,! ,RIT & UNITY ( \R !ORETICAL & PRACTICAL COH]5CE4 ,?IS P]SPECTIVE IS ! ESS5CE ( :AT SEP>ATES US FROM BO? ! LEFT & ! RIKET1 IT WILL F9D ITSELF OR CREATE = ITSELF A BLACK M>KET4 ,IF IT IS NOT TOL]AT$ 9 TRANSP>5T N#a RELATIONS1 ! REPRESS$ SELF WILL SPLIT 9 TWO2 9TO A REPRES5T$ SELF1 A P]SONAL ORGANIZATION ( APPE>ANCES1 A P]SONA1 & ?AT :I* CR+ES & PLOTS BEH9D ?IS *>ACT]->MOR N#b4 ,! REPRESSION ( EGOISM1 CONTR>Y TO ! DICTATES ( EV]Y ONE ( ! SO-CALL$ 0,COMMUNI/S0 79 OPPOSITION TO ,M>X & ,5GELS71 FROM ,L59 RIIAT4 ,! ACTUAL NEGATION ( N>R[ EGOISM IS A MATT] ( TRANSC5DANCE 70AUFHEBUNG0 N#c71 ( ! TRANSITION FROM A N>R[ TO A QUALITATIVELY EXP&$ =M ( EGOISM4 ,! ORIG9AL SELF-EXPANSION ( EGOISM WAS ID5TICALLY ! DEMISE ( ! PRIMITIVE COMMUNITY4 ,BUT ITS FUR!R SELF-EXPANSION WILL RESOLVE ITSELF 9TO A COMMUNITY ONCE AGA94 ,IT IS ONLY :5 GRE$ ITSELF AT LA/ 7OR RA!R1 ONCE AGA97 BECKONS 9 ! DIRECTION ( COMMUNITY ?AT ?AT DIRECTION WILL BE TAK54 ,H]E ! ANCI5T ,*RI/IAN TRU? ?AT NO E>?LY =CE CAN )/& HUMAN GRE$ REJO9S US ON \R SIDE ( ! B>RICADES4 #d ,IT WAS ! /RUGGLE OV] !IR GR[+ WEAL? :I* R5T ASUND] ! E>LY TRIBAL & VILLAGE COMMUNITIES N#a4 ,! ELABORATION ( ! PATRI>*AL PATT]N1 ! GR[? ( EX*ANGE-RELATIONS1 ( USURY1 DEBT-SLAV]Y1 & W> CAN ALL BE TRAC$ TO ?IS4 ,IT IS ONLY :5 ! SAME MOTIVE :I* ORIG9ALLY OCCASION$ ?IS DISSOLUTION ( COMMUNITY CALLS = ITS RECON/ITUTION ?AT COMMUNITY CAN BE CON/ITUT$ AGA94 ,& ?IS MOTIVE IS1 SIMPLY1 ! /RUGGLE = A RI*] LIFE4 ,= ONLY ?AT MOTIVE IS IRRESI/IBLE3 ONLY ?AT MOTIVE -- GRE$ -- CAN UNDO ITS [N WORK4 ,IT IS ONLY :5 ?AT SUBJECTIVE MOM5T1 ?R\< ! HI/ORICAL DEEP5+ ( ITS [N POSSIBILITY1 TURNS AGA9/ ITS [N PRES5T OBJECTIFICATION -- 9 A WORD1 CAPITAL 7CAPITALI/ PRIVATE PROP]TY1 PRIVATIVE APPROPRIATION2 ?AT IS1 PRIVATIZATION1 EXCLUSION -- 0SOCIETY0 AS AN ASSOCIATION ( /RANG]S1 ( E/RANGEM5T -- 9 %ORT1 ! TOTALITY ( ALI5ATION7 -- ?AT ! ?RE%OLD ( ! GREAT TRANS=MATION IS REA*$4 ,& ! /RUGGLE ( ?IS NEW SUBJECTIVITY AGA9/ ! PREVI\S OBJECTIFICATION 7GLOBAL CAPITALI/ SOCIETY2 9 A WORD1 CAPITAL71 ! PROCESS ( ! NEGATION ( ?AT OBJECTIFICATION ,I,S ! COMMUNI/ REVOLUTION4 #e ,WE HAVE NO D\BT ?AT PEOPLE >E CORRUPTIBLE1 BUT WE KN[ = \RSELVES ?AT !RE >E ?+S MORE TEMPT+1 MORE S$UCTIVE1 ?AN MONEY1 CAPITAL1 & ,P[] N#a -- SO MU* SO ?AT NO G5U9ELY GRE$Y HUMAN BE+ C\LD POSSIBLY RESI/ !IR ALLURE -- & IT IS UPON ?IS CORRUPTIBILITY ( MAN ?AT WE F\ND \R HOPES = REVOLUTION4 ,REVOLUTION IS NO?+ O!R ?AN ! SELF-ACCEL]AT+ SPREAD ?R\<\T SOCIETY ( ?IS MORE PR(\ND CORRUPTION1 ( ?IS DEEP] S$UCTION4 ,CURR5TLY1 GRE$ IS ALWAYS PURSU$ & ASSOCIAT$ ) ISOLATION & PRIVATISM SIMPLY BECAUSE EV]YONE UND] ! REIGN ( CAPITAL IS CONDEMN$ TO PURSUE GRE$ 9 ?IS N>R[ WAY4 ,GRE$ DOESN'T YET KN[ ITS [N POT5TIALITY4 ,WE SAY ONCE AGA93 ! PRES5T =MS ( GRE$ LOSE \T 9 ! 5D BECAUSE !Y TURN \T TO BE NOT GRE$Y 5\<4 #f ,N>R[ GRE$ IS A HOLDOV] FROM TIMES ( NATURAL SC>CITY4 ,ITS DESIRES >E REPRES5T$ TO ITSELF 9 ! =M ( COMMODITIES1 P[]1 SEX7-OBJECTS71 & EV5 MORE AB/RACTLY1 AS MONEY & AS IMAGES4 ,WE >E TOLD 9 A ?\S& WAYS ?AT ONLY !SE FEW ?+S >E WOR? HAV+ -- BY RUL]S :O WORK TO 9SURE ?AT !SE >E ! ONLY ?+S AVAILABLE 7TO BE B\R[ GRE$ 9 A WORLD ( POT5TIAL PL5TY IS PROPAGAT$ 9 ! =M ( IDEOLOGY BY ?OSE V]Y PEOPLE :O CONTROL ACCESS TO !SE ?+S4 ,ULTIMATELY1 9 \R DAILY LIVES1 WE SUFF] ! HUMILIATION ( BE+ =C$ ACCOMPLICES 9 ! MA9T5ANCE ( ?IS 0SC>CITY10 ?IS POV]TY ( *OICES4 #g ,N>R[ GRE$ WILL TURN AGA9/ ITSELF4 ,NO MORE P[]FUL WEAPON AGA9/ GRE$ C\LD POSSIBLY BE F\ND ?AN GRE$ ITSELF4 ,!RE C\LD BE NO MORE =MIDABLE TOOL = TRANS=M+ N>R[ SELFI%NESS ?AN ?IS SELFI%NESS ITSELF4 ,9 ITS [N PROCESS1 ?R\< ITS [N DEVELOPM5T1 IT MU/ DISCOV] A FULL] =M ( GRE$1 & A RI*] =M ( WEAL?4 ,IT MU/ DISCOV] ITS [N N>R[NESS4 ,A FRONTAL ASSAULT ON SOMEONE'S N>R[ SELFI%NESS WILL RUN UP AGA9/ HIS /RONGE/ DEF5SES4 ,W\LDN'T IT BE EASI] TO TURN ?AT /R5G? >\ND UPON ITSELF8 ,W\LDN'T IT BE EASI] TO 9DUCE ?AT P]SON TO TRANS=M 7HIM7_/7H]7 SELF N#a ?R\< 7HIS7_/7H]7 [N DESIRES8 ,?IS IS ! ME?OD ( S$UCTION4 ,IT 9VOLVES SPEAK+ FROM :AT IS MO/ RADICAL 9 Y\ TO :AT IS MO/ RADICAL 9 ! O!R P]SON2 ?AT IS1 SPEAK+ FROM :AT Y\ REALLY HAVE 9 COMMON3 ROOT SUBJECTIVITY2 RADICAL SUBJECTIVITY1 ! BASIS1 AT LA/ HI/ORICALLY DISCOV]$1 UPON :I* TO WORK \T ! CON/RUCTION ( AU!NTIC COMMUNITY4 ,?IS IS ! ME?OD ( IMMAN5T CRITIQUE N#b2 ( ! EVOCATION ( SELF-CRITIQUE4 ,IT IS ! PRACTICE ( DIALECTIC ITSELF4 ,HIC ,RHODUS6 ,HIC ,SALTA6 #h ,! P]SPECTIVE ( COMMUNI/ EGOISM IS ! P]SPECTIVE ( ?AT SELFI%NESS :I* DESIRES NO?+ SO MU* AS O!R SELVES1 ( ?AT EGOISM :I* WANTS NO?+ SO MU* AS O!R EGOS2 ( ?AT GRE$ :I* IS GRE$Y TO LOVE -- LOVE BE+ ! 0TOTAL APPROPRIATION0 N#a ( MAN BY MAN4 #i ,\R REV]SAL ( P]SPECTIVE ON EGOISM N#a1 \R DET\RNEM5T N#b ( 0GRE$10 & ! SC&AL\S EFFECT :I* ?IS PRODUCES & IS 9T5D$ TO PRODUCE 9 ! PREVAIL+ CONSCI\SNESS1 IS NO M]E =MAL TRICK1 & NO >BITR>Y PLAY ON WORDS4 ,WORDS1 & PRECISELY BECAUSE ( !IR MEAN+S1 >E A REAL P>T ( HI/ORY1 ( ! 0HI/ORICAL MAT]IAL10 & ( ! HI/ORICAL PROCESS4 ,TO AB&ON !M TO !IR USURP]S1 TO 9V5T NEW WORDS1 OR TO USE O!R WORDS BECAUSE ( ! DIFFICULTY ( W9N+ BACK ! TRUE1 HI/ORIC WORDS1 IS TO AB&ON ! FIELD TO ! 5EMY4 ,IT IS A !ORETICAL CONCESSION1 & A PRACTICAL CONCESSION1 :I* WE CANNOT AF=D4 ,TO DO SO W\LD ONLY ADD TO ! CONFUSION1 A CONFUSION :I*1 9 P>T1 =MS ! BASIS ( ! E/ABLI%$ ORD] N#c4 ,\R REV]SAL ( P]SPECTIVE1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 IS CL>IFY+ )9 ! V]Y T]MS ( ! CONFUSION4 ,IT IS ALREADY A REVOLUTION>Y ACT AT ! LEVEL ( ! SUBJECTIVE CONDITIONS ( REVOLUTION3 ! REV]S$ P]SPECTIVE -- ! REVOLV$ P]SPECTIVE -- IS ! P]SPECTIVE ( REVOLUTION ITSELF4 ,IDEOLOGY IS ! SUBLIME HU/LE4 ,! USE-VALUE ( IDEOLOGY IS AS A TOOL = EXPLOITATION -- ! IDEOLOGUE USES IDEOLOGY TO CON Y\ 9TO LETT+ HIM PUT HIS EGOISM ABOVE Y\RS1 9 ! NAME ( ALTRUISM1 MORALITY1 & ! 0G5]AL 9T]E/40 ,\R W9N+ BACK 9 A POSITIVE CONNOTATION ( A WORD LIKE 0GRE$0 OR 0SELFI%NESS0 -- ! C5TRAL1 UNIV]SAL1 & MUTUALLY AGRE$ UPON PREJORATIVES ( ! TWO EXTREME REPRES5TATIONS ( MOD]N CAPITALISM1 PRIVATE CAPITALI/ & /ATE CAPITALI/ IDEOLOGY1 :I* TRY TO CONF9E ! TOTALITY ( POSSIBLE OPPOSITION )9 ! UNIV]SE B\ND$ BY !IR POL> PSEUDO-OPPOSITION -- IS SU* AN ACT BECAUSE IT LOCATES PRECISELY ! PO9T ( !IR ESS5TIAL UNITY1 ! EXACT PO9T ( DEP>TURE = A REVOLUTION>Y MOVEM5T :I*1 BY BREAK+ AWAY !RE1 SIMULTANE\SLY1 ID5TICALLY1 & S+UL>LY BREAKS ) BO?4 ,NO LESS IS \R EXPROPRIATION ( A WORD LIKE 0COMMUNISM0 SU* AN ACT1 = IT IS ALREADY AN 0EXPROPRIATION ( ! EXPROPRIATORS40 C#a ,! 0,FREE ,WORLD0 IS NOT FREE & ! 0,COMMUNI/ ,WORLD0 IS NOT COMMUNI/4 #a ,WE USE ! WORDS 0COMMUNI/ SOCIETY0 TO MEAN ! DIRECT OPPOSITE ( ?AT :I* MASQU]ADES AS SU* 9 ! PRES5T WORLD NAMELY1 BUREAUCRATIC /ATE-CAPITALISM N#a4 ,?AT ! CLASSICAL PRIVATE CAPITALI/ SOCIETIES ( ! 0,WE/0 -- !MSELVES MATUR+ T[>D A =M ( /ATE-CAPITALISM -- COLLUDE ) 0,EA/]N0 P[]S 9 ! PROPAGATION ( ?IS LIE1 IS H>DLY AN ACCID5T1 & %\LD COME AS NO SURPRISE4 ,IT IS1 RA!R1 ONE FACET AMONG MYRIADS ( AN 0ANTAGONI/IC COOP]ATION0 N#b :I* REVEALS ! HIDD5 ESS5TIAL UNITY B9D+ TOGE!R !SE PSEUDO-OPPOSITES4 ,! TRUE COMMUNI/ SOCIETY BEG9S ) ! EXPROPRIATION ( ! :OLE ( CAPITALI/ SOCIETY BY 0 ! ASSOCIAT$ PRODUC]S1 C#b :I*1 IF WE >E TO JUDGE BY ! NUM]\S N#c HI/ORICAL ATTEMPTS AT ?IS PROCESS SO F>1 WILL TAKE ! =M ( GLOBAL ORGANIZATION ( WORKPLACE1 COMMUNITY1 REGIONAL1 ETC41 C\NCILS2 ! WORK]S' C\NCILS1 OR1 TO USE !IR ORIG9AL1 ,RUSSIAN NAME1 EXPROPRIAT$ 79 FACT1 AS 9 NAME7 BY ! ,BOL%EVIK BUREAUCRATS -- ! ,SOVIETS4 #aa ,WE CONCEIVE ! REALIZ$ SOCIAL 9DIVIDUAL1 0COMMUNI/ MAN10 AS HAV+ = HIS PROP]TY -- ?AT IS1 = ! OBJECT ( HIS APPROPRIATION -- HIS :OLE SOCIETY1 ! TOTALITY ( HIS SOCIAL LIFE4 ,ALL ( SOCIETY IS WEAL? = HIM4 ,HIS 9T]C\RSE ) HIS SOCIETY -- I4E41 HIS LIV+ RELATIONS ) ! RE/ ( ! SOCIAL 9DIVIDUALS & !IR OBJECTIFICATION -- IS 9 ITS TOTALITY ! APPROPRIATION ( SOCIAL LIFE4 ,PRODUCTIVE ACTIVITY BECOMES A =M ( 9DIVIDUAL CONSUMPTION JU/ AS CONSUMPTION ITSELF IS A =M ( 7SELF7 PRODUCTION4 ,! ACTIVITY ( SIMULTANE\S APPROPRIATION BY EA* 9DIVIDUAL ( ALL ! RE/1 OR ( ! APPROPRIATION ( SOCIETY BY ALL AT ONCE 9T]-APPROPRIATION 7REALIZ$ 9T]-SUBJECTIVITY1 OR CO-PROP]TY7 -- ITSELF CON/ITUTES ! TOTALITY ( SOCIAL PRODUCTION4 ,?IS APPROPRIATION BY ALL AT ONCE ( ALL IS NONE O!R ?AN ! RESONANCE N#a /ATE ( EGOISM3 0,COMMUNISM IS ! POSITIVE ABOLITION ( PRIVATE PROP]TY1 ( HUMAN SELF-ALI5ATION1 & . ?US ! REAL APPROPRIATION ( HUMAN NATURE ?R\< & = MAN4 C#c ,9 COMMUNI/ SOCIETY1 ACCORD+ TO ITS CONCEPT1 ! 0=M1 ( 9T]C\RSE C#d BECOMES ! TOTAL APPROPRIATION ( MAN BY MAN4 ,SOCIAL 9DIVIDUALS CAN APPROPRIATE ONE ANO!R SUBJECTIVELY 7I4E41 AS SUBJECTS71 & ALL-SID$LY1 ?R\< ALL ! =MS ( HUMAN 9T]C\RSE -- BY TALK+ TOGE!R1 PRODUC+ TOGE!R1 MAK+ LOVE TOGE!R1 ETC41 ETC41 & ALL ! FRUITS ( !IR APPROPRIATION1 I4E41 !MSELVES 9 !IR DEVELOP$ RI*NESS1 BECOME ?US ! PROP]TY ( !MSELVES1 & ( ALL SOCIETY1 ( ALL ! O!R SOCIAL 9DIVIDUALS4 ,! FRUITS ( Y\R APPROPRIATION1 ( Y\R CONSUMPTION ( PHYSICAL & EMOTIONAL RI*ES1 IS SOME?+ FROM :I* ,I AM EXCLUD$ AT ! LEVEL ( IMM$IACY1 ( IMM$IATE CONSUMPTION3 Y\ EAT ! PE>1 !RE=E ,I CANNOT EAT JU/ ?AT BITE ( JU/ ?AT PE>2 Y\ %>E Y\R LOVE ) ?IS P]SON1 & ,I AM P]HAPS EXCLUD$ FROM %>+ MYSELF AT ?IS MOM5T ) Y\4 ,BUT ?IS IS NOT AT ALL A PROBLEM = ME1 = ,I AM BUSY ELSE:]E1 ) ! SAME PROJECT & PRAXIS ( SELF-5RI*M5T ON MY [N & TOGE!R ) O!RS4 ,BUT LAT]1 M$IATELY1 :5 ,I COME BACK TO Y\1 Y\R APPROPRIATION1 & ! SELF-5RI*M5T Y\ D]IVE FROM IT1 COMES BACK TO ME1 BECOMES MY CONSUMPTION1 MY APPROPRIATION1 9 MY APPROPRIATION ( Y\1 & IS ! RI*] = IT4 ,TODAY1 WE HAVE TO BE JEAL\S ( EA* O!RS' PLEASURES NOT BECAUSE \R PLEASURES >E SO MANY & SO GREAT1 BUT BECAUSE !Y >E SO MEAG] & SO FEW4 ,H]E1 ON ! O!R SIDE ( POV]TY1 ON ! O!R SIDE ( SC>CITY1 MY JEAL\SY W\LD ONLY DEPRIVE MYSELF1 MY EXCLUSION ( Y\R PLEASURE W\LD ONLY EXCLUDE MY [N1 & ,I AM FREE AT LA/ TO TAKE PLEASURE 9 Y\R PLEASURE4 ,:]EAS1 )9 ! REALM ( POV]TY1 Y\R /R5G? IS A ?REAT TO ME1 Y\R DEVELOPM5T IS AT ! EXP5SE ( M9E1 & 9 G5]AL Y\R ADDITION IS MY SUBTRACTION2 ON ! CONTR>Y1 9 ! SOCIETY ( REALIZ$ WEAL?1 Y\R /R5G? IS MY /R5G?1 ! 9N] WEAL? ( Y\R BE+ IS MY WEAL?1 MY PROP]TY1 & EV]Y ONE ( Y\R HUMAN P[]S IS A MULTIPLICATION ( MY [N4 ,?US1 ! CONTRADICTION BETWE5 MY CONSUMPTION & Y\RS1 BETWE5 MY APPROPRIATION1 MY PROP]TY1 & Y\RS2 ! CONFLICT BETWE5 MY WELL-BE+ & Y\RS BECOMES ITS OPPOSITE3 SYN!SIS2 ID5TITY2 9T]-RE9=CEM5T2 9T]AMPLIFICATION2 RESONANCE4 #ab ,! POSITIVE CONCEPTION ( EGOISM1 ! P]SPECTIVE ( COMMUNI/ EGOISM1 IS ! V]Y HE>T & UNITY ( \R !ORETICAL & PRACTICAL COH]5CE4 ,?IS P]SPECTIVE IS ! ESS5CE ( :AT SEP>ATES US FROM BO? ! LEFT & ! RIR[ B\RGEOIS =M HAS BE5 PEEL$ AWAY1 :AT IS WEAL?1 IF NOT ! UNIV]SALITY ( NE$S1 CAPACITIES1 5JOYM5TS1 PRODUCTIVE P[]S1 ETC41 ( 9DIVIDUALS1 PRODUC$ 9 UNIV]SAL EX*ANGE A#a 80 C#e #ad 0,! EX*ANGE ( HUMAN ACTIVITY ) PRODUCTION ITSELF AS WELL AS ! EX*ANGE ( HUMAN PRODUCTS ) ONE ANO!R IS EQUIVAL5TLY ! SPECIES-ACTIVITY & SPECIES-SPIRIT :OSE ACTUAL1 CONSCI\S1 AU!NTIC EXI/5CE IS SOCIAL ACTIVITY & SOCIAL SATISFACTION4 ,AS HUMAN NATURE IS ! TRUE COMMUNAL NATURE1 OR COMMUNAL BE+ ( MAN1 M5 ?R\< ! ACTIVATION ( !IR NATURE CREATE & PRODUCE A HUMAN COMMUNAL BE+1 A SOCIAL BE+ :I* IS NO AB/RACTLY UNIV]SAL P[] OPPOS$ TO ! S+LE 9DIVIDUAL1 BUT IS ! NATURE ( BE+ ( EV]Y S+LE 9DIVIDUAL1 HIS [N ACTIVITY1 HIS [N LIFE1 HIS [N SPIRIT1 HIS [N WEAL?40 C#f #ae 0,! NEW PROLET>IAT 9H]ITS ! RI*ES ( ! B\RGEOIS WORLD & IT GIVES IT ITS HI/ORICAL *ANCE4 ,ITS TASK IS TO TRANS=M & DE/ROY !SE RI*ES1 TO CON/ITUTE !M AS P>T ( A HUMAN PROJECT3 ! TOTAL APPROPRIATION ( NATURE & HUMAN NATURE BY MAN4 ,A REALIZ$ HUMAN NATURE CAN ONLY MEAN ! 9F9ITE MULTIPLICATION ( REAL DESIRES & !IR GRATIFICATION40 C#g #af ,! RESONANCE ( EGOISMS HAS TO BE LOOK$ AT FROM ! PO9T ( VIEW ( WEAL? 7GRE$73 DEVELOP$ 9DIVIDUALS MAKE A RI*] COMMUNITY1 & A RI*] COMMUNITY MAKES = RI*] 9DIVIDUALITIES4 ,BEYOND A C]TA9 /AGE ( ! DEVELOPM5T ( PRODUCTIVE =CES1 0COLLECTIVISM ! SUPPRESSION ( 9DIVIDUALITY0 IS A =FEITURE ( WEAL? = ! COMMUNITY1 JU/ AS '9DIVIDUALISM "7 ! SUPPRESSION ( COMMUNITY' IS A =FEITURE ( WEAL? = ! 9DIVIDUALI/4 #ag ,! IMPOV]I%$ MAN TYPICAL ( CAPITALI/ SOCIETY1 ! SO-CALL$ 0GRE$Y0 MAN1 IS ! MAN :O IS ONLY EXCIT$ BY MONEY1 :O IS ONLY 9T]E/$ 9 FRAGM5TS ( O!R PEOPLE -- 9 BUY+ !IR SKILLS1 !IR S]VICES1 !IR PRODUCTS1 & ! RE/ IS 0NONE ( HIS BUS9ESS40 ,HE LIVES 9 A WORLD ( PRO/ITUTES1 ?AT IS1 A WORLD ( PROLET>IANS4 ,HE IS ! MA/] ( ! P>TIAL APPROPRIATION ( MAN BY MAN1 ?AT IS1 ( EXPLOITATION4N#a ,! RI* MAN1 ! GRE$Y MAN ( COMMUNI/ SOCIETY1 IS ! MAN :O HAS DISCOV]$ H[ TO APPROPRIATE ! RI*E/ 0?+0 >\ND1 ! MO/ 9T]E/+ & VALUABLE OBJECT1 ! SUBJECT1 BEG9N+ ) ! APPROPRIATION ( HIMSELF AS SU*2 ! MAN :O HAS SOCIALLY MA/]$ ! POSSIBILITY TOGE!R ) ! NECESS>Y CONDITIONS ( ?IS TOTAL APPROPRIATION ( MAN BY MAN1 ! COH]5CE ( :OSE SOCIAL LIFE IS ! SELF-NE$ ( MAN4 ,?IS IS ! SECRET ( :AT WE MEAN :5 WE SAY3 ! NEGATION ( CAPITAL IS ! REALIZATION ( REAL WEAL?1 SUBJECTIVELY & OBJECTIVELY4 ,! COMMUNI/ EGOI/1 ! G5U9ELY GRE$Y P]SON1 WANTS O!R SUBJECTS4 ,! N>R[ EGOI/1 ! EXPLOIT]1 ONLY WANTS SOME?+ FROM !M4 #ah ,A SOCIETY RI* 9 SELVES IS ! ONLY REALLY RI* SOCIETY4 ,RI*NESS 9 SUBJECTS1 9 SUBJECTIVITY1 9 PRACTICALLY & CREATIVELY POT5T HUMAN BE+S1 IS F9ALLY ! ONLY REAL WEAL? = ! SUBJECT4 #ai ,ULTIMATELY1 WEAL? IS NO?+ BUT SOCIETY ITSELF4 #b ,! LOGIC ( EX*ANGE-VALUE1 ( COMMODITY EX*ANGE-RELATIONS1 IS ! V]Y LOGIC ( N>R[ EGOISM ITSELF4 ,9 ! EX*ANGE ( A COMMODITY :I* ,I [N1 = MONEY [N$ BY SOMEBODY ELSE1 ,I HAVE P>T$ )1 ALI5AT$1 ! USE VALUE ( ! COMMODITY4 ,IT IS LO/ TO ME1 9 ORD] ?AT ,I MAY REALIZE ITS EX*ANGE-VALUE1 ITS MONEY =M1 ITS G5]AL USE-VALUE1 ?AT IS1 ITS EXPRESSION 9 ! =M ( G5]AL SOCIAL USEFULNESS OR AB/RACT LABOR-TIME1 :I* ,I CAN !N RECONV]T 9TO ANY P>TICUL> USE-VALUE TO ! EXT5T ?AT ITS PRODUCTION HAS1 BY MY /AGE ( CAPITALI/ DEVELOPM5T1 ASSUM$ ! =M ( COMMODITY-PRODUCTION4 ,ITS G5]AL USEFULNESS -- ITS USEFULNESS AS MONEY1 AS EX*ANGE-VALUE -- IS H]E 9 DIRECT CONTRADICTION TO ITS P>TICUL> USEFULNESS1 ITS SPECIFIC USE-VALUE4 ,! LOGIC ( EX*ANGE-RELATIONS 9 COMMUNI/ SOCIETY1 ACCORD+ TO ! 9N] COH]5CE ( ITS CONCEPT1 IS QUITE ! CONTR>Y H[EV]4 ,! USE-VALUES 9 :OSE PRODUCTION ,I P>TICIPATE1 & 9 :OSE CONSUMPTION Y\ & ,I BO? P>TICIPATE1 >E NOT LO/ TO ME EXCEPT IF ,I CONSUME !M IMM$IATELY1 I4E41 Y\R CONSUMPTION ( !M IS NOT A LOSS = ME4 ,!Y >E SOCIAL USE VALUES1 & SOCIETY IS MY L>G] SELF1 MY NECESS>Y SELF1 ABSOLUTELY NECESS>Y TO MY PRODUCTION & REPRODUCTION4 7,EV5 IF ,I %\LD TAKE UP ! LIFE ( AN ISOLAT$ H]MIT1 & SOMEH[ SURVIVE AT IT1 MY *ANG$ SELF-ACTIVITY W\LD %ORTLY R5D] ME A DIFF]5T P]SON74 ,!IR USE-VALUE1 CONSUM$ DIRECTLY BY O!RS RETURNS TO ME 9 ! =M ( ! MA9TA9$ OR IMPROV$ CREATIVE CAPACITY ( ?OSE O!RS 9 SOCIAL PRODUCTION2 9 ! =M ( ! REPOSIT$ OR 9CREAS$ PRODUCTION ( ! CLASS ( HUMAN BE+S UPON :OM MY REPRODUCTION DEP5DS -- ! S+LE CLASS -- OR RA!R1 ! S+LE GLOBAL NON-CLASS ( ASSOCIAT$ PRODUC]S1 :O PRODUCE ! TOTALITY ( ! WEAL? ,I CONSUME2 PR]EQUISITES TO MY PRODUCTION ( MY SELF4 ,?US1 NO SOCIAL USE-VALUE IS ALI5AT$ FROM ME4 ,RA!R1 ALL ( IT /AYS )9 MY 7EXP&$7 SELF1 ACCUMULATES !RE1 & GOES TO 5HANCE ! TOTAL QUALITY ( MY LIFE4 ,!RE=E1 ALSO1 )9 ! GLOBAL PRODUCTION-PLANN+ PROCESS ( ! C\NCILS1 ,I HAVE A LEGITIMATE BEEF :5EV] ASK$ TO P>TICIPATE 9 SOME PRODUCTION :I* DOES NOT SATISFY ?IS LOGIC4 ,ANY PRODUCTION :I* DOES NOT SATISFY ?IS LOGIC IS TRULY SOCIALLY DE/RUCTIVE1 ANTISOCIAL1 & AN ANTI-USE-VALUE 7ANTI-WEAL?74 ,IT IS !RE=E1 AT V]Y BE/1 A WA/E ( MY TIME1 ?AT IS1 ( MY LIFE4 ,ANY?+ ?AT IS NOT WOR?Y TO BE PRES]V$ WILL HAVE TO BE DE/ROY$4 #ba 0,! 9DEP5D5T1 MAT]IAL =M ( WEAL? DISAPPE>S & WEAL? IS %[N TO BE SIMPLY ! ACTIVITY ( M54 ,EV]Y?+ :I* IS NOT ! RESULT ( HUMAN ACTIVITY1 ( LABOR1 IS NATURE &1 AS SU*1 IS NOT SOCIAL WEAL?4 ,! PHANTOM ( ! WORLD ( GOODS FADES AWAY & IT IS SE5 TO BE SIMPLY A CONT9UALLY DISAPPE>+ & CONT9UALLY REPRODUC$ OBJECTIVIZATION ( HUMAN LABOR4 ,ALL SOLID MAT]IAL WEAL? IS ONLY ! TRANSITORY MAT]IALIZATION ( SOCIAL LABOR1 CRY/ALLIZATION ( ! PRODUCTION PROCESS :OSE MEASURE IS TIME1 ! MEASURE ( A MOVEM5T ITSELF40 C#h #bb ,9 ! LA/ ANALYSIS1 ALL Y\ HAVE TO GIVE IS Y\RSELF4 ,Y\R SELF IS Y\R ONLY GIFT4 ,IF Y\ DON'T POSSESS Y\RSELF -- I4E41 IF Y\ LET Y\RSELF BE =C$ TO SELL Y\RSELF -- Y\ HAVE NO?+ TO BE/[ UPON ANO!R 9DIVIDUAL1 ANO!R SELF4 ,9 ! REALIZ$ SOCIETY CALL$ COMMUNI/ SOCIETY1 EX*ANGE MU/ BECOME VISIBLY & FULLY :AT IT ALWAYS WAS ESS5TIALLY1 SELF EX*ANGE4 ,I,I4 ,9DIVIDUALISM & ,COLLECTIVISM #bc 0,TO BE AVOID$ ABOVE ALL IS E/ABLI%+ 'SOCIETY' ONCE AGA9 AS AN AB/RACTION OV] AGA9/ ! 9DIVIDUAL4 ,! 9DIVIDUAL IS ! SOCIAL BE+40 N#a ,! EXPRESSION ( HIS LIFE -- EV5 IF IT DOES NOT APPE> IMM$IATELY 9 ! =M ( COMMUNAL EXPRESSION C>RI$ \T TOGE!R ) O!RS -- IS !RE=E A MANIFE/ATION & AFFIRMATION ( SOCIAL LIFE4 ,! 9DIVIDUAL & G5]IC LIFE ( MAN >E NOT DI/9CT1 H[EV] MU* -- & NECESS>ILY SO -- ! MODE ( EXI/5CE ( 9DIVIDUAL LIFE IS EI!R A MORE P>TICUL> OR A MORE G5]AL MODE ( G5]IC OR G5]IC LIFE A MORE P>TICUL> OR UNIV]SAL MODE ( 9DIVIDUAL LIFE4 0444,?\< MAN IS !RE=E A UNIQUE 9DIVIDUAL -- & PRECISELY ?IS P>TICUL>ITY MAKES HIM AN 9DIVIDUAL1 A REALLY 9DIVIDUAL COMMUNAL BE+ -- HE IS EQUALLY ! TOTALITY1 ! IDEAL TOTALITY1 ! SUBJECTIVE EXI/5CE ( SOCIETY AS ?\S UND] A POSITIVE SIGN4 ,LET'S PUT AN 5D TO ?IS OLD SOLDI] CRAP ONCE & = ALL6 ,= O!RS TO 9T]E/ ME ,I MU/ F9D 9 MYSELF ! 5]GY = SU* AN 9T]E/4 ,:AT B9DS ME TO O!RS MU/ GR[ \T ( :AT B9DS ME TO ! MO/ EXUB]ANT & DEM&+ P>T ( MY WILL 7VOLONTE7 TO LIVE2 NOT ! O!R WAY >\ND4 ,IT IS ALWAYS MYSELF ?AT ,I AM LOOK+ = 9 O!R PEOPLE2 MY 5RI*M5T2 MY REALIZATION4 ,LET EV]YONE UND]/& ?IS & 'EA* = HIMSELF' TAK5 TO ITS ULTIMATE CONCLUSION WILL BE TRANS=M$ 9TO 'ALL = EA*4' ,! FRE$OM ( ONE WILL BE ! FRE$OM ( ALL4 ,A COMMUNITY :I* IS NOT BUILT ON ! DEM&S ( 9DIVIDUALS & !IR DIALECTIC CAN ONLY RE9=CE ! OPPRESSIVE VIOL5CE ( ,P[]4 ,! ,O!R 9 :OM ,I DO NOT F9D MYSELF IS NO?+ BUT A ?+1 & ALTRUISM LEADS ME TO ! LOVE ( ?+S1 TO ! LOVE ( MY ISOLATION4444 ,= MYSELF1 ,I RECOGNIZE NO EQUALITY EXCEPT ?AT :I* MY WILL TO LIVE ACCORD+ TO MY DESIRES RECOGNIZES 9 ! WILL TO LIVE ( O!RS4 ,REVOLUTION>Y EQUALITY WILL BE 9DIVISIBLY 9DIVIDUAL & COLLECTIVE40 C#a #be 0,LET US NOTICE FIR/ ( ALL ?AT ! SO-CALL$ RIE SIMPLY ! RIAT$ FROM O!R M5 & FROM ! COMMUNITY4444 ,LIB]TY IS1 !RE=E1 ! RIM O!RS4 ,! LIMITS )9 :I* EA* 9DIVIDUAL CAN ACT )\T H>M+ O!RS >E DET]M9$ BY LAW1 JU/ AS A B\ND>Y BETWE5 TWO FIELDS IS M>K$ BY A /AKE4 ,IT IS A QUE/ION ( LIB]TY ( MAN REG>D$ AS AN ISOLAT$ MONAD1 )DRAWN 9TO HIMSELF4444 ,LIB]TY AS A RIATION ( MAN FROM MAN4 ,IT IS ! RIATION4 N#a ,! RI5TLY CONTR>Y RATIONALITIES HAS RAG$ AN ID5TICAL GANG/]ISM1 AN ID5TICAL OPPRESSION ( ! ISOLAT$ MAN40 C#a#b #bg ,IS IT NECESS>Y ONCE AGA9 TO PO9T \T ! SELF-ABSURDITY ( ! ONE-SID$ AB/RACTIONS 0! 9DIVIDUAL0 & 0SOCIETY10 & ( ! IDEOLOGIES F\ND$ ON ?IS ONE-SID$NESS -- 09DIVIDUALISM0 7OR 0EGOISM07 & SO-CALL$ 0SOCIALISM0 7OR 0COLLECTIVISM078 ,WE CAN BE 9DIVIDUALS ONLY SOCIALLY4 ,WE CAN BE SOCIAL ONLY 9DIVIDUALLY4 ,9DIVIDUALS CON/ITUTE SOCIETY4 ,SOCIETY CON/ITUTES 9DIVIDUALS4 #bh ,DIG DEEPLY 5\< 9TO ! 9DIVIDUAL & Y\ WILL F9D SOCIETY4 ,DIG DEEPLY 5\< 9TO SOCIETY & Y\ WILL F9D ! 9DIVIDUAL4 ,DIG DEEPLY 5\< 9TO EI!R & Y\ WILL COME \T ! 0O!R0 SIDE4 ,! CONCEPT NAM$ 0! 9DIVIDUAL10 FULLY GRASP$1 IS ! SAME AS ! CONCEPT NAM$ 0SOCIETY40 ,! CONCEPT NAM$ 0SOCIETY10 FULLY GRASP$1 IS ALSO 0! 9DIVIDUAL40 ,ONE IS IMPOSSIBLE1 DOES NOT EXI/1 )\T ! O!R4 ,AT ! HE>T ( SOCIETY IS ITS 0OPPOSITE10 ! 9DIVIDUAL4 ,AT ! C5T] ( ! 9DIVIDUAL IS HIS 0ANTI!SIS10 SOCIETY4 ,WE MU/ SPEAK ( ! SOCIAL 9DIVIDUAL4 ,BO? ( ! AB/RACT UNIV]SALS1 0SOCIETY0 & 0! 