAN ,EMPIRE1 ?AT MOM5T CAME LONG AGO4 ,! /RUGGLE ( PEOPLE AGA9/ ,GOV]NM5T BEGAN EV5 9 ,ROME 2 CONT9U$ 9 ALL ! ,/ATES ?AT SUCCE$$ ,ROME1 & /ILL GOES ON4 ,TO ! ,EA/]N NATIONS 3 ,TURKEY1 ,P]SIA1 ,9DIA1 ,*9A1 ?AT MOM5T HAS NOT YET >RIV$4 ,= ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE1 IT HAS N[ COME4 ,! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE >E TO-DAY CONFRONT$ BY ! DREADFUL *OICE ( EI!R1 LIKE ! ,EA/]N NATIONS1 CONT9U+ TO SUBMIT TO !IR UNREASONABLE & DEPRAV$ ,GOV]NM5T 9 SPITE ( ALL ! MIS]Y IT HAS 9FLICT$ UPON !M 2 OR1 AS ALL ! ,WE/]N NATIONS HAVE DONE1 REALIZ+ ! EVIL ( ! EXI/+ ,GOV]NM5T1 UPSETT+ IT BY =CE1 & E/ABLI%+ A NEW ONE4 ,SU* A *OICE SEEMS QUITE NATURAL TO ! NON-LABOR+ CLASSES ( ,RUSSIA1 :O >E 9 T\* ) ! UPP] & PROSP]\S CLASSES ( ! ,WE/]N NATIONS & CONSID] ! MILIT>Y MIE QUITE CONV9C$ ?AT ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE AT ?IS CRISIS CAN DO NO?+ BETT] ?AN FOLL[ ! PA? ! ,WE/]N NATIONS HAVE TRODD5 & >E /ILL TREAD+ 3 ?AT IS TO SAY1 FILESES 7! ,GREAT & ! ,FIF?7 ! ,PHILIPS1 ,L\IS1 & ,H5RY ! ,EIS1 ROBB]IES1 MURD]S1 EXECUTIONS1 & F9I%$ ) ! FALL ( ! OLD P[] & ! ACCESSION ( A NEW ONE4 ,& :5 ! NEW P[] BECAME AS OPPRESSIVE TO ! PEOPLE AS ?AT :I* HAD BE5 OV]?R[N1 IT TOO WAS UPSET1 & ANO!R NEW ONE WAS PUT 9 ITS PLACE1 :I* BY ! SAME UNALT]ABLE NATURE ( P[]1 BECAME 9 DUE C\RSE AS H>MFUL AS ITS PR$ECESSORS4 ,?US1 = 9/ANCE1 9 ,FRANCE !RE W]E ELEV5 *ANGES ( P[] )9 EIS 3 ! ,B\RBONS1 ! ,CONV5TION1 ! ,DIRECTORY1 ,BONAP>TE1 ! ,EMPIRE1 AGA9 ! ,B\RBONS1 A ,REPUBLIC1 ,L\IS ,PHILIPPE1 AGA9 A ,REPUBLIC1 AGA9 A ,BONAP>TE1 & AGA9 A ,REPUBLIC4 ,! SUB/ITUTION ( NEW P[]S = OLD ONES TOOK PLACE AMONG O!R NATIONS TOO1 ?\< NOT SO RAPIDLY AS 9 ,FRANCE4 ,!SE *ANGES 9 MO/ CASES DID NOT IMPROVE ! CONDITION ( ! PEOPLE1 & !RE=E ?OSE :O MADE !SE *ANGES C\LD NOT HELP COM+ TO ! CONCLUSION ?AT ! MIS]Y !Y SUFF]$ DID NOT SO MU* DEP5D ON ! NATURE ( ! P]SONS 9 P[] AS ON ! FACT ?AT A FEW P]SONS EX]CIS$ P[] OV] MANY4 ,& !RE=E ! PEOPLE TRI$ TO R5D] ! P[] H>MLESS BY LIMIT+ IT4 ,& SU* LIMITATION WAS 9TRODUC$ 9 SEV]AL C\NTRIES 9 ! =M ( ELECT$ ,*AMB]S ( ,REPRES5TATIVES4 ,BUT ! M5 :O LIMIT$ ! >BITR>9ESS ( ! RUL]S & F\ND ! ,ASSEMBLIES1 BECOM+ !MSELVES POSSESSORS ( P[]1 NATURALLY SUCCUMB$ TO ! DEPRAV+ 9FLU5CE :I* ACCOMPANIES P[]1 & TO :I* ! AUTOCRATIC RUL]S HAD SUC- CUMB$4 ,!SE M51 BECOM+ %>]S 9 P[] EV5 ?\< NOT S+LY1 P]PETRAT$1 JO9TLY OR SEP>ATELY1 ! SAME K9D ( EVIL1 & BECAME AS GREAT A BURD5 ON ! PEOPLE AS ! AUTOCRATIC RUL]S HAD BE54 ,!N1 TO LIMIT ! >BITR>9ESS ( P[] /ILL MORE1 MON>*ICAL P[] WAS ABOLI%$ ALTOGE!R 9 SOME C\NTRIES1 & A ,GOV]NM5T WAS E/ABLI%$ *OS5 BY ! :OLE PEOPLE4 ,9 ?IS WAY ,REPUBLICS W]E 9/ITUT$ 9 ,FRANCE1 ,AM]ICA & ,SWITZ]L& 2 & ! ,REF]5DUM & ! ,9ITIATIVE W]E 9TRO- DUC$1 GIV+ EV]Y MEMB] ( ! COMMUNITY ! POSSIBILITY ( 9T]F]+ & P>TICIPAT+ 9 LEGISLATION4 ,BUT ! ONLY EFFECT ( ALL !SE MEASURES WAS ?AT ! CITIZ5S ( !SE ,/ATES1 P>TICIPAT+ MORE & MORE 9 P[]1 & BE+ MORE & MORE DIV]T$ FROM S]I\S OCCUPATIONS1 GREW MORE & MORE DEPRAV$4 ,! CALAMITIES FROM :I* ! PEOPLE SUFF]$ REMA91 H[EV]1 EXACTLY ! SAME UND] ,CON/ITUTIONAL1 ,MON>*ICAL1 OR ,REPUBLICAN ,GOV]NM5TS1 ) OR )\T ,REF]5DUMS4 ,NOR C\LD IT BE O!RWISE1 = ! IDEA ( LIMIT+ P[] BY ! P>TICIPATION 9 P[] ( ALL :O >E SUBJECT TO IT IS UNS\ND AT ITS V]Y CORE1 & SELF-CONTRADICTORY4 ,IF ONE MAN ) ! AID ( HIS HELP]S RULES OV] ALL1 IT IS UNJU/1 & 9 ALL LIKELIHOOD SU* RULE WILL BE H>MFUL TO ! PEOPLE4 ,! SAME WILL BE ! CASE :5 ! M9ORITY RULES OV] ! MAJORITY4 ,BUT ! P[] ( ! MAJORITY OV] ! M9ORITY ALSO FAILS TO SECURE A JU/ RULE 2 = WE HAVE NO REASON TO BELIEVE ?AT ! MAJORITY P>TICIPAT+ 9 GOV]NM5T IS WIS] ?AN ! M9ORITY ?AT AVOIDS P>TICIPATION4 ,TO EXT5D ! P>TICIPATION 9 GOV]NM5T TO ALL1 AS MIRANGEM5T ?AT MA9TA9S ! RIE RUL$1 :E!R BY ! MO/ DESPOTIC OR MO/ DEMOCRATIC ,GOV]NM5TS1 ! *IEF & FUNDAM5TAL CALAMITIES FROM :I* ! PEOPLE SUFF]1 REMA9 ! SAME 3 ! SAME EV]-9CREAS+1 5ORM\S BUDGETS1 ! SAME ANIMOSITY T[>DS !IR NEIY PREP>ATIONS & >MIES 2 ! SAME TAXES 2 ! SAME ,/ATE & PRIVATE MONOPOLIES 2 ! SAME DEPRIV+ ! PEOPLE ( ! RI 2 & ! SAME W>S1 DE/ROY+ ! LIVES ( M5 & UND]M9+ !IR MORALITY4 ,V4 ,IT IS TRUE ?AT ! ,REPRES5TATIVE ,GOV]NM5TS ( ,WE/]N ,EUROPE & ,AM]ICA -- ,CON/ITUTIONAL ,MON>*IES AS WELL AS ,REPUBLICS -- HAVE UPROOT$ SOME ( ! EXT]NAL ABUSES PRACTIC$ BY ! REPRES5TATIVES ( P[]1 & HAVE MADE IT IMPOSSIBLE ?AT ! HOLD]S ( P[] %\LD BE SU* MON/]S AS W]E ! DIFF]5T ,L\IS1 ,*>LESES1 ,H5RYS & ,JOHNS4 7,AL?\< 9 REPRES5TATIVE ,GOV]NM5T NOT ONLY IS IT POSSIBLE ?AT P[] WILL BE SEIZ$ BY CUNN+1 IMMORAL & >TFUL M$IOCRITIES1 SU* AS V>I\S ,PRIME ,M9I/]S & ,PRESID5TS HAVE BE51 BUT ! CON/RUCTION ( ?OSE ,GOV]NM5TS IS SU*1 ?AT ONLY ?AT K9D ( PEOPLE CAN OBTA9 P[]47 ,IT IS TRUE ?AT REPRES5TATIVE ,GOV]NM5TS HAVE ABOLI%$ SU* ABUSES AS ! LETTRES DE CA*ET1 HAVE REMOV$ RE/RICTIONS ON ! PRESS1 HAVE /OPP$ RELIGI\S P]SECUTIONS & OPPRESSIONS1 HAVE SUBMITT$ ! TAXATION ( ! PEOPLE TO DISCUSSION BY !IR REPRES5TATIVES1 HAVE MADE ! ACTIONS ( ! ,GOV]NM5T PUBLIC & SUBJECT TO CRITICISM1 & HAVE FACILITAT$ ! RAPID DEVELOPM5T 9 ?OSE C\NTRIES ( ALL SORTS ( TE*NICAL IMPROVEM5TS GIV+ GREAT COM=T TO ! LIFE ( RI* CITIZ5S & GREAT MILIT>Y P[] TO ! ,/ATE4 ,SO ?AT ! NATIONS :I* HAVE REPRES5TATIVE GOV]NM5T HAVE D\BTLESS BECOME MORE P[]FUL 9DU/RIALLY1 COMM]CIALLY & 9 MILIT>Y MATT]S1 ?AN DESPOTICALLY GOV]N$ NATIONS1 & ! LIVES ( !IR LEISUR$ CLASSES HAVE C]TA9LY BECOME MORE SECURE1 COM=TABLE1 AGREEABLE & ES!TIC ?AN !Y US$ TO BE4 ,BUT IS ! LIFE ( ! MAJORITY ( ! PEOPLE 9 ?OSE C\NTRIES MORE SECURE1 FRE]1 OR1 ABOVE ALL1 MORE REASONABLE & MORAL 8 ,I ?9K NOT4 ,UND] ! DESPOTIC P[] ( ONE MAN1 ! NUMB] ( P]SONS :O COME UND] ! CORRUPT+ 9FLU5CE ( P[] & LIVE ON ! LABOR ( O!RS1 IS LIMIT$1 & CONSI/S ( ! DESPOT'S CLOSE FRI5DS1 ASSI/ANTS1 S]VANTS & FLATT]]S1 & ( !IR HELP]S4 ,! 9FECTION ( DEPRAVITY IS FOCUS$ 9 ! ,C\RT ( ! DESPOT1 :5CE IT RADIATES 9 ALL DIRECTIONS4 ,:]E P[] IS LIMIT$1 I4E4 :]E MANY P]SONS TAKE P>T 9 IT1 ! NUMB] ( C5T]S ( 9FECTION IS AUGM5T$1 = EV]YONE :O %>ES P[] HAS HIS FRI5DS1 HELP]S1 S]VANTS1 FLATT]]S & RELATIONS4 ,:]E !RE IS UNIV]SAL SUFFRAGE1 !SE C5T]S ( 9FECTION >E /ILL MORE DIFFUS$4 ,EV]Y VOT] BECOMES ! OBJECT ( FLATT]Y & BRIB]Y4 ,! *>ACT] ( ! P[] ITSELF IS ALSO *ANG$4 ,9/EAD ( P[] F\ND$ ON DIRECT VIOL5CE1 WE GET A MONET>Y P[]1 ALSO F\ND$ ON VIOL5CE1 NOT DIRECTLY1 BUT ?R\< A COMPLICAT$ TRANSMISSION4 ,SO ?AT UND] REPRES5TATIVE ,GOV]NM5TS1 9/EAD ( ONE OR A FEW C5T]S ( DEPRAVITY1 WE GET A L>GE NUMB] ( SU* C5T]S -- - ?AT IS TO SAY1 !RE SPR+S UP A L>GE CLASS ( PEOPLE LIV+ IDLY ON O!RS' LABOR1 ! CLASS CALL$ ! 0 B\RGEOIS10 I4E4 PEOPLE :O1 BE+ PROTECT$ BY VIOL5CE1 >RANGE = !MSELVES EASY & COM=TABLE LIVES1 FREE FROM H>D WORK4 ,BUT AS1 :5 >RANG+ AN EASY & PLEASANT LIFE NOT ONLY = A ,MON>* & HIS ,C\RT1 BUT = ?\S&S ( LITTLE K+LETS1 MANY ?+S >E NE$$ TO EMBELLI% & TO AMUSE ?IS IDLE LIFE1 IT RESULTS ?AT :5EV] P[] PASSES FROM A DESPOTIC TO A REPRES5TATIVE ,GOV]NM5T1 9V5TIONS APPE>1 FACILITAT+ ! SUPPLY ( OBJECTS ?AT ADD TO ! PLEASURE & SAFETY ( ! LIVES ( ! WEAL?Y CLASSES4 ,TO PRODUCE ALL !SE OBJECTS1 AN EV]-9CREAS+ NUMB] ( WORK+ M5 >E DRAWN AWAY FROM AGRICULTURE1 & HAVE !IR CAPACITIES DIRECT$ TO ! PRODUCTION ( PLEAS+ TRIFLES US$ BY ! RI*1 OR EV5 TO SOME EXT5T BY ! WORK]S !MSELVES4 ,SO !RE SPR+S UP A CLASS ( T[N WORK]S SO SITUAT$ AS TO BE 9 COMPLETE DEP5D5CE ON ! WEAL?Y CLASSES4 ,! NUMB] ( !SE PEOPLE GR[S & GR[S ! LONG] ! P[] ( REPRES5TATIVE ,GOV]NM5T 5DURES1 & !IR CONDITION BECOMES WORSE & WORSE4 ,9 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES1 \T ( A POPULATION ( SEV5TY MILLIONS1 T5 MILLIONS >E PROLET>IANS1 & ! RELATION BETWE5 ! WELL-TO-DO & ! PROLET>IAT CLASSES IS ! SAME 9 ,5GL&1 ,BELGIUM & ,FRANCE4 ,! NUMB] ( M5 EX*ANG+ ! LABOR ( PRODUC+ OBJECTS ( PRIM>Y NECESSITY = ! LABOR ( PRODUC+ OBJECTS ( LUXURY IS EV] 9CREAS+ 9 ?OSE C\NTRIES4 ,IT CLE>LY FOLL[S ?AT ! RESULT ( SU* A TR5D ( AFFAIRS MU/ BE ! EV] GREAT] OV]BURD5+ ( ?AT DIM9I%+ NUMB] :I* HAS TO SUPPORT ! LUXURI\S LIVES ( ! EV] 9CREAS+ NUMB] ( IDLE PEOPLE4 ,EVID5TLY1 SU* A WAY ( LIFE CANNOT CONT9UE4 ,:AT IS HAPP5+ IS AS ?\< !RE W]E A MAN :OSE BODY W5T ON 9CREAS+ 9 WEID$ AS A NECESSITY4 ,AT FIR/ ONLY A SMALL P>T ( ! NATION %>$ 9 ! FIT PROV$ 9EFFECTUAL1 AN EV] GREAT] & GREAT] NUMB] 5T]$ 9TO ! CONFLICT1 & IT 5D$ BY ! MAJORITY ( ! PEOPLE ( ?OSE NATIONS 79/EAD ( FREE+ !MSELVES FROM ! WORRY & S9 ( FI+ 9 ! WIELD+ ( P[] 2 ! V]Y ?+ !Y WI%$ TO AVOID :5 !Y FIR/ SUBMITT$ TO P[]4 ,! 9EVITABLE RESULT ( ?IS WAS ! 9CREASE ( ! DEPRAV+ 9FLU5CE ?AT COMES ( P[]1 AN 9CREASE NOT AFFECT+ A SMALL NUMB] ( P]SONS ONLY1 AS HAD BE5 ! CASE UND] A S+LE RUL]1 BUT AFFECT+ ALL ! MEMB]S ( ! COMMUNITY4 7,/EPS >E N[ BE+ TAK5 TO SUBJECT WOM5 ALSO TO IT47 ,REPRES5TATIVE ,GOV]NM5T & ,UNIV]SAL ,SUFFRAGE RESULT$ 9 EV]Y POSSESSOR ( A FRACTION ( P[] BE+ EXPOS$ TO ALL ! EVIL ATTA*$ TO P[] 3 BRIB]Y1 FLATT]Y1 VANITY1 SELF-CONCEIT1 IDL5ESS &1 ABOVE ALL1 IMMORAL P>TICIPATION 9 DE$S ( VIOL5CE4 ,EV]Y MEMB] ( ,P>LIAM5T IS EXPOS$ TO ALL !SE TEMPTATIONS 9 A YET GREAT] DEGREE4 ,EV]Y ,DEPUTY ALWAYS BEG9S HIS C>E] ( P[] BY BEFOOL+ PEOPLE1 MAK+ PROMISES HE KN[S HE WILL NOT KEEP 2 & :5 SITT+ 9 ! ,H\SE HE TAKES P>T 9 MAK+ LAWS ?AT >E 5=C$ BY VIOL5CE4 ,IT IS ! SAME ) ALL ,S5ATORS & ,PRESID5TS4 ,SIMIL> CORRUPTION PREVAILS 9 ! ELECTION ( A ,PRESID5T4 ,9 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES ! ELECTION ( A ,PRESID5T CO/S MILLIONS TO ?OSE F9ANCI]S :O KN[ ?AT :5 ELECT$ HE WILL MA9TA9 C]TA9 MONOPOLIES OR IMPORT DUTIES ADVANTAGE\S TO !M1 ON V>I\S >TICLES1 :I* WILL 5ABLE !M TO REC\P ! CO/ ( ! ELECTION A HUNDR$FOLD4 ,& ?IS CORRUPTION1 ) ALL ITS ACCOMPANY+ PH5OM5A -- ! DESIRE TO AVOID H>D WORK & TO B5EFIT BY COM=TS & PLEASURES PROVID$ BY O!RS 2 9T]E/S & C>ES1 9ACCESSIBLE TO A MAN 5GAG$ 9 WORK1 CONC]N+ ! G5]AL BUS9ESS ( ! ,/ATE 2 ! SPREAD ( A LY+ & 9FLAMMATORY PRESS 2 &1 ABOVE ALL1 ANIMOSITY BETWE5 NATION & NATION1 CLASS & CLASS1 MAN & MAN -- HAS GR[N & GR[N1 TILL IT HAS REA*$ SU* DIM5SIONS ?AT ! /RUGGLE ( ALL M5 AGA9/ !IR FELL[S HAS BECOME SO HABITUAL A /ATE ( ?