,! ,P[] ( ! ,CLASSES ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,ANTON ,PANNEKOEK ,TEXT 3 ,PUBLI%$3 ,9T]NATIONAL ,C\NCIL ,CORRESPOND5CE1 VOL4 #b1 NO4 #f4 ,MAY #a#i#c#f4 ,TRANSCRIPTION_/,M>KUP3 ,MICAH ,MU]1 #b#a#g4 ,I ,! P[] ( ! CAPITALI/ CLASS IS 5ORM\S4 ,NEV] 9 HI/ORY WAS !RE A RUL+ CLASS ) SU* P[]4 ,!IR P[] IS FIR/1 MONEY P[]4 ,ALL ! TREASURES ( ! WORLD >E !IRS1 & MOD]N CAPITAL1 PRODUC$ BY ! CEASELESS TOIL ( MILLIONS ( WORK]S1 EXCE$S ALL ! TREASURES ( ! OLD WORLD4 ,! SURPLUS VALUE IS P>TLY ACCUMULAT$ 9TO EV] MORE & NEW CAPITAL2 P>TLY IT MU/ BE SP5T BY ! CAPITALI/S4 ,!Y BUY S]VANTS = !IR P]SONAL ATT5DANTS2 !Y ALSO BUY ,PEOPLE TO DEF5D !M1 TO SAFEGU>D !IR P[] & !IR DOM9AT+ POSITION4 ,9 CAPITALISM EV]Y?+ CAN BE B\KET GOODS4 ,SAID OLD ,JOHN ,D4 ,ROCKEFELL]3 0,EV]YONE CAN BE B\IANS TO =M A FIMIES ( ,VOLUNTE]S PROVID$ ) ! BE/ MOD]N >MS1 WELL-F$ & WELL-PAID1 TO DEF5D !IR SACR$ CAPITALI/ ORD]4 ,BUT CAPITALISM CANNOT BE DEF5D$ BY BRUTAL =CE ALONE4 ,BE+ ITSELF ! \TCOME ( A HI< DEVELOPM5T ( 9TELLECTUAL =CES1 IT MU/ CONSEQU5TLY BE DEF5D$ BY !SE SAME 9TELLECTUAL =CES4 ,BEH9D ! PHYSICAL /RUGGLE 9 ! CLASS W>1 /&S ! SPIRITUAL CONTE/ ( IDEAS4 ,CAPITALI/S KN[ ?AT1 (T5 BETT] ?AN ! WORK]S4 ,H5CE !Y BUY ALL ! GOOD BRA9S !Y CAN4 ,(T5 9 A CO>SE1 OP5 WAY2 MO/ (T5 H[EV]1 9DIRECTLY4 ,?IS IS DONE1 = 9/ANCE1 BY DONAT+ MONEY = CULTURAL PURPOSES4 ,NUM]\S /UD5TS ( SCI5CE ! WORLD OV] HAVE PR(IT$ 9 !IR RESE>*ES FROM ! 0,ROCKEFELL] ,F\NDATION04 ,?US ! NAME ',ROCKEFELL]' HAS A REPUTATION 9 ! FIELD ( NATURAL SCI5CES :]E ',LUDL[' IS NEV] HE>D (4 ,?IS K9D ( PHILAN?ROPY S]VES CAPITALISM WELL4 ,CAPITALI/S HAVE F\ND$ UNIV]SITIES ALL OV] ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES :]E AMONG O!R SCI5CES SOCIOLOGY IS TAUIES & PUBLIC HONOR AWAIT !M IF !Y DO NOT DEVIATE FROM ! /RAIRY ON !IR BUS9ESSES BY PROTECT+ & REGULAT+ !IR 9T]C\RSE4 ,! GOV]NM5T MAKES LAWS = ! PROTECTION ( 0HONE/0 BUS9ESSM5 AGA9/ 0?IEVES0 & 0MURD]]S04 ,AGA9/ /RIK]S & REVOLUTIONI/S1 :O >E F> MORE DANG]\S TO ! EXI/+ SOCIAL ORD]1 LAWS EV5 MORE DRA/IC >E MADE4 ,= ! 