,*APT] #b #aidaid ,PEOPLE 3 ,AU?OR 3 ,LEO ,TOL/OY ,TEXT 3 ,ALL SLAV]Y IS BAS$ SOLELY ON ! FACT ?AT ONE MAN CAN DEPRIVE ANO!R ( HIS LIFE1 & BY ?REAT5+ TO DO SO CAN COMPEL HIM TO DO HIS WILL4 ,WE MAY SEE = C]TA9 ?AT :5EV] ONE MAN IS 5SLAV$ BY ANO!R1 :51 AGA9/ HIS [N WILL & BY ! WILL ( ANO!R1 HE DOES C]TA9 ACTIONS CONTR>Y TO HIS 9CL9ATION1 ! CAUSE1 IF TRAC$ TO ITS S\RCE1 IS NO?+ MORE NOR LESS ?AN A RESULT ( ?IS ?REAT4 ,IF A MAN GIVES TO O!RS ALL HIS LABOR1 HAS NOT 5\< TO EAT1 HAS TO S5D HIS LITTLE *ILDR5 FROM HOME TO WORK H>D1 LEAVES ! L&1 & DEVOTES ALL HIS LIFE TO A HAT$ & UNNECESS>Y TASK1 :I* HAPP5S BE=E \R [N EYES 9 ! WORLD 7:I* WE T]M CIVILIZ$ BECAUSE WE \RSELVES LIVE 9 IT71 !N WE MAY C]TA9LY SAY ?AT HE DOES SO ONLY BECAUSE NOT TO DO SO W\LD BE EQUIVAL5T TO LOSS ( LIFE4 ,!RE=E 9 \R CIVILIZ$ WORLD1 :]E ! MAJORITY ( ! PEOPLE1 AMID T]RIBLE PRIVATIONS1 P]=M HAT$ LABORS UNNECESS>Y TO !MSELVES1 ! GREAT] NUMB] ( M5 >E 9 A SLAV]Y BAS$ ON ! ?REAT ( BE+ DEPRIV$ ( !IR EXI/5CE4 ,( :AT1 !N1 DOES ?IS SLAV]Y CONSI/8 ,:]E9 LIES ?IS P[] ( ?REAT8 ,9 OLD5 TIMES ! MEANS ( SUBJUGATION & ! ?REAT TO KILL W]E PLA9 & OBVI\S TO ALL3 ! PRIMITIVE MEANS ( 5SLAV+ M5 !N CONSI/$ 9 A DIRECT ?REAT TO KILL ) ! SWORD4 ,AN >M$ MAN SAID TO AN UN>M$1 0,I CAN KILL !E1 AS ?\ HA/ SE5 ,I HAVE DONE TO ?Y BRO!R1 BUT ,I DO NOT WANT TO DO IT3 ,I WILL SP>E !E1--FIR/1 BECAUSE IT IS NOT AGREEABLE = ME TO KILL !E2 SECONDLY1 BECAUSE1 AS WELL = ME AS = !E1 IT WILL BE MORE CONV5I5T ?AT ?\ %\LD/ LABOR = ME ?AN ?AT ,I %\LD KILL !E4 ,!RE=E DO ALL ,I ORD] !E TO DO1 BUT KN[ ?AT1 IF ?\ REFUSE/1 ,I WILL TAKE ?Y LIFE40 ,SO ! UN>M$ MAN SUBMITT$ TO ! >M$ ONE & DID EV]Y?+ HE WAS ORD]$ TO DO4 ,! UN>M$ MAN LABOR$1 ! >M$ ?REAT5$4 ,?IS WAS ?AT P]SONAL SLAV]Y :I* APPE>$ FIR/ AMONG ALL NATIONS1 & :I* /ILL EXI/S AMONG PRIMITIVE RACES4 ,?IS MEANS ( 5SLAV+ ALWAYS BEG9S ! WORK2 BUT :5 LIFE BECOMES MORE COMPLICAT$ IT UND]GOES A *ANGE4 ,) ! COMPLICATION ( LIFE SU* A ME?OD PRES5TS GREAT 9CONV5I5CES TO ! OPPRESSOR4 ,BE=E HE CAN APPROPRIATE ! LABOR ( ! WEAK] HE MU/ FE$ & CLO! !M & KEEP !M AT WORK1 & SO !IR NUMB] REMA9S SMALL2 &1 BESIDES1 ?IS COMPELS ! SLAVE-HOLD] TO REMA9 CONT9UALLY ) ! SLAVES1 DRIV+ !M TO WORK BY ! ?REAT ( MURD]+ !M4 ,& ?US ANO!R MEANS ( SUBJUGATION IS DEVELOP$4 ,FIVE ?