+S1 ?AT ,SCI5CE 7! ,SCI5CE ?AT IS 5GAG$ 9 CONDON+ ALL ! NA/9ESS DONE BY M57 HAS DECID$ ?AT ! /RUGGLE & 5MITY ( ALL AGA9/ ALL IS A NECESS>Y1 UNAVOIDABLE & B5EFIC5T CONDITION ( HUMAN LIFE4 ,?AT PEACE1 :I* TO ! ANCI5TS :O SALUT$ EA* O!R ) ! WORDS 0 ,PEACE BE UNTO Y\ 6 0 SEEM$ ! GREATE/ ( BLESS+S1 HAS N[ QUITE DISAPPE>$ FROM AMONG ! ,WE/]N PEOPLES 2 & NOT ONLY HAS IT DISAPPE>$1 BUT BY ! AID ( SCI5CE1 M5 TRY TO ASSURE !MSELVES ?AT NOT 9 PEACE1 BUT 9 ! /RIFE ( ALL AGA9/ ALL1 LIES MAN'S HIY /RIFE IS CONT9UALLY WAG$ J A /RIFE ( ,/ATE AGA9/ ,/ATE1 CLASS AGA9/ CLASS1 ,LABOR AGA9/ ,CAPITAL1 P>TY AGA9/ P>TY1 MAN AGA9/ MAN4 ,NOR IS ?IS ALL4 ,! *IEF RESULT ( ?IS P>TICIPATION ( ALL M5 9 P[] IS1 ?AT M5 BE+ MORE & MORE DRAWN AWAY FROM DIRECT WORK ON ! L&1 & MORE & MORE 9VOLV$ 9 DIV]SE WAYS ( EXPLOIT+ ! LABOR ( O!RS1 HAVE LO/ !IR 9DEP5D5CE & >E =C$ BY ! POSITION !Y LIVE 9 TO LEAD IMMORAL LIVES4 ,HAV+ NEI!R ! DESIRE NOR ! HABIT ( LIV+ BY TILL+ !IR [N L&1 ! ,WE/]N NATIONS W]E =C$ TO OBTA9 !IR MEANS ( SUBSI/5CE FROM O!R C\NTRIES4 ,!Y C\LD DO ?IS ONLY 9 TWO WAYS 3 BY FRAUD1 ?AT IS1 BY EX*ANG+ ?+S = ! MO/ P>T UNNECESS>Y OR DEPRAV+1 SU* AS ALCOHOL1 OPIUM1 WEAPONS1 = ! FOOD/UFFS 9DISP5SABLE TO !M 2 OR BY VIOL5CE1 ?AT IS1 ROBB+ ! PEOPLE ( ,ASIA & ,AFRICA :]EV] !Y SAW AN OPPORTUNITY ( DO+ ?IS ) IMPUNITY1 ,SU* IS ! POSITION ( ,G]MANY1 ,AU/RIA1 ,ITALY1 ,FRANCE1 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES1 & ESPECIALLY ,GREAT ,BRITA91 :I* IS HELD UP AS AN EXAMPLE = ! IMITATION & 5VY ( O!R NATIONS4 ,ALMO/ ALL ! PEOPLE ( !SE NATIONS1 HAV+ BECOME CONSCI\S P>TICIPATORS 9 DE$S ( VIOL5CE1 DEVOTE !IR /R5G? & ATT5TION TO ! ACTIVITIES ( ,GOV]NM5T1 & TO 9DU/RY & TO COMM]CE1 :I* AIM *IEFLY AT SATISFY+ ! DEM&S ( ! RI* = LUXURIES 2 & !Y SUBJUGATE 7P>TLY BY DIRECT =CE1 P>TLY BY MONEY7 ! AGRICULTURAL PEOPLE BO? ( !IR [N & ( =EIGN C\NTRIES1 :O HAVE TO PROVIDE !M ) ! NECESS>IES ( LIFE4 ,SU* PEOPLE =M A MAJORITY 9 SOME NATIONS 2 9 O!RS !Y >E AS YET ONLY A M9ORITY 2 BUT ! P]C5TAGE ( M5 LIV+ ON ! LABOR ( O!RS GR[S UNCONTROLLABLY & V]Y RAPIDLY1 TO ! DETRIM5T ( ?OSE :O /ILL DO REASONABLE1 AGRICULTURAL WORK4 ,SO ?AT A MAJORITY ( ! PEOPLE ( ,WE/]N ,EUROPE >E ALREADY 9 ! CONDITION 7! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES >E NOT SO YET1 BUT >E BE+ IRRESI/IBLY DRAWN T[>DS IT7 ( NOT BE+ ABLE TO SUBSI/ BY !IR [N LABOR ON !IR [N L&4 ,!Y >E OBLIG$ 9 ONE WAY OR ANO!R1 BY =CE OR FRAUD1 TO TAKE ! NECESS>IES ( LIFE FROM O!R PEOPLE :O /ILL DO !IR [N LABOR4 ,& !Y GET !SE NECESS>IES EI!R BY DEFRAUD+ =EIGN NATIONS1 OR BY GROSS VIOL5CE4 ,FROM ?IS IT NECESS>ILY RESULTS ?AT TRADE1 AIM+ *IEFLY AT SATISFY+ ! DEM&S ( ! RI*1 & ( ! RI*E/ ( ! RI* 7?AT IS1 ! ,GOV]NM5T7 DIRECTS ITS *IEF P[]S1 NOT TO IMPROV+ ! MEANS ( TILL+ ! SOIL1 BUT TO MAK+ IT POSSIBLE BY ! AID ( MA*9ES TO SOMEH[ TILL L>GE TRACTS ( L& 7( :I* ! PEOPLE HAVE BE5 DEPRIV$71 TO MANUFACTUR+ F9]Y = WOM51 BUILD+ LUXURI\S PALACES1 PRODUC+ SWEETMEATS1 TOYS1 MOTOR-C>S TOBACCO1 W9ES1 DELICACIES1 M$IC9ES1 5ORM\S QUANTITIES ( PR9T$ MATT]1 GUNS1 RIFLES1 P[D]1 UNNECESS>Y RAILWAYS1 & SO =?4 ,& AS !RE IS NO 5D TO ! CAPRICES ( M5 :5 !Y >E MET NOT BY !IR [N LABOR BUT BY ?AT ( O!RS1 9DU/RY IS MORE & MORE DIV]T$ TO ! PRODUCTION ( ! MO/ UNNECESS>Y1 /UPID1 DEPRAV+ PRODUCTS1 & DRAWS PEOPLE MORE & MORE FROM REASONABLE WORK 2 & NO 5D CAN BE =ESE5 TO !SE 9V5TIONS & PREP>ATIONS = ! AMUSEM5T ( IDLE PEOPLE1 ESPECIALLY AS ! /UPID] & MORE DEPRAV+ AN 9V5TION IS -- SU* AS ! USE ( MOTORS 9 PLACE ( ANIMALS OR ( ONE'S [N LEGS1 RAILWAYS TO GO UP M\NTA9S1 OR >MOR$ AUTOMOBILES >M$ ) QUICK-FIR+ GUNS -- ! MORE PLEAS$ & PR\D ( !M >E BO? !IR 9V5TORS & !IR POSSESSORS4 ,V,I,I4 ,! LONG] REPRES5TATIVE ,GOV]NM5T LA/$ & ! MORE IT EXT5D$1 ! MORE DID ! ,WE/]N NATIONS AB&ON AGRICULTURE & DEVOTE !IR M5TAL & PHYSICAL P[]S TO MANUFACTUR+ & TRAD+ 9 ORD] TO SUPPLY LUXURIES TO ! WEAL?Y CLASSES1 TO 5ABLE ! NATIONS TO FIE N[ EMPLOY$ 9 AGRICULTURE1 9 ,G]MANY 4#d#e ( ! POPULATION1 9 ,FRANCE ONE-HALF1 & A SIMIL> NUMB] 9 O!R ,/ATES4 ,SO ?AT AT ! PRES5T TIME ! POSITION ( !SE ,/ATES IS SU*1 ?AT EV5 IF !Y C\LD FREE !M4SELVES FROM ! CALAMITY ( PROLET>IANISM1 !Y C\LD NOT SUPPORT !MSELVES 9DEP5D5TLY ( O!R C\NTRIES4 ,ALL !SE NATIONS >E UNABLE TO SUBSI/ BY !IR [N TOIL 2 &1 JU/ AS ! PROLET>IAT >E DEP5D5T ON ! WELL-TO-DO CLASSES1 SO >E !Y COMPLETELY DEP5D5T ON C\NTRIES ?AT SUPPORT !MSELVES & >E ABLE TO SELL !M !IR SURPLUS 3 SU* AS ,9DIA1 ,RUSSIA OR ,AU/RALIA4 ,5GL& SUPPORTS FROM ITS [N L& LESS ?AN A FIF? ( ITS POPULATION 2 & ,G]MANY LESS ?AN HALF1 AS IS ! CASE ) ,FRANCE & ) O!R C\NTRIES 2 & ! CONDITION ( !SE NATIONS BECOMES YE> BY YE> MORE DEP5D5T ON ! FOOD SUPPLI$ FROM ABROAD4 ,9 ORD] TO EXI/1 !SE NATIONS MU/ HAVE REC\RSE TO ! DECEPTIONS & VIOL5CE CALL$ 9 !IR LANGUAGE 0ACQUIR+ M>KETS 0 & 0 ,COLONIAL POLICY 2 0 & !Y ACT ACCORD+LY1 /RIV+ TO ?R[ !IR NETS ( 5SLAVEM5T F>!R & F>!R TO ALL 5DS ( ! E>?1 TO CAT* ?OSE :O >E /ILL LEAD+ RATIONAL LIVES4 ,VY+ ) ONE ANO!R1 !Y 9CREASE !IR >MAM5TS MORE & MORE1 & MORE & MORE CUNN+LY1 UND] V>I\S PRETEXTS1 SEIZE ! L& ( ?OSE :O /ILL LIVE RATIONAL LIVES1 & =CE !SE PEOPLE TO FE$ !M4 ,TILL N[ !Y HAVE BE5 ABLE TO DO ?IS4 ,BUT ! LIMIT TO ! ACQUIREM5T ( M>KETS1 TO ! DECEPTION ( BUY]S1 TO ! SALE ( UNNECESS>Y & 9JURI\S >TICLES1 & TO ! 5SLAVEM5T ( DI/ANT NATIONS1 IS ALREADY APP>5T4 ,! PEOPLES ( DI/ANT L&S >E !MSELVES BECOM+ DEPRAV$ 3 >E LE>N+ TO MAKE = !MSELVES ALL ?OSE >TICLES :I* ! ,WE/]N NATIONS SUPPLI$ !M )1 & >E1 ABOVE ALL1 LE>N+ ! NOT V]Y CUNN+ SCI5CE ( >M+ !MSELVES1 & ( BE+ AS CRUEL AS !IR TEA*]S4 ,SO ?AT ! 5D ( SU* IMMORAL EXI/5CE IS ALREADY 9 SIE]1 COM=T !MSELVES 7AS PEOPLE HALF AW>E ?AT !Y >E RU9+ !IR LIVES ALWAYS DO7 BY SELF-DECEPTION & BL9D FAI? 2 & SU* BL9D FAI? IS SPREAD+ MORE & MORE WIDELY AMONG ! MAJORITY ( ,WE/]N NATIONS4 ,?IS FAI? IS A BELIEF ?AT ?OSE 9V5TIONS & IMPROVEM5TS = 9CREAS+ ! COM=TS ( ! WEAL?Y CLASSES & = FIE SOME?+ V]Y IMPORTANT ATID ALMO/ HOLY1 CALL$1 9 ! LANGUAGE ( ?OSE :O UPHOLD SU* A MODE ( LIFE1 0CULTURE10 OR EV5 MORE GR&LY1 0CIVILIZATION40 ,AS EV]Y CRE$ HAS A SCI5CE ( ,ITS [N1 SO ?IS FAI? 9 0CIVILIZATION0 HAS A SCI5CE -- ,SOCIOLOGY1 ! ONE AIM ( :I* IS TO JU/IFY ! FALSE & DESP]ATE POSITION 9 :I* ! PEOPLE ( ! ,WE/]N WORLD N[ F9D !MSELVES4 ,! OBJECT ( ?IS SCI5CE IS TO PROVE ?AT ALL !SE 9V5TIONS3 IRONCLADS1 TELEGRAPHS1 NITRO- GLYC]9 BONIBS1 PHOTOGRAPHS1 ELECTRIC RAILWAYS1 & ALL SORTS ( SIMIL> FOOLI% & NA/Y 9V5TIONS ?AT /UPEFY ! PEOPLE & >E DESIGN$ TO 9CREASE ! COM=TS ( ! IDLE CLASSES & TO PROTECT !M BY =CE1 NOT ONLY REPRES5T SOME?+ GOOD1 BUT EV5 SOME?+ SACR$1 PR$ET]M9$ BY SUPREME UNALT]ABLE LAWS2 & ?AT1 !RE=E1 ! DEPRAVITY !Y CALL 0 CIVILIZATION 0 IS A NECESS>Y CONDITION ( HUMAN LIFE1 & MU/ 9EVITABLY BE ADOPT$ BY ALL MANK9D4 ,& ?IS FAI? IS JU/ AS BL9D AS ANY O!R FAI?1 & JU/ AS UN%AKABLE & SELF-ASSUR$4 ,ANY O!R POSITION MAY BE DISPUT$ & >GU$ AB\T 2 BUT 0 CIVILIZATION 0 -- MEAN+ ?OSE 9V5TIONS & ?OSE =MS ( LIFE AMONG :I* WE >E LIV+1 & ALL ! FOLLIES & NA/9ESS :I* WE PRODUCE -- IS AN 9DUBITABLE BLESS+1 BEYOND ALL DISCUSSION4 ,EV]Y?+ ?AT DI/URBS FAI? 9 CIVILIZATION IS A LIE2 EV]Y?+ ?AT SUPPORTS ?IS FAI? IS SACR$ TRU?4 ,?IS FAI? & ITS ATT5DANT SCI5CE CAUSE ! ,WE/]N NATIONS NOT TO WI% TO SEE OR TO ACKN[L$GE ?AT ! RU9\S PA? !Y >E FOLL[+ LEADS TO 9EVITABLE DE/RUCTION4 ,! SO-CALL$ 0 MO/ ADVANC$ 0 AMONG !M1 *E] !MSELVES ) ! ?\E = !MSELVES1 M5 79FLU5C$ BY ,SOCIALI/ DOCTR9ES7 WILL SUDD5LY APPE>1 :O WILL WIELD P[] )\T BE+ DEPRAV$ BY IT1 & WILL E/ABLI% AN ORD] ( ?+S 9 :I* PEOPLE ACCU/OM$ TO A GRE$Y1 SELFI% /RUGGLE = !IR [N PR(IT1 WILL SUDD5LY GR[ SELF-SACRIFIC+1 & ALL WORK TOGE!R = ! COMMON GOOD1 & %>E ALIKE4 ,BUT ?IS CRE$1 HAV+ NO REASONABLE F\NDATION1 HAS LATELY MORE & MORE LO/ CR$IBILITY AMONG ?9K+ PEOPLE 2 & IS HELD ONLY BY ! LABOR+ MASSES1 :OSE EYES IT DIV]TS FROM ! MIS]IES ( ! PRES5T1 GIV+ !M SOME SORT ( HOPE ( A BLISSFUL FUTURE4 ,SU* IS ! COMMON FAI? ( ! MAJORITY ( ! ,WE/]N NATIONS1 DRAW+ !M T[>DS DE/RUCTION4 ,& ?IS T5D5CY IS SO /RONG ?AT ! VOICES ( ! WISE AMONG !M1 SU* AS ,R\SSEAU1 ,LAM5NAIS1 ,C>LYLE1 ,RUSK91 ,*ANN+1 ,W4 ,L4 ,G>RISON1 ,EM]SON1 ,H]Z5 & ,$W>D ,C>P5T]1 LEAVE NO TRACE 9 ! CONSCI\SNESS ( ?OSE :O1 ?\< RU%+ T[>DS DE/RUCTION1 DO NOT WI% TO SEE & ADMIT IT4 ,& IT IS TO TRAVEL ?IS PA? ( DE/RUCTION ?AT ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE >E N[ 9VIT$ BY ,EUROPEAN POLITICIANS1 :O >E DELIT ( !IR POPULATION BY P>TICIPATION 9 P[]1 HAVE BE5 L$ TO ! NECESSITY ( SEIZ+ BY =CE OR FRAUD ! FRUITS ( ! LABOR ( ! ,EA/]N NATIONS = !IR [N CONSUMPTION 2 & ?IS BY C]TA9 ME?ODS !Y HAVE DEVIS$ CALL$ 0 CIVILIZATION10 !Y SUCCE$$ 9 DO+ UNTIL ! ,EA/]N NATIONS LE>N$ ! SAME ME?ODS4 ,! ,EA/]N NATIONS1 OR ! MAJORITY ( !M1 /ILL CONT9UE TO OBEY !IR RUL]S1 &1 LAGG+ BEH9D ! ,WE/]N NATIONS 9 DEVIS+ ?