,TRUE ,CIVILIZATION 

#ahfc 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,JOSIAH ,W>R5 

,TAGS 3 DIV9E LAW ( ORD]1 9/9CT ( SELF-PRES]VATION1 LAW ( ORD]1 P]SONS & PROP]TY1 FRE$OM TO DIFF]1 DECL>ATION ( 9DEP5D5CE1 RI<T ( SOV]EIGNTY1 P]SONS OR PROP]TY1 LAWS ( NATIONS1 LAWS ( W>4 

,SECTIONS 7,T,O,C7 3 
     

O ,PREFACE 

      #fie ,WORDS2 #a#e1#d#h ,*>ACT]S     

O ,*APT] #a 3 ,GOV]NM5T & ,ITS ,TRUE ,FUNCTION 

      #f1#h#a#i ,WORDS2 #d#d1#d#a#i ,*>ACT]S     

O ,*APT] #b 3 ,SELF-,PRES]VATION 

      #a1#b#d ,WORDS2 #f1#d#d ,*>ACT]S     

O ,*APT] #c 3 ,PROB+ ,CIVILIZATION 

      #g1#b#f ,WORDS2 #d#d1#a#d ,*>ACT]S     

O ,*APT] #d 3 ,! ,PR9CIPLE ( ,EQUIVAL5TS 

      #a#a1#a#e#e ,WORDS2 #f#f1#f#i#i ,*>ACT]S     

O ,*APT] #e 3 ,ORGANIZATION & ,COOP]ATION 

      #h1#f#h#f ,WORDS2 #e#c1#i#i#c ,*>ACT]S     

O ,CONCLUSION 

      #e1#e#b#b ,WORDS2 #c#e1#c#d#c ,*>ACT]S 

,SECTIONS 7,CONT5T7 3 

O ,PREFACE 
,TRUE ,CIVILIZATION4 

  
,W>R51 ,JOSIAH 

  
7#a#h#f#c7 ,BO/ON1 ,MASS4 

  
,P,R,E,F,A,C,E4 

  

    ,! PRES5T CONDITION ( \R C\NTRY1 & ( MANY O!R P>TS ( ! WORLD1 CALLS \T & PLACES BE=E US1 AS 9 A PANORAMA1 :ATEV] !RE IS ( ?\<T2 :ATEV] !RE HAS BE5 ( PROGRESS OR RETROGRESSION1 & DISPLAYS TO US AT A SIMPLE GLANCE1 AS IT W]E1 ! PRES5T /ATE ( CIVILIZATION 9 SO VIVID A MANN] ?AT WE >E 5ABL$ TO WEI< & E/IMATE :AT WE HAVE & :AT WE NE$ ) A DEGREE ( C]TA9TY ?AT1 9 A /ATE ( REPOSE1 NO ONE'S LIFETIME MI<T 5ABLE HIM TO MEASURE2 & :I* MAY REASONABLY 9SPIRE EV5 ! HUMBLE ) A BOLDNESS SUIT$ TO ! TIME1 & ) A HOPE ?AT DISCOV]IES 9DISP5SABLE TO TRUE CIVILIZATION1 ?AT C\LD SC>CELY GA9 A S+LE E> :ILE ! ADV]SITIES ( LIFE C\LD BE BORNE1 MAY N[ RECEIVE SOME ATT5TION :]E ALL CONFID5CE 9 ! TRI$ IS LO/4 

,T,A,B,L,E ,( ,R,E,F,],5,C,E4  
    
  
,*,A,P,T,] #a3 ,G,O,V,],N,M,5,T ,& ,I,T,S ,T,R,U,E ,F,U,N,C,T,I,O,N4  
  
,*,A,P,T,] #b3  ,S,E,L,F-,P,R,E,S,],V,A,T,I,O,N4  
  
  
,*,A,P,T,] #c3  ,P,R,O,B,+ ,C,I,V,I,L,I,Z,A,T,I,O,N4  
  
  
,*,A,P,T,] #d3 ,! ,P,R,9,C,I,P,L,E ,( ,E,Q,U,I,V,A,L,5,T,S  

  
,*,A,P,T,] #e3 ,O,R,G,A,N,I,Z,A,T,I,O,N ,& ,C,O,O,P,],A,T,I,O,N444  

,C,O,N,C,L,U,S,I,O,N  
  
,C,A,U,T,I,O,N ,T,O ,! ,R,E,A,D,]4-- ,SEE ,9TRODUCTION TO ,*APT] #a4  
  
,P>AGRAPHS #b#e#i1 #b#g#d1  
#c#d#g1 #e#e#h4 
  
  
,I,S,S,U,E,S ,( ,! ,P,R,E,S,5,T ,W,> ,& ,( ,! ,A,G,E4--  
  
,P>4 #a#i1 #b1  
#b#e1 #b#h1 #c#c1  
#c#f1 #d#b1 #dc TO #d#f1 #a#h1 #aah TO #a#b#b1 #a#b#h1 #a#b#i1  
#a#c#b1 #a#c#d1 #a#c#f1  
#a#d1 #a#d#a1 #a#d#f1  
#adh TO #a#e1 #a#e#a1  
#a#e#d1 #a#e#e1 #a#h#g1  
#a#h#h1 #b#a#h1 #bd TO #b#d#b1 #b#g#i1 #c#a1  
#c#f#b1 #d#d1 #d#e#a1  
#eaa TO #e#b#a1  
#e#c#a1 #e#c#f1  
#$d TO #e#e4  

,R,O,O,T,S ,( ,C,O,N,F,U,S,I,O,N ,& ,V,I,O,L,5,C,E4--  
  
,P>4 #a1 #a#d1  
#c#e1 #a#d1 #aaf TO #a#a#h1 #a#b#a1 #abd TO #a#b#g1 #a#d#e1 #adh TO #a#e#f1 #a#e#h1 #a#f#a1  
#agc TO #a#g#h1 #a#h#f1  
#a#h#g1 #ai TO #a#i#f1  
#b#b1 #b#e1 #b#h1  
#bai TO #b#b#d1 #b#b#f1  
#bfh TO #b#g1 #b#g#g1  
#b#g#h1 #b#h#g1 #c#a1  
#c#c1 #ci TO #c#a#g1  
#cbb TO #c#b#g1 #cbh TO #c#c#b1 #cce TO #c#d1  
#c#e#a1 #c#e#b1 #cei TO #c#f#a1 #c#f#c1 #c#f#f1  
#c#f#g1 #c#f#i1 #c#h#d1  
#*h TO #c#i#d1 #cig TO #c#i#i1 #d TO #d#b1  
#d#f1 #d#a#f1 #d#e#a1  
#dha TO #d#i#f1  
#e#c1 #e#h1  
#e#i1 #e#a#e1  
#e#c1 #e#c#d1  
#e#d#f1 #e#d#i4  
  

,9,D,I,V,I,D,U,A,L ,R,E,S,P,O,N,S,I,B,I,L,I,T,Y1 ,IMPORTANCE (4-- ,P>4 #d1  
#a#b#e1 
  
  
#a#c#g1 #c#d#b1  
#d#d#i1 #di TO #d#i#d1 #d#i#i1  
#e#b#c1 #e#b#d1  
#e#c#a4  
  
,E,Q,U,I,T,A,B,L,E ,M,O,N,E,Y4--,:,A,T ,M,O,N,E,Y ,\,<,T ,T,O ,B,E4-- 

  
,P>4 #bc TO #b#d#e1  
#b#g#d1 #d#b#d1 #ebi TO #e#c#b1 #e#f#b4 ,SEE ,SPECIM51 PAGE #a#h#e4  
  
,B,>,B,>,I,S,M1 ,! ,M,O,D,E,L ,( ,P,R,E,S,5,T ,C,I,V,I,L,I,Z,A,T,I,O,N4--  
  
,P>4 #ac TO #a#f1  
#aab TO #a#a#f1 #a#a#h1  
#a#a#i1 #a#c1 #a#e#i1  
#a#f#d1 #afh TO #a#g#a1  
#a#g#e1 #a#h1 #b#f#i4  
  
,T,R,U,E ,=,M ,& ,F,U,N,C,T,I,O,N ,( ,G,O,V,],N,M,5,T4-- ,P>4 #b TO  
  
#d1 #i1 #a#g1  
#a#h1 #b#b1 #d#b1  
#d#c1 #d#f1 #dh TO #e#a1 #e#g1 #e#i1  
#f#b1 #g1 #a#d#c1  
#a#d#f1 #a#e#g1 #ccb TO #c#c#e1 #d#f#a1  
#e#h1 #e#a#a1  
#e#a#b1 #ecg TO #e#d#a1 #$d TO #e#d#f4  
  
,R,E,B,E,L,L,I,O,N ,I,M,P,O,S,S,I,B,L,E ,A,G,A,9,/ ,A ,G,O,V,],N,M,5,T  
  
,R,I,<,T,L,Y ,C,O,N,/,I,T,U,T,$4-- ,P>4 #b#h1  
#c#f1 #dfi TO #d#g#d4  
  
,9,D,I,V,I,D,U,A,L,I,T,Y1 ,! ,G,R,E,A,T ,D,I,V,9,E ,L,A,W ,( ,O,R,D,]1  
  
,S,E,C,U,R,I,T,Y1 ,P,E,A,C,E1 ,& ,S,U,C,C,E,S,S4 -- ,P>4  
#a1 #c#h1 #g#a1  
#a#f#b1 #a#f#f1 #a#f#g1  
#c#d#a1 #ce TO #c#e#b1  
#c#f#h1 #c#h#d1 #c#h#h1  
#c#i#f1 #dcd TO  
#d#c#i1 #d#d#a1  
#d#e#a1 #d#e#b1  
#d#g#e1 #dgi TO #d#h#c1 #dia TO #e1 #e#b1  
#e#c1 #e#e1  
#e#h1 #e#i1  
#e#a#a1 #e#a#c1  
#e#a#d1 #e#a#f1  
#e#a#i1 #e#b1  
#e#b#c1 #e#b#i1  
#e#d#f1 #e$ TO #e#e#g4  
  
,A,B,O,L,I,T,I,O,N ,( ,A,L,L ,=,M,S ,( ,S,L,A,V,],Y ,B,Y ,! ,P,R,9,C,I,P,L,E  
  
,( ,E,Q,U,I,V,A,L,5,T,S4-- ,P>4 #b#d#b1  
#b#h#e4  
  
,! ,M,O,/ ,D,I,S,A,/,R,\,S ,],R,O,R ,( ,H,U,M,A,N ,S,O,C,I,E,T,Y ,I,S  
  
,C,L,A,N,%,I,P1 0,U,N,I,O,N,S0 ,O,R ,C,O,M,M,U,N,I,S,M ,( ,9,T,],E,/,S4-- ,P>4 #aaf TO #a#d#a1 #a#d#d1  
#adh TO #a#e#d1 #afa TO #a#f#g1 #cbb TO #c#c#b1  
#cce TO #c#d1 #c#d#d1  
#d#c#f1 #d#c#h1  
#d#c#i1 #d#e#b1  
#di TO #e1  
#e#a1 #e#c1  
#e#a#b4  
  
,9,A,L,I,5,A,B,L,E ,R,I,<,T,S4-- ,P>4 #a1 #b1  
#c#e1 #c#f4  
  
,D,E,F,E,C,T,S ,( ,V,],B,A,L ,R,U,L,E,S4-- ,P>4 #a1  
#b#c1 #b#d1 #*h TO #d#e1 #e#f#f4  
  
,D,I,S,C,R,I,M,9,A,T,I,O,N1 ,! ,G,R,E,A,T ,B,A,L,A,N,C,E-,:,E,E,L ,T,O  
  
,T,R,U,E ,C,I,V,I,L,I,Z,A,T,I,O,N4-- ,P>4 #d TO #i1 #b#b1 #c#c1  
#c#d#f1 #di TO #d#i#e1  
#e#a4  
  
,F,A,T,A,L ,],R,O,R,S ,& ,D,E,F,E,C,T,S4-- ,P>4 #a#d1  
#a#i1 #b1 #b#c1  
#b#i1 #c#e1  
  
#d#d1 #e#d1 #a#d1  
#a#f1 #aaf TO #a#a#h1  
#a#b#a1 #a#b#b1 #a#b#d1  
#a#b#e1 #a#c1 #a#d#d1  
#a#d#h1 #aeb TO #a#e#e1  
#a#e#h1 #a#f#a1 #a#g#c1  
#a#g#d1 #a#g#h1 #a#h#g1  
#b#b#h1 #b#f#h1 #b#h#g1  
#cbb TO #c#c#b1 #cce TO #c#d1 #c#d#a1 #cdd TO #c#d#f1 #c#e#c1 #c#e#e1  
#c#e#f1 #c#e#h1 #c#e#i1  
#c#f#b1 #c#f#c1 #c#f#f1  
#c#f#i1 #c#h#d1 #*g TO #c#i#e1 #cig TO #d1  
#d#a1 #d#b1 #d#f1  
#d#d1 #d#d#h1  
#d#e#a1 #d#i1  
#e#a#a1 #e#a#c1  
#e#a#d1 #e#c1  
#e#c#d1 #ecg TO #e#d#c1 #$f TO #e#d#i4  
  
,I,M,P,O,R,T,A,N,T ,F,U,N,D,A,M,5,T,A,L ,F,A,C,T,S4--  
  
,P>4 #b1 #c1  
#e1 #f1 #h1  
#i1 #b#a1 #b#b1  
#b#d1 #b#e1 #cc TO #c#f1 #c#h1 #d#h1  
#d#i1 #f1 #f#a1  
#f#d1 #g#e1 #g#f1  
#h#b1 #a#f1 #a#a1  
#a#a#f1 #a#d#d1 #a#d#e1  
#aga TO #a#g#i1 #ahd TO #a#h#f1 #b#c#i1 #b#d#e1  
#b#e#h1 #b#g1 #b#g#c1  
#b#g#e1 #b#g#f1 #b#h#f1  
#b#h#g1 #bi TO #c1  
#c#a1 #cc TO #c#e1  
#c#i1 #c#a1 #cab TO #c#a#f1 #cag TO #c#a#i1  
#cbb TO #c#b#g4 ,SEE ,ROOTS ( ,CONFUSION4 #c#d#d1 #c#d#f1  
#cea TO #c#e#c1 #ceg TO #c#f#c1 #c#f#g1 #c#f#i1  
#c#h#d1 #*h TO #c#i#g1  
#dc TO #d#a#c1 #d#a#f1  
#d#a#i1 #d#b1 #dbf TO #d#b#i1 #d#c#a1 #d#d#b1  
#d#d#e1 #ddi TO #d#e#a1 #dfe TO #d#i#f1 #e#c1  
#e#d1 #e#h1  
#e#i1 #eaa TO #e#a#e1 #e#a#g1  
#e#a#h1 #eba TO #e#b#d1 #ebh TO #e#c1 #e#c#c1  
#e#c#d1 #e#c#f1  
#e#e#a1 #e$ TO #e#f#f1 #e#f#h4  
  
,E,Q,U,I,T,A,B,L,E ,C,O,M,P,5,S,A,T,I,O,N ,= ,L,A,B,O,R4-- ,P>4 #ahc TO #b#c#d1 #b#d#f1 #b#d#g1  
#bfd TO #b#f#i1 #b#g#d4  
  
,C,O,M,P,E,T,I,T,I,O,N ,D,E,P,R,I,V,$ ,( ,I,T,S ,D,E,/,R,U,C,T,I,V,E ,P,[,]  
  
,& ,C,O,N,V,],T,$ ,9,T,O ,A ,B,5,E,F,I,C,I,5,T ,& ,I,R,R,E,S,I,/,I,B,L,E ,R,E,G,U,L,A,T,O,R1 ,B,Y ,! ,P,R,9,C,I,P,L,E ,( ,E,Q,U,I,V,A,L,5,T,S4--,P>4 #bh TO #b#h#f1 #b#h#h1 #b#i1  
#b#i#i1 #cd TO #c#h4  
  
,M,E,A,N,S ,T,O ,B,E ,E,M,P,L,O,Y,$ ,= ,T,R,U,E ,C,I,V,I,L,I,Z,A,T,I,O,N4--  
  
,P>4 #b1 #a#g1  
#a#h1 #b#a1 #b#e1  
#b#f1 #c#b1 #db TO #d#f1 #d#i1 #e#c1  
#e#e1 #e#f1 #e#h1  
#fc TO #g#d1 #h1  
#h#a1 #ag TO #a#i1  
#a#b#i1 #a#c#a1 #a#c#b1  
#a#c#d1 #a#c#e1 #a#c#i1  
#a#d1 #a#d#c1 #a#f1  
#a#f#a1 #a#f#c1 #a#h#h1  
#a#i#h1 #b1 #b#f1  
#bbe TO #b#b#g1 #b#c#h1  
#b#d#b1 #b#d#g1 #bgc TO #b#g#e1 #bhb TO #b#h#g1  
#b#i1 #c1 #c#b1  
#c#d1 #c#a#h1 #cbb TO #c#b#g1 #c#d#b1 #cdi TO #c#e#b1 #c#e#e1 #c#e#f1  
#c#f#d1 #c#g#i1 #c#h#b1  
#c#h#c1 #d#g1 #d#a#e1  
#d#a#g1 #dba TO #d#b#e1  
#d#b#h1 #d#c1 #dcc TO #d#d#b1 #deb TO #d#e#h1 #d#f#a1  
#dfd TO #d#f#h1  
#d#g#h1 #d#i#g1  
#d#i#h1 #ec TO #e#e1 #e#h1  
#eaa TO #e#a#c1  
#e#a#f1 #e#a#h1  
#e#b#b1 #e#b#c1  
#e#b#f1 #eca TO #e#c#c1 #e#c#f1  
#$d TO #e#d#f1  
#e#e1 #e#e#f1  
#efg TO #e#f#i4  
  
,! ,9,T,],E,/,S ,( ,! ,9,D,I,V,I,D,U,A,L ,H,>,M,O,N,I,Z,$  
  
,) ,! ,9,T,],E,/,S ,( ,! ,P,U,B,L,I,C1 ,O,R ,C,O,O,P,],A,T,I,O,N4-- ,P>4 #bbg TO #b#e#h1 #b#g#b4  
  
,! ,9,D,E,/,R,U,C,T,I,B,L,E ,9,/,9,C,T ,( ,S,E,L,F-,P,R,E,S,],V,A,T,I,O,N  
  
,O,R ,9,D,I,V,I,D,U,A,L1 ,S,O,V,],E,I,G,N,T,Y1 ,B,E,+ ,U,N,D,],/,O,O,D1 ,& ,B,O,R,N,E ,9 ,M,9,D1 ,B,E,C,O,M,E,S ,! ,L,O,N,G-,N,E,$,$ ,R,E,G,U,L,A,T,O,R ,( ,H,U,M,A,N ,9,T,],C,\,R,S,E4-- ,P>4 #b1 #c1 #g1  
#a#f1 #a#i1 #b#a1  
#b#c1 #c#f1 #g TO #g#b1 #g#f1 #a#c#d1  
#a#c#i1 #a#d#e1 #c#d#i1  
#c#e#d1 #c#f1 #c#f#a1  
#c#h1 #c#h#a1 #dg TO #d#a#c1 #ddi TO #d#e#b1 #dfi TO #d#g#b1 #d#g#e1  
#e#a#f1 #e#b#c1  
#e#c#f1 #$d TO #e#d#f1 #e#e#f4  
  
,E,Q,U,I,T,A,B,L,E ,$,U,C,A,T,I,O,N4-- ,P>4 #ce TO #c#h4  
  
,O,B,/,A,C,L,E,S ,T,O ,T,R,U,E ,C,I,V,I,L,I,Z,A,T,I,O,N4-- ,P>4 #b#i#i1  
#c#b#c1 #c#c#h1 #d#g#f1  
#d#g#i1 #e#a4  
  
,D,E,L,I,B,],A,T,I,V,E ,C,\,N,C,I,L,S ,& ,!,I,R ,T,R,U,E ,F,U,N,C,T,I,O,N4  
  
-- ,P>4 #fc TO #g#f1  
#c#b#g1 #c#c#b1 #d#f#a1  
#e#f#h4  
  
,! ,P,R,9,C,I,P,L,E ,( ,E,Q,U,I,V,A,L,5,T,S4-- ,P>4 #ahc TO #b#c#d4  
  
,T,R,U,E ,F,U,N,C,T,I,O,N ,( ,L,E,A,D,],%,I,P4-- ,P>4 #a#f1  
#cdi TO #c#e#a1 #c#f#d1  
  
#c#f#e1 #c#f#g1  
#c#g1 #c#g#h1 #c#h#e4  
  
,L,E,A,D,] ,D,I,/,+,U,I,%,$ ,F,R,O,M ,T,Y,R,A,N,T4-- ,P>4 #a#f1  
#cdi TO  
  
#c#e#b1 #c#f#c4  
  
,I,M,P,O,R,T,A,N,T ,Q,U,E,/,I,O,N,S ,A,N,S,W,],$4-- ,P>4 #d1  
#b#c1 #b#e1 #b#f1  
#bhi  
  
TO #c1 #ce TO #c#h1 #c#g#a1 #c#g#b1  
#ddf TO #d#e#h1  
#e#a#h4  
  
,P,R,E,V,5,T,I,O,N ,& ,R,E,/,R,A,9,T ,D,I,/,+,U,I,%,$ ,F,R,O,M  
  
,P,U,N,I,%,M,5,T4 -- ,P>4 #d TO #f1 #b#i1 #c1  
#f#d1 #f#e4  
  
,! ,T,R,U,E 0,B,A,L,A,N,C,E ,( ,P,[,]40-- ,P>4 #d#h1  
#a#h#a1 #a#h#b1 #b#d1  
#b#d#d1 #e#c#f4  
  
,D,E,F,E,C,T,S ,( ,C,O,M,M,O,N ,M,O,N,E,Y ,& ,C,O,M,M,],C,E4-- ,P>4  
  
#a#f#h1 #a#f#i1  
#aga TO #a#g#d1 #a#g#f1  
#a#g#g1 #a#h#f1 #a#h#g1  
#b#h#g4  
  
,C,O,N,C,5,T,R,A,T,$ ,C,A,P,I,T,A,L4-- ,P>4 #b#g#e4  
  
,U,N,C,O,N,S,C,I,\,S ,E,X,],C,I,S,E ,( ,S,E,L,F-,S,O,V,],E,I,G,N,T,Y4-- ,P>4 #c1  
#b#d1 #c#f1 #d#i4  
  
,D,I,S,9,T,E,G,R,A,T,I,O,N ,! ,S,C,I,5,T,I,F,I,C ,R,E,M,$,Y ,= ,C,O,N,F,U,S,I,O,N1  
  
,& ,P,R,E,V,5,T,I,V,E ,( ,V,I,O,L,5,C,E4-- ,P>4 #g#g1#a#b#h1#a#f#b1#a#f#d TO #a#f#g1 #b#d#f1 #c#b#b1  
#c#e#e1 #dcd TO  
#d#c#h1 #d#d1  
#d#d#a1 #dha TO #e1 #e#i1  
#e#a#a1 #e#a#b1  
#e#a#i1 #e#b#c1  
#e#d#h1 #e#d#i4  
  
,9,T,],E,/ ,O,N ,M,O,N,E,Y4-- ,P>4 #bba TO #b#b#d1 #b#f1 #b#f#a1  
#bfd TO #b#f#i4  
  
,:,A,T ,C,O,N,/,I,T,U,T,E,S ,9,V,A,S,I,O,N4-- ,P>4 #cgb TO #c#g#f4  
  
,! ,L,E,G,I,T,I,M,A,T,E ,S,P,H,],E ,( ,S,O,V,],E,I,G,N,T,Y4-- ,P>4 #a TO #a#b1 #c#e#d1 #c#e#g1  
#c#f1 #c#g#h1 #c#g#i1  
#c#h#a1 #d#b#h1 #d#g1  
#d#h#g1 #e#h1  
#e#e#g4  
  
,E,Q,U,I,T,A,B,L,E ,M,],*,&,I,Z,+4-- ,P>4 #b#d#f1  
#b#d#g1 #bhb TO #b#h#e4  
  
,P,R,A,C,T,I,C,A,L ,I,L,L,U,/,R,A,T,I,O,N ,( ,E,Q,U,I,T,A,B,L,E ,F,R,E,$,O,M4  
  
-- ,P>4 #b1 #h#c1  
#a#d#e1 #b#e#h1 #b#e#i1  
#c#h#d1 #c#h#f1 #dh TO #d#a#e1 #d#b#a1 #e#b#e1  
#e#b#g1 #e#b#h1  
#efd TO #e#f#g4  
  
,E,X,P,$,I,5,T,S ,D,I,/,+,U,I,%,$ ,F,R,O,M ,P,R,9,C,I,P,L,E,S4-- ,P>4  
#d TO #i1 #c#g#b4  
  
,V,A,L,I,D,I,T,Y ,( ,C,O,N,T,R,A,C,T,S4-- #c#h#f1  
#c#h#g1 #ddf TO  
#d#g4  
  
,L,E,G,I,T,I,M,A,T,E ,R,E,S,I,/,A,N,C,E ,( ,W,R,O,N,G,S4-- ,P>4 #d TO #g1 #i1 #b#b1  
#c#f1 #c#g#b1  
#c#g#c1 #cge TO #c#g#g4  
  
,D,I,S,C,I,P,L,9,E ,R,E,C,O,N,C,I,L,$ ,) ,F,R,E,$,O,M4--,P>4 #b#c1  
#b#f1 #b#g1  
#c#f1 #c#i1 #d1  
#e#d1 #c#h#f4  
  
,O,R,G,A,N,I,Z,A,T,I,O,N ,& ,H,>,M,O,N,I,C ,C,O,O,P,],A,T,I,O,N ,),\,T  
  
,S,E,C,T,I,S,M ,O,R ,C,L,A,N,%,I,P1 ,& ,),\,T ,C,O,N,F,L,I,C,T ,) ,E,Q,U,I,T,A,B#a,E ,F,R,E,$,O,M4-- ,P>4 #bbg TO #b#e#h1  
#b#g#b1 #b#h#h1 #cdh TO #c#e#e1 #c#h#b1 #*d TO #c#h#g1 #dba TO #d#b#d1  
#e#b#f4  
  
,F,I,R,/ ,/,E,P,S ,T,[,>,D,S ,T,R,U,E ,O,R,D,] ,& ,P,R,O,S,P,],I,T,Y4  
  
-- ,P>4 #e#c1 #e#f1  
#f#c1 #ff TO #g#c1  
#a#d#f1 #a#f1 #a#f#a1  
#a#f#d1 #e#b#g1 #efg TO #e#f#i4  
  

O ,*APT] #a 3 ,GOV]NM5T & ,ITS ,TRUE ,FUNCTION 
,T,R,U,E ,C,I,V,I,L,I,Z,A,T,I,O,N4 

  
  
,9,T,R,O,D,U,C,T,I,O,N ,T,O ,*,A,P,T,] ,I4 

  

    ,?OSE :O HAVE NOT LEISURE OR 9CL9ATION TO FOLL[ ALL ! SUBTLE 9TRICACIES ( ! FOLL[+ SUBJECTS WILL AT ONCE APPRECIATE ! RELIEF PROMIS$ BY ! 0,TRIBUNALS0 PROPOS$ 9 ?IS FIR/ *APT] FOLL[+1 TO :I* EV]Y?+ ( ! K9D CAN BE REF]R$ ) A PROSPECT ( OBTA9+ AS RELIABLE OP9IONS AS C\LD BE EXPECT$ FROM ANY QU>T]2 AT LEA/1 AS RELIABLE AS OP9IONS ?AT >E NOT AU?ORITATIVE NE$ TO BE4 ,BUT1 ,I IMPLORE MY FELL[-M5 NOT LONG] TO COMMIT !MSELVES TO 9DISCRIM9ATE SUBORD9ATION TO ANY HUMAN AU?ORITY OR TO ! FATAL DELUSIONS ( LOGIC & ANALOGIES1 NOR EV5 TO IDEAS OR PR9CIPLES 7SO CALL$71 BUT TO MA9TA91 AS F> AS POSSIBLE1 AT ALL TIMES1 ! ,F,R,E,$,O,M TO ACT ACCORD+ TO ! APP>5T M]ITS ( EA* 9DIVIDUAL CASE AS IT MAY PRES5T ITSELF TO EA* 9DIVIDUAL UND]/&+4 ,!RE IS NO O!R SAFETY = US--NO O!R SECURITY = CIVILIZATION4 

    ,IF ,I %\LD PROVE MYSELF RI<T 9 N9ETY-N9E PO9TS 9 ?IS WORK1 DO NOT1 !RE=E1 CONCLUDE ?AT ,I AM RI<T 9 ! HUNDR$? )\T EXAM9ATION & Y\R [N SANCTION3 ?AT ONE PO9T MI<T BE ! ONE 9 :I* ,I WAS WRONG OR MISUND]/OOD4 

    ,:ILE A SMALL PORTION ( MANK9D CAN SEE1 AT A GLANCE1 ! PROSPECTIVE WORK+S ( A PR9CIPLE OR NATURAL LAW1 & ONLY WANT TO KN[ :AT TO DO 9 ORD] TO DO IT1 & HAVE NOT TIME TO /UDY NEW ?+S1 !RE >E O!RS :O HAVE TIME & :O WANT TO /UDY ! PHILOSOPHY1 & FOLL[ ! TRA9 ( ?\<T :I* GAVE RISE TO :ATEV] IS PROPOS$ = !IR ADOPTION1 & MAKE IT1 AS IT W]E1 !IR [N1 BE=E !Y >E READY TO ACT4 ,! FIR/ CLASS ( P]SONS MAY BE CONT5T = A :ILE ) ! FOLL[+ *APT] ON GOV]NM5T2 :ILE ! LATT] CLASS MAY F9D IMM$IATE 9T]E/ 9 TILE *APT]S :I* FOLL[4  

,*,A,P,T,] ,I4 

,G,O,V,],N,M,5,T ,& ,I,T,S ,T,R,U,E ,F,U,N,C,T,I,O,N4 

  

   #a4 ,) ALL DUE DEF]5CE TO O!R JUDGM5TS ,I V5TURE TO ASS]T ?AT \R PRES5T DEPLORABLE CONDITION1 LIKE ?AT ( MANY O!R P>TS ( ! WORLD1 IS 9 CONSEQU5CE ( ! PEOPLE 9 G5]AL NEV] HAV+ P]CEIV$1 OR ELSE HAV+ LO/ SI<T (1 ! LEGITIMATE OBJECT ( ALL GOV]NM5TS AS DISPLAY$ OR IMPLI$ 9 ! ,AM]ICAN 0,DECL>ATION ( ,9DEP5D5CE40 

   #b4 ,EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL ( MANK9D HAS AN 0,9,A,L,I,5,A,B,L,E RI<T TO ,LIFE1 ,LIB]TY1 & ! PURSUIT ( ,HAPP9ESS20 0& IT IS SOLELY TO PROTECT & SECURE ! 5JOYM5T ( !SE RI<TS UNMOLE/$ ?AT GOV]NM5TS CAN PROP]LY BE 9/ITUT$ AMONG M540 ,9 O!R T]MS1 ,S,E,L,F-,S,O,V,],E,I,G,N,T,Y IS AN 9/9CT ( EV]Y LIV+ ORGANISM2 & IT BE+ AN 9/9CT1 CANNOT BE ALI5AT$ OR SEP>AT$ FROM ?AT ORGANISM4 ,IT IS ! 9/9CT ( ,SELF-,PRES]VATION2 ! VOTES ( T5 ?\S& M5 CANNOT ALI5ATE IT FROM A S+LE 9DIVIDUAL1 NOR C\LD ! BAYONETS ( TW5TY ?\S& M5 NEUTRALIZE IT 9 ANY ONE P]SON ANY MORE ?AN !Y C\LD PUT A /OP TO ! 9/9CTIVE DESIRE = FOOD 9 A HUNGRY MAN4 

    #c4 ,! ACTION ( ?IS 9/9CT BE+ ,9,V,O,L,U,N,T,>,Y1 EV]Y ONE HAS ! SAME ABSOLUTE RI<T TO ITS EX]CISE ?AT HE HAS TO HIS COMPLEXION OR ! =MS ( HIS FEATURES1 TO ANY EXT5T1 NOT DI/URB+ ANO!R2 & IT IS SOLELY TO PREV5T OR RE/RA9 SU* DI/URBANCES OR 5CROA*M5TS1 ?AT GOV]NM5TS >E PROP]LY 9/ITUT$4 ,9 /ILL %ORT] T]MS1 ! LEGITIMATE & APPROPRIATE MISSION ( GOV]NM5TS IS ! DEF5SE & PROTECTION ( ! 9ALI5ABLE RI<T ( ,SOV]EIGNTY 9 EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL )9 HIS OR H] [N SPH]E4 

    ,BUT :AT IS IT ?AT CON/ITUTES 5CROA*M5T8 

    #d4 ,SUPPOSE MY H\SE TO BE ON FIRE1 & ,I SEIZE A PAIL ( WAT] 9 ! H&S ( A PASS]BY1 )\T WAIT+ TO EXPLA9 OR ASK LEAVE--?IS W\LD BE ONE DEGREE ( 5CROA*M5T1 BUT P]HAPS ! [N] W\LD EXCUSE IT ON ! GR\ND ( ITS NECESSITY4 ,SUPPOSE A MAN WALKS 9TO MY H\SE )\T WAIT+ = LEAVE--IT MAY OR MAY NOT DI/URB OR (F5D ME1 OR CON/ITUTE A DEGREE ( 5CROA*M5T4 ,IF ,I F9D ?AT HE HAS NO EXCUSABLE ]R&1 & REQUIRE HIM TO RETIRE & HE REFUSES1 ?IS W\LD BE A DEGREE ( 5CROA*M5T :I* ,I MI<T MEET ) A FEW WORDS1 & MI<T NE$ NO GOV]NM5T TO ASSI/ ME4 ,IF HE PROCE$S TO ROB ! H\SE1 ,I MAY HAVE REASON TO ?9K ?AT HE IS DRIV5 TO DESP]ATION BY HAV+ A />V+ FAMILY1 & ,I MAY NOT RESORT TO VIOL5CE2 OR ,I MAY P]CEIVE ?AT HE IS A WANTON & RECKLESS ROBB] OR FILLIBU/]1 & ?AT ?IS IS AN UNNECESS>Y 5CROA*M5T1 :I*1 9 DEF5SE ( MY [N RI<TS1 AS WELL AS ! SAME RI<TS 9 O!RS1 ,I AM JU/IFIABLE 9 RESI/+2 & IF ,I HAVE NOT SUFFICI5T P[] TO DO SO )\T 5DANG]+ MYSELF OR PROP]TY1 ,I WILL CALL = HELP3 --?IS HELP1 :E!R 9 ! =M ( POLICE OR AN >MY1 IS GOV]NM5T1 & ITS FUNCTION IS TO USE =CE1 TO PREV5T HIM FROM US+ =CE AGA9/ ME & M9E2 IT 9T]F]ES1 ) MY CONS5T1 TO PREV5T 9T]F]5CE ) MY SOV]EIGN RI<T TO CONTROL MY [N3-- ITS MISSION IS 09T]V5TION = ! SAKE ( NON9T]V5TION40 

    #e4 ,IF HE HAS ALREADY GOT POSSESSION ( MY PURSE1 ,I %\LD WANT HIM TO BE COMPELL$1 )\T ANY UNNECESS>Y VIOL5CE1 TO GIVE IT UP2 &1 P]HAPS1 TO COMP5SATE ! POLICE2 &1 TILL ,I HAD LE>N$ BETT]1 ,I MI<T HAVE APPROV$ ( HIS BE+ CONF9$ 9 PRISON TILL HE HAD DONE ?IS1 & COMP5SAT$ ME = BE+ DI/URB$3 BUT !RE >E OBJECTIONS TO PROCE$+ TO !SE COMPLICAT$ MEASURES4 ,!RE IS NO PR9CIPLE 7G5]ALLY7 KN[N1 BY :I* TO DET]M9E :AT CON/ITUTES COMP5SATION6--,HE C\LD NOT GET PROP]LY COMP5SAT$ = HIS WORK1 :I* MI<T BE A GREAT] 9JU/ICE TO HIM ?AN HE HAD DONE TO ME2 & IT W\LD 9FLICT ON HIS 9NOC5T FA!R1 MO!R1 BRO!RS1 & SI/]S1 HIS WIFE & *ILDR51 & ALL HIS FRI5DS1 9CALCULABLE 9JU/ICE & SUFF]+1 & ?IS W\LD BE NO COMP5SATION TO ME3 BESIDES1 ,I 7AS A CITIZ5 ( ! SAME WORLD7 AM A P>TN] 9 ! CRIME BY NOT HAV+ PREV5T$ ! TEMPTATION TO IT4 

    #f4 ,) ALL !SE CONSID]ATIONS AGA9/ PURSU+ HIM F>!R1 ,I ?9K IT ! BE/ PRES5T EXP$I5T TO PUT UP ) ! RE/ORATION ( MY PURSE1 AS HE GA9S NO?+ TO TEMPT ! CONT9UANCE ( ! BUS9ESS4 ,! WORD EXP$I5T MAY LOOK LOOSE & UNSATISFACTORY3 BUT1 AMONG ALL ! WORKS ( MANK9D !RE IS NO?+ HI<] ?AN EXP$I5TS4 

    #g4 ,! 9/9CT ( SELF-PRES]VATION OR SELF-SOV]EIGNTY IS NOT ! WORK ( MAN2 BUT TO KEEP IT CON/ANTLY 9 M9D AS A SACR$ RI<T 9 ALL HUMAN 9T]C\RSE IS HI<LY EXP$I5T4 

    #h4 ,P]CEIV+ ?AT WE CAN 9V5T NO?+ HI<] ?AN EXP$I5TS1 WE NECESS>ILY SET ASIDE ALL IMP]ATIVE OR ABSOLUTE AU?ORITIES1 ALL SANGU9>Y & UNB5D+ CODES1 CRE$S1 & !ORIES1 & LEAVE EV]Y ONE ,FREE TO *OOSE AMONG EXP$I5TS3 OR1 9 O!R WORDS1 WE PLACE ALL ACTION UPON ! VOLUNT>Y BASIS4 ,DO NOT BE AL>M$1 WE %ALL SEE ?IS TO BE ! HI<E/ EXP$I5T :5EV] IT IS POSSIBLE4 

    #i4 ,IT IS ONLY :5 ! VOLUNT>Y IS WANTONLY 5CROA*$ UPON1 ?AT ! EMPLOYM5T ( =CE IS EXP$I5T OR JU/IFIABLE4 

    #a4 ,IT APPE>S1 H[EV]1 ?AT NO RULE OR LAW CAN BE LAID D[N TO DET]M9E BE=EH&1 :AT WILL CON/ITUTE AN (F5SIVE 5CROA*M5T--:AT ONE WILL RESI/ ANO!R WILL EXCUSE1 & ! SUBTLE DIV]SITIES ( DIFF]5T P]SONS & CASES1 GR[+ \T ( ! 9H]5T 9DIVIDUALITIES ( EA*1 HAVE DEFI$ ALL ATTEMPTS AT P]FECT =MULIZ+ EXCEPT+ ?IS ( ! ,SOV]EIGNTY ( EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL OV] HIS OR H] [N2 & EV5 ?IS MU/ BE VIOLAT$ 9 RESI/+ ITS VIOLATION6 

    #a#a4 ,! LEGITIMATE SPH]E ( EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL HAS NEV] BE5 PUBLICLY DET]M9$2 BUT UNTIL IT IS CLE>LY DEF9$1 WE CAN NEV] TELL :AT CON/ITUTES 5CROA*MONT-- :AT MAY BE SAFELY EXCUS$1 OR :AT MAY BE PR(ITABLY RESI/$4 

    #a#b4 ,WE WILL ATTEMPT !N TO DEF9E ! SPH]E )9 :I* EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL MAY LEGITIMATELY1 RI<TLY EX]CISE SUPREME P[] OR ABSOLUTE AU?ORITY4 ,?IS SPH]E W\LD 9CLUDE HIS OR H] P]SON1 TIME1 PROP]TY1 & RESPONSIBILITIES4 

    #a#c4 ,BY ! WORD RI<T IS MEANT SIMPLY ?AT :I* NECESS>ILY T5DS T[>DS ! 5D 9 VIEW-- ! 5D 9 VIEW H]E IS P]MAN5T & UNIV]SAL PEACE1 & SECURITY ( P]SON & PROP]TY4 

    #a#d4 ,I HAVE SAID 79 EFFECT7 ?AT ! PRES5T CONFUSION & WIDE-SPREAD VIOL5CE & DE/RUCTION RESULT FROM A WANT ( APPRECIATION ( ?IS GREAT RI<T ( ,9DIVIDUAL ,SOV]EIGNTY1 & ITS DEF5SE BY GOV]NM5T4 

    #a#e4 ,I N[ PROCE$ TO ILLU/RATE & PROVE ?IS BY CONSID]+ :AT W\LD BE ! NATURAL CONSEQU5CES ( BE>+ !SE TWO IDEAS ALL ! TIME 9 M9D AS ! REGULATORS ( POLITICAL & MORAL MOVEM5TS1 & HOLD+ !M1 AS IT W]E1 AS SUB/ITUTES = ALL PREVI\S LAWS CU/OMS1 PREC$5TS1 & !ORIES4 

    #a#f4 ,FIR/1 !N1 :ILE ADMITT+ ?IS RI<T ( ,SOV]EIGNTY 9 EV]Y ONE1 ,I %ALL NOT BE GUILTY ( ! ILL MANN]S ( ATTEMPT+ TO (F5SIVELY 5=CE ANY ( MY !ORETICAL SPECULATIONS1 :I* HAS BE5 ! COMMON ]ROR ( ALL GOV]NM5TS6 ,?IS ITSELF W\LD BE AN ATTEMPT$ 5CROA*M5T ?AT W\LD JU/IFY RESI/ANCE4 

    #a#g4 ,! :OLE MISSION ( CO]CIVE GOV]NM5T BE+ ! DEF5SE ( P]SONS & PROP]TY AGA9/ (F5SIVE 5CROA*M5TS1 IT MU/ HAVE =CE 5\< = ! PURPOSE4 ,?IS =CE NECESS>ILY RESOLVES ITSELF 9TO ! MILIT>Y1 = ! ADVANTAGES ( DRILL & SY/EMATIC COOP]ATION3 & ?IS BE+ P]HAPS ! BE/ =M ?AT GOV]NM5T CAN ASSUME1 :ILE A CO]CIVE =CE IS NE$$1 ,I MAKE NO ISSUE ) IT BUT ONLY ) ! MISAPPLICATIONS ( ITS IMM5SE P[]4 

    #a#h4 ,ADH]+ CLOSELY TO ! IDEA ( RE/RA9+ VIOL5CE AS ! MISSION ( GOV]NM5T OR MILIT>Y P[]1 IF ?IS SOLE PURPOSE WAS 9/ILL$ 9TO ! G5]AL M9D AS AN ELEM5T ( $UCATION OR DISCIPL9E1 NO =CE C\LD BE RAIS$ TO 9VADE ANY P]SONS OR PROP]TY :ATEV]1 & NO DEF5SE W\LD BE NECESS>Y4 

    #a#i4 ,IF ! ,DECL>ATION ( ,9DEP5D5CE1 OR ?IS SACR$ RI<T ( ,9DIVIDUAL ,SOV]EIGNTY1 HAD BE5 COMMONLY APPRECIAT$ A YE> AGO 9 ! 0,UNIT$ ,/ATES10 !Y W\LD NOT N[ BE DISUNIT$4 ,NONE ( ! DE/RUCTION ( P]SONS & PROP]TY :I* HAS BLACK5$ ! PA/ YE> W\LD HAVE OCCURR$1 NOR W\LD TWELVE HUNDR$ ?\S& CITIZ5S N[ BE B5T ON DE/ROY+ EA* O!R & !IR FAMILIES & HOMES 9 !SE ,/ATES6 

    #b4 ,EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL W\LD HAVE BE5 0,FREE0 TO 5T]TA9 ANY !ORY ( GOV]NM5T :ATEV] = HIMSELF OR H]SELF1 & TO TE/ IT BY EXP]IM5T )9 EQUITABLE LIMITS2 AN ISSUE W\LD BE RAIS$ ONLY :]E ?IS SACR$ RI<T WAS D5I$1 OR AGA9/ ANY :O %\LD HAVE UND]TAK5 TO 5=CE ANY !ORY ( GOV]NM5T :ATEV] UPON ANY 9DIVIDUAL AGA9/ HIS OR H] 0CONS5T40 ,! FRANK & HONE/ ADMISSION ( ?IS 09ALI5ABLE0 RI<T W\LD EV5 N[ *ANGE ! ISSUE ( ?IS PRES5T W>1 & C>RY RELIEF & PROTECTION TO ! 9VAD$ OR OPPRESS$1 & W> OR RESI/ANCE TO ! OPPRESSOR ONLY1 :E!R HE W]E F\ND ON ONE SIDE OR ! O!R ( A GEOGRAPHICAL L9E4 ,M]E !ORI/S SAY ?AT 0! LAWS ( NATIONS DECIDE ?AT A /ATE ( W> 7BETWE5 TWO NATIONS7 PUTS ALL ! MEMB]S ( EA*1 9 HO/ILITY TO EA* O!R30 & ?AT 0! LAWS ( NATIONS JU/IFY US 9 DO+ ALL ! H>M WE CAN TO \R 5EMIES40 ,WE NE$ NO DEA?-W>RANT FROM 0AU?ORITY0 AGA9/ !SE B>B>IAN !ORIES-- ! V]Y /ATEM5T ( !M BECOMES !IR EXECUTION4 

    #b#a4 ,EV]Y P]SON BE+ 5TITL$ TO SOV]EIGNTY )9 HIS [N SPH]E1 !RE CAN BE1 CONSI/5TLY1 NO LIMITS OR EXCEPTIONS TO ! TITLE TO PROTECTION 9 ! LEGITIMATE EX]CISE ( ?IS SACR$ RI<T1 :E!R ON ?IS SIDE OR ! O!R SIDE ( ! ,ATLANTIC1 & :E!R 09 A /ATE ( W>0 OR NOT3 &1 AS SOON AS WE TAKE POSITION = ?IS UNIV]SAL RI<T = ALL ! WORLD1 WE %ALL HAVE ALL ! WORLD = US & ) US & NO 5EMIES TO CONT5D )4 ,DID MILIT>Y M5 EV] ?9K ( ?IS8 ,DID GOV]NM5TS EV] ?9K ( IT8 

    #b#b4 ,! :OLE PROP] BUS9ESS ( GOV]NM5T IS ! RE/RA9+ (F5SIVE 5CROA*M5TS1 OR UNNECESS>Y VIOL5CE TO P]SONS & PROP]TY1 OR 5=C+ COMP5SATION !RE=3 BUT IF1 9 ! EX]CISE ( ?IS P[]1 WE COMMIT ANY UNNECESS>Y VIOL5CE TO ANY P]SON :ATEV] OR TO ANY PROP]TY1 WE1 \RSELVES1 HAVE BECOME ! AGGRESSORS1 & %\LD BE RESI/$4 

    #b#c4 ,BUT :O IS TO DECIDE H[ MU* VIOL5CE IS NECESS>Y 9 ANY GIV5 CASE8 ,WE H]E >RIVE AT ! PIVOT UPON :I* ALL P[] N[ TURNS = GOOD OR EVIL2 ?IS PIVOT1 UND] =MAL1 EXACT+1 AGGRESSIVE 9/ITUTIONS OR CON/ITUTIONS1 IS ! P]SON :O DECIDES AS TO !IR MEAN+4 ,IF ONE DECIDES = ALL1 !N ALL BUT ?AT ONE >E1 P]HAPS1 5SLAV$2 IF EA* ONE'S TITLE TO ,SOV]EIGNTY IS ADMITT$1 !RE WILL BE DIFF]5T 9T]PRETATIONS1 & ?IS FRE$OM TO DIFF] WILL 5SURE EMANCIPATION1 SAFETY1 REPOSE1 EV5 9 A POLITICAL ATMOSPH]E6 & ALL ! COOP]ATION WE \<T TO EXPECT WILL COME FROM ! CO9CID5CE ( MOTIVES ACCORD+ TO ! M]ITS ( EA* CASE AS E/IMAT$ BY DIFF]5T M9DS4 ,:]E !RE IS EVID5CE ( AGGRESSION PALPABLE TO ALL M9DS1 ALL MI<T COOP]ATE TO RESI/ IT3 & :]E ! CASE IS NOT CLE>LY MADE \T1 !RE WILL BE MORE OR LESS HESITATION3 ,TWO GREAT NATIONS WILL NOT !N BE SO V]Y READY TO JUMP AT EA* O!R'S ?ROATS :5 ! MO/ CUNN+ LAWY]S >E PUZZL$ TO DECIDE :I* IS WRONG6 

    #b#d4 ,!ORIZE AS WE MAY AB\T ! 9T]PRETATION ( 0! ,CON/ITUTION10 EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL DOES UNAVOIDABLY MEASURE IT & ALL O!R WORDS BY HIS [N PECULI> UND]/&+ OR CONCEITS1 :E!R HE UND]/&S HIMSELF OR NOT1 & %\LD1 LIKE ,G5]AL ,JACKSON1 RECOGNIZE ! FACT1 0TAKE ! RESPONSIBILITY ( IT10 & QUALIFY HIMSELF TO MEET ITS CONSEQU5CES4 ,! FULL APPRECIATION ( ?IS SIMPLE BUT ALMO/ UNKN[N FACT WILL NEUTRALIZE ! W> ELEM5T 9 ALL V]BAL CONTROV]SIES1 & ! B9D+ P[] ( ALL 9DEF9ITE WORDS1 & PLACE CON=MITY !RETO ON ! VOLUNT>Y BASIS6 ,DID ANY 9/ITUTION-MAK]S 7EXCEPT ! SIGN]S ( ! 0,DECL>ATION07 EV] ?9K ( ?IS8 

    #b#e4 ,IT WILL BE ASK$1 :AT C\LD BE ACCOMPLI%$ BY A MILIT>Y ORGANIZATION1 IF EV]Y SUBORD9ATE W]E ALL[$ TO JUDGE ( ! PROPRIETY ( AN ORD] BE=E HE OBEY$ IT8 ,I ANSW] ?AT NO?+ C\LD BE ACCOMPLI%$ ?AT DID NOT COMM5D ITSELF TO M5 $UCAT$ TO UND]/&1 & TRA9$ TO RESPECT ! RI<TS ( P]SONS & PROP]TY AS SET =? 9 ! 0,DECL>ATION ( ,9DEP5D5CE20 & ?AT H]E1 & H]E ONLY1 WILL BE F\ND ! LONG-NE$$ *ECK TO ! B>B>IAN WANTONNESS ?AT LAYS T[NS 9 A%ES & DESOLATES HOMES & HE>TS = BRUTAL REV5GE1 OR TO ACT (FICE OR A LITTLE VULG> NEWSPAP] NOTORIETY4 

    #b#f4 ,BUT :AT %ALL 5SURE PROPRIETY ( JUDGM5T OR UNI=MITY OR CO9CID5CE BETWE5 ! SUBORD9ATES & ! (FIC]S8 ,I ANSW]1 ,DRILL1 ,DISCIPL9E1-- ( M9D AS WELL AS ( >MS & LEGS1-- TEA*+ ALL TO REALIZE !IR TRUE MISSION4 ,! TRUE OBJECT ( ALL !IR P[] BE+ CLE>LY DEF9$ & MADE FAMILI>1 !RE W\LD AT ONCE BE A CO9CID5CE UNKN[N BE=E1 & BUT SLI<T *ANCE ( DISS5T :5 !RE WAS GOOD GR\ND = COOP]ATION4 

    #b#g4 ,NO SUBORD9ATION CAN BE MORE P]FECT ?AN ?AT ( AN ,OR*E/RA2 BUT IT IS ALL VOLUNT>Y4 

    #b#h4 ,:5 WE >E READY TO PROTECT ANY P]SON OR PROP]TY )\T REG>D TO LOCALITY OR P>TY1 !RE CAN BE NO HO/ILE P>TIES OR NATIONS6-- ,NO?+ TO BETRAY BY TREASON6-- ,NO?+ TO REBEL AGA9/6-- ,NO P>TY TO DES]T TO6 ,!N1 :OSE FAULT IS IT ?AT !RE >E P]SONS CALL$ 0,TRAITORS10 0,REBELS10 & 0,DES]T]S08 

    #b#i4 ,IF IT BE TRUE ?AT ! SOLE PROP] FUNCTION ( CO]CIVE =CE IS TO RE/RA9 OR REPAIR ALL UNNECESS>Y VIOL5CE1 !N ! CONCLUSION IS 9EVITABLE ?AT ALL P5AL LAWS 7= PUNI%+ A CRIME OR AN ACT AFT] IT IS COMMITT$ EXCEPT SO F> AS !Y WORK TO COMP5SATE ! 9JUR$ P>TY ,EQUITABLY7 >E !MSELVES CRIM9AL6 ,! EXCUSE IS ?AT PUNI%M5T IS 0A T]ROR TO EVILDO]S20 BUT ?OSE :O PUNI% 9/EAD ( PREV5T+ CRIME >E !MSELVES EVILDO]S2 & ACCORD+ TO !IR [N !ORY !Y %\LD BE PUNI%$ & T]RIFI$2 BUT ! !ORY IS FALSE3 CONSI/5TLY C>RI$ \T1 IT W\LD DEPOPULATE ! WORLD4 ,SU* >E ! FOGS 9 :I* WE GET A/RAY :5 WE TRU/ \RSELVES AWAY FROM FIR/ PREMISES & SUB/ITUTE SPECULATIVE !ORIES 9 !IR /EAD4 ,HAD \R MILIT>Y BE5 PROP]LY $UCAT$ TO KN[ ITS TRUE FUNCTION & PURPOSE1 ,ELLSWOR? W\LD NOT HAVE BE5 %OT = TAK+ D[N A FLAG2 ! %OOT+ ( HIM DID NOT RE/RA9 HIM1 NOR DID ! %OOT+ ( ,MR4 ,JACKSON COMP5SATE ,ELLSWOR?3 BUT IT CAUS$ ,MRS4 ,JACKSON TO BECOME 9SANE ) GRIEF1 & HAS SPREAD A HO/ILE SPIRIT TO AN 9CALCULABLE EXT5T AMONG MILLIONS1 :I* WILL DESC5D TO FUTURE G5]ATIONS2 ALL ( :I* ORIG9AT$ 9 ! D5IAL TO ,MR4 ,JACKSON ( HIS 09ALI5ABLE RI<T0 TO *OOSE HIS [N GOV]NM5T1 :I* ! 0,DECL>ATION0 GU>ANTEES 9 EXPLICIT T]MS TO EV]Y ONE4 