9DIVIDUAL0 F9D !IR CONCRETE UNIV]SAL 9 ! SOCIAL 9DIVIDUAL4 #bi ,SOCIETY1 )\T ! 9DIVIDUAL1 IS EMPTY1 IS )\T ITS EXI/5CE1 JU/ AS ! 9DIVIDUAL1 )\T SOCIETY1 IS )\T ITS EXI/5CE -- & EV5 \TSIDE HUMAN SOCIETY1 IS NOT A HUMAN 9DIVIDUAL 7EV5 IF IT %\LD *ANCE TO SURVIVE AS A BIOLOGICAL 9DIVIDUAL4 ,H[EV]1 EV5 AS SU*1 IT IS ! ISSUE ( A HUMAN SOCIAL -- 9 ?IS CASE1 SEXUAL -- RELATION%IP74 ,UNLESS BO? !SE MOM5TS CAN BE AFFIRM$ SIMULTANE\SLY1 UNIVOCALLY2 GRASP$ AS A S+LE1 UNIT>Y CONCEPT -- 9 FACT AS A CONCEPTUAL S+UL>ITY -- !IR CONTRADICTION HAV+ BE5 TRANSC5D$ 7TO BEG9 )1 9 ?\E PRODUC$ ONLY BY SOCIETY4 ,SOCIETY IS PRODUC$ ONLY BY 9DIVIDUALS4 #cc ,SOCIETY CAN BE REALIZ$ ONLY EGOI/ICALLY1 JU/ AS ! EGO CAN BE >RIV$ AT1 CAN BE REALIZ$1 & IS POSSIBLE AT ALL ONLY SOCIALLY4 #cd ,! SELF IS PREEM95TLY & ESS5TIALLY SOCIAL2 SOCIETY IS PREEM95TLY & ESS5TIALLY SELFI%4 #ce ,IF ! PHILOSOPH]S ( ONE-SID$ 9DIVIDUALISM1 ( N>R[ EGOISM -- ?AT IS1 ( ! AXIOLOGY ( ! SELF -- WANT TO UND]/& ,M>X'S SOCIALISM1 !Y %\LD REFLECT ON HIS /ATEM5T TO ! EFFECT ?AT ! O!R IS A NECESS>Y P>T ( Y\R SELF4 C#a#d #cf ,! PR9CIPLE 0,I WANT NO?+ O!R ?AN MYSELF0 -- ! PR9CIPLE ( SELF-DESIRE1 SELF-ATTA*M5T 7SELF-CA!XIS1 OR SELF-C5TRATION7 -- BECOMES ! PR9CIPLE ( DAILY LIFE 9 COMMUNI/ SOCIETY ONCE IT IS SOCIALLY ACTUALIZ$ ?AT ! O!R IS A NECESS>Y P>T ( MY SELF4 C#a#e ,SOCIETY BECOMES AN OBJECT ( CA!XIS )\T ?IS ANY LONG] NECESSITAT+ PROJECTION-ID5TIFICATION -- I4E41 ! ALI5ATION ( CA!XIS FROM ! SELF -- ONCE ! SOCIAL NATURE ( ! SELF1 & ! 0SELF NATURE0 ( SOCIETY HAS BECOME A PALPABLE & TRANSP>5T TRU? ( EXP]I5CE4 #cg ,/ATE-CAPITAL1 9 SUBLAT+ N#a PRIVATE CAPITAL1 NEGATES OR REPRESSES PRIVATE CAPITAL4 ,! IDEOLOGY ( ANTI-9DIVIDUALISM -- ?AT IS1 ( COLLECTIVISM OR ONE-SID$ SOCIALISM -- SO ESS5TIAL TO ,MAOISM 9 P>TICUL> & TO REVOLUTION>Y IDEOLOGY N#b 9 G5]AL IS CONGRU5T PRECISELY ) ! PROJECT ( ! REPRESSION ( PRIVATE CAPITALISM & PRIVATE ACCUMULATION1 TOGE!R ) ! *>ACT]OLOGICAL T5D5CIES CORRESPOND+ TO !SE1 ON ! P>T ( BUREAUCRATIC CAPITALISM 7/ATE-CAPITALISM74 ,?IS POLICY ( REPRESSION1 TYPIFI$ BY ! ,MAOI/ SLOGAN 0SMA% SELF0 N#c1 ALSO HAS ! EFFECT ( 9HIBIT+ ! EM]G5CE ( COMMUNI/ EGOISM )9 ! HOME PROLET>IAT2 A =M ( EGOISM :I* ! BUREAUCRACY CONF\NDS1 CONSCI\SLY OR UNCONSCI\SLY1 ) B\RGEOIS EGOISM4 #* ,EV5 PRIVATISM ITSELF IS A SOCIAL EXPRESSION 7SEE ,!SIS #b#c72 AN EXPRESSION ( SOCIAL LIFE 9 A DEF9ITE HI/ORICAL =M ( SOCIETY4 ,?AT IS1 PRIVATISM IS ITSELF AN EXPRESSION ( ! SOCIAL 9DIVIDUAL PRODUC$ BY CONTEMPOR>Y SOCIETY4 ,PEOPLE :O DO NOT ?9K DIALECTICALLY 5D UP MAK+ 5ORM\S ]RORS H]E1 PRACTICALLY AS WELL AS !ORETICALLY1 BECAUSE !Y CAN NOT GRASP CONTEMPOR>Y AS ITSELF A SOCIAL TRU?1 AN 7ADMITT$LY SELF-REPRODUC+7 SUBJECTIFICATION 7I4E41 9T]NALIZATION71 ( CAPITALI/ SOCIETY1 :I* IS PRECISELY AN ANTISOCIAL SOCIETY4 ,SO MU* SO ?AT '! SOCIALIZATION ( SOCIETY' IS1 :]E CAPITALI/ SOCIETY IS CONC]N$1 BUT ANO!R NAME = ! PROJECT ( SOCIAL REVOLUTION ITSELF4 ,! IDEOLOGIES ( ANTI-SOCIALISM >E BAS$ ON ! MIS]Y ( ASSOCIATION 7COLLECTIVE BOR$OM1 9AU!NTIC ASSOCIATION1 ETC47 A#a UND] CONTEMPOR>Y CONDITIONS1 ?AT IS1 ON ! MIS]Y ( ASSOCIATION-AS-ALI5ATION & AS-E/RANGEM5T4 ,!Y >E EXPRESSIONS ( ! POV]TY ( SOCIAL LIFE -- ITS VIRTUAL NONEXI/5CE AS SU* -- 9 ! WORLD ( /RANG]S1 ! BELLUM OMNIUM CONTRA OMNES1 :I* IS CAPITALI/ SOCIETY4 #ci ,! LEFTI/1 TRAPP$ 9 ! P]MAN5T FALSE *OICE BETWE5 FOLL[+ HIS [N IMM$IATE DESIRES & SACRIFIC+ = HIS IDEALS1 DESPISES ! 0SELFI%0 P]SON :O UNHESITAT+LY *OOSES IMM$IATE1 PRIVATE SATISFACTION4 ,! G5U9E COMMUNI/ ALSO DESPISES ?IS LATT] TYPE1 BUT = ! OPPOSITE REASON3 BE+ RE/RICT$ TO IMM$IATE PRIVATE SATISFACTION IS NOT SATISFY+ 5\<4 ,TO ! COMMUNI/1 FUR!RMORE1 = SU* 0SELFI%0 PEOPLE TO REMA9 SATISFI$ ) !IR PRIVATIZ$1 ALI5AT$ LIVES IS A DIRECT B>RI] TO ! REALIZATION ( ! COMMUNI/'S [N EXP&$ SELF-9T]E/4 ,SOME:]E 9 EV]Y RANK & FILE LEFTI/ LURKS A CONFUS$ 9TUITION ?AT ?IS IS ! REAL REASON = HIS CONTEMPT3 BUT ?IS 9TUITION IS CONT9UALLY /IFL$ BY ! LEFTI/'S [N 9SI/5CE ON ! 0NECESSITY0 ( SACRIFICE4 #d ,! LONELY 9DIVIDUALISM ( ,AYN ,R& C#a#f1 ET4 AL41 IS ONLY ALI5ATION ACCEPT$ & ALI5ATION P]FECT$4 ,COMMUNI/ 9DIVIDUALISM OR 9DIVIDUALI/ COMMUNISM IS ! NAME = ! SOLUTION TO ! RIDDLE ( PRE-HI/ORY1 :I*1 :ILE IT HAS MOM5T>ILY1 AT TIMES & PLACES 9 ?IS C5TURY1 EXI/$1 AS YET KN[S NOT ITS [N NAME4 #da ,ANY 0COLLECTIVISM0 ON \R P>T IS AN 9DIVIDUALI/ COLLECTIVISM4 ,ANY 09DIVIDUALISM0 ON \R P>T IS A COLLECTIVI/ 9DIVIDUALISM4 #db 0,NO?+ IS MORE TO ME ?AN MYSELF40 C#a#g ,F9E4 ,AS IT /&S1 ?IS !OREM IS :OLLY ACCEPTABLE4 ,?IS IS A CLASSIC /ATEM5T ( ! EGOI/IC PO/ULATE BY ! CLASSIC EXPON5T ( 9DIVIDUALI/ AN>*ISM & N>R[ EGOISM1 & AN E>LY ANTAGONI/ ( ,M>X1 ,MAX ,/IRN]4 ,HIS LATT]-DAY FOLL[]S1 CONSCI\S & UNCONSCI\S1 9CLUDE ! 0,OBJECTIVI/S10 ! 0CLASSICAL LIB]ALS01 & ! SO-CALL$ 0LIB]T>IAN RI AS ,I AM CONC]N$4 ,IF ,I AM LO/1 !N ALL ! WORLD IS LO/ TO ME4 ,EA* TIME A P]SON DIES1 A WORLD DIES4 #dd ,! COMMUNITY ( EGOI/S IS ! ONLY POSSIBLE COMMUNITY NOT F\ND$ ON ! REPRESSION ( 9DIVIDUAL DEVELOPM5T & ?US ULTIMATELY ( COLLECTIVE DEVELOPM5T AS WELL4 #de 0,COMMUNI/ EGOISM0 NAMES ! SYN!SIS ( 9DIVIDUALISM & COLLECTIVISM1 JU/ AS COMMUNI/ SOCIETY NAMES ! ACTUAL1 MAT]IAL1 S5SU\S SOLUTION TO ! HI/ORICAL CONTRADICTION ( ! 0P>TICUL>0 & ! 0G5]AL0 9T]E/1 A CONTRADICTION 5G5D]$ ESPECIALLY 9 ! CLEAVAGE ( SOCIETY AGA9/ ITSELF 9TO CLASSES4 ,?IS 0SOLUTION0 CANNOT BE ( ! =M ( A M]E IDEA OR AB/RACTION1 BUT ONLY ( A CONCRETE =M ( SOCIETY4 #df ,! GLOBAL & EXCLUSIVE P[] ( WORK]S' C\NCILS1 ( ! ANTI-/ATE N#a1 ( ! ASSOCIAT$ PRODUC]S N#b1 OR 0G5]ALIZ$ SELF-MANAGEM5T0 A#a ?AT IS1 CONC]T$ EGOISM1 IS ! PRODUCTIVE =CE & ! SOCIAL RELATION ( PRODUCTION :I* CAN SUP]S$E ALL ! RESULTS ( ! UNCOORD9AT$ EGOI/IC ACTIVITY ( M54 ,!SE >E1 9 !IR TOTALITY1 ALI5ATION2 ! UNCONSCI\S DEVELOPM5T ( ! ECONOMY1 & ! UNCONSCI\S PRODUCTION BY ! PROLET>IAT ( ! ECONOMIC 0LAWS0 ( CAPITALISM1 ) ALL !IR DISA/R\S CONSEQU5CES = ! PROLET>IAT4 ,! !ORY ( COMMUNI/ EGOISM IS COMPLETE ONLY AS A !ORY ( REVOLUTION>Y ORGANIZATION & AS A !ORY ( REVOLUTION>Y PRACTICE 9 G5]AL2 AS A !ORY ( ! NEW SOCIAL RELATIONS & AS A !ORY ( ! PRACTICE ( ! C\NCILS4 ,?AT IS1 IT IS ADEQUATE ONLY AS A !ORY ( COMMUNI/ SOCIETY & AS A !ORY ( ! TRANSITION FROM 7/ATE7 CAPITALI/ TO COMMUNI/ SOCIETY4 ,OBVI\SLY !N1 !SE !SES HAVE /ILL A LONG WAY TO GO T[>D ! CONCRETE4 #dg ,! ESS5CE ( COMMUNISM IS EGOISM2 ! ESS5CE ( EGOISM IS COMMUNISM4 ,?IS IS ! WORLD-*ANG+ SECRET :I* ! WORLD AT L>GE /ILL KEEPS FROM ITSELF4 ,! UNRAVEL+ ( ?IS SECRET AS ! EM]G5CE ( RADICAL SUBJECTIVITY IS NO?+ O!R ?AN ! PROCESS ( ! =MATION ( COMMUNI/ SOCIETY ITSELF4 ,IT ALREADY CONTA9S ! OBJECTIVE PROCESS4 #dh 0,BUT MAN IS ONLY 9DIVIDUALIZ$ ?R\< ! PROCESS ( HI/ORY4 ,HE ORIG9ALLY APPE>S AS A G5]IC BE+1 A TRIBAL BE+1 A H]D ANIMAL -- ?\< BY NO MEANS A 0POLITICAL ANIMAL0 9 ! POLITICAL S5SE4 ,EX*ANGE ITSELF IS A MAJOR AG5T ( ?IS 9DIVIDUALIZATION40 C#b#f #di ,?US1 9 A S5SE1 ALL HI/ORY HAS 79 ! LONG RUN & IF ONLY IMPLICITLY7 BE5 A PROCESS ( 9DIVIDUALIZATION4 ,?IS 9DIVIDUALIZATION REA*ES ITS HIACT]I/IC ( PRIVATE PROP]TY IS A MAT]IALIZ$ REIFICATION :]E ! EGOISM ( ITS SUBJECTS 7CAPITALI/S & WORK]S ALIKE7 IS SUPPRESS$ & SUBORD9AT$ TO ! PSEUDO-SUBJECTIVITY ( ! 0ECONOMY = ITSELF40 N#a ,! TRU? ( ! CAPITALI/ SOCIETY & ITS PRIVATE PROP]TY IS NOT 9DIVIDUAL PROP]TY1 BUT DISPOSSESSION -- VIZ41 ! PROLET>IAT4 ,! TRU? ( PRIVATE PROP]TY IS NO?+ O!R ?AN ! PRODUCTION1 REPRODUCTION1 & GR[? ( A DISPOSSESS$ & PROP]TYLESS CLASS1 I4E41 ! CLASS ( WAGE-LABOR4 ,PRIVATE PROP]TY IS ?US ! V]Y NEGATION ( 9DIVIDUALISM & ( 9DIVIDUAL PROP]TY4 ,= ! OV]:ELM+ MAJORITY ( ITS SUBJECTS1 I4E4 ! PROLET>IAT1 PRIVATE PROP]TY IS BY NO MEANS 9DIVIDUAL PROP]TY1 BUT RA!R IT IS LOSS 7I4E4 SALE -- ALI5ATION7 ( SELF1 BE+-=-ANO!R4 ,EV5 ! CAPITALI/S >E AT BE/ M]E AG5TS ( CAPITAL -- MANAG]S ( !IR [N 7& ( ! G5]AL7 DISPOSSESSION4 ,! MY?ICAL 09DIVIDUALISM0 ( CAPITALI/ SOCIETY CAN ONLY BE REALIZ$ 9 ITS [N NEGATION & 9 ! NEGATION ( ! SOCIETY FROM :I* IT SPRANG4 ,?US ! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE ( #a#h#g#a1 ! FIR/ REALIZ$ 0,DICTATOR%IP ( ! ,PROLET>IAT10 N#b1 C#b#g ATTEMPT$ TO ABOLI% PRIVATE PROP]TY 9 ORD] 0TO MAKE 9DIVIDUAL PROP]TY A TRU?40 C#b#h 0,! CAPITALI/ MODE ( APPROPRIATION1 ! RESULT ( ! CAPITALI/ MODE ( PRODUCTION1 PRODUCES CAPITALI/ PRIVATE PROP]TY4 ,?IS IS ! FIR/ NEGATION ( 9DIVIDUAL PRIVATE PROP]TY1 AS F\ND$ ON ! LABOR ( ! PROPRIETOR4 ,BUT CAPITALI/ PRODUCTION BEGETS1 ) ! 9EXORABILITY ( ! LAW ( ,NATURE1 ITS [N NEGATION4 ,IT IS ! NEGATION ( ! NEGATION4 ,?IS DOES NOT REE/ABLI% PRIVATE PROP]TY = ! PRODUC]1 BUT GIVES HIM 9DIVIDUAL PROP]TY .<6.> BAS$ ON ! ACQUISITIONS ( ! CAPITALI/ ]A3 I4E41 ON COOP]ATION & ! POSSESSION 9 COMMON ( ! L& & ( ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION40 C#b#i ,! REVOLUTION ( G5]ALIZ$ SELF-MANAGEM5T IS ! MOVEM5T FROM N>R[ TO FULL EGOISM1 EGOISM'S [N SELF-5RI*M5T4 ,IT IS EGOISM'S ASC5T FROM ! REALM ( NECESSITY TO ! REALM ( FRE$OM4 ,I,I,I4 ,! ,DIALECTIC ( ,EGOISM #e ,! CONCEPT ( COMMUNI/ SOCIETY CAN BE >RIV$ AT1 BY ONE PA?WAY1 ?R\< ! ANALYSIS & DEVELOPM5T ( ! SELF-CONTRADICTION ( EGOISM1 ( ! SELF-CONTRADICTORY /RUCTURE ( ! EGOI/IC PROJECT4 ,COMMUNI/ SOCIETY ITSELF1 & ! SELF-TRANSC5DANCE ( ! N>R[ EGOISM ( PRIVATIZ$ MAN1 CAN ONLY BE ! \TCOME ( ! IMMAN5T & HI/ORICAL DIALECTIC ( EGOISM ITSELF4 #ea ,! EGOI/IC PROJECT1 9 ORD] TO BECOME ADEQUATE TO ITSELF1 MU/ 9CLUDE MORE ?AN ONE EGO4 #eb ,COMMUNI/ EGOISM1 LIKEWISE COMMUNI/ SOCIETY1 IS ONLY ! F9AL N#a CONCLUSION ( ! IMMAN5T CRITIQUE N#b1 ! SELF-CRITIQUE -- ( B\RGEOIS EGOISM1 ( PRIVATIZ$ LIFE4 #ec 0,COMMUNISM IS SIMPLY 9COMPREH5SIBLE TO \R SA9T A#a BECAUSE ! COMMUNI/S DO NOT PUT EGOISM AGA9/ SELF-SACRIFICE OR SELF-SACRIFICE AGA9/ EGOISM NOR DO !Y EXPRESS ?IS CONTRADICTION !ORETICALLY EI!R 9 ITS S5TIM5TAL OR 9 ITS HI<-FL[N IDEOLOGICAL =M2 ON ! CONTR>Y1 !Y DEMON/RATE ! MAT]IAL BASIS 5G5D]+ IT1 ) :I* IT DISAPPE>S ( ITSELF4 ,! COMMUNI/S DO NOT PREA* MORALITY AT ALL1 SU* AS ,/IRN] PREA*ES SO EXT5SIVELY4 ,!Y DO NOT PUT TO ! PEOPLE ! MORAL DEM&3 LOVE ONE ANO!R1 DO NOT BE EGOI/S1 ETC42 ON ! CONTR>Y1 !Y >E WELL AW>E ?AT EGOISM1 JU/ AS MU* AS SELF-SACRIFICE1 IS 9 DEF9ITE CIRCUM/ANCES A NECESS>Y =M ( ! SELF-ASS]TION ( 9DIVIDUALS4 ,H5CE1 ! COMMUNI/S BY NO MEANS WANT1 AS ,SA9T ,MAX BELIEVES1 & AS HIS LOYAL ,DOTTORE ,GRAZIANO 7,>NOLD ,RUGE7 REPEATS AFT] HIM4441 TO DO AWAY ) ! 0PRIVATE 9DIVIDUAL0 = ! SAKE ( ! 0G5]AL10 SELF-SACRIFIC+ MAN4444 ,COMMUNI/ !ORETICIANS1 ! ONLY ONES :O HAVE TIME TO DEVOTE TO ! /UDY ( HI/ORY1 >E DI/+UI%$ PRECISELY BECAUSE !Y ALONE HAVE DISCOV]$ ?AT ?R\<\T HI/ORY ! 0G5]AL 9T]E/0 IS CREAT$ BY 9DIVIDUALS :O >E DEF9$ AS 0PRIVATE P]SONS40 ,!Y KN[ ?AT ?IS CONTRADICTION IS ONLY A SEEM+ ONE BECAUSE ONE SIDE ( IT1 ! SO-CALL$ 0G5]AL10 IS CON/ANTLY BE+ PRODUC$ BY ! O!R SIDE1 PRIVATE 9T]E/1 & BY NO MEANS OPPOSES ! LATT] AS AN 9DEP5D5T =CE ) AN 9DEP5D5T HI/ORY -- SO ?AT ?IS CONTRADICTION IS 9 PRACTICE ALWAYS BE+ DE/ROY$ & REPRODUC$4 ,H5CE IT IS NOT A QUE/ION ( ! ,HEGELIAN 0NEGATIVE UNITY0 ( TWO SIDES ( A CONTRADICTION1 BUT ( ! MAT]IALLY DET]M9$ DE/RUCTION ( ! PREC$+ MAT]IALLY DET]M9$ MODE ( LIFE ( 9DIVIDUALS1 ) ! DISAPPE>ANCE ( :I* ?IS CONTRADICTION1 TOGE!R ) ITS UNITY1 ALSO DISAPPE>40 C#c #$ ,! SUPPRESSION ( PRIVATE EGOISM FOLL[S ! SAME C\RSE AS PRIVATE EGOISM C#c#a4 ,! PA? \T ( N>R[ EGOISM IS ! /RAIR[ PA? ( ?IS EGOISM ITSELF4 C#c#b 7,BUT1 AS ,E9/E9 >GU$ ) RESPECT TO PHYSICAL TIME-SPACE1 :AT IS /RAIR[ FROM ! N>R[ VIEWPO9T ( ! IMMAN5T OBS]V] MAY BE ANY?+ BUT /RAIG] VIEW -- HIR[ EGOISM PASSES ?R\< N>R[ EGOISM ITSELF4 ,& ALL ATTEMPTS TO BLOCK ?IS WAY T5D ONLY TO 9HIBIT ! DEVELOPM5T & >RE/ IT AT ?IS N>R[ /AGE4 #ef ,PRIVATE EGOISM IS EGOISM 9 CONFLICT ) ITS [N ESS5CE4 7,BUT ?IS BECOMES TRUE VISIBLY1 & !RE=E FULLY1 ONCE1 & ONLY ONCE1 ! CONDITIONS NECESSITAT+ N>R[ APPROPRIATION -- (T5 LUMP$ SLOPPILY UND] ! CONFUSIONI/ CATEGORY 0SC>CITY0 -- >E GONE & ! CONDITIONS = A FULL]1 WID] APPROPRIATION HAVE MATUR$4 ,SPECIFICALLY1 ?IS MEANS ! CONDITIONS = ! APPROPRIATION ( O!R PEOPLE AS SUBJECTS 7MUTUALITY7 AS OPPOS$ TO M]ELY AS OBJECTS 7EXPLOITATION74 ,?US1 = EXAMPLE1 ! PRES5T 0RECESSION10 ! GR[? ( POV]TY & DESP]ATION :I* IT 5TAILS1 HAS BE5 AT FIR/ A MAJOR SETBACK 9 ?IS REG>D1 & HAS DRA/ICALLY CURTAIL$ ! DAILY EXP]I5TIAL BASE :I* = A :ILE -- AT ! PEAK ( ! 0PROSP]ITY0 ( ! SIXTIES -- MADE ?IS CRITIQUE FEEL TRUE474 #eg ,:AT WE T5D NOT TO BE IMM$IATELY AW>E ( IS ?AT ! PREVAIL+ N>R[ & IMPOV]I%+ =M ( EGOISM1 ( SELF-GRATIFICATION1 IS ONE DEEPLY MIX$ ) ITS OPPOSITE2 ) ! R5UNCIATION ( SELF-GRATIFICATION2 ?AT ! 0GRE$0 WE NORMALLY EXP]I5CE IS A GRE$ RADICALLY ADMIX$ ) ITS [N NEGATION1 ) ! EMBITT]$ R5UNCIATION ( GRE$1 BAS+ ITSELF AS IT MU/ ON ! N>R[ CONDITIONS ( SELF-5JOYM5T PRES5TLY AVAILABLE & ESPECIALLY =M]LY AVAILABLE TO IT1 UND] CONDITIONS ( EXTREME DEPRIVATION & TOIL4 ,SPECIFICALLY1 ! =M ( SELF-5JOYM5T :I* IS EXCLUD$1 ! SECRET SELF-D5IAL HID+ AT ! HE>T ( PRIVATIZ$ EGOISM1 IS ! D5IAL ( ALL ! SOCIAL PLEASURES1 ! COMMUNAL PLEASURES ( SPONTANE\S GREG>I\SNESS1 ! W>M? ( HUMAN SOLID>ITY1 ! EXUB]ANCE ( AU!NTIC FE/IVITY -- ! PLEASURES ( ASSOCIATION & SOCIAL SATISFACTION 9 G5]AL4 ,! VE/IGES ( !SE >E CONF9$ )9 ! EV]-N>R[+ CIRCLE ( ! PRIVATE FAMILY1 ITSELF ! NUCLE> REMNANT1 ADAPT$ BY CAPITAL1 ( ! BYGONE PRIMITIVE-COMMUNI/ K9%IP SOCIETIES & !IR 0EXT5D$ FAMILIES01 :I* PUBLICIZES ITS F9AL SELF-CRITIQUE 9 ! BURGEON+ RATES ( DIVORCE1 DIVORCE BE+ RECOGNIZ$ AS & (FICIALLY TITL$ 0E/RANGEM5T40 ,?IS ESPECIALLY 9 ! 0ADVANC$0 CAPITALI/ C\NTRIES -- ?AT IS1 ! C\NTRIES :I* HAVE REA*$ ! ADVANC$ /AGES ( SOCIAL ALI5ATION4 ,! LAG 9 APPROPRIATION ( ! NEW] CONDITIONS ( 0NON-SC>CITY10 ( POT5TIAL & 7TO SOME EXT5T ALREADY7 ACTUAL ABUNDANCE1 IS ! CONTEXT 9 :I* ! PRES5T HI/ORICAL /AGE ( ! 'DIALECTIC ( EGOISM' MU/ BE UND]/OOD4 ,! POSITIVE MOM5T ( ! E>LY 0HIP0 MOVEM5T 7( :I* MOM5T TODAY'S PR(ESSIONAL /REET V]M9 & GUTT] HIPPIES >E 9 NO S5SE ! HEIRS7 -- ! :OLE LIBID9AL EM]G5CE :I* BEGAN 9 ! SIXTIES1 & N[1 9 ! RECESSION ( ! SEV5TIES1 IS ECLIPS$ AGA9 IS COMPREH5SIBLE 9 P>T AS A BEG9N+ ( ! APPROPRIATION ( ?OSE NEW CONDITIONS4N#a #eh ,! ROOT ILLUSION ( ALL PI\S & ASCETIC IDEOLOGIES IS ?AT1 S9CE EXPLOITATION IS ! P>TIAL APPROPRIATION ( MAN BY MAN1 ! WAY TO RID ! WORLD ( ?IS 0S90 IS 9 9/ITUT+ ! NON-APPROPRIATION ( MAN BY MAN1 RA!R ?AN ! TOTAL APPROPRIATION3 ?AT ! WAY TO ! NEGATION 70QUIET+07 ( DESIRE IS ITS REPRESSION RA!R ?AN ITS FULFILLM5T3 T\* ME NOT & ,I WILL T\* NOT !E4 ,! LOGIC ( PRIVATION4 ,! PROBLEM ( ! MIS]Y ( N>R[ EGOISM ADMITS ( ONLY TWO SOLUTIONS3 EI!R 7#a7 ITS EXAGG]ATION TO ! PO9T :]E IT OV]SPILLS ITS [N LIMITS2 ITS EXPANSION UNTIL IT BECOMES ONE ) ! TOTALITY1 R$ISCOV]+ PRECISELY )9 ITSELF ITS SUPPOS$ OPPOSITE & ?AT :I* IT =M]LY EXCLUD$1 OR 7#b7 ITS REPRESSION1 & ) ?AT EVID5TIALLY1 ! UN5D+ REIGN ( ! PRES5T =M1 :I* IS ALL ?AT ITS HI/ORICAL REPRESSION HAS SO F> SUCCE$$ 9 PRODUC+4 #ei ,COMMUNISM IS NOT ! SELF-REPRESSION ( EGOISM4 ,IT IS ONLY :5 N>R[ EGOISM WANTS TO TRANSC5D ITSELF = ITS [N DEEPE/ REASONS3 :5 IT F9DS 9T]NAL REASONS1 EGOI/IC REASONS2 :5 IT SEES ITSELF BECOM+ ITS [N RU91 DEFEAT+ TO ITSELF1 SELF-DEFEAT+1 & -- !RE=E1 SELF-CONTRADICTORY -- ?AT IT BR+S ITSELF TO ITS [N 5D1 & COMMUNISM BEG9S4 ,PRIVATE EGOISM HI/ORICALLY IS ITS [N UNDO+4 ,ITS EX]CISE BR+S AB\T ITS [N SOCIALIZATION -- SOCIAL EGOISM4 ,COMMUNISM IS ! NEGATION ( EGOISM ONLY BY VIRTUE ( BE+ A HI<] =M ( EGOISM -- EGOISM'S [N HI<] =M4 ,N>R[ EGOISM1 ! IDEOLOGY ( SELF-GRATIFICATION & SELF-REALIZATION1 & ! PRACTICE ( EXCLUSIVE SELF-GRATIFICATION & SELF-REALIZATION BECOMES1 AT A C]TA9 /AGE 9 ITS DEVELOPM5T1 A FETT] UPON SELF-REALIZATION & A FETT] UPON SELFGRATIFICATION4 ,IT BECOMES ! MA9 LIMIT & OB/ACLE TO ITS [N GOALS4 ,IT BECOMES A B>RI] TO ITSELF4 ,?IS IS ! SELF-NEGATIVITY :I* AWAK5S 9 IT ! DESIRE = ITS [N TRANSC5DANCE3 = SELF-TRANSC5DANCE1 A SUP]SESSION 9 ACCORD ) ITSELF1 ) ITS [N ESS5CE1 & ON ITS [N T]MS1 BAS+ ITSELF ON ! POSSIBILITY ( ! COMMUNITY ( GRATIFICATION AS ! UNLIMIT$ AMPLIFICATION ( GRATIFICATION4 ,?IS IS ! IMMAN5T SELF-CRITIQUE ( N>R[ EGOISM2 ! DEA? S5T5CE :I* IT PRON\NCES UPON ITSELF4 ,?US ! DET]M9ATE NEGATION ( N>R[ EGOISM CAN ONLY BE ?R\< ITS [N ORGANIC DEVELOPM5T1 ITS [N FUR!R DEVELOPM5T4 ,?AT IS1 IT CAN ONLY BE SELF-NEGATION4 0,HAPP9ESS0 AT ! EXP5SE ( O!RS2 ! EXCLUSION ( ! O!RS' HAPP9ESS FROM Y\R [N H5CE=? APPE>S AS A MIS]ABLE BASIS2 AS ! OPPOSITE ( HAPP9ESS1 AS MIS]Y1 & PRIVATE PROP]TY AS A WEAL? ( POV]TY1 COMP>$ TO ! NEW BASIS :I* HAS GR[N UP SECRETLY ) MOD]N SOCIETY ITSELF4 ,COMMUNISM IS ! COMPREH5SION ( EXCLUSIVE EGOISM AS HI/ORICALLY SELF-CONTRADICTORY & ?US F9ITE3 DOOM$ TO P]I% -- AS NOT ET]NAL 0HUMAN NATURE0 BUT1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 SELF-CANCEL+2 TRANSITORY2 TRANSITIONAL2 AS ! DECID$LY UNNATURAL 7ANTISOCIAL7 CONDITION ( MAN PRIOR TO ! HI/ORICAL SELF-COMPLETION ( ! HUMAN SPECIES4 ,COMMUNISM IS ! COMPREH5SION ( B\RGEOIS EGOISM AS ALREADY CONTA9+ & IMPLY+ ITS [N HI/ORICAL NEGATION1 AS CONTA9+ ITS [N NEGATION 9 EMBRYO -- CONTA9+ ! SE$S ( ITS [N DE/RUCTION -- BY VIRTUE ( ITS BE+ FALSE TO ITSELF4 ,SOCIETY1 0SOCIALISM0 -- & SOCIAL PRODUCTION -- WAS ITS REPRESS$ ESS5CE ALL ALONG4 #f ,ALL ALONG ! L9E1 CONSCI\SLY OR NOT1 0ME FIR/0 HAS ALWAYS BE5 ! NECESS>Y PATT]N ( EV]YONE'S PRACTICE4 ,EV]YONE AT EV]Y MOM5T ( !IR LIVES CONSCI\SLY OR NOT ACTS 9 HIS [N SELF-9T]E/ AT SOME LEVEL4 ,ANY?+ ELSE W\LD BE 9CONCEIVABLE1 IMPOSSIBLE4 N#a ,UNABLE TO PURSUE HIS DESIRES DIRECTLY1 A MASO*I/ USES ! M$IATION ( PA94 ,! MASO*I/S ( MORALITY1 IDEOLOGY & CAUSES SEEK PLEASURE BY MEANS ( ! PA9 ( SUBORD9AT+ !MSELVES ?R\< !SE PROJECTIONS4 ,! MORAL IDEALI/ ATTEMPTS TO GET :AT HE WANTS ?R\< ! M$IATION ( HIS PROJECT$ IDEAL1 BECAUSE HE DOESN'T KN[ H[ TO GET :AT HE WANTS DIRECTLY4 ,HE DOESN'T KN[ ! PRACTICAL MEANS )9 HIMSELF AS ! SUBJECT & C5T] ( ?AT PRACTICE1 SO HE POSITS HIS C5T] \TSIDE ( HIMSELF AS A RIGIDIFI$ G5]ALIZATION :I* IS TO 0DECIDE = HIM40 ,9 SO DO+ HE MAKES ! MI/AKE ( ?9K+ ?AT CONSI/5CY ) HIS IDEAL IS ALWAYS CONSI/5CY ) HIS SELF-9T]E/4 #fa 0,COMMUNI/ EGOISM0 NAMES ! NEGATION ( ! NEGATION ( PRIMITIVE EGOISM 7N>R[ EGOISM74 ,BUT ! ASPECT ( ! PROCESS AS AN IMMAN5T OR SELF-CRITIQUE1 & NEV] AN EXT]NAL OR ME*ANICAL NEGATION 7E4G4 ! 0SMA% SELF0 N#a IDEOLOGY ( ,MAOISM7 MU/ ABOVE ALL BE EMPHASIZ$1 AGA9/ ALL CO]CIVE & BUREAUCRATIC ME?ODS4 ,SOCIAL7IZ$7 EGOISM1 COMMUNI/ EGOISM1 IS ! NEGATION ( ! NEGATION ( CAPITALI/ EGOISM1 BUT IT IS ! SELF-NEGATION ( ! SELF-NEGATION ( ?AT EGOISM4 ,?IS SECOND NEGATION IS ESS5TIAL TO N>R[ EGOISM ITSELF1 NO LESS ?AN ! FIR/ NEGATION1 :I* PRODUCES ITS ANTI!SIS -- MORALISM1 ANTI-EGOISM2 ALTRUISM4 ,?IS SECOND NEGATION IS NECESS>Y TO N>R[ EGOISM1 TO ! PRES]VATION ( ITS [N PREMISES1 ONCE IT ADVANCES TO A C]TA9 ?RE%OLD 9 ITS SELF-DEVELOPM5T4 ,! PROP] ME?OD TO CATALYZE -- TO /IMULATE & ACCEL]ATE -- ?IS PROCESS IS ANO!R1 I4E41 FROM ! '\TSIDE'1 IS ! EVOCATIVE ME?OD2 ! ME?OD ( S$UCTION4 ,! ME?OD ( REBUKE1 ?\< USEFUL AT C]TA9 CRUCIAL TURNS H]E TOO1 IS1 ESPECIALLY 9 ! =M ( ! ME?OD ( *A/ISEM5T1 MORE ADEQUATE TO ! FIR/1 NOT ! SECOND1 NEGATION ( N>R[ EGOISM4 ,! ME?OD ( *A/ISEM5T IS ?AT ( =CIBLY DRAW+ \T MORAL PROJECTIONS FROM ! PSY*E1 ( CREAT+ 0H&LES0 9 ! VICTIM'S HEAD = EASY MANIPULATION 70H&L+07 BY AU?ORITIES & IDEOLOGUES ( ALL SORTS2 ( 9/ILL+ SUBMISSIV5ESS1 ( 9DUC+ ! SPLIT 9 ! VICTIM BETWE5 ! S5SE ( DUTY & ! S5SE ( 9CL9ATION2 ( =M+ ! GUILT-LOOP ( ALI5AT$ SELF-CONTROL4 ,! SECOND NEGATION MEANS1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 ! NEGATION ( ALTRUISM1 ! OV]COM+ ( ALL !SE SEP>ATIONS2 ! COLLAPSE ( ! PROJECTIONS BACK 9TO ! PSY*E2 !IR RE-[N+ 9 ! COALESC5CE ( ! SELF3 ! C5TRATION1 9/EAD ( ! ALI5ATION1 ( SELF-CONTROL4 ,?IS IS ! V]Y =MATION ( ! 