\S& YE>S AGO 7ACCORD+ TO ! ,BIBLE7 ?IS NOVEL1 CONV5I5T1 & CLEV] MEANS ( OPPRESSION WAS DISCOV]$ BY ,JOSEPH ! ,BEAUTIFUL4 ,IT IS SIMIL> TO ?AT EMPLOY$ N[ 9 ! M5AG]IES = TAM+ RE/IVE HORSES & WILD BEA/S4 ,IT IS HUNG]6 ,?IS CONTRIVANCE IS ?US DESCRIB$ 9 ! ,BIBLE 7,G5ESIS XLI41 #d#h-#e#g73-- ,& HE 7,JOSEPH7 GA!R$ UP ALL ! FOOD ( ! SEV5 YE>S1 :I* W]E 9 ! L& ( ,EGYPT1 & LAID UP ! FOOD 9 ! CITIES3 ! FOOD ( ! FIELD1 :I* WAS R\ND AB\T EV]Y CITY1 LAID HE UP 9 ! SAME4 ,& ,JOSEPH GA!R$ CORN AS ! S& ( ! SEA1 V]Y MU*1 UNTIL HE LEFT NUMB]+2 = IT WAS )\T NUMB]4 ,& ! SEV5 YE>S ( PL5TE\SNESS1 ?AT WAS 9 ! L& ( ,EGYPT1 W]E 5D$4 ,& ! SEV5 YE>S ( DE>? BEGAN TO COME1 ACCORD+ AS ,JOSEPH HAD SAID3 & ! DE>? WAS 9 ALL L&S2 BUT 9 ALL ! L& ( ,EGYPT1 !RE WAS BREAD4 ,& :5 ALL ! L& ( ,EGYPT WAS FAMI%$1 ! PEOPLE CRI$ TO ,PH>AOH = BREAD3 & ,PH>AOH SAID UNTO ALL ! ,EGYPTIANS1 ,GO UNTO ,JOSEPH2 :AT HE SAID TO Y\1 DO4 ,& ! FAM9E WAS OV] ALL ! FACE ( ! E>?3 ,& ,JOSEPH OP5$ ALL ! /OREH\SES1 & SOLD UNTO ! ,EGYPTIANS2 & ! FAM9E WAX$ SORE 9 ! L& ( ,EGYPT4 ,& ALL C\NTRIES CAME 9TO ,EGYPT TO ,JOSEPH = TO BUY CORN2 EV5 BECAUSE ?AT ! FAM9E WAS SO SORE 9 ALL L&S4 ,JOSEPH1 MAK+ USE ( ! PRIMITIVE MEANS ( 5SLAV+ M5 BY ! ?REAT ( ! SWORD1 GA!R$ CORN DUR+ ! YE>S ( PL5TY 9 EXPECTATION ( YE>S ( FAM9E :I* G5]ALLY FOLL[ YE>S ( PL5TY1--M5 KN[ ALL ?IS )\T ! DREAMS ( ,PH>AOH1--& !N BY ! PANGS ( HUNG] HE MADE ALL ! ,EGYPTIANS & ! 9HABITANTS ( ! SURR\ND+ C\NTRIES SLAVES TO ,PH>AOH MORE SECURELY & CONV5I5TLY4 ,& :5 ! PEOPLE BEGAN TO BE FAMI%$1 HE >RANG$ MATT]S SO AS TO KEEP !M 9 HIS P[] =EV]4 7,G5ESIS XLVII41 #a#c-#b#f47 ,& !RE WAS NO BREAD 9 ALL ! L&2 = ! FAM9E WAS V]Y SORE1 SO ?AT ! L& ( ,EGYPT & ALL ! L& ( ,CANAAN FA9T$ BY REASON ( ! FAM9E4 ,& ,JOSEPH GA!R$ UP ALL ! MONEY ?AT WAS F\ND 9 ! L& ( ,EGYPT1 & 9 ! L& ( ,CANAAN1 = ! CORN :I* !Y B\AOH'S H\SE4 ,& :5 MONEY FAIL$ 9 ! L& ( ,EGYPT1 & 9 ! L& ( ,CANAAN1 ALL ! ,EGYPTIANS CAME UNTO ,JOSEPH1 & SAID1 ,GIVE US BREAD3 = :Y %\LD WE DIE 9 ?Y PRES5CE8 = ! MONEY FAILE?4 ,& ,JOSEPH SAID1 ,GIVE Y\R CATTLE2 & ,I WILL GIVE Y\ = Y\R CATTLE1 IF MONEY FAIL4 ,& !Y BR\4 ,:5 ?AT YE> WAS 5D$1 !Y CAME UNTO HIM ! SECOND YE>1 & SAID UNTO HIM1 ,WE WILL NOT HIDE IT FROM MY ,LORD1 H[ ?AT \R MONEY IS SP5T2 MY LORD ALSO HA? \R