    #c4 ,TO TAKE D[N ,MR4 ,JACKSON'S FLAG WAS ONE DEGREE ( 5CROA*M5T1 BUT IT WAS NOT NECESS>Y TO %OOT ,ELLSWOR? = BAD MANN]S2 FAIL+ TO $UCATE HIM OR TO PREV5T HIM1 ONE P>TY WAS AS MU* 9 FAULT AS ! O!R4 ,! B>B>IAN HABIT ( %$D+ BLOOD = IRREP>ABLE (F5SES 70AS A T]ROR TO EVIL-DO]S07 WAS ACT$ UPON 9 ?IS CASE-- C>RI$ FULLY \T1 MUTUAL SLAU<T] W\LD HAVE CONT9U$ TILL !RE W\LD NOT BE A MAN1 WOMAN1 OR *ILD1 LIV+ UPON ! E>?4 

    #c#a4 ,>E NOT !SE /ATEM5TS P]FECTLY 9 ACCORDANCE ) ! ,DECL>ATION ( ,9DEP5D5CE AS WELL AS ) ! TEA*+S ( ! WISE/ & BE/ ( \R SPECIES8 ,I 9VITE ?\<T ON ! SUBJECT4 ,I MAKE ! ASS]TIONS NOT BECAUSE !Y >E IMPLI$ 9 ?AT 0,DECL>ATION10 BUT BECAUSE !Y >E JU/ SU* AS >E DEM&$ AT ?IS H\R AS ! ONLY POSSIBLE MEANS ( SALVATION FROM B>B>ISM4 

    #c#b4 ,IF ! SOLUTIONS H]E9 PRES5T$ %\LD APPE> TO REQUIRE MORE /EADY MANL9ESS & CONSI/5T ?\<T ?AN SU* AS COMMONLY PREVAIL1 !N ,9/RUCTION1 ,DRILL1 ,DISCIPL9E1 >E AS NECESS>Y = ! M9DS AS = ! BODIES ( \R MILIT>Y =CES3 BUT EV5 9 ?IS DISCIPL9E1 ! PR9CIPAL LABOR WILL CONSI/ 9 KEEP+ ! M9D'S EYE /EADILY UPON TWO IDEAS SO SIMPLE AS ! RI<T ( ,SOV]EIGNTY 9 EV]Y P]SON & ITS JUDICI\S DEF5SE4 

    #c#c4 ,EXP]I5CE DRIFTS US1 AGA9/ ALL !ORIES ( COMB9ATION1 TO REF] EV]Y?+ TO ,9DIVIDUAL DECISION & ACTION3 & WE CANNOT1 !RE=E SAFELY DISP5SE ) AN EV]-WAT*FUL ,D,I,S,C,R,I,M,9,A,T,I,O,N & A /RONG ,SELF-GOV]NM5T 9 EV]Y P]SON 9 PROPORTION TO ! MAGNITUDE ( HIS OR H] SPH]E ( ACTION4 ,PRACTICAL EXP]I5CE 9 ?IS C\NTRY 9 LESS ?AN ONE YE> HAS DRIV5 US1 AGA9/ ! HOPEFUL !ORY ( ,DEMOCRATIC GOV]NM5T1 UND] ! DREAD$ GOV]NM5T ( MILIT>Y DESPOTISMS1 :I* IS M]ELY PLAC+ ! DECID+ P[] 9 A FEW P]SONS1 & ! P]SONS & PROP]TY ( ALL ! PEOPLE AT !IR DISPOSAL2 :ILE ! ,DECL>ATION ( ,9DEP5D5CE & ! 9/9CT ( ,SELF-PRES]VATION ASS]T ! ABSOLUTE & 09ALI5ABLE RI<T 0 ( EV]Y ONE TO CONTROL HIS [N6 ,MAN-MADE P[]S >E >RAY$ AGA9/ ,N,A,T,U,R,E',S ,L,A,W6 ,H]E WE HAVE ! FATAL ISSUE6 ,:AT CAN BE DONE8 ,>E WE AGA9 AT ! EVE ( A LONG NI<T ( DESOLATION1 OR IS !RE SOME UNTRI$ ELEM5T 9 MOD]N ?\<T :I* CAN RECONCILE ! SEEM+ CONTRADICTION BETWE5 9/9CT & EXP]I5CE8 

    #c#d4 ,CAN IT BE POSSIBLE ?AT ONE SIMPLE ?\<T F\ND 9 \R [N *>T] ( RI<TS1 IF 9TRODUC$ 9TO MILIT>Y DISCIPL9E1 W\LD SOLVE1 NOT ?IS GREAT PROBLEM ONLY1 BUT O!RS ( EV5 GREAT] MAGNITUDE8 

    #c#e4 ,A MAN CANNOT ALI5ATE HIS 09ALI5ABLE RI<T0 ( SELF-PRES]VATION OR ,SOV]EIGNTY BY JO9+ ! MILIT>Y OR ANY O!R COMB9ATION-- ! ASSUMPTION ?AT ?IS IS POSSIBLE HAS PRODUC$ ALL \R POLITICAL CONFUSION & VIOL5CE1 & WILL CONT9UE TO PRODUCE JU/ SU* FRUITS TO ! 5D ( TIME1 IF ! *ILDI% BLUND] IS NOT EXPOS$ & CORRECT$4 

    #c#f4 ,ADMITT+ ?IS 9DE/RUCTIBLE RI<T ( ,SOV]EIGNTY 9 EV]Y ,9DIVIDUAL1 AT ALL TIMES & 9 ALL CONDITIONS1 ONE WILL NOT ATTEMPT TO GOV]N 7BUT ONLY GUIDE OR LEAD7 ANO!R2 BUT WE %ALL TRU/ TO PR9CIPLE OR PURPOSE = A G5]AL & VOLUNT>Y CO9CID5CE & COOP]ATION4 ,MILIT>Y (FIC]S WILL !N BECOME DIRECTORS OR LEAD]S1-- NOT 0COMM&]S10-- OB$I5CE WILL BE ALL ! MORE PROMPT BECAUSE IT IS R5D]$ = AN OBJECT-- ! GREATE/ ?AT CAN 9SPIRE HUMAN ACTION1 ,R,E,S,I,/,A,N,C,E ,T,O ,A,L,L ,A,T,T,E,M,P,T,S ,A,T ,(,F,5,S,I,V,E ,& ,U,N,N,E,C,E,S,S,>,Y ,G,O,V,],N,+ ,O,R ,5,C,R,O,A,*,M,5,T,S UPON ,A,N,Y P]SONS OR PROP]TY :ATSOEV]1 AS ! GREAT GU>ANTEE = ! SECURITY ( EA* & EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL4 ,!N EV]Y ,MAN1 ,WOMAN1 & ,*ILD 9 ! WORLD IS 9T]E/$ 9 ACT+ = & ) SU* A GOV]NM5T6 

    #c#g4 ,\R PROBLEM IS !ORETICALLY SOLV$6 ,BUT ITS BRI<TNESS DAZZLES US1 & ITS SUBLIME MAGNITUDE BEWILD]S-- -- ,LET US TAKE TIME6 

    #c#h4 ,HAV+ ONE MAN AS G5]AL OV] ?\S&S1 >ISES FROM ! NATURAL NECESSITY = ,9DIVIDUALITY 9 ! DIRECT+ M9D :5 NUMB]S WI% TO MOVE TOGE!R2 BUT IT DOES NOT NECESS>ILY IMPLY ANY SUP]IORITY ( JUDGM5T OR MOTIVE 9 ! DIRECTOR ( A MOVEM5T BEYOND ?OSE ( ! SUBORD9ATES1 ANY MORE %ALL ! DRIV] ( AN OMNIBUS IS PRESUM$ TO KN[ ! ROAD BETT] ?AN ! PASS5G]S2 !Y MAY ALL KN[ ! ROAD EQUALLY WELL1 BUT IF !Y ALL UND]TAKE TO DRIVE ! HORSES1 NONE ( !IR PURPOSES WILL BE ANSW]$2 & IT W\LD BE EQUALLY RIDICUL\S = ! DRIV]1 UND] ! PLEA ( UPHOLD+ SUBORD9ATION1 TO 9SI/ ON C>RY+ HIS PASS5G]S :]E !Y DID NOT WANT TO GO1 OR REFUSE TO LET !M GET \T :5 !Y WANT$ TO 0SEC$E40 

    #c#i4 ,! NECESSITY = ! PROMPT EXECUTION ( ! DIRECTIONS ( ! ONE LEAD1 OR DIRECTOR1 :]E NUMB]S >E ACT+ TOGE!R TO ATTA9 AN OBJECT 9 VIEW1 IS SO SELF-EVID5T1 OR CAN BE SO EASILY EXPLA9$1 ?AT :]E !RE IS A WALLS ( ?IS PROMPTNESS1 IT IMPLIES ?AT ! FAULT IS 9 HAV+ A BAD CAUSE1 OR UNFIT ASSOCIATES 9 A GOOD ONE4 

    #d4 ,! MO/ 9TELLIG5T PEOPLE ALWAYS MAKE ! BE/ SUBORD9ATES 9 A GOOD CAUSE1 & 9 \R MOD]N MILIT>Y IT WILL REQUIRE MORE TRUE MANHOOD TO MAKE A GOOD SUBORD9ATE ?AN IT WILL TO BE A LEAD]2 = ! LEAD] MAY V]Y EASILY GIVE ORD]S1 BUT !Y TAKE ! RESPONSIBILITY ( ?AT ONLY1 :ILE ! SUBORD9ATE TAKES ! RESPONSIBILITY ( EXECUT+ !M2 & IT WILL REQUIRE ! GREATE/ & HI<E/ DEGREE ( MANHOOD1 ( SELF-GOV]NM5T1 PRES5CE ( M9D1 & REAL H]OISM TO DISCRIM9ATE ON ! 9/ANT & TO /& UP 9DIVIDUALLY BE=E ALL ! CORPS & FUTURE CRITICISMS1 & ASSUME1 ALONE1 ! RESPONSIBILITY ( DISS5T OR DISOB$I5CE4 ,HIS ONLY SUPPORT & /R5G? W\LD BE 9 HIS CONSCI\SNESS ( BE+ MORE TRUE TO HIS PR(ESS$ MISSION ?AN ! ORD] WAS1 & 9 ! ASSURANCE ?AT HE W\LD BE SU/A9$ BY PUBLIC OP9ION & SYMPA?Y AS F> AS ?AT MISSION WAS UND]/OOD4 

    #d#a4 ,SUBORD9ATES HAVE MANY TIMES REFUS$ TO FIRE ON !IR FELL[-CITIZ5S 9 OB$I5CE TO ! M]E WANTONNESS ( AU?ORITY1 OR ( ! F]OCITY ( A CRUDE DISCIPL9E1 & HAVE ?US1 LIKE ,WILLIAM ,TELL1 5TITL$ !MSELVES TO ! LA/+ GRATITUDE & AFFECTION ( G5]ATIONS4 

    #d#b4 ,M5 MAY LEAD & M5 MU/ EXECUTE1 BUT 9TELLIG5CE1 PR9CIPLE1 MU/ REGULATE3 & ?AT PR9CIPLE MU/ BE ,! ,P,R,E,V,5,T,I,O,N ,O,R ,R,E,P,A,I,R ,( ,A,L,L ,U,N,N,E,C,E,S,S,>,Y ,V,I,O,L,5,C,E1 ,O,R ,W,A,N,T,O,N ,D,I,/,U,R,B,A,N,C,E ,( ,P,],S,O,N,S ,O,R ,P,R,O,P,],T,Y1 IF WE >E EV] TO HAVE ORD] OR PEACE ON E>?4 

    #d#c4 ,EV5 ,*ILDR51 :5 DRILL$ & TRA9$ ) ?IS IDEA 7:I* IS SIMPLY ! TRUE ,DEMOCRATIC IDEA71 W\LD BECOME AN EV]-READY POLICE TO PROTECT EA* O!R & ! G>D5S1 FRUITS1 & O!R PROP]TY >\ND !M1 9/EAD ( BE+1 AS !Y (T5 >E1 ! ,IMPS ( DI/URBANCE & DE/RUCTION4 ,! HEI<T ( !IR AMBITION BE+ TO PLAY 0SOG]10 & FI<T SOMEBODY OR DE/ROY SOME?+4 

    #d#d4 ,?IS IS \R FAULT4 ,! ,DEMOCRATIC IDEA1 !ORETICALLY AT ! BASE ( ,AM]ICAN 9/ITUTIONS1 HAS NEV] BE5 9TRODUC$ 9TO \R MILIT>Y DISCIPL9E1 NOR 9TO \R C\RTS1 NOR 9TO \R LAWS1 & ONLY 9 A C>ICATUR$ & DI/ORT$ %APE 9TO \R POLITICAL SY/EM1 \R COMM]CE1 \R $UCATION1 & PUBLIC OP9ION4 

    #d#e4 ,LET ?IS ELEM5T BE PRACTICALLY & CONSI/5TLY 9TRODUC$1 ESPECIALLY 9 ! MILIT>Y DEP>TM5T1 & \R C\NTRY IS SAV$3-- ,O!RWISE1 IT IS ,L,O,/4 

    #d#f4 ,:5 A HI< DEGREE ( 9TELLIG5CE1 GREAT MANHOOD1 SELF-GOV]NM5T1 CLOSE DISCRIM9ATION1 REAL H]OISM1 & G5TLE HUMANITY >E KN[N TO BE NECESS>Y TO MEMB]%IP 9 \R MILIT>Y CORPS 7OR GOV]NM5T71 !SE QUALITIES WILL COME 9TO FA%ION1 & BECOME ! *>ACT]I/ICS ( ! PEOPLE2 & TO BE ?\<T DE/ITUTE ( !M1 & UNWOR?Y ( MEMB]%IP 9 ! MILIT>Y W\LD CAUSE ! GREATE/ MORTIFICATION3 :ILE TO BE KN[N AS A MEMB] 9 GOOD /&+ W\LD BE AN OBJECT S\<T AS ! HI<E/ HONOR4 

    #d#g4 ,IS ALL ?IS 9 EXACT & SCI5TIFIC ACCORDANCE ) \R FIR/ PREMISES 9 ! 0,DECL>ATION ( LNDEP5D5CE10 OR IS IT ALL A ROMANTIC DREAM8 

    #d#h4 ,IF WE HAVE BE5 CORRECT 9 \R REASON+S1 !N WE HAVE F\ND ! CLUE TO ! TRUE MISSION & =M ( ,GOV]NM5T-- ,TO ! MO/ P]FECT1 YET H>MLESS SUBORD9ATION-- ,! RECONCILIATION ( OB$I5CE ) ,F,R,E,$,O,M-- ,TO ! CESSATION ( ALL HO/ILITIES BETWE5 P>TIES & ,NATIONS-- ,TO UNIV]SAL COOP]ATION = UNIV]SAL PRES]VATION & SECURITY ( P]SONS & PROP]TY4 ,WE HAVE F\ND A GOV]NM5T1 LIT]ALLY 9 ! PEOPLE1 ( ! PEOPLE1 = ! PEOPLE-- A GOV]NM5T ?AT IS ! PEOPLE3 = ,M51 ,WOM51 & ,*ILDR5 CAN TAKE SOME DIRECT OR 9DIRECT P>T 9 IT-- A READY POLICE OR >MY ADAPT$ TO ALL DEM&S = EI!R-- A SELF-PROTECT+ 0,P>TY ( ! :OLE40 

    #d#i4 ,A 0,UNION0 NOT ONLY ON PAP]1 BUT ROOT$ 9 ! HE>T-- :OSE MEMB]S1 TRA9$ 9 ! CON/ANT REV]5CE = ! 09ALI5ABLE RI<T0 ( ,SOV]EIGNTY 9 EV]Y P]SON1 W\LD BE HABITUAT$ TO =BE>ANCE T[>DS EV5 WRONG OP9IONS & DIFF]5T $UCATIONS & TA/ES1 TO PATI5T 5DURANCE ( IRREM$IABLE 9JURIES1 & A SELF-GOV]N+ DEPORTM5T & G5TL5ESS ( MANN]1 & A PROMPT BUT C>EFUL RESI/ANCE TO WANTON AGGRESSION :]EV] F\ND1 :I* W\LD MEET ) A READY & AN AFFECTIONATE WELCOME 9 ANY P>T ( ! WORLD4 

    #e4 ,EV]Y 9TELLIG5T P]SON W\LD WI% TO BE A MEMB] OR TO CONTRIBUTE1 9 SOME MANLI]1 TO ! GREAT COMMON CAUSE4 

    #e#a4 ,NO CO]CIVE SY/EM ( TAXATION C\LD BE NECESS>Y TO SU* A GOV]NM5T6 ,A GOV]NM5T SO SIMPLE ?AT *ILDR5 WILL BE FIR/ TO COMPREH5D IT1 & :I* EV5 !Y CAN SEE IT = !IR 9T]E/S TO ASSI/3 & !N W\LD AS READILY PLAY 0SOG]0 TO PREV5T MIS*IEF1 AS TO DO MIS*IEF4 

    #e#b4 ,) \R M9D'S EYE /EADILY FIX$ ON ?IS GREAT ,DEMOCRATIC PR9CIPLE & OBJECT1 LET US IMM$IATELY COMM5CE ! AGITATION ( ! IDEA ( =M+ COMPANIES ( HOME-GU>DS ON ?IS PR9CIPLE4 

    #e#c4 ,LET ANY ONE :O FEELS SO DISPOS$1 TAKE ! FIR/ /EPS & 9VITE ! COOP]ATION ( P]SONS SUFFICI5TLY 9TELLIG5T TO COMPREH5D ! OBJECT TO =M A NUCLEUS4 7,! KN[N HABITUAL REG>D TO ! 09ALI5ABLE RI<TS0 ( P]SONS & PROP]TY W\LD BE ! BE/ TITLE TO MEMB]%IP74 ,!N1 COMM5CE ,DRILL & ,DISCIPL9E1 KEEP+ 9 M9D ALL ! TIME ! K9D ( DISCIPL9E REQUIR$1 :I* W\LD BE P>TLY 9 ! =M ( LECTURES2 TAK+ AS TEXTS1 ! DETAILS ( ! DE/RUCTION ( P]SONS AN ,I PROP]TY GO+ ON ALL >\ND US1 & %[+ ) H[ MU* LESS VIOL5CE ! SAME OR BETT] OBJECTS C\LD HAVE BE5 ACCOMPLI%$3 & 9 ! DRILL1 GIV+ SOME ORD]S TO DO SOME UNNECESS>Y H>M1 ON PURPOSE TO BE DISOBEY$ 9 ORD] TO ACCU/OM ! SUBORD9ATES TO 0LOOK BE=E !Y LEAP0 OR /RIKE6 

    #e#d4 ,SU* A ,MILIT>Y =CE W\LD BE )9 BUT NOT UND] DISCIPL9E4 ,9 O!R WORDS1 ITS 0SABBA? W\LD BE MADE = MAN-- NOT MAN = ITS SABBA?40 ,TO BE UND] 9/EAD ( )9 DISCIPL9E IS A MI/AKE AS FATAL AS ?AT ( GETT+ UND] WAT] 9 /EAD ( )9 WAT]4 

    #e#e4 ,IF ! TRUE MISSION ( ! MILIT>Y OR 5=C+ P[] IS KEPT CON/ANTLY 9 VIEW1 & MADE1 AS IT W]E1 ! GUID+ />1 SC>CELY ANY?+ CAN GO S]I\SLY AMISS2 & ,N,V,C NE$ NO O!R GUIDE = ! USE ( A GOV]N+ =CE3 NOR WILL IT ANSW] TO ALL[ ANY !ORIES OR 0PREC$5TS0 TO OV]RIDE ?IS ONE SUPREME CONSID]ATION4 

    #e#f4 ,COMPANIES ?US =M$ W\LD DO WELL TO COMMUNICATE ) EA* O!R1 :I* W\LD BE ALL ! G5]AL ORGANIZATION REQUIR$ = A WORLD-WIDE COOP]ATION4 

    #e#g4 ,H]E W\LD BE A GOV]NM5T TO PRES]VE1 & NOT TO DE/ROY-- TO PROTECT & NOT TO 9VADE2 A GOV]NM5T ?AT CAN 9CLUDE ! :OLE /R5G? ( ! WORLD-- :5 MI<T W\LD BE = ! RI<T1 & NO 5EMIES TO CONT5D )6 

    #e#h4 ,! *>MS ( MUSIC1 ( MUTUAL SYMPA?Y1 ! BEAUTIES ( ORD]1 & ( UNITY ( DRESS & ( MOVEM5T 9 MILIT>Y DISPLAYS1 N[ SO S$UCTIVE TO PURPOSES ( DE/RUCTION & DEGRADATION1 W\LD 5TICE TO ! HI<E/ & NOBLE/ OBJECTS ( HUMAN AMBITION1 :I* W\LD NEV] NE$ A FIELD ( ACTIVITY AS LONG AS WANTON OPPRESSION 7EV5 ( A S+LE 9DIVIDUAL7 HAS FOOT+ ON ! E>?4 

    #e#i4 ,?US F> WE HAVE CONSID]$ ! TRUE FUNCTION ( GOV]NM5T1 & F9D ?AT IT HAS TO DEAL ONLY ) (F5SIVE 5CROA*M5TS UPON P]SONS OR PROP]TY3 LIKE A VOLUNTE] GU>D ON A WRECK$ VESSEL 9 ! CONFUSION ( DISA/]1 ! FR5ZY ( HLUNG]1 & ! FE> ( />VATION1 TO PREV5T UNNECESS>Y DE/RUCTION ( LIFE OR PROP]TY1-- AN EXP$I5T *OICE ( EVILS :]E !RE IS NO?+ BUT EVILS TO *OOSE FROM4 

    #f4 ,SOCIETY HAS ?US F> BE5 ONLY A 0S]IES ( FAILURES10 & IS AT ?IS DAY A M]E ASSEMBLAGE ( WRECKS ?R[N AGA9/ EA* O!R ON A TEMPE/U\S SEA )\T PILOTS1 *>TS1 RUDD]S1 OR COMPASS4 

    #f#a4 ,! FIR/ %IP HAS NOT YET BE5 CON/RUCT$ ?AT IS NOT LIABLE TO BE WRECK$ BY ! V]Y ELEM5T ?AT MOVES IT ON A SUCCESSFUL VOYAGE2 & ! FIR/ =M ( G5]AL SOCIETY IS YET TO BE DEVELOP$ ?AT W\LD NOT BE LIABLE TO DE/RUCTION FROM ! 9/9CTIVE 0PURSUIT ( HAPP9ESS10 )\T :I* NO SOCIETY W\LD EXI/4 

    #f#b4 ,GOV]NM5T1 /RICTLY & SCI5TIFICALLY SPEAK+ IS A CO]CIVE =CE2 A MAN1 :ILE GOV]N$ ) HIS [N CONS5T1 IS NOT GOV]N$ AT ALL4 

    #f#c4 ,DELIB]ATIVE BODIES1 SU* AS ,LEGISLATURES1 ,CONGRESSES1 ,CONV5TIONS1 ,C\RTS1 ETC41 >E NOT1 SCI5TIFICALLY SPEAK+1 >E NOT GOV]NM5T1 :I* IS SIMPLY CO]CIVE =CE4 ,BUT1 9ASMU* AS ?AT =CE %\LD NEV] BE EMPLOY$ )\T A DELIB]ATE REF]5CE TO ITS LEGITIMATE OBJECT1 & UPON :I* ALL AVAILABLE WISDOM %\LD BE BR\<T TO BE>1 A ,DELIB]ATIVE ,C\NCIL1 ACT+ BE=E OR ) ! GOV]NM5T1 SEEMS HI<LY EXP$I5T IF NOT 9DISP5SABLE4 

    #f#d4 ,MOREOV] !RE >E SUBJECTS N[ BE=E US1 & CONT9UALLY >IS+1 ON :I*1 BY TIMELY =E?\<T1 VIOL5T ISSUES MAY BE PREV5T$ FROM >IS+1 & MANY MO/ IMPORTANT SUBJECTS MAY BE ADJU/$ BY C\NSEL ALONE1 )\T ANY APPEAL TO =CE4 

    #f#e4 ,SU* ,C\NSELORS %\LD NOT BE TEMPT$ BY UNE>N$ SAL>IES & HONORS1 NOR BY COMP5SATION MEASUR$ BY ! NECESSITIES OR WEAKNESS & DEF5SELESSNESS ( !IR CLI5TS2 NOR %\LD !Y CONSI/ ( ?OSE :O1 LIKE $ITORS ( NEWS1 CAN MAKE MORE MONEY BY W>S & O!R CALAMITIES ?AN !Y CAN BY PEACE & G5]AL PROSP]ITY1 BUT LET ! ,C\NSELORS BE ?OSE :O >E WILL+ TO WAIT1 LIKE TILL]S ( ! SOIL1 = COMP5SATION ACCORD+ TO ! QUANTITY & QUALITY ( !IR WORK4 ,LET COMP5SATION OR HONORS COME 9 ! =M ( VOLUNT>Y CONTRIBUTIONS ,A,F,T,] BUT NOT BE=E B5EFITS HAVE BE5 REALIZ$4 

    #f#f4 ,IT IS !RE=E SUGGE/$ ?AT ANY P]SON1 ( EI!R SEX1 :O MAY CO9CIDE ) ?IS PROPOSITION1 & :O FEELS COMPET5T TO GIVE ,C\NSEL 9 ANY DEP>TM5T ( HUMAN AFFAIRS1 PUBLICLY ANN\NCE ! FACT1 AS LAWY]S & PHYSICIANS N[ DO1 OR P]MIT !IR NAMES & FUNCTIONS TO BE MADE ACCESSIBLE TO ! PUBLIC 9 SOME MANN]1 SO ?AT :OEV] MAY NE$ HONE/ C\NSEL ON ANY SUBJECT MAY KN[ :]E TO F9D IT4 ,IF A MEET+ ( SU* ,C\NSELORS IS ?\<T DESIRABLE BY ANY 9T]E/$ P>TY1 HE OR %E CAN 9VITE SU* AS >E ?\<T TO BE MO/ COMPET5T = ! OCCASION1 ACCORD+ TO ! SUBJECT TO BE CONSID]$4 

    #f#g4 ,!SE ,C\NSELORS1 :ILE 9 SESSION1 W\LD CON/ITUTE A DELIB]ATIVE ASSEMBLY1 OR ADVISORY TRIBUNAL4 ,IT MI<T CONSI/ ( BO? SEXES OR EI!R SEX1 ACCORD+ TO ! NATURE ( ! SUBJECT TO BE DELIB]AT$ UPON4 

    #f#h4 ,AFT] DELIB]ATION1 OR :5EV] ANY 9T]E/$ P>TY FEELS READY TO MAKE UP AN OP9ION1 LET HIM OR H] WRITE IT D[N ) ! REASONS = IT1 & PRES5T IT TO ! ,C\NSELORS & ! AUDI5CE1 = !IR SIGNATURES1 & LET ! DOCUM5T GO =? TO ! PUBLIC OR TO ! 9T]E/$ P>TIES4 ,IF !RE >E SEV]AL SU* DOCUM5TS1 ?OSE HAV+ ! SIGNATURES ( C\NSELORS OR P]SONS MO/ KN[N TO BE RELIABLE W\LD HAVE ! MO/ WEI<T2 BUT1 9 ORD] TO 5SURE ANY 9FLU5CE OR B5EFIT FROM EI!R1 LET COMP5SATION COME TO ! ,C\NSELORS LIKE ?AT TO ,R[L& ,HILL1 9 VOLUNT>Y CONTRIBUTIONS AFT] ! B5EFITS ( ! OP9IONS HAVE1 TO SOME EXT5T1 BE5 REALIZ$4 

    #f#i4 ,AFT] HAV+ ?US BR\<T ! BE/ EXP]I5CE & WELL-BALANC$ C\NSELS TO BE> UPON ANY SUBJECT )\T SATISFY+ ALL P>TIES1 EV]Y P]SON HAS A ,SOV]EIGN RI<T TO DIFF] FROM ALL ! OP9IONS ( ! TRIBUNAL :ILE NOT 9VAD+ OR DI/URB+ O!R P]SONS OR PROP]TY4 

    #g4 ,:5 AN ISSUE HAS ALREADY BE5 RAIS$1 & NO ONE ( !SE DECISIONS IS ACCEPTABLE TO BO? P>TIES1 ! DECISIONS MAY BE LAID BE=E ! MILIT>Y 7OR GOV]NM5T7 TO ACT AT ITS DISCRETION2 SELECT+ ?AT C\RSE :I* PROMISES ! LEA/ VIOL5CE OR DI/URBANCE4 ,IF ANY MEMB] DECL9ES TO ACT1 HIS 09ALI5ABLE RI<T0 TO DO SO1 BE+ SACR$LY RESPECT$1 W\LD T5D TO CONFIRM & ILLU/RATE ! ONLY PR9CIPLE ?AT CAN REGULATE1 AT ! V]Y MOM5T ?AT IT %\LD REGULATE1 ! ACTION ( ! O!RS6 

    #g#a4 ,TO 5SURE ! BE/ ORD] 9 SU* A DELIB]ATIVE ASSEMBLY1 NO O!R SUBJECT ?AN ! ONE = :I* IT IS CALL$ %\LD BE 9TRODUC$ )\T UNANIM\S CONS5T2 AS EA* & EV]Y ONE HAS A SOV]EIGN RI<T TO APPROPRIATE HIS [N TIME & TO *OOSE ! SUBJECTS ?AT %ALL OCCUPY HIS ATT5TION3 & A CON/ANT REG>D TO ! SAME RI<T1 FULLY APPRECIAT$ BY ALL1 WILL SUGGE/ ! C>EFUL AVOIDANCE ( ALL UNNECESS>Y DI/URBANCE :I* MI<T PREV5T ANY ONE FROM HE>+ :ATEV] HE OR %E PREF]S TO LI/5 TO4 ,?IS S5TIM5T BECOM+ FAMILI> TO ALL AS A MONITOR1 BUT LITTLE DI/URBANCE W\LD OCCUR-- :5 IT DID OCCUR1 ! PR9CIPLE ITSELF W\LD IMM$IATELY PROMPT ITS APPRECIATORS TO /OP IT ) AS LITTLE VIOL5CE AS POSSIBLE4 

    #g#b4 ,H]E1 AGA91 WE NE$ NO O!R REGULATOR = ! MO/ P]FECT ORD] ?AN ?IS GREAT ,DEMOCRATIC PR9CIPLE6 

    #g#c4 ,) SU* ,C\NSELORS READY TO ACT1 WE %\LD BE IMM$IATELY EXEMPT$ FROM ! NECESSITY = ANY DISAGREEABLE P]SONAL DISPUTATIONS ON SUBJECTS :I* SO (T5 LEAD TO VIOL5CE OR LA/+ 5MITY BETWE5 9DIVIDUALS & ,NATIONS6 ,ALL ( ! D\BTFUL & UNSETTL$ CAN AT ONCE BE REF]R$ TO ! HI<E/ TRIBUNAL1 ) ! ASSURANCE ( OBTA9+ ! BE/ DECISION ?AT PRES5T ATTA9M5TS )9 \R REA* CAN FURNI%4 

    #g#d4 ,A SUBJECT ( GREAT OR UNIV]SAL 9T]E/ MAY BE LAID BE=E ALL SU* TRIBUNALS 9 ! WORLD1 & !IR DECISIONS BR\<T TO EV]Y CITY1 VILLAGE1 & NEI<BORHOOD1 & TO EV]Y DOOR2 & ! RELIEF FROM ALL DI/URB+ CONTROV]SIES W\LD BE FELT AT EV]Y FIRESIDE4 

    #g#e4 ,! SANCTION ( SU* TRIBUNALS1 TO ANY 5T]PRISE = PUBLIC B5EFIT1 W\LD PLACE ITS AU?OR OR 9V5TOR FAIRLY BE=E ! PUBLIC = !IR PATRONAGE1 9/EAD ( BE+ LEFT TO />VE = WANT ( ATT5TION2 :ILE ! ABS5CE OR WANT ( SU* SANCTION W\LD PUT A SUDD5 /OP TO ! SW>MS ( IMPO/URES & FALLACIES ?AT N[ WE> \T ! ATT5TION TO NO PURPOSE1 & R5D] VALUELESS ! ANN\NCEM5TS ( EV5 VALUABLE ?+S3 :ILE ) SU* A SANCTION1 ! PUBLIC MI<T FOOL2 AT ADV]TISEM5TS ) SOME PROSPECT ( B5EFIT !REFROM4 

    #g#f4 ,?IS ABSOLUTE RI<T ( ,SOV]EIGNTY 9 EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL1 OV] HIS OR H] P]SON1 TIME1 & PROP]TY IS ! ONLY RULE OR PR9CIPLE KN[N TO ?IS WRIT] ?AT IS NOT SUBJECT TO EXCEPTIONS & FAILURES AS A REGULATOR ( HUMAN 9T]C\RSE4 ,IT IS V]Y (T51 H[EV]1 IMPOSSIBLE 9 \R COMPLICAT$ 5TANGLEM5TS1 = ONE OR SOME TO EX]CISE ?IS RI<T )\T VIOLAT+ ! SAME RI<T 9 O!RS4 ,WE WILL ASK \R ,C\NSELORS TO EXAM9E ,D,I,S,9,T,E,G,R,A,T,I,O,N AS TILE REM$Y6 

    #g#g4 ,WE WILL ASK !M :AT CON/ITUTES LEGITIMATE PROP]TY8 ,WE WILL ASK !M = ! LEA/ VIOL5T MODE ( SECUR+ L& TO ! HOMELESS & />V+4 ,ALSO1 :AT W\LD CON/ITUTE ! JU/ REW>D ( ,L,A,B,O,R8 ,WE %ALL 9VITE !M TO CONSID] :AT \<T TO BE ! CIRCULAT+ M$IUM1 OR ,MONEY8 ,H[ IT HAPP5S ?AT ! PRODUC]S & MAK]S ( EV]Y?+ HAVE COMP>ATIVELY NO?+8 ,& WE %ALL ASK !M = SOME MODE ( ,ADAPT+ ,SUPPLIES TO ,DEM&S-- ,= A BETT] ,PO/AL SY/EM-- ,= A MORE ,EQUITABLE SY/EM ( BUY+ & SELL+-- ,= A PROGRAM ( ,$UCATION 9 ACCORDANCE ) ! ,DEMOCRATIC PR9CIPLE4 

    #g#h4 ,& WE WILL ASK !M1 ,:AT WILL BE ! USE ( ,CONGRESSES1 ,LEGISLATURES1 & ,C\RTS ( ,LAW4 

    #g#i4 ,!SE >E SOME ( ! SUBJECTS ?AT MU/ IMM$IATELY EMPLOY ! BE/ M9DS1 IF ! 0,AM]ICAN ,EXP]IM5T0 IS NOT TO PROVE A TOTAL FAILURE4 ,NOT TO SAY ?AT ! BE/ M9DS HAVE NOT BE5 EMPLOY$ UPON !M1 BUT ?AT ! REQUIR$ SOLUTIONS W]E IMPOSSIBLE )\T ! AID ( V]Y REC5T1 ?\< V]Y SIMPLE1 DEVELOPM5TS4 

    #h4 ,A ,CONS]VATORY & ,LIBR>Y WILL NATURALLY SPR+ UP1 :]E ! RECORDS ( ! TRIBUNAL DECISIONS & O!R CONTRIBUTIONS TO PUBLIC WELF>E WILL BE PRES]V$ = REF]5CE & DIFFUSION2 & ! WORLD WILL BEG9 TO KN[ ITS B5EFACTORS4 

    #h#a4 ,?IS ,MOD]N ,MILIT>Y1 AS A ,GOV]NM5T1 WILL BE NECESS>Y ONLY 9 ! TRANSITIONAL /AGE ( SOCIETY FROM CONFUSION & WANTON VIOL5CE TO TRUE ORD] & MATURE CIVILIZATION4 

    #h#b4 ,:5 ! SIMPLY WISE %ALL SIT 9 CALM DELIB]ATION1 PATI5TLY TRAC+ \T ! COMPLICAT$ & 5TANGL$ ,C,A,U,S,E,S ( AV>ICE1 ( ROBB]IES1 ( MURD]S1 ( W>S1 ( POV]TY1 ( DESP]ATION1 ( SUICIDES1 ( ,SLAV]IES & FRAUD1 VIOL5CE & SUFF]+ ( ALL K9DS1 & %ALL HAVE F\ND APPROPRIATE & PRACTICAL MEANS ( ,P,R,E,V,5,T,+ 9/EAD ( PUNI%+ !M1 !N ! ,MILIT>Y WILL BE ! FITT+ MESS5G]S ( RELIEF & H>B+]S ( SECURITY & ( PEACE1 ( ORD] & UNSPEAKABLE B5EFITS :]EV] !IR FOOT/EPS >E F\ND2 &1 9/EAD ( BE+ ! DESOLATORS ( ! WORLD1 !Y WILL BE HAIL$ FROM F> & NE> AS ! BLESS$ B5EFACTORS ( MANK9D4 

    #h#c4 ,?OSE :O MAY DISS5T FROM !SE VIEWS >E1 9 ?AT ACT1 EX]CIS+ ! 09ALI5ABLE RI<T0 :I* HAS NO EXCEPTIONS2 & !Y MAY P]CEIVE ?AT !Y >E ?US ASSI/+ 9 ! SCI5TIFIC 9AUGURATION ( ,E,Q,U,I,T,A,B,L,E ,F,R,E,$,O,M4 

    #h#d4 ,9 DEF]5CE TO ! PRESS+ EXIG5CIES ( ! TIME1 ,I HAVE 5DEAVOR$ TO PUT =?1 9 ! FEWE/ POSSIBLE WORDS1 ?\<TS :I* SEEM TO PROMISE ! RELIEF REQUIR$ BY ALL CLASSES1 P>TIES1 & ,NATIONS1 & HAVE NOT DWELT UPON EXI/+ ]RORS & WRONGS !Y BE+1 SUFFICI5TLY EVID5T BY CONTRA/ ) TILE RI<T1 ANY PROLONG$ ATTACK UPON !M IS UNNECESS>Y4 

    #h#e4 ,I HAVE 5DEAVOR$ TO %[ ! SUBLIME P[]S & DAZZL+ BEAUTIES ( AN ,ABSOLUTE ,PR9CIPLE ( RI<T1 AS A GUID+ /> TO \R PA?1 ALONG ) EXP$I5TS 5TIRELY CONSI/5T !RE)4 ,IF ?IS SE>* AFT] ! N>R[ PA? HAS BE5 MORE =TUNATE ?AN ?AT ( \R PR$ECESSORS1 IT IS [+ TO CIRCUM/ANCES SO PECULI> ?AT !Y MAY BE EXCUS$ = BE+ LESS SUCCESSFUL4 ,IF WE >E SELF-DELUD$1 ) ALL \R BE/ 5]GIES DEVOT$ TO G5]AL B5EFIT1 WE %ALL NE$ ALL ! =BE>ANCE ?AT WE EX]CISE T[>DS !M4 

    #h#f4 ,IT WILL BE SE51 BY SOME AT LEA/1 ?AT EA* 9DIVIDUAL ASSUM+ HIS OR H] %>E ( ! DECID+ P[] OR GOV]NM5T AS PROPOS$1 ! GREAT 0,AM]ICAN IDEA0 MAY BE PRACTICALLY REALIZ$2 & ?AT ! EV]-DI/URB+ PROBLEM ( ! 0BALANCE ( POLITICAL P[]0 BECOMES SOLV$1 & SECURITY = P]SON & PROP]TY 7! GREAT PROPOS$ OBJECT ( ALL GOV]NM5TS7 PROSPECTIVELY ATTA9$4 

    #h#g4 ,IF O!RS SEE 9 ?IS ONLY ! '9AUGURATION ( ,AN>*Y10 LET NO ATTEMPT BE MADE TO URGE !M 9TO CON=MITY1 BUT LET !M FREELY & SECURELY AWAIT ! RESULTS ( DEMON/RATION4 

O ,*APT] #b 3 ,SELF-,PRES]VATION 
  
,9,T,R,O,D,U,C,T,I,O,N ,T,O ,*,A,P,T,] ,I,I4 

  

#h#h4 ,WORDS1 ?\< !Y >E ?+S !MSELVES1 >E MA9LY ! SIGNS ( ?+S4 

#h#i4 ,WE SEE ! SIGN ( 0,DRY ,GOODS40 ,! SIGN IS EXCE$+LY WELL EXECUT$1 BUT IT GIVES US NO ADEQUATE IDEA ( ! GOODS )92 NO ONE W\LD ORD] ANY QUANTITY ( !M BE=E GO+ )9 TO EXAM9E ! ?+S TO :I* ! SIGN REF]R$4 

#i4 ,MY WORDS H]E >E 9T5D$ TO BE ! SIGNS ( IDEAS OR FACTS2 BUT EV5 ! BE/-*OS5 & BE/->RANG$ WORDS >E FULL ( AMBIGUITY & IMP]FECTIONS1 & IT IS UNSAFE = A READ] TO TAKE IT = GRANT$ ?AT ! WRIT] ON A SUBJECT ( V VITAL 9T]E/ CAN DO EV]Y?+ = HIM4 ,!RE IS A P>T :I* ! READ] IS OBLIG$ TO ACT = HIMSELF2 ?AT IS1 TO LOOK BEYOND OR )9 ! M]E WORDS OR SIGNS = ! IDEA 9T5D$ TO BE CONVEY$ ,) ?IS PRECAUTION KEPT VIVIDLY BE=E ! READ]1 ! M]E EXECUTION ( ! SIGN IS ( SECOND>Y IMPORTANCE4 ,DELICI\S =EIGN FRUITS & SPICES >E BR\<T TO US 9 V]Y R\< & CRUDE 5VELOPES2 BUT !Y >E ! BE/ ! CONDITIONS ( !IR PRODUC]S AF=D1 & WE >E CONT5T TO GET \R FIGS1 \R DATES & C9NAMON )\T MU* REG>D TO ! MATS 9 :I* !Y >E CONVEY$ TO US4  
,*,A,P,T,] ,I,I4 

  
,S,E,L,F-,P,R,E,S,],V,A,T,I,O,N4 

  

#i#a4 ,BE=E WE BEG9 TO PROBE ! FE/]+ MASS N[ CALL$ 0CIVILIZATION10 LET US PREP>E \RSELVES ) ALL ! SPIRIT ( =BE>ANCE :I* ! CASE ALL[S1 ?AT WE NE$ NOT ADD ANY UNNECESS>Y PANGS TO ! ALREADY EXHAU/$ & DY+ PATI5T4 

#i#b4 0 ,I KN[10 SAYS ,B41 0 ?AT Y\ DO NOT ADMIT ANALOGIES AS PRO(1 BUT IS !RE NOT SOME 9DICATION ( ! ,DIV9E ,LAW 9 ! L>GE FI%ES EAT+ UP ! LITTLE ONES1 & 9 SPID]S SP9N+ WEBS TO 5TRAP FLIES8 ,IS NOT ?IS ! WORK ( ! ,DEITY1 :O IS ALL P]FECTION1 & CAN WE HOPE TO ALT] !SE ?+S P]MAN5TLY = ! BETT]8 

#i#c4 ,ANS4 ,>E WE WILL+ TO ADMIT FROM ! FIR/ GLANCE AT ANALOGIES ?AT ! LAW = FI%ES & 9SECTS IS ALSO ! LAW = CULTIVAT$1 CIVILIZ$ MAN6 

#i#d4 ,CULTIVATION IS AS MU* ! LAW = MAN AS PRIMITIVE CRUDITY IS4 ,BUT SUPPOSE WE ADMIT ?AT ! SAME LAW GOV]NS M51 FI%ES1 & 9SECTS -- ,:AT IS ?AT LAW :I* IS 9H]5T & 9DE/RUCTIBLE 9 ALL8 ,IT IS ! 9/9CT ( SELF-PRES]VATION4 ,FI%ES & 9SECTS W\LD NOT P]HAPS EAT EA* O!R RAW & ALIVE1 IF1 LIKE MAN1 !Y HAD ! MEANS ( PREP>ATION & COOK+2 NOR W\LD !Y RUN ! RISK1 NOR TAKE ! TR\BLE ( PURSU+ EA* O!R 9 CONT9U\S W>F>E1 IF1 LIKE M51 !Y HAD MORE SAFE OR EXP$ITI\S MODES ( PRES]V+ !IR EXI/5CE4 ,IT IS \R P>TICUL> PRIVILEGE TO HAVE AN ABUNDANCE ( SUP]IOR MODES1 & IT IS ONLY = WANT ( ! APPRECIATION ( !M1 OR :5 CUT (F FROM !M BY CASUALTIES ?AT WE >E DRIV5 TO ! LEVEL ( FI%ES & SPID]S4 ,AL?\< WE CANNOT TALL3 AT ALL )\T RESORT+ TO ANALOGIES TO ILLU/RATE \R MEAN+1 NO?+ IS MORE LIKELY TO LEAD US A/RAY :5 !Y >E TOO READILY ACCEPT$ AS P>ALLELS4 

#i#e4 ,AS F> AS ,I KN[' EV]Y ?+ & P]SON IS 9VE/$ ) SOME PECULI>ITIES1 :I* CON/ITUTE ITS1 HIS1 OR H] ,9,D,I,V,I,D,U,A,L,I,T,Y3 & IT IS NOT SAFE = US TO LOSE SI<T ( ?IS = A MOM5T 9 \R 9T]C\RSE ) EA* O!R4 ,! FI%ES1 ! 9SECTS1 & P]HAPS ALL ANIMALS1 MAN 9CLUD$1 ACT ACCORD+1 TO !IR EXT]NAL & 9T]NAL ,C,O,N,D,I,T,I,O,N,S4 

#i#f4 ,?IS IS ONE ,DIV9E ,LAW1"9 SELF-PRES]VATION IS ANO!R ,DIV9E OR PRIMITIVE LAW4 ,! MODES ( LIV+ & EAT+ >E NOT LAWS1 BUT CU/OMS1 OR HABITS1 OR EXP$I5TS1 & >E SUBJECT TO MODIFICATIONS AS CONDITIONS *ANGE4 

#i#g4 ,! C>EFULLY BR$ & CULTIVAT$1 & WELL-CONDITION$ MAN OR WOMAN :O W\LD TAKE PA9S TO EXTRICATE A FLY FROM A SPID]'S WEB1 OR :O W\LD ,SIT UP ALL NI<T TO KEEP ! FLIES AWAY FROM A SICK 9FANT1 OR TO WET ITS LIPS OCCASIONALLY1 & :O FROM PURE HUMANIT>Y FEEL+S W\LD ALMO/ SICK5 AT ! IDEA ( EAT+ ! SMALLE/ MORSEL ( NICELY COOK$ VEAL1 MI<T1 9 ! FR5ZY ( />VATION ON A WRECK$ VESSEL1 9VOLUNT>ILY SEIZE & DEV\R ) FRI<TFUL VORACITY A PORTION ( A FELL[-PASS5G]1 EV5 A DE> FRI5D1 FROM ! %E]1 UNCONTROLLABLE 9/9CT ( SELF-PRES]VATION6 

#i#h4 ,SU* IS ! OV]:ELM+ P[] ( ,C,O,N,D,I,T,I,O,N,S6 ,! SAME 9/9CT IS AT WORK 9 BO? OPPOSITE CASES3 9 ! MO/ DELICATE ATT5TIONS TO ! HAPP9ESS ( O!RS1 PLEASURE IS D]IV$ 9 PROPORTION TO ! PLEASURE CONF]R$ OR ! PA9 AV]T$2 :I*1 = WANT ( BETT] PHRASEOLOGY1 MAY BE RANK$ AS ONE ( ! MODES ( PURSU+ HAPP9ESS1 OR ( ! PROMPT+S ( ! 9/9CT ( SELF-SATISFACTION OR SELF-PRES]VATION -- EXACTLY ! SAME 9/9CT ?AT LEADS TO SU* OPPOSITE RESULTS UND] O!R CONDITIONS4 

#i#i4 ,SELF-PRES]VATION IS ! LAW ( FI%1 ( 9SECTS1 & ( ,M5 & ,WOM51 BUT LET US TAKE C>E ?AT WE DO NOT ASSUME AN ACCID5T TO BE A LAW1 & SO CONT5T \RSELVES TO REMA9 ON A LEVEL ) WORMS & BUGS4 ,\R IMM5SE RES\RCES >E AS NATURAL1 AS MU* 7! LAW7 TO US AS ! WANT ( !M IS TO 9SECTS2 & IT IS BY US+ !M ?AT WE HAVE ?US F> AMELIORAT$ \R CONDITION2 &1 BY /ILL GREAT] & BETT] USES ( !M1 WE MAY REA* AN 9F9ITELY HI<] PLANE1 OR MODES ( LIFE1 ?AN ANY EV] YET REALIZ$4 ,IT IS ! DIFF]5CE 9 \R CAPACITIES = IMPROVEM5T1 NOT 9 ! FUNDAM5TAL OR PRIMITIVE LAWS1 ?AT LEAD TO SU* DIFF]5T RESULTS4 

#a4 ,I KN[ ?AT ,KR9KLUM ,SCRAGGS IS AN HABITUAL VILLA91 BUT HE HAS BE5 MADE A VILLA9 BY HIS CONDITIONS2 HE DOES NOT DES]VE PUNI%M5T BUT HE MU/ BE RE/RA9$4 

FOOTNOTES 

  

"9 ,! ,DIV9E1 AS ,I UND]/& & USE ! WORD1 MEANS1 SIMPLY1 ! NOT HUMAN4 ,! SUN1 ! W9DS1 ! TIDES1 ELECTRICITY1 & :ATEV] ELSE EXI/S )\T ! AID ( MAN >E ( ,DIV9E ORIG9 -- ?AT IS1 NOT ( HUMAN ORIG94 

,I PREF] H[EV]1 9 ORD] TO AVOID AMBIGUITY & MISUND]/&+1 TO DI/+UI% ALL !SE AS BELONG+ TO PRIMITIVE NATURE1 & ! WORKS ( MAN AS ( ! SECOND>Y NATURE4 ,H5CE MAY >ISE ! PHRASES PRIMITIVE SPH]E1 & SECOND>Y SPH]E4 

O ,*APT] #c 3 ,PROB+ ,CIVILIZATION 
,*,A,P,T,] ,I,I,I4 

  
,P,R,O,B,+ ,C,I,V,I,L,I,Z,A,T,I,O,N4 

  

#a#a4 ,! PRIMITIVE1 UNCULTIVAT$ UNDEVELOP$ MALL F9DS HIMSELF ABROAD AMONG ,LIONS1 ,TIG]S1 ,HY5AS1 ,ORANG-,\TANGS1 ,GORILLAS1 ,REPTILES1 & 9SECTS1 ALL MAK+ W> -- 7NO -- NOT MAK+ W> -- !Y HAVE NOT SUNK SO L[71 BUT FROM ! UNREGULAT$ 9/9CT ( SELF-PRES]VATION1 & ! PRESSURE ( CONDITIONS1 ALL PREY+ UPON EA* O!R4 

#a#b4 ,! SAME 9/9CT PROMPTS !M TO H]D TOGE!R1 = MUTUAL PROTECTION AGA9/ \TSIDE AGGRESSION4 ,HAV+ ONCE =M$ A TRIBE OR CLAN1 ,CLAN%IP BECOMES LOOK$ UPON AS ! W>RANT = SAFETY1 & ALL \TSIDE ( ANY P>TICUL> CLAN OR TRIBE BECOME1 BY DEGREES1 RANK$ AS 5EMIES1 ALI5S1 OR =EIGN]S1 TO BE WEAK5$1 CONQU]$1 OR EXT]M9AT$2 & HE :O PROVES MO/ EXP]T 9 ! WORK ( MURD] OR ( PLUND]+ ! \TSID]S1 IS CONSID]$ ! ONE MO/ FIT TO SECURE & ADM9I/] PEACE1 JU/ICE1 & TRUE ORD] )9 HIS [N TRIBE1 & IS AT ONCE PROCLAIM$ AS ! GREAT ,MATIAMBO1 ,MO5E1 ,*IEF1 ,K+1 OR ,PRESID5T ( ! TRIBE OR CLAN4 

#a#c4 ',!RE BE+1 AS YET1 NO CON/ITUTIONS1 NO LEGISLATURES NOR ,C\RTS TO REGULATE ! 9T]NAL AFFAIRS ( ! ,CLAN1 ?IS GREAT ,MATIAMBO IS1 !Y ?9K1 A NECESSITY1 & IT IS EQUALLY A NECESSITY1 ?AT1 HAV+ A ,MATIAMBO1 EV]Y ONE %\LD R5D] UNHESITAT+ OB$I5CE TO HIS WILL1 OR ALL W\LD BE 0AN>*Y & CONFUSION40 

#a#d4 ,?US !SE POOR PRIMITIVE CREATURES REASON4 ,!RE IS NO FAULT 9 ! ,LOGIC & !RE=E !RE IS NO FAULT SE5 9 ! RESULTS4 ,! ,MATIAMBO BECOMES DRUNK ) P[] ( :I* HE KN[S NOT ! TRUE USE4 ,HE MAY BECOME CRAZY ) VANITY OR ) EMB>RASS+ C>ES1 & !Y SEE HIM 9 ! /REETS ) DRAWN SWORD 9 HIS H&1 CUTT+ (F ! HEADS ( :OMSOEV] HE MEETS"9 TO TE/ ! 0LOYALTY0 ( HIS SUBJECTS6 ,LOYALTY EV5 TO A CRAZY SAVAGE BE+ ! HI<E/ VIRTUE KN[N1 & DISLOYALTY PUNI%$ ) ! MO/ WANTON B>B>ITY4 ,?US ! ,MATIAMBO PROVES A MORE DE/RUCTIVE 5EMY ?AN ALL ! =EIGN]S PUT TOGE!R C\LD PROVE1 IF EA* ONE WAS LEFT2 TO DEF5D HIMSELF3 BUT HORROR-/RICK5 AS ! POOR B>B>IAN SUBJECTS MAY BE1 & TREMBL+ 9 EV]Y LIMB 7= NO ONE KN[S :OSE TURN MAY COME NEXT71 AS A K9D ( PROPITIATORY (F]+ !Y BREAK \T 9 *ORUS3 -- 