5=C+ ( !SE LAWS1 ! POLICE & JAIL >E US$4 ,9 EV]Y /RIKE1 9 EV]Y POLITICAL DEMON/RATION1 ! WORK]S F9D ! POLICE >RAY$ AGA9/ !M1 CLUBB+ & ?R[+ !M 9TO JAIL = ! B5EFIT ( ! CAPITALI/ CLASS & TO PROTECT ! CAPITALI/S PR(ITS4 ,GANGS ( HIR$ ?UGS >E SWORN 9 AS DEPUTY %]IFFS & GIV5 POLICE AU?ORITY2 & :5 ! WORK]S CANNOT BE SUBDU$ 9 ?IS WAY1 MILITIA & CITIZ5 GU>DS >E MOBILIZ$ AGA9/ !M4 ,9 EA* CAPITALI/ C\NTRY ! >MY IS ! /RONGE/ =CE 9 ! S]VICE ( ! CAPITALI/ CLASS1 BECAUSE = ITS W>S ) O!R C\NTRIES1 IT NE$S ! FIMY IS AN ORGANIZ$ BODY B\ND TOGE!R BY ! /RICTE/ MILIT>Y DISCIPL9E1 PROVID$ ) ! MO/ CRUEL1 REF9$ & EFFECTIVE MEANS ( KILL+ & DE/ROY+4 ,IF IT IS US$ 9 POLITICAL W>S1 :]E 9 ! WOR/ CASE ! CAPITALI/ CLASS SUFF]S ONLY HEAVY LOSSES1 IS IT NOT TO BE US$ !N 9 CASE ( REVOLUTION :]E ! CAPITALI/ CLASS IS M5AC$ ) COMPLETE LOSS ( ALL IT POSSESSES8 ,?US ! NATION IS ! /RONMY1 IT PROTECTS ! CAPITALI/ CLASS4 ,PHYSICAL =CE1 H[EV]1 IS NOT SUFFICI5T TO SUBDUE A PEOPLE OR A CLASS4 ,H[ MANY /RONG GOV]NM5TS 9 HI/ORY1 ?\< WELL->M$1 HAVE BE5 OV]?R[N BY REBELLIONS4 ,SPIRITUAL =CES 9 MO/ CASES >E DECISIVE ABOVE M]E PHYSICAL P[]4 ,9 CAPITALISM ! RULE HOLDS GOOD ?AT 9 ! LONG RUN IT IS MORE EFFECTUAL TO FOOL PEOPLE ?AN TO BEAT !M4 ,SO CAPITALI/ P[] CONSI/S ?IRDLY 9 ITS 9TELLECTUAL P[]4 ,! IDEAS ( A RUL+ CLASS P]VADE ! MAJORITY ( ! MEMB]S ( SOCIETY4 ,C]TA9LY ! CAPITALI/ CLASS C\LD NOT BUY GU>DS & 9TELLECTUALS IF !SE FELL[S DID NOT %>E ITS IDEOLOGY & S5TIM5TS4 ,CAPITALI/ GOV]NM5T C\LD NOT GOV]N1 EV5 ) ITS /RONG PHYSICAL =CE1 IF ! MASS ( ! PEOPLE W]E NOT FILL$ ) ! SAME SPIRIT AS ! GOV]NM5T ITSELF4 ,H[ IS IT POSSIBLE ?AT 9 ! MASS ( ! PEOPLE1 EV5 9 ! WORK+ CLASS1 ?IS CAPITALI/ SPIRIT PREVAILS8 ,! MA9 =CE IS TRADITION & 9H]ITANCE4 ,! IDEOLOGY ( ! CAPITALI/ CLASS IS NO?