0SELF0 CAPABLE ( 0SELF0 MANAGEM5T4 #fb ,DON'T GET US WRONG4 ,MAKE NO MI/AKE4 ,?IS !ORY IS NO APOLOGIA = N>R[ EGOISM4 ,WE HAVE NO 9T]E/ 9 ?AT NEGATION ( ALTRUISM :I* IS SIMPLY A RETURN TO N>R[ EGOISM2 A REGRESSION4 ,COMMUNI/ EGOISM1 & NOT ALTRUISM1 IS ! TRUE OPPOSITE ( N>R[ EGOISM4 ,COMMUNI/ EGOISM1 & NOT N>R[ EGOISM1 IS ! TRUE OPPOSITE ( ALTRUISM4 ,AL?\< ALTRUISM & N>R[ EGOISM >E COMMONLY TAK5 AS TRUE OPPOSITES1 !Y HAVE ?IS 9 COMMON3 AN IMMAN5T CRITIQUE ( EI!R MU/ >RIVE AT COMMUNI/ EGOISM4 ,?AT IS1 COMMUNI/ EGOISM IS ! SYN!SIS ( ALTRUISM & N>R[ EGOISM4 ,COMMUNI/ EGOISM IS SIMULTANE\SLY1 ID5TICALLY BO? ( !M & NEI!R2 IT IS ?AT UNIT>Y REJECTION ( BO? :I* IS ALSO !IR UNIT>Y AFFIRMATION4 N#a ,I,V4 ,! ,RESONANCE ( ,EGOISMS #fc 0,9 PLACE ( ! OLD B\RGEOIS SOCIETY ) ITS CLASSES & CLASS ANTAGONISMS1 WE %ALL HAVE AN ASSOCIATION 9 :I* ! FREE DEVELOPM5T ( EA* IS ! CONDITION = ! FREE DEVELOPM5T ( ALL40 C#c#c #fd 0,9 ! LABORATORIES ( 9DIVIDUAL CREATIVITY1 A REVOLUTION>Y AL*EMY TRANSMUTES ! BASE/ METALS ( EV]YDAY LIFE 9TO GOLD4 ,FIR/ & =EMO/1 ! PROBLEM IS TO DISSOLVE ! CONSCI\SNESS ( CON/RA9TS -- ?AT IS1 ! FEEL+ ( IMPOT5CE -- 9 ! MAGNETIC EX]CISE ( CREATIVITY2 MELT !M 9 ! SURGE ( CREATIVE P[]1 9 ! S]5E AFFIRMATION ( ITS G5IUS4 ,MEGALOMANIA1 /]ILE ON ! LEVEL ( PRE/IGE & ! SPECTACLE1 REPRES5TS 9 ?IS CONTEXT AN IMPORTANT /AGE 9 ! /RUGGLE OPPOS+ ! EGO TO ! COALESC$ =CES ( CONDITION+4 0,TODAY1 NIHILISM REIGNS TRIUMPHANT1 & 9 ITS NIK ( CREATIVITY1 :I* IS ! SP>K ( ALL REAL LIFE1 %9ES ONLY ! MORE BRIKS BECOME MORE FREQU5T & GRADUALLY DISSOLVE 9TO A S+LE LIMONY ( 9DIVIDUAL WILLS4 ,HI/ORIC BECOM+ HAS TAK5 US TO ! CROSS+ PO9T :]E RADICAL SUBJECTIVITY IS CONFRONT$ ) ! POSSIBILITY ( TRANS=M+ ! WORLD4 ,?IS PRIVILEG$ MOM5T IS ! REV]SAL ( P]SPECTIVE 04 C#c#d #fe ,COMMUNI/ SOCIETY IS CONCEIVABLE ONLY ON ! F\NDATION ( ! RESONANCE ( EGOISMS4 ,?US ITS BASIS IS ! COHESION ( EGOISMS1 :]EAS H]ET(ORE EGOISM HAS APPE>$ AS ! =CE ( SEP>ATION & PRIVITIZATION P> EXCELL5CE4 #ff ,! ESS5CE ( ! RESONANCE ( EGOISMS IS ?IS3 ! O!R P]SON IS A P>T ( Y\R WEAL?4 C#c#e #fg ,! RESONANCE ( EGOISMS IS ! UNITY1 ! SYN!SIS1 ! S+UL>ITY1 ( ! 0P>TICUL>0 & ! 0G5]AL0 9T]E/3 COMMUNI/ SOCIETY4 #fh ,! COHESION ( COMMUNI/ SOCIETY1 ONCE ! ?RE%OLD ( ITS CONDITIONS-PROP] HAS BE5 REA*$1 IS CONCEIVABLE ON ?IS BASIS3 ?AT ! COMMUNITY1 SOCIETY1 ASSOCIATION ITSELF IS ! GREATE/ P]SONAL VALUE ?AT ! SOCIAL 9DIVIDUALS EA* POSSESS4 ,?AT IS1 !IR SOCIAL RELATION%IPS >E ?IS GREATE/ VALUE & ?IS GREATE/ WEAL?4 ,! SOCIAL RELATION ITSELF BECOMES ! UNIT>Y1 UNIFI$1 & UNIV]SAL MEANS TO ! ATTA9M5T ( EV]Y 5D2 TO ! GRATIFICATION ( EV]Y NE$1 & ?US ALSO AN 5D 9 ITSELF4 ,SOCIETY HOLDS TOGE!R TO ! EXT5T ?AT ! SOCIAL 9DIVIDUALS F9D A GREAT] VALUE 9 ITS REPRODUCTION ?AN 9 ANY ACT ?AT W\LD DE/ROY IT4 ,V4 ,COMMUNI/ ,SOCIETY #fi 0444 9 PLACE ( ! WEAL? & POV]TY ( POLITICAL ECONOMY1 WE HAVE ! WEAL?Y MAN & ! PL5ITUDE ( HUMAN NE$4 ,! WEAL?Y MAN IS AT ! SAME TIME ! ONE :O NE$S A COMPLEX ( HUMAN MANIFE/ATIONS ( LIFE1 & :OSE [N SELF-REALIZATION EXI/S AS AN 9N] NECESSITY1 A NE$4 ,NOT ONLY ! WEAL? BUT ALSO ! POV]TY ( MAN ACQUIRES1 9 A SOCIALI/ P]SPECTIVE1 A HUMAN & ?US A SOCIAL MEAN+4 ,POV]TY IS ! PASSIVE BOND :I* LEADS MAN TO EXP]I5CE A NE$ = ! GREATE/ WEAL?1 ! O!R P]SON4 ,! SWAY ( ! OBJECTIVE 5TITY )9 ME1 ! S5SU\S ]UPTION ( MY LIFE-ACTIVITY1 IS ! PASSION :I* H]E BECOMES ! ACTIVITY ( MY BE+40 C#c#f #g 0,AU!NTIC COMMON LIFE >ISES NOT ?R\< REFLECTION2 RA!R IT COMES AB\T FROM ! NE$ & EGOISM ( 9DIVIDUALS1 ?AT IS1 IMM$IATELY FROM ! ACTIVATION ( !IR V]Y EXI/5CE4 ,IT IS NOT UP TO MAN :E!R ?IS COMMON LIFE EXI/S OR NOT4 ,H[EV]1 SO LONG AS MAN DOES NOT RECOGNIZE HIMSELF AS MAN & DOES NOT ORGANIZE ! WORLD HUMANLY1 ?IS COMMON LIFE APPE>S 9 ! =M ( ALI5ATION1 BECAUSE ITS SUBJECT1 MAN1 IS A BE+ ALI5AT$ FROM ITSELF40 C#c#g #ga ,WE ANTICIPATE A PR(\ND REV]SAL ( P]SPECTIVE AT ! ?RE%OLD ( COMMUNAL SOCIETY1 9 :I* ANY POSSIBLE /RICTLY PRIVATIZ$ VALUE WILL PALE 9TO 9SIGNIFICANCE1 & BE EXP]I5C$ AS N>R[ & IMPOV]I%$1 9 COMP>ISON TO ! 9DIVIDUAL1 P]SONAL1 0PRIVATE0 VALUE TO EA* SOCIAL 9DIVIDUAL ( HIS SOCIAL EXI/5CE4 ,& ?IS ATTITUDE W\LD BE !N1 UND] ?OSE CONDITIONS1 NO M]E IDEALI/IC PO/URE OR PI\S WI%1 NO M]E MORAL AB/RACTION1 NO REPRES5TATION OV] & ABOVE ! REAL CONDITIONS -- :I* IS ALL IT CAN EV] BE TODAY -- BUT1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 W\LD >ISE FROM ! MO/ IMM$IATE1 PALPABLE1 & CONCRETE FACTS ( LIFE4 ,9CREAS+LY UP TO ! PRES5T1 S9CE ! BREAKUP ( E>LY COMMUNAL =MS1 ALL WEAL? HAS BE5 PRIVATE1 ?AT IS1 ONLY PRIVATE PROP]TY HAS BE5 RECOGNIZ$ AS WEAL?4 ,9 ! FUTURE1 IF !RE IS A FUTURE1 ! N>R[ & ! PRIVATIZ$ WILL BE REVEAL$ AS ! ESS5CE ( POV]TY1 & WEAL? WILL BE REALIZ$ AS SOCIAL WEAL?1 AS WEAL? 9 HUMAN BE+S2 9 !IR RELATIONS & !IR CAPACITIES1 9 !IR FACULTIES & !IR OBJECTIFICATIONS4 N#a ,?AT IS1 ! GREATE/ WEAL?1 & ! NECESS>Y CONTEXT ( ALL WEAL?1 IS SOCIETY ITSELF4 #gb ,! C5TRAL PROBLEM ( COMMUNI/ SOCIAL RELATIONS IS ! FOLL[+3 :AT IS TO BE ! BASIS ( HUMAN RELATION%IPS1 ( ! 9T]P]SONAL COHESION1 BEYOND K9%IP & EX*ANGEVALUE1 ?AT IS1 BEYOND ! BLOOD-RELATIONS :I* =M$ ! 9CR$IBLE B9D+-=CE1 & GREAT WEAKNESS1 ( PRIMITIVE COMMUNI/ SOCIETIES1 & ! EX*ANGE-VALUE RELATIONS 9TO :I* !SE 9CREAS+LY DISSOLV$ 9 ! =MATION ( CLASSSOCIETIES8 ,! SOLUTION CAN ONLY BE ( ! =M ( REAL AFF9ITY1 PRACTICALLY1 S5SU\SLY DISCOV]$ & V]IFI$1 PRACTICALLY SUP]S$$ & DISSOLV$2 FREE ASSOCIATION2 ! RESONANCE ( PASSIONS4 ,BUT )9 ?IS /ATEM5T ( ! SOLUTION1 EV]Y?+ /ILL REMA9S TO BE SAID4 #gc ,LET'S GET ONE ?+ /RAIE SUBJECTIVELY 0B\ND & DET]M9$0 TO PRODUCE IT4 ,& ?IS DOES NOT D5Y AT ALL ?AT SU* A SUBJECTIVITY HAS ITS NECESS>Y OBJECTIVE CONDITIONS ?AT CAN ONLY DEVELOP HI/ORICALLY4 ,V,I4 ,RADICAL ,SUBJECTIVITY #gd ,:AT IS ?IS 0RADICAL SUBJECTIVITY08 C#c#h ,FROM N[ ON1 ! REVOLUTION>Y SUBJECT IS ! CONSCI\S -- & POSITIVELY SELF-CONSCI\S -- EGOI/1 AS OPPOS$ TO ! UNCONSCI\S OR NEGATIVELY SELF-CONSCI\S 7GUILTY7 EGOI/S AMONG :OM ! REVOLUTION>Y WALKS UNRECOGNIZ$ BUT RECOGNIZ+ !M4 ,HE CAN SU/A9 ?IS POSITIVE ATTITUDE T[>D HIS EXP&$ EGOISM1 & ITS FIR/ SIGNS 9 O!RS1 BY VIRTUE ( HIS COMPREH5SION ( ITS POSITIVE SOCIAL \TCOME 9 A SOCIETY1 SEP>AT$ FROM ?IS ONE BY ! SOCIO-PSY*O!RAPEUTIC PROCESS ( REVOLUTION1 9 :I* ! EGOISM ( EA* IS ! FIR/ CONDITION = ! FULFILLM5T ( ! EGOISM ( ALL4 #ge ,CONTR>Y TO ! IDEOLOGICAL BANALITY1 IT IS ONLY ! MO/ GRE$Y PEOPLE :O CAN NEV] BE 0B\ ,*RI/IANISM N#a :I* !RE9 /ILL REMA9$1 WE LOCATE ! V]Y ROOT ( !IR FAILURE4 #gg ,RADICAL SUBJECTIVITY1 ?AT IS1 COMMUNI/ EGOISM OR ! 7REALIZ$7 0SOCIAL 9DIVIDUAL0 C#c#i 7,M>X7 IS ! CONCRETE UNIV]SAL :I* IS EM]G5T 9 \R TIME4 ,IT IS ! P>TICUL> :I* IS 7POT5TIALLY7 EV]Y:]E4 ,RADICAL SUBJECTIVITY IS \R V]Y ROOT1 ! ROOT ( :AT WE ALL HAVE 9 COMMON1 ! REAL BASIS ( COMMUNITY4 ,ROOT SUBJECTIVITY -- ! 0PRIMITIVE0 HUMAN ROOT -- C\LD ONLY BE DIVULG$ AS SU* AT ! F> 5D ( PREHI/ORY1 AS ! \TCOME ( ! PROCESS ( ?AT PREHI/ORY ITSELF1 & AS ! SECRET BASIS ( ITS SUP]SESSION4 #< 0,I AM NO?+1 BUT ,I MU/ BE EV]Y?+40 C#d ,)9 ?IS MON/R\S DECREPITUDE ( CONTEMPOR>Y 0SOCIETY01 ! NIHILI/1 ITS COMMONPLACE PRODUCT1 KN[S ONLY ! FIR/ HALF ( ?IS /ATEM5T4 ,I AM NO?+4 ,!RE=E1 ANY?+ ELSE CAN ONLY BE LESS ?AN NO?+ TO ME4 ,9 ! UPSIDE-D[N WORLD ( ALI5ATION1 IT IS ! TOTALITY ( ?+S1 ( COMMODITIES1 ( MONEY1 ( CAPITAL1 ?AT IS EV]Y?+1 & WE1 ! WORK]S :O MAKE IT1 >E %IT4 ,! NIHILI/ IS LIKE A SYLLOGISM SUSP5D$ AT ! M9OR PREMISE1 AN ACROBAT :OSE SOM]SAULT IS BROK5 9 MID-FLIY CONCLUSION3 ,I AM NO?+1 BUT ,I MU/ BE EV]Y?+6 -- ! CONCLUSION ?AT W\LD MAKE A REVOLUTION>Y ( HIM4 ,WE PRODUCE COMMODITIES1 MONEY1 CAPITAL4 ,WE PRODUCE EV]Y?+ ?AT MAKES UP SOCIAL WEAL?4 ,WE MU/ BECOME EXPLICITLY :AT WE ALREADY >E IMPLICITLY3 EV]Y?+6 ,?IS BECOM+-VISIBLE1 ?IS BECOM+-TRUE ( ! SOCIAL TRU? EXPRESSES ! TOTAL PROCESS ( ! COMMUNI/ REVOLUTION4 ,V,I,I4 ,PLEASURE #gi ,B\RGEOIS POLITICAL ECONOMY1 ! SCI5CE ( ! EX*ANGE-VALUE1 WAS ALWAYS ONLY ! FALSE CONSCI\SNESS ( ! ECONOMY1 & ! SCI5CE ( ALI5ATION4 N#a ,?IS IS ! FIR/ & F9AL MESSAGE ( ITS ,M>XIAN CRITIQUE4 ,) ! DY+-\T ( EX*ANGE-VALUE1 ! SCI5CE ( USE-VALUE 7?US ALL ! CONCRETE SCI5CES1 N[ UNIFI$ ?R\< !IR UNIFI$ SUBJECTIVE USE7 WILL BECOME ! ONLY USEFUL SCI5CE4 ,& ! SCI5CE ( USE-VALUE IS ! SCI5CE ( PLEASURE4 #h 0,REAL ECONOMY -- SAV+S -- CONSI/S 9 ! SAV+ ( WORK+ TIME 7! M9IMUM1 & R$UCTION TO ! M9IMUM1 ( PRODUCTION CO/S72 BUT ?IS SAV+ IS ID5TICAL ) ! DEVELOPM5T ( PRODUCTIVITY4 ,ECONOMIZ+1 !RE=E1 DOES NOT MEAN ! GIV+ UP ( PLEASURE1 BUT ! DEVELOPM5T ( P[] & PRODUCTIVE CAPACITY1 & ?US BO? ! CAPACITY = & MEANS ( 5JOYM5T4 ,! CAPACITY = 5JOYM5T IS A CONDITION ( 5JOYM5T & !RE=E ITS PRIM>Y MEANS2 & ?IS CAPACITY IS ! DEVELOPM5T ( AN 9DIVIDUAL'S TAL5TS1 & ?US ( ! PRODUCTIVE =CE4 ,TO ECONOMIZE ON LABOR TIME MEANS TO 9CREASE ! AM\NT ( ! FREE TIME1 I4E4 TIME = ! COMPLETE DEVELOPM5T ( ! 9DIVIDUAL1 :I* AGA9 REACTS AS ! GREATE/ PRODUCTIVE =CE ON ! PRODUCTIVE =CE ( LABOR4 ,FROM ! /&PO9T ( ! IMM$IATE PRODUCTION PROCESS IT MAY BE CONSID]$ AS PRODUCTION ( FIX$ CAPITAL2 ?IS FIX$ CAPITAL BE+ MAN HIMSELF4 ,IT IS ALSO SELF-EVID5T ?AT ! IMM$IATE LABOR TIME CANNOT REMA9 9 ITS AB/RACT CONTRADICTION TO FREE TIME AS 9 B\RGEOIS ECONOMY4 ,WORK CANNOT BECOME A GAME A#a AS ,F\RI] W\LD LIKE IT TO BE2 HIS GREAT M]IT WAS ?AT HE DECL>$ ?AT ! ULTIMATE OBJECT MU/ BE TO RAISE TO A HI<] LEVEL NOT DI/RIBUTION BUT ! MODE ( PRODUCTION4 ,FREE TIME -- :I* 9CLUDES LEISURE TIME AS WELL AS TIME = HI<] ACTIVITIES -- NATURALLY TRANS=MS ANYONE :O 5JOYS IT 9TO A DIFF]5T P]SON1 & IT IS ?IS DIFF]5T P]SON :O !N 5T]S ! DIRECT PROCESS ( PRODUCTION4 ,! MAN :O IS BE+ =M$ F9DS DISCIPL9E 9 ?IS PROCESS1 :ILE = ! MAN :O IS ALREADY =M$ IT IS PRACTICE1 EXP]IM5TAL SCI5CE1 MAT]IALLY CREATIVE & SELF-OBJECTIFY+ KN[L$GE1 & HE CONTA9S )9 HIS [N HEAD ! ACCUMULAT$ WISDOM ( SOCIETY40 C#d#a #ha ,! MAJOR %ORTCOM+ ( CONTEMPOR>Y 9DIVIDUALS IS !IR 9CAPACITY = PLEASURE4 ,\R DAILY LIVES >E IMPOV]I%$ 9 P>T BECAUSE WE >E OP5 TO ! WORLD1 & !RE=E TO PLEASURE 7AS WELL AS TO PA97 ONLY 9 SU* N>R[ & LIMIT$ WAYS4 ,!SE >E ! DEF5SES1 ! *>ACT]->MOR1 CONGRU5T ) A WORLD OV]LOAD$ ) PA91 A WORLD ( SUFF]+1 :I* WAS & IS ! WORLD ( POV]TY ) ITS /RUGGLE = EXI/5CE1 ITS 0W> ( ALL AGA9/ ALL10 :]E TO BE OP5 IS TO BE WEAK1 & TO BE WEAK IS TO BE MADE A VICTIM4 ,! SELF-CONTRADICTION ( B\RGEOIS EGOISM %>P5S & BECOMES CONSCI\S ONLY 9 ! 5VIRONM5T ( ?AT 9CIPI5T WORLD ( PL5TY & WORLD ( PLEASURE :I* B\RGEOIS SOCIETY1 DUR+ ! PROSP]ITY PHASE ( ITS ECONOMIC CYCLE1 ITSELF =E%AD[S2 ?AT IS1 ONLY :5 ! WALLS :I* LOCK \T PA9 BEG9 TO BE P]CEIV$ 9 DAILY EXP]I5CE AS WALLS :I* LOCK \T PLEASURE4 ,! /RUGGLE AGA9/ ! SOCIAL ORGANIZATION = PA9 & = ! SOCIAL ORGANIZATION = PLEASURE IS ! REVOLUTION>Y /RUGGLE4 ,! PROBLEM1 =MULAT$ ANO!R WAY1 IS ! PRES5T N>R[ *>ACT] ( 0! APPROPRIATION ( NATURE & HUMAN NATURE BY MAN 40 C#d#b #hb ,9 ! REVOLUTION>Y PROCESS1 ! /RUGGLE IS ! /RUGGLE ( PLEASURE2 ! PLEASURE IS ! PLEASURE ( /RUGGLE4 #hc ,TODAY1 PEOPLE OPPRESS EA* O!R BY ! SMALLNESS ( !IR DESIRE2 !IR POV]TY ( SOCIAL NE$S2 !IR LACK ( A FULL] EGOISM1 A FULL] GRE$4 ,WE >E ASK+ PEOPLE TO ASK = MORE1 SO ?AT WE CAN ASK = MORE1 & GET MORE FROM !M -- GET :AT WE CAN ONLY GET BY BE+ ALL[$ TO GIVE MORE4 ,WE DO NOT ASK Y\ = MU*3 WE ASK FROM Y\ ONLY Y\R [N EGOISM1 & WE DO SO NOT \T ( ALTRUISM1 BUT = \R [N EGOI/IC REASONS4 ,FROM ! DEP?S ( \R [N1 WE ASK Y\ = ! DEP?S ( Y\RS4 ,BUT 9 ASK+ Y\ = ?AT1 WE ASK Y\ TO GIVE EV]Y?+ Y\'VE GOT2 TO GIVE Y\R ALL4 #hd 0,POSITIVE HUMAN SELF-CONSCI\SNESS0 C#d#c CAN ONLY BE GUILTLESS EGOISM1 :I* CAN ONLY MEAN COMMUNI/ EGOISM1 ! EGOISM :I* DOES NOT EXCLUDE ! PLEASURE ( O!R EGOS1 BUT ON ! CONTR>Y1 APPROPRIATES ?IS AS ITS [N PLEASURE1 9CLUDES IT PRECISELY = ITS [N SELFI% REASONS4 #he ,! NEGATIVELY SELF-CONSCI\S EGOI/ IS ! GUILTY EGOI/1 ! EGOI/ :O /RIVES AFT] HIS [N N>R[ DESIRES GUILTILY1 & ?US WORKS AGA9/ HIMSELF2 RESI/S HIMSELF -- OPPOSES A P>T ( HIS [N 5]GY TO HIS [N PROJECT4 ,IT IS ! 5]GY PRES5TLY TI$-UP 9 GUILT1 9 SELF-POLIC+1 9 SELF-REPRESSION -- *>ACT]->MOR -- :I*1 ONCE FRE$ CAN BUILD ! NEW WORLD4 ,PEOPLE SEEK+1 9 GOOD CONSCI5CE & )\T GUILT1 MORE PLEASURE = !IR [N EV]YDAY LIVES1 CONTA9 ! :OLE ( ! REVOLUTION4 #hf ,SELF-SACRIFICE IS ALWAYS ,*RI/IAN4 ,ALWAYS4 #hg ,! 'EXPANSION ( EGOISM' REF]S NOT ONLY TO ! EXPANSION 7( SELF-ID5TITY7 OV] MANY SELVES AT ANY ONE TIME1 BUT ALSO TO ITS EXPANSION OV] TIME 0AT0 ANY ONE SELF4 ,! SACRIFICE ( A FUTURE1 GREAT] PLEASURE TO A MORE IMM$IATE BUT LESS] ONE IS PRECISELY ?AT3 SACRIFICE2 NOT ! O!R WAY >\ND4 ,! RESPONSIBLE 9DIVIDUAL MU/ DECIDE = HIMSELF :AT IS TO HIS GREATE/ ADVANTAGE3 ?IS !ORY IS NO MORALITY ?AT CAN DECIDE = HIM4 ,! !ORY & PRACTICE ( EXP&$ EGOISM CAN HAVE NO CONSORT ) ANY IDEOLOGY ( H$ONISM1 ANY MORE ?AN ) ANY BR& ( PURITANISM4 ,?IS !ORY & PRACTICE IS 9SEP>ABLE FROM ! EXP&$ CONSCI\SNESS ( PLEASURE :OSE POSSIBILITY HAS DEVELOP$ 9 ! HI/ORICAL LAB\RPROCESS1 9 ! EXPANSION ( HUMAN CAPACITIES1 SELFP[]S1 & NE$S4 ,& IT IS 9SEP>ABLE NO LESS FROM ?AT PLEASURE ( CONSCI\SNESS :I* IT IMPLIES & CONTA9S & :I* SIMULTANE\SLY CONTA9S IT4 ,SELF-DISCIPL9E1 AS DIRECTLY OPPOS$ TO AU?ORIT>IAN DISCIPL9E1 EXT]NALLY IMPOS$ & 9T]NALIZ$ AS SU* -- ! COH]5T USE ( MY LIFE = MYSELF1 ACCORD+ TO MY [N IMMAN5T /&>DS & TO 5DS ( MY [N1 IS 9 ITSELF ALREADY A PLEASURE = ME4 ,SELF-MA/]Y1 ! CONSCI\S & EFFECTIVE WIELD+ ( MYSELF = MYSELF 9 ! WORLD1 IS 9DE$ AN ES!TIC SELF-PLEASURE4 ,IT IS ! >T ( LIFE4 A#a ,:5 MY SELF IS ! WORK ( MY [N >T1 & MY [N WORK ( >T1 !N ,I TAKE PLEASURE 9 MYSELF4 ,!N ,I KN[ MYSELF AS WEAL? -- = MYSELF AS WELL AS = O!RS4 ,I KN[ MYSELF AS RI*1 AS RI* 9 MYSELF1 AS A WEAL?Y MAN ?R\< MY SELF-POSSESSION4 ,& YET ?IS SUBJECTIVE WEAL?1 ?IS RI*NESS 9 SELF :I* ,I POSSESS IS ALSO SOCIETY4 ,?IS IS PROV5 BY ! FACT ?AT \TSIDE SOCIETY1 OR )\T IT1 ALL MY WEAL? W\LD WI!R 9TO DU/4 ,! ID5TITY ( MYSELF & MY SOCIETY IS PROV5 BY ! FACT ?AT ! NONEXI/5CE ( SOCIETY IMPLIES ! NONEXI/5CE ( MYSELF4 ,BUT ?IS IS A DIALECTICAL1 M$IAT$ ID5TITY1 NOT A =MAL1 AB/RACT1 IMM$IATE ONE2 AN ID5TITY ?AT PRES]VES )9 ITSELF ! MOM5T ( DIFF]5TIATION4 ,V,I,I,I4 ,SEXUALITY #hh 0,! IMM$IATE1 NATURAL1 & NECESS>Y RELATION ( HUMAN BE+ TO HUMAN BE+ IS ALSO ! RELATION ( MALE-TO-FEMALE4 N#a ,9 ?IS NATURAL SPECIES RELATION%IP MAN'S RELATION TO NATURE IS DIRECTLY HIS RELATION TO MAN1 & HIS RELATION TO MAN IS DIRECTLY HIS RELATION TO NATURE1 TO HIS [N NATURAL FUNCTION4 ,?US1 9 ?IS RELATION IS S5SU\SLY REVEAL$1 R$UC$ TO AN OBS]VABLE FACT1 ! EXT5T TO :I* HUMAN NATURE HAS BECOME NATURE = MAN & TO :I* NATURE HAS BECOME HUMAN NATURE = HIM4 ,FROM ?IS RELATION%IP MAN'S :OLE LEVEL ( DEVELOPM5T CAN BE ASSESS$4 ,IT FOLL[S FROM ! *>ACT] ( ?IS RELATION%IP H[ F> MAN HAS BECOME1 & HAS UND]/OOD HIMSELF AS1 A SPECIES-BE+1 A HUMAN BE+4 ,! RELATION ( MAN TO WOMAN IS ! MO/ NATURAL RELATION ( HUMAN BE+ TO HUMAN BE+4 ,IT 9DICATES1 !RE=E1 H[ F> MAN'S NATURAL BEHAVIOR HAS BECOME HUMAN1 & H[ F> HIS HUMAN ESS5CE HAS BECOME A NATURAL ESS5CE = HIM1 H[ F> HIS HUMAN NATURE HAS BECOME NATURE = HIM4 ,IT ALSO %[S H[ F> MAN'S NE$S HAVE BECOME HUMAN NE$S1 & CONSEQU5TLY H[ F> ! O!R P]SON1 AS A P]SON1 HAS BECOME ONE ( HIS NE$S1 & TO :AT EXT5T HE IS 9 HIS 9DIVIDUAL EXI/5CE AT ! SAME TIME A SOCIAL BE+ 40 C#d#d #hi ,ORGA/ICALLY POT5T N#a SEXUAL EXP]I5CE IS ! V]Y >*ETYPE ( ! RESONANCE ( EGOISMS3 ! IMM$IATE UNITY ( PLEASURE-GETT+ & PLEASURE-GIV+4 #i ,I DON'T JU/ WANT A FULL] SEX LIFE2 ,I WANT MY :OLE LIFE TO BE A 0SEX-LIFE06 #ia ,! SOCIALITY ( MAN REVEALS ITSELF NO:]E MORE /RONGLY ?AN 9 SEXUAL SOCIABILITY & SEXUAL SOLID>ITY4 ,! SEXUAL NE$1 MORE PR(\NDLY & MORE IMM$IATELY ?AN ANY O!R1 REVEALS ! FALLACY ( N>R[ EGOISM -- ! NE$ TO T\* ANO!R P]SON1 ANO!R'S BODY2 TO BE PHYSICALLY CLOSE1 TO C>ESS & BE C>ESS$4 ,P]HAPS IT IS \T ( ! DESIRE1 CONGRU5T ) N>R[ EGOISM1 TO D5Y ! 9T]-SUBJECTIVITY ( ?IS MO/ PR(\NDLY 9T]SUBJECTIVE ( NE$S1 ?AT SO MANY P]V]SIONS BEG92 9 ORD] TO OBJECTIFY A#a ! SUBJECT :O IS ! AIM ( ?IS NE$4 ,BUT H]E ALSO IS A ?RE%OLD1 & AN 0ATTRACTOR0 N#a :]E ! EXPANSION ( EGOISM CAN /OP1 CAN GET HUNG-UP = EPO*S3 A COLLECTIVE EGOISM ?AT NEV] GR[S BIGG] ?AN ! C\PLE1 ! COLLECTIVE ( TWO2 ! ISOLAT$ DUO1 ! NUCLE> FAMILY4 ,WE HAVE H]E ! IDEOLOGY :I* HOLDS ?AT ! EGOI/IC PROJECT C\LD BECOME ADEQUATE TO ITSELF IF ONLY IT 9CLUD$ TWO EGOS4 ,?IS IS BUT ANO!R =M ( ! IDEOLOGY ( ANTISOCIALISM2 ! IDEOLOGY ?AT SEEKS TO D5Y ! SOCIAL +R$I5T 9 ! 9DIVIDUAL1 ! SELF1 ! P]SONAL WORLD1 & 5DS UP BY D5Y+ & DEPLET+ ! SELF AS WELL2 5DS UP ) AN EMPTI$ SELF4 ,ACCORD+ TO ?IS IDEOLOGY1 ONLY ! P]SONAL1 9TIMATE1 FAMILY WORLD1 ! PRIVATE WORLD ( ! HOME1 IS REAL4 ,! /RANGE1 CRAZY1 COLD 0\TSIDE0 WORLD -- ! SOCIAL WORLD -- IS HELD TO BE UNREAL1 ?\< IT MU/ BE RELAT$ TO1 IF ONLY TO SUPPORT ?IS N>R[ 0REAL0 WORLD4 ,?IS IDEOLOGY KN[S SOCIETY ONLY AS AN 9VASION ( PRIVACY4 ,?IS IS ! IDEOLOGY ?AT WILL KEEP ! P]SONAL WORLD N>R[ & IMPOV]I%$1 & ! SOCIAL WORLD M5AC+ & ALI54 ,WILL WE GET BEYOND IT8 ,DO WE WANT TO8 ,NE$ TO8 ,ONLY TIME WILL TELL4 ,CAPITALI/ ANTI-SOCIALISM IS N[ RAPIDLY REA*+ ITS LOGICAL CONCLUSION3 ! DE/RUCTION ( SOCIETY4 ,OV] ?IS QUE/ION1 ALL ( \R LIVES >E AT /AKE4 #ib ,FREUD EV5 BASES HIS CASE = 9/9CTUAL REPRESSION ON ! PO/ULATE ( SU* AN ET]NAL CONDITION AS DESCRIB$ ABOVE 7) ! HELP ( A FEW ( HIS TYPICAL REIFI$ N#a FALSE ANTI!SES74 0,! CONFLICT BETWE5 CIVILIZATION & SEXUALITY IS CAUS$ BY ! CIRCUM/ANCE ?AT SEXUAL LOVE IS A RELATION%IP BETWE5 TWO PEOPLE1 9 :I* A ?IRD CAN ONLY BE SUP]FLU\S OR DI/URB+1 :]EAS CIVILIZATION IS F\ND$ ON RELATIONS BETWE5 L>G] GR\PS ( P]SONS4 ,:5 A LOVE RELATION%IP IS AT ITS HEIE SUFFICI5T UNTO !MSELVES1 DO NOT EV5 NE$ ! *ILD !Y HAVE 9 COMMON TO MAKE !M HAPPY04 C#d#e ,LIKE MO/ CALLS = MORAL 5=CEM5T1 IT ASSUMES1 UNBEKN[N/ TO ITS AU?OR 7:O *>ACT]I/ICALLY BELIEVES1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 ?AT PEOPLE ALREADY WANT TOO MU* & >E ALREADY TOO SELFI%7 ?AT HUMAN GRE$ WILL NOT EXP& BEYOND A C]TA9 N>R[ DOMA94 #ic ,! E>LY WOM5'S MOVEM5T WAS ONE ( ! FEW LOCI ( ! NE>LY SELF-CONSCI\S EM]G5CE ( RADICAL SUBJECTIVITY )9 ! ,NEW ,LEFT4 ,! WOM5 :O CREAT$ IT REFUS$ TO PUT (F ! /RUGGLE AGA9/ !IR SPECIAL OPPRESSION UNTIL 0AFT] ! ,REVOLUTION04 ,IF HUMAN BE+S HAVE R$UC$ EA* O!R TO SEXUAL PSEUDO-OBJECTS1 HAVE 0OBJECTIFI$0 A#a EA* O!R SEXUALLY1 ?IS IS BY NO MEANS ! ONLY OR ! MO/ FUNDAM5TAL WAY 9 :I* !Y HAVE BE5 0OBJECTIFI$04 ,?IS IS ONLY ONE FACET ( A G5]AL DEHUMANIZATION & DE-SUBJECTIFICATION4 ,! OV]COM+ ( ?IS SPECIFIC 0OBJECTIFICATION01 ( ! PROBLEM POS$ MO/ SUBJECTIVELY BY ! E>LY WOM5'S LIB]ATION MOVEM5T1 & NAM$ 0SEXISM0 BY ! P>TISANS ( ?AT MOVEM5T1 CAN ONLY BE ( ! =M ( SEXUAL SUBJECTIVITY AS OPPOS$ TO ?IS SEXUAL 0OBJECTIVITY01 & 7EXP&$7 SEXUAL EGOISM AS OPPOS$ TO SEXUAL DUTY1 SEXUAL SELF-SACRIFICE1 & SEXUAL EXPLOITATION4 ,?IS SOLUTION IS OPPOS$ ID5TICALLY TO ! V>I\S DIRECTIONS TAK5 BY ! LAT] IDEOLOGICAL EXPROPRIATORS ( ! WOM5'S MOVEM5T2 NAMELY ?AT ( ! AB/RACT NEGATION ( SEXISM -- C\NT]-SEXISM 7ANTI-MASCUL9ISM71 REV]SE EXPLOITATION ?R\< ! IDEOLOGICAL MANIPULATION ( MALE GUILT1 SEXUAL AB/95CE1 OR MORALI/IC LESBIANISM4 ,LATELY1 MORE & MORE WOM5 HAVE FELT CALL$ ON TO ACT 9 A NEW ROLE -- ?AT ( 0SI/]40 ,! JOY ( ! 9ITIAL AB/RACT UNITY HAS BE5 REPLAC$ BY ! ?REAT ( EXCLUSION = UNSI/]LY BEHAVIOR4 ,OPPRESSION TAKES A NEW =M3 WOM5 OV] WOM54 ,IT'S NOT ! MOM5TS ( G5U9E W>M? & 9TIMACY1 ( AU!NTIC COMMUNITY1 )9 ! WOM5'S MOVEM5T ?AT WE WANT TO CRITICIZE1 BUT PRECISELY ! IDEOLOGY ?AT ULTIMATELY POISON$ !SE4 ,! 