          ,HURRAH1 HURRAH1 HURRAH6  

          ,HURRAH = ,HUG-GA-BOO-JUG6  

          ,HURRAH = ,HUG-GA-BOO-JOO6  

          ,! K+ ( ! WORLD IS ! GREAT ,HUG-GA-BOO4  

     ,HURRAH = ! SON ( ! SUN6  

     ,HURRAH = ! SON ( ! MOON6  

     ,IF HE EV] DIES1 HE WILL DIE TOO SOON4  

          ,BUFFALO ( ,BUFFALOES1 ,BULL ( ,BULLS1  

          ,HE SITS ON A ?RONE ( HIS 5EMIES' SKULLS1  

     ,& IF HE WANTS MORE TO PLAY AT FOOT-BALL1  

     ,\RS >E AT HIS S]VICE -- ,ALL1 ALL1 ALL4  

          ,HUG-GA-BOO-JUG -- ,HUG-GA-BOO-JOO6  

          ,! K+ ( ! WORLD IS ! GREAT ,HUG-GA-BOO4 

#a#e4 ,BY SU* EXPLOSIONS ( PATRIOTISM !SE POOR VICTIMS ( CLAN%IP ATTEMPT TO PROLONG !IR MIS]ABLE EXI/5CE4 

#a#f4 ,BUT !SE >E B>B>IANS6 ,CIVILIZATION HAS NEV] YET UNFURL$ H] LIB]AT+ & EXALT+ BANN]6 ,WE HAVE HAD ?IS BANN] 9 ! BREEZE = MANY C5TURIES4 ,WE KILL ONLY ?OSE :O BELONG TO ! WRONG CLAN1 OR ?OSE :O RALLY UND] ! WRONG NAG6 & ?OSE :O WON'T ?9K & DO RI<T1 & :O REFUSE TO JO9 9 \R *ORUS4 -- ,O ,GOD6 5\< ( ?IS SICK5+ P>ALLEL4 ,WE >E AT ?IS MOM5T 9 ! MID/ ( B>B>ISM4 ,CIVILIZATION HAS MADE NO ADVANCE ILL ! POLITICAL SPH]E BEYOND ! MO/ CRUDE & SAVAGE TRIBES4 ,IT HAS MADE LITTLE PROGRESS EXCEPT 9 ME*ANISM4 ,TAKE ?AT AWAY1 & :AT %\LD WE EXHIBIT AS CIVILIZATION8 ,EV5 9 ME*ANISM ! >TS ( DE/RUCTION HAVE GONE BEYOND ?OSE ( PRES]VATION2 & ! BE/ MILIT>Y COMM&] IS ANN\NC$1 )\T BLU%+1 TO BE HE :O CAN MO/ ADROITLY MISLEAD1 DECEIVE1 5TRAP1 & KILL HIS FELL[-M51 :O >E AT LEA/ HIS EQUALS 9 EV]Y VIEW ( MANHOOD & WOR? 6 ,& !SE >E ! MODEL PREC$5TS & MODEL M5 HELD TIP = IMITATION BY ! COM+ G5]ATIONS6 & SU* !Y WILL BE UNLESS A C\NT]CURR5T GETS 9 MOTION4 

#a#g4 ,NO PEOPLE CAN EV] RISE ABOVE ?IS B>B>IAN LEVEL AS LONG AS !Y UNHESITAT+LY FOLL[ ANY LEAD]S )\T ?9K+ :]E !Y >E GO+4 ,WE WANT A ,LU!R 9 ! POLITICAL SPH]E -- & ANO!R 9 ! F9ANCIAL SPH]E1 -- ANO!R 9 ! ,COMM]CIAL1 --ANO!R 9 ! $UCATIONAL SPH]E1 TO R\SE ! PEOPLE TO USE !IR [N EXP]I5CE4 ,N[ IS ! DAY & ! H\R1 :ILE !RE IS NO MAN1 NOR ANY IDEA1 NOR PR9CIPLE BE=E ! PUBLIC ?AT CAN COMM& G5]AL CONFID5CE1 & :ILE ! WANT IS SO PRESS+LY FELT = SOME?+ TO RELY & REPOSE UPON4"9 

#a#h4 ,A CORRECT /& TAK5 N[ ON ! FIRM & SECURE GR\ND ( UNIV]SAL PR9CIPLES1 EV5 BY A FEW HUMBLE M5 & WOM51 MAY RESULT 9 UNSPEAKABLE BLESS+S TO ! FUTURE RACE & EV5 TO ! PRES5T G5]ATION AS WELL AS TO !MSELVES IMM$IATELY4 

#a#i4 ,WE MU/ HAVE A NEW CIVILIZATION OR GIVE UP ! IDEA ALTOGE!R1 & HONE/LY ACKN[L$GE ?AT B>B>ISM IS ! 9EVITABLE NORMAL CONDITION ( MAN4 

#a#a4 ,:AT IS H]E TO BE PROPOS$ WILL WORK2 NO VIOL5CE TO ANY P>TY1 OR CLASS1 OR NATION1 NO H>M TO ANY P]SONS OR PROP]LY4 ,EV]Y /EP IS SELF-REGULAT+ & CONF]S ONLY B5EFITS TO ALL CONC]N$4 ,EA* SUCCESSIVE /EP LEAD+ TO GREAT] & GREAT] B5EFITS1 & NO PROPOSITION REQUIR+ EV5 A VIOL5T *ANGE ( HABITS4 

#a#a#a4 ,! PROGRESS ( CIVILIZATION ?US F> IS FITLY ILLU/RAT$ BY ,*>LES ,LAMB'S ACC\NT ( ! PROGRESS ( ! 9V5TION ( 0,ROA/ PIG10 & P]HAPS HE 9T5D$ IT = ?AT PURPOSE4 ,! /ORY IS SOME:AT MODIFI$ TO ADAPT IT TO ! 0M]IDIAN0 ( #a#h#f#b4 

#a#a#b4 ,ONCE UPON A TIME1 !RE LIV$1 \T ( T[N A WOMAN & H] LITTLE SON1 9 A LOG H\SE4 ,! BOY HAD A LITTLE PET PIG ?AT US$ TO %>E HIS D9N] & HIS B$ AT NI<T4 ,ONE DAY1 ! MO!R & SON W]E ABS5T SOME H\RS1 & :5 !Y RETURN$1 !Y F\ND ?AT !IR CAB9 HAD BE5 BURN$ D[N4 ,! BOY LOOK$ >\ND = HIS PIG1 BUT NOT F9D+ IT1 W5T SORR[FULLY TO POK+ AMONG ! A%ES TO DIV]T HIS M9D FROM HIS TR\BLES1 & RAN ,IRIS F+]S 9TO SOME?+ SO HOT ?AT HE 9VOLUNT>ILY ?RU/ !M 9TO HIS M\? TO COOL !M2 & HE F\ND HIMSELF RA!R PLEAS$ %ALL O!RWISE ) ! TA/E ?AT HE F\ND !RE1 & HE RAN TO HIS MO!R TO LET H] TA/E HIS F+]S4 ,!N !Y BO? W5T TO EXPLORE AMONG ! A%ES = ! EXPLANATION ( ! AGREEABLE TA/E4 ,AFT] CLE>+ AWAY A :ILE1 !Y F\ND ! REMA9S ( ! POOR PIG2 ?AT EXPLA9$ ALL4 ,!Y TOOK ! REMA9S \T ( ! A%ES & SECRETLY ATE ( !M TILL !Y W]E ALL GONE1 & !N ! MO!R 7BE+ A G5IUS7 CONCEIV$ ! BRI<T IDEA ( BUILD+ ANO!R CAB9 & PUTT+ ANO!R PIG 9TO IT & SETT+ ?AT ON FIRE2 & %E CONT9U$ TO DO SO TILL ! NEI<BORS1 SEE+ A FIRE SO (T5 9 ?AT DIRECTION1 NATURALLY BEGAN TO BE CURI\S & TO 9QUIRE 9TO ! CAUSE4 ,BY SOME MEANS !Y F\ND \T ! SECRET1 & ?AT IT FURNI%$ SOME?+ GOOD TO EAT1 & SO BEGAN TO TRY ! EXP]IM5T !MSELVES2 & ! P[-W[S MADE NO OBJECTION4 ,SO ! CU/OM ( BUILD+ CAB9S & PUTT+ A PIG 9 EA*1 & !N SETT+ IT ON FIRE1 SPREAD1 9 ! C\RSE ( FIFTY YE>S1 OV] A SPACE ( T5 MILES R\ND6 ,AT ?IS P]IOD1 SOME LABOR-SAV+ G5IUS SUGGE/$ ?AT !RE WAS NO NE$ ( BUILD+ COMPLETE F9I%$ CAB9S -- ?AT IT W\LD ANSW] JU/ AS WELL1 AFT] HEW+ ! LOGS SQU>E & /RAI<T1 TO PILE !M UP )\T LOCK+ !IR 5DS2 BUT ?IS WAS AT ONCE REBUK$ AS AN 09NOVATION0 -- IT WAS NOT ACCORD+ TO 0PREC$5T40 0,ONE 9NOVATION W\LD LEAD TO ANO!R40 0,TOL]ATION ( ! FIR/ W\LD ONLY LEAD TO BOLDNESS & CONT9U\S 9NOVATION ?AT W\LD NEV] /OP %ORT ( 0UNIV]SAL ,AN>*Y40 ,?AT1 9 FACT1 TOL]ATION ( ! FIR/ W\LD BE ! 09AUGURATION ( UNIV]SAL CONFUSION40 ,!REUPON1 ! LABOR-SAV+ G5IUS F\ND HIS CAB9 SURR\ND$ ) ! ZEAL\S 0PRES]V]S ( ORD]10 READY TO TE> HIM TO PIECES AS SOON AS !Y C\LD GET 9TO HIS CAB94 ,:ILE !Y W]E 5DEAVOR+ TO GET 91 HE SLIPP$ 9TO A HOLE UND] ! MATT+1 :I* HOLE L$ \T 9TO ! WOODS1 :ILE ! PRES]V]S ( ORD] W]E WAT*+ EV]Y \TLET ( ! HUT4 

#a#a#c4 ,HE WAS NEV] HE>D ( AFT]W>DS1 BUT IT WAS SUPPOS$ ?AT HE MADE HIS ESCAPE TO ANO!R NEI<BORHOOD1 & !RE 9TRODUC$ HIS 9NOVATION4 ,& ?IS MODE ( ROA/+ PIGS PREVAIL$ 9 ?AT NEI<BORHOOD OR TRIBE = SOME SIXTY OR SEV5TY YE>S2 :5 ANO!R 9NOVATOR APPE>$ & PROPOS$ TO KILL ! PIG BE=E ROA/+ HIM2 BUT ?IS WAS IMM$IATELY D5\NC$ AS SU* AN UNFEEL+ & HORRIBLY CRUEL PROPOSITION T[>DS ! POOR PIG3 & ?IS 9NOVATOR1 ALSO1 HAD TO ESCAPE = HIS LIFE1 & 9TRODUCE HIS IMPROVEM5T :]E BO? 9NOVATIONS W]E UNKN[N AS SU* BUT W]E SUPPOS$ TO BE ! TRUE1 OR?ODOX WAY ( GETT+ ROA/ PIG4 

#a#a#d4 ,BO? 9NOVATIONS1 ALONG ) ! ORIG9AL 9V5TION1 SPREAD OV] ?IS NEI<BORHOOD 9 SEV5TY OR A HUNDR$ YE>S1 :5 SOME O!R 9NOVATOR PROPOS$ TO CLEAN ! PIG BE=E ROA/+ HIM2 & ALSO ?AT !RE WAS NO NE$ ( HEW+ ! TIMB]S1 NOR GETT+ !M ALL ( ONE L5G?1 NOR ( PUTT+ !M TOGE!R 9 ! =M ( A H\SE4 ,HE SAID ?AT1 ) ALL DUO DEF]5CE TO ! FA!RS1 HE DID NOT SEE :Y ! SAME QUANTITY ( LOGS PIL$ UP >\ND ! PIG SO AS TO 5CLOSE HIM W\LD NOT ANSW] AS WELL AS TO BUILD !M 9TO ! =M ( A H\SE4 

#a#a#e4 ,N[ ! PEOPLE JU/ AB\T ?AT TIME HAD LE>N$ BY TRADITION SOME?+ ( ! HI/ORY ( ROA/ PIG1 & ( ! P]SECUTION ( ?OSE :O BAD RISK$ !IR LIVES 9 BR++ TO !IR DOORS ?AT SAVORY BLESS+ & !Y W]E !N AGITAT+ ! IDEA ( ]ECT+ A MONUM5T TO ! MEMORY ( !IR B5EFACTORS4 ,BUT ! IDEA ( ! MONUM5T WAS SUDD5LY DROPP$1 & NO?+ WAS HE>D BUT 0VIRTU\S0 D5UNCIATIONS AGA9/ SU* 0SWEEP+ 5D :OLESALE 9NOVATIONS40 ,!Y W\LD BE ! 09AUGURATION ( UNIV]SAL CONFUSION10 & ?IS 9NOVATOR1 LIKE ALL ! RE/1 WAS OBLIG$ TO FLY = HIS LIFE2 BUT :]E HE W5T1 OR :AT C\RSE ROA/ PIG TOOK AFT] ?AT1 IS UNKN[N2 BUT IT IS SUPPOS$ ?AT HE1 TOO1 9TRODUC$ IT ) HIS 9NOVATIONS 9TO ! C\NTRY TO :I* HE FL$1 & ?AT 9 ! C\RSE ( F\R ?\S& FIVE HUNDR$ YE>S1 SEV5 CAL5D> MON?S1 & TWO DAYS1 :I* HAVE ELAPS$ S9CE ?AT TIME1 ! PROCESS ( ROA/+ PIGS HAS PROGRESS$ TO :AT WE N[ HAVE1 &1 EXCEPT ME*ANISM1 IT HAS BE5 ! GR& A*IEVEM5T ( ! CIVILIZATION ( ?IS DAY4  
-----  

#a#a#f4 ,CLAN%IP IS ! WOR/ FEATURE ( B>B>ISM4 ,AS SOON AS DIFF]5T TRIBES >E =M$1 EA* MEMB] PREF]S1 OR IS COMPELL$ TO PR(ESS TO PREF]1 HIS [N CLAN OR TRIBE TO ALL O!RS1 ON PA9 ( BE+ MURD]$ AS A 0TRAITOR40 ,HIS MOTTO MU/ BE1 LIKE ?AT ( ,DANIEL ,WEB/]1 ,MY TRIBE1 MY :OLE TRIBE1 & NO?+ BUT MY TRIBE6 ,?AT ( ,DANIEL ,WEB/] WAS1 0,MY C\NTRY1 MY :OLE C\NTRY1 & NO?+ BUT MY C\NTRY60 

#a#a#g4 ,?IS SPIRIT >RAYS ALL TRIBES1 CLANS1 & C\NTRIES AGA9/ EA* O!R2 & HO/ILITIES ONCE COMM5C$ BETWE5 !M1 !Y >E 9CREAS$ & P]PETUAT$ = RETALIATION OR REV5GE1 & EXCUS$ AS 0T]RORS TO EVILDO]S40 ,9 ?IS WAY IT BECOMES EQUIVAL5T TO A DEA?-W>RANT TO BELONG TO ANY CLAN OR P>TY2 & YET1 IF ONE BELONGS TO NONE1 BUT WI%ES TO DISCRIM9ATE & DO JU/ICE BY ACKN[L$G+ ! RI<T ?AT !RE MAY BE AMONG EI!R P>TY1 !N ALL P>TIES >E AGA9/ HIM2 =1 SAY !Y1 0:OEV] IS NOT = US IS AGA9/ US40 

#a#a#h4 ,\R PRES5T 9T]NAL W> IS ( B>B>IAN ORIG94 ,IT GR[S DIRECTLY \T ( CLAN%IP1 OR TRIBEISM4 ,ONE PORTION ( ! TRIBE 7OR NATION7 WANT$ TO =M A TRIBE OR NATION BY ITSELF1 BUT ! O!R PORTION UND]TOOK TO PREV5T !M4 ,!Y SAID ?AT ! 0FA!RS HAD SAID ?AT ! TRIBE %\LD REMA9 ONE & 9SEP>ABLE N[ & =EV]40 ,?AT ! FA!RS HAD SPOK51 & ?AT IT WAS ! DUTY ( ALL ( US TO OBEY4 

#a#a#i4 ,YES1 REPLIES ! O!R P>TY1 0& ! FA!RS HAVE SAID ANO!R ?+ TOO -- !Y SAID ?AT :5EV] ! GOV]NM5T ( A TRIBE WAS NOT SATISFACTORY TO ! GOV]N$1 !Y HAVE A RI<T TO 'ALT] OR ABOLI% IT4'0 

#a#b4 ,BUT1 REPLIES ! FIR/ P>TY1 0Y\ MU/ TAKE ! MODE PRESCRIB$ BY ! CON/ITUTION40 ,BUT1 SAYS ! SECOND1 0WE DON'T *OOSE TO BE RUL$ BY Y\R CON/ITUTION -- IT IS NO LONG] \R CON/ITUTION4 ,IT DOES NOT SUIT US -- WE PROPOSE TO HAVE ONE ( \R [N4 0,BUT1 SAYS ! FIR/ P>TY1 0Y\ MU/ GET A MAJORITY ( ! TRIBE TO CONS5T TO ?AT40 ,BUT1 SAYS ! SECOND1 0WE DO NOT CONS5T TO ASK LEAVE ( Y\R MAJORITY2 & IF Y\ 9SI/ ON ?AT1 Y\ D5Y ALL RI<T ( POLITICAL FRE$OM1 :I* IS A DIRECT RETURN TO B>B>IC GOV]NM5T1 OR TO ! RI<T ( ! /RONGE/4 

#a#b#a4 ,TO ?IS1 ! FIR/ P>TY REPLIES ?AT TO P]MIT DIS9TEGRATION )\T ! CONS5T ( ! MAJORITY IS TO 09AUGURATE UNIV]SAL CONFUSION40 

#a#b#b4 ,N[1 READ]1 JU/ PAUSE A MOM5T4 ,HAD !RE BE5 NO ,CLAN OR 0,UNION0 =M$ AT ALL1 OR HAD IT CONT9U$ NO LONG] ?AN ! OCCASION = IT1 ?IS W> W\LD NEV] HAVE >IS51 -- O!R DI/URBANCES MI<T HAVE COME FROM O!R CAUSES1 BUT NEV] FROM ?IS44 ,BUT1 TO PRES]VE ?IS CLAN%IP UNBROK51 & RETA9 ALL ITS MEMB]S 9 PEACEFUL REPOSE1 ! ADVOCATES ( 0UNBROK5 ,UNION0 ABRUPTLY REFUSE TO NEGOTIATE ) ! REC$+ P>TY 7:O (F] COMP5SATION = :AT !Y MU/ TAKE ) !M71 !REBY F9ALLY D5Y+ !IR RI<T TO BECOME A SEP>ATE P>LEY1 & PRON\NC+ ! F9AL WORD ?AT ! ,UNION RECOGNIZES NO TWO P>TIES :O CAN NEGOTIATE ) EA* O!R2 :I* IS EQUIVAL5T TO SAY+ ?AT ! POLITICAL ,UNION 7OR CLAN%IP7 IS MORE SACR$ ?AN P]SONS1 OR PROP]TY1 OR FRE$OM1 OR ANY O!R 9ALI5ABLE HUMAN RI<T4 ,?US COMPLETELY DE/ROY+ ! LA/ VE/IGE ( UNION BETWE5 ! P>TIES1 & =C+ BO? 9TO HO/ILE ATTITUDES1 & BO? PREP>E TO DE/ROY EA* O!R4 

#a#b#c4 ,N[ >E HE>D ! WAILS ( DI/RESS FROM ALL QU>T]S4 ,! PAP]S >E FILL$ ) ACC\NTS ( BRUTAL VIOL5CE ON BO? SIDES -- VILLAGES BURN+ -- M5 HANG+ -- F]OCITY LET LOOSE 9 EV]Y HORRID %APE & =M4 ,! HEAT$ PASSIONS ON BO? SIDES BECOME MORE & MORE F]OCI\S1 -- A CURI\S WAY TO PROMOTE 0,UNION06 ,A FR5ZY ( RAGE SWEEPS OV] ! L& :ILE ,I WRITE4 ,! LA/ /EP ( DESPOTISM HAS BE5 TAK5 BY BO? GOV]NM5TS4 ,FRE$OM ( ACTION & SPEE* >E ANNIHILAT$ 9 0! L& ( ! FREE & ! HOME ( ! BRAVE40 ,EV5 !SE WRITT5 WORDS MAY PROVE ! DEA?-W>RANT ( ! WRIT]4 ,NO?+ BUT ! CLAMOR ( W> & ! FE> ( PRISONS & VIOL5T DEA?S1 SMO!R1 = ! MOM5T1 ! L[ MOAN FROM DESOLAT$ HE>?S & BROK5 HE>TS FROM ! DEP?S ( ! HELL WE >E 96 

,9 ! MEAN TIME1 :]E IS ! 0,UNION08 

#a#b#d4 ,READ]1 LET US PAUSE A MOM5T TO REFLECT ?AT ALL ?IS IS ! NATURAL & 9EVITABLE RESULT ( CLAN%IP6 ,IF ! CLAN OR 0,UNION0 HAD NEV] BE5 =M$1 OR BAD IT CONT9U$ NO LONG] ?AN WAS AGREEABLE TO ! P>TIES TO IT1 ?IS W> W\LD NEV] HAVE OCCURR$4 

#a#b#e4 ,I TAKE UP SOME ( ! PAP]S NE>E/ AT H&1 & ,I READ ?AT ONE MAN IS NAIL$ TO A TREE -- ABSOLUTELY CRUCIFI$ & LEFT1 GAGG$ -- />V+ TO DEA? = SEV]AL DAYS2 NOT = ANY ( HIS [N ACTS1 BUT = ! ACTS OR !ORIES ( HIS CLAN OR P>TY6 ,IMM$IATELY ! CRY ( 0REV5GE0 IS HE>D -- NOT AGA9/ ! P>TICUL> P]PETRATORS ( ! HORRID DE$1 BUT AGA9/ ! P>TY OR CLAN TO :I* HE BELONGS6 -- ! 9NOC5T PORTIONS ( :OM >E MORE LIKELY TO SUFF] = ! CRIME ?AN ! P]PETRATORS ( IT4 ,?US CLAN%IP1 ANNIHILAT+ ALL 9DIVIDUAL RESPONSIBILITY LEAVES RAPACITY & CRUELTY UNRE/RA9$4 

#a#b#f4 ,AGA9 ,I READ1 0,T5 ?\S& M5 KILL$ & W\ND$1 BUT A MU* L>G] NUMB] ON ! 5EMY'S SIDE4 ,! T[N ( ,S--- 9 A%ES2 ,N--- IS ?REAT5$2 ! VILLAGE ( ,B--- 9 FLAMES )9 SI<T1 & OLD M51 *ILDR51 & WOM5 SCREAM+ FRANTICALLY1 & RUNN+ 9 ALL DIRECTIONS60 

#a#b#g4 ,! BLOOD BOILS1 ! BRA9 IS ON FIRE :5 ! CORPSE ( A DE> SON1 A FA!R1 OR HUSB& IS F\ND ON ! FIELD1 OR AMID ! RU9S ( ONCE PEACEFUL HOMES4 ,FR5ZY & DESPAIR TAKE POSSESSION ( SOME1 & A DESP]ATE SPIRIT ( REV5GE 9SPIRES O!R WOM5 :O WILL SOON BE MO!RS2 ( ! *ILDR5 BORN 9 ! MID/ ( !SE HORRORS1 MANY WILL BE /ILLBORN1 O!RS :OLLY OR P>TLY IDIOTS1 O!RS ) AN UNCONTROLLABLE H]$IT>Y DISPOSITION TO %$ BLOOD -- TO DE/ROY :ATEV] OR :OEV] COMES 9 !IR WAY4 ,!NL COME MORE W>S1 MURD]S1 & VIOL5CE BEYOND COMPUTATION 6 ,:AT !N1 IS ! PROSPECT = ! NEXT G5]ATION & !IR DESC5DANTS6 ,LET IT BE OBS]V$ ?AT1 BE=E DISPLAY+ SU* %OCK+ PROSPECTS1 ! PREV5TIVE HAS BE5 ALREADY PRES5T$ 9 ! FIR/ *APT]4 ,LET US SEE IF ! PREV5TIVE IS REALLY !RE4 

#a#b#h4 ,:5 ONE P>TY FIR/ PROPOS$ TO DIS9TEGRATE ITSELF FROM ! POLITICAL 0,UNION0 7CLAN71 IF ! O!R PORTION HAD SAID1 ACCORD+ TO ! ,DECL>ATION ( ,9DEP5D5CE1 0,AS ! RI<T ( ANY PEOPLE TO ALT] OR ABOLI% ANY GOV]NM5T IS ABSOLUTE & '9ALI5ABLE1' ( C\RSE1 Y\ HAVE ! :OLE ( ! DECID+ P[] 9 Y\R [N H&S4 ,WE CAN HAVE NO VOICE 9 ! MATT] UNLESS Y\ DESIRE IT AS C\NSEL4 ,WE ?9K IT W\LD BE A DANG]\S & DIFFICULT EXP$I5T = BO? P>TIES2 BUT ?IS OP9ION WE SUBMIT ONLY AS ADVICE4 ,IF Y\ DECIDE ON LEAV+ US1 WE HAVE SOME =TS1 M9TS1 & O!R COMMUNI/IC PROP]TY TO DIVIDE1 BUT WE ANTICIPATE NO DIFFICULTY 9 REG>D TO ?AT4 ,EA* P>TY1 OR BO? TOGE!R1 CAN CALL C\NCILS ( ! BE/-BALANC$ M9DS TO DELIB]ATE ON ! SUBJECT & SUGGE/ ! BE/ MODES ( ADJU/M5T1 & WE D>E SAY ?AT ?IS WILL NOT BE DIFFICULT40 

#a#b#i4 ,W\LD NOT ?IS MODE1 OR RA!R ?IS GREAT PR9CIPLE1 HAV+ BE5 APPLI$ 9 ! RI<T TIME1 HAVE PREV5T$ ALL !SE HORRORS & ?IS DE/RUCTION8 

#a#c4 ,:AT IS ! REPLY TO ?IS8 ,IS IT :AT WE SEE 9 ! NEWSPAP]S8 -- ?AT IT W\LD 05C\RAGE DIS9TEGRATION & BE ! '9AUGURATION ( UNIV]SAL CONFUSION'80 ,?AT ! W> IS 0TO PRES]VE ! NATION AS A NATION & ! ',UNION' UNBROK580 ,!SE /ATEM5TS1 UNI=MLY 9SI/$ ON1 EV5 BY ! EXECUTIVE HIMSELF1 PROVE DECID$LY & FULLY ?AT ! W> HAS BE5 9AUGURAT$ & PROSECUT$ M]ELY TO PRES]VE CLAN%IP1 AS ,I HAVE /AT$1 = NATIONALITY IS NO MORE OR LESS ?AN CLAN%IP1 & CLAN%IP IS ! WOR/ FEATURE ( B>B>ISM4 ,I DO NOT ACCUSE ANY ONE ( 9T5TIONAL WICK$NESS NOR ( WANTONNESS OR 9DIFF]5CE TO ! HORRORS ?AT SURR\ND & 9VOLVE US2 ON ! CONTR>Y1 ,I SEE ! :OLE TO BE A LAM5TABLE MI/AKE1 ! UNAVOIDABLE RESULT ( A BL9D REV]5CE = PREC$5TS1 = LEGAL TE*NICALITIES & =MAL 9/ITUTIONS1 9/EAD ( = ! DEEP UND]LY+ PR9CIPLES :I* GAVE RISE TO ! 9/ITUTIONS4 ,N[ LOOK AT ! RESULTS6 ,IF WE >E N[ 9 CIVILIZATION1 :AT IS B>B>ISM 8 

#a#c#a4 ,LET US1 9 IMAG9ATION AT LEA/1 HAVE DONE ) CLAN%IP1 & CONV]SE AS TWO 9DIVIDUALS DIS9TEGRAT$ FROM ALL P>TY OR P>TIAL TRAMMELS4 

#a#c#b4 ,A--- SAYS1 0,I CAN F9D NO FAULT ) ! PROPOSITION Y\ MAKE ) REG>D TO ! C\NCILS ( DELIB]ATION OR REF]5CE1 & FEEL HAPPY TO ?9K ?AT ! GREAT IDEA UND]LY+ \R 9/ITUTIONS IS NOT =GOTT5 OR IGNOR$1 BUT ?AT IT EV5 9/RUCTS US :AT TO DO 9 ! GREATE/ & MO/ DIFFICULT TRIAL4 ,BUT WILY DO Y\ ?9K ?AT AN IMM$IATE SEP>ATION W\LD BE A BAD EXP$I5T = BO? ( US80 

#a#c#c4 ,B--- REPLIES1 0,FIR/ ON ACC\NT ( ! GEOGRAPHICAL 9T]LOCK+S ( \R 9T]E/S :I* MAY BE V]Y DIFFICULT TO DIS5TANGLE SUDD5LY4 ,!N !RE IS Y\R SLAVE SY/EM4 ,! RI<T ( SELF-SOV]EIGNTY 9 EV]Y HUMAN BE+1 :I* GIVES Y\ ! SUPREME RI<T TO LEAVE US )\T ASK+ \R LEAVE GIVES TO Y\R SLAVES ! SAME RI<T TO LEAVE Y\1 & ALSO GIVES TO EV]Y MAN1 WOMAN1 & *ILD ! SAME SUPREME RI<T TO SYMPA?IZE ) AN #a ASSI/ ! DI/RESS$ OR OPPRESS$ :]EV] !Y >E F\ND AS ! GREATE/ & HOLIE/ MISSION ( LIFE2 & ?IS MI<T LEAD TO NEW DISA/]S = :I* WE HAVE NO PREV5TIVE OR REM$Y PROVID$4 ,Y\ HAVE BE5 BORN UND] ! SY/EM1 & Y\R HABITS MAKE Y\ 5TIRELY DEP5D5T UPON SLAVES4 ,I DO NOT BLAME Y\ = ! CIRCUM/ANCES UND] :I* Y\ W]E BORN2 ,I H>DLY KN[ :I* ( ! TWO CLASSES IS MO/ 5SLAV$1 OR MO/ TO BE PITI$1 SLAVES OR MA/]S4 

#a#c#d4 0,! PR9CIPLE UPON :I* Y\ CLAIM ! RI<T TO SEC$E FROM US IS P]FECTLY UNASSAILABLE IT IS ! '9ALI5ABLE' RI<T ( SELF-SOV]EIGNTY BUT IT EXT5DS F>!R ?AN Y\ MAY HAVE CONTEMPLAT$ IT4 ,IT IS A FULL & COMPLETE W>RANT = ANY ONE ( Y\R CITIZ5S TO PLACE HIMSELF ABOVE ALL Y\R LEGISLATION1 ABOVE ! :OLE CONF$]ACY1 & APPEAL TO ! WORLD = PROTECTION3 & HAV+ ASS]T$ ! PR9CIPLE 9 Y\R [N FAVOR1 Y\ CANNOT SUCCESSFULLY D5Y IT TO O!RS4 ,PROP]LY & FULLY UND]/OOD1 IT IS ! GREAT & F9AL SOLUTION ( ALL POLITICAL1 & ,I MAY SAY ALL /RIFE AMONG M52 BUT IT MI<T WORK DISA/R\SLY AMONG AN IGNORANT POPULATION1 )\T PREP>ATION4 

#a#c#e4 0,I CANNOT SAY :AT O!RS MAY DO1 &1 AS Y\ KN[1 ,I CANNOT DICTATE TO O!RS1 )\T D5Y+ !IR RI<T TO ?9K2 & DECIDE = !MSELVES2 BUT :ILE ,I ASS]T ! RI<T ( FRE$OM TO ALL SLAVES1 BLACK & :ITE1 ,I WILL EX]T MYSELF TO =ESEE & PREV5T1 AS F> AS POSSIBLE1 ALL UNNECESS>Y VIOL5CE TO Y\ FROM SLAVES OR FROM ANY O!R S\RCE40 

#a#c#f4 ,A--- ASKS1 0,IS ?IS ! PHILOSOPHY ( Y\R P>TY8 ,IF IT IS1 ,I BELONG TO IT1 9 ! ',UNION' OR \T ( ! ',UNION4'0 

#a#c#g4 ,B---1 0,I CANNOT SPEAK = A P>TY1 BUT ONLY = MYSELF POSITIVELY1 & ( PROBABILITIES ) REG>D TO O!R 9DIVIDUALS AS F> AS ,I KN[ !M4 ,NO O!R P]SON IS 9 ANY WAY PL$G$ TO OR RESPONSIBLE = ANY?+ ,I MAY SAY OR PROMISE40 

#a#c#h4 ,A---1 0,BUT :AT %ALL BE DONE ) ! CON/ITUTION 8 0 

#a#c#i4 ,B--- 1 0,I DO NOT KN[ :AT O!RS MAY DO ) IT -- MY CON/ITUTION IS )9 ME4 ,! RI<T ( SELF-SOV]EIGNTY 9 EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL IS MY CON/ITUTION40 

#a#d4 ,A---1 0,REALLY1 ?IS IS RA!R A NEW VIEW TO TAKE ( POLITICS1 BUT IT IS 9 P]FECT ACCORDANCE ) ! SPIRIT ( ALL CON/ITUTIONS4 ,I F9D MYSELF 9 UNION ) Y\ AT ANY RATE2 ON ?AT PR9CIPLE !RE NEV] CAN BE SECESSION ET ALL4 ,!RE CAN BE NO SECESSION FROM ! FRE$OM TO SEC$E60 

#a#d#a4 ,B--- 10 ,I AM EXCE$+LY HAPPY TO COME TO ?IS UND]/&+ ) Y\1 & AT A FUTURE TIME1 IF Y\ DESIRE IT1 ,I WILL PRES5T TO Y\ SOME ?\<TS REG>D+ A PRACTICAL & EASY MODE ( EM]G+ FROM ALL SLAV]IES ( ALL COLORS40 

#a#d#b4 ,A--- 1 0 ,I %ALL BE HAPPY TO LI/540 

#a#d#c4 ,B---1 0 ,ADIEU = ! PRES5T1 & IF Y\ FE> ANY SUDD5 WANTON VIOL5CE FROM ANY QU>T]1 LET ME KN[ IT IMM$IATELY3 WE HAVE 2A =CE ALREADY DRILL$ & DISCIPL9$1 :OSE SOLE AIM IT4 IS TO PREV5T OR RE/RA9 ALL WANTON VIOL5CE T[>DS ,A,N,Y P]SON OR PROP]TY1 )\T REG>D TO TRIBE1 CLAN1 CLASS1 SECT1 COLOR1 OR NATION40 

#a#d#d4 ,READ]1 IF ?IS C\RSE HAD BE5 TAK5 AT ! FIR/ 9TIMATION ( A WI% TO )DRAW FROM :AT IS CALL$ ! 0,UNION10 :AT W\LD PROBABLY HAVE BE5 \R CONDITION N[ COMP>$ TO :AT IT IS8 ,YET NO COMPROMISE HAS BE5 MADE ( HUMAN RI<TS1 BUT ON ! CONTR>Y ! FULLE/ V9DICATION ( !M HAS BE5 MA9TA9$ FROM ! BEG9N+ TO ! CUD3 BUT BECAUSE ?IS C\RSE WAS NOT PURSU$1 WE >E COMMITT$ TO UNLIMIT$ MUTUAL DE/RUCTION4 

#a#d#e4 ,! TWO GREAT CLANS >E NOT ONLY DIS9TEGRAT$1 BUT HO/ILE2 & NEI<BORS1 FAMILIES1 & ! DE>E/ FRI5DS >E NOT ONLY DIS9TEGRAT$1 BUT MADE 5EMIES TO EA* O!R FROM NATURAL & UNAVOIDABLE DIFF]5CES ( OP9ION & POLITICS1 BECAUSE !RE IS NO C5TRAL IDEA1 NO PR9CIPLE KN[N R\ND :I* !Y CAN RALLY & AGREE1 & 9 NO P>TY HAS ,F,R,E,$,O,M ,T,O ,D,I,F,F,] BE5 PRACTICALLY E/ABLI%$ AS A REGULAT+ ?\<T4 ,SELF-SOV]EIGNTY IS ! C5TRAL IDEA OR PR9CIPLE REQUIR$4 

#a#d#f4 ,HAV+ OV]LOOK$ ! NECESS>Y REGULATOR1 :AT IS !RE LEFT = US1 AS SELF-RESPECT+ M51 BUT TO FRANKLY ACKN[L$GE ! BLUND]1 & MAKE ALL L9T' REP>ATION 9 \R P[] NOT 9CONSI/5T ) TIRE REGULATOR ITSELF4 

#a#d#g4 #a W\LD GLADLY TURN N[ FROM ! SICK5+1 FA9T+ PATI5T BE=E US1 BUT MU/ PROBE A LITTLE F>!R4 

#a#d#h4 ,CLAN%IP1 BY DE/ROY+ 9DIVIDUAL RESPONSIBILITY1 5ABLES ! CRAFTY CRIM9AL TO ESCAPE1 & EXPOSE ! 9NOC5T ( HIS TRIBE TO RETRIBUTION4 ,SIX M5 >E HUNG ON ONE TREE = D>+ TO BE ( ! O!R P>TY1 & ?OSE :O HUNG !M BELONG$ TO ! P>TY PR(ESS+ TO BE CONT5D+ = ,FRE$OM6 ,O!RS >E =C$ TO EXPOSE !IR LIVES & DIE FI<T+ AGA9/ ! P>TY ( !IR *OICE6 ,!Y MU/ DO ?IS OR BE %OT BY ORD] ( !IR RUL]S6 

#a#d#i4 ,READ]1 :I* P>TY DO Y\ ?9K IT WAS ?AT HUNG !SE M5 = A DIFF]5CE ( POLITICAL PREF]5CES8 ,:I* P>TY IS IT ?AT =CES M51 ) 09ALI5ABLE RI<TS ( LIFE1 LIB]TY1 & ! PURSUIT ( HAPP9ESS10 TO FI<T AGA9/ !IR [N WILLS OR BE %OT8 ,:I* P>TY IS IT ?AT MURD]S M5 = TAK+ FL[N A FLAG1 OR PREF]R+ ONE FLAG TO ANO!R8 ,:I* P>TY IS IT ?AT PR(ESSES TO BE FI<T+ = ,FRE$OM8 

#a#e4 ,OH1 :AT QUE/IONS TO ASK 9 ! N9ETE5? C5TURY ( ,*RI/IAN CIVILIZATION6 ,& :AT A POSITION TO PLACE ONE 9 :O UND]TAKES TO ANSW] !M6 

#a#e#a4 ,HE MU/ REPLY1 ,IT IS BO? P>TIES6 & ?AT BO? PR(ESS TO BE CONT5D+ = ,FRE$OM6 

#a#e#b4 ,BO? CLAIM TO BE CONT5D+ = SELF-PRES]VATION6 ,?AT IS NO?+ NEW1 BUT ?AT ALL ! P[]S ( BO? P>TIES %\LD BE BE/[$ 9 DE/ROY+ 9/EAD ( PRES]V+ LIFE1 PROP]TY1 & ,FRE$OM CAN BE ACC\NT$ = ONLY BY ! BL9D READ9ESS ) :I* ! PRES5T IMITATES ! PA/1 )\T ANY REF]5CE TO ! 9EVITABLE CONSEQU5CES ?AT >E SURE TO FOLL[4 ,:I* P>TY IS IT ?AT DOES NOT SUPPRESS ! FRE$OM ( ACTION1 ( SPEE*1 & ( ! PRESS & PUNI% ) IMPRISONM5T OR DEA? AN HONE/ AV[AL ( AN OP9ION 9 FAVOR ( ! OPPOSITE P>TY 8 

#a#e#c4 ,:I* P>TY IS IT ?AT DOES NOT TREAT AS TREASON1 PUNI%ABLE ) DEA?1 ! ADMISSION ( A S+LE PO9T :]E9 ! OPPOSITE P>TY MAY BE RI<T1 AS 0GIV+ AID & COM=T TO ! 5EMY08 ,9 O!R WORDS1 :I* P>TY IS IT ?AT DOES NOT ?REAT5 TO PUNI% ) DEA? ?AT S+LE ITEM ( JU/ICE8 ,:O W\LD EV] ?9K ( 9TRODUC+ QUELL MON/R\S RULES IF !Y W]E NEW8 ,BUT !Y >E F\ND AMONG ! 0PREC$5TS10 ! 0USAGES ( GOV]NM5TS60 0! LAWS ( W>10 0! LAWS ( NATIONS10 & >E !RE=E BL9DLY FOLL[$ ?\< !Y LEAD ! V]Y LEAD]S 9TO ! DIT* OR OV] ! PRECIPICE4 ,?IS BL9D REPETITION ( B>B>ISM MU/ BE CRITICIZ$ & /OPP$1 OR ONE CONT9U\S R\ND ( MUTUAL MURD] & DE/RUCTION WILL CONT9UE TO ! 5D ( TIME4 

#a#e#d4 ,! FLANG+ ( !SE M5 & ! DESOLAT+ ( !IR FAMILIES WAS 9 /RICT LOGICAL ACCORDANCE ) ! B>B>IAN 0LAWS ( W>10 :I* >E AN EV]-READY EXCUSE = EV]Y WILD & %OCK+ ATROCITY ?AT RAPACITY1 REV5GE1 OR WANTONNESS MAY PROMPT4 ,! 0LAWS ( W>10 SAY !SE B>B>IANS1 PUT ALL ! MEMB]S ( A TRIBE 7NATION7 9 HO/ILITY ) EA* O!R6 & :5 AT W> WE MAY PROP]LY 0 DO ALL ! H>M WE CAN TO \R 5EMIES40 ,BO? P>TIES TAKE !IR TEXTS FROM ! SAME AU?ORITIES4 ',! 0LAWS ( W>10 0MILIT>Y NECESSITY10 ! LAWS ( NATIONS1 >E CON/ANTLY 9 ! M\?S ( BO? P>TIES AS EXCUSES = ALL !IR B>B>IAN ACTS1 & YET1 :5 ONE COMMITS AN ATROCITY 9 /RICT ACCORDANCE ) !SE ADMITT$ AXIOMS1 ! O!R P>TY =?) TALKS ( REV5GE6 

#a#e#e4 ,IF ONE P>TY IS MORE HUMANE OR MORE CIVILIZ$ ?AN ! O!R1 IT ACTS LESS 9 ACCORDANCE ) !SE 0LAWS ( W> 20 & IF ONE 9DIVIDUAL IS MORE CIVILIZ$ OR HUMANE ?AN ! RE/ ( HIS P>TY1 OR BO? P>TIES1 HE IS NOT AT HOME 9 EI!R2 ON ! CONTR>Y1 = HIS BEAUTIFUL HUMANIT>Y FEEL+S1 = HIS HI< S5SE ( HONOR1 JU/ICE1 & DISCRIM9ATION1 HE HAS TWO *ANCES ( BE+ MURD]$1 :]E BL9D1 HEADLONG P>TY F]OCITY HAS ONLY ONE6 

#a#e#f4 ,& SO IT HAS ALWAYS BE5 UND] ALL POLITICAL SY/EMS OR CODES1 AS ILLU/RAT$ BY ! CASE ( ,G5]AL ,PATKUL1 :O WAS BROK5 ON ! :EEL BY ORD] ( ,*>LES ,X,I,I41 ( ,SW$51 UND] A *>GE ( 0TREASON10 = ATTEMPT+1 BY PACIFIC NEGOTIATIONS1 TO BR+ AB\T A CESSATION ( HO/ILITIES BETWE5 HIS C\NTRY & ITS ANTAGONI/4 ,! HUMANITY ( ,PATKUL DID NOT %[ SUFFICI5T LOYALTY TO ,*>LES'S 0AU?ORITY06 

#a#e#g4 ,!RE >E NO 0 LAWS ( W>10 0NOR LAWS ( NATIONS10 NOR MILIT>Y NECESSITIES1 NOR LAWS ( M51 ?AT \<T TO COMM& A MOM5T'S RESPECT OR ATT5TION1 UNLESS !Y T5D TO DIM9I% SUFF]+ 9/EAD ( 9CREAS+ IT3 & TRUE CIVILIZATION WILL DISC>D EV]Y?+1 ?AT PROMPTS OR EXCUSES ANY UNNECESS>Y VIOL5CE TO ANY P]SON OR PROP]TY4 

#a#e#h4 ,! FATAL T5D5CY ( AN UNQUE/ION+ READ9ESS TO FOLL[ PREC$5TS MAY POSSIBLY HAVE L$ TO ! %OCK+ EASE ( CRUCIFIXION M5TION$2 P]HAPS IT WAS PROMPT$ BY ! COMMON BLUND] AS A 0T]ROR TO EVILDO]S10 P]HAPS ! HORRID ?\<T WAS FIR/ SUGGE/$ TO ! P]PETRATORS BY ! PREC$5T SO PA9FULLY FAMILI> TO ALL ,*RI/5DOM4 

#a#e#i4 ,A SIMIL> ATROCITY WAS P]PETRAT$ 9 ! ,FR5* ,REVOLUTION ,A Y\NG WOMAN ONLY = BE+ ( ! O!R P>TY1 A FACT OV] :I* %E HAD NO CONTROL1 WAS ALSO CRUCIFI$4 ,H] FEET W]E SPIK$ TO ! GR\ND1 WIDE AP>T1 & %E WAS MADE TO /& BY A TREE1 TO :I* %E WAS B\ND1 & A SL[ FIRE WAS PLAC$ & KEPT UND] H] TILL %E DI$ 9 ! MO/ EXCRUCIAT+ TORTURE4 

#a#f4 ,N[ ?AT ! RACE IS SO F> SUNK51 EI!R BY H]$IT>Y PROP5SITIES1 OR BY A CONT9U\S1 UNHESITAT+ COPY+ ( ! PA/1 :AT CAN WE DO BETT] ?AN TO /EP UP AT ONCE ABOVE !SE HORRID PREC$5TS & AU?ORITIES1 & 9T]F]E TO PREV5T ALL UNNECESS>Y & WANTON VIOL5CE8 ,?IS WAS PROBABLY ! ORIG9AL DESIGN ( MAK+ LAWS1 AS IT IS CELL$1 & TRIAL BY JURY1 ETC41 BUT !Y HAVE ALL FAIL$2 = B>B>ISM & 9SANE VIOL5CE REIGN TRIUMPHANT ?R\<\T ! MISNOM] ( CIVILIZATION4 

#a#f#a4 ,DID HUMAN BE+S EV] COMMIT ANY O!R BLUND] SO GREAT AS ?AT ( =M+ !MSELVES 9TO CLANS OR NATIONS8 ,:5 ! PASSIONS OR PROP5SITIES HAVE POSSESSION1 ! 9TELLECT SLEEPS1 & RESPONSIBILITY BE+ ANNIHILAT$1 !RE IS NO?+ TOO HORRIBLE TO EXPECT4 ,I V5TURE ! ASS]TION ?AT !RE IS BUT ,O,I,I,C WAY TO EM]GE FROM ?IS O!RWISE 5DLESS *AOS ( MIS]Y & DEGRADATION2 ?AT IS1 DIRECTLY TO BE/[ ALL PRACTICABLE 5]GIES 9 ! DIRECTION 9DICAT$ 9 ! FIR/ *APT]1 & TO SOLICIT ! COOP]ATION ( ALL P]SONS1 )\T REG>D TO P>TY1 SECT1 !ORIES1 SEX1 OR NATION1 TO CONSID] 9 LEISURE & 9 CALMNESS ! BASIS ( TRUE CIVILIZATION4 

#a#f#b4 ,CLAN%IP CAN EXI/ AMONG FI%ES ( ONE K9D AMONG ANTS1 BEES1 & O!R 9SECTS1 & AMONG ! CRUDE CLANS ( M51 :O LIKE ANTS1 BEES1 OR DRI$ H]R+S ON A /ICK1 HAVE NO 9DIVIDUAL DEVELOPM5T1 BUT :O >E ALL ALIKE4 ,:5 ! M5TAL EYES !Y HAD HAVE BE5 PUN*$ \T BY B>B>IAN P[] 9 ! PROCESS ( /R++ !M ON ! /ICK ( SUBORD9ATION OR LOYALTY3 & IF NO 9TELLECTUAL EXPANSION W]E POSSIBLE1 CLAN%IP W\LD CONT9UE TO DESOLATE ! E>?2 BUT JU/ 9 PROPORTION TO 9TELLECTUAL EXPANSION1 9DIVIDUALITY MAKES ITS APPE>ANCE1 & BEG9S TO CONFLICT ) ! DRI$-H]R+ SUBORD9ATION1 & NATURALLY GIVES RISE TO ! FIR/ /EPS 9DIS9TEGRATION OR ! COMM5CEM5T ( TRUE CIVILIZATION6 

#a#f#c4 ,=TUNATELY = US1 EXT]NAL =CE CANNOT LIMIT NOR SUPPRESS IDEAS4 ,TAKE A HUNDR$ P]SONS AS COMPLETELY 0UNITIZ$10 & AS DE/ITUTE ( IDEAS AS DRI$ H]R+S1 & PLACE !M )9 A BUILD+ HAV+ IRON WELLS ?REE FEET ?ICK1 & GU>D$ BY A ?\S& M51 IDEAS MAY F9D !IR WAY AMONG !M ?AT CAN LIB]ATE !M FROM ?AT CONDITION1 OR DE/ROY !M4 

#a#f#d4 ,A SAVAGE :O HAS = HALF A LIFETIME EAT5 ) HIS F+]S \T ( ! SAME DI% ) TW5TY O!RS1 ALL OB/RUCT+ EA* O!R'S MOVEM5TS1 CONCEIVES1 P]HAPS1 ! IDEA ( A WOOD5 PADDLE OR A PO9T$ /ICK TO USE 9 ! COMMUNI/IC DI% -- BUT IT'S NOT 0 ! FA%ION 06 ,IT IS NOT 0 ACCORD+ TO PREC$5TS06 ,IT IS NOT :AT 0! FA!RS 9T5D$06 ,BUT HE MAY SAY TO HIMSELF1 0 ,I AM NOT ONE ( ! FA!RS1 -- ,I AM ANO!R P]SON4 ,I DON'T SEE :Y ,I %\LD NOT HAVE MY WAY AS WELL AS !Y1 PROVID$ ,I DO NOT PUT ! FA!RS1 NOR ANYBODY ELSE1 TO ANY 9CONV5I5CE40 

#a#f#e4 ,N[ AS SOON AS HE BEG9S TO REASON 9 ?IS WAY1 A PROSPECTIVE GOOD-BY TO ! DRI$-H]R+ SUBORD9ATION1 TO ,LOYALTY1 & ! ,HUG-GA-BOO *ORUS1 = TRUE CIVILIZATION HAS BEGUN4 ,HE MAY BE OBLIG$ TO FLY FROM HIS CLAN OR C\NTRY1 BUT ?AT ITSELF =CES UPON HIM ! 9DIVIDUAL DI% -- ! CONV5I5CES ( :I* WILL NOT BE WILL+LY RESIGN$1 & ! EXAMPLE ( :I* MI<T PROVE AS CONTAM9AT+ AS ROA/ PIG4 

#a#f#f4 ,! G]M ( TRUE CIVILIZATION IS N[ FAIRLY PLANT$ & P]HAPS IT EXP&S SO F> ?AT HE SEES ?AT A SEP>ATE SLEEP+ AP>TM5T W\LD BE MORE AGREEABLE TO ALL 9 A HOT CLIMATE ?AN SLEEP+ 9 ONE NE/ ) TW5TY OR ?IRTY O!RS1 LIKE A LITT] ( PIGS2 BUT !N ?IS W\LD BE 0 DIS9TEGRATION10 & MI<T NOT BE P]MITT$ BY ! 0MAJORITY10 = IT IS 0ISOLATION0 & 0SELFI%NESS10 & NOT ACCORD+ TO ! 0PREC$5TS0 & 0BE/ AU?ORITIES20 0SOCIETY HAS A RI<T TO ! SOCIETY ( ALL ITS MEMB]S40 0 ,WELL10 SAYS ! SAVAGE1 0,I WILL NOT !N BE A MEMB] ( ANY SOCIETY -- ,I WILL BE AN 9DIVIDUAL40 

#a#f#g4 ,N[ A PIECE ( GR\ND IS WANT$ TO /& HIS H\SE UPON4 ,?IS POSSESSION ( A PIECE ( L& DIS9TEGRAT$1 9DIVIDUALIZ$ FROM ! COMMUNI/IC DOMA91 HAS BE5 CONSID]$ ONE ( ! GREATE/ & MO/ 9DISP5SABLE FEATURES ( CIVILIZATION1 & SO IT IS4 ,BUT BEYOND ?IS1 SOCIETY HAS ATTA9$ LITTLE OR NO?+ BY ! WAY ( ADJU/M5T4 

#a#f#h4 ,A B>B>IAN /ROLL+1 UPON ! BEA*1 P]HAPS 9 SE>* ( TORTOISES1 ACCID5TALLY PICKS UP A LITTLE %ELL ?AT IS RA!R NEW TO HIM1 & HE %[S IT TO ANO!R SAVAGE1 :O1 = ! SAKE ( ! NOVELTY1 (F]S TO GIVE HIM = IT ! BEAV] :I* HE HAS JU/ CAU<T1 & ! EX*ANGE IS MADE2 & SO1 LIKE ! PROGRESS ( ROA/ PIG1 ! SECOND [N] ( ! %ELL1 :5 HIS CURIOSITY ITS SATISFI$1 GIVES IT TO A ?IRD P]SON = A TORTOISE-%ELL4 ,A %IP >RIVES ON ! COA/ 9 SE>* ( TORTOISE-%ELLS1 & GIVES ?IS SAVAGE BEADS1 NAILS1 & A HAT*ET = HIS %ELL4 ,IMM$IATELY EV]Y SAVAGE AB&ONS HIS HUNT+ ( BEAV]S & EV]Y O!R PURSUIT = ! HUNT+ ( TORTOISES2 9 ! C\RSE ( :I* !Y F9D MORE ( ! LITTLE %ELLS1 & GIVE !M ! NAME ( 0C[RIES40 ,ONE 0C[RY0 ONCE HAV+ PUR*AS$ A BEAV]1 ?IS 0PREC$5T0 IS ACCEPT$ AS 0AU?ORITY 0 = ! 0M>KET-PRICE0 ( A BEAV]2 SO AS MANY 0C[RIES0 AS EA* F9DS1 SO MANY BEAV]S HE CONSID]S HIMSELF 0WOR?10 &1 BY DEGREES1 AS ?IS 0ROA/ PIG0 PROGRESSES1 !SE 0C[RIES0 >E GIV5 & RECEIV$ = IVORY1 FI%1 ETC41 & BECOME A CIRCULAT+ M$IUM1 OR MONEY4 ,BUT1 9 MAK+ !SE EX*ANGES NO REF]5CE :ATEV] IS HAD TO ! TIME OR TR\BLE 9 PROCUR+ EI!R ! 0C[RIES0 OR ! >TICLES EX*ANG$ = !M2 IT BE+ ALTOGE!R A MATT] ( ACCID5T1 NO CALCULATIONS CAN BE MADE4 ,!RE IS NO BASIS = CALCULATION2 BUT ! 0C[RIES0 PROVE V]Y CONV5I5T2 = !Y 5ABLE EA* ONE TO CONF9E HIS ATT5TION & PREP>ATIONS TO ONE P>TICUL> PURSUIT1 & TO EX*ANGE ITS PRODUCTS = ALL ! ?+S HE NE$S1 9/EAD ( BE+ OBLIG$ TO DO EV]Y?+ = HIMSELF TO DISADVANTAGE4 ,BY ONLY CAT*+ ,BEAV]S & GIV+ !M = 0C[RIES10 HE CAN PROCURE FI%1 TORTOISE-%ELLS1 IVORY1 MUSKRATS1 MOCCAS9S1 MATS1 SPE>S1 ETC41 :I* IS AN IMM5SE SAV+ ( TIME & TR\BLE TO HIM4 ,O!RS1 SEE+ ?IS1 IMITATE HIS EXAMPLE1 & AS ! ACCUMULATION ( 0C[RIES0 AF=DS A PROSPECT ( EV]Y?+ NE$$1 ! PURSUIT & ACCUMULATION ( 0C[RIES0 BECOMES ! RAGE ( ALL2 %ELL EV]Y SAVAGE AB&ONS HIS BEAV]-HUNT+1 OR HIS FI%+1 HIS MUSK-RAT TRAPS1 ETC41 & ALL RU% TO ! HUNT = 0C[RIES40 ,!Y GET A L>GE SUPPLY1 BUT !RE IS NO?+ TO BUY ) !M6 ,!RE >E NO FI% CAU<T1 NO MUSKRATS1 NO MATS MADE1 NO IVORY F\ND1 NO MELLONS RAIS$4 ,! %IP HAS C>RI$ AWAY ALL ! TORTOISE-%ELLS1 & ! 0C[RIES0 >E COMP>ATIVELY WOR?LESS6 