+S NE$$ = W>1 W]E =C$ TO SUBMIT TO !M4 ,BUT SOME OT !M >E ALREADY BEG9N+ TO ACQUIRE ! DEPRAVITY OR 0 CIVILIZATION 0 :I* ! ,EUROPEANS >E TEA*+ !M 2 &1 AS ! ,JAPANESE HAVE %[N1 !Y CAN EASILY ASSIMILATE ALL ! %ALL[1 CUNN+ ME?ODS ( AN IMMORAL & CRUEL CIVILIZATION1 & >E PREP>+ TO )/& !IR OPPRESSORS BY ! SAME MEANS ?AT !SE EMPLOY AGA9/ !M4 ,& N[ ! ,RUSSIAN NATION1 /&+ BETWE5 ! TWO -- O HAV+ P>TIALLY ACQUIR$ ,WE/]N ME?ODS1 YET TILL N[ CONT9U+ TO SUBMIT TO ITS ,GOV]NM5T -- IS PLAC$1 BY FATE ITSELF1 9 A POSITION 9 :I* IT MU/ /OP & ?9K 3 SEE+ ON ONE SIDE ! MIS]IES TO :I*1 LIKE ! ,EA/]N NATIONS1 IT HAS BE5 BR\DS P[]1 BUT NOT AS ! ,WE/]N NATIONS HAVE DONE4 ,! ,RUSSIAN NATION N[ /&S1 LIKE ! H]O ( ! FAIRY-TALE1 AT ! P>T+ ( TWO ROADS1 BO? LEAD+ TO DE/RUCTION4 ,IT IS IMPOSSIBLE = ! ,RUSSIAN NATION TO CONT9UE TO SUBMIT TO ITS ,GOV]NM5T4 ,IT IS IMPOSSIBLE1 BECAUSE HAV+ FRE$ ITSELF FRORRI ! PRE/IGE :I* HAS HI!RTO 5VELOP$ ! ,RUSSIAN ,GOV]NM5T1 & HAV+ ONCE UND]/OOD ?AT MO/ ( ! MIS]IES SUFF]$ BY ! PEOPLE >E CAUS$ BY ! ,GOV]NM5T1 ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE CANNOT CEASE TO BE AW>E ( ! CAUSE ( ! CALAMITIES !Y SUFF]1 OR CEASE TO DESIRE TO FREE !MSELVES FROM IT4 ,BESIDES1 ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE CANNOT CONT9UE TO SUBMIT TO ! ,GOV]NM5T1 BECAUSE N[ A ,GOV]NM5T -- SU* A ,GOV]NM5T AS GIVES SECURITY & TRANQUILITY TO A NATION -- NO LONG] EXI/S 9 REALITY4 ,!RE >E TWO 5V5OM$ & CONT5D+ P>TIES1 BUT NO ,GOV]NM5T TO :I* IT IS POSSIBLE QUIETLY TO SUBMIT4 ,= ,RUSSIANS N[ TO CONT9UE TO SUBMIT TO !IR ,GOV]NM5T1 W\LD MEAN TO CONT9UE NOT ONLY TO BE> ! EV]-9CREAS+ CALAMITIES :I* !Y HAVE SUFF]$ & >E SUFF]+ 3 L&-HUNG]1 FAM9E1 HEAVY TAXES1 CRUEL1 USELESS & DEVA/AT+ W>S 2 BUT ALSO & *IEFLY IT W\LD MEAN TAK+ P>T 9 ! CRIMES ?IS ,GOV]NM5T1 9 ITS EVID5TLY USELESS ATTEMPTS AT SELF-DEF5SE1 IS N[ P]PETRAT+4 ,/ILL LESS REASONABLE W\LD IT BE = ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE TO 5T] ON ! PA? ( ! ,WE/]N NATIONS1 S9CE ! DEADL9ESS ( ?AT PA? IS ALREADY PLA9LY DEMON/RAT$4 ,IT W\LD BE EVID5TLY IRRATIONAL = ! ,RUSSIAN NATION TO ACT SO 2 = ?\< IT WAS POSSIBLE = ! ,WE/]N NATIONS1 BE=E !Y KNEW :]E IT W\LD LEAD !M1 TO *OOSE A PA? N[ SE5 TO BE FALSE1 ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE CANNOT HELP SEE+ & KN[+ ITS DANG]4 ,MOREOV]1 :5 !Y 5T]$ ON ?AT PA?1 MO/ ( ! ,WE/]N PEOPLE W]E ALREADY LIV+ BY TRADE1 EX*ANGE & COMM]CE1 OR BY DIRECT 7NEGRO7 OR 9DIRECT SLAVE-[N+ 7AS IS N[ ! CASE 9 ,EUROPE'S ,COLONIES7 :ILE ! ,RUSSIAN NATION IS *IEFLY AGRICULTURAL4 ,= ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE TO 5T] ON ! PA? ALONG :I* ! ,WE/]N]S W5T1 W\LD MEAN CONSCI\SLY TO COMMIT ! SAME ACTS ( VIOL5CE ?AT ! ,GOV]NM5T DEM&S ( IT 7ONLY NOT = ! ,GOV]NM5T1 BUT ' AGA9/ IT7 3 TO ROB1 BURN1 BL[ UP1 MURD]1 & C>RY ON CIVIL W> 2 & TO COMMIT ALL !SE CRIMES KN[+ ?AT IT DOES SO NO LONG] 9 OB$I5CE TO ANO!R'S WILL1 BUT AT ITS [N4 ,& !Y W\LD AT LA/ ATTA9 ONLY :AT HAS BE5 ATTA9$ BY ! ,WE/]N NATIONS AFT] C5TURIES ( /RUGGLE2 !Y W\LD GO ON SUFF]+ ! SAME *IEF ILLS ?AT !Y N[ SUFF] FROM 3 L&-HUNG]1 HEAVY & EV]-9CREAS+ TAXES1 NATIONAL DEBTS1 GR[+ >MAM5TS1 & CRUEL1 /UPID W>S4 ,MORE ?AN ?AT1 !Y W\LD BE DEPRIV$1 LIKE ! ,WE/]N NATIONS1 ( !IR *IEF1 BLESS+ -- !IR ACCU/OM$1 BELOV$1 AGRICULTURAL LIFE1 & W\LD DRIFT 9TO HOPELESS DEP5D5CE ON =EIGN LABOR 2 & ?IS UND] ! MO/ DISADVANTAGE\S CONDITIONS1 C>RY+ ON AN 9DU/RIAL & COMM]CIAL /RUGGLE ) ! ,WE/]N NATIONS1 ) ! C]TA9TY ( BE+ VANQUI%$4 ,DE/RUCTION AWAITS !M ON ?IS PA? & ON ?AT4 ,I,X4 ,:AT1 !N1 IS ! ,RUSSIAN NATION TO DO 8 ,! NATURAL & SIMPLE ANSW]1 ! DIRECT \TCOME ( ! FACTS ( ! CASE1 IS TO FOLL[ NEI!R ?IS PA? NOR ?AT4 ,TO SUBMIT NEI!R TO ! ,GOV]NM5T :I* HAS BR\LY SUIT$ TO ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE AT ALL TIMES1 & ESPECIALLY AT ! PRES5T CRISIS- ,= 9DE$1 IT IS WOND]FUL ?AT A PEASANT HUSB&MAN ( ,TULA1 ,S>AT(1 ,VOLOGDA1 OR ,KH>K( ,PROV9CE1 )\T ANY PR(IT TO HIMSELF1 & SUFF]+ ALL SORTS ( MIS]Y1 SU* AS TAXATION1 LAW-C\RTS1 DEPRIVATION ( L&1 CONSCRIPTION1 ETC41 AS A RESULT ( HIS SUBMISSION TO ,GOV]NM5T1 %\LD TILL N[1 CONTR>Y TO ! DEM&S ( HIS [N CONSCI5CE1 HAVE SUBMITT$1 & %\LD EV5 HAVE AID$ HIS [N 5SLAVEM5T 3 PAY+ TAXES1 )\T KN[+ OR ASK+ H[ !Y W\LD BE SP5T1 GIV+ HIS SONS TO BE SOLDI]S1 KN[+ /ILL LESS = :AT ! SUFF]+S & DEA? ( !SE SO PA9FULLY RE>$ & TO HIM SO NECESS>Y WORK]S1 W]E WANT$4 ,IT W\LD BE JU/ AS /RANGE1 OR EV5 /RANG]1 IF SU* AGRICULTURAL PEASANTS1 LIV+ !IR PEACEFUL1 9DEP5D5T LIFE )\T ANY NE$ ( A ,GOV]NM5T1 & WI%+ TO BE RID ( ! BURD5S !Y 5DURE AT ! H&S ( A VIOL5T & TO !M UNNECESS>Y P[]1 9/EAD ( SIMPLY CEAS+ TO SUBMIT TO IT1 W]E1 BY EMPLOY+ VIOL5CE SIMIL> TO ?AT FROM :I* !Y SUFF]1 TO REPLACE ! OLD =CE-US+ P[] BY A NEW =CE-US+ P[]1 AS ! ,FR5* & ,5GLI% PEASANTS DID 9 !IR TIME4 ,:Y 6 ! ,RUSSIAN AGRICULTURAL POPULATION NE$ ONLY CEASE TO OBEY ANY K9D ( =CE-US+ ,GOV]NM5T & REFUSE TO P>TICIPATE 9 IT1 & IMM$IATELY TAXES1 MILIT>Y S]VICE1 ALL (FICIAL OPPRESSIONS1 AS WELL AS PRIVATE PROP]TY 9 L&1 & ! MIS]Y ( ! WORK+ CLASSES ?AT RESULTS FROM IT1 W\LD CEASE ( !MSELVES4 ,ALL !SE MIS=TUNES W\LD CEASE1 BECAUSE !RE W\LD BE NO ONE TO 9FLICT !M4 ,! HI/ORIC1 ECONOMIC & RELIGI\S CONDITIONS ( ! ,RUSSIAN NATION PLACE IT 9 EXCEPTIONALLY FAVORABLE CIRCUM/ANCES = ACT+ 9 ?IS MANN]4 ,9 ! FIR/ PLACE IT HAS REA*$ ! PO9T AT :I* A *ANGE ( ITS OLD RELATIONS T[>DS ! EXI/+ P[] HAS BECOME 9EVITABLE AFT] ! WRONGFULNESS ( ! PA? TRAVEL$ BY ! ,WE/]N NATIONS 7) :OM IT HAS LONG BE5 9 CLOSE/ CONNECTION7 HAS BECOME FULLY APP>5T4 ,P[] 9 ! ,WE/ HAS COMPLET$ ITS CIRCLE4 ,! ,WE/]N PEOPLES1 LIKE ALL O!RS1 ACCEPT$ A =CE-US+ P[] AT FIR/ 9 ORD] !MSELVES TO ESCAPE FROM ! /RUGGLES1 C>ES1 & S9S ( P[]4 ,:5 ?AT P[] BECAME CORRUPT & BURD5SOME1 !Y TRI$ TO LITICIPAT+ 97 IT4 ,?IS P>TICIPATION1 SPREAD+ \T MORE & MORE WIDELY1 CAUS$ MORE & MORE PEOPLE TO %>E 9 P[] 2 & F9ALLY ! MAJORITY ( ! PEOPLE 7:O AT FIR/ SUBMITT$ TO P[] TO AVOID /RIFE & TO ESCAPE FROM P>TICIPATION 9 P[]7 HAVE HAD TO TAKE P>T BO? 9 /RIFE & 9 P[]1 & HAVE SUFF]$ ! 9EVITABLE ACCOMPANIM5T ( P[] -- CORRUPTION4 ,IT HAS BECOME QUITE CLE> ?AT ! PRET5D$ LIMITATION ( P[] ONLY MEANS *ANG+ ?OSE 9 P[]1 9CREAS+ !IR NUMB]1 & !REBY 9CREAS+ ! AM\NT ( DEPRAVITY1 IRRITATION & ANG] AMONG M54 7,! P[] REMA9S AS IT WAS 3 ! P[] ( A M9ORITY ( ! WORSE M5 OV] A MAJORITY ( ! BETT]47 ,IT HAS ALSO BECOME PLA9 ?AT AN 9CREASE 9 NUMB] ( ?OSE 9 P[] HAS DRAWN PEOPLE FROM ! LABOR ON ! L& NATURAL TO ALL M51 TO FACTORY LABOR = ! PRODUCTION 7& OV]-PRODUCTION7 ( UNNECESS>Y & H>MFUL ?+S1 & HAS OBLIG$ ! MAJORITY ( ,WE/]N NATIONS TO BASE !IR LIVES ON ! DECEPTION & 5- SLAVEM5T ( O!R NATIONS4 ,! FACT ?AT 9 \R DAYS ALL ?IS HAS BECOME QUITE OBVI\S 9 ! LIVES ( ! ,WE/]N NATIONS1 IS ! FIR/ CONDITION FAVORABLE TO ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE1 :O HAVE N[ REA*$ ! MOM5T :5 !Y MU/ *ANGE !IR RELATION T[>DS ,P[]4 ,= ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE TO FOLL[ ! PA? ! ,WE/]N NATIONS HAVE TRODD51 W\LD BE AS ?\< A TRAVEL] FOLL[$ A PA? ON :I* ?OSE :O W5T BE=E HIM HAD LO/ !IR WAY1 & FROM :I* ! MO/ F>-SEE+ ( !M W]E ALREADY RETURN+4 ,SECONDLY 3 :ILE ALL ! ,WE/]N NATIONS HAVE MORE OR LESS AB&ON$ AGRICULTURE & >E LIV+ *IEFLY BY MANUFACTURE & COMM]CE1 ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE HAVE >RIV$ AT ! NECESSITY ( *ANG+ !IR RELATION T[>DS ,P[] :ILE ! IMM5SE MAJORITY ( !M >E /ILL LIV+ AN AGRICULTURAL LIFE1 :I* !Y LOVE & PRIZE SO MU* ?AT MO/ ,RUSSIANS :5 TORN FROM IT1 >E ALWAYS READY TO RETURN TO IT AT ! FIR/ OPPORTUNITY4 ,?IS CONDITION IS OT SPECIAL VALUE = ,RUSSIANS :5 FREE+ !MSELVES FROM ! EVILS ( P[] 2 = :ILE LEAD+ AN AGRICULTURAL LIFE M5 HAVE ! LEA/ NE$ ( ,GOV]NM5T 2 OR RA!R1 AN AGRICULTURAL LIFE1 LESS ?AN ANY O!R1 GIVES A ,GOV]NM5T OPPORTUNITIES ( 9T]F]+ ) ! LIFE ( ! PEOPLE4 ,I KN[ SOME VILLAGE COMMUNES :I* EMIGRAT$ TO ! ,F> ,EA/ & SETTL$ 9 PLACES :]E ! FRONTI] BETWE5 ,*9A & ,RUSSIA WAS NOT CLE>LY DEF9$1 & LIV$ !RE 9 PROSP]ITY1 DISREG>D+ ALL ,GOV]NM5TS1 UNTIL !Y W]E DISCOV]$ BY ,RUSSIAN (FICIALS4 ,T[NSM5 G5]ALLY REG>D AGRICULTURE AS ONE ( ! L[E/ OCCUPATIONS TO :I* MAN CAN DEVOTE HIMSELF ,YET ! 5ORM\S MAJORITY ( ! POPULATION ( ! :OLE WORLD >E 5GAG$ 9 AGRICULTURE1 & ON IT ! POSSIBILITY ( EXI/5CE = ALL ! RE/ ( ! HUMAN RACE DEP5DS4 ,SO ?AT1 9 REALITY1 ! HUMAN RACE IS MADE UP ( HUSB&M54 ,ALL ! RE/-- M9I/]S1 LOCKSMI?S1 PR(ESSORS1 C>P5T]S1 >TI/S1 TAILORS1 SCI5TI/S1 PHYSICIANS1 G5]ALS1 SOLDI]S -- >E BUT ! S]VANTS OR P>ASITES ( ! AGRICULTURI/4 ,SO ?AT AGRICULTURE1 BESIDES BE+ ! MO/ MORAL1 HEAL?Y1 JOYFUL & NECESS>Y OCCUPATION1 IS ALSO ! HIE /ILL LIV+ ?IS MO/ NATURAL1 MORAL & 9DEP5D5T AGRICULTURAL LIFE 2 & ?IS IS ! SECOND1 MO/ IMPORTANT1 CIRCUM/ANCE1 :I* MAKES IT POSSIBLE & NATURAL = ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE1 N[ ?AT IT IS FAC$ BY ! NECESSITY ( *ANG+ ITS RELATIONS T[>DS P[]1 TO *ANGE !M 9 NO O!R WAY ?AN BY FREE+ !MSELVES FROM ! EVIL ( ALL P[]1 & SIMPLY CEAS+ TO SUBMIT TO ANY K9D ( ,GOV]NM5T4 ,!SE >E ! FIR/ TWO CONDITIONS1 BO? ( :I* >E EXT]NAL4 ,! ?IRD CONDITION1 AN 9N] ONE1 IS ! RELIGI\S FEEL+ :I* ACCORD+ TO ! EVID5CE ( HI/ORY1 ! OBS]VATION ( =EIGN]S :O HAVE /UDI$ ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE1 & ESPECIALLY ! 