,*APT] #af ,TATIAN & ! ,FABRICATION ( ! ,NEW ,TE/AM5T #aiicaiic ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,RA\L ,VANEIGEM ,TEXT 3 ,*APT] #a#f3 ,TATIAN & ! ,FABRICATION ( ! ,NEW ,TE/AM5T ,BORN 9 ,SYRIA >\ND #a#b1 ,TATIAN PO/HUM\SLY BECAME ONE ( ! F\ND]S ( ! ,*UR* DUE TO HIS EXTREMISM 9 MATT]S ( ASCETICISM4 ,IR5AEUS ATTACK$ HIM BECAUSE1 0LIKE ,M>CION & ,SATORNIL1 HE CALL$ M>RIAGE A CORRUPTION & DEBAU*]Y4 ,HE MA9TA9$ ?AT ,ADAM WAS NOT SAV$40.<#b#e#f.> ,CONV]T$ TO ,*RI/IANITY1 & A DISCIPLE ( ,JU/9 9 ,ROME1 ,TATIAN WAS EXPOS$ TO ! ATTACKS ( ,CRESC5TIUS1 ,JU/9'S ACCUS]4 ,TEA*+ ,*RI/IANITY 9 ,ROME >\ND #a#g#b-#a#g#c1 HE PR(ESS$ ! ANTI-,M>CIONISM ( HIS MA/] & TRANSMITT$ IT TO HIS DISCIPLE1 ,RHODON4 ,!N HE LEFT = ! ,EA/ & F\ND$ S*OOLS :ILE ! ,NEW ,PROPHECY TOOK (F4 ,ONE SUPPOSES ?AT HE DI$ AT ! 5D ( ?AT DECADE4 ,TATIAN'S S+LE KN[N WORK FALLS UND] ! HEAD+ ( ! APOLOGETIC4 ,HIS ,SPEE* TO ! ,GREEKS OPPOS$ ,*RI/IANITY TO ,GREEK PHILOSOPHY 9 G5]AL & ! ,/OICS 9 P>TICUL>4 ,9 IT HE DEVELOP$ IDEAS %>$ BY ,T]TULLIAN & ! NEW POPUL> CURR5T4 ,HIS PR(ESSION ( MONO!I/ FAI? CONTRADICT$ ACCUSATIONS ( DUALISM1 :I* W]E (T5 MADE AB\T HIM BY ! ,CA?OLICS4 ,ON ! O!R H&1 HIS IDEA ( ! ,*RI/ HAD NOT EVOLV$ S9CE ,JU/93 0,! CELE/IAL ,LOGOS1 SPIRIT BORN FROM ! ,FA!R & REASON ISSU$ FROM ! REASONABLE P[] -- 9 IMITATION ( ! ,FA!R :O 5G5D]$ HIM -- MADE MAN 9 ! IMAGE ( IMMORTALITY1 SO ?AT1 TO ! EXT5T 9CORRUPTIBILITY IS 9 ,GOD1 MAN LIKEWISE P>TICIPATES 9 ! LOT ( ,GOD & POSSESSES IMMORTALITY4 ,BUT BE=E =M+ MAN1 ! ,LOGOS CREAT$ ! ANGELS40.<#b#e#g.> ,! HOLY SPIRIT IS CALL$ ! M9I/] ( ,GOD :O SUFF]$4 ,TATIAN'S ESSAY ,ON ,P]FECTION1 ,ACCORD+ TO ! ,SAVIOR IS LO/1 BUT ,CLEM5T ( ,ALEX&RIA PICK$ \T ( IT AN ABSOLUTE CONDEMNATION ( M>RIAGE ?AT SURPASSES ! ,MONTANI/ SPIRIT4 ,! ,*UR* PR(IT$ BY ]ECT+ ,TATIAN AS ! LEAD] ( A PHANTOM H]ESY CALL$ ,5CRATISM1 9 :I* W]E GR\P$ TOGE!R -- ?ANKS TO ! ,*UR*'S ,F\R? ,C5TURY /RUGGLE AGA9/ ! ,DONATI/S & ! ,CIRCONCELLIONS -- ! SUPPORT]S ( AN EXCESSIVE MORAL RIGOR4 ,NO D\BT !RE WAS ANO!R REASON = ! ANIMOSITY ( ! ,*UR* T[>DS ,TATIAN4 ,DES*N] CITES HIM AS AMONG ! COPYI/S :O RE-WORK$ ! LETT]S ( ,PAUL & GAVE !M A /YLI/IC UNITY4.<#b#e#h.> ,! WAVE ( POPUL> ,*RI/IANITY 5G5D]$ A G5]AL REVIVAL ( ! ,JEWI% MIDRA%IM1 TRANSLAT$ SOMEH[ OR O!R BY ! ,JUDEO-,*RI/IANS1 & 9 NE$ ( BE+ DE-,JUDAIZ$ & EXPLA9$ RATIONALLY TO ! G5]AL PUBLIC4 ,TATIAN HAS BE5 CR$IT$ ) HAV+ H>MONIZ$ 79 ADDITION TO ,PAUL'S LETT]S7 ! MANY PROPAG&I/IC TEXTS ?AT W]E PASS$ (F AS ! GOSPEL PREA*$ BY ! ,APO/LE1 BECAUSE !RE WAS ONLY ONE AT ! TIME4 ,NEV]!LESS1 NEI!R ,IR5AEUS1 ,T]TULLIAN1 NOR ,CLEM5T ( ,ALEX&RIA M5TION$ ! ,DIATESS>ON EUAGGELION1 :I* W\LD REMA9 UNTIL ! ,FIF? ,C5TURY ! DOGMATIC WORK P> EXCELL5CE ( ! ,SYRIAN ,*RI/IAN *UR*ES BE=E BE+ REPLAC$ BY ! F\R GOSPELS ( ! ,CA?OLIC ,*UR*4 ,A ,GREEK FRAGM5T ( #ad L9ES RECOV]$ AT ,DURA-,EUROPOS DATES FROM #bc AT ! LATE/4 ,IT PROPOSES PLAC+ 5D TO 5D ! FRAGM5TS ( ! GOSPELS ATTRIBUT$ TO ,M>K1 ,LUKE & ,MAT!W4 ,IS ?IS ! ,DIATESS>ON &1 IF SO1 IS IT ?AT ( ,TATIAN8 ,H[ COME ,T]TULLIAN1 AN ADMIR] ( ,TATIAN1 DOES NOT M5TION IT8 ,AS F> AS ! FRAGM5TS BY ,IR5AEUS1 !Y HAVE BE5 ALT]$ TOO MU* TO (F] A S]I\S TE/IMONY CONC]N+ ! CANONICAL GOSPELS 9 ! ,SECOND ,C5TURY4.