0COMMUNITY0 F\ND$ ON G5D] IS /ILL AN AB/RACT COMMUNITY1 /ILL A FALSE COMMUNITY2 /ILL ! DOM9ATION OV] ! 9DIVIDUAL & H] DESIRES ?R\< ! USE ( AB/RACT CATEGORIES & EXT]NAL QUALITIES1 BY ! IDEOLOGICAL REPRES5TATIVES ( !SE4 ,! PSEUDO-COMMUNITY ( 0SI/]S0 -- ASSUM$ & MORALI/ICALLY 5=C$ -- IS /ILL A COMMUNITY F\ND$ ON OPPRESSION3 ! REPRESSION ( RADICAL SUBJECTIVITY2 ! REPRES5TATION & 5=CEM5T ( AN AB/RACT DET]M9ATION DEF9+ A GR\P ( PEOPLE 9 ?IS CASE1 G5D] N#a -- OV] AGA9/ !IR CONCRETE P>TICUL>ITY & !IR CONSCI\S SELF-DET]M9ATION4 ,BOSSES COME 9 ALL G5D]S1 NO LESS ?AN 9 ALL COLORS4 ,H[ MU* HUMILIATION WILL IT TAKE TO LE>N ?AT A BOSS HAV+ SIMIL> SK9 COLOR OR ! SAME TYPE ( SEXUAL GL&S 0OBJECTIFIES0 ONE NO LESS ?AN ANY O!R8 ,NEXT TIME A FEM9I/ BUREAUCRAT ADDRESSES Y\ AS 0,SI/]01 LI/5 TO ! TONE ( H] VOICE4 ,:Y IS %E :9+8 ,DO H] WORDS FALL LIKE A ?REAT1 OR LIKE A *A98 ,:AT IS IT %E WANTS FROM Y\8 ,DOES %E WANT A SUBJECT OR A SLAVE2 A SEX1 I4E41 A WALK+ AB/RACTION1 OR A P]SON8 ,I,X4 ,AU?ORITY #id ,! DEVELOPM5T ( G5]ALIZ$ SELF-MANAGEM5T IS IMP$$ BY1 PRECISELY1 G5]ALIZ$ 9CAPACITY = SELF-MANAGEM5T -- ! T]ROR AT ! ?\IAN P]SONALITY4 ,?IS USUALLY TAKES ! =M ( A DIRE FE> & DI/RU/ ( O!RS 9 A SITUATION ( REVOLUTION>Y SELF-MANAGEM5T -- 0! O!R GUY IS A FUCKUP02 0! O!R GUY IS TOO /UPID & IRRESPONSIBLE TO EV] MAKE IT WORK10 ETC4 -- VALID FE>S1 TO :I* WE CAN ONLY SAY ?AT EV]YBODY IS RIIAN P]SONALITY IS ESS5TIALLY ! SLAVI% P]SONALITY1 ! P]SONALITY ?AT NE$S AU?ORITY -- ?AT PRECISELY CAN'T MANAGE )\T IT4 ,?IS *>ACT]-/RUCTURE HIDES ITS ESS5CE 9 ! ROLE ( ! MA/]2 IT REVEALS ITS ESS5CE 9 ! ROLE ( ! SLAVE4 ,CAPITALI/ SOCIETY IS SOCIETY F\ND$ ON ! EXP&$ REPRODUCTION ( ! HABIT ( SUBMISSION1 ( ! ALI5ATION 7DIS[N+7 ( SUBJECTIVITY 7WAGE-LABOR74 ,! PROLET>IAN IS PRECISELY ! DESUBJECTIFI$ MAN1 ! PSEUDO-OBJECT1 RUL$ BY ! PSEUDO-SUBJECT1 CAPITAL1 :I* HE PRODUCES & REPRODUCES4 ,REVOLUTION>Y PRACTICE IS !RE=E ! PRACTICE ( 0SUBJECTIFICATION0 N#a2 ( ! EXP&$ REPRODUCTION ( SUBJECTIVITY1 OR RADICAL SUBJECTS4 N#b ,! DET\RNEM5T ( MORALISM 7( ! PSEUDO-CRITIQUE ( 0GRE$071 ! VALIDATION & EXPANSION ( EGOISM1 IS ?US AN ESS5TIAL MOM5T ( REVOLUTION>Y PRACTICE4 ,& ?IS IS A MOM5T ( ?AT MOM5T4 ,BEYOND ! NE$ ( AU?ORITY LIES ! AU?ORITY ( NE$S & ! AU?ORITY ( DESIRE4 #ie ,9 ANY HI]>*ICAL RELATION%IP ! DOM9ATOR AS WELL AS ! SUBMISSIVE PAYS HIS DUES4 ,! PRICE PAID = ! 0GLORY ( COMM&0 IS 9DE$ HEAVY4 ,EV]Y TYRANT RES5TS HIS DUTIES4 ,HE IS RELEGAT$ TO DRAG ! DEAD WEI*ICAL EXCURSION4 ,OBVI\SLY1 ?IS CANNOT COMP>E TO ! AM\NT ( PLEASURE-5]GY RELEAS$ PLAYFULLY & WILL+LY1 NOT CO]CIVELY1 :5 EV]YONE PLAYS ! GAME4 7,! PRICE ( ONE'S AU?ORITY OV] O!RS IS ! SUMTOTAL ( ONE'S ACCEPTANCE ( ! SAME AU?ORITY OV] ONESELF474 #if ,9 A SELF-MANAG$ SOCIETY1 ! PREV5TION ( COMMUNAL SQUALOR1 ( SOCIAL MALPRACTISE 9 G5]AL 7! NONFULFILLM5T ( PRODUCTION-PLANS1 ETC47 DEP5DS1 NOT ON NOBODY BE+ AN AU?ORITY1 BUT ON EV]YBODY BE+ AN AU?ORITY :]E HIS [N NE$S & DESIRES1 HIS [N 9T]E/S1 >E CONC]N$4 ,& ?IS MEANS EXP&$ SELF-9T]E/S2 SOCIAL SELF-9T]E/S4 ,?IS MEANS ?AT ANYBODY MU/ BE SELF-AU?ORIZ$ TO MESS ) ANYBODY ELSE BEF\L+ A COMMUNAL PLACE1 IMP$+ COLLECTIVELY AGRE$-UPON PRODUCTION1 ETC41 & MU/ KN[ H[ TO DO SO4 ,ONLY SU* A NON-C5TRALIZ$1 ALL-SID$ FL[ ( PRACTICAL-CRITICAL FE$BACK & SOCIAL DIALOGUE CAN REPRODUCE SU* A SOCIETY4 ,! 5D ( SPECIALIZ$ SUP]VISION CAN ONLY BE 9 ! PROCESS ( G5]ALIZ$ SUP]VISION & COLLECTIVE SELF-SUP]VISION4 ,! 5D ( ! SPECIAL POLICE DEP5DS ON G5]AL SELF-REGULATION1 ?AT IS1 G5]ALIZ$ SELF-MANAGEM5T -- PEOPLE TAK+ RESPONSIBILITY = !IR SOCIAL NE$S4 ,?IS IS ! OPPOSITE ( ! REPRESSIVE CONCEPTION1 0SELF-POLIC+0 BAS$ ON ! PRES5T EXT]NAL POLIC+1 :I* S]VES AN ALI5 9T]E/1 & IS 9T]NALIZ$ AS SU*4 #ig ,9 ! SOCIALI/ SOCIETY ( ! FUTURE -- IF IT IS TO BE AT ALL -- EV]YONE WILL HAVE TO BE HIS [N EXP]T1 HIS [N AU?ORITY1 ON 0SAVOIR-VIV]01 ON 0H[-TO-LIVE04 ,!RE WILL BE NO HI<] AU?ORITY OV] A GIV5 MATT] ?AN ! G5]AL ASSEMBLY ( ?OSE SELF-9T]E/$ 9 ?AT MATT]4 #ih ,EV]Y TREATISE ON ! !ORY ( PRACTICE IS A 0,TRAITE DE ,SAVOIR-,VIV]0 C#d#f1 A 0,TREATISE ON ,H[ TO ,LIVE01 :E!R ITS AU?OR FULLY KN[S IT OR NOT4 0,H[-TO-LIVE0 IS JU/ ! G5]AL PROBLEM ( ! !ORY ( PRACTICE /AT$ MO/ SUBJECTIVELY4 #ii ,FRE$OM FROM EXT]NAL AU?ORITY MEANS BE+ Y\R [N AU?ORITY2 SELF-AU?ORITY4 ,FRE$OM "7 SELF-MA/]Y4 ,! MEAN+ ( ! PHRASE 0A WORLD ( MA/]S )\T SLAVES0 C#d#g CAN BE CONCEIV$ ONLY 9 ! CONCEPT ( SELF-MA/]Y4 ,BUT ?IS CANNOT BE LIMIT$ TO 09DIVIDUAL0 SELF-MA/]Y4 ,! CONCEPT ( 9DIVIDUAL SELF-MA/]Y ALREADY NECESS>ILY 9CLUDES ! MOM5T ( SOCIAL SELF-MA/]Y4 ,COMMUNI/ SOCIETY CAN ONLY MEAN ! CONSCI\S SELF-MA/]Y ( ! TOTALITY ( !IR SOCIAL SELF-PRODUCTION BY ! ASSOCIAT$ PRODUC]S4 ,SELF-DET]M9ATION1 SELF-GOV]NM5T1 SELF-MANAGEM5T -- 9 !IR NECESS>Y1 COMPLET$ MEAN+1 CAN MEAN NO?+ LESS4 ,! G5]AL NAME ( ! PROBLEM WE CONFRONT IS 0TO LE>N H[ TO LIVE10 I4E4 SOCIALLY1 H[ TO 0ASSOCIATE04 C#d#h 0,LIVE0 H]E IS OPPOS$ TO M]ELY SURVIV+1 & TO DY+ SUPPOS$LY TRY+ TO LIVE 7! 0BEAUTIFUL LOS]S0 SYNDROME71 ETC4 ,BUT ?IS HAS NO?+ TO DO ) MORALITY -- NO?+1 ?AT IS1 BUT TO ABOLI% IT6 ,X4 ,MORALITY #a ,! OLD MORAL QUE/ION ( :E!R ONE 0?9KS FIR/ ( ONESELF OR ( O!RS0 FALLS AP>T :5 WE COME TO ?9K ONLY ( \RSELVES & = ?IS REASON NEGATE ! O!RNESS ( O!RS4 #aa ,9TELLIG5CE 5DS :]E MORALITY BEG9S4 ,MORALITY 5DS :]E 9TELLIG5CE BEG9S4 ,! !ORY ( PRACTICE1 ! UNIT>Y CRITIQUE ( ALL IDEOLOGY1 MU/ AT ! SAME TIME BE ! CRITIQUE NOT ONLY ( ANY MORALISM1 BUT ( ANY POSSIBLE MORALISM4 ,EV]Y MORAL IS SUBJECTIVITY DIS[N$ & SUBJECTIVITY ALI5AT$4 ,EV]Y MORAL IS A PSY*IC TOTEM1 A M5TAL FETI%OBJECT1 BE=E :I* ! MORAL FETI%I/ SUBORD9ATES HIMSELF1 B[S D[N1 & (F]S SACRIFICE -- 9DE$ (F]S HIMSELF 9 SACRIFICE4 ,EV]Y IDEAL IS SEP>AT$ SUBJECTIVITY2 A P>T ( ! SELF SEP>AT$ (F1 EJECT$1 FROZ51 & HELD OV] ! RE/ ( ! SELF4 ,IT IS A DEPLETION ( SUBJECTIVITY1 A LOSS ( FRE$OM1 A *OICE MADE 9 ADVANCE4 ,! =MATION ( ! MORAL IDEAL IS AT ! SAME TIME A DECL9E 9 SUBJECTIVE MOBILITY & MANEUV]ABILITY2 A BALL-&-*A9 AB\T ! DANC]'S ANKLE2 A SELF-LAM+ & SELF-MAIM+ 9 ! DANCE ( LIFE4 #ab ,MORALITY & ?AT :I* TIES Y\ TO IT1 SELF-GUILT1 GUILT = EV5 BE+1 IS AN 5ORM\S 5CUMBRANCE4 ,Y\ CAN ?R[ IT (F6 ,Y\ CAN DROP ALL ?AT WEIISON TO ?AT MORAL1 BY BE+ SUSCEPTIBLE TO HIM EXPROPRIAT+ ! REPRES5TATION ( MYSELF :I* ,I HAVE ]ECT$ OR CONDON$1 & US+ IT AGA9/ MY REAL SELF4 ,AS A M]E G5]ALIZATION1 A PRACTICAL AB/RACTION -- AS !ORY -- ,I HAVE ALREADY REFUT$ IT = MYSELF 9 PRACTICE1 PROV5 ITS 9VALIDITY = ?IS 9/ANCE4 ,BUT AS A MORAL REIFICATION1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 IT IS MY DUTY TO OBEY IT4 ,NOT ,I BUT 0IT0 IS MY MA/]3 0IT0 GIVES ! ORD]S1 ,I ALI5ATE MY WILL 9TO IT2 0IT0 IS ! SUBJECT ( MY PRACTICE1 ,I 0ITS0 OBJECT4 #ac ,! PROJECTIONS ( MY SUBJECTIVITY1 NURTUR$ BY GUILT1 /ICK \T ( MY HEAD LIKE SO MANY H&LES (F]$ TO ANY MANIPULATOR1 ANY IDEOLOGUE1 :O WANTS TO GET A HOLD ( ME1 & :OSE TRADE SKILL IS ! ABILITY TO P]CEIVE SU* H&LES4 ,ONLY :5 ,I DISSOLVE MY GUILT1 :5 ,I FREE MYSELF TO BE %AMELESSLY SELFI%1 :5 ,I GRASP SELFI%NESS AS MY ONLY 0DUTY0 -- TAK+ C>E ( MYSELF AS NECESS>ILY MY FIR/ SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY -- CAN ,I BE FREE4 #ad ,! CRITIQUE ( ! TOTEMIC RELATION%IP1 CL>IFI$ BY ,FEU]BA* C#d#i 9 RELATION TO RELIGION1 !NCE APPLI$ TO POLITICAL ECONOMY BY ,M>X C#e1 & LATELY DEVELOP$ ONE-SID$LY BY ! ,GE/ALT !RAPI/S 7ESPECIALLY ,P]LS C#e#a7 LOCATES ! 9V]SION ?AT LIES AT ! HE>T ( ALL DOM9ATION & SELF-5SLAVEM5T4 ,TOTEMIC FETI%ISM OR PROJECTION LIES ALSO AT ! HE>T ( EV]Y MORAL IDEOLOGY1 :I* IS REVEAL$ ALSO 9 ! OBS]VATION ?AT EV]Y IDEOLOGY IS A MORALISM1 & A SOCIAL PLAN = ! ALLOCATION ( GUILT4 ,:ILE USABLE PRECISELY = ! SAME 5DS1 IDEOLOGY 9 G5]AL1 MORALISM 9 P>TICUL>1 >E 9 ESS5CE ! MORE SOPHI/ICAT$ & SUBTLE MEANS ( EXPLOITATION1 AS OPPOS$ TO NAK$ CO]CION4 #ae ,IT IS MY GUILT AB\T MY DESIRES :I* MAKES ME SUSCEPTIBLE TO IDEOLOGICAL EXPLOITATION BY O!RS1 & :I* MOTIVATES ME 9 PRODUC+ EXCUSES & JU/IFICATIONS 7RATIONALIZATIONS7 9 T]MS ( ! DOM9ANT IDEOLOGY 7! IDEOLOGY :I* ,I LET DOM9ATE ME74 ,! TRICK ( IDEOLOGY CONSI/S 9 ?IS3 TO RE-PRES5T DESIRES 9 A PSEUDO-UNIV]SAL -- I4E41 UNSELFI%1 ALTRUI/IC -- & !RE=E UNREPROA*ABLE1 =M1 ALWAYS 9 T]MS ( SOME AB/RACT 0G5]AL 9T]E/04 ,9 ORD] TO RECONCILE MYSELF ) MY IDEOLOGY ,I MU/ MAKE MYSELF A LI>4 ,BUT IT IS A LOS]S' GAME4 ,! LAWY]S ( ! DOM9ANT CLASS ALREADY HAVE IT SET UP 9 ADVANCE !IR WAY1 & H]E ,I AM ON !IR T]RA94 ,! USE-VALUE ( PRACTICAL G5]ALIZATIONS IS ?AT ( !ORY -- 9TELLIG5CE ( HUMAN PRACTICE2 KN[L$GE ( MEANS1 TE*NIQUES1 & CONSEQU5CES4 ,! USE-VALUE ( MORALITY IS ?AT ( IDEOLOGY -- TO DOM9ATE O!RS1 TO ATTEMPT TO GET :AT IS WANT$ 9 A N>R[LY SELFI% WAY1 BY REPRES5T+ IT AS UNSELFI%1 UNIV]SAL1 9 A CLIMATE :]E TRANSP>5T SELFI%NESS1 & TRANSP>5CY AB\T DESIRES1 IS NOT TOL]AT$1 IS *A/IS$4 #af ,9 ! AB/RACT NEGATION ( MORALITY1 ITS M]E ANTI!SIS -- TYPICAL ESPECIALLY ( ! ,SITUATIONI/ M5TALITY -- MORALISM IS TRANS=M$ 9TO ANTI-MORALISM1 :I* IS REALLY ONLY AN ANTI-MORALISM MORALISM1 & NOT TRULY ! OPPOSITE ( MORALISM AT ALL4 ,ACCORD+ TO ! LOGICAL SUB/RUCTURE ( ?IS IDEOLOGY1 ONE HAS A DUTY TO DO AT ALL TIMES :AT IS IMMORAL ACCORD+ TO ! DOM9ANT IDEOLOGY -- ?AT IS1 ! IDEOLOGY BY :I* ! ,SITUATIONI/ /ILL DEF9ES & DOM9ATES HIMSELF1 ?\< H]E 9 A NEGATIVE =M4 ,?US1 IT IS AB/RACTLY REQUIR$ TO LIVE BY /EAL+1 TO PRACTICE SEXUAL PROMISCUITY1 TO LIVE 9 SQUALOR1 TO DROP \T ( S*OOL1 TO NEV] WORK1 ETC41 ETC4 ,?IS IS /ILL QUALITATIVELY AS F> FROM ! DET]M9ATE NEGATION ( MORALISM AS IS MORALISM ITSELF4 #ag ,AS = \RSELVES1 WE HAVE NO MORALITY4 ,WE HAVE ONLY \R FEEL+S1 \R NE$S1 \R DESIRES2 \R ?\E OP5 TO FEEL+ \R [N4 #ah 0,! ABOLITION ( RELIGION AS ! ILLUSORY HAPP9ESS ( M5 IS A DEM& = !IR REAL HAPP9ESS4 ,! CALL TO AB&ON !IR ILLUSIONS AB\T !IR CONDITIONS IS A CALL TO AB&ON A CONDITION :I* REQUIRES ILLUSIONS4 ,!IR CRITICISM ( RELIGION IS1 !RE=E1 ! EMBRYONIC CRITICISM ( ?IS VALE ( TE>S ( :I* RELIGION IS ! HALO40 0,CRITICISM HAS PLUCK$ ! IMAG9>Y FL[]S FROM ! *A91 NOT 9 ORD] ?AT MAN %ALL BE> ! *A9 )\T CAPRICE OR CONSOLATION1 BUT SO ?AT HE %ALL CA/ (F ! *A9 & PLUCK ! LIV+ FL[]4 ,! CRITICISM ( RELIGION DISILLUSIONS MAN SO ?AT HE WILL ?9K1 ACT1 & FA%ION HIS REALITY AS A MAN :O HAS LO/ HIS ILLUSIONS & REGA9$ HIS REASON2 SO ?AT HE WILL REVOLVE AB\T HIMSELF AS HIS [N TRUE SUN4 ,RELIGION IS ONLY ! ILLUSORY SUN AB\T :I* MAN REVOLVES SO LONG AS HE DOES NOT REVOLVE AB\T HIMSELF40 C#e#b ,AS ) RELIGION1 SO ) RESPECT TO ! O!R PROJECTIONS1 9DIVIDUAL & COLLECTIVE 7COMMODITIES1 MONEY1 CAPITAL1 ! /ATE1 IDEOLOGIES ( EV]Y DESCRIPTION1 MORALITY 9 P>TICUL>1 REIFI$ .*ICAL.> 9/ITUTIONS ( ALL SORTS -- PSEUDO-SUBJECTS ALL4 ,TRY SUB/ITUT+ !M 967 #ai 0,! CRITICISM ( RELIGION 5DS ) ! DOCTR9E ?AT MAN IS ! SUPREME BE+ = MAN4 ,IT 5DS1 !RE=E1 ) ! CATEGORICAL IMP]ATIVE TO OV]?R[ ALL ?OSE CONDITIONS 9 :I* MAN IS A HUMILIAT$1 5SLAV$1 DESPIS$ & REJECT$ BE+40 C#e#c #aa ,! CRITICISM ( MORALITY 5DS ) ! DOCTR9E ?AT Y\ >E ! SUPREME BE+ = Y\4 7,?AT IS1 Y\R BE+1 Y\R SELF-CONSCI\SNESS1 Y\R BE+-=-Y\RSELF1 IS ! NECESS>Y M$IUM ?R\< :I* ALL O!R VALUES -- :I* CON/ITUTE OR GIVE CONT5T TO ITS VALUE -- 9CLUD+ MY VALUE = Y\1 OR MYSELF AS ONE ( Y\R VALUES1 COME 9TO BE+ = Y\4 ,IF Y\ %\LD LOSE Y\R BE+1 !N ALL O!R BE+S1 & !RE) ALL VALUES1 W\LD BE LO/ TO Y\4 ,FUR!R1 & MORE CONCRETELY1 TO ! EXT5T ?AT WE PRODUCE SOCIALLY1 & ?AT WE PRODUCE A SOCIETY2 ?AT WE EX*ANGE SELF-P[]S & !IR OBJECTIFICATIONS1 ?AT WE DEP5D UPON ONE ANO!R = ! REPRODUCTION ( \RSELVES1 !N MY LOSS1 OR ! LOSS ( ME1 IS Y\R LOSS1 & A DEPLETION ( Y\R SELF74 ,IT 5DS1 !RE=E1 ) ! CATEGORICAL IMP]ATIVE TO OV]?R[ ALL ?OSE CONDITIONS UND] :I* Y\1 ! SUBJECT1 >E SUBORD9AT$ TO SOME ?+ -- SOME FETI%1 SOME TOTEM1 SOME PROJECTION1 SOME REIFICATION1 SOME CAUSE1 SOME IDEAL1 SOME MORAL1 SOME PR9CIPLE1 SOME PSEUDO-SUBJECT -- SOME BE+ SUPPOS$LY 0HI<] ?AN Y\R SELF40 #aaa ,:AT CAUSE OR IDEAL IS !RE1 :AT PROJECTION \T ( Y\RSELF1 ?AT CAN BE HI<]1 = Y\1 ?AN Y\1 ITS S\RCE8 ,:AT EXT]NAL TO Y\R SELF ?AT Y\ VALUE CAN W>RANT = Y\ Y\R SACRIFICE8 ,:AT VALUE IS !RE ?AT Y\ W\LD NOT LOSE IF Y\ LO/ Y\RSELF8 ,SOME?+ CAN BE A VALUE = Y\ ONLY IF IT 9CLUDES & CONS]VES 9 IT Y\R SELF1 ! NECESS>Y F\NDATION ( ALL Y\R VALUES4 ,:5 Y\ >E LO/ TO Y\1 ALL ! EMANATIONS ( Y\RSELF1 & ALL ! VALUES 9 ! WORLD ?AT Y\ AFFIRM$1 >E LO/ = Y\ ALSO2 CUT (F AT !IR ROOT4 ,TAK+ RISKS IS ANO!R MATT]4 ,Y\ MU/ GAMBLE Y\R SELF 9 ORD] TO GA9 ANY VALUE2 Y\ MU/ RISK Y\RSELF 9 ORD] TO GA9 Y\RSELF BACK AGA9 MORE RI*LY4 ,:AT IS CALL$ C[>DICE' IS NOT ! PRACTICE ( ! REALIZATION EXPRESS$ ABOVE1 BUT ITS OPPOSITE3 TOO LITTLE VALUE PLAC$ ON ONE'S SELF1 & ON ?OSE VALUES & O!R P]SONS :I* >E P>T ( IT1 SO ?AT ONE FAILS TO DEF5D ONE'S SELF 9 ! EXP&$ S5SE1 OR MI/AKES M]E SURVIVAL = LIFE4 #aab ,IT IS NOT BY ANY MEANS ONLY ! N>R[LY 0SELFI%01 0EGOI/IC0 DESIRES & T5D5CIES :I* >E REPRESS$ CONT9UALLY 7MORALI/ICALLY1 :ILE AT ! SAME TIME BE+ RE9=C$ PRACTICALLY7 9 ! DAILY LIFE ( PRIVATIZ$ SOCIETY1 BUT ALSO -- REALLY1 MORE SO -- ! 0NON-EGOI/IC01 ! SO-CALL$ 0UNSELFI%0 T5D5CIES3 NATURAL GREG>I\SNESS1 SPONTANE\S HUMAN SOLID>ITY1 NATURAL COMPASSION & EMPA?Y1 SIMPLE SOCIABILITY & LOVE4 ,!RE IS AN 5]GY PRODUC$ 9 EA* HUMAN BE+ EV]Y DAY :I* AIMS AT A SOCIAL SATISFACTION & :I* IF NOT SATISFI$ SOCIALLY TURNS AGA9/ ITSELF1 BECOMES DEPRESSION1 )DRAWAL1 ETC4 ,UNLIKE TRIBAL SOCIETIES1 :]E9 !SE 0UNSELFI% T5D5CIES0 =M ! MA9 BASE ( SOCIAL SURVIVAL1 9 \R SOCIETY1 OV]DEVELOP$ 7LATE7 CAPITALI/ SOCIETY1 !SE EMOTIONS ONLY BREAK SURFACE OCCASIONALLY1 EXCEPTIONALLY4 ,9 ! VA/ ACCUMULATIONS ( CON/ANT & V>IABLE CAPITAL N#a KN[N TODAY AS 0CITIES01 ! CONT9UAL /EADFA/ REPRESSION ( !SE T5D5CIES IS 9CREAS+LY A NECESSITY ( SURVIVAL4 ,) 9CREAS+ R>ITY DOES SOCIAL GOOD-FEEL+ PASS BETWE5 /RANG]S ON ! /REET4 ,ANY /RANG] IS BE/ REG>D$ AN 5EMY4 ,& !SE TEEM+ AN?ILLS >E A WORLD ( /RANG]S4 ,! GR[+ PH5OM5ON ( MASS1 R&OM MURD]S CAN BE UND]/OOD AS A BECOM+ APP>5T ( :AT WAS ALWAYS ESS5TIAL TO CAPITALI/ SOCIETY1 N[ 5T]+ ITS HI/ORIC EXTREMITY3 0! W> ( ALL AGA9/ ALL0 IS BECOM+ >M$4 A#a ,ONCE ANES!TIZ$1 BEG9N+ 9 ! E>LY LIFE ( ! 9DIVIDUAL1 !SE SOCIAL DESIRES & T5D5CIES CAN USUALLY BE RE-EVOK$ ONLY FALSELY1 >TIFICIALLY1 CO]CIVELY4 ,H5CE ! BELIEF ?AT !SE EMOTIONS NE$ TO BE 5=C$ ?R\< ! MANIPULATION ( GUILT4 ,ANYONE /ILL MANIFE/+ SU* T5D5CIES 9 !IR DIRECT1 SPONTANE\S =M 9TO Y\NG ADUL?OOD IS IMM$IATELY SUSPECT1 OR AT BE/1 CONSID]$ 0NAIVE0 & A 0FOOL0 = HIS APP>5T 0IDEALISM0 &_/OR 0*ILDI%NESS0 7DESPITE ALL ! ALTRUI/IC PRET5SES ( (FICIAL SOCIETY73 !SE EMOTIONAL T5D5CIES >E BE+ SE5 AS A WEAKNESS 7:I*1 9 ! SOCIETY ( E/RANGEM5T1 !Y UND\BT$LY >E1 UNTIL OR UNLESS SU* AN 9DIVIDUAL DEVELOPS FULL CONSCI\SNESS ( !SE T5D5CIES & ( !IR SOCIAL CONTEXT1 APPROPRIAT+ !SE AS P>T ( A REVOLUTION>Y PROJECT74 #aac ,I LI/5 TO CRITICISM BECAUSE ,I AM GRE$Y4 ,I LI/5 TO CRITICISM BECAUSE ,I AM SELFI%4 ,I W\LD NOT D5Y MYSELF ANO!R'S 9SI\ND MYSELF2 ITS 9T5SITY FALLS (F EXPON5TIALLY ) SUBJECTIVE DI/ANCE FROM ITS S\RCE4 ,?IS EGOI/IC CRITICISM IS ! OPPOSITE ( ! MASO*I/IC & RITUALIZ$ 7SPECTACUL>7 0CRITICISM & SELF-CRITICISM0 ( ,MAOI/ MORALITY4 ,AU?ORIT>IAN CRITICISM AIMS AT MY REPRESSION1 AT RE9=C+ & REPRODUC+ PASSIVITY & S]VILITY1 AT MA9TA9+ ! HABIT ( SUBMISSION4 ,IT AIMS AT WEAK5+1 RA!R ?AN /R5G!N+1 MY SUBJECTIVITY1 AT KEEP+ ME AN AU?ORIT>IAN P]SONALITY -- A SLAVE4 ,EGOI/IC CRITICISM1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 AIMS AT /R5G!N+ ME1 9 ! MUTUAL 9T]E/ ( MY SELF & MY CRITIC1 = ! B5EFIT ( \R COMMON WEAL? & \R COMMON PROJECT4 ,IT IS IMMAN5T CRITICISM1 CRITICISM ( ME 9 MY [N 9T]E/4 ,BY ! SAME TOK51 = SU* CRITICISM TO BE POSSIBLE1 = SOMEONE'S CRITICISM TO 09T]E/0 ME1 ,I MU/ SEE MYSELF 9 !M1 & !M 9 MYSELF2 WE MU/ %>E A COMMON 9T]E/1 A CONCRETE COMMUNITY4 #aad ,! CRITIQUE ( REVOLUTION>Y IDEOLOGY1 AN>*I/ & ,L59I/ ALIKE1 ) ITS SACRIFICIAL COLLECTIVI/ MORALITY &1 9 P>TICUL>1 ! CRITIQUE ( ,MAOISM ) ITS MORALITY ( POV]TY1 REVEALS ONCE & = ALL ! POV]TY ( ALL MORALITY4 ,& ?IS 9 A D\BLE S5SE4 ,FIR/1 9 ?AT MORALITY IS ! IDEOLOGICAL PRODUCT ( POV]TY2 ( ! UND]DEVELOP$ /ATE ( HUMAN PRODUCTIVE =CES1 & ESPECIALLY ( ! CLEAVAGE ( ! 0G5]AL0 & 0P>TICUL>0 9T]E/S1 :OSE ROOT IS ! SELF-CLEAVAGE ( SOCIETY2 SOCIAL CLASSES4 ,MORALITY IS ! EXPRESSION ( ! IRRECONCILABILITY ( CLASS ANTAGONISMS4 ,IT LOCATES ! G5]AL 9T]E/ AS A PROJECTION \T ( A SOCIAL SITUATION 9 :I* IT C\LD ONLY BE F\ND AS A CONTRADICTION4 ,9 MORALITY1 ! CONTRADICTION IS REPRES5T$ AS AN AB/RACT ID5TITY ( ! 9T]E/S ( ALL M51 AS ! 9T]E/ ( AN AB/RACT MAN :O HAS NO REAL SOCIAL EXI/5CE4 ,SECOND1 9 ! S5SE ?AT MORALITY -- :I* IS PROJECTION1 OR SELFDIS[N+ -- IS A DEPLETION ( ! REAL SOCIAL WEAL?1 ( SUBJECTIVITY1 ! WEAL? ( ! SELF4 #aae ,\R SUBJECTIVITY & \R SELF-R$ISCOV]Y 9 EV]Y H]E & N[1 I4E4 \R SELF-REPRODUCTION1 IS ! ONLY POSSIBLE GU>ANTEE ( \R SUBJECTIVITY4 ,WE MU/ RE-W9 \RSELVES CON/ANTLY4 0,COMMUNI/ EGOISM0 CAN BE MADE 9TO AN IDEOLOGY4 0,! RIIO CAN BE EASILY 5VISION$3 SOME BUREAUCRAT PO9TS A GUN AT ME SAY+3 0,9 ! NAME ( Y\R EXP&$ SELF-9T]E/1 ?AT ( ! PROLET>IAT AS A :OLE1 WE HAVE DET]M9$ ?AT IT IS BE/ = Y\ = US TO KILL Y\0 & PULLS ! TRIGG]4 7CF4 ,KRON/ADT1 ! IDEOLOGY ( ! ,NATIONAL ,CAUCUS ( ,LABOR ,COMMITTEES1 ETC474 N#a #aaf ,9 A REVOLUTION>Y SITUATION IT TAKES MU* MORE ?AN ! M]E WI% TO PREV5T A BUREAUCRACY FROM >IS+4 ,! ROOTS ( BUREAUCRACY LIE 9 P]SONAL SELF D5IAL A#a1 9 TREAT+ MYSELF & MY DESIRES 9 A BUREAUCRATIC MANN]1 9 %ORT1 BE+ A BUREAUCRAT ) MYSELF4 ,! M]E AB/RACT NEGATION ( ITS 9/ITUTIONALIZ$ =M IS LIKE >RIV+ ) A BUCKET ( WAT] AFT] ! H\SE HAS ALREADY BURN$ D[N4 ,9 EV]Y RATIONALIZATION & HESITATION1 9 EV]Y /UTT]+ & SWALL[+ D[N ( DESIRE1 ( FELT RES5TM5TS1 MISCOMMUNICATIONS & SECRET HUMILIATIONS LIE ! SE$S ( \R DEMISE1 \R ,!RMIDOR4 ,! LOGICAL \TGR[? ( ANY SELF D5IAL BY ANY REVOLUTION>Y IS ! TRIUMPH ( ! C\NT]REVOLUTION & ! REIGN ( ! ,BOL%EVIKS ALL OV] AGA94 0444IT IS ALWAYS ! PR9CIPLE ( USEFUL SUFF]+ & WILL+ SACRIFICE ?AT =MS ! MO/ SOLID BASE = HI]>*ICAL P[]40 C#e#d ,! MOM5T Y\ SIT BY PASSIVELY :ILE NOT GETT+ :AT Y\ WANT1 Y\ >E PREP>+ ! GR\ND = Y\R [N DE/RUCTION4 #aag ,WE >E ON ! V]GE ( LIB]ATION ONLY :5 IT CAN BE SAID ( EA* ( US ?AT HE_/%E HAS BECOME SO REBELLI\S1 SO IRREPRESSIBLE1 & SO UNRULY ?AT %E_/HE CANNOT BE MA/]$ BY ANY?+ LESS ?AN HIS_/H] SELF 7I4E41 AMONG O!R ?+S1 :5 NO M]E PROJECTION OR REIFICATION ( A P>T ( \RSELVES WILL SUFFICE1 ANY LONG]1 OR WILL BE ABLE SUCCESSFULLY TO RULE OV] US474 #aah ,! 0GAME0 A#a IS A =M ( >MOR1 IDEOLOGY IS A 0GAME01 *>ACT]->MOR IS COMPULSIVE ROLE-PLAY+1 ! 0SCRIPT0 IS ! SELF-IMAGE PROJECT$ ?R\< TIME1 ! TEMPORALIZ$ SELF-SPECTACLE4 ,9 ! :ITE HEAT ( ! ACT ( !IR COMPREH5SION AS LIV$ EXP]I5CE & AS 9T]P]SONAL PRAXIS GO+ ON ALL >\ND US1 !SE NAMES1 & ! CONCEPTS !Y NAME GAME1 >MOR1 IDEOLOGY1 ROLE1 *>ACT]1 SCRIPT MELT 9TO ONE4 ,! SELF-SPECTACLE1 ! SPECTACUL> SELF -- SELF-REPRES5TATION -- WILL BE F\ND NECESS>Y1 A NECESS>Y USE-VALUE1 A NECESS>Y 9T]P]SONAL TOOL1 9 FACT1 A 0SURVIVAL KIT01 & ?US BE REPRODUC$1 SO LONG AS 7#a7 ! DISSONANCE ( EGOISMS1 ! TOTALITY ( CONDITIONS KN[N 9 G5]AL AS 0POV]TY01 0SC>CITY01 PREVAILS1 & CONSEQU5TLY1 7#b7 PEOPLE CANNOT GET :AT !Y WANT (T5 5\< BY BE+ TRANSP>5T ) ONE ANO!R1 BY SIMPLY ASK+ = IT1 &1 7#c7 !Y CANNOT OR WILL NOT TAKE ! RISK ( ASK+1 ! GAMBLE ( TRANSP>5CY1 EI!R = FE> ( ! PA9 ( REFUSAL OR \T ( ! DESP]ATION ( !IR NE$1 & W\LD !RE=E PREF] TO EXTRACT :AT !Y CAN BY CIRCUIT\S MEANS1 BY SUBT]FUGE & DECEPTION1 DECOY & TRICK]Y -- 9 %ORT1 BY 9TRANSP>5T MEANS4 ,! SPECTACUL> PRES5TATION ( SELF 9 EV]YDAY LIFE1 ! P]SONAL ORGANIZATION ( FALSE APPE>ANCES 7P]SONA7 -- P>TLY COMPULSIVE & 9VOLUNT>Y1 AS ESPECIALLY 9 MUSCLE >MOR -- ! LITTLE LIE -- !SE >E ! MEANS ( ! DEVI\S R\TE TO ! REALIZATION ( DESIRE4 ,9 !IR CONSCI\S P>T1 !Y WILL BE RESORT$ TO SO LONG AS ! MORE DIRECT MEANS1 TRANSP>5CY1 DOES NOT WORK ANY BETT]4 ,9 !IR MORE UNCONSCI\S1 COMPULSIVE P>T1 !Y >E ! M>K ( REPRESSION & DOM9ATION1 ! C[]+ W9CE ( ! :IPP$ CUR1 FROZ5 9TO A PO/URE4 ,*>ACT]->MOR IS 9DE$ ! =M ( PEOPLES' COMPLICITY 9 ! SPECTACLE4 ,NOT ?AT FEEL+ GUILTY AB\T ONE'S *>ACT]->MOR WILL DO ANY?