9N] CONSCI\SNESS ( EV]Y ,RUSSIAN1 WAS & IS A SPECIAL *>ACT]I/IC ( ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE4 ,9 ,WE/]N ,EUROPE -- EI!R BECAUSE ! ,GOSPELS PR9T$ 9 ,LAT9 W]E 9ACCESSIBLE TO ! PEOPLE TILL ! TIME ( ! ,RE=MATION1 & HAVE REMA9$ TILL N[ 9ACCESSIBLE TO ! :OLE ,ROMAN ,CA?OLIC WORLD1 OR BECAUSE ( ! REF9$ ME?ODS :I* ! ,PAPACY EMPLOYS TO HIDE TRUE ,*RI/IANITY FROM ! PEOPLE1 OR 9 CONSEQU5CE ( ! SPECIALLY PRACTICAL *>ACT] ( ?OSE NATIONS -- !RE IS NO D\BT ?AT ! ESS5CE ( ,*RI/IANITY1 NOT ONLY AMONG ,ROMAN ,CA?OLICS BUT ALSO AMONG ,LU!RANS1 & EV5 MORE 9 ! ,ANGLICAN ,*UR*1 HAS LONG CEAS$ TO BE A FAI? DIRECT+ PEOPLE'S LIVES1 & HAS BE5 REPLAC$ BY EXT]NAL =MS1 OR AMONG ! HI<] CLASSES BY 9DIFF]5CE & ! REJECTION ( ALL RELIGION4 ,= ! VA/ MAJORITY ( ,RUSSIANS1 H[EV] -- P]HAPS BECAUSE ! ,GOSPELS BECAME ACCESSIBLE TO !M AS E>LY AS ! T5? C5TURY1 OR BECAUSE ( ! CO>SE /UPIDITY ( ! ,RUSSO-,GREEK ,*UR*1 :I* TRI$ CLUMSILY & !RE=E VA9LY TO HIDE ! TRUE MEAN+ ( ! ,*RI/IAN TEA*+1 OR BECAUSE ( SOME PECULI> TRAIT 9 ! ,RUSSIAN *>ACT]1 & BECAUSE ( !IR AGRICULTURAL LIFE-- ,*RI/IAN TEA*+ 9 ITS PRACTICAL APPLICATION HAS NEV] CEAS$ TO BE1 & /ILL CONT9UES TO BE1 ! *IEF GUIDE ( LIFE4 ,FROM ! E>LIE/ TIMES TILL N[1 ! ,*RI/IAN UND]/&+ ( LIFE HAS MANIFE/$1 & /ILL MANIFE/S1 ITSELF AMONG ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE 9 MO/ V>I\S TRAITS1 PECULI> TO !M ALONE4 ,IT %[S ITSELF 9 !IR ACKN[L$GM5T ( ! BRO!RHOOD & EQUALITY ( ALL M51 ( :ATEV] RACE OR NATIONALITY 2 9 !IR COMPLETE RELIGI\S TOL]ATION 2 9 !IR NOT CONDEMN+ CRIM9ALS1 BUT REG>D+ !M AS UN=TUNATE2 9 ! CU/OM ( BEGG+ ONE ANO!R'S =GIV5ESS ON C]TA9 DAYS 2 & EV5 9 ! HABITUAL USE ( A =M ( ! WORD "9 =GIVE ' :5 TAK+ LEAVE ( ANYBODY 2 9 ! HABIT NOT M]ELY ( *>ITY T[>DS1 BUT EV5 ( RESPECT = BEGG>S :I* IS COMMON AMONG ! PEOPLE2 9 ! P]FECT READ9ESS 7SOMETIMES CO>SELY %[N7 = SELF-SACRIFICE = ANY?+ BELIEV$ TO BE RELIGI\S TRU?1 :I* WAS %[N & /ILL IS %[N BY ?OSE :O BURN !MSELVES TO DEA?1 OR CA/RATE !MSELVES1 & EV5 7AS 9 A REC5T CASE7 BY ?OSE :O BURY !MSELVES ALIVE4 ,! SAME ,*RI/IAN \TLOOK ALWAYS APPE>$ 9 ! RELATION ( ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE T[>DS ?OSE 9 P[]4 ,! PEOPLE ALWAYS PREF]R$ TO SUBMIT TO P[]1 RA!R ?AN TO %>E 9 IT4 ,!Y CONSID]$1 & CONSID]1 ! POSITION ( RUL]S TO BE S9FUL & NOT AT ALL DESIRABLE4 ,?IS ,*RI/IAN RELATION ( ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE T[>DS LIFE G5]ALLY1 & ESPECIALLY T[>DS ?OSE 9 P[]1 IS ! ?IRD & MO/ IMPORTANT CONDITION :I* MAKES IT MO/ SIMPLE & NATURAL = !M AT ! PRES5T JUNCTURE TO GO ON LIV+ !IR CU/OM>Y1 AGRICULTURAL4 ,*RI/IAN LIFE1 )\T TAK+ ANY P>T EI!R 9 ! OLD P[]1 OR 9 ! /RUGGLE BETWE5 ! OLD & ! NEW4 ,SU* >E ! ?REE CONDITIONS1 DIFF]5T TO ?OSE ( ! ,WE/]N NATIONS1 9 :I* ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE F9D !MSELVES PLAC$ AT ! PRES5T IMPORTANT TIME4 ,!SE CONDITIONS1 IT W\LD SEEM1 \Y VIOL5CE1 BEG9 79 ! P]SONS ( !IR WOR/ REPRES5TATIVES7 TO TAKE P>T 9 ! VIOL5CE1 & SEEM TO BE PREP>+ TO FOLL[ ! ROAD TO DE/RUCTION ALONG :I* ! ,WE/]N NATIONS HAVE TRAVEL$4 ,:Y IS ?IS SO 8 ,X4 ,:AT HAS CAUS$1 & /ILL CAUSES1 ?IS SURPRIS+ PH5OM5ON ?AT PEOPLE SUFF]+ FROM ! ABUSE ( P[] :I* !Y !MSELVES TOL]ATE & SUPPORT1 DO NOT FREE !MSELVES 9 ! MO/ SIMPLE & EASY WAY FROM ALL ! DISA/]S BR\ =CE-US+ P[]1 & OBEY ?AT8 ,:Y IS ?IS SO8 ,PEOPLE FEEL ?AT !IR UNHAPPY POSITION IS ! RESULT ( VIOL5CE1 & >E DIMLY AW>E ?AT TO GET RID ( !IR MIS]Y !Y NE$ FRE$OM 2 BUT1 /RANGE TO SAY1 TO GET RID ( VIOL5CE & GA9 FRE$OM1 !Y SEEK1 9V5T & USE ALL SORTS ( MEASURES3 MUT9Y1 *ANGE ( RUL]S1 ALT]ATIONS ( ,GOV]NM5T ALL K9DS ( ,CON/ITUTIONS1 NEW >RANGEM5TS BETWE5 DIFF]5T ,/ATES1 ,COLONIAL POLICIES1 5ROLLM5T ( ! UNEMPLOY$1 TRU/S1 SOCIAL ORGANIZATIONS -- EV]Y?+ BUT ! ONE ?+ ?AT W\LD MO/ SIMPLY1 EASILY1 & SURELY FREE !M FROM ALL !IR DI/RESSES 3 ! REFUSAL TO SUBMIT TO P[]4 ,ONE MI TO PEOPLE NOT DEPRIV$ ( REASON1 ?AT VIOL5CE BRE$S VIOL5CE 2 ?AT ! ONLY MEANS ( DELIV]ANCE FROM VIOL5CE LIES 9 NOT TAK+ P>T 9 IT4 ,?IS ME?OD1 ONE W\LD ?9K1 IS QUITE OBVI\S4 ,IT IS EVID5T ?AT A GREAT MAJORITY ( M5 CAN BE 5SLAV$ BY A SMALL M9ORITY ONLY IF ! 5SLAV$ !MSELVES TAKE P>T 9 !IR [N 5SLAVEM5T4 ,IF PEOPLE >E 5SLAV$1 IT IS ONLY BECAUSE !Y EI!R FITICIPATE 9 VIOL5CE = !IR [N P]SONAL PR(IT4 ,?OSE :O NEI!R /RUGGLE AGA9/ VIOL5CE NOR TAKE P>T 9 IT CAN NO MORE BE 5SLAV$ ?AN WAT] CAN BE CUT4 ,!Y CAN BE ROBB$1 PREV5T$ FROM MOV+ AB\T1 W\ND$ OR KILL$1 BUT !Y CANNOT BE 5SLAV$ 3 ?AT IS1 MADE TO ACT AGA9/ !IR [N REASONABLE WILL4 ,?IS IS TRUE BO? ( 9DIVIDUALS & ( NATIONS4 ,IF ! #b11 ,H9DOOS DID NOT SUBMIT TO ! ,P[] :I* DEM&S !IR P>TICIPATION 9 DE$S ( VIOL5CE1 ALWAYS CONNECT$ ) ! TAK+ ( HUMAN LIFE 3 IF !Y DID NOT 5LI/1 PAID NO TAXES TO BE US$ = VIOL5CE1 W]E NOT TEMPT$ BY REW>DS (F]$ BY ! CONQU]ORS 7REW>DS ORIG9ALLY TAK5 FROM !MSELVES7 & DID NOT SUBMIT TO ! ,5GLI% LAWS 9TRODUC$ AMONG !M1 !N NEI!R #e1 ,5GLI%M51 NOR ALL ! ,5GLI% 9 ! WORLD1 C\LD 5?RALL$ ,9DIA1 EV5 IF 9/EAD ( #b11 !RE W]E BUT #a1 ,H9DOOS4 ,SO IT IS 9 ! CASES ( ,POLES1 ,CZE*S1 ,IRI%1 ,B$\9S1 & ALL ! CONQU]$ RACES4 ,& IT IS ! SAME 9 ! CASE ( ! WORKM5 5SLAV$ BY ! CAPITALI/S4 ,NOT ALL ! CAPITALI/S 9 ! WORLD C\LD 5?RALL$ ! WORK]S IF ! WORKM5 !MSELVES DID NOT HELP1 & DID NOT TAKE P>T 9 !IR [N 5SLAVEM5T ,ALL ?IS IS SO EVID5T ?AT ONE IS A%AM$ TO M5TION IT4 ,& YET PEOPLE :O DISCUSS ALL O!R CONDITIONS ( LIFE REASONABLY1 NOT ONLY DO NOT SEE & DO NOT ACT AS REASON DICTATES 9 ?IS MATT]1 BUT ACT QUITE CONTR>Y TO REASON & TO !IR [N ADVANTAGE4 ,EA* ONE SAYS1 0 ,I CAN'T BE ! FIR/ TO DO :AT NOBODY ELSE DOES4 ,LET O!RS BEG91 & !N ,I TOO WILL CEASE TO SUBMIT TO P[]40 ,& SO SAYS A SECOND1 A ?IRD1 & EV]YBODY4 ,ALL1 UND] ! PRET5SE ?AT NO ONE CAN BEG91 9/EAD ( ACT+ 9 A MANN] UNQUE/IONABLY ADVANTAGE\S TO ALL1 CONT9UE TO DO :AT IS DISADVANTAGE\S TO EV]YBODY1 & IS ALSO IRRATIONAL & CONTR>Y TO HUMAN NATURE4 ,NO ONE LIKES TO CEASE SUBMITT+ TO P[]1 LE/ HE %\LD BE P]SECUT$ BY P[] 2 YET HE WELL KN[S ?AT OBEY+ P[] MEANS BE+ SUBJECT TO ALL SORTS ( ! GRAVE/ CALAMITIES 9 W>S =EIGN OR CIVIL4 ,:AT IS ! CAUSE ( ?IS 8 ,! CAUSE ( IT IS1 ?AT PEOPLE :5 YIELD+ TO P[] DO NOT REASON1 BUT ACT UND] ! 9FLU5CE ( SOME?+ ?AT HAS ALWAYS BE5 ONE ( ! MO/ WIDESPREAD MOTIVES ( HUMAN ACTION1 & HAS LATELY BE5 MO/ C>EFULLY /UDI$ & EXPLA9$ 2 IT IS CALL$ 0SUGGE/ION0 OR HYPNOTISM4 ,?IS HYPNOTISM1 PREV5T+ PEOPLE FROM ACT+ 9 ACCORDANCE ) !IR REASONABLE NATURE & !IR [N 9T]E/1 & =C+ !M TO DO :AT IS UNREASONABLE & DISADVANTAGE\S1 CAUSES !M TO BELIEVE ?AT ! VIOL5CE P]PE- TRAT$ BY PEOPLE CALL+ !MSELVES 0 ! ,GOV]NM5T 0 IS NOT SIMPLY ! IMMORAL CONDUCT ( IMMORAL M51 BUT IS ! ACTION ( SOME MY/]I\S1 SACR$ ,BE+1 CALL$ ! ,/ATE1 )\T :I* M5 NEV] HAVE EXI/$ 7:I* IS QUITE UNTRUE7 & NEV] CAN EXI/4 ,BUT H[ CAN REASONABLE BE+S1 M51 SUBMIT TO SU* A SURPRIS+ SUGGE/ION1 CONTR>Y TO REASON1 FEEL+1 & TO !IR [N 9T]E/ 8 ,! ANSW] TO ?IS QUE/ION IS1 ?AT NOT ONLY DO *ILDR51 ! M5TALLY DISEAS$ & IDIOTS1 SUCCUMB TO HYPNOTIC 9FLU5CE & SUGGE/ION1 BUT ALL P]SONS1 TO ! EXT5T TO :I* !IR RELIGI\S CONSCI\SNESS IS WEAK5$ 3 !IR CONSCI\SNESS ( !IR RELATION TO ! ,SUPREME ,CAUSE ON :I* !IR EXI/5CE DEP5DS4 ,& ! MAJORITY ( ! PEOPLE ( \R TIMES MORE & M"9ORE LACK ?IS CONSCI\SNESS4 ,! REASON ?AT MO/ PEOPLE ( \R TIME LACK ?IS CONSCI\SNESS IS ?AT HAV+ ONCE COMMITT$ ! S9 ( SUBMITT+ TO HUMAN P[]1 & NOT ACKN[L$G+ ?IS S9 TO BE A S91 BUT TRY+ TO HIDE IT FROM !MSELVES1 OR TO JU/IFY IT1 !Y HAVE EXALT$ ! P[] TO :I* !Y SUBMIT TO SU* AN EXT5T ?AT IT HAS REPLAC$ ,GOD'S LAW = !M4 ,:5 HUMAN LAW REPLAC$ DIV9E LAW1 M5 LO/ RELIGI\S CONSCI\SNESS & FELL UND] ! GOV]NM5TAL HYPNOTISM1 :I* SUGGE/S TO !M ! ILLUSION ?AT ?OSE :O 5?RALL$ !M >E NOT SIMPLY LO/1 VICI\S M51 BUT FIRE REPRES5TATIVES ( ?AT MY/IC ,BE+1 ! ,/ATE1 )\T :I* IT IS SUPPOS$ ?AT M5 >E UNABLE TO EXI/4 ,! VICI\S CIRCLE HAS BE5 COMPLET$ 2 SUBMISSION TO ,P[] HAS WEAK5$1 & P>TLY DE/ROY$1 ! RELIGI\S FEEL+ 9 M5 2 & ! WEAK5+ & CESSATION ( RELIGI\S CONSCI\SNESS HAS SUBJECT$ !M TO HUMAN P[]4 ,! S9 ( ,P[] BEGAN LIKE ?IS 3 ,! OPPRESSORS SAID TO ! OPPRESS$1 0,FULFILL :AT WE DEM& ( Y\2 IF Y\ DISOBEY1 WC WILL KILL Y\4 ,BUT IF Y\ SUBMIT TO US1 WE WILL 9TRODUCE ORD] & WILL PROTECT Y\ FROM O!R OPPRESSORS40 ,& ! OPPRESS$1 9 ORD] TO LIVE !IR ACCU/OM$ LIVES1 & NOT TO HAVE TO FIRI$ AWAY BY ! ATTRACTIONS & ADVANTAGES ( ,P[]4 ,! OPPRESS$ ?\D%IPS1 TAXATIONS & CRUELTIES )\T ACKN[L$G+ ! AU?ORITY ( ! OPPRESSORS TO BE LAWFUL1 & )\T PROMIS+ TO OBEY IT1 !Y W\LD NOT HAVE S9N$4 ,BUT 9 ! PROMISE TO SUBMIT TO P[] LAY A S9 7A FIAPR LA1 ]ROR1 S97 EQUAL TO ?AT ( ! WIELD]S ( P[]4 ,9 PROMIS+ TO SUBMIT TO A =CE-US+ P[]1 & 9 RECOGNIZ+ IT AS LAWFUL1 !RE LAY A D\BLE S94 ,FIR/1 ?AT 9 TRY+ TO FREE !M4SELVES FROM ! S9 ( FITICIPATION 9 KILL+ M51 9 W>S1 EXECUTIONS & 9 LAWS SANCTION+ PREP>ATIONS = W>S & EXECUTIONS1 IS BAS$ ON A DIRECT CONTRADICTION TO ,GOD'S WILL4 ,!RE=E ?OSE :O SUBMIT TO P[] !REBY R5\NCE !IR SUBMISSION TO ! LAW ( ,GOD4 ,ONE CANNOT YIELD A LITTLE ON ONE PO9T1 & ON ANO!R MA9TA9 ! LAW ( ,GOD4 ,IT IS EVID5T ?AT IF 9 ONE ?