H]DS ( CATTLE2 !RE IS NOT \AOH3 & GIVE US SE$1 ?AT WE MAY LIVE1 & NOT DIE1 & ?AT ! L& BE NOT DESOLATE4 ,& ,JOSEPH B\AOH2 = ! ,EGYPTIANS SOLD EV]Y MAN HIS FIELD1 BECAUSE ! FAM9E PREVAIL$ OV] !M3 SO ! L& BECAME ,PH>AOH'S4 ,& AS = ! PEOPLE1 HE REMOV$ !M TO CITIES FROM ONE 5D ( ! BORD]S ( ,EGYPT EV5 TO ! O!R 5D !RE(4 ,ONLY ! L&S ( ! PRIE/S B\AOH1 & DID EAT !IR PORTION :I* ,PH>AOH GAVE !M3 :]E=E !Y SOLD NOT !IR L&S4 ,!N ,JOSEPH SAID UNTO ! PEOPLE1 ,BEHOLD1 ,I HAVE B\AOH3 LO1 H]E IS SE$ = Y\1 & YE %ALL S[ ! L&4 ,& IT %ALL COME TO PASS 9 ! 9CREASE1 ?AT YE %ALL GIVE ! FIF? P>T UNTO ,PH>AOH1 & F\R P>TS %ALL BE Y\R [N1 = SE$ ( ! FIELD1 & = Y\R FOOD1 & = !M ( Y\R H\SEHOLDS1 & = FOOD = Y\R LITTLE ONES4 ,& !Y SAID1 ,?\ HA/ SAV$ \R LIVES3 LET US F9D GRACE 9 ! SIAOH'S S]VANTS4 ,& ,JOSEPH MADE IT A LAW OV] ! L& ( ,EGYPT UNTO ?IS DAY1 ?AT ,PH>AOH %\LD HAVE ! FIF? P>T2 EXCEPT ! L& ( ! PRIE/S ONLY1 :I* BECAME NOT ,PH>AOH'S4 ,=M]LY1 9 ORD] TO APPROPRIATE LABOR1 ,PH>AOH HAD TO USE VIOL5CE T[>DS !M2 BUT N[1 :5 ! /ORES & ! L& BELONG$ TO ,PH>AOH1 HE HAD ONLY TO KEEP !SE /ORES BY =CE1 & HUNG] COMPELL$ ! M5 TO LABOR = HIM4 ,ALL ! L& N[ BELONG$ TO ,PH>AOH1 & HE HAD ALL ! /ORES 7:I* W]E TAK5 AWAY FROM ! PEOPLE72 & !RE=E1 9/EAD ( DRIV+ !M TO WORK 9DIVIDUALLY BY ! SWORD1 HE HAD ONLY TO KEEP FOOD FROM !M & !Y W]E 5SLAV$1 NOT BY ! SWORD1 BUT BY HUNG]4 ,9 A YE> ( SC>CITY1 ALL M5 MAY BE />V$ TO DEA? AT ,PH>AOH'S WILL2 & 9 A YE> ( PL5TY1 ALL MAY BE KILL$ :O1 FROM CASUAL MIS=TUNES1 HAVE NO /ORES ( CORN4 ,?US COMES 9TO OP]ATION ! SECOND MEANS ( 5SLAV+1 NOT DIRECTLY ) ! SWORD1--?AT IS1 BY ! /RONG MAN DRIV+ ! WEAK ONE TO LABOR UND] ?REAT ( KILL+ HIM1--BUT BY ! /RONG ONE HAV+ TAK5 AWAY FROM ! WEAK ! /ORES ( CORN :I*1 KEEP+ BY ! SWORD1 HE COMPELS ! WEAK TO WORK =4 ,JOSEPH SAID TO ! HUNGRY M51 0,I C\LD />VE Y\ TO DEA?1 BECAUSE ,I HAVE ! CORN2 BUT ,I WILL SP>E Y\R LIVES1 BUT ONLY UND] ! CONDITION ?AT Y\ DO ALL ,I ORD] Y\ = ! FOOD :I* ,I WILL GIVE Y\40 ,= ! FIR/ MEANS ( 5SLAV+1 ! OPPRESSOR ONLY NE$S SOLDI]S TO RIDE TO & FRO AMONG ! 