+ BUT ! IDEOLOGY ( ! =M] MIDDLE CLASSES1 ! PETTY PRODUC]S4 ,! IDEA ( PRIVATE PROP]TY AS A NATURAL RIANTEES ! BE/ RESULTS1 ! MAXIM ?AT EV]YONE HAS ONLY TO C>E = HIMSELF & ,GOD WILL TAKE C>E ( ! RE/1 ! CONVICTION ?AT ?RIFT & 9DU/RY >E ! VIRTUES :I* SECURE PROSP]ITY1 & ?AT ,AM]ICA IS ! BE/ C\NTRY & %\LD BE DEF5D$ AGA9/ O!R NATIONS1 ALL !SE BELIEFS >E 9H]IT$ FROM ! TIME & ! CLASS ( SMALL BUS9ESS4 ,& ?IS IS ! V]Y CRE$ BIG BUS9ESS WANTS ! MASSES TO BELIEVE 9 AS ET]NAL TRU?S TODAY4 ,! FA!RS OR GR&FA!RS ( ! PROLET>IANS ( TODAY W]E SU* SMALL BUS9ESS M5 !MSELVES2 SMALL F>M]S1 SETTL]S1 CRAFTSM51 EV5 SMALL CAPITALI/S1 RIDD5 D[N BY COMPETITION4 ,!Y1 TOO1 HAVE 9H]IT$ !SE IDEAS1 & 9 !IR Y\? F\ND !M TO BE TRUE4 ,!N SOCIETY *ANG$ RAPIDLY & BIG 9DU/RY DEVELOP$1 & !Y BECAME =EV] PROLET>IANS4 ,!IR IDEAS1 H[EV]1 C\LD NOT *ANGE SO RAPIDLY & !IR M9D CL+S TO ! OLD IDEOLOGY4 ,/ILL1 ! S*OOL ( LIFE IS P[]FUL & IMPRESSES ! M9D ) NEW IDEAS 9 L9E ) ! *ANG+ WORLD4 ,BUT N[ ! CAPITALI/ S*OOL COMES 9TO ACTION4 ,) ALL AVAILABLE MEANS1 ! CAPITALI/ IDEAS >E PROPAGAT$ & >TIFICIALLY =C$ UPON ! M9DS ( ! PEOPLE4 ,AT FIR/ 9 ! S*OOLS :5 ! *ILDR5'S M9DS >E FLEXIBLE & IMPRESSIONABLE2 AFT]W>DS = ! ADULTS FROM ! PULPIT1 9 ! DAILY PRESS1 BY ! RADIO1 ! MOVIES1 ETC4 ,!IR TASK IS NOT ONLY TO KEEP ! CAPITALI/IC WAY ( ?9K+ ALIVE 9 ! WORK+ CLASS M9DS1 BUT /ILL MORE1 TO PREV5T !M ?9K+ AT ALL4 ,BY FILL+ !IR TIME & !IR M9DS ) EXCIT+ FUTILITIES1 !Y KILL EV]Y WI% = S]I\S READ+ & ?9K+4 ,MAY ?IS BE CALL$ FOOL+ ! WORK]S8 ,! CAPITALI/IC CLASS IS S9C]E 9 ?IS PROPAG&A2 IT BELIEVES :AT IT TRIES TO URGE UPON ! WORK]S4 ,BUT CAPITALI/IC IDEOLOGY IS FOOLI%NESS = ! WORK]S4 ,! WORK]S HAVE TO FO/] ! NEW IDEAS ?AT >E GR[+ \T ( ! *ANG+ WORLD2 !Y HAVE TO ACQUIRE ! KN[L$GE ( ! EVOLUTION ( LABOR & ( ! CLASS /RUGGLE AS ! WAY TO COMMUNISM4 ,?US ! P[] ( ! CAPITALI/ CLASS IS MORE ?AN !IR MONEY & POLITICAL P[] ALONE4 ,! SMALL BUS9ESS M51 ! SMALL F>M]S1 :O BELIEVE !Y WILL SUCCE$ BY P]SONAL EF=T -- AS SOMETIMES !Y DO -- >E A P>T ( ! CAPITALI/ P[]4 ,EV]Y WORKMAN :O ONLY C>ES = HIMSELF & NOT = ! FUTURE ( HIS CLASS1 EV]Y WORKM5 :O ONLY READS CAPITALI/ NEWSPAP]S & F9DS HIS *IEF 9T]E/ 9 BOX+ MAT*ES1 ETC41 BY SO DO+ CONTRIBUTES