+ ,GOD'S LAW CAN BE REPLAC$ BY HUMAN LAW1 !N ,GOD'S LAW IS NO LONG] ! HIE !IR P]SONAL PASSIONS & ! HYPNOTISM TO :I* !Y >E SUBJECT4 ,UND] SU* AN HYPNOTIC SUGGE/ION ( ! NECESSITY ( OB$I5CE TO ,GOV]NM5T1 LIE ALL ! NATIONS ?AT LIVE 9 ! UNIONS CALL$ ,/ATES 2 & ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE >E 9 ! SAME CONDITION4 ,?IS IS ! CAUSE ( ?AT APP>5TLY /RANGE PH5OM5ON1 ?AT A HUNDR$ MILLIONS ( ,RUSSIAN CULTIVATORS ( ! SOIL1 NE$+ NO K9D ( GOV]NM5T1 & CON/ITUT+ SO L>GE A MAJORITY ?AT !Y MAY BE CALL$ ! :OLE ,RUSSIAN NATION1 DO NOT *OOSE ! MO/ NATURAL & BE/ WAY \T ( !IR PRES5T CONDITION 7BY SIMPLY CEAS+ TO SUBMIT TO ANY =CE-US+ P[]7 BUT CONT9UE TO TAKE P>T 9 ! OLD ,GOV]NM5T & 5?RALL$ !MSELVES MORE & MORE 2 OR1 FIE = !MSELVES A NEW ONE :I*1 LIKE ! OLD ONE1 WILL EMPLOY VIOL5CE4 ,X,I4 ,WE (T5 READ & HE> DISCUSSIONS AS TO ! CAUSES ( ! PRES5T EXCIT$1 RE/LESS CONDITION ( ALL ! ,*RI/IAN NATIONS1 ?REAT5$ BY ALL SORTS ( DANG]S 2 & ( ! T]RIBLE POSITION 9 :I* ! DEM5T$1 & 9 P>T BRUTALIZ$1 ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE F9D !MSELVES AT PRES5T4 ,! MO/ V>I$ EXPLANATIONS >E BR\D 2 YET ALL ! REASONS CAN BE R$UC$ TO ONE4 ,M5 HAVE =GOTT5 ,GOD1 ?AT IS TO SAY1 !Y HAVE =GOTT5 !IR RELATIONS TO ! 9F9ITE ,S\RCE ( ,LIFE1 =GOTT5 ! MEAN+ ( LIFE :I* IS ! \TCOME ( ?OSE RELATIONS1 & :I* CONSI/S1 FIR/ ( ALL1 9 FULFILL+1 = ONE'S [N S\L'S SAKE1 ! LAW GIV5 BY ?IS ,DIV9E ,S\RCE4 ,!Y HAVE =GOTT5 ?IS1 BECAUSE SOME ( !M HAVE ASSUM$ A RITICIPATE 9 !IR RULE4 ,BY ! V]Y ACT ( SUBMITT+1 !SE M5 HAVE D5I$ ,GOD & EX*ANG$ ,HIS LAW = HUMAN LAW4 ,=GETT+ !IR RELATION TO ! ,9F9ITE1 ! MAJORITY ( M5 HAVE DESC5D$1 9 SPITE ( ALL ! SUBTLETY ( !IR M5TAL A*IEVEM5TS1 TO ! L[E/ GRADE ( CONSCI\SNESS1 :]E !Y >E GUID$ ONLY BY ANIMAL PASSIONS & BY ! HYPNOTISM ( ! H]D4 ,?AT IS ! CAUSE ( ALL !IR CALAMITIES4 ,!RE=E !RE IS BUT ONE ESCAPE FROM ! MIS]IES ) :I* PEOPLE TORM5T !MSELVES 3 IT LIES 9 REE/ABLI%+ 9 !MSELVES A CONSCI\SNESS ( !IR DEP5D5CE ON ,GOD1 & !REBY REGA9+ A REASONABLE & FREE RELATION T[>DS !MSELVES & T[>DS !IR FELL[S4 ,& SO IT IS JU/ ?IS CONSCI\S SUBMISSION TO ,GOD1 & ! CONSEQU5T AB&ONM5T ( ! S9 ( P[] & ( SUBMISSION TO IT1 ?AT N[ /&S BE=E ALL NATIONS ?AT SUFF] FROM ! CONSEQU5CE ( ?IS S94 ,! POSSIBILITY & NECESSITY ( CEAS+ TO SUBMIT TO HUMAN P[] & ( RETURN+ TO ! LAWS ( ,GOD1 IS DIMLY FELT BY ALL M51 & ESPECIALLY VIVIDLY BY ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE JU/ N[4 ,& 9 ?IS DIM CONSCI\SNESS ( ! POSSIBILITY & NECESSITY ( REE/ABLI%+ !IR OB$I5CE TO ! LAW ( ,GOD & CEAS+ TO OBEY HUMAN P[]1 LIES ! ESS5CE ( ! MOVEM5T N[ TAK+ PLACE 9 ,RUSSIA4 ,:AT IS HAPP5+ 9 ,RUSSIA IS -- NOT1 AS MANY PEOPLE SUPPOSE A REBELLION ( ! PEOPLE AGA9/ !IR ,GOV]NM5T 9 ORD] TO REPLACE ONE ,GOV]NM5T BY ANO!R 2 BUT A MU* GREAT] & MORE IMPORTANT EV5T4 ,:AT N[ MOVES ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE IS A DIM RECOGNITION ( ! WRONGNESS & UNREASONABL5ESS ( ALL VIOL5CE1 & ( ! POSSIBILITY & NECESSITY ( BAS+ ONE'S LIFE NOT ON CO]CIVE P[]1 AS HAS BE5 ! CASE HI!RTO AMONG ALL NATIONS1 BUT ON REASONABLE & FREE AGREEM5T4 ,:E!R ! ,RUSSIAN NATION WILL ACCOMPLI% ! GREAT TASK N[ BE=E IT 7! TASK ( LIB]AT+ M5 FROM HUMAN P[] SUB/ITUT$ = ! WILL ( ,GOD7 OR :E!R1 FOLL[+ ! PA? ( ! ,WE/]N NATIONS1 IT WILL LOSE ITS OPPORTUNITY & LEAVE TO SOME O!R HAPPI] ,EA/]N RACE ! LEAD]%IP 9 ! GREAT WORK ?AT LIES BE=E HUMANITY1 !RE IS NO D\BT ?AT AT ! PRES5T DAY ALL NATIONS >E BECOM+ MORE & MORE CONSCI\S ( ! POSSIBILITY ( *ANG+ ?IS VIOL5T1 9SANE & WICK$ LIFE1 = ONE ?AT %ALL BE FREE1 RATIONAL & GOOD4 ,& :AT ALREADY EXI/S 9 M5'S CONSCI\SNESS WILL 9EVITABLY ACCOMPLI% ITSELF 9 REAL LIFE4 ,= ! WILL ( ,GOD MU/ BE1 & CANNOT FAIL TO BE1 REALIZ$4 ,X,I,I4 0 ,BUT IS SOCIAL LIFE POSSIBLE )\T P[] 8 ,)\T P[] M5 W\LD BE CONT9UALLY ROBB+ & KILL+ ONE ANO!R1 0 SAY ?OSE :O BELIEVE ONLY 9 HUMAN LAW4 ,PEOPLE ( ?IS SORT >E S9C]ELY CONV9C$ ?AT M5 REFRA9 FROM CRIME & LIVE ORD]LY LIVES1 ONLY BECAUSE ( LAWS1 C\RTS ( JU/ICE1 POLICE1 (FICIALS1 & >MIES 2 & ?AT )\T GOV]NM5TAL P[] SOCIAL LIFE W\LD BECOME IMPOSSIBLE4 ,M5 DEPRAV$ BY P[] FANCY ?AT AS SOME ( ! CRIMES COMMITT$ 9 ! ,/ATE >E PUNI%$ BY ! ,GOV]NM5T1 IT IS ?IS PUNI%M5T ?AT PREV5TS M5 FROM COMMITT+ O!R POSSIBLE CRIMES4 ,BUT ! FACT ?AT ,GOV]NM5T PUNI%ES SOME CRIMES DOES NOT AT ALL PROVE ?AT ! EXI/5CE ( LAW-C\RTS1 POLICE1 >MIES1 PRISONS & DEA?-P5ALTIES1 HOLDS M5 BACK FROM ALL ! CRIMES !Y MILY PROV$ BY ! FACT ?AT :5 SOCIETY IS 9 A C]TA9 MOOD1 NO 9CREASE ( PUNITIVE MEASURES BY ,GOV]NM5T IS ABLE TO PREV5T ! P]PETRATION ( MO/ D>+ & CRUEL CRIMES1 IMP]IL+ ! SAFETY ( ! COMMUNITY1 AS HAS BE5 ! CASE 9 EV]Y ,REVOLUTION1 & AS IS N[ ! CASE 9 ,RUSSIA TO A MO/ /RIK+ DEGREE4 ,! CAUSE ( ?IS IS ?AT M51 ! MAJORITY ( M5 7ALL ! LABOR+ FOLK7 AB/A9 FROM CRIMES & LIVE GOOD LIVES -- NOT BECAUSE !RE >E POLICE1 >MIES & EXECUTIONS1 BUT BECAUSE !RE IS A MORAL P]CEPTION1 COMMON TO ! BULK ( MANK9D1 E/ABLI%$ BY !IR COMMON RELIGI\S UND]/&+ & BY ! $UCATION1 CU/OMS & PUBLIC OP9ION1 F\ND$ ON ?AT UND]/&+4 ,?IS MORAL CONCI\SNESS ALONE1 EXPRESS$ 9 PUBLIC OP9ION1 KEEPS M5 FROM CRIMES1 BO? 9 T[N C5T]S & MORE ESPECIALLY 9 VILLAGES1 :]E ! MAJORITY ( ! POPULATION DWELL4 ,I REPEAT1 ?AT ,I KN[ MANY EXAMPLES ( ,RUSSIAN AGRICULTURAL COMMUNITIES EMIGRAT+ TO ! ,F> ,EA/ & PROSP]+ !RE = SEV]AL DECADES4 ,!SE COMMUNES GOV]N$ !MSELVES1 BE+ UNKN[N TO ! ,GOV]NM5T & \TSIDE ITS CONTROL1 & :5 !Y W]E DISCOV]$ BY ,GOV]NM5T AG5TS1 ! ONLY RESULT WAS ?AT !Y EXP]I5C$ CALAMITIES UNKN[N TO !M BE=E1 & RECEIV$ A NEW T5D5CY T[>DS ! COMMISSION ( CRIME4 ,NOT ONLY DOES ! ACTION ( ,GOV]NM5TS NOT DET] M5 FROM CRIMES2 ON ! CONTR>Y1 IT 9CREASES CRIME BY ALWAYS DI/URB+ & L[]+ ! MORAL /&>D ( SOCIETY4 ,NOR CAN ?IS BE O!RWISE1 S9CE ALWAYS & EV]Y:]E A ,GOV]NM5T1 BY ITS V]Y NATURE1 MU/ PUT 9 ! PLACE ( ! HITS ( M51 & B9D+ ON EV]Y ONE7 ITS [N UNJU/1 MAN-MADE LAWS1 ! OBJECT ( :I* IS NEI!R JU/ICE NOR ! COMMON GOOD ( ALL BUT V>I\S CONSID]ATIONS ( HOME & =EIGN EXP$I5CY4 ,SU* >E ALL ! EXI/+1 EVID5TLY UNJU/1 FUNDAM5TAL LAWS ( EV]Y ,GOV]NM5T 3 LAWS MA9TA9+ ! EXCLUSIVE RI2 LAWS E/ABLI%+ MONOPOLIES 9 ! SALE ( /UPEFY+ 9TOXICANTS1 OR =BIDD+ ! FREE EX*ANGE ( PRODUCE ACROSS A C]TA9 L9E CALL$ A FRONTI] 2 & LAWS REG>D+ ! EXECUTION ( M5 = ACTIONS :I* >E NOT SO MU* IMMORAL1 AS SIMPLY DISADVANTAGE\S TO ?OSE 9 P[]4 ,ALL !SE LAWS1 & ! EXACTION ( !IR FULFILLM5T BY ?REATS ( VIOL5CE1 ! PUBLIC EXECUTIONS 9FLICT$ = ! NON-FULFILLM5T ( !SE LAWS1 & ABOVE ALL ! =C+ ( M5 TO TAKE P>T 9 W>S1 ! HABITUAL EXALTATION ( MILIT>Y MURD]S1 & ! PREP>ATION = !M -- ALL ?IS 9EVITABLY L[]S ! MORAL SOCIAL CONCI\SNESSS & ITS EXPRESSION1 PUBLIC OP9ION4 ,SO ?AT ,GOV]NM5TAL ACTIVITY NOT ONLY DOES NOT SUPPORT MORALITY1 BUT1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 IT W\LD BE H>D TO DEVISE A MORE DEPRAV+ ACTION ?AN ?AT :I* ,GOV]NM5TS HAVE HAD1 & /ILL HAVE1 ON ! NATIONS4 ,IT C\LD NEV] 5T] ! HEAD ( ANY ORD9>Y SC\NDREL TO COMMIT ALL ?OSE HORRORS 2 ! /AKE1 ! ,9QUISITION1 TORTURE1 RAIDS1 QU>T]+S1 HANG+S1 SOLIT>Y CONF9EM5TS1 MURD]S 9 W>1 ! PLUND]+ ( NATIONS1 ETC41 :I* HAVE BE5 & /ILL >E BE+ COMMITT$1 & COMMITT$ O/5TATI\SLY1 BY ALL ,GOV]NM5TS4 ,ALL ! HORRORS ( ,/5KA ,RAZ91 ,P\GAT*EF.<#b.> & O!R REBELS1 W]E BUT RESULTS1 & FEEBLE IMITATIONS1 ( ! HORRORS P]PETRAT$ BY ! ,JOHNS1 ,PET]S1 & ,BIRONS1.<#c.> & ?AT HAVE BE5 & >E BE+ P]PE- RAT$ BY ALL ,GOV]NM5TS4 ,IF 7:I* IS V]Y D\BTFUL7 ! ACTION (1 ,GOV]NM5T DOES DET] SOME DOZ5S ( M5 FROM CRIME1 HUNDR$S ( ?\S&S ( O!R CRIMES >E COMMITT$ ONLY BECAUSE M5 >E $UCAT$ 9 CRIME BY ,GOV]NM5TAL 9JU/ICE & CRUELTY4 ,IF M5 TAK+ P>T 9 LEGISLATION1 9 COMM]CE1 9 9DU/RIES1 LIV+ 9 T[NS1 & 9 ONE WAY OR O!R %>+ ! ADVANTAGES ( P[]1 CAN /ILL BELIEVE 9 ! B5EFIC5CE ( ?AT P[]1 PEOPLE LIV+ ON ! L& CANNOT HELP KN[+ ?AT ,GOV]NM5T ONLY CAUSES !M ALL K9DS ( SUFF]+ & DEPRIVATION1 WAS NEV] NE$$ BY !M & ONLY CORRUPTS ?OSE ( !M :O COME UND] ITS 9FLU5CE4 ,SO ?AT TO TRY TO PROVE TO M5 ?AT !Y CANNOT LIVE )\T A ,GOV]NM5T1 & ?AT ! 9JURY ! ?IEVES & ROBB]S AMONG !M MAY DO IS GREAT] ?AN ! 9JURY BO? MAT]IAL & SPIRITUAL :I* ,GOV]NM5T CONT9UALLY DOES BY OPPRESS+ & CORRUPT+ !M1 IS AS /RANGE AS IT W\LD HAVE BE5 TO TRY TO PROVE TO SLAVES ?AT IT WAS MORE PR(ITABLE = !M TO BE SLAVES ?AN TO BE FREE1 ,BUT JU/ AS1 9 ! DAYS ( SLAV]Y1 9 SPITE ( ! OBVI\SLY WRET*$ CONDITION ! SLAVES W]E 91 ! SLAVE-[N]S DECL>$ & CREAT$ A BELIEF ?AT IT WAS GOOD = SLAVES TO BE SLAVES1 & ?AT !Y W\LD BE WORSE (F IF !Y W]E FREE 7SOMETIMES ! SLAVES !MSELVES BECAME HYPNOTIZ$ & BELIEV$ ?IS7 SO N[ ! ,GOV]NM5T1 & PEOPLE :O PR(IT BY IT1 >GUE ?AT ,GOV]NM5TS :I* ROB & DEPRAVE M5 >E NECESS>Y = !IR WELL-BE+1 & M5 YIELD TO ?IS SUGGE/ION4 ,M5 BELIEVE 9 IT ALL1 & MU/ CONT9UE TO DO SO 2 = NOT BELIEV+ 9 ! LAW ( ,GOD1 !Y MU/ PUT !IR FAI? 9 HUMAN LAW4 ,ABS5CE ( HUMAN LAW = !M MEANS ! ABS5CE ( ALL LAW 2 & LIFE = M5 :O RECOGNIZE NO LAW1 IS T]RIBLE4 ,!RE=E1 = ?OSE :O DO NOT ACKN[L$GE ! LAW ( ,GOD1 ! ABS5CE ( HUMAN LAW MU/ SEEM T]RIBLE1 & !Y DO NOT WI% TO BE DEPRIV$ ( IT4 ,?IS LACK ( BELIEF 9 ! LAW ( ,GOD1 IS ! CAUSE ( ! APP>5TLY CURI\S PH5OM5ON1 ?AT ALL ! !ORETICAL AN>*I/S1 CLEV] & LE>N$ M5 -- FROM ,BAK\N9 & ,PRUDHON TO ,RECLUS4 ,MAX ,/IRN] & ,KROPOTK9 -- :O PROVE ) 9DISPUTABLE CORRECTNESS & JU/ICE ! UNREASONABL5ESS & H>MFULNESS ( P[]1 AS SOON AS !Y BEG9 TO SPEAK ( ! POSSIBILITY ( E/ABLI%+ A SOCIETY )\T ?AT HUMAN LAW :I* !Y REJECT1 FALL AT ONCE 9TO 9DEF9IT5ESS1 V]BOSITY1 RHETORIC1 & QUITE UNF\ND$ & FANTA/IC HYPO!SES4 ,?IS >ISES FROM ! FACT ?AT NONE ( !SE !ORETIC AN>*I/S ACCEPT ?AT LAW ( ,GOD COMMON TO ALL M51 :I* IT IS NATURAL = ALL TO OBEY 2 & )\T ! OB$I5CE ( M5 TO ONE & ! SAME LAW -- HUMAN OR DIV9E-- HUMAN SOCIETY CANNOT EXI/4 ,DELIV]ANCE FROM HUMAN LAW IS ONLY POSSIBLE ON CONDITION ?AT ONE ACKN[L$GES A DIV9E LAW COMMON TO ALL M54 ,X,I,I,I4 0 ,BUT IF A PRIMITIVE AGRICULTURAL SOCIETY1 LIKE ! ,RUSSIAN1 C>T LIVE )\T GOV]NM5T10 WILL BE SAID 9 REPLY1 0 :AT >E ?OSE1 MILLIONS TO DO :O HAVE GIV5 UP AGRICULTURE & >E LIV+ AN 9DU/RIAL LIFE 9 T[NS8 ,WE CANNOT ALL CULTIVATE ! L&40 0 ,! ONLY ?