9HABITANTS1 & MAKE !M FULFILL ! REQUIREM5TS ( !IR MA/] UND] ?REAT ( DEA?4 ,& ?US ! OPPRESSOR HAS ONLY TO PAY HIS SOLDI]S4 ,BUT ) ! SECOND MEANS1 BESIDES ! SOLDI]S1 ! OPPRESSOR MU/ HAVE DIFF]5T ASSI/ANTS = KEEP+ & PROTECT+ ! L& & /ORES FROM ! />V+ PEOPLE4 ,!SE >E ! ,JOSEPHS & !IR /EW>DS & DI/RIBUTORS4 ,& ! OPPRESSOR HAS TO REW>D !M1 & TO GIVE ,JOSEPH A DRESS ( BROCADE1 A GOLD R+1 & S]VANTS1 & CORN & SILV] TO HIS BRO!RS & RELATIVES4 ,BESIDES ?IS1 FROM ! V]Y NATURE ( ! SECOND MEANS1 NOT ONLY ! /EW>DS & !IR RELATIONS1 BUT ALL :O HAVE /ORES ( CORN BECOME P>TICIPATORS 9 ?IS VIOL5CE1 JU/ AS BY ! FIR/ MEANS1 BAS$ UPON IMM$IATE =CE1 EV]Y ONE :O HAS >MS BECOMES A P>TN] 9 TYRANNY1 SO BY ?IS MEANS1 BAS$ UPON HUNG]1 EV]Y ONE :O HAS /ORES ( PROVISION %>ES 9 IT1 & HAS P[] OV] ?OSE :O HAVE NO /ORES4 ,! ADVANTAGE ( ?IS ME?OD OV] ! =M] CONSI/S1 FIR/ & *IEFLY1 9 ! FACT ?AT ! OPPRESSOR NE$ NO LONG] COMPEL ! WORKM5 TO DO HIS WILL BY =CE1 = !Y !MSELVES COME TO HIM & SELL !MSELVES TO HIM2 SECONDLY1 9 ! CIRCUM/ANCE ?AT FEW] M5 ESCAPE FROM HIS VIOL5CE4 ,! DRAWBACK IS1 ?AT HE HAS TO EMPLOY A GREAT] NUMB] ( M54 ,= ! OPPRESS$ ! ADVANTAGE ( IT CONSI/S 9 ! FACT ?AT !Y >E NO LONG] EXPOS$ TO R\< VIOL5CE BUT >E LEFT TO !MSELVES2 & CAN ALWAYS HOPE TO PASS FROM BE+ ! OPPRESS$ TO BECOM+ OPPRESSORS 9 !IR TURN1 :I* BY =TUNATE CIRCUM/ANCES !Y SOMETIMES REALLY DO4 ,! DRAWBACK = !M IS1 ?AT !Y CAN NEV] ESCAPE FROM P>TICIPAT+ 9 ! OPPRESSION ( O!RS4 ,?IS NEW MEANS ( 5SLAV+ G5]ALLY COMES 9TO OP]ATION TOGE!R ) ! OLD ONE2 & ! OPPRESSOR LESS5S ! ONE & 9CREASES ! O!R ACCORD+ TO HIS DESIRES4 ,BUT ?IS DOES NOT FULLY SATISFY ! MAN :O WI%ES TO TAKE AWAY AS MU* AS POSSIBLE ( ! PRODUCTS ( ! LABOR ( AS MANY WORK+-PEOPLE AS HE CAN F9D1 & TO 5?RALL$ AS MANY M5 AS POSSIBLE2 &1 !RE=E1 A ?IRD MEANS ( OPPRESSION IS EVOLV$4 ,?IS IS ! SLAV]Y ( TAXATION1 &1 LIKE ! SECOND1 IT IS BAS$ UPON HUNG]2 BUT TO ! MEANS ( SUBDU+ M5 BY DEPRIV+ !M ( BREAD IS ADD$ ! DEPRIVATION ( O!R NECESS>IES4 ,! OPPRESSOR REQUIRES FROM ! SLAVES SO MU* ( ! MONEY HE HIMSELF HAS CO9$1 ?AT1 9 ORD] TO OBTA9 IT1 ! SLAVES >E COMPELL$ TO SELL NOT ONLY /ORES ( CORN 9 GREAT] QUANTITY ?AN ! FIF? P>T :I* WAS FIX$ BY ,JOSEPH1 BUT ! FIR/ NECESS>IES ( LIFE AS WELL1--MEAT1 SK9S1 WOOL1 CLO!S1 FIREWOOD1 EV5 !IR BUILD+S2 & !RE=E ! OPPRESSOR ALWAYS KEEPS HIS SLAVES 9 HIS P[]1 NOT ONLY BY HUNG]1 BUT BY ?IR/1 COLD & O!R PRIVATIONS4 ,& ?US ! ?IRD MEANS ( SLAV]Y COMES 9TO OP]ATION1 A MONET>Y1 TRIBUT>Y ONE1 CONSI/+ 9 ! OPPRESSOR