,*APT] #ag 

#ahhgahhg 

,PEOPLE 3 

,AU?OR 3 ,LEO ,TOL/OY 

,TEXT 3 

.<#a#b#d.> 

,9TO ! DELUSION ?AT ,I C\LD HELP O!RS ,I WAS L$ BY ! FACT ?AT ,I FANCI$ ?AT MY MONEY WAS ( ! SAME SORT AS ,SEMYON'S4  ,BUT ?IS WAS NOT ! CASE4 

,A G5]AL IDEA PREVAILS1 ?AT MONEY REPRES5TS WEAL?2 BUT WEAL? IS ! PRODUCT ( LABOR2 &1 !RE=E1 MONEY REPRES5TS LABOR4  ,BUT ?IS IDEA IS AS JU/ AS ?AT EV]Y GOV]NM5TAL REGULATION IS ! RESULT ( A COMPACT 7CONTRAT SOCIAL74 

,EV]Y ONE LIKES TO ?9K ?AT MONEY IS ONLY A M$IUM ( EX*ANGE = LABOR4  ,I HAVE MADE %OES1 Y\ HAVE RAIS$ GRA91 HE HAS RE>$ %EEP3 H]E1 9 ORD] ?AT WE MAY ! MORE READILY EFFECT AN EX*ANGE1 WE WILL 9/ITUTE MONEY1 :I* REPRES5TS A CORRESPOND+ QUANTITY ( LABOR1 &1 BY MEANS ( IT1 WE WILL B>T] \R %OES = A BREA/ ( LAMB & T5 P\NDS ( FL\R4  ,WE WILL EX*ANGE \R PRODUCTS ?R\< ! M$IUM ( MONEY1 & ! MONEY ( EA* ONE ( US REPRES5TS \R LABOR4 

,?IS IS P]FECTLY TRUE1 BUT TRUE ONLY SO LONG AS1 9 ! COMMUNITY :]E ?IS EX*ANGE IS EFFECT$1 ! VIOL5CE ( ONE MAN OV] ! RE/ HAS NOT MADE ITS APPE>ANCE2 NOT ONLY VIOL5CE OV] ! LABORS ( O!RS1 AS HAPP5S 9 W>S & SLAV]Y1 BUT :]E HE EX]CISES NO VIOL5CE = ! PROTECTION ( ! PRODUCTS ( !IR LABOR FROM O!RS4  ,?IS WILL BE TRUE ONLY 9 A COMMUNITY :OSE MEMB]S FULLY C>RY \T ! ,*RI/IAN LAW1 9 A COMMUNITY :]E M5 GIVE TO HIM :O ASKS1 & :]E HE :O TAKES IS NOT ASK$ TO MAKE RE/ITUTION4  ,BUT JU/ SO SOON AS ANY VIOL5CE :ATEV] IS US$ 9 ! COMMUNITY1 ! SIGNIFICANCE ( MONEY = ITS POSSESSOR LOSES ITS SIGNIFICANCE AS A REPRES5TATIVE ( LABOR1 & ACQUIRES ! SIGNIFICANCE ( A RI<T F\ND$1 NOT ON LABOR1 BUT ON VIOL5CE4 

,AS SOON AS !RE IS W>1 & ONE MAN HAS TAK5 ANY ?+ FROM ANY O!R MAN1 MONEY CAN NO LONG] BE ALWAYS ! REPRES5TATIVE ( LABOR2 MONEY RECEIV$ BY A W>RIOR = ! SPOILS ( W>1 :I* HE SELLS1 EV5 IF HE IS ! COMM&] ( ! W>RIORS1 IS 9 NO WAY A PRODUCT ( LABOR1 & POSSESSES AN 5TIRELY DIFF]5T MEAN+ FROM MONEY RECEIV$ = WORK ON %OES4  ,AS SOON AS !RE >E SLAVE-[N]S & SLAVES1 AS !RE ALWAYS HAVE BE5 ?R\<\T ! :OLE WORLD1 IT IS UTT]LY IMPOSSIBLE TO SAY ?AT MONEY REPRES5TS LABOR4 