+ EV]Y MAN CAN BE1 IS AN AGRICULTURI/10 IS ! CORRECT REPLY GIV5 BY ,H5RY ,GEORGE TO ?IS QUE/ION4 0,BUT IF EV]YBODY N[ RETURN$ TO AN AGRICULTURAL LIFE10 IT WILL AGA9 BE SAID1 0 ! CIVILIZATION MANK9D HAS ATTA9$ W\LD BE DE/ROY$1 & ?AT W\LD BE A T]RIBLE MIS=TUNE 2 & !RE=E A RETURN TO AGRICULTURE W\LD BE AN EVIL & NOT A B5EFIT = MANK9D40 ,A C]TA9 ME?OD EXI/S :]EBY M5 JU/IFY !IR FALLACIES1 & IT IS ?IS 3 ,PEOPLE1 ACCEPT+ ! FALLACY 9TO :I* !Y HAVE FALL5 AS AN UNQUE/IONABLE AXIOM1 UNITE ?IS FALLACY & ALL ITS EFFECTS 9TO ONE CONCEPTION1 & CALL IT BY ONE WORD1 & !N ASCRIBE TO ?IS CONCEPTION & WORD A SPECIAL1 9DEF9ITE & MY/ICAL MEAN+4 ,SU* CONCEPTIONS & WORDS >E1 ! ,*UR*Y ,SCI5CE1 ,JU/ICE1 T,JIE ,/ATE1 & ,CIVILIZATION1 ,?US1 ! ,*UR* BECOMES NOT :AT IT REALLY IS1 A NUMB] ( M5 :O HAVE ALL FALL5 9TO ! SAME ]ROR1 BUT A 0COMMUNION ( ?OSE :O BELIEVE RIMFULLY MISDIRECT$ BY =CE- US+ ,GOV]NM5TS7 ( ! ,WE/]N NATIONS1 :O HAVE SUCCUMB$ TO ! FALSE IDEA ( FREE+ !MSELVES FROM VIOL5CE BY VIOL5CE1 BUT ! UNQUE/IONABLY TRUE WAY T[>DS ! FUTURE WELF>E ( HUMANITY4 "9"9 ,EV5 IF IT BE TRUE10 SAY ! SUPPORT]S ( CIVILIZATION1 ?AT ALL !SE 9V5TIONS1 TE*NICAL APPLIANCES & PRODUCTS ( 9DU/RY1 >E N[ ONLY US$ BY ! RI* & >E 9ACCESSIBLE TO WORK+ M51 & CANNOT !RE=E AS YET BE CONSID]$ A B5EFIT TO ALL MANK9D1 ?IS IS SO ONLY BECAUSE !SE ME*ANICAL APPLIANCES HAVE NOT YET ATTA9$ !IR FULL P]FECTION & >E NOT YET DI/RIBUT$ AS !Y %\LD BE4 ,:5 ME*ANISM IS /ILL FUR!R P]FECT$1 & ! WORKM5 >E FRE$ FROM ! P[] ( ! ,CAPITALI/S1 & ALL ! WORKS & FACTORIES >E 9 !IR H&S1 ! MA*9ES WILL PRODUCE SO MU* ( EV]Y?+ & IT WILL ALL BE SO WELL DI/RIBUT$1 ?AT EV]YBODY WILL HAVE ! USE ( EV]Y?+4 ,NO ONE WILL LACK ANY?+1 & ALL WILL BE HAPPY40 ,NOT TO M5TION ! FACT ?AT WE HAVE NO REASON TO BELIEVE ?AT ! WORK+ M5 :O N[ /RUGGLE SO FI]CELY ) ONE ANO!R = EXI/5CE1 OR EV5 = MORE ( ! COM=TS1 PLEASURES & LUXURIES ( EXI/5CE1 WILL SUDD5LY BECOME SO JU/ & SELF- D5Y+ ?AT !Y WILL BE CONT5T TO %>E EQUALLY ! B5EFITS ! MA*9ES >E GO+ TO GIVE !M -- LEAV+ ?AT ASIDE -- ! V]Y SUPPOSITION ?AT ALL !SE WORKS ) !IR MA*9ES1 :I* C\LD NOT HAVE BE5 />T$ OR CONT9U$ EXCEPT UND] ! P[] ( ,GOV]NM5T & ,CAPITAL1 WILL REMA9 AS !Y >E1 :5 ! P[] ( ,GOV]NM5T & ,CAPITAL HAVE BE5 DE/ROY$1 IS A QUITE >BITR>Y SUPPOSITION4 ,TO EXPECT IT1 IS ! SAME AS IT W\LD HAVE BE5 TO EXPECT ?AT AFT] ! EMANCIPATION ( ! S]FS ON ONE ( ! L>GE1 LUXURI\S ,RUSSIAN E/ATES1 :I* HAD A P4IRK1 CONS]VATORIES1 >BORS1 PRIVATE !ATRICAL TR\PE1 AN OR*E/RA1 A PICTURE GALL]Y1 /ABLES1 K5NELS & /ORE-H\SES FILL$ ) DIFF]5T K9DS ( G>M5TS -- ALL !SE1 ?+S W\LD BE 9 P>T DI/RIBUT$ AMONG ! LIB]AT$ PEASANTS & 9 P>T KEPT = COMMON USE4 ,ONE W\LD ?9K IT WAS EVID5T ?AT ON AN E/ATE ( ?AT K9D1 NEI!R ! H\SES1 CLO!S1 NOR CONS]VATORIES ( ! RI* PROPRIETOR W\LD BE SUITABLE = ! LIB]AT$ PEASANTS1 & !Y W\LD NOT CONT9UE TO KEEP !M UP4 ,9 ! SAME WAY1 :5 ! WORK+ PEOPLE >E EMANCIPAT$ FROM ! P[] ( ,GOV]NM5T & CAPITAL1 !Y WILL NOT CONT9UE TO MA9TA9 ! >RANGEM5TS ?AT HAVE >IS5 UND] !SE P[]S1 & WILL NOT GO TO WORK 9 FACTORIES & WORKS :I* C\LD ONLY HAVE COME 9TO EXI/5CE [+ TO !IR 5SLAVEM5T1 EV5 IF SU* FACTORIES C\LD BE PR(ITABLE & PLEASANT = !M4 ,IT IS TRUE ?AT :5 ! WORK]S >E EMANCIPAT$ FROM SLAV]Y ONE WILL REGRET ALL ?IS CUNN+ MA*9]Y :I* WEAVES SO MU* BEAUTIFUL /UFF SO QUICKLY1 & MAKES SU* NICE SWEETS1 LOOK+- GLASSES1 ETC41 BUT1 9 ! SAME WAY1 AFT] ! EMANCIPATION ( ! S]FS ONE REGRETT$ ! BEAUTIFUL RACE-HORSES1 PICTURES1 MAGNOLIAS1 MUSICAL 9/RUM5TS & PRIVATE !AT]S ?AT DISAPPE>$4 ,BUT JU/ AS ! LIB]AT$ S]FS BR$ ANIMALS SUIT$ TO !IR WAY ( LIFE1 & RAIS$ PLANTS !Y REQUIR$1 & ! RACE-HORSES & MAGNOLIAS DISAPPE>$ ( !MSELVES1 SO ! WORKM51 FRE$ FROM ! P[] ( ,GOV]NM5T & CAPITAL1 WILL DIRECT !IR LABOR TO QUITE O!R WORK ?AN AT PRES5T4 0 ,BUT IT IS MU* MORE PR(ITABLE TO BAKE ALL ! BREAD 9 ONE OV5 ?AN ?AT EV]YBODY %\LD HEAT HIS [N1 & TO WEAVE TW5TY TIMES AS QUICKLY AT A FACTORY AS ON A H&LOOM AT HOME10 SAY ! SUPPORT]S ( CIVILIZATION1 SPEAK+ AS IF M5 W]E DUMB CATTLE = :OM FOOD1 CLO?+1 DWELL+S1 & MORE OR LESS LABOR1 W]E ! ONLY QUE/IONS TO SOLVE4 ,AN ,AU/RALIAN SAVAGE KN[S V]Y WELL ?AT IT W\LD BE MORE PR(ITABLE TO BUILD ONE HUT = HIMSELF & HIS WIFE1 YET HE ]ECTS TWO1 SO ?AT BO? HE & HIS WIFE MAY 5JOY PRIVACY4 ,! ,RUSSIAN PEASANT KN[S V]Y DECID$LY ?AT IT IS MORE PR(ITABLE = HIM TO LIVE 9 ONE H\SE ) HIS FA!R & BRO!RS 2 YET HE ,SEP>ATES FROM !M1 BUILDS HIS [N COTTAGE1 & PREF]S TO BE> PRIVATIONS RA!R ?AN OBEY HIS ELD]S1 OR QU>REL & HAVE DISAGREEM5T1 0 ,BETT] BUT A POT ( BRO?1 & TO BE ONE'S [N MA/]4 0 ,I ?9K ! MAJORITY ( REASONABLE PEOPLE WILL PREF] TO CLEAN !IR [N CLO!S & BOOTS1 C>RY WAT]1 & TRIM !IR [N LAMPS1 ?AN GO TO A FACTORY & DO OBLIGATORY LABOR = ONE H\R A DAY TO PRODUCE MA*9ES ?AT W\LD DO ALL !SE ?+S4 ,:5 CO]CION IS NO LONG] US$1 NO?+ ( ALL !SE F9E MA*9ES ?AT POLI% BOOTS & CLEAN PLATES1 NOR EV5 ( ?OSE ?AT BORE TUNNELS & IMPRESS /EEL1 ETC41 WILL PROBABLY REMA94 ,! LIB]AT$ WORKM5 WILL 9EVITABLY LET EV]Y?+ ?AT WAS F\ND$ ON !IR 5SLAVEM5T P]I%1 & WILL 9EVITABLY BEG9 TO CON/RUCT QUITE O!R MA*9ES & APPLIANCES1 ) O!R AIMS1 ( O!R DIM5SIONS1 & V]Y DIFF]5TLY DI/RIBUT$4 ,?IS IS SO PLA9 & OBVI\S1 ?AT M5 C\LD NOT HELP SEE+ IT IF !Y W]E NOT UND] ! 9FLU5CE ( ! SUP]/ITION ( CIVILIZATION4 ,IT IS ?IS WIDE-SPREAD & FIRMLY-FIX$ SUP]/ITION ?AT CAUSES ALL 9DICATIONS ( ! FALS5ESS ( ! PA? ! ,WE/]N NATIONS >E TRAVEL+1 & ALL ATTEMPTS TO BR+ ! ]R+ PEOPLES BACK TO A FREE & REASONABLE LIFE1 TO BE REJECT$1 & EV5 TO BE REG>D$ AS A K9D ( BLASPHEMY OR MADNESS4 ,?IS BL9D BELIEF ?AT ! LIFE WE HAVE >RANG$ = \RSELVES IS ! BE/ POSSIBLE LIFE1 ALSO CAUSES ALL ! *IEF AG5TS ( CIVILIZATION -- ITS ,GOV]NM5T (FICIALS SCI5TI/S1 >TI/S1 M]*ANTS1 MANUFACTUR]S1 & AU?ORS-- :ILE MAK+ ! WORK]S SUPPORT !IR IDLE LIVES -- TO OV]LOOK !IR [N S9S & TO FEEL P]FECTLY SURE ?AT !IR ACTIVITY IS1 NOT AN IMMORAL & H>MFUL ACTIVITY 7AS IT REALLY IS71 BUT A V]Y USEFUL & IMPORTANT ONE1 & ?AT !Y >E1 !RE=E1 V]Y IMPORTANT PEOPLE & ( GREAT USE TO HUMANITY 2 & ?AT ALL ! /UPID1 TRIFL+1 & NA/Y ?+S PRODUC$ UND] !IR DIRECTION1 SU* AS CANNONS1 =TRESSES1 C9EMATOGRAPHS1 CA!DRALS1 MOTORS1 EXPLOSIVE BOMBS1 PHONOGRAPHS1 TELEGRAPHS1 & /EAM PR9T+-MA*9ES ?AT TURN \T M\NTA9S ( PAP] PR9T$ ) NA/9ESS1 LIES & ABSURDITIES1 WILL REMA9 JU/ ! SAME :5 ! WORK]S >E FREE1 & WILL ALWAYS BE A GREAT BOON TO HUMANITY4 ,YET TO PEOPLE FREE FROM ! SUP]/ITION ( CIVILIZATION1 IT CANNOT BUT BE P]FECTLY OBVI\S ?AT ALL ?OSE CONDITIONS ( LIFE :I* AMONG ! ,WE/]N NATIONS >E N[ CALL$ 0 CIVILIZATION10 >E NO?+ BUT MON/R\S RESULTS ( ! VANITY ( ! UPP]1 GOV]N+ CLASSES1 SU* AS W]E ! PRODUCTIONS ( ! ,EGYPTIAN1 ,BABYLONIAN & ,ROMAN DESPOTS 3 ! PYRAMIDS1 TEMPLES & S]AGLIOS2 OR SU* AS W]E ! PRODUCTIONS ( ! ,RUSSIAN S]F-[N]S 3 PALACES1 S]F-OR*E/RAS1 PRIVATE !ATRICAL TR\PES1 >TIFICIAL LAKES1 LACE1 HUNT+ PACKS & P>KS1 :I* ! SLAVES >RANG$ = !IR LORDS4 ,IT IS SAID ?AT IF M5 CEASE TO OBEY ,GOV]NM5TS & RETURN TO AN AGRICULTURAL LIFE1 ALL ! 9DU/RIAL PROGRESS !Y HAVE ATTA9$ WILL BE LO/1 & ?AT1 !RE=E1 TO GIVE UP OBEY+ ,GOV]NM5T & TO RETURN TO AN AGRICULTURAL LIFE W\LD BE A BAD ?+4 ,BUT !RE IS NO REASON TO SUPPOSE ?AT A RETURN TO AGRICULTURAL LIFE1 FREE FROM ,GOV]NM5T1 W\LD DE/ROY SU* 9DU/RIES & A*IEVEM5TS AS >E REALLY USEFUL TO MANK9D1 & DO NOT REQUIRE ! 5SLAVEM5T ( M54 ,& IF IT /OPP$ ! PRODUCTION ( ?AT 5DLESS NUMB] ( UNNECESS>Y1 /UPID & H>MFUL ?+S1 ON :I* A CONSID]ABLE PORTION ( HUMANITY IS N[ EMPLOY$1 & R5D]$ IMPOSSIBLE ! EXI/5CE ( ! IDLE PEOPLE :O 9V5T ALL ! UNNECESS>Y & H>MFUL ?+S BY :I* !Y JU/IFY !IR IMMORAL LIVES1 ?AT DOES NOT MEAN ?AT ALL ?AT MANK9D HAS1 WORK$ \T = ITS WELF>E W\LD BE DE/ROY$4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y ! DE/RUCTION ( EV]Y?+ ?AT IS KEPT UP BY CO]CION1 W\LD EVOKE & PROMOTE AN 9T5SIFI$ PRODUCTION ( ALL ?OSE USEFUL & NECESS>Y TE*NICAL IMPROVEM5TS :I*1 )\T TURN+ M5 9TO MA*9ES & SPOIL+ !IR LIVES1 MAY EASE ! LABOR ( ! AGRICULTURI/S & R5D] !IR LIVES MORE PLEASANT4 ,! DIFF]5CE WILL ONLY BE1 ?AT :5 M5 >E LIB]AT$ FROM P[] & RETURN TO AGRICULTURAL LABOR1 ! OBJECTS PRODUC$ BY >T & 9DU/RY WILL NO LONG] AIM AT AMUS+ ! RI*1 SATISFY+ IDLE CURIOSITY1 PREP>+ = HUMAN SLAUMFUL LIVES AT ! CO/ ( USEFUL ONES1 OR PRODUC+ MA*9ES BY :I* A SMALL NUMB] ( WORKM5 CAN SOMEH[ PRODUCE A GREAT NUMB] ( ?+S OR CULTIVATE A L>GE TRACT ( L& 2 BUT !Y WILL AIM AT 9CREAS+ ! PRODUCTIV5ESS ( ! WORK ( ?OSE LABOR]S :O CULTIVATE !IR [N ALLOTM5TS ) !IR [N H&S1 & HELP TO BETT] !IR LIVES )\T TAK+ !M AWAY FROM ! L& OR 9T]F]+ ) !IR FRE$OM1 ,X,I,V4 ,BUT WILL PEOPLE BE ABLE TO LIVE )\T OBEY+ SOME HUMAN P[]8 ,H[ WILL !Y CONDUCT !IR COMMON BUS9ESS8 ,:AT WILL BECOME ( ! DIFF]5T ,/ATES8 ,:AT WILL HAPP5 TO ,IREL&1 ,POL&1 ,F9L&1 ,ALG]IA1 ,9DIA1 & TO ALL ! ,COLONIES8 ,H[ WILL ! NATIONS GR\P !MSELVES8 ,SU* QUE/IONS >E PUT BY M5 :O >E ACCU/OM$ TO ?9K ?AT ! CONDITIONS ( LIFE ( ALL HUMAN SOCIETIES >E DECID$ BY ! WILL & DIRECTION ( A FEW 9DIVIDUALS1 & :O !RE=E IMAG9E ?AT ! KN[L$GE ( H[ FUTURE LIFE WILL %APE ITSELF IS ACCESSIBLE TO MAN4 ,SU* KN[L$GE1 H[EV]1 NEV] WAS1 NOR CAN BE1 ACCESSIBLE4 ,IF ! MO/ LE>N$ & BE/ $UCAT$ ,ROMAN CITIZ51 ACCU/OM$ TO ?9K ?AT ! LIFE ( ! WORLD WAS GUID$ BY ! DECREES ( ! ,ROMAN ,S5ATE & ,EMP]ORS1 HAD BE5 ASK$ :AT W\LD BECOME ( ! ,ROMAN ,EMPIRE 9 A FEW C5TURIES 3 OR IF HE HAD HIMSELF ?