SAY+ TO ! OPPRESS$1 0,I CAN DO ) EA* ( Y\ JU/ :AT ,I LIKE2 ,I CAN KILL & DE/ROY Y\ BY TAK+ AWAY ! L& BY :I* Y\ E>N Y\R LIV+2 ,I CAN1 ) ?IS MONEY :I* Y\ MU/ GIVE ME1 BUY ALL ! CORN UPON :I* Y\ FE$1 & SELL IT TO /RANG]S1 & AT ANY TIME ANNIHILATE Y\ BY />VATION2 ,I CAN TAKE FROM Y\ ALL ?AT Y\ HAVE1--Y\R CATTLE1 Y\R H\SES1 Y\R CLO!S2 BUT IT IS NEI!R CONV5I5T NOR AGREEABLE = ME TO DO SO1 & !RE=E ,I LET Y\ ALONE1 TO WORK AS Y\ PLEASE2 ONLY GIVE ME SO MU* ( ! MONEY :I* ,I DEM& ( Y\1 EI!R AS A POLL-TAX1 OR ACCORD+ TO Y\R L& OR ! QUANTITY ( Y\R FOOD & DR9K1 OR Y\R CLO!S OR Y\R H\SES4 ,GIVE ME ?IS MONEY1 & DO :AT Y\ LIKE AMONG Y\RSELVES1 BUT KN[ ?AT ,I %ALL NEI!R PROTECT NOR MA9TA9 WID[S NOR ORPHANS NOR 9VALIDS NOR OLD PEOPLE1 NOR SU* AS HAVE BE5 BURN$ \T3 ,I %ALL ONLY PROTECT ! REGUL> CIRCULATION ( ?IS MONEY4 ,?IS RILY GIVE ME ! FIX$ NUMB] ( !SE PIECES ( MONEY3 AS TO H[ OR :]E Y\ GET IT1 ,I %ALL NOT 9 ! LEA/ TR\BLE MYSELF40 ,& SO ! OPPRESSOR DI/RIBUTES !SE PIECES ( MONEY AS AN ACKN[L$GM5T ?AT HIS DEM& HAS BE5 COMPLI$ )4 ,! SECOND ME?OD ( 5SLAV+ CONSI/$ 9 ?IS1 ?AT1 HAV+ TAK5 AWAY ! FIF? P>T ( ! H>VE/1 & COLLECT$ /ORES ( CORN1 ,PH>AOH1 BESIDES ! P]SONAL SLAV]Y BY ! SWORD1 RECEIV$1 BY HIS ASSI/ANTS1 ! POSSIBILITY ( DOM9ION OV] ! WORK+-PEOPLE DUR+ ! TIME ( FAM9E1 & OV] SOME ( !M DUR+ MIS=TUNES :I* HAPP5 TO !M4 ,! ?IRD ME?OD CONSI/S 9 ?IS3 ,PH>AOH REQUIRES FROM ! WORK+-PEOPLE MORE MONEY ?AN ! VALUE ( ! FIF? P>T ( CORN :I* HE TOOK FROM !M2 HE & HIS ASSI/ANTS GET A NEW MEANS ( DOM9ION OV] ! WORK+-CLASS1 NOT M]ELY DUR+ ! FAM9E & !IR CASUAL MIS=TUNES1 BUT P]MAN5TLY4 ,BY ! SECOND ME?OD1 M5 RETA9 SOME /ORES ( CORN :I* HELP !M TO BE> 9DIFF]5T H>VE/S & CASUAL MIS=TUNES )\T GO+ 9TO SLAV]Y2 BUT BY ! ?IRD1 :5 !RE >E MORE DEM&S1 ! /ORES1 NOT ( CORN ONLY BUT ( ALL O!R NECESS>IES ( LIFE >E TAK5 AWAY FROM !M1 & AT ! FIR/ MIS=TUNE A WORKMAN1 HAV+ NEI!R /ORES ( CORN NOR ANY O!R /ORES :I* HE MIE ! BOOTY ) !M2 = ! SECOND1 BESIDES ! PROTECTORS ( ! L& & ! /ORES1 HE MU/ HAVE COLLECTORS & CL]KS = ! DI/RIBUTION ( ! CORN2 = ! ?IRD1 BESIDES ! SOLDI]S = KEEP+ ! L& & HIS PROP]TY1 HE MU/ HAVE COLLECTORS ( TAXES1 ASSESSORS ( DIRECT TAXATION1 SUP]VISORS1 CU/OM-H\SE CL]KS1 MANAG]S ( MONEY1 & CO9]S ( IT4 ,! ORGANIZATION ( ! ?IRD ME?OD IS MU* MORE COMPLICAT$ ?AN ?AT ( ! SECOND4 ,BY ! SECOND1 ! GETT+ 9 ( CORN MAY BE LEAS$ \T1 AS WAS DONE 9 OLD5 TIMES & IS /ILL ! CU/OM 9 ,TURKEY2 BUT BY PUTT+ TAXES ON M5 !RE IS NE$ ( A COMPLICAT$ ADM9I/RATION1 :I* HAS TO 5SURE ! RIE ! PLUND] ) A /ILL GREAT] NUMB] ( M5 ?AN BY ! SECOND2 BESIDES1 ACCORD+ TO ! V]Y NATURE ( ! ?