<#b#e#i.> ,! ,CANONICAL ,GOSPELS ,:AT ASPECT DID ,*RI/IANITY PRES5T AT ! 5D ( ! ,SECOND ,C5TURY8 ,AL?\< ! ,GREEKS & ,ROMANS DID NOT DI/+UI% IT FROM ,JUDAISM & CONFUS$ ! SECT>IANS ( ,JESUS1 ! ,SE?IANS1 ! ,NAASS5ES1 ! ,B>BELITES & O!R MESSIANI/S1 ! ,NEW ,PROPHECY IMPLANT$ 9 ! URBAN MILIEU A POPUL> ,*RI/IANITY ?AT ATTRACT$ SLAVES1 A FRACTION ( ! PLEBES & ! PETITE B\RGEOIS 7?US A FR+E ( ! >I/OCRACY1 AS WELL71 UNTIL !N RA!R RECEPTIVE TO ,GNO/IC DOCTR9ES & PHILOSOPHICAL ,*RISIANITY4 ,IF ! IMPORTANCE ACCORD$ TO FAI?1 TO LIFE ACCORD+ TO ! ,*RI/1 TO ASCETICISM1 TO ! REFUSAL ( RI*ES & TO ! VOCATION ( M>TYRDOM R$UC$ ,GNO/ICISM TO A M>G9AL EXI/5CE1 :I* ,*RI/IANITY W\LD NEV]!LESS EXPLOIT 9 ! G5ESIS ( ITS !OLOGY1 ,GNO/ICISM WAS EMBRAC$ BY A GOOD NUMB] ( BI%OPS & HEADS ( COMMUNITIES :O1 S9CE ,TRAJAN'S CONV5TIONS 7R5EW$ BY ,HADRIAN71 HAD BE5 9TEGRAT$ 9TO PUBLIC LIFE &1 C>EFUL TO AVOID ALL SC&AL1 ALREADY C>RI$ !MSELVES AS IF !Y W]E FUTURE ECCLESIA/ICAL BUREAUCRATS ( ! TRIUMPHANT ,*UR*4 ,! >DOR & FANATICISM ( ! POOR ,*RI/IANS EMB>RASS$ ! LAX BI%OPS ( ! ,SECOND ,C5TURY4 ,!Y W\LD =M ! PROTO-,CA?OLIC CURR5T OR1 MORE EXACTLY1 W\LD BE *OS5 9 ! ,F\R?1 ,FIF? & ,SIX? ,C5TURIES AS ! REPRES5TATIVES ( A BACK-DAT$ OR?ODOXY4 ,ECCLESIA/ICAL RETIC5CE9CREAS$ ! NUMB] ( LAPSI1 SUPPLEM5T$ BY ! P]SECUTIONS ( ! ,?IRD ,C5TURY1 :]EAS ,MONTANI/ 9TRANSIG5CE WAS P]PETUAT$ AMONG ! P>TISANS ( ,NOVATIAN &1 MU* LAT]1 ,DONAT4 ,! MIDRA%IM ( ! ,EL*ASAITE & ,JUDEO-,*RI/IAN ,*UR*ES CONF]R$ A LEGITIMACY TO P>TICUL> & (T5 RIVAL *UR*ES3 ! *UR*ES ( ,?OMAS1 ,SIMON-,PET]1 ,JACOB1 ,SAUL-,PAUL1 ,CLEM5T1 ,PHILIPPE1 ,MAT?IAS444 ,! UNITY IMPOS$ BY ! GREAT MOVEM5T ( ! ,NEW ,PROPHECY COLLAT$ WRIT+S ( DIV]SE ORIG9S1 TRANSLAT$ SEV]AL TIMES FROM ! ,HEBREW OR ,>AMAIC1 :I* W]E REVIS$ & IMITAT$4 ,! UNUSUAL 5SEMBLE !N GAVE BIR? TO A ,PROPAG&A-LIT]ATURE ADAPT$ TO ! POPUL> BRU%WORK . ( ! MOVEM5T4 ,ANTI-,SEMITISM1 MIRACUL\S FABLES & ! EXALTATION ( POV]TY & SACRIFICE LITTLE BY LITTLE COMPOS$ A ,JESUS :O WAS BETT] CON=M$ TO ! PLEBIAN M9DSET4 ,! APO/LES1 9ITIALLY ! WITNESSES ( ! ,LORD1 :OSE MY?ICAL AU?ORITY GU>ANTE$ SU* & SU* A COMMUNITY1 !NCE=? =M$ A COHORT *>G$ ) PROPAGAT+ ! ,*RI/IAN LAW ?AT WAS SUB/ITUT$ = ,MOSAIC LAW4 ,! APO/LES ]ECT$ AS SA9TS & M>TYRS S]V$ AS MODELS = ! EXALTATION ( ! ,*RI/IANS ( ,C>?AGE1 ,SCILI1 ,LYON1 ,VI5NA & ,ROME4 ,! ,ACTS CIRCULAT$1 TELL+ ( ! M>VEL\S ADV5TURES1 DEA?S & ASC5SIONS ( ,PET]1 ,PAUL1 ,B>NABAS1 ,PHILIPPE1 ,&REW & ,JACOB1 :O W]E ! H]OES ( A SAGA DOM9AT$ BY ,JO%UA1 CUT FROM ! SAME CLO? AS ! ,*RI/IANS :O CAUS$ SC&ALS & P]I%$ = !IR FAI?4 ,JU/9.<#b#f.> & ,T]TULLIAN.<#b#f#a.> M5TION$ ! ,ACTS ( ,PILATE4 7,AUGM5T$ 9 ! ,FIF? ,C5TURY BY A DESCRIPTION ( HELL1 ! ,ACTS W\LD 9 ! ,EIIMA!A & ! ,GRAIL APPE>$4 ,! ,ACTS WAS ORIG9ALLY A ,MONTANI/ OR PRE-,MONTANI/ TEXT ?AT HAD BE5 EXCLUD$ FROM ! CANON47 ,HELD AS A SA9T & M>TYR 9 ,SYRIA & ,EGYPT1 ,PILATE /ILL BELONG$ TO A DRAMATURGY 9 :I* ! ANGELOS-*RI/OS 5T]$ 9TO A BRIEF T]RE/RIAL EXI/5CE 9 A HI/ORICAL CONTEXT4 ,! ,ACTS ( ,PILATE CONTA9 ! MAT]IALS ?AT W\LD S]VE1 9 ! H&S ( COPYI/S LESS EXALT$ & MORE C>EFUL ) HI/ORICAL PROBABILITY1 9TO ! FABRICATION ( ! CANONICAL ,GOSPELS3 0,IT WAS ! SIX? H\R2 AN OBSCURITY COV]$ ! 