,WOM5 HAVE WOV5 L951 SOLD IT1 & RECEIV$ MONEY2 S]FS HAVE WOV5 = !IR MA/]1 & ! MA/] HAS SOLD !M & RECEIV$ ! MONEY4  ,! MONEY IS ID5TICAL 9 BO? CASES2 BUT 9 ! ONE CASE IT IS ! PRODUCT ( LABOR1 9 ! O!R ! PRODUCT ( VIOL5CE4  ,9 EXACTLY ! SAME WAY1 A /RANG] OR MY [N FA!R HAS GIV5 ME MONEY2 & MY FA!R1 :5 HE GAVE ME ?AT MONEY1 KNEW1 & ,I KN[1 & EV]YBODY KN[S1 ?AT NO ONE CAN TAKE ?IS MONEY AWAY FROM ME2 BUT IF IT %\LD OCCUR TO ANY ONE TO TAKE IT AWAY FROM ME1 OR EV5 NOT TO H& IT OV] AT ! DATE :5 IT WAS PROMIS$1 ! LAW W\LD 9T]V5E ON MY BEHALF1 & W\LD COMPEL ! DELIV]Y TO ME ( ! MONEY2 &1 AGA91 IT IS EVID5T ?AT ?IS MONEY CAN 9 NO WISE BE CALL$ ! EQUIVAL5T ( LABOR1 ON A LEVEL ) ! MONEY RECEIV$ BY ,SEMYON = *OPP+ WOOD4  ,SO ?AT 9 ANY COMMUNITY :]E !RE IS ANY ?+ ?AT 9 ANY MANN] :ATEV] CONTROLS ! LABOR ( O!RS1 OR :]E VIOL5CE H$GES 91 BY MEANS ( MONEY1 ITS POSSESSIONS FROM O!RS1 !RE MONEY IS NO LONG] 9V>IABLY ! REPRES5TATIVE ( LABOR4  ,9 SU* A COMMUNITY1 IT IS SOMETIMES ! REPRES5TATIVE ( LABOR1 & SOMETIMES ( VIOL5CE4 

,?US IT W\LD BE :]E ONLY ONE ACT ( VIOL5CE FROM ONE MAN AGA9/ O!RS1 9 ! MID/ ( P]FECTLY FREE RELATIONS1 %\LD HAVE MADE ITS APPE>ANCE2 BUT N[1 :5 C5TURIES ( ! MO/ V>I$ DE$S ( VIOL5CE HAVE PASS$ = ACCUMULATIONS ( MONEY1 :5 !SE DE$S ( VIOL5CE >E 9CESSANT1 & M]ELY ALT] !IR =MS2 :51 AS EV]Y ONE ADMITS1 MONEY ACCUMULAT$ ITSELF REPRES5TS VIOL5CE2 :5 MONEY1 AS A REPRES5TATIVE ( DIRECT LABOR1 =MS BUT A V]Y SMALL PORTION ( ! MONEY :I* IS D]IV$ FROM EV]Y SORT ( VIOL5CE1--TO SAY N[ADAYS ?AT MONEY REPRES5TS ! LABOR ( ! P]SON :O POSSESSES IT1 IS A SELF-EVID5T ]ROR OR A DELIB]ATE LIE4 

,IT MAY BE SAID1 ?AT ?US IT %\LD BE2 IT MAY BE SAID1 ?AT ?IS IS DESIRABLE2 BUT BY NO MEANS CAN IT BE SAID1 ?AT ?US IT IS4 

,MONEY REPRES5TS LABOR4  ,YES4  ,MONEY DOES REPRES5T LABOR2 BUT :OSE8  ,9 \R SOCIETY ONLY 9 ! V]Y R>E/1 R>E/ ( 9/ANCES1 DOES MONEY REPRES5T ! LABOR ( ITS POSSESSOR1 BUT IT NE>LY ALWAYS REPRES5TS ! LABOR ( O!R PEOPLE1 ! PA/ OR FUTURE LABOR ( M52 IT IS A REPRES5TATIVE ( ! OBLIGATION ( O!RS TO LABOR1 :I* HAS BE5 E/ABLI%$ BY =CE4 

,MONEY1 9 ITS MO/ ACCURATE & AT ! SAME ! SIMPLE APPLICATION1 IS ! CONV5TIONAL /AMP :I* CONF]S A RI<T1 OR1 MORE CORRECTLY1 A POSSIBILITY1 ( TAK+ ADVANTAGE ( ! LABORS ( O!R PEOPLE4  ,9 ITS IDEAL SIGNIFICANCE1 MONEY %\LD CONF] ?IS RI<T1 OR ?IS POSSIBILITY1 ONLY :5 IT S]VES AS ! EQUIVAL5T ( LABOR1 & SU* MONEY MI<T BE 9 A COMMUNITY 9 :I* NO VIOL5CE EXI/$4  ,BUT JU/ AS SOON AS VIOL5CE1 ?AT IS TO SAY1 ! POSSIBILITY ( PR(IT+ BY ! LABORS ( O!RS )\T TOIL ( ONE'S [N1 EXI/S 9 A COMMUNITY1 !N ?AT PR(IT+ BY ! LABORS ( O!R M5 IS ALSO EXPRESS$ BY MONEY1 )\T ANY DI/9CTION ( ! P]SONS ON :OM ?AT VIOL5CE IS EX]CIS$4 