+ BUT EXAC]BATE ?IS PROBLEM4 ,X,I4 ,REVOLUTION #aai 0,PRODUCTIVE =CES & SOCIAL RELATION%IPS -- ! TWO DIFF]5T SIDES ( ! DEVELOPM5T ( ! SOCIAL 9DIVIDUAL -- APPE> TO BE & >E1 ONLY A MEANS = CAPITAL1 TO 5ABLE IT TO PRODUCE FROM ITS [N CRAMP$ BASE4 ,BUT 9 FACT !Y >E ! MAT]IAL CONDITIONS ?AT WILL %ATT] ?IS F\NDATION40 C#e#e #ab ,9 ! 5D1 EGOISM IS \R ONLY FRI5D2 9 ! LA/ ANALYSIS GRE$ IS ! ONLY ?+ WE CAN TRU/4 ,ANY REVOLUTION>Y :O IS TO BE C\NT$ ON CAN ONLY BE 9 IT = HIMSELF UNSELFI% PEOPLE CAN ALWAYS SWIT* LOYALTY FROM ONE PROJECTION TO ANO!R4 ,FUR!RMORE1 ONLY ! MO/ GRE$Y PEOPLE CAN BE RELI$ ON TO FOLL[ ?R\< ON !IR REVOLUTION>Y PROJECT4 ,O!RS LESS GRE$Y CAN ALWAYS BE B\E DEMON/RAT$ CONT9UALLY 9 ! HI/ORY ( ! MOD]N REVOLUTION>Y MOVEM5T4 ,JU/ AS1 9 #a#h#g#a1 9T]NALIZ$ IDEOLOGY & A MIS]ABLE H&FUL ( GU>DS W]E 5\< TO DET] ! >M$ ,COMMUN>DS FROM SEIZ+ ! ,FR5* ,NATIONAL ,BANK AT A TIME :5 MONEY WAS DESP]ATELY NE$$1 SO 9 #aifh ,FR5* 9SURG5TS 7MY/IFI$ BY TRADE-UNIONI/ & AN>*O-SYNDICALI/ IDEOLOGY7 FAIL$ TO COMPREH5D ALL ! WORLD >\ND !M AS SOCIAL PROP]TY 7& !RE=E !IRS7 & ?US T5D$ TO RE/RICT SELF-ORGANIZATION TO 0!IR [N0 WORK PLACES4 ,?\< GRE$Y & EGOI/IC 9 !IR [N RIIES W]E LEFT 9 PALTR9ESS1 ! PA!TIC POSSESSORS ( M]E FRAGM5TS ( A REVOLUTION 7!SE FRAGM5TS BY !IR V]Y NATURE SUBLAT$ 9TO NAUY7 DEFEAT ( !SE REVOLUTIONS4 ,! MEAN+ ( ,M>X'S 0,I AM NO?+1 BUT ,I MU/ BE EV]Y?+0 UNFOLDS ITS TRU? FULLY :5 WE REALIZE ?AT ONLY :5 WE BECOME EV]Y?+ %ALL WE CEASE TO BE NO?+4 #abb 0,REVOLUTION CEASES TO BE AS SOON AS IT IS NECESS>Y TO BE SACRIFIC$ TO IT40 -- GRAFFITO1 ,P>IS1 ,MAY-,JUNE1 #a#i#f#h4 C#e#f #abc ,! SOCIAL REVOLUTION IS :5 SOCIAL HUMAN BE+S1 SOCIAL 9DIVIDUALS WAKE UP 9SIDE ! LIV+1 WAK+ NIE ( PRIVATIZ$ LIFE4 #abd ,REVOLUTION IS ! SOCIAL MOM5T ( ! COLLAPSE ( ALL PROJECTIONS4 ,9 ! MOM5T ( SOCIAL REVOLUTION ! PRES5T1 ! HI/ORICAL PRES5T1 ! PRES5CE ( HI/ORY OP5S UP LIKE ! SKY4 #abe ,DON'T BE TOO AFRAID4 ,:AT IS LEFT AFT] ! COLLAPSE ( ALL PROJECTIONS IS Y\1 Y\R SELF1 PRECISELY ?AT 9 Y\ :I* ALONE WAS NOT SELF-PROJECTION4 ,DON'T PANIC -- Y\'VE BE5 LO/ SO LONG1 IT MAY TAKE Y\ A MOM5T1 AFT] ! DELUGE1 TO F9D Y\R SELF AGA91 !RE AT ! C5T] ( EV]Y?+4 ,APRES LE DELUGE1 MOI6 ,AFT] ! DELUGE3 Y\6 ,& Y\R SELF WILL NOT BE F\ND ALONE4 #abf ,! ROAD TO FUR!R EVOLUTION PASSES ?R\< REVOLUTION4 ,! PA? ?AT LEADS FROM SURVIVAL TO LIFE PASSES ?R\< ! VALLEY ( ! %AD[ ( DEA?4 ,WE HAVE DECID$ TO GO1 TO TAKE ! GAMBLE1 = \RSELVES4 ,DO Y\ WANT TO COME ) US1 = Y\RSELF8 ,WE WANT Y\4 ,WE NE$ Y\4 ,Y\ DECIDE4 ,= \RSELVES6 ,MAY #a1 #aigd ,PO/NOTES ,I4 ,NOTATIONS ,!SIS #c N#a ,BY 0TRANSP>5T0 RELATIONS WE MEAN RELATIONS BEYOND DUPLICITY2 RELATIONS 9 :I* ! ESS5TIAL IS ALSO VISIBLE1 I4E41 9 :I* ! ESS5CE APPE>S4 0,TRANSP>5CY0 IS :5 Y\ CAN SEE FROM ! SURFACE ( SOCIAL PH5OM5A ?R\< 9TO !IR CORE2 :5 !IR TRU? IS APP>5T ON ! SURFACE4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y1 ! SOCIAL RELATIONS ( CAPITALI/ SOCIETY >E OPAQUE2 %OT ?R\< ) A CONTRADICTION BETWE5 APPE>ANCE & ESS5CE2 ?+S >E1 MORE (T5 ?AN NOT ! EXACT OPPOSITE ( :AT !Y APPE> TO BE4 ,= EXAMPLE1 9 CAPITAL1 ! APP>5T SOCIAL IMP]ATIVE ( ! PRODUCTION ( MAXIMAL USE-VALUE -- 0WE'RE H]E TO S]VE Y\02 0TO PRODUCE A QUALITY PRODUCT01 ETC4 -- CONCEALS !IR ULT]IOR MOTIVE ( ! PRODUCTION ( MAXIMAL EX*ANGE-VALUE 7PR(IT71 & ?IS HIDD51 ESS5TIAL IMP]ATIVE REVEALS ITSELF ONLY :]E ! TWO IMP]ATIVES COME 9TO CONFLICT1 9 :I* CASE ! USE-VALUE IS SACRIFIC$ TO EX*ANGE-VALUE 7PLANN$ OBSOLESC5CE1 PRODUCTION ( WOR?LESS PRODUCTS1 FAD PRODUCTS1 DE/RUCTION ( CROPS & O!R PRODUCTS TO KEEP PRICES UP1 & 9 G5]AL1 ! T5D5CY ( ALL PRODUCTS PRODUC$ AS COMMODITY-CAPITAL TO DET]IORATE 9 QUALITY OV] TIME2 ! 0T5D5CY ( USE-VALUE TO FALL40 ,M>X 5VISION$ ! EM]G5CE ( TRANSP>5CY 9 SOCIAL RELATIONS AS AN ASPECT ( ! EM]G5CE ( COMMUNI/ SOCIETY1 9 ! FOLL[+ WORDS3 0,LET US N[ PICTURE \RSELVES1 BY WAY ( *ANGE1 A COMMUNITY ( FREE 9DIVIDUALS1 C>RY+ ON !IR WORK ) ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION 9 COMMON1 9 :I* ! LABOR-P[] ( ALL ! DIFF]5T 9DIVIDUALS IS CONSCI\SLY APPLI$ AS ! COMB9$ LABOR-P[] ( ! COMMUNITY 4444 ,! SOCIAL RELATIONS ( ! 9DIVIDUAL PRODUC]S1 ) REG>D BO? TO !IR LABOR & TO ITS PRODUCTS1 >E 9 ?IS CASE P]FECTLY SIMPLE & 9TELLIGIBLE1 & ?AT ) REG>D NOT ONLY TO PRODUCTION BUT ALSO TO DI/RIBUTION 4444 7MY/IFICATION.> CAN1 9 ANY CASE1 ONLY !N F9ALLY VANI%1 :5 ! PRACTICAL RELATIONS ( EV]YDAY LIFE (F] TO MAN NONE BUT P]FECTLY 9TELLIGIBLE & REASONABLE RELATIONS ) REG>D TO HIS FELL[M5 & TO ,NATURE44440 -- ,K>L ,M>X1 ,CAPITAL1 ,A ,CRITIQUE ( ,POLITICAL ,ECONOMY1 BOOK ,I1 ,9T]NATIONAL ,PUBLI%]S1 7,NEW ,YORK1 #a#i#f#g74 PP4 #g#h-#g#i1 9 ,*APT] #a1 ,SECTION #d3 0,! ,FETI%ISM ( ,COMMODITIES & ! ,SECRET ,!RE(04 N#b ,*>ACT]3 ,AN 9DIVIDUAL'S TYPICAL /RUCTURE1 HIS /]EOTYPE MANN] ( ACT+ & REACT+4 ,! ORGONOMIC CONCEPT ( *>ACT] IS FUNCTIONAL & BIOLOGICAL1 & NOT A /ATIC1 PSY*OLOGICAL OR MORALI/IC CONCEPT4 ,*>ACT] ,>MOR3 ,! SUM TOTAL ( TYPICAL *>ACT] ATTITUDES1 :I* AN 9DIVIDUAL DEVELOPS AS A BLOCK+ AGA9/ HIS EMOTIONAL EXCITATIONS1 RESULT+ 9 RIGIDITY ( ! BODY1 LACK ( EMOTIONAL CONTACT1 0DEADNESS40 ,FUNCTIONALLY ID5TICAL ) ! MUSCUL> >MOR4 -- ,WILHELM ,REI*1 ,! ,FUNCTION ( ! ,ORGASM1 ,M]IDIAN 7,NEW ,YORK4 #a#i#g#a71 ,GLOSS>Y1 PP4 #c#e#i-#c#f4 ,G5]ALLY1 *>ACT]->MOR MAY BE VIEW$ AS FROZ5 MODES ( O!RWISE NORMAL BEHAVIOR -- ! PO9T IS ! 9ABILITY ( AN 9DIVIDUAL TO *OOSE OR TO *ANGE C]TA9 ASPECTS ( HIS BEHAVIOR4 ,METAPHORICALLY1 IT IS ! UNSE5 %IELD ?AT BLOCKS EXPRESSION & P]CEPTION ( A P]SON'S 0CORE01 !IR SUBJECTIVITY1 KEEP+ IT FROM ! SURFACE & USUALLY FROM CONSCI\SNESS4 ,IT IS ! 9AU!NTIC SELF -- ! FICTITI\S OR NON-SELF -- ?AT CONCEALS & H>BORS ! REAL SELF4 ,! 9VOLUNT>Y MODES ( BEHAVIOR ?AT *>ACT]IZE >MOR >E G5]ALLY 0LE>N$0 DUR+ *ILDHOOD AS A 0RATIONAL0 RESPONSE TO AN IRRATIONAL1 OPPRESSIVE WORLD4 ,?US1 >MOR IS ESS5TIALLY NOT A ?+ LOCAT$ 9 EA* 9DIVIDUAL1 BUT A SOCIAL RELATION1 A LAY] ( CALL\S1 DEAD5$ TO ! SELF & O!R1 BUILT UP 9 ! WE> & TE> ( 7ANTI-7SOCIAL 9T]ACTIONS2 9 ! AGONY & CON/ANT DANG] ( ALI5AT$ ASSOCIATION4 ,?IS IS DEMON/RAT$ 9 ! FOLL[+ OBS]VATION3 *ANGE A P]SON'S SOCIAL RELATIONS & HIS >MOR+1 HIS *>ACT] ADJU/M5T1 WILL ALSO BEG9 TO *ANGE TO RE-ADAPT1 TO BECOME CONGRU5T AGA9 ) HIS SOCIAL LIFE1 HIS NEW RELATION%IPS4 ,?US1 IT IS ]RONE\S TO LOCATE >MOR SIMPLY 9 ! 9DIVIDUAL TAK5 SEP>ATELY1 AL?\< IT IS TRUE ?AT HIS SOCIAL RELATIONS1 HIS WAY ( RELAT+ & SURVIV+ SOCIALLY1 MAY BE 0REFLECT$0 -- MAPP$ ONTO HIS BODY -- 9 ! =M ( MUSCUL> >MOR+2 ( A PATT]N ( *RONIC CONTRACTION 9 ! V>I\S MUSCUL> SEGM5TS4 ,*>ACT]->MOR IS ?US 7#a7 ! P]SONAL ASPECT ( ! SPECTACLE4 ,IT IS ! P]SONAL ORGANIZATION ( FALSE APPE>ANCES3 SELF-REPRES5TATION2 ! SELF-SPECTACLE4 ,IT IS ! SELF-IMAGE ONE SEEKS TO PROJECT TO O!RS2 ! 0FRONT0 ONE PUTS UP2 ! ROLE ONE PLAYS3 ! 0REPUTATION0 ONE ACCUMULATES4 ,! PROJECT$1 SURFACE MOTIVES BELONG+ TO *>ACT] >E AT ! SAME TIME A SURFACE D5IAL & REPRESSION ( C]TA9 =BIDD51 IMP]MISSIBLE MOTIVES1 :I* P]SI/ B5EA? ! SURFACE ( *>ACT] AS ULT]IOR MOTIVES1 CONSCI\S OR NOT4 ,9 !IR MORE CONSCI\S P>T1 !SE ULT]IOR MOTIVES EXPRESS !MSELVES AS *>ACT] 9 ! =M ( LY+1 *EAT+1 TRICK]Y1 ! CON1 HYPOCRISY1 ETC4 -- ALL ! FAMILI> BACK/AGE ( ! SPECTACLE ( 0GOOD *>ACT]40 ,*>ACT] IS ! V]Y LOCUS ( 9T]P]SONAL DUPLICITY -- PRECISELY ! 0DUPLICATION0 ( ! SELF 7CF4 ,K>L ,M>X1 0,!SES ON ,FEU]BA*01 !SIS ,I,V1 9 ,! ,G]MAN ,IDEOLOGY1 ,PROGRESS ,PUBLI%]S 7,MOSC[1 #a#i#f#h74 P4 #f#f#f1 SEE ALSO ,M>X'S REM>K 9 HIS ,PREFACE TO ,A ,CONTRIBUTION ,TO ,! ,CRITIQUE ( ,POLITICAL ,ECONOMY2 0,JU/ AS \R OP9ION ( AN 9DIVIDUAL IS NOT BAS$ ON :AT HE ?9KS ( HIMSELF1 SO WE CAN NOT JUDGE ( SU* A P]IOD ( TRANS=MATION BY ITS [N CONSCI\SNESS40 9 ,LEWIS ,FEU]1 OP4 CIT41 P4 #d#d47 ,*>ACT]->MOR IS ALSO 7#b7 ! P]SONAL ASPECT ( CAPITAL4 ,9 ! PROLET>IAN1 *>ACT] IS ! LOCUS ( HIS 0NATURE0 AS A COMMODITY1 HIS USE-VALUE TO CAPITAL AS AN OB$I5T PSEUDO-OBJECT1 & H5CE HIS EX*ANGE-VALUE -- HIS EXPLOITABILITY -- AS 0LABOR-P[]02 AS A WORK]4 ,*>ACT]->MOR IS ! 5CRU/ATION SURR\ND+ HIS SELF2 A %IELD %IELD+ BO? ! WORLD & HIS PSEUDO-SELF FROM HIS [N POT5TIAL SUBJECTIVITY4 ,IT IS BUILT UP ?R\< LONG YE>S ( SOCIAL LABOR-TIME BE/[$ UPON HIM BY O!R 9DIVIDUALS -- HIS P>5TS1 PRIE/S1 S*OOL TEA*]S1 POLICEMAN1 & AU?ORITIES ( EV]Y SORT1 9CLUD+ HIS [N PE] GR\P -- & IS P>T ( ! LABOR TIME SOCIALLY NECESS>Y TO PRODUCE A USABLE PROLET>IAN WRET* FROM ! AVAILABLE HUMAN RAW-MAT]IAL1 H5CE IS 9CLUD$ 9 ! 7EX*ANGE-7 VALUE ( LABOR-P[]4 ,IT IS ! 0VALUE-ADD$0 TO ! 9DIVIDUAL AS HE 0MATURES0 BY ! LABOR ( ! SOCIAL AU?ORITIES1 ! IMM$IATE & 7SEMI-CONSCI\S7 AG5TS ( CLASS SOCIETY1 :O MU/ SEE TO ! REPRODUCTION ( 9DIVIDUALS *>ACT]OLOGICALLY CONGRU5T ) ,CAPITALI/ SOCIAL RELATIONS3 ) CAPITAL4 ,! PRODUCTION-PROCESS ( *>ACT] MU/ ?US BE COMPREH5D$ )9 ! CRITIQUE ( POLITICAL ECONOMY1 AS AN ASPECT ( ! REPRODUCTION-PROCESS ( CAPITAL1 ( CAPITALI/ SOCIETY1 AS A :OLE4 ,?IS PROCESS1 ! PRODUCTION PROCESS ( PROLET>IANS1 A SPECIAL =M ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION C>RI$ \T 9 SPECIAL FACTORIES KN[N AS 0S*OOLS01 0*UR*ES01 0PRISONS01 0FAMILIES01 ETC41 IS USUALLY REF]R$ TO1 9 G5]AL1 AS 0*ILD-RE>+01 0$UCATION01 OR 0SOCIALIZATION04 ,IT CONSI/S 9 7A7 ! DE/RUCTION ( SUBJECTIVITY 9 ITS DIRECT =M1 & 7B7 ! DEVELOPM5T ( A N>R[ =M ( SUBJECTIVITY1 9 AN 9DIRECT 7P]V]T$7 =M1 M$IAT$ BY AU?ORIT>IAN P]MISSION4 ,IT IS ! TOTALITY ( ! PROCESSES ( 0ADAPTATION0 NECESS>Y TO MAKE ! PROLET>IAN 0FIT0 TO 5DURE ! 0LIFE0 ( A WORK]4 ,:5 ! PROCESS MISC>RIES1 AS IT (T5 DOES !SE DAYS1 ! PRODUCT IS SAID TO BE 0UNEMPLOYABLE0 -- USELESS TO CAPITAL4 ,9 ! 0F9I%$0 PRODUCT1 ! ADULT1 *>ACT]->MOR IS ! REPOSITORY1 ! OBJECTIFICATION ( ?IS PROCESS1 ! LOCATION ( ALL ! /OR$ PROGRAMS1 HABITS1 PRACTICES1 ROLES1 & BEHAVIOR PATT]NS NECESS>Y TO ! PROLET>IAN SURVIVAL KIT -- SUBMISSIV5ESS1 SLAVI%NESS1 SELF-CONTEMPT1 PASSIVITY1 OB$I5CE1 IRRESPONSIBILITY1 GUILT1 FE> ( FRE$OM1 & SO ON4 ,*>ACT]->MOR IS ! LAY] ( FROZ5 SUBJECTIVITY ?AT MAKES ! WORK] FUNCTIONAL AS A WORK] 9 CAPITALI/ SOCIETY1 I4E41 MANIPULATABLE AS A PSEUDO-OBJECT4 ,IT IS :AT MAKES ! WORK] SUITABLE = AU?ORIT>IAN MANAGEM5T4 ,IT IS :AT MAKES HIM 7PRES5TLY7 9CAPABLE ( SELF-MANAGEM5T4 ,! WAY ?R\< ! PROBLEM IS TO HAVE PEOPLE NOT >MOR$ BUT 0>M$0 -- PHYSICALLY1 PSY*OLOGICALLY1 & !ORETICALLY -- TO BR+ :AT IS 9VOLUNT>Y MORE UND] CONSCI\S CONTROL4 N#c 0,TO TRANSC5D 7AUFHEB57 HAS ?IS D\BLE MEAN+1 ?AT IT SIGNIFIES TO KEEP OR PRES]VE & ALSO TO MAKE CEASE1 TO F9I%4 ,TO PRES]VE 9CLUDES ?IS NEGATIVE ELEM5T1 ?AT SOME?+ IS REMOV$ FROM ITS IMM$IACY & !RE=E FROM A ,DET]M9ATE ,BE+ EXPOS$ TO EXT]NAL 9FLU5CES1 9 ORD] ?AT IT MAY BE PRES]V$4 -- ,?US :AT IS TRANSC5D$ IS ALSO PRES]V$2 IT HAS LO/ ITS IMM$IACY & IS NOT ON ?AT ACC\NT ANNIHILAT$4 -- ,9 ! DICTION>Y ! TWO DET]M9ATIONS ( TRANSC5D+ MAY BE CIT$ AS TWO MEAN+S ( ?IS WORD4 ,BUT IT %\LD APPE> AS REM>KABLE ?AT A LANGUAGE %\LD HAVE COME TO USE ONE & ! SAME WORD = TWO OPPOSITE DET]M9ATIONS4 ,IT IS A JOY = SPECULATIVE ?\E ( ?IS BLUNTLY D5\NC$ WEAL? AS DE/RUCTIVE ( COMMUNITY40 -- ,K>L ,M>X1 ,GRUNDRISSE D] ,KRITIK D] ,POLITIS*5 ,OEKONOMIE4 ,QUOT$ 91 ,K>L ,M>X1 ,! ,GRUNDRISSE1 TRANSLAT$ & $IT$ BY ,DAVID ,MC,LELLAN1 ,H>P] @& ,R[1 7,SAN ,FRANCISCO1 #a#i#g#a1 P4 #a#b74 ,!SIS #e N#a ,BY 0,P[]0 ) A CAPITAL 0,P01 WE MEAN SEP>ATE P[]2 ALI5AT$ P[]1 :OSE MAJOR MOD]N EXAMPLES >E /ATE P[] & ?AT SOCIAL P[] KN[N AS 0CAPITAL'4 ,9 /ATE-CAPITALISM1 ! HIATE SOCIAL P[]4 ,WE HAVE NO QU>REL ) 0P[]' AS SU*1 ?AT IS1 ) SELF-P[] -- ! P[] ( SOCIAL SELF-DET]M9ATION & SELF-PRODUCTION2 CREATIVE1 PRODUCTIVE FACULTIES & P[] OV] ONE'S [N LIFE4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y2 ?IS IS ! V]Y DEVELOPM5T & 5RI*M5T ( 9DIVIDUALITY ITSELF4 ,ON ! CONTR>Y2 ,! RE-APPROPRIATION ( \RSELVES1 ! REPOSSESSION ( \RSELVES FROM CAPITAL1 ! RE-[N+ ( ALI5AT$ SELF-P[]S1 IS ! ESS5TIAL PURPOSE ( \R REVOLUTION1 ! COMMUNI/ REVOLUTION2 & IS \R PURPOSE 9 IT4 ,IT %\LD BE OBVI\S1 !N1 FROM :AT HAS BE5 SAID1 ?AT ,P[] IS ! OPPOSITE ( P[]4 ,! GREAT] ! ,P[] ( ! ,/ATE & ,CAPITAL1 ! MORE P[]LESS1 ! MORE IMPOT5T >E WE1 ! PROLET>IAT1 = ?AT ,P[] IS NO?+ O!R ?AN \R LO/1 \R ALI5AT$ P[]2 ! LABOR P[] WE SELL TO CAPITAL & ! POLITICAL P[] WE GIVE UP TO \R 0REPRES5TATIVES04 ,IT WAS NECESS>Y TO SAY ?IS BECAUSE ( ! LEGIONS ( MORALI/IC MASO*I/S & WOR%IP]S ( IMPOT5CE PRES5TLY TRAIPS+ ?R\< ! SPECTACLE1 = :OM WE MI TO T\* IT01 ALONG ) MONEY & CAPITAL1 \T ( DREAD ( BE+ 9/ANTLY CORRUPT$ BY IT4 ,!Y HAVE NEV] LET !MSELVES GRASP ?AT ! ONLY WAY TO BE SAFE FROM ?IS PA!TIC 0CORRUPTION0 IS TO BE -- NOT B5EA? IT1 BUT BEYOND IT4 ,= AN ACC\NT1 UNSURPASS$ 9 ITS BRILLIANCE1 ( ! DIALECTIC ( SELF-P[]S & !IR ALI5ATION1 SEE ,LORRA9E & ,FR$Y ,P]LMAN'S BOOK-L5G? DET\RNEM5T ( REVOLUTION>Y IDEOLOGY1 ,MANUAL ,= ,REVOLUTION>Y ,LEAD]S1 0BY ,MI*AEL ,VELLI0 7,B,L,A,C,K ,& ,R,$1 ,P4,O4 ,BOX #i#e#d#f1 ,DETROIT1 ,MI*IGAN1 #d#h#b#b2 PP4 #a#a-#d#i74 7,UN=TUNATELY = ALL ( US1 ! ,P]LMANS DECID$ TO TRUNCATE !IR !ORY JU/ AT ! ?RE%OLD ( ITS PRACTICE1 BY AB/RACTLY NEGAT+ REVOLUTION>Y ORGANIZATION -- TO ! EFFECT ?AT ALL ORGANIZATION IS HI]>*ICAL ORGANIZATION & ALL REVOLUTION>Y ORGANIZATION IS NECESS>ILY ,L59I/ ORGANIZATION -- & SO 5D UP EMBRAC+ IMPOT5CE = !MSELVES AS REVOLUTION>IES74 ,!SIS #g N#a ,FROM H]E ON \T1 UNLESS O!RWISE SPECIFICALLY 9DICAT$1 ! USE ( MASCUL9E PRON\N =MS IS MEANT TO 9CLUDE ! FEM99E1 S9CE ?IS IS ! CLOSE/ ?+ TO A UNIT>Y PRON\N ! ,5GLI% LANGUAGE CONTA9S1 = MO/ PURPOSES4 N#b ,IMMAN5T CRITIQUE IS CRITIQUE :I* BASES ITSELF 9 ! SAME F\NDATION1 LOGICAL1 ETC41 :I* =MS ! CORE OR ESS5CE ( ! OBJECT ( ! CRITIQUE2 CRITIQUE :I* LOCATES ITSELF 9SIDE ITS OBJECT4 ,IT ?US LOCATES ! 9T]NAL CONTRADICTIONS ( ITS OBJECT -- ! SELF-CONTRADICTIONS -- BECOM+ A CRITIQUE :I* IS ESS5TIAL TO ! OBJECT ( CRITIQUE ITSELF4 ,?US IMMAN5T CRITIQUE IS AN 9TIMATE1 9T]NAL CRITIQUE1 9 FACT1 A SELF-CRITIQUE ( ! OBJECT1 A CRITIQUE BAS$ ON ! 9T]NAL /&>DS ( ! OBJECT ( ! CRITIQUE ITSELF1 & NOT AN EXT]NAL OR ALI5 CRITIQUE -- A JUDGM5T FROM A /&PO9T \TSIDE ?AT :I* IS JUDG$4 ,!SIS #h N#a ,BY 0TOTAL APPROPRIATION0 WE MEAN1 9 G5]AL1 ALL-SID$ APPROPRIATION -- ?AT IS1 SOCIAL RELATIONS NOT RE/RICT$ TO A SPECIALIZ$ & COMP>TM5TALIZ$ 9T]*ANGE ( 0?+S0 OR ( P>TS ( PEOPLE AS 0?+S0 7MONEY1 COMMODITIES1 IMAGES1 ETC47 -- AS 9 ! PRES5T ORGANIZATION ( SOCIAL 9T]ACTION ACCORD+ TO ROLES1 :I* 5=CES A /RICT SEP>ATION ( ! V>I\S ASPECTS & 9T]E/S ( LIFE1 0,TOTAL APPROPRIATION0 IS1 AMONG O!R ?+S1 :]E Y\ >E NO LONG] CONF9$ TO 0TALK+ %OP0 EV5 9 ! %OP4 ,BY 0TOTAL0 APPROPRIATION ( ANO!R P]SON WE MEAN1 9 P>TICUL>1 AN APPROPRIATION ( !M :I* 9CLUD$ 9 ITSELF !IR APPROPRIATION ( Y\2 I4E4 IT CAN OCCUR ONLY :5 IT IS RECIPROCAL1 :5 EA* P]SON IS BO? APPROPRIATOR & APPROPRIAT$4 ,?IS IS UNLIKE EI!R ! CASE ( ! APPROPRIATION ( AN OBJECT1 :I* CAN'T 0APPROPRIATE BACK10 OR ! P>TIAL APPROPRIATION 7EXPLOITATION7 ( A SUBJECT2 ! APPROPRIATION ( A SUBJECT AS IF AN OBJECT1 EXCLUD+1 DISREG>D+ HIS OR H] DESIRES1 NE$S1 EXPECTATIONS1 & RECIPROCAL APPROPRIATION ( ! APPROPRIATOR4 ,?AT IS1 WE W\LD MEAN ?AT Y\ APPROPRIATE !IR APPROPRIATION ( Y\ AS ITSELF A NECESS>Y P>T ( !M2 9CLUDE 9 ! 0!M0 ?AT Y\ 0TOTALLY0 APPROPRIATE !IR DESIRES1 NE$S1 ATTITUDES1 & EXPECTATIONS ) REG>D TO Y\ 9 SOME WAY2 APPROPRIATE !IR SUBJECTIVITY AS ! ESS5TIAL P>T ( !M2 RELATE TO IT4 0,TOTAL APPROPRIATION0 IS ?US ! 5C\NT] BY A SUBJECT ( ANO!R SUBJECT AS A SUBJECT4 ,IT W\LD 9VOLVE ! APPROPRIATION ( ! O!R P]SON'S RESPONSE TO Y\1 9CLUD+ ( !IR RESPONSE TO Y\R RESPONSES TO !M4 ,TRUE 9F9ITY4 ,TOTAL APPROPRIATION EXI/S :5 Y\ CAN 7ACTUALLY & DIRECTLY -- NOT JU/ VIC>I\SLY7 APPROPRIATE SOMEONE ELSE'S JOY AS Y\R [N4 ,ONE MIY 0SUBJECTS0 ?AT ONE NOT ONLY DOESN'T WANT TO APPROPRIATE 'TOTALLY'1 BUT 9 FACT DOESN'T WANT ANY P>T (4 ,& TO ?IS WE C\LD ONLY AGREE1 ) H[EV] ! ADDITIONAL COMM5T>Y ?AT 7#a7 MO/ ( :AT WE DON'T WANT ANY P>T ( IS NON-SELF1 NON-SUBJECTIVITY 7FROZ5 SUBJECTIVITY2 >MOR7 TO BEG9 )1 &3 7#b7 ?IS NEGAT$ SUBJECTIVITY HAS TO BE DEALT ) 9 ONE WAY OR ANO!R ANYWAY3 NO MATT] :AT1 IT HAS TO BE FAC$1 EV5 9 PRES5T-DAY SOCIETY -- P]HAPS #i.0 ( ! FUCK-UPS 9 PRES5T-DAY CAPITALI/ BUS9ESS-PRACTICE >E DUE TO SU* *>ACT]OLOGICAL 0P]SONALITY FACTORS04 ,& 9 ! CONTEXT ( ASSOCIAT$ PRODUCTION1 :]E SU/A9$ ASSOCIATION IS AN EGOI/IC NECESSITY1 ! PROBLEM BECOMES A QUE/ION ( :AT IS ! BE/ WAY ( CONFRONT+ !SE 0FACTORS01 FROM AN EXP&$-EGOI/IC PO9T ( VIEW4 ,!RE IS NO D\BT ?AT 0TOTAL APPROPRIATION0 WILL BE1 AMONG O!R ?+S1 A CONFLICTUAL PROCESS1 A FI PROCESS4 ,TO AB/RACTLY AFFIRM AN IDYLLIC1 NON-CONFLICTUAL IMAGE ( TOTAL APPROPRIATION ( ANO!R :5 9 FACT ! O!R REMA9S TO V>Y+ DEGREES A FROZ5 SUBJECT IS TO MORALLY PROJECT & IDEALIZE TOTAL APPROPRIATION4 ,TOTAL APPROPRIATION IS A SOCIAL-HI/ORICAL PROCESS :I* GR[S \T ( PEOPLE'S COLLECTIVE TRANS=MATION ( ! WORLD & !MSELVES4 ,! FACT ?AT WE FEEL A NE$ = SU* TRANSP>5CY %[S ?AT ! PROCESS HAS ALREADY BEGUN4 ,BUT ALREADY ?IS PROCESS HAS COME 9TO CONFLICT ) ! OBJECTIVE CONDITIONS 7I4E4 ! PRES5T SOCIAL RELATIONS74 ,ULTIMATELY1 ONLY 9 REVOLUTION CAN WE SUCCE$ 9 RIDD+ \RSELVES ( ALL ! MUCK ( AGES & BECOME FITT$ TO F\ND SOCIETY ANEW4 ,!SIS #i N#a ,BY 0EGOISM0 WE MEAN SOME?+ :I*1 9 ITS FULL DEVELOPM5T1 IS QUITE DIFF]5T FROM1 9 FACT1 09F9ITELY0 DIFF]5T FROM OR OPPOSITE TO 0EGOTISM04 ,EGOTISM IS P]SONAL PRACTICE 9 FAVOR ( ONE'S SELF-SPECTACLE1 ONE'S SOCIAL IMAGE1 ONE'S P]SONA4 ,IT IS PRECISELY1 !RE=E1 ACTIVITY 9 ! 9T]E/ ( ONE'S NON-SELF1 TRULY SELFLESS ACTIVITY4 ,:]EAS1 BY EGOISM WE MEAN1 ON ! CONTR>Y1 P]SONAL ACTIVITY 9 ! 9T]E/ ( ONE'S AU!NTIC SELF1 TO ! EXT5T ONE RECOGNIZES & KN[S ?IS SELF AT ANY GIV5 TIME1 H[EV] N>R[LY OR EXP&$LY4 ,EGOTISM IS SPECTACUL>1 O!R-C5T]$ 7ALI5AT$71 ! VIC>I\S LIV+ ( Y\R [N LIFE2 EGOISM IS AUTONOM\S1 F\ND$ ON SELF-C5TRATION & ON CONCRETE1 SOCIAL SELF-KN[L$GE4 ,EGOTISM IS ?US ONE ( ! L[E/ =MS ( EGOISM4 ,IT IS1 LIKE MORALISM1 EGOISM BY MEANS ( A PROJECTION1 & TURNS 9TO 9TO ITS OPPOSITE4 N#b ,! T]M 0DET\RNEM5T01 EMPLOY$ ESPECIALLY AS A TE*NICAL T]M BY ,SITUATIONI/S1 HAS BE5 DEF9$ AS ! REVOLUTION>Y PRACTICE 0BY :I* ! SPECTACLE IS TURN$ BACK ON ITSELF1 TURN$ 9SIDE \T SO ?AT IT REVEALS ITS [N 9N] WORK+S40 ,SEE ,LOAD$ ,WORDS3 ,A ,REBEL'S ,GUIDE ,TO ,SITUATIONESE1 ,N,E,W ,M,O,R,N,+1 ,FEBRU>Y1 #a#i#g#c1 ,NEW ,MORN+ ,COLLECTIVE 7,P4,O4 ,BOX #e#c#a1 ,B]KELEY1 ,CALI=NIA1 #i#d#g#a71 P4 #ad . ,?IS MODE ( PRACTICE IS NOT CONF9$ M]ELY TO ! TURN+-AGA9/-!MSELVES ( ! WORDS1 ! LANGUAGE1 ( SPECTACUL> IDEOLOGY4 ,! TE*NIQUE HAS ALSO BE5 APPLI$ TO ! MOM5T>Y SEIZURE ( ! SPECTACUL> IMAGES ( V>I\S DOM9ANT IDEOLOGIES & 9/ITUTIONS = ! PURPOSE ( BROADCA/+ ?R\< SAID IMAGES A REVOLUTION>Y CRITIQUE4 ,SU* 0MOM5T>Y EXPROPRIATION0 ( ! MEANS ( COMMUNICATION HAS BE5 US$1 = EXAMPLE1 9 CASES :]E FRAUDUL5T MEMOR&UMS ATTRIBUT$ TO PROM95T BUREAUCRATS1 PO/]S ANN\NC+ EV5TS OR OP9IONS 9 ! NAME ( DOM9ANT SPECTACUL> ORGANIZATIONS1 PRESS RELEASES & O!R WORKS ATTRIBUT$ TO GOV]NM5T (FICIALS OR O!R SPECTACUL> 7IMAG$7 P]SONAGES1 ISSUES ( NEWSPAP]S OR O!R P]IODICALS1 ADV]TIS+ MAT]IALS1 ETC4 HAVE BE5 DISSEM9AT$ & ! RESULT+ SC&AL OR CONFUSION ( D5IALS US$ AS A LEV] TO GA9 PUBLICITY = REVOLUTION>Y !ORY4 N#c ,WORDS -- WRITT5 & SPOK5 -- >E1 9 ! BEG9N+1 ! ONLY MEANS ( PRODUCTION :I* WE1 AS PROLET>IANS1 POSSESS3 ! V]Y MEANS ( PRODUCTION ( REVOLUTION>Y CONSCI\SNESS ITSELF4 ,!SIS #a N#a 0,/ATE-CAPITALISM0 IS A T]M US$ TO DESCRIBE ! =M 7/AGE7 ( CAPITALI/ SOCIETY :I* IS *>ACT]IZ$ 9 DIFF]5T WAYS & TO DIFF]5T DEGREES BY /ATE MANAGEM5T ( ! ECONOMY1 :ILE DEF9ITIVELY CAPITALI/ RELATIONS 7SEP>ATION ( ! PRODUC]S FROM ! ACCUMULAT$ MEANS ( PRODUCTION1 WAGE-LABOR1 ETC47 >E LEFT 9TACT4 ,HI/ORICALLY1 /ATE-CAPITALISM HAS TAK5 WIDELY V>I$ =MS1 RANG+ FROM RELATIVELY M9OR REGULATION ( ! PRIVATE 9/ITUTIONS TO TOTAL NATIONALIZATION ( BASIC 9DU/RIES 9TO A /ATE-MONOPOLIZ$ NATIONAL ,CAPITAL4 ,ITS =MS V>Y FROM RII/1 0COMMUNALI/01 ETC474 0,9 ANY CASE444 ! (FICIAL REPRES5TATIVE ( CAPITALI/ SOCIETY -- ! /ATE -- WILL ULTIMATELY HAVE TO UND]TAKE ! DIRECTION ( PRODUCTION444 ,BUT ! TRANS=MATION444 9TO /ATE [N]%IP DOES NOT DO AWAY ) ! CAPITALI/IC NATURE ( ! PRODUCTIVE =CES4444 ,! MOD]N /ATE1 AGA91 IS ONLY ! ORGANIZATION ?AT B\RGEOIS SOCIETY TAKES ON 9 ORD] TO SUPPORT ! EXT]NAL CONDITIONS ( ! CAPITALI/ MODE ( PRODUCTION AGA9/ ! 