5TIRE WORLD UNTIL ! N9? H\R4 ,! SUN WAS OBSCUR$3 ! VEIL ( ! TEMPLE W5T FROM ON HI< TO D[N BEL[1 & CUT IT 9 TWO4 ,JESUS CRI$ 9 A L\D VOICE3 ,MY ,FA!R1 ,ABI1 ,ADAS*1 ,EPHKIDON1 ,ADONAI1 ,SABEL1 ,L\EL1 ,ELOEI1 ,ELEMAS1 ,ABLAKANEI1 ,ORIO?1 ,MIO?1 ,\AO?1 ,S\N1 ,P]9E?1 ,JO?AT40.<#b#f#b.> ,! NAMES EVOK$ BY ,JESUS1 :I* ID5TIFI$ HIM ) A MAGICIAN OR A ?AUMATURGI/1 CORRESPOND$ TO ! ,EONS ( P[] ?AT W]E FIGUR$ UPON ! ABRAXAS OR TALISMANS ( MAGIC RITUALS4.<#b#f#c.> ,T]TULLIAN'S RECITAL 9 HIS ,APOLOGETICS M]ITS BE+ QUOT$ BECAUSE1 EFFAC+ ?AUMATURGICAL ASPECTS1 IT CON/ITU$ A MORE SOB] & YET V]Y DIFF]5T V]SION ?AN ?AT RETA9$ BY ! ,CA?OLIC CANON4 ,! ,*RI/ WAS /ILL ! ANGELOS-*RI/OS1 BUT PREY TO A T]RE/RIAL DRAMA ?AT WAS P]FECTLY UND]/&ABLE BY ! FAI?FUL :O W]E HEAD$ T[>DS PUNI%M5T & A RADIANT CELE/IAL RESURRECTION3 ,?US1 :AT COMES FROM ,GOD IS ,GOD1 ! ,SON ( ,GOD1 & ! TWO MAKE ONLY ONE4 ,?US ! SPIRIT ?AT COMES FROM ! SPIRIT & ! ,GOD :O COMES FROM ,GOD >E DIFF]5T 9 POSITION .1 HE IS SECOND 9 RANK1 NOT 9 SITUATION1 & HE CAME FROM HIS S\RCE )\T BE+ DETA*$ FROM IT4 ,?US1 ?IS RAY ( ,GOD1 AS HE HAD ALWAYS =ETOLD1 DESC5D$ AS A ,VIRG9 &1 BE+ 9C>NAT$ 9 H] WOMB1 HE WAS BORN MAN MIX$ ) ,GOD4 ,! FLE% UNIT$ ) ! SPIRIT1 N\RI%$ ITSELF1 GREW1 SPOKE1 TAU TO Y\RS71 :ILE WAIT+ = ME TO %[ Y\ H[ ! ,*RI/ WAS TE/$ & :O W]E ?OSE :O1 9 ADVANCE1 CIRCULAT$ AMONG Y\ FABLES ( ?IS TYPE1 SO AS TO DE/ROY ?IS TRU?4 ,! ,JEWS ALSO KNEW ?AT ! ,*RI/ W\LD COME1 BECAUSE ! PROPHETS HAD SPOK5 TO !M4 ,&1 9DE$1 EV5 TODAY1 !Y AWAIT HIS COM+1 & BETWE5 !M & US !RE IS NO GREAT] SUBJECT ( CONTE/ATION ?AN !IR REFUSAL TO BELIEVE ?AT HE HAS ALREADY COME4 ,BECAUSE TWO ASC5SIONS ( ! ,*RI/S W]E ANN\NC$3 ONE ?AT W\LD BE ACCOMPLI%$ 9 ! HUMILITY ( ! HUMAN CONDITION2 ANO!R ?AT WAS EXPECT$ AT ! 5D ( ! WORLD .1 9 ! SUBLIME SPL5DOR ( ! PAT]NAL P[] RECEIV$ & ! DIV9ITY CLE>LY MANIFE/$4 ,!RE=E1 ! ,JEWS -- NOT UND]/&+ ! FIR/ -- BELIEVE ?AT ! SECOND WAS UNIQUE1 & !Y HOP$ = IT AS IT WAS CLE>LY =ETOLD4 ,BY !IR S91 ! ,JEWS HAVE 9DE$ M]IT$ BE+ UNABLE TO UND]/& ! FIR/ ONE3 !Y BELIEV$ IT1 IF !Y UND]/OOD IT & !Y HAD SALVATION1 IF !Y BELIEV$ IT4 ,!Y !MSELVES SAY 9 ! ,SCRIPTURES ?AT !Y HAVE BE5 DEPRIV$ ( WISDOM1 9TELLIG5CE & ! USAGE ( !IR EYES & E>S1 AS A PUNI%M5T4 ,9 !IR ABASEM5T1 ! ,JEWS HAVE ?US CONCLUD$ ?AT HE .<,JESUS.> IS ONLY A MAN2 & NATURALLY1 BECAUSE ( HIS P[]1 !Y TAKE HIM = A MAGICIAN3 ACTUALLY !Y SEE HIM1 ACCORD+ TO HIS [N WORD1 *AS+ DEMONS FROM ! BODIES ( M51 GIV+ SIALYZ$1 F9ALLY1 MAK+ ! DEAD COME BACK TO LIFE1 ALWAYS ACCORD+ TO HIS WORD1 MAK+ ! ELEM5TS S]VE HIM1 CALM+ ! TEMPE/S & WALK+ ON ! WAT]S1 ?US %[+ ?AT HE WAS .<9DE$.