,! L&$ PROPRIETOR HAS IMPOS$ UPON HIS S]FS NATURAL DEBTS1 A C]TA9 QUANTITY ( L951 GRA91 & CATTLE1 OR A CORRESPOND+ AM\NT ( MONEY4  ,ONE H\SEHOLD HAS PROCUR$ ! CATTLE1 BUT HAS PAID MONEY 9 LIEU ( L954  ,! PROPRIETOR TAKES ! MONEY TO A C]TA9 AM\NT ONLY1 BECAUSE HE KN[S ?AT = ?AT MONEY !Y WILL MAKE HIM ! SAME QUANTITY ( L951 7G5]ALLY HE TAKES A LITTLE MORE1 9 ORD] TO BE SURE ?AT !Y WILL MAKE IT = ! SAME AM\NT72 & ?IS MONEY1 EVID5TLY1 REPRES5TS = ! PROPRIETOR ! OBLIGATION ( O!R PEOPLE TO TOIL4 

,! PEASANT GIVES ! MONEY AS AN OBLIGATION1 TO HE KN[S NOT :OM1 BUT TO PEOPLE1 & !RE >E MANY ( !M1 :O UND]TAKE = ?IS MONEY TO MAKE SO MU* L954  ,BUT ! PEOPLE :O UND]TAKE TO MAKE ! L951 DO SO BECAUSE !Y HAVE NOT SUCCE$$ 9 RAIS+ %EEP1 & 9 PLACE ( ! %EEP1 !Y MU/ PAY MONEY2 BUT ! PEASANT :O TAKES MONEY = HIS %EEP TAKES IT BECAUSE HE MU/ PAY = GRA9 :I* DID NOT BE> WELL ?IS YE>4  ,! SAME ?+ GOES ON ?R\<\T ?IS REALM1 & ?R\<\T ! :OLE WORLD4 

,A MAN SELLS ! PRODUCT ( HIS LABOR1 PA/1 PRES5T OR TO COME1 SOMETIMES HIS FOOD1 & G5]ALLY NOT BECAUSE MONEY CON/ITUTES = HIM A CONV5I5T MEANS ( EX*ANGE4  ,HE C\LD HAVE EFFECT$ ! B>T] )\T MONEY1 BUT HE DOES SO BECAUSE MONEY IS EXACT$ FROM HIM BY VIOL5CE AS A LI5 ON HIS LABOR4 

,:5 ! SOV]EIGN ( ,EGYPT EXACT$ LABOR FROM HIS SLAVES1 ! SLAVES GAVE ALL !IR LABOR1 BUT ONLY !IR PA/ & PRES5T LABOR1 !IR FUTURE LABOR !Y C\LD NOT GIVE4  ,BUT ) ! DISSEM9ATION ( MONEY TOK5S1 & ! CR$IT :I* HAD ITS RISE 9 !M1 IT BECAME POSSIBLE TO SELL ONE'S FUTURE TOIL = MONEY4  ,MONEY1 ) CO-EXI/5T VIOL5CE 9 ! COMMUNITY1 ONLY REPRES5TS ! POSSIBILITY ( A NEW =M ( IMP]SONAL SLAV]Y1 :I* HAS TAK5 ! PLACE ( P]SONAL SLAV]Y4  ,! SLAVE-[N] HAS A RI<T TO ! LABOR ( ,PIOTR1 ,IVAN1 & ,SIDOR4  ,BUT ! [N] ( MONEY1 9 A PLACE :]E MONEY IS DEM&$ FROM ALL1 HAS A RI<T TO ! TOIL ( ALL ?OSE NAMELESS PEOPLE :O >E 9 NE$ ( MONEY4  ,MONEY HAS SET ASIDE ALL ! OPPRESSIVE FEATURES ( SLAV]Y1 UND] :I* AN [N] KN[S HIS RI<T TO ,IVAN1 & ) !M IT HAS SET ASIDE ALL HUMANE RELATIONS BETWE5 ! [N] & ! SLAVE1 :I* MITIGAT$ ! BURD5 ( P]SONAL ?RALLDOM4 