TO ! P[] ( ! CAPITALI/ CLASS4 ,9 ! RAPID DEVELOPM5T ( TE*NICAL & ECONOMIC =MS ( PRODUCTION1 ! M9D ( MAN IS LEFT BEH9D4 ,?IS M5TAL BACKW>DNESS ( ! WORK+ MASSES IS ! *IEF P[] ( ! CAPITALI/ CLASS4 ,I,I ,:AT P[] CAN ! WORK+ CLASS SET =? AGA9/ IT8 ,FIR/1 ! WORK+ CLASS IS ! MO/ NUM]\S CLASS 9 SOCIETY4 ,BY ! GR[? ( 9DU/RY IT CONT9UALLY 9CREASES1 :]EAS ! NUMB] ( 9DEP5D5T BUS9ESSM5 HAS RELATIVELY DECREAS$4 ,! AVAILABLE /ATI/ICS %[ ?AT 9 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES ! WORK+ CLASS IS ! L>GE/ CLASS4 ,ONLY ! F>M]S & ! SAL>I$ EMPLOYES FOLL[ AT SOME DI/ANCE AS IMPORTANT CLASSES4 ,! CAPITALI/ CLASS PROP] IS 9SIGNIFICANT 9 NUMB]S2 & ! SMALL & MIDDLE CLASS M5 & PETTY DEAL]S >E MU* LESS NUM]\S ?AN ! WAGE WORK]S4 ,BUT NUMB] IS NOT ! ONLY ?+ ?AT C\NTS4 ,A NUMB] ( MILLIONS1 DISP]S$ 9 WIDELY SEP>AT$ HOMES ALL OV] ! L&1 CANNOT EX]T ! SAME P[] AS ! SAME NUMB] ( MILLIONS PRESS$ TOGE!R 9 ! T[NS4 ,! BIG T[NS >E ! C5T]S ( ECONOMICAL1 CULTURAL & POLITICAL LIFE4 ,! MILLIONS ( WORK]S1 =M+ ! MAJORITIES 9 ! POPULATION 9 !SE C5T]S1 ASSEMBL$ 9TO BIG CLASS-AGGLOM]ATIONS1 MU/1 UND] !SE CONDITIONS EX]T A /RONG SOCIAL P[]4 ,9 ANCI5T ,ROME ! PROLET>IANS W]E NUM]\S ALSO1 & /RONGLY CONC5TRAT$4 ,!IR SOCIAL P[]1 H[EV]1 WAS NO?+ BECAUSE !Y DID NOT WORK4 ,!Y W]E P>ASITES2 !Y LIV$ FROM PUBLIC MONEYS4 ,) ! MOD]N PROLET>IANS1 ! MATT] IS ! REV]SE4 ,! SECOND ELEM5T ( P[] = ! WORK+ CLASS IS ITS IMPORTANCE 9 HUMAN SOCIETY4 ,IT IS ON !IR WORK ?AT SOCIETY IS F\ND$4 ,! CAPITALI/S MIM]S CAN BE COMP>$4 ,! WORK]S HAVE !IR H& ON ! PRODUCTION APP>ATUS4 ,!Y MANAGE IT2 !Y WORK IT2 !Y COMM& IT2 !Y HAVE DIRECT P[] OV] IT4 ,NOT LEGALLY1 = LEGALLY !Y HAVE TO OBEY ! CAPITALI/S1 & POLICE & SOLDI]S MAY COME TO 5=CE ?IS LEGAL RICASS4 ,IF !Y REFUSE TO WORK1 SOCIETY CANNOT EXI/4 ,IT HAS HAPP5$ ALREADY1 ?AT A G5]AL /RIKE HAS P>ALYZ$ ! 