+1 ALL ! M5 ( ! SAME OR ( ! =EIGN C\NTRY :O POSSESS MONEY BECOME %>]S ) ! OPPRESS$4 ,! ADVANTAGE ( ! ?IRD ME?OD OV] ! FIR/ & SECOND CONSI/S *IEFLY 9 ! FOLL[+ FACT3 ?AT BY IT !RE IS NO NE$ TO WAIT = A YE> ( SC>CITY1 AS 9 ! TIME ( ,JOSEPH1 BUT YE>S ( FAM9E >E E/ABLI%$ =EV]1 & 7:IL/ BY ! SECOND ME?OD ! P>T ( ! LABOR :I* IS TAK5 AWAY DEP5DS UPON ! H>VE/1 & CANNOT BE AUGM5T$ AD LIBITUM1 BECAUSE IF !RE IS NO CORN1 !RE IS NO?+ TO TAKE7 BY ! NEW MONET>Y ME?OD ! REQUIREM5T CAN BE BR\T ( !IR LABOR = CORN2 :]EAS N[1 BESIDES ?AT P>T :I* !Y GIVE = CORN1 !Y MU/ N[ GIVE ANO!R P>T = TAXES4 ,A DRAWBACK = ! OPPRESSOR IS ?AT HE HAS TO %>E ! PLUND] ) A /ILL GREAT] NUMB] ( M51 NOT ONLY ) HIS DIRECT ASSI/ANTS1 BUT ALSO ) ALL ?OSE M5 ( HIS [N C\NTRY1 & EV5 ( =EIGN C\NTRIES1 :O MAY HAVE ! MONEY :I* IS DEM&$ FROM ! SLAVES4 ,ITS ADVANTAGE = ! OPPRESS$ IS ONLY ?AT HE IS ALL[$ GREAT] 9DEP5D5CE ?AN UND] ! SECOND ME?OD2 HE MAY LIVE :]E HE *OOSES1 DO :AT HE LIKES2 HE MAY S[ OR NOT S[2 HE HAS TO GIVE NO ACC\NT ( HIS LABOR2 & IF HE HAS MONEY1 HE MAY CONSID] HIMSELF 5TIRELY FREE1 & CON/ANTLY HOPE1 ?\< ONLY = A TIME1 TO OBTA9 NOT ONLY AN 9DEP5D5T POSITION1 BUT EV5 TO BECOME AN OPPRESSOR HIMSELF1 :5 HE HAS MONEY TO SP>E4 ,! DRAWBACK = ! OPPRESS$ IS1 ?AT ON A G5]AL AV]AGE !IR SITUATION BECOMES MU* WORSE1 & !Y >E DEPRIV$ ( ! GREAT] P>T ( ! PRODUCTS ( !IR LABOR1 BECAUSE ! NUMB] ( ?OSE :O UTILIZE !IR LABOR HAS 9CREAS$1 & !RE=E ! BURD5 ( KEEP+ !M FALLS UPON A SMALL] NUMB] ( M54 ,?IS ?IRD ME?OD ( 5SLAV+ M5 IS ALSO V]Y OLD1 & COMES 9TO OP]ATION ) ! =M] TWO )\T 5TIRELY EXCLUD+ !M4 ,!SE ?REE ME?ODS ( 5SLAV+ M5 HAVE ALWAYS BE5 9 OP]ATION4 ,!Y MAY ALL BE COMP>$ TO SCREWS :I* SECURE ! BO>D LAID ON ! WORK-PEOPLE :I* PRESSES !M D[N4 ,! FUNDAM5TAL1 OR MIDDLE SCREW1 )\T :I* ! O!R SCREWS C\LD NOT HOLD1 :I* IS FIR/ SCREW$ UP1 & :I* IS NEV] SLACK5$1 IS ! SCREW ( P]SONAL SLAV]Y1 ! 