#a#f#i4 ,ONE OLD CUNN+ SAVAGE1 SEE+ ! G5]AL ?\<TLESS RU% = 0C[RIES10 HAD TAK5 ADVANTAGE ( IT & 0B\<T UP0 ALL ! FI%1 MUSK-RATS1 IVORY1 MATS1 SPE>S1 NAILS1 ETC41 AGA9/ !IR RETURN4 ,HE N[ HAS ALL 9 HIS [N P[]1 = 0:OEV] FE$S CAN GOV]N10 & HE DEM&S ! :OLE ( !IR C[RIES = ! FEW SUPPLIES ?AT !Y >E OBLIG$ TO HAVE TO SUPPLY PRES5T NECESSITIES2 & ! POPULATION GIVE HIM ALL ! C[RIES !Y HAVE GA!R$ ALONE1 ! :OLE COA/ = MON?S1 9 EX*ANGE = A FEW NECESS>IES :I* !Y C\LD HAVE MADE = !MSELVES 9 AS MANY H\RS4 ,!Y FEEL ?AT !Y >E WRONG$1 BUT DO NOT SEE :]E ! WRONG IS4 

#a#g4 ,! NEXT DAY ! CUNN+ OLD SAVAGE'S H\SE & %$S >E SET ON FIRE = REV5GE1 & NO ONE BE+ DISPOS$ TO HELP HIM1 !Y & ALL !IR CONT5TS >E CONSUM$ -- 0C[RIES0 & ALL1 & HE IS R$UC$ TO BEGG>Y2 BUT NO ONE RELIEVES HIM4 ,! C[RIES HAVE ALL BE5 COLLECT$ = MILES ALONG ! BEA* & HE CAN GET NONE3 HE IS NOT QUALIFI$ TO MAKE MATS1 NOR SPE>S1 NOR NAILS1 NOR TO CAT* BEAV]S1 & HE W&]S AB\T A MIS]ABLE & DESPIS$ SAVAGE1 HAV+ MADE HIMSELF MIS]ABLE BY OV]REA*+ HIS FELL[-SAVAGES4 

#a#g#a4 ,!RE HAS BE5 NO IMPROVEM5T UPON ?AT CRUDE & B>B>\S MONEY TO ?IS DAY ( ! ,*RI/IAN ]A1 #a#h#f#b1 UNLESS IT IS 9 SUB/ITUT+ LITTLE BITS ( COPP]1 OR O!R COMP>ATIVELY WOR?LESS METALS ) ! SEMBLANCE ( A MAN'S HEAD OR SOME ANIMAL UPON !M1 9/EAD ( ! 0C[RIES10 AS A CIRCULAT+ M$IUM4 

#a#g#b4 ,BANK-NOTES1 PROMIS+ TO PAY !SE BITS ( METAL ON DEM&1 IF !Y W]E NOT ! MEANS ( DEFRAUD+ AS WELL AS ( DELUD+ ! PUBLIC1 W\LD BE AN IMPROVEM5T UPON METALS1 AS BE+ MORE CONV5I5T ( C>RIAGE1 & CO/+ LESS TR\BLE 9 MANY WAYS2 BUT1 BE+1 AS !Y >E1 ! MEANS ( 9NUM]ABLE & CON/ANT FRAUDS & DELUSION1 !Y >E B>B>IAN MONEY B>B>IZ$4 ,ALL ! CRUDITY 9 PR9CIPLE REMA9S1 ) 9T5TIONAL FRAUDS ADD$4 

#a#g#c4 ,NO REF]5CE :ATEV] IS HAD TO ! COMP>ATIVE TR\BLE ?AT ANY?+ CO/S ! ONE :O FIR/ OBTA9S OR PRODUCES IT1 BUT :OEV] /UMBLES 9 HIS RAMBLES UPON A LUMP ( ANY ( !SE METALS1 HAS1 =?)1 ACCORD+ TO ! SIZE ( ! LUMP1 A DEM& UPON EV]Y PRODUCT & S]VICE UND] ! SUN6 

#a#g#d4 ,!RE BE+ NO PR9CIPLE KN[N = ! REGULATION OR ADJU/M5T ( ! QUANTITY ( !SE METALS1 :I* %\LD BE GIV5 9 EX*ANGE = ANY S]VICE OR COMMODITY1 ! :OLE IS LEFT TO ACCID5T1 OR ELSE TO SOME1 LIKE ! CUNN+ SAVAGE1 TO TAKE ADVANTAGE ( ! NECESSITIES ( O!RS1 & A G5]AL SCRAMBLE 5SUES TO GET ! ADVANTAGE OR TO ESCAPE BE+ OV]REA*$4 ,9 ?IS G5]AL /RIFE1 ?OSE ) ! LONGE/ PURSES1 OR ! MO/ CUNN+1 OR :O >E MO/ UNSCRUPUL\S & FALSE1 PREVAIL4 ,?OSE :O HAVE FEW OR NO C[RIES & ! LESS CRAFTY >E TRODD5 UND] FOOT1 & GR\ND TO P[D] & :AT IS CALL$ SOCIETY HAS BLUND]$ ON 9TO A UNIV]SAL SCRAMBLE = ! L>GE/ POSSIBLE ACCUMULATION ( 0 C[RY 0 METALS1 AS (F]+ ! BE/ AMONG POOR *ANCES ( SECURITY AGA9/ ! G5]AL RAPACITY4#a#g#e4 ,9 ?IS MELEE ! 9/9CT ( SELF-PRES]VATION 9 EA* ONE IS ALMO/ :OLLY B5T ,ON KEEP+ UPP]MO/1 9/EAD ( BE+ CRU%$ BEL[4 ,POLITICAL P[] & MONEY >E ! PR9CIPAL MEANS ( ATTA9+ 5DS1 & !SE >E !RE=E PURSU$ ) UNSCRUPUL\S DESP]ATE RATION4 

#a#g#f4 ,A LITTLE MONEY 7BY USURY7 0MAKES MORE10 BUT IT TAKES FROM ?OSE :O HAVE LESS11 TILL ?OSE ) LESS HAVE NONE TO TAKE4 ,!N WOE TO ?OSE :O >E F\ND 9 SU* RANKS4 ,NOBODY WILL BE F\ND !RE :O CAN AVOID IT4 ,DRIV5 TO WORK = :ATEV] MONEY-HOLD]S *OOSE TO GIVE1 !Y TAKE ! PITTANCE RA!R %ALL />VE1 & />VE :5 !Y CANNOT GET ! WORK OR ! PITTANCE4 ,!N :O ?AT CAN AVOID IT WILL BELONG TO ! RANKS ( />V$1 RAGG$1 ABUS$1 9SULT$ LABOR8 ,:OEV] CAN AVOID IT WILL DO SO1 & ! BURD5S FALL UPON ! WEAK :O HAVE NO MEANS ( ESCAPE4 

#a#g#g4 ,?IS IS ! ORIG9 ( ALL ,SLAV]IES4 ,!Y ALL GR[ \T ( ! FACT ?AT CIVILIZATION HAS NOT YET PROCE$$ F> 5\< TO DISCOV] :AT W\LD BE A PROP]1 LEGITIMATE1 EQUITABLE COMP5SATION OR PRICE EV5 = A B>REL ( FL\R6 

#a#g#h4 ,:5 ! MASSES >E SIL5C$ BY WEAKNESS1 ! CONFLICT BECOMES 9T5SIFI$ BETWE5 ! FEW :O HAVE MONOPOLIZ$ MONEY & ! GOV]N+ OR POLITICAL P[]4 ',! MASS BECOME M]E CIPH]S TO BE PLAC$ BY ! SIDES ( !SE FIGURES1 ONLY TO 9CREASE !IR MAGNITUDE & P[] 9 !IR CONTE/S ) EA* O!R4 ,! RI<T ( MI<T IS ! ONLY UMPIRE KN[N OR ACKN[L$G$1 & CONQUE/ BECOMES ! OBJECT ( ALL4 

#a#g#i4 ,LOOK+ AT CAUSES1 & UND]/&+ ! 9/9CT ( SELF-PRES]VATION1 :O WOND]S AT ! MIS]8 ,:O WOND]S AT ! BORD]S ( BLACK OR :ITE SLAVES8 ,:O WOND]S AT BURGL>Y1 HI<WAY ROBB]Y1 !FTS1 FRAUDS1 BRIB]Y1 & CORRUPTION 9 (FICE8 OR AT ! G5]AL DI/RU/ ( MAN 9 HIS K9D8 OR AT ! EXTREMES ( WA/E & WALLS ?AT >E SO (T5 F\ND FACE TO FACE8 

#a#h4 ,SEV5 ?\S& DOLL>S ( PUBLIC MONEY WAS SP5T BY A FEW POLITICAL WIRE-WORK]S 9 A MOCK FUN]AL ( A BRIB$ LAWY]1 -- BRIB$ TO UPHOLD A POLICY ?AT HAS BR\<T ?IS HORRID W> UPON US1 AL?\< AT ! TIME ( ?IS HYPOCRITICAL P>ADE MULTITUDES ( BOYS & GIRLS -- SOME ( !M ( M>RIAGEABLE AGE -- 9 RAGS & TATT]S1 NOT HALF CLAD1 %IV]+ ) COLD1 W]E SWOOP+ AWAY ! SN[Y MUD ?AT ! HYPOCRITES MI<T PASS COM=TABLY1 & OCCASIONALLY1 ) AN IMPLOR+ LOOK1 HOLD+ \T !IR H&S )1 0,PLEASE1 SIR1 GIVE ME A P5NY TO GET SOME?+ TO EAT40 -- ,I CAN PROCE$ NO FUR!R4 ,ANY ONE CAN EXT5D ! PICTURE = HIMSELF TO ANY MAGNITUDE BY CONSULT+ ANY ( ! NEWSPAP]S ( ! DAY4 

#a#h#a4 ,! TWO GREAT ELEM5TS ( P[] >E ! GOV]N+ 7MILIT>Y7 =CE & MONEY4 

#a#h#b4 ,! EQUILIBRIUM ( ! GOV]N+ P[] HAS ALREADY BE5 SUGGE/$ 9 ! FIR/ *APT]2 BUT UNTIL A PR9CIPLE IS F\ND & ACCEPT$ :I* CAN H>MONI\SLY REGULATE COMP5SATION = LABOR 7OR REGULATE PRICES71 & E/ABLI% AN EQUILIBRIUM ( ! MONEY P[]1 WE CAN H>DLY ASS]T ?AT CIVILIZATION HAS FAIRLY COMM5C$4  

   

   

  

FOOTNOTES  

-----------------  

"9,REV4 ,MR4 ,BRI]'S 0,AFRICANS AT ,HOME40 

"9,! GLORI\S ,KOSSU? SAID1 0,! FUTURE ( MANK9D CAN REPOSE ONLY ON PR9CIPLES40 

O ,*APT] #d 3 ,! ,PR9CIPLE ( ,EQUIVAL5TS 
,9,T,R,O,D,U,C,T,I,O,N ,T,O ,*,A,P,T,] ,I,V4 

  

#a#h#d4 ,WE CAN BOLD AN OBJECT SO NE> TO \R EYES ?AT WE CANNOT SEE IT4 ,ANALOG\S TO ?IS IS ! (T5-NOTIC$ FACT ?AT ?+S ) :I* WE >E MO/ FAMILI> ATTRACT ! LEA/ ATT5TION 

#a#h#e4 ,I FEEL ! =CE ( ! ABOVE MO/ PA9FULLY1 9 APPROA*+ A SUBJECT ( GREAT] MAGNITUDE ?AN AN O!R ?AT CAN OCCUPY ! M9D ( ?IS G5]ATION 2 & YET1 *ILDR5 >E ! FIR/ TO COMPREH5D IT6 ,! PR9CIPAL OB/ACLE TO ! APPRECIATION ( IT IS ITS EXTREME SIMPLICITY6 

#a#h#f4 ,:5 WE CONSID] ! PRES5T 9T]NAL W> 9 ?IS C\NTRY1 :I* IS 9CREAS+ 9 BL9D F]OCITY EV]Y H\R1 & :I* ?REAT5S TO DESOLATE EV]Y HE>? 9 IT1 & ?AT O!R C\NTRIES >E 9 CONT9U\S CONVULSIONS1 -ALL FROM ,9,J,U,/,I,C,E ,T,[,>,D,S ,L,A,B,O,R2 & :5 WE REFLECT ?AT ! :OLE ( :AT IS CALL$ CIVILIZATION RE/S UPON LABOR1 & ?AT IT IS EV]Y:]E PRO/RATE - />V+ - GROAN+1 & IMPLOR+LY LIFT+ ,UP ITS H&S 9 SIL5T AGONY = HELP2 ?AT IT HAS NO LONG] ! /R5G? TO GIVE VOICE TO ITS SUFF]+S1 & ?AT AS IT DIES CIVILIZATION DIES ) IT 2 & ?AT ?IS FRI<TFUL CON4 DITION IS ! NATURAL & 9EVITABLE RESULT1 NOT SO MU* ( DE4 LIB]ATE DESIGN AS = WANT ( ! MEANS ( DET]M9+ :AT W\LD CON/ITUTE JU/ICE T[>DS LABOR1 & H[ TO APPLY A REM$Y1 WE CAT* A GLIMPSE1 & ONLY A GLIMPSE1 ( ! IMM5SE MAGNITUDE ( ! SUBJECT BE=E US4  
,*,A,P,T,] ,I,V4 

  
,! ,P,R,9,C,I,P,L,E ,( ,E,Q,U,I,V,A,L,5,T,S4  

  

#a#h#g4 ,/,R,A,N,G,E AS ! /ATEM5T MAY APPE>1 CIVILIZATION TO-DAY KN[S NO O!R PR9CIPLE OR =MULA = ! REGULATION ( PRICES ?AN ?AT #aa ! PRICE ( A ?+ %\LD BE :AT IT WILL BR+0 OR ?AT ! PRICE %\LD BE MEASUR$ & LIMIT$ BY ! DEM&1 OR ! NECESSITIES ( ! RECEIV]4 ,!RE=E ,JOHN ,AL4 ,SE>+ 79 A CASE ON TRIAL BY ! ,U4 ,S4 ,GOV]NM5T AGA9/ ANO!R P>TY = EXTORTION AGA9/ ITSELF 71 :5 QUE/ION$ AB\T PRICE1 REPLI$1 #aa ,IF ,I ?\<T ! ,GOV]NM5T WANT$ ! PROP]TY & MU/ HAVE IT1 & C\LD NOT POSSIBLY DO )\T IT1 IF ,I HAD GIV5 ONLY FIFTE5 DOLL>S = IT1 ,I W\LD ASK TWO HUNDR$ & FIFTY ?\S& DOLL>S = IT1 OR AS MU* MORE AS ,I ?\<T ,I C\LD GET4 ,I W\LD TAKE ADVANTAGE ( ! NECESSITIES ( ! ,GOV]NM5T JU/ AS ,I W\LD ( ! NECESSITIES ( A PRIVATE 9DIVIDUAL 9 ANY BUS9ESS TRANSACTION40 

#a#h#h4 ,MR4 ,SE>+ HAS H]E /AT$ ! PRES5T E?ICS ( PRICE SO FRANKLY & SIMPLY ?AT IT DEM&S *ILDR51 OR *ILDLIKE M9DS ?AT HAVE NEV] BECOME CONTAM9AT$ BY #aa TRADE10 TO UND]/& ITS 9H]5T 9IQUITY4 ,IT IS A SIMPLE1 CLE>1 FRANK EXHIBITION ( ! G]M ( ! ,CANNIBALISM :I* UND]LIES ALL ! WORLD'S 9IQUITY & CONFUSION4 ,IT IS SAID ?AT ,MR4 ,SE>+ LO/ HIS POPUL>ITY BY HIS FRANKNESS2 !RE IS1 !RE=E1 SOME GR\ND TO SUPPOSE ?AT CIVILIZATION HAS NOT LO/ ALL P[] TO BLU%1 BUT ?AT :5 IT IS G5]ALLY P]CEIV$ ?AT ?IS HIDE\S PR9CIPLE IS ! ROOT ( ALL PUBLIC EVILS1 & ?AT RECTIFICATION IS POSSIBLE1 IT WILL1 FROM ! M]E 9/9CT ( SELF-PRES]VATION1 PURSUE ITS 9T]E/S 9 A NEW DIRECTION4 

#a#h#i4 ,!RE IS A G]M ( TRUE CIVILIZATION ALSO EXI/+ AMONG US1 BUT 9 HUMBLE LIFE1 & ALL UNCONSCI\SLY BECAUSE SO NATURALLY4 

#a#i4,IF A TRAVEL]1 9 A HOT DAY1 /OP AT A F>MH\SE = A DR9K ( WAT]1 HE G5]ALLY GETS IT )\T ANY ?\<T ( PRICE4 ,:Y 8 ,BECAUSE IT CO/S NO?+1 OR ! CO/ IS IMMAT]IAL4 ,IF ! WAT] WAS BR\<T FROM A GREAT DI/ANCE1 OV] DIFFICULT PASSES1 !RE MI<T BE A PRICE SET UPON IT :I* EV]Y ,ONE W\LD SANCTION1 IF ?AT PRICE WAS GOV]N$ BY ITS ,CO/1 OR ! LABOR ( PROCUR+ & DELIV]+ IT4 

#a#i#a4,IF ! TRAVEL] ASK$ = W9E1 HE W\LD EXPECT TO PAY = IT1 BECAUSE IT4 CO/S MORE ?AN WAT]2 & IF ?IS CO/ WAS MADE ! LIMIT ( ITS PRICE1 ALL W\LD SEEM JU/ & H>MONI\S4 ,BUT IF ! F>M]1 :5 ASK$ = WAT]1 W]E TO 5DEAVOR TO F9D \T H[ ?IR/Y ! TRAVEL] WAS1 & H[ MU* MONEY HE C\LD 9DUCE HIM TO PAY = ! WAT] RA!R ?AN NOT GET A DR9K1 & !N *>GE HIM ACCORD+LY1 ?IS PRICE W\LD BE #aa :AT IT W\LD BR+2 0 & IF ! F>M] W]E TO MONOPOLIZE ALL ! WAT] 9 ! NEI<BORHOOD1 OR FILL UP OR CONCEAL SOME ( ! SPR+S1 & CUT (F ALL ACCESS TO WAT] EXCEPT ?R\< HIM1 & !N *>GE A FA9T+ TRAVEL] A ?\S& DOLL>S = A DR9K TO SAVE HIS LIFE1 HE W\LD BE C>RY+ \T ! RULE ?AT #aa ! PRICE ( A ?+ IS :AT IT WILL BR+10 :I* IS ! MOTTO & SPIRIT ( ALL ! PR9CIPAL BUS9ESS ( ! WORLD6 ,IT IS LIMIT+ PRICE BY ! WOR? OR VALUE TO ! RECEIV] 9/EAD ( ! ,C,O,/ TO ! GIV]4 

#a#i#b4 ,! WAT] OR ! W9E MU/ POSSESS A VALUE TO ! RECEIV] 9 ORD] TO GIVE RISE TO ANY TRANSACTION 9 ! CASE3 BUT TO MAKE ?IS VALUE OR WOR? ! MEASURE ( ITS PRICE1 CON/ITUTES ! GL>+ 9IQUITY ( ! CASE1 & W\LD CLASS ! F>M] AMONG ! WRECK]S ON ! COA/ ( ,NORWAY1 :O FIR/ S9K ROCKS 9 ORD] TO WRECK4 VESSELS1 & !N DEM& ( ! CREWS ALL !IR C>GOES & VESSELS = SAV+ !IR LIVES6 ,& IT W\LD CLASS HIM ) FL\R-DEAL]S & EV]Y O!R HUCK/] ( PROVISIONS OR CLO?+1 ) BANK]S & ALL O!R MONEYMONG]S & SY/EMATIC SPECULATORS1 FROM ,JOHN ,M4 ,SE>+ TO ! HUCK/] ( C&IES & APPLES ON ! SIDEWALKS2 !Y ALL ACT ON ! SAME PR9CIPLE4 ,! ONLY DIFF]5CE BETWE5 !M IS ?AT ! WRECK] MU/ KN[ ?AT HE \<T TO BE %OT1 :ILE ! O!RS MAY SUPPOSE ?AT !Y >E FOLL[+ A V]Y #aa LEGITIMATE BUS9ESS 06 

#a#i#c4 ,! MO/ COMMON EXHIBITION ( ?IS 9IQUIT\S PR9CIPLE IS SE5 9 ! NEWSPAP]S 9 ! #aa PRICES CURR5T40 ,! FOLL[+ IS A SAMPLE3-- 

#a#i#d4 #aa ,NO NEW >RIVALS ( ,F,L,\,R - DEM& 9CREAS+2 PRICES ROSE ACCORD+LY1 S9CE YE/]DAY AT TWELVE O'CLOCK1 #be CTS4 P] B>REL4 ,NO *ANGE 9 ,C,(,F,E,E S9CE \R LA/4 ,S,U,G,> RAIS$ ON ,?URSDAY #a-#b C5T 9 CONSEQU5CE ( NEWS RECEIV$ ( %ORT CROPS2 BUT LAT] >RIVALS CONTRADICT$ ! REPORT1 & PRICES FELL AGA94 ,M,O,L,A,S,S,E,S 9 DEM&1 & HOLD]S NOT ANXI\S TO SELL4 ,P,O,R,K - LITTLE 9 M>KET1 & PRICES RIS+4 ,B,A,C,O,N - ,PL5TY & DULL 2 FELL S9CE \R LA/ FROM #ae TO #ac CTS4 ,C,O,T,T,O,N - ,ALL 9 FEW H&S1 B\<T UP ON SPECULATION40 ,AGA91 FROM A NEWSPAP] NE>E/ AT H&3 - 

#a#i#e4 0,! /OCK M>KET ADVANC$ ?IS MORN+1 & = A TIME WAS QUITE BUOYANT4 ,! AG5TS ( ,BRITI% H\SES H]E ASS]T ?AT 9/EAD ( SELL+ !IR /OCKS1 ! ,5GLI% WILL TAKE1 ADVANTAGE ( \R PANIC TO BUY MORE4 ,?IS /IMULATES SPECULATORS TO BUY ,NEW ,YORK ,C5TRAL1 ,]IE1 ,ILL9OIS ,C5TRAL1 & O!R /OCKS :I* >E HELD ABROAD1 & AT ONE TIME TO-DAY ALL !SE /OCKS W]E CONSID]ABLY HI<]4 4 4 4 4 4 4,! ADVANCE 9 ,COTTON WAS BAS$ ON ! PROBABILITY ( A R$UCTION 9 ! SUPPLY10 ETC4 

#a#i#f4 ,!SE >E ONLY AV]AGE SPECIM5S1 BUT !Y EXHIBIT ! PR9CIPLE UND] CONSID]ATION 3 !Y %[ ?AT WOR? OR VALUE TO ! RECEIV]1 RA!R ?AN ,C,O,/,S TO ! PRODUC] & V5DOR1 IS MADE ! BASIS & MEASURE ( EX*ANGEABLE PRICE4 ,!Y %[ A SY/EMATIC WAT*FULNESS ( ! FLUCTUATIONS ( ?IS VALUE1 & ?AT ! PRICE IS SET1 ACCORD+LY1 UP TO ! LA/ PO9T ! RECEIV] CAN BE> 2 & WE SEE ! DEGREES ( !IR WANTS OR NECESSITIES AS CLOSELY CALCULAT$ AS ! PULSATIONS ( ! VICTIMS ( TORTURE1 :]E ! PHYSICIAN /&S TO EXAM9E & REPORT H[ MU* ! VICTIM CAN BE> & LIVE 2 & ! P>T :I* ! PHYSICIAN ACTS 9 ! ONE CASE1 ! NEWSPAP]S ACT 9 ! O!R4 

#a#i#g4 0,BUY+ UP ON SPECULATION0 MEANS CREAT+WANT 9 ORD] TO PR(IT BY ITS SUPPLY2 & HE IS ! MO/ SUCCESSFUL SPECULATOR :O CAN CREATE ! MO/ DI/RESS & EXTORT ! MO/ FROM IT4 ,?IS IS ,C,I,V,I,L,I,Z,$ ,C,A,N,N,I,B,A,L,I,S,M4 

#a#i#h4 ,AS PRICES >E RAIS$1 ! RI* HAVE ! BE/ *ANCES ( LIFE4 ,! *ANCE ( ! POOR IS TO SUFF]1 & H5CE ! G5]AL SCRAMBLE TO AVOID UNPAID LABOR1 & TO BECOME RI* AT ANY CO/2 & :AT IS CALL$ #da SOCIETY #aa RESEMBLES A L>GE BASKET ( SLIMY WORMS1 EA* ONE WRIGGL+ & /RUGGL+ TO GET AT ! TOP RA!R ?AN TO BE CRU%$ AT ! BOTTOM4 

#a#i#i4 ,MAK+ ,C,O,/,S ! BASIS & LIMIT ( ALL PRICE4 ,W\LD UPSET ! BASKET1 & EA* /RUGGL] W\LD F9D ! NATURAL LEVEL & HIS APPROPRIATE SPH]E ( LIFE4 

#b4 ,! WORD CO/ IS US$ 9 ITS MO/ PHILOSOPHICAL & MO/ COMPREH5SIVE & EXACT S5SE - ,SIGNIFY+ ! 5DURANCE ( :ATEV] IS DI/KGREEABLE4 

#b#a4 ,FATIGUE ( M9D OR BODY IS ,CO/4 ,RESPONSIBILITY :I* CAUSES ANXIETY IS ,CO/4 ,TO HAVE \R TIME OR ATT5TION TAK5 UP AGA9/ \R PREF]5CES -TO MAKE A SACRIFICE ( ANY K9D - A FEEL+ ( MORTIFICATION - PA9FUL SUSP5SE - FE>- SUFF]+ OR 5DUR+ ANY?+ AGA9/ \R 9CL9ATION1 IS H]E CONSID]$ ,C,O,/4 

#b#b4 ,IF A B>REL ( FL\R CO/ ITS PRODUC]S1 C>RI]S1 & V5DORS ?IRTY H\RS' LABOR1 !N ?IRTY H\RS ( ANY O!R LABOR1 :E!R ) ! H&S OR ! M9D1 :I* WAS EQUALLY PA9FUL1 DISAGREEABLE1 OR REPUGNANT 7IF ,WANT$ BY ! O!R P>TIES71 W\LD CON/ITUTE AN EQUITABLE & LEGITIMATE PRICE = ! FL\R4 

#b#c4 ,! VALUE ( A LOAF ( BREAD TO A />V+ MAN IS EQUAL TO ! VALUE ( HIS LIFE 3 & IF ! PRICE ( A ?+ %\LD BE :AT IT WILL BR+1 !N A V5DOR MI<T DEM& ( ! PASS5G]S ( A WRECK$ VESSEL1 ! :OLE ( !IR FUTURE LIVES 9 S]VITUDE1 AS ! PROP] PRICE ( ! BREAD ?AT SAV$ !IR LIVES6 ,BUT ANY ONE :O %\LD MAKE SU* A DEM& W\LD BE LOOK$ UPON AS 9SANE -- A ,CANNIBAL2 & ONE SIMULTANE\S VOICE W\LD D5\NCE ! \TRAGE\S 9JU/ICE1 & ,W\LD CRY AL\D = RETRIBUTION4 ,:Y 8 ,:AT IS IT ?AT CON/ITUTES ! CANNIBALISM 9 ?IS CASE 8 ,IS IT NOT MEASUR+ ! PRICE ( ! BREAD ACCORD+ TO ITS VALUE 9/EAD ( ITS CO/1 OR SETT+ A PRICE UPON ! 0?+0 ACCORD+ TO #aa :AT IT W\LD BR+ 0 8 

#b#d4 ,IF ! PRODUC]S1 C>RI]S1 & V5DORS ( ! BREAD HAD BE/[$ ONE H\R'S LABOR UPON ?AT GIV54 TO EA* PASS5G]1 !N ONE H\R'S LABOR FROM EA*1 ,:I* WAS EQUALLY REPUGNANT1 W\LD CON/ITUTE ! JU/ COMP5SATION = ! BREAD4 

#b#e4 ,A ,W,A,T,* HAS A CO/ & A VALUE4 ,! CO/ CONSI/S ( ! CO/ ( ! LABOR BE/[$ ON ! M9]ALS 9 CONV]T+ !M 9TO METALS1 ! CO/S 7EI!R PHYSICAL OR M5TAL7 5DUR$ BY ! WORKM5 9 CON/RUCT+ ! WAT*1 ! CO/S 9 ! WE> ( TOOLS1 R5T1 FIREWOOD1 9SURANCE1 TAXES1 CL]K%IP1 SUP]9T5D5CE1 & V>I\S O!R CONT+5T EXP5SES ( ITS MANUFACTURE1 TOGE!R ) ! LABOR & O!R CO/S ( ITS TRANSMISSION TO ! ONE :O USES IT4 ,9 SOME ( !SE DEP>TM5TS1 ! LABOR IS MORE DISAGREEABLE OR MORE DELET]I\S TO HEAL? ?AN 9 O!RS1 & !RE=E %\LD BE HI<] PAID2 BUT ALL !SE ITEMS1 OR MORE1 CON/ITUTE ! ,CO/ ( ! WAT*4 

#b#f4 ,! VALUE ( A WELL-MADE WAT* DEP5DS UPON ! NATURAL QUALITIES ( ! METALS OR M9]ALS EMPLOY$2 UPON ! NATURAL PR9CIPLES ( ITS ME*ANISM2 UPON ! USES TO :I* IT IS APPLI$1 & UPON ! FANCY & WANTS ( ! PUR*AS]1 & W\LD BE DIFF]5T ) EV]Y DIFF]5T PUR*AS]1 & W\LD *ANGE EV]Y DAY 9 ! H&S ( ! [N]1 & ) EV]Y DIFF]5T USE TO :I* HE APPLI$ IT4 ,N[ :O WILL UND]TAKE TO SET A PRICE UPON ! ,VALUE ( ! WAT* 8 ,! ,CO/ WE CAN MEASURE & E/IMATE SATISFACTORILY1 BUT :O CAN DET]M9E ! VALUE ( COPP] & Z9C ORE8 OR :O HAS ANY RI<T TO SET ANY PRICE UPON !M1 OR ANY O!R NATURAL WEAL?1 BE=E HE HAS BE/[$ ANY LABOR UPON IT8 ,:O HAS ANY RI<T TO *>GE = ! PR9CIPLES ( ME*ANISM1 EXCEPT = HIS LABOR 9 APPLY+ !M8 ,:O HAS ! CAPACITY TO MEASURE1 & :O HAS ANY RI<T TO SET A PRICE ACCORD+ TO ?IS VALUE ( ! WAT*8 ,! ATTEMPT IS AS RIDICUL\S AS ! PR9CIPLE IS 9IQUIT\S4 

#b#g4 ,CO/1 !N1 IS ! TRUE BASIS & LIMIT ( PRICE1 EV5 9 ! MO/ COMPLICAT$ TRANSACTIONS4 ,! VALUE ( A ?+ IS NO MORE FIT TO MEASURE ITS PRICE ?AN A FLOAT+ LOG IS FIT = A B\ND>Y ( A PIECE ( L&4 

#b#h4 ,AN >TICLE MU/ HAVE A VALUE TO ! RECEIV] EQUAL TO ITS CO/ TO 9DUCE ANY PUR*ASE AT ALL2 BUT ,CO/1 NOT VALUE1 %\LD SET ! LIMIT ( ! PRICE4 

#b#i4 ,A MAN MAY 9=M HIS NEI<BOR ?AT HIS H\SE IS ON FIRE4 ,! 9=MATION MAY BE ( GREAT VALUE TO ! OCCUPANTS1 BUT TO MAKE ?IS A GR\ND ( PROPORTIONAL PRICE1 OR ( AN 9DEF9ITE OBLIGATION1 W\LD BE SETT+ A PRICE ACCORD+ TO ! 0WOR? ( A ?+40 

#b#a4,! P]=MANCE ( A PIECE ( MUSIC 9 :I* ! P]=M] FEELS PLEASURE BUT NO PA91 & :I* IS ATT5D$ ) NO CONT+5T CO/1 HAS NO LEGITIMATE GR\ND ( PRICE1 AL?\< IT MAY BE ( GREAT VALUE TO ALL )9 HE>+4 

#b#a#a4 ,A WORD ( SYMPA?Y TO ! DI/RESS$ MAY BE ( GREAT VALUE TO !M2 BUT TO MAKE ?IS VALUE A GR\ND ( PRICE1 OR ( AN 9DEF9ITE OBLIGATION1 IS GETT+ :AT ! 0?+ WILL BR+10 & CONTAM9AT+ ONE ( ! MO/ HOLY DEP>TM5TS ( HUMAN 9T]C\RSE4 

#b#a#b4 ,A MAN HAS A LAWSUIT P5D+1 UPON :I* HANGS HIS PROP]TY1 HIS SECURITY1 HIS P]SONAL LIB]TY1 OR HIS LIFE4 ,! LAWY] :O UND]TAKES HIS CASE MAY DEM& T51 TW5TY1 FIFTY1 FIVE HUNDR$1 OR FIVE ?\S& DOLL>S1 = A FEW H\RS' ATT5DANCE ON ! CASE4 ,?IS PRICE W\LD BE BAS$ *IEFLY ON ! VALUE ( HIS S]VICES TO HIS CLI5T4 ,N[ !RE IS NO?+ 9 ?IS /ATEM5T ?AT S\NDS WRONG1 BECAUSE \R C>S >E FAMILI>IZ$ ) WRONG4 ,BUT LET US ANALYZE IT4 ,! ,CO/S TO ! LAWY] MI<T BE TW5TY H\RS' LABOR 9 ATT5DANCE AT C\RT1 :I*1 IF REPUGNANT1 W\LD 5TITLE HIM TO COMP5SATION2 & ALL[+ A PORTION = HIS APPR5TICE%IP1 SAY TW5TY-TWO H\RS 9 ALL1 ) ALL CONT+5T EXP5SES1 W\LD CON/ITUTE A LEGITIMATE1 A JU/ GR\ND ( PRICE2 BUT ! V]Y NEXT /EP BEYOND ?IS RE/S ON VALUE1 & IS ! FIR/ /OP 9 ,CANNIBALISM4 

#b#a#c4 ,! LABOR]1 :5 HE COMES TO DIG ! LAWY]'S CELL>1 NEV] ?9KS ( SETT+ A PRICE UPON ITS FUTURE VALUE TO ! [N]2 LIE ONLY CONSID]S H[ LONG IT WILL TAKE HIM1 H[ H>D ! GR\ND IS1 :AT WILL BE ! WEA!R TO :I* HE WILL BE EXPOS$1 :AT WILL BE ! WE> ( ! TEAMS1 TOOLS1 CLO!S1 ETC42 BUT 9 ALL !SE ITEMS HE CONSID]S NO?+ BUT ! DIFF]5T ITEMS ( CO/ TO HIMSELF4 

#b#a#d4 ,R,5,T,S ,( L& & BUILD+S1 ESPECIALLY 9 ! CITIES1 >E G5]ALLY 0:AT !Y WILL BR+2 ',I & !SE R5TS >E BAS$ *IEFLY ON ! VALUE ( ! USE ( ! PROP]TY1 ACCORD+ TO ! NECESSITIES ( ! OCCUPANTS1 9/EAD ( ! CO/S TO ! [N]S1 :I* CONSI/ ( NATURAL DECAY1 9SURANCE1 TAXES1 & ! LABOR ( LETT+ ! PROP]TY1 COLLECT+ R5TS1 ETC4 

#b#a#e4 ,! DOCTOR DEM&S ( ! WOODCUTT] ! PROCE$S ( FIVE1 T51 OR TW5TY DAYS' LABOR = ! ATT5DANCE ( AN H\R1 & ASKS1 9 EXCUSE1 IF ! SICK MAN W\LD NOT PREF] TO PAY ?IS PRICE RA!R ?AN SUBMIT TO CONT9U\S DISEASE OR DEA?4 ,?IS1 AGA91 IS BAS+ A PRICE UPON AN ASSUM$ VALUE ( HIS ATT5DANCE 9/EAD ( ITS ,CO/4 ,IT IS COMMON TO PLEAD ! #aa SKILL0 REQUIR$ TO PRESCRIBE = ! SICK4 4 ,)\T WAIT+ TO DET]M9E H[ MU* SKILL MI<T BE EMPLOY$ 9 ! CASE1 IT MAY BE SUFFICI5T TO %[ ?AT SKILL OR TAL5TS :I* RESULT FROM LABOR ( BODY OR M9D1 :E!R EMPLOY$ 9 CUTT+ WOOD OR CUTT+ (F A LEG OR AN >M1 ALL CONT+5CIES CONSID]$1 SO F> AS !Y CO/ ! POS4 SESSOR1 >E A LEGITIMATE GR\ND ( E/IMATE & ( PRICE2 BUT ,SKILL OR TAL5TS :I* CO/ NO?+ >E NATURAL WEAL?1 & %\LD BE ACCESSIBLE 7IF AT ALL71 LIKE WAT] 9 \R NEI<BOR'S BROOK1 )\T PRICE4 

#b#a#f4 ,ALL PAT5TS & COPYRI<TS GIVE TO ! 9V5TOR1 DISCOV]]1 OR ! AU?OR :ATEV] HE 0CAN GET10 & ONLY :AT HE CAN GET1 = HIS PRODUCTION3 & HE MAY GET A ?\S& TIMES PAID1 OR NOT A ?\S&? P>T PAID4 ,HIS PROP] COMP5SATION W\LD BE AN EQUIVAL5T = ! CO/S ( HIS PHYSICAL OR M5TAL LABOR ADD$ TO ?AT ( HIS MAT]IALS1 ! EXP5SES ( EXP]IM5TS1 9VE/IGATIONS1 & O!R CONT+5CIES4 

#b#a#g4 ,A SPECULATOR BUYS A PIECE ( L& = A TRIFLE1 & HOLDS IT TILL SURR\ND+ IMPROVEM5TS1 MADE BY O!RS1 9CREASE ITS VALUE1 & IT IS !N SOLD 0ACCORD+LY10 = FIVE1 T51 OR A HUNDR$ TIMES ITS ORIG9AL PRICE2 YET ?IS IS ONLY 0:AT IT WILL BR+20 BUT1 FROM ?IS OP]ATION ( CIVILIZ$ CANNIBALISM :OLE FAMILIES LIVE FROM G5]ATION TO G5]ATION1 9 IDL5ESS & LUXURY1 UPON ! LABOR ( ! SURR\ND+ PEOPLE1 :O MU/ HAVE ! L& AT ANY PRICE4 ,?IS IS ONE =M ( SLAV]Y4 ,9/EAD ( ?IS1 ! PRIME CO/ ( L&1 ! TAXES1 & O!R CONT+5T EXP5SES ( SURVEY+1 ETC41 TOGE!R ) ! LABOR ( MAK+ CONTRACTS1 W\LD CON/ITUTE ! TRUE BASIS = ! PRICE ( L& PUR*AS$ = SALE4 ,IF ,I PUR*ASE A LOT = MY [N USE1 & Y\ WANT IT1 ,I MAY PROP]LY CONSID] :AT W\LD COMP5SATE ME = ! SACRIFICE ,I %\LD MAKE1 OR ! CO/ ( P>T+ ) IT2 BUT ?IS IS A V]Y DIFF]5T ?+ FROM PUR*AS+ IT ON PURPOSE TO P>T ) IT1 & :5 NO SU* SACRIFICE IS MADE4 

#b#a#h4 ,! PRODUCTS ( MA*9]Y >E N[ SOLD = :AT !Y WILL BR+10 & ITS ADVANTAGES GO *IEFLY TO ITS [N]S4 ,IF !SE PRODUCTS W]E PRIC$ BY ! WE> ( ! MA*9]Y1 ITS ATT5DANCE1 & O!R CONT+5T ITEMS ( CO/1 ! [N]S W\LD NOT BE 9T]E/$ 9 GR9D+ D[N ! WAGES ( ITS ATT5DANTS2 & 9 PROPORTION AS IT ?REW ! WORK+ CLASSES \T ( EMPLOYM5T1 IT W\LD WORK = !M4 ,H]E IS ! LONG-S\<T SOLUTION ( ! ANTAGONISM BETWE5 MA*9]Y & MANUAL LABOR6 

#b#a#i4 ,AN IMPORT] WRITES A LETT] TO A =EIGN C\NTRY = GOODS TO ! AM\NT ( =TY ?\S& DOLL>S4 ,ON !IR >RIVAL HE SELLS !M = #aa :AT !Y WILL BR+40 ,P]HAPS !Y 0BR+0 =TY-FIVE ?\S&1 P]HAPS SEV5TY ?\S&4 ,IF SIXTY ?\S&1 !N1 ALL[+ SAY TWO ?\S& = CO/S ( IMPORTATION & SALE1 HE OBTA9S EI<TTE5 ?\S& DOLL>S = P]HAPS EI<T OR T5 H\RS' LABOR OR ?\<T 9 M]*&IZ+6 

#b#b4 ,) ?IS SUM HE C\LD OBTA9 ?IRTY-SIX ?\S& TIMES AS MU* LABOR ( ! H>DE/ WORK+ M51 OR SEV5TY-TWO ?\S& TIMES AN EQUIVAL5T FROM WOM5 :O WORK = TW5TY-FIVE C5TS A DAY1 OR A HUNDR$ & =TY-F\R ?\S& TIMES AN EQUIVAL5T FROM *ILDR5 AT TWELVE C5TS A DAY6 

#b#b#a4 ,A4 L5DS TO ,B4 T5 ?\S& DOLL>S1 AT SIX P]C5T1 = ONE YE>4 ,AT ! 5D ( ! YE> HE RECEIVES BACK ! T5 ?\S& L5T1 & SIX HUNDR$ DOLL>S MORE6 ,= :AT8 ,BECAUSE IT WAS ( ?AT OR MORE VALUE TO ! BORR[]4 ,= ! SAME REASON1 :Y NOT *>GE A ?\S& DOLL>S = A BOX ( PILLS1 BECAUSE !Y SAVE ! LIFE ( ! PATI5T 8 

#b#b#b4 ,) ?IS SIX HUNDR$ DOLL>S1 :I* ! LAWS DECL>E NOT TO BE USURY1 ! CAPITALI/ CAN KEEP ?REE ( ! H>DE/ WORK+ M5 CON/ANTLY DRUDG+ = HIM A :OLE YE> OR HE C\LD COMM& ! CON/ANT WAT*FUL & SLAVI% ATT5DANCE & DEP5D5CE & LABOR ( EI<T DE/ITUTE WOM5 = A :OLE YE>1 OR HE C\LD 5?RALL$ SIXTE5 DE/ITUTE *ILDR5 = A :OLE YE>1 = FIVE OR SIX H\RS ( HIS LABOR 9 L5D+ MONEY4 ,OR = ?IS FIVE OR SIX H\RS' 7( NOT ! H>DE/7 LABOR1 HE W\LD OBTA9 AT ! RATE ( AB\T A HUNDR$ DOLL>S P] H\R1 OR AB\T ONE ?\S& SIX HUNDR$ TIMES AN EQUIVAL5T FROM ! H>DE/ WORK+ M51 OR AB\T F\R ?\S& FIVE HUNDR$ TIMES AN EQUIVAL5T FROM ! H>DE/ WORK+ WOM51 OR N9E ?\S& FIVE HUNDR$ TIMES AN EQUIVAL5T FROM SUFF]+ & DEF5SELESS *ILDR56 

#b#b#c4 ,IF Y\ SACRIFICE TW5TY DOLL>S 7TO :I* Y\ >E EQUITABLY 5TITL$7 9 L5D+ ME A HUNDR$1 !N NOT SIX P]C5T1 BUT TW5TY DOLL>S1 OR TW5TY P]C5T1 TOGE!R ) PAY = Y\R LABOR1 W\LD BE Y\R PROP] COMP5SATION4 

#b#b#d4 ,ONE1 9 GETT+ ALL HIS LABOR #aa WILL BR+10 GETS A ?\S& TIMES AN EQUIVAL5T1 :ILE ANO!R1 FOLL[+ ! SAME PR9CIPLE1 DOES NOT GET A ?\S&? P>T PAID1 :ILE ALL >E 9VOLV$ 9 A DEGRAD+ SCRAMBLE TO AVOID ! UNPAID & MORE REPUGNANT PURSUITS1 & TO CR[D 9TO ! MORE PR(ITABLE & LESS REPUGNANT 2 & ! MA9 BUS9ESS ( LIFE IS TO CONDUCT ?IS W>F>E TO ! BE/ ADVANTAGE1 AL?\< ! MO/ SUCCESSFUL >E NEV] SECURE FROM BE+ VICTIMIZ$1 UPON ! SAME PR9CIPLE BY :I* !Y SUCCE$$6 ,LAWS & GOV]NM5TS >E PR(ESS$LY 9V5T$ TO REM$Y ! 9SECURITY ?US PRODUC$1 BUT !Y CONFIRM ! V]Y PR9CIPLE ?AT PRODUCES IT1 & ADD ALL !IR [N ELEM5TS ( CONFUSION & VIOL5CE TO ! G5]AL AN>*Y4 

#b#b#e4 ,CO/S BE+ MADE ! BASIS & LIMIT ( PRICE1 !RE W\LD BE NO DI/URB+ PREF]5CE = ONE PURSUIT RA!R ?AN ANO!R2 ! ,/RIFE W\LD BE AT AN 5D - ! SUPPLY 9 ALL DEP>TM5TS W\LD BE 9 PROPORTION TO ! DEM& -NO DI/URB+ FLUCTUATIONS 9 PRICES W\LD EV] OCCUR - W>S = ! PR(ITS ( TRADE W\LD BE AT AN 5D -! POORE/ W\LD BE ABUNDANTLY RI*TEMPTATIONS TO FRAUDS & 5CROA*M5TS ( ALL K9DS W\LD CEASE1 & LAWS & GOV]NM5TS = ! #aa PROTECTION ( P]SON & PROP]TY0 W\LD BE UNNECESS>Y1 & !IR DESOLAT+ C>E] MI<T BE BR\<T TO A CLOSE6 ,?IS SIMPLE JU/ICE 7CO/ - ! LIMIT ( PRICE7 W\LD MAKE IT NECESS>Y = EV]Y ONE TO E>N AS MU* AS HE CONSUM$1 & -W\LD IRRESI/IBLY ABOLI% EV]Y =M ( SLAV]Y UND] ! SUN1 EV5 ! MO/ DEGRAD+ ( ALL -! SLAV]Y ( HOLD+ & DEP5D+ ON SLAVES6 

#b#b#f4 ,A,V,>,I,C,E 7SUPPOS$ BY SOME TO BE ! ROOT ( ALL HUMAN EVILS71 BE+ ONE ( ! EFFECTS ( 9SECURITY ( CONDITION1 W\LD NATURALLY DIE AWAY :5 ! FUTURE %\LD REPOSE ON A PUBLICLY APPROV$ PR9CIPLE :I* %\LD 5SURE AN ABUNDANCE TO EV]Y ONE AT LESS CO/ ?AN ?AT ( TAK+ C>E ( L>GE ACCUMULATIONS4 ,9 O!R WORDS1 ! PRIM>Y OBJECT ( L>GE ACCUMULATIONS ( PROP]TY IS = FUTURE SECURITY4 ,IF ! FUTURE IS SECUR$ )\T IT1 NO SU* ACCUMULATIONS W\LD BE ?\<T WOR?Y ( PURSUIT4 

#b#b#g4 ,CO/S BE+ MADE ! LIMIT ( PRICE1 EV]Y ONE BECOMES 9T]E/$ TO R$UCE CO/1 - TO LI<T5 EA* O!R'S BURD5S 6 ,!N1 EV]Y MAN'S H& ACTS ) 9/EAD ( 0AGA9/ EV]Y MAN10 & ,H,U,M,A,N ,9,T,],E,/,S ,>,E ,H,>,M,O,N,I,Z,$6 

#b#b#h4 ,LEGISLATORS6 ,FRAM]S ( 9/ITUTIONS 6 ,LEAD]S ( ! PUBLIC M9D6 BEHOLD Y\R MO/ FATAL ]ROR6 ,Y\ HAVE SUFF]$ ,VALUE 9/EAD ( ,CO/ TO BECOME ! MEASURE ( PRICE 9 ALL ! BUS9ESS ( ! WORLD6 ,H5CE ! RU9\S RAGE ( COMPETITION1 & ! DE/RUCTIVE FLUCTUATIONS 9 BUS9ESS1 & ! REMOTE ORIG9 & PR9CIPAL CAUSE ( ! W>S ( NATIONS & ( 9DIVIDUAL ANTAGONISMS6 ,H5CE1 ALSO1 ! 9SECURITY 9 ALL CONDITIONS ( LIFE1 & ! UNIV]SAL SCRAMBLE = UNLIMIT$ ACCUMULATIONS ( PROP]TY1 AS ! HI<E/ ATTA9ABLE GOOD6 ',H5CE1 TOO1 ! TEA*+ & P]PETUATION ( IGNORANCE = ! SAKE ( PR(IT1 & ALL ! DEGRADATION & CRIME & ! HORRORS ( PUNI%M5TS >IS+ FROM !SE CAUSES6 ,BEHOLD1 ALSO1 ! ,O,R,I,G,9 ,( ,R,I,* ,& ,P,O,O,R6 - ,! DEEP- SEAT$ G]M ( SPECULATION1 AT ONCE ! CURSE ( 9DIVIDUALS & ( NATIONS6,! DIABOLICAL *>M ?AT WORKS -UNSE5 EV5 BY ?OSE :O USE IT6- ,! FATAL PIT-FALL ( ! WORK+ CLASSES6,! PEOPLE'S MI/AKE6 - ,! LEGISLATIVE FRAUD6 -,! POLITICAL BLUND]6--,! H]$IT>Y TA9T ( ,B>B>ISM - ,! SUBTLE & ALL-P]VAD+ POISON ( CIVILIZATION6 

#b#b#i4 ,!SE /ATEM5TS MAY BE TOO BRIEF1 & ! CONCLUSIONS TOO SUDD5LY DRAWN = MANY M9DS1 BUT !Y WILL BE MORE ELABORATELY CONSID]$ 9 ! FOLL[+ PAGES4 

#b#c4 ,LET US N[ PROCE$ TO CONSID] :AT A CIRCULAT+ M$IUM OR MONEY1 %\LD BE4 

#b#c#a4 ,! EXP]IM5TS W]E BEGUN 9 ,C9C9NATI1 9 #a#h#b#g1 UPON ! SIMPLE BASIS ( H\R = H\R 9 ALL PURSUITS1 )\T ANY ELEM5T ( MEASUREM5T BUT ?AT ( TIME1 ACCORD+ TO A SUGGE/ION BELIEV$ TO HAVE ORIG9AT$ 9 ,5GL&4 ,IT SOON APPE>$1 H[EV]1 ?AT ! MORE PLEASANT PURSUITS W\LD BE OV]CR[D$ BY COMPETITORS :O W\LD RU9 EA* O!R1 :ILE ! EQUALLY NECESS>Y PR(ESSIONS W]E %UNN$1 & A L>GE PORTION ( WANTS W\LD BE LEFT UNSUPPLI$4 ,= 9/ANCE1 A /EAM SAW- MILL WAS TO BE KEPT RUNN+ NI<T & DAY 9 ! W9T] TIME4 ,! NI<T T\R WAS A GREAT DEAL MORE DISAGREEABLE OR UNCOM=TABLE ?AN ! DAY T\R4 ,ALL H&S PREF]R$ ! DAY T\R AT ! SAME PRICE4 ,IT WAS >RANG$ SO ?AT ! COMP5SATION = T5 H\RS AT NI<T W\LD EQUAL ?AT = F\RTE5 H\RS ( ! DAYTIME4 ,H]E WAS ONE RECOGNITION ( ! ELEM5T ( REPUGNANCE OR CO/ AS ! NECESS>Y ADJU/+ P[]4 

#b#c#b4 ,TO APPLY ?IS IDEA AS A REGULATOR ( ALL 9T]*ANGES ( LABOR IS A MATT] ( 9V5TION & ! MO/ +5I\S 9V5TOR W\LD PROBABLY SUCCE$ BE/2 BUT ?US F>1 IT HAS BE5 EFFECT$ ?US 3 - 

#b#c#c4 ,SOME /APLE >TICLE ( ! P>TICUL> LOCALITY1 SU* AS CORN OR :EAT1 IS SELECT$ AS A ,UNIT BY :I* TO COMP>E & MEASURE ALL O!R LABORS1 AS WE N[ MEASURE !M BY DOLL>S & C5TS4 ,= 9/ANCE1 AFT] ASC]TA9+ H[ MANY P\NDS ( CORN IS ! AV]AGE PRODUCT ( AN H\R'S LABOR1 SAY IT IS T5 P\NDS1 !N ANY LABOR1 :I* ! P]=M] ( IT CONSID]S AS CO/LY AS CORN-RAIS+1 W\LD BE RAT$ AT T5 P\NDS P] H\R4 ,IF ONLY HALF AS CO/LY1 ONLY FIVE P\NDS1 ETC4 

#b#c#d4 ,( C\RSE IT IS NECESS>Y ?AT BO? P>TIES CO9CIDE 9 ! PRICES SET1 :I* !Y >E LIKELY TO DO AFT] 9VE/IGATION1 = IT IS NOT EXACTNESS SO MU* AS IT IS P]MAN5CE ?AT WE WANT2 BECAUSE1 ?IS FIX$NESS ONCE ATTA9$1 SECURITY BEG9S4  
,E,X,*,A,N,G,E,S4 

  