5TIRE ECONOMIC & SOCIAL LIFE1 & !REBY WRUNG IMPORTANT CONCESSIONS FROM ! UNWILL+ RUL+ CLASS4 ,!N = A MOM5T1 LIKE A FLA% ( LIIAN CLASS1 ITS 9TIMATE CONNECTION ) ! PRODUCTION APP>ATUS1 WAS DISCLOS$4 ,TO BE SURE1 IF ?IS POSSIBLE P[] IS TO BECOME A LIV+1 ACTUAL P[]1 A WEIIAN P[]1 WE F9D SOLID>ITY1 ! SPIRIT ( UNITY1 ORGANIZATION4 ,SOLID>ITY IS ! BOND ?AT UNITES ! WILL ( ALL ! SEP>ATE 9DIVIDUALS 9TO ONE COMMON WILL1 ?US A*IEV+ ONE MIIAN VIRTUE8 ,DOES NOT CAPITALISM ITSELF PRACTICE ORGANIZATION & UNIT$ ACTION 9 ITS FACTORIES1 9 ITS TRU/S1 9 ITS >MIES8 ,H]E ! UNITY IS BAS$ UPON COMM&1 UPON F9ES1 UPON P5ALTIES4 ,C]TA9LY1 = COMMON 9T]E/S COMB9$ ACTION MU/ TAKE PLACE 9 EA* CLASS1 BUT H]E AGA9 ! TRUE ECONOMIC POSITION MANIFE/S ITSELF1 ?AT CAPITALI/S >E COMPETITORS1 & WORK]S >E COMRADES4 ,CAPITALISM IS BAS$ UPON PRIVATE BUS9ESS1 PRIVATE 9T]E/S4 ,! MORE EAG]LY ! CAPITALI/ PURSUES HIS P]SONAL 9T]E/S1 ! BETT] = HIS BUS9ESS4 ,H5CE A H>D EGOTISM IS DEVELOP$ ?AT SUBM]GES NATURAL HUMAN SYMPA?IES4 ,! WORK]S1 ON ! O!R H&1 CANNOT W9 ANY?+ BY EGOTISM4 ,SO LONG AS !Y FACE CAPITAL 9DIVIDUALLY1 !Y >E P[]LESS & MIS]ABLE2 ONLY BY COLLECTIVE ACTION CAN !Y W9 BETT] CONDITIONS4 ,! MORE !Y PURSUE P]SONAL 9T]E/S1 ! MORE !Y >E BEAT5 D[N4 ,! MORE !Y DEVELOP A FEEL+ ( FELL[%IP1 ( MUTUAL AID1 ( SELF-SACRIFICE = !IR CLASS1 ! BETT] IT IS = !IR 9T]E/S4 ,:5 AT ! DAWN ( CIVILIZATION1 PRIVATE PROP]TY CAME 9TO BE+1 M5 SEP>AT$1 EA* TO WORK ON HIS [N LOT1 9 ORD] TO DEVELOP PRODUCTIVITY ( LABOR 9 MUTUAL COMPETITION4 ,9 ?IS C5TURY-LONG DEVELOPM5T1 FROM SMALL CRAFTS TO MOD]N 9DU/RY1 CIVILIZ$ MAN ROSE TO A /URDY SELF-DET]M9ISM1 TO 9DEP5D5CE1 TO CONFID5CE 9 HIS [N P[]S & TO A /RONG FEEL+ ( 9DIVIDUALISM4 ,ALL HIS 5]GIES & FACULTIES W]E AWAK5$ TO ! S]VICE OR HIS FIIAT IS COM+ UP1 = ! FIR/ TIME A CLASS )\T PROP]TY1 H5CE )\T REAL 9T]E/S ONE AGA9/ ! O!R4 ,/ILL 5D[$ ) ! P]SONAL 5]GIES & FACULTIES 9H]IT$ FROM !IR ANCE/ORS1 !Y >E TRA9$ BY ! MA*9E 9TO ! DISCIPL9E ( COMMON ACTION4 ,& ?