> ! ,SON PREVI\SLY ANN\NC$ BY ,GOD1 & BORN = ! SALVATION ( ALL1 ?IS ,WORD ( ,GOD1 ET]NAL1 FIR/-BORN1 ACCOMPANI$ BY HIS P[] & 9TELLIG5CE1 HAV+ HIS SPIRIT = SUPPORT4 ,HE>+ ! PREA*+ ( HIS DOCTR9ES1 :I* CONFUS$ ! DOCTORS & NOTABLES AMONG ! ,JEWS1 :O W]E EXASP]AT$1 ESPECIALLY :5 !Y SAW AN IMM5SE MULTITUDE FLOCK+ TO HIM3 TO ! PO9T ?AT1 F9ALLY1 !Y DELIV]$ HIM TO ,PONTIUS ,PILATE1 :O !N GOV]N$ ,SYRIA 9 ! NAME ( ! ,ROMANS &1 ?R\< ! VIOL5CE ( !IR PUBLIC APPROVAL .1 !Y =C$ ! PRO-CURATOR TO SURR5D] ,JESUS SO AS TO PUT HIM ON A CROSS4 ,HE HIMSELF HAD =ETOLD ?AT !Y W\LD ACT ?US2 ?IS W\LD NOT HAVE BE5 MU*1 HAD NOT ! PROPHETS ALSO =ETOLD IT4 ,& YET1 ATTA*$ TO ! CROSS1 HE MADE MANY WOND]FUL REM>KS AB\T HIS DEA?4 ,9DE$1 FROM HIMSELF HE R5D]$ HIS S\L ) HIS LA/ WORDS1 =ESEE+ ! S]VICE ( ! EXECUTION]2 AT ! SAME MOM5T1 ! DAY WAS DEPRIV$ ( ! SUN1 AT ! MOM5T ?AT HE M>K$ ! PLACE ( HIS ORB4 ,ONE C]TA9LY BELIEVES ?AT ?IS WAS AN ECLIPSE1 & ?OSE :O DO NOT KN[ ?AT ?IS WOND] HAD ALSO BE5 =ETOLD = ! DEA? ( ! ,*RI/1 NOT UND]/&+ ! REASON1 D5Y IT & YET Y\ F9D ?IS GLOBAL ACCID5T SET D[N 9 Y\R >*IVES4 ,! ,JEWS1 AFT] HAV+ DETA*$ ! BODY . & AFT] HAV+ DEPOSIT$ 9 IT A SEPUL*]1 SURVEILL$ IT ) GREAT C>E1 US+ A MILIT>Y GU>D3 AS HE HAD =ETOLD ?AT HE W\LD RISE FROM ! DEAD ON ! ?IRD DAY1 ! ,JEWS FE>$ ?AT HIS DISCIPLES1 FURTIVELY REMOV+ ! CADAV]1 W\LD DECEIVE !IR SUSPICIONS4 ,BUT ON ! ?IRD DAY1 ! E>? SUDD5LY TREMBL$1 ! 5ORM\S ROCK PLAC$ ON ! SEPUL*] WAS SET ASIDE1 ! GU>D -- /RUCK BY FRIY & DEP5D5T UPON ! ,JEWS1 SPREAD ! RUMOR ?AT HE HAD BE5 RESCU$ BY HIS DISCIPLES4 ,ACTUALLY1 HE DID NOT APPE> BE=E ! MULTITUDES1 SO AS TO NOT UPROOT ! IMPI\S FROM !IR ]ROR & SO ?AT FAI?1 DE/9$ = A QUITE PRECISE COMP5SATION1 WAS CO/LY TO M54 ,BUT ,JESUS PASS$ =TY DAYS ) SEV]AL DISCIPLES 9 ,GALILEE1 9 ! PROV9CE ( ,JUDEA1 :]E HE TAU? &1 5VELOP$ 9 A CL\D1 HE ROSE TO HEAV53 AN ASC5SION QUITE A BIT TRU] ?AN ! ONE Y\R ,PROCULUS CU/OM>ILY ATTRIBUTES TO ,ROMULUS4 ,PILATE1 :O WAS HIMSELF ALREADY A ,*RI/IAN 9 HIS HE>T1 ANN\NC$ ALL ( !SE FACTS RELATIVE TO ! ,*RI/ TO ,TIB]IUS1 !N ,CEAS>4 7"97 ,! ,CEAS>S !MSELVES W\LD HAVE BELIEV$ 9 ! ,*RI/1 IF ! ,CES>S W]E NECESS>Y TO ! WORLD OR IF ! ,CEAS>S HAD BE5 ,*RI/IANS AS WELL AS ,CEAS>S4 7"97 ,IT IS NO D\BT FROM ! ,*RI/IAN LEG5D ( ,PILATE ?AT ! HI/ORICAL /AG+ ( ! TRIAL ( ,JESUS ! AGITATOR WAS DRAWN4 ,! EV5TS H]E COME UND] ! HEAD+S ( COSMIC DRAMATURGY & HI]OPHANY4 ,AS F> AS ! DISCIPLES1 SCATT]$ ?R\<\T ! WORLD1 !Y OBEY$ ! PRECEPTS ( !IR DIV9E ,MA/]2 AFT] SEE+ MANY SUFF] AT ! H&S ( ,JEWI% P]SECUTORS1 CONFID5T 9 ! TRU?1 !Y 5D$ BY SPILL+ . ) JOY !IR ,*RI/IAN BLOOD 9 ,ROME1 DUR+ ! CRUEL P]SECUTIONS ( ,N]O4 ,BUT WE WILL %[ Y\ IRRECUSABLE WITNESSES TO ! ,*RI/1 EV5 AMONG ?OSE :OM Y\ ADORE4 ,IT IS A GREAT PO9T1 :I* ,I CAN MAKE TO OBLIGE Y\ TO BELIEVE ! ,*RI/IANS1 EV5 ?OSE :OM Y\ H9D] FROM BELIEV+ ! ,*RI/IANS4 ,= ! MOM5T1 H]E IS ! *RONOLOGICAL HI/ORY ( \R RELIGION2 H]E IS1 WE DECL>E1 ! ORIG9 ( \R SECT & \R NAME1 ) !IR AU?OR4 ,ONE NO LONG] REPROA*ES US = ANY 9FAMY1 ONE DOES NOT IMAG9E ?AT !RE IS SOME?+ ELSE1 BECAUSE IT IS NOT P]MITT$ = ANYONE TO LIE AB\T HIS RELIGION4 ,9DE$1 BY SAY+ ?AT ONE ADORES ANO!R ?