#b#c#e4 ,WE CANNOT C>RY :EAT1 %OES1 C>P5T] WORK1 ETC41 AB\T US SO AS TO COMPLETE ALL \R EX*ANGES ON ! SPOT1 & !RE=E1 WE NE$ SOME?+ ?AT REPRES5TS !SE PRODUCTS1 :I* WE CAN C>RY AB\T US1 & GIVE & RECEIVE1 & :I* WILL PROCURE ALL !SE ?+S :5 WE NE$ !M4 

#b#c#f4 #a GET A PAIR ( %OES1 ! LABOR 9 :I* IS E/IMAT$ AS EQUIVAL5T TO ! LABOR CO/S 9 A HUNDR$ P\NDS ( CORN1 & ,I GIVE ! %OEMAK] MY NOTE = C>P5T] WORK EQUIVAL5T ALSO TO A HUNDR$ P\NDS4 

#b#c#g4 ,! ,CO/S ( EI<T H\RS ( MY C>P5T] WORK MAY EQUAL ! ,CO/S ( T5 H\RS ( ! %OEMAK]4 ,?IS W\LD GIVE HIM T5 P\NDS & ME TWELVE & A HALF P\NDS P] H\R4 

#b#c#h4 ,9 ?IS MANN] ANY PR(ESSION :ATEV] CAN BE COMP>$1 MEASUR$1 & EX*ANG$ ) EV]Y O!R1 EA* ISSU+ NOTES REPRES5T+ HIS OR H] LABOR1 & !SE NOTES1 PASS+ FROM H& TO H& BE=E !Y >E R$EEM$1 W\LD CON/ITUTE A CIRCULAT+ M$IUM BAS$ ON ,R,E,A,L,I,T,I,E,S--ON ! BONE & MUSCLE1 ON ! MANUAL & M5TAL CAPACITIES1 ! PROP]TY & PROP]TY-PRODUC+ P[]S ( ! :OLE ( ! PEOPLE 7! S\NDE/ ( ALL F\NDATIONS7 6 -A MONEY ( ! ONLY K9D ?AT EV] \<T TO HAVE BE5 ISSU$6 

#b#c#i4 ,! NATURAL RESULTS TO :I* SU* A MONEY W\LD LEAD >E SO EXTRAORD9>Y ?AT !Y MAKE US D\BT \R [N REASON1 &1 IF /AT$1 MI<T SUBJECT US TO ! IMPUTATION ( 9SANITY4 ,WE ASK1 !RE=E1 ! JUDGM5T ( O!RS4 

#b#d4 ,W\LD NOT EV]Y ,MAN1 ,WOMAN1 & ,*ILD 7TO ! EXT5T ( HIS OR H] USEFULNESS7 BECOME A ,B,A,N,K,]1 & ?US EQUALIZE MONEY 8 

#b#d#a4 ,C\LD ,HOT ! POORE/ BE ABUNDANTLY RI* 8 

#b#d#b4 ,W\LD NOT ! BURD5 ( NECESS>Y LABOR BE R$UC$ TO ONE OR TWO H\RS A DAY1 & C\LD !RE BE ANY 9DUCEM5T TO SP5D ! :OLE DAY 9 CONTRIV+ UNC]TA9 MEANS TO SW9DLE OR ROB ! PRODUCTS ( LABOR FROM !IR PROP] [N]S 8 ,IF NOT1 !N W\LD NOT ?IS PR9CIPLE & ?IS MONEY PEACEABLY ABOLI% EV]Y SY/EM ( FRAUD & SLAV]Y UND] ! SUN8 

#b#d#c4 ,C\LD !RE EV] BE SU* A ?+ AS A MONEY PANIC OR A MONEY PRESSURE8 

#b#d#d4 ,W\LD NOT ?IS NATURAL & JU/ DI/RIBUTION ( MONEY NECESS>ILY COMPLETE ! TRUE & ONLY PRACTICAL 0BALANCE ( P[]10 & SOLVE ! GREAT PROBLEM ?AT CONVULSES & DESOLATES ! WORLD 8 

#b#d#e4 ,?AT \T ( ?IS PR9CIPLE ( ,EQUIVAL5TS >ISES NATURALLY ?AT COOP]ATION BETWE5 ! 9DIVIDUAL & ! PUBLIC 9T]E/S1 SO MU* DESIR$ & /RIV5 =1 -SEEMS SO SELF-EVID5T1 ?AT TO ATTEMPT ILLU/RATIONS MAY SEEM TO SOME M9DS LIKE ! ATTEMPTS TO ILLU/RATE ! %9+ ( ! SUN2 BUT AT ! RISK ( OBSCUR+ ! SUBJECT1 ,I ,WILL FURNI% A FEW HI/ORICAL FACTS4 

#b#d#f4 ,9 ! EXP]IM5TAL /ORES1 CONDUCT$ ON ?IS PR9CIPLE1 IT WAS SE5 ?AT1 9 ORD] TO PUT ! LABOR ( ! M]*ANT FAIRLY AGA9/ ! LABOR ( HIS CU/OM]S1 HIS COMP5SATION MU/ BE SEP>AT$1 DIS9TEGRAT$ FROM ! PRICE ( ! GOODS4 ,?IS ,WAS DONE2 & HIS LABOR 9 -WAIT+ ON EA* CU/OM] WAS MEASUR$ BY ! TIME EMPLOY$ :I* WAS ,%[N BY A CLOCK BE=E ! EYES ( BO? P>TIES4 

#b#d#g4 ,! GOODS ,W]E SOLD = !IR FIR/ CO/ ADD$ TO A C]TA9 FIX$ & PUBLICLY KN[N P]C5TAGE1 SUFFICI5T TO PAY ALL CONT+5T EXP5SES1 & EV]Y POSSIBLE EVID5CE WAS FURNI%$ TO ! CU/OM]S TO PROVE ?AT !Y PAID ONLY AN EQUIVAL5T 94 !IR [N LABOR = ! LABOR ( ! KEEP] ( ! /ORE4 

#b#d#h4 ,:ITE ?IS SECUR$ !IR CONFID5CE & RESPECT1 IT CREAT$ 9 SOME ( !M AN 9T]E/ 9 ! PR9CIPLE ITSELF1 & ANO!R K9D ( 9T]E/ :I* ALL C\LD FEEL2 NAMELY1 TO TAKE UP AS LITTLE ( ! KEEP]'S TIME AS POSSIBLE1 & TO VOLUNTE] TO ROLL B>RELS1 MOVE BOXES1 FOLD CLO?1 ETC41 TO ABRIDGE ! LABOR TO BE PAID =4 ,9 COMMON BUS9ESS1 ! PRICE NOT BE+ LIMIT$ BY CO/S1 !RE >E NO SU* CO9CID+ OR COOP]AT+ 9T]E/S4 

#b#d#i4 ,IT WAS AMUS+1 & MORE ?AN AMUS+1 TO SEE H[ C>EFUL SOME W]E ,DOT TO TAKE UP ! TIME ( ! KEEP] 9 #aa %OPP+40 ,! CU/OM]S W]E NOT AT ALL TR\BLESOME 9 ?IS RESPECT4 ,! GOODS W]E SO >RANG$ ?AT !Y C\LD SEE ! PRICES & QUALITIES1 & ! PRICES BE+ POSITIVELY FIX$ BY A PR9CIPLE :I* !Y APPROV$1 ! BUY] & SELL] W]E NO LONG] AT W>6 

#b#e4 ,A MAN CAME 9TO ! /ORE SAY+1 AS FA/ AS HE C\LD SPEAK1 #aa #a WANT A B>REL ( Y\R MACK]EL ,I KN[ !Y >E EI<T DOLL>S !RE IS ! MONEY & A C5T = Y\R TIME ( PUTT+ IT 9TO ! DRAW] ,I CAN GET IT 9TO ! WAGON Y\ NE$N'T COME \T GOOD-BY40 ,! PR(IT OR COMP5SATION = SELL+ ?AT B>REL ( MACK]EL WAS ONE C5T6 ,IS IT WOND]FUL ?AT SU* A PR9CIPLE %\LD F9D COOP]ATORS8 

#b#e#a4 ,ANO!R MAN CAME 9 & SAID1 #aa ,!RE IS A LOT ( MO/ EXCELL5T SUG> - N9E HOG%EADS - = SALE AT ,H----'S AUCTION /ORE1 *EAP60 

#b#e#b4 ,:AT WAS HIS MOTIVE = GIV+ ?IS 9=MATION TO ! KEEP] ( ?IS /ORE 9 P>TICUL> 8 ,HE FELT DEEPLY 9T]E/$ 9 ITS PR9CIPLE = ! G5]AL GOOD1 & HE WAS SLI<TLY 9T]E/$ AS ONE ( ! CONSUM]S ( ! SUG>1 :I* LIE KNEW LIE W\LD GET AT CO/1 :ATEV] ! 0M>KET-PRICE0 MI<T BE4 ,HE WAS 9T]E/$ MORALLY & PECUNI>ILY TO COOP]ATE = ! RESULT1 :I* B5EFIT$ ALL ! O!R CU/OM]S TO ! SUG> AS WELL AS HIMSELF4 

#b#e#c4 ,OBS]VE ?AT ,I AM N[ ILLU/RAT+ ! MANN] 9 :I* ! PR9CIPLE ( ,EQUIVAL5TS NEUTRALIZES ! ANTAGONISM ( 9T]E/S1 & PRODUCES ?AT H>MONY OR COOP]ATION ( 9T]E/S ?AT HAS ALWAYS BE5 ! GREATE/ CONSID]ATION = SOCIETY1 & )\T :I* WE MU/ LOOK 9 VA9 = TRUE CIVILIZATION2 BUT ) :I*1 IT CAN REA* A HI<] PLANE ?AN MANY M9DS >E N[ PREP>$ TO UND]/&4 

#b#e#d4 ,!SE COOP]AT+ 9T]E/S 9DUC$ TWO G5TLEM5 7?\< UNKN[N TO ! KEEP] BE=E ! /ORE COMM5C$7 TO (F] TO BECOME SECURITY = HIM 9 ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES ,BANK4 ,H]E WAS COOP]ATION )\T A WORD ( PL$GE OR PROMISE2 OR1 COOP]ATION & FRE$OM H>MONIZ$6 ,NO ORGANIZATION 7AS ?AT WORD IS COMMONLY UND]/OOD7 ( ANY K9D WAS NECESS>Y2 BUT ON ! CONTR>Y ANY PROPOSITION ( ! K9D W\LD ONLY HAVE H9D]$1 & P]HAPS PREV5T$1 COOP]ATION1 = BO? ( !SE G5TLEM5 BELONG$ TO *UR*ES :I* !Y C\LD NOT WELL DISREG>D 9 =M+ NEW CONNECTIONS1 ,IF UNIV]SAL PR9CIPLES MOVE US TO \R SATISFACTION1 WE NE$ NO O!R CONNECTIONS ?AN SU* AS NATURALLY GR[ \T ( ?OSE PR9CIPLES4 

#b#e#e4 ,A Y\NG MAN CAME 9 & SAID1 #aa ,H]E >E FIFTY DOLL>S ?AT ,I MAY NOT HAVE A USE = AT PRES5T4 ,P]HAPS Y\ W\LD LIKE TO USE IT 9 'PUR*AS+ TO ! BE/ ADVANTAGE40 ,:AT WAS HIS MOTIVE8 

#b#e#f4 ,A L>GE :OLESALE M]*ANT SAID TO ! KEEP] ( ! /ORE 9 ,NEW ,H>MONY1 #a#h#d#b1 #aaa HAD RESOLV$ ?AT ,I NEV] W\LD CR$IT ANO!R MAN ) A DOLL>'S WOR? ( GOODS2 BUT AS Y\ SEEM TO BE DO+ ! SAFE/ BUS9ESS ( ANY MAN 9 ! WORLD1 IF Y\ WANT MORE GOODS ?AN Y\ CAN PAY = AT ONCE1 TAKE !M1 & PAY = !M :5 !Y >E SOLD40 ,! KEEP] DID TAKE SEV5 HUNDR$ DOLL>S' WOR?1 & CONT9U$ TO DO ,S,O4 ,:AT WAS ?IS M]*ANT'S MOTIVE8 ,Y\ MAY SUPPOSE ?AT IT WAS SOLELY TO GET A QUICK M>KET = HIS GOODS4 ,IT IS V]Y WELL IF ?IS MOTIVE ALSO COOP]ATES ) A GREAT B5EFIC5T REVOLUTION2 BUT HE HAD SAID1 ) MU* FEEL+ & EMPHASIS1 9 A CONV]SATION ON ! SUBJECT1 #aa ,IF SU* PR9CIPLES AS ?OSE C\LD BE G5]ALLY 9TRODUC$1 ,I W\LD GIVE N9ETY-N9E DOLL>S 9 EV]Y HUNDR$ ,I POSSESS6 0 & HE WAS REPUT$ TO BE V]Y RI*4 

#b#e#g4 ,AN ,5GLI% G5TLEMAN ( =TUNE WAS 9TRODUC$ TO ! KEEP]1 & FRANKLY (F]$ TO ASSI/ ) HIS CAPITAL1 BUT ! KEEP] DID NOT ,WI% TO UND]TAKE ! MANAGEM5T ( ANY L>G] BUS9ESS ?AN HE ALREADY BAD4 ,:AT WAS ?IS G5TLEMAN'S MOTIVE8 ,HE HAD RETIR$ FROM BUS9ESS1 & DID NOT WANT TO ACCUMULATE MORE MONEY4 ,:ILE ALL !SE G5TLEM5 W]E COOP]AT+ FROM !IR [N PRIVATE MOTIVES1 !Y PUT IT 9 ! P[] ( ! KEEP] TO SUPPLY HUNDR$S :O COOP]AT$ FROM V>I\S MOTIVES1 ! :OLE BE+ MOV$ & REGULAT$ BY A PR9CIPLE1 & NOT BY ANY =MAL ORGANIZATION OR CLAN%IP :ATEV]4 

#b#e#h4 ,NO ONE D5IES ?AT :5 WE SEE IT = \R 9T]E/ TO COOP]ATE1 WE %ALL DO SO1 IF CONDITIONS ALL[ ( IT4 ,TO SEE IT = \R 9T]E/ & TO 9/ALL ! CONDITIONS1 !N1 IS :AT WE NE$1 BUT TO MAKE AN EF=T TO OBTA9 COOP]ATION BY ANY O!R /IMULUS IS VA91 WA/$ LABOR4 ,BUT :AT DO WE MEAN BY \R 9T]E/S8 ,DO WE MEAN ! MONEY WE CAN MAKE OR GET AT ! PRES5T MOM5T1 DISREG>D+ ! SACRIFICE ( ALL FUTURE OPPORTUNITIES8 OR DO WE MEAN ! MO/ MONEY WE CAN MAKE N[ & 9 ! FUTURE TAK5 TOGE!R8 OR DO WE MEAN ?AT IT IS = \R 9T]E/ TO HAVE CONDITIONS FIT = \RSELVES & HUMAN NATURE G5]ALLY TO LIVE 9 8 ,DIFF]5T PEOPLE WILL ACT FROM ALL !SE DIFF]5T MOTIVES1 & ALL !SE MOTIVES1 & V>I\S O!RS1 BR\<T MULTITUDES TO COOP]ATE 9 ?OSE /ORES1 %[+ ?AT !RE WAS NO NE$ ( ANY CON=MITY ( MOTIVE TO 5SURE COOP]ATION4 ,BUT ANY SU* DEM& W\LD HAVE DRIV5 ! CU/OM]S AWAY2 :ILE FRE$OM TO DIFF] MADE !M FEEL FREE TO COME6 ,BUT :AT WAS ( /ILL GREAT] IMPORTANCE1 ?IS DIV]SITY ( MOTIVE & *>ACT] PREV5T$ CLAN%IP FROM TAK+ ROOT & GR[+ UP4 

#b#e#i4 #a %\LD NOT EXPECT1 NOR WI% TO SEE1 GREAT PECUNI>Y SACRIFICES MADE :]E !RE IS NOT COMP5SATION 9 SOME =M1 - EI!R 9 SIMIL> SACRIFICES BE+ MADE ON OCCASION BY ! B5EFIT$ P>TY1 OR COMP5SATION 9 '! PLEASURE D]IV$ FROM PROMOT+ GOOD & GREAT OBJECTS4 ,UNCOMP5SAT$ SACRIFICES W\LD CONTRADICT ! 9/9CT ( SELF- PRES]VATION1 & W\LD NOT LONG CONT9UE4 

#b#f4 ,! P]C5TAGE CONT+5T FUND HAD ACCUMULAT$ 9 ! /ORE BEYOND ! EXP5SES1 & ! KEEP] HAD GIV5 \T WORD ?AT ?IS MI<T BE US$ 7IF WELL,SECUR$7 = G5]AL PURPOSES )\T 9T]E/4 ,A COOP]ATOR 9TRODUC$ A /RANG] 7A FRI5D ( HIS71 SAY+1 #aa ,Y\ TELL US ?AT Y\ HAVE ON H& A SURPLUS FUND4 ACCUMULAT$ BEYOND EXP5SES1 :I* Y\ PROPOSE TO USE OR HAVE US$ 9 V>I\S WAYS1 = ! B5EFIT ( ! DEAL]S H]E :O HAVE ?US OV]PAID ! ,EQUITABLE DEM& UPON !M 2 & ?AT ALL Y\ REQUIRE IS ?AT IT %\LD BE KEPT SAFE4 & AVAILABLE :5 Y\ MAY BE OBLIG$ TO CALL ON IT TO SU/A9 LOSSES4 ,!RE=E1 IF ,Y\ WILL L5D TO MY FRI5D H]E ?IRTE5 DOLL>S1 ,I WILL GU>ANTEE ?AT IT %ALL BE RETURN$ 9 TWO WEEKS40 

#b#f#a4 ,! MONEY WAS L5T - ! NOTE & SECURITY TAK54 ,9 TWO WEEKS ! /RANG] RETURN$1 & LAY+ D[N ! MONEY SAID1 ?AT1 AS IT HAD SAV$ HIM & HIS FAMILY FROM SO MU* LOSS & DI/RESS1 HE WI%$ TO COMP5SATE ! KEEP] 9 PROPORTION TO ! B5EFITS !Y HAD RECEIV$4 #aa ,& N[10 ADD$ HE1 #aa #a AM READY TO PAY Y\ ANY PREMIUM Y\ MAY *OOSE TO ASK40 

#b#f#b4 0,Y\ >E A /RANG]1 ,SIR1 TO ! PR9CIPLES UPON :I* BUS9ESS IS DONE H]E10 SAID ! KEEP]4 

#b#f#c4 0,YES1 ,SIR2 BUT ,I %ALL NOT QUE/ION ANY PRICE Y\ MAY SET4 ,I CAN NEV] FEEL MYSELF ABSOLV$ FROM OBLIGATIONS TO Y\ AT ANY PRICE4 ,TAKE :ATEV] Y\ PLEASE1 ,I %ALL NOT QUE/ION IT40 

#b#f#d4 0,I SEE1 ,SIR1 ?AT Y\R FRI5D HAS NOT 9=M$ Y\ ( ! PECULI> OP]ATIONS ( ! NEW PR9CIPLES AS APPLI$ TO L5D+ MONEY4 ,! COMP5SATION OR 9T]E/ HAS NO REF]5CE TO ! B5EFIT CONF]R$ UPON ! BORR[]1 BUT IT IS BAS$ ON1 & LIMIT$ BY1 ! CO/S TO ! L5D]4 ,I EMPLOY$ AB\T FIVE M9UTES 9 L5D+ Y\ ! MONEY2 ,I %ALL EMPLOY AB\T FIVE MORE 9 RECEIV+ IT BACK AGA94 ,IT WAS SECUR$ & !RE WAS NO RISK OR LOSS4 ,I HAVE NOT BE5 OBLIG$ TO BORR[ MONEY 9 ITS PLACE2 Y\ HAVE ,ONLY TO COMP5SATE ME = MY LABOR 6 ,IF Y\ C\LD GIVE ME AN EQUIVAL5T 9 Y\R [N LABOR1 ?IS W\LD MAKE ALL RI<T2 BUT AS Y\ CANNOT1 ,I WILL RECEIVE T5 C5TS 9/EAD40 

#b#f#e4 0,I DO NOT UND]/& Y\1 ,SIR4 ,I AM REALLY 9 E>NE/ 9 :AT ,I SAY4 ,! MONEY HAS SAV$ ME & MY FAMILY FROM ! MORTIFICATION ( BE+ TURN$ 9TO ! /REET1 & HAV+ \R FURNITURE SOLD = R5T4 ,I AM A /RANG] H]E1 DISAPPO9T$ 9 MY EXPECTATIONS ( BUS9ESS1 :I* BR\<T ME FROM ,PHILADELPHIA4 ,PAY :AT ,I MAY TO Y\1 ,I CAN NEV] FEEL ABSOLV$ FROM ! GREATE/ OBLIGATIONS40 

#b#f#f4 0,I P]FECTLY UND]/& Y\1 ,SIR1 & %ALL BE ,EQUITABLY PAID ) ! T5 C5TS4 ,DON'T Y\ ?9K ,I MI<T BE SATISFI$ ) SIXTY C5TS P] H\R = MY LABOR 9 L5D+ MONEY1 :5 ! H>DE/ WORK+ M5 GET ONLY FIFTY C5TS = WORK+ A :OLE DAY AT ! MO/ DISAGREEABLE LABOR1 & GET ABUS$ & 9SULT$ BESIDES = BE+ OBLIG$ TO DO IT80 

#b#f#g4 0,WELL1 ?IS IS A MO/ EXTRAORD9>Y ?+6 ,& Y\ >E CONT5T TO L5D MONEY BY BE+ PAID ONLY = ! LABOR ( IT1 )\T TAK+ ANY ADVANTAGE ( ! NECESSITIES ( ! BORR[]8 

#b#f#h4 0,IS IT AS /RANGE1 ,SIR1 ?AT ,I %\LD BE CONT5T ) SIXTY C5TS P] H\R = MY LABOR1 AS ?AT !WORLD %\LD HAVE GONE ON = SO MANY C5TURIES 9 ,SETT+ ! PRICES ( ?+S ACCORD+ TO ! NECCESSITIES ( ! RECEIV]S8 ,?IS PR9CIPLE FOLL[$ \T 9 Y\R CASE W\LD HAVE SU/A9$ ME 9 ASK+ Y\ AS MU* = ! USE ( ! ?IRTE5 DOLL>S 7:I* IT CO/ ME NO SACRIFICE TO L5D7 AS Y\ C\LD BE 9DUC$ TO GIVE1 RA!R ?AN HAVE Y\R FAMILY TURN$ \T 9TO ! /REET1 & Y\R FURNITURE SACRIFIC$ BY ! CON/ABLE2 :I* MI<T HAVE BE5 AS MU* AS Y\ C\LD HAVE E>N$ 9 YE>S ( ANXIETY & LABOR6 ,?IS W\LD HAVE LEFT Y\ LITTLE TO *OOSE BETWE5 ABSOLUTE RU9 & BORR[+ ?IRTE5 DOLL>S1 -LITTLE TO *OOSE BETWE5 ! PRISON1 />VATION1 & ! USUR]4 ,NO WOND] ?AT M5 HAVE LOOK$ ON EA* O!R AS NATURAL 5EMIES1 SEE+ ?AT1 :E!R !Y TURN TO ONE OR ANO!R1 ! RESULT IS NE>LY ! SAME4 ,! L&LORD GETS ALL HE CAN FROM Y\R NECESSITIES4 ,IF Y\ TURN TO ! USUR] = RELIEF1 LIE DEV\RS Y\ ON ! SAME PR9CIPLE4 

#b#f#i4 0 ,IF Y\ TURN TO ! LAWY]S !Y DEV\R :AT IS LEFT ( Y\4 ,SOME ( !M WILL EV5 TELL Y\ ?AT ! GREAT LAW IS = ! BIG FI% TO EAT UP ! LITTLE ONES1 NEV] SUSPECT+ ANY?+ WRONG 9 !IR E?ICS TILL !Y HAPP5 TO BE ! LITTLE ONES 6 ,! FACT IS ?AT !Y KN[ NO?+1 ! WORLD KN[S NO?+ WOR? KN[+1 ON !SE SUBJECTS2 PR9CIPALLY = ! REASON ?AT !IR />T+--PO9TS HAVE BE5 WRONG1 CONSEQU5TLY1 ALL !IR CONCLUSIONS >E WRONG4 ,!Y HAVE />T$ ) SAY+ ?AT ! PRICE ( A ?+ %\LD BE :AT IT WILL BR+4 ,IT IS EQUIVAL5T TO SAY+ ?AT IT IS RI<T & JU/ TO DEM& A PRICE = A ?+ PROPORTION$ TO ! DI/RESS ( ! RECEIV] ( IT4 ,?IS IS ! ROOT ( ALL ! CANNIBALISM ( CIVILIZATION1 & M5 FALL TO EAT+ EA* O!R2 BUT1 AS NO ONE LILIES TO BE EAT51 !Y AGREE TO PROTECT EA* O!R AGA9/ ! OP]ATION ( !IR [N PR9CIPLES & DAILY PRACTICES1 & =M A COMB9ATION CALL$ A ,/ATE1 = ! PURPOSE2 -! MULTITUDE CANNOT CONDUCT ! BUS9ESS ( A ,/ATE1 BUT !Y SET AP>T A FEW TO SEE TO ! PROTECTION ( ALL1 & !Y PROTECT ALL AS WE PROTECT *ICK5S1 ?AT WE MAY EAT !M )\T ! TR\BLE ( CAT*+ !M4 

#b#g4 0,?IS IS ONLY ANO!R =M ( CANNIBALISM4 ,!RE HAS NEV] BE5 ANY CORRECT ?\<T ON ! SUBJECT1 & NEV] WILL BE TILL WE BEG9 RI<T4 ,! BEG9N+ ( CORRECT ?\<T = JU/ICE1 PEACE1 SECURITY1 & SUCCESSFUL SOCIETY IS1 ?AT ! PRICE ( :AT Y\ RECEIVE FROM ME %\LD BE LIMIT$1 NOT BY ITS VALUE TO Y\1 BUT BY ! TR\BLE OR SACRIFICE IT HAS CO/ ME4 ,:5 WE BEG9 TO ?9K FROM ?IS />T+- PO9T1 WE SEE ?AT ! ALL-P]VAD+ VICI\SNESS ( TRADE1 & DIRE CONFUSION & DI/RESS ?AT EV]Y:]E PREVAILS1 HAVE ORIG9AT$1 NOT 9 \R PRIM>Y NATURE1 AS HAS BE5 SO EXT5SIVELY ?\<T & TAU<T1 BUT 9 ?IS SUBTLE & UNDETECT$ ]ROR 9 ONE ( ! />T+-PO9TS ( \R 9T]C\RSE ) EA* O!R4 ,?AT ?IS BE+ CORRECT$1 ! CANNIBALISM CEASES2-! DEM& = 'PROTECTION CEASES ALONG ) IT1 & WE BEG9 TO EM]GE FROM D>KNESS & CONFUSION 9TO LI<T1 ORD]1 & REPOSE4' 0 

#b#g#a4 0,!SE ?\<TS1 ,SIR1 >E - >E - V]Y - REALLY1 ,SIR1 ,I DO NOT KN[ :AT - :AT TO SAY40 ,H]E ! G5TLEMAN BECAME TOO MU* AFFECT$ TO SPEAK DI/9CTLY1 BUT 9 A L[ & V]Y TREMUL\S TONE HE V]Y RESPECTFULLY TOOK HIS LEAVE4 

#b#g#b4 ,IS IT NOT PROBABLE ?AT G5TLEMAN HAS1 ?R\< LIFE1 COOP]AT$ :]EV] HE MAY HAVE BE51 ?\< NOT BELONG+ TO ANY =MAL ORGANIZATION OR CLAN1 9 ! SPREAD & /R5G!N+ ( ! PR9CIPLE ( ,EQUIVAL5TS1 SO F> AS HE UND]/OOD & FELT ITS PRACTICAL BE>+S8 

#b#g#c4 ,IT WILL PROBABLY BE ADMITT$ ?AT IF ! PR9CIPLE ITSELF WILL PROMPT & SECURE ALL ! DESIR$ COOP]ATION )\T CLAN%IP1 & NEUTRALIZE ALL ANTAGONISM ( 9T]E/S1 & GIVE TO ALL EX]TION ITS JU/ REW>D1 ! GREATE/ ( ALL HUMAN PROBLEMS IS SOLV$ BY IT4 

#b#g#d4 ,9,T,R,O,D,U,C,T,I,O,N ,( ,E,Q,U,I,T,A,B,L,E ,M,O,N,E,Y4 ,! KEEP] ( ! /ORE WAS TO RECEIVE ! LABOR ( HIS CU/OM]S 9 EX*ANGE = HIS [N4 ,!Y C\LD NOT PAY IRON WORK1 MASON WORK1 DOCTOR'S WORK1 WA%+1 SEW+1 ETC41 ON ! SPOT 9 ! /ORE1 &1 !RE=E1 = !SE K9DS ( LABOR !Y GAVE !IR NOTES1 PAYABLE ON DEM&1 :I* ! KEEP] ISSU$ \T AGA9 TO %OE4 MAK]S1 TAILORS1 WOODSAWY]S1 ETC41 & HE HAD AT ONE TIME1 ! NOTES ( FIVE DIFF]5T PHYSICIANS1 PROMIS+ A C]TA9 NUMB] ( H\RS ( !IR S]VICES TO ! HOLD]S ( ! NOTES1 & !SE NOTES PASS$ \T TO WA%]WOM51 SEAM/RESSES1 DRAYM51 WOODSAWY]S1 C>P5T]S1 MASONS1 ETC41 ANY ( :OM C\LD GO TO ! PHYSICIANS & GET !IR S]VICES = !SE NOTES1 :I* HAD CO/ !M ONLY EQUIVAL5TS 9 !IR [N LABOR2 & ?\< ! WA%]WOMAN PAID1 P]HAPS1 NOT MORE ?AN A HUNDR$? P>T AS MU* LABOR AS ! DOCTOR'S S]VICES HAD G5]ALLY CO/ H]1 YET ! PHYSICIANS W]E CONT5T & PLEAS$ ) ! OP]ATION4 ,SOME CU/OM]S C\LD BR+ >TICLES TO ! /ORE :I* W]E 9 DEM&1 ! LABOR 9 :I* HAD BE5 PREVI\SLY ASC]TA9$ & SETTL$1 BE=E ! >TICLES W]E BR\<T4 ,! KEEP] TOOK !SE1 & GAVE EI!R SOME O!R >TICLES :I* #aa CO/ 0 ! SAME AM\NT ( LABOR 7D$UCT+ ! TIME ( DELIV]Y71 OR HE GAVE NOTES ( O!R PR(ESSIONS1 OR HIS [N NOTES1 PAYABLE 9 M]*&IZ+2 & !SE NOTES = M]*&IZ+ W\LD CIRCALATE AMONG ALL ! CU/OM]S ( ! /ORE2 & AS NE>LY EV]YBODY )9 REA* WI%$ TO BE A CU/OM]1 !Y W]E READY TO TAKE ! NOTES = ANY?+ !Y HAD OR C\LD DO1 & ! KEEP] C\LD HAVE ISSU$ ANY AM\NT ( !M2 & H]E IS A DANG] TO BE GU>D$ AGA9/4 ,ALL IS MADE SAFE BY EA* ONE US+ SU* NOTES AS HE CANNOT MAKE HIMSELF1 & ! PR9T] OR MAK] ( !M KEEP+ AN ACC\NT ( ALL ! BLANKS ISSU$ TO EA* P]SON2 & ?IS AM\NT IS /AT$ ON ! NOTE ITSELF1 SO ?AT ! RECEIV] ( IT MAY KN[ :AT AM\NT ! SIGN] ( IT HAS ISSU$1-! NOTES ALL HAV+ ! PR9T]'S ADDRESS UPON !M4 ,IF ANY D\BT >ISES1 ! PUBLIC CAN RESORT TO ! PR9T]1 :O CAN TELL AT ONCE :AT QUANTITY ( BLANK NOTES HAVE BE5 ISSU$ TO ANY P]SON4 

#b#g#e4 ,SW>TW\T+ & ALL SIMIL> FRAUDS W\LD AT ONCE BE IMPOSSIBLE1 IF MONEY WAS SIMPLY :AT IS REQUIR$ ( IT1 NAMELY1 A CIRCULAT+ M$IUM4 ,AS SOON AS IT BECOMES CAPITAL TO LAY UP1 - IT BE+ 9 A CLOSE1 COMPACT1 PORTABLE =M1 - IT IS EASILY /OL5 & C>RI$ BEYOND RECOV]Y6 ,IT IS USELESS TO EXPECT IMPROVEM5T 9 ! MORALS ( PUBLIC FUNCTION>IES :ILE !Y POSSESS P[] & CAN BE TEMPT$ TO DEFRAUD ! PUBLIC ,SW>TW\T ONLY E/ABLI%$ A FA%ION :I* HAS RAG$ MORE & MORE EV] S9CE HIS TREA*]Y D[N TO ?IS PRES5T WRIT+4 ,TO MAKE SU* FRAUDS IMPOSSIBLE1 AS WELL AS TO SECURE MANY O!R GREAT 5DS1 :5 CAPITAL IS TO BE LAID BY1 IT %\LD CONSI/ ( SOME?+ AS NE>LY IMP]I%ABLE AS POSSIBLE2 SOME?+ 9TR9SICALLY VALUABLE1 :I* VALUE CAN NEV] BECOME NEUTRALIZ$1 NOR SUP]S$$4 ,IT %\LD BE SOME?+ ! S\RCE ( :I* CANNOT BE MONOPOLIZ$1 & :I*1 !RE=E1 CAN NEV] BE RAIS$ 9 PRICE BEYOND COMP5SATION = ! LABOR BE/[$ UPON IT2 & IF MADE ! BASIS ( A CIRCULAT+ M$IUM1 IT %\LD AT ALL TIMES BE )9 REA* ( ! PUBLIC EYE1 SUBJECT AT ALL TIMES TO PUBLIC 9SPECTION & E/IMATE1 )\T DANG] ( ITS BE+ /OL54 ,IRON IS A COMMODITY ANSW]+ ALL !SE DEM&S4 

#b#g#f4 ,?AT ! M]CANTILE WORLD - ! M5 ( 5T]PRISE1 ! F9ANCI]S & LEGISLATORS ( CONT9U\S AGES - %\LD SO LONG HAVE ADMITT$ ! CANNIBAL PR9CIPLE AS ! BASIS ( !IR OP]ATIONS1 IS A /RIK+ PRO( ( ! A/ONI%+ DOCILITY ) :I* ! HUMAN RACE RECEIVE TRADITIONS UNQUE/ION$1 & FOLL[ PREC$5TS & SELF-]ECT$ AU?ORITIES UNEXAM9$2 & IT EXPOSES A WEAKNESS ?AT L[]S \R RESPECT = EXI/+ CU/OMS1 & GIVES TO ! C>EFUL /UD5T ( HUMAN AFFAIRS A C\RAGE & /R5G? EQUAL TO ! DEM&S = !M3 BUT :AT A FIELD IT FURNI%ES = ! RECKLESS & UNSCRUPUL\S6 ,:AT CONFUSION ?IS READY CR$ULITY & CON=MITY BR+ UPON ALL6 

#b#g#g4 ,ONE NEWSPAP] SAYS ?AT SU* OR SU* AN AU?ORITY SAYS #aa ?AT M>TIAL LAW SUP]S$ES ALL O!R LAWS40 ,IF ?IS IS TRUE AT ALL1 IT IS TRUE 9 A S5SE NOT UND]/OOD BY READ]S 9 G5]AL4 ,IT IS TRUE ONLY 9 ! S5SE ?AT MILIT>Y =CE IS ! LA/ & F9AL APPEAL1 OR ! ABSOLUTE GOV]NM5T3 BUT ! M]E OP9IONS1 OR RULES1 OR /ATUTES ( M5 >E NOT LAWS AT ALL4 ,ALL ?AT W]E EV] CON/RUCT$ 9 ! WORLD1 & ALL ! MILIT>Y P[] 9 ! WORLD CONC5TRAT$ AGA9/ ONE 9DIVIDUAL1 C\LD NOT = A MOM5T OV]COME OR #aa SUP]S$E #aa ! LAW ( SELF- PRES]VATION 9 ?AT 9DIVIDUAL :ILE HE RETA9$ LIFE4 ,IT IS ?IS PRIMITIVE OR ,DIV9E LAW :I* RISES ABOVE & #aa SUP]S$ES ALL O!R LAWS40 

#b#g#h4 ,AGA91 A NEWSPAP] SAYS ! 0LAWS ,( NATIONS0 9 TIME ( W> MAKE ALL ! MEMB]S ( EA* NATION 5EMIES TO EA* O!R4 ,?IS IS NOT ONLY 9HUMAN BUT FALSE4 ,!RE >E P]SONS BELONG+ TO DIFF]5T NATIONS1 ?ANKS TO SIMPLE COMMON S5SE1 ?AT CAN NEV] BE MADE 5EMIES TO EA* O!R2 BUT1 TO REMA9 FRI5DS1 SAY ! NEWSPAP]S1 IS #aa TREASON40 ,?US ! NEWSPAP]S DE/ROY ALL RESPECT = !MSELVES FROM ANY :OSE RESPECT IS WOR? HAV+4 

#b#g#i4 ,ANO!R NEWSPAP] DELIV]S ITSELF ( ?IS SAGE APO!GM1 #aa ,! ONLY FRE$OM ( SPEE* WE WANT N[ IS ! SPEE* = FRE$OM40 ,I ASK :OSE SPEE* = FRE$OM IS IT ?AT IS WANT$ JU/ N[2 IS IT Y\RS OR M9E 8 ,ONE PAP] HAV+ SPOK51 O!RS ( ! SAME P>TY OR ,CLAN COPY2 ! CLAN REPEAT & JO9 9 ! *ORUS1 & CONFUSION FOLL[S2 & :]E CONFUSION AB\NDS ! IGNORANT >E NOISY1 ! PRUD5T >E SIL5T1 & IMPO/ORS TRIUMPH4  
,C,O,M,P,E,T,I,T,I,O,N4 

  

#b#h4 ,COMPETITION IS SO IMPORTANT AN ELEM5T 9 HUMAN AFFAIRS IT DES]VES P>TICUL> CONSID]ATION4 ,:ILE SOME ASS]T ?AT IT IS ! REGULATOR ( TRADE1 O!RS MAY ASK :]E OR :5 TRADE WAS EV] REGULAT$6 ,COMPETITION 9 TRADE1 MANUFACTURES1 & 9 EV]Y O!R PECUNI>Y DEP>TM5T1 GR9DS ! WEAK] P>TIES TO P[D]1 :ILE ?OSE :O CAN MOVE AT ALL >E 9 CON/ANT W>F>E & /RUGGLE ) EA* O!R1 9 :I* ! LONGE/ PURSES >E SURE TO PREVAIL2 ALL O!RS MU/ YIELD1 & :AT IS CALL$ SOCIETY1 PROMISES1 EV5 BY PECUNI>Y COMPETITION ALONE1 TO BECOME DIVID$ 9TO ONLY TWO CLASSES - CAPITALI/S & CRIM9ALS2 & ! CAPITALI/ ) ! LONGE/ PURSE ( #aa C[RIES #aa WILL BE MA/] ( ALL AT LA/1 ONLY TO BE RU9$ AT LA/4 

#b#h#a4 ,LET US SEE H[ ! PR9CIPLE ( ,EQUIVAL5TS AFFECTS COMPETITION4 

#b#h#b4 ,9 ONE ( ! EXP]IM5TAL /ORES1 9 #a#h#d#b1 A %OEMAK]1 BE+ PRESS$ = MONEY1 (F]$ A LOT ( %OES = SIX C5TS LESS P] PAIR ?AN !Y HAD USUALLY BE5 SOLD =4 ,BUT AS ! KEEP]'S COMP5SATION WAS 5TIRELY SEP>AT$ FROM ! PRICES ( ! GOODS1 & ! GOODS SOLD AT #aa CO/S10 HE C\LD NOT PUT ?IS EXTRA SIX C5TS 9TO HIS [N POCKET )\T VIOLAT+ ! V]Y PR9CIPLE UPON :I* HE PREF]R$ TO ACT1 &1 !RE=E1 HAD NO 9T]E/ 9 GETT+ ! %OES *EAP] ?AN USUAL1 AS LONG AS HIS CU/OM]S W]E SATISFI$ ) ! PRICES4 ,HE !RE=E RE PAID ! FULL USUAL PRICE TO ! %OEMAK]1 :O1 9 ?IS CASE1 GOT ?REE DOLL>S MORE ?AN HE EXPECT$1 AT ! V]Y TIME ?AT HE NE$$ MONEY MO/4 ,!RE WAS NO CONTE/ OR COMPETITION BETWE5 BUY] & SELL] H]E TO R$UCE ! PRICE BEL[ :AT ! CU/OM]S W]E WILL+ TO PAY4 ,& AGA91 HAD ! %OES BE5 ( POOR QUALITY1 SU* AS TO *EAT & DISAPPO9T ! CU/OM]S1 !RE WAS NO TEMPTATION TO PUR*ASE !M AT ANY PRICE1 = LET ! PRICE BE :ATEV] IT MI<T1 !Y W]E TO BE SOLD AT CO/4 ,COMPETITION C\LD NOT ACT TO R$UCE ! PRICE ( ! %OES1 & GR9D D[N ?IS %OEMAK] OR HIS COMPETITORS1 NOR TEMPT ! KEEP] BY L>GE PR(ITS TO *EAT ! CU/OM]S ) A WOR?LESS >TICLE4 

#b#h#c4 ,A MAN CAME 9TO ! /ORE 9 GREAT DI/RESS1 SAY+ ?AT HE ,I-LAD A HOG%EAD ( EXCELL5T SUG> :I* WAS 9 DANG] ( BE+ SACRIFIC$ TO PAY ! EXP5SES ( ITS /ORAGE1 & IF ! KEEP] W\LD TAKE IT1 HE %\LD HAVE IT AT A C5T LESS P] P\ND ?AN ! L[E/ PRICE ?AT HAD BE5 KN[N ?AT SEASON4 ,! KEEP] HAV+ A FULL SUPPLY ( SUG> ON H& DECL9$ TAK+ IT2 BUT ! [N] URG$ IT SO E>NE/LY1 HE CONS5T$ TO LOOK AT IT1 & F\ND IT TO BE ( UNUSUALLY GOOD QUALITY & CONCLUD$ TO TAKE IT2 BUT HE TOLD ! [N] ?AT AS HE HAD NO 9T]E/1 EXCEPT AS ONE ( ! CONSUM]S1 9 TAK+ ADVANTAGE ( HIS NECESSITIES1 HE %\LD GIVE HIM ! FULL PRICE = ! SUG>2 & HE PAID HIM ELEV5 DOLL>S MORE ?AN HE EXPECT$ TO GET = HIS HOG%EAD ( SUG>2 & YET ! PRICE WAS SO L[ :5 SOLD AT CO/S1 ?AT ! CU/OM]S W]E P]FECTLY WILL+ TO PAY IT4 

#b#h#d4 ,! LITTLE 9T]E/ ! KEEP] HAD AS CONSUM] ( ! SUG> WAS JU/ 5\< TO PREV5T HIM FROM BE+ 5TIRELY 9DIFF]5T TO ! PRICE1 BUT IT WAS NOT 5\< TO 9DUCE HIM TO TAKE ADVANTAGE ( ! NECESSITIES ( ! EMB>RASS$ [N]4 ,AT ! SAME TIME1 IF HE HAD GIV5 MU* MORE ?AN ! USUAL PRICE = ! SUG>1 HE C\LD NOT HAVE SOLD IT 9 COMPETITION ) ! O!R SUG> ?AT HE HAD ON H&4 ,COMPETITION H]E TOOK ! SUG> AWAY FROM ! ONE :O WAS LAY+ HIS PLAN TO HAVE IT SACRIFIC$ TO HIM AT AUCTION1 & GAVE TO ITS [N] ! USUAL PRICE4 

#b#h#e4 ,A PIECE ( L& WAS LAID \T1 9 #a#h#d#g1 9TO H\SE LOTS = A VILLAGE1 UND] CONTRACT ) ! [N] ( ! L& ?AT HE W\LD HOLD ! LOTS AT A FIX$ PRICE 7NAM$ 9 ! BOND7 = ?REE YE>S4 ,HE FULFILL$ HIS CONTRACT1 BUT AT ! EXPIRATION ( ! TIME1 HE BEGAN TO RAISE ! PRICES ( ! LOTS ACCORD+ TO !IR 9CREAS$ VALUE4 ,ONE MAN /EPP$ 9 & PUR*AS$ A HALF ( ALL ! UNSOLD LOTS1 & GAVE A BOND TO ! 9HABITANTS ?AT ! LOTS %\LD BE HELD AT ! PRICE HE HAD PAID = !M 7IT BE+ M5TION$ 9 ! BOND7 )\T 9T]E/1 & ) NO ADDITION TO ! PRICE NAM$1 EXCEPT TAXES & O!R CONTR+5T CO/S ( DE$S1 ETC4 ,?IS IMM$IATELY *ECK$ ! RISE 9 ! PRICES ( ! O!R LOTS1 = IT WAS IMPOSSIBLE = ! [N] TO SELL !M AT ANY HI<] RATES ?AN ?OSE SOLD = CO/S4 ,N[ COMPETITION BEGAN TO #aa REGULATE TRADE10 SOME ( !SE LOTS HAVE REMA9$ = SALE T5 YE>S AT CO/S2 & ?\< A RAILROAD HAS BE5 SURVEY$ DIRECTLY ?R\< !M1 ?IS HAS MADE NO DIFF]5CE 9 !IR PRICES4 

#b#h#f4 ,?US 0EQUITABLE0 COMPETITION BECOMES A *ECK TO L& SPECULATION1 :I* NO /ATUTES OR DEVICES ( LEGISLATORS HAVE EV] BE5 ABLE TO REA*1 :]E *ECK IS MO/ NE$$ 79 H\SE LOTS71 & ?US1 TOO1 ?IS COMPETITION MAY & W\LD NECESS>ILY BECOME A REGULATOR 9 EV]Y DEP>TM5T ( BUS9ESS1 :ILE IT W\LD OPPRESS NO ONE4 

#b#h#g4 ,AS LONG AS ! V5DOR ( GOODS1 OR L&1 OR ANY?+ ELSE1 HAS HIS COMP5SATION MIX$ UP & COMB9$ ) !IR PRICES1 )\T ANY FIX$ LIMIT TO HIS 9COME1 HE IS 9T]E/$ 9 GETT+ ! GOODS OR >TICLES AT ! L[E/ RATES1 & SELL+ !M AT ! HI<E/ RATES1 BECAUSE ALL ?AT IS GA9 OV] CO/S GOES 9TO HIS [N POCKET4 ,! MANUFACTUR] OR PRODUC] MU/ !N UND]WORK HIS COMPETITOR 9 ORD] TO GET ! CU/OM ( ! V5DOR3 !N COMES HIS [N DANG]S1 ANXIETIES1 & RISKS1 & ! GR9D+ D[N ( WAGES TO ! L[E/ LIV+ PO9T4 

#b#h#h4 ,LET ! PRODUCTS ( MA*9]Y & ( ! L& BE SOLD = EQUIVAL5TS1 & ALL ?IS BECOMES *ANG$4 ,COMPETITION IS DIVE/$ ( ITS DE/RUCTIVE P[]1 YET !RE IS /ILL 9T]E/ 5\< FELT AMONG ALL 7& ?AT 9T]E/ COOP]ATES7 TO GET MODES ( PRODUCTION SUFFICI5TLY LABOR-SAV+ TO AF=D ALL ! LEISURE OR EXEMPTION FROM DRUDG]Y ?AT CAN BE DESIR$4 

#b#h#i4 ,IS IT ASK$ :AT CAN 9DUCE CAPITALI/S TO 9VE/ !IR CAPITAL 9 MA*9]Y1 )\T ANY PROSPECT ( GA9 OV] & ABOVE PAY = !IR OV]SI<T OR C>ES1 :I* MI<T NOT AM\NT TO MORE ?AN EA* ( ! HUMBLE/ WORKM5 RECEIV$8 

#b#i4 ,?IS QUE/ION TAKES = GRANT$ ?AT ! CAPITALI/ HAS NO CAPACITY TO SEE ANY VALUE 9 ALL ?AT HAS BE5 SAID 9 ?IS WORK1 :I* IS A POOR COMPLIM5T TO HIM OR TO ! AU?OR4 ,H[EV]1 ?IS IS A QUE/ION ?AT EV]Y P]SON HAS A SOV]EIGN RI<T TO DECIDE = HIMSELF 2 BUT IT IS V]Y QUE/IONABLE :E!R MANY CAPITALI/S1 5GAG$ 9 ANY USEFUL BUS9ESS1 >E 9 ! /EADY RECEIPT ( MORE ?AN FROM F\R TO EI<T DOLL>S P] DAY2 & ON ! PR9CIPLE ( EQUIVAL5TS1 ! COMP5SATION TO WORKM5 W\LD PROBABLY BE EQUIVAL5T 9 VALUE TO A SUM BETWE5 !SE TWO1 DEP5D+ ON ! REPUGNANCE ( ! LABOR P]=M$2 & :AT HE GOT W\LD BE SECURE FROM !FT1 FRAUD1 & DE/RUCTION BY W>S & RU9\S TAXATION4 ,IT IS WELL1 TOO1 TO CONSID]1 9 ! MEAN TIME1 :AT MOTIVE ANY MAN CAN HAVE TO KEEP UP ! PRES5T B>B>ISM :5 ! MEANS ( CIVILIZATION COME TO BE UND]/OOD4 ,EQUITABLE COMPETITION HAS P[] TO REGULATE ALL UNMI/AKABLY1 & ! M]E CAPITALI/ WILL BE ! WEAKE/ & MO/ DEP5D5T ( M5 AS SOON AS TRUE1 SCI5TIFIC1 EQUITABLE MONEY GETS 9TO VOGUE4 ,!N ! H>DE/ WORK] WILL BECOME ! GREATE/ REAL CAPITALI/1 & ANY QUANTITY ( 0C[RIES0 OR M]E BITS ( COMP>ATIVELY USELESS METAL1 WILL GIVE NO ASSURANCE = BREAD = ANY L5G? ( TIME4 

#b#i#a4 ,BESIDES ALL CAPITALI/S HAVE NOT LO/ ALL !IR MANHOOD 9 GETT+ !IR #aa C[RIES40 ,ONE ( ! RI*E/ M5 9 ,C9C9NATI1 9 A CONV]SATION RELATIVE TO ! EXP]IM5TAL /ORE !N 9 OP]ATION ON ! CORN] ( ,FIF? & ,ELM ,/REETS1 SAID1 #aa ,IF SU* A /ATE ( SOCIETY C\LD BE PRODUC$1 ,I %\LD WANT TO BE ONE ( ! FIR/ 9 IT40 

#b#i#b4 ,! /ORE HAD NOT BE5 9 OP]ATION A MON? :5 A :OLESALE M]*ANT1 :O WAS QUITE FAMILI> ) IT1 SAID TO A FRI5D1 #fa ,Y\ & #a1 ,MR4 ,C---1 MAY NOT LIVE TO SEE IT2 BUT ! TIME WILL COME :5 ALL ! BUS9ESS 9 ! WORLD WILL BE CONDUCT$ ON ?AT PR9CIPLE40 

#b#i#c4 ,ANO!R :OLESALE M]*ANT ( ! SAME PLACE SAID1 #aa ,!Y >E ! TRUE & ! ONLY TRUE PR9CIPLES = ! REGULATION ( BUS9ESS4 ,! SOON] !Y PREVAIL ! BETT]4 ,I DESPISE MYSELF = ! MANN] 9 :I* ,I AM OBLIG$ TO GET MY LIV+ \T ( MY CU/OM]S40 

#b#i#d4 ,ANO!R M]*ANT ( ! SAME CITY SAID TO ! KEEP]1 #aaa CAN F9D NO FAULT ) ! PR9CIPLE4 ,I WAS TELL+ ,MR4 ,C----4 ! O!R DAY1 ?AT IT WAS NOT TO BE SUCCESSFULLY DISPUT$40 

#b#i#e4 ,ANO!R M]*ANT SAID1 9 ! PRES5CE ( F\R CU/OM]S1 0,!RE IS NO DISPUT+ ?AT ?AT IS ! TRUE PR9CIPLE = ! BASIS ( ALL BUS9ESS4 ,I CANNOT WORK ON IT AS ,I AM SITUAT$4 ,I WI% ,I C\LD40 

#b#i#f4 ,AS ,I HAVE BE=E /AT$1 A G5TLEMAN 9 A L>GE RETAIL & :OLESALE BUS9ESS 9 ,9DIANA1 SAID1 9 #a#h#d#b1 ) GREAT E>NE/NESS & MANLY FEEL+1 #aa ,IF SU* PR9CIPLES AS ?OSE C\LD BE 9TRODUC$1 ,I W\LD GIVE N9ETYN9E DOLL>S \T ( EV]Y HUNDR$ ,I POSSESS40 ,YET1 AT ! V]Y TIME ( MAK+ ?IS REM>K1 ! EQUITABLE /ORE 9 ,NEW ,H>MONY1 TW5TY-FIVE MILES DI/ANT1 HAD JU/ BROK5 UP HIS RETAIL TRADE1 & HE ACKN[L$G$ ?AT HE C\LD DO NO?+ 9 ?AT L9E6 ,HIS P>TICUL> PECUNI>Y 9T]E/S DID NOT BL9D HIM TO GREAT] G5]AL 9T]E/S4 

#b#i#g4 ,IT IS (T5 ASK$ :Y !SE /ORES W]E DISCONT9U$4 

#b#i#h4 ,!Y W]E />T$ ONLY ) ! VIEW ( BR++ PR9CIPLES TO TE/1 TRIAL1 & CRITICISM1 & TO SET !M4 BE=E ! PUBLIC 9 A PRACTICAL1 DEMON/RAT$ ATTITUDE1 PREVI\SLY TO =M+ MODEL VILLAGES2 & TO GET COOP]ATORS = ?AT PURPOSE1 ) ! IDEA ?AT ONE SUCCESSFUL MODEL VILLAGE W\LD DO ! WORK- REQUIR$ MORE EXP$ITI\SLY ?AN ANY O!R /EP ?AT C\LD AT ?AT TIME BE TAK52 :]EAS M]E /OREKEEP+ WAS BUT A SMALL ITEM1 A ,S+LE :EEL 9 ! VA/ MA*9]Y ( SOCIETY2 &1 MOREOV]1 !SE /ORES V]Y SOON BR+ ALL SURR\ND+ PRICES D[N TO !IR [N LEVEL1 :5 !RE IS NO?+ LEFT = !M TO WORK UPON6 