5CROA*M5TS ( ! 9DIVIDUAL CAPITALI/ AS ( ! WORK]S4 ,! MOD]N /ATE1 NO MATT] :AT ITS =M1 IS ESS5TIALLY A CAPITALI/ MA*9E1 ! /ATE ( ! CAPITALI/S1 ! IDEAL P]SONIFICATION ( ! TOTAL NATIONAL CAPITAL4 ,! MORE IT PROCE$S TO ! TAK+ OV] ( PRODUCTIVE =CES1 ! MORE DOES IT ACTUALLY BECOME ! NATIONAL CAPITALI/2 ! MORE CITIZ5S DOES IT EXPLOIT4 ,! WORK]S REMA9 WAGE-WORK]S -- PROLET>IANS4 ,! CAPITALI/ RELATION IS NOT DONE AWAY )4 ,IT IS RA!R BR\ IS 9 ! LA/ ANALYSIS ! LEA/ FAVORABLE FACTOR = ! PRES5T DEVELOPM5T ( CAPITALI/ SOCIETY4 ,! B\RGEOISIE IS 9 ! PROCESS ( LOS+ ! ADV]S>Y :I* OBJECTIVELY SUPPORT$ IT BY PROVID+ AN ILLUSORY UNIFICATION ( ALL NEGATION ( ! EXI/+ ORD]40 -- ,GUY ,DEBORD1 ,! ,SOCIETY ,( ,! ,SPECTACLE1 ,B,L,A,C,K ,& ,R,$1 7,DETROIT1 #a#i#g#c71 !SIS #a#a#a4 0,UNTIL N[1 ! MO/ DURABLE S\RCE ( SUPPORT = SU/A9+ & 5L>G+ ! OP]ATION ( ! /ATE-MANAGEM5T HAS BE5 ! PATT]N ( ANTAGONI/IC COOP]ATION BETWE5 ! ,U4,S4 /ATE MANAGEM5T & ITS ,SOVIET C\NT]P>T40 -- CF4 ,SEYM\R ,MELMAN1 ,P5TAGON ,CAPITALISM3 ,! ,POLITICAL ,ECONOMY ,( ,W>1 ,MC,GRAW-,HILL1 7,SAN ,FRANCISCO1 #a#i#g#a71 ,*APT] #i1 0#a#i#h#d ,BY #a#i#g#d8 ,OR1 ,CAN ,! ,/ATE-,MANAGEM5T ,BE ,/OPP$801 P4 #b#a#e3 N#c ,WORK]S' C\NCILS HAVE EM]G$ HI/ORICALLY AS A REVOLUTION>Y =CE BEG9N+ ) ! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE ( #a#h#g#a1 :]E !Y TOOK ! =M ( A COMMUNITY C\NCIL )\T WORKPLACE C\NCILS 7GIV5 ! UND]DEVELOP$ /ATE ( ! FACTORY SY/EM 9 ! ,P>IS ( ?AT TIME72 9 ,RUSSIA 9 #aie & AGA9 9 #aiag 9 ! =M ( CITY-WIDE 7& LAT] NATIONWIDE7 ,SOVIETS1 & FACTORY COMMITTEES2 9 ,G]MANY DUR+ #a#i#a#h-#a#i#a#i AS ! CLASSICAL ',SOLDI]S' & ,WORK]S' C\NCILS'2 9 ,ITALY 9 #aib 7! ,TUR9 ,SOVIET1 ETC472 9 ! ,KRON/ADT ,SOVIET ( #a#i#b#a2 9 ,SPA9 DUR+ #a#i#c#f-#g 9 ! =M ( ! ,CATALONIAN WORK]S' C\NCILS & PEASANT COOP]ATIVES2 9 ,HUNG>Y 9 #a#i#e#f1 :]E = ! FIR/ TIME S9CE ,KRON/ADT WORK]S' C\NCILS APPE>$ AS ! ORGANS ( REVOLUTION>Y /RUGGLE AGA9/ A /ATE-CAPITALI/ BUREAUCRACY 9/EAD ( A B\RGEOISIE2 9 ,ALG]IA 9 #a#i#f#c2 & MO/ REC5TLY 9 ,*ILI 7#a#i#g-#g#c7 9 EMBRYONIC =MS SU* AS ! COMM&OS COMMUNALES 7COMMUNITY PROTO-C\NCILS7 & ! CORDONES 9DU/RIALES 7MULTI-WORKPLACE PROTO-C\NCILS71 :I* W]E1 H[EV]1 /ILL L>GELY DOM9AT$ BY V>I\S BUREAUCRACIES4 ,!SIS #aa N#a ,! ROOT DEF9ITION ( 0RESONANCE0 COM+ FROM PHYSICS1 FROM ! ME*ANICS ( OSCILLATORS1 IS REVEAL+ H]E4 ,= EXAMPLE3 07A7 AN ABNORMALLY L>GE RESPONSE ( A SY/EM HAV+ A NATURAL FREQU5CY1 TO A P]IODIC EXT]NAL /IMULUS ( ! SAME1 OR NE>LY ! SAME1 FREQU5CY4 7B7 ! 9CREASE 9 9T5SITY ( S\ND BY SYMPA!TIC VIBRATION ( O!R BODIES40 -- ,C4,L4 ,B>NH>T @& ,JESS ,/E91 ,! ,AM]ICAN ,COLLEGE ,DICTION>Y1 ,R&OM ,H\SE1 7,NEW ,YORK1 #a#i#f#d71 P4 #a#c#c1 0RESONANCE1 N404 ,?AT IS1 ME*ANICAL RESONANCE OCCURS :5 ! NATURAL FREQU5CY ( OSCILLATION -- ! 'IMMAN5T'1 'ESS5TIAL'1 OR 9T]NAL FREQU5CY -- ( ! RESONAT+ OBJECT IS ID5TICAL TO ! FREQU5CY ( EXT]NALLY 0=C$0 OSCILLATION1 I4E41 TO ! EXT]NAL FREQU5CY4 ,SOCIAL RESONANCE OCCURS AS 9T]-RECOGNITION2 :5 SOCIAL 9DIVIDUALS RECOGNIZE !MSELVES 9 EA* O!R1 ! O!R 9 !MSELVES1 & !MSELVES 9 ! WORLD !Y PRODUCE2 :5 !Y RECOGNIZE !IR CONCRETE UNIV]SALITY4 ,IT OCCURS :5 :AT 0SOCIETY0 NE$S ( !M IS ALSO :AT !Y NE$ ( !MSELVES3 !IR [N PRODUCTION2 !IR [N DEVELOPM5T2 !IR [N SELF-REALIZATION2 :5 :AT 0SOCIETY0 NE$S ( !M IS NOT IMPOS$ AS AN EXT]NAL1 ALI5 =CE1 CO]CIVELY BY ! /ATE OR UNCONSCI\SLY1 AS ! 0LAW ( VALUE10 BY CAPITAL1 BUT AS !IR [N1 9T]NALLY G5]AT$ SELF-=CE1 WELL+-UP SPONTANE\SLY )9 !M4 ,FROM EA* ACCORD+ TO HIS DESIRE1 TO EA* ACCORD+ TO HIS DESIRE4 ,?IS IS POSSIBLE SU/A9$LY ONLY ONCE ! NECESS>Y SOCIAL CONDITIONS = SU* A RECOGNITION & SU* A NE$ HAVE BE5 PRODUC$ HI/ORICALLY1 I4E41 ONLY ONCE C]TA9 RELATIONS ( HUMANITY TO ITSELF1 -- NAMELY1 9T]-PRODUCTION -- GRASP$ E>LY 9 AN ALI5AT$ =M AS ! 0ET]NAL TRU?S0 ( RELIGIONS1 HAVE BECOME FACT1 ?AT IS1 BECOME HI/ORICALLY MAT]IALIZ$4 ,!SIS #ag N#a ,NOTE ?AT ?IS 0TYPICALLY0 APPLIES TO BO? CAPITALI/ & PROLET>IAN 9DIVIDUALS -- SPANS ! CLASS DIVIDE4 0,! IDEAS ( ! RUL+ CLASS >E 9 EV]Y EPO* ! RUL+ IDEAS3 I4E41 ! CLASS :I* IS ! RUL+ MAT]IAL =CE ( SOCIETY1 IS AT ! SAME TIME ITS RUL+ 9TELLECTUAL =CE4 ,! CLASS :I* HAS ! MEANS ( MAT]IAL PRODUCTION AT ITS DISPOSAL1 HAS CONTROL AT ! SAME TIME OV] ! MEANS ( M5TAL PRODUCTION1 SO ?AT !REBY1 G5]ALLY SPEAK+1 ! IDEAS ( ?OSE :O LACK ! MEANS ( M5TAL PRODUCTION >E SUBJECT TO IT4 ,! RUL+ IDEAS >E NO?+ MORE ?AN ! IDEAL EXPRESSION ( ! DOM9ANT MAT]IAL RELATION%IPS1 ! DOM9ANT MAT]IAL RELATION%IPS GRASP$ AS IDEAS3 H5CE ( ! RELATION%IPS :I* MAKE ! ONE CLASS ! RUL+ ONE1 H5CE ! IDEAS ( ITS DOM9ANCE40 -- ,K>L ,M>X & ,FR$]ICK ,5GELS1 ,! ,G]MAN ,IDEOLOGY1 ,PROGRESS ,PUBLI%]S1 7,MOSC[1 #a#i#f#h71 P4 #f#a4 ,!SIS #bc N#a ,! PASSAGE MAY APPE> TO BE CONFUS+ H]E & ?R\<\T1 P]HAPS 9 P>T BECAUSE ! TRANSLATORS DID NOT COMPREH5D ! DIALECTICAL CONCEPTS BE+ US$ NOR ! FULL RADICALITY ( :AT WAS BE+ ASS]T$1 :I*1 TO ! ,KANTIAN OR 0,FLATL&0 M9D IS IMPOSSIBLE OR ABSURD4 ,= 9/ANCE1 0SOCIAL BE+0 "7 0! BE+ ( SOCIETY02 0! EXI/5CE ( SOCIETY02 0SOCIAL EXI/5CE0 -- & NOT JU/ 0A0 SOCIAL BE+4 ,M>X IS ASS]T+ H]E ?AT ! SOCIAL 9DIVIDUAL IS ! ESS5CE ( SOCIETY3 ! SUB/ANCE & 0NATURE0 ( SOCIETY-! PLACE :]E ! *>ACT] ( SOCIETY1 ! SOCIAL *>ACT]1 BECOMES VISIBLE1 MANIFE/4 ,!SIS #be N#a ,CAPITALI/IC LIB]TY IS ! (FICIAL SANCTION = EA* TO 5HANCE & G>NI% HIS [N SEP>ATE MIS]Y 9 PRIVATE1 ) ! BLESS+ ( LAW4 ,CAPITALI/IC LIB]TY IS ! RIX IS OBVI\SLY ! NON-L9E>1 SUP]-ADDITIVE CONCEPT AS OPPOS$ TO ! L9E>1 ATOMI/IC ONE C5TRAL TO B\RGEOIS SOCIETY4 ,!SIS #cg N#a ,! T]M 0SUBLATION0 IS SOMETIMES US$ AS ! TE*NICAL ,5GLI% EQUIVAL5T = ! ,G]MAN 0AUFHEBUNG0 AS DEVELOP$ BY ,HEGEL 7SEE ! ?IRD NOTE TO ,!SIS #c74 N#b ,REVOLUTION>Y !ORY & REVOLUTION>Y IDEOLOGY >E NOT ONLY DIFF]5T1 BUT OPPOS$4 ',REVOLUTION>Y !ORY' NAMES ! !ORY ( ! PRODUCTION ( SOCIAL REVOLUTION3 ( ! PRACTICES NECESS>Y TO ?IS PRODUCTION -- ! COH]5T SY/EM ( IDEAS ( H[ TO CREATE COMMUNI/ SOCIETY4 ',REVOLUTION>Y IDEOLOGY' NAMES ! REPRES5TATION ( ?IS REVOLUTION>Y !ORY BY /ATE-CAPITALI/ BUREAUCRACY2 ! TRANS=MATION ( REVOLUTION>Y !ORY 9TO A SPECTACLE ?R\< :I* ! LA/ /& ( CAPITAL1 AS /ATE-CAPITAL1 MOM5T>ILY /R5G!NS ITS POSITION BY MASQU]AD+ AS ! V]Y NEGATION ( CAPITAL1 I4E4 AS COMMUNI/ SOCIETY4 ,! DI/9CTION HAS NEV] BE5 MORE APTLY PUT ?AN 9 !SE WORDS ( ,GUY ,DEBORD3 0,REVOLUTION>Y !ORY IS N[ ! 5EMY ( ALL REVOLUTION>Y IDEOLOGY & KN[S IT40 -- ,GUY ,DEBORD1 ,! ,SOCIETY ( ! ,SPECTACLE1 ,B,L,A,C,K ,& ,R,$1 7,DETROIT1 #a#i#g71 LA/ !SIS 9 ,*APT] ,I,V1 0,! ,PROLET>IAT ,AS ,SUBJECT ,& ,AS ,REPRES5TATION04 N#c ,! SLOGAN 0SMA% SELF60 WAS 9TRODUC$ DUR+ ! P]IOD ( ! SO-CALL$ 0,CULTURAL ,REVOLUTION0 9 ,*9A4 ,SEE = 9/ANCE ! PAMPHLET :I* WAS COMPIL$ \T ( 'EXEMPL>Y /ORIES' :I* APPE>$ 9 ! (FICIAL PRESS >\ND ! TIME ( ?AT SPECTACUL> RUKAS1 5TITL$ 7APPROPRIATELY7 0,FE> ,NEI!R ,H>D%IP ,NOR ,DEA? ,9 ,S]V+ ,! ,PEOPLE0 7,=EIGN ,LANGUAGES ,PRESS1 ,PEK+1 #a#i#g71 :I* PAMPHLET DISCUSSES 0! PR9CIPLE ( :OLLY & 5TIRELY S]V+ ! PEOPLE & UTT] DEVOTION TO O!RS )\T ANY ?\Y1 HO/ILE TO EV]Y =M ( 0/ATE04 ,A WELL-KN[N AU?ORITY ON ,M>X' VIEWS DESCRIB$ ! ANTI-/ATE *>ACT] ( ! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE ?USLY3 0,?IS WAS1 !RE=E1 A REVOLUTION NOT AGA9/ ?IS OR ?AT1 LEGITIMATE1 CON/ITUTIONAL1 REPUBLICAN1 OR ,IMP]IALI/ =M ( ,/ATE ,P[]4 ,IT WAS A ,REVOLUTION AGA9/ ! ,/ATE ITSELF1 ( ?IS SUP]NATURALI/ ABORTION ( SOCIETY1 A RESUMPTION BY ! PEOPLE = ! PEOPLE ( ITS [N SOCIAL LIFE4 ,IT WAS NOT A REVOLUTION TO TRANSF] IT FROM ONE FRACTION ( ! RUL+ CLASS TO ! O!R1 BUT A ,REVOLUTION TO BREAK D[N ?IS HORRID MA*9]Y ( ,CLASS DOM9ATION ITSELF4 ,! ,COMMUNE -- ! REABSORPTION ( ! ,/ATE P[] BY SOCIETY AS ITS [N LIV+ =CES 9/EAD ( AS =CES CONTROLL+ & SUBDU+ IT1 BY ! POPUL> MASSES !MSELVES1 =M+ !IR [N =CE 9/EAD ( ! ORGANIZ$ =CE ( !IR [N SUPPRESSION -- ! POLITICAL =M ( !IR SOCIAL EMANCIPATION1 9/EAD ( ! >TIFICIAL =CE 7APPROPRIAT$ BY !IR OPPRESSORS7 7!IR [N =CE OPPOS$ TO & ORGANIZ$ AGA9/ !M7 ( SOCIETY WIELD$ = !IR OPPRESSION BY !IR 5EMIES4 ,! =M WAS SIMPLE LIKE ALL GREAT ?+S4444 ,IT BEG9S ! EMANCIPATION ( LABOR -- ITS GREAT GOAL -- BY DO+ AWAY ) ! UNPRODUCTIVE & MIS*IEV\S WORK ( ! /ATE P>ASITES1 BY CUTT+ AWAY ! SPR+S :I* SACRIFICE AN IMM5SE PORTION ( ! NATIONAL PRODUCE TO ! FE$+ ( ! /ATE-MON/] ON ! ONE SIDE1 BY DO+1 ON ! O!R1 ! REAL WORK ( ADM9I/RATION1 LOCAL & NATIONAL1 = WORK+M5'S WAGES4 ,IT BEG9S1 !RE=E1 ) AN IMM5SE SAV+1 ) ECONOMICAL RE=M AS WELL AS POLITICAL TRANS=MATION40 C#a#h N#b ,SEE ,CITATION #b4 ,EV5 AS E>LY AS ! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE ( #a#h#g#a1 AT A TIME & PLACE :]E ! OBJECTIVE SOCIALIZATION ( ! MEANS ( PRODUCTION HAD NOT PROCE$$ V]Y F> 79 T]MS ( L>GE FACTORIES1 ETC471 ?IS !ORY ( ASSOCIAT$ PRODUCTION HAD BEGUN TO BECOME CONSCI\SLY REVOLUTION>Y PRACTICE4 ,! DOCUM5T QUOT$ BEL[1 A M&ATE FROM TWO LABOR UNIONS = !IR DELEGATES TO ! ,COMMUNE'S ,COMMISSION ON ,LABOR ,ORGANIZATION1 PROPOSES A =M ( :AT W\LD APPE> TO BE C\NCIL-CAPITALISM1 & EMPLOYS ! T]M 0ASSOCIATE0 TO DESIGNATE ! PRODUC]S AFT] !Y HAVE CEAS$ TO BE PROLET>IANS3 0,AT ITS MEET+ ( ,APRIL #b#cRD1 #a#h#g#a1 9 KEEP+ ) ! ,COMMUNE'S DECREE ( ,APRIL #a#f?1 ! ,ME*ANICS ,UNION & ! ,ASSOCIATION ( ,METAL ,WORK]S HAVE DESIGNAT$ TWO CITIZ5S TO ! ,COMMISSION ON ,LABOR ,ORGANIZATION & GIV5 !M ! FOLL[+ 9/RUCTIONS1 0,CONSID]+3 ,?AT ) ! ,COMMUNE1 PRODUCT ( ! ,REVOLUTION ( ,M>* #a#h?1 EQUALITY MU/ NOT BE AN EMPTY WORD2 ,?AT ! VALIANT /RUGGLE TO EXT]M9ATE ! CL]ICAL-ROYALI/S HAS1 AS ITS OBJECTIVE1 \R ECONOMIC EMANCIPATION2 ,?AT ?IS RESULT CAN ONLY BE OBTA9$ ?R\< ! =MATION ( WORK]S' ASSOCIATIONS1 :I* ALONE CAN TRANS=M \R POSITION FROM ?AT ( WAGE-E>N]S TO ?AT ( ASSOCIATES2 0,!RE=E 9/RUCT \R DELEGATES TO SUPPORT ! FOLL[+ OBJECTIVES2 0,! ABOLITION ( ! EXPLOITATION ( MAN BY MAN1 LA/ VE/IGE ( SLAV]Y2 0,! ORGANIZATION ( LABOR 9 MUTUAL ASSOCIATIONS ) COLLECTIVE & 9ALI5ABLE CAPITAL40 C#a#i ,!SIS #di N#a 0,! SPECTACLE SUBJUGATES LIV+ M5 TO ITSELF TO ! EXT5T ?AT ! ECONOMY HAS TOTALLY SUBJUGAT$ !M4 ,IT IS NO MORE ?AN ! ECONOMY DEVELOP+ = ITSELF4 ,IT IS ! TRUE REFLECTION ( ! PRODUCTION ( ?+S1 & ! FALSE OBJECTIFICATION ( ! PRODUC]S40 0,! SPECTACLE )9 SOCIETY CORRESPONDS TO A CONCRETE MANUFACTURE ( ALI5ATION4 ,ECONOMIC EXPANSION IS MA9LY ! EXPANSION ( PRECISELY ?IS 9DU/RIAL PRODUCTION4 ,?AT :I* GR[S ) ! ECONOMY MOV+ = ITSELF CAN ONLY BE ! ALI5ATION :I* WAS PRECISELY AT ITS ORIG940 -- ,GUY ,DEBORD1 ,! ,SOCIETY ( ! ,SPECTACLE1 OP4 CIT41 RESPECTIVELY ,!SES #af & #c#b4 N#b ,IT IS IMPORTANT ABOVE ALL H]E TO NOTE ?AT ?IS 0DICTATOR%IP ( ! PROLET>IAT0 CAN BE NO?+ O!R ?AN ! 9T]NATIONAL P[] ( ! WORK]S' C\NCILS ITSELF4 ,IT IS A DICTATOR%IP ( ! /ILL-PROLET>IAN CLASS OV] ! REMNANTS ( ! B\RGEOISIE & ! BUREAUCRACY1 BECAUSE IT ACTS CO]CIVELY AGA9/ !IR EF=TS TO RE-EXPROPRIATE SOCIAL P[] &1 :5EV] IT 7?AT IS1 ! G5]AL ASSEMBLIES ( ! WORK]S7 DEEMS NECESS>Y1 BY =CE ( >MS4 ,BUT IT IS AN ANTI-/ATE DICTATOR%IP1 ESPECIALLY ) REG>D TO ! SUPPRESSION ( ! /ATE-CAPITALI/ BUREAUCRACY1 ) RESPECT TO :I*1 ! SUPPRESSION ( ! /ATE & ! SUPPRESSION ( ! CLASS >E ONE 9 ! SAME 7IT GOES )\T SAY+ ?AT ! 0SUPPRESSION0 ( A CLASS AS A CLASS1 ITS DE/RUCTION AS SU*1 DOES NOT NECESS>ILY 5TAIL ! 0DE/RUCTION0 OR 0LIQUIDATION0 ( ! 9DIVIDUALS :O COMPOS$ IT2 IT IS ! CLASS DET]M9ATION :I* IS TO BE DET]M9ATELY NEGAT$ H]E1 NOT BIOLOGICAL 9DIVIDUALS1 & SOCIAL RELATIONS CAN NOT BE NEGAT$ )\T 0NEGAT+0 9DIVIDUALS74 ,ON ! CONCEPT ( ! 0ANTI-/ATE01 SEE FIR/ NOTE TO ,!SIS #d#f4 ,9 A LETT] TO ,AUGU/ ,BEBEL 7,M>* #a#h-#b#h1 #a#h#g#e7 ,5GELS 7AS A DELEGATION ( HIMSELF & ,M>X7 GAVE A CRITIQUE ( ! DRAFT PROGRAM ( ! ,UNIT$ ,SOCIAL-,DEMOCRATIC ,WORK]S' ,P>TY ( ,G]MANY4 ,HIS SEV]E CRITICISM1 P>TICUL>LY ( ITS MUDDL$LY /ATI/ ASPECTS1 IS ( MU* SIGNIFICANCE NOT ONLY = ?IS P>TICUL> PROGRAM1 BUT FUR!RMORE IT %$S MU* LID A CORRECT 9T]PRETATION ( VIRTUALLY ALL ( HIS & ,M>X'S WORKS3 0,! :OLE TALK AB\T ! /ATE %\LD BE DROPP$1 ESPECIALLY S9CE ! ,COMMUNE .IS ,COMMUNE ( #a#h#g#a.>1 :I* WAS NO LONG] A /ATE 9 ! PROP] S5SE ( ! WORD4 ,! 'PEOPLE'S /ATE' HAS BE5 ?R[N 9 \R FACES BY ! ,AN>*I/S TO ! PO9T ( DISGU/1 AL?\< ALREADY ,M>X'S BOOK AGA9/ ,PR\DHON .<,! ,POV]TY ( ,PHILOSOPHY.> & LAT] ! ,COMMUNI/ ,MANIFE/O DIRECTLY DECL>E ?AT ) ! 9TRODUCTION ( ! SOCIALI/ ORD] ( SOCIETY ! /ATE WILL DISSOLVE ( ITSELF & DISAPPE>4 ,AS1 !RE=E1 ! /ATE IS ONLY A TRANSITIONAL 9/ITUTION :I* IS US$ 9 ! /RUGGLE1 9 ! REVOLUTION1 TO HOLD D[N ONE'S ADV]S>IES BY =CE1 IT IS PURE NONS5SE TO TALK ( A FREE PEOPLE'S /ATE3 SO LONG AS ! PROLET>IAT /ILL USES ! /ATE1 IT DOES NOT USE IT 9 ! 9T]E/S ( FRE$OM BUT 9 ORD] TO HOLD D[N ITS ADV]S>IES1 & AS SOON AS IT BECOMES POSSIBLE TO SPEAK ( FRE$OM ! /ATE AS SU* CEASES TO EXI/4 ,WE W\LD !RE=E PROPOSE TO REPLACE /ATE EV]Y:]E BY ,GEME9WES51 A GOOD OLD ,G]MAN WORD :I* CAN V]Y WELL CONVEY ! MEAN+ ( ! ,FR5* WORD 'COMMUNE6' 0 C#e#h ,?IS CRITIQUE IS P]HAPS ONE ( ! MO/ IMPORTANT /ATEM5TS EV] MADE BY ,5GELS OR ,M>X4 ,!SIS #eb N#a 0,F9AL0 = B\RGEOIS SOCIETY & = HUMAN PREHI/ORY2 BUT ONLY ! BEG9N+ = HUMAN HI/ORY1 = COMMUNI/ SOCIETY -- ?AT IS1 SOCIALIZ$ HUMANITY4 N#b ,SEE SECOND NOTE TO ,!SIS #g4 ,!SIS #eg N#a ,NOT ?AT WE PREF] ! PSY*$ELIC CRET9S & N\VEAU-,BABBITS ( HIP CAPITALISM 7,B]KELEY HAS PROVID$ AN 9T]E/+ DEVELOPM5T ( !SE RESPECTIVE =MS4 ,H]E !IR AB/RACT UNITY HAS DIGRESS$ 9TO A DISGU/+ SYMBIOSIS BETWE5 ! 0W9N]0 & 0LOS]0 =MS ( ! HIP MOVEM5T'S REMNANTS4 ,?US WE HAVE ! RISE ( ! M]*ANTS ( C\NT]-CULTURE1 :O'S 0SUCCESS0 L>GELY FE$S (F ! CONT9U+ DEG5]ACY ( ! PO/-PSY*$ELIC LUMP5S74 ,!SIS #f N#a ,H]E EV5 ! OLD 0HUMAN NATURE0 >GUM5T -- 9 ALL CASES ! LA/ REC\RSE ( B\RGEOIS IDEOLOGY -- IS TURN$ AGA9/ ITSELF & ! MIS]ABLE CRET9S :O W\LD PROPAGATE IT4 ,!SIS #fa N#a ,SEE ! ?IRD NOTE UND] ,!SIS #c#g4 ,!SIS #fb N#a ,?IS RELATION%IP MIIFI$ 9 T]MS ( A DIALECTICAL SYMBOLIC LOGIC1 ) P1 @9P1 & @9@9P SYMBOLIZ+ /ATES -- /ATES ( AFFAIRS1 /ATES ( SOME SY/EM1 0/ATES ( ! WORLD0 -- OR SYMBOLIZ+ S5T5CES :I* REPRES5T 0/ATEM5TS02 =MULAS AB\T OR =MULATIONS ( !SE /ATES ( AFFAIRS4 ,! TILDA 0@901 ! NEGATION SIGN1 H]E SYMBOLIZES SOME TRANS=MATION1 SOME DET]M9ATE NEGATION1 ( ! S5T5TIAL LETT]S1 SU* AS P1 TO :I* IT IS APPLI$ AS A PREFIX 7! EXACT CONT5T ( ?IS OP]ATOR ?US HAS TO BE SPECIFI$ 9 EA* CASE74 ,?US1 @9@9P IS RELAT$1 BY NEGATION TO @9P & TO P4 ,! D\BLY-SLA%$ EQUALS-SIGN1 _?1 IS H]E EMPLOY$ AS ! SYMBOL = ! RELATION ( DIALECTICAL CONTRADICTION4 ,) P REPRES5T+ ?AT 7SOCIAL7 /ATE ( AFFAIRS *>ACT]IZ$ AS 0N>R[ EGOISM01 @9P REPRES5T+ ! /ATE ( 0ALTRUISM01 & @9@9P 0COMMUNI/ EGOISM01 WE CAN =MULATE ?IS RELATION AS FOLL[S3 7@9@9P _? P7 @& 7@9@9P _? @9P7 @& 7P _? @9P7 OR SIMPLY3 7P _? @9@9P _? @9P7 ,! LATT] TWO CONJUNCTIONS W\LD BE GRANT$ TRU? EV5 BY =MAL LOGIC1 BUT ! FIR/ BELONGS EXCLUSIVELY TO DIALECTICAL LOGIC4 ,ONLY A VE/IGE1 A %AD[ ( ! FIR/ CONJUNCT HOLDS )9 =MAL LOGIC3 0,A S5T5CE & ITS NEGATION >E CALL$ CONTRADICTORIES ( ONE ANO!R4 ,?\< ANY S5T5CE ( ! =M @9O HAS TWO EQUIVAL5T CONTRADICTORIES1 O & @9@9O1 IT HAS BECOME CU/OM>Y TO SPEAK LOOSELY ( '!' CONTRADICTORY ( A S5T5CE40 -- ,B5SON ,MATES1 ,ELEM5T>Y ,LOGIC1 ,OX=D ,UNIV]SITY ,PRESS1 7,NEW ,YORK1 #a#i#g#b74 ,SECOND ,$ITION1 P4 #a#a#94 ,! ABOVE QUOTATION HOLDS = DIALECTICAL LOGIC AS WELL1 EXCEPT ?AT 9 ! CASE ( DIALECTICAL LOGIC1 O & @9@9O W\LD NOT BE EQUIVAL5T1 BUT RA!R W\LD BE ALSO CONTRADICTORIES4 ,WE MIIFY ?IS BY MODEL+ DIALECTICAL LOGIC AS 9VOLV+ NOT M]ELY TWO TRU?-VALUES1 BUT RA!R 7AT LEA/7 ?REE RELAT$ TRU?-/ATES 7REALLY1 AN 9DEF9ITE NUMB] ( NEGATION-RELAT$ TRU?-/ATES -- SEE DOTT$ TRAJECTORY 9 FIGURE #a74 ,WE MID ( 0OPPOSIT5ESS01 I4E41 ! PO9T P' IS MORE OPPOSITE ( @9@9P ?AN P IS1 BUT IT DOES NOT OCCUR IMMAN5TLY1 ?AT IS1 ON ! TRAJECTORY1 & SO IS NOT A CRIT]ION2 @9P IS AN OPPOSITE 7OR CONTRADICTORY7 ( @9@9P 79 ! "4X DIRECTION71 AS WELL AS ( P 7ALSO 9 ! "4X DIRECTION71 & VISE-V]SA1 & SO ON4 ,?US1 P1 @9P1 & @9@9P CORRESPOND1 9 AN APPROXIMATE WAY1 TO ASPECTS (1 RESPECTIVELY1 ! 0!SIS01 0ANTI!SIS01 & 0SYN!SIS0 ( VULG> DIALECTICS4 ,SO UND] !SE DEF9ITIONS ! =MULAS 7#a7 HOLD = ! DEPICTION ( FIGURE #a1 & = !M IT REPRES5TS A VALID 0MODEL0 OR 09T]PRETATION04 ,WE CAN >RIVE AT A =MAL-LOGICAL V]SION ( ?IS MODEL BY R$UCTION1 SPECIFICALLY1 R$UCTION BY ONE DIM5SION 7! Y DIM5SION7 -- YIELD+ A K9D ( 0TOP VIEW0 ( FIGURE #a3 ,! GREAT ADVANTAGE ( ! ,DIALECTICAL ,LOGIC 7,FIG4 #a7 IS SE5 CONCRETELY BY US+ ! 9T]PRETATION3 P3 7!7 0N>R[ EGOISM0 7!ORY7 IS TRUE ( ! WORLD4 @9P3 0ALTRUISM0 IS TRUE ( ! WORLD4 @9@9P3 0COMMUNI/ EGOISM0 IS TRUE ( ! WORLD4 ,! MODEL POSITS P "7@> @9P "7@> @9@9P AS ! C\RSE ( AN EVOLUTION RELAT+ 70CONNECT+07 ! ?REE /ATES4 ,IT C\LD BE 9T]PRET$ AS DEPICT+1 = EXAMPLE1 ! EVOLUTION ( ! SOCIAL 9DIVIDUAL FROM A /ATE ( N>R[ EGOISM TO ONE ( ALTRUISM TO EXP&$ EGOISM1 OR ! EVOLUTION ( A SOCIETY FROM A /ATE *>ACT]IZ$ AS 7BY7 0N>R[ EGOISM0 & 0ALTRUISM0 TO ONE *>ACT]IZ$ AS 0COMMUNI/ EGOISM04 ,H]E 9DE$ P & @9@9P1 0/ACK$0 ONE ON TOP ( ! O!R1 APPE> TO CO9CIDE1 H5CE1 >E 0EQUIVAL5T04 ,! DIM5SION 9 :I* ! SEP>ATION ( P FROM @9@9P OCCURS IS H]E 9VISIBLE4 ,! TRAJECTORY FROM P TO @9P TO @9@9P OR P AGA9 IS H]E M]ELY A VICI\S CIRCLE1 GETT+ NO:]E NEW4 ,IT M]ELY BESPEAKS AN 5DLESS1 9ELUCTABLE ,KANTIAN OSCILLATION )9 ! 0ANTIMONY0 ( N>R[ EGOISM 7P7 V]SUS ALTRUISM 7@9P74 ,! Y DIM5SION MIIABLE 7"7 A /ATE-V>IABLE :OSE MAGNITUDE GR[S MONOTONICALLY ) TIME74 ,) ! ELIM9ATION ( ?IS DIM5SION 7AB/RACTION FROM TIME1 FROM HI/ORY1 FROM CONCRETE DURATION71 ! DEPICTION SUCCE$S AS A MODEL ( ! =MAL LOGIC ( !SE S5T5CES 7P1 @9P1 @9@9P7 & !IR 9T]-MUTUAL RELATIONS4 ,!SIS #ga N#a ,OBJECTIFICATION NAMES ! SPECIFIC QUALITY ( HUMAN PRODUCTION 9 G5]AL4 ,OBJECTIFICATION IS ! MAK+ OBJECTIVE1 ! MAK+ 9TO AN EXT]NAL1 IMM$IATELY OBS]VABLE1 S5SU\SLY MANIFE/ OBJECT1 ( SOME?+ ?AT WAS SUBJECTIVE1 9VISIBLE1 9T]NAL TO ! SUBJECT PRODUC+ ! OBJECTIFICATION4 ,?R\< HIS ACTIVITY1 EV5 IF ?IS ACTIVITY IS ONLY AN 9/ANTLY P]I%ABLE GE/URE1 ! SUBJECT 9SCRIBES HIMSELF 9 ! OBJECTIVE WORLD1 MAKES ! P>T ( IT UPON :I* HE LABORS 9TO A REFLECTION ( HIMSELF2 MAT]IALIZES HIS ?\ ,*RITIANISM0 TO REF] TO ALL ?OSE NON-!OLOGICAL 70SECUL>IZ$07 IDEOLOGIES :I* GREW UP \T ( ! LONG HI/ORICAL DECOMPOSITION ( ,*RI/IANITY1 =M+ ITS SECUL> CONT9UATION1 UP TO & 9CLUD+ ! ,*UR* ( ,L591 & :I* ALL ( !M FEATURE SELF-SACRIFICIAL & MORAL-FETI%I/ SYNDROMES1 C\PL$ ) AN 9T]PRETATION ( HUMAN BEHAVIOR 9 T]MS ( A CONCEPT ( S9 7NO MATT] :AT ?IS CONCEPT HAPP5S TO BE NAM$ 9 A P>TICUL> IDEOLOGICAL V>IANT1 OR :E!R IT IS RECOGNIZ$ AS SU* & NAM$ 9 ?AT P>TICUL> V>IANT AT ALL74 ,9 FACT1 A P>T ( ! 