+ ?AN :AT ONE . ADORES1 ONE D5IES :AT ONE ADORES & ONE TRANSPORTS ONE'S HOMAGES TO ANO!R .1 & BY TRANSPORT+ !M1 ONE NO LONG] ADORES :AT ONE HAS REPUDIAT$4 ,!RE=E WE SAY1 & WE SAY IT PUBLICLY1 & WE CRY IT AL\D :5 WE >E TORN & BLOOD-/A9$ BY Y\R TORTURES3 ',WE ADORE ,GOD ?R\< ! ,*RI/4' ,BELIEVE IT1 . A MAN1 IF Y\ LIKE2 IT IS ?R\< HIM ?AT ,GOD WANT$ TO BE KN[N & ADOR$4 ,TO RESPOND TO ! ,JEWS1 ,I W\LD SAY ?AT IT WAS ?R\< ,MOSES ?AT !Y1 TOO1 LE>N$ TO ADORE ,GOD2 TO ! ,GREEKS1 ,I W\LD SAY ?AT ,ORPHEUS 9 ,PI]IE1 ,MUSEE 9 ,A!NS1 ,MELAMPUS 9 ,>GOS & ,TROPHONIUS 9 ,BOETIE B\ND M5 . ?R\< 9ITIATIONS4.<#b#f#d.> ,AT ! SAME TIME ?AT ! ,GNO/IC ,GOSPELS W]E BE+ PROPAGAT$1 ! P]SI/5CE ( AN OLD] ,*RI/IANITY -- :I* ONE DISCOV]$ AT ,NAG-,HAMMADI & ?AT CONSI/$ ( FANTA/IC RECITALS SIMIL> TO ?OSE :I* ,T]TULLIAN DECANT$ = ! USE ( ! ,GREEKS & ,ROMANS -- GAVE TO ,JESUS MORE & MORE ( ! TRAITS ( A HI/ORICAL P]SONAGE SIMIL> TO ,APOLLONI\S ( ,TYANE1 NOT )\T RECALL+ ?AT HE REMA9$ ,GOD 9 ! SAME REALITY AS HIS HUMAN NATURE4 ,= ! NEW ,*RI/IAN WAVE1 ,JESUS WAS NOT A PURE SPIRIT4 ,SU* A BELIEF1 AMONG O!RS1 GR\NDS A PASSSAGE 9 ! CANONICAL ,GOSPEL ATTRIBUT$ TO ,LUKE 7#b#d1 #c#f-#d#c74 ,9 BRIEF1 !SE W]E ! POLEMICS & IDEAS ( ! ,SECOND ,C5TURY1 :I* -- RECUP]AT+ & EXPLICAT+ ,JEWI% & ,ESS5E SPECULATIONS AB\T ! ,MESSIAH -- W\LD 5D UP1 ?R\< ADDITIONS & CORRECTIONS1 9 ! NOVELS AB\T ,JESUS1 ! ,JESUS :O MADE PEOPLE =GET AB\T ,JO%UA 7BUT T>DILY1 BECAUSE 9 #bd ,ORIG5 /ILL EMPHASIZ$ ! OMNIPRES5CE ( ! SOLDI] ( ,MOSES74 ,UPON ALL ?OSE :O GLIMPS$ 9 ! GR[+ P[] ( ,*RI/IANITY ! P]SPECTIVE ( AN ASC5SION TO P[]1 ! NECESSITY IMPOS$ ITSELF ( ORD]+ & H>MONIZ+ ! ACTS1 LETT]S1 APOCALYPSES & GOSPELS ?AT W]E AS GREAT 9 NUMB] AS ! RIVAL COMMUNITIES4 ,IT WAS ! EPO* 9 :I* ,CELSE1 9 HIS ,TRUE ,DISC\RSE 7>\ND #a#h71 MOCK$ ! MULTITUDE ( ,*RI/IAN PROPHETS1 !IR RIVALRIES1 !IR LACK ( SCRUPLES 9 FABRICAT+ TEXTS & 9 REVIS+ ! OLD ONES SEV]AL TIMES4 7,T]TULLIAN %[$ :]E ! %OE P9*$ :5 HE WROTE ) SOME IRRITATION3 0,ONE DOES NOT SAY ?AT WE =GE \R MAT]IALS \RSELVES407 ,EA* *UR* PLAC$ ITS GOSPEL OR SACR$ TEXT UND] ! NAME ( A 0F\ND+ FA!R0 OR AN APO/LE4 ,! MAJORITY ( !M >E UNKN[N4 ,NEV]!LESS1 ONE CITES ,TATIAN & A C]TA9 ,LEUCIUS ,*>9US4 ,T]TULLIAN ATTRIBUT$ ! ,ACTS ( ,PAUL1 9 :I* A RECITAL ( HIS M>TYRDOM & ! LOVE ?AT C>RI$ HIM TO ! Y\NG ,!CLA1 TO ! ZEAL ( AN ,EA/]N PRIE/ :O D$ICAT$ A TRUE CULT TO ! ,APO/LE 7! TEXT W\LD 5JOY A GREAT POPUL> SUCCESS 9 ITS ,GREEK1 ,LAT91 ,COPTIC1 ,SYRIAN1 ,>M5IAN1 ,SLAVIC & ,>ABIC V]SIONS74 ,! ,ACTS ( ,PAUL P>TICIPAT$ 9 ! ,MONTANI/ F]VOR1 9 ! SAME WAY ?AT ! ,GOSPEL ATTRIBUT$ TO ,B>!LEMY1 9 :I* ,JESUS SAYS1 AS IF ADDRESS+ ,MONTAN3 0SALVATION TO Y\1 MY TW91 SECOND ,*RI/40 ,ON ! O!R H&1 ! ,ASC5SION ( ,JACOB1 ( ,EL*ASAITE ORIG91 TOOK TO ,PAUL W>MLY4 ,! MIS9T]PRETATION ( ! ,HEBREW & ,>AMAIC TEXTS 5G5D]$1 9 ! C\RSE ( ! CASCAD+ TRANSLATIONS1 9COH]5CIES & BIZ>RE ASPECTS ?AT W]E ALL ! MORE P]CEPTIBLE 9 ! APOCRYPHAL & CANONICAL ,GOSPELS1 :I* SUBSCRIB$ TO ! ,HEBREW MY?OLOGIES ?R\< LOAN$ WORDS4 ,! ,EPI/ULA APO/OLORUM1 PROBABLY ISSU$ FROM ,ASIA ,M9OR OR ,EGYPT 9 ! SECOND HALF ( ! ,SECOND ,C5TURY1 APPE>$ AS A SYNCRETIC ATTEMPT ?AT 9SI/$ ON ! MIRACLES & RESURRECTION ( ,JESUS4 ,AN APOCALYPSE 9SCRIB$ ITSELF 9 ! MILL5>IANI/ PREOCCUPATIONS ( ,MONTANISM3 9 ! ,EPI/ULA1 ,JESUS RESPONDS TO QUE/IONS AB\T ! DATES ( ! P>\SIA & ! RESURRECTION4 ,9 IT !RE >E ELEM5TS %>$ ) ! ,GOSPEL ATTRIBUT$ TO ,JOHN1 ! ,APOCALYPSE ( ,PET]1 ! ,EPI/LE ( ,B>NABAS1 & ,H]MAS' ,! ,PA/OR4 ,9 ! SAME SPIRIT1 BUT )\T MILL5>IANI/ ALLUSION1 ! ,ACTS ( ! ,APO/LES1 RETA9$ AS CANONICAL1 RECONCILES ! RIVAL VIEWS ( ,PAUL & ,SIMON-,PET] 9 A HI/ORICAL NOVEL4 ,IT CORRECTS ! ,EPI/ULA1 :I*1 9 ! ,MONTANI/ L9E1 BLAM$ ! BI%OPS & ! PRIE/S ACCUS$ ( HAV+ MISL$ ! PEOPLE ( ,GOD1 AFT] HAV+ MADE APOLOGY = 0,SAUL1 :O WANTS TO BE CALL$ ,PAUL40.<#b#f#e.> "9 "9 "9 ,N9ETY-F\R TEXTS ( ,*RI/IAN PROPAG&A W]E ?US SPREAD FROM ! ,SECOND ,C5TURY TO ! ,N9? ,C5TURY4 ,TW5TY-SEV5 ( !M W\LD BE RETA9$ 9 ! =MATION ( ! NEO-TE/AM5T>Y CORPUS & W\LD DEF9E ! ,CA?OLIC ,HOLY ,SCRPTURES4 ,!SE 0GOSPELS TRU?S0 PROCE$$ FROM A MELT+ POT .<,5GLI% 9 ORIG9AL.> 9 :I* !RE WAS A BATTLE BETWE5 ! V>I\S >MIES ( COPYI/S :O REMODEL$ & %>P5$ SECOND- & ?IRD-H& MAT]IALS ) ADJU/M5TS ?AT W]E DEM&$ BY ! POLEMICS ( ! TIME 7"97 SO AS TO 5D UP ) A DOGMATIC CORPUS ?AT ! IMP]IAL1 PONTIFICAL & 9QUISITORIAL 9/ANCES W\LD PLACE BEYOND CONTE/ATION4 ,! >GUM5T FROM AU?ORITY REMA9$ EFFICACI\S1 IF ONE JUDGES FROM ! PUSILLANIMITY ) :I* ! HI/ORIANS ( TODAY APPROA* ! QUE/ION4 ,!RE=E1 ) ! EXCEPTION ( SEV]AL PHRASES FROM ,PAUL9E LETT]S1 ALL ( ! TEXTS ( ! ,NEW ,TE/AM5T >E FAKES -- HI/ORICAL FALSIFICATIONS ?AT COV]$ = /RUGGLES1 QUITE REAL1 ?AT TOOK PLACE OV] MANY EPO*S -- ( ! SAME NATURE AS ! ,LETT]S ( ! ,JEWS S5T TO ! ,LAPIS ,LAZULI ,BRO!RS AT ! TIME ( ,JESUS1 9 :I* ,JEWS FROM ! YE> #c CONGRATULAT$ !MSELVES = CRUCIFY+ ! ,MESSIAH4 7,!SE ,LETT]S PROCUR$ = ! 9HABITANTS ( ,ULM 9 #acdh EXCELL5T REASONS = PUTT+ AN 5D TO ! 0,JEWRY0 ( ! CITY4.<#b#f#f.>7 7"97 ,CELSE3 0,IT IS NOTORI\S ?AT MANY AMONG !M .<444.> HAVE REVIS$ ! PRIMITIVE TEXT ( ! ,GOSPELS1 ?REE OR F\R TIMES1 & /ILL MORE1 SO AS TO REFUTE :AT !Y OBJECT TO40 ,NEV]!LESS1 NO ONE IS UNAW>E ?AT ! MANUSCRIPT CALL$ ,S9AITICUS1 :I* CONTA9S IMPORTANT FRAGM5TS ( ! GOSPELS LAT] *OS5 AS CANONICAL1 BELONG$ TO A LOT ( #e MANUSCRIPTS ?AT ,EUSEBIUS ( ,CES>EA1 ! FLATT]] ( ,CON/ANT9E1 HAD TRANSCRIB$ >\ND #cca UND] ! ORD]S ( ! ,EMP]OR1 :O DESIR$ TO AUTOCRATICALLY UNIFY ! EM]G+ ,CA?OLIC TRADITION BY DI/RIBUT+ COPIES TO ! PR9CIPAL *UR*ES ( ! ,EMPIRE4 ,!Y W]E MODIFI$ EV5 FUR!R1 AS ,ABBEY ,B]GI] EMPHASIZES 9 HIS ,DICTION>Y ( ,!OLOGY3 0,M5 TRULY KN[L$GEABLE 9 MATT]S ( EXEGESIS1 & ESPECIALLY S9C]E1 RECOGNIZE ?AT ! TEXT ( ! ,NEW ,TE/AM5T WAS NOT SET BE=E ! 5D ( ! ,SIX? ,C5TURY40 ,JESUS HAD BE5 AN ANGEL-MESSIAH1 !N AN AGITATOR PUT TO DEA? DESPITE ! ,*RI/IAN ,PONTIUS ,PILATE & BECAUSE ( ! ,JEWS4 ,FROM ! EXOT]IC BRU%WORK1 ASSUR$ BY ,MONTANISM1 A ,JESUS -- ,GOD & MAN1 AS 9 ! DOCTR9ES ( ,T]TULLIAN -- FRE$ HIMSELF2 & !N ANTI-,MONTANI/ REACTION SEIZ$ HIM SO AS TO REMODEL HIM4 ,CA?OLICISM ISSU$ FROM ! VICTORY & ! V5GEANCE ( ! LAPSI1 ! PRIE/S :O1 ?R\< FE> ( PUNI%M5T1 ABJUR$ DUR+ ! SUCCESSIVE P]SECUTIONS ( ! ,?IRD ,C5TURY4 ,TO ! ,MONTANI/ PR9CIPLES ( ,NOVATIAN &1 LAT]1 ,DONAT1 !SE PRIE/S OPPOS$ A CONCILIATORY ,JESUS1 LESS 9TRANSIG5T1 LESS P5ETRAT$ BY ASCETICISM ?AN ! MESSIAH ( ,T]TULLIAN1 ,CLEM5T & ,ORIG54 ,! CRITIQUE ( S\RCES1 :I* DID NOT />T UNTIL ! 