\B>IANS1 OR ,FEUDALISM1 OR ! ,PAPACY1 OR ! DIS9TEGRATION ( ! PEOPLES & !IR REUNION 9TO L>GE ,/ATES4 ,! SAME #ac TRUE ( ?OSE ,UTOPIAS1 ) FLY+ MA*9ES1 ,X-RAYS1 ELECTRIC MOTORS1 & ,SOCIALI/ ORGANIZATIONS ( LIFE 9 ! TW5TY-FIR/ C5TURY1 :I* >E SO D>+LY DRAWN BY ! ,BELLAMYS1 ,MORRISES1 ,ANATOLE ,FRANCES1 & O!RS4 ,M5 CANNOT KN[ :AT =M SOCIAL LIFE WILL TAKE 9 ! FUTURE & MORE ?AN ?AT1 H>M RESULTS FROM !IR ?9K+ !Y CAN KN[ IT4 ,= NO?+ SO 9T]F]ES ) ! /RAIDS ! UNKN[N 2 *ANG+ NOT BECAUSE C]TA9 M5 HAVE =M$ BRA9-SPUN PLANS AS TO :AT !SE *ANGES %\LD BE1 BUT 9 CONSEQU5CE ( A T5D5CY 9H]5T 9 ALL M5 TO /RIVE T[>DS MORAL P]FECTION1 ATTA9ABLE BY ! 9F9ITELY V>I$ ACTIVITY ( MILLIONS & MILLIONS ( HUMAN LIVES4 ,!RE=E ! RELATION 9 :I* M5 WILL /& T[>DS ONE ANO!R1 & ! =MS 9TO :I* !Y %APE SOCIETY DEP5D 5TIRELY ON ! 9N] *>ACT]S ( M51 & NOT AT ALL ON =ECA/+ ?IS OR ?AT =M ( LIFE :I* !Y DESIRE TO ADOPT4 ,YET ?OSE :O DO NOT BELIEVE 9 ,GOD'S LAW1 ALWAYS IMAG9E ?AT !Y CAN KN[ :AT ! FUTURE /ATE ( SOCIETY %\LD BE1 & NOT ONLY DEF9E ?IS FUTURE /ATE1 BUT DO ALL SORTS ( ?+S !Y !MSELVES ADMIT TO BE EVIL1 9 ORD] TO MOLD HUMAN SOCIETY TO ! %APE !Y ?9K IT \RANG$1 DOES NOT DI/URB !M 2 & HAV+ ASSUR$ !MSELVES ?AT !Y CAN KN[ :AT ! FUTURE ( SOCIETY \GUM5T ( ,CAIAPHAS1 "9' ,IT IS EXP$I5T ?AT ONE MAN %\LD DIE1 & ?AT ! :OLE NATION P]I% NOT10 SEEMS IRREFUTABLE TO SU* PEOPLE4 ,( C\RSE !Y MU/ KILL1 NOT ONE MAN ONLY1 BUT HUNDR$S & ?\S&S ( M51 IF !Y >E FULLY ASSUR$ ?AT ! DEA? ( !SE ?\S&S WILL GIVE WELF>E TO MILLIONS4 ,PEOPLE :O DO NOT BELIEVE 9 ,GOD & ,HIS LAW1 CANNOT BUT >GUE ?US4 ,SU* PEOPLE LIVE 9 OB$I5CE ONLY TO !IR PASSIONS1 TO !IR REASON+S1 & TO SOCIAL HYPNOTISM1 & HAVE NEV] CONSID]$ !IR DE/9Y ( LIFE1 NOR :]E9 ! REAL HAPP9ESS ( HUMANITY CONSI/S OR1 IF !Y HAVE ?\E ( A S+LE MAN LIES1 IMAG9E ?AT !Y KN[1 & KN[ BEYOND ALL D\BT1 :AT IS NE$$ = ! WELF>E ( SOCIETY AS A :OLE 3 KN[ IT SO C]TA9LY1 ?AT TO ATTA9 ?AT WELF>E1 AS !Y UND]/& IT1 !Y COMMIT DE$S ( VIOL5CE1 MURD]S & EXECUTIONS1 :I* !Y !MSELVES ADMIT TO BE EVIL4 ,AT FIR/ IT SEEMS /RANGE ?AT M5 :O DO NOT KN[ :AT !Y !MSELVES NE$1 CAN IMAG9E ?AT !Y KN[ CLE>LY & 9DUBITABLY :AT ! :OLE COMMUNITY NE$S 2 & YET IT IS JU/ BECAUSE !Y DO NOT KN[ :AT !Y NE$1 ?AT !Y IMAG9E !Y KN[ :AT ! :OLE COMMUNITY NE$S4 ,! DISSATISFACTION !Y 7LACK+ ALL GUIDANCE = !IR LIVES7 DIMLY FEEL1 !Y ATTRIBUTE NOT TO !MSELVES1 BUT TO ! BADNESS ( ! EXI/+ =MS ( SOCIAL LIFE1 :I* DIFF] FROM ! ONE !Y HAVE 9V5T$4 ,& 9 C>ES = ! RE>RANGEM5T ( SOCIETY !Y F9D A POSSIBILITY ( ESCAP+ FROM CONSCI\SNESS ( ! WRONGNESS ( !IR [N LIVES4 ,?AT IS :Y ?OSE :O DO NOT KN[ :AT TO DO ) !MSELVES >E ALWAYS P>TICUL>LY SURE :AT \E AB\T SOCIETY4 ,SU* M5 = ! MO/ P>T >E EI!R V]Y ?\E ! MO/ DEPRAV$ ( SOCIAL LEAD]S1 SU* AS ! ,M>ATS1 ,NAPOLEONS & ,BISM>CKS 2 & ?AT IS :Y ! HI/ORY ( ! NATIONS IS FULL ( MO/ T]RIBLE EVIL- DO+S4 ,! WOR/ EFFECT ( ?IS IMAG9>Y =E-KN[L$GE ( :AT SOCIETY %\LD BE1 & ( ?IS ACTIVITY DIRECT$ TO ! ALT]ATION ( SOCIETY1 IS ?AT IT IS JU/ ?IS SUPPOS$ KN[L$GE & ?IS ACTIVITY :I* MORE ?AN ANY?+ ELSE H9D]S ! MOVEM5T ( ! COMMUNITY ALONG ! PA? NATURAL TO IT = ITS TRUE WELF>E4 ,!RE=E TO ! QUE/ION1 0 ,:AT WILL ! LIVES ( ! NATIONS BE LIKE :I* CEASE TO OBEY P[] 8 0 WE REPLY ?AT WE NOT ONLY DO NOT KN[1 BUT \E PRONE TO BELIEVE 9 ! REALIZATION ( ! MO/ IMPROBABLE EV5TS UND] ! SUN4 ,!Y BELIEVE 9 ! POSSIBILITY ( FLY+ & COMMUNICAT+ ) ! PLANETS1 9 ! POSSIBILITY ( >RANG+ ,SOCIALI/IC ,COMMUNES1 9 SPIRITUALI/IC COMMUNICATIONS1 & 9 MANY O!R PALPABLY IMPOSSIBLE ?+S 2 BUT !Y DO NOT WI% TO BELIEVE ?AT ! CONCEPTION ( LIFE 9 :I* !Y & ALL :O SURR\ND !M LIVE1 CAN EV] BE ALT]$4 ,& YET SU* *ANGES1 EV5 ! MO/ EXTRAORD9>Y1 >E CONT9UALLY TAK+ PLACE 9 \RSELVES1 & AMONG ?OSE >\ND US1 & AMONG :OLE COMMUNITIES & NATIONS 2 & IT IS !SE *ANGES ?AT CON/ITUTE ! ESS5CE ( HUMAN LIFE4 ,NOT TO M5TION *ANGES ?AT HAVE HAPP5$ 9 HI/ORIC TIMES 9 ! SOCIAL CONSCI\SNESS ( NATIONS1 AT PRES5T 9 ,RUSSIA1 BE=E \R V]Y EYES1 AN APP>5TLY A/ONI%+ *ANGE IS TAK+ PLACE ) 9CR$IBLE RAPIDITY 9 ! CONSCI\SNESS ( ! :OLE ,RUSSIAN NATION1 ( :I* WE HAD NO EXT]NAL 9DICATION TWO OR ?REE YE>S AGO4 ,! *ANGE ONLY SEEMS TO US TO HAVE TAK5 PLACE SUDD5LY1 BECAUSE ! PREP>ATION = IT1 :I* W5T ON 9 ! SPIRITUAL REGION WAS NOT VISIBLE4 ,A SIMIL> *ANGE IS /ILL GO+ ON 9 ! SPIRITUAL REGION 9ACCESSIBLE TO \R OBS]VATIONS4 ,IF ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE :O TWO YE>S AGO ?\E EV5 PREP>+ TO DISOBEY IT & TO REPLACE IT BY A NEW ONE1 :Y %\LD WE NOT SUPPOSE ?AT 9 ! CONSCI\SNESS ( ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE ANO!R *ANGE 9 !IR RELATION T[>DS P[] -- MORE NATURAL TO !M -- IS N[ PREP>+1 A *ANGE :I* WILL CONSI/ 9 !IR MORAL & RELIGI\S EMANCIPATION FROM P[] 8 ,:Y MAY NOT SU* A *ANGE BE POSSIBLE AMONG ANY PEOPLE1 & :Y NOT AT PRES5T AMONG ! ,RUSSIANS 8 ,:Y1 9/EAD ( ?AT IRRITAT$1 EGOTI/ICAL MOOD ( MUTUAL /RIFE1 FE> & HATR$1 :I* HAS N[ SEIZ$ ALL NATIONS1 9/EAD ( ALL ?IS PREA*+ ( LIES1 IMMORALITY1 & VIOL5CE N[ SO /R5U\SLY CIRCULAT$ AMONG ALL NATIONS BY NEWSPAP]S1 BOOKS1 SPEE*ES1 & ACTIONS -- :Y %\LD NOT A RELIGI\S1 HUMANE1 REASONABLE1 LOV+ MOOD SEIZE ! M9DS ( ALL NATIONS1 & ( ! ,RUSSIAN NATION 9 P>TICUL>1 AFT] ALL ! S9S1 SUFF]+S & T]RORS !Y HAVE LIV$ ?R\<3 A /ATE ( M9D :I* W\LD MAKE !M SEE ALL ! HORROR ( SUBMITT+ TO ! P[] UND] :I* !Y LIVE1 & FEEL ! JOYFUL POSSIBILITY ( A REASONABLE1 LOV+ LIFE )\T VIOL5CE & )\T P[] 8 ,:Y %\LD NOT ! CONSCI\SNESS ( ! POSSIBILITY & NECESSITY ( EMANCIPAT+ !MSELVES FROM ! S9 ( P[]1 & ( E/ABLI%+ UNITY AMONG M5 BAS$ ON MUTUAL AGREEM5T & ON RESPECT & LOVE BETWE5 MAN & MAN1 BE N[ RIP5+1 JU/ AS ! MOVEM5T N[ MANIFE/+ ITSELF 9 ! ,REVOLUTION PREP>$ BY DECADES ( 9FLU5CE T5D+ 9 ONE P>TICUL> DIRECTION 8 ,SOME T5 OR FIFTE5 YE>S AGO ! GIFT$ ,FR5* WRIT]1 ,DUMAS FILS1 WROTE A LETT] TO ,ZOLA 9 :I* HE1 A TAL5T$ & 9TELLIG5T MAN *IEFLY OCCUPI$ ) ES!TIC & SOCIAL QUE/IONS1 :5 ALREADY OLD1 UTT]$ SOME /RIK+LY PROPHETIC WORDS4 ,TRULY ! SPIRIT ( ,GOD 0 BL[E? :]E IT LI/E? 0 6 ,?IS IS :AT HE WROTE 3 -- 0,! S\L1 TOO1 IS 9CESSANTLY AT WORK1 EV] EVOLV+ T[>D LIASS$ MAN1 NEV] SO DOM9AT$ HIM1 AS IS DEES TO-DAY4 ,IT IS AS ?\< IT W]E 9 ! AIR WE ALL BREA!4 ,! FEW ISOLAT$ S\LS ?AT HAD SEP>ATELY DESIR$ ! REG5]ATION ( SOCIETY HAVE1 LITTLE BY LITTLE1 S\]1 UNIT$ COMPREH5D$ ONE ANO!R1 & =M$ A GR\P1 A C5T] ( ATTRACTION1 T[>D :I* O!RS N[ FLY FROM ! F\R QU>T]S ( ! GLOBE1 LIKE L>KS T[>D A MIRROR4 ,!Y HAVE1 AS IT W]E1 =M$ ONE COLLECTIVE S\L1 SO ?AT M5 9 FUTURE MAY REALIZE TOGE!R1 CONSCI\SLY & IRRESI/IBLY1 ! APPROA*+ UNION & /EADY PROGRESS ( NATIONS ?AT W]E BUT REC5TLY HO/ILE ONE TO ANO!R4 ,?IS NEW S\L ,I F9D & RECOGNIZE 9 EV5TS SEEM+LY MO/ CALCULAT$ TO D5Y IT4 0,!SE >MAM5TS ( ALL NATIONS1 !SE ?REATS !IR REPRES5TATIVES ADDRESS TO ONE ANO!R1 ?IS RECRUDESC5CE ( RACE P]SECUTIONS1 !SE HO/ILITIES AMONG COMPATRIOTS1 >E ALL ?+S ( EVIL ASPECT1 BUT NOT ( EVIL AUGURY4 ,!Y >E ! LA/ CONVULSIONS ( ?AT :I* IS AB\T TO DISAPPE>4 ,! SOCIAL BODY IS LIKE ! HUMAN BODY4 ,DISEASE1 9 ?IS CASE1 IS BUT A VIOL5T EF=T ( ! ORGANISM TO ?R[ (F A MORBID & H>MFUL ELEM5T4 0 ,?OSE :O HAVE PR(IT$1 & EXPECT = LONG OR OR EV] TO CONT9UE TO PR(IT BY ! MI/AKES ( ! PA/1 >E UNIT+ TO PREV5T ANY MODIFICATION ( EXI/+ CONDITIONS4 ,H5CE !SE >MAM5TS & ?REATS & P]SECUTIONS 2 BUT LOOK C>EFULLY & Y\ WILL SEE ?AT ALL ?IS IS QUITE SUP]FICIAL4 ,IT IS COLOSSAL1 BUT HOLL[4 ,!RE IS NO LONG] ANY S\L 9 IT -- ! S\L HAS GONE ELSE:]E 2 !SE MILLIONS ( >M$ M5 :O >E DAILY DRILL$ TO PREP>E = A G5]AL W> ( EXT]M9ATION1 NO LONG] HATE ! M5 !Y >E EXPECT$ TO FIES TO PROCLAIM ?IS W>4 ,AS = ! APPEALS1 & EV5 ! ?REAT5+ CLAIMS1 ?AT RISE FROM ! SUFF]+ & ! OPPRESS$ -- A GREAT & S9C]E PITY1 RECOGNIZ+ !IR JU/ICE1 BEG9S AT LA/ TO RESPOND FROM ABOVE4 0 ,AGREEM5T IS 9EVITABLE1 & WILL COME AT AN APPO9T$ TIME1 NE>] ?AN IS EXPECT$4 0 ,I KN[ NOT IF IT BE BECAUSE ,I %ALL SOON LEAVE ?IS E>?1 & ! RAYS ?AT >E ALREADY REA*+ ME FROM BEL[ ! HORIZON HAVE DI/URB$ MY SIIAN4 ,MANK9D1 :I* DOES NO?+ MOD]ATELY1 IS AB\T TO BE SEIZ$ ) A FR5ZY1 A MADNESS1 ( LOVE4 ,?IS WILL NOT1 ( C\RSE1 HAPP5 SMOO?LY OR ALL AT ONCE 2 IT WILL 9VOLVE MISUND]/&+S-- EV5 SANGU9>Y ONES P]*ANCE -- SO TRA9$ & SO ACCU/OM$ HAVE WE BE5 TO HATR$1 EV5 BY ?OSE1 SOMETIMES1 :OSE MISSION IT WAS TO TEA* US TO LOVE ONE ANO!R4 ,BUT IT IS EVID5T ?AT ?IS GREAT LAW ( BRO!RHOOD MU/ BE ACCOMPLI%$ SOME DAY1 & ,I AM CONV9C$ ?AT ! TIME IS COMM5C+ :5 \R DESIRE = ITS ACCOMPLI%M5T WILL BECOME IRRESI/IBLE40 ,I BELIEVE ?AT ?IS ?\E LIV+ 9 ! TIMES PR$ICT$ BY ,*RI/1 WROTE ,LAM5NAIS4 0 ,FROM ONE 5D ( ! E>? TO ! O!R1 EV]Y?+ IS TOTT]+4 ,9 ALL 9/ITUTIONS1 :ATEV] !Y MAY BE1 9 ALL ! DIFF]5T SY/EMS ON :I* ! SOCIAL LIFE ( M5 IS F\ND$1 NO?