#b#i#i4 ,! ONE />T$ 9 ,NEW ,H>MONY 9 ,M>*1 #a#h#d#b1 ) ONLY TWO HUNDR$ DOLL>S CA% CAPITAL1 9 ! C\RSE ( ! FIR/ YE>1 BY ITS IRRESI/IBLE COMPETILION BROKE UP FIVE \T ( ! T5 /ORES ?AT W]E 9 OP]ATION 9 ?AT T[N AT ITS COMM5CEM5T1 & BR\<T D[N ! PRICES AT ! REMA9+ /ORES TO ITS [N LEVEL1 AL?\< SOME ( !M C\LD COMM& UNLIMIT$ CAPITAL4 ,BUT1 HAV+ DONE ?IS1 & BR\<T ! O!R /ORES 9 ! NEI<BOR+ C\NTRY TO ! LEVEL ( EQUIVAL5TS1 ! EQUITABLE /ORE1 LIKE ! #aa GOV]NOR #aa ( A /EAM-5G9E 7NOT ( #af /ATE 071 CEAS$ TO OP]ATE :]E !RE WAS NO?+ TO RECTIFY2 & ! NEXT PURPOSE WAS TO =M A MODEL VILLAGE1 TAK+ IT = GRANT$ ?AT PR9CIPLES SO V]Y SIMPLE1 SO UNASSAILABLE1 SO CAPABLE ( SCI5TIFIC DEMON/RATION1 & SO 9DISP5SABLY NECESS>Y TO ORD]1 PEACE1 ABUNDANCE1 & #aa SECURITY10 ONLY NE$$ TO BE SE5 9 !IR BEAUTIFUL & CONSI/5T SYMMETRY TO BE AT ONCE APPROV$ & ADOPT$4 ,BUT ?AT MODEL VILLAGE HAS NEV] BE5 P]MITT$4 ,! MO/ SUBTLE & 7TO G5]AL OBS]VATION17 ! MO/ 9COMPREH5SIBLE OB/ACLES HAVE BE5 PLAC$ DIRECTLY & 9DIRECTLY ACROSS ITS PA?4 ,IT IS PROBABLY SE51 BY ?OSE :O CAN SEE NO?+- ELSE1 ?AT SU* A MODEL VILLAGE W\LD  

 0,LIKE A :IRLW9D1 SCATT] 9 ITS BREEZE  

 ,! :OLE D>K PILE ( HUMAN MOCK]I]S0  

 & !Y ?9K ?IS W\LD NOT BR+ !M #aa C[RIES NOR (FICES4 ,MISAPPREH5SION1 MISREPRES5TATION1 DIRECT FALSEHOODS1 9S9UATIONS1 SL&]S1 & CUNN+LY CONTRIV$ DEVICES TO SET ! PUBLIC AGA9/ ! DEVELOPM5T( SU* A MODEL1 HAVE RESULT$ 9 A *ANGE ( MODE1 & ! ADOPTION ( ONE :I*1 ?\< DEM&+ GREAT] RES\RCES1 IS MORE 9 ACCORDANCE ) ! UNIV]SALITY ( ! OBJECTS 9 VIEW & ! PR9CIPLES TO BE 9TRODUC$4 

#c4 ,?IS MODE IS SUGGE/$ 9 ! FIR/ *APT] 7ON GOV]NM5T71 NAMELY1 9 EV]Y CITY1 T[N1 VILLAGE1 & NEI<BORHOOD1 TO 9VITE ?OSE SUPPOS$ TO BE MO/ COMPET5T TO UNBIASS$ & CORRECT 9VE/IGATION TO ASSEMBLE AS C\NCILS1 OR C\RTS ( 9QUIRY1 OR DELIB]ATIVE TRIBUNALS1 TO 9VE/IGATE !SE SUBJECTS 9 ! PRES5CE ( ALL ! 9HABITANTS :O *OOSE TO ATT5D AS LI/5]S1 & TO CONT9UE !SE 9VE/IGATIONS TILL A G5]AL1 CLE> UND]/&+ IS HAD ( ! MO/ IMPORTANT 9T]E/S ( LIFE4 ,AN 9TELLIG5T & CORRECT PUBLIC OP9ION WILL !N BECOME1 AS IT W]E1 A GREAT BALANCE-:EEL1 TO REGULATE PROGRESS1 & TO NURSE & PROTECT TRUE CIVILIZATION 9 ITS 9FANTILE /RUGGLES = EXI/5CE4 

#c#a4 ,\R FRI<TFUL W> IS N[ EXT5SIVELY ?\<T TO HAVE BE5 FIR/ /IMULAT$ & SET GO+ BY TRAD]S :O W]E AFRAID ( A FREE PORT BE+ OP5$ AT ! ,S\? :ILE ,NOR!RN PORTS W\LD BE HAMP]$ ) T>IFFS1 & BY (FICE-SEEK]S & BY SPECULATORS LOOK+ =W>D TO ! ADVANTAGES TO BE TAK5 ( ! NECESSITIES ?AT W\LD >ISE FROM W>4 

#c#b4 ,FROM ! HI/ORY ( ! PROGRESS ( #aa ROA/ PIG10 MAY WE NOT HOPE ?AT1 9 ! C\RSE ( A ?\S& YE>S OR MORE1 ! EXAMPLE ( ,L\IS ,NAPOLEON ( ,FRANCE WILL HAVE SO F> PROGRESS$ AS TO 9DUCE ! 0PIONE] GOV]NM5TS 0( CIVILIZATION TO EMPLOY AG5TS1 AT A FIX$ & LIMIT$ SAL>Y1 TO DO !IR L>GE PUR*AS+ & =W>D+1 9/EAD ( EMPLOY+ M5 :OSE GA9S 9CREASE 9 PROPORTION TO ! NECESSITIES ( ! GOV]NM5TS1 & ! EXTRAVAGANCE ( ! PRICES :I* !Y1 AS AG5TS1 PAY = %IPS1 ETC4 

#c#c4 ,& ! NEWSPAP]S6 ,ONE NEWSPAP] WILL MAKE 0 TWO HUNDR$ DOLL>S EXTRA 9 ONE DAY BY ! ANN\NCEM5T ( 0,T,W,5,T,Y ,?,\,S,& ,M,5 ,K,I,L,L,$ ,& ,W,\,N,D,$60 ,:ILE ! $ITOR%IP ( NEWSPAP]S IS ! DIRECT ROAD TO (FICE1 & :ILE ! 0C[RY 0 & (FICE >E ! ALL-ABSORB+ OBJECTS ( PURSUIT1 :O WILL EXPECT COMMON NEWSPAP]S TO ADVOCATE ANY PR9CIPLE T5D+ TO PUT AN 5D TO W>S8 ,:O WILL EXPECT !M TO CEASE 9FLAM+ P>TY AGA9/ P>TY & NATION AGA9/ NATION 2 OR TO PAY ANY ATT5TION TO ! RESPONSIBILITY ( PUBLIC C\NSELORS8 

#c#d4 ,ONE S+LE NEWSPAP]1 :OSE CONDUCTOR %\LD TAKE A POSITION BE=E ! PUBLIC1 GIV+ EVID5CE ?AT HIS 9COME WAS LIMIT$ TO A C]TA9 SUM P] WEEK1 EV5 IF ?IS LIMIT WAS NOT QUITE D[N TO ! LEVEL ( ,EQUIVAL5TS1 -?AT PAP] 7AT LEA/ ITS ADV]TISEM5TS7 W\LD COMM& ! CONFID5CE ( ! PUBLIC1 & C\LD1 !RE=E1 HAVE ALL ! ADV]TIS+ PATRONAGE SO F> AS IT C\LD SUPPLY ! DEM&1 &1 AS ALL ! UNPR9CIPL$ PAP]S >E SU/A9$ *IEFLY BY !IR ADV]TISEM5TS1 ! HO/ ( !SE CORRUPT DI/URB]S ( ! PUBLIC PEACE W\LD S9K AS RAPIDLY 9TO OBLIVION AS DID ! SW9E ( OLD 9TO ! SEA1 & ITS $ITOR W\LD F9D HIMSELF 9/ALL$ 9 AN (FICE ( MORAL P[] & GR&EUR FROM :I* NO VULG> TEMPTATIONS C\LD S$UCE HIM4 ,SU* IS ! IRRESI/IBLE REGULAT+ P[] ( ,EQUITABLE COMPETITION4 ,AS A FIR/ /EP T[>DS ,EQUIVAL5TS1 ?IS SIMPLE ONE ( SETT+ A PUBLIC LIMIT TO COMP5SATION WILL BE AN IMM5SE REGULAT+ P[]2 & IT IS1 P]HAPS1 AS GREAT A /EP AS CAN BE IMM$IATELY TAK5 9 ! CONFUSION ( CITIES4 ,PROVISION DEAL]S1 COAL DEAL]S1 CLO?+ /ORES1 FURNITURE /ORES1 DRY GOODS & FANCY /ORES1 LAWY]S1 MANUFACTUR]S1 PAT5TEES1 BANK]S1 & SPECULATORS ( ALL K9DS1 SET NO KN[N LIMIT TO !IR DEM&S UPON ! PUBLIC1 & H5CE ! BL9D W>F>E EV]Y:]E C>RI$ ON BETWE5 !M4 ,LET EV]Y PR(ESSION HAVE SOME KN[N LIMIT SET TO ITS DEM&S UPON ! PUBLIC1 SO ?AT COMPETITION CAN ACT UND]/&+LY1 & ALL W\LD SOON COME TO ! PEACEFUL LEVEL ( ,EQUIVAL5TS1 EV5 ?\< ! PR9CIPLE ( ,EQUIVAL5TS MI<T NOT BE UND]/OOD4 

#c#e4 ,IT IS (T5 ASK$1 #aa ,:AT WILL 9DUCE ! LAWY]1 ! PHYSICIAN1 ! >TI/1 ! 9V5TOR1 ! SKILLFUL ME*ANIC TO EX*ANGE EQUALLY ) ! WOODSAWY]1 ! NE$LEWOMAN1 ! POOR BOY OR GIRL1 ! WA%]WOMAN80 ETC4 ,! QUE/ION IMPLIES ?AT !SE PR(ESSIONS CAN BE MOV$ BY NO?+ BUT M]C5>Y CONSID]ATIONS1 & ?AT !Y W\LD NECESS>ILY HAVE LESS 9COMES ?AN !Y N[ HAVE4 ,IT IS PROBABLE ?AT ! PR9CIPLE ( ,EQUIVAL5TS W\LD RESULT 9 GREAT] 9COMES TO !SE PR(ESSIONS ?AN !Y N[ RECEIVE4 ,!Y MAY NOT COME D[N 9 !IR PRICES2 IT IS ! DEPRESS$ ?AT W\LD COME UP TO P]HAPS :AT W\LD BE EQUIVAL5T TO FROM ?REE OR F\R TO EI<T OR T5 DOLL>S A DAY1 DEP5D+ ON ! REPUGNANCE ( !IR LABORS4 ,!SE PRICES >E PROBABLY MORE ?AN !SE PR(ESSIONS /EADILY RECEIVE4 ,IF !Y SEE NO TEMPTATION TO EX*ANGE ,EQUITABLY1 NEI!R FROM !IR DIRECT PECUNI>Y 9T]E/S NOR FROM ! BEAUTIFUL & SUBLIME T5D5CIES ( SU* JU/ICE1 !N ,E,Q,U,I,T,A,B,L,E ,C,O,M,P,E,T,I,T,I,O,N WILL DO ALL ?AT IS NE$$4 

#c#f4 ,IF ONLY ONE LAWY] IS WILL+ TO EX*ANGE ,EQUITABLY 7& SEV]AL HAVE ALREADY DONE IT71 HE PUTS IT \T ( ! P[] ( O!RS TO GET MORE ?AN EQUIVAL5TS1 PROVID$ ?AT HE CAN SUPPLY ALL ! DEM&S = ?AT K9D ( LABOR 2 BUT IF NOT1 HE CAN COMM5CE TO 9/RUCT O!RS :O >E SUFF]+ = EMPLOYM5T4 ,PHYSICIANS1 >TI/S1 ME*ANICS1 ONE ( EA*1 ACT+ ON ! SAME PR9CIPLE1 DO+ ! SAME1 ?OSE :O HAD ' NEV] DREAM$ ( ANY?+ BUT A LIFE ( DRUDG]Y & ABUSE WILL F9D !MSELVES BECOM+ LAWY]S1 PHYSICIANS1 M]*ANTS1 BANK]S1 %OEMAK]S1 TAILORS1 5G9E]S1 [N]S ( HOMES1 & RESPONSIBLE & COM=TABLE CITIZ5S -EA* VILLAGE OR NEI<BORHOOD :]E ! IDEAS >E ACT$ ON1 GR[+BY ALMO/ IMP]CEPTIBLE DEGREES 9TO A ,P,O,L,Y,T,E,*,N,I,C ,U,N,I,V,],S,I,T,Y = ! $UCATION1 OR RE$UCATION1 ( ALL :O DESIRE TO PREP>E !MSELVES = LIFE1 OR TO *ANGE !IR PURSUITS4 

#c#g4 ,ONE S+LE 9DIVIDUAL MAY HAVE A BUILD+ -A POLYTE*NIC COLLEGE - ) DIFF]5T ROOMS1 & TOOLS 9 EA* = DIFF]5T >TS1 TRADES1 OR /UDIES1 :]E ANY ONE1 Y\NG OR OLD1 CAN COME & LE>N ANY BRAN* ( BUSI,HESS1 PAY+ = R5T1 USE ( TOOLS1 & 9/RUCTION1 BY ! H\R1 ON ! PR9CIPLE ( ,EQUIVAL5TS1 :I* ! POORE/ CAN (T5 EASILY PAY 9 !IR [N LABOR4 ,DOES ?IS LOOK REMOTE & IMPROBABLE8 ,IT IS1 AS ALREADY BE+ DONE4 

#c#h4 ,C,O,M,P,E,T,I,T,I,O,N1 !N1 9/EAD ( BE+ ! FI]CE & T]RIBLE OGRE- ! ,JUGG]NAUT ( ,CIVILIZATION1 CRU%+ ITS VICTIMS ( ALL AGES & PR(ESSIONS & ( BO? SEXES AT EV]Y TURN ( ITS BLOODY :EELS1 IT COMES TO A HALT ON ! GR\ND ( ,EQUIVAL5TS1 & BECOMES CONV]T$ 9TO A V]Y COM=TABLE C>RIAGE = ! CONVEYANCE ( PASS5G]S TO ! ,HOLY ,L&6 I4E41 ! L& NOT CURS$ ) UNSCRUPUL\S SPECULATION4 

O ,*APT] #e 3 ,ORGANIZATION & ,COOP]ATION 
,*,A,P,T,] ,V4 

  
,O,R,G,A,N,I,Z,A,T,I,O,N ,& ,C,O,O,P,],A,T,I,O,N ,),\,T ,S,E,C,T,I,S,M ,O,R ,C,L,A,N,%,I,P1 ,& ,),\,T ,C,O,N,F,L,I,C,T ,) ,F,R,E,$,O,M4 

  

#c#i4 ,O,R,G,A,N,I,Z,A,T,I,O,N & ,CLAN%IP >E BO? PROMPT$1 9 SOME RESPECTS1 BY SIMIL> MOTIVES - ! UNIV]SAL DESIRE = SYMPA?Y1 ! NE$ ( MUTUAL ASSI/ANCE1 & O!R EXPECT$ B5EFITS4 ,BUT :ILE CLAN%IP1 ) ITS USUAL CONCOMITANTS1 IS MORE DE/RUCTIVE TO ! V]Y 5DS PROPOS$ ?AN ANY EXT]NAL 5EMY C\LD PROVE1 ORGANIZATION )\T !SE CONCOMITANTS1 & 9 ACCORDANCE ) ! GREAT PRIMITIVE LAWS1 MAY 5ABLE US TO REALIZE MORE ?AN ,UTOPIANS EV] DREAM$ (4 

#c#a4 ,( ,S,Y,M,P,A,?,Y4 ,SU* IS ! 9/9CTIVE YE>N+ = SYMPA?Y ) \R K9D1 !RE IS NO CO/ TOO GREAT TO PAY = IT4 

#c#a#a4 ,IT IS SO PLEASANT TO CO9CIDE ) ?OSE >\ND US1 & WE >E SO WRET*$ :5 9 CONT9U\S COLLISION ) ! FEEL+S1 TA/ES1 OR OP9IONS ( O!RS1 IT IS NOT SURPRIS+ ?AT WE (T5 FALL 9 ) CU/OMS & FA%IONS )\T EXAM9ATION1 & GO ) :ATEV] CURR5T IS RUNN+ RA!R ?AN >RAY \RSELVES HOPELESSLY AGA9/ !M4 

#c#a#b4 ,A POOR Y\NG WOMAN /OLE A FA%IONABLE BONNET1 = ! SAKE ( APPE>+ AT *UR* 9 ! MODE4 ,%E WAS >RE/$ & S5T TO PRISON1 & H] SELF-RESPECT DE/ROY$ = LIFE1 BECAUSE H] DESIRE = ! SYMPA?Y ( H] K9D WAS /RONG] OR MORE DIRECTLY PRES5T TO H] ?AN ! FE> ( ! PRISON6 ,DOES NOT ?IS 9/9CTIVE PROP5SITY ALSO EXPLA9 ?AT :I* O!RWISE REMA9S )\T EXPLANATION8 ,! WORD 0,GLORY10 :AT DOES IT MEAN BUT ! PUBLIC SYMPA?Y OR NOTICE ?AT ONE GETS BY A PUBLIC ACT 8 ,! 9C5DI>Y :O SET ON FIRE ! ,TEMPLE ( ,EPHESUS1 9 ORD]1 AS HE SAID110 TO IMMORTALIZE HIMSELF10 WAS CONT5T$ TO GET EV5 ?AT DEGREE ( 0,GLORY 0 :I* FOLL[$ FROM GIV+ ! PUBLIC AN 0 EV5T0 TO TALK AB\T4 ,HIS NAME WAS NECESS>ILY 9 MANY M\?S1 & ?AT WAS 5\< TO TEMPT HIM TO ! CRIME1 AS HE C\LD GET 0GLORY0 9 NO O!R WAY4 

#c#a#c4 ,! DEVOTEES ( ,9DIA1 :O WILL HOLD ONE H& /RAI<T UP ABOVE !IR HEADS1 & NEV] *ANGE ITS POSITION DUR+ LIFE1 OR FOLD BO? ACROSS !IR BREA/S1 & KEEP !M SO = YE>S2 OR ,SIMON ,/YLITES :O REMA9$ ON ! TOP ( A HI< NAK$ COLUMN = ?IRTY YE>S1 DAY & NI<T1 EXPOS$ TO ALL WEA!RS2 & ! DEVOTEES :O VOLUNT>ILY SUSP5D !MSELVES ON HOOKS /UCK ?R\< ! FLE% ( !IR SIDES1 & ALL[ !M4 SELVES TO BE SUSP5D$ HI< 9 ! AIR & SWUNG >\ND = H\RS1 EXPOS$ TO PUBLIC GAZE1 ALL1 PROBABLY1 >E OR W]E ACTUAT$ BY SIMIL> MOTIVES TO ! ONE UND] CONTEMPLATION4 

#c#a#d4 ,P]HAPS ?IS EXPLA9S ! SUBTLE FASC9ATION !RE IS 9 ! NEWS ( CALAMITIES - ! DE/RUCTION ( LIFE & PROP]TY4 ,!Y MAKE EV]YBODY TALK ) EA* O!R2 !Y F9D !MSELVES1 = ! MOM5T1 ON ! SAME PLANE - ! />V$ SYMPA?IES >E F$4 

#c#a#e4 ,! UNCULTIVAT$ GIRL1 9 ,BULW]'S 0 ,LA/ ,DAYS ( ,POMPEII10 IS MADE TO SAY1 0 ,OH1 PRAY ! GODS S5D US A CRIM9AL = ! LIONS TO TE>1 OR ! HOLIDAYS WILL BE GOOD = NO?+40 

#c#a#f4 ,EV5 HO/ILITY & P]SECUTION = UNAVOIDABLE DIFF]5CES ( OP9ION PROBABLY >ISE FROM ?IS SAME DESIRE = 0,UNITY10 0,H>MONY'0 OR ,SYMPA?Y4 ,?IS MAY EXPLA9 ! 9VOLUNT>Y REPUGNANCE TO EV5 NE$$ 9NOVATIONS OR IMPROVEM5TS2 -! T>D9ESS 9 ADOPT+ !M1 & EV5 ! P]SECUTION ( !M2 ! SPIRIT IS1 P]HAPS1 ! SAME - ! DESIRE = G5]AL SYMPA?Y1 COMMONLY CALL$ 0 ,UNITY 0 OR 0 ,UNION40 ,PROBABLY ?IS IS ! EXPLANATION ( ! P]T9ACITY ) :I* IT IS 9SI/$ ON ?AT 0 ! ,UNION MU/ & %ALL BE PRES]V$10 ?\< COMPULSION IS DIRECTLY AGA9/ ! GREAT PR9CIPLE ?AT GAVE RISE TO IT1 & /ABS ALL UNION TO ! HE>T6 ,! SAME IMPULSE PROMPTS ?\S&S TO JO9 ANY MOVEM5T1 OR NOISE ( ANY K9D1 )\T MU* CONSCI\S DESIGN1 OR TO DO ANY?+ :I* FE$S ?IS NATURAL YE>N+ = SYMPA?Y OR COMPANION%IP4 ,! MIS=TUNE IS ?AT ?IS BEAUTIFUL T5D5CY TO G5]AL SYMPA?Y IS UNREGULAT$ - WILD - ]RATIC -BL9D4 ,IT HAS NO DURABILITY1 & CAN HAVE NONE TILL IT IS RECONCIL$ TO UNIV]SAL DIV]SITY OR ,9,D,I,V,I,D,U,A,L,I,T,Y4 ,AFT] SU* RECONCILIATION1 DIFF]5CE CANNOT DI/URB IT4 

#c#a#g4 ,:AT ELSE CAN EXPLA9 ! OMNIPOT5CE ( PUBLIC OP9ION :]E !RE IS NO OP9ION8 ,YET IT HOLDS1 -AS IT W]E1 ALL ! GOV]NM5TS 9 ! WORLD BETWE5 ITS ?UMB & F+]1 & 9 ITS H& ! DE/9IES ( ! RACE4 

#c#a#h4 ,:5 WE F9D \RSELVES ON ! IMMOVABLE PLANE = ! PRES]VATION ( LIFE1 PROP]TY1 & HAPP9ESS1 ?IS SYMPA!TIC ELEM5T1 A ?\S&- FOLD /RONG]1 WILL WORK = 9/EAD ( AGA9/ TRUE CIVILIZATION4 

#c#a#i4 ,IT IS NOT TILL AFT] LONG & PA9FUL EXP]I5CE & /UDY ?AT WE DISCOV] ?AT ! PREC$5TS1 TRADITIONS1 AU?ORITIES1 & FICTIONS UPON :I* SOCIETY HAS BE5 ALL[$ TO GR[ UP1 DO NOT CO9CIDE ) EA* O!R1 NOR ) ! GREAT UNCONQU]ABLE PRIMITIVE OR DIV9E LAWS4 

#c#b4 ,F> BE IT FROM ME TO ATTEMPT TO CONQU] ?IS GREATE/ ( ALL S\RCES ( HUMAN HAPP9ESS1 OR TO PLACE ONE UNNECESS>Y OB/ACLE 9 ITS WAY4 ,! GREAT PROBLEM IS1 ,H[ CAN ?IS GREAT1 UNIV]SAL ,DIV9E DESIRE = SYMPA?Y BE H>MLESSLY EX]CIS$ TO ITS FULL SATISFACTION1 & CONT9UE UNDI/URB$8 

#c#b#a4 ,! SOLUTION ( ?IS PROBLEM W\LD BE ! GREATE/ BOON ON E>? TO MAN4 

#c#b#b4 ,PIGS1 ,BEES1 ,FI%ES1 ,ANTS1 ETC41 BE+ PROBABLY NE>LY ALIKE1 9TELLECTUALLY1 CAN LIVE 9 COMP>ATIVE PEACE & SYMPA?Y1 HAV+ BUT FEW SUBJECTS TO DISPUTE AB\T2 BUT JU/ 9 PROPORTION TO CULTURE OR EXPANSION ( ! FEEL+S1 TA/ES1 & 9TELLECTS IS ! NECESSITY & ! T5D5CY TO TAKE MORE ROOM2 SO ?AT EA* P]SON1 LIKE A PLANET1"9 CAN MOVE 9 HIS [N ORBIT )\T DI/URB+ O!RS4 ,?IS IS ,D,I,S,9,T,E,G,R,A,T,I,O,N4 

#c#b#c4 ,9 CLOSELY 5TANGL$ 9T]E/S1 AS 9 ALL 0 COMMUNISM10 !RE IS A NECESSITY ( AGREEM5T & CON=MITY1 & SOME MU/ BE MORE OR LESS PA9$ BY ! COLLISIONS ( OP9IONS1 TA/ES1 WI%ES1 ETC41 BETWE5 !M4 ,NOT1 P]HAPS1 ANY MORE AT ! SACRIFICES REQUIR$ ( ONE'S SELF ?AN FROM P]CEIV+ ?AT O!RS MAKE SACRIFICES = US4 ,ONE OR ! O!R IS 9EVITABLE1 JU/ 9 PROPORTION TO ! NUMB] OR MAGNITUDE ( ! 9T]E/S HELD 9 COMMON4 

#c#b#d4 ,LET US ILLU/RATE3 ,9 A C]TA9 T[N 9 ,9DIANA !RE WAS1 9 #a#h#d#a1 A S*OOLH\SE BUILT BY NEI<BORHOOD SUBSCRIPTION4 ,! SUBSCRIB]S1 H[EV]1 AS MI<T HAVE BE5 EXPECT$1 SOON BEGAN TO DIFF] AB\T ! *OICE ( A TEA*]2 BUT !RE WAS NO ROOM TO DIFF] )9 ! COMB9$ 9T]E/4 ,ONLY ONE P>TY C\LD POSSIBLY HAVE ITS WAY4 ,! V]Y BE/ ( REASONS & >GUM5TS W]E FURNI%$ ON BO? SIDES1 & 0IRRESI/IBLE LOGIC 0 %[$ H[ RI<T & H[ WRONG BO? P>TIES W]E2 BUT NONE ( ! >GUM5TS HAD ANY O!R EFFECT ?AN TO MAKE ! BREA* BETWE5 !M WID] & WID]2 =1 :]EAS !Y DIFF]$ AB\T ONLY ONE ?+ AT FIR/1 !Y DIFF]$ AB\T TW5TY ?+S 9 AS MANY M9UTES ( DISPUTATION4 ,DIFF]5CE TOOK !M BY SURPRISE6 ,!Y1 LIKE 0 COMMUNITIES10 HAD CALCULAT$ ON 0UNITY0 ( OP9ION1 & DIFF]5CE BECAME A DI/URB+ & UNMANAGEABLE ELEM5T 9 ! 0,UNION40 

#c#b#e4 ,MEET+ AFT] MEET+ WAS HAD1 & DISPUTE AFT] DISPUTE R\S$1 BY DEGREES1 A HO/ILE FEEL+ ON BO? SIDES1 SO ?AT1 AL?\< BO? P>TIES W]E 0 PR(ESSORS ( RELIGION10 ONE MAN RU%$ AT HIS ANTAGONI/ ) A HUGE CLUB1 BUT WAS 9 HIS TURN SUBDU$ BY AN OV]P[]+ =CE10 & ! MEET+ BROKE UP 9 AN>*Y40 ,?AT NI<T SOME ONE1 SEE+ NO BETT] MEANS ( 0 PUTT+ AN 5D TO ! W>10 SET ! VALUABLE H\SE ON FIRE1 & IT WAS BURN$ TO A%ES4 ,! ROOT ( ! :OLE ( ! TR\BLE WAS 0 COMMUNISM10 OR ,UNION0 ( PROP]TY 9 ! S*OOLH\SE4 

#c#b#f4 ,AN HABITUAL WAT*FULNESS TO PRES]VE ! CONDITIONS NECESS>Y = ,FRE$OM TO DIFF] W\LD HAVE ADMONI%$ !M NOT TO HAVE HAD ! S*OOLH\SE 9 P>TN]%IP1 AT LEA/ UNTIL !Y HAD FIR/ ASC]TA9$ ?AT !RE C\LD NOT1 9 ! NATURE ( ?+S1 BE A DIFF]5CE ( OP9ION BETWE5 !M ON AN IMPORTANT PO9T :]E IT W\LD BE NECESS>Y TO AGREE4 ,NO?+ %ORT ( ABSOLUTE1 UN*ANGEABLE TRU? OR PRIMITIVE LAWS FUR,DI% SU* SECURITY = P]MAN5T AGREEM5T OR CO9CID5CE4 

#c#b#g4 ,HAD !RE BE5 NO 0,UNION0 ( PROP]TY 9 ! S*OOLH\SE1 & HAD ! TEA*] ACT$ ON HIS 9DIVIDUAL RESPONSIBILITY ) HIS PATRONS1 ! DIFFICULTY & DE/RUCTION W\LD NOT HAVE OCCURR$1 :ATEV] DIV]SITY !RE MI<T HAVE BE5 BETWE5 ! P>TIES4 ,BUT HAV+ TAK5 ! FIR/ ]RONE\S /EP 9 COMMUNISM ( PROP]TY1 IF IT HAD BE5 FA%IONABLE 9 ! NEI<BORHOOD TO HAVE REF]R$ ! CASE TO JUDICI\S TRIBUNALS 7AS PROPOS$ 9 ! FIR/ *APT]7 :O UND]/OOD ! PHILOSOPHY ( ! DIFFICULTY1 !SE TRIBUNALS MI<T1 P]HAPS1 HAVE GIV5 SU* ADVICE AS W\LD HAVE AV]T$ ALL ! TR\BLE4 

#c#b#h4 ,A,N,O,!,R ,C,A,S,E4 ,9 ! H\SE ( A FRI5D1 :]E ,I WAS /AY+1 ,I HE>D1 9 A ROOM NEXT TO MY [N1 TWO GIRLS DISPUT+ & CRY+ = A LONG TIME4 ,PASS+ BY !IR DOOR ,I LE>N$ ?AT !Y HAD SOME PLAY?+S 9 COMMON6 ,M>Y SAID ?AT ,ANNIE W\LDN'T LET H] H&LE ! CUPS & SAUC]S1 ?\< !IR 0 GOV]NESS TOLD !M ?AT !Y MU/ BE ACCOMMODAT+ TO EA* O!R40 

#c#b#i4 0,YES10 REPLI$ ,ANNIE1 SOBB+1 0 BUT %E MEANT ?AT Y\ MU/ BE ACCOMMODAT+ AS WELL AS ME1 & :5 ,I WANT TO PUT UP ! ?+S Y\ \<T TO LET ME40 ,H]E WAS ANO!R 0 ,UNION 06 ,BO? W]E REALLY DI/RESS$ TO F9D !MSELVES QU>REL+1 & ,I SAID TO !M1 0 ,DON'T BLAME Y\RSELVES NOR EA* O!R1 GIRLS2 ! FAULT IS NOT 9 EI!R ( Y\ 2 IT IS 9 HAV+ Y\R PLAY?+S 9 COMMON4 ,!RE %\LD BE ONLY ONE [N] TO ONE ?91-4 ,:ATEV] WAS GIV5 TO Y\ %\LD HAVE BE5 GIV5 TO ONE OR ! O!R1 OR DIVID$ BETWE5 Y\4 ,I ADVISE Y\ AT ONCE TO DIVIDE Y\R ?+S BETWE5 Y\RSELVES1 & ?AT EA* %\LD SACR$LY RESPECT ! ABSOLUTE RI<T ( ! O!R TO CONTROL H] [N 9 ANY MANN] :ATEV]1 & NOT TO SET UP ANY DEM& ON EA* O!R TO BE ANY MORE 0 0ACCOMMODATION0 ?AN %E IS AT ! TIME4 ,SU* A DEM& IS A P>TIAL D5IAL ( H] RI<T ( CONTROL OV] H] [N1:I* NOT ONLY MAKES Y\ DISAGREEABLE COMPANIONS TO EA* O!R1 BUT RAISES DISPUTES ?AT NEV] CAN BE SETTL$ BY WORDS40 

#c#c4 ,!RE IS A FATAL ]ROR LY+ AT ! BOTTOM ( ,COMMUNISM OR 0 ,UNIONS10 BUT IT IS UNSE51 OV]LOOK$ 9 ! IRRESI/IBLE YE>N+ = ! H>MONY & REPOSE1 OR SYMPA?Y1 :I* IS SUPPOS$ 7BUT NEV] REALIZ$7 TO RESULT FROM !M4 

#c#c#a4 ,AT A PLACE CALL$ ,BRU% ,CREEK1 9 ,MI*IGAN1 !RE WAS A MEET+- H\SE BUILT BY SUBSCRIPTION AMONG ! NEI<BORS1 :O HAPP5$ TO AGREE 9 ?AT ONE P>TICUL> IDEA1 ?AT A H\SE ( WOR%IP WAS NECESS>Y4 ,IT WAS BUILT ( LOGS1 9 ! LO<\SE FA%ION1 & LOCK$ TOGE!R AT ! CORN]S4 ,IT WAS NO SOON] BUILT ?AN !IR CO9CID5CE WAS AT AN 5D1 = !RE WAS IMM$IATELY A DIFF]5CE AMONG !M ) REG>D TO ! DOCTR9E ?AT %\LD BE ADVOCAT$ !RE4 ,H]E1 AS USUAL1 DIV]SITY TOOK !M BY SURPRISE1 & IT BE+ A DI/URB+ ELEM5T UND] ! CIRCUM/ANCES1 IT WAS LOOK$ UPON AS AN 0 5EMY1 & EA* /ROVE TO CONQU] IT 9 HIMSELF & 9 HIS OPPON5TS4 ,!Y DID NOT KN[ ?AT DIV]SITY WAS ANY P>T ( ,DIV9ITY1 BUT !Y LOOK$ UPON IT AS A PRO( ( P]V]SITY1 OR ! WORK+S ( ! OLD VIRUS ( ORIG9AL DEPRAVITY1 & SUPPOS$ ?AT 9 W>R+ AGA9/ EA* O!R !Y W]E V9DICAT+ #ff UNITY2 0= TO ADMIT ( S*ISM & DIV]SITY UNREBUK$ WAS TO 5C\RAGE DIS9TEGRATION1 :I* W\LD 0 9AUGURATE UNIV]SAL CONFUSION40 ,SO ! P>TIES CONT5D$ ) EA* O!R TILL !Y HAD EXHAU/$ ALL !IR RES\RCES1 & DE/ROY$ ALL !IR 0 ,UNION10 & ONE MAN WAS SO EXASP]AT$ AT ! CRUDE ATTEMPTS TO PUT HIM D[N1 ?AT HE W5T HOME & GOT A YOKE ( OX51 HIT*$ A *A9 TO ONE ( ! LOGS 9 ! SIDE ( ! H\SE1 TORE IT \T1 & DRAGG$ IT HOME = FIREWOOD1 AS HIS %>E ( ! COMMUNI/IC PROP]TY6 

#c#c#b4 ,IS IT NECESS>Y TO ADD ?AT-BUT = COMMUNISM1 OR #af ,UNION10 ! CASE NEV] W\LD HAVE OCCURR$8 ,BUT HAV+ COMMITT$ ! BLUND] ( GETT+ 9TO COMMUNISM1 OR 0 ,UNION10 HAD ! CASE BE5 REF]R$ TO AN 9TELLIG5T & DIS9T]E/$ NEI<BORHOOD-C\NCIL BE=E BUILD+ ! H\SE1 IT PROBABLY NEV] W\LD HAVE BE5 BUILT ON ! COMMUNI/IC PR9CIPLE2 BUT HAV+ COMMITT$ ?IS FIR/ MI/AKE1 IT HAD BECOME TOO LATE TO EX]CISE ! RI<T ( 9DIVIDUAL [N]%IP OV] ONE LOG1 BECAUSE ?IS C\LD NOT BE DONE )\T DO+ GREAT] VIOL5CE TO ! SAME RI<T ( ! O!R [N]S1 :OSE PROP]TY WAS S]I\SLY 9JUR$ !REBY4 ,HAD !RE BE5 A CLE> IDEA AMONG !M ( :AT ! ABSOLUTE RI<T IS1 !Y W\LD ALL HAVE SE5 ?AT !Y W]E EQUALLY P>TN]S 9 A BLUND] 9 =M+ ! 0 ,UNION10 & NOT A VIOL5T WORD W\LD PROBABLY HAVE BE5 SPOK51 & !Y W\LD HAVE TALK$ ONLY ( 9DIVIDUALIZ+ OR DIS9TEGRAT+ !IR CLAIMS TO ! PROP]TY4 ,DIFF]5T EXP$I5TS MI<T HAVE BE5 SUGGE/$1 SU* AS ONE P>TY BUY+ ! O!R \T1 OR SOME 9DIVIDUAL BUY+ ! :OLE \T4 ,A DIS9T]E/$ NEI<BORHOODTRIBUNAL MI<T1 NO D\BT1 HAVE SUGGE/$ SOME MODE LESS DE/RUCTIVE ?AN ! ONE ADOPT$1 & IF NOT ACCEPT$ ! 0 GOV]NM5T 0 MI<T1 ) PROPRIETY1 HAVE 0 9T]V5$10 & PREV5T$ ! UNNECESS>Y VIOL5CE DONE TO ! BUILD+1 & RE/RA9$ ! MAN FROM TAK+ ! LOG \T1 BUT AT ! SAME TIME REQUIRE HIM TO BE PAID = HIS TR\BLE 9 PUTT+ IT 94 

#c#c#c4 ,9 ?IS CASE ! 0 GOV]NM5T10 SEE+ ?AT ! EX]CISE ( RI<T HAD BE5 R5D]$ IMPOSSIBLE BY ! '14,UNION 0 ( ! PROP]TY1 W\LD RE/RA9 ! P]SI/+ 9 ITS EX]CISE 9 ! P>TICUL> =M ADOPT$ BY ! DESP]ATE MAN1 & MI<T HAVE REQUIR$ HIM TO TAKE AN EQUIVAL5T = HIS LOG1 OV] :I* LIE C\LD EX]CISE HIS RI<T ( [N]%IP )\T DAMAG+ ! O!R P>TIES4 

#c#c#d4 ,?IS MAKES ! GOV]NM5T1 AS A LA/ RESORT1 A F9AL UMPIRE TO DECIDE BETWE5 EXP$I5TS :5 ! RI<T HAS BE5 R5D]$ IMPOSSIBLE1 BUT IT DOES NOT RISE ABOVE ABSOLUTE HUMAN RI<TS1 & IT IS R5D]$ SAFE BY BE+ DEP5D5T ON ! VOLUNT>Y ACTION OR SOV]EIGN WILL ( ?OSE :O >E REQUIR$ TO EXECUTE ANY DECISION4 

#c#c#e4 ,A,N,O,!,R ,C,A,S,E4 ,TWO M5 W]E LEFT JO9T HEIRS ( ONE H\SE2 ONE WANT$ TO SELL IT1 & ! O!R WAS OPPOS$ TO SELL+ IT4 ,!Y >GU$ & DISPUT$ TILL !Y GREW HOT1 & !N ONE C>RI$ ! CASE TO ! C\RTS1 & KEPT IT !RE TILL MORE ?AN ! PRICE ( ! H\SE HAD BE5 CONSUM$ 9 LITIGATION1 BUT ALL )\T DECISION1 = ! 0 PREC$5TS 0 & /ATUTES W]E SIL5T ON ! SUBJECT1 & NO?+ C\LD BE DONE \TSIDE ( 0PREC$5TS0 & 0/ATUTES40 ,F9ALLY1 DESP]ATION TOOK ! CASE 9 H&2 -ONE P>TY SAW$ ! H\SE 9 TWO FROM TOP TO BOTTOM1 & MOV$ HIS P>T AWAY6 ,NOT A DOLL> W\LD HAVE BE5 SP5T 9 LITIGATION1 & NO FEEL+ ( DESP]ATION OR 5MITY W\LD HAVE >IS51 IF BO? P>TIES HAD KN[N AT FIR/ ?AT DIS9TEGRATION WAS ! REM$Y REQUIR$2 OR HAD !Y REF]R$ ! CASE TO A NEI<BORHOOD C\NCIL CALL$ = ! PURPOSE 7NOT ELECT$ TO JUDGE ! CASE BE=E IT OCCURR$71 :O W]E NOT TRAMMEL$ BY UNB5D+ PREC$5TS1 /ATUTES1 & WORDY =MS1 & :O W]E NOT BIAS$ BY ! PROSPECT ( VOTES = (FICE1 OR A L>GE FEE = MAK+ TR\BLE1 !Y MI<T HAVE GIV5 ADVICE F\ND$ ON A KN[L$GE ( ! ROOT ( SU* DIFFICULTIES1 & MO/ LIKELY ! P>TIES W\LD HAVE BE5 SAV$ !IR QU>RELS1 !IR EXP5SES1 & ! DESP]ATE REM$Y RESORT$ TO4 ,! :OLE ORIG9AT$ 9 ,COMMUNISM ( PROP]TY - ,DIS9TEGRATION WAS ! 5D ( IT1 AS F> AS AN 5D C\LD BE PUT TO IT2 BUT ! 5MITY >IS+ \T ( IT MAY HAVE CONT9U$ = YE>S1 OR UNTIL EA* P>TY MAY HAVE LE>N$ ! PHILOSOPHY ( ! TR\BLE4 

#c#c#f4 ,9 #ahdh A FRI5D PRES5T$ HIMSELF SUDD5LY BE=E ME1 FIVE HUNDR$ ,MILES FROM HIS HOME1 & SAID1 0,Y\ >E SURPRIS$1 NO D\BT1 TO SEE ME H]E1 BUT Y\ CANNOT BE MORE SURPRIS$ ?AN ,I AM TO F9D MYSELF H]E4 ,I HAVE LEFT HOME PROBABLY =EV]1 ) NO?+ BUT :AT Y\ SEE UPON ME4 ,I HAVE LEFT EV]Y?+ - MONEY1 CLO!S HORSES1 F>M1 & N[ ?R[ MYSELF UPON ! WORLD TO BEG9 IT ANEW4 ,I AM A%AM$ TO TELL Y\ ! CAUSE1 BUT ,I MU/4 ,I WILL1 IF IT IS ONLY 9 JU/ICE TO Y\ :O HAVE LABOR$ SO MU* TO %[ US ! CAUSE ( SU* S]I\S DI/URBANCES1 & :I* IS SO /RIK+LY ILLU/RAT$ 9 MY [N CASE40 

#c#c#g4 ,I DESIR$ HIM TO RE/ HIMSELF & TAKE HIS LEISURE1 & 9 MORE COMPOS$ MOM5TS TO EXPLA92 & HE AFT]W>DS GAVE ME ! FOLL[+ /ATEM5T3 - 

#c#c#h4 0,MY WIFE & ,I W]E SETT+ \T A R[ ( ONIONS 9 ! G>D51 :5 %E REM>K$ ?AT ,I HAD SET !M CROOK$4 ,I REPLI$1 ,I ,NO MATT]1 !Y >E WELL 5\<2 ,I BUT %E SAID ?AT1 AS WE W]E =EIGN]S1 ! NEI<BORS W]E ALL ! TIME CRITICIZ+ \R F>M+ & G>D5+1 & %E WANT$ EV]Y?+ TO LOOK SO AS TO DEFY !IR CRITICISMS4 ,I REPLI$ ?AT ,I W\LD NOT TR\BLE MYSELF TO SIL5CE !M2 = ! SPIRIT ( FAULTF9D+1 :5 IT4 EXI/$1 AS IT DID 9 ?AT NEI<BORHOOD1 W\LD ALWAYS F9D SOME EXCUSE = V5T+ ITSELF1 & IF WE DID NOT RISE ABOVE IT1 WE %\LD 5?RALL$ \RSELVES TO IT4 ,BUT %E WAS NOT 9SPIR$ ) MY PHILOSOPHY1 & 9SI/$4 ,I BECAME A LITTLE IRRITAT$1 & MADE SOME REPLY ?AT BR\<T FROM H] AN ALLUSION TO AN OLD SORE BETWE5 US1 ?AT ,I FELT TO ! QUICK1 & REPLI$ ) SEV]ITY3 TO :I* %E RETORT$ - ) SU* BIT+ PROVOCATION1 ?AT1 BE=E ,I KNEW :AT ,I WAS DO+1 ,I HAD ?R[N A BILLET ( WOOD AT H]1 :I* =TUNATELY DID NOT HIT H]2 BUT1 AL>M$ & DISGU/$ AT MY [N CONDUCT1 AS WELL AS AT H]1 ,I RU%$ \T ( ! H\SE1 & H]E ,I AM40 

#c#c#i4 ,N[ ?IS WAS ALL 9 CONSEQU5CE ( A COMMUNISM OR A 0 ,UNION 0 ( RESPONSIBILITY 9 A R[ ( ONIONS6 

#c#d4 ,A COMMON REM>K 9 SU* CASES IS1 0 ,!Y \<T TO BE ON !IR GU>D AGA9/ (F5D+ EA* O!R40 

#c#d#a4 ,P]HAPS !Y W]E ON !IR GU>D1 & ! GU>D WAS NOT /RONG 5\<2 AT ANY RATE1 !Y HAD BO? HE>D ?AT 9JUNCTION FROM !IR *ILDHOOD1 & IT HAD HAD ALL ! EFFECT ?AT IT C\LD HAVE 9 ! CASE4 ,PRES5T CIVILIZATION HAS NO?+ ELSE TO SAY ?AT IS ANY MORE TO ! PURPOSE4 

#c#d#b4 ,HAD ! HUSB& OR ! WIFE HAD ! RESPONSIBILITY ( ! G>D5 ,9DIVIDUALLY1 ! CASE NEV] W\LD HAVE OCCURR$4 ,AT ! REQUE/ ( BO?1 ,I GAVE SU* C\NSEL AS 9DUC$ HIM TO RETURN HOME1 :]E HE REMA9$ TILL ! DEA? ( ! WIFE4 

#c#d#c4 ,! FUNDAM5TAL ]ROR ( COMMUNISM HAS BE5 SUFFICI5TLY ILLU/RAT$1 ONE W\LD ?9K1 9 ?IS G5]ATION TO R5D] A FEW H9TS SUFFICI5T = \R PRES5T PURPOSES4 ,BUT ALL ! FAILURES & RU9 ?AT HAVE BE5 SO PROM95TLY BE=E ! PUBLIC 9 ! LA/ =TY YE>S SEEM NOT TO HAVE TAU<T ! RADICAL DEFECT 9 ITS PR9CIPLE4 

#c#d#d4 ,COMMUNI/S1 LIKE MO?S FLITT+ R\ND A LAMP1 SEEM TO LE>N NO?+ FROM !IR BURNT1 DISABL$1 & PRO/RATE COMPANIONS1 & NEV] KN[ ?AT ! FLAME CAN KILL TILL IT IS TOO LATE TO PR(IT BY ! KN[L$GE2 & ! OPPOS]S1 :ILE !Y CAN REASON LIKE PHILOSOPH]S AGA9/ ! PR9CIPLE ( COMMUNISM1 WILL ADVOCATE EXACTLY ! COMMUNI/IC PR9CIPLE 9 !IR POLITICAL 0 ,UNIONS1 ORGANIZATIONS1 CONF$]ACIES & O!R COMB9$ 9T]E/S4 

#c#d#e4 ,:AT IS CALL$ CONS]VATISM HAS ALL ! TIME BE5 5TIRELY RI<T 9 ITS OBJECTIONS TO COMMUNISM1 & 9 9SI/+ ON 9DIVIDUAL [N]%IP & 9DIVIDUAL RESPONSIBILITIES BO? ( :I* COMMUNISM ANNIHILATES2 CONS]VATISM HAS ALSO %[N WISDOM 9 ITS AV]SION TO SUDD5 & GREAT *ANGES1 = NONE HAVE BE5 DEVIS$ ?AT CONTA9$ ! ELEM5TS ( SUCCESS4 

#c#d#f4 ,! ANTAGONISM ( 9T]E/S1 SUPPOS$ BY COMMUNI/S TO BE 9H]5T 9 ,9DIVIDUALITY1 IS NOT 9H]5T 91 BUT ONLY 9CID5TAL TO1 IT2 :I* ANTAGONISM IS COMPLETELY NEUTRALIZ$1 & ALL4 ! COOP]ATION & ECONOMIES AIM$ AT BY COMMUNISM GR[ NATURALLY \T ( ! PR9CIPLE ( ,EQUIVAL5TS1 OR SIMPLE JU/ICE6 ,& ! SAME PR9CIPLE1 BY COMP5SAT+ ONLY = ,C,O,/1 OP5S ALL PRIM>Y L&1 WAT]S1 M9]ALS1 SPONTANE\S FRUITS1 & ALL O!R NATURAL WEAL?1 FREE FROM ALL PRICE1 ?US MEET+ ! COMMON-PROP]TY IDEA HALF-WAY1 BUT 9 ! S5SE 9 :I* WAT] 9 A RIV] IS N[ COMMON3 ?AT IS1 :ILE EV]Y ONE MAY TAKE :AT HE CAN USE )\T PRICE1 :5 HE HAS ONCE GOT IT 9TO HIS POSSESSION1 NO O!R P]SON MU/ HAVE ANY CLAIM UPON IT )\T ! [N]'S CONS5T1 OR CONFUSION W\LD FOLL[ ,SO1 ?\< ! PROP]TY OR WEAL? IS COMMON TO ALL1 !RE IS NO COMMUNISM OR JO9T [N]%IP BETWE5 ANY4 

#c#d#g4 ,I HAVE LABOR$ TO EXHIBIT ! HIDD51 SUBTLE1 FUNDAM5TAL CAUSE ( SO MANY PA9FUL DISAPPO9TM5TS 9 COMMUNI/IC COMB9ATIONS1 BO? SOCIAL & POLITICAL1 :I* HAVE 5D$ SO DISA/R\SLY = MANY ( ! BE/ ( M5 & WOM51 :O W]E WILL+ TO SACRIFICE EV]Y?+ = ! #df ,UNITY 0 OR 0 H>MONY 0 ( ! RACE1 & ALSO TO SUGGE/ TO C>EFUL READ]S ! UNEXPOS$ ROOT ( \R PRES5T POLITICAL AN>*Y1 & MANY ( ! MO/ PA9FUL CONFLICTS & DISAPPO9TM5TS ( LIFE4 ,LET US BE DISAPPO9T$ NO MORE2 LET US BE SURE ?AT WE HAVE GOT ! RI<T G]M BE=E WE PLANT \R SE$4 

#c#d#h4 ,LET US PROCE$ TO EXAM9E \R G]MS ( TRUE OR H>MONIC ORGANIZATION4 

#c#d#i4 ,A MAN WANTS TO RAISE A H\SE2 HE CANNOT DO IT ALONE1 & 9VITES HIS NEI<BORS TO HELP HIM4 ,!Y >E WILL+ TO DO SO1 EI!R FROM SYMPA?Y1 = ! 5JOYM5T ( ! COMPANION%IP ( ! OCCASION1 OR = PECUNI>Y COMP5SATION1 OR )\T ANY P>TICUL> CONSCI\S MOTIVE4 ,:E!R !Y >E MOV$ BY ONE MOTIVE OR ANO!R1 !IR MOVEM5T IS VOLUNT>Y1 & ! RAIS+ ( ! H\SE IS ! PO9T ( CO9CID5CE BETWE5 !M -! OBJECT :I* BR+S !M TOGE!R1 & :I* GIVES RISE TO ! COOP]ATION BETWE5 !M4 

#c#e4 ,TW5TY M5 ASSEMBLE ON ! GR\ND1 BUT !Y CAN DO NO?+1 IF ! :OLE TW5TY UND]TAKE TO GIVE DIRECTIONS4 

#c#e#a4 ,EV5 TWO CANNOT DO SO1 )\T LEAD+ DIRECTLY TO CONFUSION & C\NT]ACTION4 ,PRIMITIVE OR ,DIV9E LAW DOES NOT TOL]ATE ANY?+ MORE OR LESS ?AN ,9,D,I,V,I,D,U,A,L,I,T,Y 9 ANY LEAD4 ,:O %\LD BE ! LEAD ON ?IS OCCASION BUT HE :O TAKES ! RISKS & BE>S ALL CO/S 8 ,HE MAY PREF] TO DELEGATE HIS FUNCTION1 BUT MAY ) PROPRIETY RESUME IT AT ANY MOM5T4 

#c#e#b4 ,T5 M5 >E REQUE/$ TO LIFT A TIMB]2 !Y ALL GET READY TO DO SO1 BUT !Y CANNOT LIFT TOGE!R TILL SOME WORD OR SIGN IS GIV54 ,SELECT ?REE ( ! WISE/ OR MO/ EXP]I5C$ ( ! COMPANY TO GIVE ?AT WORD OR SIGN1 & CONFUSION W\LD RESULT1 BUT LET ONLY ONE 7,9DIVIDUAL71 ?\< A M]E *ILD1 GIVE ! WORD1 & ! TIMB] MOVES4 

#c#e#c4 ,?IS ,I UND]/& TO BE ! PHILOSOPHY ( LEAD]%IP1 & ALSO ( ,MON>*Y & DESPOTISM4 ,BUT :Y HAVE !Y PROV$ SO DE/RUCTIVE ( ! 5DS PROPOS$ BY !M 8 ,IT IS BECAUSE ( ! UNCONSCI\S ATTEMPT TO UNITE OR COMB9E ! LEAD & ! DECID+ P[] OR SOV]EIGNTY 9 ONE P]SON 6 ,LET US SEE4 

#c#e#d4 ,! TW5TY M5 HAD EA* A M9D & A MOTIVE ( HIS [N TO HELP AT ! RAIS+1 & ?\< ! MOTIVES W]E DIFF]5T1 ?IS DIFF]5CE DID NOT PREV5T !IR CO9CID+ OR COOP]AT+ ACTION 9 ?AT ONE 9DIVIDUAL ?+ TO BE DONE4 ,! [N] ( ! H\SE DID NOT UND]TAKE TO DECIDE ?AT !SE M5 %\LD HELP HIM6 ,EA* DECID$ = HIMSELF SUPREMELY 7SOV]EIGNLY7 ?AT HE W\LD HELP1 & !SE CO9CID+1 9DIVIDUAL SOV]EIGN DECISIONS ONLY WANT$ A LEAD1 & ALL WAS WELL4 

#c#e#e4 ,I REPEAT ?AT ! GREAT ]ROR HAS BE5 9 ! ATTEMPT TO COMB9E ! LEAD & ! DECID+ OR SOV]EIGN P[] ,9 ,O,N,E ,P,],S,O,N6 9/EAD ( RECOGNIZ+ ! DECID+ P[] :]E DIV9E LAW HAS IRREVOCABLY FIX$ IT1 9 EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL ( ! RACE 6 ,D,I,S,9,T,E,G,R,A,T,I,O,N ( !SE TWO ELEM5TS MU/ RECTIFY ?IS FATAL ]ROR BE=E !RE CAN BE ANY SECURITY = P]SONS OR PROP]TY1 & BE=E ANY GOV]NM5T CAN P]=M ITS LEGITIMATE FUNCTION AS ILLU/RAT$ 9 ! FIR/ *APT]4 