9ITIAL IMPETUS :I* L$ TO ! =MULATION ( ?IS !ORY 7! !ORY ( COMMUNI/ EGOISM7 >OSE FROM ! P]SONAL CONTACT ( SEV]AL ( \R F\ND+ MEMB]S ) ! MALPRACTISE ( ONE ( ! E>LY PRO-,SITUATIONI/ GR\PS 9 ,B]KELEY1 NAM$ 7APPROPRIATELY7 0,CONTRADICTION01 :O BUSI$ !MSELVES PRECISELY ) GO+ >\ND CONDEMN+1 0EXCLUD+0 7EXCOMMUNICAT+71 & 0BREAK+ )0 EV]YONE 9 SII\S ,SITUATIONI/ ANTI-MORALS2 S9S SU* AS 0BE+ B\RGEOIS01 0P>TICIPAT+ 9 SPECTACUL> LIFE01 ETC4 ,! G5]AL NAME = ! 0S90 CONCEPT C5TRAL TO ?IS P>TICUL> BR& ( SECUL> ,*RI/IAN IDEOLOGY WAS 0SEP>ATION0 -- HAV+ 0SEP>ATION0 9 ONE'S DAILY LIFE WAS ! G5]AL =M ( REPROBATE BEHAVIOR4 ,?AT SU* 0SEP>ATIONS0 MILIE/ POSSIBLE OPPORTUNITY1 )\T NE$ ( MORALI/IC CO]CION1 SEEM$ NEV] TO OCCUR TO !SE ,PONTIFFS1 EVID5TLY BECAUSE ( !IR S+UL>LY UNGRE$Y 9VE/M5T 9 SADO-MASO*I/IC TRANSACTIONS4 -- 7CF4 ,N,E,G,A,T,I,O,N1 ,! ,/ATE & ,C\NT]-,REVOLUTION3 ,:AT ,IS ,NOT ,TO ,BE ,DONE1 7,P4,O4 ,BOX #a#b#a#c1 ,B]KELEY4 ,CALI=NIA1 #i#d#g#a71 #a#i#g#b1 P4 #a#a2 ALSO3 ,TOM ,WOODHULL1 0,C\NCIL-,COMMUNISM1 ,WILHELM ,REI*1 ,& ,! ,RIDDLE ( ,MOD]N ,HI/ORY01 ,N,E,W ,M,O,R,N,+1 ,JANU>Y1 #a#i#g#c474 ,!SIS #gi N#a ,IT %\LD BE NO SECRET BY N[ ?AT ! SECRET ( ! ECONOMIC AN*ORAGE ( ! CONCEPT ( ALI5ATION 9 ,M>X IS 9 NONE O!R ?AN ! EXACT1 JURIDICAL-ECONOMIC MEAN+ ( ?AT T]M3 TO 0ALI5ATE0 IS TO SELL2 0ALI5ATION0 IS 0TRANSF] ( PROP]TY02 ! V]Y ACTIVITY ( COMMODITY -- OR 0QUID PRO QUO0 -- EX*ANGE ITSELF4 ,?US ! !ORETICAL COMPREH5SION ( ! ALI5ATION ( MAN 9 CAPITALI/ SOCIETY IS GR\ND$ 9 ! SELF-ALI5ATION ( ! WORK]2 ! FACT ?AT ! PROLET>IAN MU/ SELL HIMSELF TO CAPITAL = A WAGE1 & !REBY =FEIT ALL CONTROL OV] HIS PRODUCTIVE1 CREATIVE LIFE1 & OV] ! OBJECTIVE WORLD :I* HE PRODUCES 9 ! EX]CISE ( ?AT LIFE -- ! FACT ( ! PROLET>IAN'S SELF-DISPOSSESSION4 ,! FACT ( HIS DISPOSSESSION ( ! MEANS ( 7RE7PRODUCTION ( HIS LIFE UND] CAPITALISM IS ?US ONLY A COROLL>Y ( HIS NON-[N]%IP ( HIMSELF 9 PRODUCTION4 ,B\RGEOIS POLITICAL ECONOMY IS ! SCI5CE ( SELL+2 ( ! SOCIAL ACTIVITY ( EX*ANGE-VALUE EX*ANGE & PRODUCTION4 ,IT IS FIR/ ( ALL 9 ?IS S5SE ?AT B\RGEOIS POLITICAL ECONOMY 7&1 = ?AT MATT]1 BUREAUCRATIC 0,M>XI/0 0POLITICAL ECONOMY07 IS 0! SCI5CE ( ALI5ATION40 ,!SIS #hh N#a ,TO AVOID CONFUSION BECAUSE ( ! WAY ! T]M 0MAN0 IS EMPLOY$ 9 ! RE/ ( ! PASSAGE1 WE HAVE ALT]$ ! TRANSLATION H]E1 :I* READ 0! RELATION ( MAN TO WOMAN0 TO READ 0! RELATION ( MALE TO FEMALE04 ,!SIS #hi N#a 0,O,R,G,A,/,I,C ,P,O,T,5,C,Y4 ,ESS5TIALLY1 ! CAPACITY = COMPLETE SURR5D] TO ! 9VOLUNT>Y CONVULSION ( ! ORGANISM & COMPLETE DIS*>GE ( ! EXCITATION AT ! ACME ( ! G5ITAL EMBRACE4 ,IT IS ALWAYS LACK+ 9 NEUROTIC 9DIVIDUALS4 ,IT PRESUPPOSES ! PRES5CE OR E/ABLI%M5T ( ! G5ITAL *>ACT]1 I4E4 ABS5CE ( A PA?OLOGICAL *>ACT] -- >MOR & MUSCUL> >MOR4 ,ORGIA/IC POT5CY IS USUALLY NOT DI/+UI%$ FROM ]ECTIVE OR EJACULATIVE POT5CY1 BO? ( :I* >E ONLY PR]EQUISITES ( ORGIA/IC POT5CY40 -- ,WILHELM ,REI*1 ,! ,FUNCTION ( ! ,ORGASM1 VOL4 ,I ( ,! ,DISCOV]Y ,( ,! ,ORGONE1 ,WORLD ,PUBLI%+ ,COMPANY1 7,NEW ,YORK1 #a#i#g#a71 PP4 #c#f-#c#f#a1 7,GLOSS>Y74 ,!SIS #ia N#a ,?IS IS A BIT ( SY/EMS-!ORY /ATE-SPACE T]M9OLOGY4 0,ATTRACTORS0 >E ! 0RUTS10 ! 0VICI\S CIRCLES0 :]E EVOLUTION GETS HUNG-UP & T>RIES2 :]E EVOLUTION>Y TRAJECTORIES >E 0CAPTUR$01 SOMETIMES = LONG P]IODS4 ,ALL ( ! MAJOR HI/ORICAL SOCIAL-RELATIONS 70MODES ( PRODUCTION02 0=MS ( 9T]C\RSE01 OR 0MEANS ( PRODUCTION0 AS ,M>X SOMETIMES CALLS !M 9 ,! ,GRUNDRISSE7 -- ! PRIMITIVE COMMUNAL1 ! 0ASIATIC01 ! SLAV]Y-BAS$1 ! FEUDAL1 ! CAPITALI/1 ETC41 CAN BE SE5 AS 0ATTRACTORS0 9 SOCIAL EVOLUTION1 ) ! 0ASIATIC0 MODE ( PRODUCTION 70,ORI5TAL DESPOTISM07 REPRES5T+1 AS A HITICUL>LY /RONG 0CAPTURE04 ,SEE ,HANS ,J4 ,BREM]MAN1 0,ON ,! ,DYNAMICS ,& ,TRAJECTORIES ,( ,EVOLUTION>Y ,PROCESSES0 9 ,BIOG5ESIS ,& ,HOMEO/ASIS1 ,SPR+]-,V]LAAG1 #a#i#g#a74 ,!SIS #ib N#a ,REIFICATION NAMES ! 9V]SION ( AB/RACT & CONCRETE -- ! TREAT+ ( AB/RACTIONS AS IF !Y W]E EXT]IOR ?+S1 & MORE SPECIFICALLY1 ! 9V]SION ( SUBJECT & OBJECT -- ! TREAT+ ( OBJECTS OR AB/RACTIONS AS IF !Y W]E SUBJECTS2 ( SUBJECTS AS IF !Y W]E OBJECTS OR AB/RACTIONS4 ,!SIS #ic N#a ,! COMMUNITY ( 0SI/]S0 IS ! SOCIETY ( RADICAL SUBJECTIVITY1 ! CONCRETE UNITY ( SELVES1 ! RESONANCE ( EGOISMS -- TURN$ ON ITS HEAD6 ,H]E LIES ! SUPREME REIFICATION4 ,! W\LD-BE CONCRETE P>TICUL> IS NOT A CONCRETE P>TICUL> 7I4E4 A SUBJECT1 SELF-DET]M9ATELY OBJECTIFI$7 AT ALL1 BUT RA!R ONLY A P>TICUL> CASE ( ! AB/RACT UNIV]SAL 79 ?IS CASE1 0SI/]07444 NO?+ O!R ?AN AN AB/RACTION ( AN AB/RACTION -- CONCRETE 9V]SION1 REIFICATION1 BE+-=-ANO!R2 A MAT]IALIZ$ SELF-SPECTACLE4 ,?IS REIFICATION IS EPITOMIZ$ 9 IDEOLOGICAL MORALISMS ( 0LIB]ATION0 9 0SI/]HOOD01 SU* AS :5 ! SPONTANE\S1 SUBJECTIVE NEGATIVITY BY AN 9DIVIDUAL EGO IS MET ) ! APHORI/IC MORALISM ?AT 0,SI/]S DON'T TREAT EA* O!R ?AT WAY60 ,!SIS #id N#a 0,SUBJECTIFICATION0 79 QUOTES7 IS H]E ! CONTR>Y ( 0OBJECTIFICATION0 79 QUOTES2 SEE ! FOOTNOTE TO ,!SIS #i#a72 IT MEANS NOT ! MAK+ SUBJECTIVE ( ! OBJECTIVE1 AS 9 ! PRODUCTION ( KN[L$GE 709T]NALIZATION ( ! EXT]NAL071 ETC4 BUT RA!R ! MAK+ MORE SUBJECTIVE ( ! PSEUDO-OBJECTIVE2 ( A SUBJECT :O HAS BE5 R$UC$ TO A PSEUDO-OBJECT -- ! RETURN ( SUBJECTIVITY TO ! REAL SUBJECTS1 PREVI\SLY 0DE-SUBJECTIFI$04 N#b ,OBVI\SLY1 ?IS NECESS>ILY 9CLUDES ! SELF-OBJECTIFICATION ( ?IS NEW 9T]-SUBJECTIVITY4 ,!SIS #ab N#a ,:ILE WE CRITICIZE ! USE ( ! T]M 'PR9CIPLE' :5 ?IS USAGE IS A SYMPTOM ( PROJECTION 7SELF-DIS[N+71 AS 9 PHRASES LIKE 0,LET'S LIVE UP TO \R PR9CIPLES01 !RE IS A USAGE ( ! T]M :I*1 WE RECOGNIZE1 ESCAPES ?IS CRITIQUE4 ,?AT IS ! USAGE :]E 'PR9CIPLE' S]VES AS A SYNONYM ( 09V>IANT01 0LAW01 0SECRET01 0KEY01 ETC41 AS 9 0,! PR9CIPLE ( ?IS MA*9E IS4440 OR 0,! PR9CIPLE ( ?IS NATURAL PROCESS IS44401 OR 0,! PR9CIPLE ( ?IS SOCIAL RELATION IS44401 ETC4 ,!SIS #aab N#a ,= A DEF9ITION ( ! T]MS 0CON/ANT CAPITAL0 & 0V>IABLE CAPITAL0 SEE ,K>L ,M>X1 ,CAPITAL3 ,A ,CRITIQUE ( ,POLITICAL ,ECONOMY1 ,VOL4 ,I4 ,9T]NATIONAL ,PUBLI%]S1 7,NEW ,YORK1 #a#i#f#g71 ,*APT] ,V,I,I,I1 P4 #b#i1 ET4 PASSIM4 ,!SIS #aae N#a ,! 0,NATIONAL ,CAUCUS ( ,LABOR ,COMMITTEES0 -- ,N4,C4,L4,C4 -- IS ! MAJOR LEFT DANG] TO ! AU!NTIC REVOLUTION>Y MOVEM5T 9 ! 0,WE/10 N[ Z]O+-9 ON IT = ! KILL FROM ONE SIDE1 AT ! SAME TIME ?AT ! 9CREAS+LY DESP]ATE =CES ( CLASSICAL PRIVATE CAPITALISM1 !MSELVES TURN+ /ATE-CAPITALI/1 Z]O-9 ON IT FROM ! O!R 9 ! CONTEXT ( ! PRES5T1 & RAPIDLY DEEP5+1 G5]AL SOCIAL CRISIS4 ,N4,C4,L4,C4 IS AB\T ! ONLY RELATIVELY LIVE1 DYNAMIC T5D5CY ON ! ,LEFT 9 ! ,U4,S41 ! ONLY ONE :I* IS 9 ANY S5SE CONTEMPOR>Y ) ! PRES5T HI/ORICAL MOM5T1 &1 DESPITE ITS 9CREAS+LY P>ANOID HY/]IA1 IS /ILL LUCID 5\< TO BE ! ONLY ,L59I/ ORGANIZATION ON ! SC5E EV5 POT5TIALLY CAPABLE ( BR++ ! ,/AL9I/ V>IETY 7PURE-BUREAUCRATIC_/B\RGEOIS RUL+-CLASS2 HYBRID1 /ATE_/PRIVATE CAPITAL7 ( /ATE-CAPITALI/ TOTALIT>IANISM TO P[] 9 ! ,U4,S4 ,! ORGANIZATION HAS HAD A METEORIC RISE1 & CONT9UES TO GR[ RAPIDLY4 ,9 TWO REC5T >TICLES ON ! 0PSY*OLOGY0 ( WORK+-CLASS ORGANIZ+ PRACTICE1 >TICLES :I* CONTA9 MANY BRILLIANT DEVELOPM5TS -- SECRETLY BORR[+ MU* FROM ,REI* -- :I* WE MU/ GRE$ILY APPROPRIATE1 ,LYN ,M>CUS1 ! ,FUHR] ( ,N4,C4,L4,C41 REA*ES AN ALMO/ ,MAOI/ 7CF4 QUOTE 9 ! ?IRD NOTE TO ,!SIS #c#g7 PIT* ( PSY*O-PA?OLOGY 9 HIS TYRANT+S ON ! SUBJECT ( GRE$1 SELF-9T]E/1 SELFI%NESS1 ETC43 0,! WILL ( ! WORK] MU/ BECOME ! WILL TO DO ?AT :I* IS 9 ! HI/ORIC 9T]E/ ( ! WORLD'S WORK+ CLASS AS A :OLE1 NO?+ ELSE4 ,IF ! WORK]S PASSIONATELY CL+ TO ANY CONTR>Y S5TIM5T ( IMAG9$ SELF-9T]E/ ?AT S5TIM5T MU/ BE SEIZ$ UPON & RIPP$ \T ( !M4 ,NO HUMAN BE+ HAS ! RICUS1 0,! ,SEXUAL ,IMPOT5CE ,( ,! ,PU]TO ,RICAN ,SOCIALI/ ,P>TY01 ,! ,CAMPAIGN]1 #g3#a1 ,NOVEMB]1 #a#i#g#c1 P4#d#d74 ,SEE ALSO ,LYN ,M>CUS1 0,BEYOND ,PSY*OANALYSIS01 ,! ,CAMPAIGN]1 ,SEPTEMB] -- ,OCTOB] #a#i#g#c1 PP4 #h#h-#h#i1 ET4 PASSIM4 ,I,I4 ,ANNOTATIONS ,!SIS #ac A#a ,WE REALIZE ?AT ?IS EXP&$ CONCEPT ( EX*ANGE MAYBE DIFFICULT TO ACCEPT = A READ] :OSE OBJECTIVE LIFE HAS BE5 DOM9AT$ BY EX*ANGE-VALUE RELATION%IPS4 ,H[EV]1 ! CRITIQUE ( EX*ANGE-VALUE IS NOT TO BE CONFUS$ ) AN AB/RACT OR MORALI/IC NEGATION ( EX*ANGE ITSELF AS SU*4 ,! CONCEPT ( EX*ANGE IS MU* 0BIGG]0 ?AN ! CONCEPT ( EX*ANGE-VALUE -- OR QUID PRO QUO -- EX*ANGE3 ( COMMODITY EX*ANGE-RELATIONS4 ,EX*ANGE-VALUE EX*ANGE IS A TRANSITORY1 AN HI/ORICAL1 DISAPPE>+ NECESSITY4 ,EX*ANGE AS SU*1 H[EV]1 IS A NECESSITY ( SOCIETY 9 G5]AL1 ( SOCIAL EXI/5CE AS SU*1 BO? ) REG>D TO SOCIETY'S RELATIONS TO NATURE & ) REG>D TO ITS SELF-RELATIONS1 ! SOCIAL RELATIONS PROP]3 0,! LABOR-PROCESS444 IS HUMAN ACTION ) A VIEW TO ! PRODUCTION ( USE-VALUES1 APPROPRIATION ( NATURAL SUB/ANCES TO HUMAN REQUIREM5TS2 IT IS ! NECESS>Y CONDITION = EFFECT+ EX*ANGE ( MATT] BETWE5 MAN & ,NATURE2 IT IS ! EV]LA/+ NATURE-IMPOS$ CONDITION ( HUMAN EXI/5CE1 & !RE=E IS 9DEP5D5T ( EV]Y SOCIAL PHASE ( ?AT EXI/5CE1 OR RA!R1 9 COMMON TO EV]Y SU* PHASE40 -- ,K>L ,M>X1 ,CAPITAL1 ,A ,CRITIQUE ,( ,POLITICAL ,ECONOMY1 ,9T]NATIONAL ,PUBLI%]S1 7,NEW ,YORK1 #a#i#f#g71 PP4 #a#h#c-#d4 ,SEE ALSO1 ,K>L ,M>X1 0,FREE ,HUMAN ,PRODUCTION01 9 ,EA/ON & ,GUDDAT1 ,WRIT+S ( ! ,Y\NG ,M>X ,ON ,PHILOSOPHY & ,SOCIETY1 ,D\BL$AY & ,COMPANY1 7,G>D5 ,CITY1 #a#i#f#g71 P4 #b#g#g4 ,EX*ANGE-VALUE IS HI/ORICALLY SPECIFIC TO A C]TA9 PHASE ( ! DEVELOPM5T ( ! SOCIAL PRODUCTIVE =CES 7( ! SOCIAL 9DIVIDUAL73 EX*ANGE 9 G5]AL IS HI/ORICALLY G5]AL1 9DEP5D5T ( ANY GIV5 =M OR /AGE ( HUMAN SOCIETY4 ,EX*ANGE *>ACT]IZES 9 FACT NOT ONLY ! LABOR-PROCESS G5]ALLY1 BUT EV]Y ASPECT ( HUMAN ACTIVITY2 9T]C\RSE ) O!R HUMAN BE+S & ) NATURE4 ,9 FACT1 ALL 9T]ACTION1 SOCIAL & NATURAL1 & ALL LIFE-PROCESSES 9 G5]AL -- CONV]SATION1 D9+1 SEXUAL 9T]C\RSE1 & EV5 0PASSIVE0 CONTEMPLATION ( NATURE -- FALL )9 ?IS EXP&$ CONCEPT ( EX*ANGE -- >E AT ! V]Y LEA/1 0EX*ANGE-(-ACTION04 ,EV5 9 ONE-SID$ GIFT-GIV+2 EV5 :5 SOMEONE GIVES Y\ AN OBJECT & Y\ GIVE NO OBJECT 9 DIRECT RETURN -- LET ALONE AN EX*ANGE-VALUE EQUIVAL5T 9 RETURN -- AN EX*ANGE HAS TAK5 PLACE1 ?\< NOT AN EX*ANGE-VALUE 7COMMODITY7 EX*ANGE2 NOT AN EX*ANGE ( ! SORT :I* REPRODUCES ! LAW ( VALUE4 7,9 CAPITALI/ SOCIETY !RE ALSO EXI/ V>I\S UND]DEVELOP$ =MS OR APPROXIMATIONS ( EX*ANGE-VALUE RELATION%IPS1 E4G4 B>T]+ -- EV5 ! B>T]+ ( 0FAVORS04 ,9 FACT1 QUID PRO QUO -- LIT]ALLY 0?IS = ?AT0 -- IS1 9 A SOCIETY BAS$ ON PRIVATIZ$ SURVIVAL1 A /&>D & A P>ADIGM :I* P]VADES NOT ONLY 0ECONOMIC0 RELATION%IPS AS SU*1 BUT COMES TO DOM9ATE ALL ASPECTS ( SOCIAL LIFE -- 9CLUD+ ! MO/ 09TIMATE0 P]SONAL RELATION%IPS74 ,COMMUNI/ SOCIETY IS 9CONCEIVABLE ) ANY BUT ! MO/ M9IMAL1 M>G9AL SURVIVALS ( EX*ANGE-VALUE EX*ANGE1 BUT IT IS LIKEWISE 9CONCEIVABLE )\T EX*ANGE2 EX*ANGE 9 OBJECTS1 9=MATION1 5]GY1 EXP]I5CE1 ETC4 BETWE5 MAN & MAN & BETWE5 MAN & NATURE -- )\T :AT ,M>X CALLS 0SOCIAL METABOLISM04 ,!SIS #* A#a 0,LETS FACE IT3 HUMAN RELATION%IPS BE+ :AT SOCIAL HI]>*Y HAS MADE ( !M1 IMP]SONALITY IS ! LEA/ TIR+ =M ( CONTEMPT40 7,VANEIGEM1 OP4 CIT1 FOOTNOTE #a1 P4 #c#f74 ,IT WAS A SIMIL> 7?\< MORE ISOLATE7 DISGU/ :I* DROVE ,LUIS ,NADA1 9 ! VAPIDITY ( ! PO/W> YE>S1 TO DECL>E3 0,9 G5]AL1 ,I CONSID] ! HUMAN RACE TO BE A DAILY 9TRUSION ON MY LIFE40 7,QUOT$ FROM ,! ,LIFE & ,TIMES ( ,LUIS ,NADA1 BY ,ANNA VON ,S*TUK1 ,EX ,NIHILO ,PUBLI%]S1 #a#i#g#d1 P4 #b#c#a474 ,!SIS #df A#a 0,G5]ALIZ$ SELF-MANAGEM5T0 IS A T]M :I* HAS BE5 US$ BY ,SITUATIONI/S TO DESCRIBE ! MODE ( PRODUCTION ( COMMUNI/ SOCIETY4 ,IT REF]S TO ! PROCESS :]EBY WE TAKE DIRECTLY 9TO \R [N H&S EV]Y ASPECT ( SOCIAL LIFE4 ,?IS MU/ MEAN ! DET]M9ATE NEGATION ( ,CAPITAL1 COMMODITY PRODUCTION1 & ( ALL SEP>ATE P[]S1 I4E41 ( ALL P[]S O!R ?AN ?AT ( ! ASSOCIAT$ PRODUC]S !MSELVES4 ,EMBRYONIC =MS ( SELF-MANAGEM5T HAVE APPE>$ REPEAT$LY ?R\< MOD]N HI/ORY4 ,ITS V]Y POSSIBILITY WAS FIR/ DEMON/RAT$ 9 ! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE ( #a#h#g#a1 & ?R\<\T ! TW5TIE? C5TURY 9 ! MOVEM5TS ( ! WORK]S' C\NCILS4 ,WORK]S' C\NCILS HAVE >IS5 REPEAT$LY1 USUALLY 9 CRITICAL SITUATIONS :]E ! 9EPTITUDE ( ! PRES5T [N]S ( SOCIETY HAD BE5 CLE>LY & PRACTICALLY DEMON/RAT$4 ,ON SU* OCCASIONS 7,RUSSIA #a#i#e1 ,KRON/ADT #a#i#b#a1 ,SPA9 #a#i#c#f-#c#g1 ETC47 PROLET>IANS HAVE RECOGNIZ$ ?AT !Y'VE BE5 RUNN+ EV]Y?+ ALL ALONG1 & ?AT N[ IT WAS ONLY A MATT] ( RUNN+ EV]Y?+ = !MSELVES4 ,IF G5]ALIZ$ SELF-MANAGEM5T MEANS 0A SOCIETY 9 :I* ! FULL & FREE DEVELOPM5T ( EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL =MS ! RUL+ PR9CIPLE10 C#b IT CAN ALL[ NO ACCOMMODATION TO ANY HI<] AU?ORITY1 FETI%1 OR REIFI$ SOCIAL RELATION%IP4 ,9 ! PA/1 ,SITUATIONI/S HAVE CLE>LY RECOGNIZ$ ?AT ! IMPORTANCE ( SELF-MANAGEM5T IS NOT ONLY ITS =M1 BUT ALSO & DECISIVELY ITS CONT5T -- CLE>LY 0SELF-MANAGEM5T0 ( ! PRES5T WORLD 7I4E4 ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION1 ETC47 IS ( LITTLE 9T]E/ TO A RADICAL SUBJECT4 ,!Y HAVE BE5 9T]E/$ ONLY 9 ! SELF-MANAGEM5T ( ! TOTAL & QUALITATIVE TRANS=MATION ( ! WORLD4 ,WE HAVE S9CE EXP&$ ! DEF9ITION ( G5]ALIZ$ SELF-MANAGEM5T TO 9CLUDE MORE SIDES ( ITS MANIFOLD DIALECTIC4 ,AS WE N[ USE IT1 IT MU/ MEAN NOT ONLY ! MANAGEM5T BY SELVES ( ! WORLD 7& PRESUMABLY ( A WORLD ( M>VELS71 BUT FUR!RMORE IT MU/ MEAN ! MANAGEM5T ( SELF4 ,:AT WE >E TALK+ AB\T IS ! DIALECTICAL UNITY ( SUBJECT & OBJECT :]EBY \R ACTIVITY -- I4E4 \R S5SU\S RELATION%IP ) ! OBJECTIVE WORLD -- BECOMES ! REALIZATION1 I4E4 ACTUALIZATION I4E4 ! OBJECTIFICATION ( \R SUBJECTIVITY -- ( \R SELVES4 ,! MAK+ EXPLICIT ( ALL ?AT WE >E IMPLICITLY4 ,?IS IS L>GELY :AT ,M>X WAS GETT+ AT :5 HE SPOKE ( MAN'S 5VIRONM5T AS HIS 09ORGANIC BODY0 C#b#a4 ,A NECESS>Y MEAN+ ( ,M>X 0,I MU/ BE EV]Y?+0 C#b#b 7EMPHASIS ADD$7 N[ BECOMES CLE> 9 ITS MANY-SID$NESS4 0,WE WANT ! :OLE WORLD TO BE \R CONSCI\S SELF-CREATION0 C#b#c I4E4 NOT ONLY ! CREATION BY BUT ! CREATION ( \R SELVES4 7,?IS CONCEPT IS TO BE FUR!R EXP&$ 9 AN UPCOM+ >TICLE :I* WILL PROBABLY APPE> 9 \R J\RNAL47 ,CLE>LY !RE=E1 ANY =M ( 0SELF-MANAGEM5T0 :I* DOES NOT DECISIVELY PUT AN 5D TO ALL =MS ( COMMODITY PRODUCTION &1 9DE$1 ( LABOR ITSELF1 LOSES ALTOGE!R ?IS SIDE ( ! DIALECTIC4 ,9 A 0SELF-MANAG$0 WORK]S 5T]PRISE 7( E4G4 ! AN>*O-SYNDICALI/ OR ,TITOI/ MODEL71 ! WORK]S AT BE/ MANAGE !IR NON-SELVES1 I4E41 ! PROCESS & ! CONGELATION ( !IR [N ALI5 ACTIVITY 7NON-SELF-MANAGEM5T74 0,G5]ALIZ$ SELF-MANAGEM5T0 9 ITS FULLE/ S5SE MU/ BE ! BREAKD[N NOT ONLY ( ALL SEP>ATE P[]1 BUT ( SEP>ATION P] SE 7LEGAL1 POLITICAL1 SOCIAL1 P]SONAL1 ETC474 ,WE MU/ BE EV]Y?+6 ,?US1 0! PROLET>IANS1 IF !Y >E TO ASS]T !MSELVES AS 9DIVIDUALS1 WILL HAVE TO ABOLI% ! V]Y CONDITION ( !IR EXI/5CE HI!RTO 7:I* HAS1 MOREOV]1 BE5 ?AT ( ALL SOCIETY UP TO ! PRES5T71 NAMELY1 LABOR4 ,?US !Y F9D !MSELVES DIRECTLY OPPOS$ TO ! =M 9 :I*1 HI!RTO1 ! 9DIVIDUALS1 ( :I* SOCIETY CONSI/S1 HAVE GIV5 !MSELVES COLLECTIVE EXPRESSION1 ?AT IS1 ! ,/ATE4 ,9 ORD]1 !RE=E1 TO ASS]T !MSELVES AS 9DIVIDUALS1 !Y MU/ OV]?R[ ! ,/ATE40 C#b#d ,:AT IS G5]ALIZ$ SELF-MANAGEM5T1 0IF NOT ! ABSOLUTE ELABORATION ( . CREATIVE DISPOSITIONS1 )\T ANY PRECONDITIONS O!R ?AN ! ANTEC$5T HI/ORICAL EVOLUTION :I* MAKES ! TOTALITY ( ?IS EVOLUTION1 I4E4 ! EVOLUTION ( ALL HUMAN P[]S AS SU*1 UNMEASUR$ BY ANY PREVI\SLY E/ABLI%$ Y>D/ICK -- AN 5D 9 ITSELF8 ,:AT IS ?IS1 IF NOT A SITUATION :]E MAN DOES NOT REPRODUCE HIMSELF 9 ANY DET]M9$ =M1 BUT PRODUCES HIS TOTALITY8 ,:]E HE DOES NOT SEEK TO REMA9 SOME?+ =M$ BY ! PA/1 BUT IS 9 ! ABSOLUTE MOVEM5T ( BECOM+80 C#b#e ,:AT IF NOT ALL ! WORLD AS ! REALIZATION ( \R PASSIONS8 ,!SIS #ec A#a ,MAX ,/IRN]4 ,!SIS #ge A#a ,?AT IS TO SAY1 !Y CANNOT BE B\R[ REALM ( CORRUPTIONS ,I NORMALLY (F]$4 ,WE >E ! LA/ TO D5Y ?AT 0EV]Y MAN HAS HIS PRICE40 ,BUT JU/ AS ,HEGEL DEMON/RAT$ ?AT M]E QUANTITATIVE DIFF]5CES CAN1 PA/ A C]TA9 PO9T1 ACTUALLY BECOME QUALITATIVE *ANGES1 SO ! RADICAL SUBJECT ESCALATES HIS PRICE SO HI< ?AT IT F9ALLY TRANSC5DS ALTOGE!R ! REALM ( EX*ANGE-VALUE1 & = ?AT MATT]1 ( ALL P>TIAL APPROPRIATIONS4 ,!SIS #h A#a ,?IS DOES NOT AT ALL MEAN1 = ,M>X1 ?AT PRODUCTIVE ACTIVITY CANNOT BECOME PLEASURABLE1 ATTRACTIVE1 SELF-REALIZ+ ACTIVITY4 ,IT ONLY MEANS ?AT WORK CANNOT BECOME 0PLAY0 9 ! S5SE ( FRIVOL\S PLAY 9 CLASS SOCIETIES1 :]E ! SUBJECT'S SURVIVAL IS NOT IMM$IATELY AT /AKE 9 HIS ACTIVITY1 I4E4 :]E HIS SURVIVAL IS GU>ANTE$ BY ! PRODUCTIVE ACTIVITY ( O!RS & :]E HIS ACTIVITY IS CONF9$ TO A SEQUE/]$ ZONE & SPECIALIZ$ SOCIAL CATEGORY 0PLAY0 :I* IS NOT ALL[$ TO OV]SPILL 9TO 0S]I\S0 SOCIAL PRODUCTION PROP]4 0,WORK0 ACTIVITY ?US HAS AN ASPECT ( CONSCI\S NECESSITY1 DANG]1 :I* FRIVOL\S 0PLAY0 ACTIVITY LACKS4 ,?IS 9DICATES H[ ! RESOLUTION ( ! PRES5T CONTRADICTION BETWE5 0WORK0 & 0LEISURE01 OR 0PRODUCTION0 & 0CONSUMPTION01 CANNOT TAKE ! =M ( ONE-SID$LY EMBRAC+ ! ANTI!SIS ( WORK1 0PLAY01 BUT ONLY ( ! UNIT>Y NEGATION ( BO? -- ?AT IS1 ! NEGATION ( !IR CONTRADICTION ITSELF2 !IR SYN!SIS3 FREE CREATIVE ACTIVITY1 OR 0FREE HUMAN PRODUCTION04 ,!RE IS ANO!R PASSAGE 9 ,! ,GRUNDRISSE :]E9 ,M>X SEEMS TO PASS OV] ! SAME REGION ( HIS CONCEPTUAL MANIFOLD1 ) SLI FROM 7,ADAM.> ,SMI?'S ?\ACT] ( M]E NATURAL NECESSITIES & >E E/ABLI%$ AS PURPOSES :I* ! 9DIVIDUAL HIMSELF FIXES4 ,! RESULT IS ! SELFREALIZATION & OBJECTIFICATION ( ! SUBJECT1 !RE=E REAL FRE$OM1 :OSE ACTIVITY IS PRECISELY LABOR4 ,( C\RSE HE IS CORRECT 9 SAY+ ?AT LABOR HAS ALWAYS SEEM$ TO BE REPULSIVE1 & =C$ UPON ! WORK] FROM ! \TSIDE1 9 ITS HI/ORICAL =M ( SLAVE-LABOR1 BOND-LABOR1 & WAGE-LABOR1 & ?AT 9 ?IS S5SE NON-LABOR C\LD BE OPPOS$ TO IT AS LIB]TY & HAPP9ESS'4 ,?IS IS D\BLY TRUE ( ?IS CONTRADICTORY LABOR :I* HAS NOT YET CREAT$ ! SUBJECTIVE & OBJECTIVE CONDITIONS 7:I* IS LO/ :5 IT AB&ON$ PA/ORAL CONDITIONS7 :I* MAKE IT 9TO ATTRACTIVE LABOR & 9DIVIDUAL SELF-REALIZATION4 ,?IS DOES NOT MEAN ?AT LABOR CAN BE MADE M]ELY A JOKE1 AS ,F\RI] NAIVELY EXPRESS$ IT 9 %OP-GIRL T]MS4 ,REALLY FREE LABOR1 ! COMPOS+ ( MUSIC = EXAMPLE1 IS AT ! SAME TIME DAMN$ S]I\S & DEM&S ! GREATE/ EF=T4 ,! LABOR CONC]N$ ) MAT]IAL PRODUCTION CAN ONLY HAVE ?IS *>ACT] IF 7#a7 IT IS ( A SOCIAL NATURE1 7#b7 IT HAS A SCI5TIFIC *>ACT] & AT ! SAME TIME IS UNIV]SAL LABOR1 I4E4 IF IT CEASES TO BE HUMAN EF=T AS A DEF9ITE1 TRA9$ NATURAL =CE1 GIVES UP ITS PURELY NATURAL1 PRIMITIVE ASPECTS & BECOMES AN ACTIVITY ( A SUBJECT CONTROLL+ ALL ! =CES ( NATURE 9 ! PRODUCTION PROCESS4 ,MOREOV]1 ,A4 ,SMI? IS ?9K+ ONLY ( ! SLAVES ( CAPITAL4 ,= EXAMPLE1 EV5 ! SEMI->TI/IC WORK]S ( ! ,MIDDLE ,AGES CANNOT BE 9CLUD$ 9 HIS DEF9ITION40 -- ,K>L ,M>X1 0,GRUNDRISSE D] ,KRITIK D] ,POLITI%5 ,OKONOMIE10 CF4 ,NICOLAUS1 ,P5GU91 #a#i#g#c1 P4 #f#a#a-#f#a#b1 & ,DAVID ,MC,LELLAN1 ,H>P] @& ,R[1 #a#i#g#a1 P4 #a#b#d4 ,M>X & ,5GELS E>LY ON REF]R$ TO ?IS TRANSITION FROM UNFREE TO FREE MODES ( HUMAN PRODUCTIVE ACTIVITY AS ! ABOLITION ( LABOR' -- 0,AUFHEBUNG D] ,>BEIT0 -- SEE ,! ,G]MAN ,IDEOLOGY1 ,PROGRESS ,PUBLI%]S1 #a#i#f#h1 PP4 #g1 #g#g1 #h#f1 #i#f1 #b#b#d1 #b#d1 & FOOTNOTE P4 #g4 ,!SIS #hg A#a ,! IDEOLOGY ( HIPPIE-SLOBBISM WILL F9D NO ASYLUM H]E4 ,!SIS #ia A#a ,?IS IS 0OBJECTIFY0 NOT US$ 9 ! S5SE ( ! SUBJECT :O 9SCRIBES HIMSELF 9 ! OBJECTIVE WORLD ?R\< HIS ACTIVITY2 EXPRESSES HIS SUBJECTIVITY 9 OBJECTS & OBJECTIVE /ATES-(-!-WORLD HE CREATES1 BUT 9 ! S5SE ( ! SUBJECT :O IS TREAT$ LIKE A ?+2 TURN$ 9TO A PSEUDO-OBJECT4 ,!SE TWO S5SES >E ?US ALMO/ EXACTLY OPPOSITE4 ,?R\<\T1 WE 9DICATE ?IS SECOND USAGE BY 5CLOS+ ! WORD 9 D\BLE QUOTES1 TO DI/+UI% IT FROM ! UNQUOT$ USAGE4 ,!SIS #ic A#a ,H]E AGA9 ! S5SE ( OBJECTIFI$ DIFF]S FROM \R NORMAL USAGE1 :I* IS ! REASON WE PUT QUOTES >\ND IT4 ,SEE ! ANNOTATION TO ,!SIS #i#a4 ,!SIS #aab A#a ,9 SOME CASES !SE R&OM MASS KILL]S PROVE TO BE NOT ONLY ! MO/ APP>5T EXTREMITY ( ! W> ( ALL AGA9/ ALL1 BUT ALSO A CONSCI\S SELF-CRITIQUE ( IT4 ,9 MANY CASES ! ACTIVE NIHILI/ DELIB]ATELY & CONSCI\SLY EPITOMIZES EV]Y?+ HE HATES4 ,!SIS #aaf A#a ,IF Y\ DON'T KN[ BY N[ ?AT N>R[ EGOISM IS SELF-D5IAL1 Y\ MIE EXPROPRIAT$40 -- ,K>L ,M>X1 ,CAPITAL1 ,A ,CRITIQUE ( ,POLITICAL ,ECONOMY1 ,VOL4 ,I1 ,9T]NATIONAL ,PUBLI%]S1 #a#i#f#g1 P4 #g#f#c1 EMPHASIS \RS4 ,!SIS #a C#b ,! PHRASES 0! ASSOCIAT$ PRODUC]S01 0FREE & ASSOCIAT$ LABOR01 OR 0! ASSOCIAT$ WORK]S01 OCCUR AGA9 & AGA9 ?R\<\T ,M>X' WORKS :5 HE SEEKS TO NAME OR *>ACT]IZE ! SOCIAL RELATION ( PRODUCTION ( COMMUNI/ SOCIETY3 ASSOCIATION ITSELF4 ,?IS IS SOME?