5D ( ! ,TW5TIE? ,C5TURY 7& !N TIMIDLY71 %[S ! DIV]SE DEGREES ( TRANS=MATION ( ! BIBLICAL ,JO%UA 9TO ,JESUS ( ,NAZ>E?4 ,:5 A COMMUNITY OR *UR* %[$ ! NE$ TO AFFIRM ITS COHESION1 IT GAVE ITSELF RULES ?AT F\ND$ IT ON AN OLD] AU?ORITY4 ,IT ?US BORR[$ FROM ! ,BIBLE OR ! MIDRA%IM REM>KS 7LOGIA7 ?AT IT ATTRIBUT$ TO ! ,LORD1 SPIRITUAL MA/] ( ! FAI?FUL1 MU* LAT] ID5TIFI$ ) ,JO%UA_/,JESUS4 0,! /ATEM5T1 ',!RE IS MORE HAPP9ESS 9 GIV+ ?AN 9 RECEIV+1' PRES5T$ BY ! ,ACTS ( ! ,APO/LES 7#b1 #c#e7 AS A LOGION ( ,JESUS1 IS 9 FACT ORIG9ALLY A ,JEWI% MAXIM4 ,ONE ALSO F9DS IT 9 ! ,DIDA*E 7#a1 #e71 BUT IT ISN'T C]TA9 ?AT ?IS TEXT RECOGNIZES ! /ATUS ( ! WORD ( ! ,LORD .<444.> ,! ,*UR* ADOPT$ ! ,JEWI% PRECEPTS BY ADAPT+ !M TO ITS NE$S & TRANS=M$ !M 9TO ! LOGIA ( ,JESUS40.<#b#f#g.> ,BY ,HELL5IZ+ !MSELVES1 ! ,*RI/IANITIES ( ! ,SECOND ,C5TURY ALSO REF]R$ TO ,GREEK FABLES & PHILOSOPHICAL PRECEPTS4 ,ALSO 9SPIR$ BY ! 0WISDOM0 ( ,SOLOMON & ,JESUS1 SON ( ,SIRA1 ! LOGIA 9SCRIB$ !MSELVES 9 ! P]SPECTIVE ( ,GNO/IC ,*RI/IANITY4 ,J]OME1 CIT+ A LOGION FROM ! ,GOSPELS ( ! ,HEBREWS 9 HIS ,9 PROPHETEM ,EZE*IELEM COMM5T>IUS1 WRITES1 0,:OEV] HAS SADD5$ ! SPIRIT ( HIS BRO!R IS GUILTY ( ! GREATE/ CRIME10 :I* WAS 9 FACT A BANAL MORAL COMM&M5T ?AT HE PLAC$ 9TO ! M\? ( ,JESUS4 ,!RE=E1 ! REM>K P>TICIPAT$ 9 ,GNO/ICISM1 AS A PASSAGE FROM ,H]MAS MAKES CLE>3 SADNESS IS A VISE BECAUSE IT *ASES AWAY ! ,HOLY ,SPIRIT1 :O 9HABITS ! HUMAN S\L4 ,! SPIRIT ( ! BRO!R IS NOT ! ANIMUS1 BUT ! PNEUMA4 0,ONE CAN F9D O!R !OLOGICAL REASONS ?AT LEAD TO ! TRANS=MATION ( ANCI5T WORDS .

OLES.> & ! ELABORATION ( NEW LOGIA3 = EXAMPLE1 ON ! OCCASION ( ! CONTROV]SY ?AT TOOK PLACE ) RESPECT TO ! R5EWAL ( ! P>DON ACCORD$ TO ! S9N]S AFT] !IR CONV]SION TO ,*RI/IANITY 74447 ,>GUM5TS ?AT >E BAS$ ON ! CONT5T ( A LOGION CAN ACQUIRE MORE WEI ,9 FACT1 ! GREAT CONTROV]SY WAS BORN FROM ! RIGOR & 9TRANSIG5CE ( ! ,NEW ,PROPHECY4 ,IT WAS AGA9/ ! ,NEW ,PROPHECY ?AT ! R$ACTORS ( ! GOSPELS PLAC$ UND] ! NAMES ( ,MAT!W & ,LUKE ATTRIBUT$ !SE REM>KS TO ,JESUS3 0,IF SEV5 TIMES A DAY Y\R BRO!R (F5DS Y\ & SEV5 TIMES HE RETURNS TO Y\ TO SAY1 ',I REP5T1' Y\ WILL P>DON HIM0 7,GOSPEL ATTRIBUT$ TO ,LUKE1 #a#g1 #d72 AS WELL AS ?IS /AG+1 :I* 9SI/S ON P>DON+ ! APO/ATE PRIE/S CONTR>Y TO ! OP9ION ( ,NOVATIAN OR ,DONAT3 0,!N ,PET] APPROA*$ & SAID TO HIM1 ',LORD1 :5 MY BRO!R COMMITS AN (F5SE :]E ,I AM CONC]N$1 H[ MANY TIMES %\LD ,I P>DON HIM8 ,SEV5 TIMES8' ,JESUS SAID TO HIM1 ',I DO NOT SAY TO Y\ SEV5 TIMES1 BUT #gg TIMES SEV5 TIMES'0 7,GOSPEL ATTRIBUT$ TO ,MAT!W1 #a#h1 #b#a-#b#b74.<#b#f#i.> ,! POPUL> EXPANSION ( ,*RI/IANITY 9 ! ,GRECO-,ROMAN ,EMPIRE1 UND] ! 9FLU5CE . ( ,MONTAN & ,T]TULLIAN1 5D$ 9 ! ANECDOTAL TRANSLATION ( ! ,GNO/IC SPECUALTIONS1 9 ! APOLOGUE & ! /AG+ ( ! LOGIA4 ,) ! ,NEW ,PROPHECY1 A C]TA9 IMAG]Y -- :I* ! ,CA?OLIC ,*UR*1 CONTR>Y TO ,PROTE/ANT RETIC5CE1 HAD ALWAYS 5C\RAG$ AMONG ! 