+ /&S FIRM4 ,EV]YONE FEELS ?AT SOON IT MU/ ALL FALL TO RU9S1 & ?AT 9 ?IS TEMPLE TOO1 NOT ONE /ONE WILL BE LEFT ON ANO!R4 ,BUT AS ! DE/RUCTION ( ,J]USALEM & ITS TEMPLE1 FROM :5CE ! LIV+ ,GOD HAD DEP>T$1 =EBOD$ & PREP>$ ! ]ECTION ( A NEW CITY1 & A NEW TEMPLE1 :ITLI] ! PEOPLE ( ALL RACES & ( ALL NATIONS W\LD COME TOGE!R AT !IR [N FREE WILL -- SO ON ! RU9S ( ! TEMPLES & T[NS ( TO-DAY1 A NEW CITY & A NEW TEMPLE WILL BE ]ECT$1 PR$E/9$ TO BECOME ! UNIV]SAL TEMPLE & ! COMMON FA!RL& ( ! HUMAN RACE1 DISUNIT$ TILL N[ BY TEA*+S HO/ILE TO ONE ANO!R1 ?AT MAKE BRO!RS 9TO /RANG]S & S[ GODLESS HATR$ & REVOLT+ W>F>E AMONG !M4 ,:5 ?AT H\R1 KN[N TO ,GOD ALONE1 >RIVES -- ! H\R ( UNION ( ! NATIONS 9TO ONE TEMPLE & ONE CITY -- !N 9DE$ WILL ! ,K+DOM ( ,*RI/ COME -- ! COMPLETE FULFILLM5T ( HIS DIV9E MISSION4 ,DID HE NOT COME ) ! ONE OBJECT ( TEA*+ M5 ?AT !Y MU/ BE UNIT$ BY ! LAW ( LOVE8 0 ,*ANN+ SAID ! SAME3 0 ,MIE AT WORK 9 ! WORLD4 ,:O CAN /AY !M 8 ,GOD'S WORD HAS GONE =?1 & ' IT CANNOT RETURN TO HIM VOID4 ' ,A NEW COMPREH5SION ( ! ,*RI/IAN SPIRIT -- A NEW REV]5CE = HUMANITY1 A NEW FEEL+ ( BRO!RHOOD1 & ( ALL M5'S RELATION TO ! COMMON ,FA!R -- ?IS IS AMONG ! SIGNS ( \R TIMES4 ,WE SEE IT 2 DO WE NOT FEEL IT 8 ,BE=E ?IS1 ALL OPPRESSIONS >E TO FALL4 ,SOCIETY1 SIL5TLY P]VAD$ BY ?IS1 IS TO *ANGE ITS ASPECT ( UNIV]SAL W>F>E = PEACE4 ,! P[] ( SELFI%NESS1 ALL-GRASP+ & SEEM+LY 9V9CIBLE1 IS TO YIELD TO ?IS DIV9] 5]GY444 0,ON E>? PEACE10 WILL NOT ALWAYS S\ND AS FICTION4 ,X,V,I4 ,:Y %\LD WE SUPPOSE ?AT PEOPLE1 :O >E 5TIRELY 9 ! P[] ( ,GOD1 WILL ALWAYS REMA9 UND] ! /RANGE DELUSION ?AT ONLY HUMAN LAWS -- *ANGEABLE1 ACCID5TAL1 UNJU/ & LOCAL AS !Y >E -->E IMPORTANT & B9D+1 & NOT !ONE1 ET]NAL1 JU/ LAW ( ,GOD1 COMMON TO ALL M58 ,:Y %\LD WE ?9K ?AT ! TEA*]S ( MANK9D WILL ALWAYS PREA*1 AS !Y N[ DO1 ?AT !RE IS & CAN BE1 NO SU* LAW1 BUT ?AT ! ONLY LAWS ?AT EXI/ >E SPECIAL LAWS ( RELIGI\S RITUAL = EV]Y NATION & EV]Y SECT 2 OR ! SO-CALL$ SCI5TIFIC LAWS ( MATT] & ! IMAG9>Y LAWS ( SOCIOLOGY 7:I* DO NOT B9D M5 TO ANY?+7 OR1 F9ALLY1 CIVIL LAWS1 :I* M5 !MSELVES CAN 9/ITUTE & *ANGE8 ,SU* AN ]ROR IS POSSIBLE = A TIME1 BUT :Y %\LD VVE SUPPOSE ?AT PEOPLE TO :OM ONE & ! SAME DIV9E LAW WRITT5 9 !IR HE>TS HAS BE5 REVEAL$ 9 ! TEA*+ ( ! ,BRAHM9S1 ,BUDDHA1 ,LAO-,TSZE1 ,CONFUCIUS & ,*RI/1 WILL NOT AT LA/ FOLL[ ?IS ONE BASIS ( ALL LAWS1 AF=D+ AS IT DOES MORAL SATISFACTION & A JOYFUL SOCIAL LIFE -- BUT ?AT !Y WILL ALWAYS FOLL[ ?AT WICK$ & PITIFUL TANGLE ( ,*UR*1 SCI5TIFIC1 & ,GOV]NM5TAL TEA*+1 :I* DIV]TS !IR ATT5TION FROM ! ONE ?+ NE$FUL1 & DIRECTS IT T[>DS :AT CAN BE ( NO USE TO !M1 AS IT DOES NOT %[ !M H[ EA* SEP>ATE MAN %\LD LIVE8 ,:Y %\LD WE ?9K ?AT M5 WILL CONT9UE UNCEAS+LY & DELIB]ATELY TO TORM5T !MSELVES1 SOME TRY+ TO RULE OV] O!RS1 O!RS ) HATR$ & 5VY SUBMITT+ TO ! RUL]S & SEEK+ MEANS !MSELVES TO BECOME RUL]S8 ,:Y %\LD WE ?9K ?AT ! PROGRESS M5 PRIDE !MSELVES ON WILL ALWAYS LIE 9 ! 9CREASE ( POPULATION & ! PRES]VATION ( LIFE1 & NEV] 9 ! MORAL ELEVATION ( LIFE8 ,WILL LIE 9 MIS]ABLE ME*ANICAL 9V5TIONS BY :I* M5 WILL PRODUCE EV] MORE & MORE H>MFUL1 9JURI\S & DEMORALIZ+ OBJECTS1 & NOT LIE 9 GREAT] & GREAT] UNITY ONE ) ANO!R1 & 9 ?AT SUBJUGATION ( !IR LU/S :I* IS NECESS>Y TO MAKE SU* UNITY POSSIBLE8 ,:Y %\LD WE NOT SUPPOSE ?AT M5 WILL REJOICE & VIE ) ONE ANO!R1 NOT 9 RI*ES & LUXURIES1 BUT 9 SIMPLICITY & FRUGALITY & 9 K9DNESS ONE T[>DS ANO!R8 ,:Y %\LD WE NOT SUPPOSE ?AT M5 WILL SEE PROGRESS1 NOT 9 SEIZ+ MORE & MORE = !MSELVES1 BUT 9 TAK+ LESS & LESS FROM O!RS1 & 9 GIV+ MORE & MORE TO O!RS 2 NOT 9 9CREAS+ !IR P[]1 NOT 9 FID5S & WOODS1 ) TAME1 WELL-F$ ANIMAL FRI5DS 2 ONLY ) ?IS DIFF]5CE FROM !IR PRES5T CONDITION1 ?AT !Y DO NOT CONSID] ! L& TO BE ANYONE'S PRIVATE PROP]TY1 DO NOT !MSELVES BELONG TO ANY P>TICUL> NATION1 DO NOT PAY TAXES OR DUTIES1 PREP>E = W>1 OR FIY1 HAVE MORE & MORE ( PEACEFUL 9T]C\RSE ) EV]Y RACE8 ,TO IMAG9E ! LIFE ( M5 LIKE ?AT1 NO?+ NE$ BE 9V5T$ OR ALT]$ OR ADD$ 9 ONE'S IMAG9ATION TO ! LIVES ( ! AGRICULTURAL RACES WE KN[ 9 ,*9A1 ,RUSSIA1 ,9DIA1 ,CANADA1 ,ALG]IA1 ,EGYPT & ,AU/RALIA4 ,TO PICTURE SU* LIFE TO \RSELVES1 ONE NE$ NOT IMAG9E ANY K9D ( CUNN+ OR \T-(-!-WAY >RANGEM5T1 BUT NE$ ONLY IMAG9E TO ONESELF M5 ACKN[L$+ NO O!R SUPREME LAW BUT ! UNIV]SAL LAW EXPRESS$ ALIKE 9 ! ,BRAHM91 ,BUDDHI/' ,CONFUCIAN1 ,TAOI/ & ,*RI/IAN RELIGIONS -- -! LAW ( LOVE TO ,GOD & TO ONE'S NEIE1 ) ALL WEAKNESSES & PASSIONS NATURAL TO !M 2 !Y WILL S91 WILL P]HAPS QU>REL1 & COMMIT ADULT]Y1 & TAKE AWAY O!R PEOPLE'S PROP]TY1 & EV5 SLAY 2 BUT ALL ?IS WILL BE ! EXCEPTION & NOT1 AS N[1 ! RULE4 ,!IR LIFE WILL BE QUITE DIFF]5T [+ TO ! ONE FACT ?AT !Y WILL NOT CONSID] ORGANIZ$ VIOL5CE A GOOD ?+ & A NECESS>Y CONDITION ( LIFE1 & WILL NOT BE TRA9$ AMISS BY HE>+ ! EVIL DE$S ( ,GOV]NM5TS REPRES5T$ AS GOOD ACTIONS4 ,!IR LIFE WILL BE QUITE DIFF]5T1 BECAUSE !RE WILL NO LONG] BE ?AT IMP$IM5T TO PREA*+ & TEA*+ ! SPIRIT ( GOODNESS1 LOVE1 & SUBMISSION TO ! WILL ( ,GOD1 ?AT EXI/S AS LONG AS WE ADMIT AS NECESS>Y & LAWFUL1 GOV]NM5TAL VIOL5CE DEM&+ :AT IS CONTR>Y TO ,GOD'S LAW1 & 9VOLV+ ! ACCEPTANCE ( :AT IS CRIM9AL & BAD1 9 PLACE ( :AT IS LAWFUL & GOOD4 ,:Y %\LD WE NOT IMAG9E ?AT1 ?R\< SUFF]+1 M5 MAY BE >\S$ FROM ! SUGGE/ION1 ! HYPNOTISM1 UND] :I* !Y HAVE SUFF]$ SO LONG1 & REMEMB] ?AT !Y >E ALL SONS & S]VANTS ( ,GOD1 & !RE=E CAN & MU/ SUBMIT ONLY TO ,HIM & TO !IR [N CONSCI5CES 8 ,ALL ?IS IS NOT DIFFICULT TO IMAG9E2 IT IS EV5 DIFFICULT TO IMAG9E ?AT IT %\LD NOT BE ACCOMPLI%$4 ,X,V,I,I4 0 ,EXCEPT YE BECOME AS LITTLE *ILDR51 YE %ALL 9 NO WISE 5T] ! K+DOM ( HEAV510 DOES NOT REF] TO 9DIVIDUALS ONLY1 BUT ALSO TO HUMAN SOCIETIES4 ,AS A MAN1 HAV+ EXP]I5C$ ALL ! MIS]IES CAUS$ BY ! PASSIONS & TEMPTATIONS ( LIFE1 CONSCI\SLY RETURNS TO A /ATE ( SIMPLICITY1 K9DNESS T[>DS ALL1 & READ9ESS TO ACCEPT :AT IS GOOD 7! /ATE 9 :I* *ILDR5 UNCONSCI\SLY LIVE7 & RETURNS TO IT ) ! WEAL? ( EXP]I5CE & ! REASON ( A GR[N-UP MAN1 SO HUMAN SOCIETY ALSO1 HAV+ EXP]I5C$ ALL ! MIS]ABLE CONSEQU5CES ( AB&ON+ ! LAW ( ,GOD TO OBEY HUMAN P[]1 & ( ATTEMPT+ TO >RANGE LIFE AP>T FROM AGRICULTURAL LABOR1 MU/ N[ CONSCI\SLY RETURN1 ) ALL ! WEAL? ( EXP]I5CE GA9$ DUR+ ! TIME ( ITS AB]RATION1 FROM ! SN>ES ( HUMAN P[]1 & FROM ! ATTEMPT TO ORGANIZE LIFE ON A BASIS ( ,9DU/RIAL ACTIVITY1 & MU/ SUBMIT TO ! HIY WORK ( CULTIVAT+ ! SOIL1 :I* IT HAD TEMPOR>ILY AB&ON$4 ,CONSCI\SLY TO RETURN FROM ! SN>ES ( HUMAN P[]1 & TO OBEY ! SUPREME LAW ( ,GOD ALONE1 IS TO ADMIT AS ALWAYS & EV]Y:]E B9D+ UPON US1 ! ET]NAL LAW ( ,GOD1 :I* IS ALIKE 9 ALL ! TEA*+S 3 ,BRAHM9I/1 ,BUDDHI/1 ,CONFUCIAN1 ,TAOIAN ,*RI/IAN1 & TO SOME EXT5T 9 ,MAHOMM$AN 7,BABII/7 & IS 9COMPATIBLE ) SUBJECTION TO HUMAN P[]4 ,CONSCI\SLY TO LIVE AN AGRICULTURAL LIFE1 IS TO ACKN[L$GE IT TO BE NOT AN ACCID5TAL & TEMPOR>Y CONDITION1 BUT ! LIFE :I* MAKES IT EASIE/ = MAN TO FULFILL ! WILL ( ,GOD1 & :I* %\LD !RE=E BE PREF]R$ TO ANY O!R4 ,= SU* A RETURN TO AN AGRICULTURAL LIFE & TO CONSCI\S DISOB$I5CE TO P[]1 ! ,EA/]N NATIONS 7& AMONG !M ! ,RUSSIAN NATION7 >E MO/ FAVORABLY SITUAT$4 ,! ,WE/]N NATIONS HAVE ALREADY W&]$ SO F> ON ! FALSE PA? ( *ANG+ ! ORGANIZATION ( P[]1 & EX*ANG+ AGRICULTURAL = 9DU/RIAL WORK1 ?AT SU* A RETURN IS DIFFICULT & REQUIRES GREAT EF=TS4 ,BUT1 SOON] OR LAT]1 ! EV]-9CREAS+ ANNOYANCE & 9/ABILITY ( !IR POSITION WILL =CE !M TO RETURN TO A REASONABLE & TRULY FREE LIFE1 SUPPORT$ BY !IR [N LABOR & NOT BY ! EXPLOITATION ( O!R NATIONS4 ,H[EV] ALLUR+ ! EXT]NAL SUCCESS ( MANUFACTUR+ 9DU/RY & ! %[Y SIDE ( SU* A LIFE MAY BE1 ! MO/ P5ETRAT+ ?9K]S AMONG ! ,WE/]N NATIONS HAVE LONG PO9T$ \T H[ DISA/R\S IS ! PA? !Y >E FOLL[+1 & H[ NECESS>Y IT IS TO RECONSID] & *ANGE !IR WAY1 & TO RETURN TO ?AT AGRICULTURAL LIFE :I* WAS ! ORIG9AL =M ( LIFE = ALL NATIONS1 & :I* IS ! ORDA9$ PA? MAK+ IT POSSIBLE = ALL M5 TO LIVE A REASONABLE & JOYFUL LIFE4 ,! MAJORITY ( ! ,EA/]N PEOPLES1 9CLUD+ ! ,RUSSIAN NATION1 WILL NOT HAVE TO ALT] !IR LIVES AT AIL4 ,!Y NE$ ONLY /OP !IR ADVANCE ALONG ! FALSE PA? !Y HAVE JU/ 5T]$1 & BECOME CLE>LY CONSCI\S ( ! NEGATIVE ATTITUDE T[>DS P[] & ! AFFECTIONATE ATTITUDE T[>DS HUSB&RY :I* WAS ALWAYS NATURAL TO !M4 ,WE ( ! ,EA/]N NATIONS %\LD BE ?ANKFUL TO FATE = PLAC+ US 9 A POSITION 9 :I* WE CAN B5EFIT BY ! EXAMPLE ( ! ,WE/]N NATIONS 3 B5EFIT BY IT1 NOT 9 ! S5SE ( IMITAT+ IT1 BUT 9 ! S5SE ( AVOID+ !IR MI/AKES1 NOT DO+ :AT !Y HAVE DONE1 NOT TRAVEL+ ! DISA/R\S PA? FROM :I* NATIONS ?AT HAVE GONE SO F> >E ALREADY RETURN+1 OR >E PREP>+ TO RETURN4 ,JU/ 9 ?IS HALT 9 ! M>* ALONG A FALSE PA?1 & 9 %[+ ! POSSIBILITY & 9EVITABL5ESS ( 9DICAT+ & MAK+ A DIFF]5T PA?1 ONE EASI]1 MORE JOYFUL1 & MORE NATURAL ?AN ! ONE ! ,WE/]N NATIONS HAVE TRAVEL$1 LIES ! *IEF & MIS]-\TPUT 4W/-SMALLREFS_3BO?2L9E-HEI 8 ,TRANSLATOR'S NOTE - ,! WORD 0P[]0 OCCURS V]Y FREQU5TLY 9 ?IS >TICLE1 & IS1 AS IT W]E1 A PIVOT ON :I* IT TURNS4 ,WE HAVE BE5 TEMPT$ 9 DIFF]5T PLACES TO TRANSLATE IT 7! ,RUSSIAN WORD IS VLA/7 BY 0GOV]NM5T10 0AU?ORITIES10 0=CE0 OR 0VIOL5CE0 ACCORD+ TO ! CONTEXT4 ,BUT ! UNITY ( ! >TICLE IS BETT] MA9TA9$ BY LETT+ A S+LE ,5GLI% WORD REPRES5T ! ONE ,RUSSIAN WORD1 & WE HAVE FOLL[$ ?IS PR9CIPLE AS F> AS POSSIBLE4 8 ,TRANSLATOR'S NOTE - ,/5KA ,RAZ9 & ,P\GAT*EF W]E FAM\S ,RUSSIAN REBELS ( ! SEV5TE5? & EIS 7#a#g#c-#a#g#d#a74 ,FROM 3 ,WIKIS\RCE4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,NOVEMB] #c1 #aie 3 ,! ,MEAN+ ( ! ,RUSSIAN ,REVOLUTION -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,JULY #a#g1 #bba 3 ,! ,MEAN+ ( ! ,RUSSIAN ,REVOLUTION -- ,ADD$4 ,JANU>Y #i1 #bbb 3 ,! ,MEAN+ ( ! ,RUSSIAN ,REVOLUTION -- ,UPDAT$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/