\< !IR ATTEMPTS = A BETT] LIV+ /&>D >E HELPLESSLY BEAT5 D[N BY ! OV]:ELM+ P[] ( CAPITALISM1 MU* GOOD COMES FROM !SE ATTEMPTS4 ,!IR COMMON 9T]E/S AGA9/ ! CAPITALI/ CLASS AWAK5S 9 !M ! FEEL+S ( BRO!RHOOD4 ,AS ! WORK+ CLASS F9DS /R5G? 9 ITS MORAL SUP]IORITY OV] ! CAPITALI/ CLASS1 IT ALSO F9DS /R5G? 9 ITS 9TELLECTUAL SUP]IORITY4 ,TO ! FEEL+ IS ADD$ ! KN[L$GE4 ,FIR/ COMES ! DE$1 ! ACTION ( SOLID>ITY1 ?AT SPR+S SPONTANE\SLY FROM ! DEP? ( EMOTION & PASSION4 ,AFT] ?AT COMES ! 9SIE SE5 MORE CLE>LY2 & AS IS ! CASE ( ALL SCI5CE1 ?IS 9SIITY1 ?IS KN[L$GE IS ! F\R? ELEM5T 9 PROLET>IAN P[]4 ,IT IS ! SCI5CE DEVELOP$ *IEFLY BY ,M>X & ,5GELS :I* EXPLA9S1 FIR/1 ! C\RSE ( HI/ORY FROM ! GR[? ( SOCIETY 9 ITS PRIMITIVE BEG9N+S1 ?R\< FEUDALISM & CAPITALISM1 !NCE TO COMMUNISM1 BAS+ ?IS ANALYSIS UPON ! DEVELOPM5T ( LABOR & ITS PRODUCTIVITY4 ,& SECOND1 IT EXPLA9S ! /RUCTURE ( CAPITALI/ PRODUCTION & %[S H[ CAPITALISM MU/ BREAK D[N BY MEANS ( ITS [N =CES1 BY DEVELOP+ & EXPLOIT+ ! PROLET>IAN CLASS1 BY DRIV+ IT 9TO REVOLT ?R\< ITS [N COLLAPSES1 & BY 9CREAS+ !REBY ! PROLET>IANS' FIXISM1 IS A PROLET>IAN SCI5CE4 ,! CAPITALI/ CLASS REJECTS IT2 ITS SCI5TI/S D5Y ITS TRU?4 ,9DE$1 IT IS IMPOSSIBLE = ! CAPITALI/ CLASS TO ACCEPT IT4 ,NO CLASS CAN ACCEPT A !ORY ?AT PROCLAIMS ITS [N COLLAPSE & DEA?2 = BY ACCEPT+ IT1 IT C\LD NOT FIY 9/9CT1 9 A CLASS AS WELL AS 9 AN ORGANISM4 ,! CAPITALI/ CLASS CANNOT SEE BEYOND ! HORIZON ( CAPITALISM4 ,SO IT SEES ! GR[+ CONC5TRATION ( CAPITAL1 ! GR[+ P[] ( BIG F9ANCE1 ! HEAVY CRISES & ! IMP5D+ WORLD W>S1 ! RIS+ TIDE ( ! PROLET>IAN FIDU\S C\RSE TO ! FUTURE4 ,IT MAKES CLE> TO !M !IR LIFE1 !IR WORK1 !IR POV]TY1 !IR RELATION TO !IR EMPLOY]S1 & TO ! O!R CLASSES4 ,IT EXPLA9S TO !M ! REALITY ( ! WORLD AS !Y EXP]I5CE IT1 DIFF]5T 9DE$ FROM ! CAPITALI/ TEA*+S4 ,:]EAS ! S*OOL ( LIFE IMPRESSES !IR M9DS ) NEW IDEAS 9 L9E ) ! NEW WORLD1 IT IS ?IS SCI5CE ( SOCIETY ?AT MOLDS !SE IDEAS 9TO A FIRM CONSI/5T KN[L$GE4 ,& SO ! WORK]S WILL EV5TUALLY ACQUIRE ! WISDOM !Y NE$ 9 !IR FIXI/S4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,M>* #a1 #bba 3 ,! ,P[] ( ! ,CLASSES -- ,ADD$4 ,JANU>Y #h1 #bbb 3 ,! ,P[] ( ! ,CLASSES -- ,UPDAT$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/