5SLAV+ ( SOME M5 BY O!RS UND] ?REAT ( SLAUE MADE FA/1 & IT IS ONLY :5 ONE ( !M IS TIE SLACK5$4 ,= ! COMPLETE 5SLAVEM5T ( ! WORKMAN1 ALL ?REE >E NECESS>Y2 & 9 \R SOCIETY1 ALL ?REE >E 9 OP]ATION TOGE!R4 ,! FIR/ ME?OD ( P]SONAL SLAV]Y UND] ?REAT ( MURD] BY ! SWORD HAS NEV] BE5 ABOLI%$1 & NEV] WILL BE SO LONG AS !RE IS ANY OPPRESSION1 BECAUSE EV]Y K9D ( OPPRESSION IS BAS$ ON ?IS ALONE4 ,WE >E ALL QUITE SURE ?AT P]SONAL SLAV]Y IS ABOLI%$ 9 \R CIVILIZ$ WORLD2 ?AT ! LA/ REMNANT ( IT HAS BE5 ANNIHILAT$ 9 ,AM]ICA & 9 ,RUSSIA1 & ?AT IT IS ONLY AMONG ! B>B>IANS ?AT REAL SLAV]Y EXI/S1 & ?AT ) US IT IS NO LONG] 9 BE+4 ,WE =GET ONLY ONE SMALL CIRCUM/ANCE1--?OSE HUNDR$S ( MILLIONS ( /&+ TROOPS )\T :I* NO /ATE EXI/S1 & ) ! ABOLITION ( :I* ALL ! ECONOMICAL ORGANIZATION ( EA* /ATE W\LD 9EVITABLY FALL TO PIECES4 ,YET :AT >E !SE MILLIONS ( SOLDI]S BUT ! P]SONAL SLAVES ( ?OSE :O RULE !M8 ,>E NOT !SE M5 COMPELL$ TO DO ! WILL ( !IR COMM&]S UND] ! ?REAT ( TORTURE & DEA?1--A ?REAT (T5 C>RI$ \T8 ! DIFF]5CE CONSI/+ ONLY 9 ! FACT ?AT ! SUBMISSION ( !SE SLAVES IS NOT CALL$ SLAV]Y1 BUT DISCIPL9E1 & ?AT SLAVES >E SLAVES FROM !IR BIR?1 BUT SOLDI]S ONLY DUR+ A MORE OR LESS %ORT P]IOD ( !IR SO-CALL$ 0S]VICE40 ,P]SONAL SLAV]Y1 !RE=E1 IS NOT ONLY NOT ABOLI%$ 9 \R CIVILIZ$ WORLD1 BUT1 UND] ! SY/EM ( CONSCRIPTION1 IT HAS ( LATE YE>S BE5 CONFIRM$2 & IT HAS REMA9$ AS IT HAS ALWAYS EXI/$1 ONLY SLIS IT S]VES ONLY = ! SUBJUGATION & %AME ( ! C\NTRY4 ,BUT ( ! EXP$I5CY ( ?IS SLAV]Y = MA9TA9+ ?AT ( ! L& & TAXES !RE IS NO QUE/ION4 ,IF ,IRI% OR ,RUSSIAN PEASANTS W]E TO TAKE POSSESSION ( ! L& ( ! PROPRIETORS1 TROOPS W\LD BE S5T TO DISPOSSESS !M4 ,IF Y\ BUILD A DI/ILL]Y OR A BREW]Y & DO NOT PAY EXCISE1 !N SOLDI]S WILL BE S5T TO %UT IT UP4 ,REFUSE TO PAY TAXES1 & ! SAME ?+ WILL HAPP5 TO Y\4 ,! SECOND SCREW IS ! ME?OD ( 5SLAV+ M5 BY TAK+ AWAY FROM !M !IR L& & !IR /ORES ( PROVISIONS4 ,?IS ME?OD HAS ALSO ALWAYS BE5 9 EXI/5CE :]EV] M5 >E OPPRESS$2 &1 :ATEV] *ANGES IT MAY UND]GO1 IT IS EV]Y:]E 9 OP]ATION4 ,SOMETIMES ALL ! L& BELONGS TO ! SOV]EIGN1 AS 9 ,TURKEY1 & !RE ONE-T5? IS GIV5 TO ! /ATE TREASURY4 ,SOMETIMES A P>T ( ! L& BELONGS TO ! SOV]EIGN1 & TAXES >E RAIS$ ON IT4 ,SOMETIMES ALL ! L& BELONGS TO A FEW PEOPLE & IS LET \T = LABOR1 AS 9 ,5GL&4 ,SOMETIMES MORE OR LESS L>GE PORTIONS ( L& BELONG TO ! L&-[N]S1 AS 9 ,RUSSIA1 ,G]MANY1 & ,FRANCE4 ,BUT :]EV] !RE IS 5SLAV+ !RE EXI/S ALSO ! APPROPRIATION ( ! L& BY ! OPPRESSOR1 & ?IS SCREW IS SLACK5$ OR TIDS ( MONEY & ! /R5G!N+ ( /ATE P[]S IT HAS BECOME AN ESPECIALLY P[]FUL 9FLU5CE4 ,?IS ME?OD IS SO DEVELOP$ 9 \R DAYS ?AT IT T5DS TO BE A SUB/ITUTE = ! SECOND ME?OD ( 5SLAV+1--! L& MONOPOLY4 ,IT IS OBVI\S FROM ! /ATE ( ! POLITICAL ECONOMY ( ALL ,EUROPE1 ?AT IT IS BY ! TIT ( ! SOIL1 ! L&LORDS W]E AFRAID !Y W\LD LOSE !IR P[]2 BUT EXP]I5CE HAS %[N ?AT HAV+ LET GO ! :OLE *A9 ( P]SONAL SLAV]Y1 !Y HAD ONLY TO SEIZE ANO!R1--?AT ( ! L&4 ,A PEASANT WAS %ORT ( CORN2 HE HAD NOT 5\< TO LIVE ON4 ,! L&LORD HAD L& & /ORES ( CORN3 & !RE=E ! PEASANT /ILL REMA9$ ! SAME SLAVE4 ,ANO!R TRANS=MATION WAS CAUS$ BY ! GOV]NM5T SCREW ( TAXATION BE+ PRESS$ HOME4 ,! MAJORITY ( WORK+-PEOPLE1 HAV+ NO /ORES1 W]E OBLIG$ TO SELL !MSELVES TO !IR L&LORDS & TO ! FACTORIES4 ,?IS NEW =M ( OPPRESSION HELD ! PEOPLE /ILL TIE /ILL WORK+ = !IR L&LORDS & 9 ! FACTORIES TO PAY !SE TAXES4 ,?IS IS SO OBVI\S1 ?AT1 IF ! GOV]NM5T W]E TO REMIT TAXATION = ONE YE> ONLY1 ALL LABOR W\LD BE /OPP$ 9 ! FIELDS ( ! L&LORDS1 & 9 ! FACTORIES4 ,N9E-T5?S ( ! ,RUSSIAN PEOPLE HIRE !MSELVES \T DUR+ & BE=E ! COLLECTION ( TAXES4 ,ALL !SE ?REE ME?ODS HAVE NEV] CEAS$ TO OP]ATE1 & >E /ILL 9 OP]ATION1 BUT PEOPLE >E 9CL9$ TO IGNORE !M OR TO 9V5T NEW EXCUSES = !M4 ,&1 :AT IS MO/ REM>KABLE ( ALL IS1 ?AT ! V]Y MEANS ON :I* EV]Y?+ IS BAS$1 ?AT SCREW :I* IS SCREW$ UP TII/OTLE1 & TO ! ,ROMANS1 IT SEEM$ ?AT IT C\LD NOT BE O!RWISE1 & ?AT SLAV]Y WAS AN UNAVOIDABLE & NATURAL RESULT ( W>S1 )\T :I* ! EXI/5CE ( MANK9D WAS 9CONCEIVABLE4 ,SIMIL>LY1 9 ! ,MIDDLE ,AGES1 & TILL REC5TLY1 PEOPLE DID NOT APPREH5D ! MEAN+ ( L&-[N]%IP1 ON :I* DEP5D$ ! 5TIRE ECONOMICAL ORGANIZATION ( !IR TIME4 ,SO ALSO1 AT PRES5T1 NO ONE SEES OR WANTS TO SEE1 ?AT 9 \R TIME ! SLAV]Y ( ! MAJORITY ( ! PEOPLE DEP5DS ON TAXES COLLECT$ BY ! GOV]NM5T FROM ITS [N L& SLAVES1 TAXES COLLECT$ BY ADM9I/RATION & ! TROOPS1--BY ! V]Y SAME TROOPS :I* >E MA9TA9$ BY !SE TAXES4 ,FROM 3 ,GUT5B]G4ORG4 ,*RONOLOGY 3 ,NOVEMB] #c1 #aic 3 ,*APT] #b -- ,PUBLICATION4 ,FEBRU>Y #a#i1 #bag 3 ,*APT] #b -- ,ADD$4 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3 HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/