+ ?AT ,L59I/S ( EV]Y V>IETY SCRUPUL\SLY AVOID M5TION+ =1 ) ALL !IR TALK ( ! 0SOCIALI/ /ATE0 & 0WORK]S' GOV]NM5TS01 ETC4 !Y W\LD MU* RA!R ALL ?IS BE CONV5I5TLY =GOTT54 ,NO MORE APT PHRASE C\LD BE CONTRIV$ TO NAME & DESCRIBE ! MANAGEM5T ( SOCIETY AS A SY/EM ( WORK]S' C\NCILS ?AN PRECISELY 0! ASSOCIAT$ PRODUC]S04 ,A FEW SELECT$ CITATIONS ( REPRES5TATIVE PASSAGES :]E ?IS DESCRIPTION OCCURS1 >E LI/$ BEL[3 ,K>L ,M>X1 ,CAPITAL1 ,A ,CRITIQUE ( ,POLITICAL ,ECONOMY1 ,VOL4 #a1 ,9T]NATIONAL ,PUBLI%]S1 7,NEW ,YORK1 #a#i#f#g74 P4 #h2 VOL4 ,I,I,I1 P4 #d#c#g1 P4 #f#g1 P4 #d#d#g4 ,DAVID ,MC,LELLAN4 ,! ,GRUNDRISSE1 7,H>P] & ,R[1 #a#i#g#a7 PP4#a#e#b4 ,K>L ,M>X1 ,CAPITAL 7,VOL4 ,I,V73 ,!ORIES ( ,SURPLUS ,VALUE 7,P>T ,I,I,I71 ,PROGRESS ,PUBLI%]S 7,MOSC[1 #a#i#g#a7 P4 #b#g#c4 ,K>L ,M>X1 0,WRIT+S ON ! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE0 9 ,! ,CIVIL ,W> 9 ,FRANCE 7,FIR/ ,DRAFT71 ,HAL ,DRAP]1 ,$ITOR1 ,MON?LY ,REVIEW ,PRESS1 #a#i#g#a1 P4 #a#e#e4 ,K>L ,M>X1 0,9/RUCTIONS ,= ,! ,DELEGATES ( ,! ,PROVISIONAL ,G5]AL ,C\NCIL3 ,! ,DIFF]5T ,QUE/IONS0 _?#e3 0,COOP]ATIVE ,LABOR04 P4 #ha 9 ,K>L ,M>X & ,FR$]ICK ,5GELS1 ,SELECT$ ,WORKS1 ,VOLUME #b1 ,PROGRESS ,PUBLI%]S1 7,MOSC[1 #a#i#f#i74 ,K>L ,M>X1 0,! ,NATIONALIZATION ( ,! ,L&40 P4 #b#i1 IBID4 ,!SIS #aa C#c ,K>L ,M>X1 0,ECONOMIC & ,PHILOSOPHICAL ,MANUSCRIPTS0 9 ,T4,B4 ,BOTTOMORE1 ,K>L ,M>X1 ,E>LY ,WRIT+S1 ,MC,GRAW-,HILL1 7,NEW ,YORK1 #a#i#f#c71 P4 #a#e#e4 C#d ,?IS IS ,M>X' E>LY T]M = :AT HE LAT] CALLS ! 0SOCIAL RELATIONS ( PRODUCTION04 ,SEE3 ,K>L ,M>X & ,FR$]ICK ,5GELS1 ,! ,G]MAN ,IDEOLOGY1 ,PROGRESS ,PUBLI%]S1 7,MOSC[4 #a#i#f#h71 PP4 #h#i1 #i#b1 ETC4 ,!SIS #ac C#e ,K>L ,M>X1 ,! ,GRUNDRLSSE1 9 0,PRE-,CAPITALI/ ,ECONOMIC ,=MATIONS1' ,HOBSBAWN & ,COH51 TRANSLATORS & $ITORS1 ,9T]NATIONAL ,PUBLI%]S1 7,NEW ,YORK1 #a#i#f#e71 P4 #h#d4 ,!SIS #ad C#f ,K>L ,M>X1 0,MONEY & ,ALI5AT$ ,MAN01 9 ,EA/ON & ,GUDDAT1 ,WRIT+S ,( ,! ,Y\NG ,M>X ,ON ,PHILOSOPHY ,& ,SOCIETY1 ,D\BL$AY 7,G>D5 ,CITY1 #a#i#f#g71 PP4 #b#g#a-#b#g#b4 ,!SIS #ae C#g ,SITUATIONI/ ,9T]NATIONAL 7,MU/APHA ,KHAYATI1 ET4 AL71 0,ON ! ,POV]TY ( ,/UD5T ,LIFE0 7PUBLI%$ BY ,B,L,A,C,K ,& ,R,$1 ,P4,O4 ,BOX #i#e#d#f1 ,DETROIT1 ,MI*41 #d#h#b#b7 P4#b#d4 ,!SIS #ba C#h ,K>L ,M>X1 ,!ORIES ,( ,SURPLUS ,VALUE1 ,P>T ,I,I,I1 7,VOL4 ,I,V ( ,CAPITAL71 ,PROGRESS ,PUBLI%]S 7,MOSC[1 #a#i#g#a71 P4 #d#b#i4 ,!SIS #bc C#i ,K>L ,M>X1 ,ECONOMIC & ,PHILOSOPHICAL ,MANUSCRIPTS ( #afdd 7\R TRANSLATION7 CF4 ,T4,B4 ,BOTTOMORE1 OP4 CIT4 P4 #aeh & ,EA/ON & ,GUDDAT1 OP4 CIT4 PP4 #c#f-#c#g4 ,!SIS #bd C#a ,RA\L ,VANEIGEM1 ,TREATISE ,ON ,LIV+ ,= ,! ,USE ( ! ,Y\NG ,G5]ATION 7,5GLI% TRANSLATION ( P>T ,I AVAILABLE FROM ,BUREAU ( ,PUBLIC ,SECRETS1 ,P4,O4 ,BOX #a#d#d1 ,B]KELEY1 ,CALIPH41 #i#d#g#a7 P4 #d#e-#d#f4 ,!SIS #be C#a#a ,K>L ,M>X1 ,BRUNO ,BAU]1 ,DIE ,JUD5FRAGE1 9 ,T4,B4 ,BOTTOMORE1 OP4 CIT41 PP4 #b#d-#b#e4 ,!SIS #bf C#a#b ,RA\L ,VANEIGEM1 OP4 CIT41 P4 #a#a4 ,!SIS #c C#a#c ,HE9Z VON ,FO]/]1 0,LOGICAL ,/RUCTURE ( ,5VIRONM5T & ITS ,9T]NAL ,REPRES5TATION01 9 ,PROCE$+S ( ! #aifb ,DESIGN ,CONF]5CE1 ,ASP51 ,COLORADO1 ,R4,E4 ,ECK]/ROM1 $ITOR1 7,H]MAN ,MILL]1 #a#i#f#c74 ,!SIS #ce C#a#d ,K>L ,M>X1 0,FREE ,HUMAN ,PRODUCTION10 9 ,EA/ON & ,GUDDAT1 OP4 CIT41 P4 #b#h#a3 0,SUPPOSE WE HAD PRODUC$ ?+S AS HUMAN BE+S3 9 HIS PRODUCTION EA* ( US W\LD HAVE TWICE AFFIRM$ HIMSELF & ! O!R4444 ,I W\LD HAVE BE5 ! M$IATOR BETWE5 Y\ & ! SPECIES & Y\ W\LD HAVE EXP]I5C$ ME AS A RE9TEGRATION ( Y\R [N NATURE & A NECESS>Y P>T ( Y\R SELF44440 ,!SIS #cf C#a#e ,IBID4 ,!SIS #d C#a#f ,AYN ,R&1 ,! ,VIRTUE ( ,SELFI%NESS2 ,A ,NEW ,CONCEPT ( ,EGOISM1 ,NEW ,AM]ICAN ,LIBR>Y1 7,NEW ,YORK1 #a#i#f#e71 ET4 PASSIM4 ,CAPITALISM3 ,! ,UNKN[N ,IDEAL1 ,NEW ,AM]ICAN ,LIBR>Y1 7,NEW ,YORK1 #a#i#f#d74 ,!SIS #db C#a#g ,MAX ,/IRN]1 ,! ,EGO ,& ,HIS ,[N1 ,LIB]T>IAN ,BOOK ,CLUB1 7,NEW ,YORK1 #a#i#f#c71 P4 #e1 9 0,ALL ,?+S ,>E ,NO?+ ,TO ,ME04 ,!SIS #df ,CITATIONS #b-#b#e >E F\ND 9 ANNOTATION #a ( ,!SIS #d#f4 C#a#h ,K>L ,M>X & ,FR$]ICK ,5GELS1 0,WRIT+S ,ON ,! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE0 7FROM ! FIR/ DRAFT1 BY ,M>X1 ( ,! ,CIVIL ,W> ,9 ,FRANCE71 ,HAL ,DRAP]1 $ITOR1 PP4 #a#e-#a#e#d4 ,SEE ALSO3 ,K>L ,M>X4 ,! ,CIVIL ,W> ,9 ,FRANCE3 ,! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE1 ,9T]NATIONAL ,PUBLI%]S 7,NEW ,YORK1 #a#i#f#h71 PP4 #e#d-#f#a1 ESPECIALLY P4 #e#h4 ,SEE ALSO3 ,GUY ,DEBORD1 ,SOCIETY ,( ,! ,SPECTACLE1 ,B,L,A,C,K ,& ,R,$ 7,P4,O4 ,BOX #i#e#d#f4 ,DETROIT1 ,MI*IGAN1 #d#h#b#b71 7,DETROIT1 #a#i#g71 !SIS ,NO4 #agi 9 ,*APT] ,V,I,I 0,! ,ORGANIZATION ( ,T]RITORY04 ,SEE ALSO3 0,SITUATIONI/ ,9T]NATIONAL ,NO4 #a01 ,REVIEW ( ! ,AM]ICAN ,SECTION1 ,JUNE1 #a#i#f#i1 P4 #b#g4 ,SEE ALSO3 ,RA\L ,VANEIGEM1 ,NOTICE ,TO ,! ,CIVILIZ$ ,CONC]N+ ,G5]ALIZ$ ,SELF-,MANAGEM5T4 C#a#i ,EUG5E ,S*ULK9D1 ,! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE ( #a#h#g#a3 ,VIEW ,FROM ,! ,LEFT1 ,JONA?AN ,CAPE1 7,LONDON4 #a#i#g#b71 P4 #a#f#d4 .<,! DOCUM5TATION CONTA9$ 9 ?IS BOOK ( ! SOCIALI/ T5D5CIES )9 ! ,COMMUNE1 & ! 9FLU5CE !RE9 ( ! ,FIR/ ,9T]NATIONAL1 >E1 9 G5]AL1 A/\ND+ RELATIVE TO :AT HAS BE5 AVAILABLE BE=E & QUITE ?RILL+4.> C#b ,K>L ,M>X1 ,CAPITAL1 ,A ,CRITIQUE ( ,POLITICAL ,ECONOMY1 OP4 CIT41 P4 #e#i#b4 ,VOL4 ,I4 C#b#a ,K>L ,M>X1 ,ECONOMIC & ,PHILOSOPHIC ,MANUSCRIPTS ( #a#h#d#d1 ,9T]NATIONAL ,PUBLI%]S1 7,NEW ,YORK1 #a#i#f#d71 ET4 PASSIM4 9 ! *APT] 0,E/RANG$ ,LABOR0 SEE ALSO ,PRE-,CAPITALI/ ,ECONOMIC ,=MATIONS1 OP4 CIT41 P4 #h#e-#i#i :]E ?IS CONCEPT IS DEVELOP$ CONSID]ABLY4 C#b#b ,K>L ,M>X2 SEE ,CITATION #d2 SEE ,!SIS #g#h4 C#b#c ,= ,\RSELVES1 0,PREAMBLE ,TO ,! ,F\ND+ ,AGREEM5TS0 7SEE ,APP5DIX74 C#b#d ,K>L ,M>X1 ,FR$]ICK ,5GELS1 ,! ,G]MAN ,IDEOLOGY1 7,PROGRESS ,PUBLI%]S1 ,MOSC[ OR 9T]NATIONAL ,PUBLI%]S1 ,NEW ,YORK7 CLOS+ L9E ( ,P>T ,ONE4 ,9 ONE $ITION 7,! ,G]MAN ,IDEOLOGY1 ,P>T ,ONE1 ) SELECTIONS FROM ,P>TS ,TWO1 ,P>T ,?REE1 & ,SUPPLEM5T>Y ,TEXTS4 ,NEW ,WORLD ,PAP]BACKS1 ,NEW ,YORK1 #a#i#g7 ! TEXT IS >RANG$ SOME:AT DIFF]5TLY & ! PASSAGE APPE>S ON P4 #h#e4 C#b#e ,K>L ,M>X1 ,! ,GRUNDRISSE 9 0,PRE-,CAPITALI/ ,ECONOMIC ,=MATIONS10 LOC4 CIT41 P4 #i#f4 ,!SIS #dh C#b#f ,K>L ,M>X1 ,GRUNDRISSE 9 0,PRE-,CAPITALI/ ,ECONOMIC ,=MATIONS10 LOC4 CIT41 P4 #i#f4 ,!SIS #di C#b#g ,9 ! WORDS ( ,FR$]ICK ,5GELS3 0,LOOK AT ! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE4 ,?AT WAS ! ,DICTATOR%IP ( ! ,PROLET>IAT60 7,K>L ,M>X1 ,! ,CIVIL ,W> 9 ,FRANCE3 ,! ,P>IS ,COMMUNE1 OP4 CIT41 P4 #b#b1 CLOS+ L9E ( ! 9TRODUCTION BY ,FR$]ICK ,5GELS47 C#b#h ,K>L ,M>X1 ,! ,CIVIL ,W> ,9 ,FRANCE1 OP4 CIT41 P4 #f#a4 C#b#i ,K>L ,M>X1 ,CAPITAL1 ,A ,CRITIQUE ,( ,POLITICAL ,ECONOMY1 VOL4 ,I1 OP4 CIT41 P4 #g#f#c4 ,!SIS #ec C#c ,K>L ,M>X & ,FR$]ICK ,5GELS1 ,! ,G]MAN ,IDEOLOGY1 OP4 CIT41 P4 #b#g#b4 ,!SIS #$ C#c#a ,K>L ,M>X1 0,ECONOMIC & ,PHILOSOPHICAL ,MANUSCRIPTS01 9 ,T4,B4 ,BOTTOMORE1 OP4 CIT41 P4 #aeb 79 0,PRIVATE ,PROP]TY ,& ,COMMUNISM074 C#c#b ,SITUATIONI/ ,9T]NATIONAL1 0,ON ,! ,POV]TY ,( ,/UD5T ,LIFE01 OP4 CIT41 P4 #a4 ,!SIS #fc C#c#c ,K>L ,M>X & ,FR$]ICK ,5GELS1 0,MANIFE/O ( ! ,COMMUNI/ ,P>TY01 9 ,LEWIS ,FEU]1 ,M>X @& ,5GELS1 ,BASIC ,WRIT+S ,ON ,POLITICS ,& ,PHILOSOPHY1 ,D\BL$AY1 7,NEW ,YORK1 #a#i#e#i71 P4 #b#i4 ,!SIS #fd C#c#d ,RA\L ,VANEIGEM1 ,TRAITE DO ,SAVOIR-,VIV] A L',USAGE DES ,JEUNES ,G5]ATIONS1 ,GALLIM>D1 7,P>IS1 #a#i#f#g71 ,P4 #b4 . ,!SIS #ff C#c#e ,K>L ,M>X1 0,ECONOMIC & ,PHILOSOPHICAL ,MANUSCRIPTS4' 9 ,T4,B4 ,BOTTOMORE1 OP4 CIT41 PP4 #a#f#d1 #a#f#e4 ETC4 7SEE ALSO ,!SIS #fi & ,!SIS #h#h74 ,!SIS #fi C#c#f ,K>L ,M>X1 0,ECONOMIC & ,PHILOSOPHICAL ,MANUSCRIPTS4' 9 ,T4,B4 ,BOTTOMORE1 LOC4 CIT41 PP4 #a#f#d-#a#f#e1 7,MANUSCRIPT ,I,I,I2 0,PRIVATE ,PROP]TY & ,COMMUNISM074 ,!SIS #g C#c#g ,K>L ,M>X1 ',MONEY & ,ALI5AT$ ,MAN10 9 ,EA/ON & ,GUDDAT1 OP4 CIT41 P4 #b#g#b4 ,!SIS #gd C#c#h ,RA\L ,VANEIGEM1 ,TRAITS DE ,SAVOIR-,VIV] A L',USAGE DES ,JEUNES ,G5]ATIONS1 OP4 CIT41 ,*APT] #b#c3 0,! ,UNIT>Y ,TRIAD3 ,REALIZATION -- ,COMMUNICATION -- ,P>TICIPATION02 ,SECTION #c -- 0,RADICAL ,SUBJECTIVITY01 PP4 #b#e#e-#b#e#h1 & PASSIM4 .<,AN ,5GLI% TRANSLATION ( ?IS SECTION ( ?IS *APT] IS AVAILABLE FROM ,R,E-,9,V,5,T,I,O,N ,( ,E,V,],Y,D,A,Y ,L,I,F,E1 ,P4,O4 ,BOX #b#h#b1 ,PALO ,ALTO1 ,CALI=NIA1 #i#d#c#b.>4 ,!SIS #gg C#c#i ,K>L ,M>X1 ,GRUNDRISSE3 ,F\NDATIONS ( ! ,CRITIQUE ( ,POLITICAL ,ECONOMY 7,R\< ,DRAFT701 TRANSLAT$ BY ,M>T9 ,NICOLAUS1 ,P5GU91 7,LONDON1 #a#i#g#c71 PASSIM4 ,!SIS #< C#d ,K>L ,M>X1 ,CONTRIBUTION ,TO ,! ,CRITIQUE ( ,HEGEL'S ,PHILOSOPHY ,( ,RI4 ,!SIS #h C#d#a ,K>L ,M>X1 ,! ,GRUNDRISSE1 TRANSLAT$ & $IT$ BY ,DAVID ,MC,LELLAN1 ,H>P] @& ,R[4 7,SAN ,FRANCISCO1 #a#i#g#a74 ,PAGES #a#d#h-#a#d#i4 CF4 ,K>L ,M>X1 ,! ,GRUNDRISSE1 TRANSLAT$ BY ,M>T9 ,NICOLAUS1 OP4 CIT41 PP4 #g#a#a-#g#a#b4 ,NICOLAUS1 9 TRUE ,MAOI/ GRAY-LIFE FA%ION1 TRANSLATES ! ,G]MAN 0,G5USS0 & 0,G5USSES01 :I* ,MC,LELLAN TRANSLATES AS 0PLEASURE0 & 05JOYM5T01 AS 0CONSUMPTION40 ,HE HAS 9DE$ PRODUC$1 AS BE/ AS CAN BE1 ! /ATE-CAPITALI/ TRANSLATION ( ! ,GRUNDRISSE1 AS IS EVID5C$ ALSO 9 HIS R5D]+ ( AG] PUBLICUS 70COMMON L&'1 CF4 ,HOBSBAWM @& ,COH52 ,K>L ,M>X1 0,PRE-,CAPITALI/ ,ECONOMIC ,=MATIONS01 OP4 CIT41 P4 #f#g7 9TO 0,/ATE PROP]TY0 7SEE P4 #d#g#a1 FOOTNOTE #f#b74 ,!SIS #ha C#d#b ,SITUATIONI/ ,9T]NATIONAL1 0,ON ,! ,POV]TY ,( ,/UD5T ,LIFE01 OP4 CIT41 P4 #b#d1 7SEE ,!SIS #ae = FULL QUOTE74 ,!SIS #hd C#d#c ,K>L ,M>X1 0,ECONOMIC & ,PHILOSOPHICAL ,MANUSCRIPTS01 9 ,T4,B4 ,BOTTOMORE1 LOC4 CIT41 P4 #a#f#g4 ,!SIS #hh C#d#d ,IBID41 P4 #a#e#d4 ,!SIS #ib C#d#e ,SIGMUND ,FREUD1 ,CIVILIZATION & ITS ,DISCONT5TS1 ,HOG>? ,PRESS1 7,LONDON1 #a#i#d#i71 PP4 #g#i-#h4 ,!SIS #ih C#d#f ,RA\L ,VANEIGEM1 ,TRAITE DE ,SAVOIR-,VIV] A L',USAGE DES ,JEUNES ,G5]ATIONS1 OP4 CIT41 .E OBTA9ABLE FROM ,SOLID>ITY ,BOOK%OP1 #gac ,>MITAGE1 ,*ICAGO1 ,ILL9OIS1 #f#f#a#d1 & V]Y SOON ! 5TIRE TEXT WILL BE AVAILABLE FROM ,TOM ,WOODHULL1 ,P4,O4 ,BOX #e#c#a4 ,B]KELEY1 ,CALI=NIA1 #i#d#g#a74 ,!SIS #ii C#d#g ,IBID41 ,*APT] #b#a1 0,MA/] ,)\T ,SLAVES04 C#d#h ,SEE ,CITATION #a#i4 ,!SIS #ad C#d#i ,LUDWIG ,FEU]BA*1 ,! ,ESS5CE ,( ,*RI/IANITY1 TRANSLAT$ BY ,GEORGE ,ELIOT1 ,H>P] @& ,R[1 7,NEW ,YORK1 #a#i#e#g71 PASSIM4 7,SEE1 = EXAMPLE1 P4 #g#c74 C#e ,K>L ,M>X1 ,CAPITAL1 VOL4 ,I1 OP4 CIT41 ,*APT] #a1 ,SECTION #d1 ',! ,FETI%ISM ( ,COMMODITIES & ! ,SECRET ,!RE(01 PP4 #g#a-#h#c4 C#e#a ,F4,S4 ,P5S1 ,EGO1 ,HUNG]1 & ,AGGRESSION3 ,! ,BEG9N+ ( ,GE/ALT ,!RAPY1 ,R&OM ,H\SE4 7,NEW ,YORK1 #a#i#f#i74 PASSIM41 & ESPECIALLY ,*APT] ,V,I,I1 0,FIR/ ,P]SON ,S+UL>01 PP4 #b#a#f-#b#a#i4 ,!SIS #ah C#e#b ,K>L ,M>X1 0,CONTRIBUTION TO ! ,CRITIQUE ( ,HEGEL'S ,PHILOSOPHY ( ,RIL ,M>X1 0,CONTRIBUTION TO ! ,CRITIQUE ( ,HEGEL'S ,PHILOSOPHY ( ,RIL ,M>X1 P4 #g 7FRONTISPIECE71 ,9T]NATIONAL ,PUBLI%]S 7,NEW ,YORK1 #a#i#f#e74 ,!SIS #aaf C#e#d ,RA\L ,VANEIGEM1 ,TREATISE ,ON ,LIV+ ,= ,! ,USE ( ! ,Y\NG ,G5]ATION1 OP4 CIT41 P4 #d#a1 9 ,*APT] #d1 0,SUFF]+04 ,!SIS #aai C#e#e ,K>L ,M>X1 ,GRUNDRISSE D] ,KRITIK D] ,POLITIS*5 ,OKONOMIE1 P4 #adc 7,MC,LELLAN1 OP4 CIT47 & P4 #gf 7,NICOLAUS1 OP4 CIT474 ,!SIS #abb C#e#f ,SITUATIONI/ ,9T]NATIONAL 7,REVIEW ( ! ,AM]ICAN ,SECTION7 ,NO4 #a1 OP4 CIT41 P4 #d#a4 C#e#g ,FR$]ICK ,5GELS1 ,SOCIALISM ,UTOPIAN & ,SCI5TIFIC1 ,P>T ,I,I,I4 ,SEE ALSO3 ,K>L ,M>X & ,FR$]ICK ,5GELS1 ,SELECT$ ,WORKS 9 ,?REE ,VOLUMES1 ,PROGRESS ,PUBLI%]S1 7,MOSC[1 #a#i#g71 PP4 #a#d#d-#a#d#e4 .<,! SAME /ATEM5T APPE>S ALMO/ V]BATIM 9 ,FR$]ICK ,5GELS1 ,ANTI-,DUHR+1 ,H]R ,DUHR+'S ,REVOLUTION 9 ,SCI5CE 7,NEW ,WORLD ,PAP]BACKS1 ,NEW ,YORK71 PP4 #c#c-#c#d74 C#e#h ,IBID41 PP4 #c#d-#c#e4 ,I,V4 ,GRAPHICAL ,ADDITIONS 7BY ,LU/ = ,LIFE7 ,COV] G#a ,FROM ,PANIC BY ,TOPOR 7,CITY ,LI04 G#b ,FROM ,LI/51 ,LITTLE ,MAN6 BY ,WILHELM ,REI* 7,NOONDAY ,PRESS1 #a#i#g#a71 PAGE #a#g4 ,ILLU/RATION BY ,WILLIAM ,/EIG4 ,SECTION ,I4 ,WEAL? G#a ,FROM ,UNE ,SEMA9E DE ,BONTE3 ,A ,SURREALI/IC ,NOVEL 9 ,COLLAGE BY ,MAX ,]N/ 7,DOV] ,PUBLICATIONS1 ,9C41 #a#i#g#f71 PAGE #a#i#f4 ,9 ,?IRD ,VISIBLE ,POEM4 ,SECTION ,I,I4 ,9DIVIDUALISM & ,COLLECTIVISM G#a ,FROM ,ALICE 9 ,WOND]L& & ,?R\< ! ,LOOK+ ,GLASS BY ,LEWIS ,C>ROLL1 7,GROSSET @& ,DUNLAP1 #a#i#d#f71 PAGE #baa 7,*APT] ,I,V ( ,ALICE ,?R\< ! ,LOOK+ ,GLASS1 0,TWE$L$UM & ,TWE$L$EE074 ,ILLU/RATION BY ,JOHN ,T5NIEL4 ,SECTION ,I,I,I4 ,! ,DIALECTIC ( ,EGOISM G#a ,FROM ,PANIC BY ,TOPOR 7,CITY ,LIILYN ,NISS5SON 7,*RONICLE ,BOOKS1 #a#i#i#h71 PAGE #a#b#g4 ,SECTION ,V4 ,COMMUNI/ ,SOCIETY G#a ,FROM ,UNE ,SEMA9E DE ,BONTE3 ,A ,SURREALI/IC ,NOVEL 9 ,COLLAGE BY ,MAX ,]N/ 7,DOV] ,PUBLICATIONS1 ,9C41 #a#i#g#f71 PAGE #a#i#e4 ,9 ,?IRD ,VISIBLE ,POEM4 ,SECTION ,V,I4 ,RADICAL ,SUBJECTIVITY G#a ,FROM ,FLATT]L&3 ,LIKE ,FLATL&1 ,ONLY ,MORE ,SO BY ,IAN ,/EW>T 7,P]SEUS ,PUBLI%+1 #b#a71 PAGE #bhc 7,*APT] #a#f1 0,NO-,BRANES & ,P-,BRANES074 ,EV]Y PO9T 9 SPACE IS REALLY A MULTIDIM5SIONAL HYP]SURFACE4 G#b ,BIRDCAGE FROM UNKN[N BY UNKN[N4 ,SECTION ,V,I,I4 ,PLEASURE G#a ,FROM ,FILM AS A ,SUBV]SIVE ,>T BY ,AMOS ,VOGEL 7,R&OM ,H\SE1 #a#i#g#d71 PAGE #b#a4 ,FROM ! ,YOKO ,ONO'S FILM ,! ,FLY 7#a#i#g74 G#b ,FROM ,FLATT]L&3 ,LIKE ,FLATL&1 ,ONLY ,MORE ,SO1 7,P]SEUS ,PUBLI%+1 #b#a71 PAGE #fb 7,*APT] #d1 0,A ,HUNDR$ & ,ONE ,DIM5SIONS074 ,SECTION ,V,I,I,I4 ,SEXUALITY G#a ,FROM ,FILM AS A ,SUBV]SIVE ,>T BY ,AMOS ,VOGEL 7,R&OM ,H\SE1 #a#i#g#d71 PAGE #a#e#e4 ,FROM ! ,DUSAN ,MAKAVEJEV FILM ,W,R3 ,MY/]IES ( ! ,ORGASM4 G#b ,FROM ,]OTICA ,UNIV]SALIS1 ,VOLUME ,I,I BY ,GILLES ,N]ET 7,TAS*571 PAGE #f#e#c4 ,ILLU/RATION BY ,HANS ,BELLM]4 ,SECTION ,I,X4 ,AU?ORITY G#a ,FROM ,LI/51 ,LITTLE ,MAN6 BY ,WILHELM ,REI* 7,NOONDAY ,PRESS1 #a#i#g#a71 PAGE #a#i4 ,ILLU/RATION BY ,WILLIAM ,/EIG4 ,SECTION ,X4 ,MORALITY G#a ,FROM ,! ,UND]GR\ND ,SKET*BOOK ( ,JAN ,FAU/ 7,DOV] ,PUBLICATIONS1 ,9C41 #a#i#g#a71 PAGE #g#h4 ,SECTION ,X,I4 ,REVOLUTION G#a ,FROM ,! ,HUNDR$ ,HEADLESS ,WOMAN BY ,MAX ,]N/ 7,GEORGE ,BRAZILL]1 #a#i#h#a71 PAGE #bbc 70,QUIETTUDE0 FROM ,*APT] ,SIX74 ,APP5DIX3 ,PREAMBLE ,TO ,! ,F\ND+ ,AGREEM5TS ( ,= ,\,R,S,E,L,V,E,S4 ,C\NCIL = ,G5]ALIZ$ ,SELF-,MANAGEM5T ,WE HAVE WOK5 UP TO DISCOV] ?AT \R LIVES >E BECOM+ UNLIVABLE4 ,FROM BOR+1 MEAN+LESS JOBS TO ! HUMILIATION ( WAIT+ 5DLESSLY 9 L9ES1 AT DESKS & C\NT]S TO RECEIVE \R %>E ( SURVIVAL1 FROM PRISON-LIKE S*OOLS TO REPETITI\S1 M9DLESS 05T]TA9M5T01 FROM DESOLATE & CRIME-RIDD5 /REETS TO ! /IFL+ ISOLATION ( HOME1 \R DAYS >E A TREADMILL ON :I* WE RUN FA/] & FA/] JU/ TO KEEP ! SAME PACE4 ,LIKE ! IMM5SE MAJORITY ( ! POPULATION1 WE HAVE NO CONTROL OV] ! USE TO :I* \R LIVES >E PUT3 WE >E PEOPLE :O HAVE NO?+ TO SELL BUT \R CAPACITY TO WORK4 ,WE HAVE COME TOGE!R BECAUSE WE CAN NO LONG] TOL]ATE ! WAY WE >E =C$ TO EXI/1 WE CAN NO LONG] TOL]ATE BE+ SQUEEZ$ DRY ( \R 5]GIES1 BE+ US$ UP & ?R[N AWAY1 ONLY TO CREATE A WORLD ?AT GR[S MORE ALI5 & UGLY EV]Y DAY4 ,! SY/EM ( ,CAPITAL1 :E!R 9 ITS 0,WE/]N0 PRIVATE CORPORATE OR 0,EA/]N0 /ATE-BUREAUCRATIC =M1 WAS BRUTAL & EXPLOITATIVE EV5 DUR+ ITS ASC5T3 N[1 :]E IT IS 9 DECAY1 IT POISONS AIR & WAT]1 PRODUCES GOODS & S]VICES ( DET]IORAT+ QUALITY1 & IS LESS & LESS ABLE TO EMPLOY US EV5 TO ITS [N ADVANTAGE4 ,ITS LOGIC ( ACCUMULATION & COMPETITION LEADS 9EXORABLY T[>D ITS [N COLLAPSE4 ,EV5 AS IT L9KS ALL ! PEOPLE ( ! WORLD TOGE!R 9 ONE VA/ NETWORK ( PRODUCTION & CONSUMPTION1 IT ISOLATES US FROM EA* O!R2 EV5 AS IT /IMULATES GREAT] & GREAT] ADVANCES 9 TE*NOLOGY & PRODUCTIVE P[]1 IT F9DS ITSELF 9CAPABLE ( PUTT+ !M TO USE3 EV5 AS IT MULTIPLIES ! POSSIBILITIES = HUMAN SELF-REALIZATION1 WE F9D \RSELVES /RANGL$ 9 LAY]S ( GUILT1 FE> & SELF-CONTEMPT4 ,BUT IT IS WE \RSELVES -- \R /R5G?1 \R 9TELLIG5CE1 \R CREATIVITY1 \R PASSIONS -- ?AT >E ! GREATE/ PRODUCTIVE P[] ( ALL4 ,IT IS WE :O PRODUCE & REPRODUCE ! WORLD AS IT IS1 9 ! IMAGE ( ,CAPITAL2 IT IS WE :O RE9=CE 9 EA* O!R ! CONDITION+ ( FAMILY1 S*OOL1 *UR* & M$IA1 ! CONDITION+ ?AT KEEPS US SLAVES4 ,:5 WE DECIDE TOGE!R TO 5D \R MIS]Y1 TO TAKE \R LIVES 9TO \R [N H&S1 WE CAN RECREATE ! WORLD ! WAY WE WANT IT4 ,! TE*NICAL RES\RCES & WORLDWIDE PRODUCTIVE NETWORK DEVELOP$ UND] ! OLD SY/EM GIVE US ! MEANS3 ! CRISIS & CONT9U+ COLLAPSE ( ?AT SY/EM GIVE US ! *ANCE & ! URG5T NE$4 ,! RUL+ IDEOLOGIES ( ! WORLD SUP]P[]S1 ) !IR 9T]LOCK+ SETS ( LIES1 (F] US ONLY ! FALSE *OICE ( 0,COMMUNISM0 V]SUS 0,CAPITALISM40 ,BUT 9 ! HI/ORY ( REVOLUTION DUR+ ?IS C5TURY 7,RUSSIA1 #a#i#e2 ,G]MANY1 #a#i#a#i#b2 ,SPA91 #a#i#c#f-#c#g2 ,HUNG>Y1 #a#i#e#f7 WE HAVE DISCOV]$ ! G5]AL =M ?R\< :I* WE CAN TAKE BACK P[] OV] \R [N LIVES3 WORK]S' C\NCILS4 ,AT !IR HI ASSEMBLIES 9 WORKPLACES & COMMUNITIES1 JO9$ TOGE!R BY MEANS ( /RICTLY M&AT$ DELEGATES :O C>RI$ \T DECISIONS ALREADY MADE BY !IR ASSEMBLIES & :O C\LD BE RECALL$ BY !M AT ANY TIME4 ,! C\NCILS ORGANIZ$ !IR [N DEF5SE & RE/>T$ PRODUCTION UND] !IR [N MANAGEM5T4 ,BY N[1 ?R\< A SY/EM ( C\NCILS AT ! LOCAL1 REGIONAL1 & GLOBAL LEVEL1 US+ MOD]N TELECOMMUNICATIONS & DATA PROCESS+1 WE CAN COORD9ATE & PLAN WORLD PRODUCTION AS WELL AS BE FREE TO %APE \R [N IMM$IATE 5VIRONM5T4 ,ANY COMPROMISE ) BUREAUCRACY & (FICIAL HI]>*Y1 ANY?+ %ORT ( ! TOTAL P[] ( WORK]S' C\NCILS1 CAN ONLY REPRODUCE MIS]Y & ALI5ATION 9 A NEW =M1 AS A GOOD LOOK AT ! SO-CALL$ 0,COMMUNI/0 C\NTRIES WILL %[4 ,= ?IS REASON1 NO POLITICAL P>TY CAN REPRES5T ! REVOLUTION>Y MOVEM5T OR SEIZE P[] 0ON ITS BEHALF10 S9CE ?IS W\LD BE SIMPLY A *ANGE ( RUL+ CLASSES1 NOT !IR ABOLITION4 ,! PLAN ( ! FREELY ASSOCIAT$ PRODUC]S IS 9 ABSOLUTE OPPOSITION TO ! DICTATORIAL ,PLAN ( /ATE & CORPORATE PRODUCTION4 ,ONLY ALL ( US TOGE!R CAN DECIDE :AT IS BE/ = US4 ,= !SE REASONS1 WE CALL UPON Y\ & UPON ALL ! HUNDR$S ( MILLIONS LIKE Y\ & US1 TO JO9 US 9 ! REVOLUTION>Y TRANS=MATION ( EV]Y ASPECT ( LIFE4 ,WE WANT TO ABOLI% ! SY/EM ( WAGE & SAL>I$ LABOR1 ( COMMODITY EX*ANGE-VALUE & ( PR(IT1 ( CORPORATE & BUREAUCRATIC P[]4 ,WE WANT TO DECIDE ! NATURE & CONDITIONS ( EV]Y?+ WE DO1 TO MANAGE ALL SOCIAL LIFE COLLECTIVELY & DEMOCRATICALLY4 ,WE WANT TO 5D ! DIVISION ( M5TAL FROM MANUAL WORK & ( 0FREE0 TIME FROM WORK TIME1 BY BR++ 9TO PLAY ALL ( \R ABILITIES = 5JOYABLE CREATIVE ACTIVITY4 ,WE WANT ! :OLE WORLD TO BE \R CONSCI\S SELF-CREATION1 SO ?AT \R DAYS >E FULL ( WOND]1 LE>N+1 & PLEASURE4 ,NO?+ LESS4 ,9 SETT+ D[N ?IS M9IMUM PROGRAM1 WE >E NOT TRY+ TO IMPOSE AN IDEAL ON REALITY1 NOR >E WE ALONE 9 WANT+ :AT WE WANT4 ,\R IDEAS >E ALREADY 9 EV]YONE'S M9DS1 CONSCI\SLY OR UNCONSCI\SLY1 BECAUSE !Y >E NO?+ BUT AN EXPRESSION ( ! REAL MOVEM5T ?AT EXI/S ALL OV] ! PLANET4 ,BUT 9 ORD] TO W91 ?IS MOVEM5T MU/ KN[ ITSELF1 ITS AIMS1 & ITS 5EMIES1 AS NEV] BE=E4 ,WE DO NOT SPEAK = ?IS MOVEM5T1 BUT = \RSELVES AS ( IT4 ,WE RECOGNIZE NO ,CAUSE OV] & ABOVE \RSELVES4 ,BUT \R SELVES >E ALREADY SOCIAL3 ! :OLE HUMAN RACE PRODUCES ! LIFE ( EA* ONE ( ITS MEMB]S1 N[ MORE ?AN EV] BE=E4 ,\R AIM IS SIMPLY TO MAKE ?IS PROCESS CONSCI\S = ! FIR/ TIME1 TO GIVE TO ! PRODUCTION ( HUMAN LIFE ! IMAG9ATIVE 9T5SITY ( A WORK ( >T4 ,IT IS 9 ?IS SPIRIT ?AT WE CALL UPON Y\ TO ORGANIZE1 AS WE >E DO+1 :]E Y\ WORK & :]E Y\ LIVE1 TO BEG9 PLANN+ ! WAY WE CAN RUN SOCIETY TOGE!R1 TO DEF5D Y\RSELVES AGA9/ ! DEEP5+ MIS]Y ?AT IS BE+ IMPOS$ ON ALL ( US4 ,WE CALL UPON Y\ TO ASSAULT ACTIVELY ! LIES1 ! SELFDECEPTIONS BORN ( FE>1 ?AT KEEP EV]YONE FROZ5 9 PLACE :ILE ! WORLD IS FALL+ AP>T >\ND US4 ,WE CALL UPON Y\ TO L9K UP ) US & ) O!RS :O >E DO+ ! SAME ?+4 ,ABOVE ALL1 WE CALL UPON Y\ TO TAKE Y\RSELVES & Y\R DESIRES S]I\SLY1 TO REALIZE Y\R [N P[] TO MA/] Y\R [N LIVES4 ,IT IS N[ OR NEV]4 ,IF WE >E TO HAVE A FUTURE1 WE \RSELVES MU/ BE ?AT FUTURE4 ,= ,\,R,S,E,L,V,E,S6 ,FEBRU>Y #a#f1 #aigd ,FROM 3 ,!,AN>*I/,LIBR>Y4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,NOVEMB] #c1 #aigc 3 ,! ,RIY #c1 #bbb 3 ,! ,RI