,I WILL NOT ALLUDE TO ! FACT1 ?AT SU* A CONDITION ( ?+S IS1 POSSIBLY1 NECESS>Y = ! DEVELOPM5T ( MANK9D1 = PROGRESS1 & SO =?1--?AT ,I DO NOT CONTE/4  ,I HAVE M]ELY TRI$ TO ELUCIDATE TO MYSELF ! IDEA ( MONEY1 & ?AT UNIV]SAL ]ROR 9TO :I* ,I FELL :5 ,I ACCEPT$ MONEY AS ! REPRES5TATIVE ( LABOR4  ,I BECAME CONV9C$1 AFT] EXP]I5CE1 ?AT MONEY IS NOT ! REPRES5TATIVE ( LABOR1 BUT1 9 ! MAJORITY ( CASES1 ! REPRES5TATIVE ( VIOL5CE1 OR ( ESPECIALLY COMPLICAT$ %>P PRACTICES F\ND$ ON VIOL5CE4 

,MONEY1 9 \R DAY1 HAS COMPLETELY LO/ ?AT SIGNIFICANCE :I* IT IS V]Y DESIRABLE ?AT IT %\LD POSSESS1 AS ! REPRES5TATIVE ( ONE'S [N LABOR2 SU* A SIGNIFICANCE IT HAS ONLY AS AN EXCEPTION1 BUT1 AS A G5]AL RULE1 IT HAS BE5 CONV]T$ 9TO A RI<T OR A POSSIBILITY ( PR(IT+ BY ! TOIL ( O!RS4 

,! DISSEM9ATION ( MONEY1 ( CR$IT1 & ( ALL SORTS ( MONEY TOK5S1 CONFIRMS ?IS SIGNIFICANCE ( MONEY EV] MORE & MORE4  ,MONEY IS A NEW =M ( SLAV]Y1 :I* DIFF]S FROM ! OLD =M ( SLAV]Y ONLY 9 ITS IMP]SONALITY1 ITS ANNIHILATION ( ALL HUMANE RELATIONS ) ! SLAVE4 

,MONEY--MONEY1 IS A VALUE :I* IS ALWAYS EQUAL TO ITSELF1 & IS ALWAYS CONSID]$ LEGAL & RI<TE\S1 & :OSE USE IS REG>D$ AS NOT IMMORAL1 JU/ AS ! RI<T ( SLAV]Y WAS REG>D$4 

,9 MY Y\NG DAYS1 ! GAME ( LOTO WAS 9TRODUC$ 9TO ! CLUBS4  ,EV]YBODY RU%$ TO PLAY IT1 &1 AS IT WAS SAID1 MANY RU9$ !MSELVES1 R5D]$ !IR FAMILIES MIS]ABLE1 LO/ O!R PEOPLE'S MONEY1 & GOV]NM5T FUNDS1 & COMMITT$ SUICIDE2 & ! GAME WAS PROHIBIT$1 & IT REMA9S PROHIBIT$ TO ?IS DAY4 

,I REMEMB] TO HAVE SE5 OLD & UNS5TIM5TAL GAMBL]S1 :O TOLD ME ?AT ?IS GAME WAS P>TICUL>LY PLEAS+ BECAUSE Y\ DID NOT SEE FROM :OM Y\ W]E W9N+1 AS IS ! CASE 9 O!R GAMES2 A LACKEY BR\<T1 NOT MONEY1 BUT *IPS2 EA* MAN LO/ A LITTLE /AKE1 & HIS DISAPPO9TM5T WAS NOT VISIBLE 4 4 4  ,IT IS ! SAME ) R\LETTE1 :I* IS EV]Y:]E PROHIBIT$1 & NOT )\T REASON4 

,IT IS ! SAME ) MONEY4  ,I POSSESS A MAGIC1 9EXHAU/IBLE RUBLE2 ,I CUT (F MY C\PONS1 & HAVE RETIR$ FROM ALL ! BUS9ESS ( ! WORLD4  ,:OM DO ,I 9JURE1--,I1 ! MO/ 9(F5SIVE & K9DE/ ( M58  ,BUT ?IS IS NO?+ MORE ?AN PLAY+ AT LOTO OR R\LETTE1 :]E ,I DO NOT SEE ! MAN :O %OOTS HIMSELF1 BECAUSE ( HIS LOSSES1 AFT] PROCUR+ = ME ?OSE C\PONS :I* ,I CUT (F FROM ! BONDS SO ACCURATELY ) A /RICTLY RI<T-ANGL$ CORN]4 

