The Accumulation of Capital: An Anti-Critique

By Rosa Luxemburg

Entry 9622

Public

From: holdoffhunger [id: 1]
(holdoffhunger@gmail.com)

../templates/revoltlib/view/display_childof_anarchism.php

Revolt Library Anarchism The Accumulation of Capital: An Anti-Critique

Not Logged In: Login?

0

Author : Rosa Luxemburg

(1871 - 1919)

Rosa Luxemburg (German: [ˈʁoːza ˈlʊksəmbʊʁk] (About this soundlisten); Polish: Róża Luksemburg; also Rozalia Luksenburg; 5 March 1871 – 15 January 1919) was a Polish Marxist, philosopher, economist, anti-war activist and revolutionary socialist who became a naturalized German citizen at the age of 28. Successively, she was a member of the Social Democracy of the Kingdom of Poland and Lithuania (SDKPiL), the Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD), the Independent Social Democratic Party (USPD) and the Communist Party of Germany (KPD). (From: Wikipedia.org.)

Chapters

Chapter 1 : The Questions At Issue

First Published: 1921 – Die Akkumulation des Kapitals oder Was die Epigonen aus der Marxschen Theorie gemacht haben. Eine Antikritik (Franke, Leipzig 1921). Originally written:1915 while interned in the women’s prison, Barnimstrasse, Berlin. Source: Rosa Luxemburg and Nikolai Bukharin: Imperialism and the Accumulation of Capital. Edited with an Introduction by Kenneth J. Tarbuck. (Allen Lane The Penguin Press, London 1972), pp.45-150. Translated: (from the German) by Rudolf Wichmann. Transcription/Markup: Steve Palmer. Copyright: Kenneth J. Tarbuck and Rudolf Wichmann 1972. Notes: Notes by the editor and translator appear [thus]. MIA notes appear {thus}. Habent sua fata libelli – books have their fates. When I... (From: Marxists.org.)

Chapter 2 : The Critics

Just consider: it is a fact that the controversies in political economy over the problem of accumulation and the possibility of the realization of surplus value have gone on for a century; in the twenties, in Sismondi’s disputes with Say, Ricardo and MacCulloch,[1] in the eighties and nineties between the Russian ‘Populists’[2] and Marxists. The most distinguished political economists in France, England, Germany and Russia aired the question repeatedly, both before and after the appearance of Marx’s Capital. Wherever, under the impact of sharp social criticism, active intellectual life pulsated through political economy, the problem left no peace for the researchers. It is a fact that the second volume of Capital is ... (From: Marxists.org.)

Chapter 3 : Bauer’s General Criticisms

Naturally I shall not let myself be drawn into a discussion of Bauer’s tabulated calculations. His position and his critique of my book depend mainly on the theory of population which he counterposes to my ideas as the basis of accumulation, and which in itself really has nothing to do with any mathematical models. It is this theory which we must investigate. However, we must first get acquainted with the ways and means, with the method, in which Bauer performs his tabulated manipulations. Even if they are absolutely worthless when it comes to solving the purely social and economic problems of accumulation, they are still very characteristic of Bauer himself, and of the consciousness with which he approaches a solution to the problem.... (From: Marxists.org.)

Chapter 4 : The ‘New’ Population Theory of...

‘Every society which grows must expand its productive apparatus every year. This will be a necessity for the future socialist society as much as it is for the present capitalist society, or as it was for the simple commodity-production and peasant economy of the past, which produced for its own need.’[1] Here, in a nutshell, is Bauer’s solution to the problem of accumulation. In order to accumulate, capital needs a steadily increasing outlet to make the realization of surplus value possible. Where does the outlet come from? Bauer answers: the population in capitalist society grows, like that in any other society, thus increasing the demand for commodities and giving the foundation for accumulation in general. ‘In ca... (From: Marxists.org.)

Chapter 5 : Bauer’s ‘Practical’ Conclusion...

This is the limit of Bauer’s own explanation of capital accumulation. What is its practical conclusion? Bauer expresses it as follows: The result of our investigation is (1) that capital accumulation is possible even in isolated capitalist society, provided that it does not extend beyond a certain defined limit (i.e. the growth of the working population – R.L.); and (2) that the mechanism of capitalist production itself automatically brings it back to this limit.[1] Immediately afterwards, Bauer summarizes the quintessence of the practical application of his theory in a concluding chapter, where we read: Comrade Luxemburg explains imperialism in the following way: the conversion of surplus value into capital would be impossib... (From: Marxists.org.)

Chapter 6 : Imperialism

However that may be, we have at last arrived at imperialism. The concluding chapter of Bauer’s essay is entitled The Explanation of Imperialism. After this, the reader might well hope finally to find one. After Bauer had explained that I had only uncovered one root of imperialism, ‘but not the only one’, one could only expect that, from the standpoint of his theory, he himself would lay bare the other roots. Unfortunately, this was not the case. To the end, Bauer fails to give one single indication of the other roots, he keeps the secret to himself. In spite of the concluding chapter’s promising title and introduction we are still left with only the one miserable ‘root’ of imperialism, which forms the &ls... (From: Marxists.org.)

<< Last Entry in Anarchism An Account of The Seminary	Current Entry in Anarchism The Accumulation of Capital: An Anti-Critique	Next Entry in Anarchism >> The Accumulation of Freedom
All Nearby Items in Anarchism Account of The Seminary, An, by William Godwin Accountable to Themselves Alone: On Police Killings, by Jeff Shantz Accounting for Ourselves, by CrimethInc. Accounts from the Fall of Silent Sam, by CrimethInc. Accumulation of Capital, The, by Rosa Luxemburg "Female", A, by Renzo Novatore "Soviet" Power, by Nestor Makhno "The State Always has a Conspiracy... Have You?", by Anonymous A to Z of Communisation, An, by Gilles Dauvé A Word, The, by Anonymous Accumulation of Capital, The: Anti-Critique, An Act For Yourselves, by Peter Kropotkin Acheron in Motion, The, by Rosa Luxemburg Across the North Sea, by Charlotte Wilson ACF — The First Ten Years, by Anarchist Federation ACG June Coordination Meeting – Report, by Anarchist Communist Group Accusation of the Uncertain Sciences, by Charles Fourier Accumulation of Freedom, The, by Uri Gordon Accumulation of Freedom, The, by Wayne Price Accumulation of Freedom, The, by Ruth Ellen Kinna Accumulation of Freedom, The, by Abbey Volcano