#c#e#f4 ,CO9CID5CE MU/ BE HAD BE=E ANY?+ REQUIR+ ! COOP]ATION ( NUMB]S CAN BE PROP]LY DONE4 ,IT IS ON ?IS ACC\NT ?AT DIV]SITY ( VIEWS OR MOTIVES HAS BE5 LOOK$ UPON & TREAT$ AS AN EVIL1 BECAUSE IT T5DS TO NEUTRALIZE ! DESIR$ 0,UNITY0 ( ACTION4 ,!RE=E1 AS 9TELLECTUAL CULTURE & EXPANSION GIVE RISE TO ?IS DREAD$ DIV]SITY1 CULTURE IS LOOK$ UPON AS DANG]\S1 & ! EXPRESSION ( OP9IONS ADV]SE TO ! GOV]NM5TS >E =BIDD5 & PUNI%$ ) HEAVY P5ALTIES OR CRUEL DEA?S4 ,?US ORD] BECOMES CONV]T$ 9TO *AOS BY TRAMPL+ ! 5D UND] FOOT 9 PURSUIT ( ! MEANS6 ,! PR(ESS$ 5D IS SECURITY & PROTECTION ( P]SON & PROP]TY1 & ! MEANS ADOPT$ DE/ROY BO?6 

#c#e#g4 ,!SE P5ALTIES 9FLICT$ = DIV]SITY >E PRACTICAL ACKN[L$GM5TS ?AT ! DECID+ P[] IS 9EVITABLY FIX$ 91 & 9SEP>ABLE FROM1 EA* 9DIVIDUAL1 :O IS !RE=E PRES5T$ ) AN ASSORTM5T ( EVILS TO *OOSE FROM & DECIDE UPON6 ,IF HE DESIRES TO DISOBEY ORD]S1 HE MAY CALCULATE ! VALUE ( HIS LIFE TO HIMSELF OR O!RS1 HIS REPUGNANCE TO PA9 & DEA?1 HIS *ANCES ( ESCAPE1 & ON !SE CALCULATIONS HE DECIDES = HIMSELF 7SOV]EIGNLY7 AT LA/4 ,:]E1 !N1 DOES ! SOV]EIGN P[] RE/ 8 

#c#e#h4 ,! SOV]EIGN P[] 7OR ! 9/9CT ( SELFPRES]VATION7 CAN NEV] BE WRE/$ FROM ! MULTITUDE1 NOR FROM A S+LE ,9DIVIDUAL -IT IS 0,9,A,L,I,5,A,B,L,E2 0 & TO MAKE ! ATTEMPT TO ALI5ATE IT IS ONE ( ! MO/ FATAL POLITICAL FALLACIES EV] ATTEMPT$4 ,& A FALLACY EQUALLY FATAL IS ?AT ( SUPPOS+ ?AT ?IS DECID+ P[] CAN SUCCESSFULLY BE VE/$ 9 A MAJORITY OV] A M9ORITY1 OR OV] A S+LE P]SON4 

#c#e#i4 ,COMMON SOLDI]S SUPPOSE1 :5 !Y 5LI/ 9 ! REGUL> S]VICE1 ?AT !Y PUT !MSELVES !NCE=?1 = A SPECIFI$ TIME1 UND] ! COMM&S ( !IR (FIC]S1 ) :OM RE/ ALL DECID+ P[] AS TO !IR MOVEM5TS 2 & ?IS P[] IS SUPPOS$ BY (FIC]S &-M5 TO BE ABSOLUTE1 UNQUALIFIES & F9AL1 & EI!R W\LD />E AT CALL+ ! IDEA 9 QUE/ION4 

#c#f4 ,A COMPANY ( REGUL>S 9 ,SCOTL& W]E ON ! M>* T[>DS ! RIV] ,CLYDE4 ,AT ! $GE ( ! /REAM1 ! SOLDI]S1 RA!R ?AN WALK 9 & BE DR[N$1 HALT$ )\T WAIT+ = ! ORD] TO HALT1 :I* WAS 5TIRELY CONTR>Y TO ! CONTRACT & ! DISCIPL9E4 ,(FIC]S & M5 W]E BO? TAK5 BY SURPRISE ) ! FACT ?AT ! DECID+ P[] WAS NOT ) ! (FIC]S - ?AT IT HAD SUDD5LY MADE ITS APPE>ANCE 9 AN UNEXPECT$ QU>T]2 ! 9/9CT ( SELF-PRES]VATION 7OR SELF- SOV]EIGNTY7 HAD SUDD5LY ASSUM$ ITS SWAY1 LIKE AN IRRESI/IBLE ?IRD P>TY1 & ANNULL$ ! CONTRACT ( 0UNQUALIFI$ OB$I5CE TO ORD]S10 CONTR>Y TO DISCIPL9E & TO ! PREVI\S UND]/&+ & 9T5TIONS ( BO? P>TIES6 

#c#f#a4 ,!REUPON A LITTLE /ORM CL\D 7NO BIGG] ?AN A MAN'S H&7 >OSE BETWE5 M5 & MA/]2 BUT :5 !Y BEG9 TO DEBATE1 GOOD-BY TO ! DRI$-H]R+ SUBORD9ATION4 ,! 9/9CT ( SELF-PRES]VATION DOES NOT ALWAYS WAIT TO CONSULT 0PREC$5TS NOR 9T]PRETATIONS ( CON/ITUTIONS1 ! ,I RI<T ( REBELLION ' 0 NOR AU?ORITIES ( ANY K9D4 ,IT IS ITS [N AU?ORITY1 FROM :I* ALL O!RS >E D]IV$4 

#c#f#b4 ,9 !SE /ATES1 ! 9/ITUTIONS >E SUPPOS$ TO PLACE ALL DECID+ P[] 9 ! H&S ( C]TA9 M5 APPO9T$ TO WIELD IT2 YET ?IS SAME 9/9CT IS N[ AT WORK 9 EV]Y BREA/ 9 ! NATION1 & EV]Y ONE IS 9VOLUNT>ILY DEBAT+ OR DECID+ 9 HIS [N M9D & FEEL+S1 ACCORD+ TO HIS CONDITIONS1 & !RE IS NO CO9CID5CE AMONG ANY L>GE PORTION ( US4 ,! DECID+ P[] IS NOT 9 ! M5 APPO9T$ TO WIELD IT1 NOR EV5 HAVE !Y GOT ! EXCLUSIVE ,9DIVIDUAL LEAD4 

#c#f#c4 ,IT IS WORSE ?AN USELESS1 IT IS CALAMIT\S1 TO LEGISLATE AS IF IT W]E POSSIBLE TO DIVE/ \RSELVES ( ?IS 9VOLUNT>Y 9/9CT ( SELF- PRES]VATION OR SELF-SOV]EIGNTY1 & ?OSE :O ACCEPT OR ACT ON SU* PL$GE COMMIT AS GREAT AN ]ROR AS ?OSE :O GIVE IT1 & ALL CONTRACTS TO ?IS EFFECT BE+ IMPOSSIBLE ( FULFILLM5T >E NULL & VOID4 ,WE MAY DELEGATE ! LEAD+ FUNCTION (T5 ) ADVANTAGE1 BUT IT IS FOLLY1 BL9DNESS1 SELF-DECEPTION1 & MAY BE RU91 TO COMMIT \RSELVES UNQUALIFI$LY TO IMPLICIT & UNHESITAT+ OB$I5CE TO ANY P]SONAL LEAD = A S+LE H\R4 

#c#f#d4 ,= TRUE ORD] & CIVILIZATION1 !N1 LET US REALIZE ?AT1 ?\< ANY SUCCESSFUL LEAD MU/ BE AN ,9DIVIDUALITY1 ?IS LEAD %\LD BE ONLY A LEAD1 LIKE ! *ILD AT ! RAIS+ - ONE 9DIVIDUAL FUNCTION BY ITSELF1 & NO ATTEMPT %\LD BE MADE TO COMB9E IT ) ! DECID+ OR SOV]EIGN P[]4 

#c#f#e4 ,! MO/ P]FECT LEAD W\LD BE ?AT :I* WAS BE/ ADAPT$ TO ! P>TICUL> OCCASION = IT2 & AS EV]Y OCCASION MAY BE PECULI> 9 ITSELF1 NO ONE P]SONAL LEAD MAY BE EQUALLY ADAPT$ TO V>I\S OCCASIONS4 ,A *ILD MI<T LEAD ! LIFT+ ( ! TIMB]S ( ! H\SE1 BUT C\LD NOT LEAD 9 ! FRAM+ ( IT4 ,! PRESID5T ( A RAILROAD COMPANY MAY LEAD ITS AFFAIRS V]Y SATISFACTORILY1 BUT4 MI<T NOT BE EQUALLY ADAPT$ TO LEAD A *ILD 9 ! /UDY ( MUSIC4 

#c#f#f4 ,A V]Y COMMON MI/AKE IS MADE 9 TAK+ IT = GRANT$ ?AT1 BECAUSE A MAN HAS %[N GREAT CAPACITY TO LEAD 9 ONE DIRECTION OR DEP>TM5T1 HE IS1 !RE=E1 MO/ LIKELY TO PROVE A GOOD LEAD 9 O!R DIRECTIONS6 ,! CONTR>Y IS MO/ LIKELY TO BE ! FACT1 9ASMU* AS ?AT ! MORE TIME HE HAS SP5T 9 QUALIFY+ HIMSELF = ONE FUNCTION1 ! LESS HE W\LD HAVE TO BE/[ 9 O!RS2 AS ILLU/RAT$ BY ! V]Y PR(\ND ,CON*OLOGI/ :O ?\<T ?AT ! BEANS 9 HIS G>D5 HAD COME UP 0 ! WRONG 5D FIR/40 

#c#f#g4 ,! MO/ EFFECTUAL LEAD IS NOT NECESS>ILY ALWAYS A P]SON4 ,IT MAY BE A ?+1 AN IDEA1 OR A PR9CIPLE4 ,A CLOCK OR A WAT* LEADS OR 0 GOV]NS 0 ! MOVEM5TS ( MANY ( US MORE ?AN M5 DO4 ,BUT TWO CLOCKS :I* %\LD DIFF] WIDELY FROM EA* O!R W\LD NEUTRALIZE ! LEAD1 & MAKE ONLY CONFUSION4 ,IF !Y H>MONIZ$ ) EA* O!R1 ONE W\LD BE SUP]FLU\S4 ,BUT A PLURALITY ( M5 TO LEAD ANY ONE MOVE M5T1 HAV+ MORE ELEM5TS ( DIV]SITY )9 !M ?AN UN9TELLECTUAL CLOCKS1 >E MORE LIKELT ?AN !Y TO DIFF]1 & LEAD TO CONFUSION4 

#c#f#h4 ,PRIMITIVE NATURE 9SI/S ON AN ,9DIVIDUALITY 9 A P]SONAL LEAD1 & IT IS 9 VA9 = US TO CONT5D AGA9/ IT4 

#c#f#i4 ,A S+LE MAN MAY LEAD ! :OLE RACE1 AS IS ALREADY DEMON/RAT$ BY ! 9V5TOR ( RAILROADS1 ( /EAM P[]1 ETC42 BUT IF HE UND]TAKES TO DECIDE ?AT ! PUBLIC %ALL PATRONIZE OR FOLL[ HIM1 HE WILL F9D HIMSELF AT ONCE 9 CONFLICT ) ! ?IRD P>TY - A DIV9E LAW1 FROM :I*1 SOON] OR LAT]1 HE WILL BE OBLIG$ TO RETIRE4 

#c#g4 ,! SPH]E ( LEAD MAY H>MLESSLY EXT5D OV] ! :OLE E>?2 BUT ! SPH]E ( SOV]EIGNTY CANNOT H>MLESSLY BE EXT5D$ BEYOND ! P]SON1 TIME1 PROP]TY1 & RESPONSIBILITIES ( ! ONE P]SON :O EX]CISES ?AT SOV]EIGNTY4 

#c#g#a4 ,:AT1 !N1 IS 9VASION8 

#c#g#b4 ,IF Y\ COME 9TO MY H\SE1 AGA9/ MY WILL1 ?IS IS AN 9VASION ( MY PROP]TY C]TA9LY2 BUT IF Y\ HAVE HE>D SCREAMS )91 & CALLS = HELP1 & Y\ HAVE COME 9 TO RE/RA9 ME FROM 9VAD+ ! LIFE ( AN 9MATE1 ?\< IT BE MY [N *ILD1 Y\ HAVE MADE A JU/IFIABLE & LEGITIMATE *OICE ( EVILS 9 VIOLAT+ MY RI<T ( PROP]TY TO PREV5T ME FROM VIOLAT+ GREAT] RI<TS4 ,IF ,I W\LD HAVE MY ABSOLUTE RI<TS ( PROP]TY & P]SON HELD 9VIOLATE1 ,I MU/ OBS]VE & HOLD SACR$ ALL ! RI<TS ( O!RS4 

#c#g#c4 ,COMMODORE ,+RAHAM DID NOT 9VADE ANYBODY :5 HE PROTECT$ ,CO/ZA FROM OPPRESSION4 ,IF HE 9VAD$ A POLITICAL JURISDICTION 9 PROTECT+ ,CO/ZA1 IT WAS A JU/IFIABLE *OICE ( EVILS4 

#c#g#d4 ,?\< ,JOHN ,BR[N W5T 9TO ,VIRG9IA TO RELIEVE SLAVES FROM OPPRESSION1 IF HE HAD COMPELL$ ANY SLAVE1 BY FE> OR =CE1 TO JO9 HIM AGA9/ HIS WILL1 ?IS W\LD HAVE BE5 OPPRESSION OR 9VASION ( ! SLAVE4 ,?IS P]SONAL SOV]EIGNTY %\LD BE ABOVE ALL O!R CONSID]ATIONS4 

#c#g#e4 ,A NATION CONSI/S ( ALL ! 9DIVIDUALS 9 IT4 ,AN ,>MY :I* HAS 5T]$ A ,NATION TO PROTECT EV5 ONE 9DIVIDUAL FROM OPPRESSION1 & HAS COMMITT$ NO UNNECESS>Y VIOL5CE 9 DO+ SO1 HAS MADE A JU/IFIABLE *OICE ( EVILS4 ,?IS IDEA IS ALREADY SANCTION$ 9 ! PROTECTION BY A :OLE ,NATION R5D]$ TO ANY ONE ( ITS MEMB]S 9 ANY P>T ( ! WORLD4 

#c#g#f4 ,:5 ,CLAN%IP OR POLITICAL SY/EMS >E \TGR[N1 & EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL IS RECOGNIZ$ AS A SOV]EIGN MEMB] ( ! P>TY ( ! :OLE1 ! SAME IDEA BECOMES ONLY EXT5D$ :5 ! :OLE ( ! RACE %\LD PROTECT ONE MEMB] ( ! RACE FROM 9VASION4 

#c#g#g4 ,! K+S ( ,DAHOMEY MAY NOT ALWAYS 5JOY UNDI/URB$ REPOSE 0 UPON A ?RONE ( !IR 5EMIES' SKULLS 0 :ILE ?OSE 5EMIES >E ONLY ! WEAK & CRUELLY OPPRESS$ REBELLI\S SUBJECTS4 

#c#g#h4 ,WE HAVE SE5 ?AT ! LEAD & ! DECID+OR SOV]EIGN P[] >E TWO V]Y DI/9CT ELEM5TS2 ?AT = TRUE ORD]1 !Y MU/ BE DIS9TEGRAT$ FROM EA* O!R1 ! ONE HAV+ UNLIMIT$ SCOPE1 & ! O!R CONF9$ TO ! P]SON1 TIME1 PROP]TY1 & RESPONSIBILITIES ( ONE ,9DIVIDUAL4 

#c#g#i4 ,BEYOND ?IS 9DIVIDUAL SPH]E NO ONE1 NO NUMB] ( M5 HAVE A RI<T ( ABSOLUTE SOV]EIGNTY4 ,WE ALL HAVE A RI<T TO SYMPA?IZE ) ! DI/RESS$ 9 ANY P>T ( ! WORLD ) BUT NOT AGA9/ !IR CONS5T OR WILL4 

#c#h4 ,I SPEAK ) DECISION1 BECAUSE1 AFT] =TY YE>S' /UDY & EXP]IM5TS ON !SE SUBJECTS1 ,I HAVE >RIV$ AT DECISIONS = MYSELF1 & BECAUSE ,I ?9K ! READ] WILL PREF] IT AS ! MO/ CONV5I5T LANGUAGE = HIM AS WELL AS = ME1 & BECAUSE ,I ?9K BE WILL PREF] ! ASSURANCE :I* IS AF=D$ BY PLAC+ MYSELF UND] ! RESPONSIBILITY ( DEF9ITE & POSITIVE ASS]TIONS1 RA!R ?AN ?AT ,I %\LD GIVE \T VAGUE H9TS & ?R[ ! RESPONSIBILITY ( CONCLUSIONS UPON HIM4 ,& AFT] & 9 ! MID/ ( CONT9U\S REIT]ATION ( ! SOV]EIGN RI<T ( EV]Y 9DIVIDUAL TO DECIDE = HIMSELF1 HE WILL NOT SUSPECT ME ( ATTEMPT+ TO DECIDE = HIM AGA9/ HIS CONS5T4 

#c#h#a4 ,:ILE ! DECID+ OR SOV]EIGN P[] IS UND]/&+LY LEFT UNDI/URB$ :]E IT REALLY IS 79 ! HE>T OR HEAD ( EV]Y ,9DIVIDUAL = HIMSELF71 IT MATT]S BUT LITTLE :O UND]TAKES TO LEAD4 ,HE :O MO/ ADDRESSES HIMSELF TO ! L>GE/ CO9CID5CE OR MO/ PRESS+ WANTS ( ! TIME WILL HAVE ! MO/ FOLL[]S4 

#c#h#b4 ,CO9CID5CE BETWE5 ! LEAD & ! SOV]EIGN P[]S IS LIKE ! LOCK+ ( ! C>S TOGE!R ! :OLE MOVE4 

#c#h#c4 ,H[ TO GET ?IS CO9CID5CE IS ! GREAT PROBLEM ( ORGANIZATION & MOVEM5T4 

#c#h#d4 ,9 ! RAIS+ ( ! H\SE1 ! TW5TY M5 CO9CID$ = ?AT ONE SPECIFIC1 ,9DIVIDUAL P]=MANCE2 BUT IF ! [N] HAD ASK$ ! M5 TO HELP HIM 9 FUTURE1 )\T SPECIFIY+ :AT HELP HE WANT$1 NO ?\<TFUL MAN W\LD HAVE CONS5T$4 ,! PROPOSITION W\LD HAVE BE5 TOO G5]AL1 TOO 9DEF9ITE2 ?IS HAS BE5 ! RADICAL FAULT ( ALL ORGANIZATIONS6 ,! REM$Y IS TO ,9DIVIDUALIZE ! OCCASIONS = COOP]ATION1 LEAV+ EV]Y ONE FREE TO R5D] OR )HOLD HIS ASSI/ANCE1 ACCORD+ TO HIS 9DIVIDUAL VIEWS ( ! 9DIVIDUAL CASE N[ PRES5T 9 H&4 

#c#h#e4 ,! E/ABLI%+ A LEAD = ! P>TICUL> OCCASION ( RAIS+ ! H\SE1 & ! M5 PLAC+ !MSELVES 9 POSITION READY = LIFT+1 WAS ! ORGANIZATION1 & ! GIV+ ! WORD & LIFT+ W]E ! COOP]ATION4 

#c#h#f4 ,SUPPOSE1 N[1 ?AT ONE MAN AT ! TIMB] IS 9=M$ ?AT HIS H\SE IS ON FIRE2 HE SUDD5LY AB&ONS ! ORGANIZATION & ! COOP]ATION TO RESCUE HIS FAMILY & PRES]VE HIS PROP]TY6 ,:O C5SURES HIM8 ,YET HE HAS RIS51 SO TO SPEAK1 ABOVE ! ORGANIZATION1 ABOVE ! 9/ITUTION1 - BROK5 HIS CONTRACT4 

#c#h#g4 ,! ORGANIZATION WAS WELL ADAPT$ = ! OCCASION = IT - = ! OBJECT IT HAD 9 VIEW1 BUT BEYOND ?AT IT HAD NO APPLICABILITY1 & TO 9SI/ ON ! MAN FULFILL+ HIS CONTRACT UND] ! NEW CIRCUM/ANCES W\LD BE SIMPLY ABSURD & USELESS4 ,BUT WE WILL CONSID] ?IS F>!R BY & BY4 

#c#h#h4 ,WE SEE ?AT ,PRIMITIVE OR ,DIV9E LAW DEM&S ,9DIVIDUALITY 9 A LEAD4 ,?IS LEAD IS SOMETIMES A MAN1 SOMETIMES A WOMAN1 A *ILD1 OR A ?+2 IT IS ALSO SOMETIMES AN IDEA4 ,?IS LATT] HAS ALWAYS BE5 PRACTICALLY ADMITT$ BY ?OSE :O HAVE ATTEMPT$ TO G5]ALIZE ! EXP]I5CE ( MANK9D 9TO AXIOMS1 RULES1 WRITT5 /ATUTES1 OR 7SO CALL$7 LAWS1 ,CON/ITUTIONS1 ETC4 ,!Y 9T5D$ !SE IDEAS AS PO9TS ( CO9CID5CE TO LEAD OR =CE ! PEOPLE 9TO C]TA9 MODES ( ACTION4 

#c#h#i4 ,BUT 9 ALL !SE !RE HAS BE5 ! SAME FATAL ]ROR-,D,E,F,E,C,T,I,V,E ,G,5,],A,L,I,Z,A,T,I,O,N4 

#c#i4 ,A RULE 7OR 0LAW07 :I* MAY BE GOOD = ! CASE 9 :I* IT ORIG9AT$ MAY NOT APPLY TO ANY O!R CASE AS WELL4 ,NEW CASES GIVE RISE TO O!R RULES :I* CONFLICT ) ! FIR/2 :I* CONFFICT1 LIKE ?AT ( ! TWO DIFF]5T CLOCKS1 DE/ROYS ! P[] ( EI!R TO LEAD4 

#c#i#a4 ,!N1 AGA91 >ISES 7FROM ! 9EVITABLE ,9DIVIDUALITY ( DIFF]5T M9DS7 ! DIFF]5T 9T]PRETATIONS ( ! SAME RULES OR G5]ALISMS4 ,WITNESS ! DIFF]5T 9T]PRETATIONS ( ! ,CON/ITUTION ( ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES & ALL O!R CON/ITUTIONS4 

#c#i#b4 ,!Y >E LIABLE TO SO MANY DIFF]5T CON/RUCTIONS1 ?AT ?IS DIV]SITY NOT ONLY NEUTRALIZES !IR P[] TO LEAD1 BUT !Y BECOME POSITIVE ELEM5TS ( ANTAGONISM & VIOL5T DISS5SIONS & MUTUAL DE/RUCTION1 BECAUSE !IR LAT5T FAULTS >E TOO SUBTLE = READY DETECTION4 ,!Y W\LD BE H>MLESS & MI<T BE B5EFICIAL IF !RE WAS NO ATTEMPT TO COMB9E 9 !M ! SOV]EIGN P[]4 ,TO REM$Y ?IS FATAL DEFECT1 ! WORD 0 %ALL0 %\LD BE EXPUNG$1 & ! WORD MAY SUB/ITUT$4 

#c#i#c4 ,CONSCI\S ( ?IS DEFECT TO SOME EXT5T1 ! MAK]S ( SOME ( !SE V]BAL 9/ITUTIONS HAVE PROVID$ ?AT ! ULTIMATE OR F9AL 9T]PRETATION ( !M %ALL RE/ 9 ! SUPREME ,C\RTS2 ! PRACTICAL WORK+ ,( :I* IS TO CONC5TRATE A CO]CIVE P[] 9 ONE P]SON OV] ! DE/9IES ( MILLIONS1"9 :I* IS A RETURN TO ,DESPOTISM1 & 9 ! WOR/ =M1 BECAUSE IT IS DISGUIS$ & H$G$ R\ND ) BEWILD]+ FICTIONS & =MULAS6 

#c#i#d4 ,! ,CON/ITUTION ( ! ,UNIT$ ,/ATES 7SOCALL$7 CONTA9S A GREAT MANY =MULAS & G5]ALIZATIONS1 ! :OLE BE+ 9T5D$ TO LEAD TO PROSP]ITY1 SECURITY1 & FRE$OM4 ,! UNAVOIDABLE DIFF]5CE 9 ! 9T]PRETATIONS ( ! 9/RUM5T1 BE+ PROVID$ = ONLY 9 A =M :I* GAVE ! MONOPOLY ( ! 9T]PRET+ & 5=C+ P[] 9TO A FEW H&S1 HAS L$ TO ! SUDD5 *ECK ( ALL PROSP]ITY - HAS R5D]$ ALL P]SONS & PROP]TY 9 ! ,/ATES AS 9SE4 CURE AS POSSIBLE1 & 9/EAD ( ,FRE$OM1 !Y >E AT ?IS MOM5T UND] ! MO/ UNQUALIFI$ DESPOTISM ?AT EXI/S ON ! E>? 6  

 "9 ,WITNESS ! ,DR$ ,SCOTT ,DECISION4  

 #c#i#e4 ,! ,DECL>ATION ( ,AM]ICAN ,9DEP5D5CE EMBRACES A GREAT UNIV]SAL FACT1 OR ,PRIMITIVE OR ,DIV9E LAW1 9T5D$ TO ACT AS A PO9T ( CO9CID5CE = ! COOP]ATION & H>MONY ( ALL MANK9D2 BUT ! SAME 9/RUM5T ALSO DISPLAYS O!R FEATURES MORE PROM95T & MORE /RIK+ TO COMMON OBS]VATION1 :ILE ! G]M9AL1 C5TRAL IDEA ( ! :OLE 9/RUM5T LIES BIDD5 )9 ITS WELL-*OS5 PHRASEOLOGY1 LIKE ! LIFE-GIV+ G]M ( ! SE$1 BEYOND ! EXT]NAL EYE1 & COGNIZABLE ONLY BY ! P5ETRAT+ M5TAL VISION4 

#c#i#e4 ,! ,DECL>ATION ( ,AM]ICAN ,9DEP5D5CE EMBRACES A GREAT UNIV]SAL FACT1 OR ,PRIMITIVE OR ,DIV9E LAW1 9T5D$ TO ACT AS A PO9T ( CO9CID5CE = ! COOP]ATION & H>MONY ( ALL MANK9D2 BUT ! SAME 9/RUM5T ALSO DISPLAYS O!R FEATURES MORE PROM95T & MORE /RIK+ TO COMMON OBS]VATION1 :ILE ! G]M9AL1 C5TRAL IDEA ( ! :OLE 9/RUM5T LIES BIDD5 )9 ITS WELL-*OS5 PHRASEOLOGY1 LIKE ! LIFE-GIV+ G]M ( ! SE$1 BEYOND ! EXT]NAL EYE1 & COGNIZABLE ONLY BY ! P5ETRAT+ M5TAL VISION4 

#c#i#f4 ,EV5 !RE1 9 ?AT SUBLIME EF=T ( VIRTUE & G5IUS1 !RE IS ?AT PLURALITY ( ELEM5TS1 :I*1 LIKE ! PLURALITY ( M51 NEUTRALIZE EA* O!R AS A LEAD ACCORD+ TO ITS NOBLE DESIGN4 

#c#i#g4 ,/RUGGL+ ?R\< C5TURIES ) SU* SUBTLE DIFFICULTIES & OB/RUCTIONS1 ! BE/ M9DS HAVE BE5 B5T ON SIMPLIFY+ ,H5CE >OSE ! =MULA1 0,DO UNTO O!RS AS YE W\LD ?AT !Y %\LD DO UNTO Y\20 & ,*RI/5DOM REJOIC$ 9 ! APP>5T SUPPLY ( !IR GREATE/ E?ICAL WANT4 ,! M5 OR WOM5 ( MATURE CULTURE & EXP]I5CE & ( DELICATE SYMPA?IES1 :O TAKE PLEASURE 9 ! PLEASURE !Y CONF]1 & %>E ! PA9 !Y >E OBLIG$ TO 9FLICT1 WILL 9T]PRET & APPLY ?IS =MULA 9 A H>MLESS & EV5 A B5EFIC5T MANN]4 ,!Y >E C>EFUL NOT TO 9FLICT UNNECESS>Y PA9 ON O!RS NOR TO REQUIRE SACRIFICES ( !M )\T PECUNI>Y OR MORAL COMP5SATION4 

#c#i#h4 ,:ILE ?OSE :O >E 9DIFF]5T TO ! PA9!Y 9FLICT1 OR UND] ! 9FLU5CE ( AN ILL-DIGE/$ !ORY 7?\< WELL 9T5D$71 & :O >E SATISFI$ ) M]E ,LOGICAL CONSI/5CY1 MI<T EXCUSE !MSELVES1 BY ?IS =MULA1 = 9SI/+ ON %>+ OR DI/RIBUT+ ! PROP]TY ( O!RS1 ON ! GR\ND ?AT ! [N]S W\LD BE GLAD TO HAVE ! SAME DONE = !M1 IF ! CASES W]E REV]S$ 6 

#c#i#i4 ,! SAME RULE :I* AT FIR/ SI<T APPE>S TO PROMISE ! PO9T ( CO9CID5CE REQUIR$1 & :I* 9 SOME CASES LEADS TO V]Y DESIRABLE RESULTS1 FURNI%ES1 BY A DIFF]5T APPLICATION1 ! EXCUSE OR W>RANT = ! D5IAL ( ALL RI<TS ( PROP]TY1 W\LD /OP ALL /IMULUS TO 9DU/RY1 =ESI<T1 & ECONOMY1 &1 :I* FOLL[$ \T1 W\LD LEAD TO UNIV]SAL CONFUSION1 POV]TY1 />VATION1 & VIOL5CE4 

#d4 ,! ANCI5TS1 C5TURIES AGO1 SAW ?IS 9H]5T DEFECT 9 ALL V]BAL LAWS & =MULAS1 & CAME TO ! CONCLUSION ?AT NONE C\LD BE CON/RUCT$ BY MAN ?AT C\LD REGULATE HUMAN 9T]C\RSE2 & !Y AB&ON$ ! ATTEMPT TO CON/RUCT !M1 & VE/$ ALL P[] 9 ONE P]SON )9 EA* C]TA9 DI/RICT ( C\NTRY CALL$ A NATION1 :I* WAS A RETURN TO PRIMITIVE DES1 POTISM4 

#d#a4 ,A P]SON WAS ?\<T TO BE ! 0 ,UNIT0 ( CO9CID5CE AS WELL AS ! ,9DIVIDUAL LEAD REQUIR$2 :I*1 BE+ A LIV+ ORGANISM1 C\LD ADAPT ITSELF TO ! PECULI>ITIES 7OR 9DIVIDUALITIES7 ( P]SONS & EV5TS AS EA* CASE >OSE3 BUT IT WAS SOON SE5 ?AT ?IS 0 UNIT 0 WAS ONE DAY ONE ?+1 & ANO!R ?+ ANO!R DAY--?AT ! V]Y POSSESSION ( ! DELEGAT$ P[] SO 9TOXICAT$ OR BEWILD]$ ! DESPOT 7?\< BE=E A V]Y GOOD P]SON71 AS TO PROCURE = HIM ! TITLES ( 0 ,! MON/]10 0 ,! CRUEL10 0 ,! MAD10 ,! SC\RGE10 ETC4 

#d#b4 ,TO REM$Y !SE LONG-SUFF]$ EVILS1 ! ORIG9ATORS ( ! ,CA?OLIC ,*UR*1 ALSO SEE+ ! HOPELESSNESS ( CON/RUCT+ ANY SUCCESSFUL =MULAS1 LAWS1 OR CON/ITUTIONS1 ADOPT$ ! HUMAN 0UNIT0 NOT ONLY AS A LEAD1 BUT AS A F9AL1 DECID+1 SOV]EIGN P[] OR 0 UMPIRE ( PEACE10 OV] ALL P]SONS )9 !IR ORGANIZATION1 & BEYOND :I* UMPIRE !RE WAS TO BE NO APPEAL1 NO DISPUTE2 -VIEW+ HIM AS A FA!R1 PAPA1 OR POPE1 & 9VE/+ HIM ) ! P[] TO RESCUE ! SMITT5 & ABUS$ SUBJECTS ( ! 9TOXICAT$ DESPOTS FROM OB$I5CE & FROM ! OA? ( LOYALTY1 & TO PROTECT !M FROM 9SANE VIOL5CE2 &1 TO SECURE !MSELVES FROM SIMIL> VIOL5CE & OPPRESSION1 !Y SELECT$ A MAN = ! ,PAPA :OM !Y CONSID]$ MORE ?AN MAN - ONE :O WAS 9SPIR$ BY ,DIV9E 9FLUX1 & !Y SEEM TO HAVE SUPPOS$ ?AT ?IS DIV9E 9FLUX CAME FROM A P]SONAL EXI/5CE :I* WAS ALL P]FECTION1 & :O W\LD ALWAYS 9SPIRE ! PAPA TO DO EXACTLY RI<T4 

#d#c4 ,H]E WAS ! PO9T ( FAILURE4 ,!RE IS NO CO9CID5CE BETWE5 M5 AS TO :AT CON/ITUTES P]FECTION1 & ?\< IT N[ APPE>S ?AT ! IDEA ( AN 9FLUX OR 9SPIRATION FROM 9TELLIG5T BE+S1 ABOVE OR BEYOND OR \TSIDE ( ! HUMAN ORGANISM1 WAS A TRUE ONE1 IT SEEMS NOT TO HAVE BE5 CLE>LY UND]/OOD4 

#d#d4 ,IT APPE>S ?AT ! 9FLUX CAME FROM BE+S ONCE HUMAN1 BUT 9 A SECOND /AGE ( EXI/5CE1 ANALOG\S TO ?AT ( ! BUTT]FLY FROM ! GRUB 7N[ CALL$ SPIRITUAL EXI/5CE74 ,?AT 9 ?IS /ATE !RE IS NO SUDD5 LEAP TO P]FECTION1 & ?AT MANY SPIRITUAL 9SPIRATIONS OR COMMUNICATIONS TO US >E NO NE>] TO CO9CID5CE ?AN \R [N OP9IONS & !ORIES >E4 ,&1 MOREOV]1 ?AT ! MO/ HUMBLE1 EV5 *ILDR51 >E MORE LIKELY TO BECOME RECIPI5TS ( ?IS 9SPIRATION ?AN A MAN OR M5 SET AP>T = ! PURPOSE1 BECAUSE1 BE+ LESS EMB>RASS$ BY C>ES & ANXIETIES1 !Y >E MORE 9 ?AT /ATE ( REPOSE REQUIR$ AS A CONDITION NECESS>Y = ! 9FLUX OR COMMUNICATIONS4 

#d#e4 ,?IS WAS PROBABLY SOON KN[N TO ! 9TELLIG5T PORTIONS ( ! PRIE/HOOD & LAITY2 BUT SU* W]E ! EXCE$+ DIFFICULTIES ( !IR UND]TAK+1 & ! CRUDITY ( ! PEOPLE !Y DESIR$ TO B5EFIT1 & ! IMM5SE & 9CALCULABLE GOOD PROMIS$ TO ! RACE BY ! ABOLITION ( W>S & A UNIV]SAL PO9T ( 0 UNITY 0 OR CO9CID5CE1 !IR :OLE AIM SEEMS TO HAVE BE5 TO ATTA9 ?IS 5D1 EV5 BY MEANS ?AT %OCK US TO ?9K (1 ON ! GR\ND ?AT SU* MEANS W]E ! LEA/ ( EVILS PRES5T$ TO !M FROM :I* TO *OOSE4 

#d#f4 ,HUMANITY IS TO-DAY )\T AN UMPIRE - )\T A PR9CIPLE - )\T AN IDEA - )\T A POLICY - )\T A LEAD ?AT CAN COMM& ! ASS5T ( ANY CONSID]ABLE NUMB] ( 9TELLIG5T M5 OR WOM51 OR EV5 ! G5]AL ASS5T ( ! UNCULTIVAT$ & C>ELESS2 BUT ALL SOCIETY 7SO- CALL$7 IS EXPOS$1 UNPREP>$1 UNASSI/$1 & ,UNDEF5D$1 TO ! M]E SPIRIT ( RECKLESS ADV5TURE1 CORRUPTION1 QUACK]Y1 & DESP]ATION4 

#d#g4 ,A PO9T ( UNIV]SAL CO9CID5CE & COOP]ATION :I* W\LD NATURALLY LEAD ! RACE \T ( ITS *AOS1 IS ,D,[1 MORE ?AN EV] BE=E1 ! GREAT CONSID]ATION4 

#d#h4 ,IF IT IS ! WORK ( MAN1 IT CAN BE OV]?R[N BY MAN1 & W\LD1 !RE=E1 BE LIABLE TO DISAPPO9T OR RU9 ALL :O MI<T BUILD UPON IT4 ,IT MU/ BE 9DE/RUCTIBLE1 OR IT W\LD BE DE/ROY$4 ,IT MU/ BE AN ,9DIVIDUALITY1 OR IT CANNOT LEAD1 EXCEPT 9TO CONFUSION4 ,IT MU/ BE AN 9DIVIDUAL IDEA 7NOT A PLURALITY7 ?AT1 NOT)/&+ ! 9F9ITE DIV]SITY ( M9DS1 MOTIVES1 & CONDITIONS1 IT WILL BE SURE TO CO9CIDE ) ! 9/9CTIVE ACTION AS WELL AS ) ! NATURAL UND]/&+ ( ALL PEOPLE4 ,IS NOT ! GREAT FACT ( ,S,E,L,F,S,O,V,],E,I,G,N,T,Y SU* A UNIT8 

#d#i4 ,EV5 ! D5IAL ( IT ILLU/RATES & CONFIRMS IT4 

#d#a4 ,OPPOSITION TO IT IS AS H>MLESS AS W\LD BE ! PELT+ A BEGG> ) GOLD6 ,DISS5T ITSELF NOT BE+ ANTAGONI/IC1 BUT CO9CID+ ) IT1 :O CAN AVOID BE+ 9 H>MONY ) IT PRACTICALLY1 :ATEV] HE MAY BE !ORETICALLY 8 

#d#a#a4 ,H]E1 !N1 WE HAVE A H>MONIC W>RANT = ,F,R,E,$,O,M ,T,O ,D,I,F,F,] - A PO9T NEV] O!RWISE ATTA9$ 9 HUMAN4 AFFAIRS6 

#d#a#b4 ,H]E WE HAVE ! 0 UMPIRE ( PEACE10 ! 0 LA/ APPEAL10 ! 0 5D ( DI/URB+ DISPUTES 06 

#d#a#c4 ,I MAY HAVE A NEI<BOR :O IS AN OLD L9E ,PRESBYT]IAN1 & :O GOES EV]Y ,SUNDAY TO HE> :AT ,I CONSID] DE/RUCTIVE !ORIES2 BUT1 HOLD+ HIS SOV]EIGNTY AS SACR$1 ,I (F] NO OB/ACLE O!R ?AN ACCEPTABLE C\NSEL4 ,IF ,I HAVE ANY?+ 9 HIS WAY1 ,I WILL HA/5 TO TAKE IT \T ( ! WAY4 ,MY PUBLIC DUTY T[>DS ! ,CA?OLIC & EV]Y O!R P]SUASION IS ! SAME4 ,I HAVE NO ISSUE ) EI!R TILL AN ATTEMPT IS MADE TO 5=CE ASS5T OR CON=MITY FROM ME OR O!RS4 ,& MY DUTY T[>DS ALL POLITICAL CRE$S & !ORIES IS PRECISELY ! SAME4 ,!Y >E ALL 5TITL$ TO =BE>ANCE TILL SOME ATTEMPT IS MADE TO 5=CE !M ON ! UNWILL+4 ,?IS ATTEMPT IS AN 5CROA*M5T UPON ! GREAT SACR$ RI<T ( SELF-SOV]EIGNTY - AN ATTACK UPON ! ,DIV9E LAW ( ,9DIVIDUALITY1 & WILL ALWAYS BEGET RESI/ANCE & W>4 

#d#a#d4 ,I DO ,DOT EXPECT V]Y EXT5SIVE1 IMM$IATE CO9CID5CE 9 !SE CONCLUSIONS BUT :ILE ! ABSOLUTE SOV]EIGNTY ( EV]Y ONE 7)9 HIS [N SPH]E7 IS SACR$LY RESPECT$1 !RE WILL BE NO S]I\S COLLISION ON ?IS PO9T4 

#d#a#e4 ,F,R,E,$,O,M ,T,O ,D,I,F,F,]4 ,FRE$OM = Y\ TO DO 7AT Y\R [N CO/ OR )9 Y\R [N SPH]E7 :AT ,I MAY CONSID] WRONG1 FOOLI%1 OR 9EXP$I5T1 IS ! VITAL PR9CIPLE ( PEACE & ALL PROGRESS2 = Y\R EXP]IM5TS MAY PROVE ?AT Y\ >E RI<T6 

#d#a#f4 ,! 0,RE=MATION WAS BAS$ UPON ?IS GREAT IDEA1 BUT ! ,RE=MATION WILL NOT BE COMPLETE TILL IT IS CLE>LY UND]/OOD ?AT EA* & EV]Y P]SON IS NECESS>ILY 9VE/$ ) AN ,9DIVIDUALITY ( HIS OR H] [N1 ?AT1 LIKE ! C\NT5ANCE ( ITS POSSESSOR1 IS 0 94 ALI5ABLE 2 0 & !RE=E ?AT WE CANNOT BUILD !ORIES REQUIR+ & DEP5D+ ON CON=MITY OR UNI=MITY ( REASON+1 )\T CON/ANT LIABILITY TO CONFLICT1 CONFUSION1 & DISAPPO9TM5T4 

#d#a#g4 ,= TRUE ORD] & PROGRESS WE MU/ PRES]VE AT ALL TIMES & 9 ALL ?+S ,F,R,E,$,O,M ,T,O ,D,I,F,F,] 9 WORD & 9 ACT1 & ?US APPROA* COOP]ATION BY DEGREES 9/EAD ( BY ANY VIOL5T OR SUDD5 LEAP4 

#d#a#h4 ,NO MATT] H[ P]V]SE ANY ONE MAY BE1 HE NEV] CAN GET \TSIDE ( ! PROP5SITY TO HAVE HIS [N WAY4 

#d#a#i4 ,?IS PO9T ( CO9CID5CE ONCE UNIV]SALLY UND]/OOD1 !RE CAN BE NO \TSID]S1 NO =EIGN]S1 NO HO/ILE TRIBES OR ,CLANS1 NO POLITICAL P>TY1 EXCEPT 0 ! P>TY ( ! :OLE0 6 

#d#b4 ,! F\NDATION = UNIV]SAL COOP]ATION IS N[ !ORETICALLY LAID4 ,9 ORD] TO PRES]VE H>MONY 9 PROGRESS1 !RE MU/ BE FRE$OM TO DIFF] 9 ALL ?+S :]E DIFF]5CE IS POSSIBLE4 

#d#b#a4 ,!RE=E LET US AVOID ALL COMMITM5TS TO ANY?+ LIKE :AT >E COMMONLY CALL$ ORGANIZATIONS LEAD+ TO ,CLAN%IP4 ,\R ORGANIZATION WILL NOT CONSI/ ( SUBORD9AT+"9 RULES OR ANY O!R EXT]NAL =MULAS BUT WILL EXI/ 9 ! UND]/&+1 9T]NALLY1 9 FACT & 9 SPIRIT1 :ILE ! EXT]NAL WILL CONSI/ ( SIMPLY ,CORRESPOND5CE OR ,C,O,M,M,U,N,I,C,A,T,I,O,N ) EA* O!R1 & ?AT :I* NATURALLY & SPONTANE\SLY FL[S FROM IT4 

#d#b#b4 ,HAV+ SUBMITT$ \R PO9T ( CO9CID5CE TO ! LA/ & SEV]E/ TE/S1 & F\ND IT ONLY CONFIRM$ AS A SUBLIME TRU?1 WE WILL BEG9 TO CLU/] >\ND IT O!R TRU?S TO AID ?AT & EA* O!R 9 ! COMPLETE SOLUTION ( ! PROBLEM ( TRUE CIVILIZATION4 

#d#b#c4 ,WE BR+1 !N1 ! PR9CIPLE ( ,EQUIVAL5TS ) ITS BEAUTIFULLY B5EFIC5T P[] TO H>MONIZE \R PECUNI>Y 9T]E/S- TO NEUTRALIZE ! DE/RUCTIVE P[] ( UNREGULAT$ COMPETITION - TO MAKE ! 9T]E/S ( ! 9DIVIDUAL H>MONIZE ) ! 9T]E/S ( ! PUBLIC4 

#a#a4 #d#b#d4 ,WE WILL BR+ \R ,EQUITABLE MONEY 9TO COMPETITION ) COMMON MONEY1 :I* WILL EQUALIZE P[] 9 ! PECUNI>Y SPH]E4 ,SELF-SOV]EIGNTY 9 ALL DEP>TM5TS1 ESPECIALLY 9 ! MILIT>Y1 WILL EQUALIZE & RE/ORE BACK TO EA* 9DIVIDUAL HIS LEGITIMATE %>E ( ! GOV]N+ P[]1 & 7TO ! M9D'S EYE7 ,EQUILIBRIUM BEG9S TO EM]GE FROM *AOS4 

#d#b#d4 ,WE WILL BR+ \R ,EQUITABLE MONEY 9TO COMPETITION ) COMMON MONEY1 :I* WILL EQUALIZE P[] 9 ! PECUNI>Y SPH]E4 ,SELF-SOV]EIGNTY 9 ALL DEP>TM5TS1 ESPECIALLY 9 ! MILIT>Y1 WILL EQUALIZE & RE/ORE BACK TO EA* 9DIVIDUAL HIS LEGITIMATE %>E ( ! GOV]N+ P[]1 & 7TO ! M9D'S EYE7 ,EQUILIBRIUM BEG9S TO EM]GE FROM *AOS4 

#d#b#e4 ,! GREAT ELEM5TS ( DISCORD & REPULSION BE+ )DRAWN OR NEUTRALIZ$1 & EV]Y NEW CLU/]+ TRU? BECOM+ A NEW H>MONIZ]1 ! LONG-/IFL$ YE>N+S = SYMPA?Y ) \R K9D WILL BEG9 TO EXP&1 & ! DANG] IS ?AT WE MAY RU% TOGE!R 9TO DISA/R\S 5TANGLEM5TS1 UNLESS PRES]V$ BY CON/ANT1 WAT*FUL REG>D TO ! FATAL ]RORS ( ,CLAN%IP & ,COMMUNISM4 

#d#b#f4 ,AS ALL UNMIX$ OR PURE TRU?S H>MONIZE ) EA* O!R1 ALL M9DS FILL$ ) !SE ONLY WILL NECESS>ILY H>MONIZE2 & EXPECTATIONS F\ND$ ON !M WILL NOT BE LIKELY TO 5D 9 DISAPPO9TM5T4 

#d#b#g4 ,! CO9CID5CE OR H>MONY ( ,NATIONS WILL NECESS>ILY >ISE FROM ?AT ( ,9DIVIDUALS4 

#d#b#h4 ,! SOV]EIGNTY ( EV]Y ,9DIVIDUAL 9 HIS OR H] [N SPH]E1 PLACES ALL MANK9D UPON ! ONLY POSSIBLE PLANE ( POLITICAL ,EQUALITY4 ,ALL BE+ SOV]EIGNS1 NONE CAN BE LESS1 NONE MORE4 ,?IS IS BEAUTIFULLY ILLU/RAT$ AT EV]Y ASSEMBLY ( K+S & EMP]ORS4 ,EA* ONE IS ADMITT$ BY ALL ! O!RS TO BE SUPREME )9 HIS [N SPH]E ( JURISDICTION4 ,! SUPREMACY ( EA* CON/ITUTES ! EQUALITY ( ALL1 :ILE ANY?+ LESS ?AN ! SUPREMACY ( EI!R W\LD CON/ITUTE SO MU* POLITICAL 9EQUALITY BETWE5 !M1 & ANY ATTEMPT ( EI!R1 OR ( ! MAJORITY1 TO SUBORD9ATE ANY ONE ( !M1 W\LD AT ONCE BECOME AN ELEM5T ( W>4 

#d#b#i4 -,NO NATION OR TRIBE CAN1 )\T DIRECT VIOLATION ( ?IS GREAT REGULAT+ PR9CIPLE1 DICTATE LAWS OR POLICIES TO ANY O!R1 NOR ATTEMPT TO 9VADE OR SUBDUE OR PLUND] A S+LE 9DIVIDUAL ( ! RACE4 

#d#c4 ,C\NSELS1 ADVICE1 DELIB]ATION1 COMMUNICATION1 ,EQUITABLE COMM]CIAL EX*ANGES MAY AT ONCE COMM5CE1 & =EV] CONT9UE TO 9CREASE1 MUTUALLY 5RI*+ & BLESS+ EA* O!R1 - )\T DO+ VIOL5CE TO ANY CLASS1 P>TY1 OR P]SON4 

#d#c#a4 ,H]E >E ! MEANS ( H>MONIZ+ ! NATIONS6 ,9/EAD ( MUTUAL DE/RUCTION FROM ! WILD PROMPT+S ( UNREGULAT$ 9/9CT1 WE %ALL HAVE MUTUAL PROTECTION1 PROMPT$ BY AN 5LI<T5$ & REGULAT$ SELF- 9T]E/1 H>MONIZ+ ) UNIV]SAL 9T]E/1 & GIV+ RISE TO UNIV]SAL SYMPA?Y4 ,! !ME EXP&S UND] \R GAZE1 BUT ) SU* DAZZL+ SPL5DOR ?AT ! UNACCU/OM$ EYE CANNOT DWELL UPON IT4 

"9 ,?OSE RULES1 LAWS1 OR 9/ITUTIONS1 :I* DEM& OB$I5CE AGA9/ ! 9CL9ATION ( ! SUBJECT1 SUBORD9ATE OR 5?RALL$ MAN2 :ILE ?OSE RULES1 LAWS1 OR 9/ITUTIONS TO :I* CON=MITY IS UND]/&+LY & *E]FULLY R5D]$1 MAY BE SAID TO BE SUBORD9ATE TO MAN1 & ) !M1 MAN IS FREE4 ,9 PRES5T CIVILIZATION 9/ITUTIONS >E ABOVE M52 9 TRUE CIVILIZATION MAN WILL BE NOT UND] BUT )9 9/ITUTIONS OR ABOVE 9/ITUTIONS4 

O ,CONCLUSION 
,TRUE ,CIVILIZATION4 

  
,W>R51 ,JOSIAH 

  
7#a#h#f#c7 ,BO/ON1 ,MASS4 

  
,CONCLUSION4 

  

#d#c#b4 ,H,A,V,+ GIV5 ! SUB/ANCE ( \R PROGRAM ( TRUE CIVILIZATION1 WE LEAVE IT = ! PRES5T TO BE DIGE/$ ) ! ASSI/ANCE ( A FEW DESULTORY REM>KS4 

#d#c#c4 ,! 9SI/+ ON ,DIS9TEGRATION1 AS A FIR/ /EP 9 TRUE ORD]1 MAY REQUIRE MORE ILLU/RATION ?AN SU* AS HAS BE5 FURNI%$1 & ! PO9T IS TOO VITAL TO LEAVE UNSETTL$4 ,O!R IMPORTANT PO9TS MAY ALSO REQUIRE CONFIRMATION4 

#d#c#d4 ,:5 A MULTITUDE ( PAP]S1 LETT]S1 ETC41 LAY UPON \R TABLE 9 CONFUSION1 :AT PR9CIPLE DO WE 9VOLUNT>ILY RESORT TO TO PUT !M 9 ORD]8 ,DO WE NOT SEP>ATE !M - PUTT+ ! UNANSW]$ LETT]S 9 ONE PLACE1 & ?OSE ?AT HAVE BE5 ANSW]$ 9 V>I\S1 DIFF]5T1 SEP>ATE1 DIS9TEGRAT$ CLASSIFICATION8 ,DO WE NOT DIS9TEGRATE ALL ! NEWSPAP]S1 PUTT+ ALL ( ! SAME K9D 9 ONE PILE1 & O!RS 9 O!R PILES1 SEP>ATE FROM EA* O!R8 

#d#c#e4 ,AT A PUBLIC MEET+ MANY PEOPLE WANT TO SPEAK1 BUT ALL ADMIT ?AT !Y MU/ NOT ALL SPEAK AT ONCE1 BUT 9 A DIS9TEGRAT$ OR SEP>ATE ORD]1 ONE AT A TIME4 

#d#c#f4 ,IF Y\ & ,I [N A H\SE TOGE!R1 & Y\ WANT TO SELL IT1 & ,I DO NOT1 :AT CAN WE DO BETT] ?AN DIS9TEGRATE \R 9T]E/S 9 IT BY ONE BUY+ ! O!R \T SATISFACTORILY8 ,ON ! SIDEWALKS 9 POPUL\S CITIES1 :5 MANY PEOPLE >E GO+ 9 OPPOSITE DIRECTIONS1 !RE IS SE5 ONE CURR5T GO+ ONE WAY & ANO!R GO+ 9 ! OPPOSITE WAY1 BO? ON ! SAME SIDEWALK1 QUITE DI/9CT & SEP>ATE FROM EA* O!R1 & CONSEQU5TLY )\T CONFUSION4 

#d#c#g4 ,A MAN UNAVOIDABLY =MS A DISAGREEABLE ACQUA9TANCE1 ALTOGE!R UNCONG5IAL & UNPR(ITABLE TO EI!R1 OR TO ANYBODY2 TO DROP ! ACQUA9TANCE1 TO DIS9TEGRATE1 IS ! COMMON PRACTICE1 & P]HAPS ! BE/ EXP$I5T4 

#d#c#h4 ,SUBLIME & HOLY AS ! RI<T ( SELF-SOV]EIGNTY IS 9 ALL ITS PRACTICAL BE>+S1 AS A REGULATOR ( HUMAN 9T]C\RSE1 IT CANNOT BE EX]CIS$1 EXCEPT SO F> AS EA* ONE'S PROP]TY1 RESPONSIBILITIES1 & P]SON >E SO F> SEP>ATE FROM O!RS ?AT HE CAN EX]CISE HIS LEGITIMATE CONTROL OV] HIS [N )\T DI/URB+ !M4 ,MANY ( ! MO/ HUMANE & BE/ CITIZ5S ( ! ,AM]ICAN ,/ATES HAVE /RUGGL$ = YE>S AGA9/ BE+ RESPONSIBLE = ! COMMUNI/IC LEGISLATION 9 FAVOR ( 5SLAV+ RESPONSIBILITIES FROM ! G5]AL CONGLOM]ATION4 