,I HAVE DONE NO?+1 ,I DO NO?+1 & ,I %ALL DO NO?+1 EXCEPT CUT (F ?OSE C\PONS2 & ,I FIRMLY BELIEVE ?AT MONEY IS ! REPRES5TATIVE ( LABOR6  ,SURELY1 ?IS IS AMAZ+6  ,& PEOPLE TALK ( MADM51 AFT] ?AT6  ,:Y1 :AT DEGREE ( LUNACY CAN BE MORE FRI<TFUL ?AN ?IS8  ,A S5SIBLE1 $UCAT$1 9 ALL O!R RESPECTS SANE MAN LIVES 9 A S5SELESS MANN]1 & SOO!S HIMSELF = NOT UTT]+ ! WORD :I* IT IS 9DISP5SABLY NECESS>Y ?AT HE %\LD UTT]1 ) ! IDEA ?AT !RE IS SOME S5SE 9 HIS CONCLUSIONS1 & HE CONSID]S HIMSELF A JU/ MAN4  ,C\PONS--! REPRES5TATIVES ( TOIL6  ,TOIL6  ,YES1 BUT ( :OSE TOIL8  ,EVID5TLY NOT ( ! MAN :O [NS !M1 BUT ( HIM :O LABORS4 

,SLAV]Y IS F> FROM BE+ SUPPRESS$4  ,IT HAS BE5 SUPPRESS$ 9 ,ROME & 9 ,AM]ICA1 & AMONG US3 BUT ONLY C]TA9 LAWS HAVE BE5 ABROGAT$2 ONLY ! WORD1 NOT ! ?+1 HAS BE5 PUT D[N4  ,SLAV]Y IS ! FREE+ ( \RSELVES ALONE FROM ! TOIL :I* IS NECESS>Y = ! SATISFACTION ( \R DEM&S1 BY ! TRANSF] ( ?IS TOIL TO O!RS2 & :]EV] !RE EXI/S A MAN :O DOES NOT WORK1 NOT BECAUSE O!RS WORK LOV+LY = HIM1 BUT :]E HE POSSESSES ! P[] ( NOT WORK+1 & =CES O!RS TO WORK = HIM1 !RE SLAV]Y EXI/S4  ,!RE TOO1 :]E1 AS 9 ALL ,EUROPEAN SOCIETIES1 !RE >E PEOPLE :O MAKE USE ( ! LABOR ( ?\S&S ( M51 & REG>D ?IS AS !IR RI<T1--!RE SLAV]Y EXI/S 9 ITS BROADE/ MEASURE4 

,& MONEY IS ! SAME ?+ AS SLAV]Y4  ,ITS OBJECT & ITS CONSEQU5CES >E ! SAME4  ,ITS OBJECT IS--?AT ONE MAY RID ONE'S SELF ( ! FIR/ BORN ( ALL LAWS1 AS A PR(\NDLY ?\<TFUL WRIT] FROM ! RANKS ( ! PEOPLE HAS EXPRESS$ IT2 FROM ! NATURAL LAW ( LIFE1 AS WE HAVE CALL$ IT2 FROM ! LAW ( P]SONAL LABOR = ! SATISFACTION ( \R [N WANTS4  ,& ! RESULTS ( MONEY >E ! SAME AS ! RESULTS ( SLAV]Y1 = ! PROPRIETOR2 ! CREATION1 ! 9V5TION ( NEW & EV] NEW & NEV]-5D+ DEM&S1 :I* CAN NEV] BE SATISFI$2 ! 5]VATION ( POV]TY1 VISE1 & = ! SLAVES1 ! P]SECUTION ( MAN & !IR DEGRADATION TO ! LEVEL ( ! BEA/S4 

,MONEY IS A NEW & T]RIBLE =M ( SLAV]Y1 & EQUALLY DEMORALIZ+ ) ! ANCI5T =M ( SLAV]Y = BO? SLAVE & SLAVE-[N]2 ONLY MU* WORSE1 BECAUSE IT FREES ! SLAVE & ! SLAVE-[N] FROM !IR P]SONAL1 HUMANE RELATIONS4.> 

,*RONOLOGY 3 
,NOVEMB] #c1 #ahhf 3 ,*APT] #ag -- ,PUBLICATION4 
,JANU>Y #a#d1 #bb 3 ,*APT] #ag -- ,ADD$4 

 FILE G5]AT$ FROM 3  
HTTP3_/_/REVOLTLIB4COM_/