0SIMPLE ( SPIRIT0 -- WAS PROPAGAT$4 ,A PASSAGE FROM ! ,EPI/LE ATTRIBUT$ TO ,B>NABAS %[S ! ORIG9 ( ! SPONGE ( V9EG> PRES5T$ TO ,JESUS ON ! CROSS3 ,! ,EPI/LE ( ,B>NABAS TE/IFIES 9 ANO!R MANN]1 QUITE SIMPLE1 TO ! 5UNCIATION ( ! AU?ORITY ( ! ,LORD'S WORD4 ,9 TWO 9/ANCES 9 ?IS TEXT1 ! CITATION ( A LOGION ( ! ,LORD CONCLUDES AN EXEGETICAL DEBATE4 ,9 ! FIR/ PASSAGE1 ! AU?OR ASKS1 9 ! FRAMEWORK ( A DISCUSSION ON ! MEAN+ ( ! ,JEWI% SACRIFICIAL RITES 7,EPI/LE ( ,B>NABAS1 #g1 #a#a73 ',& :Y DOES ONE PUT ! WOOL 9 PLACE ( ! ?ORNS8 ,IT IS A PREFIGURATION ( ,JESUS PROPOS$ TO ! ,*UR*3 ! ?ORNS >E FRILET WOOL MU/ SUFF] A GREAT DEAL TO R5D] HIMSELF MA/] ( ! TE/4' ,& TO CONT9UE1 9 ! /YLE ( ! LOGIA ( ,JESUS =MULAT$ 9 ! FIR/ P]SON1 & MAK+ ! EXPRESSION FOLL[ ! PHRASE 'HE SAID'3 ',?US ?OSE :O WANT TO SEE ME & AWAIT MY K+DOM MU/ SEIZE ME ?R\< ORDEALS & SUFF]+4' ,AS ,B>NABAS GAVE A TYPOLOGICAL SIGNIFICANCE TO ! 5TIRETY ( ! RITE1 SU* A REM>K BY ,JESUS CAN -- DEP>T+ FROM ! ,JEWI% MODEL -- BE 'FRE$' )\T P>TICUL> EF=T4 ,ANO!R PASSAGE 7,EPI/LE ( ,B>NABAS1 #g1 #d-#e7 (F]S A SECOND EXAMPLE ( ?IS ME?OD3 ',ALL ! PRIE/S1 BUT !Y ALONE1 EAT 5TRAILS NOT WA%$ ) V9EG>4 ,:Y8' ,& ,B>NABAS MADE ! ,LORD 9T]V5E 9 P]SON1 TO GIVE A RESPONSE TO ?IS QUE/ION3 ',BECAUSE Y\ MAKE ME DR9K BILE ) V9EG>1 ME1 :O W\LD (F] MY FLE% = ! S9S ( MY NEW PEOPLE2 Y\ EAT1 ONLY Y\1 :ILE ! PEOPLE FA/ & LAM5T 9 ! SACK & A%ES6'.<#b#g.> ,?US ! ?REE GOSPELS CALL$ SYNOPTIC W]E LABORI\SLY COMPOS$1 H>MONIZ$ SOMEH[ OR O!R1 & PLAC$ UND] ! NAMES ( ?REE UNKN[NS3 ,M>K1 FROM :OM CAME A SECRET GOSPEL1 :I* ,H>NACK ATTRIBUTES TO ,M>CION2 ,MAT!W1 P]HAPS ISSU$ FROM A ,APOCRYPHAL ,GOSPEL ATTRIBUT$ TO ,MAT!W1 :I* HAS DISAPPE>$2 & ,LUKE1 A /YLI/1 A PR(ESSIONAL WRIT] LIKE ,LEUCIUS ,*>9US OR ,TATIAN4 7,IT SEEMS E/ABLI%$ BY ! ,GOSPEL ATTRIBUT$ TO ,JOHN ?AT1 AT ! BEG9N+1 IT WAS A ,*RI/IAN ,GNO/IC TEXT1 IF NOT ALSO ,NAASS5E OR ,SE?IAN4 ,! OLDE/ FRAGM5TS -- ACCORD+ TO ! BOOK BY ,I4 ,BEL1 ,*RI/IAN ,PAPYRI1 ,LONDON1 #aice -- DATES FROM ! YE>S #a#b#e-#a#f#e47 ,! SYNOPTIC GOSPELS W\LD ECLIPSE FROM !IR 0UNQUE/IONABLE TRU?0 A GREAT NUMB] ( 0SECRET0 GOSPELS 7APOCRYPHA 9 ,GREEK71 TO ! PO9T ?AT ! ,*UR* W\LD IMPOSE ON ! WORD 0APOCRYPHAL0 ! MEAN+ 0FALSE1 FALSIFI$40 ,! WRIT+S DISCOV]$ AT ,NAG-,HAMMADI MAKE NO REF]5CES TO ! SYNOPTICS1 & ! ,JESUS ATTE/$ TO BY SEV]AL TEXTS IS ONLY ! ANGEL-MESSIAH4 ,BUT IT W\LD BE IMPORTANT TO ! ,*UR* ( ! ,F\R? ,C5TURY1 9 ITS /RUGGLE AGA9/ ,>IUS & ,DONAT1 TO FIX HI/ORICALLY ! P]SONAGE ( ! ,MESSIAH ,JESUS1 SO ?AT HE NO LONG] APPE>$ AS ! 0SECOND ,*RI/10 LIKE ,MONTAN1 & ?AT HIS DIV9E NATURE WAS 0CONSUB/ANTIALLY0 MIX$ ) ! HUMAN NATURE ( A PROPHET ( :OM ! ,*UR* ( ,ROME W\LD ]ECT ITSELF AS ! UNIV]SAL LEGATEE1 ?R\< ! FILIATION ( ! TWELVE APO/LES -- & ESPECIALLY ,PAUL1 ! ,ROMAN CITIZ51 & ,PET]1 ! FIR/ 0POPE0 ( ! ,LAT9 ,NEW ,J]USALEM4 ,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,NOVEMB] #c1 #aiib 3 ,*APT] #af -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,APRIL #b#f1 #bb 3 ,*APT] #af -- ,ADD$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/