#d#c#i4 ,IT HAS PASS$ 9TO AN AXIOM ! ,CORPORATIONS HAVE NO S\LS1 ?AT IS1 NO RESPONSIBILITY1 = !RE IS NO RESPONSIBILITY TILL IT BECOMES ,9DIVIDUAL1 DIS9TEGRAT$ FROM COMMUNISM4 

#d#d4 ,AFT] PEOPLE HAVE OV]LOOK$ OR DISREG>D$ ! GREAT LAW ( ORD] & H>MONY1 & 5TANGL$ !MSELVES & !IR 9T]E/S TOGE!R1 & CANNOT AGREE1 & :5 !Y HAVE EXHAU/$ ALL !IR >GUM5TS & EXP$I5TS )\T >RIV+ AT CO9CID5CE1 :AT DO !Y NATURALLY & HABITUALLY RESORT TO TO AVOID FUR!R DI/URBANCES OR VIOL5CE8 

#d#d#a4 ,DIS9TEGRATION IS NECESS>Y ONLY AFT] ! GREAT ,DIV9E LAW ( ORD] HAS BE5 VIOLAT$ BY OBLIT]AT+ ! L9ES ( LEGITIMATE ,9DIVIDUAL JURISDICTION1 BY A CONGLOM]ATION ( 9T]E/S OR 05TANGL+ ALLIANCES40 

#d#d#b4 ,APP>5TLY IMPOSSIBLE SOLUTIONS >E (T5 F\ND BY MEANS SO SIMPLE & SELF-EVID5T AS TO MORTIFY US AT \R OBTUS5ESS4 

#d#d#c4 ,A MAN ONCE ASK$ ME IF ,I KNEW H[ TO 0MEASURE ! WOOD 9 A BUNDLE ( BRU%80 ,I ADMITT$ ?AT ,I ?\<T IT WAS IMPOSSIBLE4 0,WELL10 SAID HE1 0P>TLY FILL A B>REL ) WAT]1 MEASURE ITS DEP?1 PUT 9 ! BRU%1 MEASURE ! DEP? AGA91 & CALCULATE ! DIFF]5CE40 

#d#d#d4 ,A MULTITUDE ( QUE/IONS WILL >ISE 9 M9DS TO :I* !SE SUBJECTS >E COMP>ATIVELY NEW2 SOME ( !M MAY BE ANTICIPAT$4 ,A SIMPLE RIDDLE MAY PREP>E MANY TO ANSW] !IR [N QUE/IONS BETT] ?AN ANY ONE CAN DO IT = !M4 ,! RIDDLE IS1 - 
0,I'M MADE AT ,CANT]BURY & SOLD AT ,YORK1 ,I /OP A BOTTLE & AM CALL$ A 'CORK'40 

#d#d#e4 ,! :OLE IS SO PLA9LY TOLD1 & IS SO SELF-EVID5T1 IT PUZZLES4 ,I ONCE GAVE ?IS RIDDLE TO A LADY 9 PRES5CE ( H] *ILD4 ,%E C\LD NOT SOLVE IT1 & GAVE IT UP1 :5 ! *ILD EXCLAIM$1 0,:Y LA1 MO!R1 IT IS A CORK6 ,DON'T HE SAY IT IS A CORK80 

#d#d#f4 0,:AT10 SAYS ONE1 0IS EV]Y ,9DIVIDUAL TO RAISE HIMSELF UP 9 HIS SOV]EIGNTY ABOVE ALL LAW & ORD] - OBEY :AT PLEASES HIM1 & REJECT OR REBEL AGA9/ :AT DOES NOT PLEASE HIM80 

#d#d#g4 ,IS ALL TO BE LEFT TO ! SPONTANE\S :IM ( ! MOM5T OR \R PRES5T IMPULSES1 )\T ANY REF]5CE TO ! FUTURE8 ,IS EV]Y?+ TO BE SACRIFIC$ TO A WILD *ASE AFT] A DI/ORT$ FRE$OM1 ! VALUE ( :I* :5 OV]TAK5 MAY NOT EQUAL ! CO/ ( PURSUIT8 ,>E WE TO HAVE NO CONTRACTS1 NO ORD]1 NO SY/EM1 NO?+ AS A BASIS = EXPECTATIONS1 NO?+ TO DEP5D UPON8 

#d#d#h4 ,YES1 WE WILL HAVE ORD]1 SY/EM1 & CONTRACTS ?AT WILL NOT DISAPPO9T US4 

#d#d#i4 ,) REG>D TO SELF-SOV]EIGNTY RAIS+ US ABOVE LAW1 IT IT IS ITSELF ! GREAT ,DIV9E LAW ( ORD] :I* NO ONE CAN RAISE HIMSELF ABOVE4 ,Y\R [N QUE/IONS %[ Y\ TO BE EX]CIS+ ?IS SOV]EIGNTY 9 CRITICIZ+ :AT IS PROPOS$6 ! ACT ( JUDG+ A LAW OR /ATUTE RAISES ! CRITIC ABOVE ?AT LAW OR /ATUTE4 ,TO BE UND] LAW IS TO HAVE NO OP9ION1 BUT ONLY ! DUTY ( OB$I5CE TO IT4 ,CRITICISM1 ?\<T1 JUDGM5T1 RAISES US ABOVE ! ?+ CRITICIZ$ OR JUDG$4 ,ALL ! PEOPLE 9 !SE ,/ATES >E AT ?IS MOM5T ABOVE ALL ! 5ACTM5TS ( ! ,GOV]NM5T AT ,WA%+TON4 ,BUT WE NEV] CAN GET ABOVE PRIMITIVE OR ,DIV9E LAW4 ,IT PROMPTS US TO JUDGE1 & WE OBEY IT 9 JUDG+ EV]Y?+6 - EV5 9 JUDG+ ITSELF6 

#d#e4 ,) REG>DS TO SY/EM1 IT NATURALLY & H>MONI\SLY LEADS TO ! MO/ P]FECT SY/EM ( SOCIAL LIFE ?AT IT IS POSSIBLE TO CONCEIVE4 

#d#e#a4 ,! ASS]TION H]E IS1 ?AT ! TRUE LAW ( ORD] HAS BE5 0REJECT$ BY ! BUILD]S10 & ! LAW ( CONFUSION MI/AK+LY PREF]R$6 0,UNION0 ( 9T]E/S IS ?IS ROOT ( CONFUSION1 & DIS9TEGRATION IS A NECESS>Y /EP BACK T[>DS 9DIVIDUALITY :I* IS ! GREAT ,DIV9E LAW ( ORD] EV]Y:]E4 ,:]E OR :AT W\LD ! OBJECTOR BE IF HE WAS NOT FREE TO CRITICIZE !SE /ATEM5TS8 ,SIMPLY A SLAVE4 ,OBJECT+ TO !M1 HE IS EX]CIS+ ! V]Y SOV]EIGNTY TO :I* HE OBJECTS6 ,REMEMB] ! RIDDLE4 

#d#e#b4 ,WE WILL HAVE SY/EMS ADAPT$ TO ! DEM&S = !M4 ,! ME*ANIC 9 HIS %OP1 OR ! *EMI/ 9 HIS LABORATORY1 :O HAS NO P>TN] TO CONSULT1 CAN >RANGE HIS TOOLS OR HIS MAT]IALS 9 ANY MANN] :ATEV] ?AT HE PLEASES1 & CAN *ANGE HIS SY/EM ANY TIME HE PLEASES4 ,HE IS ?US ABOVE OR SOV]EIGN ( HIS SY/EM1 BUT IF HE HAS A P>TN]1 HE MU/ CONSULT ?AT P>TN]'S WI%ES1 & IF !Y HAPP5 NOT TO CO9CIDE1 NEI!R ( !M CAN EX]CISE ?IS 9DIVIDUALITY )\T VIOLAT+ ! 9DIVIDUALITY ( ! O!R4 ,IF HE HAS ?REE P>TN]S HE MU/ CONSULT ! WI%ES ( ALL1 & ! *ANCES ( AGREEM5T >E DIM9I%$ BY EV]Y ADDITIONAL P>TN] TO ! COMMUNI/IC 9T]E/ OR 0,UNION10 & BY ! MAGNITUDE & IMPORTANCE ( ! 9T]E/S HELD 9 COMMON2 & !RE MAY BE SO MANY P>TN]S ?AT !RE CANNOT BE F\ND PO9TS ( CO9CID5CE 5\< TO F\ND ANY SY/EM UPON4 ,TRUE ORD] & SY/EM >E F\ND ONLY )9 ! 9DIVIDUAL SPH]E1 OR 9 PROPORTION TO ! CO9CID5CES BETWE5 DIFF]5T P>TIES4 

#d#e#c4 ,WE WILL HAVE CONTRACTS1 >RANGEM5TS1 & APPO9TM5TS1 BUT WE WILL HAVE !M ONLY :]E !Y >E WANT$1 & UND]/&+LY CONS5T$ TO BY ! P]SONS 9VOLV$ 9 !M4 

#d#e#d4 ,WE WILL NOT MAKE SU* AS MAY PROVE IMPOSSIBLE ( FULFILLM5T1 )\T PROVID+ = SU* CONT+5CY4 

#d#e#e4 ,\R CONTRACTS WILL NOT BE ,%YLOCK CONTRACTS1 TO BE FULFILL$ TO ! LETT] 79/EAD ( ! SPIRIT71 ?\< !Y TAKE ! P\ND ( FLE% FROM ! HE>T4 

#d#e#f4 ,WE WILL NOT MAKE MAN = CONTRACTS1 BUT CONTRACTS = ! B5EFIT ( ?OSE :O MAKE !M4 ,A CONTRACT :I* CAN BE =ESE5 TO BE CONTR>Y TO DIV9E LAW1 & MAY PROVE IMPOSSIBLE ( FULFILLM5T1 IS NULL & VOID4 ,A CONTRACT BY A *ILD TO GR[ TW5TY FEET HI< IS NULL & VOID4 

#d#e#g4 ,A CONTRACT :I* IS NOT UND]/OOD ALIKE BY ! P>TIES TO IT 7SU* AS ALL WRITT5 CON/ITUTIONS71 IS NULL & VOID1 BECAUSE !Y HAVE NOT CONS5T$ TO ! SAME ?+4 

#d#e#h4 ,A CONTRACT :I*1 AT ! TIME ( MAK+ IT1 ALL ! P>TIES 9T5D TO FULFILL1 MAY BE BROK5 BY UN=ESE5 EV5TS1 OV] :I* NEI!R ( ! P>TIES C\LD HAVE ANY CONTROL4 ,! MAN ?AT AB&ON$ ! LIFT+ ( ! TIMB] TO SAVE ?IS FAMILY1 BROKE HIS CONTRACT1 :I*1 BUT = ?AT ACCID5T1 HE W\LD HAVE FULFILL$4 ,! SUDD5 AB&ONM5T ( ! TIMB] MI<T HAVE BE5 ( S]I\S CONSEQU5CE TO ! O!R P>TIES :O W]E LIFT+ IT4 ,W\LD IT NOT HAVE BE5 WELL = ! LEAD] TO HAVE A MAN OR TWO 9 RES]VE TO MEET SU* CONT+5CIES8 ,BUT !Y W]E NOT ?\<T (4 ,:AT IS TO BE DONE ) ! CASE AS A VIOLATION ( CONTRACT8 ,DOES IT NOT =CE US TO ADMIT ?AT !Y >E1 (T5 UNAVOIDABLY1 IMP]FECT DEVICES1 LIKE \R [N /RUCTURE1 & ?AT !IR DEFECTS HAVE TO BE BORNE1 LIKE ! TOO?A*E1 AS MIS=TUNES1 & ?AT TO 9SI/ ON ! ABSOLUTE P]FECTION & SACR$NESS ( ALL CONTRACTS IS AN ]ROR8 

#d#e#i4 ,IS EV]Y ONE1 !N1 TO BE P]FECTLY FREE TO 5T] 9TO ANY CONTRACT1 & EXTRACT FROM IT :ATEV] SUITS HIM1 & !N AB&ON IT1 & DISAPPO9T ! O!R P>TIES TO IT1 ON ! PLEA ( UN=ESE5 CONT+5CIES8 

#d#f4 ,NO4 ,I MAY PROMISE TO PAY Y\ TW5TY DOLL>S TOMORR[ NI<T1 AT SIX O'CLOCK2 Y\ HAVE NO MEANS ( JUDG+ ( MY RES\RCES2 !RE IS BUT LITTLE )9 \R EXP]I5CE TO =BID ! EXPECTATION ( ! MONEY1 :5 IT IS KN[N ?AT IT IS = MY [N 9T]E/ TO FULFILL ! CONTRACT4 ,AS ,I ALONE KN[ MY [N RES\RCES1 ,I TAKE ! :OLE RESPONSIBILITY ( ! PROMISE4 ,TO-MORR[ AFT]NOON ,I LOSE ALL MY MONEY BY BE+ TEMPT$ 9TO A BAD SPECULATION4 ,I FAIL TO PAY Y\1 & Y\ >E OBLIG$ TO GO TO A USUR] TO BORR[ ! MONEY4 ,Y\ CALL ON ME & /ATE Y\R GRIEVANCE4 ,I SAY ?AT UN=ESE5 CONT+5CIES PREV5T$ ME FROM FULFILL+ MY CONTRACT2 BUT ! EXPLANATION DOES NOT SATISFY Y\1 & ,I REFUSE TO GIVE FUR!R SATISFACTION4 ,:AT NEXT8 ,PRES5T CIVILIZATION FAILS TO GIVE A SATISFACTORY ANSW]4 ,WE MU/ GO F>!R ?AN IT HAS GONE4 

#d#f#a4 ,SUPPOSE Y\ SELECT TWO OR ?REE WELL-BALANC$ M9DS 9 Y\R NEI<BORHOOD TO DELIB]ATE ON ! CASE1 GIV+ ME ! OPPORTUNITY TO REPRES5T MYSELF1 & ) AN 9VITATION = ALL ! PUBLIC TO ATT5D AS LI/5]S4 ,Y\ /ATE Y\R CASE4 ,:AT CAN ,I DO8 ,P]HAPS ,I REFUSE 9 ! FACE ( ALL SELF-EVID5T RECTITUDE TO ABIDE ! DECISION ( ! TRIBUNAL1 - ON ! GR\ND ( MY RI<T ( SELF-SOV]EIGNTY4 ,BUT ! TRIBUNAL DECIDE ?AT ,I HAVE 9DIRECTLY 9VAD$ Y\R SOV]EIGNTY1 & ?AT ,I \<T TO REPAIR DAMAGES2 ?AT ,I HAVE PUT Y\ TO TR\BLE & CO/ = MY CONV5I5CE1 & WANTONLY REFUSE TO MAKE ,EQUITABLE REP>ATION1 :I* IS 9 MY P[]4 ,I /ILL REFUSE4 ,! OP9IONS ( MORE OR LESS ( ! TRIBUNAL >E H&$ OV] TO ! MILIT>Y 7OR 0! ,GOV]NM5T071 & IF !RE IS SUFFICI5T CO9CID5CE !RE TO TAKE 5\< ( MY PROP]TY TO COMP5SATE Y\1 IT WILL BE DONE4 ,:AT W\LD BE COMP5SATION 9 ! CASE8 #a/1 ,:ATEV] IT CO/ Y\ TO BORR[ ! MONEY2 #bD1 COMP5SATION = DISAPPO9TM5T2 #cD1 COMP5SATION = Y\R TIME CONSUM$ 9 GETT+ JUDGM5T FROM ! TRIBUNAL2 #d?1 CONT+5T EXP5SES ( ROOM :]E !Y MET1 & ! CO/S1 IF ANY1 ( ! AID ( ! ,GOV]NM5T OR POLICE4 

#d#f#b4 ,W\LD IT NOT HAVE BE5 MORE PR(ITABLE1 PECUNI>ILY & MORALLY1 = ME TO HAVE FULFILL$ MY PROMISE TO Y\1 OR TO HAVE 5DEAVOR$ TO HAVE GIV5 SATISFACTORY OR EXCUSABLE REASONS = NOT DO+ SO8 

#d#f#c4 0,BUT10 ASKS ANO!R1 0SUPPOSE Y\ HAD COME ACROSS AN OLD CR$ITOR ?AT AFT]NOON1 ?AT WAS JU/ ON ! PO9T ( RU91 & Y\ C\LD SAVE HIM FROM IT BY LETT+ HIM HAVE ! TW5TY DOLL>S4 ,H[ !N80 

#d#f#d4 ,9 ?IS CASE ,I HAVE A *OICE ( EVILS1 & DECIDE1 ON MY [N RESPONSIBILITY1 TO PAY ! =M] DEBT & RUN ! RISK ( SATISFY+ Y\4 

#d#f#e4 ,KN[+ ?AT ,I \<T TO PAY Y\ ALL ! CO/S ( DISAPPO9TM5T1 ,I COME AS E>LY AS POSSIBLE TO Y\1 /ATE ! CIRCUM/ANCES1 & (F] AT ONCE TO PAY ALL ! CO/S ?AT Y\ HAVE 9CURR$ BY MY NON-FULFILLM5T ( CONTRACT4 ,NO TRIBUNAL & NO RESORT TO ! GOV]NM5T W\LD !N BE ?\<T (4 ,BUT !RE IS A BETT] WAY ?AN ANY ( !SE1 :5 ?AT WAY IS POSSIBLE1 & ?AT IS TO 0[E NO MAN ANY?+10 BUT SETTLE EV]Y TRANSACTION 9 ! TIME ( IT4 ,BUT ?IS NOT BE+ ALWAYS PRACTICABLE1 ! EXP$I5T H]E RECOMM5D$ IS TO SETTLE1 AT ! TIME ( ! TRANSACTION1 :AT IS DUE1 & GIVE A NOTE ) CONDITIONS ?AT WILL NOT S]I\SLY DISAPPO9T ANY ONE4 7,SEE 0,EQUITABLE ,MONEY407 ,C>EFUL AS WE MAY BE1 CONTRACTS >E BUT HUMAN DEVICES1 &1 UNAVOIDABLY1 MORE OR LESS IMP]FECT4 

#d#f#f4 ,BE+ UND]/&+LY AM5ABLE TO ! 9JUR$ P>TY = ALL CO/S ( NON-FULFILLM5T ( LEGITIMATE CONTRACTS1 WE %ALL BE C>EFUL H[ WE 5T] 9TO !M1 & EQUALLY C>EFUL TO FULFILL !M4 ,CONTRACTS WILL NOT !N BE ! TYRANTS ( M51 BUT ! S]VANTS ( M54 

#d#f#g4 ,! SMALL] ! NUMB] ( ! P>TIES TO A CONTRACT1 ! MORE PO9TS ( AGREEM5T !RE MAY BE EXPECT$ BETWE5 !M2 ! L>G] ! NUMB]1 ! LESS PO9TS ( CO9CID5CE WILL BE F\ND4 

#d#f#h4 ,A UNIV]SAL ORGANIZATION1 TO 9CLUDE EV]Y P]SON ( ! RACE1 C\LD HAVE NO ASSURANCE ( UNIV]SAL CO9CID5CE1 EXPECT :]E ,D,I,S,S,5,T ,I,T,S,E,L,F ,C,O,N,F,I,R,M,S ,! ,C,O,M,P,A,C,T4 ,SU* IS \R PO9T ( CO9CID5CE6 

#d#f#i4 ,A MAN 9 A MODEL VILLAGE GAVE \T NOTICE ?AT HE W\LD GIVE A C\RSE ( LECTURES TO %[ ! FALLACY ( ! 0SELF-SOV]EIGNTY0 IDEA4 

#d#g4 ,! ADVOCATES ( ?AT IDEA PROVID$ HIM ) A ROOM2 OP5$ & CLOS$ IT = HIM2 9VIT$ ! PEOPLE TO HE> HIM1 &1 BUT = DI/URB+ ! AUDI5CE1 W\LD HAVE LAU<$ AL\D TO SEE HIM SO VEHEM5TLY EX]CIS+ HIS 0,9DIVIDUAL SOV]EIGNTY0 9 ATTEMPT+ TO EXPOSE ! IDEA AS A FALLACY6 

#d#g#a4 ,BUT !RE IS ANO!R ASPECT ( ?IS CASE ?AT EXCIT$ O!R FEEL+S4 ,! IDEA ( SELF-SOV]EIGNTY HAD BECOME1 AS IT W]E1 AN 9/ITUTION2 & ?IS 9/ITUTION ITSELF PROTECT$ OPPOSITION ITSELF1 & ! ?+S CALL$ 0,S,*,I,S,M10 & 0,T,R,E,A,S,O,N10 & 0,R,E,B,E,L,L,I,O,N10 W]E ,I,M,P,O,S,S,I,B,L,E4 

#d#g#b4 ,! WORD ,REBELLION IS ONLY A B>B>IAN NAME = ! EX]CISE ( ,FRE$OM1 & 0CRU%+ \T REBELLION0 IS ,C,R,U,%,+ ,\,T ,L,I,B,],T,Y64 

#d#g#c4 ,I NE$ NOT MULTIPLY WORDS TO %[ ?AT ! WORDS ,TREASON1 ,TRAITORS1 ,LOYALTY1 ,DISLOYALTY1 ,REBELLION1 ETC41 /AB TO ! HE>T ! V]Y G]M ( LIB]TY1 & ! SPIRIT ( ,AM]ICAN 9/ITUTIONS4 ,IT IS ! SPIRIT ONLY1 & NOT ! 9/ITUTIONS1 ?AT CAN SURVIVE ! W\NDS6 

#d#g#d4 ,9 ! CASE ABOVE M5TION$1 ONE WAS ASK$1 ,>E Y\ NOT GO+ TO REPLY TO ,L----8 ,NO1 C]TA9LY NOT4 ,HE HAS AN ABSOLUTE RI<T 9 HIS SOV]EIGNTY TO OPPOSE SELF-SOV]EIGNTY OR ANY?+ ELSE PROPOS$ = HIS OR ANY ONE'S ADOPTION4 ,!RE IS NO GR\ND = OPPOSITION TILL HE ATTEMPTS TO 5=CE HIS VIEWS UPON O!R SOV]EIGNS4 

#d#g#e4 ,) REG>D TO A 0WILD PURSUIT AFT] A DI/ORT$ ,FRE$OM10 NO?+ HAS EV] SO EFFECTUALLY RE/RA9$ & REGULAT$ ! 9/9CTIVE & IMPULSIVE PURSUIT ( \R [N 5DS1 & 9VE/$ ,FRE$OM ) SU* BEAUTIFUL & 5*ANT+ SYMMETRY AS ! SACR$ & CON/ANT REG>D TO ?IS ABSOLUTE RI<T ( UNQUALIFI$ SOV]EIGNTY 9 O!RS OV] !IR [N2 & SO 9SPIRES A READY SPIRIT ( =BE>ANCE & ACCOMMODATION :]E ! MUTUAL EX]CISE ( ?IS DIV9E ABSOLUTE RI<T IS IMPOSSIBLE2 & ! MO/ POLITE1 B5EVOL5T1 ,EQUITABLE1 *>M+ DEPORTM5T 9 ! HI<E/ CULTIVAT$ CIRCLES1 IS *>ACT]IZ$ 9 EV]Y /EP1 WORD1 & DE$1 AS IF ?IS IDEA WAS ! DIV9E REGULATOR ( ALL4 

#d#g#f4 ,! GREAT DIFFICULTY HAS BE5 9 DET]M9+ :AT CON/ITUTES ONE'S [N1 OV] :I* HE MAY H>MLESSLY EX]CISE ?IS UNQUALIFI$ JURISDICTION1 OR SOV]EIGNTY1 ESPECIALLY ) REG>D TO PROP]TY4 

#d#g#g4 ,IF NO ]ROR HAS BE5 COMMITT$ 9 ! PR9CIPLE ( ,EQUIVAL5TS1 ?IS GREAT OB/ACLE TO H>MONIC ADJU/M5T IS OV]COME4 

#d#g#h4 ,IT IS POSSIBLE ?AT ! SPH]E ( 9DIVIDUAL ABSOLUTE JURISDICTION HAS NOT BE5 FULLY & EXACTLY /AT$1 BUT IF EA* ONE BECOMES SO CONDITION$ ?AT HE CAN EX]CISE ?IS JURISDICTION OV] HIS OR H] [N P]SON1 RESPONSIBILITIES1 TIME1 & PROP]TY1 )\T DI/URB+ O!RS1 TRUE ORD] WILL HAVE COMM5C$1 & FUTURE WISDOM MAY SUPPLY DEFICI5CIES4 

#d#g#i4 0,9DIVIDUALITY0 HAS BE5 MISAPPREH5D$ & MISREPRES5T$ AS 0ISOLATION10 0SELFI%NESS10 0UNSOCIABL5ESS10 ETC4 

#d#h4 ,I SAY MISAPPREH5D$1 BECAUSE ,I CANNOT BELIEVE ?AT ANY ONE :O P]CEIVES ! SUBLIME IMPORTANCE ( IT1 AS A REGULATOR ( HUMAN 9T]C\RSE1 C\LD F9D A MOTIVE TO MISREPRES5T IT4 ,$UCATION1 DRILL1 ON ?IS GREAT !ME1 SEEM TO BE 9DISP5SABLE4 

#d#h#a4 ,A VOLUME :OLLY DEVOT$ TO ITS ILLU/RATION AS ! GREAT ,DIV9E LAW ( ORD] & AS A PREV5TIVE ( CONFUSION & VIOL5CE1 C\LD SC>CELY BEG9 TO DO IT JU/ICE1 & ALL ?AT CAN BE DONE H]E IS TO EXCITE ?\<T T[>DS IT AS A /UDY1 BY A FEW H9TS1 9 ADDITION TO ?OSE ALREADY GIV51 & LEAVE IT TO ! AFT] EXP]I5CE ( ! READ] = CONT9U\S ILLU/RATION & CONFIRMATION4 

#d#h#b4 ,SUPPOSE EV]Y P]SON POSSESS$ ! SAME C\NT5ANCE1 ! SAME NAME1 ! SAME VOICE1 ! SAME /ATURE1 SO ?AT ONE C\LD NOT BE DI/+UI%$ FROM ANO!R1 :AT C\LD EQUAL ! CONFUSION TO :I* IT W\LD IMM$IATELY LEAD8 ,:AT PREV5TS ?IS CONFUSION BUT ! 9DIVIDUALITIES ( C\NT5ANCE1 VOICE1 GAIT1 /ATURE1 NAME1 ETC48 

#d#h#c4 ,:Y NOT NAME EV]Y WOMAN ,EVE1 & EV]Y MAN ,ADAM8 ,BECAUSE ( ! CONFUSION IT W\LD MAKE4 

#d#h#d4 ,:Y DO WE M>K DIFF]5T DRAW]S OR PACKAGES ) DIFF]5T NUMB]S OR LETT]S8 ,TO PREV5T CONFUSION4 

#d#h#e4 ,:Y NOT HAVE ! LETT]S ( ! ALPHABET ALIKE8 ,BECAUSE WE C\LD SPELL NO?+2 WE %\LD DE/ROY ALL WRITT5 LANGUAGE & DEPRIVE \RSELVES ( ALL IT B5EFITS4 

#d#h#f4 ,:AT MAKES ! CONFUSION 9 ALL \R CONTROV]SIES8 ,IT IS BECAUSE SO MANY ( ! WORDS WE >E OBLIG$ TO USE1 >E ALIKE 9 S\ND & 9 !IR OR?OGRAPHY1 :ILE ! WORDS !MSELVES MEAN DIFF]5T ?+S4 ,! REM$Y1 IF IT W]E POSSIBLE1 W\LD BE 9 HAV+ EA* WORD TO REPRES5T ONLY ONE ,9DIVIDUAL ?+4 ,H5CE ! NECESSITY ( CONTROV]SIALI/S DEF9+ & DEF9+ & DEF9+ ! T]MS !Y USE1 TILL BO? P>TIES UND]/& ! P>TICUL> DEF9ITE ,9DIVIDUAL IDEA :I* ! WORD IS TO REPRES5T 9 !IR CONTROV]SY4 ,! SIMPLE P]CEPTION ( ?IS W\LD ALMO/ ANNIHILATE CONTROV]SIES & DISPUTES & (T5 5D 9 MO/ DISA/R\S RESULTS1 OR1 P]HAPS1 :I* NEV] 5DS6 ,\R EV]Y DAY & EV]Y H\R'S CONV]SATION - ALMO/ EV]Y REM>K1 IS 9VE/$ ) MORE OR LESS CONFUSION1 BECAUSE ONE WORD MAY MEAN MORE ?AN ONE ?+1 & COMMON $UCATION HAS NOT TRA9$ US TO ! HABITUAL CONSCI\SNESS OR P]CEPTION ( IT4 

#d#h#g4 ,! ,RE=MATION WAS ONE /EP T[>DS ?IS ,9DIVIDUALITY4 ,IT WAS A /EP 9 DIS9TEGRATION FROM CONC5TRAT$ P[] & DOM9ION2 BUT IT HAS L$ TO O!R /EPS 9 ! SAME DIRECTION - TO MORE DIVISIONS & SUBDIVISIONS ( SECTS1 TILL !OLOGICAL SECTISM IS NE>LY H>MLESS2 BUT ! ,RE=MATION WILL NOT BE COMPLETE TILL IT IS CLE>LY & UNIV]SALLY UND]/OOD ?AT EA* M9D IS AN 9DE/RUCTIBLE 9DIVIDUALITY :I* MAY OR MAY NOT CO9CIDE ) O!R M9DS 9 MORE OR LESS P>TICUL>S2 BUT ?AT TO ATTEMPT TO 5=CE CON=MITY :5 ?IS CO9CID5CE IS WANT+ IS A FATAL UND]TAK+1 :I* WILL PROCE$ 9 VIOL5CE & CONFUSION1 & 5D 9 DISAPPO9TM5T4 ,& ! SAME IS TRUE ?R\<\T ! POLITICAL SPH]E4 ,WE %ALL SEE DIVISIONS & SUBDIVISIONS ( POLITICAL P>TIES TILL P>TYISM DE/ROYS ITSELF BY ! 9SIGNIFICANCE ( EA*2 ! ULTIMATE /EP ( DIVISION L&+ US1 AS 9 ! !OLOGICAL SPH]E1 9 ,9,D,I,V,I,D,U,A,L,I,T,Y3 ! SAME PROCESS 9 ! DIFF]5T SPH]ES RESULT+ 9 EV]Y ONE BE+ HIS [N SECT & P>TY1 OR 0,PRIE/ & ,K+10 OR HIS [N SOV]EIGN4 

#d#h#h4 ,BUT ?IS IS DIRECTLY OPPOSITE 9 PR9CIPLES & 9 PROCESS TO ALL POLITICAL 0,UNIONS10 0,CONF$]ACIES10 ,COMB9ATION & ,ORGANIZATIONS ( ,/ATES1 ,NATIONS1 SECTS1 TRIBES1 CLANS1 OR P>TIES1 & DIRECTLY AWAY FROM ALL ! CONFUSIONS1 VIOL5CE1 CRIME1 DE/RUCTION1 & DESOLATION :I* NECESS>ILY ATT5D !M4 

#d#h#i4 ,FROM ?IS NEW PO9T 
0,/>T+ FRE%1 AS FROM A SECOND BIR?1 ,MAN 9 ! SUN%9E ( ! WORLD'S NEW SPR+1 ,%ALL WALK TRANSP>5T1 LIKE SOME HOLY ?+40 

#d#i4 ,9DIVIDUAL1 9/EAD ( MIX$ OR COMMUNI/IC ,RESPONSIBILITIES APPE>S TO BE ! ONLY POSSIBLE REM$Y AGA9/ A :OLE CITY OR A :OLE NATION BE+ DE/ROY$ = ! WORDS OR ACTS ( TWO OR ?REE ( ITS MEMB]S6 ,ONE1 & P]HAPS MORE1 ( ! F]OCI\S P>TISAN NEWSPAP]S OP5LY ADVOCAT$ ! DE/RUCTION ( ! :OLE CITY ( ,BALTIMORE1 ON ACC\NT ( ! ACTS ( FIVE OR SIX ( ITS 9HABITANTS6 ,$UCATION ON ?IS SUBJECT W\LD HOLD ?OSE FIVE OR SIX ALONE RESPONSIBLE = !IR ACTS1 UNLESS O!RS VOLUNT>ILY ASSUM$ RESPONSIBILITY = !M1 & NO GREAT] ELEM5T ( CONFUSION & VIOL5CE EXI/S 9 \R MID/ ?AN HOLD+ EV]Y ONE RESPONSIBLE = ALL ! OP9IONS OR ACTS ( ?OSE ) :OM !Y MAY BE OCCASIONALLY ASSOCIATE4 ,NO ONE W\LD BE WILL+ TO BE RESPONSIBLE = ALL ! ACTS ( ! BE/ FRI5D HE MAY HAVE1 & ! AXIOM1 0,TELL ME :AT COMPANY Y\ KEEP1 & ,I WILL TELL Y\ :AT Y\ >E10 IS TRUE ONLY ) ?OSE :O HAVE NO ,9DIVIDUALITY - NO SELF-HOOD1 NO PRIVATE JUDGM5T1 & IT HAS DONE1 & IS CONT9UALLY DO+1 MORE H>M ?AN CAN EV] BE E/IMAT$4 

#d#i#a4 ,TO =CE ALL ! CITIZ5S ( ,BALTIMORE 9TO A COMPACT ,CLAN%IP-RESPONSIBILITY = EA* O!R'S WORDS OR ACTS1 IS TO =CE !M1 = SELF-PRES]VATION1 TO ATTEMPT TO 5=CE AN \TW>D CON=MITY ( SPEE* & ACT TO ! PATT]N /RUCK \T BY ! CRUDE $ITOR ( A PAP]1 OR TO SOME O!R ONE PATT]N1 :I*1 BE+ IMPOSSIBLE1 LEADS DIRECTLY TO CONFUSION & VIOL5CE1 9T5SIFI$ TO ! LA/ DEGREE4 

#d#i#b4 ,A ,S\!RN PAP] SAID1 0,SLAV]Y IS ! NATURAL & NORMAL CONDITION ( ! LABOR+ MAN1 :E!R :ITE OR BLACK60 ,WE CANNOT MEASURE ! EVILS ?AT MAY HAVE GR[N TO A GREAT EXT5T \T ( ?IS REM>K HAV+ BE5 TAK5 AS ! S5TIM5TS & DESIGNS ( ALL ! ,S\?4 ,TO HAVE HELD ! WRIT] ( IT ALONE ,9DIVIDUALLY RESPONSIBLE = IT W\LD HAVE BE5 ONLY ,EQUITABLE1 & TO HAVE TREAT$ ALL SIMIL> CASES 9 ! SAME WAY MI<T HAVE AV]T$ ! PRES5T DESOLAT+ 9T]NAL W>4 

#d#i#c4 ,A RECKLESS $ITOR ( A ,NEW ,YORK PAP] IMPUD5TLY ANN\NCES HIMSELF AS ! REPRES5TATIVE ( ! ,AM]ICAN PEOPLE 9 ! 0,TR5T0 & ,MASON & ,SLIDEL CASE1 TO :I* A L>GE PORTION ( ,5GLI%M51 SUPPOS+ ?AT HE TOLD ! TRU?1 V]Y JU/LY TOOK GREAT UMBRAGE1 & W]E READY TO MAKE W> ON ! :OLE ( ! ,AM]ICANS1 ALL FROM ! S+LE MI/AKE ( ASSUM+ ?AT ! ,AM]ICANS W]E RESPONSIBLE = ?AT ONE RECKLESS MAN'S WORDS6 ,! PRACTICE ( HOLD+ EV]Y ONE ALONE ,9DIVIDUALLY RESPONSIBLE = HIS ,A,S,C,],T,A,9,$ ACTS & WORDS W\LD AV]T SU* DANG]S4 

#d#i#d4 ,?IS W\LD BREAK UP ! SY/EM ( A MAJORITY VOT+ O!R 9TO RESPONSIBILITIES :I* !Y DO NOT *OOSE TO ASSUME6 ,V]Y WELL2 !N WE HAVE AT LA/ F\ND A REM$Y = AN EVIL AS GREAT AS ANY O!R4 ,:AT1 !N1 BECOMES ( ,NATIONAL DEBTS1 =C$ ON FUTURE G5]ATIONS )\T CONSULT+ !M8 

#d#i#e4 ,I LEAVE ?IS = ! PRES5T1 TO BE ANSW]$ BY ?OSE :O 9CUR !M & APPROPRIATE ! ,LOANS1 & :O ALONE %\LD BE HELD RESPONSIBLE4 

#d#i#f4 ,CON/ITUTIONS1 /ATUTES1 RULES1 AXIOMS1 & ALL V]BAL =MULAS >E SUBJECT TO V>I\S & CONFLICT+ 9T]PRETATIONS1 ALL GR[+ \T ( ! 9H]5T & 9DE/RUCTIBLE ,9DIVIDUALITY ( DIFF]5T M9DS4 ,A COMPACT BETWE5 P>TIES :O DO NOT UND]/& IT ALIKE IS NULL & VOID1 BECAUSE !Y HAVE NOT CONS5T$ TO ! SAME ?+1 EV5 IF !Y HAVE SIGN$ IT6 ,:AT IS TO BE DONE ) ?IS FACT8 ,WE CAN DO NO?+ ) IT BUT ACCEPT IT AS AN IRREFUTABLE TRU?1 & PROVIDE MEANS ( DISP5S+ ) :ATEV] CONFLICTS ) IT4 

#d#i#g4 ,9DIVIDUALITY AS ! GREAT DIV9E LAW ( ORD] & H>MONY1 :ILE IT EXPOSES & REBUKES !SE POOR DEVICES1 ITSELF DISP5SES ) !M1 & PRACTICALLY ACCOMPLI%ES ! OBJECTS VA9LY ATTEMPT$ BY !M6 

#d#i#h4 ,9DIVIDUAL [N]%IP IS ANO!R PHASE ( 9DIVIDUALITY1 & IS ! BASE ( ALL SECURITY AGA9/ 9CESSANT CONFUSION1 CONFLICT1 REPRESSION1 & VIOL5CE4 ,COMMUNISM IS ITS EXACT ANTIPODE1 & ON ?IS ACC\NT WAS REASONABLY OBJECT$ TO BY ! ,FR5* ,GOV]NM5T1 9 ! TIME ( ,/4 ,SIMONISM1 ON ! GR\ND ?AT IT WORK$ AGA9/ SECURITY ( CONDITION4 

#d#i#i4 ,AN ACCID5TAL QU>REL OCCURS BETWE5 TWO OR ?REE 9DIVIDUALS 9 A /REET ( ,GREYT[N1 9 ,C5TRAL ,AM]ICA1 - ONE MAN ?R[S A BOTTLE AT ,MR4 ,BORL&'S NOSE 7IT SEEMS ?AT BOTTLES W]E NE>E/ AT H&71 & =?) ! :OLE T[N IS R$UC$ TO FRAGM5TS & A%ES BY A ,NOR? ,AM]ICAN %IP-(-W> LY+ 9 ! H>BOR6 ,HAD ! M5 :O WORK$ ! GUNS BE5 $UCAT$ TO KN[ ! VALUE ( ,9DIVIDUAL RESPONSIBILITIES1 9/EAD ( BE+ R$UC$ TO M]E MA*9ES BY ! DRI$-H]R+ SUBORD9ATION1 !Y W\LD NOT HAVE HAD ANY H& 9 ?AT WANTON \TRAGE1 BUT W\LD HAVE WAIT$ TILL !Y UND]/OOD SOME?+ ( ! QU>REL1 & !N W\LD HAVE SAID1 WE WILL DO NO?+ TO UNNECESS>ILY ADD TO ! VIOL5CE ALREADY DONE4 ,LET ! DI/URBANCE BE CONF9$ TO ! 9DIVIDUALS :O VOLUNT>ILY TOO P>T 91 & :O ALONE >E RESPONSIBLE = IT4 

#e4 ,9 JU/ICE TO A V]Y L>GE PORTION ( ! ,NOR? ,AM]ICANS1 IT %\LD BE /AT$ ?AT !RE WAS1 AT ! TIME1 AN 9VOLUNT>Y & EXT5SIVE \TBUR/ ( 9DIGNANT PROTE/ AGA9/ ! RUFFIAN \TRAGE1 & ?AT ! ,GOV]NM5T ITSELF HAS S9CE 7,I BELIEVE7 5T]$ 9TO NEGOTIATION = REP>ATION ( DAMAGES4 

#e#a4 ,VOLTAIRE SAYS ?AT ONE ( ! K+S ( ,PRUSSIA 7,I HAVE =GOTT5 :I*7 C&IDLY ACKN[L$G$ TO HIM ?AT HIS MO/ PROM95T REASONS = GO+ TO W> ) ! ,QUE5 ( ,BOHEMIA1 W]E1 ?AT HE HAD AN >MY ?AT WAS TIR$ ( 9ACTIVITY2 & AMBITION1 9T]E/1 & ! DESIRE TO MAKE ! WORLD TO TALK ( HIM6 

#e#b4 ,ONE CANNOT BE SAID TO ACT ON HIS [N RESPONSIBILITY1 EXCEPT SO F> AS HE TAKES ON HIMSELF ! RISKS1 CO/S1 & NATURAL P5ALTIES ( HIS [N ACTS & DECISIONS4 ,IF ?IS %\LD BECOME ONE ( ! REGULAT+ ?\<TS AMONG M51 :AT W\LD BECOME ( SU* W>S1 OR ANY W>S8 

#e#c4 ,! CONFUSION & DISCORD :I* HAVE UNI=MLY ATT5D ! ATTEMPTS AT ,COOP]ATIVE RECON/RUCTION HAVE >IS5 *IEFLY FROM ! P>TIES HAV+ PL$G$ !MSELVES TO COOP]ATION1 )\T UND]/&+ ! WORD ALIKE4 ,ONE1 P]HAPS1 HAD ?\<T ONLY ( ! ECONOMIES ?AT W\LD RESULT TO HIM2 ANO!R ( ! G5]AL H>MONY ?AT HE SAW W\LD RESULT FROM IT2 ANO!R SAW 9 IT ONLY ! OPPORTUNITY ( MAK+ SPEE*ES & GETT+ 9TO (FICE4 ,AS SOON AS !Y COMM5CE OP]ATIONS1 !Y F9D ?AT !RE IS NO CO9CID5CE1 & CONSEQU5TLY NO COOP]ATION BETWE5 !M4 ,! ATTEMPTS APPE> TO HAVE BE5 P>TIALLY SUCCESSFUL1 JU/ 9 PROPORTION AS !Y HAVE CONF9$ !MSELVES1 LIKE MO/ COMMON P>TN]%IPS1 TO ! COOP]ATION 9 ONE P>TICUL>1 9DIVIDUAL ?+4 ,= 9/ANCE1 /ORE-KEEP+1 & SAV+ & ACCUMULAT+ MONEY OR PROP]TY2 BUT SUCCESS ITSELF 9 ?IS P>TICUL> ALONE1 AS ILLU/RAT$ BY ,RAPP'S ,SOCIETY AT ,ECONOMY1 & BY ! ,RO*DALE COOP]ATORS1 BY FURNI%+ A COMMUNI/IC FUND TO DIFF] AB\T1 T5DS TO DISCORD1 DISSOLUTION1 DISAPPO9TM5T1 & 9SECURITY ( CONDITION1 :I* LATT] IS ! GREATE/ EVIL TO BE REM$I$4 

#e#d4 ,:5 \R 9T]E/S 7AS WE UND]/& !M7 COOP]ATE OR H>MONIZE1 WE %ALL COOP]ATE SO F> AS \R CONDITIONS ADMIT ( IT4 ,NO?+ FUR!R NE$ BE EXPECT$4 ,! UND]/&+1 AS WELL AS ! H&S1 %\LD COOP]ATE4 ,IF WE ATTEMPT TO G5]ALIZE COOP]ATION1 WE %ALL FAIL TO GET ! REQUIR$ COOP]ATION ( UND]/&+4 

#e#e4 ,IT IS ONLY BY ,9,D,I,V,I,D,U,A,L,I,Z,+ EA* CASE - ,D,I,S,9,T,E,G,R,A,T,+ IT FROM ALL O!RS1 & LEAV+ EV]Y ONE ,F,R,E,E TO COOP]ATE 9 ,?,A,T ,P,>,T,I,C,U,L,> ,C,A,S,E ,9 ,H,& ,O,R ,N,O,T1 ?AT WE AVOID ! DISCORDANT COLLISIONS1 & SECURE COOP]ATION SO F> AS EA* ONE EXPECTS TO BE B5EFIT$ BY IT1 OR SO F> AS HIS 9T]E/S PROMPT HIM4 

#e#f4 ,I AM NOT WILL+ TO USE ! WORD 09T]E/S0 H]E )\T EXPLA9+ ?AT ,I RECOGNIZE ,M,O,R,A,L 9T]E/S AS TAK+ PREC$5CE ( PECUNI>Y 9T]E/S2 & YET ,I W\LD HAVE IT CLE>LY UND]/OOD & SETTL$ ?AT ,I WILL NOT MAKE PECUNI>Y SACRIFICES UNLESS ,I FEEL MYSELF COMP5SAT$ 9 ! MORAL 9T]E/ ,I FEEL1 OR ! PLEASURE ,I D]IVE1 FROM ! CONTEMPLATION ( ! GOOD PROMIS$ BY IT4 

#e#g4 ,! NATURAL1 9EVITABLE NECESSITY ( ,9DIVIDUALITY 9 ANY LEAD ( COOP]ATIVE ACTION HAS ALREADY BE5 ILLU/RAT$4 

#e#h4 ,9DIVIDUALITY ( ! SOV]EIGN P[] IS EQUALLY NECESS>Y TO TRUE ORD]1 & H]E9 ,MON>*I/S >E RI<T2 BUT ?IS 9DIVIDUALITY ( ! SOV]EIGNTY IS NOT ,9,D,I,V,I,D,U,A,L AS LONG AS IT CAN BE DIVID$6 & IS NOT ATTA9$ UNTIL IT RE/S 9 EA* P]SON OV] HIS OR H] [N ONLY4 

#e#i4 ,ONE ( ! GREATE/ S\RCES ( CONFUSION 9 CONTROV]SIES OR DISPUTES IS1 ?AT ! DISPUTANTS DO NOT CONF9E !MSELVES TO ! ONE 9DIVIDUAL ?+ 9 :I* ! DISPUTE ORIG9AT$1 TILL ?AT IS SETTL$ & DISPOS$ (1 BUT !Y DRAW 9 NEW PO9TS JU/ AS DISPUTABLE1 ONE AFT] ANO!R1 TILL ! :OLE BECOMES CONGLOM]AT$ CONFUSION4 ,! REM$Y CAN BE F\ND ONLY 9 DISCUSS+ ONE 9DIVIDUAL ?+ OR PO9T AT A TIME4 

#e#a4 ,ONE SAYS ?AT ,JOHN ,VILL>S IS A ROGUE1 & ANO!R SAYS ?AT ! SAME ,JOHN ,VILL>S IS AN EXCELL5T MAN4 ,BO? MAY BE EQUALLY CORRECT4 ,UND] SOME CONDITIONS ,JOHN MI<T HAVE ACT$ ! P>T ( A ROGUE1 & UND] O!R CONDITIONS ! SAME ,JOHN ,VILL>S MI<T HAVE P]=M$ ! P>T ( AN ANGEL4 ,! 9DIVIDUALITY OR DIV]SITY ( CONDITIONS EXPLA9S ALL ?IS4 ,& !RE IS PROBABLY NO GREAT] EF=T ( SELF-GOV]NM5T REQUIR$1 NO GREAT] MORAL VICTORY TO ATTA91 ?AN ?AT ( 9DIVIDUALIZ+ EA* CASE1 - JUDG+ & TREAT+ EA* ACCORD+ TO ITS [N APP>5T M]ITS2 CONDEMN+ ONE ACT ( \R NEI<BOR AT ONE MOM5T1 & ! NEXT M9UTE BE+ READY TO APPROVE ANO!R ACT ( ! SAME NEI<BOR6 ,YET ?IS IS ONLY ,9DIVIDUALIZ+ OR EX]CIS+ DISCRIM9ATION6 

#e#a#a4 ,HAD ! ,AM]ICAN PUBLIC M9D BE5 $UCAT$ TO UND]/& ?AT ,9DIVIDUALITY IS ! VITAL PR9CIPLE ( ORD]1 IT W\LD HAVE G5]ALLY SE5 & ADMITT$ ?AT ,GOV]NM5T HAS1 PROP]LY1 BUT ONE 7,9DIVIDUAL7 FUNCTION1 :I* IS TO RESI/ OR RE/RA9 5CROA*M5TS UPON ! RI<TS ( ,9DIVIDUALS4 ,?AT IT IS NOT ! TRUE FUNCTION ( GOV]NM5TS TO PRESCRIBE OP9IONS1 EI!R MORAL1 RELIGI\S1 OR POLITICAL2 TO M$DLE ) MANUFACTURES OR IMPORTATIONS2 TO PRESCRIBE ! CUT ( ! CITIZ5'S HAIR1 ! EMPLOYM5T ( HIS TIME1 OR ! DISPOSAL ( HIS LIFE OR HIS PROP]TY1 BUT SIMPLY & SOLELY TO PROTECT HIM AGA9/ SU* IMP]T95CES4 

#e#a#b4 ,!Y W\LD HAVE SE5 ?AT ! EMPLOYM5T ( =CE = ANY O!R PURPOSE ?AN TO RESI/ OR RE/RA9 VIOL5CE1 IS1 ITSELF1 AN 5CROA*M5T :I* %\LD BE RESI/$4 ,?IS W\LD GIVE ! ABSOLUTE RI<T ( SECESSION1 P] SE1 TO ANY EXT5T :ATEV]1 LEAV+ NO?+ TO TALK AB\T BUT ! 5TANGL$ OR COMMUNI/IC PROP]TY BETWE5 ! P>TIES1 & ! PRES5T RU9 ( ALL P>TIES W\LD NOT HAVE OCCURR$4 ,A W> = ! PROTECTION OR RELIEF ( ! OPPRESS$ MI<T OR MI<T NOT HAVE >IS5 9 TIME1 BUT NOT ! PRES5T W>4 

#e#a#c4 ,AGA93 ,9 ! DISCUSSION ( ! ISSUE ( ! W>1 IF ! P>TIES HAD CONSID]$ ONE ?+ AT A TIME TILL ?AT ?+ WAS SETTL$1 ! W> W\LD NOT HAVE >IS52 BUT WE >E N[ DISCUSS+ ! RI<T OR WRONG ( SECESSION1 ! RI<TS & WRONGS ( SLAVES1 ! EXP$I5CY ( ,T>IFFS1 ! RI<T TO COLLECT REV5UE1 ! RI<T TO COMPEL CITIZ5S TO FI<T AGA9/ !IR WILLS1 ! NAVIGATION ( ! ,MISSISSIPPI ,RIV]1 POSSIBLE =EIGN RELATIONS1 & SEV]AL O!R SUBJECTS ALL AT ONCE1 & NEV] SETTLE ONE ( !M4 ,! ISSUE ( ! W> >OSE ON ! ABSOLUTE RI<T ( SECESSION4 ,IF ?AT HAD BE5 DWELT ON ,9DIVIDUALLY TILL IT WAS SETTL$ 7AS 0NO?+ IS EV] SETTL$ TILL IT IS SETTL$ RI<T071 ! W> W\LD NOT HAVE >IS51 BECAUSE ! ABSOLUTE & 9ALI5ABLE RI<T ( SELF-PRES]VATION OR SELF-SOV]EIGNTY1 ACCORD+ TO ! ,DECL>ATION ( ,9DEP5D5CE1 HAV+ BE5 >RIV$ AT & ADMITT$1 W\LD HAVE 5D$ ALL CONTROV]SY4 ,& ,I !RE=E ASS]T ?AT1 IF ! PUBLIC M9D HAD BE5 PROP]LY $UCAT$ TO DISCUSS ONE ?+ AT A TIME TILL IT WAS SETTL$1 9/EAD ( A CONGLOM]ATION ( ?+S1 & NEV] SETTL+ ONE ( !M1 WE %\LD HAVE AV]T$ ! RU9 ?AT HAS FOLL[$4 

#e#a#d4 ,= WANT ( PROP] TRA9+1 WE JUMP FROM ONE SUBJECT TO ANO!R1 UND]/&+ NONE ?OR\<LY1 & LUDICR\SLY COMMIT \RSELVES ON BO? SIDES ( ! SAME ISSUE1 & !N EXCLAIM1 0,:OEV] IS NOT = US IS AGA9/ US60 

#e#a#e4 ,ONE P>TY D5IES ! RI<T ( SECESSION OR SELF-SOV]EIGNTY1 TO ! :ITES ( ! ,S\? & TO !IR :ITE SUBORD9ATES AT HOME1 & 9 ! SAME BREA? ASS]T ?AT RI<T 9 FAVOR ( ! BLACKS ( ! ,S\?6 

#e#a#f4 ,! O!R P>TY LEAD]S CLAIM ?AT RI<T = !MSELVES1 BUT D5Y IT TO !IR :ITE SUBORD9ATES1 & TO ! BLACK PEOPLE ( ! ,S\?6 ,?IS IS ! DIFF]5CE BETWE5 ! P>TIES6 ,?AT IS1 NO DIFF]5CE AT ALL4 ,BO? FATALLY CONTRADICT !MSELVES1 & BECOME 5TANGL$ 9 A WEB ( CONFUSION1 FROM :I* NO?+ BUT ! SIMPLE ADMISSION ( ?AT GREAT 9ALI5ABLE RI<T ( SOV]EIGNTY 9 EV]Y P]SON 7)9 HIS OR H] [N SPH]E1 AS EXPLA9$7 CAN POSSIBLY EXTRICATE !M4 

#e#a#g4 ,! RI<T ( SECESSION BE+ 9CLUD$ 91 & SETTL$ BY1 ! ADMISSION ( ?IS GREAT UNIV]SAL RI<T1 POLITICAL SLAV]Y ( ALL COLORS IS LOGICALLY AT AN 5D2 BUT ! 5SLAVEM5T ( ,LABOR IS ANO!R SUBJECT :I* CONC]NS :ITES & BLACKS ALIKE1 BUT :I* CAN F9D NO SOLUTION TILL ! ,EQUITABLE COMP5SATION = LABOR IS UND]/OOD4 ,IF ,I GET AN H\R'S LABOR ( Y\ MORE ?AN ,I AM JU/LY 5TITL$ TO1 ,I HAVE 5SLAV$ Y\ PECUNI>ILY TO ?AT EXT5T2 BUT H[ CAN WE TELL :AT ,I AM ,EQUITABLY 5TITL$ TO = AN H\R ( MY S]VICES8 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahfb 3 ,TRUE ,CIVILIZATION -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,FEBRU>Y #b#c1 #bag 3 ,TRUE ,CIVILIZATION -- ,ADD$4 
,DECEMB] #c1 #bba 3 ,TRUE ,CIVILIZATION -- ,UPDAT$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/